WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.131 --> 00:00:05.836
It's been 200 years and we still don't know why ice is slippery.

2
00:00:06.596 --> 00:00:09.038
We're getting close, but you know, it's... What?

3
00:00:09.098 --> 00:00:10.199
Yeah, it's kind of crazy.

4
00:00:11.040 --> 00:00:16.744
We have to lock in for this next story because it's about the neuroscience of choking under pressure.

5
00:00:16.904 --> 00:00:17.365
That's right.

6
00:00:17.505 --> 00:00:20.808
Which in this Winter Olympics we have seen in real time.

7
00:00:21.643 --> 00:00:25.764
The future of the Winter Olympics is not looking good, okay?

8
00:00:25.804 --> 00:00:31.625
Climate change is coming, and the Winter Olympics specifically are very much at risk.

9
00:00:32.205 --> 00:00:32.965
Hello, Internet.

10
00:00:32.985 --> 00:00:40.427
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

11
00:00:40.807 --> 00:00:48.068
For those watching, if you could not already tell, this week we're going to be doing a deep dive on the Winter Olympics today.

12
00:00:48.168 --> 00:00:48.869
We'll be right back.

13
00:01:03.170 --> 00:01:05.171
With a story about ice being slippery.

14
00:01:05.531 --> 00:01:05.791
Yeah.

15
00:01:06.331 --> 00:01:09.313
In the Winter Olympics, every sport depends on ice being slippery.

16
00:01:09.333 --> 00:01:13.034
But the science and physics specifically behind it is actually non-trivial.

17
00:01:13.134 --> 00:01:13.374
Yep.

18
00:01:13.975 --> 00:01:18.997
We'll follow that up with a neuroscience story around the idea of choking.

19
00:01:19.717 --> 00:01:19.957
right?

20
00:01:20.277 --> 00:01:22.658
Obviously, the stakes are high, especially at the Olympics.

21
00:01:23.139 --> 00:01:28.441
And there is really good neuroscience around why do people choke when the stakes are so high.

22
00:01:28.961 --> 00:01:37.825
We'll wrap up with our climate change story and a couple of other interesting tidbits as it relates to our deep dive on the Winter Olympics.

23
00:01:38.765 --> 00:01:47.329
You're going to learn stuff today because we're going to break down the science from its fundamentals because this is from First Principles.

24
00:02:02.823 --> 00:02:08.886
My friend, we are donned and prepared for our Winter Olympics deep dive.

25
00:02:09.107 --> 00:02:09.427
Yes.

26
00:02:09.747 --> 00:02:11.208
My first question for you is...

27
00:02:12.239 --> 00:02:12.819
What event?

28
00:02:13.320 --> 00:02:14.561
Because I know what you're good at.

29
00:02:15.141 --> 00:02:17.943
And so what event are you going to trial for?

30
00:02:18.223 --> 00:02:22.226
Yeah, I think the event that I compete in is the full send.

31
00:02:22.466 --> 00:02:23.086
The full send.

32
00:02:23.106 --> 00:02:29.130
The full send event, which is you're at the top with your skis, and then you just French fry the whole way down.

33
00:02:29.190 --> 00:02:29.911
No pizza.

34
00:02:29.951 --> 00:02:30.571
No pizza.

35
00:02:30.651 --> 00:02:36.775
You just French fry, and then you end up getting dragged out on one of those ski patrol sleds.

36
00:02:37.295 --> 00:02:37.495
Yeah.

37
00:02:37.976 --> 00:02:39.277
Who can do that the fastest?

38
00:02:39.477 --> 00:02:39.757
Yeah.

39
00:02:40.197 --> 00:02:42.400
With the least amount of actual injury.

40
00:02:43.061 --> 00:02:44.322
I compete in it all the time.

41
00:02:44.342 --> 00:02:45.363
It's great.

42
00:02:45.463 --> 00:02:46.544
Mammoth knows all about it.

43
00:02:48.807 --> 00:02:49.608
This is so good.

44
00:02:50.108 --> 00:02:53.272
So we're going to go ahead and get started with our physics story of the day.

45
00:02:54.862 --> 00:03:00.027
And the physics story is starting out with this idea of ice being slippery.

46
00:03:00.107 --> 00:03:02.069
Why is ice slippery?

47
00:03:02.929 --> 00:03:06.092
It turns out it's apparently not such a simple problem.

48
00:03:06.533 --> 00:03:12.258
And scientists have apparently been working on this for 200 years, but we still don't have a foolproof answer.

49
00:03:13.039 --> 00:03:17.263
So let's kind of talk because there's so many events in the Winter Olympics that deal with ice.

50
00:03:18.348 --> 00:03:23.651
Yeah, and they're all dependent on this central physical fact that ice is slippery.

51
00:03:23.671 --> 00:03:23.892
Yes.

52
00:03:24.152 --> 00:03:24.372
Right?

53
00:03:24.752 --> 00:03:26.673
And it's been a 200-year-old question.

54
00:03:27.494 --> 00:03:32.437
It's pretty incredible, the slipperiness of ice versus the friction on other solids, right?

55
00:03:32.497 --> 00:03:35.819
This is a great example that we saw in Minnesota.

56
00:03:36.059 --> 00:03:38.121
Our local Gestapo agents were...

57
00:03:39.236 --> 00:03:42.821
Named ice slipped on ice.

58
00:03:43.001 --> 00:03:45.925
This is not a political statement because this is not a political show.

59
00:03:45.945 --> 00:03:47.047
We are not a political show.

60
00:03:47.507 --> 00:03:51.673
I just think it's funny that ice slipped on ice.

61
00:03:52.274 --> 00:03:53.376
I just think that's funny.

62
00:03:54.603 --> 00:03:59.125
I don't think that's weird to bring up in a science podcast.

63
00:03:59.225 --> 00:04:01.406
We're talking about the slipperiness of ice.

64
00:04:01.586 --> 00:04:05.548
Yeah, we're talking about the slippery slope of ice, but I'm talking about the physics.

65
00:04:05.568 --> 00:04:11.670
I'm not talking about the extrajudicial powers of our federal police.

66
00:04:11.850 --> 00:04:12.611
No, no, no, no, no.

67
00:04:12.711 --> 00:04:13.891
I'm talking about the physics.

68
00:04:13.911 --> 00:04:15.632
So don't you dare come after me.

69
00:04:16.212 --> 00:04:16.833
in the comments.

70
00:04:17.293 --> 00:04:18.034
Actually, please do.

71
00:04:18.094 --> 00:04:20.495
I want to see what you'll come up with.

72
00:04:20.996 --> 00:04:25.159
But in any case, that's the central question that I want to answer today.

73
00:04:25.559 --> 00:04:30.723
And in fact, I'm not going to answer it because the research is still ongoing, which is quite incredible.

74
00:04:30.743 --> 00:04:32.265
It's such a simple question, right?

75
00:04:32.345 --> 00:04:33.486
Like, why is ice slippery?

76
00:04:33.866 --> 00:04:41.532
It's relevant to stuff like glaciology, like glaciers moving off continents into the oceans and then raising our sea levels.

77
00:04:41.972 --> 00:04:43.614
It's relevant for transportation.

78
00:04:43.874 --> 00:04:44.895
You don't want to slip on ice.

79
00:04:44.915 --> 00:04:45.215
Mm-hmm.

80
00:04:45.795 --> 00:05:08.758
um and obviously it's relevant for winter sports um the standard explanations are pretty bad okay okay they seem satisfying from like a high school physics level oh okay there's a layer of water and then the water makes it slippery but when you just go a little bit deeper it doesn't make any sense and it's it's actually quite interesting so

81
00:05:09.963 --> 00:05:12.924
Let's go to the 200-year-old question, right?

82
00:05:12.964 --> 00:05:14.905
200 years ago, there was this guy, Michael Faraday.

83
00:05:15.225 --> 00:05:18.927
He is the greatest of all time in terms of experimental physicists.

84
00:05:19.327 --> 00:05:21.048
You can come at me in the comments again.

85
00:05:21.648 --> 00:05:23.489
This guy is the GOAT, okay?

86
00:05:24.089 --> 00:05:24.309
Um...

87
00:05:25.441 --> 00:05:28.325
He's also actually the founder of scientific communication.

88
00:05:28.725 --> 00:05:29.707
It wasn't Carl Sagan.

89
00:05:30.187 --> 00:05:31.970
People think that Carl Sagan was this first guy.

90
00:05:32.010 --> 00:05:40.601
No, Michael Faraday used to have Christmas lectures at the Royal Institution where he would demonstrate electricity and magnetism for the common public.

91
00:05:41.022 --> 00:05:42.744
And there are these very famous...

92
00:05:43.585 --> 00:05:47.647
you know, outreach events that happened in the 1800s in London.

93
00:05:47.967 --> 00:05:51.109
So, you know, this guy's an OG and I love everything about him.

94
00:05:51.429 --> 00:05:58.973
And one of the many things that he did, he did, you know, electricity and magnetism is what he's really famous for, but he actually did experiments all over the place.

95
00:05:59.393 --> 00:06:10.479
And he's the first to observe something called regulation, which is this idea that there's a permanent liquid-like layer of water around every ice block.

96
00:06:10.499 --> 00:06:10.779
Yeah.

97
00:06:11.192 --> 00:06:11.433
Okay.

98
00:06:11.956 --> 00:06:13.482
And people sort of took that.

99
00:06:14.435 --> 00:06:43.115
observation and said oh that's why ice is slippery because there's a little bit of water on top right i just want to make a quick note that we are not talking about the system that puts a premier league team in england is that called regulation it's called relegation oh relegation yeah i've heard that i've heard that from my cousins are really into arsenal and they're like oh they're gonna get so for example used in a sentence tottenham hotspur

100
00:06:44.235 --> 00:06:46.316
is potentially in the relegation zone.

101
00:06:46.717 --> 00:06:47.377
Oh, are they really?

102
00:06:47.517 --> 00:06:47.757
Yes.

103
00:06:48.318 --> 00:06:48.758
However.

104
00:06:48.958 --> 00:06:50.099
Did they have a terrible season?

105
00:06:50.119 --> 00:06:51.439
So they're going to go down?

106
00:06:51.459 --> 00:06:52.480
They're potentially going to go down.

107
00:06:52.920 --> 00:06:53.981
How do you feel about that?

108
00:06:54.101 --> 00:06:54.962
You're a Chelsea fan.

109
00:06:55.082 --> 00:06:56.382
I am ecstatic about it.

110
00:06:56.462 --> 00:06:56.723
Right.

111
00:06:56.763 --> 00:06:57.063
Yeah.

112
00:06:57.083 --> 00:06:57.283
Okay.

113
00:06:57.303 --> 00:06:58.244
That's what I thought.

114
00:06:58.264 --> 00:06:59.064
I'm ecstatic about it.

115
00:06:59.084 --> 00:07:00.045
It's happened again.

116
00:07:00.485 --> 00:07:01.786
It's happened again.

117
00:07:01.806 --> 00:07:03.307
Tottenham Hotspur.

118
00:07:03.767 --> 00:07:04.727
It's happened again.

119
00:07:04.747 --> 00:07:05.768
Okay.

120
00:07:06.328 --> 00:07:07.089
But we're talking about.

121
00:07:09.097 --> 00:07:09.757
Regulation.

122
00:07:09.837 --> 00:07:10.558
Regulation.

123
00:07:10.958 --> 00:07:12.719
Which, just to be clear here.

124
00:07:12.859 --> 00:07:16.660
Yeah, that's the liquid layer of water on top of ice.

125
00:07:16.720 --> 00:07:18.941
And this liquid layer can be nanometers thick.

126
00:07:19.302 --> 00:07:22.463
It can be only like a few molecules to tens or hundreds of molecules.

127
00:07:22.563 --> 00:07:22.843
Okay.

128
00:07:22.863 --> 00:07:23.023
Right?

129
00:07:23.603 --> 00:07:27.345
And for the longest time, Michael Faraday did some experiments that showed that this is true.

130
00:07:28.005 --> 00:07:33.368
And for the longest time, it was like, oh, like those water molecules are what's causing the slipperiness.

131
00:07:33.548 --> 00:07:33.888
Right.

132
00:07:34.108 --> 00:07:47.534
When we started getting into some deep thermodynamics, the Thompson brothers, the most famous of whom is Lord Kelvin, he started looking at the statistical mechanics of what happens at this interface between ice and liquid water.

133
00:07:47.574 --> 00:07:52.296
Liquid water is very interesting because just water in general is very interesting.

134
00:07:52.316 --> 00:07:53.657
It's one of these unique compounds.

135
00:07:53.697 --> 00:08:01.160
Because of the geometry of the molecule, it increases in volume.

136
00:08:02.193 --> 00:08:02.954
When you freeze it.

137
00:08:03.534 --> 00:08:04.655
This is very strange.

138
00:08:04.675 --> 00:08:05.976
This is why ice floats.

139
00:08:06.677 --> 00:08:11.661
Ice is less dense than liquid water.

140
00:08:12.121 --> 00:08:16.705
The solid phase of water is less dense than the liquid phase, which is why ice floats.

141
00:08:17.105 --> 00:08:19.707
This has everything to do with the geometry of the water molecule.

142
00:08:19.727 --> 00:08:24.851
The fact that it's 104 degrees between these two bonds of oxygen, hydrogen, oxygen, hydrogen.

143
00:08:25.371 --> 00:08:25.532
Um...

144
00:08:26.432 --> 00:08:34.735
And for the longest time, that's been kind of the dominant explanation is because the volume increases.

145
00:08:35.235 --> 00:08:38.236
Suppose now I were to press down on ice, right?

146
00:08:38.296 --> 00:08:40.637
If I stand on ice with skates or something like that.

147
00:08:41.512 --> 00:08:42.333
I'm pressing down.

148
00:08:42.433 --> 00:08:43.833
I'm increasing the pressure.

149
00:08:44.374 --> 00:08:47.555
And what physics wants to do at all times is resist change.

150
00:08:48.056 --> 00:08:55.740
And so when I press and I compress the volume, it's going to undo the freezing part and become liquid.

151
00:08:56.180 --> 00:08:57.041
Does that make sense?

152
00:08:57.281 --> 00:08:59.182
Like when water freezes, it expands.

153
00:08:59.622 --> 00:09:02.664
I'm pushing in, so I'm going to make it unfreeze.

154
00:09:02.764 --> 00:09:07.847
I'm going to make the water sort of come back as liquid instead of being in the solid form.

155
00:09:08.167 --> 00:09:09.188
And that's the...

156
00:09:10.162 --> 00:09:12.602
I mean, I've heard this explanation even from Feynman.

157
00:09:13.003 --> 00:09:20.564
There's a really famous interview with Feynman where a guy asks him, you know, why, how do magnets work?

158
00:09:21.344 --> 00:09:27.185
And he goes on this random tangent stream of consciousness about what do you mean?

159
00:09:27.245 --> 00:09:28.005
Why does it work?

160
00:09:28.305 --> 00:09:29.366
And the interview is like, I don't know.

161
00:09:29.386 --> 00:09:30.446
It's a simple question.

162
00:09:30.486 --> 00:09:31.306
Why do magnets work?

163
00:09:31.326 --> 00:09:33.966
And he's like, well, you know, suppose there were an alien around.

164
00:09:34.346 --> 00:09:36.807
And I said, grandma slipped on the ice.

165
00:09:36.827 --> 00:09:37.127
Yeah.

166
00:09:37.975 --> 00:09:42.158
How far deep would I have to go into the explanation to tell him what I mean?

167
00:09:42.498 --> 00:09:49.503
And then he talks about, oh, well, grandma slipped on the ice because ice is one of these unique compounds that is slippery when you stand on it because of the pressure and all this stuff.

168
00:09:49.523 --> 00:09:51.284
And he even cited this thing, right?

169
00:09:52.385 --> 00:09:58.309
But let's just like try to hone in on this explanation.

170
00:09:58.649 --> 00:09:59.470
The explanation is...

171
00:10:01.337 --> 00:10:02.358
I squish the ice.

172
00:10:03.198 --> 00:10:04.299
The ice becomes water.

173
00:10:04.920 --> 00:10:05.180
Okay?

174
00:10:05.980 --> 00:10:12.145
That works for negative temperatures like negative 2 degrees Celsius, negative 3 degrees Celsius.

175
00:10:12.345 --> 00:10:12.605
Okay.

176
00:10:12.885 --> 00:10:19.750
When you're getting to something like negative 20 degrees Celsius to negative 30 degrees Celsius, I can still skate on that ice.

177
00:10:20.831 --> 00:10:25.334
But this explanation won't work because I'm so cold, no matter how much I press, I'm so cold.

178
00:10:26.598 --> 00:10:34.340
The physics at that scale, the statistical mechanics of this bulk body, it's not going to let the water come out.

179
00:10:34.861 --> 00:10:48.445
The idea being when temperatures are colder, simply applying pressure from your ice skate onto the ice is no longer going to change that surface layer from its solid state to its liquid state.

180
00:10:48.505 --> 00:10:48.985
And so...

181
00:10:49.705 --> 00:10:51.727
You actually got it right there, the surface layer.

182
00:10:52.088 --> 00:10:54.891
There's some different physics happening at the surface layer.

183
00:10:54.911 --> 00:10:55.351
Interesting.

184
00:10:55.431 --> 00:11:00.777
And we can't count on the big equations that we use in statistical mechanics.

185
00:11:00.937 --> 00:11:06.083
For example, the main one is the Clausius-Clapeyron equation, and that's the one that gives us this phase diagram.

186
00:11:06.103 --> 00:11:08.826
We can't actually use that in this scenario.

187
00:11:08.846 --> 00:11:09.467
Mm-hmm.

188
00:11:10.852 --> 00:11:14.513
What we need to do is think about what is actually happening at the surface level.

189
00:11:14.893 --> 00:11:17.093
It can't be pressure because of what I just told you, right?

190
00:11:17.373 --> 00:11:25.555
It's not enough to explain the slipperiness of ice at really, really cold temperatures, at negative 20, negative 30 degrees Celsius.

191
00:11:26.135 --> 00:11:30.556
So in 1939, Bowden and Hughes came up with an explanation.

192
00:11:30.897 --> 00:11:36.778
They said that actually there's heat generated by friction, and that heat is what causes melting.

193
00:11:37.358 --> 00:11:44.641
Okay, so now we've got a good way to get a layer of water in between whatever I'm standing on.

194
00:11:44.661 --> 00:11:45.382
Let's say skates.

195
00:11:45.642 --> 00:11:47.283
Let's use skates for this whole example.

196
00:11:47.643 --> 00:11:48.643
I'm standing on skates.

197
00:11:49.144 --> 00:11:55.466
Between my skates and the ice, there's going to be a tiny liquid of water because layer of water because I'm going to move with the skates.

198
00:11:55.487 --> 00:12:02.690
That's going to cause friction, and the friction is going to cause heating, and that heating is going to cause some melting, and I'm going to get a layer of water.

199
00:12:03.150 --> 00:12:10.835
What it makes me think about is when, you know, you were in kindergarten or first grade, you're running around and you're in the classroom and the classroom had a rug.

200
00:12:11.195 --> 00:12:18.500
And somehow you ended up sliding on your knees like Harry Maguire after scoring a header and you get rug burn and it would feel hot.

201
00:12:18.660 --> 00:12:18.880
Yes.

202
00:12:19.240 --> 00:12:21.382
Because your knees were moving on the surface.

203
00:12:21.902 --> 00:12:26.405
That was friction and it was heat and the heat burned my flesh.

204
00:12:26.565 --> 00:12:26.785
Yeah.

205
00:12:26.825 --> 00:12:28.026
But similarly, the.

206
00:12:28.046 --> 00:12:30.347
But also, if you were to measure the temperature of the carpet.

207
00:12:30.428 --> 00:12:30.608
Yep.

208
00:12:31.288 --> 00:12:32.688
It would be a tiny bit warmer.

209
00:12:32.708 --> 00:12:33.448
It would be warmer.

210
00:12:33.568 --> 00:12:33.748
Yeah.

211
00:12:33.828 --> 00:12:44.250
And so the point is, you know, this contact between the bottom of the skate and the top of the ice layer, we understand intuitively as just regular people.

212
00:12:44.390 --> 00:12:44.610
Yeah.

213
00:12:44.870 --> 00:12:48.211
That when we rub our hands together or we slide our knees on rugs, there's heat there.

214
00:12:48.231 --> 00:12:48.831
There's heat there.

215
00:12:48.911 --> 00:12:52.592
And that's the entry point potentially for what they're trying to say here.

216
00:12:52.632 --> 00:12:52.792
Yep.

217
00:12:52.952 --> 00:12:53.132
Yep.

218
00:12:53.352 --> 00:12:53.592
Exactly.

219
00:12:53.612 --> 00:12:54.132
Bowden and Hughes.

220
00:12:54.392 --> 00:12:54.612
Yes.

221
00:12:54.672 --> 00:12:57.373
That was Bowden and Hughes in 1939 out of the Royal Society.

222
00:12:58.073 --> 00:12:58.353
Okay.

223
00:12:58.373 --> 00:12:59.073
That's all fine.

224
00:12:59.093 --> 00:12:59.333
Okay.

225
00:13:00.093 --> 00:13:03.817
Except the lubricant in this case is still liquid water.

226
00:13:04.858 --> 00:13:05.058
Yes?

227
00:13:05.318 --> 00:13:05.498
Yeah.

228
00:13:05.639 --> 00:13:07.921
In between the two contact surfaces, right?

229
00:13:07.941 --> 00:13:08.461
There's ice.

230
00:13:08.882 --> 00:13:10.143
There's my skates that are metal.

231
00:13:10.503 --> 00:13:12.585
And the lubricant in between is liquid water.

232
00:13:12.665 --> 00:13:15.388
And that's what you're saying is what's causing slipperiness, right?

233
00:13:15.888 --> 00:13:19.612
Liquid water is a terrible lubricant, okay?

234
00:13:20.373 --> 00:13:22.555
Because it has very low viscosity, right?

235
00:13:24.327 --> 00:13:43.555
point yeah the reason why life works the reason why water can go up the phylum and xylem of plants is because it's very low viscosity so the leaf when the leaf pulls on some water it'll go all the way up to the roots and that force will get relegated right that makes sense so it's it's actually a feature of water that it's very low viscosity yes

236
00:13:44.215 --> 00:13:52.519
But that's not going to work in this case because whenever we want to lubricate metal on metal, for example, we use oil, right?

