WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.131 --> 00:00:04.512
The recipe for life may not be uniquely terrestrial.

2
00:00:04.832 --> 00:00:13.455
And we found all five letters of the genetic code floating around in deep space with our first astrobiology story.

3
00:00:13.615 --> 00:00:14.975
Congress decided where the money went.

4
00:00:16.375 --> 00:00:18.856
It's law, it's not like an opinion.

5
00:00:19.876 --> 00:00:24.378
And the White House has begun to say, hey, you're not getting any more money.

6
00:00:24.578 --> 00:00:25.718
He drops this tweet.

7
00:00:26.338 --> 00:00:26.899
Hello there.

8
00:00:26.939 --> 00:00:28.340
The Jacobian conjecture is false.

9
00:00:28.380 --> 00:00:28.661
Thanks.

10
00:00:28.941 --> 00:00:29.822
And T-H-A-N-X.

11
00:00:31.695 --> 00:00:32.516
Hello, Internet.

12
00:00:32.536 --> 00:00:42.282
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, and I'm joined, as always, by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

13
00:00:42.803 --> 00:00:50.008
This week, we have a rundown episode with three very intriguing stories.

14
00:00:50.028 --> 00:00:55.832
We're starting off with astrobiology, where new evidence suggests that asteroids are...

15
00:00:56.852 --> 00:01:02.155
possibly could have seeded early earth with life's molecular building blocks.

16
00:01:02.816 --> 00:01:19.106
We'll then cover an update on the ongoing funding battle between the White House's Office of Management and Budget, Congress, and the scientific research community on a new funding policy change that would rewrite how federal research grants and the money

17
00:01:19.626 --> 00:01:24.669
that ultimately makes all of the great stories that we cover on this pod happen.

18
00:01:24.990 --> 00:01:28.112
Who gets to decide who gets the money and how?

19
00:01:29.853 --> 00:01:32.635
The process by which it's awarded and distributed is important.

20
00:01:32.895 --> 00:01:38.639
And so we want to make sure we touched on this because this show would not exist without our current ecosystem.

21
00:01:38.939 --> 00:01:43.522
And we will lastly end with a new math discovery that has rocked

22
00:01:44.202 --> 00:02:05.020
social media this week as AI cracked yet another 100-year-old problem, leaving mathematics to grapple with the very rapid and very troubling and unsettling change in the landscape as open problems continue to be knocked down by frontier models and what this means for rapid progress in

23
00:02:08.022 --> 00:02:13.264
And along the way, I think we might learn a little lesson in 3D calculus.

24
00:02:13.964 --> 00:02:15.465
I'm going to need that one.

25
00:02:15.825 --> 00:02:21.087
For the AI story, this is going to be a little bit more of a deep dive in this rundown because it's pretty important.

26
00:02:21.307 --> 00:02:27.949
But as always, we're going to talk about the science from the ground up today because this is from First Principles.

27
00:02:43.384 --> 00:02:50.308
So today we are going to start off with my favorite subject, aliens, as many of you longtime listeners know.

28
00:02:51.109 --> 00:02:57.052
But what's interesting about this is the recipe for life may not be uniquely terrestrial.

29
00:02:57.373 --> 00:03:05.998
And we found all five letters of the genetic code floating around in deep space with our first astrobiology story.

30
00:03:06.661 --> 00:03:28.227
Yeah, this was super interesting to me because the Japanese space agency, JAXA, put out this paper showing that all five of the nucleotides that we know and love here on Earth with all of life, there's four in DNA, A, T, G, and C, and then there's one that RNA uses.

31
00:03:28.507 --> 00:03:32.288
It uses the U, uracil, instead of thiamine that's used in DNA.

32
00:03:32.788 --> 00:03:35.212
They found all five on an asteroid.

33
00:03:35.652 --> 00:03:41.761
This isn't the first time that this has happened, but the fact that it's happened over and over is, I think, a very big deal.

34
00:03:42.062 --> 00:03:48.591
And it's hugely important for origin of life debate, things like that.

35
00:03:49.472 --> 00:03:55.393
It's hugely important for this theory called abiogenesis, which scientists have debated for a very long time.

36
00:03:55.953 --> 00:04:03.935
It's this idea that the process by which life arises naturally can be from outer space, right?

37
00:04:04.335 --> 00:04:07.016
And actually from non-living matter.

38
00:04:07.056 --> 00:04:07.896
That's the idea, right?

39
00:04:08.016 --> 00:04:11.437
Abiogenesis means from non-living to living, a bio.

40
00:04:12.504 --> 00:04:24.035
Now the question is, on early Earth, which is around 4 billion years ago, this is right after the Earth formed and it cooled down to the point where it could support liquid water, life emerged remarkably fast.

41
00:04:25.136 --> 00:04:32.382
It's like there was liquid water and then immediately we have fossils of tiny bacteria-looking thingies.

42
00:04:33.283 --> 00:04:35.845
And the question is, how come it happened so fast?

43
00:04:36.026 --> 00:04:38.568
And what's the necessary chemical ingredients that...

44
00:04:38.788 --> 00:04:41.289
that can assemble so quickly to create something like life.

45
00:04:42.169 --> 00:04:47.030
One important hypothesis is exogenous delivery, meaning asteroids and comets.

46
00:04:47.650 --> 00:04:50.831
We already know that comets brought most of the water on Earth.

47
00:04:53.551 --> 00:05:04.594
Asteroids and comets, maybe they have genetic material and material for life, and they act like a galactic postal service where life originates somewhere else.

48
00:05:04.714 --> 00:05:07.595
Let's not worry about how it originated somewhere else,

49
00:05:09.256 --> 00:05:15.645
It originates somewhere else, and then an asteroid gets kicked out of that planet or whatever thing has the life.

50
00:05:17.195 --> 00:05:21.736
It roams around space for millions, maybe billions of years, and then it finds its way on Earth.

51
00:05:22.737 --> 00:05:34.220
As an example that we've seen recently that we've covered on the show is the interstellar object of 3i Atlas that came into our neighborhood that was one of these travelers that was roaming around.

52
00:05:34.340 --> 00:05:40.642
Obviously, it did not make impact with Earth, but we've also covered the crater in Arizona.

53
00:05:40.822 --> 00:05:42.482
Yes, we've covered the crater in Arizona.

54
00:05:42.502 --> 00:05:44.403
We've covered how...

55
00:05:45.958 --> 00:05:48.994
like actual Mars, a Mars meteorite could...

56
00:05:49.983 --> 00:06:05.075
impact Mars, travel to Earth, and then get on Earth, and that entire process can be just enough, like just the right conditions where life under the surface of the asteroid could survive.

57
00:06:05.115 --> 00:06:15.102
Maybe not on the surface because it's got to survive re-entry and all that kind of stuff, but just under the surface, if there's life, it could survive the impact, and it could actually create life on Earth.

58
00:06:15.383 --> 00:06:18.205
We've had several stories in the past that talk about this.

59
00:06:18.685 --> 00:06:23.990
So scientists have found individual organic compounds in meteorites that fell on Earth, right?

60
00:06:24.410 --> 00:06:31.136
But those samples always carried a major asterisk, which is mainly that you can have terrestrial contamination.

61
00:06:31.176 --> 00:06:34.699
The most famous of this is in the 1990s when Bill Clinton...

62
00:06:35.540 --> 00:06:37.943
And he got in front of the press.

63
00:06:37.963 --> 00:06:39.925
I think it was in the Rose Garden, maybe?

64
00:06:39.945 --> 00:06:44.289
Yeah, he was in the Rose Garden, and he said, I did not have...

65
00:06:44.789 --> 00:06:47.172
I always do this because we've covered this so many times.

66
00:06:47.232 --> 00:06:48.233
It's like a running joke now.

67
00:06:48.733 --> 00:06:51.916
But he was actually announcing a science paper

68
00:06:52.637 --> 00:07:01.780
by scientists at JPL that showed that a Martian meteorite that they had found in Antarctica might have had some bacteria-looking things.

69
00:07:02.180 --> 00:07:16.225
And then immediately the entire world community of scientists was like, well, no, that could be because you've either contaminated, and also just because it looks like a bacteria-looking thing doesn't mean that it's actually bacteria from Mars, right?

70
00:07:16.786 --> 00:07:19.927
So there's been a lot of debate about whether we can even...

71
00:07:20.767 --> 00:07:22.308
make those kinds of arguments, right?

72
00:07:22.328 --> 00:07:28.812
Because once a space rock lands on Earth, it immediately gets contaminated by Earth biology.

73
00:07:29.532 --> 00:07:42.040
So here, the hero of this story is a satellite slash bombing system by the Japanese space agency called Hayabusa 2.

74
00:07:42.781 --> 00:07:46.143
And what it did was go to an asteroid called NASA,

75
00:07:48.364 --> 00:07:49.665
R-Y-U-G-U.

76
00:07:50.366 --> 00:07:51.567
Hopefully I'm pronouncing that right.

77
00:07:51.927 --> 00:07:54.329
What it does is it gets near this asteroid.

78
00:07:54.409 --> 00:08:01.234
It deploys a kind of remote bomb that pulverizes part of that asteroid.

79
00:08:01.574 --> 00:08:03.156
And then it goes back to that site.

80
00:08:03.796 --> 00:08:08.798
goes down, and then picks up the fragments of the pulverized rock.

81
00:08:09.558 --> 00:08:12.939
This is the alternative plot to Armageddon.

82
00:08:13.299 --> 00:08:18.000
Instead of going onto it and drilling, they did it from the atmosphere.

83
00:08:18.220 --> 00:08:19.721
Yeah, and they did it remotely.

84
00:08:19.781 --> 00:08:21.001
Now we can do that, right?

85
00:08:21.021 --> 00:08:21.181
So...

86
00:08:23.322 --> 00:08:25.043
That's the premise of the whole thing.

87
00:08:25.063 --> 00:08:38.090
The next video actually shows, this is a video from the JAXA probe, and it's showing you're lower down into the part of the asteroid that's been pulverized, and you grab it, you grab that part, and you come out.

88
00:08:38.190 --> 00:08:49.095
It's pretty cool that we can successfully chase this spinning top asteroid, blast a crater, and then bring back pristine dirt from an asteroid back home.

89
00:08:49.315 --> 00:08:52.157
Who was the one who was like, guys, I have an idea?

90
00:08:52.997 --> 00:08:54.038
Let's take a bomb.

91
00:08:54.098 --> 00:08:54.358
Yeah.

92
00:08:55.158 --> 00:08:59.921
Let's explode it just above the surface so that we can then go down.

93
00:08:59.961 --> 00:09:00.121
Yeah.

94
00:09:00.141 --> 00:09:02.102
And then there's a bunch of dirt instead of rocks.

95
00:09:02.202 --> 00:09:02.382
Right.

96
00:09:02.422 --> 00:09:04.443
Because the idea is the surface is solid.

97
00:09:04.463 --> 00:09:04.864
It's a little bit.

98
00:09:04.904 --> 00:09:05.264
You can't.

99
00:09:05.284 --> 00:09:05.384
Yeah.

100
00:09:05.444 --> 00:09:10.327
And the rocks are kind of big and you don't want to have to have a drilling mechanism on the whatever probe you have.

101
00:09:10.367 --> 00:09:10.587
Yeah.

102
00:09:11.047 --> 00:09:11.587
It's clever.

103
00:09:12.208 --> 00:09:16.050
I'm very curious how that conversation went in the proposal meeting.

104
00:09:16.170 --> 00:09:22.840
Yeah, and the other thing I'm actually curious about is if that little bomb changed the orbit of Raigü, right?

105
00:09:22.860 --> 00:09:28.228
Because we've talked about how planetary defense, one of the biggest things that we can do is just like...

106
00:09:29.211 --> 00:09:34.234
Put a minor explosion to change the momentum of that asteroid so that it changes the trajectory around the sun.

107
00:09:34.675 --> 00:09:42.600
I'm sure they're actually doing follow-up experiments to see if they can detect that tiny shift in momentum, which is extremely difficult.

108
00:09:42.640 --> 00:09:44.261
We've covered this in the past.

109
00:09:44.321 --> 00:09:50.525
So JAXA and the Hayabusa team, they came out with a paper in Nature Astro.

110
00:09:53.203 --> 00:10:05.766
a complete set of canonical nucleobases in the carbonaceous asteroid which means they have found A, G, C, T and they found U which is the alphabet of life in some sense right?

111
00:10:05.786 --> 00:10:09.127
It's all the ingredients we need to ratatouille ourself into the way of life.

112
00:10:09.187 --> 00:10:17.190
Yes exactly and if we go inside the lab you actually have a photo of the sample that they've got back from the asteroid.

113
00:10:17.210 --> 00:10:19.750
So there you can see the dirt from the asteroid.

114
00:10:19.770 --> 00:10:21.411
What they did was take that sample

115
00:10:22.271 --> 00:10:35.362
run it through mass spectrometry, chemical analysis, and they could actually identify individual nucleotides, the same ones that make up our DNA in that dirt, which is, I think, pretty crazy.

116
00:10:36.523 --> 00:10:45.550
It's a big deal for a number of reasons, not only the execution of it, but to your point earlier, we've removed the contamination hypothesis from the list of options.

117
00:10:45.890 --> 00:10:46.070
Yeah.

118
00:10:46.430 --> 00:10:59.559
We've removed the contamination hypothesis and it's the same nucleotide bases that we have, which is kind of like like it's kind of weird that like aliens would also have the same nucleotides that we did.

119
00:11:00.139 --> 00:11:01.400
So you're saying there's a chance.

120
00:11:01.620 --> 00:11:02.581
Yeah.

121
00:11:02.781 --> 00:11:03.681
It's kind of crazy.

122
00:11:03.741 --> 00:11:03.961
Right.

123
00:11:04.021 --> 00:11:06.843
And the big picture is so this isn't actually the first time.

124
00:11:07.103 --> 00:11:08.945
OK. NASA.

125
00:11:09.913 --> 00:11:19.826
had a similar experiment in 2023 where they went to the asteroid Bennu and they found samples that had the five nucleotide bases.

126
00:11:19.886 --> 00:11:22.329
What's cool about this is, one, that wasn't a fluke.

127
00:11:22.610 --> 00:11:27.516
The fact that it's happened again on a different asteroid means that this is something that is probably ubiquitous.

128
00:11:28.337 --> 00:11:29.578
in asteroids and comets.

129
00:11:30.118 --> 00:11:31.019
Which is incredible.

130
00:11:31.059 --> 00:11:31.619
Which is cool.

131
00:11:31.779 --> 00:11:31.999
Yeah.

132
00:11:32.240 --> 00:11:32.720
That's incredible.

133
00:11:32.740 --> 00:11:33.580
It's not a one-off thing.

134
00:11:33.600 --> 00:11:34.881
It's not like a special asteroid.

135
00:11:34.901 --> 00:11:36.282
We got lucky one time.

136
00:11:36.542 --> 00:11:36.742
Yeah.

137
00:11:36.862 --> 00:11:38.083
That's not what we're talking about.

138
00:11:38.143 --> 00:11:40.765
Twice and we find nucleotide bases.

139
00:11:41.245 --> 00:11:42.686
Not that this... And there's another variable.

140
00:11:42.726 --> 00:11:44.947
In a short time frame as well.

141
00:11:45.168 --> 00:11:49.110
It's not this is every 100 years, every 300 years, every 1,000 years.

142
00:11:49.450 --> 00:11:51.131
Something happens to come around that has it.

143
00:11:51.291 --> 00:11:54.894
This was in a... Yeah, this is just local to our solar system.

144
00:11:55.054 --> 00:11:56.414
Which is also crazy.

145
00:11:56.435 --> 00:11:56.555
Yeah.

146
00:11:56.575 --> 00:11:56.755
Yeah.

147
00:11:57.695 --> 00:11:59.136
I think it's really cool.

148
00:11:59.196 --> 00:12:09.879
And what you can do now, and what the paper did, is specifically compare the Raigü composition of nucleotides with the Bennu composition of nucleotides.

149
00:12:10.319 --> 00:12:12.280
And they actually have different ratios.

150
00:12:12.300 --> 00:12:12.900
Okay, that's interesting.

151
00:12:12.940 --> 00:12:19.902
So both asteroids have the same building blocks of adenine, guanine, cytosine, thiamine, and uracil, the same nucleotides that we have.

152
00:12:20.542 --> 00:12:22.924
But the proportions are completely different.

153
00:12:23.204 --> 00:12:28.747
In Benyu, it's heavily skewed towards the pyramidines, which are the cytosine, the thiamine, and the uracil.

154
00:12:29.027 --> 00:12:30.528
But in Rhaegu, they're more balanced.

155
00:12:30.888 --> 00:12:31.629
Now, what does that mean?

156
00:12:31.669 --> 00:12:36.172
That means that, for one, there is complex chemistry happening.

157
00:12:36.752 --> 00:12:36.972
Right.

158
00:12:37.373 --> 00:12:52.015
Either it's happening at the genesis of when the asteroid like formed or it's happening out in deep space when this stuff interacts with the ammonia that's on the asteroid, all the other stuff that's on the asteroid and with the solar wind and with radiation from all over the place like cosmic rays.

159
00:12:53.897 --> 00:13:00.459
It could mean that it has something to do with the water rock interactions that are on the asteroid, the internal temperatures.

160
00:13:00.839 --> 00:13:04.901
But the main thing is it's a lot more complicated up there, right?

161
00:13:05.221 --> 00:13:07.182
There's like actual chemistry happening.

162
00:13:07.902 --> 00:13:09.423
And it doesn't have to be on a planet.

163
00:13:09.463 --> 00:13:17.627
We have a cosmic oven, a cosmic easy bake oven that is our intergalactic postal service, like you sort of mentioned.

164
00:13:18.367 --> 00:13:32.875
And I think part of the point, what I'm getting from the point you're bringing up here is, you know, we like to keep our assumptions conservative when it comes to particularly things like...

165
00:13:34.161 --> 00:13:36.483
What's happening on earth is happening everywhere else.

166
00:13:36.703 --> 00:13:39.425
We like to see it before we believe it.

167
00:13:39.745 --> 00:13:47.771
Sure, maybe it's happening other places, but let's actually get not only one use case, Bennu, but multiple use cases.

168
00:13:48.432 --> 00:13:51.134
And the idea that we're having now...

169
00:13:53.095 --> 00:13:53.816
A catalog.

170
00:13:53.856 --> 00:13:55.617
Now we now say there's a catalog.

171
00:13:55.677 --> 00:13:55.897
Yeah.

172
00:13:55.917 --> 00:13:56.798
Because it's more than one.

173
00:13:56.998 --> 00:13:57.218
Yes.

174
00:13:57.599 --> 00:14:03.063
And as we do more and more, I'm sure we're going to find more and more asteroids with these building blocks, right?

175
00:14:03.103 --> 00:14:08.527
It's like the universe is like inherently preloaded with the chemical ingredients that are necessary for life.

176
00:14:08.587 --> 00:14:09.568
It's kind of insane.

177
00:14:09.748 --> 00:14:11.349
It's really fascinating.

178
00:14:11.389 --> 00:14:11.690
This is...

179
00:14:12.250 --> 00:14:16.653
And there's so many, again, it feels like, well, we've already known this.

180
00:14:16.673 --> 00:14:17.694
Like, why does it matter?

181
00:14:18.855 --> 00:14:27.201
But as we know with the process of science, like being able to have replicability matters a lot.

182
00:14:27.241 --> 00:14:28.682
These missions are not cheap.

183
00:14:28.983 --> 00:14:29.183
No.

184
00:14:29.583 --> 00:14:29.783
Right?

185
00:14:29.863 --> 00:14:30.244
No.

186
00:14:30.284 --> 00:14:31.024
To pull this off.

187
00:14:31.044 --> 00:14:32.005
Yeah.

188
00:14:32.065 --> 00:14:34.807
And this is two different space agencies doing it.

189
00:14:34.927 --> 00:14:35.167
Right.

190
00:14:35.267 --> 00:14:35.447
Right?

191
00:14:35.467 --> 00:14:37.909
So there's no conspiracy unless Japan is in on it.

192
00:14:38.350 --> 00:14:38.570
Right.

193
00:14:38.590 --> 00:14:38.950
Somehow.

194
00:14:39.110 --> 00:14:39.350
Right.

195
00:14:39.370 --> 00:14:39.530
Which...

196
00:14:40.351 --> 00:14:43.574
Look, look, we'll put the I'm just I know.

197
00:14:43.674 --> 00:14:44.555
Oh, I know.

198
00:14:44.595 --> 00:14:45.496
Yeah, of course.

199
00:14:45.536 --> 00:14:47.558
They're collaborating to conspire here.

200
00:14:47.598 --> 00:14:50.701
But it's not even something that's that, you know, quote unquote, sexy.

201
00:14:50.741 --> 00:14:50.941
Yeah.

202
00:14:50.961 --> 00:14:52.462
Like even waste the time to do so.

203
00:14:53.743 --> 00:14:54.824
This is a really big deal.

204
00:14:54.964 --> 00:15:05.374
And I do think the mix difference is also quite interesting because I imagine that there are several follow up inquiries into.

205
00:15:06.635 --> 00:15:12.459
seeing their journey and understanding based on that journey, why is that mix different?

206
00:15:12.719 --> 00:15:13.500
Yeah.

207
00:15:14.180 --> 00:15:15.221
Fascinating.

208
00:15:15.281 --> 00:15:15.961
Very, very cool.

209
00:15:16.702 --> 00:15:17.322
This is fascinating.

210
00:15:17.562 --> 00:15:28.009
So, you know, as always, like, you know, I'm the alien guy, and this is great, but we're going to move quickly because this is a rundown episode, and we have a big pseudo deep dive at the end.

211
00:15:28.330 --> 00:15:31.652
But before we do so, we're going to do a quick piece of housekeeping.

212
00:15:31.672 --> 00:15:31.812
Yeah.

