WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.131 --> 00:00:09.275
Hello internet, this is your captain speaking Lester Nare joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD Krishna Chowdhury.

2
00:00:09.776 --> 00:00:21.941
Today we have a wonderful episode we're going to do a story a research paper on planetary defense covering one of NASA's most audacious missions the DART mission.

3
00:00:23.142 --> 00:00:28.064
Spoiler alert it worked but where it gets interesting is in the how and the

4
00:00:29.825 --> 00:00:34.609
We're going to take a quick pause here to talk about a slight change to the programming.

5
00:00:35.670 --> 00:00:44.777
For many of you who have been listening to us for quite some time, you know that we do weekly episodes and the demand has just been insane for us to do more.

6
00:00:45.277 --> 00:00:51.222
So what we're going to try out here is actually doing multiple episodes a week.

7
00:00:51.762 --> 00:00:54.164
but having our episodes be focused on a single story.

8
00:00:54.184 --> 00:01:13.357
So today we're going to just be focused on the DART mission with planetary defense, but you will see our faces two more times this week with a follow-up story, and we will have the rundown be its own episode type, and I have some ideas about some game show elements to test our resident PhD.

9
00:01:13.958 --> 00:01:20.923
As always, we are going to learn about the science from the ground up today because this is From First Principles.

10
00:01:35.269 --> 00:01:41.031
So, if there is an asteroid coming to Earth, I would like to not die.

11
00:01:42.572 --> 00:01:43.992
Armageddon, deep impact?

12
00:01:44.252 --> 00:01:47.173
Yeah, all of these, I would like that not to happen.

13
00:01:47.413 --> 00:01:47.673
Okay?

14
00:01:48.194 --> 00:01:56.797
And it turns out the best way to have that happen is actually not to, like, blow it up, but to just gently nudge it out of the way.

15
00:01:57.177 --> 00:01:59.538
Gently, because, you know, it's a giant asteroid—

16
00:02:00.556 --> 00:02:03.698
You got to get a little aggressive because it's a giant asteroid.

17
00:02:03.738 --> 00:02:08.361
But at the end of the day, all we have to do is gently nudge it out of the way and maybe it'll avoid Earth.

18
00:02:08.501 --> 00:02:08.762
Okay.

19
00:02:09.322 --> 00:02:14.365
And the first time that this happened was on September 26th, 2022.

20
00:02:14.886 --> 00:02:17.627
This was NASA's double asteroid redirection test.

21
00:02:17.988 --> 00:02:19.169
I was watching it live.

22
00:02:19.269 --> 00:02:20.449
This was the DART mission.

23
00:02:21.150 --> 00:02:26.553
It collided with a moonlit of a two asteroid system.

24
00:02:26.573 --> 00:02:27.274
Okay.

25
00:02:27.885 --> 00:02:29.427
And I remember watching it live.

26
00:02:29.447 --> 00:02:35.575
You could literally see there was a little satellite that acted like a projectile, like a missile.

27
00:02:35.955 --> 00:02:36.996
And it had a camera on it.

28
00:02:37.056 --> 00:02:40.621
And it was taking a photo of the moon as it was getting closer and closer and closer.

29
00:02:41.262 --> 00:02:45.407
And when it finally hit, the other satellite took photos of it.

30
00:02:46.583 --> 00:02:52.145
It hit this moon at 14,000 miles per hour, which is about 6 kilometers per second.

31
00:02:52.885 --> 00:03:06.269
And the key result that we got immediately was that the orbit of this moonlet, the name was Dimorphos, orbiting around Didymus, the orbit of that moon around the main big asteroid—

32
00:03:07.808 --> 00:03:09.750
had reduced by 33 minutes.

33
00:03:10.390 --> 00:03:10.610
Okay.

34
00:03:10.650 --> 00:03:14.273
So it went from something like 12 hours to 11 and a half hours.

35
00:03:14.574 --> 00:03:21.840
So the contact changed the trajectory, the path, that this two-moonlit system was traveling on.

36
00:03:22.260 --> 00:03:22.720
Yeah, but...

37
00:03:23.941 --> 00:03:27.504
So the contact changed the orbit of the two-moonlit system.

38
00:03:27.544 --> 00:03:28.125
The orbit.

39
00:03:28.185 --> 00:03:29.346
That's what we could confirm.

40
00:03:29.606 --> 00:03:29.926
Okay.

41
00:03:30.307 --> 00:03:32.769
What you're saying is what this paper is about.

42
00:03:33.049 --> 00:03:33.369
I see.

43
00:03:33.389 --> 00:03:34.030
Okay, which is...

44
00:03:35.696 --> 00:03:38.619
I ran into the moon, and now the orbit has changed.

45
00:03:38.659 --> 00:03:38.880
Yes.

46
00:03:39.560 --> 00:03:44.486
But what does that do for how this moon, this two-asteroid system goes around Earth?

47
00:03:44.946 --> 00:03:47.188
Because the orbit you're talking about is locally.

48
00:03:47.289 --> 00:03:48.069
Yes, exactly.

49
00:03:48.310 --> 00:03:50.252
And getting that signal is super easy.

50
00:03:50.272 --> 00:03:51.032
30 minutes...

51
00:03:51.753 --> 00:03:53.054
Less than 12 hours.

52
00:03:53.094 --> 00:03:53.534
That's what?

53
00:03:53.554 --> 00:03:55.535
Something like a little bit less than like 5%.

54
00:03:55.695 --> 00:03:56.796
Right?

55
00:03:57.456 --> 00:03:59.397
That's a change that is doable.

56
00:03:59.637 --> 00:04:00.538
Like pretty immediately.

57
00:04:00.638 --> 00:04:07.141
Especially because we've got the DART mission in that asteroid system that's like monitoring the two going around.

58
00:04:07.202 --> 00:04:07.882
Right?

59
00:04:08.022 --> 00:04:09.723
So getting that data is very quick.

60
00:04:10.203 --> 00:04:11.304
Happened in 2022.

61
00:04:11.604 --> 00:04:14.225
We got that confirmation like within I think like a month.

62
00:04:14.405 --> 00:04:14.666
Okay.

63
00:04:14.746 --> 00:04:14.986
Okay?

64
00:04:15.626 --> 00:04:16.627
This is now what?

65
00:04:16.827 --> 00:04:17.587
Four years later?

66
00:04:17.707 --> 00:04:17.847
Yes.

67
00:04:17.867 --> 00:04:18.888
Three and a half years later.

68
00:04:19.448 --> 00:04:20.409
And now we have...

69
00:04:21.129 --> 00:04:38.436
A paper that's out in Science Advances, and it confirms that there's a measurable change in the barycenter of that two-moon system going around the sun, meaning those two asteroids now have a different orbit around the sun itself because of that crash on its moon.

70
00:04:39.156 --> 00:04:39.796
Does that make sense?

71
00:04:39.877 --> 00:04:40.917
It makes total sense.

72
00:04:40.977 --> 00:04:46.781
And I want to briefly talk about why the implications of something like this are so historical.

73
00:04:47.482 --> 00:04:51.484
You know, Earth has been around for 4 billion years.

74
00:04:52.345 --> 00:04:55.207
Life on Earth has been around for hundreds of millions of years.

75
00:04:55.747 --> 00:04:57.468
Some simple life, billions of years.

76
00:04:58.289 --> 00:05:00.110
And in the entirety of that time period...

77
00:05:01.552 --> 00:05:12.080
The life on Earth has never had control of its own destiny as it relates to celestial objects and their impact on the planet.

78
00:05:12.680 --> 00:05:27.631
So what you're suggesting is that humanity, for the first time in the four-plus billion-year history of Earth, has finally enabled itself to have agency on its cosmic destiny.

79
00:05:27.731 --> 00:05:27.871
Yeah.

80
00:05:27.891 --> 00:05:27.992
Yeah.

81
00:05:29.201 --> 00:05:32.084
based on these objects potentially coming in to impact us.

82
00:05:32.264 --> 00:05:32.744
Exactly.

83
00:05:32.824 --> 00:05:34.626
This is a very interesting story for us to understand.

84
00:05:34.646 --> 00:05:35.227
Yes, yes.

85
00:05:35.387 --> 00:05:38.910
And I just want to say a quote from the lead author of that paper.

86
00:05:39.270 --> 00:05:48.739
He said, if an asteroid is ever on its way to hitting the Earth, we can more confidently now say that we have the ability to push them around and away from Earth.

87
00:05:49.279 --> 00:05:53.984
This was by the lead author Raheel Makadia from the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign.

88
00:05:54.704 --> 00:06:02.508
And can I just say, the news article where this quote comes from, they quote him as a planetary defense researcher.

89
00:06:03.388 --> 00:06:03.629
Okay?

90
00:06:03.909 --> 00:06:09.291
When I was in grad school, on my CV is written graduate student researcher.

91
00:06:09.431 --> 00:06:13.633
This guy can write planetary defense researcher on his CV.

92
00:06:14.434 --> 00:06:15.174
How sick is that?

93
00:06:15.194 --> 00:06:15.895
That's so awesome.

94
00:06:16.135 --> 00:06:16.335
Right?

95
00:06:16.835 --> 00:06:21.317
All right, so as you said, let's get into the history and why this is so important.

96
00:06:21.577 --> 00:06:24.439
The threat comes from these things called near-Earth objects.

97
00:06:24.899 --> 00:06:29.041
This is an animation showing all of the near-Earth objects that we've ever seen.

98
00:06:29.422 --> 00:06:33.884
The blue circle or the blue orbit in the middle, that's the Earth.

99
00:06:34.424 --> 00:06:35.905
And look at all of these dots.

100
00:06:36.065 --> 00:06:36.305
Yes.

101
00:06:36.585 --> 00:06:37.466
All of these dots are...

102
00:06:38.466 --> 00:07:01.800
are threats to us for those who are listening and not watching the pod currently there are thousands hundreds of thousands yeah of these objects in near earth orbit it's it's actually a very nauseating amount yeah yeah it's actually quite like concerning right because if you look like let's just linger on this animation for a second the the earth's orbit there's already a yes

103
00:07:04.521 --> 00:07:07.102
Then you see there's a faint line where Mars' orbit is.

104
00:07:07.142 --> 00:07:08.382
That's the red line.

105
00:07:08.682 --> 00:07:12.344
And then there's this giant belt, almost cloud of orbits.

106
00:07:12.524 --> 00:07:15.665
That's the asteroid belt in between Mars and Jupiter.

107
00:07:16.665 --> 00:07:21.006
Those are also threats, not just the ones that are near right in Earth orbit.

108
00:07:21.326 --> 00:07:24.968
But you can imagine some random gravitational anomaly.

109
00:07:25.408 --> 00:07:27.789
Jupiter pushes one of these asteroids out of the way.

110
00:07:28.089 --> 00:07:30.229
Or these two asteroids get a little bit together.

111
00:07:30.609 --> 00:07:32.050
And then they get nudged.

112
00:07:32.570 --> 00:07:33.951
Into the inner solar system.

113
00:07:34.111 --> 00:07:34.491
Exactly.

114
00:07:34.511 --> 00:07:35.812
It's like in a car accident.

115
00:07:36.252 --> 00:07:39.274
You're changing lanes and you sideswipe the car next to you.

116
00:07:39.314 --> 00:07:39.474
Yeah.

117
00:07:39.674 --> 00:07:41.355
And then they're now sideswiping the car next to them.

118
00:07:41.375 --> 00:07:41.775
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

119
00:07:41.835 --> 00:07:43.096
And then there's an 18-wheeler behind.

120
00:07:43.196 --> 00:07:45.117
Like, it can get bad really fast.

121
00:07:45.177 --> 00:07:45.717
Really fast.

122
00:07:46.037 --> 00:07:46.238
Right?

123
00:07:46.778 --> 00:07:51.180
Similar to the Kessler effect when a satellite crashes in orbit.

