WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.220 --> 00:00:07.662
Wagwan Internet, this is your captain speaking, Lester Nari, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

2
00:00:08.042 --> 00:00:12.383
We have a fantastic super episode this week with four stories.

3
00:00:13.363 --> 00:00:24.446
Quick breakdown, we're going to start out with, we may have figured out how to mass produce the camouflage that octopi use in their predatory adventures.

4
00:00:24.846 --> 00:00:25.846
This is out of UCSD.

5
00:00:30.808 --> 00:00:34.751
There's a little bit of beef happening between orcas and sharks.

6
00:00:34.891 --> 00:00:35.832
Yeah.

7
00:00:35.972 --> 00:00:41.577
And the paper sort of understands or breaks down this new hunting technique that orcas are participating in.

8
00:00:42.478 --> 00:00:44.840
That one's out of an institution we'll talk about in a second.

9
00:00:45.140 --> 00:00:50.425
The third story out of the University of Canada is about some shit.

10
00:00:51.050 --> 00:00:51.250
Yeah.

11
00:00:51.651 --> 00:00:55.213
They're going to start charging $80 for you to drink at Starbucks.

12
00:00:55.273 --> 00:00:55.714
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

13
00:00:55.914 --> 00:00:57.015
I'm not being facetious.

14
00:00:57.315 --> 00:00:59.357
It's coming to Beverly Hills Starbucks.

15
00:00:59.497 --> 00:01:00.277
Civet coffee.

16
00:01:00.678 --> 00:01:01.338
Yeah.

17
00:01:01.999 --> 00:01:03.100
Civet shitted coffee.

18
00:01:03.140 --> 00:01:04.221
Yeah.

19
00:01:04.441 --> 00:01:05.602
Again, not a joke.

20
00:01:05.682 --> 00:01:06.282
Not a joke.

21
00:01:06.622 --> 00:01:11.646
And we'll wrap it up with a fascinating story at UCLA where we...

22
00:01:12.887 --> 00:01:21.273
I'm not saying we're defying physics, but there's some new technology that we're using that makes our telescope see what we didn't think was possible.

23
00:01:21.293 --> 00:01:21.673
That's right.

24
00:01:21.773 --> 00:01:23.554
This is going to be a great episode.

25
00:01:23.975 --> 00:01:27.337
As always, this is From First Principles.

26
00:01:42.468 --> 00:01:42.908
My friend.

27
00:01:43.448 --> 00:01:43.948
How's it going?

28
00:01:44.569 --> 00:01:45.009
How are you?

29
00:01:45.749 --> 00:01:46.229
Welcome back.

30
00:01:46.709 --> 00:01:46.909
Yep.

31
00:01:47.189 --> 00:01:47.549
Thank you.

32
00:01:48.170 --> 00:01:50.610
We have a couple of housekeeping items.

33
00:01:51.170 --> 00:01:55.131
So number one, the engagement continues to be unbelievable.

34
00:01:55.151 --> 00:02:00.113
If you're watching this on YouTube, which is probably one of the only ways you're hearing me say this part of the show,

35
00:02:00.693 --> 00:02:03.334
There's going to be that little bell icon where you can subscribe.

36
00:02:03.754 --> 00:02:04.854
It's hugely helpful.

37
00:02:04.894 --> 00:02:07.835
We need to get the billionaires to get us in the algorithm.

38
00:02:08.335 --> 00:02:13.136
So if you hit that subscribe button, that's going to really help get this science education podcast to more people.

39
00:02:13.496 --> 00:02:20.397
We also are going to have our new website up soon, which will have all of the research paper links, all of the episode links.

40
00:02:20.897 --> 00:02:22.998
We may be launching some leaderboards.

41
00:02:23.678 --> 00:02:24.218
We'll see.

42
00:02:24.318 --> 00:02:26.699
But we're going to get that ready for the holiday season.

43
00:02:26.719 --> 00:02:28.239
So keep an eye out for that.

44
00:02:29.307 --> 00:02:32.410
But we're going to dive in and start with our first story.

45
00:02:33.230 --> 00:02:33.451
Yep.

46
00:02:34.011 --> 00:02:37.394
Out of UCSD, which is a biosynthesis story.

47
00:02:37.955 --> 00:02:38.275
Yes.

48
00:02:38.976 --> 00:02:40.337
About mass producing...

49
00:02:42.008 --> 00:02:48.252
What octopi or octopus use for camouflage, and this was out of nature biotechnology.

50
00:02:48.332 --> 00:02:49.012
Yeah.

51
00:02:49.232 --> 00:02:53.655
A lot of people love talking about, like, octopi are super intelligent.

52
00:02:53.695 --> 00:02:53.955
Yes.

53
00:02:54.035 --> 00:02:56.397
And everyone's like, oh, that's like an alien intelligence in the ocean.

54
00:02:56.497 --> 00:02:57.077
Yeah.

55
00:02:57.437 --> 00:03:03.781
And this has, I think, been something we've known about, but have just now made this next step of, like, how can we replicate?

56
00:03:03.801 --> 00:03:04.602
So let's talk about this story.

57
00:03:04.622 --> 00:03:04.782
Exactly.

58
00:03:04.802 --> 00:03:05.402
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

59
00:03:05.422 --> 00:03:06.183
The idea is...

60
00:03:06.883 --> 00:03:10.884
that we want to mass produce something called xanthomatin.

61
00:03:11.084 --> 00:03:11.364
Okay.

62
00:03:11.744 --> 00:03:13.485
It's nature's master of disguise.

63
00:03:14.145 --> 00:03:19.426
It's a pigment that is responsible for cephalopod camouflage.

64
00:03:19.806 --> 00:03:20.046
Okay.

65
00:03:20.066 --> 00:03:22.707
Cephalopods are your octopus, squid, cuttlefish.

66
00:03:23.007 --> 00:03:24.307
There you've got a photo.

67
00:03:24.727 --> 00:03:25.847
I can't see the octopus.

68
00:03:25.927 --> 00:03:28.628
The octopus are incredible at camouflage.

69
00:03:28.648 --> 00:03:29.848
Oh, there's an octopus in that photo?

70
00:03:29.868 --> 00:03:30.008
Yeah.

71
00:03:30.048 --> 00:03:32.629
In that red circle, there's an octopus in there.

72
00:03:32.649 --> 00:03:33.429
That's incredible.

73
00:03:33.449 --> 00:03:42.332
Yeah, but it's not only matched the texture, but the exact color characteristics of the coral reef or the ocean floor that's behind it.

74
00:03:42.412 --> 00:03:42.632
Yeah.

75
00:03:42.832 --> 00:03:48.434
And it's honestly defying any reason how good it is.

76
00:03:48.734 --> 00:03:55.776
This same pigment is also found in the coloration of butterflies and dragonflies, in the eyes of flies.

77
00:03:56.216 --> 00:03:58.037
So it's a ubiquitous biopigment.

78
00:03:58.940 --> 00:04:06.485
It's got a really high value because it's optoelectric, which means it can change its color with a response to electrochemical potential.

79
00:04:06.525 --> 00:04:14.791
So that's how the octopus can sometimes become super vibrant and then also at the same time become this, they look like a rock, right?

80
00:04:14.831 --> 00:04:20.074
They can be like pulsing with like strobe lights and at the same time do all of these other things.

81
00:04:20.555 --> 00:04:23.477
If we can replicate this biosynthesis…

82
00:04:24.137 --> 00:04:28.321
Then we can go to next generation electronics, like electrochromic displays.

83
00:04:28.761 --> 00:04:31.304
The main thing that's nice about this is it's biocompatible.

84
00:04:31.844 --> 00:04:36.248
So, I mean, one thing that I was thinking was like, what if you had like color changing tattoos?

85
00:04:36.448 --> 00:04:36.768
Yeah.

86
00:04:36.788 --> 00:04:39.911
Where like if you flex, then like it like just changes.

87
00:04:39.951 --> 00:04:40.492
It's, you know.

88
00:04:40.752 --> 00:04:41.052
Yeah.

89
00:04:41.092 --> 00:04:41.333
Yeah.

90
00:04:41.373 --> 00:04:43.314
Like it's like Avatar, dude.

91
00:04:43.414 --> 00:04:43.715
You know?

92
00:04:43.835 --> 00:04:44.796
It is like Avatar.

93
00:04:44.816 --> 00:04:45.176
Yeah.

94
00:04:45.196 --> 00:04:45.416
Yeah.

95
00:04:45.436 --> 00:04:46.237
That's a great reference.

96
00:04:46.297 --> 00:04:46.657
So, so.

97
00:04:47.518 --> 00:04:50.060
It would be really cool, right, if we could make a bunch of this.

98
00:04:50.260 --> 00:04:58.888
So when you say it's biocompatible, it means that it could interact with our, as biological beings, our system directly.

99
00:04:58.948 --> 00:05:01.350
Yeah, and it's not like toxic, right?

100
00:05:01.510 --> 00:05:01.750
Got it.

101
00:05:01.770 --> 00:05:03.972
Because it's already a sort of organic compound.

102
00:05:03.992 --> 00:05:04.773
That makes sense.

103
00:05:05.193 --> 00:05:10.318
The other thing is like it could be used in cosmetics if you have like multifunctional ingredients or like health and skincare.

104
00:05:10.358 --> 00:05:13.200
It's very UV protectant, these coatings.

105
00:05:13.220 --> 00:05:14.842
So if we can mass produce a lot of it.

106
00:05:15.262 --> 00:05:17.362
That would be really helpful for all sorts of industries.

107
00:05:17.742 --> 00:05:19.783
The bottleneck is a supply challenge, okay?

108
00:05:20.043 --> 00:05:22.843
You can't just go into biology and try to extract it.

109
00:05:22.883 --> 00:05:25.344
Like, how many butterflies are you going to kill, right?

110
00:05:25.464 --> 00:05:26.284
Or like octopus.

111
00:05:26.344 --> 00:05:26.944
It's just not.

112
00:05:27.064 --> 00:05:27.884
It's low-yielding.

113
00:05:27.924 --> 00:05:28.805
It's labor-intensive.

114
00:05:28.945 --> 00:05:30.685
And it's not ethical, right?

115
00:05:30.785 --> 00:05:31.645
It's not like mining.

116
00:05:31.865 --> 00:05:32.145
Yes.

117
00:05:32.205 --> 00:05:33.945
Which you could argue is also not ethical.

118
00:05:33.965 --> 00:05:34.586
Yeah, exactly.

119
00:05:34.606 --> 00:05:35.346
For different reasons.

120
00:05:35.506 --> 00:05:35.986
Exactly.

121
00:05:36.046 --> 00:05:41.527
So this breakthrough here reports the first successful industrial gram-scale biosynthesis.

122
00:05:42.227 --> 00:05:42.487
Okay.

123
00:05:42.567 --> 00:05:43.008
Understood.

124
00:05:43.128 --> 00:05:43.428
Got it.

125
00:05:43.468 --> 00:05:43.689
Yep.

126
00:05:43.969 --> 00:05:52.197
And the way that they did this scaling and this production is actually what I think the story is about.

127
00:05:52.237 --> 00:05:58.743
The real science is about because the way that they produce this is kind of a plug and play type thing.

128
00:05:58.803 --> 00:06:25.911
pathway that you could use to then manufacture other challenging biochemicals the analogy that this makes me think of is kind of like how crisper like was a platform for lack of a better term that had multiple use cases or functions yeah so that you could use it with and so there's a kind of a similar platform level discovery happening here yeah it's not specific to just this yeah this is kind of like uh yeah exactly this is kind of like a proof of concept mm-hmm

129
00:06:26.191 --> 00:06:31.535
that it can be done, but the way that they did it is what I think is really, really cool.

130
00:06:31.695 --> 00:06:31.915
Okay.

131
00:06:31.935 --> 00:06:33.556
Because here's the core challenge, okay?

132
00:06:34.137 --> 00:06:40.101
Whenever you want to install, the xanthanatin comes from some genomic pathway, right?

133
00:06:40.121 --> 00:06:45.865
There's some biochemical pathway in the octopus that creates xanthanatin, okay?

134
00:06:45.925 --> 00:06:53.030
The standard approach is to take that gene or take that bunch of genes that all contribute to this, stick that into a bacteria,

135
00:06:53.650 --> 00:06:55.372
And then have the bacteria produce it, right?

136
00:06:55.613 --> 00:06:55.753
Yep.

137
00:06:55.913 --> 00:06:57.796
You install a foreign gene and that's what you do.

138
00:06:58.056 --> 00:06:58.276
Got it.

139
00:06:58.597 --> 00:07:00.419
The problem is there's a metabolic burden.

140
00:07:01.260 --> 00:07:01.520
Okay.

141
00:07:02.061 --> 00:07:02.402
Because...

142
00:07:03.738 --> 00:07:15.623
If you've got this new pathway that's taking up a lot of energy, it's taking up a lot of the ATP, a lot of the carbon atoms even, and it confers no survival advantage, the bacteria doesn't want to do it.

143
00:07:16.464 --> 00:07:17.804
Right?

144
00:07:18.244 --> 00:07:20.365
Kind of sounds a little bit like the AI thing happening right now.

145
00:07:20.666 --> 00:07:21.166
Yeah, yeah.

146
00:07:21.186 --> 00:07:21.726
Exactly.

147
00:07:22.326 --> 00:07:22.867
Exactly.

148
00:07:23.267 --> 00:07:27.889
And, you know, you can actually, in terms of AI, you can use an analogy where it's like...

149
00:07:28.941 --> 00:07:35.604
All of the energy budget and the carbon budget of an organism is very strict.

150
00:07:35.864 --> 00:07:41.947
It's had billions of years of evolution to figure out this carbon atom has to go there, this carbon atom has to go there.

151
00:07:42.547 --> 00:07:46.368
This amount of ATP needs to be used for this and so on and so forth.

152
00:07:46.428 --> 00:07:49.510
It's had billions of years of evolution to figure that out.

153
00:07:49.690 --> 00:07:56.893
And now all of a sudden you install on this electrical grid like a giant server farm with no advantage.

154
00:07:56.913 --> 00:07:57.033
Right.

155
00:07:58.797 --> 00:08:06.724
The bacteria is not going to reroute all of its electricity, all of its energy, to make this server farm when it makes no sense, right?

156
00:08:06.744 --> 00:08:06.904
Right.

157
00:08:07.265 --> 00:08:09.707
In fact, if you have a bacterial population...

158
00:08:10.847 --> 00:08:14.270
You've got an evolutionary conflict because let's say a bunch of these bacteria are there.

159
00:08:14.730 --> 00:08:17.573
There's some mutation that cuts off supply to that server farm.

160
00:08:18.073 --> 00:08:22.477
That bacteria is going to grow faster because it's not wasting all that energy.

161
00:08:22.857 --> 00:08:28.542
And then in a population, it's kind of like antibiotic resistance where you've got a population that sort of...

162
00:08:30.402 --> 00:08:38.584
there's some bacteria that use up the resistance and actually are resistant to the antibiotic and some that aren't, right?

163
00:08:38.844 --> 00:08:40.905
And those are the ones that are going to go ahead.

164
00:08:41.145 --> 00:08:48.947
But in this case, it's like those that have budgeted well and have cut off this useless server farm are going to grow faster and then they're going to dominate the entire population.

165
00:08:48.967 --> 00:08:49.707
That makes total sense.

166
00:08:49.767 --> 00:08:49.967
Right?

167
00:08:50.467 --> 00:08:51.448
So that's the problem.

168
00:08:51.528 --> 00:08:53.428
It's like we're going against evolution.

169
00:08:53.448 --> 00:08:59.350
We're trying to engineer something, but there's all these cheaters around that are just going to do what they want to do.

170
00:08:59.852 --> 00:09:07.174
Because we're trying to use literal biology as the platform by which we generate this organic compound.

171
00:09:07.194 --> 00:09:07.434
Yeah.

172
00:09:07.814 --> 00:09:09.495
Like we're not using machines.

173
00:09:09.515 --> 00:09:09.775
No.

174
00:09:10.095 --> 00:09:11.035
And a factory.

175
00:09:11.055 --> 00:09:11.235
Yeah.

176
00:09:11.716 --> 00:09:13.696
It's we're literally using biology.

177
00:09:13.736 --> 00:09:13.896
Yeah.

178
00:09:14.356 --> 00:09:19.078
And there are these inherent properties underlying the evolutionary process of biology.

179
00:09:19.098 --> 00:09:19.258
Yeah.

180
00:09:19.378 --> 00:09:22.619
That are preventative factors from just being like maximize the output we care about.

181
00:09:23.139 --> 00:09:24.679
Because it's not purely create.

182
00:09:24.699 --> 00:09:26.440
The system is not purely materialized.

183
00:09:26.960 --> 00:09:46.093
controlled by like human engineering input exactly yeah yeah so so we need to figure out a way to to make the bacteria do what we want to do right okay and run the server farm that like gives us and like makes us um have this octopus superpower right

184
00:09:46.833 --> 00:09:50.115
And the strategy that they're using is this plug-and-play strategy.

185
00:09:50.555 --> 00:09:51.876
It came out of Nature Biotech.

186
00:09:52.056 --> 00:09:54.297
Growth-coupled biosynthesis.

187
00:09:54.477 --> 00:09:55.698
That's what they're calling it.

188
00:09:56.138 --> 00:09:59.540
What they're doing is actually quite a simple thing.

189
00:10:00.161 --> 00:10:01.742
They're creating a fitness advantage.

190
00:10:01.822 --> 00:10:06.324
They're creating an evolutionary advantage for those that are using the server farm.

191
00:10:06.564 --> 00:10:07.625
And what they're doing is...

