WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.111 --> 00:00:05.954
So we've been looking for this gene for like 50 years, and now these guys have finally found it.

2
00:00:06.234 --> 00:00:14.617
They literally took a single quantum state, and then they split it into two, but then they maintained entanglement.

3
00:00:14.997 --> 00:00:19.980
It looks like it turns out that an extra chromosome isn't always a bad thing.

4
00:00:20.020 --> 00:00:21.640
Yeah, if you're a Cancer.

5
00:00:21.700 --> 00:00:22.141
If you're a Cancer.

6
00:00:22.161 --> 00:00:24.802
If you're a Cancer, extra chromosomes can be really good.

7
00:00:24.962 --> 00:00:26.022
But not a Gemini.

8
00:00:26.162 --> 00:00:26.382
No.

9
00:00:26.522 --> 00:00:27.343
Or a Sagittarius.

10
00:00:30.092 --> 00:00:30.832
Hello, Internet.

11
00:00:30.852 --> 00:00:38.695
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

12
00:00:39.095 --> 00:00:46.157
We are back in studio this week with three great main stories lined up for you along with the rundown.

13
00:00:46.558 --> 00:00:53.420
This week, we're going to touch on a story about an overlooked plant and how it could transform medicine production.

14
00:00:53.820 --> 00:00:55.901
We're going to get into some quantum entanglement.

15
00:00:56.541 --> 00:00:59.063
which is giving us superpowers to measure the impossible.

16
00:00:59.444 --> 00:01:08.631
And we're going to end with this new breakthrough tool called Alpha K, which is helping scientists predict how cancer cells will evolve before they actually do.

17
00:01:09.132 --> 00:01:15.197
We're going to learn about the science from the ground up, because this is From First Principles.

18
00:01:30.012 --> 00:01:40.617
For our first story, we have a new research paper out of the University of York in the UK that was published in the New Phytologists.

19
00:01:41.277 --> 00:01:53.083
With the byline, scientists at the University of York have discovered how plants produce chemical compounds that might assist in developing new environmentally friendly medicines.

20
00:01:53.643 --> 00:01:54.985
We always like our plant stories.

21
00:01:55.265 --> 00:01:55.505
Yes.

22
00:01:55.605 --> 00:02:02.833
So let's break down what exactly is going on here in this new study from the University of York, which was published on January 13th.

23
00:02:03.114 --> 00:02:03.514
That's right.

24
00:02:03.654 --> 00:02:12.244
And, you know, plants are not as sexy, let's say, as, you know, animal cells or like bacteria, fungi.

25
00:02:12.825 --> 00:02:13.045
But...

26
00:02:14.095 --> 00:02:15.796
They're incredibly versatile.

27
00:02:16.237 --> 00:02:22.321
They've been around for 450 million years, and they've had to deal with a lot over those 450 million years, right?

28
00:02:22.381 --> 00:02:23.742
Because they don't really move around.

29
00:02:24.523 --> 00:02:31.948
And because they don't move around, they can't do traditional defenses of just, like, running away from something that's trying to eat you, right?

30
00:02:32.028 --> 00:02:33.029
They're fixed in place.

31
00:02:33.849 --> 00:02:41.175
And so they still need to evolve defenses against herbivores, pathogens, insects that are trying to eat them.

32
00:02:42.155 --> 00:02:42.296
And...

33
00:02:43.160 --> 00:02:46.661
their solution is effectively chemical warfare, okay?

34
00:02:46.941 --> 00:02:49.482
And they're really, really good at chemical warfare.

35
00:02:49.842 --> 00:02:54.503
And the core chemicals that we're talking about in this study are something called alkaloids.

36
00:02:54.843 --> 00:02:57.864
So they're nitrogen-containing secondary metabolites.

37
00:02:58.004 --> 00:03:03.085
By secondary metabolites, we mean like, you know, it's not actively involved in photosynthesis and stuff like that.

38
00:03:03.145 --> 00:03:04.726
It's a derivative of those compounds.

39
00:03:05.266 --> 00:03:07.887
And we're aware of these.

40
00:03:08.027 --> 00:03:11.428
Morphine, nicotine, caffeine, quinine,

41
00:03:13.755 --> 00:03:19.699
alkaloids that are made by plants as defense mechanisms that they figured out through their evolution, right?

42
00:03:20.240 --> 00:03:31.427
And this particular study that's out of the York University, it solved a 50-year-old mystery about how exactly certain plants make these compounds, okay?

43
00:03:31.507 --> 00:03:33.329
This idea of alkaloid synthesis.

44
00:03:33.869 --> 00:03:40.214
They found the gene that does it for a particular pathway, and that could lead to cheaper pharmaceuticals,

45
00:03:41.190 --> 00:03:42.312
A lot of really cool things.

46
00:03:42.392 --> 00:03:53.533
And I think the chemistry in this particular study is what I found really cool because they've figured out the nitty gritty mechanism by which this particular enzyme does what it's supposed to do.

47
00:03:54.103 --> 00:04:07.450
So we're going to understand and learn how plants generate and synthesize these alkaloids, which they use as a defense mechanism, but as humans have some potential commercial applications.

48
00:04:07.510 --> 00:04:08.191
Exactly, yeah.

49
00:04:08.271 --> 00:04:10.052
Pharmaceutical applications, all of that.

50
00:04:10.112 --> 00:04:13.394
So first, let's just try and appreciate the target molecules, right?

51
00:04:13.434 --> 00:04:14.154
These alkaloids.

52
00:04:14.674 --> 00:04:17.016
They are heterocyclic rings with a nitrogen.

53
00:04:17.076 --> 00:04:22.799
By heterocyclic, that means there's a cycle of carbon atoms, but one of the carbon atoms has been replaced by...

54
00:04:22.919 --> 00:04:23.580
by nitrogen.

55
00:04:23.980 --> 00:04:26.302
They all come mostly from amino acid.

56
00:04:26.322 --> 00:04:31.966
There's a few that come from the nucleic acids, but most of them are derived from amino acids.

57
00:04:32.666 --> 00:04:34.508
There's two different types that we can think about.

58
00:04:34.548 --> 00:04:41.413
There's the lysine derived, which are from the amino acid lysine, and then there's ornithine derived lysine.

59
00:04:41.673 --> 00:04:59.428
compounds nicotine probably one that's very ubiquitous that one comes from ornithine the idea is you take ornithine which is this amino acid it's a linear in chain and then you remove some stuff you add some stuff and you put it into a ring and that ring form becomes then nicotine okay so

60
00:05:00.917 --> 00:05:03.780
Why are plants even doing this in the first place, right?

61
00:05:04.461 --> 00:05:11.408
Nicotine, for example, very specifically, is something that mimics neurotransmitters in animals.

62
00:05:11.709 --> 00:05:14.572
Specifically in insects, it paralyzes them.

63
00:05:15.072 --> 00:05:19.136
So if there's an insect that's trying to eat this plant, it can't do it anymore, right?

64
00:05:19.156 --> 00:05:19.457
Uh-huh.

65
00:05:19.797 --> 00:05:28.484
But because of animal evolution, that particular neurotransmitter in insects is also related to stuff that we use in our brain, specifically acetylcholine.

66
00:05:28.985 --> 00:05:33.288
Here you can see the nicotine molecule and the acetylcholine molecule, right?

67
00:05:33.568 --> 00:05:40.133
The shapes of the two are kind of similar, which means that when nicotine goes inside our brain...

68
00:05:40.932 --> 00:05:54.881
The acetylcholine receptors, which are receptors on our neurons that recognize acetylcholine and then open up ion channels to then turn on or turn off a neuron, they could sometimes be triggered by nicotine.

69
00:05:55.262 --> 00:06:01.486
This is what leads to the cognitive effects of nicotine, you know, the high that you get or the addiction.

70
00:06:01.646 --> 00:06:09.431
All of that is just because the Lego block of nicotine is closely mimicking the Lego block that is acetylcholine.

71
00:06:09.651 --> 00:06:09.971
Got it.

72
00:06:10.172 --> 00:06:10.392
Right?

73
00:06:10.412 --> 00:06:10.672
Got it.

74
00:06:11.313 --> 00:06:19.501
And so that's why plants sort of have an advantage when they evolve these types of molecules, right?

75
00:06:20.101 --> 00:06:24.165
And a lot of these types of molecules can be used in pharmaceutical research.

76
00:06:24.626 --> 00:06:24.786
Okay.

77
00:06:25.046 --> 00:06:25.306
Okay.

78
00:06:25.807 --> 00:06:31.052
Now, the question is, how exactly do plants make this happen?

79
00:06:31.392 --> 00:06:33.715
Because remember what I said, there's...

80
00:06:35.033 --> 00:06:43.540
An amino acid, which is a linear chain, you usually have like an amine group, a carboxyl group, a carbon in the middle, and then some stuff attached to that carbon.

81
00:06:43.580 --> 00:06:44.401
It's a linear thing.

82
00:06:44.781 --> 00:06:46.542
You got to now turn this into a ring.

83
00:06:47.103 --> 00:06:47.343
Okay?

84
00:06:47.503 --> 00:06:50.025
There's several ways to do this at a molecular level.

85
00:06:50.606 --> 00:06:56.731
But it's been kind of annoying to figure out how exactly that happens.

86
00:06:57.230 --> 00:07:06.997
We understand conceptually how to do so not naturally inside a plant or how plants naturally do so.

87
00:07:07.377 --> 00:07:14.722
We can get it conceptually, but we've not yet been able to identify how plants do it in a non-manufactured way.

88
00:07:14.802 --> 00:07:16.344
Yes, yeah, yeah, exactly.

89
00:07:16.645 --> 00:07:22.073
And so one of the tools that you can use is something that goes back for at least 50 years.

90
00:07:22.134 --> 00:07:23.956
It's something called radioisotope tracing.

91
00:07:24.277 --> 00:07:26.941
What you do is you replace the carbon atoms.

92
00:07:27.677 --> 00:07:32.298
That you grow this plant with, with carbon 13 instead of carbon 14.

93
00:07:32.638 --> 00:07:33.619
Or sorry, carbon 12.

94
00:07:33.899 --> 00:07:36.839
Carbon 12 is six protons, six neutrons in the nucleus.

95
00:07:37.200 --> 00:07:41.541
Carbon 13 is the same number of protons, six, but you have an extra neutron.

96
00:07:41.561 --> 00:07:42.161
Okay.

97
00:07:42.181 --> 00:07:42.421
Okay.

98
00:07:42.681 --> 00:07:49.443
And when you, you know, let's say we supply the plant pathway with a bunch of glucose that is only carbon 13.

99
00:07:50.363 --> 00:08:14.593
right now we can trace how is that plant going to break up this glucose and incorporate it into different types of molecules for example pyruvate or the citric acid cycle how much of it is going to go into fatty acids right and we can figure out by weighing the fatty acids and the citric acid and things like that we can be like well the citric acid is only half as heavy as it would be if

100
00:08:15.913 --> 00:08:17.774
All of the carbon-13 went in there, right?

101
00:08:17.874 --> 00:08:21.236
Because it's got three extra neutrons instead of six extra neutrons.

102
00:08:21.536 --> 00:08:22.096
Things like that.

103
00:08:22.356 --> 00:08:25.538
So that's the logic behind this idea of radioisotope tracing.

104
00:08:25.578 --> 00:08:34.022
It's been used to figure out that DNA is the genetic code of life, if we go back to our Watson and Crick episode of last year, right?

105
00:08:34.642 --> 00:08:39.765
And so the question now is, we'd like to apply this technique to...

106
00:08:40.763 --> 00:08:42.625
How do plants make these alkaloids?

107
00:08:43.146 --> 00:08:43.366
Okay.

108
00:08:43.967 --> 00:08:48.652
Now let's, let's start with the substrate lysine, which is the amino acid.

109
00:08:48.972 --> 00:08:49.232
Okay.

110
00:08:49.633 --> 00:08:55.299
And this lysine is going to go on to make like an abacine or security and some, some alkaloid that we're interested in.

111
00:08:55.319 --> 00:08:55.679
Okay.

112
00:08:55.699 --> 00:08:55.880
Okay.

113
00:08:57.017 --> 00:08:58.078
The problem is the following.

114
00:08:58.218 --> 00:09:05.965
When lysine goes through and becomes this alkaloid, there's an intermediate compound called cadaverine.

115
00:09:07.286 --> 00:09:07.906
Here's the idea.

116
00:09:08.427 --> 00:09:11.970
Lysine is not symmetric because you've got an amino group on one end.

117
00:09:11.990 --> 00:09:13.891
That's the H2N, the nitrogen.

118
00:09:14.252 --> 00:09:15.833
And then you have an amino group on the other end.

119
00:09:15.853 --> 00:09:21.738
But then that's also connected to a carboxyl group, which is the COOH, carbon, oxygen, oxygen, hydrogen.

120
00:09:22.379 --> 00:09:23.319
So it's not symmetric.

121
00:09:23.460 --> 00:09:23.740
Okay.

122
00:09:24.040 --> 00:09:32.723
There's going to be a process called decarboxylation, where you take that carboxyl group out, and now it becomes a symmetric molecule, right?

123
00:09:33.063 --> 00:09:36.705
There's an amino group, H2N on one end, and then there's an NH2 on the other end.

124
00:09:37.105 --> 00:09:41.726
The switching of the letters is just to show that it's completely symmetric.

125
00:09:42.347 --> 00:09:47.929
If I were to look at this molecule cadaverine this way, and then I were to switch it around, it would look the same to me.

126
00:09:48.109 --> 00:09:48.589
Okay.

127
00:09:48.609 --> 00:09:48.809
Okay?

128
00:09:49.289 --> 00:09:51.310
Now, if that is an intermediate...

129
00:09:52.230 --> 00:09:53.430
Then what should happen?

130
00:09:53.610 --> 00:10:00.812
Another enzyme would take that intermediate, and then it could grab on one end, or it could grab the other end.

131
00:10:00.972 --> 00:10:01.172
Right.

132
00:10:01.292 --> 00:10:05.793
Because it doesn't know which way it came out of the enzyme.

133
00:10:05.893 --> 00:10:11.735
Which end of the molecule, the left or right, had this COOH attached, it doesn't know.

134
00:10:12.015 --> 00:10:13.355
Because it's just freely floating around.

135
00:10:13.695 --> 00:10:15.856
So this next step enzyme is going to grab that.

136
00:10:22.157 --> 00:10:29.840
with the nitrogen on one end, and let's say that nitrogen is our index of reference, the radiocarbon could be either on the left or the right, right?

137
00:10:30.140 --> 00:10:38.264
Because whatever molecule turned it into a ring grabbed that cadaverine from either the left end or the right end, okay?

138
00:10:38.724 --> 00:10:44.806
And that's what we see in a lot of our stepwise symmetric pathways.

139
00:10:44.826 --> 00:10:47.308
These are called stepwise symmetric, okay?

140
00:10:47.568 --> 00:10:50.209
In the sense that it doesn't know which one,

141
00:10:51.219 --> 00:11:03.768
It grabbed, and so that top line, you get this heterocarbon ring with the nitrogen, and that tagged carbon is either to the left of the nitrogen or to the right of the nitrogen.

142
00:11:04.289 --> 00:11:11.854
Now, that happens in some plants, but in other plants, that tagged carbon is always going to be on the left of the nitrogen.

143
00:11:12.194 --> 00:11:12.675
Interesting.

144
00:11:12.835 --> 00:11:13.015
Okay.

145
00:11:13.035 --> 00:11:13.135
Okay.

146
00:11:13.715 --> 00:11:22.698
So what is making it move from being a chance, a 50-50, to 100% always being on a singular side, which creates consistency?

147
00:11:22.798 --> 00:11:23.279
Exactly.

148
00:11:23.379 --> 00:11:26.920
And there's actually a lot of these compounds that are like this.

149
00:11:26.980 --> 00:11:32.162
From both lysine and ornithine, you've got plants like nicotiana, phlegea.

150
00:11:32.982 --> 00:11:35.623
These guys make these asymmetric compounds.

151
00:11:35.703 --> 00:11:37.944
Sorry, nicotiana sounds like a Cardi B song.

152
00:11:39.384 --> 00:11:40.125
It totally does.

153
00:11:40.225 --> 00:11:41.005
And she would be...

154
00:11:42.404 --> 00:11:46.966
Remiss to say that it is an asymmetric alkaloid.

155
00:11:47.946 --> 00:11:51.448
But this is pretty common is the idea.

156
00:11:51.648 --> 00:11:52.888
So it's not a unique thing.

157
00:11:53.068 --> 00:11:56.850
We see it across a variety of these compounds.

158
00:11:56.930 --> 00:11:59.231
Yeah, it's across a variety of these compounds.

159
00:11:59.691 --> 00:12:02.212
And so there's something very interesting going on.

160
00:12:02.552 --> 00:12:05.153
And this might seem kind of just like a boring trick.

161
00:12:05.213 --> 00:12:08.914
Okay, so your tagged carbon is only on one side.

162
00:12:11.095 --> 00:12:12.336
Who cares?

163
00:12:12.376 --> 00:12:13.056
Yeah, who cares?

164
00:12:13.116 --> 00:12:27.687
But now let's actually, before we even talk about applications and stuff, let's actually think about, okay, what could be happening at the chemical level such that my enzyme is always grabbing one end?

165
00:12:27.707 --> 00:12:28.167
Mm-hmm.

166
00:12:29.536 --> 00:12:31.897
of a symmetric molecule.

167
00:12:32.077 --> 00:12:37.120
It's a rod that looks exactly the same whether I were to do it this way or turn it around.

168
00:12:37.520 --> 00:12:40.381
And yet the enzyme is always grabbing one end.

169
00:12:40.941 --> 00:12:50.065
And this is where we come to a hypothesis that was given in 1973 by Leisner and Spencer in the Journal of American Chemical Society.

170
00:12:50.806 --> 00:12:52.726
1973, so this is 50 years ago.

171
00:12:53.927 --> 00:12:55.788
They said the only way that this can happen

172
00:12:56.985 --> 00:13:05.494
is if there's a single process that goes from amino acid, strips the COOH, and then makes the ring.

173
00:13:06.613 --> 00:13:14.682
If that intermediate cadaverine were to go and freely float around, there's no way that the next enzyme would grab one end.

174
00:13:15.263 --> 00:13:19.327
This only happens if, like, you know, in some analogy, let's say I'm the enzyme.

175
00:13:19.808 --> 00:13:27.316
With my right hand, I grab the amino acid, I strip the COOH, and then I put it to my left hand and I make a ring.

176
00:13:27.336 --> 00:13:27.537
Mm-hmm.

177
00:13:28.017 --> 00:13:28.217
Right.

178
00:13:28.557 --> 00:13:30.578
I'm doing it in one smooth process.

179
00:13:30.618 --> 00:13:30.798
Yes.

180
00:13:31.038 --> 00:13:32.478
There's not I'm grabbing it.

181
00:13:32.558 --> 00:13:33.259
I'm letting it go.

182
00:13:33.299 --> 00:13:41.421
And there's some other guy who's grabbing it because if the other guy grabs it, it's had time to tumble in the 300 Kelvin environment of the cell.

183
00:13:41.861 --> 00:13:42.101
Right.

184
00:13:42.481 --> 00:13:44.982
And so it's a very nice thing.

185
00:13:45.795 --> 00:13:47.035
Kind of hypothesis, right?

186
00:13:47.196 --> 00:13:51.777
It's like when you think about it at the molecular level, this is the only way that it could have happened.

187
00:13:52.678 --> 00:14:01.581
There can't be a chain of independent processes generating this outcome because it would be the second...

188
00:14:02.321 --> 00:14:21.312
link in the chain would not have sufficient information to consistently select for the same side yeah so it has to be an end-to-end process yes that is self-contained from start to finish yes and this was in 1973 they had this hypothesis okay and people have been looking for this enzyme ever since

189
00:14:21.952 --> 00:14:28.919
So we have the hypothesis, which defines this idea that it has to be a singular process, but we've not seen it experimentally.

190
00:14:29.419 --> 00:14:30.680
Yeah, we've been trying to look for it.

191
00:14:30.800 --> 00:14:31.101
Okay.

192
00:14:31.121 --> 00:14:31.941
These guys found it.

193
00:14:32.102 --> 00:14:32.702
Okay.

194
00:14:32.722 --> 00:14:34.103
That is the paper.

195
00:14:34.243 --> 00:14:34.704
Okay.

196
00:14:34.724 --> 00:14:38.828
This phantom enzyme for over 50 years, it's now been found.

197
00:14:39.328 --> 00:14:43.332
The study is out in new phytologist, first author Wood.

198
00:14:44.637 --> 00:14:45.497
Very nice paper.

199
00:14:45.758 --> 00:14:46.538
Catherine Wood.

200
00:14:46.638 --> 00:14:50.139
And the idea, this is a 50-year-old treasure hunt.

201
00:14:50.600 --> 00:14:51.600
To try and find this thing.

202
00:14:51.880 --> 00:14:52.140
Okay?

203
00:14:52.220 --> 00:14:54.381
And there are applications that we'll get to later.

204
00:14:54.421 --> 00:15:04.686
But I think it's just incredible that, like, there's been the science question for 50 years based on a very simple experiment, which is that this pathway is not symmetric.

205
00:15:04.726 --> 00:15:09.168
And the only way it can't be symmetric is, as you said, it's got to be an end-to-end process.

206
00:15:09.188 --> 00:15:09.508
Right.

207
00:15:09.808 --> 00:15:20.454
And one thing that's always so interesting in the modern conversations, in the contemporary conversations about science is this idea that we've already solved all of the problems.

208
00:15:21.275 --> 00:15:25.977
And or solving old problems is, you know, sufficiently trivial.

209
00:15:26.198 --> 00:15:26.918
Yeah.

210
00:15:27.378 --> 00:15:28.619
And this is a perfect example.

211
00:15:28.779 --> 00:15:30.280
That's obviously not true.

212
00:15:30.400 --> 00:15:31.220
It's obviously not true.

213
00:15:31.340 --> 00:15:32.701
But this is a perfect example of that.

