WEBVTT

1
00:00:02.656 --> 00:00:04.018
A listener production.

2
00:00:13.252 --> 00:00:14.134
Hi, I'm Hannah.

3
00:00:14.194 --> 00:00:14.835
And I'm Sarah.

4
00:00:14.895 --> 00:00:16.177
And this is Big Small Talk.

5
00:00:20.249 --> 00:00:25.592
This is the podcast where we try to cover the entirety of the news cycle, from the serious to the frivolous all in one place.

6
00:00:25.652 --> 00:00:28.674
Because loving pop culture doesn't mean you understand politics.

7
00:00:29.014 --> 00:00:40.121
And today we're going to be talking about racist comedian Skit, The Odyssey and Toy Story 5, Ditch the Witch Campaign, Phoebe Bridges, Rise of One Nation, and Ariana Grande and Ethan Slater split.

8
00:00:40.321 --> 00:00:49.126
But before we begin today's episode, we would like to start by acknowledging the traditional owners of the land on which we're recording today, the Gadigal people, and pay our respect to Elders past and present.

9
00:00:51.529 --> 00:00:52.289
into the actual news.

10
00:00:52.990 --> 00:00:54.630
Now, what is your personal headline this week?

11
00:00:55.090 --> 00:00:56.231
Do you notice anything different about me?

12
00:00:58.492 --> 00:01:00.333
Oh, no.

13
00:01:00.353 --> 00:01:01.633
This is a trap.

14
00:01:01.693 --> 00:01:02.213
It is a trap.

15
00:01:02.233 --> 00:01:02.754
It is a trap.

16
00:01:02.934 --> 00:01:05.355
No, it's actually kind of a big deal, guys.

17
00:01:05.495 --> 00:01:06.695
You're like holding your ring.

18
00:01:06.875 --> 00:01:08.576
Oh, no, no.

19
00:01:08.656 --> 00:01:09.937
I was like, no.

20
00:01:10.077 --> 00:01:10.777
What?

21
00:01:10.817 --> 00:01:11.337
Whoa.

22
00:01:11.397 --> 00:01:12.358
Imagine if I just, like, boom.

23
00:01:12.378 --> 00:01:13.858
Can you imagine that's how you told me?

24
00:01:13.938 --> 00:01:14.919
Boom.

25
00:01:14.959 --> 00:01:16.539
Negative wasn't that big of a long weekend.

26
00:01:17.240 --> 00:01:18.280
A side part.

27
00:01:18.360 --> 00:01:20.641
It's actually, thank you for, thank you for, thank you for, thank you for.

28
00:01:20.861 --> 00:01:22.102
Side part mentioned.

29
00:01:22.402 --> 00:01:23.383
No, it's better than that.

30
00:01:23.784 --> 00:01:27.227
It's understandable that you might not have noticed, but I'm expecting better next week.

31
00:01:27.247 --> 00:01:29.208
I went to my first strength class on Saturday.

32
00:01:29.228 --> 00:01:31.270
Barely fit my arms in this jacket this morning.

33
00:01:31.290 --> 00:01:32.151
Feeling.

34
00:01:33.912 --> 00:01:36.695
Can I just say I thought of that joke three days ago and waiting to tell it.

35
00:01:37.443 --> 00:01:38.443
She was like, what's going to be personal?

36
00:01:38.463 --> 00:01:41.865
I was like, I'm going to make a joke where I asked Sarah to pick something about me and she gets really stressed.

37
00:01:41.945 --> 00:01:42.625
And you did!

38
00:01:42.705 --> 00:01:43.825
I did get really stressed.

39
00:01:43.865 --> 00:01:44.225
Yeah.

40
00:01:44.365 --> 00:01:45.646
Wait, so you've done a strength class?

41
00:01:45.706 --> 00:01:56.149
I'm doing a strength class on Saturday morning with Lily and recommended by my friend Juliette who said this is a really, like if you're looking for a safe space, you know, because I feel like strength is like the new frontier.

42
00:01:56.169 --> 00:01:57.710
Like we all need to be strong and lifting weights.

43
00:01:57.730 --> 00:02:00.871
We all suddenly realise that we need bone density at our old age.

44
00:02:00.891 --> 00:02:01.111
It's crazy.

45
00:02:01.131 --> 00:02:03.492
Kate Moss weirdly didn't help with that.

46
00:02:05.293 --> 00:02:12.001
But anyway, I was like, I'm so scared of like being at a commercial gym and like the weight section of like, what's my form and how do I lift?

47
00:02:12.061 --> 00:02:18.949
Also, I can't go because I genuinely can barely put my five kilo weights over my head.

48
00:02:19.049 --> 00:02:19.570
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

49
00:02:19.590 --> 00:02:20.191
No, I'm with you.

50
00:02:20.371 --> 00:02:23.314
Like, I think I need to work up to a basic level and then I have to go to the gym.

51
00:02:23.374 --> 00:02:23.915
Also, like...

52
00:02:24.976 --> 00:02:26.197
Why do these things have these names?

53
00:02:26.277 --> 00:02:29.077
What's a Bulgarian squat and a Romanian deadlift?

54
00:02:29.097 --> 00:02:32.659
For fuck's sake, are we at the Olympics back when the Olympics commenced?

55
00:02:32.879 --> 00:02:34.759
All of it feels like, is it to the death?

56
00:02:34.999 --> 00:02:39.621
Everything is creatine and protein and my God, what are you talking about?

57
00:02:39.641 --> 00:02:40.181
I can't hear about it.

58
00:02:40.201 --> 00:02:43.042
I think men just like to make things sound like it's about engineering.

59
00:02:43.802 --> 00:02:48.324
Like fuck off with your yogurt with 15 grams of protein and I'm sick of seeing things about egg whites.

60
00:02:48.464 --> 00:02:48.844
Anyway.

61
00:02:50.753 --> 00:02:53.515
I think they talk about body stuff way more than we do.

62
00:02:53.696 --> 00:02:55.737
Anyway, this is a lot for the first two minutes of the pod.

63
00:02:55.857 --> 00:02:57.539
Yeah, this took so many directions.

64
00:02:57.599 --> 00:03:04.564
But can I just say, weird that you say that though, because I also had this epiphany that I had no strength and I downloaded the Kick app again.

65
00:03:04.685 --> 00:03:06.586
And I really enjoyed it because that is what I like.

66
00:03:06.666 --> 00:03:07.867
I like doing it in my room.

67
00:03:07.987 --> 00:03:09.068
I can get it on my computer.

68
00:03:09.368 --> 00:03:12.631
I can put it on my phone so I can see it on the floor and I can see it when I stand up.

69
00:03:13.031 --> 00:03:14.673
And they're very nice to me on there.

70
00:03:14.693 --> 00:03:15.333
They are so nice.

71
00:03:15.353 --> 00:03:18.376
And I don't feel like I can leave the app either because it feels mean.

72
00:03:18.616 --> 00:03:21.837
You're like, Lauren, step up.

73
00:03:21.877 --> 00:03:22.577
But yeah, no.

74
00:03:22.597 --> 00:03:24.437
I've been really healthy.

75
00:03:24.497 --> 00:03:24.837
Love.

76
00:03:25.338 --> 00:03:32.879
But yeah, doing this strength class for the first time, I felt like I went from being terrified of weights to being like, well, I just have to do it because I'm in a class and it's 45 minutes and we're going.

77
00:03:33.299 --> 00:03:35.080
So I was squatting with weights on.

78
00:03:35.360 --> 00:03:36.160
Felt awesome.

79
00:03:36.220 --> 00:03:37.080
Anyway, I had a great time.

80
00:03:37.440 --> 00:03:39.801
Also, secondary to that, met Jacinda Ardern last week.

81
00:03:40.421 --> 00:03:41.782
Oh my God, of course.

82
00:03:42.082 --> 00:03:42.402
Yes.

83
00:03:42.643 --> 00:03:51.188
We were sitting behind her at a screening of Silence, the new sort of the documentary that was the premiere film at Sydney Film Festival last Wednesday, which I was excited to be invited to.

84
00:03:51.508 --> 00:03:58.512
Now, Khalilah and I went and our seats were in row K. So I saw Jacinda and her husband Clark going into the state theater and I was like, that's the closest I'm ever going to get.

85
00:03:58.812 --> 00:04:02.134
Row K, that's pretty close in a theater of two and a half thousand people.

86
00:04:02.174 --> 00:04:02.935
Like, that's all right.

87
00:04:02.995 --> 00:04:03.395
I'm pleased.

88
00:04:03.415 --> 00:04:04.636
I'll see her at the front row.

89
00:04:04.656 --> 00:04:04.976
Yeah.

90
00:04:05.216 --> 00:04:08.838
sit down and she's literally like the seat in front of me.

91
00:04:08.858 --> 00:04:11.860
Like I am facing her head the entire screening.

92
00:04:11.900 --> 00:04:14.001
By the way, the film was incredible.

93
00:04:14.041 --> 00:04:16.563
It's Jen Robinson who was Amber Heard's lawyer.

94
00:04:16.903 --> 00:04:18.084
Brittany Higgins was a feature.

95
00:04:18.184 --> 00:04:20.045
Amber Heard was a feature in the film as well.

96
00:04:20.505 --> 00:04:22.046
It was an incredible watch.

97
00:04:22.106 --> 00:04:23.907
Highly recommend going and seeing it if you can.

98
00:04:24.047 --> 00:04:26.328
Can I say a slight side note on Jen Robinson?

99
00:04:26.349 --> 00:04:27.009
My favourite film fact.

100
00:04:27.249 --> 00:04:29.831
Oh, I know this one you're going to say.

101
00:04:29.851 --> 00:04:32.192
I really want to get Jen Robinson on Small Talk.

102
00:04:32.292 --> 00:04:33.893
but I've reached out to a few different connections.

103
00:04:34.053 --> 00:04:38.015
Falcon, who's obviously the Inspired Unemployed, that's his cousin.

104
00:04:38.115 --> 00:04:38.755
That's hilarious.

105
00:04:39.015 --> 00:04:40.656
It's like the craziest thing ever.

106
00:04:40.756 --> 00:04:41.336
Jen Robinson.

107
00:04:41.356 --> 00:04:43.458
Jackson Ford and the Warriors and Jen Robinson.

108
00:04:43.898 --> 00:04:45.879
Jen Robinson also was Julian Assange's lawyer.

109
00:04:45.899 --> 00:04:49.721
Like, this is an Australian human rights lawyer that's like one of the most prominent advocates.

110
00:04:49.761 --> 00:04:50.961
I just love her to death.

111
00:04:50.981 --> 00:04:52.362
She's an amazing, amazing lady.

112
00:04:52.382 --> 00:04:52.782
She's incredible.

113
00:04:52.882 --> 00:04:54.443
And hilarious that she's Falcon's cousin.

114
00:04:54.483 --> 00:04:58.807
Like if she did not have her life busy enough, essentially, Falcon's cousin.

115
00:04:59.147 --> 00:04:59.627
Yeah, right.

116
00:04:59.687 --> 00:05:01.009
Like random sidebar.

117
00:05:01.029 --> 00:05:01.589
What a family.

118
00:05:01.649 --> 00:05:02.470
What a side quest.

119
00:05:02.530 --> 00:05:03.190
Yeah.

120
00:05:03.351 --> 00:05:05.072
So anyway, me and J.A.

121
00:05:05.192 --> 00:05:06.493
hanging Wednesday night.

122
00:05:07.074 --> 00:05:09.136
Well, someone I was like, I'm not going to bother her.

123
00:05:09.156 --> 00:05:12.298
She's, I became like the most starstruck person in the world.

124
00:05:12.318 --> 00:05:16.002
In fact, Kalila said, and I quote, I've never seen you like this before.

125
00:05:16.142 --> 00:05:18.504
Like this embarrassed to like exist near someone.

126
00:05:19.364 --> 00:05:22.286
and the person sitting next to her said, oh, you should meet Hannah Ferguson.

127
00:05:22.306 --> 00:05:24.747
She's running as an independent at the next election, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

128
00:05:24.767 --> 00:05:27.609
And she turned around and gave me the most beautiful five minutes of her time.