213
00:15:32.072 --> 00:15:42.422
For those listening to us on Spotify and Apple, we greatly appreciate your ears in your commute to work as you're working through cleaning up the house, whatever it might be.

214
00:15:42.963 --> 00:15:52.472
One of the ways you can help support the continued coverage that we do on this show is a quick five-star review, sharing it with a friend, bring it to Journal Club.

215
00:15:52.793 --> 00:15:53.914
For those of you watching,

216
00:15:54.254 --> 00:16:06.168
We always, if you can, recommend watching because each episode we go through 25 to 65 different overlays where we actually show what's happening.

217
00:16:06.528 --> 00:16:09.312
And it really helps to understand what's going on when you can see it.

218
00:16:09.712 --> 00:16:14.558
But we are trying to work on making sure for our audio listeners that we describe as much as possible.

219
00:16:15.759 --> 00:16:17.700
Again, a like, a share, a comment.

220
00:16:18.020 --> 00:16:22.762
Any of these engagements helps us win the battle against the billionaire algorithm.

221
00:16:23.103 --> 00:16:30.987
If you'd like to support the pod more directly, you can either donate directly at ffppod.com backslash donate.

222
00:16:31.587 --> 00:16:36.968
Or you can go to our new shop where you can buy some of our great merch.

223
00:16:37.628 --> 00:16:43.409
We are going to be donning that merch more frequently on the pod so we can shill accordingly.

224
00:16:43.770 --> 00:16:51.471
But as you all know, it's the two of us here bringing the greatest and the best newest science discoveries to you every week.

225
00:16:52.211 --> 00:16:57.792
And any support that we get from our great FFP nation is much appreciated.

226
00:17:00.993 --> 00:17:02.974
as it relates to science.

227
00:17:03.034 --> 00:17:12.638
Our second story is going to be about funding policy in the United States as it relates to science.

228
00:17:12.678 --> 00:17:19.540
Every time we cover a study on the show, um, it could be genetics, medicine, physics, space.

229
00:17:20.481 --> 00:17:26.063
We always talk about the final product, which is the published paper and usually the history and the buildup to that.

230
00:17:26.683 --> 00:17:26.863
Um,

231
00:17:27.343 --> 00:17:35.108
But what we don't talk about or see is the federal funding system that actually enables a lot of this fundamental research to happen.

232
00:17:35.388 --> 00:17:44.594
The number one funder of basic research for the American ecosystem is the federal government, and it's what makes it possible.

233
00:17:45.054 --> 00:17:49.577
And there's a recent controversy that's arisen around this, but...

234
00:17:50.377 --> 00:18:00.145
Before we get there, I thought it might be helpful to briefly talk about the basic process because many folks might not understand how this works.

235
00:18:00.225 --> 00:18:06.430
So in the U.S., Congress has what's known as the power of the purse, or if you're from Boston, Congress.

236
00:18:07.110 --> 00:18:07.590
Pocket book.

237
00:18:08.210 --> 00:18:09.331
But for the rest of us, the purse.

238
00:18:09.851 --> 00:18:11.691
The president proposes a budget every year.

239
00:18:12.212 --> 00:18:15.333
At the beginning of the year, he or she proposes a budget.

240
00:18:15.573 --> 00:18:23.355
But Congress ultimately decides how federal agencies are legally permitted to spend money and for what purposes.

241
00:18:23.835 --> 00:18:25.916
So the executive branch has all these responsibilities.

242
00:18:25.956 --> 00:18:29.697
But money and where it gets spent, Congress ultimately is decided there.

243
00:18:30.417 --> 00:18:39.846
OMB, which is the White House Office of Management and Budget, helps to execute the budget that is fundamentally decided by Congress.

244
00:18:39.866 --> 00:18:47.412
It apportions funding to executive agencies and sets government-wide rules about how that money can be spent.

245
00:18:47.453 --> 00:18:53.478
So Congress says, here's the money and who can spend it, and then OMB kind of just distributes it.

246
00:18:54.339 --> 00:18:54.899
how that goes.

247
00:18:54.959 --> 00:19:00.062
And this is how federal grants, especially in research, but not only in research, are administered.

248
00:19:00.302 --> 00:19:00.543
Okay.

249
00:19:02.618 --> 00:19:13.161
Normally, in the history of this process, the Office of Management and Budget doesn't select individual science awards or grants.

250
00:19:13.221 --> 00:19:16.482
It's not in the process of selecting who gets what money.

251
00:19:17.262 --> 00:19:25.624
That happens at each particular agency, National Institutes of Health, National Science Foundation, NASA, Department of Energy, where the experts are.

252
00:19:26.164 --> 00:19:28.365
They are the ones who get to decide how to.

253
00:19:29.045 --> 00:19:29.706
That happens.

254
00:19:29.746 --> 00:19:32.688
And the process is the agencies will announce a funding opportunity.

255
00:19:33.288 --> 00:19:35.470
Researchers will submit proposals.

256
00:19:36.191 --> 00:19:37.672
Experts evaluate their merit.

257
00:19:37.912 --> 00:19:38.592
Yep.

258
00:19:38.753 --> 00:19:41.034
As you know very well in this process.

259
00:19:41.074 --> 00:19:41.254
Yeah.

260
00:19:41.455 --> 00:19:45.698
And the agency officials ultimately decide which projects get to receive.

261
00:19:46.178 --> 00:19:46.598
Yeah.

262
00:19:46.738 --> 00:19:48.099
And shout out to my dad.

263
00:19:48.640 --> 00:19:55.103
He's one of the astrophysicists that's on a lot of these panels that like decides which grants get awarded and things like that.

264
00:19:55.424 --> 00:20:00.727
And an expert being on that is something you absolutely want to be there.

265
00:20:00.747 --> 00:20:07.711
And then from there, the university or research institution that receives the funding employs the researchers.

266
00:20:07.731 --> 00:20:08.631
They operate the labs.

267
00:20:08.651 --> 00:20:09.492
They conduct the work.

268
00:20:09.992 --> 00:20:13.874
And eventually produce what we talk about on the pod, which is the paper.

269
00:20:13.954 --> 00:20:15.375
So Congress funds it.

270
00:20:16.116 --> 00:20:17.636
OMB establishes the rules.

271
00:20:18.037 --> 00:20:20.018
Agencies select and manage the grants.

272
00:20:20.438 --> 00:20:22.439
Researchers do the science.

273
00:20:22.539 --> 00:20:24.840
That's how the process has worked forever.

274
00:20:27.508 --> 00:20:30.571
But now, you know, we're going to get into the current fight.

275
00:20:30.831 --> 00:20:31.031
Right.

276
00:20:31.071 --> 00:20:49.827
Before we do, I do want to give a lot of credit here to many of the science policy journalists who have been doggedly covering this story closely, particularly Jeffrey Mervis, Jocelyn Kaiser, Lauren Martin Agudelo, Michael Greshko, and David Malikoff at both Science and AAAS.

277
00:20:49.847 --> 00:20:50.107
Yes.

278
00:20:50.707 --> 00:21:04.333
Um, this is sort of in the weeds and they've taken a very complex bureaucratic funding and policy process and have tried to make it connect to the actual science and impact that it has for people.

279
00:21:04.873 --> 00:21:16.218
And this is really, again, a great source for us as we try to begin to now incorporate science funding policy into our discussions because we would not be able to, again, have a show without this.

280
00:21:16.238 --> 00:21:16.658
Yeah.

281
00:21:17.179 --> 00:21:23.545
So now we get to the current fight, and it's always over who has the power to decide.

282
00:21:24.986 --> 00:21:28.410
So I'm going to kind of read through a couple of the details here, which are a little bit in the weeds.

283
00:21:28.450 --> 00:21:35.376
But so on May 29th, OMB can only decide the rules, right?

284
00:21:35.396 --> 00:21:35.577
Right.

285
00:21:36.266 --> 00:21:45.454
OMB released this 412-page proposal to sort of revamp their role in distributing and managing grants and awards.

286
00:21:45.654 --> 00:21:47.035
And this is the White House effectively.

287
00:21:47.095 --> 00:21:48.296
This is the White House.

288
00:21:48.697 --> 00:21:50.338
And so this is a very important note.

289
00:21:50.558 --> 00:21:55.743
It's not some – it's literally the White House's Office of Management and Budget.

290
00:21:56.744 --> 00:22:08.473
Granted, they have a role in this process because they are the ones who initially derive and drive the national priorities when the budget process starts in January and February of every year.

291
00:22:09.534 --> 00:22:13.998
So this new proposal had until July 13th to provide comments.

292
00:22:14.839 --> 00:22:18.742
And OMB said that it wanted to sort of finalize these proposals.

293
00:22:18.922 --> 00:22:21.083
new rules by October 1st.

294
00:22:21.123 --> 00:22:30.045
The proposal applies to all federal grants, not just specifically science, but several of the provisions are kind of important.

295
00:22:30.365 --> 00:22:32.946
So we're gonna kind of just briefly walk through a few of these.

296
00:22:33.486 --> 00:22:36.207
So first, senior political appointees

297
00:22:36.827 --> 00:22:42.472
could independently review discretionary grant decisions before awards were issued, right?

298
00:22:42.712 --> 00:22:45.615
Even before they were actually issued to people, number one.

299
00:22:45.935 --> 00:22:58.126
Number two, peer review would, quote, remain a part of the process, but the proposal makes clear that scientific reviewers' recommendations, like your dad, as you just mentioned, would be advisory recommendations,

300
00:22:58.366 --> 00:22:59.448
And not controlling.

301
00:22:59.808 --> 00:23:00.029
Okay.

302
00:23:00.049 --> 00:23:00.209
Right.

303
00:23:00.389 --> 00:23:01.911
Currently, they have the controlling.

304
00:23:02.112 --> 00:23:03.373
What they say kind of goes.

305
00:23:03.574 --> 00:23:05.376
They're saying that's just more of just an opinion.

306
00:23:05.697 --> 00:23:06.758
And we get to decide.

307
00:23:07.059 --> 00:23:09.302
And we being these political appointees.

308
00:23:09.462 --> 00:23:09.662
Right.

309
00:23:10.063 --> 00:23:10.503
Great.

310
00:23:10.584 --> 00:23:10.904
Nice.

311
00:23:11.104 --> 00:23:14.830
Don't really have any scientific background.

312
00:23:14.850 --> 00:23:15.030
Yeah.

313
00:23:15.330 --> 00:23:30.614
Third, the government would have broader authority to end existing grants if officials determine they no longer advance the current agenda of whatever party controls the White House at that time in terms of the, quote, national interest.

314
00:23:30.934 --> 00:23:31.274
Okay.

315
00:23:31.434 --> 00:23:39.937
And then fourth, the proposal would impose major restrictions on international research collaborations with countries that are deemed to be a national security risk.

316
00:23:40.557 --> 00:23:41.217
The fourth one –

317
00:23:42.593 --> 00:23:43.473
Fourth one I get.

318
00:23:44.154 --> 00:23:48.116
That one has some standing and you could argue the details there.

319
00:23:48.216 --> 00:23:48.436
Yeah.

320
00:23:48.716 --> 00:23:49.036
Okay.

321
00:23:49.156 --> 00:23:51.517
So what is the argument from the White House, right?

322
00:23:52.398 --> 00:24:03.623
They're basically saying that they want to ensure that taxpayer money is lawfully executed on and that it's aligned with our priorities and there's no – the favorite phrase of D.C. – waste, fraud, and abuse.

323
00:24:04.063 --> 00:24:04.343
Right.

324
00:24:05.004 --> 00:24:10.467
I don't think if you look at the grand scheme of the budget that scientific funding and grant funding is the biggest source of waste, fraud, and abuse.

325
00:24:10.788 --> 00:24:21.615
But they argue that the peer review process has become insular and the final responsibility should remain to politically accountable appointees.

326
00:24:21.915 --> 00:24:24.837
That's the argument being made for why this proposal is being put in place.

327
00:24:24.977 --> 00:24:25.678
Okay.

328
00:24:27.254 --> 00:24:34.843
In a vacuum, you would maybe say, okay, maybe there's an argument here.

329
00:24:36.605 --> 00:24:42.432
But obviously the scientific community has reacted very strongly about this going well beyond science.

330
00:24:42.832 --> 00:25:06.882
financial oversight this is clearly a battle about power and culture and culture yeah because science which has always kind of brushed at the edges of culture has never been quite as part of a zeitgeist the zeitgeist as it has since covet happened in my view frankly at least in american culture yeah um where it's really become now a culture war issue in a way that it really never was before yeah

331
00:25:07.362 --> 00:25:14.730
So obviously the scientific community is arguing this is going to allow ideological nonsense to get involved in the process.

332
00:25:14.750 --> 00:25:26.482
So the Association of American Universities submitted a 47-page response, which I might add is the longest public comment in the organization's 126-year history.

333
00:25:27.783 --> 00:25:32.445
So clearly it struck a nerve because everyone understands what's going on here.

334
00:25:33.825 --> 00:25:37.106
And the primary – there's so many arguments to be made here.

335
00:25:37.366 --> 00:25:46.289
But the primary argument that they're making is that Congress, power of the purse, they ultimately are the deciders of where the money gets ascribed in terms of agency.

336
00:25:46.309 --> 00:25:46.689
That's right.

337
00:25:47.069 --> 00:25:52.431
Has not given OMB the authority to decide what categories of scientific research exist.

338
00:25:52.931 --> 00:25:54.373
may receive federal funding.

339
00:25:54.814 --> 00:26:00.280
That power lies purely within the agencies and their statutory directives.

340
00:26:00.480 --> 00:26:06.407
So effectively, the universities are using the Constitution to try and defend the way that we fund science.

341
00:26:06.427 --> 00:26:06.908
Which is...

342
00:26:11.513 --> 00:26:12.653
It is in the Constitution.

343
00:26:12.673 --> 00:26:12.933
Yeah.

344
00:26:13.153 --> 00:26:13.594
Literally.

345
00:26:13.874 --> 00:26:20.035
As well as the actual mechanism of the movement of and how money is budgeted.

346
00:26:20.895 --> 00:26:23.596
Like Congress decides how money is spent.

347
00:26:23.716 --> 00:26:23.976
Yeah.

348
00:26:24.096 --> 00:26:24.416
Period.

349
00:26:24.696 --> 00:26:31.198
The executive branch is effectively trying now to insert themselves in the process of how money is spent.

350
00:26:31.278 --> 00:26:31.998
Yeah.

351
00:26:32.018 --> 00:26:38.580
So there's to your point, there's a constitutional level issue here beyond even some of the practical matters.

352
00:26:39.100 --> 00:26:39.300
Yeah.

353
00:26:40.978 --> 00:26:48.622
What's interesting is this proposal generated almost 500,000, 497,000 public recorded submissions.

354
00:26:48.642 --> 00:26:57.608
So anytime there's proposals like these at different agencies or offices within all the branches of government, they open up it to public comment.

355
00:26:57.808 --> 00:27:01.490
So almost half a million comments were like, obviously, this is ridiculous.

356
00:27:02.450 --> 00:27:11.333
So again, I know this is dense, but I think this is really important because the implications here could not be more important to cover.

357
00:27:11.733 --> 00:27:17.434
So that's what's currently happening in terms of OMB trying to change the process.

358
00:27:17.754 --> 00:27:30.998
But the administration that's currently in the White House has already terminated and suspended several existing grants that were appropriated by Congress last year.

359
00:27:31.198 --> 00:27:31.398
Yeah.

360
00:27:31.798 --> 00:27:33.339
So Congress decided where the money went.

361
00:27:34.740 --> 00:27:35.260
It's law.

362
00:27:35.560 --> 00:27:37.221
It's not like an opinion.

363
00:27:38.241 --> 00:27:51.828
And the White House has begun to say, even for either programs that have yet to receive allocations or some programs that have received their first batch, but not the second, to say, hey, you're not getting any more money.

364
00:27:52.829 --> 00:27:55.910
something you may or may not have some context for.

365
00:27:56.030 --> 00:27:56.311
Oh, yeah.

366
00:27:56.391 --> 00:28:04.656
I mean, I have several friends in the university ecosystem that are very worried about their future and their present scientific endeavors, right?

367
00:28:04.696 --> 00:28:16.182
Like they're in the middle of science projects that they have a few experiments left before they publish the big paper in Nature and Science and Cell and all this other stuff.

368
00:28:16.262 --> 00:28:16.763
And, yeah, yeah.

369
00:28:17.724 --> 00:28:23.311
All of a sudden, the grant funding is gone and you haven't quite finished the story.

370
00:28:23.371 --> 00:28:23.852
What do you do?

371
00:28:24.112 --> 00:28:24.353
Right.

372
00:28:24.573 --> 00:28:26.816
It's it's really tragic.

373
00:28:28.292 --> 00:28:37.959
So as we have two sides of the story here, there's the proposal that's happening, but there's actions that have already been being taken since January of last year.

374
00:28:38.900 --> 00:28:52.830
And on July 17th, the federal judge ruled that agencies cannot use newly adopted political or pragmatic priorities to retroactively cancel grants under different criteria.

375
00:28:52.850 --> 00:28:52.950
Yeah.

376
00:28:53.270 --> 00:29:02.102
So if in 2025, Congress appropriated money based on the national priorities at the time, and then in 2026, a new administration comes in and says, we don't want to do that anymore.

377
00:29:03.263 --> 00:29:04.365
You can't do that.

378
00:29:04.565 --> 00:29:09.612
So that's been established in federal court.

379
00:29:09.912 --> 00:29:17.996
Now, a caveat to that is the government may retain legitimate authority to terminate grants, which will still continue to be challenged.

380
00:29:18.016 --> 00:29:30.663
But the judge's central point was that it cannot change the rules after an award has already been made, which is where we get the proposal language, which says they can involve themselves prior to the awards being distributed.

381
00:29:31.683 --> 00:29:43.276
This has continued where the Department of Health and Human Services notified 70 researchers funded by the Agency of Healthcare and Research Quality that their projects would not receive their next annual funding installments.

382
00:29:43.676 --> 00:29:47.940
So this is not even just in things like physics and biology.

383
00:29:47.960 --> 00:29:49.422
This is also impacting technology.

384
00:29:49.642 --> 00:29:55.785
health research studies, those projects represented approximately $185 million in multi-year commitments.

385
00:29:56.185 --> 00:29:59.847
And so they've already received a distribution, and they're saying you're getting no more money.

386
00:29:59.967 --> 00:30:00.187
Yeah.

387
00:30:00.547 --> 00:30:02.168
Even though they've already received the money for it.

388
00:30:02.788 --> 00:30:02.928
Yeah.

389
00:30:04.955 --> 00:30:12.001
What they're trying to do now as the legal battle has continued is change the language about what it is that they're doing.

390
00:30:12.041 --> 00:30:15.864
So HHS said the grants were not technically terminated.

391
00:30:16.184 --> 00:30:20.948
They were simply not awarded continued funding because it's a multi.

392
00:30:21.148 --> 00:30:28.633
So rather than saying we're terminating funding for something that is a single allocation, we're saying, oh, this was a multi-year thing.

393
00:30:28.994 --> 00:30:34.318
And we're discontinuing the continued funding of what is a multi-year install.

394
00:30:34.858 --> 00:30:53.283
that doesn't make any sense are you serious so it's basically termination under a different name termination but they're trying to just voodoo magic they're saying they're not terminating they're just discontinuing right right which very nice i'm not the thesaurus but they may be synonyms in this context yeah um

395
00:30:55.025 --> 00:30:59.006
And this is so this is both a constitutional and budgetary dispute that that's important.

396
00:30:59.346 --> 00:31:02.587
So Congress does not vote on individual research projects.

397
00:31:02.607 --> 00:31:02.847
Right.

398
00:31:03.087 --> 00:31:03.268
Right.

399
00:31:03.368 --> 00:31:05.268
It just appropriates money to an agency.

400
00:31:05.808 --> 00:31:07.729
That agency chooses individual grants.

401
00:31:08.449 --> 00:31:12.570
Multi-year grants may also receive their funding in annual installments rather than all at once.

402
00:31:12.851 --> 00:31:17.632
So you have a program that gets a $50 million allocation in 2025, but it's spread over four years.

403
00:31:17.732 --> 00:31:18.112
Yeah, yeah.

404
00:31:18.192 --> 00:31:32.042
I mean, a lot of the, like, some of the grants that I was supported during my PhD were these multi-year grants where, like, my advisor or, like, the collaboration that I was a part of would get money every year, right?

405
00:31:32.062 --> 00:31:32.982
You don't get a lump sum.

406
00:31:33.883 --> 00:31:42.590
And so the debate is really around like the executive branch doesn't have unlimited discretion to decide their role in, again, managing the rules.

407
00:31:42.810 --> 00:31:43.190
Yeah.

408
00:31:43.290 --> 00:31:44.711
It's an administrative rule.

409
00:31:44.851 --> 00:31:45.932
Yeah, it's never been that way.

410
00:31:45.992 --> 00:31:47.153
It's not a discretionary rule.

411
00:31:47.413 --> 00:31:51.036
And this is a very, very contentious issue right now.

412
00:31:51.056 --> 00:31:52.897
So the central dispute is whether...

413
00:31:54.378 --> 00:32:10.863
the administration is simply managing the congressional funded programs or whether replacing Congress's priorities has, you know, their own right to do like, if they have their own right to basically displace what Congress has already decided to do.

414
00:32:11.363 --> 00:32:20.686
And the last note here before we wrap up on this is there's sort of three different fronts that this battle is being fought

415
00:32:23.040 --> 00:32:30.526
OMB, Office of Management and Budget, is trying to rewrite the government-wide rules that then gives them authority to say you can't get money.

416
00:32:31.567 --> 00:32:39.933
Congress is in the process of negotiating the next fiscal year's appropriation bills at this same time.

417
00:32:40.394 --> 00:32:50.422
And federal courts are weighing in on how much authorities the White House effectively has on canceling existing awards.