192
00:10:08.668 --> 00:10:10.570
They've created what's called an oxotroph.

193
00:10:10.610 --> 00:10:17.537
It's an organism that has, through some kind of mutation, lost the ability to synthesize some essential ingredient.

194
00:10:17.697 --> 00:10:17.937
Okay.

195
00:10:18.038 --> 00:10:18.318
Okay?

196
00:10:18.758 --> 00:10:23.883
And the only way it can get this essential ingredient is if it runs the server farm.

197
00:10:24.404 --> 00:10:31.111
It runs this mechanical, biomechanical pathway that we've installed that gives it that ingredient to let it grow.

198
00:10:31.371 --> 00:10:36.654
That's that's so it's like like if the if if bacteria had ethics, this would be very.

199
00:10:36.994 --> 00:10:38.695
Yeah.

200
00:10:38.735 --> 00:10:39.456
Yeah.

201
00:10:40.216 --> 00:10:42.637
And I'm sure there's people out there that are making that argument.

202
00:10:42.697 --> 00:10:45.519
And I mean, I don't I don't have good arguments about that.

203
00:10:45.619 --> 00:10:47.620
OK, that's that's not my that's not the scope of this.

204
00:10:47.640 --> 00:10:50.982
Yeah, this episode of Oxitrophs.

205
00:10:51.162 --> 00:10:52.903
Yeah, but it's pretty insane.

206
00:10:53.323 --> 00:10:55.344
It's called synthetic oxotrophy, okay?

207
00:10:55.704 --> 00:10:58.246
So the idea is you have a pathway, right?

208
00:10:58.306 --> 00:11:06.170
And on the bottom, you've got your central pathway that grows the cell, that does metabolism and all that other stuff.

209
00:11:06.450 --> 00:11:07.910
And usually the input comes in.

210
00:11:08.130 --> 00:11:12.333
The input comes in from this side, and then it can fork into two paths.

211
00:11:12.353 --> 00:11:13.933
You've got, let's say, a bunch of carbon atoms.

212
00:11:14.254 --> 00:11:18.556
The carbon atoms can go to make more bacteria, or it can go to do this...

213
00:11:19.917 --> 00:11:23.521
Xanthomatin production, this engineered production.

214
00:11:24.462 --> 00:11:28.786
If you've got a choice, the bacteria is going to always pick grow myself.

215
00:11:28.886 --> 00:11:29.907
Evolution dictates that.

216
00:11:30.248 --> 00:11:36.714
But if it doesn't have a choice, it has to go through the server farm in order to get the carbon to grow itself.

217
00:11:36.995 --> 00:11:41.920
Then actually those that are better at doing that artificial production.

218
00:11:42.920 --> 00:11:45.664
pathway are going to have an evolutionary advantage.

219
00:11:45.684 --> 00:11:53.253
We've actually used evolution to our advantage now by creating a foreign Xanthamatin production pathway that...

220
00:11:54.356 --> 00:11:56.257
puts out a byproduct that it needs.

221
00:11:56.857 --> 00:11:58.418
This is interesting.

222
00:11:58.818 --> 00:12:12.145
We've hijacked our understanding of evolution to know that we need to create basically a need for the system to go down the path we want it to in order for it to be more evolutionarily advantaged against others.

223
00:12:12.365 --> 00:12:17.027
And that it's a little bit, it's interesting.

224
00:12:17.047 --> 00:12:18.048
It's interesting, dude.

225
00:12:18.108 --> 00:12:19.348
At least it's bacteria, man.

226
00:12:19.368 --> 00:12:19.769
At least...

227
00:12:20.729 --> 00:12:23.611
Let's hope they don't scale it up to larger eukaryotes.

228
00:12:23.631 --> 00:12:24.471
Yeah, exactly.

229
00:12:24.531 --> 00:12:25.512
But anyway.

230
00:12:26.172 --> 00:12:31.415
Yeah, so they're using this bacteria called Pseudomonas putida.

231
00:12:31.755 --> 00:12:33.676
It's a soil bacterium.

232
00:12:34.337 --> 00:12:41.040
It's got a robust chassis that has a lot of metabolic versatility, meaning that it can eat a bunch of different things.

233
00:12:41.080 --> 00:12:45.223
It's not like, you know, there's not one pathway that it can go through.

234
00:12:45.243 --> 00:12:45.603
It's not vegan.

235
00:12:45.623 --> 00:12:45.763
Yeah.

236
00:12:45.943 --> 00:12:46.823
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

237
00:12:47.143 --> 00:12:51.024
Even though it's like mostly glucose, it can like eat glucose in multiple different ways.

238
00:12:51.424 --> 00:12:51.684
Okay.

239
00:12:52.184 --> 00:13:00.866
And good natural tolerance to substrates and products, like anything that's coming out of that factory that we just installed.

240
00:13:00.886 --> 00:13:01.086
Yes.

241
00:13:01.526 --> 00:13:03.967
It's got a good tolerance for all sorts of stuff.

242
00:13:04.267 --> 00:13:05.987
So they're using this soil bacterium.

243
00:13:06.368 --> 00:13:09.788
And what they're doing is they're taking a molecule as hostage.

244
00:13:09.848 --> 00:13:10.829
It's the 510 MTHF.

245
00:13:13.705 --> 00:13:16.211
It's basically a C1 carrier.

246
00:13:16.251 --> 00:13:19.399
It's a carbon carrier for DNA and RNA.

247
00:13:19.499 --> 00:13:19.639
Mm-hmm.

248
00:13:20.330 --> 00:13:23.452
And for proteins, it can't make methionine without this thing.

249
00:13:23.592 --> 00:13:26.793
And it can't make the A and the G that's in our DNA.

250
00:13:27.153 --> 00:13:27.674
Okay.

251
00:13:27.714 --> 00:13:35.317
So without this pathway, it can no longer grow because it can't make DNA and it can't make proteins.

252
00:13:35.437 --> 00:13:39.239
We're creating almost this like artificial famine at the cell level.

253
00:13:39.459 --> 00:13:40.240
Exactly.

254
00:13:40.420 --> 00:13:46.483
And requiring it to go through this pathway that will generate an output we care about in order to be able to literally feed itself.

255
00:13:46.503 --> 00:13:46.903
Feed itself.

256
00:13:47.323 --> 00:13:48.645
Yeah, yeah.

257
00:13:48.765 --> 00:13:50.027
And then comes the production line.

258
00:13:50.067 --> 00:13:52.671
So now how does it actually make the food that it needs, right?

259
00:13:52.972 --> 00:13:56.617
What we do is we put a bunch of genes on a plasmid.

260
00:13:56.637 --> 00:13:59.862
A plasmid is a circular bit of DNA that we can use to...

261
00:14:02.144 --> 00:14:03.786
what the bacteria is producing.

262
00:14:03.826 --> 00:14:06.269
It's just foreign DNA that we can plug in.

263
00:14:06.309 --> 00:14:12.736
Now, these bacteria are already stressed out because they can't eat, so they're just trying to take in whatever help they can.

264
00:14:13.417 --> 00:14:17.182
We put in this plasmid that has genes on the plasmid to...

265
00:14:18.202 --> 00:14:21.104
create this artificial pathway, okay?

266
00:14:21.384 --> 00:14:32.753
Where on its way to creating xanthanatin, what it's going to do is create formate, which is a precursor for tryptophan and all of the other things that the bacterian needs.

267
00:14:32.773 --> 00:14:33.814
Right, right, right.

268
00:14:33.854 --> 00:14:34.214
Right?

269
00:14:34.254 --> 00:14:38.037
And the ultimate goal is you've got like a sole carbon source.

270
00:14:38.657 --> 00:14:39.937
which is through the factory.

271
00:14:39.977 --> 00:14:41.218
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

272
00:14:41.358 --> 00:14:44.499
You have to go, you have to pay the cost to be the boss.

273
00:14:44.519 --> 00:14:47.540
You literally, you have to go kiss the ring to survive.

274
00:14:47.600 --> 00:14:48.960
To survive, yeah.

275
00:14:49.180 --> 00:14:51.201
And even then, it wasn't so simple, okay?

276
00:14:51.281 --> 00:14:51.461
Okay.

277
00:14:51.481 --> 00:15:00.264
Because you have that single carbon source, but the bacteria still, the initial bug was it still needed supplemental glycine and L-tryptophan, which is...

278
00:15:01.284 --> 00:15:06.574
to kind of expensive ingredients that you need to give the bacteria in order to survive.

279
00:15:06.594 --> 00:15:07.756
You can't just give it glucose.

280
00:15:08.157 --> 00:15:12.164
So then what they did was they had another evolutionary lab there.

281
00:15:13.707 --> 00:15:14.768
In their little lab.

282
00:15:14.808 --> 00:15:15.028
Okay.

283
00:15:15.048 --> 00:15:19.192
What you do is you say, okay, I need you to make glycine, right?

284
00:15:19.613 --> 00:15:25.379
I'm going to give you a bunch of glycine at first, and I'm going to slowly wean off your entire population of glycine.

285
00:15:25.799 --> 00:15:30.944
And you're hoping that the bacteria just learn through some mutations because of this pressure.

286
00:15:31.324 --> 00:15:33.286
They're going to learn how to make their own glycine.

287
00:15:33.607 --> 00:15:33.787
Yep.

288
00:15:34.067 --> 00:15:36.450
Either learn how to make their own glycine or live without it.

289
00:15:36.590 --> 00:15:36.750
Yep.

290
00:15:37.070 --> 00:15:37.491
Okay?

291
00:15:37.531 --> 00:15:39.212
And that's exactly what ended up happening.

292
00:15:39.292 --> 00:15:40.354
Yep.

293
00:15:41.174 --> 00:15:45.138
The bacteria had a single amino acid change in the met K gene.

294
00:15:46.079 --> 00:15:48.702
And then all of a sudden they didn't need glycine.

295
00:15:48.762 --> 00:15:48.922
Right.

296
00:15:48.962 --> 00:15:50.524
Supplemental glycine.

297
00:15:50.584 --> 00:15:55.869
You were sort of basically through this providing withdrawal mechanism.

298
00:15:55.929 --> 00:15:56.170
Mm-hmm.

299
00:15:56.670 --> 00:15:56.850
Yeah.

300
00:15:57.872 --> 00:16:04.955
driving evolutionary progress to basically fulfill the gap of the withdrawal of providing it.

301
00:16:05.036 --> 00:16:05.276
Yeah.

302
00:16:05.356 --> 00:16:06.436
Directly to...

303
00:16:06.456 --> 00:16:07.117
Interesting.

304
00:16:07.137 --> 00:16:07.657
And it worked.

305
00:16:07.757 --> 00:16:08.717
And it worked, right?

306
00:16:08.957 --> 00:16:09.298
It worked.

307
00:16:09.338 --> 00:16:12.499
And what's cool about this is like this entire pathway, right?

308
00:16:12.519 --> 00:16:13.920
You've got the factory that's going in.

309
00:16:14.060 --> 00:16:14.580
Yes.

310
00:16:15.060 --> 00:16:23.745
The factory that they're using, that they've put in through this plasma, through this foreign DNA, the stuff that they got from the octopus and whatever, that can't just be...

311
00:16:24.585 --> 00:16:30.027
the native factory, because it has to have a byproduct that encourages the bacteria to actually work.

312
00:16:30.388 --> 00:16:33.389
So it has to be leaky in some sense.

313
00:16:33.769 --> 00:16:38.071
Not all of the carbon can go into the xanthanatine production.

314
00:16:38.751 --> 00:16:44.474
Some of it has to go out in order to create formate and then become this sole carbon source.

315
00:16:44.554 --> 00:16:45.774
Yep, that makes sense.

316
00:16:45.894 --> 00:16:54.438
So the factory has sort of two functions, both creating what we care about and also providing enough for the cell to continue to propagate.

317
00:16:54.438 --> 00:16:55.378
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

318
00:16:55.458 --> 00:17:00.561
And then those that ran the factory more actually had an advantage because they're the ones that could actually grow.

319
00:17:00.701 --> 00:17:00.881
Yep.

320
00:17:01.241 --> 00:17:02.222
Yeah, it's pretty crazy.

321
00:17:02.242 --> 00:17:03.362
That's really crazy.

322
00:17:03.482 --> 00:17:04.283
It's really crazy.

323
00:17:04.363 --> 00:17:12.126
And one of the ways that they actually showed that this was happening is an old school technique where you take an isotope of an atom.

324
00:17:12.587 --> 00:17:15.428
In this case, instead of carbon-12, they used carbon-13.

325
00:17:15.448 --> 00:17:16.468
Okay.

326
00:17:16.649 --> 00:17:23.152
And they fed it glucose with carbon-13 in a specific part of the glucose molecule, second from left or whatever.

327
00:17:23.172 --> 00:17:23.812
Yeah.

328
00:17:25.204 --> 00:17:30.271
And you can trace, because this carbon is a 13 instead of a 12, it's a little bit heavier.

329
00:17:30.291 --> 00:17:35.859
So you can trace how this carbon 13 goes through that entire chemical pathway, right?

330
00:17:35.879 --> 00:17:40.085
Because some of those molecules are going to be a little bit heavier than the other ones.

331
00:17:40.105 --> 00:17:40.406
Mm-hmm.

332
00:17:41.046 --> 00:17:43.488
Because it's got one extra neutron.

333
00:17:44.108 --> 00:17:49.693
And what you can show is atom by atom, the carbon traveled along this xanthamatin pathway.

334
00:17:49.953 --> 00:17:52.455
So through the factory, you can see, okay, now it's on the floor.

335
00:17:52.795 --> 00:17:53.415
Now it's there.

336
00:17:53.735 --> 00:17:55.217
Now it's getting this.

337
00:17:55.237 --> 00:18:02.782
There's an indicator that allows us to see the through line of the entire process to know that we're actually routing through the factory.

338
00:18:02.822 --> 00:18:03.382
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

339
00:18:03.402 --> 00:18:05.503
And you can confirm that this is what's happening, right?

340
00:18:05.523 --> 00:18:07.603
There's nothing else that's weird.

341
00:18:07.623 --> 00:18:20.887
And then finally, you know, you get this optimized ePuma xanthamatin strain that in 72 hours, you get a bunch of your pigment, a thousand times more than what you were getting earlier, or a lot less work.

342
00:18:21.107 --> 00:18:24.207
I mean, obviously, a lot of work into doing this, but now that you can do it.

343
00:18:24.227 --> 00:18:25.188
Now that you've created the system.

344
00:18:25.208 --> 00:18:28.589
Yeah, 2.4 grams per liter of xanthamatin powder.

345
00:18:29.009 --> 00:18:29.709
So this is...

346
00:18:30.655 --> 00:18:36.600
This is, you know, it's not only going to transform, let's say, the camouflage and the cosmetics.

347
00:18:36.640 --> 00:18:36.840
Yes.

348
00:18:36.981 --> 00:18:43.026
But I think what to me, what really struck was the way in which they did this.

349
00:18:43.727 --> 00:18:43.967
Right.

350
00:18:44.007 --> 00:18:45.008
This biosynthetic.

351
00:18:46.045 --> 00:19:07.912
hijacking of the metabolism right we now have sort of this plug and play platform again i don't mean to bring up the crisper analogy again but it's it's similar in the sense that other research teams are going to be able to take the insight from how you can basically facilitate biosynthesis yeah by this sort of like uh this

352
00:19:08.892 --> 00:19:13.903
pathway that advantages those that go through the factory that produce what you want it to.

353
00:19:14.564 --> 00:19:18.492
And you can apply that to any number of other of biosynthetic products.

354
00:19:19.626 --> 00:19:20.627
outputs that you're looking for.

355
00:19:20.647 --> 00:19:21.207
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

356
00:19:21.267 --> 00:19:24.069
And like, that's... That's the key insight for me.

357
00:19:24.169 --> 00:19:33.974
No, which, obviously... Yeah, I think... And, you know, you can accelerate production of antibiotics, plant alkalides, polyketides, all sorts of... That's fascinating.

358
00:19:33.994 --> 00:19:35.035
...biochemical things.

359
00:19:35.335 --> 00:19:38.317
And you can make the factory itself be different, right?

360
00:19:38.337 --> 00:19:41.659
Because all you need is something that releases a C1 molecule.

361
00:19:41.699 --> 00:19:43.080
It's a molecule with a single carbon.

362
00:19:43.100 --> 00:19:46.562
So it can be the formate pathway, the formaldehyde pathway...

363
00:19:47.062 --> 00:19:53.190
Who knows, even like CO2, you could hijack respiration itself in the mitochondria, right?

364
00:19:53.630 --> 00:19:56.774
It just leads to, I mean, that's probably a lot harder because there's so many more steps.

365
00:19:57.175 --> 00:19:57.315
But-

366
00:19:58.804 --> 00:20:13.260
Knowing that there's a stage one entry point to utilizing this as a methodology for biosynthesis means that there are any number of other use cases that with some amount of additional research are going to be unlocks.

367
00:20:13.360 --> 00:20:15.122
I mean, this is actually really, really cool.

368
00:20:15.142 --> 00:20:16.944
I thought it was really, really fascinating.

369
00:20:17.444 --> 00:20:17.685
Yeah.

370
00:20:18.245 --> 00:20:22.908
So we're going to be able to have makeup that's color changing.

371
00:20:23.128 --> 00:20:32.174
We're going to be able to have all your vehicle is going to be laced with octopi camouflage.

372
00:20:32.234 --> 00:20:34.596
So if you're driving at night and you want to go night mode.

373
00:20:34.616 --> 00:20:36.177
You have a plant-based display.

374
00:20:36.237 --> 00:20:36.777
I don't know.

