WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.451 --> 00:00:11.056
If you took like one of those mini donuts from Dunkin Donuts and you put it on the moon, that's how big those black hole donuts would be.

2
00:00:11.556 --> 00:00:18.659
What they've done is create a digital twin, a personalized 3D computer simulation of the patient's heart.

3
00:00:19.219 --> 00:00:20.160
Okay, here's how they do it.

4
00:00:20.800 --> 00:00:24.702
It's also like fairly clear from the video that it hit something.

5
00:00:25.677 --> 00:00:25.977
Right?

6
00:00:26.378 --> 00:00:27.319
How do we explain?

7
00:00:27.379 --> 00:00:28.660
It's like, I don't know.

8
00:00:29.180 --> 00:00:32.163
It's fairly clear from the video that there's a change in momentum.

9
00:00:32.724 --> 00:00:35.786
How is it that the IMU on the ball did not pick it up?

10
00:00:35.966 --> 00:00:37.108
Both things can be true.

11
00:00:37.308 --> 00:00:38.088
Hello, Internet.

12
00:00:38.128 --> 00:00:47.437
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

13
00:00:47.857 --> 00:00:50.740
We are back for one of our first questions.

14
00:00:51.020 --> 00:00:54.641
rundown episodes after all of our specials.

15
00:00:54.701 --> 00:01:00.524
If you haven't caught our America 250 or our World Cup episode, be sure to check that.

16
00:01:00.624 --> 00:01:17.830
This week, we're going to cover some of our favorite discoveries and stories in science over the last few months while we've been away, including astronomers who caught a supermassive black hole reversing its magnetic field, researchers developing a digital twin,

17
00:01:18.650 --> 00:01:30.682
for your human heart to kind of help physicians with diagnostics, a new ultrasonic CT scanner that uses nothing but sound waves and a pool of water.

18
00:01:31.323 --> 00:01:40.552
And we have two follow-up stories on the World Cup, including the Norway versus England ball tracking controversy.

19
00:01:40.953 --> 00:01:41.433
And we may...

20
00:01:41.433 --> 00:01:45.496
They sneak in a little segment of Are You Smarter Than a Scientist?

21
00:01:46.016 --> 00:01:56.924
Oh, and the other World Cup story is the science behind favoritism and home field advantage, which was clearly not in effect for any of the host nations in this World Cup.

22
00:01:57.284 --> 00:02:04.269
As always, we are going to talk about the science from the ground up today, because this is From First Principle.

23
00:02:19.540 --> 00:02:22.762
So our first story comes from the Event Horizon Telescope.

24
00:02:23.823 --> 00:02:30.967
I'm sure you remember back in 2019, they imaged a black hole for the first time.

25
00:02:31.047 --> 00:02:33.449
And there were so many memes, cat memes.

26
00:02:34.389 --> 00:02:36.811
It was the first black hole that was ever photographed.

27
00:02:36.931 --> 00:02:40.573
I think the first image actually is the cat meme that I want to show everyone.

28
00:02:40.593 --> 00:02:42.475
It's the black hole.

29
00:02:42.495 --> 00:02:45.096
And then as you zoom out, it's the cat eyes.

30
00:02:45.196 --> 00:02:46.157
I thought that was pretty funny.

31
00:02:46.477 --> 00:02:49.739
It was all over social media because it's such a big deal, right?

32
00:02:50.040 --> 00:02:54.963
For the longest time, black holes are things of theory.

33
00:02:55.503 --> 00:03:01.908
It's confined to the theory departments in physics and no one else really like messed with it.

34
00:03:03.417 --> 00:03:10.560
In the late 1990s, Andrea Ghez, among others, started imaging the black hole at the center of our Milky Way.

35
00:03:10.920 --> 00:03:14.901
But what I mean by that is they were really imaging the stars around the black hole, right?

36
00:03:14.981 --> 00:03:28.766
And they were looking at the star trails, and you could see that there was some mass that was massive, millions of times the mass of the sun, that was ringing these stars around in these Keplerian orbits.

37
00:03:29.466 --> 00:03:31.527
And so there had to be a black hole in there.

38
00:03:32.267 --> 00:03:45.374
But to actually image a black hole, right, where you've got an event horizon, you've got the accretion disk around it, that is going to take an insane amount of technology and an insane amount of coordination from the entire globe.

39
00:03:45.834 --> 00:03:56.259
So this is a follow-up story to that 2019 photograph, where now you can imagine in 2019 they photographed for the first time the black hole.

40
00:03:58.045 --> 00:03:59.606
It's been about seven years.

41
00:04:00.788 --> 00:04:11.838
You can image over and over and create a movie of a black hole, of the accretion disk revolving around a black hole and all of the weird physics that happens around that black hole.

42
00:04:11.938 --> 00:04:12.118
Right.

43
00:04:12.158 --> 00:04:13.939
So now you can start testing the theories.

44
00:04:14.340 --> 00:04:19.965
And it's such a cool thing that we are able to do because of all the technology that we have.

45
00:04:20.325 --> 00:04:31.951
So if you start from the beginning, right, most of the photos that you see of the black hole, like that cat meme, that is of M87, which is this galaxy, 55 million light years away.

46
00:04:32.591 --> 00:04:36.613
It was first discovered in 1781 as part of the Messier catalog.

47
00:04:37.034 --> 00:04:43.637
Charles Messier was a French comet astronomer, and he was basically like trying to hunt for comets.

48
00:04:43.897 --> 00:04:45.358
That was his big passion.

49
00:04:46.348 --> 00:04:48.072
And when you hunt for comets, what do you do?

50
00:04:48.092 --> 00:04:51.701
You basically point the telescope at the sky and you look for fuzzy objects.

51
00:04:53.325 --> 00:04:55.029
But those fuzzy objects have to move.

52
00:04:56.065 --> 00:05:03.351
So in order to distinguish the ones that are moving from the ones that are not, he created a catalog of all the things that he should be ignoring.

53
00:05:03.831 --> 00:05:11.518
And that became the Messier catalog, which is now much more important than all of his comet research.

54
00:05:11.858 --> 00:05:16.061
You know, he was trying to basically find comets and he made a list of stuff to ignore.

55
00:05:16.381 --> 00:05:16.582
Like...

56
00:05:17.603 --> 00:05:21.667
You know when you're coding or something and it's like ignore this flag, ignore this flag?

57
00:05:21.707 --> 00:05:24.029
That was him with the entire Night Sky.

58
00:05:24.069 --> 00:05:27.052
He created this giant catalog and turns out he cataloged

59
00:05:27.972 --> 00:05:38.501
I think something like on the order of hundreds, if not maybe a thousand objects that are now like nebulae, galaxies, other things that are close to the Milky Way and close to the sun.

60
00:05:38.602 --> 00:05:47.289
This is like a classic story in science, which is kind of like our Hubble story with the deep field we did a few episodes ago, which is let's point this at a...

61
00:05:48.230 --> 00:05:49.151
A space of nothing.

62
00:05:49.171 --> 00:05:49.311
Yeah.

63
00:05:49.511 --> 00:05:49.731
Yeah.

64
00:05:49.831 --> 00:05:50.792
And see what happens.

65
00:05:50.852 --> 00:05:52.153
And everyone's like, what?

66
00:05:52.233 --> 00:05:53.754
And it became one of the most important things ever.

67
00:05:53.774 --> 00:06:04.342
And it's like sometimes, you know, you stumble upon discoveries and just being serendipitous is really important in the process because it does still.

68
00:06:04.822 --> 00:06:09.586
Again, in this case, it's a little bit annoying because he's like, I care about this thing and I'm known for this other thing.

69
00:06:09.646 --> 00:06:10.827
But it's like you still did the work.

70
00:06:11.047 --> 00:06:20.434
No, and I don't think he would mind if he was alive today that all of these objects have the prefix M and then the object right in front.

71
00:06:20.534 --> 00:06:30.241
Everybody knows M87 in astrophysics because this is the closest large supermassive active galactic nuclei to the Milky Way.

72
00:06:30.321 --> 00:06:34.544
It's only 55 million light years away, which is actually quite close.

73
00:06:34.585 --> 00:06:37.907
The Andromeda galaxy is 2 million light years away.

74
00:06:37.987 --> 00:06:43.450
So this is only like, what, 20 to 30 times as distant as the Andromeda galaxy?

75
00:06:43.490 --> 00:06:47.093
So it's really in our local, you know, we're talking about tens of millions.

76
00:06:47.453 --> 00:06:49.454
The universe is tens of billions, right?

77
00:06:49.514 --> 00:06:51.915
So this is very local to us.

78
00:06:52.076 --> 00:06:53.757
It's in the constellation Virgo.

79
00:06:54.817 --> 00:06:59.120
And, you know, to your point, it's one of those things where...

80
00:07:00.103 --> 00:07:03.645
cataloging negative results was actually a good thing.

81
00:07:04.306 --> 00:07:05.386
In science, everybody...

82
00:07:05.606 --> 00:07:11.530
If you want to publish in science and nature and sell, you have to come up with results and positive results.

83
00:07:11.550 --> 00:07:12.991
It's like, oh, I did an experiment.

84
00:07:13.051 --> 00:07:14.072
I had a hypothesis.

85
00:07:14.412 --> 00:07:15.593
The hypothesis worked.

86
00:07:15.953 --> 00:07:21.116
Here, he was just cataloging negative things because he thought, these are the stuff that I want to ignore.

87
00:07:21.716 --> 00:07:25.259
And it turns out the negative results in this particular scientific endeavor...

88
00:07:26.079 --> 00:07:28.241
was the most important thing that he did in his life, right?

89
00:07:28.641 --> 00:07:29.022
Kind of cool.

90
00:07:29.242 --> 00:07:29.442
Right.

91
00:07:30.383 --> 00:07:39.531
So anyways, it turns out to be one of the largest galaxies in our neighborhood, and it's the most studied supermassive black hole in history.

92
00:07:39.951 --> 00:07:41.453
If you go back to that photo, actually.

93
00:07:42.093 --> 00:07:42.814
Photo number two.

94
00:07:42.894 --> 00:07:43.895
Yes, photo number two.

95
00:07:44.936 --> 00:07:52.722
Notice, it's an elliptical galaxy, so it doesn't have a lot of structure, which means it's full of old stars and it's massive.

96
00:07:53.503 --> 00:07:57.146
It's not a spiral galaxy in the sense that the Milky Way or the Andromeda galaxy is.

97
00:07:57.646 --> 00:08:01.670
And also, there's this giant jet.

98
00:08:02.030 --> 00:08:05.633
It's like a hose coming out of that center, right?

99
00:08:07.654 --> 00:08:11.998
When people saw that using the radio astronomy that was...

100
00:08:13.614 --> 00:08:17.906
built up after World War II, people were like, that's really weird.

101
00:08:17.926 --> 00:08:18.868
Because, one...

102
00:08:19.844 --> 00:08:25.187
You can actually measure the speed of that jet, and it's very, very close to the speed of light.

103
00:08:25.427 --> 00:08:27.869
At some point, people were actually saying super luminous.

104
00:08:28.169 --> 00:08:29.990
It was higher than the speed of light.

105
00:08:30.030 --> 00:08:41.277
Turns out it was like, it's not an error, but there's like some weird physics going on that like makes it seem like the stuff is moving faster than the speed of light, but really it's like kind of a group velocity type thing.

106
00:08:41.497 --> 00:08:45.999
The actual stuff is not actually moving faster than the speed of light, but maybe some phenomenon is.

107
00:08:46.640 --> 00:08:46.800
Yeah.

108
00:08:48.796 --> 00:09:01.178
When people saw that, they were like, there's got to be something really energetic at the center of that thing that is causing a giant jet to form that's like many light years ago.

109
00:09:02.676 --> 00:09:03.176
In size.

110
00:09:03.256 --> 00:09:11.761
What is creating the inciting, what is creating the force that is enabling us to image this particular situation?

111
00:09:11.961 --> 00:09:17.985
Yeah, like if you've got a hose, right, and the hose produces a jet that's light years long.

112
00:09:18.105 --> 00:09:19.025
It's a pretty strong hose.

113
00:09:19.045 --> 00:09:21.086
The hose has to be insanely strong.

114
00:09:21.186 --> 00:09:23.888
And so that's where we get the idea of active galactic nuclei.

115
00:09:24.048 --> 00:09:29.331
The idea that there could be a supermassive black hole at the center that is creating so much energy.

116
00:09:29.771 --> 00:09:41.777
from accreting matter into the black hole, that that heat and that magnetic field and that plasma is shooting out a bunch of material at this incredibly high speed.

117
00:09:42.017 --> 00:09:45.459
So this is the first sort of indication that, yes, black holes are real.

118
00:09:45.859 --> 00:09:46.480
And perhaps...

119
00:09:48.661 --> 00:09:50.822
we can study it in a really, really precise way.

120
00:09:51.322 --> 00:09:52.763
Okay?

121
00:09:53.503 --> 00:09:55.884
Then in 2019, we got two images.

122
00:09:56.484 --> 00:10:01.207
These amazing images that popped up all over social media, took over the entire globe.

123
00:10:01.547 --> 00:10:04.748
On the left is the black hole of M87.

124
00:10:05.369 --> 00:10:08.190
The center is probably where the event horizon is.

125
00:10:08.750 --> 00:10:09.030
Okay?

126
00:10:09.190 --> 00:10:09.371
Right.

127
00:10:09.391 --> 00:10:09.991
That's where...

128
00:10:10.371 --> 00:10:11.812
The dark spot in the middle.

129
00:10:11.852 --> 00:10:13.753
Yeah, that's really what the black hole is.

130
00:10:13.813 --> 00:10:20.377
But obviously, a black hole is somewhere, is a region of space where nothing can escape, not even light.

131
00:10:20.557 --> 00:10:22.659
So if light can't escape, how do you image it?

132
00:10:22.919 --> 00:10:27.021
Well, what you're really imaging is the accretion disk around the black hole.

133
00:10:27.262 --> 00:10:29.903
And I want to take a quick moment for our audio listeners.

134
00:10:30.103 --> 00:10:32.665
You know, many of you will have seen this image.

135
00:10:33.185 --> 00:10:35.307
It looks like a glazed donut.

136
00:10:35.347 --> 00:10:35.527
Right.

137
00:10:36.227 --> 00:10:36.467
Right.

138
00:10:36.487 --> 00:10:39.049
You have that orange glow, the black center.

139
00:10:39.649 --> 00:10:42.631
And it was very big in this time period.

140
00:10:42.671 --> 00:10:45.452
But that is the image we're looking at, too.

141
00:10:45.512 --> 00:10:47.413
But that is one of the two that we're looking at.

142
00:10:47.433 --> 00:10:48.674
And then you'll get to the second here.

143
00:10:48.714 --> 00:10:49.154
Exactly.

144
00:10:49.434 --> 00:10:51.816
And so the one on the left is the one at M87.

145
00:10:52.116 --> 00:10:54.057
That's 55 million light years away.

146
00:10:54.157 --> 00:10:54.757
OK. OK.

147
00:10:55.297 --> 00:10:56.118
The one on the right.

148
00:10:57.980 --> 00:11:00.883
And you can see the size of that relative to the one on the left.

149
00:11:01.023 --> 00:11:01.223
Yes.

150
00:11:01.283 --> 00:11:02.164
Right?

151
00:11:02.204 --> 00:11:03.946
The one on the right, you can see the inset.

152
00:11:04.327 --> 00:11:09.932
It would fit very neatly inside the black hole, inside the event horizon of M87.

153
00:11:10.193 --> 00:11:13.856
The one on the right is our puny little black hole of the Milky Way.

154
00:11:14.277 --> 00:11:14.617
Ah, okay.

155
00:11:14.637 --> 00:11:14.917
Okay?

156
00:11:15.058 --> 00:11:15.258
Yes.

157
00:11:15.718 --> 00:11:19.182
And it's quite amazing that...

158
00:11:20.552 --> 00:11:23.817
The M87 black hole is so much bigger than the Milky Way.

159
00:11:24.658 --> 00:11:25.779
Right?

160
00:11:25.859 --> 00:11:30.786
It's probably in the way these images are scaled, we would say maybe it's...

161
00:11:31.949 --> 00:11:33.890
Two and a half to three and a half times.

162
00:11:34.070 --> 00:11:34.310
Yeah.

163
00:11:34.750 --> 00:11:35.491
Scale-wise.

164
00:11:35.571 --> 00:11:35.811
Mm-hmm.

165
00:11:36.051 --> 00:11:38.652
I will say that the R is...

166
00:11:38.712 --> 00:11:40.753
I think it's... Is it Sagittarius A?

167
00:11:40.773 --> 00:11:41.514
Hey, Sagittarius A.

168
00:11:41.554 --> 00:11:41.774
Exactly.

169
00:11:41.794 --> 00:11:42.434
Sagittarius A.

170
00:11:42.874 --> 00:11:44.535
Kind of looks like a bagel.

171
00:11:44.875 --> 00:11:45.335
Yeah.

172
00:11:45.555 --> 00:11:46.716
A little more bagel-shaped.

173
00:11:46.736 --> 00:11:48.457
Yeah, compared to the neat donut.

174
00:11:48.477 --> 00:11:49.217
Donut shape.

175
00:11:49.537 --> 00:11:50.778
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

176
00:11:50.938 --> 00:11:52.539
And that's probably...

177
00:11:54.356 --> 00:12:01.284
It's probably a feature of the fact that M87 is so big that the accretion disc is more uniform and it's farther away.

178
00:12:01.545 --> 00:12:03.407
So you're not getting the nitty-gritty details.

179
00:12:03.547 --> 00:12:04.668
Yeah, makes sense.

180
00:12:04.889 --> 00:12:11.116
Now, the relative size of these photos, you can see that in terms of the relative size, they look about the same.

181
00:12:11.296 --> 00:12:12.017
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

182
00:12:12.137 --> 00:12:13.739
That's because in the sky...

183
00:12:14.540 --> 00:12:43.050
relative size wise they look about the same it's just that the milky way black hole sagittarius a star by the way it's not sagittarius a the star star means that we're talking about the the black hole that's that's always like that's all the m87 you see the m87 star yes that means we're talking about the black hole and when we say star we we mean asterisk asterisk yeah yeah but in in colloquial language 100 yeah just for people who might be viewing it that's what we're referring to as the exactly yeah so whenever you see like that that means we're talking about the black hole at the

184
00:12:44.470 --> 00:12:47.351
And the two are about the same size in the sky.

185
00:12:47.371 --> 00:12:51.851
So this is how big they would look if we could like zoom in, zoom in, zoom in.

186
00:12:51.911 --> 00:12:56.172
It's just that the Milky Way, even though it's so much smaller, it's so much closer to us.

187
00:12:56.212 --> 00:12:58.633
It's only 100,000 light years, right?

188
00:12:58.993 --> 00:13:00.733
Compared to the 55 million light years.

189
00:13:00.753 --> 00:13:05.994
So even though the M87 is actually way bigger, it could fit the entire Milky Way black hole inside.

190
00:13:06.154 --> 00:13:09.375
Because it's so far away, the size of it looks about the same.

191
00:13:09.415 --> 00:13:10.915
So now that brings me to my second point.

192
00:13:12.015 --> 00:13:16.476
That photograph is really, really small in the night sky.

193
00:13:16.736 --> 00:13:17.016
Okay.

194
00:13:17.336 --> 00:13:21.398
That thing is about 50 micro arc seconds across.

195
00:13:21.558 --> 00:13:24.278
So let's get to how actually big that is.

196
00:13:24.338 --> 00:13:24.518
Right.

197
00:13:25.119 --> 00:13:28.600
So this is from the Babylonian time.

198
00:13:28.620 --> 00:13:30.060
I want to quickly.

199
00:13:30.100 --> 00:13:31.760
40 micro, not 50.

200
00:13:31.940 --> 00:13:32.381
Oh, yeah.

201
00:13:32.461 --> 00:13:34.281
Well, 40 to 50.

202
00:13:34.301 --> 00:13:36.202
There's like a scale bar in there that says 40.

203
00:13:36.682 --> 00:13:36.962
It's like.

204
00:13:37.722 --> 00:13:40.823
It's nebulous like, okay, if I measure this way, it's like 60.

205
00:13:40.883 --> 00:13:42.704
If I measure this way, it's 40.

206
00:13:42.724 --> 00:13:43.244
You know what I mean?

207
00:13:43.284 --> 00:13:43.884
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

208
00:13:43.904 --> 00:13:44.845
No, no, totally fair.

209
00:13:44.945 --> 00:13:45.445
Totally fair.

210
00:13:45.465 --> 00:13:45.605
Yeah.

211
00:13:45.945 --> 00:13:50.987
But at the end of the day, it's something like tens of micro arc seconds across, right?

212
00:13:51.187 --> 00:13:51.387
Yes.

213
00:13:51.507 --> 00:13:53.968
Now, how big actually is that in the night sky?

214
00:13:54.288 --> 00:13:59.830
So astronomers use the degree system that we have inherited from the Babylonians to

215
00:14:00.090 --> 00:14:02.492
And they just took that to the extreme.

216
00:14:02.512 --> 00:14:03.632
Shout out to the Babylonians.

217
00:14:03.652 --> 00:14:05.533
Yeah, shout out to the Babylonians way back.

218
00:14:05.573 --> 00:14:07.835
They said a full circle is 360 degrees.

219
00:14:08.215 --> 00:14:12.658
So the astronomers said, okay, a full circle in the night sky is 360 degrees.

220
00:14:13.178 --> 00:14:18.982
So a single degree is 1 360th of a full circle.

221
00:14:19.062 --> 00:14:19.642
That makes sense.

222
00:14:20.022 --> 00:14:22.124
The moon is about half a degree.

223
00:14:22.744 --> 00:14:27.006
which means it would take 720 moons lined up to make a full circle.

224
00:14:27.146 --> 00:14:27.906
Does that make sense?

225
00:14:28.046 --> 00:14:28.206
Yes.

226
00:14:28.246 --> 00:14:28.406
Right?

227
00:14:28.626 --> 00:14:30.027
So the moon is about half a degree.

228
00:14:30.367 --> 00:14:36.269
Each degree has 60 arc minutes, and each minute has 60 arc seconds, right?

229
00:14:36.289 --> 00:14:41.751
The same way that we use hours and minutes and seconds in, like, normal timekeeping.

230
00:14:42.292 --> 00:14:44.452
So that's the idea.

231
00:14:44.532 --> 00:14:44.993
You've got...