418
00:32:53.263 --> 00:33:03.306
Three branches of government, the executive, the legislative, and the judicial are concurrently engaging in a battle to really define what happens here.

419
00:33:04.547 --> 00:33:08.028
The comment period for the rule proposal changes is over.

420
00:33:09.068 --> 00:33:16.732
uh, OMB wants to set the statutory deadline for October 1st, at which point this would then take play.

421
00:33:16.792 --> 00:33:20.834
This, these new rules would go into place for fiscal year, 2027.

422
00:33:21.254 --> 00:33:24.476
They're making the argument that this is about accountability.

423
00:33:25.396 --> 00:33:30.519
It is clearly not account about accountability because there's already systems in place to deal with that.

424
00:33:31.059 --> 00:33:33.020
Uh, the real kind of, uh,

425
00:33:34.368 --> 00:33:45.332
issue is does the executive branch have the authority to make individual funding decisions within programs that Congress has already authorized?

426
00:33:45.833 --> 00:33:49.094
And again, this goes back to it's a fundamental constitutional question.

427
00:33:49.994 --> 00:33:57.419
Because it literally goes counter to the structure of our co-equal branches of government.

428
00:33:57.800 --> 00:34:07.646
So will federal research continue to be evaluated under rules disclosed in advance, informed by expert review, and tied to programs funded by Congress?

429
00:34:08.186 --> 00:34:15.411
Or will every grant now be contingent on the changing political priorities of whoever's in the White House?

430
00:34:15.871 --> 00:34:15.991
Yeah.

431
00:34:17.172 --> 00:34:18.533
It moves all the time.

432
00:34:18.593 --> 00:34:24.175
So just because it stops for a four-year cycle or an eight-year cycle does not mean it's then going to flip the other direction.

433
00:34:24.195 --> 00:34:39.282
And we cannot afford to have a seesaw problem in what has made this country, a huge part of what has made this country stable and successful and resilient.

434
00:34:40.699 --> 00:34:47.744
is the fact that how we won World War II is because we've done this funding in a way that's already been structured.

435
00:34:47.924 --> 00:34:51.866
Yeah, I mean, you can go back to our America 250th anniversary episode, right?

436
00:34:52.326 --> 00:35:03.834
Like, I think something like 80% of the stories that we covered were because of federal funding or because of, like, funding that came from taxpayer money somehow, right?

437
00:35:04.314 --> 00:35:08.016
And I'm sure a lot of those grants were awarded...

438
00:35:09.137 --> 00:35:10.598
Without political oversight.

439
00:35:10.618 --> 00:35:10.818
Correct.

440
00:35:10.838 --> 00:35:10.998
Okay.

441
00:35:11.018 --> 00:35:18.581
Because I doubt the powers that be are going to understand why it's important to study bacterial immune systems.

442
00:35:19.181 --> 00:35:19.461
Okay.

443
00:35:19.781 --> 00:35:24.423
But then we get like restriction enzymes, genetic engineering, CRISPR.

444
00:35:25.984 --> 00:35:26.684
Come on, guys.

445
00:35:26.964 --> 00:35:27.605
What are we doing?

446
00:35:27.765 --> 00:35:32.587
I don't want the people that did not understand that studies using transgenic mice.

447
00:35:32.827 --> 00:35:33.147
Yeah.

448
00:35:33.727 --> 00:35:35.988
Wasn't talking about the.

449
00:35:37.293 --> 00:35:38.594
The gender of mice.

450
00:35:38.614 --> 00:35:39.495
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

451
00:35:39.535 --> 00:35:40.255
Like, you know what I mean?

452
00:35:40.315 --> 00:35:44.558
Like, that's... We can't... Yeah, transgen, and then they're like, Ugh!

453
00:35:45.319 --> 00:35:45.799
Guys.

454
00:35:46.659 --> 00:35:47.140
Like, how...

455
00:35:47.180 --> 00:35:51.022
They should not be in charge of this kind of power.

456
00:35:51.142 --> 00:35:51.883
This is insane.

457
00:35:52.083 --> 00:35:56.606
We're gonna keep you all updated on this process, because it's happening in real time.

458
00:35:57.407 --> 00:35:59.748
We will know more over the next couple of weeks.

459
00:35:59.808 --> 00:36:00.409
The one...

460
00:36:01.229 --> 00:36:15.554
note that I'll make is this is not we're not passengers to this process and Congress is not particularly happy about this because whether Congress cares about the underlying science or not, Congress is not in the business of allowing the executive branch to take power away from them.

461
00:36:15.594 --> 00:36:15.834
Yes.

462
00:36:15.894 --> 00:36:16.134
Yeah.

463
00:36:16.454 --> 00:36:16.854
Period.

464
00:36:17.334 --> 00:36:21.856
And so it is now becoming a battle between the legislative and the executive.

465
00:36:22.576 --> 00:36:24.437
And it's a midterm election year.

466
00:36:24.937 --> 00:36:31.938
And so members of Congress are particularly sensitive to issues that are animating their constituents.

467
00:36:32.378 --> 00:36:49.622
And this is something that if you believe that basic science research is something that's important and that you value and that you think should continue to exist in the construction that it does, you have the opportunity as we get into August recess, members of Congress are going to be going to their home districts.

468
00:36:52.363 --> 00:36:55.646
attend, call their offices, send them emails.

469
00:36:55.966 --> 00:36:57.027
They track this stuff.

470
00:36:57.127 --> 00:37:02.971
One of the greatest secrets ever is that people don't understand how much these members actually listen to people who reach out.

471
00:37:03.271 --> 00:37:04.532
The problem is no one reaches out.

472
00:37:04.772 --> 00:37:11.476
And so all these specialty issues get kind of overlooked because no one talks about it.

473
00:37:11.857 --> 00:37:14.579
So it's time to put the pressure on on this issue.

474
00:37:14.979 --> 00:37:17.501
Again, the system is working totally fine.

475
00:37:18.181 --> 00:37:20.303
We don't want the White House of any administration

476
00:37:21.363 --> 00:37:31.610
involving themselves in discretionary issues around funding as it relates to Congress's mandate and the mandate of the agencies who do have the experts to make these decisions.

477
00:37:31.951 --> 00:37:36.554
And again, if you want changes around who those experts are in those agencies, there's a process for that.

478
00:37:37.154 --> 00:37:38.295
We don't need the White House involved.

479
00:37:38.863 --> 00:37:39.504
We really don't.

480
00:37:41.406 --> 00:37:45.031
Well, yeah, that's a... And you said this is a developing story, right?

481
00:37:45.051 --> 00:37:47.293
So the decision is moving to October 1st.

482
00:37:48.034 --> 00:37:50.157
So it's like right before the elections.

483
00:37:50.577 --> 00:37:50.757
Right.

484
00:37:50.818 --> 00:37:54.762
It's going to be a hot-button issue, and we need to make it a hot-button issue.

485
00:37:54.782 --> 00:37:55.323
A hot-button issue.

486
00:37:55.363 --> 00:37:55.583
Yeah.

487
00:37:56.544 --> 00:37:56.845
You know...

488
00:37:58.766 --> 00:38:03.750
You guys, federal funding of science is the bedrock of American innovation.

489
00:38:04.230 --> 00:38:08.813
And American innovation is the bedrock of why this country is so great.

490
00:38:09.294 --> 00:38:12.416
Okay, so we need to get on it, guys.

491
00:38:12.476 --> 00:38:13.196
It matters a lot.

492
00:38:13.317 --> 00:38:13.597
Yeah.

493
00:38:14.237 --> 00:38:14.957
It matters a lot.

494
00:38:15.618 --> 00:38:28.963
And I know some folks' eyes will glaze over, but again, we wouldn't be able to talk about something like our next story without this ecosystem of funding because ultimately doing anything costs money.

495
00:38:29.583 --> 00:38:34.906
And I'm really excited about this story because it was all over my feed.

496
00:38:36.126 --> 00:38:36.967
All over my feed.

497
00:38:37.067 --> 00:38:44.832
Yeah, this was kind of huge because it happened in the middle of the World Cup final.

498
00:38:45.693 --> 00:38:46.914
It was actually crazy.

499
00:38:46.934 --> 00:39:00.943
The tweet that is at the center of this major, major mathematical breakthrough was tweeted in the middle of the World Cup final, which is when the entire world was fixated on something else.

500
00:39:01.780 --> 00:39:02.701
Who won that?

501
00:39:02.761 --> 00:39:03.201
I don't know.

502
00:39:03.221 --> 00:39:04.663
I can't remember.

503
00:39:04.923 --> 00:39:06.525
I know it wasn't Argentina.

504
00:39:06.585 --> 00:39:07.606
It wasn't Argentina.

505
00:39:07.626 --> 00:39:08.127
That's right.

506
00:39:08.167 --> 00:39:08.667
That's right.

507
00:39:08.708 --> 00:39:09.609
It was not.

508
00:39:09.929 --> 00:39:10.550
It was not.

509
00:39:10.950 --> 00:39:12.312
It was not Argentina.

510
00:39:12.332 --> 00:39:12.712
That's right.

511
00:39:12.732 --> 00:39:14.274
You love to see it.

512
00:39:14.414 --> 00:39:17.998
I just, you know, for everyone who suffered through our World Cup coverage, it's over.

513
00:39:18.479 --> 00:39:20.001
So we'll stop the sports ball.

514
00:39:20.021 --> 00:39:21.282
But I just, I couldn't remember.

515
00:39:21.322 --> 00:39:22.543
Yeah, yeah.

516
00:39:22.623 --> 00:39:23.964
It's good to remind oneself.

517
00:39:24.084 --> 00:39:26.666
Just to set the record straight.

518
00:39:26.686 --> 00:39:27.026
That's right.

519
00:39:27.346 --> 00:39:27.766
That's right.

520
00:39:28.227 --> 00:39:35.692
So this next story is about AI and how it is encroaching on fundamental mathematics.

521
00:39:35.812 --> 00:39:49.882
It's very, very cool because, I mean, it's completely obvious, I think, to everyone who does not live under a rock that we are living through one of the most disorienting times in the history of human intellectual life.

522
00:39:50.282 --> 00:40:05.076
OK, this is especially true when it comes to really, really hard intellectual disciplines like mathematics, because for thousands of years, mathematics has been the one domain where human beings can claim something that is very close to absolute certainty.

523
00:40:05.477 --> 00:40:05.677
Right.

524
00:40:05.977 --> 00:40:10.842
We can say that the act of understanding and the act of proving are one and the same thing.

525
00:40:12.403 --> 00:40:18.687
and a mathematical proof, it's been here since the time of the ancient Greeks with Euclid.

526
00:40:19.587 --> 00:40:22.549
It's a certificate of the truth, right?

527
00:40:23.570 --> 00:40:33.396
And it's a map as to why something has to be true, and very crucially, for the longest time, it's been something that only human minds can produce.

528
00:40:33.656 --> 00:40:34.477
Very important point.

529
00:40:34.517 --> 00:40:35.358
Very important point.

530
00:40:35.838 --> 00:40:38.420
It's, you know, we've seen a lot of disciplines

531
00:40:39.641 --> 00:40:41.583
fall to computation.

532
00:40:42.064 --> 00:40:44.407
Chess has fallen to computation.

533
00:40:44.928 --> 00:40:47.471
The game Go has fallen to computation.

534
00:40:47.872 --> 00:40:50.355
Protein folding has fallen to computation.

535
00:40:50.495 --> 00:40:53.179
And now we are finally seeing the...

536
00:40:55.481 --> 00:41:00.505
The shining city on the hill, which is pure mathematics, it is starting to fall, right?

537
00:41:00.785 --> 00:41:03.987
There's crumbles in the infrastructure.

538
00:41:04.267 --> 00:41:16.276
I just want to briefly note that, you know, in our time at Princeton, some of the smartest people we had the pleasure of being able to be around and breathe the same air that they did were smart.

539
00:41:17.712 --> 00:41:33.435
the maths folks yeah we're the maths folks yeah like yeah like they were a level of smart that is really hard to wrap my own head around yeah yeah yeah same for me i mean i i i took some courses with them right and i was just like i'm gonna stick to it

540
00:41:34.336 --> 00:41:36.958
I'll stick to the physics department, which is right next door.

541
00:41:37.278 --> 00:41:43.203
I took a few math courses and it was extremely fun, but I could just never see myself being a math major.

542
00:41:43.503 --> 00:41:47.546
I mean, even in the physics department, I was like, man, what am I doing here?

543
00:41:47.907 --> 00:41:50.829
But the math department was its own little game.

544
00:41:51.409 --> 00:41:55.773
And so this particular story has to do with an AI system.

545
00:41:55.993 --> 00:42:07.962
It was used by a researcher at Anthropic, which is like the synonymous, the company of Claude, the company that wants AI safety, AI safety.

546
00:42:08.042 --> 00:42:08.923
Regulatory capture.

547
00:42:09.258 --> 00:42:09.518
Right.

548
00:42:09.919 --> 00:42:23.548
And it has apparently disproved something called the Jacobian conjecture, which is a problem that has been at the center of algebraic geometry and the theory of polynomial maps for about 90 years.

549
00:42:24.388 --> 00:42:25.069
It's insane.

550
00:42:25.089 --> 00:42:29.812
It's not proved it in the conventional sense because what it's actually done is disproved.

551
00:42:30.525 --> 00:42:31.185
the conjecture.

552
00:42:31.485 --> 00:42:38.807
It is provided a counter example which is a mathematical object that violates whatever the rule is.

553
00:42:39.627 --> 00:42:43.648
It's a bit easier to do, albeit, than actually proving something, right?

554
00:42:43.728 --> 00:42:50.190
If you if you say a statement, proving the statement is a lot harder than just saying, hey, here's an example that shows it's not true.

555
00:42:50.630 --> 00:42:55.431
Because all you have to do is produce an example and boom, the debate is over, especially in mathematics.

556
00:42:55.711 --> 00:42:57.012
We're going to get into sort of

557
00:42:57.912 --> 00:43:16.758
how that works and why it's kind of easier than proving, but I think it's still an insane achievement that a machine, effectively, a neural network that is just doing multiplications of matrices at the end of the day, is creating this kind of truth.

558
00:43:17.767 --> 00:43:23.313
Out of something that for 90 years the top mathematicians have been apparently wasting their time with.

559
00:43:23.833 --> 00:43:24.915
Yep.

560
00:43:24.935 --> 00:43:25.515
Trying to prove.

561
00:43:25.695 --> 00:43:33.303
And this is part of the ongoing debate about whether these AI systems are, quote, stochastic parrots that...

562
00:43:34.024 --> 00:43:58.736
don't have any original thought and or anything that they do that's original is just by gathering all the information on the internet and or brute forcing and i understand that sentiment but i think it is a little bit more nuanced than the way in which it's presented in this black and white way exactly and i think like if you're not a mathematician i

563
00:43:59.216 --> 00:44:10.283
this should still matter because for one, it's showing the power of AI to like think complex things in a very, in a very real sense, right?

564
00:44:10.363 --> 00:44:12.264
AI is restructuring the labor markets.

565
00:44:13.485 --> 00:44:19.408
And now it's going after really creative mathematics is a creative discipline, right?

566
00:44:20.128 --> 00:44:22.630
And a lot of people say that AI can't be creative.

567
00:44:22.810 --> 00:44:24.391
It's as you said, a stochastic parrot.

568
00:44:24.711 --> 00:44:27.393
Well, in this case, nobody had a, nobody had a proof of this.

569
00:44:28.422 --> 00:44:32.686
And it has a novel proof that the smartest people on the planet couldn't come up with.

570
00:44:32.907 --> 00:44:33.868
For almost a century.

571
00:44:34.108 --> 00:44:36.150
Yeah.

572
00:44:36.310 --> 00:44:37.071
It's huge, right?

573
00:44:37.511 --> 00:44:41.755
So mathematics, right, as I said, it's been the gold standard of human reasoning.

574
00:44:43.297 --> 00:44:50.404
It's the language of physics, the foundations of electrical engineering, every other kind of engineering, economics, medicine.

575
00:44:50.424 --> 00:44:51.465
When we say...

576
00:44:52.686 --> 00:44:53.827
Literally everything.

577
00:44:53.887 --> 00:44:54.688
Literally everything.

578
00:44:54.708 --> 00:44:58.411
And when we say that something is mathematically proven, we mean it is literally true.

579
00:44:58.951 --> 00:44:59.131
Right?

580
00:44:59.191 --> 00:45:08.799
It's not something out of physics where like you can do an experiment and then 400 years later somebody can disprove the experiment because they went farther in the decimal places to measure something.

581
00:45:09.119 --> 00:45:10.581
Which has happened time and time again.

582
00:45:10.741 --> 00:45:14.684
In mathematics, the decimals are inherent in your proof.

583
00:45:14.744 --> 00:45:14.964
Right?

584
00:45:15.044 --> 00:45:16.586
It's like it's there and it's true.

585
00:45:16.606 --> 00:45:21.930
And if I've proven that it's true, the logic is eternal.

586
00:45:22.230 --> 00:45:31.576
Would it be fair to say that mathematics is one of, if not the only thing that we have where you can say that there is an objective truth when it comes to a mathematical proof?

587
00:45:31.736 --> 00:45:36.799
Yes, it is the pedestal of objective truth, right?

588
00:45:37.339 --> 00:45:39.541
You go from there are integers...

589
00:45:40.401 --> 00:45:44.184
And I can add and multiply them to then all of the stuff, right?

590
00:45:44.424 --> 00:45:50.087
Euclid's theorem that there are an infinite number of prime numbers, that still holds true today.

591
00:45:50.448 --> 00:45:52.129
Because no one can poke a hole into it.

592
00:45:52.169 --> 00:45:52.449
Why?

593
00:45:52.809 --> 00:45:53.950
Because it's a proof.

594
00:45:54.450 --> 00:45:57.632
They couldn't poke a hole back then because the logic was sound.

595
00:45:58.013 --> 00:45:59.734
And logic is something that is eternal.

596
00:46:00.654 --> 00:46:02.975
And so it's really cool.

597
00:46:03.275 --> 00:46:16.519
And when we start thinking about AI starting to do mathematics, not just assisting and not just suggesting, but actually proving and disproving things, then we start asking philosophical existential questions.

598
00:46:17.239 --> 00:46:18.780
And those become urgent, right?

599
00:46:18.841 --> 00:46:20.922
What is the role of the human mathematician?

600
00:46:21.303 --> 00:46:22.864
What is the role of the human mind?

601
00:46:23.324 --> 00:46:35.295
What does understanding mean if a machine can generate a proof that is true, that we can verify somehow through some kind of computation to be true, but we can't even understand it, right?

602
00:46:35.996 --> 00:46:38.358
These are now becoming real questions.

603
00:46:38.518 --> 00:46:39.239
It's kind of crazy.

604
00:46:39.259 --> 00:46:39.359
Yeah.

605
00:46:39.907 --> 00:46:47.933
So this is going to be a deep dive where I'm going to talk about the Jacobian conjecture, which is the thing that this AI model has disproven.

606
00:46:48.353 --> 00:46:52.476
We're really going to get into the weeds of it, and I think you're going to be able to understand exactly what it's done.

607
00:46:53.417 --> 00:47:06.646
And then we're going to talk about the modern phenomenon of AI and mathematics and why everyone, including mathematicians, are very worried.

608
00:47:06.666 --> 00:47:07.367
Okay?

609
00:47:07.387 --> 00:47:07.587
Okay.

610
00:47:08.327 --> 00:47:10.069
So let's start with the Jacobian conjecture.

611
00:47:10.089 --> 00:47:16.194
It's something that was proposed by Heinrich Keller in 1939, so nearly 100 years ago.

612
00:47:16.954 --> 00:47:20.898
And it addresses a fundamental local-to-global paradigm.

613
00:47:20.998 --> 00:47:22.979
It has to do with maps.

614
00:47:23.760 --> 00:47:24.000
Okay?

615
00:47:24.441 --> 00:47:25.782
By maps, I mean...

616
00:47:27.038 --> 00:47:31.561
going from one set of coordinates to another set of coordinates.

617
00:47:31.881 --> 00:47:41.286
So in order to understand the Jacobian conjecture, we have to first understand functional maps, which in physics language we like to call coordinate transformations.

618
00:47:41.827 --> 00:47:42.567
Here's the idea.

619
00:47:43.327 --> 00:47:43.848
A map...

620
00:47:45.050 --> 00:47:59.183
in this mathematical sense, is when you take a coordinate plane or a hyperplane or many-dimensional plane, and all of the points in your original space get mapped to a new space.

621
00:47:59.804 --> 00:48:02.746
In this case, what we're seeing is a 2D plane

622
00:48:03.667 --> 00:48:05.749
being mapped to another 2D plane.

623
00:48:05.950 --> 00:48:06.190
Okay?

624
00:48:06.390 --> 00:48:14.379
There's some kind of nonlinear transformation where the new x-coordinate and the new y-coordinate depend on the old x-coordinate and the old y-coordinate, right?

625
00:48:14.840 --> 00:48:19.064
In this case, a square is taken into a parallelogram.

626
00:48:19.931 --> 00:48:27.336
Notice that the new X can depend on both the old X and Y, not just the X.

627
00:48:27.636 --> 00:48:30.497
And the new Y can depend on both sets of coordinates.

628
00:48:30.938 --> 00:48:32.779
This can happen in higher dimensions as well.

629
00:48:33.179 --> 00:48:40.423
The Jacobian is the ratio between the new area and the old area.

630
00:48:40.704 --> 00:48:42.525
Which can also scale from 2D.

631
00:48:43.415 --> 00:48:44.195
Yes.

632
00:48:44.235 --> 00:48:45.756
You can have volumes, for example.

633
00:48:45.776 --> 00:48:50.158
You can have a volume in 3D that goes to a new volume in 3D, right?

634
00:48:50.178 --> 00:48:57.401
A cube can become like a weird kind of rhomboid, whatever, 3D prism is what it's called, I think.

