WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.191 --> 00:00:00.812
Hello, Internet.

2
00:00:00.832 --> 00:00:07.719
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

3
00:00:08.159 --> 00:00:13.224
We have an action-packed full episode this week with three main stories.

4
00:00:13.584 --> 00:00:16.027
We're going to start off with the neuroscience of dreams.

5
00:00:16.427 --> 00:00:19.230
We're going to follow that up with the physics of protons and

6
00:00:19.490 --> 00:00:24.372
And then we're going to wrap up with some of the latest advancements in the fight against ALS.

7
00:00:24.953 --> 00:00:31.596
We are going to learn about science from the ground up today because, as you know, this is From First Principles.

8
00:00:46.632 --> 00:00:57.959
For our first story, we are going to get a little bit into what feels like science fiction here with interactive dream engineering as the subject.

9
00:00:57.999 --> 00:01:06.624
Apparently, we now have the ability to hack into people's dreams, influence and interact with them and help them solve problems later.

10
00:01:06.684 --> 00:01:11.887
This is from Northwestern University in the neuroscience of consciousness.

11
00:01:12.267 --> 00:01:14.929
And this story is fascinating to me.

12
00:01:15.309 --> 00:01:18.011
Yeah, this one's like pretty, pretty crazy, okay?

13
00:01:18.411 --> 00:01:25.176
I mean, we've all heard of the idea that, you know, if you're trying to solve a problem and you get stuck, sleep on it, right?

14
00:01:25.316 --> 00:01:27.077
That's the advice that we get a lot of times.

15
00:01:27.357 --> 00:01:30.780
There's been a lot of problem solving that's happened during sleep.

16
00:01:32.000 --> 00:01:38.465
Inception is in the public zeitgeist about like, you know, influencing dreams.

17
00:01:39.366 --> 00:01:42.608
And it turns out there's more truth to that

18
00:01:43.858 --> 00:01:44.999
than previously thought.

19
00:01:45.019 --> 00:01:45.780
That's so crazy.

20
00:01:45.840 --> 00:01:52.968
Like, we're getting into the science fiction realm where we are able to now influence with dreams, interact with them, and then help...

21
00:01:53.761 --> 00:01:59.986
the people who we interacted with in those dreams solve problems that they previously didn't solve before.

22
00:02:00.286 --> 00:02:00.826
It's unbelievable.

23
00:02:00.866 --> 00:02:02.127
It's, it's pretty insane, dude.

24
00:02:02.448 --> 00:02:14.697
And the scientific evidence for like a lot of this, like dreams influencing your reality the next day, it's been elusive and it's been challenging because, you know, we can't really systematically manipulate dreams.

25
00:02:15.468 --> 00:02:15.948
Until now.

26
00:02:16.789 --> 00:02:17.529
That's the idea.

27
00:02:17.629 --> 00:02:20.991
There's this new study by neuroscientists at Northwestern University.

28
00:02:21.491 --> 00:02:25.613
And what it does is validate the possibility of influencing dreams.

29
00:02:26.754 --> 00:02:40.521
And it's really supporting this theory that REM sleep, which is when dreams occur, that stage of sleep when dreams occur, it might actually be especially conducive to helping individuals come up with creative solutions to problems.

30
00:02:40.836 --> 00:02:42.117
This is so fascinating.

31
00:02:42.137 --> 00:02:45.900
I mean, even the idea of saying the phrase dream engineering.

32
00:02:46.020 --> 00:02:46.260
Yeah.

33
00:02:46.920 --> 00:02:49.022
No, that seems like something out of a Chris Nolan movie.

34
00:02:49.042 --> 00:02:49.382
Yeah, exactly.

35
00:02:49.402 --> 00:02:50.723
But now it's like actually real.

36
00:02:50.743 --> 00:02:51.183
Exactly.

37
00:02:51.223 --> 00:02:54.045
There's a science paper that's out, right?

38
00:02:54.125 --> 00:02:56.147
So as always, let's start with some of the history.

39
00:02:56.607 --> 00:03:03.952
Dreams have always been viewed as sacred, as this kind of psychological gateway into the subconscious mind.

40
00:03:04.252 --> 00:03:09.615
The Egyptians literally had sleep temples for sleep and incubation rituals.

41
00:03:09.995 --> 00:03:14.818
And they used to practice these in the ancient temples with the Egyptian deity Imhotep.

42
00:03:15.198 --> 00:03:16.099
Do you remember the mummy?

43
00:03:16.519 --> 00:03:19.040
Yeah, exactly.

44
00:03:19.100 --> 00:03:24.121
And then, I mean, it's been it's been a thing of research for psychoanalysis for quite a while.

45
00:03:24.141 --> 00:03:25.762
Sidman Freud was really into it.

46
00:03:26.102 --> 00:03:27.542
Carl Jung was really into it.

47
00:03:28.023 --> 00:03:36.285
But the modern birth really came in 1953 when Aserinsky and Kleitman discovered something called rapid eye movement sleep.

48
00:03:36.725 --> 00:03:40.827
OK, and they linked that sleep stage to vivid dreams.

49
00:03:41.607 --> 00:03:45.348
What was really the breakthrough here is we didn't have a subjective experience.

50
00:03:47.057 --> 00:03:50.501
telling of, oh, I dreamed, and that was the stage that I dreamt.

51
00:03:50.881 --> 00:03:59.931
Because what they could do is they could hook up electrodes onto the skull, and they could actually see signatures of

52
00:04:01.170 --> 00:04:05.052
dreaming that were not based on subjective reporting, right?

53
00:04:05.072 --> 00:04:05.212
I see.

54
00:04:05.352 --> 00:04:07.693
You don't have to wake up and be like, hey, I was dreaming.

55
00:04:08.233 --> 00:04:10.914
You could look at the eye movement during sleep.

56
00:04:10.954 --> 00:04:16.517
There's a certain part of sleep called REM sleep, rapid eye movement sleep, where your eyes move very rapidly.

57
00:04:16.997 --> 00:04:24.520
During that part, the electrophysiological signature from the EEG electrodes is actually very distinct compared to other parts of sleep.

58
00:04:24.840 --> 00:04:28.082
So it was this real actual stage in the sleep cycle.

59
00:04:28.582 --> 00:04:33.806
It happens about 25% of total sleep, happens about 90 minutes after you fall asleep.

60
00:04:34.306 --> 00:04:40.290
And then during REM, what we've realized over the years of doing research on it, the brain is highly active.

61
00:04:40.750 --> 00:04:42.812
It actually resembles the waking state.

62
00:04:42.912 --> 00:04:57.762
If you look at the EFIS signature, like the electrode signature of what these little electrodes on our skull picks up, and then you look at other stages of sleep versus when we're awake and we're looking at stuff and thinking about stuff...

63
00:04:59.265 --> 00:05:07.427
The electrophysiological signature during REM sleep is more similar to wakefulness than it is to other stages of sleep.

64
00:05:08.167 --> 00:05:08.387
Right?

65
00:05:08.647 --> 00:05:11.908
So when we're dreaming, it's almost like the brain is kind of awake.

66
00:05:12.728 --> 00:05:14.229
But obviously, we're still asleep.

67
00:05:14.469 --> 00:05:18.850
And it's been this really cool enigma to try to figure out.

68
00:05:19.390 --> 00:05:27.712
So the starting point was you had this objective experience from people saying, while I was sleeping, I saw stuff.

69
00:05:28.032 --> 00:05:28.172
Yeah.

70
00:05:28.192 --> 00:05:28.292
Yeah.

71
00:05:29.012 --> 00:05:48.597
But we did not at the time have a way to quantitatively track with instruments that state that people were describing that they were having until in this historical context we used electrodes and tracking the brain activity to see and mapping it with this rapid eye movement sleep that –

72
00:05:49.157 --> 00:05:56.502
There is a state while you are asleep where the brain activity looks very akin to a waking state.

73
00:05:56.522 --> 00:05:56.742
Yeah.

74
00:05:56.863 --> 00:05:58.844
And that maps to when people are now happy.

75
00:05:58.884 --> 00:06:05.989
You can now map the data with the subjective reporting from those sleeping and kind of map those two together.

76
00:06:06.349 --> 00:06:06.810
Exactly.

77
00:06:06.910 --> 00:06:09.091
And then let's go even further, right?

78
00:06:09.171 --> 00:06:09.291
Okay.

79
00:06:09.311 --> 00:06:12.254
So now we figured out that there is definitely such a thing as REM sleep.

80
00:06:12.374 --> 00:06:12.574
Yes.

81
00:06:12.634 --> 00:06:13.975
And that's probably when you're dreaming.

82
00:06:14.095 --> 00:06:14.315
Yes.

83
00:06:14.655 --> 00:06:14.935
Now...

84
00:06:15.876 --> 00:06:22.603
What if we wanted to talk about dream recall and how that affects how you solve problems the next day or day to day, right?

85
00:06:22.703 --> 00:06:22.883
Right.

86
00:06:22.923 --> 00:06:24.625
That's still correlational still, right?

87
00:06:24.685 --> 00:06:27.488
Because the subject has to recall the dream.

88
00:06:28.149 --> 00:06:36.657
And then there's some correlation between him recalling certain dreams and the creativity that he has the next day.

89
00:06:37.338 --> 00:06:41.602
There's some correlation between sleep deprivation and insight.

90
00:06:41.963 --> 00:06:43.424
Like there's a decorrelation really.

91
00:06:43.444 --> 00:06:49.510
It's like because like the more you're sleep deprived, the less you're really going to do novel stuff the next day.

92
00:06:49.730 --> 00:06:52.293
You need your sleep in order to actually fully function.

93
00:06:52.613 --> 00:06:54.054
But these are all correlational, right?

94
00:06:54.074 --> 00:06:55.396
You can't do a causal –

95
00:06:56.586 --> 00:06:59.088
Meaning like this caused that.

96
00:06:59.189 --> 00:06:59.689
Exactly.

97
00:06:59.709 --> 00:06:59.929
Yeah.

98
00:06:59.949 --> 00:07:01.711
It's always just observational studies.

99
00:07:02.292 --> 00:07:13.743
And this breakthrough, which was in the neuroscience of consciousness, this is a causation study between your dreams and your ability to solve problems.

100
00:07:14.303 --> 00:07:17.546
So before we were just saying these two things are happening at the same time.

101
00:07:17.666 --> 00:07:18.847
And so we think they're related.

102
00:07:18.947 --> 00:07:19.128
Yeah.

103
00:07:19.448 --> 00:07:21.410
But we didn't really see the bridge between the two things.

104
00:07:21.430 --> 00:07:21.570
Yeah.

105
00:07:21.590 --> 00:07:21.730
Yeah.

106
00:07:21.770 --> 00:07:21.950
Yeah.

107
00:07:21.970 --> 00:07:24.292
We weren't able to literally like influence the dreams.

108
00:07:24.332 --> 00:07:25.353
And now this is what's happening.

109
00:07:25.373 --> 00:07:25.854
That's fascinating.

110
00:07:25.874 --> 00:07:25.994
Okay.

111
00:07:26.014 --> 00:07:26.214
Yeah.

112
00:07:26.394 --> 00:07:26.654
Okay.

113
00:07:26.674 --> 00:07:27.235
This is getting good.

114
00:07:27.295 --> 00:07:28.076
It's pretty insane.

115
00:07:28.116 --> 00:07:28.316
Yes.

116
00:07:28.436 --> 00:07:31.699
So let's talk about a little bit about cognitive psychology.

117
00:07:31.719 --> 00:07:31.839
Okay.

118
00:07:32.019 --> 00:07:37.341
OK, it's divided into two domains when when it comes to creative problem solving.

119
00:07:37.681 --> 00:07:39.522
There's really like two ways of thinking about it.

120
00:07:39.542 --> 00:07:44.443
There's the convergent thinking, which is the idea that it's like super brute force and logical.

121
00:07:44.803 --> 00:07:54.206
If I want to solve a problem, I start with all of my parameters and then I sort of logically deduce how to get to the solution.

122
00:08:02.418 --> 00:08:07.561
look at relationships and try to like creatively figure out how to solve a problem.

123
00:08:07.941 --> 00:08:12.923
Right now with the divergent thinking, there's something called a spreading activation model.

124
00:08:13.263 --> 00:08:20.807
The idea is that your memory is represented like a giant graph of like a graph, like, you know, the internet is a graph.

125
00:08:20.847 --> 00:08:24.709
We've talked about this before on the podcast, the idea that like on the internet, you're,

126
00:08:25.229 --> 00:08:30.431
Each web page is linked to other web pages, so you have web pages and you have links between them.

127
00:08:30.551 --> 00:08:31.671
That's what defines a graph.

128
00:08:32.071 --> 00:08:34.212
Stuff and then links between that stuff.

129
00:08:34.512 --> 00:08:42.655
Now, with the spreading activation model, our semantic memory can be thought of as a complex graph because there's nodes, which are the concepts.

130
00:08:42.955 --> 00:08:44.155
Like, for example, dog.

131
00:08:44.555 --> 00:08:46.896
Dog can be furry.

132
00:08:47.076 --> 00:08:48.037
It can be friend.

133
00:08:48.177 --> 00:08:48.837
It can be...

134
00:08:49.517 --> 00:09:13.445
foe if you're out hiking and you see a wolf like there's all these different relationships that you can go from dog all the way to is it an enemy or is it a friend is it my own dog and then from there you can start connecting nodes so you can imagine you start with a dog and then you have that idea of a dog and from a dog you can now go to friend you can go to does he want does he want to play does like all the stuff that i would think about

135
00:09:13.925 --> 00:09:15.626
when a dog comes up in my memory, right?

136
00:09:15.826 --> 00:09:16.986
There's all these connections.

137
00:09:17.066 --> 00:09:20.847
And the idea of the spreading activation model is that you start with some connection.

138
00:09:22.008 --> 00:09:28.650
And then you, if you want to solve a problem around that connection, you start exploring all the stuff that's related to that.

139
00:09:29.070 --> 00:09:32.171
And you try to figure out what's the best path to get to your solution.

140
00:09:32.511 --> 00:09:37.432
So as an example, let's say I'm afraid of dogs, which I'm not because I have three of them.

141
00:09:37.612 --> 00:09:39.633
But let's say in this example, I'm afraid of dogs.

142
00:09:39.693 --> 00:09:42.214
So when I then see a dog,

143
00:09:44.032 --> 00:09:54.421
I'm immediately now making nearby connections, which in this context might be fear, I need to run, defensive MMA, how to kick.

144
00:09:54.981 --> 00:09:59.906
Again, only because in my head, in this specific context, I'm afraid of dogs.

145
00:10:00.206 --> 00:10:06.071
And so I will be thinking of these associated concepts in my own head that are related to dogs.

146
00:10:06.571 --> 00:10:11.817
a dog, and then most adjacently fear, and then all the things that come from the... And all the stuff that comes around that, right?

147
00:10:12.138 --> 00:10:12.658
Exactly.

148
00:10:13.059 --> 00:10:19.706
And so now let's try to take this network architecture and apply it to problem solving, right?

149
00:10:20.007 --> 00:10:23.591
When you're in the waking state, what ends up happening is, suppose you want to solve a problem...

150
00:10:26.161 --> 00:10:32.285
Based on the brain state, what ends up happening is you start with the problem statement and you try to get to the solution.

151
00:10:32.885 --> 00:10:38.548
During the waking state, my activation of all these different concepts is tightly regulated.

152
00:10:38.969 --> 00:10:39.229
Okay?

153
00:10:39.509 --> 00:10:42.391
Because there's a lot of inhibition that goes on.

154
00:10:42.671 --> 00:10:46.713
There's these inhibitory neurons that are firing a lot during my wake state.

155
00:10:47.053 --> 00:10:51.856
And so only strong, obvious connections are actually the ones that are going to pop up.

156
00:10:52.277 --> 00:10:52.557
Okay?

157
00:10:52.877 --> 00:10:54.198
And so I might get stuck.

158
00:10:54.838 --> 00:11:02.883
In like a fixation where I'm trying to like solve a problem and I get stuck while trying to find the solution.

159
00:11:03.163 --> 00:11:05.464
And it's really hard for me to get out of that.

160
00:11:05.964 --> 00:11:08.005
And I've had this personally in my research.

161
00:11:08.285 --> 00:11:12.668
Like when I'm trying to solve something during my work or during my research, it's like.

162
00:11:14.419 --> 00:11:18.480
I work on it for like two hours and I'm stuck and I don't find a path forward.

163
00:11:19.000 --> 00:11:20.320
And that's when a lot of people stay.

164
00:11:20.400 --> 00:11:21.361
Why don't you just sleep on it?

165
00:11:22.741 --> 00:11:24.021
The idea is you have a problem.

166
00:11:24.201 --> 00:11:26.162
Imagine it like traffic.

167
00:11:26.202 --> 00:11:27.682
Or you're trying to drive through Los Angeles.

168
00:11:27.722 --> 00:11:27.942
Yeah.

169
00:11:28.242 --> 00:11:29.743
But 50% of the roads are closed.

170
00:11:29.843 --> 00:11:30.063
Yeah.

171
00:11:30.123 --> 00:11:30.963
In your waking state.

172
00:11:31.183 --> 00:11:31.323
Yeah.

173
00:11:31.363 --> 00:11:33.243
And so you can't take the 405.

174
00:11:33.263 --> 00:11:34.544
You can't take the 101.

175
00:11:34.904 --> 00:11:36.244
That's a really good analogy.

176
00:11:36.484 --> 00:11:39.425
And so it's going to – you can't really – it's hard to get to where you need to go.

177
00:11:39.485 --> 00:11:41.205
You try to go the back roads.

178
00:11:41.425 --> 00:11:43.186
And you end up somewhere in El Segundo.

179
00:11:43.306 --> 00:11:44.006
Yeah.

180
00:11:45.066 --> 00:11:45.347
Okay.

181
00:11:45.867 --> 00:11:46.307
Exactly.

182
00:11:46.708 --> 00:11:50.670
So maybe dreaming could fix something like this, right?

183
00:11:50.770 --> 00:11:50.990
Yes.

184
00:11:51.171 --> 00:11:55.253
And the analogy that I want to make is actually a physics analogy, something called annealing.

185
00:11:55.874 --> 00:11:56.114
Okay?

186
00:11:56.955 --> 00:12:05.861
Whenever we have a material that is in a certain state and we want to get it to a new thermodynamic equilibrium, what you can do is you can raise the temperature.

187
00:12:05.881 --> 00:12:06.221
Okay.

188
00:12:06.241 --> 00:12:06.461
Okay.

189
00:12:06.661 --> 00:12:09.404
When you raise the temperature, you're raising the noise, right?

190
00:12:10.024 --> 00:12:14.589
And so in a physics thing, suppose I've got a potential landscape, right, which is hills and valleys.

191
00:12:15.270 --> 00:12:20.135
My state is stuck in a local valley, but it's not like the global minimum.

192
00:12:20.255 --> 00:12:20.435
Yes.

193
00:12:20.495 --> 00:12:20.755
Right?

194
00:12:21.056 --> 00:12:26.321
It's stuck in some local solution, and I want to get to the global minimum, which is the actual solution.

195
00:12:26.361 --> 00:12:26.581
Yes.

196
00:12:26.842 --> 00:12:27.222
Yes.

197
00:12:27.402 --> 00:12:33.326
If the temperature is too small, my state is only going to really jiggle around that local solution.

198
00:12:33.627 --> 00:12:44.234
But if I raise the temperature, then my state is able to explore a lot of different avenues because the jiggle has increased.

199
00:12:44.815 --> 00:12:46.736
That's the idea of annealing, right?

200
00:12:47.557 --> 00:12:47.737
And...

201
00:12:49.378 --> 00:13:05.824
What people have started to figure out is perhaps the biological function of sleep and specifically dreaming is to raise the parameter of your neural network such that you start exploring different spaces in your brain.

202
00:13:05.924 --> 00:13:06.144
Yes.

203
00:13:06.204 --> 00:13:06.464
Okay?

204
00:13:06.664 --> 00:13:09.666
This happens a lot of times in, like, artificial neural networks.

205
00:13:09.746 --> 00:13:09.966
Yes.

206
00:13:09.986 --> 00:13:18.349
Like, when you're trying to code up an LLM or, like, some kind of AI, a lot of times it's going to get stuck in a local minima.

207
00:13:19.717 --> 00:13:26.742
And what you kind of do is you like increase – there's like various tricks that you can do to make it not get stuck in that local minima.

208
00:13:27.022 --> 00:13:28.703
One of the ways is to increase the temperature.

209
00:13:28.723 --> 00:13:31.665
So you increase the jump size in your gradient descent.

210
00:13:32.006 --> 00:13:41.012
The other thing you can do is introduce momentum so that if it's going in one direction, even if that's local minima, it's going to have enough to like jump over that energy barrier.

211
00:13:41.392 --> 00:13:44.214
And so the same things is sort of –

212
00:13:45.653 --> 00:13:47.274
a theory that's happening in brains.

213
00:13:47.635 --> 00:13:51.077
Now, is there like a neurological idea?

214
00:13:51.257 --> 00:13:55.821
Like, is there a mechanistic philosophy in our brain that we can actually point to here, right?

215
00:13:56.421 --> 00:13:57.142
It turns out there is.

216
00:13:57.162 --> 00:14:03.467
There's a lot of research on how this annealing phenomenon, this raising of temperature, is actually happening in our brain.

217
00:14:03.527 --> 00:14:14.636
So the REM sleep initiation... And just briefly, and just because I want to make sure I'm tracking, the way you described it earlier was when you're in the waking state, there are these tight...

218
00:14:15.356 --> 00:14:42.146
parameters around where to explore exactly the temperature is low the temperature is low and so we're basically trying to ideally we're trying to understand if you know is does dreaming loosen yes parameters the process we made we made the analogy that's akin to annealing in physics but the simple way of saying it is is turning off the guardrails a little bit to expand the ability to explore into other areas yes that's exactly right okay yeah

219
00:14:43.167 --> 00:14:44.428
That's effectively what's happening.

220
00:14:44.828 --> 00:14:50.633
And there is actually neurological studies that show that this is happening at a cellular level.

221
00:14:50.713 --> 00:14:50.973
Okay.

222
00:14:51.133 --> 00:14:52.474
At like the biochemistry level.

223
00:14:52.594 --> 00:14:52.774
Okay.

224
00:14:52.794 --> 00:14:59.780
So REM sleep initiation is driven by the activation of these REM-ON cells in our brain, okay?

225
00:15:00.120 --> 00:15:03.423
And they're located in like the LDT and the PPT.

226
00:15:03.463 --> 00:15:05.565
That's the lateral dorsal and...

227
00:15:06.285 --> 00:15:08.567
tegmental nuclei in the brainstem.

228
00:15:08.827 --> 00:15:15.652
Okay, the brainstem is the part that connects our brain to the spinal cord and makes sure our brain can talk to the rest of the body.

229
00:15:16.152 --> 00:15:23.498
Now, these cells, what they do is they flood the cortex and the hippocampus with massive amounts of acetylcholine.

230
00:15:24.198 --> 00:15:26.360
And the norepinephrine goes to zero.

231
00:15:26.400 --> 00:15:28.242
Norepinephrine is kind of an inhibition.

232
00:15:28.362 --> 00:15:30.824
Acetylcholine is an activation.

233
00:15:31.505 --> 00:15:31.785
Okay.

234
00:15:31.825 --> 00:15:34.808
During wakefulness, there's high amounts of norepinephrine.

235
00:15:35.188 --> 00:15:36.329
So you have a lot of inhibition.

236
00:15:36.349 --> 00:15:37.970
That's those guardrails that you were talking about.

237
00:15:38.251 --> 00:15:39.232
But during dreaming...

238
00:15:40.194 --> 00:15:40.734
That's gone.

239
00:15:41.515 --> 00:15:45.516
So now without that constraint, now these cortical networks have a really high temperature.

240
00:15:45.536 --> 00:15:46.637
They have a lot of noise.

241
00:15:46.997 --> 00:15:51.019
They're able to explore all the different possibilities, right?

242
00:15:51.399 --> 00:15:54.200
And then when we think about like dream phenomenology, right?

243
00:15:54.300 --> 00:16:03.164
All those like bizarre hallucinatory nature of the dreams, like when you're like flying or like random crap happens during dreaming.

244
00:16:03.244 --> 00:16:03.484
Yes.

245
00:16:03.584 --> 00:16:07.286
That might be a subjective experience that...

246
00:16:07.506 --> 00:16:08.487
Of this noise.

247
00:16:08.847 --> 00:16:09.107
I see.

248
00:16:09.167 --> 00:16:12.788
Of all of the brain sort of like getting really activated.

249
00:16:13.829 --> 00:16:23.093
So we're sort of seeing there's like the chemistry balance of what's happening in the brain changes in between waking and sleeping state with this acetylcholine.

250
00:16:23.653 --> 00:16:24.954
And what was the second one?

251
00:16:24.974 --> 00:16:26.274
It was norepinephrine.

252
00:16:26.294 --> 00:16:26.914
Norepinephrine.

253
00:16:27.174 --> 00:16:27.415
Yeah.

254
00:16:27.535 --> 00:16:30.036
The norepinephrine is the guardrails.

255
00:16:30.096 --> 00:16:30.916
Yeah, that's the guardrails.

256
00:16:30.936 --> 00:16:31.656
It's the guardrails.

257
00:16:31.996 --> 00:16:35.498
And the acetylcholine is what allows you to kind of explore a little bit more crazy.

258
00:16:35.618 --> 00:16:38.120
Yeah, and because that balance is off during REM sleep.

259
00:16:38.401 --> 00:16:40.042
Then it's like, whoa, what's over here?

260
00:16:40.202 --> 00:16:40.462
Yeah.

261
00:16:40.643 --> 00:16:41.343
Okay, very interesting.

262
00:16:41.363 --> 00:16:42.044
Oh, I'm flying.

263
00:16:42.204 --> 00:16:43.025
Oh, that's a monster.

264
00:16:43.165 --> 00:16:46.108
Like, crazy stuff during your dreams.

265
00:16:46.148 --> 00:16:50.031
And then it tracks because it makes sense for anyone who's had vivid dreams before, right?

266
00:16:50.051 --> 00:16:50.812
This idea that...

267
00:16:52.273 --> 00:16:57.135
you know, they do kind of exist in this weird realm a little bit beyond what is realistic.

268
00:16:57.355 --> 00:16:57.555
Yeah.

269
00:16:57.815 --> 00:17:00.076
But still feel grounded in realism.

270
00:17:00.136 --> 00:17:00.596
Exactly.

271
00:17:00.636 --> 00:17:00.837
Yeah.

272
00:17:00.917 --> 00:17:05.759
Because it's like synthesizing all the memories that you previously have, but now it's just on overdrive.

273
00:17:05.779 --> 00:17:07.839
It's like trying to connect to all this other kind of stuff.

274
00:17:08.280 --> 00:17:08.500
Right.

275
00:17:08.520 --> 00:17:09.200
Makes total sense.

276
00:17:09.720 --> 00:17:14.002
It's, it's, it's, it's pretty cool that we can go all the way down to the biochemistry level.

277
00:17:14.242 --> 00:17:14.482
Yeah.

278
00:17:14.682 --> 00:17:18.386
And like still see subjective effects all the way up.

279
00:17:19.387 --> 00:17:22.990
Neuroscience is like crazy and there's just so much more that we don't know about the brain.

280
00:17:23.030 --> 00:17:23.230
Right.

281
00:17:23.310 --> 00:17:26.913
And the fact that we're getting this far is already, I think, really, really cool.

282
00:17:27.454 --> 00:17:30.796
So now let's talk a little bit about information theory.

283
00:17:30.977 --> 00:17:31.217
Yes.

284
00:17:31.717 --> 00:17:32.318
And the brain.

285
00:17:32.698 --> 00:17:36.003
Okay, because the brain is an information chugging machine.

286
00:17:36.483 --> 00:17:42.392
There's this idea of entropy, which is the same kind of idea that we have in physics, the idea of randomness.

287
00:17:42.772 --> 00:17:44.815
How structured is the data in our brain?

288
00:17:45.817 --> 00:17:48.060
If we look at the ECG signals...

289
00:17:49.048 --> 00:17:54.874
which is the electrical signal that we would get if we were to put electrodes on our scalp, right?

290
00:17:55.495 --> 00:17:59.559
You can see that the wakefulness and the REM sleep look very, very similar.

291
00:17:59.679 --> 00:18:01.021
This is what I was alluding to before.

292
00:18:01.041 --> 00:18:01.702
Okay, got it.

293
00:18:01.722 --> 00:18:05.626
Slow wave sleep, which is deep sleep, that's the part where we're not dreaming.

294
00:18:06.126 --> 00:18:08.969
That's like super deep, nothing...

295
00:18:10.068 --> 00:18:13.451
There's no subjective experience so far as we can tell of that.

296
00:18:13.752 --> 00:18:17.335
And light sleep look very different compared to REM and wakefulness.

297
00:18:17.775 --> 00:18:23.320
REM is almost like we are wakeful, but our body is completely paralyzed.

