WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.171 --> 00:00:04.134
fuck sitting around watching the end of the world as if it was a series finale.

2
00:00:04.455 --> 00:00:12.681
Like there is absolutely where, like Doom wants you unhappy, Doom wants you stuck at home in a hoodie that smells like despair.

3
00:00:13.061 --> 00:00:14.963
Doom wants you inactive.

4
00:00:15.263 --> 00:00:21.308
In fact, Doom is extremely similar to Denial in its impacts.

5
00:00:21.488 --> 00:00:23.470
Denial says it's not happening.

6
00:00:23.550 --> 00:00:25.191
Doom says there's nothing you can do about it.

7
00:00:25.591 --> 00:00:27.633
In practical terms, they're exactly the same thing.

8
00:00:28.494 --> 00:00:30.275
because the outcome is nobody does anything.

9
00:00:30.656 --> 00:00:40.284
So if you've been angry at climate denial your whole life... Solitaire and Lucy, thank you very much for joining me on the Climate Unfugged podcast.

10
00:00:41.385 --> 00:00:42.286
Well, it's lovely to be here.

11
00:00:42.707 --> 00:00:43.908
Yes, ditto.

12
00:00:45.429 --> 00:00:46.450
I think we're gonna have a lot of fun.

13
00:00:46.870 --> 00:00:52.416
We want to talk about solutions about optimism about things we're excited about in this episode.

14
00:00:52.476 --> 00:00:55.439
And we've each brought something to talk about that we're excited about.

15
00:00:55.719 --> 00:01:02.847
But before we get into it, could I just ask you to introduce yourself to the person listening and the solution that you're going to talk about, please?

16
00:01:03.087 --> 00:01:04.008
Solly, do you want to go first?

17
00:01:04.468 --> 00:01:06.150
So my name is Solitaire Townsend.

18
00:01:06.190 --> 00:01:06.910
Please call me Solly.

19
00:01:07.471 --> 00:01:12.475
I love the topic of this podcast because my job title is Chief Solutionist.

20
00:01:13.135 --> 00:01:16.638
So I literally have solutions in the name.

21
00:01:17.038 --> 00:01:25.285
And I'm the Chief Solutionist of Futera, which is a worldwide agency in London and New York and Mexico, etc.,

22
00:01:25.945 --> 00:01:32.614
And also I'm the chair of trustees of a charity called the Futera Solutions Union, which is also all about solutions.

23
00:01:32.634 --> 00:01:34.817
You'll notice a theme beginning to emerge here.

24
00:01:35.277 --> 00:01:40.644
I've been working in sustainability for about 30 years and I've always been really, really focused on the answers.

25
00:01:40.684 --> 00:01:42.447
I think there's a lot of people focused on the problem.

26
00:01:42.887 --> 00:01:43.968
I want to be focused on the answers.

27
00:01:44.549 --> 00:01:49.430
And the solution I want to bring is not a piece of technology or a fantastic project.

28
00:01:49.690 --> 00:01:50.951
There's lots and lots and lots of those.

29
00:01:51.531 --> 00:01:58.052
It's more a movement that is beginning to get rolling in the creative economy.

30
00:01:58.512 --> 00:02:04.594
So I'm here to talk about filmmakers and scriptwriters and novelists and musicians.

31
00:02:05.174 --> 00:02:08.415
And this huge upswing that is beginning to happen.

32
00:02:08.795 --> 00:02:14.400
within that creative economy of dealing with climate solutions and storytelling.

33
00:02:14.681 --> 00:02:19.885
Climate problems, storytelling, there's a lot of them, you know, day after tomorrow, don't look up, etc.

34
00:02:20.166 --> 00:02:24.169
You know, climate disaster is quite easy to cover within storytelling.

35
00:02:24.449 --> 00:02:26.571
But I want to talk about storytelling and solutions.

36
00:02:27.733 --> 00:02:28.073
Awesome.

37
00:02:28.353 --> 00:02:28.914
I can't wait.

38
00:02:29.554 --> 00:02:30.275
Do you want to go, Lucy?

39
00:02:31.457 --> 00:02:34.340
Yes, I'm Lucy Siegel, obviously.

40
00:02:34.540 --> 00:02:36.882
I called Solly Sally there because it's a little joke.

41
00:02:37.923 --> 00:02:39.405
I've known her for a long time.

42
00:02:39.465 --> 00:02:40.225
She's brilliant.

43
00:02:40.326 --> 00:02:41.907
I'm very excited to be here with her.

44
00:02:41.927 --> 00:02:49.014
I am a journalist, broadcaster and communications advisor.

45
00:02:49.775 --> 00:02:54.960
And I am obsessed with storytelling in the climate and nature space.

46
00:02:54.980 --> 00:02:55.480
Yeah.

47
00:02:55.900 --> 00:03:02.224
I have been lucky enough to talk to a very mainstream audience.

48
00:03:02.405 --> 00:03:05.827
So I've been involved with a show called The One Show for 20 years.

49
00:03:07.068 --> 00:03:15.273
And I've done a lot of other writing, started in newspapers, actually started in a textile factory, but then went to newspapers.

50
00:03:15.673 --> 00:03:18.095
So anyway, that's all in the past.

51
00:03:18.435 --> 00:03:20.677
But I'm really, really obsessed with it.

52
00:03:21.177 --> 00:03:24.201
with the mechanics of storytelling.

53
00:03:24.862 --> 00:03:34.534
And I'm really excited how creative it is becoming because some of the traditional gatekeepers are being bypassed, which is always a great thing.

54
00:03:34.554 --> 00:03:36.436
I have chosen two.

55
00:03:39.860 --> 00:03:41.082
um, examples.

56
00:03:41.102 --> 00:03:53.115
Um, and I think they are sort of classic solutions, but also have a lot of ingredients that are under acknowledged and ignored and very, very exciting.

57
00:03:53.455 --> 00:03:55.758
So, um, I hope you enjoy them.

58
00:03:56.739 --> 00:03:57.019
Oh, yeah.

59
00:03:58.237 --> 00:04:01.059
Okay, so we can get into those as quick as possible.

60
00:04:01.960 --> 00:04:14.049
But so that someone has a kind of overview of what we're talking about, I think if we could just spend five minutes talking about the less obvious reasons for why this matters.

61
00:04:14.590 --> 00:04:24.657
And I was thinking of, I don't know if I will, but I was thinking of titling this episode, if you're feeling doomism or depressed about the climate crisis, about climate change, watch this.

62
00:04:24.677 --> 00:04:24.958
Yeah.

63
00:04:25.783 --> 00:04:33.070
And there's the obvious reasons for why we can think about solutions and focusing on them is helpful.

64
00:04:33.150 --> 00:04:41.379
But are there any kind of less obvious reasons that come to mind for why we should be doing this and doing it a lot more?

65
00:04:41.959 --> 00:04:43.921
Whoever wants to take that, that has a...

66
00:04:44.782 --> 00:04:45.643
and answer it.

67
00:04:45.803 --> 00:04:48.425
I'll jump in because this is my life.

68
00:04:49.125 --> 00:05:00.614
And I think we should just remind ourselves of the obvious reasons, which is, for example, 50%, 5-0%, 50% of people under 30 now think that we're doomed.

69
00:05:00.794 --> 00:05:01.154
That's it.

70
00:05:01.255 --> 00:05:02.375
They think that there is no future.

71
00:05:02.696 --> 00:05:06.999
Now, first of all, that's absolutely awful in terms of their lives and their wellbeing, their mental health.

72
00:05:07.019 --> 00:05:07.079
And

73
00:05:07.319 --> 00:05:08.541
Secondly, it's not true.

74
00:05:08.901 --> 00:05:10.463
We have no idea what will happen in the future.

75
00:05:10.503 --> 00:05:11.545
We have got some trends.

76
00:05:11.565 --> 00:05:13.447
We've got some terrible things which are happening.

77
00:05:13.467 --> 00:05:14.989
We've got some wonderful things that are happening.

78
00:05:15.290 --> 00:05:18.975
You know, aliens could come down tomorrow and solve it all for us or we could be hit by an asteroid.

79
00:05:19.195 --> 00:05:22.700
Nobody can actually prophesize the future.

80
00:05:23.180 --> 00:05:28.486
But the one thing which we do know is that when people give up, that is a given to bad things happening.

81
00:05:28.726 --> 00:05:37.256
Like the only defining characteristic of whether we win this or lose this or win it in a complicated way or lose it in a complicated way is whether people work or don't work.

82
00:05:37.796 --> 00:05:42.221
And so the fact that 50% of young people, that's why we have no youth climate movement anymore.

83
00:05:42.561 --> 00:05:44.023
They think they failed and they've given up.

84
00:05:44.363 --> 00:05:52.111
It's why politics has swung the way that it has, is that you've got a whole load of young people who are no longer speaking, protesting.

85
00:05:52.151 --> 00:05:57.757
I mean, there's still some amazing ones, and I get to work with a lot of amazing ones, but that huge movement has gone because they think that they failed.

86
00:05:58.337 --> 00:06:02.502
And, you know, this is the one place, the one podcast I can probably wear this without getting told off.

87
00:06:03.162 --> 00:06:06.325
But it's one of the reasons why we run our, am I allowed to say this?

88
00:06:06.385 --> 00:06:06.645
Fuck?

89
00:06:07.066 --> 00:06:07.606
Fuck Doom campaign.

90
00:06:07.646 --> 00:06:08.467
I mean, it's in the name.

91
00:06:08.547 --> 00:06:10.168
You're welcome to say it as much as you want.

92
00:06:10.368 --> 00:06:12.390
It's why we run our Fuck Doom campaign.

93
00:06:12.490 --> 00:06:15.332
Because I used to run campaigns called hope.

94
00:06:15.913 --> 00:06:20.817
And like hope and optimism and climate optimism and what have you, which don't feel quite right for the moment.

95
00:06:21.157 --> 00:06:25.341
And this actually came from one of the younger people that I work with, which is around Fuck Doom.

96
00:06:26.161 --> 00:06:32.249
And the way she said it was that she's grown up with there just being one story.

97
00:06:32.589 --> 00:06:36.855
The only story is it's all over, it's all over, it's all over, it's all over, it's all over, it's all over.

98
00:06:36.895 --> 00:06:37.876
That's the only story.

99
00:06:38.296 --> 00:06:41.020
And it's like the beginning of a movie when this,

100
00:06:41.240 --> 00:06:45.462
big problem has been found out and they've discovered this big, awful problem.

101
00:06:45.582 --> 00:06:49.785
And then you hit what in storytelling, what's called, that's the inciting incident.

102
00:06:50.145 --> 00:06:56.168
The inciting incident is this big revelation, this thing's happened, this someone's called out this big problem.

103
00:06:56.228 --> 00:07:01.351
That's the inciting incident, which then starts the whole rest of the story, which is where all the interesting things happen.

104
00:07:01.371 --> 00:07:02.832
I wonder what we do about that problem.

105
00:07:03.172 --> 00:07:08.875
But in our world and particularly in the climate movement, we're stuck at that inciting incident, that call to action.

106
00:07:09.355 --> 00:07:11.397
that things are fucked, we've got to do something about it.

107
00:07:11.958 --> 00:07:18.404
And we've been stuck there for 30 years of increasingly shouting about the inciting incident.

108
00:07:19.084 --> 00:07:25.290
But of course, in storytelling, the inciting incident is just the thing that gets people to think that something's happening.

109
00:07:25.670 --> 00:07:28.273
It's not the thing that makes them take action.

110
00:07:29.013 --> 00:07:32.598
So you need to have all of these other things which are taking place.

111
00:07:33.159 --> 00:07:37.044
And human beings are homo narrativium.

112
00:07:37.204 --> 00:07:38.326
We are the storytelling ape.

113
00:07:38.927 --> 00:07:41.750
Storytelling is absolutely part of it, who it is.

114
00:07:41.770 --> 00:07:45.635
We teach our children stories before we teach them to count by years.

115
00:07:46.977 --> 00:07:57.881
And so one of the things which we've been trying to do is try to move us on out of Act 1 and into Act 2 of this adventure story of how do we solve what's actually happening?

116
00:07:57.941 --> 00:07:59.102
How do we face into it?

117
00:07:59.402 --> 00:08:06.625
There will be challenges, there will be losses, there will be unexpected allies, there will be gatekeepers, there will be things which we need to do, but how do we move that on?

118
00:08:07.165 --> 00:08:15.827
And I think that that's the thing, the small unexpected negative of all the do, is that people don't have a story.

119
00:08:16.087 --> 00:08:18.807
They have just the start of the story.

120
00:08:18.847 --> 00:08:24.168
They don't have the narrative architecture to be able to move on to something else.

121
00:08:24.668 --> 00:08:27.729
And human beings need that narrative architecture.

122
00:08:27.769 --> 00:08:29.129
We need that story.

123
00:08:29.149 --> 00:08:35.890
We need to know what the narrative urgency is for the next thing in order to be able to act.

124
00:08:36.130 --> 00:08:39.812
So yes, I'm going to take this off, even though it's going to have mucked my hair up because it's a bit hot in this room.