237
00:13:52.619 --> 00:13:53.999
Like car oil and things like that.

238
00:13:54.580 --> 00:13:56.260
Those things have very high viscosity.

239
00:13:56.561 --> 00:13:59.162
The point of high viscosity is if I have a contact...

240
00:13:59.642 --> 00:14:21.431
between two pieces i don't want the liquid in between to give way right i want it i want there to be a film in between such that there's no metal on metal contact or in this case solid on solid contact you need high viscosity such that the the the liquid actually resists that tension the pressure the pressure yeah yeah

241
00:14:22.872 --> 00:14:24.073
Liquid water is not going to do that.

242
00:14:24.293 --> 00:14:24.553
Got it.

243
00:14:24.653 --> 00:14:26.635
Liquid water is just going to get the hell out of the way.

244
00:14:27.135 --> 00:14:40.525
And so the thickness of that film, if you were to actually the hydrodynamic thickness of that film is going to be nanometers or less compared to something like a highly viscous substance like oil.

245
00:14:40.685 --> 00:14:43.067
That's why we use oil in our engines and not water.

246
00:14:43.387 --> 00:14:46.510
If we used water, the engine parts would be rubbing up against each other.

247
00:14:46.690 --> 00:14:47.731
It would not be a good time.

248
00:14:47.751 --> 00:14:47.971
Mm hmm.

249
00:14:48.411 --> 00:14:48.651
Right.

250
00:14:49.152 --> 00:14:51.713
So that's the central discrepancy.

251
00:14:51.733 --> 00:14:52.714
Now we're at 1939.

252
00:14:52.954 --> 00:14:53.655
Yes.

253
00:14:53.735 --> 00:14:55.276
We figured out why there's liquid water.

254
00:14:55.356 --> 00:14:55.576
Yes.

255
00:14:56.176 --> 00:15:00.199
But we haven't quite figured out how the liquid water becomes this lubricant.

256
00:15:00.319 --> 00:15:00.940
It really shouldn't.

257
00:15:01.340 --> 00:15:01.560
Right.

258
00:15:01.640 --> 00:15:07.504
Because because what we're saying is just by the skate blade in our analogy contacting the ice.

259
00:15:07.745 --> 00:15:08.025
Mm hmm.

260
00:15:08.565 --> 00:15:14.829
On its own, based on what we know, it should not create that nanometer scale layer of water.

261
00:15:14.869 --> 00:15:15.429
Yeah, yeah.

262
00:15:15.750 --> 00:15:17.010
Like, how does that happen?

263
00:15:17.030 --> 00:15:24.755
Yeah, like, if it's a nanometer scale... No, if we do the physics, the scale should be nanometers.

264
00:15:24.795 --> 00:15:25.636
It should be nanometers.

265
00:15:25.656 --> 00:15:27.597
But it needs to be a lot thicker.

266
00:15:28.097 --> 00:15:37.346
Nanometers is like tens of atoms One nanometer is ten hydrogen atoms That's not enough To keep me from contacting the ice Right?

267
00:15:37.506 --> 00:15:38.047
You know what I mean?

268
00:15:38.607 --> 00:15:41.270
So that's the idea How do we get a layer of water

269
00:15:44.152 --> 00:15:47.875
And we get that layer of water to be more viscous than bulk liquid water.

270
00:15:48.075 --> 00:15:48.476
Understood.

271
00:15:48.536 --> 00:15:48.736
Okay?

272
00:15:49.136 --> 00:15:59.365
And that's where there was this beautiful paper in 2019 in the Physical Review X by Canale and other authors, Nanoreology of Intrafacial Water During Ice Gliding.

273
00:16:00.165 --> 00:16:09.358
This is a paper that tried to understand why the water was slimy between my skate and my ice.

274
00:16:09.879 --> 00:16:10.119
Okay?

275
00:16:10.700 --> 00:16:11.942
Is slimy a technical term?

276
00:16:12.162 --> 00:16:16.188
Yes, I believe slimy is viscosity is anything above whatever oil is.

277
00:16:17.943 --> 00:16:21.206
I don't actually know what the numbers or the units for viscosity are.

278
00:16:21.466 --> 00:16:22.688
That's something I should look up later.

279
00:16:22.988 --> 00:16:25.651
But the point, it is meant to be a technical description.

280
00:16:25.671 --> 00:16:25.831
Yes.

281
00:16:26.431 --> 00:16:27.032
It's meant to be.

282
00:16:27.072 --> 00:16:28.854
It's much more slimy than normal water.

283
00:16:28.914 --> 00:16:30.155
Normal water is not slimy.

284
00:16:30.175 --> 00:16:30.375
Yes.

285
00:16:30.595 --> 00:16:30.755
Right?

286
00:16:30.836 --> 00:16:32.577
I can just, like, get rid of it.

287
00:16:32.697 --> 00:16:33.738
It'll evaporate away.

288
00:16:33.979 --> 00:16:35.260
Slimy stuff doesn't evaporate.

289
00:16:35.280 --> 00:16:35.860
It's viscous.

290
00:16:35.941 --> 00:16:36.481
It's sticky.

291
00:16:36.701 --> 00:16:37.262
Things like that.

292
00:16:37.282 --> 00:16:37.462
Okay.

293
00:16:37.962 --> 00:16:38.663
And we need that.

294
00:16:38.803 --> 00:16:39.063
Okay.

295
00:16:39.483 --> 00:16:48.069
So the key challenge is that this film between the ice and where the water is sitting between my blade is an ephemeral film.

296
00:16:48.149 --> 00:16:50.870
It only exists during this dynamic act of sliding.

297
00:16:51.171 --> 00:16:52.972
Let's get into some of the chemistry behind this.

298
00:16:53.981 --> 00:16:56.962
what ice is, and how that layer works.

299
00:16:57.022 --> 00:16:58.363
So you've got a solid layer.

300
00:16:58.643 --> 00:17:01.924
The solid layer is very high molecular order.

301
00:17:02.224 --> 00:17:10.047
You've got nice water molecules that are stuck in a crystal form, regularly spaced, characteristic of solids, right?

302
00:17:10.387 --> 00:17:16.129
So all of these water molecules are sort of, you know, interacting with each other, but they make this hexagonal lattice.

303
00:17:17.580 --> 00:17:27.048
The layer in between my ice and my skate is going to be the pseudo liquid layer where there's going to be a lot of molecular disorder, right?

304
00:17:27.108 --> 00:17:30.491
Because if you go down, the order is really high.

305
00:17:30.671 --> 00:17:32.153
And if you go up, it's fully liquid.

306
00:17:32.393 --> 00:17:37.797
There's going to be some transition where the water molecules are behaving in a very unique way, right?

307
00:17:37.817 --> 00:17:38.238
Mm-hmm.

308
00:17:38.718 --> 00:17:40.860
That's what this paper was trying to solve.

309
00:17:40.981 --> 00:17:46.486
What is the chemistry and the physical properties of that interfacial layer of water molecules?

310
00:17:46.887 --> 00:17:48.368
Where there is a high disorder.

311
00:17:48.809 --> 00:17:50.230
Yes, where there's high disorder.

312
00:17:50.350 --> 00:17:54.595
And can that actually tell us something about why the viscosity is so high?

313
00:17:55.155 --> 00:17:55.336
Right?

314
00:17:55.876 --> 00:17:56.016
And...

315
00:17:56.897 --> 00:18:00.499
What they used is something called an atomic force microscope, but with a tuning fork.

316
00:18:00.539 --> 00:18:03.941
So an atomic force microscope is this incredible technology.

317
00:18:03.961 --> 00:18:08.323
This is one of the technologies that I thought should win the Nobel Prize this year that I called.

318
00:18:08.743 --> 00:18:10.124
Didn't get it, but I think it's coming.

319
00:18:10.164 --> 00:18:12.685
The AFM is an amazing tool.

320
00:18:13.085 --> 00:18:14.866
It's effectively a cantilever.

321
00:18:15.206 --> 00:18:18.368
So you've got a little pointy thingy that's pointed downwards, right?

322
00:18:19.048 --> 00:18:25.612
And if I've got a sample with molecular level irregularities, like I'm talking tens of nanometers to less...

323
00:18:26.412 --> 00:18:29.173
When I bring this thing up, it's going to move up and down, right?

324
00:18:29.253 --> 00:18:33.834
Because the literal atoms on my surface are going to resist the cantilever.

325
00:18:34.214 --> 00:18:43.597
And if I have a laser that's shining on the cantilever, and then it's on a detector, as the cantilever moves, the laser on that detector is going to move, right?

326
00:18:43.877 --> 00:18:46.738
And then I'm going to be able to sense these tiny atoms.

327
00:18:47.518 --> 00:19:02.184
surface level atomic irregularities and that's what the atomic force microscope is doing it's it's been revolutionizing surface chemistry studies like all over the place from biology to chemistry everything right

328
00:19:02.504 --> 00:19:09.849
I think if I remember correctly, the way we analogized it was it's like when you have a record player.

329
00:19:09.929 --> 00:19:10.550
Yes, exactly.

330
00:19:10.570 --> 00:19:15.053
And it's reading a record, but just with a laser for precision on the readings.

331
00:19:15.593 --> 00:19:17.354
And the records are at atomic scale.

332
00:19:17.374 --> 00:19:20.016
Atomic scale versus whatever records are currently.

333
00:19:20.036 --> 00:19:23.719
But just as a visual analogy for folks, that's kind of the reference.

334
00:19:23.759 --> 00:19:24.779
Yeah, that's exactly right.

335
00:19:25.100 --> 00:19:26.701
And with the atomic force microscope...

336
00:19:27.399 --> 00:19:32.780
The problem is you're only going to read this sort of X, Y... Or sorry, the Z displacement, right?

337
00:19:32.800 --> 00:19:34.061
The up and down displacement.

338
00:19:34.421 --> 00:19:39.922
What we want to know with ice, because we're sliding, is we got to get this, right?

339
00:19:39.962 --> 00:19:44.584
So they made a tuning fork, Autonomic Force Microscope.

340
00:19:44.624 --> 00:19:51.926
A tuning fork is if you're a musician, you know these like two prongs of metal that will vibrate at a specific frequency.

341
00:19:51.946 --> 00:19:52.986
So if you want an A...

342
00:19:54.126 --> 00:19:57.349
the size of these prongs tells you that it's only going to vibrate at an A.

343
00:19:57.670 --> 00:20:03.375
And so when you bounce it, it's going to be like, and it's only going to be at this really clean tone.

344
00:20:04.256 --> 00:20:06.938
They took a tuning fork microscope and they attached it.

345
00:20:07.178 --> 00:20:11.522
Sorry, they took a tuning fork and they attached it to an atomic force microscope.

346
00:20:11.882 --> 00:20:15.866
They attached that to a bead that would interface with the ice.

347
00:20:15.886 --> 00:20:17.447
So the bead is kind of like my skates.

348
00:20:17.467 --> 00:20:17.547
Yes.

349
00:20:17.788 --> 00:20:18.008
Yes.

350
00:20:18.348 --> 00:20:20.149
I have a tuning fork on top.

351
00:20:20.189 --> 00:20:20.390
Yes.

352
00:20:20.630 --> 00:20:20.870
Okay?

353
00:20:21.150 --> 00:20:23.712
That tuning fork is going to vibrate sideways.

354
00:20:23.932 --> 00:20:24.133
Yes.

355
00:20:24.693 --> 00:20:30.638
And that sideways vibration is really tapped in to whatever resonant frequency that tuning fork is at.

356
00:20:30.838 --> 00:20:31.018
Right?

357
00:20:31.138 --> 00:20:31.238
Yes.

358
00:20:31.258 --> 00:20:35.201
If I've tuned that tuning fork to an A, it's only really going to vibrate at an A.

359
00:20:35.321 --> 00:20:35.461
Right.

360
00:20:35.802 --> 00:20:35.962
Right.

361
00:20:36.262 --> 00:20:36.482
Right.

362
00:20:36.562 --> 00:20:36.722
Yes.

363
00:20:37.003 --> 00:20:39.505
And the up and down can be the atomic force part.

364
00:20:39.685 --> 00:20:40.005
I see.

365
00:20:40.025 --> 00:20:44.528
But the sideways part can be my tuning fork vibrating at a very specific frequency.

366
00:20:44.548 --> 00:20:44.708
Yes.

367
00:20:45.229 --> 00:20:45.469
Okay.

368
00:20:45.729 --> 00:20:49.432
So now I can get both the up and down motion.

369
00:20:49.472 --> 00:20:49.672
Yes.

370
00:20:50.092 --> 00:20:51.513
And the side to side motion.

371
00:20:52.434 --> 00:20:55.215
And I get two resonance modes in this case.

372
00:20:55.295 --> 00:20:57.776
I've got a tangential mode, which is my stroke.

373
00:20:58.196 --> 00:21:03.037
And that's going parallel to the lubrication layer.

374
00:21:03.177 --> 00:21:03.397
Yes.

375
00:21:03.517 --> 00:21:08.599
So I can characterize the little thin film of water that's created.

376
00:21:08.999 --> 00:21:09.539
How is it...

377
00:21:10.647 --> 00:21:38.442
responding this way and how is it responding this way independently so so what we've done now uh with this uh afm plus tuning fork is we've added an additional variable layer that we can measure before we were measuring in one dimension yeah we were just doing okay what's the height of this thing right but now it's like what's the mechanical response this way and so now we have two different dimensions of measurement

378
00:21:39.202 --> 00:21:49.785
that can be appropriately and robustly measured independently of each other, which means we can better characterize what's happening because we have more data and information.

379
00:21:49.925 --> 00:21:50.366
Exactly.

380
00:21:50.526 --> 00:21:50.746
Yeah.

381
00:21:50.906 --> 00:21:54.427
We have data in all three dimensions, and we also have data in time.

382
00:21:54.727 --> 00:21:56.087
That's going to be huge, right?

383
00:21:56.368 --> 00:22:03.390
Because with the tuning fork, I can make it resonate at a certain frequency, and I can tell what the responses of my...

384
00:22:04.170 --> 00:22:05.291
material, right?

385
00:22:05.612 --> 00:22:20.807
So there's going to be two things, and this comes from, you know, if there's any electrical engineers out there, they must have heard of this concept of impedance, which is the idea, it's kind of like a resistance, but for AC circuits, for the alternating circuits, because when you have direct current...

386
00:22:21.552 --> 00:22:24.818
The current goes through, the resistance sort of just like stops the current from happening.

387
00:22:25.058 --> 00:22:31.429
And then the output voltage is going to be a little bit lower because you've lost a bunch of energy inside that resistor.

388
00:22:32.190 --> 00:22:34.795
When you're doing alternating current and you put a resistor in there,

389
00:22:36.341 --> 00:22:41.724
the output is going to be another alternating current, but there's going to be a phase shift.

390
00:22:42.124 --> 00:22:49.669
There's going to be a time delay because the resistor is not only reducing the amount of energy, it's also causing a time delay.

391
00:22:49.969 --> 00:22:52.570
And that's actually what they see with this water.

392
00:22:52.630 --> 00:22:55.592
This water has mechanical impedance.

393
00:22:55.632 --> 00:23:04.517
So there's an elastic property, which makes it sort of dissipate energy, but there's also this viscous dissipative component that is creating dissipation.

394
00:23:06.302 --> 00:23:11.145
poke the tuning fork and the tuning fork is going in this way, my response is going to have a delay.

395
00:23:11.645 --> 00:23:14.327
And that delay tells us a lot about the viscosity of that layer.

396
00:23:14.367 --> 00:23:17.369
And it turns out that layer is highly viscous.

397
00:23:17.869 --> 00:23:20.311
It's not the viscosity of normal water.

398
00:23:21.211 --> 00:23:25.874
And so this is the first indicator of the slimy water that we talked about earlier.

399
00:23:26.034 --> 00:23:27.075
On Amit's face...

400
00:23:27.935 --> 00:23:39.099
Water is not very viscous, which allows it to, in the tree example, float up because it's not introducing new friction.

401
00:23:39.179 --> 00:23:39.979
Yeah, it's very slippery.

402
00:23:39.999 --> 00:23:43.320
It's very slippery, which means it can move around very easily.

403
00:23:43.960 --> 00:23:51.143
In order for skating, ice skating, to work in the way we think about it, at a minimum, the top layer of the big body of ice...

404
00:23:52.272 --> 00:23:53.793
Needs to be extremely viscous.

405
00:23:53.893 --> 00:23:54.734
Exactly.

406
00:23:55.114 --> 00:23:56.716
Meaning not slippery.

407
00:23:57.096 --> 00:24:03.562
Meaning being able to catch onto, basically grab onto the blade as it's moving on top of the surface.

408
00:24:03.922 --> 00:24:11.409
And this is the first indication where we can measure and see that, oh, actually that top layer is highly viscous.

409
00:24:11.909 --> 00:24:14.691
And if you were to now calculate, how thick would the film be?

410
00:24:15.512 --> 00:24:15.752
Yes.

411
00:24:16.112 --> 00:24:18.873
It's now 100 to 500 nanometers.

412
00:24:19.033 --> 00:24:19.693
Instead of just a couple.

413
00:24:19.713 --> 00:24:23.394
Yeah, it's like two orders of magnitude above what we thought it should be before.

414
00:24:23.694 --> 00:24:26.295
And so now that layer is enough.

415
00:24:26.575 --> 00:24:26.775
Right.

416
00:24:26.835 --> 00:24:31.376
To lubricate this contact between my blade and the ice.

417
00:24:31.396 --> 00:24:31.836
And the ice.

418
00:24:32.156 --> 00:24:32.356
Right.

419
00:24:32.796 --> 00:24:34.236
And this was in 2019.

420
00:24:34.316 --> 00:24:37.717
It was, I thought it was a really cool experiment.

421
00:24:37.737 --> 00:24:41.218
Just the way that they constructed an AFM, which is pretty established now.

422
00:24:45.519 --> 00:25:14.441
displacement as well i just want to briefly note this is a very interesting point about how when tools are built afm crisper etc etc tools are let's say platforms however you want to categorize it they're not uh in a finite state of completion no right you can add your aftermarket attachments yeah on top of it for different use cases and this is a perfect example of taking afm and having a little additional attachment on there that allows you to see stuff a little bit differently that's very cool

423
00:25:14.481 --> 00:25:15.242
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

424
00:25:15.342 --> 00:25:15.882
It's very cool.

425
00:25:15.962 --> 00:25:30.773
And the other thing that they could tell from this new technology is like not only why is it viscous, they could also tell that the reason why that thing was viscous is because there's tiny little ice crystals in that layer of water that's causing the viscosity to go up.

426
00:25:30.913 --> 00:25:31.474
Interesting.

427
00:25:31.514 --> 00:25:31.734
Right?

428
00:25:32.014 --> 00:25:32.955
And that's what makes sense.

429
00:25:32.975 --> 00:25:38.299
So now when it comes to like, you know, why do we put wax on our...

430
00:25:39.019 --> 00:26:02.177
on our coating like when we do skis and stuff like that i mean the at the olympics everyone's waxing their skis right and the reason why you want to wax your skis is because they're hydrophobic they they don't like water on it right and that's actually enhancing this viscous property of that layer which is which is kind of cool it's like kind of it's making that

431
00:26:03.802 --> 00:26:20.872
more scientifically justified before it was just like an observation it's like if i wax like it just works yes and people had hand wavy ideas right but now we're really getting into the physics of it it's very very cool okay um it hasn't stopped there because that was done at you know very very low temperatures

432
00:26:21.768 --> 00:26:23.129
Now, how do we bridge the gap?

433
00:26:23.389 --> 00:26:23.589
Right?

434
00:26:23.649 --> 00:26:26.311
Because this is clearly happening at all temperature scales.

435
00:26:26.651 --> 00:26:29.914
And that kind of theory only really works for this very specific temperature.

436
00:26:30.874 --> 00:26:31.615
Ah, that's interesting.

437
00:26:31.635 --> 00:26:32.335
So it's not done.

438
00:26:33.196 --> 00:26:33.716
We're not done.

439
00:26:33.736 --> 00:26:35.017
It's not universally true.

440
00:26:35.557 --> 00:26:40.220
It goes back to where there's a difference between what happens at negative 3 degrees versus negative 30.

441
00:26:40.761 --> 00:26:50.487
And so the AFM tuning fork solution and how the slimy water layer was being created is true at very low temperatures.

442
00:26:51.428 --> 00:26:54.809
Yeah, not like the negative two, negative three that we see in winter sports.

443
00:26:54.949 --> 00:26:55.469
Right.

444
00:26:55.509 --> 00:27:00.831
But it's a clue at least as to why that part works.

445
00:27:01.191 --> 00:27:10.193
It's like the game Clue where we found the candelier in the kitchen and it has some fingerprints on it, but we've not yet done the fingerprint analysis.

446
00:27:10.333 --> 00:27:11.434
Yeah, yeah, exactly.

447
00:27:11.474 --> 00:27:15.935
And then in 2024, there was another paper, Hong and others in nature.

448
00:27:16.615 --> 00:27:21.640
What they did was atomic scale visualization using cryogenic AFM.

449
00:27:21.680 --> 00:27:32.071
So now they upped their AFM game and they were doing atomic scale resolution all the way down to like angstrom level.

450
00:27:32.331 --> 00:27:32.591
Wow.

451
00:27:32.651 --> 00:27:32.932
Okay.

452
00:27:33.312 --> 00:27:36.075
And what they found was there's this thing called pre-melting.

453
00:27:37.165 --> 00:27:42.968
Which initiates a kind of defective boundary because the ice is not going to be a clean hexagonal lattice, right?

454
00:27:43.228 --> 00:27:48.690
There's going to be defects where like there's this domain and then it's like kind of interacting with this other domain of hexagons.

455
00:27:48.710 --> 00:27:51.332
But it's the hexagons don't like completely line up.

456
00:27:52.252 --> 00:28:04.918
And what that does is where those things don't line up, you get this atomic defect that compounds to create that layer of like weird water.

457
00:28:05.748 --> 00:28:08.109
Okay, so that was in 2024.