298
00:18:23.680 --> 00:18:31.928
And the way that our body does that is our brain, our brainstem, which is the part that connects our brain to the spinal cord.

299
00:18:33.551 --> 00:18:35.433
completely blocks all the signal.

300
00:18:36.273 --> 00:18:36.754
Oh, okay.

301
00:18:37.054 --> 00:18:38.896
That's why we don't act out our dreams.

302
00:18:38.916 --> 00:18:41.979
Well, I mean, some people do, and they've got a little problem.

303
00:18:42.019 --> 00:18:43.760
We're acting out our dreams right now.

304
00:18:45.041 --> 00:18:46.663
I think we are, actually, on this show.

305
00:18:47.908 --> 00:18:50.109
We've talked about this for a very long time.

306
00:18:50.129 --> 00:18:50.529
Yeah.

307
00:18:50.909 --> 00:18:52.509
But you know what I mean, right?

308
00:18:52.810 --> 00:18:59.992
Like when we're dreaming and like we're doing all the crazy stuff, our brainstem is actually paralyzing the rest of our body.

309
00:19:00.432 --> 00:19:00.732
Okay.

310
00:19:01.032 --> 00:19:06.014
But the dream state itself looks very much like the wakeful state.

311
00:19:06.174 --> 00:19:06.914
That's something that I...

312
00:19:07.654 --> 00:19:10.116
Really want you to like imagine.

313
00:19:10.216 --> 00:19:11.938
And I think that's kind of crazy to think about.

314
00:19:11.958 --> 00:19:12.318
Yeah, it is.

315
00:19:12.558 --> 00:19:18.503
That like during dreaming, the brain is basically simulating reality of being awake.

316
00:19:18.823 --> 00:19:27.290
It's just we're not acting it out because the brainstem, which is the part in the back of our brain connecting our spinal cord to the brain, is just like, no, none of that signal is getting through.

317
00:19:27.550 --> 00:19:40.827
It's sort of like the brain is putting on a biological VR headset, utilizing your memory as the context by which it then projects imagery into your mind's eye while paralyzing your body movement.

318
00:19:40.867 --> 00:19:42.929
So you don't have to worry about running into your TV.

319
00:19:43.430 --> 00:19:45.032
Yeah, dude, that's exactly right.

320
00:19:45.312 --> 00:19:47.254
That's, I mean, it's exactly what it's doing.

321
00:19:47.294 --> 00:19:48.575
It's like a little VR.

322
00:19:48.735 --> 00:19:48.955
Yeah.

323
00:19:49.115 --> 00:19:52.438
That's, that's in our head that we're making up as we go along.

324
00:19:52.918 --> 00:19:55.440
So given all this, given all these constraints, right?

325
00:19:55.840 --> 00:19:56.061
Yes.

326
00:19:56.321 --> 00:19:59.744
Now let's talk about how do we do sleep engineering?

327
00:20:00.144 --> 00:20:00.364
Right.

328
00:20:00.604 --> 00:20:13.434
Cause now we've set the basis of why we can actually look at dreaming, uh, from a quantitative perspective and understand the numbers and see it and track it.

329
00:20:13.635 --> 00:20:13.855
Yeah.

330
00:20:14.595 --> 00:20:20.297
But now the question is how can we actually be more targeted, not just read.

331
00:20:20.317 --> 00:20:21.397
How do we read and write?

332
00:20:21.717 --> 00:20:21.998
Yes.

333
00:20:22.398 --> 00:20:22.658
Yes.

334
00:20:22.978 --> 00:20:26.399
How do we now write into the sleep itself, right?

335
00:20:26.699 --> 00:20:28.980
We want a deliberate manipulation process.

336
00:20:30.443 --> 00:20:33.024
Of our sleep content, right?

337
00:20:33.324 --> 00:20:38.345
And it's funny because in the waking state, we have a variety of things that manipulate our conscious waking experience.

338
00:20:38.365 --> 00:20:38.745
Yeah, yeah.

339
00:20:39.025 --> 00:20:43.766
So theoretically, I mean, just like loosely speaking, if there's such a matchy-matchy.

340
00:20:44.106 --> 00:20:46.746
Yeah, then it should be possible, right?

341
00:20:48.367 --> 00:20:52.047
That's where we get into something called targeted memory reactivation.

342
00:20:52.227 --> 00:20:52.407
Okay.

343
00:20:52.467 --> 00:20:52.707
Okay?

344
00:20:52.967 --> 00:20:55.148
This is something that's used not just in dream practice.

345
00:20:57.463 --> 00:20:58.944
but just sleep research in general.

346
00:20:59.084 --> 00:20:59.364
Okay.

347
00:20:59.564 --> 00:21:00.264
Here's the idea.

348
00:21:00.524 --> 00:21:00.784
Okay.

349
00:21:01.244 --> 00:21:03.025
So we pair learning.

350
00:21:03.805 --> 00:21:05.906
Let's say we're awake and we're learning something.

351
00:21:06.306 --> 00:21:09.627
We pair that learning with some kind of sensory signal.

352
00:21:10.067 --> 00:21:11.007
Usually it's a sound.

353
00:21:11.567 --> 00:21:12.707
So I'm reading something.

354
00:21:13.067 --> 00:21:13.988
I'm playing the piano.

355
00:21:14.308 --> 00:21:15.588
There's a sound that's playing.

356
00:21:16.148 --> 00:21:16.408
Okay.

357
00:21:16.888 --> 00:21:22.890
Now, when we go and sleep, that same sound is going to play while we sleep.

358
00:21:23.270 --> 00:21:23.770
Okay.

359
00:21:26.945 --> 00:21:42.473
Because that sound is associated with the thing that we were learning, and now we heard it while we slept, it's going to sort of give that extra oomph to consolidate that into the greater brain machinery.

360
00:21:43.033 --> 00:21:43.874
Does that make sense?

361
00:21:43.974 --> 00:21:44.474
It does.

362
00:21:44.534 --> 00:21:50.057
It's a signal that sort of triggers hardening of the concept of...

363
00:21:50.717 --> 00:21:52.938
From your waking state in your sleeping state.

364
00:21:53.158 --> 00:21:53.618
Exactly.

365
00:21:53.638 --> 00:21:53.878
Yeah.

366
00:21:53.918 --> 00:22:02.420
There's this external stimulus that's associated with the thing that you're trying to learn, either the task that you're trying to learn or the memory that you're trying to remember.

367
00:22:02.760 --> 00:22:06.801
And then when you trigger it during your sleep, it like doubles down.

368
00:22:07.181 --> 00:22:11.122
The neurons double down because they're getting a coincidence signal.

369
00:22:11.822 --> 00:22:12.103
You know?

370
00:22:12.503 --> 00:22:13.703
I wish I knew this when we were in school.

371
00:22:14.701 --> 00:22:19.006
Dude, I mean, there's a lot of cool research now that's doing this exactly right.

372
00:22:19.346 --> 00:22:25.272
Now, historically, this TMR, targeted memory reactivation, has focused on non-REM sleep.

373
00:22:25.352 --> 00:22:28.095
Okay, non-REM sleep is the slow wave sleep that we get.

374
00:22:28.115 --> 00:22:29.457
That's the deep sleep.

375
00:22:29.757 --> 00:22:31.979
And that is usually involved in memory consolidation.

376
00:22:31.999 --> 00:22:35.163
That's the idea of whatever short-term memory that I'm getting today is.

377
00:22:35.703 --> 00:22:41.707
whatever is salient and I need to store into long-term memory, that's what happens during this deep sleep.

378
00:22:42.147 --> 00:22:59.677
And so if I want to store certain things into long-term memory, what I can do is, or if I want to like have a skill that I really want to store into long-term memory, I can have this targeted memory reactivation and it's actually highly effective in 90 plus studies, this particular one by rash and other researchers,

379
00:23:00.489 --> 00:23:04.452
Authors have shown that this is like very much works.

380
00:23:05.052 --> 00:23:05.252
Okay.

381
00:23:05.393 --> 00:23:14.759
Like those who learn piano, for example, with an auditory stimulus, and then you reactivate the auditory stimulus during sleep, they're going to remember that piano sequence better.

382
00:23:15.140 --> 00:23:18.242
Like their motor neurons literally are going to be better the next day.

383
00:23:18.950 --> 00:23:31.753
So for all the coaches who used to say don't play music while we were training for soccer, have it be known that had you let us play our rap music and then we played it during our sleep.

384
00:23:32.493 --> 00:23:35.434
During the sleep, we would have won more games.

385
00:23:35.554 --> 00:23:36.234
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

386
00:23:36.274 --> 00:23:37.114
That's the big one, right?

387
00:23:37.134 --> 00:23:38.635
I'm being facetious a little bit here.

388
00:23:38.655 --> 00:23:38.795
Yeah.

389
00:23:40.275 --> 00:23:46.239
And so here in this particular study, what they're trying to do is break that barrier and not just go into non-REM sleep.

390
00:23:46.659 --> 00:23:51.301
They're trying to do targeted memory reactivation during dreaming.

391
00:23:52.022 --> 00:23:52.302
Okay?

392
00:23:53.482 --> 00:23:54.583
It gets a little tricky.

393
00:23:54.803 --> 00:23:55.063
Okay.

394
00:23:55.243 --> 00:23:55.523
Okay?

395
00:23:55.704 --> 00:23:57.104
When we get into dreaming, right?

396
00:23:57.444 --> 00:24:06.309
Because what we want to do is we want to prove that the targeted memory reactivation during dreaming can bias dream content.

397
00:24:07.029 --> 00:24:07.250
Oh, okay.

398
00:24:07.270 --> 00:24:07.430
Right?

399
00:24:07.490 --> 00:24:07.670
Right.

400
00:24:08.863 --> 00:24:12.104
So that's one thing where like you're going to dream of certain things.

401
00:24:13.244 --> 00:24:19.186
And then the second thing is when you dream of those certain things, you're actually better at the task later on.

402
00:24:19.306 --> 00:24:19.806
Interesting.

403
00:24:20.106 --> 00:24:27.469
So we're not just trying to harden it so that it can be reactivated when there's external stimulus.

404
00:24:27.549 --> 00:24:28.509
That was just a grounding.

405
00:24:28.529 --> 00:24:34.171
What we're saying now is can we actually influence what someone sees and feels?

406
00:24:34.931 --> 00:24:36.752
when they are actively dreaming.

407
00:24:36.912 --> 00:24:37.132
Yeah.

408
00:24:37.852 --> 00:24:50.559
And then not only that, can we then also have it so that the thing we're influencing them to see and feel while they are dreaming is functionally beneficial to like a reactivation or some functional process.

409
00:24:50.579 --> 00:24:50.839
Yes.

410
00:24:51.039 --> 00:24:53.140
For when they're now returning to the waking state.

411
00:24:53.180 --> 00:24:54.380
Yes, exactly.

412
00:24:54.781 --> 00:24:59.043
And in order to really make this foolproof, they actually selected their participants.

413
00:24:59.323 --> 00:24:59.543
Okay.

414
00:24:59.823 --> 00:25:05.665
to be 20 subjects with high lucid dreaming propensity.

415
00:25:05.805 --> 00:25:07.245
Do you know about lucid dreaming?

416
00:25:07.426 --> 00:25:08.626
I am from, we do live in LA.

417
00:25:08.906 --> 00:25:12.047
So, you know, there's a lot of people who love to talk about the woo-woo.

418
00:25:12.287 --> 00:25:12.947
Yeah.

419
00:25:13.067 --> 00:25:18.889
And lucid dreaming is very, it's the idea basically that you can have agency, like you have awareness.

420
00:25:19.269 --> 00:25:19.830
During dreams.

421
00:25:19.850 --> 00:25:20.470
During dreams.

422
00:25:20.510 --> 00:25:21.750
And then you can make decisions.

423
00:25:21.810 --> 00:25:22.030
Yeah.

424
00:25:22.370 --> 00:25:24.351
Not just be on a rollercoaster ride through it.

425
00:25:24.511 --> 00:25:33.397
Yeah, I mean, I think it's one of the coolest things that we can do as human beings is be conscious of the fact that we are in our brains simulation.

426
00:25:33.477 --> 00:25:33.657
Yep.

427
00:25:33.918 --> 00:25:34.138
Right?

428
00:25:34.498 --> 00:25:37.480
And then have agency and control over that dream.

429
00:25:37.840 --> 00:25:38.041
Right?

430
00:25:38.281 --> 00:25:40.542
This is central to the plot point of Inception.

431
00:25:40.582 --> 00:25:40.762
Yes.

432
00:25:40.822 --> 00:25:41.603
And so on and so forth.

433
00:25:41.723 --> 00:25:41.863
Yes.

434
00:25:41.883 --> 00:25:42.043
Right?

435
00:25:42.384 --> 00:25:43.885
So here's what they did.

436
00:25:44.657 --> 00:25:49.939
They got 20 subjects with really high lucid dreaming propensity, okay, 39 overnight sessions.

437
00:25:50.459 --> 00:25:57.561
And what these participants did was they tried to solve tasks, like little puzzles.

438
00:25:57.621 --> 00:26:08.845
This is like a matchstick puzzle, which is like you want to move exactly five matches such that this random scale that's made out of matches is exactly balanced.

439
00:26:08.945 --> 00:26:09.145
Mm-hmm.

440
00:26:10.515 --> 00:26:12.876
And these are all insight-driven puzzles.

441
00:26:12.956 --> 00:26:14.136
That's the key.

442
00:26:14.476 --> 00:26:15.757
They're not brute force puzzles.

443
00:26:15.777 --> 00:26:22.479
They're not like math algebra problems where there's a systematic algorithm that you can use to solve it.

444
00:26:22.519 --> 00:26:24.779
They're really like a creativity type of puzzle.

445
00:26:25.040 --> 00:26:25.280
Okay?

446
00:26:26.020 --> 00:26:30.181
And participants usually used to have some amount of puzzles that were not solved.

447
00:26:30.681 --> 00:26:30.901
Okay?

448
00:26:31.321 --> 00:26:31.842
Here's the key.

449
00:26:32.102 --> 00:26:32.782
Here's what they're doing.

450
00:26:34.076 --> 00:26:42.122
While they're solving the puzzles during the normal day, there is an auditory cue for each puzzle.

451
00:26:42.683 --> 00:26:42.803
Okay.

452
00:26:42.863 --> 00:26:46.446
Each puzzle has a unique sound associated with it.

453
00:26:46.486 --> 00:26:50.569
So as they're solving it, there's a unique sound that's being played in the background.

454
00:26:50.909 --> 00:26:55.733
So they're associating subconsciously that sound to this particular puzzle.

455
00:26:55.753 --> 00:26:55.973
Mm-hmm.

456
00:26:56.293 --> 00:26:56.553
Okay.

457
00:26:57.153 --> 00:26:58.554
Now we get into their sleeping.

458
00:26:58.834 --> 00:26:59.054
Okay.

459
00:26:59.354 --> 00:27:00.034
Now they're sleeping.

460
00:27:00.534 --> 00:27:04.175
We have something called targeted lucidity reactivation.

461
00:27:04.415 --> 00:27:04.675
Okay.

462
00:27:04.775 --> 00:27:10.337
They're able to target lucid dreaming to happen in these patients.

463
00:27:10.497 --> 00:27:11.197
No way.

464
00:27:11.217 --> 00:27:11.437
Yeah.

465
00:27:11.477 --> 00:27:12.277
This is what's crazy.

466
00:27:12.297 --> 00:27:13.157
So at 4 a.m.

467
00:27:13.218 --> 00:27:13.798
They wake up.

468
00:27:14.778 --> 00:27:15.038
Okay.

469
00:27:15.298 --> 00:27:22.180
And they spend 20 minutes training their mind to associate another set of auditory clues with

470
00:27:23.247 --> 00:27:25.948
a critical state of mind that will provoke lucidity.

471
00:27:26.328 --> 00:27:35.411
So as they're falling asleep, so they wake up at 4 a.m., and as they're falling asleep, they get played these three-tone beeps that are in ascending frequency.

472
00:27:35.491 --> 00:27:37.491
It's like beep, beep, beep.

473
00:27:37.831 --> 00:27:38.892
Beep, beep, beep.

474
00:27:38.912 --> 00:27:40.512
You hear that pitch, guys?

475
00:27:40.532 --> 00:27:42.573
You hear that pitch perfect over here?

476
00:27:42.633 --> 00:27:42.853
But...

477
00:27:43.433 --> 00:27:44.475
I mean, that's what they're doing.

478
00:27:44.495 --> 00:27:45.115
No, no, no, no.

479
00:27:45.135 --> 00:27:45.516
I get you.

480
00:27:45.536 --> 00:27:46.177
It's kind of crazy.

481
00:27:46.978 --> 00:27:51.824
And what they're doing is as they're lightly falling asleep, they're aware of that.

482
00:27:52.124 --> 00:27:52.324
Right.

483
00:27:52.685 --> 00:27:54.267
And they're like, oh, that's the sound.

484
00:27:54.307 --> 00:27:54.887
That's the sound.

485
00:27:55.128 --> 00:27:56.830
And they're trying to keep that lucidity.

486
00:27:56.890 --> 00:27:59.133
So they're trying to keep the conscious awareness of the sound.

487
00:27:59.253 --> 00:27:59.493
Yes.

488
00:27:59.573 --> 00:28:00.835
While they're falling asleep.

489
00:28:01.959 --> 00:28:08.524
The reason I'm kind of like giving all these facial expressions is, have you ever heard of this concept of like binaural beats?

490
00:28:09.265 --> 00:28:09.505
No.

491
00:28:09.645 --> 00:28:17.772
So there's this whole community, like, you know, Monroe Institute and a variety of these entities have done this research into this concept of binaural beats.

492
00:28:18.452 --> 00:28:18.672
And –

493
00:28:19.753 --> 00:28:21.113
There are two aspects to it.

494
00:28:21.233 --> 00:28:26.634
One is that it helps you – the way the frequencies are tuned, it helps you like relax.

495
00:28:26.735 --> 00:28:34.196
But in particular, people use it for lucid dreaming as like the thing to fall asleep to and then like – Oh, okay.

496
00:28:34.216 --> 00:28:37.957
Yeah, that's very much – It puts you in the right – Kind of in line.

497
00:28:38.057 --> 00:28:42.058
And state that enables or makes it more likely that you lucid dream.

498
00:28:42.478 --> 00:28:46.939
It's just interesting that there is an overlap because it's very much sort of in the –

499
00:28:47.939 --> 00:29:13.400
people who are quantitative self self-improvement kind of universe um so it's fascinating that there's a direct overlap yeah i mean it's pretty crazy yes that like i mean dude this stuff is just yeah i mean so here okay so getting back to this right so so they have this like ascending three-tone beep yes that then sort of like makes them sort of aware and try to lucidly dream more

500
00:29:13.880 --> 00:29:14.862
And then here's the track.

501
00:29:14.962 --> 00:29:15.663
Here's the key, right?

502
00:29:16.163 --> 00:29:22.612
They still have those TMR cues, the same targeted memory reactivation cue of the puzzle.

503
00:29:22.772 --> 00:29:23.013
Yes.

504
00:29:23.053 --> 00:29:26.878
The puzzle sound is different from this lucid sound.

505
00:29:27.118 --> 00:29:27.379
Okay?

506
00:29:28.420 --> 00:29:29.441
If they become lucid,

507
00:29:30.481 --> 00:29:30.681
Right?

508
00:29:31.462 --> 00:29:35.648
They're going to... And we can monitor their brain state because we have electrodes on them.

509
00:29:35.888 --> 00:29:37.871
So we can see when they enter REM sleep.

510
00:29:38.411 --> 00:29:38.572
Right.

511
00:29:38.592 --> 00:29:38.772
Right?

512
00:29:39.152 --> 00:29:43.258
And when they enter REM sleep, I can start playing now the sound from the puzzle.

513
00:29:43.658 --> 00:29:46.121
And if they're lucid and they play the sound from the puzzle...

514
00:29:46.842 --> 00:29:52.327
and they hear the sound from the puzzle, they're going to seek out that puzzle in their hallucinated dream state.

515
00:29:52.787 --> 00:29:56.890
So imagine you're dreaming, and you're out in Yosemite or something.

516
00:29:56.910 --> 00:29:57.471
This is so crazy.

517
00:29:57.511 --> 00:30:02.595
And now you hear the dun-dun-dun, which is like, oh, I'm lucid.

518
00:30:03.035 --> 00:30:11.903
And now whatever sound was associated with a certain puzzle that they couldn't solve, they're going to try to hallucinate that puzzle onto the granite walls of Yosemite.

519
00:30:12.325 --> 00:30:14.486
This is unbelievable.

520
00:30:14.646 --> 00:30:18.728
I'm so – I'm like – we need to do a follow-up on this because I'm so excited about this.

521
00:30:18.808 --> 00:30:19.628
It's insane.

522
00:30:19.668 --> 00:30:27.612
So just to say it back to you from the beginning, the idea is – And I haven't even gotten to the best part, by the way, but – We start – I don't know if I can take which one.

523
00:30:27.812 --> 00:30:28.052
Yeah.

524
00:30:28.953 --> 00:30:34.520
We basically have an audio cue when the participants are trying to solve a puzzle.

525
00:30:34.700 --> 00:30:36.122
That's an insight-based puzzle.

526
00:30:36.202 --> 00:30:36.402
Yeah.

527
00:30:36.782 --> 00:30:41.008
And the idea is to connect the puzzle to the sound for the participants.

528
00:30:41.028 --> 00:30:41.108
Yep.

529
00:30:41.388 --> 00:30:42.990
The participants then go to sleep.

530
00:30:43.250 --> 00:30:43.431
Yeah.

531
00:30:43.811 --> 00:30:44.972
While they're sleeping...

532
00:30:45.673 --> 00:31:11.582
separately from that set of sounds we have a different set of sounds they wake up at 4 a.m and we're trying to induce lucidity while dreaming yeah and the second set of sounds helps to facilitate that inducement of lucidity while dreaming that lucid state while dreaming that we've now induced with our second set of sounds means we're now incepting the first set of sounds into the dream yeah literally like the movie

533
00:31:12.243 --> 00:31:12.843
Literally, yeah.

534
00:31:32.065 --> 00:31:37.607
The brain has more space to explore and is potentially more likely to come up with the novel solution.

535
00:31:37.647 --> 00:31:37.827
Yes.

536
00:31:37.907 --> 00:31:43.709
That is one of the craziest, most unbelievable things that we've talked about on this pod.

537
00:31:43.809 --> 00:31:46.890
I think this is absolutely insane.

538
00:31:47.470 --> 00:31:50.411
Here's the part that I thought was crazy.

539
00:31:50.491 --> 00:31:51.492
We need a cherry on top.

540
00:31:51.612 --> 00:31:51.852
Okay.

541
00:31:52.012 --> 00:31:53.112
This is the cherry on top.

542
00:31:53.312 --> 00:31:53.633
Okay.

543
00:31:54.233 --> 00:31:54.753
There was...

544
00:31:55.916 --> 00:31:59.099
So we've gotten to the part where it's like interactive dreaming, right?

545
00:31:59.179 --> 00:31:59.399
Right.

546
00:32:00.060 --> 00:32:05.084
But at the end of the day, I still want to be sure that I am making this happen.

547
00:32:05.484 --> 00:32:05.724
Right.

548
00:32:05.964 --> 00:32:06.245
Okay?

549
00:32:06.605 --> 00:32:12.990
I don't want subjective reporting after the patient wakes up.

550
00:32:13.010 --> 00:32:16.173
I want during the dream to know that this is happening.

551
00:32:16.233 --> 00:32:16.453
Yes.

552
00:32:16.693 --> 00:32:16.934
Okay?

553
00:32:17.726 --> 00:32:19.467
But there's a caveat, right?

554
00:32:19.487 --> 00:32:26.631
This is going to be kind of difficult because as I told you, the brainstem-mediated paralysis is paralyzing the entire body.

555
00:32:26.832 --> 00:32:27.112
Yes.

556
00:32:27.412 --> 00:32:31.234
But it spares the eye muscles because it's REM sleep, right?

557
00:32:31.294 --> 00:32:32.995
So the eye is definitely moving.

558
00:32:33.015 --> 00:32:34.696
That's why it's called rapid eye movement.

559
00:32:35.237 --> 00:32:38.219
And it's also sparing the diaphragm because you're still breathing.

560
00:32:38.599 --> 00:32:38.999
Oh, right.

561
00:32:39.059 --> 00:32:39.299
Yeah.

562
00:32:40.080 --> 00:32:45.203
These subjects were trained, if they were lucid dreaming,

563
00:32:46.140 --> 00:32:51.224
They would move their eye around in the dream and they would breathe.

564
00:32:52.125 --> 00:32:55.547
They would huff and puff during the dream, like in their dream.

565
00:32:55.687 --> 00:32:55.888
Right.

566
00:32:55.908 --> 00:32:58.470
Like, so I'm in Yosemite and I'm like in my dreamscape.

567
00:32:59.070 --> 00:33:00.991
I start huffing and puffing in my dreamscape.

568
00:33:01.011 --> 00:33:05.655
Well, that's going to transfer into the physical body, huffing and puffing.

569
00:33:05.955 --> 00:33:07.416
And I could monitor that.

570
00:33:07.496 --> 00:33:08.457
This is so crazy.

571
00:33:09.098 --> 00:33:11.039
So I have the EEG signal.

572
00:33:11.259 --> 00:33:11.480
Yes.

573
00:33:11.980 --> 00:33:13.921
I have the signal from my...

574
00:33:15.188 --> 00:33:16.709
breathing stuff.

575
00:33:17.469 --> 00:33:19.571
I have the signal from the eyes.

576
00:33:19.971 --> 00:33:27.376
And I can now get a signal of the subject reporting back to me during dreaming that he is actually doing this.

577
00:33:28.777 --> 00:33:31.018
Y'all, I want you to understand something.

578
00:33:31.338 --> 00:33:32.339
I want you to understand something.

579
00:33:33.300 --> 00:33:43.266
What you're saying is we have now experimentally shown that a patient can communicate with

580
00:33:44.412 --> 00:33:59.844
While in a dream state, particularly when they're lucid dreaming, back to the researchers that are monitoring them across at least two modalities, eye movement and breathing.

581
00:33:59.964 --> 00:34:00.444
And breathing.

582
00:34:00.584 --> 00:34:02.046
Yeah.

583
00:34:02.206 --> 00:34:05.368
While we're trying to incept an idea to help them problem.

584
00:34:07.490 --> 00:34:08.470
On top of all of that.

585
00:34:10.572 --> 00:34:10.852
Mate.

586
00:34:12.374 --> 00:34:17.658
I'm at a loss for words because that is so – it's kind of weird because literally the movie Inception.

587
00:34:18.378 --> 00:34:19.219
It's kind of happening.

588
00:34:19.239 --> 00:34:19.880
It's kind of happening.

589
00:34:19.900 --> 00:34:20.380
Yeah.

590
00:34:20.520 --> 00:34:21.020
It's insane.

591
00:34:21.040 --> 00:34:22.321
There's no sharing of dreams.

592
00:34:22.401 --> 00:34:22.742
Fine.

593
00:34:22.942 --> 00:34:23.102
Sure.

594
00:34:23.122 --> 00:34:25.644
But like a lot of the stuff is there.

595
00:34:25.704 --> 00:34:26.024
Is there.

596
00:34:26.044 --> 00:34:26.464
Right?

597
00:34:26.624 --> 00:34:32.228
And the key to this two-way communication is that there's now real-time irrefutable proof.

598
00:34:32.248 --> 00:34:32.488
Right.

599
00:34:32.589 --> 00:34:32.869
Proof.

600
00:34:33.129 --> 00:34:33.349
Right.

601
00:34:33.849 --> 00:34:35.090
That the cue was heard.

602
00:34:35.451 --> 00:34:35.651
Right.

603
00:34:35.771 --> 00:34:37.272
It was integrated into the dream.

604
00:34:37.292 --> 00:34:37.472
Right.

605
00:34:37.672 --> 00:34:39.813
And there is a conscious response that came back.

606
00:34:39.973 --> 00:34:40.153
Right.

607
00:34:40.433 --> 00:34:43.474
Because in theory, you could make the conscious response different things.

608
00:34:43.754 --> 00:34:43.934
Yeah.

609
00:34:43.994 --> 00:34:46.794
You could say breathe like this or breathe like that or move your eyes like this or move.

610
00:34:46.954 --> 00:34:51.796
In order to then track over multiple different iteration types to be like, yeah, no, this is definitely happening.

611
00:34:51.856 --> 00:34:56.037
It's not just like, oh, it's the same single type of eye movement or breathing.

612
00:34:56.057 --> 00:34:56.357
Anyway.

613
00:34:56.377 --> 00:34:56.477
Yeah.

614
00:34:56.897 --> 00:34:57.097
Yeah.

615
00:34:57.498 --> 00:35:00.020
Okay, so now let's see if there's actually an outcome.

616
00:35:00.400 --> 00:35:02.562
Were they able to solve these problems better?