125
00:08:40.192 --> 00:08:46.254
But this idea of kind of, you know, fuck sitting around watching the end of the world as if it was a series finale.

126
00:08:46.575 --> 00:08:51.377
Like there is absolutely, like Doom wants you unhappy.

127
00:08:51.457 --> 00:08:54.798
Doom wants you stuck at home in a hoodie that smells like despair.

128
00:08:55.178 --> 00:08:57.079
Doom wants you inactive.

129
00:08:57.399 --> 00:09:03.402
In fact, Doom is extremely similar to denial in its impacts.

130
00:09:04.803 --> 00:09:07.464
One denial says it's not happening.

131
00:09:07.544 --> 00:09:09.206
Doom says there's nothing you can do about it.

132
00:09:09.586 --> 00:09:14.309
In practical terms, they're exactly the same thing because the outcome is nobody does anything.

133
00:09:14.689 --> 00:09:22.214
So if you've been angry at climate denial your whole life, you should be equally as angry at climate doom because the result is the same.

134
00:09:22.474 --> 00:09:23.575
People do nothing.

135
00:09:23.895 --> 00:09:28.178
And that's why we've got to get on with actually the adventure story of solving this.

136
00:09:29.190 --> 00:09:32.111
I'm going to take my hat off now and you can see me with hat hair.

137
00:09:32.491 --> 00:09:32.711
Yeah.

138
00:09:32.731 --> 00:09:33.111
Go on then.

139
00:09:33.292 --> 00:09:35.412
I love the hat.

140
00:09:35.552 --> 00:09:36.133
Do you sell them?

141
00:09:36.153 --> 00:09:37.533
Can I get one?

142
00:09:37.753 --> 00:09:40.494
That's very good hat hair.

143
00:09:40.594 --> 00:09:46.957
We give the fuck Doom hats and the stickers and the water bottles away at our big events that we do with the creative industry.

144
00:09:47.297 --> 00:09:50.798
But enough people have asked me, I'm actually thinking of turning them into a little business.

145
00:09:51.118 --> 00:09:54.001
I'm actually selling them because so many people want them.

146
00:09:54.141 --> 00:09:56.523
And they're all, of course, ethical and environmental and recycled.

147
00:09:56.843 --> 00:09:58.985
But I'm like, actually, we need to get those out.

148
00:09:59.166 --> 00:10:08.795
And the best bit about it is wearing them around at COP or wearing them around during New York Climate Week or London Climate Week because people who don't work in the climate movement stop me and ask them,

149
00:10:09.375 --> 00:10:13.157
what's about and ends up having a conversation, which never happens.

150
00:10:13.197 --> 00:10:14.998
You never end up having a conversation.

151
00:10:15.379 --> 00:10:20.102
And I was at an event where one of the waiters was like, what's that?

152
00:10:20.342 --> 00:10:25.625
When I was wearing the fact of my hat, I said, oh, it's about the fact that we can't, you know, keep going the way that we're going.

153
00:10:26.065 --> 00:10:28.587
kind of ignoring climate change and just putting up with the fact of the underworld.

154
00:10:28.607 --> 00:10:32.150
He goes, oh, thank God, because all I've heard all week is that we're all going to die.

155
00:10:32.170 --> 00:10:34.292
I was like, oh, my God.

156
00:10:34.552 --> 00:10:45.961
We're not even bringing the people who are in the rooms with us, even if they might not have a formal role in that room in terms of the content, and people who are cleaning up around us, who are serving the drinks.

157
00:10:46.322 --> 00:10:52.827
If we're not bringing those people with us when we're having these climate conversations, how the hell are we expected to bring people beyond those rooms?

158
00:10:53.047 --> 00:10:54.909
So anyway, I feel kind of passionate about it.

159
00:10:56.543 --> 00:10:57.264
I can tell.

160
00:10:57.284 --> 00:10:59.547
Go on, listen.

161
00:10:59.587 --> 00:11:01.589
We should say that we are all going to die.

162
00:11:03.231 --> 00:11:03.972
Eventually, yes.

163
00:11:04.352 --> 00:11:06.415
Every single one of us, eventually, yes.

164
00:11:06.475 --> 00:11:09.639
But hopefully not all at the same time and for the same reason.

165
00:11:10.865 --> 00:11:19.970
Except for that man who injects himself with stuff and does, you know, ice baths a million times a day and gets far too much attention, in my opinion.

166
00:11:20.210 --> 00:11:22.951
Oh, not least because he looks about 60.

167
00:11:22.991 --> 00:11:23.671
Brian Johnson.

168
00:11:23.971 --> 00:11:27.153
It's just like everyone says, oh, he's got the body of 18 years old.

169
00:11:27.173 --> 00:11:31.055
It's like, I'm sorry, if I saw that man in the street, I would say 60 years old.

170
00:11:31.135 --> 00:11:32.896
He does not look healthy.

171
00:11:33.468 --> 00:11:35.010
He looks really stressed as well.

172
00:11:35.070 --> 00:11:43.459
It's like, surely this kind of infinite quest to get the body of an 18-year-old and end up with a 60-year-old.

173
00:11:43.799 --> 00:11:45.841
I mean, that's a sad story for him, actually.

174
00:11:46.001 --> 00:11:47.563
That's a doom story for him.

175
00:11:48.204 --> 00:11:48.504
Yeah.

176
00:11:49.105 --> 00:11:50.606
Brian, if you're watching...

177
00:11:52.515 --> 00:11:53.816
perspective, my love.

178
00:11:54.856 --> 00:11:56.637
Eat a pie or maybe a muffin.

179
00:11:57.337 --> 00:11:58.178
Eat a muffin.

180
00:11:58.198 --> 00:11:59.878
Start with a muffin and then do a pie.

181
00:11:59.939 --> 00:12:03.140
Don't go straight in with the pie because that's too much for you, Brian.

182
00:12:03.660 --> 00:12:04.060
Okay.

183
00:12:04.281 --> 00:12:14.745
So I think a really good example, Rob, of what Solly is so beautifully articulating is what's happened recently.

184
00:12:14.825 --> 00:12:17.607
So we go through five heat waves in the UK and,

185
00:12:18.715 --> 00:12:28.939
And, you know, you'll know, I'm sure you've had these conversations where I have a friend who used to be a climate denier and now he's flipped the other way.

186
00:12:29.939 --> 00:12:32.460
And I was like, oh, your garden's looking nice, Tony.

187
00:12:32.480 --> 00:12:35.541
Fucked because of climate change, isn't it?

188
00:12:36.482 --> 00:12:37.462
Not going to be able to water it.

189
00:12:39.107 --> 00:12:39.748
Oh, okay.

190
00:12:39.888 --> 00:12:40.368
Sorry.

191
00:12:40.388 --> 00:12:42.570
I thought you didn't believe in climate change.

192
00:12:42.650 --> 00:12:43.350
And now you do.

193
00:12:43.370 --> 00:12:44.271
Well, we're all doomed.

194
00:12:44.431 --> 00:12:49.615
So you flip from the denial to the doomism, which, you know, is, Solly is exactly right.

195
00:12:49.675 --> 00:12:52.797
If you feel strongly about denialism, you should feel strongly about doomism.

196
00:12:53.157 --> 00:12:53.638
I love that.

197
00:12:53.658 --> 00:12:56.039
I think that's so like on point.

198
00:12:56.279 --> 00:12:58.941
I think that one of the things, what was the original question?

199
00:12:58.981 --> 00:12:59.442
Sorry, Rob.

200
00:13:00.943 --> 00:13:15.154
I mean, Soli made a good point about speaking about the obvious reasons, but the question about the less obvious reasons why this matters for someone feeling doomism or depressing about the state of the climate.

201
00:13:15.394 --> 00:13:16.095
Oh, I see.

202
00:13:16.235 --> 00:13:19.838
The importance of the optimism stuff, but the less obvious ones.

203
00:13:20.425 --> 00:13:20.685
Yes.

204
00:13:20.845 --> 00:13:22.987
So I don't like enforced positivity.

205
00:13:25.848 --> 00:13:29.250
I think that that is can be problematic, actually.

206
00:13:30.391 --> 00:13:32.532
But optimism is something different.

207
00:13:33.153 --> 00:13:36.395
And optimism is a political act at this point.

208
00:13:37.415 --> 00:13:48.918
And it's extremely, extremely important because of the currents of denialism, doomism, and who they serve.

209
00:13:49.158 --> 00:13:50.819
So this all comes back to who they serve.

210
00:13:51.499 --> 00:13:58.020
So this is not a particularly clever sort of answer about like, I'm not unearthing something that you won't have thought of before.

211
00:13:58.901 --> 00:13:59.381
But...

212
00:14:00.535 --> 00:14:11.479
Why we are feeling a certain way has a lot to do with the way that we're being led by the culture, by the politics and by the flows of money.

213
00:14:11.559 --> 00:14:12.619
So I'm a journalist.

214
00:14:12.799 --> 00:14:16.221
OK, so the job is essentially follow the money.

215
00:14:16.681 --> 00:14:17.961
That is the job.

216
00:14:18.682 --> 00:14:19.322
And actually.

217
00:14:20.302 --> 00:14:31.372
One of the things that I really, really like about climate and nature and why I came in to report on this realm in the first place was that you don't follow the money, which is actually a bit boring.

218
00:14:31.392 --> 00:14:37.157
And you need to know a lot of technical stuff about financial markets, which are outside of my pea brains ability.

219
00:14:37.257 --> 00:14:42.862
But I like to follow the oil, which for some reason feels a lot more important.

220
00:14:43.863 --> 00:14:44.704
native to me.

221
00:14:44.764 --> 00:14:45.505
That's really weird.

222
00:14:45.745 --> 00:14:48.668
My granddad worked for Shell in the refinery, so maybe that's why.

223
00:14:50.810 --> 00:14:54.534
A lot of us in the UK are from oil and chemicals.

224
00:14:54.754 --> 00:14:59.999
Our grandparents worked in heavy industries, great-grandparents coal mining.

225
00:15:00.239 --> 00:15:02.661
My great-grandparents were tin miners and Cornwall.

226
00:15:03.582 --> 00:15:10.112
Um, so we were, we're, we're from a very industrial landscape, you know, or we all, you know, we were in service.

227
00:15:10.813 --> 00:15:15.701
We were, you know, maids and butlers and all of that sort of Downton Abbey kind of stuff.

228
00:15:15.721 --> 00:15:18.585
So we have a very, um, um,

229
00:15:19.966 --> 00:15:23.168
uh, loaded heritage in the UK, which I'll come back to maybe.

230
00:15:23.208 --> 00:15:34.913
But so the point is that we are in a system where the solution stories are not embedded in the culture because a lot of the time they're not getting through.

231
00:15:36.795 --> 00:15:50.642
So one of the things Solly mentioned, the lack of youth movement now, if we look at Just Stop Oil and we see that wasn't just a youth movement, you know, there were, you know, 80 year old vicars who got arrested and imprisoned, tried and imprisoned.

232
00:15:52.062 --> 00:15:55.764
I was lucky enough to be at Sheffield Documentary Festival at the start of the summer.

233
00:15:56.084 --> 00:16:01.527
And We the Hated was the headline documentary, which is an incredible project.

234
00:16:02.507 --> 00:16:26.184
feature length piece about um uh just stop oil in the final days um and it's actually really funny in parts as well by the way but I think I looked at it and I thought actually that a lot of these people were very successful and they're they're they're shown as a failure now hello Gus but actually I'll finish this thought because otherwise I'll never get it back Gus and

235
00:16:28.745 --> 00:16:31.306
But they were actually really successful at doing one thing.

236
00:16:31.386 --> 00:16:50.715
If you look at the data over media coverage, we got onto a parity with things like the television industry has run this survey for many years in the UK through Albert, where they basically like use subtitles and count mentions of climate change and nature and all the rest of it.

237
00:16:51.135 --> 00:16:55.037
And for many years, we were below mentions of ghosts and cake.

238
00:16:56.818 --> 00:17:01.461
While Just Stop Oil were active, we were at the same.

239
00:17:01.481 --> 00:17:03.582
We had parity with Ghosts and Cake.

240
00:17:04.523 --> 00:17:20.495
Reuters subsequently to Just Stop Oil and other Fridays for the Future and other ending of youth movements and direct action movements, Reuters has described coverage in the UK of climate and nature topics as being in terminal decline.

241
00:17:20.515 --> 00:17:20.675
Yeah.

242
00:17:21.095 --> 00:17:26.598
So that will explain why some people are feeling all they get is doom because doom still breaks through.

243
00:17:26.999 --> 00:17:31.742
We know that phrase, if it bleeds, it leads, that old sort of Fleet Street phrase.

244
00:17:32.082 --> 00:17:40.267
It is still true because there's a lot of the equipment and architecture of news in particular can hang its hat on a tragedy like Nepal.

245
00:17:40.287 --> 00:17:43.189
You bring in your politics, you bring in your environment correspondence.

246
00:17:43.509 --> 00:17:44.930
It's like all hands on decks.

247
00:17:44.970 --> 00:17:46.791
That's how we are configured to work.

