WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.171 --> 00:00:08.780
Hello internet, this is your captain speaking Lester Nare joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD Krishna Chowdhury.

2
00:00:09.181 --> 00:00:10.842
This is episode 22.

3
00:00:10.903 --> 00:00:16.088
We have a fantastic three-story episode set up plus the rundown today.

4
00:00:16.108 --> 00:00:20.072
We're going to touch on string theory, biological networks,

5
00:00:20.873 --> 00:00:45.910
three-dimensional geometry we have a neuroscience and sleep story and as always we can't forget astronomy with an interesting star formation topic my friend how's it going it's going well it's going well we're in january it's 2026 yes it's 80 degrees outside it's pretty nice pretty nice there was no snow in big bear oh yeah this weekend that was a little bit unfortunate

6
00:00:46.393 --> 00:00:51.236
Yeah, that's kind of surprising given like how much precipitation we've had in Southern California.

7
00:00:51.296 --> 00:00:52.177
So exactly.

8
00:00:52.197 --> 00:00:53.618
I was like, oh, it's going to be snow.

9
00:00:53.758 --> 00:00:55.079
It was all in the desert.

10
00:00:55.279 --> 00:00:56.000
Yeah.

11
00:00:56.020 --> 00:00:58.962
A couple of housekeeping notes for this episode.

12
00:00:58.982 --> 00:01:05.426
If you didn't catch it on social, our new website, ffppod.com is now available.

13
00:01:05.506 --> 00:01:06.006
It's great.

14
00:01:06.026 --> 00:01:07.828
You can get all of our past episodes.

15
00:01:08.268 --> 00:01:13.872
You can also see and search through all of the research papers that we cover in each episode.

16
00:01:13.892 --> 00:01:14.112
Yeah.

17
00:01:14.592 --> 00:01:18.794
We have a whole variety of details, key takeaways, links out to the original paper.

18
00:01:19.714 --> 00:01:23.696
And we also have introduced our new submissions board.

19
00:01:24.196 --> 00:01:27.517
So many of you have commented about, hey, can you cover this paper?

20
00:01:27.577 --> 00:01:28.758
Can you cover that paper?

21
00:01:29.218 --> 00:01:33.640
So you can go to ffppod.com backslash submissions.

22
00:01:34.080 --> 00:01:37.501
You'll see a ranking leaderboard of the most popular papers.

23
00:01:37.821 --> 00:01:39.822
You can upvote the papers you want us to cover.

24
00:01:40.142 --> 00:01:41.683
You can submit your own website.

25
00:01:41.783 --> 00:01:44.587
We're trying to engage the community here, so we're super excited about that.

26
00:01:44.848 --> 00:01:48.754
If you haven't taken a look, take a look, because we will have more coming to the site soon.

27
00:01:48.774 --> 00:01:50.857
I don't know, maybe a leaderboard or something?

28
00:01:50.917 --> 00:01:51.979
Yeah, something like that.

29
00:01:52.519 --> 00:01:56.165
So I think what's so fascinating...

30
00:01:56.966 --> 00:02:23.015
about the two-way street of like the social media era right it's like the response to our stuff is real time yeah right so you know immediately the day an episode comes out we're getting people like this is fantastic like the econophysics feedback from the last episode was fascinating yeah yeah yeah there were a lot of people who i think are probably in finance that had technical degrees that um are watching and hey welcome welcome

31
00:02:24.532 --> 00:02:25.893
We're going to learn something today.

32
00:02:26.113 --> 00:02:27.795
We have some fantastic stories.

33
00:02:27.995 --> 00:02:31.178
And as always, this is from First Principles.

34
00:02:46.333 --> 00:02:57.722
Okay, so for our first story, we are going to go into the world of string theory in a paper out in Nature published on January 6th.

35
00:02:58.703 --> 00:03:01.285
Paper is about nature's hidden blueprint.

36
00:03:01.945 --> 00:03:05.686
How Physical Networks Follow String Theory Mathematics.

37
00:03:06.087 --> 00:03:19.091
Scientists have discovered that biological networks from brains to blood vessels violate simple wiring rules and instead follow complex surface minimization patterns predicted by string theory.

38
00:03:19.251 --> 00:03:19.552
Yeah.

39
00:03:19.692 --> 00:03:21.172
Really good at predictions.

40
00:03:21.212 --> 00:03:27.114
This one's out of Rensselaer Polytechnic, Northwestern, the University of Chicago, and Northeastern.

41
00:03:27.154 --> 00:03:28.335
So a nice Marvel model.

42
00:03:28.855 --> 00:03:29.095
Yeah.

43
00:03:44.068 --> 00:03:45.209
and our vascular system.

44
00:03:45.349 --> 00:03:46.250
This is fascinating.

45
00:03:46.410 --> 00:03:49.132
It's really cool because it's not just the brain and vasculature.

46
00:03:49.252 --> 00:03:50.793
It's all over biology.

47
00:03:50.813 --> 00:03:56.318
If you look at mycelia and fungal networks, this has something to say about that.

48
00:03:56.498 --> 00:04:01.822
If you look at how trees branch out into patterns, this has something to say about that.

49
00:04:02.243 --> 00:04:08.247
And we've been trying to figure out the mathematics behind how these physical networks branch out

50
00:04:09.309 --> 00:04:14.415
And the unlikely savior came in the form of string theory.

51
00:04:14.736 --> 00:04:28.172
And it's really wild because it's all over the news because, you know, string theory has kind of a bad rep given that it doesn't predict anything, at least in terms of the fundamental physics that it promised to predict anything.

52
00:04:28.417 --> 00:04:34.680
But it's kind of cool that this mathematical physics approach is now being used for biological problems.

53
00:04:34.800 --> 00:04:52.909
And one of the reasons why I really loved this story is, you know, I'm a biophysicist by training, and there's so many examples of the mathematics of physics being used for something totally different being applied to biology.

54
00:04:53.049 --> 00:04:53.990
You know, if you look at

55
00:04:54.945 --> 00:05:04.531
hot field networks and associative memory in the brain, that uses the mathematics of Ising models that was being developed to describe magnetization.

56
00:05:04.951 --> 00:05:17.158
Or if you look at the renormalization group, which is being used for phase transitions or deep quantum field theory, that's being used to describe the starling flocks and how they do murmurations in the sky.

57
00:05:17.659 --> 00:05:17.859
So...

58
00:05:19.232 --> 00:05:27.236
It's one of these really cool examples of how mathematical physics research for something totally different can be applied to biology.

59
00:05:27.776 --> 00:05:32.058
And we're just discovering how life is so clever, you know?

60
00:05:32.478 --> 00:05:39.901
And this sort of translational nature of the frameworks of physics being applied in other spaces.

61
00:05:39.921 --> 00:05:40.641
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

62
00:05:40.741 --> 00:05:43.042
And I think that's just really cool.

63
00:05:43.062 --> 00:05:43.363
There's a...

64
00:05:44.692 --> 00:05:50.374
There's a neat line between the mathematics when we go really deep down.

65
00:05:50.734 --> 00:05:52.194
You know, I think that's really cool.

66
00:05:52.234 --> 00:05:55.415
So the core subject has to do with networks.

67
00:05:55.715 --> 00:05:55.975
Okay.

68
00:05:56.375 --> 00:05:58.176
Networks are basically things.

69
00:05:58.776 --> 00:06:00.917
And then those things have relationships.

70
00:06:00.997 --> 00:06:04.558
And usually when we talk about networks, what we use is graph theory.

71
00:06:04.578 --> 00:06:05.058
Okay.

72
00:06:05.078 --> 00:06:05.278
Okay.

73
00:06:06.058 --> 00:06:10.862
One of the famous networks that we all use every day is the internet, right?

74
00:06:11.102 --> 00:06:13.304
There's links from one page to another page.

75
00:06:13.364 --> 00:06:14.385
That's the relationship.

76
00:06:14.825 --> 00:06:17.908
And the things, the nodes of these networks are web pages.

77
00:06:18.448 --> 00:06:29.818
And the very famous PageRank algorithm that was developed by Larry Page out of a Stanford PhD thesis that became the bedrock of Google, a trillion-dollar company now, is

78
00:06:30.849 --> 00:06:45.362
realized that what they could do is use the mathematics of graph theory to understand relationships on the internet and then rank pages based on their connectivity rather than, you know, some naive approach that...

79
00:06:45.442 --> 00:06:49.265
If you remember Ask Jeeves, you know, we're old enough to remember Ask Jeeves.

80
00:06:49.285 --> 00:06:50.005
We are old enough.

81
00:06:50.426 --> 00:06:51.787
Or like the Yahoo search.

82
00:06:52.227 --> 00:06:56.071
They weren't as good because they weren't realizing this underlying graph structure.

83
00:06:56.451 --> 00:06:58.673
Google was good because it was ranking pages...

84
00:07:00.001 --> 00:07:03.664
With the attitude that the graph structure of the internet is what's important.

85
00:07:04.345 --> 00:07:16.114
And this ended up being confirmed to be true not only by the fact that arguably the best business model ever invented in humanity with the best margins is Google.

86
00:07:16.614 --> 00:07:19.557
And that same concept then ultimately got applied to Google.

87
00:07:20.237 --> 00:07:20.958
Social graphs.

88
00:07:21.238 --> 00:07:21.518
Yeah.

89
00:07:21.839 --> 00:07:26.383
In the rise of social media, Zuckerberg being the first to apply the same concept.

90
00:07:26.443 --> 00:07:27.144
Yeah.

91
00:07:27.204 --> 00:07:30.968
But in the context of social networking, which then became social media.

92
00:07:31.028 --> 00:07:31.768
Yes, exactly.

93
00:07:32.069 --> 00:07:34.551
And all of these things, at the end of the day, they're graphs.

94
00:07:34.591 --> 00:07:35.332
They're vertices.

95
00:07:35.492 --> 00:07:38.055
In the case of social networks, there would be individual profiles.

96
00:07:38.435 --> 00:07:40.397
And then a connection would be like a friendship.

97
00:07:40.797 --> 00:08:07.085
between the two right now when it comes to physical networks physical networks are embedded in 3d space i'm talking about the brain which has neurons connecting from one to another but this isn't isn't some abstract link there's a little physical connection of a synapse between a neuron a connecting to a neuron b right if you look at vasculature that's blood vessels that are physically connecting and all of these physical networks are

98
00:08:07.245 --> 00:08:09.687
are constrained by 3D geometry, right?

99
00:08:09.727 --> 00:08:10.887
They're constrained by thickness.

100
00:08:10.927 --> 00:08:14.209
How much room do I have to move in the brain, in the body?

101
00:08:14.549 --> 00:08:16.911
And it's not just these like 1D abstract links.

102
00:08:17.491 --> 00:08:21.434
So Ramoni Cajal in 1899, he's one of the pioneers of neuroscience.

103
00:08:21.454 --> 00:08:31.219
He's the first guy to establish the neuron doctrine, which is the idea that the nervous system is made out of tiny individual cells called neurons that connect to each other.

104
00:08:31.500 --> 00:08:33.761
And it's not just one giant network, right?

105
00:08:34.762 --> 00:08:40.284
And he proposed a neuron morphology that's driven by minimizing wire volume.

106
00:08:40.304 --> 00:08:43.705
These are some great drawings that he drew.

107
00:08:43.745 --> 00:08:53.329
He was an artist, and he could literally trace out using these incredible techniques where he would stain individual neurons, and he could trace out how these neurons connected to one another.

108
00:08:53.849 --> 00:08:58.691
And you could recreate things like the hippocampus, things like the optic nerve.

109
00:08:58.811 --> 00:08:59.311
That's incredible.

110
00:08:59.331 --> 00:08:59.531
Yeah.

111
00:09:00.191 --> 00:09:02.873
A lot of what he found even back then is true today.

112
00:09:02.954 --> 00:09:14.444
Like in the hippocampus, for example, he figured out that there's this cell layer called CA1, and it gets input from the dentate, which is another part of the hippocampus, and another part of the hippocampus called CA3, and so on and so forth.

113
00:09:15.024 --> 00:09:25.934
He was an incredible scientist, and he proposed that the way that these biological networks figure out where to go and what connections to make—

114
00:09:26.614 --> 00:09:33.217
is by minimizing wire volume, which basically turns into what's the minimum distance between two points.

115
00:09:33.337 --> 00:09:37.719
Like if I want to connect this point and this point, I just want to figure out what the minimum distance is.

116
00:09:38.159 --> 00:09:41.201
So you're saying the shortest distance between two points is a straight line?

117
00:09:41.281 --> 00:09:41.521
Yes.

118
00:09:42.041 --> 00:09:47.364
And that's exactly what he figured out that biology would at some point figure out.

119
00:09:47.424 --> 00:09:49.585
Like evolution would optimize for this, right?

120
00:09:49.605 --> 00:09:50.065
Yeah.

121
00:09:50.365 --> 00:09:51.146
He wasn't the only one.

122
00:09:51.306 --> 00:09:58.229
In 1926, there was Murray, who established Murray's Law, which governs vascular branching in the blood.

123
00:09:58.969 --> 00:10:07.913
And he figured out that, you know, you can minimize work that the body has to do by doing this minimum distance kind of thing, right?

124
00:10:08.133 --> 00:10:11.175
Where using that heuristic, what you can do is say...

125
00:10:13.075 --> 00:10:24.177
With this network architecture, the blood can maintain the blood volume, but at the same time, it does the least amount of work to get over the friction of pushing fluid through my blood vasculature.

126
00:10:24.317 --> 00:10:26.718
It's sort of like a biological optimization.

127
00:10:26.738 --> 00:10:27.458
Yes, exactly.

128
00:10:27.478 --> 00:10:34.459
And he's like, the simplest optimization of finding the shortest link between two nodes, that actually works.

129
00:10:34.939 --> 00:10:35.179
Okay?

130
00:10:35.759 --> 00:10:38.340
So it was an old paradigm, and...

131
00:10:39.660 --> 00:10:43.567
In graph theory, this is effectively what's called the Steiner tree problem.

132
00:10:43.887 --> 00:10:44.168
Okay?

133
00:10:44.749 --> 00:10:51.700
If you've got a graph of points in Euclidean space, these are the blue points in this photo, then if I want to connect them,

134
00:10:52.735 --> 00:11:13.298
with edges such that the sum of all the edges is smallest so it's the it's the most optimized graph that minimizes the distance between all these edges then what i can do is introduce little points called steiner points in between the vertices that i want to attach

135
00:11:13.918 --> 00:11:14.159
Okay.

136
00:11:14.639 --> 00:11:18.804
And there's a certain rule that all of these Steiner points follow.

137
00:11:18.964 --> 00:11:19.204
Okay.

138
00:11:19.585 --> 00:11:27.673
If I basically, if I want to have an algorithm that makes a graph such that all of the edges are least distance.

139
00:11:28.094 --> 00:11:28.334
Okay.

140
00:11:28.655 --> 00:11:30.076
Then there's two things that we notice.

141
00:11:30.136 --> 00:11:30.376
Okay.

142
00:11:30.937 --> 00:11:34.818
First is that all branching points have only three nodes.

143
00:11:34.918 --> 00:11:38.399
They're called bifurcations, meaning one path is going to lead out to two.

144
00:11:38.839 --> 00:11:40.599
There's never one path leading out to three.

145
00:11:41.099 --> 00:11:47.921
Because one path leading out to three, you could actually decompose that into one path leading out to two, and then this branch leads out to two.

146
00:11:48.141 --> 00:11:52.401
It's suboptimal to have three coming out of a single node.

147
00:11:52.421 --> 00:11:54.442
Yeah, a fork is always two.

148
00:11:55.102 --> 00:11:56.562
A fork in the road is always two.

149
00:11:56.582 --> 00:11:58.823
There's never three paths out of an input.

150
00:11:59.863 --> 00:12:00.103
Okay.

151
00:12:00.424 --> 00:12:06.168
So that's the first thing that's just a mathematical truth if you want to solve the Steiner tree problem.

152
00:12:06.388 --> 00:12:06.648
Okay.

153
00:12:06.669 --> 00:12:06.889
Okay.

154
00:12:07.169 --> 00:12:13.534
The second point is all of these intersections happen at 120 degrees.

155
00:12:14.375 --> 00:12:14.615
Okay.

156
00:12:14.815 --> 00:12:14.895
Oh.

157
00:12:14.955 --> 00:12:19.499
And that kind of makes sense because if you've got three paths coming out, a circle is 360 degrees.

158
00:12:20.079 --> 00:12:21.861
360 divided by three is 120.

159
00:12:21.901 --> 00:12:22.081
Right.

160
00:12:22.241 --> 00:12:23.062
I got you.

161
00:12:23.082 --> 00:12:25.424
So that it all like kind of makes sense.

162
00:12:25.484 --> 00:12:25.584
Okay.

163
00:12:25.604 --> 00:12:25.804
Okay.

164
00:12:26.803 --> 00:12:31.667
The problem is, if you look at empirical data from biology, this is not true.

165
00:12:32.227 --> 00:12:32.487
Okay?

166
00:12:32.547 --> 00:12:32.808
Okay.

167
00:12:32.908 --> 00:12:39.753
In recent times, we've done incredible work mapping out the 3D morphology of biological networks.

168
00:12:40.113 --> 00:12:43.636
This right here is a neuron from the Human Connectome Project.

169
00:12:43.976 --> 00:12:45.838
They've mapped out a human neuron.

170
00:12:45.918 --> 00:12:48.480
And what you can see is violations of that Steiner tree.

171
00:12:48.640 --> 00:12:48.860
Yes.

172
00:12:48.900 --> 00:12:51.322
You've got trifurcation, so a single path.

173
00:12:51.822 --> 00:12:52.683
leading out to three.

174
00:12:53.003 --> 00:12:58.487
And you've also got these orthogonal connections where the angle is not 120, but 90 degrees.

175
00:12:59.127 --> 00:13:04.571
So it is structurally, it appears to be suboptimal from an efficiency perspective.

176
00:13:04.591 --> 00:13:04.811
Yes.

177
00:13:04.991 --> 00:13:18.201
And if you were to actually calculate the minimum Steiner tree and then add up the lengths of all of these guys, the total length is about 25% more than what the minimum would be.

178
00:13:18.461 --> 00:13:20.903
So it's requiring more surface area.

179
00:13:21.822 --> 00:13:25.704
to have the output equivalent to the optimal version.

180
00:13:25.724 --> 00:13:26.184
Yeah, yeah.

181
00:13:26.305 --> 00:13:30.507
Well, you're jumping the gun here a little bit because it's requiring more length.

182
00:13:31.187 --> 00:13:31.547
Okay.

183
00:13:31.908 --> 00:13:32.188
Right?

184
00:13:32.888 --> 00:13:36.390
Like the length is what is not optimal.

185
00:13:36.570 --> 00:13:37.070
I understand.

186
00:13:37.391 --> 00:13:38.211
You see what I'm saying?

187
00:13:38.251 --> 00:13:42.514
We're separating different degrees of measurement because they have different implications.

188
00:13:42.574 --> 00:13:43.174
Exactly.

189
00:13:43.314 --> 00:13:46.536
And the older paradigm was that I want to minimize length.

190
00:13:46.916 --> 00:13:50.178
But you got there by saying, well, what if I want to minimize length?

191
00:13:51.332 --> 00:13:52.574
surface area instead.

192
00:13:52.894 --> 00:13:53.895
Now let's think about it.

193
00:13:53.956 --> 00:13:55.758
Why would I want to minimize surface area?

194
00:13:56.078 --> 00:14:00.824
If I'm a living being, why would I want to minimize surface area rather than length?

195
00:14:01.405 --> 00:14:04.849
Well, the reason is surface area is the actual thing that requires material.

196
00:14:06.420 --> 00:14:11.324
You know, I need a cell membrane and that cell membrane is the thing that I want the least of.

197
00:14:12.165 --> 00:14:14.306
Doesn't really matter what the length is.

198
00:14:14.467 --> 00:14:14.687
Right.

199
00:14:14.927 --> 00:14:15.147
Right.

200
00:14:15.567 --> 00:14:22.333
Because if I can if I can minimize surface area but have a longer length, maybe that's fine because I'm using less material.

201
00:14:23.013 --> 00:14:25.995
OK. And that is the insight of this new paper.

202
00:14:26.236 --> 00:14:26.696
Interesting.

203
00:14:26.756 --> 00:14:27.096
OK.

204
00:14:27.316 --> 00:14:31.820
The new papers introduces the fact that maybe if we minimize surface area.

205
00:14:33.268 --> 00:14:35.350
Then we can replicate biological networks.

206
00:14:35.870 --> 00:14:48.121
And what's really cool is they introduce an exact mathematical mapping between this local network design of minimizing surface area and the high dimensional Feynman diagrams that we see in string theory.