375
00:20:36.797 --> 00:20:38.678
Like all sorts of stuff, dude.

376
00:20:38.718 --> 00:20:39.218
That's actually.

377
00:20:39.259 --> 00:20:39.559
Okay.

378
00:20:39.719 --> 00:20:41.900
So this is out of UCSD.

379
00:20:41.960 --> 00:20:46.243
They've now sort of created a platform for mass producing equipment.

380
00:20:46.483 --> 00:20:51.808
uh, octopus camouflage, but it is a platform that can now be extrapolated into other arenas.

381
00:20:51.828 --> 00:20:52.088
Yeah.

382
00:20:52.369 --> 00:20:54.510
Uh, this is a paper of nature biotechnology.

383
00:20:55.071 --> 00:20:57.653
Uh, that's a great, that's a great story.

384
00:20:57.673 --> 00:20:58.234
Yeah, that was cool.

385
00:20:58.274 --> 00:20:59.175
I thought that was really cool.

386
00:20:59.255 --> 00:21:00.096
Fascinating story.

387
00:21:00.356 --> 00:21:03.879
We're gonna move on to our story number two and our story number two.

388
00:21:04.520 --> 00:21:05.741
Now I'm going to, I'm going to do my best.

389
00:21:06.501 --> 00:21:17.285
Our story number two is out of an institution called the Protección y Conservación Palagasia Association Civil AC, as well as CSU Monterey Bay.

390
00:21:17.405 --> 00:21:17.665
Yes.

391
00:21:18.126 --> 00:21:20.907
And this is about the new hunting techniques of orcas.

392
00:21:20.967 --> 00:21:23.668
Like we said, there's a beef in the ocean, right?

393
00:21:24.028 --> 00:21:29.430
And so this research study is looking at these new hunting patterns of orcas and,

394
00:21:30.210 --> 00:21:33.692
And you thought this was interesting, and I'm curious why you put this in the show notes.

395
00:21:33.732 --> 00:21:33.952
Yeah.

396
00:21:34.012 --> 00:21:42.176
I want to know about – because we've seen the story about orcas attacking yachts in the Mediterranean or on the Amafi Coast, wherever.

397
00:21:43.156 --> 00:21:44.697
But it does seem like, again –

398
00:21:46.446 --> 00:21:53.252
we're in the ocean for two of our stories back to back, which is funny, but the intelligence aspect of this is interesting to me, but that's exactly right.

399
00:21:53.312 --> 00:21:53.532
Okay.

400
00:21:53.672 --> 00:21:54.593
That's exactly right.

401
00:21:54.633 --> 00:21:55.774
It's the intelligence aspect.

402
00:21:55.794 --> 00:21:56.675
That's interesting to me.

403
00:21:57.235 --> 00:21:59.397
And more than even the intelligence, it's,

404
00:22:00.270 --> 00:22:02.712
culture, I think, that we're getting at.

405
00:22:02.852 --> 00:22:03.272
Okay?

406
00:22:03.612 --> 00:22:08.136
And I'm going to get into that a little bit later, but that's the key word why I got interested.

407
00:22:08.156 --> 00:22:10.477
Because to me, I'm fascinated with human culture.

408
00:22:10.617 --> 00:22:10.798
Right.

409
00:22:11.038 --> 00:22:16.262
And it seems like there's a few papers that we're going to go through that talk about animal culture.

410
00:22:16.362 --> 00:22:16.622
Okay.

411
00:22:16.642 --> 00:22:18.463
And I find that just extremely fascinating.

412
00:22:18.483 --> 00:22:20.425
So the culture wars are not human-specific?

413
00:22:20.485 --> 00:22:21.265
No, no, no.

414
00:22:21.705 --> 00:22:24.548
In this case, they probably have a hegemonist culture.

415
00:22:25.248 --> 00:22:25.909
Compared to ours.

416
00:22:25.989 --> 00:22:27.790
But actually, no, that's not even true.

417
00:22:27.830 --> 00:22:32.515
Even the orcas have dialects among their populations, which is fascinating to think about.

418
00:22:32.535 --> 00:22:33.115
That's interesting.

419
00:22:33.135 --> 00:22:33.295
Right?

420
00:22:33.355 --> 00:22:36.518
That, like, different populations of orcas might not understand each other.

421
00:22:36.538 --> 00:22:38.060
If you're not on the side of the equator.

422
00:22:38.080 --> 00:22:42.123
Yeah, like the Pacific ones and the Atlantic ones are going to be like, why do you talk funny?

423
00:22:42.564 --> 00:22:44.285
He looks like me, but he talks really funny.

424
00:22:45.466 --> 00:22:46.407
You know?

425
00:22:46.607 --> 00:22:50.191
It's a groundbreaking paper, I think, from Higuera Rivas.

426
00:22:50.211 --> 00:22:50.311
Yeah.

427
00:22:51.870 --> 00:22:54.873
published in November this year, Frontiers in Marine Science.

428
00:22:56.355 --> 00:23:04.984
The idea is it's the first ever recorded orca predation on young great white sharks in Mexican waters off the coast of Baja, California.

429
00:23:05.164 --> 00:23:09.469
It's actually the second time that we've seen orcas attacking great whites.

430
00:23:09.569 --> 00:23:11.471
The first time was off the coast of South Africa.

431
00:23:11.611 --> 00:23:12.572
So it's pretty far away.

432
00:23:13.369 --> 00:23:16.290
But the technique is remarkably similar.

433
00:23:16.310 --> 00:23:16.711
Okay.

434
00:23:17.011 --> 00:23:17.291
Okay?

435
00:23:17.371 --> 00:23:18.651
Which is kind of weird.

436
00:23:18.892 --> 00:23:20.292
Meaning it transcends?

437
00:23:20.392 --> 00:23:21.013
It might be.

438
00:23:21.173 --> 00:23:21.833
Yeah, yeah.

439
00:23:22.133 --> 00:23:23.274
I'm not going to say that it does.

440
00:23:23.314 --> 00:23:24.614
And the paper does not claim that it does.

441
00:23:24.774 --> 00:23:25.094
Fair enough.

442
00:23:25.134 --> 00:23:26.215
But I just find it kind of funny.

443
00:23:26.335 --> 00:23:26.755
Fair enough.

444
00:23:27.415 --> 00:23:28.056
Right?

445
00:23:28.076 --> 00:23:29.196
But that's a tall order to make.

446
00:23:29.616 --> 00:23:33.018
But I will show later on that whales have done this.

447
00:23:33.318 --> 00:23:33.578
Okay.

448
00:23:33.618 --> 00:23:33.858
Okay?

449
00:23:34.239 --> 00:23:37.300
So, the first encounter was on August 15, 2020.

450
00:23:37.320 --> 00:23:37.540
They...

451
00:23:39.601 --> 00:23:43.284
Found a pot of five female orcas, one adult and four sub-adults.

452
00:23:43.904 --> 00:23:49.288
And what they did was the one orca pushes the shark up to the surface.

453
00:23:49.748 --> 00:23:51.990
Then another orca just like punches it.

454
00:23:52.790 --> 00:23:53.050
Okay.

455
00:23:53.070 --> 00:23:53.811
Causing bleeding.

456
00:23:54.171 --> 00:23:58.834
And then there's two others that swim around the shark to make it go upside down.

457
00:23:59.475 --> 00:24:04.879
And then once the shark is upside down, you get this thing called tonic immobility where the shark can't really move.

458
00:24:04.899 --> 00:24:05.259
Mm-hmm.

459
00:24:05.539 --> 00:24:10.402
And then while that shark can't really move, the other orcas then eat out its liver.

460
00:24:11.642 --> 00:24:14.584
And like they bring out its liver and that photo had the liver there.

461
00:24:14.984 --> 00:24:16.605
And then they share it with the kids.

462
00:24:17.995 --> 00:24:20.437
Oh, that are kind of waiting in the wings.

463
00:24:20.457 --> 00:24:21.037
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

464
00:24:21.077 --> 00:24:23.680
That have sort of been like a part of this, but not really.

465
00:24:23.740 --> 00:24:24.501
Right, right, right.

466
00:24:24.801 --> 00:24:25.081
Right?

467
00:24:25.181 --> 00:24:30.467
And then they had a second encounter two years later at the same exact spot, which suggests that it's predictable.

468
00:24:30.827 --> 00:24:32.108
It's seasonal hunting pattern.

469
00:24:32.549 --> 00:24:35.672
This time it was an adult male, adult female, two sub-adults, and a calf.

470
00:24:36.012 --> 00:24:40.656
And this time the kid did nothing, just like wait, until juvenile white shark again.

471
00:24:40.676 --> 00:24:41.157
Yeah.

472
00:24:41.577 --> 00:25:03.593
much smaller than the orca gets wrecked and then shark starts bleeding liver is exposed they eat the liver and only the liver because the liver is super nutrient rich and has a bunch of like you know bang for buck yeah and it's in per pound it's like it seems like they're trying to give it for the young yeah they're saving stuff for the young i thought that was really cool that's really interesting

473
00:25:03.893 --> 00:25:05.354
Yeah, it's a pretty cool toolkit.

474
00:25:05.374 --> 00:25:16.541
I mean, obviously they're on boats, but a lot of the video and a lot of the analysis comes from the video from DJI Phantom 4 Pro, which is one of those drones.

475
00:25:16.861 --> 00:25:18.623
So drone photography has really...

476
00:25:20.386 --> 00:25:40.464
revolutionized marine ecosystem behavioral science right and sightings because it looks like this is it was a multi-platform observation system there's surface aerial underwater and photo identification yeah yeah yeah it's a multimodal yeah yeah exactly exactly yeah yeah and and and the the trick that they're using is kind of interesting they're using they're

477
00:25:44.227 --> 00:25:49.131
people who go in the middle of sharks and they're like, nothing's going to happen because I'm going to poke its nose.

478
00:25:49.471 --> 00:25:53.975
I think a lot of times what they're trying to do is turn it upside down and then it just freezes.

479
00:25:54.295 --> 00:25:57.938
There's tricks, but it's cool that orcas have figured this out.

480
00:25:58.698 --> 00:25:59.319
Organically.

481
00:25:59.659 --> 00:26:01.541
Yeah, they're both apex predators, right?

482
00:26:01.901 --> 00:26:05.224
The juvenile sharks and the orcas.

483
00:26:05.384 --> 00:26:09.247
But because they're competing, one could argue that they're just trying to take out

484
00:26:10.138 --> 00:26:27.698
the other guy who's trying to compete for the same resources they're paying for the same food supply so exactly if you're eating my food like you're you're now my enemy yeah and these these orcas only go after juvenile white sharks i mean i was actually going to ask that because like clearly they're like going after the little ones yeah yeah because the older ones when they see an orca they just get the hell out of it they're like i'm

485
00:26:27.818 --> 00:26:47.621
out yeah because they i guess they know they they've got some learning capability and they don't return we've seen white sharks see an orca and then they don't return for like two or three years oh wow they'll just leave they're like i'm good and they're like oh so that's a bad neighborhood i'm not gonna spin the block here yeah yeah i'll find my seals elsewhere

486
00:26:48.682 --> 00:26:50.584
That's actually really interesting.

487
00:26:50.624 --> 00:26:50.844
Yeah.

488
00:26:51.424 --> 00:26:55.427
And so now, I mean, there's reports in South Africa where the original report happened.

489
00:26:55.908 --> 00:27:02.193
The seal population there has gone a little bit out of control because the great white sharks just, like, avoid that area.

490
00:27:02.333 --> 00:27:05.856
Because the orcas have kind of— Yeah, and the orcas, you know, they swim around all over the ocean.

491
00:27:05.916 --> 00:27:06.096
Right.

492
00:27:06.316 --> 00:27:09.178
And so there's not a constant supply of predatory pressure.

493
00:27:09.198 --> 00:27:10.079
If that makes sense.

494
00:27:10.239 --> 00:27:13.221
And the seals have kind of— Exploded.

495
00:27:13.281 --> 00:27:13.562
Yeah, yeah.

496
00:27:14.242 --> 00:27:15.743
Which is crazy to think about.

497
00:27:15.863 --> 00:27:29.013
And the reason why I was talking about this being something that reminded me of culture is because it reminded me of a study that came out a long time ago.

498
00:27:29.073 --> 00:27:29.994
There used to be...

499
00:27:30.174 --> 00:27:33.096
So culture is something that we know animals do.

500
00:27:33.136 --> 00:27:33.997
What does culture mean?

501
00:27:34.057 --> 00:27:42.043
Culture means that you've got effectively some type of strategy...

502
00:27:42.768 --> 00:27:48.857
That is conferred through behavior and through social constructs, like groups of individuals.

503
00:27:48.937 --> 00:27:50.499
It's not something that is innate.

504
00:27:50.719 --> 00:27:50.939
Right.

505
00:27:51.220 --> 00:27:53.323
It's something that's learned from your peers.

506
00:27:53.583 --> 00:27:53.763
Yep.

507
00:27:54.004 --> 00:27:57.108
So you get the benefit of their experience, right?

508
00:27:57.368 --> 00:27:57.509
Mm-hmm.

509
00:27:57.669 --> 00:27:57.889
Like...

510
00:27:58.710 --> 00:28:04.813
You don't have to live through an orca attack, for example, if you're a juvenile shark and you can learn through culture.

511
00:28:04.893 --> 00:28:08.515
I don't know if sharks can, but I'm just giving you the example here.

512
00:28:08.535 --> 00:28:11.157
You don't have to go through that firsthand experience.

513
00:28:11.337 --> 00:28:11.537
Yes.

514
00:28:11.697 --> 00:28:11.897
Right.

515
00:28:11.937 --> 00:28:13.058
Of like, oh, that was bad.

516
00:28:13.098 --> 00:28:13.298
Yes.

517
00:28:13.438 --> 00:28:15.099
No, your parents tell you that was bad.

518
00:28:15.119 --> 00:28:15.759
Don't do that.

519
00:28:15.799 --> 00:28:18.381
Sometimes we're just like, yeah, I'll try.

520
00:28:18.461 --> 00:28:21.262
But there's other things where like, OK, clearly that's like that.

521
00:28:21.642 --> 00:28:21.802
Right.

522
00:28:22.243 --> 00:28:22.443
So.

523
00:28:24.551 --> 00:28:25.612
So there's examples of this.

524
00:28:25.632 --> 00:28:28.052
For example, Shark Bay bottlenose dolphins.

525
00:28:28.413 --> 00:28:35.535
These are sponging techniques where they carry around a sponge, like one of those, like SpongeBob, like the natural sponges.

526
00:28:36.095 --> 00:28:41.697
And they use that to probe the seafloor and that protects their bottlenose.

527
00:28:41.737 --> 00:28:41.917
Right?

528
00:28:41.957 --> 00:28:43.517
When they're like foraging the seafloor.

529
00:28:43.537 --> 00:28:43.638
Yeah.

530
00:28:43.658 --> 00:28:45.638
Because it's almost like a mission.

531
00:28:45.758 --> 00:28:45.998
Yeah.

532
00:28:46.018 --> 00:28:48.119
And it's passed from mother to calf.

533
00:28:48.239 --> 00:28:50.040
So it's a vertical cultural transmission.

534
00:28:50.140 --> 00:28:50.440
Okay.

535
00:28:50.520 --> 00:28:50.680
Right?

536
00:28:50.700 --> 00:28:50.880
Yep.

537
00:28:50.900 --> 00:28:51.020
Yep.

538
00:28:51.320 --> 00:28:53.341
And then we've got Japanese macaques.

539
00:28:53.361 --> 00:28:54.722
They wash their sweet potatoes.

540
00:28:54.742 --> 00:28:55.423
A little macaque.

541
00:28:55.623 --> 00:28:57.784
Yeah, they wash their sweet potatoes before eating it.

542
00:28:58.425 --> 00:29:02.628
And that's something that's culturally passed down because like the youngsters see the elders doing it.

543
00:29:02.648 --> 00:29:05.089
They're like, okay, that's the way to eat this thing, right?

544
00:29:05.510 --> 00:29:06.070
Yep.

545
00:29:06.310 --> 00:29:10.553
So orcopods, they've shown to have cultural things.

546
00:29:10.793 --> 00:29:13.755
For example, complex, stable vocal dialects that I was talking about.

547
00:29:14.075 --> 00:29:16.237
Almost like languages where different geographic...

548
00:29:16.697 --> 00:29:42.938
populations will have different dialects and those are obviously learned socially there was one paper that is honestly one of my favorite papers um in animal behavior okay it was in 2021 out of the royal society what it did was analyze 19th century american whaler log books in the north pacific ocean okay okay and these whalers kept meticulous lab notes when they went out in the field to try to kill sperm whales okay love to see it

549
00:29:43.318 --> 00:29:46.579
And back then, I think sperm whales were used for all sorts of stuff.

550
00:29:46.699 --> 00:29:49.400
Not only their meat, but this was before electricity.

551
00:29:49.520 --> 00:29:49.740
Right.

552
00:29:49.780 --> 00:29:52.781
So all of the oil was being used to light up our streets.

553
00:29:52.981 --> 00:30:00.424
And that actually caused one of the big epidemics of near extinction for these whales all across the ocean.

554
00:30:00.584 --> 00:30:01.084
Right.

555
00:30:01.304 --> 00:30:03.044
And the process of whaling was as follows.

556
00:30:03.064 --> 00:30:07.606
In the 18th, 19th century, you'd go with your ship, which was...

557
00:30:09.551 --> 00:30:16.957
powered by a sail, you'd spot some whales, and then you'd go out down in these duffies and try to harpoon them, the whales.

558
00:30:17.197 --> 00:30:17.378
Yes.

559
00:30:17.458 --> 00:30:20.340
And then if you harpooned one, you'd bring it back to the ship for extraction.