248
00:17:47.191 --> 00:17:56.448
So that's one of the reasons why we really, really need to look at the balance of stories and why solution stories are not as prevalent in the mix and why people end up feeling as they feel.

249
00:17:57.340 --> 00:17:57.600
Yeah.

250
00:17:58.481 --> 00:17:58.701
Wow.

251
00:17:58.981 --> 00:17:59.361
Awesome.

252
00:17:59.802 --> 00:18:04.305
Lucy, this is why you're the journalist, because I'm like, we've got to change it.

253
00:18:04.445 --> 00:18:09.328
You're like, yeah, but you need to understand why it's the way it is, that there are forces who want it there.

254
00:18:09.388 --> 00:18:10.609
I think that's just fascinating.

255
00:18:11.169 --> 00:18:11.630
Thank you.

256
00:18:11.890 --> 00:18:14.592
Well, it takes all of us, right, to build a story.

257
00:18:14.612 --> 00:18:15.772
And that's another thing it does.

258
00:18:15.932 --> 00:18:16.893
It really takes all of us.

259
00:18:18.814 --> 00:18:19.335
Hello, Gus.

260
00:18:20.215 --> 00:18:20.796
Hi, everyone.

261
00:18:20.936 --> 00:18:24.038
I'm sorry to be arriving halfway through a conversation.

262
00:18:24.058 --> 00:18:27.000
And I'm very happy to just sit here as a fly on the wall if you want to just carry on.

263
00:18:28.188 --> 00:18:38.938
Well, it's actually good timing because what Lucy was saying about the news, I feel like you couldn't have picked a better time to fly in because your organization is called Fix the News.

264
00:18:39.839 --> 00:18:40.499
Yeah.

265
00:18:40.860 --> 00:18:42.721
I set this up for you guys.

266
00:18:42.821 --> 00:18:44.122
Perfectly done, Lucy.

267
00:18:44.162 --> 00:18:45.023
So nicely done.

268
00:18:45.183 --> 00:18:45.624
Thank you.

269
00:18:46.164 --> 00:18:49.307
So do you want to – I don't know if I have anything to say.

270
00:18:49.327 --> 00:18:51.109
It sounds like Lucy might have said it already.

271
00:18:51.889 --> 00:18:53.951
Do you want to just briefly introduce –

272
00:18:56.130 --> 00:19:00.151
I take everyone else's talking points.

273
00:19:00.171 --> 00:19:00.811
Steal the thunder.

274
00:19:01.351 --> 00:19:02.872
Steal the thunder.

275
00:19:03.032 --> 00:19:04.732
Do you want to just briefly introduce yourself?

276
00:19:04.972 --> 00:19:07.253
And then should we just go straight in?

277
00:19:07.273 --> 00:19:08.613
Because otherwise we'll never get there.

278
00:19:09.294 --> 00:19:20.537
Do you want to introduce yourself and then, without missing a beat, go into the solution or movement or thing that you're excited about that gives you hope and optimism?

279
00:19:20.897 --> 00:19:21.357
How about that?

280
00:19:21.937 --> 00:19:23.037
Sure, I'm happy to do that.

281
00:19:23.297 --> 00:19:24.878
My name is Dr. Angus Harvey.

282
00:19:24.998 --> 00:19:32.120
I'm a journalist, a political economist, and I have been on the climate beat probably for about 15 years now.

283
00:19:32.540 --> 00:19:34.961
And I have done all of it.

284
00:19:35.121 --> 00:19:42.963
I've veered wildly from complete despair to unbounded optimism and have landed now somewhere halfway in between.

285
00:19:44.304 --> 00:19:47.465
I've been writing about and thinking about this issue for a very long time.

286
00:19:48.747 --> 00:19:56.671
And I have some, some fairly heterodox beliefs when it comes to what is happening with climate change and how the news covers it.

287
00:19:57.551 --> 00:20:02.653
Um, but I'm sitting in a place right now of kind of cautious optimism, which might sound strange.

288
00:20:03.734 --> 00:20:08.376
Um, but I've been in this for long enough to, I think have earned that feeling.

289
00:20:08.816 --> 00:20:10.537
Um, and.

290
00:20:11.853 --> 00:20:28.844
There is a weird paradox that describes the state of the global climate conversation right now, which is that I feel like we've never felt more despair as a species in our general conversation about it.

291
00:20:29.584 --> 00:20:35.288
And yet most people who've been doing this for long enough have never been as hopeful as they are right now.

292
00:20:38.058 --> 00:20:38.418
Hmm.

293
00:20:39.599 --> 00:20:40.320
That's wild.

294
00:20:40.720 --> 00:20:55.712
So I actually did a survey on this a few years ago for my book, The Solutionists, where we surveyed the public about whether they thought it was possible to still stop climate change or prevent it or mitigate its impacts in climate change.

295
00:20:56.052 --> 00:20:59.835
really low levels of optimism in the general public.

296
00:21:00.156 --> 00:21:08.643
I think there's something like 20% of people felt that we had what we needed and we would do what we needed on climate change.

297
00:21:09.043 --> 00:21:18.211
And then we surveyed a whole load of climate scientists and people working in sustainability, the people who know in far greater detail than the public exactly how fucked things can be.

298
00:21:18.231 --> 00:21:18.531
Right.

299
00:21:18.971 --> 00:21:22.376
And much, much, much more actually aware of the science and what I mean.

300
00:21:22.777 --> 00:21:26.743
And they were overwhelmingly more positive about our ability to do it.

301
00:21:27.163 --> 00:21:33.212
And I realized it wasn't about how close somebody was to the problem.

302
00:21:33.893 --> 00:21:39.738
and how aware they were of the problem, it was how close they were to the solutions and how aware they were of the solutions.

303
00:21:40.158 --> 00:21:45.403
Which is the public have got an increasing understanding of what the climate problem is.

304
00:21:47.144 --> 00:21:52.168
And this specialist and the experts having very, very, very detailed understanding of how much the problem is.

305
00:21:52.449 --> 00:21:56.592
But the specialists were able to articulate in great detail what the potential solutions were.

306
00:21:56.892 --> 00:22:04.974
how they were rolling out, how they would work, how the economics would work, what impacts that would have on society, how much renewables cost nowadays, etc.

307
00:22:05.294 --> 00:22:06.674
Whereas the general public had no idea.

308
00:22:06.854 --> 00:22:18.576
Like you still, the number one, and this research was done, I think, by the WTO, the number one solution to climate change when you survey the public worldwide is recycling.

309
00:22:19.117 --> 00:22:21.117
That's still the thing the public...

310
00:22:21.878 --> 00:22:25.602
mentions the most when asked about climate change.

311
00:22:25.662 --> 00:22:29.447
And I've had that experience myself in working with school groups and what have you.

312
00:22:29.887 --> 00:22:38.077
And so that's where you are in your relationship to knowing the solutions.

313
00:22:38.958 --> 00:22:40.100
Yeah, I really see that, Gus.

314
00:22:40.819 --> 00:22:41.079
Yeah.

315
00:22:41.920 --> 00:23:06.911
Is there a solution that you, that you're particularly, one that comes to mind that you, that is your like most exciting solution Gus for a reason that if someone is listening to this feeling a bit like, oh, I mean, we've had a summer of like wildfires and Nepal and wars going on and all of this, that you would be like, actually, no, I'd point you in this direction.

316
00:23:07.231 --> 00:23:08.012
Does one come to mind?

317
00:23:09.332 --> 00:23:11.973
I'm going to answer the question in three parts.

318
00:23:12.433 --> 00:23:13.593
I'll make it quick, don't worry.

319
00:23:14.693 --> 00:23:15.314
Okay.

320
00:23:16.254 --> 00:23:19.555
I'm not a long-winded economist.

321
00:23:19.595 --> 00:23:22.695
The first part is that our perception is just wildly skewed.

322
00:23:23.396 --> 00:23:27.337
So if you say to people, how have wildfires been in 2026?

323
00:23:27.437 --> 00:23:29.857
Most people will tell you it's been the worst year ever.

324
00:23:31.038 --> 00:23:34.738
But actually, it's been the lowest year for wildfires in 25 years, 2026 globally.

325
00:23:34.758 --> 00:23:35.379
Okay.

326
00:23:37.585 --> 00:23:42.406
And the reason for that is that most of the world's wildfires take place in Africa and Asia.

327
00:23:43.547 --> 00:24:00.172
And because of better fire management, changing weather conditions, and just the fact that it's been a relatively low wildfire year in those places, and in particular in Africa, we've got a rising water table that's now happening across the Sahel because of decades of better farming practices and re-greening.

328
00:24:01.232 --> 00:24:05.494
as a result of that, most of the world's wildfires take place in those places.

329
00:24:06.094 --> 00:24:07.174
They've been much, much lower.

330
00:24:07.494 --> 00:24:12.376
So if you look at the world as a whole, it has been one of the least fire-prone years ever.

331
00:24:13.237 --> 00:24:19.899
But that is not the story that we all tell because there are no cameras pointed at the savannah in Africa and at the forests in Asia.

332
00:24:20.299 --> 00:24:26.142
All of the cameras are in Western Europe and in Canada and the United States, which have had pretty bad wildfire years.

333
00:24:26.262 --> 00:24:27.542
But even in Europe

334
00:24:29.983 --> 00:24:31.024
as horrific as they've been.

335
00:24:31.044 --> 00:24:32.825
It hasn't been the worst wildfire year in Europe.

336
00:24:32.845 --> 00:24:42.173
It's been one of the worst in Western Europe, but in the Balkans, in Greece, and in large parts of the Mediterranean, the wildfires have not been nearly as bad as they have been in previous years.

337
00:24:42.213 --> 00:24:44.835
So there's this kind of skewed media perception.

338
00:24:45.335 --> 00:24:48.998
All the cameras are trained on the wildfires in France and in Britain and in Spain.

339
00:24:49.058 --> 00:24:50.940
And so everyone thinks, okay, the world's on fire.

340
00:24:51.040 --> 00:24:52.221
The world is not on fire.

341
00:24:52.962 --> 00:24:53.902
So that's the first one.

342
00:24:53.922 --> 00:24:55.363
We have a skewed perception of,

343
00:24:56.204 --> 00:25:00.649
I feel a lot better when I look at the world as a whole than when I look at one in particular region or country.

344
00:25:00.709 --> 00:25:03.792
And it's always an important thing to do when you're looking at climate stories.

345
00:25:04.493 --> 00:25:12.221
The second story is the story that I would tell on paper, which is that climate change isn't really a global story.

346
00:25:12.261 --> 00:25:13.342
It's actually a China story.

347
00:25:14.463 --> 00:25:18.267
And most of us are concerned with all the other countries, but actually it's almost all China.

348
00:25:19.068 --> 00:25:20.249
And I'll give you an example of this.

349
00:25:20.389 --> 00:25:28.856
China managed to cut its oil consumption in the first six months of this year by as much as Britain consumed throughout that entire six months.

350
00:25:29.417 --> 00:25:39.705
So the reduction in six months that China pulled off in reducing oil emissions equaled Britain's entire oil consumption for those six months.

351
00:25:40.853 --> 00:25:42.594
That's just the reduction of China.

352
00:25:44.014 --> 00:25:53.818
50% reduction in oil usage in China over the first six months of this year because of what's been happening in the Strait of Hormuz and because of the explosion of electric vehicles in China, which is the largest car market.

353
00:25:54.458 --> 00:26:06.623
So when we're sitting here and tearing our hair out and getting really upset about what's happening in Great Britain, we need to remember that China's increasing its electricity usage by almost two Great Britons every single year.

354
00:26:07.343 --> 00:26:13.869
And so small changes in the margin of what's happening in China outweigh almost everything else.

355
00:26:14.530 --> 00:26:22.578
Every roughly year, China increases its emissions, maybe just over a year, increases its emissions and electricity usage by as much as Germany.

356
00:26:23.599 --> 00:26:25.401
The entire, all of Germany.

357
00:26:26.746 --> 00:26:28.568
So it's just on a completely different scale.

358
00:26:28.588 --> 00:26:41.621
So if when we see China's carbon emissions start to plateau, which is what's happening now, and from next year it looks very likely that we're going to start seeing them decline, that is the global story of climate change, and everything else is mostly commentary.

359
00:26:42.362 --> 00:26:44.424
But that's kind of boring, energy-wonky stuff.

360
00:26:44.444 --> 00:26:46.306
So I'll tell you about the story that's actually writing me up.

361
00:26:46.486 --> 00:26:47.307
I feel really excited.

362
00:26:48.988 --> 00:26:49.349
Yeah.

363
00:26:49.649 --> 00:26:50.250
Very exciting.

364
00:26:53.072 --> 00:26:58.557
It is by far the biggest climate story, but it's not one that we know how to cover because we don't have cameras in China.

365
00:26:58.617 --> 00:26:59.978
We don't have reporters in China.

366
00:27:01.019 --> 00:27:03.922
It doesn't occupy the same level in our...

367
00:27:03.982 --> 00:27:05.843
It doesn't occupy the same place in our discourse.

368
00:27:06.143 --> 00:27:06.284
Yeah.

369
00:27:06.884 --> 00:27:10.525
And quite rightly, we're upset about what is happening with climate change in our particular countries.

