WEBVTT

1
00:00:10.247 --> 00:00:14.454
Welcome to Under the Banyan Tree, where we put Asian markets and economics in context.

2
00:00:14.494 --> 00:00:20.122
My name is Fred Newman, Chief Asian Economist here at HSBC's Asian Headquarters in Hong Kong.

3
00:00:21.117 --> 00:00:21.657
Yeah, that's right.

4
00:00:23.478 --> 00:00:27.661
Let me introduce the people that we are going to... Harold, who are you?

5
00:00:28.321 --> 00:00:28.882
Oh, myself.

6
00:00:29.302 --> 00:00:30.342
Let me introduce myself.

7
00:00:30.482 --> 00:00:33.464
So I'm the co-host of Under the Banyard Tree.

8
00:00:33.844 --> 00:00:36.426
And we have three other people here on the stage today.

9
00:00:36.826 --> 00:00:37.667
Yuu-Chan in the middle.

10
00:00:37.827 --> 00:00:42.389
She is our expert on electric vehicles, but also on tech hardware.

11
00:00:42.409 --> 00:00:43.330
So we're going to talk about...

12
00:00:43.670 --> 00:00:51.534
That particular topic today, we have Frank sitting here, the analyst who looks at NVIDIA and all other matters of tech in the world.

13
00:00:51.875 --> 00:00:54.496
So we're going to look at US and China tech in this discussion.

14
00:00:54.876 --> 00:00:59.359
And of course, we've got Paul Merkel here, who knows everything about the Peruvian currency.

15
00:00:59.379 --> 00:01:02.160
And all other currencies in the world as well.

16
00:01:05.701 --> 00:01:12.948
Now, before we get started, we should probably mention to our listeners and viewers at home that this is a live recording.

17
00:01:13.048 --> 00:01:16.952
And with that, Harold, what's been shaking in the equity world?

18
00:01:16.972 --> 00:01:21.537
You've been away a little bit, but I look at those equity indices.

19
00:01:21.577 --> 00:01:22.938
They don't look that encouraging.

20
00:01:22.938 --> 00:01:25.158
No, actually I've been on holiday over the last two weeks.

21
00:01:25.759 --> 00:01:28.299
And suddenly... That's why?

22
00:01:28.319 --> 00:01:29.059
That's maybe why.

23
00:01:29.499 --> 00:01:32.780
But yeah, I come back and of course these markets are down.

24
00:01:32.900 --> 00:01:36.021
Actually, certain markets have held up, I think reasonably well.

25
00:01:37.201 --> 00:01:39.021
India, for example, has held up reasonably well.

26
00:01:39.061 --> 00:01:41.022
The S&amp;P has actually held up well.

27
00:01:41.042 --> 00:01:41.842
The Nasdaq is down.

28
00:01:41.882 --> 00:01:44.482
So it's really to a large extent a tax story.

29
00:01:44.863 --> 00:01:46.823
But let me quickly go back and...

30
00:01:47.283 --> 00:01:49.324
Maybe you can help me out a little bit here, Fred.

31
00:01:50.245 --> 00:01:50.905
What has happened?

32
00:01:50.925 --> 00:01:52.446
We've seen bond yields move.

33
00:01:52.786 --> 00:01:54.667
We can talk with Paul about the currencies.

34
00:01:55.067 --> 00:01:56.788
But why has this happened?

35
00:01:56.808 --> 00:02:04.492
Has there been any economic data that's come out that scared markets while I was seeing Mexican temples?

36
00:02:04.552 --> 00:02:06.834
There are a few themes out there in the market.

37
00:02:06.954 --> 00:02:12.578
One is that, of course, there's still worries about inflation and where central banks are taking interest rates.

38
00:02:12.658 --> 00:02:15.760
So interest rates are going up in most economies.

39
00:02:16.000 --> 00:02:17.341
Oil price is very high.

40
00:02:17.361 --> 00:02:20.804
That worries investors who invest in bonds, for example.

41
00:02:21.064 --> 00:02:21.945
That's one big theme.

42
00:02:21.985 --> 00:02:28.930
And then, of course, we also saw a bit of a shakeout in the AI trade, where investors are getting a bit more nervous about inflation.

43
00:02:29.190 --> 00:02:32.774
this idea about AI valuations, for example.

44
00:02:32.794 --> 00:02:34.936
Some volatility in that part as well.