560
00:30:20.440 --> 00:30:20.640
Yes.

561
00:30:20.741 --> 00:30:20.981
Okay.

562
00:30:22.262 --> 00:30:31.310
What they noticed was whenever they went to a certain spot, the success rate plummeted from when they first got there.

563
00:30:32.988 --> 00:30:33.789
Okay.

564
00:30:33.809 --> 00:30:34.269
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

565
00:30:34.289 --> 00:30:35.630
So they go to a certain spot.

566
00:30:35.691 --> 00:30:40.054
On the top, you've got a map of all of the spots that they've been in the North Pacific.

567
00:30:40.074 --> 00:30:41.676
This is between Japan and America.

568
00:30:42.496 --> 00:30:47.541
And there you've got the rate at which you're able to kill whales.

569
00:30:47.581 --> 00:30:47.801
Yes.

570
00:30:48.722 --> 00:30:49.022
Okay?

571
00:30:49.122 --> 00:30:49.342
Yes.

572
00:30:49.803 --> 00:30:52.325
And the rate was diminishing.

573
00:30:52.885 --> 00:30:54.167
Now, there's four hypotheses.

574
00:30:54.187 --> 00:30:54.467
Okay.

575
00:30:55.434 --> 00:30:55.875
Okay?

576
00:30:55.935 --> 00:30:57.277
There's four ways we can think about it.

577
00:30:57.837 --> 00:31:01.242
One is just the first guys who went to that particular spot were just good at it.

578
00:31:01.262 --> 00:31:02.464
They were LeBron and you're not LeBron.

579
00:31:02.484 --> 00:31:02.985
Yeah, yeah.

580
00:31:03.085 --> 00:31:11.457
And so everyone, that doesn't make sense because we have the logbooks from the same whalers that go to other spots like the North Atlantic and they get the baseline rate.

581
00:31:12.297 --> 00:31:13.778
The fact that this is new, right?

582
00:31:13.818 --> 00:31:14.879
This is the North Pacific.

583
00:31:15.199 --> 00:31:20.122
So this is a harvesting ground for whales that hasn't been extracted before, right?

584
00:31:20.322 --> 00:31:23.364
Whaling has been around for centuries in the North Atlantic, right?

585
00:31:23.664 --> 00:31:24.965
Europeans have been at it forever.

586
00:31:25.245 --> 00:31:25.845
Yes.

587
00:31:26.166 --> 00:31:27.486
So that's the first hypothesis.

588
00:31:27.506 --> 00:31:28.527
The first whalers were good.

589
00:31:28.807 --> 00:31:29.428
That's not the case.

590
00:31:29.448 --> 00:31:29.528
Yep.

591
00:31:30.857 --> 00:31:41.502
Second one is the first whales that were taken out were these juvenile sort of slower, let's say, or they weren't very good at getting away.

592
00:31:42.322 --> 00:31:45.243
That also is something that we can model, right?

593
00:31:45.303 --> 00:31:52.186
We can model, we can have some type of population model that says, okay, like the slower whales in a population die out.

594
00:31:52.546 --> 00:31:56.048
How would the rate decrease then if it's some sort of random strategy?

595
00:31:56.088 --> 00:31:56.288
Right.

596
00:31:56.348 --> 00:31:56.628
Okay.

597
00:31:56.668 --> 00:31:56.908
Okay.

598
00:31:57.008 --> 00:32:11.458
The third one is the whales learn from personal experience, meaning I'm part of a pod that had this crazy thing happen to me where a bunch of our pod got shot in the ocean and then, and then got extracted.

599
00:32:11.798 --> 00:32:14.400
And so now I'm never going to have that happen to my pod again.

600
00:32:14.500 --> 00:32:17.622
This is literally, I think the plot of the second or third avatar movie.

601
00:32:17.682 --> 00:32:18.182
Yeah.

602
00:32:18.222 --> 00:32:18.602
Yeah.

603
00:32:18.702 --> 00:32:19.523
One of those.

604
00:32:19.663 --> 00:32:24.806
Like it's one of them where the ocean thingies and then they were getting hunted and then they didn't go back to the spot.

605
00:32:24.826 --> 00:32:25.147
Exactly.

606
00:32:25.247 --> 00:32:25.727
Exactly.

607
00:32:25.987 --> 00:32:27.788
Because that's where we lost all our people.

608
00:32:28.028 --> 00:32:28.468
Exactly.

609
00:32:28.788 --> 00:32:31.048
And then the fourth one is the best one.

610
00:32:31.509 --> 00:32:31.749
Okay.

611
00:32:31.769 --> 00:32:32.989
That I want to be true.

612
00:32:33.089 --> 00:32:33.829
I'll just be honest.

613
00:32:33.849 --> 00:32:34.149
Okay.

614
00:32:34.309 --> 00:32:38.250
And it's that the whales learned between unit learning.

615
00:32:38.330 --> 00:32:43.152
Meaning, there was a pod that I ran into yesterday that had that experience.

616
00:32:43.192 --> 00:32:45.432
They told me about it, and they told me how to get away.

617
00:32:45.993 --> 00:32:48.153
The idea is you're on the block.

618
00:32:48.213 --> 00:32:49.433
Your block is block two.

619
00:32:50.094 --> 00:32:53.855
But the cats from block one pull up, and they're like, yo, yesterday on block one...

620
00:32:55.255 --> 00:32:58.058
This happened, so y'all watch out.

621
00:32:58.198 --> 00:32:58.458
Yeah.

622
00:32:58.839 --> 00:33:05.565
And so there's a transferring socially of learning without having to physically or literally experience.

623
00:33:05.745 --> 00:33:06.906
And that's the culture part.

624
00:33:07.007 --> 00:33:07.687
That's the culture part.

625
00:33:07.707 --> 00:33:08.989
That's the culture part, right?

626
00:33:09.169 --> 00:33:11.411
So the question is, do the whales have culture?

627
00:33:11.531 --> 00:33:13.413
Is the fourth hypothesis true?

628
00:33:13.433 --> 00:33:13.533
Yeah.

629
00:33:13.773 --> 00:33:14.394
or any of these.

630
00:33:14.654 --> 00:33:16.135
And what they did was modeling.

631
00:33:16.275 --> 00:33:21.599
They did mathematical modeling to see how that rate would decrease based on these three hypotheses.

632
00:33:21.780 --> 00:33:28.025
And the one that had the best fit was the one where the whales adapted, learned, and shared defensive knowledge

633
00:33:29.043 --> 00:33:30.843
Too rapidly for genetic evolution.

634
00:33:31.003 --> 00:33:42.526
The point is the rate of decrease of efficacy of the hunting was so steep that it couldn't have just been from personal experience because there wasn't enough volume for personal experience to be the trigger.

635
00:33:42.726 --> 00:33:47.067
There's not enough juveniles in the population spread of whales for it to just be the juveniles.

636
00:33:47.487 --> 00:33:51.168
And it can't be that they're just that good because in other areas they were doing just fine.

637
00:33:51.428 --> 00:33:55.909
And so these other three things don't account for the rate of decrease in efficacy.

638
00:33:59.070 --> 00:34:21.913
crazy that okay when you got these whales and here's what they would do um usually they do defensive huddling okay so if orcas come up yeah what you do is like kind of what elephants do where you huddle around your young and you try to bite the people around that slows you down and that is super effective ineffective against boats right you come up on a boat they're already slowed down great just you know go at it so

639
00:34:22.213 --> 00:34:24.154
Pretty soon they realized that's not going to work.

640
00:34:24.235 --> 00:34:30.639
And in their whaler journals, they showed that the whales abandoned that traditional defensive huddling and they went for new tactics.

641
00:34:30.679 --> 00:34:35.283
For example, if they know which way the wind is, just swim opposite direction of the wind.

642
00:34:35.543 --> 00:34:36.804
Oh, because they know we can't.

643
00:34:38.205 --> 00:34:44.770
They figured out that these guys can only go in the direction of the wind with their big ship.

644
00:34:45.537 --> 00:34:45.737
Right.

645
00:34:45.937 --> 00:34:47.858
And so they just like swim in the other direction.

646
00:34:48.198 --> 00:34:51.680
Evasive deep diving resurface like many miles away.

647
00:34:51.740 --> 00:34:51.920
Yep.

648
00:34:52.360 --> 00:34:53.061
Away from the ship.

649
00:34:53.181 --> 00:34:53.361
Yep.

650
00:34:54.101 --> 00:34:54.321
Right.

651
00:34:54.741 --> 00:34:57.303
And some people just started doing aggressive defensing.

652
00:34:57.343 --> 00:34:59.984
If like they were cornered, they would just like start attacking.

653
00:35:00.284 --> 00:35:02.025
You know, the best defense is the attack.

654
00:35:02.065 --> 00:35:02.185
Yeah.

655
00:35:02.325 --> 00:35:09.932
You know what's funny is the social learning from this era might still be persisting, which is why the yachts are getting attacked.

656
00:35:09.952 --> 00:35:11.254
Yes, I was going to say.

657
00:35:11.274 --> 00:35:13.336
And that's the final photo that we have.

658
00:35:13.356 --> 00:35:14.016
That's right.

659
00:35:14.096 --> 00:35:19.422
It's like now we've got this thing coming back where the orcas are now all around Spain and Portugal.

660
00:35:19.442 --> 00:35:21.984
They're just like attacking yachts, right?

661
00:35:22.284 --> 00:35:26.869
And it's become like kind of an epidemic of orca on yacht violence, right?

662
00:35:26.889 --> 00:35:26.969
Yep.

663
00:35:27.329 --> 00:35:28.990
Yep, and we don't have harpoons on those yachts.

664
00:35:29.030 --> 00:35:31.530
Yeah, and that also looks like it's a cultural thing.

665
00:35:31.890 --> 00:35:35.371
Because it started one day, and then everyone started doing it.

666
00:35:35.451 --> 00:35:41.413
All across the North Sea, all across Portugal, through the Straits of Gibraltar.

667
00:35:41.493 --> 00:35:44.834
I wouldn't be surprised if not all of the Mediterranean is starting it.

668
00:35:45.154 --> 00:35:53.817
And what's interesting is, at the time of when whaling was happening, you have sort of a reason for the behavior change that's identifiable.

669
00:35:53.857 --> 00:35:54.097
Yeah.

670
00:35:54.890 --> 00:36:00.314
It's not necessarily obvious or clear in this recent... Yeah, it's not necessarily obvious.

671
00:36:00.514 --> 00:36:09.421
There was one hypothesis that was saying that, like, oh, because we have, like, so much tuna in the ocean now, because we've curbed fishing, that the orcas are just getting bored.

672
00:36:09.862 --> 00:36:11.243
And so with their time, they're doing this.

673
00:36:11.383 --> 00:36:12.063
I don't buy that.

674
00:36:12.163 --> 00:36:13.845
I think that's a fisherman lobby.

675
00:36:14.565 --> 00:36:18.748
Like paying some special interest group to be like, hey, we have too much fish.

676
00:36:19.168 --> 00:36:20.749
And so we can just like start fishing again.

677
00:36:21.530 --> 00:36:26.073
Another one that I thought was pretty likely was that like they've recognized that boats are fishermen boats.

678
00:36:26.493 --> 00:36:29.255
And the same reason why you go after the shark is why you go after the boat.

679
00:36:29.315 --> 00:36:32.217
It's a competing predator that's like depleting my resources.

680
00:36:32.377 --> 00:36:32.878
That makes sense.

681
00:36:32.898 --> 00:36:36.140
Like I was going up against a school of tuna and now half of them are gone.

682
00:36:36.200 --> 00:36:37.261
And there was a boat right there.

683
00:36:37.321 --> 00:36:37.601
Yeah.

684
00:36:37.641 --> 00:36:38.662
So like screw that guy.

685
00:36:38.682 --> 00:36:38.822
Yeah.

686
00:36:38.982 --> 00:36:39.984
Yeah, exactly.

687
00:36:40.004 --> 00:36:41.046
That makes a lot of sense.

688
00:36:41.086 --> 00:36:42.409
That makes a lot more sense to me.

689
00:36:43.311 --> 00:36:49.623
But I just think like these kinds of stories are so interesting at,

690
00:36:50.688 --> 00:36:58.253
And so capable of sort of putting humans in their place when it comes to uniqueness.

691
00:36:58.533 --> 00:36:58.733
Yeah.

692
00:36:58.853 --> 00:37:02.795
Like we always think that like, oh, culture is very unique to us, right?

693
00:37:02.835 --> 00:37:03.396
Cognition.

694
00:37:03.436 --> 00:37:04.557
Cognition is not unique.

695
00:37:04.777 --> 00:37:05.537
Yep.

696
00:37:06.037 --> 00:37:10.780
More and more, I mean, I think it's pretty obvious that consciousness is not unique to humans.

697
00:37:10.840 --> 00:37:12.281
I think a lot of people out there agree.

698
00:37:12.601 --> 00:37:15.143
And now culture is not unique, right?

699
00:37:15.243 --> 00:37:15.423
Right.

700
00:37:15.523 --> 00:37:16.584
Feelings are not unique.

701
00:37:16.604 --> 00:37:17.905
We can see animals in pain.

702
00:37:17.925 --> 00:37:18.065
Right.

703
00:37:18.085 --> 00:37:18.265
Right.

704
00:37:18.525 --> 00:37:23.066
It's, yeah, it's quite humbling that like, and we've got now scientific backing.

705
00:37:23.086 --> 00:37:23.967
Yeah, right, right.

706
00:37:24.087 --> 00:37:24.547
For that.

707
00:37:24.867 --> 00:37:30.689
I mean, this is the whole, there's a whole sort of culture of no longer eating like calamari.

708
00:37:31.249 --> 00:37:34.350
Because it's like the idea is like you have this highly intelligent conscious.

709
00:37:34.470 --> 00:37:34.670
Yeah.

710
00:37:34.690 --> 00:37:34.790
Yeah.

711
00:37:35.390 --> 00:38:02.557
creature yeah and there's now this like ethical sort of piece to this like well like you know we don't eat other humans yeah yeah generally speaking generally speaking yeah um i mean dude it's it's interesting to me i mean i i'm i'm a selfish person so i will eat the calamari because it tastes so good but at the same time i will acknowledge that like yeah it's there's it's iffy here and no it's it but this is i think what's interesting is like we're now

712
00:38:03.937 --> 00:38:09.349
getting more research studies, particularly because we also, like, again, have, like, this multimodal

713
00:38:10.298 --> 00:38:18.100
systems that are able to sort of track in ways where we get a more robust data set where we can now draw more deeper conclusions because of that.

714
00:38:18.300 --> 00:38:25.662
And it's, it's not surprising to anyone who watched free Willy that orcas are incredibly intelligent.

715
00:38:25.682 --> 00:38:26.503
That's exactly right.

716
00:38:26.523 --> 00:38:27.463
Potentially have culture.

717
00:38:27.483 --> 00:38:38.446
It's why, or if you've seen that documentary about the sea world or that's just like grueling, I haven't visited a single aquatic theme park after watching that.

718
00:38:39.286 --> 00:38:40.928
You know how they're solving... That was messed up.

719
00:38:40.968 --> 00:38:44.913
You know how they're solving their... Because they're clearly struggling for business.

720
00:38:45.073 --> 00:38:56.506
But the SeaWorld or whatever the brand is in San Diego, this summer they had a summer series of concerts with like...

721
00:38:57.267 --> 00:39:00.991
Bow Wow and Lil' Camp, like all these OG.

722
00:39:01.191 --> 00:39:01.631
Okay.

723
00:39:01.791 --> 00:39:07.817
So you have like these rappers like on the stage that's on the water, like at SeaWorld.

724
00:39:07.837 --> 00:39:08.218
Oh, God.

725
00:39:08.678 --> 00:39:09.259
Sold out.

726
00:39:09.519 --> 00:39:10.219
Yeah.

727
00:39:10.240 --> 00:39:11.581
On Waka Faka Flame.

728
00:39:11.621 --> 00:39:12.181
Like it was –

729
00:39:13.042 --> 00:39:14.043
It did look quite fun.

730
00:39:14.363 --> 00:39:19.446
And so, look, if you want to change the venue from holding animals in captivity to a concert venue.

731
00:39:19.606 --> 00:39:19.927
Oh, yeah.

732
00:39:19.967 --> 00:39:22.368
Then, okay, I thought they were doing it with the animals.

733
00:39:22.408 --> 00:39:23.209
No, no, no, no, no.

734
00:39:23.249 --> 00:39:24.289
I was like, geez.

735
00:39:24.910 --> 00:39:25.830
Waka Flocka.

736
00:39:25.951 --> 00:39:26.591
I know you got.

737
00:39:26.611 --> 00:39:27.652
You got Orca flipping over.

738
00:39:27.672 --> 00:39:27.892
Yeah.

739
00:39:28.432 --> 00:39:31.334
Because they have no, they're not getting people to come for the other stuff.

740
00:39:31.354 --> 00:39:31.775
Do that.

741
00:39:31.795 --> 00:39:32.515
I'll come to those.

742
00:39:32.595 --> 00:39:33.956
I think that's a great off-ramp.

743
00:39:34.117 --> 00:39:34.337
Yeah.

744
00:39:34.417 --> 00:39:38.320
We would love to see more summer series and converting these places into concert venues.

745
00:39:38.360 --> 00:39:39.781
Fantastic.

746
00:39:40.201 --> 00:39:40.902
Story number two.

747
00:39:40.942 --> 00:39:41.602
That was a great one.

748
00:39:41.622 --> 00:39:42.743
Yeah, it was cool.

749
00:39:42.863 --> 00:39:45.025
Frontiers in Marine Science.