129
00:05:27.629 --> 00:05:29.790
I was like, I have to humiliate myself.

130
00:05:29.810 --> 00:05:30.411
Could we get a picture?

131
00:05:30.431 --> 00:05:31.732
And she was like, I'll take the selfie.

132
00:05:31.772 --> 00:05:32.612
And I was like, this is...

133
00:05:32.872 --> 00:05:34.913
Anyway, I just loved her.

134
00:05:34.933 --> 00:05:38.335
If you haven't seen her Prime Minister documentary, I just cried during the whole thing.

135
00:05:38.455 --> 00:05:40.177
I made my partner watch it the other night.

136
00:05:40.937 --> 00:05:41.777
I just cried the whole time.

137
00:05:41.797 --> 00:05:45.340
And he was like, this is really sad and uplifting and also sad while we're watching.

138
00:05:45.360 --> 00:05:46.020
And I was like, it's just...

139
00:05:46.220 --> 00:06:12.714
young woman in politics and she was pregnant and she's just it was COVID and all these awful things happened and I just love her so much anyway it was awesome what's your personal headline of the week honestly I don't have anything major to add to this I feel like we covered we've covered some major ground give Jacinta Ardern the space that she needs and I'm also concerned that we have a lot to cover so I'm actually not going to just tell you like oh I had a quiet long weekend we all know moving on sorry

140
00:06:13.915 --> 00:06:17.140
I really talked about the strength class for too long upon reflection.

141
00:06:21.675 --> 00:06:27.859
A comedian posted a deeply racist video on Instagram last week and the internet responded.

142
00:06:28.520 --> 00:06:29.601
When did you see this video?

143
00:06:30.181 --> 00:06:31.682
Someone showed it to me.

144
00:06:32.203 --> 00:06:33.063
Who showed it to me?

145
00:06:33.443 --> 00:06:46.713
It's one of those things that just travels around an office, especially if you're in like a younger office where this is kind of like, you know, like, you know that this is a sort of culture war moment where someone's resting on creating a problem in the zeitgeist effectively.

146
00:06:46.733 --> 00:06:46.873
Mm-hmm.

147
00:06:47.333 --> 00:06:49.134
No, I think, Helen, you showed it to me.

148
00:06:49.154 --> 00:06:56.516
It was one of those things that I was like watching the video and then it just got progressively worse and then I almost didn't know what I was watching.

149
00:06:56.776 --> 00:06:58.517
It is kind of like that, isn't it?

150
00:06:59.617 --> 00:07:05.979
Just to paint the picture, I think I saw it, it must have been Tuesday or Wednesday last week, and it was horrifying to watch.

151
00:07:05.999 --> 00:07:14.182
Now, the person behind, and I'm not going to say the comedian behind, I'm going to say the person behind the video is a woman named Lisa Jane Spencer.

152
00:07:14.902 --> 00:07:26.650
I know a lot of people don't want to give her airtime, and I totally understand and agree with that sentiment, but I think our job also is to name the person, to talk about their history, to give context to this story.

153
00:07:27.010 --> 00:07:28.811
And it has made headlines.

154
00:07:28.831 --> 00:07:29.592
Yeah, it has.

155
00:07:30.012 --> 00:07:33.255
Now, I've come across some of Lisa's work before.

156
00:07:33.355 --> 00:07:37.919
I mean, even we'll bring up this morning, she's been someone who's kind of made posts about Abby Chatfield.

157
00:07:38.379 --> 00:07:46.206
I've watched some of her quite offensive, and it's hard to even say the word skit, that was directed towards, you know, South Asian people, towards Indian people.

158
00:07:46.607 --> 00:07:49.669
There's a lot of it that is really tough to watch.

159
00:07:49.689 --> 00:07:50.190
Yeah.

160
00:07:50.706 --> 00:07:57.109
And I think there's a conversation unfolding online about what is humour and what jokes are and aren't allowed to be made.

161
00:07:57.129 --> 00:07:59.870
And I actually think that's just not the conversation here whatsoever.

162
00:08:00.650 --> 00:08:11.735
So in this particular video, we're going to play a snippet from it as well, just to understand and hear the tone of the video and the nature of the in quotations jokes that Spencer is trying to make.

163
00:08:11.755 --> 00:08:13.016
So we might start with a bit of that.

164
00:08:16.557 --> 00:08:18.018
So I'm Auntie Lisa.

165
00:08:18.478 --> 00:08:22.921
I started identifying as a black fella a few months ago.

166
00:08:23.401 --> 00:08:24.782
Am I Aboriginal?

167
00:08:25.283 --> 00:08:25.543
Yes.

168
00:08:26.143 --> 00:08:26.764
Yes, I am.

169
00:08:27.384 --> 00:08:30.406
And I finally feel at peace with who I am.

170
00:08:31.207 --> 00:08:36.370
One of the mob.

171
00:08:36.590 --> 00:08:40.012
Aboriginal identity transcends skin colour.

172
00:08:42.774 --> 00:08:44.095
I am Aboriginal.

173
00:08:44.995 --> 00:08:45.756
End of story.

174
00:08:48.946 --> 00:08:55.691
Now, in this video, Lisa's wearing like a faux fur jacket for part, holding a bowl with burning eucalyptus leaves.

175
00:08:55.731 --> 00:08:58.733
She's mocking Indigenous cultural practices.

176
00:08:58.793 --> 00:09:01.615
She's mocking a First Nation smoking ceremony.

177
00:09:02.155 --> 00:09:04.057
Her face is painted in white symbols.

178
00:09:04.357 --> 00:09:07.959
There's all these really racist tropes that are being played out in this sketch.

179
00:09:08.019 --> 00:09:10.181
It also ends with her sniffing petrol.

180
00:09:10.241 --> 00:09:11.662
Yeah, it's disgusting.

181
00:09:11.842 --> 00:09:17.248
One of the first things I actually wanted to mention about this video too is you'll see in the corner of the video, it's actually been taken down.

182
00:09:17.648 --> 00:09:30.862
But one of the things you'll see online if you're seeing sort of repeat imagery being screenshotted and reposted of it is she's also placed the SBS Insight shows logo in the corner of the video as if it's from their TV show.

183
00:09:30.982 --> 00:09:31.243
Yeah.

184
00:09:31.683 --> 00:09:39.005
And so one of the things I was looking out for really immediately when seeing all the reporting of this start to emerge is what SBS would do in response.

185
00:09:39.945 --> 00:09:48.507
And SBS gave a statement to 9.com.au and they said, SBS is aware of these posts and the unauthorised use of SBS logos.

186
00:09:48.807 --> 00:09:52.628
The posts and individual are in no way associated with our content and have been reported.

187
00:09:53.188 --> 00:09:59.309
SBS unequivocally condemns all forms of racism and recognises the damaging impact it has on individuals, communities and social cohesion.

188
00:09:59.370 --> 00:10:01.350
Such views have no place in Australian society.

189
00:10:01.710 --> 00:10:05.031
What I find weird about this as well is, like, it is part of a series.

190
00:10:05.391 --> 00:10:07.912
Like, this isn't a standalone video, as we were saying.

191
00:10:07.932 --> 00:10:09.413
She's attacked quite a few minorities.

192
00:10:10.453 --> 00:10:12.814
The Indian video was horrifying.

193
00:10:13.094 --> 00:10:18.096
And, like, in the similar way that she ended with sniffing petrol on the Indigenous video, she ends with, like...

194
00:10:18.796 --> 00:10:22.018
what looks like taking a shit on the side of the road in the Indian video.

195
00:10:22.178 --> 00:10:22.418
Yeah.

196
00:10:22.678 --> 00:10:27.681
In response, obviously there was a lot of backlash in those initial couple of days following the videos publishing.

197
00:10:28.421 --> 00:10:39.067
Lisa then posted to her Instagram story and released sort of like a statement where she started with, okay, so I have some people's attention, dot, dot, dot, which is just forgot.

198
00:10:39.087 --> 00:10:41.128
Like you can just imagine, the tone is just horrendous.

199
00:10:42.614 --> 00:10:46.999
She said, I love Aboriginal people and I think they're smart enough to know when they're being used.

200
00:10:47.600 --> 00:10:48.782
Petrol sniffing happens.

201
00:10:49.723 --> 00:10:52.766
AI will tell you, which is a weird thing to say.

202
00:10:53.447 --> 00:10:56.451
The government will tell you and Aboriginals will tell you too.

203
00:10:57.112 --> 00:10:57.492
E.g.

204
00:10:57.572 --> 00:10:59.094
there was a song about it made by a few of them.

205
00:10:59.795 --> 00:11:01.616
It's a very real thing in remote Australia.

206
00:11:02.516 --> 00:11:10.799
And then she kind of goes on for paragraphs and paragraphs about, you know, politicians and activists using Aboriginal suffering, that they parade it for votes.

207
00:11:11.239 --> 00:11:15.240
And then she talks about, you know, Aboriginal people wanting to be the eternal victim and

208
00:11:15.580 --> 00:11:18.544
And there's just a lot of kind of, this is comedy.

209
00:11:18.605 --> 00:11:22.771
If you can't make jokes about certain people and things that, you know, that's a form of privilege and hierarchy.

210
00:11:22.851 --> 00:11:24.373
And, you know, this is what I do.

211
00:11:24.393 --> 00:11:25.214
I push boundaries.

212
00:11:25.234 --> 00:11:26.096
That's never going to change.

213
00:11:26.476 --> 00:11:28.118
And she said, thanks to everyone who laughed.

214
00:11:28.419 --> 00:11:28.960
Prayer hands.

215
00:11:29.020 --> 00:11:30.081
It's a fun ride, eh?

216
00:11:30.582 --> 00:11:38.108
It's interesting because in some sense of it, she's trying to portray and push to the public that she supports First Nations communities.

217
00:11:38.448 --> 00:11:47.234
But in other paragraphs, she's then talking about how people perform identity for attention and that stereotypes do play out.

218
00:11:47.975 --> 00:11:52.679
It's so interesting to try and it's just like easy fallback of like this is edgy comedy.

219
00:11:52.899 --> 00:11:54.140
And it's like, well, then...

220
00:11:54.760 --> 00:11:55.580
be funny.

221
00:11:56.201 --> 00:12:04.624
Sorry, that's what I just keep coming back to on this, which is like, we have spoken time and time again about stand-up comedy and comedians and genuinely edgy comedy.

222
00:12:04.644 --> 00:12:06.585
Like, I really do believe comedy can make a point.

223
00:12:06.705 --> 00:12:06.905
Yeah.

224
00:12:07.485 --> 00:12:10.466
And that it can speak to some really complex issues in interesting ways.

225
00:12:10.926 --> 00:12:13.527
Sorry, Lisa, this is not edgy.

226
00:12:13.687 --> 00:12:15.728
No, and also, I think when...

227
00:12:15.988 --> 00:12:21.350
When we're having this conversation, a lot of people struggle to articulate exactly why you can't make certain jokes about certain things.

228
00:12:22.030 --> 00:12:26.572
Now, I'm a firm believer in that, you know, you can make a joke about almost anything.

229
00:12:26.792 --> 00:12:30.813
It's the way in which you make the joke and who the target audience for the joke is, right?

230
00:12:31.273 --> 00:12:38.316
So say if the video, in my mind, if the video was mocking white people for something like performance activism, right?

231
00:12:38.336 --> 00:12:39.096
Yeah.

232
00:12:39.316 --> 00:12:48.262
If the target of the joke is for white people to understand that they are ironically being made fun of because there is performance of identity of being progressive or being from a minority group of blah, blah, blah.

233
00:12:48.682 --> 00:12:50.543
We are one, a privilege.

234
00:12:50.664 --> 00:12:54.366
White people have white privilege in this society and mocking us for engaging in certain behaviours.

235
00:12:54.546 --> 00:12:55.527
That's not punching down.

236
00:12:55.547 --> 00:12:56.207
It's not punching down.

237
00:12:56.547 --> 00:13:00.010
That's a point that blonde Lisa could make.

238
00:13:00.150 --> 00:13:04.573
But the issue with this, right, is that you've got to also think who are you aiming the joke at?

