WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.171 --> 00:00:02.813
Hello Internet, this is your captain speaking, Lester Nare.

2
00:00:02.914 --> 00:00:07.398
I'm joined by my co-host and our resident PhD, Dr. Krishna Chowdhury.

3
00:00:07.698 --> 00:00:09.259
This is From First Principles.

4
00:00:09.559 --> 00:00:11.101
We have a great episode this week.

5
00:00:11.501 --> 00:00:15.144
We are going to touch on first, Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice.

6
00:00:15.865 --> 00:00:18.127
Found a companion, but this is not Love Island.

7
00:00:18.548 --> 00:00:21.631
A great story about a stellar companionship.

8
00:00:22.211 --> 00:00:25.975
Second story, atom scale images of atoms vibrating.

9
00:00:26.215 --> 00:00:27.897
We've seen atoms doing the Harlem shake.

10
00:00:28.378 --> 00:00:28.998
What does it mean?

11
00:00:29.018 --> 00:00:30.079
What are the implications?

12
00:00:30.560 --> 00:00:33.202
Story number three, high energy cosmic rays.

13
00:00:33.523 --> 00:00:36.225
We're talking too fast and too furious.

14
00:00:37.006 --> 00:00:40.208
Fourth story, navigating the stars using a camera.

15
00:00:40.228 --> 00:00:43.551
We've figured out an interstellar Google Maps, or have we?

16
00:00:44.011 --> 00:00:49.134
And lastly, we'll end with our mystery box, which is Krishna's story of the day.

17
00:00:49.154 --> 00:00:49.755
How are you, good sir?

18
00:00:50.216 --> 00:00:50.897
I'm doing well.

19
00:00:52.017 --> 00:00:52.818
Second episode.

20
00:00:52.898 --> 00:00:54.039
I'm very excited about this.

21
00:00:54.259 --> 00:00:54.459
Yeah.

22
00:00:54.559 --> 00:00:55.219
First one went well.

23
00:00:55.460 --> 00:00:56.080
First one went well.

24
00:00:56.100 --> 00:00:56.981
Maybe we'll do a third one.

25
00:00:57.021 --> 00:00:57.241
Yeah.

26
00:00:58.041 --> 00:00:58.261
Yeah.

27
00:00:58.742 --> 00:01:00.343
So we'll start with our first story.

28
00:01:01.664 --> 00:01:03.725
Interestingly, it got all the way to CNN.

29
00:01:04.966 --> 00:01:05.246
Yes.

30
00:01:05.466 --> 00:01:07.488
Which is usually when news gets there.

31
00:01:07.988 --> 00:01:09.369
It's a little bit dicey.

32
00:01:09.389 --> 00:01:10.230
This one's not fake.

33
00:01:10.490 --> 00:01:10.770
Okay.

34
00:01:11.370 --> 00:01:11.590
Okay.

35
00:01:11.610 --> 00:01:12.511
This one is not fake.

36
00:01:13.031 --> 00:01:17.494
So the title on the story is Beetlejuice, one of the most familiar stars in the sky.

37
00:01:17.534 --> 00:01:17.634
Yes.

38
00:01:18.595 --> 00:01:22.237
may have a hidden companion star orbiting it.

39
00:01:22.618 --> 00:01:34.945
Astronomers have observed what they believe to be a never-before-seen companion star orbiting Betelgeuse, a pulsating red supergiant star in the shoulder of the Orion constellation.

40
00:01:35.026 --> 00:01:36.246
That's right.

41
00:01:36.506 --> 00:01:38.968
What exactly is happening here?

42
00:01:40.029 --> 00:01:40.989
Why does it matter?

43
00:01:41.750 --> 00:01:43.691
And does the galaxy lie on Orion's belt?

44
00:01:44.607 --> 00:01:46.868
The galaxy is not on Orion's belt.

45
00:01:47.148 --> 00:01:52.231
Orion's belt is actually just in the galaxy itself, so it's the other way around.

46
00:01:53.531 --> 00:01:59.334
Beetlejuice is just one of my favorite stars, and so whenever anything happens with Beetlejuice, I get very excited.

47
00:02:00.514 --> 00:02:08.038
This might not matter in the grand scheme of things to human beings, but I still think it's an extremely cool...

48
00:02:08.798 --> 00:02:12.562
observation that we've made about my favorite star.

49
00:02:13.322 --> 00:02:14.083
So, you know what?

50
00:02:14.243 --> 00:02:14.483
Tough.

51
00:02:14.543 --> 00:02:16.145
If you guys don't like Beetlejuice, whatever.

52
00:02:17.086 --> 00:02:20.429
Just go see Orion, and you'll see him on the top right shoulder.

53
00:02:20.949 --> 00:02:22.851
So Beetlejuice makes up the top right shoulder.

54
00:02:23.271 --> 00:02:24.132
It's unmistakable.

55
00:02:24.252 --> 00:02:24.853
It's red.

56
00:02:25.974 --> 00:02:28.756
It looks like Mars except it's blinking, so you know it's a star.

57
00:02:29.236 --> 00:02:34.561
Mars is about the same brightness, but it doesn't blink because it's closer to Earth, so it's a little bit bigger.

58
00:02:34.901 --> 00:02:42.087
Mars is kind of like a circle, whereas Betelgeuse is 700 light years away, so it's literally a point, and so it twinkles a little bit.

59
00:02:42.147 --> 00:02:45.430
That's a nice little short drive through the interstellar.

60
00:02:45.490 --> 00:02:46.911
Honestly, it's not that far.

61
00:02:46.951 --> 00:02:49.233
700 light years in the grand scheme of things is not that far.

62
00:02:49.273 --> 00:02:50.494
It's actually the closest...

63
00:02:51.074 --> 00:03:13.802
red supergiant to earth so when you say supergiant is it it's it's a star it's a star so a lot of people will think oh it's like a bigger jupiter but that's not true no no this thing is it's nice that you mentioned jupiter so this star is so big that if you were to put it where the sun is it would be as big as jupiter's orbit

64
00:03:15.040 --> 00:03:15.761
Oh, wow.

65
00:03:16.242 --> 00:03:16.483
Yes.

66
00:03:16.844 --> 00:03:19.630
So it would be like this all the way past the asteroid.

67
00:03:19.790 --> 00:03:21.575
Yeah, it would swallow Jupiter.

68
00:03:23.027 --> 00:03:24.368
Now you see why it's my favorite star.

69
00:03:24.408 --> 00:03:25.809
It's like it's an amazing star.

70
00:03:25.829 --> 00:03:27.109
It's this red supergiant.

71
00:03:27.470 --> 00:03:29.171
This thing's only 10 million years old.

72
00:03:29.511 --> 00:03:29.751
Okay.

73
00:03:29.891 --> 00:03:30.131
Okay.

74
00:03:30.431 --> 00:03:33.373
So it's like the sun is 5 billion years old.

75
00:03:33.393 --> 00:03:33.713
Okay.

76
00:03:34.214 --> 00:03:37.936
And the sun is going to become a red giant, but not a supergiant.

77
00:03:38.056 --> 00:03:39.177
Oh, so this is it's...

78
00:03:39.437 --> 00:03:40.337
This is it's dying.

79
00:03:40.457 --> 00:03:41.058
It's on the path.

80
00:03:41.078 --> 00:03:41.778
This thing is dying.

81
00:03:41.878 --> 00:03:49.443
It used to be a blue massive star, and then it ran out of oxygen because one of the cool things about stars is like the bigger you are...

82
00:03:50.063 --> 00:03:51.525
the shorter your lifespan.

83
00:03:51.885 --> 00:03:54.627
It's kind of like you party too hard and then you're just like fucked.

84
00:03:54.927 --> 00:03:55.147
Yeah.

85
00:03:55.168 --> 00:03:55.408
Right.

86
00:03:55.468 --> 00:03:56.288
Live free and die hard.

87
00:03:56.389 --> 00:03:57.249
Yes, exactly.

88
00:03:57.329 --> 00:03:57.489
Yep.

89
00:03:57.850 --> 00:03:58.550
Stars do that.

90
00:03:59.491 --> 00:04:00.072
Exactly.

91
00:04:00.412 --> 00:04:04.855
Like the bigger you are, the faster you deplete the hydrogen that gives you life.

92
00:04:04.875 --> 00:04:05.056
Right.

93
00:04:05.136 --> 00:04:05.916
That gives you life.

94
00:04:05.976 --> 00:04:07.938
And then now you ran out of hydrogen.

95
00:04:07.958 --> 00:04:09.539
Now you got to start burning, burning helium.

96
00:04:09.820 --> 00:04:12.582
Once you run out of helium, now you got to start burning carbon and nitrogen.

97
00:04:12.602 --> 00:04:12.762
Yeah.

98
00:04:13.002 --> 00:04:17.643
Once you start running out of that, you swell up and then, you know, things are bad.

99
00:04:17.983 --> 00:04:26.444
So this is this this thing is in its last legs, but it's this massive star 700 light years away, 700 times the radius of the sun.

100
00:04:28.805 --> 00:04:31.785
And it's it does a lot of really cool things.

101
00:04:31.965 --> 00:04:37.186
OK, one of the cool things it does is every like I think it's every 400 days.

102
00:04:37.606 --> 00:04:41.187
It has a cycle where it like dims and it gets brighter and it dims and it gets brighter.

103
00:04:41.547 --> 00:04:42.247
Now, that's OK.

104
00:04:42.508 --> 00:04:45.269
That's pretty close to the Earth's cycle.

105
00:04:45.709 --> 00:04:46.690
Yeah, it is.

106
00:04:46.730 --> 00:04:47.150
365, 400.

107
00:04:47.190 --> 00:04:47.570
Yeah, 365, 400.

108
00:04:47.590 --> 00:04:48.610
Yeah, right?

109
00:04:48.911 --> 00:04:49.871
It dims, it gets brighter.

110
00:04:50.411 --> 00:04:53.172
That's like okay for red supergiants because things do that.

111
00:04:53.272 --> 00:04:53.552
Okay?

112
00:04:53.672 --> 00:04:54.713
A lot of these stars do that.

113
00:04:54.813 --> 00:04:55.333
Okay.

114
00:04:55.433 --> 00:04:58.454
If you look at other red supergiants that are farther away, they'll do the same thing.

115
00:04:58.694 --> 00:05:00.195
So they don't stay at the static...

116
00:05:00.855 --> 00:05:02.376
No, they're called variable stars.

117
00:05:02.476 --> 00:05:15.485
And they're actually very important for like, that's actually super important for like fundamental science reasons, because that tells us how far stuff is by looking at the frequency of this, it tells us how bright they really are.

118
00:05:15.505 --> 00:05:21.028
And then you can tell, okay, well, I know how bright it really is, because it's oscillating at this frequency.

119
00:05:21.409 --> 00:05:23.550
But I see it as this bright.

120
00:05:24.070 --> 00:05:26.812
So why is why is it this bright when it should be this bright?

121
00:05:26.852 --> 00:05:28.053
Oh, it's because it's this far away.

122
00:05:28.293 --> 00:05:29.794
And you can tell the distance to stars.

123
00:05:30.094 --> 00:05:35.218
So variable stars are extremely important for fundamental science in terms of like calibrating that.

124
00:05:35.338 --> 00:05:39.901
Edwin Hubble did the first kind of survey of that out in Mount Hubble.

125
00:05:40.261 --> 00:05:40.702
Oh, yeah.

126
00:05:40.742 --> 00:05:41.462
Not Mount Hubble.

127
00:05:42.063 --> 00:05:44.424
Mount Wilson, right in the outskirts of L.A.

128
00:05:44.504 --> 00:05:52.470
This is the same thing you were telling me about the other day, I think, with like how we use quasars for time and for navigation, like because they're so consistent.

129
00:05:52.670 --> 00:06:01.092
Yeah, because they're so far away and so consistent, you can use them to chart like a 360-degree rotation of the Earth.

130
00:06:01.512 --> 00:06:09.855
In this case, it's like because these guys are so consistent in the way that they vibrate and how bright they are, we can use them to chart distances as we go out.

131
00:06:09.935 --> 00:06:10.555
That makes sense.

132
00:06:10.955 --> 00:06:11.135
Yeah.

133
00:06:11.375 --> 00:06:13.396
Anyway, so 400 days, it does this cycle.

134
00:06:13.416 --> 00:06:13.836
That's fine.

135
00:06:13.976 --> 00:06:14.136
Yep.

136
00:06:14.896 --> 00:06:17.358
But every six years, it does another cycle.

137
00:06:17.758 --> 00:06:19.660
So there's like a 400-day cycle.

138
00:06:20.000 --> 00:06:23.203
And on top of that, there's this slower six-year cycle.

139
00:06:23.243 --> 00:06:24.123
You see what I'm saying?

140
00:06:24.143 --> 00:06:28.607
There's like a slower oscillation on top of this faster oscillation.

141
00:06:28.667 --> 00:06:30.328
And that slower oscillation is six years.

142
00:06:30.388 --> 00:06:31.149
And that one's weird.

143
00:06:31.609 --> 00:06:31.829
Okay.

144
00:06:31.849 --> 00:06:32.069
Okay.

145
00:06:32.490 --> 00:06:34.471
So people thought, okay, that's weird.

146
00:06:34.511 --> 00:06:35.732
Six years is kind of long.

147
00:06:36.733 --> 00:06:40.216
They thought that maybe there's another star that is wobbling it.

148
00:06:41.197 --> 00:06:43.519
That would be impacting.

149
00:06:43.899 --> 00:06:45.701
That would be orbiting it every six years.

150
00:06:45.721 --> 00:06:45.961
Yep.

151
00:06:46.182 --> 00:06:46.422
Okay.

152
00:06:46.802 --> 00:06:50.405
But it's been incredibly hard to see because Betelgeuse is so massive.

153
00:06:51.046 --> 00:06:51.226
Right?

154
00:06:51.266 --> 00:06:52.767
It's the size of Jupiter's orbit.

155
00:06:53.608 --> 00:06:56.610
So like it's like it's like to try and image the other star.

156
00:06:57.030 --> 00:07:04.454
It's like you got you got this one dancing partner that's like outshining you in every form of the word.

157
00:07:04.474 --> 00:07:07.696
This is like I don't think people understand the scale of what you're talking about.

158
00:07:07.716 --> 00:07:07.936
Yeah.

159
00:07:08.076 --> 00:07:11.378
Like this thing is so incredibly large.

160
00:07:12.732 --> 00:07:13.313
I can't.

161
00:07:13.413 --> 00:07:13.914
It's hard to.

162
00:07:13.954 --> 00:07:15.115
Yeah, it's hard to even.

163
00:07:15.395 --> 00:07:19.280
It's so incredibly large and so incredibly bright because it's large.

164
00:07:19.420 --> 00:07:19.620
Right.

165
00:07:19.740 --> 00:07:19.960
Right.

166
00:07:20.161 --> 00:07:23.244
Like when we point a telescope at it, all you're going to see is it.

167
00:07:24.045 --> 00:07:25.547
You're not going to see the other guy.

168
00:07:26.067 --> 00:07:26.247
Right.

169
00:07:26.267 --> 00:07:26.748
That's right.

170
00:07:26.948 --> 00:07:33.896
That's like right next to it, like four Earth orbits away because it basically gets sort of engulfed.

171
00:07:34.285 --> 00:07:35.787
Yeah.

172
00:07:36.008 --> 00:07:36.689
In the super giant.

173
00:07:36.729 --> 00:07:49.227
I mean, this sounds very similar to what we talked about last episode about Earth's one millisecond shift in its orbit time, which was partly because of, we don't know, but other objects...

174
00:07:50.982 --> 00:07:52.823
interacting with Earth.

175
00:07:52.843 --> 00:07:56.685
So similarly, you're saying that the supergiant is having this companion.

176
00:07:56.826 --> 00:07:57.046
Yeah.

177
00:07:57.266 --> 00:08:02.068
That is what is impacting and creating the six year cycle in addition to this 400 day cycle.

178
00:08:02.088 --> 00:08:02.909
Yes, exactly.

179
00:08:03.029 --> 00:08:03.269
Okay.

180
00:08:03.309 --> 00:08:03.489
Right.

181
00:08:03.769 --> 00:08:09.553
And so like the idea is like you have this interaction and we see it in the brightness of Beetlejuice.

182
00:08:09.973 --> 00:08:11.874
But we want to we want to actually see the thing.

183
00:08:11.934 --> 00:08:12.134
Right.

184
00:08:12.254 --> 00:08:13.455
We want to see its partner.

185
00:08:13.615 --> 00:08:13.775
Right.

186
00:08:14.055 --> 00:08:16.416
So that becomes incredibly hard.

187
00:08:16.456 --> 00:08:23.618
Wait, just really quick, because you're saying we can measure and then make a hypothesis that is being impacted by this thing.

188
00:08:23.818 --> 00:08:25.519
But we've not made a direct observation.

189
00:08:25.619 --> 00:08:25.959
Yes, yes.

190
00:08:26.339 --> 00:08:30.041
Because when you point when you point your telescope at it, all you see is a single point of light.

191
00:08:30.381 --> 00:08:30.561
Right.

192
00:08:30.781 --> 00:08:34.902
You see a single point of light and that light's brightness is going up and down every six years.

193
00:08:35.423 --> 00:08:35.623
Right.

194
00:08:36.343 --> 00:08:38.644
Now, what we think is that there are two points of light.

195
00:08:39.284 --> 00:08:39.444
Right.

196
00:08:39.464 --> 00:08:41.405
But how do we resolve that two points of light?

197
00:08:41.425 --> 00:08:41.725
Got it.

198
00:08:42.125 --> 00:08:42.365
Because

199
00:08:44.422 --> 00:08:45.823
I actually did the calculation.

200
00:08:46.043 --> 00:08:46.343
Okay.

201
00:08:47.724 --> 00:08:52.886
This thing, it turns out, this thing is about four Earth astronomical units.

202
00:08:52.906 --> 00:08:56.587
So four Earth orbits away from its star.

203
00:08:56.788 --> 00:08:57.048
Okay.

204
00:08:57.408 --> 00:09:00.429
And it's got about 4% the brightness of Betelgeuse, this new star.

205
00:09:00.569 --> 00:09:00.789
Okay.

206
00:09:01.029 --> 00:09:01.250
Okay.

207
00:09:01.910 --> 00:09:02.990
So it's very dim in comparison.

208
00:09:03.010 --> 00:09:03.110
Yeah.

209
00:09:03.170 --> 00:09:04.871
And this thing is 700 light years away.

210
00:09:05.391 --> 00:09:09.973
So that's the same as if somebody in New York City...

211
00:09:10.454 --> 00:09:10.714
Okay.

212
00:09:11.474 --> 00:09:16.376
went onto the top of the Empire State Building and put up two iPhones with their flashlights.

213
00:09:16.576 --> 00:09:16.776
Yeah.

214
00:09:17.916 --> 00:09:19.537
They put them right next to each other, right?

215
00:09:19.597 --> 00:09:23.739
You hold two iPhones, you hold two iPhones, you put the two flashlights, right?