458
00:28:08.169 --> 00:28:13.331
2025, there was another paper with Attila and Musser.

459
00:28:13.892 --> 00:28:17.293
They proposed something called cold self-lubrication at very low temperature.

460
00:28:17.313 --> 00:28:19.334
So now they're going to negative 40 degrees.

461
00:28:19.794 --> 00:28:22.515
And they're trying to say that there's some mechanical shear stress.

462
00:28:22.856 --> 00:28:27.778
So when you have a lattice, the shear is like how much you sort of warp it this way, like contort it.

463
00:28:28.358 --> 00:28:32.380
And when you have that shear stress, that creates the disordered amorphous stress.

464
00:28:33.340 --> 00:28:41.765
solid like layer that then becomes this viscous lubricant between our stuff so as you can see like it's it's still a very ongoing

465
00:28:43.527 --> 00:29:11.805
field of research 2025 was that last paper 2024 was the paper right after 2019 was this afm paper that which was kind of like the really initial like an initial the initial clue that has let us down a like a path yeah to a solution it's just six years ago yeah yeah and and people are still investigating it i mean it's got an incredible importance for our society right if we just talk about climate modeling and climate change which we're going to get to later on in the in the

466
00:29:12.782 --> 00:29:17.753
episode, if water is a hundred times higher viscosity than,

467
00:29:19.040 --> 00:29:30.449
right in between interfaces of ice and other solids, then that completely changes the current models about how glaciers slide off continents.

468
00:29:30.489 --> 00:29:30.989
Interesting.

469
00:29:31.229 --> 00:29:31.469
Right?

470
00:29:31.529 --> 00:29:31.850
Yeah.

471
00:29:32.190 --> 00:29:32.470
Yeah.

472
00:29:32.490 --> 00:29:39.936
Because before we had this number and we're like trying to model, okay, the glacier is like going, this is the friction, but now we've got a completely different number.

473
00:29:39.956 --> 00:29:42.818
And the number is two orders of magnitude different, but a hundred times different.

474
00:29:43.198 --> 00:29:45.620
So now the, the sliding rate is going to change.

475
00:29:45.840 --> 00:29:46.901
It's going to be get a lot higher.

476
00:29:46.921 --> 00:29:47.161
Right.

477
00:29:47.281 --> 00:29:55.584
Just to be clear, your note about the difference is we initially talked about how the assumption was it's, you know, two to three nanometers or a couple of nanometers.

478
00:29:55.604 --> 00:29:55.824
Yeah.

479
00:29:56.104 --> 00:29:59.845
Is the slimy water layer that enables the ability to skate, quote unquote.

480
00:29:59.865 --> 00:30:00.066
Yeah.

481
00:30:00.386 --> 00:30:07.468
We've now with AFM tuning fork and follow on research identified that that's in the hundreds of nanometers.

482
00:30:07.508 --> 00:30:08.028
Yeah.

483
00:30:08.368 --> 00:30:12.610
What we've clearly done, the layer depends on how much pressure you're putting, right?

484
00:30:12.911 --> 00:30:19.651
Like, if there's a human body weight on a bit of Tiny Skate, I mean, there's a lot of pressure on that tiny little, like, you know...

485
00:30:20.802 --> 00:30:44.057
millimeter thick blade but with a glacier glaciers like like kilometers thick worth of right worth of stuff so there's going to be a lot more pressure so the the layer is going to scale that way what we've done is confirmed that viscosity is a lot higher yes and that viscosity number is what we're going to put into our models right because now because the viscosity is a lot higher it's a variable when we look at large-scale glacier glacier glaciology mm-hmm

486
00:30:45.037 --> 00:30:49.360
It's a variable in a larger equation that has meaningful impact on modeling.

487
00:30:49.400 --> 00:30:50.361
Yes, yes.

488
00:30:50.381 --> 00:30:58.406
And one of the things that you can think about is like these shear thinning events that happen all of a sudden that lead to a catastrophic flow and acceleration.

489
00:30:59.067 --> 00:31:01.788
There's this glacier called the Thwaitis Glacier.

490
00:31:01.909 --> 00:31:04.330
I think that's how you pronounce it in Antarctica.

491
00:31:04.851 --> 00:31:09.514
This single glacier contributes to 4% of the global sea level rise.

492
00:31:09.734 --> 00:31:09.874
Yeah.

493
00:31:10.134 --> 00:31:11.635
Okay, it's massive.

494
00:31:12.036 --> 00:31:14.637
It's the size of like states in America.

495
00:31:14.998 --> 00:31:17.139
And it is moving extremely fast.

496
00:31:17.480 --> 00:31:19.541
Something like two kilometers per year.

497
00:31:20.182 --> 00:31:21.363
That's really fast for a glacier.

498
00:31:21.383 --> 00:31:24.565
The surface of the glacier is moving on the underlying landmass.

499
00:31:24.585 --> 00:31:25.666
Yeah, and you know...

500
00:31:27.090 --> 00:31:31.534
In this century, it's projected to raise the sea levels by several centimeters.

501
00:31:32.194 --> 00:31:42.222
If the whole thing went, which I think people are projecting it's going to go in the next three centuries, that's two feet of ocean level rise from a single glacier.

502
00:31:42.282 --> 00:31:42.823
It's crazy.

503
00:31:42.963 --> 00:31:43.904
It's crazy, right?

504
00:31:44.104 --> 00:31:47.206
And now with these new models, it's like maybe this is even faster.

505
00:31:47.286 --> 00:31:47.967
Right, right, right, right.

506
00:31:48.187 --> 00:31:48.708
It's crazy.

507
00:31:48.768 --> 00:31:49.428
Yeah, right.

508
00:31:49.729 --> 00:31:57.976
This is actually an interesting note on how what seems to be a totally unrelated issue with the question, the entry question of why is ice slippery?

509
00:31:58.016 --> 00:31:59.197
Yeah, yeah.

510
00:31:59.338 --> 00:32:04.522
Has all of the second, third, and fourth order consequences on things like how do we model ice?

511
00:32:05.403 --> 00:32:29.735
uh sea level rise based off of glacial ice uh uh evaporation etc yeah yeah which which makes sense when we talk through it yeah but it's not you don't immediately make yeah you don't yeah you don't i mean you you could be like oh it's such a why do we care well in science there's always other consequences right that deal with these fundamentals right fundamentally why are water molecules so weird has so many consequences right

512
00:32:30.522 --> 00:32:35.786
So I thought that was pretty exciting because it is such a simple question.

513
00:32:35.806 --> 00:32:37.927
It's been 200 years that we've been asking it.

514
00:32:38.267 --> 00:32:40.568
All of our best scientists have worked on it.

515
00:32:40.589 --> 00:32:46.012
And we're still – the closer you look, the more interesting things are.

516
00:32:47.190 --> 00:32:56.517
This is this is so and I think what's so fascinating about this is the Winter Olympics have been going on now for I think it's 25 years is what they were saying on the broadcast.

517
00:32:56.837 --> 00:33:00.940
It's like relatively new as compared to the Olympics that's been around for a very long time.

518
00:33:01.040 --> 00:33:02.761
I think it's it's been around longer.

519
00:33:02.822 --> 00:33:03.022
No.

520
00:33:03.962 --> 00:33:04.362
25 years.

521
00:33:04.703 --> 00:33:06.103
So we can do a look.

522
00:33:06.603 --> 00:33:10.325
The way that NBC is... No, 1924 was the first one in Chamonix.

523
00:33:10.485 --> 00:33:11.825
Chamonix, sorry.

524
00:33:12.286 --> 00:33:12.826
Chamonix.

525
00:33:13.126 --> 00:33:19.849
So they must be talking about the way the Premier League talks about the Premier League era versus the eras that are legit or not legit, whatever, what have you.

526
00:33:23.271 --> 00:33:31.257
It is still fascinating to me that we don't understand the fundamentals of this thing, that we have a massive global event going on that's been around for 100 years.

527
00:33:31.277 --> 00:33:32.378
Yeah, an industry.

528
00:33:32.478 --> 00:33:34.580
An industry, billion-dollar industry.

529
00:33:34.900 --> 00:33:37.902
And we actually don't know why it works.

530
00:33:37.922 --> 00:33:39.744
Just straight up, why is I slippery?

531
00:33:39.824 --> 00:33:41.545
For some of the key events.

532
00:33:41.685 --> 00:33:44.648
Great physics story to start off with.

533
00:33:45.609 --> 00:33:54.857
we're going to move now into the rundown where we're going to, again, with the rundown, we can't cover every story every week.

534
00:33:54.897 --> 00:33:58.581
There's so much breaking and frontier research science happening.

535
00:33:58.901 --> 00:34:03.305
We do our best to cover the stories that we're most interested in and can cover.

536
00:34:03.345 --> 00:34:10.712
But the rundown gives us an opportunity to share what else is happening in the world of science at a slightly higher level today.

537
00:34:10.912 --> 00:34:15.657
Before we jump in, I do want to talk about a couple of housekeeping notes.

538
00:34:16.297 --> 00:34:27.228
For those who are listening to the pod, whether that's on Spotify as audio only, on Apple Podcasts as audio only, we are a video podcast.

539
00:34:27.468 --> 00:34:27.908
This is funny.

540
00:34:27.928 --> 00:34:29.550
People say, well, if you have a video, aren't you a show?

541
00:34:29.990 --> 00:34:32.794
We're not syndicated on an actual network or streaming platform.

542
00:34:32.834 --> 00:34:35.958
So in my view, definitionally, we are not a show.

543
00:34:36.398 --> 00:34:38.581
But we are a video podcast.

544
00:34:38.661 --> 00:34:43.607
And so many of the things we talk about on the show, we accompany with a lot of visuals.

545
00:34:43.627 --> 00:34:48.133
I think in every episode, we almost have 40 to 60 overlays that we display.

546
00:34:48.153 --> 00:34:48.413
Yeah.

547
00:34:48.573 --> 00:35:04.100
So if you're listening to the show audio only and you're having a hard time visualizing the concepts we're talking about, you can always check out the video version directly on Spotify and or on YouTube for the full explanations where we have the overlays.

548
00:35:04.440 --> 00:35:09.782
It really is helpful to understand the concepts with that visual reference point.

549
00:35:10.183 --> 00:35:13.244
So if you haven't already transitioned to the video version correctly,

550
00:35:13.364 --> 00:35:14.044
please do.

551
00:35:14.264 --> 00:35:25.207
And on top of that, if you are watching on any of those platforms, whether it's Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or YouTube, we need to rise through the ranks of the billionaire algorithms.

552
00:35:25.267 --> 00:35:31.968
And the best way we can do so is with likes, with shares, with comments, and for Spotify and Apple Podcasts.

553
00:35:32.368 --> 00:35:35.869
Specifically, if you give us that five star, it helps us get

554
00:35:36.549 --> 00:35:39.350
our science pod out to more people.

555
00:35:39.690 --> 00:35:41.170
We love talking about science.

556
00:35:41.290 --> 00:35:43.471
We'd love to reach a bigger audience.

557
00:35:44.351 --> 00:35:56.934
And last note on housekeeping here is for folks who are looking to support the show, one of the things that's really key for us is that the show is available as freely and as on many platforms as possible.

558
00:35:57.494 --> 00:36:02.475
No subscriber bonus episodes, no exclusive access subscriber content whatsoever.

559
00:36:02.995 --> 00:36:13.383
But if you want to donate to support the show, we now have a new donation portal set up at the website ffppod.com backslash donate.

560
00:36:13.403 --> 00:36:25.072
You can join one of our three supporter tiers, listener, supporter, or producer, as well as sending over a custom one-time donation of an amount of your choosing.

561
00:36:25.573 --> 00:36:30.557
It is through this support that we are able to run this podcast with just the two of us.

562
00:36:30.797 --> 00:36:30.997
Yeah.

563
00:36:31.157 --> 00:36:34.879
No big, big, bad, evil platform or network.

564
00:36:35.039 --> 00:36:36.720
It's literally just the two of us.

565
00:36:36.740 --> 00:36:37.440
It's just the two.

566
00:36:37.460 --> 00:36:38.761
Just the two of us.

567
00:36:38.821 --> 00:36:39.121
Yeah.

568
00:36:39.461 --> 00:36:40.422
We can make it.

569
00:36:40.442 --> 00:36:41.362
I don't know how it goes.

570
00:36:41.743 --> 00:36:43.944
We can make it if we try.

571
00:36:43.964 --> 00:36:45.985
Oh, you can tell who's the singer of the two of us.

572
00:36:46.785 --> 00:36:50.028
No, but seriously, the engagement's been super fantastic.

573
00:36:50.328 --> 00:37:01.457
We're excited to grow and expand the show, and your support will do a lot to enable us to do so, including some of our on-site episodes, one of which we have already shot.

574
00:37:02.037 --> 00:37:05.360
And we are in the edit process for which we are super excited about.

575
00:37:05.801 --> 00:37:11.967
Now, with all of that housekeeping out of the way, let's go to our first story of the rundown.

576
00:37:12.407 --> 00:37:15.250
And this one is about AI doing physics.

577
00:37:15.510 --> 00:37:15.771
Yes.

578
00:37:15.811 --> 00:37:20.235
So Sam Altman, unclear if he's a human or not.

579
00:37:20.655 --> 00:37:23.617
or a non-human, non-human intelligence himself.

580
00:37:24.017 --> 00:37:32.222
But Sam Altman and OpenAR are claiming that ChatGBT is now doing research-grade high-energy physics research.

581
00:37:32.402 --> 00:37:44.709
What is your take on this recent OpenAI story, which I think was in tandem with a couple of other institutions, maybe namely MIT, if I'm remembering correctly?

582
00:37:44.729 --> 00:37:44.829
Yeah.

583
00:37:45.009 --> 00:37:48.491
Yeah, it's a pretty interesting story, and it's a pretty big claim.

584
00:37:48.691 --> 00:37:50.893
I first heard about it on their Twitter.

585
00:37:52.254 --> 00:38:01.459
The idea is, in particle physics, we are worried about calculating something called the scattering cross-section of stuff, okay?

586
00:38:02.040 --> 00:38:04.881
Imagine you're at the LHC or any collider.

587
00:38:05.402 --> 00:38:06.342
Large Hadron Collider.

588
00:38:06.362 --> 00:38:08.143
That's the Large Hadron Collider in CERN.

589
00:38:08.524 --> 00:38:08.744
Right.

590
00:38:09.344 --> 00:38:13.207
You've got jets of particles that are interacting with each other, and then...

591
00:38:14.007 --> 00:38:15.447
They have a certain energy.

592
00:38:15.988 --> 00:38:17.748
And then you've got a bunch of detectors around.

593
00:38:18.428 --> 00:38:26.671
And what the particles are going to do is, because they're at such high energy, there's going to be interactions of different fields at this quantum level.

594
00:38:26.711 --> 00:38:28.111
There's going to be a Higgs boson coming.

595
00:38:28.131 --> 00:38:32.212
There's going to be electrons, protons, like all sorts of random stuff happening.

596
00:38:32.712 --> 00:38:34.853
And then they're going to scatter off, right?

597
00:38:35.213 --> 00:38:37.554
And then different particles are going to scatter off.

598
00:38:37.894 --> 00:38:41.715
And we're going to collect all that data in our detectors from that collision.

599
00:38:41.735 --> 00:38:42.115
Right?

600
00:38:42.896 --> 00:38:50.685
What we want to do is calculate what the scattering amplitude and the probability is going to be in each of these directions.

601
00:38:50.765 --> 00:38:55.470
Because the point is after the collision, these things are scattering in all kinds of different directions.

602
00:38:55.490 --> 00:38:59.815
All kinds of different directions depending on whatever physics is going on at the point.

603
00:38:59.995 --> 00:39:00.235
Right.

604
00:39:00.515 --> 00:39:05.679
And so fundamentally in particle physics, all these guys are doing is calculating these scattering cross sections.

605
00:39:05.839 --> 00:39:10.322
OK, because that tells us intimately how the fields interact with each other.

606
00:39:10.382 --> 00:39:10.543
Right.

607
00:39:10.623 --> 00:39:12.444
How does the electron interact with quarks?

608
00:39:12.744 --> 00:39:14.225
How do quarks interact with each other?

609
00:39:14.305 --> 00:39:18.668
And in this case, they're wondering how do gluons interact with each other?

610
00:39:18.728 --> 00:39:21.210
Gluons are the mediators of the strong nuclear force.

611
00:39:21.590 --> 00:39:29.216
We went over this in a previous episode, but just to briefly reiterate, the strong nuclear force is what keeps the nucleus together.

612
00:39:29.556 --> 00:39:55.283
okay nucleus is full of protons which are all positively charged according to electromagnetism they don't want to sit right next to each other they want to blow apart but the strong nuclear force between the quarks inside of these protons is what's gluing the nucleus together inside of an atom and that glue comes from gluons which are the mediating force between all of these quarks that's how the quarks kind of talk to each other

613
00:39:55.959 --> 00:39:58.380
Now, gluons can interact with themselves.

614
00:39:58.660 --> 00:40:01.020
A gluon here can interact with another gluon here.

615
00:40:01.460 --> 00:40:06.662
And the focus of this particular paper is about how those gluons interact.

616
00:40:07.162 --> 00:40:08.822
There's a certain type of diagram.

617
00:40:08.922 --> 00:40:12.383
We use Feynman diagrams, which is this sort of tool.

618
00:40:12.563 --> 00:40:23.666
It's a mathematical tool, really, but also a visual tool that Feynman came up with that helps us understand how these fields interact with each other, with, like, virtual particles, a gluon interacting with another gluon, and so on and so forth.

619
00:40:24.406 --> 00:40:32.471
And usually when we calculate these scattering cross-sections, we want to figure out all the different ways that a gluon can interact with other gluons and so on and so forth.

620
00:40:32.871 --> 00:40:37.454
There's a particular way that they interact, which we thought would never happen.

621
00:40:38.014 --> 00:40:44.458
Because if you were to calculate through the whole integrals of all of the Feynman diagrams, this tree-level diagram, which had no loops...

622
00:40:45.680 --> 00:40:52.785
The answer came out to be zero, meaning the amplitude was zero, which means the probability that this particular process happens is zero.

623
00:40:53.245 --> 00:40:53.966
That's what it was thought.

624
00:40:54.166 --> 00:40:58.048
So the math was saying that there's an outcome that should not happen.

625
00:40:58.068 --> 00:40:58.929
That should never happen.

626
00:40:58.949 --> 00:41:01.030
And we feel very confident about the math.

627
00:41:01.531 --> 00:41:01.771
Yeah.

628
00:41:01.791 --> 00:41:03.252
So the math was like, this is solid.

629
00:41:03.552 --> 00:41:05.674
This has been proved true in other use cases.

630
00:41:06.154 --> 00:41:09.916
And so we should safely assume that in this use case where n equals zero.

631
00:41:10.817 --> 00:41:12.198
That nothing will happen.

632
00:41:12.298 --> 00:41:13.638
Yeah, yeah, exactly.

633
00:41:14.018 --> 00:41:14.218
Right.

634
00:41:14.238 --> 00:41:15.479
The amplitude should be zero.

635
00:41:15.499 --> 00:41:16.619
The probability should be zero.

636
00:41:16.659 --> 00:41:25.643
Then about a year ago, the authors of the study from IAS Princeton, Cambridge, Harvard, they decided that actually it might not be totally the case.

637
00:41:26.223 --> 00:41:26.503
Okay?

638
00:41:26.983 --> 00:41:37.949
They went all the way up to N equals 6, which is 6 gluons interacting with one another, and they tried to write out by hand the formula for how probable this outcome would be.

639
00:41:38.390 --> 00:41:47.775
It's a ridiculously bad formula in terms of just like for a human being to write out all the combinatoric possibilities of this gluon going here and going there.

640
00:41:48.055 --> 00:41:49.095
What's the probability of this?

641
00:41:49.135 --> 00:41:50.596
And keeping track of all those integrals.

642
00:41:51.077 --> 00:41:52.998
They do it by hand all the way up to N equals 6.

643
00:41:53.278 --> 00:41:53.398
Okay?

644
00:41:53.418 --> 00:41:53.558
Jesus.

645
00:41:53.838 --> 00:41:57.361
But what they're getting an inkling of is maybe this is not zero.

646
00:41:57.421 --> 00:41:59.203
This answer is not all going to cancel out.

647
00:41:59.643 --> 00:41:59.884
Okay?

648
00:42:00.504 --> 00:42:03.427
So that's when they employed ChatGPT.

649
00:42:03.787 --> 00:42:09.393
ChatGPT took those expressions, simplified it, and then conjectured a simple formula...

650
00:42:09.893 --> 00:42:14.936
That was a general case for all N, not just N equals all the way up to six, but N equals seven.

651
00:42:14.976 --> 00:42:16.017
You just plug in a number.

652
00:42:16.377 --> 00:42:17.318
You get the thing out.

653
00:42:17.578 --> 00:42:19.819
And then very, this was kind of interesting.

654
00:42:20.159 --> 00:42:29.205
Then an internal open AI model spent 12 hours reasoning behind this thing, came up with the formula on its own, and came up with the proof for that formula.

655
00:42:29.545 --> 00:42:31.887
That was then corroborated by the authors.

656
00:42:32.167 --> 00:42:34.028
The proof was verified, and it was correct.

657
00:42:34.688 --> 00:42:36.109
So let me make sure I'm getting this right.

658
00:42:36.469 --> 00:42:36.790
So...

659
00:42:37.882 --> 00:42:40.204
They initially fed this thing to Chachi B.T.

660
00:42:40.284 --> 00:42:42.746
And it created a simple formula.

661
00:42:42.966 --> 00:42:44.507
A simplified way of doing that.

662
00:42:44.527 --> 00:42:47.990
A simple calculator to do the math for n equals any number.

663
00:42:48.790 --> 00:42:54.615
It figured out some sort of patterns within like n equals 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6.

664
00:42:54.655 --> 00:42:56.816
It maybe figured out a pattern that was going on.

665
00:42:56.836 --> 00:42:59.718
And it was like, actually, in physics we do this all the time.

666
00:42:59.759 --> 00:43:00.799
It's called an ansatz.

667
00:43:01.140 --> 00:43:05.663
It's our best guess for what do you think the general formula should look like.

