WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.111 --> 00:00:01.712
Konnichiwa Gwan, internet.

2
00:00:01.732 --> 00:00:08.518
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

3
00:00:08.558 --> 00:00:12.982
This is from First Principles, also known as FFP Pod.

4
00:00:13.522 --> 00:00:18.006
We are joining you here in our post-Nobel Prize Week episode.

5
00:00:18.506 --> 00:00:20.608
Unbelievable week.

6
00:00:20.648 --> 00:00:21.509
Super interesting.

7
00:00:21.569 --> 00:00:21.949
Amazing.

8
00:00:21.989 --> 00:00:23.330
We did three days in a row.

9
00:00:23.571 --> 00:00:24.731
We put out the full episode.

10
00:00:24.752 --> 00:00:27.073
The engagement has been unbelievable.

11
00:00:27.194 --> 00:00:28.334
Clearly, people liked our

12
00:00:29.075 --> 00:00:47.778
sort of espn style coverage waking up at 2 30 was worth it um super interesting stuff we're gonna do a follow-up this episode but before we start uh one of the questions that kept coming up in a lot of the comments as more and more people started watching the show was who are you guys

13
00:00:48.859 --> 00:00:52.162
Um, which is a fair question given we just started the podcast.

14
00:00:52.182 --> 00:00:52.402
Yeah.

15
00:00:52.722 --> 00:00:55.284
Our first episode was July 31st of 2025.

16
00:00:55.304 --> 00:00:55.804
Yep.

17
00:00:56.565 --> 00:01:10.194
So we're only a couple of months in and we thought it would be a good time to kind of talk about our origin story, uh, which is not dissimilar from any other podcasts, but it all starts at one place we talk about a lot on the podcast, which is Princeton.

18
00:01:11.015 --> 00:01:14.918
Uh, we both sort of were at Prince at the same time, became best friends, uh,

19
00:01:15.638 --> 00:01:21.321
And at that time, you were in one of the most illustrious programs on the planet.

20
00:01:21.862 --> 00:01:22.182
Yeah.

21
00:01:22.622 --> 00:01:23.903
In the Princeton physics program.

22
00:01:23.923 --> 00:01:24.203
Yes.

23
00:01:24.963 --> 00:01:26.684
Boy, that was a doozy, wasn't it?

24
00:01:26.845 --> 00:01:30.867
So we met sophomore year, which was 2011.

25
00:01:30.907 --> 00:01:33.548
So we've been friends for about 14 years now.

26
00:01:33.748 --> 00:01:37.891
Our wives are very close at this point, which is another interesting variable.

27
00:01:38.351 --> 00:01:39.372
But at the time...

28
00:01:40.252 --> 00:01:50.501
You know, I played soccer and I was moving from economics to program two, which was Shirley Tillman's pet project for creating an arts program at the school.

29
00:01:50.581 --> 00:01:50.801
Right.

30
00:01:51.622 --> 00:01:53.683
And you were busy doing the hard sciences.

31
00:01:54.064 --> 00:01:56.345
Yeah, I was pretty set on physics right when I got there.

32
00:01:56.806 --> 00:02:01.470
I remember asking you one day, oh, like, you know, physics, like, oh, was that hard?

33
00:02:01.490 --> 00:02:02.190
And you were like, mate.

34
00:02:02.450 --> 00:02:03.111
Mate.

35
00:02:03.311 --> 00:02:04.172
You have no idea.

36
00:02:04.192 --> 00:02:04.372
Yeah.

37
00:02:05.033 --> 00:02:05.393
Yeah.

38
00:02:06.718 --> 00:02:11.123
Program started with like 20, 200 freshmen being like, I'm going to be a physics major.

39
00:02:11.744 --> 00:02:18.151
And then slowly it just ended up being like the 20 of us being like, bro, this is ridiculous.

40
00:02:19.853 --> 00:02:22.254
So we have a long friendship and a long history.

41
00:02:22.274 --> 00:02:39.184
And a lot of the times, even back in the day, I would always come to you about, one of the interesting overlaps in both of our lives is that we both come from immigrant families, Indian and Zimbabwean, both of whom have two parents that are heavily involved in the sciences.

42
00:02:39.224 --> 00:02:40.185
That's right, yeah.

43
00:02:40.225 --> 00:02:42.246
Between the two of us, we have three PhD parents.

44
00:02:42.406 --> 00:02:43.407
Yeah.

45
00:02:43.487 --> 00:02:48.810
We have physics, botany, parasitology, and clinical trials as the sort of

46
00:02:49.390 --> 00:03:15.009
verticals that our parents work in and so i think part of the initial like substance of why this show works is we both grew up in science-based households yeah that were very academic focused yeah in terms of us exactly and like the the stories that i would hear growing up about like the heroes right would for me would be like scientists 100 you know my dad would tell me stories about

47
00:03:15.919 --> 00:03:19.204
Feynman and Einstein and Chandra Shekhar, you know?

48
00:03:19.324 --> 00:03:24.612
And so instead of sports, we got, I got at least a lot of just...

49
00:03:25.557 --> 00:03:26.938
science heroes to look up to.

50
00:03:27.558 --> 00:03:33.881
I mean, it's very similar in Zim culture where, you know, your path out, a lot of times people don't know a lot about Zimbabwe.

51
00:03:33.941 --> 00:03:41.425
The number one thing most people know about Zimbabwe is we had a trillion dollar note because of hyperinflation in like the 2000 or 2001.

52
00:03:42.266 --> 00:03:48.109
But one thing that's not well known is we have an incredible academic infrastructure in the country.

53
00:03:48.609 --> 00:03:49.930
And when you grow up,

54
00:03:51.525 --> 00:03:58.712
you're built to be in the sciences, be a doctor, be in mathematics, because that was your way to sort of salivate.

55
00:03:58.732 --> 00:04:00.973
That was your way out of poverty.

56
00:04:01.354 --> 00:04:01.854
Same in India.

57
00:04:01.874 --> 00:04:03.035
I was going to say it's very similar.

58
00:04:03.315 --> 00:04:05.157
Education was your lottery ticket.

59
00:04:05.437 --> 00:04:05.878
Exactly.

60
00:04:06.078 --> 00:04:06.658
Yeah.

61
00:04:07.059 --> 00:04:10.341
And so we have this sort of shared background, both family and college-wise.

62
00:04:11.703 --> 00:04:13.984
There's an LA connection as well.

63
00:04:14.165 --> 00:04:15.426
That's right.

64
00:04:15.466 --> 00:04:17.567
You born here, me moving here after college.

65
00:04:17.628 --> 00:04:18.348
I wasn't born here.

66
00:04:18.628 --> 00:04:19.009
Not born.

67
00:04:19.449 --> 00:04:20.269
Yeah.

68
00:04:20.369 --> 00:04:22.010
I was born in India, but I did grow up.

69
00:04:22.030 --> 00:04:23.531
This is the most I've grown up in.

70
00:04:23.731 --> 00:04:25.872
This is the place I've most grown up in.

71
00:04:26.052 --> 00:04:27.553
The most normal home.

72
00:04:27.673 --> 00:04:27.893
Yeah.

73
00:04:28.213 --> 00:04:38.818
And what's interesting is I remember when I was trying to decide between New York, San Francisco, and L.A., which is the classic three choices that you have after school.

74
00:04:38.918 --> 00:04:39.739
Yeah.

75
00:04:40.059 --> 00:04:45.962
I really wanted to come to L.A. And you were so, you were just like, yeah, mate.

76
00:04:46.142 --> 00:04:46.802
Yeah, you got it.

77
00:04:47.955 --> 00:04:49.596
LA is the best.

78
00:04:49.656 --> 00:04:50.837
We both ended up back here.

79
00:04:50.857 --> 00:04:52.298
Yeah.

80
00:04:52.318 --> 00:04:53.419
A little bit of different paths.

81
00:04:54.599 --> 00:04:56.300
I went straight to the private sector.

82
00:04:56.320 --> 00:05:03.805
I've worked in sort of entertainment and tech for the last 10 years, which is kind of where I've acquired a lot of the equipment that it now enables this podcast.

83
00:05:04.385 --> 00:05:11.710
It's been sort of 10 years of working in influencer marketing and gaming and now running a tech company.

84
00:05:12.676 --> 00:05:13.756
You stayed in academia.

85
00:05:14.156 --> 00:05:14.397
Yeah.

86
00:05:14.557 --> 00:05:15.097
For a little bit.

87
00:05:15.357 --> 00:05:15.617
Yeah.

88
00:05:15.937 --> 00:05:17.818
Went to UCLA for graduate school.

89
00:05:18.758 --> 00:05:19.778
Got my PhD there.

90
00:05:20.538 --> 00:05:23.839
Ended up first in the physics department, of course.

91
00:05:24.059 --> 00:05:32.342
And, you know, at Princeton, I got really interested in the emerging field of biological physics, which is the idea of...

92
00:05:34.641 --> 00:05:41.423
trying to figure out how life even exists in a world where physics is king.

93
00:05:41.923 --> 00:05:42.224
Right.

94
00:05:42.504 --> 00:05:54.968
In a world where the second law of thermodynamics is an axiom where everything needs to go to soup and entropy needs to increase and everything needs to be uniform and not equilibrium.

95
00:05:55.788 --> 00:06:08.703
we are clearly like highly non-equilibrium beings that are just creating podcasts and not just us, but like plants, bacteria, all of these little things are hacking physics at a fundamental level to stay alive.

96
00:06:09.204 --> 00:06:11.947
And that was always so fascinating to me that, you know,

97
00:06:12.788 --> 00:06:23.239
In a world where the second law of thermodynamics is an axiom, you can have so much stuff that is just like visibly breaking that rule somehow.

98
00:06:23.419 --> 00:06:23.940
But it's not.

99
00:06:24.180 --> 00:06:30.827
You know, it's definitely not breaking the rule, but it's very clever in how it circumnavigates that rule, you know?

100
00:06:31.327 --> 00:06:32.669
And I thought that was awesome.

101
00:06:32.689 --> 00:06:33.569
So at Princeton Night...

102
00:06:34.310 --> 00:06:42.554
Did some research in like theoretical physics of DNA confinement, like polymer physics, how DNA bends and curves and stuff like that.

103
00:06:43.274 --> 00:06:50.257
And protein aggregation in stuff like Alzheimer's, where these amyloid proteins like aggregate in the neurons.

104
00:06:50.277 --> 00:06:51.598
So what are the statistics of that?

105
00:06:51.638 --> 00:06:57.881
And then finally, for my senior thesis, I did a little bit on this thing called the omitted stimulus response, which is...

106
00:06:59.179 --> 00:07:09.141
a way in which the retina in your eye literally acts like a little microcircuit controller that sends compressed data to your brain in a very cool way.

107
00:07:09.221 --> 00:07:12.462
So that's where I got really into neural computation.

108
00:07:12.642 --> 00:07:12.862
Right.

109
00:07:13.342 --> 00:07:21.184
Of like, how does a neural network that is biological and running at 300 Kelvin in this hot and soupy environment able to compute stuff?

110
00:07:21.684 --> 00:07:22.925
And so that's where I got into that.

111
00:07:22.985 --> 00:07:27.126
And then when I came to UCLA, I did my PhD in neuroscience and physics.

112
00:07:27.206 --> 00:07:28.426
But it was in the physics department.

113
00:07:29.506 --> 00:07:39.854
Most of my scientific inquiry was physics-based, although the experiments were biological because they had to do with real neurons in real brains.

114
00:07:41.380 --> 00:07:45.703
But it was a really cool synthesis of the two fields.

115
00:07:46.264 --> 00:07:53.589
Got my PhD in physics at UCLA, did a postdoc, and now I'm working as a scientist in the private sector.

116
00:07:54.189 --> 00:07:55.870
I think while you were...

117
00:07:56.091 --> 00:07:58.813
Some of your work, correct me if I'm wrong, while you were...

118
00:07:59.573 --> 00:08:05.516
at UCLA did get some sort of press coverage as being pretty important.

119
00:08:05.536 --> 00:08:06.996
Yeah, yeah, that was cool.

120
00:08:07.256 --> 00:08:13.259
My first author paper came out of Nature Communications, and a lot of the press really, really took it up.

121
00:08:14.659 --> 00:08:20.282
You know, as the press do, there are some things I was like, no, that's not quite right, but hey, I'm happy you're talking about it.

122
00:08:21.579 --> 00:08:22.640
Yeah.

123
00:08:22.660 --> 00:08:24.000
He got some international coverage, too.

124
00:08:24.020 --> 00:08:24.761
That was really cool.

125
00:08:24.781 --> 00:08:28.183
There was a news article in Iran.

126
00:08:28.703 --> 00:08:30.324
There was a news article in Japan.

127
00:08:30.384 --> 00:08:33.826
So that was pretty cool to see people responding to my work.

128
00:08:34.406 --> 00:08:41.030
So how do we get from this soup of backgrounds to deciding to do a science podcast?

129
00:08:42.891 --> 00:08:45.494
It's not our first rodeo.

130
00:08:45.574 --> 00:08:51.219
In my work, I've previously done solo podcasts that were more focused in the tech space.

131
00:08:51.339 --> 00:09:00.769
Given that I have a production background, again, all the technical implementation of lights, cameras, switchers, editing, distribution.

132
00:09:01.269 --> 00:09:02.690
That was kind of the learning curve there.

133
00:09:03.391 --> 00:09:26.863
around COVID, uh, we had actually, you know, one of the things I'd always pushed on was even early on back when we were at Princeton, I was like, I think, I think you have the gift of gab around science communication that has potential, you know, and we tried it with the dark dark matters podcasts, uh, right around when COVID started.

134
00:09:27.243 --> 00:09:31.905
And I think in part the inspiration was the clear lack of like sort of, uh,

135
00:09:32.445 --> 00:09:37.888
The public health communication during that time period was maybe, let's say, lacking.

