WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:05.600
The internet for a long time is growing like crazy, and then it kind of stalled out for the last

2
00:00:05.600 --> 00:00:09.200
little bit. And the number of new websites that were being created, number of new domains,

3
00:00:09.200 --> 00:00:16.240
kind of plateaued from about 2012, 2011, 2012 until actually quite recently. What's changed is

4
00:00:16.960 --> 00:00:21.280
I think that because a lot of these tools have allowed more people to be creators,

5
00:00:21.280 --> 00:00:27.760
to be coders, to be developers, the actually for the first time in really the last 15 years,

6
00:00:27.760 --> 00:00:31.600
the number of websites that are being created, the number of new things that are happening is actually

7
00:00:31.600 --> 00:00:36.800
is actually growing. Again, and growing at rates that look like what the early 2000s growth

8
00:00:36.800 --> 00:00:40.640
rates of the internet look like. So I actually think that's kind of optimistic that there's more

9
00:00:40.640 --> 00:00:45.360
things that are being created that are out there and are coming online.

10
00:00:49.120 --> 00:00:53.280
Bangladesh nation very excited to introduce you to Matthew Prince. He's the co-founder and CEO

11
00:00:53.280 --> 00:00:59.680
of Cloudflare. That's a $70 billion company that sits between the internet and roughly 20%

12
00:00:59.680 --> 00:01:04.960
of the world's websites run on top of Cloudflare. I think he's one of the most thoughtful voices on

13
00:01:04.960 --> 00:01:10.560
the question of how is the business model of the internet changing. He's also recently joined

14
00:01:10.560 --> 00:01:16.880
X402. Got some stablecoin stuff to talk about. Matthew, there's so much to discuss today. Welcome to

15
00:01:16.960 --> 00:01:23.680
Bangladesh. Thank you for having me. So we've seen estimates that at a certain year AI bot traffic

16
00:01:23.680 --> 00:01:30.080
is going to exceed all human traffic on the internet. I don't know if that's 2027, 2028, 2029,

17
00:01:30.080 --> 00:01:36.880
or maybe even this year. When do you think that happens and is the internet ready for it?

18
00:01:36.880 --> 00:01:42.400
Yeah, I think that based on what we've seen, we were saying it was 2027. We're now saying

19
00:01:42.480 --> 00:01:49.840
the first half of 2027 that that will cross. It's just been extraordinary to watch the growth

20
00:01:49.840 --> 00:01:56.000
of agent traffic, bot traffic over the last little bit. For a long time, bots were bad.

21
00:01:56.960 --> 00:02:01.840
But you increasingly are saying these agents, which are actually helping humans trying to do

22
00:02:01.840 --> 00:02:06.480
things which are really useful, just driving an enormous amount of traffic. I think

23
00:02:06.480 --> 00:02:11.200
any of us who have used any AI tools can see how that happens. If I'm personally going to go

24
00:02:11.360 --> 00:02:17.360
think about buying a new digital camera, I might get a site or two, a few pages that are out there

25
00:02:17.360 --> 00:02:22.320
and then I'll make a decision. Someone who's maybe more thorough than I might get a five sites

26
00:02:22.320 --> 00:02:29.200
and compare reviews. The agents, you can just watch it as you ask a chat GPT or a GROC or a

27
00:02:29.200 --> 00:02:37.120
cloud to do work on your behalf. They're taking oftentimes a thousand times more in-depth research

28
00:02:37.120 --> 00:02:42.160
and that means there's just a lot more traffic that is hitting the internet. In terms of whether

29
00:02:42.160 --> 00:02:46.880
the internet's ready, I think that's a little bit of an open question. I think one of the challenges

30
00:02:47.840 --> 00:02:53.760
from a technical perspective, I think we can manage that and we can scale through it. We've seen

31
00:02:53.760 --> 00:03:01.600
explosive growth in internet traffic before. I harken back to April of 2020 when COVID hit

32
00:03:01.600 --> 00:03:06.000
and all of a sudden overnight, internet traffic doubled over the course of two weeks.

33
00:03:06.400 --> 00:03:11.600
It was extraordinary how much the system still held together and while it created challenges,

34
00:03:12.320 --> 00:03:16.240
it was able to scale and we were able to keep the internet functioning and help us get through

35
00:03:16.240 --> 00:03:20.000
that time. I think this is the same sort of moment where you're going to see a lot more

36
00:03:20.000 --> 00:03:24.640
more traffic so I think technically we'll be okay. I think the big question though is what's the

37
00:03:24.640 --> 00:03:29.440
business model going to be and who's going to pay for it because there's a lot of servers,

38
00:03:29.440 --> 00:03:34.480
there's a lot of infrastructure, there's a lot of stuff which is behind all of that. If the

39
00:03:34.480 --> 00:03:40.240
business model of the internet for the last 30 years has been ads and subscriptions from

40
00:03:40.240 --> 00:03:45.680
as agents don't click on ads and buying one subscription and then having agents be able to

41
00:03:45.680 --> 00:03:51.600
basically pick all of the content back up from that, that's not going to help make sure that

42
00:03:51.600 --> 00:03:54.880
the people who are creating that content get compensated for, the people who are providing the

43
00:03:54.880 --> 00:04:02.000
infrastructure to power that content get actually compensated for the work that they're doing.

44
00:04:02.240 --> 00:04:07.360
We have to figure out some new business model and that's a lot of what I'm spending my time

45
00:04:07.360 --> 00:04:10.880
thinking about these days. I can't wait to discuss that with you. I think that's going to be

46
00:04:10.880 --> 00:04:15.840
the bulk of the episode. Before we get there into the new business model that might be required,

47
00:04:15.840 --> 00:04:21.600
why ads are breaking down, why subscriptions are breaking down, talk about Cloudflare for just a

48
00:04:21.600 --> 00:04:28.640
second because I think our audience may not know exactly what Cloudflare does even though they're

49
00:04:28.640 --> 00:04:34.640
probably a daily active user of Cloudflare because if Cloudflare turned off tomorrow big chunks

50
00:04:34.640 --> 00:04:39.600
of the web that would just go completely dark and you guys have been part of the story of how the

51
00:04:39.600 --> 00:04:45.920
internet has scaled over the last decade or so. One way I think of Cloudflare is sort of like

52
00:04:45.920 --> 00:04:52.000
that ice wall from Game of Thrones where it's just like this giant ice wall that kept the white

53
00:04:52.000 --> 00:04:58.240
walkers out and all of the bad bots and Russia and North Korea and just malicious things,

54
00:04:58.320 --> 00:05:05.920
you guys play a role in that. I know that's not all you do though. Talk about how would you explain Cloudflare

55
00:05:05.920 --> 00:05:13.680
to I guess a normal tech savvy audience member. So I think it's kind of like any superhero needs

56
00:05:13.680 --> 00:05:20.160
an origin story and so our origin story started pretty simply which was we saw that all of the world

57
00:05:20.160 --> 00:05:25.120
of software was going to the cloud. We saw that all the world of like servers were going to cloud

58
00:05:25.120 --> 00:05:30.480
and so it seemed obvious to us that sort of networking and the security appliances that were out

59
00:05:30.480 --> 00:05:35.120
there before the firewalls of the world were going to go to the cloud as well and so Cloudflare

60
00:05:35.120 --> 00:05:39.440
started with a really simple idea which is how could you take a firewall and put it in the cloud.

61
00:05:40.880 --> 00:05:45.520
And one of the challenges we had was we knew that in order to be successful we had to then someday

62
00:05:45.520 --> 00:05:52.400
sell to big banks and governments and healthcare organizations and things like that but we were

63
00:05:52.400 --> 00:05:59.520
tiny and so the challenge was we didn't have a big network. We didn't have the data to really

64
00:05:59.520 --> 00:06:04.560
stop the most sophisticated threats of the time and so one of the things that we did was we made a

65
00:06:04.560 --> 00:06:10.160
stripped down version of the service available to everyone in order to basically help us bootstrap

66
00:06:10.160 --> 00:06:16.960
getting the network built and also to help get the data to be able to identify what the

67
00:06:17.040 --> 00:06:24.400
threats and challenges were. And the combination of decisions really caused us to then have what

68
00:06:24.400 --> 00:06:30.400
were just a series of almost endless problems. The next thing we knew we had every human rights

69
00:06:30.400 --> 00:06:34.960
organization in the world that signed up which meant that then every sort of authoritarian regime

70
00:06:34.960 --> 00:06:39.600
in the world was attacking us trying to knock them offline and so we had to build not just a firewall

71
00:06:39.600 --> 00:06:44.800
but now we had to do de-os mitigation. We had hacker kids that were trying to literally steal our

72
00:06:44.800 --> 00:06:49.680
domain so we had to build a registrar and we had our own employees that were getting attacked as

73
00:06:49.680 --> 00:06:54.160
they would go online so we had to build our own VPN service that was there. We even had to build our

74
00:06:54.160 --> 00:07:00.480
own developer platform in order to be able to keep up with all the feature requests and be able

75
00:07:00.480 --> 00:07:05.040
to build things ourselves. And so the story of Cloudflare has really been like start with this

76
00:07:05.040 --> 00:07:08.800
simple idea how do you put a firewall in the cloud make it available to as broad a set of people

77
00:07:08.800 --> 00:07:13.200
as possible have a series of problems that that then creates and then solve those problems for

78
00:07:13.200 --> 00:07:19.440
ourselves. And then it turns out if you're building whether it's an AI company today where 80%

79
00:07:19.440 --> 00:07:26.160
of the major AI companies and labs are our customers of ours in the crypto space almost 100%

80
00:07:26.160 --> 00:07:34.160
of the crypto space uses Cloudflare today. And then across Fortune 500 and global 2000 we're seeing

81
00:07:34.160 --> 00:07:41.520
closing a 30, 40, 50% of those companies that are relying on us as well. And so today what we really

82
00:07:41.520 --> 00:07:46.480
think about ourselves as is what's the next generation cloud if you could start over and you

83
00:07:46.480 --> 00:07:51.120
didn't have sort of all the assumptions that an AWS or a Google or a Microsoft had if you could

84
00:07:51.120 --> 00:07:56.960
sort of think about instead of serving you know Ashburn Virginia or one particular region if you

85
00:07:56.960 --> 00:08:01.520
could serve if you're the region that you served was the earth. And if you could take everything that

86
00:08:01.520 --> 00:08:08.160
we've learned from powering 20% plus of the internet and make it available like I think that's what

87
00:08:08.640 --> 00:08:13.200
that's what we're doing in Cloudflare and and and I think our audiences is really how do we make

88
00:08:13.200 --> 00:08:18.400
the internet better our mission is to help build a better internet and the reason you know I'm still

89
00:08:18.400 --> 00:08:22.320
so excited to come to work every day is I think that's a really important mission. I can't think

90
00:08:22.320 --> 00:08:26.320
of anything more important I could be working on and especially right now when so much is changing

91
00:08:26.320 --> 00:08:30.480
about the internet. You know I really I really love the fact that we have a seat at the table trying

92
00:08:30.480 --> 00:08:35.200
to figure out how do we make sure that works for everyone. If you could get a 3% top off on your

93
00:08:35.200 --> 00:08:39.360
entire portfolio today would you take it because Coinbase is basically offering exactly that. If

94
00:08:39.360 --> 00:08:44.320
you've been looking for an excuse to consolidate your assets this is it. Until May 31st Coinbase is

95
00:08:44.320 --> 00:08:49.920
giving a straight 3% Bitcoin boost on any crypto or cash deposits all month. Coinbase 1 is built to

96
00:08:49.920 --> 00:08:54.800
be useful day to day. You've got zero trading fees on thousands of crypto assets around 3.5%

97
00:08:54.800 --> 00:09:00.800
API on USDC boosted staking and lending rewards and up to 4% Bitcoin back with the Coinbase 1 card.

98
00:09:00.800 --> 00:09:06.000
Plus you can still claim 20% off the first year of Coinbase 1 annual plans and a $50 Bitcoin

99
00:09:06.000 --> 00:09:11.040
bonus when you spend $100 at a new Coinbase 1 card in the first 30 days through May 31st.

100
00:09:11.040 --> 00:09:17.040
Get your 3% boost at Coinbase.com slash bankless. Visit Coinbase.com slash bankless as Coinbase.com slash

101
00:09:17.040 --> 00:09:21.840
bankless to claim your Bitcoin bonus. Offers a valid until May 31st. Terms apply Coinbase 1 card

102
00:09:21.840 --> 00:09:24.640
as offered through Coinbase Inc and Cardless Inc. Card issued by first electronic bank. Bitcoin

103
00:09:24.640 --> 00:09:28.720
back rates are based on card holder assets on Coinbase. Trading is changing not gradually right now.

104
00:09:28.720 --> 00:09:34.800
OKX just launch trading bots directly inside the OKX app. Grid trading, DCA, Arbitrage,

105
00:09:34.800 --> 00:09:39.440
you set your strategy once and then execute around the clock. No staring at Charles Alde,

106
00:09:39.440 --> 00:09:43.440
no manual entries, no missing moves while you're asleep. And for the first time,

107
00:09:43.440 --> 00:09:48.240
automated trading actually feels simple. But OKX is thinking bigger than just trading.

108
00:09:48.240 --> 00:09:53.280
They also launched the agent payments protocol, an open standard that lets AI agents execute

109
00:09:53.280 --> 00:09:58.400
full commercial transactions on chain. The Ethereum Foundation, Uniswap, and AWS are already

110
00:09:58.400 --> 00:10:02.560
building on it. And now it's live inside the United States. And new users who deposit and trade

111
00:10:02.560 --> 00:10:07.280
can get up to $500 in Bitcoin through the bankless link. The link is in the show notes to learn more,

112
00:10:07.280 --> 00:10:12.480
not investment advice, not available in New York or Texas. $100,000 is up for grabs.

113
00:10:12.480 --> 00:10:17.040
But a mask and ondo are giving it away in the ondo trading competition. Five weeks,

114
00:10:17.040 --> 00:10:21.520
three tiers, whoever earns the best percentage return in each tier wins the biggest cut.

