WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.231 --> 00:00:01.192
Ni hao, Internet.

2
00:00:01.212 --> 00:00:12.319
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host, our resident PhD, and number one Chamath Paliapathia cosplayer, Krishna Chowdhury.

3
00:00:13.577 --> 00:00:14.077
My friend.

4
00:00:14.377 --> 00:00:14.817
That's right.

5
00:00:15.238 --> 00:00:18.159
I can't afford the sweaters that he wears.

6
00:00:18.179 --> 00:00:21.400
The alpaca shipped from God knows where.

7
00:00:21.440 --> 00:00:22.881
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

8
00:00:22.921 --> 00:00:24.941
This is nylon shipped from TikTok shop.

9
00:00:25.482 --> 00:00:27.002
You don't have the SPAC money.

10
00:00:27.122 --> 00:00:27.322
No.

11
00:00:28.022 --> 00:00:28.623
Maybe one day.

12
00:00:28.883 --> 00:00:29.203
One day.

13
00:00:29.363 --> 00:00:33.304
Maybe not via SPAC, but via science communication.

14
00:00:34.525 --> 00:00:35.245
It is now.

15
00:00:35.345 --> 00:00:36.826
We are in the holiday season.

16
00:00:37.587 --> 00:00:39.069
So we are winding down for the year.

17
00:00:39.869 --> 00:00:41.992
Big shout out to everyone who's joined the show.

18
00:00:42.452 --> 00:00:44.775
We started less than six months ago.

19
00:00:44.855 --> 00:00:45.155
Yeah.

20
00:00:45.455 --> 00:00:46.917
The response has been incredible.

21
00:00:47.818 --> 00:00:50.721
We're going to be wrapping up season one basically at the end of the year.

22
00:00:51.202 --> 00:00:52.042
I think we've made the...

23
00:00:52.723 --> 00:00:56.607
random executive decision to decide our seasons are just going to be every year.

24
00:00:57.328 --> 00:01:00.271
And so we started only in halfway through this year.

25
00:01:00.331 --> 00:01:01.932
Season one, a little truncated.

26
00:01:02.072 --> 00:01:02.673
Yeah, no, it's good.

27
00:01:02.693 --> 00:01:03.114
Pilot season.

28
00:01:03.274 --> 00:01:06.677
No, the Gregorian calendar is a great calendar.

29
00:01:06.697 --> 00:01:07.618
It's a great calendar.

30
00:01:07.858 --> 00:01:09.160
So that's how we're going to do our seasons.

31
00:01:09.200 --> 00:01:09.420
Yeah.

32
00:01:10.564 --> 00:01:14.066
So this is the first of kind of our wrap-up of the year episodes.

33
00:01:14.106 --> 00:01:14.366
Yes.

34
00:01:14.947 --> 00:01:20.250
With holidays, with travel, all these things, with Mariah Carey being on the radio nonstop.

35
00:01:20.290 --> 00:01:20.770
Yeah.

36
00:01:20.790 --> 00:01:22.311
She's creeping up.

37
00:01:22.351 --> 00:01:24.092
It's the holiday season.

38
00:01:25.333 --> 00:01:30.095
So what we're going to do this episode is similar to what we've done when we did the Nobel Prizes.

39
00:01:30.296 --> 00:01:30.516
Yes.

40
00:01:30.816 --> 00:01:34.058
Which is we're going to do a single story, deep dive.

41
00:01:34.928 --> 00:01:38.750
And what we're going to talk about in this episode is the discovery of DNA.

42
00:01:39.010 --> 00:01:39.270
Yes.

43
00:01:40.030 --> 00:01:47.454
And the reason why we're going to talk about the discovery of DNA is the unfortunate recent passing of one of the pioneers...

44
00:01:48.499 --> 00:01:53.160
of the discovery of the double helix, which was James Watson, who recently passed away.

45
00:01:53.300 --> 00:01:53.561
Yes.

46
00:01:54.621 --> 00:01:58.702
And there's a lot of drama in this story.

47
00:01:59.102 --> 00:02:00.723
This will be a complex episode.

48
00:02:01.503 --> 00:02:10.846
We are really focused on science, experimental design, the concepts, thinking about things from first principles.

49
00:02:10.906 --> 00:02:14.647
But this is one of the things I think we both do is it's a human story.

50
00:02:14.807 --> 00:02:15.047
Yes.

51
00:02:15.067 --> 00:02:15.147
Yes.

52
00:02:16.067 --> 00:02:17.935
And it's a fascinating hand story.

53
00:02:17.955 --> 00:02:19.743
And there's a lot of controversy...

54
00:02:21.625 --> 00:02:24.046
associated with Mr. Watson.

55
00:02:24.667 --> 00:02:27.948
And so we're not going to shy away from... No, not at all.

56
00:02:28.128 --> 00:02:35.571
You know, talking about that in the context of what was one of the greatest... Discoveries.

57
00:02:35.591 --> 00:02:36.011
Discoveries.

58
00:02:36.352 --> 00:02:37.372
Of the 20th century.

59
00:02:37.432 --> 00:02:37.652
Yeah.

60
00:02:37.992 --> 00:02:38.232
Yeah.

61
00:02:38.713 --> 00:02:38.993
Easy.

62
00:02:39.633 --> 00:02:42.314
And as always, you guys know we're going to go deep.

63
00:02:42.594 --> 00:02:43.314
It's going to be fun.

64
00:02:43.334 --> 00:02:45.295
It's going to be lighthearted but serious.

65
00:02:45.315 --> 00:02:47.036
We're going to learn something today.

66
00:02:47.576 --> 00:02:49.557
This is from First Principles.

67
00:03:05.823 --> 00:03:18.686
So James Watson, he recently passed away and colleagues and people in the field are wrestling with his legacy because he is a very controversial character.

68
00:03:20.306 --> 00:03:25.247
He is clearly one of the greatest scientists of the 20th century.

69
00:03:26.927 --> 00:03:29.428
Discovering the structure of DNA is...

70
00:03:30.408 --> 00:03:32.789
an incredible achievement.

71
00:03:33.350 --> 00:03:45.115
It is quite possibly, I would say in, in the world of biomolecular chemistry, it is the crown jewel of human achievement up till now is the discovery.

72
00:03:45.155 --> 00:03:46.076
The DNA is this,

73
00:03:46.756 --> 00:03:59.699
periodic, you know, double helix, twisted ladder, beautiful looking molecule that is ubiquitous in all of life from bacteria, archaea, fungi, plants, animals, all the way to us.

74
00:04:00.339 --> 00:04:04.200
It's something that tells us that we're all connected, right?

75
00:04:04.320 --> 00:04:08.760
Me and the plant and the bacteria, we all have the same lineage.

76
00:04:08.780 --> 00:04:15.242
One of the definitive proofs of that is the fact that all of us use DNA as our information

77
00:04:16.422 --> 00:04:16.642
Right.

78
00:04:17.683 --> 00:04:20.406
It's the idea of this universal storage system.

79
00:04:20.606 --> 00:04:20.866
Yeah.

80
00:04:21.086 --> 00:04:28.853
Like everything that we classify as life uses the same Samsung hard drive.

81
00:04:28.973 --> 00:04:29.233
Yeah.

82
00:04:29.494 --> 00:04:29.754
Yeah.

83
00:04:29.814 --> 00:04:30.214
Yeah.

84
00:04:30.294 --> 00:04:31.776
Everyone uses like the same.

85
00:04:31.856 --> 00:04:32.196
Yeah.

86
00:04:32.276 --> 00:04:34.358
It's like a transistor in some sense.

87
00:04:34.398 --> 00:04:37.481
Like it's everywhere.

88
00:04:37.501 --> 00:04:37.781
Yeah.

89
00:04:37.921 --> 00:04:38.441
It's everywhere.

90
00:04:38.701 --> 00:04:40.742
And it's so good at what it does.

91
00:04:41.323 --> 00:04:45.125
And one of the reasons why it's so good at what it does has to do with its structure.

92
00:04:45.185 --> 00:04:49.447
At the end of the day, biology, I've told you, is just lock and key, right?

93
00:04:49.487 --> 00:04:49.947
Right.

94
00:04:50.548 --> 00:04:56.591
And the shape of these molecules has everything to do with what the thing is.

95
00:04:57.471 --> 00:05:04.235
And DNA is one of these things that's just incredibly beautiful to look at, incredibly beautiful to think about.

96
00:05:04.982 --> 00:05:08.884
beautiful to innovate on as a technology.

97
00:05:09.985 --> 00:05:13.707
At the same time, James Watson is a very controversial figure.

98
00:05:14.267 --> 00:05:15.968
He helped strengthen U.S. research.

99
00:05:17.229 --> 00:05:24.033
He single-handedly did a lot for U.S. biomedical research, but at the same time, he was very controversial.

100
00:05:24.093 --> 00:05:28.656
He said some really out-of-pocket things towards the later years of his life.

101
00:05:28.896 --> 00:05:31.317
Sorry, I'm looking for my pocket, but it's kind of out right now.

102
00:05:31.357 --> 00:05:32.158
Yeah, yeah.

103
00:05:34.148 --> 00:05:39.473
Yeah, he was, dude, later on in the story, we're going to get into some of the stuff he said.

104
00:05:39.633 --> 00:05:44.257
And they're like comical how bad they are as takes, right?

105
00:05:44.418 --> 00:05:50.063
Look, as a member of the black community, it's exactly like the story of R. Kelly.

106
00:05:50.623 --> 00:05:50.884
Yeah.

107
00:05:51.104 --> 00:05:51.824
Great music.

108
00:05:52.625 --> 00:05:53.746
But, man.

109
00:05:53.806 --> 00:05:54.326
Man.

110
00:05:55.668 --> 00:05:56.268
Really?

111
00:05:57.049 --> 00:05:57.649
You can't.

112
00:05:57.709 --> 00:05:58.230
It's tough.

113
00:05:58.430 --> 00:05:58.670
Yeah.

114
00:05:58.870 --> 00:05:59.370
It's tough.

115
00:05:59.470 --> 00:05:59.871
It's tough.

116
00:05:59.911 --> 00:06:02.433
But you got to celebrate the good with the bad, right?

117
00:06:02.453 --> 00:06:07.076
And you got to know all of the nuances of the story to really appreciate it.

118
00:06:07.116 --> 00:06:08.217
It's the human experience, right?

119
00:06:08.237 --> 00:06:08.598
Yes, it is.

120
00:06:08.918 --> 00:06:09.719
Yeah.

121
00:06:10.039 --> 00:06:12.441
And I want to start by just talking about...

122
00:06:13.329 --> 00:06:23.317
the historical landscape that sets up DNA as this molecule that everybody is going after, why it was such a big deal that we got this structure.

123
00:06:23.957 --> 00:06:31.223
And then, and then we'll go into some of the future of, you know, after the 1950s, when this was discovered, what happened to the players.

124
00:06:31.744 --> 00:06:32.024
Okay.

125
00:06:32.144 --> 00:06:32.324
Okay.

126
00:06:32.764 --> 00:06:38.149
So we're going to start actually all the way back in the 1800s with a man named Gregor Mendel, who,

127
00:06:38.789 --> 00:06:43.211
Back then, you know, everyone knows about, like, inheritance, right?

128
00:06:43.291 --> 00:06:46.792
Like, you get stuff from your parents, but nobody really knew how.

129
00:06:47.452 --> 00:06:48.813
Gregor Mendel is this guy.

130
00:06:48.853 --> 00:06:54.095
He's an Austrian monk, and he does experiments on pea plants.

131
00:06:54.995 --> 00:06:59.317
And he starts noticing that, actually, when you do these quantitative experiments, you can—

132
00:07:01.112 --> 00:07:08.536
really mathematically say how much of the next generation is going to get a certain trait from their parents.

133
00:07:08.936 --> 00:07:18.222
He was doing very selective breeding where, for example, let's say a peapod had green, and then there was another pea plant that had yellow pods, right?

134
00:07:18.522 --> 00:07:24.565
If you selectively breed them together, how many of the next generation are going to inherit the yellow versus the green?

135
00:07:24.865 --> 00:07:29.548
How many of the next generation are going to inherit tall versus short?

136
00:07:29.568 --> 00:07:29.768
Mm-hmm.

137
00:07:29.968 --> 00:07:32.319
How many are going to do this or that, right?

138
00:07:32.861 --> 00:07:34.970
And there was a mathematics to it.

139
00:07:35.850 --> 00:07:39.871
There was an understanding that you could glean, which means that there's something.

140
00:07:39.971 --> 00:07:41.451
It wasn't random.

141
00:07:41.511 --> 00:07:42.871
It wasn't completely random.

142
00:07:43.191 --> 00:07:45.672
There's some mechanism that's happening.

143
00:07:45.712 --> 00:07:49.173
And this is before the whole mechanistic view about biology.

144
00:07:49.393 --> 00:07:49.673
Got it.

145
00:07:49.733 --> 00:07:50.133
Right?

146
00:07:50.633 --> 00:07:56.174
Biology was still kind of a dark science of like things are just happening and we're trying to figure it out.

147
00:07:56.234 --> 00:08:02.015
But here, this is one of these first clues that something as fundamental as inheritance was.

148
00:08:02.075 --> 00:08:04.176
could be put into a mathematical language.

149
00:08:04.436 --> 00:08:10.897
And if it's being put into a mathematical language, that means there must be some physical thingy that is going on.

150
00:08:10.917 --> 00:08:15.778
That is facilitating the structure that allows you to make those, effectively, predictions.

151
00:08:15.958 --> 00:08:17.259
Yes, exactly.

152
00:08:17.379 --> 00:08:20.259
About what will happen based on initial conditions.

153
00:08:20.339 --> 00:08:21.019
Exactly, yeah.

154
00:08:21.320 --> 00:08:26.061
So it started out as a statistical abstraction that represented inheritance.

155
00:08:26.661 --> 00:08:30.102
And pretty soon, people started asking, well, what is the thing?

156
00:08:30.182 --> 00:08:31.142
What is the material?

157
00:08:32.323 --> 00:08:53.405
that is conferring this inheritance right right so the prevailing view was that it's proteins okay everyone and and it kind of makes sense if you look back in the 1920s 1930s proteins have a really complicated structure there's 20 different amino acids that we had already kind of figured out from biochemical pathways

158
00:08:54.377 --> 00:09:01.641
And the fact that there's 20 different amino acids, proteins already we know have so many different functions, right?

159
00:09:01.962 --> 00:09:08.766
So it's like, it's kind of an obvious thing to say that, yeah, proteins are the thing that are conferring inheritance.

160
00:09:08.786 --> 00:09:08.986
Right.

161
00:09:09.646 --> 00:09:13.549
The idea is proteins are where a lot of – it's the workhorse.

162
00:09:13.829 --> 00:09:14.169
Yes.

163
00:09:14.289 --> 00:09:15.770
It's where a lot of stuff can happen.

164
00:09:15.790 --> 00:09:16.490
Happen, yeah.

165
00:09:16.610 --> 00:09:17.091
It happens.

166
00:09:17.351 --> 00:09:17.511
Yes.

167
00:09:17.531 --> 00:09:18.972
It can literally happen.

168
00:09:18.992 --> 00:09:21.773
Yes, literally proteins are doing all these things.

169
00:09:22.034 --> 00:09:23.474
They're incredibly diverse.

170
00:09:23.695 --> 00:09:23.835
Right.

171
00:09:23.895 --> 00:09:27.677
And given the diversity of life – It's just like, oh, it's another thing in the toolbox.

172
00:09:27.837 --> 00:09:28.777
Yes, exactly.

173
00:09:28.797 --> 00:09:29.638
Which is a fair...

174
00:09:30.278 --> 00:09:30.978
Totally fair.

175
00:09:31.038 --> 00:09:31.538
Totally fair.

176
00:09:31.578 --> 00:09:32.119
Totally fair.

177
00:09:32.439 --> 00:09:34.139
Right?

178
00:09:34.239 --> 00:09:43.243
In 1869, actually, there was this guy, Friedrich Mischer, who identified something called nucleon, which is what we now call DNA.

179
00:09:44.466 --> 00:09:49.247
He identified that inside the nucleus of cells, there were two different types of compounds.

180
00:09:49.267 --> 00:09:53.668
There were proteins, and then there was this other thing that he said was nucleon.

181
00:09:53.988 --> 00:09:56.529
But he was like, it's probably just like some structural thing.

182
00:09:56.689 --> 00:09:57.989
He was like, nucleon.

183
00:09:58.289 --> 00:10:00.790
Yeah, because it's in the nucleus.

184
00:10:01.170 --> 00:10:02.670
So I'm going to call it nucleon.

185
00:10:02.970 --> 00:10:06.811
And it was seen as a monotonous structural scaffold.

186
00:10:06.871 --> 00:10:12.293
It's just like conferring structure into whatever is really important inside of the nucleus.

187
00:10:15.394 --> 00:10:20.161
Then came Phoebus Levine from 1905 to 1930.

188
00:10:20.221 --> 00:10:24.446
He was actually at the Rockefeller Institute, which is now called the Rockefeller University.

189
00:10:24.867 --> 00:10:30.174
It's on the Upper East Side of Manhattan, endowed by the Rockefeller Foundation.

190
00:10:31.466 --> 00:10:33.867
He discovered nucleotides.

191
00:10:34.188 --> 00:10:34.448
Okay.

192
00:10:34.548 --> 00:10:45.154
So he was going into this nucleon stuff, and he discovered that there's these things called nucleotides that really make up the structure of nucleon.

193
00:10:45.174 --> 00:10:45.834
Okay.

194
00:10:45.854 --> 00:10:48.395
And there's three different parts to a nucleotide.

195
00:10:48.736 --> 00:10:53.258
There's some kind of sugar, which he identified as deoxyribose.

196
00:10:53.338 --> 00:10:54.459
It's just a type of sugar.

197
00:10:54.899 --> 00:10:56.240
It's like a carbohydrate.

198
00:10:56.260 --> 00:10:56.840
Okay.

199
00:10:57.147 --> 00:11:01.948
He also identified that there's a part of the molecule that's the phosphate, right?

200
00:11:02.348 --> 00:11:07.810
And then if you actually look it up, there's another thing called the nitrogenous base.

201
00:11:07.850 --> 00:11:09.030
There's something with nitrogen.

202
00:11:09.050 --> 00:11:11.751
So there's three different parts to a nucleotide.

203
00:11:11.831 --> 00:11:14.712
You have a base, you have a sugar, and you have a phosphate.

204
00:11:14.892 --> 00:11:15.372
Exactly.

205
00:11:15.812 --> 00:11:19.113
And these are the things that make up my nucleon.

206
00:11:19.253 --> 00:11:19.513
Okay.

207
00:11:19.773 --> 00:11:20.033
Okay?

208
00:11:21.310 --> 00:11:23.471
That was sort of the prevailing thing.

209
00:11:23.791 --> 00:11:25.411
There's four different types of nucleotides.

210
00:11:25.812 --> 00:11:31.113
What he did notice was that there's four different types of bases in DNA.

211
00:11:31.473 --> 00:11:37.956
Here we're actually showing five because RNA, which is another type of nucleon, has another type of nucleotide.

212
00:11:37.996 --> 00:11:41.817
But notice the following, and this is going to be important later.

213
00:11:42.977 --> 00:11:47.839
With those nitrogenous bases, which is part of the building block of this nucleon,

214
00:11:52.018 --> 00:11:53.819
those are called the pyramidines.

215
00:11:54.180 --> 00:11:54.380
Yes.

216
00:11:54.520 --> 00:11:57.002
And then some of them have a double carbon ring.

217
00:11:57.102 --> 00:11:58.763
They're a little bit bigger, right?

218
00:11:58.783 --> 00:12:04.088
They've got a pentagon on a hexagon, whereas the other guys are just a bunch of hexagons, single hexagons.

219
00:12:04.188 --> 00:12:05.349
Yes, yes, yes.

220
00:12:05.509 --> 00:12:05.669
Right?

221
00:12:05.809 --> 00:12:16.479
And he noticed that there's these four different types, and he had this thing called the tetranucleotide hypothesis, which is basically that all of DNA is just basically made up of

222
00:12:17.492 --> 00:12:28.837
these four types of nucleic acids that are all coming for, and this, what you're seeing here, is the first ever proposed structure for DNA.

223
00:12:29.358 --> 00:12:29.838
Okay.

224
00:12:30.198 --> 00:12:38.322
He's like, these four different things, there's the A, there's the C, there's the T and the G, that's adenine, guanine, cytosine, and thymine.

225
00:12:38.862 --> 00:12:45.245
Those things come together, and they create a structure called DNA, or nuclein at that point, and...

226
00:12:45.405 --> 00:12:50.447
And this is what confers that structural scaffold into the nucleus.

227
00:12:50.487 --> 00:12:54.548
So this is the very, very first proposed structure of DNA.

228
00:12:54.688 --> 00:12:54.928
Okay.

229
00:12:55.068 --> 00:12:55.348
Okay.

230
00:12:55.428 --> 00:12:57.629
It's just like this box-like structure.

231
00:12:57.749 --> 00:12:58.489
Yes.

232
00:12:58.669 --> 00:13:01.570
With the four just in a little rectangle.

233
00:13:01.590 --> 00:13:01.830
Yes.

234
00:13:02.050 --> 00:13:02.230
Okay.

235
00:13:02.250 --> 00:13:03.331
And he's like, this is what it is.

236
00:13:04.311 --> 00:13:05.852
It clearly is not what it is.

237
00:13:06.012 --> 00:13:07.173
It clearly is not what it is.

238
00:13:07.213 --> 00:13:08.574
We know that now.

239
00:13:08.634 --> 00:13:09.195
We know that now.

240
00:13:09.455 --> 00:13:14.598
But back then, you can imagine, like, the tools that they have is not at all what the tools that we have, right?

241
00:13:14.618 --> 00:13:16.179
There's no X-ray crystallography.

242
00:13:16.219 --> 00:13:20.162
There's no genetic sequencing.

243
00:13:21.003 --> 00:13:24.705
You're dealing with really crude tools compared to what we have today.

244
00:13:24.725 --> 00:13:30.790
It's incredible that they were able to get to this intuition and this directionality of what was correct.

245
00:13:30.810 --> 00:13:31.330
Right.

246
00:13:32.052 --> 00:13:33.513
Details were a little fuzzy.

247
00:13:33.553 --> 00:13:33.774
Yeah.

248
00:13:34.014 --> 00:13:36.256
But it was directionally accurate and tactically wrong.

249
00:13:36.276 --> 00:13:36.876
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

250
00:13:36.956 --> 00:13:37.737
Tactically wrong.

251
00:13:38.158 --> 00:13:40.299
But he had already figured out that there's four different types.

252
00:13:40.360 --> 00:13:40.580
Right.

