WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.091 --> 00:00:08.780
Hello internet, this is your captain speaking Lester Nare joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD Krishna Chowdhury.

2
00:00:09.220 --> 00:00:10.522
My friend, how are you?

3
00:00:10.782 --> 00:00:11.403
Pretty good.

4
00:00:11.743 --> 00:00:14.586
You have any exciting Thanksgiving plans for the week?

5
00:00:14.606 --> 00:00:16.628
Yeah, I'm actually I'm gonna go to Maui.

6
00:00:17.828 --> 00:00:44.519
with um my parents it's gonna be great yeah awesome yeah hopefully i'm gonna get to see the the daniel k anyway telescope i was actually gonna ask if you're gonna make a trip out to yeah yeah we're definitely gonna make a trip out i don't know if the telescope is operating but um you know it'd be nice to see whatever i can absolutely absolutely and it's uh an interesting dovetail at least on the observatory piece for yeah the story we're gonna spend a lot of time

7
00:00:45.980 --> 00:00:47.621
We're going to talk about 3i Atlas.

8
00:00:47.721 --> 00:00:49.141
We now have the observations.

9
00:00:49.701 --> 00:00:51.021
We've had time to put it together.

10
00:00:51.042 --> 00:00:53.462
We did touch on this once before.

11
00:00:53.542 --> 00:00:53.822
Yes.

12
00:00:54.042 --> 00:00:59.044
So we're doing a little bit of an update based on all the latest and greatest.

13
00:00:59.364 --> 00:01:00.424
It's been in high demand.

14
00:01:00.764 --> 00:01:02.485
We're going to start off with 3i Atlas today.

15
00:01:03.105 --> 00:01:07.490
Followed up by a new story that's going to be out of Maynooth University in Ireland.

16
00:01:07.650 --> 00:01:14.136
It was in forensic chemistry around a new technique for taking fingerprints off of fired bullet casings.

17
00:01:14.657 --> 00:01:19.221
So this is a new forensic technique that will help us catch the bad guys even better.

18
00:01:19.962 --> 00:01:28.425
ending with a new Alzheimer's sort of discovery around microglia or the immune cells that are in our brain.

19
00:01:28.885 --> 00:01:31.726
This is a combination of a couple of universities in nature.

20
00:01:31.846 --> 00:01:38.168
Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, Max Planck Institute of Biology and Aging, and the University of Cologne.

21
00:01:38.188 --> 00:01:40.108
So three incredible stories.

22
00:01:40.128 --> 00:01:42.389
We're going to touch on all the details.

23
00:01:42.889 --> 00:01:45.390
This is from First Principles.

24
00:02:01.162 --> 00:02:04.703
So our first story of the day is three eye Atlas.

25
00:02:04.723 --> 00:02:05.403
Yes.

26
00:02:05.483 --> 00:02:10.805
This is the one that obviously everyone keeps asking us about because the government is back open.

27
00:02:10.965 --> 00:02:11.505
Yeah.

28
00:02:11.885 --> 00:02:15.627
And so NASA has now released new imagery.

29
00:02:15.927 --> 00:02:16.487
Yes.

30
00:02:16.587 --> 00:02:20.088
So let's sort of just start right from the top here.

31
00:02:20.268 --> 00:02:25.390
Yeah, I mean, it's an interstellar visitor, as we all know.

32
00:02:25.711 --> 00:02:27.551
It's the third interstellar object.

33
00:02:27.912 --> 00:02:30.353
There's been two predecessors that it's had.

34
00:02:31.093 --> 00:02:33.394
The first one was Oumuamua.

35
00:02:33.794 --> 00:02:35.575
The second one was Tuai Borisov.

36
00:02:35.595 --> 00:02:38.917
And this is the third and the largest one that we have by far.

37
00:02:38.937 --> 00:02:39.237
Okay.

38
00:02:39.257 --> 00:02:39.357
Okay.

39
00:02:39.677 --> 00:02:39.977
Okay.

40
00:02:40.638 --> 00:02:44.219
Oumuamua was a really strange words.

41
00:02:44.459 --> 00:02:48.861
It was an inert, highly elongated object that was flying through.

42
00:02:49.182 --> 00:02:55.144
Then we had 2i Borisov, which was basically just like a normal comet, like any other comet that we'd seen.

43
00:02:55.164 --> 00:03:00.807
The only thing that was really different was that it was moving so fast that it wasn't trapped by the sun's gravity, right?

44
00:03:01.047 --> 00:03:04.009
And then now we've got finally this guy, 3i Atlas.

45
00:03:04.029 --> 00:03:06.070
The I stands for interstellar.

46
00:03:06.870 --> 00:03:08.971
The three stands for the fact that it's the third.

47
00:03:09.512 --> 00:03:17.217
And the Atlas stands for the fact that it was discovered by the Atlas system, which is the Asteroid Terrestrial Impact Last Alert System.

48
00:03:18.057 --> 00:03:20.659
These are a bunch of telescopes all over the world.

49
00:03:21.279 --> 00:03:23.621
The one that actually discovered this was in Chile.

50
00:03:24.727 --> 00:03:33.249
And the whole point of this telescope system is to find near-Earth objects or objects that are coming through and going to be a little bit close.

51
00:03:33.409 --> 00:03:33.589
Right.

52
00:03:33.669 --> 00:03:34.750
Right, in our solar system.

53
00:03:34.870 --> 00:03:35.450
Right.

54
00:03:36.010 --> 00:03:39.551
It preferentially looks in the plane of the planets.

55
00:03:40.031 --> 00:03:40.371
Okay.

56
00:03:40.431 --> 00:03:40.651
Right?

57
00:03:41.231 --> 00:03:41.531
So...

58
00:03:41.972 --> 00:03:42.372
Meaning?

59
00:03:42.672 --> 00:03:49.193
Meaning, so if the sun is here, all of the planets revolve around the sun in the same sort of plate.

60
00:03:49.734 --> 00:03:50.014
Got it.

61
00:03:50.094 --> 00:03:50.674
It's not like...

62
00:03:51.234 --> 00:04:17.663
the big bang atom okay from the from the show where it's like you know there's one going this way there's another going the other way they're all sort of along the same plane makes sense right yes and that's because when the solar system first formed there was some some angular momentum of that cloud so when it collapsed you know everything has to be on that plane to preserve the angular momentum makes sense um so that's actually why we discovered this thing and one of

63
00:04:19.763 --> 00:04:22.926
sort of taking a tour of the planetary systems, right?

64
00:04:22.966 --> 00:04:28.252
It's kind of by design that Atlas finds objects that are along this plane, right?

65
00:04:28.912 --> 00:04:34.238
So it begs the question, there might be other objects that are not in the plane that we're not really sensitive to.

66
00:04:34.398 --> 00:04:34.578
Right.

67
00:04:34.618 --> 00:04:38.002
But perhaps with the new Vera Rubin telescopes and things like that, we will be.

68
00:04:38.662 --> 00:04:38.842
But...

69
00:04:39.702 --> 00:04:41.803
In any case, that's how it got its name, right?

70
00:04:42.303 --> 00:04:43.644
It's inbound.

71
00:04:43.784 --> 00:04:46.085
It's got an extremely hyperbolic orbit.

72
00:04:46.825 --> 00:04:50.547
So an eccentricity of approximately 6.2.

73
00:04:51.487 --> 00:04:52.968
The Earth is basically at a one.

74
00:04:53.008 --> 00:04:54.588
It looks like a circle, right?

75
00:04:54.948 --> 00:04:57.430
But this thing is extremely hyperbolic.

76
00:04:57.790 --> 00:05:02.672
You can see that it's going so fast, 58 kilometers per second, that it barely...

77
00:05:03.492 --> 00:05:20.691
even changes its orbit as it as it passes the sun right right unlike the uh you know the wicked um movie there's that one of my favorite songs is like uh like a comet pulled from orbit as it passes the sun this is not doing that yeah it is not changed

78
00:05:21.692 --> 00:05:25.354
In any real sense, for the better or the worse.

79
00:05:25.775 --> 00:05:28.396
But 58 kilometers per second, right?

80
00:05:28.897 --> 00:05:35.341
That's a velocity that's three times higher than what's expected for a usual star encounter.

81
00:05:35.441 --> 00:05:38.262
So this thing's moving extremely, extremely quickly.

82
00:05:38.322 --> 00:05:40.684
Yeah, and it begs the question, like, what even gave it?

83
00:05:41.264 --> 00:05:43.007
its speed to begin with.

84
00:05:43.027 --> 00:05:43.869
How do they reach that?

85
00:05:43.969 --> 00:05:47.936
Yeah, how does something move that fast through the solar system?

86
00:05:48.457 --> 00:05:51.422
And the orientation is it's also retrograde.

87
00:05:51.742 --> 00:05:52.764
The other weird thing is...

88
00:05:54.092 --> 00:05:58.414
You know, in the Milky Way, the sun is moving around the Milky Way, right?

89
00:05:58.494 --> 00:05:58.714
Yeah.

90
00:05:58.974 --> 00:06:05.216
And the plane of the planets is about perpendicular to the motion.

91
00:06:05.536 --> 00:06:13.419
So our entire sort of solar system is moving through the Milky Way galaxy, like let's say on the X axis.

92
00:06:13.879 --> 00:06:17.941
But then the orbit of the planets in that context while we're doing that is on the Y axis.

93
00:06:17.981 --> 00:06:19.981
Yeah, it is in this Y direction.

94
00:06:20.041 --> 00:06:20.502
And so...

95
00:06:22.583 --> 00:06:32.130
When 3i Atlas, when we say that it's taking a tour of the solar system, what it's really doing is it's like going piercing through the Milky Way in some sense, right?

96
00:06:32.350 --> 00:06:33.171
It's not moving.

97
00:06:33.691 --> 00:06:41.797
I mean, obviously, it has some direction along the Milky Way's rotation as well, but it's going through the plate of the Milky Way as well.

98
00:06:41.937 --> 00:06:46.120
That's why it's going through all the planets in the plane of our ecliptic.

99
00:06:46.180 --> 00:06:49.963
Which is sort of a cosmic...

100
00:06:51.063 --> 00:07:08.754
the cosmic serendipity there is yeah is is yeah it's it's kind of a mystery where it came from and things like that and we're going to get into some of that later so um there's been some milestones that have happened since the last time we talked um it flew by mars on october 3rd 2025 that was when it got the

101
00:07:09.034 --> 00:07:29.987
as close as it possibly could and that was a really cool way of providing a local observation right because we have the mars reconnaissance orbiter around mars the esa the european space agency has a bunch of stuff around there and it's about 28 million kilometers away from these guys so you can get some at least some close-ups

102
00:07:30.367 --> 00:07:32.089
You know, it's still far away.

103
00:07:32.149 --> 00:07:33.610
28 million kilometers.

104
00:07:33.630 --> 00:07:34.471
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

105
00:07:34.551 --> 00:07:36.172
It's like, it's close enough, right?

106
00:07:36.252 --> 00:07:37.093
Yep.

107
00:07:37.393 --> 00:07:47.742
And then on October 30th, 29th, it had its closest approach to the sun, which was at a distance of 1.36 astronomical units.

108
00:07:48.322 --> 00:07:50.384
One astronomical unit is the orbit of the Earth.

109
00:07:50.844 --> 00:07:53.507
So it didn't even get closer than Earth is to the sun.

110
00:07:53.667 --> 00:07:53.947
Got it.

111
00:07:54.027 --> 00:07:54.267
Okay.

112
00:07:54.808 --> 00:07:56.009
A lot of comets...

113
00:07:56.449 --> 00:08:02.797
You know, the really bright ones get within Earth's orbit, sometimes even like as close as Mercury.

114
00:08:02.937 --> 00:08:03.117
Right.

115
00:08:03.257 --> 00:08:03.478
Right.

116
00:08:03.718 --> 00:08:05.861
As close as like between Venus and Mercury.

117
00:08:06.121 --> 00:08:09.125
And those are the ones that glow and you can see with your naked eye.

118
00:08:10.286 --> 00:08:11.368
This one, not so much.

119
00:08:11.428 --> 00:08:11.628
Right.

120
00:08:12.169 --> 00:08:13.670
It wasn't that it wasn't that close.

121
00:08:14.211 --> 00:08:20.536
And then finally, in December 19th, it's going to be well outside the Earth's orbit, but that's when it's actually going to be the closest to Earth.

122
00:08:20.636 --> 00:08:25.719
It's going to be 80% of the distance between Earth and the sun, but it's going to be in the other side.

123
00:08:25.739 --> 00:08:25.819
Yep.

124
00:08:25.999 --> 00:08:26.400
Right?

125
00:08:26.420 --> 00:08:27.681
So the sun will be in front of us.

126
00:08:28.041 --> 00:08:30.783
The comet will be kind of behind us.

127
00:08:31.223 --> 00:08:32.404
But that's when it's going to get closer.

128
00:08:32.424 --> 00:08:32.844
Okay.

129
00:08:33.064 --> 00:08:33.305
So...

130
00:08:34.123 --> 00:08:36.867
I told you that it's got a really weird orbit, right?

131
00:08:37.348 --> 00:08:42.295
It's coming through really fast, and it's going along the plane of the planets.

132
00:08:42.575 --> 00:08:50.065
It's unclear whether it's coming from a part of our Milky Way called the Thin Disc, which is really what you see when...

133
00:08:50.546 --> 00:08:53.530
you look out in the night sky and you see the Milky Way or from the thick disc.

134
00:08:53.830 --> 00:09:03.221
Because if you trace back the yellow trajectory here shows where the, the comet is and the red trajectory is where we are, where the sun is.

135
00:09:03.541 --> 00:09:08.146
And it's sort of like playing tag and go with our son because it's,

136
00:09:09.127 --> 00:09:12.068
About the same distance away from the center of the Milky Way as we are.

137
00:09:12.088 --> 00:09:12.408
Interesting.

138
00:09:12.469 --> 00:09:14.329
And so it's going to be kind of sharing our orbit.

139
00:09:14.369 --> 00:09:14.489
Yeah.

140
00:09:14.529 --> 00:09:21.112
The same way that, you know, you can imagine the Trojan asteroids outside of Jupiter.

141
00:09:21.492 --> 00:09:24.454
They share the same orbit with Jupiter and they move around with Jupiter.

142
00:09:24.474 --> 00:09:28.235
The James Webb telescope is orbiting the sun with the Earth, right?

143
00:09:28.275 --> 00:09:33.077
Because it's feeling the same gravitational pull from the sun that the Earth is and the moon is.

144
00:09:34.218 --> 00:09:34.498
So...

145
00:09:35.455 --> 00:09:37.137
The question is, where did it come from?

146
00:09:37.698 --> 00:09:42.703
The idea is, as we are traveling through the Milky Way, we're going on a particular orbit.

147
00:09:42.823 --> 00:09:50.992
And the way that 3A atlas moves through the Milky Way is in that similar circular orbit.

148
00:09:51.373 --> 00:09:52.414
Exactly.

149
00:09:52.694 --> 00:09:54.216
The radius of that orbit is...

150
00:09:54.516 --> 00:09:54.756
Yeah.

151
00:09:54.796 --> 00:09:55.436
Almost identical.

152
00:09:55.476 --> 00:09:56.697
It's almost identical, right?

153
00:09:56.777 --> 00:09:58.218
I mean, hence it's right here.

154
00:09:58.378 --> 00:09:58.558
Right.

155
00:09:58.678 --> 00:10:03.920
And the Milky Way just has a gravitational potential because of all the stars and gas in it.

156
00:10:04.220 --> 00:10:04.360
Yep.

157
00:10:04.500 --> 00:10:08.042
And the sun is feeling the same gravitational potential that the comet is.

158
00:10:08.142 --> 00:10:08.322
Yep.

159
00:10:10.037 --> 00:10:15.580
And because of Newton's law of gravitation, the acceleration that we feel is independent of our mass.

160
00:10:15.600 --> 00:10:26.385
So even though the comet, 3A Atlas, is really, really small compared to the sun, all objects fall at the same rate, according to Galileo, right?

161
00:10:26.485 --> 00:10:26.706
Yeah.

162
00:10:28.266 --> 00:10:33.710
In terms of the orbit, it's not really going to matter if it's the sun or a star, right?

163
00:10:33.810 --> 00:10:35.311
Yep, that's a good distinction.

164
00:10:35.371 --> 00:10:35.951
That's the point.

165
00:10:36.411 --> 00:10:40.614
That's why the James Webb Telescope is moving around the sun the same way that we are.

166
00:10:40.754 --> 00:10:43.276
Right, even though it's obviously smaller than the Earth.

167
00:10:43.336 --> 00:10:43.516
Right.

168
00:10:43.936 --> 00:10:44.256
So...

169
00:10:45.617 --> 00:10:50.424
The first paper that tried to answer this was from Oxford in the Astrophysical Journal, Letters.

170
00:10:50.705 --> 00:10:54.510
This was in July, and they said that it's from the thick disk.