136
00:09:37.968 --> 00:09:38.969
Yeah.

137
00:09:39.089 --> 00:09:39.569
Severely.

138
00:09:39.829 --> 00:09:45.452
And there was not really an understanding of the basics around a lot of the things related to vaccines, the immune system.

139
00:09:45.852 --> 00:09:47.993
We'll actually touch on the immune system in this episode a little bit.

140
00:09:48.453 --> 00:09:54.737
And so a little bit of the inspiration to try it then was that it just didn't work at the time for a number of reasons.

141
00:09:55.357 --> 00:10:02.084
Then we tried again earlier, like last year, you doing a solo, me running production.

142
00:10:03.326 --> 00:10:07.731
And, you know, it just wasn't the magic dust.

143
00:10:07.791 --> 00:10:08.411
It wasn't there.

144
00:10:08.792 --> 00:10:11.335
And then I finally decided, let me come out from behind the camera.

145
00:10:11.615 --> 00:10:15.739
I had actually done a little bit of a UAP, Unidentified Anomalous Phenomenon,

146
00:10:16.981 --> 00:10:21.204
content creation and podcasts over the last two years.

147
00:10:21.344 --> 00:10:21.865
Yeah.

148
00:10:21.885 --> 00:10:31.533
And in that process, you set up this studio as a part of that and found success there and kind of figured out, I think, the way in which we need to structure a show.

149
00:10:31.853 --> 00:10:33.674
So I came back and was like, let's try again.

150
00:10:33.694 --> 00:10:34.275
Yeah, let's do it.

151
00:10:34.495 --> 00:10:38.318
And that's how we got to where we are today with From First Principles.

152
00:10:38.899 --> 00:10:41.120
And so just a little bit of background on...

153
00:10:41.881 --> 00:10:43.001
you know, where we're coming from.

154
00:10:43.421 --> 00:10:47.563
And ultimately we've built this show with sort of two component ideas.

155
00:10:48.103 --> 00:11:05.428
One is it's, it's meant to be a love letter to the scientific community, academics, researchers, especially who give us the incredible life we have today where every device, every convenience that we take for granted is the result of some researcher toiling away years ago.

156
00:11:06.428 --> 00:11:11.010
And ultimately that getting into industrial production and then into end consumer products.

157
00:11:11.030 --> 00:11:11.430
Yeah.

158
00:11:12.074 --> 00:11:12.297
Um, um,

159
00:11:13.083 --> 00:11:22.249
And I think the second reason, and this is more of my reason, is when I look around and I'm looking for content to consume, I'm like, why is there not an ESPN for science?

160
00:11:23.390 --> 00:11:31.476
Why isn't there something that is doing the same kind of analysis and promotion and hyping around the thing that makes all of our lives so much better?

161
00:11:32.276 --> 00:11:41.543
And so this combination of love letter to the scientific community and building the ESPN for science is a lot of the thesis and theory of the case for why we've built the pod.

162
00:11:42.403 --> 00:11:54.138
And with all of that being said, one other question that came up was, how did you guys get sponsored by a beverage company if you're so new?

163
00:11:54.218 --> 00:12:01.006
So many of you probably have seen the show is presented by Standard Model Beverages, which has been conveniently placed online.

164
00:12:01.346 --> 00:12:07.833
For those who are listening, if you watch on the video, it's always in the podcast as the drink of choice.

165
00:12:08.254 --> 00:12:08.694
That's right.

166
00:12:08.934 --> 00:12:12.398
And what is the history behind Standard Model Beverages?

167
00:12:12.798 --> 00:12:16.923
So Standard Model Beverages also has a history in science.

168
00:12:18.404 --> 00:12:20.907
It was started by me and a friend of mine.

169
00:12:22.281 --> 00:12:25.703
Cameron Bravo, he was a PhD friend from UCLA.

170
00:12:25.743 --> 00:12:29.544
He worked in particle physics at CERN, experimental particle physics.

171
00:12:29.665 --> 00:12:31.665
And he got really good at making drinks.

172
00:12:32.106 --> 00:12:33.186
Oh, my God.

173
00:12:33.266 --> 00:12:36.168
I remember at the bachelor party, the brew he made was incredible.

174
00:12:36.488 --> 00:12:38.569
I remember talking to him like, are you going to do something with this?

175
00:12:38.609 --> 00:12:39.269
Yeah, exactly.

176
00:12:39.309 --> 00:12:43.091
At the bachelor party was when we started thinking like, hey, maybe we could do this.

177
00:12:43.111 --> 00:12:45.572
And then after my wedding, he brought more beer.

178
00:12:45.672 --> 00:12:46.753
And then it was a hit there.

179
00:12:46.873 --> 00:12:49.674
And then we were like, you know, let's make a science-centric beer.

180
00:12:51.915 --> 00:12:57.837
company, a beverage company that celebrates science and scientists and the experimental method of how we create these things.

181
00:12:57.857 --> 00:13:05.599
Because he's a man of science as well, and he uses the scientific method to get the best sort of ingredients and the best flavors.

182
00:13:06.199 --> 00:13:15.802
And so we called it the Standard Model Beverage Company, after the Standard Model of Particle Physics, which we're huge fans of and maybe we'll get into in some of the later episodes.

183
00:13:16.622 --> 00:13:16.842
Yeah.

184
00:13:17.622 --> 00:13:22.531
It's right now we make non-alcoholic soda from agave sugars.

185
00:13:23.590 --> 00:13:28.213
And on the back of every can, you'll find a featured scientist that you can learn about.

186
00:13:28.233 --> 00:13:30.014
So this one has Galileo Galilei.

187
00:13:30.074 --> 00:13:33.116
It'll tell you all about his life and the science that he's known for.

188
00:13:33.576 --> 00:13:35.197
Other cans have other scientists.

189
00:13:35.577 --> 00:13:43.882
So it's really, again, just as this show is a love letter to scientists and science, this drinks company is a love letter to science and scientists.

190
00:13:44.262 --> 00:13:50.006
You can go on our website and learn about the quantum mechanics behind our logo, which is

191
00:13:51.005 --> 00:13:57.190
a visual depiction of the Durak equation, which is the equation for an electron or any relativistic particle.

192
00:13:57.250 --> 00:14:03.795
And it gives you a prediction of matter and antimatter, the antimatter being the hole in a sea.

193
00:14:04.576 --> 00:14:12.062
Again, something that we can go into in later episodes because that's one of the greatest achievements of theoretical physics is to literally predict...

194
00:14:12.662 --> 00:14:16.584
antimatter based on the fact that a square root can be positive and negative.

195
00:14:17.204 --> 00:14:17.424
Right.

196
00:14:17.724 --> 00:14:23.626
And that's what that's what sort of so all of our artwork, all of our branding is around this love for science.

197
00:14:24.466 --> 00:14:25.267
And check us out.

198
00:14:25.347 --> 00:14:28.448
Our website should be on the links.

199
00:14:29.208 --> 00:14:33.610
We're working towards our alcohol license from the ABC Office of California.

200
00:14:33.830 --> 00:14:35.811
And pretty soon we'll we'll be offering more.

201
00:14:35.831 --> 00:14:36.191
Yeah.

202
00:14:36.663 --> 00:14:43.224
And I think what's so funny is if you listen to this podcast, you'll be one of the few people that understands the secret of the logo that goes on the front of the can.

203
00:14:43.244 --> 00:14:43.644
Exactly, yeah.

204
00:14:44.004 --> 00:14:58.327
And shout out to Snapple Facts, which if you grew up in the 90s and drank Snapples, you turned the cap and there was a little fun fact on the underneath, and that was a little bit of inspiration for featuring a scientist on every can.

205
00:14:58.867 --> 00:15:02.228
And so with all of that procedural nonsense out of the way,

206
00:15:03.188 --> 00:15:05.869
we can get back to regularly scheduled programming.

207
00:15:06.129 --> 00:15:10.691
Also not industry plants, by the way, we're not industry plants.

208
00:15:10.711 --> 00:15:10.911
Yeah.

209
00:15:10.931 --> 00:15:11.091
Yeah.

210
00:15:11.111 --> 00:15:11.371
Yeah.

211
00:15:11.451 --> 00:15:13.792
That would make my finances a lot easier to manage.

212
00:15:13.832 --> 00:15:14.113
Yeah.

213
00:15:14.173 --> 00:15:14.333
Yeah.

214
00:15:14.353 --> 00:15:15.653
This is all self-funded.

215
00:15:15.933 --> 00:15:17.974
It's, it's just, it's just the two of us.

216
00:15:18.014 --> 00:15:19.075
We don't have like a team.

217
00:15:19.095 --> 00:15:20.295
There's no production crew.

218
00:15:20.655 --> 00:15:25.557
Everything is done, processed, edited, produced output just by the two of us.

219
00:15:25.837 --> 00:15:28.879
So all the support that you guys give us is really, really meaningful.

220
00:15:29.019 --> 00:15:29.219
Yeah.

221
00:15:29.299 --> 00:15:32.020
As we try to, again, grow this into a network, uh,

222
00:15:32.320 --> 00:15:38.528
And again, build that ESPN for science, which in the times we live in today is more important than ever.

223
00:15:39.409 --> 00:15:45.657
And with that, we will now pivot into our quick Nobel recap.

224
00:15:46.037 --> 00:15:50.463
So last week, we did coverage of all of the three science Nobels.

225
00:15:52.204 --> 00:15:53.665
Medicine, chemistry, and physics.

226
00:15:54.125 --> 00:16:04.390
And we want to do a quick follow-up on a couple of the discoveries, starting with the medicine follow-up on non-immune roles in regulatory T-cells, or T-regs.

227
00:16:04.570 --> 00:16:06.631
And so we'll start with that quick recap now.

228
00:16:06.791 --> 00:16:07.011
Yeah.

229
00:16:07.111 --> 00:16:08.712
The 2025 Nobel Prize was...

230
00:16:11.463 --> 00:16:17.625
given to three individuals, Shimon Shakaguchi, Fred Ramsdell, and Mary Brunkow.

231
00:16:18.425 --> 00:16:27.629
Shimon Shakaguchi was at the University of Osaka in Japan, and Fred Ramsdell and Mary Brunkow were two individuals at private research companies in Washington in America.

232
00:16:28.489 --> 00:16:35.131
They were given for basically discovering Tregs, which are regulatory T-cells.

233
00:16:36.012 --> 00:16:36.852
This is the...

234
00:16:38.245 --> 00:16:41.588
It's a cartoon that the Nobel Prize Committee came up with.

235
00:16:41.628 --> 00:16:45.791
It's got an alien, I guess, inside of a police ship.

236
00:16:46.071 --> 00:16:51.055
And the police ship is the T-reg, which is the T-cell that is a regulatory T-cell.

237
00:16:51.656 --> 00:17:07.108
And inside, the alien has a cap on, and the cap says FOXP3, because the FOXP3 is the gene that sort of creates and regulates the T-reg itself and makes the T-reg different from all the other T-cells in our body.

238
00:17:08.843 --> 00:17:11.945
And just as a quick review for what these T-regs do, right?

239
00:17:12.726 --> 00:17:15.988
Their basic role is to act as the police of the police.

240
00:17:16.548 --> 00:17:28.015
The police being our greater immune system that targets viruses, targets antigens, targets other human cells that have...

241
00:17:29.240 --> 00:17:33.364
been affected by a virus or an antigen and are now falling apart.

242
00:17:33.704 --> 00:17:39.309
So T-cells are normally involved with identifying those guys and then gearing them up for

243
00:17:42.547 --> 00:17:49.674
greater immune like therapy, greater immune attack from macrophages, from all these other kinds of things that come in.

244
00:17:50.014 --> 00:17:55.019
And once the T cell has identified that bad cell, the other guys come in and sort of take care of business.

245
00:17:55.380 --> 00:17:55.520
Right.

246
00:17:55.540 --> 00:17:59.143
But every once in a while, the T cell is going to, is going to identify one of your own,

247
00:17:59.924 --> 00:18:02.786
as a bad cell because all it is is a lock and key method.

248
00:18:02.806 --> 00:18:06.228
And sometimes the locks and the keys don't work like they're supposed to.

249
00:18:06.748 --> 00:18:11.431
And so what these regulatory T cells do is they inhibit that immune response.

250
00:18:11.871 --> 00:18:12.051
Right.

251
00:18:12.311 --> 00:18:14.192
And that's what these three individuals showed.

252
00:18:14.232 --> 00:18:22.197
Shakaguchi was the guy who found Tregs and showed that they were completely different from normal Treg cells.

253
00:18:22.317 --> 00:18:23.458
I mean, from normal T cells.

254
00:18:23.818 --> 00:18:28.621
And then Fred Ramsdell and Mary Brunkow found the FOXP3 genome that actually

255
00:18:29.901 --> 00:18:31.423
makes these Tregs what they are.

256
00:18:31.683 --> 00:18:42.512
So it was both the discovery of the function of this special class of T cells in addition to understanding how they are actually created at a genomic level.

257
00:18:42.752 --> 00:18:43.733
It's both aspects.

258
00:18:43.753 --> 00:18:46.836
Yeah, and that's why there were three that got the Nobel Prize, right?

259
00:18:47.896 --> 00:18:48.077
But...

260
00:18:48.837 --> 00:18:52.900
Since then, it's been, you know, 40 years of research since all of this has been happening.

261
00:18:53.420 --> 00:18:58.763
And now we figured out that Tregs aren't just about controlling immunity, right?

262
00:18:58.783 --> 00:19:03.306
They can also directly influence non-immune tissue function.

263
00:19:04.640 --> 00:19:08.063
in a way that previously we hadn't really seen immune cells do.