214
00:15:32.861 --> 00:15:33.281
Exactly.

215
00:15:33.361 --> 00:15:38.442
And this paper is also really nice because it uses very modern techniques to answer this problem.

216
00:15:38.763 --> 00:15:41.483
We've got AlphaFold with AI that we're going to get into later.

217
00:15:41.503 --> 00:15:42.424
Okay.

218
00:15:42.764 --> 00:15:47.665
New techniques that are only, you know, sort of available now in the modern day.

219
00:15:48.265 --> 00:15:48.465
Right?

220
00:15:49.026 --> 00:15:52.947
So the target organism that they used in this study is Phlugea.

221
00:15:53.767 --> 00:16:07.378
sufruticosa it's um actually used in chinese medicine yi yi qi i believe is how you pronounce it um i got one of my friends who's chinese to to send me a voice recording so if that's wrong that's his fault um

222
00:16:09.379 --> 00:16:10.260
Maybe he's setting me up.

223
00:16:10.680 --> 00:16:17.964
But it's been used in Chinese medicine, and we know consistently that it forms non-symmetric alkaloid securinine.

224
00:16:18.224 --> 00:16:18.684
Okay.

225
00:16:18.724 --> 00:16:24.807
So this is now the model organism that we're going to use to try and find what is the enzyme in this plant that is doing this.

226
00:16:25.608 --> 00:16:31.551
They do transcriptome analysis, so they extract the RNA from 15 different tissues in the plant.

227
00:16:32.211 --> 00:16:40.058
And they do de novo transcriptome analysis of the whole thing to figure out what the mRNA is that is being transcribed from the DNA.

228
00:16:40.739 --> 00:16:42.260
From that, they get a bunch of candidates.

229
00:16:42.901 --> 00:16:43.742
And they look for...

230
00:16:44.669 --> 00:16:49.333
what are the enzymes that could be possible that are creating this?

231
00:16:49.733 --> 00:16:51.395
They find two enzymes.

232
00:16:51.435 --> 00:16:55.178
There's gene 4984, 4984.

233
00:16:55.518 --> 00:16:57.339
That's your standard cadaverine.

234
00:16:57.439 --> 00:16:59.962
It produces your cadaverine, which is the intermediate product.

235
00:17:00.502 --> 00:17:11.911
But then they've got this one gene, 1864, and that produced your 1-peperidine, which is a precursor of that securonine with the alkaloid.

236
00:17:12.312 --> 00:17:13.793
It's producing that end product.

237
00:17:15.018 --> 00:17:15.298
In one step.

238
00:17:15.318 --> 00:17:15.598
In one step.

239
00:17:15.619 --> 00:17:16.819
You're not getting any cadaverine.

240
00:17:17.220 --> 00:17:17.460
Okay?

241
00:17:17.700 --> 00:17:19.602
You're not getting anything in the middle.

242
00:17:19.662 --> 00:17:23.625
And this is that Olado enzyme that we're going to get into later on.

243
00:17:23.645 --> 00:17:25.066
But that's the enzyme that they found.

244
00:17:25.466 --> 00:17:30.270
And they found that this enzyme could take you from lysine all the way to the end in one go.

245
00:17:30.290 --> 00:17:30.410
Okay.

246
00:17:30.910 --> 00:17:40.073
So the idea is gene 4984 was just getting us to, in this chart that we're looking at, the middle step where the cadaverine is created.

247
00:17:40.333 --> 00:17:47.875
But it did not bring us through the oxidation and then all the way down into the sort of final product.

248
00:17:47.915 --> 00:17:48.335
That's right.

249
00:17:48.515 --> 00:17:56.017
But that gene 1864, this was the smoking gun because it was that end-to-end process.

250
00:17:56.097 --> 00:17:56.617
Exactly.

251
00:17:56.837 --> 00:18:01.860
Yeah, and it's the smoking gun, but that's not going to make your paper.

252
00:18:02.580 --> 00:18:02.961
I see.

253
00:18:03.141 --> 00:18:03.441
Okay.

254
00:18:03.701 --> 00:18:08.644
Because if you just submitted a paper being like, hey, we found this enzyme that does the whole thing.

255
00:18:09.525 --> 00:18:11.666
Well, it could be doing all sorts of other stuff.

256
00:18:11.906 --> 00:18:17.409
Reviewer 2 is going to be like, well, you didn't really show that it's non-symmetric and all this other stuff, right?

257
00:18:17.449 --> 00:18:17.709
Yeah.

258
00:18:17.729 --> 00:18:19.270
So, Reviewer 2 is going to get you.

259
00:18:19.290 --> 00:18:20.411
You got to go even deeper.

260
00:18:20.451 --> 00:18:23.573
You got to really convince your reviewers that...

261
00:18:24.431 --> 00:18:30.901
that this is the thing that is doing that non-symmetric grabbing, and how is it doing it?

262
00:18:32.343 --> 00:18:33.385
All this other stuff, right?

263
00:18:33.445 --> 00:18:35.187
And so they didn't stop there.

264
00:18:35.548 --> 00:18:39.854
Next, what they did was they purified that gene, they incubated it, and then...

265
00:18:41.077 --> 00:18:43.859
They wanted to see how exactly is it doing this.

266
00:18:44.280 --> 00:18:48.223
So they got a lysine and they tagged the nitrogen this time.

267
00:18:48.583 --> 00:18:49.043
Okay.

268
00:18:49.504 --> 00:18:52.246
The nitrogen this time is only going to be on one end.

269
00:18:53.267 --> 00:18:59.832
And if it is stepwise, meaning there's an intermediate, then the nitrogen is going to—we're going to see—

270
00:19:00.818 --> 00:19:08.360
We're going to see a nitrogen getting stripped, and so you'll see the final product not have that radioactivity, that radioactive isotope of nitrogen.

271
00:19:09.220 --> 00:19:11.721
Or you're going to see the radioactivity, right?

272
00:19:11.801 --> 00:19:12.461
It's going to be 50-50.

273
00:19:12.541 --> 00:19:13.522
Okay.

274
00:19:13.682 --> 00:19:20.184
The nitrogen that you put in, that you tagged, is either going to be there or it's not because the enzyme is either grabbing the left end or the right end.

275
00:19:20.204 --> 00:19:21.204
Or the right end.

276
00:19:22.076 --> 00:19:27.018
If it is a concerted single-step reaction, then the nitrogen is always going to be there.

277
00:19:27.318 --> 00:19:31.880
The nitrogen that you put in on one end of this lysine is always going to be there.

278
00:19:32.940 --> 00:19:34.021
And that is what they found.

279
00:19:34.421 --> 00:19:38.142
They found that this is, again, this radioisotope measurement that they did.

280
00:19:38.522 --> 00:19:43.084
The other thing they did was nuclear magnetic resonance, the NMR, which is the stuff when we get—

281
00:19:45.605 --> 00:19:46.866
are MRIs.

282
00:19:47.047 --> 00:19:47.227
Yes.

283
00:19:47.407 --> 00:19:48.468
It's the same technology.

284
00:19:48.488 --> 00:19:56.015
What they're using is that the nitrogen that they tagged has an odd number of nucleons in it, which means it's going to have a spin.

285
00:19:56.335 --> 00:20:01.940
And so you can measure that nuclear spin to figure out if your nitrogen is currently there.

286
00:20:02.380 --> 00:20:02.601
Okay.

287
00:20:02.761 --> 00:20:03.682
And they found that, yep,

288
00:20:04.162 --> 00:20:09.605
That nitrogen is definitely still there in our product, which means that this is the asymmetric reaction.

289
00:20:09.885 --> 00:20:12.386
Because your nitrogen in the beginning was only on the left end.

290
00:20:12.426 --> 00:20:12.626
Yes.

291
00:20:12.826 --> 00:20:13.026
Right?

292
00:20:13.326 --> 00:20:17.868
And now the fact that it's 100% there all the time means this enzyme is always grabbing that left end.

293
00:20:18.449 --> 00:20:18.669
Right?

294
00:20:19.709 --> 00:20:30.994
And so we've used the combination of observational tools and tracing tools to actually watch the evolution of the process.

295
00:20:31.095 --> 00:20:31.235
Mm-hmm.

296
00:20:32.320 --> 00:20:37.562
To both show the stepwise and concerted versions and what happens.

297
00:20:37.602 --> 00:20:41.383
And because we're tagging the nitrogen, which is supposed to always be in the same spot.

298
00:20:41.524 --> 00:20:41.764
Yeah.

299
00:20:42.224 --> 00:20:47.526
Each time it's very obvious when you look at the tracing that in one of these pathways, it's always there.

300
00:20:47.586 --> 00:20:47.706
Yeah.

301
00:20:47.726 --> 00:20:47.826
Yeah.

302
00:20:48.346 --> 00:20:53.895
And so it's a combination of these different levels of tooling that have allowed them to make this observation.

303
00:20:53.975 --> 00:20:54.396
Exactly.

304
00:20:54.416 --> 00:20:54.616
Yeah.

305
00:20:54.736 --> 00:20:57.761
And then they want to get into even deeper this enzyme.

306
00:20:57.821 --> 00:20:59.283
How does the enzyme actually work?

307
00:20:59.463 --> 00:21:00.144
Still not good enough.

308
00:21:00.164 --> 00:21:00.845
Still not good enough.

309
00:21:00.885 --> 00:21:02.989
Why is it different from the normal ones?

310
00:21:04.130 --> 00:21:09.215
So this class of enzymes, they're calling it ornithine, lysine, arginine, decarboxyl oxidases.

311
00:21:09.515 --> 00:21:15.801
The decarboxyl oxidases is key because it's both doing the decarboxylation and the oxidation in a single step.

312
00:21:16.602 --> 00:21:18.384
These are called OLADOS.

313
00:21:18.464 --> 00:21:19.505
Yeah, OLADOS.

314
00:21:19.585 --> 00:21:21.066
OLADOS is the acronym.

315
00:21:21.126 --> 00:21:21.547
Yeah.

316
00:21:21.927 --> 00:21:27.911
Yeah, and they're from a class of proteins called PLPs, which use vitamin B6 as a cofactor.

317
00:21:27.931 --> 00:21:34.434
So the vitamin B6 is like helping along the enzyme, even though it's not part of the active substrate.

318
00:21:34.915 --> 00:21:38.077
It's like in the back, sort of like making sure that the enzyme...

319
00:21:39.359 --> 00:22:04.440
shape is correct okay next they used alpha fold okay this is an ai tool that was developed my google's deep mind to predict the 3d structure before let me just take a step back but before we had alpha fold you had to like do all sorts of protein crystallography maybe like cryo em all this other stuff now you can just plug it in to alpha fold and you'll get a really nice

320
00:22:05.723 --> 00:22:06.464
3D structure.

321
00:22:06.684 --> 00:22:08.106
Plug it in, plug it in.

322
00:22:08.146 --> 00:22:08.366
Right?

323
00:22:08.626 --> 00:22:10.649
And it's like, it's super cheap to do.

324
00:22:11.470 --> 00:22:18.297
Once you've got that, now we can figure out what is the difference between the ancestral Ola-do and this particular Ola-do.

325
00:22:19.153 --> 00:22:25.379
The difference is a tiny amino acid, difference between tyrosine and phenylalanine.

326
00:22:25.799 --> 00:22:27.260
Look at the structures of these two.

327
00:22:27.621 --> 00:22:32.285
They're exactly the same, except for a hydroxyl group, an OH.

328
00:22:32.665 --> 00:22:38.730
The phenylalanine just has an OH attached, and that OH is the entire difference.

329
00:22:39.391 --> 00:22:40.112
That's so funny.

330
00:22:40.812 --> 00:22:41.933
Such a minuscule...

331
00:22:42.273 --> 00:22:43.674
It's a tiny... Yeah.

332
00:22:44.334 --> 00:22:47.176
All it is is one of the carbons is attached to an OH.

333
00:22:47.536 --> 00:22:50.038
Otherwise, the entire amino acid is exactly the same.

334
00:22:50.638 --> 00:22:56.682
But that one site difference in the active site is what causes this entire change.

335
00:22:57.742 --> 00:22:58.203
Downstream.

336
00:22:58.223 --> 00:23:00.684
It's what basically changes all of the downstream.

337
00:23:00.904 --> 00:23:01.645
All of the downstream.

338
00:23:01.665 --> 00:23:09.890
Because if you don't have the OH, effectively what that means is if you don't have the OH, the cadaverine comes in, or you make the cadaverine, and then...

339
00:23:10.530 --> 00:23:19.053
The OH, if you have the OH, it stops another hydrogen from coming in and sort of freeing this guy.

340
00:23:19.133 --> 00:23:19.433
Got it.

341
00:23:19.773 --> 00:23:19.973
Got it.

342
00:23:20.013 --> 00:23:20.293
Okay?

343
00:23:20.354 --> 00:23:24.595
Before, there was nothing to stop another H plus ion from coming in and just like freeing this.

344
00:23:24.855 --> 00:23:28.456
This thing goes away and then, you know, some other enzyme hooks up with it.

345
00:23:28.756 --> 00:23:31.758
Here, because I've got the OH, I'm not messing with this cadaverine.

346
00:23:31.998 --> 00:23:34.619
The cadaverine stays inside my enzyme for longer.

347
00:23:34.979 --> 00:23:38.720
And then the process of oxidation can actually happen within the same spot.

348
00:23:38.780 --> 00:23:39.360
If that makes sense.

349
00:23:39.580 --> 00:23:46.003
It's sort of like this because of its presence, it dictates whether it will stay or whether it will.

350
00:23:46.023 --> 00:23:46.183
Yeah.

351
00:23:46.303 --> 00:23:53.047
For like the time that it stays inside the enzyme is determined by whether that oxygen and hydrogen are there or not.

352
00:23:53.587 --> 00:24:00.150
OK. What's again very cool about this particular enzyme is also it is very promiscuous.

353
00:24:00.250 --> 00:24:00.390
Right.

354
00:24:00.590 --> 00:24:02.891
It's not loyal to lysine or ornithine.

355
00:24:03.211 --> 00:24:05.572
It does lysine or ornithine, arginine.

356
00:24:05.832 --> 00:24:10.213
So it's incredibly versatile if we want to use it for industrial purposes.

357
00:24:10.594 --> 00:24:28.780
This goes back to the idea we keep coming up with with some of these things, whereas is it a single point discovery or is it in my analogy of it more of a platform that has multiple use case possibilities because it's a fundamental unlock that has more than a singular point solution?

358
00:24:28.820 --> 00:24:29.561
Exactly, yeah.

359
00:24:29.641 --> 00:24:31.984
So it's very cool in that way, right?

360
00:24:32.024 --> 00:24:33.426
Because it's very versatile.

361
00:24:33.786 --> 00:24:39.733
It can use all sorts of amino acids to create these compounds of many different types.

362
00:24:39.773 --> 00:24:40.935
It's like a little mini factory.

363
00:24:40.975 --> 00:24:41.696
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

364
00:24:41.796 --> 00:24:42.356
It's very cool.

365
00:24:42.416 --> 00:24:45.000
And it's doing both processes at once.

366
00:24:45.060 --> 00:24:47.102
It's like a single machine that end to end.

367
00:24:47.382 --> 00:24:47.623
Yes.

368
00:24:47.943 --> 00:24:54.165
Which is it like an efficiency play, less likelihood for issues, transitioning from a step one to a step two.

369
00:24:54.205 --> 00:24:54.865
All these kind of things.

370
00:24:54.885 --> 00:24:55.185
All these.

371
00:24:55.225 --> 00:24:55.506
Yeah.

372
00:24:55.686 --> 00:24:59.387
And you're already getting to sort of what I'm going to talk about at the end, which is the applications.

373
00:24:59.467 --> 00:25:07.470
But before we do that, the last bit that they studied was the evolution of this particular enzyme.

374
00:25:07.730 --> 00:25:07.970
Okay.

375
00:25:08.250 --> 00:25:10.991
How did plants figure out how to make this?

376
00:25:11.391 --> 00:25:11.651
Yeah.

377
00:25:11.671 --> 00:25:11.851
Okay.

378
00:25:12.031 --> 00:25:12.231
Yeah.

379
00:25:12.291 --> 00:25:17.013
You would think that the plants, you know, usually you'd naively think the plants have some precursor protein.

380
00:25:17.778 --> 00:25:20.220
And then that precursor protein gets mutated in some way.

381
00:25:20.680 --> 00:25:22.602
And then I have this new use case.

382
00:25:23.562 --> 00:25:29.667
This particular enzyme is actually more related to bacterial enzymes, not plants.

383
00:25:30.027 --> 00:25:30.448
Interesting.

384
00:25:30.488 --> 00:25:30.768
Okay.

385
00:25:31.148 --> 00:25:34.431
That's kind of weird because bacteria are not plants.

386
00:25:34.771 --> 00:25:35.071
Right.

387
00:25:35.812 --> 00:25:39.275
Unless we remember that the chloroplasts that are inside bacteria...

388
00:25:39.982 --> 00:25:40.543
were once...

389
00:25:40.963 --> 00:25:46.871
I mean, sorry, the chloroplasts that are inside plants now were once cyanobacteria.

390
00:25:47.352 --> 00:25:54.922
They were once bacteria that through endosymbiosis became integrated inside the plant cell

391
00:25:55.402 --> 00:26:05.885
And they've just stuck around for like a billion years because they've had a good, the plant cell has had a good, the plant cell gets glucose and ATP, so energy and food out of the cyanobacteria.

392
00:26:06.225 --> 00:26:09.746
The cyanobacteria is in a nice, like, all-inclusive resort.

393
00:26:10.226 --> 00:26:16.328
It doesn't have to worry about, like, trying to get food for itself because the plant is just supplying it as long as it does the work, right?

394
00:26:16.788 --> 00:26:17.028
So...

395
00:26:17.828 --> 00:26:24.091
This particular enzyme is more related to the decarboxylases in bacteria than it is to plants.

396
00:26:24.711 --> 00:26:31.475
And if we look through the evolution, there's independent lineages that all of these different plants have.

397
00:26:31.495 --> 00:26:33.215
Because remember, we've got different plants, right?

398
00:26:33.235 --> 00:26:35.957
We've got rosids, nicotiana.

399
00:26:37.337 --> 00:26:37.998
Artemisia.

400
00:26:38.839 --> 00:26:43.884
All of these are different plants that are finding ways to make this happen.

401
00:26:44.504 --> 00:26:50.750
They've independently found this bacteria enzyme and they've repurposed it.

402
00:26:51.131 --> 00:26:54.434
So it's not like one guy did it and then he let everyone know.

403
00:26:54.894 --> 00:26:56.196
All of these different lineages

404
00:26:57.405 --> 00:27:00.269
did it at different times, but they found the same use case.

405
00:27:00.349 --> 00:27:01.250
That's so fascinating.

406
00:27:01.270 --> 00:27:02.832
Which is pretty interesting, right?

407
00:27:02.852 --> 00:27:10.322
It's almost like a fundamental thing that's like each of these lineages were like, this is the most efficient way to do this process.

408
00:27:10.402 --> 00:27:10.623
Yeah.

409
00:27:10.923 --> 00:27:11.464
And they all...

410
00:27:13.169 --> 00:27:16.590
sort of ended up centering on the same implementation.

411
00:27:16.610 --> 00:27:20.791
Yeah, they reinvented the wheel like four or five times in evolution.

412
00:27:20.811 --> 00:27:27.053
It's kind of interesting to think about because one thing you could ask is like, how is this even possible, right?

413
00:27:27.353 --> 00:27:29.153
How do you do this kind of evolution?

414
00:27:29.173 --> 00:27:32.614
Well, the cyanobacteria genome gets integrated.

415
00:27:33.534 --> 00:27:36.075
The bacterial genome gets integrated into the plant genome.

416
00:27:36.535 --> 00:27:38.736
And then what you have is these things called tandem arrays,

417
00:27:39.396 --> 00:27:44.697
which is effectively when you replicate a gene, sometimes you get multiple copies of that gene.

418
00:27:44.897 --> 00:27:45.117
Okay.

419
00:27:45.337 --> 00:27:47.257
And that becomes something called a tandem array.

420
00:27:47.918 --> 00:27:51.258
Now your main copy, you don't want to mess with.

421
00:27:51.338 --> 00:27:51.558
Right.

422
00:27:51.858 --> 00:27:52.118
Okay.

423
00:27:52.899 --> 00:27:54.039
It's kind of like in GitHub.

424
00:27:54.359 --> 00:28:00.080
When you like push commits, you have a branch separately for yourself where you're doing all sorts of heinous crap.

425
00:28:00.260 --> 00:28:01.160
Don't push it to main.

426
00:28:01.440 --> 00:28:02.040
Yeah.

427
00:28:02.060 --> 00:28:05.761
You never push it to main unless you're really sure that it's working.

428
00:28:06.281 --> 00:28:06.501
Right.

429
00:28:07.142 --> 00:28:11.545
And so this tandem array is basically that it's effectively like multiple GitHub branches.

430
00:28:11.905 --> 00:28:14.968
You're messing around here and your main is still going at it.

431
00:28:15.488 --> 00:28:18.290
But with all these copies, you can you can start doing some mutations.

432
00:28:18.310 --> 00:28:18.991
You can figure it out.

433
00:28:19.231 --> 00:28:22.854
And if something works, hey, let's keep it, you know, because evolution wants to keep it.

434
00:28:23.389 --> 00:28:26.592
plants invented version control before GitHub.

435
00:28:26.712 --> 00:28:27.072
Okay.

436
00:28:27.492 --> 00:28:29.374
So this, you heard it here first.

437
00:28:29.574 --> 00:28:29.834
Yeah.

438
00:28:29.934 --> 00:28:30.115
Yeah.

439
00:28:30.175 --> 00:28:32.697
Plant based version control is the true OG.

440
00:28:32.777 --> 00:28:33.057
Yeah.

441
00:28:33.197 --> 00:28:33.978
Yeah, exactly.

442
00:28:33.998 --> 00:28:35.639
And we're just, we're just repurposing it.

443
00:28:35.659 --> 00:28:36.440
Repurposing it.