171
00:10:54.771 --> 00:11:00.880
The thick disk is the part of the Milky Way that's just above all of the stars and the real gas space.

172
00:11:02.001 --> 00:11:07.024
So the stuff that we see in the night sky when we look up, that's the thin disk.

173
00:11:07.104 --> 00:11:09.265
The thick disk is the part that's right above or below.

174
00:11:09.685 --> 00:11:11.406
That's an old population of stars.

175
00:11:11.446 --> 00:11:15.168
We know that because we can look at the spectral signatures of the stars that are above there.

176
00:11:16.069 --> 00:11:24.873
And there are these very red, long-lasting stars with lots of metal, which means they've been doing fusion for a while.

177
00:11:24.893 --> 00:11:27.595
Actually, I don't know.

178
00:11:28.455 --> 00:11:29.336
It depends, actually.

179
00:11:29.396 --> 00:11:31.698
But it depends on whether it's high metal or low metal.

180
00:11:32.058 --> 00:11:40.866
High metal could also mean that you're the second or third generation of stars that are coming from the ashes of the older stars that have made the metal.

181
00:11:41.266 --> 00:11:45.269
And then low metallicity could mean that, okay, you just have hydrogen and helium.

182
00:11:45.390 --> 00:11:46.771
So it's like from the Big Bang.

183
00:11:46.791 --> 00:11:48.112
You've got nothing else.

184
00:11:48.352 --> 00:11:51.215
You know, but so there's ways of quantifying it.

185
00:11:51.255 --> 00:11:55.999
But in any case, they've quantified that a lot of these stars are between seven to 14 billion years old.

186
00:11:56.300 --> 00:11:56.500
Right.

187
00:11:56.520 --> 00:12:00.664
So it's it's much older than the sun, which is about five billion years old.

188
00:12:00.884 --> 00:12:01.084
Right.

189
00:12:01.305 --> 00:12:01.465
Right.

190
00:12:02.285 --> 00:12:03.727
So that was the first one.

191
00:12:03.987 --> 00:12:06.429
Then there's some new work that came out in September.

192
00:12:07.170 --> 00:12:09.833
This is not in a journal, but it's it's on the archive.

193
00:12:10.413 --> 00:12:10.573
And.

194
00:12:11.314 --> 00:12:16.043
It was from the Tenerife Observatory, a bunch of people there in Spain.

195
00:12:16.784 --> 00:12:20.691
They were trying to trace back the object's origins in a similar way.

196
00:12:22.650 --> 00:12:39.418
And they showed that they used this Python package called Milky Way Potential 2022, which basically what it can do is it can take your object and then run back the clock for however long that you want, given the Milky Way potential.

197
00:12:39.978 --> 00:12:46.121
And what they found was that if you integrate over the millions of stars in that database and you go back...

198
00:12:47.127 --> 00:12:56.191
At least in the last 10 million years, there's no close encounter that's going to cause this giant velocity.

199
00:12:56.852 --> 00:12:57.152
Okay?

200
00:12:57.452 --> 00:12:57.672
Okay.

201
00:12:57.732 --> 00:13:03.155
If you go through all of the—and those are the stars that it had close encounters with.

202
00:13:03.255 --> 00:13:03.415
Yep.

203
00:13:04.771 --> 00:13:08.874
And none of them were close enough to really add any velocity to this thing.

204
00:13:09.594 --> 00:13:18.740
The point being, Three-Eye Atlas had to get its acceleration from an encounter with some celestial object at some point in its history.

205
00:13:18.860 --> 00:13:19.520
Yeah.

206
00:13:20.161 --> 00:13:21.622
But it can't be the recent history.

207
00:13:21.742 --> 00:13:22.982
But it can't be the recent history.

208
00:13:23.002 --> 00:13:23.163
Yeah.

209
00:13:23.423 --> 00:13:23.723
Okay.

210
00:13:24.123 --> 00:13:28.546
And then when we look in this Milky Way potential 2022…

211
00:13:30.447 --> 00:13:40.392
and trace back the journey that it had made and the stars that it would have passed, these celestial objects would have passed on the way, none of those are of sufficient mass and size.

212
00:13:40.432 --> 00:13:41.872
Yeah, and it wasn't close enough.

213
00:13:41.892 --> 00:13:45.274
It wasn't enough to generate the acceleration that we're seeing.

214
00:13:45.294 --> 00:13:46.274
That's what the paper is trying to say.

215
00:13:46.294 --> 00:13:47.695
That's what the paper is trying to say, right.

216
00:13:48.035 --> 00:13:51.197
So then they say, okay, what we can do is we can really just...

217
00:13:52.145 --> 00:13:53.426
run back the clock, right?

218
00:13:53.786 --> 00:14:04.952
And we can say, okay, if it's not in our recent history, let's just treat the Milky Way as this potential landscape and ask, how far does it deviate away from the thin disk, right?

219
00:14:05.252 --> 00:14:13.257
Because what it could do, what the original paper was saying was that because it's got such a high velocity perpendicular to the disk,

220
00:14:13.837 --> 00:14:15.038
It must be coming from up there.

221
00:14:15.278 --> 00:14:15.478
Yeah.

222
00:14:15.639 --> 00:14:15.819
Right?

223
00:14:16.059 --> 00:14:20.963
But the potential landscape is such that when it goes above the disk, the disk is going to start pulling back.

224
00:14:21.343 --> 00:14:23.065
And so there's going to be some oscillation

225
00:14:24.473 --> 00:14:25.474
Through the disk, right?

226
00:14:25.514 --> 00:14:28.516
It's going to go up, and then it's going to come back down, and it's going to go down.

227
00:14:28.877 --> 00:14:30.418
Then it's going to get pulled back up again.

228
00:14:30.458 --> 00:14:30.658
Yes.

229
00:14:30.798 --> 00:14:30.999
Right?

230
00:14:31.079 --> 00:14:32.760
So how big is that amplitude?

231
00:14:32.920 --> 00:14:33.080
Right.

232
00:14:33.100 --> 00:14:33.521
Yeah, yeah.

233
00:14:33.561 --> 00:14:34.442
Of that oscillation?

234
00:14:34.702 --> 00:14:40.167
Basically, how high, how far above and below the thin disk is it sort of?

235
00:14:40.267 --> 00:14:41.067
Is it going, right?

236
00:14:41.147 --> 00:14:42.709
Is it going all the way to the thick disk?

237
00:14:42.989 --> 00:14:47.193
Because we also have velocity profiles of the stars that are up there.

238
00:14:47.413 --> 00:14:48.394
There's some typical...

239
00:14:48.914 --> 00:15:10.373
trajectories that those guys take and there's some typical trajectories that the thin disc takes which one does this thing belong to got it right and so that's what they did and what they think is happening is that it stayed basically within the thin disc and they're ruling out the fact that it could be in that upper thick disc okay they found where the

240
00:15:11.192 --> 00:15:17.854
The velocity profile of this comet is compared to the stars in these two regions, and it's more aligned with the thin disk.

241
00:15:18.034 --> 00:15:18.494
Interesting.

242
00:15:18.514 --> 00:15:18.635
Right?

243
00:15:18.655 --> 00:15:22.236
So this is kind of a clapback to the Oxford paper.

244
00:15:22.456 --> 00:15:23.376
Which was that original one.

245
00:15:23.396 --> 00:15:24.497
Which was that original one.

246
00:15:24.857 --> 00:15:28.738
So we're going to have to see if Oxford comes back and says, nah.

247
00:15:29.398 --> 00:15:33.682
This is good because when we first covered this, the Oxford paper was the only one.

248
00:15:33.702 --> 00:15:34.342
It was the only one.

249
00:15:34.382 --> 00:15:35.964
And everyone was like, okay, that's got to be it.

250
00:15:36.244 --> 00:15:39.226
But the process of science is extremely dynamic.

251
00:15:39.487 --> 00:15:42.209
There's a bunch of researchers vying for the spotlight.

252
00:15:42.329 --> 00:15:42.549
Right.

253
00:15:42.749 --> 00:15:45.652
So someone's going to say this.

254
00:15:45.672 --> 00:15:46.833
The other person's going to say that.

255
00:15:46.853 --> 00:15:47.313
Right.

256
00:15:47.793 --> 00:15:48.654
This is very good.

257
00:15:48.754 --> 00:16:02.299
So we now we now are in a position in terms of the locational origin of the RIA Atlas, which initially was believed to be coming from above where we are on the thin disk in the thick disk.

258
00:16:02.640 --> 00:16:05.101
But there's at least now a rebuttal.

259
00:16:05.221 --> 00:16:05.501
Yes.

260
00:16:05.761 --> 00:16:09.823
There's at least now a rebuttal to that that can explain away the thickness.

261
00:16:09.843 --> 00:16:09.943
Yeah.

262
00:16:10.923 --> 00:16:37.559
origin hypothesis yeah yeah exactly and now it calls into question um whether it is as old as they say they are because it used to be we were really excited right this is going to be the oldest thing in the solar system right it's going to be older than seven billion years old because all of the stars that are up there are super old and if it came from there then it's got to be super old too now well if it's just one of these thin disk populations that just got bumped maybe a bunch a long long time ago right mm-hmm

263
00:16:38.559 --> 00:16:40.259
It's no longer maybe that old.

264
00:16:40.459 --> 00:16:40.660
Right.

265
00:16:40.780 --> 00:16:42.580
Maybe it is quite contemporary.

266
00:16:42.880 --> 00:16:49.461
So there's a bunch of, you know, very cool science that is still happening, trying to figure this out.

267
00:16:49.501 --> 00:16:52.322
Trying to trace back its location, origin location.

268
00:16:52.642 --> 00:16:53.662
Yeah.

269
00:16:53.942 --> 00:16:55.923
So that's the origin story.

270
00:16:55.963 --> 00:16:56.803
It's still in question.

271
00:16:56.923 --> 00:16:57.123
Yes.

272
00:16:57.403 --> 00:17:01.604
Now let's talk about what it actually is and why it is so interesting.

273
00:17:01.744 --> 00:17:03.325
It is quite a bizarre comet.

274
00:17:03.445 --> 00:17:03.685
Okay.

275
00:17:03.825 --> 00:17:04.085
Okay.

276
00:17:04.105 --> 00:17:05.145
If we're completely honest...

277
00:17:05.565 --> 00:17:09.727
There's a typical comet that we see in our solar system, and this is a pretty bizarre one.

278
00:17:09.867 --> 00:17:11.047
It's not unprecedented.

279
00:17:11.107 --> 00:17:16.049
We have seen comets that do the weird things that this thing is doing, but it's been like one or two.

280
00:17:16.249 --> 00:17:16.489
Got it.

281
00:17:16.509 --> 00:17:16.729
Okay?

282
00:17:16.749 --> 00:17:20.391
So it's rare, but it's not like totally unprecedented.

283
00:17:20.471 --> 00:17:21.071
Unprecedented.

284
00:17:21.091 --> 00:17:21.271
Yep.

285
00:17:21.391 --> 00:17:21.631
Okay?

286
00:17:21.851 --> 00:17:22.351
Yep.

287
00:17:23.572 --> 00:17:24.952
So it's got a nucleus.

288
00:17:24.972 --> 00:17:29.714
The radius is about anywhere between 0.22 kilometers to 2.8 kilometers.

289
00:17:29.754 --> 00:17:30.775
That's how we constrained it.

290
00:17:31.235 --> 00:17:31.595
Okay.

291
00:17:33.155 --> 00:17:35.456
There's a lot of activity on this thing.

292
00:17:36.737 --> 00:17:39.498
It's called a hyperactive comet.

293
00:17:40.019 --> 00:17:54.326
As the comet gets closer and closer to the sun, the solar radiation and the photons from the sun start creating chemical reactions and physical reactions on the comet's surface, and that's going to just make it glow and do all of the cool things that it does.

294
00:17:54.727 --> 00:17:58.449
And a lot of the weird stuff that it does, it's been implied...

295
00:17:59.169 --> 00:18:04.134
That, you know, maybe there's something weird going on, if there's a techno signature, blah, blah, blah.

296
00:18:04.274 --> 00:18:07.357
A lot of this actually came from Avi Loeb at Harvard.

297
00:18:07.377 --> 00:18:21.231
But then in October of this year, he came out with this model, which is a physical model for the Icecoma of 3i Atlas with Avi Loeb and one of his collaborators, Eric Kito.

298
00:18:22.432 --> 00:18:29.037
And this one is trying to suggest how the physics of a comet could produce all of the weird stuff that we're seeing.

299
00:18:29.538 --> 00:18:35.202
Just normal comet, maybe not a normal comet, kind of a weird comet, but just ordinary physics.

300
00:18:35.642 --> 00:18:36.263
Stuff that we know.

301
00:18:36.603 --> 00:18:40.626
Okay, one of the things that it tries to explain is something called the anti-tail.

302
00:18:40.646 --> 00:18:42.167
This was very weird, right?

303
00:18:42.247 --> 00:18:46.771
There was a, if you can see over there, this is from the Hubble Space Telescope.

304
00:18:46.871 --> 00:18:50.534
On the right is where the sun is, and there's some projection.

305
00:18:50.554 --> 00:18:51.435
There's like a jet projection.

306
00:18:52.113 --> 00:18:55.116
From the comet coming out towards the sun.

307
00:18:55.176 --> 00:19:08.749
Which is counterintuitive because the idea would be if the comet is traveling at high velocity towards the sun, you would imagine the quote-unquote jet would be pointing in the opposite direction.

308
00:19:08.809 --> 00:19:09.510
And there is one.

309
00:19:09.530 --> 00:19:09.770
Yes.

310
00:19:09.970 --> 00:19:10.811
Yeah, and there is one.

311
00:19:10.831 --> 00:19:12.111
There is an anti-sun tail.

312
00:19:12.372 --> 00:19:15.053
And because of the way that we're looking, right, it's coming at us.

313
00:19:15.333 --> 00:19:20.096
So the anti-sun tail is kind of behind the comet, and the sun-facing one is towards us.

314
00:19:20.197 --> 00:19:20.617
I get that.

315
00:19:20.637 --> 00:19:24.399
So because of our vantage point, it looks like the sun-facing emission is that much brighter.

316
00:19:24.419 --> 00:19:25.400
But that's not actually true.

317
00:19:25.680 --> 00:19:27.981
But in any case, there is a sun-facing emission, right?

318
00:19:28.001 --> 00:19:28.342
Okay.

319
00:19:28.602 --> 00:19:29.883
And then when it...

320
00:19:30.925 --> 00:19:33.226
went past post-perihelion.

321
00:19:33.586 --> 00:19:35.627
So it went past the sun on the other side.

322
00:19:35.987 --> 00:19:37.588
Now there's no anti-sun tail.

323
00:19:38.108 --> 00:19:40.069
Sorry, now there's no towards the sun tail.

324
00:19:40.289 --> 00:19:41.710
There's only the anti-sun tail.

325
00:19:42.090 --> 00:19:43.031
Okay, so it disappeared.

326
00:19:43.051 --> 00:19:45.171
This is from the Very Large Array.

327
00:19:45.412 --> 00:19:47.893
Sorry, the Very Large Telescope, the VLT in Chile.

328
00:19:48.493 --> 00:19:50.034
So the nucleus has been...

329
00:19:50.894 --> 00:19:53.959
has done this thing where it had jets pointing in both directions.

330
00:19:54.140 --> 00:19:54.300
Yes.

331
00:19:54.420 --> 00:19:57.525
And then on the other side of the sun, it no longer has that.

332
00:19:57.545 --> 00:19:57.705
Yes.

333
00:19:58.066 --> 00:19:58.968
So what's going on?

334
00:19:59.328 --> 00:20:02.734
The model that Keto and Loeb proposed is the following.

335
00:20:03.034 --> 00:20:03.635
So when...

336
00:20:04.854 --> 00:20:09.755
When the comet is coming towards the sun, there's going to be something called sublimation.

337
00:20:09.815 --> 00:20:17.357
Sublimation is what happens with dry ice, where you go directly from a solid form to a gas form.

338
00:20:17.377 --> 00:20:29.741
There's no in-between of liquid because the temperature, the energy is enough to cause the CO2 molecule to just free itself from the gas, not transition through that liquid phase.

339
00:20:30.161 --> 00:20:31.101
Now, when it's happening...

340
00:20:32.098 --> 00:20:41.283
and it's coming towards us, that sublimation is actually going to cause chunks of CO2 to sort of shoot out from the comet.

341
00:20:41.944 --> 00:20:49.928
And if you're far enough away, those chunks of CO2 are going to shoot out, but they're going to follow with the comet because it's the same thing that I said earlier.

342
00:20:50.209 --> 00:20:55.932
They're falling towards the sun the same way the comet is, even though the comet is this giant mountain of stuff.

343
00:20:56.412 --> 00:20:58.053
And let's say a chunk of CO2 is...

344
00:20:59.414 --> 00:21:05.796
you know, centimeters to meters to maybe tens of meters big, that thing is still feeling the sun's gravity.