750
00:39:45.145 --> 00:39:49.008
We're moving on to our third story, which is about... Shh.

751
00:39:49.248 --> 00:40:15.253
civet shitted coffee yeah no literally literally shit out coffee if you go to starbucks and you think inflation has made your coffee expensive now there's 80 dollar cups of coffee yeah it's coffee it's shit and no literally i don't know about the taste but it's literally shit coffee that's coming from the shit of something called a civet this is out of the university of kerala and it was in nature scientific reports

752
00:40:16.173 --> 00:40:24.596
Um, I, when you put this in the show notes, the like title was, you know, Kopi Luwak, the paradoxical luxury of biological processing.

753
00:40:24.696 --> 00:40:24.936
Yeah.

754
00:40:25.356 --> 00:40:26.577
And I had not yet.

755
00:40:27.157 --> 00:40:27.597
Yeah, no.

756
00:40:27.637 --> 00:40:28.838
And then I had a footnote.

757
00:40:29.098 --> 00:40:30.078
Civit shitted coffee.

758
00:40:30.118 --> 00:40:31.298
And they're like, is that shitted?

759
00:40:31.358 --> 00:40:32.159
Like, like shit.

760
00:40:32.279 --> 00:40:33.059
And I was like, no, no.

761
00:40:33.079 --> 00:40:34.760
Like the biological term.

762
00:40:37.821 --> 00:40:43.383
So tell me about, I mean, so I think I've literally seen this on some billionaire podcast about how they've moved to Civit coffee.

763
00:40:43.403 --> 00:40:43.763
Cause it's.

764
00:40:44.472 --> 00:40:46.979
Except yeah, apparently it's, uh, apparently it's exceptional.

765
00:40:47.219 --> 00:40:49.626
Um, it's a bizarre luxury drink costs 30 to $75 a cup.

766
00:40:49.646 --> 00:40:49.766
Um,

767
00:40:53.213 --> 00:41:17.914
1300 per pound you see the you see the coffee and it's all agglomerated you know in a little clump that's because it came out of of the of the anus of a civet okay i'm sorry to our uh listeners but i really i saw this and i was like we try our best to be a pg-13 rated yeah but this is biological it's literal it's literal i'm not i'm not

768
00:41:18.394 --> 00:41:21.255
I'm not comparing something to shit.

769
00:41:21.355 --> 00:41:22.176
It's literal.

770
00:41:22.316 --> 00:41:23.196
Yeah.

771
00:41:23.256 --> 00:41:24.137
It's literal feces.

772
00:41:24.337 --> 00:41:25.437
It's literal feces.

773
00:41:25.457 --> 00:41:25.557
Okay.

774
00:41:25.577 --> 00:41:25.797
All right.

775
00:41:26.277 --> 00:41:26.678
All right.

776
00:41:26.698 --> 00:41:27.498
Let's get serious.

777
00:41:27.578 --> 00:41:27.918
All right.

778
00:41:27.938 --> 00:41:30.919
So the market value is $7 billion for this.

779
00:41:31.800 --> 00:41:34.981
Civic Coffee, the real chemistry behind this bizarre luxury drink.

780
00:41:35.021 --> 00:41:36.542
And that's what this paper is about.

781
00:41:36.642 --> 00:41:36.802
Right.

782
00:41:36.882 --> 00:41:43.625
It's about describing the chemistry behind why when coffee beans go through the gastrointestinal tract...

783
00:41:44.370 --> 00:41:48.453
of this animal, they taste better when they come out of the other side.

784
00:41:49.194 --> 00:41:49.434
Okay.

785
00:41:49.514 --> 00:41:52.557
It's a, it's, it's a coffee called kopi luwak.

786
00:41:53.017 --> 00:41:56.520
It began in the 18th century because classic colonialism.

787
00:41:56.620 --> 00:41:56.980
Okay.

788
00:41:57.120 --> 00:42:02.324
The Dutch East Indies, which is now Indonesia, they had coffee plantation workers.

789
00:42:02.785 --> 00:42:06.788
The plantation workers were forbidden from drinking the coffee that they were collecting.

790
00:42:06.808 --> 00:42:06.948
Okay.

791
00:42:07.108 --> 00:42:07.368
Okay.

792
00:42:07.508 --> 00:42:07.789
Okay.

793
00:42:08.189 --> 00:42:09.951
Because, you know, white people.

794
00:42:10.091 --> 00:42:11.092
Yeah.

795
00:42:11.152 --> 00:42:19.619
So instead they collected the undigested beans from the droppings of Asian palm civets to drink those.

796
00:42:20.279 --> 00:42:26.925
And then when the white plantation owners found out and they tried some, they're like, oh, this actually tastes really good.

797
00:42:27.005 --> 00:42:33.431
And it became a new expensive export for the Dutch because the Dutch back then were always after getting rich.

798
00:42:33.711 --> 00:42:39.653
This is so funny because there's so many things in like oxtail being $30 a pound or whatever now.

799
00:42:40.073 --> 00:42:42.494
Kale salads being $20.

800
00:42:42.694 --> 00:42:47.756
Oxtail and kale were eaten because it was cheap and it was the stuff no one else wanted.

801
00:42:47.896 --> 00:42:48.956
And now it's been repressed.

802
00:42:48.976 --> 00:42:51.337
Yeah, dude, I think it's the same with like IPAs.

803
00:42:51.757 --> 00:42:54.558
Honestly, there's no one who actually enjoys IPAs.

804
00:42:55.098 --> 00:42:55.298
All right?

805
00:42:55.559 --> 00:42:56.039
No one can...

806
00:42:56.879 --> 00:42:59.960
convince me in a blind tasting that they like IPAs.

807
00:43:00.020 --> 00:43:00.300
Okay.

808
00:43:00.840 --> 00:43:03.321
But they need everyone else to know that they drink.

809
00:43:03.701 --> 00:43:04.001
Anyways.

810
00:43:04.321 --> 00:43:10.743
So I first actually heard about it in the bucket list movie with Jack Nicholson and Morgan Freeman.

811
00:43:10.763 --> 00:43:15.165
This is one of the things that, that he wanted to drink before he died of cancer.

812
00:43:16.093 --> 00:43:21.015
So the civet is this Asian common palm civet.

813
00:43:21.135 --> 00:43:22.696
It looks kind of like a raccoon to me.

814
00:43:22.836 --> 00:43:25.357
It looks like a hyena mixed with a raccoon.

815
00:43:25.637 --> 00:43:25.878
Yeah.

816
00:43:26.418 --> 00:43:35.482
And it consumes the ripest berries, and the beans pass through in about 12 hours, and they become 10 times the value somehow.

817
00:43:36.682 --> 00:43:47.125
And the digestive process, it's thought that the digestive process modifies the beans' chemical composition, refining flavor precursors, and giving a je ne sais quoi.

818
00:43:47.145 --> 00:43:49.886
And they're another awesome civet dropping.

819
00:43:50.386 --> 00:43:53.707
This is funny that this episode we did our first story on biosynthesis.

820
00:43:53.727 --> 00:43:55.987
Yeah, this is another kind of biosynthesis.

821
00:43:56.047 --> 00:43:56.508
Exactly.

822
00:43:56.528 --> 00:43:56.968
Yeah.

823
00:43:57.008 --> 00:43:57.268
Yeah.

824
00:43:58.260 --> 00:44:04.643
And, you know, it's actually led, jokes aside, it's led to a lot of unethical cage farming of these civets.

825
00:44:04.703 --> 00:44:14.867
Because obviously, if you have something that is a commodity that is highly valuable and it comes from an animal, humans don't care about the animal's welfare.

826
00:44:15.307 --> 00:44:19.209
And so it's led to, like, cage farming driven by the demand.

827
00:44:19.229 --> 00:44:22.670
So there's demand in Japan, South Korea, and USA.

828
00:44:23.030 --> 00:44:26.532
And the cage farming has happened in places like Vietnam, Vietnam.

829
00:44:27.372 --> 00:44:29.054
and those Southeast Asian countries.

830
00:44:29.214 --> 00:44:31.095
So it has become a real problem.

831
00:44:31.536 --> 00:44:35.880
I mean, this is literally what we just talked about, about the ethical issue of doing biosynthesis with bacteria.

832
00:44:35.960 --> 00:44:36.200
Yeah.

833
00:44:36.380 --> 00:44:39.603
But this is now like you're scaling it up, and it's the same problem set.

834
00:44:39.623 --> 00:44:41.184
Yeah, yeah, it's the same problem set, right?

835
00:44:41.605 --> 00:44:44.847
And this particular paper...

836
00:44:45.568 --> 00:44:48.590
Focused on wild civets, wild civets, not in captivity.

837
00:44:48.751 --> 00:44:48.971
Okay.

838
00:44:48.991 --> 00:44:54.815
In the Western Ghats, which are these mountain ranges on the western side of the Indian Peninsula.

839
00:44:55.155 --> 00:44:56.637
Beautiful, absolutely beautiful.

840
00:44:56.717 --> 00:44:57.477
One day we will go.

841
00:44:57.637 --> 00:44:58.718
We will go.

842
00:44:58.998 --> 00:45:00.620
With our wives and whoever else.

843
00:45:01.180 --> 00:45:03.082
And it's in Nature Scientific Reports.

844
00:45:04.783 --> 00:45:10.187
It's wild, meaning that there's coffee plantations there, but then there's wild civets that go and eat some of the berries.

845
00:45:10.768 --> 00:45:13.189
And you can collect the droppings.

846
00:45:13.390 --> 00:45:13.550
Yep.

847
00:45:14.610 --> 00:45:19.774
And what they wanted to figure out was what actually is going on here chemically.

848
00:45:20.094 --> 00:45:20.234
Right.

849
00:45:20.254 --> 00:45:20.474
Okay.

850
00:45:20.975 --> 00:45:22.956
Is there anything going on or is it just placebo?

851
00:45:23.196 --> 00:45:23.697
Okay.

852
00:45:23.717 --> 00:45:29.421
So first thing what they did was they actually, you know, what you can do with coffee is you can roast it.

853
00:45:29.881 --> 00:45:35.906
And when you roast it, you get this thing called a Mylard reaction, which generates that final aroma and taste profile.

854
00:45:36.346 --> 00:45:39.088
They wanted to look at the coffee bean before the roast, right?

855
00:45:39.308 --> 00:45:42.511
Because you don't want anything that is volatile or...

856
00:45:43.797 --> 00:45:45.599
anything that requires some kind of heat.

857
00:45:45.860 --> 00:45:48.643
You want to look at the raw naked chemical composition, right?

858
00:45:48.683 --> 00:45:50.866
Before you treat it to, to that heat.

859
00:45:51.247 --> 00:45:52.568
And so that's exactly what they did.

860
00:45:53.650 --> 00:45:57.555
They figured out that there's in the civic gut, there's, there's a bioreactor.

861
00:45:57.635 --> 00:45:59.677
There's just like we have gut bacteria.

862
00:45:59.738 --> 00:46:01.099
The civets have gut bacteria.

863
00:46:01.260 --> 00:46:01.440
Yes.

864
00:46:01.540 --> 00:46:01.660
And,

865
00:46:02.501 --> 00:46:09.366
We're pretty sure that gluconobacter, which is highly abundant in the civet gut, that's linked to some kind of fermentation.

866
00:46:09.846 --> 00:46:13.069
It metabolizes like sulfur-containing amino acids.

867
00:46:13.529 --> 00:46:15.410
It metabolizes hydrogen sulfide.

868
00:46:15.730 --> 00:46:22.936
So that could be some kind of chemistry that's leading to this unique taste that happens in the civet, right?

869
00:46:23.636 --> 00:46:28.860
One thing that they did notice was that the beans that came out of the gut of the civet

870
00:46:30.133 --> 00:46:33.017
were significantly larger than the manually harvested beans.

871
00:46:33.218 --> 00:46:33.458
Really?

872
00:46:33.478 --> 00:46:36.483
And that might be because the civet has some natural way of like...

873
00:46:38.024 --> 00:46:39.324
picking which ones to eat.

874
00:46:39.625 --> 00:46:41.005
You know what I mean?

875
00:46:41.145 --> 00:46:42.465
It's not necessarily about what's happening.

876
00:46:42.525 --> 00:46:43.626
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

877
00:46:43.646 --> 00:46:44.426
They're selective.

878
00:46:44.546 --> 00:46:45.566
They're selective about it.

879
00:46:46.147 --> 00:46:50.968
The other thing they realized was caprylic acid methyl ester and capric acid methyl ester.

880
00:46:51.008 --> 00:46:55.190
These are two types of medium chain fatty acids.

881
00:46:55.730 --> 00:46:58.631
Their name is derived from the capric and the caprylic.

882
00:46:58.991 --> 00:47:01.792
Their name is derived from the Latin term for goat.

883
00:47:02.632 --> 00:47:22.202
or capra and they're basically these chains of carbon compounds that impart a desirable dairy or milk-like aroma oh okay and and the compounds that came out of the civic gut had a higher concentration of this so we're saying civet shit coffee is the goat yes

884
00:47:23.538 --> 00:47:24.258
Very nice.

885
00:47:24.539 --> 00:47:25.039
Very nice.

886
00:47:25.119 --> 00:47:25.879
Apparently it is.

887
00:47:26.260 --> 00:47:27.200
Yeah.

888
00:47:27.420 --> 00:47:30.142
So there's two things that can happen with the study.

889
00:47:30.302 --> 00:47:33.584
One, you can target fraud.

890
00:47:34.004 --> 00:47:36.786
You can test for these compounds and be like, this is not.

891
00:47:36.846 --> 00:47:38.347
This did not come out of a civet sass.

892
00:47:38.367 --> 00:47:45.671
So anyone who's branding $80 cups of coffee in New York and LA and San Francisco, that's really just selling off-the-shelf Colombian coffee beans.

893
00:47:46.111 --> 00:47:47.292
You can actually have like a...

894
00:47:47.812 --> 00:47:48.973
You can actually have a test.

895
00:47:49.313 --> 00:47:57.980
The other thing that I'm more excited about is, you know, you do have this ethical crisis with the caging and mistreatment of these animals.

896
00:47:58.200 --> 00:47:58.401
Yes.

897
00:47:58.441 --> 00:48:05.646
Well, if you could, like, identify the key microbial players and the chemical output, you could make fake ones of this.

898
00:48:06.247 --> 00:48:09.790
Just how we make fake diamonds now, so we don't need blood diamonds.

899
00:48:10.210 --> 00:48:12.612
And you could then sell these for a lot less.

900
00:48:13.553 --> 00:48:13.693
And...

901
00:48:14.370 --> 00:48:15.571
Without the ethical dilemma.

902
00:48:15.611 --> 00:48:16.632
Without caging civics.

903
00:48:16.732 --> 00:48:20.674
Knowing humans, they'll still pay the premium for the real shit.

904
00:48:20.694 --> 00:48:21.295
For the real stuff.

905
00:48:21.435 --> 00:48:21.935
As they say.

906
00:48:21.955 --> 00:48:22.716
For the real stuff.

907
00:48:22.876 --> 00:48:23.256
Yeah.

908
00:48:23.536 --> 00:48:24.817
The literal real shit.

909
00:48:24.957 --> 00:48:25.778
The literal real shit.

910
00:48:25.798 --> 00:48:26.318
That's what I mean.

911
00:48:26.338 --> 00:48:27.579
Yeah.

912
00:48:27.719 --> 00:48:29.180
But I think it's still pretty cool.

913
00:48:29.440 --> 00:48:30.361
No, that is.

914
00:48:30.481 --> 00:48:33.623
So I, again, I think I'd only ever heard of this one time.

915
00:48:34.144 --> 00:48:35.685
And I was like, I think coffee's terrible.

916
00:48:35.725 --> 00:48:37.666
I mean, I was from a colonial country, so tea.

917
00:48:37.806 --> 00:48:38.106
Yeah.

918
00:48:38.367 --> 00:48:40.629
Is my thing.

919
00:48:40.649 --> 00:48:41.671
A little chai tea.

920
00:48:42.211 --> 00:48:44.534
I'll take a little Earl Grey, a little oolong.

921
00:48:44.934 --> 00:48:52.744
However, I understand coffee is what most people like to drink as their...

922
00:48:53.304 --> 00:49:20.038
hot drink that's right or their cold drink yeah uh a nice iced chai tea latte is is quite nice but this this is this is it's good to know because i will never be buying a cup of civet yeah i don't think it's needed um but we now have like the path yeah move from this maybe if they make the fake one i'll get it i'll get it right right and and also being able to call out frauds uh funny great great heartwarming story i thought that was funny

923
00:49:20.458 --> 00:49:21.118
Just make sure.

924
00:49:21.138 --> 00:49:23.379
This is out of nature, scientific reports.

925
00:49:23.419 --> 00:49:23.959
Look, look.

926
00:49:23.999 --> 00:49:25.159
And they were like, yeah, this is pretty good.

927
00:49:25.179 --> 00:49:26.119
It's pretty good.

928
00:49:26.159 --> 00:49:27.000
Pretty good coffee.

929
00:49:28.180 --> 00:49:37.022
We're going to wrap up with a nice physics-defying story out of our local favorite UCLA.

930
00:49:37.622 --> 00:49:42.983
We literally can almost not go through one week without the UC system being one of our stories.

931
00:49:43.063 --> 00:49:44.184
This week it was two of our stories.

932
00:49:44.204 --> 00:49:44.644
That's right.

933
00:49:44.764 --> 00:49:45.944
We started with UCSD.