124
00:07:51.200 --> 00:07:57.063
And it basically creates catastrophic failure for everything because there's just these little things flying around.

125
00:07:57.083 --> 00:07:57.263
Yeah.

126
00:07:57.424 --> 00:07:58.184
And it's going to impact everything.

127
00:07:58.224 --> 00:07:58.964
Yeah, exactly.

128
00:07:59.004 --> 00:08:01.065
And any momentum transfer can be really bad.

129
00:08:01.125 --> 00:08:01.305
Yes.

130
00:08:01.465 --> 00:08:01.645
Right.

131
00:08:01.865 --> 00:08:03.626
And Hollywood is obviously obsessed with this.

132
00:08:03.666 --> 00:08:07.307
We've got, as you were mentioning, Armageddon, Deep Impact.

133
00:08:08.367 --> 00:08:09.448
I can't think of many more.

134
00:08:09.508 --> 00:08:10.908
Oh, Don't Look Up is a big one.

135
00:08:11.248 --> 00:08:12.189
That's the most recent one.

136
00:08:12.209 --> 00:08:13.749
That was more about climate change.

137
00:08:13.849 --> 00:08:14.049
Yes.

138
00:08:14.330 --> 00:08:16.890
But it was still like the metaphor was really funny.

139
00:08:16.910 --> 00:08:21.332
And at the end of the day, the literal movie is about a comet that is coming into Earth.

140
00:08:21.432 --> 00:08:23.112
And nobody believes the scientists.

141
00:08:23.593 --> 00:08:23.853
So...

142
00:08:24.953 --> 00:08:27.434
This has actually happened in human recorded history.

143
00:08:27.874 --> 00:08:31.275
1908 was the Tunguska event in Siberia.

144
00:08:31.775 --> 00:08:36.716
It was a 50 to 80 meter object and it burst 10 miles above the surface.

145
00:08:37.036 --> 00:08:39.617
So it didn't even make contact with the earth.

146
00:08:40.097 --> 00:08:42.758
It exploded because it was heated up by so much.

147
00:08:43.438 --> 00:08:46.999
And it flattened 30 million trees over hundreds of kilometers squared.

148
00:08:47.659 --> 00:08:50.320
Fortunately, it was in the middle of nowhere in Siberia.

149
00:08:50.400 --> 00:08:53.721
But imagine if that happened on a population center.

150
00:08:53.741 --> 00:08:53.841
Yeah.

151
00:08:53.861 --> 00:08:54.101
Yeah.

152
00:08:54.481 --> 00:08:57.704
it would be way, way worse than Hiroshima and Nagasaki, right?

153
00:08:58.044 --> 00:08:58.704
Yes.

154
00:08:58.804 --> 00:09:08.612
In 1980, there was the Alvarez hypothesis, which was linking the Cretaceous-Paleogene extinction, which is the extinction of the dinosaurs 66 million years ago.

155
00:09:10.173 --> 00:09:13.295
It linked that to a cosmic impact.

156
00:09:13.375 --> 00:09:22.622
In 1991, the Chiksa Club crater was discovered in the Yucatan Peninsula because a bunch of oil companies were...

157
00:09:23.863 --> 00:09:45.916
charting the gravity the specific gravity around the yucatan peninsula looking for oil right and so in order to look for oil what you want to look for is like low density packets under the earth's crust and one of the best ways to do that is to literally just measure the acceleration due to gravity the thing that we learn in high school being 9.8 meters per second squared well if you

158
00:09:50.118 --> 00:10:05.431
The little tiny deviations of that acceleration due to gravity, if it's a little less than normal here versus somewhere else, that could mean that there's a low-density packet underneath the ground, which is why it's not pulling on whatever object that you're using to measure that acceleration.

159
00:10:05.471 --> 00:10:06.792
So oil companies were doing that.

160
00:10:07.173 --> 00:10:09.495
They actually found a ring of high density.

161
00:10:10.516 --> 00:10:10.636
Oh.

162
00:10:11.336 --> 00:10:13.979
And that ring was the size of the Yucatan Peninsula.

163
00:10:15.042 --> 00:10:18.083
And it was this primordial crater from 66 million years ago.

164
00:10:18.443 --> 00:10:19.803
I have one clarifying question.

165
00:10:19.843 --> 00:10:26.745
When you mentioned like low-density pocket, what you're referring to is like a lake of oil under the ground.

166
00:10:26.765 --> 00:10:27.245
Yes, exactly.

167
00:10:27.345 --> 00:10:27.565
Okay.

168
00:10:27.625 --> 00:10:28.025
Yeah, yeah.

169
00:10:28.085 --> 00:10:28.806
Instead of rock.

170
00:10:28.846 --> 00:10:32.366
Instead of rock because the oil is less dense than rock.

171
00:10:32.486 --> 00:10:33.947
And so what they're looking for is...

172
00:10:34.547 --> 00:10:35.888
An underground lake of oil.

173
00:10:36.048 --> 00:10:36.649
Exactly, yeah.

174
00:10:36.729 --> 00:10:41.052
And that underground lake of oil would decrease the effect of gravity in that location.

175
00:10:41.092 --> 00:10:46.196
So if you were to measure gravity very, very precisely, you'd be able to chart out where the oil is.

176
00:10:46.336 --> 00:10:46.916
That makes sense.

177
00:10:46.936 --> 00:10:50.379
This is also why science is so important to capitalism.

178
00:10:50.419 --> 00:10:50.679
Yeah.

179
00:10:50.799 --> 00:10:52.861
Because the alpha matters.

180
00:10:52.901 --> 00:10:54.322
The alpha matters.

181
00:10:54.622 --> 00:10:59.546
And like the closer you get to this precision, the more you can unlock, you know?

182
00:10:59.726 --> 00:10:59.966
Mm-hmm.

183
00:11:00.506 --> 00:11:06.649
And then finally in 2013, there was the Chelybinsk meteor, which was a 20-meter object.

184
00:11:06.689 --> 00:11:06.789
Yes.

185
00:11:07.129 --> 00:11:08.190
Over 1,000 injuries.

186
00:11:08.390 --> 00:11:08.530
Yes.

187
00:11:08.550 --> 00:11:09.690
It happened also over Russia.

188
00:11:09.890 --> 00:11:10.611
Yes.

189
00:11:11.131 --> 00:11:25.858
And this was one that was very – there was video – because we had media and technology and devices, it's probably the most prominent atmospheric, large object atmospheric breakup explosion.

190
00:11:25.878 --> 00:11:25.978
Yeah.

191
00:11:26.958 --> 00:11:28.799
And, you know, over a thousand inches.

192
00:11:28.819 --> 00:11:29.580
I mean, it was a lot.

193
00:11:29.720 --> 00:11:30.260
It was a lot.

194
00:11:30.300 --> 00:11:30.760
It was a lot.

195
00:11:30.800 --> 00:11:33.021
A lot of broken windows and things like that.

196
00:11:33.462 --> 00:11:37.364
One of the reasons why we have so much footage on that is because Russians...

197
00:11:38.463 --> 00:11:40.224
The Russians love having dash cams.

198
00:11:40.284 --> 00:11:40.745
Yeah, yeah.

199
00:11:40.945 --> 00:11:44.107
Because, I don't know, I mean, I don't want to say anything.

200
00:11:44.127 --> 00:11:47.489
Comment in the thread if you know the reason why that's true.

201
00:11:47.569 --> 00:11:48.049
Yeah, yeah.

202
00:11:48.089 --> 00:11:50.111
But anyways, Russians love having dash cams.

203
00:11:50.171 --> 00:11:54.194
And so there's so much dash cam footage of the meteor just like coming down, right?

204
00:11:54.314 --> 00:11:55.595
It's pretty incredible.

205
00:11:55.735 --> 00:12:00.898
I want to just reemphasize that that 2013 meteor was only 20 meters.

206
00:12:00.958 --> 00:12:01.078
Yeah.

207
00:12:01.098 --> 00:12:01.599
Yeah.

208
00:12:03.940 --> 00:12:05.341
In, I guess, diameter.

209
00:12:05.401 --> 00:12:06.382
Yeah.

210
00:12:06.522 --> 00:12:08.304
It's not a super large object.

211
00:12:08.344 --> 00:12:08.944
No, no, no.

212
00:12:09.345 --> 00:12:10.766
It's like the size of a house.

213
00:12:10.906 --> 00:12:13.748
The force and the impact.

214
00:12:13.768 --> 00:12:16.971
Because the devastation was pretty severe.

215
00:12:17.171 --> 00:12:17.411
Yeah.

216
00:12:17.671 --> 00:12:17.892
Right.

217
00:12:18.072 --> 00:12:19.213
So, in any event.

218
00:12:19.713 --> 00:12:25.236
So our best strategy when it comes to planetary defense is actually to nudge it.

219
00:12:25.516 --> 00:12:28.398
We want to give it some momentum, and then we want to get out of the way.

220
00:12:28.818 --> 00:12:30.959
And hopefully that thing gets out of the way, right?

221
00:12:31.019 --> 00:12:34.141
Because we've nudged it, and it just avoids Earth.

222
00:12:34.601 --> 00:12:38.523
It keeps going around the sun, but now its orbit has changed a little bit.

223
00:12:38.783 --> 00:12:55.573
In the same analogy of the car accident, like before, imagine you're in a James Bond movie, and James Bond is in a car in the left lane, and the love interest in that movie is handcuffed to the steering wheel in the car in the right lane, and they're both going 90 miles an hour down a road, and the right car is about to hit something.

224
00:12:55.913 --> 00:13:05.519
He's like, well, let me just bump it out of the way, because that'll change how it's driving out of the way of about to hit this brick wall that's in front of us, just as like a grounded analogy.

225
00:13:05.539 --> 00:13:05.979
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

226
00:13:06.039 --> 00:13:07.880
Is this one of the dream fantasies of your...

227
00:13:11.330 --> 00:13:14.833
Yeah, he had a lot of detail in that one, guys.

228
00:13:15.293 --> 00:13:16.915
Yeah, but that's exactly right.

229
00:13:16.935 --> 00:13:18.956
We want to just nudge it, get it out of the way.

230
00:13:19.076 --> 00:13:21.578
In 2022, that was the DART mission.

231
00:13:22.379 --> 00:13:24.140
It was the first intentional deflection.

232
00:13:24.160 --> 00:13:29.564
It was actually launched out of Vandenberg in 2013, which is right down the street of Southern California.

233
00:13:30.485 --> 00:13:33.728
It went with the Earth to meet up with this double asteroid system.

234
00:13:33.768 --> 00:13:38.511
So this double asteroid system, which is Didymus and Dimorphos, so

235
00:13:39.472 --> 00:13:41.593
We can look at an animation of their orbits, right?

236
00:13:41.673 --> 00:13:44.373
The green is the double asteroid system.

237
00:13:44.513 --> 00:13:44.714
Yes.

238
00:13:44.754 --> 00:13:45.874
The teal is Earth.

239
00:13:46.174 --> 00:13:46.414
Yes.

240
00:13:46.674 --> 00:13:54.316
And the pink is what we're seeing of the our like what you might call it.

241
00:13:55.096 --> 00:13:56.017
The dark mission.

242
00:13:56.037 --> 00:13:56.937
The dark mission.

243
00:13:56.957 --> 00:13:57.237
Sorry.

244
00:13:57.357 --> 00:13:58.757
So let me just recap.

245
00:13:58.898 --> 00:13:59.698
The blue is Earth.

246
00:13:59.718 --> 00:14:00.018
Yes.

247
00:14:00.038 --> 00:14:00.198
Yes.

248
00:14:00.698 --> 00:14:03.420
The DART mission comes out in pink from Earth.

249
00:14:03.520 --> 00:14:05.082
It's following Earth, as you can see.

250
00:14:05.182 --> 00:14:06.463
It's just leading it a little bit.

251
00:14:06.483 --> 00:14:07.063
Yes, yes.