232
00:14:47.118 --> 00:14:51.539
You got half a degree, so that's 30 arc minutes is the moon, right?

233
00:14:51.599 --> 00:14:53.479
Because an hour would be a full degree.

234
00:14:53.779 --> 00:14:53.979
Yes.

235
00:14:54.319 --> 00:14:54.580
Okay.

236
00:14:54.900 --> 00:15:00.541
So the moon is 30 arc minutes, which means it's 60 arc seconds to a minute.

237
00:15:00.821 --> 00:15:03.881
So that's 1,800 arc seconds.

238
00:15:04.421 --> 00:15:04.621
Yes.

239
00:15:04.801 --> 00:15:04.981
Right?

240
00:15:05.201 --> 00:15:08.302
So imagine taking the moon and dividing it up into 1,800.

241
00:15:08.382 --> 00:15:09.662
That's a single arc second.

242
00:15:10.002 --> 00:15:12.923
And then now a micro arc second is a millionth of that.

243
00:15:14.472 --> 00:15:16.414
To give you an idea, you see that donut?

244
00:15:16.734 --> 00:15:17.875
Remember that donut?

245
00:15:18.215 --> 00:15:28.821
If you took one of those mini donuts from Dunkin' Donuts and you put it on the moon, that's how big those black hole donuts would be.

246
00:15:29.362 --> 00:15:30.663
Does that make sense?

247
00:15:30.683 --> 00:15:31.463
That's crazy!

248
00:15:32.984 --> 00:15:34.865
That's crazy that that's what we're imaging.

249
00:15:34.905 --> 00:15:35.125
Right.

250
00:15:35.325 --> 00:15:39.567
Like, if you want to put it into terrestrial terms.

251
00:15:39.767 --> 00:15:43.469
You're saying we put a munchkin on the moon.

252
00:15:43.609 --> 00:15:43.869
Yeah.

253
00:15:44.129 --> 00:15:45.970
And then we imaged it from here.

254
00:15:46.030 --> 00:15:46.531
From Earth.

255
00:15:46.591 --> 00:15:47.371
From ground.

256
00:15:47.391 --> 00:15:49.292
And we're looking at a munchkin on the moon.

257
00:15:49.332 --> 00:15:49.572
Yeah.

258
00:15:50.132 --> 00:15:50.953
That's what we're talking about.

259
00:15:50.973 --> 00:15:51.933
That's what we're talking about.

260
00:15:52.313 --> 00:15:56.556
And if you want to put it into terrestrial terms, it's like an ant.

261
00:15:56.576 --> 00:15:57.396
Yeah.

262
00:16:00.177 --> 00:16:26.485
on the empire state building viewed from los angeles which for those who are not familiar with the u.s geography is that's across the continent it's across the continent yeah yeah okay or like or like from new york to paris okay you could do you could do that if you want which is so i think the point you're trying to point out here is the level of precision over the scale of distance is outrageous on its face

263
00:16:26.665 --> 00:16:27.266
Yes.

264
00:16:27.746 --> 00:16:28.907
It's incredible.

265
00:16:29.227 --> 00:16:31.930
And the thing is, that donut, it wasn't just a donut.

266
00:16:31.950 --> 00:16:33.631
We could see details in the donut.

267
00:16:33.831 --> 00:16:36.954
So the resolution we're getting is like insane.

268
00:16:37.255 --> 00:16:37.415
Right?

269
00:16:37.435 --> 00:16:39.296
We're getting sprinkles on the donut.

270
00:16:39.336 --> 00:16:40.698
Like which side has sprinkles?

271
00:16:40.798 --> 00:16:41.939
Is it a Boston cream?

272
00:16:41.999 --> 00:16:43.100
Is it sprinkles?

273
00:16:43.180 --> 00:16:46.283
What is the one that has the little crumpled edges on it?

274
00:16:46.483 --> 00:16:47.163
Oh, I hate those.

275
00:16:47.984 --> 00:16:49.165
I only like glazed.

276
00:16:49.305 --> 00:16:50.266
Plain glazed.

277
00:16:50.286 --> 00:16:51.027
Plain glazed.

278
00:16:52.088 --> 00:16:52.228
But...

279
00:16:53.248 --> 00:16:55.229
It's incredible that we're able to do this, right?

280
00:16:55.269 --> 00:17:06.613
And to give you an idea, right, we've actually covered the tyranny of resolution when it comes to astronomy plenty of times on this podcast.

281
00:17:07.253 --> 00:17:11.975
There's a fundamental physics issue with trying to resolve stuff, okay?

282
00:17:12.115 --> 00:17:12.215
Yeah.

283
00:17:12.235 --> 00:17:12.395
Yeah.

284
00:17:12.895 --> 00:17:16.779
So, light at the end of the day is a wave, right?

285
00:17:16.859 --> 00:17:21.524
And so, if I have two, let's say I have two light bulbs that are right next to each other.

286
00:17:21.924 --> 00:17:25.147
If they're right in front of my face, of course I can discern them, right?

287
00:17:25.427 --> 00:17:31.893
Because my eye acts like a tiny little telescope and it creates an image in the back of my retina.

288
00:17:32.714 --> 00:17:43.900
And if the light bulb A goes to a certain part of my retina and light bulb B goes to another part of my retina, then I can discern that there are two light bulbs.

289
00:17:43.960 --> 00:17:47.641
Because these rods and cones are saying, hey, I'm seeing a light bulb over here.

290
00:17:47.922 --> 00:17:50.983
These rods and cones are saying, hey, I see a light bulb over here, right?

291
00:17:51.203 --> 00:17:55.445
And so the two light bulbs are not overlapping in my detector.

292
00:17:55.825 --> 00:17:57.366
And therefore, I can discern the two.

293
00:17:58.427 --> 00:17:59.047
Now, what?

294
00:17:59.770 --> 00:18:10.239
There comes something called the rally limit, which is if I take those two light bulbs, those two points of light, let's say tiny little LEDs, and I take them really, really far away, all of a sudden they merge into one LED.

295
00:18:10.519 --> 00:18:10.820
Why?

296
00:18:11.320 --> 00:18:11.500
Right.

297
00:18:11.921 --> 00:18:12.481
Why?

298
00:18:12.681 --> 00:18:16.705
Because the LEDs, the image in my retina is now getting overlapped.

299
00:18:17.205 --> 00:18:18.647
Because of the wave nature of light.

300
00:18:18.967 --> 00:18:31.981
My pupil is only this big, and so the wave nature of light is going to, like, diffract in my pupil, and that's going to cause a blurring effect that is just purely due to the wave nature of light.

301
00:18:32.282 --> 00:18:33.703
There's nothing I can do about it.

302
00:18:33.984 --> 00:18:37.107
There's no, like, oh, put it in a vacuum, put it in cold.

303
00:18:37.127 --> 00:18:37.227
Yeah.

304
00:18:38.068 --> 00:18:38.428
Nothing.

305
00:18:39.049 --> 00:18:46.615
Because of the distance and the fundamentals of how light travels over distance.

306
00:18:47.315 --> 00:18:58.785
As you increase that distance away from our own detectors, which are our eyes, the farther the distance away, the more overlap will happen between two independent light sources.

307
00:18:59.485 --> 00:19:00.766
They could be very far away.

308
00:19:00.946 --> 00:19:01.607
Yeah.

309
00:19:01.647 --> 00:19:06.851
But the farther you go away, it becomes hard to discern that there's a gap between these two.

310
00:19:07.031 --> 00:19:07.271
Yes.

311
00:19:07.411 --> 00:19:10.013
And so how do we do anything, right?

312
00:19:10.673 --> 00:19:13.515
Well, we make the detector bigger, right?

313
00:19:13.575 --> 00:19:14.696
We make our telescope bigger.

314
00:19:14.756 --> 00:19:16.677
The eye is a terrible detector.

315
00:19:16.697 --> 00:19:19.839
It's only about like less than a centimeter in diameter.

316
00:19:20.720 --> 00:19:22.141
That's why we have large telescopes.

317
00:19:22.301 --> 00:19:23.542
The larger the telescope...

318
00:19:24.382 --> 00:19:28.266
The smaller the angular resolution that you can have, right?

319
00:19:29.266 --> 00:19:35.652
Or I should say the greater the angular resolution, the smaller the angular distance you can discern between two independent points.

320
00:19:35.672 --> 00:19:36.993
Which is why we continue to speak.

321
00:19:37.033 --> 00:19:40.235
Why do we need to make bigger and bigger telescopes?

322
00:19:40.456 --> 00:19:40.676
Right.

323
00:19:40.756 --> 00:19:48.943
Because the bigger we make them, this is why, for example, between Hubble and JWST, we have fuzzy versus less fuzzy.

324
00:19:49.103 --> 00:19:51.645
There's different wavelengths in there and there's details.

325
00:19:51.665 --> 00:19:51.785
Right.

326
00:19:51.885 --> 00:19:52.105
Yes.

327
00:19:52.205 --> 00:19:59.311
But fundamentally speaking, we have giant Magellan that's coming out versus regular Magellan.

328
00:19:59.531 --> 00:20:01.253
Why do you need to make a bigger Magellan?

329
00:20:01.273 --> 00:20:01.493
Yeah.

330
00:20:01.593 --> 00:20:03.434
Because we like 4K TV.

331
00:20:03.514 --> 00:20:03.795
Yes.

332
00:20:03.915 --> 00:20:05.296
We don't like 720p.

333
00:20:05.536 --> 00:20:05.736
No.

334
00:20:05.796 --> 00:20:08.178
We don't like fuzzy CRT TV.

335
00:20:08.478 --> 00:20:10.820
We want to see every blade of grass.

336
00:20:10.860 --> 00:20:13.522
We want to see every teardrop that comes from the face.

337
00:20:13.843 --> 00:20:19.908
And you can get that from making your detector larger in order to resolve light.

338
00:20:19.928 --> 00:20:20.248
Yeah.

339
00:20:20.608 --> 00:20:41.369
to more of a level a better level of granularity exactly and if we're not going to settle for 720p on our tvs we shouldn't settle for it in astronomy you know you know what i'm saying yes come on guys 100 um so so the rally limit that's that's that's the fundamental trade-off that we have okay right now there's two ways to make your resolution better okay

340
00:20:43.230 --> 00:20:49.134
The smallest angular resolution, the smallest angular distance that you can discern is given by the Rayleigh limit.

341
00:20:49.474 --> 00:20:55.638
It's effectively the wavelength of the light divided by the diameter of your aperture, the diameter of your telescope.

342
00:20:55.658 --> 00:20:57.259
This is something that we've been over a lot, right?

343
00:20:57.699 --> 00:20:58.641
And it kind of makes sense.

344
00:20:58.661 --> 00:21:03.347
The smaller the wavelength of the light, the less it's going to, like, bend around your detector.

345
00:21:03.687 --> 00:21:06.451
And so you can maybe discern smaller and smaller things.

346
00:21:06.511 --> 00:21:09.335
The bigger the detector, the smaller the thing you can discern.

347
00:21:09.355 --> 00:21:11.138
That's why the detector is in the denominator.

348
00:21:11.418 --> 00:21:12.920
The wavelength is in the numerator.

349
00:21:13.241 --> 00:21:13.481
Okay.

350
00:21:14.022 --> 00:21:14.242
So...

351
00:21:15.123 --> 00:21:19.326
Suppose we go for radio wavelengths, like millimeter wavelengths.

352
00:21:19.466 --> 00:21:20.446
So it's not quite radio.

353
00:21:20.466 --> 00:21:21.787
It's like millimeter.

354
00:21:21.987 --> 00:21:23.948
So it's like shortwave radio.

355
00:21:24.128 --> 00:21:24.249
Yeah.

356
00:21:24.269 --> 00:21:24.449
Okay.

357
00:21:24.849 --> 00:21:26.790
So about like 1.3 millimeters.

358
00:21:27.771 --> 00:21:32.553
And I'll get into why we want to do radio and not optical, which is at the hundreds of nanometers.

359
00:21:32.614 --> 00:21:32.814
Right.

360
00:21:33.994 --> 00:21:41.339
So suppose we want to do radio wavelengths and we want to image a donut on the moon.

361
00:21:42.220 --> 00:21:49.301
Okay, we can calculate, okay, we want to image at the level of like single micro arc seconds.

362
00:21:51.090 --> 00:21:54.593
Plug that into the theta of the Raleigh criterion.

363
00:21:55.354 --> 00:21:57.936
The lambda is 1.3 millimeters.

364
00:21:58.557 --> 00:22:00.258
So how big should my diameter be?

365
00:22:00.819 --> 00:22:06.823
The diameter turns out to be 10,000 kilometers.

366
00:22:06.843 --> 00:22:08.125
That's quite large.

367
00:22:08.185 --> 00:22:08.585
Quite large.

368
00:22:09.806 --> 00:22:16.792
What it's saying is in order to image a donut on the moon with radio wavelengths,

369
00:22:17.838 --> 00:22:21.999
I need a detector, a radio telescope the size of the Earth.

370
00:22:22.720 --> 00:22:23.820
10,000 kilometers.

371
00:22:23.960 --> 00:22:24.660
Take it or leave it.

372
00:22:25.000 --> 00:22:25.841
That's what physics says.

373
00:22:26.181 --> 00:22:29.022
Let's get a Dyson sphere going, baby.

374
00:22:29.702 --> 00:22:34.564
Well, these guys created like a telescope sphere around the Earth, effectively.

375
00:22:34.624 --> 00:22:34.884
Okay?

376
00:22:35.124 --> 00:22:36.784
The next video shows you how they did it.

377
00:22:37.144 --> 00:22:39.005
They said, okay, this is what it is, right?

378
00:22:39.305 --> 00:22:40.966
We need a telescope the size of the Earth.

379
00:22:41.026 --> 00:22:41.266
Yes.

380
00:22:41.746 --> 00:22:43.186
We can't build a single telescope.

381
00:22:43.226 --> 00:22:44.607
What we're going to do is rig up.

382
00:22:45.440 --> 00:22:53.782
a bunch of radio telescopes all across the globe, and they're all going to communicate with each other and take independent images of this thing.

383
00:22:54.082 --> 00:23:00.083
Now, our light-gathering power is not going to be that high because the detector is not the size of the Earth.

384
00:23:00.143 --> 00:23:06.325
But our resolution capacity is going to be the size of the Earth because I'm able to take...

385
00:23:06.865 --> 00:23:10.008
light from this part of the detector and this part of the detector.

386
00:23:10.268 --> 00:23:13.392
So there's, there's two detectors in Chile.

387
00:23:13.712 --> 00:23:15.454
There's one in Tucson.

388
00:23:15.474 --> 00:23:17.175
There's one in Hawaii.

389
00:23:17.215 --> 00:23:19.217
There's one in Northern Africa, California,

390
00:23:20.098 --> 00:23:25.584
And as the Earth rotates, you use the Earth's rotation to image the black hole.

391
00:23:26.585 --> 00:23:27.386
Isn't that sick?

392
00:23:28.207 --> 00:23:35.754
And this is what is so brilliant about this is how resourceful it is, which is we're saying we don't have Dyson spheres.

393
00:23:35.814 --> 00:23:37.776
We're not going to build a 10.

394
00:23:37.797 --> 00:23:40.439
Yeah, we're not civilization stage for whatever.

395
00:23:40.459 --> 00:23:41.160
Whatever it is.

396
00:23:41.200 --> 00:23:41.620
Right, right.

397
00:23:42.381 --> 00:23:43.842
In the comments, tell me what it is.

398
00:23:44.002 --> 00:23:48.346
We don't have enough political social collaboration to pull something like that off at this moment in humanity.

399
00:23:48.706 --> 00:23:56.092
So we say, okay, we have these detection platforms all over the surface of the earth.

400
00:23:56.532 --> 00:24:07.200
And because they are covering the surface of the earth in these different latitude, longitude positions, we can image the same object at distance.

401
00:24:07.420 --> 00:24:07.660
Yeah.

402
00:24:07.841 --> 00:24:10.343
But from these different points on the planet.

403
00:24:10.363 --> 00:24:10.523
Yeah.

404
00:24:11.103 --> 00:24:21.975
And then we can basically blend the results from that to create what would effectively be the same thing as having a 10 kilometer wide singular device.

405
00:24:22.035 --> 00:24:22.216
Yeah.

406
00:24:22.416 --> 00:24:26.380
You would have to take more time because you don't have as much light gathering power.

407
00:24:26.661 --> 00:24:26.941
Right.

408
00:24:27.121 --> 00:24:30.465
Like you don't have as many photons coming in because you've only got these individual detectives.

409
00:24:31.185 --> 00:24:34.447
If you had something the size of the Earth, then you could just, boom, take an image.

410
00:24:34.767 --> 00:24:42.330
But we're not harvesting all of Mercury's mass to create a giant radio telescope.

411
00:24:42.350 --> 00:24:44.911
Maybe in our future as humanity, we will do that.

412
00:24:44.951 --> 00:24:45.871
Fingers crossed.

413
00:24:46.091 --> 00:24:50.713
Yeah, we will destroy the planet of Mercury and create a giant telescope.

414
00:24:51.594 --> 00:24:55.395
I'm sure there's going to be people that really don't want that to happen, right?

415
00:24:55.435 --> 00:24:56.996
Mercury retrograde is a very big thing.

416
00:24:57.016 --> 00:24:57.816
It's very popular.

417
00:24:58.316 --> 00:24:59.697
I heard with the horoscopes.

418
00:24:59.817 --> 00:25:02.558
Yeah, but that's effectively what's happening.

419
00:25:02.598 --> 00:25:05.899
I mean, you've been to the very large array in New Mexico, right?

420
00:25:05.919 --> 00:25:06.599
That's the same thing.

421
00:25:06.679 --> 00:25:08.060
It's an interferometer.

422
00:25:08.100 --> 00:25:08.840
That's what this is called.

423
00:25:08.860 --> 00:25:11.141
This is called radio interferometry.

424
00:25:11.481 --> 00:25:26.326
The idea is to use interference between all of your detectors to create an image with an exquisite resolution that is effectively given by the size of how far apart your farthest telescopes are.

425
00:25:26.446 --> 00:25:26.626
Right.

426
00:25:27.086 --> 00:25:28.667
And in this case, it's the Earth.

427
00:25:28.887 --> 00:25:32.629
One more thing I want to point out with that video, actually, if you don't mind.

428
00:25:33.390 --> 00:25:35.371
So notice, the Earth is rotating, right?

429
00:25:35.431 --> 00:25:37.912
And this is from the vantage point of M87.

430
00:25:38.472 --> 00:25:41.394
So it's like, I'm at M87 looking at the Earth.

431
00:25:41.854 --> 00:25:42.875
Now the Earth is tilted.

432
00:25:43.915 --> 00:25:48.798
And so notice, Antarctica is always facing M87, right?

433
00:25:48.998 --> 00:25:53.361
Because the Earth is tilted, so Antarctica is always facing the constellation of Virgo.

434
00:25:54.521 --> 00:25:59.464
So the telescope in Antarctica on the South Pole is called the South Pole Telescope.

435
00:26:00.024 --> 00:26:02.266
It's just always staring at M87.

436
00:26:03.266 --> 00:26:08.009
And then the other guys are like picking and choosing, filling in the data.

437
00:26:08.129 --> 00:26:09.450
At time in the day, things like that.

438
00:26:09.490 --> 00:26:13.792
But it's just cool that no matter what part of the year, right, because the Earth's tilt doesn't change.

439
00:26:14.273 --> 00:26:18.395
So no matter what part of the year, it's just going to keep staring at that spot in the sky.

440
00:26:18.695 --> 00:26:24.461
And fortunately with radio astronomy, it doesn't really mind staring at the sky during the daytime.

441
00:26:24.981 --> 00:26:25.201
Right.

442
00:26:25.261 --> 00:26:25.862
Right.

443
00:26:25.882 --> 00:26:31.347
So the sun isn't really affecting radio astronomy as much as optical.

444
00:26:31.367 --> 00:26:31.707
Optical.

445
00:26:31.747 --> 00:26:32.188
Yeah.

446
00:26:32.308 --> 00:26:32.608
Optical.

447
00:26:32.668 --> 00:26:34.410
Obviously we can't see any stars during the day.

448
00:26:34.770 --> 00:26:37.032
Radio, if you look, you'll be able to see stuff.

449
00:26:37.233 --> 00:26:42.417
We have our atmosphere, and there's blocking happening, and light, and it's interfering.

450
00:26:42.438 --> 00:26:52.247
Yeah, like the sun is still a source of radio waves, don't get me wrong, but it's not like getting scattered as much by the atmosphere as compared to, you know, like optical light.

451
00:26:52.267 --> 00:26:52.387
Right.

452
00:26:52.507 --> 00:26:55.449
So as long as you don't like just stare directly at the sun, you're good to go.

453
00:26:55.629 --> 00:26:56.229
100%.

454
00:26:56.489 --> 00:27:00.371
I just think that's, it's such a cool thing that we've done as humanity.

455
00:27:00.571 --> 00:27:02.472
It's also a cool thing that we've figured out, right?

456
00:27:02.552 --> 00:27:05.914
Because you can just be like, oh, we can't build a 10 kilometer wide telescope.

457
00:27:06.234 --> 00:27:12.758
I'm going to give up because this problem is insurmountable for us because we're not going to have the engineering capacity, the funding and whatever.

458
00:27:12.978 --> 00:27:21.643
And it's like, this is, I think one of the beauties of the process that we talk about so much on the show is how can you do more with less?

459
00:27:22.400 --> 00:27:22.620
Yeah.

460
00:27:23.281 --> 00:27:31.465
And the ingenuity that arrives from if we can't do X, can we maybe do Y ultimately to get the same end result?

461
00:27:31.645 --> 00:27:39.570
And this is a perfect example of how, you know, we're not going to get the funding to do what we want to do, but we already have the resources to be.

462
00:27:40.550 --> 00:27:46.273
So pragmatic in getting to the same end result, which is this imaging task.

463
00:27:46.673 --> 00:27:47.353
Exactly.

464
00:27:47.393 --> 00:27:53.095
Which has given us this M87, this beautiful, beautiful, beautiful image.

465
00:27:53.115 --> 00:27:53.796
Beautiful image.

466
00:27:54.176 --> 00:27:54.396
Right.

467
00:27:54.856 --> 00:27:59.618
And so now the other point that I just want to make is why radio, right?

468
00:27:59.678 --> 00:28:03.720
If we can do this with like just light at the end of the day, right?

469
00:28:04.100 --> 00:28:04.840
Light is light.

