WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.291 --> 00:00:09.333
Hello Internet, this is your captain speaking Lester Nare, joined by my co-host and our resident PhD as always, Krishna Chowdhury.

2
00:00:09.693 --> 00:00:18.575
This is from First Principles, where we talk about breaking science news and headlines so that you don't need a PhD to understand it.

3
00:00:19.195 --> 00:00:26.177
This week we're covering some fantastic stories, starting with, thought crimes are now illegal.

4
00:00:26.877 --> 00:00:29.620
as scientists discover how to read our inner thoughts.

5
00:00:30.100 --> 00:00:32.062
No, this is not a line from Minority Report.

6
00:00:32.402 --> 00:00:37.907
It is a new study out of Stanford, followed up by finding genes that make us human.

7
00:00:38.587 --> 00:00:49.637
Maybe we actually are just hairless apes, but with a twist, as new study on genes from UC San Diego is helping us understand what exactly makes us human.

8
00:00:50.277 --> 00:00:53.140
Third story, diamonds get an upgrade.

9
00:00:53.740 --> 00:01:05.543
This is the first story my wife has actually cared about as scientists in China are now able to grow stronger diamonds from the Center for High Pressure Science and Technology Advanced Research in Beijing.

10
00:01:06.064 --> 00:01:10.825
Hopefully this means we can stop exploiting the continent of Africa, but more at 11.

11
00:01:11.805 --> 00:01:20.854
And we will round out with our first retrospective as the UN designates 2025 the International Year of Quantum Mechanics.

12
00:01:21.254 --> 00:01:26.899
So we'll take a look back at the last 100 years of quantum and review how it all started.

13
00:01:27.380 --> 00:01:29.962
This is From First Principles.

14
00:01:44.730 --> 00:01:45.171
My friend.

15
00:01:46.332 --> 00:01:46.833
How's it going?

16
00:01:46.913 --> 00:01:47.313
How are you?

17
00:01:47.593 --> 00:01:48.214
Pretty good.

18
00:01:48.455 --> 00:01:49.155
Episode five.

19
00:01:49.275 --> 00:01:50.697
Yeah, we got some great stories today.

20
00:01:51.758 --> 00:01:53.280
I'm really excited about this first story.

21
00:01:53.721 --> 00:01:59.207
So the headline on this story coming out of Stanford, reading people's inner thoughts,

22
00:02:00.398 --> 00:02:02.980
Meaning thought crimes are now officially illegal.

23
00:02:03.320 --> 00:02:03.880
Yeah.

24
00:02:03.980 --> 00:02:06.301
As scientists discover how to read our inner thoughts.

25
00:02:07.222 --> 00:02:11.384
And this one is we got brain computer interfaces, brain implants.

26
00:02:12.925 --> 00:02:17.148
My deepest, darkest, darkest, private secrets are now accessible.

27
00:02:17.668 --> 00:02:19.389
Tell me what we got going on here.

28
00:02:20.427 --> 00:02:22.449
Yeah, this is a pretty crazy story.

29
00:02:24.130 --> 00:02:26.452
Inner thoughts, not just outer thoughts.

30
00:02:26.492 --> 00:02:28.213
Not stuff that we're saying out loud.

31
00:02:28.273 --> 00:02:34.999
This is stuff that we think about and we might not want anyone to know, right?

32
00:02:35.559 --> 00:02:36.540
Like I'm on the freeway.

33
00:02:36.620 --> 00:02:37.801
I get cut off by a car.

34
00:02:38.582 --> 00:02:39.362
I see who it is.

35
00:02:39.883 --> 00:02:40.383
Inner thoughts.

36
00:02:40.523 --> 00:02:40.784
Yeah.

37
00:02:41.344 --> 00:02:41.584
All right.

38
00:02:41.744 --> 00:02:43.304
Inner thoughts that I don't want anyone to know.

39
00:02:43.885 --> 00:02:47.605
But it turns out with this new tech, people might have access to it.

40
00:02:48.046 --> 00:02:48.146
OK.

41
00:02:48.166 --> 00:02:52.567
So there are some pretty big ethical dilemmas.

42
00:02:53.167 --> 00:02:53.587
Obviously.

43
00:02:53.787 --> 00:02:53.987
Right.

44
00:02:54.367 --> 00:02:57.888
But before we even get into that, let's talk about like why anybody would want to do this.

45
00:02:58.468 --> 00:03:01.589
OK. We don't want to be like Jeff Goldblum.

46
00:03:01.629 --> 00:03:04.890
Like you never you didn't think if you could should.

47
00:03:05.010 --> 00:03:05.250
Right.

48
00:03:05.290 --> 00:03:05.470
Right.

49
00:03:05.490 --> 00:03:05.650
Right.

50
00:03:05.670 --> 00:03:05.830
Right.

51
00:03:06.150 --> 00:03:06.370
Yeah.

52
00:03:06.570 --> 00:03:10.271
So one of the real problems is,

53
00:03:11.371 --> 00:03:20.294
in neuroscience is trying to understand the brain from a functional sense, from like a causal sense of like what brain regions are doing what.

54
00:03:20.814 --> 00:03:33.578
And on top of that, trying to get that understanding and try to help people with neurological disorders, with paralysis, with all sorts of like neural and cognitive impairments.

55
00:03:33.898 --> 00:03:34.098
Right.

56
00:03:34.838 --> 00:03:40.299
So there are people who have severe paralysis, who develop it later on in life.

57
00:03:40.759 --> 00:03:48.121
Things like ALS or brainstem stroke where they're completely left without control of their body.

58
00:03:48.621 --> 00:03:54.302
And they have this kind of locked in syndrome, you know, where they're like totally conscious of the world, but they can't interact with it.

59
00:03:54.322 --> 00:03:55.642
They can't communicate with anything.

60
00:03:56.123 --> 00:03:57.983
And so for something like that.

61
00:03:58.463 --> 00:04:02.266
you would like to have a way for them to communicate.

62
00:04:03.247 --> 00:04:06.330
And that's fundamentally where this study is coming from.

63
00:04:06.370 --> 00:04:08.411
That's the entry point for this research.

64
00:04:08.471 --> 00:04:19.580
Yes, that's the entry point where it's like, okay, can we use all of these technologies that we have with brain-computer interfaces and try to help people that have these kinds of severe debilitating paralysis?

65
00:04:20.381 --> 00:04:21.982
And what's interesting about this is...

66
00:04:23.143 --> 00:04:30.706
Many people might understand or know about BCIs primarily because of the company started by Elon Musk, Neuralink.

67
00:04:30.726 --> 00:04:31.406
Yeah, Neuralink.

68
00:04:31.546 --> 00:04:38.748
Which is arguably, there are other ones out there, but just in the mainstream, probably one of the more well-known use cases.

69
00:04:38.868 --> 00:04:42.149
Yeah, it's also probably the most aggressive in terms of its technology.

70
00:04:42.410 --> 00:04:42.630
Fair.

71
00:04:42.810 --> 00:04:43.050
Yeah.

72
00:04:43.250 --> 00:04:43.430
Fair.

73
00:04:44.130 --> 00:04:55.722
And so it's a similar space that we're operating in, but the study was primarily starting on focusing on like the medical entry point as opposed to the matrix where we download Jiu-Jitsu.

74
00:04:55.822 --> 00:04:56.263
Yeah, yeah.

75
00:04:56.323 --> 00:05:00.547
The point is not to try and like download your inner thoughts.

76
00:05:00.667 --> 00:05:05.272
The point is to try to get these people with severe paralysis and ability to communicate with the world.

77
00:05:05.672 --> 00:05:10.296
without having to resort to, like, really tedious avenues.

78
00:05:10.336 --> 00:05:19.363
Like, before, people used to use eye tracking because, like, sometimes if you're paralyzed from the, like, spinal cord down, basically, you can still have control over your eyes.

79
00:05:19.764 --> 00:05:23.447
So you can use those eyes as a signal for, like, what this person is trying.

80
00:05:23.467 --> 00:05:24.968
Like, you can train that person to, like...

81
00:05:25.408 --> 00:05:27.650
Say that, you know, certain eye movements mean something.

82
00:05:28.371 --> 00:05:35.177
There's also this thing called like sip and puff switches, which are like you have like two things, one where you sip, one where you puff.

83
00:05:35.578 --> 00:05:41.803
And then those are two different signals from which you can like control like two different sort of electronic thingies.

84
00:05:41.823 --> 00:05:43.785
You're basically communicating binary.

85
00:05:43.905 --> 00:05:44.145
Yeah.

86
00:05:44.246 --> 00:05:44.446
Yeah.

87
00:05:44.706 --> 00:05:48.692
And then that binary can get translated to like higher order communication.

88
00:05:49.052 --> 00:05:50.854
But you can imagine it's like super tedious.

89
00:05:50.935 --> 00:05:51.175
Right.

90
00:05:51.515 --> 00:05:59.506
And for somebody who maybe doesn't even have that kind of ability to like control their mouth muscles, then they're just totally out of the dark.

91
00:05:59.566 --> 00:05:59.787
Right.

92
00:06:00.307 --> 00:06:15.374
So one way, like the Holy Grail in this sort of thing is to bypass the entire active part of this communication and just go directly into somebody thinking what they're going to say and then have it be said.

93
00:06:15.654 --> 00:06:16.574
Think to action.

94
00:06:16.794 --> 00:06:17.254
Yes.

95
00:06:17.274 --> 00:06:18.595
Think straight to action.

96
00:06:18.615 --> 00:06:18.755
Right.

97
00:06:18.975 --> 00:06:20.176
And that's what this thing is doing.

98
00:06:20.236 --> 00:06:23.217
And it's actually pretty crazy the amount of tech that's involved here.

99
00:06:23.577 --> 00:06:36.366
It involves like first invasive electrophysiology, meaning like in the brain, you're putting in electrodes and you're listening to neurons inside the brain, not on the outside with a scalp.

100
00:06:36.526 --> 00:06:36.786
Okay.

101
00:06:36.986 --> 00:06:38.868
So this is not headgear that you can just put on.

102
00:06:38.888 --> 00:06:39.308
No, no.

103
00:06:39.348 --> 00:06:40.148
This is invasive.

104
00:06:40.168 --> 00:06:40.729
You have to go.

105
00:06:40.769 --> 00:06:40.909
Yeah.

106
00:06:40.929 --> 00:06:44.051
You got to bore a hole and you got to stick a electrode down there.

107
00:06:44.391 --> 00:06:44.632
Okay.

108
00:06:44.972 --> 00:06:49.455
And then the second is you've got this input of all of your brain.

109
00:06:50.872 --> 00:06:55.936
signals from all the neurons that are in whatever cortex that you put the electrode in.

110
00:06:55.976 --> 00:06:57.637
In this case, it's the motor cortex.

111
00:06:58.197 --> 00:07:02.480
And then that input needs to get translated into the output communication.

112
00:07:02.540 --> 00:07:02.700
Right.

113
00:07:03.201 --> 00:07:06.963
And this is where they used our favorite thing, artificial intelligence.

114
00:07:06.983 --> 00:07:07.644
All right.

115
00:07:07.764 --> 00:07:08.565
AI is back.

116
00:07:08.605 --> 00:07:08.865
Yeah.

117
00:07:09.666 --> 00:07:13.030
In this case, it's a very specific artificial intelligence paradigm.

118
00:07:13.070 --> 00:07:16.034
It's really just machine learning where they're learning from the input.

119
00:07:16.074 --> 00:07:20.540
How do I map from input to an output kind of vocabulary and communication?

120
00:07:20.600 --> 00:07:24.805
You have an input that's in brain language, and we need to output it into action language.

121
00:07:24.905 --> 00:07:26.105
Yeah, exactly.

122
00:07:26.446 --> 00:07:28.746
So the study goes as follows.

123
00:07:28.766 --> 00:07:33.928
They used four patients that have this kind of debilitating paralysis.

124
00:07:34.749 --> 00:07:38.890
And what they did was they targeted the motor cortex and they stuck in these electrodes.

125
00:07:39.390 --> 00:07:43.412
Now, these electrodes can be anywhere from like 100 little tiny electrodes.

126
00:07:43.432 --> 00:07:47.513
So electrodes are just like tiny little pieces of silicon that are connected to by wires.

127
00:07:47.533 --> 00:07:48.774
And they're connected.

128
00:07:49.974 --> 00:07:55.299
When you stick it inside the brain, neurons are fundamentally electrical units.

129
00:07:56.200 --> 00:08:01.064
They're like cells that use electricity as their bread and butter.

130
00:08:01.284 --> 00:08:01.545
Okay?

131
00:08:01.805 --> 00:08:11.153
So whenever they talk to one another, they create these things called spikes, action potentials, which can be registered on your electrode as a tiny little spike.

132
00:08:11.474 --> 00:08:11.734
Okay?

133
00:08:12.254 --> 00:08:17.138
And then from that spike, these spikes last like, you know, like one millisecond to five millisecond.

134
00:08:17.158 --> 00:08:19.801
They're extremely, extremely short.

135
00:08:20.261 --> 00:08:24.745
But there's like thousands of neurons in your brain that are like talking all the time.

136
00:08:25.285 --> 00:08:32.151
So you can listen to all of them and you can listen to this like aggregate activity sort of of like all the neurons and where they are.

137
00:08:32.211 --> 00:08:34.093
Like, you know, when you put in the electrode, there's going to be...

138
00:08:35.113 --> 00:08:42.878
There's going to be multiple electrodes along some axis and you know from your computer when you plug it in which electrode corresponds to which.

139
00:08:42.938 --> 00:08:49.042
And then you have some sort of like map along this axis of like where the activity is in each time bin.

140
00:08:49.182 --> 00:08:49.822
In a time series.

141
00:08:50.222 --> 00:08:52.223
In a time series kind of thing, you have like 100.

142
00:08:52.483 --> 00:08:57.345
Let's say you have 124 little silicon dots.

143
00:08:57.645 --> 00:09:01.446
Then each of those 124 silicon dots is going to register some amount of activity.

144
00:09:01.866 --> 00:09:03.287
And then you can chunk it up.

145
00:09:03.307 --> 00:09:08.749
In this case, they chunked it up into about like 10 millisecond, 20 millisecond time series.

146
00:09:08.909 --> 00:09:10.709
So it's at 100 hertz.

147
00:09:10.729 --> 00:09:12.190
100 data points a minute.

148
00:09:12.490 --> 00:09:13.210
Sorry, a second.

149
00:09:13.790 --> 00:09:16.931
And then you get like 100...

150
00:09:18.632 --> 00:09:40.558
data points a second yes and then each data point is an array of like what is the activity in each of the things okay there's this really high fidelity data yep right yep it's a lot of data the point is we're getting a very we're recording uh a wide spectrum of data points in time at a very small time interval yeah which which means that we're not looking at

151
00:09:41.538 --> 00:09:51.441
TV resolution from 1990, we have 4K Ultra HD as the analogy here in terms of how robust Yeah, exactly.

152
00:09:51.501 --> 00:09:53.142
What the input data is that we're getting.

153
00:09:53.182 --> 00:09:59.904
Yeah, I mean, in this sense, like EEG, like the stuff that's on your head, that stuff's like radio compared to this 4K.

154
00:09:59.944 --> 00:10:00.204
Got it.

155
00:10:00.324 --> 00:10:00.544
Right.

156
00:10:00.564 --> 00:10:05.406
Like here you're going into the brain when you when you work with like EEG and stuff that's on the brain.

157
00:10:05.846 --> 00:10:07.986
You've got this really annoying skull.

158
00:10:08.327 --> 00:10:08.687
Yeah.

159
00:10:08.747 --> 00:10:09.787
That's in the middle of everything.

160
00:10:09.807 --> 00:10:12.268
I was talking to someone about this the other day randomly skull diffraction.

161
00:10:12.468 --> 00:10:12.948
Yeah.

162
00:10:12.968 --> 00:10:15.609
So when you're trying to like read like the skull is of this layer.

163
00:10:15.709 --> 00:10:15.889
Yeah.

164
00:10:15.909 --> 00:10:19.430
The skull is this massive layer of bone and fat and skin.

165
00:10:19.910 --> 00:10:25.072
And so, you know, the neurons, they talk at, you know, one millisecond intervals.

166
00:10:25.872 --> 00:10:29.055
All of that signal is going to get completely filtered out by the skull.

167
00:10:29.075 --> 00:10:32.579
You're not going to hear any individual neurons or even chatter at that frequency.

168
00:10:32.599 --> 00:10:32.999
It makes sense.

169
00:10:33.019 --> 00:10:35.942
The skull basically acts like a low pass filter.

170
00:10:36.283 --> 00:10:36.543
Okay.

171
00:10:36.663 --> 00:10:37.904
All of the high pass signal.

172
00:10:38.085 --> 00:10:41.048
I mean, all the higher frequency signal just gets filtered out.

173
00:10:41.168 --> 00:10:41.308
Yep.

174
00:10:41.468 --> 00:10:47.290
So you really need to go inside the brain to listen to this kind of data.

175
00:10:47.530 --> 00:10:53.572
Maybe, uh, maybe, uh, God decided it wouldn't be a great idea for people to be able to read your thoughts.

176
00:10:53.612 --> 00:10:54.332
Yeah.

177
00:10:54.512 --> 00:10:54.872
Yeah.

178
00:10:54.912 --> 00:10:55.792
Yeah.

179
00:10:55.812 --> 00:10:56.292
Yeah.

180
00:10:56.352 --> 00:10:56.812
Yeah.

181
00:10:56.893 --> 00:11:01.054
Well, I don't, I don't even think God like thought that we would, we would be getting this far.

182
00:11:01.094 --> 00:11:01.454
Right.

183
00:11:01.574 --> 00:11:05.275
If God was behind evolution, he was just like, okay, we, the brain is great.

184
00:11:05.355 --> 00:11:05.695
Yeah.

185
00:11:06.355 --> 00:11:08.536
Uh, we need to, we need to make the skull real thick.

186
00:11:09.636 --> 00:11:13.319
because the humans have no other advantage, right?

187
00:11:13.359 --> 00:11:14.340
We can't swim fast.

188
00:11:14.400 --> 00:11:16.281
We're not the strongest, but we got a good brain.

189
00:11:16.441 --> 00:11:22.425
So then evolution was just like, I'm going to encase this thing, and we're going to keep it safe.

190
00:11:22.925 --> 00:11:26.208
And then now we're so far advanced, we're like, yeah, let's get in there.

191
00:11:26.268 --> 00:11:28.269
Let's mess with the secret formula a little bit.

192
00:11:28.289 --> 00:11:29.290
Yeah, it's pretty crazy.

193
00:11:30.611 --> 00:11:31.231
But that makes sense.

194
00:11:31.351 --> 00:11:32.232
Yeah, yeah.

195
00:11:32.692 --> 00:11:33.713
So you got to really get in.

196
00:11:33.773 --> 00:11:36.074
And that's actually what Neuralink is doing too, right?

197
00:11:36.254 --> 00:11:37.996
The innovation of Neuralink is like,

198
00:11:38.776 --> 00:11:45.039
They were just like, no, in order to really get these kinds of brain computer interfaces where I can think and then I'll post an Instagram story.

199
00:11:45.560 --> 00:11:45.780
Right.

200
00:11:45.920 --> 00:11:46.860
Yep.

201
00:11:47.801 --> 00:11:49.101
I need to get inside the brain.

202
00:11:49.141 --> 00:11:51.443
So they also they bore a hole in the skull.

203
00:11:52.043 --> 00:11:54.984
It's about the size of a like a nickel.

204
00:11:55.405 --> 00:12:00.207
And then they have like a chip that gets implanted with a bunch of electrodes that go in.

205
00:12:00.307 --> 00:12:02.648
And then we're listening to individual neurons from there.

206
00:12:02.809 --> 00:12:03.029
Right.

207
00:12:03.329 --> 00:12:03.489
Mm hmm.

208
00:12:04.069 --> 00:12:10.054
So so the unfortunately to really get into the brain, you really just got to get a guide into the brain.

209
00:12:10.214 --> 00:12:10.454
Yeah.

210
00:12:10.494 --> 00:12:10.654
Right.

211
00:12:10.674 --> 00:12:10.855
Yeah.

212
00:12:11.135 --> 00:12:12.196
You really got to get into the brain.

213
00:12:12.476 --> 00:12:12.596
Right.

214
00:12:12.616 --> 00:12:13.437
You got to go to the source.

215
00:12:13.717 --> 00:12:13.957
Yeah.

216
00:12:14.758 --> 00:12:19.061
So the way they train this thing is kind of interesting because like at the end of the day.

217
00:12:19.081 --> 00:12:20.382
OK, so now you have all this data.

218
00:12:20.822 --> 00:12:21.043
Right.

219
00:12:21.383 --> 00:12:22.143
But it's just going to be like.

220
00:12:23.264 --> 00:12:23.544
Right.

221
00:12:23.684 --> 00:12:25.185
It's effectively gibberish.

222
00:12:25.245 --> 00:12:28.325
Yeah, it's just effectively just like really high-frequency noise.

223
00:12:28.665 --> 00:12:33.466
If you plug it into a speaker, it's going to be like super high-frequency white noise effectively.

224
00:12:33.486 --> 00:12:37.587
There's going to be like little like pops, and that will be your individual neurons.

225
00:12:37.667 --> 00:12:38.748
Each electrode is doing this.

226
00:12:39.048 --> 00:12:44.469
So you need to find a way to take all that data and put it into words in English.

227
00:12:44.689 --> 00:12:44.829
Yes.

228
00:12:44.869 --> 00:12:45.129
Okay?

229
00:12:45.269 --> 00:12:46.029
In this case, English.

230
00:12:46.089 --> 00:12:47.330
But it could be anything.

231
00:12:47.350 --> 00:12:47.910
It could be anything.

232
00:12:53.672 --> 00:13:00.598
They were cued on a screen to attempt speech and also imagine speech.

233
00:13:00.878 --> 00:13:01.138
Okay.

234
00:13:01.339 --> 00:13:07.784
So by attempt speech, I mean, you don't want to say something, but you want to imagine your tongue moving.

235
00:13:07.804 --> 00:13:07.945
Mm-hmm.

236
00:13:08.745 --> 00:13:13.427
And like imagine your mouth moving to say something.

237
00:13:13.867 --> 00:13:17.949
And then imagine speech is like the kind of imagine speech where I can just like read.

238
00:13:18.209 --> 00:13:18.409
Yes.

239
00:13:18.749 --> 00:13:22.851
I just read and I'm like, you know, there's like this inner narrative of like what I'm reading.

240
00:13:23.231 --> 00:13:26.953
If you're one of those people that doesn't have an inner voice in your head, I'm sorry.

241
00:13:27.133 --> 00:13:30.375
Yeah, I guess we can't read your inner thoughts.

242
00:13:30.495 --> 00:13:32.896
You're protected from the thought police.

243
00:13:33.436 --> 00:13:33.736
Yeah.

244
00:13:33.856 --> 00:13:35.797
But it is a fun conversation in there sometimes.

245
00:13:36.051 --> 00:13:37.713
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

246
00:13:37.933 --> 00:13:45.419
Sometimes not what I want people to hear, but you know, so they had so they had the participants like choose a strategy.

247
00:13:45.760 --> 00:13:59.031
So either you do do this motoric inner speech where you like try to sort of imagine auditory movements and then there's like pure inner speech, which is just like just imagine hearing the sound like imagine sort of reading the sound in some sense, things like that.

248
00:13:59.612 --> 00:13:59.952
And then.

249
00:14:01.233 --> 00:14:06.316
So now we've got, you know, in machine learning all the time, you want the input and you want to match it to the output.

250
00:14:06.357 --> 00:14:09.519
And then the neural network in the middle is just going to figure it out.

251
00:14:09.599 --> 00:14:09.759
Yep.

252
00:14:09.879 --> 00:14:11.480
That's the magic of machine learning, right?

253
00:14:11.560 --> 00:14:21.727
It's like you don't actually have to tell the neural network how to figure it out because it'll do it by itself using the rules of backpropagation and this like loss that they come up with.

254
00:14:21.827 --> 00:14:22.567
I get what you're saying.

255
00:14:22.607 --> 00:14:25.669
We have two sides of the equation where we have known variables.

256
00:14:25.709 --> 00:14:26.890
Yeah, we have input and output.

257
00:14:27.010 --> 00:14:30.272
Because you've defined what the output is by saying either of these two types.

258
00:14:30.292 --> 00:14:31.752
Yeah, we're like, okay, imagine cat.

259
00:14:31.832 --> 00:14:32.813
They're going to imagine cat.

260
00:14:32.913 --> 00:14:34.293
Or they're going to imagine saying cat.

261
00:14:34.353 --> 00:14:34.514
Yes.

262
00:14:34.674 --> 00:14:36.494
There's going to be some neural thingy.

263
00:14:36.635 --> 00:14:36.815
Yes.

264
00:14:36.935 --> 00:14:41.157
And then the neural network is going to be like, okay, that neural thingy maps to cat.

265
00:14:41.957 --> 00:14:42.177
Right?

266
00:14:42.697 --> 00:14:48.040
And then it's going to adjust its weights in the middle to make that thing say cat.

267
00:14:48.440 --> 00:14:48.680
Got it.

268
00:14:48.720 --> 00:14:48.900
Right.

269
00:14:48.940 --> 00:14:52.322
That's how that's how neural networks train effectively.

270
00:14:52.642 --> 00:14:53.522
So that's what they did here.

271
00:14:54.623 --> 00:14:57.264
And they use like a bunch of different words.

272
00:14:58.384 --> 00:15:03.046
And at the end of the day, so the neural network itself, it's a recurrent neural network.

273
00:15:03.406 --> 00:15:09.389
This is like a predecessor of the transformer model, which is now very famous in ChatGPT and all these large language models.

274
00:15:09.509 --> 00:15:15.111
A recurrent neural network model has this thing called a hidden state, which is effectively like a memory.

275
00:15:15.511 --> 00:15:15.751
Okay.

276
00:15:16.112 --> 00:15:24.260
And that's why these these recurrent neural network models are really good at trying to sort of remember and figure out time series data.

277
00:15:24.520 --> 00:15:24.780
Got it.

278
00:15:24.800 --> 00:15:24.960
Okay.

279
00:15:25.240 --> 00:15:30.926
You can have these things called feed forward models where it's just like one layer of neurons talks to the next, talks to the next, talks to the next.

280
00:15:31.226 --> 00:15:32.788
This thing has a feedback loop.

281
00:15:32.888 --> 00:15:35.410
Instead of being just being a pure linear process.

282
00:15:35.430 --> 00:15:35.931
Feed forward.

283
00:15:36.031 --> 00:15:36.231
Right.

284
00:15:36.351 --> 00:15:36.831
Feed forward.

285
00:15:36.851 --> 00:15:36.972
Yeah.

286
00:15:36.992 --> 00:15:38.413
This thing has this back loop.

287
00:15:38.513 --> 00:15:39.333
Back propagation.

288
00:15:39.493 --> 00:15:39.754
Yeah.

289
00:15:39.794 --> 00:15:42.575
Back propagation is the rule with which we set weights.

290
00:15:42.835 --> 00:15:43.075
Okay.

291
00:15:43.095 --> 00:15:45.856
Not to be confused with a backwards connection.

292
00:15:46.056 --> 00:15:46.456
Understood.

293
00:15:46.536 --> 00:15:54.719
Which is like where it's going back into its own hidden state and trying to see, okay, did this output sort of make sense with this hidden interstate?

294
00:15:54.979 --> 00:16:04.223
And so it's like, it has this like, like sort of memory you can say, where now we can keep track of temporal sequences, like time sequences where it can keep track of the past.

295
00:16:04.903 --> 00:16:19.090
What's interesting about the transformer model is they had to build memory as a separate component of what we now see in like the latest chat GPT-5 and the latest thinking models, where if you open the little dropdown, you can actually see that inner dialogue.

296
00:16:19.310 --> 00:16:19.950
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

297
00:16:19.990 --> 00:16:22.292
But what you're, I think the point you're identifying is like.

298
00:16:22.312 --> 00:16:23.152
That's that chain of thought.

299
00:16:23.452 --> 00:16:24.353
chain of thought.

300
00:16:24.433 --> 00:16:24.653
Yeah.

301
00:16:24.833 --> 00:16:26.854
Which is, but it's, that's a different, it's a different thing.

302
00:16:27.994 --> 00:16:32.997
With recurrent, with a recurrent model, you get that hidden state out of the box.

303
00:16:33.037 --> 00:16:34.358
You don't have to sort of build.

304
00:16:34.398 --> 00:16:34.678
Yes.

305
00:16:34.758 --> 00:16:34.978
Yeah.

306
00:16:35.058 --> 00:16:36.259
It's like, it's like in it.

307
00:16:36.379 --> 00:16:36.619
Yeah.

308
00:16:36.639 --> 00:16:36.799
Yeah.

309
00:16:36.819 --> 00:16:40.201
There is, there is like a part of the neural network is a hidden state.

310
00:16:40.281 --> 00:16:40.461
Right.

311
00:16:40.561 --> 00:16:40.801
Right.

312
00:16:40.921 --> 00:16:41.101
Right.

313
00:16:41.281 --> 00:16:41.381
Yeah.

314
00:16:41.401 --> 00:16:41.822
That makes sense.

315
00:16:42.442 --> 00:16:42.982
That makes sense.

316
00:16:43.122 --> 00:16:43.843
This, oh, okay.

317
00:16:44.103 --> 00:16:44.363
Got it.

318
00:16:44.443 --> 00:16:44.683
Okay.

319
00:16:44.723 --> 00:16:49.826
So we have our, we, we went into the brain, we wired it up with these electrodes.

320
00:16:51.387 --> 00:17:06.178
We have this machine learning model in the middle, and we have the output in the framework of how they define the input and output to train the model so that it could actually learn what is this high frequency noise that's coming out of the brain actually mean.

321
00:17:06.258 --> 00:17:06.718
Yeah, yeah.

322
00:17:06.978 --> 00:17:11.642
And then the hidden – so this neural network model here, which is the recurrent neural network –

323
00:17:12.042 --> 00:17:14.143
It puts out like representations.

324
00:17:14.564 --> 00:17:14.784
Okay.

325
00:17:15.064 --> 00:17:20.107
And then from that, then they have a language model that takes that and then puts it in the language.

326
00:17:20.227 --> 00:17:23.629
And that language model, you know, they've used a transformer on one of them.

327
00:17:23.649 --> 00:17:25.451
They've also used another type of language model.

328
00:17:25.491 --> 00:17:26.031
I forget the name.

329
00:17:26.051 --> 00:17:27.432
I think it's in here somewhere.

330
00:17:27.912 --> 00:17:30.233
Yeah, they've used the Ngram language model.

331
00:17:30.633 --> 00:17:33.834
And then they've also used a transformer language model.