345
00:21:05.836 --> 00:21:11.138
So it's going to follow in the same sort of path, but maybe a little bit ahead because it got shot towards the sun.

346
00:21:11.178 --> 00:21:11.318
Yep.

347
00:21:11.398 --> 00:21:11.559
Yep.

348
00:21:11.739 --> 00:21:11.979
Got it.

349
00:21:12.219 --> 00:21:12.439
Got it.

350
00:21:12.519 --> 00:21:20.442
And the solar radiation out there far away is not enough to quickly melt these chunks.

351
00:21:21.123 --> 00:21:23.484
Okay, so it's sort of like the comet is here.

352
00:21:23.744 --> 00:21:29.505
You've got these chunks of CO2 ahead, and it's moving along the sun, right?

353
00:21:30.045 --> 00:21:41.128
Now, as it gets close to the sun, there's going to be so much pressure, radiation pressure and ionization pressure, that these chunks, as soon as they get out of the comet, they're just going to immediately evaporate.

354
00:21:41.428 --> 00:21:47.130
And so that's why we're seeing that loss of the front-facing tail.

355
00:21:47.170 --> 00:21:47.370
Mm-hmm.

356
00:21:48.110 --> 00:21:48.330
Right.

357
00:21:48.370 --> 00:21:55.471
Because the closer you get, the shorter the lifespan of the stuff that's getting ejected.

358
00:21:55.891 --> 00:21:58.232
At distance, we're seeing these large chunks break off.

359
00:21:58.712 --> 00:21:58.952
Right.

360
00:21:58.972 --> 00:22:06.593
But they're in such large size and the pressure is not high enough yet that they maintain its structure.

361
00:22:06.633 --> 00:22:06.813
Yeah.

362
00:22:06.833 --> 00:22:07.874
And they just follow along.

363
00:22:08.034 --> 00:22:08.274
Right.

364
00:22:09.134 --> 00:22:14.395
At this slightly, you know, again, because it's basically getting broken off.

365
00:22:15.095 --> 00:22:42.346
from the front side yeah as it's making its way over but as you get so close the heat the the radiation is so high that that the lifespan of that tail that is appearing in front doesn't basically it's not doesn't have a long time to exist before it evaporates into going from that sublimation process from solid to liquid which if i recall correctly was also part of the original walk that we did about where the origins of this could have been where it could have been around a

366
00:22:42.846 --> 00:23:08.080
star that had this accumulation yes exactly things and then then it broke up so there in that first episode it's interesting that same process was discussed well before even this keto low paper came out yeah and that was that was in how it formed and how it formed in the snow line yes in that ice line right where the co2 goes from gas to being able to freeze so there's a there's a bunch of

367
00:23:08.620 --> 00:23:15.283
frozen stuff right at this ice line and maybe the comet formed there, which is why there's so much CO2 compared to water.

368
00:23:15.463 --> 00:23:19.425
And which is basically the opposite process on the formation.

369
00:23:19.445 --> 00:23:21.506
Now we're seeing it on the other side.

370
00:23:21.646 --> 00:23:24.047
If you go back and watch that episode, it does a good job.

371
00:23:24.227 --> 00:23:31.551
We go into detail about the concept of sublimation and that formation process that actually kind of dovetails to what you just talked about quite nicely.

372
00:23:31.831 --> 00:23:33.132
Exactly, yeah.

373
00:23:33.952 --> 00:23:34.852
So that's sort of...

374
00:23:36.710 --> 00:23:38.191
The keto lobe hypothesis.

375
00:23:38.271 --> 00:23:38.472
Right.

376
00:23:38.572 --> 00:23:41.474
For why we're seeing a tail sometimes and not other times.

377
00:23:41.514 --> 00:23:43.095
The sunward extension.

378
00:23:43.276 --> 00:23:44.136
Yeah.

379
00:23:44.337 --> 00:23:45.998
Specifically, the other thing that was weird.

380
00:23:46.098 --> 00:23:46.518
Yeah, yeah.

381
00:23:46.538 --> 00:23:51.042
So I wanted to highlight that paper because I thought that was a quite interesting physical model.

382
00:23:51.202 --> 00:23:51.863
Yep.

383
00:23:52.063 --> 00:23:53.344
That's out of Harvard Astronomy.

384
00:23:53.745 --> 00:23:57.027
So now let's get into some of the observations that have been happening.

385
00:23:57.228 --> 00:23:57.408
Yes.

386
00:23:57.448 --> 00:24:01.251
So the James W. Space Telescope.

387
00:24:03.669 --> 00:24:05.430
Infrared chemical fingerprinting.

388
00:24:06.090 --> 00:24:08.592
So this is in the infrared range.

389
00:24:09.613 --> 00:24:11.313
The Space Telescope took that photo.

390
00:24:12.414 --> 00:24:17.357
The coma is highly dominated by emission that's coming from CO2 and H2O.

391
00:24:17.777 --> 00:24:21.399
And one can see that the mixing ratio between the CO2 and H2O is 7.6%.

392
00:24:23.707 --> 00:24:28.610
Which is way higher than the typical solar system comets, right?

393
00:24:28.630 --> 00:24:31.933
The typical solar system comets are at 0.1 to 0.2.

394
00:24:31.973 --> 00:24:34.234
3-I Atlas is all the way up there.

395
00:24:34.475 --> 00:24:34.855
So, yeah.

396
00:24:34.875 --> 00:24:36.896
So we're looking at this graph.

397
00:24:37.457 --> 00:24:38.017
It's a plot.

398
00:24:38.137 --> 00:24:38.718
It's a plot.

399
00:24:39.038 --> 00:24:42.780
And then we see basically that 3-I Atlas is well above...

400
00:24:43.841 --> 00:24:44.421
The trendline.

401
00:24:44.441 --> 00:24:45.141
The trendline.

402
00:24:45.281 --> 00:24:46.202
Well, well above the trendline.

403
00:24:46.222 --> 00:24:53.463
Yeah, there are a few that, like the C-2016 R2, that's another comet that's local, and that's even more above than 3-A-Atlas.

404
00:24:53.523 --> 00:24:54.724
But these are exceptions.

405
00:24:54.764 --> 00:24:55.364
That's the point.

406
00:24:55.424 --> 00:24:55.624
Yes.

407
00:24:55.724 --> 00:24:57.424
These are very much exceptions.

408
00:24:57.545 --> 00:25:03.326
And the fact that, you know, we've had two interstellar visitors, one is typical, the other is crazy.

409
00:25:03.446 --> 00:25:10.968
Of course, like, N equals 2 is a very small sample size, but it begs the question, are most interstellar comets...

410
00:25:11.591 --> 00:25:12.152
atypical.

411
00:25:12.272 --> 00:25:12.452
Right.

412
00:25:12.693 --> 00:25:12.893
Right.

413
00:25:12.953 --> 00:25:13.293
Right.

414
00:25:13.454 --> 00:25:13.594
Right.

415
00:25:13.714 --> 00:25:18.961
It's kind of an interesting question because we don't know where they formed and how they formed, around what stars they formed and things like that.

416
00:25:19.282 --> 00:25:22.686
The other thing that's kind of weird about this is there's a lot of nickel

417
00:25:23.816 --> 00:25:25.717
And there's not a lot of iron.

418
00:25:26.537 --> 00:25:30.678
This is very strange because those two usually come side by side together.

419
00:25:31.298 --> 00:25:31.538
Okay.

420
00:25:31.838 --> 00:25:35.959
They're formed at the core of stars during explosions, things like that.

421
00:25:36.439 --> 00:25:44.641
And one can imagine that whenever they form in a dust cloud and they're in some environment, they have typically the same kind of elemental mass.

422
00:25:45.082 --> 00:25:46.522
So they're going to be forming together.

423
00:25:47.673 --> 00:25:50.956
It's not unprecedented again, but it's definitely unusual.

424
00:25:51.396 --> 00:25:53.818
That there's a lot of nickel, there's not a lot of iron.

425
00:25:53.858 --> 00:25:56.220
The ratio between these two is so... Yeah.

426
00:25:56.280 --> 00:25:57.501
The delta is so large.

427
00:25:57.521 --> 00:25:58.822
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

428
00:25:58.982 --> 00:26:01.104
So that, again, there's another question mark there.

429
00:26:01.544 --> 00:26:03.906
How did you get a lot of nickel on a comet but no iron?

430
00:26:04.467 --> 00:26:09.451
So one of the questions is like the velocity question, which goes to origin.

431
00:26:09.911 --> 00:26:11.232
One of the questions is the...

432
00:26:12.633 --> 00:26:37.851
co2 the sunward extension oh yeah piece yeah and and then and then this is now like the like a third question which is the um the composition itself yeah just to try to like quickly summarize those those three key points that are quote in question yeah okay exactly um another really cool local view that we got i was telling you about the mars fleet that we had yes so the maven um probe which is on mars imaged

433
00:26:39.754 --> 00:26:48.587
We found a massive neutral hydrogen corona using the Lyman Alpha line, which is one of the spectral lines of hydrogen that this MAVEN instrument actually had access to.

434
00:26:49.753 --> 00:26:56.201
So from that, we can actually derive a water production rate, and there's a lot of water sublimation that's happening on that comet, okay?

435
00:26:56.721 --> 00:26:59.585
Which is kind of cool, but that's not really that unprecedented.

436
00:26:59.625 --> 00:27:00.766
Comets have a lot of water.

437
00:27:01.247 --> 00:27:09.396
It used to be thought, actually, that— and it still is thought— that a lot of the Earth's water came from comets, because when Earth was forming—

438
00:27:10.037 --> 00:27:12.278
Probably all the water just got evaporated.

439
00:27:12.558 --> 00:27:20.241
And then comets came and deposited their water during the early bombardment of Earth when it was forming.

440
00:27:20.561 --> 00:27:28.824
And one can actually look at the isotopic ratios of different isotopes in water in comets and in the ocean.

441
00:27:29.224 --> 00:27:30.004
And they're the same.

442
00:27:30.584 --> 00:27:32.325
So that suggests that there is a link.

443
00:27:32.485 --> 00:27:32.665
Mm-hmm.

444
00:27:34.069 --> 00:27:39.572
The last piece from Mars that I want to highlight is the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter high-rise.

445
00:27:40.212 --> 00:27:44.554
This confirmed that there is a nuclear diameter, which is probably less than 30 kilometers.

446
00:27:44.954 --> 00:27:47.496
That's the limit of the high-resolution imager.

447
00:27:47.816 --> 00:27:49.817
I mean, we've had tighter constraints before.

448
00:27:50.157 --> 00:27:58.381
Actually, I saw an interview of Avi Loeb on NBC, where he was just like, there's nothing new here.

449
00:27:58.421 --> 00:27:59.421
The data kind of sucks.

450
00:27:59.622 --> 00:27:59.862
Yeah.

451
00:28:00.742 --> 00:28:03.046
It's like, you know, I mean, give them a break.

452
00:28:03.246 --> 00:28:06.050
They were supposed to they were supposed to image Mars with this thing.

453
00:28:06.090 --> 00:28:08.995
They didn't know that they were going to have like a comet on their hand.

454
00:28:09.255 --> 00:28:11.819
That's like a astronomical unit away.

455
00:28:11.839 --> 00:28:15.705
But I just thought it was funny because like everybody's like really excited about this data.

456
00:28:16.450 --> 00:28:32.614
But because the orbiters around Mars are built for Mars, right, as like, you know, within hundreds of kilometers to thousands of kilometers, now you're asking them to image something that's 30 million kilometers away, that's much smaller than Mars.

457
00:28:32.654 --> 00:28:33.874
They're not going to have a good time.

458
00:28:34.894 --> 00:28:44.076
I think this is an important sort of side note because I think this has been the one thing that a lot of people have been like leaning on, which is like we spend billions of dollars.

459
00:28:46.697 --> 00:29:13.541
you know we can't um capture imagery that is you know equivalent to like this and they just bring up an example of something else and i think for the mars specific for the mars uh orbiters specifically you know it would be like asking you to take a picture of someone holding a penny on the empire state building from los angeles with your iphone you know and it's like it's not built for that it's not built for that yeah you know maybe you could use a specialized tool to do so but that just wasn't what was up there at the time

460
00:29:13.701 --> 00:29:14.301
Yeah, exactly.

461
00:29:14.321 --> 00:29:18.322
Like wildlife photographers use giant telephoto lenses, right?

462
00:29:18.402 --> 00:29:19.342
To get those shots.

463
00:29:19.402 --> 00:29:21.083
They spend thousands of dollars on that.

464
00:29:21.423 --> 00:29:23.223
They don't just all go up with an iPhone.

465
00:29:23.663 --> 00:29:31.425
As someone who's had to take photos of my little brother at sports games and having video lenses, not a telephoto lens.

466
00:29:31.525 --> 00:29:32.245
Yeah.

467
00:29:32.305 --> 00:29:32.906
Yeah.

468
00:29:32.946 --> 00:29:34.526
There's a reason why the lens matters.

469
00:29:35.026 --> 00:29:37.067
Like it's a hardware problem at some point, right?

470
00:29:37.087 --> 00:29:37.947
Yeah.

471
00:29:38.947 --> 00:29:45.793
The other really cool way of monitoring this thing was with something called Stereo A, which is solar conjunction monitoring.

472
00:29:46.434 --> 00:29:56.603
This is a really cool set of satellites we have on two sides of Earth's orbit that monitor the sun all the time.

473
00:29:56.983 --> 00:30:00.587
Because the Earth only sees the side of the sun that it's seeing.

474
00:30:00.667 --> 00:30:00.787
Right.

475
00:30:00.807 --> 00:30:00.967
Right?

476
00:30:01.287 --> 00:30:01.528
Right.

477
00:30:01.628 --> 00:30:01.828
Right.

478
00:30:02.757 --> 00:30:06.441
What we'd like to do is see all of the sun all the time.

479
00:30:06.501 --> 00:30:06.681
Right.

480
00:30:06.882 --> 00:30:16.932
So what they do is as the earth is revolving around the sun, they have two satellites that share earth's orbit, but are on 180 degrees away from each other.

481
00:30:17.313 --> 00:30:19.595
So they're imaging the sun from two different sides.

482
00:30:19.615 --> 00:30:19.876
Mm-hmm.

483
00:30:20.476 --> 00:30:21.797
One is leading the Earth.

484
00:30:22.197 --> 00:30:23.659
The other is trailing behind us.

485
00:30:24.279 --> 00:30:30.644
And so with this, we can actually track 3A Atlas as it goes behind the sun, right?

486
00:30:30.724 --> 00:30:34.867
Because when it was coming towards Earth, it actually went behind the sun and we could no longer see it.

487
00:30:34.907 --> 00:30:36.328
Well, with these two satellites, we can.

488
00:30:36.408 --> 00:30:37.009
We can track it.

489
00:30:37.529 --> 00:30:41.292
And we were tracking it and the object kept its structural integrity.

490
00:30:42.410 --> 00:30:42.570
Okay.

491
00:30:43.050 --> 00:30:46.733
Again, this thing is built for imaging the sun, not comets.

492
00:30:46.773 --> 00:30:46.973
Yes.

493
00:30:46.993 --> 00:30:49.956
But at least it could see that, okay, this thing still exists on the other side.

494
00:30:49.996 --> 00:30:50.196
Right.

495
00:30:50.396 --> 00:30:53.078
It didn't like totally disintegrate like some comets sometimes do.

496
00:30:53.098 --> 00:30:54.539
Yep, yep, yep.

497
00:30:54.719 --> 00:31:05.007
And then finally, I want to mention that ISRO, the Indian Space Research Organization, did some observations with the 1.2 meter Mount Abu Infrared Observatory.

498
00:31:05.027 --> 00:31:05.427
Okay.

499
00:31:05.727 --> 00:31:08.869
I have actually been to that observatory because my dad used to work there.

500
00:31:09.049 --> 00:31:10.090
Look at this guy.

501
00:31:10.250 --> 00:31:13.893
Yeah, that's me when I was probably like nine or ten years old.

502
00:31:13.913 --> 00:31:15.254
That's so awesome.

503
00:31:15.354 --> 00:31:17.996
Taking a photo with that 1.2 meter telescope.

504
00:31:18.076 --> 00:31:18.976
Yes, yes.

505
00:31:19.557 --> 00:31:27.682
So that was pretty cool that I saw that one of these observatories that my dad did a lot of research at back when we were in India did some things.

506
00:31:28.022 --> 00:31:29.744
They've got a really nice spectrometer there.

507
00:31:30.204 --> 00:31:32.826
So they found some key molecules in that observatory.

508
00:31:33.546 --> 00:31:59.207
spectrum they found the swan bands which are c2 and c3 that's two carbons and three carbons and they also found cyanogen which is carbon and nitrogen like those bonds have very specific spectra and from that spectrum we can actually find that okay these these molecules do exist and it sort of refutes any lingering claims that there's some like inert or artificial composition because again comets are very typically have these kinds of carbon spectral lines and

509
00:32:00.507 --> 00:32:12.211
So that's sort of where we're at in terms of 3i Atlas, the current data, all of the current observations.