617
00:35:02.882 --> 00:35:08.147
So for one, 75% of participants reported the cued puzzle elements in their dreams.

618
00:35:08.487 --> 00:35:08.747
Okay.

619
00:35:08.847 --> 00:35:10.609
Okay, which is way greater than control.

620
00:35:10.649 --> 00:35:14.792
Meaning, like, I played the sound from the puzzle and the puzzle was in their dream.

621
00:35:14.812 --> 00:35:16.374
They were, like, solving it or doing whatever.

622
00:35:16.634 --> 00:35:16.774
Right.

623
00:35:16.794 --> 00:35:16.974
Right?

624
00:35:17.755 --> 00:35:23.880
The targeted dream efficacy, right, the subjects reported 40% more...

625
00:35:27.019 --> 00:35:30.265
Success on the queued puzzles versus the not queued puzzles.

626
00:35:30.285 --> 00:35:31.126
That's so crazy.

627
00:35:31.146 --> 00:35:36.355
So people who got the inception to solve the puzzle 40% of the time.

628
00:35:38.505 --> 00:35:42.768
were able to do so after the fact, greater than those who did not have the inception.

629
00:35:42.948 --> 00:35:43.128
Yeah.

630
00:35:43.649 --> 00:35:46.631
So if you didn't get incepted, you didn't do well.

631
00:35:46.831 --> 00:35:47.011
Yeah.

632
00:35:47.071 --> 00:35:50.514
If you did get incepted... You did a little bit better because sleep always... Sure.

633
00:35:50.534 --> 00:35:51.895
Like natural sleep... Sure.

634
00:35:51.915 --> 00:35:54.476
...will get you a little bit farther.

635
00:35:54.536 --> 00:35:57.038
But this is like engineered dreaming...

636
00:35:57.138 --> 00:35:57.358
Yes.

637
00:35:57.439 --> 00:36:00.541
...is making you superhuman at solving these puzzles.

638
00:36:00.621 --> 00:36:01.021
This is...

639
00:36:01.081 --> 00:36:01.461
This is...

640
00:36:01.521 --> 00:36:02.402
This is...

641
00:36:02.602 --> 00:36:03.063
I can't...

642
00:36:03.143 --> 00:36:03.563
I just...

643
00:36:05.187 --> 00:36:06.527
It's insane, dude.

644
00:36:06.907 --> 00:36:12.349
For those who are listening on audio, my mouth has been mostly open, slack-jawed, for a lot of this story.

645
00:36:12.549 --> 00:36:13.189
Dude, yeah.

646
00:36:13.309 --> 00:36:14.629
It's pretty – This is quite nice.

647
00:36:14.709 --> 00:36:15.449
This is quite nice.

648
00:36:15.469 --> 00:36:15.950
This is quite nice.

649
00:36:15.990 --> 00:36:18.050
And these studies are not in a vacuum, right?

650
00:36:18.070 --> 00:36:23.551
There's actually a lot of broad effort to do dream engineering and sleep engineering in general.

651
00:36:23.631 --> 00:36:27.432
It reminded me of this study from MIT called Dormio.

652
00:36:27.792 --> 00:36:29.693
They were actually targeting non-REM sleep.

653
00:36:29.753 --> 00:36:34.414
So this is like the edge of sleep, N1, which is called hypnagogia.

654
00:36:34.474 --> 00:36:34.654
Mm-hmm.

655
00:36:35.474 --> 00:36:37.036
It's like right when you're falling asleep.

656
00:36:37.096 --> 00:36:39.778
It's this transitional state between wakefulness and sleep.

657
00:36:40.098 --> 00:36:41.079
And they had a sensor.

658
00:36:41.299 --> 00:36:43.602
They had a glove that people would put on with sensors.

659
00:36:44.162 --> 00:36:46.344
And then it would give a cue.

660
00:36:46.444 --> 00:36:50.468
Like, think of a tree right when you were going to sleep.

661
00:36:50.728 --> 00:36:51.088
Okay?

662
00:36:51.428 --> 00:36:55.552
This thing was targeting divergent creativity, which is that the –

663
00:36:57.614 --> 00:37:05.878
Sorry, this thing was actually targeting convergent creativity, which is like the – Going down the rabbit hole, right?

664
00:37:05.958 --> 00:37:06.579
Yes, yes.

665
00:37:06.759 --> 00:37:11.141
And so we're doing like separate different things, and this is part of that.

666
00:37:11.461 --> 00:37:20.667
So I'm just saying there's like a huge modality of scientific research that is going into specifically sleep engineering.

667
00:37:20.687 --> 00:37:21.187
Right.

668
00:37:21.387 --> 00:37:26.436
And this is like one of the coolest examples that I've seen of like,

669
00:37:27.267 --> 00:37:28.167
Yeah.

670
00:37:28.187 --> 00:37:29.368
No, this is very good stuff.

671
00:37:29.568 --> 00:37:32.048
I mean, have you ever had a lucid dream before?

672
00:37:32.208 --> 00:37:32.908
I've had it once.

673
00:37:33.328 --> 00:37:37.329
Yeah, but I haven't been able to, like, control it, you know?

674
00:37:39.050 --> 00:37:41.070
I want to say twice, but it was only awareness.

675
00:37:41.130 --> 00:37:44.171
It was not... Yeah, I wasn't able to, like, literally be like, all right, I'm going to fly now.

676
00:37:44.191 --> 00:37:44.631
Yeah, yeah.

677
00:37:44.791 --> 00:37:45.751
You know, I wish I could do that.

678
00:37:45.891 --> 00:37:51.213
If you've ever had a lucid dream before, it is one of the coolest things.

679
00:37:51.613 --> 00:37:56.414
It can be obviously very scary, like, depending on whatever is in your subconscious and stuff like that.

680
00:37:56.434 --> 00:37:56.834
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

681
00:37:57.734 --> 00:38:05.358
It is such a fascinating mind bending thing because it's so bizarre, obviously.

682
00:38:05.438 --> 00:38:06.259
But you're there.

683
00:38:08.820 --> 00:38:22.928
It's like movies like Inception always may be like, well, like, you know, what is like, do you have an opposite life in opposite world in your dream that is consistent because it just kind of mirrors your own life and has different parameters and relationships that transcend time and stuff like that.

684
00:38:22.948 --> 00:38:23.928
But you just don't remember it.

685
00:38:25.029 --> 00:38:28.430
obviously we will find out soon because now we can incept our dreams.

686
00:38:28.470 --> 00:38:34.412
Yeah, no, no, I think this is, I think this is opening up doors for all kinds of really cool research.

687
00:38:34.512 --> 00:38:37.073
And there is clinical potential for this, right?

688
00:38:37.113 --> 00:38:40.694
For example, if you can do like nighttime neuro prosthetics,

689
00:38:41.134 --> 00:38:42.677
That's a new and emerging field.

690
00:38:43.237 --> 00:38:44.780
People who have PTSD, right?

691
00:38:44.860 --> 00:38:49.707
PTSD can be modeled as a pathological local minimum in some landscape.

692
00:38:50.288 --> 00:38:53.813
It's like a fear network and you're trapped in this local minima, right?

693
00:38:53.833 --> 00:38:54.614
And you can't get out.

694
00:38:54.975 --> 00:38:56.156
Well, if you do...

695
00:38:57.765 --> 00:39:01.806
targeted memory reactivation during REM sleep and you can cue stuff.

696
00:39:02.186 --> 00:39:05.368
You could theoretically restructure traumatic memories.

697
00:39:05.448 --> 00:39:08.329
That's a huge deal to not be traumatic anymore.

698
00:39:08.349 --> 00:39:08.569
Yeah.

699
00:39:08.609 --> 00:39:09.869
That's a huge deal, right?

700
00:39:09.929 --> 00:39:10.709
That's a huge deal.

701
00:39:10.729 --> 00:39:11.049
Yeah.

702
00:39:11.089 --> 00:39:14.231
No, I mean for veterans, for victims of abuse.

703
00:39:14.371 --> 00:39:19.132
I mean, there's a whole swath of people who could majorly benefit from that.

704
00:39:19.232 --> 00:39:19.452
Yeah.

705
00:39:20.073 --> 00:39:23.234
And of course, with all of this comes the ethical concern.

706
00:39:23.294 --> 00:39:23.754
Of course.

707
00:39:23.834 --> 00:39:24.034
Right.

708
00:39:24.434 --> 00:39:26.935
Because you're, you're,

709
00:39:28.055 --> 00:39:32.284
You're beating this sensory gate to get into dreams.

710
00:39:32.925 --> 00:39:33.747
Now imagine...

711
00:39:34.845 --> 00:39:45.115
if researchers can cue puzzle solutions, what if like commercial or malicious actors attempt to embed like branded content or, you know, alter preferences.

712
00:39:45.175 --> 00:39:51.201
This is, I, I get remembered of Tom Hardy's role in inception as like the defense guy.

713
00:39:51.241 --> 00:39:53.123
He was like dream, dream a little bigger.

714
00:39:53.163 --> 00:39:55.005
And he like came up with a giant gun.

715
00:39:55.085 --> 00:39:55.305
Yep.

716
00:39:55.966 --> 00:39:58.748
Um, it's like, it's like, so is dream sovereignty, um,

717
00:39:59.489 --> 00:40:02.070
going to now be the premier neuroethical challenge.

718
00:40:02.731 --> 00:40:05.672
I mean, this might...

719
00:40:05.772 --> 00:40:18.459
I didn't even think about this nexus, but while this might sound like, oh, this is early stage research and there's a ways to go, which is true, if you just look at, in the US, the recent...

720
00:40:19.399 --> 00:40:44.790
uh disclosures around uh what has been colloquially called havana syndrome but is uh what is also known as anomalous health incidents there is real legitimate congressional hearings and restitution being provided to veterans who've been victims of what are being called microwave weapon attacks from some foreign actor there are these diplomats who are started in congressman

721
00:40:45.430 --> 00:40:58.219
Havana, Cuba, which is why it's called Havana syndrome, where, you know, what the theory of the case is that there's this sort of small form factor microwave weapon, you point it at the target, and it creates all kinds of nausea and, you know, neurological issues.

722
00:40:58.700 --> 00:41:08.287
Allegedly, the director of national intelligence and some of their people just went to review one of these Havana syndrome weapons recently in order to bring it into the...

723
00:41:08.987 --> 00:41:14.352
U.S. inventory, it's been an issue that the government's very hesitant to discuss or address.

724
00:41:15.013 --> 00:41:26.042
I think because it touches on the same neurological sovereignty question that this issue brings up, which is not an area we've really spent a lot of time thinking about.

725
00:41:26.062 --> 00:41:34.150
But these technologies are getting us to a place where we can have impact on individuals

726
00:41:36.425 --> 00:41:40.287
external to their brain, but impacts their brain.

727
00:41:41.268 --> 00:41:41.808
And that gets...

728
00:41:42.308 --> 00:41:42.969
It gets tricky.

729
00:41:43.029 --> 00:41:43.849
That gets very dicey.

730
00:41:43.949 --> 00:41:45.570
Yeah, it gets very, very tricky.

731
00:41:45.810 --> 00:41:47.731
It's a frontier in neuroscience.

732
00:41:47.791 --> 00:41:50.032
I think it's going to be incredibly...

733
00:41:51.617 --> 00:41:53.858
exciting and a little bit weird.

734
00:41:54.118 --> 00:41:58.180
I just want to also briefly note that it, you know, we talk about, this is a science show.

735
00:41:58.240 --> 00:42:08.085
So we talk about the research and like how it, you know, what the implications are and what people are doing just because that's the focus of the show does not mean that we don't identify with and understand the,

736
00:42:09.105 --> 00:42:14.310
risks and challenges that are related to these in a whole number of different ways and situations.

737
00:42:14.670 --> 00:42:19.955
There are a lot of people who spend a lot of time thinking about that area and do content around that.

738
00:42:20.696 --> 00:42:25.901
We just try to talk about the science from first principles to give everyone a frame of reference to understand the,

739
00:42:26.501 --> 00:42:29.362
Where is technology going and how is it going to impact our everyday life?

740
00:42:29.562 --> 00:42:30.422
Yeah, and how does it work?

741
00:42:30.502 --> 00:42:31.402
And how does it work?

742
00:42:31.482 --> 00:42:37.824
Because we need to know how these things work to know, to even have the discussion about neurological sovereignty, which sounds so ridiculous.

743
00:42:37.844 --> 00:42:38.044
Yeah.

744
00:42:38.284 --> 00:42:41.845
But once you know how it works, you get why that's important to discuss.

745
00:42:42.005 --> 00:42:42.185
Yes.

746
00:42:42.225 --> 00:42:43.766
But we just don't yet always know how it works.

747
00:42:44.046 --> 00:42:44.446
Exactly.

748
00:42:44.686 --> 00:42:47.408
Yeah, and I just wanted to end this story on a lighter note.

749
00:42:47.468 --> 00:42:48.328
Yes.

750
00:42:48.868 --> 00:42:52.210
There's a movie, a little indie film that I was involved in.

751
00:42:52.330 --> 00:42:57.433
I was the scientific advisor on this film called Goldmine from a mutual friend of ours.

752
00:42:57.473 --> 00:43:00.355
He was the producer, director, and writer of the film.

753
00:43:00.515 --> 00:43:05.638
It is being distributed on Amazon and other digital platforms starting February 24th, 2026.

754
00:43:05.778 --> 00:43:09.400
I was the scientific advisor on the film.

755
00:43:10.161 --> 00:43:12.162
Lester was involved in some of the promotion of it.

756
00:43:12.722 --> 00:43:13.363
It's about...

757
00:43:14.443 --> 00:43:18.429
It's a really nice story about a father-daughter relationship.

758
00:43:18.890 --> 00:43:26.701
It involves virtual reality, getting into the neural landscape of virtual reality, maybe some potential...

759
00:43:28.212 --> 00:43:30.833
therapeutic advantages of virtual reality in the future.

760
00:43:31.013 --> 00:43:32.233
I think you guys should go check it out.

761
00:43:32.353 --> 00:43:35.654
It's available on Amazon starting pretty soon.

762
00:43:35.754 --> 00:43:37.175
I think this week.

763
00:43:37.315 --> 00:43:39.476
Yes, please go watch Goldmine.

764
00:43:39.596 --> 00:43:47.218
Big shout out to writer-director Matt Marder, who was one of the original co-hosts on one of your past podcast endeavors.

765
00:43:47.238 --> 00:43:47.558
That's right.

766
00:43:47.798 --> 00:43:48.398
Dark Matters.

767
00:43:48.699 --> 00:43:49.259
Yeah.

768
00:43:49.419 --> 00:43:50.540
So friend of the pod.

769
00:43:50.600 --> 00:43:51.260
Friend of the pod.

770
00:43:51.941 --> 00:43:53.722
Really, really helpful.

771
00:43:54.262 --> 00:43:56.103
Anyone is interested, it's fantastic.

772
00:43:56.344 --> 00:43:57.224
We went to the premiere.

773
00:43:57.504 --> 00:44:00.066
It's definitely worth a watch, so definitely check that out.

774
00:44:00.726 --> 00:44:02.227
One of our first friends to make it to streaming.

775
00:44:02.508 --> 00:44:02.708
Yeah.

776
00:44:02.728 --> 00:44:04.309
It's fantastic.

777
00:44:04.669 --> 00:44:08.832
Great story number one, neuroscience story, dream engineering.

778
00:44:09.621 --> 00:44:12.542
Again, you're not going to get these kind of stories anywhere else, folks.

779
00:44:12.962 --> 00:44:14.042
It's the best of the best.

780
00:44:14.062 --> 00:44:14.842
Yeah, that was crazy, bro.

781
00:44:14.882 --> 00:44:15.262
The best.

782
00:44:15.782 --> 00:44:16.003
Sir.

783
00:44:16.903 --> 00:44:20.083
And with that, we will move into our rundown.

784
00:44:20.143 --> 00:44:26.665
Again, we cannot cover every breaking science research story every week in the level of detail of our main stories.

785
00:44:27.045 --> 00:44:32.206
So we use the rundown as a way to talk about other stories we found fascinating that we want to share with you all.

786
00:44:32.566 --> 00:44:34.307
You can go in and dig in on your own.

787
00:44:34.627 --> 00:44:38.208
But we'll just cover them topically a little bit at first.

788
00:44:39.568 --> 00:44:39.808
Yeah.

789
00:45:03.020 --> 00:45:08.983
And if you're having an issue trying to grok the subjects we're talking about, check out the video podcast version.

790
00:45:09.423 --> 00:45:18.028
It's a much more robust way to learn these concepts and have them sink in so we can get it reactivated when we start manipulating your dreams later.

791
00:45:18.048 --> 00:45:18.748
And...

792
00:45:20.289 --> 00:45:26.837
When you're on said Spotify and YouTube, we are in our fight for our lives in the billionaire algorithm.

793
00:45:27.257 --> 00:45:32.664
So a five star on either is super helpful for us to get this show out to more people.

794
00:45:33.144 --> 00:45:39.311
Leave a comment if you want to say you have a different idea or you want to cover something, anything.

795
00:45:39.852 --> 00:45:40.472
Put it in the comments.

796
00:45:40.492 --> 00:45:41.793
Or even just like random words.

797
00:45:41.813 --> 00:45:42.594
Just anything.

798
00:45:42.734 --> 00:45:44.195
It's super helpful for us.

799
00:45:45.035 --> 00:45:45.956
Share it with a friend.

800
00:45:46.076 --> 00:45:48.897
If you're at a research lab, bring it up during your lunch.

801
00:45:49.297 --> 00:45:51.419
I know you guys have coffees and lunch and learns we talk about.

802
00:45:51.719 --> 00:45:55.261
This is the best show for the science research community.

803
00:45:55.681 --> 00:45:56.722
Trying to get it out to more people.

804
00:45:56.962 --> 00:45:57.082
And.

805
00:45:57.562 --> 00:46:04.208
If you would like to support the show, we have a new donation portal at ffppod.com backslash donate.

806
00:46:04.548 --> 00:46:06.210
Become a monthly patron.

807
00:46:06.530 --> 00:46:10.994
It helps us run this show, which, again, is just the two of us.

808
00:46:11.014 --> 00:46:13.236
I'm going to get better at singing so I can sing that better.

809
00:46:13.596 --> 00:46:17.177
Last note, we do have a new update to the website.

810
00:46:17.557 --> 00:46:30.441
We now have chaptering on all of our videos as well as all of the past both research papers and news articles related to each episode with a little bit of a more robust research papers page.

811
00:46:31.061 --> 00:46:35.183
We are now set up for some of our more fun features we're looking to do in the future.

812
00:46:35.643 --> 00:46:40.044
So please go check that out at ffppod.com.

813
00:46:40.505 --> 00:46:47.147
Our first story in the rundown is a possible pulsar at the Milky Way Center.

814
00:46:47.167 --> 00:46:48.548
This is an astrophysics story.

815
00:46:48.888 --> 00:46:53.389
There's a supermassive black hole at the center of our galaxy.

816
00:46:53.450 --> 00:46:54.410
What's going on here?

817
00:46:54.810 --> 00:46:55.070
Yes.

818
00:46:55.471 --> 00:47:03.740
What they're looking for with the supermassive black hole, which is a very famous supermassive black hole, it's the closest supermassive black hole to Earth.

819
00:47:03.980 --> 00:47:05.762
It's at the center of our Milky Way galaxy.

820
00:47:06.443 --> 00:47:06.643
And...

821
00:47:08.098 --> 00:47:14.760
We finally found a pulsar, or we think at least, that we found a pulsar near that supermassive black hole.

822
00:47:15.040 --> 00:47:19.682
A pulsar is a neutron star that's extremely, extremely dense.

823
00:47:20.042 --> 00:47:22.763
It's about – neutron stars are like the size of the sun.

824
00:47:23.603 --> 00:47:23.823
Sorry.

825
00:47:24.023 --> 00:47:25.484
No, I should say this clearly.

826
00:47:26.304 --> 00:47:32.486
A neutron star is about the mass of the sun, if not bigger, but it's about the size of a city.

827
00:47:32.866 --> 00:47:33.126
Okay.

828
00:47:33.246 --> 00:47:33.526
Okay?

829
00:47:33.926 --> 00:47:46.110
Extremely dense star where it's called a neutron star because the pressure from gravity is so high that the electrons and the protons fuse together, and it's a giant ball of neutrons.

830
00:47:46.490 --> 00:47:50.732
Like, not even atoms can exist at this amount of gravitational pressure.

831
00:47:50.932 --> 00:47:51.132
Okay?

832
00:47:51.152 --> 00:47:51.392
Okay.

833
00:47:52.851 --> 00:47:58.718
What's cool about pulsars are they are specific types of neutron stars that have a really high spin.

834
00:47:59.519 --> 00:48:03.084
And they shoot out radio waves.

835
00:48:03.925 --> 00:48:07.729
And the radio waves are like a lighthouse as they're spinning.

836
00:48:08.818 --> 00:48:13.019
And pulsars are such that the lighthouse beam is exactly aligned with Earth.

837
00:48:13.559 --> 00:48:13.980
Okay.

838
00:48:14.000 --> 00:48:14.180
Okay?

839
00:48:14.480 --> 00:48:17.781
There's plenty of neutron stars where the lighthouse beam is not aligned with Earth.

840
00:48:17.861 --> 00:48:18.061
Mm-hmm.

841
00:48:18.521 --> 00:48:23.282
But for pulsars, we just happen to be lucky enough that the lighthouse beam is aligned with Earth.

842
00:48:23.302 --> 00:48:24.943
So when we point our radio dish...

843
00:48:25.523 --> 00:48:33.210
at that pulsar, we're going to get beep, beep, beep, beep, beep, metronomic radio pulses from that point in the sky.

844
00:48:33.670 --> 00:48:33.910
Okay?

845
00:48:34.391 --> 00:48:38.074
This particular pulsar that they think they found is about 8 milliseconds.

846
00:48:38.474 --> 00:48:39.715
This is a millisecond pulsar.

847
00:48:39.735 --> 00:48:42.097
So every 8 milliseconds, this thing is turning around.

848
00:48:42.157 --> 00:48:42.718
Imagine that.

849
00:48:43.098 --> 00:48:46.641
Something the size of the sun, if not bigger, about the size of a city.

850
00:48:47.102 --> 00:48:48.603
The mass of the sun is the size of a city.

851
00:48:48.623 --> 00:48:49.184
Yeah, sorry.

852
00:48:49.204 --> 00:48:49.965
I keep saying that.

853
00:48:49.985 --> 00:48:53.168
The mass of the sun, but the size of a city rotating around, right?

854
00:48:53.529 --> 00:48:58.535
And given the conservation of angular momentum, this thing is not slowing down, okay?

855
00:48:59.155 --> 00:49:02.699
This thing is going to keep going at 8 milliseconds.

856
00:49:02.780 --> 00:49:02.980
Mm-hmm.

857
00:49:04.151 --> 00:49:06.634
That makes this a really nice clock.

858
00:49:07.274 --> 00:49:07.474
Right.

859
00:49:07.935 --> 00:49:08.195
Okay?

860
00:49:08.656 --> 00:49:23.371
And if we find such a really nice clock near the galactic center where there's a giant black hole that is warping space and time, we can test Einstein's general relativity to unprecedented degree.

861
00:49:23.771 --> 00:49:25.373
That's why everyone's excited about this.

862
00:49:25.933 --> 00:49:29.314
is the idea that the pulsar becomes an instrument in and of itself.

863
00:49:29.334 --> 00:49:29.574
Yes.

864
00:49:29.774 --> 00:49:29.974
Yes.

865
00:49:30.074 --> 00:49:30.915
That's exactly right.

866
00:49:30.955 --> 00:49:31.135
Yeah.

867
00:49:31.155 --> 00:49:32.435
Because a lot of things can happen.

868
00:49:33.095 --> 00:49:38.397
The gravitational field of the black hole itself can start influencing the pulsar.

869
00:49:38.477 --> 00:49:38.617
Right.

870
00:49:38.637 --> 00:49:38.837
Right.

871
00:49:39.377 --> 00:49:46.139
And maybe if it wobbles a little bit less or if the timing is delayed, we can test Einstein's prediction that way.

872
00:49:46.579 --> 00:49:51.660
On the other hand, the radio signal that's coming from the pulsar is light.

873
00:49:52.081 --> 00:49:53.301
And light is itself...

874
00:49:54.688 --> 00:49:56.771
you know, affected by space and time.

875
00:49:56.811 --> 00:49:57.012
Right.

876
00:49:57.252 --> 00:50:01.559
And if there's a lot of warping by that black hole, that light is going to get affected.

877
00:50:01.599 --> 00:50:01.759
Yes.

878
00:50:01.859 --> 00:50:07.348
So monitoring this thing over years is going to give us extremely nice test

879
00:50:08.708 --> 00:50:10.790
For Einstein's general theory of relativity.

880
00:50:10.810 --> 00:50:11.891
That's why everyone's excited.

881
00:50:11.971 --> 00:50:15.914
It's not entirely foolproof, the analysis.

882
00:50:16.095 --> 00:50:19.838
And so, you know, there's still more stuff that needs to be done to confirm it.

883
00:50:19.918 --> 00:50:20.118
Yes.

884
00:50:20.539 --> 00:50:22.620
But it's tantalizingly close.

885
00:50:22.640 --> 00:50:29.927
This was out of Columbia University and the Breakthrough Listen project, which I don't know if you know, that's the like new SETI.

886
00:50:30.047 --> 00:50:30.467
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

887
00:50:30.568 --> 00:50:30.748
Right?

888
00:50:30.768 --> 00:50:31.008
Yeah, yeah.

889
00:50:31.508 --> 00:50:41.911
And they have this giant like breakthrough listen galactic center survey where they conducted like the most sensitive radio search for pulsars near the galactic center.

890
00:50:42.492 --> 00:50:44.072
It was out in the Astrophysical Journal.

891
00:50:44.152 --> 00:50:47.753
It's something a lot of astrophysicists are very excited about.

892
00:50:47.793 --> 00:50:48.713
That is very exciting.

893
00:50:48.753 --> 00:50:53.475
Again, it's early, as is almost every story we talk about on this podcast.

894
00:50:53.495 --> 00:51:00.037
So it goes without saying that we're waiting for continued further analysis, replication, etc.,

895
00:51:00.477 --> 00:51:01.638
And I think it's going to be soon.

896
00:51:01.698 --> 00:51:05.080
So, you know, when we get a confirmation, maybe we'll do a deep dive into it.

897
00:51:05.140 --> 00:51:06.681
This is very exciting.

898
00:51:06.701 --> 00:51:08.162
That's actually a huge deal.

899
00:51:08.202 --> 00:51:11.424
That was our story number one, Columbia to Astrophysical Journey.

900
00:51:11.885 --> 00:51:22.472
For number two, decoding an ancient Roman board game, an archaeology story about how AI has now helped us figure out the rules for...

901
00:51:23.752 --> 00:51:27.054
For this unknown board game from the Roman period.

902
00:51:27.194 --> 00:51:28.755
Yeah, this one was pretty cool.

903
00:51:28.815 --> 00:51:34.118
Okay, so there's a 2000 year old limestone slab that was found in the Netherlands.

904
00:51:34.798 --> 00:51:37.580
And it was identified as an ancient Roman board game.

905
00:51:37.840 --> 00:51:40.682
It was sitting in a museum.

906
00:51:41.742 --> 00:51:44.424
And some people who are really into...

907
00:51:45.658 --> 00:51:51.161
board games from antiquity and from like human civilization saw it and wanted to analyze it.

908
00:51:51.682 --> 00:51:53.022
The rules are lost to history.

909
00:51:53.223 --> 00:51:58.086
Obviously, there's no like, you know, you know, the manual that comes with the board game about what the rules are.

910
00:51:58.126 --> 00:51:59.566
OK, there's nothing that we can do that.

911
00:51:59.947 --> 00:52:05.030
But what we can do is look at that slab of limestone and figure out where the wear and tear is.

912
00:52:05.962 --> 00:52:12.067
And then we can use AI to play thousands of simulated games with various rules.

913
00:52:12.267 --> 00:52:12.507
Right.

914
00:52:12.647 --> 00:52:12.887
Right.

915
00:52:13.548 --> 00:52:14.869
So an AI plays with itself.

916
00:52:14.889 --> 00:52:19.332
This is kind of like how Google DeepMind trained AlphaGo.

917
00:52:19.392 --> 00:52:19.572
Yep.

918
00:52:19.832 --> 00:52:20.092
You know?

919
00:52:20.293 --> 00:52:20.493
Yep.

920
00:52:20.953 --> 00:52:25.957
So we've got all of these AIs that are playing thousands of different rules.

921
00:52:27.211 --> 00:52:35.476
And from those thousands of different games, tens of thousands of different games, we can figure out which games required the movement of pieces.

922
00:52:35.616 --> 00:52:35.876
Right.

923
00:52:35.976 --> 00:52:40.279
Such that it would match the wear and tear on the limestone slab.

924
00:52:40.879 --> 00:52:44.602
And they figured out about, like, I think there were, like, four...