444
00:28:36.800 --> 00:28:38.341
So now let's look into applications.

445
00:28:38.741 --> 00:28:39.662
What could this be used for?

446
00:28:39.702 --> 00:28:40.063
Well, uh,

447
00:28:41.243 --> 00:28:43.545
these alkaloids are very important in medicine, right?

448
00:28:44.265 --> 00:28:55.333
And what you can do, for example, if you want to make securinine, which is this particular compound that we're studying, this is, you know, in cancer, this can be used against leukemia.

449
00:28:55.673 --> 00:29:02.778
For leukemia therapy, it can be used as a kind of neuroprotection type thing.

450
00:29:03.979 --> 00:29:07.341
Before, what we used to have to do is grow this plant

451
00:29:08.593 --> 00:29:10.355
And get the compound out.

452
00:29:10.755 --> 00:29:12.337
You can imagine that's not scalable.

453
00:29:12.557 --> 00:29:12.757
No.

454
00:29:13.058 --> 00:29:14.219
And it's very expensive.

455
00:29:14.239 --> 00:29:14.479
Yeah.

456
00:29:15.020 --> 00:29:16.761
Now we know the gene that does it.

457
00:29:17.242 --> 00:29:20.185
Furthermore, the gene is a one-step process.

458
00:29:21.026 --> 00:29:26.651
So we can just crisper this gene into yeast and then grow yeast.

459
00:29:26.691 --> 00:29:26.891
Yeah.

460
00:29:27.832 --> 00:29:36.215
The idea being is we know the factory that produces the outcome we're looking for at this molecular level inside of plants.

461
00:29:36.815 --> 00:29:44.498
But because we understand the genes, the needed gene expression to replicate that factory, we have the blueprints.

462
00:29:44.558 --> 00:29:45.098
Yeah, yeah.

463
00:29:45.358 --> 00:29:56.002
So we can just take any yeast cell and give it the instructions to build the small factory, which now removes the need to grow the plant or any of that life cycle process.

464
00:29:56.022 --> 00:29:56.162
Yep.

465
00:29:56.482 --> 00:30:03.306
We literally can just have a single function yeast cell that focuses on producing this outcome, period.

466
00:30:03.387 --> 00:30:04.067
Yeah, exactly.

467
00:30:04.127 --> 00:30:06.268
And then we can just scale up the number of yeast cells.

468
00:30:06.328 --> 00:30:06.549
Yeah.

469
00:30:06.929 --> 00:30:09.310
And it's one step, no life cycle.

470
00:30:09.450 --> 00:30:10.311
You can do it in the lab.

471
00:30:10.731 --> 00:30:16.215
And this is how you get the industrial grade, industrial volume of production.

472
00:30:16.395 --> 00:30:16.815
Exactly.

473
00:30:16.875 --> 00:30:20.938
So it's making this very cheap because all you have to do is grow yeast, which we know how to do.

474
00:30:20.998 --> 00:30:22.278
That's like bread and beer.

475
00:30:22.759 --> 00:30:22.939
Right.

476
00:30:23.239 --> 00:30:31.003
So this synthetic biology approach can completely revolutionize how we grow these class of compounds.

477
00:30:31.584 --> 00:30:31.764
Right.

478
00:30:32.024 --> 00:30:32.924
And it's a whole class.

479
00:30:33.184 --> 00:30:34.485
It's not just that particular one.

480
00:30:35.106 --> 00:30:37.207
This is the first enzyme that we found that does this.

481
00:30:37.427 --> 00:30:37.547
Right.

482
00:30:37.587 --> 00:30:40.489
Now we've got a blueprint on how to even approach this problem.

483
00:30:40.789 --> 00:30:40.949
Right.

484
00:30:40.989 --> 00:30:41.149
Right.

485
00:30:41.429 --> 00:30:42.290
We can scale up.

486
00:30:43.070 --> 00:30:45.572
We can do all sorts of really cool stuff.

487
00:30:45.792 --> 00:30:53.836
So Securinine is the one that's particularly a specific candidate that would help as it relates to leukemia therapy.

488
00:30:53.857 --> 00:30:54.077
Yeah.

489
00:30:54.337 --> 00:30:58.900
But what you're saying is Securinine is only one of the outputs of this mini-factor.

490
00:30:58.920 --> 00:30:59.340
Yeah, yeah.

491
00:30:59.360 --> 00:31:02.362
There's so many alkaloids out there, right, that...

492
00:31:03.364 --> 00:31:05.346
could be using this one-step process.

493
00:31:05.747 --> 00:31:09.892
And a one-step process is just really good because it's just much more manageable.

494
00:31:09.932 --> 00:31:10.733
It's a single factory.

495
00:31:10.753 --> 00:31:11.453
You don't need two.

496
00:31:11.894 --> 00:31:16.539
You don't need the second one to find the intermediary and da-da-da-da-da, you know?

497
00:31:17.480 --> 00:31:19.423
Very, very, very interesting.

498
00:31:19.443 --> 00:31:19.583
Yeah.

499
00:31:19.823 --> 00:31:27.306
So I thought this was a very cool, like, you know, botany doesn't get a lot of love, but this was a very cool one.

500
00:31:27.606 --> 00:31:30.687
All the botanists out there, you're always going to get some love on this channel.

501
00:31:30.807 --> 00:31:31.087
Yeah.

502
00:31:31.207 --> 00:31:34.949
You're always going to get it because that was, and again, there's levels to this, right?

503
00:31:35.269 --> 00:31:43.852
It's not only the observation, it's showing how that observation is functionally happening, the mechanisms by which that process arises.

504
00:31:43.872 --> 00:31:44.032
Mm-hmm.

505
00:31:45.132 --> 00:31:50.713
Then getting with that understanding, now it's let's see how we can apply this to other areas of research.

506
00:31:51.093 --> 00:32:00.555
Again, it feels very much like a platform because you can generate any number of different alkaloids with this factory.

507
00:32:01.535 --> 00:32:02.596
It's funny.

508
00:32:02.616 --> 00:32:08.557
The old town that I'm from in North Carolina, that area used to be called like it's tobacco used to be the big.

509
00:32:09.297 --> 00:32:35.297
agriculture uh so like even in durham they call it a tobacco district they converted these old oh yeah massive tobacco factories into like you know co-working spaces and all this that i will have everybody know that the collapse of the tobacco industry and the rtp was not due yes these many factories we weren't there yet however i mean i'm it's it seems like there is like if nicotine is one of these alkaloids that could come out of this factory yeah

510
00:32:37.276 --> 00:32:41.139
That seems like a place that some people who are trying to line their pockets are going to run to.

511
00:32:41.159 --> 00:32:47.262
I don't know what the economics are around nicotine production, so that might be totally off base.

512
00:32:47.282 --> 00:32:50.144
But there's a million different use cases you can see for this.

513
00:32:50.644 --> 00:32:55.127
A great story number one starting off with botany, which we don't always cover.

514
00:32:55.187 --> 00:32:55.407
No.

515
00:32:55.787 --> 00:32:56.668
But we want to give some love.

516
00:32:57.854 --> 00:33:03.276
We're going to jump into one of the most popular parts of the show, the rundown.

517
00:33:03.916 --> 00:33:11.579
We are not able to cover every breaking science research story week to week because there's just so much science happening globally.

518
00:33:11.959 --> 00:33:19.662
So we take the rundown as an opportunity to give you a little taste of what else is happening in the world of science without going into a deep dive.

519
00:33:20.202 --> 00:33:21.983
But before we get into the rundown...

520
00:33:22.943 --> 00:33:27.166
Just a quick little couple of housekeeping notes, such as, how are you, my friend?

521
00:33:27.586 --> 00:33:28.226
Pretty good.

522
00:33:28.827 --> 00:33:31.728
We had our Super Bowl festivities yesterday.

523
00:33:31.808 --> 00:33:32.149
Yes.

524
00:33:32.749 --> 00:33:37.032
One of the most entertaining Super Bowls in recent memory.

525
00:33:37.232 --> 00:33:38.753
I was riveting, dude.

526
00:33:39.473 --> 00:33:41.154
It was riveting.

527
00:33:41.635 --> 00:33:50.380
As the footballer on the pod, football as in not American football, but the true football, I've only recently learned the rules.

528
00:33:50.400 --> 00:33:50.600
Yes.

529
00:33:50.820 --> 00:33:51.421
Okay, nice.

530
00:33:51.522 --> 00:33:54.326
And so I, you know, I don't know.

531
00:33:54.587 --> 00:33:55.288
It was not great.

532
00:33:55.428 --> 00:33:56.029
It was not great.

533
00:33:56.049 --> 00:33:56.310
Yeah.

534
00:33:56.871 --> 00:33:59.535
There was a lot of not running.

535
00:34:00.357 --> 00:34:02.280
I think that's the technical term.

536
00:34:02.761 --> 00:34:03.462
They did not run.

537
00:34:04.447 --> 00:34:05.528
The sports ball term.

538
00:34:05.828 --> 00:34:08.450
It will be the Super Bowl, if I'm not mistaken.

539
00:34:08.490 --> 00:34:10.652
It sounds like it's going to be in Los Angeles next year.

540
00:34:10.812 --> 00:34:11.973
Oh, nice.

541
00:34:12.293 --> 00:34:18.998
So if anyone at the NFL wants to do a segment on the science of football, we are here in local.

542
00:34:19.178 --> 00:34:21.240
It's a quick, short drive over at SoFi.

543
00:34:21.460 --> 00:34:23.282
Yeah, we could do Deflategate.

544
00:34:23.322 --> 00:34:32.929
We could do a breakdown of Deflategate, which is why Belichick apparently didn't get into the Hall of Fame as a first ballot Hall of Famer, which is a whole thing.

545
00:34:32.949 --> 00:34:33.670
It's a bit much.

546
00:34:34.190 --> 00:34:34.410
It is.

547
00:34:34.550 --> 00:34:38.132
Isn't he like one of the greatest coaches ever?

548
00:34:38.472 --> 00:34:39.893
I mean, he's, it's not.

549
00:34:40.073 --> 00:34:43.094
You could take away everything after Deflategate and he's still top two.

550
00:34:43.214 --> 00:34:43.454
Right.

551
00:34:43.494 --> 00:34:44.855
So it's like, okay, guys, come on.

552
00:34:45.475 --> 00:34:45.776
All right.

553
00:34:45.896 --> 00:34:48.317
Enough of the sports ball and banter.

554
00:34:49.075 --> 00:34:50.876
We will now jump into our rundown.

555
00:34:50.896 --> 00:34:51.937
We have four stories.

556
00:34:52.697 --> 00:35:03.044
We're starting off with our first story, which was in CBS News, about the delay for the Artemis 2 launch due to technical challenges.

557
00:35:04.124 --> 00:35:11.169
It faces delays after a critical test revealed that there were hydrogen leaks pushing the much-anticipated launch back.

558
00:35:11.209 --> 00:35:13.070
So, yeah, what's going on here with this story?

559
00:35:13.430 --> 00:35:14.091
Yeah, yeah.

560
00:35:14.751 --> 00:35:17.392
Basically, hydrogen is really small, right?

561
00:35:17.932 --> 00:35:22.434
The hydrogen atom is the smallest because it's single proton, single neutron.

562
00:35:22.875 --> 00:35:24.515
Sorry, single proton, single electron.

563
00:35:24.935 --> 00:35:28.497
So it's going to leak through when they're trying to pump up the rocket.

564
00:35:29.097 --> 00:35:30.318
Better to catch these things now.

565
00:35:31.018 --> 00:35:40.124
Then later, I always knew there was going to be probably the first the first one is always scrapped because the rocket hasn't really been tested.

566
00:35:40.204 --> 00:35:41.584
So they really need to make sure.

567
00:35:42.045 --> 00:35:44.446
So, you know, Artemis is the SLS.

568
00:35:44.486 --> 00:35:50.910
The space launch system is still sitting on the launch pad waiting for its March debut.

569
00:35:52.611 --> 00:35:53.892
But they're still going to the moon.

570
00:35:54.882 --> 00:35:59.586
I heard that they couldn't get the Hollywood studio prepared for the launch in time.

571
00:35:59.746 --> 00:36:02.508
And so, you know, they had to get Netflix ready.

572
00:36:02.548 --> 00:36:03.068
Rain.

573
00:36:03.148 --> 00:36:05.490
It was raining and they couldn't mimic the rain.

574
00:36:05.550 --> 00:36:06.891
It just wasn't accurate.

575
00:36:06.951 --> 00:36:07.811
Yeah, that's what it was.

576
00:36:07.831 --> 00:36:11.054
And so for those who are listening and not watching my faces.

577
00:36:11.634 --> 00:36:12.695
Full of sarcasm.

578
00:36:13.997 --> 00:36:20.002
But we did mention this in our Artemis deep dive that, you know, it's a launch window, not a launch date.

579
00:36:20.463 --> 00:36:30.313
And we explained why this launch in particular, which was our episode 24, has a lot more complications because unlike the Gemini and Apollo missions where we tested...

580
00:36:30.773 --> 00:36:35.555
different aspects of the workflow across multiple launches.

581
00:36:35.895 --> 00:36:40.657
We're basically trying to condense all of that into a much smaller amount of launches.

582
00:36:41.097 --> 00:36:43.178
And so there's a lot of things that can go wrong there.

583
00:36:43.518 --> 00:36:51.702
So we'll keep an eye out for the actual launch date for Artemis 2, which again is built in Lego, not plural, not Legos.

584
00:36:52.782 --> 00:36:54.864
Lego, which we got in our comments.

585
00:36:54.924 --> 00:37:00.408
Yes, Lego is already plural behind Krishna's left shoulder in all camera views.

586
00:37:00.588 --> 00:37:09.134
If you're watching on social or on the pod, our story number two is about the king of the jungle, which is sometimes debated.

587
00:37:09.154 --> 00:37:19.762
But lions having a second roar that scientists have only just discovered, which could potentially help with conservation efforts.

588
00:37:20.442 --> 00:37:22.463
And so this was a weird story.

589
00:37:23.084 --> 00:37:25.445
What's instrumental about this discovery here in animal behavior?

590
00:37:25.565 --> 00:37:29.027
Yeah, I mean, so everyone is aware of the lion's roar, right?

591
00:37:29.287 --> 00:37:30.368
Lion is the king of the jungle.

592
00:37:30.488 --> 00:37:31.249
It has a roar.

593
00:37:31.369 --> 00:37:33.970
And everyone kind of knows what it sounds like.

594
00:37:34.290 --> 00:37:35.511
Kind of like that, exactly.

595
00:37:36.131 --> 00:37:36.312
And...

596
00:37:37.192 --> 00:37:47.115
Now what they've done is they've taken thousands of hours of recordings of lions, and they've ran that through an AI classifier.

597
00:37:47.635 --> 00:37:52.576
And what the AI has figured out is there's actually two subtypes of roars that lions make.

598
00:37:52.616 --> 00:37:55.317
There's the first one, that's the loud one that everyone knows.

599
00:37:55.717 --> 00:38:02.439
And then there's a second one that is a little bit lower, takes a little bit longer, and,

600
00:38:03.265 --> 00:38:05.168
And is a lot more unique to each lion.

601
00:38:05.608 --> 00:38:17.603
So when we say this can be used for population studies, what you could do is you could have a recording of the jungle, and you can have an AI then go through, and each lion is going to have a different voice profile, right?

602
00:38:18.124 --> 00:38:18.645
And so you can...

603
00:38:19.065 --> 00:38:38.642
identify how many individuals there are in a certain territory where are they going you can identify a line here and then a month later if he like went to the neighboring national park you can say oh wow he like traveled all the way right this um the recordings were taken from tanzania and zimbabwe ah so um a lot of these lines have collars that

604
00:38:39.242 --> 00:38:42.423
they've been fitted to sort of track and they also have little microphones.

605
00:38:42.723 --> 00:38:44.224
And so that's where the data set comes from.

606
00:38:44.724 --> 00:38:45.544
I think it could be huge.

607
00:38:45.865 --> 00:38:53.748
One thing that I learned when I was reading about this story is that, you know, the MGM roar, the Metro Goodwin mayor.

608
00:38:53.768 --> 00:38:53.848
Yes.

609
00:38:53.948 --> 00:38:54.128
Yes.

610
00:38:55.040 --> 00:39:21.692
lion's roar that comes in the beginning of all these different films now owned by amazon yes that's actually now that's actually a tiger roaring yes it's not even a lion for those who don't know the best roar of the big cats 100 is the tiger 100 yeah the line is not that great and so they used a tiger but they put a lion there it's like it's like dubbing it's it's very low a lion's roar is a kind of low energy jeb

611
00:39:22.172 --> 00:39:24.054
They're a little apathetic.

612
00:39:24.154 --> 00:39:24.614
Exactly.

613
00:39:25.575 --> 00:39:32.320
Tiger, again, the mascot of the greatest university institution on the planet.

614
00:39:32.340 --> 00:39:32.780
That's right.

615
00:39:32.940 --> 00:39:33.841
It's chosen for a reason.

616
00:39:33.981 --> 00:39:34.962
Yeah.

617
00:39:35.262 --> 00:39:36.803
Also, a great Zim shout out.

618
00:39:36.843 --> 00:39:37.284
Well done.

619
00:39:37.384 --> 00:39:38.124
Yeah.

620
00:39:38.164 --> 00:39:41.467
It's not always that we can get to plug my...

621
00:39:42.968 --> 00:39:44.669
My motherland in the story.

622
00:39:44.689 --> 00:39:45.610
That's a good one.

623
00:39:45.630 --> 00:39:46.711
I thought that was a cool one.

624
00:39:46.811 --> 00:39:50.753
And the research comes out of the University of Exeter and the University of Oxford.

625
00:39:51.234 --> 00:39:53.735
And it's currently out in Ecology and Evolution, the journal.

626
00:39:54.196 --> 00:39:55.256
Fantastic.

627
00:39:56.057 --> 00:40:06.163
We're going to move to our third breakdown story related to NASA's Juno mission reveals that Jupiter is much smaller than we previously thought.

628
00:40:06.183 --> 00:40:06.784
What's going on here?

629
00:40:07.344 --> 00:40:11.187
Yeah, this one was weird because I was like, how do you get the size of a planet wrong?

630
00:40:11.207 --> 00:40:11.507
Yeah.

631
00:40:12.130 --> 00:40:13.171
Especially one that's very large.

632
00:40:13.551 --> 00:40:14.612
It's like quite big.

633
00:40:14.872 --> 00:40:16.333
Like, how do you do that, right?

634
00:40:16.554 --> 00:40:19.776
And then it's actually an interesting question.

635
00:40:19.816 --> 00:40:21.277
How do you measure the size of a planet?

636
00:40:21.537 --> 00:40:21.758
Yes.

637
00:40:21.938 --> 00:40:22.158
Right?

638
00:40:23.399 --> 00:40:29.063
So the way that they measured it before was when Voyager 1 and 2 and Pioneer 10 and 11 went to Jupiter.

639
00:40:29.083 --> 00:40:29.744
Right.

640
00:40:30.054 --> 00:40:35.978
What you can do is you can beam... You're beaming data to JPL at all times.

641
00:40:36.038 --> 00:40:39.140
The NASA Deep Space Network, which currently is at JPL.

642
00:40:39.180 --> 00:40:40.461
I don't know where it was back then.

643
00:40:40.841 --> 00:40:44.063
I shouldn't say that they were beaming to JPL, but now they do.

644
00:40:44.123 --> 00:40:45.684
So you're beaming data to JPL.

645
00:40:46.125 --> 00:40:48.626
At some point, you're going to go behind the planet.

646
00:40:49.207 --> 00:40:50.107
So you're going to get blocked.

647
00:40:50.628 --> 00:40:54.290
And then at another point, you're going to get back.

648
00:40:54.490 --> 00:40:55.291
You're going to start beaming.

649
00:40:55.651 --> 00:40:56.952
That occlusion...

650
00:40:58.067 --> 00:41:01.493
tells you how big Jupiter is, the slice of Jupiter at the time, right?

651
00:41:01.813 --> 00:41:06.962
Now with Voyager 1 and 2 and Pioneer 10 and 11, you only really have six data points, right?

652
00:41:06.982 --> 00:41:07.563
Because it's like...

653
00:41:08.597 --> 00:41:16.039
You go behind, you go, so there's but one, two for each, and then there's like, you know, only four, so eight, sorry, eight data points, right?

654
00:41:16.239 --> 00:41:17.319
Because you're only going once.

655
00:41:17.639 --> 00:41:19.460
They didn't revolve around Jupiter.

656
00:41:19.760 --> 00:41:23.541
They just like visited and then they were on their way to the other planets.

657
00:41:23.581 --> 00:41:26.361
Juno has been going around Jupiter for quite a while, right?

658
00:41:26.781 --> 00:41:30.222
So we get more measurements, which means that our error bar can get smaller.

659
00:41:30.582 --> 00:41:33.003
Now our error bar is less than half a kilometer.

660
00:41:33.023 --> 00:41:33.363
Right.

661
00:41:33.575 --> 00:41:33.775
Okay.

662
00:41:34.256 --> 00:41:34.976
Which is quite good.

663
00:41:34.996 --> 00:41:35.937
It's quite nice.

664
00:41:36.617 --> 00:41:39.820
And since it arrived in 2016, it's collected a lot more data.

665
00:41:40.640 --> 00:41:40.881
Okay?

666
00:41:41.601 --> 00:41:56.833
What these guys did was with that additional data, what you can do is now actually calculate the size of Jupiter, not only, you know, at the equator, but also at the poles, because it's sort of traversing latitude on Jupiter as well as it moves around.

667
00:41:58.354 --> 00:42:00.475
What ends up happening is you send radio waves...

668
00:42:01.388 --> 00:42:05.432
Now, imagine when there's no Jupiter between you, the radio wave just goes through fine.

669
00:42:06.133 --> 00:42:16.704
As you start approaching the disk of the gas giant, the radio waves are going to go through the top parts of the atmosphere, which have a bunch of ions, the ionosphere that we also have on Earth.

670
00:42:17.666 --> 00:42:22.287
And those ions are going to start changing the frequency of the radio waves.