264
00:19:08.584 --> 00:19:08.844
Okay?

265
00:19:09.084 --> 00:19:16.230
So one of the things in today's topic, there's so many different ways that Tregs are doing this, where they're doing this non-immune function.

266
00:19:16.710 --> 00:19:20.013
But the thing that we'll focus on today was discovered in 2013, and...

267
00:19:22.615 --> 00:19:28.000
It shows that T-regs are really involved in muscle repair and regeneration.

268
00:19:28.040 --> 00:19:36.968
We've got a, that's the paper that came out of Harvard Medical School by Berzine and others in Nature Medicine in 2013.

269
00:19:37.008 --> 00:19:39.150
They're the ones who found a population of T-regs

270
00:19:39.730 --> 00:19:44.614
in damaged muscle cell tissue that can actually promote repair of those muscles.

271
00:19:44.914 --> 00:19:45.134
Okay.

272
00:19:45.374 --> 00:19:52.280
And the way it works is in photo four, you go, these T-Rex, they actually sit in your muscles.

273
00:19:52.540 --> 00:19:53.701
So they're tissue resident.

274
00:19:54.608 --> 00:19:57.489
instead of sort of circulating in the blood.

275
00:19:57.769 --> 00:20:01.690
A lot of times we think of immune cells as just circulating in the bloodstream, right?

276
00:20:01.770 --> 00:20:04.210
And they go and they find stuff to take care of.

277
00:20:04.590 --> 00:20:09.251
These are tissue resident T cells, Tregs, that are found in our muscle tissue.

278
00:20:09.271 --> 00:20:12.472
And what they do is they modulate the action of stem cells.

279
00:20:12.892 --> 00:20:21.354
Stem cells are the cells that don't really have an identity yet, but they lead to progenitor cells that lead to some kind of tissue cell.

280
00:20:21.574 --> 00:20:24.155
So in this case, they would become muscle progenitor cells,

281
00:20:24.675 --> 00:20:29.476
That would then become new muscle cells and repair and damage the tissue there.

282
00:20:30.317 --> 00:20:30.977
Does that make sense?

283
00:20:31.257 --> 00:20:31.617
Yes.

284
00:20:31.637 --> 00:20:31.857
Yeah.

285
00:20:32.117 --> 00:20:36.298
And these kinds of stem cells are found all over.

286
00:20:36.338 --> 00:20:37.618
They're found in our bone marrow.

287
00:20:37.638 --> 00:20:39.419
They're found in our muscles.

288
00:20:39.439 --> 00:20:40.859
They're found in our hair follicles.

289
00:20:41.259 --> 00:20:44.620
And that's actually the other thing that I wanted to highlight that's kind of cool.

290
00:20:45.080 --> 00:20:46.621
This was pretty recent.

291
00:20:46.641 --> 00:20:47.081
Yeah.

292
00:20:47.750 --> 00:21:00.919
Another way that these T-cell T-regs are doing stuff that's outside of the immune system is they become on-site repair formin for stem cells in our hair follicles.

293
00:21:01.339 --> 00:21:09.285
So they promote hair growth in our hair follicles by actually influencing the stem cells that are in there.

294
00:21:09.965 --> 00:21:11.505
that are called hair follicle stem cells.

295
00:21:11.865 --> 00:21:15.926
And those stem cells promote the growth of hair in those hair follicles, right?

296
00:21:16.226 --> 00:21:24.207
So without the Tregs actually mediating that interaction, you're not going to get hair growth in those hair follicles.

297
00:21:24.448 --> 00:21:29.108
So we can thank the cellular military police for our wonderful locks of hair.

298
00:21:29.128 --> 00:21:31.089
Yeah, they do a bunch of side jobs too, right?

299
00:21:31.369 --> 00:21:31.969
Right, right.

300
00:21:31.989 --> 00:21:37.950
Where they're just maintaining a lot of the tissue resident stem cells

301
00:21:38.770 --> 00:21:40.292
or doing whatever job that they're doing.

302
00:21:40.432 --> 00:21:46.418
So they get deployed into local cities across your body to maintain order.

303
00:21:46.878 --> 00:21:47.739
Yeah, there it is.

304
00:21:47.759 --> 00:21:48.300
There it is.

305
00:21:48.320 --> 00:21:49.241
Don't listen.

306
00:21:49.321 --> 00:21:51.343
Let's not get too triggering.

307
00:21:51.483 --> 00:21:54.746
But this was work that was done by UC Santa...

308
00:21:55.827 --> 00:21:56.588
San Francisco.

309
00:21:57.169 --> 00:22:03.696
And this was a paper in Cell in 2023 that showed that T-Rex can actually help hair follicle regeneration.

310
00:22:04.316 --> 00:22:15.608
They use something called the notch signaling pathway, which is just another, it's one of these other lock and key signaling pathways where the T-cell locks and keys into a stem cell.

311
00:22:15.648 --> 00:22:17.951
And then the stem cell is like, oh, okay, I need to start doing that.

312
00:22:18.478 --> 00:22:19.259
whatever I need to do.

313
00:22:19.519 --> 00:22:20.380
This is fascinating.

314
00:22:20.420 --> 00:22:21.401
So not only...

315
00:22:22.101 --> 00:22:29.768
The Nobel discovery was around the existence of this specific T cell type and its genomic origins.

316
00:22:30.148 --> 00:22:35.613
And then now, since those early discoveries, we've now begun to understand that...

317
00:22:36.273 --> 00:22:42.176
these regulatory T cells, these Tregs, have multiple functions.

318
00:22:42.196 --> 00:22:44.677
They're not just in the highway of the bloodstream.

319
00:22:44.937 --> 00:22:52.401
They can be in the tissue cells and actually facilitate other aspects, other processes that are independent of the immune response, which is its primary responsibility.

320
00:22:52.481 --> 00:22:53.122
Exactly, yeah.

321
00:22:53.182 --> 00:22:58.084
And that's how they were discovered, but now it turns out they've got a much larger role in our body, right?

322
00:22:58.404 --> 00:23:05.448
So it really shows why something like that deserves the Nobel Prize, like discovering this whole new class that is actually doing so much more

323
00:23:05.808 --> 00:23:09.469
than just an autoimmune response.

324
00:23:09.489 --> 00:23:12.290
Sort of, yeah, like curtailing the autoimmune response.

325
00:23:12.330 --> 00:23:13.631
Now it's doing all sorts of stuff.

326
00:23:13.671 --> 00:23:27.216
The other thing that's interesting, and this goes back to kind of what you always talk about with biology as compared to physics, where it's like the here, like, there's a lot of complexity still that we are continuing to better understand in terms of biological systems.

327
00:23:27.336 --> 00:23:28.316
Yeah.

328
00:23:29.197 --> 00:23:31.298
And there's complexity there.

329
00:23:31.338 --> 00:23:33.358
There's complexity at every level.

330
00:23:33.438 --> 00:23:34.119
It's insane.

331
00:23:34.179 --> 00:23:34.819
Biology is...

332
00:23:35.319 --> 00:23:42.342
is somehow this like hodgepodge stack of cards that is just like staying alive.

333
00:23:42.362 --> 00:23:47.343
Because everyone is making sure the cards don't fall, right?

334
00:23:47.443 --> 00:23:48.124
At every level.

335
00:23:48.864 --> 00:23:52.365
At the molecular level, at the cellular level, at the organism level.

336
00:23:52.685 --> 00:23:56.066
Then you can go into like ecosystems and there's population dynamics.

337
00:23:56.206 --> 00:23:57.187
It's an incredible...

338
00:23:57.827 --> 00:24:01.550
like hierarchy of, of being, it's, it's very cool.

339
00:24:01.570 --> 00:24:04.953
The combinatorial problem set there is, yeah, is, uh, yeah.

340
00:24:05.213 --> 00:24:05.913
One to behold.

341
00:24:06.014 --> 00:24:06.234
Yeah.

342
00:24:06.594 --> 00:24:10.837
And, and so that was again, the, the medicine Nobel from last week.

343
00:24:10.877 --> 00:24:18.543
If you haven't watched last week's episodes, we have both individual stories for each of the individual awards, as well as a collective episode with all of them.

344
00:24:18.964 --> 00:24:23.167
So you can zoom in to the subject you care about or zoom out and listen to them all.

345
00:24:23.327 --> 00:24:24.268
They're all fascinating.

346
00:24:24.908 --> 00:24:25.089
Um,

347
00:24:25.829 --> 00:24:31.332
And then so day two, which was Tuesday, was physics.

348
00:24:31.772 --> 00:24:35.094
This one was for macroscopic quantum tunneling.

349
00:24:35.114 --> 00:24:35.314
Yep.

350
00:24:36.115 --> 00:24:42.058
I will note, you know, there was some commentary about the use of the word macroscopic.

351
00:24:42.178 --> 00:24:42.458
Yeah.

352
00:24:43.039 --> 00:24:45.140
And understandably in this context...

353
00:24:45.880 --> 00:24:46.920
It is macroscopic.

354
00:24:47.020 --> 00:24:52.502
But in our everyday lived life, when we say macroscopic, we don't mean laptop macroscopic.

355
00:24:53.043 --> 00:24:54.343
It's still quite, quite small.

356
00:24:54.363 --> 00:24:56.104
This thing is still quite small, yes.

357
00:24:56.144 --> 00:24:57.944
It's at the nano micro scale.

358
00:24:58.104 --> 00:25:01.046
But it's still meaningfully different than where we were before.

359
00:25:01.106 --> 00:25:05.267
Yeah, it's still 10 to the 9, you know, 1 billion things, quantum tunneling.

360
00:25:05.647 --> 00:25:07.408
That's not a joke, right?

361
00:25:08.308 --> 00:25:12.490
It was given to John Clark, Michelle D'Avore, and John Martinez.

362
00:25:12.510 --> 00:25:12.610
Yeah.

363
00:25:13.390 --> 00:25:15.851
for their discovery of macroscopic quantum tunneling.

364
00:25:15.931 --> 00:25:19.792
It was an experiment that they had done in the 1980s at Berkeley.

365
00:25:19.832 --> 00:25:22.213
John Clark was the principal investigator at Berkeley.

366
00:25:23.093 --> 00:25:27.474
Michel Devereux was a postdoc in his lab, and John Martinez was a PhD student in his lab.

367
00:25:27.934 --> 00:25:32.776
I will be remiss to say we also call it Cal on this podcast.

368
00:25:34.577 --> 00:25:35.958
But guys, Berkeley is fine.

369
00:25:35.998 --> 00:25:39.941
But for the sake of the international audience, we will refer to it as Berkeley.

370
00:25:39.961 --> 00:25:41.302
Yeah, yeah.

371
00:25:41.422 --> 00:25:45.244
I mean, I think in science, I've almost never heard it called Cal.

372
00:25:45.324 --> 00:25:45.765
I'm sorry.

373
00:25:45.825 --> 00:25:47.926
I've been around circles in science.

374
00:25:48.527 --> 00:25:49.848
It's called Berkeley, okay?

375
00:25:49.968 --> 00:25:51.569
Go Bears in athletics.

376
00:25:51.729 --> 00:25:51.969
Yeah.

377
00:25:52.009 --> 00:25:52.890
Cal, yes.

378
00:25:52.910 --> 00:25:53.570
Cal, yeah.

379
00:25:53.730 --> 00:25:56.432
In science, we'll stay with Berkeley.

380
00:25:56.452 --> 00:25:58.614
I don't think anyone from Berkeley is pressed about it.

381
00:25:59.074 --> 00:25:59.794
Honestly.

382
00:26:00.014 --> 00:26:00.615
Okay, anyway.

383
00:26:00.635 --> 00:26:01.595
Let us know in the comments.

384
00:26:01.615 --> 00:26:03.676
Yeah, let us know.

385
00:26:03.996 --> 00:26:11.459
And in any case, like what they did was they showed that you could build and customize this kind of artificial atom in some sense, right?

386
00:26:11.799 --> 00:26:21.623
That even though it was 10 to the 9 different things that were doing this quantum tunneling, all of them collectively are obeying the Schrodinger equation.

387
00:26:22.083 --> 00:26:25.525
And so one could use this as a substrate to simulate things.

388
00:26:25.545 --> 00:26:25.825
Yeah.

389
00:26:26.652 --> 00:26:29.594
That do quantum mechanics, for example, atoms.

390
00:26:30.014 --> 00:26:32.775
And this is the central idea behind a quantum computer, right?

391
00:26:32.795 --> 00:26:39.399
It was actually first hypothesized by Richard Feynman, one of our favorite physicists, in a 1981 talk.

392
00:26:39.819 --> 00:26:43.401
The talk became a 1982 paper in the International Journal of Theoretical Physics.

393
00:26:43.621 --> 00:26:50.565
And the paper was titled, Simulating Physics with Quantum Systems, right?

394
00:26:52.000 --> 00:26:55.762
It's an incredible paper that's so forward thinking.

395
00:26:55.942 --> 00:26:58.183
And it's something very much in the style of Feynman.

396
00:26:58.563 --> 00:27:00.063
He builds it from first principles.

397
00:27:00.544 --> 00:27:05.986
And he asks, like, okay, what if I want to simulate a quantum system?

398
00:27:06.486 --> 00:27:06.666
Right.

399
00:27:06.826 --> 00:27:07.086
Okay.

400
00:27:07.766 --> 00:27:08.727
What would that take?

401
00:27:09.848 --> 00:27:11.650
And here's the math that he does.

402
00:27:11.690 --> 00:27:18.657
He says, suppose I have an interacting system of n quantum particles, okay?

403
00:27:19.177 --> 00:27:20.738
And I want to simulate all of that.

404
00:27:20.799 --> 00:27:22.560
Can I do this with a classical computer?

405
00:27:23.341 --> 00:27:25.743
Pretty soon it gets way, way out of hand.