510
00:32:12.691 --> 00:32:13.231
Not all of them.

511
00:32:13.251 --> 00:32:14.951
I mean, we still keep doing a bunch.

512
00:32:15.011 --> 00:32:25.514
There's a lot of actually amateur astronomers that are taking really great photos of this thing, which I find really awesome.

513
00:32:25.695 --> 00:32:27.075
It's a weird comet for sure.

514
00:32:28.303 --> 00:32:30.485
Probably came from a metal-rich star system.

515
00:32:30.845 --> 00:32:32.166
That's why it's got a bunch of nickel.

516
00:32:32.727 --> 00:32:35.009
The fact that it doesn't have a lot of iron is kind of weird.

517
00:32:36.851 --> 00:32:40.914
But there's a lot of stuff that we can do with it, right?

518
00:32:40.974 --> 00:32:43.957
I'm really excited for the Vera Rubin Observatory that's going to come online.

519
00:32:44.397 --> 00:32:48.140
I'm also really excited for an ESA mission called the Comet Interceptor.

520
00:32:48.661 --> 00:32:52.644
It's this new type of mission where it's scheduled for 2029.

521
00:32:52.664 --> 00:32:53.085
It's going to...

522
00:32:55.999 --> 00:32:58.883
It's designed for high-speed flybys, okay?

523
00:32:59.264 --> 00:33:01.607
And this thing is the highest speed possible, right?

524
00:33:02.047 --> 00:33:07.975
So now we've got sort of a parameter space on how high we think flybys should be capable of.

525
00:33:07.995 --> 00:33:08.856
Right, right, right, right.

526
00:33:08.876 --> 00:33:14.403
Because we have a real-world data point now with the Atlas of knowing, like, okay, we are going to see objects that are moving this quickly.

527
00:33:14.403 --> 00:33:15.203
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

528
00:33:15.383 --> 00:33:20.684
And so now we need to meet those expectations of, okay, we found this thing in July.

529
00:33:20.704 --> 00:33:23.185
Yeah, in July we found it.

530
00:33:23.645 --> 00:33:29.926
We've got like a few months to scramble the fighter jets, to scramble the rockets and get this thing going.

531
00:33:30.266 --> 00:33:35.247
That's the capability that we need in order to really study these things really up close.

532
00:33:35.327 --> 00:33:36.047
Yep.

533
00:33:36.207 --> 00:33:38.688
So now we have some data points to actually...

534
00:33:39.469 --> 00:33:41.593
you know, give us that ballpark estimate.

535
00:33:41.733 --> 00:33:44.980
It basically gives like a sort of a mission orientation.

536
00:33:45.161 --> 00:33:45.922
Yes.

537
00:33:46.283 --> 00:33:47.085
For the, like, you know,

538
00:33:49.032 --> 00:34:11.824
what how how fast do we need to set up a rapid response yeah uh and what are the sort of implement like what are the keys to implementation in order to be able to accomplish it and do so yeah um with and i cannot wait for i keep thinking about how with vera rubin uh the number of these interstellar objects is gonna just uh balloon and explode yeah if you

539
00:34:13.065 --> 00:34:17.769
If they are there to be discovered, it will be discovered.

540
00:34:17.789 --> 00:34:19.310
It will be discovered by the Vera Rubin.

541
00:34:19.490 --> 00:34:20.151
Yeah.

542
00:34:20.171 --> 00:34:20.451
100%.

543
00:34:21.572 --> 00:34:26.616
The Vera Rubin would have discovered this thing had it gone online three weeks earlier.

544
00:34:26.636 --> 00:34:27.456
Which is so crazy.

545
00:34:27.476 --> 00:34:27.697
Right?

546
00:34:28.277 --> 00:34:28.957
It's so crazy.

547
00:34:28.998 --> 00:34:31.740
And the quality of that data would have been...

548
00:34:33.128 --> 00:34:33.828
Fantastic.

549
00:34:34.068 --> 00:34:48.793
Again, this being a tool that is built for that type of observation in contrast to the Mars orbiters, which just happened to be closer in proximity and also able to see it at a time where we were on the other side of the sun.

550
00:34:48.893 --> 00:34:52.013
So very well would not have been helpful during that window of time.

551
00:34:52.033 --> 00:34:52.834
Yeah, yeah, definitely not.

552
00:34:52.854 --> 00:34:54.854
During just that window of time.

553
00:34:55.474 --> 00:34:56.095
Fascinating.

554
00:34:56.115 --> 00:34:56.735
So we still...

555
00:34:57.872 --> 00:34:59.192
Jury's still out on origins.

556
00:34:59.532 --> 00:35:00.253
Yep.

557
00:35:00.493 --> 00:35:03.733
Locationally, like where it is coming from.

558
00:35:03.793 --> 00:35:05.614
And that's, jury's still out on age.

559
00:35:06.174 --> 00:35:08.134
Because location is tied to age.

560
00:35:08.415 --> 00:35:10.555
So we still don't know like where and how old.

561
00:35:11.015 --> 00:35:11.655
Yeah.

562
00:35:12.075 --> 00:35:15.556
We have an interesting explanation for the Sunward extension.

563
00:35:16.516 --> 00:35:18.317
But that still is being developed.

564
00:35:18.337 --> 00:35:19.537
Yeah.

565
00:35:19.557 --> 00:35:20.837
Again, that's on archive.

566
00:35:20.857 --> 00:35:23.058
That's not been peer-reviewed and published.

567
00:35:23.198 --> 00:35:23.418
Right.

568
00:35:23.898 --> 00:35:24.898
Right.

569
00:35:25.399 --> 00:35:26.579
And we, you know...

570
00:35:29.060 --> 00:35:32.482
don't quite have the explanation for the nickel-iron ratio.

571
00:35:33.282 --> 00:35:35.243
So these are still open questions.

572
00:35:35.263 --> 00:35:36.283
Yeah.

573
00:35:36.323 --> 00:35:37.824
Which is fair and understandable.

574
00:35:37.844 --> 00:35:39.645
And it's interesting to see the internet process.

575
00:35:39.665 --> 00:35:41.626
I mean, this thing's a few months old.

576
00:35:41.646 --> 00:35:41.766
Right.

577
00:35:41.806 --> 00:35:42.086
Right.

578
00:35:42.126 --> 00:35:44.828
Right now, we're still in the capture all the data you can.

579
00:35:45.408 --> 00:35:48.230
In December, it's going to be close to Jupiter.

580
00:35:48.590 --> 00:35:48.730
Right.

581
00:35:49.230 --> 00:35:50.270
So that'll be interesting.

582
00:35:50.310 --> 00:35:56.212
We have some probes there that perhaps can go, you know, orient and take a look.

583
00:35:56.232 --> 00:35:57.332
I don't know what the plans are there.

584
00:35:57.752 --> 00:36:03.794
I think what is interesting is it's, you know, it hasn't been clear or we haven't had a lot of these.

585
00:36:03.834 --> 00:36:10.635
So we've never had the opportunity to say, hey, we have all these instruments in our solar system now, which we didn't have before.

586
00:36:10.715 --> 00:36:11.115
No.

587
00:36:11.135 --> 00:36:12.676
We have a ton of stuff that's just out there.

588
00:36:13.276 --> 00:36:17.677
And when there is these ephemeral events, these events that happen, you know.

589
00:36:18.697 --> 00:36:35.325
in a moment in time where are these tools going to be used to capture this data or not and this is like proof positive that like everyone understands the import and the unique opportunity and chose to do so so uh another update on 3d atlas i'm sure we'll do another one

590
00:36:35.905 --> 00:36:37.106
Once it's all gone.

591
00:36:37.146 --> 00:36:40.707
Once it's all gone and everyone's really doing that deep dive.

592
00:36:40.787 --> 00:36:43.028
Or once it puts probes in Jupiter.

593
00:36:43.788 --> 00:36:44.308
Right, right.

594
00:36:44.348 --> 00:36:44.668
Apparently.

595
00:36:44.688 --> 00:36:45.389
We'll know in a month.

596
00:36:45.689 --> 00:36:46.609
December 19th.

597
00:36:46.669 --> 00:36:47.570
It's still not done yet.

598
00:36:47.730 --> 00:36:50.371
So we're waiting for quote unquote whatever.

599
00:36:50.391 --> 00:36:50.911
December 19th.

600
00:36:52.112 --> 00:36:56.055
That was our story number one, which was, again, a quick update on 3A Atlas.

601
00:36:57.015 --> 00:37:04.161
We're going to now move on to story number two, which is a very different context.

602
00:37:04.201 --> 00:37:06.543
We're going into a forensic story.

603
00:37:06.563 --> 00:37:07.143
Yeah, we've never done that.

604
00:37:07.183 --> 00:37:29.312
done a friends i think it's our first uh it's our first i thought this was really cool a true crime uh so if you're a fan of true crime we're gonna love this one yeah uh this is out of forensic chemistry uh research out of my new university in ireland for fingerprints from fired bullet casings so i think the the top line is there's a new technique yeah that is making it more efficient to figure out who done it

605
00:37:29.532 --> 00:37:30.953
Yeah, yeah.

606
00:37:30.973 --> 00:37:45.323
And from fired bullet casings, which is really quite something, because it's kind of the holy grail of modern forensics, okay, is to find fingerprints from bullet cases that have already been fired, right?

607
00:37:45.363 --> 00:37:45.763
Because...

608
00:37:46.884 --> 00:37:52.788
Then you can tie a suspect to actually loading the gun rather than just possession of the firearm.

609
00:37:52.868 --> 00:37:54.469
That's actually, that's an important distinction.

610
00:37:54.509 --> 00:37:56.050
Yeah, that's, that's, that's pretty big.

611
00:37:56.110 --> 00:37:56.911
Yes.

612
00:37:57.771 --> 00:38:01.914
It's a, it's a really cool methodology involving electrodeposition.

613
00:38:02.635 --> 00:38:07.038
The paper is out in forensic chemistry by Mayneth University in Ireland.

614
00:38:07.638 --> 00:38:11.501
The fingerprints are typically destroyed whenever a firearm discharges, right?

615
00:38:11.641 --> 00:38:16.565
Because you have stuff like 500 degrees Celsius, pressures of 50,000 pounds per square inch.

616
00:38:17.586 --> 00:38:24.832
And this method exploits some organic residue that remains even after all of this stress.

617
00:38:25.572 --> 00:38:30.296
And it amplifies that organic residue to create a fingerprint.

618
00:38:30.376 --> 00:38:35.300
And it's very cool that the electrochemical techniques that they're using to do this.

619
00:38:36.080 --> 00:38:42.606
And the significance is, as I was saying, the print on the casing links individuals to the act of loading the gun.

620
00:38:43.046 --> 00:38:46.689
And before, we really only have the possession of the firearm.

621
00:38:47.169 --> 00:38:48.951
But somebody else could have done it.

622
00:38:49.011 --> 00:38:51.212
Somebody could have taken the power firearm and done something.

623
00:38:52.874 --> 00:38:57.778
And the prevailing consensus is the violent process of actually firing a bullet...

624
00:38:58.458 --> 00:39:14.581
would destroy the fingerprint on the casing right the the the the theory of the case is you're never going to get the fingerprint off of the fired bullet exactly yeah and it is a pretty violent process right of firing i've fired a gun only once i went to a shooting range and it was like

625
00:39:15.622 --> 00:39:19.183
One of the craziest exhilarating experiences I've ever had.

626
00:39:19.203 --> 00:39:20.064
I've never done it again.

627
00:39:21.144 --> 00:39:25.406
So I had to do a lot of research on how the gun works and the physics of the gun.

628
00:39:25.686 --> 00:39:28.947
But this is my two-minute summary of the process.

629
00:39:29.307 --> 00:39:31.828
This whole thing happens in under two milliseconds.

630
00:39:32.108 --> 00:39:34.289
You've got a casing that has gunpowder.

631
00:39:34.969 --> 00:39:37.830
And then you've got the bullet, which is the projectile in the front.

632
00:39:38.271 --> 00:39:39.451
You've got a firing pin.

633
00:39:39.751 --> 00:39:41.712
And when you hit the firing pin with...

634
00:39:42.432 --> 00:39:49.520
the trigger, that causes a chemical reaction, which raises the temperature inside of the casing.

635
00:39:49.860 --> 00:39:51.923
All of that gunpowder or whatever...

636
00:39:53.462 --> 00:40:02.746
goes up in temperature around something like you can get as much as 2,000 degrees Celsius, and then that's going to expand a lot of air, which is going to shoot the gun forward, okay?

637
00:40:02.986 --> 00:40:08.609
That's not the end, though, because afterwards, you have to take out the casing and replace it with the next one, right?

638
00:40:08.629 --> 00:40:12.271
So there's like a thing that grabs the case, pulls it back,

639
00:40:13.193 --> 00:40:16.215
throws it away, and then loads up the next one, right?

640
00:40:16.555 --> 00:40:20.918
So all of that stuff is going to mess with the fingerprint that's on the outside.

641
00:40:21.198 --> 00:40:30.083
Because when the bullet is fired, that expansion of the air is also going to, first of all, it's going to heat up everything.

642
00:40:30.363 --> 00:40:34.886
So any organic residue that you have, like the proteins or any carbon, that's just going to burn off.

643
00:40:34.906 --> 00:40:35.166
Then...

644
00:40:37.322 --> 00:40:40.123
the casing itself is going to expand into the chamber.

645
00:40:40.683 --> 00:40:47.624
And when you pull it back, that friction is going to then again destroy any residue of a fingerprint that's on the outside.

646
00:40:47.704 --> 00:40:47.864
Yep.

647
00:40:48.064 --> 00:40:48.224
Right?

648
00:40:48.284 --> 00:40:54.565
So there's all of these different things that are happening that will completely mess with the fingerprint that's on the outside.

649
00:40:54.625 --> 00:40:54.805
Right.

650
00:40:54.945 --> 00:40:55.185
Okay?

651
00:40:55.425 --> 00:41:00.686
So the recovery relies on some persistence of like a decomposition product that's on the outside.

652
00:41:00.746 --> 00:41:01.026
Okay?

653
00:41:01.587 --> 00:41:03.027
And what this particular...

654
00:41:04.679 --> 00:41:07.540
paper is focusing on is the carbonized ash.

655
00:41:07.961 --> 00:41:15.025
So there's going to be some inorganic salts that are left by our sweat and our oils that is going to remain.

656
00:41:15.165 --> 00:41:19.328
It's going to get burned up, but the ash is going to remain on the outside.

657
00:41:19.768 --> 00:41:30.395
There's the idea being the theory of the case is there's no organic residue that will be left after the bullet is fired because it's just going to get burned.

658
00:41:30.415 --> 00:41:30.615
Yeah.

659
00:41:30.675 --> 00:41:32.677
Like the proteins, the oils and the lipids.

660
00:41:33.557 --> 00:41:33.898
It's gone.

661
00:41:34.378 --> 00:41:41.627
But their hypothesis was there's going to be a little indicator still left despite all of that.

662
00:41:42.548 --> 00:41:43.229
Yeah.

663
00:41:43.369 --> 00:41:46.032
And it should be the burned up ash of all of that stuff.

664
00:41:46.052 --> 00:41:46.753
Of all of that stuff.

665
00:41:46.773 --> 00:41:46.973
Right.

666
00:41:47.193 --> 00:41:48.775
And there should be a little bit left.

667
00:41:49.436 --> 00:41:49.616
Right.

668
00:41:49.716 --> 00:41:52.259
And if there's even a little bit left, there's a chance.

669
00:41:52.299 --> 00:41:52.520
Yeah.

670
00:41:53.340 --> 00:41:55.421
So you're saying there's a chance.

671
00:41:55.842 --> 00:41:56.322
Exactly.

672
00:41:56.682 --> 00:41:58.803
And so that's what they're doing here.

673
00:41:59.144 --> 00:42:01.205
This isn't completely unprecedented, okay?

674
00:42:01.425 --> 00:42:04.106
So in 2008, there was a guy, Dr. John Bond.

675
00:42:04.567 --> 00:42:09.509
He came up with a mechanism to actually figure out these casings.

676
00:42:10.790 --> 00:42:12.711
That's crazy that his name is Bond.

677
00:42:12.771 --> 00:42:13.272
Yeah, yeah.

678
00:42:13.352 --> 00:42:13.572
And it...

679
00:42:14.212 --> 00:42:19.736
I thought it was like part of the bond when I was reading it because my summary just had bond.

680
00:42:20.076 --> 00:42:23.198
And even the news articles about this just have bond.

681
00:42:23.218 --> 00:42:24.639
And I'm like, like James Bond?

682
00:42:25.440 --> 00:42:32.444
Like this is, you know, maybe this is one of Q's, like the weird techniques that he's made.

683
00:42:32.504 --> 00:42:34.165
But no, this is Dr. John Bond.