216
00:09:24.259 --> 00:09:35.543
Imaging Beetlejuice and its companion, it's as hard as imaging two flashlights on two iPhones right next to each other on the Empire State Building from Los Angeles.

217
00:09:37.337 --> 00:09:37.557
Right.

218
00:09:37.857 --> 00:09:40.500
Imagine trying to take a picture of that from L.A.

219
00:09:40.620 --> 00:09:42.501
I mean, the Samsung Galaxy's are pretty good.

220
00:09:42.782 --> 00:09:43.522
Hey.

221
00:09:43.622 --> 00:09:44.383
You know, right?

222
00:09:44.403 --> 00:09:46.044
The Xiaomi phones are also pretty good.

223
00:09:46.064 --> 00:09:46.825
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

224
00:09:46.845 --> 00:09:48.086
But I don't believe.

225
00:09:48.146 --> 00:09:48.806
I don't think they.

226
00:09:48.827 --> 00:09:50.128
I don't think if I was.

227
00:09:50.388 --> 00:09:58.314
Even if I was at Spire 73 in downtown Los Angeles, the highest open air bar in Western Hemisphere, at least as of two years ago.

228
00:09:58.334 --> 00:09:58.915
It's a great bar.

229
00:09:59.115 --> 00:09:59.936
And I pointed it.

230
00:10:00.636 --> 00:10:01.758
At New York.

231
00:10:01.798 --> 00:10:02.018
Yeah.

232
00:10:02.498 --> 00:10:05.001
Well, the earth would be in the way because the earth is round.

233
00:10:05.842 --> 00:10:05.922
Ah.

234
00:10:06.443 --> 00:10:08.726
But let's assume it's flat.

235
00:10:08.766 --> 00:10:09.647
Let's assume it's flat.

236
00:10:09.707 --> 00:10:10.007
Fine.

237
00:10:10.127 --> 00:10:10.928
Don't get in the comments.

238
00:10:10.948 --> 00:10:11.689
Don't clip this.

239
00:10:11.709 --> 00:10:12.410
Don't do the thing.

240
00:10:12.490 --> 00:10:12.790
Okay.

241
00:10:13.131 --> 00:10:13.751
Yeah.

242
00:10:14.072 --> 00:10:16.715
But I don't even know that I would get to the east side.

243
00:10:16.855 --> 00:10:17.035
No.

244
00:10:17.075 --> 00:10:17.435
Yeah.

245
00:10:17.936 --> 00:10:18.136
Yeah.

246
00:10:18.456 --> 00:10:19.817
Like even if there was a vacuum.

247
00:10:20.017 --> 00:10:20.157
Right.

248
00:10:20.177 --> 00:10:20.297
Right.

249
00:10:20.337 --> 00:10:22.098
You wouldn't be able to resolve these things.

250
00:10:22.158 --> 00:10:27.020
It would just if you were lucky enough to even see the two iPhones, they would be like one dot.

251
00:10:27.120 --> 00:10:30.802
This is actually really helpful for understanding the scale of the challenge.

252
00:10:30.822 --> 00:10:31.082
Yes.

253
00:10:31.302 --> 00:10:31.582
Yes.

254
00:10:31.662 --> 00:10:32.083
Exactly.

255
00:10:32.103 --> 00:10:34.704
With these with with these experiments, these tools.

256
00:10:34.884 --> 00:10:35.064
Yeah.

257
00:10:35.344 --> 00:10:37.946
So it's an incredible feat that we could do this.

258
00:10:38.046 --> 00:10:39.947
And the image that they produced is amazing.

259
00:10:39.967 --> 00:10:41.348
They used the Gemini Space Telescope.

260
00:10:41.668 --> 00:10:43.069
Not the Gemini Space Telescope, sorry.

261
00:10:43.389 --> 00:10:45.450
They used the Gemini Telescope in Hawaii.

262
00:10:45.830 --> 00:10:49.253
That's at the peak of Mauna Kea in the big island of Hawaii.

263
00:10:49.293 --> 00:10:51.114
It's a beautiful, massive telescope.

264
00:10:51.134 --> 00:10:51.754
Hawaii.

265
00:10:51.914 --> 00:11:02.377
Yeah, it's one of the best parts of Hawaii is the fact that they have these incredible astronomical observatories that are like unmatched in the northern hemisphere.

266
00:11:02.878 --> 00:11:04.498
Which makes it because no light pollution.

267
00:11:04.518 --> 00:11:05.819
Yeah, no light pollution.

268
00:11:06.539 --> 00:11:07.939
It's like perfectly poised.

269
00:11:08.339 --> 00:11:11.120
Super high altitude in the middle of the ocean.

270
00:11:11.140 --> 00:11:13.121
13,000 feet above sea level.

271
00:11:13.761 --> 00:11:16.562
Which is 4,000 feet lower than the Atacama.

272
00:11:16.962 --> 00:11:18.543
Because the Atacama one is about 17,000.

273
00:11:19.603 --> 00:11:22.185
Yeah, and Atacama is basically a bunch of Europeans.

274
00:11:22.645 --> 00:11:26.707
Like, they've colonized the shit out of Chile's high desert.

275
00:11:27.028 --> 00:11:27.308
Right.

276
00:11:27.328 --> 00:11:27.948
For astronomy.

277
00:11:27.988 --> 00:11:29.629
But it's for astronomy, so, you know.

278
00:11:29.969 --> 00:11:31.470
I will make a small caveat.

279
00:11:31.510 --> 00:11:36.493
We do respect the desires of the locals in Hawaii and that their lands are theirs.

280
00:11:36.573 --> 00:11:40.996
And so this is not a claim to that land as being property of the globe.

281
00:11:41.236 --> 00:11:47.640
However, there is a lot of value for all of us in being able to have these tools in particular locations.

282
00:11:47.660 --> 00:11:47.840
Yeah.

283
00:11:47.980 --> 00:11:50.402
And we are grateful to the people of Hawaii for that.

284
00:11:50.482 --> 00:11:59.149
Yes, we're incredibly grateful for the people of Hawaii for lending their land to give us these tools to explore what really is the final frontier.

285
00:11:59.229 --> 00:11:59.409
Right.

286
00:11:59.549 --> 00:11:59.769
Right.

287
00:11:59.849 --> 00:12:07.135
Like, I don't want to digress too much, but it's like in the cultures, it's like exploring the unknown, right?

288
00:12:07.215 --> 00:12:09.577
Exploring the oceans was how they got to Hawaii.

289
00:12:09.617 --> 00:12:13.179
And now it's like they're exploring the vast ocean of space.

290
00:12:13.199 --> 00:12:14.040
Right, right.

291
00:12:14.220 --> 00:12:20.643
It's incredibly romantic to me that Hawaii is the spot where all of this is happening.

292
00:12:20.663 --> 00:12:20.803
Yeah.

293
00:12:21.323 --> 00:12:26.165
I will say that my wife wanted me to propose when we went to Hawaii and we're looking at the observatories.

294
00:12:26.366 --> 00:12:28.647
I did not get the memo, so that did not go over well.

295
00:12:29.007 --> 00:12:29.547
Oh, dude.

296
00:12:29.787 --> 00:12:31.328
However, we are still here today.

297
00:12:31.928 --> 00:12:32.809
Yeah, you're good.

298
00:12:32.929 --> 00:12:33.609
It could have been worse.

299
00:12:33.749 --> 00:12:34.389
It could have been worse.

300
00:12:34.449 --> 00:12:35.730
It could have been worse.

301
00:12:35.810 --> 00:12:37.070
I proposed on Mount Wilson.

302
00:12:37.471 --> 00:12:37.971
Oh, really?

303
00:12:37.991 --> 00:12:39.191
Yeah.

304
00:12:39.211 --> 00:12:42.573
So I don't think she got the memo, but I had the memo.

305
00:12:44.272 --> 00:12:45.653
This is great.

306
00:12:45.773 --> 00:12:53.600
So the real story here is sort of this connection between measurement and direct observation.

307
00:12:53.620 --> 00:12:54.120
Yeah.

308
00:12:54.560 --> 00:12:55.081
Or measurement.

309
00:12:55.121 --> 00:12:56.402
It's like a hypothesis, right?

310
00:12:56.462 --> 00:12:58.684
We're doing the scientific method where we see this thing.

311
00:12:58.784 --> 00:12:58.964
Yep.

312
00:12:59.084 --> 00:13:01.366
And we exhaust all the other possibilities.

313
00:13:01.406 --> 00:13:03.388
And we're like, well, it's got to be like a companion.

314
00:13:03.508 --> 00:13:03.668
Yep.

315
00:13:03.848 --> 00:13:05.690
And then we're like, okay, how do we measure this thing?

316
00:13:06.130 --> 00:13:10.714
And so we point this Gemini North telescope to it.

317
00:13:10.874 --> 00:13:11.034
Yep.

318
00:13:11.354 --> 00:13:16.540
And we also use this thing called speckle imaging, which was actually developed at UCLA.

319
00:13:16.580 --> 00:13:25.950
A lot of it was developed at UCLA to try and image the center of the galaxy to see those beautiful star trails around the Black Hole Center that won Andrea Ghezzi.

320
00:13:26.430 --> 00:13:28.091
Nobel Prize very recently.

321
00:13:28.731 --> 00:13:32.593
It was actually like on the floor above my PhD lab.

322
00:13:32.653 --> 00:13:41.897
I was on the fifth floor and then the sixth floor was basically all an imaging lab that was trying to make imaging these tiny little things possible.

323
00:13:41.937 --> 00:13:42.097
Right.

324
00:13:42.137 --> 00:13:45.319
And they use that to prove the supermassive black hole.

325
00:13:45.979 --> 00:13:52.503
But in this case what they used in speckle imaging is basically like you take a bunch of really fast images.

326
00:13:52.783 --> 00:13:53.003
Okay.

327
00:13:53.023 --> 00:13:53.223
Okay.

328
00:13:53.543 --> 00:13:56.385
You take a bunch of really fast images and then you average them together.

329
00:13:56.565 --> 00:13:56.765
Okay.

330
00:13:56.785 --> 00:14:00.587
The reason why you're doing this is you treat each image as an independent sample.

331
00:14:00.827 --> 00:14:05.430
So instead of like taking a long exposure where like the atmosphere is in the way.

332
00:14:05.450 --> 00:14:05.590
Yep.

333
00:14:05.790 --> 00:14:07.011
And so you get a lot of blurring.

334
00:14:07.051 --> 00:14:07.211
Yep.

335
00:14:07.271 --> 00:14:09.632
What you do is take a bunch and then you.

336
00:14:11.413 --> 00:14:35.118
mess around with each image and average it in just the right way that you can start resolving like incredible detail that's right because you want high resolution and high contrast right which you can't get on the long exposure you can't get with a short exposure but high volume yes exactly so that's called speckle imaging and some of these exposures they're like extremely short they're like 14 milliseconds 14 milliseconds this is oh my goodness

337
00:14:35.198 --> 00:14:35.398
Right.

338
00:14:35.458 --> 00:14:38.800
And you're taking like thousands of these and then you're averaging them together.

339
00:14:39.100 --> 00:14:43.123
And finally, you get this beautiful picture of Beetlejuice and its little companion.

340
00:14:43.403 --> 00:14:46.785
The little companion is like four percent as bright as Beetlejuice.

341
00:14:46.825 --> 00:14:49.427
So obviously we weren't seeing the little bro.

342
00:14:49.447 --> 00:14:50.287
This is a little bro.

343
00:14:50.327 --> 00:14:51.088
Little bro.

344
00:14:51.288 --> 00:14:52.269
And a little giant.

345
00:14:52.289 --> 00:14:56.651
And unfortunately, it is not a nice relationship.

346
00:14:56.731 --> 00:14:57.352
This is not.

347
00:14:57.992 --> 00:14:58.372
Oh, okay.

348
00:14:58.392 --> 00:15:00.773
So this is not a Disney happy ending.

349
00:15:00.893 --> 00:15:07.396
I referenced Love Island earlier because I thought companion is usually, you know, referenced in a way that it's not going to end well.

350
00:15:08.416 --> 00:15:14.259
I imagine the super giant is going to be engulfing the companion.

351
00:15:14.279 --> 00:15:14.479
Yes.

352
00:15:15.319 --> 00:15:17.020
We don't support a piece of relations.

353
00:15:17.100 --> 00:15:19.742
Yeah, that's 4% the size.

354
00:15:19.902 --> 00:15:20.703
It's not.

355
00:15:21.123 --> 00:15:25.426
It's like, I think in the next 10,000 years, it's going to be gone.

356
00:15:25.687 --> 00:15:28.629
I'm so happy we're going to be able to see that in our lifetime.

357
00:15:28.669 --> 00:15:29.990
Yeah, it's going to be pretty cool.

358
00:15:30.030 --> 00:15:30.770
That's incredible.

359
00:15:31.171 --> 00:15:31.891
One last thing.

360
00:15:32.291 --> 00:15:32.572
Sorry.

361
00:15:32.892 --> 00:15:33.452
No, no, no.

362
00:15:33.472 --> 00:15:33.773
Go ahead.

363
00:15:33.853 --> 00:15:39.837
Oh, I was going to say one last thing that I think is very nicely done by the astronomers, right?

364
00:15:39.897 --> 00:15:42.499
When you discover a new object, you tend to get to name it.

365
00:15:43.019 --> 00:15:43.259
Okay.

366
00:15:43.379 --> 00:15:43.599
Okay.

367
00:15:44.160 --> 00:15:45.060
So, Beetlejuice.

368
00:15:45.680 --> 00:15:47.081
Beetlejuice is an interesting name.

369
00:15:47.501 --> 00:15:52.743
Spelled B-E-T-E-L-G-E-U-S-E.

370
00:15:52.924 --> 00:15:53.164
Yes.

371
00:15:53.924 --> 00:15:55.305
Not like the Beetlejuice we know.

372
00:15:55.525 --> 00:15:55.685
No.

373
00:15:55.705 --> 00:15:56.485
It's like a French.

374
00:15:56.625 --> 00:15:56.845
Yes.

375
00:15:56.945 --> 00:15:58.626
This is a weird, weird Beetlejuice.

376
00:15:58.766 --> 00:16:01.988
It's actually an Arabic name.

377
00:16:02.188 --> 00:16:02.408
Okay.

378
00:16:02.428 --> 00:16:02.648
Okay.

379
00:16:03.308 --> 00:16:13.274
It was named by the Arabs back when, you know, Europe was in the Dark Ages and Arabia was, you know, where scientific learning and all of that was happening.

380
00:16:13.294 --> 00:16:14.495
They don't teach us that in school.

381
00:16:14.595 --> 00:16:15.475
No, but it's...

382
00:16:15.495 --> 00:16:17.696
They deliberately ignore centuries.

383
00:16:17.716 --> 00:16:19.838
Like algebra is from Al-Jabar.

384
00:16:20.498 --> 00:16:23.740
Algorithm is like named after an Arabic word.

385
00:16:23.820 --> 00:16:27.182
Anyways, Beetlejuice means the hand of a giant.

386
00:16:27.662 --> 00:16:27.962
Okay.

387
00:16:28.042 --> 00:16:29.363
Because like it's on his shoulder.

388
00:16:29.443 --> 00:16:29.623
Yep.

389
00:16:29.643 --> 00:16:29.823
Right.

390
00:16:30.143 --> 00:16:30.583
Okay.

391
00:16:30.923 --> 00:16:33.604
And they probably inherited those constellations from the Greeks.

392
00:16:34.204 --> 00:16:34.564
Got it.

393
00:16:35.204 --> 00:16:35.484
Right.

394
00:16:36.344 --> 00:16:39.485
And Aljus means giant in Arabic.

395
00:16:40.146 --> 00:16:48.428
So they stuck to that theme and they're naming this new star Siwarha, which means bracelet.

396
00:16:49.008 --> 00:16:49.268
Okay.

397
00:16:49.288 --> 00:16:49.848
Oh, yeah.

398
00:16:49.888 --> 00:16:51.309
It's like a bracelet on the hand of a giant.

399
00:16:51.369 --> 00:16:52.309
I thought that's kind of cool.

400
00:16:52.870 --> 00:16:53.290
I don't know.

401
00:16:53.570 --> 00:16:58.011
Look, look, I appreciate that you can both be technical and creative.

402
00:16:58.031 --> 00:16:58.592
Yeah, yeah.

403
00:16:58.732 --> 00:16:59.452
At the same time.

404
00:16:59.512 --> 00:16:59.952
Yeah, yeah.

405
00:17:00.132 --> 00:17:02.153
And, yeah, I think it's nice, you know?

406
00:17:02.693 --> 00:17:11.196
So, although the ending of the story may not be the most happy, this is not a Disney movie, as you said.

407
00:17:11.276 --> 00:17:11.476
No.

408
00:17:12.017 --> 00:17:15.558
It is another great example of, again, just the incredible...

409
00:17:16.462 --> 00:17:19.306
genius of so many of the human beings around us.

410
00:17:20.108 --> 00:17:25.135
And so I think now we talked about really, really big stuff.

411
00:17:25.295 --> 00:17:25.536
Yes.

412
00:17:26.137 --> 00:17:28.540
This is that star was the size of Jupiter.

413
00:17:29.978 --> 00:17:31.419
The orbit, not the planet.

414
00:17:31.459 --> 00:17:33.761
The orbit of Jupiter, like the sun, Jupiter.

415
00:17:33.781 --> 00:17:33.941
Yeah.

416
00:17:34.622 --> 00:17:36.544
So now we're going to go in the opposite direction.

417
00:17:36.564 --> 00:17:36.764
Yeah.

418
00:17:38.085 --> 00:17:50.637
So the headline on our second story here is first direct images reveal atomic thermal vibrations in quantum materials.

419
00:17:50.917 --> 00:17:51.897
That's right.

420
00:17:52.038 --> 00:18:13.026
And then the byline goes, Researchers investigating atomic scale phenomena impacting next generation electronic and quantum devices have captured the first microscopy images of atomic thermal vibrations revealing a new type of motion that could reshape the design of quantum technologies and ultra thin electronics.

421
00:18:13.187 --> 00:18:15.948
So the way I've described it was we've seen atoms do the Harlem Shake.

422
00:18:16.148 --> 00:18:16.428
Mm-hmm.

423
00:18:16.708 --> 00:18:24.653
So but it seems like the key idea here is it's an imaging feat of something really, really, really small.

424
00:18:25.373 --> 00:18:31.076
And the thing that we image that was really, really, really small was was doing a little shimmy.

425
00:18:31.176 --> 00:18:32.377
Yes.

426
00:18:32.837 --> 00:18:37.240
So how do we go from this really small thing?

427
00:18:38.140 --> 00:18:41.801
vibrating to ultra thin electronics.

428
00:18:41.881 --> 00:18:43.121
Yes.

429
00:18:43.702 --> 00:18:46.803
Well, first we got to understand what is the thing that we imaged.

430
00:18:46.923 --> 00:18:47.183
Okay.

431
00:18:47.203 --> 00:18:47.423
Yes.

432
00:18:47.723 --> 00:18:51.744
So for that, have you ever heard of moire patterns?