671
00:42:22.948 --> 00:42:25.468
And it's also going to start bending the radio waves, right?

672
00:42:25.488 --> 00:42:26.689
But just because of refraction.

673
00:42:27.369 --> 00:42:28.970
And so you're going to get that data too.

674
00:42:29.050 --> 00:42:30.190
The frequency is going to change.

675
00:42:31.030 --> 00:42:33.851
And then at some point it's going to get completely cut off.

676
00:42:34.031 --> 00:42:34.231
Right.

677
00:42:34.471 --> 00:42:34.651
Right.

678
00:42:35.052 --> 00:42:37.052
And you're doing it at multiple latitudes.

679
00:42:37.412 --> 00:42:42.814
What ends up happening is, so we found out that the poles are 12 kilometers smaller than

680
00:42:42.894 --> 00:42:43.875
than previous measurements.

681
00:42:43.975 --> 00:42:44.275
Okay.

682
00:42:44.576 --> 00:42:48.640
And the equator is only a little bit smaller by 2.5 miles.

683
00:42:48.940 --> 00:42:50.942
So it's flatter and the whole thing is smaller.

684
00:42:51.042 --> 00:42:51.342
Okay.

685
00:42:51.582 --> 00:42:52.363
And that's what we found.

686
00:42:52.764 --> 00:43:06.557
This is important because if we want to make models of Jupiter, like the weather on Jupiter, what kind of weather phenomenon we'd see, the climate on Jupiter, things like that, even a number this small is quite small.

687
00:43:07.068 --> 00:43:07.648
A big deal.

688
00:43:07.688 --> 00:43:09.629
Significant for any derivative calculations.

689
00:43:09.869 --> 00:43:10.430
Yeah.

690
00:43:10.710 --> 00:43:12.230
Or simulation creation.

691
00:43:12.250 --> 00:43:12.471
Yeah.

692
00:43:13.371 --> 00:43:14.151
Oh, that was cool.

693
00:43:14.191 --> 00:43:14.672
Very cool.

694
00:43:14.692 --> 00:43:16.752
That one's out of NASA.

695
00:43:17.033 --> 00:43:17.313
Yes.

696
00:43:17.553 --> 00:43:21.775
Jupiter, smaller, flatter, but still very big.

697
00:43:22.035 --> 00:43:22.275
Yes.

698
00:43:22.735 --> 00:43:23.415
Very, very big.

699
00:43:23.516 --> 00:43:24.496
Yeah, very, very big.

700
00:43:24.536 --> 00:43:25.797
And it was a nature astronomy.

701
00:43:26.417 --> 00:43:34.140
So our last story is about physicists getting a peek at how matter is born from nothing.

702
00:43:34.841 --> 00:43:35.081
Yes.

703
00:43:36.296 --> 00:43:36.617
Okay.

704
00:43:36.817 --> 00:43:37.658
Out of the vacuum.

705
00:43:37.878 --> 00:43:39.901
I'm going to need an explanation for this one.

706
00:43:40.522 --> 00:43:41.664
Out of the quantum vacuum.

707
00:43:41.724 --> 00:43:41.924
Right.

708
00:43:42.025 --> 00:43:42.305
Okay.

709
00:43:42.345 --> 00:43:42.626
So...

710
00:43:43.721 --> 00:43:51.244
We really want to understand how particles like protons and neutrons get created, especially in the very, very early universe.

711
00:43:51.504 --> 00:43:56.726
Right after the Big Bang, this mechanism of creation of these particles called hadrons.

712
00:43:57.066 --> 00:44:02.709
Hadrons are, you know, this collection of quarks.

713
00:44:02.769 --> 00:44:08.551
Quarks are the fundamental atomic particles of the nucleus, not protons, but what's inside the protons.

714
00:44:10.212 --> 00:44:12.373
And it's a little unclear how that forms.

715
00:44:12.693 --> 00:44:12.953
Okay?

716
00:44:13.473 --> 00:44:16.234
There was something called a quark-gluon plasma.

717
00:44:16.994 --> 00:44:18.194
Quarks are the particles.

718
00:44:18.854 --> 00:44:22.415
Gluons are the force carriers of the strong nuclear force.

719
00:44:22.455 --> 00:44:24.516
That's the thing that binds a nucleus together.

720
00:44:24.736 --> 00:44:27.597
Because if you think about it, the nucleus is a bunch of positive charge, right?

721
00:44:27.917 --> 00:44:30.257
Protons on top of protons on top of protons.

722
00:44:30.637 --> 00:44:32.538
All that positive charge wants to get away from it.

723
00:44:33.766 --> 00:44:37.929
the other positive charges, because electromagnetism wants it to leave.

724
00:44:38.329 --> 00:44:44.853
But what keeps them together is the strong nuclear force, which overpowers the electromagnetic force.

725
00:44:45.413 --> 00:44:51.077
The strong nuclear force is very, very weird, because if you think about gravity and electromagnetism,

726
00:44:53.313 --> 00:44:56.154
the farther you get, the weaker the force.

727
00:44:56.814 --> 00:45:02.176
The strong nuclear force up to a certain length scale, the farther you get, the stronger the force.

728
00:45:02.396 --> 00:45:03.096
It's very weird.

729
00:45:03.396 --> 00:45:09.458
It leads to something called quark confinement, which is this idea that if I have two quarks that are right next to each other,

730
00:45:10.601 --> 00:45:14.203
and I start spreading them apart, the force between them is going to get bigger.

731
00:45:14.223 --> 00:45:14.963
What does that really mean?

732
00:45:14.983 --> 00:45:18.185
That means the energy density in between them is going to get really big.

733
00:45:18.505 --> 00:45:22.988
At some point, the energy density is going to be enough where two quarks pop out of existence.

734
00:45:23.348 --> 00:45:23.508
Mm-hmm.

735
00:45:24.192 --> 00:45:27.673
out of just the gluon energy that's there, right?

736
00:45:27.993 --> 00:45:30.474
And so you're never going to see quarks on their own.

737
00:45:31.054 --> 00:45:37.656
So it's been really hard to study how protons form because you never see the individual constituents on their own.

738
00:45:37.676 --> 00:45:38.776
Does that make sense?

739
00:45:38.796 --> 00:45:39.317
Yes, yes.

740
00:45:39.337 --> 00:45:39.537
Okay.

741
00:45:40.077 --> 00:45:43.738
This new paper is about a technique that lets us study that

742
00:45:44.635 --> 00:46:10.416
formation process without really relying on trying to see a single quark on its own okay okay this is from the star collaboration at the brookhaven national lab they have something called a relativistic heavy ion collider this is the largest particle collider that we have in um the u.s although you know people at fermilab might disagree with that depends on what you're trying to talk if you're from fermilab and you want to complain about that factoid please put in the comments yeah

743
00:46:10.696 --> 00:46:11.076
Go ahead.

744
00:46:11.437 --> 00:46:18.483
And so what happens is in this relativistic heavy ion collider, there's a ton of energy, right?

745
00:46:19.103 --> 00:46:28.391
And sometimes what you get is a strange and an anti-strange quark that pops out of the vacuum just from vacuum fluctuations.

746
00:46:28.832 --> 00:46:35.938
Now, vacuum fluctuations meaning the quantum vacuum is the lowest energy state, but because of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle...

747
00:46:36.815 --> 00:46:40.220
that lowest energy state is still going to have a tiny bit of jiggle, right?

748
00:46:40.260 --> 00:46:43.824
And that jiggle means there's really particles popping in and out of existence.

749
00:46:43.864 --> 00:46:48.290
Sometimes you get a strange and an anti-strange particle that pop in and out of existence.

750
00:46:48.731 --> 00:46:53.717
That could borrow energy from this high collision that we're getting inside this collider.

751
00:46:54.218 --> 00:46:54.338
And,

752
00:46:54.999 --> 00:47:01.961
When it borrows energy, it turns into a cousin of the proton called the lambda hyperon.

753
00:47:02.502 --> 00:47:03.782
So it's still three quarks.

754
00:47:04.002 --> 00:47:07.783
The proton is up, up, down, and the neutron is up, down, down.

755
00:47:08.143 --> 00:47:10.504
Those are the three quarks that make up the proton and the neutron.

756
00:47:10.884 --> 00:47:14.005
Here, you've got a strange up, down, or a strange up, up.

757
00:47:14.686 --> 00:47:15.986
That's this lambda hyperon.

758
00:47:16.006 --> 00:47:17.727
So it's like a cousin of the proton.

759
00:47:18.127 --> 00:47:18.647
You're going to get...

760
00:47:19.607 --> 00:47:24.594
the lambda particle and the anti-lambda particle, because you always have to conserve charge and all this other stuff.

761
00:47:24.994 --> 00:47:28.819
But the spins of these guys are going to be correlated because the strange...

762
00:47:29.907 --> 00:47:33.509
the strange quarks that came out of the vacuum have correlated spins, right?

763
00:47:34.390 --> 00:47:41.794
And what they could do is measure the spin correlations of these particles, okay?

764
00:47:42.355 --> 00:47:44.816
When you do that, that's something I can actually measure, right?

765
00:47:44.896 --> 00:47:58.545
I can wait for these lambda particles to decay into different products, measure the angular momentum of all these different products, figure out what the original spin was, and then I could see if these two are correlated because they formed at the same time, things like that.

766
00:47:58.565 --> 00:47:58.705
Mm-hmm.

767
00:48:00.755 --> 00:48:10.119
What's cool is this gives a way to think about how hadrons form without having to worry about trying to observe individual quarks.

768
00:48:10.619 --> 00:48:17.601
Now we can actually peer into this process of how does that three constituent particle form from a thing out of the vacuum?

769
00:48:18.202 --> 00:48:19.582
How does that spin correlate?

770
00:48:19.862 --> 00:48:22.123
If they're closer together, there's higher correlation.

771
00:48:22.183 --> 00:48:24.464
If they're farther apart, there's less correlation.

772
00:48:25.124 --> 00:48:34.649
And, you know, it's kind of cool because the relativistic heavy ion collider is retiring now, and it's going to become part of something much bigger called the electron ion collider.

773
00:48:34.709 --> 00:48:35.690
It's part of the DOE.

774
00:48:35.770 --> 00:48:41.273
What they're doing is building with the existing infrastructure at Brookhaven, this larger collider now.

775
00:48:41.513 --> 00:48:43.454
So this is one of the last things that it did.

776
00:48:43.814 --> 00:48:45.315
But it's very fundamental.

777
00:48:45.715 --> 00:48:48.197
It was in Nature out of the Star collaboration.

778
00:48:48.677 --> 00:48:52.059
It's kind of, you know, the swan song of...

779
00:48:53.188 --> 00:49:10.298
that collider and it's it's quite fundamental it's people are very excited just a quick point of order for those who don't know the doe is the department of energy uh they are the federal agency which is in charge of all of our nuclear weapons for example and anything that has a nexus

780
00:49:11.038 --> 00:49:17.464
to atomic or nuclear energy weapons and fundamental research in those categories.

781
00:49:18.045 --> 00:49:25.992
And what's interesting about this, it sort of sounds like we basically have found, it's this whole tracing mechanism, similarly to our past story.

782
00:49:26.012 --> 00:49:31.477
It's like we found a way to look at the derivative products or outcomes and then reverse engineer

783
00:49:32.618 --> 00:49:43.689
With math, where they came from, which allows us to not have to worry about the ability to observe because we have enough data to get to the original state.

784
00:49:43.889 --> 00:49:44.250
Exactly.

785
00:49:44.270 --> 00:49:45.271
There was derivative observations.

786
00:49:45.311 --> 00:49:45.751
Yeah, yeah.

787
00:49:45.811 --> 00:49:48.134
And this is a common technique in particle physics.

788
00:49:48.174 --> 00:49:52.558
Like when we found the Higgs boson, for example, at CERN, right?

789
00:49:53.139 --> 00:49:55.901
Again, it's always these decay products that you want to catch.

790
00:49:55.921 --> 00:49:56.082
Right.

791
00:49:56.582 --> 00:50:01.704
And then from that, reconstitute what the Higgs was, what is the mass of the Higgs, so on and so forth.

792
00:50:01.924 --> 00:50:10.808
So this is doing it, but now it's actually looking at spin, looking at the angular momentum of these tiny little objects and trying to make it happen, right?

793
00:50:10.828 --> 00:50:13.309
They're trying to trace back what's happening with the quantum vacuum.

794
00:50:14.883 --> 00:50:16.084
You know why I love this story?

795
00:50:16.104 --> 00:50:16.524
Of course.

796
00:50:17.085 --> 00:50:25.550
Because if we're talking about the quantum vacuum or vacuum energy, obviously we have to talk about zero point energy.

797
00:50:25.790 --> 00:50:26.111
Yeah.

798
00:50:26.231 --> 00:50:27.932
And that's how the aliens are getting here, guys.

799
00:50:28.032 --> 00:50:28.472
Exactly.

800
00:50:28.492 --> 00:50:33.636
It's obviously they figured out how to manifest and utilize vacuum energy to...

801
00:50:34.469 --> 00:50:37.010
In a very similar way to maybe how we're describing.

802
00:50:37.030 --> 00:50:37.510
Yeah, dude.

803
00:50:37.970 --> 00:50:38.670
Not proven.

804
00:50:38.750 --> 00:50:44.912
I'm sort of just putting it out there, getting it into your minds, letting it ruminate a little bit.

805
00:50:45.633 --> 00:50:50.074
Maybe we'll have a future research story that actually points to it, but we're not quite there yet.

806
00:50:50.694 --> 00:51:02.538
But speaking of the quantum, we're going to end the rundown here, and we are going to go into our story number two, which is a quantum sensing story.

807
00:51:04.867 --> 00:51:14.233
The question here or the idea here is we have this new multi-parameter estimation with an array of entangled atomic sensors.

808
00:51:14.653 --> 00:51:23.740
This was published in Science in January from the University of Basel as well as Sorbonne in France, the Laboratory Castel-Brosel.

809
00:51:24.700 --> 00:51:49.018
um and the some one of us can kind of pronounce french stuff um and the idea here is how can quantum entanglement revolutionize uh measurement precision yeah and that appears to be what we have going on here yes um measurement precision is very big in physics physicists love to measure things extremely precisely okay okay

810
00:51:49.879 --> 00:51:54.326
Now classical measurement is limited by something called the standard quantum limit.

811
00:51:54.626 --> 00:52:03.499
Okay, the idea is the quantum world is discrete, which means for example if I want to measure photons that are coming into my photo detector,

812
00:52:04.555 --> 00:52:11.160
there's going to be fluctuating power on that photodetector because photons are going to be arriving one by one.

813
00:52:11.520 --> 00:52:13.502
This is the idea of shot noise, okay?

814
00:52:14.122 --> 00:52:28.373
And because the quantum world is what it is, it's quantum, there's all this discrete stuff, you're going to get an error based on whatever measurement because of the discreteness of the world that you are measuring, okay?

815
00:52:28.753 --> 00:52:33.637
And that error goes like 1 over the square root of n, where n is the number of particles that you've sort of

816
00:52:35.807 --> 00:52:36.868
observed, okay?

817
00:52:37.608 --> 00:52:39.810
We want to go even beyond that, right?

818
00:52:40.671 --> 00:52:49.017
Because the fundamental limit when it comes to actually recording something is really the Heidelberg uncertainty limit, right?

819
00:52:49.538 --> 00:52:59.105
And what this particular paper is doing is what they've done is successfully split a cloud of atoms that they've made into a Bose-Einstein condensate.

820
00:52:59.486 --> 00:53:00.887
They've split it into three atoms.

821
00:53:01.855 --> 00:53:11.623
And what they're doing is using the entanglement between those clouds of atoms to then up their game on how sensitive they can measure something.

822
00:53:12.404 --> 00:53:14.125
They can do it with multiple parameters.

823
00:53:14.546 --> 00:53:17.568
So you can measure something here on the left.

824
00:53:17.588 --> 00:53:19.810
You can measure another thing on the right, so on and so forth.

825
00:53:20.370 --> 00:53:22.032
And you can do it across space.

826
00:53:23.101 --> 00:53:30.423
And they're very clever about how they're able to use this entanglement to then get beyond that standard quantum limit.

827
00:53:30.743 --> 00:53:35.244
They're starting to probe the real limit, which is the Heisenberg uncertainty principle.

828
00:53:35.264 --> 00:53:36.004
Right.

829
00:53:36.664 --> 00:53:48.987
I will just note, as someone who comes from the software world, SQL, meaning standard quantum limit, is a little bit, maybe I've done a different naming convention there because SQL is a popular database.

830
00:53:49.267 --> 00:53:49.667
Oh, really?

831
00:53:49.847 --> 00:53:50.547
Oh, yeah, SQL.

832
00:53:50.587 --> 00:53:51.548
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

833
00:53:51.588 --> 00:53:52.928
So it's... For sure.

834
00:53:53.469 --> 00:53:55.231
I don't think physicists care, though.

835
00:53:55.451 --> 00:53:56.232
Zero percent.

836
00:53:56.672 --> 00:53:57.153
Zero percent.

837
00:53:57.173 --> 00:53:59.235
I'm sure they use SQL all the time.

838
00:53:59.275 --> 00:54:00.897
I mean, I use it all the time in my work.

839
00:54:00.957 --> 00:54:05.663
But yeah, for us, at least for the AMO guys, SQL means standard quantum limit.

840
00:54:05.743 --> 00:54:08.366
It's OK. We can always learn multiple acronyms.

841
00:54:08.426 --> 00:54:09.548
Yeah.

842
00:54:09.688 --> 00:54:10.609
Context switching, right?

843
00:54:10.869 --> 00:54:11.470
Exactly.

844
00:54:11.830 --> 00:54:14.813
So let's get into uncertainty and information, right?

845
00:54:15.493 --> 00:54:22.319
When it comes to the real limit, it is the uncertainty principle that's been guided by Werner Heisenberg in 1927.

846
00:54:22.359 --> 00:54:23.840
He came out with the uncertainty principle.

847
00:54:24.721 --> 00:54:27.623
And people have been chasing this limit ever since.

848
00:54:28.043 --> 00:54:29.605
This is the limit of the universe.

849
00:54:30.165 --> 00:54:36.288
You can't go beyond this just because of the nature of quantum mechanics and the nature of our reality, right?

850
00:54:36.808 --> 00:54:47.793
The classical limit is the standard quantum limit, 1 over square root of n. You've got shot noise because there's uncertainty on how much you can measure based on discrete amount of stuff coming in.

851
00:54:48.493 --> 00:54:49.474
Now, here's the deal, though.

852
00:54:50.754 --> 00:54:52.015
The Heisenberg uncertainty limit...

853
00:54:53.384 --> 00:54:59.708
is a limit on the product of two observables, the product of the noise on two observables.

854
00:54:59.768 --> 00:55:03.810
For example, the standard one that you think about is momentum and position, right?

855
00:55:04.371 --> 00:55:14.857
If I know my position really well, then I don't know my momentum that well, and so on and so forth, because the product of these two numbers, if one number is small, the other has to be big, such that the product remains about the same.

856
00:55:15.978 --> 00:55:16.198
But...

857
00:55:17.030 --> 00:55:19.151
what you could do is exactly what I said.

858
00:55:19.731 --> 00:55:25.893
If I really want to know my position very, very well, I could not care about my momentum.

859
00:55:26.854 --> 00:55:32.076
I could squeeze my observation such that my delta on...

860
00:55:33.176 --> 00:55:38.041
one axis is very big, and my delta on another axis is really small.

861
00:55:38.441 --> 00:55:53.094
So instead of a circle where the error in my, let's say, x and y, these are two different observables, is the same, my error on x could be really small, that could be my position, and my error on the y-axis, which is my momentum, could be very big, because maybe I don't care.

862
00:55:53.774 --> 00:55:56.116
Maybe I don't care to actually measure that.

863
00:55:56.697 --> 00:56:00.260
And when I do this with this quantum metrology,

864
00:56:01.442 --> 00:56:07.152
I could get 100 times better than my standard quantum limit and still stay above the Heisenberg uncertainty limit.

865
00:56:07.332 --> 00:56:07.593
Okay.

866
00:56:07.994 --> 00:56:08.234
Okay?

867
00:56:08.895 --> 00:56:10.538
These are called squeezed states.

868
00:56:11.560 --> 00:56:11.800
Okay?

869
00:56:12.121 --> 00:56:14.405
Because you're squeezing in one direction and you're like...

870
00:56:15.421 --> 00:56:18.606
stretching in the other direction and squeezing in the direction that you care about.

871
00:56:18.886 --> 00:56:19.267
Right.

872
00:56:19.287 --> 00:56:26.216
We're basically saying we want to increase the level of precision in one of these two observed states or dimensions.

873
00:56:27.078 --> 00:56:27.258
Yeah.

874
00:56:28.099 --> 00:56:31.304
And I'm trying to understand why.

875
00:56:31.524 --> 00:56:31.664
Yeah.

876
00:56:31.884 --> 00:56:32.105
Yeah.

877
00:56:32.565 --> 00:56:33.225
But we'll get there.

878
00:56:33.286 --> 00:56:44.792
But the first idea is instead of having an even distribution on error across both observed states, we're trying to maximize precision on one while giving up precision on the other.

879
00:56:44.952 --> 00:56:45.192
Yes.

880
00:56:45.752 --> 00:56:48.554
And to think about, like, why would you want to do this?

881
00:56:48.854 --> 00:56:52.256
Let's go back to let's go into like an example like LIGO.

882
00:56:52.736 --> 00:56:54.956
the gravitational wave observatory, right?

883
00:56:55.376 --> 00:57:00.757
Where we want to measure the position of our spin, of our mirrors really well, right?

884
00:57:00.977 --> 00:57:05.918
So I want to measure how far apart one leg is versus another, right?

885
00:57:05.938 --> 00:57:07.078
I want to do that.

886
00:57:07.138 --> 00:57:18.340
Now, the way I do that is through interferometry, where what I'm really trying to measure is the amplitude of the light that's coming when it goes from on one arm versus the other arm, and it comes back, it interferes.