252
00:14:07.304 --> 00:14:11.327
And the green double asteroid system that we're trying to hit is going to come meet up with us.

253
00:14:11.507 --> 00:14:11.687
Yes.

254
00:14:11.927 --> 00:14:14.289
The double asteroid system is actually in near-Earth orbit.

255
00:14:14.369 --> 00:14:15.130
And there you go.

256
00:14:15.150 --> 00:14:15.650
Yep.

257
00:14:15.971 --> 00:14:17.092
That's when the impact happens.

258
00:14:17.472 --> 00:14:20.054
You can tell that the impact is happening pretty close to Earth.

259
00:14:20.114 --> 00:14:20.755
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

260
00:14:21.315 --> 00:14:41.077
are moving together and then the impact happens here but earth is pretty close yes that is by design because what we want to do is we want to have all of the observatories on earth looking at this thing to get as much data as possible the the impact was like six million miles which in the grand scheme of things is not is not that far away

261
00:14:41.637 --> 00:14:54.609
I want to just pull this back up really quick, this animation, because I think what's so interesting is when you look at where it launches from, the launch of DART happened on the opposite side.

262
00:14:54.689 --> 00:15:00.695
It first left Earth on the opposite side of the sun from where the asteroid was coming in.

263
00:15:01.216 --> 00:15:04.178
And it did almost a three-quarters orbit.

264
00:15:04.338 --> 00:15:04.579
Yeah.

265
00:15:05.550 --> 00:15:07.332
Prior to contact.

266
00:15:07.712 --> 00:15:08.372
And I just want to.

267
00:15:08.813 --> 00:15:10.654
The distance.

268
00:15:11.275 --> 00:15:13.577
Look if I'm trying to throw a paper ball.

269
00:15:14.318 --> 00:15:15.979
A paper towel ball.

270
00:15:16.119 --> 00:15:17.120
Into the trash can.

271
00:15:17.140 --> 00:15:17.801
From my desk.

272
00:15:18.758 --> 00:15:21.180
I'm maybe going to hit it six times out of ten.

273
00:15:21.780 --> 00:15:23.942
We're trying to send this thing in an orbit.

274
00:15:24.402 --> 00:15:25.083
Around the sun.

275
00:15:25.103 --> 00:15:25.983
Around the sun.

276
00:15:26.003 --> 00:15:26.624
With the earth.

277
00:15:26.784 --> 00:15:27.184
With the earth.

278
00:15:27.484 --> 00:15:28.445
Millions of miles.

279
00:15:28.465 --> 00:15:29.446
Yeah.

280
00:15:30.006 --> 00:15:32.488
And it made direct contact.

281
00:15:32.768 --> 00:15:37.372
I just want to really emphasize the level of precision that is required to...

282
00:15:38.292 --> 00:16:00.573
because that's not the point of this this story per se it's the second piece yeah but that initial part in and of itself yeah is an exceptional piece of just both the engineering yeah math and the operational planning to execute on yeah i mean and nasa is just incredible at doing this kind of stuff um and you as you mentioned right like the thing gets released it makes almost full circle so it's almost

283
00:16:00.573 --> 00:16:03.336
Almost like if it got launched in...

284
00:16:03.756 --> 00:16:05.998
I wish I knew the exact date that it got launched, right?

285
00:16:06.018 --> 00:16:11.624
But if it got launched somewhere, it's going to almost do a full year around, right?

286
00:16:11.784 --> 00:16:12.005
Yes.

287
00:16:12.025 --> 00:16:13.046
Before actually getting there.

288
00:16:13.386 --> 00:16:14.067
Pretty incredible.

289
00:16:15.888 --> 00:16:16.129
So...

290
00:16:17.015 --> 00:16:18.136
That's what we want to do, right?

291
00:16:18.216 --> 00:16:25.481
We want to have it impact very close, and then we want to have all of the observatories watch this impact happen.

292
00:16:25.501 --> 00:16:25.681
Yes.

293
00:16:25.981 --> 00:16:26.181
Right?

294
00:16:26.401 --> 00:16:26.601
Yes.

295
00:16:26.701 --> 00:16:26.902
Yeah.

296
00:16:27.062 --> 00:16:29.863
Because we don't have a lot of instruments deeper in space.

297
00:16:30.904 --> 00:16:35.827
And so the best way we can capture data is when it's as close to our instruments as possible.

298
00:16:35.847 --> 00:16:36.248
That's right.

299
00:16:36.288 --> 00:16:36.908
Yeah, that's right.

300
00:16:37.408 --> 00:16:39.150
And before we move on...

301
00:16:39.350 --> 00:16:39.530
Yes.

302
00:16:39.550 --> 00:16:39.770
Yes.

303
00:16:39.910 --> 00:16:40.891
Let's do some housekeeping.

304
00:16:40.931 --> 00:16:41.171
Yes.

305
00:16:41.411 --> 00:16:42.432
So housekeeping notes.

306
00:16:42.812 --> 00:16:47.295
Again, we are testing our new format two to three episodes a week.

307
00:16:47.715 --> 00:16:54.559
Each episode, when it's a research paper or a deep dive, is going to be fully focused just on that topic matter.

308
00:16:54.960 --> 00:16:59.703
We are also going to do the rundown as its own standalone episode.

309
00:17:00.375 --> 00:17:04.758
One, so we can have a little bit of fun, talk about a variety of things, a little grab bag.

310
00:17:04.778 --> 00:17:07.700
Think about it like the weekend update on SNL.

311
00:17:08.300 --> 00:17:16.785
And I am determined to make a science game show out of this with Krishna as our recurring contestant, which you can't see from the current angle.

312
00:17:17.105 --> 00:17:19.487
He's getting a little bit of indigestion at the thought of that.

313
00:17:19.847 --> 00:17:30.231
But if you are intrigued by the concept or you're a longtime listener, as you know, we are a victim like we all are to the billionaire algorithm.

314
00:17:30.612 --> 00:17:38.055
So a like, follow, share, subscribe is super valuable for us to help get the show to more people.

315
00:17:38.775 --> 00:17:52.078
And if you are really passionate about what we're doing, it really fills your cup every day, and you want to find a way to support us, we do have our donation portal at ffppod.com backslash donate.

316
00:18:08.622 --> 00:18:13.565
And I believe that is the conclusion of our show notes this week.

317
00:18:13.665 --> 00:18:15.966
Yeah, one more thing, just from me on a personal end.

318
00:18:16.346 --> 00:18:27.773
So for those listening, if anyone is going to APS, the Global Summit meeting in Denver, that's the American Physical Society Global Summit in Denver this coming week, so the week of this event.

319
00:18:28.702 --> 00:18:55.241
podcast release on thursday i'm giving a talk so you know if you're going just look me up on the schedule and come check out my talk on thursday i'm still you know doing doing stuff and and talking to people about all the research that i'm doing and if you want to know about the research that he's doing which is very interesting make sure if you're at aps you go see it and embarrass krishna by asking for an autograph in front of all the scientists and academics

320
00:18:57.037 --> 00:18:59.223
Okay, let's get back to the story, please.

321
00:19:00.801 --> 00:19:01.081
All right.

322
00:19:01.261 --> 00:19:05.604
The target of the DART mission was the Didymus Dimorphous Binary System.

323
00:19:06.144 --> 00:19:13.789
Just to show how the two asteroids compare, the moon, the moonlet that we were trying to target, is a bit bigger.

324
00:19:13.889 --> 00:19:17.832
It's in between the Statue of Liberty and the Eiffel Tower in terms of how big it is.

325
00:19:18.332 --> 00:19:23.515
Didymus is like Burj Khalifa type in terms of how big it is, like the diameter.

326
00:19:24.596 --> 00:19:26.778
And what we're trying to kamikaze is the moonlet.

327
00:19:26.998 --> 00:19:28.238
Yes, the small one.

328
00:19:28.339 --> 00:19:29.159
The little small one.

329
00:19:29.299 --> 00:19:29.459
Yep.

330
00:19:29.599 --> 00:19:29.819
Okay?

331
00:19:32.578 --> 00:19:42.666
During the mission, actually, the main dart probe, the satellite, actually stood behind to watch this unfold.

332
00:19:42.767 --> 00:19:47.831
And it let out a little kamikaze satellite drone.

333
00:19:48.151 --> 00:19:49.112
Fox 1, go.

334
00:19:49.172 --> 00:19:49.973
Yeah, exactly.

335
00:19:50.393 --> 00:19:56.238
And so this guy's job was to go and bomb.

336
00:19:56.298 --> 00:19:56.398
Yes.

337
00:19:56.519 --> 00:19:56.719
Yes.

338
00:19:57.817 --> 00:19:58.818
Dimorphous.

339
00:19:58.858 --> 00:20:00.600
Let's say make contact.

340
00:20:00.660 --> 00:20:01.280
Make contact.

341
00:20:01.320 --> 00:20:02.161
Sorry.

342
00:20:02.341 --> 00:20:02.561
Yeah.

343
00:20:02.621 --> 00:20:05.184
In today's world, let's rephrase that.

344
00:20:05.524 --> 00:20:07.345
We're trying to make contact with dimorphous.

345
00:20:07.526 --> 00:20:07.706
Yes.

346
00:20:07.826 --> 00:20:16.253
And the other, the main ship, the mothership, is watching this all in action because it wants to see what is the effect of that contact on the system.

347
00:20:16.473 --> 00:20:17.214
Why binary?

348
00:20:17.274 --> 00:20:20.697
It's because we want rapid measurement of deflection, right?

349
00:20:20.737 --> 00:20:20.897
Right.

350
00:20:22.298 --> 00:20:23.658
The orbit is going one way.

351
00:20:23.998 --> 00:20:25.919
We want to see if it's slowed down or sped up.

352
00:20:26.299 --> 00:20:26.879
Okay, whatever.

353
00:20:27.059 --> 00:20:35.501
And with a dual orbit system, it is easier to ascertain the answer to that than a single object moving.

354
00:20:35.581 --> 00:20:36.381
Yes, exactly.

355
00:20:36.461 --> 00:20:37.021
And here's why.

356
00:20:37.121 --> 00:20:37.361
Okay.

357
00:20:37.961 --> 00:20:43.282
The mutual orbit velocity of Dimorphos and Didymus is about 17 centimeters per second.

358
00:20:43.442 --> 00:20:43.623
Okay.

359
00:20:43.863 --> 00:20:44.103
Okay.

360
00:20:44.523 --> 00:20:45.383
Which means that...

361
00:20:46.255 --> 00:21:01.764
If we were to impact some momentum, 17 centimeters per second, even for something as large as a rock, a mountain, let's say, I can reasonably try and discern some change because I'm going at it at 6 kilometers per second.

362
00:21:01.804 --> 00:21:06.407
So reasonably, some of my momentum is going to get transferred, and then I'm going to be able to see a change.

363
00:21:06.467 --> 00:21:07.688
And they were able to see a change.

364
00:21:08.008 --> 00:21:11.370
They saw that the mutual orbit period was...

365
00:21:12.110 --> 00:21:13.611
altered by 33 meters.

366
00:21:14.091 --> 00:21:16.073
And this is something that we can rapidly measure.

367
00:21:16.433 --> 00:21:17.574
The orbit got smaller.

368
00:21:17.914 --> 00:21:19.755
It got shorter by 33 meters.

369
00:21:20.175 --> 00:21:26.420
And the DART system, which is monitoring this, can calculate that, measure it, no problem.

370
00:21:27.020 --> 00:21:28.121
Makes total sense.

371
00:21:28.161 --> 00:21:32.904
We sent up an observer and a probe to make contact.

372
00:21:33.804 --> 00:21:42.868
The initial data point that was going to be captured is, is the local orbit going to change from 17 centimeters per second to something else?

373
00:21:42.908 --> 00:21:56.334
Because by making contact, going back to our car analogy, if you're in a two-lane highway and you're one car and you swerve to the right and make contact with the other car, your momentum in part will be transferred to that other car.