433
00:18:52.504 --> 00:18:53.585
M-O-I-R-E.

434
00:18:55.385 --> 00:18:58.667
Yes, like with the accent on the moire.

435
00:18:58.747 --> 00:19:01.168
Yeah, that's so you might have seen it.

436
00:19:01.268 --> 00:19:02.328
Yeah, it's kind of like that.

437
00:19:02.608 --> 00:19:04.990
Do you know what it is in in film?

438
00:19:05.330 --> 00:19:08.671
You get it on your imaging like in particular situations.

439
00:19:08.691 --> 00:19:10.392
They call it like a more effect.

440
00:19:10.452 --> 00:19:10.672
Yes.

441
00:19:10.932 --> 00:19:11.673
Yes, exactly.

442
00:19:11.913 --> 00:19:12.893
And so, yes.

443
00:19:12.953 --> 00:19:13.934
But what does that have to do?

444
00:19:13.974 --> 00:19:14.214
Right.

445
00:19:14.294 --> 00:19:14.954
Like I get it.

446
00:19:15.054 --> 00:19:20.677
You can get it all the time if you like, if you if you take your phone and then like if I were to take my phone

447
00:19:21.117 --> 00:19:24.118
and then take a photo of your LCD screen, right?

448
00:19:24.178 --> 00:19:36.221
And then I zoom in on the, like, if you've ever taken a photo with your phone of like a screen and then you zoomed in on the screen, you're going to get these like weird, like, like, like netty patterns.

449
00:19:36.281 --> 00:19:36.481
Yes.

450
00:19:36.602 --> 00:19:36.902
You know?

451
00:19:37.062 --> 00:19:37.342
Yes.

452
00:19:37.602 --> 00:19:38.522
And why is that happening?

453
00:19:38.562 --> 00:19:41.943
That's because there's a pattern on the LCD screen.

454
00:19:42.103 --> 00:19:42.383
Okay.

455
00:19:42.663 --> 00:19:47.965
So because the LCD screen is a bunch of pixels, so there's a regular pattern on there and then your phone,

456
00:19:48.725 --> 00:19:51.647
the way it's displaying it has another pattern, right?

457
00:19:51.968 --> 00:19:54.990
So what you're doing is you've got these two patterns.

458
00:19:55.030 --> 00:19:57.332
You've got these two patterns that are overlapping.

459
00:19:57.452 --> 00:19:57.772
Yeah.

460
00:19:57.912 --> 00:20:00.915
And when you do that, you get these giant patterns.

461
00:20:01.455 --> 00:20:03.497
Like there's a third bigger pattern.

462
00:20:03.897 --> 00:20:08.039
From the sort of the amalgamation of those two small ones.

463
00:20:08.059 --> 00:20:08.479
Yeah, yeah.

464
00:20:08.519 --> 00:20:12.341
So what you need is like two small patterns and then you slightly offset it.

465
00:20:12.621 --> 00:20:15.963
And you'll get these like nice like looking bigger patterns.

466
00:20:16.063 --> 00:20:19.465
I think some film people would disagree with you about the characterization of nice.

467
00:20:19.505 --> 00:20:19.765
Yes.

468
00:20:19.905 --> 00:20:20.265
However.

469
00:20:20.285 --> 00:20:21.146
I don't know if it's nice.

470
00:20:21.886 --> 00:20:24.868
From a quantum materials perspective, it is quite nice.

471
00:20:25.188 --> 00:20:25.828
This is okay.

472
00:20:25.948 --> 00:20:26.188
Okay.

473
00:20:26.208 --> 00:20:28.930
So I do know what you're talking about.

474
00:20:28.970 --> 00:20:29.130
Yeah.

475
00:20:29.150 --> 00:20:31.751
And it's basically it's an interference pattern.

476
00:20:31.871 --> 00:20:36.632
Yes, it's an interference pattern between two regular 2D patterns, right?

477
00:20:36.692 --> 00:20:38.212
There's like two patterns in 2D.

478
00:20:38.552 --> 00:20:40.353
We're making them interfere slightly.

479
00:20:40.413 --> 00:20:41.673
It can't be like completely.

480
00:20:41.953 --> 00:20:42.213
Got it.

481
00:20:42.353 --> 00:20:44.714
It's got to be like just slightly a little bit off.

482
00:20:44.794 --> 00:20:48.635
And then you'll get these like long range patterns, right?

483
00:20:48.775 --> 00:20:52.635
The smaller the difference between them, the longer the range, right?

484
00:20:52.695 --> 00:20:53.656
Okay.

485
00:20:54.156 --> 00:20:59.917
And so what you can do now is you can create these like silicon heterostructures.

486
00:21:00.417 --> 00:21:06.341
So you can have these like materials that are made out of silicon and then you like put some other stuff in it.

487
00:21:06.481 --> 00:21:06.641
Yep.

488
00:21:06.881 --> 00:21:07.061
Right.

489
00:21:07.141 --> 00:21:07.582
Like chips.

490
00:21:07.682 --> 00:21:07.922
Yes.

491
00:21:08.702 --> 00:21:13.566
I mean, chips are, yeah, chips are exactly like silicon and I think boron or like some other kind of element on top.

492
00:21:14.006 --> 00:21:23.372
But in this case, what we're really trying to do is we're trying to measure the properties of tiny, like extremely thin silicon heterostructures.

493
00:21:23.472 --> 00:21:23.672
Okay.

494
00:21:23.692 --> 00:21:23.952
Okay.

495
00:21:24.152 --> 00:21:25.854
Heterostructure, hetero just means different.

496
00:21:25.874 --> 00:21:27.655
So you're putting some other stuff in there.

497
00:21:29.336 --> 00:21:35.098
You get the silicon, and usually this structure forms a kind of 2D lattice, right?

498
00:21:35.158 --> 00:21:36.038
A 2D grid.

499
00:21:36.579 --> 00:21:39.080
Now, if you stack two on top... Like graph paper.

500
00:21:39.100 --> 00:21:39.700
Yes, yes.

501
00:21:40.060 --> 00:21:44.842
If you stack two on top, then there's going to be some kind of defect, right, usually.

502
00:21:45.222 --> 00:21:52.726
And that's going to cause these moiré patterns because you have a lattice of atoms, and then you have another lattice of atoms.

503
00:21:52.926 --> 00:21:55.207
These lattices are like nanometers...

504
00:21:55.867 --> 00:22:01.072
apart, so like tens of atoms apart, and then there's going to be some defects.

505
00:22:01.472 --> 00:22:08.258
So you get these moire patterns within the atomic structure of the thing that you're trying to study.

506
00:22:08.978 --> 00:22:19.908
What it makes me think of is when I was in math class and I would have my notebook and I would have graph paper, and if I would remove the paper slightly so it wasn't perfectly aligned with the page below it,

507
00:22:20.268 --> 00:22:24.429
you could kind of see a little bit of the, yeah, you can exactly see a more, right?

508
00:22:24.469 --> 00:22:24.649
Right.

509
00:22:24.669 --> 00:22:29.730
Like, yeah, is it loosely in a simplified way, a similar concept?

510
00:22:29.750 --> 00:22:31.411
I mean, no, it's literally that concept.

511
00:22:31.471 --> 00:22:31.931
Okay.

512
00:22:31.971 --> 00:22:32.211
Okay.

513
00:22:32.251 --> 00:22:33.171
It's not even loosely.

514
00:22:33.211 --> 00:22:35.312
It's literally that, right?

515
00:22:35.332 --> 00:22:39.273
You got grid, you got a grid on top and then it's a little bit off and you get a little pattern.

516
00:22:39.413 --> 00:22:39.693
Okay.

517
00:22:39.733 --> 00:22:39.893
Right.

518
00:22:40.133 --> 00:22:40.353
Got it.

519
00:22:40.373 --> 00:22:44.994
So, so, so, so what, so these in this pattern,

520
00:22:46.365 --> 00:22:53.429
We're trying to image this really, really small structure that has these patterns present.

521
00:22:53.569 --> 00:22:53.789
Yes.

522
00:22:53.949 --> 00:22:57.411
And so these patterns, like these structures, right?

523
00:22:57.451 --> 00:23:01.674
These like thin structures with like these interacting sheets that have this like...

524
00:23:02.294 --> 00:23:04.476
long periodicity in space.

525
00:23:04.856 --> 00:23:10.420
They're really important for things like superconductivity, heat conduction studies, new materials, like stuff of the future.

526
00:23:10.560 --> 00:23:11.341
The meta materials.

527
00:23:11.361 --> 00:23:14.843
Like the stuff that we want to make in the future.

528
00:23:14.943 --> 00:23:15.984
We want to make it cheaply.

529
00:23:16.024 --> 00:23:18.005
We want to make it at an industrial scale.

530
00:23:18.146 --> 00:23:21.728
But in order to do that, first we need to understand physically what is going on.

531
00:23:22.188 --> 00:23:28.593
So as an analogy, we have a Lego block that's eight by eight.

532
00:23:28.973 --> 00:23:29.193
Yeah.

533
00:23:29.334 --> 00:23:31.315
That's the level at which we can like engineer everything.

534
00:23:31.435 --> 00:23:31.595
Yeah.

535
00:23:32.036 --> 00:23:35.719
We're trying to get down to a Lego block that's one by one.

536
00:23:35.739 --> 00:23:36.540
In some sense, yeah.

537
00:23:36.580 --> 00:23:39.563
And a smaller... And understanding of Lego blocks.

538
00:23:39.583 --> 00:23:42.085
Understanding of the Lego blocks at that scale.

539
00:23:42.105 --> 00:23:42.726
At that scale.

540
00:23:42.806 --> 00:23:50.233
And at that, like, even... You're trying to also make the Lego block, like, incredibly cold so that you can understand the physics at the basic level.

541
00:23:50.293 --> 00:23:50.713
I got you.

542
00:23:50.773 --> 00:23:50.974
Right?

543
00:23:51.274 --> 00:23:52.715
And you're trying to understand, like...

544
00:23:53.796 --> 00:23:56.377
the atoms within the Lego block in some sense.

545
00:23:56.437 --> 00:24:01.378
And like how the Lego block stretches and shears and squishes.

546
00:24:01.958 --> 00:24:05.159
That way, when you make a bigger thing, you have a better handle on it.

547
00:24:05.179 --> 00:24:12.360
You understand all of the sort of derivative outcomes that will happen because of effects at this really, really, really, really small scale.

548
00:24:12.380 --> 00:24:12.600
Yes.

549
00:24:12.661 --> 00:24:12.841
Yeah.

550
00:24:13.161 --> 00:24:15.661
And so you've got these like more patterns, right?

551
00:24:16.141 --> 00:24:18.782
And it turns out these patterns will actually move around.

552
00:24:20.085 --> 00:24:20.305
Okay.

553
00:24:20.385 --> 00:24:20.625
Okay.

554
00:24:20.645 --> 00:24:20.926
Hold on.

555
00:24:21.126 --> 00:24:22.126
Yeah.

556
00:24:22.226 --> 00:24:23.607
Because the defect, right?

557
00:24:23.647 --> 00:24:27.710
The defect that creates this pattern is going to move because the temperature is not zero.

558
00:24:28.210 --> 00:24:31.972
So because temperature is not zero, there's going to be some wiggling going on in the lattice.

559
00:24:32.193 --> 00:24:37.976
And because there's some wiggling going on in the lattice, the pattern itself is going to move and it's going to be constantly shifting.

560
00:24:39.417 --> 00:24:50.048
Understanding how this thing shifts, what's the physics of that is incredibly powerful and incredibly needed for understanding like how these 2D heterostructures work.

561
00:24:50.348 --> 00:24:51.469
And that's what these guys did.

562
00:24:51.489 --> 00:24:52.971
They're from the University of Maryland.

563
00:24:53.371 --> 00:24:55.994
They did something called electron tichography.

564
00:24:56.294 --> 00:24:59.757
That's P-T-Y-C-O-graphy.

565
00:25:00.138 --> 00:25:00.378
Okay.

566
00:25:01.059 --> 00:25:05.102
Tycho means to fold in Greek.

567
00:25:05.903 --> 00:25:09.146
It's a new form of electron microscopy, basically.

568
00:25:09.746 --> 00:25:14.530
But it's halfway between X-ray crystallography and electron microscopy.

569
00:25:14.810 --> 00:25:16.992
So electron microscopy is the idea of...

570
00:25:19.333 --> 00:25:22.796
When we think microscope, we think like a light microscope, right?

571
00:25:22.896 --> 00:25:23.396
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

572
00:25:23.436 --> 00:25:24.417
Like the stuff in your bio lab.

573
00:25:24.437 --> 00:25:25.678
This is the stuff we did in eighth grade.

574
00:25:25.698 --> 00:25:25.858
Yeah.

575
00:25:25.878 --> 00:25:27.099
We're looking at frog lights.

576
00:25:27.119 --> 00:25:29.061
Where it's like, okay, you're using visible light.

577
00:25:29.081 --> 00:25:32.804
You've got a traditional lens, and then you try to, like, see stuff.

578
00:25:33.184 --> 00:25:40.190
Now, visible light has a size, like the wavelength of visible light, the stuff that's in these lights.

579
00:25:40.210 --> 00:25:40.290
Yep.

580
00:25:40.970 --> 00:25:43.691
of about 400 to 700 nanometers.

581
00:25:44.152 --> 00:25:44.372
Okay.

582
00:25:44.592 --> 00:25:51.975
So the wave has a spatial resolution of 400 to 700 nanometers, which means you can't see stuff smaller than that, right?

583
00:25:52.095 --> 00:26:01.239
If you've ever been to the ocean, if there's a tiny little island and the waves are like 10 meters apart and the island is like a meter, the waves don't give a fuck.

584
00:26:01.259 --> 00:26:02.800
They're just gonna go through, right?

585
00:26:03.140 --> 00:26:09.003
But if the island is massive and the waves are small, then the waves bend around it and that's when you can actually resolve stuff.

586
00:26:09.523 --> 00:26:16.429
Okay, so visible light is not going to work because visible light, the smallest you can go is like 400 nanometers, right?

587
00:26:16.610 --> 00:26:22.095
This is why when people talk about like signals intelligence gathering or these kind of detection platforms, right?

588
00:26:22.115 --> 00:26:22.255
Yeah.

589
00:26:22.535 --> 00:26:26.819
You have optical, you have radio, you have infrared.

590
00:26:27.199 --> 00:26:29.962
And the point there is that that range...

591
00:26:30.582 --> 00:26:31.624
Is that different?

592
00:26:31.644 --> 00:26:33.245
Yeah, it tells you the resolution of the stuff.

593
00:26:33.606 --> 00:26:37.069
And there's some atmospheric effects in the stuff that you're talking about.

594
00:26:37.109 --> 00:26:48.361
But for example, with radio, if you take a long wave radio image of something, and the something is the size of you, then you're not going to resolve anything.

595
00:26:48.882 --> 00:26:50.864
Because the radio wave is massive.

596
00:26:52.303 --> 00:26:53.243
So what are you doing?

597
00:26:53.263 --> 00:26:53.643
What are you doing?

598
00:26:55.064 --> 00:26:55.204
No.

599
00:26:55.244 --> 00:26:55.484
Okay.

600
00:26:55.504 --> 00:26:59.665
So the scale of this stuff just continues to always blow my mind.

601
00:26:59.785 --> 00:27:00.285
Yeah.

602
00:27:00.325 --> 00:27:01.605
That we can even.

603
00:27:02.486 --> 00:27:02.666
Yeah.

604
00:27:02.686 --> 00:27:05.086
I haven't even told you the resolution that these guys got.

605
00:27:05.346 --> 00:27:05.586
Okay.

606
00:27:05.606 --> 00:27:06.847
So but here's the other thing.

607
00:27:06.947 --> 00:27:07.127
Okay.

608
00:27:07.387 --> 00:27:08.287
So I told you, right?

609
00:27:08.447 --> 00:27:11.768
Like usually you use light and light microscope in the bio lab.

610
00:27:12.068 --> 00:27:16.429
But now, like biologists, increasingly they use electron microscopes because of quantum mechanics.

611
00:27:16.849 --> 00:27:18.510
Electrons have wave-like properties.

612
00:27:19.170 --> 00:27:22.311
And the wavelength of electrons is around x-rays.

613
00:27:22.371 --> 00:27:23.471
It's extremely small.

614
00:27:23.551 --> 00:27:23.851
Got it.

615
00:27:24.011 --> 00:27:30.933
So if you shoot electrons through stuff, through a sample, then you can resolve at the wavelength of electrons, right?

616
00:27:30.953 --> 00:27:32.874
Because they're the same in quantum mechanics.

617
00:27:33.234 --> 00:27:36.195
And so now you can like resolve down to like the angstrom level.

618
00:27:37.155 --> 00:27:37.635
Right?

619
00:27:37.655 --> 00:27:38.395
But that's not good enough.

620
00:27:38.856 --> 00:27:40.596
That's still not good enough.

621
00:27:40.816 --> 00:27:44.357
One angstrom is the size of a hydrogen atom, and that's not good enough for these guys.

622
00:27:44.577 --> 00:27:44.837
Okay?

623
00:27:45.297 --> 00:27:47.258
Because in order to see these thermal vibrations...

624
00:27:47.278 --> 00:27:47.858
Were they Chinese?

625
00:27:49.078 --> 00:27:50.138
No, University of Maryland.

626
00:27:50.318 --> 00:27:51.959
But were the scientists Chinese?

627
00:27:52.959 --> 00:27:53.999
It might be, yeah.

628
00:27:54.879 --> 00:27:55.419
They might be.

629
00:27:55.600 --> 00:27:56.340
Immigration matters.

630
00:27:56.360 --> 00:27:57.520
That's okay.

631
00:27:57.760 --> 00:28:01.441
But I mean, I don't know the citizenship of them and things like that, right?

632
00:28:01.461 --> 00:28:01.761
That's fair.

633
00:28:01.961 --> 00:28:06.323
But I mean, if they're US citizens, then, yeah, we got to keep them right here.

634
00:28:06.343 --> 00:28:07.264
This is important stuff.

635
00:28:07.284 --> 00:28:08.525
This is important stuff.

636
00:28:08.765 --> 00:28:09.765
We want the ultra thin.

637
00:28:09.785 --> 00:28:10.766
Yes, yes, yes.

638
00:28:10.846 --> 00:28:12.547
Yeah, we want the ultra thin electronics.

639
00:28:12.627 --> 00:28:15.288
I want the self-driving car that can jump over a puddle.

640
00:28:15.549 --> 00:28:15.969
Exactly.

641
00:28:16.309 --> 00:28:16.569
Anyway.

642
00:28:16.609 --> 00:28:18.550
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

643
00:28:19.171 --> 00:28:19.351
So.

644
00:28:20.271 --> 00:28:22.772
These guys, it wasn't good enough for them and Engstrom, right?

645
00:28:23.252 --> 00:28:28.975
And so what they did was with electron tichography, what you can do, and this only happens with periodic materials.

646
00:28:29.355 --> 00:28:31.976
So with like stuff that looks like graph paper.

647
00:28:32.296 --> 00:28:37.978
What you can do is you can shoot electrons at something that looks like graph paper and you're going to get what's called a diffraction pattern.