45
00:02:34.956 --> 00:02:44.925
But that had partially also to do, I think, with bond yields rising and people worried that the financing, we can talk about this in a second, of course, that maybe financing would be an issue.

46
00:02:44.945 --> 00:02:47.868
So there was a bit of an economic component to this as well.

47
00:02:47.888 --> 00:02:51.972
And I love how the equity strategist always blames the economics when things go south.

48
00:02:51.992 --> 00:02:52.833
Yeah, why not, right?

49
00:02:53.373 --> 00:02:57.096
But maybe we should start right here on the more of the macro side and bring Paul in.

50
00:02:57.116 --> 00:02:57.356
Yes.

51
00:02:57.636 --> 00:03:01.939
Paul, talk to us about the big view on currencies.

52
00:03:02.039 --> 00:03:06.361
The U.S. dollar relatively resilient this year, I think.

53
00:03:06.541 --> 00:03:10.124
Is that a theme that you think will remain in play?

54
00:03:10.484 --> 00:03:11.885
Interest rates in the U.S. high.

55
00:03:11.905 --> 00:03:15.287
Does the dollar remain well supported or is there some cracks showing there?

56
00:03:15.507 --> 00:03:20.832
Well, it is very much the baseline scenario that we think that the dollar can perform quite well.

57
00:03:20.852 --> 00:03:26.217
I mean, that's been the case since largely June this year, maybe a little bit before that.

58
00:03:26.917 --> 00:03:33.003
And I think that there are some connection points here about its outperformance, maybe what's happening in your world too.

59
00:03:33.843 --> 00:03:37.606
What's happening is that the Federal Reserve has been telling us that they want to raise rates.

60
00:03:38.146 --> 00:03:42.589
And you get some tightening of financial conditions alongside that.

61
00:03:42.649 --> 00:03:45.190
That puts the dollar in a stronger orbit.

62
00:03:45.230 --> 00:03:49.353
But we're also seeing maybe a longer-term theme, not yet,

63
00:03:49.853 --> 00:03:51.775
that could eventually challenge the dollar.

64
00:03:51.795 --> 00:04:00.922
I mean, we've had some moments recently where, say, the U.S. equity market on the technology side is not performing that well, and the dollar weakens.

65
00:04:01.302 --> 00:04:04.925
So you're seeing some stretching points that can challenge the dollar.

66
00:04:04.945 --> 00:04:10.069
If you get enough fear occurring in parts of the equity complex, it's not necessarily good for the currency.

67
00:04:10.309 --> 00:04:11.249
Can I just follow up on that?

68
00:04:11.390 --> 00:04:18.233
Is the dollar supported by high interest rates or because the AI theme is so strong that it sucks in money?

69
00:04:18.513 --> 00:04:21.154
What is the bigger driver of the dollar at the moment?

70
00:04:21.274 --> 00:04:22.154
It's a good question.

71
00:04:22.254 --> 00:04:28.537
I think that our approach is more associated with interest rates and short-term interest rate differentials.

72
00:04:29.178 --> 00:04:34.040
But there's no question, if you look at the flow of funds that's been going into the United States,

73
00:04:34.840 --> 00:04:36.881
some of the data provided by the US Treasury.

74
00:04:37.221 --> 00:04:43.024
I mean this year there's been hundreds of billions of dollars going into the US equity market, much more than perhaps fixed income.

75
00:04:43.564 --> 00:04:47.847
So again, there's definitely a connection between what's going on with the equity market.

76
00:04:47.927 --> 00:04:56.531
Exactly, but also if you believe that you are going to be a winner in the AI sort of new industry that emerges, if you pay

77
00:04:57.211 --> 00:05:02.833
say 7 or 8 or 9 percent on interest rates on a bond, that's not a big thing.

78
00:05:02.853 --> 00:05:07.495
You're thinking you're going to make 100 percent in profits, 500 percent in profits, right?

79
00:05:07.835 --> 00:05:16.318
So one or two percentage points higher interest rates is not really going to dent your confidence that you want to invest.

80
00:05:16.338 --> 00:05:20.040
So higher interest rates is probably not going to slow down these investments that quickly.

81
00:05:20.642 --> 00:05:22.663
Well, it comes down to timeframes, of course.

82
00:05:23.724 --> 00:05:25.485
But ultimately, look, I think you're right.

83
00:05:25.525 --> 00:05:29.527
From a longer term perspective, it's feeding into this view of dollar exceptionalism.

84
00:05:29.888 --> 00:05:32.669
We've had multiple rounds of this over the last decade.