239
00:13:05.013 --> 00:13:07.675
So in this joke, Lisa is making...

240
00:13:08.335 --> 00:13:17.142
a mockery of the First Nations community punching down and the intended audience is not First Nations people laughing at themselves.

241
00:13:17.783 --> 00:13:31.695
A white woman making fun of really racist tropes that are, you know, that deeply are stigmatising for First Nations communities is intended by her to be laughed at by the far right, by other white people.

242
00:13:31.715 --> 00:13:32.255
Mm-hmm.

243
00:13:32.375 --> 00:13:35.677
And in that system of comedy, that is not funny.

244
00:13:35.737 --> 00:13:37.178
That is just racist, right?

245
00:13:37.638 --> 00:13:40.499
She is not having an inside joke with First Nations people.

246
00:13:40.920 --> 00:13:47.043
She is mocking and using racist stereotypes against them for the benefit of other white people on the other side of politics.

247
00:13:47.523 --> 00:13:50.284
And that is why so many people have said this is deeply harmful.

248
00:13:50.785 --> 00:13:55.327
So for her to come out and say, I love First Nations people and they agree with me.

249
00:13:55.707 --> 00:13:56.007
Who?

250
00:13:56.367 --> 00:13:58.188
Have you got one example of that?

251
00:13:58.508 --> 00:14:07.053
Do not come out and defend yourself through that rhetoric because that's not the intention here as a comic because also all of her content leads into these tropes, right?

252
00:14:08.093 --> 00:14:13.856
And I just want to play a grab from Brooke Blurton speaking about this to our Instagram followers as well.

253
00:14:14.989 --> 00:14:18.332
Words matter and content matters.

254
00:14:19.473 --> 00:14:36.887
And when someone with a platform chooses to reiterate and spread racial stereotypes, harmful racial stereotypes, mind you, it actually contributes to the discrimination that First Nations and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are already facing every day.

255
00:14:37.270 --> 00:14:40.211
Now, Brooke Blurton is a Noongar and Yamaji woman.

256
00:14:40.271 --> 00:14:40.911
She's an advocate.

257
00:14:40.931 --> 00:14:41.531
She's a youth worker.

258
00:14:41.551 --> 00:14:42.992
She was the bachelorette.

259
00:14:43.052 --> 00:14:46.193
She's also someone who has worked for, you know, NITV.

260
00:14:46.413 --> 00:14:59.476
And she is a prominent First Nations woman in Australian society that has to be the one to come out and like immediately push back against this horrendous, like disgusting rhetoric alongside so many other First Nations activists and advocates in the space.

261
00:15:00.116 --> 00:15:05.258
Now, following on from this video as well in the days after, Lisa was also fired from her job.

262
00:15:05.778 --> 00:15:11.185
There was a Media Week article called Jokes on Her, Comedian is Sacked, Slammed by SBS After Racist Video.

263
00:15:11.865 --> 00:15:24.461
Lisa was working at Peninsula Hot Springs and they posted to social media saying, Peninsula Hot Springs is aware of concerns that have been raised regarding social media content circulating online from a former employee.

264
00:15:25.001 --> 00:15:28.204
And basically they go on to say that they don't endorse or support the content.

265
00:15:28.304 --> 00:15:29.745
It's not consistent with their values.

266
00:15:30.126 --> 00:15:36.011
And they've actually talked about, you know, for more than two decades, Peninsula Hot Springs has been privileged to build meaningful relationships with First Nations people.

267
00:15:36.291 --> 00:15:43.297
They're talking all about being culturally safe and inclusive, which I think is really important to come out and offer that as a place of employment, but as a service as well.

268
00:15:44.158 --> 00:15:57.581
And what just I find such a struggle with, right, is what will happen now and what is already happening now is the media and many commentators on the right will say, like, this is the left cancel culture once again.

269
00:15:58.002 --> 00:16:05.864
When realistically, like, we have, you know, in many ways also been the victims of people on the right calling for our cancellation on a bunch of issues.

270
00:16:05.944 --> 00:16:10.445
It's always, like, attributed to the left cancel culture when actually people just as customers...

271
00:16:10.465 --> 00:16:11.185
Cancel culture just is.

272
00:16:11.405 --> 00:16:14.347
And also we're talking about what's cancellation versus accountability.

273
00:16:14.427 --> 00:16:29.879
If you publicly produce content, which is deeply harmful and racist, and the result of that is that people raise concern with your employer about that content and you do not represent the values of an organization and they remove you from that organization, that is not you being cancelled.

274
00:16:30.459 --> 00:16:34.322
That is you being held to account because you do not represent that organization or its values.

275
00:16:34.382 --> 00:16:34.583
Right.

276
00:16:35.403 --> 00:16:37.084
I'm sorry, but that is the outcome here.

277
00:16:37.444 --> 00:16:38.585
She started a GoFundMe.

278
00:16:38.945 --> 00:16:43.828
Yeah, so there is a GoFundMe for Lisa that's got over $48,000 committed to her already.

279
00:16:44.349 --> 00:16:54.835
And all we can do is say, if you have a First Nations person in your life, reach out to them and make sure they're okay after seeing and having to be subjected to that kind of deep harm and those tired stereotypes.

280
00:16:55.235 --> 00:16:56.516
But we need to be talking about it as well.

281
00:16:58.947 --> 00:17:05.213
The ongoing casting debate around Christopher Nolan's upcoming film, The Odyssey, Explained, and also Toy Story 5.

282
00:17:05.233 --> 00:17:05.633
Oh, we're here.

283
00:17:05.834 --> 00:17:06.114
Oh, okay.

284
00:17:06.154 --> 00:17:06.294
Yeah.

285
00:17:06.895 --> 00:17:07.235
Just easy.

286
00:17:07.255 --> 00:17:09.517
Let's just put those together and let's just see how that goes.

287
00:17:09.537 --> 00:17:12.260
Put those together because they're movies, but I will be taking it one by one.

288
00:17:12.380 --> 00:17:20.587
So Christopher Nolan obviously has a major film coming out that has had people talking for lots of different reasons.

289
00:17:21.408 --> 00:17:25.234
And I've sort of just been keeping track of the articles and posts as I've seen them.

290
00:17:25.274 --> 00:17:29.480
And now, I mean, I didn't even realize it actually comes out in like a month.

291
00:17:29.878 --> 00:17:33.939
But Christopher Nolan is one of the most famous film directors of all time.

292
00:17:34.259 --> 00:17:41.861
He's earned over $6 billion worldwide from his films, which makes him the seventh highest grossing film director of all time.

293
00:17:42.521 --> 00:17:51.703
His films include The Dark Knight Trilogy, Inception, Interstellar, Dunkirk, Tenet, Oppenheimer, which he won Best Director and Best Picture for.

294
00:17:52.103 --> 00:17:58.484
One of my all-time top five, like I would say it's probably my top five favorite movies of all time is The Prestige, which is also a Christopher Nolan film.

295
00:17:58.844 --> 00:18:04.729
It actually hurts me how much I love his films, even though they have a lack of female characters that are ever fucking good.

296
00:18:05.049 --> 00:18:08.212
Now we have The Odyssey, which as I said, is out next month.

297
00:18:08.232 --> 00:18:13.696
I think it's July 17th and it has a reported budget of $250 million.

298
00:18:14.456 --> 00:18:15.717
Far out these films.

299
00:18:16.198 --> 00:18:17.239
No, it's massive.

300
00:18:17.259 --> 00:18:25.065
I saw a post the other day that was like, I think all the most famous directors should be forced to make a film on an indie budget just to see if they still have it every year.

301
00:18:25.085 --> 00:18:25.145
No.

302
00:18:25.505 --> 00:18:38.391
I think that is an important... Also, you know, the thing about Christopher Nolan films, because I know what kind of topic we're going to get into, I've seen a lot of this rhetoric, is that he is such a name that people don't read scripts, they just accept the offer.

303
00:18:38.671 --> 00:18:39.051
So...

304
00:18:40.432 --> 00:18:44.895
The Odyssey is an adaptation of Homer's 3,000-year-old poem.

305
00:18:44.935 --> 00:18:48.737
So a little bit of ancient Greek mythology history here.

306
00:18:49.157 --> 00:18:58.563
The Odyssey of Homer is an epic Greek poem that tells the journey of Odysseus to the island of Ithaca from the war at Troy, which Homer addressed in the Iliad.

307
00:18:59.043 --> 00:19:09.710
And in Greek tradition, the war lasted 10 years, and Odysseus then spent a further 10 years getting home in the face of hostility from Poseidon, god of the earth and sea.

308
00:19:10.290 --> 00:19:13.933
Now, it has an insane A-list lineup that has been casted.

309
00:19:13.973 --> 00:19:20.298
So we have Matt Damon as Odysseus, which is the king and the hero of the Trojan War.

310
00:19:20.779 --> 00:19:26.543
We have Tom Holland as Telemachus, who I hope I'm pronouncing all these right.

311
00:19:26.563 --> 00:19:29.446
Telemachus, the son of Odysseus and Penelope.

312
00:19:30.426 --> 00:19:34.530
Also, fun fact, Tom Holland delayed Spider-Man Homecoming to be in this film.

313
00:19:34.710 --> 00:19:34.950
You do.

314
00:19:35.155 --> 00:19:35.415
would.

315
00:19:35.635 --> 00:19:40.759
But I also think apparently the studios let him because they know Christopher Nolan is good at keeping on schedule.

316
00:19:40.819 --> 00:19:41.939
Yeah, that's nice.

317
00:19:42.019 --> 00:19:47.203
Complimentary to... Anne Hathaway as Penelope, which is the wife of Odysseus.

318
00:19:47.663 --> 00:19:55.488
We have Robert Patterson as Atinaus, who is most arrogant and aggressive of Penelope's suitors.

319
00:19:56.048 --> 00:19:59.931
And then we have Lupita Nyong'o, who is Helena Troy and

320
00:20:00.651 --> 00:20:03.392
and also Anne Clytemnestra.

321
00:20:03.752 --> 00:20:05.512
So she plays a dual role in it.

322
00:20:05.592 --> 00:20:09.233
She plays Helen of Troy, and then she also plays her sister.

323
00:20:10.374 --> 00:20:11.294
Yes, so she's both.

324
00:20:11.674 --> 00:20:16.155
We have Zendaya as Athena, which is the Greek goddess of wisdom and strategic warfare.

325
00:20:16.516 --> 00:20:22.237
Charlize Theron as Calypso, which is the sea witch that keeps Odysseus captive.

326
00:20:22.257 --> 00:20:24.038
And then we have Elliot Page.

327
00:20:24.438 --> 00:20:24.878
Now this is

328
00:20:25.518 --> 00:20:36.409
Actually officially unconfirmed by Universal Pictures, although he is heavily rumoured and expected to play Elpnor, who was the youngest crewmate on Odysseus' ship.

329
00:20:37.495 --> 00:20:48.605
However, everybody lost their fucking minds as the Elliot Page rumor surfaced because he was rumored at first to be playing Achilles.

330
00:20:49.366 --> 00:20:56.573
And essentially it was just awful commentary about how this is woke casting and Hollywood has gone too far because Elliot is a trans man.

331
00:20:58.429 --> 00:21:03.635
Also, for those who don't know, like Elliot has, like, he's an Oscar nominated actor.

332
00:21:03.776 --> 00:21:05.538
He has had an insane career.

333
00:21:05.838 --> 00:21:07.180
He was in Umbrella Academy.

334
00:21:07.881 --> 00:21:09.523
Definitely not his, like, number one thing.

335
00:21:09.583 --> 00:21:10.884
I really loved Umbrella Academy.

336
00:21:10.965 --> 00:21:11.705
I'm a Juno diehard.

337
00:21:11.765 --> 00:21:12.326
I love Juno.

338
00:21:12.346 --> 00:21:15.750
Yeah, it was Juno, X-Men, Inception.

339
00:21:15.790 --> 00:21:17.012
So has been in an old one before.

340
00:21:17.032 --> 00:21:17.452
Yeah, yeah.