470
00:28:05.201 --> 00:28:08.282
Why don't we just like wait for the nighttime and then image with optical?

471
00:28:08.302 --> 00:28:08.442
Right.

472
00:28:09.159 --> 00:28:12.900
Right, because the argument would be like some of our optical stuff is pretty tough.

473
00:28:12.960 --> 00:28:13.780
It's pretty tough, right?

474
00:28:14.221 --> 00:28:16.501
But we don't have optical interferometers.

475
00:28:17.021 --> 00:28:17.642
Not really.

476
00:28:17.882 --> 00:28:18.702
We've got a few.

477
00:28:19.062 --> 00:28:24.644
Which is meaning more like this large array of optical telescopes.

478
00:28:25.104 --> 00:28:32.406
So the VLA being the very large array of radio telescopes, which are lower cost, right?

479
00:28:33.346 --> 00:28:37.688
And maybe you could argue lower data stream complexity and downstream...

480
00:28:38.488 --> 00:28:39.229
That's the main one.

481
00:28:39.309 --> 00:28:39.569
Okay.

482
00:28:39.769 --> 00:28:44.373
It's the data stream, not the complexity in the sense of computational complexity.

483
00:28:45.054 --> 00:28:45.254
No.

484
00:28:45.394 --> 00:28:49.117
In terms of literal physics, radio is slow.

485
00:28:50.238 --> 00:28:50.618
Ah, okay.

486
00:28:50.758 --> 00:28:51.559
That makes sense.

487
00:28:51.579 --> 00:28:52.240
Radio is slow.

488
00:28:52.580 --> 00:28:57.604
The radio wavelengths are longer, which means the cycle of the light is slower.

489
00:28:58.045 --> 00:28:58.305
Okay?

490
00:28:58.605 --> 00:29:00.066
Now, here's the key thing.

491
00:29:00.467 --> 00:29:02.689
With interferometry, what I need to do is...

492
00:29:03.429 --> 00:29:09.414
interfere the light signals, which means a wave is coming in over here, a wave is coming in over here.

493
00:29:09.534 --> 00:29:16.399
I need to know the exact timing of these waves so that I can add them up and destructively and constructively interfere them.

494
00:29:16.899 --> 00:29:21.043
Now with radio astronomy, like something like the VLA, right, I'm going to

495
00:29:23.088 --> 00:29:31.192
you're looking at about the cycle, the cycle between these things is going to be about 10 to the minus 12 to 10 to the minus 10 seconds.

496
00:29:31.593 --> 00:29:33.574
So like, you know,

497
00:29:35.345 --> 00:29:40.448
0.009 or 10 zeros and then one second is going to be the cycle time of this thing.

498
00:29:40.729 --> 00:29:41.549
Okay?

499
00:29:41.709 --> 00:29:44.851
This is in the megahertz to gigahertz range.

500
00:29:45.091 --> 00:29:45.231
Right.

501
00:29:45.251 --> 00:29:46.572
And that's something that we know how to do.

502
00:29:46.592 --> 00:29:47.112
We know how to handle it.

503
00:29:47.192 --> 00:29:47.372
Right?

504
00:29:47.453 --> 00:29:49.514
Radio, like literally the radio in your car.

505
00:29:49.654 --> 00:29:49.794
Right.

506
00:29:49.814 --> 00:29:49.954
Right?

507
00:29:49.994 --> 00:29:52.255
We know how to tune stuff at that range.

508
00:29:52.556 --> 00:29:52.656
Okay?

509
00:29:52.676 --> 00:29:52.876
Okay.

510
00:29:54.283 --> 00:29:59.929
And what that means is we've got the timing just right that we can add them up and subtract them and so on and so forth.

511
00:29:59.949 --> 00:30:00.950
Yes.

512
00:30:01.370 --> 00:30:10.000
So what you can do with radio astronomy is you can take data at the South Pole and take data in Spain and take data in Hawaii and stuff like that.

513
00:30:10.340 --> 00:30:12.683
Rig it up to a clock that is accurate enough.

514
00:30:13.103 --> 00:30:24.427
And then when you put it all together with like your petabytes and petabytes of data, you have the tag of like when the signal came and you can you can you can match and you can do the computational.

515
00:30:24.447 --> 00:30:25.507
You can make the math math.

516
00:30:25.527 --> 00:30:26.427
You can make the math math.

517
00:30:26.467 --> 00:30:26.667
Right.

518
00:30:27.748 --> 00:30:34.710
With with optical now, you run into the block that the cycle time is faster than your clock.

519
00:30:34.750 --> 00:30:40.192
Like the light that's coming in is faster than the reliable clock that you have to record the thing.

520
00:30:40.792 --> 00:30:43.273
So you can't actually line up the signals.

521
00:30:44.173 --> 00:30:45.513
That makes total sense.

522
00:30:45.553 --> 00:30:45.793
Right?

523
00:30:45.973 --> 00:30:55.316
And this is why, so there is a famous optical interferometer in Chile called the Very Large Telescope, VLT, compared to the VLA.

524
00:30:55.996 --> 00:31:00.177
And what they do in order to do the interference, they don't do computational interference.

525
00:31:00.437 --> 00:31:09.000
They literally have tunnels underneath the ground that are routing the light physically so that the light physically interferes.

526
00:31:09.875 --> 00:31:10.075
Right.

527
00:31:10.376 --> 00:31:10.576
Right?

528
00:31:10.656 --> 00:31:15.060
Because that's like, okay, you can't record the data and do it computationally.

529
00:31:15.440 --> 00:31:16.261
Hardware is king.

530
00:31:16.681 --> 00:31:16.882
Right?

531
00:31:16.982 --> 00:31:20.105
And even when it comes to astronomy, hardware is king.

532
00:31:20.325 --> 00:31:23.108
As we've discussed multiple times on the show.

533
00:31:23.168 --> 00:31:24.669
And so VLT does it that way.

534
00:31:25.009 --> 00:31:30.535
But if I wanted to rig up an optical array that's the size of the Earth, currently it's not possible.

535
00:31:30.615 --> 00:31:30.895
Yeah.

536
00:31:30.995 --> 00:31:33.137
Because we just don't have the timing complexity.

537
00:31:33.377 --> 00:31:34.839
Now, there are optical clocks.

538
00:31:34.859 --> 00:31:35.139
Right.

539
00:31:35.339 --> 00:31:38.041
that are getting to that level of accuracy.

540
00:31:38.081 --> 00:31:38.282
Right.

541
00:31:38.342 --> 00:31:43.866
But like now deploying it across all of these telescopes and it's a challenge, right?

542
00:31:43.886 --> 00:31:45.888
Because it's still a very new technology.

543
00:31:46.228 --> 00:31:54.876
But this is, just to be clear, this is an engineering problem, not necessarily a fundamental science or physics problem at this point.

544
00:31:55.076 --> 00:31:58.359
Like we would know, we have potential paths well identified.

545
00:31:58.399 --> 00:32:00.140
Yes, the potential paths are well identified.

546
00:32:00.200 --> 00:32:03.223
I think realizing those paths, there still might be some physics issues.

547
00:32:03.323 --> 00:32:03.603
Okay.

548
00:32:03.663 --> 00:32:08.567
You know, like creating an optical clock that is stable enough.

549
00:32:09.007 --> 00:32:13.090
Like, I don't know much about, and I think we're going to do future episodes on optical clocks, right?

550
00:32:13.130 --> 00:32:13.590
This is a good one.

551
00:32:13.630 --> 00:32:16.232
Comment below if you want this one.

552
00:32:16.272 --> 00:32:19.195
Because people always talk about, oh, we have atomic clocks.

553
00:32:19.455 --> 00:32:21.776
But what we're saying is there are not enough decimal clocks.

554
00:32:21.796 --> 00:32:23.358
Even the atomic clocks are like, yeah.

555
00:32:23.378 --> 00:32:24.679
There's not enough decimal places.

556
00:32:24.699 --> 00:32:25.119
Yeah, yeah.

557
00:32:25.199 --> 00:32:28.742
And if there aren't enough decimal places, it's like only in Boulder, Colorado.

558
00:32:28.762 --> 00:32:28.862
Yeah.

559
00:32:29.402 --> 00:32:29.882
Right.

560
00:32:29.902 --> 00:32:33.625
There's like there's like a few groups in Boulder, Colorado that have this thing working.

561
00:32:33.705 --> 00:32:36.327
We have it for the nukes, but not for science.

562
00:32:36.367 --> 00:32:39.829
Let's make the clocks for nukes work for science.

563
00:32:39.949 --> 00:32:40.709
That's what we want.

564
00:32:40.790 --> 00:32:47.494
So so and I do also want to shout out there's there's a team at Mount Wilson that we covered that also had.

565
00:32:47.514 --> 00:32:48.575
Sure.

566
00:32:49.575 --> 00:32:50.755
An optical interferometer.

567
00:32:50.795 --> 00:32:53.696
And they're the guys that found sunspots on other stars.

568
00:32:53.736 --> 00:32:54.937
We covered that episode.

569
00:32:55.197 --> 00:32:56.637
But they also do the hardware thing.

570
00:32:56.717 --> 00:32:58.678
They've got a tunnel with a bunch of lasers.

571
00:32:59.158 --> 00:33:01.158
And they're interfering it optically.

572
00:33:01.198 --> 00:33:01.919
Yes.

573
00:33:02.079 --> 00:33:10.881
So doing this, which is really a computational challenge, we haven't been able to figure out for optical telescopes.

574
00:33:10.981 --> 00:33:12.962
And the description is really important.

575
00:33:12.982 --> 00:33:17.003
Because basically what we're saying is radio waves travel through space

576
00:33:18.484 --> 00:33:23.590
slower than light does, which is what we mean when we say optical.

577
00:33:23.930 --> 00:33:27.214
And so we have a work... No, I should be clear.

578
00:33:27.474 --> 00:33:29.897
Radio waves travel at the same speed as optical.

579
00:33:30.257 --> 00:33:31.579
The cycle...

580
00:33:31.659 --> 00:33:32.640
The cycle...

581
00:33:33.141 --> 00:33:34.983
The wave goes up and down...

582
00:33:35.383 --> 00:33:35.683
Slower.

583
00:33:35.723 --> 00:33:36.123
Slower.

584
00:33:36.203 --> 00:33:36.403
Right?

585
00:33:36.544 --> 00:33:37.524
The speed of light is the same.

586
00:33:37.804 --> 00:33:38.704
People are going to come at us.

587
00:33:38.724 --> 00:33:39.525
No, no, no, no.

588
00:33:39.545 --> 00:33:39.805
No, no.

589
00:33:39.825 --> 00:33:41.165
That's a fair distinction.

590
00:33:41.285 --> 00:33:42.426
And excuse my misnomer there.

591
00:33:42.646 --> 00:33:43.606
That's a fair distinction.

592
00:33:44.047 --> 00:33:50.309
And as a crude analogy, it's like we're a police with a police radar watching people go by.

593
00:33:50.589 --> 00:33:54.591
But the rate at which we can see the up and down go is too slow for the police.

594
00:33:54.871 --> 00:33:57.533
for the Dodge Charger, whatever the Dodge.

595
00:33:57.753 --> 00:33:59.133
The Bugatti.

596
00:33:59.153 --> 00:34:00.814
The Dodge Charger, it's going to be fine.

597
00:34:00.854 --> 00:34:01.575
Wait, hold on.

598
00:34:01.595 --> 00:34:04.356
Some people are going to be mad because there's the Trackhawks.

599
00:34:04.817 --> 00:34:06.397
There's some label of them that are fast.

600
00:34:06.598 --> 00:34:08.839
But the point is... Yeah, you've got to like ring it up.

601
00:34:11.961 --> 00:34:24.235
But we just are not able to move as quickly to have enough discrete granularity from a measurement perspective and timing to do anything valuable.

602
00:34:24.635 --> 00:34:29.581
And that's kind of the – and once we could be able to do that, it's a very big deal.

603
00:34:29.601 --> 00:34:30.122
Yeah.

604
00:34:30.522 --> 00:34:33.606
Because then we can start resolving crazy things.

605
00:34:33.866 --> 00:34:35.107
Not just the black hole, right?

606
00:34:35.167 --> 00:34:40.474
But just imagine resolving features in Andromeda.

607
00:34:40.834 --> 00:34:49.003
All of the nebulae that we have, like the Horsehead Nebula, the Orion Nebula, the Pillars of Creation, all of that is in the Milky Way.

608
00:34:49.804 --> 00:34:51.666
Imagine being able to resolve...

609
00:34:52.327 --> 00:35:00.338
those types of star-creating regions in Andromeda, for example, and seeing similar structures in M87 even.

610
00:35:00.538 --> 00:35:02.040
I think it would be insane.

611
00:35:02.060 --> 00:35:06.166
So that's kind of a frontier of astronomy that is just ripe.

612
00:35:06.186 --> 00:35:07.368
But it involves physics, right?

613
00:35:09.951 --> 00:35:11.532
And engineering to happen first.

614
00:35:11.552 --> 00:35:12.392
To happen first.

615
00:35:12.592 --> 00:35:14.493
Anyways, it was a long sojourn.

616
00:35:14.773 --> 00:35:16.794
So now we've got the Event Horizon Telescope.

617
00:35:16.834 --> 00:35:18.235
2019, it came out with that photo.

618
00:35:18.395 --> 00:35:19.475
But it's been seven years.

619
00:35:19.515 --> 00:35:21.176
So it's been taking data this whole time.

620
00:35:21.296 --> 00:35:21.496
Yes.

621
00:35:21.776 --> 00:35:28.379
And now, finally, it has released a video of our black hole.

622
00:35:29.160 --> 00:35:30.520
The M87 black hole.

623
00:35:30.600 --> 00:35:31.881
Which looks beautiful.

624
00:35:32.001 --> 00:35:32.181
Yeah.

625
00:35:32.461 --> 00:35:33.502
This is a video.

626
00:35:34.102 --> 00:35:36.183
This is a video over six years.

627
00:35:37.113 --> 00:35:40.477
Of the black hole at the center of the M87 galaxy.

628
00:35:40.497 --> 00:35:41.798
This is so outrageous.

629
00:35:41.898 --> 00:35:43.140
Billions of light years.

630
00:35:43.180 --> 00:35:44.321
This is so outrageous.

631
00:35:44.521 --> 00:35:46.383
I mean, sorry, billions of solar masses.

632
00:35:46.944 --> 00:35:48.065
Right, right, right.

633
00:35:49.286 --> 00:35:50.648
55 million light years away.

634
00:35:50.668 --> 00:35:51.949
When you say solar masses...

635
00:35:52.109 --> 00:35:53.290
Yeah, it's the sun.

636
00:35:53.650 --> 00:35:54.151
Our sun.

637
00:35:54.311 --> 00:35:55.012
Billions of suns.

638
00:35:55.032 --> 00:35:56.073
Billions of our sun.

639
00:35:56.153 --> 00:35:58.695
Inside a black hole that is like accreting.

640
00:35:59.055 --> 00:36:04.380
And all of those lines that you see, this is what's very special about this new finding.

641
00:36:04.660 --> 00:36:11.366
Those lines are the polarization of the radio waves from that part of the accretion disk.

642
00:36:11.426 --> 00:36:12.267
Now, why is that important?

643
00:36:12.287 --> 00:36:12.367
Why?

644
00:36:12.587 --> 00:36:16.830
polarization is a property of light that has to do with the fact that, you know, light is a wave.

645
00:36:17.150 --> 00:36:21.914
So, well, it could oscillate this way or it could oscillate this way, or it could oscillate anywhere in between.

646
00:36:21.974 --> 00:36:22.154
Right.

647
00:36:22.194 --> 00:36:24.455
There's a, there's a 2d degree of freedom.

648
00:36:25.736 --> 00:36:32.821
The direction of the polarization tells you something about the direction and the strength of the magnetic field.

649
00:36:32.961 --> 00:36:33.201
Right.

650
00:36:33.362 --> 00:36:33.602
Okay.

651
00:36:34.002 --> 00:36:41.207
And black holes have intense magnetic fields around them because you've got all this plasma, which is a bunch of charged particles, charged particles moving around, and,

652
00:36:41.467 --> 00:36:43.949
Maxwell's equations, you get giant magnetic fields.

653
00:36:44.269 --> 00:36:49.413
The giant magnetic fields are the reason why M87 has that giant jet that we saw earlier.

654
00:36:49.793 --> 00:37:00.300
And so studying that magnetic field is extremely important for figuring out the properties of not only the black hole, but also the properties of elliptical galaxies in general.

655
00:37:00.421 --> 00:37:05.224
I don't know if you remember the Carnegie episode that we had with Michael Blanton.

656
00:37:05.304 --> 00:37:06.485
Yes.

657
00:37:07.025 --> 00:37:08.846
We asked him, what's the one...

658
00:37:09.747 --> 00:37:34.620
like question that you would want answered at the end towards the end of the episode 100 and he said i'd really like to know why these large elliptical galaxies and like these large old galaxies don't create any new stars he was like for some reason yeah for some reason for some reason yeah and there's like there's like 10 different theories and everyone's got an idea right right but no one knows no one knows this happens yeah but it's just for some reason and

659
00:37:34.720 --> 00:37:39.403
Yeah, and every single one of those theories, the culprit is the black hole.

660
00:37:39.983 --> 00:37:40.244
Okay?

661
00:37:40.464 --> 00:37:44.947
The black hole does something, and then all of the stars stop forming.

662
00:37:45.307 --> 00:37:48.609
No new babies in the galaxy because of the black hole.

663
00:37:48.769 --> 00:37:49.610
Right.

664
00:37:50.170 --> 00:37:55.914
Studying the black hole, like M87, is going to give us clues as to whether one...

665
00:37:56.775 --> 00:37:58.476
Theory is correct versus the other.

666
00:37:58.796 --> 00:38:13.167
So, I mean, first of all, just like the technological achievement of creating this video of a black hole that's 55 million years, 55 million light years away is insane.

667
00:38:13.207 --> 00:38:15.008
You can see the magnetic field changing.

668
00:38:15.288 --> 00:38:19.992
It's even flipping in some directions, which is kind of crazy, which means that like...

669
00:38:21.293 --> 00:38:24.055
The stuff in the accretion disk is moving at near the speed of light.

670
00:38:24.636 --> 00:38:31.462
And the size of that accretion disk is about where if the sun was at the center, Voyager would be where the main donut is.

671
00:38:32.042 --> 00:38:35.485
So it's outside the realm of Pluto.

672
00:38:35.705 --> 00:38:44.693
But it's not that big, which means if this stuff is going at near the speed of light, this is a highly dynamic system where we are going to see changes on a yearly basis.

673
00:38:45.014 --> 00:38:45.875
And if we can get that...

674
00:38:46.555 --> 00:38:50.940
time down to even monthly, we are going to see changes on a monthly basis.

675
00:38:51.180 --> 00:38:52.782
The system is highly turbulent.

676
00:38:52.882 --> 00:38:53.883
Yes.

677
00:38:54.063 --> 00:38:59.309
It's a highly active, relatively, maybe not dense is the right word.

678
00:38:59.329 --> 00:39:00.770
No, of course it's dense.

679
00:39:00.790 --> 00:39:02.372
Relatively dense.

680
00:39:03.173 --> 00:39:06.717
And the amount of activity that's happening is,

681
00:39:07.930 --> 00:39:10.111
We've never been able to visualize in motion.

682
00:39:10.291 --> 00:39:11.332
No, we never have.

683
00:39:11.512 --> 00:39:12.132
In motion.

684
00:39:12.272 --> 00:39:15.054
Right, and most things in astronomy just stay put.

685
00:39:15.574 --> 00:39:22.798
They, like, the pillars of creation that were photographed by Hubble, and then we photographed with James Webb, they look the same.

686
00:39:22.818 --> 00:39:23.058
Right.

687
00:39:23.238 --> 00:39:24.439
And it's like 20 years later.

688
00:39:25.319 --> 00:39:31.561
It looks about the same because the stuff is not moving at relativistic speeds, and the size of the stuff is light years across.

689
00:39:32.041 --> 00:39:37.923
But here, you've got something that's light hours to days, and the stuff is moving at light speed.

690
00:39:37.943 --> 00:39:39.783
So you're going to have a lot of motion.

691
00:39:39.823 --> 00:39:45.965
It's extremely exciting for theorists, for astronomers, for people in AI that are like…

692
00:39:46.505 --> 00:39:54.287
like putting algorithms to the test with like how to make this data better because you've got petabytes and petabytes of data, right?

693
00:39:54.427 --> 00:39:55.907
It's a really cool, cool thing.

694
00:39:56.247 --> 00:39:59.808
If you're looking for motion in the universe, check out M87.

695
00:39:59.828 --> 00:40:00.448
That's right.

696
00:40:00.528 --> 00:40:02.508
Because that's where the motion is.

697
00:40:03.249 --> 00:40:06.649
M87 has motion, as the kids would say.

698
00:40:06.809 --> 00:40:07.449
Yeah.

699
00:40:07.869 --> 00:40:09.670
I think it's an incredible story.

700
00:40:09.690 --> 00:40:10.270
Yeah.

701
00:40:10.630 --> 00:40:12.792
Okay, so moving on to our second story.

702
00:40:12.812 --> 00:40:13.612
Yeah, this is a good one.

703
00:40:13.632 --> 00:40:21.398
So that was our first one on the sort of magnetic field related to black holes and our ability to actually see it now.

704
00:40:21.619 --> 00:40:21.839
Yeah.

705
00:40:22.059 --> 00:40:24.241
We're moving on to our digital heart twin.

706
00:40:24.541 --> 00:40:24.821
Yes.

707
00:40:25.762 --> 00:40:31.226
Not to be confused with the FIFA twin that's created when you get scanned in for VAR.

708
00:40:31.246 --> 00:40:31.486
Yeah.

709
00:40:31.887 --> 00:40:34.829
The VAR, the very not truthful.

710
00:40:34.849 --> 00:40:35.489
Yeah.

711
00:40:36.390 --> 00:40:41.433
So we talked about in our previous episode, you get every player gets scanned into this FIFA system.

712
00:40:41.453 --> 00:40:45.075
So when they do the VAR animations, it's not just a random stick figure.

713
00:40:45.115 --> 00:40:46.235
It's their actual scan.

714
00:40:46.435 --> 00:40:46.636
Yeah.

715
00:40:46.856 --> 00:40:51.278
We're doing something not dissimilar for our hearts.

716
00:40:51.518 --> 00:40:53.479
Not dissimilar, exactly.