374
00:21:56.414 --> 00:21:58.715
Which is why then you have to see the driving scenes where they're like, oh.

375
00:21:59.055 --> 00:22:00.716
Yeah, exactly.

376
00:22:00.736 --> 00:22:03.018
To counteract the transfer of momentum.

377
00:22:03.038 --> 00:22:05.800
Yeah, and that's why the double system matters, right?

378
00:22:05.820 --> 00:22:12.324
Because this is a small enough system where I can make that change discernible.

379
00:22:12.364 --> 00:22:16.207
33 minutes out of 12 hours, something I can easily measure now, right?

380
00:22:16.227 --> 00:22:16.607
That makes sense.

381
00:22:17.548 --> 00:22:20.610
When it comes to the big thing, now let's think about the big thing.

382
00:22:20.870 --> 00:22:23.011
There's the big system that's moving around the sun.

383
00:22:23.192 --> 00:22:23.372
Yes.

384
00:22:23.572 --> 00:22:27.414
That thing is moving at 23 kilometers per second, okay?

385
00:22:27.795 --> 00:22:28.015
Mm-hmm.

386
00:22:28.758 --> 00:22:33.703
The change that my momentum is going to cause is going to be less than a millimeter per second.

387
00:22:34.624 --> 00:22:35.906
That's way harder to measure.

388
00:22:36.346 --> 00:22:36.587
Yeah.

389
00:22:36.827 --> 00:22:38.529
And that is what this paper is doing.

390
00:22:38.789 --> 00:22:39.069
I see.

391
00:22:39.169 --> 00:22:40.891
This paper is measuring the big one.

392
00:22:41.312 --> 00:22:43.854
So let's get into some of the physics that we were talking about, right?

393
00:22:43.874 --> 00:22:43.975
Okay.

394
00:22:43.995 --> 00:22:44.155
Okay.

395
00:22:45.019 --> 00:22:54.323
We've got the kinetic impactor, which is this idea of a sort of satellite drone going in, making contact, and its momentum getting transferred.

396
00:22:54.643 --> 00:23:00.386
Now, it's not that simple because it's not a simple momentum conservation undergrad problem, okay?

397
00:23:00.446 --> 00:23:00.726
Okay.

398
00:23:01.006 --> 00:23:02.307
It turns out that...

399
00:23:03.347 --> 00:23:11.637
When I go and make this contact at high velocity at 6 kilometers per second to this little moon, that's going to generate shock waves.

400
00:23:11.677 --> 00:23:13.680
So the asteroid is going to ring a little bit.

401
00:23:14.040 --> 00:23:15.282
There's going to be an impact crater.

402
00:23:15.562 --> 00:23:19.487
And there's also going to be massive ejecta that is flying the opposite direction.

403
00:23:19.827 --> 00:23:21.649
So imagine my hand is the moon.

404
00:23:22.572 --> 00:23:23.353
I make contact.

405
00:23:23.373 --> 00:23:25.354
There's going to be ejecta flying this way.

406
00:23:25.455 --> 00:23:30.099
It's almost like another little rocket impulse that's going the opposite direction.

407
00:23:30.139 --> 00:23:33.401
So what I'm going to get is something called momentum enhancement.

408
00:23:34.202 --> 00:23:41.148
The amount of momentum that gets transferred is not just how much I went in with, but also how much that it threw out.

409
00:23:41.228 --> 00:23:41.448
Yes.

410
00:23:41.809 --> 00:23:42.049
Right?

411
00:23:42.129 --> 00:23:42.309
Yes.

412
00:23:42.389 --> 00:23:45.912
And so there's this beta factor called momentum enhancement factor.

413
00:23:46.192 --> 00:23:49.996
And that's the ratio of the total momentum that was transferred to the target.

414
00:23:50.953 --> 00:23:53.915
Divided by the total momentum that I had.

415
00:23:54.615 --> 00:24:05.462
If beta is greater than one, that means that I've actually impacted more momentum than I originally had because the original object has pushed out a bunch of debris in the opposite direction.

416
00:24:05.822 --> 00:24:06.622
Does that make sense?

417
00:24:06.643 --> 00:24:07.103
Yeah.

418
00:24:07.123 --> 00:24:08.023
So what we're saying is...

419
00:24:09.184 --> 00:24:09.965
We have an object.

420
00:24:10.365 --> 00:24:12.287
Our object's coming in to make contact with something.

421
00:24:12.347 --> 00:24:17.791
This actually dovetails with the panspermia story we talked about in our last episode about impacts.

422
00:24:17.811 --> 00:24:18.251
Yeah.

423
00:24:18.511 --> 00:24:19.672
That there's ejecta.

424
00:24:19.892 --> 00:24:19.993
Yeah.

425
00:24:20.013 --> 00:24:24.056
And the velocity by which you hit something can shoot that stuff very, very far.

426
00:24:24.076 --> 00:24:24.536
Very, very fast.

427
00:24:24.656 --> 00:24:25.977
And can potentially spread life.

428
00:24:25.997 --> 00:24:30.080
But what we're saying here is the amount of stuff that gets ejected out.

429
00:24:30.821 --> 00:24:34.865
almost creates this additional push in the direction you were already going.

430
00:24:34.886 --> 00:24:35.126
Yes.

431
00:24:35.206 --> 00:24:38.730
In addition to the amount of push that you individually as the object was giving.

432
00:24:38.770 --> 00:24:38.950
Yes.

433
00:24:39.010 --> 00:24:40.171
And that's that enhancement.

434
00:24:40.231 --> 00:24:41.092
And that's the enhancement.

435
00:24:41.272 --> 00:24:41.473
Right.

436
00:24:41.493 --> 00:24:41.673
Yes.

437
00:24:41.953 --> 00:24:45.817
And so it's really important for us to calculate what this enhancement is because if –

438
00:24:46.498 --> 00:24:48.380
God forbid there's an asteroid coming for us.

439
00:24:48.480 --> 00:24:48.720
Yes.

440
00:24:49.441 --> 00:24:55.826
Knowing this value of beta is going to be instrumental for figuring out how fast do I need to nudge it, right?

441
00:24:55.947 --> 00:24:56.167
Yes.

442
00:24:56.207 --> 00:25:01.772
How big of the drone does the satellite need to be in order to make contact?

443
00:25:02.012 --> 00:25:04.054
How much momentum am I trying to put in there?

444
00:25:04.254 --> 00:25:08.618
Because the momentum transfer is not just what I'm putting in initially, but it's this beta factor.

445
00:25:08.938 --> 00:25:10.439
Multiplied by the initial momentum.

446
00:25:10.639 --> 00:25:22.844
So the idea here is when Morgan Freeman is in the classified room talking and someone says, we have an Ellie, an extinction level event, because this rock is coming.

447
00:25:23.324 --> 00:25:25.985
And they're saying, okay, what options do we have?

448
00:25:26.805 --> 00:25:49.232
NASA would be able to come into the room and say, because we had our DART mission, where we were able to get real-world data about what the momentum enhancement factor is, we know that because this trajectory is X, Y, or Z, we're going to need to send this amount of payload at this speed because the math is mathing.

449
00:25:49.432 --> 00:25:50.013
Exactly.

450
00:25:50.253 --> 00:25:52.993
And now we have all the parameters to make that math math.

451
00:25:53.053 --> 00:25:53.274
Right.

452
00:25:53.534 --> 00:25:53.734
Right.

453
00:25:53.814 --> 00:25:54.074
Okay.

454
00:25:54.194 --> 00:25:54.454
Okay.

455
00:25:56.132 --> 00:26:00.815
With the DART mission, we got a local version of beta, right?

456
00:26:00.975 --> 00:26:01.175
Yes.

457
00:26:01.416 --> 00:26:03.637
But let's do a little lesson in undergrad physics.

458
00:26:03.817 --> 00:26:03.917
Okay.

459
00:26:03.937 --> 00:26:08.040
We're going to talk about systems and what are their components.

460
00:26:08.320 --> 00:26:08.540
Okay.

461
00:26:09.461 --> 00:26:16.505
Whenever we do undergrad physics, we're always trying to think of what is the system that is isolated from the environment that we're trying to work with.

462
00:26:17.406 --> 00:26:20.768
For example, the Earth-Sun-Moon system.

463
00:26:20.988 --> 00:26:21.189
Yes.

464
00:26:21.289 --> 00:26:22.649
There's three bodies, right?

465
00:26:23.110 --> 00:26:24.711
When we think about, like...

466
00:26:26.186 --> 00:26:30.929
you know, shooting something off Earth, or we think about just tides, for example.

467
00:26:31.229 --> 00:26:33.891
Actually, tides is a bad idea because we need both the sun and the moon.

468
00:26:34.011 --> 00:26:34.151
Sure.

469
00:26:34.251 --> 00:26:40.655
But if there's stuff that's local to the Earth and the moon, we don't really need to worry about the sun too much.

470
00:26:40.875 --> 00:26:41.275
Okay.

471
00:26:41.295 --> 00:26:41.495
Okay?

472
00:26:41.776 --> 00:26:45.538
We can have momentum transfer in between the Earth and the moon, and we'll be fine.

473
00:26:45.998 --> 00:26:48.260
Would satellite stuff be an example of that?

474
00:26:48.280 --> 00:26:52.162
Yeah, satellite stuff would kind of be an example of that because, like, the sun is kind of far away.

475
00:26:52.242 --> 00:26:55.264
It's, like, really big, but it's still, like...

476
00:26:56.550 --> 00:27:00.812
It doesn't come into the equation, or it comes into the equation in another way.

477
00:27:01.133 --> 00:27:08.297
The idea is that there's granular levels of how we want to describe a physics problem, right?

478
00:27:09.637 --> 00:27:12.019
And my point here is...

479
00:27:13.287 --> 00:27:25.532
When the local measurement was made, when we figured out, oh, the orbit decreased by 30 minutes between the two of them, what we really did was figure out a local beta.

480
00:27:25.793 --> 00:27:39.299
We figured out a local momentum transfer that happened because of the moon and how much escaped the little moon's gravity, right?

481
00:27:42.895 --> 00:27:44.817
in relation to the big Didymus.

482
00:27:44.957 --> 00:27:45.137
Yes.

483
00:27:45.197 --> 00:27:47.459
So Dimorphos is now speeding up.

484
00:27:47.699 --> 00:27:47.939
Mm-hmm.

485
00:27:48.840 --> 00:27:49.520
In relation...

486
00:27:49.540 --> 00:27:50.721
In relation to Didymus.

487
00:27:50.801 --> 00:27:51.021
Right.

488
00:27:51.762 --> 00:27:57.586
What we really care about when it comes to planetary defense is the sun binary system.

489
00:27:57.746 --> 00:27:58.007
Mm-hmm.

490
00:27:58.487 --> 00:28:06.033
What we care about is the heliocentric momentum enhancement factor, not the center of mass frame momentum enhancement factor.

491
00:28:06.473 --> 00:28:08.414
Here what we're looking at is...

492
00:28:09.375 --> 00:28:34.550
from earth the impact on didymus okay okay and what you can see is you don't even resolve the binary system it looks like a single dot yes but we didn't hit the main dot we hit the moon and yet there's all this ejecta yeah that came out yes all of that ejecta that came out has escaped the binary system that ejecta not only escaped the moon

493
00:28:35.738 --> 00:28:40.140
the main Didymus, big asteroid, couldn't even keep it together.

494
00:28:40.441 --> 00:28:52.047
So all of that ejecta escaped the moon and the big asteroid and has gone out into outer space, which means that there is a momentum enhancement factor on the entire system as a whole.

495
00:28:52.107 --> 00:28:57.270
It's a really nice sort of little undergrad problem on conservation of energy, right?

496
00:28:57.550 --> 00:29:03.653
Which is this idea that even though I only hit the moon, I'm actually changing the trajectory of the entire moon

497
00:29:04.874 --> 00:29:06.795
Planet or moon asteroid system.