341
00:21:19.070 --> 00:21:25.634
So as a sign of all valid and interesting discourse there is, Elon Musk then was up in arms and decided to weigh in.

342
00:21:25.714 --> 00:21:26.855
Oh, fuck off.

343
00:21:26.875 --> 00:21:27.896
I don't even want to hear it.

344
00:21:28.816 --> 00:21:29.396
It's so bad.

345
00:21:29.457 --> 00:21:33.419
He started by calling this one of the dumbest and twisted things he's ever heard.

346
00:21:33.479 --> 00:21:36.081
Also remembering that Elon Musk has a trans child.

347
00:21:36.241 --> 00:21:36.701
Vivian.

348
00:21:36.801 --> 00:21:37.041
Yeah.

349
00:21:37.201 --> 00:21:39.083
Oh, God, I'm so angry at the moment.

350
00:21:39.243 --> 00:21:40.683
Had two clown emojis.

351
00:21:41.244 --> 00:21:47.648
And then he continued by insulting Christopher Nolan on X on Wednesday, saying Chris Nolan is pissing on Homer's grave.

352
00:21:48.153 --> 00:21:50.435
Grow up, you fucking loser.

353
00:21:50.455 --> 00:21:51.756
Like, I'm so sick of it.

354
00:21:51.816 --> 00:22:01.586
That's not even the end of this disappointing discourse, though, because also then people lost their minds over Lupita because she was cast as Helen of Troy for being a black woman.

355
00:22:01.766 --> 00:22:07.792
And that has just been amplified over the last few weeks after Nolan confirmed this in his Time cover interview.

356
00:22:08.432 --> 00:22:11.075
Musk did not stop tweeting for seven days straight.

357
00:22:12.298 --> 00:22:13.258
Seven days straight with that news.

358
00:22:13.278 --> 00:22:15.079
Wait till he hears about what they did with Bridgerton.

359
00:22:16.140 --> 00:22:17.860
And wait till he hears about what they did with Hamilton.

360
00:22:19.741 --> 00:22:21.942
No one take Elon Musk to see Hamilton.

361
00:22:21.982 --> 00:22:24.363
He will absolutely lose the shit.

362
00:22:24.523 --> 00:22:28.285
Oh, no, a creative decision that absolutely makes the show better.

363
00:22:28.605 --> 00:22:39.009
But, like, he's not alone because Christopher Nolan, after he confirmed the casting, Helen of Troy, was, like, the number one trending search for a week.

364
00:22:39.189 --> 00:22:39.329
Right.

365
00:22:40.837 --> 00:22:42.118
I wouldn't even get riled up yet.

366
00:22:42.239 --> 00:22:43.319
It gets worse.

367
00:22:43.359 --> 00:22:44.520
Can I just make a comment?

368
00:22:44.621 --> 00:22:50.305
You know how we have this issue where young men aspire to be billionaires and therefore defend people like Elon Musk?

369
00:22:50.325 --> 00:22:51.046
He worked hard.

370
00:22:51.526 --> 00:22:52.407
He needs to be working hard.

371
00:22:52.427 --> 00:22:54.809
If he has time for this, he ain't working hard.

372
00:22:55.189 --> 00:22:57.431
Someone give this man some manual labour to do.

373
00:22:57.571 --> 00:23:00.814
Someone put the time limit on his Instagram like the rest of us.

374
00:23:00.834 --> 00:23:01.854
Send men to war again.

375
00:23:01.874 --> 00:23:03.476
This is just...

376
00:23:04.076 --> 00:23:06.079
Yeah, someone give him a brick or whatever that's called.

377
00:23:06.119 --> 00:23:07.301
Yeah, someone give him the brick phone.

378
00:23:07.841 --> 00:23:09.163
Ah, that's enough.

379
00:23:09.664 --> 00:23:10.445
Sorry, sorry.

380
00:23:10.465 --> 00:23:17.815
Matt Walsh, also who's a podcast host on Ben Shapiro's struggling Daily Wire, said –

381
00:23:19.477 --> 00:23:23.661
Not one person on the planet actually thinks Lupita is the most beautiful woman in the world.

382
00:23:24.662 --> 00:23:30.689
He also wrote, Christopher Nolan knows that he would be called racist if he gave the most beautiful woman role to a white woman.

383
00:23:31.029 --> 00:23:33.211
Nolan is technically talented, but a coward.

384
00:23:33.492 --> 00:23:35.113
To which Musk commented, true.

385
00:23:35.554 --> 00:23:35.874
God.

386
00:23:36.875 --> 00:23:39.977
You know what I don't want to ever do is listen to a podcast of them talking about this shit.

387
00:23:40.277 --> 00:23:40.997
It's interesting, right?

388
00:23:41.097 --> 00:23:41.878
I'm getting riled up.

389
00:23:41.978 --> 00:23:45.620
I know this is a long segment and I'm sort of injecting chat.

390
00:23:45.640 --> 00:23:49.842
I think we've gone from the story above this right into this and we're like, fuck!

391
00:23:49.962 --> 00:23:50.543
But also...

392
00:23:51.337 --> 00:23:53.698
I get that I'm riled up and I'm responding and that's not helpful.

393
00:23:53.718 --> 00:23:56.278
Like in many ways, it's not even helpful to give these men airtime.

394
00:23:56.458 --> 00:24:08.202
But also it is good to know that it's living in their heads rent free, that this creative casting decision has been made, which I think is an excellent decision, not because of the race decision, but just because I think Lupita's an incredible actress, right?

395
00:24:08.222 --> 00:24:09.342
And she deserves this role.

396
00:24:09.862 --> 00:24:19.465
And I think it's just like this is taking up so much anger and time in their head that I actually need to lessen my anger by realising that actually they can't control the outcome and everyone's going to go see this film and it's going to make a lot of money.

397
00:24:19.685 --> 00:24:19.945
right?

398
00:24:20.246 --> 00:24:27.376
Musk also said that Chris Nolan desecrated the Odyssey so that he would be eligible for an Academy Award.

399
00:24:27.657 --> 00:24:33.405
Now, I want to talk about this because he backed that statement up by citing the Oscars diversity rules.

400
00:24:33.746 --> 00:24:34.687
I think this is a common misconception.

401
00:24:34.707 --> 00:24:42.913
conception as well, because to be clear, those rules don't actually state that a certain number of onscreen roles need to be played by people of colour.

402
00:24:43.373 --> 00:24:45.054
It's for the entire production.

403
00:24:45.474 --> 00:24:55.121
Also, those rules were already in place in 2023, which was when Christopher Nolan's nearly all-white Oppenheimer was nominated for 13 Academy Awards and won seven.

404
00:24:55.441 --> 00:24:59.484
So the movie was still eligible at the Oscars due to the diversity production of its staff.

405
00:24:59.504 --> 00:24:59.704
Yeah.

406
00:24:59.904 --> 00:25:00.085
Anyway.

407
00:25:00.105 --> 00:25:00.205
Yeah.

408
00:25:00.845 --> 00:25:05.969
Conservative influencer Tanya Bass has also complained that Helen is a historically white character.

409
00:25:06.189 --> 00:25:08.791
She said this was like casting Pocahontas as white.

410
00:25:09.252 --> 00:25:29.067
Thankfully, though, like if you look at the comments of that, I think it quickly jumps to pointing out that Pocahontas was an actual historical figure, while Helen is a mythical creation who, according to the story, was born after the god Zeus and assumed the form of a swan and then mated with a human woman.

411
00:25:29.227 --> 00:25:31.408
Lupita, do you have feathers?

412
00:25:31.508 --> 00:25:33.829
I mean, this should have gone to a swan.

413
00:25:33.889 --> 00:25:35.529
It could also have been an argument.

414
00:25:35.549 --> 00:25:36.910
It's like, oh my God.

415
00:25:36.970 --> 00:25:40.111
Randomly then, Alec Baldwin ended the chat.

416
00:25:40.151 --> 00:25:40.611
Why?

417
00:25:40.631 --> 00:25:43.412
But supporting Lupita, he said,

418
00:25:44.752 --> 00:25:47.354
Dear Elon, she is the most beautiful woman in the world.

419
00:25:47.574 --> 00:25:51.236
Jimmy Kimmel also ridiculed Muspher's comments telling him to stay in his lane.

420
00:25:51.536 --> 00:25:54.678
Whoopi Goldberg said, I don't know why you feel like you need to speak on this.

421
00:25:54.838 --> 00:25:59.260
And I would suggest looking in the mirror if you have any concerns about people's looks, if this is where we're going.

422
00:25:59.620 --> 00:26:02.262
It's just hilarious like roundtable.

423
00:26:02.682 --> 00:26:06.544
Alec Baldwin, Jimmy Kimmel and Whoopi Goldberg are coming to Lupita Nyong'o.

424
00:26:06.564 --> 00:26:07.865
She's like, I didn't ask any of you.

425
00:26:08.305 --> 00:26:09.586
Well, then she responded.

426
00:26:09.706 --> 00:26:12.507
She responded and said, this is a mythological story.

427
00:26:12.587 --> 00:26:16.288
I'm very supportive of Chris's intention with it and the version of the story that he is telling.

428
00:26:16.649 --> 00:26:18.349
Our cast is representative of the world.

429
00:26:18.649 --> 00:26:20.490
I'm not spending my time thinking of a defense.

430
00:26:20.570 --> 00:26:22.791
The criticism will exist whether I engage with it or not.

431
00:26:23.051 --> 00:26:23.451
Sexy.

432
00:26:23.551 --> 00:26:24.092
Amazing.

433
00:26:24.132 --> 00:26:24.552
Perfect.

434
00:26:24.612 --> 00:26:25.112
Incredible.

435
00:26:25.592 --> 00:26:34.859
There was a writer, Claire Willett, who also pointed out that I found, I really found this interesting, that the outrage itself actually mirrors the plot of another Homer epic pretty well, the Iliad, right?

436
00:26:35.379 --> 00:26:43.164
She said, in a way, isn't causing men to crash out before she's even done anything just proof that Lupita is perfect for the role of Helen of Troy?

437
00:26:43.184 --> 00:26:43.785
Love it.

438
00:26:44.205 --> 00:26:46.747
Also, get on my high horse for a second too here.

439
00:26:47.107 --> 00:26:49.389
But I think it's interesting to note, I love a little side quest.

440
00:26:49.969 --> 00:26:54.893
Homer's epics were originally passed down through spoken performances in the 8th century.

441
00:26:55.814 --> 00:27:03.220
So long before they were ever able to be written down, which means characters like Helen of Troy were actually shaped by interpretation over centuries.

442
00:27:03.460 --> 00:27:08.243
Because it took until like the 17th century to actually get this even written down in English, right?

443
00:27:08.844 --> 00:27:18.411
So every translator, every artist, every historian over these centuries projected their own era's beauty standards, their own biases onto these stories until the 17th century.

444
00:27:18.891 --> 00:27:27.297
So while later European art portrayed the Greeks as pale and as like classical figures, the reality is that ancient Mediterranean world was...

445
00:27:27.597 --> 00:27:28.737
was way more diverse.

446
00:27:28.817 --> 00:27:36.839
Early depictions of Helena Troy have her dark-haired, athletic, strong, which reflected, of course, Spartan women at the time would have to be that.

447
00:27:37.219 --> 00:27:49.641
I think what we're looking at here is this is kind of the same as when people were up in arms around Rachel Zegler being cast as Snow White, Halle Bailey being cast as Ariel, when Ariel's a fucking mermaid.

448
00:27:49.881 --> 00:27:53.282
But I do think there is a fair criticism in this, which is the fact that

449
00:27:54.035 --> 00:27:56.137
I don't think anyone in the cast has Greek heritage.

450
00:27:56.157 --> 00:28:04.944
No, actually, I think I was complimentary of Christopher Nolan casting Lupita Nyong'o, but there's a bigger issue about the lack of diverse casting everywhere else because it's not representative.

451
00:28:05.124 --> 00:28:12.630
I just think it's weird not to have anyone from actual Greek heritage in this, considering that it's their own foundational mythologies and epics.

452
00:28:12.930 --> 00:28:14.911
I just feel like that's a real missed opportunity.