332
00:17:34.014 --> 00:17:41.737
And the loss function that they've used is pretty interesting because it's the CTC loss function where, you know, usually when it comes to losses.

333
00:17:42.317 --> 00:17:47.199
So the way the loss function works is it takes its guess and then it takes what the ground truth is.

334
00:17:47.719 --> 00:17:49.560
And then it computes a difference between the two.

335
00:17:49.960 --> 00:17:52.161
And then it's like, oh, I was really wrong here.

336
00:17:52.521 --> 00:17:54.282
So I really need to start changing the weights.

337
00:17:54.782 --> 00:17:56.423
Because I'm going in the wrong direction.

338
00:17:56.623 --> 00:17:58.404
Or it's like, oh, I'm getting closer.

339
00:17:58.705 --> 00:17:59.285
I'm getting closer.

340
00:17:59.305 --> 00:18:00.726
I'm going to keep going in this direction.

341
00:18:00.766 --> 00:18:03.228
That's what the loss function and backpropagation does.

342
00:18:03.528 --> 00:18:05.309
Is it kind of like a scoring system?

343
00:18:05.389 --> 00:18:05.869
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

344
00:18:05.909 --> 00:18:07.170
Effectively, it's a scoring system.

345
00:18:07.190 --> 00:18:08.471
That's why we call it a loss function.

346
00:18:08.491 --> 00:18:11.433
It's like, what is the loss between your target and your prediction, right?

347
00:18:11.753 --> 00:18:17.637
And then they use this thing called CTC loss, which it's kind of a loose loss function.

348
00:18:17.777 --> 00:18:18.037
Okay.

349
00:18:18.297 --> 00:18:25.541
What it does is give a little bit of freedom in terms of like what the input was and what you're trying to predict.

350
00:18:25.961 --> 00:18:31.805
Because with the kind of data that we're working with, it's at 100 hertz, right?

351
00:18:32.045 --> 00:18:36.027
So it's like one every 10 to 20 milliseconds.

352
00:18:36.328 --> 00:18:36.668
But like...

353
00:18:37.248 --> 00:18:39.970
the words that are going to come out are not going to be at that speed.

354
00:18:40.350 --> 00:18:44.092
So you need some bit of looseness to try to match the input to the output.

355
00:18:44.392 --> 00:18:46.193
It needs room to explore a little bit.

356
00:18:46.213 --> 00:18:47.054
Yeah, exactly.

357
00:18:47.134 --> 00:18:47.834
In time.

358
00:18:47.934 --> 00:18:48.315
In time.

359
00:18:48.335 --> 00:18:49.495
Yeah.

360
00:18:49.615 --> 00:18:56.639
And so it was like a really cool way of using like loss, but like not in this rigid format, which I thought was interesting.

361
00:18:56.659 --> 00:18:59.221
That is interesting because it's maybe a little counterintuitive.

362
00:18:59.301 --> 00:18:59.561
Yeah.

363
00:18:59.601 --> 00:19:03.143
Because the idea is you want rigid control over the outputs of these systems.

364
00:19:03.163 --> 00:19:03.583
Yeah, yeah.

365
00:19:03.683 --> 00:19:06.005
Usually if you're like – if there's like a photo of a cat –

366
00:19:06.325 --> 00:19:10.108
and you want it to be a cat, it's like, okay, no, cat is just mapped to cat, right?

367
00:19:10.188 --> 00:19:13.951
But this is like a sequence of stuff that we don't even know how it works.

368
00:19:13.971 --> 00:19:15.913
It's just like neurons talking.

369
00:19:16.193 --> 00:19:19.736
And we need a little bit of discovery to allow it to have a little bit of discovery space.

370
00:19:19.776 --> 00:19:19.996
Yes.

371
00:19:20.177 --> 00:19:21.217
Yeah, in time.

372
00:19:21.318 --> 00:19:23.099
And that's exactly what this thing is doing.

373
00:19:23.159 --> 00:19:25.321
And the results are pretty interesting.

374
00:19:25.661 --> 00:19:29.224
So once they did this, they trained all this, and now comes the time to test.

375
00:19:29.444 --> 00:19:29.584
Right.

376
00:19:29.645 --> 00:19:29.885
Okay?

377
00:19:30.285 --> 00:19:31.866
So first, it's like...

378
00:19:32.727 --> 00:19:35.068
Let's just be let's just let's just do seven words.

379
00:19:35.448 --> 00:19:35.708
Okay.

380
00:19:36.369 --> 00:19:37.849
Like, let's not do like thoughts.

381
00:19:39.210 --> 00:19:40.471
Like, why don't you think cat?

382
00:19:40.811 --> 00:19:42.412
And then we're going to try to predict cat.

383
00:19:42.652 --> 00:19:43.112
All right.

384
00:19:43.572 --> 00:19:44.112
They did that.

385
00:19:44.893 --> 00:19:48.034
Attempted speech was at 98 percent correct classification.

386
00:19:48.795 --> 00:19:49.115
Okay.

387
00:19:49.195 --> 00:19:49.455
Okay.

388
00:19:49.755 --> 00:19:54.537
So that's attempted speech, meaning like they thought, okay, I'm going to say the word cat.

389
00:19:54.917 --> 00:19:55.077
Yes.

390
00:19:55.177 --> 00:20:00.540
And then and then the the neural network was like, oh, I see cat being represented in the neurons.

391
00:20:00.760 --> 00:20:01.960
Even with grade deflation.

392
00:20:02.561 --> 00:20:03.501
Bro, that's an A+.

393
00:20:03.561 --> 00:20:04.181
That's still an A+.

394
00:20:04.201 --> 00:20:04.781
That's an A+.

395
00:20:04.801 --> 00:20:06.682
You know they don't have grade deflation anymore?

396
00:20:06.702 --> 00:20:07.742
We're not going to have this conversation.

397
00:20:07.762 --> 00:20:08.402
No, that's for later.

398
00:20:08.422 --> 00:20:10.963
Because it is very upsetting.

399
00:20:11.003 --> 00:20:13.803
Because I got wrecked.

400
00:20:13.823 --> 00:20:13.943
100%.

401
00:20:13.983 --> 00:20:14.304
Anyways.

402
00:20:15.324 --> 00:20:16.444
Inner speech was at 72%.

403
00:20:16.544 --> 00:20:16.944
Okay.

404
00:20:17.324 --> 00:20:19.345
So you can see that if they think –

405
00:20:20.045 --> 00:20:24.626
So if they think the word cat and we want to predict the word cat, that's at 98.

406
00:20:24.966 --> 00:20:29.447
But if they just think about the word cat, but they're not trying to like say it.

407
00:20:29.647 --> 00:20:29.887
Right.

408
00:20:30.047 --> 00:20:30.767
Then it's at 72.

409
00:20:30.807 --> 00:20:34.548
They're not trying to when you're not trying to trigger the motor function of speech.

410
00:20:34.568 --> 00:20:35.168
Exactly.

411
00:20:35.188 --> 00:20:35.428
Yes.

412
00:20:35.688 --> 00:20:36.588
You got it.

413
00:20:36.708 --> 00:20:37.648
It is it is worse.

414
00:20:37.668 --> 00:20:45.250
But when you add the element of the thought plus trying to trigger the motor action of moving your mouth, moving your tongue,

415
00:20:45.710 --> 00:20:48.834
That almost the fidelity for us to make the matches better.

416
00:20:48.934 --> 00:20:49.134
Yep.

417
00:20:49.574 --> 00:20:49.754
Yep.

418
00:20:50.135 --> 00:20:50.936
Now that, yeah.

419
00:20:50.996 --> 00:21:06.833
And that fidelity decreased when you start, when you went to a higher vocabulary, so like at 50%, um, sorry, at like a 50 word vocabulary, that fidelity decreased from 98% to like, now we're getting down to like 35%, but it's still better than chance.

420
00:21:07.033 --> 00:21:07.213
Yes.

421
00:21:07.373 --> 00:21:14.118
And it's still way faster than some of the older stuff that we were doing, like eye tracking and all of these other like the pole.

422
00:21:14.158 --> 00:21:14.458
Yeah.

423
00:21:14.498 --> 00:21:14.698
Yeah.

424
00:21:14.758 --> 00:21:15.398
All of that stuff.

425
00:21:15.659 --> 00:21:17.380
I mean, yeah, this is starting out.

426
00:21:17.440 --> 00:21:24.425
So you can imagine like, you know, maybe more electrodes, maybe a bigger neural network with a larger hidden state.

427
00:21:24.725 --> 00:21:33.010
You know, more time for training, more data for training, more individual subjects that have these in them to have a wider spectrum of different.

428
00:21:34.151 --> 00:21:36.993
There's a variety of very straightforward things.

429
00:21:37.814 --> 00:21:38.634
implementations.

430
00:21:38.694 --> 00:21:39.835
Yeah, to make this better.

431
00:21:39.855 --> 00:21:40.475
To make it better.

432
00:21:40.495 --> 00:21:54.985
The fundamental point is that it's possible to get to a high level of efficacy in translating the input of an inner thought to the output and knowing with a level of certainty that that's the correct translation.

433
00:21:55.005 --> 00:21:55.285
That's right.

434
00:21:55.445 --> 00:21:58.507
And so we have a dictionary with seven words in it.

435
00:21:59.067 --> 00:22:00.568
And they're at 98.

436
00:22:00.668 --> 00:22:02.250
And now we got a dictionary of 50.

437
00:22:02.270 --> 00:22:04.051
And then they upgraded to a dictionary of 125,000.

438
00:22:04.091 --> 00:22:04.491
Oh, interesting.

439
00:22:06.312 --> 00:22:08.776
And it was still like, you know, way better than chance.

440
00:22:08.836 --> 00:22:09.036
Yes.

441
00:22:09.236 --> 00:22:16.566
It was out like 26% for inner speech, which which means they're extrapolating from the map that was built with the seven.

442
00:22:16.666 --> 00:22:16.926
Yeah.

443
00:22:17.026 --> 00:22:19.590
To try to arbitrarily map to this whole.

444
00:22:19.890 --> 00:22:20.631
No, no, no, no, no.

445
00:22:20.651 --> 00:22:21.192
They're not trying to.

446
00:22:21.472 --> 00:22:23.275
They built a map for each successive one.

447
00:22:23.375 --> 00:22:23.595
Okay.

448
00:22:23.735 --> 00:22:26.016
Yeah, they did build a map for each successive one.

449
00:22:26.116 --> 00:22:26.856
Okay.

450
00:22:27.257 --> 00:22:28.157
But it's still...

451
00:22:28.237 --> 00:22:31.258
It's still... First time.

452
00:22:31.418 --> 00:22:31.598
Yeah.

453
00:22:31.718 --> 00:22:33.359
First time's pretty damn good.

454
00:22:33.399 --> 00:22:33.839
Pretty good.

455
00:22:34.059 --> 00:22:34.260
Yeah.

456
00:22:34.320 --> 00:22:38.841
And actually, I think they only built the map with the 50-word vocabulary.

457
00:22:39.002 --> 00:22:40.602
And then they tried it on this bigger one.

458
00:22:40.662 --> 00:22:40.822
Yes.

459
00:22:40.902 --> 00:22:46.025
And because the thing sound kind of similar, it was able to guess new novel words.

460
00:22:46.065 --> 00:22:46.485
Yes.

461
00:22:46.545 --> 00:22:47.085
Pretty crazy.

462
00:22:47.105 --> 00:22:48.726
Which is... That's very... Yeah.

463
00:22:48.786 --> 00:22:49.546
Very interesting.

464
00:22:49.566 --> 00:22:49.706
Yeah.

465
00:22:49.966 --> 00:22:51.267
But I think the coolest test...

466
00:22:51.507 --> 00:22:51.767
Okay.

467
00:22:52.167 --> 00:22:53.027
is the following.

468
00:22:53.107 --> 00:22:53.387
Okay.

469
00:22:53.727 --> 00:22:57.388
So then they did something called the arrow recall test.

470
00:22:57.448 --> 00:22:57.608
Okay.

471
00:22:57.628 --> 00:23:06.090
This is a pretty familiar test for like, um, psychological experiments where like you see arrows that are up, down, left, right, and things like that.

472
00:23:06.770 --> 00:23:09.690
Um, and all you're doing is seeing them and then thinking about the arrow.

473
00:23:10.071 --> 00:23:13.091
And then the, this thing could say up down.

474
00:23:13.431 --> 00:23:17.512
So even when they're not actively thinking, but they're like seeing stuff,

475
00:23:19.028 --> 00:23:21.210
This thing could pick up what they're like, what the brain.

476
00:23:21.230 --> 00:23:21.390
Yeah.

477
00:23:21.410 --> 00:23:21.530
Right.

478
00:23:21.550 --> 00:23:21.690
Right.

479
00:23:21.710 --> 00:23:21.830
Right.

480
00:23:21.850 --> 00:23:21.971
Right.

481
00:23:21.991 --> 00:23:22.111
Right.

482
00:23:22.131 --> 00:23:22.251
Right.

483
00:23:22.271 --> 00:23:22.431
Right.

484
00:23:22.451 --> 00:23:28.416
Like almost in this like sub sub Rosa brain process that's happening when you're seeing something, it is even.

485
00:23:28.436 --> 00:23:29.357
And you're thinking about it.

486
00:23:29.417 --> 00:23:29.617
Right.

487
00:23:29.777 --> 00:23:30.878
Oh, I see an up arrow.

488
00:23:30.938 --> 00:23:32.319
And then this like thing is going to.

489
00:23:32.499 --> 00:23:33.961
Oh, I.

490
00:23:34.041 --> 00:23:36.823
And then and then and then the other thing they did was with numbers.

491
00:23:36.843 --> 00:23:41.427
They had like counting object and then the thing would put out one, five.

492
00:23:41.687 --> 00:23:43.388
So it extrapolates beyond language.

493
00:23:43.588 --> 00:23:43.968
Exactly.

494
00:23:43.988 --> 00:23:45.808
To sort of like not like to like imagery.

495
00:23:45.928 --> 00:23:50.530
And crucially, these two tasks are not something that the neural network was trained on.

496
00:23:51.390 --> 00:23:51.570
Oh.

497
00:23:51.710 --> 00:23:53.190
That's what's insane.

498
00:23:53.330 --> 00:23:53.991
Okay.

499
00:23:54.011 --> 00:23:56.811
These two tasks, the neural network was trained on.

500
00:23:57.231 --> 00:24:02.433
These are the neurons that are being activated when this person thinks about certain words.

501
00:24:02.713 --> 00:24:02.973
Okay.

502
00:24:03.013 --> 00:24:05.734
From that mapping, it could then take, oh.

503
00:24:06.574 --> 00:24:32.958
up like it's seeing the guy is seeing an up arrow the guy is counting three objects that's scary right so like because the neural representations yes are going to be like they've abstracted yes so like what is the brain look like yes when it's in the space of thinking about three right right right not even about trying to say three yes it's like just the idea of this thing yes what does it look like in the brain

504
00:24:34.299 --> 00:24:34.680
Right.

505
00:24:34.940 --> 00:24:36.543
So now you can see the ethical concern.

506
00:24:36.603 --> 00:24:36.943
No, no, no.

507
00:24:36.963 --> 00:24:45.235
This is because very quickly, I mean, the only bottleneck to this right now is that you need brain surgery.

508
00:24:46.568 --> 00:24:46.788
Right.

509
00:24:46.848 --> 00:24:47.109
Yeah.

510
00:24:47.149 --> 00:24:49.611
Which is a, which is a high barrier.

511
00:24:49.631 --> 00:24:49.751
Yeah.

512
00:24:49.771 --> 00:24:51.192
Which is its own like ethical thing.

513
00:24:51.252 --> 00:24:51.432
Right.

514
00:24:51.473 --> 00:25:01.822
Because like the only reason that these, um, that neurosurgeons were like, okay, I'm going to do this brain surgery is because these four patients were like severely paralytic.

515
00:25:01.862 --> 00:25:02.062
Right.

516
00:25:02.082 --> 00:25:03.163
And they volunteered to do this.

517
00:25:03.263 --> 00:25:03.503
But like,

518
00:25:05.618 --> 00:25:09.561
Yeah, it's going to take a while for just like normal people to get casual brain surgery.

519
00:25:12.323 --> 00:25:24.352
You know, this is very I think what's so what's so fascinating about this story is we all see these headlines, particularly with Neuralink being in the news where it's like, ah, oh.

520
00:25:24.892 --> 00:25:30.256
But actually understanding what's happening and why it works.

521
00:25:30.396 --> 00:25:32.498
It's a mechanistic thing, right?

522
00:25:32.578 --> 00:25:40.064
It's like you get into the brain, you start listening to neurons, and then you start trying to decipher what those neurons are saying.

523
00:25:40.384 --> 00:25:41.065
How do we do that?

524
00:25:41.425 --> 00:25:44.648
It's by sort of training this input-output system.

525
00:25:45.108 --> 00:26:11.565
response and there's these underlying patterns and then it starts making sense it's like oh that's why it works it's not like some we can just read brain right it's like we have to learn how to read that brain correct you know and that's i think an important detail yeah um because it's it's not like um i think there's two things that are interesting one there's a process by which we learn how to translate and then also partial translation which is like that word the word input output mapping they had yeah

526
00:26:11.965 --> 00:26:25.171
can also be used to, with some level of better-than-chance odds, make novel connections about what the brain may or may not be saying or thinking, even when you haven't mapped for those things explicitly.

527
00:26:25.351 --> 00:26:26.072
Yeah.

528
00:26:26.232 --> 00:26:38.978
Which means just increasing the amount of work being done on mapping the inputs can have really crazy implications downstream, even if we don't map everything exactly.

529
00:26:39.198 --> 00:26:43.781
Which again, for people who work with LLMs, it's kind of very similar.

530
00:26:43.801 --> 00:26:44.341
Yeah, it is.

531
00:26:44.421 --> 00:26:44.721
It is.

532
00:26:44.741 --> 00:26:56.808
Like in that, you know, it takes the whole corpus of the Internet as text, as training data, but it can still put words together in strings that are not exactly mimicking what's from the training data.

533
00:26:56.828 --> 00:27:07.154
No, yeah, it's novelty now because it's learned a pattern internalized within its, you know, billions and billions of parameters, right?

534
00:27:07.254 --> 00:27:08.575
It's learned something about it.

535
00:27:08.995 --> 00:27:14.719
And, yeah, the next question that's obvious to ask is like, this is a slippery slope.

536
00:27:14.739 --> 00:27:14.940
Yeah.

537
00:27:14.980 --> 00:27:15.280
All right.

538
00:27:15.340 --> 00:27:16.861
What are we doing to like control this?

539
00:27:16.921 --> 00:27:17.121
Right.

540
00:27:17.361 --> 00:27:24.847
Because, I mean, even if you're like even if you're that paralyzed individual, maybe you don't want all your inner thought like you're talking to someone using this interface.

541
00:27:24.907 --> 00:27:25.127
Right.

542
00:27:25.588 --> 00:27:27.809
Maybe you don't want all your inner thoughts to go out.

543
00:27:27.889 --> 00:27:30.551
OK. All humans are kind of, you know, fallible.

544
00:27:30.972 --> 00:27:32.933
No one's perfect.

545
00:27:32.953 --> 00:27:35.215
So so so how do we how do we figure this out?

546
00:27:35.555 --> 00:27:37.516
And so they came up with a strategy.

547
00:27:37.856 --> 00:27:40.156
I don't know if it's a good one, but at least it's a strategy.

548
00:27:41.517 --> 00:27:43.277
It's an interesting data analysis tool.

549
00:27:43.337 --> 00:27:46.358
It's something called Principal Component Analysis, PCA.

550
00:27:46.738 --> 00:27:51.119
It's used a lot in these kinds of high dimensional data sets whenever you're trying to analyze them.

551
00:27:51.419 --> 00:27:58.641
What you're trying to do is you have this really high dimensional data set, but frequently if we're trying to study two different things,

552
00:27:59.281 --> 00:28:06.122
then that data is going to fall on two different directions in this high dimensional space.

553
00:28:06.383 --> 00:28:06.643
Okay.

554
00:28:06.923 --> 00:28:08.083
And that's what PCA is.

555
00:28:08.123 --> 00:28:12.744
It's basically trying to reduce like what's the direction with the most information.

556
00:28:13.064 --> 00:28:15.885
And then what's the direction with the next most information.

557
00:28:16.245 --> 00:28:20.886
So they did this PCA analysis for this inner speech and attempted speech.

558
00:28:21.246 --> 00:28:27.047
And what they found was that when you have attempted speech and inner speech, they both fall on the same axis.

559
00:28:27.587 --> 00:28:27.907
Okay.

560
00:28:28.127 --> 00:28:34.069
It's just that the inner speech is like a little bit like sort of the amplitude along that direction is less.

561
00:28:34.109 --> 00:28:43.592
But if you have intent, motor intent speech, which is like I intended to say that, that's on a different axis.

562
00:28:44.986 --> 00:28:45.266
Okay.

563
00:28:45.706 --> 00:29:00.950
So now they can, they can have this kind of password protection, like in their brain where it's like, it's like, like the guy, the, the, the person can have some like password set that thinks along this direction.

564
00:29:00.990 --> 00:29:04.551
And then that opens up the BCI to be like, oh, okay.

565
00:29:04.831 --> 00:29:05.731
Now I can like.

566
00:29:06.916 --> 00:29:08.617
say what he's trying to think.

567
00:29:08.717 --> 00:29:09.458
Right, right.

568
00:29:09.538 --> 00:29:13.560
And then he can go the other password, and then the BCI will shut up.

569
00:29:13.580 --> 00:29:22.505
So you can have this learned dimensionality in someone's brain, and then the person can have this password in his head that he thinks about.

570
00:29:22.685 --> 00:29:22.885
Yes.

571
00:29:23.446 --> 00:29:24.546
And then it's like, okay, now I'm going to speak.

572
00:29:24.566 --> 00:29:26.367
That turns off the access to the translation.

573
00:29:26.728 --> 00:29:28.669
Yeah, yeah.

574
00:29:28.749 --> 00:29:30.370
It's a cool way of, I don't know.

575
00:29:30.410 --> 00:29:33.972
We're talking about multi-factor authentication with...

576
00:29:34.210 --> 00:29:34.730
Yeah, bro.

577
00:29:34.931 --> 00:29:36.172
For your inner thoughts.

578
00:29:36.192 --> 00:29:37.113
For your inner thoughts.

579
00:29:37.173 --> 00:29:37.653
Yeah.

580
00:29:37.673 --> 00:29:39.134
It's like a face ID.

581
00:29:39.154 --> 00:29:40.896
Face ID in your brain.

582
00:29:41.016 --> 00:29:41.636
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

583
00:29:41.676 --> 00:29:42.157
Brain ID.

584
00:29:42.577 --> 00:29:43.198
Yeah, dude.

585
00:29:43.258 --> 00:29:45.380
Hashtag TM trademark brain ID.

586
00:29:45.480 --> 00:29:46.080
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

587
00:29:46.160 --> 00:29:46.881
Heard here first.

588
00:29:48.182 --> 00:29:50.024
That's actually a very clever.

589
00:29:50.424 --> 00:29:56.489
That's a clever sort of solution to the problem that actually like lives within the control of the patient.

590
00:29:56.529 --> 00:29:57.130
Of the person.

591
00:29:57.150 --> 00:29:57.350
Yeah.

592
00:29:57.370 --> 00:29:57.530
Right.

593
00:29:57.670 --> 00:30:01.313
Yeah, because because at the end of the day, like like they need to be in charge.

594
00:30:01.413 --> 00:30:01.613
Right.

595
00:30:01.673 --> 00:30:01.913
Right.

596
00:30:02.133 --> 00:30:02.313
Right.

597
00:30:02.433 --> 00:30:05.175
For this thing to be make any ethical sense whatsoever.

598
00:30:05.555 --> 00:30:08.938
I can't believe we're talking about role based access controls for your brain.

599
00:30:08.998 --> 00:30:12.140
Bro, it's nuts.

600
00:30:12.160 --> 00:30:12.921
Yeah, this is 2025.

601
00:30:13.001 --> 00:30:13.241
Yeah.

602
00:30:13.341 --> 00:30:14.782
I mean, there's risks, obviously.

603
00:30:14.842 --> 00:30:15.082
Right.

604
00:30:15.362 --> 00:30:17.284
Like you can you can you can hack it.

605
00:30:17.484 --> 00:30:17.684
Yes.

606
00:30:17.704 --> 00:30:17.924
Right.

607
00:30:17.944 --> 00:30:21.765
Of course you just I mean, all of this is going to be in code right at the end of the day.

608
00:30:21.986 --> 00:30:22.126
Right.

609
00:30:22.146 --> 00:30:26.967
Well, where the BCI is going to choose to turn off because there's a bit of code that's like, oh, he went this way.

610
00:30:27.007 --> 00:30:27.768
So I'm going to turn off.

611
00:30:28.108 --> 00:30:28.788
You just hack it.

612
00:30:28.808 --> 00:30:30.129
And then it's like neuro hacking.

613
00:30:30.169 --> 00:30:32.349
Now you get like into the inner thoughts.

614
00:30:32.449 --> 00:30:37.711
I mean, this is literally the three letter agencies are going to have, you know, neural hackers.

615
00:30:37.971 --> 00:30:38.572
Yeah.

616
00:30:38.652 --> 00:30:42.073
It's easy to bypass your inner thought.

617
00:30:42.393 --> 00:30:42.553
Yeah.

618
00:30:42.573 --> 00:30:47.076
And then what started off as a medical tool is going to turn into something totally different.

619
00:30:47.116 --> 00:30:54.640
Like you could have like espionage, surveillance, counterintel, interrogation.

620
00:30:54.700 --> 00:30:55.080
Right.

621
00:30:55.760 --> 00:30:57.581
I mean, like, what do they call it?

622
00:30:57.621 --> 00:31:00.463
Do I have a plead the fifth inside my head?

623
00:31:01.443 --> 00:31:02.323
Fourth Amendment, right?

624
00:31:02.463 --> 00:31:03.604
Yeah, I plead the Fifth.

625
00:31:03.684 --> 00:31:06.845
No, it's like it's my right to not incriminate myself.

626
00:31:06.865 --> 00:31:07.585
Self-incriminate, right.

627
00:31:07.605 --> 00:31:08.005
Yeah, right?

628
00:31:08.325 --> 00:31:08.885
Although, I don't know.

629
00:31:08.925 --> 00:31:10.826
The Constitution is kind of loose today, so.

630
00:31:11.086 --> 00:31:14.247
This is always very true.

631
00:31:14.607 --> 00:31:19.469
I think the Fourth is the right to not having a legal search and seizure, but they can just search your brain.

632
00:31:20.009 --> 00:31:20.189
Yeah.

633
00:31:20.229 --> 00:31:22.210
And it's like there are so many implications.

634
00:31:22.310 --> 00:31:23.711
It's there's so many implications.

635
00:31:23.751 --> 00:31:23.971
Right.

636
00:31:24.252 --> 00:31:26.013
The founding fathers didn't know.

637
00:31:26.173 --> 00:31:26.593
Bullshit.

638
00:31:28.214 --> 00:31:34.057
The fact that we're talking about the constitutional implications of brain computer interfaces is.

639
00:31:35.298 --> 00:31:37.119
Crazy that we're talking about this in 2025.

640
00:31:37.219 --> 00:31:47.246
And I think papers like this really start putting an impetus on us as a society to start talking about this in a much more serious way.

641
00:31:47.567 --> 00:31:53.731
Like we've had social media and our data online for 20 plus years now.

642
00:31:55.432 --> 00:32:00.658
And there's barely any legislation in Congress trying to deal with like data privacy rights.

643
00:32:00.738 --> 00:32:07.886
Which I've actually worked on like public advocacy work to push for data privacy laws.

644
00:32:08.567 --> 00:32:09.028
It's nuts.

645
00:32:09.168 --> 00:32:12.732
And it's been 20 years since everyone's been on Facebook.

646
00:32:12.872 --> 00:32:14.374
Talking about random nonsense.

647
00:32:14.434 --> 00:32:16.557
And it's not that controversial of an issue.

648
00:32:16.917 --> 00:32:22.885
And it's weirdly caught up in political dynamics of who's being censored more, which is like irrelevant to the point of data privacy.

649
00:32:22.905 --> 00:32:27.971
But that's the discussion has become now we're being more censored than you in online speech.

650
00:32:29.353 --> 00:32:29.873
Yeah.

651
00:32:29.933 --> 00:32:33.676
And so now imagine like now we get into like just neural data being everywhere.

652
00:32:33.776 --> 00:32:33.957
Right.

653
00:32:33.997 --> 00:32:35.318
This stuff is going to get uploaded.

654
00:32:35.338 --> 00:32:35.518
Right.

655
00:32:36.259 --> 00:32:39.762
Like whose right is it like we need we need legislation.

656
00:32:39.842 --> 00:32:42.384
And now you can't sue people if they lose your data currently.

657
00:32:42.604 --> 00:32:48.830
And so you're just kind of SOL in terms of even getting any kind of remuneration or like financial compensation.

658
00:32:48.850 --> 00:32:49.050
Yeah.

659
00:32:49.130 --> 00:32:49.310
I mean.

660
00:32:49.310 --> 00:32:51.131
These are really deep, complex issues.

661
00:32:51.271 --> 00:32:51.492
Yeah.

662
00:32:51.652 --> 00:32:53.633
And we need to start having that conversation.

663
00:32:53.653 --> 00:32:54.214
It's the same.

664
00:32:54.534 --> 00:33:07.463
This is the same issue that the AI space is having generally where like AI safety people or people who advocate that we need to be like thinking about AI safety have been sidelined because we're in a global arms race to reach super intelligence.

665
00:33:07.483 --> 00:33:07.703
Yeah.

666
00:33:08.244 --> 00:33:11.786
And stuff like this on the neural side is going to have the same...

667
00:33:13.127 --> 00:33:21.250
Game theoretic dynamics around nation states viewing the upside being more important than any of the safety allocation.

668
00:33:21.510 --> 00:33:23.691
So this is like really, really important.

669
00:33:23.711 --> 00:33:23.931
Yeah.

670
00:33:24.051 --> 00:33:25.912
And it might not feel like it impacts you every day.

671
00:33:26.232 --> 00:33:30.113
But people were talking about the social media implications 20 years ago.

672
00:33:30.173 --> 00:33:30.394
Yeah.

673
00:33:30.534 --> 00:33:31.334
We didn't listen to them.

674
00:33:31.594 --> 00:33:31.714
No.

675
00:33:31.734 --> 00:33:33.637
And now everyone's upset about the way it works.

676
00:33:33.757 --> 00:33:33.977
Yeah.