498
00:29:07.515 --> 00:29:08.855
I didn't touch the asteroid.

499
00:29:08.955 --> 00:29:09.135
Yes.

500
00:29:09.175 --> 00:29:13.257
But the asteroid's orbit has been changed because I hit its moon.

501
00:29:13.417 --> 00:29:18.139
So as maybe a pop culture reference point, let me know if this actually tracks with what you're saying.

502
00:29:18.359 --> 00:29:23.920
There's a famous, not a famous, there's a movie that came out maybe in the last two, three years called Moonfall.

503
00:29:24.201 --> 00:29:24.501
Okay.

504
00:29:24.701 --> 00:29:25.321
And the moon...

505
00:29:27.462 --> 00:29:28.283
Oh, dude.

506
00:29:28.343 --> 00:29:29.484
Yeah, I know this one.

507
00:29:29.544 --> 00:29:49.022
And so the point is, even though the moon had yet to make contact with Earth, the simple fact that it moved from its existing orbital position around the Earth to getting closer totally disrupted a variety of things in Earth because the tides changed and the proximity.

508
00:29:49.543 --> 00:29:51.465
So it's like a local movement.

509
00:29:51.865 --> 00:29:57.570
It's like local, but it had this larger impact even though it's maybe not the right analogy.

510
00:29:57.771 --> 00:29:58.051
Okay.

511
00:29:58.091 --> 00:30:03.216
So I want to take that a step further because in that one, what you're talking about is local changes again.

512
00:30:03.376 --> 00:30:04.857
Oh, that's what I'm still talking about.

513
00:30:04.917 --> 00:30:08.561
What I'm saying here is like suppose something hit the moon, which caused it to fall.

514
00:30:08.601 --> 00:30:08.801
Yes.

515
00:30:09.041 --> 00:30:09.221
Right?

516
00:30:09.241 --> 00:30:09.682
Right.

517
00:30:10.122 --> 00:30:12.723
there would be an energy transfer into the moon.

518
00:30:12.923 --> 00:30:13.103
Yes.

519
00:30:13.123 --> 00:30:13.383
Right?

520
00:30:13.743 --> 00:30:17.244
So looking from Earth's perspective, the moon would gain some energy, let's say.

521
00:30:18.125 --> 00:30:25.667
Now looking from an alien perspective that looks at the Earth and moon system as a single system, there would be a change in energy in that entire system.

522
00:30:25.807 --> 00:30:27.828
Both the Earth and the moon would gain some energy.

523
00:30:28.188 --> 00:30:32.909
So both that system as a whole would change its trajectory around the sun.

524
00:30:33.710 --> 00:30:34.390
That's the idea.

525
00:30:34.430 --> 00:30:35.450
That's the idea.

526
00:30:35.470 --> 00:30:38.111
Depending on how granular you make your system...

527
00:30:38.271 --> 00:30:43.156
At the end of the day, conservation of energy and conservation of momentum are paramount.

528
00:30:43.216 --> 00:30:43.396
Yes.

529
00:30:43.617 --> 00:30:48.682
So if the momentum was transferred to the moon, it'll also be transferred to the earth-moon system.

530
00:30:48.722 --> 00:30:48.942
Yes.

531
00:30:49.143 --> 00:30:52.947
Which means that the earth-moon system moving around the sun is going to change.

532
00:30:53.047 --> 00:30:53.968
That's what's happening here.

533
00:30:54.148 --> 00:30:55.189
That makes sense.

534
00:30:55.229 --> 00:30:58.813
That's the key that I need everyone to try to sort of internalize.

535
00:30:58.833 --> 00:30:58.993
Yes.

536
00:30:59.173 --> 00:31:03.617
Which is conservation of energy and momentum is true regardless of the size of your system.

537
00:31:04.597 --> 00:31:04.998
Yeah, right.

538
00:31:05.818 --> 00:31:19.489
At whatever level or layer you're observing the system, a change of momentum in one of those layers will transcend across all of the downstream or upstream.

539
00:31:19.509 --> 00:31:21.971
I don't know which direction it is either.

540
00:31:22.031 --> 00:31:23.212
But one of those two.

541
00:31:23.252 --> 00:31:25.634
Yeah, you get exactly what I'm saying, right?

542
00:31:25.654 --> 00:31:26.034
Yes, yes.

543
00:31:26.074 --> 00:31:26.515
And so...

544
00:31:27.647 --> 00:31:36.112
If that ejecta is escaping the combined gravity of Didymus and Dimorphos, then it's going to change the trajectory of the entire system.

545
00:31:36.592 --> 00:31:37.553
I see now.

546
00:31:37.693 --> 00:31:41.455
I need to figure out a beta for the entire system.

547
00:31:41.715 --> 00:31:45.057
Not just what I had figured out before, which is just the little moon.

548
00:31:45.417 --> 00:31:45.778
Around...

549
00:31:46.698 --> 00:31:46.938
This.

550
00:31:47.098 --> 00:31:47.298
Yes.

551
00:31:48.119 --> 00:31:49.019
That makes sense.

552
00:31:49.039 --> 00:31:52.640
Because ultimately, from a planetary defense perspective... That's what matters.

553
00:31:52.680 --> 00:31:53.761
You care about the whole system.

554
00:31:53.781 --> 00:31:54.001
Yeah.

555
00:31:54.121 --> 00:31:54.341
Yeah.

556
00:31:54.601 --> 00:31:54.801
Yeah.

557
00:31:54.861 --> 00:31:55.261
That's what matters.

558
00:31:55.281 --> 00:31:57.102
And being able to change the whole system.

559
00:31:57.122 --> 00:31:57.782
The whole system.

560
00:31:57.822 --> 00:32:06.165
But in order to do so, you need to understand the component parts necessary to be able to impart that level of change on the whole system.

561
00:32:06.225 --> 00:32:06.685
Exactly.

562
00:32:06.925 --> 00:32:07.125
Yeah.

563
00:32:07.526 --> 00:32:10.447
And to tell you just how hard that is to do...

564
00:32:10.567 --> 00:32:10.747
Right.

565
00:32:10.767 --> 00:32:11.107
Right.

566
00:32:11.950 --> 00:32:14.712
The heliocentric velocity, this is something that I covered a little bit earlier.

567
00:32:15.012 --> 00:32:17.373
The system moves at 23 kilometers per second.

568
00:32:18.074 --> 00:32:19.835
And I'm trying to detect...

569
00:32:20.983 --> 00:32:25.584
I'm trying to detect a change that is less than one millimeter per second.

570
00:32:26.425 --> 00:32:28.885
This thing is moving at 26 kilometers per second.

571
00:32:29.306 --> 00:32:30.586
And I need... 23.

572
00:32:31.706 --> 00:32:33.607
Sorry, yeah, 23 kilometers per second.

573
00:32:34.007 --> 00:32:36.288
This thing is moving at 23 kilometers per second.

574
00:32:36.308 --> 00:32:36.488
Yes.

575
00:32:36.988 --> 00:32:41.109
And that velocity is going to change by a millimeter per second.

576
00:32:41.249 --> 00:32:41.890
Actually, less.

577
00:32:42.910 --> 00:32:43.910
Does that make sense?

578
00:32:43.930 --> 00:32:45.231
That's several orders of magnitude.

579
00:32:45.251 --> 00:32:48.692
A millimeter is a thousandth of a meter, which is a thousandth of a kilometer.

580
00:32:48.712 --> 00:32:49.112
So this is...

581
00:32:49.872 --> 00:32:51.216
About 10 millionth.

582
00:32:51.496 --> 00:32:51.717
Yeah.

583
00:32:52.078 --> 00:32:53.160
One part in 10 million.

584
00:32:53.321 --> 00:32:53.481
Yeah.

585
00:32:53.721 --> 00:32:54.844
Is what I'm trying to sense.

586
00:32:54.864 --> 00:32:55.225
Yeah.

587
00:32:55.285 --> 00:32:57.851
Or an asteroid that is millions of miles away.

588
00:32:59.646 --> 00:33:01.448
we like to say this is non-trivial.

589
00:33:01.568 --> 00:33:03.809
This is extremely non-trivial.

590
00:33:03.829 --> 00:33:04.970
Right?

591
00:33:05.190 --> 00:33:11.475
To make that measurement, this is another lesson in, again, some of our favorite topics on the podcast, precision measurement.

592
00:33:11.595 --> 00:33:11.795
Right.

593
00:33:11.995 --> 00:33:17.279
That's such a key... We have a toolbox in science with a hammer, food driver.

594
00:33:17.739 --> 00:33:19.120
Some tools are more useful than others.

595
00:33:19.580 --> 00:33:20.881
Some tools you use all the time.

596
00:33:20.901 --> 00:33:22.583
Like a hammer, there's a lot of things you can do with a hammer.

597
00:33:23.023 --> 00:33:25.605
Lasers is the thing in physics.

598
00:33:25.685 --> 00:33:26.706
Put a laser in it.

599
00:33:26.726 --> 00:33:27.406
Yeah, whatever.

600
00:33:27.426 --> 00:33:27.746
Whatever.

601
00:33:29.147 --> 00:33:44.195
But I think, again, measurement, it's not – measurement is a whole craft in and of itself with a level of density of complexity and expertise necessary to be able to do so in a robust enough way.

602
00:33:44.215 --> 00:33:45.076
Yeah.

603
00:33:45.516 --> 00:33:47.437
And this is a measurement challenge.

604
00:33:47.977 --> 00:33:55.481
Speaking of measurement challenges, in our first nine minutes of our appearance on the Dave Chang show,

605
00:33:55.861 --> 00:34:15.368
show which is on netflix check it out oh yeah spent on the double slit experiment which is a measurement problem yeah that is a measurement problem that completely caught me off guard because like we just got there and he's like what about the mit paper i'm like that was like months ago what what is going on i can't believe he like watched that one like that that's he's

606
00:34:17.609 --> 00:34:18.409
He's quite sharp.

607
00:34:18.489 --> 00:34:18.689
Yeah.

608
00:34:18.869 --> 00:34:20.090
He remembered so much.

609
00:34:20.130 --> 00:34:21.650
He's quite sharp on that.

610
00:34:21.690 --> 00:34:22.331
That was really cool.

611
00:34:22.411 --> 00:34:23.551
But the measurement problem.

612
00:34:23.611 --> 00:34:24.391
Measurement problem.

613
00:34:24.551 --> 00:34:26.572
And this is where this particular paper comes in.

614
00:34:26.752 --> 00:34:35.575
It's measuring this unmeasurable one millimeter per second, actually a lot less, change in a 23 kilometer per second object.

615
00:34:35.655 --> 00:34:37.276
That is millions of miles away.

616
00:34:37.376 --> 00:34:44.205
And this was a paper that came out in Science Advances, Direct Detection of an Asteroid's Heliocentric Deflection.

617
00:34:44.606 --> 00:34:44.826
Okay?

618
00:34:45.146 --> 00:34:50.193
The target change that they measured was 11 microns per second.

619
00:34:50.313 --> 00:34:50.674
Jesus.

620
00:34:50.774 --> 00:34:51.074
Okay?

621
00:34:51.735 --> 00:34:53.618
Out of 26 kilometers per second.

622
00:34:54.038 --> 00:34:54.339
Jesus.

623
00:34:55.550 --> 00:34:58.693
And what this means, to just give you a sense of scale...

624
00:34:58.713 --> 00:34:58.953
Yes.

625
00:34:59.414 --> 00:35:04.879
So that asteroid system goes around the Earth every 770 days, so that's about two years.

626
00:35:05.640 --> 00:35:10.905
And this tiny change in velocity means that the two years...

627
00:35:12.169 --> 00:35:16.452
Of orbit has been shortened by 0.15 seconds.

628
00:35:16.652 --> 00:35:17.973
Oh, my goodness.

629
00:35:18.053 --> 00:35:18.614
Okay.