453
00:28:14.951 --> 00:28:19.033
And there's lots of people from the Greek diaspora in Hollywood.

454
00:28:19.213 --> 00:28:21.014
So that seems strange.

455
00:28:21.515 --> 00:28:25.096
And I will say that Christopher Nolan has come out and defended his casting.

456
00:28:25.117 --> 00:28:28.298
He said, hopefully they'll enjoy the film, even if they don't agree with everything.

457
00:28:28.318 --> 00:28:34.822
We've had a lot of scientists complain about Interstellar, but you just don't want people to think that you took it on frivolously.

458
00:28:35.182 --> 00:28:37.383
You had a lot of scientists complain about Interstellar.

459
00:28:37.683 --> 00:29:00.327
it's a really funny comparison to a race complaint or like a diversity in casting complaint they didn't agree with how i depicted a black hole in interstellar is slightly different i mean like i think if you've done as many big films as him like i think he's just so used to someone's gonna have a problem but he also defended at the same time travis scott being an

460
00:29:00.387 --> 00:29:01.348
Travis Scott's in it?

461
00:29:01.588 --> 00:29:02.469
Thank you for raising this.

462
00:29:02.529 --> 00:29:03.450
This is helpful to know.

463
00:29:03.510 --> 00:29:04.131
Yes.

464
00:29:04.151 --> 00:29:07.194
So Travis Scott plays a bard in it.

465
00:29:07.334 --> 00:29:16.683
And Christopher Nolan literally said, I cast him because I wanted to nod towards the idea that this story has been handed down through oral poetry, which is analogous to rap.

466
00:29:17.083 --> 00:29:19.746
So I'm excited to see this film.

467
00:29:19.766 --> 00:29:19.926
Oh, no.

468
00:29:19.946 --> 00:29:22.048
This is coming out to you for my birthday and I'm like booked in.

469
00:29:22.348 --> 00:29:22.789
Booked in?

470
00:29:22.809 --> 00:29:23.509
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

471
00:29:23.709 --> 00:29:24.570
I'm like really excited.

472
00:29:25.992 --> 00:29:27.574
Yeah, I think a lot of it's also just rumor mill.

473
00:29:27.594 --> 00:29:30.897
Like, I think I was happy to do this story because I could actually lay out what was in it.

474
00:29:31.258 --> 00:29:31.638
Yeah.

475
00:29:32.038 --> 00:29:39.186
But there's so many memes and accounts on Instagram that are just completely spreading this information on this as well.

476
00:29:39.266 --> 00:29:40.728
Let's start a big Small Talk book club.

477
00:29:40.768 --> 00:29:42.810
Let's start with the epic Greek poem.

478
00:29:43.651 --> 00:29:44.192
I would.

479
00:29:46.250 --> 00:29:48.272
You're saying that as a joke and I'm like, the Iliad, yes.

480
00:29:48.292 --> 00:29:49.393
I'm not doing that.

481
00:29:50.034 --> 00:29:52.376
Also, speaking of new movies, we have Toy Story 5.

482
00:29:52.396 --> 00:29:52.957
Quick pivot.

483
00:29:53.217 --> 00:29:53.798
Quick pivot.

484
00:29:54.378 --> 00:29:57.001
This is scheduled for very soon.

485
00:29:57.181 --> 00:29:58.102
Have you booked in?

486
00:29:58.122 --> 00:29:59.223
For like 19th of June, 2026?

487
00:29:59.263 --> 00:29:59.643
No, I haven't.

488
00:29:59.904 --> 00:30:01.265
I've never booked in to see movies.

489
00:30:01.385 --> 00:30:03.607
You are the only person I know that books movies.

490
00:30:03.648 --> 00:30:04.889
I'm sick of this sort of hate.

491
00:30:05.509 --> 00:30:06.210
It's bullying.

492
00:30:06.711 --> 00:30:08.552
But every time we do a movie, you go, I'm booked in.

493
00:30:08.613 --> 00:30:09.313
And I go, I...

494
00:30:11.231 --> 00:30:11.531
to do that.

495
00:30:11.551 --> 00:30:12.192
I am booked in.

496
00:30:12.212 --> 00:30:16.535
I would like to be invited to more screenings because I'm a big booker in or a girl when it comes to film.

497
00:30:18.076 --> 00:30:22.239
You've heard me talk about my popcorn and choc top thing where I must be seated before the ads commence.

498
00:30:22.339 --> 00:30:23.260
I must see every ad.

499
00:30:23.580 --> 00:30:27.503
I love going to the movies because I love doing, oh my God, I got the best tag the other day.

500
00:30:27.823 --> 00:30:34.568
So I think I must have spoken about on the podcast how I put M&amp;Ms in with my popcorn so it like melts and it's like a chocolatey, salty amazingness.

501
00:30:34.588 --> 00:30:35.249
Disgusting.

502
00:30:36.318 --> 00:30:37.119
Don't knock it too, try it.

503
00:30:37.899 --> 00:30:44.265
And then I had like two people message me and someone put on their story a photo of them doing it in the cinema and said, influenced.

504
00:30:44.806 --> 00:30:45.587
It's like, fuck yeah.

505
00:30:45.607 --> 00:30:48.469
As if also you're the original person to put M&amp;Ms in popcorn.

506
00:30:48.489 --> 00:30:49.210
It's really funny.

507
00:30:49.310 --> 00:30:50.751
I just spoke of it fondly.

508
00:30:50.771 --> 00:30:51.372
I love that.

509
00:30:51.552 --> 00:30:54.915
But the central idea is essentially it's toy meets tech.

510
00:30:55.736 --> 00:30:58.659
So it's like the toys come up against an iPad.

511
00:30:58.679 --> 00:30:58.859
Yeah.

512
00:30:59.239 --> 00:31:05.187
And Bonnie is now older and she's now like attached to her devices and like more attached than she is to her toys.

513
00:31:05.227 --> 00:31:07.469
And the toys struggle with being replaced by technology.

514
00:31:07.550 --> 00:31:09.152
And there's a tablet called Lilypad.

515
00:31:09.652 --> 00:31:10.573
Also Bad Bunny's in it.

516
00:31:10.754 --> 00:31:11.875
I really, what?

517
00:31:12.195 --> 00:31:12.856
Bad Bunny's in it.

518
00:31:13.357 --> 00:31:15.700
He voices a new character called Pizza with Sunglasses.

519
00:31:17.134 --> 00:31:17.715
That's the name.

520
00:31:17.895 --> 00:31:20.217
His role isn't huge, but it matters a lot.

521
00:31:20.237 --> 00:31:22.700
Pizza with sunglasses doesn't sound like it's huge if it doesn't have a fucking name.

522
00:31:23.701 --> 00:31:26.104
We also have the returning core cast.

523
00:31:26.244 --> 00:31:31.730
We have Tom Hanks as Woody, Tim Allen as Buzz, Joan Cusack as Jessie.

524
00:31:31.770 --> 00:31:33.632
I mean, a lot of people haven't put this together.

525
00:31:33.672 --> 00:31:35.413
Joan Cusack, if you've seen School of Rock...

526
00:31:36.074 --> 00:31:38.715
The principal in School of Rock is Joan Cusack, right?

527
00:31:39.336 --> 00:31:40.116
People don't get that.

528
00:31:40.156 --> 00:31:42.097
That is Jessie from Toy Story.

529
00:31:42.557 --> 00:31:49.040
It's interesting that you do go to School of Rock because I definitely go the mother of Ice Princess.

530
00:31:49.080 --> 00:31:51.982
I haven't booked in to see Toy Story 5, but I will be now that I know the plot line.

531
00:31:52.322 --> 00:31:53.683
Can I also say some other new additions?

532
00:31:53.703 --> 00:31:54.443
Yes, it's Bad Bunny.

533
00:31:54.463 --> 00:31:57.725
We also have Conan O'Brien, Keanu Reeves, Greta Lee.

534
00:31:58.065 --> 00:32:02.027
Also, for the Australian New Zealand release of the film, Fisher.

535
00:32:02.487 --> 00:32:04.248
Fisher will be voicing the garden gnome.

536
00:32:04.728 --> 00:32:07.090
I mean, I think he'd make a great personality for it.

537
00:32:07.290 --> 00:32:08.851
He actually does have the energy.

538
00:32:08.871 --> 00:32:10.012
He has the energy.

539
00:32:10.032 --> 00:32:11.133
I think that's amazing.

540
00:32:11.533 --> 00:32:14.235
And then, of course, Taylor Swift came out with a new song for it.

541
00:32:14.995 --> 00:32:17.557
She wrote and recorded it with Jack Antonoff.

542
00:32:17.577 --> 00:32:19.419
It's called I Knew It, I Knew You.

543
00:32:19.919 --> 00:32:21.140
I listened to it on my walk.

544
00:32:21.600 --> 00:32:22.201
I enjoyed it.

545
00:32:22.281 --> 00:32:24.342
I like that she's coming out with different variations of it.

546
00:32:24.442 --> 00:32:26.444
It's like a bit of a departure from her usual sound.

547
00:32:27.264 --> 00:32:29.446
But it's about Jessie's character arc.

548
00:32:29.686 --> 00:32:36.357
What I will say on Toy Story is that it's the only animated franchise, I believe, that maintained its quality past number two.

549
00:32:38.027 --> 00:32:39.067
I still think there's been a dip.

550
00:32:39.468 --> 00:32:40.928
I'm interested to see when it happens to number five.

551
00:32:40.948 --> 00:32:41.468
But three...

552
00:32:41.488 --> 00:32:43.529
I did have a conniption when I saw it was five.

553
00:32:43.729 --> 00:32:45.130
I don't think I've seen past three.

554
00:32:45.270 --> 00:32:48.191
I don't think I've seen four, but I think all the reviews have maintained.

555
00:32:48.211 --> 00:32:49.871
Like, number three was as good.

556
00:32:50.231 --> 00:32:51.712
I thought number two was better than the original.

557
00:32:51.792 --> 00:32:52.352
I agree with that.

558
00:32:52.372 --> 00:32:55.813
This is a rarity in any sequel sort of land.

559
00:32:56.114 --> 00:33:02.536
But to get to five and to be maintaining the cultural conversation with the iPad versus, it's fascinating.

560
00:33:02.556 --> 00:33:02.956
Good for them.

561
00:33:03.116 --> 00:33:03.456
Good for them.

562
00:33:03.616 --> 00:33:04.196
I'm going to go see it.

563
00:33:09.423 --> 00:33:10.524
Sexism is back.

564
00:33:10.544 --> 00:33:13.147
It's a really tough app, isn't it?

565
00:33:13.187 --> 00:33:13.928
It's a really tough app.

566
00:33:14.669 --> 00:33:20.014
Victorian Premier Jacinta Allen is the face of a billboard campaign in Melbourne with the label Ditch the Witch.

567
00:33:21.195 --> 00:33:21.896
Yeah, it's a toughie.

568
00:33:22.316 --> 00:33:23.998
I'm glad we had the Toy Story slide in there.

569
00:33:24.278 --> 00:33:25.119
Thank God.

570
00:33:25.139 --> 00:33:25.720
Thank God.

571
00:33:25.980 --> 00:33:26.701
Comic relief.

572
00:33:26.741 --> 00:33:27.121
Yeah.

573
00:33:27.282 --> 00:33:28.463
So in 2011...

574
00:33:30.336 --> 00:33:31.397
Take your minds back.

575
00:33:31.958 --> 00:33:32.438
Where were you?

576
00:33:32.658 --> 00:33:34.060
Well, we were both 13, so.

577
00:33:34.660 --> 00:33:35.301
So, yeah.

578
00:33:35.381 --> 00:33:37.102
It was like year eight, year nine?

579
00:33:37.623 --> 00:33:38.083
Year nine.

580
00:33:38.103 --> 00:33:38.944
2011?

581
00:33:38.964 --> 00:33:40.366
Sorry, 2011 was year seven for us.

582
00:33:40.386 --> 00:33:41.547
Year seven.

583
00:33:41.607 --> 00:33:42.708
We were starting high school.

584
00:33:43.268 --> 00:33:43.529
Yeah.