925
00:52:46.628 --> 00:52:49.550
four to nine different games.

926
00:52:50.110 --> 00:52:54.572
And they're all of a particular type that are still kind of played in Scandinavia.

927
00:52:55.592 --> 00:52:57.733
And they match the wear and tear of this thing.

928
00:52:57.993 --> 00:53:01.315
And it turns out it's like an asymmetric blockade game.

929
00:53:01.515 --> 00:53:02.836
You can actually go and play it.

930
00:53:03.116 --> 00:53:04.496
They made an online version of it.

931
00:53:04.576 --> 00:53:07.558
It's called Ludus Coriovali.

932
00:53:08.018 --> 00:53:10.439
It's played with four hounds trying to trap...

933
00:53:10.899 --> 00:53:11.760
Two hairs.

934
00:53:12.040 --> 00:53:12.821
That's what they called it.

935
00:53:13.001 --> 00:53:13.261
Okay.

936
00:53:13.661 --> 00:53:19.465
But it's very cool because it's like a use of AI to something that I literally never thought about.

937
00:53:19.545 --> 00:53:21.827
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

938
00:53:21.847 --> 00:53:26.931
And it's a clever use case because you have some kind of physical indicator, which is the where.

939
00:53:27.111 --> 00:53:27.411
Yeah.

940
00:53:27.551 --> 00:53:28.012
And tear.

941
00:53:28.472 --> 00:53:37.719
And ultimately, there's a finite number of options for what the rule set was for the game that would result in, especially on a limestone board, that kind of wear and tear.

942
00:53:37.839 --> 00:53:40.101
So it makes logical sense, but I never would have thought of that.

943
00:53:40.121 --> 00:53:41.062
I never would have thought of that.

944
00:53:41.082 --> 00:53:41.522
Yeah.

945
00:53:41.642 --> 00:53:49.168
And I mean, it's really cool because this discovery pushes the known history of these types of board games back several centuries now.

946
00:53:49.508 --> 00:53:49.808
You know?

947
00:53:50.229 --> 00:53:50.929
Fantastic.

948
00:53:50.949 --> 00:53:51.350
That's a good one.

949
00:53:51.370 --> 00:53:51.630
Very cool.

950
00:53:52.210 --> 00:53:53.712
We love our archaeology.

951
00:53:53.732 --> 00:53:55.573
We've touched on Rome a couple times.

952
00:53:55.753 --> 00:53:59.197
And this is out of Leiden University in the journal Antiquity.

953
00:53:59.377 --> 00:54:00.938
Yes, this is good, good, good.

954
00:54:01.419 --> 00:54:04.501
We are going to keep it hot with our story number three.

955
00:54:04.902 --> 00:54:07.384
This one is a genetics and human evolution story.

956
00:54:08.125 --> 00:54:14.130
How we became human might be related to, unsurprisingly, our fingers.

957
00:54:14.190 --> 00:54:16.272
But what about this one is particularly interesting?

958
00:54:16.292 --> 00:54:16.552
Yeah.

959
00:54:16.632 --> 00:54:21.437
Yeah, this one was really cool because usually when we think about human evolution, we always think about brain size.

960
00:54:21.917 --> 00:54:22.178
Yes.

961
00:54:22.558 --> 00:54:26.782
Bigger brain size means we're smarter, means we're more human-like to modern-day humans.

962
00:54:27.183 --> 00:54:31.567
This new research points to the fact that prenatal hormones— Mm-hmm.

963
00:54:31.687 --> 00:54:41.489
that we are subject to when we are in our mother's womb, that's actually a surprising driving factor to brain size and finger size.

964
00:54:41.889 --> 00:54:45.670
The clue lies in 2D to 4D finger ratio.

965
00:54:45.690 --> 00:54:50.251
That's the ratio between your ring finger and your index finger.

966
00:54:50.892 --> 00:54:58.513
And if you've got a longer index finger, that usually means that you've had higher prenatal estrogen exposure during the first trimester.

967
00:55:02.054 --> 00:55:03.235
larger brain size.

968
00:55:03.635 --> 00:55:05.416
Boo.

969
00:55:06.596 --> 00:55:08.077
For boys and not girls, too.

970
00:55:08.397 --> 00:55:09.117
Oh, no.

971
00:55:09.417 --> 00:55:10.478
I have a small brain.

972
00:55:10.578 --> 00:55:17.881
Now, I think this is an overarching evolution story rather than individual... Fair, fair, fair.

973
00:55:17.921 --> 00:55:22.703
Because I think what they're saying is the effect is something where these two genes are correlated.

974
00:55:23.143 --> 00:55:23.403
Okay.

975
00:55:23.463 --> 00:55:23.684
Right?

976
00:55:23.804 --> 00:55:24.104
Okay.

977
00:55:24.284 --> 00:55:28.586
And it's in line with a lot of recent...

978
00:55:30.463 --> 00:55:51.281
research that shows that there's like this this thing called the feminization of the skeleton and this is not like anything political or anything like that it's not a culture war i think no this is not a culture war at all it's relevant because in human evolution increases in brain size are found alongside something called the feminization of the skeleton

979
00:55:52.810 --> 00:56:08.585
For example, high values of this 2D to 4D in males, the ring finger to the index finger, they've been found with elevated rates of heart problems, poor sperm counts, predisposition to schizophrenia in males.

980
00:56:08.785 --> 00:56:09.106
I see.

981
00:56:09.166 --> 00:56:09.446
Okay.

982
00:56:09.726 --> 00:56:14.251
And it seems that this stuff is coming from prenatal hormones from the fact that we are—

983
00:56:15.934 --> 00:56:18.877
we were subjected to estrogen in our first trimester.

984
00:56:19.237 --> 00:56:23.881
That led to heightened brain size, but it also led to all of these problems.

985
00:56:23.941 --> 00:56:24.661
I see.

986
00:56:24.681 --> 00:56:35.070
And in the course of evolution, I guess the human species decided, I'll go with the large brain size, even though it comes with all of these problems.

987
00:56:35.170 --> 00:56:36.191
That's fascinating.

988
00:56:36.391 --> 00:56:36.771
You know?

989
00:56:36.851 --> 00:56:37.512
No, that isn't...

990
00:56:38.292 --> 00:56:39.834
The... You know, the...

991
00:56:40.961 --> 00:56:41.381
Let me not.

992
00:56:41.602 --> 00:56:42.082
I'll leave it.

993
00:56:42.582 --> 00:56:43.163
I won't.

994
00:56:43.203 --> 00:56:43.543
Let me leave.

995
00:56:43.563 --> 00:56:49.287
This is out of the Swansea University and Istanbul University in the journal Early Human Development.

996
00:56:49.307 --> 00:56:56.912
I thought it was quite interesting because we always think about how genes are related to each other when they go through evolution.

997
00:56:57.093 --> 00:56:58.514
So this is something that's very important.

998
00:56:58.914 --> 00:57:01.276
I mean, you can also map this onto the site –

999
00:57:03.013 --> 00:57:18.984
When people talk about quote-unquote masculinity and the change in body, the body stature of, like, men generally over time, if there's a correlation to higher brain size equals to the skeletal structure of us being slightly different, that is an interesting... That is an interesting angle, yeah.

1000
00:57:19.024 --> 00:57:23.507
That, like, we kind of see manifesting, unfortunately, in the culture war, but has sort of this...

1001
00:57:24.727 --> 00:57:26.468
genetic basis for it.

1002
00:57:27.128 --> 00:57:28.368
Fascinating story number three.

1003
00:57:28.448 --> 00:57:35.510
Our last story of the rundown combines AI with bioengineering.

1004
00:57:35.550 --> 00:57:36.931
So no risk here at all.

1005
00:57:37.271 --> 00:57:41.872
A new machine learning pipeline that is streamlining protein engineering.

1006
00:57:41.892 --> 00:57:45.433
We've talked about AlphaFold God knows how many times.

1007
00:57:45.673 --> 00:57:45.913
Yes.

1008
00:57:45.953 --> 00:57:46.854
We've gotten comments.

1009
00:57:46.954 --> 00:57:48.034
Yes, we understand.

1010
00:57:48.114 --> 00:57:48.914
It's not perfect.

1011
00:57:49.094 --> 00:57:50.915
Nothing we're talking about on the podcast is perfect.

1012
00:57:50.935 --> 00:57:51.215
Yeah.

1013
00:57:51.355 --> 00:57:52.318
No, this is science.

1014
00:57:52.418 --> 00:57:53.020
We get that.

1015
00:57:54.524 --> 00:57:56.831
That being said... That being said...

1016
00:57:57.947 --> 00:57:59.168
Alpha fold is not everything.

1017
00:57:59.809 --> 00:58:00.029
Right.

1018
00:58:00.089 --> 00:58:00.289
Right?

1019
00:58:00.629 --> 00:58:04.693
Alpha fold means you give me a protein sequence, which is a bunch of amino acids and a line.

1020
00:58:05.434 --> 00:58:08.617
I'll probably be able to tell you what it looks like in 3D.

1021
00:58:09.157 --> 00:58:09.417
Okay?

1022
00:58:09.698 --> 00:58:10.879
And how it changes shape.

1023
00:58:11.499 --> 00:58:11.739
Okay.

1024
00:58:12.540 --> 00:58:15.122
What if we wanted to design proteins?

1025
00:58:15.523 --> 00:58:21.008
If we want to design proteins, the search space is incredibly big because if I have 100 amino acids...

1026
00:58:21.468 --> 00:58:22.809
that I want to fit into a protein.

1027
00:58:22.829 --> 00:58:24.710
There's 20 choices for each amino acid.

1028
00:58:25.091 --> 00:58:27.552
That's 20 to the 100th power.

1029
00:58:27.893 --> 00:58:29.414
There's more atoms in the universe.

1030
00:58:29.814 --> 00:58:30.755
So I'm not going to...

1031
00:58:30.895 --> 00:58:36.279
I need ways to hone down if I want to design a new protein.

1032
00:58:36.699 --> 00:58:37.800
How to actually...

1033
00:58:39.621 --> 00:58:41.242
Reduce that search space.

1034
00:58:41.622 --> 00:58:41.902
Okay?

1035
00:58:42.022 --> 00:58:42.243
Right.

1036
00:58:42.603 --> 00:58:48.546
So nowadays what we can do with various techniques is get down to like tens of thousands of protein candidates.

1037
00:58:49.146 --> 00:58:54.049
If we get down to tens of thousands of protein candidates, the bottleneck then becomes the lab.

1038
00:58:54.429 --> 00:58:54.650
Right.

1039
00:58:54.890 --> 00:58:59.993
Because I can only really efficiently build and test around 100 different variants.

1040
00:59:00.113 --> 00:59:00.273
Right.

1041
00:59:00.293 --> 00:59:00.413
Right.

1042
00:59:02.094 --> 00:59:09.562
So what's the best way to choose which hundred I want to actually test and make in the lab and then figure out?

1043
00:59:10.123 --> 00:59:17.731
That is what these guys at the University of California at Berkeley and the ARC Institute are doing with this particular story that came out in science.

1044
00:59:18.131 --> 00:59:21.154
They created something called Multi-Evolve.

1045
00:59:21.715 --> 00:59:25.516
The idea is they've created an ensemble of protein language models.

1046
00:59:26.356 --> 00:59:33.498
And what these protein language models do is not just care about the fitness landscape of like, what is the stuff that evolution constrains me for?

1047
00:59:34.399 --> 00:59:39.440
These models also care about stuff like, is the enzyme going to catalyze faster?

1048
00:59:40.640 --> 00:59:42.841
Is the antibody going to bind tighter?

1049
00:59:44.001 --> 00:59:47.182
Is the CRISPR tool going to edit better?

1050
00:59:47.262 --> 00:59:49.563
These are things that aren't really captured by evolution.

1051
00:59:49.583 --> 00:59:50.003
Yeah.

1052
00:59:50.379 --> 00:59:53.173
But this particular multi-evolve

1053
00:59:54.510 --> 01:00:21.957
paradigm is actually going to do and what what's very cool about this is now we've put the lab and the ai right in the loop right okay like it's one big loop yes of discovery where the ai is interacting with people in the lab telling you what to what to do in the lab the lab is going back to the ai and you can have this iteration happen even faster right and the ai framework was able to accurately predict how proteins will function

1054
01:00:22.718 --> 01:00:24.788
Even when several of their amino acids...

1055
01:00:25.425 --> 01:00:26.226
get mutated.

1056
01:00:26.646 --> 01:00:34.453
Because what you want to do is if you have an amino acid, you want to figure out, oh, if I replace this amino acid with a different one, is it going to make it better or is it going to make it worse?

1057
01:00:34.833 --> 01:00:38.776
What's more is if I replace these two, is that going to make it better?

1058
01:00:38.876 --> 01:00:44.321
Because if I just replace this one and it's good, and I replace this one and it's good, that doesn't mean if I replace both of them, it's good.

1059
01:00:44.581 --> 01:00:47.143
There's some synergistic landscape.

1060
01:00:47.564 --> 01:00:48.825
Maybe they're antagonists.

1061
01:00:48.885 --> 01:00:49.245
Yes.

1062
01:00:49.325 --> 01:00:49.545
Right?

1063
01:00:49.885 --> 01:00:52.307
And so all of these relationships are now...

1064
01:00:53.068 --> 01:00:56.411
Something that I can parameterize with this multi-evolved model, right?

1065
01:00:56.471 --> 01:01:06.141
And bioengineers can now develop this new machine learning framework that condenses that problem of protein engineering into a single round of testing.

1066
01:01:06.881 --> 01:01:14.289
And in their test, the model was successfully able to find combinations of mutations that outperformed the original proteins.

1067
01:01:14.509 --> 01:01:15.290
Yep, showing that.

1068
01:01:15.830 --> 01:01:21.275
that having it in the loop like that actually has fundamental improvement value.

1069
01:01:21.335 --> 01:01:21.815
Yeah, yeah.

1070
01:01:21.935 --> 01:01:32.544
And it's very cool because the Ark Institute, which is in Silicon Valley, the whole point of it is to have frontier AI capabilities and experimental biologists under the same physical roof.

1071
01:01:33.004 --> 01:01:34.105
That's how they operate.

1072
01:01:34.685 --> 01:01:34.866
And...

1073
01:01:35.506 --> 01:01:38.629
Closing that loop between computation and the wet lab.

1074
01:01:38.789 --> 01:01:38.949
Yep.

1075
01:01:39.490 --> 01:01:40.931
This is like their first iteration.

1076
01:01:40.971 --> 01:01:43.113
It's very exciting to see what they're going to come up with next.

1077
01:01:43.813 --> 01:01:49.338
This is fascinating because this is something similar that, you know, my mom works in clinical trials.

1078
01:01:49.458 --> 01:02:01.169
And there's this similar desire to find ways to incorporate tools like AI into the process to create that feedback, that virtuous cycle and feedback loop.

1079
01:02:01.449 --> 01:02:02.470
But you have to start somewhere.

1080
01:02:02.750 --> 01:02:05.970
And so it's interesting to hear in a variety of these spaces across –

1081
01:02:07.493 --> 01:02:16.036
both fundamental research and application, for example, in pharmaceuticals, um, that people are finding ways to integrate it.

1082
01:02:16.376 --> 01:02:18.237
That is changing outcomes.

1083
01:02:18.317 --> 01:02:18.537
Yeah.

1084
01:02:18.677 --> 01:02:20.117
That is straight up changing.

1085
01:02:20.197 --> 01:02:20.397
Yeah.

1086
01:02:20.657 --> 01:02:22.198
Influencing outcomes for the positive.

1087
01:02:22.598 --> 01:02:23.058
I get that.

1088
01:02:23.078 --> 01:02:26.019
Everyone wants to say it's wrong because they tried it one time.

1089
01:02:26.619 --> 01:02:30.220
And that means that all of it is wrong, but, um, that's just not how it works.

1090
01:02:30.780 --> 01:02:35.482
Uh, it's not perfect, but it is, it is filling in gaps that are significantly meaningful.

1091
01:02:35.502 --> 01:02:35.642
Yeah.

1092
01:02:35.662 --> 01:02:35.822
Yeah.

1093
01:02:36.854 --> 01:02:38.415
Great rundown this week.

1094
01:02:38.455 --> 01:02:40.916
I mean, it's going to be the first story, the rundown.

1095
01:02:40.936 --> 01:02:43.758
These are some fantastic stories.

1096
01:02:44.198 --> 01:02:47.420
We're going to move on to our main story number two.

1097
01:02:47.900 --> 01:02:50.722
This one is a fundamental physics story.

1098
01:02:50.742 --> 01:02:54.884
It's about trying to measure one of the smallest things in the universe.

1099
01:02:54.904 --> 01:02:57.366
We talked about it a lot on this pod, the proton.

1100
01:02:57.846 --> 01:03:00.408
It's one of the fundamental particles inside the atomic nucleus.

1101
01:03:00.428 --> 01:03:00.508
Yes.

1102
01:03:01.565 --> 01:03:03.286
And we've done it to super high accuracy.

1103
01:03:03.486 --> 01:03:05.588
Yes, extremely high accuracy.

1104
01:03:05.648 --> 01:03:10.911
This is from the Max Planck Institute for Quantum Optics, and it was published in Nature.

1105
01:03:10.951 --> 01:03:12.052
I'm excited for this one.

1106
01:03:12.072 --> 01:03:12.612
Let's dig in.

1107
01:03:13.072 --> 01:03:13.292
Yeah.

1108
01:03:13.833 --> 01:03:15.134
We'll start with the standard model.

1109
01:03:15.394 --> 01:03:15.574
Yes.

1110
01:03:15.594 --> 01:03:22.618
The standard model of particle physics is the most successful model that we have to date about our universe.

1111
01:03:23.158 --> 01:03:23.399
Okay?

1112
01:03:23.819 --> 01:03:25.440
It's the model that...

1113
01:03:26.872 --> 01:03:32.494
The working constituents are the fundamental particles, or I should really say the fundamental quantum fields.

1114
01:03:33.294 --> 01:03:34.755
The Higgs boson comes out of it.

1115
01:03:34.935 --> 01:03:38.336
The electron, the proton is actually not in the standard model.

1116
01:03:38.456 --> 01:03:40.116
You have up and down quarks.

1117
01:03:40.557 --> 01:03:43.378
Those are the constituents of the protons and the neutrons.

1118
01:03:43.958 --> 01:03:45.058
And it's incredible.

1119
01:03:45.738 --> 01:03:47.859
It is incredible, but it is incomplete.

1120
01:03:48.259 --> 01:03:49.239
There's no dark matter.

1121
01:03:49.740 --> 01:03:50.820
There's no dark energy.

1122
01:03:51.320 --> 01:03:52.361
And there's no gravity.

1123
01:03:53.161 --> 01:03:56.242
So we've always been in the search for new physics.

1124
01:03:56.862 --> 01:04:00.884
How do we break the standard model so we can find out what is missing?

1125
01:04:01.445 --> 01:04:04.406
And what is the path forward to find out what is missing?

1126
01:04:04.686 --> 01:04:06.367
This is the idea of like unification.

1127
01:04:06.387 --> 01:04:06.627
Yeah.

1128
01:04:06.647 --> 01:04:08.328
A grand unified theory.

1129
01:04:08.348 --> 01:04:08.549
Yeah.

1130
01:04:08.629 --> 01:04:08.849
Yeah.

1131
01:04:08.909 --> 01:04:12.231
Not just unification, but also these new particles like is dark matter a particle?

1132
01:04:12.451 --> 01:04:13.311
I understood.

1133
01:04:13.331 --> 01:04:16.393
That's like not even has anything to do with unifying with gravity.

1134
01:04:16.413 --> 01:04:17.894
It's like there's just a whole set of...

1135
01:04:18.494 --> 01:04:20.155
other particles that we don't know anything about.

1136
01:04:20.175 --> 01:04:21.717
Most of the universe, we have no idea what it is.

1137
01:04:21.797 --> 01:04:23.058
Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly.

1138
01:04:23.078 --> 01:04:25.019
So there's got to be a way for us to find out, right?

1139
01:04:25.039 --> 01:04:25.179
Right.

1140
01:04:25.399 --> 01:04:33.225
And usually when we think about probing that frontier of particle physics, we think about particle accelerators, right?

1141
01:04:33.786 --> 01:04:35.467
The most famous one is the one at CERN.

1142
01:04:35.627 --> 01:04:40.651
The Large Hadron Collider is, you know, tens of kilometers long.

1143
01:04:41.011 --> 01:04:47.015
They want to build like a giant future collider that's hundreds of kilometers long.

1144
01:04:48.037 --> 01:04:53.439
They want a lot of money because they want to build these large, large colliders.

1145
01:04:54.319 --> 01:04:59.361
Higher energy means we can probe the depths of these particles in these fields.

1146
01:05:00.222 --> 01:05:09.205
But there's another frontier that physicists talk about when they're looking to test the standard model, and that is the precision frontier.

1147
01:05:10.105 --> 01:05:13.927
And it might offer an equally vital search for new physics.

1148
01:05:15.034 --> 01:05:25.982
What you can do is instead of building giant particle colliders, you build extremely precise experiments in your lab, in a room, in a physics department.

1149
01:05:26.643 --> 01:05:34.709
And you're able to now measure stuff so precisely that perhaps you can discern between what is known physics and what is new.

1150
01:05:35.089 --> 01:05:41.574
This particular photograph is from the Max Planck Institute.

1151
01:05:42.863 --> 01:05:51.846
And I saw this actually on LinkedIn from the author of the study that we're going to talk about, Lothar Meissenbacher.

1152
01:05:51.866 --> 01:05:52.266
Okay.

1153
01:05:52.526 --> 01:05:57.568
He posted this photo of his lab that actually made this measurement of the size of the proton.

1154
01:05:57.588 --> 01:05:58.208
Okay.

1155
01:05:58.228 --> 01:06:05.211
And what it reminds me of is a colloquium that I had attended at UCLA when I was a PhD student there.

1156
01:06:05.891 --> 01:06:09.612
It was a colloquium given by Dave DeMille, who's now at University of Chicago.

1157
01:06:09.672 --> 01:06:11.092
He used to be at Yale.

1158
01:06:11.852 --> 01:06:17.293
He was one of these precision physicists, AMO, atomic molecular optical physicists.

1159
01:06:17.933 --> 01:06:24.655
And he was showing the lab setup, and he was trying to measure the dipole moment of the electron.

1160
01:06:24.695 --> 01:06:26.915
Effectively, how round is the electron?

1161
01:06:27.175 --> 01:06:30.576
We think the electron is the roundest object in the universe.

1162
01:06:30.916 --> 01:06:31.136
Okay?

1163
01:06:31.516 --> 01:06:31.696
But—

1164
01:06:32.507 --> 01:06:36.350
there's a possibility that it's like got a tiny bump on the North pole.

1165
01:06:36.370 --> 01:06:36.871
Okay.

1166
01:06:37.071 --> 01:06:37.291
Right.

1167
01:06:37.411 --> 01:06:40.514
And the, and the not tiny bump on the South pole.

1168
01:06:40.814 --> 01:06:44.878
So there, there might be a little bit of not roundedness in the electron.

1169
01:06:45.138 --> 01:06:46.299
And he wanted to measure that.

1170
01:06:46.420 --> 01:06:50.823
And what he was showing was, he showed a photo of his lab and he would,

1171
01:06:53.033 --> 01:06:55.854
The path of the laser light is a few meters, things like that.

1172
01:06:56.334 --> 01:07:10.622
But he would put that as .001 kilometers, and he would do a dig at the particle accelerator guys and be like, I'm going to put this in a unit of length that these particle accelerator guys can understand.

1173
01:07:10.662 --> 01:07:14.344
So this is about .001 kilometers.

1174
01:07:15.044 --> 01:07:17.085
The size of my lens is about .0.

1175
01:07:17.445 --> 01:07:20.327
And it was just so funny, dude, because it's just like...

1176
01:07:20.867 --> 01:07:22.109
He's just like pulling their leg.

1177
01:07:22.169 --> 01:07:22.770
That's quite nice.

1178
01:07:22.930 --> 01:07:24.572
I think it was so funny.

1179
01:07:24.712 --> 01:07:26.835
Look, it's okay to take the piss every once in a while.

1180
01:07:27.016 --> 01:07:28.157
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1181
01:07:28.257 --> 01:07:29.920
He was a really funny guy.

1182
01:07:30.240 --> 01:07:31.582
Really great speaker as well.

1183
01:07:32.003 --> 01:07:35.367
So what these guys are trying to do at the Max Planck Institute –

1184
01:07:36.088 --> 01:07:46.834
when they came out with this landmark nature paper in February 2026, so just this month, is try to solve the proton radius puzzle.

1185
01:07:47.194 --> 01:07:47.474
Okay?

1186
01:07:47.995 --> 01:07:53.958
There's been a decade-long discrepancy in how big the proton is.

1187
01:07:54.258 --> 01:07:54.558
Okay?

1188
01:07:54.818 --> 01:07:58.941
And this particular paper in Nature is trying to put that to rest.

1189
01:07:59.121 --> 01:07:59.341
Yes.

1190
01:07:59.401 --> 01:07:59.661
Okay?

1191
01:08:00.582 --> 01:08:02.583
Subpart per trillion test results.

1192
01:08:03.507 --> 01:08:06.249
Of the standard model with atomic hydrogen.

1193
01:08:06.289 --> 01:08:07.209
What a great name.

1194
01:08:08.370 --> 01:08:08.630
You know?

1195
01:08:08.830 --> 01:08:13.373
They're testing the standard model with just a normal hydrogen atom.

1196
01:08:13.533 --> 01:08:13.833
Okay.

1197
01:08:13.973 --> 01:08:14.213
Okay?

1198
01:08:14.534 --> 01:08:16.815
This is out of the Max Planck Institute for Quantum Optics.

1199
01:08:17.095 --> 01:08:17.315
Yes.

1200
01:08:17.775 --> 01:08:22.138
And the precision is 0.7 parts per trillion.

1201
01:08:22.198 --> 01:08:23.539
That's pretty small.

1202
01:08:23.739 --> 01:08:23.959
Yeah.

1203
01:08:24.159 --> 01:08:24.780
That's pretty small.

1204
01:08:24.800 --> 01:08:25.340
That's pretty small.

1205
01:08:25.360 --> 01:08:29.502
And I want to give you a sense of just how small that is and why that's, like, ridiculous.

1206
01:08:29.622 --> 01:08:29.883
Okay.

1207
01:08:30.243 --> 01:08:30.503
Okay?

1208
01:08:31.564 --> 01:08:31.824
Um...

1209
01:08:32.755 --> 01:08:34.857
We're going to start with the hydrogen atom.

1210
01:08:35.078 --> 01:08:35.378
Okay.

1211
01:08:35.738 --> 01:08:36.720
This is our favorite atom.

1212
01:08:36.840 --> 01:08:38.301
Every physicist's favorite atom.

1213
01:08:38.762 --> 01:08:43.607
If you don't understand the hydrogen atom, there's no hope in understanding anything else.

1214
01:08:43.627 --> 01:08:46.210
And it's something that we do on our first...

1215
01:08:47.274 --> 01:08:49.035
First semester, quantum mechanics.

1216
01:08:49.115 --> 01:08:56.798
You do the Schrodinger equation and you solve the hydrogen atom because it is the only atom that you can perfectly solve for.

1217
01:08:56.958 --> 01:08:57.238
Okay.

1218
01:08:57.938 --> 01:09:00.279
The idea with quantum mechanics is the following, right?

1219
01:09:00.359 --> 01:09:02.520
We can never observe the electron.

1220
01:09:02.560 --> 01:09:08.482
This is something that Heisenberg said when he actually came up with quantum mechanics 100 years ago in 1925.

1221
01:09:08.542 --> 01:09:14.325
We can never observe the electron moving around a hydrogen atom, but what we can observe...

1222
01:09:15.025 --> 01:09:22.209
is electrons jumping from one energy state to another energy state, because that's when light comes out.

1223
01:09:22.909 --> 01:09:29.152
When we make hydrogen atoms glow, certain colors are emitted by that hydrogen atom.

1224
01:09:29.212 --> 01:09:31.053
Different atoms emit different colors.

1225
01:09:31.453 --> 01:09:38.016
And by observing those colors of light, we can discern the structure of the atom inside.

1226
01:09:38.536 --> 01:09:41.798
That's always the game when it comes to quantum optics.

1227
01:09:42.198 --> 01:09:42.478
Okay?

1228
01:09:45.425 --> 01:09:48.707
These shells are not just like simple bore shells.

1229
01:09:49.048 --> 01:09:50.449
They're actually very complicated.

1230
01:09:50.629 --> 01:09:50.889
Okay.

1231
01:09:50.929 --> 01:09:52.230
The hydrogen wave function...

1232
01:09:53.917 --> 01:09:59.420
looks like very cool clouds of electrons around the central proton.

1233
01:09:59.460 --> 01:10:01.962
This looks like some sick app icons right here.