370
00:27:10.565 --> 00:27:18.348
And we're upset that the government isn't doing enough and that the politics are skewed and that the fossil fuel giants are corrupt and all the rest.

371
00:27:18.408 --> 00:27:21.690
But that is mostly commentary.

372
00:27:22.930 --> 00:27:30.012
The final thing that is really lighting me up that I'm very excited about is that it's got nothing to do with energy and electricity at all.

373
00:27:30.512 --> 00:27:33.733
It's to do with land use emissions, which is where I started in this whole game.

374
00:27:34.713 --> 00:27:42.755
And it turns out that about a third of the world's irrecoverable carbon, which is carbon that if it gets released, we can't get it back.

375
00:27:43.655 --> 00:27:58.813
if it gets released through burning or, you know, crops line art or crops decomposing, that happens to be on land that is managed or owned by indigenous groups worldwide.

376
00:27:59.694 --> 00:27:59.814
And

377
00:28:00.810 --> 00:28:15.457
It turns out there's a bunch of new studies that have come out in the last three or four years showing that indigenous groups manage land far more effectively than land that is managed in conserved parks.

378
00:28:16.257 --> 00:28:24.562
So what we've been doing with conservation for generations is we've been saying, we're going to lock this park off, no one's allowed in there, and we're going to let nature recover inside of that park.

379
00:28:25.122 --> 00:28:34.928
And it turns out that in the places where indigenous people actually manage those areas and where they live on those lands, those lands actually do better than the lands that we just block off and lock away.

380
00:28:35.548 --> 00:28:51.584
So in other words, if you want to keep the carbon in the ground and you want those lands to recover, to regenerate, if you want to save species on them, if you want to keep the carbon locked in on those places, you want people on those lands, which goes almost completely opposite to the way we thought about Western conservation for as long as we've all lived.

381
00:28:52.425 --> 00:28:56.489
And all we need to do there is we don't need to put people onto those lands.

382
00:28:56.509 --> 00:28:57.270
They're already there.

383
00:28:57.850 --> 00:29:01.434
We don't need to really do anything different because they're already conducting those practices.

384
00:29:02.014 --> 00:29:03.476
All we need to do is give them tenure.

385
00:29:04.437 --> 00:29:09.561
Because in those places, only 14% of indigenous groups who live on those lands have official tenure.

386
00:29:10.470 --> 00:29:14.831
So they have where they've been given permission by the government to actually look after those lands.

387
00:29:15.431 --> 00:29:18.032
And that is a very, very easy policy change.

388
00:29:18.372 --> 00:29:25.713
And that is something that I think could make a huge difference over the next 20 or 30 years in keeping a lot of that carbon locked away.

389
00:29:26.094 --> 00:29:30.154
And at the same time, managing to conserve a lot of Earth's most pristine places.

390
00:29:31.915 --> 00:29:32.155
Wow.

391
00:29:33.465 --> 00:29:37.187
They're really cool.

392
00:29:37.948 --> 00:29:45.973
I think something that came back to your first point, which was in a way almost the underlying assumption of what happens when we either talk about positive or negative.

393
00:29:46.553 --> 00:29:56.360
I think people's underlying assumption is if I say something negative, people are more likely to act because they're more worried and they see that the problem is bigger.

394
00:29:57.280 --> 00:29:59.462
And conversely, if they hear something positive,

395
00:30:00.454 --> 00:30:05.318
I'm less likely to act because it's already happening, so I don't need to do something.

396
00:30:06.319 --> 00:30:10.202
And I feel good, but it's like, you know, someone else has solved it.

397
00:30:10.543 --> 00:30:11.523
That's happy days.

398
00:30:13.145 --> 00:30:21.492
I think that one of the big questions I've had coming into this discussion, and about the topic in general, is how to...

399
00:30:23.452 --> 00:30:32.341
I mean, obviously those assumptions are like wrong or like they should be questioned, but I think quite a lot of people have them.

400
00:30:32.601 --> 00:30:44.032
So how do you get the balance between talking about something positively without people getting complacent, but talking about it realistically without people feeling doom?

401
00:30:45.349 --> 00:30:53.500
I'm going to jump in here and just say I find that whole argument that if we tell people about the solutions and what's going on, it will demotivate them to act.

402
00:30:54.241 --> 00:31:02.393
Literally laughable after 30 years of telling everybody how unbelievably fucked everything is and that not leading to them acting.

403
00:31:03.033 --> 00:31:06.575
It's a basic misunderstanding of how psychology works.

404
00:31:06.915 --> 00:31:08.977
And I'll give you a little analogy.

405
00:31:09.057 --> 00:31:19.143
So my dad has got lots and lots of issues with heart disease and all the rest of it and has been told by his doctor for many, many years, if you don't change your lifestyle, you're going to die.

406
00:31:19.463 --> 00:31:28.428
So literally, not even on the scale of a humanity or species level, this is one man being told, if you don't change how you live and how you eat, you personally do nothing.

407
00:31:28.668 --> 00:31:31.550
Like my mum, me, everybody trying to do something wrong.

408
00:31:31.770 --> 00:31:40.902
What ended up actually changing how he eats and how he lives was when a new doctor told him, you're going to sleep better if you stop eating so much meat at night.

409
00:31:41.522 --> 00:31:45.347
Literally, your quality of sleep is going to go through the roof, try it for a week.

410
00:31:45.487 --> 00:31:47.650
I promise you you're going to come back here and it'll be revelation.

411
00:31:48.671 --> 00:31:49.792
Changed his behavior overnight.

412
00:31:50.613 --> 00:31:57.134
We know that threats and fear don't motivate on a personal level.

413
00:31:57.514 --> 00:32:01.295
Otherwise, as human beings, we would be much, much, much, much less.

414
00:32:02.856 --> 00:32:03.836
Nobody would ever smoke.

415
00:32:03.956 --> 00:32:05.216
Nobody would ever drink a glass of wine.

416
00:32:05.236 --> 00:32:07.837
Nobody would ever cross the road or get in a car.

417
00:32:08.237 --> 00:32:14.598
As human beings, in many ways, we're terrible at our own long-term survival as individuals, let alone collectively.

418
00:32:15.659 --> 00:32:29.933
It's also one of the other things is that because so many of people in the climate movement have a particular personality type that is motivated by large existential threats, they forget that they're weirdos.

419
00:32:30.553 --> 00:32:32.734
We'll change that and say, we're weirdos.

420
00:32:33.134 --> 00:32:35.815
We are a personality type that is motivated by this.

421
00:32:36.135 --> 00:32:42.317
And every single human being on the planet of that personality type is part of the climate movement.

422
00:32:42.457 --> 00:32:44.158
We have recruited them all.

423
00:32:44.478 --> 00:32:49.520
And every single new one that's born is by the time they're about five, they are huge environmentalists.

424
00:32:49.980 --> 00:32:54.142
Turns out we are not representative of the rest of the public.

425
00:32:55.142 --> 00:33:13.675
Because we get motivated and turned on by this kind of information presented in this way, we've not understood the fact that there's lots of other different personality types, lots of other different worldviews, lots of other different ways of seeing your place within the wonderful psychologist researcher called Pat Dade actually broke it down into pioneers who get...

426
00:33:13.935 --> 00:33:40.987
motivated by big global existential crises, settlers who get motivated by what's happening in their local area and the rest of the world is essentially mythological, doesn't really exist, just they're motivated, and prospectors who are primarily motivated by what other people think of them, very Jungian, externally motivated, internally motivated, and that all of our messages and all of our concerns about our messages are within that small group.

427
00:33:42.388 --> 00:33:51.733
was actually one of the things which I find motivates the most is when I was a kid, growing up in the UK in council housing.

428
00:33:52.113 --> 00:33:54.274
Council housing in the 70s was not that great.

429
00:33:54.775 --> 00:34:00.338
And in fact, my home was warmed by an actual fire grate in the living room that we

430
00:34:01.078 --> 00:34:13.096
put coal into and lit coal and our food was cooked on a Rayburn, which is a sort of, you know, slightly crappy version of the sort of agas that everybody loves nowadays.

431
00:34:13.516 --> 00:34:15.499
And we would put wood into it.

432
00:34:16.260 --> 00:34:17.282
Point of order.

433
00:34:17.582 --> 00:34:18.503
Love the Rayburn.

434
00:34:18.703 --> 00:34:19.924
Love, love, okay, good.

435
00:34:19.944 --> 00:34:21.085
Lucy knows the Rayburn.

436
00:34:21.625 --> 00:34:22.646
Not an Arga.

437
00:34:22.867 --> 00:34:29.532
And that's how my life for the first sort of 12, 15 years was fuelled by fossil fuels.

438
00:34:30.053 --> 00:34:42.203
And now I live in a home which is powered by the solar panels that we have on the side of the home, which means in my own lifetime, and I'm not that frigging old, in my own lifetime, I've lived through this giant energy transition.

439
00:34:42.623 --> 00:34:45.724
as so many people, particularly in the global south, have done.

440
00:34:46.065 --> 00:34:53.848
They've gone from being children, being fueled by dung or by charcoal, and now they're living lives fueled by renewables.

441
00:34:54.108 --> 00:34:59.491
I think one of the challenges for a lot of very middle class people is they haven't actually lived through this transition.

442
00:34:59.871 --> 00:35:03.152
Their lives now are not that significantly different than their lives when they were young.

443
00:35:03.172 --> 00:35:09.115
They've not seen how much the world changed because privilege tends not to involve a great deal of change.

444
00:35:09.555 --> 00:35:16.239
And so they're not experiencing this visceral transformation, which is happening for so many people's lives around the world.

445
00:35:16.639 --> 00:35:17.459
And I think that that's...

446
00:35:17.779 --> 00:35:25.763
So one, those of us who are motivated by large existential global planetary crises are weirdos, and we're not representative of the rest of the world.

447
00:35:26.084 --> 00:35:28.445
The rest of the world tends to get motivated by what's in it for me.

448
00:35:29.505 --> 00:35:36.729
And by the fact that you want to join a solution, you want to join something that's winning, you want to join this side that's actually in ascendance.

449
00:35:36.749 --> 00:35:39.571
So that's why solutions are so, so, so powerful for that group.

450
00:35:39.971 --> 00:35:43.273
And then thirdly, as Gus just put so wonderfully,

451
00:35:44.133 --> 00:35:53.896
Far more change is happening around the world than most people in middle class lives in the UK are aware of because they've not experienced this giant transformation.

452
00:35:54.636 --> 00:35:57.357
Their lives were pretty privileged to begin with and now they're the same now.

453
00:35:57.397 --> 00:36:02.658
So they haven't realized how much has changed in the daily life of so many people around the world.

454
00:36:02.938 --> 00:36:09.488
And by the way, growing up with coal, my house stunk, my hands were filthy, we all had asthma.

455
00:36:10.029 --> 00:36:14.095
And now I live in a house where everything's clean and everything's beautiful and renewable energy.

456
00:36:14.496 --> 00:36:18.162
It's just so much better in so many ways for those lives.

457
00:36:18.602 --> 00:36:35.026
Then those old forms of powers, which again, if all you've ever had is electricity and lots of heaters around your home, you don't know how much this transformation has brought huge benefits as well, not just to our climate, but for everybody's lives.

458
00:36:37.106 --> 00:36:48.643
Um, I've, that was epic, by the way, firstly, and thank you very much for did for deconstructing my because I, I know that it's wrong, but I also used to believe it.

459
00:36:49.104 --> 00:36:51.147
And I think I can see a lot of other people believing it.

460
00:36:52.008 --> 00:37:08.320
But in the interest of being a strict time moderator and making sure that people can get through their solutions, I'm going to come to Lucy for the thing that you're excited about, the movement or the solution that you would like more people to know about.

461
00:37:09.110 --> 00:37:11.012
Yeah, I mean, I'm taking loads of notes.

462
00:37:11.573 --> 00:37:12.193
I saw this.

463
00:37:12.213 --> 00:37:12.614
Amazing.

464
00:37:12.654 --> 00:37:13.715
What are you going to do with them?

465
00:37:14.055 --> 00:37:16.018
It's always scary when a journalist does that.

466
00:37:16.058 --> 00:37:16.758
Yeah, it is.

467
00:37:17.179 --> 00:37:25.408
And listen, let me just tell you, I'm conscious that my head is down and, you know, you just see my highlights, which fortunately I have had done my roots, but...

468
00:37:25.868 --> 00:37:27.570
I, I, yeah, they're nice.

469
00:37:27.990 --> 00:37:33.634
Um, I, it's how I orientate myself is how I process.

470
00:37:33.654 --> 00:37:35.456
So I'm not stealing your ideas.

471
00:37:35.476 --> 00:37:36.397
I'm not being diffident.

472
00:37:36.437 --> 00:37:40.640
I'm literally just enjoying the conversation so much with my scrawled notes.

473
00:37:40.660 --> 00:37:41.421
That's how I do it.

474
00:37:42.141 --> 00:37:47.185
Um, and I just wanted to just, um, pick up on something when Solly was talking about the coal, uh,

475
00:37:48.546 --> 00:37:53.047
And I also grew up in a house originally which had a coal hatch.