207
00:14:48.900 --> 00:14:49.160
Okay?

208
00:14:49.320 --> 00:14:49.500
Yes.

209
00:14:49.560 --> 00:14:50.521
That's the key insight.

210
00:14:50.561 --> 00:14:50.801
Okay.

211
00:14:50.821 --> 00:14:55.463
The key insight is string theorists have been worried about this problem for like 30 years.

212
00:14:56.543 --> 00:14:58.624
And if we can just borrow all their mathematics.

213
00:14:58.864 --> 00:14:59.605
And apply it.

214
00:14:59.845 --> 00:15:00.145
Here.

215
00:15:00.425 --> 00:15:04.407
Instead of in an abstract space, in a measurable space.

216
00:15:04.587 --> 00:15:11.210
Then all of a sudden we've got a heuristic, a mathematical heuristic that solves for why biology is doing this.

217
00:15:11.590 --> 00:15:20.938
It's a language to interpret the observations of biology where we don't necessarily have a coherent, cohesive language to describe it mathematically.

218
00:15:20.978 --> 00:15:21.158
Yeah.

219
00:15:21.219 --> 00:15:21.679
Currently.

220
00:15:21.779 --> 00:15:22.420
Yeah, currently.

221
00:15:22.460 --> 00:15:23.440
But now maybe we do.

222
00:15:23.541 --> 00:15:23.801
Okay.

223
00:15:23.841 --> 00:15:24.001
Right?

224
00:15:24.281 --> 00:15:24.982
That's the idea.

225
00:15:25.222 --> 00:15:25.382
Yes.

226
00:15:25.422 --> 00:15:26.763
So let's think about this.

227
00:15:27.604 --> 00:15:28.965
a little bit more in detail.

228
00:15:29.185 --> 00:15:32.266
Okay, biological networks are 3D manifolds, right?

229
00:15:32.566 --> 00:15:35.628
There are these 2D structures embedded in 3D.

230
00:15:35.668 --> 00:15:39.690
So you've got tubes bounded by membranes, bounded by endothelium, things like that.

231
00:15:40.350 --> 00:15:43.892
And what we want to do, the optimization is to find the minimal surface.

232
00:15:44.292 --> 00:15:45.973
This is what's called a plateau problem.

233
00:15:46.433 --> 00:15:48.134
And physical structures do this all the time.

234
00:15:48.194 --> 00:15:50.815
Here, you see a bubble in between two rings.

235
00:15:51.636 --> 00:15:57.722
that bubble naturally is going to minimize the surface area of the bubble because of surface tension.

236
00:15:58.283 --> 00:16:04.810
So we sort of see this concave-esque... Because a bubble, when you say bubble, it's...

237
00:16:05.550 --> 00:16:06.451
It's a spherical thing.

238
00:16:06.471 --> 00:16:10.113
But imagine now two rings, like the bubble generators, right?

239
00:16:10.173 --> 00:16:11.393
And they're right next to each other.

240
00:16:11.694 --> 00:16:13.515
You get this sort of concave surface.

241
00:16:13.635 --> 00:16:13.915
Yeah.

242
00:16:14.175 --> 00:16:14.375
Right?

243
00:16:14.395 --> 00:16:15.596
Because it's trying to minimize.

244
00:16:15.776 --> 00:16:16.016
Yeah.

245
00:16:16.256 --> 00:16:17.217
The surface area.

246
00:16:17.377 --> 00:16:19.218
This is a natural example.

247
00:16:19.278 --> 00:16:19.478
Yeah.

248
00:16:19.498 --> 00:16:19.658
Yeah.

249
00:16:19.678 --> 00:16:19.918
Yeah.

250
00:16:20.058 --> 00:16:24.060
I mean, the reason why a bubble is spherical is because a sphere minimizes surface area.

251
00:16:24.441 --> 00:16:24.661
Right?

252
00:16:24.941 --> 00:16:27.202
So the same mathematics maybe we can use for this.

253
00:16:27.362 --> 00:16:27.623
Right?

254
00:16:28.103 --> 00:16:31.625
And the other constraint is that the surface curvature has to be continuous.

255
00:16:31.865 --> 00:16:32.005
Right?

256
00:16:32.085 --> 00:16:33.166
So you can't have like kinks.

257
00:16:33.626 --> 00:16:39.711
You can't have like singularities, like little points, like, you know, you want a smooth surface everywhere.

258
00:16:39.731 --> 00:16:41.092
You want a nice, smooth, bald head.

259
00:16:41.312 --> 00:16:42.954
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

260
00:16:43.754 --> 00:16:50.580
And so with that in mind, let's now do a little bit of string theory, a deep dive into string theory.

261
00:16:50.720 --> 00:16:50.940
Okay.

262
00:16:50.980 --> 00:16:51.240
Okay.

263
00:16:51.640 --> 00:16:55.744
The infamous physics theory that is supposed to solve everything.

264
00:16:56.144 --> 00:16:56.284
Okay.

265
00:16:56.304 --> 00:16:56.404
Yes.

266
00:16:56.444 --> 00:16:56.644
Okay.

267
00:16:57.705 --> 00:17:08.754
And just briefly before we dive in, is this the idea that it's meant to be a theory of everything or unifying classical and quantum?

268
00:17:08.935 --> 00:17:10.676
Or no, that's like a different concept.

269
00:17:10.696 --> 00:17:11.237
No, no, no, no.

270
00:17:11.277 --> 00:17:12.337
This is the same theory.

271
00:17:12.357 --> 00:17:15.460
And it's unifying general relativity and quantum.

272
00:17:15.480 --> 00:17:15.800
I'm sorry.

273
00:17:15.840 --> 00:17:16.081
Okay.

274
00:17:16.101 --> 00:17:16.221
Yeah.

275
00:17:16.241 --> 00:17:16.421
Yeah.

276
00:17:16.641 --> 00:17:19.262
Yeah, but it is – that is exactly what we're talking about.

277
00:17:19.282 --> 00:17:26.643
This is the thing of Ed Witten fame and who's that guy who goes on Joe Rogan and talks trash all the time?

278
00:17:27.023 --> 00:17:27.583
I know.

279
00:17:27.643 --> 00:17:28.523
We're talking.

280
00:17:28.543 --> 00:17:29.084
Weinstein.

281
00:17:29.124 --> 00:17:29.384
Yeah.

282
00:17:29.444 --> 00:17:31.124
Eric Weinstein, I believe his name is.

283
00:17:31.164 --> 00:17:32.524
It's the geometric unity.

284
00:17:32.544 --> 00:17:33.585
Geometric unity.

285
00:17:33.685 --> 00:17:39.606
So string theory is purporting to do the following, which is unify quantum mechanics with general relativity, right?

286
00:17:39.626 --> 00:17:39.886
Copy.

287
00:17:40.106 --> 00:17:40.286
And –

288
00:17:40.846 --> 00:17:49.492
In quantum mechanics, the best picture, my favorite picture is Feynman's picture, which has to do with the particle picture, but the field picture of quantum mechanics.

289
00:17:49.952 --> 00:17:57.537
The way we understand the interaction between particles in quantum mechanics is that they exchange virtual particles.

290
00:17:57.617 --> 00:17:59.258
So here what we see is an electron.

291
00:17:59.838 --> 00:18:01.518
that's being deflected by an electron.

292
00:18:01.538 --> 00:18:03.139
You know, electrons repel each other.

293
00:18:03.459 --> 00:18:04.819
That's the classical picture, right?

294
00:18:05.239 --> 00:18:08.340
Electrons have negative charge, so they don't like to be next to each other.

295
00:18:08.720 --> 00:18:17.862
In the quantum picture, the reason why they don't want to be next to each other and the reason why they get deflected in opposite directions is because they're exchanging a virtual photon.

296
00:18:18.082 --> 00:18:20.283
Okay, and that's what you're seeing in that Feynman diagram.

297
00:18:20.583 --> 00:18:28.705
An electron is coming from the left, an electron is coming from the right, and they're exchanging a virtual photon, and that's how the momentum gets transferred from one to another.

298
00:18:29.245 --> 00:18:29.566
Copy.

299
00:18:29.746 --> 00:18:31.608
Okay, so that's the Feynman picture, right?

300
00:18:32.129 --> 00:18:35.132
In string theory, there's no longer anything called particles.

301
00:18:35.493 --> 00:18:41.520
Instead, all of our fundamental particles, all of our fundamental fields are made out of one-dimensional strings.

302
00:18:41.660 --> 00:18:43.882
So you can imagine a rubber band that's one-dimensional.

303
00:18:43.942 --> 00:18:44.523
It's a line.

304
00:18:44.884 --> 00:18:48.488
And that line oscillates in multiple dimensions.

305
00:18:49.068 --> 00:18:55.633
Just like a guitar string can oscillate this way or into the guitar and out of the guitar, so that's two dimensions that it's oscillating.

306
00:18:55.933 --> 00:19:02.558
A string can oscillate in multiple dimensions, sometimes 10, sometimes 12, depending on what theory is your favorite.

307
00:19:02.778 --> 00:19:14.147
And the idea here is that in this diagram we see starting from matter all the way at the top as you break down to smaller scales, molecule, atom, neutron, strings are smaller.

308
00:19:14.407 --> 00:19:14.787
Than that.

309
00:19:15.907 --> 00:19:22.110
are the most, in this theory, are the most fundamental atomic unit of physical reality.

310
00:19:22.130 --> 00:19:22.470
Exactly.

311
00:19:22.490 --> 00:19:23.310
And they're the same.

312
00:19:23.870 --> 00:19:33.294
The beauty of string theory is that it's all just one string, but the way that it oscillates in all these different dimensions make it an electron or a photon or a...

313
00:19:33.654 --> 00:19:59.660
up quark or a down quark things like that so it's this nice like unified principle right that actually there's no such thing as all these different fields and all these different particles there's only one fundamental thing and that is the one-dimensional string and the way that it moves around in these 10 dimensions gives it the properties of an electron or up quark or a down quark and all these things so it's it's a nice like mathematical unified picture that's interesting um it just hasn't found any like

314
00:20:00.340 --> 00:20:11.949
real-world physics use cases, because in order to prove whether these strings exist, you need to go down to the fundamental scale, like the Planck scale, of really tiny length, really tiny time.

315
00:20:12.630 --> 00:20:20.175
The energy is massive, 10 to the 19 gigaelectron volts, which, you know, the LHC only has 10 to the 4 gigaelectron volts.

316
00:20:20.196 --> 00:20:20.516
Absolutely.

317
00:20:20.976 --> 00:20:25.938
So we're trying to do 10 to the 15 on top of what the LHC at CERN is doing.

318
00:20:26.038 --> 00:20:28.359
The Large Hadron Collider, for those who might not know.

319
00:20:28.439 --> 00:20:28.819
That's right.

320
00:20:28.859 --> 00:20:30.700
Yeah, the LHC is the Large Hadron Collider.

321
00:20:30.720 --> 00:20:36.021
So we need to LHC the size of the galaxy in order to probe these limits.

322
00:20:36.522 --> 00:20:45.305
And so the point being, this is very largely theoretical, because as of yet, there's been no way to experimentally

323
00:20:46.385 --> 00:20:47.786
play with these theories.

324
00:20:48.006 --> 00:20:48.506
Exactly.

325
00:20:48.886 --> 00:20:49.687
Yeah, exactly.

326
00:20:50.027 --> 00:20:53.789
And it's been a really cool mathematics exercise on its own.

327
00:20:54.149 --> 00:20:56.250
If you were to just look at the mathematics, it's amazing.

328
00:20:56.290 --> 00:20:57.351
It's won Fields medals.

329
00:20:57.871 --> 00:21:00.773
Ed Witten won the Fields medal for his work in string theory.

330
00:21:01.433 --> 00:21:03.375
he's never going to win the physics Nobel prize.

331
00:21:03.715 --> 00:21:03.876
Right.

332
00:21:03.936 --> 00:21:04.196
Okay.

333
00:21:04.436 --> 00:21:11.844
Because to win the physics Nobel prize, there has to be some experimental grounding for whatever thing you do, but the fields metal is pretty nice.

334
00:21:12.365 --> 00:21:14.907
So I don't think he's like too worried about it.

335
00:21:14.967 --> 00:21:16.789
He didn't win the Oscar, but he got the golden globe.

336
00:21:16.869 --> 00:21:17.250
Oh no.

337
00:21:17.450 --> 00:21:17.690
Yeah.

338
00:21:17.750 --> 00:21:18.010
Yeah.

339
00:21:18.831 --> 00:21:19.612
Yeah, exactly.

340
00:21:20.253 --> 00:21:20.813
Even though, I mean,

341
00:21:21.534 --> 00:21:25.839
Well, I think you're going to piss off some mathematicians in the audience.

342
00:21:25.879 --> 00:21:27.621
Bad analogy.

343
00:21:27.681 --> 00:21:28.763
Bad analogy.

344
00:21:28.863 --> 00:21:30.344
Do not come in my comments.

345
00:21:30.405 --> 00:21:35.551
Maybe like something closer is like he won finals MVP, but not league MVP.

346
00:21:35.571 --> 00:21:36.131
Yeah, yeah.

347
00:21:36.271 --> 00:21:37.132
That's maybe a better.

348
00:21:37.212 --> 00:21:37.933
Yeah, yeah.

349
00:21:38.254 --> 00:21:38.614
No one.

350
00:21:38.914 --> 00:21:40.016
Please stay out of my comments.

351
00:21:41.268 --> 00:21:48.171
Yeah, but so in string theory, you know, we had that original Feynman diagram, which was looking at the interaction between particles.

352
00:21:48.511 --> 00:21:55.815
So in string theories, what you can do is you can turn a Feynman diagram into something called a world sheet.

353
00:21:56.155 --> 00:21:58.576
Okay, so on the left, we have that same Feynman diagram.

354
00:21:58.976 --> 00:22:01.697
And on the right, you have strings that are merging together.

355
00:22:02.098 --> 00:22:08.420
And they're interacting in this world sheet, which is like how they're going through space time and all these dimensions.

356
00:22:08.781 --> 00:22:09.541
And then they come out.

357
00:22:10.835 --> 00:22:13.799
And that is the key here.

358
00:22:14.140 --> 00:22:14.761
The world sheet.

359
00:22:14.801 --> 00:22:24.974
That world sheet is the key here because it turns out that that smooth merging of those 2D world sheets, those 2D string world sheets, because when they merge, they have to obey...

360
00:22:27.178 --> 00:22:51.335
smoothness there can't be any kinks in this world sheet because that's unphysical and they also have to minimize the surface area in this world sheet in this in this you know space whatever they're moving in and that is topologically identical to the smooth merging of biological tubes in 3d space yes that's the key insight okay yes okay yes

361
00:22:52.143 --> 00:22:52.384
Yes.

362
00:22:52.544 --> 00:22:53.808
That is the key insight.

363
00:22:54.310 --> 00:22:56.396
And the equivalence is pretty stark.

364
00:22:56.437 --> 00:22:57.620
They lay it out in their paper.

365
00:22:58.924 --> 00:23:02.267
You know, on the right-hand side, they've got that Feynman diagram and the world sheet.

366
00:23:02.347 --> 00:23:02.547
Yes.

367
00:23:03.107 --> 00:23:10.152
And on the left, what they're showing is if you've got these physical networks, they're going to start obeying the same physics of those world sheets.

368
00:23:10.172 --> 00:23:10.973
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

369
00:23:10.993 --> 00:23:11.313
Right?

370
00:23:11.413 --> 00:23:12.174
That's the key thing.

371
00:23:12.514 --> 00:23:15.957
The string cross-section is now our biological tube cross-section.

372
00:23:16.777 --> 00:23:24.263
The time evolution for strings, like how I go from past to future, for us, it's just, oh, I'm just like moving along the tube.

373
00:23:24.383 --> 00:23:24.863
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

374
00:23:24.903 --> 00:23:25.063
Okay?

375
00:23:25.084 --> 00:23:26.585
So it's another spatial dimension.

376
00:23:26.605 --> 00:23:26.805
Mm-hmm.

377
00:23:27.245 --> 00:23:29.927
My 2D world sheet is my biological membrane now.

378
00:23:30.528 --> 00:23:41.576
And the tension, the string tension, which is something that is used in string theory to figure out how tense sort of the strings are in a loose sense, that becomes the metabolic cost of surface area.

379
00:23:41.596 --> 00:23:41.696
Yeah.

380
00:23:42.457 --> 00:23:42.817
Yes.

381
00:23:43.518 --> 00:23:45.399
Oh, that's so, that's really.

382
00:23:46.420 --> 00:23:46.921
Okay.

383
00:23:47.201 --> 00:23:58.510
I'm tracking because I think what's fascinating is we've basically, there's been a mathematical structure that has been very, millions and millions of dollars has been spent on.

384
00:23:58.570 --> 00:23:58.830
Yes.

385
00:23:58.890 --> 00:24:05.256
In string theory to really hone in on this mathematical framework and language to communicate a conceptual idea.

386
00:24:05.276 --> 00:24:05.536
Yes.

387
00:24:06.096 --> 00:24:10.080
That when we look at these physical manifolds and like biology, right?

388
00:24:10.840 --> 00:24:22.026
That math that we've spent millions of dollars on almost is a perfect, as you can see from these images, almost a perfect map onto our observed biological structures that effectively take the same shape.

389
00:24:22.226 --> 00:24:22.626
Exactly.

390
00:24:22.646 --> 00:24:24.827
And potentially respond to a similar math framework.

391
00:24:24.927 --> 00:24:25.388
Exactly.

392
00:24:25.768 --> 00:24:26.208
Exactly.

393
00:24:26.248 --> 00:24:26.948
That's the idea.

394
00:24:27.329 --> 00:24:34.112
And what they're doing is they're trying to basically do the math of string theory, which is this Nambu Goto action.

395
00:24:34.572 --> 00:24:39.675
It's an action that measures the area of the world sheet, which is the total cost.

396
00:24:40.375 --> 00:24:41.796
And the equation is insane.

397
00:24:41.816 --> 00:24:43.977
I think I've got a little photo of it.

398
00:24:44.098 --> 00:24:50.521
The equation is it's minimizing this integral over all of your possibilities.

399
00:24:50.702 --> 00:24:52.783
And it's making sure...

400
00:24:53.103 --> 00:24:55.785
This mathematics is making sure that your stuff is smooth.

401
00:24:56.185 --> 00:25:03.669
And it's making sure that if you minimize this giant integral, that the surface area of this whole thing is going to be minimal.

402
00:25:03.709 --> 00:25:04.490
It's going to be minimal.

403
00:25:04.730 --> 00:25:06.791
The point is, this math looks insane.

404
00:25:07.051 --> 00:25:07.532
Looks like man-man.

405
00:25:09.118 --> 00:25:09.838
We've worked on it.

406
00:25:10.018 --> 00:25:10.459
Yeah.

407
00:25:10.539 --> 00:25:13.700
Because all of these physicists have been working on string theory.

408
00:25:13.720 --> 00:25:13.860
Yes.

409
00:25:13.960 --> 00:25:14.821
So we've worked on it.

410
00:25:15.101 --> 00:25:16.541
So we don't need to start from scratch.

411
00:25:16.561 --> 00:25:19.323
We can just take all of these results and apply it here.

412
00:25:19.463 --> 00:25:19.663
Yes.

413
00:25:19.703 --> 00:25:19.883
Right.

414
00:25:20.143 --> 00:25:21.484
And it bakes in the smoothness.

415
00:25:24.712 --> 00:25:32.296
And all of these mathematical toolkits that have been developed can now just be applied directly to the biological problem.

416
00:25:32.416 --> 00:25:43.921
So the point being the biologists don't have to spend years sort of wading through the dark of discovery around, you know, finding the four corners of the sandbox on the mathematics.

417
00:25:44.421 --> 00:25:45.982
It's a Lego block that already exists.

418
00:25:46.002 --> 00:25:47.703
They can just be like, oh, here are these glasses.

419
00:25:47.723 --> 00:25:48.643
Let's look at it over here.

420
00:25:48.823 --> 00:25:49.804
Oh my god, I can see.

421
00:25:49.824 --> 00:25:51.185
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

422
00:25:51.365 --> 00:25:51.986
It's pretty cool.

423
00:25:52.306 --> 00:25:52.886
It's pretty cool.

424
00:25:53.347 --> 00:25:56.429
So now let's see how it actually works with biology.

425
00:25:56.469 --> 00:25:56.589
Yes.

426
00:25:56.649 --> 00:25:56.909
Okay?

427
00:25:57.550 --> 00:26:07.898
So let's first tackle the bifurcation versus trifurcation, which is the idea of a single path going to two, according to the old paradigm of Steiner trees.