253
00:13:40.780 --> 00:13:49.247
But because he had this hypothesis that, well, they're all just like conglomerated in this square shape, there's no real way for them to...

254
00:13:50.128 --> 00:14:12.086
be complex they're just simple yeah and life is very complex so how do you how do you go from the simplicity of that structure and to all of the complicated kind of a little kind of yeah and so they're like okay okay so this is not this is not what it is right okay that makes sense then we get to a fisher so this is in liverpool university liverpool yeah shout out to all the scousers out there you never walk alone

255
00:14:13.492 --> 00:14:14.374
Frederick Griffith.

256
00:14:14.514 --> 00:14:14.794
Okay.

257
00:14:14.834 --> 00:14:19.782
He's, he's at the Liverpool university and at the Liverpool medical institution.

258
00:14:19.802 --> 00:14:20.083
Okay.

259
00:14:20.543 --> 00:14:25.331
And he does a few experiments with bacteria and mice.

260
00:14:25.952 --> 00:14:26.853
And this is what he's doing.

261
00:14:27.885 --> 00:14:35.728
Back then, we knew that there were two types of bacteria of this particular strain called S. pneumoniae.

262
00:14:35.888 --> 00:14:37.329
I think it's basically pneumonia.

263
00:14:38.089 --> 00:14:38.469
Okay.

264
00:14:38.789 --> 00:14:40.490
It's pneumonia that affects mice.

265
00:14:40.770 --> 00:14:40.970
Okay.

266
00:14:41.010 --> 00:14:41.250
Okay.

267
00:14:41.610 --> 00:14:43.591
There's two types of these bacteria.

268
00:14:43.631 --> 00:14:49.934
There's a smooth strain, which is the S. And then there's a rough strain, which is the R. Okay.

269
00:14:50.194 --> 00:14:52.995
And we know that the smooth strain kills mice.

270
00:14:53.595 --> 00:14:53.815
Okay.

271
00:14:54.255 --> 00:14:55.536
But the rough strain does not.

272
00:14:56.710 --> 00:14:56.950
Okay?

273
00:14:57.170 --> 00:14:59.611
You can inject the rough strain into mice, they'll live.

274
00:14:59.951 --> 00:15:01.851
The smooth strain into mice, they won't live.

275
00:15:02.051 --> 00:15:02.351
Okay.

276
00:15:02.811 --> 00:15:03.651
But here's the kicker.

277
00:15:03.711 --> 00:15:06.352
Here's the genius of his experiment.

278
00:15:06.832 --> 00:15:14.754
What Griffiths did was he said, okay, can I turn the rough strain into the smooth strain?

279
00:15:15.934 --> 00:15:17.134
And you turn water into wine.

280
00:15:17.394 --> 00:15:17.654
Yes.

281
00:15:17.974 --> 00:15:18.574
In some sense.

282
00:15:18.634 --> 00:15:19.415
Or the rice.

283
00:15:19.915 --> 00:15:20.435
In some sense.

284
00:15:20.775 --> 00:15:21.415
Here's what he's doing.

285
00:15:21.455 --> 00:15:21.655
Like...

286
00:15:22.856 --> 00:15:28.799
What he can do is, so if he puts the rough and the smooth strain together, and then he puts it in the mice, they die.

287
00:15:29.079 --> 00:15:33.962
But that makes sense because you just put the smooth strain, the virulent form in the mice and they died.

288
00:15:34.262 --> 00:15:34.442
Right.

289
00:15:34.822 --> 00:15:38.604
What he does was he heat kills the smooth.

290
00:15:38.985 --> 00:15:39.585
Heat kills?

291
00:15:39.765 --> 00:15:40.445
Yeah.

292
00:15:40.725 --> 00:15:45.168
So he gets a bunch of bacteria that are really bad that are going to kill the mice, and he heat kills them.

293
00:15:45.864 --> 00:15:46.965
I don't know what that means.

294
00:15:47.065 --> 00:15:48.607
Just heat it up.

295
00:15:48.807 --> 00:15:53.772
So he literally turned the volume to 11 on the heat.

296
00:15:53.792 --> 00:15:54.693
Yeah, he boiled them up.

297
00:15:54.794 --> 00:15:56.035
Literally, just heat.

298
00:15:56.255 --> 00:15:57.717
Yeah, just literally heated them up.

299
00:15:58.117 --> 00:16:01.361
And then it inoculated kind of the fatal aspects of it.

300
00:16:01.381 --> 00:16:01.601
Yes.

301
00:16:02.021 --> 00:16:05.225
And now when he puts that into the mice, they still live.

302
00:16:06.040 --> 00:16:06.801
They still live, right?

303
00:16:07.021 --> 00:16:08.242
Because you've killed a bacteria.

304
00:16:08.362 --> 00:16:08.642
I see.

305
00:16:08.702 --> 00:16:09.283
That makes sense.

306
00:16:09.303 --> 00:16:09.743
That makes sense.

307
00:16:09.903 --> 00:16:10.564
But here's the thing.

308
00:16:10.864 --> 00:16:11.544
This is the kicker.

309
00:16:11.945 --> 00:16:16.288
He takes that heat-killed strain, that little sample that he has.

310
00:16:16.929 --> 00:16:18.290
Let's say it's in a test tube.

311
00:16:18.750 --> 00:16:20.732
He's put it into a really hot water bath.

312
00:16:21.012 --> 00:16:22.173
It's killed all the bacteria.

313
00:16:22.653 --> 00:16:25.655
And he mixes that with the non-viralant type.

314
00:16:26.616 --> 00:16:28.137
And then he puts that mixture...

315
00:16:29.093 --> 00:16:29.953
Into the mice.

316
00:16:30.454 --> 00:16:31.694
So he's taking the thing that's bad.

317
00:16:32.154 --> 00:16:32.894
He's boiled it.

318
00:16:33.134 --> 00:16:33.635
He's boiled it.

319
00:16:33.655 --> 00:16:35.015
And now he's done a little mix.

320
00:16:35.335 --> 00:16:37.336
Mixing with the stuff that was fine.

321
00:16:37.376 --> 00:16:38.036
That was fine.

322
00:16:38.536 --> 00:16:40.277
And then he puts that mixture into the mice.

323
00:16:40.417 --> 00:16:41.137
And the mice die.

324
00:16:41.918 --> 00:16:50.261
Ah, so even when you boil, even when you heat, heat it up, boil it all up, and still mix, there's something there.

325
00:16:50.281 --> 00:16:51.361
There's something there.

326
00:16:52.381 --> 00:16:53.362
There's something there.

327
00:16:53.662 --> 00:16:54.282
That's the thing.

328
00:16:54.322 --> 00:16:54.802
That's the thing.

329
00:16:54.822 --> 00:16:55.242
That's the thing.

330
00:16:55.282 --> 00:16:56.963
There's something physically there.

331
00:16:56.983 --> 00:16:57.083
Yeah.

332
00:16:58.686 --> 00:17:07.014
That has transformed the non-viral form into the one that kills mice.

333
00:17:07.174 --> 00:17:09.476
And it has nothing to do...

334
00:17:10.076 --> 00:17:12.559
It's still present even after trying to have heated.

335
00:17:12.699 --> 00:17:12.979
Yes.

336
00:17:13.059 --> 00:17:16.762
Which the theory was that will kill any problematic things.

337
00:17:16.863 --> 00:17:19.125
Yeah, that's why that control was very important, right?

338
00:17:19.145 --> 00:17:19.425
Interesting.

339
00:17:19.445 --> 00:17:24.409
The control of let's heat up my virulent form and then put that into the mice.

340
00:17:24.549 --> 00:17:24.710
Right.

341
00:17:24.730 --> 00:17:24.850
Right.

342
00:17:25.623 --> 00:17:26.223
They don't die.

343
00:17:26.503 --> 00:17:27.144
They don't die.

344
00:17:27.244 --> 00:17:31.405
So I've killed a bacteria, but I've preserved something in that bacteria.

345
00:17:31.645 --> 00:17:32.665
That is continuing to propagate.

346
00:17:32.685 --> 00:17:36.947
That is continuing to propagate this ability to kill mice.

347
00:17:38.007 --> 00:17:38.207
Yep.

348
00:17:38.247 --> 00:17:38.447
Right?

349
00:17:38.888 --> 00:17:40.228
This ability to be violent.

350
00:17:40.308 --> 00:17:45.530
And that has gone and transformed the nice bacteria into the bad bacteria that...

351
00:17:46.523 --> 00:17:47.804
And gone and done the experiment.

352
00:17:47.824 --> 00:17:55.567
The point being there is something more fundamental than what we thought to be what is driving this process.

353
00:17:55.607 --> 00:17:56.988
Yeah, it's not just the bacteria.

354
00:17:57.008 --> 00:18:04.552
There's something inside the bacteria that is staying put, that is going inside the non-bad bacteria, the good one.

355
00:18:04.632 --> 00:18:05.812
And replicating bad stuff.

356
00:18:05.832 --> 00:18:06.313
Making them bad.

357
00:18:06.333 --> 00:18:06.553
Bad.

358
00:18:07.153 --> 00:18:08.714
And that's okay, right?

359
00:18:09.094 --> 00:18:10.655
This is a very fundamental experiment.

360
00:18:10.675 --> 00:18:11.696
It's very simple.

361
00:18:11.796 --> 00:18:12.536
It's very simple.

362
00:18:12.876 --> 00:18:17.079
But it shows you that there's a physical element to this idea of ability.

363
00:18:17.839 --> 00:18:24.683
I want to just take a quick pause to point out how sometimes simple ability

364
00:18:24.963 --> 00:18:29.488
or straightforward some of this early stage science sounds like.

365
00:18:29.588 --> 00:18:29.828
Yeah.

366
00:18:30.269 --> 00:18:35.534
But you actually need to be able to simplify before you can complexify, for lack of a better way to put it.

367
00:18:35.554 --> 00:18:36.235
No, no, totally.

368
00:18:36.595 --> 00:18:41.000
And with the tools that they had, this is already a huge leap, right?

369
00:18:41.080 --> 00:18:41.300
Right.

370
00:18:41.360 --> 00:18:47.726
This is showing that there is something there, that there's something physically there that is transforming the bacteria

371
00:18:48.387 --> 00:18:49.948
to become something else.

372
00:18:50.128 --> 00:18:50.308
Right.

373
00:18:50.328 --> 00:18:50.508
Right?

374
00:18:50.849 --> 00:18:55.352
The bacteria is going from a non-virulent form to a virulent form.

375
00:18:55.432 --> 00:18:55.612
Right.

376
00:18:55.872 --> 00:18:59.294
And it now has the ability to kill mice.

377
00:18:59.395 --> 00:18:59.575
Right.

378
00:18:59.955 --> 00:19:01.476
Even, yes, yes, yes.

379
00:19:01.516 --> 00:19:02.256
Right?

380
00:19:02.337 --> 00:19:03.597
This is pretty crazy.

381
00:19:03.657 --> 00:19:04.078
No.

382
00:19:04.138 --> 00:19:04.478
Already.

383
00:19:05.339 --> 00:19:06.539
And this is in 1928.

384
00:19:06.599 --> 00:19:07.980
Right?

385
00:19:08.060 --> 00:19:14.325
So this is during, like, in the middle of the two wars in Liverpool that he's figured this out.

386
00:19:14.525 --> 00:19:15.165
Liverpool!

387
00:19:15.185 --> 00:19:15.966
Right?

388
00:19:15.986 --> 00:19:16.166
Right.

389
00:19:17.322 --> 00:19:19.084
People are trying to figure out what is that thing.

390
00:19:19.704 --> 00:19:20.805
Which makes sense.

391
00:19:20.886 --> 00:19:25.230
Now we've pointed out there's a mystery that is clearly identifiable and replicatable.

392
00:19:25.310 --> 00:19:25.530
Yeah.

393
00:19:25.770 --> 00:19:26.211
What is it?

394
00:19:26.491 --> 00:19:26.891
What is it?

395
00:19:27.272 --> 00:19:34.259
And now we get to the resolution of that with an experiment by Avery, McLeod, and McCarty in 1944.

396
00:19:34.359 --> 00:19:34.879
Okay?

397
00:19:35.980 --> 00:19:40.144
What they do is they systematically purify whatever the thing is.

398
00:19:40.945 --> 00:19:43.206
that is doing this transformation.

399
00:19:43.266 --> 00:19:44.026
And here's what they do.

400
00:19:44.426 --> 00:19:46.506
They say, okay, there's possibilities, right?

401
00:19:46.586 --> 00:19:50.307
It could be protein, it could be RNA, or it could be DNA.

402
00:19:50.607 --> 00:20:02.990
What I'm going to do is I'm going to take that soup of heated up bad bacteria, and I'm going to treat it with something called trypsin, which basically cuts a bunch of protein,

403
00:20:04.191 --> 00:20:06.053
and inoculates all the proteins.

404
00:20:06.153 --> 00:20:07.395
It degrades all the proteins.

405
00:20:07.415 --> 00:20:13.303
So the point is, if protein is the source, we're injecting a kill switch that kills the protein.

406
00:20:13.904 --> 00:20:15.686
And so if the protein was the source...

407
00:20:18.064 --> 00:20:18.925
It would not have...

408
00:20:18.945 --> 00:20:20.986
The bacteria would not carry... Yeah.

409
00:20:21.306 --> 00:20:21.866
Yeah.

410
00:20:21.906 --> 00:20:22.987
And then mice would live.

411
00:20:23.007 --> 00:20:23.527
Mice would live.

412
00:20:23.787 --> 00:20:23.988
Right?

413
00:20:24.168 --> 00:20:25.228
Yes.

414
00:20:25.408 --> 00:20:25.989
They still die.

415
00:20:26.549 --> 00:20:30.792
Kill switch was maybe a bad terminology to use when we had double kill going on.

416
00:20:31.052 --> 00:20:34.594
However, the point is, trypsin killed the proteins.

417
00:20:34.934 --> 00:20:37.015
Proteins no longer being problematic.

418
00:20:37.215 --> 00:20:38.256
We put them to the new mice.

419
00:20:38.556 --> 00:20:39.397
The new mice still die.

420
00:20:39.637 --> 00:20:40.477
The new mice still die.

421
00:20:40.537 --> 00:20:41.118
So it's not protein.

422
00:20:41.138 --> 00:20:41.878
So it's not protein.

423
00:20:41.898 --> 00:20:42.378
It's not protein.

424
00:20:42.398 --> 00:20:42.659
Okay?

425
00:20:42.919 --> 00:20:45.861
Then we do something called RNAs, which we know it's something that...

426
00:20:47.121 --> 00:20:47.962
kills RNA.

427
00:20:48.042 --> 00:20:49.103
It cuts RNA out.

428
00:20:49.223 --> 00:20:49.523
Okay.

429
00:20:50.504 --> 00:20:50.905
Same thing.

430
00:20:51.145 --> 00:20:51.425
Nothing.

431
00:20:51.765 --> 00:20:56.449
Then we do something called DNAs, which is something that cuts up DNA.

432
00:20:56.489 --> 00:20:57.010
We know that.

433
00:20:57.310 --> 00:20:57.450
Mm-hmm.

434
00:20:58.687 --> 00:21:00.187
That's when the mice live.

435
00:21:00.747 --> 00:21:02.908
Not to be confused with CRISPR, which also cuts up DNA.

436
00:21:02.928 --> 00:21:03.168
Yes.

437
00:21:03.488 --> 00:21:06.669
I mean, this was a very big precursor.

438
00:21:06.969 --> 00:21:09.349
This is like, you know, 100 years ago.

439
00:21:09.689 --> 00:21:11.069
It's a very specific CRISPR.

440
00:21:11.830 --> 00:21:12.210
Understood.

441
00:21:12.230 --> 00:21:12.410
Right?

442
00:21:12.770 --> 00:21:13.270
But it is.

443
00:21:13.710 --> 00:21:14.350
It's a scissor.

444
00:21:14.690 --> 00:21:16.391
And what it's doing is it's cutting up DNA.

445
00:21:16.711 --> 00:21:24.232
Well, and you cut up the DNA that would give the instructions to the bacteria to actually tell the bacteria how to infect the mice.

446
00:21:24.872 --> 00:21:26.293
That's when we killed that ability.

447
00:21:28.913 --> 00:21:30.817
Now we've found the building block.

448
00:21:30.957 --> 00:21:31.218
Yes.

449
00:21:31.699 --> 00:21:34.143
Now we've found the building block for the gene.

450
00:21:34.183 --> 00:21:37.710
The idea of inheritance is something that is coming from DNA.

451
00:21:37.970 --> 00:21:41.156
I actually want to take a quick step back and talk about this because at this time...

452
00:21:42.206 --> 00:21:49.131
We did not understand how traits were passed generationally.

453
00:21:49.292 --> 00:21:50.232
We knew that they were.

454
00:21:50.252 --> 00:21:51.193
From Mendel.

455
00:21:51.433 --> 00:21:51.713
Obviously.

456
00:21:51.753 --> 00:21:52.434
And from all these.

457
00:21:52.534 --> 00:21:54.636
I mean, obviously, like, I look like my parents.

458
00:21:54.696 --> 00:21:55.636
You look like your parents.

459
00:21:55.656 --> 00:21:56.857
So obviously there's something.

460
00:21:56.917 --> 00:22:03.863
And then experimentally, we also proved it in a controlled context to know that there is this inheritance concept that...

461
00:22:04.403 --> 00:22:05.884
of inheritance exists.

462
00:22:06.164 --> 00:22:07.244
Yes, but what it is.

463
00:22:07.424 --> 00:22:10.926
What actually makes up the fabric of that?

464
00:22:11.086 --> 00:22:11.466
Yeah.

465
00:22:11.586 --> 00:22:13.247
It's actually a really important point to know.

466
00:22:13.267 --> 00:22:16.549
We actually didn't know that barely 100 years ago.

467
00:22:17.089 --> 00:22:18.610
It is quite incredible, right?

468
00:22:18.630 --> 00:22:19.210
100 years ago.

469
00:22:19.390 --> 00:22:20.811
It is quite incredible to think about.

470
00:22:20.831 --> 00:22:25.113
We didn't really know how I look like my dad.

471
00:22:25.173 --> 00:22:25.353
Yeah.

472
00:22:25.373 --> 00:22:25.473
Yeah.

473
00:22:25.653 --> 00:22:27.373
Yeah, this is 1944.

474
00:22:27.553 --> 00:22:29.194
That's crazy.

475
00:22:29.234 --> 00:22:29.654
1944.

476
00:22:29.714 --> 00:22:32.955
We didn't know if it was DNA or proteins or something else.

477
00:22:33.055 --> 00:22:35.815
We figured out how to split the atom and create nukes.

478
00:22:35.915 --> 00:22:36.236
Yeah.

479
00:22:36.456 --> 00:22:38.496
But we still didn't know why I look like my dad.

480
00:22:38.616 --> 00:22:38.836
Yeah.

481
00:22:39.096 --> 00:22:42.757
I mean, that just goes to show you how complicated biology is, right?

482
00:22:43.057 --> 00:22:47.198
And how hard it is to do experiments and really figure out what the hell is going on.

483
00:22:47.278 --> 00:22:49.699
We talk about this often where you talk about like, oh, physics.

484
00:22:49.979 --> 00:22:50.299
Yeah.

485
00:22:50.399 --> 00:22:50.659
Yeah.

486
00:22:51.019 --> 00:22:51.579
We've got that.

487
00:22:51.739 --> 00:22:52.619
Biology.

488
00:22:53.020 --> 00:22:54.320
Biology is tough, mate.

489
00:22:54.380 --> 00:22:58.161
The variables are a little... Yeah, yeah, because every molecule is different.

490
00:22:58.241 --> 00:23:00.082
Every individual is different.

491
00:23:00.422 --> 00:23:05.963
You know, in physics, we have the nice pleasure of being like, that electron is the same as every other electron.

492
00:23:06.003 --> 00:23:07.504
Electron in the universe.

493
00:23:07.544 --> 00:23:08.144
In the universe.

494
00:23:08.204 --> 00:23:10.544
We've never found one that's different, right?

495
00:23:10.684 --> 00:23:15.586
So it is an incredible experiment that they did back in 1944, right?

496
00:23:15.626 --> 00:23:16.086
Got it.

497
00:23:16.126 --> 00:23:16.326
Okay.

498
00:23:16.786 --> 00:23:18.246
At the same time in 1944, you've got...

499
00:23:21.104 --> 00:23:23.825
Erwin Schrodinger's book called What is Life?

500
00:23:24.325 --> 00:23:27.126
This is one of my favorite books of all time.

501
00:23:27.806 --> 00:23:28.066
Okay.

502
00:23:28.226 --> 00:23:31.107
It's on the FFP Readers bestseller list.

503
00:23:31.188 --> 00:23:31.708
100%.

504
00:23:32.248 --> 00:23:34.529
It's a very short book.

505
00:23:34.569 --> 00:23:37.010
You can read it in about two hours.

506
00:23:37.550 --> 00:23:38.810
Honestly, it's very short.

507
00:23:38.850 --> 00:23:43.572
It's just a bunch of lectures that he gave at the Dublin College in Ireland.

508
00:23:44.212 --> 00:23:50.280
But it is one of my favorite books of all time because it really shows how a physicist would approach this problem.

509
00:23:50.800 --> 00:23:51.061
Okay.

510
00:23:51.561 --> 00:23:51.802
Okay?

511
00:23:52.022 --> 00:23:58.911
He was influenced by someone, by a bunch of physicists at the time, like Max Delbruck, who was a physicist.

512
00:24:00.220 --> 00:24:04.143
that had gone to University of Göttingen, which we've talked about.

513
00:24:04.363 --> 00:24:06.024
He was mentored by Lisa Meitner.

514
00:24:06.204 --> 00:24:06.405
Yep.

515
00:24:06.725 --> 00:24:09.307
And then he finally gets to Caltech.

516
00:24:09.667 --> 00:24:15.991
And he shows that he really starts thinking about how hereditary material must be something that is solid.

517
00:24:16.732 --> 00:24:21.275
It must be something that can resist temperature fluctuations.

518
00:24:21.435 --> 00:24:22.476
Because of what we just talked about.

519
00:24:22.496 --> 00:24:22.736
Yes.

520
00:24:22.976 --> 00:24:24.958
And it must also be non-repetitive.

521
00:24:26.441 --> 00:24:27.001
What does that mean?

522
00:24:27.361 --> 00:24:27.621
Yeah.

523
00:24:27.661 --> 00:24:33.983
If it's repetitive, if it's just a bunch of repetition, you can't store a lot of information there.

524
00:24:34.524 --> 00:24:37.865
It's got to store a bunch of information, right?

525
00:24:38.205 --> 00:24:41.266
It's got to be like, this is how you do this, and this is how you do that.

526
00:24:41.686 --> 00:24:43.566
A recipe book is not repetitive.

527
00:24:43.706 --> 00:24:44.987
Yeah, right, right.