406
00:27:26.144 --> 00:27:26.884
Okay, and here's why.

407
00:27:27.345 --> 00:27:32.009
Consider just two quantum particles that can be in two states, okay?

408
00:27:33.000 --> 00:27:34.081
Okay.

409
00:27:34.161 --> 00:27:36.283
They can be in a zero or a one, right?

410
00:27:36.584 --> 00:27:37.645
In a classical computer.

411
00:27:38.065 --> 00:27:42.449
Well, you would just have one thing be the first state and one thing be the second state.

412
00:27:42.830 --> 00:27:47.014
And then you can decide whether it's a zero or a one and you have four bits, right?

413
00:27:47.294 --> 00:27:51.078
But you can just keep track of each of the bits and, you know,

414
00:27:51.338 --> 00:27:57.999
As you grow the number of bits, it just grows linearly in terms of how much stuff you need to save.

415
00:27:58.399 --> 00:28:02.580
You need to store n bits, that's n different transistors that are storing a 0 or a 1.

416
00:28:03.381 --> 00:28:10.682
If you want to start doing quantum systems now, combinatorically, it goes insane.

417
00:28:11.542 --> 00:28:15.323
Let's imagine two quantum systems, two electrons that are spin up or spin down.

418
00:28:17.035 --> 00:28:20.376
You actually have to keep track of four different complex numbers.

419
00:28:20.836 --> 00:28:21.116
Okay.

420
00:28:21.376 --> 00:28:23.257
Each complex number is actually two numbers.

421
00:28:23.417 --> 00:28:26.978
One, how much, how much of the, how much of the number is on the real axis?

422
00:28:27.018 --> 00:28:28.958
How much of the numbers on the imaginary axis?

423
00:28:29.418 --> 00:28:32.619
And what you have to do is you have to keep track of the spin up, spin down.

424
00:28:32.999 --> 00:28:38.241
You have to keep track of the spin down, spin down, and then spin up, spin down, spin down, spin up, right?

425
00:28:38.521 --> 00:28:41.521
That's four different complex numbers that you got to keep track of.

426
00:28:41.541 --> 00:28:43.242
So that's eight different things with the,

427
00:28:43.842 --> 00:28:49.029
Three, now I've got to keep track of all eight of these spin systems.

428
00:28:49.049 --> 00:28:49.290
Yes.

429
00:28:49.350 --> 00:28:49.550
Right?

430
00:28:49.930 --> 00:28:58.662
And with n, it becomes two to the n. Two to the n different numbers that I've got to keep track of to really fully characterize a quantum system.

431
00:28:58.703 --> 00:28:59.884
Because each of these...

432
00:29:00.625 --> 00:29:03.906
each of these individual spin states are themselves distinct.

433
00:29:04.606 --> 00:29:07.207
And so I need a number for each of these distinct spin states.

434
00:29:07.247 --> 00:29:20.110
And so pretty much what ends up happening is if you scale with the number of bits, the amount of stuff that you can store in a classical computer becomes linear, but the amount of stuff you can store in a quantum computer becomes exponential.

435
00:29:20.150 --> 00:29:29.132
Because a quantum computer by design is storing all of the little values for each of the superposition of these states.

436
00:29:30.286 --> 00:29:35.268
So it was a very simple argument that Feynman made, and he did this back-of-the-envelope calculation.

437
00:29:35.368 --> 00:29:43.892
He's like, well, if you need 2 to the n numbers to keep track of a quantum state that has n things, each of those things having two states, then, you know, with...

438
00:29:45.357 --> 00:29:50.719
if you want just like 40 interacting particles with two states, that's two to the 40.

439
00:29:51.719 --> 00:30:00.542
And one real quick trick to convert two to the something into 10 to the something is to know that two to the 10 is 1024, which is about 10 to the three.

440
00:30:01.162 --> 00:30:03.663
So two to the 40 becomes about 10 to the 12.

441
00:30:04.003 --> 00:30:04.843
That's a trillion.

442
00:30:05.263 --> 00:30:09.624
That's a trillion bits that you need in your Ram, not in your hard disk.

443
00:30:09.644 --> 00:30:11.265
You need in your Ram because you're,

444
00:30:12.382 --> 00:30:14.925
you're messing with all of those numbers, right?

445
00:30:15.807 --> 00:30:16.828
In terms of computation.

446
00:30:16.848 --> 00:30:19.552
This isn't data that's being stored on a permanent basis.

447
00:30:19.652 --> 00:30:24.979
This is stuff in the middle of your computation that you're using to then calculate the new state and the new state and the new state.

448
00:30:24.999 --> 00:30:27.502
So that's a terabyte of stuff in your RAM.

449
00:30:28.343 --> 00:30:29.724
which is already a lot.

450
00:30:29.744 --> 00:30:31.585
A terabyte of RAM is quite a bit.

451
00:30:31.606 --> 00:30:33.267
I wish I had a terabyte of RAM on the computer.

452
00:30:33.287 --> 00:30:34.508
We'd have to render the episodes.

453
00:30:34.528 --> 00:30:36.669
For this stuff, yeah.

454
00:30:36.749 --> 00:30:40.372
That's reaching at the level of supercomputers.

455
00:30:40.412 --> 00:30:43.514
But 40 different things is not really what we're even talking about.

456
00:30:43.534 --> 00:30:44.975
We're trying to do 200 or 400 qubits.

457
00:30:45.075 --> 00:30:49.518
Because for a protein, for example, a protein will have on the order of 100 to 400 atoms.

458
00:30:49.538 --> 00:30:49.638
Yeah.

459
00:30:54.842 --> 00:31:00.165
that many interacting quantum states, right, for each of the little configurations that the electrons can do.

460
00:31:00.645 --> 00:31:03.847
And already at like 2 to the 200, you're getting to 10 to the 66.

461
00:31:03.967 --> 00:31:05.648
That's an insane number.

462
00:31:05.728 --> 00:31:10.631
Which is an insane number because there's only about 10 to the 80 atoms in the universe, right?

463
00:31:10.691 --> 00:31:11.611
So like what?

464
00:31:12.071 --> 00:31:15.673
Each atom in your universe is now, you know, like you can't make transistors.

465
00:31:15.734 --> 00:31:16.454
Yeah, it's not feasible.

466
00:31:16.574 --> 00:31:17.575
It's not feasible anymore.

467
00:31:17.615 --> 00:31:17.835
So...

468
00:31:18.675 --> 00:31:29.263
That was the main impetus, and it was sort of introduced by Feynman in the 1980s, to start thinking about what if we wanted to do quantum simulations?

469
00:31:29.663 --> 00:31:33.186
We would really need a quantum computer in order to do it.

470
00:31:33.787 --> 00:31:42.273
Classical systems don't have basically the horsepower to be able to sustain as you get to more complex simulations.

471
00:31:42.373 --> 00:31:43.854
Yeah, exactly.

472
00:31:43.874 --> 00:31:47.778
And so we need a computer that's made out of quantum bits, right?

473
00:31:48.278 --> 00:31:59.508
And this is where the superconducting circuits that won the Nobel Prize, they sort of became a leading platform because the superconducting circuit itself can now...

474
00:32:00.148 --> 00:32:01.609
have these quantum behaviors.

475
00:32:01.929 --> 00:32:06.453
And so you can use that as your two-state system that encodes a zero and a one.

476
00:32:06.733 --> 00:32:09.835
And that's what sort of I want to get into is just a little bit of background.

477
00:32:09.855 --> 00:32:13.999
We can't cover all of it because that's going to be an episode in itself that maybe we can do.

478
00:32:14.339 --> 00:32:22.205
But I just wanted to give you a little bit of a starter on why superconducting qubits became like this sort of

479
00:32:23.614 --> 00:32:26.976
ubiquitous method of making a quantum computer.

480
00:32:27.277 --> 00:32:30.939
And this is the Josephson Junction circus.

481
00:32:30.999 --> 00:32:37.364
Yeah, this is exactly the Josephson Junction stuff that we talked about on the episode that became a qubit in itself.

482
00:32:37.524 --> 00:32:51.054
So a good primer, if you haven't already watched our Nobel Prize episode on physics, would be to watch that, because we go into very good detail from first principles about what is a Josephson Junction, which is important to understand, like...

483
00:32:51.734 --> 00:32:55.156
why this fundamentally is a workable solution to the problem.

484
00:32:55.176 --> 00:32:55.777
Yes, exactly.

485
00:32:55.797 --> 00:32:55.977
Yeah.

486
00:32:56.257 --> 00:32:56.457
Yeah.

487
00:32:56.517 --> 00:32:58.278
But we'll give you a tiny primer here.

488
00:32:59.059 --> 00:33:01.060
We'll start with just an LC circuit.

489
00:33:01.240 --> 00:33:01.501
Okay.

490
00:33:01.821 --> 00:33:11.467
An LC circuit is something that I think anyone who's taken an undergrad physics class, the second semester you go into AC circuits, which is analog circuits.

491
00:33:12.148 --> 00:33:14.269
And an LC circuit is very simple.

492
00:33:14.289 --> 00:33:15.110
There's a capacitor.

493
00:33:15.130 --> 00:33:15.710
Yeah.

494
00:33:16.015 --> 00:33:16.896
And there's an inductor.

495
00:33:17.036 --> 00:33:22.220
A capacitor is a configuration of metals, basically, that lets you store charge.

496
00:33:22.641 --> 00:33:27.565
And an inductor is like a coil of stuff that lets you create magnetic fields.

497
00:33:27.985 --> 00:33:28.946
And you can charge it up.

498
00:33:29.347 --> 00:33:30.968
And you can de-charge the magnetic field.

499
00:33:31.068 --> 00:33:35.012
It becomes a little battery in some sense.

500
00:33:35.072 --> 00:33:35.332
Okay?

501
00:33:35.752 --> 00:33:39.476
And if you hook up a capacitor to an inductor...

502
00:33:40.116 --> 00:33:42.257
And you charge up the capacitor and then you turn on the switch.

503
00:33:42.677 --> 00:33:47.859
What's going to end up happening is the capacitor is going to discharge because it's storing a bunch of charge.

504
00:33:47.879 --> 00:33:55.142
But then the circuit is going to be like, oh, there's a way for me to for the charge to rebalance as it as it rebalances.

505
00:33:55.162 --> 00:33:56.503
That's going to create a current.

506
00:33:57.023 --> 00:34:07.174
in my loop, that current is going to turn on and then create a magnetic field in my inductor, which is going to become like a kind of battery that's going to reverse the circuit.

507
00:34:07.434 --> 00:34:08.935
And the circuit is going to go the other way.

508
00:34:09.316 --> 00:34:11.618
And then it's going to go one way and then it's going to go the other way.

509
00:34:11.958 --> 00:34:17.965
And this charging and discharging of the capacitor and the charging and discharging of the inductor becomes a sort of,

510
00:34:18.445 --> 00:34:19.646
simple harmonic oscillator.

511
00:34:19.686 --> 00:34:21.768
This is ubiquitous in physics.

512
00:34:21.808 --> 00:34:23.849
We love simple harmonic oscillators, okay?

513
00:34:24.109 --> 00:34:26.791
Because everything is a pendulum in some sense, right?

514
00:34:27.091 --> 00:34:34.717
Everything is around some energy minima, and it oscillates as it goes from one part to the other part of that energy minima.

515
00:34:35.157 --> 00:34:37.619
And that's what an LC circuit becomes.

516
00:34:37.659 --> 00:34:39.180
It becomes a simple harmonic oscillator.

517
00:34:39.260 --> 00:34:46.186
Now, you take anything at the classical level, in this case an LC circuit, which is a simple harmonic

518
00:34:49.375 --> 00:34:58.324
First of all, this circuit is going to become superconducting, meaning that there's going to be no resistance, which means this guy, this circuit is just going to keep going.

519
00:34:58.805 --> 00:35:02.349
There's no Joule heating involved, and so it's not going to lose any energy.

520
00:35:03.009 --> 00:35:06.093
So this thing can keep going as an oscillation, right?

521
00:35:06.753 --> 00:35:15.419
And in anyone who's taken first semester quantum mechanics usually goes through the Griffiths quantum mechanics textbook.

522
00:35:15.739 --> 00:35:16.840
And this is the cartoon they have.

523
00:35:16.860 --> 00:35:23.765
They show Schrodinger's cat going up and down a ladder and all the ladders, the rungs of the ladders are equally spaced.

524
00:35:24.325 --> 00:35:29.169
And what this guy is doing is going up and down the energy states of a quantum harmonic oscillator.

525
00:35:29.489 --> 00:35:33.612
In a classical harmonic oscillator, you can in a classical harmonic oscillator.

526
00:35:34.846 --> 00:35:37.228
My pendulum can be in any state, right?

527
00:35:37.969 --> 00:35:38.789
It can go up.

528
00:35:38.929 --> 00:35:41.371
And if I push the pendulum more, it'll have a higher amplitude.

529
00:35:41.391 --> 00:35:42.712
This is like you want to swing, right?

530
00:35:43.313 --> 00:35:45.475
You can have arbitrarily low amount of energy.

531
00:35:45.715 --> 00:35:48.857
You can just sit on the swing stationary with no swinging.

532
00:35:49.258 --> 00:35:50.239
Or you can have a little bit.

533
00:35:50.319 --> 00:35:52.320
If you push a little bit more, you can have a little bit more.

534
00:35:52.921 --> 00:35:53.121
Um,

535
00:35:53.461 --> 00:36:06.388
In a quantum harmonic oscillator, though, quantum mechanics takes over, and there are discrete energy levels where the quantum harmonic oscillator will have a certain frequency, or it'll have a little bit more frequency, or it'll have a little bit more frequency.

536
00:36:06.488 --> 00:36:15.193
And each of those frequencies of oscillation is tied to an energy just by h-bar omega, right?