635
00:48:57.601 --> 00:49:02.903
And then you're comparing the ratio between the volume or the area, depending on what dimensional space you're talking about.

636
00:49:02.923 --> 00:49:05.444
Between the two is where the Jacobian comes in.

637
00:49:05.464 --> 00:49:06.124
Yes, exactly.

638
00:49:06.144 --> 00:49:11.608
And in this case, I think from my eye, the area is about the same.

639
00:49:11.768 --> 00:49:14.811
So the Jacobian in this transform would be one.

640
00:49:15.391 --> 00:49:15.971
Okay?

641
00:49:16.131 --> 00:49:17.352
That's what the Jacobian means.

642
00:49:17.432 --> 00:49:23.677
Effectively, it's saying, okay, I have a map, and that map is preserving area if the Jacobian is one.

643
00:49:23.697 --> 00:49:27.700
If the Jacobian is greater than one, then it's going to larger cases, right?

644
00:49:27.740 --> 00:49:27.900
Right.

645
00:49:28.520 --> 00:49:35.645
And like when I think about maps, the reason why it's called a map is because it really starts from this concept of like maps of the earth.

646
00:49:36.085 --> 00:49:36.265
Right.

647
00:49:36.325 --> 00:49:43.290
You can think about the Mercator projection or these other projections that change the area and change the shape.

648
00:49:43.410 --> 00:49:46.773
But keep sorry, they change the shape, but they keep the area the same.

649
00:49:46.793 --> 00:49:48.254
For example, with the Mercator projection.

650
00:49:48.294 --> 00:49:48.454
Right.

651
00:49:49.014 --> 00:49:52.236
We all know that areas near the poles get larger.

652
00:49:52.696 --> 00:49:56.398
So the Jacobian near the poles is greater than one.

653
00:49:56.538 --> 00:49:56.758
Right?

654
00:49:57.038 --> 00:50:00.660
That's why Africa looks small and Greenland looks the size of Africa.

655
00:50:01.401 --> 00:50:08.664
Because the Jacobian near Greenland is much larger than the Jacobian near Africa when it comes to the Mercator projection.

656
00:50:08.704 --> 00:50:15.468
But there's other projections where they try to preserve the Jacobian everywhere, but then that's going to distort the shape in some sense.

657
00:50:15.488 --> 00:50:15.728
Exactly.

658
00:50:15.868 --> 00:50:20.310
So people would argue which is better when you talk about geographic maps.

659
00:50:20.350 --> 00:50:22.471
Is it better to keep the Jacobian closer to one?

660
00:50:22.571 --> 00:50:23.331
Yeah.

661
00:50:23.411 --> 00:50:29.553
Where you're going to get some shape distortion or is it better to have it have shape clarity?

662
00:50:29.733 --> 00:50:29.953
Yeah.

663
00:50:30.053 --> 00:50:34.415
But you have distortions at some extremes as it relates.

664
00:50:34.675 --> 00:50:34.875
Very.

665
00:50:34.915 --> 00:50:35.616
OK. Yeah.

666
00:50:35.656 --> 00:50:38.418
So that's what we're talking about when we talk about Jacobians.

667
00:50:38.498 --> 00:50:45.944
OK, it's really it's a it's a ratio of how my transformation is changing little tiny areas, infinitesimal areas.

668
00:50:46.364 --> 00:50:46.504
Right.

669
00:50:46.524 --> 00:50:49.506
Because in calculus, we think about like there's continuous transformation.

670
00:50:49.546 --> 00:50:53.269
So the Jacobian here can be different from the Jacobian there and so on and so forth.

671
00:50:53.309 --> 00:50:55.091
It's not a family in the Game of Thrones.

672
00:50:55.311 --> 00:50:56.552
No, no, not at all.

673
00:50:56.872 --> 00:50:59.434
And so let's do a very simple case, okay?

674
00:50:59.654 --> 00:51:00.794
A linear transformation.

675
00:51:00.874 --> 00:51:01.055
Yes.

676
00:51:01.375 --> 00:51:05.437
Now, in this case, this is a very simple matrix, 2, 1, 1, 2, okay?

677
00:51:05.717 --> 00:51:09.480
When we multiply that by any 2D vector...

678
00:51:10.308 --> 00:51:11.469
we're going to get a new vector.

679
00:51:11.509 --> 00:51:14.310
For example, the red vector is getting slightly skewed like that.

680
00:51:14.590 --> 00:51:16.371
So the red vector is really a 1, 0.

681
00:51:16.391 --> 00:51:21.194
That's the x-axis, just 1 on the x-axis, 0 on the y-axis.

682
00:51:21.534 --> 00:51:27.037
That gets transformed to 2 on the x-axis and 1 on the y-axis, right?

683
00:51:27.517 --> 00:51:28.898
Similarly, the y...

684
00:51:29.598 --> 00:51:35.963
unit vector, which is 0, 1, that gets transformed to 1, 2, which means 1 on the x-axis, 2 on the y-axis.

685
00:51:35.983 --> 00:51:41.587
That's why the green arrow is slanted more towards the y-axis, the red arrow is slanted more towards the x-axis.

686
00:51:41.947 --> 00:51:47.511
And in this case, the determinant of that matrix, if you were to do it, it's 4 minus 1, so that's 3.

687
00:51:47.892 --> 00:51:51.955
You can see that the square becomes a rhombus that's the size of 3.

688
00:51:52.455 --> 00:51:55.678
And it has to do with the determinant of that matrix.

689
00:51:56.038 --> 00:51:58.920
So when we say a Jacobian determinant, that's what we're talking about.

690
00:51:59.140 --> 00:51:59.380
Okay?

691
00:51:59.560 --> 00:51:59.740
Yes.

692
00:52:00.160 --> 00:52:02.041
Okay, so this is a very simple case.

693
00:52:02.561 --> 00:52:10.784
Now let's give you kind of a more complicated case, but one of my favorite coordinate transformations as a physicist, which is the Lorentz transformation.

694
00:52:10.884 --> 00:52:14.666
This is the transformation that we know and love from relativity.

695
00:52:14.826 --> 00:52:15.026
Right.

696
00:52:15.366 --> 00:52:15.566
Right?

697
00:52:15.706 --> 00:52:18.327
In special relativity, we have the Lorentz transformation.

698
00:52:19.607 --> 00:52:20.488
You might have heard that...

699
00:52:21.386 --> 00:52:26.189
When we move fast, length contracts and time dilates.

700
00:52:26.449 --> 00:52:29.891
So the clock runs slower and length gets shorter.

701
00:52:30.932 --> 00:52:32.693
That's two different things, right?

702
00:52:33.073 --> 00:52:36.735
Our coordinate in this case is, let's just think about 1D, right?

703
00:52:36.956 --> 00:52:37.476
There's a length.

704
00:52:37.536 --> 00:52:38.697
I'm like moving in this direction.

705
00:52:38.737 --> 00:52:42.319
So there's a length forward and backwards in the direction of my movement.

706
00:52:43.740 --> 00:52:45.501
And there's also time.

707
00:52:45.621 --> 00:52:46.661
I've got a time on my watch.

708
00:52:48.345 --> 00:52:51.088
Now, time gets dilated.

709
00:52:51.188 --> 00:52:51.729
What does that mean?

710
00:52:51.789 --> 00:52:58.796
That means that the clock is running slower, which means that a second is getting longer.

711
00:52:58.816 --> 00:52:58.916
Yeah.

712
00:52:59.915 --> 00:53:02.135
but my length is getting shorter.

713
00:53:02.856 --> 00:53:08.897
So one coordinate is getting shorter, and the other coordinate, the time coordinate, is getting longer.

714
00:53:09.257 --> 00:53:12.337
That is central to the physics of relativity.

715
00:53:12.397 --> 00:53:15.078
And let me show you by considering this plot.

716
00:53:15.098 --> 00:53:17.558
So let's consider this plot.

717
00:53:17.658 --> 00:53:20.979
This is a plot that almost every physics undergrad has seen.

718
00:53:21.399 --> 00:53:25.160
On the x-axis is space, on the y-axis is time.

719
00:53:26.120 --> 00:53:29.443
So on the y-axis, we've got 1 second, 2 second, 3 second, 4 second.

720
00:53:29.864 --> 00:53:33.407
On the x-axis is meters, but actually the 1 is not 1 meter.

721
00:53:33.827 --> 00:53:35.569
The 1 is 1 light second.

722
00:53:36.089 --> 00:53:40.193
So it's really like 300,000 kilometers, 600,000 kilometers.

723
00:53:40.253 --> 00:53:44.777
So it's the speed of light multiplied by 1 second, 2 seconds, 3 seconds, and 4 seconds.

724
00:53:44.797 --> 00:53:45.698
Why do we want to do that?

725
00:53:46.058 --> 00:53:52.224
Well, if we represent the x-axis that way, then the speed of light is a diagonal.

726
00:53:52.304 --> 00:53:52.564
Yeah.

727
00:53:52.824 --> 00:53:53.024
Right.

728
00:53:53.344 --> 00:53:54.345
Because it's like one to one.

729
00:53:54.385 --> 00:53:57.628
It's like, OK, in one second, it travels one light second.

730
00:53:57.728 --> 00:53:59.589
In two seconds, it travels two light seconds.

731
00:53:59.609 --> 00:54:05.533
So you've got a nice the dotted green line is what light would do in this coordinate system.

732
00:54:05.813 --> 00:54:10.357
OK, so that's that's usually how we represent things in relativity.

733
00:54:11.198 --> 00:54:11.418
All right.

734
00:54:11.718 --> 00:54:20.344
For many folks who math may not be something you do very often, the closest thing you may have seen that touches this concept is interstellar.

735
00:54:20.565 --> 00:54:20.825
Yes.

736
00:54:20.905 --> 00:54:28.790
When they're on the wave planet, the guy is on the ship still, and they have that time dilation issue because of exactly what we're talking about.

737
00:54:28.810 --> 00:54:30.131
Because of exactly what we're talking about.

738
00:54:30.191 --> 00:54:30.651
Exactly.

739
00:54:30.972 --> 00:54:33.213
And so we've considered that plot.

740
00:54:33.393 --> 00:54:35.555
Now let's consider, for example...

741
00:54:36.862 --> 00:54:38.422
We're in this plot, right?

742
00:54:39.363 --> 00:54:40.103
It's the two of us.

743
00:54:40.383 --> 00:54:40.583
Yes.

744
00:54:40.703 --> 00:54:40.963
Okay?

745
00:54:41.383 --> 00:54:42.423
We're both stationary.

746
00:54:42.463 --> 00:54:44.364
We're both in the same reference frame.

747
00:54:44.604 --> 00:54:45.784
Mate, I got a lot of motion.

748
00:54:45.844 --> 00:54:47.724
I don't know what you're talking about.

749
00:54:47.744 --> 00:54:49.305
But as of now, I'm going to have you move.

750
00:54:49.465 --> 00:54:51.085
I'm going to have you move in the next plot.

751
00:54:51.405 --> 00:54:52.165
But in this plot.

752
00:54:52.185 --> 00:54:54.326
I don't have motion right now, but I will in the future.

753
00:54:54.906 --> 00:54:58.067
I want to give you a little sense of how relativity is so cool.

754
00:54:58.287 --> 00:54:58.627
Okay?

755
00:54:59.267 --> 00:55:02.808
So let's consider we've got we're sitting here.

756
00:55:02.908 --> 00:55:04.608
This is X equals zero, this table.

757
00:55:04.789 --> 00:55:07.369
OK. OK. And we set the time.

758
00:55:07.689 --> 00:55:08.590
We have a stopwatch.

759
00:55:08.670 --> 00:55:10.130
I've got a stopwatch on my iPhone.

760
00:55:10.170 --> 00:55:11.550
I set it to time equals zero.

761
00:55:12.051 --> 00:55:15.491
And let's say there are three explosions that happen.

762
00:55:15.832 --> 00:55:17.652
OK. Or like three light switches.

763
00:55:18.532 --> 00:55:20.713
In the physics textbooks, it's always like light switches.

764
00:55:20.733 --> 00:55:21.113
Right.

765
00:55:21.393 --> 00:55:23.114
Let's do explosions.

766
00:55:23.255 --> 00:55:24.095
I like explosions.

767
00:55:24.435 --> 00:55:25.957
But we can survive the explosions.

768
00:55:26.077 --> 00:55:26.317
Okay.

769
00:55:26.677 --> 00:55:32.442
There's an explosion that happens here where we're sitting, but in two seconds time.

770
00:55:33.282 --> 00:55:33.503
Okay.

771
00:55:33.883 --> 00:55:36.285
There's an explosion that happens in front of us.

772
00:55:37.841 --> 00:55:40.683
Two light seconds away, so 600,000 kilometers away.

773
00:55:41.144 --> 00:55:41.604
Real close.

774
00:55:42.405 --> 00:55:44.486
And there's an explosion that happens behind us.

775
00:55:45.247 --> 00:55:46.768
Two light seconds behind us.

776
00:55:47.108 --> 00:55:47.488
Okay.

777
00:55:47.528 --> 00:55:50.550
So 600,000 kilometers behind us.

778
00:55:50.911 --> 00:55:53.092
But they all happen at the same time because we're sitting here.

779
00:55:53.573 --> 00:55:58.836
And we see the explosions happen at the same time.

780
00:55:58.856 --> 00:55:59.217
Okay.

781
00:55:59.237 --> 00:55:59.437
Okay.

782
00:56:00.187 --> 00:56:01.088
So we're like, okay, cool.

783
00:56:01.428 --> 00:56:09.057
The coordinates of these explosions in space-time, now we're thinking about coordinates in space-time, not just space.

784
00:56:09.537 --> 00:56:16.725
The coordinates in space-time are, the explosion that happens here is at space equals zero, because it's right here, and the time equals two seconds.

785
00:56:16.745 --> 00:56:17.266
The coordinates...

786
00:56:17.486 --> 00:56:33.749
the explosion in front of us is space equals two yes and the time equals two because it happened at the same time and back there it's negative two time equals two when you say space time in this example we're talking about two axes yeah and one is space and one is time and so you can represent space time

787
00:56:34.550 --> 00:56:38.873
on a two-dimensional X, Y graph in this example.

788
00:56:39.273 --> 00:56:42.315
And it's not this... No, it's literal now.

789
00:56:42.636 --> 00:56:44.277
It's literal on a coordinate axis.

790
00:56:44.297 --> 00:56:45.618
This is the genius of Einstein.

791
00:56:45.678 --> 00:56:46.138
Right, okay.

792
00:56:46.198 --> 00:56:46.518
Right?

793
00:56:46.578 --> 00:56:50.521
He's like putting this stuff on a coordinate plane, and he's asking, right?

794
00:56:50.561 --> 00:56:54.604
And this is actually, Lorenz came up with this stuff even before Einstein.

795
00:56:54.644 --> 00:56:59.247
He was thinking about Lorenz transformations, and Einstein's the real guy to be like, let's just take it seriously, guys.

796
00:56:59.507 --> 00:57:00.067
Right.

797
00:57:00.408 --> 00:57:00.668
Okay?

798
00:57:01.028 --> 00:57:03.510
So now we ask the following.

799
00:57:04.360 --> 00:57:06.361
We're both sitting here and we agree.

800
00:57:06.662 --> 00:57:09.884
If we were both sitting here, these explosions would happen at the same time.

801
00:57:10.424 --> 00:57:18.590
Now, suppose you were moving that way to the front at very close to the speed of light.

802
00:57:19.371 --> 00:57:19.611
Okay?

803
00:57:21.232 --> 00:57:27.677
The three events that happen simultaneously for me, they are not going to happen simultaneously for you.

804
00:57:28.197 --> 00:57:28.458
Why?

805
00:57:29.558 --> 00:57:31.340
The explosion that's in front of us

806
00:57:32.483 --> 00:57:35.745
But before you, yeah, so this is me, right?

807
00:57:35.805 --> 00:57:36.666
This is my...

808
00:57:36.926 --> 00:57:37.307
Yes.

809
00:57:37.407 --> 00:57:41.830
So to me, everything's happening at the same time, which is why everyone's in the same time axis.

810
00:57:42.090 --> 00:57:42.190
Yes.

811
00:57:42.250 --> 00:57:46.633
Now, before we consider the next plot, let's just think about what would happen.

812
00:57:46.793 --> 00:57:51.477
You're moving towards the explosion in front of me at near the speed of light.

813
00:57:51.497 --> 00:57:52.217
Which is at 2-2.

814
00:57:52.357 --> 00:57:53.918
Yep, which is at 2-2 for me.

815
00:57:54.239 --> 00:57:54.619
For you.

816
00:57:54.839 --> 00:57:55.159
For me.

817
00:57:55.500 --> 00:57:56.440
But I'm moving towards it.

818
00:57:56.460 --> 00:57:57.741
But you're moving towards it, right?

819
00:57:57.761 --> 00:57:58.562
At the speed of light.

820
00:57:59.242 --> 00:58:00.163
Near the speed of light.

821
00:58:00.403 --> 00:58:01.224
Near the speed of light.

822
00:58:02.115 --> 00:58:02.475
Sue me.

823
00:58:02.696 --> 00:58:03.376
Yeah, okay.

824
00:58:03.857 --> 00:58:10.163
But if you're moving out there near the speed of light, now, from Einstein's relativity, we know that length is going to contract for you.

825
00:58:10.884 --> 00:58:17.491
So the distance to that explosion is going to go down, and the time is going to get a little bit slower.

826
00:58:17.951 --> 00:58:21.355
But at the same time, you're moving towards...

827
00:58:22.204 --> 00:58:22.845
That explosion.

828
00:58:22.905 --> 00:58:23.085
Yeah.

829
00:58:23.145 --> 00:58:25.607
So the light from that explosion is going to come meet you.

830
00:58:26.287 --> 00:58:27.148
Mm-hmm.

831
00:58:27.168 --> 00:58:29.890
Because we're basically, it's like two trains coming at each other.

832
00:58:29.910 --> 00:58:30.131
Yes.

833
00:58:30.511 --> 00:58:37.397
But because of the speed at which I'm moving towards it, from your perspective, it's going to take time for that light.

834
00:58:37.417 --> 00:58:38.578
It's going to take two seconds.

835
00:58:39.178 --> 00:58:44.823
But because I'm basically meeting the light before it gets to you at that speed, it's going to happen.

836
00:58:44.843 --> 00:58:45.063
Yeah.

837
00:58:45.303 --> 00:58:50.668
And so for you, that event is going to happen sooner than two seconds.

838
00:58:50.688 --> 00:58:50.968
Yeah.

839
00:58:51.748 --> 00:58:56.913
And it's going to happen closer than two light seconds because the length is contracted.

840
00:58:57.293 --> 00:59:05.859
Similarly, the event that happens here is going to take a little bit longer than two seconds because this thing happens for me at two seconds, but then the light has to go to wherever you are.

841
00:59:06.580 --> 00:59:08.642
So it's going to happen a little bit longer than two seconds.

842
00:59:09.122 --> 00:59:12.184
And the explosion that was way back there, that's going to take even longer.

843
00:59:12.845 --> 00:59:16.488
So what we should see when we look at your perspective...

844
00:59:17.479 --> 00:59:27.364
If we look at your perspective, the event that's in front of you should go down on the y-axis and down on the x-axis for your x and y.

845
00:59:27.784 --> 00:59:30.805
My x and y is stationary.

846
00:59:30.905 --> 00:59:33.807
And when we say down on the y-axis, because our y...

847
00:59:33.827 --> 00:59:35.007
So it's sooner in time.

848
00:59:35.107 --> 00:59:35.647
It's sooner in time.

849
00:59:35.667 --> 00:59:36.788
And it's sooner in space.

850
00:59:37.148 --> 00:59:37.328
Right.

851
00:59:37.748 --> 00:59:39.669
And getting closer to the origin.

852
00:59:39.729 --> 00:59:39.909
Yep.

853
00:59:40.009 --> 00:59:40.210
Yep.

854
00:59:40.370 --> 00:59:40.570
Yep.

855
00:59:40.670 --> 00:59:40.950
Okay.

856
00:59:41.190 --> 00:59:42.651
Got it.

857
00:59:42.691 --> 00:59:44.972
So now let's see how we did, right, with that logic.

858
00:59:45.826 --> 00:59:46.926
So we go to the next plot.

859
00:59:47.626 --> 00:59:50.047
In this plot, nothing has happened so far.

860
00:59:50.127 --> 00:59:55.688
I'm giving you some analysis of what we're talking about.

861
00:59:55.848 --> 00:59:58.589
As I said, the diagonals are light, right?

862
00:59:58.969 --> 01:00:05.610
So the diagonals are what light would travel, like the path that light would travel in my space time.

863
01:00:05.730 --> 01:00:12.752
Because, again, our x-axis is light seconds, and our y-axis is just time.

864
01:00:12.992 --> 01:00:13.212
Right.

865
01:00:13.832 --> 01:00:15.272
Right, and so that's why it's diagonal.

866
01:00:15.312 --> 01:00:22.494
And all of the dotted lines are diagonal because if a light beam started at T equals 1, then it would travel like at the...

867
01:00:22.594 --> 01:00:25.254
It would be the dotted line that's just above the T equals 0.

868
01:00:25.314 --> 01:00:31.375
This is why we want to decrement the x-axis in this way so that it creates this simplicity to understand the point.

869
01:00:31.395 --> 01:00:32.255
Exactly, exactly.

870
01:00:32.295 --> 01:00:40.357
Now, one of the... And the other big thing is there's two points and there's actually a line, a black line, right on the...

871
01:00:41.377 --> 01:00:46.299
right on the y-axis here, which says I'm not moving, right?

872
01:00:46.339 --> 01:00:47.540
Because you're the one who's moving.

873
01:00:47.860 --> 01:00:52.422
So to me, I'm just stationary at x equals zero for all of time.

874
01:00:52.542 --> 01:00:52.762
Yes.