528
00:24:45.107 --> 00:24:52.029
Every page or every couple pages is a different... Is different, is a different recipe for all of the different things that I need in life, right?

529
00:24:52.289 --> 00:24:59.880
This is quite nice, but it's a fundamental thing that you can even think about for a bit and be like, yeah, of course.

530
00:24:59.900 --> 00:25:00.501
Okay, that makes sense.

531
00:25:00.521 --> 00:25:01.903
Whatever the thing that is...

532
00:25:02.827 --> 00:25:07.711
Giving you the information for inheritance has to be something that is not repetitive.

533
00:25:08.031 --> 00:25:12.795
It's something that encodes a bunch of information, like a recipe book, right?

534
00:25:13.996 --> 00:25:15.857
You can have multiple books.

535
00:25:15.977 --> 00:25:21.021
Books are repetition, but within the context of a book, there's complexity within that object type.

536
00:25:22.422 --> 00:25:22.902
Exactly.

537
00:25:23.043 --> 00:25:23.723
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

538
00:25:24.083 --> 00:25:29.008
And one of the key things that he says, it's a postulate that he puts, Erwin Schrödinger.

539
00:25:29.448 --> 00:25:33.051
He says the gene is an aperiodic crystal.

540
00:25:33.511 --> 00:25:34.352
What does he mean by that?

541
00:25:35.133 --> 00:25:37.315
What he means is there's periodic crystals, right?

542
00:25:37.375 --> 00:25:38.796
Diamond is a periodic crystal.

543
00:25:38.836 --> 00:25:41.178
It's a bunch of carbon, carbon, carbon, carbon, carbon.

544
00:25:42.119 --> 00:25:46.302
You can have salt, which is sodium chloride, sodium chloride, sodium chloride.

545
00:25:46.663 --> 00:25:47.944
Not a lot of information there.

546
00:25:48.084 --> 00:25:53.028
There's like two bits of information, which is you put the sodium here and the chlorine here, and then you repeat.

547
00:25:53.609 --> 00:25:57.993
An aperiodic crystal is somewhere where the atomic arrangements are different.

548
00:25:59.503 --> 00:26:04.545
And that difference tells you how to do whatever inheritance thing that you're doing.

549
00:26:05.305 --> 00:26:09.987
So he was the first person to postulate that there's some kind of hereditary code script.

550
00:26:10.267 --> 00:26:14.509
There's some aperiodic crystal inside of biology.

551
00:26:15.727 --> 00:26:19.188
That is conferring information to the next generation.

552
00:26:19.969 --> 00:26:27.191
And this is really important because this is cited by both Watson and Crick, who are the discoverers of the double helix.

553
00:26:27.312 --> 00:26:31.093
They said this was a primary motivation for seeking the genetic structure.

554
00:26:31.473 --> 00:26:36.015
What they wanted to do with their life was find this aperiodic crystal.

555
00:26:36.355 --> 00:26:40.997
So just the idea here is that someone...

556
00:26:42.150 --> 00:26:43.810
basically said it's a treasure map.

557
00:26:44.030 --> 00:26:44.270
Yeah.

558
00:26:44.750 --> 00:26:46.791
There's a treasure map, and this is what it looks like.

559
00:26:46.971 --> 00:26:47.171
Right.

560
00:26:47.671 --> 00:26:55.292
And this is this aperiodic crystal concept with a hereditary code script, which makes, you can intuit that logic.

561
00:26:55.332 --> 00:26:56.192
Yeah.

562
00:26:56.292 --> 00:27:03.814
From first principles, you can build it up and be like, okay, something that requires information capacity needs to be aperiodic.

563
00:27:03.934 --> 00:27:06.374
It needs to not be the same everywhere, right?

564
00:27:06.474 --> 00:27:06.634
Right.

565
00:27:06.834 --> 00:27:10.535
Because your level of fidelity, if you just have two...

566
00:27:11.215 --> 00:27:15.320
bits is very low as compared to 16 or 32 or 64.

567
00:27:15.481 --> 00:27:16.021
Yeah.

568
00:27:16.422 --> 00:27:18.244
And the order of those bits is what matters.

569
00:27:18.264 --> 00:27:18.585
Is what matters.

570
00:27:18.605 --> 00:27:18.765
Right?

571
00:27:18.785 --> 00:27:20.807
You can't just be 0, 1, 0, 1, 0, 1, 0, 1.

572
00:27:20.828 --> 00:27:21.108
Right.

573
00:27:21.488 --> 00:27:24.472
It's got to be a different, and that sequence...

574
00:27:25.390 --> 00:27:26.991
is what tells you what the information is.

575
00:27:27.031 --> 00:27:32.713
Because DNA ultimately runs a variety of biological processes.

576
00:27:33.213 --> 00:27:37.535
And so how are the instructions stored?

577
00:27:37.955 --> 00:27:46.299
And you need basically a system of enough different component parts or variables to store that complexity.

578
00:27:46.359 --> 00:27:46.559
Yeah.

579
00:27:46.959 --> 00:27:51.481
And so we have the treasure map, and then with Watson and Crick we have the treasure hunters.

580
00:27:51.641 --> 00:27:53.662
Yes, that's a very good way of putting it.

581
00:27:53.702 --> 00:27:58.445
Yeah, they read this book and they're like, this is a treasure that I want to find.

582
00:27:58.465 --> 00:27:59.966
Let's go find the gold of whatever.

583
00:28:00.006 --> 00:28:10.313
What's that famous place where they had all the gold, the ancient place that back in the day... Yeah, I know what you're saying.

584
00:28:10.333 --> 00:28:13.575
I saw National Treasure 2, one of my favorite movies.

585
00:28:13.715 --> 00:28:15.016
The City of Gold, right?

586
00:28:15.056 --> 00:28:16.077
It's the City of Gold.

587
00:28:16.377 --> 00:28:17.178
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

588
00:28:17.198 --> 00:28:17.878
The City of Gold.

589
00:28:18.398 --> 00:28:20.260
They were looking... Because frankly...

590
00:28:21.260 --> 00:28:22.580
The things we live, we'll get there.

591
00:28:22.961 --> 00:28:23.901
City of gold.

592
00:28:24.401 --> 00:28:26.042
So they're trying to find this thing.

593
00:28:26.062 --> 00:28:26.842
They read this book.

594
00:28:26.902 --> 00:28:29.102
It's an incredibly influential book for them.

595
00:28:29.302 --> 00:28:29.523
Yes.

596
00:28:29.763 --> 00:28:36.064
And they're like, we want to go find what this aperiodic crystal is and what does this crystal look like.

597
00:28:36.165 --> 00:28:36.365
Right.

598
00:28:36.725 --> 00:28:36.965
Okay.

599
00:28:38.425 --> 00:28:40.046
This is around 1944.

600
00:28:40.306 --> 00:28:43.907
So at this point, people are already trying to...

601
00:28:44.888 --> 00:28:49.972
justify that DNA is really the thing that carries the genetic information.

602
00:28:50.272 --> 00:28:50.593
Okay.

603
00:28:51.173 --> 00:28:56.718
Erwin Chargaff, Chargaff, Erwin Chargaff at the University of Columbia in Manhattan.

604
00:28:57.118 --> 00:28:58.499
I should say Columbia University.

605
00:28:59.100 --> 00:28:59.260
Um,

606
00:29:00.328 --> 00:29:07.934
He uses this technique of partition chromatography to look at what is the base composition of this DNA across species.

607
00:29:08.334 --> 00:29:08.494
Okay.

608
00:29:08.514 --> 00:29:08.695
Okay.

609
00:29:08.955 --> 00:29:17.902
Because, you know, back then when Levine was trying to look at the base composition, he just said everything's the same, right?

610
00:29:18.122 --> 00:29:22.385
There's an A, a C, a T, and a G, and they all just come together and it's all equal parts.

611
00:29:22.746 --> 00:29:24.247
He didn't have the resolution.

612
00:29:24.527 --> 00:29:24.667
Mm.

613
00:29:25.448 --> 00:29:28.872
to figure out if there was more A or more T and so on and so forth, right?

614
00:29:29.312 --> 00:29:32.776
Chargaff uses this new method called partition chromatography.

615
00:29:34.160 --> 00:29:37.882
To quantify how much A is there in a species.

616
00:29:38.403 --> 00:29:39.564
How much T is there.

617
00:29:39.824 --> 00:29:44.487
How much G and how much C. As an analogy, you can say, oh, it's all soda.

618
00:29:44.687 --> 00:29:46.108
But it's like, is it Coke?

619
00:29:46.368 --> 00:29:47.048
Is it Sprite?

620
00:29:47.208 --> 00:29:47.429
Yeah.

621
00:29:47.629 --> 00:29:48.309
Is it Fanta?

622
00:29:48.449 --> 00:29:48.649
Yeah.

623
00:29:48.709 --> 00:29:50.571
And are they all in equal proportions?

624
00:29:50.671 --> 00:29:50.811
Right.

625
00:29:50.831 --> 00:29:52.912
Like, is there, what is the, is it Coke Zero?

626
00:29:53.172 --> 00:29:53.413
Yeah.

627
00:29:53.613 --> 00:29:53.793
Right.

628
00:29:53.813 --> 00:29:53.933
Yeah.

629
00:29:53.953 --> 00:29:54.153
Yeah.

630
00:29:54.173 --> 00:29:54.333
Yeah.

631
00:29:54.433 --> 00:29:55.094
Or Diet Coke?

632
00:29:55.114 --> 00:29:55.994
What's the sugar volume?

633
00:29:56.394 --> 00:29:58.176
I'm trying to identify, like, create an A or 4.

634
00:29:58.196 --> 00:29:59.957
Well, there's only four different types of sodas.

635
00:30:00.958 --> 00:30:04.040
So Coke, Sprite, Fanta, grape soda.

636
00:30:04.140 --> 00:30:04.381
Yeah.

637
00:30:04.401 --> 00:30:05.962
We'll say those four.

638
00:30:06.002 --> 00:30:11.447
And those are the four, but Levine has said that they're all equal, and they're just creating the scaffold, right?

639
00:30:11.867 --> 00:30:15.431
And Chargaff went out to say, okay, is this actually true?

640
00:30:15.851 --> 00:30:21.997
And he actually dismantled that hypothesis by showing that there's species-specific variation, meaning...

641
00:30:22.617 --> 00:30:32.024
Like the amount of A's and T's that I have is different from the amount that the cow has, is different from the amount that a pig has from a bird and so on and so forth.

642
00:30:32.444 --> 00:30:37.388
And he came up with a rule that said there's actually a pairing ratio.

643
00:30:38.168 --> 00:30:38.408
Okay.

644
00:30:39.149 --> 00:30:42.952
The A and the T are always the same amount.

645
00:30:44.298 --> 00:30:48.040
And the G and the C are always the same amount.

646
00:30:48.241 --> 00:30:52.583
And if you look at that, this is an expert from his paper.

647
00:30:53.584 --> 00:30:58.307
The source is actually, this is for humans, it actually comes from human semen.

648
00:30:58.907 --> 00:30:59.488
Ah, we love it.

649
00:30:59.808 --> 00:31:00.048
Yeah.

650
00:31:00.548 --> 00:31:06.432
I mean, these guys, when you're doing science at the cutting edge, you got to get down under the weeds.

651
00:31:06.452 --> 00:31:07.413
You got to go to the source.

652
00:31:07.473 --> 00:31:07.693
Yeah.

653
00:31:07.833 --> 00:31:11.936
And the advantage of human semen is like most of the stuff is DNA.

654
00:31:11.956 --> 00:31:12.296
Yeah.

655
00:31:13.530 --> 00:31:14.011
I get it.

656
00:31:14.071 --> 00:31:15.452
You know, it's a good source.

657
00:31:15.552 --> 00:31:23.180
Like with normal cells, there's so many proteins that like it's going to cloud whatever chromatography that you're doing.

658
00:31:23.240 --> 00:31:27.924
With human semen, the sperm cell is like mostly just packaged DNA.

659
00:31:27.944 --> 00:31:28.325
Mm-hmm.

660
00:31:28.865 --> 00:31:29.406
And a tail.

661
00:31:29.746 --> 00:31:30.507
So it's pure.

662
00:31:30.627 --> 00:31:31.068
It's pure.

663
00:31:31.088 --> 00:31:31.428
It's like...

664
00:31:31.488 --> 00:31:32.189
It's sigma.

665
00:31:32.229 --> 00:31:32.409
Yeah.

666
00:31:32.429 --> 00:31:32.890
Pure alpha.

667
00:31:32.970 --> 00:31:33.891
Yeah, exactly.

668
00:31:33.971 --> 00:31:34.352
Exactly.

669
00:31:34.392 --> 00:31:37.816
Like, the most of the stuff that's in there is like your DNA.

670
00:31:37.876 --> 00:31:38.997
It's what you're looking for.

671
00:31:39.077 --> 00:31:39.958
It's what you're looking for.

672
00:31:40.278 --> 00:31:42.101
So he used that and he showed that...

673
00:31:42.121 --> 00:31:42.361
I love that.

674
00:31:42.381 --> 00:31:43.983
You know, with humans, the...

675
00:31:45.079 --> 00:31:46.999
The A and T's were about 35%.

676
00:31:47.139 --> 00:31:47.480
Yeah.

677
00:31:47.960 --> 00:31:49.320
And the C and G's were the rest.

678
00:31:49.780 --> 00:31:53.441
And then when he looked at, let's say, cows, he found a different ratio.

679
00:31:54.101 --> 00:31:56.202
And with pigs, he found a different ratio.

680
00:31:56.542 --> 00:31:59.082
But the ratios always came in these pairs.

681
00:31:59.242 --> 00:32:03.683
So the point is A and C's, A and T's like to hang out.

682
00:32:04.043 --> 00:32:05.904
And C's and G's like to hang out.

683
00:32:05.984 --> 00:32:07.684
And that's true across species.

684
00:32:07.744 --> 00:32:08.264
Across species.

685
00:32:08.404 --> 00:32:09.545
The numbers could be different.

686
00:32:09.565 --> 00:32:11.525
The proportion of it is a little different.

687
00:32:11.545 --> 00:32:11.805
Yeah.

688
00:32:11.925 --> 00:32:14.206
But in everything, the A and T's...

689
00:32:15.627 --> 00:32:22.262
are hanging out and the season season which is like another level of

690
00:32:23.733 --> 00:32:24.673
of fidelity.

691
00:32:24.713 --> 00:32:24.894
Yes.

692
00:32:24.914 --> 00:32:25.474
That we're going down.

693
00:32:25.494 --> 00:32:25.734
Yes.

694
00:32:26.135 --> 00:32:28.957
So we're getting clues into what DNA is, right?

695
00:32:29.057 --> 00:32:29.217
Right.

696
00:32:29.258 --> 00:32:31.720
We're getting slowly, we're honing down into this.

697
00:32:31.760 --> 00:32:38.186
These are called Chargass rules, which is the A equals the T, the C equals the G, and they all add up to 100%.

698
00:32:38.526 --> 00:32:45.712
Everything we have today is building off of the shoulders of the people who came before, who asked maybe simpler questions.

699
00:32:45.732 --> 00:32:45.852
Yeah.

700
00:32:45.872 --> 00:32:46.053
Yeah.

701
00:32:47.182 --> 00:32:51.369
figured out the simpler question that allowed us to ask now more complex questions.

702
00:32:51.409 --> 00:32:51.649
Yes.

703
00:32:52.190 --> 00:32:52.811
Yes, exactly.

704
00:32:52.831 --> 00:32:54.594
And we're kind of going through an example of that journey.

705
00:32:54.634 --> 00:32:54.854
Yeah.

706
00:32:54.914 --> 00:33:00.303
And I, I, that's why I love this story is like, it's really building up this, this,

707
00:33:01.213 --> 00:33:02.574
you know, crown jewel, right?

708
00:33:02.855 --> 00:33:04.496
It's not, it's not just randomly.

709
00:33:04.516 --> 00:33:07.319
These guys came up with, they didn't walk into a cave and find it.

710
00:33:07.359 --> 00:33:07.639
Yeah.

711
00:33:07.759 --> 00:33:09.040
They had to be crafted.

712
00:33:09.160 --> 00:33:10.762
There were, there were a bunch of people.

713
00:33:10.802 --> 00:33:13.785
There was an entire community trying to figure this out.

714
00:33:13.805 --> 00:33:13.985
Right.

715
00:33:14.245 --> 00:33:15.766
And maybe these guys just got lucky.

716
00:33:15.927 --> 00:33:16.127
Right.

717
00:33:16.247 --> 00:33:16.888
You know, right.

718
00:33:17.068 --> 00:33:18.009
Look, that happens.

719
00:33:18.329 --> 00:33:18.749
It happens.

720
00:33:18.949 --> 00:33:23.353
And now after all that, we get to the setting of the story.

721
00:33:23.594 --> 00:33:24.715
After all that.

722
00:33:25.596 --> 00:33:26.036
1951, England.

723
00:33:27.966 --> 00:33:30.507
Oh, so what's great is we were in Liverpool.

724
00:33:31.847 --> 00:33:32.527
Speaking of Scouts.

725
00:33:32.547 --> 00:33:33.527
We were in Liverpool.

726
00:33:33.567 --> 00:33:35.028
We were in Columbia.

727
00:33:35.368 --> 00:33:40.029
We were in Rockefeller Institute in Manhattan.

728
00:33:40.469 --> 00:33:44.530
And now we're finally getting to where the room where it happens.

729
00:33:44.570 --> 00:33:45.370
The room where it happens.

730
00:33:45.390 --> 00:33:46.970
There's two rooms where it happens, it turns out.

731
00:33:47.451 --> 00:33:51.572
In the Cavendish Lab, which is the physics department of Cambridge University.

732
00:33:52.212 --> 00:33:53.532
And King's College London.

733
00:33:53.912 --> 00:33:55.412
I'm feeling a little Cavendish right now.

734
00:33:56.473 --> 00:33:57.113
I don't know.

735
00:33:58.373 --> 00:34:01.756
Yeah, but those are the two rooms where it happens, okay?

736
00:34:01.776 --> 00:34:04.619
The Cavendish Lab, which is a storied lab.

737
00:34:05.359 --> 00:34:10.604
It's where all sorts of stuff have happened, right?

738
00:34:10.624 --> 00:34:10.924
J.D.

739
00:34:10.944 --> 00:34:13.086
Thompson discovered the electron.

740
00:34:13.446 --> 00:34:20.712
This is the crucible of experimental physics before America took over post-war, okay?

741
00:34:21.092 --> 00:34:24.535
And this is actually one of the last big things that they did.

742
00:34:25.776 --> 00:34:26.096
Tough.

743
00:34:26.397 --> 00:34:26.677
But...

744
00:34:27.721 --> 00:34:28.462
It's good.

745
00:34:28.562 --> 00:34:30.683
They had a good run while they were at it.

746
00:34:30.703 --> 00:34:33.884
And look, we appreciate the work that was done.

747
00:34:33.904 --> 00:34:34.265
Oh, yeah.

748
00:34:34.325 --> 00:34:35.265
Incredible work.

749
00:34:35.385 --> 00:34:43.689
And one day when this podcast is big, I want to go there and record and show the room where it happens.

750
00:34:43.749 --> 00:34:46.771
Because they still have the old Cavendish Lab there.

751
00:34:47.031 --> 00:34:52.554
They have a new building now in Cambridge that is off campus that has all of the big facilities, obviously.

752
00:34:52.594 --> 00:34:54.315
And Cavendish Lab in Cambridge, don't get me wrong.

753
00:34:54.595 --> 00:35:01.437
Okay, Cavendish Lab in Cambridge is still one of the foremost institutions for experimental physics research, right?

754
00:35:01.697 --> 00:35:09.880
But the old building, which is in the center of town, in like the old Gothic architecture, I mean, you can't beat that.

755
00:35:09.900 --> 00:35:10.400
You can't beat it.

756
00:35:10.460 --> 00:35:13.681
It's kind of like the Frisk Campus Center at Princeton, right?

757
00:35:13.941 --> 00:35:17.763
Frisk Campus Center, there it says Palmer Physics Lab, and you've got –

758
00:35:19.164 --> 00:35:26.254
You've got these statues of Benjamin Franklin and Joseph Henry, which are some of the founders of American physics.

759
00:35:26.535 --> 00:35:32.063
You can't beat the building where Einstein had an office.

760
00:35:32.103 --> 00:35:33.785
Now we've got Jadwin Hall, which is...

761
00:35:34.406 --> 00:35:58.023
might i just say the most depressing piece of architecture on princeton campus built in the 1960s brutalist architecture i saw the brutalist it's a fine movie the architecture is absolute trash can i just say i it is when you look at it because there's a lot of beautiful amazing things to look at on princeton's campus yeah no and jack and hall is not one of them it's pretty depressing no it's it's awful

762
00:35:58.383 --> 00:36:00.165
Yeah, but it does its job.

763
00:36:00.425 --> 00:36:03.248
It does its job, and it's still pumping out amazing research.

764
00:36:03.308 --> 00:36:05.070
Look, and Nobel Prize winners.

765
00:36:05.110 --> 00:36:06.371
Yeah, yeah, all the time.

766
00:36:06.451 --> 00:36:10.995
So anyways, let's get back to Cavendish Lab and King's College.

767
00:36:11.075 --> 00:36:13.197
These are the two rooms where it happens, okay?

768
00:36:13.858 --> 00:36:16.260
We're first actually going to run into Rosalind Franklin.

769
00:36:16.521 --> 00:36:16.701
Okay.

770
00:36:17.722 --> 00:36:21.626
Rosalind Franklin is this young PhD right out of Paris, who's a young PhD.

771
00:36:23.290 --> 00:36:32.192
She joins John Randall's group at the MRC, which is the Medical Research Council, the biophysics unit at King's College.

772
00:36:32.392 --> 00:36:32.552
Okay.

773
00:36:32.572 --> 00:36:32.853
Okay.

774
00:36:33.553 --> 00:36:37.594
And Randall writes to her and assigns her responsibility for the DNA project.

775
00:36:39.614 --> 00:36:47.476
But he does not clearly inform the guy who he already has on staff, Maurice Wilkins, that he's doing this.

776
00:36:48.117 --> 00:36:48.217
Oh.

777
00:36:48.397 --> 00:36:49.497
So Maurice Wilkins...

778
00:36:51.267 --> 00:36:55.520
thinks that Rosalind Franklin is joining as kind of a lab assistant.

779
00:36:56.262 --> 00:36:56.744
Here we go.

780
00:36:57.679 --> 00:37:03.463
But Randall has explicitly wrote in a letter to Rosalind Franklin that, no, you're going to have your own lab.

781
00:37:04.263 --> 00:37:09.006
She's been doing a lot of X-ray crystallography, which we're going to get into, in Paris.