585
00:33:43.549 --> 00:33:44.730
The whole world in front of us.

586
00:33:44.750 --> 00:33:45.631
Yeah, that's tough.

587
00:33:46.111 --> 00:33:54.719
Tony Abbott in 2011 stood outside Parliament House in front of, you know, the famous posters that said like, Bob Brown's bitch and ditch the witch.

588
00:33:54.739 --> 00:33:55.320
Yeah.

589
00:33:55.620 --> 00:33:59.803
And it was referring to Australia's first female prime minister, Julia Gillard.

590
00:34:00.283 --> 00:34:02.264
And obviously Tony Abbott was the opposition leader at the time.

591
00:34:02.344 --> 00:34:08.448
And that was one of the most sort of infamous moments in Australian politics of the last few decades in particular.

592
00:34:09.369 --> 00:34:15.453
Now, 15 years later, that slogan has reappeared and it's been seen for the last six weeks as...

593
00:34:16.242 --> 00:34:21.765
on a mobile billboard in Melbourne CBD, featuring like a doctored image of Jacinta Allen.

594
00:34:21.785 --> 00:34:25.148
I've seen one where she has like a witch's nose and hat on.

595
00:34:25.768 --> 00:34:27.449
And the phrase next to it is ditch the witch.

596
00:34:27.529 --> 00:34:30.371
Now, obviously, Victoria's heading up to an election soon.

597
00:34:30.731 --> 00:34:33.012
Also, clearly, this whole thing was created by...

598
00:34:33.953 --> 00:34:37.655
boomers because you call a Gen Z a witch and they'll go thank you.

599
00:34:38.056 --> 00:34:38.656
No, that's so true.

600
00:34:38.696 --> 00:34:44.380
It's been like so – they'd be like Etsy witch, former circle, witchy, witching hour.

601
00:34:44.400 --> 00:34:44.840
Yeah.

602
00:34:45.040 --> 00:34:50.804
When you were in the Odyssey thing before and you said Charlize Theron was playing the sea witch, I was like, well, that's the role we would obviously want.

603
00:34:50.824 --> 00:34:52.885
That's the one we'd like to have because it's so popular.

604
00:34:53.346 --> 00:34:56.367
But what's interesting is who is behind the billboard.

605
00:34:56.488 --> 00:34:56.648
Mm-hmm.

606
00:34:57.368 --> 00:35:16.589
Oddly, the owner of a Melbourne brothel called Gotham City named Franco Puglio confirmed he was one of the businesses behind the campaign, which is alleged to have cost about $105,000 to fund this, like, mobile truck billboard to circulate around Melbourne.

607
00:35:17.070 --> 00:35:27.916
And I read that figure, 105 grand, in the Saturday paper, and they also included a quote from The Ages Reporting, which said that Pulio said the phrase isn't sexist, it's just what the Victorian public are feeling right now.

608
00:35:28.236 --> 00:35:31.778
So for anyone who doesn't know, Jacinta Allen is the Premier of Victoria.

609
00:35:31.798 --> 00:35:35.380
She's the Labor Premier of Victoria, and she has taken over from Dan Andrews.

610
00:35:35.400 --> 00:35:37.181
So she's been in the job for a couple of years now.

611
00:35:37.742 --> 00:35:40.303
Her polling is not good at the moment.

612
00:35:40.783 --> 00:35:45.266
Now, Victoria is headed for a state election in November of this year.

613
00:35:45.686 --> 00:35:49.647
Now, New South Wales will also have an election by April, May next year.

614
00:35:49.667 --> 00:35:51.008
I think it's set for April next year.

615
00:35:52.589 --> 00:35:57.450
Now, the opposition leader in Victoria is a woman as well, and her name is Jess Wilson.

616
00:35:57.470 --> 00:36:02.072
Now, she has come out and said that the campaign is sexist, but after a lot of other political leaders in the space did.

617
00:36:03.098 --> 00:36:10.184
What I'm finding is that it's kind of interesting to discuss this election, given we're outside of Victoria, so we're probably missing quite a bit of local context.

618
00:36:10.204 --> 00:36:14.487
I'm sure a lot of our listeners who are based in Melbourne can probably message us in what their thoughts are and just send to Alan too.

619
00:36:14.507 --> 00:36:29.380
It'd be good to get some feedback about how a lot of progressive women are feeling about the Labor government in Victoria right now too, because this has been a Labor government that has had a tough on crime, tough on youth incarceration approaches, a lot of what we have covered of Victorian policy in recent times.

620
00:36:29.960 --> 00:36:33.601
You know, Jacinta Allen's also been someone that's tried to implement some women's health policy.

621
00:36:33.621 --> 00:36:35.822
She's come forward with her own experience of endometriosis.

622
00:36:36.283 --> 00:36:42.845
We've seen bits and pieces from Victoria, but we also know that the state is largely unhappy with this Labor government.

623
00:36:42.865 --> 00:36:43.045
Yeah.

624
00:36:43.485 --> 00:36:45.706
And I wonder what is going to happen at this election.

625
00:36:45.746 --> 00:36:46.827
Now, we don't know for sure.

626
00:36:46.847 --> 00:36:48.908
There's still a few months until the election.

627
00:36:49.388 --> 00:36:54.230
But it seems like from the outside, at the very least, that Jacinta Allen is not a popular leader.

628
00:36:54.250 --> 00:36:54.790
Mm-hmm.

629
00:36:54.910 --> 00:37:13.487
And I do think that also comes back to the kind of rhetoric we're seeing with, you know, which I'll talk about in the next story as well later in this episode, about One Nation's rise, the growing frustrated sentiment with the major parties, and that, you know, just seeing this establishment politician kind of continue on the same old path is not leading to like a happy state.

630
00:37:14.047 --> 00:37:26.812
And Victoria is kind of, you know, we had South Australia's election earlier this year, but Victoria is the next test really for how One Nation is tracking, because we also know that on average, Victoria is a more progressive state than others in Australia as well.

631
00:37:27.572 --> 00:37:39.117
So returning to this campaign too, we have seen many prominent political figures come out and condemn the billboard campaign, including former Prime Minister Julia Gillard herself released a statement that I read on Instagram.

632
00:37:39.657 --> 00:37:43.820
And one of the paragraphs that I wanted to read, because there's the whole, you know, she kind of condemns it.

633
00:37:43.860 --> 00:37:49.204
She speaks about this rhetoric being tired, being decades old and not expecting it to sort of come back.

634
00:37:49.645 --> 00:37:53.167
But in her statement, she also said, I'm also angry.

635
00:37:53.428 --> 00:37:59.713
Whoever funded the billboards bearing these signs should be outed for what they are, unimaginative, ugly sexists.

636
00:38:00.453 --> 00:38:05.405
The billboard company should do the responsible thing and take these signs down immediately.

637
00:38:06.086 --> 00:38:10.336
Why should women and girls in Victoria be subjected to such visible misogyny?

638
00:38:11.466 --> 00:38:19.691
And, you know, the Prime Minister, Anthony Albanese, also came forward and said, the sexist campaign targeting the Victorian Premier is totally unacceptable and has no place in public life.

639
00:38:20.311 --> 00:38:30.517
And Jacinta Allen herself has also come forward and condemned these and talked about the sexism she's experiencing and said, like, it's fine to disagree with me, that is democratic, but this is not, essentially.

640
00:38:30.757 --> 00:38:30.977
Yeah, yeah.

641
00:38:31.317 --> 00:38:47.103
I wonder, you know, looking at this 15-year gap between these campaigns, it also makes me consider that one of the key differences between 2011 and 2026 is that there was actually a quicker response 15 years ago.

642
00:38:47.803 --> 00:38:52.945
And I think it's because with the rise of social media and the rise of, you know, figures like Donald Trump,

643
00:38:53.822 --> 00:38:55.823
We are so desensitised.

644
00:38:56.484 --> 00:39:05.529
It feels like, and I don't know if you feel like this too, I certainly do at the moment, and I think it's the same on the pod in many ways in the way we're talking about issues and the way we feel we can approach discussion.

645
00:39:06.289 --> 00:39:13.053
I'm increasingly feeling like we can't talk about social issues or women's issues because we have to focus on things that, you know, One Nation are targeting.

646
00:39:13.613 --> 00:39:16.015
Because I think in these times where we feel this swing,

647
00:39:16.855 --> 00:39:28.123
I know a lot of women around me, a lot of progressive people feel like in order to kind of claw back some sort of vote, some hope, some support, we need to focus on things like cost of living.

648
00:39:28.143 --> 00:39:30.464
We need to focus on issues that affect all Australians.

649
00:39:30.984 --> 00:39:36.008
And sometimes it feels like to talk about the issues that are affecting us day to day, talk about the issues that were big.

650
00:39:36.488 --> 00:39:46.334
Two years ago, five years ago, I just wonder in this timeline that we're in right now, growing kind of exhaustion from people that they can't talk about 10 issues at once, that all matter deeply as well.

651
00:39:46.754 --> 00:40:03.103
So I'm finding that like the ditch the witch thing, I wonder if people didn't notice for a couple of days, one, because we might not be in Victoria, so it might not be as in our face, but also if people are, the sort of increasing worry and attention spend that we're having is forcing us to choose conversations if there's that kind of feeling amongst the population as well.

652
00:40:05.667 --> 00:40:12.397
Phoebe Bridges just performed a sold-out show at Madison Square Garden where tickets cost $1 and no phones were allowed.

653
00:40:13.278 --> 00:40:17.584
So this happened on June 4th that she announced with only a few days' notice.

654
00:40:17.844 --> 00:40:22.131
And then, yeah, the tickets, the $1 tickets were distributed via a raffle.

655
00:40:23.770 --> 00:40:28.216
just think that is such a nice relief from the Ticketmaster bloodbaths that we've gotten used to.

656
00:40:28.737 --> 00:40:34.645
And all the proceeds from the night went to Community Justice Exchange's Immigration Bond Freedom Fund.

657
00:40:35.186 --> 00:40:36.768
She performed for nearly two hours.

658
00:40:36.888 --> 00:40:38.431
There was eight new songs in there.

659
00:40:39.192 --> 00:40:39.712
And there was a

660
00:40:40.233 --> 00:40:45.037
Like really serious ban on every phone or device that could be in use there.

661
00:40:45.597 --> 00:40:53.062
And it's funny, like even from the reports that I've seen from journalists or whoever that did go, she was stunned by it even working.

662
00:40:53.403 --> 00:40:56.265
Like she said, I certainly haven't been to a concert like this in my life.

663
00:40:57.270 --> 00:41:01.151
And I think the $1 thing is interesting as well because it was sort of dual purpose.

664
00:41:01.211 --> 00:41:07.852
It's like one to rail against what's happening in the industry right now, which is these like insanely inflated prices.

665
00:41:08.673 --> 00:41:14.174
But also genius marketing and a way to build hype without traditional promotions.

666
00:41:14.854 --> 00:41:17.595
And the no phones thing, again, dual purpose.

667
00:41:17.835 --> 00:41:21.856
We're all talking about this need to actually connect, have community.

668
00:41:21.876 --> 00:41:25.117
I just think concerts are getting fucking ruined by phones.

669
00:41:28.038 --> 00:41:29.759
I go to concerts, I film everything.

670
00:41:30.319 --> 00:41:31.920
I have not played it back once.

671
00:41:32.080 --> 00:41:32.361
Yes.

672
00:41:32.621 --> 00:41:33.601
Like, who does that?

673
00:41:33.661 --> 00:41:33.882
No.

674
00:41:33.982 --> 00:41:35.383
Have you ever gone back and listened?

675
00:41:36.063 --> 00:41:36.283
No.

676
00:41:36.624 --> 00:41:38.085
And sometimes you think, oh, I'm going to go back and listen.

677
00:41:38.105 --> 00:41:40.486
And then you go back and listen, you're like, this is not a depiction of how it happened.

678
00:41:40.526 --> 00:41:41.207
Like, it's not.

679
00:41:41.247 --> 00:41:41.407
No.

680
00:41:41.427 --> 00:41:42.948
The iPhone is not capturing what happened.