677
00:33:34.338 --> 00:33:37.662
And that's because we didn't listen to the people talking about this and saying that this was going to happen.

678
00:33:37.742 --> 00:33:38.142
Exactly.

679
00:33:38.162 --> 00:33:42.067
Like 20 years ago on social media, I was just talking about like, oh, I'm going to my friend's house.

680
00:33:42.608 --> 00:33:46.833
And then now today we're like declaring war and like fixing elections.

681
00:33:47.314 --> 00:33:48.235
Like what's going to happen here?

682
00:33:48.455 --> 00:33:53.040
Yeah, the implications are crazy, and this is definitely going to be an arena.

683
00:33:53.081 --> 00:34:03.232
We've touched on a couple of these neuroscience stories, and they all kind of intersect at the same nexus, which is that the research progress is moving apace.

684
00:34:03.873 --> 00:34:06.816
The public understanding is not keeping up with where it is.

685
00:34:06.896 --> 00:34:07.116
No.

686
00:34:07.456 --> 00:34:14.523
And the political will to even learn about it such that you could legislate for it.

687
00:34:14.603 --> 00:34:14.843
Yeah.

688
00:34:15.143 --> 00:34:15.724
Is is.

689
00:34:16.004 --> 00:34:16.124
Yeah.

690
00:34:16.144 --> 00:34:17.345
It's just it's not there.

691
00:34:17.385 --> 00:34:17.586
Yeah.

692
00:34:17.666 --> 00:34:17.926
It's zero.

693
00:34:18.006 --> 00:34:20.688
Everyone's thinking about the next election in two years.

694
00:34:21.489 --> 00:34:21.689
Right.

695
00:34:22.010 --> 00:34:23.431
Yeah, it's it's super annoying.

696
00:34:23.471 --> 00:34:30.277
But like but science is just moving forward and technology is moving forward because like these players, they're they're just trying to push.

697
00:34:30.497 --> 00:34:30.697
Yep.

698
00:34:30.817 --> 00:34:34.120
And then, you know, maybe maybe Jeff Goldblum was right.

699
00:34:34.160 --> 00:34:38.264
Like maybe we do need to stop and think like, OK, should we be doing this?

700
00:34:38.304 --> 00:34:40.726
And maybe if we should, like, what are the safeguards?

701
00:34:40.966 --> 00:34:41.166
Yes.

702
00:34:41.267 --> 00:34:41.487
Right.

703
00:34:41.587 --> 00:34:41.947
How are we?

704
00:34:42.007 --> 00:34:45.670
How can we make sure that this isn't going to be like getting nasty?

705
00:34:45.770 --> 00:34:46.631
Yeah.

706
00:34:46.651 --> 00:34:48.273
Because it can get nasty very quickly.

707
00:34:48.293 --> 00:34:48.513
Yeah.

708
00:34:48.913 --> 00:34:51.894
An incredible story out of Stanford.

709
00:34:52.395 --> 00:34:55.476
Thought crimes are definitely illegal now.

710
00:34:55.496 --> 00:34:55.696
Yeah.

711
00:34:55.816 --> 00:34:56.196
Yeah.

712
00:34:56.236 --> 00:34:57.037
We're about to be.

713
00:34:57.137 --> 00:34:58.277
We're already seeing that with ice.

714
00:34:58.517 --> 00:34:59.958
So we're on the road.

715
00:35:00.098 --> 00:35:01.319
Yeah, dude.

716
00:35:01.999 --> 00:35:05.720
On that depressing note, we'll do a hard pivot.

717
00:35:05.840 --> 00:35:07.001
It's not totally depressing.

718
00:35:07.161 --> 00:35:07.881
I will say, right?

719
00:35:07.921 --> 00:35:16.945
Like, I mean, the prospect of like giving paralyzed individuals the ability to communicate like is pretty awesome.

720
00:35:17.185 --> 00:35:18.506
But at the same time, yeah.

721
00:35:18.766 --> 00:35:25.354
Especially for folks who either have someone in their family or in their network or their friends that are impacted by something like that or your parents.

722
00:35:25.374 --> 00:35:25.494
Yeah.

723
00:35:25.514 --> 00:35:25.654
Right.

724
00:35:25.974 --> 00:35:30.019
As you get older, parents, you know, naturally we all have these neurodegenerative diseases.

725
00:35:30.039 --> 00:35:30.179
Yeah.

726
00:35:30.199 --> 00:35:34.084
I mean, like if we get someone like Stephen Hawking around today.

727
00:35:34.104 --> 00:35:34.524
Right.

728
00:35:34.624 --> 00:35:37.528
They could be using something like this instead of like the computer interface.

729
00:35:37.688 --> 00:35:37.908
Right.

730
00:35:38.028 --> 00:35:38.208
Right.

731
00:35:38.689 --> 00:35:38.829
And.

732
00:35:39.169 --> 00:35:39.289
Ugh.

733
00:35:40.385 --> 00:35:44.150
So, yeah, but again, we need to start having the conversation.

734
00:35:44.191 --> 00:35:44.491
Come on.

735
00:35:44.671 --> 00:35:46.293
And the scientists who did the study were.

736
00:35:46.914 --> 00:35:48.496
And that's the point.

737
00:35:48.657 --> 00:35:54.404
Yeah, they went into this like password type thing and they were like – and they also call for it in their paper.

738
00:35:54.424 --> 00:35:54.765
They're like –

739
00:35:56.064 --> 00:35:58.566
This is clearly going to be an issue, right?

740
00:35:58.646 --> 00:36:02.709
Like we're thinking about the clinical aspects of it, but clearly this is going to be an issue.

741
00:36:02.769 --> 00:36:07.031
So especially geopolitically with, you know, the great war, power war with China.

742
00:36:07.052 --> 00:36:09.353
But we'll come to China in our third story.

743
00:36:10.514 --> 00:36:11.434
Our second story.

744
00:36:12.375 --> 00:36:15.619
is about finding genes that make us human.

745
00:36:16.159 --> 00:36:18.822
This is where I said maybe we actually are just hairless apes.

746
00:36:18.862 --> 00:36:18.962
Yeah.

747
00:36:18.982 --> 00:36:28.893
But this new study brings a little twist from UC San Diego that's helping us understand what exactly makes us human.

748
00:36:28.953 --> 00:36:29.955
So the byline is

749
00:36:31.596 --> 00:36:45.085
This UCSD team discovery comes from their investigation of human accelerated regions, HARs, sections of the human genome that have accumulated an unusually high level of mutations as humans have evolved.

750
00:36:45.645 --> 00:36:58.754
And so how is this new HARs, HARs, HARs, why is this – help me understand what it is and why it's giving us a better understanding of our evolutionary background.

751
00:36:58.774 --> 00:36:58.874
Yeah.

752
00:36:59.252 --> 00:37:00.112
Yeah.

753
00:37:00.572 --> 00:37:02.893
I mean, it's a fascinating question, right?

754
00:37:02.993 --> 00:37:05.213
Like, what is it that makes us human?

755
00:37:05.653 --> 00:37:09.794
It's something that I think we've – it's probably one of the oldest questions ever, right?

756
00:37:10.114 --> 00:37:16.856
Like, we have – in Greek mythology, we have Pandora's box, like this thing that gave us reason and whatever.

757
00:37:17.276 --> 00:37:21.136
And then in all sorts of mythological traditions, we have that.

758
00:37:21.556 --> 00:37:29.018
In the 2001 Space Odyssey, you've got, like, the monolith that the apes touch, and then all of a sudden they get reason and they get tools and things like that.

759
00:37:29.458 --> 00:37:30.738
So it's a fascinating question.

760
00:37:30.818 --> 00:37:32.119
What makes us human?

761
00:37:33.439 --> 00:37:40.621
When the genetic revolution came along in the 1940s and 50s, when we figured out, okay, DNA is the blueprint for all of life.

762
00:37:40.961 --> 00:37:47.962
And that's sort of telling mechanistically the DNA sequence is telling an organism what proteins to create.

763
00:37:49.003 --> 00:37:50.683
That became the central focus, right?

764
00:37:50.983 --> 00:37:55.944
And there was this thing called the central dogma, which sounds just as bad as it is, okay?

765
00:37:56.304 --> 00:37:58.525
These biologists, they literally, they called it themselves.

766
00:37:59.785 --> 00:38:00.605
I don't understand them.

767
00:38:00.765 --> 00:38:01.046
Okay.

768
00:38:01.846 --> 00:38:03.126
Like dogma.

769
00:38:03.466 --> 00:38:03.806
Okay.

770
00:38:04.046 --> 00:38:12.149
Anyways, like the central dogma was you go from DNA to mRNA and RNA, which is this intermediary.

771
00:38:12.189 --> 00:38:13.869
And from RNA, you get to proteins.

772
00:38:14.269 --> 00:38:14.509
Okay.

773
00:38:14.830 --> 00:38:18.811
And so the thing that really matters is the DNA that makes proteins.

774
00:38:19.251 --> 00:38:19.491
Okay.

775
00:38:20.071 --> 00:38:22.632
Then we got into big sequencing projects.

776
00:38:22.772 --> 00:38:22.992
Okay.

777
00:38:23.012 --> 00:38:27.814
The human genome project started after the human genome project was finished in like early 2000s.

778
00:38:28.155 --> 00:38:35.818
Then we had something called the thousand genomes project because the human genome is like they were just sequencing one one dude's DNA.

779
00:38:36.158 --> 00:38:38.299
And it's like probably a white dude, you know.

780
00:38:38.379 --> 00:38:45.682
And so and then with a thousand genomes project, now you get this diversity of human genomes to see like, okay, how are the different human genomes different?

781
00:38:46.662 --> 00:39:12.591
turns out not a lot very few very few differences and then we started also sequencing our closest living ancestors living relative I shouldn't say ancestor because we had a common ancestor but our closest living relative the chimpanzee so so we 23 and meet the chimpanzee yes we 23 meet the chimpanzee and we also 23 mean ourselves and then now we compare the two and surprise surprise

782
00:39:14.232 --> 00:39:16.435
There's very, very few differences.

783
00:39:17.216 --> 00:39:17.456
Okay?

784
00:39:17.857 --> 00:39:20.320
So when people call me a chimpanzee, I can't really complain?

785
00:39:20.340 --> 00:39:21.522
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

786
00:39:21.942 --> 00:39:23.545
You're actually being unreasonable.

787
00:39:26.912 --> 00:39:30.633
Okay, but actually they should be calling each other chimpanzee.

788
00:39:30.713 --> 00:39:33.474
Like we're all part of the same like sort of ape family.

789
00:39:33.814 --> 00:39:40.317
And there's something like 98% similarities between the chimpanzee genome and the human genome.

790
00:39:41.377 --> 00:39:43.418
So now we reach this kind of like conundrum.

791
00:39:43.918 --> 00:39:46.159
Where it's like there's not that many differences.

792
00:39:46.279 --> 00:39:48.939
And clearly we are like way different.

793
00:39:49.140 --> 00:39:50.380
At the genetic level.

794
00:39:50.700 --> 00:39:54.762
At the base pair level, there's not that many differences, like 2%.

795
00:39:54.842 --> 00:39:58.324
But then when we get to this, we're like, holy shit.

796
00:39:58.644 --> 00:40:02.106
Once we go through the mRNA that translates, proteins get created.

797
00:40:02.146 --> 00:40:03.426
Now I can read inner thoughts.

798
00:40:03.587 --> 00:40:03.787
Right.

799
00:40:03.927 --> 00:40:04.167
Right.

800
00:40:04.267 --> 00:40:05.107
Okay.

801
00:40:05.167 --> 00:40:05.828
So how are we?

802
00:40:05.868 --> 00:40:07.609
What's the gap here?

803
00:40:07.789 --> 00:40:07.949
Right.

804
00:40:08.129 --> 00:40:15.092
So there was a paradigm shift in sort of the mid-2000s where we started going away from the central dogma.

805
00:40:15.453 --> 00:40:15.733
Okay.

806
00:40:16.553 --> 00:40:25.543
Because we started realizing that a tiny minority of the human genome is actually coding for protein.

807
00:40:26.664 --> 00:40:27.224
Oh, interesting.

808
00:40:27.304 --> 00:40:27.585
Okay.

809
00:40:27.885 --> 00:40:29.367
So we have these long set of base pairs.

810
00:40:29.527 --> 00:40:31.389
We have like billions of base pairs.

811
00:40:31.529 --> 00:40:33.791
And only like some – And only a small – less than 10%.

812
00:40:35.032 --> 00:40:39.934
Less than 10% are coding for actual proteins, which was the whole point of the central dogma.

813
00:40:40.014 --> 00:40:43.456
It's like, oh, DNA makes proteins like different DNA, different proteins.

814
00:40:43.476 --> 00:40:50.519
But here we're like different DNA, same protein, because like the changes are no longer in the protein coding part of the DNA.

815
00:40:50.879 --> 00:40:54.001
We're actually seeing that a lot of the changes are happening outside.

816
00:40:55.069 --> 00:40:58.651
in a part of the DNA that used to be called junk DNA because we didn't know any better.

817
00:40:59.151 --> 00:40:59.411
Okay.

818
00:40:59.952 --> 00:41:02.473
Then we started thinking about genetics.

819
00:41:03.053 --> 00:41:04.014
How does it work?

820
00:41:04.274 --> 00:41:04.534
Okay.

821
00:41:04.874 --> 00:41:07.195
We started discovering things called promoters.

822
00:41:07.816 --> 00:41:08.036
Okay.

823
00:41:08.396 --> 00:41:09.496
So not for the club.

824
00:41:09.737 --> 00:41:10.037
All right.

825
00:41:10.277 --> 00:41:11.357
No, we're not shaking.

826
00:41:11.377 --> 00:41:12.158
Kind of though.

827
00:41:12.378 --> 00:41:12.678
Okay.

828
00:41:13.138 --> 00:41:17.601
You know how a promoter like finds hot girls and then brings them to the club.

829
00:41:17.641 --> 00:41:17.861
Yes.

830
00:41:18.521 --> 00:41:29.112
A promoter on DNA finds the transcription machinery, like RNA polymerase, and brings it to transcribe a segment of DNA into RNA.

831
00:41:29.232 --> 00:41:31.674
I can't believe we're talking about janky promoters and DNA.

832
00:41:31.974 --> 00:41:37.280
Yeah, dude, they're probably as smelly and as shady.

833
00:41:37.540 --> 00:41:40.563
They sit right next to the bit of the DNA.

834
00:41:41.003 --> 00:41:44.407
The club is right here and then they're sitting right next to it and they're like, come on.

835
00:41:44.728 --> 00:41:49.553
And then the guy comes and then RNA polymerase goes and transcribes the bit of DNA.

836
00:41:49.573 --> 00:41:50.655
So that's what a promoter does.

837
00:41:50.995 --> 00:41:54.399
That thing is outside of the part that's making a protein.

838
00:41:54.779 --> 00:41:57.382
But it's extremely important in terms of...

839
00:41:58.263 --> 00:41:59.723
getting that protein to be made.

840
00:41:59.984 --> 00:42:00.164
Right.

841
00:42:00.304 --> 00:42:04.005
Because if you got a club without a promoter, no hot girls, it's a bad club.

842
00:42:04.025 --> 00:42:04.605
Nobody wants to go.

843
00:42:04.625 --> 00:42:05.205
No one wants to go.

844
00:42:05.265 --> 00:42:12.368
And then the dudes don't want to spend $200 on a fucking, you know, smear it off vodka, you know?

845
00:42:12.668 --> 00:42:18.510
So, so, so you need the promoter to start bringing in the transcription machinery to actually translate this thing.

846
00:42:18.630 --> 00:42:22.771
So, so the DNA defined some 10% defines what proteins need to be created.

847
00:42:23.011 --> 00:42:23.912
Yeah, less than 10.

848
00:42:23.952 --> 00:42:24.412
Less than 10.

849
00:42:24.452 --> 00:42:24.913
Even, yeah.

850
00:42:25.493 --> 00:42:35.381
But there's this intermediary function, which is these promoters, that are actually who brings all of the stuff together to actually make the transcription happen.

851
00:42:35.401 --> 00:42:35.621
To make it.

852
00:42:35.981 --> 00:42:37.102
On top of that, that's not it.

853
00:42:37.383 --> 00:42:38.303
The promoter is not it.

854
00:42:38.363 --> 00:42:40.225
There's also something called an enhancer.

855
00:42:40.585 --> 00:42:40.805
Okay.

856
00:42:40.865 --> 00:42:42.026
Which can be very far away.

857
00:42:42.046 --> 00:42:45.467
The promoter usually sits right next to the thing that you want to transcribe, right?

858
00:42:45.487 --> 00:42:49.368
Because the Lego block comes, the RNA polymerase comes, binds to the promoter.

859
00:42:49.388 --> 00:42:50.489
The promoter is like this way.

860
00:42:50.749 --> 00:42:53.830
And then it goes, and then it like makes the mRNA.

861
00:42:53.850 --> 00:42:56.451
The mRNA then goes outside and becomes a protein, right?

862
00:42:56.731 --> 00:43:01.933
You've got an enhancer, which is kind of like a volume control on the promoter.

863
00:43:02.293 --> 00:43:02.553
Okay.

864
00:43:02.653 --> 00:43:02.934
Okay?

865
00:43:03.414 --> 00:43:07.497
Which, now this enhancer can be very far away on the bit of DNA.

866
00:43:07.577 --> 00:43:07.778
Okay.

867
00:43:08.018 --> 00:43:17.786
And, like, the DNA can, like, fold such that an enhancer that was really far away is going to come closer and then, like, start promoting the transcription of this thing.

868
00:43:17.826 --> 00:43:20.248
So the enhancer acts kind of like a volume control.

869
00:43:20.328 --> 00:43:20.568
Got it.

870
00:43:20.668 --> 00:43:21.229
Got it.

871
00:43:21.469 --> 00:43:22.049
On this gene.

872
00:43:22.109 --> 00:43:22.290
Yes.

873
00:43:22.370 --> 00:43:27.354
And it has – and so you've got all of these sort of different machinery.

874
00:43:27.494 --> 00:43:27.694
Yes.

875
00:43:27.754 --> 00:43:28.174
That was –

876
00:43:28.995 --> 00:43:33.780
That's found in the junk part of the DNA, the part that doesn't do any protein synthesis.

877
00:43:33.840 --> 00:43:37.644
Which previously was thought to be not relevant.

878
00:43:37.664 --> 00:43:39.185
Yeah, it was just like a relic.

879
00:43:39.445 --> 00:43:39.645
Right.

880
00:43:39.726 --> 00:43:39.866
Yeah.

881
00:43:39.886 --> 00:43:46.332
People thought, oh, it's just like there because like, you know, maybe the genetic machinery is like lazy and didn't get rid of it.

882
00:43:46.352 --> 00:43:46.993
It was the appendix.

883
00:43:47.013 --> 00:43:48.714
It just wants to like – we're just hoarders.

884
00:43:48.734 --> 00:43:49.695
We're like DNA hoarders.

885
00:43:49.735 --> 00:43:50.316
Right, right.

886
00:43:50.476 --> 00:43:52.338
And we're not getting rid of the junk DNA.

887
00:43:52.698 --> 00:43:59.381
But it turns out all of this stuff is important and might be the most important for trying to figure out why we are human.

888
00:43:59.541 --> 00:44:02.802
In retrospect, it was probably naive to think that way.

889
00:44:02.822 --> 00:44:03.022
Yes.

890
00:44:03.663 --> 00:44:03.883
Yes.

891
00:44:04.043 --> 00:44:08.385
But I can't fault them because, like, you don't know what the hell – At the time.

892
00:44:08.565 --> 00:44:13.967
At the time, even getting that far was like, dude, we're like – I can make insulin.

893
00:44:14.087 --> 00:44:14.267
Right.

894
00:44:14.367 --> 00:44:15.188
This is insane.

895
00:44:15.208 --> 00:44:15.408
Right.

896
00:44:15.588 --> 00:44:15.728
Right.

897
00:44:16.168 --> 00:44:18.509
Like I can make human insulin in a bacteria.

898
00:44:18.529 --> 00:44:23.692
This is what, what, what, what, what, like, you know, so, so I, yeah, they're, they're doing the best they can.

899
00:44:24.252 --> 00:44:27.474
Um, but the, the question now shifts, right.

900
00:44:27.614 --> 00:44:28.974
About like what makes us human?

901
00:44:29.475 --> 00:44:34.077
What is, there's no longer this like, like black monolith one gene.

902
00:44:34.197 --> 00:44:34.397
Yes.

903
00:44:34.537 --> 00:44:35.317
To rule them all.

904
00:44:35.497 --> 00:44:35.678
Right.

905
00:44:35.778 --> 00:44:43.321
Now the question shifts from what are the genes that make us human to what is the machinery and the control mechanism.

906
00:44:43.401 --> 00:44:43.581
Right.

907
00:44:43.841 --> 00:44:44.462
That affects,

908
00:44:45.082 --> 00:44:48.443
the already existing genes that make us human.

909
00:44:48.503 --> 00:44:48.723
Right.

910
00:44:49.103 --> 00:44:49.523
Okay.

911
00:44:49.563 --> 00:44:51.963
And that's where these human accelerated regions come in.

912
00:44:52.704 --> 00:44:52.944
Okay.

913
00:44:52.984 --> 00:44:53.364
Okay.

914
00:44:53.384 --> 00:44:57.805
Because the idea here, I think I see where this is going, is that the machinery.

915
00:44:58.365 --> 00:44:59.365
That's the thing that's changing.

916
00:44:59.385 --> 00:45:06.946
That's the thing that's changing that has created the diversion between us and our nearest cousins, the chimpanzees.

917
00:45:06.966 --> 00:45:07.787
Yes, exactly.

918
00:45:07.827 --> 00:45:09.047
The nearest existing cousins.

919
00:45:09.878 --> 00:45:16.501
The for human accelerated regions, now that we have like this template of chimpanzee DNA, we've got a we've got the human DNA.

920
00:45:16.561 --> 00:45:18.001
Okay, now we can compare and contrast.

921
00:45:18.061 --> 00:45:18.222
Right.

922
00:45:18.242 --> 00:45:18.402
Yes.

923
00:45:18.662 --> 00:45:23.044
So human accelerated regions are regions that have two characteristics.

924
00:45:23.444 --> 00:45:23.644
Okay.

925
00:45:23.944 --> 00:45:28.186
The first characteristic is this region is conserved across vertebrates.

926
00:45:28.566 --> 00:45:29.726
So it's found in chickens.

927
00:45:30.047 --> 00:45:34.448
It's found in like all sorts of stuff, not just like humans and chimpanzees, but like all over the place.

928
00:45:34.809 --> 00:45:37.950
Meaning this part is just like super important.

929
00:45:38.390 --> 00:45:38.890
For all life.

930
00:45:38.910 --> 00:45:43.593
For like mammals and like vertebrates and like life, big formed life in general.

931
00:45:43.773 --> 00:45:44.013
Okay.

932
00:45:44.733 --> 00:45:56.259
The second characteristic is between chimpanzees and humans, there's been hella way more mutations than there should have been over the past like 6 million years or 10 million years that we've had since evolving.

933
00:45:57.500 --> 00:46:02.002
Whatever snippet of DNA there is, there's way more changes than there should be by chance.

934
00:46:02.282 --> 00:46:05.626
So as an analogy, I'm going to make a video game analogy.

935
00:46:05.826 --> 00:46:06.046
Yeah.

936
00:46:06.166 --> 00:46:09.209
The first set you talked about is like buying the game.

937
00:46:09.730 --> 00:46:11.672
And then the second set's like the expansion pack.

938
00:46:11.792 --> 00:46:11.992
Yeah.

939
00:46:12.072 --> 00:46:14.775
And like we have the expansion pack that has like extra levels.

940
00:46:14.855 --> 00:46:15.076
Yeah.

941
00:46:15.116 --> 00:46:15.356
Yeah.

942
00:46:15.456 --> 00:46:15.816
All this stuff.

943
00:46:15.836 --> 00:46:16.057
Yeah.

944
00:46:16.077 --> 00:46:16.257
Yeah.

945
00:46:16.297 --> 00:46:19.300
But the game is like has to be really good that everybody has it.

946
00:46:19.500 --> 00:46:19.680
Right.

947
00:46:19.720 --> 00:46:19.880
Yeah.

948
00:46:19.900 --> 00:46:21.101
You know, everyone has the game.

949
00:46:21.161 --> 00:46:21.382
Yeah.

950
00:46:21.442 --> 00:46:23.463
But only we have the super cool.

951
00:46:23.523 --> 00:46:24.004
Yeah.

952
00:46:24.024 --> 00:46:24.204
Yeah.

953
00:46:24.244 --> 00:46:24.484
Yeah.

954
00:46:24.544 --> 00:46:27.787
Like we bought all the skins, you know, right.

955
00:46:28.287 --> 00:46:28.527
Yeah.

956
00:46:28.907 --> 00:46:33.991
So this particular so human accelerated regions, they sort of started becoming a thing in the 2000s.

957
00:46:34.011 --> 00:46:34.232
Okay.

958
00:46:35.272 --> 00:46:46.080
The first one, HAR1, was a gene that was identified, and it was like there was this correlation between the gene, the presence of that gene, and its expression in brains.

959
00:46:46.220 --> 00:46:51.244
So we're like, ooh, okay, like this human accelerator region is like affecting brain development.

960
00:46:51.404 --> 00:46:51.644
Nice.

961
00:46:51.925 --> 00:46:53.326
There was another one, HAR2.

962
00:46:54.046 --> 00:46:57.108
That one became correlated with the opposable thumb.

963
00:46:57.749 --> 00:46:58.469
We're like, ooh, okay.

964
00:46:59.470 --> 00:47:03.472
Notice, there's no protein for the opposable thumb.

965
00:47:03.532 --> 00:47:10.536
But there's a switch that's telling whatever protein is doing this to be like, make it a little bit longer and make it a little bit over there.

966
00:47:11.417 --> 00:47:12.478
Yeah.

967
00:47:12.698 --> 00:47:15.860
Like chimpanzees have thumbs, but they're not so nice.

968
00:47:15.940 --> 00:47:16.180
Right.

969
00:47:16.200 --> 00:47:18.241
They're like, make ours pretty.

970
00:47:18.261 --> 00:47:18.521
Yeah.

971
00:47:18.641 --> 00:47:24.765
And then that same gene is also doing foot evolution, like ankle, so that we can be bipedal.

972
00:47:24.945 --> 00:47:26.606
So now you start getting this like –

973
00:47:27.666 --> 00:47:32.290
correlation between human accelerated regions and human characteristics.

974
00:47:32.690 --> 00:47:38.214
Just to make sure I'm tracking on this, because this is so fascinating, the machinery that you're talking about.

975
00:47:38.334 --> 00:47:44.238
One of the key insights here among many is that the machinery that's dictating the protein synthesis,

976
00:47:45.948 --> 00:47:47.649
has different instruction manuals.

977
00:47:47.929 --> 00:47:48.149
Yeah.

978
00:47:48.429 --> 00:47:50.309
In these, particularly in these HARs.

979
00:47:50.689 --> 00:47:50.909
Yeah.

980
00:47:51.290 --> 00:47:54.290
Well, these HARs are the sort of instruction manuals.

981
00:47:54.310 --> 00:47:55.091
Instruction manual, okay, got it.

982
00:47:55.111 --> 00:47:57.691
On how to use that protein, how much to use.

983
00:47:57.932 --> 00:47:58.212
Got it.

984
00:47:58.472 --> 00:47:58.772
Got it.

985
00:47:58.992 --> 00:47:59.572
Got it, right.

986
00:47:59.752 --> 00:48:00.312
When to use.

987
00:48:00.352 --> 00:48:01.553
When to use.

988
00:48:01.713 --> 00:48:09.115
And so one of the, what's interesting is then that totally changes the picture of trying to then now map

989
00:48:10.055 --> 00:48:28.225
how even though 98%, 99% of the base pairs are similar, the differences in this machinery are not only great in that first set, which all vertebrates have, etc., but also in the second set where there's a difference between us and chimps have this special set of stuff, but ours is even more extra special.

990
00:48:28.345 --> 00:48:30.646
Even more extra special, yeah.

991
00:48:30.666 --> 00:48:32.567
There's a bunch of mutations in these HARs.

992
00:48:32.867 --> 00:48:33.769
We've got 3000 HARs.

993
00:48:33.789 --> 00:48:34.289
Okay.

994
00:48:34.690 --> 00:48:34.910
Okay.

995
00:48:34.990 --> 00:48:41.060
But the problem until now, and this is where the study is like, I think it's a beautiful exercise in science.

996
00:48:41.160 --> 00:48:41.841
Okay.

997
00:48:41.881 --> 00:48:48.271
The reason for that is, so before like HARs were pretty hard to nail down what is actually happening.

998
00:48:48.711 --> 00:48:50.952
Because frequently they affect brain development.

999
00:48:51.492 --> 00:48:57.853
Brain development and just brain in general, it's really hard to study without the current tools that we have now.

1000
00:48:58.133 --> 00:49:01.194
This kind of study would only be possible in today's world.

1001
00:49:01.214 --> 00:49:02.414
Because of the other tools.

1002
00:49:02.454 --> 00:49:11.496
Yeah, because all of the stuff that they did to go from correlation, which is what I told you about, oh, HAR2, opposable thumbs, it's kind of related.

1003
00:49:18.998 --> 00:49:29.748
cause it like give causation links from HAR 123, which is what they're studying here all the way to what is happening in the brain.

1004
00:49:30.248 --> 00:49:30.529
Okay.

1005
00:49:30.549 --> 00:49:30.849
Wow.

1006
00:49:31.029 --> 00:49:32.170
And that's what we're going to go through.

1007
00:49:32.250 --> 00:49:32.510
Okay.

1008
00:49:32.610 --> 00:49:32.871
Okay.

1009
00:49:33.251 --> 00:49:38.255
So first you've got to identify HAR 123, right?

1010
00:49:38.295 --> 00:49:38.896
How do you do that?

1011
00:49:38.956 --> 00:49:45.222
Well, um, so it's a 442 base pair segment and there were nine, um, differences.

1012
00:49:46.247 --> 00:49:48.829
Might not sound like a lot, but it's actually pretty significant.

1013
00:49:48.869 --> 00:49:49.129
Okay.

1014
00:49:49.369 --> 00:49:57.115
So the mammalian mutation rate is about like 10 to the – one part in 10 to the 9 per year.

1015
00:49:57.535 --> 00:50:02.759
So one part – like one in a billion base pairs per year gets – Mutates.

1016
00:50:02.979 --> 00:50:03.860
Mutates, right?

1017
00:50:04.200 --> 00:50:07.582
So we've – the divergence is maybe let's say 6 million years.