684
00:42:34.566 --> 00:42:39.549
And he came up with a way of using really high voltage, 2.5 kilovolts, right?

685
00:42:39.609 --> 00:42:40.329
And what you do is...

686
00:42:41.230 --> 00:42:47.970
you realize that most of these casings are made out of brass, which is copper and zinc.

687
00:42:49.825 --> 00:42:56.589
And the zinc and the copper are going to react with the oils on my finger in different ways.

688
00:42:56.969 --> 00:43:04.332
So where the fingerprint was, that's actually going to create a chemical reaction and a corrosion of the zinc part, not the copper part.

689
00:43:04.452 --> 00:43:04.712
Okay.

690
00:43:04.772 --> 00:43:05.013
Okay.

691
00:43:05.373 --> 00:43:07.454
So there's going to be different resistance.

692
00:43:07.474 --> 00:43:11.236
There's going to be different tiny layer of different metals.

693
00:43:11.736 --> 00:43:14.037
And what I'm going to do is subject this...

694
00:43:15.105 --> 00:43:41.416
casing to really high voltage people are crazy and then put a fine conducting powder on top and then that powder is going to be attracted to the corrosion type sites because that's going to be high more conductive than the rest right and then i can i can make a fingerprint out of that that's so brilliant it's it's pretty brilliant so in 2008 this has already happened this is going one step further further okay okay and so the the we've we've identified that we can basically put

695
00:43:42.757 --> 00:44:06.471
like current into a substrate and it will basically reveal this red like this pattern which is the fingerprint we're looking for because the zinc interacts yeah the metal itself the metal itself interacted differently with the organic you know residue which is just us touching outside of the brass bullet casing yeah where he's like let's just pump it and yeah it just shows up

696
00:44:07.312 --> 00:44:09.334
I know that's like a bastard, but that's so...

697
00:44:09.374 --> 00:44:10.115
I think that's pretty cool.

698
00:44:10.135 --> 00:44:11.436
That's pretty cool in and of itself.

699
00:44:11.477 --> 00:44:11.797
Yeah.

700
00:44:12.097 --> 00:44:16.282
The problem is it works on brass because it requires this alloy, right, of copper and zinc.

701
00:44:16.302 --> 00:44:16.462
Yep.

702
00:44:17.083 --> 00:44:21.888
Well, now, I mean, I think there are now casings made out of steel, stainless steel and things like that.

703
00:44:21.908 --> 00:44:22.589
It's not going to work there.

704
00:44:22.609 --> 00:44:23.650
It's not a universal solution.

705
00:44:23.670 --> 00:44:27.414
The chemistry is not going to work with the iron and the carbon that's in the steel.

706
00:44:28.015 --> 00:44:28.295
Okay.

707
00:44:28.455 --> 00:44:34.241
So what these guys did was use a process called cyclic voltometry.

708
00:44:34.281 --> 00:44:37.343
So you start with an electrochemical cell, which is a three electrode setup.

709
00:44:37.784 --> 00:44:38.925
You've got a working electrode.

710
00:44:38.985 --> 00:44:42.848
In this case, this is going to be our brass casing, the thing that we want to actually test on.

711
00:44:43.329 --> 00:44:46.672
There's going to be a counter electrode, which basically completes the circuit.

712
00:44:46.912 --> 00:44:50.635
And then there's a reference electrode that keeps the circuit at a certain voltage.

713
00:44:50.876 --> 00:44:50.996
Okay.

714
00:44:51.775 --> 00:45:00.182
And you've got, so imagine you take your brass casing, you put it in a chamber with a bunch of electrolyte around it.

715
00:45:00.422 --> 00:45:02.944
So chemically conducting water effectively.

716
00:45:03.445 --> 00:45:05.346
You attach a electrode lead to it.

717
00:45:05.586 --> 00:45:06.907
You have other leads.

718
00:45:07.188 --> 00:45:10.771
And now what you can do is start turning on the voltage very gradually.

719
00:45:10.791 --> 00:45:11.031
Mm-hmm.

720
00:45:11.511 --> 00:45:11.731
Okay?

721
00:45:12.311 --> 00:45:13.892
And that's called cyclic voltometry.

722
00:45:14.172 --> 00:45:17.953
You turn on the voltage extremely gradually, and what you do is you measure the current.

723
00:45:18.353 --> 00:45:20.274
There's going to be a blip in the current.

724
00:45:20.294 --> 00:45:25.196
There's going to be a peak in the current, and that corresponds to something called the oxidation potential.

725
00:45:25.616 --> 00:45:31.058
Effectively, there's some current that is going to allow a chemical reaction to take place on that surface.

726
00:45:31.618 --> 00:45:31.858
Okay?

727
00:45:33.158 --> 00:45:35.219
Once you tune it to that peak current,

728
00:45:36.318 --> 00:45:46.321
You can keep that current as low as possible so you don't make any other weird chemistry that's happening and really tune it to that residue that you want.

729
00:45:47.442 --> 00:45:47.642
Right.

730
00:45:47.962 --> 00:45:53.124
And this is the ash that's been left over after the casings come out.

731
00:45:53.804 --> 00:45:54.024
Right.

732
00:45:54.104 --> 00:45:54.284
Yep.

733
00:45:54.464 --> 00:45:56.185
So you're at a low enough voltage.

734
00:45:56.205 --> 00:45:56.765
Right.

735
00:45:56.977 --> 00:46:03.358
where you're not causing anything else to start destroying the ash that's there.

736
00:46:03.378 --> 00:46:06.479
You're only tuning it barely to that ash itself.

737
00:46:06.939 --> 00:46:08.219
Barely to that ash itself.

738
00:46:09.099 --> 00:46:14.020
And what ends up happening is you get these two polymers called E dot and P E dot.

739
00:46:14.561 --> 00:46:15.701
It doesn't matter what they are.

740
00:46:16.201 --> 00:46:24.302
The effect is they're polymers that are long chains, but still really, really small in terms of, you know, every day.

741
00:46:27.043 --> 00:46:36.032
And what those single chemicals are going to do is when this chemical reaction is happening, this oxidation reaction, the chemicals are going to get deposited on the ash.

742
00:46:38.135 --> 00:46:38.455
Okay.

743
00:46:39.076 --> 00:46:39.776
Oh, actually, no.

744
00:46:39.816 --> 00:46:40.037
Sorry.

745
00:46:40.057 --> 00:46:44.661
They're going to get deposited on the metal and they're going to leave the ash alone.

746
00:46:45.061 --> 00:46:45.281
Okay.

747
00:46:45.301 --> 00:46:47.063
Because the ash is going to be insulating.

748
00:46:47.183 --> 00:46:47.583
I got you.

749
00:46:47.623 --> 00:46:48.204
I should say that.

750
00:46:48.244 --> 00:46:49.084
I should say that again.

751
00:46:50.265 --> 00:46:53.048
You stick the electrode in, you charge up the casing.

752
00:46:53.228 --> 00:46:53.388
Yes.

753
00:46:53.668 --> 00:46:56.251
That's going to have a bunch of carbon ash and residue on it.

754
00:46:56.571 --> 00:46:58.773
That ash is going to be insulating compared to the metal.

755
00:46:59.173 --> 00:47:03.577
So the chemicals are going to get deposited on the metal, but leave holes in the metal.

756
00:47:03.837 --> 00:47:29.341
where the ash is it's it's like the opposite of the tracer stuff that they put in mice when they're trying to test them to follow it it's like the opposite yes yes exactly exactly like what's what's left is what we're looking for yes exactly and so now we have a way of of actually doing this right now why is this better than the 2008 method okay yeah for one i can do this on steel okay right i

757
00:47:32.982 --> 00:47:36.585
The other is you get a lot higher resolution on this, okay?

758
00:47:36.805 --> 00:47:42.270
This E.thionine method consistently yields grade 3 visualization.

759
00:47:43.171 --> 00:47:44.432
I didn't know this about fingerprints.

760
00:47:44.792 --> 00:47:47.915
With fingerprints, there's level 1 pattern, which is the fingerprint itself.

761
00:47:48.536 --> 00:47:51.018
The level 2 pattern is the detail on the ridges.

762
00:47:51.498 --> 00:47:55.662
And the level 3 pattern is within each of our ridges, there's little pores that...

763
00:47:57.706 --> 00:48:04.091
Where the pattern of that pour is also unique to each individual.

764
00:48:04.392 --> 00:48:12.918
And so to really start getting something that I can admit in court and all of this other kind of stuff, it'd be really nice to get level three patterns.

765
00:48:12.938 --> 00:48:17.742
Because sometimes level two patterns, like let's say you have just the edge of someone's fingerprint.

766
00:48:17.982 --> 00:48:21.385
Well, that edge could maybe match to somebody else's fingerprint and things like that.

767
00:48:21.665 --> 00:48:25.128
But if you have the edge of someone's fingerprint and you have the pattern of the holes...

768
00:48:25.668 --> 00:48:30.169
That's now extremely hard to match erroneously.

769
00:48:30.249 --> 00:48:30.629
Yeah, yeah.

770
00:48:31.110 --> 00:48:31.370
Right?

771
00:48:31.650 --> 00:48:40.192
And so this current method actually lets you resolve those pores with these micro deposits, right?

772
00:48:40.232 --> 00:48:42.713
You've got a mechanism to now actually...

773
00:48:43.769 --> 00:48:47.153
visualize those pores with those electrolyte contacts.

774
00:48:47.173 --> 00:48:48.215
And this is from the paper.

775
00:48:48.255 --> 00:48:51.439
You can see very clearly the pores and the ridges, right?

776
00:48:51.799 --> 00:48:54.422
And this is at tens of microns of resolution.

777
00:48:54.963 --> 00:48:56.605
That's the other key that's very different.

778
00:48:56.985 --> 00:48:58.768
In the 2008 method from Dr.

779
00:48:58.928 --> 00:48:59.108
Bond,

780
00:49:00.925 --> 00:49:02.506
He used a conductive powder.

781
00:49:03.166 --> 00:49:08.190
That powder, the size of the powder is bigger than the pores.

782
00:49:08.250 --> 00:49:09.951
That's your limiting factor for resolution.

783
00:49:10.111 --> 00:49:12.272
Here we're doing single molecule deposition.

784
00:49:12.312 --> 00:49:13.113
Right, right, right.

785
00:49:13.173 --> 00:49:14.514
Right, right, right.

786
00:49:14.834 --> 00:49:16.975
It makes total sense.

787
00:49:17.796 --> 00:49:18.556
This is so...

788
00:49:18.676 --> 00:49:19.297
I'm just like...

789
00:49:20.945 --> 00:49:25.387
been out of shape at how clever conceptually people think about this stuff.

790
00:49:25.607 --> 00:49:25.867
Yeah.

791
00:49:26.047 --> 00:49:26.207
Yeah.

792
00:49:26.227 --> 00:49:26.407
Yeah.

793
00:49:26.427 --> 00:49:26.607
Yeah.

794
00:49:26.647 --> 00:49:29.488
Put it in a, and then put some electrolytes around it.

795
00:49:29.788 --> 00:49:34.950
And then we know, because we know the other aspects of this chemistry, we can just into it.

796
00:49:35.450 --> 00:49:35.690
Right.

797
00:49:35.730 --> 00:49:35.990
Yeah.

798
00:49:36.070 --> 00:49:38.251
This should probably work.

799
00:49:38.351 --> 00:49:38.591
Yeah.

800
00:49:38.791 --> 00:49:50.195
And then when you do it and you see the, you know, the example image we just looked at, where it's getting the, the, the level of detail, sorry, not this one, but not number eight, where we now see in the real world, that detail difference,

801
00:49:50.395 --> 00:50:14.981
yeah um i mean like again even as as sort of someone who's maybe not in francis you could understand why you would want something with this the level of fidelity on the right yeah versus on the left yeah yeah exactly and then it's it's pretty awesome it's pretty cool yeah um the other cool thing that they did was actually like so you know your casing goes in yep um in order to maintain a uniform electric field around that casing during this electrochemical reaction

802
00:50:20.462 --> 00:50:22.143
make a uniform electric field.

803
00:50:22.303 --> 00:50:22.584
Okay.

804
00:50:22.644 --> 00:50:30.589
Because if you put it inside a box, then the edges, the edge effects are going to be different and you're not going to get the complete fingerprint around the thing, you know?

805
00:50:30.829 --> 00:50:42.977
So now it moves to a place where, okay, if we want to implement this in industry for each different size of casing, we should have different size chambers to actually do this reaction.

806
00:50:43.018 --> 00:50:45.799
The other cool thing about this is the Dr.

807
00:50:45.819 --> 00:50:46.540
Bond method is,

808
00:50:47.625 --> 00:50:49.106
took 2.5 kilovolts.

809
00:50:49.787 --> 00:50:54.071
That's not something that I can, like, hook up to my car battery and, like, right?

810
00:50:54.812 --> 00:50:57.654
This thing takes less than 1.1 volts.

811
00:50:58.035 --> 00:51:02.959
So this could be handheld by the crime-fighting units.

812
00:51:02.999 --> 00:51:04.160
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

813
00:51:04.200 --> 00:51:05.121
You could do it on site.

814
00:51:05.141 --> 00:51:06.643
You wouldn't necessarily have to send it to a lab.

815
00:51:06.683 --> 00:51:07.003
Yes.

816
00:51:07.203 --> 00:51:09.986
And then, you know, with that stuff, timing is everything, right?

817
00:51:10.046 --> 00:51:11.067
Yeah, that's actually a really big deal.

818
00:51:11.988 --> 00:51:15.430
So there's a lot of really new stuff that's happening.

819
00:51:15.791 --> 00:51:27.800
Now, before it actually gets implemented, it needs to pass something called the Dobert standard, which is the standard that they have in forensics before you can admit something in court.

820
00:51:28.221 --> 00:51:30.542
Like DNA testing had to go through this, things like that.

821
00:51:30.963 --> 00:51:32.424
It relies on testability.

822
00:51:32.624 --> 00:51:33.605
You got to have peer review.

823
00:51:33.625 --> 00:51:36.007
They already have peer review with this paper.

824
00:51:36.127 --> 00:51:38.008
You got to figure out what the error rates are

825
00:51:38.849 --> 00:52:01.434
among a general population like not just let's say white males but okay how does it work with women how does it work with different races things like that and generally to accept everything all of these things have to be checked so that's the next step it's sort of like the regulatory process or the governing standard for this moving from being something that is interesting and people could

826
00:52:02.094 --> 00:52:28.602
utilize but not then have be admissible in court to it being be able being able to be used to actually say you know as evidence that someone is the shooter yeah exactly and um one last thing that i want to talk about is the fact that they can actually do old casings as well they tried to do a fingerprint from a 16 month old casing and they were actually able to recover a fingerprint which is uh you know so this isn't like just now

827
00:52:29.222 --> 00:52:30.202
They could be going back.

828
00:52:30.222 --> 00:52:31.183
This is okay.

829
00:52:31.203 --> 00:52:31.483
Yeah.

830
00:52:31.903 --> 00:52:32.323
Look.

831
00:52:32.363 --> 00:52:35.205
So if you thought you got away, I don't know.

832
00:52:36.585 --> 00:52:36.825
Yeah.

833
00:52:36.965 --> 00:52:39.867
That's actually very, a very important detail.

834
00:52:40.187 --> 00:52:40.547
Yeah.

835
00:52:40.607 --> 00:52:40.867
Yeah.

836
00:52:40.887 --> 00:52:46.970
Because it kind of, you know, I think because for example, if for all the fans of true crime podcasts, et cetera.

837
00:52:47.610 --> 00:52:52.691
With the advent of DNA testing, a lot of cold cases have been reopened.

838
00:52:52.711 --> 00:52:53.532
Yeah.

839
00:52:53.552 --> 00:53:00.334
And people have started to get caught for stuff they did ages ago.

840
00:53:00.354 --> 00:53:00.454
Yeah.

841
00:53:00.614 --> 00:53:03.535
This is another lever that could unlock a lot of stuff there.

842
00:53:03.715 --> 00:53:03.955
Yeah.

843
00:53:04.155 --> 00:53:07.676
I mean, there's a lot of recent cases I can think of where this existing...

844
00:53:09.116 --> 00:53:25.024
would have invited i mean meg the stallion and had a case with uh that little rapper that i can't remember his name right now who's in jail and like it has this issue of they fingerprinted the gun but uh they could they not the casings

845
00:53:25.364 --> 00:53:26.365
that were shot.

846
00:53:26.425 --> 00:53:29.307
And so that would be a case where it would be interesting.

847
00:53:29.367 --> 00:53:32.749
Another one is obviously the recent unfortunate assassination of Charlie Kirk.

848
00:53:32.770 --> 00:53:33.130
Yes.

849
00:53:33.530 --> 00:53:46.319
That would be an example where this would really go... Because there's a lot of issues about the weapon and the suspect and all of the timeline doesn't... Yeah, quite.

850
00:53:46.540 --> 00:53:47.100
Yeah, yeah.