648
00:28:38.098 --> 00:28:38.338
Okay.

649
00:28:38.459 --> 00:28:38.619
Right?

650
00:28:38.659 --> 00:28:44.481
Because like all of the electrons are going to interfere because of the lattice structure, because of the periodic structure of stuff.

651
00:28:44.901 --> 00:28:46.782
So you're going to get like one lattice pattern.

652
00:28:47.162 --> 00:28:50.466
Now what you're going to do is move the samples up and then do it again.

653
00:28:50.886 --> 00:28:52.428
And then move the sample up and do it again.

654
00:28:52.688 --> 00:28:55.951
And because the sample itself is periodic, right?

655
00:28:56.251 --> 00:29:00.796
The fact that you're moving this is going to give you higher resolution on the image that comes at the end.

656
00:29:01.497 --> 00:29:03.038
That's the genius of electron tichography.

657
00:29:03.058 --> 00:29:04.059
This is so...

658
00:29:05.020 --> 00:29:05.461
Right.

659
00:29:05.561 --> 00:29:08.003
Like it's the fact that this thing is graph.

660
00:29:08.043 --> 00:29:13.028
If this thing wasn't graph paper, then you'd be just taking like photos of like different parts of the stuff.

661
00:29:13.168 --> 00:29:14.869
But because it's graph paper, I move it up.

662
00:29:14.909 --> 00:29:16.671
It's the same thing from before.

663
00:29:17.011 --> 00:29:17.231
Right.

664
00:29:17.652 --> 00:29:24.578
And so now I can use the spatial invariance to nail down my resolution in space.

665
00:29:25.018 --> 00:29:28.742
And then I get down to 15 picometers, which is 0.15 angstroms.

666
00:29:30.163 --> 00:29:32.387
So it's 15% the size of a hydrogen atom.

667
00:29:32.788 --> 00:29:36.575
And that's the images that you're seeing there in that article.

668
00:29:36.635 --> 00:29:39.981
Those individual dots, those are individual atoms, right?

669
00:29:41.480 --> 00:29:43.461
Like that's a single atom in a lattice.

670
00:29:43.861 --> 00:29:44.602
And then there's a bunch.

671
00:29:45.202 --> 00:29:47.423
Like each dot is an atom.

672
00:29:47.763 --> 00:29:48.524
It's incredible.

673
00:29:48.564 --> 00:29:49.745
Like the image is incredible.

674
00:29:49.825 --> 00:29:57.088
The image we're looking at right now kind of looks like when you were a kid and you go up to the TV really, really, really close.

675
00:29:57.129 --> 00:30:00.730
And you can see each of the individual pixels on the TV.

676
00:30:00.750 --> 00:30:01.271
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

677
00:30:01.371 --> 00:30:02.491
Just for the audio listeners.

678
00:30:02.531 --> 00:30:05.253
Back when it was like we had like the electron tubes.

679
00:30:05.353 --> 00:30:05.653
Yes.

680
00:30:05.673 --> 00:30:06.354
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

681
00:30:06.374 --> 00:30:07.154
The vacuum tube tube.

682
00:30:07.194 --> 00:30:07.854
Yeah, yeah.

683
00:30:07.874 --> 00:30:08.895
I don't know.

684
00:30:09.973 --> 00:30:12.556
I'm kind of a loss of words.

685
00:30:12.816 --> 00:30:17.200
We're seeing the nature of the material in itself.

686
00:30:17.280 --> 00:30:18.461
It's incredible.

687
00:30:18.501 --> 00:30:21.444
Isn't this a level at which things start to get a little weird?

688
00:30:22.204 --> 00:30:23.065
We're getting close.

689
00:30:23.625 --> 00:30:24.326
I mean, no, no.

690
00:30:24.346 --> 00:30:25.467
Things are already getting weird.

691
00:30:25.487 --> 00:30:26.668
Things are already weird.

692
00:30:27.028 --> 00:30:28.230
At this level, it's already...

693
00:30:28.270 --> 00:30:29.190
It's a little... Yeah.

694
00:30:29.851 --> 00:30:30.051
Yeah.

695
00:30:30.091 --> 00:30:34.575
Now you're starting to get into Heisenberg uncertainty principle style stuff.

696
00:30:34.675 --> 00:30:34.895
Okay.

697
00:30:34.915 --> 00:30:35.136
Yeah.

698
00:30:36.056 --> 00:30:36.757
This is incredible.

699
00:30:36.857 --> 00:30:37.417
Okay.

700
00:30:37.517 --> 00:30:43.798
And so I think one shout out to US academic research institution.

701
00:30:43.818 --> 00:30:44.058
Yes.

702
00:30:44.419 --> 00:30:48.719
Shout out to how we import the best talent in the world.

703
00:30:48.819 --> 00:30:51.080
Like, yeah, you're still going to get funding.

704
00:30:51.400 --> 00:30:52.180
Don't worry about it.

705
00:30:52.200 --> 00:30:53.580
We got enough money flowing in.

706
00:30:53.680 --> 00:30:58.061
Come here, help us build and discover incredible.

707
00:30:58.701 --> 00:31:05.663
I just yeah, it's really hard to like for a layman to to internalize.

708
00:31:06.523 --> 00:31:12.709
Because I think the delta between my everyday understanding of science as someone who comes from a family of scientists.

709
00:31:12.949 --> 00:31:13.190
Yeah.

710
00:31:13.690 --> 00:31:29.125
And then like people who just don't have that conversational context or exposure to the information don't really understand how thorough, robust, and outrageous the process is to do the things we talk about.

711
00:31:29.145 --> 00:31:29.745
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

712
00:31:29.826 --> 00:31:31.207
That then make it into papers.

713
00:31:31.467 --> 00:31:31.667
Yeah.

714
00:31:31.787 --> 00:31:37.210
No, it's again, it's like 0.15 the size of a hydrogen atom, right?

715
00:31:37.250 --> 00:31:38.471
That's the resolution.

716
00:31:38.511 --> 00:31:41.673
That's the size of the pixel that we're imaging this thing.

717
00:31:41.933 --> 00:31:43.614
It's also reproducible.

718
00:31:43.654 --> 00:31:45.214
So there's no belief going on here.

719
00:31:45.515 --> 00:31:46.075
No.

720
00:31:46.215 --> 00:31:49.297
No, somebody else can do exactly what they did and be like, ah.

721
00:31:49.397 --> 00:31:50.417
Oh, yeah.

722
00:31:50.497 --> 00:31:57.741
And you know what will probably happen is like whoever's the competitor is going to do what they did, make some tweak, make it better and be like, well, I made it better.

723
00:31:57.921 --> 00:31:58.542
Yeah.

724
00:31:59.142 --> 00:32:00.223
Like that's how scientists are.

725
00:32:00.243 --> 00:32:00.863
We're petty as fuckers.

726
00:32:01.043 --> 00:32:01.564
Fuck, dude.

727
00:32:02.204 --> 00:32:04.046
Yeah.

728
00:32:04.226 --> 00:32:07.149
That second story, I'm going to have to take a second to tell.

729
00:32:07.169 --> 00:32:08.730
Yeah, it's crazy.

730
00:32:08.810 --> 00:32:16.057
Because the more we understand these kinds of materials, right, the closer we are to these next generation materials of superconductivity.

731
00:32:16.918 --> 00:32:26.949
It could be like there's also some talk about creating quantum computing using these 2D materials.

732
00:32:27.010 --> 00:32:33.697
Maybe the vibrations in these materials can be our zero and ones for the quantum computer that we want to make.

733
00:32:34.038 --> 00:32:35.920
I mean, that may be a little bit.

734
00:32:37.335 --> 00:32:38.696
Caveats, caveats, caveats.

735
00:32:38.736 --> 00:32:40.537
Yeah, like there's a lot more work there.

736
00:32:40.817 --> 00:32:46.220
But like understanding 2D materials that are this thin are incredibly important for like quantum sensing, which is very important.

737
00:32:46.240 --> 00:32:49.122
We can't get to the next step until we get to the first step.

738
00:32:49.142 --> 00:32:49.282
Yeah.

739
00:32:49.362 --> 00:32:53.484
And the first step is knowing how stuff at this level operates.

740
00:32:53.525 --> 00:32:53.705
Yeah.

741
00:32:53.905 --> 00:32:59.228
And this is also the first time that electron tichography has been used to study this kind of material.

742
00:33:00.128 --> 00:33:13.376
So the big thing is using this experimental method, which has been used before, but now it's being used for this kind of stuff, applying to these moray patterns in these 2D defect structures.

743
00:33:14.237 --> 00:33:17.779
So it opens up like, okay, what else can we do with electron tichography?

744
00:33:17.959 --> 00:33:19.480
There's two big key insights here.

745
00:33:23.662 --> 00:33:27.363
One is that the methodology applied to this use case bears fruit.

746
00:33:28.403 --> 00:33:30.963
And two, the fruit that we got is delicious.

747
00:33:31.143 --> 00:33:31.363
Yeah.

748
00:33:33.004 --> 00:33:33.504
It's ripe.

749
00:33:33.664 --> 00:33:34.304
It is nice.

750
00:33:34.324 --> 00:33:34.764
Juicy.

751
00:33:35.404 --> 00:33:36.484
And we can get more of it.

752
00:33:37.484 --> 00:33:37.745
Yeah.

753
00:33:37.765 --> 00:33:37.925
Okay.

754
00:33:37.965 --> 00:33:38.225
Okay.

755
00:33:38.245 --> 00:33:38.765
This is great.

756
00:33:39.085 --> 00:33:41.125
So we started off really big.

757
00:33:42.145 --> 00:33:44.326
Then we went... Really small.

758
00:33:44.426 --> 00:33:45.046
Way small.

759
00:33:45.066 --> 00:33:45.286
Yeah.

760
00:33:45.506 --> 00:33:45.926
Really small.

761
00:33:45.946 --> 00:33:46.566
A little whiplash.

762
00:33:47.126 --> 00:33:51.567
We're going to stay small for our third story, which...

763
00:33:55.042 --> 00:33:56.163
Okay, let's just jump into it.

764
00:33:56.523 --> 00:34:01.666
So in Antarctica, we have, would you call it?

765
00:34:02.426 --> 00:34:03.567
It's not an observatory.

766
00:34:03.707 --> 00:34:04.587
We have a facility.

767
00:34:04.727 --> 00:34:05.748
Yeah.

768
00:34:05.868 --> 00:34:08.569
It kind of is an observatory.

769
00:34:09.030 --> 00:34:10.170
But not the way people think about it.

770
00:34:10.210 --> 00:34:11.591
But not the way people think, yeah.

771
00:34:11.711 --> 00:34:11.911
Right.

772
00:34:12.051 --> 00:34:12.291
Yeah.

773
00:34:12.592 --> 00:34:15.873
So Ice Cube, not NWA Ice Cube.

774
00:34:15.893 --> 00:34:16.494
Yeah, yeah.

775
00:34:17.054 --> 00:34:18.775
There's no space in between the two words.

776
00:34:20.015 --> 00:34:27.539
Neutrino search sets first constraints on proton fraction of ultra-high energy cosmic rays.

777
00:34:28.200 --> 00:34:36.124
Neutrinos are subatomic particles with no charge and very little mass that are known to weakly interact with other matter in the universe.

778
00:34:36.204 --> 00:34:43.047
Due to their weak interactions with other particles, these particles are notoriously difficult to detect.

779
00:34:43.688 --> 00:34:44.268
However...

780
00:34:45.988 --> 00:34:48.269
It seems like we may be on the path here.

781
00:34:48.769 --> 00:35:00.632
And so this is where we're talking about too fast, too furious, because we're dealing with ultra high energy, ultra high, ultra high energy, cosmic rays.

782
00:35:00.732 --> 00:35:00.972
Yeah.

783
00:35:01.572 --> 00:35:05.073
I mean, this sounds both dangerous and exciting.

784
00:35:05.807 --> 00:35:11.190
Yeah, it's incredibly exciting because it's a part of physics that like seriously people don't know.

785
00:35:12.050 --> 00:35:12.651
Okay.

786
00:35:12.691 --> 00:35:15.212
How you get something so fast, so furious.

787
00:35:15.232 --> 00:35:18.394
Because what we're saying is this is after Fast Five.

788
00:35:18.434 --> 00:35:28.679
So for the Fast and Furious franchise watchers who are familiar, everything up to Fast Five was, generally speaking, realistic.

789
00:35:28.759 --> 00:35:31.241
Everyone could be like, oh, I can understand how a car goes that fast.

790
00:35:31.661 --> 00:35:32.621
I can understand da-da-da.

791
00:35:32.842 --> 00:35:33.362
Makes sense.

792
00:35:33.782 --> 00:35:42.130
As soon as they started flying off of cliffs and being in space with cars, then the question, all right, how do you do that?

793
00:35:42.371 --> 00:35:43.031
How do you do that?

794
00:35:43.311 --> 00:35:45.033
And that's what physicists are asking.

795
00:35:45.233 --> 00:35:46.034
How do you do that?

796
00:35:46.054 --> 00:35:54.442
For these ultra high energy cosmic rays, the schtick seems to be, in some cases, they're moving so fast.

797
00:35:55.123 --> 00:36:00.668
that we don't have an idea of how they were able to achieve that level of speed.

798
00:36:00.928 --> 00:36:01.168
Yes.

799
00:36:01.429 --> 00:36:02.029
Is that accurate?

800
00:36:02.189 --> 00:36:03.030
That's exactly right.

801
00:36:03.110 --> 00:36:03.330
Yeah.

802
00:36:03.631 --> 00:36:05.352
So let me tell you first about cosmic rays.

803
00:36:05.672 --> 00:36:05.933
Okay.

804
00:36:05.973 --> 00:36:06.193
Okay.

805
00:36:06.573 --> 00:36:09.756
Cosmic rays are basically particles that come from outside the earth.

806
00:36:10.076 --> 00:36:10.317
Okay.

807
00:36:10.537 --> 00:36:12.278
And they're like big particles.

808
00:36:12.298 --> 00:36:12.919
Big particles.

809
00:36:12.979 --> 00:36:18.023
I mean like, yes, like immigrating particles from way out there.

810
00:36:18.324 --> 00:36:18.584
Okay.

811
00:36:19.104 --> 00:36:21.106
This can be something as light as a proton.

812
00:36:21.607 --> 00:36:21.847
Okay.

813
00:36:22.187 --> 00:36:24.290
to something as big as like a gold nucleus.

814
00:36:24.810 --> 00:36:25.171
Okay.

815
00:36:25.191 --> 00:36:25.371
Right?

816
00:36:25.411 --> 00:36:27.293
A gold nucleus is like hundreds of protons.

817
00:36:27.674 --> 00:36:27.914
Okay.

818
00:36:28.014 --> 00:36:28.195
Right?

819
00:36:28.615 --> 00:36:32.700
So, and they're incredibly fast.

820
00:36:32.860 --> 00:36:34.482
They're going very close to the speed of light.

821
00:36:34.783 --> 00:36:35.023
Okay?

822
00:36:35.564 --> 00:36:36.465
Now, usually...

823
00:36:37.566 --> 00:36:52.675
What we do is we measure the energy of these particles using something called the electron volt, which is how much energy it takes to raise, to move an electron across one voltage of electric potential.

824
00:36:52.735 --> 00:36:56.678
It's just a way of measuring energy at the particle level.

825
00:36:57.639 --> 00:37:03.745
To give you some idea of what that means, like CERN, which is the big particle collider.

826
00:37:03.845 --> 00:37:09.310
It's where apparently European scientists are interacting with interdimensional beings, according to the Internet.

827
00:37:09.702 --> 00:37:11.484
Oh, that's new.

828
00:37:11.584 --> 00:37:14.987
I should talk to some of my friends who work there and see if they can put us in touch.

829
00:37:15.388 --> 00:37:18.851
That'd be a great guest on this podcast, Interdimensional Beings.

830
00:37:19.912 --> 00:37:22.835
Tell me, sir, do you know where cosmic rays come from?

831
00:37:23.616 --> 00:37:24.296
Was that you?

832
00:37:25.137 --> 00:37:25.818
Was that you?

833
00:37:25.838 --> 00:37:26.638
Well, actually...

834
00:37:28.320 --> 00:37:32.223
But CERN is the same thing as the LHC.

835
00:37:32.343 --> 00:37:33.904
Yeah, it's the Large Hadron Collider.

836
00:37:33.924 --> 00:37:39.368
So the Large Hadron Collider, this massive, massive particle collider that builds the biggest.

837
00:37:39.769 --> 00:37:41.210
It's like a mile or two miles?

838
00:37:41.250 --> 00:37:42.231
No, it's like 13 miles.

839
00:37:42.251 --> 00:37:42.871
Oh, it's over.

840
00:37:43.051 --> 00:37:45.293
It's across two countries.

841
00:37:45.373 --> 00:37:45.653
Yeah, yeah.

842
00:37:45.673 --> 00:37:49.596
Like France and Switzerland share a border, and it goes underneath that border.

843
00:37:49.656 --> 00:37:50.317
It's that big.

844
00:37:50.337 --> 00:37:50.557
Okay.

845
00:37:50.977 --> 00:37:56.863
Um, it's, it's what created the God particle, the Higgs boson, um, incredibly high energy.

846
00:37:56.903 --> 00:38:01.187
Some of the highest energies that we can pack into a small space into individual particles.

847
00:38:01.708 --> 00:38:08.815
Um, the proton beams that go around CERN right now are at six TeV, which is six times 10 to the 12.

848
00:38:09.216 --> 00:38:12.639
So six with 12 zeros electron volts.

849
00:38:12.859 --> 00:38:13.079
Okay.

850
00:38:13.219 --> 00:38:14.740
I want that in my bank account.

851
00:38:14.760 --> 00:38:15.641
Yeah.

852
00:38:15.661 --> 00:38:19.704
Like that's a lot of electron volts packed into a single proton.

853
00:38:19.864 --> 00:38:20.044
Right.

854
00:38:20.204 --> 00:38:20.405
Right.

855
00:38:20.885 --> 00:38:25.048
An electron volt is how much energy you would need to take one electron up one volt.

856
00:38:25.208 --> 00:38:25.408
Right.

857
00:38:25.448 --> 00:38:26.609
This is all of that.

858
00:38:26.649 --> 00:38:30.072
Six times 10 to the 12 into a single particle.

859
00:38:30.372 --> 00:38:30.632
Okay.

860
00:38:31.192 --> 00:38:32.333
That's a lot of energy.

861
00:38:32.854 --> 00:38:34.535
But at least we can imagine...

862
00:38:34.895 --> 00:38:35.656
How to make it.

863
00:38:37.217 --> 00:38:37.738
Okay.

864
00:38:37.938 --> 00:38:44.564
And you might have seen all the headlines of being like, we're accessing the beginning of the universe.

865
00:38:44.584 --> 00:38:44.744
Right.

866
00:38:45.124 --> 00:38:45.585
And we are.

867
00:38:45.845 --> 00:38:50.809
Because at those energies, we're accessing the beginning of space and time itself.