875
01:00:52.842 --> 01:00:53.062
Right?

876
01:00:53.082 --> 01:00:57.084
So no matter what time it is, I'm always at x equals zero.

877
01:00:57.244 --> 01:00:57.564
OK?

878
01:00:57.684 --> 01:00:59.665
So now what would you see for me?

879
01:00:59.765 --> 01:01:06.548
Well, you would see me, if you're coming from back there, you'd see me with a positive x-axis, and then you'd see me go backwards, right?

880
01:01:06.828 --> 01:01:09.890
Because to you, I'm coming from up there and then going backwards.

881
01:01:10.050 --> 01:01:10.270
Okay?

882
01:01:10.630 --> 01:01:15.233
Now let's go ahead and do the Lorentz transformation to see what you would see.

883
01:01:15.413 --> 01:01:15.674
Okay.

884
01:01:16.214 --> 01:01:16.594
Okay?

885
01:01:16.874 --> 01:01:17.755
What would you see?

886
01:01:18.996 --> 01:01:20.296
What you would see is the following.

887
01:01:20.336 --> 01:01:20.877
You'd see...

888
01:01:21.892 --> 01:01:24.595
the coordinate axes change.

889
01:01:24.916 --> 01:01:30.683
And notice, first thing we want to notice is the three red dots are doing exactly what we had predicted.

890
01:01:31.103 --> 01:01:34.587
The event that's in front is getting closer to you.

891
01:01:34.848 --> 01:01:37.851
So the time is decreasing and the X is decreasing.

892
01:01:38.152 --> 01:01:39.593
The event that's happening right here

893
01:01:40.636 --> 01:01:44.000
is going forward in time because it's not two seconds.

894
01:01:44.060 --> 01:01:48.526
It's a little bit more because the light has to catch up to you for you to be like, ah, there was an explosion.

895
01:01:48.786 --> 01:01:52.751
And the event that happened way back there is happening way farther at two seconds.

896
01:01:52.812 --> 01:01:53.072
Right.

897
01:01:54.293 --> 01:01:55.395
But notice two things.

898
01:01:55.695 --> 01:01:58.919
And, and, and for one, the line that is me,

899
01:01:59.600 --> 01:02:04.524
which is usually time t equals zero, x equals, time, time equals whatever, x equals zero.

900
01:02:04.704 --> 01:02:12.210
That thing is shifting to where at negative time, so before time t equals zero, I'm ahead of you, and then I go behind you, right?

901
01:02:12.370 --> 01:02:13.231
That's the black line.

902
01:02:13.271 --> 01:02:13.471
Yep.

903
01:02:14.607 --> 01:02:19.033
Here's the key thing about this coordinate transformation, which is the genius of the Lorentz transformation.

904
01:02:19.894 --> 01:02:22.557
All of the diagonals are still diagonal.

905
01:02:23.438 --> 01:02:23.979
What does that mean?

906
01:02:24.039 --> 01:02:30.087
That means even in your reference frame, light is still moving at the same speed.

907
01:02:30.667 --> 01:02:33.050
It is still moving at the speed of light.

908
01:02:33.070 --> 01:02:33.331
Mm-hmm.

909
01:02:33.751 --> 01:02:33.991
Right?

910
01:02:34.612 --> 01:02:40.456
What's really happening is the length is contracting and the time is getting faster.

911
01:02:40.817 --> 01:02:45.180
But they're happening at the same rate such that the diagonals are always diagonal.

912
01:02:45.200 --> 01:02:50.724
Yeah, they're just shifting on the same ratio of proportionality to each other.

913
01:02:50.784 --> 01:02:51.565
Yes, yes.

914
01:02:51.685 --> 01:02:53.807
By the Lorentz factor, actually, is what it is.

915
01:02:53.887 --> 01:02:54.327
And so...

916
01:02:57.089 --> 01:03:02.935
It preserves relativity because one of the tenets of relativity is that the speed of light is the same in any reference frame.

917
01:03:03.135 --> 01:03:04.236
It's constant.

918
01:03:04.456 --> 01:03:08.620
So even when we go into your reference frame, the diagonals are still diagonal, but...

919
01:03:10.205 --> 01:03:12.606
The space has changed and the time has changed.

920
01:03:13.146 --> 01:03:17.027
The other cool thing about this is the volume of space-time is always the same.

921
01:03:17.568 --> 01:03:23.770
The area of the square becomes a rectangle, but the area of each rectangle is exactly the same.

922
01:03:24.290 --> 01:03:24.630
Yes.

923
01:03:25.070 --> 01:03:30.012
Again, because everything is – it's a shift that's happening.

924
01:03:30.292 --> 01:03:32.453
It goes back to this mapping point that you were bringing up earlier.

925
01:03:32.813 --> 01:03:38.755
We are making this transformation in our map, but fundamentally our Jacobian remains as one the entire time.

926
01:03:38.815 --> 01:03:39.015
Yes.

927
01:03:39.035 --> 01:03:39.255
Yes.

928
01:03:39.835 --> 01:03:40.635
That's exactly right.

929
01:03:41.015 --> 01:03:45.477
And what that means is if, like, the volume of space-time is always preserved.

930
01:03:45.537 --> 01:03:45.797
Yes.

931
01:03:46.617 --> 01:03:47.958
In the Lorentz transformation.

932
01:03:48.258 --> 01:03:48.518
Okay?

933
01:03:48.818 --> 01:03:50.558
That's the central tenet of relativity.

934
01:03:50.798 --> 01:03:50.999
Okay.

935
01:03:51.139 --> 01:03:51.399
Okay?

936
01:03:51.819 --> 01:03:55.120
That ensures that the speed of light is always the same for the both of us.

937
01:03:55.700 --> 01:03:58.341
And really, it's kind of crazy when you think about it.

938
01:03:58.381 --> 01:04:04.583
The universe is doing all this just to make sure that the speed of light is the same for me as it is for you.

939
01:04:05.483 --> 01:04:06.825
Because neither of us are right.

940
01:04:07.205 --> 01:04:07.565
Correct.

941
01:04:07.666 --> 01:04:07.906
Right?

942
01:04:08.266 --> 01:04:12.291
Your perspective is the same as my perspective.

943
01:04:12.371 --> 01:04:13.852
So the speed of light better be the same.

944
01:04:14.193 --> 01:04:23.402
And the universe is doing all this nonsense of contracting length and making time go slower just so that the diagonals remain diagonal.

945
01:04:23.983 --> 01:04:27.204
I'm not saying it's a simulation, but if you wanted to make it a simulation.

946
01:04:27.244 --> 01:04:29.185
Yeah, this would be a rule that I would code up.

947
01:04:29.665 --> 01:04:31.006
It would make sense.

948
01:04:31.246 --> 01:04:40.609
And I'm being facetious here, but I think the point you're bringing up is important, which is that the constant of the speed of light requires the universe to do all this other stuff.

949
01:04:40.669 --> 01:04:40.869
Yeah.

950
01:04:41.470 --> 01:04:50.533
So that regardless of your speed or your position in the universe, that constant remains the same.

951
01:04:50.713 --> 01:04:51.013
Exactly.

952
01:04:51.033 --> 01:04:52.535
Which requires it to do all this other stuff.

953
01:04:52.555 --> 01:04:53.936
All this other things.

954
01:04:54.117 --> 01:04:56.819
So it's almost like the speed of light is a golden rule.

955
01:04:56.859 --> 01:04:57.060
Yeah.

956
01:04:57.400 --> 01:04:58.561
It always must be followed.

957
01:04:58.581 --> 01:04:58.801
Yes.

958
01:04:59.042 --> 01:05:00.944
No matter where you are, no matter how fast you're going.

959
01:05:01.204 --> 01:05:03.726
Because I don't know if you're moving or I'm moving, right?

960
01:05:03.826 --> 01:05:05.588
We'll figure out the other stuff to make it happen.

961
01:05:05.748 --> 01:05:06.509
Yeah, exactly.

962
01:05:06.850 --> 01:05:10.974
And so that's a central tenet of Einstein's special relativity.

963
01:05:11.254 --> 01:05:11.474
Okay?

964
01:05:11.755 --> 01:05:13.697
And that's the Lorentz transformation that...

965
01:05:14.217 --> 01:05:35.393
gives rise to all of the rich behavior that is a consequence of special relativity so that again is just a that's a linear transformation as i said right it's um it's not too complicated i was able i was able to get it yeah yeah exactly it's not special relativity is like actually not that bad when you like really just think about it it's like

966
01:05:35.893 --> 01:05:37.313
Yeah, kind of makes sense.

967
01:05:37.353 --> 01:05:42.755
It's when we get to general, when it's like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, slow down.

968
01:05:43.395 --> 01:05:44.155
I just got here.

969
01:05:45.475 --> 01:05:47.116
So that's special relativity, right?

970
01:05:47.156 --> 01:05:54.777
And the Jacobian there is one, meaning that the volume in space time is preserved no matter what reference frame you're in.

971
01:05:55.237 --> 01:05:55.517
Okay.

972
01:05:55.738 --> 01:05:59.238
And when you say reference frame, you mean both position and speed?

973
01:06:00.419 --> 01:06:00.799
And time.

974
01:06:00.839 --> 01:06:01.279
And time.

975
01:06:01.299 --> 01:06:02.339
So both position and time.

976
01:06:02.399 --> 01:06:02.899
Yeah, yeah.

977
01:06:02.979 --> 01:06:09.064
Whatever volume in your position and time versus my position and time are going to be exactly the same.

978
01:06:09.364 --> 01:06:14.909
It's just that each individual thing is going to be changed, but the product of the two are going to remain the same.

979
01:06:14.949 --> 01:06:15.089
Yep.

980
01:06:15.229 --> 01:06:15.389
Right?

981
01:06:15.409 --> 01:06:18.251
Because the Lorentz factor is going to cancel out.

982
01:06:18.311 --> 01:06:18.672
Makes sense.

983
01:06:18.732 --> 01:06:18.992
Okay.

984
01:06:19.332 --> 01:06:26.358
And that happens in, we showed a 1D case where we were only considering like, you know, forward and backwards where the boost is.

985
01:06:26.398 --> 01:06:28.159
But this applies in all three.

986
01:06:28.179 --> 01:06:31.522
In that case, you get like the Minkowski tensor and all sorts of stuff.

987
01:06:31.862 --> 01:06:34.143
But that's effectively what's happening.

988
01:06:34.203 --> 01:06:35.844
So this is a coordinate transformation, right?

989
01:06:36.164 --> 01:06:42.946
Space-time gets distorted, but the Jacobian is 1, so the volume of space-time remains the same.

990
01:06:43.446 --> 01:06:46.348
Now let's talk about nonlinear transformations, okay?

991
01:06:47.048 --> 01:06:50.049
This is an example of a nonlinear transformation.

992
01:06:50.401 --> 01:06:59.368
Here, the x-axis goes to x plus sine of y over 2, and the y-axis goes to y plus sine of x over 2.

993
01:06:59.408 --> 01:07:02.271
This is what I mean by now you can start mixing stuff, right?

994
01:07:02.531 --> 01:07:05.814
In the other one, you were also mixing, but here you're doing it in a nonlinear way.

995
01:07:05.834 --> 01:07:10.237
You're not just like adding some Lorentz factor times the constant.

996
01:07:10.517 --> 01:07:12.659
This is like sine, which is an oscillatory thing.

997
01:07:12.919 --> 01:07:15.621
And so you're seeing like stuff shift, right?

998
01:07:15.661 --> 01:07:16.802
Things are getting wiggly.

999
01:07:16.842 --> 01:07:17.103
Mm-hmm.

1000
01:07:18.343 --> 01:07:20.965
In this case, what is the Jacobian going to do?

1001
01:07:21.205 --> 01:07:24.787
Well, the Jacobian now is actually different in different spots.

1002
01:07:25.147 --> 01:07:27.648
You can see in some cases the areas are getting squished.

1003
01:07:28.088 --> 01:07:31.470
In other cases, the areas are remaining about the same.

1004
01:07:31.870 --> 01:07:39.594
And if we go and see and zoom in on a central area element of this transformation, what happens?

1005
01:07:39.874 --> 01:07:40.914
Well, let's look at those...

1006
01:07:42.896 --> 01:07:47.387
Let's look at that sector that's right in the middle of the 1-1 box.

1007
01:07:47.768 --> 01:07:47.988
Okay?

1008
01:07:51.059 --> 01:07:54.700
The transformation is nonlinear, so it's curved in every sense.

1009
01:07:55.101 --> 01:07:57.601
But the beauty of calculus is the following.

1010
01:07:57.701 --> 01:08:03.624
If I take a small enough element, stuff is mostly going to be a line.

1011
01:08:03.784 --> 01:08:05.624
That's all calculus is.

1012
01:08:05.925 --> 01:08:13.667
The essence of calculus is weird stuff is happening, but if I take a small enough element, it's mostly just linear.

1013
01:08:14.068 --> 01:08:15.228
Calculus, just zoom in.

1014
01:08:15.468 --> 01:08:15.988
Just zoom.

1015
01:08:16.008 --> 01:08:17.449
Yeah, no, exactly.

1016
01:08:17.729 --> 01:08:20.670
Just zoom in and the square becomes a parallelogram.

1017
01:08:20.710 --> 01:08:23.411
It's not becoming a weird curved shape.

1018
01:08:23.551 --> 01:08:34.335
It goes back to the example we just talked about previously, but it's all about what is your perspective of the or or context by which you're making your calculations.

1019
01:08:34.435 --> 01:08:35.155
Yeah, exactly.

1020
01:08:35.195 --> 01:08:44.817
And in this case, we can understand what the Jacobian is because the Jacobian at that point is going to be what is the ratio of the square area to the new parallelogram area.

1021
01:08:45.017 --> 01:08:49.578
Okay, in this case, it looks like 1 because it's getting squished and the rhombus looks about the same.

1022
01:08:49.938 --> 01:08:57.059
So in that locality, the Jacobian is 1, but somewhere else it could be 2, somewhere else it could be less than 1, and so on and so forth.

1023
01:08:57.099 --> 01:09:02.980
But that's the beauty of calculus is that you can zoom in and you can figure out a well-defined Jacobian at every given point.

1024
01:09:03.160 --> 01:09:11.204
We have a larger complex system, but at sufficient zoom in, that complex system still comes back to the fundamental that we just talked about.

1025
01:09:11.224 --> 01:09:11.864
Yeah, okay.

1026
01:09:12.164 --> 01:09:12.925
Yeah, exactly.

1027
01:09:12.965 --> 01:09:16.206
And so now we've got this core concept, which is the Jacobian matrix.

1028
01:09:16.226 --> 01:09:21.889
The Jacobian matrix tells you how each of the directions sort of swish and become one another.

1029
01:09:22.389 --> 01:09:28.592
And the determinant of that matrix tells you the ratio of the areas before and after.

1030
01:09:28.612 --> 01:09:28.872
Mm-hmm.

1031
01:09:29.052 --> 01:09:34.173
or I should say it's the ratio of areas after divided by before.

1032
01:09:34.413 --> 01:09:36.373
So 2 means that the ratio went up.

1033
01:09:36.873 --> 01:09:38.514
Less than 1 means the ratio went down.

1034
01:09:38.814 --> 01:09:43.134
There's also negative Jacobians, which means that the axes got flipped.

1035
01:09:43.174 --> 01:09:46.255
So it's like, I mean, it's just flipped.

1036
01:09:46.335 --> 01:09:48.075
It's like it got flipped, right?

1037
01:09:48.635 --> 01:09:56.177
Okay, so if the determinant at a given point is non-zero, as we just saw, then it signifies a linear approximation, right?

1038
01:09:56.417 --> 01:09:57.337
And it doesn't collapse.

1039
01:09:58.230 --> 01:10:04.734
Now here we've got an example that is at the center of the Jacobian conjecture.

1040
01:10:05.114 --> 01:10:05.374
Okay?

1041
01:10:05.874 --> 01:10:10.457
We've got to consider situations where the determinant is a non-zero constant.

1042
01:10:11.157 --> 01:10:12.598
It's a constant everywhere.

1043
01:10:13.198 --> 01:10:18.001
Meaning, no matter where I am in my map, the area is actually the same.

1044
01:10:18.181 --> 01:10:21.163
Even though the upper part is getting more squished, you would think,

1045
01:10:22.345 --> 01:10:26.047
The actual area, the ratio of the areas is actually exactly the same.

1046
01:10:26.367 --> 01:10:29.549
This is a particular map that I came up with in Desmos.

1047
01:10:29.569 --> 01:10:44.216
There's a lot of really cool Desmos pre-made applications where you can plug in your own custom linear map and you can visualize how the map is going to change the axis.

1048
01:10:44.256 --> 01:10:49.019
So in this case, the new x-axis is x plus one-fourth y squared.

1049
01:10:49.879 --> 01:10:51.821
And the y-axis is just the y-axis.

1050
01:10:52.101 --> 01:10:58.247
So every y gets plotted to its own y, but the x gets shifted by a parabola.

1051
01:10:58.267 --> 01:11:00.989
That's why these things are becoming a parabola.

1052
01:11:01.269 --> 01:11:04.993
But the horizontal lines are remaining horizontal lines.

1053
01:11:05.053 --> 01:11:08.596
It's going from lanes on a highway to a track, the elliptical of a track.

1054
01:11:08.656 --> 01:11:11.378
Yeah, and the lanes on the highway is the X, right?

1055
01:11:11.398 --> 01:11:13.399
So that's why that's getting shifted into a parabola.

1056
01:11:13.759 --> 01:11:21.684
But the horizontal lines of latitude, so to speak, are remaining the same because the Y just gets plotted to the new Y.

1057
01:11:21.884 --> 01:11:22.505
Nothing happens.

1058
01:11:22.885 --> 01:11:32.651
Okay, in this case, if you were to plot that area, that little green area, that little green area becomes a parallelogram, but the area is preserved.

1059
01:11:33.152 --> 01:11:34.292
The Jacobian here is one.

1060
01:11:34.613 --> 01:11:36.614
If I were to take that area and put it up top,

1061
01:11:37.877 --> 01:11:40.658
The parallelogram might get more squished, right?

1062
01:11:40.738 --> 01:11:44.240
It might have a different shape, but the area is still going to be 1.

1063
01:11:44.620 --> 01:11:58.947
This particular mapping is one where the Jacobian determinant is constant, meaning that the transformation of area everywhere to all of infinity in X and Y, the area is preserved, okay?

1064
01:12:00.648 --> 01:12:07.051
Now, given this, one can ask, suppose I was given the end product, right?

1065
01:12:08.137 --> 01:12:08.397
Okay?

1066
01:12:08.757 --> 01:12:18.462
If I was given the end product of the last, like, the points in that after the transformation.

1067
01:12:18.742 --> 01:12:18.943
Yes.

1068
01:12:18.983 --> 01:12:21.444
Suppose I were given the points after the transformation.

1069
01:12:21.864 --> 01:12:22.925
Can I go backwards?

1070
01:12:23.565 --> 01:12:23.785
Right.

1071
01:12:24.085 --> 01:12:25.746
Meaning, is the map invertible?

1072
01:12:25.866 --> 01:12:26.066
Yes.

1073
01:12:26.226 --> 01:12:26.466
Okay?

1074
01:12:27.007 --> 01:12:27.847
In this case, it is.

1075
01:12:27.987 --> 01:12:29.348
You can actually solve for it.

1076
01:12:29.488 --> 01:12:30.709
If you give me the new...

1077
01:12:31.669 --> 01:12:54.914
x and y coordinates in this case i'm going to call it u and v because their u is going to be my new x-axis v is going to be my new y-axis if i want to recover the old x and y-axis that like gave me that point i can just like do the mathematics and plug in it's actually u minus one fourth v squared so the the plus one fourth becomes a minus okay and then i can recover the old map

1078
01:12:55.214 --> 01:12:58.357
Is it as a concept to help me grok this?

1079
01:12:58.437 --> 01:13:00.839
Is it similar to when you talk about encryption and decryption?

1080
01:13:00.859 --> 01:13:02.120
When you have the key in the middle.

1081
01:13:02.140 --> 01:13:03.661
Very good.

1082
01:13:03.681 --> 01:13:05.803
You're able to go back, even though it's jumbled.

1083
01:13:05.963 --> 01:13:06.103
Yeah.

1084
01:13:06.123 --> 01:13:08.045
Because you have the key that allows you to.

1085
01:13:08.325 --> 01:13:08.525
Okay.

1086
01:13:08.605 --> 01:13:09.066
Exactly.

1087
01:13:09.146 --> 01:13:09.586
Exactly.

1088
01:13:09.706 --> 01:13:09.846
And.

1089
01:13:10.607 --> 01:13:16.570
In that particular transformation, because the Jacobian was not zero, I could go backwards.

1090
01:13:16.670 --> 01:13:18.211
If the Jacobian is zero, what does that mean?

1091
01:13:18.231 --> 01:13:23.313
That means an area collapses into a point or like a line, something with zero area.

1092
01:13:23.333 --> 01:13:29.176
Well, what that means is now we've got a bunch of points where it's degenerate.

1093
01:13:29.216 --> 01:13:33.618
Like let's say the extreme case where like a giant square collapsed into a single point.

1094
01:13:33.898 --> 01:13:37.700
Well, now if you give me that single point, I don't know where in the square it came from.

1095
01:13:37.720 --> 01:13:37.860
Right.

1096
01:13:38.638 --> 01:13:39.079
Right.

1097
01:13:39.099 --> 01:13:42.583
If you give me a line, for example, the entire square gets collapsed into a line.

1098
01:13:42.863 --> 01:13:44.905
Well, that line is only 1D information.

1099
01:13:44.925 --> 01:13:47.148
I don't know where in the 2D.

1100
01:13:47.228 --> 01:13:47.448
Right.

1101
01:13:47.548 --> 01:13:48.349
The thing came from.

1102
01:13:48.369 --> 01:13:49.491
You need both.