887
00:57:18.780 --> 00:57:21.701
If both the arms are exactly the same length,

888
00:57:22.401 --> 00:57:25.545
then the light is going to cancel and I'm going to get zero brightness.

889
00:57:26.185 --> 00:57:33.334
But if there's a slight offset, then I'm going to get a tiny amount of brightness in my detector because the light is not exactly canceling out.

890
00:57:33.974 --> 00:57:36.297
The only thing I care about is the amplitude.

891
00:57:36.577 --> 00:57:36.778
Right.

892
00:57:37.158 --> 00:57:37.358
Right?

893
00:57:37.438 --> 00:57:37.639
Yes.

894
00:57:38.119 --> 00:57:38.299
Yes.

895
00:57:38.319 --> 00:57:38.399
Yes.

896
00:57:39.425 --> 00:57:46.110
And I couldn't care about, let's say, the frequency of the light, because I know that the laser is my frequency.

897
00:57:46.171 --> 00:57:46.391
Right.

898
00:57:46.811 --> 00:57:47.031
Right?

899
00:57:47.171 --> 00:57:47.351
Right.

900
00:57:47.452 --> 00:57:51.675
So this is just like something that I'm sort of doing a back of the envelope here.

901
00:57:51.715 --> 00:57:52.816
Obviously, there's other things.

902
00:57:53.256 --> 00:57:54.657
But that's the idea.

903
00:57:54.797 --> 00:57:54.957
Yes.

904
00:57:54.977 --> 00:57:56.178
What if you only care about one thing?

905
00:57:56.258 --> 00:57:58.860
In LIGO, the only thing I care about is the amplitude of the light.

906
00:57:59.181 --> 00:57:59.341
Yep.

907
00:57:59.501 --> 00:57:59.701
Right?

908
00:57:59.801 --> 00:57:59.961
Yes.

909
00:58:00.161 --> 00:58:04.985
Because then I can make this kind of gravitational wave drawing.

910
00:58:05.065 --> 00:58:05.546
That makes sense.

911
00:58:05.846 --> 00:58:06.106
Okay?

912
00:58:06.226 --> 00:58:06.406
Yes.

913
00:58:06.787 --> 00:58:07.027
So...

914
00:58:08.522 --> 00:58:13.003
The challenge is there's incompatibility between different observations.

915
00:58:13.043 --> 00:58:17.844
For example, what I was saying with the position and momentum, Heisenberg says you can't measure both at the same time.

916
00:58:18.405 --> 00:58:22.786
And the other thing is, what if I want to measure at two different spots in space?

917
00:58:23.366 --> 00:58:23.626
Okay.

918
00:58:24.226 --> 00:58:30.748
That is what, so what ends up happening is you've got like two different spots in space.

919
00:58:31.548 --> 00:58:33.929
What you can do is instead use entanglement.

920
00:58:34.469 --> 00:58:35.209
This is your,

921
00:58:36.565 --> 00:58:39.607
quantum action at a distance, spooky action at a distance, right?

922
00:58:40.007 --> 00:58:43.610
This won the Nobel Prize a few years back in physics.

923
00:58:44.210 --> 00:58:48.593
We always use Alice and Bob for these experiments.

924
00:58:48.673 --> 00:58:49.193
I don't know why.

925
00:58:49.213 --> 00:58:55.857
There's even a quantum company called Alice and Bob because that is what we use to show entanglement and teach entanglement.

926
00:58:56.318 --> 00:58:57.698
You get a pair of particles.

927
00:58:58.059 --> 00:58:59.460
You send one particle to Alice.

928
00:58:59.860 --> 00:59:01.261
You send the other particle to Bob.

929
00:59:02.288 --> 00:59:11.910
And then you ask one of them to measure their particle, and that's immediately going to affect, in some sense, the measurement that Alice has, okay?

930
00:59:12.270 --> 00:59:22.913
Because these two particles, because they're entangled, they're connected to each other across space and time through some weird mechanism that's, like, kind of faster than speed of light, but, like, not really, but there's nuances.

931
00:59:23.293 --> 00:59:27.834
But what ends up happening is if I measure the spin of here, that's going to affect the spin here.

932
00:59:27.894 --> 00:59:29.114
At least that's what it looks like.

933
00:59:29.494 --> 00:59:31.995
The two are correlated even across these distances.

934
00:59:32.455 --> 00:59:34.357
Okay.

935
00:59:34.377 --> 00:59:45.128
And what these guys figured is, well, actually what we could do is maybe use this to then up our game in terms of measuring different things at different locations.

936
00:59:45.849 --> 00:59:46.109
Okay.

937
00:59:47.410 --> 00:59:48.371
They use something.

938
00:59:48.611 --> 00:59:49.312
You see what I'm saying?

939
00:59:49.432 --> 00:59:49.592
Yeah.

940
00:59:49.873 --> 00:59:50.153
Like, yeah,

941
00:59:51.293 --> 00:59:51.953
We'll get into it.

942
00:59:52.393 --> 00:59:55.374
The first Bose-Einstein condensate, that's what they used.

943
00:59:55.714 --> 00:59:58.375
The first Bose-Einstein condensate was in the late 1990s.

944
00:59:58.475 --> 01:00:00.135
In Boulder, they made it.

945
01:00:00.795 --> 01:00:04.656
This is kind of sometimes colloquially called the fifth state of matter.

946
01:00:05.056 --> 01:00:14.859
What you end up doing is cooling atoms down to just above absolute zero, such that all of these individual atoms behave like a single entity.

947
01:00:15.019 --> 01:00:17.679
They behave like a single quantum wave packet.

948
01:00:17.819 --> 01:00:17.999
Yes.

949
01:00:18.219 --> 01:00:18.459
Okay?

950
01:00:18.980 --> 01:00:20.680
They're just riding on top of each other.

951
01:00:22.405 --> 01:00:49.406
What these guys did, Lee and others, in 2026, in this particular paper, is they created a Bose-Einstein condensate, and then they spatially split that macroscopic entangled state and made a bunch of different atomic sensors that were entangled with each other, made an array, and then they could estimate whatever thing they were trying to estimate across these different things while still maintaining entanglement.

952
01:00:51.892 --> 01:01:03.383
You guys, you guys, this is, I just, I cannot get over how creative some people are.

953
01:01:04.392 --> 01:01:24.853
in at the edges of our understanding and being so clever because I can already, I can already see where this is going, but let me, let's continue because I'm curious about a couple of details, but I think you're going to get to them around, around how, because ultimately what we're trying to be able to do is not only before we talk about increasing precision in one dimension, but,

954
01:01:25.934 --> 01:01:31.376
Because of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, we can't know two observable states with high precision.

955
01:01:31.776 --> 01:01:34.877
And this has sort of been the boogeyman that everyone's been trying to work around.

956
01:01:35.397 --> 01:01:43.680
And this appears to be a very clever way to hijack the limitations using quantum intelligence.

957
01:01:43.700 --> 01:01:46.460
Yes, and that multiple parameter is what's interesting, right?

958
01:01:46.480 --> 01:01:46.681
Right.

959
01:01:46.721 --> 01:01:51.242
Because what you could do is say, hey, what if I just measure the position over here with the momentum over here?

960
01:01:51.302 --> 01:01:52.242
Yeah, exactly.

961
01:01:52.262 --> 01:01:54.083
Because those two... You never said...

962
01:01:55.882 --> 01:01:56.983
You know what I mean?

963
01:01:57.003 --> 01:01:57.684
Yes.

964
01:01:57.884 --> 01:01:58.784
That's what's happening.

965
01:01:58.824 --> 01:01:59.765
Yes.

966
01:01:59.865 --> 01:02:00.126
Okay.

967
01:02:00.266 --> 01:02:00.526
Got it.

968
01:02:00.726 --> 01:02:01.287
Okay.

969
01:02:01.387 --> 01:02:02.187
So how did they do it?

970
01:02:02.307 --> 01:02:04.189
They've got this thing called the atomic chip.

971
01:02:04.609 --> 01:02:10.274
It's microfabricated gold wires that create these very steep magnetic field gradients.

972
01:02:10.494 --> 01:02:10.734
Okay.

973
01:02:10.754 --> 01:02:10.955
Okay.

974
01:02:11.715 --> 01:02:20.081
And with those very steep magnetic field gradients, you can trap rubidium-87 atoms, and you can use those rubidium atoms as a two-state qubit system.

975
01:02:20.101 --> 01:02:30.988
Because the outer electron of that rubidium atom, the spin of that could be either with the nucleus or opposite the nucleus, the same way we talk about the hydrogen hypersplitting.

976
01:02:31.348 --> 01:02:34.170
This is the rubidium hyperfine ground state.

977
01:02:34.751 --> 01:02:36.012
And that's a two-level system.

978
01:02:36.032 --> 01:02:36.592
Yeah.

979
01:02:36.632 --> 01:02:47.343
You can tightly confine that thing, and you can have the atom transfer between, you know, either the electron spinning this way or spinning this way by sending in a radio frequency pulse.

980
01:02:47.803 --> 01:02:49.004
This is our zero or one.

981
01:02:49.365 --> 01:02:51.547
Yeah, so you've got a kind of qubit here, right?

982
01:02:51.947 --> 01:02:56.392
And you can tightly confine this cloud of atoms near that chip surface.

983
01:02:56.412 --> 01:02:56.832
Right.

984
01:02:56.932 --> 01:03:00.775
And when you tightly confine it at really low temperatures, you get a Bose-Einstein condensate.

985
01:03:01.235 --> 01:03:01.756
Okay, great.

986
01:03:02.116 --> 01:03:05.959
That's no longer that cutting edge anymore, which is kind of crazy to think about.

987
01:03:06.099 --> 01:03:06.999
Right.

988
01:03:07.059 --> 01:03:08.881
In like 20 years, it's like, oh, yeah, okay, fine.

989
01:03:08.901 --> 01:03:10.842
You made a Bose-Einstein condensate.

990
01:03:10.882 --> 01:03:11.082
Great.

991
01:03:11.142 --> 01:03:11.383
Cool.

992
01:03:11.443 --> 01:03:12.143
Good for you.

993
01:03:12.463 --> 01:03:12.704
Yeah.

994
01:03:13.604 --> 01:03:18.468
Next, what you do is you split them apart.

995
01:03:18.768 --> 01:03:19.028
Okay?

996
01:03:19.288 --> 01:03:21.370
So now using your radiofrequency...

997
01:03:22.778 --> 01:03:31.063
What you can do is toggle that atom and very slowly turn the single potential well, which is where the atoms are sitting.

998
01:03:31.503 --> 01:03:37.627
You can start making a little hill in the middle, and the atoms are going to split into two wells.

999
01:03:37.887 --> 01:03:40.289
You've got to do this very, very slowly.

1000
01:03:40.989 --> 01:03:45.232
You've got to do this extremely slowly, adiabatically is what we call it.

1001
01:03:45.832 --> 01:03:51.496
And when we get there, we're going to create these radiofrequency-dressed potentials.

1002
01:03:52.495 --> 01:03:55.157
where you have multiple little wave packets of atoms.

1003
01:03:55.337 --> 01:04:06.864
So a single atom is now being split up into multiple different clouds that are still entangled because we did it slowly enough that the entanglement of that original Bose-Einstein condensate is splitting.

1004
01:04:07.505 --> 01:04:20.253
And just as a quick note, just for my recollection about Bose-Einstein condensates, the idea there was what you were able to do is you create one sort of macro object

1005
01:04:20.993 --> 01:04:25.675
that maintains all the parameters as one sort of holistic thing.

1006
01:04:25.735 --> 01:04:27.195
Yeah, it's one-way function.

1007
01:04:27.215 --> 01:04:32.557
It's one-way function, which has its own inherent value in and of itself.

1008
01:04:32.577 --> 01:04:32.817
Yes.

1009
01:04:33.037 --> 01:04:46.963
And so now we're building on top of that concept to take that macro, this one-way function across multiple component parts, and we're now splitting it where they are maintaining entanglement.

1010
01:04:46.983 --> 01:04:47.303
Yeah, exactly.

1011
01:04:48.824 --> 01:04:50.546
which is then going to be our next...

1012
01:04:50.566 --> 01:04:54.270
But I'm correctly understanding the idea behind the Bose-Einstein condensate.

1013
01:04:54.290 --> 01:04:54.751
Yes, exactly.

1014
01:04:55.211 --> 01:04:58.575
It's one wave function that we're now splitting into, I guess, two wave functions.

1015
01:04:58.876 --> 01:05:05.343
But the two wave functions, because they were derived from the first one, and we're doing it slowly enough, the entanglement is still very strong.

1016
01:05:05.523 --> 01:05:06.004
It's staining.

1017
01:05:06.064 --> 01:05:06.324
Okay.

1018
01:05:06.344 --> 01:05:06.504
Right?

1019
01:05:06.825 --> 01:05:08.066
And now what we can do...

1020
01:05:08.907 --> 01:05:20.650
with those multiple clouds of atoms, is we can measure one quantity here, we can measure another quantity here, another quantity here, so on and so forth.

1021
01:05:21.030 --> 01:05:25.471
But because they are entangled, these are not independent variables.

1022
01:05:25.971 --> 01:05:27.832
And so the noise is not independent.

1023
01:05:28.212 --> 01:05:29.572
This is what's crucial, okay?

1024
01:05:29.992 --> 01:05:31.553
If they were independent, what would happen?

1025
01:05:32.073 --> 01:05:36.775
If they were independent, let's say I've got atom cloud A and atom cloud B.

1026
01:05:37.015 --> 01:05:37.275
Okay?

1027
01:05:37.795 --> 01:05:39.796
I measure some parameter on atom cloud A.

1028
01:05:40.116 --> 01:05:45.258
That's going to be, let's say, you know, A plus or minus some number because that plus or minus number is an error.

1029
01:05:45.478 --> 01:05:45.679
Yes.

1030
01:05:46.219 --> 01:05:48.420
With B, I'm going to measure plus or minus some number.

1031
01:05:48.600 --> 01:05:48.780
Right?

1032
01:05:48.840 --> 01:05:56.203
If I wanted to calculate, let's say, a difference between what is A and what is B and things like that, those errors would be independent and...

1033
01:05:57.262 --> 01:06:01.648
When I calculated that sum or that difference, the error would only go down by 1 over the root 2.

1034
01:06:01.668 --> 01:06:02.168
Okay.

1035
01:06:02.369 --> 01:06:02.609
Okay?

1036
01:06:02.949 --> 01:06:03.911
Because they're independent.

1037
01:06:03.951 --> 01:06:04.131
Yes.

1038
01:06:05.312 --> 01:06:09.017
Now, when I measure A plus or minus something and B plus or minus something...

1039
01:06:09.985 --> 01:06:12.606
that plus or minus is not independent.

1040
01:06:13.006 --> 01:06:13.727
They're related.

1041
01:06:14.467 --> 01:06:19.709
So what I could do is measure something like A plus B and A minus B.

1042
01:06:20.029 --> 01:06:30.274
Or if I have three things, I can measure A plus B plus C, A minus B plus C, A minus B minus C. I could measure all of these different combinations, and the noise in that total...

1043
01:06:31.740 --> 01:06:36.985
measurement is going to be smaller than if I would have measured the two independently.

1044
01:06:37.425 --> 01:06:38.446
That is the key.

1045
01:06:38.466 --> 01:06:39.106
Oh my goodness.

1046
01:06:39.126 --> 01:06:39.707
Does that make sense?

1047
01:06:40.468 --> 01:06:40.828
Yes.

1048
01:06:40.848 --> 01:06:40.928
Yes.

1049
01:06:41.188 --> 01:06:41.909
We're doing like...

1050
01:06:43.153 --> 01:06:44.134
Number magic here.

1051
01:06:44.234 --> 01:06:44.855
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1052
01:06:44.915 --> 01:06:48.399
We're like measuring combinations of states rather than individual states.

1053
01:06:48.839 --> 01:06:55.306
And whereby we do that, because the noise is correlated, because the stuff is entangled, the total noise is smaller.

1054
01:06:55.346 --> 01:07:01.772
It's smaller on the aggregate measurement as opposed to the individual measurement.

1055
01:07:02.870 --> 01:07:18.175
fascinating which goes back to now I'm thinking about that original chart we looked at with the circle and the oval and the implications on the level of precision because the noise is now smaller because we're making we have this aggregate measurement that allows us to decrease noise

1056
01:07:19.389 --> 01:07:21.171
Does it kind of make sense on that?

1057
01:07:21.291 --> 01:07:21.731
It does.

1058
01:07:22.072 --> 01:07:27.177
And this feels very cool because in theory... Let me pause.

1059
01:07:27.257 --> 01:07:28.118
Let me let you continue.

1060
01:07:28.338 --> 01:07:30.260
Yeah, so let's see how they actually did it, right?

1061
01:07:30.721 --> 01:07:36.267
So as I said, they've got a single wave function with the Bose-Einstein condensate.

1062
01:07:36.567 --> 01:07:38.729
Now let's see what they do with just two clouds.

1063
01:07:38.809 --> 01:07:41.893
So when they do two clouds, they've got this local microwave that...

1064
01:07:42.657 --> 01:07:44.378
You know, splits it into two clouds there.

1065
01:07:44.398 --> 01:07:46.319
You can actually see the sort of two clouds.

1066
01:07:46.499 --> 01:07:46.719
Yes.

1067
01:07:46.799 --> 01:07:51.762
Right next to each other about like a few tens of microns to hundreds of microns apart.

1068
01:07:52.002 --> 01:07:52.202
Yes.

1069
01:07:52.262 --> 01:07:52.462
Right.

1070
01:07:52.802 --> 01:07:58.245
And what we're going to do is measure some parameter, which effectively means we're measuring like a phase of the wave function.

1071
01:07:58.285 --> 01:08:01.127
It's like an angle difference between the two things.

1072
01:08:01.167 --> 01:08:02.948
Like we're measuring an angle at all times.

1073
01:08:03.688 --> 01:08:03.888
Okay.

1074
01:08:04.288 --> 01:08:04.469
On...

1075
01:08:05.552 --> 01:08:07.654
something called a block sphere, but we don't have to get into that.

1076
01:08:07.915 --> 01:08:09.536
We're measuring some parameter, okay?

1077
01:08:09.777 --> 01:08:18.846
The two parameters are correlated, and that's why when you look at, you know, if we were to measure phase two versus phase one, the clouds are not completely circles.

1078
01:08:19.307 --> 01:08:20.528
They're spin-squeezed.

1079
01:08:20.788 --> 01:08:22.390
They're these ellipses, right?

1080
01:08:23.051 --> 01:08:24.392
One direction is the sum,

1081
01:08:25.033 --> 01:08:27.434
Theta, like phase one plus phase two.

1082
01:08:27.815 --> 01:08:29.175
The other direction is the difference.

1083
01:08:29.616 --> 01:08:30.736
Phase one minus phase two.

1084
01:08:31.056 --> 01:08:38.460
What you can measure is, let's say, on one end, we measure the sum, which is the axis perpendicular to the ellipse.

1085
01:08:38.781 --> 01:08:43.423
So that's the squeezed axis, the part that's like shorter on that ellipse.

1086
01:08:43.463 --> 01:08:44.143
We measure that.

1087
01:08:44.624 --> 01:08:50.047
And then what I can do is rotate the second one so that now I'm...

1088
01:08:50.885 --> 01:08:55.668
The squeezed axis is on the difference part, and now I measure the difference.

1089
01:08:55.688 --> 01:08:55.888
Yes.

1090
01:08:56.248 --> 01:08:56.508
Okay?

1091
01:08:57.009 --> 01:08:58.089
That's another key thing.

1092
01:08:58.109 --> 01:09:04.213
They could rotate and manipulate these things such that whatever axis they wanted to do, that's the one that would be squeezed.

1093
01:09:04.713 --> 01:09:05.013
Okay?

1094
01:09:05.373 --> 01:09:07.515
So you've got this ellipse, and you're like, I want to measure here.

1095
01:09:07.835 --> 01:09:08.555
Now let's rotate.

1096
01:09:08.575 --> 01:09:09.496
Now I want to measure here.

1097
01:09:09.516 --> 01:09:09.716
Yes.

1098
01:09:09.796 --> 01:09:10.717
So they're able to do both.

1099
01:09:10.918 --> 01:09:11.819
It's not at the same time.

1100
01:09:11.839 --> 01:09:12.801
So you're still not cheating.

1101
01:09:13.021 --> 01:09:13.221
Yes.

1102
01:09:13.261 --> 01:09:13.442
Right.

1103
01:09:13.482 --> 01:09:14.483
Heisenberg is still happy.

1104
01:09:14.543 --> 01:09:14.764
Yes.

1105
01:09:15.164 --> 01:09:17.668
But at different times, you're getting these measurements.

1106
01:09:18.229 --> 01:09:19.431
You've measured the sum in one.

1107
01:09:19.471 --> 01:09:20.873
You've measured the difference in the other.

1108
01:09:21.154 --> 01:09:24.599
So now with the sum, I can find the average value of this parameter.

1109
01:09:24.639 --> 01:09:24.759
Yep.

1110
01:09:24.779 --> 01:09:24.859
Yep.

1111
01:09:25.300 --> 01:09:26.961
With the difference, I can find the gradient.

1112
01:09:27.001 --> 01:09:29.023
I can find what is the difference between here and here.

1113
01:09:29.443 --> 01:09:29.623
Right?

1114
01:09:29.823 --> 01:09:31.364
And I'm still keeping Heisenberg happy.

1115
01:09:31.404 --> 01:09:31.624
Yes.

1116
01:09:31.824 --> 01:09:35.627
But because of this entanglement and all of the fancy tricks that I've done, Yes.

1117
01:09:36.267 --> 01:09:41.391
each measurement now of the sum and the difference, I've beaten the standard quantum limit.

1118
01:09:41.551 --> 01:09:41.791
Right.

1119
01:09:42.251 --> 01:09:42.432
Right?

1120
01:09:42.472 --> 01:09:43.993
Because I'm not measuring independent.

1121
01:09:44.153 --> 01:09:44.353
Right.