476
00:37:53.067 --> 00:37:54.468
I remember the coal man coming.

477
00:37:54.988 --> 00:38:08.872
And it reminded me of the Climate Assembly a few years ago in the UK, which yielded some really interesting and very sort of, I'm going to say, beautiful results just in the way that 100 members of the public were chosen at random and then distributed.

478
00:38:09.012 --> 00:38:18.316
subjected to a lot of climate information and not just climate information, consumerism, embedded carbon, things that we think are too hard for people.

479
00:38:18.916 --> 00:38:25.820
And, you know, the way that they grapple with that and the way that they turn that into sort of living policy was truly amazing to me.

480
00:38:26.320 --> 00:38:31.042
But I do remember at the start, there was, my friends made a documentary.

481
00:38:31.062 --> 00:38:33.183
So they were filming a number of the participants.

482
00:38:33.663 --> 00:38:38.144
And there was one young woman who was brilliant, actually, really, really lovely girl.

483
00:38:38.224 --> 00:38:39.424
I think she was a hairdresser.

484
00:38:40.064 --> 00:38:45.486
And she listened to some eminent scientists for half a day.

485
00:38:46.086 --> 00:38:47.366
These things were held at the weekend.

486
00:38:47.706 --> 00:38:53.607
And then she turned to her fellow climate assembly people at her table, because you sat in these little round tables.

487
00:38:54.067 --> 00:38:56.308
And she said, is coal bad?

488
00:38:56.348 --> 00:38:56.468
Yeah.

489
00:38:57.751 --> 00:39:03.815
And that was like so brilliant because it was like, she's like, I've got, I'm, my house is heated on coal.

490
00:39:03.855 --> 00:39:04.496
Is it bad?

491
00:39:04.976 --> 00:39:10.359
So all day she'd been sitting there watching these charts, listening to all these very elevated conversation.

492
00:39:10.379 --> 00:39:12.141
And she was like, hang on a minute.

493
00:39:12.161 --> 00:39:13.341
There's something going on here.

494
00:39:13.682 --> 00:39:15.523
And this happens all the time.

495
00:39:16.003 --> 00:39:18.765
I have, is coal bad conversations?

496
00:39:19.185 --> 00:39:24.509
Not just coal, but I went to a thing called Heatwave 76 recently, which was where,

497
00:39:24.929 --> 00:39:35.745
we had three of our meteorologists who are on TV, like the proper ones that everyone knows, and they presented a forecast for 2056.

498
00:39:36.266 --> 00:39:36.706
Oh, I saw this.

499
00:39:39.891 --> 00:39:40.091
Yeah.

500
00:39:40.171 --> 00:39:46.634
And as they were presenting it, the government issued a red heat alert, which they've never done before, as far as I understand.

501
00:39:47.254 --> 00:39:53.117
Anyway, at the end, I spoke to a lovely woman who was a finance influencer on social media.

502
00:39:53.517 --> 00:39:54.918
And I said, why did you come here today?

503
00:39:54.958 --> 00:39:57.159
And she said, it's actually really embarrassing.

504
00:39:57.179 --> 00:39:59.720
I came here today because I was born in 1976.

505
00:40:00.000 --> 00:40:03.341
And I thought this was a reunion of people who were born in 1976.

506
00:40:05.782 --> 00:40:07.724
And I was like, and how are you now?

507
00:40:07.864 --> 00:40:11.166
And she burst into tears and she was like, why did nobody tell me?

508
00:40:11.186 --> 00:40:15.630
So we think that we are, you know, like giving all this information.

509
00:40:15.910 --> 00:40:20.073
There's people wandering around who are hearing it for the first time.

510
00:40:20.393 --> 00:40:24.757
And I think it's really incumbent upon us in the media to know that.

511
00:40:24.917 --> 00:40:27.979
Sorry, I am going to get to my solutions, Rob, because I know that you are.

512
00:40:27.999 --> 00:40:28.600
No, this is epic.

513
00:40:29.000 --> 00:40:29.200
to.

514
00:40:29.720 --> 00:40:34.223
Okay, so there's two things, and one of them is recycling, for which I really apologise.

515
00:40:37.485 --> 00:40:38.885
I'm also sorry, not sorry.

516
00:40:38.965 --> 00:40:47.050
So the first one, and this is a sort of solution in that it's one woman scientist who's...

517
00:40:47.590 --> 00:40:50.891
who has been on the most kind of epic struggle, essentially.

518
00:40:50.951 --> 00:41:01.073
So Suzanne Simard, who is a Canadian forestry scientist, she wrote Finding the Mother Tree, which was this sort of nature blockbuster.

519
00:41:01.433 --> 00:41:02.954
I met her last year.

520
00:41:03.134 --> 00:41:10.715
I'd actually come back from British Columbia from Elephant Hill, which is one of the biggest wildfires that Canada has ever seen.

521
00:41:12.016 --> 00:41:16.497
Again, thank God they didn't have such a bad season this year, but that's also because there's nothing left to burn.

522
00:41:18.077 --> 00:41:18.737
in that area.

523
00:41:18.757 --> 00:41:27.280
But I know there were wildfires on the border because obviously Trump blamed Canada for pollution.

524
00:41:27.780 --> 00:41:32.202
But what was kind of really important about Suzanne is that

525
00:41:32.902 --> 00:41:36.166
She basically had to reteach us how forests work.

526
00:41:36.206 --> 00:41:40.270
So since Darwin, Survival of the Fittest, you know, we thought we knew how it worked.

527
00:41:40.331 --> 00:41:49.441
And she obviously revealed to the mainstream via this incredible book that the world would web.

528
00:41:49.481 --> 00:41:50.762
She did her PhD on this.

529
00:41:50.802 --> 00:41:52.724
It's not just something she conjured up for a book.

530
00:41:53.365 --> 00:42:01.230
And what is incredible is that she had to reteach us how interconnected the forest work and how important the understory is.

531
00:42:01.370 --> 00:42:03.071
So we always were looking up in the canopy.

532
00:42:03.111 --> 00:42:05.472
It's actually the understory that's the really important thing.

533
00:42:05.993 --> 00:42:13.257
Her new book, which I now can't find, but I did write down the title somewhere, is actually about, OK, we know this now.

534
00:42:13.317 --> 00:42:14.298
What are we going to do about it?

535
00:42:14.358 --> 00:42:15.959
So it's much more activist-looking.

536
00:42:17.520 --> 00:42:25.749
And this is really, really important because she does, she conducts her experimentation in the forest on these vast sites.

537
00:42:26.009 --> 00:42:32.736
So her laboratory is essentially the size of Denmark, which I think to a person in the UK just blows your mind.

538
00:42:33.437 --> 00:42:44.942
And she will only co-create science or work in this living laboratory with indigenous practitioners of forestry, which goes back a little to what Gus is talking about.

539
00:42:45.343 --> 00:42:46.603
The evidence is there.

540
00:42:46.683 --> 00:43:00.670
I've actually just come back this summer from another project in Butte Inlet, which is on the Pacific coast of BC, where I experienced a project with the Hamalko people.

541
00:43:02.090 --> 00:43:16.694
And what is very, very interesting to me, the Hamalko are canoeists and river people who are having to learn how to canoe.

542
00:43:17.154 --> 00:43:29.958
Because in the 1960s and 70s, the current leaders, so the chief is a guy called Darren Blaney, were put into residential schools where basically their culture was erased.

543
00:43:30.718 --> 00:43:37.641
And as a result of this, where they were subjected to abuse, physical, emotional and sexual.

544
00:43:38.101 --> 00:43:43.984
And a lot of people have addiction, substance addiction stories as a result of that.

545
00:43:44.644 --> 00:43:53.728
So part of this whole scheme, which is an environmental scheme to protect the salmon fisheries and the forest, has to start with healing and recovery.

546
00:43:53.748 --> 00:43:53.848
Okay.

547
00:43:54.628 --> 00:44:10.796
So I was looking at a project which was essentially using tourism, the tourism dollar to finance a recovery and to bring the Hamalko people back onto their land, which they've been evicted from.

548
00:44:11.436 --> 00:44:17.140
And then we get into the tenure, which Gus was talking about, and the legal ownership projects as well.

549
00:44:17.540 --> 00:44:23.044
So it's like a vast, huge program and project.

550
00:44:23.544 --> 00:44:27.647
And it's obviously a multi-generational piece of work.

551
00:44:28.107 --> 00:44:29.448
And this is also a problem.

552
00:44:29.488 --> 00:44:38.795
So I felt like Gus was really describing the limitations of the dominant forms of storytelling, of media architecture,

553
00:44:39.435 --> 00:44:45.458
when you're looking at places like when he said there's no cameras in China to sort of bring you this.

554
00:44:45.839 --> 00:44:47.319
There are other ways of doing it.

555
00:44:47.379 --> 00:44:55.924
And I feel like that is the gauntlet is being thrown down to journalists like myself to find ways of doing this.

556
00:44:56.364 --> 00:45:06.370
So back to the China example, I think what we're starting to see is a focus on materials and resources because people like the sort of wow stats and

557
00:45:06.650 --> 00:45:07.250
things like that.

558
00:45:07.310 --> 00:45:12.991
And I see like Ed Conway's book, Material World, referenced again and again and again.

559
00:45:13.652 --> 00:45:16.412
And that's not always in environmental journalism.

560
00:45:16.492 --> 00:45:18.213
I'm seeing it creep into business.

561
00:45:18.293 --> 00:45:20.493
I'm seeing it creep into politics coverage.

562
00:45:20.993 --> 00:45:26.434
And I think that is kind of interesting because part of the issue has been that we are so siloed.

563
00:45:26.774 --> 00:45:33.896
And the other part of the problem when it comes to storytelling solutions is that it often comes down to trauma.

564
00:45:34.576 --> 00:45:46.804
And if I go to an editor of a broadsheet in the UK and I say I want to write about trauma, you know, I will feel, you know, it'll be like, you know, don't catch your ass in the door as it slams behind you.

565
00:45:46.844 --> 00:45:52.067
Like, I'm not going to get good feedback because these men are terrified of trauma.

566
00:45:52.087 --> 00:45:55.109
You know, they probably went to boarding school.

567
00:45:55.969 --> 00:45:58.332
And this is where it comes.

568
00:45:58.412 --> 00:46:08.503
Like, you know, you have to talk to the individual to get the piece that is written about all of humanity and the solutions for all of humanity.

569
00:46:08.543 --> 00:46:12.688
And you're dealing with individual resistance at every single stage.

570
00:46:13.108 --> 00:46:16.312
And just one little point, Solly was talking about

571
00:46:17.273 --> 00:46:21.876
which I thought was so brilliant, like who's closest to the story, who's closest to the solutions.

572
00:46:22.357 --> 00:46:25.919
And it made me realize why I crave talking to scientists.

573
00:46:25.979 --> 00:46:28.061
And I walk around like a little puppy dog.

574
00:46:28.081 --> 00:46:33.745
I'm like a stalker to, you know, the scientists that are monitoring El Nino at the moment and stuff like that.

575
00:46:33.765 --> 00:46:36.507
In fact, I'm going to see them on Friday and I'm really excited.

576
00:46:37.307 --> 00:46:43.211
And I just want them to tell me what's happening and what they're uncovered and where they're putting their energy.

577
00:46:43.632 --> 00:46:51.017
Because I know that that is soothing me in a way and it's allowing me to operate in a sense.

578
00:46:51.317 --> 00:46:56.601
Very, very quickly, my other solution was a more local one.

579
00:46:56.721 --> 00:46:58.202
And it starts with a story.

580
00:46:58.723 --> 00:47:01.365
David Bowie was making the film Labyrinth.

581
00:47:02.125 --> 00:47:06.769
around, I think it was Ealing Studios in London, film studios.

582
00:47:07.129 --> 00:47:12.774
And he went outside for a cigarette, which is one of his body doubles, who told us this story.

583
00:47:13.254 --> 00:47:18.178
And David looked at all the stuff because part of the set was being dismantled, being thrown in a skip.

584
00:47:18.578 --> 00:47:20.260
And he said, this is ridiculous, man.

585
00:47:20.620 --> 00:47:24.423
You know, this is, what was this, in the 1980s when Labyrinth was made?

586
00:47:24.823 --> 00:47:27.966
He said, why are we throwing away all this stuff?

587
00:47:28.826 --> 00:47:29.787
Well, this summer...

588
00:47:31.075 --> 00:47:44.466
An amazing project was launched called Restage, which takes, it's a kind of joined up all of these hubs for the theatre stage and screen industry in the UK, which is huge.

589
00:47:44.506 --> 00:47:51.611
We spent nearly £8 billion creating props and sets in the UK and we ditched most of it.

590
00:47:51.671 --> 00:47:57.296
Like most productions have a budget for skipping and no budget for recirculating.

591
00:47:57.636 --> 00:48:05.644
So these amazing women, Sarah Turnbull and Sherry Dobbin, have come into this and basically got this huge coalition together.

592
00:48:06.004 --> 00:48:13.371
And they have costed and worked out this incredible way of recirculating all of this stuff in the UK.