1234
01:10:02.102 --> 01:10:06.745
Yeah, but that's actually what the electrons are doing around a hydrogen atom.

1235
01:10:06.785 --> 01:10:14.830
If you were to put them in certain orbitals, in certain states of angular momentum and energy, they would occupy those clouds.

1236
01:10:15.230 --> 01:10:18.492
Those are the probability clouds that the electrons occupy.

1237
01:10:18.572 --> 01:10:18.852
Okay?

1238
01:10:18.872 --> 01:10:19.132
Got it.

1239
01:10:19.293 --> 01:10:19.753
And so...

1240
01:10:22.048 --> 01:10:28.887
What we want to do when we want to probe something like what is the size of the proton is we want to probe...

1241
01:10:30.160 --> 01:10:37.221
what the colors of light are and how those colors of light shift when the proton is yay big versus yay big.

1242
01:10:37.461 --> 01:10:37.661
Right.

1243
01:10:37.761 --> 01:10:38.022
Okay.

1244
01:10:38.042 --> 01:10:52.784
Because if the proton is some size or some other size, what that is going to do is change the electron orbitals, which will then change the light that comes out when electrons transition from one orbital to the other.

1245
01:10:52.824 --> 01:10:53.024
Yes.

1246
01:10:53.264 --> 01:10:53.444
Yes.

1247
01:10:53.664 --> 01:10:54.625
Is that perfectly clear?

1248
01:10:54.665 --> 01:10:54.965
Yeah.

1249
01:10:54.985 --> 01:10:56.085
So different sizes...

1250
01:10:56.965 --> 01:11:09.472
Of the proton, the way in which we can look at the way in which we understand the probabilities of where the electron will be, which is this electron cloud concept, is going to be fundamentally different.

1251
01:11:09.552 --> 01:11:09.812
Yes.

1252
01:11:10.072 --> 01:11:20.597
And we use, like, the color spectra, the energy, and how it appears as a means by which to identify what those cloud configurations will look like?

1253
01:11:20.777 --> 01:11:21.058
Yes.

1254
01:11:21.518 --> 01:11:23.619
If the proton is a certain size, it's a certain size.

1255
01:11:23.799 --> 01:11:37.845
The cloud will look a tiny bit different, which means that the light that comes out when the electron transitions from one cloud, one energy state to another, is going to be slightly different frequency.

1256
01:11:37.885 --> 01:11:38.085
Yes.

1257
01:11:38.306 --> 01:11:44.969
And if we can measure that very precisely, then we can tell, back calculate what the size of the proton is.

1258
01:11:45.109 --> 01:11:46.109
I see what you're saying.

1259
01:11:46.189 --> 01:11:46.869
And so, okay.

1260
01:11:47.170 --> 01:11:47.370
Yes.

1261
01:11:47.550 --> 01:11:47.930
Makes sense.

1262
01:11:48.310 --> 01:11:52.772
So what we're getting at is we're not measuring the proton directly.

1263
01:11:52.792 --> 01:11:54.012
Yeah, you're not taking a ruler.

1264
01:11:54.232 --> 01:11:58.414
Right, and looking like, hey, here's the, it's, you know, three angstrom.

1265
01:11:58.454 --> 01:12:06.197
What we're saying is there is an emission, which is this electron changing energy states.

1266
01:12:06.937 --> 01:12:10.959
That emission, if we measure that emission with a level of precision,

1267
01:12:12.312 --> 01:12:16.234
we can derive the size of the proton from that quote.

1268
01:12:16.294 --> 01:12:18.496
I'm using emission as a loose term here.

1269
01:12:18.856 --> 01:12:19.276
Exactly.

1270
01:12:19.356 --> 01:12:20.897
And if we look at photo number eight, right?

1271
01:12:20.917 --> 01:12:21.117
Yes.

1272
01:12:22.018 --> 01:12:24.480
The electrons are in these different clouds.

1273
01:12:24.800 --> 01:12:25.020
Yes.

1274
01:12:25.260 --> 01:12:26.581
There's different orbitals.

1275
01:12:26.641 --> 01:12:33.825
For those in chemistry, you guys will remember something called 1s, 1s2, 2s2, 2p6, 3s2, 3p6.

1276
01:12:33.905 --> 01:12:40.810
It's like a rap game that we used to memorize about all the electron configurations of each of the elements on the periodic table.

1277
01:12:40.830 --> 01:12:41.510
Yeah.

1278
01:12:41.510 --> 01:12:45.914
So each of these orbitals are shapes of the electron clouds.

1279
01:12:46.254 --> 01:12:48.716
The 1s and the 2s are spherical.

1280
01:12:49.336 --> 01:12:49.556
Okay.

1281
01:12:49.576 --> 01:12:51.238
There's no net angular momentum.

1282
01:12:51.758 --> 01:12:57.062
But like the 2ps, those are when electrons are lobed in particular axes.

1283
01:12:57.102 --> 01:12:59.945
Like there's the x-axis, the y-axis, and the z-axis, right?

1284
01:13:00.185 --> 01:13:01.706
And that's that second energy level.

1285
01:13:01.986 --> 01:13:03.868
The first energy level, there's just the sphere.

1286
01:13:03.888 --> 01:13:04.088
Yeah.

1287
01:13:04.268 --> 01:13:11.253
The second energy level, the electron can be in the sphere, or it can be in these like dungbell shapes along the three axes, right?

1288
01:13:11.353 --> 01:13:11.573
Yes.

1289
01:13:11.794 --> 01:13:15.296
Now notice, the 1s and the 2s, those are spheres.

1290
01:13:15.556 --> 01:13:15.756
Yes.

1291
01:13:15.877 --> 01:13:17.378
Those will actually interact.

1292
01:13:17.986 --> 01:13:20.990
With the proton, if there's a proton in the middle of that sphere.

1293
01:13:21.110 --> 01:13:21.351
Okay.

1294
01:13:21.511 --> 01:13:21.751
Okay?

1295
01:13:22.092 --> 01:13:26.918
The 2S and the 2P, most of the time, the electron is hanging out on the outside.

1296
01:13:27.359 --> 01:13:30.082
It's not hanging out near the nucleus of the atom.

1297
01:13:30.323 --> 01:13:32.626
Which in this context is where the XYZ intersects.

1298
01:13:32.766 --> 01:13:33.707
Yeah, the center.

1299
01:13:33.847 --> 01:13:34.008
Yes.

1300
01:13:34.048 --> 01:13:34.228
Right?

1301
01:13:34.428 --> 01:13:34.588
Yes.

1302
01:13:34.628 --> 01:13:35.069
And so...

1303
01:13:36.010 --> 01:13:44.932
By looking at transitions between these different energies, we can figure out what is the contribution of the proton that's in the center and what is not.

1304
01:13:45.292 --> 01:13:46.592
Because we're looking at basically the difference.

1305
01:13:46.752 --> 01:13:47.012
Yes.

1306
01:13:47.172 --> 01:13:47.412
Yes.

1307
01:13:47.772 --> 01:13:51.753
Because the difference in these energies tells us what the frequency of the light that will come out.

1308
01:13:52.013 --> 01:13:53.993
Higher frequency means higher energy difference.

1309
01:13:54.213 --> 01:13:54.453
Okay?

1310
01:13:55.033 --> 01:13:58.934
But to give you a sense of the scale of what we're talking about, right?

1311
01:14:00.374 --> 01:14:03.595
Because we're – let's not lose sight of the fact –

1312
01:14:04.135 --> 01:14:09.498
That we're talking about a hydrogen atom, and on top of that, we're talking about a proton at the center of the hydrogen atom.

1313
01:14:09.518 --> 01:14:11.038
Right.

1314
01:14:11.158 --> 01:14:17.981
The proton at the center of the hydrogen atom is measured in femtometers, which is 10 to the minus 15 meters.

1315
01:14:18.281 --> 01:14:18.642
Okay.

1316
01:14:18.782 --> 01:14:22.463
The hydrogen atom itself is about an angstrom, which is 10 to the minus 10.

1317
01:14:23.024 --> 01:14:24.244
Okay, so there's 100,000 meters.

1318
01:14:27.467 --> 01:14:55.049
difference between the size of a hydrogen atom and the size of a proton at the center of the hydrogen atom and to visualize this unimaginable scale i wanted to consider an analogy okay okay if a single hydrogen atom is expanded to the size of a professional sports stadium then the proton that's at its center is like the size of a p oh my god at the 50 yard line oh my god that's not that's not the worst part though okay in order to discern the size of the p

1319
01:14:56.725 --> 01:15:00.448
We are looking at an electron that is in the grandstands.

1320
01:15:00.568 --> 01:15:03.009
Oh, my God.

1321
01:15:03.069 --> 01:15:03.750
You see what I'm saying?

1322
01:15:03.770 --> 01:15:04.330
Yeah, no, that's ridiculous.

1323
01:15:04.350 --> 01:15:06.692
Because the electron is hanging out all the way out here.

1324
01:15:06.732 --> 01:15:07.132
Over there.

1325
01:15:07.192 --> 01:15:15.118
We're looking at the behavior of these electrons that are hanging out at the grandstands to figure out how big is the P on the 50-yard line.

1326
01:15:16.098 --> 01:15:17.439
I just – I have no – I have nothing.

1327
01:15:17.459 --> 01:15:20.341
I just don't even – I don't even know what to say.

1328
01:15:20.361 --> 01:15:22.903
It is insane that we can do these kinds of calculations.

1329
01:15:22.923 --> 01:15:23.483
That's what I'm saying.

1330
01:15:23.503 --> 01:15:24.004
Like, that's –

1331
01:15:25.854 --> 01:15:28.896
Yeah, because I'm trying to even think about how you would do that at macro scale.

1332
01:15:29.016 --> 01:15:29.676
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1333
01:15:29.776 --> 01:15:31.877
If I had a P. Yeah, yeah.

1334
01:15:31.977 --> 01:15:38.121
I can't have a P. What kind of telephoto lens would I need at the grandstand?

1335
01:15:38.241 --> 01:15:38.721
To be able to.

1336
01:15:39.361 --> 01:15:39.561
Yeah.

1337
01:15:39.762 --> 01:15:40.102
Okay.

1338
01:15:40.182 --> 01:15:43.824
So this is something that is so infinitesimally small.

1339
01:15:44.724 --> 01:15:55.090
And meaning the way in which we do all, like the engineering we do to even be able to do this stuff has to be able to operate at these impossibly small.

1340
01:15:55.430 --> 01:15:55.670
Yes.

1341
01:15:55.950 --> 01:15:56.370
Scales.

1342
01:15:56.670 --> 01:15:56.890
Yeah.

1343
01:15:57.070 --> 01:15:59.351
And at impossibly small error.

1344
01:16:00.091 --> 01:16:00.411
Right.

1345
01:16:00.531 --> 01:16:01.411
That's the main part.

1346
01:16:01.431 --> 01:16:01.651
Right.

1347
01:16:01.971 --> 01:16:02.192
Right.

1348
01:16:02.232 --> 01:16:05.772
You're chasing down like 12 decimal places.

1349
01:16:05.992 --> 01:16:06.192
Right.

1350
01:16:06.673 --> 01:16:06.973
Okay.

1351
01:16:07.013 --> 01:16:07.173
Right.

1352
01:16:07.213 --> 01:16:08.953
That's a really important point.

1353
01:16:09.013 --> 01:16:09.113
Yeah.

1354
01:16:09.133 --> 01:16:10.493
Because it's not just like, oh, we got no.

1355
01:16:10.513 --> 01:16:14.574
It's like to a level of specificity where 12 decimals is crazy.

1356
01:16:14.734 --> 01:16:15.555
Which it's insane.

1357
01:16:15.575 --> 01:16:16.635
It's like, no, it's not that.

1358
01:16:16.695 --> 01:16:17.255
It's actually...

1359
01:16:18.090 --> 01:16:18.350
This.

1360
01:16:18.531 --> 01:16:18.991
Yeah.

1361
01:16:19.392 --> 01:16:19.652
Okay.

1362
01:16:19.712 --> 01:16:20.193
Oh, my God.

1363
01:16:20.213 --> 01:16:20.653
My brain.

1364
01:16:20.934 --> 01:16:21.554
Yeah.

1365
01:16:21.695 --> 01:16:22.636
It's absolutely nuts.

1366
01:16:22.776 --> 01:16:23.056
Okay.

1367
01:16:23.116 --> 01:16:25.219
So here's how we're going to do it.

1368
01:16:25.379 --> 01:16:25.619
Okay.

1369
01:16:25.639 --> 01:16:25.900
Okay.

1370
01:16:26.280 --> 01:16:29.945
We are going to calculate the transition frequency between different...

1371
01:16:31.680 --> 01:16:32.060
orbitals.

1372
01:16:32.380 --> 01:16:32.600
Okay.

1373
01:16:32.620 --> 01:16:32.901
Okay.

1374
01:16:33.441 --> 01:16:39.043
When we do that, this is the equation of what an electron sees when it's on the outside.

1375
01:16:39.063 --> 01:16:41.104
This is the binding energy of atomic hydrogen.

1376
01:16:41.484 --> 01:16:45.826
So what is the energy of an electron that's bound to the proton in the center?

1377
01:16:46.466 --> 01:16:49.407
What I love about this is this is the first line of their paper.

1378
01:16:49.667 --> 01:16:55.910
The binding energy of atomic hydrogen can be expressed as a giant equation.

1379
01:16:55.930 --> 01:16:59.211
For those listening, there's like, I don't know, 23 different characters.

1380
01:16:59.311 --> 01:16:59.611
Yeah.

1381
01:16:59.711 --> 01:17:00.292
It's just, it is.

1382
01:17:00.372 --> 01:17:00.672
It's just,

1383
01:17:01.272 --> 01:17:04.153
And it depends on – crucially, it depends on two things, okay?

1384
01:17:04.453 --> 01:17:08.334
It depends on something called the Rydberg constant, which is like a fundamental energy scale.

1385
01:17:08.494 --> 01:17:08.754
Okay.

1386
01:17:08.834 --> 01:17:11.994
And it depends on the proton charge radius, okay?

1387
01:17:12.754 --> 01:17:15.735
Now, those are two different unknowns, right?

1388
01:17:16.235 --> 01:17:20.616
And in order to figure out what those two unknowns are, you need two different observations.

1389
01:17:20.776 --> 01:17:21.956
You can't just rely on one.

1390
01:17:22.337 --> 01:17:24.357
So you can't just rely on a single atomic –

1391
01:17:25.782 --> 01:17:30.291
energy spacing, you need to observe two different transition frequencies.

1392
01:17:30.311 --> 01:17:30.511
I see.

1393
01:17:30.531 --> 01:17:34.719
You need to observe two different colors that are coming out of my atomic hydrogen.

1394
01:17:34.759 --> 01:17:34.979
Okay.

1395
01:17:35.080 --> 01:17:35.841
That makes sense.

1396
01:17:35.861 --> 01:17:36.663
Now the first one

1397
01:17:38.134 --> 01:17:39.155
is the anchor measurement.

1398
01:17:39.195 --> 01:17:40.295
That's already been done before.

1399
01:17:40.636 --> 01:17:40.876
Okay.

1400
01:17:41.336 --> 01:17:44.038
This is the ultra precise 1s to 2s transition.

1401
01:17:44.398 --> 01:17:48.841
What they're doing in this paper is the 6p to 2s transition.

1402
01:17:48.861 --> 01:17:50.282
The 6p orbital looks like that.

1403
01:17:50.602 --> 01:17:54.865
It's dumbbells on top of, it's like a Russian nesting doll of dumbbells.

1404
01:17:54.945 --> 01:17:55.205
Okay.

1405
01:17:55.545 --> 01:18:01.369
What they're looking for is an electron in this particular energy state going down to the 2s state.

1406
01:18:01.929 --> 01:18:02.170
Okay.

1407
01:18:02.570 --> 01:18:05.892
What they want to do here is observe that transition frequency.

1408
01:18:06.012 --> 01:18:09.675
And the 2S state was the larger spherical state that we talked about earlier.

1409
01:18:09.695 --> 01:18:11.136
Yes, that we had talked about earlier.

1410
01:18:11.156 --> 01:18:12.377
This is even bigger than that.

1411
01:18:12.477 --> 01:18:12.677
Okay.

1412
01:18:12.717 --> 01:18:17.982
This is, like, way out in the grandstands to, let's say, like, on the sidelines.

1413
01:18:18.242 --> 01:18:18.422
Yep.

1414
01:18:18.442 --> 01:18:18.622
Right?

1415
01:18:18.902 --> 01:18:22.625
The electron is going from the grandstand all the way to, like, the really nice seats.

1416
01:18:22.645 --> 01:18:23.666
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1417
01:18:23.686 --> 01:18:26.308
And that transition is what they're trying to look for.

1418
01:18:26.408 --> 01:18:26.709
Got it.

1419
01:18:26.809 --> 01:18:27.189
Got it.

1420
01:18:27.209 --> 01:18:27.409
Okay.

1421
01:18:27.529 --> 01:18:27.689
Yep.

1422
01:18:28.330 --> 01:18:28.510
Yep.

1423
01:18:28.790 --> 01:18:30.712
Let's talk about why this is even an issue.

1424
01:18:31.878 --> 01:18:32.118
Right.

1425
01:18:32.319 --> 01:18:32.599
Okay.

1426
01:18:32.759 --> 01:18:33.020
Okay.

1427
01:18:33.160 --> 01:18:33.520
Yeah, yeah.

1428
01:18:33.580 --> 01:18:34.321
Proton size.

1429
01:18:34.802 --> 01:18:35.303
Right.

1430
01:18:35.443 --> 01:18:43.675
Because part of what I said earlier, which may or may not be true, it's like, you know, why can't we just measure it directly?

1431
01:18:44.916 --> 01:18:45.137
Yeah.

1432
01:18:45.217 --> 01:18:45.717
Well, I mean...

1433
01:18:46.947 --> 01:18:49.610
How would you measure something that is a femtometer?

1434
01:18:49.650 --> 01:18:49.810
Right.

1435
01:18:50.411 --> 01:18:55.837
But so like for someone who might not understand the scale of the problem set, it's like, well, why don't you just look at it?

1436
01:18:55.997 --> 01:18:56.197
Yeah.

1437
01:18:56.257 --> 01:19:00.863
And it's like, well, the problem is it's what are we going to use to do that?

1438
01:19:00.963 --> 01:19:01.323
Exactly.

1439
01:19:01.363 --> 01:19:02.564
I mean, you could think, right?

1440
01:19:02.584 --> 01:19:04.086
Like what if we just like set light?

1441
01:19:04.847 --> 01:19:05.107
Okay.

1442
01:19:05.307 --> 01:19:05.568
Okay.

1443
01:19:05.808 --> 01:19:06.789
What if we just had like...

1444
01:19:08.492 --> 01:19:10.074
Light at a femtometer.

1445
01:19:10.494 --> 01:19:11.055
Mm-hmm.

1446
01:19:11.796 --> 01:19:11.956
How...

1447
01:19:12.036 --> 01:19:15.039
I think that kind of light is extremely high frequency.

1448
01:19:15.219 --> 01:19:15.440
Okay.

1449
01:19:15.580 --> 01:19:15.840
Okay?

1450
01:19:16.060 --> 01:19:18.163
Like a light at a wavelength of a femtometer.

1451
01:19:18.223 --> 01:19:19.144
Yeah.

1452
01:19:19.244 --> 01:19:21.546
Anything larger than the obstacle.

1453
01:19:22.087 --> 01:19:24.449
If I were to shine, like, visible light.

1454
01:19:24.509 --> 01:19:24.710
Yes.

1455
01:19:24.810 --> 01:19:26.291
Which is, like, 400 nanometers.

1456
01:19:26.431 --> 01:19:26.552
Right.

1457
01:19:26.572 --> 01:19:26.792
Right.

1458
01:19:27.132 --> 01:19:28.493
On something that is a femtometer.

1459
01:19:28.633 --> 01:19:32.274
400 nanometers is 10 to the minus 7 meters.

1460
01:19:32.794 --> 01:19:34.315
This thing is 10 to the minus 15.

1461
01:19:34.775 --> 01:19:36.575
Imagine a giant ocean wave.

1462
01:19:37.296 --> 01:19:38.596
And then there's a pebble in the way.

1463
01:19:39.316 --> 01:19:40.597
Is the ocean wave going to care?

1464
01:19:41.297 --> 01:19:42.137
No.

1465
01:19:42.358 --> 01:19:47.860
The way we image things is that the wavelength of light needs to be way smaller than the thing we're measuring.

1466
01:19:48.060 --> 01:19:51.621
Because then the light bends and refracts and bounces off.

1467
01:19:51.741 --> 01:19:52.541
This is important.

1468
01:19:52.561 --> 01:19:54.462
But if it's like, you know...

1469
01:19:55.183 --> 01:20:02.031
The object we're trying to measure is literally half the size of the wavelength of light we would send at it to even measure it.

1470
01:20:02.111 --> 01:20:02.912
Yeah, not even half.

1471
01:20:02.992 --> 01:20:05.475
No, it's a hundred thousandth.

1472
01:20:05.956 --> 01:20:06.677
A hundred thousandth.

1473
01:20:06.697 --> 01:20:07.818
Or a millionth the size.

1474
01:20:07.939 --> 01:20:08.740
So it literally is.

1475
01:20:08.820 --> 01:20:09.440
It's a pebble.

1476
01:20:09.460 --> 01:20:09.941
With a tsunami.

1477
01:20:09.961 --> 01:20:10.662
With a tsunami.

1478
01:20:10.822 --> 01:20:17.307
Like, no, a grain of sand versus, like, the Nazare, you know, the Portugal wave.

1479
01:20:17.327 --> 01:20:18.468
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

1480
01:20:18.488 --> 01:20:20.069
The 100-foot wave in Nazare, Portugal.

1481
01:20:20.089 --> 01:20:21.530
Yeah, in Nazare, Portugal.

1482
01:20:21.551 --> 01:20:21.911
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1483
01:20:21.991 --> 01:20:28.936
Do you think the Nazare, Portugal wave cares about a tiny bit of grain of sand misplaced one way or the other?

1484
01:20:28.976 --> 01:20:29.857
No, it really doesn't.

1485
01:20:29.897 --> 01:20:30.077
Right.

1486
01:20:30.137 --> 01:20:32.319
So we got to get really clever with this kind of stuff.

1487
01:20:32.439 --> 01:20:35.981
So we can't just image it the way we normally do optical imaging.

1488
01:20:36.081 --> 01:20:36.241
No.

1489
01:20:36.401 --> 01:20:39.803
It's just the scale is not – it doesn't even make sense.

1490
01:20:39.863 --> 01:20:40.743
It doesn't even make sense.

1491
01:20:40.803 --> 01:20:41.484
Yeah, exactly.

1492
01:20:41.504 --> 01:20:41.784
Okay.

1493
01:20:41.864 --> 01:20:43.365
And so people have done it before.

1494
01:20:43.425 --> 01:20:46.366
People have measured the size of a proton before.

1495
01:20:46.526 --> 01:20:46.726
Yes.

1496
01:20:46.806 --> 01:20:56.071
And it came out to about 0.8758 according to this giant consortium where they had like electrons that would scatter off nuclei.

1497
01:20:56.091 --> 01:20:56.692
Yeah, yeah.

1498
01:20:56.752 --> 01:20:58.893
And then they would try to figure out, okay, like what is the –

1499
01:20:59.433 --> 01:21:01.094
what is the size of the proton in there.

1500
01:21:01.114 --> 01:21:04.416
They also had something called electronic hydrogen spectroscopy.

1501
01:21:04.456 --> 01:21:05.917
It's a traditional laser measurement.

1502
01:21:06.277 --> 01:21:10.259
Kind of similar, but not as insane as the one that we're going to talk about.

1503
01:21:10.660 --> 01:21:14.202
And they got it to about 0.8758 femtometers.

1504
01:21:14.882 --> 01:21:17.364
Then in 2010, there was a bombshell.

1505
01:21:17.404 --> 01:21:17.744
Because...

1506
01:21:18.994 --> 01:21:24.260
Some of the same guys in this current paper made an exotic hydrogen atom.

1507
01:21:24.621 --> 01:21:26.963
They made a hydrogen atom out of muons.

1508
01:21:27.424 --> 01:21:27.764
Okay.

1509
01:21:28.205 --> 01:21:32.550
And they published a paper in Nature called The Size of the Proton.

1510
01:21:32.990 --> 01:21:34.873
This was almost 16 years ago.

1511
01:21:35.033 --> 01:21:35.794
Almost 16 years ago.

1512
01:21:35.814 --> 01:21:36.455
These guys published...

1513
01:21:39.244 --> 01:21:45.831
a hydrogen atom, where instead of an electron moving around it, they've got a muon that moves around it.

1514
01:21:45.931 --> 01:21:51.336
A muon is the close cousin of the electron, but it's 200 times more massive.

1515
01:21:51.837 --> 01:21:53.718
And because it's 200 times more massive...

1516
01:21:56.116 --> 01:22:01.558
The atom that you create with a proton and a muon is going to be 200 times smaller.

1517
01:22:01.638 --> 01:22:05.600
And we've got a little sort of like thing to show for that, right?

1518
01:22:05.620 --> 01:22:09.902
The atom is going to be – the muonic hydrogen is going to be 200 times smaller.

1519
01:22:10.362 --> 01:22:20.606
If it's 200 times smaller, that muon – effectively what we've done is take that giant stadium and turn it into like a high school stadium.

1520
01:22:20.686 --> 01:22:20.946
Now –

1521
01:22:21.746 --> 01:22:28.450
The relationship between my muon and the proton is going to be a lot closer, and my error bar is going to be smaller.

1522
01:22:29.411 --> 01:22:34.914
The measurement we're trying to make is the distance between the electron and the grandstands and the proton at the 50-yard line.

1523
01:22:34.974 --> 01:22:39.077
Yeah, effectively, we're trying to get, like, the light that comes out of this atom.

1524
01:22:39.117 --> 01:22:42.379
The smaller the atom is, like, the more we can sort of...

1525
01:22:43.351 --> 01:22:45.572
nail down exactly what that frequency is.

1526
01:22:45.712 --> 01:22:46.632
Right.

1527
01:22:47.012 --> 01:22:49.372
The delta for error is much smaller.

1528
01:22:49.412 --> 01:22:51.993
Yeah, because we've effectively made the atom smaller.

1529
01:22:52.053 --> 01:22:52.253
Right.

1530
01:22:52.613 --> 01:22:52.833
Right.

1531
01:22:53.013 --> 01:23:00.755
And the key idea here was the muon as the orbiting part, as opposed to a standard electron.

1532
01:23:01.195 --> 01:23:05.396
It was much more massive, which meant the proton necessarily needed to be smaller, which is what creates...

1533
01:23:05.416 --> 01:23:06.396
The atom needs to be smaller.

1534
01:23:06.436 --> 01:23:06.797
Excuse me.

1535
01:23:07.077 --> 01:23:12.258
The atom needs to be smaller, which is what collapsed the surface area of the measurement to be this more...

1536
01:23:13.458 --> 01:23:14.279
Deal with a bowl.

1537
01:23:14.499 --> 01:23:14.759
Yes.

1538
01:23:14.959 --> 01:23:15.300
Size.

1539
01:23:15.360 --> 01:23:15.620
Yes.

1540
01:23:16.140 --> 01:23:19.583
And we got a whole new number for the size of the proton there.

1541
01:23:20.003 --> 01:23:21.524
0.84 instead of 0.87.

1542
01:23:21.544 --> 01:23:22.205
Okay.

1543
01:23:23.065 --> 01:23:26.428
Already on the second significant figure, we're off.

1544
01:23:27.825 --> 01:23:28.345
Okay.

1545
01:23:28.465 --> 01:23:31.886
That is unheard of for physicists who are doing precision measurement.

1546
01:23:31.906 --> 01:23:34.467
They're like, this is absolutely awful.

1547
01:23:34.827 --> 01:23:35.307
Okay.

1548
01:23:35.468 --> 01:23:35.728
Okay.

1549
01:23:35.748 --> 01:23:40.589
That's like almost 5% difference.

1550
01:23:40.629 --> 01:23:40.969
Yeah.

1551
01:23:40.989 --> 01:23:41.589
That's unacceptable.

1552
01:23:41.609 --> 01:23:42.590
That's unacceptable.

1553
01:23:43.190 --> 01:23:43.490
Okay.

1554
01:23:43.550 --> 01:23:44.710
In every sense of the word.

1555
01:23:45.211 --> 01:23:45.511
There's two...

1556
01:23:46.968 --> 01:23:47.989
There's two possibilities.

1557
01:23:48.350 --> 01:23:48.610
Okay.

1558
01:23:48.690 --> 01:23:48.931
Okay?

1559
01:23:49.031 --> 01:23:53.176
Either our theory is wrong, meaning leptons are not universal.

1560
01:23:53.676 --> 01:23:58.042
We used to think that the muon and the electron, the only thing that's different between them is the mass.

1561
01:23:58.743 --> 01:24:05.671
But what if there's new physics and the muon is actually behaving differently around my proton, which is why I'm getting this different...