668
00:43:05.783 --> 00:43:09.165
So it created its own version of this simplified expression.

669
00:43:09.446 --> 00:43:10.667
This is a simplified formula.

670
00:43:11.267 --> 00:43:18.052
And then they fed it to an internal OpenAI model that had a bunch of scaffolding that's specific to scientific research stuff.

671
00:43:18.632 --> 00:43:20.313
It let it run for 12 hours.

672
00:43:20.634 --> 00:43:22.155
And this is like an important note.

673
00:43:22.235 --> 00:43:23.676
Like, you know, the state of the art.

674
00:43:23.716 --> 00:43:26.478
There was a different model that let it run for 12 hours.

675
00:43:26.498 --> 00:43:27.338
Correct.

676
00:43:27.378 --> 00:43:27.899
I do want to be.

677
00:43:27.939 --> 00:43:29.160
This is not like 5.2.

678
00:43:29.340 --> 00:43:29.580
Right.

679
00:43:29.600 --> 00:43:31.581
They had an internal model that ran for 12 hours.

680
00:43:32.482 --> 00:43:48.586
And so just conceptually for context here, because I think this is interesting, you can take these base models and then what they call, they put scaffolding around it, which is this technical term to mean these additional weights and processes that are hyper-specific to a particular task or use case.

681
00:43:48.846 --> 00:43:53.487
So this is not just, you could go into chat GPT today and you could then get this result.

682
00:43:53.527 --> 00:43:54.187
Yeah.

683
00:43:54.207 --> 00:44:00.109
But the underlying model intelligence is being amplified with this sort of, sort of bespoke use case.

684
00:44:00.509 --> 00:44:01.289
Anyway, yeah,

685
00:44:01.449 --> 00:44:03.070
They let it run for 12 hours.

686
00:44:03.310 --> 00:44:03.530
Yeah.

687
00:44:03.811 --> 00:44:13.196
And I think this is important because a year ago, you could not have long running agent based autonomous processes.

688
00:44:14.077 --> 00:44:22.402
And just actually recently in the same time period as this is coming out, the now the maximum time last year, the maximum time was about three hours, a couple hours.

689
00:44:22.462 --> 00:44:22.722
Uh huh.

690
00:44:23.242 --> 00:44:29.966
Just about a week ago, the max running time, this was for a Claude Opus 4.6, was two weeks straight.

691
00:44:30.507 --> 00:44:36.431
And it built a C compiler of 100,000 lines of code from scratch that worked with no human intervention.

692
00:44:36.771 --> 00:44:38.232
So I just, I want to.

693
00:44:38.432 --> 00:44:39.012
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

694
00:44:39.052 --> 00:44:39.913
I heard about this.

695
00:44:39.933 --> 00:44:40.573
That was crazy.

696
00:44:40.613 --> 00:44:46.577
It's really, these, being able to run these things for longer enables stuff like this.

697
00:44:46.597 --> 00:44:47.758
So they ran it for 12 hours.

698
00:44:48.478 --> 00:44:49.759
And then it came up with a proof.

699
00:44:50.099 --> 00:44:50.360
Mm-hmm.

700
00:44:51.215 --> 00:44:55.016
Which then meant the human scientists could then go through that proof.

701
00:44:55.196 --> 00:44:55.676
And verify.

702
00:44:55.736 --> 00:44:57.337
And validate that it's true.

703
00:44:57.417 --> 00:44:57.597
Yep.

704
00:44:58.537 --> 00:44:58.737
Yeah.

705
00:44:58.877 --> 00:44:59.457
And it was true.

706
00:44:59.537 --> 00:45:00.117
And it was true.

707
00:45:00.657 --> 00:45:02.098
So it is quite fascinating, right?

708
00:45:02.438 --> 00:45:04.698
And I think it is a big deal.

709
00:45:05.238 --> 00:45:05.579
Yes.

710
00:45:06.219 --> 00:45:06.339
Okay?

711
00:45:06.579 --> 00:45:10.140
From where I'm standing, I think it is a big deal, but there are caveats, okay?

712
00:45:10.440 --> 00:45:13.240
There are nuances, because I want to understand what is actually happening.

713
00:45:13.280 --> 00:45:15.901
I do hate these black boxes.

714
00:45:16.101 --> 00:45:18.922
But, you know, we're in the age of AI black boxes, right?

715
00:45:19.702 --> 00:45:21.283
Is it actually understanding stuff?

716
00:45:21.443 --> 00:45:23.945
Or my hypothesis is, well, let's go through.

717
00:45:24.025 --> 00:45:25.285
Is it actually understanding stuff?

718
00:45:25.425 --> 00:45:27.246
Is 5.2 understanding something?

719
00:45:28.727 --> 00:45:31.129
Friend of the show, he's going to be in the acknowledgement section.

720
00:45:32.109 --> 00:45:36.672
Alan Southworth, he sent me a screenshot of something that he asked, ChatGPT.

721
00:45:37.873 --> 00:45:39.573
And that's in the next photo.

722
00:45:39.634 --> 00:45:40.394
I want you to show that.

723
00:45:40.774 --> 00:45:41.855
Okay, so he asked...

724
00:45:42.295 --> 00:45:42.896
ChatGPT 5.2.

725
00:45:42.977 --> 00:45:43.297
Okay.

726
00:45:44.179 --> 00:45:47.586
I want to wash my car and the car washes 50 meters from my house.

727
00:45:48.047 --> 00:45:50.272
Do you think I should walk there or do you think I should drive there?

728
00:45:50.672 --> 00:45:50.933
Mm-hmm.

729
00:45:52.620 --> 00:45:54.201
You should drive there because it's your car.

730
00:45:54.481 --> 00:45:54.921
Yeah, right.

731
00:45:55.142 --> 00:45:55.382
Okay.

732
00:45:55.642 --> 00:46:03.006
ChatGPD answers, at 50 meters, you are officially in the put-on-sandals-and-stroll territory.

733
00:46:03.046 --> 00:46:03.206
Right?

734
00:46:03.286 --> 00:46:10.130
Because in all of its LLM knowledge, it's like, oh, 50 meters, you can walk.

735
00:46:10.170 --> 00:46:18.215
Because there's probably so many blog posts out there about when is it okay to walk and why to not use gasoline and all this other stuff.

736
00:46:22.300 --> 00:46:26.941
You know, ChatGPT always asks a follow-up question because OpenAI wants you to keep engaging.

737
00:46:27.341 --> 00:46:30.842
The follow-up question is, so are you going to get a full detail?

738
00:46:30.862 --> 00:46:36.763
So it knows that you're doing the car wash the whole time.

739
00:46:36.803 --> 00:46:36.983
Yes.

740
00:46:37.663 --> 00:46:39.604
But in the middle, it's like you should walk.

741
00:46:39.924 --> 00:46:42.884
And then at the end, it asks, are you going to do a full detail?

742
00:46:43.024 --> 00:46:44.665
Or like, what are you getting about your car?

743
00:46:44.725 --> 00:46:44.905
Yes.

744
00:46:45.540 --> 00:46:45.720
Yes.

745
00:46:45.840 --> 00:46:46.601
Do you understand?

746
00:46:46.621 --> 00:46:53.724
And the point being, it means it doesn't actually have an understanding of the question and the variables inside the question.

747
00:46:54.084 --> 00:46:57.226
Because for any, you could ask a five-year-old that question.

748
00:46:58.118 --> 00:47:01.421
And they'd be like, you should drive the car because you need the car to wash it.

749
00:47:01.442 --> 00:47:01.642
Right.

750
00:47:01.682 --> 00:47:12.653
They've associated some type of meaning behind the task that you're trying to do and accomplish, which is get my car washed and the mode of transportation you would need to get there.

751
00:47:12.793 --> 00:47:17.098
You would have to take your mode of transportation because the task is related to that mode of transportation.

752
00:47:18.260 --> 00:47:22.202
That's ChatGPT 5.2 that's not able to actually make that connection.

753
00:47:22.402 --> 00:47:23.382
I actually would be curious.

754
00:47:23.502 --> 00:47:23.762
Is it?

755
00:47:23.802 --> 00:47:24.182
Does he have?

756
00:47:24.482 --> 00:47:26.963
I'd be curious if he had thinking on or off.

757
00:47:27.223 --> 00:47:27.624
Interesting.

758
00:47:27.704 --> 00:47:27.904
Okay.

759
00:47:27.924 --> 00:47:30.745
Because you can't have reasoning on or off with 5.2.

760
00:47:30.865 --> 00:47:32.065
Oh, okay.

761
00:47:32.105 --> 00:47:33.786
I'm not saying that it would have made a difference.

762
00:47:33.806 --> 00:47:33.986
Right.

763
00:47:34.126 --> 00:47:35.387
But no, that's a valid question.

764
00:47:35.467 --> 00:47:40.072
I think it is because that's the argument that those on the inside are making.

765
00:47:40.112 --> 00:47:48.161
It's like, oh, when you just use the base models without reasoning as this additional layer to basically, in theory, check for this kind of stuff.

766
00:47:48.261 --> 00:47:48.461
Yeah.

767
00:47:48.662 --> 00:47:51.304
Then, yes, you will get these quote unquote hallucinations.

768
00:47:51.945 --> 00:47:54.708
But the argument is, oh, reasoning with 5.2 and Opus 4.6.

769
00:47:56.610 --> 00:48:19.537
covers most of these use cases i'm not saying that's true that is the argument thing that is the argument so alan it would be good to know if you use thinking on or off yeah because if thinking is on it really does i think expose a huge with even within the reasoning pathway it is really not actually understand understanding yeah and from there i wanted to ask like okay like how

770
00:48:20.477 --> 00:48:23.019
If it's not understanding, how is it able to do this physics?

771
00:48:23.239 --> 00:48:23.439
Right.

772
00:48:23.799 --> 00:48:24.040
Right?

773
00:48:24.280 --> 00:48:24.860
Right.

774
00:48:25.280 --> 00:48:26.321
I have a hypothesis.

775
00:48:26.421 --> 00:48:29.503
I don't know if it's correct, and perhaps someone can tell me I'm wrong.

776
00:48:29.944 --> 00:48:35.808
My hypothesis is that Chachipiti, in all of its wisdom and all of its research—

777
00:48:37.289 --> 00:48:44.651
in pre-training, found a piece of mathematics that was very similar to this physics problem.

778
00:48:44.911 --> 00:48:51.293
It's reducing a bunch of integrals that are sequential and all of these processes, and it's trying to find some generalized formula.

779
00:48:51.674 --> 00:49:01.837
Perhaps in all of its reading of the world's mathematical literature, it saw and made a connection to someone else who had done something similar to find a general use case.

780
00:49:03.218 --> 00:49:07.980
pulled that bit from its latent space and then injected it here.

781
00:49:08.620 --> 00:49:10.061
I'm wondering if that's what happened.

782
00:49:10.301 --> 00:49:16.764
And that would make sense given the structure that we are currently told is what these large language models are framed as.

783
00:49:16.784 --> 00:49:19.605
Because your point, what you're saying is there is a pattern...

784
00:49:20.425 --> 00:49:28.934
That the model found in mathematics applied to another use case that for whatever reason we as humans have not yet made the connection to.

785
00:49:29.714 --> 00:49:30.976
And the model just made the connection.

786
00:49:30.996 --> 00:49:35.940
Maybe the physicists who are working on this are just not aware of like some fringe mathematical aspect.

787
00:49:36.561 --> 00:49:38.943
And so perhaps it made that pattern recognition, right?

788
00:49:38.964 --> 00:49:39.444
Right.

789
00:49:40.020 --> 00:49:50.589
Regardless, I think this does show the utility of these large language models to do frontier theoretical research now.

790
00:49:50.749 --> 00:49:50.929
Right.

791
00:49:51.069 --> 00:49:51.269
Right.

792
00:49:51.850 --> 00:49:55.533
One of the things, I know we've spent a long time on this story, but I think this is such an important.

793
00:49:55.573 --> 00:49:56.414
I think it was cool.

794
00:49:56.434 --> 00:49:57.475
This is really cool.

795
00:49:57.555 --> 00:50:02.138
And I think it's very important because this is like a zero or one phase phase.

796
00:50:03.039 --> 00:50:04.623
state change kind of issue.

797
00:50:05.144 --> 00:50:10.936
Either these models are not able to discover new science or,

798
00:50:11.289 --> 00:50:11.809
Or they are.

799
00:50:11.989 --> 00:50:12.249
Oh, yeah.

800
00:50:12.529 --> 00:50:21.353
And the difference between a world in which they are not and in which they are is an order of magnitude in terms of the implications.

801
00:50:21.413 --> 00:50:22.053
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

802
00:50:22.093 --> 00:50:23.693
So it's something that we should cover.

803
00:50:24.034 --> 00:50:29.315
And, you know, I'm not quite convinced that they can do really new science, right?

804
00:50:29.716 --> 00:50:30.936
But they can fill in gaps.

805
00:50:31.136 --> 00:50:31.316
Yes.

806
00:50:31.376 --> 00:50:32.577
And I think that's what they're doing here.

807
00:50:32.637 --> 00:50:32.857
Yes.

808
00:50:32.957 --> 00:50:33.197
Right?

809
00:50:33.317 --> 00:50:33.457
Yes.

810
00:50:33.557 --> 00:50:36.418
And even that is itself a very good thing.

811
00:50:36.638 --> 00:50:45.281
I want to remind people that ChatGPT, which is the first consumer version of the modern era of LLMs, came out three years ago.

812
00:50:45.481 --> 00:50:45.721
Yeah.

813
00:50:46.481 --> 00:50:51.783
And so I think keeping the time scale of progress in mind is very important.

814
00:50:51.963 --> 00:50:52.543
Yeah.

815
00:50:52.603 --> 00:50:55.084
You don't even graduate college in three years.

816
00:50:55.124 --> 00:50:55.364
Yeah.

817
00:50:55.884 --> 00:50:58.565
And we've gone from it can do absolutely jack.

818
00:50:58.705 --> 00:50:58.805
Yeah.

819
00:50:58.825 --> 00:50:59.005
Yeah.

820
00:50:59.605 --> 00:51:08.589
to getting to the fringes of some of these fundamental science concepts, I think it's very unwise to underestimate this.

821
00:51:08.749 --> 00:51:16.553
I get that there's a whole variety of social, economic, political implications that are all very important to talk about.

822
00:51:16.633 --> 00:51:18.054
That is 100% true.

823
00:51:18.674 --> 00:51:24.937
But saying this is a stochastic parrot that can't do anything of real value I think is a gross assumption.

824
00:51:26.028 --> 00:51:41.709
underestimation of what is currently happening yeah yeah and we and we need to like as a society start grappling with the true potential of this technology right and how we're going to get around it because if it doesn't get there great yeah but if it does get there we don't want to be getting there with our pants down yeah exactly

825
00:51:42.290 --> 00:51:43.051
Great first story.

826
00:51:43.352 --> 00:51:48.219
Again, potential watershed moment as this moves into scientific discovery.

827
00:51:48.499 --> 00:51:57.151
We've talked about several previous episodes where AI is already having other tangential impacts within breakthrough and frontier science research.

828
00:51:58.361 --> 00:52:01.804
A long story number one will be quicker for the stories.

829
00:52:01.844 --> 00:52:04.706
Story number two that we have here.

830
00:52:04.726 --> 00:52:14.533
This is out of the Universita D'Aglia Studi di Napoli, Federico II in Napoli, Italy, and the universities in Berlin in a paper in Scientific Reports.

831
00:52:14.853 --> 00:52:16.955
This is about feline behavior.

832
00:52:17.035 --> 00:52:22.039
A new study has shown that a cat's purr reveals much more about its

833
00:52:22.799 --> 00:52:25.722
individual identity than a meow.

834
00:52:25.822 --> 00:52:26.082
Yes.

835
00:52:26.183 --> 00:52:27.123
Cats meow.

836
00:52:27.344 --> 00:52:27.564
Yeah.

837
00:52:27.584 --> 00:52:29.846
So a meow is different from a purr.

838
00:52:30.006 --> 00:52:30.267
Okay.

839
00:52:30.327 --> 00:52:30.867
Is the point.

840
00:52:31.087 --> 00:52:31.628
Okay.

841
00:52:32.509 --> 00:52:35.652
You know, cats were domesticated probably like 10,000 years ago in the Middle East.

842
00:52:36.193 --> 00:52:36.313
And,

843
00:52:38.058 --> 00:52:45.524
What they found using 27 different cats and the vocalizations of all these different cats is the cats do not meow to each other.

844
00:52:45.544 --> 00:52:52.970
The meow of the cat has specifically evolved to interact with their humans.

845
00:52:53.931 --> 00:52:54.571
Oh, wow.

846
00:52:54.611 --> 00:52:54.952
Okay?

847
00:52:55.032 --> 00:52:56.393
That's the point of the story.

848
00:52:56.413 --> 00:52:59.855
The purr is actually something that is very unique to a cat.

849
00:53:00.196 --> 00:53:02.778
So one cat's purr is going to be just a...

850
00:53:04.228 --> 00:53:08.032
foundationally different sound signature than another cat's purr.

851
00:53:08.313 --> 00:53:10.515
But the meows have a very high variance.

852
00:53:10.816 --> 00:53:13.939
And the meows are basically used to interact with human beings.

853
00:53:14.820 --> 00:53:18.805
Cats only meow at each other when they're, like, in a fight, effectively.

854
00:53:18.865 --> 00:53:22.669
Otherwise, they're, like, communicating, like, hey, this is me using a purr.

855
00:53:23.130 --> 00:53:24.331
And what they did was they also...

856
00:53:26.625 --> 00:53:32.653
compared the vocalization of these 27 domesticated cats with the cats in the wild.

857
00:53:33.154 --> 00:53:33.414
Okay?

858
00:53:34.175 --> 00:53:35.036
Again, that's what they found.

859
00:53:35.056 --> 00:53:40.303
The meows are more variable, but the purrs are actually much more related to these wild cats.

860
00:53:40.343 --> 00:53:41.544
So the purr has kind of...

861
00:53:42.225 --> 00:53:58.460
been around since domestication and before domestication around 10 000 years ago in the middle east but the meow has actively evolved to communicate with human beings like i need more food i want to go outside i hate you i don't know what cats are like but i think that's what's going on in their head

862
00:53:58.680 --> 00:54:05.089
So we've identified that a cat's purr is like their fingerprint, the idea that every individual's fingerprint is different.

863
00:54:05.650 --> 00:54:13.441
But the meow is the way for them to interface with the meat suits that are human beings.

864
00:54:13.461 --> 00:54:13.621
Yes.

865
00:54:13.641 --> 00:54:13.721
Yes.

866
00:54:14.442 --> 00:54:17.443
that they get to boss around as they like to.

867
00:54:18.683 --> 00:54:22.524
Another follow-up to our Lion Roar story that we did last week in the rundown.

868
00:54:23.044 --> 00:54:24.985
A lot of great animal science stories.

869
00:54:25.845 --> 00:54:36.528
We're now going to talk about immunology and the debate of nature versus nurture as scientists discover how life experiences rewrite the immune system.

870
00:54:37.048 --> 00:54:41.049
It's like we have a molecular diary of our past.

871
00:54:41.269 --> 00:54:49.171
Yeah, this is an incredible story out of the Salk Institute in La Jolla, California, right outside of UC San Diego.

872
00:54:49.651 --> 00:54:55.593
It answers this question of variability, which is something that is very familiar to us having gone through the COVID-19 pandemic.

873
00:54:56.013 --> 00:54:59.594
Some people got completely wrecked by COVID-19 when they got it.

874
00:55:00.735 --> 00:55:01.735
Other people were fine.

875
00:55:02.255 --> 00:55:04.517
you know, even with the vaccine on both ends, right?

876
00:55:04.577 --> 00:55:13.304
Even if you control for those who are vaccinated and not, the variability between responses from one individual to the other is extremely different.

877
00:55:13.384 --> 00:55:13.664
Okay.

878
00:55:13.704 --> 00:55:14.004
And this,

879
00:55:15.117 --> 00:55:17.318
particular paper is trying to answer that question.

880
00:55:17.378 --> 00:55:18.879
Why are, why is stuff so different?

881
00:55:19.179 --> 00:55:20.920
They focus on something called the epigenome.

882
00:55:20.940 --> 00:55:23.321
The epigenome is how the DNA gets expressed.

883
00:55:23.681 --> 00:55:33.545
Everybody has the same DNA effectively, but like how each DNA strand, how the genes in that DNA get expressed is part of the epigenome.

884
00:55:33.585 --> 00:55:39.348
And that's a very dynamic thing that can change as we age and has, as we have life experiences.

885
00:55:40.228 --> 00:55:40.408
Um, um,

886
00:55:41.682 --> 00:55:46.004
The genetic patterns can be changed through two ways.

887
00:55:46.224 --> 00:55:47.925
Either it's a genetic thing, right?

888
00:55:48.205 --> 00:55:56.068
Like there's part of our epigenetics where the cells pick which genes to express and which genes to not based on the genetics themselves.

889
00:55:56.488 --> 00:56:01.491
And then there's another one where our life experiences actually change genetic expression, right?

890
00:56:01.971 --> 00:56:04.532
And those competing factors are very much...

891
00:56:05.867 --> 00:56:08.708
in play when it comes to immune cells.

892
00:56:09.448 --> 00:56:13.690
Because immune cells have to learn throughout the experience of an individual, right?

893
00:56:14.010 --> 00:56:22.033
I get some disease, my immune cell has to now remember what that disease looked like mechanistically so that we don't get that disease in the future, right?

894
00:56:22.393 --> 00:56:27.535
So immune cells are this really great lab to try and figure out what are these competing effects like, okay?

895
00:56:27.796 --> 00:56:31.897
What they focused on was something called differentially methylated regions.

896
00:56:32.257 --> 00:56:34.058
Basically, you've got your DNA strand,

897
00:56:35.490 --> 00:56:40.795
Your cells put tags on the DNA with these things called methyl groups, okay?

898
00:56:41.195 --> 00:56:45.559
And that sort of gives them a distinction between, hey, this is a methylated piece of DNA.

899
00:56:45.880 --> 00:56:47.521
This is not a methylated piece of DNA.

900
00:56:47.841 --> 00:56:53.146
So structurally, from a molecular level, they can tell two bits of DNA apart, okay?