593
00:48:13.431 --> 00:48:16.094
I just hope somebody backs it because it's really, really important.

594
00:48:16.414 --> 00:48:17.455
It creates jobs.

595
00:48:17.995 --> 00:48:18.596
It takes jobs.

596
00:48:19.016 --> 00:48:26.622
stuff that we feel very strongly about, all these iconic series from these film sets and screen stages, and it recirculates them.

597
00:48:26.862 --> 00:48:30.465
And I really like that because it's an infrastructure thing and it's very, very practical.

598
00:48:30.945 --> 00:48:36.850
And as Solly pointed out, people have mistakenly thought that recycling is the key.

599
00:48:38.071 --> 00:48:41.974
But hey, it's got traction and it keeps them on board with the issues.

600
00:48:42.134 --> 00:48:43.635
So what's that phrase?

601
00:48:43.695 --> 00:48:45.977
Don't let perfection be the enemy of progress.

602
00:48:46.737 --> 00:48:47.598
I'm going to take that.

603
00:48:49.338 --> 00:48:49.698
Wow.

604
00:48:51.140 --> 00:48:54.402
I love the variety of examples that you give.

605
00:48:54.542 --> 00:49:00.567
And also pulling together different people's points, like different strands of China and indigenous stuff.

606
00:49:01.788 --> 00:49:02.949
And that was very impressive.

607
00:49:03.750 --> 00:49:04.551
Thanks, Rob.

608
00:49:06.712 --> 00:49:06.932
Yeah.

609
00:49:08.645 --> 00:49:11.806
I am aware we have about 25 minutes left.

610
00:49:12.647 --> 00:49:15.548
So I want to ask some questions about that.

611
00:49:15.688 --> 00:49:26.552
But I also want to ask Solly's solution and not shoot myself in the foot and give myself two minutes where I've got to garble my own.

612
00:49:27.192 --> 00:49:30.034
So if I could come to you.

613
00:49:30.614 --> 00:49:30.854
Sorry.

614
00:49:31.377 --> 00:49:33.118
Oh, I can go first or would you want to go first?

615
00:49:33.138 --> 00:49:33.859
Yeah, you go first.

616
00:49:33.879 --> 00:49:34.159
Yeah, yeah.

617
00:49:34.399 --> 00:49:34.899
I'll go first.

618
00:49:35.420 --> 00:49:39.302
Although I'm really nervous because I've got two amazing journalists on the school.

619
00:49:39.322 --> 00:49:42.164
They're taking notes.

620
00:49:42.524 --> 00:49:50.409
And actually, I'm going to jump off what Lucy was sharing, which is absolutely spot on about this tracking how often climate change is mentioned.

621
00:49:50.969 --> 00:49:53.811
Because quite a lot of the time, that's the news media.

622
00:49:54.532 --> 00:50:00.736
And Gus and Lucy both are top-notch journalists and they can talk about the news media much, much, much more than I can.

623
00:50:02.317 --> 00:50:07.900
I, back in the 90s, I did a master's in sustainability.

624
00:50:08.700 --> 00:50:17.085
Oh, and by the way, back then in 1997, when I did the master's in sustainability, we were on track for five to eight degrees of global warming, just as a given.

625
00:50:17.306 --> 00:50:19.427
That's what we learned about from the scientists.

626
00:50:19.707 --> 00:50:24.429
So renewable energy was an expensive joke that a few people in California had.

627
00:50:25.070 --> 00:50:28.751
And the movie Who Killed the Electric Car had told us that electric cars were never coming back.

628
00:50:28.771 --> 00:50:34.434
So again, not just from my childhood, but even from when I first started in this industry, so much has changed.

629
00:50:35.554 --> 00:50:37.516
But I also did a master's in Shakespeare.

630
00:50:37.756 --> 00:50:38.797
Now, this tells you a couple of things.

631
00:50:38.937 --> 00:50:56.148
One is, my loves are halfway between the logic and the magic, between the logic, the science, the maths, the evidence of sustainability and the magic, the storytelling and the human truths and the stuff beyond and transcendent effects, both of those things.

632
00:50:56.388 --> 00:51:01.671
It also tells you I was a really, really, really boring young woman who was very obsessed with lots of academic pieces.

633
00:51:01.691 --> 00:51:02.392
Yeah.

634
00:51:02.772 --> 00:51:05.914
And I've been trying to put those two things together ever since.

635
00:51:06.174 --> 00:51:18.962
So how do we put together this very evidence-based, very fact-based, very proof-point-based, sometimes statistic-based story about what's happening in our world and the storytelling?

636
00:51:19.802 --> 00:51:23.323
One of the things about storytelling is it's got nothing to do with facts.

637
00:51:23.923 --> 00:51:26.363
It's curated emotion.

638
00:51:26.763 --> 00:51:44.127
We had a panel in Climate Week in the UK where a wonderful script writer who'd recently, her big piece had come out of sort of Murder Mystery, which is very popular in the UK, which then currently escapes me and I will remember it before the end of this podcast.

639
00:51:44.827 --> 00:51:46.767
And she'd read Uninhabitable Earth.

640
00:51:50.249 --> 00:51:52.071
can't write a story about any of that.

641
00:51:52.592 --> 00:51:54.094
It's all facts and stats information.

642
00:51:54.414 --> 00:52:00.462
And she's like, how can I write a story that makes people feel the same way as I felt writing that book?

643
00:52:00.883 --> 00:52:02.044
And that's what storytelling is.

644
00:52:02.285 --> 00:52:07.812
And far too often, we try to talk about storytelling as if it was like the marketing department, the science department.

645
00:52:08.072 --> 00:52:10.474
or like was in service of trying to tell the science.

646
00:52:10.494 --> 00:52:12.636
It's not the job of storytelling at all.

647
00:52:12.656 --> 00:52:14.477
The best stories absolutely transcend it.

648
00:52:14.677 --> 00:52:21.342
In fact, you know, I'm not sure if you've read the books, The Martian or Project Hail Mary, absolutely stuffed with science.

649
00:52:21.682 --> 00:52:22.983
Most of the original, everybody remembers.

650
00:52:23.324 --> 00:52:28.647
All they remember is the emotional stories, the highs and lows.

651
00:52:29.468 --> 00:52:37.375
And so my solution thing which I'm most excited about is how much the creative industries are getting interested in climate decisions.

652
00:52:37.395 --> 00:52:50.107
They've actually been interested in the problem for a while because, of course, climate change creates unexpected crises and it throws people's lives out of whack, all of which is really good fodder for storytelling.

653
00:52:50.467 --> 00:53:02.091
The solutions have not been as easy for storytellers to say, simply because they also have this issue of being very distant from solutions, not knowing them, not understanding them, thinking most of them are quite boring technology rather than feeling close to them.

654
00:53:02.571 --> 00:53:09.553
But work that, and Lucy mentioned the work that BAFTA Albert has been doing, work that the Sustainable Entertainment Alliance in the US has been doing.

655
00:53:09.813 --> 00:53:16.717
In fact, actually last year I went out and I spent like two months in LA with a whole load of script writers from all the big studios working on this.

656
00:53:17.338 --> 00:53:24.362
And we've got a piece of work we're working on at the moment where we've gone through a whole load of the tropes that you find in entertainment.

657
00:53:24.382 --> 00:53:33.928
So the tropes in romance, the meet cute in romance, the tropes in action where you've got the sort of the chase scene, that kind of thing.

658
00:53:34.288 --> 00:53:34.909
And some other trips.

659
00:53:35.129 --> 00:53:38.071
And we've aligned all those tropes with climate solutions.

660
00:53:38.291 --> 00:53:40.773
So how could you have the meet cute in a farmer's market?

661
00:53:40.793 --> 00:53:45.036
How could you have the meet cute in a solution scenario?

662
00:53:45.316 --> 00:53:47.658
Car chases are beginning to get a little bit dull.

663
00:53:47.678 --> 00:53:48.738
They've all been done to death.

664
00:53:48.818 --> 00:53:53.021
So how can you have the chase, a train chase?

665
00:53:53.222 --> 00:53:55.043
How can you have electric bike chases?

666
00:53:55.063 --> 00:53:56.344
There are more things you can do with that.

667
00:53:57.124 --> 00:54:00.167
And I wrote a climate novel.

668
00:54:00.927 --> 00:54:05.250
And now I'm, Godstorm, it's over my shoulder for anyone who wants to get their copy.

669
00:54:06.291 --> 00:54:09.253
And I've started now working with a whole set of novelists.

670
00:54:09.273 --> 00:54:13.095
We've got a big Discord group of solutions storytellers.

671
00:54:13.275 --> 00:54:17.458
So how we can bring these storytellers together to find out how they can weave solutions in.

672
00:54:17.758 --> 00:54:24.803
And Gus, I was thinking about your point about there aren't the cameras, there aren't the stories coming out of China and how hard,

673
00:54:24.883 --> 00:54:25.883
hard that is going to be.

674
00:54:26.223 --> 00:54:27.824
So could we bypass that?

675
00:54:27.864 --> 00:54:38.868
Could we have the Kung Fu Panda story coming out of China, which includes the shows, the radical transformation, you know, thinking about K-pop demon hunters?

676
00:54:38.908 --> 00:54:47.931
How can we, if we're struggling to get these into the news media, because some of the forces that are against us are obsessed with the news media,

677
00:54:48.371 --> 00:55:01.664
Can we bypass them and actually create this as fodder for storytelling and where climate solutions can be the emotional high that helps to solve and resolve the story?

678
00:55:02.544 --> 00:55:09.511
Where the climate solution comes in as sort of the deus machina, where the climate solution is the thing that actually helps the emotional story resolve.

679
00:55:09.931 --> 00:55:17.519
And that's the thing which I'm most excited about because you probably won't be able to count the numbers of time climate change is mentioned within those.

680
00:55:17.559 --> 00:55:19.200
It will be visual.

681
00:55:19.260 --> 00:55:20.762
It will be implied.

682
00:55:20.782 --> 00:55:26.828
It will be through show, not tell, through the description of what's happening rather than telling people what's happening.

683
00:55:27.108 --> 00:55:29.669
But that's one of the things which I'm really, really excited about.

684
00:55:29.689 --> 00:55:40.175
And one of the reasons why I'm most excited about it is I think of news media as being the waves on the top of the sea that are constantly changing and always new and there's always something else.

685
00:55:40.575 --> 00:55:49.640
Where storytelling is like the deep, deep tides we have below, which affect us in ways that we're only just beginning to understand.

686
00:55:50.100 --> 00:55:55.244
not least the fact that human beings believe stories more than we believe facts.

687
00:55:55.404 --> 00:56:01.950
And one of the reasons why we believe stories more than we believe facts is because we remember them 20 times more than we remember facts.

688
00:56:02.210 --> 00:56:07.234
So people retain stories, which means it's probably a good job that we believe them more because actually we can remember them.

689
00:56:07.714 --> 00:56:09.755
And so that's the thing which is exciting me most.

690
00:56:10.715 --> 00:56:27.639
And working with the novelists, working with the filmmakers and the script makers, seeing this deep passion for that curated emotion and realising the only emotion we have curated in climate communications and climate public engagement so far is terror.

691
00:56:27.999 --> 00:56:30.120
That's literally the only emotion that we've curated.

692
00:56:30.480 --> 00:56:35.601
And going, we actually now need to curate the rest of the emotions and give people that

693
00:56:36.121 --> 00:56:42.042
emotional journey of awe and overwhelm and fear within there as well, because that's always what's in a good story.

694
00:56:42.422 --> 00:56:54.065
But to actually start thinking about whether there's an ending to this story that we're part of that isn't just Armageddon, not least because bluntly that's become ever so, ever so tropey and hackneyed.

695
00:56:54.165 --> 00:56:56.925
It's like we have done that story to death.

696
00:56:56.985 --> 00:56:58.406
We are so bored of it.

697
00:56:58.926 --> 00:57:04.047
We need to actually switch up and have a bit of a plot twist, essentially, in climate change.

698
00:57:05.325 --> 00:57:05.625
Yeah.

699
00:57:06.746 --> 00:57:07.686
Yeah.

700
00:57:07.926 --> 00:57:14.969
When I watch something with, like you were saying, kind of weaving it into culture, and I think that's really, really important.

701
00:57:15.410 --> 00:57:19.792
And like watching stuff or consuming movies or books or...

702
00:57:20.652 --> 00:57:28.041
news that isn't about it that kind of talks about it without it being like, oh, yeah, and by the way, we're fucked, moving on to the next thing.

703
00:57:28.441 --> 00:57:38.793
And instead of being like, oh, yes, you know, you could, you know, someone in a Bond movie was like, oh, actually, no, we've got your new, your new Aston Martin, it's electric, because it means that

704
00:57:39.314 --> 00:57:42.357
You know, you can go there silently or whatever.

705
00:57:42.377 --> 00:57:43.237
Yeah, exactly.

706
00:57:43.317 --> 00:57:44.478
We've got wonderful writers.

707
00:57:44.498 --> 00:57:45.119
You've got N.K.

708
00:57:45.139 --> 00:57:46.780
Jensen and the work that she's been doing.