934
00:49:51.045 --> 00:50:10.854
to see things that really shouldn't be possible yeah and this is out of the astrophysical journal letters um i'm super excited about this story yeah this is this is a pretty pretty crazy story it's out of the ucla astrophysics department along with a bunch of other institutions

935
00:50:12.123 --> 00:50:18.229
What they've done is hack the telescope and have sharper views into the universe.

936
00:50:18.789 --> 00:50:19.049
Okay.

937
00:50:19.350 --> 00:50:22.392
And they hacked it to the point where even I was like, whoa, whoa, whoa.

938
00:50:22.533 --> 00:50:22.793
Okay.

939
00:50:23.213 --> 00:50:26.516
They have, they have a line that I'll get, get to in their paper that I was like, what are you talking about?

940
00:50:26.957 --> 00:50:27.117
Um,

941
00:50:28.020 --> 00:50:31.182
Okay, so the goal is always higher angular resolution.

942
00:50:31.483 --> 00:50:34.185
You want to be able to resolve smaller and smaller things.

943
00:50:34.625 --> 00:50:46.114
The epitome of that is the Event Horizon Telescope, which gave us that beautiful view of the black hole at the center of our Milky Way and the black hole in M86, which is a far, far away galaxy.

944
00:50:46.374 --> 00:50:55.321
You're looking at a thing that's about the size of a solar system, maybe several solar systems, but it's millions of light years away.

945
00:50:56.474 --> 00:50:56.654
Right.

946
00:50:57.154 --> 00:50:57.855
It's insane.

947
00:50:58.175 --> 00:50:58.875
It's not close.

948
00:50:58.956 --> 00:50:59.936
Yeah, it's not close.

949
00:50:59.976 --> 00:51:08.761
It's something like, I mean, I think somebody was saying something like the head of a pin or they're resolving a quarter on the Empire State Building if you're looking from Los Angeles.

950
00:51:09.442 --> 00:51:09.642
Right.

951
00:51:10.062 --> 00:51:12.283
Resolution is what that means.

952
00:51:12.664 --> 00:51:15.565
How fine detail can you resolve something in the night sky?

953
00:51:15.906 --> 00:51:18.747
And we want to always push this as far as possible.

954
00:51:18.867 --> 00:51:19.027
Right.

955
00:51:19.328 --> 00:51:22.950
This is new work that came out of the UCLA Astrophysics Department.

956
00:51:24.447 --> 00:51:29.248
What they've done is demonstrate sub-diffraction limited astronomical measurement.

957
00:51:29.748 --> 00:51:30.008
Okay?

958
00:51:30.288 --> 00:51:31.728
And that key thing is what got me.

959
00:51:31.888 --> 00:51:33.109
Sub-diffraction limited.

960
00:51:33.229 --> 00:51:33.969
So what does that mean?

961
00:51:34.529 --> 00:51:34.789
Okay.

962
00:51:35.289 --> 00:51:39.230
There is a limit when it comes to the resolution that you can have with light.

963
00:51:39.610 --> 00:51:39.870
Okay?

964
00:51:40.130 --> 00:51:43.931
It's dependent on the wavelength, and it's dependent on the size of your aperture.

965
00:51:44.251 --> 00:51:44.471
Okay.

966
00:51:44.511 --> 00:51:45.591
It's called the Rayleigh limit.

967
00:51:45.971 --> 00:51:54.093
If you've got two points of light that are really close together, as they are on the right-hand side, then they're going to look like one point of light, and I won't be able to resolve them differently.

968
00:51:54.913 --> 00:52:04.219
On the other hand, if I have two points that are a little bit farther apart, then I can resolve them because they're Gaussian peaks, this sort of like envelope of stuff.

969
00:52:04.239 --> 00:52:05.340
It's not technically Gaussian.

970
00:52:05.360 --> 00:52:07.561
It's like this other function called the ARI function.

971
00:52:07.841 --> 00:52:11.544
But in any case, if they don't overlap enough, I can resolve the two as separate things.

972
00:52:11.564 --> 00:52:12.084
As separate things.

973
00:52:12.124 --> 00:52:12.344
Right?

974
00:52:12.745 --> 00:52:12.925
Yes.

975
00:52:13.185 --> 00:52:13.465
Yes.

976
00:52:13.645 --> 00:52:16.188
How far apart they need to be an angle.

977
00:52:16.608 --> 00:52:17.949
It's not actually distance, right?

978
00:52:17.989 --> 00:52:20.932
Because if something's closer, then they need to be closer away.

979
00:52:21.233 --> 00:52:23.135
If they're farther away, then they could be really far.

980
00:52:23.175 --> 00:52:24.536
It's the angle that matters.

981
00:52:24.596 --> 00:52:26.678
It's like the angle between them, right?

982
00:52:27.018 --> 00:52:32.344
And how far away they can be in terms of angle is determined by something called the Raleigh criterion, which is what we just saw.

983
00:52:32.964 --> 00:52:36.386
It's a ratio between the wavelength and the diameter.

984
00:52:36.446 --> 00:52:36.687
Okay?

985
00:52:36.727 --> 00:52:42.210
Wavelength divided by diameter times some constant, which has to do with the shape of your aperture.

986
00:52:42.311 --> 00:52:45.032
Usually it's 1.22 because your apertures are usually round.

987
00:52:47.528 --> 00:52:51.309
So the bigger the wavelength, the larger this angle has to be.

988
00:52:51.589 --> 00:52:52.530
And that makes sense, right?

989
00:52:52.570 --> 00:53:00.413
Because if the wavelength is really large, then, you know, we've looked at large waves that try to go across a rock.

990
00:53:00.633 --> 00:53:01.513
They get unbothered.

991
00:53:01.813 --> 00:53:03.414
Because the large waves will just go through.

992
00:53:03.614 --> 00:53:05.394
The smaller waves are the ones that will bend.

993
00:53:05.714 --> 00:53:09.076
And that bending is what actually gives us any type of information.

994
00:53:10.256 --> 00:53:12.417
Also, the larger the diameter of your lens...

995
00:53:13.257 --> 00:53:14.838
the smaller you can resolve.

996
00:53:14.958 --> 00:53:15.138
Yes.

997
00:53:15.238 --> 00:53:15.419
Right?

998
00:53:15.619 --> 00:53:16.079
That makes sense.

999
00:53:16.099 --> 00:53:17.020
That's why we have big telescopes.

1000
00:53:17.040 --> 00:53:19.342
That's why I have these giant, massive telescopes.

1001
00:53:19.362 --> 00:53:19.882
Massive telescopes.

1002
00:53:19.902 --> 00:53:21.623
Big, big mirrors and lenses.

1003
00:53:21.663 --> 00:53:22.424
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1004
00:53:22.464 --> 00:53:32.932
One of the reasons is light gathering, but the other reason is so that we can have a giant sort of diffraction thingy that lets us resolve.

1005
00:53:33.112 --> 00:53:33.272
Yes.

1006
00:53:33.432 --> 00:53:33.692
Okay?

1007
00:53:34.032 --> 00:53:39.737
And the one that they're doing here, they're using the 8.2 meter Subaru telescope in Hawaii.

1008
00:53:40.637 --> 00:53:41.178
That thing...

1009
00:53:43.110 --> 00:53:53.638
You know, if we take the wavelength of light to be around 656 nanometers, the diffraction limit there with the 8.2 meter Subaru telescope is 20 milli arc seconds.

1010
00:53:54.019 --> 00:53:54.259
Okay.

1011
00:53:54.439 --> 00:53:54.659
Okay.

1012
00:53:54.939 --> 00:53:57.421
And to think about arc seconds, it's like you got degrees.

1013
00:53:57.822 --> 00:53:59.263
From degrees, then you get minutes.

1014
00:53:59.363 --> 00:54:00.744
From minutes, you get seconds.

1015
00:54:00.764 --> 00:54:04.186
And then from seconds is divided into 1,000 arc seconds.

1016
00:54:04.226 --> 00:54:06.008
So it goes 60, 60, then 1,000.

1017
00:54:06.368 --> 00:54:06.568
Okay.

1018
00:54:06.588 --> 00:54:07.729
It's extremely small.

1019
00:54:07.749 --> 00:54:10.551
It means if we were to look at Pluto right now from Earth.

1020
00:54:10.571 --> 00:54:10.852
Yes.

1021
00:54:11.052 --> 00:54:11.232
Yes.

1022
00:54:13.115 --> 00:54:15.876
Pluto would be a fifth the size of that angle.

1023
00:54:15.956 --> 00:54:19.478
So Subaru telescope could actually tell Pluto and Karen apart.

1024
00:54:20.398 --> 00:54:23.259
The two, Pluto and its moon apart, right?

1025
00:54:23.299 --> 00:54:24.139
That's quite nice.

1026
00:54:24.159 --> 00:54:27.941
Because its resolution is smaller than Pluto's.

1027
00:54:28.001 --> 00:54:28.521
That's quite nice.

1028
00:54:28.621 --> 00:54:33.523
Pluto's about 100 arc seconds, and this thing's resolution is 20 milli-arc seconds.

1029
00:54:33.663 --> 00:54:34.783
0.2 times 100, right?

1030
00:54:34.903 --> 00:54:35.063
Yep.

1031
00:54:35.143 --> 00:54:35.863
It's a fifth of that.

1032
00:54:36.023 --> 00:54:36.184
Yep.

1033
00:54:36.404 --> 00:54:36.524
Okay.

1034
00:54:36.544 --> 00:54:36.724
Okay.

1035
00:54:36.944 --> 00:54:37.184
Okay.

1036
00:54:37.604 --> 00:54:38.844
There's a bunch of problems, right?

1037
00:54:38.864 --> 00:54:44.186
The other problem that gets to us is not just Raleigh thing, which is just physics, right?

1038
00:54:44.626 --> 00:54:46.146
Like even the Hubble has this problem.

1039
00:54:46.206 --> 00:54:47.507
James Webb has this problem.

1040
00:54:47.887 --> 00:54:52.188
The other thing is we're under the Earth's atmosphere, and the Earth's atmosphere causes the twinkling of stars.

1041
00:54:52.568 --> 00:54:54.489
It also causes the twinkling of distant...

1042
00:54:55.449 --> 00:55:21.147
lights if you're on top of a mountain right because all the earth's atmosphere has this turbulent packets of warm air and then cold air and highly dense and then lower dense so the light is gonna is gonna start moving around before it gets to your detector interacting with the atmosphere on its way to the exactly capturing it with yeah exactly and so and so the resulting disc of your point source let's say if you're trying to look at a star is

1043
00:55:22.205 --> 00:55:26.428
it's going to go up by 500 to 1,000 milli arc seconds.

1044
00:55:27.028 --> 00:55:31.151
It's going to be 25 to 50 times worse than that theoretical limit.

1045
00:55:31.451 --> 00:55:35.234
And so what we can do is we can do something called adaptive optics.

1046
00:55:35.614 --> 00:55:38.036
We can correct by making a fake star.

1047
00:55:38.236 --> 00:55:46.742
Here what you're seeing is the Keck telescope, and there's two lasers pointing out at where the telescope is looking, and it's creating a fake star there.

1048
00:55:46.762 --> 00:55:47.322
Right.

1049
00:55:47.742 --> 00:55:48.683
The trick is the following.

1050
00:55:49.303 --> 00:55:56.466
You've got a fake star that looks like any other star, but we know that it came from our laser, so it should be stationary.

1051
00:55:56.646 --> 00:56:03.949
The star and the stuff that I'm looking at could be moving and it could have dynamics, but I know that the laser that I'm pointing is definitely straight.

1052
00:56:04.709 --> 00:56:09.251
And the laser is going through the same bit of atmosphere that the starlight is coming in.

1053
00:56:09.931 --> 00:56:12.032
So if I can change...

1054
00:56:12.752 --> 00:56:23.820
If I have some kind of deformable mirror, right, that is taking that starlight and right in the middle, I have like little ways in which I can change the shape of that mirror.

1055
00:56:23.940 --> 00:56:24.100
Yes.

1056
00:56:24.260 --> 00:56:30.044
In order to keep that laser stationary, that's going to cancel out the effects of that column of the atmosphere.

1057
00:56:30.184 --> 00:56:31.405
Makes total sense.

1058
00:56:31.525 --> 00:56:31.705
Right.

1059
00:56:31.805 --> 00:56:34.607
I have to say this because I would be remiss if we didn't.

1060
00:56:34.967 --> 00:56:37.589
We're in between photos six and seven on the show notes.

1061
00:56:37.609 --> 00:56:37.889
Yeah.

1062
00:56:38.009 --> 00:56:38.730
And you literally.

1063
00:56:39.030 --> 00:56:40.331
And I literally didn't say, oh, God.

1064
00:56:40.431 --> 00:56:40.651
Yeah.

1065
00:56:42.432 --> 00:56:43.533
I still don't understand that.

1066
00:56:43.993 --> 00:56:54.299
But the point you're saying is because we have a fixed point from the lasers in the sky that we can then measure and basically remove the impacts of the atmosphere on how we're detecting the other stuff.

1067
00:56:54.319 --> 00:56:56.340
Because we have a fixed point that we control.

1068
00:56:56.561 --> 00:56:56.761
Yes.

1069
00:56:56.781 --> 00:56:58.822
That then can remove the noise that comes from the atmosphere.

1070
00:56:58.962 --> 00:56:59.403
Exactly.

1071
00:56:59.503 --> 00:57:02.806
And then we can finally get to that diffraction limit.

1072
00:57:03.126 --> 00:57:03.346
Got it.

1073
00:57:03.406 --> 00:57:03.686
Okay.

1074
00:57:04.107 --> 00:57:08.711
We can finally get to what the telescope is truly capable of, given Raleigh criterion.

1075
00:57:09.031 --> 00:57:13.395
And here what we're seeing is the center of our Milky Way in infrared.

1076
00:57:14.015 --> 00:57:18.239
On the left is without adaptive optics, and on the right is with adaptive optics.

1077
00:57:18.259 --> 00:57:19.040
My goodness.

1078
00:57:19.280 --> 00:57:22.263
You can see the huge change.

1079
00:57:22.543 --> 00:57:24.565
This is how Andrea Ghez won the Nobel Prize.

1080
00:57:24.785 --> 00:57:25.605
This is crazy.

1081
00:57:25.625 --> 00:57:30.026
For listeners who are not watching the video, and I encourage you to go to YouTube because we always have graphics for this.

1082
00:57:30.486 --> 00:57:34.347
On the left, it basically looks like a gradient, a red-orange gradient.

1083
00:57:34.367 --> 00:57:34.927
With blobs.

1084
00:57:35.067 --> 00:57:35.887
It's just a massive blob.

1085
00:57:36.067 --> 00:57:37.168
And maybe 20 blobs.

1086
00:57:37.188 --> 00:57:39.668
There's no discrete shape of any kind.

1087
00:57:39.708 --> 00:57:41.308
It's just like a sauce.

1088
00:57:41.808 --> 00:57:45.389
On the right, you can see very discrete points of light, multiple.

1089
00:57:45.409 --> 00:57:45.989
There's maybe...

1090
00:57:46.069 --> 00:57:47.630
Even in the zoomed-in version, right?

1091
00:57:47.650 --> 00:57:48.470
There's an inset.

1092
00:57:48.490 --> 00:57:49.090
Yeah, there's an inset.

1093
00:57:49.110 --> 00:57:50.590
And you can see in the inset, there's like...

1094
00:57:51.130 --> 00:57:54.231
It's incredibly high-fidelity comparatively.

1095
00:57:54.251 --> 00:57:54.391
Yeah.

1096
00:57:54.711 --> 00:58:02.937
And here, you're looking at something called Sagittarius A star and the stars around that compact object.

1097
00:58:03.558 --> 00:58:10.222
And if we were to make a movie out of this, you'd see all of the stars going around an invisible point.

1098
00:58:10.242 --> 00:58:10.543
Mm-hmm.

1099
00:58:11.896 --> 00:58:14.338
And that invisible point is our supermassive black hole.

1100
00:58:14.838 --> 00:58:18.581
And this is why Andrew Ghez at UCLA won the Nobel Prize.

1101
00:58:18.881 --> 00:58:24.265
UCLA has had an incredible history of imaging techniques.

1102
00:58:24.905 --> 00:58:26.326
They're really good.

1103
00:58:26.587 --> 00:58:30.990
They've got like two floors dedicated in the Knudsen Hall, I think, to just...

1104
00:58:31.710 --> 00:58:33.911
getting imaging to the next level.

1105
00:58:33.971 --> 00:58:35.892
And this is the next sort of thing that they're doing.

1106
00:58:35.932 --> 00:58:37.193
I mean, LA is the home of Hollywood.

1107
00:58:37.413 --> 00:58:37.933
It is, right?

1108
00:58:37.953 --> 00:58:40.054
Yeah.

1109
00:58:40.134 --> 00:58:40.975
So that's pretty funny.

1110
00:58:41.755 --> 00:58:43.116
So you can see now, right?

1111
00:58:43.156 --> 00:58:44.517
Adaptive optics is insane.

1112
00:58:44.557 --> 00:58:44.797
Yes.

1113
00:58:44.917 --> 00:58:46.158
That's a big deal.

1114
00:58:46.198 --> 00:58:49.019
The other thing that we can do is not just adaptive optics.

1115
00:58:49.079 --> 00:58:54.182
We can make the telescope size bigger without actually making the telescope bigger.

1116
00:58:54.602 --> 00:58:55.542
The effective size.

1117
00:58:55.562 --> 00:58:56.143
You've seen this.

1118
00:58:56.183 --> 00:58:56.823
The VLA.

1119
00:58:56.863 --> 00:58:58.504
You've been to the VLA.

1120
00:58:58.524 --> 00:59:00.325
Very large...