1018
00:50:08.403 --> 00:50:10.525
So 6 million times –

1019
00:50:11.205 --> 00:50:15.451
Divided by 1 billion, that's going to give you 6 divided by 1,000.

1020
00:50:15.851 --> 00:50:16.091
Okay?

1021
00:50:16.312 --> 00:50:21.759
So for every 1,000 base pairs, we should have about 6 changes.

1022
00:50:21.939 --> 00:50:22.179
Okay.

1023
00:50:22.300 --> 00:50:22.560
Okay?

1024
00:50:23.621 --> 00:50:27.687
Now, which means for 442 nucleotides, we should have about 2 or 3.

1025
00:50:28.267 --> 00:50:28.628
We've got 9.

1026
00:50:29.769 --> 00:50:30.089
Okay.

1027
00:50:30.149 --> 00:50:30.409
Okay.

1028
00:50:30.589 --> 00:50:30.770
Yeah.

1029
00:50:30.790 --> 00:50:33.251
Like statistically now you can start doing this math.

1030
00:50:33.371 --> 00:50:33.571
Right.

1031
00:50:33.831 --> 00:50:33.991
Right.

1032
00:50:34.011 --> 00:50:36.092
Where it's like, we're expecting two or three.

1033
00:50:36.152 --> 00:50:37.092
This isn't four or five.

1034
00:50:37.132 --> 00:50:37.733
This is nine.

1035
00:50:37.793 --> 00:50:38.893
It's a three or three times.

1036
00:50:38.913 --> 00:50:39.113
Yeah.

1037
00:50:39.133 --> 00:50:39.373
Three times.

1038
00:50:39.393 --> 00:50:39.593
Right.

1039
00:50:39.793 --> 00:50:44.996
Which means like, and because this is a nice binomial distribution, we can like calculate the probability for that.

1040
00:50:45.356 --> 00:50:47.217
And it's like, no, this is not by chance.

1041
00:50:47.277 --> 00:50:54.400
Like this is sort of like evolution kind of directed HRR 123 to change in this direction.

1042
00:50:54.420 --> 00:50:57.101
You know, who's going to perk up when you hear that?

1043
00:50:57.181 --> 00:50:57.381
What?

1044
00:50:57.441 --> 00:50:57.701
Who?

1045
00:50:57.801 --> 00:50:59.382
All the people, all the alien people.

1046
00:50:59.942 --> 00:51:00.322
Oh, really?

1047
00:51:00.362 --> 00:51:07.304
Yeah, because because because the key of the core story is we were genetically engineered by the aliens.

1048
00:51:07.324 --> 00:51:11.225
And that explains right in our divergence in our evolution.

1049
00:51:11.285 --> 00:51:17.827
OK, well, if aliens are natural selection in in some abstract way, I don't even know.

1050
00:51:18.187 --> 00:51:23.309
Then then I guess it makes sense because we are genetically sort of engineered, but through a process of natural selection.

1051
00:51:23.709 --> 00:51:24.069
Right.

1052
00:51:24.169 --> 00:51:26.870
It's just like those who got this were like way smarter, I guess.

1053
00:51:27.450 --> 00:51:31.791
And so they were like, and then back then there's no like society or ethics.

1054
00:51:31.851 --> 00:51:32.131
Yeah.

1055
00:51:32.171 --> 00:51:34.112
So the other people just like die.

1056
00:51:34.232 --> 00:51:34.592
Yeah.

1057
00:51:34.672 --> 00:51:34.852
Right.

1058
00:51:34.892 --> 00:51:37.092
And then, you know, like now it's like, okay.

1059
00:51:37.332 --> 00:51:42.014
But like back then, so this is how you would have some kind of genetic drift like that.

1060
00:51:42.074 --> 00:51:42.234
Right.

1061
00:51:42.254 --> 00:51:46.315
Like those who are smarter, procreate more and then you get genetic drift in this direction.

1062
00:51:46.355 --> 00:51:50.816
So then this is how HR 123 starts sort of coming in.

1063
00:51:51.096 --> 00:51:51.376
Okay.

1064
00:51:52.623 --> 00:51:56.385
So first thing they got to do is establish what is HAR-123.

1065
00:51:56.485 --> 00:51:56.825
Okay.

1066
00:51:57.905 --> 00:52:09.530
So what they did was they do this thing called a luciferase assay where they attach it to, they basically attach it to a plasmid that has this luciferase protein.

1067
00:52:10.691 --> 00:52:17.794
And then the HAR-123, when it gets activated, it's going to activate the luciferase and then it's going to glow.

1068
00:52:18.314 --> 00:52:21.155
And then so now you've established it as an enhancer.

1069
00:52:21.295 --> 00:52:21.535
Okay.

1070
00:52:21.555 --> 00:52:21.736
Okay.

1071
00:52:21.976 --> 00:52:24.301
So now it's like, okay, HR-123 is an enhancer.

1072
00:52:24.441 --> 00:52:25.282
Not a promoter.

1073
00:52:25.443 --> 00:52:26.064
Not a promoter.

1074
00:52:26.144 --> 00:52:26.885
It's an enhancer.

1075
00:52:26.986 --> 00:52:27.226
Okay.

1076
00:52:27.246 --> 00:52:27.467
Okay.

1077
00:52:28.569 --> 00:52:30.913
So we've proven that it's enhancer activity.

1078
00:52:30.933 --> 00:52:31.294
Mm-hmm.

1079
00:52:32.499 --> 00:52:39.525
Next thing we're going to do is we're going to say, okay, what does – where does this enhancer express itself?

1080
00:52:40.446 --> 00:52:40.706
Okay.

1081
00:52:41.226 --> 00:52:42.027
This one's interesting.

1082
00:52:42.127 --> 00:52:46.711
So they use something called mouse transgenic enhancer assay.

1083
00:52:46.851 --> 00:52:47.552
Oh, my God.

1084
00:52:47.892 --> 00:52:49.093
Did you see this story?

1085
00:52:49.293 --> 00:52:49.493
No.

1086
00:52:49.593 --> 00:52:51.695
About transgenic mice in the news?

1087
00:52:51.715 --> 00:52:51.935
No.

1088
00:52:53.136 --> 00:52:54.017
If you can imagine.

1089
00:52:54.177 --> 00:52:54.477
Okay.

1090
00:52:54.637 --> 00:52:55.077
Let's hear it.

1091
00:52:55.097 --> 00:52:57.398
There's been a lot of defunding of government programs.

1092
00:52:57.678 --> 00:52:58.579
Oh, no way.

1093
00:53:00.860 --> 00:53:11.224
And one of the programs that got all these headlines was the woke left is trying to make mice trans because they didn't know what the words trans.

1094
00:53:11.244 --> 00:53:11.645
No.

1095
00:53:11.785 --> 00:53:13.766
I swear to God.

1096
00:53:13.966 --> 00:53:14.066
No.

1097
00:53:14.086 --> 00:53:15.406
We'll put it up in the video.

1098
00:53:15.486 --> 00:53:15.707
Yeah.

1099
00:53:16.027 --> 00:53:18.548
This was a whole thing like maybe two months ago, three months ago.

1100
00:53:19.068 --> 00:53:23.251
So this does not mean that you're making mice trans.

1101
00:53:23.311 --> 00:53:23.811
No, no.

1102
00:53:24.031 --> 00:53:27.273
Transgenic meaning like they're genetically altered.

1103
00:53:28.074 --> 00:53:32.436
They're like lab specific mice that are not found in the wild.

1104
00:53:34.497 --> 00:53:37.279
And they couldn't care less about their...

1105
00:53:37.319 --> 00:53:38.300
I didn't mean to get you off your...

1106
00:53:38.960 --> 00:53:45.629
But I mean, the government is now literally not allowing funding for studies that involve doing stuff with transgenic mice, which means we do.

1107
00:53:45.649 --> 00:53:46.711
That's going to cripple.

1108
00:53:46.911 --> 00:53:47.172
I know.

1109
00:53:47.192 --> 00:53:47.732
Like, I know.

1110
00:53:48.473 --> 00:53:48.694
I know.

1111
00:53:49.174 --> 00:53:49.935
Genetic studies.

1112
00:53:50.076 --> 00:53:50.256
I know.

1113
00:53:50.276 --> 00:53:50.837
That's going to like.

1114
00:53:51.177 --> 00:53:51.397
I know.

1115
00:53:51.478 --> 00:53:53.901
Like, this is like a bread and butter for a lot of these labs.

1116
00:53:54.121 --> 00:53:54.302
I know.

1117
00:53:55.623 --> 00:53:56.044
Please continue.

1118
00:53:56.064 --> 00:53:56.304
All right.

1119
00:53:56.344 --> 00:53:59.307
Anyways, back when we had the ability to do this.

1120
00:53:59.727 --> 00:54:00.268
Think about this.

1121
00:54:00.308 --> 00:54:02.910
This is actually like insane how we can do this.

1122
00:54:03.291 --> 00:54:07.575
So we take a mouse like embryo.

1123
00:54:07.815 --> 00:54:07.995
Yes.

1124
00:54:08.115 --> 00:54:08.335
Okay.

1125
00:54:08.616 --> 00:54:17.584
And then we're going to stick in this HAR-123 with an assay that's going to make it like whenever this thing gets expressed, the stuff is going to glow.

1126
00:54:17.864 --> 00:54:17.965
Okay.

1127
00:54:17.985 --> 00:54:18.145
Okay.

1128
00:54:18.665 --> 00:54:23.890
Now that embryo has your promote or your enhancer.

1129
00:54:23.910 --> 00:54:24.170
Sorry.

1130
00:54:24.250 --> 00:54:24.511
H.A.R.

1131
00:54:24.571 --> 00:54:25.091
one twenty three.

1132
00:54:25.652 --> 00:54:29.595
You're going to stick that into a mom and then they're going to make babies.

1133
00:54:30.116 --> 00:54:34.900
Then you can DNA sequence the babies to make sure that they have that.

1134
00:54:35.401 --> 00:54:38.844
And then whatever babies that have that, then you create more of those.

1135
00:54:39.945 --> 00:54:53.788
And then now what you can do is when the young mice, the prenatal mice are developing, you can halt their development and then you can look for where in their brain.

1136
00:54:55.107 --> 00:54:57.769
this particular enhancer is being expressed.

1137
00:54:57.809 --> 00:54:59.911
Oh my, that's okay.

1138
00:54:59.931 --> 00:55:00.772
You see what I'm saying?

1139
00:55:00.792 --> 00:55:01.212
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1140
00:55:01.232 --> 00:55:04.695
And you can only do this with like, with like now modern day, like technology.

1141
00:55:04.715 --> 00:55:05.236
Right, right.

1142
00:55:05.636 --> 00:55:06.377
It's insane.

1143
00:55:06.457 --> 00:55:20.609
Because now what you're saying is, where it's being expressed in the brain is allowing us to create that through line you talked about earlier, from the beginning of just the identification of this area to how is it actually

1144
00:55:22.492 --> 00:55:26.758
acting in the development process of its end destination, which is the brain in this case.

1145
00:55:26.798 --> 00:55:27.479
Yeah.

1146
00:55:27.639 --> 00:55:31.124
And what they found was they could – so here's what we can do.

1147
00:55:31.445 --> 00:55:36.853
We can put in the human version, and we can also put in the chimp version and see what is the difference.

1148
00:55:38.114 --> 00:55:54.132
ah so now that's the key at the end of the of the road we can see where where is the the chip version of hr123 going and where is the human version going and the human version is going in the forebrain and the midbrain yeah and the chip version is going in the hide brain from just nine base pair differences

1149
00:55:55.033 --> 00:56:01.599
And so the point here being from just this nine base pair difference between us and chimpanzees.

1150
00:56:01.639 --> 00:56:03.561
It's targeting different regions in the brain.

1151
00:56:03.801 --> 00:56:12.169
And how it develops such that like this gets back to the whole point of how is it that a small difference can have such an outsized impact.

1152
00:56:12.489 --> 00:56:13.890
It's because it's fundamentally.

1153
00:56:13.910 --> 00:56:14.031
Yeah.

1154
00:56:14.691 --> 00:56:37.411
changing over the evolutionary time what at like what it actually is developing yeah particularly like if we talk about the brain use case yeah in this case it's like the forebrain and that's like sort of where like higher mental capacity so you know now we're on to something right and and that's what i meant by like this this study is really cool in terms of all the techniques that they used and compounded on top compounded on top and they weren't done

1155
00:56:37.831 --> 00:56:38.071
Okay.

1156
00:56:38.291 --> 00:56:41.612
So after that, then they get embryonic stem cells.

1157
00:56:42.113 --> 00:56:42.273
Yep.

1158
00:56:42.433 --> 00:56:42.693
Okay.

1159
00:56:42.733 --> 00:56:49.915
Human embryonic stem cells, which is basically like a model for embryonic development in a Petri dish.

1160
00:56:49.975 --> 00:56:54.017
You can now sort of like get – and embryonic stem cells are basically –

1161
00:56:54.777 --> 00:56:56.338
cells who don't know who they are.

1162
00:56:56.758 --> 00:56:57.038
Okay.

1163
00:56:57.078 --> 00:57:06.161
They haven't had their, um, you know, identity, um, you know, teenage years where they're like, I'm going to be God, you know, or like, I'm going to be a skin cell.

1164
00:57:06.201 --> 00:57:08.661
I'm going to be an, I'm going to be, you know, a bone.

1165
00:57:08.842 --> 00:57:09.022
Yeah.

1166
00:57:09.082 --> 00:57:13.103
Like these are all cells that, that are still trying to figure out what they're going to be.

1167
00:57:13.563 --> 00:57:19.465
So now this is where we can put in, um, HR one 23 and see what's going to happen.

1168
00:57:19.985 --> 00:57:26.427
Okay, so here what they did was, you know, these human stem cells already have HR123, right?

1169
00:57:27.007 --> 00:57:28.628
So you can go in with CRISPR-Cas9.

1170
00:57:28.708 --> 00:57:30.688
Yeah, CRISPR strikes again.

1171
00:57:30.708 --> 00:57:31.428
CRISPR strikes again.

1172
00:57:31.448 --> 00:57:32.589
This is something that we can do now.

1173
00:57:32.989 --> 00:57:41.231
We can take CRISPR-Cas9 and we can cut out the entire gene, the 442, right?

1174
00:57:41.732 --> 00:57:42.192
Yes, yes.

1175
00:57:42.372 --> 00:57:46.193
We can cut that out and say, okay, what's going to happen?

1176
00:57:47.302 --> 00:57:51.263
And we can, instead of cutting it out, we can also put in the chip version and be like, what's going to happen?

1177
00:57:51.723 --> 00:58:01.705
And what you see is that, so these cells, you can induce them to become sort of brain cells.

1178
00:58:02.345 --> 00:58:15.608
But those that don't have the human version of that HAR123, they don't make the precursors to neurons as well as the ones that do.

1179
00:58:16.128 --> 00:58:20.011
These are called neural progenitor cells, I believe.

1180
00:58:20.571 --> 00:58:21.231
NPCs.

1181
00:58:22.232 --> 00:58:24.353
Not those NPCs.

1182
00:58:24.393 --> 00:58:25.134
Right when I say that.

1183
00:58:25.394 --> 00:58:30.077
Yeah, but in this case, these are like the baby neurons that become our brain.

1184
00:58:30.197 --> 00:58:32.539
It's the prerequisite to get the final form.

1185
00:58:32.599 --> 00:58:36.301
And so what they found was in these stem cells, you took out the HR-123.

1186
00:58:37.542 --> 00:58:44.711
You can no longer generate neurons in glia with as much fidelity as you could before.

1187
00:58:44.971 --> 00:58:45.932
Which is like obvious.

1188
00:58:45.952 --> 00:58:46.833
Now it's making sense.

1189
00:58:47.054 --> 00:58:47.254
Right.

1190
00:58:47.294 --> 00:58:47.494
Right?

1191
00:58:47.734 --> 00:58:48.035
Exactly.

1192
00:58:48.095 --> 00:58:50.998
It's like in the mouse brain, it was like different regions.

1193
00:58:51.058 --> 00:58:53.541
Now it's like this thing also is promoting...

1194
00:58:54.863 --> 00:58:56.284
neurons and glia in a specific way.

1195
00:58:56.344 --> 00:59:00.928
Because this goes back to the enhancer can sort of impact what the motor does.

1196
00:59:00.948 --> 00:59:01.729
That gene is still there.

1197
00:59:01.849 --> 00:59:03.570
All of the proteins are still there.

1198
00:59:03.610 --> 00:59:04.451
That's what's key here.

1199
00:59:04.671 --> 00:59:04.871
Yes.

1200
00:59:04.971 --> 00:59:06.152
All of the proteins are still there.

1201
00:59:06.192 --> 00:59:09.775
All we've done is like take out the volume control and put in a new one.

1202
00:59:09.956 --> 00:59:11.177
And the new one's just like shitty.

1203
00:59:11.357 --> 00:59:11.477
Right.

1204
00:59:11.517 --> 00:59:14.259
And if it's dialed to 11, it works.

1205
00:59:14.560 --> 00:59:14.760
Yeah.

1206
00:59:14.780 --> 00:59:17.262
But if it's dialed to 4, it doesn't work as well.

1207
00:59:17.402 --> 00:59:18.142
Yeah, yeah.

1208
00:59:18.243 --> 00:59:27.328
And then you can take these cells and then you can do something called RNA sequencing where you try to figure out what are the RNA that's being expressed?

1209
00:59:27.428 --> 00:59:27.568
Yep.

1210
00:59:27.609 --> 00:59:29.950
What are the RNA that's being transcribed from the genes?

1211
00:59:30.030 --> 00:59:30.170
Yep.

1212
00:59:30.290 --> 00:59:34.493
And you can see that these cells are sort of getting halted at some, like, intermediate state.

1213
00:59:34.513 --> 00:59:39.556
They're not going all the way fully to become these, like, NPCs that are then going to become neurons.

1214
00:59:39.636 --> 00:59:40.797
On the chimpanzee side.

1215
00:59:40.837 --> 00:59:41.297
Yeah.

1216
00:59:41.317 --> 00:59:41.477
Yeah.

1217
00:59:41.557 --> 00:59:41.698
Yes.

1218
00:59:41.718 --> 00:59:41.898
Yeah.

1219
00:59:41.998 --> 00:59:42.278
Yeah.

1220
00:59:42.578 --> 00:59:42.818
Yeah.

1221
00:59:43.058 --> 00:59:48.861
And then so then now it's like now the next thing they did, this is all in vitro in a Petri dish.

1222
00:59:48.921 --> 00:59:50.541
So they've done in vivo studies with the mouse.

1223
00:59:50.701 --> 00:59:50.881
Yes.

1224
00:59:50.941 --> 00:59:51.962
Right now in vitro.

1225
00:59:52.262 --> 01:00:01.566
The other thing they do is this thing called high C chromatin capture, which is sort of a way of mapping out how the bulk DNA is working.

1226
01:00:01.926 --> 01:00:02.066
Right.

1227
01:00:02.086 --> 01:00:04.707
Because like I told you, this enhancer is like kind of like.

1228
01:00:05.880 --> 01:00:07.861
a little bit far away from where the protein is.

1229
01:00:07.921 --> 01:00:08.122
Yes.

1230
01:00:08.182 --> 01:00:11.344
But you can now see and visualize like – How it folds to get close.

1231
01:00:11.364 --> 01:00:22.631
Like the proximity of like this thing to that and see that, oh, this thing really is regulating this particular gene called HIC1, which is called hypermethylated in cancer one.

1232
01:00:23.471 --> 01:00:25.253
It doesn't have to do specifically with cancer.

1233
01:00:25.273 --> 01:00:27.054
It actually has to do a lot with brain development.

1234
01:00:27.334 --> 01:00:32.257
But because of historical reasons, it was first found in the 1990s as having to do something with cancers.

1235
01:00:32.317 --> 01:00:34.939
And then they're like, we're going to name it hypermethylated in cancer one.

1236
01:00:34.959 --> 01:00:35.139
Yeah.

1237
01:00:35.800 --> 01:00:38.263
So now that's just like what we're stuck with.

1238
01:00:38.704 --> 01:00:48.076
But like, but this, this, this brain, this, this HIC1 is like involved in brain development.

1239
01:00:48.296 --> 01:00:51.820
And so you can see that this enhancer is going and like affecting that guy.

1240
01:00:51.860 --> 01:00:52.001
Yes.

1241
01:00:52.421 --> 01:01:05.495
You know what's interesting about kind of how you're talking through this is at each stage of the process from the DNA all the way through the like protein synthesis.

1242
01:01:06.476 --> 01:01:13.743
When you're talking about the promoter, the enhancer, and then like the actual process of the proteins getting generated and how they form.

1243
01:01:14.564 --> 01:01:24.489
They basically put systems or tools or machinery at each of those stages to be able to monitor and actually track what's happening with different switching out.

1244
01:01:24.550 --> 01:01:24.850
Yeah.

1245
01:01:24.950 --> 01:01:25.170
Yeah.

1246
01:01:25.230 --> 01:01:25.470
Very.

1247
01:01:25.490 --> 01:01:29.072
I mean, it's like it's yeah, it's it's it's decades and decades of research.

1248
01:01:29.172 --> 01:01:29.352
Right.

1249
01:01:29.372 --> 01:01:33.034
Like other people creating these tools that now that they have the suite.

1250
01:01:33.434 --> 01:01:35.736
They're just like throwing the whole thing.

1251
01:01:35.756 --> 01:01:36.056
Right.

1252
01:01:36.116 --> 01:01:36.296
Right.

1253
01:01:36.316 --> 01:01:38.717
They took the whole toolbox out and said, we're going to look at everything.

1254
01:01:38.737 --> 01:01:40.258
Yeah, we're going to do the whole thing.

1255
01:01:40.538 --> 01:01:43.600
And then finally, this is this is when it gets crazy.

1256
01:01:44.080 --> 01:01:51.042
Finally, they're like, okay, so we've established all of these causation links between like development and the thing.

1257
01:01:52.583 --> 01:01:55.643
Does it actually impact cognitive ability?

1258
01:01:56.924 --> 01:01:58.604
You can only test that with behavior.

1259
01:01:59.565 --> 01:02:08.287
So they literally raised knockout mouse that don't have this gene or this enhancer.

1260
01:02:08.347 --> 01:02:09.327
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1261
01:02:11.688 --> 01:02:16.050
And then they compared it with the ones that do.

1262
01:02:16.230 --> 01:02:16.430
Yes.

1263
01:02:16.650 --> 01:02:16.910
Okay?

1264
01:02:17.690 --> 01:02:19.691
And this is what's crazy.

1265
01:02:20.171 --> 01:02:23.213
So the mice, so they both, they're fine.

1266
01:02:23.913 --> 01:02:24.813
They grow up.

1267
01:02:24.973 --> 01:02:25.153
Yes.

1268
01:02:25.774 --> 01:02:26.454
They're fertile.

1269
01:02:26.654 --> 01:02:27.474
They can have babies.

1270
01:02:27.834 --> 01:02:28.034
Right?

1271
01:02:28.355 --> 01:02:31.296
So which means that, like, it's not, again, this is not a protein.

1272
01:02:31.336 --> 01:02:33.256
If you took out the protein, this thing would be.

1273
01:02:33.336 --> 01:02:37.478
But this is a volume control on some, it's an enhancer.

1274
01:02:37.498 --> 01:02:38.819
It's regulating the proteins.

1275
01:02:38.899 --> 01:02:39.079
Right?

1276
01:02:39.439 --> 01:02:39.699
So, yeah.

1277
01:02:40.199 --> 01:02:42.842
The mice are fine, whether it's wild type or whether it's knockout.

1278
01:02:43.603 --> 01:02:49.849
But the knockout mouse could also learn just fine.

1279
01:02:50.229 --> 01:02:57.837
There's this thing called the barn's maze, which is a standard test where you stick a mouse in the middle and then there's a bunch of tunnels that go out.

1280
01:02:58.157 --> 01:03:00.600
And then there's one tunnel that leads to the cheese.

1281
01:03:00.940 --> 01:03:03.843
So he learns this is the tunnel that leads to the cheese, and he goes down this tunnel.

1282
01:03:04.203 --> 01:03:26.340
several tries he's like okay there's the tunnel and then they know right and then they know and remember everyone could do that just fine there's also this thing called the morse water maze which is um where like you put them in water that's like opaque so it's like kind of milky so they can't see anything but there's like a platform that's hidden just underneath the water so they don't know where the water is but looking at the visual cues they can be like oh the platform is over there they go over there they get a little bit of cheese

1283
01:03:26.737 --> 01:03:27.698
Okay.

1284
01:03:28.019 --> 01:03:28.779
They can do those fine.

1285
01:03:29.300 --> 01:03:36.028
But now, what if we do a reversal test where we change where the platform is or we change which tunnel has the cheese?

1286
01:03:36.308 --> 01:03:38.090
The wild type might – they're going to go down.

1287
01:03:38.110 --> 01:03:40.593
They're going to be like, where's the cheese?

1288
01:03:40.613 --> 01:03:40.773
Yeah.

1289
01:03:40.793 --> 01:03:41.594
They're going to come back.

1290
01:03:41.614 --> 01:03:44.617
They're going to try everything else, find the one, and then relearn.

1291
01:03:44.758 --> 01:03:46.479
Immediately be like, okay, this is the new one.

1292
01:03:46.580 --> 01:03:46.760
Yep.

1293
01:03:47.841 --> 01:03:48.801
Same with the Morse water maze.

1294
01:03:48.821 --> 01:03:50.642
You take out the platform, they go swim over there.

1295
01:03:50.682 --> 01:03:51.543
They're like, where's the platform?

1296
01:03:51.563 --> 01:03:51.923
It's not here.

1297
01:03:52.183 --> 01:03:52.784
They keep swimming.

1298
01:03:52.804 --> 01:03:53.824
They find the new platform.

1299
01:03:53.844 --> 01:03:56.626
They learn pretty quickly that this is the new platform.

1300
01:03:56.646 --> 01:03:57.787
They go there, they get the reward.

1301
01:03:58.147 --> 01:04:02.650
The ones without HR 123 could not do that.

1302
01:04:03.130 --> 01:04:05.432
Once they learned it, they were just stuck in that behavior.

1303
01:04:05.532 --> 01:04:07.193
This sort of relearning paradigm.

1304
01:04:07.493 --> 01:04:13.219
Now, it's kind of dangerous to, like, take this and extrapolate to, like, what humans are doing for learning, right?

1305
01:04:13.239 --> 01:04:14.440
Because the mouse brain is different.

1306
01:04:14.480 --> 01:04:19.646
But the point of this thing is that, like, it's not impairing the brain even.

1307
01:04:19.766 --> 01:04:19.966
Right.

1308
01:04:20.286 --> 01:04:23.490
But it's impairing, like, specific qualities when it comes to learning.

1309
01:04:23.530 --> 01:04:23.710
Right.

1310
01:04:24.110 --> 01:04:24.251
Right.

1311
01:04:24.291 --> 01:04:24.471
Right?

1312
01:04:24.611 --> 01:04:25.732
And learning behavior.

1313
01:04:25.752 --> 01:04:27.214
And it's, like, very specific.

1314
01:04:27.254 --> 01:04:27.394
Right.

1315
01:04:27.594 --> 01:04:33.839
So imagine what it's doing in the brain of a human being, right, compared to a chimpanzee, right?

1316
01:04:33.979 --> 01:04:46.269
It's an incredible paper because it's like going all the way from the bioinformatics of, okay, we've identified using mathematics and using like this kind of matching that maybe this is something we can target.

1317
01:04:46.749 --> 01:04:54.591
Now all the way to we've got all of these like cell and developmental techniques that we can like put it through.

1318
01:04:55.111 --> 01:04:57.891
And then also now this in vivo study of like behavior.

1319
01:04:58.051 --> 01:04:58.231
Right.

1320
01:04:58.332 --> 01:05:00.712
It's like the full vertical integration.

1321
01:05:00.752 --> 01:05:00.912
Right.

1322
01:05:01.032 --> 01:05:01.192
Right.

1323
01:05:01.532 --> 01:05:02.312
Of of this.

1324
01:05:02.572 --> 01:05:06.833
And you can see where the diversions happen at each of those specific steps.

1325
01:05:06.893 --> 01:05:07.113
Yeah.

1326
01:05:07.213 --> 01:05:08.074
In that process.

1327
01:05:08.094 --> 01:05:08.414
Yeah.

1328
01:05:08.514 --> 01:05:09.254
It's pretty crazy.

1329
01:05:09.294 --> 01:05:11.354
Which is like it's more than pretty crazy.

1330
01:05:11.374 --> 01:05:12.234
Yeah.

1331
01:05:12.434 --> 01:05:14.275
It's just such a cool like story.

1332
01:05:14.295 --> 01:05:14.555
It's like.

1333
01:05:15.175 --> 01:05:16.636
They really like close the book.

1334
01:05:16.976 --> 01:05:18.277
They wrote every chapter.

1335
01:05:18.637 --> 01:05:19.658
Yeah.

1336
01:05:20.238 --> 01:05:21.959
That's actually fascinating.

1337
01:05:22.099 --> 01:05:28.042
I mean, that's so I mean, I imagine just just like we talk a lot about about experimental design.

1338
01:05:28.142 --> 01:05:30.003
Yeah, I love experimental design and it's I think.

1339
01:05:30.123 --> 01:05:31.344
It's like, how do we know what we know?

1340
01:05:31.384 --> 01:05:32.324
Well, this is how we know.

1341
01:05:32.344 --> 01:05:33.105
This is how we know what we know.

1342
01:05:33.125 --> 01:05:51.317
And I think it's so important to talk about the experimental design because, again, people don't have context or understanding for, like, how deeply complex the process is to get to this headline, which is, you know, humans are 99% genetically identical chimpanzees.

1343
01:05:51.597 --> 01:05:53.558
How does the other 1% make us different?

1344
01:05:54.019 --> 01:05:56.781
It's not intuitive when you think of that 1% in the headline.

1345
01:05:56.821 --> 01:05:57.061
No.

1346
01:05:57.541 --> 01:06:05.585
That there's all this sort of first principle background that like helps me now really contextualize like, oh, that's how we know that makes sense.

1347
01:06:05.605 --> 01:06:18.730
That's how we got to this understanding of what the processes are and seeing where these differences in ours versus chimpanzees happen and understanding that it's not enough to just look at the base and say it's 99 and one.

1348
01:06:18.910 --> 01:06:26.774
No, it's all of these other sub processes that are impacted even by a very small amount of changes.

1349
01:06:26.894 --> 01:06:27.474
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1350
01:06:27.514 --> 01:06:29.035
And it's like we're not we're not making it up.

1351
01:06:29.315 --> 01:06:29.475
Right.