709
00:57:46.800 --> 00:57:48.582
And this is really hard stuff to read.

710
00:57:48.602 --> 00:57:50.343
This is an easy story.

711
00:57:50.363 --> 00:57:50.903
This is intense.

712
00:57:50.923 --> 00:57:55.807
You've got Becky Chalmers and the folks who are writing all the Uplift stuff and Sam for the Wild Belt.

713
00:57:55.827 --> 00:57:58.510
You've got all of these writers who are working on it.

714
00:57:58.530 --> 00:58:05.055
And now you've begun to get filmmakers and scriptwriters who are beginning to think about how can we read some of this through.

715
00:58:05.495 --> 00:58:17.962
And honestly, I think the forces that are right against us should be more afraid of that than of public movements or journalism, because stories are the programming language of human beings.

716
00:58:18.102 --> 00:58:22.024
It's actually how you program a human being is you fill their heads with a whole set of parables and stories.

717
00:58:22.284 --> 00:58:25.845
which is why we teach and tell our children stories before we ever teach them to count.

718
00:58:26.206 --> 00:58:32.208
It's like we're programmed with narrative and we play these narratives out.

719
00:58:32.508 --> 00:58:37.370
And so I feel like it's our sort of storytelling is our secret solutions weapon.

720
00:58:38.278 --> 00:58:40.559
Yeah.

721
00:58:40.579 --> 00:58:44.702
Well, I would love to do a whole episode on like storytelling and climate storytelling.

722
00:58:44.742 --> 00:58:51.066
I was chatting to a guy called Matt Golding who has this podcast, Screw This, Let's Try Something Else.

723
00:58:51.106 --> 00:59:02.953
And we were talking about kind of the mistakes in storytelling that climate and progressive people make and the very small, narrow kind of like...

724
00:59:03.433 --> 00:59:14.462
you know, lead with the problem, you know, and then make it a bit worse and then make it a bit worse and then finish versus like the whole range of potential story arcs that we have to choose from.

725
00:59:15.243 --> 00:59:22.569
But if I don't have, if I don't keep my strict time thing brain, then I'll, then I will run out of time.

726
00:59:22.669 --> 00:59:25.151
So in the interest of that, I...

727
00:59:27.152 --> 00:59:35.977
I, two things about this, my exciting solution, or it's a movement, I would say, is called the National Emergency Briefing.

728
00:59:36.738 --> 00:59:39.119
I've talked about it quite a few times on this podcast.

729
00:59:39.480 --> 00:59:44.122
At one point, I even said, it sounds like they sponsor it, which they don't.

730
00:59:44.883 --> 00:59:49.966
But I've kind of had a bit of reservation because on the one hand, it's,

731
00:59:50.806 --> 00:59:55.511
you could argue that it's relaying the problem again.

732
00:59:56.392 --> 01:00:04.420
But I think it does something quite key that's different that gives it an extremely useful spin.

733
01:00:04.801 --> 01:00:10.326
So it's a 50-minute movie that is basically nine experts

734
01:00:11.007 --> 01:00:14.229
talking about the climate and nature crisis from different angles.

735
01:00:14.689 --> 01:00:22.293
So you've got tipping points, economics, you've got military, national security, etc.

736
01:00:23.033 --> 01:00:38.622
And they turned that briefing that was in Westminster Hall to 1,200 MPs and other business leaders and cultural faith leaders into a 50-minute movie that has been shown in, I think, 2,500 screenings so far around the country.

737
01:00:38.662 --> 01:00:39.242
So that's about

738
01:00:39.982 --> 01:00:45.786
120,000 people, between 120,000 and 150,000 people that have attended one of these.

739
01:00:46.666 --> 01:01:01.295
And then what they have at the end, which is similar to the Carbon Literacy Project, another really great initiative that's kind of in this similar vein of informing the public, is then having a discussion at the end as to what we can do.

740
01:01:02.416 --> 01:01:16.487
And I've found it, you know, when you work in this, as I'm sure you guys have found as well, people, you say to someone you do it and they're like, oh, fuck, I don't really want to ask anything else.

741
01:01:17.067 --> 01:01:19.649
And then if they do ask anything else, they might go, are we doomed?

742
01:01:19.669 --> 01:01:19.770
Yeah.

743
01:01:20.450 --> 01:01:25.251
And then if you say no, they might say, okay, what's maybe something I could do?

744
01:01:25.751 --> 01:01:31.613
And then I'm like fist pumping the air in my head because I'm like, oh, we've actually got like a productive place to talk about this from.

745
01:01:32.453 --> 01:01:47.496
And then if I want to suggest something that they do that is systemic, I often feel a bit stumped because I'm like, you could lobby your government, you could send an email to your MP, but that just feels really like insignificant, you know,

746
01:01:50.777 --> 01:01:53.598
You know, there's a lot more to like civic engagement.

747
01:01:54.098 --> 01:01:59.580
I'm reading a book called Citizens, which covers this incredibly well by John Alexander at the moment.

748
01:02:00.080 --> 01:02:14.425
But I often feel kind of stumped for like what we can do as individuals that make some kind of systemic change in a tangible way that is in a time frame that is understandable in my head and not like 2050.

749
01:02:14.465 --> 01:02:14.565
Yeah.

750
01:02:16.101 --> 01:02:22.543
But this has felt like a antidote to that feeling because when someone has said, oh, what should I do?

751
01:02:23.383 --> 01:02:34.907
I say to them, like my mum or my friend from school or, you know, someone I chat to at an event, you should either go and see the national emergency briefing.

752
01:02:35.327 --> 01:02:39.028
And then once you've seen it, then you can kind of, it empowers you.

753
01:02:39.628 --> 01:03:06.641
to you can go and um like facilitate a viewing in in your workspace or your community center or your school or wherever and then you can it's kind of like a a viral virus effect like one person gets it then they go and become a spreader then one of the 30 people who attends that decides they're going to screen their own and it's this this this chain reaction um

754
01:03:08.202 --> 01:03:19.512
And it's felt incredibly empowering, to be honest, to have something to point someone at that's not like, maybe you could reduce your meat consumption.

755
01:03:19.712 --> 01:03:20.673
These things make a difference.

756
01:03:20.833 --> 01:03:21.753
Maybe you could fly less.

757
01:03:22.154 --> 01:03:23.195
It makes a difference.

758
01:03:24.075 --> 01:03:31.481
You know, I don't talk about recycling, but that does make a smaller difference.

759
01:03:32.302 --> 01:03:32.422
And

760
01:03:35.865 --> 01:03:45.148
And to actually have something to point them at that feels more kind of holistically tangible, that feels like it is going to make a difference.

761
01:03:45.248 --> 01:03:55.492
And it's had 121,000 signatures for a debate to be debated in Parliament, like 120 MPs have signed this call.

762
01:03:55.872 --> 01:04:01.894
And what they're basically pushing for is this, but on a national scale, so a nationally televised emergency briefing,

763
01:04:02.374 --> 01:04:07.821
So similar to what we had in COVID, you know, you have experts stand at the front and say, this is what's going on.

764
01:04:07.941 --> 01:04:08.402
What do you think?

765
01:04:08.823 --> 01:04:09.744
Anyone who wants to take that?

766
01:04:10.457 --> 01:04:11.658
Shall I talk about it?

767
01:04:11.698 --> 01:04:15.802
Because I worked the original national emergency briefing.

768
01:04:15.862 --> 01:04:23.988
So I did all the red carpet interviews because there was a physical national emergency briefing last winter.

769
01:04:24.589 --> 01:04:29.613
And well, you'll know that the atmosphere in the room was kind of electrifying.

770
01:04:29.693 --> 01:04:31.895
I thought it was really like charged.

771
01:04:32.456 --> 01:04:33.617
It was quite emotional.

772
01:04:34.277 --> 01:04:37.300
And it felt like such an important point because –

773
01:04:38.816 --> 01:04:47.265
It really felt like a little bit of a breakthrough because we'd had such a standoff with the government really not saying anything about climate, particularly as I remember it.

774
01:04:47.786 --> 01:04:54.112
And it felt like almost like a massive sort of relief to have, I don't know, what was it like?

775
01:04:55.153 --> 01:05:05.561
seven or eight of our chief experts from healthcare through to the army, to the fire service, stand up and say, this is the reality of what's going on.

776
01:05:05.901 --> 01:05:08.683
And essentially they're saying our system is not fit for purpose.

777
01:05:08.703 --> 01:05:09.704
We're not prepared enough.

778
01:05:10.104 --> 01:05:15.088
They treated it as a very much from a risk point of view, from flooding to fire.

779
01:05:15.668 --> 01:05:18.270
And, you know, they've been proved right a lot this summer.

780
01:05:18.350 --> 01:05:20.212
You know, I'm sure people in Stourbridge are,

781
01:05:20.832 --> 01:05:29.477
where they lost their homes to wildfire, feel differently about climate change because they've got a lived experience of a national emergency.

782
01:05:29.917 --> 01:05:35.120
I also think given, is that a siren in the background as I talk about national emergency?

783
01:05:35.140 --> 01:05:37.581
I'll mute myself, sorry.

784
01:05:38.261 --> 01:05:39.162
And the heat wave.

785
01:05:39.322 --> 01:05:40.102
No, it's good.

786
01:05:40.262 --> 01:05:42.303
It was that rub that's atmosphere.

787
01:05:42.723 --> 01:05:46.145
Yeah, we need to do it on purpose.

788
01:05:46.465 --> 01:05:49.026
Yeah, you probably got a little button that you press with a sound effect.

789
01:05:49.046 --> 01:05:56.030
But, you know, as as the government is bringing out, apparently, you know, telling us that we need to store and water in tins.

790
01:05:57.190 --> 01:06:10.319
in its risk assessment or whatever it's supposed to be bringing out in the next few months, as they've done in some Scandinavian countries, it would seem to me entirely appropriate that we see the national emergency broadcast televised.

791
01:06:11.240 --> 01:06:12.260
I don't know if we will.

792
01:06:12.861 --> 01:06:17.584
I went to a party the other day and the director general of the BBC was there.

793
01:06:17.944 --> 01:06:19.685
So I took it upon myself to go and

794
01:06:21.307 --> 01:06:36.285
harangue him about it um he um poor man he um he wasn't especially effusive in that moment but maybe that's a contextual thing but there were a lot of other sort of senior producers and a uh

795
01:06:40.410 --> 01:06:45.152
TV network should run and then have a debate afterwards, like you're saying is happening in all of the regional ones.

796
01:06:45.652 --> 01:06:56.177
I had set up a climate and nature festival where I used to live along the Thames because we lived alongside the River Thames and nobody ever talked about flooding.

797
01:06:56.637 --> 01:06:59.318
So I set up a festival and it's amazing what you can unlock.

798
01:06:59.498 --> 01:07:09.145
from a few film screenings and interviewing some authors on stage, you know, you get where climate deniers come, we have conversations with people in the community, and it's really good for that.

799
01:07:09.265 --> 01:07:11.387
It's a solution to a problem that you found.

800
01:07:11.807 --> 01:07:13.268
So therefore, it's a solution.

801
01:07:13.548 --> 01:07:15.530
The one thing that I would just say...

802
01:07:16.610 --> 01:07:27.397
I actually am quite peed off, not with you, but with the general kind of anything that's individual action.

803
01:07:27.517 --> 01:07:28.598
I say it's personal action.

804
01:07:28.678 --> 01:07:29.418
Excuse me for two seconds.

805
01:07:29.438 --> 01:07:30.699
Sorry, Baby's just crying.

806
01:07:30.719 --> 01:07:31.299
Can you one second?

807
01:07:31.539 --> 01:07:32.140
Oh, no.

808
01:07:32.520 --> 01:07:33.181
No worries.

809
01:07:33.581 --> 01:07:35.002
He's dealing with a baby as well.

810
01:07:35.142 --> 01:07:36.123
And he's in a different time.

811
01:07:36.163 --> 01:07:48.734
So one of the things that I think just a little point of correction is that we've had this quite artificial wall between personal action and individual action and systemic change.

812
01:07:49.234 --> 01:07:53.218
And I think we need to drop that because, A, we lost a lot of traction.

813
01:07:53.238 --> 01:07:53.338
Yeah.

814
01:07:53.718 --> 01:08:02.424
Because the general public actually does think a lot in personal change and domestic change in industrialized nations because, you know, we all go, ha, ha, ha, recycling.

815
01:08:02.984 --> 01:08:07.847
Actually, I gave you a systemic change solution.

816
01:08:07.927 --> 01:08:08.267
You did.

817
01:08:08.647 --> 01:08:09.208
I'm sorry.

818
01:08:09.468 --> 01:08:10.889
I realized after I said it.

819
01:08:11.269 --> 01:08:18.992
Yeah, but you see, if we all have an automatic reflex, oh God, we can't talk about plastics or recycling.

820
01:08:19.372 --> 01:08:28.575
It's actually, these are the things that keep people engaged and they stop them from flipping from the denialism to the doomism.

821
01:08:28.655 --> 01:08:34.417
I said this to George Monbiot recently, and he on Blue Sky, and he sent me back one word.

822
01:08:34.698 --> 01:08:35.618
He went, true.