85
00:05:33.570 --> 00:05:34.150
And it's back.

86
00:05:34.290 --> 00:05:36.892
But it's always in the back of my mind

87
00:05:37.827 --> 00:05:42.790
while we've been on more on the right side of the fence over the last six months or so, what could go wrong?

88
00:05:42.830 --> 00:05:43.991
What could challenge the thinking?

89
00:05:44.011 --> 00:05:48.274
And as I said, there's been some indications there that maybe not everything is great.

90
00:05:49.074 --> 00:05:56.979
But you mentioned dollar exceptionalism, but we also talked about the de-dollarization or debasement trade.

91
00:05:57.019 --> 00:06:01.842
I don't know if you want to call it, where people at some point say, we're looking for alternatives to the U.S. dollar.

92
00:06:01.862 --> 00:06:03.043
We're going to gold somewhere else.

93
00:06:03.063 --> 00:06:04.144
We want to move away from it, yeah.

94
00:06:04.324 --> 00:06:08.487
How does an FX guru like you respond to those worries?

95
00:06:09.428 --> 00:06:12.670
I've been to that rodeo so many times in my career.

96
00:06:12.690 --> 00:06:14.671
And you're Canadian, you've been to a few rodeos.

97
00:06:14.731 --> 00:06:16.573
I've been to a few rodeos.

98
00:06:16.653 --> 00:06:19.655
But I'm quite patient about it when it comes back.

99
00:06:20.535 --> 00:06:26.740
I do field a lot of questions that is this the moment that it's really going to hurt and eventually the storm begins to go away.

100
00:06:27.300 --> 00:06:29.881
But currencies are always a two-sided game, right?

101
00:06:30.021 --> 00:06:32.322
One currency is strengthened, the other one is going to be weakened.

102
00:06:32.582 --> 00:06:34.202
So what have we seen in Asia?

103
00:06:34.702 --> 00:06:37.663
Which currencies have strengthened, which ones have held up reasonably well?

104
00:06:37.863 --> 00:06:39.024
Well, absolutely.

105
00:06:39.324 --> 00:06:45.906
What the team has been identifying for quite a long time, led by Joey Chu, is that the Remembe should be an outperformer.

106
00:06:45.966 --> 00:06:50.627
I mean, the team has been having this thinking pretty much since September last year.

107
00:06:51.028 --> 00:06:52.288
It's been absolutely right.

108
00:06:52.648 --> 00:06:57.353
You know, you did hit some points where maybe they don't want the currency appreciation to be too strong.

109
00:06:57.393 --> 00:06:58.694
That is the regulators.

110
00:06:59.255 --> 00:07:02.038
But on the other hand, the direction of travel has been very, very clear.

111
00:07:02.078 --> 00:07:02.999
So there are exceptions.

112
00:07:03.079 --> 00:07:07.263
And that currency is held up very nicely in a strong dollar world.

113
00:07:07.283 --> 00:07:08.765
So, again, there are some exceptions.

114
00:07:08.965 --> 00:07:09.365
And the yen?

115
00:07:10.286 --> 00:07:12.749
The Japanese yen is a different story.

116
00:07:12.789 --> 00:07:14.991
It's probably, you know, it's gone through...

117
00:07:15.902 --> 00:07:20.726
quite significant weakness over the last few years, but that appears to be dissipating.

118
00:07:21.226 --> 00:07:30.533
Perhaps, again, the worst has passed, but the recovery will be a lot slower because you're still dealing with quite a high interest rate differential between the US and Japan.

119
00:07:31.874 --> 00:07:35.375
Perhaps one last question for you, Paul, before we move on to our other guests here.

120
00:07:35.855 --> 00:07:39.516
Obviously, gold falls into your purview as well.

121
00:07:40.476 --> 00:07:46.478
We have an environment of high inflation, high geopolitical risk, a lot of uncertainty in the world economy.

122
00:07:46.998 --> 00:07:52.279
Is this now the era for gold, or is that a bit overdone?

123
00:07:52.379 --> 00:07:53.820
Gold has actually declined this year.

124
00:07:53.840 --> 00:07:54.240
Yeah, it's all over.

125
00:07:54.400 --> 00:08:05.523
Yeah, it's a very volatile animal and when you think it should be holding up in periods of significant risk aversion, again I've seen enough moments in my time when that doesn't work.

126
00:08:06.163 --> 00:08:06.963
You have a rodeo.