868
00:38:50.849 --> 00:38:51.210
Right.

869
00:38:51.230 --> 00:38:53.892
We're getting as close to the Big Bang as we possibly can.

870
00:38:53.912 --> 00:38:54.072
Right.

871
00:38:54.252 --> 00:38:54.753
Right.

872
00:38:54.853 --> 00:38:55.093
Okay.

873
00:38:55.313 --> 00:38:56.174
So 10 to the 12.

874
00:38:56.234 --> 00:38:58.536
10 to the 12 electron volts is like...

875
00:38:59.617 --> 00:39:00.238
It's pretty nice.

876
00:39:00.298 --> 00:39:01.159
We can do it.

877
00:39:01.239 --> 00:39:02.520
We can create that.

878
00:39:02.840 --> 00:39:04.181
We can understand it.

879
00:39:04.281 --> 00:39:05.082
We can understand it.

880
00:39:05.222 --> 00:39:05.803
We're good to go.

881
00:39:05.863 --> 00:39:06.803
And we have all the frameworks.

882
00:39:06.823 --> 00:39:07.484
Yeah, we're good to go.

883
00:39:07.504 --> 00:39:09.306
We know the tactics and strategy.

884
00:39:09.446 --> 00:39:10.747
We're good to go.

885
00:39:10.787 --> 00:39:10.927
Yeah.

886
00:39:11.267 --> 00:39:15.171
And then came the biggest cosmic ray of all time.

887
00:39:15.191 --> 00:39:16.031
I think I remember this.

888
00:39:16.312 --> 00:39:17.933
Okay, it was called the OMG particle.

889
00:39:17.953 --> 00:39:19.314
The Oh My God particle.

890
00:39:19.554 --> 00:39:20.595
Oh My God.

891
00:39:20.715 --> 00:39:22.337
Yeah, it was discovered in Utah.

892
00:39:23.197 --> 00:39:23.798
randomly.

893
00:39:24.398 --> 00:39:25.519
I mean, not randomly.

894
00:39:25.579 --> 00:39:28.240
Obviously, a bunch of physicists had these cosmic ray detectors.

895
00:39:29.441 --> 00:39:34.024
It had 10 to the 20 electron volts in a single particle.

896
00:39:35.565 --> 00:39:45.908
That's how they detected 10 to the 20, which is a million times the energy of the proton in the LHC.

897
00:39:46.328 --> 00:39:47.408
OK. OK. OK.

898
00:39:47.448 --> 00:39:49.008
So now now we're like, OK, what?

899
00:39:49.068 --> 00:39:49.268
What?

900
00:39:49.288 --> 00:39:49.468
What?

901
00:39:49.488 --> 00:39:49.668
What?

902
00:39:49.689 --> 00:39:49.849
What?

903
00:39:49.869 --> 00:39:50.009
What?

904
00:39:50.029 --> 00:39:50.169
What?

905
00:39:50.189 --> 00:39:50.309
What?

906
00:39:50.329 --> 00:39:50.469
What?

907
00:39:50.489 --> 00:39:50.649
What?

908
00:39:50.669 --> 00:39:50.809
What?

909
00:39:50.829 --> 00:39:50.929
What?

910
00:39:50.949 --> 00:39:51.069
What?

911
00:39:51.109 --> 00:39:51.769
Hold on a second.

912
00:39:52.349 --> 00:39:52.909
Hold up.

913
00:39:53.409 --> 00:39:53.830
Hold up.

914
00:39:54.430 --> 00:39:59.671
How do you how do you pack so much energy into a into a single particle?

915
00:40:00.472 --> 00:40:01.413
You know what this reminds me of?

916
00:40:01.593 --> 00:40:02.694
And it's totally unrelated.

917
00:40:03.555 --> 00:40:09.721
But our discussion about vacuum energy, which has a similar question of how can there actually be that much energy?

918
00:40:09.741 --> 00:40:09.961
Yeah.

919
00:40:10.302 --> 00:40:13.505
It's unrelated, but just the level of...

920
00:40:14.549 --> 00:40:18.875
Yeah, the level of awe about, like, how does this even happen?

921
00:40:19.076 --> 00:40:19.236
Right.

922
00:40:19.316 --> 00:40:19.496
Right?

923
00:40:19.516 --> 00:40:23.342
Like, let me give you some stats because I did some calculations about, like, what that would mean.

924
00:40:23.422 --> 00:40:23.682
Okay?

925
00:40:24.203 --> 00:40:28.068
So, 10 to the 20 electron volts in a single particle.

926
00:40:28.088 --> 00:40:29.510
This is the oh my god particle.

927
00:40:32.753 --> 00:40:40.036
If we wanted to see how fast it was going in terms of the speed of light, because nothing can go faster than the speed of light, but the closer you get to the speed of light, the higher your energy is.

928
00:40:40.076 --> 00:40:40.276
Right?

929
00:40:40.796 --> 00:40:48.620
This thing had 0.9999999999 with 24 nines before other numbers show up.

930
00:40:48.740 --> 00:40:48.940
Oh my God.

931
00:40:48.980 --> 00:40:53.822
In terms of like, so 0.999, 24 nines, and then like 5, 4, 10, like C times the speed of light.

932
00:40:56.743 --> 00:41:00.012
Okay, going that fast, if it originated...

933
00:41:05.218 --> 00:41:15.367
1.5 billion light years away, then because of relativity, from our reference frame, it would basically take 1.5 billion years to get here.

934
00:41:15.707 --> 00:41:20.452
But because of time dilation, in relativity, the faster you move, the slower your clock goes.

935
00:41:20.852 --> 00:41:22.914
From that particle's perspective, it would only have lived 1.5 days.

936
00:41:22.934 --> 00:41:23.215
Get the...

937
00:41:29.140 --> 00:41:32.702
To us, it's 1.5 billion years.

938
00:41:32.842 --> 00:41:36.404
But to the whatever particle it was, it was just like, oh, 1.5 days.

939
00:41:36.444 --> 00:41:37.145
I'm here on Earth.

940
00:41:37.865 --> 00:41:38.746
Hey, it's Utah.

941
00:41:39.246 --> 00:41:42.368
It takes us that long to get to like Texas from here.

942
00:41:42.508 --> 00:41:43.388
Yeah.

943
00:41:43.709 --> 00:41:47.991
Mate, like so the other thing it would it would take a photon 250,000 years.

944
00:41:49.932 --> 00:41:53.276
So like if it was in a race with a photon, right?

945
00:41:53.416 --> 00:41:56.600
So there's our particle, the OMG particle, and then there's a photon.

946
00:41:57.181 --> 00:42:01.946
If these two were in a race, it would take the photon 250,000 years to get a one centimeter lead.

947
00:42:06.429 --> 00:42:06.990
On this guy.

948
00:42:07.570 --> 00:42:09.532
I don't like this.

949
00:42:09.572 --> 00:42:11.233
So that's what's happening here, right?

950
00:42:11.734 --> 00:42:17.259
That's where we're like, okay, this is incredibly fast.

951
00:42:17.939 --> 00:42:25.706
What makes something, what makes a single particle that is massive, it's trivial for photons to move that fast because they're massless.

952
00:42:25.766 --> 00:42:26.467
Right, right, right.

953
00:42:26.487 --> 00:42:31.752
But this is something that has mass, so it requires work to actually accelerate it.

954
00:42:32.272 --> 00:42:32.472
Right?

955
00:42:32.652 --> 00:42:32.832
Yeah.

956
00:42:33.273 --> 00:42:37.454
No, I mean... Like, you can't... Photology is created, it moves because it's massless.

957
00:42:37.514 --> 00:42:41.356
We're not concerned about the speed of a photon because it has no mass.

958
00:42:41.736 --> 00:42:44.938
And so, of course, it can move at incredibly high speeds.

959
00:42:44.998 --> 00:42:45.798
Yeah.

960
00:42:45.818 --> 00:42:47.359
Like, by relativity, it's, like, trivial.

961
00:42:47.639 --> 00:42:49.180
But, like, this thing, it has stuff in it.

962
00:42:49.380 --> 00:42:50.360
In it, right.

963
00:42:50.540 --> 00:42:53.342
And the stuff is... Like, it has a rest mass.

964
00:42:53.402 --> 00:42:55.043
And its rest mass is also huge comparatively.

965
00:42:55.083 --> 00:42:55.323
Yes.

966
00:42:55.403 --> 00:42:55.983
Comparatively.

967
00:42:56.063 --> 00:42:59.145
Yeah, I mean, it's a proton compared to a photon, which is zero.

968
00:42:59.186 --> 00:43:01.547
Yeah, it's like it's at least a proton, right?

969
00:43:01.627 --> 00:43:03.529
It could be a higher nucleus.

970
00:43:03.609 --> 00:43:04.129
Right, right, right.

971
00:43:04.209 --> 00:43:04.990
But it's at least that.

972
00:43:05.050 --> 00:43:05.270
Yeah.

973
00:43:06.151 --> 00:43:09.534
And all of these calculations are with the least.

974
00:43:09.574 --> 00:43:11.175
This is like I can't.

975
00:43:11.235 --> 00:43:15.038
So and you start wondering, okay, like where do these big cosmic rays come from?

976
00:43:15.398 --> 00:43:17.340
Okay, you might think, okay, it's like supernova.

977
00:43:17.840 --> 00:43:18.020
Right.

978
00:43:18.321 --> 00:43:19.182
Like supernova.

979
00:43:19.262 --> 00:43:20.123
It's a massive star.

980
00:43:20.143 --> 00:43:20.904
It blows up.

981
00:43:21.064 --> 00:43:26.430
And then it like, like sprays a bunch of like mass, like these particles with massive energies.

982
00:43:26.470 --> 00:43:27.051
Like fine.

983
00:43:27.171 --> 00:43:27.791
No, no, no.

984
00:43:27.811 --> 00:43:30.755
But those, those cosmic rays should not have 10 to the 20.

985
00:43:31.055 --> 00:43:31.255
Okay.

986
00:43:31.275 --> 00:43:31.476
Okay.

987
00:43:31.736 --> 00:43:33.638
Like for a supernova to have 10 to the 20,

988
00:43:34.699 --> 00:43:39.624
is like, it's, the star is too big to have, like, even existed in the first place.

989
00:43:39.664 --> 00:43:42.947
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, it's like, nah, right?

990
00:43:43.288 --> 00:43:52.697
And then it's like, so, so there's some theories that suggest that it's, it's a particle that's been like, forming from the great, great beginning of the universe and then it's interacting with,

991
00:43:53.257 --> 00:44:01.563
the cosmic microwave background, which is just the background light of the universe that's left over from the Big Bang.

992
00:44:01.883 --> 00:44:06.747
And that light from the universe is bombarding it in just the way to accelerate it.

993
00:44:06.787 --> 00:44:08.328
But even that seems crazy.

994
00:44:08.688 --> 00:44:10.309
I don't like that explanation.

995
00:44:10.449 --> 00:44:13.071
The idea is we need more data about this.

996
00:44:13.371 --> 00:44:17.474
So that's where a neutrino observatory like Ice Cube comes in.

997
00:44:18.255 --> 00:44:21.457
So Ice Cube was started by the University of Wisconsin, Madison.

998
00:44:21.837 --> 00:44:31.663
One of the great things about America is that like our flagship state institutions are just doing like ridiculous research that like other countries would be jealous of.

999
00:44:31.983 --> 00:44:33.624
But ours is like, no, Wisconsin.

1000
00:44:33.904 --> 00:44:36.405
This is S tier basic research.

1001
00:44:36.446 --> 00:44:38.167
No, this is like Wisconsin got this.

1002
00:44:38.187 --> 00:44:41.128
Like all those like alcoholics over there are like, you know what?

1003
00:44:41.268 --> 00:44:45.111
We're also going to make the greatest neutrino observatory in the world.

1004
00:44:45.131 --> 00:44:47.692
Shout out UW Madison because this is it's incredible.

1005
00:44:47.852 --> 00:44:52.756
No, so this thing, this Ice Cube Observatory is like one of my favorite things that humans have done.

1006
00:44:53.017 --> 00:44:53.257
Okay.

1007
00:44:53.537 --> 00:44:55.079
We basically went to Antarctica.

1008
00:44:55.299 --> 00:44:56.360
We're like, we got all this ice.

1009
00:44:56.600 --> 00:44:56.740
Yep.

1010
00:44:57.100 --> 00:44:57.681
What do we do with it?

1011
00:44:58.301 --> 00:45:04.207
So they board like this, like one to two mile deep tunnels into the ice.

1012
00:45:05.608 --> 00:45:09.111
So the area of the observatory is about one square kilometer.

1013
00:45:09.491 --> 00:45:10.772
It's like a few city blocks.

1014
00:45:10.792 --> 00:45:10.893
Yeah.

1015
00:45:11.213 --> 00:45:12.934
And then they board a bunch of tunnels.

1016
00:45:13.195 --> 00:45:13.335
Yep.

1017
00:45:14.276 --> 00:45:19.123
That are one to two miles deep and in it they put photomultiplier tubes, which are basically like light detectors.

1018
00:45:19.323 --> 00:45:21.046
Okay, and think of them as light detectors.

1019
00:45:21.106 --> 00:45:21.827
Now here's what happens.

1020
00:45:22.368 --> 00:45:23.289
Cosmic Ray comes in.

1021
00:45:23.550 --> 00:45:23.730
Yep.

1022
00:45:23.950 --> 00:45:26.995
Okay, slams into the ice.

1023
00:45:27.275 --> 00:45:27.455
Yep.

1024
00:45:27.696 --> 00:45:27.916
Okay.

1025
00:45:28.717 --> 00:45:35.202
When it slams into the ice, all of that energy, it's going to hit one of the water molecules or something like that.

1026
00:45:35.222 --> 00:45:38.064
It's going to spray a bunch of neutrinos everywhere, right?

1027
00:45:38.404 --> 00:45:40.266
Because all of that energy has got to go somewhere.

1028
00:45:40.286 --> 00:45:41.707
So it's going to spray all these neutrinos.

1029
00:45:42.087 --> 00:45:45.490
And then those neutrinos are going to bump into other water molecules and so on and so forth.

1030
00:45:45.810 --> 00:45:55.077
Pretty soon what's going to happen is there's going to be a charged particle, either a proton or an electron, that's going to move through the ice at faster than the speed of light in ice.

1031
00:45:56.835 --> 00:45:57.776
Think about that for a second.

1032
00:45:57.876 --> 00:45:58.416
I don't get it.

1033
00:45:58.436 --> 00:45:58.616
Yeah.

1034
00:45:59.417 --> 00:46:02.258
The speed limit of the universe is the speed of light in a vacuum.

1035
00:46:02.558 --> 00:46:02.739
Right.

1036
00:46:03.299 --> 00:46:06.401
But light moves slower in stuff, right?

1037
00:46:06.461 --> 00:46:08.082
Light moves a little bit slower in air.

1038
00:46:08.382 --> 00:46:09.963
It moves hella slower in water.

1039
00:46:10.323 --> 00:46:13.505
It moves the slowest in diamond, which is what gives it its sparkle.

1040
00:46:13.545 --> 00:46:14.466
Okay.

1041
00:46:14.486 --> 00:46:16.207
In ice, it moves pretty slow, right?

1042
00:46:16.267 --> 00:46:19.569
It's got the water has this crystalline structure that's slowing down the water.

1043
00:46:19.589 --> 00:46:24.912
That scares me because if that's the case, then what you're about to say is even crazier.

1044
00:46:24.972 --> 00:46:25.232
Yeah.

1045
00:46:25.292 --> 00:46:36.058
So when this cosmic ray came in, it knocked out particles and those particles had enough energy to move through ice higher at a faster speed than light moves through ice.

1046
00:46:37.219 --> 00:46:38.139
Does that make sense?

1047
00:46:39.000 --> 00:46:43.362
Because the speed limit is light in a vacuum, not light in ice.

1048
00:46:45.299 --> 00:46:45.579
Okay.

1049
00:46:45.639 --> 00:46:46.460
That's the speed limit.

1050
00:46:46.480 --> 00:46:49.623
We're going to need to take a break because I think my brain is going to explode.

1051
00:46:50.063 --> 00:46:52.765
It's incredible what we're using to find these things.

1052
00:46:53.246 --> 00:46:55.407
So you know what happens when something like that happens?

1053
00:46:55.748 --> 00:46:55.948
Yeah.

1054
00:46:56.328 --> 00:46:56.908
You would know this.

1055
00:46:56.969 --> 00:46:59.591
You're into like, you know, UAPs and all that kind of stuff.

1056
00:46:59.831 --> 00:47:02.373
What happens when an object moves faster than speed of sound?

1057
00:47:03.530 --> 00:47:07.772
Oh, I mean, you're supposed to get massive, like, you know, you get the sonic boom.

1058
00:47:07.812 --> 00:47:08.472
Sonic boom.

1059
00:47:08.532 --> 00:47:08.912
Exactly.

1060
00:47:08.952 --> 00:47:09.792
You get a sonic boom.

1061
00:47:09.812 --> 00:47:10.073
Why?

1062
00:47:10.153 --> 00:47:11.133
Too much friction.

1063
00:47:11.193 --> 00:47:11.873
Yeah, yeah.

1064
00:47:12.033 --> 00:47:15.254
Because the thing is moving through the air faster than the speed of sound.

1065
00:47:15.314 --> 00:47:17.175
And so you're creating this, like, disturbance.

1066
00:47:17.275 --> 00:47:17.435
Yep.

1067
00:47:17.515 --> 00:47:19.196
But, like, what is sound?

1068
00:47:19.236 --> 00:47:23.378
Sound is the rate at which the disturbance moves through air.

1069
00:47:23.498 --> 00:47:23.658
Yeah.

1070
00:47:23.678 --> 00:47:26.519
So you're piercing through the air faster than the speed of sound.

1071
00:47:26.539 --> 00:47:27.659
So you get this sonic boom.

1072
00:47:27.679 --> 00:47:27.919
Yeah.

1073
00:47:28.019 --> 00:47:29.460
You get this cone shock wave.

1074
00:47:29.740 --> 00:47:30.360
Oh, there's the same.

1075
00:47:30.400 --> 00:47:32.541
We're creating a light shock wave.

1076
00:47:32.721 --> 00:47:33.882
A light boom!

1077
00:47:34.102 --> 00:47:35.103
A light boom.

1078
00:47:35.143 --> 00:47:38.765
And that's what all these photomultiplier tubes, all these light detectors are catching.

1079
00:47:39.066 --> 00:47:39.826
The light boom.

1080
00:47:40.206 --> 00:47:41.327
Here comes the boom!

1081
00:47:41.447 --> 00:47:42.668
Yeah.

1082
00:47:42.688 --> 00:47:43.108
Wait.

1083
00:47:43.149 --> 00:47:50.754
So all of those tunnels are catching the light booms from these high energy particles as they knock out other particles and create this churn.

1084
00:47:50.794 --> 00:47:51.274
That's actually weird.

1085
00:47:51.334 --> 00:47:52.935
It's called churnkov radiation.

1086
00:47:53.436 --> 00:47:53.896
Churnkov.