428
00:26:08.278 --> 00:26:10.920
But now what we see is single paths going to three.

429
00:26:11.280 --> 00:26:17.305
Why would the new paradigm, now that we've borrowed this math from string theory, allow trifurcations...

430
00:26:18.410 --> 00:26:19.691
And make that totally chill.

431
00:26:19.871 --> 00:26:20.031
Yes.

432
00:26:20.311 --> 00:26:20.531
Okay?

433
00:26:20.951 --> 00:26:25.814
The reason for that is because the surface area is what matters.

434
00:26:26.575 --> 00:26:26.775
Right.

435
00:26:26.835 --> 00:26:27.475
Not the length.

436
00:26:27.495 --> 00:26:27.996
Not the length.

437
00:26:28.036 --> 00:26:28.196
Right?

438
00:26:28.636 --> 00:26:38.322
So the wiring economy of minimum length only matters if your width of the world sheet is really small.

439
00:26:39.002 --> 00:26:46.166
And basically, if the thickness of your world sheet, the string, like the radius of your string, is really small, then it becomes a line.

440
00:26:46.386 --> 00:26:46.566
Yes.

441
00:26:46.706 --> 00:26:47.667
And then you only have...

442
00:26:48.900 --> 00:26:49.761
Bifurcations.

443
00:26:49.801 --> 00:26:52.542
There's not enough complexity to need trifurcations.

444
00:26:52.582 --> 00:26:52.923
Right.

445
00:26:53.083 --> 00:27:00.327
But the thicker we make the biological network, the more we might need trifurcations.

446
00:27:00.467 --> 00:27:02.129
And that's what you see in this paper.

447
00:27:02.149 --> 00:27:03.009
That's what they figured out.

448
00:27:03.690 --> 00:27:14.997
As we go from thinner manifolds to thicker manifolds, at some point, the two forks in the road merge to become these...

449
00:27:16.352 --> 00:27:17.773
Three forks in the road.

450
00:27:19.214 --> 00:27:25.039
Because as you get thicker, your surface area is increasing over every length of distance.

451
00:27:25.139 --> 00:27:25.360
Yeah.

452
00:27:25.780 --> 00:27:30.524
And so subsequently, it's becoming inefficient, even if you're at the same distance.

453
00:27:30.544 --> 00:27:31.144
Yes, exactly.

454
00:27:31.204 --> 00:27:32.966
And they actually introduce an order parameter.

455
00:27:33.226 --> 00:27:34.027
They call it chi.

456
00:27:34.347 --> 00:27:37.490
And that controls whether you're going to go for two or three.

457
00:27:37.730 --> 00:27:37.950
Okay.

458
00:27:37.970 --> 00:27:38.170
Okay?

459
00:27:38.651 --> 00:27:43.495
If it's really thick compared to the separation distance, that's the thing that matters.

460
00:27:43.535 --> 00:27:43.735
Yeah.

461
00:27:43.935 --> 00:27:44.235
You see?

462
00:27:44.255 --> 00:27:44.775
Yeah, that makes sense.

463
00:27:44.795 --> 00:27:49.297
If it's like, if it's really far away, then I could do these Steiner tree approximations.

464
00:27:49.597 --> 00:27:58.441
But if my branching is really close compared to my thickness, then I'm going to need to do these higher order furcations.

465
00:27:58.641 --> 00:27:59.501
But that makes sense.

466
00:27:59.521 --> 00:28:00.061
You know what I mean?

467
00:28:00.322 --> 00:28:01.342
And that's what this is showing.

468
00:28:01.622 --> 00:28:05.024
And you can actually see the prevalence in the biological data.

469
00:28:05.044 --> 00:28:07.665
So they got data from the Human Connectome Project.

470
00:28:07.705 --> 00:28:09.346
They got data from fly neurons.

471
00:28:09.606 --> 00:28:11.447
They got data from tropical trees.

472
00:28:11.727 --> 00:28:13.388
They got data from blood vessels.

473
00:28:13.468 --> 00:28:14.829
They got data from coral.

474
00:28:15.209 --> 00:28:17.130
It's just a massive amount of data.

475
00:28:17.170 --> 00:28:22.133
And what you can see is 15% of the time you do have these trifurcations.

476
00:28:22.453 --> 00:28:25.615
And it depends on that order parameter that I was telling you about.

477
00:28:25.635 --> 00:28:25.895
Yes.

478
00:28:26.015 --> 00:28:27.737
How thin is it versus how thick is it?

479
00:28:27.797 --> 00:28:28.018
Yes.

480
00:28:28.098 --> 00:28:31.482
Like how far away is the branching versus how thick it is?

481
00:28:31.622 --> 00:28:31.822
Yes.

482
00:28:31.862 --> 00:28:37.269
And they can immediately map the biological data and show that the Steiner tree algorithm is wrong.

483
00:28:37.569 --> 00:28:40.793
But this new heuristic that they have using the string tree...

484
00:28:41.995 --> 00:28:43.016
Using the string tree...

485
00:28:44.137 --> 00:28:49.200
Using the string theory mathematics, that's what's closer to the biological data.

486
00:28:50.401 --> 00:28:59.067
The idea is if you have two nodes at some distance apart, the old Steiner model worked if the distance between those two nodes where the branching was happening was less.

487
00:28:59.285 --> 00:28:59.925
Really far away.

488
00:28:59.945 --> 00:29:00.626
Really far away.

489
00:29:01.146 --> 00:29:19.714
But as those nodes close in distance, the thickness of the line between those two nodes or the path and branch between those two nodes, as it gets thicker and as it gets closer, again, the optimization algorithm flips from...

490
00:29:21.810 --> 00:29:23.731
Optimizing for two bifurcations.

491
00:29:24.111 --> 00:29:26.372
So now we need to start introducing three.

492
00:29:26.432 --> 00:29:37.898
We need to offload more and keep – it's almost like the thicker you are, the shorter you need the distances, the more outlets you need for optimizing for efficiency.

493
00:29:38.018 --> 00:29:38.419
Exactly.

494
00:29:38.499 --> 00:29:45.382
And what's really cool to me is that across all of these different biological networks, right, we've got neurons.

495
00:29:45.522 --> 00:29:46.443
We've got trees.

496
00:29:46.563 --> 00:29:47.563
We've got fungi.

497
00:29:47.603 --> 00:29:48.304
We've got corals.

498
00:29:48.324 --> 00:29:48.504
Yes.

499
00:29:48.804 --> 00:29:52.186
It's all showing the same strategy.

500
00:29:52.286 --> 00:30:06.613
There is an under... Again, going back to what we always talk about, there is something that is true across all these different types that they all are speaking the same mathematical language that the string theorists have been trying to get everyone else to think about for so long.

501
00:30:06.773 --> 00:30:11.855
And it kind of makes sense because even though these guys are so evolutionarily distinct, right?

502
00:30:11.875 --> 00:30:15.937
You've got plants, fungi, coral, and the human brain.

503
00:30:16.978 --> 00:30:17.418
Even though...

504
00:30:18.227 --> 00:30:21.757
evolutionarily were divided by millions, hundreds of millions of years.

505
00:30:23.168 --> 00:30:26.991
The fundamental resource is surface area, right?

506
00:30:27.071 --> 00:30:29.792
The fundamental resource is how can I build this?

507
00:30:30.433 --> 00:30:35.156
And so I still want to optimize minimum surface area because I don't want the building cost to go up.

508
00:30:35.196 --> 00:30:35.376
Yes.

509
00:30:35.716 --> 00:30:35.896
Right?

510
00:30:36.497 --> 00:30:48.024
The second thing that I was telling you about the Steiner tree is all of the nodes happen at 120 degrees, but in normal biological networks, sometimes it happens at 90 degrees.

511
00:30:48.385 --> 00:30:49.285
Why is that happening?

512
00:30:49.325 --> 00:30:51.587
Well, if the thing that's coming out of my tube...

513
00:30:52.415 --> 00:30:55.836
is really thin, again, it's that same order parameter.

514
00:30:56.276 --> 00:31:03.258
If the thing that's coming out of my tube is really thin, then it's actually preferable for me to be 90 degrees away from the tube.

515
00:31:03.699 --> 00:31:09.860
On the other hand, if the branching is like thick, thick, thick, then I get to the 120 degrees.

516
00:31:10.201 --> 00:31:11.141
And that's what they're showing.

517
00:31:11.401 --> 00:31:14.442
They're showing that with these neurons, what you can see is...

518
00:31:15.463 --> 00:31:23.545
If you've got these tiny little synapses that come out of, let's say, an axon or a dendrite spine, right?

519
00:31:24.025 --> 00:31:29.607
Those tiny little synapses are really thin compared to the thickness of the dendrite.

520
00:31:30.147 --> 00:31:33.928
And so what I really want to do in that situation is come out at 90 degrees.

521
00:31:34.048 --> 00:31:38.929
I don't want to go at 120 because that's the thing that minimizes surface area.

522
00:31:39.109 --> 00:31:41.270
It's funny if you think about suburban neighborhoods—

523
00:31:42.310 --> 00:31:47.252
And or the design like the the design of the road networks.

524
00:31:47.292 --> 00:31:47.552
Yeah.

525
00:31:48.273 --> 00:31:50.754
You know, this looks like a cul-de-sac in a subdivision.

526
00:31:50.894 --> 00:31:51.514
It kind of does.

527
00:31:51.554 --> 00:31:54.335
You know, because you have your main two lane road.

528
00:31:54.816 --> 00:32:00.778
Then you have these offshoots that are narrower right off the main road at 90 degree angles.

529
00:32:00.818 --> 00:32:01.999
Yeah.

530
00:32:02.359 --> 00:32:03.960
So we've also mimicked that obviously.

531
00:32:04.000 --> 00:32:04.720
And for, you know.

532
00:32:04.800 --> 00:32:05.280
Yeah.

533
00:32:05.360 --> 00:32:08.922
It's the whole image of you see people with traffic going really fast in cities.

534
00:32:08.942 --> 00:32:11.003
And then people like map the blood vessels.

535
00:32:11.023 --> 00:32:11.223
Yeah.

536
00:32:11.403 --> 00:32:13.144
And there's the similarities in these structures.

537
00:32:13.164 --> 00:32:16.866
Yeah, I mean, there's structure all the way down.

538
00:32:16.906 --> 00:32:17.506
All the way down.

539
00:32:17.946 --> 00:32:20.888
And so I just thought this was really cool.

540
00:32:20.928 --> 00:32:25.090
In terms of the computational methodology, I thought the way that they did it was very cool.

541
00:32:25.110 --> 00:32:27.351
This is the Minsurf NetWa.

542
00:32:27.871 --> 00:32:29.452
It was implemented in Mathematica.

543
00:32:29.592 --> 00:32:35.757
This is the new code that they use with finite element methods to solve for surface variation problems.

544
00:32:36.197 --> 00:32:39.279
They actually have it available on GitHub, so you can use it.

545
00:32:39.419 --> 00:32:40.000
Yes.

546
00:32:40.020 --> 00:32:41.741
And what they really did was...

547
00:32:42.670 --> 00:32:46.893
They inputted the connectivity of real maps, and then they said, okay, what is...

548
00:32:47.694 --> 00:32:51.336
They asked the algorithm to generate the optimal surface geometry.

549
00:32:51.576 --> 00:32:59.542
So it makes up a bunch of meshes, of polygonal meshes, and then tries to figure out what the optimal surface geometry is, such that it minimizes surface area.

550
00:32:59.762 --> 00:33:03.204
And they could reproduce what the biological networks were doing.

551
00:33:03.564 --> 00:33:05.186
So there's sort of this generative...

552
00:33:05.866 --> 00:33:27.750
model that's based on mathematics yeah but it is it is not it is generating net new yeah structures and those net new structures that were generated based on this underlying mathematical framework when then held up next to our observed biological uh comparison yeah the statistics match it's just it's it's like and it's very nice it's very nice

553
00:33:28.070 --> 00:33:30.551
So I just thought this was a very cool paper, right?

554
00:33:30.611 --> 00:33:36.452
And it's kind of a unification of biological physics across so many different types of organisms.

555
00:33:36.532 --> 00:33:42.173
Fungi, plants, vessels, brains, coral, all of them have the same principle, right?

556
00:33:42.534 --> 00:33:52.096
The structure is shaped by a universal physical constraint of minimizing the amount of membrane that I need to use to create a network.

557
00:33:52.116 --> 00:33:52.456
Okay.

558
00:33:52.496 --> 00:34:00.443
Because it kind of makes sense, too, because we think, you know, the larger your surface area, the more energy you need to make it to make the things and sustain the thing.

559
00:34:00.483 --> 00:34:02.524
So it's like, again, if you're trying to minimize that.

560
00:34:02.585 --> 00:34:02.825
Yeah.

561
00:34:03.105 --> 00:34:03.285
Yeah.

562
00:34:03.445 --> 00:34:06.828
And it's not not just the energy and making the thing is the material cost.

563
00:34:07.148 --> 00:34:08.590
You're using more carbon atoms.

564
00:34:08.710 --> 00:34:08.930
Right.

565
00:34:08.970 --> 00:34:12.213
You're using more hydrogen atoms, which you could use for something else.

566
00:34:12.293 --> 00:34:12.473
Right.

567
00:34:12.573 --> 00:34:12.733
Right.

568
00:34:12.753 --> 00:34:14.655
So you want to optimize at all times.

569
00:34:14.675 --> 00:34:15.035
Right.

570
00:34:15.435 --> 00:34:18.297
There are a bunch of really cool applications that I just want to go over.

571
00:34:18.377 --> 00:34:20.639
One of them is 3D bioprinting.

572
00:34:21.099 --> 00:34:33.547
So what you can do is design scaffolds using this algorithm to create physically correct microvasculature if you want to create an artificial tissue and you want to improve blood flow in medicine.

573
00:34:33.847 --> 00:34:33.947
Yes.

574
00:34:33.987 --> 00:34:34.167
Right?

575
00:34:35.028 --> 00:34:40.611
So now we now basically have a pathway to 3D print things that can be integrated into our system.

576
00:34:40.671 --> 00:34:41.171
Exactly.

577
00:34:41.231 --> 00:34:43.113
That would map structurally.

578
00:34:43.133 --> 00:34:43.253
Yeah.

579
00:34:44.281 --> 00:34:51.669
more onto the way our biological system is exactly is exists to, to optimize for the potential of the body rejecting it and all these.

580
00:34:51.749 --> 00:34:52.170
Exactly.

581
00:34:52.230 --> 00:34:59.037
And, and the body not having to work harder than it should to push blood through this artificial system.

582
00:34:59.077 --> 00:34:59.257
Yes.

583
00:34:59.457 --> 00:34:59.678
Right.

584
00:34:59.898 --> 00:35:00.318
Yes.

585
00:35:00.438 --> 00:35:01.900
Another one could be hardware design.

586
00:35:01.920 --> 00:35:06.104
Like if you want to use the surface optimization principles to make the

587
00:35:06.665 --> 00:35:08.806
3D chip architectures, right?

588
00:35:09.166 --> 00:35:11.326
Like neuromorphic chips.

589
00:35:11.426 --> 00:35:13.667
You can now use these principles to do that.

590
00:35:13.867 --> 00:35:14.067
Yes.

591
00:35:14.107 --> 00:35:14.787
Right?

592
00:35:14.807 --> 00:35:19.709
And finally, what I want to touch on is like kind of the philosophy of science, right?

593
00:35:20.009 --> 00:35:22.650
There's string theory has gotten a lot of heat.

594
00:35:22.670 --> 00:35:23.110
Right?

595
00:35:23.410 --> 00:35:30.715
And it shows in this XKCD comic, String Theory Summarized, the string theorist said, I just had an awesome idea.

596
00:35:30.775 --> 00:35:34.077
Suppose all matter and energy is made of tiny vibrating strings.

597
00:35:34.437 --> 00:35:36.938
And his friend says, okay, what would that imply?

598
00:35:36.958 --> 00:35:39.180
And the string theorist says, I don't know.

599
00:35:40.640 --> 00:35:48.383
String theory has been the butt of so many jokes in physics and mathematics in the idea of funding fundamental science.

600
00:35:48.663 --> 00:35:50.384
And I think that's like quite dangerous.

601
00:35:50.444 --> 00:35:56.506
Now, there's stuff to be said about perhaps the scale at which we funded string theory versus something else.

602
00:35:56.846 --> 00:36:00.828
But the idea of funding something like string theory should not be...

603
00:36:01.548 --> 00:36:10.362
totally looked down upon just because, oh, it doesn't have any real world applications because at the end of the day, if we go into fundamental research, yes,

604
00:36:11.212 --> 00:36:14.535
Just being curious about how stuff works.

605
00:36:14.955 --> 00:36:15.996
Maybe it works this way.

606
00:36:16.076 --> 00:36:17.577
What would the mathematics look like?

607
00:36:17.917 --> 00:36:19.639
You don't know where it's going to end up.

608
00:36:20.079 --> 00:36:20.639
100%.

609
00:36:20.779 --> 00:36:23.802
And this is a perfect example of the importance of curiosity.

610
00:36:23.922 --> 00:36:25.803
Just curiosity-driven research.

611
00:36:25.823 --> 00:36:26.824
In frontier research.

612
00:36:26.884 --> 00:36:36.472
Again, this is the difference between research that's being done in the corporate environment and in business architectures, which are well-funded.

613
00:36:36.492 --> 00:36:36.892
Mm-hmm.

614
00:36:37.092 --> 00:36:44.495
but do not have the incentive to explore areas of research that don't immediately have a profit motive.

615
00:36:44.675 --> 00:36:45.155
Exactly.

616
00:36:45.215 --> 00:36:57.881
And there are so many things that are beneficial to mankind and all of us in our health, in our socialization, all these things that don't inherently have the profit motive, but are still valuable.

617
00:36:58.221 --> 00:37:04.904
Again, if you're starting to create artificial hearts and heart transplant stuff or our skin grafting and replacement therapies, yeah,

618
00:37:05.424 --> 00:37:09.866
based on the fact that strength there is spent all this time and money figuring out the structure.

619
00:37:10.266 --> 00:37:12.307
And now it's going to save people and extend your life.

620
00:37:13.368 --> 00:37:13.948
That's pretty cool.

621
00:37:13.968 --> 00:37:14.608
That's pretty good.

622
00:37:15.769 --> 00:37:16.969
That's pretty good.

623
00:37:17.509 --> 00:37:25.813
And this is, again, why we always like to talk about the methods and the concepts behind things, even if it's not an immediately applicable, like...

624
00:37:26.454 --> 00:37:34.057
Finding because this is what we're going to end up utilizing as we get older, as our children get older in the world around us.

625
00:37:34.137 --> 00:37:34.837
It's not going away.

626
00:37:34.877 --> 00:37:35.817
It's only accelerating.

627
00:37:36.177 --> 00:37:41.399
And it's a great way to start episode 22 with a little bit of balanced balance.

628
00:37:43.639 --> 00:38:05.404
views on string theory yeah you know we have ours not we it's still funny it's the the comic is still funny i'm gonna laugh you know uh this is this is so good and i could there's so many things about that i could dive into but we are moving on to the rundown for the week after our first deep

629
00:38:14.928 --> 00:38:16.811
see what else will come from that.

630
00:38:16.851 --> 00:38:19.014
But here's the thing.

631
00:38:19.034 --> 00:38:19.555
That's interesting.

632
00:38:20.477 --> 00:38:23.582
You have four universities involved in this story.

633
00:38:25.565 --> 00:38:26.746
It takes a village.

634
00:38:27.147 --> 00:38:27.267
Yeah.

635
00:38:27.287 --> 00:38:27.387
Yeah.

636
00:38:28.118 --> 00:38:28.858
To do these things.

637
00:38:28.878 --> 00:38:31.619
This is not some one person in a lab by themselves.

638
00:38:32.059 --> 00:38:37.741
It really requires cross-institutional and cross-functional work to do so.

639
00:38:38.801 --> 00:38:41.362
But that being said, we will move into the rundown.

640
00:38:42.142 --> 00:38:44.623
It seems like the audience likes a little quick rapid fire.

641
00:38:44.643 --> 00:38:47.104
So again, the concept of the rundown, we can't cover everything.

642
00:38:47.364 --> 00:38:52.610
All frontier science research in the level of detail we do, we would be here until the end of time.

643
00:38:52.951 --> 00:38:57.075
But it is still important to know briefly what's going on in the world around us.

644
00:38:57.456 --> 00:39:04.604
And we're going to start with our first rundown story from January 8th, The Hidden Strength of Iron Asteroids.

645
00:39:04.924 --> 00:39:06.827
This is a planetary defense story.