1103
01:13:49.631 --> 01:13:50.612
You need you need both.

1104
01:13:50.812 --> 01:13:51.012
Yeah.

1105
01:13:51.493 --> 01:13:53.395
You can't have only one and then zero on the other.

1106
01:13:53.475 --> 01:13:53.916
Exactly.

1107
01:13:54.036 --> 01:13:54.196
Right.

1108
01:13:54.236 --> 01:13:55.738
And that happens when the Jacobian is zero.

1109
01:13:55.958 --> 01:13:58.161
So when the Jacobian is zero, I can't go backwards.

1110
01:13:58.601 --> 01:13:59.001
Trivial.

1111
01:13:59.041 --> 01:13:59.682
It's not invertebrate.

1112
01:13:59.702 --> 01:14:00.863
That makes sense, right?

1113
01:14:01.223 --> 01:14:04.226
And that's like a well-known theorem in calculus, right?

1114
01:14:04.286 --> 01:14:08.569
And where locally, if I have the Jacobian that's not zero, then I can go backwards.

1115
01:14:08.589 --> 01:14:09.110
That makes sense.

1116
01:14:09.510 --> 01:14:09.690
Okay?

1117
01:14:10.050 --> 01:14:12.472
Now we can finally understand the conjecture.

1118
01:14:12.492 --> 01:14:12.993
Okay.

1119
01:14:13.153 --> 01:14:15.154
The Jacobian conjecture is the following.

1120
01:14:15.895 --> 01:14:24.222
It says that if I have a map where the Jacobian is a constant everywhere, can I always go backwards?

1121
01:14:24.402 --> 01:14:24.542
Okay.

1122
01:14:25.132 --> 01:14:25.332
Right.

1123
01:14:25.772 --> 01:14:26.272
Everywhere.

1124
01:14:26.952 --> 01:14:27.232
Okay?

1125
01:14:27.573 --> 01:14:29.073
If the constant is...

1126
01:14:29.193 --> 01:14:35.134
If the Jacobian is constant everywhere, can I always create an invertible function?

1127
01:14:35.634 --> 01:14:39.795
You give me a function where the Jacobian is constant everywhere, can I always go backwards?

1128
01:14:39.955 --> 01:14:40.275
Okay?

1129
01:14:40.415 --> 01:14:41.956
The formal statement is the following.

1130
01:14:42.036 --> 01:14:42.216
Okay?

1131
01:14:42.456 --> 01:14:44.356
Let K have a characteristic of zero.

1132
01:14:44.656 --> 01:14:45.416
K is a ring.

1133
01:14:45.816 --> 01:14:47.897
A ring really just means like numbers.

1134
01:14:48.337 --> 01:14:48.597
Okay?

1135
01:14:48.857 --> 01:14:52.838
Mathematicians have other types of rings, but for us, let's just say they're numbers.

1136
01:14:52.918 --> 01:14:53.058
Okay?

1137
01:14:53.078 --> 01:14:53.238
Okay?

1138
01:14:53.258 --> 01:14:53.458
Okay?

1139
01:14:54.618 --> 01:14:56.320
they have a characteristic of zero.

1140
01:14:56.420 --> 01:15:00.602
A characteristic of zero, a ring really means something that has addition and multiplication.

1141
01:15:00.903 --> 01:15:02.203
Okay?

1142
01:15:02.323 --> 01:15:05.766
A characteristic of zero means that, you know, a ring has a one.

1143
01:15:05.946 --> 01:15:07.467
It's some kind of element that's a one.

1144
01:15:07.547 --> 01:15:10.929
For example, in the matrices, the one element is the identity.

1145
01:15:11.329 --> 01:15:13.010
For numbers, it's just the number one.

1146
01:15:13.611 --> 01:15:19.275
And a characteristic of zero means no matter how many times I add one to itself, I'm never going to get back zero.

1147
01:15:19.295 --> 01:15:19.575
Mm-hmm.

1148
01:15:20.435 --> 01:15:22.857
That just means to me normal numbers.

1149
01:15:22.917 --> 01:15:31.342
Mathematicians will come up with rings that have characteristics that are non-zero, where I add the number one five times and I get zero for some reason.

1150
01:15:31.842 --> 01:15:35.925
I don't know why you would want to study such objects, but they find a way.

1151
01:15:36.805 --> 01:15:40.168
In any case, we're talking about normal things here, okay?

1152
01:15:40.208 --> 01:15:44.452
Let k have a characteristic of zero, so this is just real numbers, complex numbers, things like that.

1153
01:15:45.112 --> 01:15:58.684
And if jf, which is the Jacobian determinant, is a non-zero constant of some functional map, then f, which is the functional map, has an inverse function g that plots my n-dimensional function,

1154
01:15:59.820 --> 01:16:21.017
space to back to the n-dimensional space yeah yeah okay yeah and this thing is regular meaning that its components are polynomials okay okay so if i have a polynomial function that's going in polynomial meaning things like x cube plus x squared y like powers of stuff then the inverse map is also a polynomial okay

1155
01:16:21.337 --> 01:16:21.497
Okay.

1156
01:16:22.318 --> 01:16:24.579
That is the Jacobian conjecture.

1157
01:16:24.619 --> 01:16:24.919
Okay.

1158
01:16:24.939 --> 01:16:34.883
So this is actually interesting because now I can understand the formulation here of what this open problem is trying to...

1159
01:16:36.347 --> 01:16:58.004
suggest yes it's trying to suggest that anytime right i have a function where the jacobian determinant is a constant everywhere meaning the the function preserves area preserves area i shouldn't say preserves area it scales area but it scales it in the same way everywhere yeah okay yeah if this function scales it in the same way everywhere

1160
01:16:59.143 --> 01:17:01.445
Then I should always be able to go backwards.

1161
01:17:01.645 --> 01:17:04.048
I should always be able to decrypt my encryption.

1162
01:17:04.088 --> 01:17:04.328
Yes.

1163
01:17:04.828 --> 01:17:05.089
Okay.

1164
01:17:05.189 --> 01:17:09.813
As long as it preserves area in the same scale everywhere.

1165
01:17:10.153 --> 01:17:10.394
Okay.

1166
01:17:10.714 --> 01:17:11.675
That's the conjecture.

1167
01:17:12.015 --> 01:17:18.521
It was formulated way back about 90 years ago, and people have been trying to prove it ever since.

1168
01:17:19.102 --> 01:17:19.362
Okay.

1169
01:17:20.463 --> 01:17:21.284
That is the question.

1170
01:17:22.515 --> 01:17:27.960
The problem was number 16 on Stephen Smalley's 1998 list of important mathematical challenges.

1171
01:17:28.120 --> 01:17:33.265
And it has very famously defeated top, top mathematicians, which we're going to get into later.

1172
01:17:33.325 --> 01:17:33.966
Top 20, baby.

1173
01:17:34.126 --> 01:17:34.346
Yeah.

1174
01:17:34.586 --> 01:17:35.487
That's top 20.

1175
01:17:35.667 --> 01:17:36.208
Top 20.

1176
01:17:36.328 --> 01:17:38.250
Top 20 open problems.

1177
01:17:38.290 --> 01:17:39.151
Yeah, that's quite nice.

1178
01:17:39.751 --> 01:17:45.637
Now, July 19th, 2026, in the middle of the World Cup final.

1179
01:17:46.771 --> 01:17:47.031
Okay.

1180
01:17:47.412 --> 01:17:55.719
Levant Alpuge, he is part of the Harvard Society of Fellows and also one of the researchers at Anthropic.

1181
01:17:55.859 --> 01:17:57.020
He drops this tweet.

1182
01:17:58.001 --> 01:17:59.923
I saw it within 30 minutes of it going up.

1183
01:17:59.943 --> 01:18:02.085
Yeah, because it was insane.

1184
01:18:02.205 --> 01:18:03.165
Literally 30 minutes.

1185
01:18:03.205 --> 01:18:03.386
Yeah.

1186
01:18:03.466 --> 01:18:05.147
First of all, it's all lowercase.

1187
01:18:05.267 --> 01:18:07.709
It looks like he's trolling.

1188
01:18:07.830 --> 01:18:08.870
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1189
01:18:08.971 --> 01:18:09.211
You know?

1190
01:18:09.451 --> 01:18:10.011
Hello there.

1191
01:18:10.052 --> 01:18:11.453
The Jacobian conjecture is false.

1192
01:18:11.493 --> 01:18:11.773
Thanks.

1193
01:18:12.053 --> 01:18:12.614
And T-H-A-N-X.

1194
01:18:15.058 --> 01:18:26.547
Thanks to my close friend Akil, we're going to get into who that is, for asking about it, and my other close friend Fable, which is the AI anthropic model, for working during the World Cup final.

1195
01:18:27.367 --> 01:18:29.789
And then he just shows the counterexample.

1196
01:18:29.809 --> 01:18:30.650
He just writes it out.

1197
01:18:31.898 --> 01:18:33.858
There's so many things, but I'm not going to bring it up now.

1198
01:18:33.918 --> 01:18:34.999
And it could fit in a tweet.

1199
01:18:35.019 --> 01:18:38.039
You know, there's like the 100 character whatever limit thing.

1200
01:18:38.059 --> 01:18:40.760
He just fit the entire proof in a tweet.

1201
01:18:41.200 --> 01:18:42.080
That's all you need.

1202
01:18:42.400 --> 01:18:46.441
Arguably, if NFTs were still a thing, this NFT would be very valuable.

1203
01:18:46.461 --> 01:18:48.302
Bro, I would buy this NFT.

1204
01:18:48.322 --> 01:18:50.142
This would be so valuable.

1205
01:18:50.662 --> 01:18:53.303
Yeah, we would get this NFT for the FFP vault.

1206
01:18:53.503 --> 01:18:54.043
Right, exactly.

1207
01:18:54.063 --> 01:18:57.764
Because for those who may not understand Twitter culture,

1208
01:19:02.465 --> 01:19:03.226
You had to be there.

1209
01:19:04.367 --> 01:19:13.173
And to see, because it's real time and so many people, especially in the AI research community, are there and apparently also were not watching the World Cup final at the time.

1210
01:19:13.714 --> 01:19:19.418
The immediate conversation that arose...

1211
01:19:21.526 --> 01:19:44.900
literally within an hour yeah of this being out there was as a bystander as like an as an innocent bystander was one of the most fascinating things yeah this was insane when i saw it because i heard about the jacobian conjecture when when i was at princeton doing mathematics i took a course in like um algebra and they like dropped hints of it about how it was unsolved but it's like fairly easy to understand yeah yeah right yeah it's like

1212
01:19:45.680 --> 01:19:50.222
If you don't get into the weird rings and all that kind of stuff, like as a physicist, I was like, oh, you're talking about numbers.

1213
01:19:50.242 --> 01:19:51.723
You're talking about coordinate transformations.

1214
01:19:52.003 --> 01:19:52.383
You're talking.

1215
01:19:52.483 --> 01:19:54.124
OK, like it kind of makes sense to me.

1216
01:19:54.364 --> 01:20:00.107
OK, and then to see this come out in a troll language, I think it's just so, so funny.

1217
01:20:00.367 --> 01:20:04.029
OK, so let's talk about that exact solution that it has.

1218
01:20:04.089 --> 01:20:06.690
OK, and in the next in the next overlay.

1219
01:20:08.150 --> 01:20:12.313
We have it type formatted because within hours it was on Wikipedia.

1220
01:20:12.333 --> 01:20:16.375
You go into the Jacobian Conjecture Wikipedia article, it says counterexample.

1221
01:20:16.775 --> 01:20:18.336
And it shows that it's not true.

1222
01:20:18.576 --> 01:20:20.257
You know that meme where we got him?

1223
01:20:20.437 --> 01:20:21.117
We got him.

1224
01:20:21.157 --> 01:20:23.719
With what's his name and the balloons and confetti?

1225
01:20:24.119 --> 01:20:24.339
Yeah.

1226
01:20:24.579 --> 01:20:25.620
They did it immediately.

1227
01:20:25.760 --> 01:20:27.260
Yeah, yeah, immediately, right?

1228
01:20:27.561 --> 01:20:31.843
And this is a counterexample, meaning he has shown a map where...

1229
01:20:32.686 --> 01:20:34.987
The Jacobian determinant is a constant.

1230
01:20:35.608 --> 01:20:40.730
So this functional mapping, this map between, this is in 3D.

1231
01:20:40.810 --> 01:20:44.673
So we're taking 3D space and plotting it to another 3D space.

1232
01:20:44.693 --> 01:20:46.734
So volume is getting morphed.

1233
01:20:47.114 --> 01:20:52.057
But the volume getting morphed is always at a constant of negative 2, meaning one of the axes is flipped.

1234
01:20:52.437 --> 01:20:53.898
So it's like getting flipped.

1235
01:20:54.378 --> 01:21:00.141
And if you've got a cube of the size 1, it becomes a cube of size 2 in the new one.

1236
01:21:00.161 --> 01:21:01.642
But one of the axes is a little bit...

1237
01:21:02.122 --> 01:21:02.622
It is flipped.

1238
01:21:03.522 --> 01:21:14.986
This is a functional map that shows that we've got a constant Jacobian determinant, but two different points are being plotted to the same resulting point.

1239
01:21:16.426 --> 01:21:16.966
Aha.

1240
01:21:17.166 --> 01:21:19.667
Meaning, if you gave me that resulting point...

1241
01:21:20.643 --> 01:21:23.366
I couldn't tell you which of the two it came from.

1242
01:21:23.826 --> 01:21:24.026
Yes.

1243
01:21:25.027 --> 01:21:35.897
The point being, you don't have the ability to go from the result back to the original map because two points point to the same place.

1244
01:21:36.217 --> 01:21:37.338
It could be one of two things.

1245
01:21:37.919 --> 01:21:39.941
So it's inherently not invertible.

1246
01:21:40.141 --> 01:21:42.463
It turns out there's a third point as well.

1247
01:21:42.723 --> 01:21:46.507
And this is actually what's crazy about this is you can do this yourself.

1248
01:21:47.715 --> 01:21:49.736
And I actually did it.

1249
01:21:49.776 --> 01:21:57.100
Like, before we, like, as I was doing research for this episode, I went ahead and did it by hand.

1250
01:21:57.480 --> 01:21:59.701
And I can show you my work.

1251
01:22:00.002 --> 01:22:00.762
It's in the next one.

1252
01:22:01.382 --> 01:22:03.243
So this is, I did it myself, right?

1253
01:22:03.323 --> 01:22:04.084
I took the three...

1254
01:22:06.963 --> 01:22:27.082
components of the function so the new x coordinate is some seven degree polynomial that has that mixes x y and z the new y coordinate is another i think seven degree polynomial and then the the z coordinate is not a seven degree polynomial it's a little bit simpler but you i've got this map where x x y and z goes to a new x new y new z and

1255
01:22:27.743 --> 01:22:30.605
I calculated the derivatives, which are on the left.

1256
01:22:30.966 --> 01:22:33.948
So that becomes a matrix, which you see on the top right.

1257
01:22:34.008 --> 01:22:34.188
Right.

1258
01:22:34.448 --> 01:22:40.573
And then I did a little bit of cheating because I decided I didn't want to multiply all those polynomials.

1259
01:22:40.773 --> 01:22:41.293
Okay.

1260
01:22:41.694 --> 01:22:44.456
I wanted to see if I could still do it, if I still got it.

1261
01:22:44.496 --> 01:22:45.897
And I got halfway and I'm like...

1262
01:22:46.217 --> 01:22:47.960
I still got it.

1263
01:22:47.980 --> 01:22:52.986
So then I went on Wolfram Alpha, and I just multiplied all of those polynomials to calculate the determinant.

1264
01:22:53.347 --> 01:22:54.969
And the determinant is negative 2.

1265
01:22:55.490 --> 01:22:58.794
And then I went ahead and plugged in those two numbers.

1266
01:22:59.295 --> 01:23:00.036
So fascinating.

1267
01:23:00.536 --> 01:23:02.739
And they went to the same number, negative 1 fourth, 0, 0.

1268
01:23:04.467 --> 01:23:04.847
There you go.

1269
01:23:05.047 --> 01:23:08.069
I did it on a single piece of paper plus, okay, a little bit of Wolfram Alpha.

1270
01:23:08.589 --> 01:23:08.769
Right?

1271
01:23:08.869 --> 01:23:11.330
It would have involved another piece of paper for me to do it.

1272
01:23:11.710 --> 01:23:13.611
But I was already, you can see the crossing out.

1273
01:23:13.671 --> 01:23:14.892
I was like starting to make mistakes.

1274
01:23:14.952 --> 01:23:15.632
I was like, let's.

1275
01:23:16.072 --> 01:23:27.978
This is so interesting because, you know, and I think this is why it had the, you know, it comes back to your point earlier about why it's easier to disprove than to prove.

1276
01:23:28.018 --> 01:23:31.820
Because especially given the structure of this open problem.

1277
01:23:32.841 --> 01:23:38.566
And the nature of the disproof, if that's the right naming convention.

1278
01:23:38.607 --> 01:23:39.728
The counter example.

1279
01:23:39.768 --> 01:23:40.789
Sorry, the counter example.

1280
01:23:44.433 --> 01:23:49.237
Anyone can do it and see that it is true, going back to our point about mathematics.

1281
01:23:49.278 --> 01:23:49.498
Yeah.

1282
01:23:49.838 --> 01:23:51.099
And the objective nature of it.

1283
01:23:51.320 --> 01:23:52.301
Yeah, exactly.

1284
01:23:52.761 --> 01:23:53.162
I did it.

1285
01:23:53.282 --> 01:23:54.022
Anyone can do it.

1286
01:23:54.767 --> 01:23:54.967
Right.

1287
01:23:55.007 --> 01:23:57.569
This is something that algorithmically there's no AI here.

1288
01:23:57.729 --> 01:23:57.929
Right.

1289
01:23:58.069 --> 01:23:58.269
Right.

1290
01:23:58.309 --> 01:24:02.632
It's just it's an algorithmic process of taking derivatives, taking the determinant of the Jacobian.

1291
01:24:02.912 --> 01:24:03.372
There you go.

1292
01:24:03.412 --> 01:24:04.913
Boom.

1293
01:24:04.933 --> 01:24:08.415
There's a constant determinant and two points point to the same thing.

1294
01:24:08.695 --> 01:24:09.476
So I can't go backwards.

1295
01:24:09.496 --> 01:24:10.276
I can't go backwards.

1296
01:24:10.316 --> 01:24:15.580
And it's not invertible, which means the Jacobian conjecture fundamentally not a real thing.

1297
01:24:15.680 --> 01:24:16.360
It's not a real thing.

1298
01:24:16.700 --> 01:24:16.920
Right.

1299
01:24:17.080 --> 01:24:17.861
It's not a real thing.

1300
01:24:18.168 --> 01:24:24.872
And it's a counter example in degree, well, it's in degree 7, but it's in three dimensions, right?

1301
01:24:25.152 --> 01:24:28.494
Which means for all higher dimensions, it's also not true.

1302
01:24:28.514 --> 01:24:34.978
Because I can just take, like, consider the trivial map where I take a function of four dimensions.

1303
01:24:35.138 --> 01:24:41.341
Let's say X, Y, Z, and T. T is our fourth dimension in a la relativity.

1304
01:24:42.162 --> 01:24:46.024
X, Y, and Z do what that function was doing, and T just points to T, right?

1305
01:24:46.044 --> 01:24:47.005
So the time doesn't change.

1306
01:24:48.258 --> 01:24:57.622
That is going to have the same Jacobian determinant, and the things are going to point to the same point in 3D space, and the time doesn't change.

1307
01:24:58.222 --> 01:24:58.402
Right?

1308
01:24:58.442 --> 01:25:03.184
I can do that for n equals 5, n equals 6, any dimension greater than 3 now.

1309
01:25:03.204 --> 01:25:05.765
So this proved all dimensions greater than 3.

1310
01:25:05.945 --> 01:25:06.245
Right.

1311
01:25:06.485 --> 01:25:07.726
So it's only true in 2.

1312
01:25:08.206 --> 01:25:08.406
Yeah.

1313
01:25:08.446 --> 01:25:10.207
Now it's like, now it's an open question.

1314
01:25:10.227 --> 01:25:11.227
Oh, right, because we don't know.

1315
01:25:11.267 --> 01:25:11.687
We don't know.

1316
01:25:11.707 --> 01:25:12.268
Yeah.

1317
01:25:13.540 --> 01:25:14.081
Right?

1318
01:25:14.342 --> 01:25:18.511
So now the Jacobian conjecture is, yes, it's only in two dimensions.

1319
01:25:18.552 --> 01:25:19.915
Now it's still an open problem.

1320
01:25:19.935 --> 01:25:20.937
Still an open problem.

1321
01:25:21.077 --> 01:25:21.759
Not yet solved.

1322
01:25:21.879 --> 01:25:22.180
Okay.

1323
01:25:22.973 --> 01:25:24.094
But that's interesting.

1324
01:25:24.174 --> 01:25:27.175
But like for all the infinity of dimensions above.

1325
01:25:27.495 --> 01:25:30.477
Which is like really a much more meaningful.

1326
01:25:30.517 --> 01:25:30.997
Yeah, yeah.

1327
01:25:31.037 --> 01:25:31.938
It's crazy.

1328
01:25:32.038 --> 01:25:32.358
No, this.

1329
01:25:32.778 --> 01:25:49.727
And I think what's so interesting is that, again, and we might get to this, but one of the things that people always want to view a solution that has an AI system involved as being there has to be some, you know, it's a magic show.

1330
01:25:49.747 --> 01:25:51.128
So there has to be some trick somewhere.

1331
01:25:51.148 --> 01:25:51.248
Yeah.

1332
01:25:51.968 --> 01:25:57.311
Oh, you just ask Fable, the latest frontier model from Anthropik, to just brute force it.

1333
01:25:57.771 --> 01:26:05.655
And if you look at the amount of time required to brute force, it's just, it's like to the power of...