1087
00:47:53.916 --> 00:47:54.837
Churnkov radiation.

1088
00:47:54.877 --> 00:47:58.980
After the Russian physicist who first proposed it and stuff like that.

1089
00:47:59.040 --> 00:48:01.722
I'm glad you made that connection because that helped solidify it.

1090
00:48:01.762 --> 00:48:01.962
Yeah.

1091
00:48:02.122 --> 00:48:02.742
Yeah.

1092
00:48:02.823 --> 00:48:04.003
Because now I get what you're saying.

1093
00:48:04.023 --> 00:48:18.313
You've got a charged particle that's moving, so now the electromagnetic field can't move faster than the thingy, so you're getting this shockwave in the electromagnetic field, and that's creating a bunch of light, and that's what you're seeing, right?

1094
00:48:18.573 --> 00:48:24.497
And so that's the way that Ice Cube, this giant observatory, observes cosmic rays.

1095
00:48:24.657 --> 00:48:24.857
Right.

1096
00:48:25.097 --> 00:48:25.297
Right?

1097
00:48:25.578 --> 00:48:26.958
And the point here is like...

1098
00:48:28.039 --> 00:48:30.182
We are actively observing them.

1099
00:48:30.202 --> 00:48:30.703
Yes, yes.

1100
00:48:30.783 --> 00:48:32.044
And we're actively observing them.

1101
00:48:32.305 --> 00:48:35.568
And what we want to do is we want to find these really, really big ones.

1102
00:48:36.109 --> 00:48:36.349
Okay.

1103
00:48:36.730 --> 00:48:47.283
And what IceCube has done right now, it has put constraints on how many of the big ones of these really big ones can be protons and not like heavier stuff.

1104
00:48:47.663 --> 00:48:47.843
Got it.

1105
00:48:47.863 --> 00:48:48.683
Because that's important.

1106
00:48:48.763 --> 00:48:49.624
So we want to.

1107
00:48:49.684 --> 00:48:59.366
Yeah, we want to figure out like how much of it is protons, how much of it is like like helium nuclei, maybe nitrogen nuclei, maybe even higher gold nuclei, iron nuclei.

1108
00:48:59.426 --> 00:48:59.606
Right.

1109
00:48:59.947 --> 00:49:02.007
And so they put a constraint on it.

1110
00:49:02.047 --> 00:49:08.209
They said that like less than 70 percent are protons, which means that 30 percent have to be these higher protons.

1111
00:49:09.049 --> 00:49:28.687
um nuclei which now that that's crazy because 30 are like these bigger nuclei how did they get that fast it's it's like it's it's it's already crazy that the proton yeah it's going this fast and then now we're saying there's there's other stuff that's bigger yeah and it's that has the same energy it's like you know so something is not right

1112
00:49:29.047 --> 00:49:32.109
Yeah, and it's incredibly exciting, right?

1113
00:49:32.629 --> 00:49:36.612
And Ice Cube, I think, is expanding, or at least it was before the budget cuts.

1114
00:49:36.812 --> 00:49:43.836
But they were supposed to do an Ice Cube 2.0, which is just bigger area.

1115
00:49:44.257 --> 00:49:45.717
And so you get higher resolution.

1116
00:49:45.998 --> 00:49:48.459
You get more resolution about where it came from.

1117
00:49:49.300 --> 00:49:52.902
One of the cool things about Ice Cube is that it's actually more sensitive to stuff.

1118
00:49:53.422 --> 00:50:16.885
like okay here's the earth right ice cube is on the bottom yep it's more sensitive to stuff coming from up here because then up here because here there's so much background there's all sorts of random shit by the time it comes all the way yeah only the big stuff is going all the way through yeah yeah so the earth acts like a filter and so what ice cube is really doing if you're on north pole you're looking for stuff coming out of the ground

1119
00:50:17.846 --> 00:50:18.747
Isn't that kind of funny?

1120
00:50:19.067 --> 00:50:19.287
It is.

1121
00:50:19.407 --> 00:50:23.390
Like, you're looking for particles coming out of the ground, like, from the earth.

1122
00:50:23.730 --> 00:50:25.971
Because the earth has done the work of filtering.

1123
00:50:26.052 --> 00:50:28.793
And this stuff coming from God knows how far away.

1124
00:50:28.813 --> 00:50:29.254
Yeah, yeah.

1125
00:50:29.354 --> 00:50:30.054
And how far in the back.

1126
00:50:30.074 --> 00:50:30.394
Yeah, yeah.

1127
00:50:30.434 --> 00:50:31.895
This is, like, outside our galaxy.

1128
00:50:32.015 --> 00:50:32.816
This is really true.

1129
00:50:32.836 --> 00:50:34.837
Like, this is very much outside our galaxy.

1130
00:50:35.298 --> 00:50:36.478
Is this facility...

1131
00:50:38.981 --> 00:50:42.803
Because Antarctica has a lot of complicated geopolitical issues.

1132
00:50:44.084 --> 00:50:45.264
It's an international facility.

1133
00:50:45.364 --> 00:50:45.885
Okay.

1134
00:50:45.925 --> 00:50:48.386
Yeah, this is kind of like a CERN on Antarctica.

1135
00:50:48.666 --> 00:50:49.086
Makes sense.

1136
00:50:49.146 --> 00:50:49.767
Yeah, yeah.

1137
00:50:50.047 --> 00:50:55.330
I mean, like, Wisconsin-Madison, I think, was one of the first people to, like, create it.

1138
00:50:55.550 --> 00:50:58.831
But, like, and they had, like, two or, like, not that many.

1139
00:50:59.192 --> 00:51:01.373
And I think they partnered with other institutions as well.

1140
00:51:01.393 --> 00:51:03.654
But now it's become this big effort, right?

1141
00:51:03.674 --> 00:51:05.035
Because it's, like, it's just, like, such a...

1142
00:51:06.275 --> 00:51:07.176
It's such a nice thing.

1143
00:51:07.196 --> 00:51:10.377
Like the earth has provided us with a giant ice sheet.

1144
00:51:10.457 --> 00:51:10.797
Yeah.

1145
00:51:10.817 --> 00:51:10.937
Right.

1146
00:51:10.957 --> 00:51:11.097
Right.

1147
00:51:11.117 --> 00:51:12.538
That basically doesn't move.

1148
00:51:12.658 --> 00:51:12.858
Right.

1149
00:51:13.198 --> 00:51:13.379
Right.

1150
00:51:13.399 --> 00:51:17.981
So we can utilize as a sort of substrate by which to run these experiments.

1151
00:51:18.741 --> 00:51:20.362
And so this is.

1152
00:51:22.380 --> 00:51:23.861
I thought that was such a cool story.

1153
00:51:23.921 --> 00:51:25.342
No, this is really interesting.

1154
00:51:25.502 --> 00:51:29.864
Because what's so funny is this facility has so many conspiracy theories about it.

1155
00:51:30.044 --> 00:51:30.384
Really?

1156
00:51:30.604 --> 00:51:31.304
You've heard about it?

1157
00:51:31.384 --> 00:51:32.305
In the UFO community.

1158
00:51:32.325 --> 00:51:33.665
Because people are like, ah.

1159
00:51:34.146 --> 00:51:36.106
No, no, no.

1160
00:51:36.607 --> 00:51:37.307
It's just tunnels.

1161
00:51:37.327 --> 00:51:38.888
The saucers are under the ice.

1162
00:51:39.248 --> 00:51:41.609
And it's there so that they can...

1163
00:51:42.029 --> 00:51:44.250
No, I mean, all of the data is publicly available.

1164
00:51:44.631 --> 00:51:47.472
I mean, this is why we operate from first principle.

1165
00:51:47.512 --> 00:51:47.972
Yeah, yeah.

1166
00:51:48.212 --> 00:51:51.814
No, it's just a bunch of tunnels with, like, light detectors.

1167
00:51:52.595 --> 00:51:56.037
And we're trying to look at light booms.

1168
00:51:56.157 --> 00:51:58.398
I will say there was an interesting thing.

1169
00:51:58.418 --> 00:52:03.401
I'll ask you about this next week, about someone talking about neutrinos.

1170
00:52:03.961 --> 00:52:04.942
Because so many people...

1171
00:52:05.522 --> 00:52:06.302
Let me ask you this question.

1172
00:52:06.582 --> 00:52:08.763
There's not that many neutrino detectors.

1173
00:52:09.443 --> 00:52:09.583
No.

1174
00:52:09.803 --> 00:52:10.063
On Earth.

1175
00:52:10.463 --> 00:52:14.704
No, there's there's there's a big one in Japan that's quite, quite famous.

1176
00:52:14.744 --> 00:52:18.044
There's one in I think South Dakota in the Black Hills is quite famous.

1177
00:52:18.064 --> 00:52:19.965
This one's the this one's a really good one.

1178
00:52:20.185 --> 00:52:21.525
Yeah, the reason not that many though.

1179
00:52:21.625 --> 00:52:27.906
This is the reason I bring this up is someone who's making this hypothetical of if you're I'm always talking about the intelligence agency.

1180
00:52:27.926 --> 00:52:33.287
If you're an intelligence agency and you're looking for a communication channel, that's extremely difficult to be able to intercept or hack.

1181
00:52:33.327 --> 00:52:33.527
Yeah.

1182
00:52:34.387 --> 00:52:43.671
because there's not that many neutrino detectors, it is a medium by which if you can figure out how to make it a controlled medium, it is a secure channel.

1183
00:52:43.891 --> 00:52:46.992
I'm not saying that's a thing, but a lot of people have talked about this.

1184
00:52:47.032 --> 00:52:48.953
No, I understand what you're saying.

1185
00:52:49.393 --> 00:52:50.274
There's a patent.

1186
00:52:50.454 --> 00:53:03.319
So one of my friends, completely unrelated to the UAP community, one of my friends sent me this patent that somebody from Johns Hopkins had made about neutrino communication.

1187
00:53:03.999 --> 00:53:06.420
where instead of using electricity, they use neutrinos.

1188
00:53:06.980 --> 00:53:09.000
I was extremely skeptical, right?

1189
00:53:09.020 --> 00:53:11.881
Because neutrinos are like incredibly hard to interact with.

1190
00:53:11.901 --> 00:53:13.241
I mean, we already, we just talked about why.

1191
00:53:13.261 --> 00:53:29.084
Yeah, I mean, it's like, dude, like I kid you not, in the early days of like neutrino observations, there was like, there's a funny story of a PhD at Caltech who like wanted to like study neutrinos over his PhD.

1192
00:53:29.544 --> 00:53:32.425
And he observed seven neutrinos.

1193
00:53:33.005 --> 00:53:33.805
in like six years.

1194
00:53:34.065 --> 00:53:37.027
So he had names for every age between us.

1195
00:53:37.367 --> 00:53:40.608
So like in his defense, he's like, so then I observed Fred.

1196
00:53:40.788 --> 00:53:42.428
And that was about Fred.

1197
00:53:42.488 --> 00:53:44.749
Like, you know, it's like, it was that hard.

1198
00:53:44.789 --> 00:53:48.251
Now we're getting a lot more because these observatories are getting bigger and bigger.

1199
00:53:48.291 --> 00:53:51.612
But like, you know, like to communicate, you would need something this big.

1200
00:53:52.392 --> 00:53:57.655
Yeah, it's I and the other thing about neutrino communication is the background is so insane.

1201
00:53:57.735 --> 00:53:57.995
Right.

1202
00:53:58.236 --> 00:54:01.577
Because like the sun, like we put our we put our hands out right now.

1203
00:54:01.618 --> 00:54:07.361
The sun is putting millions of neutrinos through us, through our hands right now.

1204
00:54:07.541 --> 00:54:07.741
Right.

1205
00:54:08.041 --> 00:54:08.381
So like.

1206
00:54:09.422 --> 00:54:10.443
It's tough.

1207
00:54:10.563 --> 00:54:12.584
I don't think it's as simple as a telephone.

1208
00:54:12.604 --> 00:54:14.765
No, I totally agree.

1209
00:54:14.905 --> 00:54:22.190
It is interesting having both feeds of information in terms of sort of talking through this.

1210
00:54:23.193 --> 00:54:24.494
That story number three.

1211
00:54:24.514 --> 00:54:26.415
So we went big, small, small.

1212
00:54:27.155 --> 00:54:29.656
Now we're gonna go back to big.

1213
00:54:29.876 --> 00:54:34.939
And we're talking about our potential interstellar Google Maps.

1214
00:54:35.599 --> 00:54:41.182
And so this is New Horizons, images enables first test.

1215
00:54:42.002 --> 00:54:44.924
First, number one, numero uno.

1216
00:54:46.077 --> 00:54:47.658
of interstellar navigation.

1217
00:54:48.039 --> 00:54:54.643
By looking at the shifting stars and photos from New Horizons probe, astronomers have calculated its position in the galaxy.

1218
00:54:55.024 --> 00:55:01.228
A technique, again, we always talk about tools and techniques and frameworks because they're not single use.

1219
00:55:01.548 --> 00:55:03.350
You can expand and sort of.

1220
00:55:04.671 --> 00:55:08.573
get an incredible amount of value from one key insight, like CRISPR in our last episode.

1221
00:55:09.514 --> 00:55:13.396
This technique could be useful for interstellar missions.

1222
00:55:13.736 --> 00:55:19.460
So if I'm trying to go to Alpha Centauri, Centauri, Centauri, I'm gonna need navigation.

1223
00:55:19.680 --> 00:55:20.721
Yes, that's right.

1224
00:55:21.141 --> 00:55:24.344
You're going to need navigation, and you can't rely on the Earth.

1225
00:55:25.465 --> 00:55:26.706
That's the key here.

1226
00:55:27.166 --> 00:55:29.228
Alpha Centauri is four light years away.

1227
00:55:29.528 --> 00:55:32.431
Okay, so if you're trying to beam back to Earth, being like, hey, where am I?

1228
00:55:32.491 --> 00:55:34.493
You're going to have to wait eight years, right?

1229
00:55:34.553 --> 00:55:36.434
Four years to get there, four years to get back.

1230
00:55:36.474 --> 00:55:37.855
There's so many movies.

1231
00:55:38.696 --> 00:55:44.421
Every space movie touches on, oh, we have this big ball that glows, or we have this...

1232
00:55:44.661 --> 00:55:48.909
projector hologram and then you're going to use the star, the deep...

1233
00:55:49.210 --> 00:55:52.957
But navigation is fundamental to every space movie.

1234
00:55:52.997 --> 00:55:53.178
Yeah.

1235
00:55:53.358 --> 00:55:55.502
Because you got to know where you're going.

1236
00:55:55.582 --> 00:55:55.743
Yeah.

1237
00:55:55.763 --> 00:55:56.885
Because once you start going...

1238
00:55:57.254 --> 00:55:58.514
Yeah, once you start going, you got it.

1239
00:55:59.155 --> 00:56:12.199
And you know what's incredibly romantic to me about this particular story is we're navigating the same way that the big explorers navigated back during, okay, okay, European colonization.

1240
00:56:12.219 --> 00:56:14.860
But like they use the stars.

1241
00:56:15.700 --> 00:56:19.101
You know, don't fucking.

1242
00:56:19.181 --> 00:56:20.002
I didn't think of that.

1243
00:56:20.042 --> 00:56:22.823
But like I was saying it, I was like, oh, wait, no, no, no.

1244
00:56:22.843 --> 00:56:24.503
Those are the that's a bad people.

1245
00:56:25.104 --> 00:56:26.744
Anyways, but you know what I mean?

1246
00:56:27.024 --> 00:56:29.145
Like it's like Magellan when he went around the world.

1247
00:56:29.165 --> 00:56:30.366
Well, he died halfway.

1248
00:56:30.406 --> 00:56:35.047
But when his ship went around the world, he used the stars to navigate.

1249
00:56:35.108 --> 00:56:36.048
Right.

1250
00:56:36.068 --> 00:56:39.709
And we're doing the same thing here at JPL and NASA.

1251
00:56:39.849 --> 00:56:40.229
Right.

1252
00:56:40.530 --> 00:56:41.710
It makes logical sense.

1253
00:56:41.790 --> 00:56:41.990
Yeah.

1254
00:56:42.290 --> 00:56:43.911
And we've talked about this where.

1255
00:56:44.511 --> 00:57:00.064
distances and frequency of different types of interaction, quasars, we talked about the vibration stuff earlier, allow for – or the dimming, rather, the great dimming – allow for a consistent reference point in order for us to be able to do so.

1256
00:57:00.144 --> 00:57:04.107
But this is interesting because I guess – and tell me – like, help me understand.

1257
00:57:04.307 --> 00:57:05.908
They were using existing imagery.

1258
00:57:06.249 --> 00:57:07.270
This is another important point.

1259
00:57:08.030 --> 00:57:13.813
We put the stuff on Earth or in orbit and we point it out and we capture data.

1260
00:57:14.013 --> 00:57:14.213
Yeah.

1261
00:57:14.713 --> 00:57:19.796
And it's not like Twitter or the news where that data has a week of value.

1262
00:57:20.156 --> 00:57:24.978
And then after the first week, all the possible insight that could be derived out of that has already been figured out.

1263
00:57:25.018 --> 00:57:25.218
No.

1264
00:57:25.438 --> 00:57:26.599
It doesn't work that way.

1265
00:57:26.699 --> 00:57:27.779
No, no, no.

1266
00:57:27.879 --> 00:57:29.180
That data has timeless value.

1267
00:57:29.340 --> 00:57:29.500
Right.

1268
00:57:29.681 --> 00:57:29.841
Right.

1269
00:57:29.861 --> 00:57:34.085
There's always there's always some massaging we can do to get some new insight.

1270
00:57:34.145 --> 00:57:34.346
Right.

1271
00:57:34.406 --> 00:57:34.546
Right.

1272
00:57:34.586 --> 00:57:42.455
And that's what these guys are doing, because so basically, like the New Horizons spacecraft is a spacecraft that was launched in 2006.

1273
00:57:42.635 --> 00:57:47.781
It was the fastest thing that humanity has ever thrown out there into the cosmos.

1274
00:57:47.821 --> 00:57:47.981
OK.

1275
00:57:48.421 --> 00:57:52.645
Right now, this thing was just on a straight shot to Pluto.

1276
00:57:53.005 --> 00:57:58.890
Actually, first it was going to Jupiter, and then it was going to use a gravity assist by Jupiter to go straight to Pluto.

1277
00:57:58.990 --> 00:58:02.373
We watch space movies, so we know about the gravity assist.

1278
00:58:03.154 --> 00:58:05.216
Yeah, you go around like that.

1279
00:58:05.256 --> 00:58:09.640
You use Newton's laws, basically, to give yourself a boost.

1280
00:58:10.520 --> 00:58:14.284
And this thing is currently moving at 10,000 kilometers an hour.

1281
00:58:14.784 --> 00:58:15.505
It's past Pluto.

1282
00:58:15.985 --> 00:58:17.526
So it took 10 years to get to Pluto.

1283
00:58:17.606 --> 00:58:21.007
Just imagine how far Pluto is, right?