717
00:40:53.579 --> 00:41:01.464
For some medicinal benefit and to assist with how physicians do different diagnosis.

718
00:41:01.764 --> 00:41:10.330
I'm actually very curious about this because obviously in recent news, unfortunately, we've seen the passing of Senator Lindsey Graham.

719
00:41:10.390 --> 00:41:13.872
And he seems to have had a cardiac-related diagnosis.

720
00:41:15.433 --> 00:41:18.776
cause of death for those who are not looking at conspiracy theories.

721
00:41:18.976 --> 00:41:19.337
Oh, okay.

722
00:41:19.697 --> 00:41:23.280
And so there's this... My Instagram is only conspiracy theories.

723
00:41:23.300 --> 00:41:23.841
No, I'm just kidding.

724
00:41:24.301 --> 00:41:25.222
But yeah.

725
00:41:25.262 --> 00:41:33.970
So precision medicine for the heart being one of the number one and two and three maybe leading causes of death in America at least.

726
00:41:34.670 --> 00:41:36.270
Hugely, hugely beneficial.

727
00:42:04.897 --> 00:42:15.900
So it's basically you've got like a fast heart rhythm that originates somewhere in your heart, usually in your lower chambers, okay, in the ventricles, like the two that are on the bottom.

728
00:42:16.480 --> 00:42:23.542
And historically what doctors do when they want to treat this is they stick a catheter and they do a catheter ablation.

729
00:42:23.942 --> 00:42:34.149
So basically you thread a wire into the heart, into the pulmonary arteries, like the arteries that are around the heart, that are keeping the heart going, right?

730
00:42:34.169 --> 00:42:36.230
Because the heart is a muscle, so it needs blood.

731
00:42:36.590 --> 00:42:38.491
The blood comes from these veins and arteries.

732
00:42:38.812 --> 00:42:46.917
So you thread a wire through these arteries, and you effectively try to look for where the arrhythmia is happening.

733
00:42:47.497 --> 00:42:50.580
Okay, and it's like a needle in a haystack type of problem.

734
00:42:50.960 --> 00:43:02.271
You're trying to find this thing, and then when you finally find it, you burn, you ablate a tiny patch of that tissue, and that hopefully stops the erratic signal, the erratic electrical signal.

735
00:43:02.292 --> 00:43:03.753
You're trying to disturb the system somehow.

736
00:43:03.873 --> 00:43:06.696
Yeah, you're trying to just like, there's like some cells in there.

737
00:43:07.037 --> 00:43:12.803
There's like some like pacemaker neurons or like whatever neurons that are part of the contracting of the heart that are like doing weird things.

738
00:43:13.343 --> 00:43:15.005
You burn them off.

739
00:43:15.125 --> 00:43:15.606
You kill them.

740
00:43:15.886 --> 00:43:18.429
And then the rest of the heart kind of just like moves on.

741
00:43:18.529 --> 00:43:19.530
Okay.

742
00:43:20.511 --> 00:43:22.934
But as I said, it's like finding a needle in a haystack, right?

743
00:43:23.274 --> 00:43:24.636
So this new procedure...

744
00:43:26.178 --> 00:43:28.519
It was published in the New England Journal of Medicine.

745
00:43:29.079 --> 00:43:30.059
We love to see it.

746
00:43:30.139 --> 00:43:30.419
Yes.

747
00:43:30.639 --> 00:43:32.060
Still waiting for our subscription.

748
00:43:32.080 --> 00:43:32.520
Yeah.

749
00:43:32.660 --> 00:43:40.762
I still had to call in favors from my doctor friends to get access to this journal article.

750
00:43:40.982 --> 00:43:47.503
But at the end of the day, the procedure that usually takes hours, because the doctors are literally prodding and looking for where this thing is happening.

751
00:43:48.144 --> 00:43:50.344
Now they've brought it down to 30 minutes.

752
00:43:51.184 --> 00:43:53.225
And if the doctor misses the exact spot...

753
00:43:54.360 --> 00:43:55.421
This thing finds it.

754
00:43:55.741 --> 00:44:02.867
What they've done is create a digital twin, a personalized 3D computer simulation of the patient's heart.

755
00:44:03.428 --> 00:44:03.668
Okay?

756
00:44:03.748 --> 00:44:04.388
Here's how they do it.

757
00:44:05.089 --> 00:44:12.936
They first take a bunch of really high-resolution MRI scans, and they create a 3D digital twin of the patient's heart.

758
00:44:13.236 --> 00:44:17.940
So every patient gets his or her own digital twin.

759
00:44:18.420 --> 00:44:18.680
Okay?

760
00:44:19.261 --> 00:44:19.981
Then what you do...

761
00:44:20.882 --> 00:44:24.083
is you reconstruct that in your software, okay?

762
00:44:24.623 --> 00:44:43.909
All of those 2D images from the MRI scans become this 3D, really high-resolution image, and then you simulate what is happening in that heart, because now you know enough about heart cardiology, about heart physiology, about how these neurons are working, and the model is then assigned these electrical properties...

763
00:44:44.729 --> 00:44:59.963
And the researchers pace that digital heart in the same way that the pacemaker cells create this electrical gradient that causes the heart to contract and then push out blood to the lungs, take in blood from the lungs, so on and so forth.

764
00:45:00.624 --> 00:45:03.546
And what you can do here is you can do a virtual surgery.

765
00:45:03.807 --> 00:45:05.889
So here's what's happening in the video.

766
00:45:06.129 --> 00:45:07.190
Oh, that's fascinating.

767
00:45:07.210 --> 00:45:07.470
Yeah.

768
00:45:07.630 --> 00:45:10.854
So you've got the heart, you've created this 3D model.

769
00:45:11.375 --> 00:45:14.839
Now you're simulating the electrical signals in that heart.

770
00:45:15.180 --> 00:45:20.527
And you're trying to figure out where, just according to the physiology of the heart...

771
00:45:21.570 --> 00:45:23.391
There should be that arrhythmia.

772
00:45:24.012 --> 00:45:26.954
And there you see it in the VT, that circle that you see.

773
00:45:26.974 --> 00:45:32.398
You're seeing the current kind of loop around that center.

774
00:45:32.679 --> 00:45:33.539
It shouldn't be doing that.

775
00:45:33.639 --> 00:45:34.780
It's the eye of the hurricane.

776
00:45:34.820 --> 00:45:36.241
Yes, it's an eye of the hurricane.

777
00:45:36.301 --> 00:45:37.102
It shouldn't be doing that.

778
00:45:37.122 --> 00:45:38.183
There should be no hurricane.

779
00:45:38.503 --> 00:45:46.766
It should be cleanly diffusing and creating the sort of contracting that we all know and love that keeps our blood going.

780
00:45:46.786 --> 00:45:49.947
So in the simulation, you can identify exactly where it's happening.

781
00:45:50.428 --> 00:45:58.971
And then in the simulation, you can ablate that part and see what the resulting pattern of electrical stimulation is going to do.

782
00:45:59.231 --> 00:46:01.352
And if you ablate that part, is it going to work?

783
00:46:02.093 --> 00:46:07.594
If it works, then finally you go to the surgeon and you're like, yep, we've got a best strategy.

784
00:46:07.694 --> 00:46:12.375
Out of all of the different strategies that we've tried, we've got a best strategy that we found on the computer.

785
00:46:12.735 --> 00:46:13.595
Now you're the surgeon.

786
00:46:13.995 --> 00:46:17.636
Go in and just do it.

787
00:46:17.856 --> 00:46:19.477
30 minutes instead of hours.

788
00:46:19.597 --> 00:46:27.498
And I think what we're sort of saying is particularly for having a patient under during that time period where you have to be searching, doing search and rescue.

789
00:46:27.858 --> 00:46:30.219
You no longer have to have the patient under to do search and rescue.

790
00:46:30.639 --> 00:46:30.939
You've...

791
00:46:31.759 --> 00:46:33.480
theoretically de-risk.

792
00:46:33.520 --> 00:46:34.560
But it's like way lower.

793
00:46:36.001 --> 00:46:37.481
The de-risk.

794
00:46:37.581 --> 00:46:39.081
It's way lower.

795
00:46:39.362 --> 00:46:47.644
You've been able to do enough pre-work here where the patient risk profile is also lower.

796
00:46:47.724 --> 00:46:48.844
Yeah, exactly.

797
00:46:48.965 --> 00:46:55.607
And it's so fascinating because we've been studying the heart vigorously for a very, very long time now.

798
00:46:55.887 --> 00:47:00.088
And so we have a lot of knowledge as it relates to this particular organ.

799
00:47:00.368 --> 00:47:03.871
And it builds, this is built on all of that knowledge.

800
00:47:03.891 --> 00:47:04.832
It's not just out of thin air.

801
00:47:04.872 --> 00:47:05.072
Yep.

802
00:47:05.273 --> 00:47:05.473
Right.

803
00:47:05.513 --> 00:47:15.462
And I think that's a really important point here, which is like we can do things like this now because we've spent so much time gathering data about the heart, building simulations around the heart.

804
00:47:15.622 --> 00:47:21.307
And then so you can now go to an individual patient and then apply all of that history of knowledge.

805
00:47:21.447 --> 00:47:30.397
Create a personalized solution to them and basically run the surgery in silica.

806
00:47:30.537 --> 00:47:32.038
Yeah, exactly.

807
00:47:32.218 --> 00:47:34.341
Before you go in vivo.

808
00:47:35.482 --> 00:47:36.923
Yes, that's exactly right.

809
00:47:36.943 --> 00:47:37.384
That's incredible.

810
00:47:37.884 --> 00:47:41.566
Yeah, and in a 10-patient trial, so this was all FDA approved, by the way.

811
00:47:41.666 --> 00:47:42.306
Yes.

812
00:47:42.746 --> 00:47:43.987
The trial was FDA approved.

813
00:47:44.327 --> 00:47:50.350
And in the 10-patient trial, all participants were free of the sustained arrhythmias at the follow-up.

814
00:47:50.590 --> 00:47:50.990
Incredible.

815
00:47:51.010 --> 00:47:54.952
And that's far exceeding the typical rate, which is like 60% success rate, right?

816
00:47:54.972 --> 00:47:57.133
So for 10 people to have success...

817
00:47:57.673 --> 00:48:03.454
Like at 60%, that's 0.6 to the 10th power, which is about 0.006.

818
00:48:03.895 --> 00:48:10.756
So like that happening by chance among like a normal with normal procedures is like less than 1%.

819
00:48:11.056 --> 00:48:12.277
But here it was happening, right?

820
00:48:13.197 --> 00:48:13.997
100% of the time.

821
00:48:14.117 --> 00:48:14.337
Yeah.

822
00:48:14.617 --> 00:48:15.257
Every time.

823
00:48:15.397 --> 00:48:16.038
Exactly.

824
00:48:16.378 --> 00:48:17.238
So here you don't even.

825
00:48:17.278 --> 00:48:18.398
Yeah, this isn't.

826
00:48:18.898 --> 00:48:19.959
You can't really argue on it.

827
00:48:20.259 --> 00:48:25.620
The other thing that was crazy is the eight of the patients were entirely off antiarrhythmia medications.

828
00:48:26.311 --> 00:48:28.331
They didn't even have to take medications.

829
00:48:28.712 --> 00:48:31.692
Two of them had lower doses, but eight of them were just like done.

830
00:48:31.732 --> 00:48:32.112
We're good.

831
00:48:32.432 --> 00:48:32.833
Yeah.

832
00:48:32.873 --> 00:48:33.293
They did it.

833
00:48:33.613 --> 00:48:49.556
And I think one of the things, technology understandably is very complicated in our modern era in consumer applications and a variety of other contexts and the economics that relates to people who make technological discoveries.

834
00:48:49.776 --> 00:48:49.997
Yeah.

835
00:48:56.658 --> 00:48:59.620
Is hugely incredible for patient outcomes.

836
00:48:59.800 --> 00:49:00.020
Yeah.

837
00:49:00.880 --> 00:49:06.783
The healthcare system is not what we're talking about when we talk about just the raw ability to get the solution.

838
00:49:07.243 --> 00:49:10.245
And then we have to deal with how do we make this more accessible.

839
00:49:10.605 --> 00:49:15.508
And there's sort of the public health, healthcare insurance paradigm that's.

840
00:49:16.508 --> 00:49:17.348
needs to be dealt with.

841
00:49:17.769 --> 00:49:38.378
But our ability to have real solutions to these problems that are this effective is so, again, I'm sure many people who are listening, us personally, others, have had friends, family, who have had maybe not this specific heart-related issue, but adjacent-related heart-related issues.

842
00:49:38.478 --> 00:49:45.562
And it's the number one killer of people in the U.S. And we're slowly chipping away at the tool set

843
00:49:46.605 --> 00:49:48.186
to start to solve these problems.

844
00:49:49.186 --> 00:49:53.968
Again, it's from hours to 30 minutes.

845
00:49:54.709 --> 00:49:56.770
If anyone's been to the hospital, you don't want to be in there.

846
00:49:56.970 --> 00:49:57.690
No, that's insane.

847
00:49:57.770 --> 00:50:02.232
I mean, the surgeons don't want to do a surgery for hours when they can do something in 30 minutes.

848
00:50:03.453 --> 00:50:12.557
One funny thing I will say is, so I saw an interview with Natalia Treonova, who is the professor of biomedical engineering at Johns Hopkins.

849
00:50:12.777 --> 00:50:12.897
And

850
00:50:15.278 --> 00:50:30.971
her team there i think they're like trying to work on a desktop app now that is um that is going to make this accessible on a desktop that's and so doctors can have this information in minutes pretty soon they're going to make an app store like on the iphone i think that's what

851
00:50:31.251 --> 00:50:32.512
I think that was kind of funny.

852
00:50:32.552 --> 00:50:36.495
It's like now it's just like we're just going to miniaturize it and put it on a laptop.

853
00:50:36.555 --> 00:50:37.436
Yeah.

854
00:50:37.496 --> 00:50:47.963
And like there's no like that's kind of the I mean ultimately eventually basically you'll have the tooling and then your end surface a laptop or a phone.

855
00:50:48.684 --> 00:50:50.385
And right now some of us have.

856
00:50:50.665 --> 00:51:14.921
watches or aura rings yeah do very rudimentary yeah it's just yeah the monitoring is going to go up the technology is going to go up this is great the time is going to go down down which which matters in terms of saving lives yeah frankly um this is very cool super super fascinating great story that's our story number two i'm going to queue up a story number three for you

857
00:51:15.701 --> 00:51:20.545
Which, interestingly, is related to our story number two.

858
00:51:21.005 --> 00:51:22.286
We didn't plan this, but we should.

859
00:51:22.326 --> 00:51:24.668
Right, right, right, right, right, right, right.

860
00:51:24.688 --> 00:51:26.990
This ended up being convenient, even though.

861
00:51:27.370 --> 00:51:33.435
So, as you guys know, with the rundown, we're not going super deep into any particular story, except the black hole story.

862
00:51:33.675 --> 00:51:33.895
Yeah.

863
00:51:33.915 --> 00:51:34.456
That was good.

864
00:51:34.756 --> 00:51:36.677
There's still so much more I could talk about.

865
00:51:36.697 --> 00:51:39.860
Like, we only spent 30 minutes on it.

866
00:51:40.060 --> 00:51:41.321
I could have spent an hour and a half.

867
00:51:41.341 --> 00:51:43.983
You guys know me, if you're regular listeners.

868
00:51:45.404 --> 00:51:54.371
But we try to use the rundown as a way in which to give the listeners a little taste of many of the things happening at the frontier.

869
00:51:54.411 --> 00:52:04.858
As we mentioned at the beginning of this episode, we're trying to cover a couple of stories we weren't able to get to earlier in the year as we get back into now doing our normal weekly rundown.

870
00:52:04.899 --> 00:52:09.762
So we're hitting what's happening as it's happening because it's happening very fast.

871
00:52:10.082 --> 00:52:13.125
And one story that I saw that was fascinating to me

872
00:52:13.825 --> 00:52:18.329
was the introduction of MidJourney Medical.

873
00:52:18.909 --> 00:52:22.892
And some of you who are listening may be familiar with MidJourney.

874
00:52:23.373 --> 00:52:29.197
For those who don't know, MidJourney is primarily known for being an image generation tool.

875
00:52:29.698 --> 00:52:35.963
It initially started as a Discord-only image generation thing.

876
00:52:35.983 --> 00:52:38.705
So they had a bot on Discord.

877
00:52:38.725 --> 00:52:38.845
Right.

878
00:52:39.245 --> 00:52:43.190
I remember using your Discord account to try to mess around with it.

879
00:52:43.211 --> 00:52:44.192
There was no website.

880
00:52:44.212 --> 00:52:45.373
There was no interface.

881
00:52:45.674 --> 00:52:54.746
And they were very early, even before a lot of the big model providers opened AI and thought, but in terms of leaning into...

882
00:52:56.468 --> 00:52:57.148
Image generation.

883
00:52:57.188 --> 00:53:02.330
So the question might be, what does mid-journey medical have to do with AI image generation?

884
00:53:02.390 --> 00:53:07.231
And the underlying company has created this, what they're calling an ultra CT scanner.

885
00:53:08.051 --> 00:53:09.451
They've launched a healthcare division.

886
00:53:10.212 --> 00:53:14.433
And they've now announced this full body ultrasound.

887
00:53:14.453 --> 00:53:14.553
Yeah.

888
00:53:15.273 --> 00:53:29.998
scanner that aims to image the entire body in about 60 seconds using sound waves and water without radiation or magnetic fields, which would be the MRI would be the comparative here, which I talked about a lot recently on the podcast.

889
00:53:30.478 --> 00:53:34.900
And so a lot of people's spidey senses went up.

890
00:53:35.620 --> 00:53:38.401
Historically, a lot of tech companies make a lot of claims.

891
00:53:38.561 --> 00:53:40.742
There's not been a single of the modern

892
00:53:41.622 --> 00:54:04.516
tech architecture that has moved into medical imaging right uh at any time and the founder of midjourney has done a couple of different endeavors that he's really tried to lean into saying how can we utilize something like ai image generation to create a funding vehicle for greater good purposes right instead of having to raise money all the time so this is kind of

893
00:54:05.617 --> 00:54:09.018
what his vision has been for some time, and MidJourney broke through.

894
00:54:09.058 --> 00:54:22.561
So the main idea here is it's a first-generation prototype with no FDA regulatory clearance yet, and it's built on licensed technology from Butterfly Network rather than obviously MidJourney's generative AI.

895
00:54:22.981 --> 00:54:32.683
But at launch, they want to offer full-body composition maps rather than diagnostics with a first location planned for late 2027 in San Francisco.

896
00:54:35.604 --> 00:54:41.447
So the idea here is Mid Journey wants to create these Mid Journey spas.

897
00:54:41.888 --> 00:54:51.793
We're now looking at this video of their prototype that they brought forth at this demo that they brought for other people where you stand in what is like a circular platform that lowers

898
00:54:52.994 --> 00:54:59.221
of water, you're surrounded in a soup by these circular micron level sized sensors.

899
00:54:59.241 --> 00:55:13.957
There's like thousands of millions of these sensors that are sending these radio waves at you and you're getting this real time, because it's ultrasound, or it's Zemar, you're getting this real time sort of cross-sectional scan of your body that they then through

900
00:55:15.280 --> 00:55:19.543
a few algorithmic systems, then compose a 3D image afterwards.

901
00:55:19.663 --> 00:55:23.525
And we're gonna get into some of the technical details for a second.

902
00:55:23.545 --> 00:55:27.007
So when you step in the water, you're staying on the platform.

903
00:55:27.027 --> 00:55:39.995
It's connected to a tube to these rails and the gates of the gate, moving into the center and gently lower your power to patches over five centimeters, or simply some of these one-way phrases, and then out of the water.

904
00:55:45.627 --> 00:55:46.710
doing here.

905
00:55:46.810 --> 00:55:55.070
As you descend, you pass through a made of about half a billion tiny squares, each the size of a fine grain of sand, each capable

906
00:56:09.619 --> 00:56:11.700
Oh, very nice.

907
00:56:11.720 --> 00:56:15.281
In all these directions, they're doing this super, super high frequency.

908
00:56:15.301 --> 00:56:16.022
Ah, very nice.

909
00:56:16.102 --> 00:56:16.742
Right.

910
00:56:16.922 --> 00:56:28.746
And so this is now how they're trying to create a different implementation of the underlying concept.

911
00:56:28.826 --> 00:56:30.087
No, so that's really cool.

912
00:56:30.147 --> 00:56:31.407
Yeah, you've got...

913
00:56:31.547 --> 00:56:34.028
It's the microphone and speaker that you were talking about, right?

914
00:56:34.068 --> 00:56:37.069
Yeah, you're sending out ultrasound and then the...

915
00:56:39.512 --> 00:56:46.415
Yeah, it reminds me of how we mapped the Earth's interior using seismic waves.

916
00:56:46.675 --> 00:56:47.235
You know what I mean?

917
00:56:47.275 --> 00:56:47.755
Exactly.

918
00:56:47.995 --> 00:57:04.622
Like, we figured out that there's a mantle and a core and an inner and outer core and all that other kind of stuff because we looked at how seismic waves, earthquake waves, bent around in the interior of space and we deduced that there has to be like...

919
00:57:04.962 --> 00:57:27.544
these layers in the earth's crust or it's under the earth's crust and here what you're doing is effectively that but you're creating fake earthquakes right you're creating fake little earthquakes where you can control the size and the frequency of them and then you have a bunch of like sensors that's crazy that's so clever each of the squares creates ultrasonic waves and records the earth plus back millions of times

920
00:57:32.173 --> 00:57:35.497
The challenge is the processing pipeline.

921
00:57:35.517 --> 00:57:36.037
Right.

922
00:57:36.137 --> 00:57:40.702
It's not just sensing, but it's also how you process the data.

923
00:57:41.163 --> 00:57:49.251
So take a look here now at the next one, which is so what we're looking at is sort of one of the 3D images that it creates.

924
00:57:49.271 --> 00:57:51.834
And on the labels on each side, you kind of see the different.

925
00:57:52.294 --> 00:57:53.935
parts that it's identifying.

926
00:57:53.955 --> 00:57:58.917
As waves travel through the water, your body and your body, they kind of change shape.

927
00:57:58.957 --> 00:58:00.278
And the shapes change.

928
00:58:00.318 --> 00:58:12.703
Whenever they change, it helps them understand the density and stiffness, going from water to fat to muscle to bone, of what the underlying structure is by looking at how the shapes of all the waves change.