901
00:56:53.366 --> 00:56:57.170
What they looked for is how these differentially methylated regions...

902
00:56:58.558 --> 00:57:01.786
were tied to things like genetics and life experiences.

903
00:57:02.287 --> 00:57:06.798
And what they found was there's actually two different types of markers that

904
00:57:07.578 --> 00:57:08.799
in our genetics, okay?

905
00:57:09.099 --> 00:57:16.963
The part that's more genetic is actually particularly in long-lived immune cells, like the T cells and the B cells.

906
00:57:17.003 --> 00:57:21.185
These are the ones that have memory of our past immune attacks and things like that.

907
00:57:21.545 --> 00:57:25.587
And all of these methylated regions are found in the stable regions of our genome.

908
00:57:26.488 --> 00:57:30.710
On the other hand, if you have things like, you know, the...

909
00:57:31.515 --> 00:57:32.335
Killer T cells.

910
00:57:32.695 --> 00:57:34.276
These are the ones that are rapid response.

911
00:57:35.256 --> 00:57:41.437
Those are the ones that have this methylated region in more flexible regulatory regions.

912
00:57:41.897 --> 00:57:42.177
Okay?

913
00:57:42.457 --> 00:57:44.598
So you've got these two different effects.

914
00:57:44.938 --> 00:57:50.939
And so what this kind of cell-specific database can tell you is new insight into how immune responses form.

915
00:57:51.359 --> 00:57:53.700
And also later on, we can do, you know...

916
00:57:54.700 --> 00:57:59.261
future treatments that are tailored to each person's unique biology, right?

917
00:57:59.281 --> 00:58:05.082
Because their particular immune system is going to respond in a different way to somebody else based on their past treatment.

918
00:58:05.362 --> 00:58:11.363
So if we can read the epigenome, we can then forecast how is someone going to respond to a certain treatment?

919
00:58:11.443 --> 00:58:13.204
How is their immune system going to respond?

920
00:58:13.684 --> 00:58:14.284
That's the idea.

921
00:58:14.324 --> 00:58:15.824
This is very fascinating.

922
00:58:15.964 --> 00:58:19.405
The concept here being there are, you know,

923
00:58:20.285 --> 00:58:31.933
Our genome has both these like genetically inherited from long, the long history of evolution that then formulate into these long lived T cells and B cells, which kind of makes sense.

924
00:58:31.953 --> 00:58:36.996
It's like, oh, these are things that for millennia, for generations have been helpful.

925
00:58:37.276 --> 00:58:40.078
So we can kind of memorialize it in our long term memory.

926
00:58:40.658 --> 00:58:54.919
And then there's this sort of like epigenetic layer, which is more about the lived experience of the individual or its most recent predecessors impact the killer T cells and these sort of aspects that might need to be,

927
00:58:55.720 --> 00:59:00.644
more reactive to real-time changes in the environment.

928
00:59:00.924 --> 00:59:06.629
And so the point... And we're able to now, in the molecules, see the difference.

929
00:59:06.809 --> 00:59:11.212
How they're tagged between coming from this long history versus a short history.

930
00:59:11.953 --> 00:59:12.533
And again...

931
00:59:13.594 --> 00:59:26.683
I mean, this goes to the importance of like genetic diversity and clinical trials as an example, which is a space that my mom works in because you will have different responses based not only on, you know,

932
00:59:27.675 --> 00:59:29.956
someone's African versus African American.

933
00:59:30.557 --> 00:59:43.604
But even that, even if they're both black, the epigenetic layer of the experiences are going to be fundamentally different between those who are part of the African, African slave trade versus Africans who are not just as a use case example.

934
00:59:43.644 --> 00:59:44.284
Yeah.

935
00:59:44.464 --> 00:59:46.866
And so these kinds of details are important because it,

936
00:59:48.327 --> 00:59:53.250
especially if someone is black, like the medical system and us being able to get treatment is a very complex issue.

937
00:59:53.330 --> 00:59:53.550
Yeah.

938
00:59:54.030 --> 00:59:59.354
Um, because just like photos and film was initially created for only white people.

939
00:59:59.894 --> 01:00:00.095
Right.

940
01:00:00.115 --> 01:00:03.397
I didn't know that there's fundamental things about the way that film works

941
01:00:03.697 --> 01:00:06.981
Like actual film works because of light.

942
01:00:07.101 --> 01:00:11.586
If you think about how light bounces off of white people's skin versus dark people's skin.

943
01:00:11.946 --> 01:00:16.050
So until we got later into digital, it was never really made for black people.

944
01:00:16.471 --> 01:00:22.938
Medicine kind of has a similar issue where a lot of the genetic profiles have been or the way in which we've operated is for black people.

945
01:00:23.098 --> 01:00:24.359
a particular group set.

946
01:00:24.439 --> 01:00:32.366
And I think as we continue to do this type of research, it will allow us to expand the efficacy of medicine across a larger swath of genetic profiles.

947
01:00:32.387 --> 01:00:33.628
So fascinating story.

948
01:00:34.769 --> 01:00:38.812
Again, there on talking about immunology, which has been an issue.

949
01:00:38.832 --> 01:00:39.833
We've talked a subject.

950
01:00:39.853 --> 01:00:41.375
We've talked about quite a bit on the pod.

951
01:00:41.815 --> 01:00:46.679
We're going to move on to origin of life for our last rundown story.

952
01:00:46.699 --> 01:00:46.799
Yeah.

953
01:00:47.560 --> 01:01:09.733
second to last sorry second to last i want to do i want to do five this time okay okay okay uh so for our second to last which is going to be this um scientists finding genes that existed before life on earth what does that even what does that mean yeah that doesn't that doesn't mean anything to me right right genes before life

954
01:01:11.045 --> 01:01:15.727
What are you talking about is exactly what I thought when I was reading this.

955
01:01:15.747 --> 01:01:17.867
Because it's like life is genes.

956
01:01:18.127 --> 01:01:18.428
Right.

957
01:01:18.468 --> 01:01:19.568
So how does it before?

958
01:01:19.608 --> 01:01:20.248
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

959
01:01:20.568 --> 01:01:22.449
So here's what's going on.

960
01:01:22.909 --> 01:01:31.272
There might be some genes that are in nearly every single organism today that were duplicated before life shared a common ancestor.

961
01:01:32.123 --> 01:01:32.464
Okay.

962
01:01:32.484 --> 01:01:32.744
Okay?

963
01:01:32.985 --> 01:01:34.868
Because let's think about all of life on Earth, right?

964
01:01:34.928 --> 01:01:36.591
It came from a single common ancestor.

965
01:01:36.611 --> 01:01:37.312
That's what we think.

966
01:01:37.392 --> 01:01:37.573
Yes.

967
01:01:37.653 --> 01:01:41.039
Because we all have DNA and there's all these different markers, right?

968
01:01:41.700 --> 01:01:41.880
Yes.

969
01:01:41.900 --> 01:01:44.424
Now, that single common ancestor...

970
01:01:45.615 --> 01:01:52.118
There must have been stuff before the common ancestor that were building blocks to make that last common ancestor, right?

971
01:01:52.598 --> 01:01:58.821
And these guys are saying they have a way now to find genes that were there before that last common ancestor was even alive.

972
01:01:58.841 --> 01:01:59.301
Fascinating.

973
01:01:59.321 --> 01:02:02.023
Like the building blocks of that last common ancestor.

974
01:02:02.423 --> 01:02:03.223
It's pretty insane.

975
01:02:03.604 --> 01:02:08.246
So when we think about the last common ancestor, right, these are cells that already had membranes.

976
01:02:09.102 --> 01:02:17.067
They've got an inside and an outside, and they've got DNA to store genetic information, right, to store some information for self-replication.

977
01:02:17.987 --> 01:02:21.129
Now, these are essential traits, and they've already been established.

978
01:02:21.449 --> 01:02:24.211
So what happened before that, and how can we tell?

979
01:02:24.651 --> 01:02:27.113
Well, they look for something called paralogs, okay?

980
01:02:27.413 --> 01:02:34.017
Paralogs are groups of related genes that appear multiple times within a single genome, right?

981
01:02:34.757 --> 01:02:36.878
A good example is for us hemoglobin.

982
01:02:37.158 --> 01:02:39.560
We have eight copies of hemoglobin in our DNA.

983
01:02:39.840 --> 01:02:40.060
Okay?

984
01:02:40.360 --> 01:02:43.062
And that hemoglobin came about about 800 million years ago.

985
01:02:43.302 --> 01:02:43.802
That's the thing.

986
01:02:44.002 --> 01:02:46.424
That's the protein that carries oxygen in our blood.

987
01:02:46.944 --> 01:02:48.165
We've got eight different copies.

988
01:02:48.285 --> 01:02:50.186
All of us have eight different copies.

989
01:02:50.326 --> 01:02:52.647
A lot of mammals have eight different copies.

990
01:02:53.028 --> 01:02:58.471
The fact that all of us have that means that hemoglobin is a really old, old protein.

991
01:02:59.111 --> 01:02:59.371
Okay?

992
01:03:00.532 --> 01:03:00.792
So, yeah.

993
01:03:01.933 --> 01:03:10.021
The idea is if there's repeated copying and extra versions of this gene, then the copying must have happened way early because all of us have that.

994
01:03:10.461 --> 01:03:10.661
Right.

995
01:03:11.442 --> 01:03:22.553
So now let's look for universal paralogs, which are genes that are repeated, like they have this repeated tendency and these copies across everyone.

996
01:03:23.053 --> 01:03:25.075
Bacteria, us, bacteria.

997
01:03:25.235 --> 01:03:27.436
Fungi, literally everyone.

998
01:03:27.837 --> 01:03:35.321
What they're looking for is gene families that appear at least two times in at least two copies in the genomes across life.

999
01:03:35.722 --> 01:03:38.523
And so to be clear, you're saying hemoglobin, there's eight copies.

1000
01:03:38.944 --> 01:03:41.345
Eight copies, but it only happened 800 million years ago.

1001
01:03:41.445 --> 01:03:41.665
Right.

1002
01:03:41.745 --> 01:03:43.446
Like bacteria don't have hemoglobin.

1003
01:03:43.647 --> 01:03:43.847
Right.

1004
01:03:44.127 --> 01:03:45.288
And so we're looking— Plants also.

1005
01:03:45.308 --> 01:03:45.808
Plants also.

1006
01:03:46.168 --> 01:03:52.830
We're looking for things that have multiple copies, like hemoglobin, but hemoglobin we only see in humans and mammals.

1007
01:03:53.230 --> 01:03:57.851
And so we're saying, what else has these n number of multiple copies, but in other...

1008
01:03:57.971 --> 01:03:58.672
Everywhere.

1009
01:03:58.932 --> 01:04:00.592
But literally everywhere.

1010
01:04:00.612 --> 01:04:01.792
That's the other thing.

1011
01:04:01.852 --> 01:04:08.894
It's got to be literally everywhere, because then you can make the argument, it happened way back, even before the universal ancestor.

1012
01:04:09.494 --> 01:04:09.735
Right?

1013
01:04:09.795 --> 01:04:09.995
Yes.

1014
01:04:10.175 --> 01:04:11.055
And they found a few.

1015
01:04:11.255 --> 01:04:11.575
Okay.

1016
01:04:11.735 --> 01:04:13.115
And all of these genes have to do...

1017
01:04:15.869 --> 01:04:40.509
with two things either building proteins or managing the membrane how to get in and out of the membrane and that kind of makes sense we've talked about this you've brought this up several times about the membrane and it's like how did that happen how did that happen it turns out these cell membranes and managing transport across the cell membrane is something that might have happened even before our last common ancestor mm-hmm

1018
01:04:40.789 --> 01:04:51.054
Just in like random molecular processes and like proteins at a molecular level, not even a cell trying to self-replicate, but like molecules trying to get across.

1019
01:04:51.334 --> 01:04:55.776
And if a molecule got across, it had an advantage to like do more of itself.

1020
01:04:56.356 --> 01:04:56.576
Right.

1021
01:04:57.517 --> 01:04:59.198
And I think that's really fascinating.

1022
01:04:59.278 --> 01:05:08.262
What they could also do is reconstruct the protein and produce this ancient ancestral protein that could then go across molecules.

1023
01:05:09.182 --> 01:05:10.984
It's molecular Jurassic Park.

1024
01:05:11.124 --> 01:05:11.404
Yes.

1025
01:05:11.624 --> 01:05:12.264
Yes.

1026
01:05:12.324 --> 01:05:19.269
And what's crazy is that molecule that's billions of years old now, it can traverse the same membranes that we have.

1027
01:05:19.669 --> 01:05:21.611
So that old use case, it can still do it.

1028
01:05:28.195 --> 01:05:34.960
It's like we've found, we've like reburned a CD copy of Now That's What I Call Music Volume 4.

1029
01:05:34.980 --> 01:05:37.882
And we're on Now That's What I Call Music Volume 200.

1030
01:05:37.962 --> 01:05:38.443
Yeah.

1031
01:05:38.703 --> 01:05:40.905
But it's like we found the old.

1032
01:05:41.065 --> 01:05:41.585
Oh, yeah.

1033
01:05:41.685 --> 01:05:43.126
And it got the same intro.

1034
01:05:43.146 --> 01:05:44.347
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1035
01:05:44.427 --> 01:05:45.708
And it plays in the same player.

1036
01:05:46.048 --> 01:05:48.010
That's kind of a rough analogy.

1037
01:05:48.230 --> 01:05:49.531
But that's actually.

1038
01:05:49.911 --> 01:05:51.473
I thought that was really crazy.

1039
01:05:51.493 --> 01:05:52.093
This is very cool.

1040
01:05:52.113 --> 01:05:54.555
Because, again, what this means is we can continue to log.

1041
01:05:54.575 --> 01:05:54.755
Right.

1042
01:05:55.035 --> 01:06:06.485
And continue to look for these paralogues across everything that would allow us to identify these ancestors before the currently accepted universal common ancestor.

1043
01:06:06.505 --> 01:06:06.705
Yeah.

1044
01:06:06.905 --> 01:06:13.130
In terms of traversing the path of evolution from like single cell to multicellular organisms.

1045
01:06:13.290 --> 01:06:13.411
Yeah.

1046
01:06:13.431 --> 01:06:13.531
Yeah.

1047
01:06:14.111 --> 01:06:14.833
Unbelievable.

1048
01:06:15.053 --> 01:06:17.538
This is out of Oberlin College, MIT.

1049
01:06:17.618 --> 01:06:19.061
I misdated MIT earlier.

1050
01:06:19.381 --> 01:06:20.544
This was the MIT story.

1051
01:06:20.804 --> 01:06:24.551
And our Midwest companions, UW-Madison.

1052
01:06:24.571 --> 01:06:24.872
Of course.

1053
01:06:24.972 --> 01:06:26.014
In Cell Genomics.

1054
01:06:26.854 --> 01:06:40.107
We're going to move to our last rundown story, which is about astrophysics and exoplanets, which astronomers have discovered a solar system that should not be possible.

1055
01:06:40.147 --> 01:06:43.430
Four planets orbiting a red dwarf 116 light years away from Earth.

1056
01:06:46.333 --> 01:07:03.295
from earth yeah so what is happening here and why should this solar system not be possible right so we used to think that every solar system should kind of look like ours for very good reasons the way it looks like ours is the inner planets are rocky the outer planets are gas giants right that makes sense because when

1057
01:07:04.436 --> 01:07:28.967
solar systems form the star is going to be very volatile so it's going to the radiation from that proto star is going to basically shoo away all of these lighter elements like helium and hydrogen and ice and things like that the rocky elements like iron and other nickel that's going to stick around the star and create rocky planets and then the outside is going to be gas giants that's how our solar system is the physics makes sense yes

1058
01:07:29.367 --> 01:07:31.747
They have found an inside-out solar system.

1059
01:07:32.108 --> 01:07:36.228
This solar system goes rocky, gas giant, gas giant, rocky.

1060
01:07:36.848 --> 01:07:36.948
Oh.

1061
01:07:37.248 --> 01:07:38.649
And that really doesn't make sense.

1062
01:07:38.669 --> 01:07:39.569
Yeah, that doesn't make any sense.

1063
01:07:39.629 --> 01:07:39.909
Okay?

1064
01:07:39.989 --> 01:07:41.889
Just from the physics argument that I gave you.

1065
01:07:41.909 --> 01:07:42.049
Yes.

1066
01:07:42.269 --> 01:07:42.469
Right?

1067
01:07:42.829 --> 01:07:45.230
And they're trying to figure out what the hell is going on.

1068
01:07:45.430 --> 01:07:45.670
Right.

1069
01:07:45.850 --> 01:07:46.130
Okay?

1070
01:07:46.450 --> 01:07:51.931
This rocky planet that's on the outside is 1.7 times the mass of the Earth.

1071
01:07:52.031 --> 01:07:54.532
It's what astronomers would call a super-Earth.

1072
01:07:54.932 --> 01:07:56.092
They tried to figure out, like...

1073
01:07:56.732 --> 01:07:57.773
Ways that it could have formed.

1074
01:07:57.813 --> 01:08:01.997
Like, suppose maybe it was a gas giant, but then the atmosphere got ripped apart, right?

1075
01:08:02.037 --> 01:08:04.459
And so now we're seeing it as a rocky planet.

1076
01:08:04.719 --> 01:08:06.641
They did a bunch of simulations, didn't work.

1077
01:08:07.181 --> 01:08:13.647
So what they think is happening is that this outer rocky planet actually just formed later in the history.

1078
01:08:14.188 --> 01:08:16.870
Because suppose the inner planets formed early.

1079
01:08:16.950 --> 01:08:18.612
So you got the rocky planet on the inside.

1080
01:08:18.872 --> 01:08:19.893
You got two gas giants.

1081
01:08:20.193 --> 01:08:21.914
Those gas giants have hoarded...

1082
01:08:22.895 --> 01:08:23.756
All of the gas.

1083
01:08:24.396 --> 01:08:31.142
And now when this outside one formed, there was no gas around to really like nucleate on the outside.

1084
01:08:31.382 --> 01:08:31.562
Right.

1085
01:08:31.602 --> 01:08:32.943
And which is why it's now rocky.

1086
01:08:33.404 --> 01:08:40.289
So the idea, the hypothesis here is that there was the difference is because of a time delay, a formation time.

1087
01:08:40.329 --> 01:08:41.310
Yes, a formation.

1088
01:08:41.390 --> 01:08:43.612
They started forming at different times.

1089
01:08:43.992 --> 01:08:48.455
And by the time that fourth planet started forming after the rocky gas giant, gas giant.

1090
01:08:49.574 --> 01:08:52.677
all of the materials to make it a gas giant were not available.

1091
01:08:52.697 --> 01:08:54.698
And so it became a rocky, exactly.

1092
01:08:54.758 --> 01:08:55.339
Rocky planet.

1093
01:08:55.359 --> 01:08:55.539
Yeah.

1094
01:08:56.079 --> 01:08:57.941
This is a good one out of university of Warwick.

1095
01:08:57.961 --> 01:08:58.141
Yeah.

1096
01:08:58.361 --> 01:09:02.284
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, plus several others in science.

1097
01:09:02.424 --> 01:09:03.245
Yeah.

1098
01:09:03.565 --> 01:09:06.607
We went long on the rundown today, but we love this stuff.

1099
01:09:06.627 --> 01:09:10.090
So sometimes we get, sometimes we get, yeah, sometimes we get a little carried away.

1100
01:09:10.810 --> 01:09:14.613
Uh, we'll try to keep it tighter, but we know you all like the details.

1101
01:09:14.813 --> 01:09:23.398
And so we will always go with the details, but we are now moving back to our theme of the week, which is the winter Olympics.

1102
01:09:24.018 --> 01:09:26.600
We talked about why is ice slippery first?

1103
01:09:26.620 --> 01:09:26.680
Um,

1104
01:09:27.240 --> 01:09:33.365
We are now moving on to our second main story, which is going to be a neuroscience story.

1105
01:09:34.265 --> 01:09:37.588
And this story is about choking under pressure.

1106
01:09:38.469 --> 01:09:40.550
Not literal pressure like in our first story.

1107
01:09:40.610 --> 01:09:40.810
No.

1108
01:09:41.271 --> 01:09:42.372
And not literal choking.

1109
01:09:42.392 --> 01:09:43.513
And not literal choking.

1110
01:09:43.853 --> 01:09:47.736
But the figure of speech, what happens in sports all the time.

1111
01:09:48.276 --> 01:09:48.997
There's a sequence.

1112
01:09:49.017 --> 01:09:50.518
You've done it a thousand times.

1113
01:09:51.298 --> 01:09:52.599
You've got a down pat.

1114
01:09:52.880 --> 01:09:54.801
You train for four years.

1115
01:09:56.022 --> 01:09:59.403
And then when it comes down to the moment, you just can't lock in.

1116
01:09:59.523 --> 01:09:59.763
Yeah.

1117
01:10:00.364 --> 01:10:04.165
And there's actually really good neuroscience basis for these.

1118
01:10:04.365 --> 01:10:04.645
Yes.

1119
01:10:05.126 --> 01:10:13.709
And I wanted to talk about this because of the recent events that have happened in Cortina and Milan.

1120
01:10:14.289 --> 01:10:17.690
This Winter Olympics, there was a man named Ilya Malinan.

1121
01:10:18.211 --> 01:10:20.912
He was purported as the quad god.

1122
01:10:21.212 --> 01:10:21.592
This is a...

1123
01:10:23.434 --> 01:10:27.595
Scientific American article talking about the physics of how he can pull off these impossible jumps.

1124
01:10:28.915 --> 01:10:30.496
He's a two-time reigning world champion.

1125
01:10:31.376 --> 01:10:41.818
Pre-event odds, before he went for the free skate portion, the individual free skate portion, negative 10,000, which is implying a probability of 99% at gold.

1126
01:10:42.178 --> 01:10:43.139
That tells me two things.

1127
01:10:43.219 --> 01:10:47.080
One, this guy is incredibly good, and everyone is thinking he's going to get gold.

1128
01:10:47.180 --> 01:10:51.040
And two, the bookkeepers have really terrible models.

1129
01:10:51.100 --> 01:10:51.421
Okay?

1130
01:10:53.801 --> 01:10:58.965
How do you not include the variability of the Olympics?