1122
01:09:44.393 --> 01:09:48.015
I'm not measuring phase one and phase two, and then I'm taking the difference.

1123
01:09:48.055 --> 01:09:49.676
I'm actually just measuring the difference.

1124
01:09:49.736 --> 01:09:49.957
Yes.

1125
01:09:49.977 --> 01:09:50.257
Yes.

1126
01:09:50.977 --> 01:09:52.198
Right.

1127
01:09:52.278 --> 01:10:12.810
Through this mechanism of the atomic sensors in the Bose-Einstein condensate, which gives you this mechanism by which to be able to measure where now the aggregate measurement has less noise than the independent measurements.

1128
01:10:13.470 --> 01:10:16.492
And because you can now also rotate in the way that you described it,

1129
01:10:17.052 --> 01:10:20.814
we can get a level of precision across multiple observable states.

1130
01:10:20.854 --> 01:10:21.114
Yes.

1131
01:10:21.254 --> 01:10:23.475
Instead of having to choose one or the other.

1132
01:10:23.835 --> 01:10:29.438
So in the LIGO example you talked about earlier, the examples, we just care about one thing, which is the mirrors.

1133
01:10:29.458 --> 01:10:29.678
Yeah.

1134
01:10:32.462 --> 01:10:46.529
With this conceptually, you can now expand that to say, well, we care about two things, and we can now get a level of precision above the SQL, closer to the Heisenberg limit, which is theoretically the actual limit of observational precision.

1135
01:10:46.589 --> 01:10:50.251
Yeah, we can't get better than that, but we'd like to get as close to that as possible.

1136
01:10:50.471 --> 01:10:54.693
And here, what we're doing is we're measuring the actual, let's say, difference, right?

1137
01:10:54.713 --> 01:10:56.514
We're measuring 4 minus 3 equals 1.

1138
01:10:56.614 --> 01:10:57.915
Before, we were measuring 4 minus 3.

1139
01:10:58.655 --> 01:11:02.117
three, and then we'd have to do the math to be like, oh, four minus three is one.

1140
01:11:02.337 --> 01:11:03.458
Here, we're just measuring one.

1141
01:11:04.539 --> 01:11:07.901
And the plus or minus on that one is much smaller than we would have done otherwise.

1142
01:11:07.941 --> 01:11:10.442
Because the four and the three would have had their own individual error.

1143
01:11:10.622 --> 01:11:12.403
And so the noise at the...

1144
01:11:12.443 --> 01:11:13.364
When you get to the...

1145
01:11:14.610 --> 01:11:15.910
conclusion is much higher.

1146
01:11:15.930 --> 01:11:17.491
We're actually observing the conclusion.

1147
01:11:18.571 --> 01:11:19.912
Very, very, very fascinating.

1148
01:11:19.932 --> 01:11:22.853
And now with three, we can do all three combinations.

1149
01:11:22.953 --> 01:11:28.014
With three, I can do the plus, plus, plus, plus, minus, plus, plus, minus, minus, so on and so forth.

1150
01:11:28.394 --> 01:11:29.115
And the...

1151
01:11:30.350 --> 01:11:34.694
Diagonals that you see is what they're actually doing right like what are you actually measuring?

1152
01:11:35.014 --> 01:11:36.996
This needs to be a proof of concept, right?

1153
01:11:37.257 --> 01:11:43.062
It's not like they're measuring some magnetic field that's changing because if you were to do that as a first experiment, right?

1154
01:11:43.082 --> 01:11:45.324
You'd be like well, how do you know you even measured it correctly?

1155
01:11:45.344 --> 01:11:45.744
Correct.

1156
01:11:45.825 --> 01:11:46.525
Yeah, that makes sense.

1157
01:11:46.545 --> 01:11:47.306
So what you do, what do you do?

1158
01:11:47.386 --> 01:11:49.108
You actually encode the parameter.

1159
01:11:49.388 --> 01:11:53.812
You engineer in and you encode the parameter and then you say can I measure this?

1160
01:11:53.932 --> 01:11:54.633
what I encoded.

1161
01:11:54.713 --> 01:11:58.336
So you ultimately know what the result is prior to measurement such that it's controlled.

1162
01:11:58.416 --> 01:11:59.837
Yeah, because this is a controlled experiment.

1163
01:11:59.857 --> 01:12:01.378
This is a proof of concept, right?

1164
01:12:01.398 --> 01:12:06.382
You need to show that it works on stuff that you already know the ground truth for, and that's what shows in the diagonal.

1165
01:12:06.402 --> 01:12:12.447
It's like they're trying to – for the off-diagonal stuff, it's like you encode something, but you're trying to measure in some other state.

1166
01:12:12.707 --> 01:12:16.310
Like you encoded plus, plus, minus, but then you try to measure plus, plus, plus.

1167
01:12:16.490 --> 01:12:18.372
You're not able to do that because that wasn't the point.

1168
01:12:18.492 --> 01:12:18.832
Right.

1169
01:12:18.912 --> 01:12:20.954
And that's kind of the point of that diagonal.

1170
01:12:21.074 --> 01:12:25.439
Along the diagonal, you get this boost in sensitivity.

1171
01:12:25.959 --> 01:12:26.219
Okay?

1172
01:12:26.259 --> 01:12:27.400
That's the negative decibels.

1173
01:12:27.721 --> 01:12:31.744
The negative decibels is how much more boost you have over the quantum limit.

1174
01:12:31.765 --> 01:12:35.748
You're getting like negative 5 decibels, which is like a 3x improvement.

1175
01:12:35.768 --> 01:12:36.189
Improvement.

1176
01:12:36.349 --> 01:12:36.549
Right?

1177
01:12:36.709 --> 01:12:36.889
Right.

1178
01:12:37.150 --> 01:12:37.830
And that makes sense.

1179
01:12:37.850 --> 01:12:39.091
The point is, you know, the –

1180
01:12:41.134 --> 01:12:49.285
In order to be able to sufficiently prove and convince that this is true, you need to be able to show that it measures something we have a discrete value for.

1181
01:12:49.365 --> 01:12:49.946
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1182
01:12:49.986 --> 01:12:52.389
It's like something you've engineered that you know the ground truth for.

1183
01:12:52.509 --> 01:12:54.111
And then you're like, hey, I was able to do this.

1184
01:12:54.552 --> 01:12:57.235
Now I can go and use this to measure other stuff.

1185
01:12:57.255 --> 01:12:57.356
Yeah.

1186
01:12:57.376 --> 01:12:57.516
Yeah.

1187
01:12:57.756 --> 01:13:24.143
right yeah that makes sense the applications for this are very cool okay so for one you can measure magnetic fields really really precisely you can create kind of like a vector camera that images the full magnetic vector field so you have the x component the y component and the z component of some material let's say you can create this sensor now and measure inside that material the magnetic fields in each direction you can do this like

1188
01:13:24.843 --> 01:13:26.925
trick where it's like, okay, now I care about X.

1189
01:13:27.066 --> 01:13:27.786
Let's measure X.

1190
01:13:28.107 --> 01:13:28.968
Now I care about Y.

1191
01:13:29.028 --> 01:13:32.271
Let's measure Y. I mean, again, you're not going to do it simultaneously.

1192
01:13:32.511 --> 01:13:39.899
But if you do it 1000 times, and you have reasonable assumptions about how constant magnetic field is, you can get to pretty nice precision, right?

1193
01:13:40.020 --> 01:13:42.102
You can just repeat the experiment over and over again.

1194
01:13:43.103 --> 01:13:45.726
Internal, you can have a quantum internet of clocks.

1195
01:13:46.747 --> 01:14:00.439
Okay, so, you know, by entangling atoms at different sites in a kind of lattice, what you can do is have a distributed clock network, where there's a clock here, there's a clock here, extremely precise based on this two-level splitting.

1196
01:14:01.019 --> 01:14:12.449
And then you can measure gravitational redshifts at the millimeter scale, meaning I have my Bose-Einstein condensate here, I raise it by one millimeter, right?

1197
01:14:12.695 --> 01:14:17.416
If I raise it by one millimeter, it's going to feel the earth a little bit less.

1198
01:14:18.657 --> 01:14:19.637
By a millimeter.

1199
01:14:19.657 --> 01:14:20.057
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1200
01:14:20.377 --> 01:14:25.679
If it feels the earth a little bit less, time is going to be sped up a little bit more.

1201
01:14:26.399 --> 01:14:31.360
And you can actually measure that by having the clock decide where it is on a millimeter scale.

1202
01:14:31.380 --> 01:14:31.980
This is so cool.

1203
01:14:32.040 --> 01:14:34.241
And finally, if you're interested in dark matter...

1204
01:14:35.273 --> 01:14:48.708
There's this one theory of dark matter and of like, if you want to measure gravitational waves, when a gravitational wave comes through, each different part of the sensor is going to feel the gravitational wave at different time points.

1205
01:14:49.108 --> 01:14:50.229
So you can measure it that way.

1206
01:14:50.550 --> 01:14:54.674
If you've got a dark matter particle or a dark matter quantum wave that goes through...

1207
01:14:55.355 --> 01:14:56.315
You're going to get a jitter.

1208
01:14:56.815 --> 01:15:02.157
And so the more sensitive we can get, the better we can measure these really, really tiny things.

1209
01:15:02.617 --> 01:15:16.460
Because the point is that each points of the measurement apparatus, you're going to have up to a 3x increase in level of precision, which when we're talking about gravitational wave detection is extremely valuable.

1210
01:15:16.540 --> 01:15:17.861
Yes, it's extremely valuable.

1211
01:15:18.161 --> 01:15:26.968
And I mean, for their proof of concept, you know, when they when they went from two at the level of two, I think they got about a three X precision when they got to three.

1212
01:15:27.428 --> 01:15:28.349
They didn't have a three X.

1213
01:15:28.409 --> 01:15:31.411
It was only like maybe, you know, 50, 10 percent or something like that.

1214
01:15:31.431 --> 01:15:31.751
Which is fair.

1215
01:15:31.871 --> 01:15:32.011
Right.

1216
01:15:32.031 --> 01:15:32.512
Which is fair.

1217
01:15:32.532 --> 01:15:33.312
Yeah.

1218
01:15:34.293 --> 01:15:35.813
But it's a proof of concept, right?

1219
01:15:36.474 --> 01:15:37.994
We need a large number of atoms.

1220
01:15:38.334 --> 01:15:42.075
Right now, they've only got about 5,000 atoms in this Bose-Einstein condensate.

1221
01:15:42.115 --> 01:15:48.257
If you had something like 10 to the 6, a million atoms, then you could start competing with classical sensors, right?

1222
01:15:48.497 --> 01:15:52.858
And then if you have even more, now you're really going gangbusters with your improvement.

1223
01:15:52.878 --> 01:15:55.839
You're really hitting that Heisenberg uncertainty limit, right?

1224
01:15:55.859 --> 01:15:56.639
This is quite nice.

1225
01:15:56.659 --> 01:15:57.879
So it's a proof of concept.

1226
01:16:01.137 --> 01:16:06.220
We're transitioning to this multi-parameter quantum metrology, right?

1227
01:16:07.061 --> 01:16:09.142
And it's going from theory to experimental reality.

1228
01:16:09.182 --> 01:16:10.022
And I was reading about it.

1229
01:16:10.302 --> 01:16:13.044
It's like even the theory of this was not really well-founded.

1230
01:16:13.564 --> 01:16:16.606
But they're running with it, and they're showing that the experiment kind of works.

1231
01:16:16.906 --> 01:16:17.767
It's very, very cool.

1232
01:16:18.167 --> 01:16:28.453
This, again, is out of the physics department at the University of Basel, as well as the Laboratory Castel-Brosol at the University of Sorbonne in France.

1233
01:16:28.493 --> 01:16:29.233
The Europeans.

1234
01:16:29.774 --> 01:16:30.174
Doing well.

1235
01:16:30.394 --> 01:16:30.914
Doing well.

1236
01:16:31.555 --> 01:16:32.715
The French doing well.

1237
01:16:32.755 --> 01:16:33.636
The French doing well.

1238
01:16:33.656 --> 01:16:38.319
We have had a lot of French stories in the last couple of episodes.

1239
01:16:38.859 --> 01:16:45.203
Very fascinating, especially because, like we talk about all the time, the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle is one of those things to me that's

1240
01:16:46.003 --> 01:16:47.364
still so weird.

1241
01:16:49.165 --> 01:16:55.008
The analogy I always kind of bring up when we talk about it is like, and this is probably the common analogy in video games.

1242
01:16:56.209 --> 01:17:01.652
You reach the edge of the level, the map, the edge of where the developers built the map and you can't,

1243
01:17:02.788 --> 01:17:03.729
can't go beyond the edge.

1244
01:17:04.329 --> 01:17:05.270
Like that's the limit.

1245
01:17:05.370 --> 01:17:05.591
Yeah.

1246
01:17:05.851 --> 01:17:06.672
And it's just the limit.

1247
01:17:06.832 --> 01:17:07.052
Yeah.

1248
01:17:07.172 --> 01:17:07.673
And that's it.

1249
01:17:07.913 --> 01:17:08.353
And that's it.

1250
01:17:08.533 --> 01:17:14.579
And you can never know what's outside the limit or, and it's like crude analogy, but it's very weird.

1251
01:17:14.699 --> 01:17:15.780
It's just very weird.

1252
01:17:15.880 --> 01:17:18.903
It's, it's a central tenant of, of quantum mechanics.

1253
01:17:19.264 --> 01:17:21.466
It's what makes it so different from classical mechanics.

1254
01:17:21.666 --> 01:17:21.886
Right.

1255
01:17:22.086 --> 01:17:22.286
Right.

1256
01:17:22.387 --> 01:17:22.567
Right.

1257
01:17:23.308 --> 01:17:41.450
uh beautiful we always love a good solid physics story we are going to end with our final story of the day which is uh about alpha k yeah uh which is this local adaptive mapping uh that's specific for cancer research

1258
01:17:42.050 --> 01:17:50.980
This was the Nature Communications from the H. Lee Moffitt Cancer Center and Research Institute Integrated Mathematical Oncology.

1259
01:17:51.861 --> 01:17:59.930
This one, there's a lot of concepts we've talked about that have helped me kind of grok this concept, I think, a little bit better because...

1260
01:18:01.786 --> 01:18:05.348
I didn't understand what gradients and gradient descent was before and things like that.

1261
01:18:05.368 --> 01:18:08.769
And there seems to be conceptually some overlap here.

1262
01:18:08.829 --> 01:18:11.470
And so now I have a mental model for us to work with.

1263
01:18:11.530 --> 01:18:15.632
But what do we have going on here in this sort of new cancer story?

1264
01:18:15.912 --> 01:18:17.973
Yeah, this is a very cool cancer story, I thought.

1265
01:18:18.473 --> 01:18:22.054
Again, uses a lot of physics, which is my favorite kind of biology.

1266
01:18:23.295 --> 01:18:28.797
They're introducing this new tool, Alpha K. This is out of the Moffitt Hospital in Tampa, Florida.

1267
01:18:29.681 --> 01:18:34.646
What they're effectively doing is trying to predict how cancer evolves.

1268
01:18:35.587 --> 01:18:40.592
It's a paradigm shift in the way we think about cancer evolution because before we used to think there's just no rules.

1269
01:18:41.272 --> 01:18:41.873
It's chaotic.

1270
01:18:42.393 --> 01:18:47.238
The whole thing is just – this cancer thing is just trying its hardest to live.

1271
01:18:47.699 --> 01:18:50.882
These tumors are trying its hardest to beat whatever we throw at it.

1272
01:18:51.262 --> 01:18:54.245
And the way that it does it is in a very chaotic environment where…

1273
01:18:54.285 --> 01:18:56.767
The genome is changing very chaotically.

1274
01:18:57.047 --> 01:18:59.450
And so it's very hard to predict something that is chaotic, right?

1275
01:18:59.470 --> 01:19:00.631
It's kind of like weather.

1276
01:19:01.071 --> 01:19:04.154
But at the end of the day, even weather is predictable, right?

1277
01:19:04.374 --> 01:19:08.257
We have weather models, and they're pretty good most of the time.

1278
01:19:08.317 --> 01:19:08.557
Yes.

1279
01:19:08.638 --> 01:19:08.858
Right?

1280
01:19:09.018 --> 01:19:09.238
Yes.

1281
01:19:09.318 --> 01:19:16.184
Maybe not like Mammoth, because Mammoth has mountains, and mountains can get in the way of predictions and things like that.

1282
01:19:16.264 --> 01:19:18.266
But for Los Angeles, it's pretty good.

1283
01:19:18.286 --> 01:19:19.047
It's quite nice.

1284
01:19:19.587 --> 01:19:21.309
So can we do the same thing?

1285
01:19:21.949 --> 01:19:23.370
with cancer genomes.

1286
01:19:23.410 --> 01:19:26.972
Particularly what they're trying to tackle is something called aneuploidy.

1287
01:19:27.232 --> 01:19:28.633
There's a paradox in aneuploidy.

1288
01:19:28.933 --> 01:19:32.735
We've heard about aneuploidy when it comes to disorders like trisomy 21.

1289
01:19:33.175 --> 01:19:34.556
That's how you get Down syndrome, right?

1290
01:19:34.796 --> 01:19:39.438
You get three copies of the chromosome 21, and that leads to Down syndrome.

1291
01:19:40.359 --> 01:19:46.502
We should only have two copies for sort of typical organisms.

1292
01:19:46.802 --> 01:19:48.643
Two copies of each chromosome, right?

1293
01:19:48.875 --> 01:19:52.059
We've got 23 chromosomes, so 48 different chromosomes.

1294
01:19:52.520 --> 01:19:54.923
If we've got two copies, we're good to go.

1295
01:19:55.343 --> 01:20:01.051
But aneuploidy is when we have more or less of a specific chromosome.

1296
01:20:02.773 --> 01:20:05.436
It is very bad and catastrophic for normal cells.

1297
01:20:06.280 --> 01:20:08.381
But cancer cells love it.

1298
01:20:08.921 --> 01:20:10.041
Okay?

1299
01:20:10.081 --> 01:20:12.722
90% of solid tumors are aneuploid tumors.

1300
01:20:13.082 --> 01:20:13.362
Okay.

1301
01:20:13.522 --> 01:20:13.762
Okay?

1302
01:20:14.042 --> 01:20:15.383
Here you can look at a cancer cell.

1303
01:20:15.583 --> 01:20:16.743
There's four of two.

1304
01:20:17.043 --> 01:20:18.204
There's three of one.

1305
01:20:18.644 --> 01:20:19.904
Three, I guess, there's still two.

1306
01:20:19.984 --> 01:20:21.504
So three is still chilling.

1307
01:20:21.524 --> 01:20:26.466
There's four copies of four, three copies of five, three copies of 12, three copies of 11.

1308
01:20:26.566 --> 01:20:27.346
Ten is still two.

1309
01:20:27.566 --> 01:20:28.246
You see what I'm saying?

1310
01:20:28.266 --> 01:20:28.767
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1311
01:20:28.787 --> 01:20:32.848
This, like, if somebody looked at this chromosome, it's like, there's no way this is a normal cell.

1312
01:20:32.908 --> 01:20:33.088
Right.

1313
01:20:33.108 --> 01:20:33.228
Right.

1314
01:20:33.608 --> 01:20:35.049
Because what is going on?

1315
01:20:35.229 --> 01:20:36.630
Yeah, it's just all over the place.

1316
01:20:36.650 --> 01:20:37.531
It's all over the place.

1317
01:20:37.571 --> 01:20:38.411
There's three of some.

1318
01:20:38.932 --> 01:20:41.533
Some are completely deleted and just not even there.

1319
01:20:41.553 --> 01:20:42.394
Right.

1320
01:20:42.534 --> 01:20:43.094
What's going on?

1321
01:20:43.415 --> 01:20:44.696
Cancer loves doing this.

1322
01:20:44.836 --> 01:20:45.116
Okay.

1323
01:20:45.136 --> 01:20:45.396
Okay.

1324
01:20:45.656 --> 01:20:50.439
And there's a clear evolutionary advantage to doing this for a cancer cell.

1325
01:20:50.760 --> 01:20:55.343
There's clear a disadvantage for a normal cell, but somehow for cancer, those cells love it.

1326
01:20:55.723 --> 01:20:55.903
Right.

1327
01:20:56.384 --> 01:20:59.528
There's some kind of benefit that you get from that genetic variation.

1328
01:20:59.928 --> 01:21:10.361
And it kind of makes sense because the more copies of a chromosome that you have, the more you can mess around with mutations.

1329
01:21:10.861 --> 01:21:11.041
Right.

1330
01:21:11.101 --> 01:21:12.783
It's that same concept of the GitHub algorithm.

1331
01:21:13.384 --> 01:21:14.785
main versus your branch.

1332
01:21:15.005 --> 01:21:20.688
If you're a cancer cell, you've got a bunch of your own branches that you're just trying all sorts of stuff to survive, right?

1333
01:21:20.748 --> 01:21:27.272
Because whoever the patient is and the doctors that are treating the patient, they're throwing radiation, chemotherapy, everything at you.

1334
01:21:27.552 --> 01:21:38.058
And from a cancer cell's perspective, it's like, I got to change as fast as I can and evolve out of my current environment to get through to the next stage of whatever therapy that they're going to put in, right?

1335
01:21:38.298 --> 01:21:40.459
The cancer cell is trying to evolve and survive.

1336
01:21:40.940 --> 01:21:41.140
And the,

1337
01:21:42.197 --> 01:21:48.820
If we wanted to look at the possible number of karyotypes, karyotypes are this set of chromosomes, right?

1338
01:21:49.561 --> 01:22:01.906
If we were to look at all of the sets of all the different chromosomes that we'd have to model in order to sort of try and figure out some kind of simulation of cancer evolution, it would be something like 10 to the 10 to the 20.

1339
01:22:01.926 --> 01:22:03.787
So 10 to the 20 zeros.

1340
01:22:05.529 --> 01:22:12.994
That's a which is a billion billion zeros, not a billion billion combinations, a billion billion zeros and a one.