929
00:58:12.723 --> 00:58:14.204
They can reconstruct

930
00:58:14.724 --> 00:58:14.884
Right.

931
00:58:14.904 --> 00:58:15.525
This detail map.

932
00:58:15.545 --> 00:58:18.747
It's not dissimilar to other medical imaging technologies.

933
00:58:18.807 --> 00:58:22.510
It's just kind of a little bit of a different medium.

934
00:58:22.910 --> 00:58:31.496
And then so all of these images will then come together to create this 3D mockup of your body.

935
00:58:31.516 --> 00:58:36.200
So we see in this graphic here there you're looking at two legs.

936
00:58:36.660 --> 00:58:36.920
Right.

937
00:58:37.461 --> 00:58:37.681
Right.

938
00:58:38.181 --> 00:58:40.323
And then they're basically stretching out these two legs.

939
00:58:40.363 --> 00:58:41.103
It's like slices.

940
00:58:41.123 --> 00:58:44.706
Spreading out to the different slices that are these individual images.

941
00:58:45.086 --> 00:58:57.214
And so what they're putting, they're sort of saying their pieces, the software pipeline to go from the slices to the 3D imaging, the time span to be able to do so, the processing system.

942
00:58:57.694 --> 00:59:01.297
And their goal is quite interesting here.

943
00:59:01.317 --> 00:59:03.778
So let's talk about what exists now.

944
00:59:04.119 --> 00:59:04.699
Yeah.

945
00:59:04.779 --> 00:59:05.219
And what doesn't.

946
00:59:06.300 --> 00:59:10.061
A working Gen 1 prototype demonstrated live, as we saw.

947
00:59:10.261 --> 00:59:11.081
And that's what we saw.

948
00:59:11.281 --> 00:59:11.961
That's what we saw.

949
00:59:12.302 --> 00:59:13.862
It does body composition mapping.

950
00:59:14.202 --> 00:59:15.842
That's the stated launch capability.

951
00:59:16.403 --> 00:59:23.244
And they did this with a licensing deal with Butterfly Network, which has some of the underlying image sensing technology pieces.

952
00:59:23.664 --> 00:59:26.945
They kind of put the pipeline together to make it this end solution.

953
00:59:27.325 --> 00:59:29.566
And the public announcement and marketing site was...

954
00:59:29.686 --> 00:59:44.499
What is claimed or planned from MidJourney Medical is image quality superior to MRI, which many in the radiological and scientific community have some feedback about, which I'll talk about in a second.

955
00:59:44.939 --> 00:59:47.641
Diagnostic capability pending FDA submissions.

956
00:59:48.082 --> 00:59:57.490
They want to have 50,000 scanners worldwide over a six-year period, and they want to be doing a billion full-body scans per month.

957
00:59:58.010 --> 01:00:02.836
That's their stated goal for this system and platform.

958
01:00:02.856 --> 01:00:04.378
So like what is the so what here?

959
01:00:04.618 --> 01:00:05.660
Like, okay, great.

960
01:00:05.680 --> 01:00:07.442
Like why does this kind of like really matter?

961
01:00:08.982 --> 01:00:19.405
Ultrasound is generally excellent for a wide range of problems, including assessing abdominal organs, blood vessels, the heart, pregnancy, and many other soft tissue problems.

962
01:00:19.425 --> 01:00:19.825
Yeah, yeah.

963
01:00:19.945 --> 01:00:20.125
Right?

964
01:00:20.645 --> 01:00:22.726
In real time, without radiation.

965
01:00:23.626 --> 01:00:24.126
Okay, great.

966
01:00:24.806 --> 01:00:29.728
What it doesn't do straightforwardly and can't replace kind of what MRI does currently—

967
01:00:30.809 --> 01:00:33.532
is the soft tissue contrast for the brain and the spinal cord.

968
01:00:34.072 --> 01:00:35.414
Not quite as good in those contexts.

969
01:00:35.894 --> 01:00:37.976
Characterization of joints and certain tumors.

970
01:00:38.477 --> 01:00:42.761
And then validation pathways for certain platforms like DEXA for bone density.

971
01:00:42.942 --> 01:00:47.507
So it's not quite as able to be great in those areas.

972
01:00:47.527 --> 01:00:50.129
And when I looked at some of the back and forth,

973
01:00:50.710 --> 01:00:55.274
People said medical imaging technology is about a toolbox of instruments.

974
01:00:55.814 --> 01:00:57.616
It's not a one instrument to rule them all.

975
01:00:57.976 --> 01:01:01.259
And depending on your use case, you have better options than others.

976
01:01:01.619 --> 01:01:09.886
So the idea is a whole new body ultrasound system can do some things very well, and it might not answer every problem.

977
01:01:09.966 --> 01:01:13.629
But doing some things really well that makes it more accessible is super valuable.

978
01:01:13.649 --> 01:01:13.749
Yeah.

979
01:01:14.770 --> 01:01:16.531
In and of itself.

980
01:01:17.032 --> 01:01:25.877
And so that's kind of I thought this was interesting because it's this, you know, we have a lot of the tech folks come in to say we want to help save the world.

981
01:01:26.537 --> 01:01:29.239
This seems to be an actual practice, something that could be really practical.

982
01:01:30.120 --> 01:01:34.983
If they can go through the FDA process and get approval here and fit into the toolbox.

983
01:01:35.503 --> 01:01:36.284
of medical imaging.

984
01:01:36.304 --> 01:01:38.967
It would be the first new medical imaging device.

985
01:01:39.028 --> 01:01:40.770
I believe it's in like over 50 years.

986
01:01:41.391 --> 01:01:41.791
Wow.

987
01:01:42.171 --> 01:01:45.596
That's really, you know, has to gain adoption and get buy-in.

988
01:01:46.036 --> 01:01:48.479
But I think there's some interesting.

989
01:01:48.600 --> 01:01:53.546
I mean, that is, that is really cool in the fundamentals of, of what they're doing here.

990
01:01:53.886 --> 01:01:55.227
Yeah, yeah, definitely.

991
01:01:55.347 --> 01:02:02.090
I mean, the only ultrasound that I've ever really experienced is like, you know, for like pregnancies and things like that, right?

992
01:02:02.150 --> 01:02:09.253
So, but obviously, yeah, doing soft tissue probing is going to be huge.

993
01:02:09.273 --> 01:02:16.836
The one thing that I'm like kind of skeptical about, I would say, is the billion full body scans per month.

994
01:02:16.916 --> 01:02:18.997
There's only 7 billion people on the earth.

995
01:02:19.861 --> 01:02:21.242
So like what?

996
01:02:21.322 --> 01:02:27.827
I guess a single person could have multiple full body scans because this is, as you said, a real time thing.

997
01:02:28.087 --> 01:02:31.330
And they're trying to make it a lifestyle spa concept.

998
01:02:31.370 --> 01:02:32.431
Then they got to make it cheap.

999
01:02:32.931 --> 01:02:33.611
Which I agree with you.

1000
01:02:33.651 --> 01:02:33.832
Right?

1001
01:02:34.012 --> 01:02:34.652
No, which I agree with you.

1002
01:02:34.672 --> 01:02:39.856
A billion a month is like that already you're saturating the developed world.

1003
01:02:44.161 --> 01:02:44.762
You know what I mean?

1004
01:02:45.502 --> 01:02:54.229
Now you got to tap into like a lot of countries that don't have the kind of capital for the health care that we do here in the States.

1005
01:02:54.249 --> 01:02:56.011
I don't know if we were up and things like that.

1006
01:02:56.051 --> 01:02:59.594
We don't need a spa like this in Zimbabwe, for example.

1007
01:02:59.634 --> 01:03:00.034
Exactly.

1008
01:03:00.054 --> 01:03:01.916
I don't think that's the right entry point.

1009
01:03:01.996 --> 01:03:04.398
So a billion full body scans per month.

1010
01:03:04.458 --> 01:03:04.658
What?

1011
01:03:04.718 --> 01:03:06.880
So a single person is doing multiple per month.

1012
01:03:08.197 --> 01:03:34.020
month yeah and then also it's like well if one scan is really good why do i need to be doing exactly like how much is my body really changing month per month um anyways that's the only number that i'm like kind of skeptical about um 50 000 scanners worldwide that makes sense that's not that there's there's a lot of cities in the world that are relative that have a relatively well to do enough population to like want to want something like this in one of their hospitals

1013
01:03:34.320 --> 01:03:36.660
We could do a dozen to two dozen in L.A. alone.

1014
01:03:36.841 --> 01:03:37.341
Exactly.

1015
01:03:37.421 --> 01:03:39.921
So, yeah.

1016
01:03:40.041 --> 01:03:44.462
I still think, yeah, the fact that it's a new medical imaging device.

1017
01:03:44.502 --> 01:03:46.122
I think that's what the interesting thing is.

1018
01:03:46.262 --> 01:03:56.764
It's just at least we're pushing, you know, again, there's both this balance between what's tried and true and then also integrating like CRISPR, right?

1019
01:03:56.824 --> 01:03:59.725
As an example, it's a new medical technology in a totally different context.

1020
01:04:00.105 --> 01:04:02.866
And we're now trying to figure out how do we make this safe?

1021
01:04:03.306 --> 01:04:04.186
How do we scale it?

1022
01:04:04.406 --> 01:04:06.127
And I think it is good to push the envelope.

1023
01:04:06.787 --> 01:04:14.289
The weird part about this story is, at least in part, the source, which is coming from a nontraditional player.

1024
01:04:14.309 --> 01:04:14.889
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1025
01:04:14.909 --> 01:04:15.709
Mid-journey.

1026
01:04:16.069 --> 01:04:19.270
In the medical imaging space, which has created a lot of skepticism.

1027
01:04:19.470 --> 01:04:20.090
Yeah.

1028
01:04:20.191 --> 01:04:21.431
But again, the proof's in the pudding.

1029
01:04:21.471 --> 01:04:22.331
It's falsifiable.

1030
01:04:22.751 --> 01:04:24.012
They can put it to the test.

1031
01:04:24.052 --> 01:04:25.132
And if the FDA approves it...

1032
01:04:25.772 --> 01:04:28.095
we will have a great new solution.

1033
01:04:28.135 --> 01:04:31.919
We are going to take this moment after our first three stories.

1034
01:04:32.279 --> 01:04:34.581
We still have, I believe it is two stories left.

1035
01:04:34.842 --> 01:04:37.444
Yeah, but those are really kind of fake stories.

1036
01:04:38.145 --> 01:04:40.788
They're going to be fun because we're going to end on some World Cup hype.

1037
01:04:41.348 --> 01:04:44.330
But before we get there, I'm going to do a little bit of housekeeping.

1038
01:04:44.850 --> 01:04:50.813
For those who are listening, as you know, with myself and Krishna, it is us two on the pod.

1039
01:04:51.193 --> 01:04:55.015
No network, no extra people coming around.

1040
01:04:55.075 --> 01:04:57.336
We really do this, just the two of us.

1041
01:04:57.656 --> 01:05:07.681
We really appreciate the support from our patrons who help support bringing you the best entertaining science and deep dive content that you can find here.

1042
01:05:08.081 --> 01:05:11.162
In the world, in English language, you get it here on FFP.

1043
01:05:11.482 --> 01:05:14.543
If you want to help support the podcast, there's a couple ways you can support.

1044
01:05:15.023 --> 01:05:18.684
You can become a donor by going to ffppod.com backslash donate.

1045
01:05:19.044 --> 01:05:21.905
We have a variety of different options one time and monthly.

1046
01:05:22.505 --> 01:05:31.067
If you cannot support monetarily in this economy, please share it with a friend, bring it to journal club, post it on your Instagram, your socials.

1047
01:05:31.648 --> 01:05:36.649
Any kind of promotion is helpful to help us get put up in the

1048
01:05:36.789 --> 01:05:59.771
billionaire algorithms which we do not control and science and science education and news is so important especially in this day and age which is it is progressing faster than ever and it is could not be more it could not be uh less understood in an era where it's growing so quickly and so any support that you could give us is super appreciated

1049
01:06:00.011 --> 01:06:01.912
All of our shows are on FFBpod.com.

1050
01:06:01.932 --> 01:06:05.292
You can listen to us on all of the podcast networks.

1051
01:06:05.713 --> 01:06:06.873
Our clips are on social.

1052
01:06:07.373 --> 01:06:15.615
If you have found yourself stumbling upon this episode after watching some of our World Cup content in the past couple of weeks, welcome.

1053
01:06:15.975 --> 01:06:18.976
This is what this show is like when we're not talking about football.

1054
01:06:19.456 --> 01:06:21.618
We will talk about it a little bit at the end of the episode.

1055
01:06:21.898 --> 01:06:26.181
But what you just experienced in the first half is really what the show is about.

1056
01:06:26.621 --> 01:06:28.842
It's great for a car ride, a commute to work.

1057
01:06:29.463 --> 01:06:34.126
It's great if you want, you have some kids getting to the teenage years.

1058
01:06:34.506 --> 01:06:37.108
You want to get them into some content that's about science.

1059
01:06:37.448 --> 01:06:38.649
But everything else is boring.

1060
01:06:39.049 --> 01:06:40.310
We have Drake memes.

1061
01:06:40.770 --> 01:06:44.712
We understand what's going on on the interwebs, what the kids are doing these days.

1062
01:06:45.193 --> 01:06:46.714
There's something about 6'7".

1063
01:06:47.014 --> 01:06:47.494
Who knows?

1064
01:06:48.955 --> 01:06:52.276
It's a great way to get everyone started and engaged with science.

1065
01:06:52.336 --> 01:06:58.178
It's fun, entertaining, but still detailed about the fundamentals and the facts.

1066
01:06:58.718 --> 01:07:15.864
And with that, what we are going to do, which has been a long time since we have done it, is bring back one of my favorite segments, which is Are You Smarter Than a Scientist?

1067
01:07:18.077 --> 01:07:43.366
our favorite game show oh okay with our resident phd krishna chowdhury as we know the world cup is about to end everyone is gonna have to find something to entertain themselves and to end the world cup journey we have our question this week is to name the 10 most common injuries

1068
01:07:45.673 --> 01:08:03.590
And I will just note that this is based on UEFA Elite Club's injury study, which is a long-running European pro club data study that was first published in 2009 with newer findings from the 2021 and 2022 seasons.

1069
01:08:05.732 --> 01:08:13.155
including their latest ECIS update in the British Journal of Sports Medicine in 2023.

1070
01:08:13.615 --> 01:08:16.456
So this is not just us making up what it is.

1071
01:08:17.357 --> 01:08:18.677
This is published data.

1072
01:08:18.997 --> 01:08:22.499
I'm trying to give you time to think because now you are on the spot.

1073
01:08:23.599 --> 01:08:24.160
Okay.

1074
01:08:24.300 --> 01:08:25.061
Common.

1075
01:08:25.121 --> 01:08:28.785
Can I just name like the specific body parts?

1076
01:08:30.446 --> 01:08:39.536
You're going to need to name a body part and potentially the type of thing that's happening with the body part.

1077
01:08:39.896 --> 01:08:42.319
Because I initially made this as just body part only.

1078
01:08:43.239 --> 01:08:44.241
But that was too easy.

1079
01:08:44.541 --> 01:08:44.921
Okay.

1080
01:08:45.101 --> 01:08:45.362
Shit.

1081
01:08:45.682 --> 01:08:46.383
So...

1082
01:08:48.506 --> 01:08:49.166
All right.

1083
01:08:49.206 --> 01:08:51.987
What about like the Achilles tendon?

1084
01:08:52.528 --> 01:08:53.888
Achilles tendon.

1085
01:08:54.088 --> 01:08:55.889
Like the Achilles, you know, the...

1086
01:08:56.369 --> 01:08:57.009
Your Achilles heel.

1087
01:08:57.049 --> 01:08:57.449
The heel.

1088
01:08:57.690 --> 01:08:58.490
Achilles heel.

1089
01:08:59.050 --> 01:09:04.392
So the question is, is Achilles heel an answer on the list?

1090
01:09:05.052 --> 01:09:06.573
And unfortunately... No?

1091
01:09:06.673 --> 01:09:08.014
Oh, my God.

1092
01:09:08.054 --> 01:09:11.875
I'm already... That is going to be your first trick early in the game.

1093
01:09:11.895 --> 01:09:12.555
Early in the game.

1094
01:09:12.855 --> 01:09:13.296
I don't...

1095
01:09:13.316 --> 01:09:14.016
This is the first time.

1096
01:09:14.336 --> 01:09:15.697
I don't even have one on there.

1097
01:09:17.157 --> 01:09:28.463
Okay, one actually, okay, I'm pretty sure even though this is European football and American soccer, there should probably be concussion on here, no?

1098
01:09:29.304 --> 01:09:31.905
Like, people are getting hit with yellow cards.

1099
01:09:32.126 --> 01:09:34.767
Like, yeah, I would say, okay, let's do concussion.

1100
01:09:35.968 --> 01:09:40.030
Is concussion on the list?

1101
01:09:41.171 --> 01:09:42.551
I really hate to say it.

1102
01:09:42.932 --> 01:09:43.152
No?

1103
01:09:43.172 --> 01:09:43.232
No?

1104
01:09:44.770 --> 01:09:47.273
But it is not in the top 10 most common.

1105
01:09:47.293 --> 01:09:47.773
It's not 10.

1106
01:09:47.933 --> 01:09:48.194
Okay.

1107
01:09:48.334 --> 01:09:49.395
In the most common.

1108
01:09:49.895 --> 01:09:52.598
You were more directionally correct with your first.

1109
01:09:53.138 --> 01:09:55.140
It's got to do with legs, huh?

1110
01:09:55.381 --> 01:09:55.841
All right.

1111
01:09:56.302 --> 01:10:01.667
I'm just going to say that.

1112
01:10:01.687 --> 01:10:03.129
You know, hamstring.

1113
01:10:03.569 --> 01:10:03.889
Okay.

1114
01:10:04.870 --> 01:10:06.592
So we're saying hamstring.

1115
01:10:06.692 --> 01:10:06.792
Yeah.

1116
01:10:06.812 --> 01:10:06.972
Yeah.

1117
01:10:08.012 --> 01:10:11.495
And we're going to be on the board with a hamstring strain.

1118
01:10:11.595 --> 01:10:11.836
Okay.

1119
01:10:11.856 --> 01:10:12.456
I'll give you that.

1120
01:10:12.776 --> 01:10:13.077
Okay.

1121
01:10:13.097 --> 01:10:14.238
So very common.

1122
01:10:14.398 --> 01:10:14.918
Very common.

1123
01:10:14.938 --> 01:10:15.339
Yeah.

1124
01:10:15.399 --> 01:10:17.160
I think you've even mentioned it.

1125
01:10:17.220 --> 01:10:17.441
Yes.

1126
01:10:17.541 --> 01:10:18.161
At 24%.

1127
01:10:19.362 --> 01:10:20.463
It's kind of the meme.

1128
01:10:21.224 --> 01:10:24.707
Celebrations have been made over people grabbing their hamstring.

1129
01:10:24.767 --> 01:10:25.007
Yeah.

1130
01:10:25.187 --> 01:10:28.030
Like after they score a goal, pretending they have a hamstring injury.

1131
01:10:28.483 --> 01:10:28.763
Okay.

1132
01:10:28.863 --> 01:10:29.564
So we're on the board.

1133
01:10:29.904 --> 01:10:30.204
Okay.

1134
01:10:30.664 --> 01:10:32.325
So we're cooking.

1135
01:10:32.365 --> 01:10:32.905
You'll get some.

1136
01:10:33.206 --> 01:10:33.686
You'll get some.

1137
01:10:33.746 --> 01:10:34.086
Okay.

1138
01:10:34.306 --> 01:10:35.727
Okay.

1139
01:10:36.367 --> 01:10:38.508
I'm going to need some lifelines, though, because I'm already on two.

1140
01:10:38.628 --> 01:10:39.369
Okay.

1141
01:10:39.429 --> 01:10:40.009
Okay.

1142
01:10:40.089 --> 01:10:41.990
So you're going to have to give me a few.

1143
01:10:42.030 --> 01:10:43.231
What I would say here is think about...

1144
01:10:46.592 --> 01:10:51.154
Football is a sport where we run long distances, right?

1145
01:10:51.734 --> 01:11:09.361
And there's a part of the body over those long distances that is very active in being a – try not to be too specific here – in being a facilitator of other parts of the lower body moving over long distances.

1146
01:11:09.381 --> 01:11:09.541
Right?

1147
01:11:13.039 --> 01:11:14.340
No, I'm thinking of the heart.

1148
01:11:14.640 --> 01:11:15.061
No, no, no.

1149
01:11:15.241 --> 01:11:16.602
But that doesn't make sense.

1150
01:11:16.702 --> 01:11:17.662
The lower, okay.

1151
01:11:19.404 --> 01:11:27.929
Think about the different component parts, and something has to be a translator between... Oh, like the knee?

1152
01:11:28.329 --> 01:11:28.750
I don't know.

1153
01:11:28.910 --> 01:11:29.470
I'm just saying.

1154
01:11:29.490 --> 01:11:30.250
Okay, so...

1155
01:11:30.371 --> 01:11:30.931
I'm just saying.

1156
01:11:30.951 --> 01:11:31.631
Wait, what's in the knee?

1157
01:11:31.671 --> 01:11:32.652
Oh, the ACLU.

1158
01:11:32.932 --> 01:11:38.176
No, that's the... That's the... No, but you know what I mean?

1159
01:11:38.216 --> 01:11:39.136
The thingy.

1160
01:11:40.157 --> 01:11:41.438
There are three letters there that are correct.

1161
01:11:42.078 --> 01:11:42.758
The ACL.

1162
01:11:42.819 --> 01:11:43.479
The ACL.

1163
01:11:44.119 --> 01:11:45.120
Yeah.

1164
01:11:45.580 --> 01:11:46.241
ACL tear.

1165
01:11:46.381 --> 01:11:47.061
Okay, there we go.

1166
01:11:47.101 --> 01:11:48.122
Is our number 10 answer.

1167
01:11:48.942 --> 01:11:51.784
And a little bit lower than many would expect at only 2%.

1168
01:11:51.884 --> 01:11:52.224
Okay.

1169
01:11:54.025 --> 01:11:54.966
But like that's the knee.

1170
01:11:55.146 --> 01:11:55.606
That's the knee.

1171
01:11:55.626 --> 01:11:56.326
Okay, that's the knee.

1172
01:11:56.547 --> 01:11:57.827
We're getting a tear in the knee.