1352
01:06:29.495 --> 01:06:30.535
We did the experiments.

1353
01:06:30.635 --> 01:06:33.996
And then like this is what and somebody else can go and do it.

1354
01:06:34.016 --> 01:06:35.217
So in someone else can go and do it.

1355
01:06:35.337 --> 01:06:36.077
Yeah.

1356
01:06:36.277 --> 01:06:38.298
Maybe not the transgenic mice thing, though, unfortunately.

1357
01:06:38.318 --> 01:06:41.259
Yeah, unfortunately, yeah, these guys, these guys got more funding.

1358
01:06:41.999 --> 01:06:42.879
Oh, my God.

1359
01:06:42.999 --> 01:06:43.259
I know.

1360
01:06:43.279 --> 01:06:43.520
Yeah.

1361
01:06:43.540 --> 01:06:43.980
So crazy.

1362
01:06:44.080 --> 01:06:45.680
What a great story.

1363
01:06:45.700 --> 01:06:48.881
Look, California, by the way, was our first two stories.

1364
01:06:49.401 --> 01:06:49.882
Stanford.

1365
01:06:50.042 --> 01:06:50.462
Oh, yeah.

1366
01:06:50.482 --> 01:06:51.362
UC San Diego.

1367
01:06:51.582 --> 01:06:51.962
Easy.

1368
01:06:52.022 --> 01:06:53.823
The Republic of California continues.

1369
01:06:54.143 --> 01:06:56.685
Easy to be the light shining light on a hill.

1370
01:06:56.945 --> 01:06:57.706
Yeah.

1371
01:06:58.026 --> 01:06:58.146
Yeah.

1372
01:06:58.166 --> 01:06:59.848
Maybe Gavin Newsom is going to be like, you know what?

1373
01:06:59.908 --> 01:07:02.209
We are going to keep transgenic money.

1374
01:07:02.269 --> 01:07:02.670
That's true.

1375
01:07:02.690 --> 01:07:03.050
He's the guy.

1376
01:07:03.090 --> 01:07:04.291
He can do what he wants.

1377
01:07:04.331 --> 01:07:05.012
He can do what he wants.

1378
01:07:05.032 --> 01:07:08.134
We do have an 80 billion dollar surplus that we give back to federal government.

1379
01:07:08.154 --> 01:07:08.534
That's right.

1380
01:07:08.574 --> 01:07:09.555
Take a billion or two off.

1381
01:07:09.575 --> 01:07:09.775
Yeah.

1382
01:07:09.875 --> 01:07:10.136
Easy.

1383
01:07:11.316 --> 01:07:20.944
So we're not going to go across the pond, but in the opposite direction of the pond that people normally associate with that phrase from California all the way to Beijing.

1384
01:07:21.451 --> 01:07:26.013
where we have learned that diamonds have gotten an upgrade.

1385
01:07:27.794 --> 01:07:35.098
My wife immediately texted me when she saw the stories for today and was like, can you, I want you to tell me about this one after you're done.

1386
01:07:35.198 --> 01:07:35.978
Nice.

1387
01:07:36.158 --> 01:07:50.566
This is out of the Center for High Pressure Science and Technology Advanced Research in Beijing, where apparently scientists are able to create extra hard hexagonal diamonds

1388
01:07:51.386 --> 01:08:02.017
in the lab that are up to 60% stronger than normal diamonds and can be used to create super tough drilling and cutting tools for industrial applications.

1389
01:08:02.538 --> 01:08:04.219
Sorry, honey, this is not Tiffany's.

1390
01:08:04.520 --> 01:08:04.760
No.

1391
01:08:04.840 --> 01:08:07.162
But interesting nonetheless.

1392
01:08:07.203 --> 01:08:12.268
So help me understand what exactly is going on with this new lab grown diamond stuff.

1393
01:08:12.608 --> 01:08:12.808
Yeah.

1394
01:08:13.409 --> 01:08:14.130
So diamonds.

1395
01:08:14.811 --> 01:08:15.511
Girl's best friend.

1396
01:08:15.732 --> 01:08:16.853
Yes.

1397
01:08:17.574 --> 01:08:24.202
Usually when we think about diamonds, we're thinking about the thing that you're going to buy for your girl when you want to get the government involved.

1398
01:08:24.242 --> 01:08:24.442
Yes.

1399
01:08:24.502 --> 01:08:24.762
You know?

1400
01:08:25.002 --> 01:08:26.184
We love the government involved.

1401
01:08:27.265 --> 01:08:30.429
The diamond is a pure form of carbon.

1402
01:08:30.769 --> 01:08:30.989
Okay.

1403
01:08:31.029 --> 01:08:31.270
Okay?

1404
01:08:31.630 --> 01:08:32.831
Something called an allotrope.

1405
01:08:33.392 --> 01:08:35.673
There's nothing other than carbon in diamond.

1406
01:08:36.114 --> 01:08:36.334
Okay.

1407
01:08:36.434 --> 01:08:36.714
Okay?

1408
01:08:36.954 --> 01:08:37.695
Which is pretty cool.

1409
01:08:37.715 --> 01:08:38.755
That's pretty cool.

1410
01:08:38.895 --> 01:08:45.820
There's very few elements that actually do this kind of thing, where they form, like, a solid that is only that.

1411
01:08:47.020 --> 01:08:48.101
And it's, like, a compound.

1412
01:08:48.441 --> 01:08:50.683
Like, metals, I guess, do this, but they're not, like...

1413
01:08:51.263 --> 01:09:13.807
bonded in the sense that like diamonds are bonded like these these are covalent bonds between carbon atoms that make it so strong there's other allotropes of carbon and every time there's an allotrope of carbon it's like it does amazing things we've got carbon nanotubes which are like these like tubes made out of entirely of carbon that's the carbon fiber that you're like that we see in formula one and things like that yep

1414
01:09:14.467 --> 01:09:16.489
There's Bucky balls, the Buckminster Fuller Rain.

1415
01:09:16.509 --> 01:09:17.610
Yeah, my favorite.

1416
01:09:17.710 --> 01:09:18.751
The soccer ball, right?

1417
01:09:18.771 --> 01:09:19.171
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1418
01:09:19.231 --> 01:09:20.011
Made out of carbon.

1419
01:09:20.252 --> 01:09:20.752
Yep.

1420
01:09:20.832 --> 01:09:23.794
There's obviously also graphite, which is the thing in your pencil lead.

1421
01:09:24.375 --> 01:09:28.358
And graphene, which is a single layer of graphite.

1422
01:09:28.398 --> 01:09:32.681
That one won the Nobel Prize many years ago because that has, like, extraordinary electrical...

1423
01:09:33.221 --> 01:09:54.779
and um conducting properties i think batman's suit is based on graphene graphene yeah i can imagine it's a um it's it's like one of those things that you can use in movies right because there's so many unexplored things like oh quantum this like just say it yeah you know like graphene is one of those um where it's like there's so many unexplored areas for graphene that you can

1424
01:09:56.940 --> 01:09:59.201
Um, so diamond is one of those things.

1425
01:09:59.241 --> 01:10:04.863
It's called an L allotrope, um, where you have this like pure elemental covalently bonded, bonded form.

1426
01:10:05.583 --> 01:10:08.224
Um, and it is the hardest thing that we know on earth.

1427
01:10:08.664 --> 01:10:08.965
Okay.

1428
01:10:09.245 --> 01:10:15.627
On the most hardness scale, it is like by definition 10 because it's the hardest thing and it's used in industrial applications.

1429
01:10:15.707 --> 01:10:18.388
If you want to like cut stuff, like you use a diamond, right?

1430
01:10:18.448 --> 01:10:20.349
If you want to cut like really, really hard things.

1431
01:10:20.369 --> 01:10:21.189
Um, yeah.

1432
01:10:23.235 --> 01:10:26.597
We used to think the diamond was the most, the hardest thing.

1433
01:10:26.797 --> 01:10:31.260
And like we had sort of exhausted the possibilities on all the things that carbon could be.

1434
01:10:31.741 --> 01:10:31.961
Okay.

1435
01:10:32.281 --> 01:10:43.028
And then people started looking at this thing called the Canyon Diablo meteorite, which is the meteorite that fell on Arizona 50,000 years ago.

1436
01:10:43.068 --> 01:10:44.129
Have you been to Meteor Crater?

1437
01:10:44.449 --> 01:10:45.210
I know of it.

1438
01:10:45.270 --> 01:10:45.870
I've never been.

1439
01:10:45.990 --> 01:10:50.776
Yeah, it's right off the, I think it's off the 40 freeway.

1440
01:10:50.836 --> 01:10:51.256
40, yep.

1441
01:10:51.356 --> 01:10:54.660
Yeah, on your way from like Grand Canyon to Albuquerque.

1442
01:10:56.062 --> 01:10:58.084
It's a wonderful place.

1443
01:10:58.184 --> 01:11:04.351
It's the best preserved meteor crater on the planet because in these arid conditions, you see this beautiful.

1444
01:11:04.592 --> 01:11:05.833
It was also only 50,000 years ago.

1445
01:11:06.654 --> 01:11:08.196
America always has the best.

1446
01:11:08.236 --> 01:11:09.638
We always got the best.

1447
01:11:09.678 --> 01:11:10.940
Yeah.

1448
01:11:11.221 --> 01:11:16.588
And so it was also like one of the first places that my dad visited when he came to America from India.

1449
01:11:17.670 --> 01:11:22.056
So I remember when I was like in India, I was like seeing like photos of the meteor crater going like, that's crazy.

1450
01:11:22.376 --> 01:11:22.596
You know.

1451
01:11:24.499 --> 01:11:26.963
So people found the meteorite for this thing.

1452
01:11:27.003 --> 01:11:30.948
It's a massive meteorite called the Canyon Diablo meteorite, 640 kilograms.

1453
01:11:31.609 --> 01:11:37.017
And in this, people started doing like chemical analyses and they thought they saw another form of a diamond.

1454
01:11:37.318 --> 01:11:37.618
Okay.

1455
01:11:37.698 --> 01:11:37.939
Okay.

1456
01:11:39.279 --> 01:11:40.960
It was called Lonsdalite.

1457
01:11:41.581 --> 01:11:41.861
Okay.

1458
01:11:42.441 --> 01:11:48.424
And it was this elusive hexagonal thing that people had theorized existed, but maybe it was in there.

1459
01:11:49.104 --> 01:11:50.124
Very trace amounts.

1460
01:11:50.685 --> 01:11:53.846
And there was controversy, like, are you really seeing what you're seeing?

1461
01:11:53.906 --> 01:11:55.007
Like, is this real?

1462
01:11:57.108 --> 01:12:01.690
People started doing theoretical modeling of it and were like, this thing would be even harder than diamond.

1463
01:12:02.350 --> 01:12:13.978
If if it was true, the hypothesis is that whatever carbon was in the meteorite, it slammed like this meteorite was so big that it didn't just like burn up in the Earth's atmosphere, actually slammed into the ground.

1464
01:12:14.018 --> 01:12:14.178
Right.

1465
01:12:14.478 --> 01:12:21.803
And when it slammed into into the ground, that carbon in all that high temperature and pressure fused into this new form, which makes sense of Leon's.

1466
01:12:22.003 --> 01:12:22.163
Yeah.

1467
01:12:22.363 --> 01:12:22.964
And it makes sense.

1468
01:12:23.264 --> 01:12:25.466
So and you see these trace amounts.

1469
01:12:25.486 --> 01:12:29.148
But ever since then, people have been on the hunt to try to make this thing.

1470
01:12:29.348 --> 01:12:29.608
Okay.

1471
01:12:29.868 --> 01:12:32.589
Because it's going to be kind of like a holy grail for material science.

1472
01:12:32.629 --> 01:12:32.769
Right.

1473
01:12:32.789 --> 01:12:34.830
You're going to get even harder than diamond.

1474
01:12:34.850 --> 01:12:36.811
You're going to get novel electrical properties.

1475
01:12:37.191 --> 01:12:42.053
Perhaps you can start using it in like quantum computers and like like all sorts of stuff.

1476
01:12:42.073 --> 01:12:42.233
Right.

1477
01:12:42.393 --> 01:12:42.513
Right.

1478
01:12:42.533 --> 01:12:45.275
So you want to you want to try and make it first.

1479
01:12:45.515 --> 01:12:48.296
But it ended up being extremely hard to make.

1480
01:12:48.576 --> 01:12:48.816
Okay.

1481
01:12:49.076 --> 01:12:49.316
Okay.

1482
01:12:52.197 --> 01:12:58.620
The reason for that is people were people were basically trying to put carbon under a lot of stress.

1483
01:13:00.858 --> 01:13:05.243
To hope for making this structure.

1484
01:13:05.303 --> 01:13:08.386
They should just put them in Princeton during grade deflation.

1485
01:13:08.646 --> 01:13:09.708
That'll be plenty of stress.

1486
01:13:09.728 --> 01:13:10.268
Yeah, dude.

1487
01:13:10.368 --> 01:13:11.910
Yeah, during finals week, easy.

1488
01:13:12.210 --> 01:13:13.151
That's where diamonds are made.

1489
01:13:15.093 --> 01:13:17.456
So they're trying to make this hexagonal diamond.

1490
01:13:17.776 --> 01:13:44.082
yes right the the the normal diamonds that we have those are called cubic diamonds cubic okay and that's because like the the way that the bonds all work it looks like it's it's got this like cubic form that repeats over and over in the hexagonal diamond you're gonna get hexagonal close packing where like the bonds are now slightly different but in this like weird hexagonal heterostructure that like with like two different bond lengths that becomes extremely

1491
01:13:47.763 --> 01:13:48.803
So you're trying to make this thing.

1492
01:13:49.504 --> 01:13:54.925
Everyone's, everyone's, um, process is basically the same high stress, high temperature, high pressure.

1493
01:13:55.545 --> 01:14:04.848
Um, what these guys did was they were like, we need to control this thing really, really well in order to actually make it.

1494
01:14:05.028 --> 01:14:05.248
Okay.

1495
01:14:05.288 --> 01:14:05.549
Okay.

1496
01:14:06.009 --> 01:14:07.729
So their setup is actually kind of crazy.

1497
01:14:08.349 --> 01:14:15.692
Um, their, their setup is they've got, um, a diamond anvil press.

1498
01:14:16.432 --> 01:14:16.672
Okay.

1499
01:14:16.872 --> 01:14:17.152
Okay.

1500
01:14:17.753 --> 01:14:20.735
You, they're, they're trying to reach pressures that are insane.

1501
01:14:20.755 --> 01:14:25.679
200,000 times the atmospheric pressure.

1502
01:14:25.919 --> 01:14:26.179
Okay.

1503
01:14:26.359 --> 01:14:26.599
Okay.

1504
01:14:26.920 --> 01:14:29.221
So Marianas Trench is like a thousand atmospheres.

1505
01:14:29.402 --> 01:14:33.385
This is 200 times the pressure that you see in Marianas Trench.

1506
01:14:33.405 --> 01:14:35.266
The highest pressure in the natural environment.

1507
01:14:35.366 --> 01:14:35.506
Yeah.

1508
01:14:35.546 --> 01:14:38.468
So how do we achieve that pressure without blowing everything up?

1509
01:14:38.729 --> 01:14:38.929
Right.

1510
01:14:39.489 --> 01:14:42.071
Well, you use the best thing there is, which is a diamond.

1511
01:14:42.792 --> 01:14:43.853
You make a press.

1512
01:14:44.313 --> 01:14:44.393
How?

1513
01:14:45.014 --> 01:14:45.715
Out of diamonds.

1514
01:14:45.795 --> 01:14:46.456
Oh, my God.

1515
01:14:46.476 --> 01:14:48.539
It's called a diamond anvil press.

1516
01:14:48.579 --> 01:14:50.381
Diamonds on diamonds.

1517
01:14:50.401 --> 01:14:50.942
Yeah, yeah.

1518
01:14:50.962 --> 01:14:54.447
They're using the old diamond to make the new diamond.

1519
01:14:54.547 --> 01:14:55.048
That's so funny.

1520
01:14:55.128 --> 01:14:55.348
Right?

1521
01:14:55.649 --> 01:14:55.829
Yeah.

1522
01:14:55.989 --> 01:14:56.830
It's kind of cool.

1523
01:14:56.850 --> 01:14:59.775
So they've got this diamond anvil cell that goes in like this.

1524
01:14:59.795 --> 01:15:00.035
Okay?

1525
01:15:00.055 --> 01:15:00.335
Okay.

1526
01:15:01.136 --> 01:15:04.219
And in that, you can now start squishing everything.

1527
01:15:04.520 --> 01:15:07.823
So it goes to extremely high pressure inside that thing.

1528
01:15:08.123 --> 01:15:10.906
They put in a single crystal of graphite.

1529
01:15:11.327 --> 01:15:16.832
OK, this is like you're the lead in your pencil is graphite, but it's not a single crystal.

1530
01:15:16.912 --> 01:15:21.257
It's usually like sheared layers, which is why, like, you know, you can like write with it like shears off.

1531
01:15:21.637 --> 01:15:22.759
This is a single crystal.

1532
01:15:22.779 --> 01:15:30.008
So you've got these hexagonal lattices that are on top of each other that are connected by Van der Waals forces, which are like just loose forces.

1533
01:15:30.028 --> 01:15:31.310
They're not covalently bonded.

1534
01:15:31.450 --> 01:15:31.931
Got it.

1535
01:15:32.291 --> 01:15:39.981
Like the layer within the layer itself, these hexagons are a bunch of carbons that are covalently bonded, but the two layers are not covalently bonded.

1536
01:15:40.261 --> 01:15:47.584
What we want to get is hexagonal layers that are now covalently bonded in like this, like crazy hexagonal sort of crystal.

1537
01:15:47.985 --> 01:15:48.145
Right.

1538
01:15:48.385 --> 01:15:50.226
So they start with a single crystal like that.

1539
01:15:50.526 --> 01:15:52.667
They pump it with all this pressure.

1540
01:15:52.947 --> 01:15:56.728
They have lasers that are heating it through the diamond.

1541
01:15:56.748 --> 01:15:57.409
Always have lasers.

1542
01:15:57.449 --> 01:15:58.589
Always have lasers.

1543
01:15:58.609 --> 01:16:01.711
When all has failed, just shine some lasers on it, heat it up.

1544
01:16:02.051 --> 01:16:06.673
So they're heating up this thing to like a thousand to like 1500 degrees Celsius.

1545
01:16:07.373 --> 01:16:10.375
So like, you know, 2000, 3000 degrees Fahrenheit.

1546
01:16:10.735 --> 01:16:15.638
And then they create this structure that they think is this hexagonal diamond.

1547
01:16:16.979 --> 01:16:20.060
And not only that, they haven't created like trace amounts.

1548
01:16:20.100 --> 01:16:22.662
They've created something like that's as big as a millimeter.

1549
01:16:23.142 --> 01:16:27.565
Which sounds like small, but like, dude, that's, you know, that's what, 10 to the 20 atoms?

1550
01:16:27.625 --> 01:16:27.905
Yeah.

1551
01:16:27.985 --> 01:16:28.525
That's a lot.

1552
01:16:28.665 --> 01:16:29.446
Yeah.

1553
01:16:29.486 --> 01:16:29.986
That's a lot.

1554
01:16:30.006 --> 01:16:30.366
Yeah.

1555
01:16:30.727 --> 01:16:32.428
And also it's a novel technique.

1556
01:16:32.708 --> 01:16:32.968
Yeah.

1557
01:16:33.048 --> 01:16:33.228
Right.

1558
01:16:33.248 --> 01:16:34.789
So they have to like first create.

1559
01:16:35.169 --> 01:16:38.130
first create even a million, even a millimeter's worth.

1560
01:16:38.410 --> 01:16:38.590
Right.

1561
01:16:38.630 --> 01:16:40.671
Like people had done way, way less.

1562
01:16:40.911 --> 01:16:44.492
We're like, you got to go into with the electron microscope and be like, I right there.

1563
01:16:44.532 --> 01:16:48.573
See, like that little part, that little part there's got a hexagonal diamond.

1564
01:16:48.593 --> 01:16:49.273
That's a diamond.

1565
01:16:49.293 --> 01:16:49.553
Yeah.

1566
01:16:49.593 --> 01:16:49.773
Yeah.

1567
01:16:49.813 --> 01:16:51.113
But here it's like a millimeter.

1568
01:16:51.153 --> 01:16:52.774
I can like see that with my naked eye.

1569
01:16:52.834 --> 01:16:53.094
Yeah.

1570
01:16:53.114 --> 01:16:55.314
You know, so so they finally did this.

1571
01:16:56.035 --> 01:16:58.275
And the first thing everyone's going to do is say, nah.

1572
01:16:58.515 --> 01:16:58.815
Yeah.

1573
01:16:58.835 --> 01:16:58.995
Right.

1574
01:16:59.516 --> 01:17:00.036
You didn't do it.

1575
01:17:00.056 --> 01:17:00.216
Right.

1576
01:17:01.396 --> 01:17:10.720
So they, again, just like those previous stories that we've had, we're going to run through a suite of tests to make sure that we're talking about what we're talking about.

1577
01:17:11.741 --> 01:17:16.003
So they did X-ray diffraction, which is the idea of shooting X-rays at a crystal.

1578
01:17:16.443 --> 01:17:18.364
The X-rays are going to diffract in a certain way.

1579
01:17:18.684 --> 01:17:25.547
And depending on the crystal structure of the atoms, they're going to diffract and create an image of where the X-rays bounced off.

1580
01:17:26.287 --> 01:17:29.568
And that'll tell you sort of the bond spacing and like the bonding was and things like that.

1581
01:17:29.688 --> 01:17:29.828
Yep.

1582
01:17:30.068 --> 01:17:30.608
Things match.

1583
01:17:30.788 --> 01:17:30.968
Yep.

1584
01:17:31.068 --> 01:17:35.029
So you know those hexagonal layers actually like ended up covalently bonding.

1585
01:17:35.069 --> 01:17:35.369
Yeah.

1586
01:17:35.429 --> 01:17:35.889
Yeah.

1587
01:17:35.989 --> 01:17:39.330
And like the like the spacing of it, like is it 1.5 angstroms?

1588
01:17:39.390 --> 01:17:40.170
Is it one angstrom?

1589
01:17:40.450 --> 01:17:47.612
Like down to like, you know, hydrogen hydrogen like atom length type stuff.

1590
01:17:47.832 --> 01:17:51.493
They also do high resolution transmission electron microscopy.

1591
01:17:52.073 --> 01:17:53.014
That's just the standard thing.

1592
01:17:53.034 --> 01:17:53.934
You got to put it in there.

1593
01:17:54.194 --> 01:17:57.556
You got to see, oh, you got like the little hexagonal structures.

1594
01:17:57.916 --> 01:17:58.576
So that's nice.

1595
01:17:59.196 --> 01:18:07.300
They also did something called Raman spectroscopy after named after C.V. Raman, my guy from India, the first Nobel Prize winner in physics from India.

1596
01:18:08.200 --> 01:18:11.942
Raman spectroscopy is the idea that molecules vibrate.

1597
01:18:12.502 --> 01:18:12.702
Right.

1598
01:18:13.223 --> 01:18:25.429
And so in normal spectroscopy, you want to see you shoot in some light and then like the you're going to go to a high quantum state, lower quantum state, and then that's going to release some energy right here.

1599
01:18:25.869 --> 01:18:30.392
Some of the light that goes in is going to get like lost into the vibrational modes of the molecule.

1600
01:18:30.432 --> 01:18:34.454
And then you're going to get a different color of light that sometimes might be even higher.

1601
01:18:34.814 --> 01:18:34.994
Right.

1602
01:18:35.054 --> 01:18:38.836
Because like the vibration is going to like dump like some energy and stuff like that.

1603
01:18:39.056 --> 01:18:47.882
So you get this inelastic sort of scattering where the weird energy happens when you start doing this kind of stuff.

1604
01:18:48.223 --> 01:18:51.745
So they did that, and they found three vibrational modes.

1605
01:18:51.905 --> 01:18:59.451
So one this way, one that's longer, which confirms that there are two different bond lengths, which is what the theory suggests.

1606
01:18:59.471 --> 01:19:04.654
When you go and you do the crystalline structure, you're like, there should be one bond length that's at 1.58.

1607
01:19:05.835 --> 01:19:10.157
which is the the intralayer one that's like within the buckled honeycomb layer.

1608
01:19:10.437 --> 01:19:13.619
And then there's one point five zero, which is linking one layer to the other.

1609
01:19:13.639 --> 01:19:15.580
And these two should be different links.

1610
01:19:16.280 --> 01:19:22.263
And that the Raman spectroscopy, you do this, the simulation and you find out that it is in fact there.

1611
01:19:22.623 --> 01:19:22.803
Right.

1612
01:19:23.163 --> 01:19:25.084
So they're doing all of these all of these things.

1613
01:19:25.144 --> 01:19:28.106
And it's it's kind of a crazy story because actually earlier this year,

1614
01:19:29.486 --> 01:19:43.233
another Chinese group came out saying that they had a plan, concept of a plan, concept of a plan to like, to like, they had this like promising, um, procedure to make the six second diamond.

1615
01:19:43.313 --> 01:19:43.533
Okay.

1616
01:19:44.013 --> 01:19:44.273
Okay.

1617
01:19:44.313 --> 01:19:46.975
And they were like, you know, we're going to have like, y'all wait.

1618
01:19:47.095 --> 01:19:47.675
Yeah.

1619
01:19:47.895 --> 01:19:50.256
And then I think these guys scooped them.

1620
01:19:50.956 --> 01:19:52.937
Oh, that other group was from university of Shanghai.

1621
01:19:52.977 --> 01:19:57.720
And these guys from Beijing, like, so, I mean, it also shows just how far China has come.

1622
01:19:57.840 --> 01:19:58.000
Right.

1623
01:19:58.020 --> 01:19:58.420
Right.

1624
01:19:58.620 --> 01:20:22.430
as a scientific powerhouse right we're like they're scooping within their country now right right right not even in the global competition yeah yeah yeah now it's like they're competing amongst themselves it's actually like like they've advanced so much that now they've got competing institutions that are like yeah now you know they're like having beef with each other and pushing the boundaries of of the frontier of science research which is like that's actually very interesting yeah um

1625
01:20:23.181 --> 01:20:41.269
And I know there's a lot of, in the popular discourse, there can tend to be this knee-jerk reaction when referring to Chinese studies because there is the geopolitical nexus here, which creates an incentive for there to be cutting corners to be able to show advancements happening.

1626
01:20:41.329 --> 01:20:41.549
Yeah.

1627
01:20:41.809 --> 01:20:51.273
And so a lot of times, again, in the zeitgeist conversation, it's like, well, the Chinese study comes out, the data may be fake, and take it with a grain of salt.

1628
01:20:51.293 --> 01:20:51.394
Yeah.

1629
01:20:51.414 --> 01:20:52.294
It's kind of like the...

1630
01:20:52.654 --> 01:21:17.817
the response i mean but this is published in nature they did all of these correct and i think that perception it's the same thing with like the same idea with looking at china from the trade secrets perspective where maybe 15 20 years ago it was true that and there still is obviously yeah there probably still is however that is an independent point to the fact that they've now established that

1631
01:21:18.097 --> 01:21:27.219
their own flywheel of educating a large amount of their populace in the fundamental areas of science, mathematics, etc.

1632
01:21:27.759 --> 01:21:32.580
Necessary to then populate these institutions with people to do these studies.

1633
01:21:33.180 --> 01:21:37.661
And then actually funding those institutions to be able to get results.

1634
01:21:37.801 --> 01:21:45.342
And that infrastructure exists independent if there's some funny business going on in some cases.

1635
01:21:48.623 --> 01:21:58.385
of like really taking in earnest things that are coming out of here, which I think is not a great thing for us to do from just a strategic surprise perspective.

1636
01:21:58.625 --> 01:21:58.745
No.

1637
01:21:58.765 --> 01:22:00.766
Because what we don't want to do is underestimate.

1638
01:22:01.026 --> 01:22:01.246
Yes.

1639
01:22:01.346 --> 01:22:04.447
And then there's now this runaway because like progress compounds, right?

1640
01:22:04.867 --> 01:22:09.368
And we don't want to have this runaway train where with what we're seeing with manufacturing in the U.S.,

1641
01:22:09.828 --> 01:22:12.969
Where we didn't care about it, and then now we're like, oh, we need to re-onshore.

1642
01:22:13.009 --> 01:22:14.429
And it's like – Yeah, it's like now it's impossible.

1643
01:22:14.449 --> 01:22:14.949
It's too late.

1644
01:22:15.009 --> 01:22:20.811
Yeah, like the global economy has already gone 30 paces ahead, and this is what it is, right?

1645
01:22:20.831 --> 01:22:22.831
Yeah, and if you don't like it, just like fun science.

1646
01:22:22.851 --> 01:22:23.931
Yeah, correct.

1647
01:22:23.971 --> 01:22:24.211
Right?

1648
01:22:24.331 --> 01:22:24.651
Correct.

1649
01:22:24.812 --> 01:22:29.753
If we're in this great power war with China, one of the battlefields is frontier research.

1650
01:22:29.813 --> 01:22:30.393
It always is.

1651
01:22:30.653 --> 01:22:31.113
It always is.

1652
01:22:31.133 --> 01:22:32.093
Yeah, anywhere.

1653
01:22:32.113 --> 01:22:33.654
That's how we won World War II.

1654
01:22:33.774 --> 01:22:33.974
Yeah.

1655
01:22:40.015 --> 01:22:42.196
the global world power that we are still baffles me.

1656
01:22:42.216 --> 01:22:43.736
Yeah, that's a digression.

1657
01:22:44.177 --> 01:22:47.558
But at point context, because a lot of people show China study shut down.

1658
01:22:47.758 --> 01:22:47.938
Mm hmm.

1659
01:22:48.138 --> 01:22:48.298
Right.

1660
01:22:48.318 --> 01:22:51.459
And this is why we talk about it from first principles, because you can.

1661
01:22:51.499 --> 01:22:52.059
Well, they did it.

1662
01:22:52.100 --> 01:22:52.620
They did the work.

1663
01:22:52.640 --> 01:22:52.920
They did it.

1664
01:22:53.120 --> 01:22:55.541
They did the work like they got hexagonal diamonds.

1665
01:22:55.601 --> 01:23:00.443
This has been this has been something that people have been after for 50 years and they got it.

1666
01:23:00.903 --> 01:23:01.243
You're right.

1667
01:23:01.363 --> 01:23:03.904
Like in material science, this was kind of like that.

1668
01:23:04.845 --> 01:23:06.526
That thing on the hill that you want to get to.

1669
01:23:07.206 --> 01:23:07.706
And they got it.

1670
01:23:07.766 --> 01:23:07.966
Yeah.