646
00:39:07.207 --> 00:39:11.889
The obleque of space, why iron asteroids are harder to deflect.

647
00:39:11.949 --> 00:39:22.733
The byline on the story is a groundbreaking simulation reveals that iron-rich asteroids possess a hidden strength that makes them more resilient to impact space.

648
00:39:22.833 --> 00:39:24.594
than previously theorized.

649
00:39:24.634 --> 00:39:28.835
This is out of the University of Oxford and CERN.

650
00:39:28.855 --> 00:39:39.519
And the implications here are using CERN's high-rad map facility, physicists irradiated meteorite samples with high-energy proton beams to see how they would deform under stress.

651
00:39:40.140 --> 00:39:49.143
They discovered that there was this dampening, meaning that the faster the asteroid is hit, the better its internal structure dissipates energy, which is a little counterproductive.

652
00:39:49.163 --> 00:39:49.403
Yeah.

653
00:39:49.463 --> 00:39:50.043
Intuitive.

654
00:39:50.063 --> 00:40:00.027
So this just suggests that kinetic impactors, like the idea of NASA's DART mission, which I believe was to like intercept, shoot something, intercept an asteroid on, on, on its way in.

655
00:40:00.227 --> 00:40:00.487
Yeah.

656
00:40:00.607 --> 00:40:03.548
So intercept an asteroid and change its trajectory.

657
00:40:03.628 --> 00:40:03.708
Yes.

658
00:40:03.828 --> 00:40:04.008
Yes.

659
00:40:04.548 --> 00:40:11.832
Yes, the idea is that it would remain intact because it would be able to dissipate the energy.

660
00:40:11.872 --> 00:40:14.214
The asteroid would be able to dissipate the energy on impact.

661
00:40:14.314 --> 00:40:14.714
Exactly.

662
00:40:14.834 --> 00:40:21.538
We wouldn't have like an Armageddon situation where the asteroid would break up into a bunch of chunks.

663
00:40:21.958 --> 00:40:26.781
And then now instead of worrying about one thing, we're worrying about nine things that are coming in.

664
00:40:27.962 --> 00:40:32.465
Basically, the idea is like as you hit the asteroid, if it's full of iron, it's going to like ring.

665
00:40:32.485 --> 00:40:32.585
Yeah.

666
00:40:33.406 --> 00:40:36.475
You know, and sort of dissipate its energy internally.

667
00:40:36.556 --> 00:40:36.776
Yes.

668
00:40:36.857 --> 00:40:39.284
Maybe heat up a little bit, but it's not going to totally...

669
00:40:40.213 --> 00:40:40.773
Break apart.

670
00:40:40.853 --> 00:40:41.073
Yes.

671
00:40:41.733 --> 00:40:42.254
Very cool.

672
00:40:42.554 --> 00:40:48.716
The context analogy for this one is it's similar to hitting a pool of oblec, which is cornstarch and water.

673
00:40:48.996 --> 00:40:51.517
If you poke it slowly, it's soft.

674
00:40:51.997 --> 00:40:54.798
But if you punch it hard, it turns into a solid wall.

675
00:40:55.178 --> 00:41:00.759
And these asteroids essentially have this hardening response to an impact, making them tougher to move.

676
00:41:00.839 --> 00:41:05.841
So if you're in planetary defense, we can't just bomb and shoot our problems away.

677
00:41:05.921 --> 00:41:06.701
Yeah.

678
00:41:06.721 --> 00:41:08.362
You got to get a little bit clever, but...

679
00:41:09.082 --> 00:41:11.282
The asteroid could do some of the work for you.

680
00:41:12.243 --> 00:41:13.243
Armageddon was a great movie.

681
00:41:13.343 --> 00:41:14.143
It was a good movie.

682
00:41:14.223 --> 00:41:15.043
I liked that movie.

683
00:41:15.123 --> 00:41:21.945
There was one of Ben Affleck's greatest works was the DVD commentary on Armageddon.

684
00:41:22.285 --> 00:41:23.805
I have not watched this really.

685
00:41:24.045 --> 00:41:36.447
Because if you remember, it was like a bunch of guys who work on an oil rig came into NASA, and they were like, we have no one else on the planet who can do this job other than a bunch of guys from the oil rig, which Ben Affleck was making fun of in his DVD commentary.

686
00:41:36.468 --> 00:41:38.528
He's like, why would NASA not know how to drill?

687
00:41:39.328 --> 00:41:39.549
Right.

688
00:41:39.869 --> 00:41:40.249
Oh, yeah.

689
00:41:40.289 --> 00:41:45.153
It's like, why couldn't we just train astronauts to do oil rigs?

690
00:41:45.254 --> 00:41:48.937
Maybe that's easier than training oil riggers to be astronauts.

691
00:41:49.657 --> 00:41:49.838
Yeah.

692
00:41:49.918 --> 00:41:52.960
And it was having having having a fun time taking the piss.

693
00:41:53.161 --> 00:41:54.241
Our story number two.

694
00:41:55.022 --> 00:41:59.227
Reform, an artificial metabolism for carbon.

695
00:41:59.567 --> 00:42:02.250
This is a synthetic biology story.

696
00:42:02.871 --> 00:42:04.653
January 5th, 2026.

697
00:42:04.713 --> 00:42:10.960
Headline, synthetic biologists transform waste CO2 into the building blocks of carbon.

698
00:42:11.220 --> 00:42:11.720
of life.

699
00:42:11.800 --> 00:42:22.286
Scientists have created an entirely new artificial metabolism that bypasses natural evolution to turn waste carbon dioxide into valuable chemicals.

700
00:42:22.426 --> 00:42:29.891
And this is out of Stanford University and Northwestern University led by Michael Jewett.

701
00:42:30.571 --> 00:42:32.552
Yeah, this one's a pretty interesting one.

702
00:42:32.572 --> 00:42:34.433
It's using like this cell-free system.

703
00:42:34.853 --> 00:42:37.134
So they remove all of the enzymes from a cell.

704
00:42:37.154 --> 00:42:38.454
They put it inside a test tube.

705
00:42:38.774 --> 00:42:46.057
And then what you can do is screen thousands, I think 3,000 enzyme variants to create what they call the reform pathway.

706
00:42:46.077 --> 00:42:48.218
And what it's doing is it's a synthetic system.

707
00:42:48.258 --> 00:42:57.662
So it's outside of a living cell and it's taking formate, which is a chemical compound that's derived from CO2 and converting that into acetyl coenzyme A.

708
00:42:58.062 --> 00:43:00.744
which is a universal molecule found in all living cells.

709
00:43:01.264 --> 00:43:03.085
It's part of our metabolism.

710
00:43:03.325 --> 00:43:05.447
Mitochondria, love it, so on and so forth.

711
00:43:05.907 --> 00:43:13.252
And it provides a path for sustainable carbon neutral manufacturing because if we want to take CO2 out of the atmosphere, we got to get clever.

712
00:43:13.412 --> 00:43:14.873
Maybe this is one of the ways that we do it.

713
00:43:15.153 --> 00:43:15.293
Mm-hmm.

714
00:43:15.833 --> 00:43:16.774
Mm-hmm.

715
00:43:16.914 --> 00:43:26.102
For those who are lost in the explanation, the analogy is imagine opening the hood of a car and using the engine to power a factory instead of just driving the car.

716
00:43:26.482 --> 00:43:33.368
Researchers are using the machinery of life in a test tube to build sustainable products out of thin air.

717
00:43:33.448 --> 00:43:38.592
Again, that's out of Stanford University and Northwestern University, Stanford.

718
00:43:38.992 --> 00:43:47.053
Story number three is a stem cell research story culturing the immune system's conductors.

719
00:43:47.133 --> 00:43:49.334
This is January 8th, 2026.

720
00:43:49.934 --> 00:43:55.315
Headline, UBC scientists solve the mystery of growing helper T cells.

721
00:43:55.395 --> 00:44:01.016
Now, if you've watched this show in the past, you know we've talked about the immune system a lot.

722
00:44:01.216 --> 00:44:03.456
So in our past episodes, we do cover this.

723
00:44:03.836 --> 00:44:07.817
But the logline is, for the first time, researchers have reliably produced T cells.

724
00:44:07.897 --> 00:44:14.848
helper T cells from stem cells, a major hurdle in creating off-the-shelf living drugs.

725
00:44:14.988 --> 00:44:22.179
And this is out of the University of British Columbia, led by Peter Zanstra and Megan Levings.

726
00:44:23.013 --> 00:44:31.135
Yeah, this one's interesting because, you know, we've been able to grow killer T cells, which are, you know, the soldiers of our immune system.

727
00:44:31.575 --> 00:44:39.696
But the helper T cells, which are kind of like the generals or like the kernels of the immune system, they're the ones that conduct all of the responses.

728
00:44:39.736 --> 00:44:42.077
They activate B cells to make antibodies.

729
00:44:42.477 --> 00:44:47.518
They trigger the macrophages, which are the eating immune cells that like eat up

730
00:44:48.886 --> 00:44:50.347
Bacteria and bad things.

731
00:44:50.787 --> 00:44:59.930
They conduct all of this stuff by releasing cytokines and all of these other important factors, but they're really hard to grow in a lab.

732
00:45:00.650 --> 00:45:09.674
And these guys precisely tuned a development signal called notch, and they were able to direct stem cells to become either type.

733
00:45:10.414 --> 00:45:10.594
Right.

734
00:45:10.634 --> 00:45:10.994
Killer or helper.

735
00:45:11.014 --> 00:45:12.315
Either killer or helper.

736
00:45:12.635 --> 00:45:12.815
Right.

737
00:45:12.875 --> 00:45:15.377
And now this allows for large scale manufacturing.

738
00:45:15.857 --> 00:45:17.118
Again, personalized drugs.

739
00:45:17.138 --> 00:45:26.183
You could take the stem cells from a patient and then make designed helper T cells that are specific to that specific patient.

740
00:45:26.403 --> 00:45:27.244
Yeah.

741
00:45:27.404 --> 00:45:28.865
It could be much more affordable.

742
00:45:29.305 --> 00:45:32.086
You know, you can customize patient specific therapies.

743
00:45:32.146 --> 00:45:32.667
It's very cool.

744
00:45:33.493 --> 00:45:44.861
So to the analogy that you brought up, we've already learned how to train soldiers to fight cancer, but we didn't know how to recruit the conductors who lead the orchestra on the battlefield.

745
00:45:44.881 --> 00:45:52.746
So this discovery finally gives us the full leadership team needed for a strong, lasting immune response.

746
00:45:53.427 --> 00:46:00.792
Our last rundown story of the day, as the UFO guy, you know we always have to...

747
00:46:01.152 --> 00:46:07.493
At some point, talk about exoplanet exploration, unmasking alien atmospheres.

748
00:46:07.533 --> 00:46:11.954
This is on January 12th, a conversation.

749
00:46:12.034 --> 00:46:19.136
NASA's Pandora Telescope will study stars in detail to learn about exoplanets orbiting them.

750
00:46:19.456 --> 00:46:24.757
Now, I'll just briefly note, this is not the last time we're going to be talking about planets.

751
00:46:25.437 --> 00:46:50.674
exoplanet exploration that's right we're not going to leak any classified information at this moment in time but for this story log line as the first mission of nasa's astrophysics pioneers program the pandora small sat will provide the first ever high precision tool for disentangling stellar noise from the actual atmospheric signal of distant worlds and we did talk about this in the episode where we covered the greatest evidence yet

752
00:46:50.774 --> 00:46:51.995
Yeah, K-218b.

753
00:46:52.195 --> 00:46:53.795
Of life on an exoplanet.

754
00:46:54.316 --> 00:47:06.681
But this story is out of the University of Arizona, led by Daniel Apai, NASA Goddard Space Flight Center and Ames Research Center, and the Lawrence Livermore National Lab and Cornell University.

755
00:47:07.041 --> 00:47:11.944
Yeah, this one's a cool one because it's quite a small satellite.

756
00:47:12.464 --> 00:47:18.667
The lens is only like 17 inches, which is pretty small compared to like Hubble or James Webb.

757
00:47:19.732 --> 00:47:21.013
But it's very specific.

758
00:47:21.193 --> 00:47:26.135
What it's trying to do is basically stare at the stars that have transiting planets.

759
00:47:26.716 --> 00:47:39.982
And what they want to do is disentangle when we see a planet going in front of the star and the sort of light coming from the star going down versus if the star has a sunspot and the sunspot has come this way.

760
00:47:40.122 --> 00:47:43.684
And now all of a sudden I'm just seeing less light because part of the star is dark.

761
00:47:43.744 --> 00:47:43.864
Right.

762
00:47:43.884 --> 00:47:44.024
Right.

763
00:47:44.305 --> 00:47:44.485
Right.

764
00:47:45.225 --> 00:47:55.455
It's very hard to disentangle the two, but if you just stare at something for a long enough time, you'll have an averaged out version of what that star should look like.

765
00:47:55.755 --> 00:48:01.601
And then you'll have a much better idea of what the planet looks like when it goes in front of the star.

766
00:48:01.741 --> 00:48:01.942
Yes.

767
00:48:02.102 --> 00:48:03.984
You can disentangle those two aspects.

768
00:48:04.064 --> 00:48:04.264
Yes.

769
00:48:04.764 --> 00:48:07.387
It's only in charge of 20 planetary systems.

770
00:48:07.767 --> 00:48:08.168
It's got...

771
00:48:08.688 --> 00:48:31.815
a year's worth of really yeah it's it's it's kind of like a pilot project in some sense but not really because you know even 20 getting that understanding for just 20 at that precision is going to be vital for interpreting data from larger missions like the james webb space telescope you can use that understanding for how stars work and then now start applying it to when the james webb looks at some something right mm-hmm mm-hmm

772
00:48:32.415 --> 00:48:40.117
This goes back to our point we always talk about, which is all of these discoveries and these movements are cumulative.

773
00:48:40.177 --> 00:48:41.677
They're not happening in a vacuum.

774
00:48:42.057 --> 00:48:53.680
So the immediate thing I just thought of was Vera Rubin and the massive amount of data that's going to be there in combination with JWST and some of the instruments that are looking at exoplanet atmospheres.

775
00:48:53.700 --> 00:48:58.301
There are data sets that have answers that we already have in our possession.

776
00:48:58.841 --> 00:49:01.002
Some are proprietary, some are open source, whatever.

777
00:49:03.062 --> 00:49:08.103
Once we find an unlock, all of a sudden makes these data sets incredibly valuable.

778
00:49:08.664 --> 00:49:10.704
And this is sort of maybe a scout type of mission.

779
00:49:10.784 --> 00:49:11.004
Yeah.

780
00:49:11.244 --> 00:49:15.725
To be able to create some of that better understanding, to get rid of the baseline of the planet.

781
00:49:15.865 --> 00:49:16.745
Exactly.

782
00:49:17.206 --> 00:49:22.987
And so that's, again, the exoplanet stuff I'm always such a huge fan of.

783
00:49:23.571 --> 00:49:30.074
We are going to come back into our main story number two of three.

784
00:49:30.814 --> 00:49:34.515
And this one is going to be an interesting combination.

785
00:49:34.756 --> 00:49:38.777
It's neuroscience, sleep, and marine biology.

786
00:49:38.837 --> 00:49:39.858
Yes.

787
00:49:39.898 --> 00:49:42.939
This is in Nature Communications, published on January 7th.

788
00:49:43.359 --> 00:49:46.580
Why do jellyfish need sleep?

789
00:49:47.441 --> 00:49:49.722
The ancient origins of our nightly rest.

790
00:49:49.762 --> 00:49:51.622
This is from Bar Ilhan University.

791
00:49:53.303 --> 00:49:55.465
The hook here is imagine a creature without a brain.

792
00:49:55.765 --> 00:49:56.006
Yep.

793
00:49:56.446 --> 00:49:57.687
That sleeps just like you.

794
00:49:58.928 --> 00:50:02.532
And scientists have discovered that jellyfish do exactly that.

795
00:50:02.552 --> 00:50:03.292
Do exactly that.

796
00:50:03.312 --> 00:50:05.394
They have no brain, but they sleep like us.

797
00:50:05.574 --> 00:50:05.835
Yes.

798
00:50:07.256 --> 00:50:09.999
It's a core paradox in biology, to be honest.

799
00:50:10.059 --> 00:50:11.140
It's like, why do we sleep?

800
00:50:12.079 --> 00:50:20.026
It's a very simple question, but if you think about it from an evolutionary point of view, it seems naively really dumb to do.

801
00:50:20.046 --> 00:50:21.588
Okay?

802
00:50:21.928 --> 00:50:28.874
Because sleep is a state, there's behavioral vulnerability, you're not aware of stuff, something could come and kill you.

803
00:50:30.010 --> 00:50:31.391
You're vulnerable to predation.

804
00:50:32.111 --> 00:50:33.112
It ceases foraging.

805
00:50:33.132 --> 00:50:34.092
You're not getting food.

806
00:50:34.572 --> 00:50:36.313
And also you're not having sex.

807
00:50:36.733 --> 00:50:37.994
So you're not really procreating.

808
00:50:38.074 --> 00:50:38.334
Yes.

809
00:50:38.434 --> 00:50:38.654
Right?

810
00:50:38.934 --> 00:50:39.915
So what's the point?

811
00:50:40.215 --> 00:50:43.636
And yet it's conserved across 600 million years of evolution.

812
00:50:44.357 --> 00:50:45.837
We have whales doing it.

813
00:50:45.997 --> 00:50:46.798
Humans do it.

814
00:50:47.078 --> 00:50:48.659
And now we've got jellyfish do it.

815
00:50:48.899 --> 00:50:49.099
Right?

816
00:50:49.419 --> 00:50:55.602
And the traditional view was it's a neurocentric view, meaning it has to do with complicated neuro...

817
00:50:56.402 --> 00:50:57.462
mechanisms, right?

818
00:50:57.602 --> 00:51:07.266
This idea of the synaptic homeostasis hypothesis, which is the idea that over the day, your neurons are constantly learning, and your synapses are growing.

819
00:51:07.686 --> 00:51:16.289
And if you just let it just keep growing and growing and growing, then you're going to get this runaway interaction, kind of like last episode we were talking about in DeepSeek, right?

820
00:51:16.369 --> 00:51:18.110
If you have these matrices that just

821
00:51:18.950 --> 00:51:22.995
start blowing up, then you're going to get a very chaotic system.

822
00:51:23.015 --> 00:51:24.677
So you need some way to constrain them.

823
00:51:24.957 --> 00:51:31.565
And maybe sleep was one way to constrain our synapses such that the signals don't propagate in a chaotic way.

824
00:51:32.306 --> 00:51:38.213
But now we've got this new finding, which shows that sleep is actually a fundamental cellular requirement for...

825
00:51:38.313 --> 00:51:39.794
because of DNA repair.

826
00:51:40.274 --> 00:51:44.097
And it's happening even in these brainless basal metazoans.

827
00:51:44.478 --> 00:51:50.782
So in this case, jellyfish, but they also did the experiments on sea anemone and they found very similar results.

828
00:51:51.042 --> 00:51:51.282
Okay.

829
00:51:51.603 --> 00:51:54.525
So let's get into some of the historical context for sleep research.

830
00:51:55.763 --> 00:51:58.825
Pre-1980s, there was this guy Hans Berger in 1929.

831
00:51:58.905 --> 00:52:02.146
He invents the EEG, which is the electroencephalogram.

832
00:52:02.586 --> 00:52:10.810
And what he showed was that people that are sleeping, they've got these cortical oscillations, alpha waves, and other types of brain waves.

833
00:52:11.631 --> 00:52:15.513
And he said, okay, sleep is basically the state when we get that.

834
00:52:16.454 --> 00:52:16.634
Right.

835
00:52:16.754 --> 00:52:17.015
All right.

836
00:52:17.555 --> 00:52:25.063
Now, that's fine, but that totally excludes invertebrates because invertebrates don't—I can't do an EEG on an invertebrate, right?

837
00:52:25.143 --> 00:52:26.845
I need some kind of centralized brain.

838
00:52:27.125 --> 00:52:29.908
So I can do this on mammals, but are you saying that, like, you know—

839
00:52:31.475 --> 00:52:34.396
lower order organisms don't sleep.

840
00:52:35.117 --> 00:52:40.339
So in the 1980s, there was this neuroscientist, Irene Tobler, at the University of Zurich.

841
00:52:40.679 --> 00:52:43.461
She came up with the behavioral criterion, okay?

842
00:52:44.341 --> 00:52:53.125
She showed that actually insects sleep, scorpions sleep, and there were three things that she wanted to classify something as sleep.

843
00:52:53.265 --> 00:52:54.486
She was a pioneer in her field.

844
00:52:54.906 --> 00:52:56.067
The three things are the following.