1173
01:11:58.288 --> 01:12:00.329
All right, we got hamstring, which is I think thighs.

1174
01:12:00.929 --> 01:12:01.389
Now we got knees.

1175
01:12:01.409 --> 01:12:01.690
Okay.

1176
01:12:02.570 --> 01:12:04.212
No, there's got to be something in the foot.

1177
01:12:04.252 --> 01:12:06.735
The guy from Canada broke his...

1178
01:12:07.276 --> 01:12:10.880
Didn't he break something because of the Qatari red card?

1179
01:12:11.942 --> 01:12:12.803
I plead the fifth.

1180
01:12:13.123 --> 01:12:14.084
That's got to be something.

1181
01:12:14.144 --> 01:12:16.467
I plead the fifth.

1182
01:12:16.527 --> 01:12:21.093
I'll give you another lifeline, which is I would stay in...

1183
01:12:23.766 --> 01:12:25.527
muscles more than bones.

1184
01:12:25.647 --> 01:12:26.667
More than bones, okay.

1185
01:12:26.847 --> 01:12:29.589
Only Christian Pulisic gets a microfracture.

1186
01:12:29.789 --> 01:12:30.629
Right.

1187
01:12:31.169 --> 01:12:32.390
Well, that's actually not true.

1188
01:12:32.470 --> 01:12:32.590
Yeah.

1189
01:12:32.610 --> 01:12:36.011
And so let me not, that's not, it may be in our answers, so that's not true.

1190
01:12:36.511 --> 01:12:41.834
But I think being more muscle oriented would be the correct approach here.

1191
01:12:42.674 --> 01:12:44.735
I know there's people who are watching at home and they're like,

1192
01:12:45.465 --> 01:12:47.267
Bing, bing, bong, boom, bing, bing.

1193
01:12:47.708 --> 01:12:49.149
And they're just going through this list.

1194
01:12:49.570 --> 01:12:53.474
I've gotten actually probably six to eight of these injuries myself.

1195
01:12:53.514 --> 01:12:53.935
Oh, really?

1196
01:12:54.015 --> 01:12:54.215
Yeah.

1197
01:12:55.236 --> 01:12:56.498
This muscle...

1198
01:12:58.610 --> 01:12:59.010
Let's see.

1199
01:12:59.051 --> 01:13:00.072
No, hamstring is done.

1200
01:13:00.792 --> 01:13:03.475
The calves, calf strain.

1201
01:13:03.976 --> 01:13:07.119
We will go ahead and put calf strain at number seven.

1202
01:13:07.279 --> 01:13:07.500
Nice.

1203
01:13:07.560 --> 01:13:08.581
With 4%.

1204
01:13:08.621 --> 01:13:09.802
We are on the board.

1205
01:13:10.123 --> 01:13:11.344
Again, you're starting to...

1206
01:13:11.364 --> 01:13:11.604
Okay.

1207
01:13:11.965 --> 01:13:13.026
You're starting to wind it.

1208
01:13:13.046 --> 01:13:14.407
It's been a while since we've done it.

1209
01:13:14.908 --> 01:13:16.109
I will note, Christian is...

1210
01:13:17.050 --> 01:13:39.395
a biophysicist physicist because biophysicists people get annoyed about it yeah mostly like at the molecular level not uh molecular and cellular level not at a full organism um no calves hamstrings hamstring um you're on the board you're on the board aclu is the there's got to be something with the foot how about um like uh

1211
01:13:41.206 --> 01:13:42.306
No, I already said Achilles.

1212
01:13:42.346 --> 01:13:43.007
That didn't work.

1213
01:13:45.548 --> 01:13:48.969
Again, think about soccer being a sport where we run a lot.

1214
01:13:49.349 --> 01:13:49.589
Yeah.

1215
01:13:49.949 --> 01:13:50.309
Okay.

1216
01:13:50.430 --> 01:13:51.430
So, calves.

1217
01:13:51.850 --> 01:13:52.210
What else?

1218
01:13:52.390 --> 01:13:53.371
What is this thing called?

1219
01:13:53.391 --> 01:13:53.871
The thigh?

1220
01:13:53.951 --> 01:13:54.111
No.

1221
01:13:54.131 --> 01:13:54.911
The thigh muscle?

1222
01:13:55.571 --> 01:13:56.932
The quad.

1223
01:13:57.072 --> 01:13:57.532
Quad.

1224
01:13:57.792 --> 01:13:58.613
Quad strain.

1225
01:13:58.873 --> 01:14:00.193
We got it on the board.

1226
01:14:00.233 --> 01:14:01.134
Number six.

1227
01:14:01.254 --> 01:14:02.574
Quad strain.

1228
01:14:03.054 --> 01:14:04.255
With five percent.

1229
01:14:04.295 --> 01:14:04.575
Okay.

1230
01:14:04.615 --> 01:14:05.455
Now I just got to...

1231
01:14:05.475 --> 01:14:06.035
Okay.

1232
01:14:06.075 --> 01:14:08.656
How many muscles can I think of that are in the lower body?

1233
01:14:11.933 --> 01:14:32.116
we're cooking we're missing number two three four five eight and nine there's a lot of items on the board well it's drained damn i really thought concussion was gonna be on here um thankfully we don't make contact with our heads that often cte is not a problem in the game of football

1234
01:14:33.149 --> 01:14:38.573
How about... Now I'm just blanking.

1235
01:14:38.633 --> 01:14:39.834
I literally have no idea.

1236
01:14:39.854 --> 01:14:40.854
I'm going to say heel.

1237
01:14:41.515 --> 01:14:41.975
The heel.

1238
01:14:42.375 --> 01:14:42.976
The heel.

1239
01:14:43.136 --> 01:14:44.557
The heel muscle.

1240
01:14:44.677 --> 01:14:45.938
The heel muscle.

1241
01:14:46.718 --> 01:14:49.960
Is it on the board for our last strike?

1242
01:14:51.181 --> 01:14:52.482
Unfortunately...

1243
01:14:54.288 --> 01:14:55.929
That is not on the board.

1244
01:14:55.950 --> 01:14:56.490
Yeah, that's fair.

1245
01:14:56.550 --> 01:14:57.651
This was a tough one.

1246
01:14:58.071 --> 01:15:01.154
Yeah, it just shows you how little I know about the human body.

1247
01:15:01.214 --> 01:15:04.237
I was really trying to mostly rage bait the audience.

1248
01:15:04.297 --> 01:15:07.480
We're screaming the answers at home right now.

1249
01:15:08.361 --> 01:15:09.682
I kind of put you in a tough spot.

1250
01:15:10.222 --> 01:15:12.584
But we're going to go through with the correct answers.

1251
01:15:13.085 --> 01:15:14.366
In our number two spot...

1252
01:15:15.669 --> 01:15:21.292
was a contusion at 17%, which you can get bruising, bone contusion.

1253
01:15:21.713 --> 01:15:21.953
Okay.

1254
01:15:21.973 --> 01:15:22.673
Very common.

1255
01:15:23.694 --> 01:15:35.721
Number three is an injury I currently have after going to, shout out to Ben, Ben Fong's birthday party, where I got a groin strain at 9%.

1256
01:15:36.341 --> 01:15:39.303
I should have done groin, yeah.

1257
01:15:39.523 --> 01:15:40.323
Very common.

1258
01:15:41.144 --> 01:15:42.485
I know you said Achilles.

1259
01:15:43.265 --> 01:15:44.066
It was close.

1260
01:15:45.052 --> 01:15:47.233
But not quite the ankle sprain.

1261
01:15:47.654 --> 01:15:47.794
Oh.

1262
01:15:48.014 --> 01:15:51.276
Which was the answer we were looking for at 7%.

1263
01:15:51.416 --> 01:15:53.798
That's probably an Achilles in there.

1264
01:15:53.958 --> 01:15:55.079
I don't think that's correct.

1265
01:15:55.239 --> 01:15:55.479
No.

1266
01:15:55.699 --> 01:15:58.441
I'm shocked we didn't get the ankle sprain.

1267
01:15:59.321 --> 01:16:01.563
Now, we talked about the ACLU tear.

1268
01:16:01.983 --> 01:16:02.403
Yes.

1269
01:16:03.284 --> 01:16:09.128
But we did not talk about the MCL sprain, which is another type of...

1270
01:16:10.765 --> 01:16:12.046
abbreviation sprain.

1271
01:16:12.367 --> 01:16:13.267
I'm not a doctor.

1272
01:16:14.008 --> 01:16:16.270
I know there's ACL, MCL.

1273
01:16:16.871 --> 01:16:17.951
Everyone talks about it.

1274
01:16:18.012 --> 01:16:18.872
It's so common.

1275
01:16:19.453 --> 01:16:20.554
Our number eight.

1276
01:16:22.017 --> 01:16:32.659
which is more in the direction of the former captain of the U.S. Men's National Team, Christian Pulisic, with a fracture at 4%.

1277
01:16:33.259 --> 01:16:39.661
And our last option, I was trying to talk about the connector, is a meniscus tear.

1278
01:16:40.201 --> 01:16:41.601
Oh, I could have gotten that.

1279
01:16:41.721 --> 01:16:42.181
Which was at 3%.

1280
01:16:42.201 --> 01:16:42.921
We did not get a...

1281
01:16:47.165 --> 01:16:48.106
this episode.

1282
01:16:48.186 --> 01:16:49.867
No, I didn't deserve that.

1283
01:16:49.947 --> 01:17:00.274
It was not that well, but we really do appreciate all of our listeners joining for another great installment of Are You Smarter Than a Scientist?

1284
01:17:00.894 --> 01:17:16.284
I did put Krishna on the spot today and the stream deck worked perfectly with no interruptions, so we are not rusty at all as we are now pushing an hour and 15 minutes for what was supposed to be a short episode.

1285
01:17:17.165 --> 01:17:20.628
But as you know us, we like to yap on this show.

1286
01:17:21.048 --> 01:17:25.711
And so we're going to go now into the last of our two stories, which are going to be fun.

1287
01:17:25.932 --> 01:17:26.952
It's going to be relaxing.

1288
01:17:27.333 --> 01:17:29.054
We're going to wrap this up pretty quick here.

1289
01:17:29.574 --> 01:17:34.478
We are going into our England versus Norway World Cup goal.

1290
01:17:34.938 --> 01:17:35.779
Ball camera.

1291
01:17:36.139 --> 01:17:36.680
Cable.

1292
01:17:37.060 --> 01:17:38.321
Hey, Jude.

1293
01:17:38.941 --> 01:17:40.002
Bellingham story.

1294
01:17:40.342 --> 01:17:40.623
Yes.

1295
01:17:40.823 --> 01:17:41.023
So.

1296
01:17:42.147 --> 01:17:45.909
Norway versus England in the quarterfinals.

1297
01:17:46.129 --> 01:17:51.652
The goalie of Norway kicks a ball, and I think we've got a video of it on Fox Sports.

1298
01:17:51.792 --> 01:17:54.153
This is video 14.

1299
01:17:54.453 --> 01:17:55.494
This is on Fox Sports, right?

1300
01:17:56.074 --> 01:17:57.135
He kicks the ball.

1301
01:17:57.195 --> 01:18:11.222
Apparently, it hits a wire, one of the wires that holds up the sky cam, and then it lands directly on an English player who then dribbles, gives it to Bellingham somewhere, and then Bellingham scores.

1302
01:18:11.482 --> 01:18:17.184
I think that's Anthony Gordon, $80 million Barcelona player, eat your heart out, Marcus Rashford.

1303
01:18:17.564 --> 01:18:19.725
And then the Norway team's like, it definitely hit.

1304
01:18:19.885 --> 01:18:23.987
And Fox Sports, there's Erling Haaland saying it definitely hit.

1305
01:18:24.407 --> 01:18:28.849
And Fox Sports on their Instagram says it hit a wire.

1306
01:18:29.609 --> 01:18:33.672
So they went on the record to say it hit a wire, right?

1307
01:18:33.712 --> 01:18:36.694
Now let's go to the next video.

1308
01:18:36.834 --> 01:18:41.838
This is from TSN, which is, I think, the Canadian ESPN.

1309
01:18:42.238 --> 01:18:49.403
And they show from the side, it hits the spider cam, and then it goes down, changes the trajectory...

1310
01:18:51.200 --> 01:18:53.061
Looks a little Infantino-ish.

1311
01:18:53.261 --> 01:18:54.002
A little sketch.

1312
01:18:54.182 --> 01:18:55.223
It looks a little sketchy.

1313
01:18:55.283 --> 01:18:59.705
It looks like, I mean, they're doing this whole, like, you know, zoom in and things like that, right?

1314
01:19:00.006 --> 01:19:05.509
The next video we've got is just a clean video that I found of the ball going up.

1315
01:19:05.949 --> 01:19:08.091
And then it definitely, like, falls down.

1316
01:19:08.231 --> 01:19:08.571
Bruh, bruh.

1317
01:19:09.372 --> 01:19:11.954
It definitely falls down.

1318
01:19:12.835 --> 01:19:20.682
The camera itself is moving, which is why I can't really get a good handle on what's going on.

1319
01:19:20.763 --> 01:19:25.207
But it seems like it goes up, and then it falls faster than it should.

1320
01:19:25.587 --> 01:19:29.251
This is not a rainbow where there's gold at the end of the rainbow.

1321
01:19:29.531 --> 01:19:30.212
No, right?

1322
01:19:30.512 --> 01:19:33.114
And it seems more than air resistance.

1323
01:19:33.295 --> 01:19:33.655
Yeah.

1324
01:19:33.795 --> 01:19:38.017
Because I do understand that, like, you know, it's not going to be a perfect parabola.

1325
01:19:38.057 --> 01:19:40.119
The parabola is going to get squished as you keep going.

1326
01:19:40.139 --> 01:19:43.761
It just doesn't look quite like air resistance.

1327
01:19:44.361 --> 01:19:44.621
Right?

1328
01:19:44.981 --> 01:19:45.802
It's a little sketch.

1329
01:19:46.042 --> 01:19:46.242
Right?

1330
01:19:46.602 --> 01:19:47.803
Now, the ball has a sensor.

1331
01:19:48.223 --> 01:19:48.884
That's the story.

1332
01:19:49.104 --> 01:19:50.044
Which we talked about.

1333
01:19:50.104 --> 01:19:50.325
Yes.

1334
01:19:50.365 --> 01:19:55.147
We talked about the ball has a sensor, and it's taking data at 500 hertz.

1335
01:19:55.207 --> 01:20:01.731
It's got this IMU inertial mass unit right under the surface of the ball.

1336
01:20:02.371 --> 01:20:02.511
Yeah.

1337
01:20:03.452 --> 01:20:08.276
It goes off and it's sending data at 500 times a second, right?

1338
01:20:08.616 --> 01:20:11.299
This thing is measuring acceleration in three directions.

1339
01:20:11.899 --> 01:20:15.682
So FIFA puts out this video of the ball.

1340
01:20:16.403 --> 01:20:18.725
There's the data from the IMU.

1341
01:20:18.865 --> 01:20:26.591
In the bottom left corner, we see it like what looks like if you watch ER or the pit or any hospital shows, the little thing that shows your heartbeat.

1342
01:20:26.812 --> 01:20:27.512
Yeah.

1343
01:20:27.552 --> 01:20:28.473
This is flatlined.

1344
01:20:28.713 --> 01:20:32.875
It's flatlined, except for when the goalie kicks it.

1345
01:20:33.056 --> 01:20:33.396
That's it.

1346
01:20:33.516 --> 01:20:34.336
It's flatlining.

1347
01:20:34.456 --> 01:20:36.878
There's a little bit of undulation, you can actually tell.

1348
01:20:37.058 --> 01:20:39.339
If you look closely, there's a tiny bit of undulation.

1349
01:20:39.359 --> 01:20:40.340
It's not totally flat.

1350
01:20:41.100 --> 01:20:41.820
It's not a line.

1351
01:20:41.941 --> 01:20:48.944
It's not a line, which tells me, because there's a theory that's going out there saying that, oh, perhaps the ball cut off.

1352
01:20:49.545 --> 01:20:55.008
It was far enough away from the receivers to where the data packet wasn't going through.

1353
01:20:55.548 --> 01:20:59.211
I don't see that because I'm seeing it's still, it's continues to continue.

1354
01:20:59.251 --> 01:21:00.593
Like it's not flat lining.

1355
01:21:00.633 --> 01:21:00.773
Right.

1356
01:21:00.793 --> 01:21:05.117
There's still, there's still like salient data going through a consistent signal.

1357
01:21:05.137 --> 01:21:07.439
That is not, it's not just a, whatever, uh,

1358
01:21:08.779 --> 01:21:09.840
y equals zero.

1359
01:21:10.120 --> 01:21:10.600
Exactly.

1360
01:21:10.800 --> 01:21:11.441
Yeah.

1361
01:21:12.141 --> 01:21:14.263
So now this brings me to my next point, right?

1362
01:21:14.303 --> 01:21:16.504
Which is, and I'd like you to stay on this, right?

1363
01:21:16.524 --> 01:21:16.624
Okay.

1364
01:21:16.644 --> 01:21:17.625
Well, we're going to keep this up.

1365
01:21:17.645 --> 01:21:17.865
Yeah.

1366
01:21:18.005 --> 01:21:22.128
So it brings me to my next point, which is the ball is now traveling through the air.

1367
01:21:22.468 --> 01:21:22.728
Yeah.

1368
01:21:23.008 --> 01:21:23.228
Right?

1369
01:21:23.609 --> 01:21:24.769
It's experiencing free fall.

1370
01:21:25.230 --> 01:21:34.435
It's also spinning because as with any ball, and I think you can see in the video, the ball is actually spinning, but this thing is flatlined or almost.

1371
01:21:34.856 --> 01:21:37.758
There is a tiny undulation, which I think is caused by the spin.

1372
01:21:37.778 --> 01:21:37.878
Yeah.

1373
01:21:38.638 --> 01:21:49.688
But what I think is happening is that there is post-processing algorithms that are taking the raw data.

1374
01:21:49.708 --> 01:21:51.869
Because what we're seeing right now is...

1375
01:21:52.805 --> 01:21:53.926
Just a 1D trace.

1376
01:21:54.026 --> 01:21:57.788
First of all, it's infuriating to me that there's no axes labels.

1377
01:21:57.968 --> 01:21:58.929
Yeah.

1378
01:21:59.049 --> 01:21:59.189
Okay?

1379
01:21:59.229 --> 01:22:04.793
My PhD advisor would have my neck if I presented him any data that looked like that.

1380
01:22:05.113 --> 01:22:06.074
And for good reason.

1381
01:22:06.154 --> 01:22:06.374
Right.

1382
01:22:06.494 --> 01:22:06.854
Okay?

1383
01:22:06.914 --> 01:22:07.054
Right.

1384
01:22:07.074 --> 01:22:08.856
You got to have labels on your axes.

1385
01:22:08.876 --> 01:22:09.236
Yeah.

1386
01:22:09.256 --> 01:22:10.677
Tell me like a second.

1387
01:22:10.757 --> 01:22:10.957
Right.

1388
01:22:11.397 --> 01:22:14.538
And what the y-axis even means, is it a meters per second?

1389
01:22:14.838 --> 01:22:16.198
Am I looking at acceleration?

1390
01:22:16.518 --> 01:22:18.378
Am I looking at angular acceleration?

1391
01:22:18.478 --> 01:22:19.699
What am I even looking at?

1392
01:22:19.779 --> 01:22:20.319
Is it jerk?

1393
01:22:20.379 --> 01:22:22.619
Is it the derivative of acceleration?

1394
01:22:22.679 --> 01:22:23.659
So on and so forth, right?

1395
01:22:23.959 --> 01:22:28.960
So anyways, there's got to be, there's like a sensitivity threshold, right?

1396
01:22:29.040 --> 01:22:30.360
For when things get triggered.

1397
01:22:30.541 --> 01:22:30.761
Right.

1398
01:22:31.041 --> 01:22:36.062
And I think there's got to be some post-processing of the data that is happening.

1399
01:22:36.362 --> 01:22:36.602
Right.

1400
01:22:36.662 --> 01:22:38.242
Which is true of a lot of...

1401
01:22:39.117 --> 01:22:41.778
sense of platforms where you have the level of volume of data.

1402
01:22:42.198 --> 01:22:43.658
There's just so much noise.

1403
01:22:43.878 --> 01:22:45.458
What are you looking for?

1404
01:22:45.598 --> 01:22:49.919
Yeah, and in any case, the IMU is measuring three units of acceleration.

1405
01:22:50.019 --> 01:22:52.019
It's an X, Y, and Z in acceleration.

1406
01:22:52.299 --> 01:23:00.181
If something is spinning, you're going to get acceleration in X, Y, and Z, and all of those are going to cycle through, which is going to cause the spinning.

1407
01:23:00.521 --> 01:23:05.642
So the fact that I'm seeing this flatlining means that there is some post-processing going on.

1408
01:23:05.662 --> 01:23:06.122
Fundamentally.

1409
01:23:06.262 --> 01:23:06.422
Right?

1410
01:23:06.462 --> 01:23:07.103
Fundamentally.

1411
01:23:07.523 --> 01:23:09.525
We're not even seeing the...

1412
01:23:09.686 --> 01:23:11.688
Anyway, we would see a three-dimensional thing.

1413
01:23:11.708 --> 01:23:14.571
Yeah, I would see three traces at least, but I'm seeing only one.

1414
01:23:14.891 --> 01:23:18.535
Now, perhaps they're signaling out one, but in any case, I'm not seeing the whole thing.

1415
01:23:18.935 --> 01:23:19.156
Okay?

1416
01:23:19.396 --> 01:23:22.579
We can all agree that this is not raw data that I'm seeing.

1417
01:23:23.160 --> 01:23:23.420
100%.

1418
01:23:23.520 --> 01:23:23.740
Okay?

1419
01:23:23.900 --> 01:23:24.661
With no labels.

1420
01:23:24.962 --> 01:23:26.663
Yeah, with no labels.

1421
01:23:26.783 --> 01:23:27.004
Okay.

1422
01:23:27.364 --> 01:23:28.665
Now, the second thing is...

1423
01:23:29.697 --> 01:23:40.705
Now, if the ball is spinning and it's subject to this constant acceleration, right, there's got to be an algorithm that's looking for a discrete touch, like the one that the goalie had, like the one when he fell.

1424
01:23:41.766 --> 01:23:44.408
Or the one where it hit the hair of the one player on that one team.