127
00:08:07.124 --> 00:08:09.124
Another rodeo or a series of rodeos.

128
00:08:09.524 --> 00:08:15.426
But you have to think about the longer term game and again the direction of travel is another phrase we're using.

129
00:08:15.746 --> 00:08:18.167
And for us we're still long term constructive on it.

130
00:08:18.387 --> 00:08:23.128
You know the demand I think is still going to remain pretty resilient whether it's from central banks or retail.

131
00:08:23.568 --> 00:08:26.569
different types of investors, but again it's quite volatile.

132
00:08:27.269 --> 00:08:35.232
So we've spoken about the dollar, the investment flows coming into the US, and that's to a large extent a US tech story, right?

133
00:08:36.113 --> 00:08:39.054
Frank, that's your purview, that's your area.

134
00:08:40.334 --> 00:08:42.655
These companies, they're still making good profits, right?

135
00:08:43.415 --> 00:08:47.797
Have we seen a slowdown in the investments by these companies in the US?

136
00:08:48.400 --> 00:08:54.247
Yeah, I think if you look at, you know, obviously the market's been very volatile with the AI leading the way down.

137
00:08:55.148 --> 00:09:01.035
The number one issue, I think, is still something that plagues the market over the last few years, which is funding, right?

138
00:09:01.335 --> 00:09:03.478
The amount of capex spending is unprecedented.

139
00:09:04.219 --> 00:09:08.764
But this year it's become especially sensitive because this is the first year where...

140
00:09:09.084 --> 00:09:17.188
these hyperscalers in the US are starting to turn negative free cash flow, which means they have to start raising money either through debt or through equity.

141
00:09:17.508 --> 00:09:22.671
Hence, with inflation concerns and bond rates, this has been a key issue.

142
00:09:23.751 --> 00:09:28.894
But I think if you look at the balance sheet of the hyperscalers, generally they're all very healthy.

143
00:09:29.214 --> 00:09:30.655
We've looked at this earlier this year.

144
00:09:31.655 --> 00:09:34.477
I think next year they could raise their capex from

145
00:09:35.077 --> 00:09:40.341
750 billion this year to almost 1 and 1 half trillion, which is 100% growth.

146
00:09:40.601 --> 00:09:47.566
That would have raised the debt to equity for this group probably to about 15 to 20%, which we think is still very manageable.

147
00:09:47.847 --> 00:09:50.909
Well, you're telling a very bullish picture here.

148
00:09:50.929 --> 00:10:01.877
You're saying that US investment could jump to almost 1 and 1 half trillion, would double what it is this year, which would completely blow out all supply chains in Asia.

149
00:10:03.558 --> 00:10:06.539
I want to challenge you a little bit and explain this to me.

150
00:10:06.559 --> 00:10:11.419
There's a lot of concern in markets that essentially it's all a shell game.

151
00:10:11.459 --> 00:10:17.941
There's companies like big semiconductor companies, NVIDIA being one, making a lot of money.

152
00:10:18.021 --> 00:10:19.641
They fund people in order to buy their products.

153
00:10:19.661 --> 00:10:23.702
And they then put money into, lend the money to the customers to buy their chips.

154
00:10:23.862 --> 00:10:25.122
And so it goes back and forth.

155
00:10:25.162 --> 00:10:28.422
And it looks like everybody's making money, but really they're just lending to each other.

156
00:10:28.602 --> 00:10:31.743
Is this not ultimately a recipe for...

157
00:10:32.363 --> 00:10:34.745
kind of a sharp downturn to say the least.

158
00:10:35.486 --> 00:10:41.370
Because vendor financing, to finance your own sales, that's a bit of a odd.

159
00:10:41.390 --> 00:10:42.391
A tricky situation.

160
00:10:43.212 --> 00:10:49.116
Yeah, I think that's ultimately why the valuation for a lot of these companies are not that high.

161
00:10:49.217 --> 00:10:58.944
I mean, you look at Nvidia earnings, it's generating nearly 100% in earnings, but the multiple is lower now than it's seen in even the crypto area, right?

162
00:10:59.965 --> 00:11:03.306
the uncertainty because of these financing, right?

163
00:11:03.506 --> 00:11:08.328
But I would say in the last few months though, there's still other issues such as power, right?

164
00:11:09.088 --> 00:11:11.168
Power build out in the US infrastructure.

165
00:11:11.709 --> 00:11:17.110
There are concerns that is there a big delay and this is going to lead to a slowdown in data center builds.