115
00:10:21.520 --> 00:10:27.360
Pick from 260 ondo tokenized stocks, funds, and commodities to swap inside Metamask and let

116
00:10:27.360 --> 00:10:31.360
your portfolio do the talking. If you think you can out trade everyone else, this is your chance

117
00:10:31.360 --> 00:10:36.080
to prove it from now until June 18th. Click the link in the description below and opt in on Metamask

118
00:10:36.080 --> 00:10:42.080
mobile. Trade RWA's on mobile or desktop to compete, not investment advice. Can we illuminate

119
00:10:42.080 --> 00:10:48.240
what the internet is like to the people who don't they don't really know what's on the user

120
00:10:48.240 --> 00:10:53.200
rines metaphor was on the other side of the ice wall. There's a lot of just naive users of

121
00:10:53.200 --> 00:10:58.160
the internet. And I say that as a good thing, like cloud flare and like the protective services

122
00:10:58.160 --> 00:11:02.560
that you guys provide for the internet means that I don't have to worry about the white walkers

123
00:11:02.560 --> 00:11:07.600
on the other side of the wall. You do and you see that every single day, can you maybe just

124
00:11:07.600 --> 00:11:14.000
illuminate just how hostile of a place the internet is for the people who don't really have exposure

125
00:11:14.080 --> 00:11:19.920
to that. Yeah, what's it like to be on the wall? Yeah, it's a yeah. I've served this many days,

126
00:11:19.920 --> 00:11:29.920
right? My watch is done. Yeah, your watch is not over. I mean, it's it's pretty amazing to see

127
00:11:29.920 --> 00:11:34.320
you know, the things that that we have to deal with. And again, like I would never imagined

128
00:11:35.280 --> 00:11:45.360
these these things when when you know, in February or in February 2022 or 23, when the when

129
00:11:45.360 --> 00:11:52.240
the Ukraine war broke out, like we had provided our services at no cost to Ukraine and all of a

130
00:11:52.240 --> 00:11:57.040
sudden the entire Russian government was trying to figure out how to take us down in one way or

131
00:11:57.040 --> 00:12:02.000
another. They weren't successful. We helped make sure that Ukraine stayed online. And in my reward

132
00:12:02.000 --> 00:12:06.320
was I'm now personally sanctioned by the Russian government. So I get don't get to go to Moscow

133
00:12:06.320 --> 00:12:12.080
anytime soon. You know, when when right now the conflict is going on in the Middle East with Iran,

134
00:12:12.080 --> 00:12:16.640
you know, watching the Iranian hackers who are very sophisticated, trying to find any possible

135
00:12:16.640 --> 00:12:22.480
vulnerability and we can track them as they as they as they do that is extraordinary. And so,

136
00:12:22.480 --> 00:12:28.240
you know, there are in any given second, you know, literally tens of millions of attacks,

137
00:12:28.240 --> 00:12:33.040
which are hitting our network. And what we act as is that immune system that helps make sure

138
00:12:33.040 --> 00:12:37.120
that, you know, you can just put cloud fire in front of it and not have to think about any of

139
00:12:37.120 --> 00:12:42.400
those those other challenges. And I think that's been a big piece of what has has really driven our

140
00:12:42.400 --> 00:12:46.560
our success. And that that's in the sort of cyber threat side. I think that the thing which which

141
00:12:46.560 --> 00:12:52.000
I find interesting is that even as we change and bring in things like agents, like that may not

142
00:12:52.000 --> 00:12:55.680
seem like a cyber threat, but it's really a threat to the business model of people who are doing

143
00:12:55.760 --> 00:13:00.960
contact creation and other things. And so we get pulled into kind of those other other conversations

144
00:13:00.960 --> 00:13:05.280
as well because we're sitting in that in that that position. And again, I think we have a

145
00:13:05.280 --> 00:13:10.880
responsibility not just to ourselves, but but but not just even to our customers, but to the internet

146
00:13:10.880 --> 00:13:17.520
as a whole because, you know, any given month, six billion people, basically everyone online passes

147
00:13:17.520 --> 00:13:21.680
through our network at one point or another. And when we when we're doing our job right, like,

148
00:13:21.680 --> 00:13:25.600
you don't you don't see it capture you don't have to identify bicycles. You don't have to do

149
00:13:25.600 --> 00:13:30.400
anything. We just make sure that the white walkers stay out and that the rest of, you know, the

150
00:13:30.400 --> 00:13:36.560
normal people are able to transact and do so safely. So as the ice wall on the internet, you guys

151
00:13:36.560 --> 00:13:41.520
have a unique vantage point. It's it's kind of higher above, I guess, the rest of the rest of the

152
00:13:41.520 --> 00:13:47.280
kingdom. And maybe let's get back to that thread of the business model because you said your role,

153
00:13:47.280 --> 00:13:53.440
your mission really at Cloudflare is to build a better internet. And there's almost an assessment of

154
00:13:53.440 --> 00:13:59.600
like, how good is the internet today? Do we have a good internet? I mean, I remember the early

155
00:13:59.600 --> 00:14:04.800
dream of the internet and the 99 use this, you know, set of open communication protocols. It felt

156
00:14:04.800 --> 00:14:10.640
very decentralized. It felt very organic. It felt very bottom up. And then we we hit sort of

157
00:14:10.640 --> 00:14:16.160
this period where it almost turned into kind of a Disneyland, if you will, where everything felt

158
00:14:16.160 --> 00:14:22.400
synthetic, you know, big corporations kind of were the, you know, wasn't they open internet so

159
00:14:22.400 --> 00:14:27.600
much as it was an app on your phone that Google or, you know, some big tech company harnessed.

160
00:14:28.400 --> 00:14:35.520
And now we have a world where it seems like these AI agents are starting to break some of the

161
00:14:35.520 --> 00:14:41.920
original business model that formed the basis of this. Talk about that. What has, how has the

162
00:14:41.920 --> 00:14:50.400
internet evolved? What's the ecosystem like? Who pays for it? Yeah. So, so I think so so big question

163
00:14:50.400 --> 00:14:57.840
and at risk of of, you know, falling back into my own, my old sort of professorial ways. Let me

164
00:14:57.840 --> 00:15:02.240
let me kind of take that in various bits. So, so at the very beginning, I remember we were in

165
00:15:02.240 --> 00:15:05.440
a venture capital meeting at one point and they were like, who's your competition?

166
00:15:06.400 --> 00:15:11.760
And I said Facebook and the VCs all rolled their eyes. But actually there's something that was

167
00:15:11.760 --> 00:15:17.680
really true to that. This was like what 2009 or so when you guys were in the 2011, 2012, you know,

168
00:15:17.680 --> 00:15:22.560
early early, early days. And because I think that, you know, what Facebook, like a lot of the value

169
00:15:22.560 --> 00:15:27.760
that Facebook provided is it provided all of this safety within kind of their Disneyland.

170
00:15:28.400 --> 00:15:33.280
But in exchange, you had to give up a lot of what was unique about whatever it was that you were,

171
00:15:33.280 --> 00:15:37.840
that you were doing online. And I think if clubs are hadn't come along, actually Facebook would be

172
00:15:37.840 --> 00:15:42.640
a lot larger in terms of how much was was there. Because in the early days of clubs are the

173
00:15:42.640 --> 00:15:46.560
sure 2009, 10, 11, 12, there's a period of time where people are like, everything's going to

174
00:15:46.560 --> 00:15:50.560
end up on Facebook behind that walled garden. And there's not going to be as much of kind of the

175
00:15:50.560 --> 00:15:56.160
independent internet anymore. I think that we are to Facebook as like Shopify is to Amazon.

176
00:15:56.960 --> 00:16:02.320
We provide kind of what the the base functionality of keeping you safe, making sure that you can do

177
00:16:02.320 --> 00:16:06.560
whatever you want. But then it's up to you in order to really innovate and create and have your own

178
00:16:06.560 --> 00:16:11.040
your own experience. And so you said we sit above. I always think we kind of sit below. We're kind of

179
00:16:11.040 --> 00:16:16.320
that deep infrastructure layer that's down, down, you know, buried somewhere, which again, if we're

180
00:16:16.320 --> 00:16:19.760
doing our job right, you shouldn't even have to think about it. And you can be as creative as possible.

181
00:16:19.760 --> 00:16:24.720
If you then the look kind of over the last period of time that Clappler has been around,

182
00:16:24.720 --> 00:16:28.880
if the internet for a long time is growing like crazy. And then it kind of stalled out

183
00:16:29.760 --> 00:16:32.720
for the last little bit. And the number of like new websites that were being created,

184
00:16:32.720 --> 00:16:39.760
number of new domains kind of plateaued from about 2012, 2011, 2012 until actually quite recently.

185
00:16:40.640 --> 00:16:46.800
What's changed is I think that because a lot of these tools have allowed more people to be creators,

186
00:16:46.800 --> 00:16:52.720
to be, you know, coders, to be developers, the actually for the first time in really the last 15

187
00:16:52.720 --> 00:16:56.480
years, the number of websites that are being created, the number of new things that are happening

188
00:16:56.480 --> 00:17:03.120
is actually is actually growing again and growing at rates that look and resemble like what the

189
00:17:03.120 --> 00:17:07.200
early 2000s growth rates of the internet look like. So I actually think that's kind of optimistic

190
00:17:07.200 --> 00:17:14.480
that there's more things that are being created that are out there and are coming online.

191
00:17:15.360 --> 00:17:20.960
I think though that your kind of Disneyland analogy is the right one because I think those of us

192
00:17:21.520 --> 00:17:27.920
I mean, I've been on the internet for, you know, since the early 90s and remember the quirky,

193
00:17:27.920 --> 00:17:32.800
weird people were just putting stuff up for the sake of putting stuff up. And what feels like

194
00:17:32.800 --> 00:17:39.520
it changed along the way is that is that a business model really did develop around it. And the

195
00:17:39.520 --> 00:17:44.320
core business model of the internet really was advertising. And Google was the company that

196
00:17:44.320 --> 00:17:49.200
that did more to push that than anyone else. You know, we all think of Google as a search engine,

197
00:17:49.200 --> 00:17:55.040
but beyond search, they were the ones that provided, you know, with adsense and double click and

198
00:17:55.040 --> 00:17:59.680
all of those things. They provide the infrastructure that actually said, I'm going to take traffic

199
00:17:59.680 --> 00:18:07.280
and turn it into revenue. And so the game became because of Google, how do I get as much traffic

200
00:18:07.280 --> 00:18:11.760
as possible? Now that, you know, people have taken that as, you know, step further. So Google kind of

201
00:18:11.760 --> 00:18:17.520
turns into Facebook, which turns into TikTok. And we're increasingly playing this game where

202
00:18:17.600 --> 00:18:22.320
the goal is, how do I get as much traffic as possible? Because every bit of traffic I can then put

203
00:18:22.320 --> 00:18:27.440
an ad in front of someone. And there's some percentage of those ads that I'm going to get paid

204
00:18:27.440 --> 00:18:32.960
for. So the more traffic I have, especially the more that I'm going to get, the problem is traffic

205
00:18:32.960 --> 00:18:38.240
has always been a terrible proxy for value. Like if you think about things in life that, you know,

206
00:18:38.240 --> 00:18:42.320
you might, that might generate traffic, like take it off the internet for a second, even like there's

207
00:18:42.320 --> 00:18:50.800
a car accident. And people rubber neck to look at the car accident. And it creates a traffic jam.

208
00:18:50.800 --> 00:18:54.880
Like that's not a good thing. That's not appealing to our sort of better angels. That's kind of,

209
00:18:54.880 --> 00:18:59.520
it's kind of the morbid sick part of humanity where we sort of stop to look at the car accidents

210
00:18:59.520 --> 00:19:04.640
that are happening. And so traffic has actually always been a somewhat bad proxy for actually

211
00:19:04.640 --> 00:19:09.120
the values there. And in fact, a lot of the media space for a long time, I remember sitting with,

212
00:19:09.120 --> 00:19:16.240
you know, a senior, a founder of a very prominent media firm and talking to this person. And she

213
00:19:16.240 --> 00:19:23.280
was bragging about how they generated content articles as inexpensively as possible. And that

214
00:19:23.280 --> 00:19:30.240
they would then a b test headlines to see which ones provoke the most rage because the more rage

215
00:19:30.240 --> 00:19:33.120
they could provoke, the more likely you were to click on it and the more likely they were able

216
00:19:33.120 --> 00:19:39.040
to serve you an ad. Oh my God. That's just a horrible, like that's that that isn't making society

217
00:19:39.040 --> 00:19:44.880
better in any, any possible way. And so what I think that, that feeling that a lot of us who've

218
00:19:44.880 --> 00:19:50.720
been on the internet for a long time have had is that the, the traffic-based attention-based

219
00:19:50.720 --> 00:19:56.640
economy that the internet has had, that that actually has kind of led us to both kind of a Disney

220
00:19:56.640 --> 00:20:02.480
version, but, but with kind of rage bait attached to it, right? So it's sort of like an unfriendly

221
00:20:02.480 --> 00:20:10.000
Disney version. A rage Disney is a terrible idea. And so actually make an argument that a lot of

222
00:20:10.000 --> 00:20:13.840
what's wrong with the world today, a lot of why you've had this massive rise in populism, a lot of

223
00:20:13.840 --> 00:20:18.560
the reason why the world feels so divided is because that's been the business model of media,

224
00:20:18.560 --> 00:20:23.600
that's been the business model of the internet is how do we actually provoke rage and cause people

225
00:20:23.600 --> 00:20:28.800
to click on things so that we can serve them ads. And so I think that as we think about what a new

226
00:20:28.800 --> 00:20:34.720
bot business model of the internet should be, we should actually try and say, how can we not reward

227
00:20:34.720 --> 00:20:41.440
like just traffic, but how can we reward actually content creation or even more important that,

228
00:20:41.440 --> 00:20:47.520
you know, like like knowledge creation. And I think that's, you know, that's that's that's that's

229
00:20:47.520 --> 00:20:52.160
a lot of what I think as we think about what that future looks like. We should be trying to figure

230
00:20:52.640 --> 00:20:55.600
out, you know, the people who actually really create knowledge, those are the ones who should get

231
00:20:55.600 --> 00:20:59.360
compensated, not the ones who can write the most, you know, incendiary headline.

232
00:20:59.360 --> 00:21:04.080
Well, let's think about what that future looks like. But before we get to kind of bright futures

233
00:21:04.080 --> 00:21:09.200
and rosy futures, let's talk about blame for a second because it's so, you know, we can assign some

234
00:21:09.200 --> 00:21:15.680
blame here. And I'm not sure if you blame individual actors or the system itself, maybe it's more

235
00:21:15.920 --> 00:21:21.680
the latter. I think I read a quote from you, you talked about everything wrong with the world

236
00:21:21.680 --> 00:21:26.320
today is Google's faults. And I feel like you're being somewhat tongue in cheek with that.

237
00:21:26.320 --> 00:21:31.520
Yeah, I think a little bit. Google has been a massive force of good in the world. Like you just

238
00:21:31.520 --> 00:21:36.960
think about the fact that we can all carry around in our pocket access to, you know, all the world's

239
00:21:36.960 --> 00:21:41.760
information, had Google not existed or something like Google hadn't existed. Like the internet

240
00:21:41.840 --> 00:21:47.680
wouldn't be nearly as big, nearly as robust. It wouldn't be nearly as accessible. Like a lot of

241
00:21:47.680 --> 00:21:51.840
the business models of, you know, the old like, you know, those are your old men have to remember

242
00:21:51.840 --> 00:21:56.960
like CD ROMs. It was, how do I sell you this really expensive thing to access knowledge? Google

243
00:21:56.960 --> 00:22:02.320
actually figured out a business model that made it so that knowledge was was available and it

244
00:22:02.320 --> 00:22:06.640
made sense to make knowledge available for as many people as possible. And I think that's that's

245
00:22:06.640 --> 00:22:12.640
incredibly good. But at the same time, again, the core problem was what they were rewarding was

246
00:22:12.640 --> 00:22:18.880
traffic. And traffic is just a poor proxy for value or for quality. And so what I think it would

247
00:22:18.880 --> 00:22:22.880
be better as we think about the future is how do yes we create incentives for things to be as

248
00:22:22.880 --> 00:22:28.080
open as possible. But also how do we create incentives for the, and then the people who are,

249
00:22:28.080 --> 00:22:32.800
who are, you know, creating, creating that content to create content, which is actually

250
00:22:32.880 --> 00:22:36.160
furthering human knowledge as opposed to just, you know, provoking outreach.

251
00:22:36.160 --> 00:22:39.520
Yeah, I feel what you're saying. I mean, it's, it's almost the problem of the classic problem

252
00:22:39.520 --> 00:22:45.520
of over optimization, right? If you over optimize and just basically any direction, you get a set of

253
00:22:45.520 --> 00:22:50.560
outcomes that feels almost dystopian, right? And so we've been pursuing this ad-based,

254
00:22:50.560 --> 00:22:55.760
eyeballs-based business model for like two decades. And so this is the state world.

255
00:22:55.760 --> 00:23:02.160
Almost basically 30 years. Google will be 28 years old and in September. So I can't believe it.

256
00:23:02.160 --> 00:23:06.000
I still think of Google as like kind of a new company, but it's really not, right? It's been

257
00:23:06.000 --> 00:23:12.480
operating this business model for 30 years. So I mean, and maybe no one's to blame. I know

258
00:23:12.480 --> 00:23:18.080
Mark Andreessen famously talks about, you know, missing payments was the original sin of the internet.