782
00:37:09.466 --> 00:37:16.571
She's been actually investigating the structure of coal using X-rays and trying to figure out the crystalline properties of coal.

783
00:37:17.631 --> 00:37:26.157
There's a miscommunication there happening from the head of the lab, John Randall, and that seeds years of personal tension between Maurice Wilkins and...

784
00:37:26.717 --> 00:37:27.738
and Rosalind Franklin.

785
00:37:27.838 --> 00:37:31.399
These are two players at King's College in London.

786
00:37:31.579 --> 00:37:33.440
Maurice is like, I'm here.

787
00:37:33.660 --> 00:37:34.601
Oh, you're bringing someone new?

788
00:37:34.781 --> 00:37:36.042
They're my executive assistant.

789
00:37:36.062 --> 00:37:37.582
They're going to help me take out the trash.

790
00:37:37.622 --> 00:37:37.923
Yeah.

791
00:37:38.443 --> 00:37:39.003
Give me coffee.

792
00:37:39.083 --> 00:37:39.543
Yeah, yeah.

793
00:37:39.663 --> 00:37:43.345
If I'm going to be like, I need this particular scan done, they're going to do it.

794
00:37:43.385 --> 00:37:44.346
They're not really going to have...

795
00:37:45.086 --> 00:37:49.411
the intellectual autonomy that is required for a true scientist.

796
00:37:49.431 --> 00:37:49.772
Right, right.

797
00:37:50.132 --> 00:37:53.636
They're not going to be smart enough and they're not going to have agency was Maurice's viewpoint.

798
00:37:53.917 --> 00:37:54.157
Yeah.

799
00:37:54.497 --> 00:37:56.380
But Randall was like, no, no, no, no, no.

800
00:37:56.860 --> 00:38:00.364
Like, you're going to... You're at equal level.

801
00:38:00.384 --> 00:38:00.825
Yeah, right.

802
00:38:01.005 --> 00:38:02.127
But he didn't tell Maurice.

803
00:38:02.147 --> 00:38:02.527
Oh, that's right.

804
00:38:04.032 --> 00:38:04.332
You know?

805
00:38:04.753 --> 00:38:07.155
And obviously that's going to cause issues.

806
00:38:07.215 --> 00:38:07.995
100%.

807
00:38:08.156 --> 00:38:08.376
Right?

808
00:38:08.616 --> 00:38:10.678
Especially because, like, Rosalind Franklin is a woman.

809
00:38:10.718 --> 00:38:13.800
So, like, it's like she's coming in.

810
00:38:13.941 --> 00:38:16.463
At the time she's coming in, it's like, oh, this is my secretary.

811
00:38:16.483 --> 00:38:16.803
Right?

812
00:38:17.630 --> 00:38:23.875
This is actually in the same era, maybe a little bit earlier, as Mad Men, the TV show.

813
00:38:23.915 --> 00:38:24.896
No, no, exactly.

814
00:38:25.196 --> 00:38:26.437
Just in terms of context.

815
00:38:26.457 --> 00:38:28.179
Yeah, it's the same dynamic, right?

816
00:38:28.519 --> 00:38:29.820
There's a new person that comes in.

817
00:38:30.160 --> 00:38:40.108
She's really good at what she does, but no one's taking her seriously, least of all Maurice Wilkins, because he didn't get the memo that this is someone that you need to take seriously as an equal.

818
00:38:40.288 --> 00:38:40.469
Right.

819
00:38:40.729 --> 00:38:40.949
Right.

820
00:38:41.029 --> 00:38:41.209
Right.

821
00:38:41.569 --> 00:38:41.830
Right.

822
00:38:42.750 --> 00:38:46.651
So at the time, they both get into King's College.

823
00:38:46.831 --> 00:38:48.392
Maurice Wilkins is already there.

824
00:38:48.492 --> 00:38:49.732
He's established there.

825
00:38:50.332 --> 00:38:52.153
Rosalind Franklin is a new researcher.

826
00:38:53.713 --> 00:38:55.734
And they start researching DNA.

827
00:38:56.434 --> 00:39:00.095
They get these samples from Rudolf Signer in Austria.

828
00:39:00.715 --> 00:39:03.296
And this guy, Rudolf Signer, is...

829
00:39:04.825 --> 00:39:08.046
An incredible DNA experimentalist.

830
00:39:08.706 --> 00:39:13.188
And what he's really good at is getting pure samples of DNA.

831
00:39:13.468 --> 00:39:13.708
Okay.

832
00:39:13.828 --> 00:39:14.589
Okay.

833
00:39:14.609 --> 00:39:20.551
And we've got pure samples of DNA that are coming in from this guy all the way from Austria.

834
00:39:20.811 --> 00:39:21.011
Okay.

835
00:39:21.191 --> 00:39:21.391
Right?

836
00:39:23.053 --> 00:39:30.000
They're originally obtained by Wilkins, but now because Rosen and Franklin is kind of this equal player, she's getting samples too.

837
00:39:30.660 --> 00:39:34.564
And these are very precious because it's really hard to extract DNA.

838
00:39:34.944 --> 00:39:37.947
Signer's found some secret formula to do it.

839
00:39:38.067 --> 00:39:39.609
He found the Krabby Patty secret formula.

840
00:39:39.629 --> 00:39:40.289
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

841
00:39:40.329 --> 00:39:43.993
And he's not telling anyone how he does it, but he's like, I'll give you my samples.

842
00:39:44.413 --> 00:39:47.254
Just like, you know, cite me in your paper.

843
00:39:47.474 --> 00:39:48.594
A little quid pro quo.

844
00:39:48.634 --> 00:39:49.854
Yeah, yeah.

845
00:39:49.994 --> 00:39:50.695
And then we'll do it.

846
00:39:51.235 --> 00:39:56.696
So Rosalind Franklin, she's incredible at x-ray crystallography, which is taking pictures with x-rays.

847
00:39:56.876 --> 00:39:57.096
Yes.

848
00:39:58.056 --> 00:40:04.858
She builds her own camera apparatus, and she starts doing humidity-controlled photographs of DNA.

849
00:40:04.938 --> 00:40:05.198
Okay.

850
00:40:05.398 --> 00:40:10.079
And she actually starts creating the best pictures there are ever of DNA.

851
00:40:10.139 --> 00:40:11.220
Morris, eat your heart out.

852
00:40:11.740 --> 00:40:12.240
Yeah.

853
00:40:13.300 --> 00:40:14.762
Rosalind Franklin is just incredible.

854
00:40:15.122 --> 00:40:20.807
Her and her PhD student, Raymond Gosling, are just incredible at taking pictures of DNA.

855
00:40:20.927 --> 00:40:22.708
Ryan Gosling, no relation?

856
00:40:22.808 --> 00:40:23.349
No relation.

857
00:40:23.489 --> 00:40:23.949
Oh, maybe.

858
00:40:24.029 --> 00:40:24.430
I don't know.

859
00:40:24.890 --> 00:40:28.553
But in this case, Raymond Gosling is learning from Rosalind Franklin.

860
00:40:28.753 --> 00:40:30.935
So she has an underling, right?

861
00:40:31.135 --> 00:40:32.877
And they're coming in and they're just crushing.

862
00:40:32.957 --> 00:40:33.717
They're just crushing.

863
00:40:33.777 --> 00:40:38.722
Crushing the high quality capture using x-ray crystallography of DNA.

864
00:40:38.802 --> 00:40:39.482
And it's just like...

865
00:40:40.443 --> 00:40:45.805
Yeah, and the personalities are crashing because Rosalind Franklin is very, you know, she's a woman in science.

866
00:40:45.825 --> 00:40:48.726
And at the time, you got to be confrontational.

867
00:40:48.786 --> 00:40:49.546
Yeah, you got to be tough.

868
00:40:49.606 --> 00:40:50.287
You got to be tough.

869
00:40:50.307 --> 00:40:50.787
You got to be tough.

870
00:40:50.807 --> 00:40:53.748
Maurice Wilkins is this really shy guy, you know.

871
00:40:54.108 --> 00:40:55.989
And so even personalities are crashing.

872
00:40:56.009 --> 00:40:57.349
And he always got what he wanted in his life.

873
00:40:57.369 --> 00:40:57.749
Yeah, yeah.

874
00:40:57.769 --> 00:40:58.430
And now all of a sudden.

875
00:40:58.470 --> 00:41:02.771
Because of being smart and all of a sudden this tough, you know, charismatic, you know, attitude.

876
00:41:02.791 --> 00:41:03.572
He doesn't know what to do.

877
00:41:03.752 --> 00:41:04.232
Exactly.

878
00:41:04.272 --> 00:41:04.512
Yeah.

879
00:41:04.912 --> 00:41:08.317
Okay, so that's the situation at King's College in London.

880
00:41:08.577 --> 00:41:08.958
Understood.

881
00:41:08.998 --> 00:41:11.261
Now let's go to Cambridge in the Cavendish lab.

882
00:41:11.521 --> 00:41:12.462
Again, we're in 1951.

883
00:41:12.482 --> 00:41:12.703
Mm-hmm.

884
00:41:14.483 --> 00:41:17.104
These are happening simultaneously.

885
00:41:17.484 --> 00:41:21.486
Simultaneously, James Watson moves there to Cavendish Lab.

886
00:41:21.807 --> 00:41:24.268
He had just come out of a PhD in Chicago.

887
00:41:24.288 --> 00:41:26.269
He had done a postdoc at Copenhagen.

888
00:41:26.549 --> 00:41:29.070
And there in Cavendish Lab, he meets Francis Crick.

889
00:41:29.210 --> 00:41:33.953
At the time, the Cavendish Lab, the director was Lawrence Bragg.

890
00:41:34.573 --> 00:41:40.416
Lawrence Bragg is very famous for being the youngest Nobel Prize winner of all time in the sciences.

891
00:41:40.576 --> 00:41:41.056
In the sciences.

892
00:41:41.156 --> 00:41:42.076
In the sciences, right?

893
00:41:42.297 --> 00:41:42.877
He won...

894
00:41:44.364 --> 00:41:49.248
In 1915, at the age of 25, that's unreal.

895
00:41:49.348 --> 00:41:49.728
Unreal.

896
00:41:49.968 --> 00:41:50.368
Physics.

897
00:41:50.388 --> 00:41:52.630
That's... Physics.

898
00:41:52.890 --> 00:41:55.512
Yeah, this is a really, really interesting story, okay?

899
00:41:55.872 --> 00:41:58.274
So he won it with his dad, William Bragg.

900
00:41:58.915 --> 00:42:02.437
William Bragg and Lawrence Bragg won it together.

901
00:42:02.657 --> 00:42:03.498
That's crazy.

902
00:42:03.558 --> 00:42:03.838
Okay?

903
00:42:04.078 --> 00:42:04.959
They're also the only...

904
00:42:04.979 --> 00:42:07.381
They're the only LeBron, Bronny, James...

905
00:42:07.541 --> 00:42:09.162
Yeah, to win at the same time.

906
00:42:09.243 --> 00:42:12.465
Niels Bohr and Niels Bohr's son also won, but at separate.

907
00:42:12.746 --> 00:42:13.286
At separate times.

908
00:42:13.366 --> 00:42:13.987
At separate times.

909
00:42:14.007 --> 00:42:14.507
That doesn't matter.

910
00:42:14.747 --> 00:42:17.049
This is the same prize going to father and son duo.

911
00:42:17.069 --> 00:42:18.971
We have a bunch of NBA players who have sons that play.

912
00:42:18.991 --> 00:42:19.091
Yeah.

913
00:42:19.111 --> 00:42:19.812
No one cares about that.

914
00:42:19.832 --> 00:42:20.292
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

915
00:42:20.312 --> 00:42:23.575
But you play on the same team at the same time?

916
00:42:23.815 --> 00:42:24.656
Yeah.

917
00:42:24.736 --> 00:42:26.277
So this is William and Lawrence Bragg.

918
00:42:26.517 --> 00:42:27.298
That's cool.

919
00:42:27.378 --> 00:42:30.441
They won for developing X-ray crystallography.

920
00:42:31.487 --> 00:42:38.352
Basically, the idea of X-ray crystallography is you've got some crystal, let's say, which is a bunch of electron density maps, right?

921
00:42:38.592 --> 00:42:42.074
You've got electron densities here and here and here where the atoms are.

922
00:42:42.515 --> 00:42:43.596
An X-ray comes in.

923
00:42:43.916 --> 00:42:50.420
Remember, the X-ray has a wavelength that is about the size of the atomic spacing, about one angstrom.

924
00:42:50.801 --> 00:42:59.287
So what you can do is when the X-ray interacts with that crystal, it's going to constructively interfere and destructively interfere, meaning it's going to add up

925
00:42:59.927 --> 00:43:00.989
and it's going to cancel out.

926
00:43:01.430 --> 00:43:05.097
So at certain angles, it's going to add up, and you're going to get a bright spot.

927
00:43:05.217 --> 00:43:09.565
At other angles, it's going to cancel out, and you're going to get nothing, right?

928
00:43:10.486 --> 00:43:12.129
By looking at the angles...

929
00:43:13.492 --> 00:43:16.855
Of where stuff adds up and where stuff cancels out.

930
00:43:18.077 --> 00:43:22.801
You know, by looking at the angle, what I mean is you can rotate this crystal and keep shooting x-rays.

931
00:43:22.821 --> 00:43:23.122
Right, right.

932
00:43:23.162 --> 00:43:24.843
So I'm shooting a beam.

933
00:43:25.164 --> 00:43:25.604
A beam.

934
00:43:25.924 --> 00:43:26.445
Of x-rays.

935
00:43:26.465 --> 00:43:27.025
Of x-rays.

936
00:43:27.546 --> 00:43:28.147
At a crystal.

937
00:43:29.067 --> 00:43:31.830
And then it's going to go through that crystal.

938
00:43:31.870 --> 00:43:33.112
And on the other side.

939
00:43:33.372 --> 00:43:34.473
I have a photographic plate.

940
00:43:34.613 --> 00:43:36.034
I have something that I'm going to track.

941
00:43:36.867 --> 00:43:43.888
And I can move the crystal around, and I'm going to get a different map based on how.

942
00:43:44.128 --> 00:43:52.390
And that map allows me to actually then reconstruct what the crystal is, even though the map is like a 2D structure.

943
00:43:52.750 --> 00:43:55.410
But because I rotate, and then I can reverse engineer.

944
00:43:55.450 --> 00:43:56.510
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

945
00:43:57.211 --> 00:44:04.832
In technical terms, you're getting a kind of Fourier transform in frequency space of like what frequencies at what angles are doing what.

946
00:44:05.252 --> 00:44:07.933
And then from that, I can then back calculate.

947
00:44:08.013 --> 00:44:08.233
Right.

948
00:44:08.293 --> 00:44:09.014
Right.

949
00:44:09.374 --> 00:44:11.855
And the funny thing about this, right?

950
00:44:12.075 --> 00:44:16.937
You think Lawrence Bragg and William Bragg, father-son duo, sounds like Nepo baby.

951
00:44:17.097 --> 00:44:17.477
Yeah.

952
00:44:17.837 --> 00:44:19.318
Sounds like a Nepo baby, right?

953
00:44:20.058 --> 00:44:24.600
Lawrence Bragg, who's the son, is actually the guy who came up with this technique.

954
00:44:25.240 --> 00:44:26.721
No way.

955
00:44:26.741 --> 00:44:27.661
Yeah.

956
00:44:27.701 --> 00:44:33.845
His dad, William Bragg, was in charge of the lab at the time, and he set up the experimental apparatus.

957
00:44:33.905 --> 00:44:37.486
But Lawrence Bragg is the guy who came up with the mathematics and the equations for it.

958
00:44:37.526 --> 00:44:38.547
That's incredible.

959
00:44:38.567 --> 00:44:50.493
And when his dad, William Bragg, reported their results at the meetings and in a paper, he gives credit to his unnamed son saying that this person...

960
00:44:51.721 --> 00:44:56.703
My son came up with the equation, but the son is not a co-author on the paper.

961
00:44:57.864 --> 00:45:02.205
And this is something that, like, Lawrence Bragg had to deal with for the rest of his life.

962
00:45:02.245 --> 00:45:04.886
It was kind of like a trauma that he got from his dad.

963
00:45:04.986 --> 00:45:06.367
No way, bro.

964
00:45:06.387 --> 00:45:07.207
You're telling me.

965
00:45:07.247 --> 00:45:07.848
Dude, it wasn't.

966
00:45:07.968 --> 00:45:08.748
Yeah, dude, this is.

967
00:45:09.088 --> 00:45:10.489
He's not a Nepo baby.

968
00:45:11.089 --> 00:45:13.070
The dad is a Nepo dad.

969
00:45:13.210 --> 00:45:14.170
You know who this is?

970
00:45:14.370 --> 00:45:19.532
There's a viral story right now about Simon Cowell, the, like, judge from American Idol or whatever.

971
00:45:19.553 --> 00:45:20.253
Yeah, yeah, yeah, of course.

972
00:45:20.953 --> 00:45:29.481
he's come out in public in the last two weeks and said, my son is going to get none of my whatever, $500 million empire.

973
00:45:29.942 --> 00:45:30.262
Zero.

974
00:45:30.743 --> 00:45:33.726
All my money is going to go to charity, and he's going to have to figure it out.

975
00:45:34.286 --> 00:45:40.092
And it's not quite the perfect analogy, but the dad basically took the son's work and was like, oh,

976
00:45:41.488 --> 00:45:43.049
I guess I'm the only named person.

977
00:45:43.069 --> 00:45:43.329
Yeah.

978
00:45:43.629 --> 00:45:44.329
Oh, that's nice.

979
00:45:44.430 --> 00:45:45.230
That's convenient.

980
00:45:45.250 --> 00:45:45.570
Yeah.

981
00:45:45.670 --> 00:45:52.353
I mean, I wouldn't say that because with the Simon thing, at least Simon is the guy who like did the thing.

982
00:45:52.494 --> 00:45:52.914
The thing.

983
00:45:52.954 --> 00:45:53.474
He did the thing.

984
00:45:53.494 --> 00:45:56.956
This is Lawrence Bragg actually came up with x-ray crystallography.

985
00:45:57.016 --> 00:45:57.616
His kids work.

986
00:45:57.676 --> 00:45:58.977
He put it in the paper and said, ah.

987
00:46:00.257 --> 00:46:00.918
My name's on it.

988
00:46:00.978 --> 00:46:01.238
Yeah.

989
00:46:01.618 --> 00:46:01.778
Yeah.

990
00:46:02.038 --> 00:46:03.299
He wasn't even a co-author.

991
00:46:04.000 --> 00:46:05.481
They both got the Nobel Prize.

992
00:46:06.061 --> 00:46:10.084
But to be honest, only the son should have gotten the Nobel Prize.

993
00:46:10.265 --> 00:46:12.206
The dad just had this name on the building.

994
00:46:12.346 --> 00:46:12.666
Yeah.

995
00:46:13.207 --> 00:46:14.148
He just had the facilities.

996
00:46:14.168 --> 00:46:14.288
Yeah.

997
00:46:14.308 --> 00:46:15.348
So he was a Nepo dad.

998
00:46:15.468 --> 00:46:17.450
I don't think you have the facilities from that brother.

999
00:46:17.530 --> 00:46:21.132
At this point, Lawrence Bragg is clearly extremely talented.

1000
00:46:21.192 --> 00:46:25.653
And at this point, he is the director of the Cavendish Lab for good reason.

1001
00:46:25.813 --> 00:46:27.414
At 25, he wins a Nobel Prize.

1002
00:46:27.454 --> 00:46:28.515
He's astute.

1003
00:46:28.955 --> 00:46:37.278
And he wants – he's been using the Cavendish Lab to create X-ray crystallography of a bunch of crystals.

1004
00:46:37.618 --> 00:46:43.461
They're just getting into biological compounds, creating protein crystals, and finding the structure of those.

1005
00:46:44.814 --> 00:46:45.715
He really wants this.

1006
00:46:46.375 --> 00:46:51.718
He really wants the DNA structure to be in England.

1007
00:46:52.159 --> 00:46:52.439
Okay?

1008
00:46:52.539 --> 00:46:52.739
Okay.

1009
00:46:52.959 --> 00:46:53.600
In Cavendish.

1010
00:46:53.760 --> 00:46:54.000
Okay?

1011
00:46:54.120 --> 00:46:54.380
Okay.

1012
00:46:54.540 --> 00:46:55.061
Okay.

1013
00:46:55.081 --> 00:46:55.661
I see what you're doing.

1014
00:46:55.881 --> 00:46:56.081
Right?

1015
00:46:56.221 --> 00:46:57.102
I see what you're doing.

1016
00:46:57.122 --> 00:46:59.443
And now, so he hires Francis Crick.

1017
00:46:59.483 --> 00:47:00.744
Francis Crick is a physicist.

1018
00:47:01.044 --> 00:47:07.148
And at the time, Francis Crick, he starts studying with a bunch of other colleagues at the time.

1019
00:47:07.849 --> 00:47:10.971
He starts studying just extra crystallography in general.

1020
00:47:11.471 --> 00:47:14.153
And he's asking, what would extra crystallography look like?

1021
00:47:14.173 --> 00:47:14.373
Yeah.

1022
00:47:15.327 --> 00:47:16.989
for different types of molecules.

1023
00:47:17.489 --> 00:47:23.054
Specifically, he's trying to ask, what would a helical molecule look like in an x-ray photograph?

1024
00:47:23.074 --> 00:47:24.336
Helical meaning helix?

1025
00:47:24.536 --> 00:47:25.957
Helix meaning a spiral.

1026
00:47:26.538 --> 00:47:29.661
A spiral molecule, I subject it to x-rays.

1027
00:47:29.721 --> 00:47:30.642
What is it going to look like?

1028
00:47:31.102 --> 00:47:38.106
He comes up with the Cochran Crick Vand theory with his two colleagues in 1952, and he publishes this paper.

1029
00:47:38.506 --> 00:47:46.150
And what it shows is that the scattering amplitude, like where the dark spots and the light spots should be, they should come up in X.

1030
00:47:47.090 --> 00:47:48.371
They should have these spots.

1031
00:47:48.731 --> 00:47:48.891
Mm-hmm.

1032
00:47:49.833 --> 00:47:53.837
And they should have the cross shape as a signature of a helix.

1033
00:47:54.318 --> 00:47:59.704
The angle of the cross tells you what the pitch of the angle is of that helix, right?

1034
00:48:00.044 --> 00:48:00.725
And things like that.

1035
00:48:00.825 --> 00:48:05.250
So they came up with a formula for if you're looking at a helix object.

1036
00:48:05.350 --> 00:48:05.790
Yeah.

1037
00:48:06.011 --> 00:48:07.733
And I have the photograph from the x-ray.

1038
00:48:08.253 --> 00:48:11.435
What would that tell me about the structure of the helical object?