537
00:36:15.554 --> 00:36:15.734
And...

538
00:36:16.632 --> 00:36:21.713
The key with a quantum harmonic oscillator is the rungs of that ladder are equally spaced.

539
00:36:22.314 --> 00:36:25.234
Now, this is cool for a quantum harmonic oscillator.

540
00:36:25.294 --> 00:36:28.415
It becomes a problem if we want to make a quantum computer out of it.

541
00:36:29.015 --> 00:36:31.236
Because what we want are just two states.

542
00:36:31.796 --> 00:36:35.397
And we want to be able to reliably go between one state and the other.

543
00:36:35.737 --> 00:36:42.479
But imagine if the energy difference between zero and one is the same as the energy difference between one and two.

544
00:36:46.580 --> 00:36:48.021
it could go to 2.

545
00:36:48.081 --> 00:36:48.782
We don't want that.

546
00:36:48.842 --> 00:36:52.465
We want it to be fixed within 0 and 1.

547
00:36:52.966 --> 00:36:57.650
And so what we do is we add a Josephson junction to our superconducting circuit.

548
00:36:57.910 --> 00:37:01.133
And what that does is, so on the left we've got a perfect parabola.

549
00:37:01.373 --> 00:37:04.917
That's our omega x squared, which is...

550
00:37:06.008 --> 00:37:08.490
A perfect parabola, that's our simple harmonic oscillator.

551
00:37:08.790 --> 00:37:09.030
Okay?

552
00:37:09.310 --> 00:37:10.211
That's like Hooke's Law.

553
00:37:10.271 --> 00:37:12.773
You know, a spring and a mass on a spring.

554
00:37:13.093 --> 00:37:15.094
The energy of that thing is one half kx squared.

555
00:37:15.134 --> 00:37:19.177
Similarly, if you have a parabola, then you get a perfect pendulum.

556
00:37:19.477 --> 00:37:20.398
That's what we don't want.

557
00:37:20.758 --> 00:37:23.320
So when we add a Josephson junction...

558
00:37:24.233 --> 00:37:32.919
to our LC circuit, then what ends up happening is you add a cosine term to that parabola.

559
00:37:33.279 --> 00:37:37.442
And that cosine is very much like a parabola in the bottom, right?

560
00:37:37.462 --> 00:37:44.446
If you zoom in close to its minima, it's going to be like a parabola, but it's going to add a little bit of wiggle on the outside.

561
00:37:44.466 --> 00:37:46.288
And that's what's called an anharmonicity.

562
00:37:46.308 --> 00:37:46.688
Right.

563
00:37:46.788 --> 00:37:54.435
which means we've gone from a harmonic, simple harmonic oscillator, to an harmonic oscillator that has a tiny bit of a difference in that parabola.

564
00:37:54.755 --> 00:38:03.663
And what that does is now our ladders, it's still a ladder, but the rungs of the ladder are no longer equally spaced in energy.

565
00:38:03.963 --> 00:38:06.726
And so what I can do is now tune my poking...

566
00:38:08.152 --> 00:38:14.414
so that it only resonates to that 0-1 transition, and it doesn't resonate with anything else.

567
00:38:14.554 --> 00:38:19.956
And so I can reliably now control whether it's in a 0 and a 1, and I can switch it from a 0 to a 1.

568
00:38:20.276 --> 00:38:22.796
And that's where this Josephson junction comes in.

569
00:38:23.076 --> 00:38:31.959
It adds that little cosine magic that turns my perfect quantum harmonic oscillator into something that I can manage as a two-state system.

570
00:38:32.385 --> 00:38:41.674
Which is required in order to make a quantum computer operate in the way in which we needed to to get tangible, to have it operational.

571
00:38:41.954 --> 00:38:44.937
Yeah, we want a two-state system at all times for a quantum.

572
00:38:45.037 --> 00:38:47.439
I mean, we like bits, right?

573
00:38:48.080 --> 00:38:52.264
And the simplest logic you can do is with a bit, a two-state system.

574
00:38:52.864 --> 00:38:53.005
Yeah.

575
00:38:53.565 --> 00:38:59.727
This was first actually implemented at Tokyo by Nakamura and his colleagues in a Nature paper in 1999.

576
00:39:00.167 --> 00:39:03.568
And that's what sort of started the field of superconducting qubits.

577
00:39:04.168 --> 00:39:05.388
And it's come a long way, right?

578
00:39:05.488 --> 00:39:12.590
And now one of the papers that I wanted to highlight was the big paper in 2019 by the Google team.

579
00:39:13.250 --> 00:39:17.491
John Martinez was involved in the hardware leadership team.

580
00:39:17.871 --> 00:39:27.358
And they published in Nature in October 2019 with an experiment titled quantum supremacy using a programmable superconducting processor.

581
00:39:27.438 --> 00:39:28.619
This was a very big deal.

582
00:39:28.679 --> 00:39:30.840
They're claiming quantum supremacy.

583
00:39:30.900 --> 00:39:35.844
Quantum supremacy is the idea that we have done something now with a quantum computer.

584
00:39:36.777 --> 00:39:42.362
That cannot be done with a classical computer no matter how long you wait.

585
00:39:43.122 --> 00:39:43.423
Okay?

586
00:39:44.203 --> 00:39:45.144
Not no matter how long.

587
00:39:45.444 --> 00:39:48.627
They said something like a million years.

588
00:39:49.048 --> 00:39:49.308
Okay?

589
00:39:49.568 --> 00:39:50.269
Something crazy.

590
00:39:50.609 --> 00:39:53.231
And they were like, we did this in 200 seconds.

591
00:39:53.291 --> 00:39:55.273
That would have taken a million years to do.

592
00:39:55.393 --> 00:39:59.216
The point is, in a classical system, it would be so far beyond the...

593
00:40:00.157 --> 00:40:03.420
life cycle of humans, that it's irrelevant.

594
00:40:03.440 --> 00:40:03.560
Yeah.

595
00:40:03.600 --> 00:40:04.841
It's do it in a million years.

596
00:40:04.861 --> 00:40:05.121
Yeah.

597
00:40:05.181 --> 00:40:05.381
Yeah.

598
00:40:05.441 --> 00:40:07.803
It's like, it's something that we could not do.

599
00:40:08.423 --> 00:40:09.885
Okay.

600
00:40:10.465 --> 00:40:16.109
Now what they did was they designed a random quantum circuit sampling task.

601
00:40:16.570 --> 00:40:20.212
And this is where their claim met some scrutiny.

602
00:40:20.513 --> 00:40:20.773
Okay.

603
00:40:20.813 --> 00:40:25.657
Because the task that they're saying they did that a classical computer couldn't do was itself a,

604
00:40:26.520 --> 00:40:29.148
a quantum task in some sense.

605
00:40:29.168 --> 00:40:31.976
So, so you're, maybe you're gearing the problem,

606
00:40:33.122 --> 00:40:34.463
for the hardware that you have.

607
00:40:34.823 --> 00:40:41.088
And that's not completely out of precedent, but you can understand if their competitors were like, yeah, you know, it doesn't count.

608
00:40:41.108 --> 00:40:41.328
Yeah.

609
00:40:41.368 --> 00:40:41.568
Yeah.

610
00:40:41.588 --> 00:40:42.108
It doesn't count.

611
00:40:42.128 --> 00:40:51.315
But in any case, they said that this is like, you know, the, the, the burden of proof is I've done something that a classical computer can't do.

612
00:40:51.895 --> 00:40:52.075
Right.

613
00:40:52.296 --> 00:40:59.180
Quantum simulation is another thing that Feynman came up with that is obviously by design, something a classical computer can't do.

614
00:40:59.401 --> 00:40:59.581
Yes.

615
00:40:59.761 --> 00:40:59.961
Right.

616
00:41:00.161 --> 00:41:02.403
So it's not, it's not that like weird for me.

617
00:41:02.423 --> 00:41:02.883
Yeah.

618
00:41:03.724 --> 00:41:07.086
They've got a 53 qubit computer, okay?

619
00:41:07.126 --> 00:41:08.767
54 physical qubits.

620
00:41:09.128 --> 00:41:13.590
That's in a sort of nice chess board pattern.

621
00:41:14.471 --> 00:41:19.514
Each of the qubits talks to four of its neighbors using a coupler.

622
00:41:20.775 --> 00:41:22.576
And it's all in a 2D grid.

623
00:41:22.856 --> 00:41:24.597
Their chip was called the Syncomore chip.

624
00:41:25.278 --> 00:41:25.458
It's...

625
00:41:27.354 --> 00:41:34.498
54 physical qubits, tiny, tiny chip that's inside of a giant dilution refrigerator, like those chandelier stuff that we were talking about.

626
00:41:34.739 --> 00:41:39.101
It's got to be cooled down to where these things can be superconducting and they can do all of those things.

627
00:41:39.742 --> 00:41:44.985
And their claim was that this quantum device could sample, i.e.

628
00:41:45.045 --> 00:41:52.910
could produce these bit strings from a quantum distribution, from a probability distribution that was inherently quantum

629
00:41:53.790 --> 00:42:00.034
And in 200 seconds, they could produce enough bit strings to totally characterize this probability distribution.

630
00:42:00.475 --> 00:42:00.755
Okay.

631
00:42:01.115 --> 00:42:07.399
And they estimated that a classical supercomputer, like this is a big supercomputer, would require 10,000 years to do the same.

632
00:42:07.720 --> 00:42:07.960
Okay.

633
00:42:08.220 --> 00:42:15.385
And they did some cross-entropy benchmarking to show, like, for smaller number of qubits that this would work and how that thing would scale.

634
00:42:16.265 --> 00:42:17.286
And so that was their main thing.

635
00:42:17.306 --> 00:42:19.287
They were like, look, we did this in 200 seconds.

636
00:42:19.587 --> 00:42:24.950
This would require 10,000 years on a supercomputer, a million years on a normal computer, like blah, blah, blah.

637
00:42:25.930 --> 00:42:27.051
Okay.

638
00:42:27.551 --> 00:42:32.614
It's sort of outperforming these classical algorithms, right?

639
00:42:32.754 --> 00:42:35.895
IBM claps back because IBM is the other big...

640
00:42:38.649 --> 00:42:40.372
in the field of superconducting circuits.

641
00:42:40.772 --> 00:42:48.806
So shortly after the Google announcement, they published this blog post that, you know, it's not that hard.

642
00:42:48.987 --> 00:42:49.207
Yeah.

643
00:42:50.171 --> 00:42:51.972
Their first thing was like 10,000 years.

644
00:42:53.052 --> 00:42:56.353
And they made a better classical simulation.

645
00:42:57.114 --> 00:43:03.416
They outlined a better way to do that classical simulation that would take 2.5 days, not 10,000 years.

646
00:43:03.636 --> 00:43:04.896
So they kind of undercut.

647
00:43:04.916 --> 00:43:05.957
They were like, well.

648
00:43:06.037 --> 00:43:06.397
Yeah.

649
00:43:06.557 --> 00:43:07.137
Yeah.

650
00:43:07.237 --> 00:43:13.739
It's like, well, you didn't use the latest sort of classical algorithm to benchmark how good your quantum computer was.

651
00:43:14.240 --> 00:43:17.861
You know, 2.5 days is still not 200 seconds, which is what Google did.

652
00:43:17.881 --> 00:43:18.001
Right.

653
00:43:18.021 --> 00:43:18.181
Right.

654
00:43:18.261 --> 00:43:20.282
But it's also not 10,000 years.

655
00:43:20.642 --> 00:43:23.002
So they were saying, you know, you shouldn't say quantum supremacy.

656
00:43:23.042 --> 00:43:24.563
You should say quantum advantage.

657
00:43:25.023 --> 00:43:25.783
At this point, yeah.

658
00:43:25.823 --> 00:43:30.064
It's like they're pressed because this is a big deal still, right?

659
00:43:30.444 --> 00:43:39.927
And if you think about just also just economically from the business context, IBM has been struggling to survive both in chips –

660
00:43:41.247 --> 00:43:44.809
in its clientele base in terms of being dominated.

661
00:43:44.829 --> 00:43:51.252
They are being pressed by Google, by NVIDIA, by AMD, in all avenues of their business.

662
00:43:51.352 --> 00:43:53.673
And they've made a big push in the quantum...

663
00:43:54.742 --> 00:44:17.482
place you know and so they had to say something yeah they had to yeah and i mean the other things that they did talk about is like the the paper itself is quite self-aggrandizing like the 2019 paper in nature says quantum processors have thus reached the regime of quantum supremacy we expect that their computational power will continue to grow at a double exponential rate i mean that's that's

664
00:44:18.842 --> 00:44:20.003
You know, that's a lot.

665
00:44:20.344 --> 00:44:25.289
That's saying a lot that maybe you shouldn't say in a scientific paper, and maybe the press should say that, right?

666
00:44:25.509 --> 00:44:26.229
But, so...

667
00:44:27.093 --> 00:44:28.734
There's still ongoing scrutiny.

668
00:44:28.774 --> 00:44:37.759
There's some papers that say that they've improved the classical simulation algorithms to decrease that gap even further.

669
00:44:39.480 --> 00:44:45.043
There's philosophical critiques about, well, should we really say supremacy and all this other kind of stuff?

670
00:44:45.363 --> 00:44:47.645
So it's still an ongoing debate.

671
00:44:47.805 --> 00:44:53.408
And meanwhile, the field of quantum computing just forges forward with these superconducting circuits.

672
00:44:53.988 --> 00:44:55.169
It's going to be very exciting.

673
00:44:55.549 --> 00:45:12.940
I think the implications of, you know, stepping back from some of the corporate intransigence, the implications are that we now have computing systems that have a capability set to simulate massively complex systems.