630
00:35:18.634 --> 00:35:25.579
So a year on that asteroid is now shorter by 0.15 seconds because we crashed into the moon.

631
00:35:26.219 --> 00:35:27.100
That's incredible.

632
00:35:27.180 --> 00:35:30.222
And so there's sort of two things about this, which is interesting.

633
00:35:30.402 --> 00:35:36.867
One is what an exceptional job we've done to be able to measure such a small-scale change.

634
00:35:37.207 --> 00:35:39.028
And that's what we're going to get into next.

635
00:35:39.328 --> 00:35:46.210
And then the second piece is now we then have a reference point to be able to say, how much do we need to scale up?

636
00:35:46.230 --> 00:35:47.751
Because we just had a small little thing.

637
00:35:48.171 --> 00:35:52.533
We didn't send a big old because also getting payloads into space is expensive and costs money.

638
00:35:52.953 --> 00:35:56.955
And we don't like to spend too much money now on fundamental science stuff.

639
00:35:57.295 --> 00:36:02.877
But now you could go to the joint chiefs and say, we're going to need a hundred thousand megaton X. Yeah.

640
00:36:03.577 --> 00:36:03.737
Yeah.

641
00:36:03.797 --> 00:36:05.659
In order to get the level of momentum change.

642
00:36:05.679 --> 00:36:05.779
Yeah.

643
00:36:05.799 --> 00:36:07.540
But we just have a baseline now.

644
00:36:07.581 --> 00:36:07.881
Yeah.

645
00:36:07.921 --> 00:36:08.882
We have the numbers now.

646
00:36:09.162 --> 00:36:09.322
Right.

647
00:36:09.342 --> 00:36:09.542
Right?

648
00:36:10.043 --> 00:36:20.732
So in order to make that detection, right, so 11 microns per second is the difference between before and after, before the impact and after the impact.

649
00:36:20.832 --> 00:36:20.992
Mm-hmm.

650
00:36:21.172 --> 00:36:23.814
Before the impact, it was going at about 23 kilometers per second.

651
00:36:23.874 --> 00:36:24.095
Mm-hmm.

652
00:36:25.896 --> 00:36:26.076
Right?

653
00:36:26.336 --> 00:36:28.857
And after the impact, it's still going at 23 kilometers per second.

654
00:36:28.877 --> 00:36:30.979
This is like in the hypersonic velocity.

655
00:36:30.999 --> 00:36:32.859
No, this is not even hypersonic.

656
00:36:32.879 --> 00:36:35.381
This is like way, way, way.

657
00:36:35.581 --> 00:36:36.201
Okay, way.

658
00:36:36.241 --> 00:36:36.481
Yeah.

659
00:36:36.541 --> 00:36:39.563
Like the speed of sound is 343 meters per second.

660
00:36:39.663 --> 00:36:40.103
Okay.

661
00:36:40.183 --> 00:36:42.424
So 0.3 meters per second.

662
00:36:42.584 --> 00:36:42.864
Okay.

663
00:36:42.924 --> 00:36:43.184
Okay?

664
00:36:43.405 --> 00:36:44.325
This thing is 23.

665
00:36:44.885 --> 00:36:46.046
So that's what?

666
00:36:46.566 --> 00:36:48.087
Three times the way.

667
00:36:48.267 --> 00:36:49.087
60 times.

668
00:36:49.227 --> 00:36:50.568
About 60 times the speed.

669
00:36:50.668 --> 00:37:11.337
of sound okay hypersonic is five yeah so five and we're happy so we're in uap land right yeah yeah we're we're most likely in uap land here's the idea right in order to measure that change of 11 microns per second what i need to do is have that precision on the before and after before we get into the after mm-hmm

670
00:37:12.296 --> 00:37:12.496
Right.

671
00:37:12.656 --> 00:37:23.467
Like if I were to say if I were to measure something like, oh, the speed of the car, like imagine I'm a cop on the on the on the highway and the guy is going at 70 kilometers per second.

672
00:37:23.928 --> 00:37:32.857
And then I say, oh, he decreased his he decreased his speed by point zero zero zero three kilometers per second.

673
00:37:33.237 --> 00:37:35.920
Well, I'd need to know what the initial thing was, right?

674
00:37:35.980 --> 00:37:38.923
Otherwise, like, how do you—I could just be going like 71.

675
00:37:38.963 --> 00:37:41.246
If you said 70, that's only one significant figure.

676
00:37:41.566 --> 00:37:45.931
For those students in science, that means it could be 71 or 69 or 68, right?

677
00:37:46.231 --> 00:37:50.556
So we need to know the before and after equally well in order to make that subtraction.

678
00:37:50.576 --> 00:37:51.377
That's a really good point.

679
00:37:51.477 --> 00:37:59.322
We don't have, like, the tools in physics where I can, like, do destructive interference where I don't actually need to know the answer because the answer cancels out.

680
00:37:59.382 --> 00:38:00.783
No, we're not doing any fancy.

681
00:38:01.123 --> 00:38:03.945
We just need to know what the number is and then do subtraction.

682
00:38:04.185 --> 00:38:08.628
So the point being we need to measure it before we do anything.

683
00:38:08.648 --> 00:38:09.389
Yeah.

684
00:38:09.409 --> 00:38:11.470
And that measurement needs to be very, very good.

685
00:38:11.510 --> 00:38:12.871
It's very, very precise.

686
00:38:12.951 --> 00:38:14.232
Down to the micrometer level.

687
00:38:14.412 --> 00:38:14.772
Precise.

688
00:38:14.952 --> 00:38:15.132
Yes.

689
00:38:15.233 --> 00:38:15.393
Yes.

690
00:38:16.133 --> 00:38:22.617
The way they did that was, so this system, Didymos and Dimorphos, has approached Earth over the past 29 years.

691
00:38:23.078 --> 00:38:27.621
And we have massive radio telescopes that have bounced microwave signals off this thing.

692
00:38:27.901 --> 00:38:36.907
And we can now fit the orbit with a simulator, like a small body simulator, and JPL's Comet and Asteroid Orbit Determination Program.

693
00:38:37.307 --> 00:38:41.069
And from that, we can figure out what was the before velocity.

694
00:38:41.349 --> 00:38:44.712
Because we have this historical data that has captured...

695
00:38:45.452 --> 00:38:46.913
Pictures over time?

696
00:38:46.953 --> 00:38:48.393
Yeah, over 29 years.

697
00:38:48.514 --> 00:38:52.035
So you're capturing the movement even though the picture is static.

698
00:38:52.115 --> 00:38:52.515
Exactly.

699
00:38:52.535 --> 00:38:53.536
And it's not just pictures.

700
00:38:53.576 --> 00:38:54.396
It's also radar.

701
00:38:54.496 --> 00:38:54.777
Okay.

702
00:38:55.017 --> 00:38:55.437
Got it.

703
00:38:55.457 --> 00:38:57.358
Because we can beam it and it'll come back.

704
00:38:57.398 --> 00:38:59.479
So it'll give us a distance at least from Earth.

705
00:38:59.559 --> 00:38:59.779
Yes.

706
00:38:59.919 --> 00:39:03.040
And then the beam will also get blue shifted.

707
00:39:03.141 --> 00:39:03.361
Yes.

708
00:39:03.441 --> 00:39:05.902
Because the guy is either coming away from us or like...

709
00:39:06.262 --> 00:39:08.725
If it's moving away, then it'll be red shifted.

710
00:39:08.845 --> 00:39:12.049
If it's moving towards us, the beam that bounces back will be blue shifted.

711
00:39:12.109 --> 00:39:15.433
And we can measure that difference in frequency to figure out the velocity.

712
00:39:15.673 --> 00:39:16.954
You do this over multiple...

713
00:39:17.984 --> 00:39:42.366
years 29 years and you get a really nice right um number and it and that's the before and this is like we basically have a uh it's like a when you go on a run on an app like whatever strava or whatever and you get the little trail and it shows like where you've run before it's like we have that very precise very precisely the movement of this yeah over time over 29 years it's been doing the same thing right over and over again

714
00:39:42.846 --> 00:39:45.149
Okay, so now, how do we get after?

715
00:39:45.169 --> 00:39:46.570
Because it's only been three years.

716
00:39:46.611 --> 00:39:49.494
We've only got three years, not 29, in order to gather this data.

717
00:39:49.854 --> 00:39:50.835
So there's two ways to do it.

718
00:39:50.996 --> 00:39:52.457
One is through radio astronomy.

719
00:39:52.858 --> 00:39:55.881
Astrometry, which is the same thing that I was saying earlier.

720
00:39:56.222 --> 00:39:58.584
So radio astrometry is simply you...

721
00:39:59.425 --> 00:40:02.907
use radar to bounce a microwave signal there and back.

722
00:40:02.927 --> 00:40:08.070
They actually use the Goldstone solar system radar, which is part of JPL's deep space network.

723
00:40:08.150 --> 00:40:10.071
This is actually whenever we go to Mammoth.

724
00:40:10.171 --> 00:40:11.072
Yeah.

725
00:40:11.272 --> 00:40:14.094
You know, next time when we go, we should like just pull over.

726
00:40:14.134 --> 00:40:14.354
Yeah.

727
00:40:14.634 --> 00:40:17.376
And I don't think we can get in because it's like security or whatever.

728
00:40:17.396 --> 00:40:18.236
Hey, let us in.

729
00:40:18.256 --> 00:40:21.918
It's still like next time we go, I'll point out the radio dishes to you.

730
00:40:21.938 --> 00:40:22.038
Yeah.

731
00:40:22.058 --> 00:40:22.759
Yeah.

732
00:40:23.759 --> 00:40:25.020
So we use that.

733
00:40:25.381 --> 00:40:27.423
And from that, we can get the time delay.

734
00:40:27.463 --> 00:40:30.165
So that'll tell us within tens of meters what the position is.

735
00:40:30.606 --> 00:40:31.747
We get multiple positions.

736
00:40:31.787 --> 00:40:33.208
Then we can calculate the momenta.

737
00:40:33.248 --> 00:40:40.595
And also the fact that the signal is red shifted or blue shifted, that Doppler shift is going to give us some idea about velocity.

738
00:40:40.915 --> 00:40:44.498
But over three years, it's not going to give us enough of that error bar going down.

739
00:40:44.558 --> 00:40:45.459
It's going to be part of it.

740
00:40:45.919 --> 00:40:46.900
But we need something else.

741
00:40:47.000 --> 00:40:49.121
And this is where something very cool comes in.

742
00:40:49.201 --> 00:40:50.922
It's called stellar occultations.

743
00:40:51.063 --> 00:40:51.343
Okay.

744
00:40:51.643 --> 00:40:55.245
The idea is the asteroid is going to pass in front of stars in the night sky.

745
00:40:55.305 --> 00:40:55.565
No way.

746
00:40:55.806 --> 00:40:57.607
And it's going to eclipse stars.

747
00:40:57.627 --> 00:40:58.727
No way.

748
00:40:58.767 --> 00:40:59.848
And so we can measure.

749
00:40:59.908 --> 00:41:02.890
Whenever it eclipses stars, the star is going to blink.

750
00:41:03.270 --> 00:41:05.292
And we know the star doesn't actually blink.

751
00:41:05.981 --> 00:41:06.241
Right?

752
00:41:07.141 --> 00:41:08.622
The star has a constant brightness.

753
00:41:08.662 --> 00:41:12.183
So when it, like, goes down and up, and we know where it's going to be.

754
00:41:12.203 --> 00:41:15.484
So we're like, dude, this thing is going to move in front of that star.

755
00:41:15.564 --> 00:41:15.884
Yeah.

756
00:41:16.165 --> 00:41:17.865
Like, around this time.

757
00:41:17.985 --> 00:41:18.345
Yeah.

758
00:41:18.465 --> 00:41:20.406
So we can have volunteer astronomers.

759
00:41:20.486 --> 00:41:22.527
And that's what I found very cool about this story.