681
00:41:42.948 --> 00:41:52.115
It's not the same, but also was a way of preventing leaks because she hasn't even given an announcement of what this new album is called or when it's going to come out.

682
00:41:52.235 --> 00:41:53.536
So it helps with that.

683
00:41:53.796 --> 00:41:55.137
But I want to read out a little paragraph.

684
00:41:55.157 --> 00:42:02.082
There was Erin Summers who wrote a piece, What I Saw at Phoebe Bridges No Phone MSG Show, to the best of my recollection.

685
00:42:02.682 --> 00:42:02.983
She said,

686
00:42:03.763 --> 00:42:07.629
You cannot bring digital recorders, cameras, smartwatches, or even a pencil and paper.

687
00:42:07.969 --> 00:42:13.437
Your iPhone and AirPods must be turned off and sealed in a thick black yonder pouch by a cheerful professional.

688
00:42:13.778 --> 00:42:19.246
If you're writing about the show for a magazine, you are not permitted to transcribe lyrics from new songs The Bridges Plays.

689
00:42:20.267 --> 00:42:23.148
Offenders will be unceremoniously removed by security.

690
00:42:23.268 --> 00:42:27.610
The tech ban, which will remain in force throughout the tour, seems to me doomed.

691
00:42:27.850 --> 00:42:28.190
Silly.

692
00:42:28.851 --> 00:42:31.832
Certainly the moratorium of pencils is over the top.

693
00:42:32.252 --> 00:42:35.954
I understand not wanting videos of new songs online, but lyrics?

694
00:42:36.374 --> 00:42:39.916
Is transcription of lyrics really going to ruin someone's enjoyment of a new song?

695
00:42:40.256 --> 00:42:43.257
Is it going to chip away its streams, erode fan excitement?

696
00:42:43.797 --> 00:42:45.298
Ours is a culture of spoilers.

697
00:42:45.932 --> 00:42:47.832
Now, Erin, I disagree.

698
00:42:47.852 --> 00:42:49.053
I'm glad because I do too.

699
00:42:49.173 --> 00:42:49.793
I disagree.

700
00:42:50.013 --> 00:42:52.213
Like, I understand what the point is here.

701
00:42:52.253 --> 00:42:54.854
And I get that that's like very unheard of for this time.

702
00:42:54.874 --> 00:42:57.135
And I guess it's a question of like, can you really do that?

703
00:42:57.755 --> 00:43:00.815
But I hate that we have a culture of spoilers.

704
00:43:00.915 --> 00:43:03.136
I would like to unwind that if we could.

705
00:43:03.636 --> 00:43:09.317
Also, lyrics are important, especially when you're a famous figure, when people are going to be decoding your relationships.

706
00:43:09.537 --> 00:43:11.678
Then yes, I think that's weird to undermine that.

707
00:43:11.718 --> 00:43:12.198
Also, like...

708
00:43:12.858 --> 00:43:16.383
I just think the nature of this is that it's a bit fun in how strict it is, right?

709
00:43:16.784 --> 00:43:20.109
Like, no, they did not need to put a moratorium on pencils.

710
00:43:20.149 --> 00:43:24.636
Like, it's actually adding to the layer of fun about this experience.

711
00:43:24.656 --> 00:43:26.018
It's just being ridiculously strict.

712
00:43:26.538 --> 00:43:27.239
I love that.

713
00:43:27.680 --> 00:43:28.161
I love it too.

714
00:43:28.181 --> 00:43:32.506
And I think the mystery and like scarcity is something that's really hard to cultivate in this day and age.

715
00:43:32.526 --> 00:43:34.948
And the fact she's doing it is quite impressive.

716
00:43:35.068 --> 00:43:43.738
Also, it plays into what I keep talking about, about how we just need to get more and more and more inventive every time something comes out, if there's a movie rollout, if there's an album rollout.

717
00:43:44.619 --> 00:43:50.304
Marketing has to sort of be quite meta and layered to work these days.

718
00:43:50.924 --> 00:43:52.846
A good example was last year.

719
00:43:52.866 --> 00:43:54.767
There was Lucy Dacus.

720
00:43:54.807 --> 00:43:55.047
Yes.

721
00:43:55.548 --> 00:44:01.132
Who played like a short run of museum shows with tickets that were only available via Lottery as well.

722
00:44:01.553 --> 00:44:04.915
And then like Drake built an ice installation in Toronto.

723
00:44:05.516 --> 00:44:08.458
Also, the fire department melted it because it was team to public service.

724
00:44:09.915 --> 00:44:12.939
But then like smaller artists really have to do a lot to stand out now.

725
00:44:13.239 --> 00:44:23.269
There was an artist in New York called Lexa Gates who walked for 10 hours on a human-sized wheel to make it an art installation statement for her new album.

726
00:44:23.349 --> 00:44:24.351
Walked on a wheel?

727
00:44:24.911 --> 00:44:25.151
Yeah.

728
00:44:25.732 --> 00:44:27.474
Like rode a wheel or like walked on a...

729
00:44:27.554 --> 00:44:29.276
I imagine it looks like a hamster wheel.

730
00:44:29.836 --> 00:44:30.377
It's awesome.

731
00:44:30.617 --> 00:44:31.138
It's a lot.

732
00:44:31.258 --> 00:44:31.739
It's a lot.

733
00:44:31.899 --> 00:44:32.479
Ten hours.

734
00:44:32.499 --> 00:44:33.100
Mm-hmm.

735
00:44:33.461 --> 00:44:34.202
It's really impressive.

736
00:44:34.262 --> 00:44:40.349
I kind of like that in this era of just over the top everything all the time, this is the new way to be different.

737
00:44:40.389 --> 00:44:40.850
I like that.

738
00:44:43.471 --> 00:44:47.354
One Nation's popularity is rising, but how do we respond to it?

739
00:44:48.175 --> 00:44:51.778
Now, I wanted to run a bit of a different segment in this week's episode.

740
00:44:52.138 --> 00:45:03.066
Yesterday's been a long weekend here in New South Wales, and Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, during the King's Birthday kind of press conference and announcements, did commit to a cut to migration.

741
00:45:04.026 --> 00:45:07.568
a direct measure clearly aimed at countering One Nation.

742
00:45:07.608 --> 00:45:14.053
And during this press conference, and what he committed to on behalf of the Labor government, is a reduction in migration over the next couple of years to 225,000.

743
00:45:14.233 --> 00:45:18.896
Now, I went and looked at ABS data this morning on this.

744
00:45:19.296 --> 00:45:24.579
Now, net overseas migration was in the 24-25 financial year, 306,000, and the year before that was 429,000.

745
00:45:24.599 --> 00:45:26.941
So, again, just a gradual series of cuts, essentially.

746
00:45:26.961 --> 00:45:27.081
Yeah.

747
00:45:32.342 --> 00:45:36.463
Now, we talked a little bit in the last segment about the rise of One Nation.

748
00:45:36.783 --> 00:45:50.988
And I also want to talk about probably the biggest story last week, which really went through the papers, was Redbridge polling for the Australian Financial Review, which showed that for the first time One Nation was ahead of Labor with a primary vote support of 31%.

749
00:45:52.548 --> 00:45:54.529
Labor was down three on 28%.

750
00:45:54.929 --> 00:45:57.730
The coalition was down to 20%, which is another 2% down.

751
00:45:58.130 --> 00:45:59.571
The Greens were on 12%.

752
00:45:59.711 --> 00:46:03.033
And obviously, independents and minor parties made up about 9%, I believe.

753
00:46:03.453 --> 00:46:12.056
This data, and again, what I'm saying, which I agree with, I think lots of the commentators online have been saying, you know, like, take this with a grain of salt.

754
00:46:12.597 --> 00:46:13.057
Absolutely.

755
00:46:13.137 --> 00:46:13.597
Absolutely.

756
00:46:13.677 --> 00:46:14.437
This is polling.

757
00:46:14.617 --> 00:46:15.678
We are not near an election.

758
00:46:15.978 --> 00:46:22.563
But we need to also understand that this is good data taken from an adequate sample size, more than 1,000 Australians nationally.

759
00:46:22.963 --> 00:46:26.486
And when we're looking at what a good representative model is, it's over 1,000.

760
00:46:26.846 --> 00:46:29.688
And Redbridge accent research is trustworthy.

761
00:46:30.049 --> 00:46:33.031
So yes, we don't know for sure, but this is a great depiction.

762
00:46:33.131 --> 00:46:35.713
And this also is reflected in other data.

763
00:46:35.733 --> 00:46:39.436
So YouGov had the same results effectively as well, that One Nation was the most popular.

764
00:46:39.456 --> 00:46:39.736
Yeah.

765
00:46:40.677 --> 00:46:52.114
So there are complicating factors, but it's also something that we need to be talking about as we kind of are seeing right now that we're almost trailing in the conversation, the US and the UK by one or two years.

766
00:46:52.718 --> 00:47:04.481
And I was at a talk last week and one of the speakers very much said that, you know, during the last federal election, there was very, and I was part of this saying, you know, Australia rejected Trump's playbook when we rejected Peter Dutton.

767
00:47:05.381 --> 00:47:15.643
And this person said, well, actually just wait a couple of years because we've seen like Donald Trump and Nigel Farage for Reform UK are the voices coming out for the far right movements and Australia might just be one or two years behind.

768
00:47:15.683 --> 00:47:18.844
And this Pauline Hanson rise really feels like that, doesn't it?

769
00:47:19.184 --> 00:47:39.958
And one of the things that I wanted to speak about with this polling and this emerging rhetoric is that what the research is also telling us is that One Nation supporters are very much opting into One Nation based on a frustration and anger, which we talk about quite frequently on the podcast, but not necessarily an understanding of policy.

770
00:47:40.658 --> 00:47:43.940
It's not about backing in their policy platform.

771
00:47:44.180 --> 00:47:46.422
It's about sending a message to the major parties.

772
00:47:46.928 --> 00:47:51.451
The thing that we talked about, Sarah and I, last week was the increasing vote among women.

773
00:47:51.832 --> 00:47:52.032
Yeah.

774
00:47:52.452 --> 00:47:57.136
Because I think it's also pitched very much, and I've been part of this as well, saying, you know, it is rural men.

775
00:47:57.256 --> 00:47:59.498
It is, you know, a specific subset of Australian society.

776
00:47:59.518 --> 00:48:01.599
It's not represented in metro areas, which is true.

777
00:48:02.100 --> 00:48:12.908
But I read research that in April this year, 28% of women in Australia had One Nation as their first vote, their number one pick for the House of Reps.

778
00:48:14.157 --> 00:48:19.982
Just to contrast that, that number is up 19% since June last year.

779
00:48:20.542 --> 00:48:23.264
That is incredible growth.

780
00:48:23.284 --> 00:48:26.127
It's a huge jump in the space of less than a year.

781
00:48:26.247 --> 00:48:26.467
Yeah.

782
00:48:27.087 --> 00:48:29.609
And so the question is, you know, can we change this?

783
00:48:29.689 --> 00:48:33.933
How will this look in a year, in 18 months, as we head towards the next federal election?

784
00:48:34.613 --> 00:48:39.878
Also, when there's such a narrative around, like, we support them because they're against the major parties and we're fed up.

785
00:48:40.498 --> 00:48:42.439
but people don't understand their policy platform.

786
00:48:42.559 --> 00:48:50.382
The question is then, how can we develop media literacy around this to stop this or to educate people about what their actual policies are?

787
00:48:50.843 --> 00:48:56.585
Yeah, I feel like there is so much general conversation around One Nation and yet no one could actually...

788
00:48:56.685 --> 00:48:56.845
Yeah.

789
00:49:19.648 --> 00:49:23.230
Your options, and the Liberal Party doesn't really seem like an option either.

790
00:49:23.390 --> 00:49:23.691
No.

791
00:49:23.831 --> 00:49:29.094
And also you've got, like, and we talked about this last week with this teal segment around the idea of a teal party too.

792
00:49:29.134 --> 00:49:35.278
Like, I spoke to my dad last week and one of the things that he said was like, well, it doesn't really feel like it's an option outside.

793
00:49:35.298 --> 00:49:37.899
Like, this is a very metro thing, the independence, right?

