WEBVTT

1
00:00:01.067 --> 00:00:11.954
Welcome to HSBC Global Viewpoint, the podcast series that brings together business leaders and industry experts to explore the latest global insights, trends, and opportunities.

2
00:00:12.755 --> 00:00:15.316
Make sure you're subscribed to stay up to date with new episodes.

3
00:00:15.676 --> 00:00:17.858
Thanks for listening, and now onto today's show.

4
00:00:22.295 --> 00:00:25.716
Welcome to the HSBC Perspectives podcast series.

5
00:00:25.816 --> 00:00:26.776
My name is Fred Newman.

6
00:00:26.796 --> 00:00:29.357
I'm a chief Asia economist here at HSBC.

7
00:00:29.377 --> 00:00:39.460
I'm delighted to welcome Michael Pettis, senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace and really a renowned China scholar, international scholar.

8
00:00:39.500 --> 00:00:44.241
Michael, you've been commenting on China and the world for decades now.

9
00:00:44.341 --> 00:00:47.242
So your books, published books on the matters.

10
00:00:47.262 --> 00:00:49.182
We're delighted to be here, that you're here.

11
00:00:49.382 --> 00:00:51.163
And you're still a Beijing native.

12
00:00:51.883 --> 00:00:52.604
Pretty much so.

13
00:00:52.704 --> 00:00:53.284
Thank you, Fred.

14
00:00:53.484 --> 00:00:54.165
Yes.

15
00:00:54.545 --> 00:00:58.507
Now, I wanted to start really on the domestic Chinese economic situation.

16
00:00:58.547 --> 00:01:01.329
Now, we read a lot about weak consumer spending.

17
00:01:01.369 --> 00:01:07.593
The economy is still growing, but how would you characterize how the economy looks from your perspective?

18
00:01:07.613 --> 00:01:09.794
Sitting in Beijing, is it soft?

19
00:01:09.854 --> 00:01:12.896
Is it, I mean, there's a lot of investment tech coming through.

20
00:01:12.956 --> 00:01:16.598
How would you characterize the growth perspective right now?

21
00:01:16.898 --> 00:01:22.081
The thing everyone is saying, the thing everyone's been talking about is the famous current K-shaped economy.

22
00:01:22.701 --> 00:01:28.164
So you have a part of the economy that's doing extremely well, the high-tech part, the AI part, etc.

23
00:01:28.824 --> 00:01:32.506
And then you have much of the economy doing extremely poorly.

24
00:01:33.566 --> 00:01:48.312
And the hope within Beijing is that by continuing to invest in the high KK value added new productive forces, you can eventually shift the entire Chinese economy from the lower leg of VK to the upper leg of VK.

25
00:01:48.332 --> 00:01:53.834
So is this like a trickle down kind of theory where you think one part of the economy pulls the other one with it?

26
00:01:54.835 --> 00:01:57.076
And probably as effective as trickle-down.

27
00:01:57.116 --> 00:01:59.097
In other words, it's not going to be terribly effective.

28
00:01:59.717 --> 00:02:03.320
The upward part of decay is really, really small.

29
00:02:04.200 --> 00:02:08.283
The vast majority of the economy is really on the downward part of decay.

30
00:02:09.003 --> 00:02:17.308
And although there's always difficulties in quantifying it, unemployment is probably quite high in China.

31
00:02:17.348 --> 00:02:18.949
Officially, as you know, it's 5, 5.1%.

32
00:02:21.190 --> 00:02:34.402
Unofficially, if you include all of the people who've given up job hunts and gone home, one very well-known Chinese academic very close to the government said a month ago that is about 10.2%.

33
00:02:34.923 --> 00:02:39.126
What really surprised us was not the number, but that he was able to say it so openly.

34
00:02:39.947 --> 00:02:46.211
And in addition, there's been explosive growth in employment in the Gedi economy.

35
00:02:46.231 --> 00:02:50.893
You know, Gedi, which is the Chinese Uber and the motorcycle, Gliberty guys.

36
00:02:51.434 --> 00:02:56.917
And we don't really know how to include those numbers, but if you included those numbers into the unemployment,

37
00:02:57.357 --> 00:03:00.581
we would probably see easily double-gigit unemployment.