674
00:45:14.111 --> 00:45:20.216
concepts, environments, at a degree that we don't have the capability for in classical systems.

675
00:45:20.817 --> 00:45:23.780
And there are a variety of use cases that you can imagine.

676
00:45:23.800 --> 00:45:29.224
A lot of times people talk about, oh, it's going to break encryption because you can just, you know, brute force hack, blah, blah.

677
00:45:29.465 --> 00:45:31.867
That's like the low-hanging fruit of implications.

678
00:45:31.887 --> 00:45:32.748
But you can imagine...

679
00:45:33.568 --> 00:45:35.871
you know, simulating biological systems.

680
00:45:35.891 --> 00:45:37.173
That's what I'm most excited about.

681
00:45:37.193 --> 00:45:37.413
Right.

682
00:45:37.473 --> 00:45:37.673
Right.

683
00:45:37.773 --> 00:45:43.981
It's like the, the breaking encryption is like fine, I guess, from a national security point of view or whatever.

684
00:45:44.061 --> 00:45:48.526
But for me, it's like doing quantum simulation, the dream that Feynman had originally, right.

685
00:45:48.887 --> 00:45:49.087
Right.

686
00:45:49.187 --> 00:45:53.052
Of like now imagine you, you've got a new idea for a material, right.

687
00:45:53.939 --> 00:45:59.742
It's incredibly hard to simulate the physics of a material now because of this problem of exponential blowup.

688
00:46:00.062 --> 00:46:06.144
Well, now, what if we could just, you know, put in, we know where the positions of all the electrons are.

689
00:46:06.505 --> 00:46:11.867
We can create this molecular Hamiltonian that tells you how the physics of that molecule is going to work.

690
00:46:11.887 --> 00:46:17.209
And then we put that into a computer and we try to see things like, okay, what is the base energy?

691
00:46:17.229 --> 00:46:18.570
What is the conductivity of this thing?

692
00:46:18.950 --> 00:46:28.596
Imagine finding a room temperature superconductor by just hypothesizing all of the different materials that it could be, putting it into the quantum computer and having it tell us, hey, is this thing superconducting or not?

693
00:46:29.156 --> 00:46:36.041
There's huge implications in material science and drug discovery, in personalized healthcare.

694
00:46:36.121 --> 00:46:38.522
It's hard to figure.

695
00:46:40.203 --> 00:46:40.824
Make a list.

696
00:46:40.964 --> 00:46:41.545
Yeah.

697
00:46:41.785 --> 00:46:46.851
You know, it is as fundamental as, you know, vacuum tubes giving us computing for the first time.

698
00:46:46.891 --> 00:46:49.934
It's as fundamental as the move to mobile, as the internet.

699
00:46:49.995 --> 00:46:51.937
It's just in terms of you can only...

700
00:46:53.545 --> 00:47:02.713
It's hard to even imagine all the use cases we could do with it because it's sort of an infinite canvas of opportunity.

701
00:47:02.793 --> 00:47:04.975
I always find the quantum space so fascinating.

702
00:47:05.035 --> 00:47:05.255
Yeah.

703
00:47:05.835 --> 00:47:09.238
And then I guess the last one we did was chemistry.

704
00:47:09.499 --> 00:47:09.779
Yes.

705
00:47:09.819 --> 00:47:12.001
The last follow-up was for chemistry.

706
00:47:12.021 --> 00:47:14.242
This was on metal organic frameworks.

707
00:47:15.063 --> 00:47:17.805
And it was our third day.

708
00:47:17.826 --> 00:47:17.926
Yeah.

709
00:47:20.087 --> 00:47:45.019
of waking up at 2 30 in the morning yeah but it was equally as interesting uh and it was one that i had the least amount of basis for understanding i think someone made an interesting comment that was like chemistry never gets the love that it deserves yeah how like important and crazy yeah the stuff we do and it is so we're making sure that uh shout out to all the chemists out there yeah that chemistry some of the most important sort of nobel prizes have come in chemistry right

710
00:47:45.419 --> 00:47:47.402
We're going to make sure you guys get your Just Desserts here.

711
00:47:47.762 --> 00:47:48.503
And so, yes.

712
00:47:48.624 --> 00:47:52.669
So chemistry was our last prize that we covered last week.

713
00:47:52.689 --> 00:47:54.711
Yes, this was for metal organic frameworks.

714
00:47:54.771 --> 00:48:01.841
It was given to Susumu Kitagawa at Kyoto, Richard Robson at Melbourne, and Omar Yagi at Berkeley.

715
00:48:01.901 --> 00:48:03.282
Omar Yagi is someone that I called...

716
00:48:03.883 --> 00:48:04.143
Yes.

717
00:48:04.804 --> 00:48:05.725
I totally predicted that.

718
00:48:05.886 --> 00:48:09.070
And next year, we're going to do a more crazy prediction show.

719
00:48:09.090 --> 00:48:14.536
We're going to try to get some partnerships with, I don't know, maybe we'll do, what is it?

720
00:48:14.637 --> 00:48:15.357
Poly Market.

721
00:48:15.398 --> 00:48:15.738
Yeah.

722
00:48:15.798 --> 00:48:17.300
Maybe we'll get Kalshi.

723
00:48:17.540 --> 00:48:18.241
Yeah.

724
00:48:18.321 --> 00:48:19.683
One of the prediction markets out there.

725
00:48:19.763 --> 00:48:21.585
Yeah, that'll be hilarious.

726
00:48:21.725 --> 00:48:26.029
But Omar Yagi specifically, we're going to focus on some of his follow-ups.

727
00:48:27.111 --> 00:48:32.696
He made MOF5, which was the really big deal, Metal Organic Framework, right?

728
00:48:32.977 --> 00:48:37.942
This thing had a single gram, had several football fields worth of surface area.

729
00:48:38.522 --> 00:48:38.702
And...

730
00:48:39.513 --> 00:48:45.557
We got a lot of questions in the comments, actually, about like, what does that even mean for a molecule to have surface area?

731
00:48:45.637 --> 00:48:50.960
And this was something that I sort of had an idea what they were talking about, but I wanted to dig deeper.

732
00:48:51.040 --> 00:48:58.785
So, you know, my initial inclination was that they're basically talking about how much area...

733
00:48:59.485 --> 00:49:03.748
is available for interactions at a molecular level, right?

734
00:49:03.928 --> 00:49:13.173
When we think about adsorption of molecules, this is a 2D surface interacting with molecules and absorbing it and making it stick, right?

735
00:49:13.373 --> 00:49:16.155
Instead of absorption with a B, which is...

736
00:49:17.235 --> 00:49:20.736
a 3D way of absorbing molecules.

737
00:49:21.056 --> 00:49:27.558
So at a 2D level, how much surface area is available for interaction with other chemistry?

738
00:49:27.918 --> 00:49:28.618
That's the idea.

739
00:49:28.978 --> 00:49:31.359
And the analogy you can use is like a parking garage, right?

740
00:49:31.899 --> 00:49:36.140
It's a single building, but it has an insane amount of surface area.

741
00:49:36.440 --> 00:49:40.261
It's packing like five or six parking lots into a single 3D structure.

742
00:49:40.601 --> 00:49:42.302
And so you can park a bunch of cars there, right?

743
00:49:42.602 --> 00:49:45.003
And in this case, we're calculating the surface area.

744
00:49:45.023 --> 00:49:45.823
We're using how much...

745
00:49:46.543 --> 00:49:50.946
surface area is available for parking other chemical stuff.

746
00:49:51.447 --> 00:49:51.687
Okay?

747
00:49:52.307 --> 00:50:00.834
One of the ways that they do this to calculate the actual surface area is by using liquid nitrogen and nitrogen gas adsorption.

748
00:50:01.174 --> 00:50:02.315
So here what they do is...

749
00:50:03.180 --> 00:50:09.046
They take your sample and they cool it down with liquid nitrogen so that it's super cold.

750
00:50:09.447 --> 00:50:19.778
And then they run nitrogen gas over it and they see how much nitrogen gas is gone from the sample and gone into the sample.

751
00:50:21.023 --> 00:50:29.067
And from that, you get this curve where on the x-axis, you vary the amount of nitrogen that you're putting in, that you're exposing that MOF to.

752
00:50:29.487 --> 00:50:35.590
And on the y-axis, you get, okay, how much nitrogen gas volume-wise was absorbed by this compound.

753
00:50:35.850 --> 00:50:48.537
And then you can fit something called the Browner-Emmett-Teller equation, the BET equation, which then calculates how much volume has been absorbed to create a monolayer, a single layer of N2 on this thing.

754
00:50:49.297 --> 00:50:52.239
Which would it be the equivalent of a single level of the parking garage?

755
00:50:52.399 --> 00:50:53.220
Yeah, exactly.

756
00:50:53.280 --> 00:50:56.222
It's like a single, it's the amount of stuff, exactly.

757
00:50:56.242 --> 00:51:00.825
And then the more pressure you put in, the more molecules are going to get absorbed.

758
00:51:00.905 --> 00:51:09.570
And then from this, you can figure out, okay, what is the constant amount of surface area that is needed to show this dynamics of how much is being absorbed?

759
00:51:09.850 --> 00:51:11.371
And that's where you get this 3,000...

760
00:51:14.293 --> 00:51:15.534
Square meters per gram.

761
00:51:15.554 --> 00:51:16.094
Per gram.

762
00:51:16.155 --> 00:51:18.296
Like several football fields per gram.

763
00:51:18.596 --> 00:51:27.203
It's because the amount of stuff that this one gram of thing is absorbing, the amount of nitrogen that this thing is absorbing...

764
00:51:28.348 --> 00:51:37.332
would be equivalent of if I had a football field of nitrogen absorbing area, and that's how much nitrogen was absorbed.

765
00:51:37.793 --> 00:51:51.519
And so part of the idea here is like, you know, we've engineered the space of the parking garage to be maximally efficient for the number of cars that can park at any given level at any given time.

766
00:51:51.659 --> 00:51:54.921
So you can imagine a parking garage with double wide spaces.

767
00:51:54.941 --> 00:51:55.141
Yeah.

768
00:51:55.161 --> 00:51:55.321
Yeah.

769
00:51:55.961 --> 00:52:07.805
And we've created the minimal amount of space for any individual molecule car to be able to park to maximize the amount of cars that can be parked at each level.

770
00:52:07.845 --> 00:52:08.525
Yeah, exactly.

771
00:52:08.565 --> 00:52:10.826
And sometimes maybe you do want the double wide spaces.

772
00:52:10.846 --> 00:52:12.286
So then there's MOFs that do that.

773
00:52:12.526 --> 00:52:12.666
Right.

774
00:52:12.686 --> 00:52:14.087
That only work for larger vehicles.

775
00:52:14.547 --> 00:52:15.867
Right, like for CO2, right?

776
00:52:15.907 --> 00:52:20.429
CO2 is slightly larger than N2, but you want to absorb that and not the N2.

777
00:52:20.729 --> 00:52:22.149
So then there's other ways of doing it.

778
00:52:22.189 --> 00:52:23.610
But exactly, it's tunable.

779
00:52:24.370 --> 00:52:26.530
The space of the parking garage is tunable.

780
00:52:27.371 --> 00:52:28.251
It's very cool.

781
00:52:28.551 --> 00:52:31.652
And the other question that we were getting a lot, and this is something that I was also...

782
00:52:32.472 --> 00:52:55.142
interested in is you know how do you make these things in a lab right how do you make these things and i was briefly in um a chemistry lab at ucla when i was doing rotations um from one lab to the other to figure out what i want to do my phd physics in this was a lab that was actively doing cryo electron microscopy to find um you know

783
00:52:56.503 --> 00:52:58.825
the structures of giant proteins.

784
00:52:59.626 --> 00:53:05.571
And in that my advisor at the time, she said, you know, chemistry is a lot like cooking.

785
00:53:06.191 --> 00:53:06.472
Okay.

786
00:53:06.772 --> 00:53:18.722
And that there's only, there's, there's a few techniques that you have and you have to be extremely good at figuring out which techniques you want to do and the order in which you want to put them in order to actually make your chemistry happen.

787
00:53:19.063 --> 00:53:21.705
But it is really like cooking because you've got standard tools, right?

788
00:53:21.725 --> 00:53:22.346
You've got heat,

789
00:53:23.506 --> 00:53:24.387
You can heat up stuff.

790
00:53:24.407 --> 00:53:26.329
You can cool down stuff.

791
00:53:26.529 --> 00:53:30.312
You can mix stuff together, and you can stir stuff together.

792
00:53:30.773 --> 00:53:37.519
Every once in a while, you have fancy techniques, like if you want to do creme brulee or whatever that thing is with a blowtorch, right?

793
00:53:37.579 --> 00:53:42.323
And you're like, every once in a while, or you want to electrically shock stuff for some reason.

794
00:53:43.384 --> 00:53:48.248
But most of it is basically mixing, heating, letting it sit.

795
00:53:48.929 --> 00:53:51.413
all of the techniques that we use in the kitchen to make a really good meal.

796
00:53:51.653 --> 00:53:51.833
Right.

797
00:53:51.873 --> 00:53:54.257
And that's, what's happening in chemistry, like in the lab, you,

798
00:53:55.214 --> 00:53:56.375
That's what you have.

799
00:53:57.215 --> 00:54:01.458
And so MOFs are created by this process called solvothermal synthesis.

800
00:54:01.839 --> 00:54:02.099
Okay?

801
00:54:02.679 --> 00:54:05.802
Effectively, what you're doing is you're mixing together metal salts.

802
00:54:06.062 --> 00:54:08.684
Think like zinc nitrate.

803
00:54:08.704 --> 00:54:13.167
You've got copper, zirconium, and chlorine together.

804
00:54:13.607 --> 00:54:20.152
You mix that in with your organic linker, which is the linker between the things that makes that cube happen.