845
00:52:56.167 --> 00:52:56.467
First...

846
00:52:57.247 --> 00:52:59.909
Reversible immobility That makes sense, right?

847
00:52:59.969 --> 00:53:17.923
When we sleep, we're still-ish But somebody can wake us up So that's the reversible part The second one is increased arousal threshold If I poke you when you're awake You can sense it But if I poke you when you're asleep You probably can't I need to poke you really hard in order to wake you up

848
00:53:18.523 --> 00:53:18.803
Okay?

849
00:53:19.223 --> 00:53:21.044
Like, I need to, like, slap you.

850
00:53:21.764 --> 00:53:22.764
And then you're going to wake up.

851
00:53:22.824 --> 00:53:28.286
The amount of effort needed to elicit a behavioral response is higher.

852
00:53:28.486 --> 00:53:29.546
Is higher when you sleep.

853
00:53:29.866 --> 00:53:30.126
Okay.

854
00:53:30.426 --> 00:53:32.767
And the third thing is homeostatic regulation.

855
00:53:33.087 --> 00:53:38.689
This means that if I deprive you of this sleep, then the next time you sleep, you're going to sleep longer.

856
00:53:39.369 --> 00:53:40.329
We've all had this, right?

857
00:53:40.349 --> 00:53:40.489
Yes.

858
00:53:40.849 --> 00:53:42.590
Like, if you've had a night out...

859
00:53:43.330 --> 00:53:45.634
The next day, you're, quote, hungover.

860
00:53:45.694 --> 00:53:50.603
But what you're really doing is homeostatic regulation on top of the fact that you don't have any electrolytes.

861
00:53:50.623 --> 00:53:53.247
But, you know, you're sleeping way longer than you should be.

862
00:53:53.388 --> 00:53:53.568
Yes.

863
00:53:53.808 --> 00:53:54.169
Yes.

864
00:53:54.447 --> 00:53:59.949
So those are the three sort of behavioral definitions that I need in order to characterize sleep.

865
00:54:00.169 --> 00:54:03.450
I don't think I've ever thought about how do you define sleep before in my life.

866
00:54:03.730 --> 00:54:04.410
But that's interesting.

867
00:54:04.630 --> 00:54:06.591
It becomes obvious when you talk about humans.

868
00:54:06.611 --> 00:54:08.151
You can just ask them, like, did you sleep?

869
00:54:08.431 --> 00:54:11.192
With mammals, again, you could hook up an EEG.

870
00:54:11.552 --> 00:54:13.653
But now when we're getting into something like jellyfish...

871
00:54:14.375 --> 00:54:18.779
It's like, how do we define sleep for an organism that's just doing this the whole time?

872
00:54:19.299 --> 00:54:19.519
Right?

873
00:54:19.559 --> 00:54:20.200
Yes.

874
00:54:20.320 --> 00:54:23.483
But these three criteria, actually, we can translate.

875
00:54:24.103 --> 00:54:24.343
Okay?

876
00:54:24.804 --> 00:54:30.789
So the model organisms in this paper are niderians, jellyfish, and sea anemone.

877
00:54:31.149 --> 00:54:31.429
Okay?

878
00:54:32.670 --> 00:54:34.732
It's a paper that came out of Nature Communications.

879
00:54:35.192 --> 00:54:40.557
And these organisms actually diverged from the bilaterals, which are us, the...

880
00:54:41.260 --> 00:54:50.044
the bilateral meaning to the symmetric kind of thing instead of the round symmetry, they diverged from us 600 million years ago.

881
00:54:50.684 --> 00:54:57.207
It's even thought that maybe the nervous system of these Niderians is completely separately evolved from us.

882
00:54:57.287 --> 00:55:07.151
There's a little bit of debate on that because if you look at the neurons of these guys, the genes that they expressed are very similar to the genes that our neurons express.

883
00:55:07.471 --> 00:55:08.872
So perhaps there's a little bit of...

884
00:55:09.612 --> 00:55:13.993
Independence, but also at the same time, a little bit of the same genes going forward.

885
00:55:14.394 --> 00:55:17.214
But what's very cool is these guys don't have a brain.

886
00:55:17.575 --> 00:55:18.695
They have nerve nets.

887
00:55:19.155 --> 00:55:21.476
There's no centralized repository.

888
00:55:22.016 --> 00:55:22.276
Okay.

889
00:55:22.536 --> 00:55:28.338
It's a bunch of nerves that are just in a net together and they're making decisions completely.

890
00:55:28.518 --> 00:55:52.464
together and it's very unclear how they're doing okay but in any case very different from our centralized nervous system that we have with a central hub and it branching out to create motor functions there's a decision making that happens in our brain and then the rest of the neurons carry it out here we've got a very decentralized decision making process is this the idea of like there's like no executive function in these uh

891
00:55:53.024 --> 00:55:55.186
Yeah, it's very related.

892
00:55:55.286 --> 00:55:59.188
There's not an authority who decides and then everyone else has to follow.

893
00:55:59.249 --> 00:55:59.689
That's right.

894
00:55:59.769 --> 00:56:00.049
Yeah.

895
00:56:00.069 --> 00:56:00.309
Put it.

896
00:56:00.690 --> 00:56:00.930
Okay.

897
00:56:01.470 --> 00:56:02.311
Very, very much so.

898
00:56:02.631 --> 00:56:08.635
So the challenge now becomes, okay, we've got these two organisms that we want to study.

899
00:56:09.075 --> 00:56:11.257
Let's try to define sleep for them, right?

900
00:56:11.397 --> 00:56:12.478
Using those three criteria.

901
00:56:12.498 --> 00:56:12.618
Okay.

902
00:56:13.278 --> 00:56:20.980
So what they did was just make videos of these organisms in their natural, not natural habitat, but in lab conditions.

903
00:56:21.260 --> 00:56:27.261
They used infrared light because if you use normal light, then you're just messing with their rhythm, right?

904
00:56:27.281 --> 00:56:29.442
It's like you still need a night and day cycle.

905
00:56:29.782 --> 00:56:32.362
So instead you use high resolution infrared light.

906
00:56:32.642 --> 00:56:33.723
So this is infrared light.

907
00:56:33.763 --> 00:56:36.763
And here you see the jellyfish that are pulsating, right?

908
00:56:36.783 --> 00:56:39.744
This is Cassiopeia andromeda, the jellyfish.

909
00:56:40.364 --> 00:56:52.538
And what they could do is analyze these videos and figure out, basically classify two behavioral states based on those three rules that we had about what sleep is.

910
00:56:52.938 --> 00:56:56.462
They did the same thing for the starlit sea anemone.

911
00:56:56.762 --> 00:57:00.567
That's the nematostella vectenis.

912
00:57:01.287 --> 00:57:03.248
These are like Hydra-looking things.

913
00:57:03.268 --> 00:57:05.149
This is a 20-minute time lapse.

914
00:57:05.169 --> 00:57:09.692
They're much slower moving, so it's actually harder to classify immobility.

915
00:57:10.152 --> 00:57:19.878
But what you could do is actually classify the – even when they're awake, they have a little bit of jitter, and they could really hone in on that jitter and classify immobility.

916
00:57:20.908 --> 00:57:24.229
Rest, just five minutes of rest versus actual sleep.

917
00:57:24.249 --> 00:57:24.489
Sleep.

918
00:57:24.629 --> 00:57:25.089
Okay.

919
00:57:25.230 --> 00:57:26.470
Oh, interesting.

920
00:57:26.590 --> 00:57:29.591
And that's what was really cool about how they did this, right?

921
00:57:29.611 --> 00:57:41.035
They actually figured out a way to move beyond just these arbitrary dimensions and used threshold-based optimization algorithms that were custom-made for this use case, right?

922
00:57:41.055 --> 00:57:41.255
Yes, yes.

923
00:57:41.835 --> 00:57:42.055
Yes.

924
00:57:42.496 --> 00:57:43.797
And it's a rigorous definition.

925
00:57:43.938 --> 00:57:44.078
Yes.

926
00:57:44.098 --> 00:57:46.320
So they came up with these rigorous definitions.

927
00:57:46.861 --> 00:57:49.644
And now let's go ahead and try to analyze the sleep.

928
00:57:50.025 --> 00:57:55.532
When you analyze the sleep, one thing that's really cool is the Cassiopeia Andromeda, which is the jellyfish.

929
00:57:55.812 --> 00:57:55.992
Yes.

930
00:57:56.052 --> 00:57:56.252
Yeah.

931
00:57:56.393 --> 00:58:00.097
That's the one that actually it's so in the light phase, it was highly active.

932
00:58:00.117 --> 00:58:01.459
So during the day, it's very active.

933
00:58:01.859 --> 00:58:03.681
That's the high on the Y-axis.

934
00:58:03.981 --> 00:58:06.464
And then during dark times, it was very inactive.

935
00:58:06.784 --> 00:58:11.288
But what's very cool is during the day, right in the middle, it takes a siesta.

936
00:58:11.428 --> 00:58:12.610
It takes a midday nap.

937
00:58:12.750 --> 00:58:14.031
They're very European, I see.

938
00:58:14.051 --> 00:58:14.612
Yeah, yeah.

939
00:58:14.652 --> 00:58:17.635
These jellyfish are Spanish, in fact.

940
00:58:17.795 --> 00:58:18.135
In fact.

941
00:58:18.295 --> 00:58:19.677
Yeah.

942
00:58:20.537 --> 00:58:23.160
So these jellyfish, just like us, we like taking naps.

943
00:58:23.220 --> 00:58:25.242
These jellyfish like taking naps.

944
00:58:25.602 --> 00:58:26.003
The...

945
00:58:27.245 --> 00:58:32.927
Sea anemone, on the other hand, they were actually more active during dusk and dawn, and then they slept mainly during morning.

946
00:58:33.187 --> 00:58:37.709
And that could have something to do with the fact that their feeding has to do with tides, right?

947
00:58:37.809 --> 00:58:39.349
Because the water is moving in and out.

948
00:58:39.569 --> 00:58:47.172
So perhaps you want to be more active during the dusk and dawn, and then you can be less active when the sun is high in the sky and when the sun is low in the sky.

949
00:58:47.212 --> 00:58:50.153
Which kind of maps onto nocturnal versus non-nocturnal.

950
00:58:50.633 --> 00:58:54.635
Yeah, and speaking of nocturnal versus non-nocturnal, they also had the melatonin.

951
00:58:55.494 --> 00:58:56.394
That was affecting them.

952
00:58:56.434 --> 00:59:00.736
So melatonin, you know, that's the very famous compound that we can take in order to induce sleep.

953
00:59:00.856 --> 00:59:01.056
Yes.

954
00:59:01.196 --> 00:59:04.057
They tested it with 100 micromolar melatonin.

955
00:59:04.337 --> 00:59:12.000
And the melatonin promoted sleep in both the diurnal jellyfish and these anemone.

956
00:59:12.340 --> 00:59:20.663
So you're saying that someone's going to make billions of dollars selling melatonin 10 milligram, 100 milligram, whatever packages to see like Nemo.

957
00:59:20.683 --> 00:59:20.924
Yeah.

958
00:59:21.264 --> 00:59:22.424
Nemo, tell your dad.

959
00:59:22.444 --> 00:59:23.004
Yeah.

960
00:59:23.024 --> 00:59:24.325
We're coming with the melatonin.

961
00:59:24.385 --> 00:59:24.845
Yeah, exactly.

962
00:59:25.205 --> 00:59:27.527
Yeah, there's a huge market there, dude.

963
00:59:29.709 --> 00:59:29.929
Yeah.

964
00:59:30.230 --> 00:59:35.314
So now we've established that they sleep and the sleep is like pretty close to how we do it.

965
00:59:35.354 --> 00:59:38.396
And we saw it both in a natural context and by trying to induce it.

966
00:59:38.517 --> 00:59:39.457
Yes, exactly.

967
00:59:39.818 --> 00:59:43.040
So now the big question is why are these guys sleeping so much?

968
00:59:43.341 --> 00:59:43.581
Mm-hmm.

969
00:59:43.861 --> 00:59:54.526
OK, if they have no brains, if they've got no brain, the way we the way we conceptualize, yeah, the way we conceptualize brains, they don't have these like synaptic connections that they need to regulate up and down.

970
00:59:54.806 --> 00:59:56.307
So why are they sleeping so much?

971
00:59:56.947 --> 01:00:00.809
And this is the key significant contribution of this paper.

972
01:00:01.149 --> 01:00:13.155
OK, they're tying the sleep not to neural activity, but to cellular activity and the idea that at the molecular level, all cells need to recover.

973
01:00:15.097 --> 01:00:15.257
Oh.

974
01:00:15.658 --> 01:00:20.801
Because at the molecular level, what's happening with activity is activity means high entropy, right?

975
01:00:20.821 --> 01:00:22.121
There's high metabolic flux.

976
01:00:22.402 --> 01:00:23.943
The mitochondria are going crazy.

977
01:00:23.983 --> 01:00:25.043
They're creating ATP.

978
01:00:25.383 --> 01:00:29.806
Now, that's going to create a lot of reactive oxygen species, okay?

979
01:00:30.106 --> 01:00:36.290
And these reactive oxygen species are going to cause damage to the DNA backbone, okay?

980
01:00:36.430 --> 01:00:40.511
If you remember from our DNA episode, the DNA has this phosphate backbone, right?

981
01:00:40.791 --> 01:00:48.754
The reactive oxygen species that come as a byproduct of mitochondrial metabolism is going to start attacking this DNA backbone.

982
01:00:48.874 --> 01:00:52.955
And if you ever get something like a double-stranded break, that's really bad.

983
01:00:53.635 --> 01:00:53.875
Okay?

984
01:00:54.095 --> 01:01:00.217
And what they could actually quantify is during wakefulness, the double-stranded break was happening more often.

985
01:01:00.237 --> 01:01:00.657
Okay?

986
01:01:01.844 --> 01:01:16.320
So literally the process of living, of being awake and active is not only impacting your body in the physical sense that we think about it today.

987
01:01:16.360 --> 01:01:16.680
Mm-hmm.

988
01:01:17.341 --> 01:01:25.087
But the reason that our body needs sleep and rest is because at the DNA level, it's causing damage.

989
01:01:25.107 --> 01:01:26.287
It's causing damage.

990
01:01:26.748 --> 01:01:34.373
And that's because, again, I always thought, like, from my layman's perspective, like, oh, we sleep because your brain is tired.

991
01:01:34.413 --> 01:01:34.693
Yes.

992
01:01:34.893 --> 01:01:36.174
Like that was the idea.

993
01:01:36.254 --> 01:01:37.755
It's like you need to give your brain a rest.

994
01:01:37.775 --> 01:01:38.775
You're going to go crazy.

995
01:01:38.895 --> 01:01:39.135
Yeah.

996
01:01:39.515 --> 01:01:47.639
But really what this is identifying is that the destructive property that happens from lack of sleep is a degradation of your underlying DNA.

997
01:01:47.739 --> 01:01:48.200
Yeah, yeah.

998
01:01:48.480 --> 01:01:54.783
And for higher order organisms, it could be that the brain is also tired and the synaptic homeostasis model works, right?

999
01:01:55.023 --> 01:01:55.983
And that could be a thing.

1000
01:01:56.123 --> 01:01:56.304
Yes.

1001
01:01:56.664 --> 01:01:57.904
And it most definitely is.

1002
01:01:57.924 --> 01:01:59.105
There's a lot of papers that do that.

1003
01:02:03.647 --> 01:02:11.671
We needed sleep because fundamentally the act of living, as you said, degrades the molecular structure of our genetics.

1004
01:02:12.431 --> 01:02:12.671
Right.

1005
01:02:12.972 --> 01:02:17.354
And what they could do is show they could actually tag phosphorylated histone.

1006
01:02:17.694 --> 01:02:20.235
And this phosphorylation happens at double stranded breaks.

1007
01:02:20.495 --> 01:02:25.317
And they could track that actually the longer you're awake, the more double stranded breaks you're having.

1008
01:02:25.778 --> 01:02:30.220
OK. And if you kept these organisms awake, the breaks would actually build up.

1009
01:02:31.370 --> 01:02:38.595
The craziest thing to me was they could actually use that damage to drive sleep.

1010
01:02:38.896 --> 01:02:41.417
So you know that homeostatic regulation that I was telling you about?

1011
01:02:41.497 --> 01:02:45.640
Like, okay, if I deprive these animals of sleep, then they want to sleep longer.

1012
01:02:46.021 --> 01:02:52.525
Well, I could actually artificially make double-stranded breaks happen, expose them to UV radiation.

1013
01:02:53.046 --> 01:02:54.867
Now I have a bunch of DNA damage.

1014
01:02:55.948 --> 01:02:57.089
The animals would sleep more.

1015
01:02:58.147 --> 01:03:01.509
Because of more UV radiation, because there was more double-stranded breaks.

1016
01:03:01.870 --> 01:03:04.051
So it's a direct causation now.

1017
01:03:04.191 --> 01:03:05.252
It's not just a correlation.

1018
01:03:05.512 --> 01:03:09.795
You've established a direct causation between DNA damage and more sleep.

1019
01:03:10.155 --> 01:03:10.856
That's fascinating.

1020
01:03:10.876 --> 01:03:11.816
Very cool.

1021
01:03:11.936 --> 01:03:17.300
They artificially triggered DSBs, double-stranded breaks,

1022
01:03:17.540 --> 01:03:17.760
Yeah.

1023
01:03:18.161 --> 01:03:20.363
After having already monitored natural behavior.

1024
01:03:20.403 --> 01:03:20.583
Yep.

1025
01:03:21.124 --> 01:03:37.861
And it triggered an increase in the amount of sleep in both the jellyfish and the sea anemone when they were exposed to an external factor that one of the primary things it did was create a larger volume of double-stranded breaks.

1026
01:03:37.901 --> 01:03:38.301
Yeah, exactly.

1027
01:03:38.321 --> 01:03:40.063
Or degradation of the molecular DNA stuff.

1028
01:03:40.263 --> 01:03:46.750
And they didn't comment on this, but I've always felt that, like, if I'm out in the sun for really long, I need a nap.

1029
01:03:46.810 --> 01:03:47.350
I need a nap.

1030
01:03:47.450 --> 01:03:54.217
I don't know if— I'm not saying that the authors— I'm just saying it's, like, kind of— I don't know.

1031
01:03:54.378 --> 01:03:58.161
Look, it is Southern California, so we do know what it's like to be out in the sun a lot.

1032
01:03:58.201 --> 01:04:01.225
I feel like when I get sunburned— And I do get sunburned, okay?

1033
01:04:01.625 --> 01:04:04.626
Like, even though, like, I'm brown, I do get sunburned.

1034
01:04:04.686 --> 01:04:09.649
And then when I do, it's like I do like I end up napping for like two hours and it's the best now.

1035
01:04:09.689 --> 01:04:10.169
It's the best.

1036
01:04:10.229 --> 01:04:10.969
It's usually the best.

1037
01:04:10.989 --> 01:04:11.489
Yeah.

1038
01:04:11.509 --> 01:04:11.790
Yeah.

1039
01:04:11.890 --> 01:04:12.250
It's usually.

1040
01:04:12.270 --> 01:04:18.573
And, you know, maybe that's like, you know, the DNA repair being like, finally, we get to, like, fix all this nonsense that he's been up to.

1041
01:04:20.354 --> 01:04:21.195
This is good.

1042
01:04:21.235 --> 01:04:26.839
And again, this is like, again, a story at the intersection of spaces I didn't expect to sort of see.

1043
01:04:27.420 --> 01:04:27.660
Right.

1044
01:04:28.080 --> 01:04:30.102
You have it was like DNA damage.

1045
01:04:30.182 --> 01:04:30.442
OK.

1046
01:04:30.842 --> 01:04:35.066
The neuroscience story because we thought that sleep was about the brain only.

1047
01:04:35.166 --> 01:04:36.587
Again, we've caveated.

1048
01:04:36.607 --> 01:04:42.592
This is not saying that sleep is not involved in neurological activity.

1049
01:04:42.672 --> 01:04:45.314
It's just that we can see that it is not the only brain.

1050
01:04:45.874 --> 01:04:46.995
thing that it's involved in.

1051
01:04:47.075 --> 01:04:47.315
Yeah.

1052
01:04:47.855 --> 01:04:50.717
And it's like an invariant across animals that have neurons.

1053
01:04:50.977 --> 01:04:55.440
And one of the cool things is when you think about like, why would neurons specifically need sleep?

1054
01:04:55.640 --> 01:04:55.840
Yeah.

1055
01:04:56.120 --> 01:04:56.320
Right.

1056
01:04:57.021 --> 01:05:00.943
Neurons are organisms that don't divide.