166
00:11:17.470 --> 00:11:25.693
There's also talks about the political environment in the States, whether that's gonna lead to a slowdown in data center, which ultimately will hit the hardware guys.

167
00:11:26.353 --> 00:11:33.297
But I think when you think about the underlying demand of compute, it still remains quite positive.

168
00:11:33.317 --> 00:11:39.580
So you can look at, for example, there are GPU rentals.

169
00:11:39.860 --> 00:11:41.761
People are able to rent out their GPUs.

170
00:11:42.241 --> 00:11:43.782
And you can look at them on Bloomberg.

171
00:11:43.842 --> 00:11:46.063
It's basically a commodity price.

172
00:11:46.423 --> 00:11:48.144
The trend there has continued to go up.

173
00:11:49.805 --> 00:11:54.448
I do think that underlying demand isn't an issue, but the funding is a question mark.

174
00:11:54.969 --> 00:11:57.210
What does that mean for the Asian producers?

175
00:11:57.250 --> 00:12:03.835
Because, as Fred said, if we see more investments, we're already running at all sorts of capacity problems.

176
00:12:03.875 --> 00:12:07.978
Certain factories are running at full speed in order to get the DRAM and…

177
00:12:08.458 --> 00:12:10.080
and any other components out.

178
00:12:10.140 --> 00:12:12.263
Can they actually expand faster in the US?

179
00:12:12.643 --> 00:12:16.127
Because the components they need to get from the US, we haven't got the additional capacity.

180
00:12:16.147 --> 00:12:18.510
And when is that capacity gonna come online?

181
00:12:18.570 --> 00:12:20.232
For example, in memory chips.

182
00:12:20.867 --> 00:12:25.091
Yeah, I think when you look at the capacity issue, it will still be a challenge next year.

183
00:12:26.092 --> 00:12:35.241
But I think at the same time though, you know, the market concern is not so much capacity driven, but more of sustainability into 2028.

184
00:12:35.541 --> 00:12:44.370
So it's kind of a little bit of an ironic thing where you have market is extremely tight next year because supply, yet there's fear about 2028 being sustainable.

185
00:12:44.710 --> 00:12:46.191
This is not the first time we've seen this.

186
00:12:46.231 --> 00:12:50.933
I mean, the last couple of years, there's always question marks about sustainability of this trend.

187
00:12:51.673 --> 00:12:58.556
But so far, we've seen after a few months, the market basically gains some confidence that the sustainability will continue.

188
00:12:58.776 --> 00:13:05.059
But what's more important, though, is that I actually think the application of AI is no longer something that needs proof of concept.

189
00:13:05.499 --> 00:13:10.642
I think when we started this a few years ago, there was this worry that, well, how are we going to use AI?

190
00:13:10.662 --> 00:13:11.942
But it's pretty clear we all are using it.

191
00:13:11.962 --> 00:13:13.443
Will people pay for it and these sort of things?

192
00:13:13.783 --> 00:13:15.604
So that's a fair argument.

193
00:13:16.165 --> 00:13:18.646
But there are other risks that have come up as well.

194
00:13:18.666 --> 00:13:20.248
So we have the funding risk we spoke about.

195
00:13:20.648 --> 00:13:22.969
Also, Chinese competition is an issue, right?

196
00:13:23.009 --> 00:13:26.532
And we'll maybe talk with Yuchen about this in a second.

197
00:13:26.552 --> 00:13:29.894
But that's another fear that is hitting the markets as well.

198
00:13:30.274 --> 00:13:31.656
I think the Chinese competition...

199
00:13:31.676 --> 00:13:45.031
I know in this region we like to talk about China versus the U.S., but I think if you look at where, because of the geopolitical aspect of where things are going, I don't see there's a lot of overlap between China and the U.S.

200
00:13:45.071 --> 00:13:45.692
I think they will...

201
00:13:46.112 --> 00:13:47.715
each will kind of go its own path.

202
00:13:48.376 --> 00:13:49.537
I'll give you an example.

203
00:13:50.018 --> 00:14:00.494
Early in the year, there was a lot of concern about Kimi coming out, and that would be very, that could have a big impact on the US market because the open source model was more efficient.

204
00:14:01.380 --> 00:14:11.564
It is more efficient, but what it did was that it caused the US market to look at the open source model approach and create their own open source models.