259
00:23:18.080 --> 00:23:23.440
I think Ben Thompson is. Nobody encryption also. Oh my god. Oh, you're speaking our language

260
00:23:23.440 --> 00:23:28.480
encryption. Yeah, we forgot that one too. And Ben Thompson says, well, look, it was, it was the

261
00:23:28.480 --> 00:23:32.480
only way that the model could have grown, right? It's it was an inevitability. There's no one

262
00:23:32.480 --> 00:23:36.800
really to blame. Well, there's never been a micro payment system that worked. That's right.

263
00:23:36.800 --> 00:23:43.680
At scale, other than advertising. And advertising is pretty amazing because like I'm a pretty

264
00:23:43.680 --> 00:23:47.920
like target rich advertiser, if I see an ad, you know, it's, it's, it's actually super, super,

265
00:23:47.920 --> 00:23:53.360
super valuable for that to be shown to me. Whereas some, you know, kid in Botswana, you know,

266
00:23:53.520 --> 00:23:58.960
they're maybe getting, you know, a tiny fraction showing an ad to them. But it's still a tiny

267
00:23:58.960 --> 00:24:04.640
fraction. And the marginal cost of serving that kid in Botswana is is so low that that again,

268
00:24:04.640 --> 00:24:10.480
that the the business model of Google and the reason why again, Google gets a huge amount of credit

269
00:24:10.480 --> 00:24:15.600
for this. The business model allowed that kid in Botswana to have access to the same information

270
00:24:15.600 --> 00:24:22.080
that I have access to. And that's that's that's a that's sort of per se good. And I think that as

271
00:24:22.080 --> 00:24:25.680
we think about this and one of the problems, by the way, with both micro payments is, yeah,

272
00:24:25.680 --> 00:24:30.160
for me, for you guys, not such a big deal. It's a fraction of penny every time I access a website,

273
00:24:30.160 --> 00:24:35.040
kid in Botswana actually kind of is a big deal. And so I think there's always going to be trade-offs

274
00:24:35.040 --> 00:24:40.960
as we think about these things. And we may solve one set of problems to create, you know, a very

275
00:24:40.960 --> 00:24:45.760
different set of problems going forward. And again, I think we should, we should just be cognizant

276
00:24:46.320 --> 00:24:51.760
of that. And I'm certain that, you know, that, you know, 30 years from now, someone will be

277
00:24:51.760 --> 00:24:54.960
being like, ah, all the stuff that, you know, Klausler did really screwed up the internet.

278
00:24:57.120 --> 00:25:03.280
We do seem to be approaching toward like the end game of the ads-based business model of the

279
00:25:03.280 --> 00:25:07.760
internet. It's really it's mature. It's kind of done its thing. And this is happening at the same

280
00:25:07.760 --> 00:25:14.400
time that now we have agents. Can you talk about the addition of the agents variable into just the

281
00:25:14.400 --> 00:25:17.760
the internet itself, the economics of the internet and how that's impacting things?

282
00:25:17.760 --> 00:25:22.880
Yeah, I think Matthew used these terms, which I really appreciated. You said the AI agents are

283
00:25:22.880 --> 00:25:28.400
almost strip mining the web. That's right. And I think that's so. So first of all, you're absolutely

284
00:25:28.400 --> 00:25:33.600
right. The ads economy has been declining. And that's been true because if, you know, we people got

285
00:25:34.400 --> 00:25:39.360
you know, privacy blockers, ad blockers that were out there, you know, that was that was changing

286
00:25:39.360 --> 00:25:45.520
the equation. I don't think that the internet has always explained well enough that the trade off

287
00:25:45.520 --> 00:25:51.280
was like, we'll take that, you know, we'll take the energy and the infrastructure to give you this

288
00:25:51.280 --> 00:25:56.160
content. But in exchange, we get to show you ads, right? And that was that was the quid pro quo

289
00:25:56.160 --> 00:26:00.640
that was there. And again, I think that I'm sitting here in Europe like a lot of people just don't

290
00:26:00.640 --> 00:26:04.640
get that. Like they don't understand that that was the trade. It was just like, well, I should be

291
00:26:04.640 --> 00:26:08.880
able to get this stuff for free, but you can't show me any ads that are out there. That doesn't work.

292
00:26:08.880 --> 00:26:14.320
And it's and it's been declining. But the change that's been so dramatic has really been in just

293
00:26:14.320 --> 00:26:19.920
the last in the last two years. And that change has really been driven by the way, yeah, you sort of

294
00:26:19.920 --> 00:26:26.160
saw this steady decline in in sort of ad revenue and in what it what called CPMs, which is sort of

295
00:26:26.160 --> 00:26:30.960
the rate that you get for an advertisement that was out there. Those were sort of declining over

296
00:26:30.960 --> 00:26:37.760
over time. But in the last little bit, what's happened is you've just seen a just sharp almost

297
00:26:37.760 --> 00:26:44.080
step function drop in the in the value that people are being able to get from from from these

298
00:26:44.080 --> 00:26:49.920
these ads that they're they're delivering. And what's changed is like if you just look at Google,

299
00:26:49.920 --> 00:26:56.000
like if you type something into to Google, like when did bankless start as a podcast in the past

300
00:26:56.000 --> 00:26:59.920
Google would show you 10 blue links and you'd have to click on one of them in order to go find the

301
00:26:59.920 --> 00:27:05.920
answer to your question. What happens now is Google presents an AI overview at the top of that page

302
00:27:05.920 --> 00:27:10.320
and it's going to give you that answer. And what's increasing happens, those answers are getting

303
00:27:10.320 --> 00:27:14.800
better and better and the way Google gets them, they go out in a spider the web, they effectively

304
00:27:14.800 --> 00:27:18.720
strip mine the internet, they pull it back and then they give you the answer. Now from a user's

305
00:27:18.720 --> 00:27:23.040
perspective, from an end user's perspective, that's great because I don't want to have to go

306
00:27:23.040 --> 00:27:28.880
spelunking through the web like like a search engine. The search isn't over when I get the 10 blue

307
00:27:28.880 --> 00:27:33.280
links. That's just the beginning of the search. That's a treasure map that I have to go click through

308
00:27:33.280 --> 00:27:38.960
in order to find what I'm looking for. What what Google is turning into and what chat GPT and

309
00:27:38.960 --> 00:27:45.200
Quad and XAI, all of these companies are, they're not search engines, they're answer engines. And

310
00:27:45.200 --> 00:27:49.360
that again, from a customer's perspective, we've all had that experience of like, wow, this is

311
00:27:49.360 --> 00:27:53.840
save me a huge amount of time and given me answers of things, they maybe didn't even exist

312
00:27:53.840 --> 00:27:58.880
out there before in a way that a search engine never could. But if you're a publisher of your

313
00:27:58.880 --> 00:28:03.520
content creator, if people aren't clicking on the links, if they're not going to the sites,

314
00:28:03.520 --> 00:28:08.400
then no one is seeing the ads and there's nothing which is compensating you. And so all of these

315
00:28:08.400 --> 00:28:13.520
different companies, all of these answer engines are taking content, but they're not sending traffic

316
00:28:13.520 --> 00:28:19.200
back anymore. And what that then means is that because they're not sending human traffic, eyeball

317
00:28:19.200 --> 00:28:24.480
traffic back, that there's no one to show an ad to. And since agents don't click on ads,

318
00:28:24.480 --> 00:28:29.520
then all of these companies are just massively losing the revenue that they're getting from their

319
00:28:29.520 --> 00:28:34.720
ad-based business models. And that's going to start to hurt. It's already hurting content creation,

320
00:28:34.720 --> 00:28:40.480
which is out there, either by content creators putting walls up where neither you nor your agents

321
00:28:40.480 --> 00:28:45.440
can get to that content. Or in many cases, you know, publication shuddering because they can't

322
00:28:45.440 --> 00:28:51.680
actually have a business model to support themselves anymore. Can we just double down on why this is bad?

323
00:28:51.680 --> 00:28:59.760
Because me as a user, I get my questions answered faster. We get more truth faster. Things

324
00:28:59.760 --> 00:29:06.560
are more free for more people. Now I understand that independent publications might have a hard time.

325
00:29:06.560 --> 00:29:13.120
Maybe they have to shudder, but maybe that's just an evolution of the internet. Now there's more

326
00:29:13.120 --> 00:29:19.040
information. There's more free for more people. Can you just articulate just the downsides of what

327
00:29:19.040 --> 00:29:25.200
happens if we let this happen kind of unfettered? Yeah. So first of all, like I'm not sure it

328
00:29:25.200 --> 00:29:30.400
means it's more free for more people. Most of these AI companies, their business model is actually,

329
00:29:30.400 --> 00:29:35.200
again, there's a subscription that you pay. And that gives you a certain amount of access to it.

330
00:29:35.200 --> 00:29:39.680
And again, for us, that's fine. Like I am paid 20 bucks a month or 100 bucks a month or you

331
00:29:39.680 --> 00:29:45.040
know, a thousand dollars a month if I want. But I think actually the people who are in the global

332
00:29:45.040 --> 00:29:49.520
south, people who don't have the ability to pay for those subscriptions, I actually think that the

333
00:29:49.520 --> 00:29:53.600
internet's getting smaller for them, not bigger. And I don't think these AI tools are actually

334
00:29:53.600 --> 00:29:57.680
solving a lot of their problems. I think it's actually, they feel like those things that

335
00:29:57.680 --> 00:30:01.520
the wealthy people have on the other side of the wall, but they don't. And I think that's a problem

336
00:30:01.520 --> 00:30:07.280
that we're going to have to wrestle with and almost a solution that we come up with is not

337
00:30:07.280 --> 00:30:13.440
necessarily going to solve. I think back to the other question though, is like, you know, you said

338
00:30:13.520 --> 00:30:17.360
maybe the independent publications are going to have to shutter. I'm not sure that every publication

339
00:30:17.360 --> 00:30:23.920
isn't going to have to shutter. Like if over time, and we've watched where the difficulty of

340
00:30:23.920 --> 00:30:31.680
getting traffic back to your site, as compared to sort of the Google of old, today it's 20 times

341
00:30:31.680 --> 00:30:37.760
harder with Google than it used to be. But that's the good news with OpenAI. It's 1500 times harder

342
00:30:37.920 --> 00:30:43.920
with Anthropic. It's 60,000 times harder. And so if you're doing the work, if you're a journalist

343
00:30:43.920 --> 00:30:47.920
that's doing the work of creating things, or you're an academic that's doing the work of creating

344
00:30:47.920 --> 00:30:52.320
things, and these AI companies are coming and they're taking all the work that you do,

345
00:30:52.320 --> 00:30:56.320
but they're not giving you anything back. They're not compensating you in any way. Like over time,

346
00:30:56.320 --> 00:31:00.080
I don't think it's just the independent publications. I think that anyone who's doing contact creation

347
00:31:00.080 --> 00:31:04.720
has to be crazy to continue to do contact creation. Why would you do it if there's no business

348
00:31:04.720 --> 00:31:08.880
model behind it? Like, yeah, sure. Maybe the edges, they're going to people who do it just because

349
00:31:08.880 --> 00:31:14.240
they love it. But that's a really small universe. People have to eat. And so journalists have to get

350
00:31:14.240 --> 00:31:18.640
paid somehow. And if the way that we're going to be consuming information is through these AI

351
00:31:18.640 --> 00:31:22.320
systems, that's going to change the business model. But what I think people don't totally understand

352
00:31:22.320 --> 00:31:28.160
is the internet has gone through a number of different platform shifts. We went from browsing the

353
00:31:28.160 --> 00:31:34.880
web on our laptop or desktop on a browser to then social and basically consuming information

354
00:31:34.880 --> 00:31:40.480
largely through social and then to mobile. And through each of those, the ad-based business model

355
00:31:40.480 --> 00:31:48.080
has stayed the same. AI is yet another platform shift. The frame that you're going to view content

356
00:31:48.080 --> 00:31:53.360
through is going to be through your helpful AI agent. But what's different about it is for the first

357
00:31:53.360 --> 00:31:59.040
time, it's going to pull the information back to you as opposed to pushing you to the information.

358
00:31:59.040 --> 00:32:02.960
And as it pulls that information back to you, it might be that the AI companies are going to be

359
00:32:02.960 --> 00:32:08.640
able to create great ad businesses themselves. But the people who are the original content creators,

360
00:32:08.640 --> 00:32:14.080
the people who are doing the work going out there, reporting on the news, doing the basic

361
00:32:14.080 --> 00:32:20.080
research and science, all of those don't have a business if they're not selling ads and they're

362
00:32:20.080 --> 00:32:27.600
not selling subscriptions. And so in this new platform that is AI, I think that no matter what,

363
00:32:27.600 --> 00:32:31.440
people are going to be reading from the AI system, which means they're not going to go back to

364
00:32:31.440 --> 00:32:35.920
the original source, which means that it's much harder for whoever's creating that original content

365
00:32:35.920 --> 00:32:41.920
to get paid. Now, the good news is, at the end of the day, the AI companies need the journalists

366
00:32:41.920 --> 00:32:47.680
out there creating content as much as anything else. They need original content getting fed

367
00:32:47.760 --> 00:32:53.840
into the system. So they have an incentive to actually create a business. And across almost all

368
00:32:53.840 --> 00:33:00.000
of the AI companies that we've talked to, every one of them has said, we understand that we're happy

369
00:33:00.000 --> 00:33:05.120
to pay, but it can't be a position where we pay and no one else does. This has to be something

370
00:33:05.120 --> 00:33:09.440
which is industry-wide and that everyone supports it. And so I think that's one of the places where

371
00:33:09.440 --> 00:33:14.480
we're in an interesting position where we can help set what those standards are, apply them across

372
00:33:14.480 --> 00:33:19.120
the entire industry and then find a way that we can do something where, you know, over time,

373
00:33:19.120 --> 00:33:24.480
the AI companies are actually compensating the creators for it. My hunch is that if you look at the

374
00:33:24.480 --> 00:33:30.880
AI companies, you know, take something that's not an AI company. Take YouTube. When YouTube first

375
00:33:30.880 --> 00:33:38.080
started, it was like a science project. It was how do I build the technology to be able to deliver

376
00:33:38.080 --> 00:33:43.280
a stream of video more reliably and less expensively than anyone else? And that was their

377
00:33:43.280 --> 00:33:48.320
incredible innovation. Over time, everyone else figured that out. So that became kind of a commodity.

378
00:33:48.320 --> 00:33:53.440
And so then YouTube pivoted and then their big innovation was discoverability, the search that

379
00:33:53.440 --> 00:33:57.680
Google had and you could find videos better than anyone else. And then everyone caught up with

380
00:33:57.680 --> 00:34:05.600
that. And so today, the most modern incarnation of YouTube is one where the creators create for

381
00:34:05.600 --> 00:34:12.320
YouTube because YouTube pays better than anyone else. And it's the number one platform in terms of

382
00:34:12.320 --> 00:34:16.720
compensation. And if you talk to Mr. Beast or any of the big, you know, creators are out there,

383
00:34:16.720 --> 00:34:20.480
they're like, YouTube actually compensates us better than anyone else. I think AI is going to go

384
00:34:20.480 --> 00:34:24.160
through that exact same challenge. Right now, it seems like a science project where everyone's

385
00:34:24.160 --> 00:34:28.240
chasing AGI. And I'm like, okay, what happens when you get to AGI? And it's like, well, you know,

386
00:34:28.240 --> 00:34:32.320
Google gets there tomorrow, then open AGI, go there a few days later and then anthropic will get

387
00:34:32.320 --> 00:34:36.080
there a few days after that and next will get there a few days after that. And then and then AGI

388
00:34:36.080 --> 00:34:40.640
won't be enough. It will be have to be AGI plus or AGI plus plus or whatever. There's a real

389
00:34:40.640 --> 00:34:44.640
risk that these are just commodities and that everyone's going to be chasing them. So then how do

390
00:34:44.640 --> 00:34:49.600
they differentiate? I think the natural evolution is that over time, the AI companies will look a lot

391
00:34:49.600 --> 00:34:55.440
more like a YouTube or a Netflix where they're all going to have unique content, which is very special

392
00:34:55.440 --> 00:35:00.880
to who they are. And then there and people are going to compete by saying, like if I'm if I if I

393
00:35:00.880 --> 00:35:07.520
want the kind of ultimate AI doctor, then I want to have the one that has access to science and

394
00:35:07.600 --> 00:35:12.560
nature and the latest publications and research and all of the different information that's out there.