805
00:54:20.792 --> 00:54:22.574
And these can be like carboxylates,

806
00:54:23.533 --> 00:54:25.274
organic molecules.

807
00:54:25.635 --> 00:54:26.956
You've got some kind of solvent.

808
00:54:27.056 --> 00:54:30.018
Usually that's DMF, which is dimethylformamide.

809
00:54:30.598 --> 00:54:32.920
This is pretty toxic solvent.

810
00:54:33.160 --> 00:54:36.162
You can also now, there's techniques that are using ethanol or water.

811
00:54:36.603 --> 00:54:38.804
And then what you do is you mix them up.

812
00:54:39.325 --> 00:54:45.109
You heat them in a sealed vessel for 250 degrees Celsius.

813
00:54:45.369 --> 00:54:50.893
You can heat them up for hours to days in these vessels that are like Teflon-lined autoclaves.

814
00:54:50.953 --> 00:54:52.054
Autoclaves are like ways to

815
00:54:53.224 --> 00:54:57.167
to make high pressure, high temperature reactions happen.

816
00:54:57.667 --> 00:54:59.249
And then you can cool them slowly.

817
00:54:59.309 --> 00:55:03.952
The idea is to cool them very slowly so that that promotes the crystalline growth.

818
00:55:04.093 --> 00:55:15.862
As you cool, the chemicals are now going to start forming in this energetically favorable way where the organic linkers are going to find the metal, and then the metal are going to find more organic linkers, and you're going to grow this MOF.

819
00:55:16.302 --> 00:55:19.122
out of a tiny seedling of stuff.

820
00:55:19.383 --> 00:55:33.965
The mix has the prerequisites such that when you apply heat and then apply cooling, the end result is what is planned for based on the amount of heat applied, the period of time the heat is applied, the amount of cooling that's applied, the period of time that the cooling is applied.

821
00:55:34.245 --> 00:55:45.207
So it's going to fall into place based on just the mix, how it's mixed, the proportions of each component part, and that sort of heating and cooling cycle.

822
00:55:45.287 --> 00:55:45.727
Exactly.

823
00:55:45.767 --> 00:55:48.870
And that's why I'm telling you it's like a lot like cooking, right?

824
00:55:48.910 --> 00:56:01.239
Because if the bread is underproved, if people watch The Great British Baking Show, which I love, if the bread is underproved or overproved, it becomes like stodgy and whatever.

825
00:56:01.840 --> 00:56:05.042
So everything has to go perfect for all of this to happen, right?

826
00:56:05.583 --> 00:56:07.384
And so it really is like a cooking thing.

827
00:56:07.404 --> 00:56:10.387
And after all of that's done, now you've got these crystals.

828
00:56:11.948 --> 00:56:14.390
And what you have to do is now wash out the solvent.

829
00:56:15.497 --> 00:56:19.060
And then you have a naked MOF, right?

830
00:56:19.341 --> 00:56:23.384
And you get these crystals, which they kind of look like this under the microscope.

831
00:56:23.404 --> 00:56:25.847
They're tiny, tiny amounts, you know, grams at a time.

832
00:56:26.888 --> 00:56:30.871
The real challenge now is scaling this thing industrially.

833
00:56:31.172 --> 00:56:35.515
I do remember one comment saying, well, can you produce it at industrial scale?

834
00:56:35.535 --> 00:56:36.056
Yeah, yeah.

835
00:56:36.156 --> 00:56:37.157
And it's difficult.

836
00:56:37.197 --> 00:56:37.858
There's a lot of...

837
00:56:38.418 --> 00:57:05.577
difficulty here first of all the dmf which is a common solvent that's used this thing is toxic and it's expensive so we'd rather use stuff like ethanol or water the yield is pretty small we're getting like you know grams of stuff at a time and if you scale up then you can imagine the crystals are less good because the environment is not completely uniform the bigger the vessel there's going to have you're going to have like edge effects right where the edge temperature is different from the central temperature the pressures are different um

838
00:57:07.203 --> 00:57:15.147
And removing that solvent is pretty hard at larger and larger scales because what you have to do is basically vacuum pump all of that stuff out.

839
00:57:15.707 --> 00:57:19.649
And producing a big enough vacuum pump for industrial scale is pretty hard.

840
00:57:20.389 --> 00:57:21.269
I did find a company.

841
00:57:21.289 --> 00:57:25.331
There are several companies, but there's one company I wanted to highlight, Novo MOF.

842
00:57:25.351 --> 00:57:26.612
They're a company out of Switzerland.

843
00:57:26.832 --> 00:57:29.153
We're not sponsored by them or anything, okay?

844
00:57:29.173 --> 00:57:29.433
Yeah.

845
00:57:30.013 --> 00:57:31.754
But it's a cool company that I found.

846
00:57:31.914 --> 00:57:41.759
They made 300 kilograms of their NMOF, and that 300 kilograms has 240 kilometers squared of surface area, which is like the size of cities.

847
00:57:42.139 --> 00:57:42.379
Right.

848
00:57:42.419 --> 00:57:45.541
And they're using this for carbon capture in factories, right?

849
00:57:45.561 --> 00:57:56.066
But on their website, they talk about the challenges that comes with trying to scale these up at an industrial level and some of the techniques that they're using to...

850
00:57:56.826 --> 00:57:59.930
go through and actually mitigate those things.

851
00:58:00.090 --> 00:58:07.358
So what's interesting is the concept of metal organic, like most of the Nobels, the discoveries have been made quite some time ago.

852
00:58:07.518 --> 00:58:07.738
Yeah.

853
00:58:08.259 --> 00:58:14.886
And, you know, with metal organic frameworks, we're at a place now where they've been experimentally proven.

854
00:58:14.967 --> 00:58:17.730
There's a variety of different methodologies that have kind of been identified.

855
00:58:17.750 --> 00:58:17.870
Yeah.

856
00:58:18.090 --> 00:58:22.135
There's been also the rule book on how to make stuff, right?

857
00:58:22.176 --> 00:58:25.240
The cookbook is now pretty well established.

858
00:58:25.680 --> 00:58:32.169
And so now the challenge is going from making a meal for me, you, the spouses.

859
00:58:32.489 --> 00:58:33.771
To like McDonald's level.

860
00:58:33.791 --> 00:58:34.432
To McDonald's.

861
00:58:35.253 --> 00:58:41.197
How do you make this industrial grade, volume, size, scale?

862
00:58:41.518 --> 00:58:49.444
Which, again, is non-trivial, but is the tail end of this sort of fundamental research to end consumer product cycle.

863
00:58:49.644 --> 00:58:50.745
Yeah, exactly.

864
00:58:51.946 --> 00:58:58.491
And it really shows how science benefits us as a society, right?

865
00:58:58.551 --> 00:59:00.613
It's like the process is always...

866
00:59:01.593 --> 00:59:06.408
Fundamental science needs to happen first to show the base case it's possible and

867
00:59:07.395 --> 00:59:08.075
And it's worth it.

868
00:59:08.676 --> 00:59:12.797
Once you have that, then you go into, okay, how do I industrial scale this thing?

869
00:59:12.817 --> 00:59:13.998
How do I make it better?

870
00:59:14.498 --> 00:59:15.538
How do I make it cheaper?

871
00:59:15.939 --> 00:59:17.399
Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

872
00:59:17.459 --> 00:59:24.162
This is an important context in understanding how the public and private sector work in terms of innovation.

873
00:59:24.582 --> 00:59:31.565
A lot of times, especially in the modern tech era, innovation is framed as the private sector is the only location that...

874
00:59:31.725 --> 00:59:37.949
in which innovation can arise because in the public sector there's too much bureaucracy and all this other stuff.

875
00:59:38.209 --> 00:59:50.096
And the challenge with that viewpoint is so much of the innovation, big-eye innovation that gets talked about, has a basis that was publicly funded for fundamental research that dictates it.

876
00:59:50.316 --> 00:59:54.759
There are some exceptions to this rule where the private sector will look at an area –

877
00:59:55.359 --> 01:00:03.401
And usually it'll be a founder-led company where the founder has super voting shares to be able to dictate what happens and it doesn't matter.

878
01:00:03.661 --> 01:00:05.222
And they have a conviction about something.

879
01:00:05.522 --> 01:00:08.002
And then they'll go and do that fundamental research.

880
01:00:08.222 --> 01:00:17.025
They'll acquire all – we've seen this particularly, for example, in AI, which, again, is still based on decades of fundamental research.

881
01:00:17.065 --> 01:00:17.945
Even every private –

882
01:00:18.505 --> 01:00:23.949
company that is doing this fundamental research, they're standing on the shoulders of giants, right?

883
01:00:24.009 --> 01:00:30.534
And those giants are always funded by public institutions and by our taxpayer dollars.

884
01:00:30.674 --> 01:00:44.405
Because there's not a profit incentive for the private sector to do fundamental research where they can't tie it to quarterly earnings or shareholder value in a time cycle that is reasonable for the sort of stock market system that...

885
01:00:44.565 --> 01:00:45.265
we have today.

886
01:00:45.285 --> 01:00:46.665
I mean, if we look at AI, right?

887
01:00:46.686 --> 01:00:52.267
Like John Hopfield in the 1980s working on neural networks was NSF funded.

888
01:00:52.807 --> 01:00:56.068
Everybody thought he was just like doing some weird biophysics like stuff.

889
01:00:56.508 --> 01:00:59.208
Okay, like you made an Ising model out of the brain.

890
01:00:59.348 --> 01:00:59.669
Cool.

891
01:01:00.029 --> 01:01:08.551
And then, you know, Jeffrey Hinton saying that guys, neural networks are the future and everybody else was going for the algorithmic AI.

892
01:01:08.791 --> 01:01:12.091
He's the one who was like, no, let's just make it bigger and bigger.

893
01:01:12.712 --> 01:01:14.272
And with Backprop, it's going to work.

894
01:01:15.073 --> 01:01:19.738
No one believed him, but he got funding because some people were like, it might work.

895
01:01:19.878 --> 01:01:21.219
Let's let's give him some funding for it.

896
01:01:21.560 --> 01:01:23.162
And now we have all of AI, right?

897
01:01:23.422 --> 01:01:24.123
The the.

898
01:01:25.240 --> 01:01:33.988
The PhD students of Jeffrey Hinton that went and started OpenAI and all this stuff, they were supported by grants from taxpayer dollars.

899
01:01:34.749 --> 01:01:37.592
And now it's a multi-trillion dollar global issue.

900
01:01:37.632 --> 01:01:43.157
Neuralink, the PhD students that started Neuralink were supported by grants from the American government.

901
01:01:43.398 --> 01:01:43.958
100%.

902
01:01:43.998 --> 01:01:44.178
Right?

903
01:01:44.218 --> 01:01:48.002
Like there's no world where this isn't happening anymore.

904
01:01:48.187 --> 01:01:51.348
because of funding from our taxpayer dollars.

905
01:01:51.508 --> 01:01:58.691
And this is one thing that I really feel really strongly about, is like when I pay taxes, I want it to go for this kind of stuff.

906
01:01:59.092 --> 01:02:13.118
One of the things that has created this strategic advantage for the U.S., where we have been a dominant global power, driven not only by our military, but by our technology, both of which...

907
01:02:14.398 --> 01:02:19.662
are fundamentally where they are because of our investment in fundamental science research.

908
01:02:19.782 --> 01:02:20.002
Yeah.

909
01:02:20.102 --> 01:02:24.566
We would not have dominance in air and sea with the Navy and the Air Force.

910
01:02:24.926 --> 01:02:30.390
We would not have dominance where all of the biggest technology companies on the planet are here.

911
01:02:30.771 --> 01:02:32.832
We would not have that without...

912
01:02:34.920 --> 01:02:40.507
the early investments in these arenas that were perceived as not being commercially viable at the time.

913
01:02:40.628 --> 01:02:40.828
Yeah.

914
01:02:41.208 --> 01:02:41.409
Yeah.

915
01:02:41.629 --> 01:02:42.350
Yeah, exactly.

916
01:02:42.430 --> 01:02:47.877
It's like, it doesn't make any sense to me because this used to be, this used to be a bipartisan thing.

917
01:02:48.278 --> 01:02:49.239
That's what's so interesting.

918
01:02:49.359 --> 01:02:51.001
This used to be a very bipartisan thing.

919
01:02:51.021 --> 01:02:51.862
We're going to be the best.

920
01:02:52.463 --> 01:02:53.864
when it comes to science, okay?

921
01:02:54.445 --> 01:03:00.890
George Bush funded NASA's re-going to Mars and stuff like that.

922
01:03:02.371 --> 01:03:15.721
There's so many things that have happened now, especially with the current administration, that is just totally, totally bankrupting us when it comes to our supremacy in the sciences.

923
01:03:16.001 --> 01:03:17.742
And it's really, really rather unfortunate.

924
01:03:18.243 --> 01:03:20.925
We have sort of photo seven here, which is...

925
01:03:22.806 --> 01:03:24.388
We're leading in Nobel Prizes.

926
01:03:24.668 --> 01:03:25.929
Our universities are at the top.

927
01:03:26.510 --> 01:03:30.833
But the current administration is just running scientists out of our country.

928
01:03:31.674 --> 01:03:33.355
Which is another problem.

929
01:03:33.495 --> 01:03:36.418
If you look at the Nobel Prizes from the U.S.

930
01:03:36.658 --> 01:03:38.880
Even this year, we led.

931
01:03:38.960 --> 01:03:39.741
And who they are.

932
01:03:40.541 --> 01:03:43.364
And how they got to be Americans.

933
01:03:43.804 --> 01:03:44.785
Omar Yagi, he was...

934
01:03:46.585 --> 01:03:57.069
An immigrant from Jordan, Palestinian refugee, came in, embraced this country, was supported by the DOE, was supported by the NSF, did an NSF postdoc fellowship at Harvard.