205
00:14:11.984 --> 00:14:20.588
So basically they looked at what the guys in China did and said that was actually quite interesting, it may be a more efficient way of doing it, but we're not going to use the Chinese models.

206
00:14:20.668 --> 00:14:24.610
We're going to basically continue to have the US model, but we'll change the approach.

207
00:14:24.950 --> 00:14:28.411
So I think you're not really going to see a direct head-to-head competition.

208
00:14:29.472 --> 00:14:29.712
Frank?

209
00:14:30.732 --> 00:14:33.254
When you, I mean, everybody talks about AI.

210
00:14:33.374 --> 00:14:35.717
Everybody's now suddenly an expert.

211
00:14:35.777 --> 00:14:37.258
I know Harold is suddenly an expert.

212
00:14:37.338 --> 00:14:45.465
I'm now suddenly an expert, just as much as I was a virus expert a few years ago, just as much as I was a terror expert a few years ago.

213
00:14:45.846 --> 00:14:46.887
But you're the real expert.

214
00:14:46.947 --> 00:14:49.589
You follow the semiconductor companies.

215
00:14:49.649 --> 00:14:50.790
You're in the weeds there.

216
00:14:51.050 --> 00:14:53.633
What is the one thing you think all of us get wrong?

217
00:14:53.673 --> 00:14:57.276
What is the one thing where you say, guys, you're just not getting it?

218
00:14:57.716 --> 00:14:59.618
You're just not getting it.

219
00:14:59.798 --> 00:15:05.743
Is it that there is much more investment coming around the pike, down the pike on data centers?

220
00:15:05.903 --> 00:15:09.186
Is it that the rest of the world hasn't even started to invest?

221
00:15:09.627 --> 00:15:11.428
Is it the bullish case that we don't get?

222
00:15:11.548 --> 00:15:12.829
Is it the bearish case?

223
00:15:13.230 --> 00:15:13.550
Tell me.

224
00:15:15.032 --> 00:15:20.335
I think the Buller's case is really the application of AI, right?

225
00:15:20.495 --> 00:15:23.557
And what that, how big that could be.

226
00:15:23.677 --> 00:15:29.700
So for example, I think one of the things we saw this year was the talk about agentic AI, right?

227
00:15:29.720 --> 00:15:34.663
You know, that's, that wasn't even in discussion up until the beginning of this year.

228
00:15:35.044 --> 00:15:39.786
And we're just hitting the surface of what agentic AI means, what we could do with agentic AI.

229
00:15:40.106 --> 00:15:41.067
So that's driving.

230
00:15:41.667 --> 00:15:44.049
another part of the compute demand on CPUs, right?

231
00:15:44.069 --> 00:15:51.313
So I think this is the part that it's hard to know is because the applications of it continue to change and continue to adapt.

232
00:15:51.353 --> 00:15:59.977
And I think that's where perhaps the more cautious view is because we don't see what the next application layer is going to look like.

233
00:15:59.997 --> 00:16:06.641
Is there something when Frank Lee goes to bed at night and anything that worries you, keeps you up at night, anything that could go wrong?

234
00:16:07.201 --> 00:16:17.455
I think, well, it's very interesting because we did a tech tour recently in the Bay Area, and you go there, and it's like not a care in the world.

235
00:16:17.535 --> 00:16:20.219
These guys are super confident.

236
00:16:20.419 --> 00:16:20.980
They think 2027...

237
00:16:22.570 --> 00:16:24.511
There's no cloud, demand's gonna be great.

238
00:16:24.811 --> 00:16:26.311
But Wall Street doesn't feel that way, right?

239
00:16:26.392 --> 00:16:29.833
Wall Street has a different perception because they think there will be a slowdown.

240
00:16:29.853 --> 00:16:32.934
So there's this constant debate between the two sides.

241
00:16:34.395 --> 00:16:36.495
We could talk for hours on AI.

242
00:16:36.816 --> 00:16:42.138
We're gonna grill you a bit more maybe later, but I wanna turn to you, Chin, who's our expert on

243
00:16:42.938 --> 00:16:45.860
With China technology, but particularly automotive technology.

244
00:16:45.880 --> 00:16:48.321
But I have one question I want to start off with.

245
00:16:48.741 --> 00:16:54.044
When, when finally can I drive in Hong Kong, be driven around in an autonomous vehicle?

246
00:16:54.424 --> 00:16:55.345
When is it going to happen?

247
00:16:55.365 --> 00:16:56.445
Because we promised that.