395
00:35:12.560 --> 00:35:17.040
And that that and it might be that not everybody has access to that, but the ones that do are going

396
00:35:17.040 --> 00:35:22.320
to be able to have very unique skills based on that and that content creators will actually get

397
00:35:22.320 --> 00:35:27.600
compensated based on different AI companies where they say I want to have a unique specialty or

398
00:35:27.600 --> 00:35:31.520
unique niche around around this space. Very different than what the world looks like today,

399
00:35:31.520 --> 00:35:36.320
but it's hard to imagine how it evolves in a way that isn't that because otherwise everyone's

400
00:35:36.400 --> 00:35:40.560
just going to be chasing one after another and the models will keep kind of leapfrogging each

401
00:35:40.560 --> 00:35:44.160
other and it's not clear what the competitive advantage of one versus the other is going to be.

402
00:35:44.160 --> 00:35:48.320
That is a hopeful future. It's going to take some steps to get there and you sort of wonder

403
00:35:48.320 --> 00:35:54.000
about the various incentives around those steps and whether the the future that you laid out is

404
00:35:54.000 --> 00:35:59.040
kind of incentive compatible for all of the players. Right now, I think the way you describe it,

405
00:35:59.040 --> 00:36:03.200
that term strip mining, that sort of feels like what's happening to the open internet. I've made

406
00:36:03.200 --> 00:36:08.560
comments to David before. Now I feel like I go to a website and it's like I'm in an advertising

407
00:36:08.560 --> 00:36:14.800
slum. So it's not just the website writing quality has deteriorated. It's also I'm hit by an

408
00:36:14.800 --> 00:36:20.800
ad on the side, you know, a pop up in my face. It's like more inflation of ads. My only other

409
00:36:20.800 --> 00:36:25.760
alternative is something like the New York Times say and then I'm hit with a subscription paywall.

410
00:36:25.760 --> 00:36:30.080
That's just, oh my god, I have to take out a credit card, pay for the subscription and

411
00:36:30.160 --> 00:36:34.160
they they trap me and I'm never going to be able to cancel. I forget that I have it.

412
00:36:34.160 --> 00:36:38.640
And these are my options right now. All of the subscriptions that you want for all of the websites.

413
00:36:38.640 --> 00:36:44.640
20,000 years. It's yeah, we got to have something like it's it's not it's isn't because,

414
00:36:44.640 --> 00:36:48.560
you know, the media companies are getting wildly rich, right?

415
00:36:48.560 --> 00:36:52.800
I mean, it's never in a harder time to be a media company. And so they there's real costs.

416
00:36:52.800 --> 00:36:57.600
Again, people have to eat. And so we have to have some way of doing that. And yes, as

417
00:36:57.600 --> 00:37:01.920
fewer humans are going to sites and more people are putting in ad blockers and all these things,

418
00:37:01.920 --> 00:37:07.760
then the only reaction has to either be put up to paywall or crank up the ads. And that's and

419
00:37:07.760 --> 00:37:12.960
that's that that isn't that that again is it feels like kind of a decaying system.

420
00:37:13.920 --> 00:37:21.680
What I think is I'm optimistic about is that over time, this should definitely be a very

421
00:37:21.680 --> 00:37:29.200
um we're about to see a massive change because the platform of AI is going to just force the

422
00:37:29.200 --> 00:37:33.520
rest of the world to change and and to your question of incentives. I think the good news is

423
00:37:33.520 --> 00:37:37.840
you have AI companies that are that that really want to differentiate themselves with unique

424
00:37:37.840 --> 00:37:42.000
content, which is out there. You have content creators that really want to create that content.

425
00:37:42.000 --> 00:37:46.080
They don't want to create the yet another story of what happened at 1500 Pennsylvania Avenue

426
00:37:46.080 --> 00:37:50.240
today. But they want to tell unique original stories that are out there. And for the first time in

427
00:37:50.240 --> 00:37:54.640
history, I actually think that we have a real alignment or at least for the first time,

428
00:37:54.640 --> 00:38:00.160
so it's like the meta cheese. We have a real alignment of like the the people who are who want

429
00:38:00.160 --> 00:38:05.120
are willing to pay for the content are aligned with the content creators wanting to do real

430
00:38:05.120 --> 00:38:10.320
interesting work and interesting knowledge. And so if we can create some sort of system where the

431
00:38:10.320 --> 00:38:14.880
AI companies are actually compensating people for creating new knowledge, I think that that that

432
00:38:14.880 --> 00:38:19.280
might be that we're on and sort of a cusp of a golden age of content creators.

433
00:38:19.280 --> 00:38:23.280
I think you're right. And what you're describing is almost like a Netflix type of model of paying

434
00:38:23.280 --> 00:38:29.440
for creators just at scale and much more decentralized. But I guess the point is the AI the AI

435
00:38:29.440 --> 00:38:35.840
companies may not go there willingly. It might be sort of like the capitalists in the industrial

436
00:38:35.840 --> 00:38:42.480
revolution where it really took some union work from labor forces to band together and push

437
00:38:42.560 --> 00:38:47.760
for some reforms. And I somewhat wonder if that's what you're doing at Cloudflare right now. So

438
00:38:48.480 --> 00:38:52.800
about a year ago, a lot of people on our legal team would be very uncomfortable with that language.

439
00:38:56.000 --> 00:39:02.080
I think there's something to that where we sort of stopped and said, okay, at a basic level,

440
00:39:02.080 --> 00:39:07.920
what do markets require? Everyone says they require supply and demand. That's not exactly accurate.

441
00:39:08.640 --> 00:39:14.960
What they require is actually limited supply and demand. If you have infinite supply,

442
00:39:14.960 --> 00:39:20.160
like wherever we are all sitting like we're breathing air, there's no market for air because air

443
00:39:20.160 --> 00:39:24.240
is plentiful. If I go scuba diving, there's a market for air because there's no air down there.

444
00:39:24.240 --> 00:39:29.520
So you actually need limited supply plus plus demand that's out there. The good news is there's

445
00:39:29.520 --> 00:39:35.600
tons of demand. All of the AI companies are trying to figure out how can they get as much data as

446
00:39:35.600 --> 00:39:40.000
possible. And they're all trying to figure out how can they find the corner of the internet that

447
00:39:40.000 --> 00:39:44.080
nobody has gotten to before. And what they're really trying to do is, if you think about what's the

448
00:39:44.080 --> 00:39:48.960
history of why did OpenAI start? It was Elon and Sam trying to figure out how do they make sure

449
00:39:48.960 --> 00:39:54.720
that Google doesn't run away with the whole game? What did Anthropics start? Because Dario spins

450
00:39:54.720 --> 00:40:00.880
out from OpenAI. So again, it's a derivative of how do you compete with Google? XAI, again, same

451
00:40:00.960 --> 00:40:06.880
thing. Everyone is trying to catch Google and Google has significantly more data than anyone else

452
00:40:06.880 --> 00:40:12.400
that's out there. Every page that OpenAI sees on the internet, Google sees four. For every page

453
00:40:12.400 --> 00:40:18.000
that OpenAI or that Microsoft sees, Google sees five. For every page that Anthropics sees,

454
00:40:18.000 --> 00:40:24.320
Google sees six. For every page that XAI sees, Google sees 22. And those pages are incredibly

455
00:40:24.320 --> 00:40:29.200
valuable. It's local news, medical health, you know, all of these things. And the question is,

456
00:40:29.200 --> 00:40:33.520
why does Google have access to all that? It's because they've been doing this for 27 years. They've

457
00:40:33.520 --> 00:40:38.000
done all the deals with all the weird corners of the internet. They found their way behind every

458
00:40:38.000 --> 00:40:43.520
paywall that's out there. They've done all of these things that are there. And so I actually think

459
00:40:43.520 --> 00:40:48.160
that there's a, if you talk, when we talk to the AI companies, all of them are saying like, hey,

460
00:40:48.160 --> 00:40:52.720
you know, I'm a little uncomfortable if Google gets everything for free. Why should we have to

461
00:40:52.720 --> 00:40:58.160
pay for it? So one answer is we've got to bring Google down to the same level as everyone else.

462
00:40:58.240 --> 00:41:01.600
The other answer is, well, maybe what we, what you pay for is not, you know,

463
00:41:01.600 --> 00:41:05.840
every piece of content is out there. Maybe you just pay for catching Google because that's going

464
00:41:05.840 --> 00:41:11.360
to take forever for anyone to create on their own. And so that's actually been an incredibly

465
00:41:11.360 --> 00:41:16.080
fruitful sort of line of thinking. And as we've had conversations with all of the AI companies,

466
00:41:16.080 --> 00:41:21.280
they're like, actually, that's really interesting. If you could help us catch Google and get as much

467
00:41:21.280 --> 00:41:26.000
information as Google, we'd be happy to compensate for that. And then in the process, we can actually

468
00:41:26.000 --> 00:41:31.280
gather that up and say, okay, now we'll turn around and give that to the various publishers.

469
00:41:31.280 --> 00:41:35.760
At the same time, I think that in order to create that scarcity, you need some sort of tool

470
00:41:35.760 --> 00:41:40.000
to be able to keep the, the scrapers from getting your stuff. And so that's exactly where

471
00:41:40.000 --> 00:41:44.640
Cloudflare comes in again and says, we can help make sure that people can't have your content

472
00:41:44.640 --> 00:41:49.040
unless you let them have your content. And that's been a big piece of, again, creating that,

473
00:41:49.040 --> 00:41:52.960
that scarcity, which again, I think is helping now drive, drive demand.

474
00:41:53.040 --> 00:41:58.640
It's a supply and demand market. And it's a complicated coordination game. And so can you

475
00:41:58.640 --> 00:42:03.120
describe maybe there, there almost seems to be, maybe you wouldn't call it a war, maybe the legal

476
00:42:03.120 --> 00:42:08.880
folks in this episode wouldn't call it a war. But that's sort of, they're fine with war. They're

477
00:42:08.880 --> 00:42:13.840
just okay. They're fine with war. Let's use the term. It turns out that you have all kinds of

478
00:42:13.840 --> 00:42:18.160
antitrust problems. If you're, if you're, if you're coordinating people together in order to

479
00:42:18.320 --> 00:42:22.720
compete on price, but that's a, that's a whole, whole nother, whole nother story there. So okay,

480
00:42:22.720 --> 00:42:29.760
okay. So content independence day. That was July 1st, 2025. That was last year. We'll use the

481
00:42:29.760 --> 00:42:35.920
terms of war. There was, of course, a revolutionary war, which was, you know, kind of the, the

482
00:42:35.920 --> 00:42:44.480
creators in the colonies escaping their, their British overlords. And this was a, a blog post

483
00:42:44.560 --> 00:42:52.080
that Cloudflare authored that was about blocking AI crawlers by default across your customer base.

484
00:42:52.080 --> 00:42:57.520
So essentially, little, little a little asterix there, but we, yeah, okay. So essentially, as

485
00:42:57.520 --> 00:43:03.040
I understood this, Cloudflare has about 20% of the world's websites of the internet, something

486
00:43:03.040 --> 00:43:11.680
like this. And you set a, Cloudflare put a, a rule in place such that creators could opt in,

487
00:43:11.680 --> 00:43:17.200
website publishers create, like, they could opt into this to say, Hey, I want to block AI

488
00:43:17.200 --> 00:43:23.040
bots from just going through all of my websites content. At some level, this is publishers,

489
00:43:23.040 --> 00:43:28.400
this is creators, you know, kind of pushing back and say, Hey, you haven't asked for any of this.

490
00:43:28.400 --> 00:43:33.440
You just troll our website. And then you put it in chat GPT. You're not compensating us. I want

491
00:43:33.440 --> 00:43:39.120
to opt out of that. I want to turn that off. That's how I understood content independence day.

492
00:43:39.120 --> 00:43:43.040
There's a little bit of confusion here because people then assume that we apply that across

493
00:43:43.040 --> 00:43:48.080
all 20%. That's there. And that's actually not, not right. There's a huge percentage of the

494
00:43:48.080 --> 00:43:53.680
internet that deeply wants to be. And in fact, it's working super hard to be in all of these AI

495
00:43:53.680 --> 00:43:57.680
systems. So just take Cloudflare. So Cloudflare, we published a bunch of knowledge-based articles.

496
00:43:58.800 --> 00:44:02.800
Those knowledge-based articles are like how you configure our system, how you use our developer

497
00:44:02.800 --> 00:44:07.440
tools. We want every AI company in the world to have that stuff. We do a whole bunch of things to

498
00:44:07.440 --> 00:44:13.040
make it as easy as possible for AI companies to consume that stuff because our business model

499
00:44:13.040 --> 00:44:17.680
isn't ads or subscriptions. Our business model is how do we get more people to use our tools,

500
00:44:17.680 --> 00:44:21.680
right? So we want to make that as easy as possible. A lot of the internet wants to make that as

501
00:44:21.680 --> 00:44:25.280
easy as possible. And for those people who want to make that as easy as possible, we're not only

502
00:44:25.280 --> 00:44:30.480
not blocking the AI crawlers. We're actually making it super easy for you to make it consumable,

503
00:44:30.480 --> 00:44:35.680
you know, switching code mode, do markup instead of HTML by demand because it consumes a few

504
00:44:35.680 --> 00:44:42.960
or tokens, lots of different stuff to make that, you know, much more accessible for those companies

505
00:44:42.960 --> 00:44:48.720
or creators or organizations out there that want their stuff to be in the LLMS. There's a whole

506
00:44:48.720 --> 00:44:56.880
other universe and it largely is based on is your business model based on ads. That universe wants

507
00:44:56.880 --> 00:45:01.360
the AI companies to have none of their content unless they compensate them in some way because

508
00:45:01.520 --> 00:45:06.320
fundamentally, if they have their content, it's taking it basically giving people the cliff notes

509
00:45:06.320 --> 00:45:10.240
versions, which makes it less likely that they're going to go and see the ads and click on it.

510
00:45:10.240 --> 00:45:15.760
So we want to support either side of that. We're not religious on either of it. What we're religious

511
00:45:15.760 --> 00:45:21.120
about is it's your content and you should have the tools to be able to control who has access to

512
00:45:21.120 --> 00:45:25.760
it, either making it super easy or making it super hard. And then that's that's kind of the position

513
00:45:25.760 --> 00:45:29.360
that we're in. Content Independence Day was saying we're going to make these tools available

514
00:45:30.080 --> 00:45:33.760
for everyone. Regardless of your budget, you can use the free version of Cloudflow service.

515
00:45:33.760 --> 00:45:38.720
You should all be able to control who has access to your content. And that was really kind of

516
00:45:38.720 --> 00:45:46.160
the line in the sand that we drew last July. Okay, so I'm of split minds about this, I suppose.