1334
01:26:07.067 --> 01:26:08.648
To the power of crazy.

1335
01:26:08.808 --> 01:26:10.569
And that's actually my next point.

1336
01:26:10.749 --> 01:26:11.089
Okay.

1337
01:26:11.229 --> 01:26:13.450
We can actually ask, did Fable just brute force?

1338
01:26:13.650 --> 01:26:14.370
Right, right.

1339
01:26:14.390 --> 01:26:16.551
Did it just do like supercomputer nonsense?

1340
01:26:17.072 --> 01:26:18.212
Because they have a lot of computers.

1341
01:26:18.332 --> 01:26:21.254
Yeah, and there's history behind supercomputer nonsense, okay?

1342
01:26:21.494 --> 01:26:24.215
So let's talk about, like, this is a counterexample, okay?

1343
01:26:24.275 --> 01:26:28.677
And historically, computation has been very good at producing counterexamples, okay?

1344
01:26:28.917 --> 01:26:30.598
Way back in the 1960s, actually.

1345
01:26:30.858 --> 01:26:32.839
So let's talk about Euler's conjecture.

1346
01:26:33.179 --> 01:26:34.380
Euler's conjecture is the following.

1347
01:26:34.900 --> 01:26:39.503
That you remember we were talking about like Fermat's last theorem and the Pythagorean theorem.

1348
01:26:39.784 --> 01:26:43.946
Like the Pythagorean theorem is that like the sum of two squares can equal another square.

1349
01:26:43.966 --> 01:26:44.046
Yes.

1350
01:26:44.467 --> 01:26:45.728
So like two squares.

1351
01:26:46.869 --> 01:26:51.191
Two thingies to the power of two equals another thing to the power of two.

1352
01:26:51.471 --> 01:26:56.594
Trivial example, three squared plus four squared equals five squared because nine plus 16 equals 25.

1353
01:26:57.595 --> 01:27:09.981
Plato, way back in the day, had found another kind of Pythagorean-looking thing where he showed that three cubed plus four cubed plus five cubed is actually six cubed, which is kind of cool.

1354
01:27:10.261 --> 01:27:11.382
It's called Plato's Number.

1355
01:27:11.502 --> 01:27:11.722
Mm-hmm.

1356
01:27:12.679 --> 01:27:13.941
Um, so, all right.

1357
01:27:14.762 --> 01:27:24.193
The Euler looked at this, looked at Plato's number, and he said, well, um, look, if, if, if I need, in that case, I needed three cubes.

1358
01:27:24.613 --> 01:27:24.833
Yes.

1359
01:27:25.174 --> 01:27:26.215
To get to another cube.

1360
01:27:26.255 --> 01:27:26.635
Yeah, right.

1361
01:27:26.816 --> 01:27:27.076
Okay.

1362
01:27:27.096 --> 01:27:27.256
Right.

1363
01:27:27.356 --> 01:27:28.818
So Euler's like, what if I need N...

1364
01:27:29.839 --> 01:27:32.861
To the nth power to get to another nth power.

1365
01:27:33.121 --> 01:27:38.124
I need at least n things to the nth power to get to another nth power.

1366
01:27:38.244 --> 01:27:46.808
So if I want something like a to the fourth plus b to the fourth plus c to the fourth, I would need another d to the fourth in order to get to an e to the fourth.

1367
01:27:46.848 --> 01:27:48.349
He was trying to generalize Plato's number.

1368
01:27:49.610 --> 01:27:50.010
Exactly.

1369
01:27:50.050 --> 01:27:52.951
He's trying to generalize, because Pythagorean theorem already happened, right?

1370
01:27:53.231 --> 01:27:54.792
Three squared plus four squared equals five squared.

1371
01:27:54.812 --> 01:27:57.893
Plato's number is saying, okay, I need three cubes to get to another cube.

1372
01:27:58.233 --> 01:28:00.933
So maybe I need four to the fourth power to get to a fourth.

1373
01:28:01.234 --> 01:28:02.914
I need five to the fifth power, right?

1374
01:28:02.934 --> 01:28:04.655
And that's Euler's conjecture.

1375
01:28:04.775 --> 01:28:06.195
Remains untrue for a very long time.

1376
01:28:06.655 --> 01:28:15.378
Lo and behold, Lander and Parkin, in a very, very famous mathematical paper, one of the shortest math papers of all time,

1377
01:28:15.958 --> 01:28:16.139
Right.

1378
01:28:16.439 --> 01:28:23.807
They're like direct search with the CDC 6000 66000, which is one of the first successful supercomputers.

1379
01:28:24.287 --> 01:28:25.288
They just brute forced it.

1380
01:28:25.348 --> 01:28:26.530
Yeah.

1381
01:28:26.550 --> 01:28:28.532
And they found a counter example.

1382
01:28:30.267 --> 01:28:38.910
27 to the fifth power plus 84 to the fifth power plus 110 to the fifth power plus 133 to the fifth power equals 144 to the fifth power.

1383
01:28:39.130 --> 01:28:42.871
So I only needed four fifth power thingies to get to a fifth power.

1384
01:28:42.891 --> 01:28:43.711
We don't like that.

1385
01:28:43.771 --> 01:28:44.011
Yeah.

1386
01:28:44.111 --> 01:28:48.453
And they were just like, it's the smallest instance in which five fifth powers.

1387
01:28:49.013 --> 01:28:49.493
There you go.

1388
01:28:49.633 --> 01:28:49.993
Sorry.

1389
01:28:50.313 --> 01:28:51.133
Sorry, Euler.

1390
01:28:51.193 --> 01:28:51.634
You're wrong.

1391
01:28:51.714 --> 01:28:52.814
Which is crazy to say.

1392
01:28:52.854 --> 01:28:53.014
Right.

1393
01:28:53.054 --> 01:28:54.134
Euler is wrong.

1394
01:28:56.735 --> 01:28:58.557
But this is a perfect point.

1395
01:28:58.577 --> 01:29:02.881
This is why people immediately go to, again, you know, the... Oh, they just brute force.

1396
01:29:02.901 --> 01:29:03.341
Yeah, right.

1397
01:29:03.481 --> 01:29:03.661
Right.

1398
01:29:03.901 --> 01:29:07.484
And this, in this case, the brute force, it could work.

1399
01:29:07.745 --> 01:29:12.609
Because the sample space that they were, they were just like, okay, let's just go for fifth powers.

1400
01:29:12.629 --> 01:29:14.270
Let's go all the way up to like 200.

1401
01:29:14.290 --> 01:29:14.410
200.

1402
01:29:15.271 --> 01:29:16.872
For all the numbers, and let's just try it out.

1403
01:29:17.013 --> 01:29:17.933
And it happened to be that.

1404
01:29:18.073 --> 01:29:22.217
And the search space is small enough where with a big enough supercomputer, I can do it.

1405
01:29:22.617 --> 01:29:24.799
And this was some time ago.

1406
01:29:24.839 --> 01:29:25.860
Yeah, this was in the 60s.

1407
01:29:26.180 --> 01:29:29.423
And now we've found more and more exceptions of Euler's conjecture.

1408
01:29:29.503 --> 01:29:30.024
It's rare.

1409
01:29:30.124 --> 01:29:31.105
It's increasingly rare.

1410
01:29:31.545 --> 01:29:34.347
And there's a lot of mathematics about how rare it is.

1411
01:29:34.748 --> 01:29:36.569
And that's its own mathematical field.

1412
01:29:36.709 --> 01:29:36.889
Yes.

1413
01:29:37.030 --> 01:29:40.653
But let's consider, could Fable have just brute forced it?

1414
01:29:41.153 --> 01:29:41.333
Right.

1415
01:29:41.593 --> 01:29:42.154
I don't think so.

1416
01:29:42.214 --> 01:29:43.955
I think this is fundamentally different, right?

1417
01:29:43.995 --> 01:29:46.077
The search space is actually, I think, too large.

1418
01:29:46.477 --> 01:29:51.341
Because here, what we'd have to do is test every single function...

1419
01:29:53.175 --> 01:29:55.456
of polynomials, right?

1420
01:29:55.476 --> 01:29:56.717
There's X, Y, and Z.

1421
01:29:56.998 --> 01:30:00.200
So let's just do like, okay, it found like the seven degree polynomial, right?

1422
01:30:00.240 --> 01:30:01.561
There was an X to the seven there.

1423
01:30:03.242 --> 01:30:12.450
If you just think about seven degree polynomials and seven degree maps, so you can have seven degrees in X, seven degrees in Y, seven degrees in Z.

1424
01:30:13.530 --> 01:30:17.271
And each of those can have different numbers.

1425
01:30:17.571 --> 01:30:21.132
So first of all, that's 343 different polynomial terms.

1426
01:30:21.632 --> 01:30:26.193
Each of those polynomial terms can then make up 1,300 cubic equations.

1427
01:30:26.593 --> 01:30:28.414
And then the coefficients of that equation, right?

1428
01:30:28.494 --> 01:30:30.154
Is it 1x squared y?

1429
01:30:30.574 --> 01:30:31.714
Is it 2x squared y?

1430
01:30:32.014 --> 01:30:33.315
Is it 1x cubed y?

1431
01:30:33.735 --> 01:30:42.437
Each of those coefficients to create individual functional maps, even if you were to test within a tiny integer range of, let's say, negative 10 to 10,

1432
01:30:43.137 --> 01:30:48.320
and try all of the different coefficients, that would be something like 10 to the 475 candidates.

1433
01:30:48.420 --> 01:30:48.600
Right.

1434
01:30:48.860 --> 01:30:49.080
Right?

1435
01:30:49.160 --> 01:30:49.360
Right.

1436
01:30:50.020 --> 01:30:59.345
Even like a million-cubit quantum computer, if we were to create a quantum algorithm that could somehow do this, which I'm just saying, we don't even have one.

1437
01:30:59.625 --> 01:31:00.285
For another day.

1438
01:31:00.385 --> 01:31:01.326
Yeah, that's for another day.

1439
01:31:01.346 --> 01:31:02.086
We don't even have one.

1440
01:31:02.106 --> 01:31:03.607
But, like, you can't.

1441
01:31:04.598 --> 01:31:05.278
You can't do that.

1442
01:31:05.539 --> 01:31:07.660
This is not a brute force thing, right?

1443
01:31:07.700 --> 01:31:24.792
Like Fable had to understand something about the structure of polynomial maps, understand something about the properties of polynomial maps where the Jacobian is constant, and then look for places where things would overlap.

1444
01:31:24.812 --> 01:31:29.436
Because if the Jacobian is constant, that means that any given infinitesimal area is constant.

1445
01:31:30.216 --> 01:31:31.837
is being put into the same thing.

1446
01:31:31.857 --> 01:31:35.378
So it's not just trivially that the thing is going to the same spot.

1447
01:31:35.418 --> 01:31:42.741
There's overlap happening where different parts of the space are getting mapped to the same thing in some weird way.

1448
01:31:42.961 --> 01:31:45.762
But somehow the Jacobian determinant is still a constant.

1449
01:31:46.942 --> 01:31:52.946
I think what's been interesting to hear about the discussion of open problems and AI systems, and this is, I think, is a perfect example.

1450
01:31:53.726 --> 01:31:54.767
There was a discussion.

1451
01:31:55.727 --> 01:31:57.268
It's going to escape me who it was with.

1452
01:31:57.288 --> 01:32:13.437
But there were sort of three different there are three people in the field who were coming from three different perspectives about AI's potential in particularly this idea of novelty or or scientific discovery.

1453
01:32:13.517 --> 01:32:13.737
Yeah.

1454
01:32:13.757 --> 01:32:15.118
General, not well-defined term.

1455
01:32:15.799 --> 01:32:29.074
And one of the arguments was that even if a system like Fable has scooped up every math paper ever.

1456
01:32:29.434 --> 01:32:29.534
Yeah.

1457
01:32:29.554 --> 01:32:29.694
Right?

1458
01:32:29.975 --> 01:32:30.175
Right.

1459
01:32:31.682 --> 01:32:36.944
It also has the benefit of having every physics paper, every biology paper.

1460
01:32:37.424 --> 01:32:53.790
And because of the way structurally these fields are for human beings, although it's maybe changing in recent times, people who are very deep in a particular lane or expertise in math or in physics or in biology are...

1461
01:32:54.430 --> 01:33:05.539
They may dip their toe in orthogonal fields, but they don't have the same level of expertise in their own field in that other field.

1462
01:33:06.159 --> 01:33:13.765
And simply by just having that same level of expertise in a cross-functional, in a cross-field way...

1463
01:33:16.220 --> 01:33:19.562
Because a lot of science is making these connections that are non-obvious.

1464
01:33:19.982 --> 01:33:24.045
The ability for these systems to make connections that are non-obvious is just exponential.

1465
01:33:24.125 --> 01:33:24.365
Yeah.

1466
01:33:24.765 --> 01:33:37.934
And we may discover that there are a lot of solutions just simply in taking known information and finding things you can carry over from physics.

1467
01:33:38.894 --> 01:33:43.156
that have an application in math that we've just not explored.

1468
01:33:43.296 --> 01:33:44.097
Yeah, that's true.

1469
01:33:44.157 --> 01:33:48.599
I mean, like in string theory, for example, string theory bleeds a lot into fundamental mathematics, right?

1470
01:33:48.899 --> 01:33:55.302
Now, one of the things that is really unclear about this discovery is like what the prompt that was used, right?

1471
01:33:56.303 --> 01:34:02.546
If the chain of thought has some insight into how it got to this particular functional map, right?

1472
01:34:02.946 --> 01:34:04.527
And whether it used all of those...

1473
01:34:05.527 --> 01:34:06.407
All of that knowledge.

1474
01:34:06.487 --> 01:34:19.313
Like that was my that was my suspicion when there was that one discovery that we talked about with the the glue on tree and like how there's like a seven glue on Feynman diagram that it could calculate that's non zero.

1475
01:34:19.614 --> 01:34:21.074
And that's something that we have to worry about.

1476
01:34:21.154 --> 01:34:24.816
I was like, OK, maybe there's some mathematics that's happening elsewhere that is like.

1477
01:34:25.656 --> 01:34:26.917
bleeding into this physics, right?

1478
01:34:27.297 --> 01:34:32.500
It's, however, very rare to go up the chain of logical inquiry.

1479
01:34:33.480 --> 01:34:35.562
And that's why I'm, like, freaked out, kind of.

1480
01:34:35.662 --> 01:34:45.347
I think this is an important point because I wanted to lay that out there to this exact note, which is, like, even if that's true, what I just walked through,

1481
01:34:46.147 --> 01:34:53.690
What we're talking about with this solution to the Jacobian conjecture seems to be outside of that, potentially outside of that sandbox.

1482
01:34:53.710 --> 01:34:54.010
Yeah.

1483
01:34:54.230 --> 01:34:54.670
Yeah.

1484
01:34:54.690 --> 01:34:55.131
It seems.

1485
01:34:55.231 --> 01:34:55.811
It seems.

1486
01:34:55.831 --> 01:34:56.171
I don't know.

1487
01:34:56.251 --> 01:34:56.571
I don't know.

1488
01:34:57.572 --> 01:34:59.052
And I'd love to talk to Levant.

1489
01:34:59.332 --> 01:35:00.373
Even the potential.

1490
01:35:00.813 --> 01:35:00.933
Yeah.

1491
01:35:00.973 --> 01:35:01.073
Yeah.

1492
01:35:01.413 --> 01:35:04.716
That it's not obviously what we just talked about, which has been the case for other things.

1493
01:35:04.776 --> 01:35:04.876
Yeah.

1494
01:35:04.896 --> 01:35:08.579
It's like, oh, this is they made the connection here and you can draw the through line.

1495
01:35:09.219 --> 01:35:11.381
Even just the potential that that's true.

1496
01:35:11.461 --> 01:35:11.701
Yeah.

1497
01:35:12.041 --> 01:35:15.143
Is, you know, and people need the part of it.

1498
01:35:15.284 --> 01:35:18.966
You know, the Levant who discovered it is obviously one of the world's greatest mathematicians.

1499
01:35:19.367 --> 01:35:20.347
It's been so for a long time.

1500
01:35:20.367 --> 01:35:21.068
But he's not.

1501
01:35:21.448 --> 01:35:21.949
Oh, he's not.

1502
01:35:21.969 --> 01:35:22.029
No.

1503
01:35:22.849 --> 01:35:24.651
I mean, look, no offense to Levant.

1504
01:35:25.051 --> 01:35:26.532
Look, I don't want that heat.

1505
01:35:26.992 --> 01:35:28.373
Look, look, no offense to Levant.

1506
01:35:28.393 --> 01:35:33.137
He's got a PhD from Princeton, so he's clearly in the top 1% of math petitions, I'd say, right?

1507
01:35:33.457 --> 01:35:34.138
So on and so forth.

1508
01:35:34.178 --> 01:35:37.360
But he's not like an active researcher, I would say.

1509
01:35:37.380 --> 01:35:38.000
Okay, that's fair.

1510
01:35:38.081 --> 01:35:38.361
That's fair.

1511
01:35:38.641 --> 01:35:39.001
And...

1512
01:35:40.202 --> 01:35:48.047
But he knows clearly, I mean, he's a researcher in anthropic, and he's very good at understanding how to use and leverage anthropic, right?

1513
01:35:48.307 --> 01:35:51.008
And clearly he knows a lot about mathematics, right?

1514
01:35:51.348 --> 01:35:57.092
But this isn't like someone like Peter Sarnak, that's like a number theorist, using this stuff, right?

1515
01:35:57.112 --> 01:35:57.352
Right.

1516
01:35:58.754 --> 01:36:02.796
That's why I really want to know what the prompt was.

1517
01:36:03.077 --> 01:36:05.058
Which almost makes it again even more.

1518
01:36:05.538 --> 01:36:06.238
Yeah.

1519
01:36:06.458 --> 01:36:11.041
Like he's clearly gifted, but he's not at that top level that's getting Fields medals.

1520
01:36:11.161 --> 01:36:13.422
Fascinating.

1521
01:36:13.943 --> 01:36:24.429
There's so many angles to this story that I think are, you know, again, a lot of the CEOs and people around who are at the frontier of these systems who have unlimited compute with them, by the way.

1522
01:36:24.509 --> 01:36:24.769
Yeah.

1523
01:36:24.969 --> 01:36:26.150
Which is part of the value out there.

1524
01:36:27.230 --> 01:36:47.345
have been sort of the canary in the coal mine around that look they've been saying that this is where it's headed this is and everyone's kind of been like yeah yeah show me yeah well yeah and there's several examples right now before we get into the other examples one thing i wanted to talk about was like how humans have been approaching this problem right

1525
01:36:47.625 --> 01:36:48.385
right?

1526
01:36:48.425 --> 01:36:54.107
There's been this degree paradox where human researchers have spent decades brute-forcing variables.

1527
01:36:54.147 --> 01:36:59.368
Like, we've been doing a lot of the brute-forcing, up to 16 variables, degree 100 plus.

1528
01:36:59.689 --> 01:37:09.711
So for 2D, for example, we've been focusing as humans a lot on the 2D case, because we thought 2D would be where we could find, with the least amount of computation, some kind of

1529
01:37:11.692 --> 01:37:12.953
counter example, right?

1530
01:37:13.274 --> 01:37:26.868
But it turns out there's proofs that show that the smallest 2D case would have to have a polynomial of degree like 100, like X to the 100 plus X to the 99, da-da-da-da-da, right?

1531
01:37:27.008 --> 01:37:28.550
And so we've been focusing on this like...

1532
01:37:29.090 --> 01:37:30.370
Highly complicated thing.

1533
01:37:30.710 --> 01:37:36.532
But here, Claude Fable V proves that a low degree, degree 7, it's just in a higher dimension.

1534
01:37:36.632 --> 01:37:36.932
Yeah.

1535
01:37:37.232 --> 01:37:38.112
Dimension 3.

1536
01:37:38.272 --> 01:37:38.492
Right.

1537
01:37:38.832 --> 01:37:40.153
That counterexample exists.

1538
01:37:40.573 --> 01:37:44.113
It's kind of like a human blind spot that we didn't really consider.

1539
01:37:44.133 --> 01:37:48.434
There's not a lot of papers about the Jacobian conjecture in degree 3.

1540
01:37:49.015 --> 01:37:50.015
Sorry, in dimension 3.

1541
01:37:50.035 --> 01:37:50.195
Yes.

1542
01:37:50.395 --> 01:37:50.595
Yes.

1543
01:37:51.375 --> 01:37:55.036
Yeah, which goes back to then what is the source material for the insight.

1544
01:37:55.196 --> 01:37:58.457
And historically, there's kind of an irony.

1545
01:37:58.577 --> 01:38:03.759
If you look at Yiteng Zhang, he's a very famous number theorist.

1546
01:38:03.899 --> 01:38:09.500
He's one of the first guys to bring down the prime gaps to something like, I think it was like 79 million.

1547
01:38:09.540 --> 01:38:14.862
Prime gaps meaning, you know, the twin prime conjecture where like there's an infinite number of primes that are two apart.

1548
01:38:15.302 --> 01:38:18.565
three and five, 11 and 13, one-on-one, one-on-three.

1549
01:38:18.945 --> 01:38:22.909
So we still don't know if there's an infinite number of those, but he's the first guy to bring down.

1550
01:38:22.949 --> 01:38:27.473
And he said, there are an infinite number of primes that are like less than 70 million.

1551
01:38:27.854 --> 01:38:29.515
And everyone was like, ah, right.

1552
01:38:29.555 --> 01:38:39.444
But his story is insane because like during his PhD at Purdue university, he was under the advice of, um, so on seeing Mo and,

1553
01:38:40.605 --> 01:38:43.107
And his work was on this very conjecture.

1554
01:38:43.527 --> 01:38:44.908
It led to years of hardship.

1555
01:38:44.928 --> 01:38:45.828
He couldn't get anywhere.