1284
00:58:21.207 --> 00:58:26.229
It took these incredible shots of Pluto, and then now it's just out in the outer solar system.

1285
00:58:26.450 --> 00:58:27.450
On search for Planet Nine.

1286
00:58:28.072 --> 00:58:29.253
Yeah, it's trying to find it.

1287
00:58:30.253 --> 00:58:30.873
We'll see, right?

1288
00:58:30.973 --> 00:58:31.154
Yeah.

1289
00:58:32.014 --> 00:58:46.021
So usually when stuff like this goes out, like the Pioneer that's out in the interstellar space, Voyager, which is out in interstellar space now, New Horizons, usually in order to figure out where you are, you basically beam back to Earth.

1290
00:58:46.681 --> 00:58:55.125
And JPL has this thing, JPL, which is NASA's Jet Propulsion Lab out in Pasadena, maintains something called the Deep Space Network.

1291
00:58:55.705 --> 00:58:55.925
Right.

1292
00:58:56.065 --> 00:58:57.466
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1293
00:58:57.486 --> 00:58:57.667
Okay.

1294
00:58:57.687 --> 00:59:00.949
So there's like an antenna dish that's like near Death Valley in California.

1295
00:59:01.309 --> 00:59:02.530
There's one in Madrid.

1296
00:59:02.990 --> 00:59:04.151
I forget where the third one is.

1297
00:59:04.211 --> 00:59:06.273
But effectively, it's at 120.

1298
00:59:06.573 --> 00:59:08.614
It's like at a third of a circle around the earth.

1299
00:59:09.055 --> 00:59:13.338
So there's always a dish pointing in every direction.

1300
00:59:13.398 --> 00:59:19.082
You know what scene we should insert here is that scene from Independence Day where Jeff Goldblum is talking about line of sight to the president.

1301
00:59:19.142 --> 00:59:22.124
And he's saying the reason that they have this global communication network is because – anyway.

1302
00:59:22.224 --> 00:59:22.885
Of a line of sight.

1303
00:59:22.905 --> 00:59:26.367
But in this case, there's a line of sight to every part of the cosmos.

1304
00:59:26.407 --> 00:59:26.547
Yep.

1305
00:59:26.768 --> 00:59:26.948
Right.

1306
00:59:27.148 --> 00:59:31.851
So you've got like Earth with like three beams that are going out in opposite directions.

1307
00:59:32.692 --> 00:59:36.015
And so what you do is you point to Earth and you say, OK, how long did it take to get there?

1308
00:59:36.395 --> 00:59:40.898
I know which way the satellite is pointing to an extremely high degree of accuracy.

1309
00:59:41.279 --> 00:59:41.459
So.

1310
00:59:43.719 --> 00:59:48.161
I can then within tens of meters resolve where I am.

1311
00:59:48.681 --> 00:59:50.322
Which is pretty good if you're close.

1312
00:59:50.462 --> 00:59:50.702
Yeah.

1313
00:59:51.202 --> 00:59:53.463
But gets increasingly not as good if you're far.

1314
00:59:53.503 --> 00:59:53.623
Yeah.

1315
00:59:53.643 --> 00:59:54.383
Is that kind of the point?

1316
00:59:54.443 --> 00:59:55.343
That's kind of the point.

1317
00:59:55.624 --> 01:00:00.185
If we're trying to do this for real, we're trying to go to the stars, we can't be waiting.

1318
01:00:00.345 --> 01:00:05.107
Like even New Horizons probably has to wait like several hours, right, to get that information.

1319
01:00:05.127 --> 01:00:05.747
Yeah.

1320
01:00:06.127 --> 01:00:06.667
Right.

1321
01:00:06.767 --> 01:00:08.048
If we're trying to navigate...

1322
01:00:08.560 --> 01:00:08.720
Right.

1323
01:00:08.780 --> 01:00:09.001
Right.

1324
01:00:09.081 --> 01:00:12.264
Not just like coast, which right now New Horizons is coasting.

1325
01:00:12.304 --> 01:00:19.791
But if we're trying to navigate, what we're going to have to do is update our location as we're going through our journey.

1326
01:00:19.991 --> 01:00:20.172
Right.

1327
01:00:20.352 --> 01:00:23.054
And so what these guys did was they looked at where.

1328
01:00:23.495 --> 01:00:27.579
So as you're moving, right, we always talk about on this podcast how we're stuck on Earth.

1329
01:00:28.200 --> 01:00:29.040
Well, these guys aren't.

1330
01:00:29.801 --> 01:00:30.021
Right.

1331
01:00:30.442 --> 01:00:31.883
These guys are not stuck on Earth.

1332
01:00:32.223 --> 01:00:33.684
They're moving through the cosmos.

1333
01:00:33.704 --> 01:00:36.486
They're now in the interstellar medium away from the sun's influence.

1334
01:00:36.866 --> 01:00:41.109
And so to them, the positions of the stars are slightly different.

1335
01:00:42.150 --> 01:00:42.290
Right.

1336
01:00:42.310 --> 01:00:42.930
Does that make sense?

1337
01:00:42.950 --> 01:00:46.933
Yeah, because we're moving at some incredible speed as a system.

1338
01:00:47.013 --> 01:00:47.254
Yeah.

1339
01:00:47.494 --> 01:00:48.254
In a direction.

1340
01:00:48.454 --> 01:00:50.656
Yeah, in some direction, but they're moving this way.

1341
01:00:50.776 --> 01:00:54.719
And now the background looks different because they're from a different vantage point.

1342
01:00:55.039 --> 01:00:58.301
And by looking at that vantage point and our vantage point,

1343
01:00:59.282 --> 01:01:03.466
and taking those pictures exactly, we can now resolve where they are, right?

1344
01:01:03.946 --> 01:01:07.029
Because it can only look like that from one spot.

1345
01:01:07.489 --> 01:01:09.010
And so we know where that one spot is.

1346
01:01:09.030 --> 01:01:09.911
That makes total sense.

1347
01:01:10.011 --> 01:01:11.072
And that's what this thing did.

1348
01:01:11.172 --> 01:01:12.333
Okay, got it.

1349
01:01:12.453 --> 01:01:18.298
It is creating the next sort of – instead of just looking back at Earth as a single point of reference to –

1350
01:01:20.740 --> 01:01:24.223
understand your position in this larger vastness of space.

1351
01:01:24.624 --> 01:01:28.807
We are now using both that reference point and the reference point.

1352
01:01:28.827 --> 01:01:30.528
No, this one doesn't even use the Earth.

1353
01:01:30.969 --> 01:01:32.530
It's just that.

1354
01:01:32.570 --> 01:01:33.371
Because we know.

1355
01:01:33.931 --> 01:01:41.898
And so we can back engineer, back calculate from just the snapshot of the sky, which has an orientation.

1356
01:01:42.198 --> 01:01:45.101
Or like a frame that allows us to be like, oh.

1357
01:01:45.641 --> 01:01:46.442
Yeah, we're from there.

1358
01:01:46.622 --> 01:01:47.963
Over there's the Hollywood sign.

1359
01:01:48.063 --> 01:01:49.384
Over there's Sunset Boulevard.

1360
01:01:49.424 --> 01:01:50.225
Over there's Venice Beach.

1361
01:01:50.365 --> 01:01:52.087
Exactly, which means I must be here.

1362
01:01:52.407 --> 01:01:53.288
Yeah, exactly.

1363
01:01:53.628 --> 01:01:57.111
And the camera on New Horizons was not meant for this kind of stuff.

1364
01:01:57.592 --> 01:01:59.954
So the air bar is like pretty big.

1365
01:02:00.034 --> 01:02:02.356
It's like an astronomical unit.

1366
01:02:02.656 --> 01:02:03.697
Like the orbit of the Earth.

1367
01:02:03.857 --> 01:02:04.357
Okay.

1368
01:02:04.778 --> 01:02:06.079
So not great, but...

1369
01:02:07.460 --> 01:02:08.580
It's about the principle.

1370
01:02:08.680 --> 01:02:08.860
Yes.

1371
01:02:09.320 --> 01:02:09.520
Right?

1372
01:02:09.760 --> 01:02:10.861
It's about the first principle.

1373
01:02:10.941 --> 01:02:12.161
Yeah, exactly.

1374
01:02:12.241 --> 01:02:16.222
It's about the – this is the first time they use that principle.

1375
01:02:16.342 --> 01:02:23.323
Yeah, so I think it's a cool story because they use Proxima Centauri and Wolf 359, which are very close stars.

1376
01:02:23.783 --> 01:02:29.964
They figured out where they were in relation to the background, and then they did the back calculation.

1377
01:02:30.164 --> 01:02:33.324
I mean this – And this is something we're going to use later, right?

1378
01:02:33.405 --> 01:02:34.565
I was going to say, I'm going to extrapolate for me.

1379
01:02:34.585 --> 01:02:36.185
When we go to the stars, this is how we do it.

1380
01:02:36.465 --> 01:02:43.231
We upgrade the cameras so we get higher resolution, which will then bring that one astral, that error bar down.

1381
01:02:43.251 --> 01:02:43.431
Yeah.

1382
01:02:43.752 --> 01:02:43.952
Right?

1383
01:02:44.372 --> 01:02:45.673
And we get that error bar down.

1384
01:02:45.693 --> 01:02:52.920
I mean, is there a theoretical situation here where on platform, like on the New Horizons 2.0,

1385
01:02:56.202 --> 01:03:02.465
It can get some sort of asynchronous update from our mapping of the whole universe, right?

1386
01:03:02.505 --> 01:03:03.586
Like happening in the background.

1387
01:03:04.006 --> 01:03:12.170
But it can be capturing live imagery and doing a calculation in real time because we're sort of feeding it this background algorithm.

1388
01:03:12.450 --> 01:03:13.011
Yeah, totally.

1389
01:03:13.271 --> 01:03:13.811
I mean, it could...

1390
01:03:16.012 --> 01:03:29.621
How I would design it is I would have a computer that would already have the information on where the relevant stars are and then use that to then just locally make the calculation.

1391
01:03:29.661 --> 01:03:31.882
You can have the LLM on your local machine.

1392
01:03:31.902 --> 01:03:32.122
Yeah.

1393
01:03:32.202 --> 01:03:33.523
You don't need to go to the cloud.

1394
01:03:33.763 --> 01:03:34.964
Although I don't want to hallucinate.

1395
01:03:35.244 --> 01:03:38.465
And this is an easy enough problem where I could just brute force it.

1396
01:03:38.785 --> 01:03:39.086
Fair.

1397
01:03:39.186 --> 01:03:40.986
I don't need a neural network here.

1398
01:03:41.167 --> 01:03:42.647
I think this is actually an important insight, though.

1399
01:03:42.667 --> 01:03:45.108
I might need a neural network to actually identify the dots.

1400
01:03:45.168 --> 01:03:47.890
But once I have identified the dots, right?

1401
01:03:48.010 --> 01:03:53.492
Because identifying dots is really good, like image recognition, in terms of object recognition stuff.

1402
01:03:53.552 --> 01:03:56.974
But once I have the dots, then it's just physics and geometry.

1403
01:03:57.614 --> 01:04:01.156
This, I think, is really important, though, because it allows...

1404
01:04:02.227 --> 01:04:05.469
untethered interstellar navigation.

1405
01:04:05.729 --> 01:04:06.630
Yes, exactly.

1406
01:04:06.670 --> 01:04:09.071
That's like the... That's the key.

1407
01:04:09.111 --> 01:04:09.672
That's the key.

1408
01:04:09.752 --> 01:04:14.114
Like, I don't want to depend on the Earth, which might be like very far away at some point.

1409
01:04:14.274 --> 01:04:18.697
Which also means you could imagine, right, that you have, you know, light sails like a

1410
01:04:18.897 --> 01:04:42.292
fleet of light sails or whatever that go out that have their own onboard system like you described but also because if you send a bunch of them directionally in like a close proximity but not you know over there they could also information share yeah right in their local context oh yeah and then like do like a hive mind type of thing right right where they're sensing right yeah the

1411
01:04:45.758 --> 01:04:46.819
learns to do self-driving.

1412
01:04:47.319 --> 01:04:52.785
I just... What I'm trying to do is really hone in on the import of...

1413
01:04:53.866 --> 01:05:01.575
It's the technical insight and what it unlocks is a totally different... You know those games like Age of Empire...

1414
01:05:02.175 --> 01:05:04.457
or civilizations.

1415
01:05:04.537 --> 01:05:04.978
Yeah, dude.

1416
01:05:05.018 --> 01:05:05.959
I play those all the time.

1417
01:05:05.979 --> 01:05:07.040
They have the technology tree.

1418
01:05:07.260 --> 01:05:07.540
Yes.

1419
01:05:07.600 --> 01:05:10.302
And the choices you make unlock different paths.

1420
01:05:10.322 --> 01:05:12.264
That's exactly, dude, yes, you're on it.

1421
01:05:12.364 --> 01:05:18.249
This is like why this kind of stuff, because now we have all of these 5,200 new doors to open.

1422
01:05:18.309 --> 01:05:19.350
New doors to open, yeah.

1423
01:05:19.370 --> 01:05:22.233
That if we had not made that kind of fundamental insight...

1424
01:05:22.613 --> 01:05:28.560
Which seems at this point, because we don't invest money in these things and we don't have wonder anymore and all that stuff.

1425
01:05:28.640 --> 01:05:29.060
Yeah.

1426
01:05:29.080 --> 01:05:32.324
But it has interesting implications.

1427
01:05:32.644 --> 01:05:34.946
Being able to have untethered navigation.

1428
01:05:35.959 --> 01:05:37.160
Like imagine having Google Maps.

1429
01:05:37.520 --> 01:05:37.680
Yeah.

1430
01:05:37.841 --> 01:05:38.501
Just offline.

1431
01:05:38.521 --> 01:05:38.701
Yeah.

1432
01:05:38.941 --> 01:05:42.304
But that can like update based on like cameras around your car.

1433
01:05:42.324 --> 01:05:43.125
Right.

1434
01:05:43.405 --> 01:05:44.026
That's kind of cool.

1435
01:05:44.046 --> 01:05:44.506
That's great.

1436
01:05:44.546 --> 01:05:44.766
Yeah.

1437
01:05:44.786 --> 01:05:46.708
I've been on my in my car with no service.

1438
01:05:46.728 --> 01:05:46.948
Yeah.

1439
01:05:47.268 --> 01:05:47.809
Several times.

1440
01:05:47.829 --> 01:05:47.949
Yeah.

1441
01:05:47.969 --> 01:05:51.532
But if like but if you're but if your computer just had the earth memorized.

1442
01:05:51.672 --> 01:05:51.812
Right.

1443
01:05:51.852 --> 01:05:52.032
Right.

1444
01:05:52.353 --> 01:05:56.336
And then like just looked around with all the cameras and been like, oh, I know that mountain.

1445
01:05:56.496 --> 01:05:56.696
Yeah.

1446
01:05:57.177 --> 01:05:58.177
And be like, oh, you're here.

1447
01:05:58.338 --> 01:05:59.458
This is that's right.

1448
01:05:59.539 --> 01:06:00.479
I think that's incredible.

1449
01:06:00.599 --> 01:06:01.300
Yeah.

1450
01:06:01.660 --> 01:06:03.422
I think it's I think it's a really cool concept.

1451
01:06:03.442 --> 01:06:03.602
Yeah.

1452
01:06:03.942 --> 01:06:07.046
And it's like the obvious thing to do, but like somebody's got to do it.

1453
01:06:07.466 --> 01:06:11.471
And New Horizons is a great probe because the camera is still working.

1454
01:06:11.511 --> 01:06:13.013
It's like in good condition.

1455
01:06:13.373 --> 01:06:13.533
Right.

1456
01:06:13.593 --> 01:06:15.355
Voyager is like barely holding on.

1457
01:06:15.676 --> 01:06:17.418
Like it launched in the 70s.

1458
01:06:17.478 --> 01:06:21.102
It's like, bro, just like I'll tell you I'm alive and that's it.

1459
01:06:21.162 --> 01:06:21.783
Don't ask me to.

1460
01:06:23.004 --> 01:06:23.464
Very.

1461
01:06:23.524 --> 01:06:28.725
And again, there is a delta between where we are now and like it being applied.

1462
01:06:28.745 --> 01:06:29.165
Yeah.

1463
01:06:29.265 --> 01:06:29.485
Yeah.

1464
01:06:29.565 --> 01:06:31.206
But somebody's got to make that first leap.

1465
01:06:31.246 --> 01:06:32.986
We have to start somewhere.

1466
01:06:33.066 --> 01:06:33.686
Yeah.

1467
01:06:33.886 --> 01:06:34.326
Someone.

1468
01:06:34.506 --> 01:06:38.867
We all get fried chicken, chicken wings, burgers, pizza.

1469
01:06:39.267 --> 01:06:41.708
Someone had to do it first.

1470
01:06:41.868 --> 01:06:42.068
Yeah.

1471
01:06:42.648 --> 01:06:45.429
And so that's why a lot of these stories are so important.

1472
01:06:45.709 --> 01:06:48.649
We have reached the point in the show.

1473
01:06:49.149 --> 01:06:49.810
Mystery box.

1474
01:06:50.750 --> 01:06:51.870
Mystery box time.

1475
01:06:52.882 --> 01:06:59.135
Krishna is going to bring forth a story of the day, of the week rather, that I know nothing about.

1476
01:06:59.596 --> 01:06:59.837
Yeah.

1477
01:07:00.297 --> 01:07:02.823
And this week, it's going to be.

1478
01:07:05.004 --> 01:07:06.185
About woo-woo.

1479
01:07:06.966 --> 01:07:08.687
Ah, mind-body woo-woo.

1480
01:07:09.948 --> 01:07:11.610
I gave you that little preview, right?

1481
01:07:11.650 --> 01:07:12.791
Mind-body woo-woo.

1482
01:07:12.971 --> 01:07:16.294
As LA residents, we're big fans of the mind-body woo-woo.

1483
01:07:16.314 --> 01:07:17.475
Yeah, mind-body woo-woo.

1484
01:07:17.495 --> 01:07:18.075
This one's real.

1485
01:07:18.355 --> 01:07:18.596
Okay?

1486
01:07:18.876 --> 01:07:25.361
So this is a story that involves brain scans, blood tests, and Google's Oculus.

1487
01:07:25.762 --> 01:07:26.262
Okay.

1488
01:07:26.621 --> 01:07:28.884
The VR system sounds like a party I don't want to go to.

1489
01:07:28.924 --> 01:07:29.765
Yeah.

1490
01:07:30.245 --> 01:07:33.790
I think I've been to one of those parties and it was not fun.

1491
01:07:33.830 --> 01:07:34.931
No.

1492
01:07:35.412 --> 01:07:37.855
But fundamentally, let me ask you a question.

1493
01:07:37.875 --> 01:07:38.115
Okay.

1494
01:07:38.175 --> 01:07:38.395
Okay.

1495
01:07:39.196 --> 01:07:43.602
When you get sick or when you get exposed to a pathogen, how does your body respond?

1496
01:07:44.422 --> 01:07:45.423
There's an immune response.

