WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.151 --> 00:00:03.955
Two different children, two different babies born on the same day today, okay?

2
00:00:04.015 --> 00:00:05.176
In two different places, though.

3
00:00:05.456 --> 00:00:08.759
One born in Norway, one born in Sierra Leone, okay?

4
00:00:08.979 --> 00:00:10.040
Let me just give you some hard facts.

5
00:00:10.060 --> 00:00:10.981
Like you said, it's measurable.

6
00:00:11.021 --> 00:00:14.524
Let me give you some hard facts of, like, what that looks like at their starting points.

7
00:00:14.764 --> 00:00:17.166
The first one, let's say they're born in Oslo in Norway, okay?

8
00:00:17.887 --> 00:00:22.609
She will statistically, she has a very high chance of living to about 83 years old.

9
00:00:22.809 --> 00:00:22.929
Okay.

10
00:00:22.949 --> 00:00:24.509
That's her life expectancy at birth.

11
00:00:24.890 --> 00:00:32.052
She'll have access to free healthcare, free university education, one of the strongest social safety nets that's ever been built by humanity.

12
00:00:32.192 --> 00:00:34.213
She has access to that from day one, right?

13
00:00:35.293 --> 00:00:39.217
Her country's GDP per capita is about $82,000 per person.

14
00:00:39.477 --> 00:00:45.081
Childhood mortality risk, which is like the likelihood that she'll die before the age of five, is only two in 1,000.

15
00:00:45.302 --> 00:00:52.808
The infrastructure she has access to, like the roads there and hospitals and education, all of that is top rate.

16
00:00:53.568 --> 00:00:54.990
Some of the best you can find in the world, right?

17
00:00:55.290 --> 00:00:56.431
Obviously, she didn't choose any of that.

18
00:00:56.451 --> 00:00:57.111
Yeah.

19
00:00:57.352 --> 00:00:57.612
Right?

20
00:00:58.988 --> 00:01:02.410
Compare that to a child born the same day in Freetown, Sierra Leone.

21
00:01:03.010 --> 00:01:03.310
Okay.

22
00:01:03.550 --> 00:01:05.551
Life expectancy there at birth is 62.

23
00:01:05.712 --> 00:01:08.913
So full 21 years shorter than Norway.

24
00:01:09.033 --> 00:01:12.335
Country's GDP is about $800 per person per year.

25
00:01:12.615 --> 00:01:15.837
So about 100 times, more than 100 times less than in Norway.

26
00:01:16.768 --> 00:01:21.191
Childhood mortality risk is 94 in 1,000 compared to two in 1,000.

27
00:01:21.211 --> 00:01:23.833
Okay, so 47 times worse.

28
00:01:24.033 --> 00:01:33.959
The infrastructure, there's really, education is lacking access to healthcare, roads, recent civil war, lots of violence, no guarantees of safety.

29
00:01:34.679 --> 00:01:36.300
All of that is very, very present, okay?

30
00:01:36.401 --> 00:01:42.665
When we say, oh, this heaven look, like obviously if you're gonna choose, you'd wanna be born in Norway over Sierra Leone.

31
00:01:43.185 --> 00:01:44.226
Yes, those are stark differences.

32
00:01:44.986 --> 00:01:46.988
But what do we do with that information, Mark?

33
00:01:47.288 --> 00:01:50.050
Like, how are we supposed to think about that?

34
00:01:50.150 --> 00:01:52.852
You can look at that and you say, well, we're shit out of luck, right?

35
00:01:52.952 --> 00:01:55.594
There's a fatalism to it that's very easy to go to.

36
00:01:55.694 --> 00:01:57.356
But is that the right reaction?

37
00:01:57.656 --> 00:01:57.916
Yeah.

38
00:01:57.996 --> 00:02:02.240
And like we talked about in chapter one, our natural inclination is...

39
00:02:03.080 --> 00:02:13.482
the just world hypothesis, which is that whenever we see a large disparity between people, we assume that something unfair is happening or that it is inherently unfair.

40
00:02:13.522 --> 00:02:16.863
Maybe it is, but to your question of like, what do we do with that?

41
00:02:17.603 --> 00:02:25.065
I think it's ultimately, as with anything outside of our control, the best we can do is find a way to accept it and leverage it.

42
00:02:25.245 --> 00:02:30.646
I want to come back to this comparison because this idea of luck and who is lucky is,

43
00:02:30.886 --> 00:02:36.848
So there's a philosopher named John Rawls, and he has this amazing concept that he called the veil of ignorance.