248
00:16:56.766 --> 00:16:58.066
It was promised to me years ago.

249
00:16:58.106 --> 00:16:59.147
It still hasn't arrived.

250
00:16:59.287 --> 00:17:02.469
Yeah, I remember this question last year when we did the session.

251
00:17:02.789 --> 00:17:05.330
Again, it's a geofence situation.

252
00:17:05.690 --> 00:17:09.172
So you specifically defined in Hong Kong, so it's up for the Hong Kong government.

253
00:17:09.493 --> 00:17:11.914
I would say the technology is now viable.

254
00:17:12.054 --> 00:17:21.359
So Heron and I have been discussing the trip, like we want to take our time to drive a car, to drive it from Shenzhen to Beijing, and then see how much of the disengagement.

255
00:17:21.659 --> 00:17:28.763
I think the major obstacles preventing us from doing the trip is we don't have time, we haven't synced the schedule.

256
00:17:29.163 --> 00:17:33.544
It's like no doubt on the commercial, the technology and the product.

257
00:17:34.824 --> 00:17:35.264
That's right.

258
00:17:36.044 --> 00:17:41.065
So China has done remarkably good on the EV side, right?

259
00:17:41.926 --> 00:17:44.246
How much is that mirrored on the tech hardware side?

260
00:17:44.266 --> 00:17:48.067
We just talked about what happens in the US.

261
00:17:48.587 --> 00:17:53.768
Is we seeing something very similar on the tech hardware side or is that a completely different sort of story?

262
00:17:54.648 --> 00:17:57.010
The tech hardware, broadly speaking, right?

263
00:17:57.030 --> 00:18:03.015
So basically, we talked about 1.5 trillion capex spending in the US.

264
00:18:03.315 --> 00:18:06.578
So basically, that's gonna benefit China hardware supply chain.

265
00:18:06.978 --> 00:18:15.145
So basically, Agentic AI, more tokens, more capex from the US CSPs, meaning they're gonna build more data center.

266
00:18:15.385 --> 00:18:21.890
They're gonna procure more servers, and they need a faster connection, they need a higher bandwidth,

267
00:18:22.190 --> 00:18:24.512
They need more reliable power delivery.

268
00:18:24.812 --> 00:18:27.134
So these are the components China has been doing.

269
00:18:27.474 --> 00:18:34.961
So the optics, these tech items, yeah, these bomb items are basically benefiting the China supply chain.

270
00:18:35.001 --> 00:18:37.663
So we've seen the huge rally.

271
00:18:37.843 --> 00:18:39.064
Can I just ask you actually on that?

272
00:18:39.084 --> 00:18:40.925
And maybe also a Frank.

273
00:18:41.266 --> 00:18:45.329
We're talking about the US investing in data centers and we're providing all the components.

274
00:18:45.369 --> 00:18:47.090
China is, Korea is, et cetera.

275
00:18:47.591 --> 00:18:48.852
Why not China itself?

276
00:18:48.992 --> 00:18:53.254
Why are these data centers not built at a grander scale in China as well?

277
00:18:53.274 --> 00:18:56.915
Wouldn't China, is China falling behind in the data center race?

278
00:18:56.995 --> 00:18:57.695
Why not China?

279
00:18:57.995 --> 00:18:59.156
I'm glad you asked.

280
00:18:59.176 --> 00:19:00.696
Yeah, I'm glad you asked.

281
00:19:00.817 --> 00:19:05.458
So let's say, if you look at the end game, let's say, the large language model.

282
00:19:05.758 --> 00:19:06.959
So China, US, similar?

283
00:19:07.479 --> 00:19:12.982
But if you compare the CapEx spending, US is seven to eight times versus what China spent.

284
00:19:13.442 --> 00:19:20.686
So I think there is a fundamental difference between China and the US because they optimize for different objective function.

285
00:19:21.027 --> 00:19:24.088
US more like optimize on the frontier.

286
00:19:24.508 --> 00:19:33.133
So China is more like optimize the system efficiency under constraint because the China- Sorry, what do you mean?

287
00:19:33.213 --> 00:19:34.234
A system under constraint?

288
00:19:34.654 --> 00:19:36.255
Yes, system-on-constrained.

289
00:19:36.475 --> 00:19:44.058
China CSP, Better Dance, Alibaba, they wanted to procure the most advanced Nvidia chips, but they couldn't because of the export control.