823
01:08:38.108 --> 01:09:01.815
can i just a hundred percent back that because i'm just add another layer to it which is the dismissal of personal action is inherently horribly sexist always has been it's been i wrote an article about this it's incredibly sexist um so number one 80 80 of purchases particularly for the home are made by women so it is put

824
01:09:02.435 --> 01:09:06.999
consumer action, changing what you buy, changing how the home works is primarily a job for women.

825
01:09:07.479 --> 01:09:15.725
Secondly, political action is all protesting, writing, turning up at events, etc.

826
01:09:16.105 --> 01:09:17.446
is very much a male behaviour.

827
01:09:17.466 --> 01:09:22.329
And one of the reasons for that is who the hell is at home looking after the kids or the old people or strew out there protesting.

828
01:09:22.710 --> 01:09:23.090
So there was a

829
01:09:23.850 --> 01:09:28.932
huge gender difference between public activism and consumer action.

830
01:09:29.512 --> 01:09:35.375
One of this overwhelmingly undertaken by women and the other one overwhelming to be undertaken by men.

831
01:09:35.635 --> 01:09:38.456
Not least because there's also a great deal of personal violence

832
01:09:39.416 --> 01:09:44.241
a jeopardy for women in taking public action, particularly in places around the world.

833
01:09:44.681 --> 01:09:48.284
Like there are things that happen to women when they're arrested that don't happen to men.

834
01:09:48.745 --> 01:09:54.830
There are issues around maintaining and protecting your children and your home, which often fall to women, not to men.

835
01:09:55.150 --> 01:10:04.775
And so this dismissal of consumer action is primarily a dismissal of historically through all time the big area where women have power.

836
01:10:05.156 --> 01:10:18.123
And I always relate this back to when we think about the slave trade and the huge actions that were taken to try to, here in the UK, legally end the slave trade.

837
01:10:18.683 --> 01:10:21.024
And of course, this is a time when women didn't have the vote.

838
01:10:21.424 --> 01:10:33.746
So actually, not only were we less likely to participate in public action and all the things which are happening in Parliament and William Wallace and all the rest of it, we were legally excluded from that.

839
01:10:33.766 --> 01:10:37.687
And one of the things which is often not covered in stories about this, but was

840
01:10:41.128 --> 01:10:45.031
of sugar, these huge sugar boycotts, all won by women.

841
01:10:45.211 --> 01:10:58.141
And if you look at, there's a whole load of political cartoons at the time, everyone drinking their tea going, oh, because there's no sugar in their tea, because women were refusing to have colonial sugar that was being produced by slaves in their home.

842
01:10:59.101 --> 01:11:02.702
This was huge, a huge part of the ending of that trade.

843
01:11:02.862 --> 01:11:05.103
It absolutely cut off.

844
01:11:05.243 --> 01:11:11.664
There was actually debates around the fact that the government was going to have to start buying the sugar because consumers were refusing to buy it.

845
01:11:11.885 --> 01:11:13.085
That was all led by women.

846
01:11:13.425 --> 01:11:24.528
And so I 100% agree with Lucy in terms of the assuming that political action and action outside of the home is inherently more valuable than...

847
01:11:24.968 --> 01:11:28.670
then action that you're taking home is horribly sexist.

848
01:11:29.010 --> 01:11:39.154
And it's excluding a huge amount of action, not least because the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change says that we can save 5% of demand-side carbon almost immediately through consumer action.

849
01:11:39.174 --> 01:11:41.315
So there's also no frigging scientific basis.

850
01:11:41.735 --> 01:11:47.617
It is an inherent bias that the climate movement has, and it's pretty sexist as a bias.

851
01:11:47.997 --> 01:11:49.518
So sorry for that rant, but I just...

852
01:11:49.538 --> 01:11:51.039
No, I really appreciate it.

853
01:11:51.080 --> 01:11:52.341
No scientific basis.

854
01:11:52.501 --> 01:11:57.986
The scientific basis shows that demand-side carbon can be changed almost immediately through socio-behavioral activity.

855
01:11:58.186 --> 01:12:04.192
And that's more, that's twice as much as the impact of air travel.

856
01:12:04.873 --> 01:12:08.616
So, you know, 5% of demand-side carbon versus 2.5% of demand-side carbon.

857
01:12:08.677 --> 01:12:08.877
Yeah.

858
01:12:09.377 --> 01:12:12.840
So what we do in our own homes could transform climate overnight.

859
01:12:12.860 --> 01:12:15.743
So there's no scientific basis for dismissing consumer action.

860
01:12:16.023 --> 01:12:21.007
And secondly, it's dismissing what women do, which, by the way, our movement has been doing for a very long time.

861
01:12:21.307 --> 01:12:33.618
So, yes, off my rant, but bring back massively supporting, loving and thanking the public for everything which they do about climate change in their own home, because every single bit of carbon is a bit of carbon.

862
01:12:34.298 --> 01:12:37.320
Also needs to go back to who does this serve, as we were saying before.

863
01:12:37.380 --> 01:12:42.904
You know, it's really, really helped out denialists, oil and gas.

864
01:12:42.924 --> 01:12:45.946
This whole thing is shutting down that whole kind of avenue.

865
01:12:46.306 --> 01:12:54.212
The truth of it is an unfortunate reality in Western societies, particularly the UK, which is controlled by supermarkets.

866
01:12:54.272 --> 01:12:56.073
Our purchasing is controlled by supermarkets.

867
01:12:56.473 --> 01:12:58.715
Our supply chains are dominated by supermarkets.

868
01:12:59.215 --> 01:13:01.358
People don't have political traction.

869
01:13:01.658 --> 01:13:10.991
And that is why we see the rise of reform and restore and, you know, all of these kind of hard right politically affiliated organisations.

870
01:13:11.512 --> 01:13:14.817
And it, you know, partly, you know,

871
01:13:16.001 --> 01:13:28.304
I think the environmental movement has been really culpable in dismissing a whole load of people and, you know, where we actually built up some traction.

872
01:13:28.624 --> 01:13:38.827
It doesn't fit a nice, you know, progressive Marxist leaning political ideology, but it's the reality of what we're dealing with.

873
01:13:39.587 --> 01:13:44.291
Oh, even I hear people saying, oh, the idea of personal carbon and what you can do in your home was invented by BP.

874
01:13:44.331 --> 01:13:45.352
It's like, no, it wasn't.

875
01:13:45.592 --> 01:13:46.092
I was there.

876
01:13:46.372 --> 01:13:51.656
I was there in the 90s when all of this work started and when we were working on personal carbon.

877
01:13:51.977 --> 01:13:52.877
It's a story.

878
01:13:53.238 --> 01:13:56.140
The environment movement loves to tell itself that BP invented this.

879
01:13:56.580 --> 01:13:58.802
For those of us who were there, it's like, no, they didn't.

880
01:14:00.183 --> 01:14:01.804
That's a complete myth that we have.

881
01:14:02.024 --> 01:14:08.808
They might have helped popularise it, just like they popularised many other things, just like they popularised solar panels at the time when they're going through beyond petroleum.

882
01:14:09.128 --> 01:14:19.814
But the idea that as individuals we can make a difference, some of that stuff was invented by my mum in the 70s and women all through time who have worked on this.

883
01:14:20.134 --> 01:14:27.599
So BP does not get to – we don't get to gift BP the idea that consumer and personal action can make a difference in the world.

884
01:14:29.125 --> 01:14:30.746
I really appreciate that.

885
01:14:31.066 --> 01:14:44.252
Because I think I've had a... Like you were saying at the very start of this, and maybe this is a good place to bring it to a close, Gus, you said you've swung wildly from radical optimism to radical pessimism, and now you've ended somewhere in the middle.

886
01:14:44.272 --> 01:14:48.475
I think I'm on my own kind of understanding of like...

887
01:14:49.577 --> 01:14:57.401
you know, my collective, my individual actions, my collective actions, the importance of, or, and portions of both.

888
01:14:58.302 --> 01:15:08.608
And I think, yeah, that's, that's a really important bit of context to have when, because it is easy and I've done it, I hold my hands up, I've done it myself.

889
01:15:09.348 --> 01:15:15.112
Yeah, we'll, we'll, it would be great to do another episode like this, because I feel like we could, we could talk for like multiple hours.

890
01:15:15.912 --> 01:15:17.293
Can I just make one point?

891
01:15:17.613 --> 01:15:17.994
Yes.

892
01:15:18.454 --> 01:15:25.820
That Gus missed the conversation there on gendered exclusion because he was tending to his baby.

893
01:15:31.905 --> 01:15:33.667
I wonder if I could just leave you also.

894
01:15:33.687 --> 01:15:37.930
I don't know if you know this, but the UK is doing great.

895
01:15:40.272 --> 01:15:41.393
You do know that, don't you?

896
01:15:44.495 --> 01:15:48.761
I can see the expression on all your faces.

897
01:15:48.801 --> 01:15:51.364
The national psyche does not take compliments well.

898
01:15:51.504 --> 01:15:55.509
We're not necessarily disagreeing on proof there.

899
01:15:55.569 --> 01:15:56.751
The UK is doing great.

900
01:15:56.771 --> 01:16:01.117
We're all just like shriveling up at the fact that you're saying nice things about the UK.

901
01:16:01.157 --> 01:16:01.978
We just can't take it.

902
01:16:02.629 --> 01:16:16.293
Look, if you keep on showing a kid only the Fs on the report card and you don't show the kid any of the As, that kid is eventually going to come to believe that they are a bad kid, that they are useless, which is what we do.

903
01:16:16.413 --> 01:16:18.974
And in the UK, you are particularly good at this.

904
01:16:19.754 --> 01:16:23.235
You love looking at and talking about the Fs on the report card, but...

905
01:16:24.344 --> 01:16:32.094
But carbon emissions in the UK fell by 1.8% in 2025, and that's now down to the lowest level in 150 years.

906
01:16:33.155 --> 01:16:35.799
And gas is down to 34-year low.

907
01:16:36.139 --> 01:16:42.487
Coal use is down to the levels that were last seen in 1600 when Queen Elizabeth was on the throne and Shakespeare was writing Hamlet.

908
01:16:43.168 --> 01:16:52.538
So, you know, I know it's a lot, but the UK's emissions are now 54% below 1990 levels, and your GDP has nearly doubled since then.

909
01:16:52.618 --> 01:16:55.241
So it's a big fight, and there's a lot going on.

910
01:16:55.381 --> 01:17:02.048
But the UK is doing better than almost any other country in the world at reducing its emissions, and it is a pioneer in doing that.

911
01:17:02.609 --> 01:17:05.831
And it is a pioneer in many other areas as well, not just wind power.

912
01:17:06.712 --> 01:17:11.455
It's just committed 400 million pounds to the Tropical Forest Forever Fund.

913
01:17:12.376 --> 01:17:16.018
It is one of the best countries in the world when it comes to decarbonization or reducing emissions.

914
01:17:16.139 --> 01:17:17.099
And it is a global leader.

915
01:17:17.519 --> 01:17:19.301
And I think that's something worth remembering.

916
01:17:19.741 --> 01:17:22.283
You're one of the only countries where emissions are falling.

917
01:17:22.899 --> 01:17:23.219
It is.

918
01:17:23.339 --> 01:17:24.200
It's a really good point.

919
01:17:24.260 --> 01:17:31.204
And also, we export a lot of that consultancy and that sort of prowess.

920
01:17:31.604 --> 01:17:34.586
You know, there's lots of people who do that, which is never talked about.

921
01:17:35.087 --> 01:17:35.567
Yes, you do.

922
01:17:35.727 --> 01:17:41.110
And there are some of the best climate negotiators are British, and a lot of the leadership in international forums is British.

923
01:17:41.170 --> 01:17:43.532
So, you know, don't forget it.

924
01:17:44.622 --> 01:17:45.182
Thank you, Gus.

925
01:17:45.503 --> 01:17:54.749
I'm going to suggest that we've got a group of people here who are absolutely happy to be huge vocal proponents for solutions, but not for pride.

926
01:17:55.090 --> 01:17:56.811
So we need to get better at that one.

927
01:17:59.313 --> 01:17:59.593
Yes.

928
01:17:59.713 --> 01:18:02.635
Just remember, you've got to celebrate the A's as well as the F's.

929
01:18:03.596 --> 01:18:06.978
Yeah, that's a wonderful note to leave it on.

930
01:18:07.178 --> 01:18:09.360
So thank you all very much for coming.

931
01:18:09.540 --> 01:18:11.962
And yeah, much appreciated.

932
01:18:13.720 --> 01:18:14.782
Rob, thank you so much.

933
01:18:14.802 --> 01:18:15.964
What an amazing discussion.

934
01:18:15.984 --> 01:18:17.006
Yeah, it was great.

935
01:18:17.026 --> 01:18:18.328
It went by very quick.

936
01:18:18.829 --> 01:18:19.229
It did.

937
01:18:19.269 --> 01:18:20.191
It went way too quick.

938
01:18:21.573 --> 01:18:23.997
Yeah, I think we should pencil in like two hours next time.

939
01:18:24.358 --> 01:18:25.620
I don't know if our calendars will.