517
00:45:46.160 --> 00:45:52.480
So I'm a creator and I'm also a user. So from a creator perspective, I definitely need to be

518
00:45:52.480 --> 00:45:57.840
want to be compensated for my creator output. And some of the podcast model, of course,

519
00:45:57.840 --> 00:46:02.480
is ad model. Some of it is subscription model. So we use both of those at bankless.

520
00:46:02.480 --> 00:46:09.440
From a user perspective, I feel like I want my AI agent to be able to scan different websites

521
00:46:09.440 --> 00:46:14.960
and be able to bring that information into my knowledge base. And I get frustrated when I go to

522
00:46:14.960 --> 00:46:20.240
my quad or my chat GPT instance and I'm like, Hey, here's a link. And it's like, I can't read

523
00:46:20.240 --> 00:46:25.280
this link. And then I have to go and I have to go copy and paste it or clip it in MD file and

524
00:46:25.520 --> 00:46:30.000
paste it in and be like, now can you read it? And I feel like a part of my life, a fraction of

525
00:46:30.000 --> 00:46:35.600
my life right now is I'm just like a copy and paste agent for some super intelligent LLM. And

526
00:46:35.600 --> 00:46:40.800
that feels that feels weird. I feel like an unnecessary middleman. And so what about the argument

527
00:46:40.800 --> 00:46:47.760
that no, you know, AI agents are actually acting on behalf of humans. And it's kind of the same thing.

528
00:46:47.760 --> 00:46:53.760
If so, if you block an AI agent from a from a website, then you're effectively you can be blocking

529
00:46:53.840 --> 00:46:59.120
a human from marshaling that AI website as their hands to go acquire that information.

530
00:46:59.680 --> 00:47:04.400
Yeah, I mean, I guess again, comes back to something even simpler, which is like if you're not

531
00:47:04.400 --> 00:47:09.840
going the site with your eyeballs, then you're not seeing ads. If you're not seeing ads, then the

532
00:47:09.840 --> 00:47:14.640
website isn't getting paid. And if the website isn't getting paid, then the person who's creating

533
00:47:14.640 --> 00:47:20.560
that content can't eat. And eventually they're going to stop creating content. And so like I get it,

534
00:47:20.560 --> 00:47:24.960
like I think as a user, we want to make that as easy as possible. But it's the same thing that like,

535
00:47:24.960 --> 00:47:29.840
I'm so sorry, if you don't, you know, subscribe to, if you only subscribe to Netflix, but you don't

536
00:47:29.840 --> 00:47:34.960
describe, subscribe to Hulu, then you can't watch, you know, I don't know, or HBO, you can't watch

537
00:47:34.960 --> 00:47:39.520
Game of Thrones, right? I mean, there, there's going to be different things that different people

538
00:47:39.520 --> 00:47:43.520
have access to. Because at the end of the day, the people who are doing the work to create content

539
00:47:43.520 --> 00:47:48.640
deserve to be compensated for it. And we've got to create some system to do it. I think over time,

540
00:47:48.640 --> 00:47:53.760
that that system looks a lot more like a, again, a Netflix or a Spotify, where some amount that

541
00:47:53.760 --> 00:47:58.720
you're paying in a subscription to your AI company, then gets carved off and actually sent to

542
00:47:58.720 --> 00:48:03.760
the content creators, they're creating content that's out there. And in an ideal case, the

543
00:48:03.760 --> 00:48:09.120
AI companies are also feeding information back to content creators, say, hey, here's knowledge we

544
00:48:09.120 --> 00:48:14.240
feel like is missing in the world. It'd be great if you went and did research on that and figured

545
00:48:14.400 --> 00:48:19.600
out and we could compensate you for that, for that creation of knowledge. And like, that's a

546
00:48:19.600 --> 00:48:24.080
business model that works. I went up to Stockholm to meet with Daniel Ak, who's the founder of Spotify.

547
00:48:24.960 --> 00:48:28.560
And he told me a bunch of stories, but the one that's really stuck with me, he said, you know,

548
00:48:29.520 --> 00:48:34.320
the way Spotify works, like if somebody searches for like Taylor Swift, shake it off, like we

549
00:48:34.320 --> 00:48:39.200
return results and we are sure we've gotten people what they want, right? On the other hand,

550
00:48:39.200 --> 00:48:43.760
if somebody searches for like, I want a song to a disco beat about how fun it is to dance with

551
00:48:43.760 --> 00:48:50.560
your cat, not a lot of content, which is out there for that. And they know that they know that

552
00:48:50.560 --> 00:48:55.680
they kind of get a bad hit on the searches. So what they do is they actually take those searches

553
00:48:55.680 --> 00:49:00.560
that people run where they don't have good answers and they publish the back to music creators

554
00:49:00.560 --> 00:49:04.320
that are out there. And this is the moment in time where like anyone listening is going to be like,

555
00:49:04.320 --> 00:49:11.680
I am in the wrong business. There's a guy that makes 40 million euros a year just writing songs for

556
00:49:11.680 --> 00:49:16.240
unfulfilled Spotify queries. And he's not alone. Like he's like the top comes in. I'd be there's

557
00:49:16.240 --> 00:49:20.160
a whole bunch of people are making millions of dollars a year. There's writing songs for people

558
00:49:20.160 --> 00:49:25.760
that things that people search for. And I think good songs. Hey, I mean, people are listening to me.

559
00:49:25.760 --> 00:49:29.840
I don't get paid if they don't get listened to. So I just objective David, you don't get to decide.

560
00:49:30.640 --> 00:49:34.240
But I also think that what I actually think there's something kind of beautiful about that because

561
00:49:34.240 --> 00:49:37.360
like if you think about it, when someone searches for a song, it's like they're trying to summon

562
00:49:37.360 --> 00:49:41.920
an emotion, right? And if they don't find it, then they don't find it. And we might not know what

563
00:49:41.920 --> 00:49:45.920
those emotions are. But this is a way of actually surfacing that. And you could think about a model

564
00:49:45.920 --> 00:49:49.680
in the future where the eye companies will say, Hey, listen, we didn't find such a great, you know,

565
00:49:53.520 --> 00:50:00.800
information about what the carrying capacity of an online swallow is. So if you go out there and

566
00:50:00.800 --> 00:50:05.920
like do research on that, we're going to be happy to pay you for that, that information. And then

567
00:50:05.920 --> 00:50:09.520
we can figure out what incorporate into the system. And you know, the way I think about is, you

568
00:50:09.520 --> 00:50:17.120
know, that we've never, until now, had a mathematical model of the sum total of human knowledge.

569
00:50:18.480 --> 00:50:23.760
We kind of do now, like that's what the LLM's are, right? And I picture like a giant block of

570
00:50:23.760 --> 00:50:27.920
Swiss cheese. There's a lot of cheese that's the knowledge, but there's a lot of holes in the

571
00:50:27.920 --> 00:50:34.480
cheese. And the same mathematical models actually show you where the holes are. And so in the future,

572
00:50:34.480 --> 00:50:37.920
I actually think one of the things that would be really interesting is maybe we compensate people

573
00:50:37.920 --> 00:50:42.720
for filling in the holes in the cheese, right? Which is different than compensating them for

574
00:50:42.720 --> 00:50:47.040
traffic. We're actually compensating you for filling in where the gaps in human knowledge are.

575
00:50:47.040 --> 00:50:52.160
And if I were running one of the big AIM companies, I would launch, I don't know if it's if it's the

576
00:50:52.160 --> 00:50:57.520
equivalent of like a Nobel Prize or an Academy Award, but every year across all of the different

577
00:50:57.520 --> 00:51:03.600
fields, they should publish, here is the person, here's the content creator, academic, you know,

578
00:51:03.680 --> 00:51:09.280
researcher, journalist, whoever it is. Here's the content creator who did the most to advance,

579
00:51:09.280 --> 00:51:17.840
you know, biology or physics or journalism or whatever it is and actually reward that both with,

580
00:51:17.840 --> 00:51:22.800
you know, recognition, but then also with, you know, maybe compensation in some way. And I think that

581
00:51:23.680 --> 00:51:28.880
it's amazing that for the first time we can actually measure who did the most in terms of

582
00:51:28.880 --> 00:51:33.680
furthering human knowledge in any given topic, which is out there. And I think that's super

583
00:51:33.680 --> 00:51:38.240
exciting. And then starts to suggest what what that business model is. You just want to make one

584
00:51:38.240 --> 00:51:44.000
observation that that model that you described seems a lot healthier than the eyeballs attention

585
00:51:44.000 --> 00:51:49.600
economics model that is rotting our brains. Yes, except, and I don't know the solution to this.

586
00:51:49.600 --> 00:51:57.840
So I'm I am all ears for ideas done done. I think there are two potential problems, potential

587
00:51:57.840 --> 00:52:05.200
problem number one is it all depends on a subscription model for the AI companies where the

588
00:52:05.200 --> 00:52:12.160
AI companies are collecting dollars and then they are basically putting those into a ASCAP BMI

589
00:52:12.160 --> 00:52:17.280
Spotify like pool that then goes out to the different contact creators that are out there.

590
00:52:17.280 --> 00:52:23.200
And the challenge again, as I think in the global south, you know, people don't have the money

591
00:52:23.280 --> 00:52:28.400
to pay for this. And so it might be that we're going to create a much bigger divide in terms of

592
00:52:28.400 --> 00:52:34.720
information halves and have nots in the future. And again, that's that's a that I agree that we

593
00:52:34.720 --> 00:52:39.440
solve a lot of the kind of attention economy whole problems, but we might get something else.

594
00:52:39.440 --> 00:52:43.840
And people there, I was just at an advertising conference. And everyone's like, oh, someone's

595
00:52:43.840 --> 00:52:48.640
going to create the ad words for AI. No, I don't think they are or maybe they will, but it's not

596
00:52:48.640 --> 00:52:54.400
going to be nearly as good a business because like in the future, I am sure that I will be spending

597
00:52:54.400 --> 00:53:02.240
over $1,000 a year for my AI agent, like for sure. Compare that with Google today, which gets

598
00:53:02.240 --> 00:53:11.760
about $600 per US user that's out there in the case of like meta, it's like $253,000 per US user

599
00:53:11.760 --> 00:53:16.640
that's out there. So $1,000 is a way better business in terms of just the amount of revenue

600
00:53:16.720 --> 00:53:20.320
that's there. And I think a lot of people, a lot of households are going to spend that. I might

601
00:53:20.320 --> 00:53:26.480
spend even more than that to be able to have a helpful agent. If that helpful agent has ads

602
00:53:26.480 --> 00:53:29.520
associated with it, if I say, hey, what car should I buy? And it's like, well, you should buy

603
00:53:29.520 --> 00:53:34.320
a Ford because Ford paid me to tell you that very quickly. I'm going to say, I'm not going to spend

604
00:53:34.320 --> 00:53:38.880
$1,000 for this bias agent. I'm going to go shift to someone who's unbiased. So I actually think

605
00:53:38.880 --> 00:53:43.520
that being trustworthy is going to be one of the things that for those of us who can afford it,

606
00:53:43.520 --> 00:53:47.680
is going to differentiate different agents that are out there. If you can't afford it, though,

607
00:53:47.680 --> 00:53:52.480
it's going to be an ad-based model. But it's going to be kind of the lowest end of the ad-based

608
00:53:52.480 --> 00:53:56.880
model. And a lot of just fraud and problems and all kinds of things that are out there. And so,

609
00:53:56.880 --> 00:54:00.400
again, I think that that's one of the big problems is it's going to differentiate like

610
00:54:00.400 --> 00:54:04.800
halves and have knots in that space. And I think we should be really cognizant of that and try to

611
00:54:04.800 --> 00:54:11.200
think of solutions to it. I think the other problem is there's a real risk that done incorrectly

612
00:54:11.200 --> 00:54:17.440
that any of these models can just exacerbate who already has a lot of money. So, for instance,

613
00:54:17.440 --> 00:54:22.080
imagine an inversion of the future that for an art, we just set a price for an article, an article

614
00:54:22.080 --> 00:54:28.320
costs a 10th of a cent or something in order to purchase. And so every time your agent goes and

615
00:54:28.320 --> 00:54:32.400
does that, a 10th of a cent goes out of your account. And again, we can talk about the mechanics of

616
00:54:32.400 --> 00:54:38.160
how that would happen. But we do that. The challenge is that if we do that, especially if it's a

617
00:54:38.160 --> 00:54:44.080
bid-based system, then the winner of whoever gets access to the articles is just who has the

618
00:54:44.080 --> 00:54:51.520
most money today. And so that means that Google, Meta, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, those companies

619
00:54:51.520 --> 00:54:56.880
could basically block everyone else who's out there out. And what I really worry about is how do we

620
00:54:56.880 --> 00:55:03.360
make sure that as we create these systems that a new entrant, a new startup is able to have

621
00:55:03.360 --> 00:55:09.360
access in a way that they don't have to pay the same amount as someone like Google. And so

622
00:55:09.360 --> 00:55:14.000
at some level, I think we've got to figure out how do you pay different amounts depending on

623
00:55:14.000 --> 00:55:18.960
what your scale is. And the answer might be it's a percentage of what your revenue is. If your

624
00:55:18.960 --> 00:55:24.640
revenue is really high, you put more into the pool. If you're just starting out, you put less

625
00:55:24.640 --> 00:55:29.280
into the pool, but it's still the same percentage that's getting built in. And then if you're successful

626
00:55:29.360 --> 00:55:33.520
and you grow, then that will grow with it. But I think we have to be really, really,

627
00:55:33.520 --> 00:55:39.520
really careful as we design the market to make sure that we, yeah, I think we'll solve a lot of

628
00:55:39.520 --> 00:55:44.160
the problems we've had, but we may create whole new problems going forward. In 2024, emerging

629
00:55:44.160 --> 00:55:50.640
markets generated over $115 billion in annual yield for investors, with yields ranging between 10

630
00:55:50.640 --> 00:55:55.840
to 40%. These are some of the highest most persistent yields on earth. The problem, DeFi can't

631
00:55:56.640 --> 00:56:01.120
access them. Bricks changes this. Built on mega-eath, Bricks takes emerging market, money markets,

632
00:56:01.120 --> 00:56:05.440
and sovereign carry, and turns them into composable primitives you can access straight from your

633
00:56:05.440 --> 00:56:10.080
wallet. While DeFi investors earned 3 to 6% on stablecoins and T-bills, institutions have been

634
00:56:10.080 --> 00:56:16.000
harvesting 10 to 50% yields backed by sovereign monetary policy. Bricks connects these worlds with

635
00:56:16.000 --> 00:56:21.120
institutional gray tokenization, local banking rails, compliance across jurisdictions, and real-time

636
00:56:21.200 --> 00:56:25.840
stablecoin settlement. Bricks does the heavy lifting, so DeFi can finally access real collateral

637
00:56:25.840 --> 00:56:30.480
and structured products on top of real world yield. Even the best carry trades can be within reach.

638
00:56:30.480 --> 00:56:35.040
Bricks brings DeFi's promise to the emerging world, and brings the emerging market yield to your

639
00:56:35.040 --> 00:56:40.320
wallet. Let the yield flow with Bricks. Some exciting news, we are launching a new podcast to help

640
00:56:40.320 --> 00:56:44.400
people figure out the crypto cycle, how to navigate it. The best crypto cycle investor I know,

641
00:56:44.400 --> 00:56:48.800
his name is Michael NATO, he runs the DeFi report. This is the guy that sent me a sell alert

642
00:56:48.880 --> 00:56:54.080
before the 1010 price drop happened. His cycle analysis has been absolutely on point,

643
00:56:54.080 --> 00:56:59.200
I've been following him for years, and this year we started recording weekly podcast episodes.