1039
00:48:11.455 --> 00:48:11.815
Got it.

1040
00:48:11.915 --> 00:48:21.582
It's kind of like a dictionary or like a translation between a results list and what is the interpretable meaning of the raw results.

1041
00:48:22.162 --> 00:48:22.602
Exactly.

1042
00:48:23.103 --> 00:48:33.089
So Watson at this time moves there after a PhD in Chicago, postdoc in Copenhagen, and he strikes up an immediate friendship with Francis Crick.

1043
00:48:33.169 --> 00:48:35.931
They think very alike in terms of these words.

1044
00:48:36.840 --> 00:48:37.801
scientific problems.

1045
00:48:38.021 --> 00:48:39.342
They're very much alike, okay?

1046
00:48:39.602 --> 00:48:43.225
So they start working on the DNA structure with whatever information that they have.

1047
00:48:43.425 --> 00:48:46.588
We're going to need a photo like that on Princeton's campus in black and white.

1048
00:48:46.748 --> 00:48:46.948
Yeah.

1049
00:48:47.128 --> 00:48:48.509
In the whole... Easy.

1050
00:48:48.529 --> 00:48:50.290
We're going to need one of those.

1051
00:48:50.311 --> 00:48:51.692
Yeah, we're definitely going to need one.

1052
00:48:52.032 --> 00:48:52.973
Yeah.

1053
00:48:53.513 --> 00:48:58.297
So this is sort of setting up that situation, right?

1054
00:48:58.437 --> 00:49:05.903
Cavendish versus... Cavendish, you've got these theorists and these X-ray crystallographers that are trying to figure out what an X-ray crystall...

1055
00:49:06.523 --> 00:49:11.777
picture would look like and then in king's college london they're the guys that are actually taking the photos right right

1056
00:49:12.585 --> 00:49:19.727
Okay, so you have the people taking the pictures, and then you have the people creating the framework for the interpretation of the pictures.

1057
00:49:19.827 --> 00:49:20.047
Yes.

1058
00:49:20.368 --> 00:49:21.648
And they're both kind of cooking.

1059
00:49:21.868 --> 00:49:23.069
They're both kind of cooking, right?

1060
00:49:23.089 --> 00:49:23.589
At the same time.

1061
00:49:23.649 --> 00:49:26.810
Yes, and they're cooking at the same time, and they're kind of competing against each other.

1062
00:49:26.830 --> 00:49:29.071
Because they want to be, each one wants to be first.

1063
00:49:29.091 --> 00:49:29.811
For the whole thing.

1064
00:49:29.991 --> 00:49:32.092
They realize what this is.

1065
00:49:32.232 --> 00:49:33.372
Right, yeah.

1066
00:49:33.672 --> 00:49:34.812
Everyone knows what this is.

1067
00:49:34.852 --> 00:49:36.173
The treasure map was already created.

1068
00:49:36.193 --> 00:49:36.473
Yes.

1069
00:49:36.893 --> 00:49:38.254
They know that there's a city of gold.

1070
00:49:38.354 --> 00:49:40.534
Yes, yes, and they're trying to find it, right?

1071
00:49:41.235 --> 00:49:42.195
Franklin and Gosling.

1072
00:49:43.014 --> 00:49:45.256
Now we're back in King's College, London.

1073
00:49:46.176 --> 00:49:51.420
What they figure out is there's actually two different types of DNA in the sample that they got.

1074
00:49:51.460 --> 00:49:51.740
Okay.

1075
00:49:52.060 --> 00:49:52.301
Okay?

1076
00:49:52.681 --> 00:49:54.902
There's A-DNA and B-DNA.

1077
00:49:55.223 --> 00:49:57.785
And it has to do with two different types of humidity.

1078
00:49:58.465 --> 00:49:59.966
Okay?

1079
00:50:00.186 --> 00:50:03.389
Something that's super dehydrated is called A-DNA.

1080
00:50:03.789 --> 00:50:06.130
And that's what Rosalind Franklin was really after.

1081
00:50:06.651 --> 00:50:10.554
And then there's something that has a bunch of humidity, a bunch of water molecules there.

1082
00:50:10.974 --> 00:50:11.815
And that's the B-DNA.

1083
00:50:11.835 --> 00:50:12.115
Correct.

1084
00:50:12.595 --> 00:50:14.356
The way they're doing this is actually incredible.

1085
00:50:14.376 --> 00:50:18.538
They take single bits of DNA, like strings, okay?

1086
00:50:18.838 --> 00:50:23.320
And they pull these wires like spider webs.

1087
00:50:24.101 --> 00:50:26.001
And they put it in front of their x-ray machine.

1088
00:50:27.582 --> 00:50:29.563
And they take photographs with the x-ray machine.

1089
00:50:30.003 --> 00:50:32.705
And the exposures are something like 60 hours.

1090
00:50:33.625 --> 00:50:34.726
They're exposing this thing.

1091
00:50:34.746 --> 00:50:36.727
Because it's a tiny little thing, right?

1092
00:50:36.747 --> 00:50:40.608
So you need a really long time exposure to capture all of that information.

1093
00:50:40.628 --> 00:50:41.169
That makes sense.

1094
00:50:41.229 --> 00:50:41.449
Right?

1095
00:50:42.336 --> 00:50:44.897
So there's two different types of DNA that they're looking at.

1096
00:50:46.198 --> 00:50:47.359
Franklin is looking at both.

1097
00:50:47.599 --> 00:50:53.522
She gives an internal talk at King's, okay, explaining that there's these two different types.

1098
00:50:53.582 --> 00:50:59.865
The phosphates, the phosphate groups that I was talking about in those building blocks, those phosphates lie on the outside.

1099
00:51:00.666 --> 00:51:04.848
And there's some kind of helical structure that they've already found because phosphates.

1100
00:51:05.398 --> 00:51:06.758
They see these X's, right?

1101
00:51:07.138 --> 00:51:09.359
The stuff that Francis Crick was talking about.

1102
00:51:09.419 --> 00:51:10.739
They've already seen these X's.

1103
00:51:10.799 --> 00:51:12.759
So they're seeing a helical form.

1104
00:51:15.580 --> 00:51:21.861
Rosalind Franklin gives a seminar in King's College where she's talking about her work.

1105
00:51:22.801 --> 00:51:26.622
James Watson is in attendance in that seminar.

1106
00:51:27.022 --> 00:51:31.143
So the point is we have someone from this block and someone from that block.

1107
00:51:31.163 --> 00:51:32.623
They're both trying to be the best.

1108
00:51:32.803 --> 00:51:33.023
Yeah.

1109
00:51:33.424 --> 00:51:37.548
And then so Franklin on her block is like, I'm going to preach the gospel.

1110
00:51:37.608 --> 00:51:37.948
Yeah.

1111
00:51:38.129 --> 00:51:39.990
I'm going to do the actual experimental work.

1112
00:51:40.211 --> 00:51:42.433
And then Watson rolls up.

1113
00:51:42.553 --> 00:51:43.194
Watson rolls up.

1114
00:51:43.474 --> 00:51:44.535
He's in the back of the seminar.

1115
00:51:44.655 --> 00:51:45.856
He's kind of peeping game.

1116
00:51:45.897 --> 00:51:47.939
He's like, what's going on over here?

1117
00:51:47.999 --> 00:51:50.121
Yeah.

1118
00:51:50.421 --> 00:51:51.462
And he goes to the seminar.

1119
00:51:51.582 --> 00:51:51.823
Okay.

1120
00:51:51.943 --> 00:51:52.964
He's extremely excited.

1121
00:51:52.984 --> 00:51:54.585
He comes back to Cavendish.

1122
00:51:54.605 --> 00:51:54.806
Yeah.

1123
00:51:54.926 --> 00:51:55.587
He goes to Crick.

1124
00:51:56.167 --> 00:51:59.009
And he's like, this is all the stuff that they were talking about in the seminar.

1125
00:51:59.289 --> 00:52:02.151
He misremembers what happened in the seminar.

1126
00:52:02.311 --> 00:52:03.872
He didn't have a voice memo.

1127
00:52:03.912 --> 00:52:07.255
No, he didn't have the chemistry background, really.

1128
00:52:07.355 --> 00:52:09.636
Oh, to understand what was going on.

1129
00:52:09.696 --> 00:52:10.537
And internalize.

1130
00:52:10.877 --> 00:52:13.979
So he tells Francis Crick about all these things.

1131
00:52:14.700 --> 00:52:15.500
They get to working.

1132
00:52:16.081 --> 00:52:17.001
They create a model.

1133
00:52:17.061 --> 00:52:20.524
And at that time, Watson and Crick were really...

1134
00:52:21.497 --> 00:52:48.740
into making lego models these are like little stick figurine models of the they're like okay this is what the purine looks like it's a hexagon with these little sticks and the and the stick represents a hydrogen and the hexagon represents carbon ring and so on and so forth so they start creating this model and they think they have a model okay it's it's a triple helix there's three strands that are going out the phosphates are on the inside because he misremembers that but he's like really excited

1135
00:52:49.400 --> 00:53:17.268
He's like, oh, this might work So the Cavendish group Called the King's London The King's College group To come on down, get your car, come on down Check it out So Rosalind Franklin rolls up Demolishes them Okay In the presence of Lawrence Bragg Who's the director of Cavendish She's like, this is wrong This is wrong, this is wrong This is just stupid Laughter

1136
00:53:19.583 --> 00:53:19.823
Right.

1137
00:53:19.983 --> 00:53:31.449
And in Watson's garbled account, they've built this three-stranded helix and the data contradicts what the model they've built.

1138
00:53:32.930 --> 00:53:34.511
Cavendish is embarrassed.

1139
00:53:35.191 --> 00:53:35.891
Embarrassed?

1140
00:53:35.951 --> 00:53:36.392
Embarrassed.

1141
00:53:36.432 --> 00:53:36.732
Okay.

1142
00:53:36.752 --> 00:53:38.393
Lawrence Bragg is like, you need to stop.

1143
00:53:40.172 --> 00:53:41.432
This is in 1951.

1144
00:53:41.532 --> 00:53:42.833
You're making us look bad?

1145
00:53:42.853 --> 00:53:43.033
Yeah.

1146
00:53:43.413 --> 00:53:43.633
Yeah.

1147
00:53:44.273 --> 00:53:44.713
Stop it.

1148
00:53:44.893 --> 00:53:45.273
Stop it.

1149
00:53:45.613 --> 00:53:47.654
So Lawrence Bragg is like, this is, no.

1150
00:53:48.334 --> 00:53:50.034
This is not what we do in Cavendish.

1151
00:53:50.074 --> 00:53:51.534
Right.

1152
00:53:51.574 --> 00:53:54.275
One of the most, like, again, one of the most legendary.

1153
00:53:54.315 --> 00:53:54.515
Yeah.

1154
00:53:54.535 --> 00:53:55.855
This guy's a legend.

1155
00:53:55.955 --> 00:53:57.436
He won the Nobel Prize at 25.

1156
00:53:57.476 --> 00:53:58.336
He's telling you to stop.

1157
00:53:58.656 --> 00:53:59.376
He's in charge.

1158
00:53:59.856 --> 00:54:00.136
Stop.

1159
00:54:00.536 --> 00:54:00.956
They stop.

1160
00:54:01.317 --> 00:54:01.577
Okay?

1161
00:54:01.657 --> 00:54:02.217
They stop.

1162
00:54:02.297 --> 00:54:03.477
In 1951, they stop.

1163
00:54:04.557 --> 00:54:05.617
This is incredible.

1164
00:54:05.717 --> 00:54:06.878
It's actually incredible.

1165
00:54:07.198 --> 00:54:07.458
Then.

1166
00:54:07.478 --> 00:54:08.178
Okay.

1167
00:54:09.877 --> 00:54:11.778
The King's College group still keeps going on.

1168
00:54:11.998 --> 00:54:13.798
They still keep collecting data.

1169
00:54:15.499 --> 00:54:21.700
In 1953, early 1953, they get wind of a guy named Linus Pauling.

1170
00:54:21.840 --> 00:54:23.000
When you say they, who?

1171
00:54:23.621 --> 00:54:25.921
This is both King's College.

1172
00:54:26.061 --> 00:54:26.721
And Cavendish.

1173
00:54:26.861 --> 00:54:27.602
And Cavendish.

1174
00:54:27.682 --> 00:54:28.202
The Brits.

1175
00:54:28.322 --> 00:54:29.162
Okay, the Brits.

1176
00:54:29.402 --> 00:54:31.422
The Brits get wind of the Americans.

1177
00:54:31.442 --> 00:54:32.423
The Americans.

1178
00:54:32.863 --> 00:54:33.223
Okay.

1179
00:54:33.963 --> 00:54:37.084
Because Linus Pauling at Caltech.

1180
00:54:37.124 --> 00:54:37.224
Yeah.

1181
00:54:37.244 --> 00:54:37.384
Yeah.

1182
00:54:38.475 --> 00:54:41.897
has just discovered the structure of the alpha helix.

1183
00:54:42.457 --> 00:54:46.940
The alpha helix is a fundamental building block of proteins.

1184
00:54:47.500 --> 00:54:47.801
Okay.

1185
00:54:48.201 --> 00:54:53.964
There's a helical structure that almost a lot of proteins have this helical structure.

1186
00:54:54.225 --> 00:54:54.425
Okay.

1187
00:54:54.445 --> 00:54:54.625
That...

1188
00:54:55.265 --> 00:55:02.070
It's called a secondary structure that is used to build the tertiary big 3D structure.

1189
00:55:02.150 --> 00:55:02.590
Okay.

1190
00:55:02.630 --> 00:55:07.834
You build a bunch of these alpha helixes together and you make whatever protein you want.

1191
00:55:08.194 --> 00:55:11.697
It's a single Lego block that makes the thing you want to make of your Lego.

1192
00:55:11.737 --> 00:55:12.237
Exactly.

1193
00:55:12.477 --> 00:55:12.957
Exactly.

1194
00:55:12.998 --> 00:55:13.758
Right?

1195
00:55:13.938 --> 00:55:19.302
And Linus Powelling comes out with this manuscript of the alpha helix.

1196
00:55:20.669 --> 00:55:25.173
He's incredibly good at chemistry, trained under Neil's board.

1197
00:55:25.393 --> 00:55:25.814
Dangerous.

1198
00:55:26.034 --> 00:55:26.654
Dangerous.

1199
00:55:26.754 --> 00:55:29.977
Everyone's sweating over him.

1200
00:55:30.117 --> 00:55:31.579
And he comes out with this.

1201
00:55:31.979 --> 00:55:35.982
The Cavendish guys are like, wow, he just scooped us because they were working on the same thing.

1202
00:55:36.082 --> 00:55:36.303
Okay.

1203
00:55:36.503 --> 00:55:36.763
Okay.

1204
00:55:37.304 --> 00:55:38.164
Okay.

1205
00:55:38.184 --> 00:55:40.126
And at the same time, in 1953...

1206
00:55:42.435 --> 00:55:46.256
Linus Pauling comes out with his version of the DNA helix.

1207
00:55:46.416 --> 00:55:46.676
Okay.

1208
00:55:47.076 --> 00:55:48.897
It is the same triple helix.

1209
00:55:48.917 --> 00:55:49.417
Triple helix.

1210
00:55:49.577 --> 00:55:50.298
Very similar.

1211
00:55:50.638 --> 00:55:55.159
This three-stranded helical structure that Watson and Crick had done that was wrong.

1212
00:55:55.299 --> 00:55:55.639
Correct.

1213
00:55:55.819 --> 00:55:56.239
Right?

1214
00:55:56.259 --> 00:55:57.500
Because he has limited data.

1215
00:55:57.560 --> 00:55:59.220
He doesn't actually know the data.

1216
00:55:59.320 --> 00:56:00.761
Because he doesn't have the source.

1217
00:56:00.821 --> 00:56:01.401
Yeah.

1218
00:56:01.481 --> 00:56:02.922
He hasn't been to King's College.

1219
00:56:03.042 --> 00:56:05.662
If he was at that seminar, he's a chemist.

1220
00:56:05.682 --> 00:56:06.143
Yeah.

1221
00:56:06.223 --> 00:56:07.303
He would have figured it out.

1222
00:56:07.743 --> 00:56:15.570
So the point is that at King's, they were getting source data because of their expertise in being able to do the x-ray crystallography.

1223
00:56:15.670 --> 00:56:16.191
Exactly.

1224
00:56:16.271 --> 00:56:20.455
And so they had basically the best map for where the treasure is.

1225
00:56:20.495 --> 00:56:20.735
Yes.

1226
00:56:21.255 --> 00:56:25.739
And Watson and Craig only were able to get to it because they were local.

1227
00:56:25.860 --> 00:56:26.360
They were local.

1228
00:56:26.380 --> 00:56:28.422
Down the road, whatever, and were able to see it.

1229
00:56:28.882 --> 00:56:31.585
Now at Caltech, Pao Ling, he...

1230
00:56:32.145 --> 00:56:36.269
He is intuiting this without having a really good map.

1231
00:56:36.329 --> 00:56:37.150
No, no.

1232
00:56:37.210 --> 00:56:39.091
He's intuiting it from published data.

1233
00:56:39.251 --> 00:56:39.672
Right, right.

1234
00:56:39.692 --> 00:56:41.473
From stuff that's already out.

1235
00:56:41.654 --> 00:56:42.494
Right, right.

1236
00:56:42.514 --> 00:56:47.058
But this is a huge red flag for everyone in Great Britain.

1237
00:56:47.078 --> 00:56:47.819
Yeah, they're like freaking out.

1238
00:56:47.839 --> 00:56:50.021
It's like, oh, no, no, no, Linus Pauling is on it.

1239
00:56:50.041 --> 00:56:51.202
Yeah, the Americans are coming.

1240
00:56:51.302 --> 00:56:54.144
We got like a few months tops.

1241
00:56:54.164 --> 00:56:54.485
Right, right.

1242
00:56:54.865 --> 00:56:56.526
We're in the final lap of this race.

1243
00:56:57.287 --> 00:56:57.567
Okay?

1244
00:56:57.967 --> 00:56:58.908
No more pit stops.

1245
00:56:59.208 --> 00:56:59.789
This is it.

1246
00:57:00.349 --> 00:57:04.292
Whatever tires we have now, we need to get to the finish.

1247
00:57:04.332 --> 00:57:08.955
Because otherwise, Linus Pauling is like Max Verstappen.

1248
00:57:09.055 --> 00:57:09.996
Yeah, he's coming.

1249
00:57:10.016 --> 00:57:10.476
He's coming.

1250
00:57:10.596 --> 00:57:13.799
And if he figures it out, he's going to figure it out very soon.

1251
00:57:14.139 --> 00:57:14.639
This guy...

1252
00:57:15.600 --> 00:57:27.523
has the credentials, trained under Niels Bohr, knows quantum mechanics, like discovered the pi bond, which is like the way in which the quantum mechanics of how atoms bond to each other.

1253
00:57:27.583 --> 00:57:29.623
Like he's done incredible work, okay?

1254
00:57:29.683 --> 00:57:31.744
This guy is dangerous.

1255
00:57:31.824 --> 00:57:34.264
If he has a little bit more information, he's going to do it.

1256
00:57:34.284 --> 00:57:35.085
He's going to do it.

1257
00:57:35.365 --> 00:57:36.085
Okay.

1258
00:57:36.245 --> 00:57:45.407
So Watson actually gets wind of this manuscript because Linus Palin's son brought an early version of the manuscript to Cambridge.

1259
00:57:47.729 --> 00:57:51.371
I love 19 or mid 20th century.

1260
00:57:51.872 --> 00:57:53.673
Yeah, because there's no online, right?

1261
00:57:53.753 --> 00:57:56.535
It's not, it's not like just, it goes on nature website.

1262
00:57:56.615 --> 00:58:05.342
And then like, so, so physically Linus Pauling's son brought the manuscript to the Cavendish folks because he knew that they were working on it too.

1263
00:58:05.362 --> 00:58:06.463
And they, they might want to see it.

1264
00:58:06.583 --> 00:58:06.743
Right.

1265
00:58:07.083 --> 00:58:11.905
Watson looks at the manuscript and he's like, okay, this guy's clearly wrong because he's doing the same mistakes that I did.

1266
00:58:12.345 --> 00:58:14.006
But this guy's Linus Pyle.

1267
00:58:14.026 --> 00:58:14.906
Yeah.

1268
00:58:14.926 --> 00:58:15.126
Okay.

1269
00:58:15.466 --> 00:58:16.247
I am concerned.

1270
00:58:16.267 --> 00:58:16.467
Yeah.

1271
00:58:16.607 --> 00:58:17.067
Yeah.

1272
00:58:17.087 --> 00:58:19.388
So he goes to King's College.

1273
00:58:19.568 --> 00:58:19.808
Okay.

1274
00:58:20.348 --> 00:58:25.050
And he tries to show the manuscript to Rosalind Franklin and Maurice Wilkins.

1275
00:58:25.070 --> 00:58:27.932
He's like, guys, we need to set our differences aside.

1276
00:58:27.952 --> 00:58:28.492
Differences aside.

1277
00:58:29.612 --> 00:58:34.697
This is like in LA, it would be like two gangs in LA in different parts, right?

1278
00:58:34.717 --> 00:58:37.719
The blood and the curse being like, look, we have a bigger enemy right now.

1279
00:58:37.899 --> 00:58:40.481
Can we just have moratorium for a moment?

1280
00:58:40.561 --> 00:58:41.982
Yeah, like New York is coming up.

1281
00:58:42.003 --> 00:58:42.663
New York is coming.

1282
00:58:43.344 --> 00:58:43.964
Yeah.

1283
00:58:44.264 --> 00:58:47.147
50 just dropped Get Rich or Die Trying.

1284
00:58:47.687 --> 00:58:49.488
Yeah, it's going to be a problem.

1285
00:58:49.588 --> 00:58:50.049
It's going to be.

1286
00:58:50.069 --> 00:58:50.269
Yeah.

1287
00:58:50.389 --> 00:58:56.473
He's hooked up with Jimmy Iovine, Eminem, and Dr. Dre.

1288
00:58:56.553 --> 00:58:57.593
Yeah, exactly.

1289
00:58:58.014 --> 00:59:00.415
So this is when Watson goes to King's College.

1290
00:59:00.535 --> 00:59:00.775
Okay.

1291
00:59:01.035 --> 00:59:03.957
And he's like, look, we got a problem here.

1292
00:59:03.977 --> 00:59:04.598
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1293
00:59:04.618 --> 00:59:06.259
He goes to Rosalind Franklin.

1294
00:59:07.359 --> 00:59:08.660
This is where things get sketchy.

1295
00:59:08.920 --> 00:59:09.141
Okay.

1296
00:59:09.781 --> 00:59:11.322
He goes to Rosalind Franklin's office.