1425
01:23:44.428 --> 01:23:45.529
Yes, and actually that's the next one.

1426
01:23:45.569 --> 01:23:49.232
If you go to the next one, we've got Croatia versus Portugal.

1427
01:23:49.512 --> 01:23:57.698
There's a little bump of it hitting the guy, his hair, and then all of a sudden Croatia's goal is disallowed, right?

1428
01:23:57.718 --> 01:23:58.479
Right.

1429
01:23:58.799 --> 01:24:06.561
Now, there's not a lot of information about the post-processing of the data.

1430
01:24:06.581 --> 01:24:12.483
There's a lot of information out there on the FIFA website about the 500 hertz, about the IMU.

1431
01:24:12.983 --> 01:24:18.945
But at the end of the day, fundamentally, what is the data that I'm seeing on my TV that they're presenting as evidence?

1432
01:24:20.525 --> 01:24:21.125
I don't know.

1433
01:24:21.705 --> 01:24:27.027
Now, the worst case scenario would be that there is an AI algorithm.

1434
01:24:28.112 --> 01:24:44.124
that is behind this, right, that has been trained on player touches, that has been trained on what to look for when I kick a ball, when a hand feels a ball, when it hits my head, right?

1435
01:24:44.444 --> 01:24:47.226
These are things that the AI algorithm would have been trained for.

1436
01:24:47.847 --> 01:24:50.569
And perhaps the signature... Perchance.

1437
01:24:51.049 --> 01:24:51.449
Perchance.

1438
01:24:51.769 --> 01:24:54.471
Perchance the signature of the ball hitting a wire...

1439
01:24:55.432 --> 01:25:03.397
is a very different signature in that IMU compared to hitting a human body because there's a springiness in us compared to, like, the wire.

1440
01:25:03.437 --> 01:25:05.478
But I guess the wire also has a springiness.

1441
01:25:05.998 --> 01:25:12.822
But, like, maybe the timing is, like, small enough where, like, the algorithm thought it was just noise.

1442
01:25:12.962 --> 01:25:14.603
It's, like, some type of thing, right?

1443
01:25:15.203 --> 01:25:18.165
I'm just saying I don't think this is a good way...

1444
01:25:18.365 --> 01:25:19.846
It's not in the training data set.

1445
01:25:19.966 --> 01:25:22.027
Yeah, perhaps it's not in the training data set.

1446
01:25:22.107 --> 01:25:22.748
And so now...

1447
01:25:23.611 --> 01:25:24.492
And it gets filtered out?

1448
01:25:24.953 --> 01:25:26.895
It gets filtered out because it thinks it's noise.

1449
01:25:28.316 --> 01:25:28.597
Look.

1450
01:25:28.737 --> 01:25:29.217
I don't know.

1451
01:25:29.798 --> 01:25:43.453
So we do know after our Match and Momentum video that there are folks who've worked on some of FIFA's graphics and digital analytics tools that are displayed in-game.

1452
01:25:44.198 --> 01:25:48.004
We would love to actually understand this question.

1453
01:25:48.685 --> 01:25:49.587
It's in the weeds.

1454
01:25:50.228 --> 01:25:55.036
It's in the weeds, but it's also fairly clear from the video that it hit something.

1455
01:25:56.014 --> 01:25:56.314
Right?

1456
01:25:56.714 --> 01:25:57.675
How do we explain?

1457
01:25:57.715 --> 01:25:59.675
It's like, I don't know.

1458
01:25:59.835 --> 01:26:02.496
It's fairly clear from the video that there's a change in momentum.

1459
01:26:03.057 --> 01:26:06.138
How is it that the IMU on the ball did not pick it up?

1460
01:26:06.298 --> 01:26:07.458
Both things can be true.

1461
01:26:07.638 --> 01:26:07.858
Right.

1462
01:26:07.999 --> 01:26:08.219
Right?

1463
01:26:08.279 --> 01:26:08.479
Right.

1464
01:26:08.839 --> 01:26:09.019
Right.

1465
01:26:09.779 --> 01:26:12.480
It can be true in saying, well, we have these ball sensors.

1466
01:26:12.640 --> 01:26:15.401
And I don't, yeah, like nothing got triggered.

1467
01:26:15.521 --> 01:26:16.662
And so the referee didn't see it.

1468
01:26:16.742 --> 01:26:17.062
Okay.

1469
01:26:17.282 --> 01:26:24.805
However, we have visuals from multiple angles that don't align with that description of events.

1470
01:26:24.825 --> 01:26:25.085
Yeah.

1471
01:26:25.405 --> 01:26:27.827
And so this is a great learning opportunity.

1472
01:26:28.188 --> 01:26:28.408
Yeah.

1473
01:26:28.468 --> 01:26:31.831
We'd be happy to have you on and to discuss.

1474
01:26:33.354 --> 01:26:34.935
Is there a filter?

1475
01:26:35.355 --> 01:26:43.461
Is there sort of an AI algorithm that helps to distill down these three axes into what we see in a 2D plane with no labels?

1476
01:26:44.401 --> 01:26:44.902
And I get it.

1477
01:26:44.922 --> 01:26:46.222
It's sports.

1478
01:26:46.583 --> 01:26:48.484
People don't want to read labels.

1479
01:26:48.524 --> 01:26:50.205
And fair play to the Norway team.

1480
01:26:50.505 --> 01:26:52.606
They said, let's not make this a big deal.

1481
01:26:52.646 --> 01:26:53.907
That's not why we lost.

1482
01:26:53.947 --> 01:26:55.068
Let's play.

1483
01:26:55.368 --> 01:26:55.869
However...

1484
01:26:56.729 --> 01:26:59.170
It is... Yeah.

1485
01:26:59.330 --> 01:27:00.030
I'd like to know.

1486
01:27:00.590 --> 01:27:00.790
Right?

1487
01:27:01.090 --> 01:27:04.671
And I also think, like, it's also just a bad way to do...

1488
01:27:04.971 --> 01:27:13.853
If you were in an experimental lab and you were only relying on a single sensor that has a heavy amount of data manipulation, that's just a bad way to do things.

1489
01:27:13.953 --> 01:27:14.133
Right.

1490
01:27:14.153 --> 01:27:15.814
You should always have coincident data.

1491
01:27:16.134 --> 01:27:20.135
And so, like, and I'm pretty sure FIFA has a bunch of cameras, as we were talking about.

1492
01:27:20.535 --> 01:27:20.755
Right?

1493
01:27:20.915 --> 01:27:21.175
So...

1494
01:27:22.144 --> 01:27:27.650
There's got to be other perhaps that modality of data sensing is not in real time.

1495
01:27:28.591 --> 01:27:31.734
And and so and as such, you can't stop.

1496
01:27:31.754 --> 01:27:36.239
And perhaps only the sensor is the thing that is like affecting real time decisions.

1497
01:27:36.419 --> 01:27:43.827
And if there's a filter there, at least at a minimum, we can say, hey, yes, we need to expand the filter a little bit.

1498
01:27:43.907 --> 01:27:44.147
Yeah.

1499
01:27:44.207 --> 01:27:52.350
To account for this incidental event type that was not in our initial problem set when we defined how to define the filters.

1500
01:27:52.370 --> 01:27:52.570
Yeah.

1501
01:27:52.730 --> 01:27:53.310
And that's okay.

1502
01:27:53.750 --> 01:27:54.891
This is just like, this is fun.

1503
01:27:55.071 --> 01:27:55.291
Yeah.

1504
01:27:55.351 --> 01:27:56.451
I just, I don't know.

1505
01:27:56.471 --> 01:27:57.471
Like, we don't know.

1506
01:27:58.932 --> 01:28:01.513
I'm literally just speculating, but like, given what I've seen.

1507
01:28:02.353 --> 01:28:04.595
It doesn't add up.

1508
01:28:04.815 --> 01:28:06.457
The math is not mathing.

1509
01:28:06.737 --> 01:28:08.619
And so we would appreciate an answer.

1510
01:28:09.179 --> 01:28:14.644
FIFA, we are here to give you a platform to explain if you would like to.

1511
01:28:15.185 --> 01:28:19.229
And if you would not like to, we will still get the answer one way or another.

1512
01:28:19.289 --> 01:28:19.529
Yeah.

1513
01:28:19.669 --> 01:28:20.970
And so... We'll figure it out.

1514
01:28:21.331 --> 01:28:21.951
It is just...

1515
01:28:23.862 --> 01:28:28.926
These are the challenges that happen when you put new technology into production.

1516
01:28:29.426 --> 01:28:30.767
And it happens in hardware.

1517
01:28:30.867 --> 01:28:32.108
It happens in software.

1518
01:28:32.949 --> 01:28:34.370
We now it's the US.

1519
01:28:34.390 --> 01:28:36.171
We have these crazy sky cams.

1520
01:28:37.332 --> 01:28:38.172
Blah, blah, blah.

1521
01:28:38.512 --> 01:28:39.573
They're moving quickly.

1522
01:28:40.754 --> 01:28:42.474
Players can kick the ball higher now.

1523
01:28:42.975 --> 01:28:43.495
All this stuff.

1524
01:28:43.675 --> 01:28:49.376
We're going to move to our second one, which is another interesting aspect of the World Cup.

1525
01:28:49.396 --> 01:28:49.636
Yes.

1526
01:28:49.836 --> 01:28:53.937
I'm sure you've seen the entire world turn on Argentina.

1527
01:28:54.357 --> 01:28:55.377
It has happened.

1528
01:28:55.437 --> 01:28:56.438
It has happened, right?

1529
01:28:57.278 --> 01:28:59.098
This is the BBC, classic BBC.

1530
01:28:59.138 --> 01:29:00.059
Classic BBC.

1531
01:29:00.139 --> 01:29:02.939
Ahead of the Argentina-England match.

1532
01:29:03.119 --> 01:29:05.900
Are Argentina being treated favorably at the World Cup?

1533
01:29:07.180 --> 01:29:10.261
Is Messi and Argentina being favored by FIFA, right?

1534
01:29:10.921 --> 01:29:14.083
So there's a lot of just like rhetoric out there.

1535
01:29:14.303 --> 01:29:16.344
A lot of anecdotal evidence.

1536
01:29:16.825 --> 01:29:19.927
A lot of people watching the Egypt game.

1537
01:29:20.187 --> 01:29:22.008
Witness testimony, one would say.

1538
01:29:22.048 --> 01:29:22.768
What's going on?

1539
01:29:23.229 --> 01:29:25.910
People watching the Swiss game saying what's going on.

1540
01:29:26.931 --> 01:29:27.971
There is a...

1541
01:29:28.992 --> 01:29:36.937
Guy from a Northeastern, from the Northeastern Sports Statistics NetSI Sports Research Group, Brennan Klein.

1542
01:29:37.297 --> 01:29:39.959
So he compiled some data.

1543
01:29:40.339 --> 01:29:41.020
We love data.

1544
01:29:41.060 --> 01:29:41.740
We love data.

1545
01:29:41.820 --> 01:29:42.080
Okay.

1546
01:29:42.421 --> 01:29:44.082
So here's a chart that's created by him.

1547
01:29:45.602 --> 01:30:01.346
What he's showing is this year's World Cup, all of the teams that have seen the most favorable VAR outcomes, that's in blue, and those that have seen the least favorable VAR outcomes using a baseline of per hundred fouls.

1548
01:30:01.527 --> 01:30:04.587
So he's normalizing for the number of fouls.

1549
01:30:07.188 --> 01:30:14.191
How many VAR decisions were turned in favor of me and how many VAR decisions were turned in the favor of...

1550
01:30:14.391 --> 01:30:15.371
Per 100 fouls.

1551
01:30:15.431 --> 01:30:15.671
Yes.

1552
01:30:15.931 --> 01:30:16.812
Per 100 fouls.

1553
01:30:16.952 --> 01:30:17.692
Yeah, yeah.

1554
01:30:17.772 --> 01:30:23.534
Per 100 fouls is just a way of saying I'm normalizing by the number of... Like I'm just dividing by the number of fouls, right?

1555
01:30:23.554 --> 01:30:23.895
I got you.

1556
01:30:23.935 --> 01:30:26.396
So it's like a per foul type thing, right?

1557
01:30:26.456 --> 01:30:26.916
That makes sense.

1558
01:30:26.936 --> 01:30:30.297
But this becomes a percentage because now you have 100 in the denominator.

1559
01:30:30.397 --> 01:30:30.957
I got you.

1560
01:30:30.977 --> 01:30:31.758
So, okay.

1561
01:30:31.938 --> 01:30:32.218
Okay.

1562
01:30:33.657 --> 01:30:35.758
Mexico actually tops that list.

1563
01:30:36.859 --> 01:30:38.160
And then it's Argentina.

1564
01:30:38.180 --> 01:30:38.840
Okay.

1565
01:30:39.140 --> 01:30:39.421
Okay.

1566
01:30:39.821 --> 01:30:42.022
And then it's a bunch of other countries.

1567
01:30:42.142 --> 01:30:43.403
England is somewhere in the middle.

1568
01:30:43.763 --> 01:30:44.984
France is somewhere in the middle.

1569
01:30:45.144 --> 01:30:46.725
But France is also net positive.

1570
01:30:46.745 --> 01:30:48.906
There's no net negatives against them.

1571
01:30:49.086 --> 01:30:49.867
Yeah.

1572
01:30:50.287 --> 01:30:52.729
There's another plot that's there.

1573
01:30:52.849 --> 01:30:55.911
I just want to note that the U.S. is net negative.

1574
01:30:56.411 --> 01:30:56.631
Yeah.

1575
01:30:57.878 --> 01:30:59.579
VAR does not support the US.

1576
01:30:59.700 --> 01:31:00.480
No, not at all.

1577
01:31:00.580 --> 01:31:01.921
Or Canada, for that matter.

1578
01:31:02.962 --> 01:31:05.184
Or Belgium, so I can't complain about the Belgium game.

1579
01:31:05.504 --> 01:31:06.144
Yeah.

1580
01:31:06.785 --> 01:31:12.369
And so the next plot is something that I found on Reddit.

1581
01:31:14.034 --> 01:31:19.039
Here, the Y-axis is the opposition fouls per yellow card.

1582
01:31:19.259 --> 01:31:19.539
Okay?

1583
01:31:19.599 --> 01:31:19.799
Okay.

1584
01:31:19.819 --> 01:31:27.406
So fouls per yellow card that you're getting, meaning how many fouls your opponent commits until they receive a yellow.

1585
01:31:27.727 --> 01:31:27.967
Okay?

1586
01:31:28.247 --> 01:31:29.448
What's the, like, the threshold?

1587
01:31:29.668 --> 01:31:29.849
Mm-hmm.

1588
01:31:30.549 --> 01:31:36.093
And the lower on the y-axis, the more favorable the team is.

1589
01:31:36.593 --> 01:31:41.397
Okay, the x-axis is the delta between penalties won and penalties conceded.

1590
01:31:41.797 --> 01:31:44.098
So that's how you get 3, 2, 1.

1591
01:31:44.339 --> 01:31:53.945
Okay, Argentina, the bubble size, by the way, the size of the bubble shows how many fouls the team commits until they are shown a yellow card.

1592
01:31:54.225 --> 01:31:57.808
So the bigger the size of the bubble is,

1593
01:31:58.408 --> 01:32:01.289
the more tolerant the referees are for that team.

1594
01:32:01.870 --> 01:32:05.992
Argentina's on the bottom right corner, right?

1595
01:32:07.292 --> 01:32:09.473
And so... With a pretty big bubble.

1596
01:32:09.493 --> 01:32:10.834
With a pretty big bubble, right?

1597
01:32:10.854 --> 01:32:19.018
Which means the bigger the bubble, the more tolerant the referees are, so to speak, in a very crude, crude example, right?

1598
01:32:19.038 --> 01:32:26.582
And it naively would suggest that the referees are being biased.

1599
01:32:27.122 --> 01:32:32.126
Argentina won most penalties while its opponents receive a yellow card after five fouls committed.

1600
01:32:32.486 --> 01:32:34.748
They get a yellow after 19 fouls.

1601
01:32:34.908 --> 01:32:35.148
Yeah.

1602
01:32:35.488 --> 01:32:35.648
Yeah.

1603
01:32:35.889 --> 01:32:39.811
So Argentina needs 19 fouls to commit to get a yellow.

1604
01:32:40.432 --> 01:32:42.073
Their opponents need about five.

1605
01:32:42.353 --> 01:32:43.114
I don't know.

1606
01:32:43.534 --> 01:32:43.874
You're right.

1607
01:32:44.215 --> 01:32:45.696
And that's what I would say, too.

1608
01:32:46.056 --> 01:32:46.697
I don't know.

1609
01:32:46.737 --> 01:32:47.977
Because I want to believe.

1610
01:32:48.558 --> 01:32:49.078
Look.

1611
01:32:49.098 --> 01:32:49.899
I want to believe.

1612
01:32:50.579 --> 01:32:50.780
But...

1613
01:32:52.441 --> 01:32:56.242
I'm going to also have to put on my data scientist hat on.

1614
01:32:56.342 --> 01:32:56.662
Okay.

1615
01:32:56.682 --> 01:32:56.942
Okay?

1616
01:32:57.102 --> 01:32:57.382
Okay.

1617
01:32:57.502 --> 01:32:59.103
And just do some good hygiene.

1618
01:32:59.243 --> 01:32:59.543
Okay.

1619
01:32:59.843 --> 01:33:00.183
Okay?

1620
01:33:00.323 --> 01:33:00.663
Okay.

1621
01:33:01.303 --> 01:33:01.963
First of all...

1622
01:33:02.143 --> 01:33:02.363
Yes.

1623
01:33:03.043 --> 01:33:05.264
It's an incredibly small sample size.

1624
01:33:05.524 --> 01:33:05.824
Okay.

1625
01:33:06.004 --> 01:33:06.304
All right?

1626
01:33:06.364 --> 01:33:08.164
If you go back to that...

1627
01:33:08.184 --> 01:33:08.885
This is 22?

1628
01:33:09.025 --> 01:33:09.665
Yeah.

1629
01:33:09.745 --> 01:33:10.805
If you go back to that...

1630
01:33:10.825 --> 01:33:11.025
Okay.

1631
01:33:11.065 --> 01:33:17.646
The x-axis is discretized by negative 1, 0, 1, 2, and 3.

1632
01:33:18.026 --> 01:33:19.967
But they've made the plot...

1633
01:33:20.747 --> 01:33:43.873
fatter on the x-axis so it seems like the x-axis is the more salient dimension i see that but like there's nothing there's no way to have a 2.5 yeah right right i see what you're saying okay so so already there's there's a bit of like movie magic happening there's a little bit of manipulation of the visual representation now the other thing is they're treating every foul equally

1634
01:33:44.957 --> 01:33:45.217
Right?

1635
01:33:45.797 --> 01:33:47.518
That's not completely true.

1636
01:33:47.838 --> 01:34:00.780
Like, if you've got a team like Argentina that presses all the time, you've got someone like Messi who's, like, always in your space, then, like, if you commit a foul against them, there's a higher chance of, like, that resulting in a penalty.

1637
01:34:01.060 --> 01:34:02.841
That's not truly accounted for here.

1638
01:34:02.861 --> 01:34:03.541
Okay.

1639
01:34:03.741 --> 01:34:03.941
Right?

1640
01:34:04.001 --> 01:34:09.082
So style of play perhaps is not something that is accounted for.

1641
01:34:09.122 --> 01:34:14.763
Like, Cape Verde, for example, like, those dudes had a great defense for quite a while.

1642
01:34:15.483 --> 01:34:43.655
So part of what you're saying I think style of play I think that example May be contested Generally speaking This idea of if you play Haram ball which is what Arsenal Play and you just sit And it's 11 of you in your own box And then you just wait to counter attack Like necessarily you don't have A lot of opportunities Theoretically as many opportunities to be fouled Egypt certainly did that Because you're not on the ball

1643
01:34:45.123 --> 01:34:45.343
Right?

1644
01:34:45.723 --> 01:34:48.325
So that's not something that has been taken into account.

1645
01:34:48.625 --> 01:34:58.390
Also, the types of fouls, like Argentina, the fact that they require 19 fouls to get a yellow, perhaps it's because they're doing smaller technical fouls.

1646
01:34:58.430 --> 01:35:00.932
Now, anecdotally, I would say that's not...

1647
01:35:02.423 --> 01:35:03.504
True, probably.

1648
01:35:03.524 --> 01:35:05.686
The comments are going to go crazy.

1649
01:35:06.726 --> 01:35:16.774
But there's all sorts of like, I think with all of this stuff, and I think the author of the Northeastern paper, right, or the Northeastern study actually said this.

1650
01:35:17.134 --> 01:35:20.917
Like, this kind of exercise, given the small data size and the heat...

1651
01:35:25.000 --> 01:35:30.323
of what we're doing, the exercise is fraught with confirmation bias.

1652
01:35:30.763 --> 01:35:39.868
But at the end of the day, it's the World Cup, and I personally want FIFA to be biased to Argentina.

1653
01:35:39.968 --> 01:35:46.511
So at the end of the day, all I'm going to say is, look, is this truly convincing data that Argentina...

1654
01:35:47.532 --> 01:35:47.772
Sorry.

1655
01:35:48.192 --> 01:35:52.354
Is this truly convincing data that there is a bias for Argentina by FIFA?

1656
01:35:52.374 --> 01:35:52.835
No.

1657
01:35:52.875 --> 01:35:53.055
No.

1658
01:35:53.943 --> 01:35:55.024
But do I care?

1659
01:35:55.464 --> 01:35:56.024
Also, no.

1660
01:35:56.424 --> 01:35:56.785
All right?

1661
01:35:57.345 --> 01:35:58.466
So, yeah.

1662
01:35:58.666 --> 01:35:59.646
Hashtag rigged.

1663
01:36:00.047 --> 01:36:01.787
Hashtag stop the steal.

1664
01:36:02.448 --> 01:36:03.869
Better call Infantino.

1665
01:36:04.369 --> 01:36:11.753
I just want everyone to know that I am not an Argentina supporter, and I do not condone any rigging.

1666
01:36:11.793 --> 01:36:20.038
However, I will say the comment thread is going to be full of the shot of Messi giving a red card foul raise on the calf.

1667
01:36:20.423 --> 01:36:24.086
One of the main injuries we saw from our Are You Smarter Than a Scientist game show segment.

1668
01:36:24.186 --> 01:36:24.707
Yeah.

1669
01:36:24.807 --> 01:36:27.309
And say, oh, how is this not a foul?