935
01:03:57.589 --> 01:04:00.410
And the NSF postdoc fellowship is now completely gutted.

936
01:04:01.130 --> 01:04:08.453
The NSF postdoc fellowship used to be this thing that would take graduate students that were stars and put them at these top institutions.

937
01:04:08.733 --> 01:04:09.013
Right.

938
01:04:09.133 --> 01:04:15.099
to do postdoc research and gear them up for becoming top faculty members at our leading institutions.

939
01:04:15.139 --> 01:04:16.140
And now that thing is gutted.

940
01:04:16.381 --> 01:04:24.549
You know what's funny is the only reason that I am able to be in the U.S. is, you know, my dad did his postdoc at Harvard and was funded.

941
01:04:25.310 --> 01:04:30.135
He not only got in through a newly created visa program that was specific to Zimbabwe.

942
01:04:30.435 --> 01:04:30.755
Okay.

943
01:04:30.915 --> 01:04:31.136
Right?

944
01:04:31.436 --> 01:04:34.538
And it was the first round, and he won the lottery the first round.

945
01:04:34.858 --> 01:04:40.181
He similarly got to be able to do – that's how he got to McGill, where he did grad school.

946
01:04:40.201 --> 01:04:48.306
And then he got to do the Harvard postdoc because of a similarly federally funded grant program around postdoc research.

947
01:04:49.487 --> 01:04:53.490
And like, you know, he's been in Science and Nature, published multiple times.

948
01:04:53.510 --> 01:04:54.190
Right.

949
01:04:54.270 --> 01:04:58.355
has multiple patents that are accruing value to multiple American companies.

950
01:04:58.515 --> 01:05:02.460
You know, he's been a director of biology at a biotech that sold for

951
01:05:03.903 --> 01:05:09.067
millions of dollars and like all of that value creation is because of these systems that existed.

952
01:05:09.087 --> 01:05:09.247
Yeah.

953
01:05:09.427 --> 01:05:15.872
I mean, same for my dad, my dad came on a, um, and I think it was an NOA fellowship or an NSF fellowship.

954
01:05:15.972 --> 01:05:18.414
We first came to Huntsville, Alabama from India.

955
01:05:18.674 --> 01:05:19.615
We stayed there for two years.

956
01:05:19.655 --> 01:05:23.138
He was working at the Marshall space flight center for NASA.

957
01:05:23.258 --> 01:05:27.881
And then he got a tenure track position here in LA and that's how he moved here.

958
01:05:27.921 --> 01:05:30.103
But even throughout his position, he,

959
01:05:30.603 --> 01:05:33.685
As a professor here in LA, he's gotten funding from the NSF.

960
01:05:33.745 --> 01:05:35.125
And now all of that is going down.

961
01:05:35.526 --> 01:05:41.309
It's just really, really quite insane to me that this is happening at a countrywide scale.

962
01:05:41.609 --> 01:05:44.250
And it's not something that I think we should take lightly.

963
01:05:44.630 --> 01:05:52.194
Because, you know, Germany, I hate to bring up Germany as an example, but it really is such a great example.

964
01:05:52.234 --> 01:05:59.918
Because before the 1920s and 1930s, Germany won almost every Nobel Prize in chemistry, in biology, in science.

965
01:06:00.696 --> 01:06:03.119
And then afterwards, they haven't won a lot.

966
01:06:03.599 --> 01:06:05.581
It took them a while to crawl back.

967
01:06:05.922 --> 01:06:08.324
And we're seeing that happening with American institutions.

968
01:06:08.604 --> 01:06:11.087
The UC system has a hiring freeze.

969
01:06:11.727 --> 01:06:12.428
Right.

970
01:06:12.808 --> 01:06:16.472
JPL has let go of 500 of their staff.

971
01:06:16.832 --> 01:06:17.053
Right.

972
01:06:17.253 --> 01:06:18.894
And that's just right around the corner from us here.

973
01:06:19.155 --> 01:06:21.957
I mean, it's just nuts, dude.

974
01:06:21.977 --> 01:06:22.198
Like...

975
01:06:23.407 --> 01:06:29.348
It's going to take us, I fear that it's going to take us decades to come back from this.

976
01:06:29.788 --> 01:06:36.950
And I think, you know, we should really be thinking about this as a nation, about like what is important to us.

977
01:06:37.090 --> 01:06:42.751
Like if American exceptionalism is important to us, which it should be, certainly important to me.

978
01:06:42.791 --> 01:06:50.173
Like, you know, I got my American citizenship and I love the fact that America is exceptional at a lot of things, right?

979
01:06:50.233 --> 01:06:50.753
And it's...

980
01:06:51.393 --> 01:06:59.222
Perhaps more so than any other profession, I think scientists understand what that means to have American exceptionalism, right?

981
01:06:59.242 --> 01:07:05.469
We have the greatest research infrastructure in the world, and we shouldn't be so casually letting that go.

982
01:07:05.489 --> 01:07:07.371
100%.

983
01:07:07.431 --> 01:07:12.016
I mean, and it's one of those things that takes a long time to see...

984
01:07:12.857 --> 01:07:32.796
transpire and it's why ringing the alarm sooner rather than later matters because the Nobel prizes that went out last week were for discoveries from decades ago and so there's like an inertia yeah right exactly show up in the system yeah yeah and so just because we don't want to be in the 2050s now and then

985
01:07:33.577 --> 01:07:37.160
All the Nobel Prizes are being won by countries outside of the U.S.

986
01:07:37.440 --> 01:07:43.025
There's several stories of scientists now leaving the U.S. because of what's happening, right?

987
01:07:43.466 --> 01:07:49.551
Other countries are salivating at the opportunity to just poach all of our scientists.

988
01:07:49.911 --> 01:07:51.633
And this is happening now in real time.

989
01:07:51.693 --> 01:07:53.154
This is something that needs to stop.

990
01:07:53.795 --> 01:07:56.497
This is an important subject we have covered before.

991
01:07:56.677 --> 01:08:01.887
Yeah, but I really, yeah, I think the recent Nobel Prizes, like, really made me think about it, right?

992
01:08:01.927 --> 01:08:08.840
Because, you know, Omar Yaa, like, we're also doing this whole anti-immigration thing, which I totally get.

993
01:08:09.899 --> 01:08:10.119
Right?

994
01:08:10.300 --> 01:08:12.642
Like with the illegal immigration and all that.

995
01:08:12.662 --> 01:08:14.264
Like there's arguments to be made there.

996
01:08:14.565 --> 01:08:24.877
But I think both sides of the aisle should agree that curating exceptional international talent is something that America should be doing.

997
01:08:25.057 --> 01:08:27.340
It's what we've been doing for hundreds of years.

998
01:08:27.701 --> 01:08:27.921
Yeah.

999
01:08:28.181 --> 01:08:28.461
And it...

1000
01:08:29.042 --> 01:08:31.164
We've done it through multiple world wars.

1001
01:08:31.444 --> 01:08:32.845
Yeah, we've done it since the 1800s.

1002
01:08:32.925 --> 01:08:35.547
Andrew Carnegie was an immigrant.

1003
01:08:36.048 --> 01:08:37.569
And look what he did for our nation, right?

1004
01:08:38.410 --> 01:08:39.751
Albert Einstein was an immigrant.

1005
01:08:40.191 --> 01:08:41.532
Enrico Fermi was an immigrant.

1006
01:08:41.572 --> 01:08:42.773
Like, oh, come on, guys.

1007
01:08:42.813 --> 01:08:44.355
Tesla was an immigrant.

1008
01:08:44.375 --> 01:08:46.516
If you look at most of the top...

1009
01:08:48.698 --> 01:08:50.619
companies in the S&amp;P 500.

1010
01:08:52.320 --> 01:08:59.444
If you look at Fang, most of these, you know, Facebook, Amazon, Netflix, Google, et cetera, et cetera.

1011
01:08:59.864 --> 01:09:08.049
The NVIDIA, the biggest companies that the U.S. has right now, the majority of them are founded by immigrants.

1012
01:09:08.129 --> 01:09:08.349
Yeah.

1013
01:09:08.389 --> 01:09:08.589
Yeah.

1014
01:09:08.869 --> 01:09:09.890
And I mean, even this,

1015
01:09:11.215 --> 01:09:12.716
years Nobel Prizes, right?

1016
01:09:13.137 --> 01:09:16.240
Four out of the six Americans are immigrants.

1017
01:09:16.860 --> 01:09:18.802
You've got, actually, no, sorry, three out of the six.

1018
01:09:18.862 --> 01:09:24.647
John Clark, he's an immigrant from the UK, did his PhD at Cambridge, and then came here to Berkeley.

1019
01:09:24.968 --> 01:09:29.492
Michel Devereux did his PhD at Paris Sood, came here to Berkeley.

1020
01:09:29.792 --> 01:09:33.476
We've got Omar Yagi, obviously, from Jordan, came here.

1021
01:09:33.936 --> 01:09:34.196
So,

1022
01:09:35.217 --> 01:09:36.179
It's worked, guys.

1023
01:09:37.220 --> 01:09:39.223
Even if you look at our math Olympiad team.

1024
01:09:39.424 --> 01:09:39.984
Yeah.

1025
01:09:40.365 --> 01:09:41.827
I think it's 100% Chinese.

1026
01:09:42.128 --> 01:09:42.328
Yeah.

1027
01:09:42.388 --> 01:09:44.451
No, there's an Indian guy and there's an American guy.

1028
01:09:44.511 --> 01:09:44.731
Okay.

1029
01:09:44.751 --> 01:09:46.194
There's a US guy, like a white guy.

1030
01:09:46.354 --> 01:09:46.654
That's fair.

1031
01:09:46.674 --> 01:09:46.794
Yeah.

1032
01:09:47.015 --> 01:09:49.378
But I mean, I love that, dude.

1033
01:09:49.398 --> 01:09:51.041
Like, I love the fact that like...

1034
01:09:52.114 --> 01:09:56.635
Our country curates talent from all over the world, and we just create the A-team.

1035
01:09:56.815 --> 01:09:57.015
Yes.

1036
01:09:57.115 --> 01:09:57.336
Right?

1037
01:09:57.436 --> 01:09:58.296
Yes.

1038
01:09:58.316 --> 01:09:59.476
I absolutely love that.

1039
01:09:59.696 --> 01:10:01.017
And we should continue to do so.

1040
01:10:01.117 --> 01:10:02.117
Yeah.

1041
01:10:02.137 --> 01:10:03.357
We're getting the plus ones, right?

1042
01:10:03.777 --> 01:10:04.578
It's our scoreboard.

1043
01:10:04.658 --> 01:10:04.858
Right.

1044
01:10:05.758 --> 01:10:06.158
100%.

1045
01:10:06.798 --> 01:10:08.319
This is an important issue.

1046
01:10:09.379 --> 01:10:13.420
We need to continue to fund fundamental science in the United States.

1047
01:10:13.460 --> 01:10:19.202
We need to continue to bring the best and brightest from the world here to continue to facilitate the life of...

1048
01:10:19.482 --> 01:10:25.885
and the lifestyle that we have facilitated, and also give the gift of what we create to the rest of the world.

1049
01:10:26.725 --> 01:10:28.526
We have the infrastructure to do so.

1050
01:10:28.986 --> 01:10:30.187
We have the sort of...

1051
01:10:31.261 --> 01:10:34.223
cultural dynamics to do so.

1052
01:10:34.263 --> 01:10:35.804
We're irrationally confident.

1053
01:10:35.984 --> 01:10:37.385
Yeah.

1054
01:10:38.066 --> 01:10:38.706
And it works.

1055
01:10:38.786 --> 01:10:39.306
And it works.

1056
01:10:39.366 --> 01:10:39.947
And it works.

1057
01:10:40.067 --> 01:10:42.408
We are irrationally confident and we just do it.

1058
01:10:42.869 --> 01:10:43.569
And we just do it.

1059
01:10:43.709 --> 01:10:49.813
And if it doesn't work, we try again and we try again because we're so confident that it's going to work.

1060
01:10:50.454 --> 01:10:56.478
And that's how we get stuff like MOF5 that has a football field size...

1061
01:10:57.772 --> 01:10:58.933
surface area in a gram.

1062
01:10:59.013 --> 01:10:59.553
Or a LIGO.

1063
01:10:59.573 --> 01:11:01.795
Everybody else was like, what are you talking about?

1064
01:11:01.955 --> 01:11:06.618
He's like, no, this thing literally has a football field in a gram.

1065
01:11:07.973 --> 01:11:10.516
It's been a really fascinating two weeks with the Nobel Prizes.

1066
01:11:11.377 --> 01:11:21.466
We want to thank all of you who are listening, whether it's on YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, TikTok, Instagram, X, Facebook.

1067
01:11:22.647 --> 01:11:24.549
You guys really are powering the show.

1068
01:11:25.550 --> 01:11:26.992
Continue to send over questions.

1069
01:11:27.752 --> 01:11:29.474
We'll try to touch on them as much as possible.

1070
01:11:29.794 --> 01:11:32.557
We may introduce a listener question section soon.

1071
01:11:32.697 --> 01:11:33.578
Yeah, we might.

1072
01:11:33.918 --> 01:11:34.859
In future episodes.

1073
01:11:35.960 --> 01:11:45.508
But this is one of the most important subjects to all of our lives, our everyday lives, our family, our careers, and everything.

1074
01:11:45.908 --> 01:11:50.932
And we're going to try to continue to do it justice by covering it from First Principles.

1075
01:11:51.373 --> 01:11:58.278
I am your host, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

1076
01:11:58.679 --> 01:12:00.180
This is from First Principles.

1077
01:12:00.320 --> 01:12:01.241
We'll see you all next week.