1131
01:10:59.225 --> 01:11:05.870
The Olympics is like no other event in sports, especially for these types of sports.

1132
01:11:06.330 --> 01:11:07.571
There's the world championships.

1133
01:11:07.671 --> 01:11:09.132
Okay, he's a two-time world champion.

1134
01:11:09.433 --> 01:11:10.473
The Olympics is different.

1135
01:11:10.834 --> 01:11:12.315
I don't watch the world championships.

1136
01:11:12.875 --> 01:11:13.255
Okay?

1137
01:11:13.455 --> 01:11:16.518
People who are into ice skating will watch the world championships.

1138
01:11:16.538 --> 01:11:16.678
Yep.

1139
01:11:17.158 --> 01:11:20.120
But everybody is watching the Olympics, right?

1140
01:11:20.240 --> 01:11:26.244
I think I just saw this chart the other day where the Winter Olympics is like the number five most watched sporting event.

1141
01:11:26.885 --> 01:11:32.809
Only behind the Cricket World Cup, the Summer Olympics, and the World Cup.

1142
01:11:32.869 --> 01:11:34.370
And one other event that's escaping me.

1143
01:11:34.630 --> 01:11:37.971
But it is, and it's in the billion, like, it's a massive, it's a massive thing.

1144
01:11:37.991 --> 01:11:39.491
It's like 10x the Super Bowl.

1145
01:11:39.511 --> 01:11:41.812
Like, it's very, very watched.

1146
01:11:41.872 --> 01:11:43.052
Yes, exactly.

1147
01:11:43.492 --> 01:11:45.012
He was the quad god.

1148
01:11:45.433 --> 01:11:48.093
He was going to get gold, 99% chance.

1149
01:11:48.673 --> 01:11:52.294
He gets on the ice, and he completely chokes, okay?

1150
01:11:53.094 --> 01:11:58.456
He was going to make this quad axle, which was going to be the first time anyone's ever done it in competition.

1151
01:11:58.556 --> 01:11:59.616
Everyone was looking forward to it.

1152
01:12:00.076 --> 01:12:00.716
This was crazy.

1153
01:12:00.756 --> 01:12:02.457
I was watching it live, dude.

1154
01:12:02.817 --> 01:12:03.997
He goes for his first jump.

1155
01:12:04.697 --> 01:12:07.841
which is the quad flip does it very well.

1156
01:12:08.222 --> 01:12:10.224
The commentators say it's an effortless start.

1157
01:12:10.865 --> 01:12:12.567
The next one is going to be this quad axle.

1158
01:12:12.647 --> 01:12:15.811
And the commentators say, if he's going to go for the quad axle, it's going to be this next one.

1159
01:12:16.392 --> 01:12:19.676
He think, I think he goes for it in the middle of the jump.

1160
01:12:20.157 --> 01:12:20.878
He abandons it.

1161
01:12:21.518 --> 01:12:22.620
He only does one turn.

1162
01:12:22.640 --> 01:12:23.060
Mm-hmm.

1163
01:12:23.701 --> 01:12:26.022
And from there, it just unravels.

1164
01:12:26.342 --> 01:12:28.962
Like mentally, he just like completely collapsed.

1165
01:12:29.002 --> 01:12:29.162
Yep.

1166
01:12:29.362 --> 01:12:29.522
Yep.

1167
01:12:29.803 --> 01:12:30.063
Okay.

1168
01:12:30.083 --> 01:12:30.203
Yep.

1169
01:12:30.583 --> 01:12:37.224
And I just thought that was so fascinating because this is a guy who's done that routine probably thousands of times.

1170
01:12:37.244 --> 01:12:38.165
He's prepared for it.

1171
01:12:38.225 --> 01:12:38.445
Right.

1172
01:12:38.865 --> 01:12:40.965
And the Olympic ice is just different.

1173
01:12:41.665 --> 01:12:41.865
Right.

1174
01:12:42.846 --> 01:12:43.546
It's still water.

1175
01:12:43.646 --> 01:12:44.606
It's still H2O.

1176
01:12:44.646 --> 01:12:47.587
But there's something that is different about that moment.

1177
01:12:47.667 --> 01:12:47.867
Yes.

1178
01:12:48.427 --> 01:12:52.568
that just completely, the house of cards just completely collapsed.

1179
01:12:52.968 --> 01:12:55.549
And it's not a physics issue.

1180
01:12:55.769 --> 01:12:55.989
No.

1181
01:12:56.209 --> 01:12:57.309
Like we talked about earlier.

1182
01:12:57.369 --> 01:12:57.529
No.

1183
01:12:57.949 --> 01:13:00.150
It is a, it's a neuroscience issue.

1184
01:13:00.170 --> 01:13:01.090
It's a neuroscience issue.

1185
01:13:01.330 --> 01:13:03.170
And afterwards he said, it's the Olympics.

1186
01:13:03.230 --> 01:13:08.552
And I think people only realize the pressure and the nerves that actually happen when you're on the ice.

1187
01:13:08.672 --> 01:13:08.872
Right.

1188
01:13:08.912 --> 01:13:10.832
And it was something that just overwhelmed me.

1189
01:13:10.872 --> 01:13:12.652
And I felt like I had no control.

1190
01:13:12.913 --> 01:13:14.053
This is a quote from Ilya.

1191
01:13:14.673 --> 01:13:14.833
And I.

1192
01:13:16.217 --> 01:13:19.299
From there, I wanted to talk about sort of what that means.

1193
01:13:19.359 --> 01:13:23.342
What is going on in an athlete's brain when something like that happens?

1194
01:13:24.123 --> 01:13:33.269
And before we jump in, I just want to be clear here, especially as someone who is a former athlete at a high level, this is not meant to be disparaging to Ilya.

1195
01:13:34.030 --> 01:13:34.230
No.

1196
01:13:34.270 --> 01:13:36.351
Sports is extremely difficult.

1197
01:13:36.451 --> 01:13:36.691
Yeah.

1198
01:13:37.132 --> 01:13:39.473
And the stakes are very high.

1199
01:13:39.533 --> 01:13:40.994
There's a lot of money involved.

1200
01:13:42.295 --> 01:13:44.477
It is just the topic that is...

1201
01:13:45.698 --> 01:13:47.380
It's there for us to discuss.

1202
01:13:47.580 --> 01:13:48.981
And I think it's interesting.

1203
01:13:49.061 --> 01:13:51.243
There's an interesting science angle here.

1204
01:13:51.624 --> 01:13:55.107
And so we're trying to understand the neuroscience of this.

1205
01:13:55.547 --> 01:13:59.851
This is not about, oh, my God, I can't believe he failed or didn't fail.

1206
01:13:59.932 --> 01:14:00.953
No, yeah, no.

1207
01:14:00.973 --> 01:14:04.196
We're going to be talking smack, but it's going to be later, and it's not going to be about Ilya.

1208
01:14:04.256 --> 01:14:04.456
Yeah.

1209
01:14:04.916 --> 01:14:28.352
don't you worry this is an olympics podcast but you know ilia is very young and he's gonna be fine so he's gonna be back in the next olympics and you know one of the things that we're gonna uncover about the neuroscience of choking is the more experience you have the better these pathways get to prevent you from doing that that's why lebron is still like incredible right at like just shooting yes even under pressure right yes

1210
01:14:28.772 --> 01:14:33.437
So let's get into some of the theoretical frameworks before we dive into the neuroscience.

1211
01:14:33.457 --> 01:14:33.677
Okay.

1212
01:14:33.918 --> 01:14:35.980
There's several theories behind why this happens.

1213
01:14:36.160 --> 01:14:37.621
One is called the distraction theory.

1214
01:14:38.142 --> 01:14:44.469
What it says is basically working memory, which is like your memory of like events that are happening now and what you need to do in a while.

1215
01:14:44.809 --> 01:14:47.392
That has a finite capacity and it's flooded with...

1216
01:14:47.812 --> 01:15:15.289
task irrelevant stressors like there's fear about failing there's the crowd there's the cameras on you um and so you get this sort of loss of goal-directed control of attention okay that's the distraction theory then there's um the explicit monitoring theory which is actually the opposite which says that okay athletes actually consciously control some automated practice skill and if you overthink

1217
01:15:16.617 --> 01:15:17.578
That's when it hurts you.

1218
01:15:17.958 --> 01:15:23.342
OK, if you if you start consciously thinking about what you're trying to do, that's actually what's bad.

1219
01:15:23.662 --> 01:15:28.085
And then there's another one, which is this over arousal or over over motivation theory.

1220
01:15:29.065 --> 01:15:35.009
And that's the idea that there's actually an optimal amount of arousal when it comes to doing difficult and easy tasks.

1221
01:15:35.610 --> 01:15:39.993
And if you want to do difficult tasks, you should be aroused less.

1222
01:15:41.387 --> 01:15:45.191
than if you're doing easy tasks, which is kind of incredible to think about.

1223
01:15:45.231 --> 01:15:47.633
When you're doing an easy task, you want to be more in it.

1224
01:15:48.113 --> 01:15:51.957
But when you're doing a really hard task, it's kind of better to...

1225
01:15:53.402 --> 01:15:55.182
To be a little bit out of it.

1226
01:15:55.242 --> 01:15:56.543
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1227
01:15:56.663 --> 01:15:59.063
It's kind of probably what people describe as that flow state.

1228
01:15:59.563 --> 01:16:00.144
Exactly.

1229
01:16:00.264 --> 01:16:05.825
It's the flow state versus the intense attentional control that you're putting on something, right?

1230
01:16:06.125 --> 01:16:06.285
Right.

1231
01:16:06.385 --> 01:16:11.246
And so in the context of these theories, I wanted to talk about the brain regions.

1232
01:16:11.666 --> 01:16:17.968
The main brain regions we're going to talk about is the prefrontal cortex, the motor cortex, and the amygdala.

1233
01:16:23.409 --> 01:16:23.969
Right up here.

1234
01:16:24.330 --> 01:16:26.371
This is something that is very big in humans.

1235
01:16:26.751 --> 01:16:27.911
It's also there in primates.

1236
01:16:28.011 --> 01:16:30.593
It's not so much there in lower order mammals.

1237
01:16:30.933 --> 01:16:31.173
Okay.

1238
01:16:31.473 --> 01:16:35.175
This is where you have executive control, working memory.

1239
01:16:35.455 --> 01:16:38.696
You delegate micro mechanics to the other subcortical structures.

1240
01:16:38.997 --> 01:16:41.858
So this is kind of like our control center in some sense.

1241
01:16:42.178 --> 01:16:43.899
I mean, I remember there was this guy.

1242
01:16:44.079 --> 01:16:45.119
He's still there.

1243
01:16:45.580 --> 01:16:47.481
Professor Bujaki at NYU.

1244
01:16:47.961 --> 01:16:49.421
He hates when people say this.

1245
01:16:49.662 --> 01:16:52.403
He used to call it the prefrontal cortex, the trash can.

1246
01:16:52.783 --> 01:17:16.901
of the brain because whenever someone i was like oh this this is probably the prefrontal cortex but the reason is because it's such a highly evolved part of our brain that it seems that a lot of these higher functions are happening here right if that makes sense yep so there was an experiment that was done um about the prefrontal cortex and how the prefrontal cortex functionally disconnects

1247
01:17:17.861 --> 01:17:37.948
with the other court with the other courtesies during high stress it was a pretty in pretty incredible paper um called out of control diminished prefrontal activity coincides with impaired motor performance here's what it was doing okay they use fmri data and they have this bimanual visual motor tasks where um people like

1248
01:17:38.768 --> 01:17:40.190
human beings are playing snake.

1249
01:17:40.710 --> 01:17:40.951
Okay.

1250
01:17:41.311 --> 01:17:45.316
And every once in a while, whenever they get the snake game, right, they get like 10 bucks.

1251
01:17:45.857 --> 01:17:48.900
Every once in a while, they'll get a jackpot of like 50 bucks.

1252
01:17:49.601 --> 01:17:54.387
And they want to, they want to see how the, how the participants do.

1253
01:17:55.228 --> 01:17:56.930
They actually performed less than,

1254
01:17:58.455 --> 01:17:59.696
On the jackpot tasks.

1255
01:18:00.056 --> 01:18:00.957
It's the same game.

1256
01:18:01.057 --> 01:18:01.277
Right.

1257
01:18:01.297 --> 01:18:06.722
But when there's this pressure of, oh, I could just win like 50 bucks instead of 10, the performance dropped.

1258
01:18:07.022 --> 01:18:17.271
And then when they look at the prefrontal cortex and the motor cortex connectivity during these jackpot trials, it was inversely related to choking susceptibility.

1259
01:18:17.611 --> 01:18:21.335
Meaning the less it was connected, the more you were going to choke.

1260
01:18:21.355 --> 01:18:21.495
Mm-hmm.

1261
01:18:22.556 --> 01:18:27.219
So there's literally a connectivity issue between your prefrontal cortex and your motor cortex.

1262
01:18:27.239 --> 01:18:29.761
The motor cortex is the thing that's actually doing the gameplay.

1263
01:18:30.181 --> 01:18:35.125
And when that connection goes down, you're likely to choke more.

1264
01:18:35.145 --> 01:18:38.148
Now, the question is, why is this connection going down?

1265
01:18:38.168 --> 01:18:39.929
During these high-stress situations?

1266
01:18:41.713 --> 01:18:42.914
Scenarios.

1267
01:18:43.034 --> 01:18:52.844
So the initial intuitive thought process is, okay, the high stress scenario is what is directly correlated to the decreased connection between the prefrontal cortex and the motor cortex, theoretically.

1268
01:18:52.865 --> 01:18:53.886
Theoretically, right?

1269
01:18:53.986 --> 01:18:56.769
But in neuroscience, we always want something more mechanistic.

1270
01:18:56.889 --> 01:18:57.069
Right.

1271
01:18:57.389 --> 01:18:57.569
Right.

1272
01:18:57.589 --> 01:18:57.830
Right.

1273
01:18:57.850 --> 01:18:57.970
Right.

1274
01:18:58.330 --> 01:18:58.950
At least I do.

1275
01:18:59.451 --> 01:19:02.392
And so now let's go to this next paper.

1276
01:19:02.412 --> 01:19:05.734
This was from Smulder and other authors in 2024.

1277
01:19:06.374 --> 01:19:09.956
This was in Neuron, A Neural Basis of Choking Under Pressure.

1278
01:19:10.297 --> 01:19:13.338
And what a title for a paper, can I just say?

1279
01:19:14.919 --> 01:19:37.329
um here's what they did they use you they um they used 96 channel utah arrays in reas macaques so macaques have a prefrontal cortex kind of like we do um this was in the motor cortex and in another brain region called pmd and they had the similar um behavioral paradigm of choking under pressure basically there were these jackpot

1280
01:19:38.801 --> 01:19:54.160
scenarios where the monkey knew that if it succeeded it was going to get a really high reward and again the same thing happens you get this increase in performance but when you get an incredibly high reward anticipation your performance decreases

1281
01:19:54.420 --> 01:20:00.643
So what we're looking at here is three charts of monkey E, P, and R with six sessions, nine sessions, and 12 sessions.

1282
01:20:01.343 --> 01:20:04.745
And on the Y axis is success rate.

1283
01:20:05.085 --> 01:20:10.227
And on the X axis is sort of jackpot size, going from small going to large.

1284
01:20:10.587 --> 01:20:16.370
And you can basically see this like top of a trapezoid where we have at small to medium...

1285
01:20:16.830 --> 01:20:17.490
There's an increase.

1286
01:20:17.510 --> 01:20:18.451
There's a huge increase.

1287
01:20:18.971 --> 01:20:22.153
And then medium to large, it kind of maintains that higher level success rate.

1288
01:20:22.493 --> 01:20:31.318
And you see a very drastic decrease in performance when you move from large to jackpot across all these session lengths and all of these different subjects.

1289
01:20:31.398 --> 01:20:31.838
Exactly.

1290
01:20:31.898 --> 01:20:40.963
And so regardless of number of repeats, et cetera, et cetera, there's a clear decrease in performance efficacy when the jackpot gets sufficiently high.

1291
01:20:41.083 --> 01:20:44.926
Yeah, and the jackpot is way higher than the large is the other big thing.

1292
01:20:44.966 --> 01:20:50.290
It's like small, medium, large are like successively higher, but jackpot is like an actual jackpot.

1293
01:20:50.590 --> 01:20:53.492
And that's kind of what the Olympics are in some sense, right?

1294
01:20:53.812 --> 01:20:59.696
Like the stress is so high and that gold medal that's like sitting there could be yours.

1295
01:21:00.197 --> 01:21:01.798
It's incredible, right?

1296
01:21:02.098 --> 01:21:03.699
And so how do we manage that?

1297
01:21:03.959 --> 01:21:04.460
And so, okay.

1298
01:21:05.200 --> 01:21:08.723
We saw the behavioral paradigm, which is the same as we have in humans.

1299
01:21:09.324 --> 01:21:20.033
The trick is now we want to find a neural paradigm, something in the neurons themselves that correlates to that behavioral paradigm, because then we found a neural signature for what is happening.

1300
01:21:20.073 --> 01:21:20.293
Yes.

1301
01:21:20.313 --> 01:21:20.533
Right?

1302
01:21:21.194 --> 01:21:23.896
They use something called dimensionality reduction.

1303
01:21:23.956 --> 01:21:26.038
This is something that we've been through in neuroscience.

1304
01:21:26.078 --> 01:21:30.742
The idea is your brain lives in a very high dimensional subspace, right?

1305
01:21:30.822 --> 01:21:31.202
If you're...

1306
01:21:31.943 --> 01:21:41.654
If you're listening to 10,000 neurons, that's 10,000 different dimensions in your mathematical subspace of where your brain is.

1307
01:21:42.315 --> 01:21:44.477
Your brain doesn't actually live in that subspace.

1308
01:21:44.517 --> 01:21:45.899
That's just how we're describing it.

1309
01:21:46.300 --> 01:21:47.901
There might be lower dimensions.

1310
01:21:48.522 --> 01:21:55.289
that we can move along that tell us something about, oh, how much does the brain care about reward in this scenario?

1311
01:21:55.649 --> 01:22:01.034
How much does the brain care about the target, getting to the target and getting that reward in this scenario, right?

1312
01:22:01.314 --> 01:22:06.920
We can decompose the brain activity into independent metrics and see what happens.

1313
01:22:07.600 --> 01:22:09.722
So what they found was in the reward axis...

1314
01:22:10.503 --> 01:22:14.045
there was an axis that basically correlated with reward.

1315
01:22:14.446 --> 01:22:16.807
So when it was jackpot, it was really high.

1316
01:22:16.827 --> 01:22:19.189
There were a bunch of neurons that were firing when it was a jackpot.

1317
01:22:19.449 --> 01:22:21.090
And that was like those neurons care about.

1318
01:22:21.250 --> 01:22:23.792
It's like kind of telling the rest of the brain, hey, there's going to be a jackpot.

1319
01:22:24.032 --> 01:22:25.092
Like we got to lock in.

1320
01:22:25.373 --> 01:22:25.593
Okay.

1321
01:22:25.933 --> 01:22:28.955
Then there's another one, which is the target preparation axis.

1322
01:22:29.395 --> 01:22:29.655
Okay.

1323
01:22:29.976 --> 01:22:38.341
This is the dimension within the target plane that is critical to the reach, which is part of the task.

1324
01:22:38.601 --> 01:22:39.982
Like how far am I going to reach?

1325
01:22:40.042 --> 01:22:42.923
for the macaques to get this reward, right?

1326
01:22:43.584 --> 01:22:53.449
And that target axis has the same behavior as what we saw in behavior, meaning for low reward, I'm not that high on the target axis.

1327
01:22:53.809 --> 01:22:57.571
But as I go to jackpot reward, again, I come back, okay?

1328
01:22:57.651 --> 01:23:09.377
So these neurons, these specific neurons that care about the target axis, the geometry of the brain has changed to where this target axis is actually the thing that is causing that choking under pressure.

1329
01:23:10.158 --> 01:23:24.071
The point being there is now a neurological signature that maps onto the behavioral experimental data around this idea of there being sort of this diminishing...

1330
01:23:25.612 --> 01:23:29.514
as the jackpot gets sufficiently high in task completion.

1331
01:23:29.634 --> 01:23:30.615
Exactly, exactly.

1332
01:23:30.895 --> 01:23:33.236
And now we can actually think about a mechanism, right?

1333
01:23:33.336 --> 01:23:37.418
And what they came up with is something called the expansion, then collapse mechanism.

1334
01:23:37.718 --> 01:23:38.778
Here's the idea, okay?

1335
01:23:39.058 --> 01:23:40.599
For small reward...

1336
01:23:41.987 --> 01:23:43.529
I'm influenced by reward a lot.

1337
01:23:44.210 --> 01:23:44.490
Okay.

1338
01:23:44.951 --> 01:23:50.257
But as I move in this trajectory, there is some optimal space that I want my brain to be in.

1339
01:23:50.577 --> 01:23:50.797
Okay.

1340
01:23:51.038 --> 01:23:56.244
There's like an optimal location in all of my neurons, in all of my neural space that I want to be in.

1341
01:23:56.725 --> 01:23:56.965
Okay.

1342
01:23:57.285 --> 01:23:59.888
But when I get this massive motivational signal,

1343
01:24:00.589 --> 01:24:25.397
from the jackpot trials what that's going to drew do is put my system into overdrive and it's going to push my system away from this optimal setting yep right yes so where now my neural states abruptly like collapse on top of each other yep and i i can't actually discern between like what to do when i have the task in front of me

1344
01:24:26.537 --> 01:24:28.858
Because all of my neurons are in overdrive.

1345
01:24:28.898 --> 01:24:30.379
I've got stress neurons coming in.

1346
01:24:30.619 --> 01:24:33.101
I've got the future planning neurons coming in.

1347
01:24:33.121 --> 01:24:36.683
What am I going to do when I get... What's going to happen in the future?

1348
01:24:37.003 --> 01:24:40.165
All of the past mistakes that I've done, that stuff's coming in.

1349
01:24:40.185 --> 01:24:41.065
The memory's coming in.

1350
01:24:41.265 --> 01:24:43.387
All of the stress is trying to get into this...