1562
01:24:06.307 --> 01:24:34.055
measurement okay yeah either that or okay there's some undetected systematic error in the earlier measurement of the electron hydrogen basically the first time we did it something was wrong something was wrong no or no one caught it at the time yeah but now we get it or there's literal new physics right that's one of the two it's one of the two and now you can see why this is such a big deal yeah we need to really figure out if that first measurement was was actually wrong correct because that's actually a okay yes right that would be a big deal

1563
01:24:34.215 --> 01:24:41.217
That would be a big deal because if the first measurement was correct, then this is a really big deal because then that means there is actually new physics.

1564
01:24:41.257 --> 01:24:44.217
The muon and the electron are actually different somehow.

1565
01:24:44.257 --> 01:24:44.457
Yes.

1566
01:24:44.677 --> 01:24:47.718
And there's like now the theorists are super happy.

1567
01:24:47.758 --> 01:24:47.918
Right.

1568
01:24:47.938 --> 01:24:48.138
Right.

1569
01:24:48.258 --> 01:24:48.438
Right.

1570
01:24:48.858 --> 01:24:51.239
Or the experimentalists are not happy.

1571
01:24:51.319 --> 01:24:51.619
Yeah.

1572
01:24:51.859 --> 01:24:57.720
And these new experimentalists are happy because they like their muonic hydrogen measurement was actually correct.

1573
01:24:57.781 --> 01:24:57.981
Yes.

1574
01:24:58.141 --> 01:24:59.381
And it's like everybody else.

1575
01:24:59.441 --> 01:25:01.301
Theorists go back to the chalkboard.

1576
01:25:01.441 --> 01:25:01.641
Yeah.

1577
01:25:01.661 --> 01:25:02.282
Yeah.

1578
01:25:02.502 --> 01:25:03.542
It's not a field day for you guys.

1579
01:25:03.562 --> 01:25:03.682
Right.

1580
01:25:03.722 --> 01:25:03.862
Right.

1581
01:25:04.582 --> 01:25:08.524
And so that's where this current experiment comes in.

1582
01:25:08.564 --> 01:25:09.924
Oh, this is fascinating.

1583
01:25:09.964 --> 01:25:12.145
They replicated that muon experiment.

1584
01:25:12.305 --> 01:25:12.865
Okay.

1585
01:25:12.965 --> 01:25:13.785
From 2010.

1586
01:25:13.865 --> 01:25:14.686
From 2010.

1587
01:25:14.866 --> 01:25:20.668
They've been working on it for 10 years to try and nail down this measurement using just normal...

1588
01:25:21.348 --> 01:25:22.849
Store grade hydrogen.

1589
01:25:23.189 --> 01:25:23.429
Okay.

1590
01:25:23.589 --> 01:25:23.869
Okay.

1591
01:25:24.389 --> 01:25:25.790
And it's incredibly difficult.

1592
01:25:26.390 --> 01:25:29.831
This is going back to our bigger stadium instead of our muonic smaller stadium.

1593
01:25:29.851 --> 01:25:31.312
Now we're trying to do the same thing.

1594
01:25:31.432 --> 01:25:31.612
Yes.

1595
01:25:31.692 --> 01:25:32.952
But with our bigger stadium.

1596
01:25:32.992 --> 01:25:35.013
And with a bigger stadium, there's a lot more problems.

1597
01:25:35.033 --> 01:25:35.213
Yes.

1598
01:25:35.533 --> 01:25:35.873
Yes.

1599
01:25:35.953 --> 01:25:36.194
Okay.

1600
01:25:36.414 --> 01:25:39.495
And it's just incredible some of the stuff that they were dealing with, dude.

1601
01:25:40.307 --> 01:25:41.908
It's actually insane.

1602
01:25:42.288 --> 01:25:43.568
Okay?

1603
01:25:43.828 --> 01:25:48.990
The transition that they were trying to figure out was this 6P orbital to 2S.

1604
01:25:49.190 --> 01:25:51.631
So all the way up there to, like, down here.

1605
01:25:52.011 --> 01:25:53.292
There's that transition.

1606
01:25:53.692 --> 01:25:55.453
That transition releases...

1607
01:25:56.473 --> 01:25:59.696
Violet light at 410 nanometers.

1608
01:26:00.016 --> 01:26:00.256
Okay.

1609
01:26:00.316 --> 01:26:01.237
That's the first issue.

1610
01:26:01.457 --> 01:26:01.737
Okay.

1611
01:26:02.238 --> 01:26:04.439
Violet light at 410 nanometers.

1612
01:26:04.479 --> 01:26:05.700
That's really short wavelength.

1613
01:26:06.221 --> 01:26:11.284
We've got lasers at, like, blue and green and red.

1614
01:26:12.065 --> 01:26:13.826
We don't have lasers in violet.

1615
01:26:13.967 --> 01:26:14.207
Okay.

1616
01:26:14.227 --> 01:26:15.548
You can't just buy that off the shelf.

1617
01:26:15.968 --> 01:26:18.990
You've got to make a laser at 410 nanometers.

1618
01:26:19.050 --> 01:26:19.271
Okay.

1619
01:26:19.331 --> 01:26:19.611
Okay?

1620
01:26:19.791 --> 01:26:20.111
Okay.

1621
01:26:20.251 --> 01:26:20.512
So...

1622
01:26:21.332 --> 01:26:22.432
That's something that they had to do.

1623
01:26:22.472 --> 01:26:29.394
They actually took like a titanium sapphire laser, which operates at the infrared at 820 nanometers.

1624
01:26:30.234 --> 01:26:37.316
And they effectively did like a trick where they stuck that inside a nonlinear optical crystal.

1625
01:26:38.096 --> 01:26:40.717
And what this crystal did was, you know how when you like play guitar?

1626
01:26:41.717 --> 01:26:45.420
And you like strum on one of the strings.

1627
01:26:45.820 --> 01:26:49.802
But then if you like clamp down in the middle, then you're going to get the octave higher.

1628
01:26:49.822 --> 01:26:50.023
Yes.

1629
01:26:50.263 --> 01:26:50.463
Right.

1630
01:26:50.723 --> 01:26:52.104
That's what this crystal is doing.

1631
01:26:52.164 --> 01:26:52.484
Okay.

1632
01:26:52.664 --> 01:26:53.425
It takes in...

1633
01:26:54.810 --> 01:27:00.091
a laser light at 820 nanometers, but then effectively squishes the wavelength by half.

1634
01:27:00.651 --> 01:27:03.812
So the frequency goes up by two, and then I get a 410 nanometer.

1635
01:27:04.032 --> 01:27:08.932
For music producers who use keyboards, it's the jog wheel on the left is the same idea.

1636
01:27:08.992 --> 01:27:10.353
When you jog the wheel up.

1637
01:27:10.693 --> 01:27:12.073
Yeah, the octave just goes up.

1638
01:27:12.113 --> 01:27:17.454
This is just like, it's going from, you know, a C to the C that's the dodo.

1639
01:27:17.534 --> 01:27:17.794
Yeah, yeah.

1640
01:27:17.854 --> 01:27:20.074
You know, it's just the octave is now up.

1641
01:27:20.094 --> 01:27:20.274
Yes.

1642
01:27:20.534 --> 01:27:20.634
Okay.

1643
01:27:20.654 --> 01:27:20.994
Makes sense.

1644
01:27:21.255 --> 01:27:23.075
So now we've got a laser.

1645
01:27:23.095 --> 01:27:23.395
Right.

1646
01:27:23.415 --> 01:27:23.595
Right.

1647
01:27:24.175 --> 01:27:27.719
Now we've got to cool our hydrogen atoms down to 5 Kelvin.

1648
01:27:27.799 --> 01:27:28.420
Trivial, you know.

1649
01:27:28.440 --> 01:27:28.820
Trivial.

1650
01:27:29.261 --> 01:27:31.663
Honestly, at this rate, this is pretty trivial.

1651
01:27:31.703 --> 01:27:32.544
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1652
01:27:32.564 --> 01:27:34.006
Okay, cooling them down to 5 Kelvin.

1653
01:27:34.286 --> 01:27:38.911
But even at 5 Kelvin, these hydrogen atoms in your cloud of hydrogen atoms that you're trying to, like...

1654
01:27:39.492 --> 01:27:47.716
probe, those hydrogen atoms are moving at hundreds of meters per second, which means there's going to be some moving towards you, some moving away from you.

1655
01:27:47.736 --> 01:27:49.758
So there's going to be Doppler shifting, right?

1656
01:27:50.078 --> 01:27:55.581
And so if you're trying to measure the frequency of light, well, the guys that are coming towards you...

1657
01:27:56.261 --> 01:27:58.462
They're going to be sensitive to shorter wavelengths.

1658
01:27:58.482 --> 01:28:02.103
The guys that are going away from you are going to be sensitive to the longer wavelengths.

1659
01:28:02.123 --> 01:28:05.444
And so you're going to have a Doppler broadening of your transition line.

1660
01:28:05.464 --> 01:28:10.065
And the whole point is I really need to measure what frequency this transition line is at.

1661
01:28:10.125 --> 01:28:10.325
Yes.

1662
01:28:10.665 --> 01:28:11.085
Okay?

1663
01:28:11.165 --> 01:28:12.926
So that's going to be a huge problem.

1664
01:28:13.026 --> 01:28:14.086
We don't want a range.

1665
01:28:14.246 --> 01:28:15.387
We want an explicit.

1666
01:28:15.407 --> 01:28:15.687
No, yeah.

1667
01:28:16.427 --> 01:28:18.148
I want, like, this is the frequency.

1668
01:28:18.168 --> 01:28:18.389
Yes.

1669
01:28:18.849 --> 01:28:19.049
Right?

1670
01:28:19.249 --> 01:28:19.349
Yes.

1671
01:28:19.409 --> 01:28:20.891
And so here's what they...

1672
01:28:21.231 --> 01:28:21.751
Very cool.

1673
01:28:21.771 --> 01:28:25.234
What they did was Doppler-free one-photon spectroscopy.

1674
01:28:25.554 --> 01:28:30.838
Effectively, the idea is they custom-built, like, these active fiber-based retro reflectors.

1675
01:28:31.278 --> 01:28:31.539
Okay?

1676
01:28:32.119 --> 01:28:35.322
And what it's going to do is it's going to fire a laser at the atoms.

1677
01:28:35.522 --> 01:28:36.723
The atoms are going to capture it.

1678
01:28:37.263 --> 01:28:40.365
And then it's going to... And then the atoms come back.

1679
01:28:40.986 --> 01:28:43.968
It's going to reflect that perfectly back into the atoms.

1680
01:28:44.048 --> 01:28:44.288
Okay?

1681
01:28:44.308 --> 01:28:44.509
Okay.

1682
01:28:45.229 --> 01:28:48.510
The other thing that you want is you want this beam to be perfectly straight.

1683
01:28:49.330 --> 01:28:54.391
The beam of the lasers, it can't be like spreading out as it goes into my apparatus.

1684
01:28:54.731 --> 01:29:03.953
And the usual optics that's built for 486 nanometer wavelengths, which is blue-green, you can buy that like kind of off the shelf.

1685
01:29:04.053 --> 01:29:04.213
Okay.

1686
01:29:04.253 --> 01:29:07.174
There's like specialized science companies where you can buy that stuff.

1687
01:29:07.194 --> 01:29:07.354
Sure.

1688
01:29:07.374 --> 01:29:07.634
Sure.

1689
01:29:08.453 --> 01:29:11.014
If it works for 486, it's not going to work for 410.

1690
01:29:11.534 --> 01:29:12.194
Okay.

1691
01:29:12.394 --> 01:29:17.276
At that frequency, it's the opposite of diminishing returns.

1692
01:29:17.436 --> 01:29:19.157
Every nanometer is a headache.

1693
01:29:19.197 --> 01:29:25.259
So you need to build custom optics such that my beam is completely straight.

1694
01:29:25.399 --> 01:29:28.320
My new purple laser that we also had to custom make.

1695
01:29:28.380 --> 01:29:28.660
Yes.

1696
01:29:28.840 --> 01:29:30.041
We have to keep it in line.

1697
01:29:30.221 --> 01:29:37.107
And so we need these custom, like, literally, like, optics glass lenses that keep it in a line.

1698
01:29:37.307 --> 01:29:37.527
Yeah.

1699
01:29:37.727 --> 01:29:44.612
And because it's a frequency where most optics are not built for it, that purple laser, it's fully, it has to be fully custom.

1700
01:29:44.632 --> 01:29:44.973
Yeah, yeah.

1701
01:29:45.013 --> 01:29:47.274
So the whole thing is, like, a custom apparatus, right?

1702
01:29:47.294 --> 01:29:47.735
We love it.

1703
01:29:47.755 --> 01:29:50.397
And then on top of that, there's, like...

1704
01:29:51.296 --> 01:29:55.358
The quantum hurdle, which is you're putting in light in here, right?

1705
01:29:55.618 --> 01:29:58.579
And the light is like bouncing back because of the earlier thing that I said.

1706
01:29:58.679 --> 01:29:58.799
Yes.

1707
01:29:58.819 --> 01:30:01.981
Well, if the light is going there and bouncing back, now you've created a standing wave.

1708
01:30:02.321 --> 01:30:03.242
Same thing with the guitar.

1709
01:30:03.282 --> 01:30:06.263
When you like pluck a string, it's fastened at both ends.

1710
01:30:06.363 --> 01:30:08.024
So the wave is going to go back and forth.

1711
01:30:08.324 --> 01:30:10.005
It's going to create a standing wave, right?

1712
01:30:10.225 --> 01:30:12.066
There's going to be nodes and anti-nodes.

1713
01:30:12.106 --> 01:30:12.306
Yes.

1714
01:30:12.566 --> 01:30:14.807
Nodes are going to be where the light piles up.

1715
01:30:14.967 --> 01:30:15.127
Yep.

1716
01:30:15.327 --> 01:30:16.908
Anti-nodes are going to be where there's nothing.

1717
01:30:16.928 --> 01:30:17.028
Yes.

1718
01:30:17.048 --> 01:30:17.208
Yes.

1719
01:30:17.408 --> 01:30:19.029
Now, usually you don't care.

1720
01:30:19.309 --> 01:30:19.529
Yes.

1721
01:30:19.589 --> 01:30:28.812
But when we're doing a precision measurement where we've put hydrogen into the 6p state, the electron orbital is a little bit like it's not spherical.

1722
01:30:28.912 --> 01:30:29.112
Right.

1723
01:30:29.152 --> 01:30:29.372
Right.

1724
01:30:29.832 --> 01:30:39.336
And so because it's got these nodes, that electron is going to start caring about where the antinodes and the nodes are because the electric field is going to be higher here, lower here, higher here.

1725
01:30:39.696 --> 01:30:42.177
And so the hydrogen atom that you're trying to...

1726
01:30:43.037 --> 01:31:01.763
understand is now getting perturbed by the system itself right and so they had to make so many like monte carlo supercomputer simulations to model what would the electron do right in this space yes and and then correct for that right right because because it's

1727
01:31:03.788 --> 01:31:06.270
There's so much headache, which is why this took like 10 years.

1728
01:31:06.330 --> 01:31:08.431
That makes sense.

1729
01:31:08.531 --> 01:31:11.673
It's effectively you have to remove the noise.

1730
01:31:11.973 --> 01:31:13.414
Yeah, it's called the Stark shift.

1731
01:31:13.674 --> 01:31:15.075
Okay, okay, right.

1732
01:31:15.415 --> 01:31:19.158
And in order to do that, you kind of have to simulate first.

1733
01:31:19.218 --> 01:31:19.478
Yeah.

1734
01:31:19.738 --> 01:31:22.560
Because it's too expensive to do it experimentally all these times.

1735
01:31:22.600 --> 01:31:25.402
No, but yeah, it's like the experiment has this artifact –

1736
01:31:25.982 --> 01:31:27.383
In itself.

1737
01:31:27.683 --> 01:31:29.123
I got you.

1738
01:31:29.223 --> 01:31:40.607
It's like when you have Google Photos, and it's the feature where you take a photo of you and your loved one in a crowd, and then they have the Google Magic Eraser, and you just select someone's head behind your head, and then it's gone.

1739
01:31:40.627 --> 01:31:41.328
And you shoot up.

1740
01:31:41.408 --> 01:31:43.028
That's exactly what they're doing.

1741
01:31:43.208 --> 01:31:43.468
Okay.

1742
01:31:43.548 --> 01:31:48.090
But they need to build it and do the Monte Carlo simulation completely.

1743
01:31:48.230 --> 01:31:52.031
In order to then be able to even have the thingy that will remove the noise.

1744
01:31:52.172 --> 01:31:52.692
So they have to...

1745
01:31:54.613 --> 01:32:16.708
it's nuts people i love the i love the uh the just the drive to not be beaten yeah by mother nature yeah no dude no it's like i will figure out what the size of the proton is you are not going to stop me okay it might take me 10 years but i want to know how big the proton is

1746
01:32:18.235 --> 01:32:18.895
That's so good.

1747
01:32:19.276 --> 01:32:19.996
Okay, that makes sense.

1748
01:32:20.036 --> 01:32:22.017
Yeah, it's absolutely nuts.

1749
01:32:22.277 --> 01:32:24.899
And finally, after all of this, they publish their measurement.

1750
01:32:27.080 --> 01:32:28.521
They publish their measurement.

1751
01:32:28.541 --> 01:32:28.841
Okay.

1752
01:32:30.062 --> 01:32:33.584
The blue little starfighter that you see there.

1753
01:32:33.664 --> 01:32:34.424
Yeah, in the middle.

1754
01:32:34.884 --> 01:32:35.325
In the middle?

1755
01:32:35.545 --> 01:32:35.765
Yeah.

1756
01:32:36.085 --> 01:32:38.146
That is their measurement.

1757
01:32:38.486 --> 01:32:39.427
0.84.

1758
01:32:39.747 --> 01:32:40.527
Okay.

1759
01:32:40.888 --> 01:32:41.408
Okay.

1760
01:32:41.808 --> 01:32:44.990
It is in line with their Muon measurement that they took.

1761
01:32:46.551 --> 01:32:47.312
16 years ago.

1762
01:32:47.393 --> 01:32:49.836
So the 0.87, I think it was.

1763
01:32:49.856 --> 01:32:50.437
The 0.87?

1764
01:32:50.457 --> 01:32:51.539
Yeah, yeah.

1765
01:32:51.799 --> 01:32:52.680
That's all these other...

1766
01:32:53.121 --> 01:32:54.002
Things over to the right.

1767
01:32:54.022 --> 01:32:54.122
Yeah.

1768
01:32:54.142 --> 01:32:54.283
Yeah.

1769
01:32:56.154 --> 01:32:57.015
That is wrong.

1770
01:32:57.375 --> 01:32:58.656
You are the weakest link.

1771
01:32:58.796 --> 01:32:59.256
Goodbye.

1772
01:32:59.456 --> 01:32:59.656
Yeah.

1773
01:33:00.137 --> 01:33:00.717
Yeah.

1774
01:33:00.837 --> 01:33:02.638
So they corroborated that measurement.

1775
01:33:02.678 --> 01:33:05.500
The muonic hydrogen is the same as the normal hydrogen.

1776
01:33:05.940 --> 01:33:08.842
The true size of the proton is 0.84.

1777
01:33:09.383 --> 01:33:16.087
And there is no new physics, at least in terms of the difference between the muon and the electron.

1778
01:33:16.407 --> 01:33:19.749
They are indeed the same up to this significance.

1779
01:33:19.930 --> 01:33:20.090
Mm-hmm.

1780
01:33:21.150 --> 01:33:25.714
For all intents and purposes, the only thing that is different between the muon and the electron is their mass.

1781
01:33:25.794 --> 01:33:26.414
Is the mass.

1782
01:33:26.654 --> 01:33:27.015
That's it.

1783
01:33:27.095 --> 01:33:27.515
That's it.

1784
01:33:28.255 --> 01:33:34.160
And what this also means then is that the theorists have to go back to the woodshed and work on it.

1785
01:33:34.320 --> 01:33:37.042
Yeah, they need to figure out what else to try.

1786
01:33:37.182 --> 01:33:37.362
Right.

1787
01:33:37.582 --> 01:33:37.943
Right.

1788
01:33:38.103 --> 01:33:38.263
Right.

1789
01:33:38.283 --> 01:33:46.292
Because they were – I bet you there were tons of theorists that were really hoping that this measurement was not going to fall within that error bar.

1790
01:33:46.312 --> 01:33:46.872
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1791
01:33:46.932 --> 01:33:47.112
Right?

1792
01:33:47.713 --> 01:33:49.175
That the muon was going to be here.

1793
01:33:49.475 --> 01:33:50.716
The electron was going to be here.

1794
01:33:50.796 --> 01:33:53.920
And they'd be like, oh, I got a theory for why they're different.

1795
01:33:54.400 --> 01:33:56.401
Turns out they're not.

1796
01:33:56.642 --> 01:34:05.607
This is actually a really great story around understanding the refinement that goes through the scientific process on something like the size of a proton.

1797
01:34:06.007 --> 01:34:07.768
Like why it's incredibly difficult.

1798
01:34:07.968 --> 01:34:08.728
Yeah.

1799
01:34:08.869 --> 01:34:13.331
Like fundamentally because it's so small like we can't just image it the way we normally would.

1800
01:34:13.731 --> 01:34:23.497
And so we have to go through this process of understanding like how these things interact because how they interact creates these derivative things.

1801
01:34:24.545 --> 01:34:52.577
variables that we can measure exactly that electron piece that we just talked about and then you can sort of now back calculate what you're looking for because you actually have a strong understanding of these other uh aspects of physics and the relationship between these different moving parts and again this tension between theory and experiment uh and the back and forth and sort of it's it's sort of like a it's sort of like a

1802
01:34:53.962 --> 01:34:55.983
it's like a dance, right?

1803
01:34:56.943 --> 01:35:02.786
Where both influence and counter-argue each other at different periods in time.

1804
01:35:03.026 --> 01:35:04.947
However, the theorists did not win this one.

1805
01:35:05.227 --> 01:35:06.308
No.

1806
01:35:06.328 --> 01:35:06.988
I'm sorry to say.

1807
01:35:07.168 --> 01:35:07.869
Yeah.

1808
01:35:08.129 --> 01:35:08.769
Maybe next time.

1809
01:35:09.189 --> 01:35:09.850
Maybe next time.

1810
01:35:09.870 --> 01:35:10.550
Probably not.

1811
01:35:10.570 --> 01:35:12.951
I mean, is this why they're always looking at string theory?

1812
01:35:12.971 --> 01:35:14.872
Because then the experimentalists can't...

1813
01:35:14.992 --> 01:35:20.775
Yeah, because on string theory, they're just like, oh, well, I need like 10 more decimals on your measurement.

1814
01:35:20.795 --> 01:35:21.635
And then just keep going.

1815
01:35:21.975 --> 01:35:22.776
Just keep going.

1816
01:35:23.136 --> 01:35:24.936
To really validate my theory or not.

1817
01:35:25.177 --> 01:35:34.401
But jokes aside, I mean, it seems like a relatively boring thing to talk about, just the size of the proton.

1818
01:35:34.941 --> 01:35:43.065
But the techniques and the fact that this closed that door on there being some new physics.

1819
01:35:43.365 --> 01:35:43.525
Mm-hmm.

1820
01:35:44.085 --> 01:35:45.526
We don't have to think about that anymore.

1821
01:35:45.546 --> 01:35:46.226
Right, right, right.

1822
01:35:46.286 --> 01:35:48.027
Like lepton universality is a thing.

1823
01:35:48.327 --> 01:35:51.149
The muon and the electron are the same except for mass.

1824
01:35:51.329 --> 01:35:51.509
Yes.

1825
01:35:51.729 --> 01:35:53.490
Now we can worry about other stuff.

1826
01:35:53.530 --> 01:35:53.751
Yes.

1827
01:35:53.891 --> 01:35:54.091
Right?

1828
01:35:54.271 --> 01:35:56.652
We can put constraints on exotic particles.

1829
01:35:56.732 --> 01:36:01.835
Like there's zero anomalous deviation from quantum electrodynamics rules.

1830
01:36:02.456 --> 01:36:02.656
Right?

1831
01:36:02.776 --> 01:36:05.257
So like a bunch of other stuff about dark matter.

1832
01:36:05.637 --> 01:36:07.779
Like, oh, there's this dark sector that maybe does this.

1833
01:36:07.859 --> 01:36:13.322
Well, if that particular way of thinking about dark matter has a different measurement,

1834
01:36:14.338 --> 01:36:14.778
It's wrong.

1835
01:36:14.899 --> 01:36:15.119
Right.

1836
01:36:15.419 --> 01:36:15.619
Right.

1837
01:36:15.679 --> 01:36:18.422
Falsifiability is everything when it comes to physics, right?

1838
01:36:18.762 --> 01:36:19.823
That's actually – I didn't think about that.

1839
01:36:19.843 --> 01:36:32.135
What you're saying is this experimental result can now inform research areas that are not about measurements of these subatomic particles and things like that.

1840
01:36:32.155 --> 01:36:32.315
Yeah.

1841
01:36:33.997 --> 01:36:45.153
There's overlap conceptually or architecturally that if you were basing your dark matter model off of the original 0.087 theoretical framework.

1842
01:36:46.215 --> 01:36:46.495
Sorry.

1843
01:36:46.656 --> 01:36:46.936
Sorry.

1844
01:36:47.717 --> 01:36:47.857
Yeah.

1845
01:36:47.937 --> 01:36:48.178
Yeah.

1846
01:36:51.348 --> 01:36:52.088
Gotta love science.

1847
01:36:52.108 --> 01:36:55.050
That's a good – that is a very good, very technical story.

1848
01:36:55.070 --> 01:36:55.971
Yeah.

1849
01:36:56.651 --> 01:37:02.154
But really, again, the fun to me is in the journey and the process.

1850
01:37:02.254 --> 01:37:03.155
Yeah.

1851
01:37:03.535 --> 01:37:04.595
Not simply the results.

1852
01:37:04.636 --> 01:37:06.477
Like you said, the result – okay, the size of the proton.

1853
01:37:06.497 --> 01:37:06.757
Great.

1854
01:37:06.917 --> 01:37:07.517
Yeah.

1855
01:37:08.097 --> 01:37:13.701
But all of those new techniques, again, also are not isolated to just this specific research question.

1856
01:37:13.841 --> 01:37:14.641
Fantastic.

1857
01:37:15.001 --> 01:37:15.542
That was –

1858
01:37:16.242 --> 01:37:25.752
So the sort of physics story on the proton size, we have this out of Max Planck Institute, and it was for quantum optics in nature.

1859
01:37:25.772 --> 01:37:29.416
I'll ask you questions.

1860
01:37:29.496 --> 01:37:30.297
I really like that one.

1861
01:37:30.317 --> 01:37:32.940
I'll ask you questions off air about that one because there's a couple more I have.

1862
01:37:33.280 --> 01:37:42.789
We are going to go ahead and move into our last story, which is a medicine story about ALS.

1863
01:37:42.909 --> 01:37:50.295
It's been in the news recently because of the recent death of Eric Dane.

1864
01:37:51.016 --> 01:37:52.437
Many of you have maybe saw the...

1865
01:37:53.601 --> 01:37:55.422
Netflix documentary that came out.

1866
01:37:56.162 --> 01:38:04.004
For those who may not know, Eric Dane is quite a famous and popular actor and father and husband.

1867
01:38:04.285 --> 01:38:08.526
He was Dr. McSteamy in Grey's Anatomy.

1868
01:38:09.346 --> 01:38:20.730
And he, while having been diagnosed with LAS, I think it was just over 10 months ago, excuse me, when he had found out about his diagnosis, he was just wrapping up

1869
01:38:21.270 --> 01:38:38.529
the shooting of season three of euphoria um unfortunately accelerated quite quickly and so we just wanted to um you know take this opportunity to i think cover you know what is the latest in the the fight against als

1870
01:38:39.630 --> 01:38:45.917
understanding it a little bit, and then we'll end with a funding piece that's related to this research area.

1871
01:38:46.858 --> 01:38:54.706
So, you know, we know it's something that a lot of folks have been not only talking about, but have been personally impacted by because of the way in which...

1872
01:38:56.036 --> 01:39:09.645
Eric communicated just his worldview, what it's like to be a father, his message to his kids, the stories that he had to tell about life, I think really resonated with a lot of people.

1873
01:39:10.805 --> 01:39:15.969
And so with that, we're going to kind of sort of look at the current landscape.

1874
01:39:16.449 --> 01:39:16.769
Yes.

1875
01:39:17.029 --> 01:39:24.494
I wanted to take this opportunity to talk about ALS, the disease, and one particular scientific paper that came out

1876
01:39:25.545 --> 01:39:31.728
last year that is just, you know, one of the latest in a series of breakthroughs.

1877
01:39:32.128 --> 01:39:36.129
Obviously, it's still very much a crisis in medicine.