1671
01:23:08.346 --> 01:23:17.210
And not only did they get it, they were potentially on pace to get it twice before anyone else of that other university that wasn't beaten up by the Bayesian one also did it, right?

1672
01:23:17.230 --> 01:23:19.310
Yeah, they probably shouldn't have published like that early.

1673
01:23:19.670 --> 01:23:23.712
Like, I wonder if like that gave, oh, that's what we were missing.

1674
01:23:24.072 --> 01:23:25.212
Like they were already almost there.

1675
01:23:25.252 --> 01:23:25.673
Yeah, yeah.

1676
01:23:25.693 --> 01:23:28.574
Oh, let's just change that to a tune.

1677
01:23:29.294 --> 01:23:31.355
So unfortunately for this use case,

1678
01:23:32.675 --> 01:23:37.259
We're not going to get cheaper diamonds to put on ring fingers.

1679
01:23:37.279 --> 01:23:37.639
No, no.

1680
01:23:37.759 --> 01:23:39.400
Cheaper diamonds are actually already here.

1681
01:23:39.740 --> 01:23:40.861
We have lab-grown diamonds.

1682
01:23:41.922 --> 01:23:47.166
The lab-grown diamonds actually – one of the processes that they use for lab-grown diamonds is this high-temperature, high-pressure.

1683
01:23:47.646 --> 01:23:53.387
But then there's a much more effective and cheaper way to do it, which is chemical vapor deposition.

1684
01:23:53.507 --> 01:23:53.607
Okay.

1685
01:23:53.827 --> 01:23:58.088
Which is interesting where you have like a diamond sort of seed.

1686
01:23:58.649 --> 01:24:07.151
And then you fill the chamber with – usually it's like methane, which is CH4, so carbon and hydrogen.

1687
01:24:07.511 --> 01:24:11.392
And then you start heating up the methane with lasers to take out the hydrogen.

1688
01:24:17.913 --> 01:24:19.393
a lab-grown diamond, right?

1689
01:24:19.433 --> 01:24:35.357
The only reason diamonds are expensive is because the De Beers Corporation has a monopoly on it, and now they're putting out this propaganda saying, oh yeah, but you want one from the Earth that's actually caused human suffering.

1690
01:24:35.417 --> 01:24:38.698
Because otherwise your wife is not going to know that you love her.

1691
01:24:38.778 --> 01:24:43.439
True love comes from the human suffering of minds all over Africa that are getting you these earth-grown diamonds.

1692
01:24:43.559 --> 01:24:45.300
Otherwise, what is this all about?

1693
01:24:46.160 --> 01:24:46.460
You know?

1694
01:24:46.921 --> 01:24:48.982
No, that is what they say.

1695
01:24:49.042 --> 01:24:49.763
Yeah.

1696
01:24:49.843 --> 01:24:50.804
That is what they say.

1697
01:24:51.945 --> 01:24:52.745
Great story.

1698
01:24:52.885 --> 01:24:54.146
Diamond's getting an upgrade.

1699
01:24:54.447 --> 01:24:56.668
Crazy industrial use cases.

1700
01:24:56.688 --> 01:24:57.609
Yeah, it's going to be cool.

1701
01:24:57.629 --> 01:25:01.992
Fascinating implementation to get to the answer to what has been a 50-year-ish.

1702
01:25:03.153 --> 01:25:11.843
quest to be able to actually experimentally realize that this hexagonal diamond was possible.

1703
01:25:13.004 --> 01:25:23.556
And he did bring up as an analogy or as a reference point that things like if you can do the hexagonal diamond, maybe there are use cases in other technologies, maybe like in quantum computers,

1704
01:25:24.096 --> 01:25:28.078
Which may well like an industry like you always want harder things.

1705
01:25:28.098 --> 01:25:28.298
Right.

1706
01:25:28.519 --> 01:25:28.679
Right.

1707
01:25:29.019 --> 01:25:29.259
Right.

1708
01:25:29.319 --> 01:25:31.020
Drilling is obviously going to be a use case.

1709
01:25:31.240 --> 01:25:31.500
Easy.

1710
01:25:31.900 --> 01:25:52.052
But with quantum, that is a segue into our last story of the day, which is our retrospective on the U.N. designating this current year, 2025, as the International Year of Quantum Mechanics, a subject we talk about on almost every episode one way or another.

1711
01:25:52.232 --> 01:25:52.452
Yeah.

1712
01:25:52.772 --> 01:26:04.909
Um, so as we take a look back at the last hundred years, uh, we want to review a little bit on how it all started for us to get to this point of the UN designating 2025.

1713
01:26:05.030 --> 01:26:05.871
It's been a hundred years.

1714
01:26:06.131 --> 01:26:07.353
As the year of quantum mechanics.

1715
01:26:07.593 --> 01:26:09.594
Yeah, it's been 100 years.

1716
01:26:09.614 --> 01:26:11.955
100 years.

1717
01:26:12.075 --> 01:26:12.515
1925.

1718
01:26:14.336 --> 01:26:18.138
It was a seminal year in physics.

1719
01:26:18.178 --> 01:26:19.458
There were four big papers.

1720
01:26:20.439 --> 01:26:22.280
There was one paper by Wolfgang Pauli.

1721
01:26:23.080 --> 01:26:24.681
There's one paper by Paul Dirac.

1722
01:26:25.281 --> 01:26:29.023
And then there's two papers, one by Heisenberg, which is the big one.

1723
01:26:29.743 --> 01:26:45.487
And then there's there's a follow up paper that he wrote with his Ph.D. advisor and another colleague, not Ph.D. advisor, postdoc advisor and a colleague of his that was sort of a follow up to his big paper, the paper, and it's like legendary.

1724
01:26:45.847 --> 01:26:49.308
OK, this paper is something that Steven Weinberg, Nobel Prize winner,

1725
01:26:50.628 --> 01:26:54.750
He once said that there are two types of great physicists.

1726
01:26:55.270 --> 01:27:00.492
There's the sage physicists and then there's the magician physicists.

1727
01:27:00.512 --> 01:27:05.854
With sage physicists, one can read their papers and understand where they're coming from.

1728
01:27:06.394 --> 01:27:06.775
It's obvious.

1729
01:27:08.075 --> 01:27:11.337
And you're almost asking yourself, God, why didn't I think of that?

1730
01:27:11.857 --> 01:27:16.040
And once you see it, you have the same epiphany that the sage did.

1731
01:27:16.440 --> 01:27:19.582
And you realize that the universe starts making sense.

1732
01:27:19.622 --> 01:27:21.463
And it's just like, oh, this is beautiful.

1733
01:27:21.884 --> 01:27:22.064
Right?

1734
01:27:22.584 --> 01:27:25.066
Newton is a sage physicist, I would say.

1735
01:27:25.926 --> 01:27:28.208
Einstein, also a sage physicist.

1736
01:27:28.228 --> 01:27:30.069
Like his relativity paper, it's like...

1737
01:27:30.809 --> 01:27:32.070
Oh, that that's so nice.

1738
01:27:32.090 --> 01:27:32.470
Yeah.

1739
01:27:32.590 --> 01:27:32.930
Yeah.

1740
01:27:33.070 --> 01:27:33.910
Yeah.

1741
01:27:34.151 --> 01:27:34.351
Yeah.

1742
01:27:34.411 --> 01:27:35.811
Heisenberg is a magician.

1743
01:27:35.831 --> 01:27:36.872
Physicist.

1744
01:27:36.912 --> 01:27:41.474
People read his paper and still to to this day, nobody reads his paper in 1925.

1745
01:27:41.594 --> 01:27:46.476
And even though that's the paper, that's why this year is called the year of quantum mechanics.

1746
01:27:46.636 --> 01:27:53.639
Nobody in their right mind reads his paper to understand quantum mechanics because it's a magician paper.

1747
01:27:54.039 --> 01:27:56.300
It's it's like, where did you pull that out?

1748
01:27:57.321 --> 01:27:59.682
You know, it's like you just like did a card trick.

1749
01:28:00.683 --> 01:28:03.610
And then now there's like this random equation that explains everything.

1750
01:28:04.312 --> 01:28:09.464
And there's no, you didn't say anything about like what your thought, what are your thoughts?

1751
01:28:10.248 --> 01:28:10.548
You know?

1752
01:28:10.788 --> 01:28:10.969
Right.

1753
01:28:11.249 --> 01:28:12.430
What the hell are you talking about?

1754
01:28:12.450 --> 01:28:12.630
Right.

1755
01:28:12.830 --> 01:28:13.010
Right.

1756
01:28:13.110 --> 01:28:13.351
You know?

1757
01:28:14.291 --> 01:28:16.233
So that's the paper that I want to cover.

1758
01:28:16.293 --> 01:28:16.553
Okay.

1759
01:28:16.673 --> 01:28:16.954
Okay?

1760
01:28:17.014 --> 01:28:22.198
You know, usually in this podcast, we cover papers that happened over the past week or like very recently.

1761
01:28:22.538 --> 01:28:26.461
This is a hundred-year-old paper that was published almost exactly a hundred years ago.

1762
01:28:26.742 --> 01:28:27.422
It was in July.

1763
01:28:28.703 --> 01:28:35.749
But some of the other papers, like the born Jordan Heisenberg paper was published in September and then Dirac was published a little bit later.

1764
01:28:36.049 --> 01:28:38.170
So it's really a whole year worth of stuff.

1765
01:28:38.450 --> 01:28:41.411
And to really understand that whole year, I'm going to take you on a journey.

1766
01:28:41.471 --> 01:28:41.731
Okay.

1767
01:28:42.211 --> 01:28:43.692
Back to 1900.

1768
01:28:44.312 --> 01:28:44.832
The 1900s.

1769
01:28:44.872 --> 01:28:45.912
Back to the 1900s.

1770
01:28:45.972 --> 01:28:46.252
Okay.

1771
01:28:46.293 --> 01:28:47.493
Physics is doing really good.

1772
01:28:47.533 --> 01:28:47.713
Okay.

1773
01:28:47.733 --> 01:28:48.353
All right.

1774
01:28:48.433 --> 01:28:49.554
We've understood temperature.

1775
01:28:49.574 --> 01:28:53.275
We we got we were pretty sure there's atoms.

1776
01:28:54.175 --> 01:28:58.397
um, electromagnetism, you know, Edwin Hubble's got lights.

1777
01:28:59.278 --> 01:29:00.498
Like it's crazy.

1778
01:29:00.699 --> 01:29:01.019
Okay.

1779
01:29:01.039 --> 01:29:02.099
We got the phonograph.

1780
01:29:02.139 --> 01:29:07.242
Like now I can listen to music and, um, like there's all this, like everyone's like, this is dope.

1781
01:29:08.122 --> 01:29:13.925
There's, there's two or three big conundrums, but everyone's kind of like, not a big deal.

1782
01:29:13.965 --> 01:29:15.846
You know, uh, we'll figure it out.

1783
01:29:15.886 --> 01:29:16.346
We'll get there.

1784
01:29:16.426 --> 01:29:17.207
We'll figure it out.

1785
01:29:17.247 --> 01:29:21.889
Lord Kelvin said they're like these little like clouds on the horizon, but they're, they're soon going to part.

1786
01:29:22.449 --> 01:29:22.650
Um, um,

1787
01:29:23.690 --> 01:29:27.252
One of them is how hot things glow.

1788
01:29:28.092 --> 01:29:29.593
So-called black body radiation.

1789
01:29:29.613 --> 01:29:33.155
You know, if you heat up like if you've seen hot glass, it glows right.

1790
01:29:34.035 --> 01:29:34.936
A stovetop.

1791
01:29:34.976 --> 01:29:35.536
The stovetop.

1792
01:29:35.576 --> 01:29:35.756
Yeah.

1793
01:29:35.876 --> 01:29:37.657
The olgy stove tops with the coils.

1794
01:29:37.677 --> 01:29:38.017
Yeah.

1795
01:29:38.117 --> 01:29:38.338
Yeah.

1796
01:29:38.438 --> 01:29:39.258
The coils glow.

1797
01:29:39.358 --> 01:29:40.058
Right.

1798
01:29:41.239 --> 01:29:44.921
And so the question is how like when you heat something up, why does it glow the way it does?

1799
01:29:45.882 --> 01:29:49.945
Specifically, why does it not run away and glow infinitely bright?

1800
01:29:50.585 --> 01:29:53.027
Because that's what the theory was suggesting.

1801
01:29:53.368 --> 01:30:03.356
The Boltzmann theory, which was the statistical stat mech theory of how we figured out PV equals NRT, our sense of temperature and pressure and volume.

1802
01:30:05.002 --> 01:30:06.122
has immense success.

1803
01:30:07.583 --> 01:30:11.984
But at the same time, it's like totally failing when it comes to electromagnetic radiation, when it comes to light.

1804
01:30:13.765 --> 01:30:25.509
The other thing is when we look at the sun and when we glow, like when we look at, you know, lamps of gas, when we put a gas and then we electrically spark it and we look at the light that comes out, it's discrete.

1805
01:30:25.989 --> 01:30:26.929
It's not a continuous.

1806
01:30:26.970 --> 01:30:31.151
The sun is continuous, but then if you look really closely at the sun, there's these dark lines.

1807
01:30:31.531 --> 01:30:38.233
And then those dark lines end up corresponding to the lines that we see in the laboratory, which is how we actually discovered helium.

1808
01:30:38.753 --> 01:30:39.113
Right?

1809
01:30:39.133 --> 01:30:49.615
Like somebody noticed that there's like lines on the sun, actually like right outside, not dark lines, but like right outside the sun, you're getting these like emission, like these bright lines in these two spots.

1810
01:30:49.635 --> 01:30:54.736
And those two spots are exactly the same as the helium line that I discovered in the laboratory.

1811
01:30:54.756 --> 01:30:56.517
So they're like, that must be up there.

1812
01:30:56.917 --> 01:30:57.917
I'm going to call this helium.

1813
01:30:58.457 --> 01:30:59.518
Right.

1814
01:30:59.638 --> 01:31:00.539
For Helios, the sun.

1815
01:31:00.960 --> 01:31:04.243
So so those lines are like, OK, what's going on?

1816
01:31:04.943 --> 01:31:05.724
Why are there lines?

1817
01:31:06.345 --> 01:31:11.930
And then the other thing was light needs an ether or something.

1818
01:31:12.671 --> 01:31:14.493
Sound moves through through air.

1819
01:31:14.973 --> 01:31:16.295
Water waves move through water.

1820
01:31:16.415 --> 01:31:16.595
Yeah.

1821
01:31:17.135 --> 01:31:18.677
Light needs something to move through.

1822
01:31:20.527 --> 01:31:22.049
It's the ether.

1823
01:31:22.169 --> 01:31:23.110
But what is the ether?

1824
01:31:23.330 --> 01:31:24.652
Can somebody find it?

1825
01:31:25.032 --> 01:31:26.393
Are we moving through the ether?

1826
01:31:26.714 --> 01:31:28.776
Does the ether itself have a velocity?

1827
01:31:28.956 --> 01:31:29.677
Yeah.

1828
01:31:29.777 --> 01:31:32.480
So all of these things are happening, and everyone's like, we're going to figure it out.

1829
01:31:32.620 --> 01:31:34.082
It's fine.

1830
01:31:34.522 --> 01:31:37.005
Then comes the revolution from Einstein.

1831
01:31:37.045 --> 01:31:37.165
Yeah.

1832
01:31:37.645 --> 01:31:38.966
First of all, we can't find the ether.

1833
01:31:39.206 --> 01:31:44.310
Michelson and Morley do these amazing experiments at Case Western University where they're trying to measure the ether.

1834
01:31:44.630 --> 01:32:01.001
So they try to measure the speed of the ether when the earth, like at one time, let's say at 6 p.m., and then they try to measure it at 6 a.m. Because then the earth is going to be on the other – their lab is going to be on the other side of the earth, right?

1835
01:32:01.262 --> 01:32:05.865
So if the earth is moving like this or like if the earth is stationary like this and the ether is coming this way –

1836
01:32:06.345 --> 01:32:11.230
Then at one point their lab is going against the ether and the other time their lab is going towards the ether.

1837
01:32:11.270 --> 01:32:13.212
So they're trying to find a difference here and they can't.

1838
01:32:13.233 --> 01:32:13.653
Yeah.

1839
01:32:13.833 --> 01:32:15.375
So they're like the speed of light is the same.

1840
01:32:15.555 --> 01:32:15.755
Yeah.

1841
01:32:16.056 --> 01:32:16.696
There's no wind.

1842
01:32:16.816 --> 01:32:17.537
There's no wind.

1843
01:32:17.857 --> 01:32:21.822
And like it's like our air bar is now like like we grinded.

1844
01:32:22.382 --> 01:32:26.583
It's so hard and our error bar is so small that it doesn't make sense anymore.

1845
01:32:26.603 --> 01:32:26.863
Right.

1846
01:32:27.123 --> 01:32:29.343
So we're pretty sure there's no ether and I don't know what's going on.

1847
01:32:29.723 --> 01:32:33.904
Einstein has a big epiphany with this, with the theory of relativity.

1848
01:32:33.924 --> 01:32:37.805
And he says, let's just say that light is constant speed.

1849
01:32:38.365 --> 01:32:43.726
And let's say that all laws of physics are the same when when I'm doing stuff.

1850
01:32:43.846 --> 01:32:44.006
Yeah.

1851
01:32:44.126 --> 01:32:44.306
Right.

1852
01:32:44.346 --> 01:32:50.987
If I do an experiment here and then I get on a train and the train is moving at constant speed and I do the experiment there, they should be the same.

1853
01:32:51.807 --> 01:32:57.049
He's actually influenced by a philosopher, a philosopher and a physicist, Ernst Mach.

1854
01:32:57.249 --> 01:32:58.589
You know the Mach number?

1855
01:32:58.729 --> 01:32:59.029
Yeah.

1856
01:32:59.489 --> 01:33:01.270
Mach 5, Mach 6.

1857
01:33:01.570 --> 01:33:09.392
That's named after Ernst Mach, who's the first guy who described what happens when stuff moves faster than the speed of sound.

1858
01:33:09.632 --> 01:33:11.133
He has this very famous photograph,

1859
01:33:11.713 --> 01:33:32.464
um black and white back in those days like with the like this is like civil war camera you know like the ken burns documentary yeah yeah like he took a photo of a speeding bullet and showed the shockwave oh that's using like those cameras yeah which is an insane feat i actually still don't understand how he got that photo i was gonna say like i would yeah

1860
01:33:32.624 --> 01:33:34.246
Like that's an insane photo to get.

1861
01:33:34.346 --> 01:33:34.546
Right.

1862
01:33:34.626 --> 01:33:38.149
Even now, I don't know how to with a digital camera, how to get that.

1863
01:33:38.169 --> 01:33:52.342
So but but so he does all this physics stuff, but he's also really into philosophy and he he champions this thing called positivism, which is the idea that we should be concerned about describing stuff that we can see with our immediate experience.

1864
01:33:52.923 --> 01:33:53.163
OK. Yeah.

1865
01:33:53.703 --> 01:33:55.304
So this is not woke ideology.

1866
01:33:55.425 --> 01:33:57.526
No, this is not woke ideology at all.

1867
01:33:57.566 --> 01:34:05.372
This is like what is what is in front of me and what can I like see and be sure exists?

1868
01:34:05.973 --> 01:34:08.255
OK, be very, very sure exists.

1869
01:34:08.815 --> 01:34:12.838
Einstein takes this to heart and he starts asking crazy questions.

1870
01:34:12.958 --> 01:34:14.660
OK, he's like, what is time?

1871
01:34:15.500 --> 01:34:16.982
And everyone's like, what are you talking about?

1872
01:34:17.002 --> 01:34:17.822
What time is time?

1873
01:34:17.862 --> 01:34:18.523
And he's like, no, no, no.

1874
01:34:18.563 --> 01:34:20.724
What is what is time?

1875
01:34:21.705 --> 01:34:27.328
And he figures that time is like the me seeing change, right?

1876
01:34:27.848 --> 01:34:29.789
In the simplest sense, there's a clock on the wall.

1877
01:34:30.289 --> 01:34:31.450
The second hand is moving.

1878
01:34:32.130 --> 01:34:35.912
Time for me is the rate at which I see the second hand move.

1879
01:34:36.573 --> 01:34:36.813
Okay?

1880
01:34:37.193 --> 01:34:41.655
The second hand makes one round every 60 seconds, and every one second it's going this.

1881
01:34:42.135 --> 01:34:42.636
It's doing this.

1882
01:34:43.116 --> 01:34:44.357
That for me is time.

1883
01:34:44.677 --> 01:34:46.578
That's how I experience time.

1884
01:34:46.898 --> 01:34:48.559
And according to Mach's positivism,

1885
01:34:49.479 --> 01:34:53.142
That is literally time is the rate at which I'm seeing this for me.

1886
01:34:53.943 --> 01:34:55.204
And then he makes a simple argument.

1887
01:34:55.244 --> 01:35:11.036
Like if I'm moving away at the speed of light, then the image of that second hand changing is never going to reach me because I'm always going to be running away from that image of the second hand moving, which means I'm never going to see the second hand move.

1888
01:35:11.096 --> 01:35:11.296
Right.

1889
01:35:11.556 --> 01:35:13.298
Which means if I'm going at the speed of light,

1890
01:35:13.958 --> 01:35:15.780
Time is like slowing down to zero.

1891
01:35:16.020 --> 01:35:17.061
Do you see what I'm saying?

1892
01:35:17.081 --> 01:35:17.401
Right, right.

1893
01:35:17.521 --> 01:35:23.747
Because what you're saying is if the clock is here and you're moving away at the speed of light, the actual imagery of the clock.

1894
01:35:23.767 --> 01:35:25.929
Of the clock moving, like changing its second hand.

1895
01:35:25.949 --> 01:35:28.712
Which has to be like, it's like, you know, it has to travel.

1896
01:35:28.832 --> 01:35:29.052
Yeah.

1897
01:35:29.292 --> 01:35:31.134
Like you're always going to be.

1898
01:35:31.214 --> 01:35:32.135
You're running away from it.

1899
01:35:32.455 --> 01:35:35.256
Like it's like Wile E. Coyote and whatever the other thing.

1900
01:35:35.476 --> 01:35:36.236
It never catches.

1901
01:35:36.256 --> 01:35:42.738
So meaning you don't actually see the change in which to find – like in the analogy he brings up.

1902
01:35:42.758 --> 01:35:55.201
It's like, well, if I'm not seeing it change, then time – Then the time in that outside – like if I'm in a train and I'm like watching this, then the time on the outside is like according to me, there's just like – There's no time has gone by.

1903
01:35:55.221 --> 01:35:56.821
Yeah, there's no time has gone by, right?

1904
01:35:57.181 --> 01:36:00.222
And so he's taking this like positivism like so seriously.

1905
01:36:00.242 --> 01:36:00.782
Right, right.

1906
01:36:00.942 --> 01:36:01.082
Right.

1907
01:36:01.102 --> 01:36:04.064
And he's like, the only thing that matters to me is my experience.

1908
01:36:04.324 --> 01:36:04.904
Right.

1909
01:36:05.185 --> 01:36:11.008
And it's this nice marriage of physics, mathematics, and philosophy at the end of the day.

1910
01:36:11.048 --> 01:36:14.470
Like it took this philosophical leap to actually get there.

1911
01:36:14.810 --> 01:36:14.970
Right.

1912
01:36:15.010 --> 01:36:19.333
And that's actually one of the geniuses of Einstein is like he literally took this thing seriously.

1913
01:36:19.673 --> 01:36:19.833
Right.

1914
01:36:19.973 --> 01:36:23.475
Newton is another one of these sort of philosophers who literally took it seriously.

1915
01:36:23.495 --> 01:36:23.675
Yeah.

1916
01:36:23.775 --> 01:36:28.918
Like everybody back in the day was talking about how the heavens should have the same rules as on earth.

1917
01:36:28.958 --> 01:36:29.158
Yeah.

1918
01:36:29.278 --> 01:36:30.059
There's no difference.

1919
01:36:30.099 --> 01:36:30.279
Yeah.

1920
01:36:30.379 --> 01:36:31.280
Everyone's saying it.

1921
01:36:31.380 --> 01:36:32.440
But they weren't really about that life.

1922
01:36:32.460 --> 01:36:33.821
But they weren't really about that life.

1923
01:36:33.921 --> 01:36:35.342
Newton was like, no, no, no.

1924
01:36:35.402 --> 01:36:41.947
If I take it seriously, then the apple falling on my head is also the thing that's making the moon fall into Earth.

1925
01:36:41.967 --> 01:36:42.767
Right.

1926
01:36:43.148 --> 01:36:44.729
He took it so seriously.

1927
01:36:44.789 --> 01:36:45.569
Right, right.

1928
01:36:45.629 --> 01:36:46.430
And then he did the math.

1929
01:36:46.470 --> 01:36:47.350
He's like, actually, no.

1930
01:36:47.370 --> 01:36:49.071
This is literally what's happening.

1931
01:36:49.091 --> 01:36:49.232
Yeah.

1932
01:36:49.292 --> 01:36:49.692
Right?

1933
01:36:49.792 --> 01:36:51.673
It's a philosophical leap that he had to do.

1934
01:36:51.773 --> 01:36:51.933
Yes.

1935
01:36:52.073 --> 01:36:53.915
Everybody else knew what gravity was.

1936
01:36:53.975 --> 01:36:55.336
People had measured things going.

1937
01:36:55.656 --> 01:36:57.417
Like Galileo had dropped gravity.

1938
01:36:57.617 --> 01:36:58.018
Stuff.

1939
01:36:58.038 --> 01:36:58.779
Stuff, right?

1940
01:36:58.839 --> 01:37:03.725
And, like, measured the measure G. But he's the first one who's like, guys, you guys keep talking.

1941
01:37:03.845 --> 01:37:04.145
Yeah.

1942
01:37:04.766 --> 01:37:05.948
Like, let's do the walk.

1943
01:37:06.028 --> 01:37:06.188
Right.

1944
01:37:06.408 --> 01:37:06.608
Right?

1945
01:37:06.689 --> 01:37:07.850
So Einstein does this as well.

1946
01:37:07.890 --> 01:37:08.010
Right.

1947
01:37:08.411 --> 01:37:10.133
And so he comes up with relativity.

1948
01:37:10.173 --> 01:37:10.754
It's amazing.

1949
01:37:11.094 --> 01:37:11.695
Yes.

1950
01:37:12.536 --> 01:37:13.337
Everyone's like, dope.

1951
01:37:13.397 --> 01:37:14.018
This is dope.

1952
01:37:14.098 --> 01:37:14.538
Yeah.

1953
01:37:15.259 --> 01:37:18.701
At the same time, we start getting into really cool experiments.

1954
01:37:18.721 --> 01:37:21.343
So the electron is discovered by JJ Thompson.

1955
01:37:21.743 --> 01:37:26.766
Rutherford discovers the nucleus of the atom, and now we're running into some serious problems.

1956
01:37:27.087 --> 01:37:27.327
Okay?

1957
01:37:27.827 --> 01:37:34.011
Once the nucleus is discovered, now we know that the nucleus is this tiny thing of positive charge with electrons moving around it.

1958
01:37:34.171 --> 01:37:35.432
We already know the electron is there.

1959
01:37:35.752 --> 01:37:42.074
And now, according to classical electromagnetism, if a charged particle moves, remember from last week we talked about the synchrotron.

1960
01:37:42.134 --> 01:37:42.314
Yes.

1961
01:37:42.414 --> 01:37:44.455
Where the electron is moving around in a circle.

1962
01:37:44.515 --> 01:37:44.695
Yes.

1963
01:37:44.775 --> 01:37:46.175
And it's like putting out x-rays.

1964
01:37:46.215 --> 01:37:49.156
And then that's how we did the dinosaur autopsy.

1965
01:37:49.176 --> 01:37:49.276
Yes.

1966
01:37:51.577 --> 01:37:58.544
Okay, if it's a smaller little synchrotron inside of an atom where the electron is moving like this, it should also be releasing light.

1967
01:37:58.924 --> 01:38:02.567
And if it releases light, it should decrease in energy.

1968
01:38:02.667 --> 01:38:02.848
Yes.

1969
01:38:03.368 --> 01:38:06.231
And then it should fall into the atom, to the nucleus.

1970
01:38:06.271 --> 01:38:07.372
And so there should be no atoms.

1971
01:38:07.572 --> 01:38:07.732
Right.

1972
01:38:08.233 --> 01:38:08.793
Okay.

1973
01:38:09.013 --> 01:38:12.957
But obviously, clearly, there are atoms.

1974
01:38:13.558 --> 01:38:14.158
So what do we do?

1975
01:38:14.438 --> 01:38:15.019
That doesn't work.

1976
01:38:15.159 --> 01:38:15.940
Yeah.

1977
01:38:16.060 --> 01:38:19.983
At this point, Rutherford is like – Rutherford is an experimentalist.

1978
01:38:20.003 --> 01:38:21.665
He's like, look, I gave you the nucleus.

1979
01:38:21.705 --> 01:38:21.925
Yeah.

1980
01:38:22.786 --> 01:38:23.106
I don't know.

1981
01:38:23.226 --> 01:38:24.007
You go theorize.

1982
01:38:24.487 --> 01:38:25.348
Yeah.

1983
01:38:25.388 --> 01:38:28.551
And at that point, like theoretical physics is still at its nascent day.

1984
01:38:28.851 --> 01:38:30.072
People aren't really respecting it.

1985
01:38:30.092 --> 01:38:33.415
The real guys are the experimentalists, right, because they're like dealing with truth.

1986
01:38:33.895 --> 01:38:36.037
The theorists are basically fancy mathematicians.

1987
01:38:36.057 --> 01:38:36.257
Yeah.

1988
01:38:36.618 --> 01:38:37.038
Exactly.

1989
01:38:37.138 --> 01:38:37.799
Right.

1990
01:38:38.399 --> 01:38:40.661
And so along comes Niels Bohr.

1991
01:38:41.822 --> 01:38:44.784
Niels Bohr joins as a postdoc in Rutherford's lab.

1992
01:38:45.465 --> 01:38:47.146
And Rutherford's like, all right, I'm going to hire you.

1993
01:38:47.166 --> 01:38:49.307
You're going to tell me what the hell is going on.

1994
01:38:49.367 --> 01:38:49.547
Right?

1995
01:38:49.587 --> 01:38:50.668
This is your job now.

1996
01:38:51.048 --> 01:38:51.289
Okay?

1997
01:38:51.609 --> 01:38:53.690
And Bohr's like, bro, I got this.

1998
01:38:53.770 --> 01:38:55.692
I'm going to tell you how every single atom works.

1999
01:38:56.372 --> 01:38:56.712
Tries.