760
00:41:22.827 --> 00:41:25.268
There were volunteer astronomers that went out.

761
00:41:25.488 --> 00:41:25.608
Yes.

762
00:41:25.628 --> 00:41:25.728
Yes.

763
00:41:27.239 --> 00:41:29.860
And tried to capture these stellar occultations.

764
00:41:29.900 --> 00:41:37.162
We're effectively trying to capture the shadow of this asteroid passing in front of a star in the night sky.

765
00:41:37.182 --> 00:41:41.304
The shadow is only about a kilometer wide.

766
00:41:42.468 --> 00:41:48.472
Okay, so you need very precise, like, timing of, like, where you need to be in order to capture it.

767
00:41:48.732 --> 00:41:49.573
And also space.

768
00:41:50.073 --> 00:41:57.297
And one thing that I found really cool was there was a guy, volunteer again, he observed two of these occultations.

769
00:41:57.598 --> 00:42:02.721
He drove two days each way in the Australian outback in order to get this data.

770
00:42:03.221 --> 00:42:07.484
That's... Like, shout out to this Kangaroo Jack guy, dude.

771
00:42:07.844 --> 00:42:08.384
The Aussies.

772
00:42:08.485 --> 00:42:09.645
Aussie, Aussie, Aussie.

773
00:42:09.765 --> 00:42:10.906
Yeah, dude.

774
00:42:11.346 --> 00:42:12.067
It's pretty awesome.

775
00:42:12.087 --> 00:42:12.187
Yeah.

776
00:42:12.567 --> 00:42:23.250
But this is this is so interesting, again, because sometimes, you know, there's a lot of astrophotographers, I guess, that are very popular now on socials and stuff like that.

777
00:42:23.350 --> 00:42:25.711
And it's a real craft in and of itself.

778
00:42:25.731 --> 00:42:26.351
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

779
00:42:26.371 --> 00:42:27.791
This guy had to know where to point.

780
00:42:27.811 --> 00:42:28.251
Exactly.

781
00:42:28.291 --> 00:42:29.772
Like how to get the data.

782
00:42:29.892 --> 00:42:30.172
Exactly.

783
00:42:30.192 --> 00:42:34.873
Exactly where to be, because you've got a one kilometer radius that you need to you need to get this thing.

784
00:42:35.093 --> 00:42:45.501
And you can not only do it for the joys of being curious about the universe around us, but also be a participant and a contributor into sort of institutional research.

785
00:42:45.521 --> 00:42:45.982
Yeah, dude.

786
00:42:46.082 --> 00:42:51.346
I think he should put planetary defense researcher on his CV, right?

787
00:42:51.626 --> 00:42:55.649
Whatever he's doing in the Australian Outback, that should be part of his CV.

788
00:42:56.050 --> 00:43:02.274
So with this international network, they captured 22 distinct occultations between October 2022 and March 2025.

789
00:43:02.294 --> 00:43:02.815
Okay.

790
00:43:04.476 --> 00:43:11.998
And that is where they got all of their data to where they can say 11 micrometers per second is the change in the velocity of this asteroid.

791
00:43:12.018 --> 00:43:17.679
Because now we have like another reference point, another reference frame by which to like understand.

792
00:43:17.699 --> 00:43:19.820
Because we have the historical data set from the 29 years.

793
00:43:19.840 --> 00:43:20.780
Yeah, and that's the before.

794
00:43:20.840 --> 00:43:21.721
And we need an after.

795
00:43:21.781 --> 00:43:22.621
And we need an after.

796
00:43:22.801 --> 00:43:28.042
And so basically the stars that are behind this passing in between us –

797
00:43:31.323 --> 00:43:34.364
create a reference point for us to measure against.

798
00:43:34.404 --> 00:43:34.744
Yes.

799
00:43:35.164 --> 00:43:41.605
And that allows us to get the after because we have such a precise understanding of the stars and their positions.

800
00:43:41.645 --> 00:43:42.266
And their positions.

801
00:43:42.286 --> 00:43:43.586
So it's almost like they're a ruler.

802
00:43:43.746 --> 00:43:43.926
Yeah.

803
00:43:43.946 --> 00:43:45.846
The stars become a ruler by which we're measuring.

804
00:43:45.886 --> 00:43:47.487
And it's extremely precise.

805
00:43:47.527 --> 00:43:49.967
And that's how you get that precision in such a short time.

806
00:43:50.027 --> 00:43:50.227
Yeah.

807
00:43:50.307 --> 00:43:55.029
If we just waited for Goldstone radar to keep going, we'd have to wait for it to come back.

808
00:43:55.209 --> 00:43:57.249
And then like, you know, that's just going to take forever.

809
00:43:57.269 --> 00:43:58.169
That makes so much sense.

810
00:44:01.831 --> 00:44:02.932
astronomical data, right?

811
00:44:02.972 --> 00:44:04.253
And then we run the models on it.

812
00:44:04.293 --> 00:44:16.646
Then we can get the error rate down to where we can really say, yep, 11 micrometers per second is how much we took away from that asteroid, which means that its year, which is about two years, is going to be shorter by 0.15 seconds.

813
00:44:17.027 --> 00:44:18.248
And that's how we get that

814
00:44:19.560 --> 00:44:19.840
Data.

815
00:44:20.001 --> 00:44:21.182
That's so fascinating.

816
00:44:21.202 --> 00:44:22.523
That's how we conclude that number.

817
00:44:22.603 --> 00:44:22.763
Right.

818
00:44:22.984 --> 00:44:24.405
But it's hard work.

819
00:44:24.645 --> 00:44:27.589
And it's a really creative solution to the time problem.

820
00:44:27.749 --> 00:44:30.131
Because it's like you have a little, you know, what is it?

821
00:44:30.171 --> 00:44:31.633
A necessity breeds invention.

822
00:44:31.653 --> 00:44:33.475
And they're like, okay, we don't got time.

823
00:44:33.495 --> 00:44:33.875
Yeah.

824
00:44:34.135 --> 00:44:34.936
What are we going to do?

825
00:44:35.076 --> 00:44:35.517
Yeah.

826
00:44:35.577 --> 00:44:36.138
Well, what if?

827
00:44:37.125 --> 00:44:37.485
And it worked.

828
00:44:37.566 --> 00:44:38.006
Very good.

829
00:44:38.146 --> 00:44:38.846
Very good.

830
00:44:38.967 --> 00:44:45.111
And so now from there, we can actually calculate the momentum enhancement along the heliocentric path, not just the local path.

831
00:44:45.151 --> 00:44:45.351
Yes.

832
00:44:45.451 --> 00:44:50.755
But how much boost did both of them get on their way around the sun?

833
00:44:50.855 --> 00:44:51.075
Yeah.

834
00:44:51.175 --> 00:44:51.676
Given that...

835
00:44:52.556 --> 00:44:56.599
My, you know, Kamikaze drone satellite had a certain momentum.

836
00:44:56.899 --> 00:44:58.360
How much momentum boost did they get?

837
00:44:58.480 --> 00:45:02.022
And the beta that we get is about two, a little bit more than two.

838
00:45:02.342 --> 00:45:08.806
So twice as much momentum was transferred to that system than what we put in because of all the ejecta that came out.

839
00:45:08.926 --> 00:45:12.869
So basically the amount of momentum we put in, that same amount was ejected out.

840
00:45:13.609 --> 00:45:13.830
Yeah.

841
00:45:14.130 --> 00:45:14.330
Yeah.

842
00:45:14.630 --> 00:45:15.370
I thought it was pretty cool.

843
00:45:15.391 --> 00:45:16.411
That's very nice.

844
00:45:16.671 --> 00:45:18.773
It also confirms like the density of this.

845
00:45:20.185 --> 00:45:20.566
Moonlit.

846
00:45:20.726 --> 00:45:21.006
Yeah.

847
00:45:21.066 --> 00:45:21.566
It's about...

848
00:45:22.067 --> 00:45:26.471
It's significantly lower than solid silicate rock, which means that it's highly porous.

849
00:45:26.852 --> 00:45:28.653
It's actually not just like normal rock.

850
00:45:28.894 --> 00:45:30.475
It's like a very light rock.

851
00:45:30.495 --> 00:45:32.777
It's like the rock you are supposed to wash your feet with.

852
00:45:32.797 --> 00:45:33.378
What do they call it?

853
00:45:33.398 --> 00:45:34.119
Pumice stone?

854
00:45:34.159 --> 00:45:35.260
Yeah, pumice stone.

855
00:45:35.300 --> 00:45:35.720
Exactly.

856
00:45:35.740 --> 00:45:35.920
Yeah.

857
00:45:36.060 --> 00:45:36.481
Yeah.

858
00:45:36.621 --> 00:45:39.163
It's 1630 kilograms per meter cubed.

859
00:45:39.304 --> 00:45:39.404
Okay.

860
00:45:39.424 --> 00:45:39.624
Okay.

861
00:45:39.784 --> 00:45:43.367
Which is, so it's still going to sink in water.

862
00:45:43.587 --> 00:45:45.930
Water is 1,000 kilograms per meter cubed.

863
00:45:45.970 --> 00:45:48.772
But, you know, it's not that much more dense than water.

864
00:45:48.932 --> 00:45:53.496
I just want to note, we just implemented a latex notation in our script notes.

865
00:45:53.516 --> 00:45:54.637
Yeah, it's pretty great.

866
00:45:55.298 --> 00:45:56.659
Look at that plus or minus sign.

867
00:45:56.679 --> 00:45:57.840
It displays a real formula.

868
00:45:57.960 --> 00:45:58.200
Yeah.

869
00:45:58.300 --> 00:46:01.023
And I'm looking at this, and you just riffed that off the cuff so quick.

870
00:46:01.063 --> 00:46:01.203
Yeah.

871
00:46:02.712 --> 00:46:27.620
read it also the the beta with the under like there's a subscript you know beta h along because that's the beta heliospheric along the path before i had to like read the latex where it would go slash b-e-t-a underscore um parenthesis squiggly parentheses h oh my god it's now it's in english yeah now it's an actual english very good

872
00:46:29.062 --> 00:46:30.203
So, broader implications.

873
00:46:30.403 --> 00:46:30.623
Yes.

874
00:46:30.723 --> 00:46:32.604
We've got a valid measurement of beta.

875
00:46:32.965 --> 00:46:33.185
Yes.

876
00:46:33.305 --> 00:46:35.206
Now, that validates this kinetic impactor.

877
00:46:35.246 --> 00:46:37.668
That means that, like, in the future, we're not blowing things up.

878
00:46:37.868 --> 00:46:38.068
Right.

879
00:46:38.248 --> 00:46:44.412
Like, if we're going to get twice the momentum enhancement, that means, like, you know, all we need to really toggle is how big is the payload.

880
00:46:44.512 --> 00:46:44.692
Yep.

881
00:46:44.912 --> 00:46:45.653
Which we can...

882
00:46:46.755 --> 00:46:48.436
We can toggle as much as we want, right?

883
00:46:48.456 --> 00:46:51.157
We can do multiple hits if we need to.

884
00:46:51.877 --> 00:46:54.758
And then, like, how fast are we moving?

885
00:46:54.878 --> 00:46:55.718
How big is the payload?

886
00:46:55.738 --> 00:46:56.959
How fast are we moving?

887
00:46:57.039 --> 00:46:58.839
And then multiple if we need it, right?

888
00:46:58.899 --> 00:46:59.920
So this is now, like...

889
00:47:00.649 --> 00:47:01.990
A strategic advantage for us.

890
00:47:02.050 --> 00:47:03.692
It confirms that we can actually do this.

891
00:47:03.992 --> 00:47:08.576
All the things we've seen in all these asteroid movies, some of which they just tried to put a drill.

892
00:47:08.736 --> 00:47:11.278
I think Armageddon, they tried to drill and then blow it up.

893
00:47:11.438 --> 00:47:11.638
Yeah.