851
00:53:47.280 --> 00:53:48.141
So, I mean, this would be another...

852
00:53:48.161 --> 00:53:48.761
Trying to sell something.

853
00:53:49.221 --> 00:53:51.703
You know, an empirical thing that would be...

854
00:53:54.393 --> 00:54:16.211
valuable in that context yeah i think i think it's it's a very cool use of just fundamental electrochemistry for a problem that's been around for ages uh toy lanes i had to say the name because i was going to be mad if i couldn't remember it that was yeah it's the stallion and toy lanes yeah okay i didn't forget guys it's a little brain fart i got it i got it i got it i don't know who either i don't know who

855
00:54:19.706 --> 00:54:21.807
It's funny because it was very on TikTok.

856
00:54:21.867 --> 00:54:23.027
It was a very anyway.

857
00:54:23.987 --> 00:54:25.648
Story number two, our first forensic story.

858
00:54:25.668 --> 00:54:26.588
We should do more.

859
00:54:26.628 --> 00:54:27.248
Yeah, we should do.

860
00:54:27.368 --> 00:54:29.689
Yeah, that was that was that was cool.

861
00:54:29.769 --> 00:54:31.150
A nice little true crime vibe.

862
00:54:31.390 --> 00:54:38.352
And so, again, we have now a new way to identify fingerprints from fired bullet casings.

863
00:54:38.872 --> 00:54:43.058
This is out of my new university in Ireland, and it was in forensic chemistry.

864
00:54:43.639 --> 00:54:45.461
We're going to move on to our last story.

865
00:54:47.043 --> 00:54:55.935
We've done a lot of health-related or health care-related stories just because science is having an absolute problem.

866
00:54:56.095 --> 00:55:01.798
just tear, I think, on just some of these new models, new detection mechanisms.

867
00:55:02.118 --> 00:55:05.760
And so this last story is about Alzheimer's.

868
00:55:05.840 --> 00:55:06.140
Yes.

869
00:55:06.821 --> 00:55:19.107
And we have sort of a paper in Nature, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, Max Planck Institute for Biology of Aging, and the University of Cologne seem to have a new detection.

870
00:55:19.787 --> 00:55:26.609
Yeah, it's a new type of immune system, or it's a new type of immune cell that they found in the brain.

871
00:55:27.290 --> 00:55:30.891
And even that is kind of, let me be very careful.

872
00:55:31.271 --> 00:55:44.215
It's not a new type of immune cell, because we already knew the microglia existed, but it's a state that the cell is in that is very important for mitigating Alzheimer's.

873
00:55:44.475 --> 00:55:48.437
And we're honing in on what exactly that cell needs to be

874
00:55:49.457 --> 00:55:51.938
in order to help Alzheimer's not happen.

875
00:55:52.179 --> 00:55:52.539
Interesting.

876
00:55:52.559 --> 00:55:52.719
Okay.

877
00:55:52.999 --> 00:55:53.259
Okay.

878
00:55:53.559 --> 00:55:54.180
Got it.

879
00:55:54.300 --> 00:55:56.821
Alzheimer's is an incredibly difficult disease.

880
00:55:57.341 --> 00:55:57.581
Okay.

881
00:55:57.982 --> 00:55:59.262
Incredibly difficult.

882
00:55:59.863 --> 00:56:05.126
There used to be this thing called the amyloid hypothesis, where the basic idea was...

883
00:56:06.246 --> 00:56:13.716
There's a protein in our brain called beta myeloid that misfolds, starts aggregating, and then starts creating clumps.

884
00:56:14.116 --> 00:56:16.920
And then those clumps are what get in the way of neurons.

885
00:56:16.940 --> 00:56:18.101
They start killing neurons.

886
00:56:18.141 --> 00:56:20.144
They start killing synapses.

887
00:56:20.284 --> 00:56:22.787
And then that is what leads to Alzheimer's.

888
00:56:23.842 --> 00:56:31.744
That's been sort of shut out by a lot of recent evidence suggesting that that might not actually be the case.

889
00:56:31.904 --> 00:56:36.065
So the hypothesis is basically there's a blockage that starts growing.

890
00:56:36.325 --> 00:56:36.545
Yeah.

891
00:56:36.705 --> 00:56:38.685
And then that's what impacts the brain activity.

892
00:56:38.745 --> 00:56:39.005
Yes.

893
00:56:39.025 --> 00:56:40.146
This growth of this blockage.

894
00:56:40.266 --> 00:56:40.766
Exactly.

895
00:56:41.086 --> 00:56:51.108
And now we're slowly shifting from there's this like protein blockage to there might be an innate immune system in the brain that might be failing at doing its job.

896
00:56:52.398 --> 00:57:16.715
this okay so that's the shift that we're we're sort of in the middle of actually right now as more and more papers come out i think i know where this is okay and um okay so the the core study that came out in nature um first author ayata lymphoid gene expression supports neuroproductive microglia function what they've what they found is a novel immune like microglial state um

897
00:57:17.662 --> 00:57:22.970
And they've identified exactly the transcription factor that is required.

898
00:57:23.731 --> 00:57:29.600
They've identified exactly the genes that are involved in this transcription.

899
00:57:29.887 --> 00:57:47.400
microglial state and they've identified how those genes and those transcription factors create the downstream effect of mitigating alzheimer's so it's top down all the way they have a full map they have a full map of of how it's happening and it's it's very very cool very interesting

900
00:57:47.600 --> 00:57:49.502
Okay, so let's start with Alzheimer's, right?

901
00:57:49.802 --> 00:57:51.103
It's an evolving landscape.

902
00:57:51.224 --> 00:57:57.189
Alwa Alzheimer's, 1906, described these senile plaques and neurofibrillary tangles.

903
00:57:57.890 --> 00:58:02.875
And the field of neurodegradation has been intellectually sort of focused on these plaques.

904
00:58:02.895 --> 00:58:06.138
You can see the really dark plaque in the middle of brain tissue.

905
00:58:06.478 --> 00:58:08.720
That's going to just get in the way of stuff, right?

906
00:58:09.781 --> 00:58:09.961
Mm-hmm.

907
00:58:10.802 --> 00:58:18.412
Then we started targeting immunotherapies that were capable of stripping the brain of these amyloid plaques, right?

908
00:58:18.713 --> 00:58:22.598
And those had only modest effects on cognitive decline.

909
00:58:23.179 --> 00:58:25.181
And that suggests that these plaques are...

910
00:58:25.842 --> 00:58:28.724
like kind of a match that starts a much larger fire.

911
00:58:29.365 --> 00:58:29.645
Okay?

912
00:58:29.905 --> 00:58:33.588
There's something else downstream of the plaques that's really the cause.

913
00:58:33.608 --> 00:58:34.769
There's something more fundamental.

914
00:58:34.789 --> 00:58:35.810
Yes, exactly.

915
00:58:36.191 --> 00:58:45.618
And that thing that is more fundamental, people thought, could be neuroinflammation, which is the inflammation of the brain because of stress, because of an immune response.

916
00:58:45.658 --> 00:58:47.260
Effectively, it's kind of like...

917
00:58:48.049 --> 00:58:51.190
an autoimmune response, but local to our brain.

918
00:58:51.370 --> 00:58:51.591
Okay.

919
00:58:51.971 --> 00:58:52.231
Okay?

920
00:58:52.631 --> 00:59:00.894
There's the immune system itself that's supposed to be cleaning everything is now in a stage where it's just attacking all the time.

921
00:59:01.535 --> 00:59:01.755
Okay?

922
00:59:02.095 --> 00:59:13.780
So there's some genetic evidence for this because a vast majority of the late-onset Alzheimer's genetic risk, like we can tell because some people have Alzheimer's and others don't, we can look at what the genetic mutations are,

923
00:59:14.830 --> 00:59:18.772
All of those are targeted on these things called microglia, not neurons.

924
00:59:19.752 --> 00:59:20.372
Okay.

925
00:59:20.412 --> 00:59:27.615
Those genetic loci are activated in microglia and not in neurons.

926
00:59:28.075 --> 00:59:36.679
So that's telling us that the riskiness of the Alzheimer's, at least from a genetic standpoint, is happening in the cells that are the microglia, not on the neurons.

927
00:59:37.019 --> 00:59:37.319
Right.

928
00:59:37.699 --> 00:59:40.821
Not on the computation, but on these housekeeping cells.

929
00:59:40.841 --> 00:59:40.981
Yeah.

930
00:59:41.061 --> 00:59:41.321
Okay.

931
00:59:41.341 --> 00:59:42.361
That might be acting up.

932
00:59:42.381 --> 00:59:42.541
Yep.

933
00:59:42.581 --> 00:59:42.761
Yep.

934
00:59:42.781 --> 00:59:42.982
Yep.

935
00:59:43.062 --> 00:59:43.282
Right.

936
00:59:43.362 --> 00:59:43.762
Yep.

937
00:59:43.802 --> 00:59:43.982
Yep.

938
00:59:44.222 --> 00:59:47.063
Microglia are a specific type of cell.

939
00:59:47.083 --> 00:59:51.524
They actually originate in the yolk sac, the stem cells in the yolk sac back when we're in embryo.

940
00:59:52.425 --> 00:59:55.886
They colonize the brain before the blood-brain barrier forms.

941
00:59:56.406 --> 00:59:56.846
Oh, okay.

942
00:59:57.066 --> 01:00:02.347
So they get inside, and then the blood-brain barrier forms, and then they maintain themselves within the blood-brain barrier.

943
01:00:02.648 --> 01:00:07.309
So they don't come from the bone marrow like other immune cells do.

944
01:00:07.489 --> 01:00:10.190
They're sort of innate in the brain, and they stay in the brain.

945
01:00:10.770 --> 01:00:10.970
Okay.

946
01:00:11.231 --> 01:00:15.216
So another big reason why it's hard to access these things is they're inside the blood brain barrier.

947
01:00:15.236 --> 01:00:15.416
Right.

948
01:00:15.556 --> 01:00:15.697
Right.

949
01:00:15.717 --> 01:00:18.060
So you can't really like poke it with drugs and things like that.

950
01:00:18.080 --> 01:00:18.140
Um,

951
01:00:20.331 --> 01:00:24.613
And a lot of times they're basically in homeostasis.

952
01:00:24.633 --> 01:00:30.074
So they're doing their normal thing where they're moving around, they're cleaning up byproducts.

953
01:00:30.194 --> 01:00:39.278
They have these things called processes, which are if you've ever seen immune cells like in real time, they'll like protrude out.

954
01:00:39.818 --> 01:00:43.979
They'll have these arms that stick out and they're basically just surveying, right?

955
01:00:43.999 --> 01:00:44.899
They don't have eyes.

956
01:00:45.180 --> 01:00:46.600
So they're using these processes.

957
01:00:46.820 --> 01:00:51.691
protrusions to increase their surface area and sense the chemical environment.

958
01:00:52.172 --> 01:00:55.298
And if they sense something that's bad, then they...

959
01:00:56.410 --> 01:01:06.337
Go into a state of response where they try to eat whatever thing is bad or they try to deal with the plaques and stuff like that.

960
01:01:06.657 --> 01:01:10.620
But if you have too much of that, then that's going to destroy the neurons around you as well.

961
01:01:11.300 --> 01:01:11.721
Right.

962
01:01:11.781 --> 01:01:15.203
So if you have too much upregulation of that state, that's pretty bad.

963
01:01:15.223 --> 01:01:15.663
Right.

964
01:01:15.803 --> 01:01:15.984
Right.

965
01:01:17.164 --> 01:01:25.949
And what ends up happening is you've got this aggressive amyloid deposition that happens in, let's say, mice models, right?

966
01:01:26.129 --> 01:01:26.750
Yep.

967
01:01:27.390 --> 01:01:29.331
This is something that mimics the Alzheimer's.

968
01:01:29.792 --> 01:01:35.555
So you've got a neuron in the middle and all of these plaques that are sort of getting in the way of the neuron trying to do everything.

969
01:01:36.736 --> 01:01:39.017
And if you're...

970
01:01:40.343 --> 01:02:06.300
microglial cell like actually senses some of these plaques senses too much of the plaques or just has this up regulation and can't down regulate then it's the a runaway reaction of immune stuff that's happening in our brain so what we're sort of getting at here is this idea that these immune cells might be over activated uh based on some stimuli yeah and that over activation

971
01:02:07.380 --> 01:02:32.902
um is actually the driver for the neurodegeneration yeah it could be one of the drivers one one of the drivers yeah um of of the decline in in cognition because now it's these arms that are going to pick up stuff yeah are are just everywhere yeah there's too much too much doing too much yeah yeah pick up too many people off the street yeah

972
01:02:33.182 --> 01:02:41.689
And when they're doing too much, they're not doing their original job of like cleaning the plaque and like compacting it and all this other kind of stuff.

973
01:02:42.050 --> 01:02:45.673
It's like if the janitor became a vigilante at night at the building.

974
01:02:45.713 --> 01:02:47.454
And so instead of doing the normal janitor stuff.

975
01:02:47.475 --> 01:02:51.738
Yeah, now the building's falling apart while the janitor's going to be a vigilante.

976
01:02:51.778 --> 01:02:52.179
Yeah, yeah.

977
01:02:52.199 --> 01:02:53.880
And he's not good at vigilanteism either.

978
01:02:53.900 --> 01:02:54.501
It's like, bro.

979
01:02:56.618 --> 01:02:56.879
You know?

980
01:02:57.339 --> 01:02:58.160
Okay.

981
01:02:58.560 --> 01:03:03.045
So they had a bunch of different methodologies that they used, which was quite cool.

982
01:03:03.325 --> 01:03:08.471
They used a mouse model, and the mouse model mimics the adult Alzheimer's.

983
01:03:08.811 --> 01:03:17.640
They also have this Krelox recombination system, which what you can do is you can induce gene deletion four to six weeks after surgery.

984
01:03:18.761 --> 01:03:19.802
They're born, right?

985
01:03:19.922 --> 01:03:25.525
Usually you imagine with gene deletion, the deletion needs to happen, and then you create the life form.

986
01:03:25.685 --> 01:03:32.129
But then you have problems because, like, what if the development is perturbed, right?

987
01:03:32.169 --> 01:03:34.351
Then you've created this defective life form.

988
01:03:34.591 --> 01:03:39.774
You're making conclusions, and you don't know if it's the development or the actual gene that's happening in the adult population.

989
01:03:39.794 --> 01:03:42.576
So here, this is a way to delay deletion.

990
01:03:43.176 --> 01:04:04.741
deleting a gene and then it ensures that any phenotypes that are observed and anything that we observe in the experiment is due to a loss of gene function in the adult deceased brain because alzheimer's is the adult yeah right it's not it's not something that you know right this gene is doing something bad once you're getting old right right and so that's what we want to mimic so so they were able to do that they also have this um

991
01:04:06.187 --> 01:04:14.873
The other really cool thing that they could do was something called TRAP, which is translating ribosome affinity purification.

992
01:04:15.213 --> 01:04:30.725
The idea is I want to prove that the transcripts, the mRNA that's getting translated in the microglia, like, so the instructions from the DNA into making protein, those instructions that the microglia is paying attention to,

993
01:04:31.688 --> 01:04:39.215
it's coming from the actual microglia and not because the microglia is like, let's say, eating another immune cell, right?

994
01:04:39.415 --> 01:04:44.800
Because if the microglia eats another immune cell, well, that immune cell is going to have its own mRNA.

995
01:04:45.160 --> 01:04:54.368
And when I sequence, I don't know if this mRNA came from me doing my own thing or me eating something else and then that food is what's getting transcribed, right?

996
01:04:54.388 --> 01:04:56.190
So how do we make that distinction?

997
01:04:56.530 --> 01:04:58.432
There's this incredible...

998
01:04:59.710 --> 01:05:21.192
way of doing it called gfp tagging where you take this green fluorescent protein you tag a ribosome with it okay so the ribosome has attached this green fluorescent protein and now the ribosome is going along and it's transcribing your mrna you take that you take those cells in that culture and you have another part

999
01:05:22.080 --> 01:05:28.530
that attaches to the GFP, that green fluorescent protein, but that thing is attached to a magnetic bead.

1000
01:05:29.292 --> 01:05:29.612
Okay.

1001
01:05:29.692 --> 01:05:35.702
Okay, and now with a magnetic field, I can rip only the ribosomes from the...

1002
01:05:36.988 --> 01:05:38.608
from the microglia, right?

1003
01:05:38.628 --> 01:05:41.169
Because the magnetic bead is something I can use a force on.

1004
01:05:41.229 --> 01:05:42.069
Right, right, right, right.

1005
01:05:42.189 --> 01:05:44.029
I am so in there.

1006
01:05:44.149 --> 01:05:48.030
And then I have, and the ribosome is going to have an mRNA attached, right?

1007
01:05:48.050 --> 01:05:49.771
Because it's in the middle of doing some job.

1008
01:05:49.831 --> 01:05:50.011
Right.