44
00:02:36.948 --> 00:02:44.309
And basically what Rawls argued was that the only way to tell how just a society was was by doing a thought experiment.

45
00:02:44.329 --> 00:02:53.712
And that thought experiment was assume that you're not born yet and you get to choose which society you're going to be born into, not knowing what individuals you're going to be born as.

46
00:02:53.732 --> 00:02:54.312
So you don't know.

47
00:02:54.772 --> 00:03:01.336
Your gender, race, ethnicity, what your family situation is going to be like, what your talent is going to be like, what your IQ is going to be.

48
00:03:01.536 --> 00:03:07.720
The simple question is, is when presented with a society, would you choose to be born into that society or not?

49
00:03:08.321 --> 00:03:18.347
Now, from a veil of ignorance perspective, obviously, if offered the chance to be born into Norway or be born into Sierra Leone, I think pretty much everybody would choose to be born into Norway.

50
00:03:19.041 --> 00:03:26.787
But that doesn't mean that every single person in Norway is luckier than every single person in Sierra Leone, right?

51
00:03:26.847 --> 00:03:35.915
So you could be born into Norway and, I don't know, be born with some chronic disease or get cancer at the age of five or something and die when you're seven.

52
00:03:36.315 --> 00:03:44.462
Whereas in Sierra Leone, you know, there's plenty of stories of people who have overcome incredible hardship and actually become very fortunate.

53
00:03:44.482 --> 00:03:47.744
There was a story that I found about a local pastor who...

54
00:03:48.805 --> 00:03:58.569
was digging through a local riverbed looking for essentially gold dust and happened to stumble across the second largest diamond ever found.

55
00:03:59.270 --> 00:04:02.811
It was worth close to $10 million.

56
00:04:02.891 --> 00:04:06.733
And then this pasture ended up netting about two and a half million dollars for his trouble.

57
00:04:07.053 --> 00:04:10.675
Keep in mind, this isn't a country that they make less than a thousand dollars a year.

58
00:04:10.995 --> 00:04:12.216
And he just landed two

59
00:04:13.476 --> 00:04:13.676
Right.

60
00:04:13.736 --> 00:04:15.317
And he did all sorts of amazing things.

61
00:04:15.337 --> 00:04:22.699
He built schools, community centers, built roads, infrastructure for the community, gave a bunch of money away to friends and family and local children.

62
00:04:22.959 --> 00:04:24.199
Would you say he's lucky?

63
00:04:25.459 --> 00:04:25.800
Right.

64
00:04:27.360 --> 00:04:34.762
He's actually luckier than most other people on the planet, even though he was born into an extremely unlucky circumstance.

65
00:04:35.422 --> 00:04:40.864
And the reason I bring this up is that luck is ultimately simply a comparison between people.

66
00:04:41.804 --> 00:04:44.446
Reality and potential alternatives.

67
00:04:45.006 --> 00:04:48.628
And so by definition, luck is always relative.

68
00:04:49.208 --> 00:04:53.731
Like if you're saying that he's unlucky or he's lucky, it's lucky compared to what?

69
00:04:54.491 --> 00:04:55.732
Unlucky compared to what?

70
00:04:56.970 --> 00:05:01.553
Yes, it's unlucky to be born in Sierra Leone today versus being born into Norway today.

71
00:05:02.394 --> 00:05:07.917
But it's also lucky to be born in Sierra Leone today versus born there when there was a civil war raging.

72
00:05:08.438 --> 00:05:13.381
Or a hundred years ago when there was zero infrastructure and rampant colonialism.

73
00:05:13.801 --> 00:05:15.963
Or a thousand years ago where, like, you had...

74
00:05:16.743 --> 00:05:22.689
absolutely no basic services and the life expectancy was probably like 25 years old, right?

75
00:05:22.729 --> 00:05:25.853
So it's like lucky compared to what?

76
00:05:26.093 --> 00:05:33.040
The most important takeaway of heaven luck is that luck is ultimately a perspective.

77
00:05:33.361 --> 00:05:36.063
It's a frame of reference that you choose to adopt.

78
00:05:36.204 --> 00:05:36.364
It's a

79
00:05:39.527 --> 00:05:42.188
your life versus whatever else.

80
00:05:42.508 --> 00:05:48.049
You know, there's this old Chinese fable about the farmer and the horse, which I think illustrates this perfectly.