1121
00:59:02.089 --> 00:59:02.369
Array.

1122
00:59:02.570 --> 00:59:04.412
Yeah, a very large array in New Mexico.

1123
00:59:04.852 --> 00:59:13.062
A giant 27-mile-long radio telescope made of smaller telescopes that are all coordinated, and they can sense the time in which the light came.

1124
00:59:13.102 --> 00:59:14.143
They can have them interfere.

1125
00:59:14.523 --> 00:59:16.626
And so the light-gathering power is not as much.

1126
00:59:16.646 --> 00:59:19.609
You're not gathering as much light, but you're...

1127
00:59:21.531 --> 00:59:35.747
resolution is limited by how far away your telescopes are right yeah now with the radio it's easier to do because the radio waves are slower yes with visible light it's harder but actually the gold standard right now is in mount wilson it's called the kara array

1128
00:59:36.781 --> 00:59:42.023
It's six one-meter telescopes all along the mountain that you can see over there.

1129
00:59:42.383 --> 00:59:46.384
The baseline is 330 meters, so about three football fields wide.

1130
00:59:47.585 --> 00:59:52.626
It's effectively a visible optical light telescope that is three football fields wide.

1131
00:59:53.407 --> 00:59:54.187
And with that...

1132
00:59:55.107 --> 01:00:04.150
you can achieve an angular resolution of 0.2 micro arc seconds, which is insane because you can now image other stars like this.

1133
01:00:04.730 --> 01:00:07.111
Like this is a star called Altair.

1134
01:00:07.511 --> 01:00:15.894
It revolves really fast on its axis, which is why it's got this like really big grapefruit bulge on the equator because it's revolving so fast.

1135
01:00:16.534 --> 01:00:18.899
And because in the equator, you can also see that it's dimmer.

1136
01:00:19.100 --> 01:00:19.701
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1137
01:00:19.841 --> 01:00:23.649
Because like that gas is farther away from the equator compared to the pole.

1138
01:00:23.789 --> 01:00:23.950
Yep.

1139
01:00:24.110 --> 01:00:25.773
So it's a little bit dimmer.

1140
01:00:26.925 --> 01:00:29.726
This is a single star that we're imaging like this.

1141
01:00:29.787 --> 01:00:31.067
Yeah, that's incredible.

1142
01:00:31.167 --> 01:00:32.068
It's incredible.

1143
01:00:32.088 --> 01:00:39.571
We've also, with the Kara Array, we've been able to see sunspots on other stars.

1144
01:00:40.012 --> 01:00:42.973
So star spots on other stars with the Kara Array.

1145
01:00:42.993 --> 01:00:48.636
And it was really cool because the last time I went up there was for one of these...

1146
01:00:50.257 --> 01:00:50.697
They have...

1147
01:00:51.737 --> 01:00:55.564
classical music concerts at Mount Wilson in the telescope dome.

1148
01:00:56.065 --> 01:01:02.017
And I, for the longest time thought that nighttime astronomy was dead at Mount Wilson because of the,

1149
01:01:03.198 --> 01:01:04.819
light pollution from Los Angeles.

1150
01:01:05.179 --> 01:01:08.261
Nighttime astronomy had been retired and all they did was solar astronomy.

1151
01:01:08.581 --> 01:01:10.042
But no, CARA was up there.

1152
01:01:10.522 --> 01:01:13.424
Six small one-meter telescopes all along the mountain.

1153
01:01:13.764 --> 01:01:16.405
They route their light through vacuum tubes.

1154
01:01:16.445 --> 01:01:17.226
Which is crazy.

1155
01:01:17.766 --> 01:01:22.408
And then they have a central array where they make them interfere and actually get that resolution.

1156
01:01:22.428 --> 01:01:22.689
It was cool.

1157
01:01:22.709 --> 01:01:23.149
It was cool.

1158
01:01:24.018 --> 01:01:29.582
Yeah, that, you know, astronomy, cutting edge astronomy is still alive and well in Mount Wilson.

1159
01:01:29.782 --> 01:01:31.583
In beautiful, sunny Los Angeles.

1160
01:01:31.603 --> 01:01:32.964
Los Angeles, where it all started.

1161
01:01:35.105 --> 01:01:37.347
So this paper's profound claim.

1162
01:01:37.687 --> 01:01:42.751
So we've gone through, you know, Raleigh Limit, which is just the physics of light waves.

1163
01:01:42.851 --> 01:01:43.051
Yes.

1164
01:01:43.391 --> 01:01:45.813
And we've gone through the atmosphere and so on and so forth.

1165
01:01:45.953 --> 01:01:46.153
Yes.

1166
01:01:46.173 --> 01:01:46.373
Yes.

1167
01:01:47.292 --> 01:01:54.356
The core claim that got me thinking about what this paper was, they said, the rally criterion is not fundamental.

1168
01:01:55.456 --> 01:01:59.338
So it's like Jack Sparrow being like, it's more like guidelines.

1169
01:01:59.759 --> 01:02:00.159
Right?

1170
01:02:01.713 --> 01:02:04.135
Like, like I was like, what are you talking about?

1171
01:02:04.215 --> 01:02:07.637
Like, I thought the Raleigh criterion, I learned this in undergrad and I thought that was it.

1172
01:02:07.737 --> 01:02:07.917
Yeah.

1173
01:02:07.957 --> 01:02:08.138
Right.

1174
01:02:08.418 --> 01:02:08.598
Right.

1175
01:02:08.638 --> 01:02:09.018
Insane.

1176
01:02:09.439 --> 01:02:10.639
So here's the thing.

1177
01:02:10.659 --> 01:02:14.902
The idea is like there's previously this was viewed as a fundamental limitation.

1178
01:02:15.103 --> 01:02:15.343
Yeah.

1179
01:02:15.423 --> 01:02:16.063
At a physics level.

1180
01:02:16.083 --> 01:02:16.824
At a physics level.

1181
01:02:17.104 --> 01:02:17.324
Right.

1182
01:02:18.705 --> 01:02:19.546
Then I started reading.

1183
01:02:19.646 --> 01:02:22.188
So the Raleigh criterion assumes the following.

1184
01:02:22.668 --> 01:02:25.310
The only thing that you're sensitive to is the intensity of the light.

1185
01:02:25.330 --> 01:02:25.570
Right.

1186
01:02:25.862 --> 01:02:26.143
Okay.

1187
01:02:26.443 --> 01:02:26.704
Okay?

1188
01:02:27.044 --> 01:02:27.205
Mm-hmm.

1189
01:02:27.405 --> 01:02:28.608
You've got a telescope.

1190
01:02:28.748 --> 01:02:30.031
You've got a CCD in the back.

1191
01:02:30.211 --> 01:02:31.433
The telescope creates an image.

1192
01:02:31.473 --> 01:02:32.876
The CCD then...

1193
01:02:34.137 --> 01:02:38.361
tells how much intensity of light is coming from this direction, this direction, and it creates an image.

1194
01:02:39.702 --> 01:02:44.086
But light is an electromagnetic wave, and there is phase information.

1195
01:02:44.807 --> 01:02:45.087
Okay.

1196
01:02:45.267 --> 01:02:45.608
Right?

1197
01:02:45.708 --> 01:02:47.830
Because the electromagnetic wave is coming at you.

1198
01:02:48.210 --> 01:02:49.531
At some point, it's going to be up.

1199
01:02:49.611 --> 01:02:51.193
At some point, it's going to be down this way.

1200
01:02:51.553 --> 01:02:51.713
Right?

1201
01:02:51.994 --> 01:02:52.734
There's a phase.

1202
01:02:52.774 --> 01:02:55.237
There's a timing that the light is coming through.

1203
01:02:55.277 --> 01:02:57.158
And if you can extract the timing...

1204
01:02:57.799 --> 01:02:59.060
then you have both parts of the wave.

1205
01:02:59.080 --> 01:03:01.462
You have the amplitude, which is the intensity, which you already had.

1206
01:03:01.522 --> 01:03:01.682
Yes.

1207
01:03:01.862 --> 01:03:04.425
And you also have the timing in which that wave packet came in.

1208
01:03:04.445 --> 01:03:04.605
Yes.

1209
01:03:04.905 --> 01:03:05.125
Right?

1210
01:03:05.205 --> 01:03:05.365
Yes.

1211
01:03:05.706 --> 01:03:08.788
And so now it's kind of like with a complex number, right?

1212
01:03:09.068 --> 01:03:13.672
A complex number, as I said the other day, it's a clock that has a length and it has a phase.

1213
01:03:13.692 --> 01:03:13.772
Yes.

1214
01:03:13.792 --> 01:03:13.953
Yes.

1215
01:03:14.673 --> 01:03:17.956
We were only sensitive to the length of this thing with the CCD.

1216
01:03:18.677 --> 01:03:28.066
What these guys are doing now is they're getting sensitive to the phase of that light, creating much more information out of that single resolution.

1217
01:03:28.086 --> 01:03:29.928
Out of the existing system that's already there.

1218
01:03:30.108 --> 01:03:30.368
Yes.

1219
01:03:31.049 --> 01:03:32.530
Which is like a key idea here.

1220
01:03:32.550 --> 01:03:34.552
They're adding another little piece of equipment.

1221
01:03:34.732 --> 01:03:34.853
Right.

1222
01:03:34.873 --> 01:03:35.033
Right.

1223
01:03:35.493 --> 01:03:38.274
Instead of the CCD, they have this thing that we're going to talk about.

1224
01:03:38.574 --> 01:03:41.394
But that thing is now going to capture all of this additional information.

1225
01:03:41.714 --> 01:03:48.756
And what's happening is they're dividing up the light into its notes, into its musical notes.

1226
01:03:48.816 --> 01:03:57.458
Like when you listen to a musical note, let's say a chord that has A, C, and a G, that's three different piano keys that are put down, right?

1227
01:03:57.818 --> 01:03:58.919
How does your ear hear it?

1228
01:03:59.019 --> 01:04:01.059
Your ear actually hears the three different notes.

1229
01:04:05.681 --> 01:04:06.942
that's in the cochlea.

1230
01:04:07.002 --> 01:04:08.725
The cochlea is this curled up little thing.

1231
01:04:09.166 --> 01:04:11.068
That's a hardware part of our ear.

1232
01:04:11.509 --> 01:04:14.173
And what it does is it's made out of cells of different thickness.

1233
01:04:14.673 --> 01:04:14.934
Okay?

1234
01:04:16.690 --> 01:04:20.773
The lower frequency, the bass notes, are going to vibrate the cells with the big thickness.

1235
01:04:21.494 --> 01:04:24.937
And the higher frequency are going to vibrate the thinner, smaller cells.

1236
01:04:25.557 --> 01:04:32.302
So where in this spiral the cells are getting excited tells you which piano notes are being played.

1237
01:04:32.883 --> 01:04:33.143
Okay?

1238
01:04:33.563 --> 01:04:41.810
Our ear has hardware that is breaking down the sound that is coming in into its respective modes, as you would say.

1239
01:04:41.870 --> 01:04:43.031
Into its respective, like...

1240
01:04:44.409 --> 01:04:44.929
components.

1241
01:04:45.510 --> 01:04:45.810
Okay.

1242
01:04:46.430 --> 01:04:49.452
We're going to do the same thing with the light that's coming through a telescope.

1243
01:04:49.472 --> 01:04:50.292
Okay.

1244
01:04:50.312 --> 01:04:50.493
Okay.

1245
01:04:50.873 --> 01:04:55.215
What we have is we've got a wave guide that takes in the light that's coming in from the telescope.

1246
01:04:55.255 --> 01:04:55.436
Yes.

1247
01:04:55.756 --> 01:04:55.996
Okay.

1248
01:04:56.396 --> 01:05:02.079
And then what it's going to do is make it go through this fiber optic sort of chassis.

1249
01:05:02.460 --> 01:05:02.680
Okay.

1250
01:05:03.240 --> 01:05:06.302
And all of that multimodal, the sound that's coming from an

1251
01:05:10.835 --> 01:05:12.875
into each individual fiber optic cable.

1252
01:05:12.955 --> 01:05:13.175
Yes.

1253
01:05:13.396 --> 01:05:13.656
Okay?

1254
01:05:13.916 --> 01:05:20.477
And so you're decomposing the light field into a basis of what are the notes that make up that light field.

1255
01:05:20.877 --> 01:05:22.657
Which also changes over time.

1256
01:05:22.737 --> 01:05:23.017
Yes.

1257
01:05:23.417 --> 01:05:27.718
And each of those notes has a certain phase to it, right?

1258
01:05:28.558 --> 01:05:34.459
Because some of the notes are going to be arriving a little bit later, some of them earlier, some of them are going to be louder than the others.

1259
01:05:34.739 --> 01:05:37.600
And so if you go to the next one, we'll have...

1260
01:05:38.480 --> 01:05:40.322
This is what the light notes look like.

1261
01:05:40.382 --> 01:05:44.787
On the left-hand side over here, we've got the actual image.

1262
01:05:45.047 --> 01:05:48.030
Let's say it's a dot with a ring around it or something like that.

1263
01:05:48.070 --> 01:05:50.272
That can be broken up into a dot in the center.

1264
01:05:50.793 --> 01:05:52.615
Then there's maybe two lobes this way.

1265
01:05:52.635 --> 01:05:53.716
There's two lobes this way.

1266
01:05:53.996 --> 01:05:59.482
And what we can do is we can say, what are the modes, which are these individual notes?

1267
01:06:00.263 --> 01:06:01.183
How do they add up?

1268
01:06:01.919 --> 01:06:03.759
to make the image that I'm seeing.

1269
01:06:03.899 --> 01:06:05.820
That's what that deconstruction is doing.

1270
01:06:05.880 --> 01:06:06.920
You know what this looks like?

1271
01:06:06.960 --> 01:06:15.862
For any video or film editors that are listening, it looks like the color panel on DaVinci Resolve when you're color correcting your video footage.

1272
01:06:16.262 --> 01:06:18.963
It gives you the color wheels of all these different permutations.

1273
01:06:19.083 --> 01:06:20.543
It literally looks just like it.

1274
01:06:20.623 --> 01:06:21.864
It's actually hilarious.

1275
01:06:22.064 --> 01:06:23.684
It's kind of similar in that sense, right?

1276
01:06:23.744 --> 01:06:27.605
It's like it's extracting this like low...

1277
01:06:28.483 --> 01:06:29.825
information, right?

1278
01:06:30.206 --> 01:06:31.548
All the stuff that makes it up.

1279
01:06:31.908 --> 01:06:37.917
This is only really possible if you look at very simple objects, for example, a single star, or like stuff around a single star.

1280
01:06:37.957 --> 01:06:42.744
If you wanted to image the Eagle Nebula or something, this wouldn't really work.

1281
01:06:43.405 --> 01:06:45.587
Mathematics is simple because the source is simple.

1282
01:06:45.607 --> 01:06:45.948
That makes sense.

1283
01:06:45.968 --> 01:06:49.912
And because the source is simple, I only need to worry about the first, like, 20 notes.

1284
01:06:50.292 --> 01:06:50.652
I got you.

1285
01:06:50.672 --> 01:06:52.454
I don't need to worry about... Because you can...

1286
01:06:52.694 --> 01:06:57.559
I mean, in theory, you can recreate any image using, like, just a bunch of, like, notes like this.

1287
01:06:57.639 --> 01:06:57.799
Yes.

1288
01:06:57.900 --> 01:06:59.481
But in practice, it's going to get difficult.

1289
01:06:59.501 --> 01:06:59.862
That makes sense.

1290
01:06:59.882 --> 01:07:00.722
With a simple...

1291
01:07:01.528 --> 01:07:07.691
objective, which is just, we're looking at a star, we want to resolve the stuff in the star and around the star very nicely.

1292
01:07:07.971 --> 01:07:08.571
That's what we can do.

1293
01:07:08.591 --> 01:07:16.435
And the key principle is the phase information of that input is now converted into a measurable intensity difference between all of these different notes, right?

1294
01:07:16.895 --> 01:07:19.036
If the star's position, for example, it shifts

1295
01:07:19.756 --> 01:07:23.078
then one of those fiber optic inputs is going to be brighter than the other.

1296
01:07:23.098 --> 01:07:26.519
If it ships the other way, then another fiber optic input is going to be brighter.

1297
01:07:26.819 --> 01:07:26.980
Right?

1298
01:07:27.300 --> 01:07:27.480
Yes.

1299
01:07:27.900 --> 01:07:39.446
And the raw data has gone from being a CCD to now, it's not a picture of the star, but it's 38 different spectra in each of these different modes.

1300
01:07:40.046 --> 01:07:40.306
Okay?

1301
01:07:40.546 --> 01:07:41.387
So it's like how...

1302
01:07:42.467 --> 01:07:45.150
How loud was this note at this frequency?

1303
01:07:45.590 --> 01:07:45.891
Yes.

1304
01:07:46.271 --> 01:07:46.451
Yes.

1305
01:07:46.591 --> 01:07:47.052
So to speak.

1306
01:07:47.072 --> 01:07:47.692
So to speak.

1307
01:07:47.772 --> 01:07:48.013
Right?

1308
01:07:48.113 --> 01:07:48.333
Right.

1309
01:07:48.833 --> 01:07:50.395
This is...

1310
01:07:50.455 --> 01:07:52.397
But that's the best way that I can describe it.

1311
01:07:52.757 --> 01:07:57.042
We're trying to distill it into an analogy that doesn't require us to go through more layers.

1312
01:07:57.062 --> 01:07:58.423
Yeah, go through all of the data.

1313
01:07:58.463 --> 01:07:58.903
But it's like...

1314
01:07:59.604 --> 01:08:04.969
They've basically got 19 different notes and two polarizations because polarization is also important, right?