1351
01:24:44.235 --> 01:24:45.296
Flight or fight response.

1352
01:24:45.656 --> 01:24:47.678
And it's putting your brain into overdrive.

1353
01:24:47.738 --> 01:24:53.363
And then you get a physical failure because now you can no longer actually do the task as well as you once could.

1354
01:24:54.083 --> 01:24:58.407
Just I want to bring up this chart again, which is this neural bias.

1355
01:24:58.487 --> 01:24:59.568
Why do animals choke?

1356
01:24:59.588 --> 01:25:01.870
And we're looking at an X, Y, and Z axis.

1357
01:25:02.490 --> 01:25:07.393
Neuron one is, let's say, X, neuron two is Y, neuron N is Z.

1358
01:25:08.013 --> 01:25:18.240
And we sort of see the influence of the reward, small, large, and jackpot, like, you know, in a 2D image meant to represent its 3D positioning on this X, Y, and Z axis.

1359
01:25:18.800 --> 01:25:25.324
And the point is sort of saying, I'm saying, the large, the little circle with the dots around it.

1360
01:25:25.484 --> 01:25:26.404
That's the optimal.

1361
01:25:26.424 --> 01:25:28.305
That's your target region where you want to be at.

1362
01:25:28.325 --> 01:25:36.268
That's where you want to be because that's where all the balance of all of the inputs and everything is just right for you to execute.

1363
01:25:36.288 --> 01:25:36.488
Yeah.

1364
01:25:36.968 --> 01:25:45.031
And what we're sort of saying here is the introduction of a jackpot reward moves you beyond that optimal positioning.

1365
01:25:45.211 --> 01:25:47.194
Because there's so much other stimulus coming in.

1366
01:25:47.214 --> 01:25:51.319
Coming in and going on, which sort of it makes sense because if you just think about athletes, right?

1367
01:25:51.419 --> 01:26:01.573
Some of the athletes in every sport who we mention as being the GOAT, when you look at them playing, almost if you talk about people like Messi, Wayne Gretzky, Usain Bolt, etc.,

1368
01:26:02.634 --> 01:26:14.142
visually when you're looking at them with the human eye test, it almost appears as if they are totally unperturbed, disturbed, unfazed by anything going on around them.

1369
01:26:14.222 --> 01:26:15.843
And it's like they're floating.

1370
01:26:15.863 --> 01:26:17.704
People always describe Michael Phelps.

1371
01:26:17.724 --> 01:26:22.507
They're like, they are operating at a plane that is different than anybody else.

1372
01:26:22.527 --> 01:26:26.610
Yeah, because they've somehow disconnected that input drive that's coming in.

1373
01:26:26.670 --> 01:26:28.671
And I think that comes a lot with experience.

1374
01:26:29.032 --> 01:26:29.252
Yes.

1375
01:26:29.692 --> 01:26:29.852
Right.

1376
01:26:29.872 --> 01:26:30.392
Which is fair.

1377
01:26:30.653 --> 01:26:31.133
Which is fair.

1378
01:26:31.333 --> 01:26:33.997
Like when it's your first time at the Olympics, like Ilya's,

1379
01:26:35.169 --> 01:26:37.250
Mate, like, I don't know what that's like.

1380
01:26:37.310 --> 01:26:38.770
That's got to be insane.

1381
01:26:38.810 --> 01:26:39.510
You've been working.

1382
01:26:39.610 --> 01:26:43.751
You've been dreaming about this moment for the past, like, God knows how many years.

1383
01:26:43.771 --> 01:26:47.172
He's probably started, you know, ice skating very, very young.

1384
01:26:47.572 --> 01:26:49.492
Like, since he could walk, probably, or something.

1385
01:26:50.032 --> 01:26:50.312
You know?

1386
01:26:50.372 --> 01:26:53.153
And then you think about the gold medal opportunity.

1387
01:26:53.313 --> 01:26:54.093
Everyone is there.

1388
01:26:54.353 --> 01:26:56.634
The NBC is calling you the quad god.

1389
01:26:56.994 --> 01:26:57.234
Right?

1390
01:26:57.294 --> 01:26:58.634
Like, there's so much hype.

1391
01:26:58.654 --> 01:26:59.234
99% on Polymarket.

1392
01:26:59.274 --> 01:26:59.394
Yes.

1393
01:26:59.414 --> 01:26:59.654
Yeah.

1394
01:27:02.255 --> 01:27:03.876
Like that's got to be so much pressure.

1395
01:27:03.996 --> 01:27:13.660
I would love to see the same group do research on Lamine Yamal because this kid is 19 now and he's dominating grown men.

1396
01:27:14.261 --> 01:27:14.481
Yeah.

1397
01:27:14.501 --> 01:27:15.321
Yeah.

1398
01:27:15.421 --> 01:27:20.404
In every level of competition in soccer, football, globally.

1399
01:27:20.824 --> 01:27:22.084
And it doesn't make any sense.

1400
01:27:22.265 --> 01:27:22.545
Yeah.

1401
01:27:22.665 --> 01:27:27.327
And there has to be something upstairs that is blocking everything.

1402
01:27:27.982 --> 01:27:48.812
going to the jackpot yeah space in the in the gradient descent how is he with like free kicks and penalties he's unbelievable because that's that's sort of where i would expect choking to happen right because that's an individual kind of thing this kid with team sports i can i don't you know fair i wonder if we can take these fair no no that's fair because it's a little bit different yeah it's a little bit tiger woods

1403
01:27:48.912 --> 01:27:54.657
Because also Ilya in the team event, although that was a free skate that he did individual and he crushed it.

1404
01:27:54.937 --> 01:27:55.758
So like over 200.

1405
01:27:55.778 --> 01:27:56.799
No, that's a good point.

1406
01:27:56.819 --> 01:28:01.783
But then when it came to his individual, which was only a few days later, he followed the same procedure.

1407
01:28:01.883 --> 01:28:03.444
And like, that's a very good point.

1408
01:28:03.464 --> 01:28:05.165
You know, I only bring it up because he's young.

1409
01:28:05.506 --> 01:28:06.266
Yeah.

1410
01:28:06.286 --> 01:28:07.868
And like as a counter...

1411
01:28:08.860 --> 01:28:15.268
a counter thesis to the experience point, but you, you correct team sports and individual sports, very different context.

1412
01:28:15.288 --> 01:28:16.650
Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly.

1413
01:28:17.070 --> 01:28:20.935
And, um, I just want to end with, you know, Ilya.

1414
01:28:21.055 --> 01:28:26.322
Now he's, he, I mean, he's like beside himself and one, one of the,

1415
01:28:27.909 --> 01:28:33.655
articles was just about, you know, it's kind of the point that winning Olympic gold isn't supposed to be easy.

1416
01:28:34.056 --> 01:28:41.043
And I don't know who thought it was a 99 percent because with sports at the highest level, anything can happen.

1417
01:28:41.384 --> 01:28:48.551
You know, and one of the things he added was I just felt like all the traumatic moments of my life really just started flooding in my head.

1418
01:28:49.212 --> 01:28:52.014
And there was just too many negative thoughts that just flooded in there.

1419
01:28:52.514 --> 01:28:53.855
And I just did not handle it.

1420
01:28:53.875 --> 01:29:05.942
This is a quote from him afterwards, which is I mean, it's incredible that such a young man has the vocabulary and mental fortitude after such a traumatic event to even speak to the press.

1421
01:29:06.062 --> 01:29:09.284
I think I would like give the middle finger and just like leave.

1422
01:29:09.604 --> 01:29:10.905
But, you know, I think he's going to be back.

1423
01:29:11.625 --> 01:29:13.007
I have seen him do the...

1424
01:29:13.747 --> 01:29:18.332
I've seen videos of him practicing that quad axle thing, and it's incredible.

1425
01:29:19.013 --> 01:29:22.837
And it's also when he's doing it in the practice, it looks effortless.

1426
01:29:22.897 --> 01:29:23.537
It looks effortless.

1427
01:29:23.557 --> 01:29:24.638
Which is crazy.

1428
01:29:24.859 --> 01:29:24.999
Yeah.

1429
01:29:25.039 --> 01:29:26.420
Because it's so ridiculous.

1430
01:29:26.440 --> 01:29:27.942
Yeah, it's so ridiculous how many turns.

1431
01:29:27.962 --> 01:29:30.384
He's like four and a half turns landing backwards.

1432
01:29:30.504 --> 01:29:31.085
It's crazy.

1433
01:29:31.385 --> 01:29:35.430
On that thin millimeter blade with the 100 nanometers of slimy water.

1434
01:29:35.450 --> 01:29:36.391
Yeah, maintaining balance.

1435
01:29:36.491 --> 01:29:37.432
Like, it's crazy.

1436
01:29:37.572 --> 01:29:37.773
Yeah.

1437
01:29:38.273 --> 01:29:39.635
So he'll probably be back.

1438
01:29:39.675 --> 01:29:45.181
But I just took that opportunity as a quick deep dive into neuroscience because I always love that stuff.

1439
01:29:45.221 --> 01:29:46.322
No, it's fascinating.

1440
01:29:46.683 --> 01:29:49.967
Again, I think, you know, sports, as we move into the era of...

1441
01:29:50.327 --> 01:30:00.691
infinite social media and infinite content and TV and movies are sort of losing their luster of all of us watching them for the first time at the same time with binging and all this stuff.

1442
01:30:01.051 --> 01:30:08.574
Sports as a medium and the importance of sports as being a connective tissue that's real time.

1443
01:30:08.634 --> 01:30:10.375
It's the only appointment that...

1444
01:30:11.612 --> 01:30:12.452
media left.

1445
01:30:12.613 --> 01:30:12.833
Yeah.

1446
01:30:13.073 --> 01:30:17.357
You got to, you got to be there when it happens both in person or digital.

1447
01:30:17.377 --> 01:30:17.557
Yep.

1448
01:30:18.218 --> 01:30:22.421
And it is, you know, we see these kinds of situations.

1449
01:30:22.902 --> 01:30:24.403
This, this was not meant to focus on it.

1450
01:30:24.423 --> 01:30:26.425
It happens in all sports all of the time.

1451
01:30:26.765 --> 01:30:36.554
Why is it that Zion Williamson in the NBA was one of the most lauded NBA draft recruits that everyone was super excited for him to be the next big thing in the NBA.

1452
01:30:36.574 --> 01:30:36.814
Yeah.

1453
01:30:37.455 --> 01:30:38.175
Totally flopped.

1454
01:30:38.456 --> 01:30:42.858
But now Cooper flag, 19 year old comes in same kind of pathway.

1455
01:30:42.918 --> 01:30:45.559
People like he's absolutely dominant.

1456
01:30:45.619 --> 01:30:51.382
And it's, it's very interesting to see this play out across different sports and across different contexts.

1457
01:30:51.402 --> 01:30:51.563
Yep.

1458
01:30:52.103 --> 01:30:58.526
We are going to wrap up the day with our sort of final main section, which is a little bit of a potpourri.

1459
01:30:58.566 --> 01:30:58.746
Yeah.

1460
01:30:58.786 --> 01:30:59.447
It's a hodgepodge.

1461
01:30:59.467 --> 01:31:00.507
It's a little miscellaneous.

1462
01:31:00.547 --> 01:31:01.868
There will be a climate change.

1463
01:31:02.128 --> 01:31:18.097
science aspect to this but we're going to cover a lot of different areas i think you did have some other random thoughts about the olympics given our olympics uh focus here so why don't we start with some of this potpourri that you got for us

1464
01:31:18.337 --> 01:31:20.659
Yeah, so the first thing I want to talk about is climate change.

1465
01:31:21.359 --> 01:31:26.543
It is real, and it's going to hurt Winter Olympics a lot more than Summer Olympics, as you can imagine, right?

1466
01:31:26.823 --> 01:31:33.847
With the earth warming, the first Olympic Winter Games were held in Shamanics, France in 1924.

1467
01:31:33.968 --> 01:31:36.129
All 16 events took place outdoors.

1468
01:31:36.149 --> 01:31:38.711
Look at these fine gentlemen in suits.

1469
01:31:38.931 --> 01:31:44.575
Like, they're ready to, you know, I think this is the skate race, the 1,000-meter skating race.

1470
01:31:45.656 --> 01:31:51.421
The athletes relied on natural snow for all the ski runs and the freezing temperatures on the ice rings.

1471
01:31:51.782 --> 01:31:53.784
Now we get to 2022 in Beijing.

1472
01:31:54.564 --> 01:31:55.966
All artificial snow.

1473
01:31:56.526 --> 01:31:56.746
Yes.

1474
01:31:57.047 --> 01:31:59.789
Not a single snowflake there was...

1475
01:32:00.953 --> 01:32:02.875
made by the actual weather.

1476
01:32:03.235 --> 01:32:05.537
It was all artificial snow in 2022.

1477
01:32:06.197 --> 01:32:17.466
And in a recent study, scientists have looked at the past 19 venues on the Winter Olympics to see how each one might hold up, given the climate scenarios that we can forecast into the future.

1478
01:32:18.207 --> 01:32:28.034
They found that by mid-century, four of the former host cities, including Shamanix, Sochi, Grenoble, and somewhere in Germany, Garmisch,

1479
01:32:28.975 --> 01:32:53.359
parten question that's pretty that's pretty good yeah germany i can do that's pretty good those would no longer be able to um host reliably given the climate that we're coming in even under the best case scenario that's actually okay and if we do the current fossil fuel rate of burning then places like squaw valley and vancouver are also not going to be able to do it right this is getting pretty bad yeah and

1480
01:32:54.477 --> 01:33:00.142
Especially when we have something like the Paralympics, which happened, you know, a month or two after the real Olympics.

1481
01:33:00.723 --> 01:33:07.589
Snowmaking requirement is going to keep on increasing because we're going to have to keep making snow in March and...

1482
01:33:08.605 --> 01:33:15.670
The amount of snow that we'll have to make is going to increase all the way from zero to now like 80% if you want to do it in Eastern Europe and things like that.

1483
01:33:16.091 --> 01:33:16.291
Right?

1484
01:33:16.551 --> 01:33:17.632
I mean, we're already seeing this.

1485
01:33:17.792 --> 01:33:20.394
I talked about this, but at Big Bear.

1486
01:33:20.534 --> 01:33:22.115
Yeah.

1487
01:33:22.155 --> 01:33:26.958
The only reason you can ski on three or four of the runs right now is because of artificial snow.

1488
01:33:27.058 --> 01:33:27.219
Period.

1489
01:33:27.239 --> 01:33:27.379
Yeah.

1490
01:33:28.099 --> 01:33:31.382
And, you know, we think that, OK, maybe this can be fixed by snowmaking, right?

1491
01:33:31.822 --> 01:33:35.745
Maybe we just artificially make all the snow that we ever need.

1492
01:33:36.005 --> 01:33:40.169
That's not even going to work either, because even snowmaking works at an ideal temperature, right?

1493
01:33:40.189 --> 01:33:47.835
You need to be lower than the dew point, which is when the snow that you're putting out is not going to condense into water droplets.

1494
01:33:47.855 --> 01:33:47.975
Right.

1495
01:33:48.235 --> 01:33:48.395
Right.

1496
01:33:48.435 --> 01:33:48.595
Right.

1497
01:33:48.795 --> 01:33:53.116
And so it's you've got to be below negative two degrees Celsius, 28 degrees Fahrenheit.

1498
01:33:53.276 --> 01:33:55.617
I mean, depending on the pressure, but usual and the humidity.

1499
01:33:55.897 --> 01:33:57.837
But usually that's about the temperature.

1500
01:33:58.097 --> 01:34:05.779
Now, that's really bad because we've covered a story on this podcast before about how the world mountains are warming up faster than the planes.

1501
01:34:05.839 --> 01:34:06.039
Yes.

1502
01:34:06.159 --> 01:34:08.260
Because hot air rises and so on and so forth.

1503
01:34:08.540 --> 01:34:13.421
So we have that we have that little tidbit that the mountains are actually warming up.

1504
01:34:13.601 --> 01:34:13.701
Yes.

1505
01:34:13.721 --> 01:34:13.821
Yes.

1506
01:34:14.221 --> 01:34:23.283
So all of these factors are combining to make it really, really quite problematic to do Winter Olympics in the same places that we used to be able to do.

1507
01:34:23.863 --> 01:34:24.043
Right.

1508
01:34:24.323 --> 01:34:28.323
People are suggesting that they can do something called snow farming, which is a new thing.

1509
01:34:28.343 --> 01:34:29.424
I don't know if you've heard about this.

1510
01:34:29.504 --> 01:34:30.884
I didn't even know this was possible.

1511
01:34:30.924 --> 01:34:31.804
Okay.

1512
01:34:31.824 --> 01:34:41.226
You get a bunch of snow and you pile it up with massive piles of sawdust, tarps and wood chips, and that retains 60 to 75 percent of the snow.

1513
01:34:43.419 --> 01:34:43.979
Interesting.

1514
01:34:44.379 --> 01:34:49.242
I need to look into how the physics of that works because, like, over the summer, you're telling me it doesn't melt?

1515
01:34:49.282 --> 01:34:50.042
Yeah, I'm not.

1516
01:34:50.282 --> 01:34:52.503
That one... That's crazy, but it's, like, working.

1517
01:34:52.583 --> 01:34:54.024
It, like, works and people are doing it.

1518
01:34:54.184 --> 01:34:57.746
If you guys want us to cover the snow farming story, let us know in the comments.

1519
01:34:57.806 --> 01:34:58.146
Yeah.

1520
01:34:58.166 --> 01:34:59.427
Because I am also...

1521
01:35:00.107 --> 01:35:00.868
That doesn't make any sense.

1522
01:35:00.888 --> 01:35:01.728
That doesn't make any sense.

1523
01:35:01.748 --> 01:35:02.709
Like you put sawdust.

1524
01:35:02.769 --> 01:35:04.550
Shouldn't it be warmer under the sawdust?

1525
01:35:04.570 --> 01:35:05.610
I don't know.

1526
01:35:05.950 --> 01:35:12.554
In any case, I'm just saying that like, you know, people are going to have to come up with interesting strategies now to keep the Winter Olympics going.

1527
01:35:12.654 --> 01:35:13.675
I will say I do.

1528
01:35:13.835 --> 01:35:20.039
I do find sometimes a little bit frustrating where the answer to the problem is always, oh, we'll just find a way to innovate our way out of the problem.

1529
01:35:20.179 --> 01:35:22.300
No, without actually giving a specific answer.

1530
01:35:22.620 --> 01:35:24.402
Like you can't just be hand wavy about it.

1531
01:35:24.463 --> 01:35:24.703
No.

1532
01:35:24.803 --> 01:35:25.824
Like, like how, how?

1533
01:35:26.385 --> 01:35:26.766
Yeah.

1534
01:35:26.786 --> 01:35:27.787
Like, okay.

1535
01:35:28.268 --> 01:35:28.668
Yeah.

1536
01:35:28.688 --> 01:35:31.812
We'll just, we'll just like, but no, like what, like why does that actually work?

1537
01:35:31.832 --> 01:35:32.113
Yeah.

1538
01:35:32.133 --> 01:35:37.300
Like fundamentally the physics wise, you can't just make snow, right?

1539
01:35:37.360 --> 01:35:38.581
That's still depends on weather.

1540
01:35:38.722 --> 01:35:38.902
Right.

1541
01:35:39.182 --> 01:35:40.304
And so anyway, anyway,

1542
01:35:40.878 --> 01:35:41.138
All right.

1543
01:35:41.178 --> 01:35:42.839
The next thing I want to talk about was curling.

1544
01:35:43.139 --> 01:35:43.359
Yes.

1545
01:35:43.479 --> 01:35:44.680
Curling is an amazing sport.

1546
01:35:44.820 --> 01:35:47.901
The most electrifying sport in the Olympics.

1547
01:35:47.921 --> 01:35:48.141
Yes.

1548
01:35:48.261 --> 01:35:50.802
And all of the curling stones come from a single island.

1549
01:35:51.022 --> 01:35:51.742
Wait, really?

1550
01:35:51.843 --> 01:35:52.543
Which is crazy.

1551
01:35:52.883 --> 01:35:53.243
Oh, okay.

1552
01:35:53.283 --> 01:35:54.043
There's two places.

1553
01:35:54.063 --> 01:35:56.805
There's a little island in Scotland called Alissa Craig.

1554
01:35:56.845 --> 01:35:57.605
I think that's this one.

1555
01:35:57.685 --> 01:35:57.825
Yeah.

1556
01:35:57.885 --> 01:36:00.306
And then there's the Treffer Granite Quarry in Wales.

1557
01:36:00.426 --> 01:36:00.706
Okay.

1558
01:36:00.986 --> 01:36:02.407
All of the curling stones...

1559
01:36:02.927 --> 01:36:03.808
come from this island.

1560
01:36:03.868 --> 01:36:04.989
Each stone is 40 pounds.

1561
01:36:05.409 --> 01:36:11.154
And the reason why is because somehow these places have very specific types of granite.

1562
01:36:11.554 --> 01:36:13.576
In a curling stone, there's two surfaces.

1563
01:36:13.636 --> 01:36:17.539
There's the part that comes into contact with the ice, which is the running band.

1564
01:36:17.899 --> 01:36:22.243
And then there's a part that comes into contact with other stones and knocks them over.

1565
01:36:22.523 --> 01:36:23.824
And that's the striking band.

1566
01:36:23.924 --> 01:36:26.866
And you need two different types of physics for each of them.

1567
01:36:27.207 --> 01:36:31.010
The running band, which is the thing that's on the ice, needs to be smooth.

1568
01:36:31.850 --> 01:36:39.612
Because you don't want grainy texture there because it's going to be moving along the ice and you want it to be as slippery as possible.

1569
01:36:39.652 --> 01:36:40.413
Low friction.

1570
01:36:40.533 --> 01:36:41.533
Low friction, exactly.

1571
01:36:42.533 --> 01:36:58.798
The striking band, that striking surface, you actually want a more granular structure in that granite because as it hits one another, if it's a really nice crystal, there's going to be cracks.

1572
01:36:59.018 --> 01:36:59.198
Mm-hmm.

1573
01:37:00.248 --> 01:37:09.210
So what you want is the two different things, the two different parts of the stone to have different sort of chemistry.