81
00:05:48.249 --> 00:05:54.031
So basically there was a poor farmer in ancient China and all he had was a single horse.

82
00:05:54.851 --> 00:06:01.153
And one day that horse runs away and his son comes running in, says, dad, dad, our horse is gone.

83
00:06:01.673 --> 00:06:02.453
This is terrible.

84
00:06:02.973 --> 00:06:03.914
We're so unlucky.

85
00:06:04.294 --> 00:06:07.855
And the farmer looks at his son and he says, good luck, bad luck.

86
00:06:08.715 --> 00:06:09.075
Who knows?

87
00:06:09.415 --> 00:06:15.319
And so the son goes looking for the horse, and he, like, wanders out into the wilderness, and he comes back the next day with five horses.

88
00:06:15.579 --> 00:06:22.302
Turns out that the horse that ran away went and found a bunch of horsey friends, and they hung out and had a little party, and then they came back together.

89
00:06:22.903 --> 00:06:24.303
So his son comes back, and he's got five.

90
00:06:24.343 --> 00:06:26.244
He's like, Dad, oh, my God, I can't believe it.

91
00:06:26.284 --> 00:06:27.565
We have five horses now.

92
00:06:27.585 --> 00:06:28.125
We're rich.

93
00:06:28.305 --> 00:06:29.186
We're so lucky.

94
00:06:30.086 --> 00:06:32.788
And the farmer looks at him and says, hmm, good luck, bad luck.

95
00:06:33.488 --> 00:06:33.808
Who knows?

96
00:06:33.828 --> 00:06:34.869
Who knows?

97
00:06:35.009 --> 00:06:40.572
So then the son starts spending the next couple of weeks trying to train these wild horses, trying to tame them and get them to do farm work.

98
00:06:40.732 --> 00:06:49.257
And one day one of the horses rears up and kicks him off the back and the son falls and breaks his leg and the farmer's poor.

99
00:06:49.297 --> 00:06:50.598
So he has no, no other workers.

100
00:06:50.658 --> 00:06:51.518
It's just him and his son.

101
00:06:51.578 --> 00:06:53.800
And so the son is like, oh my God, dad, this is terrible.

102
00:06:53.820 --> 00:06:55.240
This is, we're so unlucky.

103
00:06:55.380 --> 00:06:56.461
I can't believe this happened to us.

104
00:06:57.361 --> 00:06:59.523
The farmer says, uh, good luck, bad luck.

105
00:06:59.563 --> 00:06:59.923
Who knows?

106
00:07:01.386 --> 00:07:05.091
And then a week later, the local militia comes through.

107
00:07:05.131 --> 00:07:14.383
There's a war has started, and the local lord or king of the local fiefdom is, like, recruiting, drafting young men into his army.

108
00:07:14.623 --> 00:07:19.790
They see the farmer's son sitting there with a broken leg, and they're like, oh, well, we can't draft him into the war, so...

109
00:07:20.430 --> 00:07:21.691
you know, we'll, we'll leave them here.

110
00:07:21.871 --> 00:07:22.972
And the son looks up at his daddy.

111
00:07:22.992 --> 00:07:24.834
He's like, Oh my God, we're so lucky dad.

112
00:07:24.894 --> 00:07:26.855
This is, thank God this happened.

113
00:07:27.175 --> 00:07:30.138
And his dad says, good luck, bad luck, who knows?

114
00:07:30.758 --> 00:07:32.319
And the story goes on and on and on.

115
00:07:32.359 --> 00:07:34.421
And it just keeps shifting back and forth.

116
00:07:34.461 --> 00:07:34.641
Right.

117
00:07:34.661 --> 00:07:41.106
And it's like the same exact occurrence is both lucky and unlucky, depending on the frame of

118
00:07:45.189 --> 00:07:47.951
that you can imagine that has not happened.

119
00:07:48.151 --> 00:08:02.120
And so in this sense, both feeling lucky and feeling unlucky is available to us in every moment, depending on simply what alternative realities we choose to imagine for ourselves.

120
00:08:02.460 --> 00:08:05.742
And as we'll see, this has very significant consequences.

121
00:08:05.762 --> 00:08:07.484
Hey everybody, that's it.

122
00:08:07.584 --> 00:08:08.424
The clip is over.

123
00:08:08.524 --> 00:08:10.045
This comes from The Solve Podcast.

124
00:08:10.065 --> 00:08:12.547
You can get the whole chapter and it's sitting right here.