1297
00:59:11.642 --> 00:59:12.323
She's not in there.

1298
00:59:12.723 --> 00:59:13.003
Okay.

1299
00:59:14.404 --> 00:59:15.665
I guess the door is open.

1300
00:59:15.685 --> 00:59:15.785
Okay.

1301
00:59:16.697 --> 00:59:20.660
This is where, you know, I don't know if the door is open or not.

1302
00:59:20.760 --> 00:59:21.120
Okay.

1303
00:59:21.400 --> 00:59:21.700
Okay.

1304
00:59:22.101 --> 00:59:22.901
He just goes in.

1305
00:59:23.582 --> 00:59:30.126
Rosen Franklin walks up on him in her office looking through her stuff.

1306
00:59:30.166 --> 00:59:30.266
Yeah.

1307
00:59:30.286 --> 00:59:31.166
No, no, no, no.

1308
00:59:31.587 --> 00:59:33.008
Never a good look.

1309
00:59:33.028 --> 00:59:33.968
No, no, no, no.

1310
00:59:33.988 --> 00:59:34.469
Okay.

1311
00:59:34.629 --> 00:59:35.389
Never a good look.

1312
00:59:35.850 --> 00:59:37.831
At this point, this is 1953.

1313
00:59:38.131 --> 00:59:40.873
Rosen Franklin has already had it with Maurice Wilkins.

1314
00:59:42.228 --> 00:59:45.830
because of the dynamic where they're just not getting along.

1315
00:59:45.950 --> 00:59:50.351
So, Rosen Franklin is about to leave in about six months to go to another university.

1316
00:59:50.391 --> 00:59:50.951
Right.

1317
00:59:51.612 --> 00:59:55.053
And the head of the group

1318
00:59:55.962 --> 01:00:05.344
has told Rosalind Franklin to give up all of the resources and all of the research that she's been doing on DNA to Maurice Wilkins, hand it over, right?

1319
01:00:05.404 --> 01:00:07.365
Because you're no longer going to be part of this group.

1320
01:00:07.845 --> 01:00:09.865
All of that is going to go to you.

1321
01:00:10.185 --> 01:00:16.387
Gosling, who is the PhD student, is also now going to go under Maurice Wilkins because he needs to finish his PhD.

1322
01:00:16.407 --> 01:00:18.107
Yes, he got to do what he got to do.

1323
01:00:18.407 --> 01:00:22.248
And in this whole time, Watson is in her lab just like...

1324
01:00:23.197 --> 01:00:23.917
Looking through her stuff.

1325
01:00:23.937 --> 01:00:25.058
Rifling through papers.

1326
01:00:25.218 --> 01:00:25.458
Right?

1327
01:00:25.638 --> 01:00:27.019
I mean, the guy is desperate.

1328
01:00:27.099 --> 01:00:27.739
I get it.

1329
01:00:27.759 --> 01:00:28.960
But my guy.

1330
01:00:28.980 --> 01:00:29.380
No, no.

1331
01:00:29.420 --> 01:00:30.861
That's like, what are you doing?

1332
01:00:31.341 --> 01:00:31.601
Okay.

1333
01:00:32.142 --> 01:00:33.762
Rosalind Franklin catches him.

1334
01:00:33.863 --> 01:00:35.023
It's like, what are you doing?

1335
01:00:35.403 --> 01:00:38.645
They have a little, you know, tiny argument.

1336
01:00:38.985 --> 01:00:42.727
Watson's like, well, I wanted to show you this paper from Linus Powling.

1337
01:00:42.747 --> 01:00:43.828
You know, we're on the same team.

1338
01:00:44.757 --> 01:00:46.801
Roland Franklin is not having it.

1339
01:00:46.841 --> 01:00:49.106
You were just in my office.

1340
01:00:49.206 --> 01:00:51.631
And now all of a sudden, like we're on the same.

1341
01:00:51.752 --> 01:00:52.032
No.

1342
01:00:52.413 --> 01:00:52.714
Okay.

1343
01:00:52.734 --> 01:00:53.976
Get the hell out of my office.

1344
01:00:55.148 --> 01:00:55.428
Okay.

1345
01:00:56.168 --> 01:00:57.069
He's like, fine, I'll go.

1346
01:00:58.489 --> 01:01:00.650
Down the hall, he goes to Maurice Wilkins' office.

1347
01:01:01.110 --> 01:01:02.791
Maurice Wilkins is in his office.

1348
01:01:03.191 --> 01:01:04.231
He goes to Maurice Wilkins.

1349
01:01:04.251 --> 01:01:05.892
He's like, maybe I can talk to this guy.

1350
01:01:05.932 --> 01:01:08.913
He's like, look, this is the manuscript, Linus Powling.

1351
01:01:08.933 --> 01:01:09.713
He's coming at it.

1352
01:01:11.314 --> 01:01:15.395
Wilkins has all of the data from Rosalind Franklin.

1353
01:01:15.435 --> 01:01:15.615
Right.

1354
01:01:15.795 --> 01:01:15.996
Right?

1355
01:01:16.036 --> 01:01:17.536
Because the transfer is happening.

1356
01:01:17.556 --> 01:01:17.756
Right.

1357
01:01:18.416 --> 01:01:21.678
And Wilkins shows him the famous photo 51.

1358
01:01:21.738 --> 01:01:21.918
Okay.

1359
01:01:23.098 --> 01:01:23.398
Okay.

1360
01:01:23.999 --> 01:01:26.401
This is the famous photo of BDNA.

1361
01:01:26.902 --> 01:01:32.247
This is an extremely famous photo of the X, the characteristic X that gets you the helix.

1362
01:01:32.467 --> 01:01:32.688
Yes.

1363
01:01:33.475 --> 01:01:35.137
It's so well done.

1364
01:01:35.377 --> 01:01:38.180
This is the photo that Ryan Gosling took at.

1365
01:01:38.861 --> 01:01:39.361
Not Ryan.

1366
01:01:39.822 --> 01:01:40.462
No, not Ryan.

1367
01:01:40.482 --> 01:01:41.023
What was his name?

1368
01:01:41.083 --> 01:01:41.463
Raymond.

1369
01:01:41.483 --> 01:01:41.924
Sorry.

1370
01:01:41.944 --> 01:01:42.785
Raymond Gosling.

1371
01:01:42.825 --> 01:01:43.866
I just screwed up on that.

1372
01:01:43.886 --> 01:01:44.626
This is the photo.

1373
01:01:44.646 --> 01:01:46.408
This is the photo that Raymond Gosling took.

1374
01:01:46.929 --> 01:01:48.270
Incredible detail.

1375
01:01:48.310 --> 01:01:48.590
Yeah.

1376
01:01:48.711 --> 01:01:49.211
Right.

1377
01:01:49.251 --> 01:01:50.693
The spots.

1378
01:01:50.813 --> 01:01:53.756
The you can tell the angle so you can tell the pitch of the helix.

1379
01:01:53.796 --> 01:01:53.996
Right.

1380
01:01:54.076 --> 01:01:56.418
You can tell that it's a helix because of the X.

1381
01:01:56.918 --> 01:02:02.683
The distance between the spots tells you how far apart each nucleotide is.

1382
01:02:03.764 --> 01:02:06.767
For people who are listening and not watching, I want to describe what we're seeing here.

1383
01:02:06.887 --> 01:02:09.229
So there's two photos next to each other.

1384
01:02:09.649 --> 01:02:11.330
There's sort of a black and white.

1385
01:02:12.271 --> 01:02:21.719
If you've ever looked at photos of people taking a picture of a Petri dish, like in any science context, that's what it looks like on the left, and then on the right is a 3D recreation of the structure.

1386
01:02:21.839 --> 01:02:22.720
Of what it would look like.

1387
01:02:24.060 --> 01:02:27.661
The point is there's a 2D black and white image.

1388
01:02:27.801 --> 01:02:30.382
Yes, and it's rich in information.

1389
01:02:30.642 --> 01:02:39.245
And you can derive the three-dimensional double helix from a variety of the angle.

1390
01:02:39.365 --> 01:02:41.285
The angle, the spacing of the dots.

1391
01:02:41.645 --> 01:02:43.486
All of these things in this black and white.

1392
01:02:43.506 --> 01:02:49.107
The fact that there's nothing in the middle means that one strand goes one way and the other strand goes the other way.

1393
01:02:49.468 --> 01:02:50.748
So it's anti-parallel.

1394
01:02:51.805 --> 01:02:51.985
Right?

1395
01:02:52.206 --> 01:02:53.768
There's so much information in this.

1396
01:02:54.109 --> 01:02:56.833
And Wilkins shows Watson this photograph.

1397
01:02:57.214 --> 01:02:58.777
Watson is immediately enamored.

1398
01:02:59.317 --> 01:03:00.980
He tries to memorize this photograph.

1399
01:03:01.000 --> 01:03:01.281
They were ops.

1400
01:03:01.301 --> 01:03:02.002
They were ops.

1401
01:03:03.024 --> 01:03:05.285
Kind of, because they were kind of competing with each other.

1402
01:03:05.745 --> 01:03:09.767
And then it came to a situation where the enemy of my enemy is my friend.

1403
01:03:09.807 --> 01:03:10.067
Yes.

1404
01:03:10.527 --> 01:03:10.767
Right?

1405
01:03:10.927 --> 01:03:12.308
Because Pao Ling showed up.

1406
01:03:12.608 --> 01:03:12.828
Yeah.

1407
01:03:12.948 --> 01:03:15.830
And we're like, at the end of the day, we're not going to let New York win.

1408
01:03:15.870 --> 01:03:16.770
The Americans.

1409
01:03:16.790 --> 01:03:18.111
We're not going to let Caltech win.

1410
01:03:18.151 --> 01:03:18.491
Right, right.

1411
01:03:18.511 --> 01:03:21.132
So in the rapper analogy, they already won.

1412
01:03:21.352 --> 01:03:22.492
With Alpha Helix.

1413
01:03:22.512 --> 01:03:24.213
Right.

1414
01:03:24.293 --> 01:03:28.195
So now Maurice is like, okay, let me show you what we got.

1415
01:03:28.295 --> 01:03:28.955
Here's what we got.

1416
01:03:28.975 --> 01:03:29.756
She's leaving anyway.

1417
01:03:29.796 --> 01:03:30.056
Yeah.

1418
01:03:30.996 --> 01:03:31.836
Yeah, exactly.

1419
01:03:32.256 --> 01:03:32.776
Exactly.

1420
01:03:33.076 --> 01:03:33.957
Let me show you what we got.

1421
01:03:33.997 --> 01:03:34.717
Okay.

1422
01:03:35.237 --> 01:03:39.958
Watson immediately heads back to Cambridge to tell Crick about this photo that he saw.

1423
01:03:39.978 --> 01:03:40.398
He saw it.

1424
01:03:40.578 --> 01:03:40.758
Right.

1425
01:03:41.298 --> 01:03:50.620
At the same time, Franklin publishes an internal report, which is something that institutions do where they talk about the research that they've done over the past year.

1426
01:03:50.920 --> 01:03:55.861
And it's an internal Medical Research Council report and King's College report that...

1427
01:03:58.261 --> 01:04:07.668
shows all of the, that shows this photograph along with a lot of the determination that Franklin has done on the photograph because she has the original, right?

1428
01:04:07.688 --> 01:04:08.628
She has that original print.

1429
01:04:08.909 --> 01:04:15.393
So she can measure the distance between those black spots and say that, okay, these things are 3.4 angstroms apart.

1430
01:04:16.094 --> 01:04:20.016
Each turn of the helix is 10 nucleotides, 34 angstroms.

1431
01:04:21.718 --> 01:04:23.319
And all of these little details.

1432
01:04:23.919 --> 01:04:25.761
This is a Medical Research Council report.

1433
01:04:26.501 --> 01:04:27.322
Crick gets...

1434
01:04:28.022 --> 01:04:30.103
wind of this and gets a copy of it.

1435
01:04:30.143 --> 01:04:30.684
Of course he does.

1436
01:04:30.964 --> 01:04:31.224
Okay.

1437
01:04:32.064 --> 01:04:35.166
All of this stuff is happening without Franklin knowing.

1438
01:04:36.327 --> 01:04:37.307
That's the key.

1439
01:04:37.887 --> 01:04:39.168
It's not with consent.

1440
01:04:39.248 --> 01:04:39.628
You're right.

1441
01:04:39.708 --> 01:04:40.549
Informed consent.

1442
01:04:40.649 --> 01:04:40.849
Right.

1443
01:04:41.449 --> 01:04:41.630
Right.

1444
01:04:41.750 --> 01:04:41.990
Okay.

1445
01:04:42.030 --> 01:04:45.892
And especially in this world at when the stakes are as high as they are.

1446
01:04:47.169 --> 01:04:47.849
It is a very meaningful...

1447
01:04:47.869 --> 01:04:48.590
They're working on DNA.

1448
01:04:48.610 --> 01:04:49.430
Yeah, this is a very meaningful...

1449
01:04:49.470 --> 01:04:52.731
They're working on the physical substrate of genetics.

1450
01:04:53.011 --> 01:04:56.632
I mean, obviously, they're working on a Nobel Prize level.

1451
01:04:56.812 --> 01:04:57.453
Everyone knows.

1452
01:04:57.673 --> 01:04:58.173
Everyone knows.

1453
01:04:58.413 --> 01:04:59.253
That this is what's happening.

1454
01:04:59.273 --> 01:04:59.793
The treasure map.

1455
01:04:59.813 --> 01:05:00.154
We know.

1456
01:05:01.174 --> 01:05:01.374
Right?

1457
01:05:02.134 --> 01:05:04.595
And so, Watson and Crick get to work.

1458
01:05:04.615 --> 01:05:05.956
They have all of this information.

1459
01:05:06.196 --> 01:05:06.376
Right.

1460
01:05:07.296 --> 01:05:09.677
They go up to Bragg, and they're like, look, Bragg...

1461
01:05:11.429 --> 01:05:12.730
Linus Powling is working on it.

1462
01:05:13.290 --> 01:05:14.431
We have all this information.

1463
01:05:14.912 --> 01:05:17.153
We need you to let us work on this again.

1464
01:05:17.374 --> 01:05:20.316
Because in 1951, he's like, stop embarrassing us.

1465
01:05:20.336 --> 01:05:21.097
Stop embarrassing us.

1466
01:05:22.237 --> 01:05:24.960
Bragg does not like Powling.

1467
01:05:26.461 --> 01:05:26.581
Ah.

1468
01:05:28.903 --> 01:05:29.663
Okay?

1469
01:05:31.264 --> 01:05:31.925
I love it.

1470
01:05:32.445 --> 01:05:33.306
It's such a human story.

1471
01:05:33.346 --> 01:05:34.967
Yeah, it's such a human story.

1472
01:05:35.027 --> 01:05:36.909
Bragg does not like Powling.

1473
01:05:36.929 --> 01:05:37.569
So he's on board.

1474
01:05:37.649 --> 01:05:37.950
Okay?

1475
01:05:38.050 --> 01:05:40.011
So he's like, do what you got to do.

1476
01:05:40.031 --> 01:05:40.592
Right, right, right.

1477
01:05:41.511 --> 01:05:42.492
Don't screw it up.

1478
01:05:42.812 --> 01:05:44.973
This time, do not embarrass me again.

1479
01:05:45.514 --> 01:05:46.794
I want this for Cavendish.

1480
01:05:48.095 --> 01:05:48.315
Okay?

1481
01:05:48.496 --> 01:05:49.256
Yeah.

1482
01:05:49.376 --> 01:05:49.976
This is ours.

1483
01:05:50.017 --> 01:05:50.357
Yeah.

1484
01:05:50.797 --> 01:05:51.517
You need to do it.

1485
01:05:52.338 --> 01:05:55.740
So, Watson and Crick go down to the machine shop.

1486
01:05:55.760 --> 01:05:57.221
They're like, boys, we're back in business.

1487
01:05:57.241 --> 01:06:00.864
I need you to make me little models of it so that we can tinker around.

1488
01:06:02.144 --> 01:06:07.108
They get these models of nucleotides, those base pairs that I was showing you earlier.

1489
01:06:07.128 --> 01:06:07.228
Yeah.

1490
01:06:07.971 --> 01:06:12.352
And they start trying to put them together in the way that they know now, right?

1491
01:06:12.492 --> 01:06:13.873
Things have to be anti-parallel.

1492
01:06:14.153 --> 01:06:15.873
The phosphates have to be on the outside.

1493
01:06:16.033 --> 01:06:18.134
The nitrogens and bases have to be on the inside.

1494
01:06:18.814 --> 01:06:27.857
It's still not quite working until their office mate, Jerry Donahue, looks at the bases that they're the Lego blocks that they're using to like do this.

1495
01:06:28.817 --> 01:06:31.738
And he's like, actually, you're doing it wrong.

1496
01:06:33.976 --> 01:06:41.621
Given the pH of the cell and the temperature of living organisms, the hydrogen there isn't actually going to be there.

1497
01:06:41.641 --> 01:06:42.422
It's going to be over here.

1498
01:06:44.483 --> 01:06:47.385
And Watson's like, oh, okay.

1499
01:06:47.825 --> 01:06:49.226
And then he goes back to the machine shop.

1500
01:06:49.246 --> 01:06:50.347
He's like, make me new ones.

1501
01:06:50.787 --> 01:06:53.069
And the new ones work out splendidly.

1502
01:06:53.930 --> 01:06:55.511
They fit like puzzle blocks.

1503
01:06:56.965 --> 01:07:00.226
Like that singular, subtle insight.

1504
01:07:00.266 --> 01:07:05.147
That subtle insight from his lab mate, Jerry Donahue, to turn from keto.

1505
01:07:06.407 --> 01:07:11.928
They exist in keto and amino forms and not in the enol form, meaning that the hydrogen was in the wrong place.

1506
01:07:12.288 --> 01:07:19.650
But now when the hydrogen is in the right place, the hydrogen of one is going to hydrogen bond with the nitrogen of the other or the oxygen of the other.

1507
01:07:19.930 --> 01:07:22.130
And you're going to create these weak bonds in the middle.

1508
01:07:22.670 --> 01:07:25.251
The other thing that was crazy was that when they –

1509
01:07:26.199 --> 01:07:47.225
had the A and the T and the G and the C, there was structural consistency because the A and the T is pairing two carbon rings with one carbon ring and two carbon rings with one carbon ring, meaning the distance between the backbones was going to be the same, right?

1510
01:07:47.505 --> 01:07:50.446
And there's a... You see?

1511
01:07:50.806 --> 01:07:52.266
You've got the C and the G. Yes.

1512
01:07:52.486 --> 01:07:52.646
Yes.

1513
01:07:54.707 --> 01:07:57.529
Those have three hydrogen bonds between them.

1514
01:07:57.549 --> 01:07:59.010
The A and the T have two.

1515
01:07:59.750 --> 01:08:02.232
In that case, that's a U, but same thing, right?

1516
01:08:02.352 --> 01:08:03.193
Yeah.

1517
01:08:03.693 --> 01:08:09.237
But notice that the distance between the phosphate backbone on the top and the bottom are the same.

1518
01:08:09.357 --> 01:08:16.501
So we're looking at an image where in the middle we have on the left the G and the C with three hydrogen bonds in the middle.

1519
01:08:16.801 --> 01:08:18.663
And on the right, the A and the...

1520
01:08:19.203 --> 01:08:20.364
I guess it's supposed to be a T?

1521
01:08:20.444 --> 01:08:23.827
Yeah, that's a U for the RNA, but it's the same structure.

1522
01:08:23.907 --> 01:08:26.169
It's a T with two hydrogen bonds.

1523
01:08:26.389 --> 01:08:35.637
And the point is, when you look at it at top to bottom, even though there's a difference in pair and number, the vertical distance is identical.

1524
01:08:35.777 --> 01:08:36.358
Yes.

1525
01:08:36.378 --> 01:08:38.299
Which means it can be a structure.

1526
01:08:38.319 --> 01:08:39.540
Which means it can be a structure.

1527
01:08:39.560 --> 01:08:43.424
It can be a Lego block where I can swap out A's and T's and A's and T's.

1528
01:08:43.604 --> 01:08:45.786
But the overall structure remains the same.

1529
01:08:45.846 --> 01:08:46.026
Yes.

1530
01:08:46.366 --> 01:08:47.947
So I've just created a code.

1531
01:08:47.967 --> 01:08:48.047
Yes.

1532
01:08:48.128 --> 01:08:48.388
Yes.

1533
01:08:49.417 --> 01:08:55.598
Where the Lego blocks themselves are different...

1534
01:08:56.434 --> 01:09:06.965
But when you extrapolate to the larger molecule, it fits and they're all the same, which means that whatever physics is happening here in this location, let's say there's more A's and less T's.

1535
01:09:07.425 --> 01:09:09.287
In that location, there's the other way around.

1536
01:09:09.588 --> 01:09:10.829
The physics is going to be the same.

1537
01:09:10.889 --> 01:09:12.671
The rope is going to look the same.

1538
01:09:12.911 --> 01:09:13.131
Yes.

1539
01:09:13.311 --> 01:09:13.532
Right?

1540
01:09:13.672 --> 01:09:13.872
Yes.

1541
01:09:14.112 --> 01:09:14.753
No.

1542
01:09:14.813 --> 01:09:16.555
The rope might be colored differently.

1543
01:09:16.575 --> 01:09:17.396
Right, right, right, right.

1544
01:09:17.436 --> 01:09:19.458
But the physics of the rope is going to be the same.

1545
01:09:20.770 --> 01:09:24.231
It's the aperiodic crystal that Schrodinger was talking about.

1546
01:09:24.251 --> 01:09:33.813
They finally now found the missing piece for what is required to actually create the physical structure of this aperiodic crystal.

1547
01:09:33.833 --> 01:09:34.113
Yes.

1548
01:09:34.233 --> 01:09:36.314
Which initially there was like, oh, it's a triple helix.

1549
01:09:36.434 --> 01:09:39.754
Because again, we have to remember there's no conception of this structure.

1550
01:09:39.774 --> 01:09:40.735
No, it's just all in the dark.

1551
01:09:40.955 --> 01:09:44.536
There's no concept of what the structure is.

1552
01:09:44.576 --> 01:09:46.616
Yeah, they're just trying to figure out what is going on.

1553
01:09:46.696 --> 01:09:49.277
They know that these are the building blocks, but they're like, does it go this way?

1554
01:09:49.517 --> 01:09:50.297
Does it go this way?

1555
01:09:51.237 --> 01:09:51.937
Are there three?

1556
01:09:51.997 --> 01:09:52.657
Are there five?

1557
01:09:52.677 --> 01:09:53.858
God.

1558
01:09:53.958 --> 01:10:06.200
And that one flip of the not eno form but the keto and amino form, that of the hydrogen, which creates the three and two pairing, which now is like that's how everything can now click together.