1057
01:05:00.963 --> 01:05:01.123
Right.

1058
01:05:02.778 --> 01:05:04.159
neurons are not organisms.

1059
01:05:04.239 --> 01:05:06.519
Neurons are cells that are post-mitotic.

1060
01:05:06.820 --> 01:05:07.860
They don't do mitosis.

1061
01:05:07.920 --> 01:05:08.820
They don't cell divide.

1062
01:05:09.080 --> 01:05:10.321
So once you have them, you have them.

1063
01:05:10.581 --> 01:05:14.342
So maintaining the cell state of a neuron is way more important than, let's say, skin cells.

1064
01:05:14.642 --> 01:05:20.124
Skin cells, if you've got something that's bad, you shed it, you make new ones, because those things are going through mitosis all the time.

1065
01:05:20.684 --> 01:05:21.625
Muscle cells as well.

1066
01:05:21.925 --> 01:05:23.165
They're replicating all the time.

1067
01:05:23.225 --> 01:05:25.446
Neurons, on the other hand, you got what you got.

1068
01:05:25.906 --> 01:05:27.807
And so you need to maintain it, right?

1069
01:05:27.987 --> 01:05:30.668
Which is why animals with neurons...

1070
01:05:31.408 --> 01:05:36.510
might require sleep because DNA damage in a neuron is way more important to fix than anything else.

1071
01:05:38.090 --> 01:05:51.075
And so in order to protect your limited neurons, make sure you share the pod with a friend because what better way to stretch out and exercise those neurons than listening to the From First Principles podcast.

1072
01:05:51.135 --> 01:05:52.096
It's for your brain health.

1073
01:05:52.356 --> 01:05:52.636
Yes.

1074
01:05:52.816 --> 01:05:58.718
So if they ask you, this podcast helps my mental health, my biological mental health,

1075
01:05:59.334 --> 01:05:59.594
Yeah.

1076
01:05:59.955 --> 01:06:02.658
Stretching and pulling and keeping flexi.

1077
01:06:02.778 --> 01:06:09.806
And then get some sleep right after because then that'll actually, studies have shown that, you know, sleep actually consolidates that memory into long-term storage.

1078
01:06:09.826 --> 01:06:12.750
So you might actually remember something that we're talking about.

1079
01:06:13.010 --> 01:06:13.951
It's for your health.

1080
01:06:14.432 --> 01:06:15.693
That's why you listen to the pod.

1081
01:06:16.614 --> 01:06:17.596
Great story number two.

1082
01:06:17.616 --> 01:06:18.737
We started with string theory.

1083
01:06:18.977 --> 01:06:19.238
Yeah.

1084
01:06:19.978 --> 01:06:35.926
Then we went into this sort of biology, neuroscience, sleep story, understanding a little bit more about sleep having a larger scope of value to other sort of animals within the animal kingdom.

1085
01:06:36.847 --> 01:06:42.430
And we're going to end this episode with a space story.

1086
01:06:42.750 --> 01:06:44.111
Yes.

1087
01:06:44.231 --> 01:06:48.373
Story number three is about dark matter.

1088
01:06:48.812 --> 01:06:49.133
Yes.

1089
01:06:50.094 --> 01:06:55.764
Dark Matters, First Frontier, and the discovery of Cloud 9.

1090
01:06:55.984 --> 01:06:56.765
Not that Cloud 9.

1091
01:06:58.093 --> 01:06:58.753
Different cloud net.

1092
01:06:58.814 --> 01:06:59.234
Or is it?

1093
01:06:59.434 --> 01:06:59.854
Or is it?

1094
01:06:59.974 --> 01:07:00.375
I don't know.

1095
01:07:00.455 --> 01:07:01.716
I don't know how it was named, honestly.

1096
01:07:02.336 --> 01:07:03.637
We will get to that question.

1097
01:07:03.657 --> 01:07:18.708
But astronomers may have found the first example of a primordial gas cloud trapped in a dark matter halo, offering a rare glimpse into how the universe's first structures formed billions of years ago.

1098
01:07:18.908 --> 01:07:27.334
This is coming in the Astrophysical Journal Letters on January 7th from the Space Telescope Science Institute,

1099
01:07:27.934 --> 01:07:34.599
The Universita D'Aglia Studi di Milano Bioka, University of Victoria.

1100
01:07:35.140 --> 01:07:41.124
And another placement, I think they might be third place in our stories, of the University of Wisconsin.

1101
01:07:41.144 --> 01:07:44.067
Wisconsin is doing well in our stories.

1102
01:07:44.107 --> 01:07:46.589
They are performing very, very highly.

1103
01:07:47.770 --> 01:07:55.616
So what makes Cloud9, the new celestial discovery, a cosmic game changer for star formation theories?

1104
01:07:55.636 --> 01:07:55.816
Yes.

1105
01:07:55.896 --> 01:08:03.445
Yeah, so they're claiming, you know, it's been all over the news, they're claiming that this is a new type of object, okay?

1106
01:08:03.505 --> 01:08:06.909
It's a compact, gas-rich, starless object.

1107
01:08:08.051 --> 01:08:08.211
And...

1108
01:08:09.447 --> 01:08:11.988
It's a totally different thing in our cosmic zoo.

1109
01:08:12.168 --> 01:08:20.052
You know, we got galaxies, we got stars, we got planets, and now perhaps a totally different animal altogether.

1110
01:08:20.312 --> 01:08:20.692
Okay.

1111
01:08:20.792 --> 01:08:21.212
Okay?

1112
01:08:21.392 --> 01:08:22.132
That's very rare.

1113
01:08:22.693 --> 01:08:24.974
Because we've been staring at the night sky for a while.

1114
01:08:25.054 --> 01:08:25.474
Right, right.

1115
01:08:25.834 --> 01:08:29.556
So a new type of object is quite interesting, right?

1116
01:08:29.616 --> 01:08:30.376
Yes.

1117
01:08:30.556 --> 01:08:32.317
That definitely doesn't fit into another bucket.

1118
01:08:32.337 --> 01:08:32.977
Yes, yes.

1119
01:08:33.137 --> 01:08:36.679
And what's really important about this new type of object is it's confirming a lot of

1120
01:08:37.459 --> 01:08:39.702
Theories about dark matter that we have.

1121
01:08:40.163 --> 01:08:43.667
There were some holes in that theory that this is sort of filling.

1122
01:08:44.048 --> 01:08:48.894
And at the same time, it's raising some new questions as almost all new stuff does.

1123
01:08:49.034 --> 01:08:49.214
Yes.

1124
01:08:49.314 --> 01:08:49.475
Right.

1125
01:08:49.675 --> 01:08:50.896
So let's start at the very beginning.

1126
01:08:50.916 --> 01:08:54.481
We're going to start at the Big Bang and we're going to start with something called Lambda CDM.

1127
01:08:54.781 --> 01:08:55.602
In the Beninging.

1128
01:08:55.622 --> 01:08:55.703
Yes.

1129
01:08:56.624 --> 01:08:57.425
There it is.

1130
01:08:57.465 --> 01:08:59.587
Lambda CDM is cold dark matter.

1131
01:08:59.787 --> 01:09:05.654
That's the prevailing cosmological model that we have for all the stuff that is in our universe.

1132
01:09:06.234 --> 01:09:07.356
Not a lot of normal matter.

1133
01:09:08.573 --> 01:09:09.534
a lot of dark matter.

1134
01:09:09.674 --> 01:09:15.678
So I think 85% of stuff that is gravitationally influenced is dark matter.

1135
01:09:16.218 --> 01:09:18.060
Only 15% is normal matter.

1136
01:09:18.340 --> 01:09:21.362
And then we don't have to talk about dark energy, which is a whole other thing.

1137
01:09:22.143 --> 01:09:24.584
That's actually even more than dark matter, right?

1138
01:09:24.844 --> 01:09:25.705
But let's not get into that.

1139
01:09:25.745 --> 01:09:28.007
Let's just talk about stuff that is influenced by gravity.

1140
01:09:28.447 --> 01:09:30.628
So in the very beginning, there was the Big Bang.

1141
01:09:30.949 --> 01:09:32.590
The Big Bang expanded into

1142
01:09:35.205 --> 01:09:36.405
It didn't expand into space.

1143
01:09:36.565 --> 01:09:37.766
Space itself expanded.

1144
01:09:37.806 --> 01:09:39.606
Let me catch myself when I say that.

1145
01:09:39.646 --> 01:09:39.806
Right?

1146
01:09:40.086 --> 01:09:41.847
The comets would have gone crazy with that one.

1147
01:09:42.307 --> 01:09:42.727
Yeah, yeah.

1148
01:09:42.747 --> 01:09:46.088
So 300,000 years after the Big Bang, we formed atoms.

1149
01:09:46.188 --> 01:09:48.208
That's when we got our cosmic microwave background.

1150
01:09:48.608 --> 01:09:52.749
And then we had our first stars, our first galaxies, our first black holes.

1151
01:09:53.890 --> 01:09:58.691
And through all of this, dark matter was also expanding with all of the baryonic matter.

1152
01:09:58.731 --> 01:10:02.932
That's the ordinary matter, stuff of atoms, quarks, electrons, things like that.

1153
01:10:04.273 --> 01:10:09.936
And at some point, the first stars began collapsing.

1154
01:10:10.256 --> 01:10:12.017
They started blowing up.

1155
01:10:12.317 --> 01:10:17.620
The black holes started creating a mess, right?

1156
01:10:17.660 --> 01:10:19.921
They started creating ultraviolet radiation.

1157
01:10:20.962 --> 01:10:27.625
And all of this time, what was happening was this ultraviolet radiation was heating up the intergalactic medium, right?

1158
01:10:28.895 --> 01:10:34.357
to a temperature of approximately 10 to the 4, so 10,000 Kelvin, 10,000 degrees Celsius.

1159
01:10:35.057 --> 01:10:35.277
Okay?

1160
01:10:35.777 --> 01:10:36.217
Pretty cool.

1161
01:10:36.377 --> 01:10:36.798
Pretty cool.

1162
01:10:36.838 --> 01:10:40.339
And this was happening around 400 million years after the Big Bang.

1163
01:10:40.359 --> 01:10:42.659
This is called the reionization epoch.

1164
01:10:43.120 --> 01:10:50.262
Because what's happening now is all of the hydrogen that's in our intergalactic medium is getting bathed in this UV radiation.

1165
01:10:50.782 --> 01:10:51.002
Okay?

1166
01:10:51.542 --> 01:10:53.763
And this whole time, dark matter is just doing its thing.

1167
01:10:54.603 --> 01:10:58.765
So all of the hydrogen, which is the baryonic matter, is getting bathed in UV radiation.

1168
01:10:58.825 --> 01:11:02.787
Meanwhile, the UV radiation is not at all interacting with the dark matter.

1169
01:11:02.827 --> 01:11:03.908
That's the point of dark matter.

1170
01:11:04.228 --> 01:11:07.229
It does not interact with light, hence it's dark.

1171
01:11:07.950 --> 01:11:10.671
So dark matter has been collapsing this whole time.

1172
01:11:10.771 --> 01:11:13.753
And when dark matter collapses, it forms clumps.

1173
01:11:15.005 --> 01:11:16.026
These are called halos.

1174
01:11:16.726 --> 01:11:20.208
And the clumps happen at all different scales.

1175
01:11:20.629 --> 01:11:29.214
If we look out at the dark matter halo function, the mass function that we see today, that function is something that we call scale-free.

1176
01:11:29.574 --> 01:11:36.338
So instead of the size of the dark matter halos sort of collapsing as an exponential, where there's some like...

1177
01:11:36.718 --> 01:12:01.774
fundamental scale constant of that exponential this thing is a power law which means as we get to smaller and smaller scale like scales of halos there should be more and more of these dark matter halos so there should be a halo for the milky way that is as big as the milky way and at the center of this dark matter halo is the our normal milky way but then around this milky way there should be a bunch of different tiny clumps and around those tiny clumps there should be even smaller

1178
01:12:07.242 --> 01:12:10.104
referential fractally system.

1179
01:12:10.344 --> 01:12:11.525
It's like the Russian dolls.

1180
01:12:11.725 --> 01:12:12.646
Yes, exactly.

1181
01:12:12.906 --> 01:12:15.548
But the smaller the Russian doll, the more there should be.

1182
01:12:15.888 --> 01:12:16.308
That's key.

1183
01:12:16.489 --> 01:12:16.729
Okay.

1184
01:12:16.929 --> 01:12:17.209
Okay.

1185
01:12:17.289 --> 01:12:17.469
Yes.

1186
01:12:17.790 --> 01:12:17.990
Yeah.

1187
01:12:18.050 --> 01:12:18.390
Okay.

1188
01:12:18.470 --> 01:12:18.910
Interesting.

1189
01:12:19.130 --> 01:12:19.391
Okay.

1190
01:12:19.951 --> 01:12:25.775
So now let's think about what would happen with these halos, right?

1191
01:12:27.216 --> 01:12:30.238
The bigger the halo, there should be galaxies inside, right?

1192
01:12:30.799 --> 01:12:33.120
We don't actually see all that many halos.

1193
01:12:34.201 --> 01:12:35.222
That's kind of a problem.

1194
01:12:36.035 --> 01:12:36.575
OK, yeah.

1195
01:12:36.775 --> 01:12:41.398
Now, there could be a solution about why we don't see a bunch of small halos.

1196
01:12:41.938 --> 01:12:47.782
OK, and that has to do with the nature of these halos and the normal matter that's inside of these halos.

1197
01:12:47.822 --> 01:12:51.004
So let's talk about something called hydrostatic equilibrium.

1198
01:12:51.344 --> 01:12:56.527
Normally, we think about hydrostatic equilibrium in the sense of why are stars stable?

1199
01:12:56.807 --> 01:12:58.688
Like, why isn't every star a black hole?

1200
01:12:59.729 --> 01:13:04.536
Because if gravity is just pushing everything inside, then everything should just collapse into a black hole.

1201
01:13:04.576 --> 01:13:12.407
Well, the reason is there's a bunch of fusion going on, and that fusion creates an external pressure outward that is counteracting the gravitational pressure.

1202
01:13:13.208 --> 01:13:14.470
And that's what keeps a star...

1203
01:13:15.512 --> 01:13:15.852
Stable.

1204
01:13:16.072 --> 01:13:16.252
Yes.

1205
01:13:16.593 --> 01:13:18.454
Okay, now let's think about dark matter halos.

1206
01:13:18.474 --> 01:13:19.274
Okay.

1207
01:13:19.294 --> 01:13:29.220
Okay, with dark matter halos, remember I told you that during reionization, this cosmic dawn is what they call it, when there was a bunch of ultraviolet radiation, that ultraviolet radiation is going to heat up

1208
01:13:29.967 --> 01:13:31.268
normal matter.

1209
01:13:31.488 --> 01:13:35.011
So that normal matter is inside of a gravitational well of dark matter.

1210
01:13:35.351 --> 01:13:37.112
So it's getting pushed in because of gravity.

1211
01:13:37.493 --> 01:13:38.393
But it's also hot.

1212
01:13:39.174 --> 01:13:41.556
And the hot is going to push out.

1213
01:13:42.256 --> 01:13:45.338
And so there itself is a kind of hydrostatic equilibrium.

1214
01:13:45.519 --> 01:13:47.480
The hotness is not coming from fusion.

1215
01:13:47.620 --> 01:13:51.843
It's just coming from being bathed by this early ultraviolet light.

1216
01:13:52.164 --> 01:13:52.384
Got it.

1217
01:13:52.424 --> 01:13:52.804
Understood?

1218
01:13:52.924 --> 01:13:53.104
Yes.

1219
01:13:53.224 --> 01:13:53.765
Okay.

1220
01:13:53.805 --> 01:13:57.848
So there we get into a very cool thing.

1221
01:13:59.141 --> 01:14:08.144
which is there's actually a size limit to how big a dark matter halo can get before it starts having stars inside of it.

1222
01:14:08.424 --> 01:14:11.265
Because imagine a very large dark matter halo, okay?

1223
01:14:11.505 --> 01:14:13.525
It's got a bunch of matter inside.

1224
01:14:13.905 --> 01:14:16.306
The very large dark matter halo is going to start collapsing.

1225
01:14:16.626 --> 01:14:20.847
The matter inside is big enough that it's going to start collapsing and it's going to start creating galaxies.

1226
01:14:21.027 --> 01:14:22.268
But if it's really small...

1227
01:14:23.028 --> 01:14:28.591
The matter inside is just going to sort of evaporate out because the hotness is too big.

1228
01:14:29.491 --> 01:14:30.912
Sorry, the hotness is too hot.

1229
01:14:31.672 --> 01:14:38.275
The particles are moving too fast for the gravitation of that small, tiny little dark matter halo to keep everything inside.

1230
01:14:38.675 --> 01:14:41.537
So there comes this critical mass threshold.

1231
01:14:42.097 --> 01:14:48.424
And they calculate it, the paper actually quotes it to be around 10 to the 9.7 times the mass of the sun.

1232
01:14:48.704 --> 01:14:50.986
The Milky Way for context is around 10 to the 12.

1233
01:14:51.266 --> 01:14:52.988
So this is much smaller than the Milky Way.

1234
01:14:54.390 --> 01:14:58.994
But at that critical mass threshold, the dark matter halo is...

1235
01:15:00.078 --> 01:15:04.860
big enough where it's like keeping the stuff inside.

1236
01:15:05.180 --> 01:15:05.420
Okay.

1237
01:15:05.681 --> 01:15:12.444
Anything bigger and the stuff that's inside is going to coalesce to become a galaxy and become stars, anything smaller and it's not enough.

1238
01:15:12.624 --> 01:15:14.284
And the, and the gas is just going to leave.

1239
01:15:14.605 --> 01:15:26.190
But right at that threshold, we've got this sweet spot where the gas is going to retain inside of my halo, but it's not enough to create stars and galaxies.

1240
01:15:26.210 --> 01:15:26.690
Okay.

1241
01:15:27.375 --> 01:15:27.675
You see?

1242
01:15:27.715 --> 01:15:27.876
Yes.

1243
01:15:27.896 --> 01:15:30.157
There's a sweet spot.

1244
01:15:30.337 --> 01:15:35.960
It is this buffer line where it can just contain a lot of...

1245
01:15:35.980 --> 01:15:37.501
This is why I'm thinking about...

1246
01:15:37.521 --> 01:15:40.483
This is why the cloud metaphor becomes interesting here.

1247
01:15:40.523 --> 01:15:47.387
Because it's at a threshold where it can't materialize... Like this physical large-scale matter the way we think about it.

1248
01:15:47.407 --> 01:15:50.389
And it's just these gas particles all... Yeah, just moving around...

1249
01:15:50.849 --> 01:15:51.269
Hanging out.

1250
01:15:51.349 --> 01:15:52.410
Hanging out, yeah.

1251
01:15:52.590 --> 01:15:56.813
And so there was a term that was coined in 2017 in monthly notices.

1252
01:15:57.133 --> 01:16:03.158
It was called the RELHIC, which is, I think it stands for Reionization Limited H1 Clouds.

1253
01:16:03.358 --> 01:16:05.819
H1 meaning neutral hydrogen, okay?

1254
01:16:06.540 --> 01:16:12.424
It was a paper out in monthly notices, and what they said was there should be these halos right at the critical mass, right?

1255
01:16:12.704 --> 01:16:22.548
That should be massive enough to retain neutral gas, neutral hydrogen gas, but not massive enough to cool down and condense and form stars.

1256
01:16:22.588 --> 01:16:22.788
Yes.

1257
01:16:23.128 --> 01:16:23.368
Okay.

1258
01:16:23.548 --> 01:16:23.728
Yes.

1259
01:16:24.448 --> 01:16:25.529
And these are called relics.

1260
01:16:26.129 --> 01:16:28.870
So finding one of these relics would be awesome.

1261
01:16:29.110 --> 01:16:33.331
I just want to quickly pause and say back engineering.

1262
01:16:33.351 --> 01:16:35.072
I can't remember what the name for it was.

1263
01:16:35.132 --> 01:16:37.553
Back engineering, the acronym from what you want it to sound like.

1264
01:16:38.173 --> 01:17:01.055
relics i mean it's clever it's a good one scientists do this all the time so relics is a really good one reionization limited h1 clouds that's pretty good okay so finding these relics would be really awesome yes but finding it is very hard because this thing has no stars right right so how do the whole point like how do we see something we see it using light but this thing has no stars

1265
01:17:02.236 --> 01:17:03.297
Dark matter is invisible.

1266
01:17:03.437 --> 01:17:04.218
Yeah, right.

1267
01:17:04.238 --> 01:17:09.321
Which is what makes any kind of discovery around this subject of dark matter extremely difficult.