290
00:19:44.658 --> 00:19:52.401
And the China semi-industry is constrained to purchase the most advanced equipment, say, EUV.

291
00:19:52.901 --> 00:20:00.344
So this is the system has to live under constraint, but that does not stop the system to evolve, to update.

292
00:20:00.824 --> 00:20:02.545
But the objective function is different.

293
00:20:03.525 --> 00:20:06.288
We can't do this, we can't do that, but we need to deliver the results.

294
00:20:06.568 --> 00:20:11.692
So when we talk to the China tech guys, they're mostly talking about the system efficiency.

295
00:20:11.992 --> 00:20:23.021
So if we don't have a strong hardware, maybe we do more in terms of the software efficiency so that my end product, let's say, when we use the Chinese AI, it's still very good and advanced.

296
00:20:23.241 --> 00:20:28.745
So I would like to stress this fundamental difference, even though the money span has been very different.

297
00:20:28.946 --> 00:20:31.948
But if you look at the results, it's actually quite similar.

298
00:20:32.570 --> 00:20:34.030
Frank, do you have a view on this?

299
00:20:34.911 --> 00:20:36.971
I think you're talking, again, like two different markets.

300
00:20:38.332 --> 00:20:47.395
I think people like to talk about China and the US, but there's only one area in the tech hardware where there's a huge overlap, and that's on the optical side.

301
00:20:48.475 --> 00:20:56.498
You know, if you look at people talk about Chinese developing their own CPUs and GPUs, it will be for the China market, but it won't really be applicable to the US.

302
00:20:56.898 --> 00:20:59.919
But what you are seeing, and I think the question is,

303
00:21:00.959 --> 00:21:06.365
is there going to be even greater diversification moving away?

304
00:21:06.465 --> 00:21:13.152
Because on the optical side, now the U.S. government has realized that China is 70% of the overall market.

305
00:21:13.613 --> 00:21:19.519
So I think they're now looking at, over time, we find a way to reduce the dependency on China.

306
00:21:20.681 --> 00:21:22.943
So we have a new technology.

307
00:21:23.543 --> 00:21:27.707
It's had massive macroeconomic consequences.

308
00:21:28.127 --> 00:21:30.629
Bond yields currencies have moved on that.

309
00:21:31.010 --> 00:21:37.695
We're still in a world whereby we're not quite sure how much demand will there be, but the investments are pretty significant.

310
00:21:38.156 --> 00:21:43.921
Now we're seeing that the market over the last couple of weeks, while I was on holiday, have started to...

311
00:21:44.461 --> 00:21:46.161
get seriously worried about this.

312
00:21:46.662 --> 00:21:50.542
But the story that I get here is that that's not really being played out yet.

313
00:21:51.083 --> 00:21:56.844
It might work out that actually there is demand and that thinks we're gonna see a lot of volatility in this story.

314
00:21:57.104 --> 00:22:01.125
So are you saying you're coming away bullish from this conversation, Harold?

315
00:22:01.145 --> 00:22:04.146
Because as an equity strategist, that really surprises me.

316
00:22:04.286 --> 00:22:04.426
Yes.

317
00:22:04.486 --> 00:22:05.666
You're turning bullish.

318
00:22:05.926 --> 00:22:14.611
Yeah, you're always joking that we're positive, but I'd like to highlight that if you do invest in equities, you would have actually done pretty well over the last one or two decades.

319
00:22:15.011 --> 00:22:16.512
It pays to be an optimist, Fred.

320
00:22:17.033 --> 00:22:18.333
It does, yeah.

321
00:22:18.533 --> 00:22:20.715
No, but I think this was a fantastic conversation.

322
00:22:21.455 --> 00:22:23.636
Thank you very much for all of your contributions.

323
00:22:23.957 --> 00:22:34.863
And thank you very much for joining us here for our live video recording of Under the Banyan Tree, where we put Asian markets and economics in context.

324
00:22:35.503 --> 00:22:38.586
and we want you to not miss an episode.

325
00:22:38.767 --> 00:22:45.533
Therefore, you have to like and subscribe wherever you get your podcast to under the Ben interview.

326
00:22:45.553 --> 00:22:45.913
Is that right?

327
00:22:46.334 --> 00:22:47.455
That is absolutely correct.

328
00:22:47.475 --> 00:22:49.577
You remember that very well, that sentence.

329
00:22:50.057 --> 00:22:50.458
That's right.

330
00:22:50.678 --> 00:22:51.859
Thank you very much for joining us.