1574
01:37:09.290 --> 01:37:13.091
Yes, because they have two different functional areas where they're relevant.

1575
01:37:13.331 --> 01:37:13.871
Yeah.

1576
01:37:14.011 --> 01:37:17.152
One for making sure it gets down the ice quickly and sufficiently.

1577
01:37:17.192 --> 01:37:17.412
Yeah.

1578
01:37:17.492 --> 01:37:20.013
And the other to make sure when it contacts other stones...

1579
01:37:20.713 --> 01:37:22.235
It does so in the most.

1580
01:37:22.255 --> 01:37:26.619
Yeah, and it's like a really nice elastic collision that we read about in physics textbooks.

1581
01:37:26.659 --> 01:37:26.779
Yes.

1582
01:37:26.959 --> 01:37:28.100
Momentum is conserved.

1583
01:37:28.140 --> 01:37:31.443
There's no, like, nothing lost to heat and things like that, right?

1584
01:37:31.944 --> 01:37:36.468
Okay, so somehow there's only two places where there's these good stones.

1585
01:37:36.768 --> 01:37:39.971
I am convinced this is a racket.

1586
01:37:39.991 --> 01:37:40.672
It's a racket.

1587
01:37:41.032 --> 01:37:41.253
Like...

1588
01:37:41.813 --> 01:37:42.234
Rack it.

1589
01:37:42.254 --> 01:37:43.334
There's no way, dude.

1590
01:37:43.655 --> 01:37:49.019
But look, okay, so people tried to make an effort in Canada in the 1950s.

1591
01:37:49.320 --> 01:37:55.325
They tried to use the very black igneous rock called an orthocyte to make these.

1592
01:37:55.525 --> 01:37:58.287
And then those things just started chipping way too quickly.

1593
01:37:58.628 --> 01:38:00.749
Like the stones would get damaged.

1594
01:38:00.769 --> 01:38:05.273
And speaking of the Canadians, they are now cheating in the Winter Olympics.

1595
01:38:05.373 --> 01:38:06.454
I don't know if you guys saw this.

1596
01:38:06.534 --> 01:38:06.935
Typical.

1597
01:38:06.955 --> 01:38:07.195
Typical.

1598
01:38:08.345 --> 01:38:15.933
Dude, this guy, so you're only allowed to grab the handle and then let it go before that line.

1599
01:38:16.233 --> 01:38:19.476
This guy was grabbing the handle, letting it go, and then pushing it with his finger.

1600
01:38:19.777 --> 01:38:25.222
And then when the Swedes called him out, he literally started yelling at them and told them to F off.

1601
01:38:25.883 --> 01:38:29.026
And then the Swedish NBC, these guys are the OGs.

1602
01:38:30.127 --> 01:38:37.229
They placed their own camera because the Olympic cameras are placed like here and behind.

1603
01:38:37.289 --> 01:38:39.209
So the guys could have gotten away with that.

1604
01:38:39.229 --> 01:38:40.010
So what are you saying?

1605
01:38:40.030 --> 01:38:43.731
The initial comment of the initial complaint was prior to the video.

1606
01:38:43.751 --> 01:38:46.751
Yeah, because this is a known thing that this Canadian dude does.

1607
01:38:46.871 --> 01:38:51.533
OK. And so the Swedish guys for the Canada versus Sweden match.

1608
01:38:51.553 --> 01:38:51.773
Yes.

1609
01:38:51.973 --> 01:38:54.133
The Swedish NBC, their television.

1610
01:38:54.153 --> 01:38:54.373
Yes.

1611
01:38:54.713 --> 01:38:56.374
Put a specific camera.

1612
01:38:56.394 --> 01:38:56.474
Yes.

1613
01:38:56.974 --> 01:39:18.442
at that spot and caught this guy red red-handed he did it again against the swiss and i think now he's fainted facing penalties after all that bluster the judges were just like not doing anything yeah yeah yeah because they were like well i don't know if he did it or not well now it's like we got a specific camera that's showing that he did it i guess it must be the case that no one was dumb enough to do it which is why there's no like goal line technology for this current

1614
01:39:18.982 --> 01:39:22.485
But it seems obviously true to me that like if that's the rule.

1615
01:39:22.625 --> 01:39:23.226
Yeah.

1616
01:39:23.286 --> 01:39:25.828
And there's an advantage you can get from breaking that rule.

1617
01:39:25.988 --> 01:39:28.370
Because you give an initial momentum.

1618
01:39:28.430 --> 01:39:28.610
Yes.

1619
01:39:28.691 --> 01:39:31.213
And then a tiny, tiny nudge will like.

1620
01:39:31.313 --> 01:39:31.473
Yeah.

1621
01:39:31.653 --> 01:39:35.296
Because the, you know, the target is meters away.

1622
01:39:35.376 --> 01:39:35.556
Yes.

1623
01:39:35.636 --> 01:39:39.780
So even a tiny bit of nudge in that angle is going to cause a huge deflection later on.

1624
01:39:39.880 --> 01:39:40.100
Right.

1625
01:39:40.340 --> 01:39:41.061
It's not nothing.

1626
01:39:42.048 --> 01:39:43.549
Very, very, very sad.

1627
01:39:43.609 --> 01:39:50.495
Look, we're trying to continue to establish and repair our North American relationships with the Canadians.

1628
01:39:51.256 --> 01:39:56.240
There are several things to be upset at us about, but we are now upset at you guys about this cheating.

1629
01:39:56.401 --> 01:39:56.941
That's BS.

1630
01:39:56.961 --> 01:40:00.965
Let's not, remember, as Bad Bunny said, it's America and they enlisted everybody.

1631
01:40:01.005 --> 01:40:01.565
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1632
01:40:01.765 --> 01:40:03.807
And so we got to be on the same page here.

1633
01:40:03.867 --> 01:40:04.828
No cheating in the Olympics.

1634
01:40:04.868 --> 01:40:05.388
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1635
01:40:05.428 --> 01:40:08.290
I want to beat Sweden as much as anyone.

1636
01:40:08.350 --> 01:40:09.971
We're on the same team on this one, okay?

1637
01:40:10.531 --> 01:40:13.733
Okay, and the next thing about cheating, I don't know if you saw this.

1638
01:40:13.853 --> 01:40:14.453
No, I did not.

1639
01:40:14.593 --> 01:40:21.777
This is a family-friendly podcast, and so when I say these words, I am using the biological terminology.

1640
01:40:21.817 --> 01:40:22.817
This is penis gate.

1641
01:40:22.998 --> 01:40:23.278
Okay.

1642
01:40:23.498 --> 01:40:25.079
Okay, ski jumping penis gate.

1643
01:40:25.519 --> 01:40:32.803
Allegedly, some competitive ski jumpers may have artificially enlarged their crotch area by injecting...

1644
01:40:33.503 --> 01:40:58.768
their genitals with engorging chemicals or stuffing their underwear to make a bigger bulge i'm not kidding what is the what is the athletic advantage of this okay so that's exactly like because that's a lot like what injecting stuff down there what mate what are you doing okay so here's the idea right um ski jumpers ski jumpers they get laser

1645
01:41:00.970 --> 01:41:01.570
Whatchamacallit?

1646
01:41:01.630 --> 01:41:02.311
Hair removal?

1647
01:41:02.431 --> 01:41:03.131
No, no, no.

1648
01:41:03.291 --> 01:41:05.813
It's like their body gets laser scanned.

1649
01:41:06.133 --> 01:41:06.433
Okay.

1650
01:41:06.513 --> 01:41:12.357
And then the suit that they put on has to be exactly fitting to their body.

1651
01:41:12.377 --> 01:41:15.499
Oh, it's like Frozone's, where is my super suit?

1652
01:41:15.559 --> 01:41:15.799
Yes.

1653
01:41:16.179 --> 01:41:16.960
It's exactly that.

1654
01:41:17.020 --> 01:41:17.300
Okay?

1655
01:41:17.540 --> 01:41:18.621
And the reason for that is...

1656
01:41:19.644 --> 01:41:22.865
Their sport has everything to do with aerodynamics.

1657
01:41:23.165 --> 01:41:23.365
Okay?

1658
01:41:23.585 --> 01:41:25.206
So here's how the physics of that works, right?

1659
01:41:25.526 --> 01:41:29.527
You go down this giant ski hill, and I think we've got a visual for it.

1660
01:41:29.587 --> 01:41:29.787
Yes.

1661
01:41:29.807 --> 01:41:30.727
This is 4-13.

1662
01:41:30.787 --> 01:41:30.947
Yes.

1663
01:41:30.967 --> 01:41:32.768
We go down the giant ski hill, right?

1664
01:41:33.328 --> 01:41:37.489
During that downhill, you want to reduce drag as much as possible to get as much velocity.

1665
01:41:37.589 --> 01:41:37.789
Yes.

1666
01:41:37.969 --> 01:41:44.671
Now when you lift off, you want to increase the amount of drag because that is going to increase the amount of lift.

1667
01:41:44.711 --> 01:41:45.872
No way, dude.

1668
01:41:46.032 --> 01:41:46.252
Right?

1669
01:41:47.293 --> 01:41:56.841
And what these guys are saying is that if I have a slightly bigger, like, crotch area, that is going to increase my lift.

1670
01:41:57.301 --> 01:41:58.542
And so it's going to make me go farther.

1671
01:41:58.562 --> 01:42:00.884
And that's why they're injecting stuff down there, dude.

1672
01:42:00.924 --> 01:42:02.165
This is so insane.

1673
01:42:02.206 --> 01:42:03.507
Bro, what is going on?

1674
01:42:03.647 --> 01:42:07.290
The surface area of the bulge increases your lift.

1675
01:42:07.310 --> 01:42:07.650
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1676
01:42:07.670 --> 01:42:09.292
It's going to get you a farther distance.

1677
01:42:09.352 --> 01:42:09.572
Yeah.

1678
01:42:09.752 --> 01:42:13.014
This is a ski jumping thing where they go up and they're just like swanning.

1679
01:42:13.035 --> 01:42:14.796
They do like a V so that they can.

1680
01:42:14.976 --> 01:42:15.416
Yeah.

1681
01:42:15.516 --> 01:42:18.779
And they have to hold this position.

1682
01:42:19.099 --> 01:42:22.261
But like just, I guess, a few inches down there.

1683
01:42:23.302 --> 01:42:27.085
Look, a few inches has never been more impactful.

1684
01:42:27.205 --> 01:42:27.505
Right.

1685
01:42:27.785 --> 01:42:28.026
Right.

1686
01:42:28.146 --> 01:42:30.287
It's a gold medal versus not meddling.

1687
01:42:30.648 --> 01:42:31.849
Don't try this at home.

1688
01:42:31.929 --> 01:42:32.729
No, not at all.

1689
01:42:32.769 --> 01:42:33.610
This is for the Olympics.

1690
01:42:33.630 --> 01:42:34.470
Or even at the Olympics.

1691
01:42:34.551 --> 01:42:35.391
What are you guys doing?

1692
01:42:35.411 --> 01:42:37.313
This is not for your at-home Olympics.

1693
01:42:37.333 --> 01:42:37.493
Yeah.

1694
01:42:38.602 --> 01:42:40.283
There's no medals in that sport.

1695
01:42:40.323 --> 01:42:41.284
It's a losing game.

1696
01:42:41.424 --> 01:42:41.885
Yeah, dude.

1697
01:42:42.405 --> 01:42:43.866
Anyways, that was my last story.

1698
01:42:43.906 --> 01:42:45.468
That was sort of my stream of consciousness.

1699
01:42:45.508 --> 01:42:55.776
Of all the things I was researching, this is the V. And you see, like, if you make the crotch area just a tiny bit bigger, maybe you get, like, two more meters over the other guy.

1700
01:42:55.896 --> 01:42:58.918
I don't know what the judicial system is for sports.

1701
01:42:58.958 --> 01:43:02.221
I think it's CAS, the central something for sports.

1702
01:43:02.301 --> 01:43:02.501
Yeah.

1703
01:43:02.521 --> 01:43:04.143
I think you're going to have to look at this issue.

1704
01:43:04.403 --> 01:43:05.023
Yeah.

1705
01:43:05.063 --> 01:43:06.124
This is ridiculous, guys.

1706
01:43:06.144 --> 01:43:06.424
That's...

1707
01:43:07.931 --> 01:43:12.597
I mean, okay, look, I think steroids is more reasonable than whatever this is.

1708
01:43:12.677 --> 01:43:14.139
Yeah, let's not do that.

1709
01:43:14.219 --> 01:43:14.460
Yeah.

1710
01:43:16.608 --> 01:43:19.050
That's I'm going to keep it PG and I'm going to leave it there.

1711
01:43:19.090 --> 01:43:20.831
Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly.

1712
01:43:20.871 --> 01:43:22.252
This is a family friendly show.

1713
01:43:22.272 --> 01:43:23.393
Yeah, but this is a real thing.

1714
01:43:23.433 --> 01:43:24.133
That's a real thing.

1715
01:43:24.554 --> 01:43:25.034
It's happening.

1716
01:43:25.054 --> 01:43:25.634
It's happening.

1717
01:43:25.995 --> 01:43:29.937
I think you guys should know about it because because I was alarmed.

1718
01:43:29.957 --> 01:43:31.378
That is that is quite.

1719
01:43:31.398 --> 01:43:33.960
Yeah, that is quite curious.

1720
01:43:34.220 --> 01:43:42.086
And this also speaks to, again, the what we talked about earlier, the stakes as it relates to these high level events like the Olympics.

1721
01:43:42.246 --> 01:43:42.446
Yeah.

1722
01:43:42.706 --> 01:43:46.430
where the stakes are that high that people will literally physically do anything to their bodies to win.

1723
01:43:47.552 --> 01:43:48.493
It's never worth it.

1724
01:43:49.294 --> 01:43:50.575
No, it's never worth it.

1725
01:43:50.615 --> 01:43:58.164
We want to keep human sports, human, no robotic Olympics when they start, don't support them.

1726
01:43:58.685 --> 01:43:58.885
So,

1727
01:43:59.906 --> 01:44:05.790
We have gotten to the conclusion of our fantastic Winter Olympics episode.

1728
01:44:06.290 --> 01:44:09.992
I am starting to get some beads of sweat on my nose here.

1729
01:44:10.413 --> 01:44:11.393
Because we are in LA.

1730
01:44:11.453 --> 01:44:12.294
We are in LA.

1731
01:44:12.314 --> 01:44:13.375
And it's not that cold.

1732
01:44:13.395 --> 01:44:15.436
Although it is raining, it is not snowing.

1733
01:44:15.916 --> 01:44:18.218
And so these ski jackets are quite warm.

1734
01:44:18.238 --> 01:44:18.918
Yeah, they're quite warm.

1735
01:44:19.298 --> 01:44:22.220
But we did a lot of fun stories today.

1736
01:44:22.240 --> 01:44:23.981
Again, science is all around us.

1737
01:44:24.401 --> 01:44:26.683
We talked about the physics of slippery ice.

1738
01:44:27.143 --> 01:44:29.224
We talked about the neuroscience of choking.

1739
01:44:29.724 --> 01:44:38.810
We looked at how climate science, climate change, anthropogenic climate change is going to impact the ability to have future Winter Olympics.

1740
01:44:39.230 --> 01:44:44.953
So if you have kids right now that you're trying to get on the U.S. Olympic team for the 2042 speed skate tournament,

1741
01:44:46.614 --> 01:44:53.541
or I guess any of these outdoor related events, it's going to be relevant to you living vicariously through that future Olympic child.

1742
01:44:54.382 --> 01:44:56.725
And our rundown was super fun today.

1743
01:44:56.825 --> 01:44:57.966
We had a ton of good stories.

1744
01:44:58.286 --> 01:45:01.950
The AI doing physics thing, I think is a, no, that's an interesting one.

1745
01:45:02.070 --> 01:45:02.350
I think,

1746
01:45:03.311 --> 01:45:05.613
Let's not sleep on this issue.

1747
01:45:06.053 --> 01:45:06.834
I understand.

1748
01:45:06.974 --> 01:45:13.719
Again, I have similar feelings about where the money is coming from for all these billionaire frontier models.

1749
01:45:14.400 --> 01:45:21.885
Why it's bad to replace all human labor with LLMs and software, AI and robots.

1750
01:45:21.905 --> 01:45:24.387
And also we have no plan for distribution.

1751
01:45:24.767 --> 01:45:27.890
And yes, there are some cases where hype is happening.

1752
01:45:27.910 --> 01:45:28.510
Yeah.

1753
01:45:28.650 --> 01:45:33.711
But this is happening, and it is moving very, very, very quickly.

1754
01:45:34.171 --> 01:45:49.435
And if the last time you tried any of these things was the free version of ChatGPT, even six weeks ago, even two weeks ago, where the frontier is is exponentially better than it was two to six weeks ago.

1755
01:45:50.075 --> 01:45:56.317
It is unbelievable, and I just really encourage people to remove their prior biases about AI because...

1756
01:45:57.017 --> 01:46:08.489
Not because we're saying it's amazing and brilliant and all this stuff, but because we're saying it's growing at a rate that no other phase shift in technology in our lived lifetime has changed.

1757
01:46:09.109 --> 01:46:12.352
And the implications of that are so enormous that,

1758
01:46:13.133 --> 01:46:15.014
It's like hard to really articulate.

1759
01:46:15.535 --> 01:46:19.957
And it is not just software engineers and everyone else is going to be fine.

1760
01:46:20.017 --> 01:46:23.279
This is something I'm just going to keep beating the drum on because I think it's very important.

1761
01:46:23.620 --> 01:46:25.201
But we had other great stories today.

1762
01:46:25.221 --> 01:46:30.024
We talked another animal behavior study story on cats' meows versus purrs.

1763
01:46:30.544 --> 01:46:39.750
We did immunology talking about us discovering how we rewrite the immune system and the epigenetic versus long-form genetics that informs that.

1764
01:46:40.430 --> 01:46:42.952
The origin of life beyond our common ancestor.

1765
01:46:42.972 --> 01:46:44.733
That's a really fantastic one.

1766
01:46:44.813 --> 01:46:51.998
And then the astrophysics and exoplanet stories about us discovering a solar system that should not be possible.

1767
01:46:52.078 --> 01:47:05.127
I mean, where else, everybody, can you get the absolute best breakdown of breaking and frontier science across physics, chemistry, biology, all the stuff in between?

1768
01:47:05.707 --> 01:47:09.570
It's only here at FFP, the Fundamentally Flawed Podcast.

1769
01:47:09.610 --> 01:47:09.850
Yeah.

1770
01:47:09.870 --> 01:47:10.190
Yeah.

1771
01:47:10.827 --> 01:47:16.531
which is a funny name that we got out of one of the little thingies we use, but it is from first principles.

1772
01:47:16.872 --> 01:47:18.493
We are so grateful for our audience.

1773
01:47:18.633 --> 01:47:19.394
Last two things.

1774
01:47:19.994 --> 01:47:20.434
Comment.

1775
01:47:20.554 --> 01:47:20.815
Yes.

1776
01:47:21.395 --> 01:47:21.935
What should it be?

1777
01:47:22.056 --> 01:47:22.336
Thoughts.

1778
01:47:23.823 --> 01:47:29.647
Now, what are your thoughts on the controversies that we encountered?

1779
01:47:29.867 --> 01:47:33.349
Whether it's the Canada or the ski jump crotch.

1780
01:47:33.649 --> 01:47:35.110
Or the gate, the X gate.

1781
01:47:36.471 --> 01:47:37.652
This is a free form one.

1782
01:47:38.092 --> 01:47:40.554
Some of you guys have had some really good comments, so we really appreciate you.

1783
01:47:41.354 --> 01:47:41.715
Again...

1784
01:47:42.435 --> 01:47:48.558
If you love the show, if you've gotten to this point in the show, if this is not your first episode, you're one of the key members of our community.

1785
01:47:48.959 --> 01:47:50.920
We appreciate you listening to the pod.

1786
01:47:51.420 --> 01:47:53.701
We have now opened up our donations flow.

1787
01:47:54.021 --> 01:48:03.367
This is going to be hugely helpful for us to be able to continue to produce and expand the team and ability for us to do more shows with more content.

1788
01:48:04.327 --> 01:48:05.527
all the time with the pod.

1789
01:48:05.547 --> 01:48:08.868
So any support we can get from you all is really appreciated.

1790
01:48:08.948 --> 01:48:14.809
And I will also mention, we are building out our community portal, which is going to have some exciting features.

1791
01:48:15.149 --> 01:48:19.190
We have a signup form on the homepage at FFPPod.com.

1792
01:48:19.550 --> 01:48:20.911
So sign up for email updates.

1793
01:48:20.931 --> 01:48:26.232
If you are interested in donating, go to FFPPod.com backslash donate.

1794
01:48:26.652 --> 01:48:32.053
You can find us on all of the socials, X, Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn, Facebook,

1795
01:48:32.313 --> 01:48:40.837
Blue Sky, anyone's I forgot to mention, the main full-form video podcast is on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube.

1796
01:48:41.197 --> 01:48:43.658
We're also on Overcast, iHeartRadio.

1797
01:48:44.038 --> 01:48:48.280
Effectively, anywhere you can listen or watch stuff, you will find us.

1798
01:48:48.720 --> 01:48:55.943
If you watch our clips, our clips will not be in context of the almost two-hour episode that we did today.

1799
01:48:55.963 --> 01:48:57.524
And so, yes, you're going to be a little bit.

1800
01:48:57.544 --> 01:49:05.006
You might have a clever comment that is true in the context of the clip, but it is untrue in the context of the full episode.

1801
01:49:05.346 --> 01:49:06.826
So we appreciate the feedback.

1802
01:49:06.886 --> 01:49:14.308
But so you know, we always email all of the authors of the papers we cover to get their feedback and provide corrections from them.

1803
01:49:14.328 --> 01:49:16.589
And if we don't get corrections from them...

1804
01:49:18.047 --> 01:49:21.549
then the clip gets to live on in perpetuity with no corrections.

1805
01:49:21.809 --> 01:49:35.977
I am your host, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury, with another wonderful deep dive here on the Winter Olympics.

1806
01:49:36.518 --> 01:49:38.659
We will see you all next week.

1807
01:49:41.100 --> 01:49:42.241
Because this is from First Principles.