1268
01:17:09.341 --> 01:17:09.601
Yes.

1269
01:17:09.801 --> 01:17:15.865
Because we are only as good as the instruments we build in order to understand the world around us, and we have not yet...

1270
01:17:16.700 --> 01:17:16.940
Maybe.

1271
01:17:17.240 --> 01:17:17.440
Yeah.

1272
01:17:17.761 --> 01:17:19.221
Figured out a lot of this, but maybe.

1273
01:17:19.461 --> 01:17:19.722
Maybe.

1274
01:17:20.042 --> 01:17:20.302
Maybe.

1275
01:17:20.722 --> 01:17:24.104
And what comes to the rescue is the hydrogen 21 centimeter line.

1276
01:17:24.184 --> 01:17:24.404
Yes.

1277
01:17:24.624 --> 01:17:24.904
Okay.

1278
01:17:25.465 --> 01:17:27.846
This is our favorite line.

1279
01:17:28.026 --> 01:17:28.726
Yes.

1280
01:17:28.766 --> 01:17:29.547
1420 megahertz.

1281
01:17:29.647 --> 01:17:29.887
Yes.

1282
01:17:29.927 --> 01:17:31.728
This is the hyperfine transition.

1283
01:17:31.748 --> 01:17:34.930
This was used in the Pioneer plaque to tell...

1284
01:17:35.730 --> 01:17:47.300
Aliens, what our standard time and our standard unit of measurement is for all of the, you know, diagrams that we have on the Pioneer plaque in case the aliens found the Pioneer plaque and they wanted to see where Earth was.

1285
01:17:47.881 --> 01:17:56.989
All of the standard measurement on that Pioneer plaque is made using the hyperfine transition of hydrogen, which is effectively hydrogen has a proton and an electron.

1286
01:17:57.529 --> 01:18:00.032
If they're spinning parallel to one another...

1287
01:18:00.993 --> 01:18:14.881
Versus when they're spinning opposite to one another, that difference in energy corresponds to a particle of light, a photon, that is exactly the wavelength 21 centimeters or around 1420 megahertz, right?

1288
01:18:15.761 --> 01:18:16.222
Sidebar.

1289
01:18:17.222 --> 01:18:28.668
At Princeton Physics, one of my favorite classes was the undergraduate advanced physics lab, where we actually used the hydrogen 21 centimeter line to map out the Milky Way.

1290
01:18:29.008 --> 01:18:36.712
There was a radio telescope on the roof of the physics department that we could use to point it in different directions, and we could point it...

1291
01:18:38.178 --> 01:18:56.765
at the galactic disk of the Milky Way, and you could see the 21 centimeters, and you could actually figure out what part of the galactic disk was moving away from us versus moving towards us by pointing it in different directions, and that 1420 megahertz would be a little bit red shifted or a little bit blue shifted, depending on where you were looking.

1292
01:18:57.205 --> 01:18:59.266
And what you could do, I mean, there's a lot of error, right?

1293
01:18:59.286 --> 01:19:01.266
Because you don't know exactly where you're pointing.

1294
01:19:01.506 --> 01:19:05.408
It's kind of a, you know, old disk that they were like, okay, let the undergrads

1295
01:19:06.068 --> 01:19:07.430
you know, use it for their lab.

1296
01:19:08.492 --> 01:19:19.588
So you don't know where it's pointing and the frequency resolution is not that great, but you could actually like, I remember calculating the rotation curve, which is depending on how far away I am from the galactic center.

1297
01:19:19.608 --> 01:19:19.668
Um,

1298
01:19:21.622 --> 01:19:23.603
how fast is the stuff moving?

1299
01:19:23.924 --> 01:19:32.211
And you could actually chart out the galactic rotation curve and you could see that the galactic rotation curve plateaued.

1300
01:19:32.491 --> 01:19:34.873
Now, okay, this is not as good as the data that I got.

1301
01:19:34.933 --> 01:19:36.555
The data that I got had massive error

1302
01:19:36.715 --> 01:19:59.452
bars and only like eight data points but what you could see is that it would rise and then it would plateau and this is characteristic of dark matter vera rubin the astronomer actually used these galactic rotation curves to calculate dark matter because if you think about it the farther away you get from a galaxy center the slower yes you should be moving right because newton's laws inverse

1303
01:20:01.453 --> 01:20:05.354
Here, the farther you get away, you're still moving at the same rate.

1304
01:20:05.414 --> 01:20:09.935
The only way this is possible is if there's a bunch of invisible matter that's actually pulling on you.

1305
01:20:09.955 --> 01:20:10.135
Yes.

1306
01:20:10.455 --> 01:20:12.796
That's creating this gravitational force.

1307
01:20:12.836 --> 01:20:13.596
That's sustained.

1308
01:20:13.616 --> 01:20:20.178
That creates that plateau of sustained speed because otherwise... Like, there's no other external factor that could be...

1309
01:20:20.438 --> 01:20:22.378
Yeah, because we don't see any stars.

1310
01:20:22.418 --> 01:20:26.259
And yet you're telling me that there's a bunch of new mass that's pulling on you.

1311
01:20:26.359 --> 01:20:28.740
Because you're farther and farther away and your speed has not changed.

1312
01:20:28.820 --> 01:20:29.060
Yeah.

1313
01:20:29.260 --> 01:20:32.681
Even though it should now be slower because you're farther away from the gravitational center.

1314
01:20:32.821 --> 01:20:33.221
Exactly.

1315
01:20:33.241 --> 01:20:35.982
So that gravitational force must come from something.

1316
01:20:36.022 --> 01:20:36.862
It has to come from something.

1317
01:20:37.162 --> 01:20:39.703
And that's where sort of, okay, yeah, dark matter.

1318
01:20:39.743 --> 01:20:40.203
It makes sense.

1319
01:20:40.223 --> 01:20:43.844
There's a lot of other avenues of research that actually point to dark matter.

1320
01:20:43.884 --> 01:20:49.225
But this is one of the really cool ways of showing, yeah, there's got to be something there that we're not seeing.

1321
01:20:49.305 --> 01:20:53.188
And it's also, like, even for someone who's not as deep in this, it can be relatively intuitive.

1322
01:20:53.248 --> 01:20:53.708
Yeah, yeah.

1323
01:20:53.888 --> 01:20:56.049
And it's something that an undergrad can figure out, you know?

1324
01:20:56.209 --> 01:20:56.510
Right.

1325
01:20:56.590 --> 01:21:01.473
Using a shitty radio dish on the roof of Jadwin Hall.

1326
01:21:02.914 --> 01:21:07.957
That was one of my favorite, like, two weeks was actually doing this experiment and then writing the report.

1327
01:21:08.397 --> 01:21:08.958
Okay, so...

1328
01:21:09.598 --> 01:21:10.739
Now let's get back to the story.

1329
01:21:11.039 --> 01:21:11.799
How do we find these?

1330
01:21:11.819 --> 01:21:14.341
Well, we look at the hydrogen 21 centimeter line, right?

1331
01:21:14.821 --> 01:21:24.746
And the FAST radio telescope, which is the 500 meter aperture spherical telescope, in 2023, it found a region of space that looked kind of weird.

1332
01:21:25.066 --> 01:21:26.307
This is the radio telescope.

1333
01:21:26.347 --> 01:21:29.309
It's out in Guizhou, China, just north of Vietnam.

1334
01:21:29.749 --> 01:21:33.051
It looks kind of like Arecibo, which was out in Puerto Rico.

1335
01:21:33.091 --> 01:21:36.793
It got damaged by the hurricane and is no longer in operation.

1336
01:21:36.813 --> 01:21:39.174
But now China has something that's even better.

1337
01:21:39.574 --> 01:21:41.415
That pronunciation was pretty good.

1338
01:21:41.435 --> 01:21:42.495
Where did you learn that from?

1339
01:21:42.515 --> 01:21:44.436
I looked it up.

1340
01:21:44.516 --> 01:21:45.456
I looked it up earlier.

1341
01:21:47.377 --> 01:21:47.577
Yeah.

1342
01:21:47.897 --> 01:21:51.358
So they've got this telescope, the Fast Radio Telescope.

1343
01:21:51.458 --> 01:21:53.299
In 2023, it spots this object, okay?

1344
01:21:53.359 --> 01:21:53.539
Yes.

1345
01:21:53.799 --> 01:22:00.422
And this object has a bunch of 21 centimeter, 1420 hertz coming through.

1346
01:22:01.522 --> 01:22:05.043
And from all of the previous surveys, there's nothing starry there.

1347
01:22:05.344 --> 01:22:05.624
Right.

1348
01:22:05.944 --> 01:22:06.464
Okay?

1349
01:22:06.484 --> 01:22:08.985
So it's a patch of sky where we're getting a bunch of...

1350
01:22:10.197 --> 01:22:12.699
hydrogen emission, but there's no real stars there.

1351
01:22:12.719 --> 01:22:13.180
There's nothing there.

1352
01:22:13.200 --> 01:22:25.712
It's right next to another galaxy, the M94 group, and the recession velocity of this gas, so if you were to look at the redshift of this gas, it's very similar to the recession velocity of 304 kilometers per second

1353
01:22:26.523 --> 01:22:27.324
Of the galaxy.

1354
01:22:27.564 --> 01:22:31.888
So it's associated to that galaxy because they're both moving away from us at the same speed.

1355
01:22:32.088 --> 01:22:33.409
And they're both right next to each other.

1356
01:22:33.669 --> 01:22:35.390
So they've got to be sort of tied together.

1357
01:22:35.431 --> 01:22:35.591
Yes.

1358
01:22:35.691 --> 01:22:35.931
Right.

1359
01:22:36.331 --> 01:22:36.591
Okay.

1360
01:22:36.932 --> 01:22:39.334
So that's the first observational signature, right?

1361
01:22:39.994 --> 01:22:44.418
The second observational signature comes from the VLA, the very large array.

1362
01:22:44.518 --> 01:22:44.738
Yes.

1363
01:22:45.599 --> 01:22:46.600
This is very recent.

1364
01:22:46.760 --> 01:22:48.041
I think it came out last year.

1365
01:22:48.722 --> 01:22:53.946
It shows that the broadening of that hydrogen line...

1366
01:22:55.687 --> 01:23:03.909
is very close to what we would expect if that hydrogen was thermalized to that UV radiation that I was talking about in the reionization epoch.

1367
01:23:03.929 --> 01:23:04.729
Because imagine, right?

1368
01:23:04.989 --> 01:23:06.209
I've got a cloud of hydrogen.

1369
01:23:06.509 --> 01:23:07.049
It's hot.

1370
01:23:07.389 --> 01:23:13.110
And the temperature is right about at 10 to the 4 Kelvin, which is what we calculate the UV radiation to be back then.

1371
01:23:13.530 --> 01:23:19.732
And if the temperature is around that, then there's going to be some gas particles that are moving away from us, some gas particle moving towards us.

1372
01:23:20.032 --> 01:23:21.092
And the spread...

1373
01:23:21.792 --> 01:23:41.634
of that thermal radiation is going to be right around 12 kilometers per second if you calculate what the thermal radiation should be and that's exactly what we see the vla looks at that thing and sees that the spread is about 12 kilometers per second so again okay this is thermalized radiation yes from that realization epoch yes okay very good very good

1374
01:23:42.335 --> 01:23:52.322
And also, if you look at rotating dwarf galaxies, those dwarf galaxies have a thermal radiation of like 30 to 50 kilometers per second, much faster than what we see.

1375
01:23:52.622 --> 01:23:56.144
And this is where we get to the Astrophysical Journal letters paper that we're going to talk about.

1376
01:23:56.464 --> 01:23:59.806
The main story is this paper that came out very recently.

1377
01:24:00.247 --> 01:24:01.167
The first relic?

1378
01:24:01.187 --> 01:24:01.447
Yeah.

1379
01:24:02.408 --> 01:24:08.273
They're asking, is this cloud nine that we've been looking at for the past two or three years?

1380
01:24:08.333 --> 01:24:08.594
Yes.

1381
01:24:08.734 --> 01:24:13.378
Is this finally the thing that we had hypothesized in 2017?

1382
01:24:13.398 --> 01:24:19.784
And actually, some of the authors of this paper were the authors on that original paper that hypothesized the relic.

1383
01:24:20.064 --> 01:24:21.706
So this guy's been chasing after.

1384
01:24:21.786 --> 01:24:21.986
Yes.

1385
01:24:22.286 --> 01:24:24.167
A relic for like three or four years now.

1386
01:24:24.407 --> 01:24:26.827
And he's finally trying to figure out, is this it?

1387
01:24:26.987 --> 01:24:27.187
Yes.

1388
01:24:27.287 --> 01:24:34.609
And what he's done is use the Hubble Space Telescope to point it at that thing and say there are no stars here.

1389
01:24:34.809 --> 01:24:35.570
Right, right, right.

1390
01:24:35.630 --> 01:24:35.950
Okay?

1391
01:24:35.990 --> 01:24:36.150
Yes.

1392
01:24:36.530 --> 01:24:37.150
Unequivocally.

1393
01:24:37.170 --> 01:24:40.331
Because before we have like surveys and they might have missed something.

1394
01:24:40.711 --> 01:24:44.292
But here we've got a Hubble Space Telescope mission that is looking at this thing.

1395
01:24:44.312 --> 01:24:44.972
Right.

1396
01:24:45.092 --> 01:24:47.097
for a very long time, okay?

1397
01:24:47.558 --> 01:24:48.981
Almost five hours total.

1398
01:24:49.041 --> 01:24:50.925
So it had two 9,000-second...

1399
01:24:53.492 --> 01:24:56.333
exposures at that spot in the sky.

1400
01:24:56.753 --> 01:24:58.593
And it's looking at it with two different filters.

1401
01:24:58.933 --> 01:25:02.834
And those filters are optimized so that it looks for red giant branch stars.

1402
01:25:03.174 --> 01:25:08.695
Because if there's a dwarf galaxy in there, that dwarf galaxy is probably going to be old and metal poor.

1403
01:25:09.015 --> 01:25:11.556
So the brightest stars in there are going to be red giants.

1404
01:25:11.856 --> 01:25:12.076
Okay.

1405
01:25:12.416 --> 01:25:15.877
And the amount of exposure time that these guys used was,

1406
01:25:16.077 --> 01:25:19.501
was enough to see stars that are much fainter than those red giants.

1407
01:25:19.762 --> 01:25:20.863
So we're not going to miss it.

1408
01:25:20.983 --> 01:25:21.203
Right.

1409
01:25:21.464 --> 01:25:22.004
That's the point.

1410
01:25:22.184 --> 01:25:24.067
If there's any there, we're not going to miss it.

1411
01:25:24.087 --> 01:25:26.149
The threshold was high enough that it would have captured it.

1412
01:25:26.309 --> 01:25:26.970
It would have captured it.

1413
01:25:27.030 --> 01:25:29.273
It's like, oh, well, you didn't turn Cricket to 11.

1414
01:25:29.293 --> 01:25:29.813
No, no, no.

1415
01:25:29.853 --> 01:25:31.335
We stared at this thing for long enough.

1416
01:25:31.555 --> 01:25:33.037
If there was something there, we would have seen it.

1417
01:25:33.298 --> 01:25:35.120
And they only observed three sources.

1418
01:25:35.520 --> 01:25:36.921
That they detected in that region.

1419
01:25:37.261 --> 01:25:38.761
And then they said, okay, is three a lot?

1420
01:25:38.841 --> 01:25:42.083
Maybe those three stars are, you know, what can I say?

1421
01:25:42.243 --> 01:25:42.803
Is that a lot?

1422
01:25:42.863 --> 01:25:43.403
Is that a little?

1423
01:25:43.723 --> 01:25:52.627
Well, this is something that's very clever and something that people do in science all the time is they try to measure something and then they say, what could I see just by chance?

1424
01:25:53.207 --> 01:25:54.668
What is my background?

1425
01:25:54.788 --> 01:25:55.348
Okay.

1426
01:25:55.388 --> 01:26:01.250
So they looked and they measured the density of sources in blank regions of that image that are far away from cloud nine.

1427
01:26:01.650 --> 01:26:06.532
And what they found was the average background is about 3.7 for a similar region.

1428
01:26:06.952 --> 01:26:13.254
So even just by chance, the amount of stuff that I would see in something that's not there is about 3.7.

1429
01:26:13.314 --> 01:26:16.455
So the fact that I'm seeing three is kind of just a roll of the dice.

1430
01:26:16.475 --> 01:26:16.615
Yes.

1431
01:26:17.195 --> 01:26:17.575
You know?

1432
01:26:17.816 --> 01:26:18.276
Yes.

1433
01:26:18.376 --> 01:26:21.598
It's not out of...

1434
01:26:22.299 --> 01:26:23.760
It's not out of the ordinary.

1435
01:26:24.080 --> 01:26:27.623
The fact that there's three there is what all other background space looks like.

1436
01:26:27.723 --> 01:26:28.063
Exactly.

1437
01:26:28.083 --> 01:26:29.024
It's about three things there.

1438
01:26:29.044 --> 01:26:29.184
Yeah.

1439
01:26:29.584 --> 01:26:30.285
Yeah, exactly.

1440
01:26:30.325 --> 01:26:35.389
So if I were to just, like, look at a random patch in the sky, I'd see three things in that region.

1441
01:26:35.589 --> 01:26:39.191
But if there's a dwarf galaxy there, I should see a hell of a lot more than just three.

1442
01:26:39.311 --> 01:26:39.512
Yes.

1443
01:26:39.652 --> 01:26:39.852
Right?

1444
01:26:40.152 --> 01:26:43.454
They also simulated what it would look like if there was a galaxy there.

1445
01:26:47.397 --> 01:26:52.799
You see, okay, what if there's like this many, what if there's a dwarf galaxy that's this big?

1446
01:26:52.959 --> 01:26:53.159
Okay.

1447
01:26:53.199 --> 01:26:56.200
And they went all the way down to really small dwarf galaxy.

1448
01:26:56.340 --> 01:26:56.520
Yes.

1449
01:26:56.940 --> 01:26:59.100
And they said you would still be able to see something.

1450
01:26:59.221 --> 01:26:59.421
Yes.

1451
01:26:59.641 --> 01:26:59.901
Okay.

1452
01:27:00.041 --> 01:27:02.702
If I do the simulation, I'd be able to see something.

1453
01:27:02.782 --> 01:27:02.942
Yes.

1454
01:27:03.082 --> 01:27:03.602
But I'm not.

1455
01:27:03.802 --> 01:27:04.322
I'm only.

1456
01:27:04.662 --> 01:27:06.303
We're seeing three in real life.

1457
01:27:07.243 --> 01:27:11.464
If we simulate being very bright and very dim, we would see 25.

1458
01:27:11.644 --> 01:27:12.124
Yeah.

1459
01:27:12.244 --> 01:27:13.105
We'd see a lot more.

1460
01:27:13.365 --> 01:27:14.445
But we're seeing three.

1461
01:27:14.465 --> 01:27:14.605
Three.

1462
01:27:16.446 --> 01:27:41.094
so it's like there is nothing there guys yes yes yes yes there's nothing there and a lot of this is it's trying to like remove it's trying to one provide a repeatable path to say you can look at the same patch of sky yeah and you can do the same math calculations and it's not a red dwarf this that and the third because we've done it and you can repeat it and you would get to the same yeah yeah it'd be hard to get time on the hubble space telescope again to look at the same patch of sky fair

1463
01:27:41.294 --> 01:27:43.715
But, I mean, there's a ground-based telescope and things like that.

1464
01:27:43.775 --> 01:27:44.736
So you could do it.

1465
01:27:45.016 --> 01:27:55.421
And actually, one of the future things that you could do is maybe use the James Webb Space Telescope and look for that same patch of sky and get into an even deeper stellar mass limit, right?

1466
01:27:55.521 --> 01:27:59.503
Maybe we're not seeing, like, brown dwarves or, like, really cool stars, right?

1467
01:27:59.523 --> 01:28:00.003
Yes, yes.

1468
01:28:00.543 --> 01:28:02.563
That's something that the James Webb telescope could do.

1469
01:28:02.844 --> 01:28:06.984
Okay, so the next thing they did was derive the halo mass of this thing.

1470
01:28:07.445 --> 01:28:15.786
And this is actually kind of cool because usually when we want to derive the halo mass, the dark matter halo that's in a galaxy, what we look at is stars.

1471
01:28:16.046 --> 01:28:19.087
We say, okay, how fast is the star moving around?

1472
01:28:19.267 --> 01:28:19.467
Yes.

1473
01:28:19.587 --> 01:28:23.488
Based on that, I can calculate how much mass is inside the stellar orbit.

1474
01:28:23.548 --> 01:28:23.708
Yes.