1009
01:05:50.131 --> 01:05:51.491
Now all of a sudden you like pick it up.

1010
01:05:51.511 --> 01:05:54.211
So it's like dragging the mRNA with it.

1011
01:05:54.452 --> 01:05:58.292
And then you're like, okay, now I'm going to sequence this mRNA.

1012
01:05:58.312 --> 01:05:58.472
Right.

1013
01:05:58.512 --> 01:06:06.374
That gives me an insight into the actual transcriptome of the immune cell rather than all of the mRNA in the immune cell.

1014
01:06:06.394 --> 01:06:06.854
That makes sense.

1015
01:06:06.874 --> 01:06:15.719
I'm actively looking at only the mRNA that is being transcribed into protein that's actually being put through this machinery.

1016
01:06:15.799 --> 01:06:16.019
Yes.

1017
01:06:16.380 --> 01:06:16.580
Yes.

1018
01:06:16.600 --> 01:06:16.780
Right?

1019
01:06:16.880 --> 01:06:19.061
I thought that's a really cool technique.

1020
01:06:19.201 --> 01:06:21.022
I just...

1021
01:06:21.443 --> 01:06:29.527
The way that folks think about this as the solution to the problem, because it makes sense.

1022
01:06:29.567 --> 01:06:34.030
You want to be able to know what is actively being translated into

1023
01:06:34.190 --> 01:06:34.430
Yeah.

1024
01:06:35.070 --> 01:06:35.291
Yes.

1025
01:06:35.791 --> 01:06:44.635
And so you need to be able to track, like in order to be able to validate, like what is your process by which you can actually do validation?

1026
01:06:45.755 --> 01:06:47.036
And it's a very clever way.

1027
01:06:47.096 --> 01:06:47.776
It's very clever.

1028
01:06:47.836 --> 01:06:48.937
It's like, just like do that.

1029
01:06:48.977 --> 01:06:49.157
Yeah.

1030
01:06:49.177 --> 01:06:50.938
Basically tag the factory.

1031
01:06:51.158 --> 01:06:51.358
Right.

1032
01:06:51.558 --> 01:06:52.638
That's making the stuff.

1033
01:06:52.919 --> 01:06:53.099
Right.

1034
01:06:53.319 --> 01:06:58.221
And so any product and then drag the factory out and then see what's inside the factory.

1035
01:06:58.681 --> 01:06:58.881
Right.

1036
01:06:59.101 --> 01:07:02.023
So if you want only the cars in that particular location,

1037
01:07:02.743 --> 01:07:15.917
like let's say city and you don't want all the cars that are right uh being ridden around by the by the general population you just tag the factory drag out the factory no yeah that's oh that's really good you know that's really good

1038
01:07:16.712 --> 01:07:18.093
It was very cool.

1039
01:07:18.573 --> 01:07:19.954
So now let's get into...

1040
01:07:19.974 --> 01:07:21.355
It's funny they call it trap, too.

1041
01:07:21.555 --> 01:07:23.257
Yeah, they literally call it trap.

1042
01:07:23.317 --> 01:07:24.538
Yeah, yeah.

1043
01:07:24.658 --> 01:07:33.404
A lot of times with these acronyms, I'm pretty sure they start with the acronym, and then they're like, okay, what are the words... 100%.

1044
01:07:33.424 --> 01:07:35.365
...that can make it happen?

1045
01:07:35.405 --> 01:07:36.066
I like trap.

1046
01:07:36.266 --> 01:07:37.407
Yeah, okay.

1047
01:07:37.487 --> 01:07:39.668
And then they put down, okay, in the lab meeting, trap.

1048
01:07:39.728 --> 01:07:40.389
Translating?

1049
01:07:40.449 --> 01:07:41.890
Okay, that works, that works.

1050
01:07:41.930 --> 01:07:45.292
Ribosome, there's an R. Yeah, exactly.

1051
01:07:45.352 --> 01:07:46.233
So funny.

1052
01:07:47.340 --> 01:07:51.044
So let's get into what they actually found.

1053
01:07:51.104 --> 01:07:51.424
Okay.

1054
01:07:51.464 --> 01:07:51.704
Okay.

1055
01:07:52.145 --> 01:07:57.650
They focused on a transcription factor called PU1.

1056
01:07:58.150 --> 01:07:58.371
Okay.

1057
01:07:58.651 --> 01:08:01.734
A transcription factor is basically something that...

1058
01:08:03.422 --> 01:08:13.231
gets attached to the DNA, and promotes RNA polymerase, which is the factory that creates mRNA, to actually transcribe a gene.

1059
01:08:13.451 --> 01:08:17.015
Okay, so this is how we get from gene to mRNA to protein.

1060
01:08:17.075 --> 01:08:27.605
That first step, you need something called a transcription factor to get where that DNA is, bring in an RNA polymerase, and be like, all right, you need to start here, look for that start codon, and then...

1061
01:08:27.945 --> 01:08:29.305
and then start transcribing.

1062
01:08:29.325 --> 01:08:36.467
The transcription factor is like identifying where the things need to happen, where the polymerase needs to come in to do stuff.

1063
01:08:36.507 --> 01:08:39.868
Yes, and each gene usually has different transcription factors.

1064
01:08:39.908 --> 01:08:46.669
So this particular one, this gene, SPI1, has a transcription factor PU1.

1065
01:08:47.350 --> 01:08:49.970
And different genes have different transcription factors.

1066
01:08:50.290 --> 01:08:52.671
These transcription factors have different affinities.

1067
01:08:52.951 --> 01:08:54.931
There's some that'll bind immediately.

1068
01:08:55.232 --> 01:08:56.852
So even at low concentration...

1069
01:08:57.392 --> 01:08:59.714
it's going to find that bit of DNA and bind.

1070
01:09:00.015 --> 01:09:03.338
Those are usually the housekeeping genes that you can't live without.

1071
01:09:03.818 --> 01:09:09.504
Okay, those are the ones that like, it's like, how do I make sure that I stay alive as a cell?

1072
01:09:09.944 --> 01:09:13.327
Okay, then there's stuff that have to do with function, specific states.

1073
01:09:13.647 --> 01:09:15.629
Like this PU1 gene is...

1074
01:09:16.972 --> 01:09:22.534
the one that is controlling whether microglia are chilling or if they're doing the vigilante stuff, right?

1075
01:09:22.974 --> 01:09:32.698
And what they found was that when microglia were in the plaque environment, that plaque environment actively enforces low PU1.

1076
01:09:33.558 --> 01:09:34.579
It's very counterintuitive.

1077
01:09:34.819 --> 01:09:44.022
You would think that I want a lot of inflammation and a lot of policing around my plaques.

1078
01:09:44.082 --> 01:09:45.063
That's not what's happening.

1079
01:09:45.743 --> 01:09:59.790
What's happening is near the plaques, there's a down regulation of PU1, of that transcription factor, which is already a first clue that perhaps we don't fully understand this ecosystem of what's happening, right?

1080
01:09:59.810 --> 01:09:59.970
Mm-hmm.

1081
01:10:00.990 --> 01:10:14.466
So then they actually used a bunch of tools to figure out what is the signal transduction pathway that goes from I sense a myeloid, I sense my plaques, to I downregulate PU1.

1082
01:10:14.926 --> 01:10:21.013
And they used some knockout versions of mice to actually link all of these signal transduction pathways together.

1083
01:10:21.033 --> 01:10:21.694
Yeah.

1084
01:10:21.914 --> 01:10:27.981
They also showed that there is an upregulation of a T-cell-associated gene.

1085
01:10:28.481 --> 01:10:28.782
Okay.

1086
01:10:28.962 --> 01:10:29.262
Okay?

1087
01:10:29.883 --> 01:10:32.185
In those low PU1 populations.

1088
01:10:32.205 --> 01:10:34.708
So when there's low PU, right?

1089
01:10:34.768 --> 01:10:35.048
Yeah.

1090
01:10:35.088 --> 01:10:35.289
Right.

1091
01:10:35.649 --> 01:10:38.772
There's this, there's a T-cell gene.

1092
01:10:39.213 --> 01:10:40.735
There's a T-cell gene.

1093
01:10:41.195 --> 01:10:43.538
That now more frequently...

1094
01:10:44.298 --> 01:10:51.099
arises or proliferates because of that low population environment.

1095
01:10:51.119 --> 01:10:51.620
Exactly.

1096
01:10:51.940 --> 01:11:05.762
And what they think is happening is when you don't have that transcription factor or when you don't have a lot of that transcription factor, the chromatin around that part sort of relaxes and it exposes some of the genes.

1097
01:11:06.202 --> 01:11:08.383
And one of these genes that it exposes is CD28.

1098
01:11:08.423 --> 01:11:08.523
Yeah.

1099
01:11:09.503 --> 01:11:11.725
which is a neuroprotective master switch.

1100
01:11:12.065 --> 01:11:15.068
You might recognize CD28 from our Nobel Prize videos.

1101
01:11:15.088 --> 01:11:16.329
I was literally going to say.

1102
01:11:16.449 --> 01:11:25.977
Okay, CD28 is the gene that sort of regulates T cells from becoming normal T cells to T regulatory cells, right?

1103
01:11:26.177 --> 01:11:34.224
So that same gene, that same part of the gene is also having a role in microglia in the brain.

1104
01:11:34.244 --> 01:11:36.246
That's actually crazy.

1105
01:11:36.506 --> 01:11:46.289
So it's like the brain is, these cells are borrowing a motif from innate immunity elsewhere in the body and saying, well, I can actually use this for my own gains over here.

1106
01:11:46.329 --> 01:11:46.829
Right, right.

1107
01:11:46.950 --> 01:11:51.511
For this function, which ultimately sort of generates this neuroprotective master switch.

1108
01:11:51.711 --> 01:11:52.051
Yeah.

1109
01:11:52.191 --> 01:11:57.433
And so the idea is because if we come back at it, because I just want to make sure I'm tracking here.

1110
01:11:57.493 --> 01:11:57.733
Yeah.

1111
01:12:07.775 --> 01:12:15.420
microglia is, we don't want it when it's close to these plaque regions, it is less active.

1112
01:12:15.580 --> 01:12:19.722
Yeah, the PU1 is less active.

1113
01:12:19.762 --> 01:12:21.583
There's not enough PU1 in the cell.

1114
01:12:21.904 --> 01:12:27.247
Right, and because of that, that induces... Yeah, then the chromatin sort of relaxes.

1115
01:12:27.747 --> 01:12:32.070
And now parts of the DNA get exposed, and one of the parts that gets exposed is the CD28.

1116
01:12:32.090 --> 01:12:32.690
And that one is sort of...

1117
01:12:36.032 --> 01:12:38.054
This is that neuroprotective master switch.

1118
01:12:38.074 --> 01:12:38.794
Master switch.

1119
01:12:38.814 --> 01:12:39.775
Which is so like we can start.

1120
01:12:39.955 --> 01:12:41.437
It's like the Tylenol button.

1121
01:12:41.637 --> 01:12:43.538
It's like go fix and make all my problems go away.

1122
01:12:43.919 --> 01:12:44.439
Right?

1123
01:12:44.619 --> 01:12:49.243
And because of that low PU, it is what helps to release more of that.

1124
01:12:49.283 --> 01:12:49.563
Yeah.

1125
01:12:49.703 --> 01:12:54.287
And so what you don't want to happen is that process to get.

1126
01:12:56.261 --> 01:13:00.927
prevented because that is potentially then what is causing the neurodegeneration.

1127
01:13:01.047 --> 01:13:01.467
Exactly.

1128
01:13:01.487 --> 01:13:05.072
Because we're not basically releasing the Tylenol response.

1129
01:13:05.572 --> 01:13:05.733
Yeah.

1130
01:13:05.993 --> 01:13:06.193
Yeah.

1131
01:13:06.493 --> 01:13:08.436
And so exactly.

1132
01:13:08.456 --> 01:13:13.742
That master switch is the switch that is controlling the cell fate of these microglia.

1133
01:13:14.243 --> 01:13:16.085
That's turning it vigilante janitor.

1134
01:13:16.105 --> 01:13:16.946
That's okay.

1135
01:13:17.046 --> 01:13:17.606
You know?

1136
01:13:17.747 --> 01:13:18.788
Yeah.

1137
01:13:18.968 --> 01:13:29.718
And so if we can control that and we can have therapies that now that we understand this entire chain of all of the stuff that's happening, we can actually, you know, maybe do something.

1138
01:13:29.919 --> 01:13:30.099
Right.

1139
01:13:30.259 --> 01:13:30.719
Right?

1140
01:13:31.040 --> 01:13:35.884
And so these microglia are now, you know, they're calling it the Tregs of the brain.

1141
01:13:35.904 --> 01:13:36.045
Yeah.

1142
01:13:36.605 --> 01:13:42.747
T-Rex being, again, the thing that won these three scientists the Nobel Prize.

1143
01:13:42.787 --> 01:13:43.968
The military police.

1144
01:13:44.028 --> 01:13:44.588
Yes.

1145
01:13:44.628 --> 01:13:46.208
The police of the police, right?

1146
01:13:46.228 --> 01:13:54.951
The system by which that regulates the things that regulate your body can in and of itself break down.

1147
01:13:55.111 --> 01:13:55.612
Exactly.

1148
01:13:55.932 --> 01:14:02.054
And maybe that's what's happening in these Alzheimer's brains, which is causing these runaway effects that we see as symptoms.

1149
01:14:02.654 --> 01:14:04.395
but maybe this is the cause, right?

1150
01:14:04.415 --> 01:14:05.896
This is, or one of the causes.

1151
01:14:06.056 --> 01:14:09.778
Obviously Alzheimer's is extremely complicated, right?

1152
01:14:09.858 --> 01:14:13.240
And there's probably multifaceted genes that are happening all in an environment.

1153
01:14:13.520 --> 01:14:18.583
But, you know, step by step, we're getting closer to understanding what is really going on.

1154
01:14:19.103 --> 01:14:22.085
And they are called the Tregs of the brain because it's very similar.

1155
01:14:22.105 --> 01:14:25.287
They've got a very small population, just like regulatory T cells.

1156
01:14:26.187 --> 01:14:31.250
Dominant suppressive effects, so they suppress immune responses, just like the Tregs.

1157
01:14:31.590 --> 01:14:33.771
And then they're also dependent on the CD28.

1158
01:14:33.811 --> 01:14:34.552
The same gene.

1159
01:14:34.592 --> 01:14:34.772
Yeah.

1160
01:14:35.092 --> 01:14:36.153
The same gene is in both.

1161
01:14:36.633 --> 01:14:38.674
Right?

1162
01:14:38.694 --> 01:14:45.919
I understand the connection to T-Rex because the deep dive we did for the Nobel Prize, we went really, really deep on.

1163
01:14:46.259 --> 01:14:51.682
And it is definitely worth watching in the context of – we have so many throwback connections to past episodes in this one.

1164
01:14:52.223 --> 01:15:08.484
Because I can now much more intuitively translate in my head the idea of it being Tregs of the brain because of understanding the function of regulatory T cells in the immune response.

1165
01:15:09.665 --> 01:15:18.652
And why a breakdown in the regulatory T cells can sort of be a driver for problems that we see arise.

1166
01:15:18.892 --> 01:15:20.113
So you can map.

1167
01:15:20.493 --> 01:15:24.476
It's a very direct map to this problem set.

1168
01:15:24.556 --> 01:15:27.538
Just in terms of the framework of how to think about it.

1169
01:15:27.778 --> 01:15:30.080
Obviously understanding it's a combinatorial problem set.

1170
01:15:30.100 --> 01:15:31.621
There's multiple blah, blah, blahs.

1171
01:15:31.661 --> 01:15:32.321
Exactly, yeah.

1172
01:15:32.341 --> 01:15:33.382
But very, very interesting.

1173
01:15:33.382 --> 01:15:34.582
But it is very cool.

1174
01:15:34.602 --> 01:15:38.164
And they use not only mouse models, they also had human brain tissue.

1175
01:15:38.404 --> 01:15:38.684
Okay.

1176
01:15:39.024 --> 01:15:44.086
And the same results were in the human brain tissue, which is very important.

1177
01:15:44.166 --> 01:15:46.727
Obviously, you can't do the in vivo effects and things like that.

1178
01:15:47.148 --> 01:15:47.648
Sure, sure.

1179
01:15:47.968 --> 01:15:55.831
But on the tissue, as much as you can sort of express one thing, express the other thing, all of this stuff tracks, even in humans, right?

1180
01:15:56.351 --> 01:16:00.033
The one really cool thing that I thought they did was they used hippocampal tissue,

1181
01:16:00.713 --> 01:16:04.274
And they looked at something called LTP, which is long-term potentiation.

1182
01:16:04.654 --> 01:16:11.835
This is the idea that synapses will grow and shrink based on how the neurons are talking to one another.

1183
01:16:11.895 --> 01:16:16.156
This is the physical mechanism by which we learn.

1184
01:16:16.476 --> 01:16:24.657
Like when we say the connections are strengthening, literally what's happening is the size of the synapses, the connections, is getting bigger and smaller.