894
00:47:11.878 --> 00:47:14.501
But then it just created thousands of pieces that still came in the earth.

895
00:47:14.521 --> 00:47:15.181
Yeah, we're not doing that.

896
00:47:15.201 --> 00:47:15.641
We're not doing that.

897
00:47:15.661 --> 00:47:16.923
Armageddon was incorrect.

898
00:47:17.003 --> 00:47:17.183
Right?

899
00:47:17.463 --> 00:47:19.565
It's less, okay, it's less Hollywood-esque.

900
00:47:19.585 --> 00:47:19.685
Yeah.

901
00:47:19.705 --> 00:47:19.845
Yeah.

902
00:47:19.945 --> 00:47:22.188
There's no big nuclear explosions in space.

903
00:47:22.568 --> 00:47:23.750
But I just want to live.

904
00:47:24.351 --> 00:47:24.591
Right.

905
00:47:24.671 --> 00:47:25.813
And we just need to nudge it.

906
00:47:25.853 --> 00:47:26.634
We just need to hit it.

907
00:47:27.054 --> 00:47:28.236
Sideswipe it a little bit.

908
00:47:28.336 --> 00:47:29.037
Yeah, exactly.

909
00:47:29.057 --> 00:47:30.219
Just get it to go in the other direction.

910
00:47:30.239 --> 00:47:31.400
Yeah, it's like a hockey puck, right?

911
00:47:31.420 --> 00:47:33.483
Just like, you know, just move it out of the way.

912
00:47:34.084 --> 00:47:34.785
The near-Earth...

913
00:47:35.185 --> 00:47:36.086
Orbiter Surveyor.

914
00:47:36.206 --> 00:47:36.426
Yes.

915
00:47:36.446 --> 00:47:39.728
So this thing is NASA's next generation space-based infrared telescope.

916
00:47:39.768 --> 00:47:42.389
It's going to launch in 2027 in September.

917
00:47:42.910 --> 00:47:48.153
And it's designed to detect dark asteroids that are not visible by ground-based optical telescopes.

918
00:47:48.473 --> 00:47:51.115
For whatever reason, sometimes they're coming right at us from the sun.

919
00:47:51.415 --> 00:47:52.535
They're like in our orbit.

920
00:47:52.796 --> 00:47:53.376
Things like that.

921
00:47:53.396 --> 00:47:55.297
So that's what this surveyor is going to do.

922
00:47:55.337 --> 00:47:56.898
That's going to give us more and more information.

923
00:47:57.238 --> 00:47:59.541
You know, just in case some random crap happens.

924
00:47:59.661 --> 00:48:09.290
I want to note that the 2013 Russia example that we talked about, because some of the questions might be like, oh, well, planetary defense, we already know where all this stuff is, so we'll be fine anyway.

925
00:48:09.670 --> 00:48:14.655
That 2013 one came out of nowhere and no one saw it.

926
00:48:14.715 --> 00:48:18.079
Yeah, and it was super alarming because I was like, I thought you guys had this together.

927
00:48:18.119 --> 00:48:18.319
Right.

928
00:48:18.479 --> 00:48:19.140
And so...

929
00:48:19.720 --> 00:48:28.515
planetary defense is not we are a single point of failure yeah like like species i think i think we have i think nasa says that we've got all of the um

930
00:48:29.861 --> 00:48:35.703
All of the really bad ones, like the dinosaur impact type ones, probably under control.

931
00:48:35.723 --> 00:48:39.684
But still, the one on Russia, right?

932
00:48:39.845 --> 00:48:47.347
If that had not exploded out in whatever altitude, that could have been really bad.

933
00:48:47.367 --> 00:48:49.208
That could have taken out a small city.

934
00:48:49.268 --> 00:48:49.508
Yeah.

935
00:48:50.320 --> 00:48:51.320
I don't want that either.

936
00:48:51.580 --> 00:48:51.800
Right.

937
00:48:52.520 --> 00:49:07.623
Because the other flip side of this, which is just sort of an interesting dynamic in the world we live in today, which is relevant, is I think this is actually the this is the plot to Paradise, the Hulu show.

938
00:49:07.703 --> 00:49:07.963
Yeah.

939
00:49:08.343 --> 00:49:16.405
Where it was an external object that was coming in like a comet or an asteroid, and it triggered nuclear war.

940
00:49:17.516 --> 00:49:20.338
Because of its, like, as existential context.

941
00:49:20.658 --> 00:49:26.202
So, like, if something has impact and then there's misinformation, like, there's not good information sharing about what the thingy was.

942
00:49:26.242 --> 00:49:28.724
Yeah, I mean, we're going to war for a lot less.

943
00:49:29.124 --> 00:49:34.127
You know, so it just creates, you know, planetary defense is really important.

944
00:49:34.267 --> 00:49:39.751
We, you know, we are not well equipped to survive a massive impact.

945
00:49:39.851 --> 00:49:41.313
No, so I'd rather not have it.

946
00:49:41.474 --> 00:49:54.534
And we now have at least a baseline to be able to provide the defense industry the answer when they all get around that round table and they have an extinction level event from a celestial or cosmic object head to Earth.

947
00:49:54.995 --> 00:49:56.716
The NASA scientists have the math now.

948
00:49:56.876 --> 00:49:57.336
Exactly.

949
00:49:57.416 --> 00:49:57.596
Yeah.

950
00:49:57.896 --> 00:50:01.517
And one last thing that I want to highlight is that this is an international effort, right?

951
00:50:01.837 --> 00:50:02.777
Planetary defense.

952
00:50:02.857 --> 00:50:03.778
We're on the same planet.

953
00:50:04.098 --> 00:50:09.159
The ESA has HERA, which is arriving at Didymus and Dimorphos.

954
00:50:09.519 --> 00:50:12.060
It's actually going to map out the DART impact crater.

955
00:50:12.760 --> 00:50:17.542
And it's going to directly measure Dimorphos' mass via radio tracking.

956
00:50:18.402 --> 00:50:25.347
And really refine those values of delta V and then beta subsequently and so on and so forth.

957
00:50:25.367 --> 00:50:36.314
So it's really an international effort that we've just sort of created a lab test bed in space of Didius and Dimorphis, this binary asteroid system.

958
00:50:37.395 --> 00:50:37.955
It's very cool.

959
00:50:38.355 --> 00:50:46.457
Look, any space story you know I'm in on, I owned both Armageddon and Deep Impact on VHS when they both came out in whatever it was, 1997.

960
00:50:46.517 --> 00:50:58.340
I still think it's hilarious to think that Bruce Willis and Ben Affleck, who were a bunch of guys who worked on an oil rig, were the only people who could save Earth and had to learn how to become astronauts.

961
00:50:58.360 --> 00:51:05.301
And apparently it was easier to train people who worked on an oil rig to be astronauts than it was to train astronauts how to drill on this thing.

962
00:51:05.461 --> 00:51:05.681
Yeah.

963
00:51:05.801 --> 00:51:06.382
Ben Affleck did.

964
00:51:06.402 --> 00:51:14.670
And if you the one of the your movie buff, I think in the the extra scenes, whatever the when we used to have the DVDs with the extra stuff.

965
00:51:15.450 --> 00:51:18.433
Oh, the director, like the director's cut where they would voice over while I was playing.

966
00:51:18.994 --> 00:51:22.537
He was just taking the piss about how ridiculous the plot was.

967
00:51:22.557 --> 00:51:23.118
Yeah, yeah.

968
00:51:23.778 --> 00:51:24.518
the whole time.

969
00:51:24.538 --> 00:51:25.078
That makes sense.

970
00:51:25.399 --> 00:51:26.439
Very, very cool story.

971
00:51:26.479 --> 00:51:28.339
Dart, our planetary defense story today.

972
00:51:28.920 --> 00:51:37.342
And the key piece to this was the ability to calculate the heliocentric momentum change.

973
00:51:37.742 --> 00:51:43.724
It's really a precision physics and precision astronomy story, more than anything else.

974
00:51:43.764 --> 00:51:44.444
Right, right.

975
00:51:44.544 --> 00:51:48.045
But in the media we like to say, planetary defense!

976
00:51:48.146 --> 00:51:49.746
How do we make this militarized?

977
00:51:50.306 --> 00:51:52.287
But I just love the, like, you know,

978
00:51:53.267 --> 00:51:57.770
For astronomers, like, this kind of precision is, like, unprecedented, right?

979
00:51:58.150 --> 00:52:02.092
They're, like, plus or minus 10,000 kilometers, you know, type of guys.

980
00:52:02.172 --> 00:52:02.393
Right.

981
00:52:02.433 --> 00:52:02.813
Right.

982
00:52:05.899 --> 00:52:08.260
And just to recap, this was in Science Advances.

983
00:52:09.780 --> 00:52:12.261
Came out March 5th, March 6th.

984
00:52:12.301 --> 00:52:18.284
University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, which has been a key institution we've talked about quite a bit on the pod.

985
00:52:18.704 --> 00:52:30.489
Also, NASA JPL, Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Lab, and a few European universities in collaboration, as you were just mentioning, from the ESA side.

986
00:52:30.509 --> 00:52:31.210
Yeah.

987
00:52:31.870 --> 00:52:33.391
Really fantastic story.

988
00:52:33.771 --> 00:52:37.613
We are going to wrap up on the episode for the day.

989
00:52:38.094 --> 00:52:39.294
However, we have one.

990
00:52:40.535 --> 00:52:41.075
We have two things.

991
00:52:41.095 --> 00:52:43.877
One, we need our comment, which we did not write out in our script notes.

992
00:52:44.517 --> 00:52:44.778
Oh, no.

993
00:52:44.798 --> 00:52:45.138
Why do you?

994
00:52:45.198 --> 00:52:45.618
No, we did.

995
00:52:45.738 --> 00:52:46.058
It was.

996
00:52:46.459 --> 00:52:46.779
Oh, yes.

997
00:52:46.799 --> 00:52:49.060
Why do you think the Russians have so many dash cams?

998
00:52:49.120 --> 00:52:49.480
Oh, yes.

999
00:52:49.660 --> 00:52:49.881
Yes.

1000
00:52:50.121 --> 00:52:50.301
Yes.

1001
00:52:50.761 --> 00:52:56.944
So if you're still listening, an hour in, because we are now not doing two and a half hour episodes.

1002
00:52:56.964 --> 00:53:02.627
We're doing multiple, more bite-sized, more digestible episodes that are focused.

1003
00:53:02.667 --> 00:53:04.749
So why do you think they have so many dash cams?

1004
00:53:04.989 --> 00:53:15.995
And we do want to do one correction from episode 29, which was from the rundown related to the research study about the Neanderthal human mating bias.

1005
00:53:16.315 --> 00:53:20.397
We really appreciate all of the comments from folks on a variety of platforms on that story.

1006
00:53:20.897 --> 00:53:26.599
Part of the challenge is with the rundown, it is not a main focus, so we don't necessarily get into the weeds as much.

1007
00:53:27.099 --> 00:53:34.341
We use some imprecise language in that segment, and the study itself was really just focused on mating bias.

1008
00:53:34.761 --> 00:53:39.582
There was a conversation about the difference between consensual and non-consensual that was not...

1009
00:53:40.762 --> 00:53:42.763
in the purview of the study itself.

1010
00:53:43.263 --> 00:53:45.023
And so we appreciate that feedback.

1011
00:53:45.043 --> 00:53:54.525
We will keep that in mind in terms of making sure we are much more attuned and accurate as we cover things, even if it's in the rundown and not a main story.

1012
00:53:54.886 --> 00:53:56.906
So we really appreciate that feedback from you guys.

1013
00:53:57.366 --> 00:54:06.708
I am your host, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD who is not a planetary defense researcher.

1014
00:54:07.228 --> 00:54:08.649
No, just a measly grad student.

1015
00:54:10.691 --> 00:54:12.334
we'll catch you guys for the next episode this week