2000
01:38:56.973 --> 01:38:58.213
He spectacularly fails.

2001
01:38:58.233 --> 01:38:58.854
Okay?

2002
01:38:58.874 --> 01:38:59.895
He has no idea what he's doing.

2003
01:39:00.275 --> 01:39:03.137
And then he's like, okay, I'm just going to focus on the hydrogen atom.

2004
01:39:04.297 --> 01:39:05.978
Single proton, single electron.

2005
01:39:05.998 --> 01:39:07.818
Because the other ones, there's a bunch of electrons.

2006
01:39:08.078 --> 01:39:09.639
The electrons are pushing against each other.

2007
01:39:09.999 --> 01:39:11.839
They're also getting the nucleus.

2008
01:39:12.159 --> 01:39:17.741
He's like, all right, single proton, single... And single proton, single electron, hydrogen atom.

2009
01:39:17.821 --> 01:39:19.161
Can I solve the hydrogen atom?

2010
01:39:19.681 --> 01:39:24.683
And at that point, it was known that the hydrogen spectra had this thing called the Balmer series.

2011
01:39:25.523 --> 01:39:40.696
it always came in this really peculiar pattern, okay, where it's like there's a line here, and then there's another line, and then another line sort of shorter away, shorter away, shorter away, and then there'd be another set of these up here, then there'd be another set of those up there.

2012
01:39:41.577 --> 01:39:48.003
And somebody worked out that the frequencies of all of these lines was proportional to

2013
01:39:49.403 --> 01:39:54.005
to the difference in one over squares of numbers.

2014
01:39:54.686 --> 01:39:56.467
Just pure numerology.

2015
01:39:56.507 --> 01:39:59.508
He was just like, look, if I do one minus one fourth,

2016
01:40:00.487 --> 01:40:01.207
I get this line.

2017
01:40:01.567 --> 01:40:05.128
If I do one minus one ninth, I get this line.

2018
01:40:05.208 --> 01:40:08.308
If I do, you know, just pure numerology.

2019
01:40:08.708 --> 01:40:08.968
Yeah.

2020
01:40:09.008 --> 01:40:09.208
Right.

2021
01:40:09.609 --> 01:40:12.669
And he's like, he's like, guys, as the kids say, the math was mathing.

2022
01:40:12.689 --> 01:40:13.549
The math was mathing.

2023
01:40:13.729 --> 01:40:14.809
No idea what's going on.

2024
01:40:15.249 --> 01:40:20.770
But he's like, if I do one over a square minus one over another square, that always gives me a line.

2025
01:40:21.330 --> 01:40:21.591
Okay.

2026
01:40:21.851 --> 01:40:24.931
So everyone's like, okay, this is like, just like now woo woo.

2027
01:40:25.111 --> 01:40:28.472
Like seeing, I mean, clearly it's working.

2028
01:40:28.512 --> 01:40:29.492
So there's something there.

2029
01:40:29.592 --> 01:40:29.792
Right.

2030
01:40:30.912 --> 01:40:35.353
Bohr sees this and he has an idea.

2031
01:40:35.973 --> 01:40:36.213
Okay.

2032
01:40:36.473 --> 01:40:49.977
So before this, Max Planck had already found out that if I quantize the electromagnetic field, which means that I say, okay, I can't have light that's arbitrarily small at a given frequency.

2033
01:40:50.377 --> 01:40:59.919
Like if I have light at, let's say, like really high frequency, like gamma radiation, I can't have like an arbitrarily small amount of gamma radiation.

2034
01:41:00.499 --> 01:41:04.082
There's like a minimum amount of gamma radiation.

2035
01:41:04.102 --> 01:41:04.622
There's a floor.

2036
01:41:04.802 --> 01:41:05.483
There's a floor.

2037
01:41:05.523 --> 01:41:07.684
And that floor is proportional to the frequency.

2038
01:41:07.764 --> 01:41:08.745
Got it.

2039
01:41:08.765 --> 01:41:10.346
So the floor moves based on the frequency.

2040
01:41:10.386 --> 01:41:11.247
Based on the frequency.

2041
01:41:11.327 --> 01:41:14.189
And the rate at which this floor moves, I'm going to name a constant.

2042
01:41:14.389 --> 01:41:14.589
Okay.

2043
01:41:14.929 --> 01:41:17.511
That's where we get Planck's constant.

2044
01:41:17.671 --> 01:41:17.892
Ah.

2045
01:41:17.912 --> 01:41:18.112
Okay.

2046
01:41:18.152 --> 01:41:21.974
He's like, if I have frequency this much, the minimum amount of energy is this much.

2047
01:41:22.014 --> 01:41:22.195
Yeah.

2048
01:41:22.375 --> 01:41:24.836
If I have frequency this much, the minimum amount of energy is this much.

2049
01:41:24.897 --> 01:41:26.578
The slope of this guy, it's a constant.

2050
01:41:27.018 --> 01:41:27.578
It's a constant.

2051
01:41:28.999 --> 01:41:31.700
And people started calling it Planck's constant.

2052
01:41:31.860 --> 01:41:32.100
Okay?

2053
01:41:32.480 --> 01:41:36.962
So Bohr is like, okay, he did that, and it worked.

2054
01:41:37.002 --> 01:41:37.262
Yeah.

2055
01:41:38.342 --> 01:41:38.982
Why don't I do that?

2056
01:41:39.002 --> 01:41:39.943
Why don't I do that here?

2057
01:41:40.223 --> 01:41:48.105
Why don't I say that the angular momentum of the electron around my hydrogen atom comes in chunks of Planck's constant?

2058
01:41:48.145 --> 01:41:48.445
Yeah.

2059
01:41:48.565 --> 01:41:51.386
Divided by 2 pi because there's like 2 pi in a circle.

2060
01:41:51.466 --> 01:41:51.606
Yes.

2061
01:41:51.666 --> 01:41:56.428
There's like angular versus – Anyways, but he's like, let's say that it comes as –

2062
01:41:57.208 --> 01:42:01.153
1 times h over 2 pi or 2 times h over 2 pi, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

2063
01:42:01.173 --> 01:42:01.293
Yeah.

2064
01:42:03.670 --> 01:42:07.852
And he basically noticed that like Planck's constant kind of looks like angular momentum.

2065
01:42:07.872 --> 01:42:08.852
The units are the same.

2066
01:42:10.433 --> 01:42:16.835
So maybe, you know, when he does this, he gets these like orbits.

2067
01:42:17.055 --> 01:42:21.317
There's like a smaller orbit where it's where it's one h bar over two pi.

2068
01:42:21.337 --> 01:42:22.337
Then there's two h bar over two.

2069
01:42:22.497 --> 01:42:23.537
And he gets these orbits.

2070
01:42:24.098 --> 01:42:29.659
And when he says, OK, if I take differences between the energies at these orbits, I can calculate the kinetic energy, right?

2071
01:42:29.699 --> 01:42:30.860
And the total energy of the system.

2072
01:42:31.340 --> 01:42:32.680
I can take the difference.

2073
01:42:34.041 --> 01:42:38.762
That is exactly this numerology nonsense that people have been doing.

2074
01:42:38.942 --> 01:42:41.103
That is the same numerology as this stuff.

2075
01:42:41.603 --> 01:42:45.685
On top of that, I can now justify how big these orbits are.

2076
01:42:46.205 --> 01:42:48.606
And that corresponds to one angstrom.

2077
01:42:48.766 --> 01:42:52.527
The number 10 to the minus 10 meters, which is the size of the hydrogen atom.

2078
01:42:53.427 --> 01:42:54.068
it pops out.

2079
01:42:54.328 --> 01:42:55.669
So he's like, bro, I'm on to something.

2080
01:42:55.689 --> 01:42:55.830
Yes.

2081
01:42:56.270 --> 01:43:00.895
He almost didn't publish this thing because he's like, I, you know, I only figured it out for hydrogen.

2082
01:43:01.035 --> 01:43:01.195
Right.

2083
01:43:01.415 --> 01:43:03.097
Like I was supposed to do it for everything.

2084
01:43:03.137 --> 01:43:04.038
And Rutherford's like, bro,

2085
01:43:05.652 --> 01:43:07.233
You're never going to publish the whole thing.

2086
01:43:07.273 --> 01:43:07.693
Okay.

2087
01:43:07.813 --> 01:43:09.514
Like this is already good enough.

2088
01:43:10.154 --> 01:43:13.136
Like, and Rutherford despised theorists.

2089
01:43:13.716 --> 01:43:15.537
But he's like, this is pretty good.

2090
01:43:16.017 --> 01:43:17.718
The fact that it's working so well.

2091
01:43:19.339 --> 01:43:21.040
And clearly there's issues.

2092
01:43:21.080 --> 01:43:24.622
Like where does the electron go when it transitions from one to the other?

2093
01:43:25.122 --> 01:43:25.422
Okay.

2094
01:43:25.482 --> 01:43:25.662
Yeah.

2095
01:43:25.803 --> 01:43:29.505
How does the electron know to put out exactly the right amount to go down?

2096
01:43:29.585 --> 01:43:29.806
Yes.

2097
01:43:30.046 --> 01:43:30.266
Right.

2098
01:43:30.726 --> 01:43:35.910
Like there's all these, there's all these little questions, but the math is, but the math is mathing.

2099
01:43:36.090 --> 01:43:38.872
It seems he's pulled it completely out of his ass.

2100
01:43:39.292 --> 01:43:39.513
Right.

2101
01:43:39.913 --> 01:43:43.135
But it's, it's, but at, at that point, everyone's doing this.

2102
01:43:43.155 --> 01:43:43.275
Right.

2103
01:43:43.295 --> 01:43:43.456
Right.

2104
01:43:43.496 --> 01:43:43.636
Right.

2105
01:43:43.676 --> 01:43:47.458
Like Max Planck also did this thing and was like, Oh, it works.

2106
01:43:47.819 --> 01:43:48.159
Yeah.

2107
01:43:48.519 --> 01:43:54.703
You know, but but he thought of it as like this might just be an emission and absorption type thing.

2108
01:43:54.803 --> 01:43:55.004
Sure.

2109
01:43:55.584 --> 01:43:59.226
Bohr is now taking that concept and being like, OK, I'm going to put it into the atom.

2110
01:43:59.367 --> 01:43:59.567
Yep.

2111
01:44:00.604 --> 01:44:01.624
So that goes really well.

2112
01:44:01.744 --> 01:44:01.944
Yes.

2113
01:44:03.005 --> 01:44:06.406
Then there's a guy Sommerfeld in Munich, and this is where Heisenberg comes in.

2114
01:44:06.686 --> 01:44:06.946
Okay.

2115
01:44:07.206 --> 01:44:12.907
Heisenberg is now a PhD student with Sommerfeld at the University of Munich.

2116
01:44:13.427 --> 01:44:20.309
And at the University of Munich, Sommerfeld and some of his other students start looking at Boer's atom and they're like, well, this kind of looks like planets.

2117
01:44:20.969 --> 01:44:21.169
Right.

2118
01:44:21.949 --> 01:44:25.710
Basically, he's just saying that the planet, the orbits are no longer like can be anywhere.

2119
01:44:25.750 --> 01:44:27.411
They're only in these discrete spots.

2120
01:44:27.431 --> 01:44:27.571
Sure.

2121
01:44:28.111 --> 01:44:30.952
But like planets, they're racetracks that are predefined.

2122
01:44:31.193 --> 01:44:31.433
Yeah.

2123
01:44:31.613 --> 01:44:31.773
Yeah.

2124
01:44:31.793 --> 01:44:33.273
They're racetracks that are predefined.

2125
01:44:33.313 --> 01:44:34.494
And Boris, like they're all circles.

2126
01:44:34.834 --> 01:44:35.034
Okay.

2127
01:44:35.534 --> 01:44:45.519
But the planets are held together by a central force due to gravity, which has the same exact form as the central force due to electromagnetism.

2128
01:44:45.919 --> 01:44:47.080
Just the constant is different.

2129
01:44:47.120 --> 01:44:48.940
Electromagnetism is a little bit strong.

2130
01:44:49.100 --> 01:44:49.981
Not a little bit, actually.

2131
01:44:50.361 --> 01:44:51.542
a whole lot stronger.

2132
01:44:51.962 --> 01:44:57.826
But the one over R squared thing, where it's like if I double the distance, I decrease the force by one fourth, that thing is the same.

2133
01:44:58.266 --> 01:45:04.971
So the mathematical structure is the same, which means that the kinds of orbits that planets do, these electrons should do around it, right?

2134
01:45:05.211 --> 01:45:07.032
And planets don't do circular orbits.

2135
01:45:07.193 --> 01:45:12.296
From the time of Newton, and actually from the time of Kepler, we know that they use elliptical orbits, right?

2136
01:45:12.616 --> 01:45:15.018
So Sommerfeld's like, let's generalize this thing, okay?

2137
01:45:15.298 --> 01:45:17.600
So we've got one number that tells you the orbit that it's in,

2138
01:45:18.300 --> 01:45:22.161
What if we have another number that tells you sort of like the electricity of this thing?

2139
01:45:22.261 --> 01:45:22.421
Yes.

2140
01:45:22.461 --> 01:45:24.862
Like how how skewed this orbit is.

2141
01:45:25.102 --> 01:45:27.883
Is it like a wider elliptical orbit?

2142
01:45:27.963 --> 01:45:28.203
Yeah.

2143
01:45:28.283 --> 01:45:30.304
Or is it super, super circular?

2144
01:45:30.324 --> 01:45:30.564
Right.

2145
01:45:30.584 --> 01:45:33.405
You know, and then and then so that's that that becomes this guy.

2146
01:45:33.545 --> 01:45:33.725
Yep.

2147
01:45:34.045 --> 01:45:37.706
OK. And so he's like, let's let's let's start including that.

2148
01:45:38.246 --> 01:45:39.467
Okay, what's the advantage of this?

2149
01:45:39.547 --> 01:45:47.316
There's always, in physics, whenever you try to come up with a new idea in terms of a theory, you want to try to see if it can explain some kind of experimental fact, right?

2150
01:45:48.357 --> 01:45:49.158
Einstein did this.

2151
01:45:49.698 --> 01:45:57.486
When it comes to, he explained the not presence of an ether and like this whole stuff and why light can go at the same speed everywhere.

2152
01:45:57.706 --> 01:45:58.207
It's constant.

2153
01:45:58.627 --> 01:46:03.569
Planck's constant explained black body radiation really well.

2154
01:46:03.789 --> 01:46:05.530
It fit the data amazingly well.

2155
01:46:07.510 --> 01:46:11.231
So Bohr obviously with the spectral lines.

2156
01:46:11.772 --> 01:46:14.873
So now this guy is like, okay, what are we trying to explain here?

2157
01:46:14.893 --> 01:46:16.973
There's something called the Zeeman effect.

2158
01:46:16.993 --> 01:46:20.215
Basically, when you put the, you know, you get these emission lines.

2159
01:46:21.655 --> 01:46:26.837
But if you put the gas in a magnetic field and then you do this experiment, instead of one line, you're going to get three.

2160
01:46:27.157 --> 01:46:27.297
Okay.

2161
01:46:27.317 --> 01:46:32.859
You're going to get the original line, then you're going to get one that's slightly higher frequency and one that's slightly lower frequency.

2162
01:46:33.159 --> 01:46:33.379
Okay.

2163
01:46:34.039 --> 01:46:46.423
So this Zeeman effect is now explained because if I've got an elliptical orbit, and I put a magnetic field, that elliptical orbit can be, he said, can be oriented towards.

2164
01:46:48.869 --> 01:47:13.602
perpendicular or anti-parallel right right like kind of like a magnet yes um a compass how does a compass work it finds the true north based on the earth's big magnetic field right it aligns with it yes well now we've got like this electric electron orbit that'll either align with the magnetic field for a lower energy right or yes not aligned for a higher energy or an intermediate value so now you get your three that's why there's the three bars okay

2165
01:47:13.782 --> 01:47:14.243
Right.

2166
01:47:14.263 --> 01:47:15.206
So he's like, okay, cool.

2167
01:47:15.586 --> 01:47:15.867
Dope.

2168
01:47:16.047 --> 01:47:16.208
Yes.

2169
01:47:16.268 --> 01:47:16.889
This is working.

2170
01:47:17.110 --> 01:47:17.771
Yes.

2171
01:47:18.032 --> 01:47:19.656
And, you know, he gets some points there.

2172
01:47:19.836 --> 01:47:20.016
Yes.

2173
01:47:20.782 --> 01:47:23.783
Sommerfeld at this point is this established guy at University of Munich.

2174
01:47:24.124 --> 01:47:26.064
Heisenberg is his student.

2175
01:47:26.164 --> 01:47:26.304
Yes.

2176
01:47:26.625 --> 01:47:27.565
Okay.

2177
01:47:27.665 --> 01:47:30.146
Heisenberg does his Ph.D. defense under Sommerfeld.

2178
01:47:31.347 --> 01:47:35.388
He nearly fails his Ph.D. defense because it was too theoretical.

2179
01:47:36.049 --> 01:47:47.154
And like Wien, who was the other big physics guy at University of Munich, nearly failed him because first of all, Wien was like, what physics did you do?

2180
01:47:47.274 --> 01:47:47.994
Right.

2181
01:47:48.054 --> 01:47:48.274
Right.

2182
01:47:48.314 --> 01:47:49.775
You're just doing like math.

2183
01:47:49.955 --> 01:47:50.095
Yeah.

2184
01:47:50.996 --> 01:47:59.288
And then we asked him to like just do like simple like just ask him simple like honestly really simple experimental questions.

2185
01:47:59.709 --> 01:47:59.909
Right.

2186
01:47:59.969 --> 01:48:05.177
Like it's like if I'm measuring these two quantities and they're related in this way, where's the most error coming from?

2187
01:48:05.597 --> 01:48:07.839
Something that every experimental physicist should know, right?

2188
01:48:07.859 --> 01:48:08.920
They're concerned with errors.

2189
01:48:09.041 --> 01:48:09.201
Yes.

2190
01:48:09.541 --> 01:48:10.962
Heisenberg is just like faltering.

2191
01:48:11.403 --> 01:48:13.385
He starts writing random shit on the blackboard.

2192
01:48:13.685 --> 01:48:15.547
And then and then Summerfield just stops him.

2193
01:48:15.607 --> 01:48:17.629
And then the two of them start having an argument.

2194
01:48:17.969 --> 01:48:20.932
Summerfield and they start having an argument about what is physics.

2195
01:48:21.052 --> 01:48:21.633
Right.

2196
01:48:21.913 --> 01:48:25.617
And Summerfield is like, like, dude, this guy, you know, and they start.

2197
01:48:26.157 --> 01:48:28.579
And so finally he gets the degree, but he's super like.

2198
01:48:29.460 --> 01:48:30.641
He's super down on himself.

2199
01:48:30.801 --> 01:48:38.888
And he actually – his next job was supposed to be with Max Born at the University of Göttingen, which is another powerhouse.

2200
01:48:39.249 --> 01:48:46.315
Back then, dude, Germany had these amazing, amazing research institutions in Berlin, in Munich, in Göttingen.

2201
01:48:46.795 --> 01:48:50.438
All of that just got trashed by the Nazis over the course of like five years.

2202
01:48:50.798 --> 01:48:54.882
But like before the Nazis, they were like the epitome of –

2203
01:48:55.502 --> 01:48:56.763
It was them and then Cambridge.

2204
01:48:57.264 --> 01:48:58.926
And that was the whole thing.

2205
01:48:59.046 --> 01:49:01.648
History doesn't repeat itself, but it does rhyme.

2206
01:49:01.688 --> 01:49:02.709
Yeah, but it does rhyme.

2207
01:49:02.869 --> 01:49:11.197
And so one of the things is like it's so hard to build up these institutions and so easy to just like break it down in like a couple of years.

2208
01:49:11.237 --> 01:49:15.181
We got to be very careful as a society that we're not doing that right now.

2209
01:49:15.881 --> 01:49:19.365
So he goes to Bourne and he's like, dude, I don't know if you still want me.

2210
01:49:19.905 --> 01:49:21.185
Like I just nearly failed.

2211
01:49:21.205 --> 01:49:21.546
Yeah.

2212
01:49:21.626 --> 01:49:22.866
And then born was like, was it ween?

2213
01:49:23.506 --> 01:49:26.727
He's like, I know that.

2214
01:49:26.767 --> 01:49:27.107
Yeah.

2215
01:49:27.128 --> 01:49:27.408
Yeah.

2216
01:49:27.608 --> 01:49:28.988
And then he's like, what happened?

2217
01:49:29.308 --> 01:49:31.629
And then like Heisenberg, like, tells him and born is like, okay.

2218
01:49:32.969 --> 01:49:35.830
Arguably, you should have known how to do that.

2219
01:49:35.890 --> 01:49:37.491
He's got it right.

2220
01:49:37.511 --> 01:49:37.731
Yeah.

2221
01:49:37.751 --> 01:49:38.491
But okay, fine.

2222
01:49:38.511 --> 01:49:38.871
Whatever.

2223
01:49:38.912 --> 01:49:42.073
Let's just let I'll you're still my postdoc.

2224
01:49:42.313 --> 01:49:42.773
Like, come on.

2225
01:49:43.653 --> 01:49:47.614
So all of this stuff is what's called old quantum theory.

2226
01:49:47.815 --> 01:49:48.115
Okay.

2227
01:49:48.215 --> 01:49:48.475
Okay.

2228
01:49:49.816 --> 01:49:59.104
Because the whole point is what they're trying to do is they're trying to get some kind of visual mechanistic understanding of what's happening inside of the atom.

2229
01:50:00.285 --> 01:50:03.328
They're like, how does the electron go around the atom?

2230
01:50:04.349 --> 01:50:06.871
And this starts frustrating a lot of people.

2231
01:50:08.189 --> 01:50:09.491
Specifically the young people.

2232
01:50:10.011 --> 01:50:12.294
Because the old guys are really into this, right?

2233
01:50:12.855 --> 01:50:18.401
They're in this old phase from the 1905, 1910s, 1920s where it's worked.

2234
01:50:18.501 --> 01:50:19.623
Bohr did this and it worked.

2235
01:50:19.683 --> 01:50:21.845
Sommerfeld did this and now he's explaining this stuff.

2236
01:50:22.767 --> 01:50:23.547
So it's working.

2237
01:50:23.567 --> 01:50:23.988
Mm-hmm.

2238
01:50:25.145 --> 01:50:27.265
But the new guys aren't aren't really sold on it.

2239
01:50:27.285 --> 01:50:28.146
They're not rocking with it.

2240
01:50:28.206 --> 01:50:28.386
Right.

2241
01:50:28.906 --> 01:50:31.326
So Heisenberg specifically is not rocking with it.

2242
01:50:31.726 --> 01:50:34.787
He's also really into mock and positivism.

2243
01:50:35.127 --> 01:50:39.208
OK, so he has this like crazy case of hay fever.

2244
01:50:39.548 --> 01:50:40.808
He had allergies all his life.

2245
01:50:41.468 --> 01:50:45.349
He actually went to Copenhagen for a bit to see Niels Bohr, got the hay fever.

2246
01:50:45.629 --> 01:50:49.550
And so he went to this this island off the North Sea in Germany.

2247
01:50:50.590 --> 01:50:56.973
Um, and he just like stayed there for like two weeks all on his own.

2248
01:50:57.494 --> 01:50:59.815
And that's where he comes up with this magician shit.

2249
01:50:59.895 --> 01:51:00.555
Oh my God.

2250
01:51:00.635 --> 01:51:00.895
Okay.

2251
01:51:01.255 --> 01:51:06.358
On his own on an Island trying to recover from allergies on his bout of hay fever.

2252
01:51:06.418 --> 01:51:06.698
Yeah.

2253
01:51:06.718 --> 01:51:14.522
Sweating in the bed, sweating in the bed and he has this epiphany and his epiphany has to do with the same one of his big, he was a huge fan of Einstein.

2254
01:51:14.922 --> 01:51:15.142
Okay.

2255
01:51:15.602 --> 01:51:21.804
And he loved the fact that Einstein used this like mox positivism to say, what is the stuff that I can measure?

2256
01:51:21.884 --> 01:51:23.044
What is my experience?

2257
01:51:23.444 --> 01:51:25.024
And he asked the same thing about this.

2258
01:51:26.365 --> 01:51:37.507
And his paper, the Umdeutung paper in 1925, his first page is like a manifesto about philosophy and how physics needs a new direction.

2259
01:51:37.947 --> 01:51:43.909
And it's this pretentious, it's like this tirade on why everyone else is wrong.

2260
01:51:46.449 --> 01:51:51.591
The central tenet is, can you see an electron going around an atom?

2261
01:51:52.752 --> 01:51:53.452
That's what he asks.

2262
01:51:53.912 --> 01:51:54.633
The answer is no.

2263
01:51:55.133 --> 01:51:57.454
We cannot observe an electron going around an atom.

2264
01:51:57.634 --> 01:51:58.394
We can't see it.

2265
01:51:59.134 --> 01:51:59.835
What can we see?

2266
01:52:00.255 --> 01:52:05.357
What we can see are spectral lines, their frequencies, and their brightness.

2267
01:52:06.237 --> 01:52:07.878
That's what we should be concerned about.

2268
01:52:09.020 --> 01:52:11.341
Those are in principle observable.

2269
01:52:11.382 --> 01:52:12.062
That's what he uses.

2270
01:52:12.422 --> 01:52:14.303
He says in principle those are observable.

2271
01:52:14.583 --> 01:52:18.206
The atom, there's no way we can see an electron.

2272
01:52:18.566 --> 01:52:21.768
We can see planets move around, but we can't do that with this stuff.

2273
01:52:22.468 --> 01:52:26.131
What we can see is their transitions from different energy levels.

2274
01:52:27.498 --> 01:52:31.420
and we can see how bright those transitions are.

2275
01:52:31.760 --> 01:52:33.220
That's what we should be concerned with.

2276
01:52:33.881 --> 01:52:40.383
So he develops a new quantum description for the kinematics and the mechanics of atoms.

2277
01:52:40.563 --> 01:52:41.244
That's what he called it.

2278
01:52:43.285 --> 01:52:46.846
And when he's doing this, this is where the magician stuff comes in.

2279
01:52:47.146 --> 01:52:53.789
He's like, okay, you know how I have like a, I can go from like, let's say n equals six, the higher orbital to n equals one.

2280
01:52:54.329 --> 01:52:55.970
Okay, I can go all the way down like that.

2281
01:52:57.851 --> 01:53:00.972
I can do that in one jump or I can do that in several jumps.

2282
01:53:00.992 --> 01:53:04.133
I can go from six to three, three to one or six to two, two to one.

2283
01:53:04.413 --> 01:53:06.975
And each of those transitions corresponds to a frequency.

2284
01:53:07.415 --> 01:53:11.236
And if I add those frequencies, then they equal the big frequency.

2285
01:53:11.416 --> 01:53:11.557
Okay.

2286
01:53:11.717 --> 01:53:13.337
Because of the way that the energy works, right?

2287
01:53:13.357 --> 01:53:16.339
With like the energy is proportional to the frequency.

2288
01:53:16.359 --> 01:53:21.521
So if I want to add the energy from here to here, all I'm doing is I'm adding the frequencies from here to here, right?

2289
01:53:21.681 --> 01:53:23.182
So the frequencies add.

2290
01:53:24.223 --> 01:53:26.241
Okay, so he's like, what does that remind me of?

2291
01:53:26.382 --> 01:53:26.705
Well...

2292
01:53:28.158 --> 01:53:47.389
The way we describe waves in mathematics is with an exponential, e to the power of i times some omega t. Basically, I'm saying e to the power of some imaginary times like the angular component, which is the speed at which my angle is moving, the frequency, times some time.

2293
01:53:47.589 --> 01:53:49.610
That's going to give me a sine wave and a cosine wave.

2294
01:53:50.190 --> 01:53:55.193
And with exponentials, just like e to the power of a times,

2295
01:53:56.305 --> 01:53:59.707
If I want to add, like the frequencies are in the exponentials, right?

2296
01:53:59.727 --> 01:54:03.649
So if I want to add the exponential stuff, I got to multiply these two.

2297
01:54:03.749 --> 01:54:03.929
Yes.

2298
01:54:04.409 --> 01:54:04.810
Make sense?

2299
01:54:04.830 --> 01:54:05.010
Yes.

2300
01:54:05.350 --> 01:54:10.333
So e to the power of a times e to the power of b is going to give me a plus b on the top.

2301
01:54:10.773 --> 01:54:10.953
Right?

2302
01:54:11.033 --> 01:54:13.374
That's the standard thing that we do with exponentials.

2303
01:54:13.474 --> 01:54:13.735
Yep.

2304
01:54:14.715 --> 01:54:16.836
Okay, so that's the frequency part.

2305
01:54:17.016 --> 01:54:17.156
Yes.

2306
01:54:17.436 --> 01:54:19.656
The amplitude part is the stuff that's in front, right?

2307
01:54:19.676 --> 01:54:25.318
There's going to be some number multiplied by this sign that's going to tell me how big my sine and cosine is, right?

2308
01:54:25.878 --> 01:54:30.900
So if I'm adding the exponential part, I'm going to have to multiply the amplitude part.

2309
01:54:31.300 --> 01:54:31.520
Okay.

2310
01:54:31.820 --> 01:54:35.582
So he's like, that's what I should be worried about is how do I multiply these amplitudes?

2311
01:54:35.862 --> 01:54:37.002
He tries doing it the normal way.

2312
01:54:37.022 --> 01:54:37.542
It doesn't work.

2313
01:54:37.662 --> 01:54:37.882
Okay.

2314
01:54:38.003 --> 01:54:38.143
Okay.

2315
01:54:38.163 --> 01:54:43.185
It doesn't like just mesh with the way that like these transitions work and things like that.

2316
01:54:43.505 --> 01:54:46.606
And he comes up with this really weird multiplication rule.

2317
01:54:47.852 --> 01:54:54.375
that says that if I multiply two like A times B, that's different from if I multiply B times A.

2318
01:54:55.255 --> 01:54:55.996
Okay.

2319
01:54:56.236 --> 01:54:57.896
It's called non-commutativity.

2320
01:54:58.377 --> 01:54:58.657
Okay.

2321
01:54:58.837 --> 01:55:00.137
Non-commutation, okay?

2322
01:55:00.298 --> 01:55:00.538
Okay.

2323
01:55:00.938 --> 01:55:05.460
The commutative, like, commutation is central to the multiplication of normal numbers, right?

2324
01:55:05.520 --> 01:55:07.481
Five times four equals four times five equals 20.

2325
01:55:07.501 --> 01:55:08.121
Yes, right, right.

2326
01:55:08.141 --> 01:55:09.982
That's why I'm furrowing my brow.