1315
01:08:05.229 --> 01:08:11.775
The electric field oscillating this way or this way tells us something about what the thing is that is producing that light.

1316
01:08:11.995 --> 01:08:16.940
So it's 19 different nodes all in two different polarizations to get 38 different spectra.

1317
01:08:17.520 --> 01:08:30.168
The idea is before we were looking at just like one box, and now we have like 19 boxes with two flavors to analyze the same object we were looking at before that was just one box.

1318
01:08:30.308 --> 01:08:31.169
Yes, exactly.

1319
01:08:31.449 --> 01:08:35.711
And the one box, sure, it had the direct information of how bright this thing was.

1320
01:08:36.052 --> 01:08:38.893
But now we're just sophisticating it, right?

1321
01:08:38.953 --> 01:08:42.075
We're no longer taking, let's say, just how loud the sound is.

1322
01:08:42.135 --> 01:08:42.916
But what are the...

1323
01:08:44.034 --> 01:08:45.054
Thingies on top.

1324
01:08:45.114 --> 01:08:50.857
The another analogy this makes me think of is like for DJs, when you get a track, right?

1325
01:08:51.137 --> 01:08:57.400
The track is like one audio waveform and it has the drums, it has the vocals, it has everything as one waveform.

1326
01:08:57.500 --> 01:08:57.960
Exactly.

1327
01:08:58.140 --> 01:09:04.003
Now there's all these AI tools that allow you to separate out the drums from the vocals, from the synths.

1328
01:09:04.343 --> 01:09:13.627
And now you have it as these, and like there is information when you're looking at just the individual instrument that is hard to decipher when you're looking at the singers.

1329
01:09:13.647 --> 01:09:13.767
way.

1330
01:09:13.787 --> 01:09:14.267
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1331
01:09:14.287 --> 01:09:15.508
And this is very similar to that.

1332
01:09:15.568 --> 01:09:16.948
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1333
01:09:16.988 --> 01:09:18.569
I think that's a good analogy.

1334
01:09:18.929 --> 01:09:19.089
Right?

1335
01:09:19.149 --> 01:09:24.071
It's taking the aggregate light and it's decomposing it into these individual modes.

1336
01:09:24.311 --> 01:09:25.231
You know?

1337
01:09:26.031 --> 01:09:31.113
And what you can do now, the second thing that you can do is this star, it's

1338
01:09:34.446 --> 01:09:35.486
It's got two different...

1339
01:09:35.727 --> 01:09:42.529
So this star specifically, what they're looking at is a star in Canis Minoris, Beta CMI.

1340
01:09:42.790 --> 01:09:44.610
It's 162 light years away.

1341
01:09:44.931 --> 01:09:46.631
It's surrounded by gas of hydrogen.

1342
01:09:46.671 --> 01:09:53.274
Canis Minoris is one of the two dogs that are the hunting companions of Orion, the hunter.

1343
01:09:53.934 --> 01:09:54.475
And so...

1344
01:09:55.535 --> 01:10:02.401
This star specifically, it's got a gas of hydrogen around it, and that gas is spinning so fast that we can see a Doppler shift.

1345
01:10:02.701 --> 01:10:09.387
We're on one side, it's blue shifted because it's coming at us, and on the other side, it's red shifted because it's going away.

1346
01:10:10.368 --> 01:10:13.290
So what we want to do is resolve this gas cloud.

1347
01:10:13.770 --> 01:10:14.791
There's two ways to do this.

1348
01:10:15.492 --> 01:10:16.192
There's two steps.

1349
01:10:16.553 --> 01:10:20.496
The first is to say, okay, all of the light, most of the light is coming from the star, right?

1350
01:10:21.076 --> 01:10:22.257
There's going to be some jitter,

1351
01:10:22.978 --> 01:10:25.099
Because of the adaptive optics.

1352
01:10:25.180 --> 01:10:34.366
Remember when we talked about the episode about AI being used for LIGO, for the gravitational observatory?

1353
01:10:34.686 --> 01:10:41.911
And I told you that when you have these control systems, you can eliminate low frequency noise, but you're going to inject high frequency noise.

1354
01:10:42.291 --> 01:10:44.212
This thing is injecting high frequency noise, right?

1355
01:10:44.513 --> 01:10:45.934
So that there's going to be some jitter.

1356
01:10:47.001 --> 01:10:48.682
of the star there, right?

1357
01:10:48.942 --> 01:11:05.732
What you can do is you can capture that response map of a single star that's basically telling you how the instrument and this modal system that we have is responding to that jitter at every single point that the star is at, okay?

1358
01:11:05.792 --> 01:11:09.935
So you've got a response map effectively being like, this is what the astronomical jitter...

1359
01:11:11.164 --> 01:11:12.464
From the stars.

1360
01:11:12.724 --> 01:11:12.924
Yes.

1361
01:11:13.584 --> 01:11:13.805
Yes.

1362
01:11:14.425 --> 01:11:15.505
That's from all of the light.

1363
01:11:15.725 --> 01:11:15.905
Yes.

1364
01:11:16.045 --> 01:11:19.586
Then what you do is you look at something called the H-alpha emission line.

1365
01:11:19.806 --> 01:11:20.066
Okay.

1366
01:11:20.326 --> 01:11:23.086
The H-alpha emission line is because of quantum mechanics.

1367
01:11:23.526 --> 01:11:25.507
Hydrogen has discrete levels.

1368
01:11:25.587 --> 01:11:25.787
Yes.

1369
01:11:25.987 --> 01:11:26.187
Right?

1370
01:11:26.587 --> 01:11:36.529
And whenever the hydrogen atom goes from the N equals 3 to N equals 2 energy, it releases this red light.

1371
01:11:37.790 --> 01:11:40.432
That's right at 650 nanometers, about.

1372
01:11:40.452 --> 01:11:42.714
I think 656 nanometers, okay?

1373
01:11:43.194 --> 01:11:55.103
So if we look only at that frequency of light, we're going to see the gas cloud, the accretion, the disk of hydrogen around the star.

1374
01:11:55.283 --> 01:11:58.705
So what we can do is we can take an image in the H-alpha line.

1375
01:11:59.206 --> 01:12:04.470
We can take an image with all the light, subtract the two, and we'll get a nice...

1376
01:12:05.370 --> 01:12:07.232
Hydrogen gas cloud.

1377
01:12:07.552 --> 01:12:09.153
That is surrounding the star.

1378
01:12:09.253 --> 01:12:11.255
And so it's like not just that.

1379
01:12:11.335 --> 01:12:11.575
Okay.

1380
01:12:11.775 --> 01:12:19.160
We're now able to basically make the star's structure and the gas cloud structure discrete using this methodology.

1381
01:12:19.200 --> 01:12:20.021
Yes, exactly.

1382
01:12:20.381 --> 01:12:23.103
And we can do it because this is sub-diffraction, right?

1383
01:12:23.123 --> 01:12:23.283
Right.

1384
01:12:23.403 --> 01:12:28.367
This is where we're going way inside what Raleigh even thought was possible.

1385
01:12:28.387 --> 01:12:28.627
Yes.

1386
01:12:28.827 --> 01:12:29.108
Okay.

1387
01:12:29.348 --> 01:12:29.588
Yes.

1388
01:12:29.708 --> 01:12:30.309
That tracks us.

1389
01:12:30.929 --> 01:12:31.730
It's pretty cool.

1390
01:12:31.870 --> 01:12:36.955
And what they found is with this technique, they found that the disc was lopsided.

1391
01:12:37.515 --> 01:12:40.118
It's not completely like a plate.

1392
01:12:40.298 --> 01:12:41.259
It's not symmetric.

1393
01:12:41.459 --> 01:12:44.382
There's like a little bulge to it that they actually saw.

1394
01:12:44.742 --> 01:12:46.744
And there's a non-zero shift

1395
01:12:47.603 --> 01:12:48.424
in that accretion disk.

1396
01:12:48.464 --> 01:12:52.686
And that means that now the modelers can go and be like, okay, how do we, how do we get something like this?

1397
01:12:52.826 --> 01:12:52.966
Right.

1398
01:12:52.986 --> 01:12:54.387
What is causing that non-zero shift?

1399
01:12:54.907 --> 01:12:55.428
Exactly.

1400
01:12:56.008 --> 01:12:56.228
Yeah.

1401
01:12:56.368 --> 01:12:58.089
I mean, I think, I think it's really cool.

1402
01:12:58.109 --> 01:13:01.091
It proves that, you know, you've got this compact, it's cost effective.

1403
01:13:01.491 --> 01:13:03.653
You just like stick it in the back of the telescope.

1404
01:13:03.713 --> 01:13:03.893
Right.

1405
01:13:04.053 --> 01:13:04.213
Right.

1406
01:13:04.273 --> 01:13:05.334
Where the light was coming in.

1407
01:13:05.354 --> 01:13:06.954
Now, now it goes through this other thing.

1408
01:13:07.035 --> 01:13:07.935
It's a bolt on.

1409
01:13:08.255 --> 01:13:09.136
It's like a bolt on.

1410
01:13:09.296 --> 01:13:09.516
Yeah.

1411
01:13:09.536 --> 01:13:12.618
Like you don't have to rebuild any of these systems from scratch.

1412
01:13:13.118 --> 01:13:15.900
You can add this as a, as a, as an add on.

1413
01:13:17.047 --> 01:13:20.309
And it just receives the existing feed and then processes it.

1414
01:13:20.329 --> 01:13:22.330
Yeah, and then processes it in its own way.

1415
01:13:23.151 --> 01:13:25.272
And there's so much more that we can do with this.

1416
01:13:25.312 --> 01:13:27.454
You can put this on a space telescope, for example.

1417
01:13:27.474 --> 01:13:30.716
Because those guys are also limited by Raleigh, but maybe not anymore.

1418
01:13:31.436 --> 01:13:34.358
And the last photo that we had, photo 19, I just wanted to...

1419
01:13:34.698 --> 01:13:34.898
Yes.

1420
01:13:34.978 --> 01:13:36.038
Dwell on a little bit there.

1421
01:13:36.058 --> 01:13:39.139
You can see the gas cloud and you can see the clear Doppler.

1422
01:13:39.419 --> 01:13:39.679
Yes.

1423
01:13:39.919 --> 01:13:40.620
Red, blue shift.

1424
01:13:40.660 --> 01:13:41.600
Red, blue shift, right?

1425
01:13:41.660 --> 01:13:44.841
Between the part that's coming away from us and the part that's coming towards us.

1426
01:13:44.941 --> 01:13:46.901
The blue is where it's coming from towards us.

1427
01:13:47.341 --> 01:13:48.642
And the red is where it's going away.

1428
01:13:49.042 --> 01:13:53.263
And that scale bar is one micro arc second.

1429
01:13:53.343 --> 01:13:53.903
Arc second.

1430
01:13:54.123 --> 01:13:54.343
Right.

1431
01:13:54.683 --> 01:13:56.584
And I told you before there used to be 20.

1432
01:13:56.964 --> 01:13:59.265
Now you've resolved stuff to that.

1433
01:13:59.645 --> 01:14:00.025
To one.

1434
01:14:00.525 --> 01:14:04.166
And you can even see the lopsidedness that you were talking about earlier in this too.

1435
01:14:04.586 --> 01:14:06.907
This is unbelievable.

1436
01:14:06.927 --> 01:14:11.648
So I think it's a new dawn of higher than Raleigh resolution.

1437
01:14:11.809 --> 01:14:12.089
Yeah.

1438
01:14:12.869 --> 01:14:13.069
Yeah.

1439
01:14:13.189 --> 01:14:16.030
Which is, I mean, I think it's going to be really, really cool.

1440
01:14:16.250 --> 01:14:18.171
Again, this is where we talk about this all the time.

1441
01:14:18.191 --> 01:14:30.055
There's a compounding happening right now of these fundamental either techniques, methodologies, tools, combination of these things that are now not only allowing us to

1442
01:14:30.855 --> 01:14:36.138
take our existing tooling and make it better, take our existing data sets and analyze it differently.

1443
01:14:36.218 --> 01:14:36.438
Yeah.

1444
01:14:36.598 --> 01:14:39.740
By giving us a totally new way in which we see the world around us.

1445
01:14:39.980 --> 01:14:40.620
Yeah.

1446
01:14:40.960 --> 01:14:42.081
This was, this was a good story.

1447
01:14:42.121 --> 01:14:42.621
It's really cool.

1448
01:14:42.641 --> 01:14:44.102
Now that, that's, this is really cool.

1449
01:14:44.122 --> 01:14:46.163
We covered, this was a super episode.

1450
01:14:46.183 --> 01:14:47.043
We hit four stories.

1451
01:14:47.063 --> 01:14:47.264
Yep.

1452
01:14:47.804 --> 01:14:47.924
Uh,

1453
01:14:48.324 --> 01:14:50.605
I don't think we're going to hit two hours this episode.

1454
01:14:51.185 --> 01:14:51.845
We went through it quick.

1455
01:14:52.025 --> 01:14:53.226
We started with UCSD.

1456
01:14:53.586 --> 01:14:57.227
We're mass producing camouflage from octopus, octopi.

1457
01:14:57.427 --> 01:14:58.308
Yeah.

1458
01:14:58.408 --> 01:14:59.348
This was out of UCSD.

1459
01:14:59.368 --> 01:15:00.788
By hijacking bacteria.

1460
01:15:00.808 --> 01:15:03.329
By hijacking the factory, the biosynthesis.

1461
01:15:03.849 --> 01:15:08.951
We're now telling these organisms, you got to go through the factory to make what we want before you can make what you want.

1462
01:15:08.971 --> 01:15:09.211
Yeah.

1463
01:15:09.331 --> 01:15:10.012
Which is crazy.

1464
01:15:10.032 --> 01:15:10.172
Crazy.

1465
01:15:10.192 --> 01:15:10.692
Crazy.

1466
01:15:12.027 --> 01:15:14.047
This is not an ethics podcast.

1467
01:15:14.168 --> 01:15:17.668
That was in Nature Biotechnology.

1468
01:15:18.048 --> 01:15:27.190
Our second story was about these new hunting techniques in orcas, both out of CSU Monterey Bay and the Protección Conservación Pelagasia Asociación Civil AC.

1469
01:15:27.750 --> 01:15:29.151
That was in Frontiers of Marine Science.

1470
01:15:29.471 --> 01:15:39.513
That was a cool story because there's been a lot of news about the yachts being crushed by all of the orcas, but understanding culture might not be specific to human beings.

1471
01:15:41.773 --> 01:16:01.521
you know this cross pod communication process happening yeah our third story was about civet coffee and nature nature scientific reports out of the university of carla um that was that was hilarious that was fun i'm never buying 80 coffee no i barely buy nine dollar coffee which is what it is now in la yeah yeah

1472
01:16:01.961 --> 01:16:05.843
And we ended with our second UC story of the day out of UCLA.

1473
01:16:06.604 --> 01:16:13.628
We are now able to take our telescopes and see more and deeper into the universe in a way we have not before.

1474
01:16:14.028 --> 01:16:17.410
The imagery difference that we showed was crazy.

1475
01:16:17.470 --> 01:16:20.932
Because it's like, obviously, you don't have to be someone who knows.

1476
01:16:20.952 --> 01:16:22.593
You can look at one and look at the other and be like, that one's better.

1477
01:16:22.613 --> 01:16:23.253
Oh, wow, that's crazy.

1478
01:16:23.273 --> 01:16:23.713
That's better.

1479
01:16:23.893 --> 01:16:24.414
Yeah, that's way better.

1480
01:16:24.434 --> 01:16:25.254
That's really far away.

1481
01:16:25.294 --> 01:16:26.735
And, okay, we can see it that well.

1482
01:16:26.755 --> 01:16:26.875
Yeah.

1483
01:16:27.975 --> 01:16:33.977
I know when I'm trying to zoom in on my iPhone and I see all the Samsung Galaxy commercials about how you can go zoom into a skyscraper.

1484
01:16:34.037 --> 01:16:35.358
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1485
01:16:35.938 --> 01:16:37.159
Fantastic episode.

1486
01:16:37.219 --> 01:16:39.359
As always, we appreciate you guys joining us.

1487
01:16:39.780 --> 01:16:48.783
Please, if you've made it this far, there's very few of you, but if you have made it this far, I want you to comment either Civit or...

1488
01:16:49.802 --> 01:16:53.325
Wagwan or We Love You Krishna in the comments.

1489
01:16:53.845 --> 01:16:55.226
So we know you've made it this far.

1490
01:16:55.666 --> 01:16:56.387
Please subscribe.

1491
01:16:56.547 --> 01:16:57.488
Share it with a friend.

1492
01:16:57.808 --> 01:16:59.249
We're trying to really push science.

1493
01:16:59.449 --> 01:17:00.430
The shutdown is over.

1494
01:17:00.650 --> 01:17:00.930
Yes.

1495
01:17:00.970 --> 01:17:04.893
Which might mean we'll get some scientific funding back in the mix.

1496
01:17:04.933 --> 01:17:05.213
Yes.

1497
01:17:05.493 --> 01:17:06.774
We still need to do more.

1498
01:17:06.974 --> 01:17:07.194
Yeah.

1499
01:17:07.355 --> 01:17:08.675
We cannot fall behind.

1500
01:17:08.856 --> 01:17:09.676
Always.

1501
01:17:10.517 --> 01:17:14.680
I'm joined, as always, by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

1502
01:17:15.020 --> 01:17:16.101
My name is Lester Nare.

1503
01:17:16.541 --> 01:17:18.222
This is From First Principles.

1504
01:17:18.242 --> 01:17:19.263
We'll see you guys next week.