1185
01:16:24.677 --> 01:16:29.118
It's increasing in surface area, and that's causing the connection to get strengthened.

1186
01:16:29.378 --> 01:16:33.123
This is something that doesn't happen in Alzheimer's.

1187
01:16:33.924 --> 01:16:34.806
Okay.

1188
01:16:34.906 --> 01:16:45.941
So what they did was they used these brain slices, and they showed that if they have these manipulations where they down-regulate PU1, and then the CD28 comes out and stuff like that, you can restore...

1189
01:16:46.682 --> 01:16:47.503
this LTP.

1190
01:16:47.543 --> 01:16:58.713
You can restore this ability of the hippocampus to start forming connections and have a dynamic way of expanding connections, contracting connections, so on and so forth.

1191
01:16:58.893 --> 01:16:59.854
That is very intriguing.

1192
01:16:59.894 --> 01:17:03.798
So there was a mechanistic link here to straight up learning.

1193
01:17:04.098 --> 01:17:04.318
Right.

1194
01:17:04.539 --> 01:17:06.721
That is tied to this process.

1195
01:17:06.901 --> 01:17:10.864
And the hippocampus is the center for consolidation of memories.

1196
01:17:11.525 --> 01:17:11.745
right?

1197
01:17:12.125 --> 01:17:15.968
And the access to the long-term memories and things like that, right?

1198
01:17:16.308 --> 01:17:25.474
So having this happen in hippocampal slices is also super, super important to show that, you know, this could be a target for therapies in the future.

1199
01:17:25.955 --> 01:17:28.877
And because, you know, the idea would be you want to try to target

1200
01:17:29.757 --> 01:17:51.892
uh to the lowest level of abstraction possible yeah um and because of like this again analogy of t-rex for the brain this seems to be an interesting place to target because it has so many derivative like it's like it's like it's at the foundation and then that is going to impact processes that happen at a higher higher orders and all that so that that is interesting yeah

1201
01:17:51.892 --> 01:17:52.432
Yeah, yeah.

1202
01:17:52.452 --> 01:17:58.436
So now when we look at translational horizons, it's promising, but we have to be very, very careful, okay?

1203
01:17:58.896 --> 01:18:02.699
One way to think about it was, okay, what if we just, okay, it depends on CD28, right?

1204
01:18:02.959 --> 01:18:06.181
What if we just, like, stimulate CD28 and we boost these populations?

1205
01:18:06.381 --> 01:18:06.801
Yep.

1206
01:18:07.722 --> 01:18:10.105
That sounds simple, and biology is never that simple.

1207
01:18:10.125 --> 01:18:17.855
There's actually this really famous disaster that happened in 2006 when it went to phase one trials of doing exactly this.

1208
01:18:18.496 --> 01:18:20.479
This wasn't in the brain, but this was in the body.

1209
01:18:20.819 --> 01:18:23.483
They were trying to stimulate CD28 to get...

1210
01:18:25.265 --> 01:18:41.785
the autoimmunity to go away and things like that get the t-rex to come back um this is called the tgn 1412 disaster six patients it resulted in cytokine release syndrome in all six volunteers multiple organ failures because basically all the t-cells just got activated

1211
01:18:42.646 --> 01:18:51.296
And then it didn't care that usually the T cell is presented with some kind of antigen and then they just like started acting.

1212
01:18:51.556 --> 01:18:52.757
And it was really bad, right?

1213
01:18:53.038 --> 01:18:58.404
So we have to be very careful with messing with the immune system, right?

1214
01:18:59.044 --> 01:19:09.719
And you could have something called specific antibodies, like bispecific antibodies, where it targets not just CD28, but it also targets something that is very specific to microglia.

1215
01:19:10.019 --> 01:19:10.860
And you need both.

1216
01:19:11.080 --> 01:19:15.647
It's an and, not an or, that, like, makes this thing... Yeah, activate.

1217
01:19:15.807 --> 01:19:16.247
Activate.

1218
01:19:16.267 --> 01:19:16.368
Yep.

1219
01:19:16.388 --> 01:19:16.528
Yep.

1220
01:19:16.848 --> 01:19:18.089
Perhaps that's one way of doing it.

1221
01:19:18.109 --> 01:19:21.272
You got to have brain penetrating vectors that go through the blood brain barrier.

1222
01:19:21.592 --> 01:19:24.915
That's always like if now something's in my brain.

1223
01:19:25.055 --> 01:19:33.402
I don't like the brain is if that thing also matches in shape to some other random thing in my neurons, then what's going to happen?

1224
01:19:33.762 --> 01:19:37.965
So like trying to create translational therapies.

1225
01:19:38.826 --> 01:19:43.993
is one thing, and that's its own bag of worms.

1226
01:19:45.035 --> 01:19:48.560
But understanding the mechanism itself is the first step, right?

1227
01:19:48.580 --> 01:19:53.987
The fundamental science needs to happen first before we start saying, okay, what part of this pathway can I poke?

1228
01:19:54.067 --> 01:19:54.228
Okay.

1229
01:19:54.548 --> 01:19:59.531
We have to first define the treasure map, and then we can figure out the plan of how we're going to go get the treasure.

1230
01:19:59.852 --> 01:20:10.139
And now we have an interesting treasure map that is specifically to this issue that, again, also might have insights that are connected to other related topics.

1231
01:20:10.179 --> 01:20:15.702
This is such a great piggyback off of our T-Rex episode.

1232
01:20:15.802 --> 01:20:15.962
Yeah.

1233
01:20:15.982 --> 01:20:16.083
Yeah.

1234
01:20:17.183 --> 01:20:21.648
Yeah, I think it's a pretty good story, right?

1235
01:20:23.010 --> 01:20:25.052
It shows just how complicated the brain is.

1236
01:20:25.232 --> 01:20:25.813
Right, right.

1237
01:20:26.313 --> 01:20:27.875
Like the brain is not just neurons.

1238
01:20:27.895 --> 01:20:28.896
It's blood vessels.

1239
01:20:28.956 --> 01:20:29.797
It's immune cells.

1240
01:20:30.078 --> 01:20:33.581
Those immune cells have been there since forever, since we were born, right?

1241
01:20:33.702 --> 01:20:36.324
All of these microglia are just hanging out in our brain.

1242
01:20:37.400 --> 01:20:39.022
And we're not getting any new ones.

1243
01:20:39.062 --> 01:20:39.763
Right, right.

1244
01:20:39.964 --> 01:20:42.968
Because they can't go through the blood grain barrier.

1245
01:20:42.988 --> 01:20:43.488
Right, right.

1246
01:20:43.589 --> 01:20:45.411
Because it stops at some point in that development.

1247
01:20:45.451 --> 01:20:45.691
Yeah.

1248
01:20:45.972 --> 01:20:47.914
It's so good.

1249
01:20:47.974 --> 01:20:48.936
This is so good.

1250
01:20:48.956 --> 01:20:53.802
So this was a – and kudos to another multi-institution –

1251
01:20:54.343 --> 01:20:54.583
Yes.

1252
01:20:54.643 --> 01:20:55.384
Nature paper.

1253
01:20:55.424 --> 01:20:55.584
Yeah.

1254
01:20:55.604 --> 01:20:57.245
Multi-institution, multi-country.

1255
01:20:57.305 --> 01:20:58.045
Multi-country.

1256
01:20:58.325 --> 01:20:58.925
Yeah.

1257
01:20:59.145 --> 01:21:08.650
You know, again, with Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, Max Planck Institute for Biology of Aging and the University of Cologne.

1258
01:21:08.710 --> 01:21:11.492
I mean, this is again, people are working really hard.

1259
01:21:11.512 --> 01:21:13.713
Like, obviously, we lose a lot of people, too.

1260
01:21:14.033 --> 01:21:34.882
yeah alzheimer's every year yeah it is uh it's the next frontier it's the next frontier um it's going to be hugely impactful if we can sort of take this and continue to iterate to the point where hopefully we again we don't want to have another tn you know yeah disaster disaster but we have better tools now we have better understandings

1261
01:21:35.302 --> 01:21:39.846
Yeah, and I think we learned a lot from that disaster on how to start phase one trials for immunology.

1262
01:21:39.886 --> 01:21:46.932
Maybe we do a lot more testing in vitro before going in vivo into a human at least, you know.

1263
01:21:47.473 --> 01:21:57.261
But the other thing with this kind of stuff is it's incredibly hard to, because this is such a unique sort of late stage evolution, right?

1264
01:21:58.475 --> 01:21:58.956
problem.

1265
01:21:59.456 --> 01:22:11.688
And what I mean by that is a lot of these problems with Alzheimer's is something that happens because the brain, the human brain, is the most recent organ to have evolved, right?

1266
01:22:12.308 --> 01:22:18.494
A lot of the mutations that are different, that make us different from the chimpanzees, have to do with neurodevelopment.

1267
01:22:18.954 --> 01:22:19.215
I mean...

1268
01:22:20.055 --> 01:22:21.175
Ah, done, right?

1269
01:22:21.395 --> 01:22:32.838
But what that also means is the locations, the part of our genome and the part of our brain that is so new also means there's a lot of stuff that can go wrong, right?

1270
01:22:33.159 --> 01:22:34.779
Because it's kind of by design.

1271
01:22:35.039 --> 01:22:37.120
We're still evolving this thing, right?

1272
01:22:37.160 --> 01:22:43.241
All of a sudden, we kind of put evolution on pause because survival of the fittest isn't the same in the classical sense anymore.

1273
01:22:43.261 --> 01:22:46.002
We're not having 20 kids and then the smartest ones...

1274
01:22:46.422 --> 01:22:57.072
Like, you know, we're a completely different animal now, where the evolution that's happening in humans is now not something that is in Darwin's origin of the species.

1275
01:22:57.392 --> 01:22:59.234
But the genetics doesn't know that.

1276
01:22:59.434 --> 01:22:59.634
Right.

1277
01:22:59.794 --> 01:23:00.014
Right.

1278
01:23:00.395 --> 01:23:01.976
Our genome doesn't know that.

1279
01:23:02.236 --> 01:23:04.919
And so the mutation rate is still really high.

1280
01:23:05.359 --> 01:23:05.719
And the...

1281
01:23:06.520 --> 01:23:10.908
the genome is still kind of experimenting with what the brain is doing, right?

1282
01:23:11.730 --> 01:23:14.535
And that's going to cause all of these failure mechanisms.

1283
01:23:14.655 --> 01:23:16.558
So it's really hard to find...

1284
01:23:17.453 --> 01:23:25.600
You know, you can't just, with heart disease, you can sometimes even take a pig's heart, put it into a human, and it'll work, right?

1285
01:23:25.640 --> 01:23:27.462
You can't do that with the brain.

1286
01:23:27.482 --> 01:23:28.563
Yeah, right, right, right, right.

1287
01:23:28.723 --> 01:23:29.023
Right?

1288
01:23:29.103 --> 01:23:38.812
It's like... That's actually a really good... Like, it's, you know, it's because it's by design the most recent organ, it's going to have these failure modes that are just way more complicated than normal.

1289
01:23:41.239 --> 01:24:05.285
and also the accessibility problem it's kind of hard to get in there as compared to the rest of the body that's just another layer of complexity three great stories this week we touched on a review of 3i Atlas which was the most demanded story I hope you're happy now another wicked reference

1290
01:24:07.385 --> 01:24:11.570
And it is very similar to what we said in our original coverage of it.

1291
01:24:11.750 --> 01:24:11.970
Yeah.

1292
01:24:12.111 --> 01:24:12.731
It basically.

1293
01:24:12.751 --> 01:24:13.512
It's a weird comment.

1294
01:24:13.632 --> 01:24:16.596
It's panned out exactly the way we described it the first time.

1295
01:24:16.936 --> 01:24:18.678
What are the things that were going to be weird?

1296
01:24:18.979 --> 01:24:21.281
What were the areas that still needed more information?

1297
01:24:21.301 --> 01:24:21.662
Yeah.

1298
01:24:21.702 --> 01:24:25.967
We discussed about why we would be able to get stuff on from the Mars orbiters.

1299
01:24:26.327 --> 01:24:27.689
Why it wouldn't be that good.

1300
01:24:27.709 --> 01:24:27.849
Yeah.

1301
01:24:27.869 --> 01:24:28.049
We.

1302
01:24:28.049 --> 01:24:29.370
We talked about how it was not good.

1303
01:24:29.490 --> 01:24:33.574
Even the guys were like, guys, you guys know it's not going to be that good, right?

1304
01:24:33.594 --> 01:24:34.375
We brought it up.

1305
01:24:34.395 --> 01:24:35.876
This was months ago at this point.

1306
01:24:35.976 --> 01:24:38.859
But again, still so much to be learned.

1307
01:24:38.999 --> 01:24:39.219
Yeah.

1308
01:24:39.620 --> 01:24:42.903
We followed that up with the fingerprint story, which is so clever.

1309
01:24:42.923 --> 01:24:43.704
Yeah, that's clever.

1310
01:24:44.064 --> 01:24:45.365
That one is this clever.

1311
01:24:45.485 --> 01:24:48.588
We can now pull fingerprints off of fired bullet casings.

1312
01:24:48.648 --> 01:24:49.289
Yeah.

1313
01:24:49.629 --> 01:24:51.951
And it works retroactively.

1314
01:24:52.612 --> 01:24:53.172
Old stuff.

1315
01:24:54.110 --> 01:24:55.752
Does works for that too.

1316
01:24:55.772 --> 01:24:59.417
So at least 16 months, at least 16 months.

1317
01:24:59.778 --> 01:25:00.839
And they, I don't know.

1318
01:25:00.879 --> 01:25:01.980
We haven't pushed it.

1319
01:25:02.141 --> 01:25:03.543
And they're going to push it.

1320
01:25:03.563 --> 01:25:04.023
Oh, there are.

1321
01:25:04.043 --> 01:25:04.243
Yeah.

1322
01:25:04.284 --> 01:25:05.385
They're going to push it.

1323
01:25:05.565 --> 01:25:10.231
And then we finally ended with a great story about a better understanding of the different States.

1324
01:25:11.353 --> 01:25:27.713
that are helping us better understand how Alzheimer's, sort of the process by which it begins and a potential pathway for us to think about therapeutics to try to address what is one of the most important,

1325
01:25:28.053 --> 01:25:32.455
uh, prevalent neurodegenerative diseases that we're seeing in the human population.

1326
01:25:32.975 --> 01:25:35.316
Uh, I'm ready for some good food this week.

1327
01:25:35.877 --> 01:25:37.157
Uh, I'm going to eat a lot.

1328
01:25:37.838 --> 01:25:44.040
Thanksgiving is always, uh, you know, um, my birthday is the same week as Thanksgiving.

1329
01:25:44.180 --> 01:25:53.104
And so it's always a little bit of, uh, uh, I have to be thankful when we're supposed to be celebrating me.

1330
01:25:53.425 --> 01:25:53.685
Right.

1331
01:25:53.705 --> 01:25:54.025
Yeah.

1332
01:25:55.242 --> 01:25:55.823
That's funny.

1333
01:25:56.103 --> 01:25:58.306
Like, why am I, this week is supposed to be about me.

1334
01:25:58.706 --> 01:25:59.407
But I get food.

1335
01:25:59.427 --> 01:26:01.009
They should be thankful for you.

1336
01:26:01.029 --> 01:26:02.991
That's exactly right.

1337
01:26:04.413 --> 01:26:05.754
But it'll be good.

1338
01:26:05.975 --> 01:26:06.956
I'm excited to travel.

1339
01:26:06.976 --> 01:26:08.237
You're going to have a little good time.

1340
01:26:08.257 --> 01:26:08.738
To Hawaii.

1341
01:26:08.818 --> 01:26:09.679
Good time in Hawaii.

1342
01:26:09.739 --> 01:26:10.460
That's going to be great.

1343
01:26:10.580 --> 01:26:14.685
After three weeks of rain here or whatever it was, we'll have to get to some nice weather for a little bit.

1344
01:26:14.705 --> 01:26:14.845
Yes.

1345
01:26:15.265 --> 01:26:39.865
um as always we really appreciate the listeners especially those of you who get to the banter at the end who reach us all the way here uh we are going to have a couple more episodes through the end of the year and we may do some best of coverage for the end of year wrap-up so if you're interested in us choosing our favorite stories from the year and doing like a huge

1346
01:26:40.465 --> 01:27:00.781
summary kind of top 10 top five kind of video in the comments wherever you see this put that we yeah if you made it this if you made it this far you know put some stuff in the comments yeah give us ideas for the next month yeah we we want to try to do something for the holidays we think we want to do top 10 or a top best of kind of list to wrap up the year

1347
01:27:01.598 --> 01:27:02.559
But let us know in the comments.

1348
01:27:03.599 --> 01:27:11.125
I'm your host, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury, for another fantastic episode.

1349
01:27:11.625 --> 01:27:13.887
This is From First Principles.