644
00:56:59.200 --> 00:57:03.840
Each one we get into his portfolio, what he's holding, the market structure, entry targets,

645
00:57:03.840 --> 00:57:08.160
fair market value of Bitcoin and Ether, and where we are in the cycle, there's new episodes that

646
00:57:08.160 --> 00:57:11.920
are released every Wednesday, they're 30 minutes, they're short, they're punchy. I think this

647
00:57:11.920 --> 00:57:16.880
crypto cycle is harder to navigate than most, so let's do it together. Go subscribe to this podcast,

648
00:57:16.880 --> 00:57:22.080
search the DeFi report, wherever you get your podcast, YouTube, Apple, Spotify, or find a link

649
00:57:22.080 --> 00:57:26.960
in the show notes. There's a new episode waiting for you now. Yeah, certainly the implementation

650
00:57:26.960 --> 00:57:32.160
details need to be fleshed out, but I do kind of want to step back and talk about how great this might

651
00:57:32.160 --> 00:57:40.160
be. What you're saying is a little bit reminiscent of what platforms like YouTube or Twitter

652
00:57:40.160 --> 00:57:45.840
or Facebook or Instagram did to the internet, where it just allowed more people to create more,

653
00:57:46.400 --> 00:57:52.960
and allowed for more business models, more archetypes of people, influencers as a business model,

654
00:57:52.960 --> 00:57:57.520
like whatever people think about influencers, it's a whole entire economy out there.

655
00:57:58.160 --> 00:58:03.360
Twitter is the goddamn funniest website that I've ever come across. The jokes and memes on there

656
00:58:03.360 --> 00:58:09.840
are hilarious. YouTube can answer any of my questions, even questions I didn't know that I had.

657
00:58:09.840 --> 00:58:15.920
So in terms of just like human creativity and content production, all of these platforms just

658
00:58:15.920 --> 00:58:20.560
unlocked something massive for humanity. And I'm seeing something kind of similar to what you're

659
00:58:20.560 --> 00:58:27.840
saying, where we're creating the new economic substrate that we're creating can incent just brand

660
00:58:27.840 --> 00:58:35.760
new economies and allow for more aggregate content production, more than we've ever seen so far

661
00:58:35.840 --> 00:58:39.520
because of this new substrate. Now like so much of this conversation so far has been

662
00:58:40.480 --> 00:58:46.000
solving problems like their ads model is kind of fraying, the AIs are going to cause some

663
00:58:46.000 --> 00:58:51.920
problems so we need to fix them, which is totally great. But also I kind of just want to emphasize

664
00:58:52.720 --> 00:58:59.120
how great this could be in the future. And like totally there's problems along the way that are

665
00:58:59.120 --> 00:59:04.560
going to be created that we need to fix. But I also don't want it to finish the massive potential

666
00:59:04.560 --> 00:59:09.440
that we have if we design this thing correctly. Am I being overly optimistic here?

667
00:59:09.440 --> 00:59:13.680
No, again, as I said, I think we might be on the cusp of a golden native content creation.

668
00:59:13.680 --> 00:59:18.800
Because again, if we're designing content, which is actually furthering human knowledge and the

669
00:59:18.800 --> 00:59:25.200
people who do that get rewarded as opposed to or or or make people laugh or just entertain like

670
00:59:25.200 --> 00:59:30.160
those are all good things. Whereas if you've just written the same story as cheaply as possible

671
00:59:30.240 --> 00:59:34.960
and put an incendiary headline on top, but that's a per se bad thing. And we should we should not

672
00:59:34.960 --> 00:59:39.040
be building business models that encourage that. And so I do think that there's something there's

673
00:59:39.040 --> 00:59:44.160
something that's really really potentially amazing if we if we get this right. And it's also just

674
00:59:44.160 --> 00:59:48.080
maybe more straightforward. Like it's kind of weird that like you go to the website to read the

675
00:59:48.080 --> 00:59:53.280
thing and then you get monetized by an ad that's there. At some level just when you go to the website

676
00:59:53.280 --> 00:59:59.280
you pay and that helps cover the cost of the journalist eating but also the cost of actually

677
00:59:59.280 --> 01:00:03.040
delivering the website to you. I mean, that's kind of a more honest business model. Everyone

678
01:00:03.040 --> 01:00:06.000
like a cloud flare like one of the things that's been great about our business is super simple.

679
01:00:06.000 --> 01:00:11.040
Like we make money because people pay us like and they pay us because we make them faster and more

680
01:00:11.040 --> 01:00:15.360
secure and more reliable. Like those are the things that are there. Like we've never had kind of that

681
01:00:15.360 --> 01:00:19.920
ad-based business model and it's always felt kind of a little bit confusing like who's the

682
01:00:19.920 --> 01:00:24.880
who's the customer, you know, who's who's the who's the who's the who's the product. Like if you go

683
01:00:24.880 --> 01:00:31.360
to an ad-based site, you're the product, right? The customer is the advertiser, right? The

684
01:00:31.360 --> 01:00:36.240
customers who ever pays you. That's not how most people think about it. If you found it a different

685
01:00:36.240 --> 01:00:39.760
way where you're actually doing something like a micro-payment, now all of a sudden you're the

686
01:00:39.760 --> 01:00:45.440
customer which means that the journalist is about serving you as opposed to about serving the advertiser.

687
01:00:45.440 --> 01:00:50.160
And so I think that there's a way that going forward this could be really healthy. And so I don't

688
01:00:50.160 --> 01:00:54.720
want to diminish just because there are problems. It doesn't mean it doesn't make the world better.

689
01:00:55.200 --> 01:00:59.840
But I also think it's important to just say it's not like it's not panacea. They're still going

690
01:00:59.840 --> 01:01:02.720
to be challenged and we're going to still have to figure out our way through them. And we should

691
01:01:02.720 --> 01:01:07.520
be cognizant of those as we design this and think about like what do we want the future to look like?

692
01:01:07.520 --> 01:01:11.840
The way I just read is like I want a future where there are not five ad companies. There are 500,

693
01:01:11.840 --> 01:01:16.080
thousand ad companies. How do we make that as as easy as possible? I want a future where there's not,

694
01:01:16.080 --> 01:01:20.400
you know, a few content creators, but there's an explosion where anyone can be a content creator,

695
01:01:20.400 --> 01:01:24.400
anyone can share truth. And it's an accessible and they get compensated for it. It's actually

696
01:01:24.400 --> 01:01:30.080
valuable. And then I want a world where, you know, businesses large and small can compete and thrive

697
01:01:30.080 --> 01:01:35.440
on a really fair playing field. And like as I think about this, those are the goals that I'm playing

698
01:01:35.440 --> 01:01:40.240
for. And I think that's that it's actually pretty easy to go alignment around policy makers,

699
01:01:40.240 --> 01:01:46.560
most internet users, you know, even most most AI companies say that's kind of what we want as well.

700
01:01:46.560 --> 01:01:50.880
I love that goal. And I think more people need to listen that that to me would be a better

701
01:01:50.880 --> 01:01:55.440
internet. Let's talk about how we can actually achieve it and how you guys are working to achieve

702
01:01:55.440 --> 01:02:01.520
it using some of the technology that we have today. So a perfect world, of course, let's say I'm in

703
01:02:01.520 --> 01:02:06.560
my chat GPD, Claude user interface. And I want to go access some content from a creator. I'm actually

704
01:02:06.560 --> 01:02:12.400
paying for it. Okay. And it goes happens in the background. It's a micro transaction. I've scanned

705
01:02:12.960 --> 01:02:21.040
20 different articles. I pay one cent each. Yeah. It's less than that. Okay. So fractions of a

706
01:02:21.040 --> 01:02:26.800
cent. My my my macro paying not micro paying brain can't even comprehend how small these

707
01:02:26.800 --> 01:02:32.240
transactions can actually be. You had this line in a back and forth with apology about a year ago

708
01:02:32.240 --> 01:02:36.320
that I read. And this was the moment I was like, we got to get Matthew on the podcast. You said

709
01:02:36.800 --> 01:02:43.120
apology. Utopia's humans get content for free. And the robots pay a ton. I think that's kind of

710
01:02:43.120 --> 01:02:48.240
what we're talking about. So the content is still free. It's democratized. But it's the robots

711
01:02:48.240 --> 01:02:53.280
that are paying and it's embedded in these micro transactions. Can you talk about all this?

712
01:02:53.280 --> 01:03:00.960
Pay per crawl x402. How do we implement this? Yeah. So okay. So right now, Cloudflare handles

713
01:03:01.680 --> 01:03:08.640
any given second about half a billion requests. So 500 million requests per second flowing through

714
01:03:08.640 --> 01:03:15.200
our our system. When we look at those requests, we think that somewhere between one and 10% of those

715
01:03:15.200 --> 01:03:18.880
are requests that you could actually monetize in some way that people would pay for

716
01:03:19.680 --> 01:03:24.880
having access to. And again, fractions of pennies for it. But if you imagine that just the

717
01:03:24.880 --> 01:03:29.040
traffic to the internet is going to continue to grow like crazy, the fraction of pennies can add up

718
01:03:29.280 --> 01:03:34.720
pretty quickly. It's sort of the Superman 3 or office space business model where you're trying to

719
01:03:34.720 --> 01:03:40.240
find fractions of pennies that are out there. But that's depends how old your audience is.

720
01:03:40.240 --> 01:03:45.760
That might have gone over a while. Spotify does this model, right? Exactly. It's the same thing,

721
01:03:45.760 --> 01:03:53.120
right? And so I think that we understand what we have to do. And the good news is that 402

722
01:03:54.080 --> 01:04:01.040
has existed as a sort of response code for a long time, which is the response code that says

723
01:04:01.040 --> 01:04:07.200
payment is required. And so we along with Coinbase and a handful of others are working on

724
01:04:07.200 --> 01:04:13.200
creating what does that what does that foundation look like? When a website says you need to be paid,

725
01:04:13.200 --> 01:04:18.960
how do we make sure that the rails all exist for that to happen? I think the thing that's I'll

726
01:04:18.960 --> 01:04:23.280
tell you the thing that's hold this back. Like again, everything that's happening in crypto is

727
01:04:23.280 --> 01:04:27.360
is amazing. And obviously this is going to have to be like you can't put this on visa's rails.

728
01:04:27.360 --> 01:04:32.160
Like it doesn't it doesn't work at at at the scale that costs are too high because you've got to

729
01:04:32.160 --> 01:04:36.880
be able to do this incredibly and expensively. Well, it doesn't visa charge like a 30 cent just

730
01:04:36.880 --> 01:04:41.920
initiation fee on every transaction. Yeah, and so like that just doesn't that doesn't work, right?

731
01:04:41.920 --> 01:04:48.000
So in order to do this, you it's got to be some sort of stablecoin solution. What what we've

732
01:04:48.000 --> 01:04:53.440
struggled with is people like will say to us, oh my gosh, you know, we're so excited. We can handle

733
01:04:53.440 --> 01:05:03.600
two million transactions per second. And and I'm like, it's awesome. Good job. But I think day one,

734
01:05:03.600 --> 01:05:08.800
I need 10 million transactions per second. Oh my god. And I think it's going to just go up

735
01:05:08.800 --> 01:05:15.120
from there. And so and so I think that the thing that that is that we're struggling with and

736
01:05:15.120 --> 01:05:21.200
again, we don't I don't want to build any of this stuff. But we don't see in the ecosystem yet.

737
01:05:21.200 --> 01:05:26.160
Anyone who has built something that we think can scale to the levels with it with it with it,

738
01:05:26.160 --> 01:05:32.560
the transactions amounts are tiny. But the volumes are extraordinary. And so that's what we're

739
01:05:32.560 --> 01:05:37.520
trying to make friends with everyone who's in the space who is who is doing something something

740
01:05:37.520 --> 01:05:42.720
interesting. And again, I think we've we've we I feel like we're talking to all the right people.

741
01:05:42.720 --> 01:05:48.640
But but but that's the place where I just don't think that people are thinking about the scale.

742
01:05:49.280 --> 01:05:54.400
I mean, a million transactions per second is more than visa does. And so like like like

743
01:05:55.120 --> 01:06:00.880
and I think you've got a you probably have to have a way of scaling to you know, at least two and

744
01:06:00.880 --> 01:06:05.920
maybe three orders of magnitude bigger than that. And that's and that's that's what we're trying

745
01:06:05.920 --> 01:06:11.520
to figure out right now is exactly how does that work. Once we got that again, I'm kind of

746
01:06:11.520 --> 01:06:15.520
optimistic. We got willing buyers. We got willing sellers. We've got you know, I mean, Sam

747
01:06:15.520 --> 01:06:19.440
Altman talks about how important micro transactions are going to be, you know, the anthropic guys

748
01:06:19.440 --> 01:06:24.000
thinking about like I think we've actually got a lot of alignment. But now it's kind of how do we

749
01:06:24.000 --> 01:06:29.200
make sure that whatever whatever systems we implement are going to actually be able to scale to the

750
01:06:29.200 --> 01:06:35.040
the potential of of of you know, the new business model of the internet. Okay. So let me make sure

751
01:06:35.040 --> 01:06:40.160
I repeat some of this back to you to make sure we understand. So right now what we have is a

752
01:06:40.160 --> 01:06:45.040
a screaming need for micro transactions so that creators can get compensated for all of the AI

753
01:06:45.040 --> 01:06:49.360
agents that are harvesting their content and and strip mining them. They can be compensated for this.

754
01:06:49.360 --> 01:06:56.480
Okay. So we have that. We also have this standard called 402 X 402, which is kind of a an open

755
01:06:56.480 --> 01:07:02.960
cryptocurrency micro transaction standard on top so that AI agents can go pay with some sort of

756
01:07:03.680 --> 01:07:08.560
stable coin and get hooked into the system. So we have the ability to do micro transactions.

757
01:07:08.560 --> 01:07:13.680
So it's saying that it's a standard. I think it's it's an evolving standard. I think we

758
01:07:13.680 --> 01:07:20.560
I mean, there's there 402 is part of the original specification of of web servers. Then Coinbase

759
01:07:20.560 --> 01:07:24.960
took that and said hey, let's actually build then the infrastructure to hook that into, you know,

760
01:07:24.960 --> 01:07:31.600
payments, payment rails and systems. They then donated what they their work and to the to the

761
01:07:31.600 --> 01:07:37.040
the Linux foundation and then and then brought other people including us into help flesh that

762
01:07:37.120 --> 01:07:42.240
standard out. I think we're still in the in the process of figuring that out. But then even if you

763
01:07:42.240 --> 01:07:47.440
figure that out, you've got to then have a stable coin infrastructure which sits behind that or more

764
01:07:47.440 --> 01:07:52.400
than one ideally that can actually handle the volumes that that are are going to be out there. And

765
01:07:52.400 --> 01:07:57.040
again, I think those those volumes are beyond, you know, what anyone is is anticipated. So that's

766
01:07:57.040 --> 01:08:01.200
what you're stuck on right now or that's what you're trying to figure out how to engineer that.

767
01:08:01.200 --> 01:08:05.760
What solutions have you seen? So does this be in a blockchain? There's obviously what Stripe is

768
01:08:05.760 --> 01:08:12.080
doing with with tempo. You know, Circle has a very successful stable coin. They have ARC. You have

769
01:08:12.080 --> 01:08:19.360
Coinbase with with base cloud flare has talked about at least we've heard rumors of a stable coin as

770
01:08:19.360 --> 01:08:23.120
well. So what's kind of the latest and greatest? How are you thinking about slicing, dicing this

771
01:08:23.120 --> 01:08:28.320
problem? Yeah, I mean, I think we went into this thinking that we were going to build sort of a layer

772
01:08:28.320 --> 01:08:35.200
to stable coin that would live on more than one different kind of layer one chains that were that

773
01:08:35.200 --> 01:08:40.720
were out there. And we and again, we've talked to every one of the people that you just mentioned.