1670
01:36:27.509 --> 01:36:28.430
Argentina never gets called.

1671
01:36:28.570 --> 01:36:31.312
Like that's, I'm just saying it because I already know.

1672
01:36:31.392 --> 01:36:31.972
Yeah.

1673
01:36:32.253 --> 01:36:35.936
It's going to be the image that is all in the clips of this.

1674
01:36:36.076 --> 01:36:36.276
Yeah.

1675
01:36:36.376 --> 01:36:38.278
And let's put this at the end of the clip.

1676
01:36:38.498 --> 01:36:38.698
Yeah.

1677
01:36:38.978 --> 01:36:46.604
So that people who comment it before reaching the end of the video, which apparently no one watches 90 seconds of content.

1678
01:36:46.664 --> 01:36:46.904
Yeah.

1679
01:36:47.125 --> 01:36:47.505
Anymore.

1680
01:36:47.905 --> 01:36:48.986
before just rage.

1681
01:36:49.166 --> 01:37:09.521
I just want you guys to know your brain is rotting because this is a 90 second clip and you saw Christian say something about Argentina that was favorable and then we came in here and said yes we know about the messy foul with the thingy and his plate in the calf and you're going to put the image of it and you're going to look stupid.

1682
01:37:09.541 --> 01:37:10.581
I just want you to know that.

1683
01:37:11.802 --> 01:37:14.104
I just got to get that off my chest.

1684
01:37:14.945 --> 01:37:16.826
Yeah and the point basically being like

1685
01:37:18.048 --> 01:37:22.193
Look, I don't know how much of me thinking that there's an Argentina bias.

1686
01:37:22.613 --> 01:37:25.897
It's just because of all the stuff that I'm seeing on social media.

1687
01:37:26.337 --> 01:37:33.445
But for the purposes of me enjoying this England versus Argentina game, I am believing 100% of it.

1688
01:37:33.505 --> 01:37:35.187
And I want Argentina to go down.

1689
01:37:37.750 --> 01:37:38.570
And that is rare.

1690
01:37:38.630 --> 01:37:41.091
Coming from an Indian.

1691
01:37:41.111 --> 01:37:42.051
A hundred percent.

1692
01:37:42.351 --> 01:37:42.931
Of Indian descent.

1693
01:37:42.951 --> 01:37:45.192
You've seen the memes with the map where it's like the two countries that care.

1694
01:37:45.212 --> 01:37:46.592
It's like Argentina and India.

1695
01:37:46.652 --> 01:37:46.872
Yeah.

1696
01:37:46.892 --> 01:37:48.893
That want India to win and the rest of the world is England.

1697
01:37:48.933 --> 01:37:49.673
No, like I'm.

1698
01:37:49.833 --> 01:37:50.753
It's a big deal.

1699
01:37:50.873 --> 01:37:51.733
I want England to win.

1700
01:37:51.773 --> 01:37:52.273
No, it's a big deal.

1701
01:37:52.293 --> 01:37:54.114
Rule Britannia, as they say.

1702
01:37:54.474 --> 01:37:57.635
Again, we'll put this at the end of my part of the clip.

1703
01:37:58.355 --> 01:37:59.355
So people also.

1704
01:37:59.555 --> 01:37:59.955
No, but this.

1705
01:38:00.035 --> 01:38:00.575
It'll be fun.

1706
01:38:00.635 --> 01:38:00.875
It's great.

1707
01:38:00.895 --> 01:38:01.256
It'll be fun.

1708
01:38:01.336 --> 01:38:02.276
The World Cup is great.

1709
01:38:02.456 --> 01:38:06.037
You know, the U.S. is out, which we're not going to comment on.

1710
01:38:06.077 --> 01:38:06.457
But yeah.

1711
01:38:06.617 --> 01:38:06.857
Yeah.

1712
01:38:08.257 --> 01:38:20.285
I, as a Chelsea fan, up the Chels, I want to see Tuchel be successful because my club unceremoniously sacked him after he brought us to Champions League with nobodies.

1713
01:38:20.945 --> 01:38:21.626
Wow.

1714
01:38:21.826 --> 01:38:24.948
Like, he brought us to Champions League with nobodies.

1715
01:38:25.088 --> 01:38:29.451
with like, like with, with anyway, I'm not, can't think of analogy.

1716
01:38:29.491 --> 01:38:32.973
Like we did not have the best players on paper.

1717
01:38:33.233 --> 01:38:33.474
Yeah.

1718
01:38:33.754 --> 01:38:33.954
Right.

1719
01:38:34.754 --> 01:38:38.537
And then there's some, and you got to the chip and we won the champions league.

1720
01:38:38.677 --> 01:38:38.977
And we won.

1721
01:38:39.297 --> 01:38:39.858
That's quite good.

1722
01:38:40.278 --> 01:38:41.099
Captain America.

1723
01:38:41.319 --> 01:38:43.160
Christian Pulisic has a champions league.

1724
01:38:43.520 --> 01:38:47.022
Thanks to Thomas Tuchel, the current England gaffer.

1725
01:38:47.623 --> 01:38:49.384
So I know he's good.

1726
01:38:50.064 --> 01:38:53.867
I know he can do a lot with a little there's talent on the England squad.

1727
01:38:53.887 --> 01:38:54.007
Yeah.

1728
01:38:55.614 --> 01:38:57.676
I'm so conflicted about this game.

1729
01:38:57.856 --> 01:38:58.136
Yeah.

1730
01:38:58.917 --> 01:39:03.820
Because I have disdain for both for different reasons.

1731
01:39:04.601 --> 01:39:08.484
And it's like, what's the lesser of two evils?

1732
01:39:08.824 --> 01:39:18.311
I will say, as a fan of the Prem, I will likely have to say I would prefer to see England win this one.

1733
01:39:19.936 --> 01:39:20.837
And then losing the final.

1734
01:39:21.998 --> 01:39:23.119
It can't come home right now.

1735
01:39:23.699 --> 01:39:24.960
We can't have us lose.

1736
01:39:25.180 --> 01:39:25.600
Let me not.

1737
01:39:25.641 --> 01:39:26.321
I'm not going to talk.

1738
01:39:26.361 --> 01:39:26.681
Yeah.

1739
01:39:26.741 --> 01:39:27.682
At America's 250th.

1740
01:39:27.882 --> 01:39:28.463
Yeah.

1741
01:39:28.483 --> 01:39:28.663
Yeah.

1742
01:39:28.683 --> 01:39:29.504
Like we can't.

1743
01:39:29.824 --> 01:39:31.305
This is supposed to be our celebration.

1744
01:39:31.325 --> 01:39:31.425
Yeah.

1745
01:39:31.445 --> 01:39:32.066
And then they win it.

1746
01:39:32.246 --> 01:39:33.086
Yeah.

1747
01:39:33.146 --> 01:39:33.907
We just can't have our.

1748
01:39:34.027 --> 01:39:36.089
Especially after we didn't just lose.

1749
01:39:36.149 --> 01:39:37.190
We like got embarrassed.

1750
01:39:37.210 --> 01:39:37.510
Embarrassed.

1751
01:39:37.910 --> 01:39:39.870
And then the Europeans rub it in our face.

1752
01:39:39.890 --> 01:39:40.250
Yeah.

1753
01:39:40.510 --> 01:39:42.051
And like we deserve it.

1754
01:39:42.131 --> 01:39:42.891
And we deserve it.

1755
01:39:43.111 --> 01:39:45.211
Because we had the whole red card ball.

1756
01:39:45.371 --> 01:39:46.472
Like it got reversed.

1757
01:39:46.572 --> 01:39:47.132
It was just like.

1758
01:39:47.592 --> 01:39:48.112
It's just like.

1759
01:39:48.252 --> 01:39:51.192
It was like the worst way to go out, dude.

1760
01:39:51.552 --> 01:39:52.533
It's bad management.

1761
01:39:52.673 --> 01:39:52.953
Yeah.

1762
01:39:53.073 --> 01:39:53.793
It was so bad.

1763
01:39:53.873 --> 01:39:56.053
None of us asked for anything to be rescinded.

1764
01:39:56.433 --> 01:39:56.813
All right.

1765
01:39:57.653 --> 01:40:00.954
I know Kwanzaa had the two game suspension, which doesn't make sense.

1766
01:40:01.014 --> 01:40:02.034
And Balogun got it removed.

1767
01:40:02.314 --> 01:40:03.254
This is getting in the weeds.

1768
01:40:03.375 --> 01:40:03.615
Yeah.

1769
01:40:03.675 --> 01:40:05.275
This is not a sports podcast.

1770
01:40:05.335 --> 01:40:05.735
However.

1771
01:40:06.455 --> 01:40:12.698
So the last thing that I want to say, okay, is like because I was like going in a deep dive about like what could it be, right?

1772
01:40:12.898 --> 01:40:13.078
Right.

1773
01:40:13.478 --> 01:40:15.819
I have a theory about the Argentina bias.

1774
01:40:16.199 --> 01:40:16.479
Okay.

1775
01:40:16.539 --> 01:40:17.479
That I think is new.

1776
01:40:17.499 --> 01:40:20.221
Ooh, new Argentina bias theory.

1777
01:40:20.241 --> 01:40:25.823
So it could be that there is a bias for Argentina and FIFA has nothing to do with it.

1778
01:40:26.483 --> 01:40:26.763
Okay.

1779
01:40:26.783 --> 01:40:27.023
Okay.

1780
01:40:27.383 --> 01:40:31.445
It could be that they have a home court advantage at all of these games.

1781
01:40:31.525 --> 01:40:38.608
Because I don't know if you've seen in all of these Argentina games, the stands are flooded with Argentina fans.

1782
01:40:38.989 --> 01:40:39.949
It's the messy effect.

1783
01:40:40.029 --> 01:40:40.529
Yeah.

1784
01:40:40.729 --> 01:40:44.631
Everybody has an Argentina jersey, mostly a messy jersey.

1785
01:40:45.491 --> 01:40:46.472
I see what you're saying.

1786
01:40:46.932 --> 01:40:59.182
There are studies, so this is in 2007, Boiko and other researchers, what they did was try to quantify the home field advantage.

1787
01:41:00.407 --> 01:41:02.569
which is a well-documented phenomenon, right?

1788
01:41:02.609 --> 01:41:06.292
Like there's a home field advantage for like the players, they get riled up.

1789
01:41:06.852 --> 01:41:09.194
There's a home field advantage for refereeing.

1790
01:41:09.795 --> 01:41:14.559
There is a referee bias that contributes to home field advantage in the English Premier League.

1791
01:41:14.839 --> 01:41:16.560
And it has to do with just like psychology, right?

1792
01:41:16.580 --> 01:41:25.327
Like the referee doesn't want to give a bad decision to the thousands and tens of thousands of people that are watching him.

1793
01:41:26.248 --> 01:41:27.969
Now, it didn't quite work with the Balogun.

1794
01:41:28.530 --> 01:41:28.710
Right.

1795
01:41:29.745 --> 01:41:30.286
Situation.

1796
01:41:30.866 --> 01:41:40.193
But it did work when Argentina was in Miami, where Messi plays in the MLS in Miami, which is home field effectively.

1797
01:41:40.293 --> 01:41:40.713
Exactly.

1798
01:41:40.753 --> 01:41:43.595
And like even the Kansas City game, right, against Switzerland.

1799
01:41:43.635 --> 01:41:43.856
Packed.

1800
01:41:43.896 --> 01:41:45.617
Packed with Argentinian fans.

1801
01:41:45.637 --> 01:41:45.877
100%.

1802
01:41:45.897 --> 01:41:50.120
Like every single one of these Argentina games just has so many fans, right?

1803
01:41:50.440 --> 01:41:54.784
And so what these guys did was, you know, it's hard to disentangle the...

1804
01:41:57.025 --> 01:42:00.127
the performance of the team with the performance of the referees.

1805
01:42:00.467 --> 01:42:10.933
But what they did was separate out referees and look at individual referees, whether they were judging a home game versus another game, and look at individual referees.

1806
01:42:10.993 --> 01:42:15.876
So now you've washed out the effect of whether the team is at home or not.

1807
01:42:15.916 --> 01:42:17.297
And in the next figure, we'll show you.

1808
01:42:17.337 --> 01:42:18.298
This is a figure from the...

1809
01:42:21.774 --> 01:42:32.522
From the paper, on the X-axis, all the individual referees, and this is the mean goal differential that they could have contributed to based on their yellow cards and all things like that, all of it is positive.

1810
01:42:32.903 --> 01:42:37.086
Meaning, like, the referee bias is always positive for the home team.

1811
01:42:37.106 --> 01:42:37.927
That's very...

1812
01:42:38.647 --> 01:42:47.329
Even then, you could be like, it's really hard to conflate the home field advantage from the referee and the home field advantage from the team.

1813
01:42:47.369 --> 01:42:49.449
Like the team is more inspired.

1814
01:42:49.529 --> 01:42:51.190
Maybe they're more violent.

1815
01:42:51.210 --> 01:42:53.570
The 12th man, the fan, all these things.

1816
01:42:53.670 --> 01:42:54.190
Right.

1817
01:42:54.210 --> 01:42:55.771
They play their every whatever.

1818
01:42:56.011 --> 01:42:56.451
Exactly.

1819
01:42:56.531 --> 01:43:01.292
So what we really need to do as a control would be to remove the 12th man.

1820
01:43:01.892 --> 01:43:02.092
Right.

1821
01:43:02.732 --> 01:43:03.512
Right.

1822
01:43:03.532 --> 01:43:07.333
And lo and behold, the COVID pandemic happens.

1823
01:43:09.461 --> 01:43:11.242
Oh, wait, this is perfect.

1824
01:43:11.662 --> 01:43:14.244
It's the only time you'd ever be able to get this data.

1825
01:43:14.324 --> 01:43:15.224
Yes.

1826
01:43:15.905 --> 01:43:19.607
It's the only time where you're playing football and there's no one in the stands.

1827
01:43:19.627 --> 01:43:20.467
There's nobody there.

1828
01:43:20.688 --> 01:43:20.908
Right?

1829
01:43:22.008 --> 01:43:22.749
Wait, this is great.

1830
01:43:23.029 --> 01:43:24.850
So now you've got to control.

1831
01:43:25.831 --> 01:43:35.416
That's why I wanted to bring this up because I thought it was so cool that we've got a 2007 study that is showing that there is a home field advantage for referee bias, right?

1832
01:43:35.456 --> 01:43:36.877
Referees are biased for the home team.

1833
01:43:36.897 --> 01:43:37.017
Yes.

1834
01:43:37.177 --> 01:43:39.419
But you could always be like, it's so hard to conflate.

1835
01:43:39.439 --> 01:43:39.899
100%.

1836
01:43:40.059 --> 01:43:40.220
Right?

1837
01:43:40.500 --> 01:43:41.381
Okay.

1838
01:43:41.541 --> 01:43:49.527
The next paper is the natural experiment by Arendelle in the frontiers of behavioral economics.

1839
01:43:49.667 --> 01:43:49.867
Yes.

1840
01:43:50.028 --> 01:43:55.792
And they looked at the same pattern, but now for the games during the COVID-19 pandemic.

1841
01:43:55.812 --> 01:43:56.433
This is so good.

1842
01:43:56.613 --> 01:44:06.441
Because you can't, there is no, there is effectively, at least you could say the pitch still, but really it's about the fans and the energy and the ambiance.

1843
01:44:07.907 --> 01:44:08.127
No.

1844
01:44:08.468 --> 01:44:08.688
Yeah.

1845
01:44:08.708 --> 01:44:08.988
Zero.

1846
01:44:09.589 --> 01:44:11.331
And they confirmed that referee bias.

1847
01:44:11.351 --> 01:44:17.217
They looked at 7,000 matches across Europe, and they showed that when the crowd goes silent, there's no crowd.

1848
01:44:17.578 --> 01:44:20.501
The referee bias for the home team is eliminated.

1849
01:44:20.902 --> 01:44:23.244
That's incredible.

1850
01:44:23.364 --> 01:44:23.584
Yeah.

1851
01:44:24.685 --> 01:44:28.508
And again, anecdotally, everyone's believed this to be true.

1852
01:44:28.608 --> 01:44:29.409
Yeah, forever.

1853
01:44:29.429 --> 01:44:31.831
This is why home field advantage is even a concept.

1854
01:44:31.971 --> 01:44:39.237
Yeah, it's like a home field advantage not only in the psyche of the players, but now they're showing it's in the psyche of the referee himself or herself.

1855
01:44:39.277 --> 01:44:40.698
There's bias in the...

1856
01:44:41.198 --> 01:44:42.119
I thought this was so cool.

1857
01:44:42.159 --> 01:44:48.304
No, that's really good because, again, we will probably never really ever get.

1858
01:44:48.404 --> 01:44:50.827
No, we're never going to get that experiment again.

1859
01:44:50.847 --> 01:44:52.248
I mean, God willing, right?

1860
01:44:52.268 --> 01:44:52.808
Right, right, right.

1861
01:44:52.828 --> 01:44:53.229
Let's hope so.

1862
01:44:53.269 --> 01:44:53.689
Right, right.

1863
01:44:53.869 --> 01:44:54.630
Especially with the skit.

1864
01:44:54.650 --> 01:44:59.354
Because you could argue like, oh, well, one team can be banned from having fans in the stands for some period of time.

1865
01:44:59.394 --> 01:44:59.654
Yeah.

1866
01:44:59.714 --> 01:45:01.176
But we're saying it was everybody.

1867
01:45:01.196 --> 01:45:01.936
Yeah, for a whole year.

1868
01:45:02.998 --> 01:45:03.178
Right?

1869
01:45:03.398 --> 01:45:07.643
And the amount of data that they've used, it's like 5,000 games, 7,000 games.

1870
01:45:07.683 --> 01:45:09.845
Now you're getting a statistically significant effect.

1871
01:45:09.865 --> 01:45:11.047
That is so...

1872
01:45:12.370 --> 01:45:13.291
People are so glad.

1873
01:45:13.451 --> 01:45:14.691
Yeah, I thought it was good.

1874
01:45:14.751 --> 01:45:15.932
Because they also built on the other one.

1875
01:45:15.952 --> 01:45:17.373
It was like, well, let's double.

1876
01:45:17.913 --> 01:45:21.855
And so the point is, it was positive in the study where the fans were there.

1877
01:45:22.155 --> 01:45:23.396
And then you took away the fans.

1878
01:45:23.976 --> 01:45:24.997
When the fans were not there.

1879
01:45:25.377 --> 01:45:27.978
Which means, understandably, the refs want to get home safe.

1880
01:45:28.198 --> 01:45:28.398
Yeah.

1881
01:45:28.659 --> 01:45:30.660
And so they might be a little.

1882
01:45:31.160 --> 01:45:33.801
And just psychologically, right?

1883
01:45:33.841 --> 01:45:36.743
There's something in your psyche when there's 50,000 people booing you.

1884
01:45:36.763 --> 01:45:37.263
You don't want it.

1885
01:45:41.506 --> 01:45:48.895
Even though you're supposed to be neutral and whatever, there's going to be part of you that wants to be liked by the 70,000 people.

1886
01:45:48.995 --> 01:45:53.581
You want to hear cheers for when you do this and you say no penalty or penalty or whatever.

1887
01:45:53.601 --> 01:45:53.781
So...

1888
01:45:55.705 --> 01:46:01.549
This is going to do numbers for the Argentina bias community.

1889
01:46:01.869 --> 01:46:05.212
Yeah, so that's my theory, which I think it's a new theory.

1890
01:46:05.612 --> 01:46:09.895
And so this is an out for FIFA because FIFA doesn't have anything to do with this.

1891
01:46:09.935 --> 01:46:12.437
This is just like the home field advantage that Argentina has.

1892
01:46:12.817 --> 01:46:16.459
Again, this is terrible data science because clearly it didn't work for America.

1893
01:46:16.820 --> 01:46:17.000
Right.

1894
01:46:17.800 --> 01:46:28.648
However, one would argue that our fans don't instill the same fear in referees that footballing nation fans do.

1895
01:46:29.028 --> 01:46:31.410
The English fans, the Argentinian fans.

1896
01:46:31.490 --> 01:46:35.373
Like, these Americans, they can't even... USA, who's scared of that?

1897
01:46:35.433 --> 01:46:36.514
You know what I mean?

1898
01:46:36.654 --> 01:46:38.715
Yeah, and then we stop caring.

1899
01:46:38.735 --> 01:46:39.176
Yeah, right.

1900
01:46:39.616 --> 01:46:40.357
Immediately.

1901
01:46:40.377 --> 01:46:41.798
They're not going to do anything.

1902
01:46:41.818 --> 01:46:43.559
They're going to watch the TV.

1903
01:46:44.420 --> 01:46:45.220
Fascinating.

1904
01:46:45.260 --> 01:46:45.941
This has been...

1905
01:46:46.621 --> 01:46:52.304
A blockbuster rundown, our longest rundown by literally 2X.

1906
01:46:52.505 --> 01:46:52.745
Yeah.

1907
01:46:53.125 --> 01:46:56.727
Because we just love yapping and we love talking to you guys.

1908
01:46:56.827 --> 01:46:59.489
And there's so many good things and exciting things happening.

1909
01:47:00.009 --> 01:47:08.314
We covered Black Holes, Digital Heart Twin, the ultrasound CT scanner from MidJourney.

1910
01:47:08.895 --> 01:47:10.736
Two wonderful World Cup stories.

1911
01:47:11.236 --> 01:47:21.622
First, about the controversy about the camera, which, again, FIFA, if you'd like to come on and explain yourself, you have a platform to do so.

1912
01:47:22.443 --> 01:47:24.024
And where does it?

1913
01:47:24.044 --> 01:47:28.286
It wasn't about the Argentina bias specifically, but home field advantage.

1914
01:47:28.907 --> 01:47:30.348
Is it statistically significant?

1915
01:47:30.648 --> 01:47:34.050
Referee bias being actually the thing that creates the Argentina bias is

1916
01:47:34.670 --> 01:47:37.957
I think is a very clever hypothesis.

1917
01:47:38.639 --> 01:47:44.010
We will see what the algorithm and the comments on the internet say

1918
01:47:45.278 --> 01:47:57.641
My name is Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD and Argentina-biased hypothesis creator, Krishna Chowdhury.

1919
01:47:58.041 --> 01:48:05.742
We really appreciate you all, as always, for joining us, meandering through our friendship in a journey of curiosity and science.

1920
01:48:06.163 --> 01:48:07.983
We will see you all next week.