1559
01:10:06.220 --> 01:10:06.440
Yes.

1560
01:10:06.720 --> 01:10:08.940
And then this also explains chargas rules, right?

1561
01:10:09.000 --> 01:10:09.240
Yes.

1562
01:10:09.300 --> 01:10:13.081
Because now the A's and the T's are pairing and the C and the G's are pairing.

1563
01:10:13.121 --> 01:10:19.802
Because it's the two and the three hydrogen bonds as what creates – that's the reason why they're paired in that way.

1564
01:10:19.822 --> 01:10:20.062
Yes.

1565
01:10:20.582 --> 01:10:22.826
There's a physical understanding there, right?

1566
01:10:23.206 --> 01:10:26.932
And it's an incredible story, right?

1567
01:10:26.952 --> 01:10:27.272
That's good.

1568
01:10:27.392 --> 01:10:31.819
All of this stuff coming together because they hate the Caltech guy.

1569
01:10:31.839 --> 01:10:34.523
Look, I just want everyone to know California is still the best.

1570
01:10:34.563 --> 01:10:35.405
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1571
01:10:35.725 --> 01:10:37.106
But like, they were scared.

1572
01:10:37.766 --> 01:10:38.407
They were scared.

1573
01:10:38.527 --> 01:10:42.429
And they were scared for a good reason because nothing's happened since.

1574
01:10:42.729 --> 01:10:44.710
So they were correct in their fear.

1575
01:10:44.730 --> 01:10:47.552
Dude, Linus Pauling was really scaring them.

1576
01:10:47.592 --> 01:10:51.554
So it's like, so now they finally figured this out.

1577
01:10:51.754 --> 01:10:52.394
April 1953.

1578
01:10:52.635 --> 01:10:53.795
Yes, okay.

1579
01:10:53.835 --> 01:10:55.796
Is when they decide, okay, we're going to publish this.

1580
01:10:55.916 --> 01:10:56.037
Okay.

1581
01:10:56.057 --> 01:10:56.277
Okay.

1582
01:10:57.150 --> 01:10:58.691
They have a triple publication.

1583
01:10:58.951 --> 01:11:07.175
Watson and Crick published their very famous molecular structure of nucleic acid, a structure for deoxyribonucleic acid.

1584
01:11:07.596 --> 01:11:10.537
It's just a two-page paper in nature.

1585
01:11:10.737 --> 01:11:11.518
No way.

1586
01:11:11.538 --> 01:11:12.899
It's a two-page paper in nature.

1587
01:11:13.159 --> 01:11:16.280
There's no experimental findings because they didn't do any experiments.

1588
01:11:16.300 --> 01:11:16.941
They just put it out.

1589
01:11:16.961 --> 01:11:17.601
They just put it out.

1590
01:11:17.621 --> 01:11:18.682
They're like, this is the structure.

1591
01:11:18.702 --> 01:11:19.282
They're going to work first.

1592
01:11:19.662 --> 01:11:19.862
Yeah.

1593
01:11:19.942 --> 01:11:20.783
Because we have to beat them.

1594
01:11:21.323 --> 01:11:25.646
So Wilkins, Stokes, and Wilson, they provided supporting evidence of the helical structure.

1595
01:11:25.946 --> 01:11:32.610
And then Franklin and Gosling Post had the third paper in the same issue, same issue of nature, back to back to back.

1596
01:11:32.670 --> 01:11:33.551
No way.

1597
01:11:33.731 --> 01:11:34.211
All three?

1598
01:11:34.432 --> 01:11:34.852
All three.

1599
01:11:35.232 --> 01:11:41.756
All three back to back to back had these papers, presented the empirical data with the famous photograph 51.

1600
01:11:43.057 --> 01:11:45.439
I'm going to need to get a copy of this April version.

1601
01:11:45.560 --> 01:11:47.141
Oh, I bet it's worth a lot of money.

1602
01:11:47.221 --> 01:11:49.944
I would love to have that on the wall.

1603
01:11:50.024 --> 01:11:57.871
Okay, so if you, audience, if you are currently in possession of the April 25, 1953 Nature triple publication of DNA –

1604
01:12:01.875 --> 01:12:02.816
please DM us.

1605
01:12:03.216 --> 01:12:03.437
Yeah.

1606
01:12:03.877 --> 01:12:08.461
If you know somebody that's in possession of that copy, please DM us.

1607
01:12:08.521 --> 01:12:13.406
Cause it will make a great addition as one of our first pieces on the wall.

1608
01:12:13.426 --> 01:12:14.927
We've now decided we're going to put,

1609
01:12:15.900 --> 01:12:21.084
The annals and history of science and great memorabilia on the walls behind us.

1610
01:12:21.164 --> 01:12:22.985
And this would be just absolutely incredible.

1611
01:12:23.025 --> 01:12:26.668
It's a single issue of nature that has all three of these publications.

1612
01:12:26.688 --> 01:12:27.649
That is so crazy.

1613
01:12:27.669 --> 01:12:27.909
Yeah.

1614
01:12:28.269 --> 01:12:29.770
That is so crazy.

1615
01:12:29.970 --> 01:12:36.836
They approached the editor of nature and they're like, this is... We got three things and they're these three.

1616
01:12:36.896 --> 01:12:39.538
And the editor of nature was like, yeah.

1617
01:12:39.718 --> 01:12:40.698
Obviously.

1618
01:12:40.859 --> 01:12:41.539
We got to put it together.

1619
01:12:41.559 --> 01:12:42.540
Yeah, we got to put it together.

1620
01:12:42.620 --> 01:12:43.881
And they put it back to back.

1621
01:12:44.201 --> 01:12:45.042
That's incredible.

1622
01:12:45.062 --> 01:12:45.302
Yeah.

1623
01:12:45.602 --> 01:12:52.103
This order, though, the fact that Watson and Crick were first, it sort of cemented that priority in the narrative, right?

1624
01:12:52.143 --> 01:12:55.064
Because there are the guys who came up with the structure.

1625
01:12:55.604 --> 01:12:59.985
Rosalind Franklin comes up with the empirical data that suggests that that structure is true.

1626
01:13:00.105 --> 01:13:02.846
But she didn't come up with the structure, technically.

1627
01:13:02.946 --> 01:13:04.786
Yeah, technically she did not come up with the structure.

1628
01:13:04.866 --> 01:13:06.727
She was incredibly close.

1629
01:13:07.127 --> 01:13:12.368
If you look at the laboratory notes, she has notes in her labs about how this has to be two strands.

1630
01:13:13.028 --> 01:13:14.089
They're anti-parallel.

1631
01:13:14.629 --> 01:13:15.489
All from her data.

1632
01:13:15.569 --> 01:13:16.370
Because she took the data.

1633
01:13:16.390 --> 01:13:17.590
And if Maurice didn't leak.

1634
01:13:18.110 --> 01:13:19.231
If Maurice didn't leak.

1635
01:13:19.251 --> 01:13:20.431
She could have had a little bit more time.

1636
01:13:20.451 --> 01:13:21.292
She would have had time.

1637
01:13:21.332 --> 01:13:21.892
And who knows?

1638
01:13:21.992 --> 01:13:22.592
Who knows?

1639
01:13:22.772 --> 01:13:22.992
Yeah.

1640
01:13:23.113 --> 01:13:26.914
But, you know, she was there.

1641
01:13:27.114 --> 01:13:27.835
She had the source.

1642
01:13:27.955 --> 01:13:28.355
She was there.

1643
01:13:28.435 --> 01:13:29.595
She was really the source.

1644
01:13:29.615 --> 01:13:29.756
Yeah.

1645
01:13:29.856 --> 01:13:33.337
And if you look at her notes, she didn't have the pairing, which was crucial.

1646
01:13:33.357 --> 01:13:34.217
That's the creepy.

1647
01:13:34.258 --> 01:13:35.278
That Donahue.

1648
01:13:35.358 --> 01:13:35.918
Yeah, yeah.

1649
01:13:36.238 --> 01:13:39.159
And she didn't have that guy who was like, no, it's not that form.

1650
01:13:39.199 --> 01:13:40.219
It's this other form, right?

1651
01:13:40.659 --> 01:13:50.182
And one of the other great things about Watson and Crick's paper is they say that it doesn't escape us that the replication mechanism is now obvious.

1652
01:13:50.822 --> 01:13:52.702
Because you've got a double helix.

1653
01:13:53.383 --> 01:13:54.123
You unzip.

1654
01:13:54.952 --> 01:14:00.115
Now there's a C here, you attach a G. If there's a T, you attach an A.

1655
01:14:00.195 --> 01:14:12.101
Because of the hydrogen bonding, which is unique, a 2 goes with a 2, a 3 goes with a 3, and the length constrains, the spacing of the ladder constrains that an A will not go with an A.

1656
01:14:12.181 --> 01:14:13.582
Even though an A and an A have...

1657
01:14:14.282 --> 01:14:19.007
two hydrogen bonds, it's going to be too wide for the latter.

1658
01:14:19.127 --> 01:14:19.767
That's a good point.

1659
01:14:19.848 --> 01:14:20.468
Right?

1660
01:14:20.508 --> 01:14:26.754
So it's obvious now, given the structure, how you would replicate this information, which was a huge deal.

1661
01:14:27.034 --> 01:14:33.220
Like, how can you have a molecule that does both, that stores and also is able to replicate really quickly?

1662
01:14:33.300 --> 01:14:33.480
Right.

1663
01:14:33.841 --> 01:14:34.041
Right.

1664
01:14:34.441 --> 01:14:34.621
Right?

1665
01:14:34.641 --> 01:14:35.522
Right.

1666
01:14:36.603 --> 01:14:37.564
It's an incredible story.

1667
01:14:37.604 --> 01:14:39.305
So now there's a shift in research.

1668
01:14:39.605 --> 01:14:44.827
Franklin, as I was saying, she moves to Birkbeck College, and she focuses on the tobacco mosaic virus.

1669
01:14:45.128 --> 01:14:49.930
She does incredible work on the tobacco mosaic virus with a colleague named Erin Klug.

1670
01:14:50.350 --> 01:14:53.412
Unfortunately, given that she was working with x-rays, it's...

1671
01:14:54.252 --> 01:15:01.455
Um, it's thought that the x-ray research actually contributed to ovarian cancer that she developed later on in life.

1672
01:15:01.835 --> 01:15:02.675
Not that much later.

1673
01:15:02.715 --> 01:15:05.616
She died actually in 1958 at the age of 37.

1674
01:15:05.996 --> 01:15:09.938
This is a photo of her when she was visiting California, um, in Yosemite.

1675
01:15:10.438 --> 01:15:14.299
And she had visited Berkeley to give some talks and UCLA to give some talks.

1676
01:15:14.860 --> 01:15:15.020
Um,

1677
01:15:15.920 --> 01:15:19.222
It's really unfortunate that she died so young at the age of 37.

1678
01:15:19.342 --> 01:15:20.743
Yeah, that's crazy.

1679
01:15:20.823 --> 01:15:23.225
And it was incandescently bright.

1680
01:15:23.385 --> 01:15:25.046
Yes, incredibly bright.

1681
01:15:25.586 --> 01:15:26.727
Incredibly bright.

1682
01:15:27.247 --> 01:15:29.849
And she figured out the structure of the tobacco mosaic virus.

1683
01:15:30.189 --> 01:15:37.654
Her colleague, Erin Klug, who was her subordinate at the time, went on to win the Nobel Prize for the tobacco mosaic virus.

1684
01:15:37.674 --> 01:15:41.417
So very, very likely that had she lived, she would have won the Nobel Prize.

1685
01:15:41.437 --> 01:15:41.937
Won the Nobel Prize.

1686
01:15:42.157 --> 01:16:06.005
for that as well um 1958 is when she dies four years later the nobel prize is awarded to james watson francis crick and maurice wilkins um obviously you can't give nobel prizes and actually john steinbeck won the literature prize there so he's he's in the in the group photo as well um obviously you can't give

1687
01:16:06.952 --> 01:16:10.575
the Nobel prize for posthumously, right.

1688
01:16:10.995 --> 01:16:16.180
And Rosalind Franklin was already four years passed away.

1689
01:16:17.421 --> 01:16:21.584
The problem is there is not a single mention of her in their Nobel lectures.

1690
01:16:23.285 --> 01:16:23.806
That's crazy.

1691
01:16:23.826 --> 01:16:24.707
That's crazy.

1692
01:16:24.727 --> 01:16:25.327
That's crazy.

1693
01:16:25.707 --> 01:16:29.230
Given, given photograph 51, like that is just insane.

1694
01:16:29.250 --> 01:16:29.450
Yeah.

1695
01:16:29.631 --> 01:16:32.113
You guys wouldn't have been, you would have been in the dark.

1696
01:16:33.044 --> 01:16:36.026
but for Maurice leaky ass.

1697
01:16:36.066 --> 01:16:36.366
Yeah.

1698
01:16:36.847 --> 01:16:37.587
Leaky Wilkins.

1699
01:16:37.627 --> 01:16:46.973
Leaky Wilkins giving you, for his own beef, that his personal attention is probably a non-zero driver opening the books up.

1700
01:16:46.993 --> 01:16:47.574
100%.

1701
01:16:47.654 --> 01:16:48.835
To a local competitor.

1702
01:16:48.875 --> 01:16:49.115
Yeah.

1703
01:16:49.515 --> 01:16:49.795
Right?

1704
01:16:50.716 --> 01:16:53.037
And so you can't not.

1705
01:16:53.238 --> 01:16:55.059
Yeah, you can't not say anything.

1706
01:16:55.459 --> 01:16:55.859
Nothing?

1707
01:16:55.919 --> 01:16:56.600
That's insane.

1708
01:16:56.700 --> 01:16:57.420
Nothing is crazy.

1709
01:16:57.440 --> 01:16:59.021
And Rosalind Franklin would have sort of,

1710
01:17:00.374 --> 01:17:01.555
gone under the radar.

1711
01:17:02.175 --> 01:17:11.219
But nowadays, whenever we think about DNA, I'll be honest, whenever people who know the story of DNA, if they know James Watson, they know Rosalind Franklin.

1712
01:17:11.959 --> 01:17:20.283
I mean, because of the resurgence of her persona and all of that happened because she was so wronged.

1713
01:17:20.503 --> 01:17:23.625
One, she was not given due credit in the Nobel lecture.

1714
01:17:24.505 --> 01:17:28.447
And then second, in 1968, James Watson publishes

1715
01:17:29.267 --> 01:17:32.751
The Double Helix, which is this book.

1716
01:17:33.171 --> 01:17:34.673
My dad bought this book.

1717
01:17:34.813 --> 01:17:40.219
It's in terrible condition because he bought this in the late 90s when he first came to America.

1718
01:17:40.239 --> 01:17:46.425
This is one of the first books that he bought, and he brought it all the way back to India, and we brought it back when we moved back.

1719
01:17:46.465 --> 01:17:47.987
The Double Helix was published in 1968.

1720
01:17:48.007 --> 01:17:48.628
It's a firsthand book.

1721
01:17:53.519 --> 01:17:56.682
memoir, first-person memoir about the scientific discovery.

1722
01:17:57.083 --> 01:18:01.107
It's unusual for its time because a lot of scientists didn't really talk about the human story.

1723
01:18:01.548 --> 01:18:04.491
But James Watson puts this out in print.

1724
01:18:04.952 --> 01:18:07.294
He wanted to get it published in the Harvard...

1725
01:18:08.175 --> 01:18:08.936
press.

1726
01:18:09.316 --> 01:18:16.644
But Francis Crick and Wilkins were like, no, we don't want that because they read copies of it.

1727
01:18:16.684 --> 01:18:19.387
And it was a lot of self-aggrandizing.

1728
01:18:20.128 --> 01:18:23.891
The other thing is he calls Rosie by her nickname.

1729
01:18:24.652 --> 01:18:29.057
He calls Rosalind Franklin by her nickname, Rosie, which at the time was actually a

1730
01:18:30.487 --> 01:18:36.128
No one said that to her face because she wasn't really a rosy personality, right?

1731
01:18:36.408 --> 01:18:38.088
As I was saying, she's a tough woman.

1732
01:18:38.128 --> 01:18:39.909
She's a woman in science and a man's field.

1733
01:18:39.949 --> 01:18:40.769
She's a tough woman.

1734
01:18:41.229 --> 01:18:43.489
So he's calling her rosy.

1735
01:18:43.830 --> 01:18:52.391
He's basically saying that Rosalind Franklin did not have the scientific expertise and the brain to figure it out on her own.

1736
01:18:52.411 --> 01:18:53.491
She didn't have the hutspa.

1737
01:18:53.651 --> 01:18:55.152
And yeah, and the men had to do it.

1738
01:18:55.752 --> 01:18:56.032
Yeah.

1739
01:18:56.932 --> 01:19:00.174
This creates a lot of tension among all of her colleagues.

1740
01:19:00.214 --> 01:19:01.715
And they're like, what are you talking about?

1741
01:19:02.095 --> 01:19:06.077
And then that's what starts this movement to be like, no, you're not going to get away with this.

1742
01:19:06.177 --> 01:19:09.959
We're going to start talking about Rosalind Franklin and her contributions.

1743
01:19:10.799 --> 01:19:12.760
Right?

1744
01:19:13.300 --> 01:19:16.922
That's so crazy given the context.

1745
01:19:17.442 --> 01:19:18.163
Because like...

1746
01:19:19.263 --> 01:19:22.244
Y'all were putting Legos together in the lab.

1747
01:19:22.284 --> 01:19:22.545
Yeah.

1748
01:19:22.845 --> 01:19:25.446
She was doing x-ray crystallography.

1749
01:19:25.486 --> 01:19:26.687
Yeah.

1750
01:19:26.747 --> 01:19:33.170
And actually got the key image that created the entire unlock for everything downstream.

1751
01:19:33.230 --> 01:19:33.690
Exactly.

1752
01:19:34.010 --> 01:19:35.991
And to not even just be able to...

1753
01:19:36.831 --> 01:19:37.412
Acknowledge?

1754
01:19:37.432 --> 01:19:39.112
Acknowledge that is weird, bro.

1755
01:19:39.172 --> 01:19:39.953
It's weird.

1756
01:19:39.993 --> 01:19:40.873
That's like weird.

1757
01:19:40.893 --> 01:19:41.854
It's really weird.

1758
01:19:42.294 --> 01:19:43.394
It's really, really weird.

1759
01:19:43.414 --> 01:19:46.416
It doesn't make your insight any less important.

1760
01:19:46.656 --> 01:19:46.796
No.

1761
01:19:46.816 --> 01:19:46.876
No.

1762
01:19:47.525 --> 01:19:49.266
Like, it didn't have to be anyway.

1763
01:19:49.466 --> 01:19:49.666
No.

1764
01:19:49.986 --> 01:19:50.246
Yeah.

1765
01:19:51.027 --> 01:19:51.647
That's crazy.

1766
01:19:51.687 --> 01:19:52.228
It's weird.

1767
01:19:52.488 --> 01:19:53.228
It's really weird.

1768
01:19:54.008 --> 01:19:58.091
James Watson goes on to be appointed the director of the Cold Spring Harbor National Lab.

1769
01:19:58.471 --> 01:20:01.112
This is a private, non-profit research institution.

1770
01:20:01.152 --> 01:20:01.953
It's kind of like the...

1771
01:20:03.073 --> 01:20:07.574
Institute for Advanced Study, but for biology and chemistry and biochemistry.

1772
01:20:07.954 --> 01:20:09.434
At the time, it was very small.

1773
01:20:09.774 --> 01:20:14.935
James Watson really transforms this into a research environment that is unparalleled.

1774
01:20:15.035 --> 01:20:16.535
And I will have to give him credit for that.

1775
01:20:16.836 --> 01:20:27.637
Cold Spring Harbor Lab today is one of the foremost great world institutions when it comes to cancer research, when it comes to genetic research.

1776
01:20:28.178 --> 01:20:30.158
They have eight Nobel Prizes to their name.

1777
01:20:30.178 --> 01:20:30.238
Oh.

1778
01:20:30.698 --> 01:20:32.741
For a single institution that is not a university.

1779
01:20:32.761 --> 01:20:33.562
That's not a university?

1780
01:20:33.702 --> 01:20:35.364
It's just like an institution.

1781
01:20:35.785 --> 01:20:36.365
It's pretty good.

1782
01:20:36.686 --> 01:20:41.792
BioArchive, which is the biology archive, is hosted by them.

1783
01:20:41.932 --> 01:20:42.213
Okay.

1784
01:20:42.233 --> 01:20:45.897
They discover telomeres, jumping genes, a bunch of other things.

1785
01:20:46.158 --> 01:20:47.379
Oh, we just talked about telomeres.

1786
01:20:47.539 --> 01:20:47.800
Yes.

1787
01:20:48.260 --> 01:20:49.522
In one of the two episodes ago.

1788
01:20:49.642 --> 01:20:50.403
Yeah, yeah.

1789
01:20:50.503 --> 01:20:56.769
So they've done a bunch of research, and James Watson was really one of the pioneer drivers of creating that institution.

1790
01:20:56.789 --> 01:20:57.950
So I have to give him credit for that.

1791
01:20:58.110 --> 01:20:59.251
Sure.

1792
01:20:59.331 --> 01:21:04.536
In 1990, he actually became head of the Human Genome Project before it was taken over by Francis Collins.

1793
01:21:05.017 --> 01:21:10.021
He left two years later because the NIH director at the time, Bernadine Healy...

1794
01:21:11.515 --> 01:21:19.617
was proposing acquiring patents on gene sequences, and he opposed any ownership of laws of nature.

1795
01:21:19.657 --> 01:21:24.759
So I have to give him credit for that too, because he said that genes are something that belong to humanity.

1796
01:21:24.859 --> 01:21:27.300
You can't patent something that is within me.

1797
01:21:27.740 --> 01:21:29.560
That sounds completely absurd.

1798
01:21:29.880 --> 01:21:31.361
So that's also really great.

1799
01:21:32.581 --> 01:21:37.743
In 1994, he goes back to Cold Spring Harbor, and that's where things get unhinged.

1800
01:21:38.083 --> 01:21:38.843
Starts getting old.

1801
01:21:39.483 --> 01:21:41.144
Maybe he starts thinking he's invincible.

1802
01:21:41.205 --> 01:21:42.305
Yeah.

1803
01:21:42.446 --> 01:21:44.067
We've seen that story before.

1804
01:21:44.507 --> 01:21:51.994
So in 2000, in Berkeley, Watson gives a lecture where he suggests there's a link between skin color and sex drive.

1805
01:21:54.015 --> 01:21:54.656
No way.

1806
01:21:55.717 --> 01:21:56.037
At Berkeley.

1807
01:21:56.117 --> 01:21:56.638
Berkeley.