794
00:49:37.919 --> 00:49:44.943
So a lot of people, a lot of the commentary I'm seeing in Chicks' inbox, in my personal inbox at the moment, is people saying to me, well, who are you voting for?

795
00:49:44.963 --> 00:49:45.744
Like, what's the plan?

796
00:49:45.984 --> 00:49:51.309
You know, because you can tell that people are saying, like, I don't feel like I have anything available to me.

797
00:49:51.469 --> 00:49:58.216
If, you know, a lot of people say in like in an inner city area, like, oh, you know, I want to send a message by voting for the Greens or I want to vote for this India or blah, blah, blah, blah.

798
00:49:58.797 --> 00:50:03.421
But you're also seeing this frustration with Labour and Liberals and going, well, I don't know what my option is.

799
00:50:04.242 --> 00:50:08.566
And one of the things that I also want to say is, you know, let's remind ourselves that we are not the US.

800
00:50:08.586 --> 00:50:08.806
Yeah.

801
00:50:09.835 --> 00:50:14.637
And that this is a system we live in where you're not being asked whether you're voting for Anthony Albanese or Pauline Hanson.

802
00:50:15.117 --> 00:50:20.019
You are going to be asked who you support in your electorate and how you want to order your ballot.

803
00:50:20.059 --> 00:50:22.720
And that looks very different depending on where you are in this country.

804
00:50:23.400 --> 00:50:30.963
So there's also a more complex conversation to be had about voting literacy and what the individual options available to us are and how.

805
00:50:31.183 --> 00:50:37.245
And also, I think a large part of this problem is there's a lot of noise on social media that doesn't translate to community action.

806
00:50:37.525 --> 00:50:37.665
Mm-hmm.

807
00:50:38.085 --> 00:50:45.691
And I say that again as someone with a clear bias here who wants to run up the next election as an independent, that increasingly there's just people making a lot of noise online.

808
00:50:45.711 --> 00:50:47.973
This is always going to be a debate with performance activism.

809
00:50:48.453 --> 00:50:54.058
But at what point do we need to actually go and speak to our neighbours about this too and actually go and get on the ground and speak to our family members?

810
00:50:54.118 --> 00:50:59.462
Because what I'm finding with One Nation as well is they are targeting people.

811
00:50:59.742 --> 00:51:04.624
ideas and feelings, but not actually communicating their policy platforms and the damage they'll do.

812
00:51:04.824 --> 00:51:10.967
And I wrote this piece last night on One Nation's reproductive rights policy, which we talked about a little bit in last week's episode too.

813
00:51:10.987 --> 00:51:16.449
But one of the things that I think is a really important contrast is their voter base versus the actual policies they're backing in.

814
00:51:16.969 --> 00:51:21.091
So there's also research from this year from the Australia Institute that found that

815
00:51:22.291 --> 00:51:25.574
87% of Australians support abortion access in some form.

816
00:51:25.834 --> 00:51:34.200
So maybe it's not that, you know, the conversation around late-term abortions is the same for everyone, but 87% of Australians support access to these services in some capacity.

817
00:51:34.900 --> 00:51:38.002
And notably, this was strongest in rural parts of Australia.

818
00:51:38.563 --> 00:51:44.167
And also, this data showed that 50% of One Nation voters support abortion access.

819
00:51:44.867 --> 00:51:57.251
Meanwhile, you've got Barnaby Joyce at this anti-choice rally last week, and you've got Pauline Hanson and Barnaby Joyce as One Nation's effective leaders right now, pushing a dangerous rhetoric around access to these reproductive rights.

820
00:51:57.891 --> 00:52:02.593
And one of the conversations I wanted to have in the face of this polling and all this confusion, and I think fear...

821
00:52:03.453 --> 00:52:25.323
is that we're getting really afraid of having conversations because we feel a lot of people feel ill-equipped to talk about One Nation because their lack of transparent policies means that if someone comes at us with like anti-immigration rhetoric or anti-choice rhetoric, people don't feel like they can respond because we don't have enough information yet about their candidates, about their policy platform, and about what they're actually going to change in Australia.

822
00:52:26.183 --> 00:52:30.264
And one of the things I just wanted to spend this time talking about is this polling is really scary.

823
00:52:30.564 --> 00:52:37.486
The rise of the far right, the copycat behaviour of the blueprint of Trump's playbook and Project 2025, all of that, right, it's terrifying.

824
00:52:38.186 --> 00:52:49.329
But we need to be less focused in these conversations on picking apart particular policy points and instead trying to engage with people that are maybe thinking about voting for One Nation by saying, like, what about them do you like?

825
00:52:49.569 --> 00:52:50.529
What policy do you like?

826
00:52:50.569 --> 00:52:51.429
What can you point to?

827
00:52:51.829 --> 00:52:54.890
And getting to the emotion underneath that and finding those shared frustrations too.

828
00:52:57.218 --> 00:53:01.500
Okay, we are now at the Q&amp;A section for this week.

829
00:53:01.820 --> 00:53:04.322
And I mean, it's kind of exciting when this happens.

830
00:53:04.842 --> 00:53:07.443
News unfolds on a Tuesday morning.

831
00:53:07.644 --> 00:53:13.727
And I actually saw this news because I went in my inbox and like three people had messaged this morning being like, are you guys going to cover this?

832
00:53:13.767 --> 00:53:16.468
And I was like, guess what the Q&amp;A will be today then.

833
00:53:17.749 --> 00:53:24.132
Breaking news, Ariana Grande and Ethan Slater have called it quits, according to people.

834
00:53:24.152 --> 00:53:25.513
So that's like three years.

835
00:53:26.378 --> 00:53:26.858
Yeah.

836
00:53:26.879 --> 00:53:27.379
A long time.

837
00:53:27.419 --> 00:53:29.501
Apparently they did split like several months ago.

838
00:53:29.521 --> 00:53:33.584
Again, people's kind of yet to get it wrong, if I'm honest.

839
00:53:33.905 --> 00:53:36.487
Pulitzer Prize winning journalism once again.

840
00:53:36.527 --> 00:53:37.748
The Pulitzer joke never gets old.

841
00:53:37.788 --> 00:53:38.509
Never gets old.

842
00:53:39.250 --> 00:53:50.099
But weren't they – can I ask, just jog my memory, were they distant at the wicked for good premieres and like press and we were kind of like is he giving her her moment?

843
00:53:50.119 --> 00:53:50.820
Like was that –

844
00:53:52.250 --> 00:53:54.452
It brings all that into question again, doesn't it?

845
00:53:54.712 --> 00:53:55.072
Doesn't it?

846
00:53:55.152 --> 00:53:56.453
I mean, I think they're amicable.

847
00:53:56.473 --> 00:53:57.454
I think they're friends.

848
00:53:58.434 --> 00:54:01.276
I know they posted sort of supporting each other just a few months ago.

849
00:54:01.897 --> 00:54:06.200
The timing as well, like she's just kicked off her Eternal Sunshine tour this week.

850
00:54:06.280 --> 00:54:06.460
Yeah.

851
00:54:07.180 --> 00:54:09.822
And I am sad for her.

852
00:54:10.443 --> 00:54:13.905
Like I want to say that at the top, like I think that's always like that is sad.

853
00:54:13.985 --> 00:54:14.585
That's tough.

854
00:54:14.685 --> 00:54:18.008
And I think it's especially tough because there's so many interesting conversations.

855
00:54:18.288 --> 00:54:20.730
The cut actually did a really interesting piece that was like –

856
00:54:21.450 --> 00:54:27.734
is cheating okay if they're the love of your life or like if you stay together or whatever it is, like the ethical question with that.

857
00:54:28.154 --> 00:54:33.237
And again, there was a lot of speculation around Ariana Grande and Ethan Slater's start of their relationship.

858
00:54:34.458 --> 00:54:40.782
But it sat badly with everyone because it was so public and clearly, I think it was Lily was Ethan's wife.

859
00:54:40.802 --> 00:54:40.942
Mm-hmm.

860
00:54:42.585 --> 00:54:44.826
was clearly was the victim of that.

861
00:54:44.866 --> 00:54:46.287
Like, that was awful.

862
00:54:46.387 --> 00:54:51.109
And, like, to recap a little bit of that, we know that that was quite messy.

863
00:54:51.729 --> 00:54:54.471
She sort of implied that timelines overlapped.

864
00:54:55.051 --> 00:54:58.393
Like, Ariana Grande was finalising her divorce and then...

865
00:54:59.233 --> 00:55:06.999
Lily had just given birth just a month before Ethan and Ariana were then spotted in Disneyland together and then they were spotted like consistently together after that.

866
00:55:07.500 --> 00:55:16.888
And then she had that article, like a little snippet of it was, and this is Lily, I confidently moved to another country with my two-month-old baby and my husband to support his career.

867
00:55:17.248 --> 00:55:23.193
Consumed by the magic and mundanity of new motherhood, I didn't understand the growing distance between us.

868
00:55:23.713 --> 00:55:26.436
Motherhood, I have learned, fills your time but not your mind.

869
00:55:26.796 --> 00:55:37.827
In the countless hours I spent rocking my son to sleep, pushing his stroller, marveling at his sweaty little hands grasping a crayon, I worked diligently on my private project on accepting the sudden public downfall of my marriage.

870
00:55:38.888 --> 00:55:41.370
I just remember everyone's heart broke in that time.

871
00:55:41.390 --> 00:55:43.111
And of course, we don't know what it was like.

872
00:55:43.211 --> 00:55:47.494
Also, like, it feels like she's almost blaming herself for mothering too much and, like, neglect.

873
00:55:47.554 --> 00:55:48.815
It's like, that's not it at all.

874
00:55:48.975 --> 00:55:49.255
Yeah.

875
00:55:49.455 --> 00:55:53.758
And she was a psychologist and she can't really, she couldn't really speak about her private life because it would impact her.

876
00:55:53.778 --> 00:55:57.101
Like, I just remember the whole time being like, what the fuck, guys?

877
00:55:57.161 --> 00:55:58.682
It's actually still an open wound for me.

878
00:55:58.962 --> 00:55:59.382
Yeah.

879
00:55:59.402 --> 00:56:01.604
Like, I wrote this news this morning and I went straight back to that article.

880
00:56:01.824 --> 00:56:04.766
does also make, I feel like I need to go listen to her new song again.

881
00:56:05.106 --> 00:56:07.688
She just came out with a song that said, hate that I made you love me.

882
00:56:07.928 --> 00:56:10.249
And the lyrics are like, hate that I made you love me.

883
00:56:10.429 --> 00:56:12.731
Sorry if I made you my type.

884
00:56:12.751 --> 00:56:16.233
And at the time, again, when that song came out, I didn't really think much of it.

885
00:56:16.273 --> 00:56:19.215
And now I'm like in the context of all this, I was like, oh, fuck.

886
00:56:19.335 --> 00:56:22.577
It wasn't, I mean, I hope they're lifelong friends at least.

887
00:56:22.717 --> 00:56:25.058
I mean, I wonder if he'll make comment, frankly.

888
00:56:25.699 --> 00:56:26.019
Yeah.

889
00:56:26.039 --> 00:56:26.379
I doubt it.

890
00:56:26.719 --> 00:56:27.020
Yeah.

891
00:56:27.040 --> 00:56:27.420
I doubt it.

892
00:56:29.955 --> 00:56:32.216
Thank you so much for listening again this week.

893
00:56:32.656 --> 00:56:39.119
If you'd like to tap the bell, leave a review, follow us on Instagram, join our group, chat on Instagram, BSTES, besties.

894
00:56:39.139 --> 00:56:39.519
Besties.

895
00:56:39.539 --> 00:56:40.179
It's very clever.

896
00:56:40.379 --> 00:56:42.440
You'll get to vote on things and contribute and respond.

897
00:56:42.460 --> 00:56:43.400
We love feedback.

898
00:56:43.420 --> 00:56:44.661
Leave a comment on the show.

899
00:56:44.901 --> 00:56:45.921
And we'll see you next Tuesday.

900
00:56:46.121 --> 00:56:46.902
See you next Tuesday.