1556
01:38:47.709 --> 01:38:58.076
It's a really kind of a sad story because his dissertation relied on this auxiliary corollary about the conjecture that was proved by his advisor, later discovered to be false under peer review.

1557
01:38:58.336 --> 01:39:00.037
And so his entire PhD...

1558
01:39:00.617 --> 01:39:02.779
Turns out to not be true because that's how math works.

1559
01:39:03.279 --> 01:39:03.499
Right.

1560
01:39:03.599 --> 01:39:05.621
And then kind of crazy.

1561
01:39:05.681 --> 01:39:10.565
He like he couldn't get a his advisor was kind of pissed off about that.

1562
01:39:10.585 --> 01:39:10.885
Yeah.

1563
01:39:11.025 --> 01:39:13.347
He couldn't get a recommendation letter.

1564
01:39:13.828 --> 01:39:18.471
And he was he was a subway worker, minimum wage, and he lived out of his car.

1565
01:39:18.692 --> 01:39:19.252
Jesus Christ.

1566
01:39:19.412 --> 01:39:28.134
for a while before he proved the twin prime corollary and then became like a very famous mathematician.

1567
01:39:28.294 --> 01:39:40.618
And now we've got something like AI that maybe can save mathematicians time, but at the same time it's like how much of this is AI going to do to the point where are mathematicians going to be left with a job?

1568
01:39:40.998 --> 01:39:44.198
Or are they going to just be explaining stuff that AI is doing?

1569
01:39:44.679 --> 01:39:45.899
That brings me to my next point.

1570
01:39:46.399 --> 01:39:47.740
Which is about the...

1571
01:39:47.860 --> 01:39:48.441
In 2020...

1572
01:39:48.481 --> 01:39:49.662
This is part of a trend.

1573
01:39:49.862 --> 01:39:50.322
Yes.

1574
01:39:50.422 --> 01:40:00.891
In 2026, the OpenAI model disproved the Erdos planar unit distance conjecture that was conjectured by Erdos, Paul Erdos in 1946.

1575
01:40:01.932 --> 01:40:03.213
This is the proof for it.

1576
01:40:03.333 --> 01:40:04.995
It has to do with like the...

1577
01:40:06.126 --> 01:40:12.552
it asks like the maximum number of pairs of points that can be exactly one unit apart in 2d.

1578
01:40:12.952 --> 01:40:17.096
So like trivially, you could imagine a grid of points, right?

1579
01:40:17.136 --> 01:40:17.777
A grid of points.

1580
01:40:17.877 --> 01:40:20.219
All of these points are one distance apart.

1581
01:40:20.379 --> 01:40:23.842
And you would think that that's like the best way to pack all the points, right?

1582
01:40:23.943 --> 01:40:28.607
Airdosh showed that there's like an upper bound on how many points I can pack with this amount of distance.

1583
01:40:29.247 --> 01:40:29.408
And,

1584
01:40:31.109 --> 01:40:36.153
The OpenAI model disproved that bound and showed that there's a better bound.

1585
01:40:36.513 --> 01:40:44.759
And then later on, mathematicians took that proof and made a short, digested, human-verified version of that counterexample.

1586
01:40:45.040 --> 01:40:46.220
Again, it's a counterexample.

1587
01:40:46.641 --> 01:40:50.644
But here, the authors are a who's who of mathematicians.

1588
01:40:50.684 --> 01:40:54.447
We've got Timothy Gowers from Trinity College at the University of Cambridge.

1589
01:40:55.187 --> 01:40:55.948
in the UK.

1590
01:40:57.089 --> 01:40:58.149
He's a Fields Medalist.

1591
01:40:58.209 --> 01:41:03.353
We've also got Jacob Zimmerman, which it's been leaked, is the Fields Medalist this year.

1592
01:41:03.834 --> 01:41:08.057
If you go on Polymarket, it's all collapsed to 99% for people.

1593
01:41:08.477 --> 01:41:09.458
That's like, okay.

1594
01:41:09.798 --> 01:41:12.300
Somehow it got leaked, and now no one's betting anymore.

1595
01:41:12.780 --> 01:41:14.562
Jacob Zimmerman, actually, I think he was my...

1596
01:41:16.383 --> 01:41:18.204
He was my TA in freshman year.

1597
01:41:18.304 --> 01:41:19.025
Oh, we love that.

1598
01:41:19.045 --> 01:41:24.049
Yeah, because he was a PhD student of Peter Sarnak, who was teaching my... Come on the show.

1599
01:41:24.069 --> 01:41:25.550
We'd love to talk to you about it.

1600
01:41:25.590 --> 01:41:29.212
Yeah, we'd love to talk to you about how you gave me a... Never mind.

1601
01:41:29.232 --> 01:41:31.134
Let's not talk about how you graded my midterm.

1602
01:41:31.434 --> 01:41:34.917
But, you know, so this is a who's who, and what they're doing is...

1603
01:41:35.657 --> 01:41:51.462
taking the work of open ai and trying to make it human digestible so is that what mathematicians are going to just end up doing right right right being translators of the machine genius yeah and and the funny thing about this right so um open ai solved that eros conjecture

1604
01:41:52.402 --> 01:42:17.085
um levant our hero from this story at anthropic he tweeted again in all lower caps he's like um over the weekend i checked the obvious thing which is whether mythos is able to solve the erdos unit distance problem um aka erdos problem um the answer is yeah i love i think he's just trolling it's just all all lowercase

1605
01:42:18.327 --> 01:42:20.589
Gen Z capitalization language.

1606
01:42:20.669 --> 01:42:24.913
And then his colleague is like, you know, huge, huge credit to the OpenAI team.

1607
01:42:25.553 --> 01:42:26.674
But he's like retweeting.

1608
01:42:27.135 --> 01:42:31.038
But there are colleagues and he's like trying to make it a little bit more.

1609
01:42:31.058 --> 01:42:32.119
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1610
01:42:32.179 --> 01:42:32.960
Corpo speak.

1611
01:42:32.980 --> 01:42:33.640
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1612
01:42:33.700 --> 01:42:35.642
But it's just so funny.

1613
01:42:35.682 --> 01:42:36.903
I think the guy's just trolling.

1614
01:42:36.923 --> 01:42:37.043
Yeah.

1615
01:42:37.243 --> 01:42:37.983
This is so...

1616
01:42:38.023 --> 01:42:38.863
There's so much here.

1617
01:42:39.003 --> 01:42:40.044
Sorry, continue though.

1618
01:42:40.644 --> 01:42:40.804
Yeah.

1619
01:42:41.044 --> 01:42:47.605
And the final thing I want to end with is this is clearly now becoming an existential crisis for mathematics, right?

1620
01:42:47.945 --> 01:42:52.046
If AI is going to prove everything, what are pure mathematicians going to do?

1621
01:42:52.466 --> 01:42:55.106
And it makes me kind of sad, if I'm not going to lie.

1622
01:42:55.146 --> 01:43:00.448
It makes me happy that we're seeing such obvious counterexamples for things and stuff that I can understand.

1623
01:43:00.888 --> 01:43:01.788
And who knows?

1624
01:43:01.868 --> 01:43:02.568
We'll maybe...

1625
01:43:03.128 --> 01:43:19.215
Find a proof for the Riemann Zeta, or maybe we'll find a counterexample for the Riemann Zeta hypothesis where it's going to just come up with a zero for the Riemann function that's like, I don't know, two billion on the one half real line.

1626
01:43:19.975 --> 01:43:20.656
Who knows, right?

1627
01:43:20.676 --> 01:43:20.956
Who knows?

1628
01:43:21.076 --> 01:43:25.559
Probably not, because every mathematician that I know says that the Riemann hypothesis is true.

1629
01:43:26.080 --> 01:43:27.781
But who knows, right?

1630
01:43:27.821 --> 01:43:32.024
At this point, it would be kind of cool to find it, because that I could also check.

1631
01:43:32.044 --> 01:43:32.385
Yeah.

1632
01:43:32.505 --> 01:43:37.789
Like, not by hand, maybe, because I'd have to do it a bunch of times, but I could probably check on Wolfram, right?

1633
01:43:38.089 --> 01:43:41.411
So it's concerning.

1634
01:43:42.392 --> 01:43:45.133
It's concerning, to say the least, for pure mathematics.

1635
01:43:45.473 --> 01:43:50.774
And in June 2026, there was a statement from the Lorentz Center regarding AI-generated proof.

1636
01:43:50.914 --> 01:43:56.936
It was called the Leiden Declaration on Artificial Intelligence and Mathematics.

1637
01:43:57.236 --> 01:44:04.578
A bunch of mathematicians came together, and they laid out their key concerns about this new shift

1638
01:44:05.621 --> 01:44:09.385
In how we are starting to do mathematics as a discipline.

1639
01:44:09.986 --> 01:44:11.888
There's a threat to open science, right?

1640
01:44:11.948 --> 01:44:15.472
Because we don't know what the model weights are.

1641
01:44:15.612 --> 01:44:15.853
Yes.

1642
01:44:16.693 --> 01:44:17.594
Because they're closed source.

1643
01:44:17.735 --> 01:44:18.616
Yeah, they're closed source.

1644
01:44:18.656 --> 01:44:21.439
So I don't know what's happening inside.

1645
01:44:21.919 --> 01:44:22.860
It's not really open.

1646
01:44:22.900 --> 01:44:23.821
I'd have to pay to play.

1647
01:44:24.022 --> 01:44:24.262
Mm-hmm.

1648
01:44:25.603 --> 01:44:35.347
it's unsustainable journal review backlogs, because you can just now start making all sorts of proofs, submit it to the analysis of mathematics, and then what?

1649
01:44:35.987 --> 01:44:37.808
The humans are going to... And then now what?

1650
01:44:37.828 --> 01:44:39.048
We get AI reviewers?

1651
01:44:39.189 --> 01:44:39.429
Yeah.

1652
01:44:39.609 --> 01:44:40.389
Seems...

1653
01:44:40.529 --> 01:44:41.029
I don't know.

1654
01:44:41.089 --> 01:44:41.690
We don't like that.

1655
01:44:41.790 --> 01:44:43.430
I don't know, right?

1656
01:44:43.630 --> 01:44:53.435
And then there's divergent incentives, because you've got a commercial focus on benchmarks from all of these AI companies, versus the mathematicians who want to do deep theory.

1657
01:44:53.455 --> 01:44:53.795
Mm-hmm.

1658
01:44:54.641 --> 01:44:55.262
What are we going to do?

1659
01:44:55.282 --> 01:44:56.623
And they made some recommendations.

1660
01:44:56.743 --> 01:44:58.445
One was mandatory AI disclosure.

1661
01:44:59.566 --> 01:45:00.387
We love disclosure.

1662
01:45:00.407 --> 01:45:01.188
We love disclosure.

1663
01:45:01.208 --> 01:45:02.269
Here on this podcast.

1664
01:45:03.210 --> 01:45:04.051
Enhance scrutiny.

1665
01:45:04.151 --> 01:45:07.415
And there's proper attribution for human research.

1666
01:45:07.475 --> 01:45:10.398
Where did these AI models get the inspiration, right?

1667
01:45:10.618 --> 01:45:12.440
We'd like to know in our workings.

1668
01:45:12.700 --> 01:45:13.041
Bingo.

1669
01:45:13.141 --> 01:45:16.865
It's going to be tough because a lot of these LLMs are black boxes at the end of the day.

1670
01:45:16.985 --> 01:45:23.769
Claude, Anthropic is doing a great job trying to elucidate what is happening in the inner layers of their models.

1671
01:45:24.109 --> 01:45:27.131
But at the end of the day, it is kind of...

1672
01:45:28.827 --> 01:45:29.748
A black box, right?

1673
01:45:30.448 --> 01:45:40.836
They're also trying to go for independent funding from these industries to support mathematicians because you just covered a story about how fundamental research funding is down.

1674
01:45:40.856 --> 01:45:43.418
Well, mathematics research is also down.

1675
01:45:43.639 --> 01:45:47.181
And I don't think it should be one of those things where, oh, AI can do it.

1676
01:45:47.301 --> 01:45:48.482
We shouldn't have humans doing it.

1677
01:45:48.823 --> 01:45:53.746
I mean, I think mathematics is one of the most beautiful human disciplines that we can ever take part in, right?

1678
01:45:54.087 --> 01:45:55.348
It's something where we can say...

1679
01:45:55.968 --> 01:46:00.431
a statement is true and it will live on forever as long as human civilization is alive.

1680
01:46:00.771 --> 01:46:18.320
If we can engrave it in stone, right, and it outlasts human civilizations, and aliens came down a la Halo and saw the forerunners and saw Fermat's last theorem embedded in rock, they would be like, I kind of understand that, right?

1681
01:46:18.340 --> 01:46:20.862
If they saw squares in Pythagorean theorem, like...

1682
01:46:21.702 --> 01:46:26.563
That would be so cool because they have their own versions of that.

1683
01:46:26.683 --> 01:46:32.724
And so I don't want this to be a death sentence for mathematics.

1684
01:46:33.104 --> 01:46:37.285
It's really, I really hope that's not what's happening.

1685
01:46:37.665 --> 01:46:43.046
I do think another kind of aspect to this that you bring up is mathematics as an understanding.

1686
01:46:43.726 --> 01:46:50.467
If we want to retain human oversight over AI systems is fundamentally necessary.

1687
01:46:50.607 --> 01:46:50.827
Yeah.

1688
01:46:51.247 --> 01:46:56.933
Because the way these systems are built and work requires this as a discipline that is understood very well.

1689
01:46:56.953 --> 01:46:59.335
Yes, logic, correctness, truth.

1690
01:46:59.895 --> 01:47:06.442
And you cannot, we cannot say, oh, we'll have AGI and artificial general and artificial superintelligence.

1691
01:47:07.022 --> 01:47:09.725
And again, the argument is, well, if it's superintelligent, humans can't keep up.

1692
01:47:12.002 --> 01:47:19.146
We need to maintain this cohort of experts for as long as possible to manage whatever this transition is going to be.

1693
01:47:19.186 --> 01:47:26.010
Because I think we're now, I think Sir Demas Asabas has said, we are on the shores.

1694
01:47:26.650 --> 01:47:29.372
He has a great phraseology for this.

1695
01:47:30.873 --> 01:47:37.217
Oh, we are on the shores of the singularity, or we are on basically the sort of the dawn of the singularity here.

1696
01:47:37.237 --> 01:47:37.337
Yeah.

1697
01:47:37.857 --> 01:47:44.039
And I know Ray Kurzweil is known as kind of the modern proponent for this concept.

1698
01:47:44.919 --> 01:47:54.102
No one has ever been able to describe in words what it would feel like to be right there when the flip was about to switch.

1699
01:47:54.722 --> 01:47:58.403
And to me, even as a layman.

1700
01:48:00.063 --> 01:48:23.312
you can start to feel the ground moving yeah underneath our feet it's not to say the killer robot outcome and sky now that's not what we're talking about but if the raw power of machines at the edges of what human capability is is is here now what does that mean and there are so many ways in which

1701
01:48:25.701 --> 01:48:35.409
mathematically, scientifically, engineering-wise, socially, politically, economically, religiously, all of the E's.

1702
01:48:37.790 --> 01:48:43.374
You know, someone made the joke, it's like, when people say that they're, why do I care about politics, it doesn't affect me.

1703
01:48:43.675 --> 01:48:49.499
Oh, that must mean you're not, you know, a public employee, a veteran, a young person, an old person, a disabled person.

1704
01:48:49.799 --> 01:48:51.721
You come from wealth.

1705
01:48:52.661 --> 01:48:52.901
It is.

1706
01:48:53.262 --> 01:48:53.822
I know.

1707
01:48:53.842 --> 01:48:57.785
I know that everyone is tired of hearing about AI.

1708
01:48:58.125 --> 01:48:58.646
I know that.

1709
01:48:58.726 --> 01:48:59.186
I get it.

1710
01:48:59.286 --> 01:49:00.267
I totally understand it.

1711
01:49:01.508 --> 01:49:09.634
However, if we could have stopped the bankers from doing 08 before it happened, would people say no to that?

1712
01:49:09.814 --> 01:49:10.034
Yeah.

1713
01:49:10.234 --> 01:49:17.239
And it feels like a similar situation where there's a runaway train here and we need to do something.

1714
01:49:17.259 --> 01:49:17.360
Yeah.

1715
01:49:18.280 --> 01:49:18.501
Yeah.

1716
01:49:18.621 --> 01:49:19.562
I don't know what the answer is.

1717
01:49:19.622 --> 01:49:19.802
Yeah.

1718
01:49:19.862 --> 01:49:23.026
And maybe it's not to stop the progress because progress is always good.

1719
01:49:23.046 --> 01:49:24.147
Right.

1720
01:49:24.167 --> 01:49:26.209
But we got to talk about it.

1721
01:49:26.730 --> 01:49:27.911
And we have to engage in it.

1722
01:49:27.931 --> 01:49:28.091
Yeah.

1723
01:49:28.131 --> 01:49:29.393
And we have to have these discussions.

1724
01:49:29.893 --> 01:49:32.076
And we got to have some kind of policy, right?

1725
01:49:32.156 --> 01:49:34.178
It can't just be, oh, it's like too late.

1726
01:49:34.198 --> 01:49:34.458
Right.

1727
01:49:34.519 --> 01:49:34.699
Right.

1728
01:49:34.919 --> 01:49:36.101
Because everyone's unemployed.

1729
01:49:36.401 --> 01:49:36.902
Because it's not.

1730
01:49:36.922 --> 01:49:38.264
And now let's try to solve it.

1731
01:49:38.644 --> 01:49:39.926
Because right now it's not too late.

1732
01:49:39.986 --> 01:49:41.548
But very quickly it might be too late.

1733
01:49:41.628 --> 01:49:42.509
For mathematicians.

1734
01:49:42.850 --> 01:49:43.110
Yeah.

1735
01:49:43.130 --> 01:49:44.432
Or for some of these industries.

1736
01:49:44.472 --> 01:49:44.753
A lot of.

1737
01:49:45.233 --> 01:49:46.215
Oh, it's the white collar jobs.

1738
01:49:46.235 --> 01:49:46.896
Who cares?

1739
01:49:47.136 --> 01:49:47.937
I'm blue collar.

1740
01:49:47.957 --> 01:49:48.818
It's not going to impact me.

1741
01:49:49.519 --> 01:49:49.759
Well.

1742
01:49:49.780 --> 01:49:49.840
No.

1743
01:49:50.500 --> 01:49:51.741
The humanoid robotics are coming.

1744
01:49:51.801 --> 01:49:56.903
So it is, this is, you know, I know I'm making this larger philosophical and sociological point.

1745
01:49:57.543 --> 01:50:02.145
But the detail of what we walked through today is the canary in the coal mine.

1746
01:50:02.165 --> 01:50:15.230
The second time I'm saying this, this episode for, I think, a larger shift that is part of the reason we do this show, which is to make sure that the frontier of research in all of these industries is,

1747
01:50:15.890 --> 01:50:26.172
does not get so far ahead of the everyday person that people don't understand what people are doing on their behalf, especially with taxpayer-funded money.

1748
01:50:27.753 --> 01:50:29.213
This was so good, dude.

1749
01:50:30.113 --> 01:50:31.054
This was really, really good.

1750
01:50:31.074 --> 01:50:35.175
I can't believe I can go around and be like, oh, yeah, the Jacobian, it equals one.

1751
01:50:36.675 --> 01:50:38.875
It's a ratio of areas.

1752
01:50:38.975 --> 01:50:42.156
You should say volumes.

1753
01:50:42.196 --> 01:50:45.237
Because to mathematicians, an area is really a 2D volume.

1754
01:50:46.918 --> 01:50:48.019
Oh, those mathematicians.

1755
01:50:48.039 --> 01:50:48.780
They crack me up.

1756
01:50:49.080 --> 01:50:49.600
We love them.

1757
01:50:50.221 --> 01:50:53.283
This was, again, we're having a problem staying under two hours.

1758
01:50:53.964 --> 01:50:56.926
We're approaching two hours again this episode.

1759
01:50:57.467 --> 01:51:01.911
One, it's because we love y'all so much, and we just can't stop because it's all so good.

1760
01:51:02.071 --> 01:51:03.312
We touched on astrobiology.

1761
01:51:03.532 --> 01:51:06.435
We talked on science funding, and we spent a long time...

1762
01:51:07.275 --> 01:51:32.478
on what may be as we continue to see what transpires what was the prompt can we get a little bit more detail about how we got here what may be another watershed moment in the line of deep blue alpha fold alpha go uh the original i can't remember the name the points in the grid one that opening i did not that long ago no that was this year that was yeah yeah

1763
01:51:33.854 --> 01:51:34.815
It's all happening this year.

1764
01:51:34.875 --> 01:51:35.836
It's happening right now.

1765
01:51:35.876 --> 01:51:37.537
We are so blessed to have you all listening.

1766
01:51:37.557 --> 01:51:45.724
If you are still listening at this point in the pod, we need a quote, a comment for our deep, deep audience.

1767
01:51:45.744 --> 01:51:47.165
Make fun of mathematicians.

1768
01:51:47.266 --> 01:51:49.588
I love doing it as a physicist.

1769
01:51:49.608 --> 01:51:52.210
Just say something that's funny about mathematicians.

1770
01:51:53.210 --> 01:52:06.334
I am your host, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host, our Princeton undergraduate physics, UCLA, PhD physics, occasional mathematician, Krishna Chowdhury.

1771
01:52:06.574 --> 01:52:08.154
Thank you all for joining us again.

1772
01:52:08.554 --> 01:52:10.995
We are coming up on our one-year anniversary.

1773
01:52:11.835 --> 01:52:13.296
It's incredible that it's only been a year.

1774
01:52:13.676 --> 01:52:15.356
We have so many fun things planned for the future.

1775
01:52:15.736 --> 01:52:18.277
We will see you all next week.