1475
01:28:23.848 --> 01:28:36.338
And then from that, then I can extrapolate and say, okay, if there's this much mass inside the stellar orbit and the mass function of a galactic halo kind of falls off like this, then I can integrate over that entire volume.

1476
01:28:36.619 --> 01:28:40.582
And then I could say, okay, the total mass of the halo is something like this.

1477
01:28:41.142 --> 01:28:42.223
Here, I've got no stars.

1478
01:28:42.704 --> 01:28:43.264
Yeah.

1479
01:28:43.284 --> 01:28:43.725
So how do you...

1480
01:28:43.745 --> 01:28:45.166
So how do I... What am I going to do?

1481
01:28:45.626 --> 01:28:46.167
Right?

1482
01:28:46.207 --> 01:28:46.567
Yes.

1483
01:28:46.707 --> 01:28:51.071
So what they did was they went back to that hydrostatic equilibrium analogy and they said, okay...

1484
01:28:51.611 --> 01:28:58.294
If I've got a gas temperature that's 10 to the 4 and I do it, I can calculate the mass.

1485
01:28:58.614 --> 01:29:06.438
And the mass is somewhere close to 5 times 10 to the 9 solar masses, which is very close to the 10 to the 9.7 that they were showing earlier.

1486
01:29:07.238 --> 01:29:16.145
So they calculate this critical mass, and it's right at that threshold, which is, again, very good because that's the whole point of that theory of like there's this critical mass.

1487
01:29:16.186 --> 01:29:18.848
Now we've actually found this critical mass, and it matches up.

1488
01:29:19.148 --> 01:29:19.328
Yes.

1489
01:29:19.748 --> 01:29:20.349
It's unique.

1490
01:29:20.409 --> 01:29:24.192
And just to clarify, the point being it's this critical mass where it is –

1491
01:29:25.873 --> 01:29:34.120
not going to end up with stars forming because things collapse inwardly and it's not going to end up with dissipation because things are exiting because it's too hot.

1492
01:29:34.321 --> 01:29:34.861
It's balanced.

1493
01:29:34.901 --> 01:29:35.882
It's just balanced.

1494
01:29:36.022 --> 01:29:41.787
And we're observationally seeing something that is at that line where there should be that balance.

1495
01:29:42.027 --> 01:29:42.228
Which,

1496
01:29:42.948 --> 01:29:47.193
And that's inevitably like it kind of is all pointing to this could be the relic.

1497
01:29:47.213 --> 01:29:47.914
This could be the relic.

1498
01:29:47.934 --> 01:29:58.025
Because it's in the Goldilocks zone for this dark matter halo concept with no matter inside but still able to maintain structure without dissipating or expanding.

1499
01:29:58.205 --> 01:29:58.626
Exactly.

1500
01:29:58.666 --> 01:29:58.906
Okay.

1501
01:29:59.146 --> 01:29:59.627
Exactly.

1502
01:29:59.787 --> 01:30:00.087
Yeah.

1503
01:30:00.428 --> 01:30:02.931
And so now the question is how unique is this thing?

1504
01:30:03.411 --> 01:30:03.591
Right.

1505
01:30:04.052 --> 01:30:04.252
Right?

1506
01:30:04.452 --> 01:30:04.912
Right.

1507
01:30:05.293 --> 01:30:07.714
Because you're saying this is a new celestial object.

1508
01:30:07.775 --> 01:30:07.975
Yes.

1509
01:30:08.095 --> 01:30:09.076
That's a tall order.

1510
01:30:09.116 --> 01:30:09.296
Yes.

1511
01:30:09.456 --> 01:30:09.736
Okay?

1512
01:30:09.976 --> 01:30:14.600
So here what they've plotted is on the x-axis the stellar mass of the thing.

1513
01:30:14.860 --> 01:30:15.060
Yes.

1514
01:30:15.360 --> 01:30:17.882
And then on the y-axis is the hydrogen mass.

1515
01:30:18.223 --> 01:30:19.384
How much hydrogen does it have?

1516
01:30:19.904 --> 01:30:24.267
Most of the stuff, like the dwarf galaxies, normal galaxies, are way to the right.

1517
01:30:24.468 --> 01:30:25.248
The top to the right.

1518
01:30:25.288 --> 01:30:25.569
Yeah.

1519
01:30:25.589 --> 01:30:27.350
They're very big with a lot of hydrogen.

1520
01:30:27.370 --> 01:30:27.470
Yeah.

1521
01:30:27.530 --> 01:30:33.575
Yeah, because the point is, if you've got a lot of hydrogen, then usually you're going to have a bunch of stars.

1522
01:30:34.596 --> 01:30:34.856
Okay?

1523
01:30:34.996 --> 01:30:37.899
If you've got a lot of intergalactic hydrogen, usually you've got a bunch of stars.

1524
01:30:38.299 --> 01:30:41.522
Here, you don't have a lot of stars, but you've got a bunch of hydrogen.

1525
01:30:41.682 --> 01:30:42.843
That's why it's all the way to the left.

1526
01:30:43.063 --> 01:30:44.164
And there's nothing like it.

1527
01:30:44.884 --> 01:30:45.405
Right?

1528
01:30:45.565 --> 01:30:45.765
It is.

1529
01:30:45.845 --> 01:30:54.792
And for people who are listening, and we really do encourage you if you have the opportunity to watch the show when you can or even segments because the visuals really illustrate it.

1530
01:30:54.812 --> 01:30:55.373
Right?

1531
01:30:55.613 --> 01:30:57.394
This is like an order of magnitude.

1532
01:30:57.414 --> 01:31:02.776
Yeah, no, it's actually two orders of magnitude because the axes are on a log scale.

1533
01:31:03.077 --> 01:31:04.217
Ah, okay.

1534
01:31:04.257 --> 01:31:04.617
Yeah.

1535
01:31:04.717 --> 01:31:09.860
It is like so far away from anything else to the point of is it unique?

1536
01:31:09.880 --> 01:31:11.441
And it's like, well, it doesn't look at them.

1537
01:31:11.561 --> 01:31:12.741
Look, look, look, dude.

1538
01:31:12.841 --> 01:31:14.442
It's like there's nothing around it.

1539
01:31:15.263 --> 01:31:15.483
right?

1540
01:31:15.743 --> 01:31:15.983
Yeah.

1541
01:31:16.003 --> 01:31:20.047
This is a new type of object and it could be this relic that they've been trying to look for.

1542
01:31:20.087 --> 01:31:20.307
Yes.

1543
01:31:20.547 --> 01:31:20.688
Right.

1544
01:31:20.708 --> 01:31:20.848
Yes.

1545
01:31:20.868 --> 01:31:21.008
Yes.

1546
01:31:21.028 --> 01:31:21.128
Yes.

1547
01:31:21.148 --> 01:31:23.290
So future observations, what are you going to do?

1548
01:31:23.630 --> 01:31:28.955
James Webb space telescope, obviously try to find even cooler stars and really rule out that there's no stars there.

1549
01:31:28.995 --> 01:31:29.716
Yes.

1550
01:31:30.156 --> 01:31:31.597
The other one that I thought was really cool.

1551
01:31:31.637 --> 01:31:32.038
Interesting.

1552
01:31:32.058 --> 01:31:34.180
It was the deep H alpha imaging, right?

1553
01:31:34.640 --> 01:31:39.284
This is the idea of really honing in on that hydrogen line, because if the,

1554
01:31:40.105 --> 01:31:43.727
there's a bunch of hydrogen there and it's fluorescing, right?

1555
01:31:43.807 --> 01:31:49.251
Because it's still interacting with all of the radiation that's in the universe.

1556
01:31:49.611 --> 01:31:57.656
Then on the skin of that cloud, you should be able to see H alpha emission that's more prominent than let's say on the interior.

1557
01:31:57.736 --> 01:31:59.777
So you should see like a ring around that cloud.

1558
01:32:00.017 --> 01:32:02.198
If you really stare at it for long enough, right?

1559
01:32:02.378 --> 01:32:07.822
And from that, you could maybe figure out the substructure of that cloud and how that hydrogen is like,

1560
01:32:08.482 --> 01:32:11.204
moving around, let's say, or like really clumped together.

1561
01:32:11.224 --> 01:32:20.369
Because you would map the outside, and because you then have ideas of how motion and things move in space, then you can sort of project in simulations.

1562
01:32:20.509 --> 01:32:23.591
How would you end up with this based on some of the composition?

1563
01:32:23.631 --> 01:32:25.352
Exactly, based on all the stuff that's around.

1564
01:32:25.732 --> 01:32:30.555
And you can figure out the ionization rate of that hydrogen and the gas density profile.

1565
01:32:30.915 --> 01:32:32.996
The other cool thing is there's a new...

1566
01:32:34.077 --> 01:32:36.580
Array coming up, the Square Kilometer Array.

1567
01:32:36.700 --> 01:32:37.081
Oh, yes.

1568
01:32:37.101 --> 01:32:39.503
It's going to be in Australia, and it's going to be in South Africa.

1569
01:32:39.844 --> 01:32:42.507
It's set to come online in 2027.

1570
01:32:42.807 --> 01:32:44.009
This is an artist's rendition.

1571
01:32:44.029 --> 01:32:44.930
They haven't made these yet.

1572
01:32:45.130 --> 01:32:45.390
Okay?

1573
01:32:45.731 --> 01:32:47.072
But it's going to be massive.

1574
01:32:47.092 --> 01:32:47.473
This is very big.

1575
01:32:47.513 --> 01:32:48.474
There's going to be a bunch.

1576
01:32:48.494 --> 01:32:50.055
It's going to be VLA on steroids.

1577
01:32:50.075 --> 01:32:51.357
This is, like, way bigger than VLA.

1578
01:32:51.457 --> 01:32:57.365
Yeah, it's going to be the very large array, but very, very, very large array, the square kilometer array.

1579
01:32:57.665 --> 01:33:00.528
And it's expected to detect thousands of these relics.

1580
01:33:00.849 --> 01:33:08.338
So if we can really hone in on how to find a relic using this one that we found, then we could transform the study of...

1581
01:33:09.019 --> 01:33:32.483
these into a statistical science rather than it's a one-off deal this kind of maps conceptually onto the idea of the our previous story where the string theorists created the framework that then was very easily able to be applied to biology in a new category with new data this is same same yeah this is same same not different different yeah but the idea that past work is helping to lower the barrier yeah and that's always something that science does right past work is always good for

1582
01:33:33.523 --> 01:33:33.983
The future.

1583
01:33:34.403 --> 01:33:36.724
We love to see Compounding Valley.

1584
01:33:36.844 --> 01:33:37.964
This was great.

1585
01:33:38.044 --> 01:33:39.164
I thought this was very cool.

1586
01:33:39.205 --> 01:33:40.045
This was very cool.

1587
01:33:40.125 --> 01:33:51.368
And we are going to have our call out for those who have listened to what has been one of our most tightly run pods, especially with our new season two setup.

1588
01:33:51.388 --> 01:33:52.708
This was great for episode two.

1589
01:33:53.168 --> 01:33:56.709
If you've listened this far and you've stayed, it's helpful for us to know.

1590
01:33:57.049 --> 01:33:59.310
So the comment of those for those who stayed is...

1591
01:34:01.111 --> 01:34:08.116
what do you think the reason is why this was named Cloud9 or any other Cloud9 related puns?

1592
01:34:08.136 --> 01:34:10.358
Yeah, because I don't know why it was named Cloud9.

1593
01:34:10.398 --> 01:34:10.819
We don't know.

1594
01:34:10.919 --> 01:34:15.763
And actually, one thing I do want to shout out is a friend of the pod, Daniel Gilman.

1595
01:34:15.843 --> 01:34:16.063
Yes.

1596
01:34:16.083 --> 01:34:17.744
I actually asked him about this story.

1597
01:34:17.764 --> 01:34:18.045
Yeah.

1598
01:34:18.245 --> 01:34:21.768
And he connected me with Julio, who's one of the...

1599
01:34:22.428 --> 01:34:46.574
authors of this paper and we had a really quick email exchange where i had some questions about some of the stuff that was said on this so you know thank you guys for actually indulging and like giving me a little bit of your time because i know you guys are busy trying to figure out what dark matter is and all this stuff but very cool paper julio yes yes and thank you for the work and hopefully if you take a listen to it we did it justice

1600
01:34:46.854 --> 01:34:48.015
Yes, let us know.

1601
01:34:48.355 --> 01:34:57.141
If not, always send over a correction for us, which brings up our next section, which is going to be corrections from last episode.

1602
01:34:57.241 --> 01:35:02.324
Yeah, these aren't that egregious, but, you know, as always, we try to stay true to who we are.

1603
01:35:02.484 --> 01:35:04.846
So if we do make mistakes, we do want to shout them out.

1604
01:35:05.246 --> 01:35:06.047
Okay, first one.

1605
01:35:06.567 --> 01:35:08.950
Not a science mistake, more of a literature mistake.

1606
01:35:09.291 --> 01:35:09.952
I said that...

1607
01:35:10.272 --> 01:35:16.861
I was quoting Julius Caesar, the famous Shakespeare play, and I said that the friends Romans countrymen lend me your ears...

1608
01:35:18.073 --> 01:35:22.194
And also, you know, but Brutus was an honorable man, and they're all honorable men.

1609
01:35:22.295 --> 01:35:25.056
I said that was Augustus, a.k.a.

1610
01:35:25.176 --> 01:35:25.756
Octavius.

1611
01:35:26.316 --> 01:35:30.157
No, that was a speech by Mark Antony at Caesar's funeral.

1612
01:35:30.337 --> 01:35:30.537
Yes.

1613
01:35:30.838 --> 01:35:37.040
And it's an amazing speech because that's the speech that finally convinces all of Romans that Brutus is actually a bad guy.

1614
01:35:37.400 --> 01:35:39.341
And maybe killing Caesar was not a good thing.

1615
01:35:39.461 --> 01:35:40.161
Yeah.

1616
01:35:41.342 --> 01:35:44.203
The second, this is more of not really a correction.

1617
01:35:44.243 --> 01:35:45.744
This is kind of an interesting tidbit.

1618
01:35:45.784 --> 01:36:04.452
I was talking to my friend Alan Southworth who works in energy in California, and he was actually telling me that energy markets might be an exception to the square root law because energy markets don't really work the same way that commodities markets or stock markets or crypto markets work because –

1619
01:36:05.660 --> 01:36:09.065
The demand is like not elastic at all.

1620
01:36:09.365 --> 01:36:11.808
Like the price and demand stuff is not elastic at all.

1621
01:36:11.828 --> 01:36:12.669
Because imagine, right?

1622
01:36:13.030 --> 01:36:16.875
Let's say that like there's a demand for electricity at a certain rate.

1623
01:36:17.215 --> 01:36:20.720
Like we're offering to buy electricity at a certain rate.

1624
01:36:22.282 --> 01:36:36.387
At that rate, it might only be feasible for certain electricity producers to meet that demand because it could be wind or solar or things like that because turning on additional wind turbines is not really that hard.

1625
01:36:36.447 --> 01:36:36.927
Right, right, right.

1626
01:36:37.187 --> 01:36:44.650
On the other hand, turning on like nuclear or turning on natural gas, you've got to buy a bunch of natural gas to turn something on, right?

1627
01:36:44.910 --> 01:36:45.130
So –

1628
01:36:46.010 --> 01:36:50.434
So it's not so trivial to just be like, oh, you need this much amount of electricity.

1629
01:36:50.494 --> 01:36:53.717
Let me just go turn on my gas burner.

1630
01:36:54.438 --> 01:36:58.081
So there, that square root law might not actually work.

1631
01:36:58.321 --> 01:37:00.143
So it might not be truly universal.

1632
01:37:00.243 --> 01:37:00.883
Universal.

1633
01:37:01.044 --> 01:37:06.849
And that's something that the Tokyo Stock Exchange might not actually account for, which is what that paper was.

1634
01:37:06.869 --> 01:37:10.012
That paper was very specifically for the Tokyo Stock Exchange.

1635
01:37:10.052 --> 01:37:10.232
Right.

1636
01:37:10.652 --> 01:37:13.754
Perhaps it's different for these other types of markets.

1637
01:37:13.934 --> 01:37:16.496
Great, great insight and note from Friend of the Pod.

1638
01:37:16.536 --> 01:37:16.736
Yeah.

1639
01:37:16.976 --> 01:37:28.124
And then the final one was I did say that there was a Japanese satellite that took that photo of being in between the sun and the earth, taking that photo of the moon coming in between and crashing it.

1640
01:37:28.184 --> 01:37:28.964
That's not actually true.

1641
01:37:28.984 --> 01:37:32.547
That's from the Deep Space Climate Observatory, which is a NASA satellite.

1642
01:37:32.887 --> 01:37:34.548
So we want to give NASA its due credit.

1643
01:37:34.668 --> 01:37:36.670
That was NASA, not the Japanese.

1644
01:37:36.690 --> 01:37:37.310
As always.

1645
01:37:37.410 --> 01:37:38.070
The Americans.

1646
01:37:38.150 --> 01:37:38.391
Yeah.

1647
01:37:38.631 --> 01:37:38.991
We're doing it.

1648
01:37:39.011 --> 01:37:45.034
Whenever something good, really good, or really bad is happening, a reasonable response is the Americans.

1649
01:37:47.075 --> 01:37:47.716
Yep.

1650
01:37:48.136 --> 01:37:49.377
So those are the three corrections.

1651
01:37:49.397 --> 01:37:50.117
Three corrections.

1652
01:37:50.637 --> 01:37:54.239
And just as a quick reminder, we love comments.

1653
01:37:54.279 --> 01:37:56.100
We love seeing the back and forth and discussion.

1654
01:37:56.701 --> 01:37:57.441
Keep commenting.

1655
01:37:57.481 --> 01:37:57.961
Keep sharing.

1656
01:37:58.001 --> 01:38:01.203
If you work in a lab, bring it into your next lab meeting.

1657
01:38:01.784 --> 01:38:02.984
Just play them a snippet.

1658
01:38:03.465 --> 01:38:04.285
People will love it.

1659
01:38:04.585 --> 01:38:06.006
You're going to sound great and amazing.

1660
01:38:06.546 --> 01:38:31.372
so we appreciate the sharing we're trying to fight the billionaire algorithms as best that we can and we're trying to provide some mental health benefits to the people of the world by stretching out some of those neurons getting them exercised your feeds are full of enough random nonsense uh so those who tune in and listen to the full thing we really appreciate you again great episode today we started off

1661
01:38:32.350 --> 01:38:34.891
String theory applying to biological networks.

1662
01:38:34.911 --> 01:38:35.131
Yep.

1663
01:38:35.371 --> 01:38:36.911
That was a nice crossover episode.

1664
01:38:36.931 --> 01:38:40.072
It's like when Power Rangers went on whatever thing you learned.

1665
01:38:40.092 --> 01:38:44.213
The Power Rangers from space hooked up with the Power Rangers from Mighty Morphin.

1666
01:38:44.253 --> 01:38:45.773
Yeah.

1667
01:38:45.873 --> 01:38:46.713
Great first story.

1668
01:38:46.733 --> 01:38:47.714
We did our rundown.

1669
01:38:47.994 --> 01:38:49.534
We had some fascinating tidbits.

1670
01:38:50.334 --> 01:38:52.595
Jellyfish sleep, even though they don't have a brain.

1671
01:38:52.635 --> 01:38:53.415
Yeah, that's a cool one.

1672
01:38:53.435 --> 01:38:55.155
And it's because it damages your DNA.

1673
01:38:55.856 --> 01:39:01.677
And we may have found a genuinely new celestial object in Cloud 9.

1674
01:39:02.737 --> 01:39:03.178
More soon.

1675
01:39:03.778 --> 01:39:04.399
We shall see.

1676
01:39:04.619 --> 01:39:05.299
We shall see.

1677
01:39:05.439 --> 01:39:12.305
A great spectrum of institutions with papers in Nature Communications, Nature, and the Astrophysical Journals.

1678
01:39:13.567 --> 01:39:22.134
I'm your host, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, who is off-center in this broadcast.

1679
01:39:22.154 --> 01:39:24.156
So we'll make sure that he's more set.

1680
01:39:24.196 --> 01:39:25.817
I'm sure someone's going to say some shit.

1681
01:39:26.038 --> 01:39:27.999
Oh, why are you leaning into the camera?

1682
01:39:28.019 --> 01:39:29.360
Can't we get the camera angle centered?

1683
01:39:29.440 --> 01:39:32.503
Yeah, you can't do anything right.

1684
01:39:32.543 --> 01:39:34.385
We really appreciate you all so much.

1685
01:39:34.685 --> 01:39:38.108
As always, this is from First Principles.