1341
01:22:13.434 --> 01:22:14.375
OK, it's a lot.

1342
01:22:14.455 --> 01:22:15.316
It's never going to happen.

1343
01:22:15.536 --> 01:22:15.856
You're right.

1344
01:22:16.076 --> 01:22:18.278
Even with quantum computing, it's never going to happen.

1345
01:22:18.398 --> 01:22:19.719
OK, stop trying to make it happen.

1346
01:22:20.159 --> 01:22:27.904
So instead, these researchers came up with Alpha K, which is inferring what's called a local landscape of fitness.

1347
01:22:29.145 --> 01:22:29.425
And it's.

1348
01:22:30.612 --> 01:22:36.315
It's trying to figure out how the tumor is going through this local landscape of fitness.

1349
01:22:37.015 --> 01:22:45.139
So the big initial problem is that the scale of trying to just map all the possibilities is...

1350
01:22:45.899 --> 01:22:48.380
is so, it's just impossibly large.

1351
01:22:48.400 --> 01:22:48.600
Yeah.

1352
01:22:48.880 --> 01:22:52.021
And so it's not worth trying to like create the map of everything.

1353
01:22:52.041 --> 01:22:53.621
Yeah, like a brute force strategy.

1354
01:22:53.721 --> 01:22:54.741
Right, right.

1355
01:22:54.941 --> 01:22:57.202
So even with content, it's just like the scale is too large.

1356
01:22:57.662 --> 01:23:05.244
So what they're trying to do is basically say, can we isolate certain aspects of the landscape that are meaningful

1357
01:23:06.244 --> 01:23:09.486
to basically deal with the scale problem.

1358
01:23:09.546 --> 01:23:10.426
Yes, exactly.

1359
01:23:10.566 --> 01:23:10.966
Exactly.

1360
01:23:11.026 --> 01:23:12.767
Specifically when it comes to this aneuploidy.

1361
01:23:12.787 --> 01:23:18.210
And before we move off aneuploidy, I just wanted to talk about Ohalo by David Freeberg.

1362
01:23:18.230 --> 01:23:19.150
David Freeberg!

1363
01:23:20.411 --> 01:23:22.292
Of the other podcast fame.

1364
01:23:22.412 --> 01:23:22.652
Yes.

1365
01:23:23.432 --> 01:23:27.974
And he's CEO of this company called Ohalo.

1366
01:23:28.474 --> 01:23:30.976
They are doing aneuploidy effectively.

1367
01:23:31.016 --> 01:23:33.637
They have something called Boosted...

1368
01:23:34.902 --> 01:23:35.422
what is it called?

1369
01:23:35.463 --> 01:23:38.025
Boosted reproduction or boosted genetics.

1370
01:23:38.525 --> 01:23:44.210
Effectively, you know, when we were born, we get half of our genes from our mom, half of our genes from our dad.

1371
01:23:44.790 --> 01:23:48.353
And so you get one set of chromosomes from your mom, one set of chromosomes from your dad.

1372
01:23:48.694 --> 01:23:51.336
And that makes you, what he figured was in plants.

1373
01:23:51.376 --> 01:23:54.599
What if we just got, well, what if we just kept the, kept the entire set?

1374
01:23:55.119 --> 01:24:01.224
So we had tetraploids, meaning two chromosomes from dad, two chromosomes from mom, right in the nucleus.

1375
01:24:01.745 --> 01:24:01.965
And the,

1376
01:24:03.248 --> 01:24:05.969
I was really surprised that it works.

1377
01:24:06.689 --> 01:24:10.290
Like that it doesn't just, the plant doesn't just die.

1378
01:24:10.410 --> 01:24:10.610
Right.

1379
01:24:10.650 --> 01:24:13.571
To me, trivially, it's like you should just die.

1380
01:24:13.991 --> 01:24:16.492
But these plants, they're making bigger potatoes.

1381
01:24:16.832 --> 01:24:19.073
The potatoes are like lasting longer on the shelf.

1382
01:24:19.473 --> 01:24:20.273
All sorts of stuff.

1383
01:24:20.653 --> 01:24:23.154
It's like incredible genetic technology.

1384
01:24:23.254 --> 01:24:26.955
And they must have done some crazy stuff.

1385
01:24:28.419 --> 01:24:49.967
engineering to make sure that these you know these cells are like actually lasting as long as they do the the i think the main idea behind ohalo is you know if we look at our agricultural supply chains globally yeah which are very susceptible to any number of both environmental as well as geopolitical crises if folks remember back to the beginning of the

1386
01:24:50.687 --> 01:24:58.155
Russia-Ukraine conflict, one of the things that was brought up is that Ukraine is one of the breadbaskets of Europe.

1387
01:24:58.655 --> 01:25:06.143
And if the agriculture goes down, there's going to have these cascading supply chain issues across not only Europe, but other countries as well.

1388
01:25:06.743 --> 01:25:07.904
And we obviously have...

1389
01:25:08.605 --> 01:25:35.983
anthropogenic climate change issues and all of this stuff and so finding ways to make the yield on agriculture and crops higher for the same amount of used space we don't need to expand to larger amounts of area being uh used for crops but can we just actually genetically modify the orms just be better yeah more rice bigger potatoes bigger tomatoes yeah

1390
01:25:36.183 --> 01:25:38.125
So that's like the fundamental concept.

1391
01:25:38.265 --> 01:25:39.466
And it's incredible.

1392
01:25:39.486 --> 01:25:40.607
I mean, apparently it's working.

1393
01:25:40.948 --> 01:25:44.631
But the way that they went about with the genetics, I just thought it would never work.

1394
01:25:44.832 --> 01:25:46.013
And it's fascinating.

1395
01:25:46.193 --> 01:25:46.393
Yeah.

1396
01:25:46.453 --> 01:25:47.134
It's a good thing.

1397
01:25:47.294 --> 01:25:47.594
You know.

1398
01:25:47.635 --> 01:25:48.415
Yeah, it is a good thing.

1399
01:25:48.495 --> 01:25:49.757
And I'd love to know.

1400
01:25:50.097 --> 01:25:57.905
I'd love to like one day when we get big enough, I'd love to I'd love to have the chief scientist of a hollow on and just ask him, like, how is this even possible?

1401
01:25:57.925 --> 01:25:58.145
Yeah.

1402
01:25:58.305 --> 01:26:10.651
If you are connected to the chief scientist at Ohalo and you are a fan of the pod and would like to send them a DM, we would love to dig into this because it's, I think, a really impactful concept.

1403
01:26:10.671 --> 01:26:11.752
Yeah, I think it's very cool.

1404
01:26:11.852 --> 01:26:13.413
And it's very cool technically.

1405
01:26:13.573 --> 01:26:14.013
Yeah.

1406
01:26:14.053 --> 01:26:15.334
So we'd love to connect.

1407
01:26:15.374 --> 01:26:17.575
However, for this story, that is not the focus.

1408
01:26:17.615 --> 01:26:18.255
That is not the focus.

1409
01:26:18.315 --> 01:26:23.018
I just wanted to because the aneuploidy reminded me of this multiple copies.

1410
01:26:23.298 --> 01:26:23.458
Totally.

1411
01:26:23.478 --> 01:26:26.720
So now let's get back into the genealogy of cancer.

1412
01:26:27.598 --> 01:26:29.640
Let's talk about something called the fitness landscape.

1413
01:26:29.680 --> 01:26:31.102
This is something that we've been alluding to.

1414
01:26:31.142 --> 01:26:33.384
You alluded to the gradient descent and things like that.

1415
01:26:34.265 --> 01:26:37.629
In 1932, there was this guy, Sewell Wright.

1416
01:26:38.069 --> 01:26:42.434
He came up with this analogy of how evolution happens.

1417
01:26:42.794 --> 01:26:45.777
What you can think about is a 2D landscape

1418
01:26:46.538 --> 01:26:48.061
that has hills and valleys, okay?

1419
01:26:48.362 --> 01:26:53.151
The axes in 2D, so the direction north-south, could be how much of gene A do I have?

1420
01:26:53.832 --> 01:26:56.737
East-west could be how much of gene B do I have, okay?

1421
01:26:56.978 --> 01:26:57.819
So every point...

1422
01:26:58.772 --> 01:27:03.995
is a location in genetic space where it's like I have this much of gene A, this much of gene B.

1423
01:27:04.476 --> 01:27:08.999
There would be hills, which is where you're more fit, so it's an advantage to be here.

1424
01:27:09.359 --> 01:27:11.380
And there's valleys where there's less fit, right?

1425
01:27:11.720 --> 01:27:13.081
And so you don't want to be in the valley.

1426
01:27:13.101 --> 01:27:14.122
You want to be towards the hill.

1427
01:27:14.842 --> 01:27:19.025
This is the fitness landscape analogy of evolution.

1428
01:27:19.545 --> 01:27:26.870
And physicists love this because everything is a potential energy landscape, and we're just looking at trying to get to the highest point.

1429
01:27:27.455 --> 01:27:29.958
Makes sense, and I just want to make sure I'm understanding this graphic.

1430
01:27:29.978 --> 01:27:41.651
So we're looking at basically sort of an XYZ plane, and we see gene A and gene B in the way that you just described, and then I guess the...

1431
01:27:42.732 --> 01:27:42.952
Height?

1432
01:27:43.112 --> 01:27:45.554
Yeah, the height is this population fitness.

1433
01:27:45.714 --> 01:27:45.934
Yeah.

1434
01:27:46.154 --> 01:27:52.818
And so the idea is the taller, like the hills are where it's highly fit, and the valleys are where it's lowly fit.

1435
01:27:52.839 --> 01:28:01.404
So it looks like if you've ever played, like, create a level in Fortnite or any video game, and you want to put, like, you can generate hills or mountains.

1436
01:28:01.584 --> 01:28:07.028
It kind of looks like that sort of imagery in terms of just what we're visualizing here.

1437
01:28:07.068 --> 01:28:10.210
Yeah, and if you want to be a sniper, you want to get to the highest elevation, right?

1438
01:28:11.210 --> 01:28:15.074
So here, if you're an organism, you want to get to the highest elevation on this fitness landscape.

1439
01:28:15.515 --> 01:28:17.296
Now, this is a nice metaphor.

1440
01:28:17.517 --> 01:28:19.839
And for the longest time, it was just a metaphor.

1441
01:28:20.500 --> 01:28:20.720
Okay.

1442
01:28:21.300 --> 01:28:28.007
What these guys have done with the Alpha K concept is operationalize that metaphor into something that's quantifiable.

1443
01:28:28.107 --> 01:28:28.387
Okay.

1444
01:28:28.407 --> 01:28:28.688
Okay.

1445
01:28:29.228 --> 01:28:34.971
Because what you can do is now make empirical fitness estimates based on data.

1446
01:28:35.531 --> 01:28:37.152
That is what this paper is doing.

1447
01:28:37.592 --> 01:28:46.997
It's taking that metaphor and it's saying, actually, this is a real thing that we can at least apply very quantitatively to the problem of aneuploidy.

1448
01:28:47.417 --> 01:28:50.159
Because aneuploidy, your axes...

1449
01:28:50.939 --> 01:28:52.099
Don't have to be genes.

1450
01:28:52.140 --> 01:28:55.021
They can be number of a certain chromosome.

1451
01:28:55.501 --> 01:28:59.422
You can have this axis be, I have one of chromosome one.

1452
01:28:59.522 --> 01:29:00.843
I have two of chromosome one.

1453
01:29:01.263 --> 01:29:02.883
Three, four, five copies.

1454
01:29:03.264 --> 01:29:04.184
Six copies, right?

1455
01:29:04.544 --> 01:29:05.464
That'll be one axis.

1456
01:29:05.544 --> 01:29:08.406
The other axis will be, how many of chromosome two do I have?

1457
01:29:08.766 --> 01:29:10.366
How many of chromosome three do I have?

1458
01:29:10.646 --> 01:29:11.387
The fourth axis.

1459
01:29:11.607 --> 01:29:15.388
And so you have 22 dimensions, each chromosome.

1460
01:29:15.948 --> 01:29:20.250
And the point where you are is how many copies of each chromosome you have.

1461
01:29:20.670 --> 01:29:33.344
So if you only had three chromosomes, let's say you were some organism, and you had three copies of one, two copies of number two, and four copies of number three, then my point on this axis would be three this way, two this way, four up.

1462
01:29:33.964 --> 01:29:34.625
That's where I am.

1463
01:29:34.925 --> 01:29:36.347
That's where this particular cell is.

1464
01:29:36.427 --> 01:29:36.607
Yes.

1465
01:29:36.828 --> 01:29:36.988
Right?

1466
01:29:37.188 --> 01:29:37.288
Yes.

1467
01:29:37.308 --> 01:29:40.051
So now we can create an actual quantitative chromosome.

1468
01:29:40.202 --> 01:29:40.703
landscape.

1469
01:29:41.544 --> 01:29:45.870
And we can measure at each point, what is the slope of this landscape?

1470
01:29:46.171 --> 01:29:51.659
Because we can track that cell at that particular point and ask which way did it go, right?

1471
01:29:51.939 --> 01:29:53.321
And we can reconstruct

1472
01:29:54.097 --> 01:29:55.378
The fitness landscape that way.

1473
01:29:56.038 --> 01:29:56.759
That's what they're doing.

1474
01:29:57.159 --> 01:30:02.122
Very quantitatively, they're like reconstructing this in a very real sense.

1475
01:30:02.162 --> 01:30:03.203
It's no longer a metaphor.

1476
01:30:03.863 --> 01:30:08.066
Initially, this concept was strictly meant as a mental model.

1477
01:30:08.126 --> 01:30:08.386
Yeah.

1478
01:30:08.926 --> 01:30:13.329
As a way to grok or to kind of imagine how this happens.

1479
01:30:13.729 --> 01:30:21.174
What we're saying is now scientists are actually taking real world data and creating a literal fitness landscape.

1480
01:30:21.194 --> 01:30:21.314
Yeah.

1481
01:30:21.694 --> 01:30:23.615
particularly in oncological studies.

1482
01:30:23.675 --> 01:30:24.356
Yes, yes.

1483
01:30:24.496 --> 01:30:29.318
And that's why it's called adaptive local fitness landscapes or aneuploid karyotypes.

1484
01:30:29.639 --> 01:30:31.880
They're literally making that fitness landscape.

1485
01:30:32.180 --> 01:30:35.702
And then from that construction, now we can tell which way is it going to go.

1486
01:30:35.742 --> 01:30:36.803
Is it going to go down the valley?

1487
01:30:36.823 --> 01:30:38.644
Is it going to go up this way to this peak?

1488
01:30:38.664 --> 01:30:40.165
Or is there another peak that's nearby?

1489
01:30:40.185 --> 01:30:41.886
These are the questions that they can answer.

1490
01:30:42.186 --> 01:30:43.867
This is not a trivial problem to do, right?

1491
01:30:44.127 --> 01:30:46.789
Because, and it really comes from technology.

1492
01:30:47.069 --> 01:30:50.791
So before we used to have the standard single cell sequencing, which,

1493
01:30:50.891 --> 01:30:59.655
where what we do something called MDA, what we would do is effectively have these polymerases, these DNA replicators.

1494
01:31:00.695 --> 01:31:04.817
They would exponentially amplify certain parts of DNA.

1495
01:31:05.397 --> 01:31:09.979
So if we wanted to sequence the DNA of a single gene, single cell, there's not a lot of DNA, right?

1496
01:31:10.259 --> 01:31:14.321
So in order to sequence, you need to amplify the amount of DNA so that then we can sequence it.

1497
01:31:15.141 --> 01:31:16.362
When you amplify things,

1498
01:31:17.443 --> 01:31:29.530
You could get exponential speed up on certain chromosomes, and then the protein that's doing the DNA replication maybe got to another chromosome a little bit later.

1499
01:31:29.890 --> 01:31:34.933
So there's not a lot of five because it started on five later, but on one it started right away.

1500
01:31:35.213 --> 01:31:38.855
And so one, there's like a thousand copies of one, but there's two copies of two.

1501
01:31:39.575 --> 01:31:42.879
That's not going to help for us, especially for aneuploidy, right?

1502
01:31:42.919 --> 01:31:46.403
If we've got like a thousand copies of gene one, which is on chromosome one.

1503
01:31:46.763 --> 01:31:53.751
Well, I don't know if that's because there's actually a thousand copies or if or if the guy just like started there first.

1504
01:31:53.911 --> 01:31:54.172
Right.

1505
01:31:54.192 --> 01:31:54.332
Right.

1506
01:31:55.502 --> 01:31:58.724
Instead, these guys used the DLP plus solution.

1507
01:31:59.024 --> 01:32:05.968
There was already a paper that was out that had direct library preparation of single cells.

1508
01:32:06.008 --> 01:32:11.772
What you're doing with DLP plus is you don't care about the sequences of the chromosomes.

1509
01:32:12.152 --> 01:32:14.093
You only care about the number, right?

1510
01:32:14.113 --> 01:32:16.174
Because that's what you want for this particular study.

1511
01:32:16.294 --> 01:32:16.454
Yes.

1512
01:32:16.775 --> 01:32:18.135
And so what you do here is you...

1513
01:32:19.974 --> 01:32:46.099
dilute your tissue so you've got the tissue with a bunch of cells you dilute it so that each drop that comes out of your pipette has a single cell in it you put each drop into a microfluidics like um array it's like a chip and you can now weigh each droplet to figure out how much of this chromosome is there how much of this because each combination is going to get you a unique weight right if i have like

1514
01:32:46.819 --> 01:32:50.560
Four one kilogram weights and two five kilogram weights, so on and so forth.

1515
01:32:50.600 --> 01:32:54.181
I can like figure out and back construct how much of each is there.

1516
01:32:54.601 --> 01:32:54.801
Right.

1517
01:32:55.782 --> 01:32:56.942
And that's what they used.

1518
01:32:56.962 --> 01:32:58.383
That's the data set that they used.

1519
01:32:58.663 --> 01:33:03.244
It was already there and they're actually using this data set to now create this data

1520
01:33:04.705 --> 01:33:05.947
22-dimensional space.

1521
01:33:06.167 --> 01:33:16.260
Because what they're doing there is it removes the distinguishing, the problem of how to distinguish because everything is sort of

1522
01:33:17.305 --> 01:33:19.667
universal, like it's like a clean base.

1523
01:33:19.707 --> 01:33:20.748
Yeah, it's a clean base.

1524
01:33:20.808 --> 01:33:21.588
It's like flat.

1525
01:33:21.788 --> 01:33:22.909
There's uniform coverage.

1526
01:33:22.949 --> 01:33:25.411
It's not like, oh, chromosome 1 got lucky.

1527
01:33:25.771 --> 01:33:30.295
It's kind of like, you know, when you want to just figure out how many pages there are in a book, right?

1528
01:33:30.815 --> 01:33:38.321
The MDA analogy would be you have a noisy photocopier that sometimes it'll copy a thousand pages

1529
01:33:38.561 --> 01:33:43.307
Copies of page one, two copies of page two, 5,000 copies of page three.

1530
01:33:43.647 --> 01:33:45.049
Fine, you'll get to read the book.

1531
01:33:45.129 --> 01:33:45.870
Yeah, but it's...

1532
01:33:46.070 --> 01:33:48.633
But I don't know if the original book had 1,000...

1533
01:33:48.753 --> 01:33:50.936
I don't know, you know, maybe the author was crazy.

1534
01:33:51.116 --> 01:33:51.336
Right.

1535
01:33:51.436 --> 01:33:51.636
But...

1536
01:33:52.500 --> 01:33:57.604
With DLP+, all you're doing is weighing the book and from that inferring how many pages it has.

1537
01:33:57.624 --> 01:33:59.205
Because the only thing you care about is the pages.

1538
01:33:59.305 --> 01:34:02.487
You don't want to read the book for this particular use case.

1539
01:34:02.587 --> 01:34:03.007
Understood.

1540
01:34:03.508 --> 01:34:06.610
You only care about the number of chromosomes that you've got.

1541
01:34:07.270 --> 01:34:13.154
And so from that discrete data point, now we've constructed this 22-dimensional space.

1542
01:34:13.474 --> 01:34:18.398
This is the original paper from 2021 in Nature that actually put out that...

1543
01:34:19.139 --> 01:34:19.860
Data library.

1544
01:34:19.900 --> 01:34:20.080
Yes.

1545
01:34:20.200 --> 01:34:22.021
And this is the data library that they're using.

1546
01:34:22.301 --> 01:34:27.365
So again, this goes back to what I always like to talk about is this science has this compounding effect.

1547
01:34:27.385 --> 01:34:27.606
Yes.

1548
01:34:27.886 --> 01:34:28.106
Yeah.

1549
01:34:28.306 --> 01:34:30.548
And, you know, new discoveries can enable others.

1550
01:34:30.588 --> 01:34:42.517
So basically what we're saying is there is a library that this DLP plus library that the Alpha K team was able to use to deal with this data.

1551
01:34:44.036 --> 01:34:50.081
problem of number of different, uh, expression, the note, the volume of expression.

1552
01:34:50.262 --> 01:34:50.402
Yeah.

1553
01:34:50.422 --> 01:34:51.823
That was not what they were measuring for.

1554
01:34:51.863 --> 01:34:59.149
They just needed a clean base in order to be able to look at, um, this specific issue as it relates to how cancer works.

1555
01:35:00.090 --> 01:35:08.997
Like how cancer is making these selections about number of chromosome types as a means to traverse this fitness landscape.

1556
01:35:09.017 --> 01:35:09.477
Exactly.

1557
01:35:09.757 --> 01:35:13.860
And now we can finally get into reconstructing the fitness landscape.

1558
01:35:13.960 --> 01:35:14.201
Right.

1559
01:35:14.421 --> 01:35:16.142
Because now we can follow single cells.

1560
01:35:16.542 --> 01:35:16.782
Right.

1561
01:35:16.842 --> 01:35:18.464
And we can ask, what are they doing?

1562
01:35:18.844 --> 01:35:19.104
Right.

1563
01:35:19.605 --> 01:35:19.825
Right.

1564
01:35:20.105 --> 01:35:20.345
Right.