2327
01:55:10.002 --> 01:55:12.203
Yeah, but now you're like, and even Heisenberg's like,

2328
01:55:14.244 --> 01:55:16.285
even he didn't know the magic trick that he was pulling.

2329
01:55:16.365 --> 01:55:16.546
Right.

2330
01:55:16.706 --> 01:55:16.866
Right.

2331
01:55:16.886 --> 01:55:18.747
But he wrote this up and he sends it.

2332
01:55:18.847 --> 01:55:20.168
He's like, this is, it works.

2333
01:55:21.869 --> 01:55:29.714
It tells you the brightness of the, of the spectral lines, which is a new experimental thing that you've like sort of explained.

2334
01:55:30.334 --> 01:55:31.455
He's like, I don't, I don't know.

2335
01:55:31.815 --> 01:55:32.035
Right.

2336
01:55:32.555 --> 01:55:32.756
Yeah.

2337
01:55:33.096 --> 01:55:36.598
He sends it to, he sends it to his postdoc advisor, Max Born.

2338
01:55:38.099 --> 01:55:41.101
And Max Born's like, Oh dude, these are matrices.

2339
01:55:41.121 --> 01:55:41.261
Right.

2340
01:55:42.270 --> 01:55:42.570
Okay.

2341
01:55:43.211 --> 01:55:47.676
Because Max Born has had the experience of being a mathematical physicist for 20 years.

2342
01:55:47.716 --> 01:55:48.517
Right, right.

2343
01:55:48.537 --> 01:55:51.079
Like Heisenberg might be a new guy who's got ideas.

2344
01:55:51.139 --> 01:55:51.400
Yeah.

2345
01:55:51.640 --> 01:55:54.823
But Max Born immediately recognizes this mathematics as matrices.

2346
01:55:54.863 --> 01:55:55.103
Yeah.

2347
01:55:55.284 --> 01:55:55.504
Okay.

2348
01:55:55.764 --> 01:56:00.629
And in matrices, matrices are ways in which you can manipulate vectors.

2349
01:56:00.649 --> 01:56:00.829
Yeah.

2350
01:56:00.849 --> 01:56:00.990
Yeah.

2351
01:56:01.570 --> 01:56:04.512
Such that they point in different directions, you stretch them out and things like that.

2352
01:56:04.793 --> 01:56:06.114
That's like standard linear algebra.

2353
01:56:06.154 --> 01:56:11.998
Linear algebra back then was not something that every physicist took, which is why Heisenberg had no idea what the hell he was doing.

2354
01:56:12.058 --> 01:56:19.164
But Max Born had done mathematics, and so he knew some basic linear algebra, and he recognizes this immediately.

2355
01:56:19.444 --> 01:56:21.445
So Heisenberg publishes his Umdoitung paper.

2356
01:56:21.826 --> 01:56:27.010
Max Born and Jordan then published their version of the paper, reformulating it in terms of matrices.

2357
01:56:27.070 --> 01:56:27.230
Yep.

2358
01:56:28.371 --> 01:56:33.895
And to give you a sense of why this commutation thing works, I'm going to give you a little demonstration, okay?

2359
01:56:34.416 --> 01:56:35.777
We got the gold eagle.

2360
01:56:35.857 --> 01:56:37.579
This is why I wanted the gold eagle in the beginning.

2361
01:56:37.599 --> 01:56:38.499
Straight from the White House.

2362
01:56:38.620 --> 01:56:38.900
Okay?

2363
01:56:39.400 --> 01:56:41.342
So here we've got a thing.

2364
01:56:41.582 --> 01:56:41.782
Yes.

2365
01:56:41.842 --> 01:56:42.022
Right?

2366
01:56:42.083 --> 01:56:44.284
Let's say it's an abstract.

2367
01:56:45.105 --> 01:56:45.785
Like object?

2368
01:56:45.926 --> 01:56:46.126
Yes.

2369
01:56:46.266 --> 01:56:46.506
Okay.

2370
01:56:47.026 --> 01:56:56.171
And one of the ways to visualize what matrices do, one of the common techniques that you use in matrices is you can have a three by three matrix, which is nine different numbers in three rows, three columns.

2371
01:56:56.191 --> 01:56:56.391
Yes.

2372
01:56:56.752 --> 01:56:58.533
All with a bunch of sines and cosines.

2373
01:56:58.973 --> 01:57:02.595
And there's sines and cosines of the angle of rotation that you rotate an object.

2374
01:57:02.715 --> 01:57:02.975
Okay.

2375
01:57:03.095 --> 01:57:09.999
Frequently in video games also, like when you rotate stuff or when things are happening, you're using matrices to actually render.

2376
01:57:10.019 --> 01:57:11.140
It's like this three-axis.

2377
01:57:11.580 --> 01:57:14.082
Yeah, there's like X, Y, Z.

2378
01:57:14.242 --> 01:57:18.924
And so when you rotate along some axis, there's some signs and some cosines somewhere and things like that.

2379
01:57:18.944 --> 01:57:19.825
Okay, that makes sense.

2380
01:57:19.965 --> 01:57:28.030
So what we're going to do right now is we're going to apply two different matrices to this thing, two different rotation matrices, but in different orders.

2381
01:57:28.450 --> 01:57:28.690
Okay.

2382
01:57:28.831 --> 01:57:30.613
Okay?

2383
01:57:30.793 --> 01:57:35.558
So, let's going to start off with the eagle facing away from me.

2384
01:57:35.659 --> 01:57:35.879
Yes.

2385
01:57:36.279 --> 01:57:39.863
The first rotation we're going to do is along the Z-axis, so from the top down.

2386
01:57:39.964 --> 01:57:40.204
Yeah.

2387
01:57:40.244 --> 01:57:42.927
We're going to rotate 90 degrees towards you, to the left.

2388
01:57:42.947 --> 01:57:43.187
Okay.

2389
01:57:43.368 --> 01:57:43.468
Okay?

2390
01:57:43.488 --> 01:57:43.668
Okay.

2391
01:57:43.948 --> 01:57:51.291
And the second one we're going to do is along this axis, which is perpendicular to me, like, and it's going to rotate away from me downward.

2392
01:57:51.311 --> 01:57:51.651
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

2393
01:57:51.671 --> 01:57:54.272
So it's going to be facing the… So we're going to see what happens.

2394
01:57:54.292 --> 01:57:55.093
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

2395
01:57:55.113 --> 01:57:57.714
So the first thing we're going to rotate 90 degrees along Z.

2396
01:57:57.914 --> 01:57:58.114
Yes.

2397
01:57:58.234 --> 01:57:59.675
And then 90 degrees along this.

2398
01:57:59.755 --> 01:57:59.955
Yes.

2399
01:58:00.075 --> 01:58:00.315
Okay.

2400
01:58:00.615 --> 01:58:02.256
So the first thing, 90 degrees along U.

2401
01:58:02.296 --> 01:58:03.096
Now it's facing U.

2402
01:58:03.196 --> 01:58:03.416
Yes.

2403
01:58:03.816 --> 01:58:05.277
Now we rotate along this axis.

2404
01:58:05.317 --> 01:58:06.377
So it's facing downward.

2405
01:58:06.417 --> 01:58:06.577
Yeah.

2406
01:58:07.078 --> 01:58:07.918
And it's looking like that.

2407
01:58:08.018 --> 01:58:08.218
Yes.

2408
01:58:08.338 --> 01:58:08.618
Okay.

2409
01:58:08.918 --> 01:58:13.020
So it's an eagle that's like kind of like lying down on the table.

2410
01:58:13.240 --> 01:58:13.981
Now facing.

2411
01:58:14.441 --> 01:58:15.121
Facing you.

2412
01:58:15.201 --> 01:58:15.541
My direction.

2413
01:58:15.561 --> 01:58:16.622
Lying down, facing you.

2414
01:58:16.762 --> 01:58:16.962
Yes.

2415
01:58:17.062 --> 01:58:17.322
Okay.

2416
01:58:17.663 --> 01:58:19.003
Now let's start again.

2417
01:58:19.203 --> 01:58:20.344
Having started facing.

2418
01:58:20.484 --> 01:58:21.125
Vertically facing.

2419
01:58:21.265 --> 01:58:23.066
Having started facing upright that way.

2420
01:58:23.146 --> 01:58:23.366
Okay.

2421
01:58:23.406 --> 01:58:24.907
Now I'm going to do it the opposite direction.

2422
01:58:24.947 --> 01:58:26.708
I'm going to first rotate along this axis.

2423
01:58:26.748 --> 01:58:26.968
Yeah.

2424
01:58:27.008 --> 01:58:27.188
Yeah.

2425
01:58:27.868 --> 01:58:28.649
Now it's facing down.

2426
01:58:28.889 --> 01:58:30.670
And then now I'm going to rotate along this axis.

2427
01:58:30.730 --> 01:58:31.911
Yeah.

2428
01:58:31.931 --> 01:58:33.292
Now it's facing downward.

2429
01:58:33.352 --> 01:58:33.532
Yeah.

2430
01:58:33.832 --> 01:58:34.993
With its stomach on the table.

2431
01:58:35.013 --> 01:58:35.113
Yes.

2432
01:58:35.133 --> 01:58:35.353
Yes.

2433
01:58:35.913 --> 01:58:36.193
Yes.

2434
01:58:36.554 --> 01:58:41.897
And this is why the order of the order matters matters because of the rotational dynamics that happen.

2435
01:58:41.917 --> 01:58:43.438
Because this is a matrix.

2436
01:58:43.578 --> 01:58:43.798
Right.

2437
01:58:44.339 --> 01:58:47.501
What I just applied is not I didn't multiply this by a simple number.

2438
01:58:47.581 --> 01:58:47.801
Right.

2439
01:58:48.021 --> 01:58:49.402
I multiplied it by a matrix.

2440
01:58:49.442 --> 01:58:52.144
The orientation of this thing, I applied a matrix to it.

2441
01:58:52.184 --> 01:58:52.424
Right.

2442
01:58:52.925 --> 01:58:53.125
Right.

2443
01:58:53.145 --> 01:58:54.646
That gave me a new orientation.

2444
01:58:54.786 --> 01:58:54.966
Right.

2445
01:58:55.266 --> 01:58:55.486
Right.

2446
01:58:55.687 --> 01:58:56.027
Versus.

2447
01:58:57.490 --> 01:59:04.035
Yes, that's actually, no, that's a great visual explainer for why the order matters.

2448
01:59:04.095 --> 01:59:06.778
Yeah, the order in linear algebra, the order matters.

2449
01:59:07.218 --> 01:59:09.240
The order of operations matter.

2450
01:59:09.260 --> 01:59:12.022
The operation that we're doing is not multiplying by a number.

2451
01:59:12.122 --> 01:59:12.302
Right.

2452
01:59:12.362 --> 01:59:14.284
We're acting with a matrix.

2453
01:59:14.884 --> 01:59:25.972
One of the things I really am upset about my early math education is that I'm a visual learner and I just did not get – no one ever translated the visual of what's actually happening.

2454
01:59:26.012 --> 01:59:26.232
Yeah.

2455
01:59:27.053 --> 01:59:29.535
As we were discussing the concepts, I only learned that later in life.

2456
01:59:29.555 --> 01:59:30.836
I'm like this would have been way easier for me.

2457
01:59:30.996 --> 01:59:31.216
Yeah.

2458
01:59:31.656 --> 01:59:40.823
Because it – Dude, because mathematics is a language about – it's a beautiful – it's the only language that works when we're trying to describe like –

2459
01:59:42.013 --> 01:59:44.834
like, you know, processes in a very precise way.

2460
01:59:44.894 --> 01:59:45.054
Yes.

2461
01:59:45.475 --> 01:59:45.675
Right.

2462
01:59:45.815 --> 01:59:46.015
Yes.

2463
01:59:46.675 --> 01:59:47.256
That's brilliant.

2464
01:59:47.376 --> 01:59:47.956
I totally get it.

2465
01:59:48.196 --> 01:59:49.156
It makes sense.

2466
01:59:49.196 --> 01:59:49.597
Right.

2467
01:59:49.657 --> 01:59:51.137
And another like just a side bit.

2468
01:59:51.738 --> 01:59:54.399
These rotations do not commute in three dimensions.

2469
01:59:54.939 --> 01:59:59.021
But if I were to do a two dimensional rotation, meaning I can only do this way.

2470
01:59:59.101 --> 01:59:59.301
Yeah.

2471
01:59:59.501 --> 01:59:59.661
Right.

2472
01:59:59.942 --> 02:00:02.983
Three dimensions means I can rotate this way and like all these ways.

2473
02:00:03.263 --> 02:00:05.464
Two dimensional means I'm like I'm stuck on the plane.

2474
02:00:05.544 --> 02:00:05.724
Yeah.

2475
02:00:05.844 --> 02:00:08.266
If I rotate this way, 90 degrees and then this way, 30.

2476
02:00:09.246 --> 02:00:13.511
Whereas if I rotate this way 30 and then this way 90, I get the same.

2477
02:00:13.571 --> 02:00:14.192
Yeah.

2478
02:00:14.272 --> 02:00:14.452
Right.

2479
02:00:14.692 --> 02:00:16.895
So in two dimensions, rotations commute.

2480
02:00:17.175 --> 02:00:17.355
Right.

2481
02:00:17.615 --> 02:00:18.797
And the order doesn't matter.

2482
02:00:19.037 --> 02:00:20.459
But in three dimensions, they do.

2483
02:00:21.220 --> 02:00:28.327
And that's actually going to be like, you know, if you if we get into quantum mechanics later, like that's actually like a huge, huge thing.

2484
02:00:29.369 --> 02:00:30.150
in quantum mechanics.

2485
02:00:30.170 --> 02:00:35.056
This is called SO3, the group of rotations in 3D.

2486
02:00:35.477 --> 02:00:37.519
And it's the underpinning for, like, spin.

2487
02:00:37.539 --> 02:00:38.000
Yep.

2488
02:00:38.120 --> 02:00:39.182
And, like, all the...

2489
02:00:39.222 --> 02:00:40.223
Spin up, spin down.

2490
02:00:40.243 --> 02:00:41.545
Yeah, all of the crazy stuff.

2491
02:00:41.585 --> 02:00:42.125
Yeah, like...

2492
02:00:44.508 --> 02:00:49.710
And all of that just comes from like basic mathematics of us living in three dimensions.

2493
02:00:50.411 --> 02:01:00.355
It's an interesting application of like fundamental math concepts and what and what the implications of them are when you apply it into like this functional context.

2494
02:01:00.495 --> 02:01:00.715
Yeah.

2495
02:01:00.895 --> 02:01:01.095
Yeah.

2496
02:01:01.135 --> 02:01:09.179
But this is and it's it's crazy that like Heisenberg like came up with this multiplication rule not knowing what the hell he was doing.

2497
02:01:10.199 --> 02:01:10.479
Right?

2498
02:01:11.360 --> 02:01:14.022
Like, he must have thought he was going fully crazy.

2499
02:01:14.042 --> 02:01:17.325
He's like, I got A times B does not equal B times A.

2500
02:01:18.946 --> 02:01:20.747
And then Bourne was like, no, this is fine.

2501
02:01:21.488 --> 02:01:22.889
Actually, I'll do you one better.

2502
02:01:23.769 --> 02:01:30.595
And then Max Bourne, Heisenberg, and Jordan did the follow-up after that, all in 1925.

2503
02:01:30.935 --> 02:01:37.300
And it started just – because now you got this language, right, where now you don't have to care about –

2504
02:01:37.900 --> 02:01:39.221
what the electron is doing.

2505
02:01:39.361 --> 02:01:39.541
Right.

2506
02:01:39.921 --> 02:01:40.141
Right?

2507
02:01:40.261 --> 02:01:40.441
Right.

2508
02:01:41.382 --> 02:01:42.962
It's that positivism concept.

2509
02:01:42.982 --> 02:01:49.905
You focus on what is actually, which has, it's interesting because the theory created experimental outcome.

2510
02:01:49.945 --> 02:01:52.586
Like it changed the experimental framework of how you think about it.

2511
02:01:52.606 --> 02:01:52.826
Yeah, yeah.

2512
02:01:52.846 --> 02:01:53.827
How you even think about it.

2513
02:01:53.947 --> 02:01:55.628
Now you got these quantum states.

2514
02:01:55.928 --> 02:01:56.148
Yes.

2515
02:01:56.648 --> 02:01:56.848
Right.

2516
02:01:56.968 --> 02:01:58.369
And oh, what are the quantum states?

2517
02:01:58.409 --> 02:02:01.571
It's like now we start getting in the whole Copenhagen interpretation.

2518
02:02:01.631 --> 02:02:05.653
It's like now and now we're just starting to piss off Einstein.

2519
02:02:05.973 --> 02:02:07.274
Actually, a funny story.

2520
02:02:07.534 --> 02:02:09.175
So Heisenberg told Einstein.

2521
02:02:09.295 --> 02:02:09.475
Yes.

2522
02:02:09.555 --> 02:02:12.796
They're like, I'm a huge fan of yours and like the whole mock and positivism.

2523
02:02:12.857 --> 02:02:14.397
Like your philosophy is amazing.

2524
02:02:15.118 --> 02:02:16.598
So I actually used it to do this.

2525
02:02:16.879 --> 02:02:19.000
This is when Einstein and Heisenberg were in a debate.

2526
02:02:19.420 --> 02:02:22.201
And then it's like, dude, I used your and then Heisenberg.

2527
02:02:22.522 --> 02:02:23.982
Einstein apparently said, you know,

2528
02:02:25.403 --> 02:02:27.304
A good joke is only funny the first time.

2529
02:02:28.385 --> 02:02:29.485
What a dick.

2530
02:02:30.306 --> 02:02:31.686
Yeah, that's kind of a dick move.

2531
02:02:31.726 --> 02:02:34.488
It's like Heisenberg is like way younger than you.

2532
02:02:34.588 --> 02:02:36.689
It's like thinks of you as his idol.

2533
02:02:36.709 --> 02:02:39.771
Like he was born when you wrote the 1905 papers.

2534
02:02:40.231 --> 02:02:42.652
And then now it's like you're so funny, dude.

2535
02:02:44.193 --> 02:02:51.537
My mind is just sort of because, you know, as we continue to have these conversations, everything gets more and more crystallized.

2536
02:02:51.557 --> 02:02:51.817
Yeah.

2537
02:02:51.857 --> 02:02:51.957
Yeah.

2538
02:02:52.897 --> 02:03:00.423
So I can begin to intuit as you're going through because we've talked about the Heisenberg uncertainty principle multiple times on the show.

2539
02:03:00.784 --> 02:03:03.546
We've talked about quantum mechanics in general ways all the time.

2540
02:03:03.806 --> 02:03:10.851
But now having walked through this story arc, the historical context is also super important and I don't want to lose sight of.

2541
02:03:12.272 --> 02:03:15.494
It's this idea like these ideas are compounding.

2542
02:03:15.514 --> 02:03:16.434
Yeah, they're built up.

2543
02:03:16.794 --> 02:03:18.075
They're built up one at a time.

2544
02:03:18.095 --> 02:03:19.696
It's not just like thin air.

2545
02:03:19.876 --> 02:03:20.076
No.

2546
02:03:20.336 --> 02:03:22.817
Each time fresh from zero baseline.

2547
02:03:22.877 --> 02:03:23.637
No.

2548
02:03:24.238 --> 02:03:29.400
Because a lot of people spend a lot of time doing stuff and being wrong, by the way.

2549
02:03:29.620 --> 02:03:29.780
Yeah.

2550
02:03:30.020 --> 02:03:33.842
Like Sommerfeld, his PhD advisor was wrong about there's no elliptical orbits.

2551
02:03:33.922 --> 02:03:34.082
Right.

2552
02:03:34.582 --> 02:03:36.363
That was just something that was something you made up.

2553
02:03:36.383 --> 02:03:36.543
Right.

2554
02:03:37.003 --> 02:03:37.283
Right.

2555
02:03:37.463 --> 02:03:37.643
Right.

2556
02:03:37.843 --> 02:03:41.265
But like even Bohr, Bohr's like circular orbits, again, something you made up.

2557
02:03:41.285 --> 02:03:42.165
That's not how it works.

2558
02:03:43.086 --> 02:03:43.306
Right.

2559
02:03:43.586 --> 02:03:49.128
But it's like but these incremental advances start sort of gave way to the to the ideas that we have today.

2560
02:03:49.468 --> 02:03:51.369
And even the Heisenberg uncertainty principle.

2561
02:03:51.429 --> 02:03:51.589
Right.

2562
02:03:51.909 --> 02:03:53.510
That didn't exist in 1925.

2563
02:03:53.890 --> 02:03:55.731
That came about after this.

2564
02:03:55.931 --> 02:04:05.355
This stuff, because it turns out that if you have these non-commutations, these variables like A times B, there's some things like A times C where A times C equals C times A.

2565
02:04:05.855 --> 02:04:08.036
For those two, there's no Heisenberg-Unscerny principle.

2566
02:04:08.336 --> 02:04:12.918
The Heisenberg-Unscerny principle only goes for variables that do not commute.

2567
02:04:13.698 --> 02:04:13.898
Right?

2568
02:04:14.158 --> 02:04:18.639
So when you have momentum times position, that's different times position times momentum.

2569
02:04:18.779 --> 02:04:26.161
If you measure one and then the other, that's different from measuring P and then the... And this is part of the reason why you can only know one and not the other.

2570
02:04:26.221 --> 02:04:26.821
Yeah, yeah.

2571
02:04:26.961 --> 02:04:29.081
And then it becomes a super general thing.

2572
02:04:29.341 --> 02:04:31.922
Because like, look, these rotations don't commute either, right?

2573
02:04:31.942 --> 02:04:32.102
Yes.

2574
02:04:32.142 --> 02:04:37.303
So now you have something like the total angular momentum and the angular momentum in a particular direction.

2575
02:04:37.643 --> 02:04:42.424
Which is like, you know, the J total and then JZ is what we say in quantum mechanics.

2576
02:04:42.724 --> 02:04:46.845
The angular momentum in this direction and the angular momentum total in any given direction.

2577
02:04:46.865 --> 02:04:46.965
Yeah.

2578
02:04:47.225 --> 02:04:49.145
Those two don't commute because of these rules.

2579
02:04:49.445 --> 02:04:52.446
And so that means you can't – those have a Heisenberg uncertainty principle.

2580
02:04:52.486 --> 02:04:52.626
Right.

2581
02:04:52.726 --> 02:04:55.507
Energy and time also have a Heisenberg uncertainty principle, right?

2582
02:04:55.807 --> 02:05:01.108
All because of this mathematical structure that Heisenberg found in this 1925 Umdeutung paper.

2583
02:05:01.468 --> 02:05:06.049
I got 99 problems, but certainty ain't one.

2584
02:05:06.089 --> 02:05:06.309
Yeah.

2585
02:05:07.369 --> 02:05:08.050
Yeah.

2586
02:05:08.390 --> 02:05:10.071
And that's not a problem for him.

2587
02:05:10.432 --> 02:05:11.272
It is for Einstein.

2588
02:05:11.312 --> 02:05:11.853
It is for Einstein.

2589
02:05:13.074 --> 02:05:16.477
This is – and I mean this really – Yeah, and that was 100 years ago.

2590
02:05:16.497 --> 02:05:17.057
Right.

2591
02:05:17.137 --> 02:05:28.287
And this is kind of like that 100 years where now the UN is now proclaiming 2025 as the International Year of Quantum Science and Technology, which it's crazy –

2592
02:05:28.767 --> 02:05:30.907
to understand how it all started.

2593
02:05:31.088 --> 02:05:31.308
Yeah.

2594
02:05:31.588 --> 02:05:33.488
From a random hay fever guy.

2595
02:05:33.608 --> 02:05:33.828
Right.

2596
02:05:33.848 --> 02:05:35.508
Like dude was 23.

2597
02:05:35.829 --> 02:05:36.089
Right.

2598
02:05:36.129 --> 02:05:39.409
Like he was young and that's why he came up with this stuff.

2599
02:05:39.889 --> 02:05:43.290
There is there is something about the youthful naivete.

2600
02:05:43.330 --> 02:05:44.030
Yeah.

2601
02:05:44.230 --> 02:05:54.312
That you're not in you're not blocked by your prior biases that have been built up from years of experience, which may be good in some avenues.

2602
02:05:54.352 --> 02:05:56.293
But when you're trying to do novel ideation,

2603
02:05:57.233 --> 02:06:01.536
Having a wider search space because you don't already have things blocked off.

2604
02:06:01.596 --> 02:06:01.816
Yeah.

2605
02:06:02.276 --> 02:06:04.337
Allows for serendipitous discovery.

2606
02:06:04.358 --> 02:06:04.598
Yeah.

2607
02:06:04.638 --> 02:06:04.818
Yeah.

2608
02:06:04.858 --> 02:06:08.940
Which is what we're seeing with Heisenberg in the story, which is so crazy.

2609
02:06:09.160 --> 02:06:09.381
Yeah.

2610
02:06:09.661 --> 02:06:11.402
Because we also are in a situation.

2611
02:06:11.422 --> 02:06:13.463
Someone would have come up with it eventually, likely.

2612
02:06:13.483 --> 02:06:16.005
But if Heisenberg didn't get that PhD.

2613
02:06:17.025 --> 02:06:18.366
which was on the table.

2614
02:06:18.486 --> 02:06:19.667
Yeah, that was on the table.

2615
02:06:20.007 --> 02:06:21.468
It was very much on the table.

2616
02:06:22.009 --> 02:06:24.810
Yeah, what is the trajectory?

2617
02:06:24.990 --> 02:06:26.952
I mean, we would have been a few years late, I think.

2618
02:06:27.032 --> 02:06:28.092
Right.

2619
02:06:28.152 --> 02:06:31.475
And I think we would have come about it in a different way.

2620
02:06:31.695 --> 02:06:33.216
There wouldn't have been a magician paper.

2621
02:06:33.556 --> 02:06:36.258
It would have required a bit more and a bit more and a bit more.

2622
02:06:36.538 --> 02:06:41.061
Schrodinger actually independently came up with his wave equation that was separate from Heisenberg's.

2623
02:06:41.541 --> 02:06:43.562
And then it turns out that those two were equivalent.

2624
02:06:43.722 --> 02:06:44.003
Got it.

2625
02:06:44.843 --> 02:06:51.387
But Schrodinger's was much more still in the vein of old quantum of like, I want to see what the electron is doing.

2626
02:06:51.427 --> 02:06:51.727
Right.

2627
02:06:51.847 --> 02:06:53.709
So he came up with these orbitals and things like that.

2628
02:06:53.769 --> 02:07:00.233
And that's predominantly what physicists use today, because still to this day, we like having a mental picture of what is going down.

2629
02:07:00.273 --> 02:07:00.433
Right.

2630
02:07:00.553 --> 02:07:00.753
Right.

2631
02:07:01.093 --> 02:07:07.357
And Schrodinger's, I mean, Schrodinger's mechanics is like the wave wave mechanics is an awesome thing.

2632
02:07:07.637 --> 02:07:15.321
But this commutation stuff and this algebra, this non-commutative algebra is actually much more deep.

2633
02:07:15.521 --> 02:07:29.088
Because this is something that underpins, like this idea of symmetry and using algebra with symmetry and all of these principles is something that now underpins like everything, like quantum field theory, standard model, like all sorts of stuff.

2634
02:07:29.949 --> 02:07:40.336
Speaking of standard model, we have our lovely drink that our co-host has been drinking all episode, which is the inaugural standard model agave soda.

2635
02:07:40.917 --> 02:07:43.138
Named after the standard model of particle physics.

2636
02:07:43.399 --> 02:07:44.980
Which we love to talk about on the show.

2637
02:07:45.020 --> 02:07:46.781
Yeah, and we'll always talk about it.

2638
02:07:47.342 --> 02:07:49.423
Great plug for standard model.

2639
02:07:49.663 --> 02:07:54.847
We've covered four incredible topics, concept stories today.

2640
02:07:55.468 --> 02:07:56.288
We started off...

2641
02:07:57.649 --> 02:08:00.591
Way different with reading and her thoughts.

2642
02:08:00.691 --> 02:08:01.911
Reading and her thoughts, yeah.

2643
02:08:02.032 --> 02:08:03.512
Minority Report is here.

2644
02:08:04.293 --> 02:08:05.253
Study out of Stanford.

2645
02:08:05.694 --> 02:08:08.675
We then moved on to finding genes that make us human.

2646
02:08:09.936 --> 02:08:12.037
All the stories this week were super interesting.

2647
02:08:12.177 --> 02:08:19.321
But that one was really fascinating to me because it gave me a framework into understanding evolution in a way that I didn't understand before.

2648
02:08:19.361 --> 02:08:20.422
Yeah, yeah.

2649
02:08:20.662 --> 02:08:24.904
That totally changes my concept of how to think about that.

2650
02:08:25.104 --> 02:08:26.044
Yeah, yeah.

2651
02:08:26.484 --> 02:08:28.125
And shout out to UCSD.

2652
02:08:28.205 --> 02:08:29.405
Two California stories.

2653
02:08:29.445 --> 02:08:30.085
Yeah, yeah.

2654
02:08:30.225 --> 02:08:31.365
Shout out to California Republic.

2655
02:08:31.625 --> 02:08:32.986
We then went across the pond.

2656
02:08:33.286 --> 02:08:35.786
We saw and talked about how diamonds have gotten an upgrade.

2657
02:08:35.806 --> 02:08:48.109
We have a saginal one millimeter large saginal diamonds have been created from scratch in the bakery at the high pressure science and technology advanced research.

2658
02:08:49.049 --> 02:08:56.853
in Beijing and we ended with a great, really, really illuminating retrospective on the history of quantum mechanics.

2659
02:08:56.873 --> 02:09:05.958
The 100th anniversary of the magician paper, the magician paper, which, oh, God, I think that's what Eric Weinstein thinks his unified theory is.

2660
02:09:06.078 --> 02:09:13.262
He probably does think that, you know, and I don't know, who knows, maybe in 400 years, we'll look back and think that I have my doubts.

2661
02:09:14.523 --> 02:09:16.304
We will soon know in 400 years from now.

2662
02:09:16.324 --> 02:09:16.544
Yeah.

2663
02:09:17.705 --> 02:09:21.628
Thank you all of those who've stayed to watch with us for this whole episode.

2664
02:09:22.189 --> 02:09:31.137
As always, we cover the week's breaking science headlines, research papers, and an occasional mystery box or retrospective.

2665
02:09:31.837 --> 02:09:39.084
I am your host, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Dr. Krishna Chowdhury.

2666
02:09:39.584 --> 02:09:41.306
This is From First Principles.

2667
02:09:41.326 --> 02:09:42.227
We'll see you guys next week.