1808
01:21:57.781 --> 01:22:01.184
Like of all institutions at Berkeley, you're going to say this shit?

1809
01:22:01.204 --> 01:22:09.310
I mean, Berkeley is like in the Oakland area of California, which is very diverse, very black.

1810
01:22:09.450 --> 01:22:09.831
Yeah.

1811
01:22:09.851 --> 01:22:11.552
And Berkeley is extremely liberal.

1812
01:22:11.752 --> 01:22:12.993
Yeah.

1813
01:22:13.033 --> 01:22:13.434
Like it's –

1814
01:22:13.994 --> 01:22:15.696
Because they have people around.

1815
01:22:15.836 --> 01:22:16.136
Anyway.

1816
01:22:16.216 --> 01:22:16.456
Yeah.

1817
01:22:16.496 --> 01:22:16.656
Yeah.

1818
01:22:16.717 --> 01:22:20.140
And he hypothesizes that dark skinned people have stronger libidos.

1819
01:22:20.180 --> 01:22:21.701
That's the dumbest thing.

1820
01:22:21.821 --> 01:22:27.727
And the lecture argues that like melanin, which is the thing that's giving us the brown and black color.

1821
01:22:27.807 --> 01:22:28.007
Yes.

1822
01:22:28.207 --> 01:22:33.552
That's somehow a derivative of a compound that boosts sex drive.

1823
01:22:33.832 --> 01:22:37.116
And then, quote, he says, that's why you have Latin lovers.

1824
01:22:37.136 --> 01:22:37.576
Yeah.

1825
01:22:38.182 --> 01:22:44.425
You've never heard of an English lover, only an English patient.

1826
01:22:44.605 --> 01:22:46.366
Bro, what are you doing?

1827
01:22:46.686 --> 01:22:48.167
I cannot cringe any hard.

1828
01:22:48.267 --> 01:22:49.728
That's pretty wild.

1829
01:22:49.768 --> 01:22:50.568
That's pretty wild.

1830
01:22:50.628 --> 01:22:51.789
And that's not even the start, dude.

1831
01:22:51.849 --> 01:22:52.309
Okay.

1832
01:22:52.889 --> 01:22:54.070
These are some other quotes from him.

1833
01:22:54.470 --> 01:22:59.032
Whenever you interview fat people, you feel bad because you know you're not going to hire them.

1834
01:23:00.132 --> 01:23:05.115
And then he doubles down later and he says that thin people are smarter.

1835
01:23:05.135 --> 01:23:05.395
Yeah.

1836
01:23:06.667 --> 01:23:08.168
What are you talking about?

1837
01:23:08.188 --> 01:23:10.170
Why is this consistent?

1838
01:23:10.290 --> 01:23:10.650
Anyway.

1839
01:23:10.690 --> 01:23:10.870
Yeah.

1840
01:23:10.890 --> 01:23:15.134
You know, earlier in the episode when I said like, you know, this guy's controversial.

1841
01:23:15.174 --> 01:23:15.454
Yeah.

1842
01:23:16.214 --> 01:23:17.315
It's more than controversial.

1843
01:23:17.335 --> 01:23:17.796
Yeah.

1844
01:23:17.836 --> 01:23:18.256
Right.

1845
01:23:18.536 --> 01:23:18.776
Yeah.

1846
01:23:18.836 --> 01:23:24.040
Like the behavior was not only problematic during the discovery.

1847
01:23:24.141 --> 01:23:24.401
Yeah.

1848
01:23:24.541 --> 01:23:24.761
Yeah.

1849
01:23:24.841 --> 01:23:25.702
During the discovery.

1850
01:23:25.722 --> 01:23:27.003
He's already like sketch.

1851
01:23:27.943 --> 01:23:31.826
Then afterwards trying to like rewrite history.

1852
01:23:31.846 --> 01:23:31.967
Yeah.

1853
01:23:32.687 --> 01:23:57.470
act also sketch also sketch and now you're just like just pointing fingers at everyone now he's just saying nonsense right and i just want to read you some of the other crazy stuff you said uh people say it would be terrible if we made all girls pretty i think it would be great bro i just just stop talking i just so at this point at this point cold spring harbor suspends any affiliation to him wait

1854
01:23:58.719 --> 01:24:01.802
Oh, yeah, he doesn't even leave the Indians alone.

1855
01:24:01.902 --> 01:24:03.344
So this is what he said about the Indians.

1856
01:24:03.364 --> 01:24:04.064
There's one more.

1857
01:24:04.105 --> 01:24:04.785
Yeah, there's one more.

1858
01:24:05.045 --> 01:24:05.686
I got to keep going.

1859
01:24:05.906 --> 01:24:08.609
So he doesn't leave the Indians alone.

1860
01:24:08.949 --> 01:24:14.075
He's like, Indians are servile because of selection under caste endogamy.

1861
01:24:14.315 --> 01:24:19.920
Caste endogamy meaning castes marry within castes in the Hindu tradition.

1862
01:24:20.461 --> 01:24:22.223
And because of that, we're servile.

1863
01:24:22.583 --> 01:24:28.285
Nothing to do with maybe the 200 years of colonialism that was subject to us by the British.

1864
01:24:28.605 --> 01:24:29.905
We'd love to never touch on that.

1865
01:24:29.925 --> 01:24:30.545
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1866
01:24:30.605 --> 01:24:31.306
It doesn't matter.

1867
01:24:31.366 --> 01:24:41.068
And the other thing is, look, with the caste system, it's like he's only basically interacted with the top tier of caste, probably.

1868
01:24:41.188 --> 01:24:49.491
Because the way the caste system works is the lower caste haven't really had the kinds of opportunities that the higher caste have because of the messed up nature of the caste system.

1869
01:24:49.511 --> 01:24:49.791
Correct.

1870
01:24:49.811 --> 01:24:50.011
So...

1871
01:24:50.935 --> 01:24:53.756
The stereotype doesn't, the argument doesn't even make sense.

1872
01:24:53.816 --> 01:24:54.836
It makes sense.

1873
01:24:54.856 --> 01:24:54.996
100%.

1874
01:24:55.016 --> 01:25:00.757
Because he's interacting with the, you know, it's like at least be scientific in your bigotry.

1875
01:25:01.617 --> 01:25:03.978
Africans are less intelligent than Westerners.

1876
01:25:04.358 --> 01:25:11.159
Watson said his intention was to promote science, not racism, but some UK venues canceled his appearance.

1877
01:25:11.219 --> 01:25:11.359
Yeah.

1878
01:25:11.399 --> 01:25:14.600
He was going on a book tour and the UK canceled his appearances.

1879
01:25:15.260 --> 01:25:15.400
Um,

1880
01:25:16.320 --> 01:25:21.845
In 2007, the Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory suspended any affiliation.

1881
01:25:22.125 --> 01:25:23.726
Even though he was the father.

1882
01:25:23.906 --> 01:25:25.647
He basically created it.

1883
01:25:26.068 --> 01:25:27.569
I mean, he's doubling down on this stuff.

1884
01:25:27.589 --> 01:25:29.230
He's not even apologizing.

1885
01:25:29.350 --> 01:25:31.432
He's just saying that, no, this is how it is.

1886
01:25:31.792 --> 01:25:36.836
And there's this YouTube page called Web of Stories.

1887
01:25:37.276 --> 01:25:38.818
It's one of my favorite YouTube stories.

1888
01:25:39.378 --> 01:25:52.446
channels big plug for web of stories yeah it really is because what they do is they they have these long-winded interviews with the titans of science so they have james watson but they also have freeman dyson for example hans beta um

1889
01:25:53.800 --> 01:25:56.281
They also have Edward Teller.

1890
01:25:56.421 --> 01:25:56.682
Yeah.

1891
01:25:56.722 --> 01:25:59.243
And they're just – it's just stream of consciousness about their life.

1892
01:25:59.363 --> 01:25:59.543
Yeah.

1893
01:25:59.603 --> 01:25:59.863
Okay?

1894
01:26:00.244 --> 01:26:03.025
The ones from Hans Bethe and Edward Teller, I really enjoy.

1895
01:26:03.045 --> 01:26:06.607
They talk about their time in Manhattan Project and all of the physics that they did.

1896
01:26:06.647 --> 01:26:09.209
They talk about their experience with Niels Bohr and things like that.

1897
01:26:11.188 --> 01:26:11.649
Right.

1898
01:26:11.729 --> 01:26:15.572
So they also did James Watson because he is a titan of science, let's be honest.

1899
01:26:15.612 --> 01:26:18.475
The 20th century, he discovered DNA, the structure of DNA.

1900
01:26:18.775 --> 01:26:21.938
He got there in weird ways, but at the end of the day, he's the one who got there first.

1901
01:26:22.159 --> 01:26:22.439
He won.

1902
01:26:22.459 --> 01:26:23.740
Yeah, he won that race.

1903
01:26:23.760 --> 01:26:26.943
Max Verstappen, he might be a little bit of a dirty race, but he wins.

1904
01:26:27.003 --> 01:26:27.544
Yeah, he wins.

1905
01:26:27.704 --> 01:26:33.409
And so there was this one clip where he's asked about Rosalind Franklin.

1906
01:26:33.430 --> 01:26:35.431
The first thing he says was, I can't give...

1907
01:26:36.193 --> 01:26:39.603
I can't give a lecture anywhere without a few questions about Rosie.

1908
01:26:39.944 --> 01:26:42.571
It's like, yeah, no, because you stole her data.

1909
01:26:44.508 --> 01:26:51.433
Like, okay, so he's clearly already not in a good mood because the interviewer is asking him about Rosalind Franklin.

1910
01:26:51.473 --> 01:26:54.155
And he thinks that Rosalind Franklin doesn't deserve all of this attention.

1911
01:26:55.295 --> 01:27:02.780
And then the most unhinged thing was like, you know, Rosalind, she was a woman and she was also Jewish.

1912
01:27:03.201 --> 01:27:06.403
And they say that the woman brain...

1913
01:27:07.338 --> 01:27:10.522
does not think in 3d and neither does the Jewish brain.

1914
01:27:10.542 --> 01:27:13.827
The Jewish brain does not think in 3d crazy, bro.

1915
01:27:13.847 --> 01:27:15.369
What are you talking about?

1916
01:27:15.389 --> 01:27:16.170
He's saying this, right.

1917
01:27:16.210 --> 01:27:18.894
And then the interviewer is like, Oh, what about like Einstein?

1918
01:27:20.176 --> 01:27:20.436
Right?

1919
01:27:20.917 --> 01:27:24.401
Like I, I literally did like 40 mathematics.

1920
01:27:24.421 --> 01:27:24.862
Yeah.

1921
01:27:25.743 --> 01:27:27.204
And he's just like, yeah, well, yeah.

1922
01:27:27.244 --> 01:27:28.845
But he was a man.

1923
01:27:28.865 --> 01:27:30.246
He had a penis.

1924
01:27:30.266 --> 01:27:33.307
Dude, it's so insane the stuff that this guy is saying.

1925
01:27:33.848 --> 01:27:39.911
So really, I don't really have a good appreciation for how unhinged and problematic this guy was.

1926
01:27:41.068 --> 01:27:43.829
But I saw that video and I was like, oh my God.

1927
01:27:43.849 --> 01:27:44.790
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

1928
01:27:45.070 --> 01:27:46.310
Like, he's just saying this.

1929
01:27:46.450 --> 01:27:49.391
Like, it's everyone, it's fair game on everybody.

1930
01:27:49.551 --> 01:27:53.033
If you're a woman, if you're a person of color, if you're Jewish.

1931
01:27:53.073 --> 01:27:54.053
Like, it doesn't matter.

1932
01:27:54.573 --> 01:27:58.555
Like, unless you're Watson, you ain't shit.

1933
01:27:58.995 --> 01:28:00.376
Dude, it was insane.

1934
01:28:00.396 --> 01:28:08.039
I was watching these videos just going like, this is the guy who discovered the double helix that we celebrate.

1935
01:28:08.199 --> 01:28:10.140
And, you know, it really...

1936
01:28:11.777 --> 01:28:13.379
I don't even know what to think, right?

1937
01:28:13.620 --> 01:28:15.502
Because clearly he's a great...

1938
01:28:17.649 --> 01:28:41.706
scientist and he's a great uh thinker and he's a great manager of science but man oh man terrible human being terrible human being i gotta say like one of the worst i mean there was such a great opportunity to actually uplift rosalind in that context yeah like and and have this like the uk is better than you like you could have had a whole yeah

1939
01:28:42.586 --> 01:28:44.487
Like narrative and story around...

1940
01:28:44.507 --> 01:28:47.169
There could have been so many other ways to go about...

1941
01:28:47.429 --> 01:28:47.649
Right.

1942
01:28:48.650 --> 01:28:50.371
And handling that situation.

1943
01:28:50.391 --> 01:28:58.255
And what's interesting is when we were growing up and we heard the story about Watson and Crick, none of this stuff was really kind of like... No, dude.

1944
01:28:58.355 --> 01:28:59.416
I read the double helix.

1945
01:28:59.476 --> 01:29:00.877
I read this version, right?

1946
01:29:00.957 --> 01:29:03.238
And it just shows that he's like this brilliant guy.

1947
01:29:03.598 --> 01:29:04.919
Everyone else around him is dumb.

1948
01:29:04.959 --> 01:29:05.539
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1949
01:29:05.699 --> 01:29:07.601
And like, you know, taking it at face value.

1950
01:29:07.741 --> 01:29:08.061
Yeah.

1951
01:29:08.221 --> 01:29:09.602
Which is why if you're going to...

1952
01:29:10.855 --> 01:29:11.415
Do anything.

1953
01:29:11.455 --> 01:29:13.676
Make sure you write your own biography.

1954
01:29:14.177 --> 01:29:15.037
Autobiography.

1955
01:29:15.097 --> 01:29:17.938
Because the world will make the story up of your life.

1956
01:29:18.498 --> 01:29:24.161
You either die a hero or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain.

1957
01:29:24.221 --> 01:29:24.481
Yeah.

1958
01:29:24.721 --> 01:29:25.962
Watson lived long enough.

1959
01:29:25.982 --> 01:29:26.302
Yeah.

1960
01:29:26.702 --> 01:29:28.264
To see himself become the villain.

1961
01:29:28.284 --> 01:29:29.645
But it's out of his own making.

1962
01:29:30.265 --> 01:29:30.445
Right.

1963
01:29:30.465 --> 01:29:32.007
He didn't have to say any of these things.

1964
01:29:32.067 --> 01:29:34.449
He could have just been a quiet old man.

1965
01:29:34.469 --> 01:29:36.091
The thing is, he didn't have to say any of it.

1966
01:29:36.131 --> 01:29:39.153
No, none of this.

1967
01:29:39.233 --> 01:29:43.437
This was so cool, though, because, like, again, this...

1968
01:29:43.838 --> 01:29:45.039
I know we kind of talk about it.

1969
01:29:45.079 --> 01:29:48.602
If you've reached this part of the episode...

1970
01:29:50.345 --> 01:29:54.728
In the comments, I want you to put Watson is not the guy.

1971
01:29:55.328 --> 01:29:55.548
Yeah.

1972
01:29:55.828 --> 01:29:56.589
Yeah, that's a good one.

1973
01:29:56.709 --> 01:29:57.929
Watson is not the guy.

1974
01:29:58.349 --> 01:30:01.731
That's how we'll know that people really enjoyed this journey.

1975
01:30:02.111 --> 01:30:03.472
I really enjoyed this journey.

1976
01:30:03.512 --> 01:30:04.192
Yeah.

1977
01:30:04.392 --> 01:30:07.454
Because DNA is one of these things that, again, we learn about in school.

1978
01:30:07.474 --> 01:30:08.154
We talk about.

1979
01:30:08.535 --> 01:30:09.655
It's Watson and Crick.

1980
01:30:09.695 --> 01:30:11.176
And it's like that's the only part of it.

1981
01:30:11.716 --> 01:30:12.557
Understanding this –

1982
01:30:13.597 --> 01:30:19.484
Cavendish versus Kings versus Caltech Caltech sort of like energy.

1983
01:30:19.504 --> 01:30:26.613
Uh, the, the starts and stops the actual fundamental science that led to the, like, how do we know?

1984
01:30:26.633 --> 01:30:27.133
Yeah.

1985
01:30:27.154 --> 01:30:27.334
Yeah.

1986
01:30:28.272 --> 01:30:30.253
How did we get there?

1987
01:30:30.693 --> 01:30:32.014
It was a triple helix at first.

1988
01:30:32.214 --> 01:30:32.614
Crazy.

1989
01:30:33.075 --> 01:30:33.815
Obviously dumb.

1990
01:30:34.095 --> 01:30:34.816
Yeah.

1991
01:30:34.896 --> 01:30:37.057
Now we're thinking about it.

1992
01:30:37.077 --> 01:30:39.178
Triple helix, you fucking idiot.

1993
01:30:40.019 --> 01:30:42.320
Asshole.

1994
01:30:42.420 --> 01:30:48.684
But really, from an image, from a 2D image of X-ray crystallography of...

1995
01:30:49.639 --> 01:30:54.221
like what the double being able to then extrapolate to the structure.

1996
01:30:54.482 --> 01:30:54.722
Yeah.

1997
01:30:54.942 --> 01:30:58.324
And shout out to Donahue who no one ever talks about.

1998
01:30:58.504 --> 01:31:01.825
No, but it's kind of like the last, the last little peg.

1999
01:31:01.845 --> 01:31:02.126
Yeah.

2000
01:31:02.286 --> 01:31:06.328
Peg in the, in the, in the structure to like get to the point of insight.

2001
01:31:07.628 --> 01:31:17.634
I think one of the most important things that I know as someone who works in tech startups and has been building teams for a long time is it's never about any individual.

2002
01:31:17.654 --> 01:31:17.754
Yeah.

2003
01:31:18.474 --> 01:31:30.140
It is always a team effort, whether that's one person gives 98% and another person gives 2% or 50-50 or there's 100 people or there's 1,000 people.

2004
01:31:31.661 --> 01:31:36.683
We are not sufficiently all-knowing as individuals.

2005
01:31:36.743 --> 01:31:36.964
Yeah.

2006
01:31:37.504 --> 01:31:39.065
And it requires collaboration.

2007
01:31:39.085 --> 01:31:39.545
Yeah, yeah.

2008
01:31:39.785 --> 01:31:40.966
It requires teamwork.

2009
01:31:42.264 --> 01:31:47.986
And just dogged commitment and unwillingness to give up.

2010
01:31:48.346 --> 01:31:48.586
Yeah.

2011
01:31:48.846 --> 01:31:50.547
To get to, like, these places.

2012
01:31:50.607 --> 01:31:52.087
Like, this is such a cool.

2013
01:31:52.648 --> 01:31:53.748
It's such a cool story.

2014
01:31:53.828 --> 01:31:54.668
It's such a cool story.

2015
01:31:54.688 --> 01:31:54.928
Yeah.

2016
01:31:54.968 --> 01:31:55.549
Because of the ending.

2017
01:31:55.569 --> 01:31:56.369
Science is not.

2018
01:31:56.389 --> 01:31:57.729
And these characters are so.

2019
01:31:57.809 --> 01:31:58.990
It's like Game of Thrones-y.

2020
01:31:59.010 --> 01:31:59.430
Yes, yes.

2021
01:32:00.050 --> 01:32:02.433
It is all science is a human story.

2022
01:32:02.913 --> 01:32:11.742
And we've talked about this before in a pod where it's like, even when you do a research paper, you're creating a narrative because raw data does not have a through line.

2023
01:32:11.762 --> 01:32:11.962
No.

2024
01:32:12.243 --> 01:32:14.865
That is, is digestible without, without,

2025
01:32:16.046 --> 01:32:19.589
framing and reference and context.

2026
01:32:20.149 --> 01:32:21.350
An unbelievable story.

2027
01:32:21.750 --> 01:32:28.875
Unfortunately, James Watson, again, as we mentioned at the beginning of the story, has recently passed away at age 97.

2028
01:32:29.576 --> 01:32:31.137
Clearly karma does not exist.

2029
01:32:31.157 --> 01:32:32.257
Yeah.

2030
01:32:33.458 --> 01:32:34.958
Because, you know, that's a whole thing.

2031
01:32:34.978 --> 01:32:36.219
Yeah, he lived till 97.

2032
01:32:36.259 --> 01:32:37.899
Rosalind Franklin only lived till 38.

2033
01:32:38.099 --> 01:32:40.860
And it's like, how does that work?

2034
01:32:41.200 --> 01:32:45.381
However, one of our best deep dives.

2035
01:32:45.601 --> 01:32:49.082
Yeah, I really enjoyed doing the research for this.

2036
01:32:49.282 --> 01:32:50.062
This was a good one.

2037
01:32:51.262 --> 01:32:52.262
We're in December now.

2038
01:32:52.603 --> 01:32:53.463
It's the holidays.

2039
01:32:53.503 --> 01:32:53.803
Yes.

2040
01:32:54.083 --> 01:33:02.685
As we get to the last episodes of season one, which will round us out for 2025, we are likely to do some probably best of episodes.

2041
01:33:03.325 --> 01:33:06.107
Maybe we'll do a little bit of a twist.

2042
01:33:06.647 --> 01:33:11.971
Had this idea of analyzing and breaking down the science of movies and TV.

2043
01:33:12.691 --> 01:33:14.032
Famous scenes we all know.

2044
01:33:15.770 --> 01:33:18.912
When Dr. Ian Malcolm talks about chaos theory.

2045
01:33:19.132 --> 01:33:20.193
Yeah.

2046
01:33:20.213 --> 01:33:21.834
And the amphibian DNA.

2047
01:33:21.854 --> 01:33:24.616
And you can just take some frog and mix it with... Yeah, yeah, yeah.

2048
01:33:24.656 --> 01:33:27.738
So the amber, or... We're not going to do Interstellar.

2049
01:33:27.778 --> 01:33:28.499
Everyone's already done that.

2050
01:33:28.539 --> 01:33:37.765
But we're going to try to do some concepts as we get into the holidays and it gets a little bit difficult for us to shoot to keep you guys tied over with the best content.

2051
01:33:37.885 --> 01:33:39.066
You guys are the best audience.

2052
01:33:39.086 --> 01:33:40.007
We're so grateful.

2053
01:33:40.447 --> 01:33:40.667
Thank you.

2054
01:33:40.687 --> 01:33:41.668
My name is Lester Nare.

2055
01:33:42.088 --> 01:33:43.169
As always, joined by...

2056
01:33:43.809 --> 01:33:51.316
our co-host and resident PhD, and the better brown person than Chamath, Krishna Chowdhury.

2057
01:33:52.777 --> 01:33:54.578
This is From First Principles.

2058
01:33:54.598 --> 01:33:55.519
We'll see you guys next week.

2059
01:33:56.020 --> 01:33:56.320
Peace.