1878
01:39:37.290 --> 01:39:47.634
Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, okay, it's a catastrophic motor neuron degradation that happens with motor neurons specifically.

1879
01:39:48.274 --> 01:39:48.674
These are the

1880
01:39:55.849 --> 01:40:06.153
ALS in its most advanced phase gets so bad that even the contraction of the muscles like the diaphragm that allow you to breathe.

1881
01:40:06.193 --> 01:40:11.595
Because everything, every bit of movement in our body is from muscular contraction, right?

1882
01:40:11.955 --> 01:40:12.715
And like...

1883
01:40:13.175 --> 01:40:19.336
Even the act of breathing becomes something that the brain cannot sustain because these motor neurons have degraded so much.

1884
01:40:19.877 --> 01:40:23.117
The survival is really quite bad.

1885
01:40:23.377 --> 01:40:26.738
2.3 to 5 years post-diagnosis is on average.

1886
01:40:27.178 --> 01:40:29.799
One of the most famous cases is Stephen Hawking.

1887
01:40:30.199 --> 01:40:35.460
He survived for like 50 years, but it's extremely rare to do that.

1888
01:40:35.500 --> 01:40:42.642
Now he's no longer the scientific hero that he once was, but he's one of these rare, rare cases.

1889
01:40:43.622 --> 01:40:48.766
Annual patient care is about 250,000 plus per patient, right?

1890
01:40:49.306 --> 01:40:53.709
And the current incidence, it's about one to two per 100,000.

1891
01:40:56.251 --> 01:41:01.755
By 2040, there's approximately going to be a 25% increase in the global prevalence.

1892
01:41:03.216 --> 01:41:03.436
And...

1893
01:41:04.409 --> 01:41:08.050
If we talk about like, there's really two types of ALS.

1894
01:41:08.330 --> 01:41:13.652
There's familial ALS, which comes from genetic mutations that you inherit from your family.

1895
01:41:14.212 --> 01:41:15.953
That's only about 10% of cases.

1896
01:41:16.813 --> 01:41:19.414
90% of cases are sporadic ALS.

1897
01:41:19.954 --> 01:41:21.495
There's all these polygenetic...

1898
01:41:22.255 --> 01:41:25.978
landscapes in our genome that causes sporadic ALS.

1899
01:41:26.038 --> 01:41:29.781
And that happens just, there's no familial history of it.

1900
01:41:30.281 --> 01:41:32.363
You know, you didn't carry a mutation from your parents.

1901
01:41:32.823 --> 01:41:33.484
It just happened.

1902
01:41:34.104 --> 01:41:40.769
So let's get into like, what exactly is going on in our nervous system when ALS happens.

1903
01:41:41.269 --> 01:41:44.712
So ALS, as I described, it's motor neurons, right?

1904
01:41:44.912 --> 01:41:45.152
Yes.

1905
01:41:45.412 --> 01:41:48.355
Motor neurons are extreme in scale.

1906
01:41:48.955 --> 01:41:49.215
Okay.

1907
01:41:49.575 --> 01:41:51.696
They can be about a meter long, a needle.

1908
01:41:51.976 --> 01:41:52.776
That's three feet.

1909
01:41:53.016 --> 01:41:53.336
Oh, wow.

1910
01:41:53.356 --> 01:41:56.536
A single cell is the size of like three feet.

1911
01:41:56.877 --> 01:41:57.177
Okay.

1912
01:41:57.757 --> 01:41:59.237
If you think about it, it kind of makes sense, right?

1913
01:41:59.257 --> 01:42:02.718
Because think about your spinal cord, like the lumbar spinal cord.

1914
01:42:02.738 --> 01:42:03.258
Sure, sure, sure.

1915
01:42:03.338 --> 01:42:11.199
A single cell body is going to be located in the spinal cord, but it's going to relay signal all the way down to the foot.

1916
01:42:11.359 --> 01:42:11.519
Yep.

1917
01:42:11.819 --> 01:42:12.239
That makes sense.

1918
01:42:12.259 --> 01:42:12.399
Okay.

1919
01:42:12.479 --> 01:42:14.220
That's a single motor neuron that's doing it.

1920
01:42:14.380 --> 01:42:14.620
Okay.

1921
01:42:14.740 --> 01:42:14.840
Okay.

1922
01:42:14.860 --> 01:42:15.020
Okay.

1923
01:42:16.272 --> 01:42:26.659
Now, maintaining this kind of architecture over an extremely long distance requires moving a massive amount of physical cargo from one end of the cell to the other, right?

1924
01:42:26.899 --> 01:42:28.360
You're going to have to move proteins.

1925
01:42:28.700 --> 01:42:34.544
You're going to have to move mRNA from your nucleus if you want to, like, you know, make it all the way out there.

1926
01:42:34.584 --> 01:42:35.945
You have to move mitochondria.

1927
01:42:36.325 --> 01:42:41.429
You have to move synaptic vesicles, which are like the acetylcholine and the neurotransmitters.

1928
01:42:41.469 --> 01:42:42.249
That's got to move.

1929
01:42:42.769 --> 01:42:44.911
All of that stuff has to move across...

1930
01:42:46.239 --> 01:42:48.441
A meter, a yard worth of stuff.

1931
01:42:48.622 --> 01:42:48.882
Right.

1932
01:42:49.202 --> 01:42:55.148
That requires a lot of energy, and it requires a lot of motion from these molecular motors.

1933
01:42:55.909 --> 01:42:57.090
They're called kinesin.

1934
01:42:58.572 --> 01:43:04.177
These kinesin are like little tiny molecular motors that actually step in eight nanometer steps.

1935
01:43:04.197 --> 01:43:04.317
Right.

1936
01:43:05.510 --> 01:43:06.730
On our microtubules.

1937
01:43:06.830 --> 01:43:12.552
They're incredible machines that literally take up ATP, which is like the energy currency of our cell.

1938
01:43:13.072 --> 01:43:18.394
And each ATP they take up gets them eight nanometers across.

1939
01:43:19.094 --> 01:43:23.255
Now, eight nanometers, that's eight times ten to the negative nine meters.

1940
01:43:23.615 --> 01:43:29.377
If I want to traverse a meter worth of stuff for a single molecule, that's on the order of ten to the eight.

1941
01:43:29.657 --> 01:43:29.937
Mm-hmm.

1942
01:43:30.780 --> 01:43:32.922
ATP molecules that I need to hydrolyze.

1943
01:43:33.083 --> 01:43:33.323
Yep.

1944
01:43:33.383 --> 01:43:33.603
Right?

1945
01:43:33.823 --> 01:43:34.024
Yep.

1946
01:43:34.484 --> 01:43:36.446
It requires a lot of energy.

1947
01:43:37.027 --> 01:43:37.287
Okay?

1948
01:43:37.608 --> 01:43:40.871
And when you have a lot of ATP that's being built up...

1949
01:43:41.707 --> 01:43:46.908
and something is wrong in the genetics of that neuron, you're going to get an accumulation of misfolded proteins.

1950
01:43:47.268 --> 01:43:49.709
Specifically, one of the main ones is TDP43.

1951
01:43:50.089 --> 01:43:58.491
It's a misfolded protein that causes physical blockage and traffic jams on these highways of transport.

1952
01:43:58.831 --> 01:44:04.412
And when you have that traffic jam, you're going to get into an energy crisis because now your mitochondria are unhappy.

1953
01:44:04.772 --> 01:44:07.193
They don't have the actual raw materials.

1954
01:44:07.433 --> 01:44:11.454
They're the factories that create the powerhouse of the cell or whatever.

1955
01:44:11.814 --> 01:44:14.116
They're the factories that actually create this ATP.

1956
01:44:14.816 --> 01:44:16.738
You're going to not have them being happy.

1957
01:44:17.138 --> 01:44:21.982
Those guys are going to create reactive oxygen species, which are just like byproducts with oxygen.

1958
01:44:22.162 --> 01:44:25.464
Oxygen is just like something that wants to react with everything.

1959
01:44:25.885 --> 01:44:29.607
And so it's going to cause effectively like rust in your neurons.

1960
01:44:30.068 --> 01:44:32.269
The same way the iron rusts in atmosphere.

1961
01:44:32.770 --> 01:44:40.936
If you don't have the correct machinery to regulate the reactive oxygen, that reactive oxygen is going to go and go haywire in your neurons.

1962
01:44:40.956 --> 01:44:41.176
Right.

1963
01:44:42.081 --> 01:44:44.743
The other analogy for this would sort of be on that highway.

1964
01:44:44.863 --> 01:44:48.386
It's just like you're getting potholes over time that never get fixed.

1965
01:44:48.426 --> 01:44:51.829
You don't have Department of Transportation coming through and fixing it.

1966
01:44:51.849 --> 01:44:56.053
And then it just deteriorates over time to a point where you can no longer traverse.

1967
01:44:56.153 --> 01:44:56.573
Exactly.

1968
01:44:56.613 --> 01:44:59.075
It's this thermodynamic breakdown, right?

1969
01:44:59.355 --> 01:45:02.098
And ALS is like a macroscopic manifestation.

1970
01:45:02.618 --> 01:45:04.119
of that thermodynamic breakdown.

1971
01:45:04.159 --> 01:45:04.500
You're right.

1972
01:45:04.540 --> 01:45:10.765
The neuron can literally not maintain its highly ordered state because the mitochondria is doing all sorts of crap.

1973
01:45:11.205 --> 01:45:17.410
The, the genetics is not being good enough to keep that low entropy state alive.

1974
01:45:17.550 --> 01:45:17.770
Right.

1975
01:45:18.031 --> 01:45:18.251
Right.

1976
01:45:18.351 --> 01:45:18.531
Right.

1977
01:45:18.651 --> 01:45:25.216
And so, and so you're getting just massive amounts of failure everywhere for these motor neurons.

1978
01:45:25.276 --> 01:45:29.080
And the point is, this is something that's, it's like, it's across your, your whole system.

1979
01:45:29.320 --> 01:45:29.520
Yeah.

1980
01:45:29.540 --> 01:45:31.742
The entire motor neuron, like, it's just like, right.

1981
01:45:32.246 --> 01:45:32.487
Yeah.

1982
01:45:32.827 --> 01:45:33.048
Right?

1983
01:45:33.208 --> 01:45:33.428
Yeah.

1984
01:45:33.469 --> 01:45:39.621
Now, the muscle's not so much, but the motor neuron is like the wire that is sending the muscle the signal.

1985
01:45:39.781 --> 01:45:39.982
Yeah.

1986
01:45:40.142 --> 01:45:40.382
Right?

1987
01:45:40.483 --> 01:45:40.703
Yeah.

1988
01:45:41.324 --> 01:45:43.849
It's like in your car when your computer goes down.

1989
01:45:45.428 --> 01:45:46.228
Yeah.

1990
01:45:46.909 --> 01:45:48.409
Turn it however much you want.

1991
01:45:48.609 --> 01:45:49.690
The engine could be fine.

1992
01:45:49.730 --> 01:45:50.650
The engine's still fine.

1993
01:45:51.150 --> 01:45:52.631
It may not be, but the engine's still fine.

1994
01:45:52.651 --> 01:45:53.091
Yeah.

1995
01:45:53.111 --> 01:45:54.312
But the problem is you don't have no...

1996
01:45:54.352 --> 01:45:55.592
But like your spark plug or whatever.

1997
01:45:55.612 --> 01:45:56.253
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1998
01:45:56.273 --> 01:45:57.833
It's like there's no electricity going there.

1999
01:45:57.853 --> 01:45:58.393
Yeah, that makes sense.

2000
01:45:58.413 --> 01:45:58.974
To do anything.

2001
01:45:59.014 --> 01:45:59.694
Yeah, that makes sense.

2002
01:45:59.714 --> 01:45:59.994
You know?

2003
01:46:00.154 --> 01:46:00.754
Yeah.

2004
01:46:00.914 --> 01:46:02.655
So that's the problem.

2005
01:46:02.915 --> 01:46:05.156
It's the motor neurons that are really just...

2006
01:46:07.257 --> 01:46:10.622
from overuse and from degradation are not working properly.

2007
01:46:11.683 --> 01:46:16.149
And there's been a translational chasm in drug development.

2008
01:46:16.630 --> 01:46:17.711
It's not been good.

2009
01:46:18.593 --> 01:46:22.578
We've been, as humanity, incredible at solving problems.

2010
01:46:22.813 --> 01:46:23.653
medical problems.

2011
01:46:24.233 --> 01:46:27.714
ALS is one where historically it's just been beating us.

2012
01:46:28.114 --> 01:46:29.335
And it's been crazy, dude.

2013
01:46:29.355 --> 01:46:30.975
Like there's the example of failed drugs.

2014
01:46:31.015 --> 01:46:38.297
Like there's so many failed drugs because they all show preclinical promise in like rat models and mouse models.

2015
01:46:38.397 --> 01:46:40.577
But then when you get to humans, it's all failed.

2016
01:46:40.897 --> 01:46:42.758
These are just some of the many.

2017
01:46:43.158 --> 01:46:46.819
There's, I think something like more than a hundred

2018
01:46:53.320 --> 01:46:56.981
But then when it comes to humans, it's just all failure, failure, failure.

2019
01:46:57.001 --> 01:46:57.161
Okay?

2020
01:46:57.481 --> 01:46:58.341
And what does that say?

2021
01:46:58.701 --> 01:47:08.024
What that says is we don't have a good model in the lab to test drugs for ALS.

2022
01:47:08.364 --> 01:47:08.604
Right.

2023
01:47:08.664 --> 01:47:15.565
Because the point here is for a variety of things, we can use these rodent, mouse, rat model.

2024
01:47:15.665 --> 01:47:17.006
We can use them as the test bed.

2025
01:47:17.286 --> 01:47:17.586
Yeah.

2026
01:47:17.606 --> 01:47:19.066
And there's so many where it works.

2027
01:47:19.166 --> 01:47:19.366
It works.

2028
01:47:19.386 --> 01:47:20.747
That's why we do research on them.

2029
01:47:20.767 --> 01:47:22.307
It works fine and it's fantastic.

2030
01:47:22.327 --> 01:47:22.627
Yeah.

2031
01:47:22.747 --> 01:47:23.607
It does not work for this.

2032
01:47:23.747 --> 01:47:24.988
It does not work for ALS.

2033
01:47:25.008 --> 01:47:26.389
There's something fundamentally different.

2034
01:47:26.649 --> 01:47:31.111
And what we need is in lab a model that we can actually test drugs on.

2035
01:47:31.251 --> 01:47:31.471
Right.

2036
01:47:31.991 --> 01:47:32.131
Right.

2037
01:47:32.171 --> 01:47:32.351
Right.

2038
01:47:32.471 --> 01:47:38.054
That translates post-preclinical into actually the clinical trials.

2039
01:47:38.454 --> 01:47:43.476
And this is where the – now we can start talking about the paper that I want to talk about.

2040
01:47:43.496 --> 01:47:43.677
Okay.

2041
01:47:43.817 --> 01:47:45.677
The paper has to do with iPSCs.

2042
01:47:46.018 --> 01:47:48.059
These are pluripotent stem cells.

2043
01:47:48.279 --> 01:47:48.559
Okay.

2044
01:47:50.388 --> 01:47:54.113
These are induced pluripotent stem cells.

2045
01:47:54.233 --> 01:48:04.047
In 2012, the Nobel Prize went to John Gurdon and Shinya Yamanaka for the discovery that mature cells can be reprogrammed

2046
01:48:04.847 --> 01:48:06.068
to become stem cells.

2047
01:48:06.388 --> 01:48:07.469
Stem cells are...

2048
01:48:07.629 --> 01:48:15.375
So stem cells are cells that have not differentiated into skin cells or blood cells or bone cells or whatever.

2049
01:48:15.756 --> 01:48:16.937
They are a clean slate.

2050
01:48:17.197 --> 01:48:18.478
They don't have a specialization.

2051
01:48:18.758 --> 01:48:20.179
They're like you in high school.

2052
01:48:20.279 --> 01:48:26.124
Before you went into college and then got a major and now you're stuck at whatever path of life.

2053
01:48:26.324 --> 01:48:26.544
Yes.

2054
01:48:26.664 --> 01:48:26.905
Right?

2055
01:48:27.385 --> 01:48:30.528
And what induced pluripotent stem cells do...

2056
01:48:31.407 --> 01:48:42.164
is now we're able to reprogram someone who's, let's say, been through college and a PhD, pre-program their brain so that now their brain is back in high school and they can be something totally different.

2057
01:48:42.926 --> 01:48:58.091
Just to quickly note, that's like a phenomenal – like in and of itself, this which is from the 2012 Nobel Prize, that concept is really powerful because effectively what you're saying is I'm in the college – high school college analogy.

2058
01:48:58.471 --> 01:49:04.973
If I get to age 45 and the world has changed and my industry has been replaced by insert whatever –

2059
01:49:06.513 --> 01:49:18.504
I can just be almost reset to being 19, 20 and retrained again without like – with a substrate that is not my 45-year-old mind, but it's my 20-year-old mind.

2060
01:49:18.524 --> 01:49:19.405
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

2061
01:49:19.525 --> 01:49:25.911
And this is really amazing for biomedical research because, one, we don't have to rely on embryonic stem cells.

2062
01:49:25.931 --> 01:49:26.532
Yeah, that's a good point.

2063
01:49:26.572 --> 01:49:46.547
point because embryonic stem cells are really where the stem cells are right because as an embryo you can imagine from an egg and a sperm that egg is just like a single cell right that single cell is now becoming my nails my my lungs my skin my muscles my neurons right so somewhere that single cell becomes a ball yes

2064
01:49:46.967 --> 01:49:49.248
And that ball has a bunch of embryonic stem cells.

2065
01:49:49.368 --> 01:49:51.509
Each cell now defines, I'm going to go become the eye.

2066
01:49:51.769 --> 01:49:53.630
I'm going to go become a hair cell, so on and so forth.

2067
01:49:54.070 --> 01:49:57.031
With this technology, we don't need embryonic stem cells.

2068
01:49:57.312 --> 01:50:05.115
We can take skin cells, graft them, put them with a genetic cocktail, and then they are going to become stem cells on their own.

2069
01:50:05.195 --> 01:50:06.636
It completely changes the landscape.

2070
01:50:06.856 --> 01:50:08.436
And that's why they won the Nobel Prize in 2012.

2071
01:50:08.476 --> 01:50:09.177
That makes sense.

2072
01:50:09.237 --> 01:50:16.660
Very much deserved because it's changed biomedical research, not just for ALS, but like countless other diseases.

2073
01:50:17.060 --> 01:50:18.241
Okay.

2074
01:50:19.102 --> 01:50:22.906
Now, as you can imagine, 2012, this is a pretty old technology.

2075
01:50:23.046 --> 01:50:23.266
Sure.

2076
01:50:23.366 --> 01:50:23.586
Right?

2077
01:50:24.567 --> 01:50:26.910
We have tried to use it for ALS.

2078
01:50:26.930 --> 01:50:29.192
There was this consortium called Answer ALS.

2079
01:50:29.552 --> 01:50:34.897
They got 1,000 lines from ALS patients, and they tried to make lines of stem cells.

2080
01:50:35.658 --> 01:50:40.663
But they observed the same problem, which is that the drugs—

2081
01:50:42.851 --> 01:50:49.097
Like the same drugs that don't work in clinical trials, they'll work in pluripotent stem cells.

2082
01:50:49.137 --> 01:50:49.777
They will.

2083
01:50:49.897 --> 01:50:50.318
They will.

2084
01:50:50.878 --> 01:50:53.060
So they were still missing something.

2085
01:50:53.220 --> 01:50:53.521
Right.

2086
01:50:53.741 --> 01:50:53.961
Right?

2087
01:50:54.261 --> 01:50:59.646
It's like these stem cells were not mimicking ALS motor neurons.

2088
01:50:59.787 --> 01:51:01.088
They were trying, right?

2089
01:51:01.248 --> 01:51:06.493
We got the stem cells from ALS patients that have the disease, but when we make...

2090
01:51:07.400 --> 01:51:08.321
them into stem cells.

2091
01:51:08.401 --> 01:51:10.962
We get the donor skin cells from the ALS patients.

2092
01:51:10.982 --> 01:51:14.885
When we try to make them into stem cells, they don't mimic the disease that the patient has.

2093
01:51:15.425 --> 01:51:16.206
And that's the whole point.

2094
01:51:16.226 --> 01:51:16.806
That's the whole point.

2095
01:51:17.407 --> 01:51:19.148
So what's going on?

2096
01:51:19.568 --> 01:51:21.910
Oh, which is interesting because...

2097
01:51:23.463 --> 01:51:24.184
Anyway.

2098
01:51:24.524 --> 01:51:25.844
You understand what I'm saying though, right?

2099
01:51:25.864 --> 01:51:32.148
Yeah, because in my head, intuitively, I'd be like, oh, well, if you're taking my skin – let's say I have ALS in this example.

2100
01:51:32.168 --> 01:51:35.070
You take my skin cells and then you try to reprogram it.

2101
01:51:35.150 --> 01:51:37.191
Yeah, and I try to make that into a motor neuron.

2102
01:51:37.351 --> 01:51:37.531
Right.

2103
01:51:37.871 --> 01:51:41.794
The problem is the motor neuron is not my body's stuff, which has it.

2104
01:51:41.854 --> 01:51:43.695
Yeah, it's just like a normal motor neuron.

2105
01:51:43.855 --> 01:51:45.736
Right, because it's been reprogrammed.

2106
01:51:45.856 --> 01:51:47.617
But the whole point is I want to make –

2107
01:51:48.037 --> 01:51:48.277
Right.

2108
01:51:48.618 --> 01:51:51.119
A model of ALS in a Petri dish.

2109
01:51:51.240 --> 01:51:51.540
Correct.

2110
01:51:51.560 --> 01:51:53.261
That I can then mess around with.

2111
01:51:53.401 --> 01:51:59.386
Which currently we just can't get from the boilerplate out of the box induced pluripotent stem cell process.

2112
01:51:59.646 --> 01:52:02.949
And that is where we get to our study in 2025.

2113
01:52:03.009 --> 01:52:03.449
Okay.

2114
01:52:03.769 --> 01:52:06.371
It's an in vitro model of sporadic ALS.

2115
01:52:06.431 --> 01:52:09.333
It was a nature neuroscience, large scale drug screening.

2116
01:52:09.974 --> 01:52:12.656
And what they did was actually figure out how to make this happen.

2117
01:52:12.776 --> 01:52:13.036
Okay.

2118
01:52:13.076 --> 01:52:14.598
How to make Petri dish...

2119
01:52:15.358 --> 01:52:25.285
level, ALS, that I can mess around with in a lab and really try to understand what drugs would work and what drugs wouldn't, right?

2120
01:52:25.565 --> 01:52:26.926
It's out of the University of Melbourne.

2121
01:52:27.930 --> 01:52:31.191
and the University of Queensland, a lot of Australian universities.

2122
01:52:31.311 --> 01:52:34.512
Yeah, there's quite a few institutions that were collaborating on this.

2123
01:52:34.792 --> 01:52:35.213
That's right.

2124
01:52:35.553 --> 01:52:37.473
So what they did different is the following.

2125
01:52:37.493 --> 01:52:41.395
So they got 100 patients with sporadic ALS.

2126
01:52:41.935 --> 01:52:44.696
They got 11 patients with familial ALS.

2127
01:52:44.816 --> 01:52:46.316
They got 25 healthy controls.

2128
01:52:46.797 --> 01:52:50.798
They got skin cells from the dermal fibroblasts.

2129
01:52:50.878 --> 01:52:54.519
They extracted from skin biopsies from these patients and from these 25 controls.

2130
01:52:57.273 --> 01:53:01.655
They used something called non-integrating epizomal vectors.

2131
01:53:01.976 --> 01:53:17.504
So usually when we try to make stem cells, like pluripotent stem cells from whatever donor skin cells that we got, I need to change the genetics of that skin cell to now forget everything about being a skin cell and go back to being a stem cell.

2132
01:53:17.524 --> 01:53:17.724
Right.

2133
01:53:18.125 --> 01:53:22.307
Usually how we do that is we use a retrovirus.

2134
01:53:22.667 --> 01:53:22.907
Okay.

2135
01:53:22.967 --> 01:53:29.492
So a virus that has a piece of RNA, the RNA goes into the cell that becomes reverse transcribed into DNA.

2136
01:53:29.772 --> 01:53:34.975
The DNA then goes and gets mixed in with the native DNA of the cell.

2137
01:53:35.515 --> 01:53:41.720
With these specific non-integrating episomal vectors, this is DNA that just goes into the nucleus and hangs out.

2138
01:53:42.000 --> 01:53:42.240
Hmm.

2139
01:53:42.480 --> 01:53:45.904
It doesn't get inserted into the chromosome of the cell.

2140
01:53:46.024 --> 01:53:46.284
Okay.

2141
01:53:46.324 --> 01:53:52.851
And what that does is prevent any random, you know, like off-target stuff from happening.

2142
01:53:53.131 --> 01:53:54.313
It's exactly what we want.

2143
01:53:54.393 --> 01:53:54.893
Yeah.

2144
01:53:54.993 --> 01:53:56.895
It's just it's not messing with anything.

2145
01:53:57.096 --> 01:53:57.316
Right.

2146
01:53:57.416 --> 01:54:02.238
That's already there because the cell is already in this sort of, it's from an ALS patient.

2147
01:54:02.258 --> 01:54:05.739
So it already has the mutations that are causing ALS.

2148
01:54:05.819 --> 01:54:09.901
We don't want to mess with that because we want to replicate the ALS in my Petri dish.

2149
01:54:10.321 --> 01:54:17.044
So if I want to reprogram the cell to become a motor neuron, I just get my DNA, I put it in the nucleus, and I just have you hang out.

2150
01:54:17.444 --> 01:54:19.605
Do not go inside the house.

2151
01:54:19.685 --> 01:54:20.565
Just hang out.

2152
01:54:21.366 --> 01:54:21.966
Okay.

2153
01:54:21.986 --> 01:54:22.186
Right?

2154
01:54:22.366 --> 01:54:22.626
Okay.

2155
01:54:22.806 --> 01:54:24.807
Because previously the retrovirus insertion,

2156
01:54:25.027 --> 01:54:25.908
Yeah, it would insert.

2157
01:54:26.148 --> 01:54:28.550
And then that changes whatever's happening inside the house.

2158
01:54:28.690 --> 01:54:31.552
And because this is such a combinatorial problem, we have no idea.

2159
01:54:31.572 --> 01:54:32.072
You don't know.

2160
01:54:32.112 --> 01:54:32.552
We don't know.

2161
01:54:32.833 --> 01:54:34.114
Yeah, we don't know what happened.

2162
01:54:34.154 --> 01:54:35.835
But now we have total control.

2163
01:54:35.875 --> 01:54:43.280
We're trying to have total control over each of the sort of second and third order steps that happen after we introduce it into the environment.

2164
01:54:43.300 --> 01:54:43.781
Exactly, yeah.

2165
01:54:43.981 --> 01:54:47.103
And they did a lot of other stuff that I'm not going to totally get into.

2166
01:54:47.143 --> 01:54:47.944
Sure.

2167
01:54:47.964 --> 01:54:48.984
But the way that they...

2168
01:54:50.165 --> 01:55:11.469
grew the stem cells they actually withdrew a bunch of growth factors that would prevent artificial masking of this phenotype of als because we want that phenotype to actually happen yes they also like cultured it under strict five percent oxygen which is this hypoxic condition that happens in the spinal cord so it's something that you want to mimic when you want to make

2169
01:55:11.629 --> 01:55:14.371
modern neurons that are like ALS.

2170
01:55:14.491 --> 01:55:19.395
So we removed stuff that would potentially make it so that the thing would, like the system would make it go away.

2171
01:55:19.415 --> 01:55:39.689
And we also created the environment that is almost identical to the environment that exists to remove, again, any possibility that we're missing the mark in terms of the, like the variables that need to be present in order to generate the results we're looking for with this new lab, to be able to basically replicate it in a Petri dish.

2172
01:55:39.689 --> 01:55:42.590
Yes, we want ALS motor neurons in a petri dish.

2173
01:55:42.991 --> 01:55:43.191
Right?

2174
01:55:43.611 --> 01:55:47.052
And finally, the resulting purity that they got, it was exceptionally pure.

2175
01:55:47.433 --> 01:55:52.015
Motor neurons, 90% were co-expressing the gene that we wanted.

2176
01:55:52.135 --> 01:55:52.795
Okay.

2177
01:55:52.955 --> 01:55:55.436
Very low contamination, so there's not that many astrocytes.

2178
01:55:55.476 --> 01:55:56.777
There's not that many microglia.

2179
01:55:57.037 --> 01:56:00.659
They're all motor neurons, and they all look great.

2180
01:56:00.679 --> 01:56:04.801
Okay, so this is a very big deal.

2181
01:56:04.841 --> 01:56:06.882
Yes, so finally, we might have...

2182
01:56:07.662 --> 01:56:09.445
Our ALS in a Petri dish.

2183
01:56:09.485 --> 01:56:09.725
Yes.