38
00:03:01.041 --> 00:03:03.243
So they're in a pretty tough position.

39
00:03:03.604 --> 00:03:11.132
They need to shift or they plan to shift, I think it's impractical, out of the old part of the economy into the new part of the economy.

40
00:03:11.952 --> 00:03:15.376
Until they do that, it'll be very hard to regenerate growth.

41
00:03:15.436 --> 00:03:29.542
Now, if you observe the Chinese economy, there are tremendous technological advances, just eye-popping, really, if you think about autonomous driving, if you think about even some of the semiconductor advances, AI, for example.

42
00:03:30.943 --> 00:03:36.806
But you're characterizing that as being insufficient to pull the rest of the economy along.

43
00:03:36.846 --> 00:03:39.887
In other words, the trickle down is not enough.

44
00:03:41.107 --> 00:03:46.269
Is it just a question of the size, of the small size of the advanced K shape that's going up?

45
00:03:46.369 --> 00:03:49.990
Or is there something else that's kind of blocking that trickle-down mechanism?

46
00:03:50.510 --> 00:03:51.630
That's a great question.

47
00:03:51.890 --> 00:03:56.011
And what I would argue is the answer is probably two things.

48
00:03:56.191 --> 00:03:57.612
One, it's simply not big enough.

49
00:03:57.672 --> 00:04:02.173
The vast majority of employment is not in the good part of the economy, it's in the bad part.

50
00:04:02.813 --> 00:04:14.646
But more importantly, while China has spectacular technology, spectacular infrastructure, all of this really great stuff, it's not very clear that any of that is economically viable, right?

51
00:04:14.726 --> 00:04:19.111
Of course, China, where it is very successful is in terms of its exports.

52
00:04:19.331 --> 00:04:22.174
So China is gaining global export market share.

53
00:04:22.934 --> 00:04:25.497
And that speaks to its competitiveness.

54
00:04:26.178 --> 00:04:33.425
How sustainable is it that you have an economy of China size grow through exports over time?

55
00:04:33.465 --> 00:04:36.788
Because there is a risk of saturating global markets.

56
00:04:36.808 --> 00:04:41.412
There is protectionist perhaps reaction in the U.S. with terrorists right now.

57
00:04:41.452 --> 00:04:43.754
We've seen some friction with Europe.

58
00:04:43.774 --> 00:04:46.097
How viable a growth path is it?

59
00:04:47.050 --> 00:05:00.337
Well, if you exclude a few periods where countries like the United States were running massive surpluses to supply Europe and Japan, who had been devastated by war, we've never seen these level of imbalances.

60
00:05:00.357 --> 00:05:04.859
We've never seen such a large economy depend so heavily on exports.

61
00:05:05.740 --> 00:05:07.640
And the reason is pretty straightforward.

62
00:05:08.281 --> 00:05:12.263
In China, everything is focused towards subsidizing production.

63
00:05:12.923 --> 00:05:15.346
As you know, domestic demand is incredibly weak.

64
00:05:15.946 --> 00:05:24.875
If you produce a lot of stuff and you can't absorb it at home through consumption of investments, then by definition, you must absorb it through net exploits.

65
00:05:24.935 --> 00:05:25.816
And that's what's happening.

66
00:05:26.606 --> 00:05:37.170
You talk about imbalances and we mentioned the Chinese economic imbalances to some extent, but isn't that also reflected then in overseas economic balance?

67
00:05:37.210 --> 00:05:43.452
I'm thinking about the United States, for example, having the opposite problem, absorbing more that they can produce or save.

68
00:05:43.973 --> 00:05:46.854
How do you look at that if you look at US and China?

69
00:05:47.774 --> 00:05:49.735
Is that imbalance really just one side?

70
00:05:49.775 --> 00:05:50.375
Is it China?

71
00:05:50.495 --> 00:05:53.416
Or is there also kind of the issue on the other side?

72
00:05:53.576 --> 00:05:55.077
How do you relate the two imbalances?

73
00:05:55.757 --> 00:05:59.119
By definition, it's impossible to have an imbalance on one side, right?