1497
01:07:45.463 --> 01:07:46.363
Yeah, I get sweaty.

1498
01:07:46.403 --> 01:07:47.063
I get a fever.

1499
01:07:47.143 --> 01:07:47.943
Yeah, you get a fever.

1500
01:07:48.043 --> 01:07:50.124
Your immune system goes up.

1501
01:07:50.684 --> 01:07:57.047
Your first responders in the immune system are like, okay, I'm going to start attacking whoever's coming in.

1502
01:07:57.507 --> 01:07:58.827
Right?

1503
01:07:59.547 --> 01:08:04.109
What if you just thought that you were getting sick?

1504
01:08:05.504 --> 01:08:06.004
Wait a minute.

1505
01:08:06.205 --> 01:08:06.445
Okay.

1506
01:08:07.906 --> 01:08:08.926
I have, this is funny.

1507
01:08:09.507 --> 01:08:09.847
Yeah.

1508
01:08:10.187 --> 01:08:12.268
Not even, what if you just thought that you were getting sick?

1509
01:08:12.309 --> 01:08:15.210
What if you just saw a sick person near you?

1510
01:08:15.451 --> 01:08:15.711
Uh-huh.

1511
01:08:17.352 --> 01:08:17.592
Okay.

1512
01:08:18.734 --> 01:08:23.758
It turns out the body has the same response.

1513
01:08:24.719 --> 01:08:27.942
The immune system starts working.

1514
01:08:29.003 --> 01:08:34.587
Even if you see a sick person near you, that's what's, it's crazy.

1515
01:08:34.867 --> 01:08:38.070
This makes so much sense.

1516
01:08:38.390 --> 01:08:38.691
Really?

1517
01:08:39.231 --> 01:08:39.491
Yes.

1518
01:08:39.952 --> 01:08:40.292
I want it.

1519
01:08:40.412 --> 01:08:42.033
This is again, mystery box.

1520
01:08:42.053 --> 01:08:42.774
So, so,

1521
01:08:45.205 --> 01:08:45.765
Okay, go on.

1522
01:08:45.785 --> 01:08:46.306
No, no.

1523
01:08:46.346 --> 01:08:50.188
So, my wife and I, I tell her this all the time.

1524
01:08:50.208 --> 01:08:50.609
Yeah.

1525
01:08:50.669 --> 01:08:57.473
When I fly, I've gotten sick almost every time I've flown in the last 6 to 12 months, which is brand new for me.

1526
01:08:58.174 --> 01:08:58.354
Yeah.

1527
01:09:00.027 --> 01:09:05.210
In one of the recent times I flew out, I told her, I was like, I'm just gonna, I'm not getting sick.

1528
01:09:05.490 --> 01:09:05.710
Yeah.

1529
01:09:05.850 --> 01:09:10.332
And I'm like, I'm just gonna think I'm not gonna get sick and I won't get sick.

1530
01:09:10.652 --> 01:09:10.912
Okay.

1531
01:09:11.453 --> 01:09:12.153
And it has worked.

1532
01:09:12.333 --> 01:09:12.933
And it has worked.

1533
01:09:13.013 --> 01:09:14.154
Since I've started saying that.

1534
01:09:14.714 --> 01:09:18.216
But this idea of me making eye contact with someone with the sniffles.

1535
01:09:19.296 --> 01:09:20.877
And then your immune system responding.

1536
01:09:21.417 --> 01:09:23.738
The like background system being like, oh.

1537
01:09:23.758 --> 01:09:24.019
Yeah.

1538
01:09:24.159 --> 01:09:24.959
That's what this is.

1539
01:09:24.999 --> 01:09:26.940
That's, that makes, but it makes sense though.

1540
01:09:27.280 --> 01:09:27.961
That's what this is.

1541
01:09:28.141 --> 01:09:29.522
I mean, it kind of makes sense.

1542
01:09:29.582 --> 01:09:30.543
It's a survival mechanism.

1543
01:09:30.723 --> 01:09:33.986
Yeah, yeah, no, that's exactly what the authors of this paper are arguing.

1544
01:09:34.367 --> 01:09:45.417
But to me, no, to me, what's incredible is like your nervous system is like prying your immune system.

1545
01:09:46.438 --> 01:09:47.159
You know what I mean?

1546
01:09:47.339 --> 01:09:52.563
Like, it's this, like, this connection between mind and body that's, like, so real.

1547
01:09:52.603 --> 01:09:55.045
So, let me describe to you before we get into it, okay?

1548
01:09:55.065 --> 01:09:55.286
Go ahead.

1549
01:09:55.506 --> 01:09:57.327
Let me describe to you what the experiment was.

1550
01:09:57.467 --> 01:09:57.688
Yes.

1551
01:09:57.768 --> 01:09:59.789
And then how they concluded all this stuff.

1552
01:09:59.829 --> 01:10:01.891
Because it's pretty interesting.

1553
01:10:01.971 --> 01:10:02.191
Okay.

1554
01:10:02.532 --> 01:10:05.314
So, they got these volunteers, okay?

1555
01:10:05.614 --> 01:10:06.635
Split them up into two groups.

1556
01:10:06.855 --> 01:10:07.036
Mm-hmm.

1557
01:10:07.856 --> 01:10:08.077
Okay.

1558
01:10:09.438 --> 01:10:13.263
First group, you had these volunteers put on VR headsets.

1559
01:10:13.783 --> 01:10:14.023
Okay.

1560
01:10:14.524 --> 01:10:22.253
These are virtual reality because, okay, you know, ethically, if you want to do this kind of experiment, you can't like literally expose people to sick people.

1561
01:10:22.393 --> 01:10:22.593
All right.

1562
01:10:22.673 --> 01:10:23.334
Like, all right.

1563
01:10:23.715 --> 01:10:23.915
Okay.

1564
01:10:24.135 --> 01:10:26.016
So let's get past that.

1565
01:10:26.956 --> 01:10:27.396
What do you do?

1566
01:10:27.456 --> 01:10:29.417
You put on the Google's Oculus.

1567
01:10:29.517 --> 01:10:39.101
OK. And you got one group that has like like people with like rashes and like like sniffles and like coughs they approach in this virtual reality world.

1568
01:10:39.181 --> 01:10:39.441
OK.

1569
01:10:40.081 --> 01:10:42.865
And the other group just has like normal people approach.

1570
01:10:42.925 --> 01:10:43.125
Okay.

1571
01:10:43.325 --> 01:10:45.849
And then there's a third group that gets flu shots.

1572
01:10:46.349 --> 01:10:46.569
Okay.

1573
01:10:46.830 --> 01:10:56.842
So the first two groups, the Oculus group, Oculus group that gets the rashes and the coughs, they're being exposed to visible visual stimuli of sick people.

1574
01:10:57.463 --> 01:11:02.708
The second group in the Oculus cohort, they get exposed to normal people.

1575
01:11:03.108 --> 01:11:05.810
And then the third group get exposed to real pathogens, right?

1576
01:11:05.830 --> 01:11:13.176
Because a flu shot is like some kind of like sort of dead virus, but it's still a virus and it's going to create an immune response.

1577
01:11:13.196 --> 01:11:14.938
That's the whole point of a vaccine.

1578
01:11:15.578 --> 01:11:15.799
Okay.

1579
01:11:16.119 --> 01:11:20.002
So what they found was that the group that had...

1580
01:11:21.243 --> 01:11:29.249
the Oculus VR experience with the rashes and the coughs had the same kind of immune response as the people who had the vaccine.

1581
01:11:30.610 --> 01:11:32.991
Get the F out of here.

1582
01:11:33.092 --> 01:11:34.192
And that's not all, okay?

1583
01:11:34.493 --> 01:11:44.260
So they went a little bit further, and they actually did EEG, which is electroencephalography, like on their brains, where you attach a bunch of electrodes to the skull to try to see what brain areas are active.

1584
01:11:44.520 --> 01:11:50.124
And they also did MRI imaging on the brain to see which brain areas became active during that time.

1585
01:11:50.844 --> 01:11:59.291
And the part of the brain that became active was the frontal and the parietal cortex, like up here, which has to do with something called the...

1586
01:11:59.451 --> 01:12:00.792
It's like a preemptive response.

1587
01:12:00.852 --> 01:12:06.176
It's the part of the body that deals with the stuff that is near you.

1588
01:12:06.296 --> 01:12:06.636
Yeah.

1589
01:12:06.756 --> 01:12:11.340
Like this sense of self and personal space.

1590
01:12:11.380 --> 01:12:11.760
Yeah.

1591
01:12:12.201 --> 01:12:12.741
Okay.

1592
01:12:12.821 --> 01:12:13.642
Your little aura bubble.

1593
01:12:13.662 --> 01:12:13.902
Yes.

1594
01:12:13.982 --> 01:12:14.202
Yes.

1595
01:12:14.242 --> 01:12:15.583
Your aura bubble.

1596
01:12:15.683 --> 01:12:17.705
It activated the peripersonal...

1597
01:12:19.026 --> 01:12:46.086
space system okay so now you've got this like mechanistic understanding right where it's like okay I see sick people the part of my brain that deals with like my body and like the immediate surroundings of my body are being triggered and then that triggers yeah and that triggers the lymphatic system and the immune system to then release these things called ILCs which are innate lymphoid cells which are like the first responders yeah

1598
01:12:46.766 --> 01:12:46.946
Right.

1599
01:12:46.966 --> 01:12:54.372
So then when you did the blood test on the patients on the on the volunteers, you get like the same level of these ILCs that people with.

1600
01:12:55.753 --> 01:12:57.735
Like it's it's it's so weird.

1601
01:12:57.775 --> 01:13:04.060
This is like it's like it's like a conscious like a conscious observation.

1602
01:13:05.538 --> 01:13:07.380
triggered like an immune response.

1603
01:13:07.620 --> 01:13:14.626
The way I was thinking about it in my head is like the immune system has akin to giving a computer computer vision, right?

1604
01:13:14.786 --> 01:13:15.027
Yeah.

1605
01:13:15.207 --> 01:13:17.329
It's like giving the immune system access.

1606
01:13:17.429 --> 01:13:17.689
Yeah.

1607
01:13:17.969 --> 01:13:21.492
I mean, it always had this, but this is the first time we measured it, right?

1608
01:13:21.513 --> 01:13:22.834
Like it can...

1609
01:13:23.454 --> 01:13:29.915
And it's like, at some point, it's like, yeah, of course, the brain, of course, there's like, there's like some subconscious pathway, right?

1610
01:13:30.115 --> 01:13:30.295
Sure.

1611
01:13:30.315 --> 01:13:34.676
That is going to see that and then, and then trigger the immune system.

1612
01:13:34.776 --> 01:13:34.936
Yeah.

1613
01:13:35.156 --> 01:13:35.356
Right.

1614
01:13:35.416 --> 01:13:43.417
Just like how, like, things are triggered by stress and things are triggered by, but it's, it's, it's a very, I like the way that they did the experiment.

1615
01:13:43.498 --> 01:13:44.598
I was literally going to say.

1616
01:13:44.618 --> 01:13:46.178
With the VR and with the.

1617
01:13:46.258 --> 01:13:47.638
I think that's the, that's the interesting thing.

1618
01:13:47.658 --> 01:13:51.799
It's like, even in this manufactured.

1619
01:13:53.806 --> 01:13:57.129
Because you could argue, like, if it's human to human, it's real life, right?

1620
01:13:57.490 --> 01:14:05.558
There is something that is subtly different about, like, the real-world interaction versus an abstraction via the VR headset.

1621
01:14:05.898 --> 01:14:09.402
What's almost most fascinating is that it still activates.

1622
01:14:10.123 --> 01:14:10.523
Yeah.

1623
01:14:10.623 --> 01:14:13.366
Yeah, like, obviously, they knew they were in Oculus.

1624
01:14:13.686 --> 01:14:13.907
Right.

1625
01:14:14.047 --> 01:14:14.467
Right.

1626
01:14:14.988 --> 01:14:17.532
Like they were consciously aware that they're in a VR system.

1627
01:14:17.572 --> 01:14:24.201
But like still the subconscious part of the pathway was like, that person's got a rash.

1628
01:14:24.421 --> 01:14:30.550
Like, you know, like whatever neural network is working in the background, identifying like.

1629
01:14:31.747 --> 01:14:33.328
That's like sick people.

1630
01:14:33.508 --> 01:14:35.489
You know when people say, I feel like I'm getting it.

1631
01:14:35.509 --> 01:14:36.489
Like they get that feeling.

1632
01:14:36.509 --> 01:14:36.749
Yeah.

1633
01:14:36.869 --> 01:14:38.850
That they feel like they know they're about to get sick.

1634
01:14:39.191 --> 01:14:40.771
It's kind of like this interaction.

1635
01:14:40.791 --> 01:14:40.931
Yeah.

1636
01:14:40.971 --> 01:14:41.152
Yeah.

1637
01:14:41.272 --> 01:14:41.952
And so.

1638
01:14:42.012 --> 01:14:42.252
Yeah.

1639
01:14:42.372 --> 01:14:43.212
And like.

1640
01:14:44.313 --> 01:14:44.633
Yeah.

1641
01:14:44.673 --> 01:14:45.093
Wait.

1642
01:14:45.293 --> 01:14:45.834
That's cool.

1643
01:14:45.874 --> 01:14:47.835
That's actually really, really cool.

1644
01:14:48.035 --> 01:14:48.255
Yeah.

1645
01:14:48.275 --> 01:14:52.897
The experimental design is interesting because it sort of creates one interesting degree of separation like we just talked about.

1646
01:14:53.037 --> 01:14:53.157
Yeah.

1647
01:14:53.417 --> 01:14:58.320
And the fact that the system still has similar activation levels.

1648
01:14:58.560 --> 01:14:58.780
Yeah.

1649
01:14:59.841 --> 01:15:25.384
with a digital I mean there's so many like weird implications of that because you could again you probably extrapolate there's a lot of people who've had concerns about like digital companions and VR and it's ability to affect your like emotional yeah but this is going even beyond that it's not even it's like it's like the subconscious immune system thing that I didn't even know I could control but like visible stimuli is now controlling it

1650
01:15:25.664 --> 01:15:38.591
Which sort of brings up this like issue of like, okay, so that means, right, like all of our forms of visual consumption, regardless of whether it's real life.

1651
01:15:38.631 --> 01:15:39.431
Like on the phone.

1652
01:15:39.511 --> 01:15:40.492
Or digital.

1653
01:15:40.552 --> 01:15:41.292
Yeah.

1654
01:15:41.612 --> 01:15:45.114
Is having this, at least in this context.

1655
01:15:45.174 --> 01:15:46.354
Wow, I didn't even think about that.

1656
01:15:46.374 --> 01:15:46.955
You know what I'm saying?

1657
01:15:46.975 --> 01:15:49.396
Like that implications of that are actually kind of crazy.

1658
01:15:49.416 --> 01:15:50.897
That is kind of crazy shit.

1659
01:15:50.937 --> 01:15:51.177
Yeah.

1660
01:15:51.537 --> 01:15:53.558
Like, which is why it's interesting.

1661
01:15:53.578 --> 01:15:55.959
They did VR with it for ethical reasons.

1662
01:15:55.999 --> 01:15:56.980
Yeah.

1663
01:15:57.440 --> 01:15:58.540
No, but no, you're right.

1664
01:15:58.621 --> 01:15:59.941
It's like, where does that stop?

1665
01:16:00.101 --> 01:16:00.822
Yeah.

1666
01:16:00.942 --> 01:16:04.483
It's like the content that I consume digitally.

1667
01:16:04.964 --> 01:16:07.465
How much is that shaping like a subconscious

1668
01:16:08.700 --> 01:16:08.920
Yes.

1669
01:16:09.281 --> 01:16:10.922
Part of me, like my body.

1670
01:16:11.002 --> 01:16:11.202
Yes.

1671
01:16:11.562 --> 01:16:13.304
More than my mind at this point, right?

1672
01:16:13.504 --> 01:16:18.668
You would maybe make the argument that with VR, because it more closely mimics your normal perception.

1673
01:16:19.128 --> 01:16:19.388
Yeah.

1674
01:16:19.488 --> 01:16:20.249
I mean, that's the point.

1675
01:16:20.329 --> 01:16:22.371
That probably has a higher... Yeah.

1676
01:16:22.451 --> 01:16:22.671
Yeah.

1677
01:16:23.011 --> 01:16:23.391
Whatever.

1678
01:16:23.612 --> 01:16:23.812
Yes.

1679
01:16:23.852 --> 01:16:24.072
Yes.

1680
01:16:24.092 --> 01:16:24.312
Yes.

1681
01:16:24.392 --> 01:16:26.694
But it's not a steep cutoff, right?

1682
01:16:26.734 --> 01:16:32.979
There's going to be some... And so the question is, what is the delta between the VR context versus the...

1683
01:16:33.239 --> 01:16:35.361
Anyway, I didn't even think about that, dude.

1684
01:16:35.381 --> 01:16:36.903
This is why we love Mystery Box.

1685
01:16:36.923 --> 01:16:38.024
That's crazy.

1686
01:16:38.185 --> 01:16:39.706
What a great story, dude.

1687
01:16:40.047 --> 01:16:41.668
Yeah, I saw this.

1688
01:16:41.768 --> 01:16:44.011
I was like, oh, dude, Lester's going to love this.

1689
01:16:44.231 --> 01:16:44.692
Oh, my God.

1690
01:16:44.712 --> 01:16:45.753
I hate being sick.

1691
01:16:46.153 --> 01:16:47.174
It's the worst thing ever.

1692
01:16:47.214 --> 01:16:47.455
Yeah.

1693
01:16:47.675 --> 01:16:50.838
However, it is good to know, you know...

1694
01:16:51.599 --> 01:16:52.681
Don't look at the sick people.

1695
01:16:53.321 --> 01:16:53.562
Yeah.

1696
01:16:53.882 --> 01:16:54.082
Yeah.

1697
01:16:54.143 --> 01:16:54.323
Yeah.

1698
01:16:54.343 --> 01:16:55.584
Just don't look at them, dude.

1699
01:16:56.025 --> 01:16:56.446
It's like that.

1700
01:16:56.466 --> 01:16:57.707
What is that?

1701
01:16:57.847 --> 01:16:59.470
It's not like there's those.

1702
01:16:59.510 --> 01:17:05.137
Well, but then your immune system won't get primed and then maybe you will actually get sick.

1703
01:17:05.237 --> 01:17:06.699
So this is chicken and egg.

1704
01:17:06.819 --> 01:17:07.440
Damn if you do.

1705
01:17:07.720 --> 01:17:08.421
Damn if you don't.

1706
01:17:09.082 --> 01:17:15.806
With that, we are going to wrap up this week's episode of From First Principles.

1707
01:17:16.126 --> 01:17:25.592
I am your host again, Lester Nare, joined by my co-host and the smartest person I know, as well as our resident PhD, Krishna Chaudhary.

1708
01:17:25.632 --> 01:17:26.893
You need to get more friends, mate.

1709
01:17:29.174 --> 01:17:30.194
We'll see you guys next week.

1710
01:17:30.455 --> 01:17:30.775
Peace.