1565
01:35:20.365 --> 01:35:22.747
How are they going about in this fitness landscape?

1566
01:35:23.027 --> 01:35:27.090
You can ask for a frequency change based on, you know, individual fitness.

1567
01:35:29.852 --> 01:35:32.393
of a particular cell at a certain point, right?

1568
01:35:32.654 --> 01:35:38.697
And from that infer, okay, this is actually a really steep slope because the cell is reproducing way faster.

1569
01:35:39.117 --> 01:35:40.958
That means that it's going up in fitness, right?

1570
01:35:41.058 --> 01:35:41.918
And so on and so forth.

1571
01:35:42.299 --> 01:35:45.100
So it's actually very, very cool to think about.

1572
01:35:46.141 --> 01:35:49.022
The other really cool technique that they used was something called Krigging.

1573
01:35:49.302 --> 01:35:50.143
Have you heard of Krigging?

1574
01:35:50.223 --> 01:35:50.383
No.

1575
01:35:50.683 --> 01:35:51.904
Yeah, I hadn't heard of it either.

1576
01:35:51.984 --> 01:35:54.485
It's called Gaussian process regeneration.

1577
01:35:54.865 --> 01:36:04.469
Effectively, you've got a bunch of points, and you ask, okay, how do I smoothly fit a bunch of Gaussian processes such that you can interpolate between these different points, okay?

1578
01:36:04.709 --> 01:36:09.531
So it's not just like standard interpolation where you just like add lines between points.

1579
01:36:09.831 --> 01:36:11.391
You want there to be some kind of flow.

1580
01:36:12.212 --> 01:36:19.495
This was originally found because they were looking for how to infer where the gold was,

1581
01:36:20.435 --> 01:36:21.717
In a South African mine.

1582
01:36:21.837 --> 01:36:22.217
Of course.

1583
01:36:22.438 --> 01:36:22.738
Okay.

1584
01:36:23.078 --> 01:36:24.520
Of course.

1585
01:36:24.600 --> 01:36:34.152
They drilled boreholes everywhere, and they found the amount of gold in each borehole, and then they figured, okay, a gold line is going to be kind of a Gaussian sort of smooth thing.

1586
01:36:34.432 --> 01:36:38.717
So if I have data here, how do I infer where the gold is in between?

1587
01:36:38.737 --> 01:36:39.158
Mm-hmm.

1588
01:36:39.638 --> 01:36:43.983
And that's what it was originally used for, but now people are using it on all sorts of stuff.

1589
01:36:44.163 --> 01:36:45.464
It's used in finance a lot, too.

1590
01:36:45.745 --> 01:36:49.629
But in this case, for cancer research, which I thought was very cool.

1591
01:36:49.689 --> 01:36:51.290
That is interesting.

1592
01:36:51.631 --> 01:36:51.851
So...

1593
01:36:53.380 --> 01:36:55.382
Now we've got to prove that this map is real, right?

1594
01:36:55.422 --> 01:36:56.603
We've constructed this map.

1595
01:36:56.984 --> 01:36:57.184
Right.

1596
01:36:57.464 --> 01:37:00.987
We understand how we were able to generate this fitness landscape.

1597
01:37:01.748 --> 01:37:03.350
And now, okay, great.

1598
01:37:03.370 --> 01:37:04.010
That's cool.

1599
01:37:04.091 --> 01:37:04.971
Nice diagram.

1600
01:37:05.011 --> 01:37:05.932
Yeah, nice diagram.

1601
01:37:05.952 --> 01:37:07.694
Nice, like, 22-dimensional space.

1602
01:37:08.255 --> 01:37:09.556
Can you actually predict stuff?

1603
01:37:09.776 --> 01:37:09.956
Yes.

1604
01:37:09.976 --> 01:37:10.216
Okay.

1605
01:37:10.597 --> 01:37:12.618
They did in silico validation.

1606
01:37:12.638 --> 01:37:16.200
So they made agent-based models where they simulate sort of cancer.

1607
01:37:16.661 --> 01:37:18.322
And they saw that the cancer was great.

1608
01:37:18.362 --> 01:37:19.563
But again, that's simulation.

1609
01:37:19.603 --> 01:37:20.123
Yeah, it's not real.

1610
01:37:20.143 --> 01:37:22.244
It's not going to get you a paper in Nature Communications.

1611
01:37:22.264 --> 01:37:22.525
Okay.

1612
01:37:22.685 --> 01:37:22.925
Okay.

1613
01:37:23.125 --> 01:37:25.787
You've got to have some experimental data to back it up.

1614
01:37:26.047 --> 01:37:28.188
So what they did was something called sister passages.

1615
01:37:28.549 --> 01:37:30.990
What you do is you've got a cancer tissue.

1616
01:37:31.271 --> 01:37:31.451
Yeah.

1617
01:37:31.511 --> 01:37:32.632
You split that up into two.

1618
01:37:33.452 --> 01:37:34.453
You sequence one of them.

1619
01:37:35.453 --> 01:37:35.674
And...

1620
01:37:36.462 --> 01:37:39.925
You train your model or you parametrize your model that way.

1621
01:37:40.245 --> 01:37:43.527
And then you ask the model, okay, now try and predict where the cancer is going to go.

1622
01:37:43.888 --> 01:37:48.771
And you follow that second sister cells to see how it would move.

1623
01:37:50.293 --> 01:37:51.373
And it's tracking.

1624
01:37:51.594 --> 01:37:52.474
I'm so mad.

1625
01:37:52.614 --> 01:37:52.815
Right?

1626
01:37:53.795 --> 01:37:54.836
That's kind of nice.

1627
01:37:54.916 --> 01:37:56.036
This is really good.

1628
01:37:56.577 --> 01:37:57.537
This is really good.

1629
01:37:57.577 --> 01:38:07.603
The point is we created a map, a 22-dimensional space map of a fitness landscape using that library that was created in that previous nature paper in I think it was 2021.

1630
01:38:07.803 --> 01:38:08.003
Yeah.

1631
01:38:08.323 --> 01:38:13.926
And the idea was this used to be this theoretical concept that's actually literal.

1632
01:38:14.026 --> 01:38:14.646
Yeah.

1633
01:38:14.867 --> 01:38:16.267
Like it translates literally.

1634
01:38:16.548 --> 01:38:20.570
We created our Google Maps of cancer, and we took...

1635
01:38:22.832 --> 01:38:47.692
one cancer cell we split into two we create generated the map based off one and then the real world other ones traversed what the map said it would traverse yep meaning that that fitness landscape is literal yeah and it's like literal yeah yeah yeah like there is a fitness landscape and these guys are following it right um in chemotherapy this this works out really well so um cisplatin which is a type of chemotherapy

1636
01:38:48.943 --> 01:38:52.326
One could ask, well, you've made a fitness landscape now.

1637
01:38:53.087 --> 01:38:56.830
Suppose I introduce a stress like Cisplatin.

1638
01:38:57.191 --> 01:38:59.293
That's going to completely change the fitness landscape.

1639
01:38:59.333 --> 01:38:59.633
Right.

1640
01:38:59.733 --> 01:38:59.933
Right.

1641
01:39:00.113 --> 01:39:02.996
It's going to be now dynamic because certain hills are going to become valleys.

1642
01:39:03.016 --> 01:39:03.256
Yes.

1643
01:39:03.377 --> 01:39:04.217
And so on and so forth.

1644
01:39:04.237 --> 01:39:04.478
Yes.

1645
01:39:04.498 --> 01:39:04.798
Yes.

1646
01:39:05.038 --> 01:39:08.959
Can you predict there?

1647
01:39:09.259 --> 01:39:10.119
And they could.

1648
01:39:10.479 --> 01:39:12.400
They could show that there was an increased variance.

1649
01:39:12.440 --> 01:39:19.561
And this actually is in support of something called punctuated equilibrium, which is a model of evolution that is not gradualism.

1650
01:39:19.881 --> 01:39:23.422
In gradualism, you get changes very gradually over time.

1651
01:39:23.842 --> 01:39:25.763
Punctuated equilibrium is there is a stress.

1652
01:39:26.083 --> 01:39:29.964
That stress leads to bifurcations in your tree of life.

1653
01:39:35.105 --> 01:39:36.846
Species and cell lines and so forth.

1654
01:39:36.866 --> 01:39:40.108
Basically almost not instantaneously in a literal sense.

1655
01:39:40.128 --> 01:39:41.349
Yeah, but short time scale.

1656
01:39:41.369 --> 01:39:42.229
In a short time scale.

1657
01:39:42.329 --> 01:39:42.950
Short time scale.

1658
01:39:42.970 --> 01:39:44.771
And this actually shows the cancer...

1659
01:39:45.606 --> 01:39:48.047
is very much a punctuated equilibrium process, right?

1660
01:39:48.307 --> 01:39:55.150
The therapy actually sharpens the selection gradients, so certain fitness hills become even more steep.

1661
01:39:55.330 --> 01:39:59.392
Some totally get squashed, and so on and so forth.

1662
01:39:59.412 --> 01:40:00.972
Which tracks, like, conceptually.

1663
01:40:00.992 --> 01:40:03.653
Like, if you were to think about, like, why is cancer so hard to defeat?

1664
01:40:03.733 --> 01:40:04.754
Like, it moves so fast.

1665
01:40:05.054 --> 01:40:07.215
It would make sense that this punctuated equilibrium is...

1666
01:40:08.019 --> 01:40:08.860
is what's happening.

1667
01:40:09.140 --> 01:40:16.825
And it's cool to see that you can actually measure, get measurements that, you know, that point to that being the case.

1668
01:40:16.865 --> 01:40:17.325
Exactly.

1669
01:40:17.585 --> 01:40:23.609
And one thing that one can think about is like, so why would cancer cells do this?

1670
01:40:23.689 --> 01:40:26.291
Where you have this whole genome doubling sometimes where...

1671
01:40:27.051 --> 01:40:31.875
you know, kind of like in a hollow, all of your chromosomes have now four copies instead of two.

1672
01:40:32.176 --> 01:40:32.396
Okay.

1673
01:40:32.696 --> 01:40:33.437
Why would you do this?

1674
01:40:33.477 --> 01:40:37.561
Well, what this does is create a flat fitness landscape.

1675
01:40:37.901 --> 01:40:52.514
And so you have something called survival of the flattest where imagine right before, if there's a really thin peak, your organisms will want to stay near that really thin peak because that thin peak is really, really tall.

1676
01:40:53.075 --> 01:40:53.215
But

1677
01:40:54.132 --> 01:41:02.634
With cancer, because you're throwing so much at them, you kind of want to be in a flat hill rather than a thin peak.

1678
01:41:02.674 --> 01:41:06.655
Because in a thin peak, if you go off by a little bit, it's like El Cap, right?

1679
01:41:06.795 --> 01:41:08.676
In Yosemite, you're just going to fall.

1680
01:41:08.756 --> 01:41:15.618
But if you've got a sort of nice Kilimanjaro-like hill, then even if you stray a lot...

1681
01:41:16.400 --> 01:41:20.662
in your landscape, you're still going to be able to be doing just fine in terms of fitness.

1682
01:41:21.222 --> 01:41:32.828
And you can literally see that with this kind of trade-off, the tumor shifts from this sharp peak, high fitness, low tolerance to flat peaks, right?

1683
01:41:33.068 --> 01:41:40.992
And the clinical relevance is if you've got instability and that instability pushes you past some kind of error threshold, then the

1684
01:41:41.824 --> 01:41:47.371
your population is going to collapse onto flatter peaks and not stay on that thinner peak.

1685
01:41:47.411 --> 01:41:55.320
So then you're going to have a harder time maybe because at the flatter peak, there's a lot of different stuff that cancer can explore and still be just fine.

1686
01:41:56.762 --> 01:41:58.924
The, the, the point being, you know,

1687
01:41:59.445 --> 01:42:07.108
you don't want to basically give an evolutionary advantage unnecessarily by how you're targeting your therapeutics and stuff like that.

1688
01:42:07.448 --> 01:42:26.036
And so if you can say, hey, we know if we sort of attack this in a particular way, it's actually going to spread the evolutionary optionality that the cancer cells have across a wider surface area, which is then going to actually make it subsequently more difficult to deal with.

1689
01:42:26.056 --> 01:42:26.176
Yeah.

1690
01:42:26.176 --> 01:42:26.756
Yeah.

1691
01:42:49.867 --> 01:42:54.569
Traditional theory says that I can't get to the neighboring peak because I'd have to go through the valley.

1692
01:42:54.989 --> 01:43:03.792
But now with this Alpha K, we can actually, it's kind of like providing a navigational chart to steer and predict how it goes from one to the next.

1693
01:43:04.172 --> 01:43:07.573
How it could go from one peak to the other without going through the valley.

1694
01:43:08.093 --> 01:43:08.293
Right.

1695
01:43:08.313 --> 01:43:08.433
Right.

1696
01:43:08.453 --> 01:43:09.674
Because it's basically this map.

1697
01:43:09.734 --> 01:43:09.994
Yeah.

1698
01:43:10.134 --> 01:43:10.254
Yeah.

1699
01:43:10.294 --> 01:43:10.414
Right.

1700
01:43:10.634 --> 01:43:13.895
And so we know all the routes between two different points on said map.

1701
01:43:14.556 --> 01:43:15.596
And so we, that's fantastic.

1702
01:43:16.116 --> 01:43:35.687
so good and it's it's really cool i mean it just shows this very quantitative physics-based approach yes so now i'm like going up on a fitness landscape yes i can sequence not sequence but i can tell how much of a particular chromosome i have in certain cells and from that create this map of karyotypes right and create okay

1703
01:43:36.760 --> 01:43:38.161
How much of cell one do I need?

1704
01:43:38.342 --> 01:43:39.723
It can depend on my past.

1705
01:43:40.203 --> 01:43:45.208
It can depend on all the other contexts that I have because this model can build that in.

1706
01:43:45.809 --> 01:43:46.710
It's very cool.

1707
01:43:46.750 --> 01:43:52.055
And the computational cost is, you know, it's right now it's 22 dimensions.

1708
01:43:52.575 --> 01:43:53.796
So it is pretty expensive.

1709
01:43:54.657 --> 01:43:57.200
But it's better than doing the sister...

1710
01:43:59.590 --> 01:44:05.700
the sister cell treatment, which is what we used to do, where you take a little bit of the cancer cell and you see how it evolves in a test tube.

1711
01:44:06.180 --> 01:44:07.943
I mean, here you can just plug it into a computer.

1712
01:44:07.983 --> 01:44:08.745
Right, right, right.

1713
01:44:08.805 --> 01:44:09.766
Which, you know...

1714
01:44:10.918 --> 01:44:15.180
One, while it may be expensive now, it's the first formulation of the concept.

1715
01:44:15.220 --> 01:44:23.864
You can, in theory, create other flavors that choose for different levels of dimensional precision as one key aspect.

1716
01:44:23.884 --> 01:44:30.387
But two, it's all simulation, so you don't have the physical lab-related costs associated with it.

1717
01:44:30.867 --> 01:44:32.448
This is very, very good stuff.

1718
01:44:32.488 --> 01:44:33.509
Yeah, I thought it was very cool.

1719
01:44:33.589 --> 01:44:35.870
And, you know, this one is doing it for...

1720
01:44:36.790 --> 01:44:38.872
aneuploidy, which is number of chromosomes.

1721
01:44:38.892 --> 01:44:46.877
But now you can think about creating, you know, you can think about creating landscapes for actual within a chromosome.

1722
01:44:47.157 --> 01:44:48.398
How much of gene one do I have?

1723
01:44:48.438 --> 01:44:49.659
How much of gene two do I have?

1724
01:44:49.859 --> 01:44:54.102
In a transcriptome, how much of mRNA for this particular gene do I have?

1725
01:44:54.563 --> 01:44:59.006
You know, it's like really taking that fitness landscape and being like, no, we can actually just treat it as real.

1726
01:44:59.266 --> 01:44:59.486
Right.

1727
01:44:59.926 --> 01:45:03.249
And then you can apply that to more than just the aneuploidy for cancer.

1728
01:45:03.269 --> 01:45:04.870
I mean, it can be applied in...

1729
01:45:05.410 --> 01:45:06.231
across the board.

1730
01:45:06.311 --> 01:45:06.511
Right.

1731
01:45:06.531 --> 01:45:10.795
And I can now forecast what the cancer would do if I give it this treatment.

1732
01:45:11.315 --> 01:45:12.496
This is very, very good.

1733
01:45:12.576 --> 01:45:18.721
I mean, you know, obviously cancer treatment, we've talked about a lot of different type of cancer related research stories.

1734
01:45:19.322 --> 01:45:22.424
And, you know, one of the, there's so many challenges that are involved in it.

1735
01:45:22.445 --> 01:45:26.888
Like there's, it's like a multi combinatorial mass of stuff.

1736
01:45:27.148 --> 01:45:27.789
Yeah.

1737
01:45:28.189 --> 01:45:32.453
But one of the things that's been so interesting is our tools to look at

1738
01:45:32.984 --> 01:45:44.175
measure and or understand what is literally happening have, have been accelerating because we kind of right now have like more of a shotgun approach for therapeutics versus a sniper approach.

1739
01:45:44.195 --> 01:45:48.559
Obviously there's some cases that are getting more close to a sniper approach.

1740
01:45:49.000 --> 01:45:54.625
But like chemo is obviously very destructive to all the cell, like all the cells, which we actually discussed in a previous episode.

1741
01:45:54.645 --> 01:45:55.967
So why that's the case is,

1742
01:45:56.687 --> 01:46:01.050
Um, so stuff like this is really, really impactful for oncology generally.

1743
01:46:01.791 --> 01:46:04.032
Um, which is fascinating.

1744
01:46:04.052 --> 01:46:09.236
I mean, my, my mom works in clinical trials and they've, you know, historically they've looked at a whole variety of things.

1745
01:46:09.296 --> 01:46:15.560
Obviously a lot of big pharmaceuticals are trying to go to big ticket things that have huge market value.

1746
01:46:15.901 --> 01:46:17.962
And obviously oncology is a huge one, huge one.

1747
01:46:18.302 --> 01:46:18.523
Um, yeah.

1748
01:46:19.383 --> 01:46:21.564
And so really great stories.

1749
01:46:21.884 --> 01:46:24.105
Nice spectrum that we covered.

1750
01:46:24.685 --> 01:46:33.048
We started with botany, one of our first plant stories about alkaloid biosynthesis.

1751
01:46:33.909 --> 01:46:37.450
And that small factory we're now able to replicate in yeast.

1752
01:46:37.790 --> 01:46:44.213
And the new phytologist that was from York, University of York in the UK.

1753
01:46:44.233 --> 01:46:44.453
Yeah.

1754
01:46:45.713 --> 01:46:49.876
We had a great rundown with a bunch of different variety of different pieces.

1755
01:46:50.456 --> 01:46:52.797
The quantum entanglement story was fantastic.

1756
01:46:53.838 --> 01:46:58.160
That one at the University of Basel and Sorbonne.

1757
01:46:58.441 --> 01:46:59.721
Very, very interesting.

1758
01:47:00.282 --> 01:47:01.482
Again, measurement precision.

1759
01:47:01.802 --> 01:47:04.344
Talking about my favorite, the Heisenberg uncertainty principle.

1760
01:47:04.664 --> 01:47:08.126
We now can sort of not break the concept.

1761
01:47:08.146 --> 01:47:08.606
No, we're not.

1762
01:47:08.626 --> 01:47:08.927
We're not.

1763
01:47:08.947 --> 01:47:10.968
We're not doing anything when it's not magic.

1764
01:47:11.008 --> 01:47:11.248
Yeah.

1765
01:47:11.488 --> 01:47:15.170
But it's clever creativity for how to work around those limitations.

1766
01:47:15.750 --> 01:47:29.978
And we ended with this Alpha K local adaptive mapping, which again, I now have a way to grok this concept because we've talked about concepts like gradient descent in the past, like with a lot of the foundation and frontier models.

1767
01:47:30.338 --> 01:47:31.939
That's how these things work.

1768
01:47:31.959 --> 01:47:36.642
They're traversing these high multidimensional spaces.

1769
01:47:37.502 --> 01:47:39.022
And so all very, very good stuff.

1770
01:47:40.423 --> 01:47:46.384
I just, the only thing that I think we forgot this episode was what people should comment.

1771
01:47:46.724 --> 01:47:47.104
Oh, yeah.

1772
01:47:47.704 --> 01:47:48.824
We didn't come up with a good one yet.

1773
01:47:49.104 --> 01:47:50.505
So we're going to do this on the fly.

1774
01:47:50.525 --> 01:47:54.365
How about Alpha K, alternative?

1775
01:47:54.806 --> 01:47:55.326
Alternative.

1776
01:47:56.886 --> 01:48:02.507
Alternative full forms of the acronym Alpha K, which is not Alpha like the Alpha particle or Alpha Greek.

1777
01:48:02.547 --> 01:48:04.047
It's A-L-F-A-K.

1778
01:48:04.308 --> 01:48:04.588
Yes.

1779
01:48:04.748 --> 01:48:04.968
Yes.

1780
01:48:05.728 --> 01:48:05.928
Yes.

1781
01:48:06.748 --> 01:48:07.289
That's a good one.

1782
01:48:07.409 --> 01:48:10.852
Yeah, let's see what people come up with, because we do have some comedians.

1783
01:48:10.912 --> 01:48:14.216
We did see a lot of good responses to LBF from last episode.

1784
01:48:14.716 --> 01:48:16.198
The Freedom one was the best.

1785
01:48:16.298 --> 01:48:16.998
Pound Force.

1786
01:48:17.239 --> 01:48:18.139
Yeah.

1787
01:48:18.240 --> 01:48:23.284
Pound Force is the correct one, but Pounds Per Freedom, I think, we're good.

1788
01:48:23.465 --> 01:48:28.089
And yes, the Imperial system versus metric system is...

1789
01:48:29.110 --> 01:48:46.278
has has its issues um my name is lester nare joined as always by my co-host and our resident phd and all-around science genius krishna chowdhury this is from first principles