74
00:05:59.319 --> 00:06:02.261
If there's an imbalance on one side, there must be an imbalance on the other.

75
00:06:02.901 --> 00:06:09.545
And by coincidence, or maybe not coincidence, my next book, which will come out in April, really tries to address that.

76
00:06:10.005 --> 00:06:12.247
So there are two theories, or there are three theories.

77
00:06:12.387 --> 00:06:17.050
One theory is that the imbalances exist because the Americans save too little.

78
00:06:17.850 --> 00:06:23.854
And so they force the Chinese to save a lot in order to accommodate very low saving in the U.S.,

79
00:06:24.934 --> 00:06:32.202
The second theory is that China saves too much for structural reasons, and those savings have to go abroad.

80
00:06:32.283 --> 00:06:39.310
And by definition, when savings are exported, if they're exported to developing countries, they result in a rise in investment.

81
00:06:39.350 --> 00:06:45.097
And if they're exported to advanced economies, they result in a reduction in saving in the advanced economy.

82
00:06:45.677 --> 00:06:53.663
And then the third theory, which is quite silly, but implicitly it's what most people believe, is that the U.S. has a deficit because of internal reasons.

83
00:06:54.144 --> 00:06:56.526
China has a surplus because of internal reasons.

84
00:06:57.126 --> 00:07:05.213
And through some lucky coincidence or perhaps because there's a special God who orders these things, both imbalances are always perfectly matched.

85
00:07:05.813 --> 00:07:07.855
So I think that's where the debate is.

86
00:07:08.075 --> 00:07:10.357
I would argue that if you look at the Chinese economy,

87
00:07:10.877 --> 00:07:22.745
It's very hard to argue that the imbalances in the Chinese economy, which are the most extreme in history, are a result of China's need to accommodate low-sated in the U.S.

88
00:07:22.805 --> 00:07:24.006
I would turn it around.

89
00:07:24.887 --> 00:07:30.291
And I would also argue that it's more likely for a country that controls its external account...

90
00:07:31.031 --> 00:07:37.258
to export domestic imbalances than it is for a country that doesn't control those external accounts.

91
00:07:37.298 --> 00:07:45.527
So what I would argue is that as the Chinese imbalances adjust, much of the remaining imbalances in the world would also adjust.

92
00:07:46.268 --> 00:07:50.632
And that brings us then to policy solutions, potentially.

93
00:07:50.692 --> 00:08:07.308
So if there is a need to rebalance the mainland Chinese economy, and that would ultimately also help to rebalance other economies by extension, is a prescription here to revive demand in China through a big fiscal stimulus?

94
00:08:07.488 --> 00:08:09.710
Is it to go through the effects?

95
00:08:10.330 --> 00:08:17.653
exchange rate, for example, how would you, what would be your policy advice to address some of these imbalances?

96
00:08:18.253 --> 00:08:21.034
Well, I don't think there's any big secret here, Fred.

97
00:08:21.534 --> 00:08:26.316
For nearly 20 years, there's been recognition that China needs to increase consumption.

98
00:08:27.136 --> 00:08:37.860
And for at least five years, there's been discussion, at least privately among Chinese economists, that the only substantial way to do that is to increase the household income share of GDP.

99
00:08:38.680 --> 00:08:40.863
And in the last year, that's gone quite public.

100
00:08:40.903 --> 00:08:43.686
You can see it in People's Daily, in Seixian, everywhere.

101
00:08:44.066 --> 00:08:46.749
We need to raise the household income share of GDP.

102
00:08:47.089 --> 00:08:48.251
But how do you do that?

103
00:08:49.712 --> 00:08:57.941
One way is to reduce the share that goes to government or business, simply transfer income from those sectors.

104
00:08:58.682 --> 00:09:09.232
That's incredibly difficult to do because governments are really struggling with revenues and businesses are really struggling with profits.

105
00:09:09.292 --> 00:09:13.736
So anything that you do there would be either disruptive politically or economically.

106
00:09:14.356 --> 00:09:23.721
The other possibility is the one that you mentioned, an increasing number of Chinese economists and foreign economists to say, expand your fiscal expenditures.

107
00:09:25.302 --> 00:09:28.784
And the problem there is that I don't think people understand this.