2184
01:56:09.985 --> 01:56:18.437
And now we can start doing preclinical trials in our Petri dish with some confidence that it might work.

2185
01:56:19.611 --> 01:56:20.452
At the clinical stage.

2186
01:56:20.672 --> 01:56:31.078
The point here is we're saying this ALS in a Petri dish is going to increase the conversion rate of preclinical targets to those that actually can make it into clinical trials.

2187
01:56:31.638 --> 01:56:44.766
Because we are basically saying – we're basically recreating the environment that would be an actual human in the trials, not using the rodent, mouse, rat model, which can work in a lot of other cases.

2188
01:56:44.866 --> 01:56:45.066
Yeah.

2189
01:56:45.286 --> 01:56:46.667
But just in this one, it does not.

2190
01:56:46.767 --> 01:56:47.187
Exactly.

2191
01:56:47.267 --> 01:56:47.408
Okay.

2192
01:56:47.448 --> 01:56:47.528
Yes.

2193
01:56:47.708 --> 01:56:47.968
Yeah.

2194
01:56:48.228 --> 01:56:59.038
And when they created these motor neurons in the Petri dish, those motor neurons would exhibit the same kind of damage that we got in ALS.

2195
01:56:59.098 --> 01:57:01.900
They came up with this metric called the lethal day 50%.

2196
01:57:01.940 --> 01:57:03.102
So it's the exact day.

2197
01:57:04.042 --> 01:57:09.324
when the total length of the neurites degrades by 50%, the maximum peak length.

2198
01:57:09.504 --> 01:57:16.206
So it's like imagine you made the motor neuron, and then you press play, and then because of degradation, it's going to get shorter and shorter.

2199
01:57:16.806 --> 01:57:17.947
They came up with this metric.

2200
01:57:18.387 --> 01:57:24.729
That metric was correlated, and this is kind of the nail in the coffin that we have replicated in the Petri dish.

2201
01:57:24.969 --> 01:57:28.070
It's kind of an unfortunate metric, but at the same time,

2202
01:57:29.010 --> 01:57:31.577
It's a lot of hope for the future because here's what they did.

2203
01:57:32.018 --> 01:57:37.832
That metric is correlated with the actual clinical patient survival time.

2204
01:57:39.237 --> 01:57:40.438
Oh, interesting.

2205
01:57:40.498 --> 01:57:41.258
Do you see what I'm saying?

2206
01:57:41.278 --> 01:57:41.539
Yes.

2207
01:57:41.619 --> 01:57:56.028
So the patient that I got my donation from of the skin cells that I made my pluripotent stem cells from to make into a motor neuron, the survival of that culture is correlated with the patient, him or herself.

2208
01:57:57.048 --> 01:58:03.292
The unfortunate point being here is that the real world outcome for the patient in terms of time.

2209
01:58:03.513 --> 01:58:03.693
Yeah.

2210
01:58:03.713 --> 01:58:03.813
Yeah.

2211
01:58:04.667 --> 01:58:08.168
Is correlated with our ALS in a Petri dish.

2212
01:58:08.228 --> 01:58:08.528
Yes.

2213
01:58:08.749 --> 01:58:16.711
Meaning it is replicating the problem that the patient had to a degree that it's matching.

2214
01:58:16.811 --> 01:58:17.332
It's matching.

2215
01:58:17.352 --> 01:58:17.712
One to one.

2216
01:58:17.732 --> 01:58:18.392
Exactly, yeah.

2217
01:58:18.632 --> 01:58:20.873
And it's unfortunate, but at the same time, very encouraging.

2218
01:58:20.913 --> 01:58:24.594
Because now we have the model in our Petri dish.

2219
01:58:24.634 --> 01:58:26.235
Now we can finally start...

2220
01:58:27.273 --> 01:58:29.234
getting to the bottom of how do we fix this?

2221
01:58:29.294 --> 01:58:29.574
Yes.

2222
01:58:29.774 --> 01:58:30.335
Right.

2223
01:58:30.355 --> 01:58:32.096
That's actually a really, really big deal.

2224
01:58:32.136 --> 01:58:33.036
Yeah.

2225
01:58:33.196 --> 01:58:34.657
And we didn't have this before.

2226
01:58:34.697 --> 01:58:34.897
Right.

2227
01:58:35.337 --> 01:58:35.517
Right.

2228
01:58:35.557 --> 01:58:35.758
Right.

2229
01:58:35.878 --> 01:58:39.840
This is like we were working with like rats and mice that were just like awful.

2230
01:58:40.100 --> 01:58:40.300
Right.

2231
01:58:40.400 --> 01:58:41.000
Just didn't work.

2232
01:58:41.140 --> 01:58:41.341
Right.

2233
01:58:41.541 --> 01:58:41.701
Right.

2234
01:58:41.841 --> 01:58:43.162
And now we finally got a model.

2235
01:58:43.182 --> 01:58:45.663
We were throwing darts at the board, but the board was behind us.

2236
01:58:45.703 --> 01:58:47.204
Yeah, exactly.

2237
01:58:47.304 --> 01:58:48.524
And it's like, what are we doing?

2238
01:58:48.544 --> 01:58:49.085
What are we doing?

2239
01:58:49.145 --> 01:58:49.765
Yeah.

2240
01:58:50.305 --> 01:58:52.727
But the challenge here is, again, to your point, you know,

2241
01:58:53.487 --> 01:58:57.011
The model, the sort of rodent model works in so many other arenas.

2242
01:58:57.532 --> 01:58:59.774
It's fair to have extrapolated it to this one.

2243
01:58:59.794 --> 01:59:00.195
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

2244
01:59:00.295 --> 01:59:00.655
Totally.

2245
01:59:00.695 --> 01:59:01.696
But after some time.

2246
01:59:01.877 --> 01:59:03.559
Yeah, you're just like, okay, we need something else.

2247
01:59:03.599 --> 01:59:04.600
We need something else.

2248
01:59:04.700 --> 01:59:05.020
Yeah.

2249
01:59:05.301 --> 01:59:06.182
This is totally not working.

2250
01:59:06.222 --> 01:59:06.422
Yes.

2251
01:59:06.702 --> 01:59:06.862
Right?

2252
01:59:06.882 --> 01:59:06.982
Yes.

2253
01:59:07.623 --> 01:59:09.045
So here's what they did.

2254
01:59:09.345 --> 01:59:10.587
They made a screening library.

2255
01:59:10.627 --> 01:59:10.727
Yeah.

2256
01:59:11.548 --> 01:59:15.874
107 commercially available drugs from phase one to three ALS trials.

2257
01:59:16.194 --> 01:59:17.195
So this is preclinical.

2258
01:59:17.376 --> 01:59:17.596
Yes.

2259
01:59:17.676 --> 01:59:17.876
Right.

2260
01:59:18.798 --> 01:59:19.118
Pretty sure.

2261
01:59:19.138 --> 01:59:19.298
Right.

2262
01:59:19.338 --> 01:59:21.762
Phase one to three is, is I think preclinical.

2263
01:59:21.802 --> 01:59:25.447
And then 97% of the tested drugs failed.

2264
01:59:25.467 --> 01:59:25.567
Yeah.

2265
01:59:25.587 --> 01:59:25.767
Yeah.

2266
01:59:26.588 --> 01:59:29.650
And this is sort of what we want.

2267
01:59:30.030 --> 01:59:31.631
Because that's what we're seeing.

2268
01:59:31.651 --> 01:59:33.372
We're seeing them pass the preclinical.

2269
01:59:33.432 --> 01:59:37.094
And then only when they get to clinical stage in a human being, they're failing.

2270
01:59:37.234 --> 01:59:38.914
Now they're failing in the Petri dish.

2271
01:59:39.055 --> 01:59:44.998
I don't have to waste time and resources like actually doing a clinical trial if it's failing in the Petri dish.

2272
01:59:45.058 --> 01:59:45.798
That's the whole point.

2273
01:59:45.818 --> 01:59:46.959
Just to say it back to you.

2274
01:59:47.439 --> 01:59:51.041
We took what was working in preclinical before but failing in humans.

2275
01:59:51.401 --> 01:59:53.202
We took our Petri dish platform.

2276
01:59:53.782 --> 02:00:03.550
We applied the already commercially available options and 97% of them failed in our petri dish when they were passing in the preclinical in the prior regime.

2277
02:00:04.071 --> 02:00:18.142
And so the point here is, again, not only are we seeing in patients the one-to-one on survival time, we are also seeing a one-to-one on efficacy in testing patients.

2278
02:00:19.215 --> 02:00:25.340
in this sort of pre-trial environment, in this in-lab environment.

2279
02:00:25.360 --> 02:00:25.580
Yeah, yeah.

2280
02:00:25.900 --> 02:00:27.261
Not even in the in-lab.

2281
02:00:27.461 --> 02:00:27.622
Yeah.

2282
02:00:27.902 --> 02:00:31.965
Meaning we can feel, we can have some level of confidence in the world.

2283
02:00:32.567 --> 02:00:37.308
that we are actually in a new 2.0 foundation.

2284
02:00:37.688 --> 02:00:38.888
For lab testing.

2285
02:00:38.908 --> 02:00:39.828
For lab testing.

2286
02:00:40.028 --> 02:00:40.228
Yeah.

2287
02:00:40.428 --> 02:00:41.188
For lab testing.

2288
02:00:41.268 --> 02:00:41.729
Exactly.

2289
02:00:41.989 --> 02:00:45.909
And out of the 107, three actually did pretty good.

2290
02:00:46.689 --> 02:00:51.790
Riluzol, memantine, and baricitinib.

2291
02:00:52.370 --> 02:00:53.511
I think that's how you pronounce it.

2292
02:00:53.771 --> 02:00:54.591
Okay.

2293
02:00:54.951 --> 02:00:57.951
So let's get into what each of these things are.

2294
02:00:59.552 --> 02:01:01.472
Riluzol is actually something that...

2295
02:01:02.531 --> 02:01:04.213
People are already testing nowadays.

2296
02:01:04.774 --> 02:01:05.695
It was dose-dependent.

2297
02:01:05.795 --> 02:01:11.681
There was significant rescue of this lethal day 50% metric that I was telling you about.

2298
02:01:12.242 --> 02:01:18.309
And if we look at the physical effect on these neurons, there was restored electrical coherence.

2299
02:01:18.329 --> 02:01:20.151
So on the top row, you see...

2300
02:01:21.164 --> 02:01:22.804
Just control.

2301
02:01:23.005 --> 02:01:23.185
Yes.

2302
02:01:23.225 --> 02:01:26.005
On the bottom row, they're treated with riluzole.

2303
02:01:26.025 --> 02:01:26.245
Yes.

2304
02:01:26.426 --> 02:01:27.586
The neurons are healthier.

2305
02:01:27.706 --> 02:01:28.086
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

2306
02:01:28.106 --> 02:01:28.266
Right?

2307
02:01:28.346 --> 02:01:29.266
They just look better.

2308
02:01:29.286 --> 02:01:29.646
Yep.

2309
02:01:29.967 --> 02:01:31.707
And it inverted the disease vector.

2310
02:01:31.747 --> 02:01:39.509
So there was a negative correlation with, like, the effect and, like, how much time the neurons actually stayed alive.

2311
02:01:39.529 --> 02:01:39.869
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

2312
02:01:39.889 --> 02:01:40.830
So it was all a good thing, right?

2313
02:01:40.850 --> 02:01:41.190
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

2314
02:01:41.370 --> 02:01:42.050
The other two...

2315
02:01:43.537 --> 02:01:47.864
They did not confer statistically significant population-level benefit.

2316
02:01:48.025 --> 02:01:48.305
Okay.

2317
02:01:48.345 --> 02:01:50.068
So you think, okay, maybe they're a dud, right?

2318
02:01:50.549 --> 02:01:51.110
Not so fast.

2319
02:01:51.190 --> 02:01:51.511
Okay.

2320
02:01:51.571 --> 02:01:52.633
What if we combine...

2321
02:01:53.997 --> 02:01:58.158
The drugs, the three drugs that we had a positive effect on, what if we combine them?

2322
02:01:58.739 --> 02:02:02.020
Is it a synergistic multiplication effect?

2323
02:02:02.080 --> 02:02:02.580
Right?

2324
02:02:02.640 --> 02:02:04.080
And that is what they found.

2325
02:02:04.340 --> 02:02:11.483
They found that each of these columns now is individual drugs, and then you add the two, right?

2326
02:02:11.523 --> 02:02:14.104
Like there's Riluzol and Mimantin.

2327
02:02:14.144 --> 02:02:16.504
There's Baracitinib and Mimantin.

2328
02:02:16.524 --> 02:02:17.485
And then there's all three.

2329
02:02:18.225 --> 02:02:25.409
The more you added, the three were somehow working together to create a much better lasting effect.

2330
02:02:25.429 --> 02:02:28.811
I mean, the visuals here are just astonishing.

2331
02:02:28.871 --> 02:02:30.371
As you go from left to right, right?

2332
02:02:30.431 --> 02:02:32.132
It's just like healthier and healthier neurons.

2333
02:02:32.152 --> 02:02:33.053
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

2334
02:02:33.073 --> 02:02:40.277
And then basically on the one with all three, at all levels, it basically maintains its structure.

2335
02:02:40.397 --> 02:02:40.677
Yes.

2336
02:02:41.857 --> 02:02:44.519
Whereas when we were just having Untreated...

2337
02:02:45.508 --> 02:02:46.269
By the time we get to that.

2338
02:02:46.289 --> 02:02:47.610
Yeah, but by the time...

2339
02:02:47.710 --> 02:02:49.831
I mean, it's just like the time axis is on the Y axis.

2340
02:02:49.851 --> 02:02:50.872
On the Y axis, yep.

2341
02:02:50.892 --> 02:02:52.253
So it's like the earliest.

2342
02:02:52.593 --> 02:02:55.295
And then as time goes on, they just start dying, right?

2343
02:02:55.315 --> 02:02:56.176
I mean, this fish is astonishing.

2344
02:02:56.216 --> 02:02:59.178
But at the rightmost with all three of them, it's like they're still alive.

2345
02:02:59.338 --> 02:03:00.218
That's astonishing.

2346
02:03:00.419 --> 02:03:00.539
Yeah.

2347
02:03:00.579 --> 02:03:02.440
I mean, the level of impact...

2348
02:03:02.600 --> 02:03:03.901
Yeah, the level of impact is crazy.

2349
02:03:04.021 --> 02:03:05.961
On the combinatorial piece.

2350
02:03:06.021 --> 02:03:06.141
Yes.

2351
02:03:06.301 --> 02:03:09.723
And then if you wanted to do, okay, so what is the ultimate zenith, right?

2352
02:03:09.743 --> 02:03:10.023
Right.

2353
02:03:10.043 --> 02:03:10.683
Is it all three?

2354
02:03:10.743 --> 02:03:11.444
Is it just two?

2355
02:03:12.404 --> 02:03:13.264
You can actually test.

2356
02:03:13.544 --> 02:03:16.466
Now that we've got a Petri dish, we can do A-B testing.

2357
02:03:16.546 --> 02:03:16.786
Right.

2358
02:03:17.026 --> 02:03:17.226
Right?

2359
02:03:17.326 --> 02:03:17.626
Yeah, yeah.

2360
02:03:18.046 --> 02:03:23.590
On all the different patient donors, like all the different profiles, is it only for sporadic?

2361
02:03:23.650 --> 02:03:24.791
Is it only for familial?

2362
02:03:25.091 --> 02:03:32.095
We can do all of these different categorical tests and figure out that the triple combination is actually the best.

2363
02:03:32.375 --> 02:03:32.555
Right?

2364
02:03:32.856 --> 02:03:35.837
Each of those cells actually lasted for 30 more days.

2365
02:03:36.218 --> 02:03:42.502
30 might not seem like a lot, but it's actually a 6.5 times greater than just Riluzole alone.

2366
02:03:42.522 --> 02:03:42.682
Right.

2367
02:03:42.702 --> 02:03:42.902
Right?

2368
02:03:43.222 --> 02:03:43.462
Right.

2369
02:03:43.602 --> 02:03:43.802
Right.

2370
02:03:44.803 --> 02:03:48.666
It's, it's, I mean, this is something that we can now take to clinical trials, right?

2371
02:03:48.886 --> 02:03:51.167
Like, why don't we just try all three at the same time?

2372
02:03:51.187 --> 02:03:51.848
Right, right.

2373
02:03:51.928 --> 02:03:52.128
Right.

2374
02:03:52.248 --> 02:03:55.270
Let alone the fact that you have the new in-lab test bed.

2375
02:03:55.350 --> 02:03:56.971
Yeah, that's the proof of concept now.

2376
02:03:57.071 --> 02:03:57.931
To then do whatever.

2377
02:03:58.192 --> 02:03:58.472
Yeah.

2378
02:03:58.532 --> 02:04:02.654
To do, even if you say, let's not use these three, let's now try something totally different.

2379
02:04:02.674 --> 02:04:03.055
Yeah.

2380
02:04:03.075 --> 02:04:05.516
The fact that we can now try something totally different, right?

2381
02:04:05.576 --> 02:04:10.840
It creates a scalable, robust, and like pharmacologically predictive model.

2382
02:04:10.860 --> 02:04:10.940
Yes.

2383
02:04:10.960 --> 02:04:11.200
Yes.

2384
02:04:11.600 --> 02:04:19.166
Of ALS That's a really big deal Yeah, I think it's a really big deal I thought it was a really cool paper And the clinical advantage is clearly there, right?

2385
02:04:19.226 --> 02:04:38.782
Like all three drugs You do a cocktail of all three drugs These drugs are already FDA approved For other indications With known safety profiles So they've got known safety profiles Now we can actively start prescribing these To patients The next step is to rapidly move to Human clinical trials

2386
02:04:39.923 --> 02:04:46.530
But I think it's got a potential to fundamentally alter ALS therapy and projections, right?

2387
02:04:46.550 --> 02:04:48.032
I thought it was very cool.

2388
02:04:48.092 --> 02:04:58.702
It's very clearly a step function change in what can be done in therapeutics for ALS and research in this area.

2389
02:04:58.722 --> 02:04:59.463
Yeah.

2390
02:05:00.284 --> 02:05:13.973
The area we wanted to just end on here, just given Congress actually just approved new funding for this month, is related to federal funding for ALS research.

2391
02:05:14.493 --> 02:05:26.441
So for those who might not be super familiar with who pays for fundamental science and how do we actually get the money to do a lot of this stuff, there are a variety of sources, but the federal government –

2392
02:05:27.673 --> 02:05:36.163
has been a huge funder of fundamental science research since the Constitution.

2393
02:05:36.183 --> 02:05:37.244
Let me – I don't know if you know this.

2394
02:05:37.264 --> 02:05:37.885
Did you know this?

2395
02:05:38.105 --> 02:05:47.717
In the Constitution, the word science is used, and I think like in Article 1, which is establishing the powers of the legislative branch –

2396
02:05:48.943 --> 02:06:03.395
I think it's section eight, clause eight, is that Congress must basically promote the investment and work in the sciences and related arts.

2397
02:06:03.735 --> 02:06:04.116
Wow.

2398
02:06:04.196 --> 02:06:05.437
And the word science –

2399
02:06:06.651 --> 02:06:09.473
is an Article I of the Constitution.

2400
02:06:09.613 --> 02:06:10.414
That's really cool.

2401
02:06:10.554 --> 02:06:13.056
That's got to be either Benjamin Franklin or Thomas Jefferson.

2402
02:06:13.196 --> 02:06:13.637
Yeah, 100%.

2403
02:06:13.677 --> 02:06:14.237
One of those two.

2404
02:06:14.257 --> 02:06:14.577
100%.

2405
02:06:14.597 --> 02:06:14.978
Yeah.

2406
02:06:15.358 --> 02:06:22.744
And so it is a part of the ethos of even the founding document for our nation.

2407
02:06:23.405 --> 02:06:25.446
It's a great document, by the way.

2408
02:06:25.466 --> 02:06:25.586
It is.

2409
02:06:25.626 --> 02:06:26.727
They were so ahead of the time.

2410
02:06:26.767 --> 02:06:28.849
Yeah, the Constitution is an amazing document.

2411
02:06:28.869 --> 02:06:29.449
It's quite nice.

2412
02:06:29.610 --> 02:06:33.112
If you have not read it, I encourage you because we now need to understand it now more than ever.

2413
02:06:33.132 --> 02:06:33.333
Yeah.

2414
02:06:34.293 --> 02:06:40.219
But on February 3rd of this year, Congress approved new ALS funding for the fiscal year of 2026.

2415
02:06:40.639 --> 02:06:48.807
So that means for the year that we're in, fiscal year of 2026, every year all these federal agencies and projects, they need to go –

2416
02:06:49.648 --> 02:06:53.089
They need to be appropriated new funding by Congress.

2417
02:06:53.489 --> 02:06:58.450
This is what Congress is always fighting about, among other things, is where should money be allocated?

2418
02:06:58.971 --> 02:07:07.753
So for fiscal year 2026, meaning next year they're going to have to, you know, all of the folks who are supporting and doing the nonprofit work to provide.

2419
02:07:08.753 --> 02:07:14.056
make sure Congress does continue to appropriate money, are consistently advocating for this to be true.

2420
02:07:14.556 --> 02:07:20.659
This year was a total of $315 million, which is the highest level of funding ever for ALS research.

2421
02:07:20.759 --> 02:07:21.699
It's a lot of money.

2422
02:07:22.539 --> 02:07:26.781
And I just briefly want to break down what the different categories of where this is going is.

2423
02:07:27.002 --> 02:07:27.222
Right.

2424
02:07:28.262 --> 02:07:33.207
$90 million is going for accelerating access to critical therapies for ALS.

2425
02:07:33.267 --> 02:07:41.215
It's sort of called ACT for ALS at the NIH, National Institutes of Health, which is a $15 million increase over fiscal year 2025.

2426
02:07:41.235 --> 02:07:45.340
They're going to do $30 million for Advanced Research Projects Agency for Health.

2427
02:07:45.700 --> 02:07:46.681
This is like ARPA-H.

2428
02:07:46.721 --> 02:07:49.084
It's like DARPA, but for health.

2429
02:07:49.504 --> 02:07:50.044
And so this is...

2430
02:07:50.745 --> 02:07:51.686
Net new funding.

2431
02:07:52.186 --> 02:07:55.408
This $30 million is net new that didn't exist previously.

2432
02:07:55.428 --> 02:08:02.653
$145 million for NIH general ALS research, not specific to critical therapies, which is sort of a subsidiary under NIH.

2433
02:08:03.334 --> 02:08:09.038
$40 million for Department of Defense ALS research through their directed medical research programs.

2434
02:08:09.438 --> 02:08:17.844
And then $10 million for the Center for Disease Control, CDC, and Prevention of National ALS Registry.

2435
02:08:18.784 --> 02:08:19.545
So, you know...

2436
02:08:21.718 --> 02:08:27.739
This funding is super important to generate outcomes.

2437
02:08:27.900 --> 02:08:38.782
It is not just private pharmaceutical companies and all these things that are kind of working in these areas, especially in areas that are not perceived to be financially lucrative.

2438
02:08:38.822 --> 02:08:42.563
Like my dad used to work in neglected diseases.

2439
02:08:43.183 --> 02:08:45.384
So this is a lot of things that impact the economy.

2440
02:08:46.745 --> 02:08:49.267
you know, sub-Saharan African population, et cetera.

2441
02:08:49.808 --> 02:08:54.872
There is no market for leishmania or African sleeping sickness, et cetera, et cetera.

2442
02:08:55.192 --> 02:09:01.517
And so it can be difficult to actually get the funding to do this work.

2443
02:09:02.058 --> 02:09:02.818
That does impact.

2444
02:09:02.838 --> 02:09:10.525
So kudos to Congress for being able to not only continue funding ALS research, but increasing it, and I think applying it in ways that are going to be impactful to,

2445
02:09:11.105 --> 02:09:19.314
And again, we are seeing the results of – because through NIH, et cetera, they give grants out to universities and research labs.

2446
02:09:19.334 --> 02:09:25.521
And so this money flows through the system in order to reach the experts like the folks we just talked about in the previous story.

2447
02:09:25.601 --> 02:09:25.842
Yeah.

2448
02:09:26.908 --> 02:09:28.989
Yeah, incredibly important work.

2449
02:09:29.229 --> 02:09:31.390
The U.S. has always been at the forefront.

2450
02:09:32.031 --> 02:09:44.998
Not always, but since post-war, we have been at the forefront of scientific research because our government has used our incredible economy to bankroll amazing scientific research.

2451
02:09:45.698 --> 02:09:46.559
And that shouldn't stop.

2452
02:09:47.620 --> 02:09:48.180
It should not.

2453
02:09:48.261 --> 02:09:49.542
It's incredibly important.

2454
02:09:49.562 --> 02:09:55.071
We had a fantastic, big, chunky, over two hours.

2455
02:09:55.371 --> 02:09:56.793
I think we're just over two hours.

2456
02:09:57.694 --> 02:09:58.435
We got a little excited.

2457
02:09:58.456 --> 02:10:00.198
We had some pretty good stories.

2458
02:10:00.258 --> 02:10:02.441
I mean, we started with the dream engineering, which...

2459
02:10:02.942 --> 02:10:07.265
I still want to follow up on that was out of Northwestern in the Neuroscience of Consciousness.

2460
02:10:07.545 --> 02:10:16.410
We followed that up with Understanding Measuring Protons, where we actually confirmed the previous experimental measurement.

2461
02:10:16.430 --> 02:10:19.091
This was from Max Planck Institute for Quantum Optics.

2462
02:10:19.131 --> 02:10:20.152
That was in Nature.

2463
02:10:20.532 --> 02:10:25.055
We ended with a sort of high-level overview of ALS research generally.

2464
02:10:26.316 --> 02:10:28.537
And the rundown, we had a bunch of stories in there as well.

2465
02:10:28.997 --> 02:10:31.558
We are going to go ahead and wrap this up.

2466
02:10:31.939 --> 02:10:38.962
Again, if you are still here listening, you are one of the core FFP nation.

2467
02:10:39.323 --> 02:10:40.763
You are so important to us.

2468
02:10:40.803 --> 02:10:46.026
We really appreciate those of you who find this interesting and valuable in your busy day.

2469
02:10:46.066 --> 02:10:48.027
There's so many ways you could spend your time.

2470
02:10:48.408 --> 02:10:50.649
There's so much infinite amounts of content.

2471
02:10:51.009 --> 02:10:54.071
You're choosing to spend your time with us, and we are grateful to you.

2472
02:10:54.511 --> 02:10:56.092
We must do our comment.

2473
02:10:56.612 --> 02:10:58.553
For our late show listeners.

2474
02:10:58.673 --> 02:10:58.953
Yes.

2475
02:10:59.013 --> 02:11:00.174
I think you said you had an idea.

2476
02:11:00.194 --> 02:11:01.455
Did I?

2477
02:11:01.775 --> 02:11:03.256
I'm sorry.

2478
02:11:03.416 --> 02:11:03.956
Brain fried.

2479
02:11:03.996 --> 02:11:04.416
No, look.

2480
02:11:04.637 --> 02:11:06.077
It's been two hours.

2481
02:11:06.218 --> 02:11:07.718
Hey, what would you...

2482
02:11:07.818 --> 02:11:11.120
If you could dream engineer... Oh, yeah.

2483
02:11:11.320 --> 02:11:11.481
Yeah.

2484
02:11:11.581 --> 02:11:13.822
What would you want to dream engineer in your dreams?

2485
02:11:13.882 --> 02:11:14.762
Yes, that's a good one.

2486
02:11:15.223 --> 02:11:17.444
Because we're going to get some interesting answers.

2487
02:11:17.684 --> 02:11:18.845
So let us know in the comments.

2488
02:11:19.685 --> 02:11:20.085
below.

2489
02:11:20.545 --> 02:11:26.167
Again, if you're listening, make sure you check us on video on Spotify and YouTube.

2490
02:11:26.467 --> 02:11:28.907
We're on all the socials where we put out all of our clips.

2491
02:11:29.227 --> 02:11:35.669
The clips don't always have the full context, so it's always encouraged to listen to the full podcast.

2492
02:11:36.169 --> 02:11:42.991
If you would like to support the show, you can become a patron by going to ffppod.com slash donate.

2493
02:11:43.271 --> 02:11:44.691
Follow, like, subscribe as always.

2494
02:11:46.127 --> 02:11:52.389
My name is Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

2495
02:11:52.869 --> 02:11:55.110
We are just so grateful for you all.

2496
02:11:55.150 --> 02:11:58.551
We will see you all next week.

2497
02:11:59.051 --> 02:12:03.013
And I now forget what I'm supposed to say with this is from First Principles at the end of the episode.

2498
02:12:03.053 --> 02:12:04.193
Something like that, yeah.

2499
02:12:04.613 --> 02:12:05.414
Something, something.

2500
02:12:06.734 --> 02:12:07.874
This is from First Principles.

2501
02:12:08.095 --> 02:12:09.275
Cue exit music.