774
01:08:40.720 --> 01:08:47.120
And they're all really smart. They've done amazing things. What I think is hard for people to

775
01:08:47.120 --> 01:08:55.840
comprehend is just the volumes that that the internet really looks like. And what what and so that's

776
01:08:55.840 --> 01:09:01.600
where we kind of come in and go, that's awesome. But you've got to be able to support two or three

777
01:09:01.600 --> 01:09:07.360
orders of magnitude more than what you're talking about today. So we are still looking for that.

778
01:09:07.360 --> 01:09:13.280
I think the question for us has been, do we wait until we figure out exactly what's the right

779
01:09:13.280 --> 01:09:18.640
long-term solution before we launch? That or do we sort of try and cobble together something

780
01:09:18.640 --> 01:09:23.920
that'll hold up now? And then the background kind of create what that that future is? And again,

781
01:09:23.920 --> 01:09:28.320
like whether it's us creating it or whether it's one of those companies, there are a bunch of

782
01:09:28.320 --> 01:09:33.280
startups that are doing really interesting things as well. If you're out there and you're working

783
01:09:33.280 --> 01:09:37.200
on this problem and you're not talking to us already, you should be because we can give you

784
01:09:37.200 --> 01:09:43.440
that incredible distribution. We have no pride of ownership here. And what we want is to live

785
01:09:43.440 --> 01:09:47.760
up to our mission, which is help build a better internet. And that means we're going to support

786
01:09:47.840 --> 01:09:56.000
everything which works out there. But the volumes and scale are so enormous that again, I think a lot

787
01:09:56.000 --> 01:10:03.200
of what, again, a lot of the companies that you mentioned have incredible purposes for what they're

788
01:10:03.200 --> 01:10:09.360
doing. But nobody is doing the volumes that we potentially can help facilitate. And again,

789
01:10:09.360 --> 01:10:15.840
it won't just be us. I think done correctly, this goes across the entire internet. And the volumes

790
01:10:16.400 --> 01:10:20.880
could be just extraordinary. So we've got to make sure that we've got the plumbing right in order

791
01:10:20.880 --> 01:10:26.560
to support what the future is going to bring. Maybe I need help understanding the magnitude of

792
01:10:26.560 --> 01:10:31.120
the volumes that you're talking about. But a lot of these blockchains are being built in the most

793
01:10:31.120 --> 01:10:38.960
modern era. In 2026, we know how to build blockchains that go as fast as we've ever known.

794
01:10:39.200 --> 01:10:45.520
Arc, Tempo, MegaEath, all of these things have completely taken off the breaks in terms of

795
01:10:45.520 --> 01:10:52.160
capacity. Yes. And so I'm kind of confused as to actually how what they've built somehow still

796
01:10:52.160 --> 01:10:58.160
isn't big enough to do. I know the internet is very big. But I would imagine our size is not

797
01:10:58.160 --> 01:11:02.800
size, David. I think that's what he's saying. He's saying our size is size. Yeah, crypto size.

798
01:11:02.800 --> 01:11:07.520
Matthew size is not size. Crypto size is not. That's right. Yeah. These aren't going to be like the

799
01:11:07.520 --> 01:11:13.680
dollar volumes might be small. But the transaction volumes are going to be extraordinary.

800
01:11:13.680 --> 01:11:19.440
Yeah. But on day one, like on day one, it's still going to be like when things are just

801
01:11:19.440 --> 01:11:24.320
going to get rolled out here, right? That's the challenge with us. Like that's true for most

802
01:11:24.320 --> 01:11:30.240
people. If you've got to go out and there and sell one website at a time, it's fine. We can take

803
01:11:30.320 --> 01:11:38.160
and again, we say 20%. But real numbers bigger than that of the internet. And we can turn it on

804
01:11:38.160 --> 01:11:44.080
overnight. Like the volumes are pretty high. Again, I right now we do about half a million,

805
01:11:44.080 --> 01:11:49.920
half a billion, 500 million transactions per second at CloudFlare. Not every one of them

806
01:11:49.920 --> 01:11:56.160
is going to be monetizable. But we think it's between one and 10%. So that's between 5 million

807
01:11:56.240 --> 01:12:03.200
and 50 million transactions per second that are monetizable. There's no blockchain out there today

808
01:12:03.200 --> 01:12:08.080
that supports 5 million. The highest we've seen is two. And so if you are out there,

809
01:12:08.080 --> 01:12:12.640
if you're listening to this and you support higher than two, talk to us because that's exactly

810
01:12:12.640 --> 01:12:17.520
what we need in order to do it. And again, I think it's inevitable that it's going to happen.

811
01:12:18.320 --> 01:12:24.480
I'm trying to not have to be the person who has to build it. But again, at some level, if we're

812
01:12:24.560 --> 01:12:29.360
the only one who has the problem, maybe we do have to figure that out. So if you want to go build

813
01:12:29.360 --> 01:12:39.040
like a layer one blockchain that can support 100 million transactions per second, call us.

814
01:12:39.040 --> 01:12:48.320
Because I think that's going to be that is what is necessary in order for us to help build

815
01:12:48.320 --> 01:12:52.160
what is going to be the business model that will be sustainable for the internet in a world of

816
01:12:53.120 --> 01:12:58.880
I guess I'm confused as to why it seems like it's a flip of a switch rather than a slow increase

817
01:12:58.880 --> 01:13:03.200
because as I understand it, we're going to bake stablecoin payments. You're a cloudflare

818
01:13:03.200 --> 01:13:10.960
customer and we turn this on. And we say, oh, only these guys over here get it. You don't get it.

819
01:13:10.960 --> 01:13:14.880
Like, I mean, that's just going to like it doesn't like. Yeah, but don't you have to like fund

820
01:13:14.960 --> 01:13:22.240
stablecoin while it's like, it still has to like defuse out all of those things can happen very

821
01:13:22.240 --> 01:13:28.560
quickly. Okay. All right. Yeah, again, we're a we're a we're a we're a fairly substantial,

822
01:13:28.560 --> 01:13:32.640
you know, public company that that's not going to be our limiting fact. We're not a startup.

823
01:13:33.280 --> 01:13:38.080
And so our limiting factor isn't going to be how do we go, you know, convince everyone to do it.

824
01:13:38.080 --> 01:13:42.800
The limiting factor is going to be how do we make sure that when we turn it on, it can actually

825
01:13:42.800 --> 01:13:49.200
scale as big as you want. And that's again, that's a it's a high class problem, but it's but it

826
01:13:49.200 --> 01:13:55.360
is a problem that we think about it. And what the worst case is we do it and it starts to scale

827
01:13:55.360 --> 01:14:00.960
and it breaks. And so that's what we're trying to make sure is that we've if this takes off the

828
01:14:00.960 --> 01:14:06.000
way we think it will, that it can continue to scale up and support that because agent traffic

829
01:14:06.000 --> 01:14:11.760
isn't slowing down, it's going to go just straight up. And again, something has to help compensate

830
01:14:11.760 --> 01:14:16.400
the content creators and the people who are providing the infrastructure to make that that those

831
01:14:16.400 --> 01:14:20.480
agents may have it able to have access to information. Let's talk about the final form of this then.

832
01:14:20.480 --> 01:14:26.400
Let's say we figure out the scaling problem. Okay, we got microtransactions. We got 402. We have

833
01:14:26.400 --> 01:14:33.520
agents paying micro sense for access to content. What does what else is needed here? Like what does

834
01:14:33.520 --> 01:14:37.760
the world look like? Or is it just like tech is the missing ingredient? I mean Matthews,

835
01:14:37.760 --> 01:14:42.400
there's got to be some coordination challenges here, right? How do you get the AI companies on board?

836
01:14:42.400 --> 01:14:46.720
How do you know David was talking about users with wallet? It's all of this stuff. You're already

837
01:14:46.720 --> 01:14:53.200
frustrated with your agent can't get to things because Cloudflare blocks it. Yeah. So like I think

838
01:14:53.200 --> 01:14:58.480
the court, I think we're in this unique position where we're going to 80% of the AI companies are

839
01:14:58.480 --> 01:15:03.520
customers. We know them super well. Huge percent of the internet is using us. Like I think we're

840
01:15:03.520 --> 01:15:06.960
going to help coordinate and catalyze it. Now I don't think we'll be the only ones providing it.

841
01:15:07.040 --> 01:15:12.400
But once you get that kind of key critical mass, I think the rest of the internet can then go off

842
01:15:12.400 --> 01:15:16.480
and adopt it. And then it can become a standard that works across across everywhere. And is that

843
01:15:16.480 --> 01:15:21.440
just like, does that just become the business model for creators moving forward? They're still getting

844
01:15:21.440 --> 01:15:26.720
paid. I think it's going to be different. I think there's going to be different parts of it. Like one

845
01:15:26.720 --> 01:15:30.560
of it will be again, the micropayments, which is what this is is a piece of it. I think there's

846
01:15:30.640 --> 01:15:39.280
another part that maybe how you train models, how you find that. Like it's the training versus

847
01:15:39.280 --> 01:15:45.840
grounding. Those things might have all slightly different versions at this. And I do think that

848
01:15:46.400 --> 01:15:50.480
over time you still want to have, especially for certain content, you want people to go back to

849
01:15:50.480 --> 01:15:54.400
original sources. And there should be some way of, there's still going to be an advertising

850
01:15:54.400 --> 01:15:58.080
business that exists. It's going to be there. It's going to be smaller. It's the same way that,

851
01:15:58.080 --> 01:16:05.680
you know, you still sell vinyl albums. It's just a smaller part of your business than it used

852
01:16:05.680 --> 01:16:10.080
to be. Whereas the Spotify streaming has become a much bigger part of your business. I think this

853
01:16:10.080 --> 01:16:14.960
will just change exactly what those allocations are. But I am optimistic. If you think about

854
01:16:14.960 --> 01:16:24.080
the music industry, almost 23 years ago to the day was dying. Whole music industry was

855
01:16:24.080 --> 01:16:29.200
worth valued about $8 billion, which is a lot of money, but not a lot of money for like the entire

856
01:16:29.200 --> 01:16:33.520
music industry. And so it's pretty crazy. And what was happening was people were just stealing

857
01:16:33.520 --> 01:16:37.920
the content with Napster and Groxter and all these, these various things that were out there.

858
01:16:37.920 --> 01:16:44.960
And then Steve Jobs steps on stage, almost 23 years ago to the day, and announces I choose 99 cents

859
01:16:44.960 --> 01:16:51.360
of stock. Not the business model that won, but it was a critical step to get to the business model

860
01:16:51.360 --> 01:16:57.520
that won. And so again, the business model eventually won was Spotify, you know, $10 a month,

861
01:16:57.520 --> 01:17:03.440
all you can eat. But you had to kind of go through that. So I don't know what we're going to end

862
01:17:03.440 --> 01:17:09.120
up at, but I know we've got to do something that puts a line in the sand that says content is valuable

863
01:17:09.120 --> 01:17:14.080
and the people who create it should get compensated for it. And then we've got to create the technical

864
01:17:14.080 --> 01:17:20.000
solutions that make it possible to do that in a way, which is fair so that everyone has to pay

865
01:17:20.000 --> 01:17:26.160
something which is fair and either depending on their size or however that works. And then once

866
01:17:26.160 --> 01:17:30.240
that happens, I think that the business models will evolve over time. But what we're trying to do is

867
01:17:30.240 --> 01:17:34.960
say, how do you create the right conditions for a market to develop and then provide the technical

868
01:17:34.960 --> 01:17:40.400
infrastructure or partner to provide the technical infrastructure to actually then allow that market

869
01:17:40.400 --> 01:17:45.440
to thrive? Do you think this new business model could power journalism as small as kind of like

870
01:17:45.440 --> 01:17:50.960
the local newspaper? I know that you and your wife, you bought the park record, which is your

871
01:17:50.960 --> 01:17:59.280
local hometown newspaper circulation 8,000, Park City, Utah. Okay. So apply maybe micro payments to

872
01:18:00.160 --> 01:18:04.560
the park record. I mean, could it work? Yeah, I mean, it was been interesting about the park record

873
01:18:04.720 --> 01:18:13.200
has been so that if you think about what businesses, content creation businesses, you know, thrived

874
01:18:14.000 --> 01:18:19.840
over the last 30 years versus which ones withered and died. Local news is one of the ones that

875
01:18:19.840 --> 01:18:25.440
withered and died. It was incredibly hard because you needed scale in order to drive the economics

876
01:18:25.440 --> 01:18:31.200
and advertising. It just didn't work otherwise. And so like again, we bought the newspaper, not because

877
01:18:31.200 --> 01:18:35.840
we thought it was a great business, but because we thought local news matters. And what you want to

878
01:18:35.840 --> 01:18:42.240
do in order to support a community is actually have sources of information that people can trust.

879
01:18:42.240 --> 01:18:46.560
And the only KPI that we measured, we wasn't around financials or anything else. The only KPI

880
01:18:46.560 --> 01:18:51.680
measured was voter turnout. And voter turnout when we write the election right before we bought

881
01:18:51.680 --> 01:18:56.560
the paper was at 23%. The last election, which was an off-cycle non-presidential election,

882
01:18:56.560 --> 01:19:01.440
it was 63%. And the only thing that changed was we actually covered like the election a lot

883
01:19:01.440 --> 01:19:05.120
better and covered candidates and things because people don't like to vote if they don't feel like

884
01:19:05.120 --> 01:19:08.960
they know what's going on. And so I'm really proud of that. What's been interesting though is

885
01:19:10.480 --> 01:19:18.080
I think that this year we may make more at the park record off AI licensing deals,

886
01:19:18.080 --> 01:19:21.280
which don't require micro payments or anything else. Those are like one-off deals with AI

887
01:19:21.280 --> 01:19:28.240
companies. Then we do off digital advertising. Why? Because it turns out that local news is exactly

888
01:19:28.240 --> 01:19:32.480
what the AI companies want. Like if you go to chat GPT and you say, hey, I'm planning a vacation

889
01:19:32.480 --> 01:19:37.600
to parks in Utah, what's the best new restaurant? If you don't have the information from the park

890
01:19:37.600 --> 01:19:43.440
record, you cannot answer that question. And so actually more local news is more valuable. Compare that

891
01:19:44.160 --> 01:19:48.720
with like the New York Times versus the Wall Street Journal. If one of those papers

892
01:19:49.520 --> 01:19:54.480
doesn't license their content to you, but the other one does, you basically just take the

893
01:19:54.480 --> 01:19:59.280
Wall Street Journal and tell it to rewrite its content as if it's a New York liberal and you get

894
01:19:59.280 --> 01:20:05.760
the New York Times. It's unfair to the New York Times, but not radically unfair.

895
01:20:08.000 --> 01:20:14.000
Another way to say that is that the media business for a long time was tell the exact same story

896
01:20:14.000 --> 01:20:17.360
to an increasingly narrow tribe and an increasingly narrow audience.

897
01:20:18.640 --> 01:20:22.560
I don't think that that has much value in the future, whereas imagine in future

898
01:20:22.560 --> 01:20:28.640
versus the New York Times that reviewed not hotels in New York, but hotel rooms in New York.

899
01:20:28.640 --> 01:20:33.920
I can tell you whether 1313 versus 1314 in the Marriott Marquis is better.