108
00:09:28.924 --> 00:09:34.307
China already has the highest debt in the world after Japan, the deputy GDP ratio.

109
00:09:34.527 --> 00:09:35.408
You mean public debt?

110
00:09:36.189 --> 00:09:36.749
Total debt.

111
00:09:36.789 --> 00:09:37.029
Total.

112
00:09:37.310 --> 00:09:43.876
And in total debt, China's debt-to-GDP ratio is officially 320%.

113
00:09:44.297 --> 00:09:50.083
But more importantly, it's rising at a rate that we have never seen in history.

114
00:09:50.383 --> 00:09:52.846
So to give you a comparison, Satan, the U.S.,

115
00:09:53.406 --> 00:10:00.528
A lot of people are worried that debt will rise by 10 percentage points of GDP over the next five to 10 years.

116
00:10:01.028 --> 00:10:04.629
Well, as you know, in China, we do more than that every year.

117
00:10:04.990 --> 00:10:06.950
Last year, it grew by 12 percentage points.

118
00:10:06.990 --> 00:10:09.151
This year, it's on track to grow by more than that.

119
00:10:09.951 --> 00:10:11.051
So that's the problem.

120
00:10:11.171 --> 00:10:15.893
If you increase the fiscal deficit now to direct funding into the household sector,

121
00:10:16.433 --> 00:10:26.461
We're talking about taking the fastest growing fiscal back asset, the fastest growing debt leverage of the world, and significantly expanding it.

122
00:10:27.102 --> 00:10:29.584
And the question there is, can you really do that?

123
00:10:29.664 --> 00:10:34.368
And if so, how much longer can you do that before you run into debt capacity constraints?

124
00:10:34.788 --> 00:10:36.149
But what is in this solution?

125
00:10:36.169 --> 00:10:39.632
Because a fiscal expansion is not necessarily a good solution.

126
00:10:40.793 --> 00:10:43.255
What other ways are there then to rebalance?

127
00:10:44.871 --> 00:10:59.302
I had dinner with an advisor to one of the presidents, one of the largest countries in Europe, and he said, we need a solution that will make the Americans happy, that'll make the Chinese happy, and that'll make Europe happy.

128
00:11:00.903 --> 00:11:03.946
And my response was, I don't think that solution exists.

129
00:11:04.767 --> 00:11:06.969
And so it's the same thing that I would answer to you.

130
00:11:07.249 --> 00:11:09.952
Is there a good solution that'll make everyone happy?

131
00:11:10.072 --> 00:11:10.693
I doubt it.

132
00:11:10.773 --> 00:11:14.557
I think it's really difficult to make this adjustment.

133
00:11:15.137 --> 00:11:17.079
And if you look at the historical track records

134
00:11:17.840 --> 00:11:36.306
Any country that has had very, very low consumption and very rapid growth in debt, along with a large trade surplus, we've seen this many times before, never as extreme as China's, but we've seen this many times before, they always adjust either in the form of an economic contraction, like the US did in the 1930s,

135
00:11:37.706 --> 00:11:42.829
Or in the form of decades of stagnation like Chip had it after 1991.

136
00:11:43.509 --> 00:11:50.313
So I'm not sure there's a way to do this that doesn't involve a significant slowdown in growth.

137
00:11:52.162 --> 00:12:01.407
Michael, we could talk to you for hours about this very complex and nuanced topic, of course, and I'm conscious we just touched the tip of the iceberg here.

138
00:12:01.487 --> 00:12:08.050
But for anybody who wants to follow up, you have a whole range of publications, and you have a book coming out as well.

139
00:12:08.491 --> 00:12:12.713
So maybe that's where some of our listeners can take up the analysis.

140
00:12:12.733 --> 00:12:16.435
But I want to thank you very much, and thank you very much for joining us.

141
00:12:16.755 --> 00:12:17.355
Thank you, Fred.

142
00:12:17.455 --> 00:12:20.463
Thank you for joining us at HSBC Global Viewpoint.

143
00:12:20.904 --> 00:12:22.308
We hope you enjoyed the discussion.

144
00:12:23.070 --> 00:12:25.736
Make sure you're subscribed to stay up to date with new episodes.