900
01:20:34.880 --> 01:20:40.640
Incredible local news. You know, I can tell you what bodega in New York is the best place to

901
01:20:40.640 --> 01:20:45.440
get a bagel, right? Or whatever it is. Like I think that's the content, which is actually going to

902
01:20:45.440 --> 01:20:50.960
be incredibly valuable for AI companies going forward. You can't be a GI if you don't have that

903
01:20:50.960 --> 01:20:56.640
information. Whereas if you don't have yet another take on what happened to the White House today,

904
01:20:56.640 --> 01:21:00.640
like there's plenty of places to get that information. So I think the future of news actually

905
01:21:00.640 --> 01:21:06.640
might be much more unique, much more local, much more original. And it's the same reason that

906
01:21:06.640 --> 01:21:11.360
if you take the New York Times, great, amazing media organization. And you take a Reddit,

907
01:21:11.360 --> 01:21:15.680
also amazing media organization. It turns out that if you look at the corpuses, they have about

908
01:21:15.680 --> 01:21:20.160
the same number of tokens in them. You know, New York Times has been publishing a lot longer,

909
01:21:20.160 --> 01:21:26.560
Reddit's higher volume. But Reddit got substantially more for the same number of tokens for their

910
01:21:26.560 --> 01:21:33.440
content than the New York Times. Why? Because if you don't have Reddit, you don't have Reddit.

911
01:21:33.440 --> 01:21:39.280
If you don't have the New York Times, go get the FT or the Washington Post or the Boston

912
01:21:39.280 --> 01:21:44.160
Globe or the Wall Street Journal. And you can kind of cobble it back together. I think that the

913
01:21:44.160 --> 01:21:49.440
future media is going to be not that like I'm just going to tell the same story, you know, with

914
01:21:49.440 --> 01:21:54.080
my hyper local audience. It's going to be much more I'm going to tell stories that nobody else is

915
01:21:54.080 --> 01:21:59.280
telling. And by the way, as an audience member, how much more would you rather actually see that?

916
01:21:59.280 --> 01:22:03.840
You don't want to see yet another story of what happened in the White House. You want to see like,

917
01:22:03.840 --> 01:22:08.800
hey, here's a really interesting thing that happened in your hometown or your neighborhood or

918
01:22:08.800 --> 01:22:12.400
what was going on. Like people are craving that. And so if we can create a business model that

919
01:22:12.400 --> 01:22:17.360
rewards it, I think that's actually, you know, really pretty amazing. Matthew, I feel like there's

920
01:22:17.360 --> 01:22:22.080
one last problem we have to solve here. And you've alluded to it several times throughout this

921
01:22:22.080 --> 01:22:27.520
conversation. And I'm not sure this new business model for media has fully addressed it. And that

922
01:22:27.520 --> 01:22:35.280
is the concentration of power issue, the concentration of power in maybe the top tech companies, the top

923
01:22:35.280 --> 01:22:42.960
AI labs. I know you have some history here. So you have your JD from Chicago. You also used to

924
01:22:42.960 --> 01:22:49.600
teach cyber law. And I know even Cloudflare started as kind of like open source technology. And

925
01:22:49.600 --> 01:22:54.320
you care about building a better internet. And so much of that has been based on the open

926
01:22:54.320 --> 01:23:01.040
standards and civil liberties that we kind of built in this one web 1.0 era. So from like, I guess

927
01:23:01.040 --> 01:23:07.040
maybe a balance of power perspective or a civil liberties perspective, how can we fix that

928
01:23:07.040 --> 01:23:14.000
problem? How do we solve the problem of too much centralization of power or censorship ability

929
01:23:14.000 --> 01:23:18.080
in the hands of a small group of tech oligarchs, let's say.

930
01:23:18.240 --> 01:23:25.920
Yeah. So again, I come back to what am I, what am I playing for? And I'm playing for a world where

931
01:23:26.560 --> 01:23:31.680
you have lots of AI companies. You've got lots of media companies. You've got lots of businesses

932
01:23:31.680 --> 01:23:38.400
and they can all compete in a way, which is, which is, which is, which is fair. That isn't the

933
01:23:38.400 --> 01:23:42.800
natural state of things like we already feel like there's a very small number of AI companies that

934
01:23:42.800 --> 01:23:48.960
might win the game. And if it turns out that building any of these models cost billions of dollars,

935
01:23:50.000 --> 01:23:57.120
like that's going to limit the number of people who are able to do it. You know, I like the black

936
01:23:57.120 --> 01:24:04.480
mirror version of this is like content is going to be enormously valuable. But could you imagine

937
01:24:04.480 --> 01:24:10.240
open AI launching their own version of the associated press? Would it cost that much?

938
01:24:10.720 --> 01:24:14.560
A lot of work journalists right now. And they've got to have unique content that's out there.

939
01:24:14.560 --> 01:24:18.400
And so they had bureaus around the world that was reporting out what was ever going on,

940
01:24:18.400 --> 01:24:24.560
then it would feed that back. And by the way, what you would then see is you'd have one AI

941
01:24:24.560 --> 01:24:28.160
company that would be, and you're already seeing this to some extent, you'd have the liberal one

942
01:24:28.160 --> 01:24:31.840
and the conservative one and they'd all have different opinions. And by the way,

943
01:24:31.840 --> 01:24:36.800
that would then lock us into silos because we're basically all going to subscribe to one or a

944
01:24:36.800 --> 01:24:43.200
very small number of these things in that world. And so we get kind of focused and just in our own

945
01:24:43.200 --> 01:24:47.840
filter bubbles that are out there. And then by the way, if we want something else to just have

946
01:24:47.840 --> 01:24:53.760
nightmares over, like the real challenge going forward, I think we maybe solve the media challenge.

947
01:24:53.760 --> 01:24:59.760
The one I'm the most worried about is what happens to small businesses that are there.

948
01:25:00.480 --> 01:25:03.920
If you think about any small business that you do business with today,

949
01:25:06.160 --> 01:25:11.840
the reason you do business with them tends to be either because they have physical proximity

950
01:25:11.840 --> 01:25:18.400
to where you are. And so you can have, you know, you can save time because your time is limited

951
01:25:19.120 --> 01:25:24.240
or because you have some emotional connection to them. Your agent doesn't care about either of those

952
01:25:25.040 --> 01:25:29.360
things. And so your agent is actually going to bypass the local bodega to figure out where they

953
01:25:29.360 --> 01:25:34.320
can get eggs, the cheapest or that match whatever your preferences are. And who might win that

954
01:25:34.320 --> 01:25:38.960
in the future is not a bunch of small businesses. It might be a bunch of very big corporations that

955
01:25:38.960 --> 01:25:44.240
are very good at talking to and answering to agents. And so like, there's a lot of ways this

956
01:25:44.240 --> 01:25:50.800
can go wrong. And in fact, I think the natural tendency is going to be, we have very few AI

957
01:25:50.800 --> 01:25:55.200
companies, very few few contact creators and very few big companies that solve it. I was talking

958
01:25:55.200 --> 01:25:59.840
to a guy who ran small business that had into it and then ran PayPal for a while. And he said,

959
01:25:59.840 --> 01:26:06.320
in the future, I worry there are five companies, literally. One that makes things, one that holds the

960
01:26:06.320 --> 01:26:13.440
land, one that transports things, one that holds the money, and then one AI company. And again,

961
01:26:13.440 --> 01:26:19.040
that's an extreme version. But like, you could see a version of that. And so I think the first

962
01:26:19.040 --> 01:26:24.320
most important thing for all of us to do is articulate what future we want. We want one that

963
01:26:24.320 --> 01:26:28.640
doesn't have five AI companies, but 500,000. We want one that has anyone being able to be a

964
01:26:28.640 --> 01:26:33.360
content creator and get compensated for creating original knowledge. And we want one where

965
01:26:33.360 --> 01:26:39.600
businesses large and small can compete and thrive in this interesting world. And then as we go

966
01:26:39.600 --> 01:26:44.640
forward and we think about this, we can ask ourselves, is that is what we're doing? Is the business

967
01:26:44.640 --> 01:26:51.440
model we're creating facilitating that or kind of tearing that down? And again, I don't have all

968
01:26:51.440 --> 01:26:55.440
of the answers, but I'll say these are the things that I'm thinking about. And these are the things

969
01:26:55.440 --> 01:26:59.680
that everyone Cloudflare is thinking about. And if you or your listeners are interested in this,

970
01:26:59.680 --> 01:27:05.040
like these, I think are the most interesting and important questions over the next five years.

971
01:27:05.040 --> 01:27:08.400
And the entire business model of the internet is going to change. And if you're not thinking about

972
01:27:08.400 --> 01:27:11.200
what that change is going to be, you're not thinking about what the most interesting question

973
01:27:11.200 --> 01:27:16.080
the world is. Matthew, we've answered a number of questions and I feel like we're also closing

974
01:27:16.080 --> 01:27:21.520
this conversation with many more remaining, right? And it's going to be up to us to shape the path

975
01:27:21.520 --> 01:27:27.920
and figure out how this future works out. Your message lately has been to content creators.

976
01:27:27.920 --> 01:27:33.680
And I'm sure we have a number of different content creators listening right now. If for someone

977
01:27:33.680 --> 01:27:37.920
is a content creator, let's say they're involved in kind of the media side of things. They have a

978
01:27:37.920 --> 01:27:42.800
blog. Maybe they have a podcast with the advent of AI. Do you have any advice for them? Like,

979
01:27:42.800 --> 01:27:49.280
what should their move be? I mean, I think you've got to think about who do you want to have access

980
01:27:49.280 --> 01:27:53.040
to your content? And the answer is going to be different depending on what the content creator is.

981
01:27:53.040 --> 01:27:55.920
And it's going to be different based on what your business is. If you're running an ad support

982
01:27:55.920 --> 01:28:04.560
of business, it's going to get really tough for that alone to work if the companies can just

983
01:28:04.560 --> 01:28:08.960
slurp your content down because they can literally just say, you know, you can type in,

984
01:28:08.960 --> 01:28:12.560
you know, what happened on the bankless podcast today? And then they have to go listen to you,

985
01:28:12.560 --> 01:28:18.560
right? So which of your embedding ads or superfaces? And that's really a challenge for

986
01:28:18.560 --> 01:28:22.640
content creators. And so I think the first step has got to be like, I'm going to take control of

987
01:28:22.640 --> 01:28:27.040
the content. That's why we at Cloudflare. And again, it doesn't have to be us. We're trying to say,

988
01:28:27.040 --> 01:28:33.280
let's give the tools to everyone that's out there. We need to make sure that you are controlling who

989
01:28:33.280 --> 01:28:37.120
has access to your content and who doesn't have access to content. And that doesn't have to be

990
01:28:37.120 --> 01:28:42.880
the final step. Like over time, you want anyone who's compensating you in a way that seems fair

991
01:28:42.880 --> 01:28:46.720
to be able to have access to your content. But if they're not compensating you, then why would you

992
01:28:46.720 --> 01:28:50.800
give access to them? Right? If that's if your business model is is somehow doing that. If you're just

993
01:28:50.800 --> 01:28:54.800
doing it because you, you know, love to create content. Great. That's great. Do do whatever you want.

994
01:28:54.800 --> 01:28:59.760
Weaving it that the key is let's make sure that content creators have the tools to either make it

995
01:28:59.760 --> 01:29:04.720
super hard or super easy for their content to be accessible based on what their rules and their

996
01:29:04.720 --> 01:29:10.320
preferences are. And that's and again, I think that's where I would start. And and once you've done

997
01:29:10.320 --> 01:29:13.760
that, then you could kind of figure out what that future is. And again, I don't know that we're

998
01:29:13.760 --> 01:29:16.800
going to invent what the business model is. It might be some content creator that's out there.

999
01:29:16.800 --> 01:29:23.440
This is hey, I figured out that I can put my content available. And when a bot comes to see it,

1000
01:29:23.440 --> 01:29:28.800
I'll actually serve them with kind of, you know, prompt that that helps kind of inform things and

1001
01:29:28.800 --> 01:29:32.880
I can sell access to that prompt. I don't know. There's a lot of different possibilities. We're

1002
01:29:32.880 --> 01:29:36.080
going to have a ton of experiments that are out there. I don't think we have all the solutions.

1003
01:29:36.080 --> 01:29:40.880
But we're sure that there has to be some sort of control over content in order for content creators

1004
01:29:40.880 --> 01:29:46.560
to get paid. And then we're sure that there needs to be some really, really, really efficient way

1005
01:29:46.560 --> 01:29:51.040
to deliver those payments at an enormous scale. That again, I don't think there's any financial

1006
01:29:51.040 --> 01:29:54.960
system out there that has been built to support yet. What do you think about sub-sax

1007
01:29:54.960 --> 01:29:59.920
positioning here? Because exactly what you said, where there's a business model that make sure

1008
01:29:59.920 --> 01:30:06.000
the creators get paid. Well, sub-stack is a platform for creators. It's already subscription-based.

1009
01:30:06.000 --> 01:30:13.600
I can easily see sub-stack just baking in AI communications, agent communications. So and then they

1010
01:30:13.600 --> 01:30:19.680
they could easily pivot to being like the most primary modern business model for content creators

1011
01:30:19.920 --> 01:30:22.720
on the internet if they just implemented some of the stuff that you're talking about.

1012
01:30:22.720 --> 01:30:26.880
What do you think about their position? I mean, sub-sax to customer. So I don't I don't want to

1013
01:30:26.880 --> 01:30:32.800
I don't want to speak for them. But I do think that I think that there, you know, there's going to be

1014
01:30:32.800 --> 01:30:38.000
a lot of opportunities for people to experiment and figure out what the business model looks like

1015
01:30:38.000 --> 01:30:42.800
in the future. And again, I think we're in a unique position to do that. Someone like sub-stack is

1016
01:30:42.800 --> 01:30:48.560
an unique position to do that. You know, the X's and and and Meta's of the world are in unique

1017
01:30:48.560 --> 01:30:54.480
positions to do that. And what I think is we've just got to all kind of recognize the the internet

1018
01:30:54.480 --> 01:31:01.680
of the last 30 years for all of its amazing things and all of its all of its challenges is going to

1019
01:31:01.680 --> 01:31:08.560
change what it changes to. I don't exactly know, but but I think that's so exciting. And so I

1020
01:31:08.560 --> 01:31:12.160
would hope that the folks at sub-stack are trying to figure out how to do that. And again,

1021
01:31:12.160 --> 01:31:17.520
we're happy to happy to help in any way that we can. But but anyone who's creating content,

1022
01:31:17.520 --> 01:31:23.200
any platform that's helping like host or or surface that content has got to be thinking like

1023
01:31:24.000 --> 01:31:28.000
something is going to change here because it can't be that opening eye by as a single

1024
01:31:28.000 --> 01:31:32.560
subscribe subscription to each of their of their publications slopes all the information out

1025
01:31:32.560 --> 01:31:36.320
and then publishes it to everyone. You know, that's kind of exactly what's happening right now.

1026
01:31:36.320 --> 01:31:42.240
And and that's that's not sustainable. Matthew, this has been great. Thank you for the mission

1027
01:31:42.240 --> 01:31:47.840
of building a better internet and we'll hold you to that. We need some help helping build a better

1028
01:31:47.840 --> 01:31:52.960
internet because we can't and so again, we we're we're always trying to find ways to partner and

1029
01:31:52.960 --> 01:31:58.960
do more with with others. And so if anything about this sparked an idea, love love to chat.

1030
01:31:58.960 --> 01:32:02.640
Well, you are dialed into the crypto audience. And I think there was a clear call to action of

1031
01:32:02.640 --> 01:32:07.840
anyone knows how to build a super high performance to cloud flare levels layer one. You know,

1032
01:32:07.840 --> 01:32:13.840
you know, contact cloud flare contact Matthew guys got to let you know, of course,

1033
01:32:13.840 --> 01:32:18.320
crypto is risky. So is the entire internet. You can lose what you put in, but we are headed west.

1034
01:32:18.320 --> 01:32:22.080
This is the frontier. It's not for everyone. But we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey.

1035
01:32:22.080 --> 01:32:23.600
Thanks a lot.
