WEBVTT

1
00:00:03.323 --> 00:00:09.227
A chemist in Paris and a chemist in Tokyo who cracked one of life's oddest habits.

2
00:00:10.307 --> 00:00:11.188
Look at your hands.

3
00:00:12.148 --> 00:00:12.929
Mirror images.

4
00:00:13.849 --> 00:00:17.031
But a left glove won't fit your right hand.

5
00:00:18.112 --> 00:00:21.394
Many molecules come in left and right versions too.

6
00:00:22.415 --> 00:00:23.756
One smells like spearmint.

7
00:00:24.316 --> 00:00:26.357
Its mirror twin smells like rye bread.

8
00:00:27.438 --> 00:00:30.700
But chemistry in a flask always makes both.

9
00:00:30.720 --> 00:00:31.540
50-50.

10
00:00:33.527 --> 00:00:37.408
In 1986, Henri Gagin found something odd.

11
00:00:38.328 --> 00:00:44.309
A catalyst that was only a little right-handed made products that were mostly right-handed.

12
00:00:45.489 --> 00:00:49.370
Picture six right-handers and four lefties on a dance floor.

13
00:00:50.330 --> 00:00:53.691
Each lefty pairs off with a right-hander and sits down.

14
00:00:54.671 --> 00:00:55.672
Who's still dancing?

15
00:00:56.452 --> 00:00:57.492
Only right-handers.

16
00:00:58.590 --> 00:01:06.097
Then, Kenzo Soai built a molecule that copies itself, hand and all, like a rumor that spreads.

17
00:01:07.218 --> 00:01:14.364
A head start of one molecule in two million became more than 99% in just three rounds.

18
00:01:16.025 --> 00:01:18.828
Life builds itself from just one hand.

19
00:01:19.989 --> 00:01:24.593
This is a clue to how that happened, and a sharper way to make medicines.

20
00:01:25.752 --> 00:01:29.651
And this is the 2026 Nobel Prize in Chemistry.

21
00:01:33.620 --> 00:01:34.440
Hello, Internet.

22
00:01:34.480 --> 00:01:43.524
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

23
00:01:44.205 --> 00:01:50.267
We are on day three and our final day of Nobel Prize week.

24
00:01:50.768 --> 00:02:01.773
We are going to go from the search for ghostly particles in Antarctica to the winner of the chemistry Nobel Prize.

25
00:02:02.713 --> 00:02:09.101
And this one is interesting and it reminds me of one of my favorite episodes that we did at the end of last year.

26
00:02:10.262 --> 00:02:12.925
We have left and right hands.

27
00:02:13.786 --> 00:02:17.390
And similarly, there are left and right molecules.

28
00:02:17.650 --> 00:02:22.316
But life overwhelmingly prefers one specific thing.

29
00:02:22.656 --> 00:02:28.138
Today's prize is about how chemistry can make that asymmetry happen.

30
00:02:28.158 --> 00:02:32.500
It connects the way we make medicines to a much older question.

31
00:02:32.840 --> 00:02:38.323
Why did life settle on particular molecular building blocks in the first place?

32
00:02:39.003 --> 00:02:40.504
This is going to be interesting.

33
00:02:40.884 --> 00:02:48.167
As always, we are going to talk about the science from the ground up today, starting with who won.

34
00:02:49.637 --> 00:03:04.760
The 2026 Nobel Prize in Chemistry has been awarded to Henri B. Cagan of the former University Paris-Sud in France and Kenzo Soai of Tokyo University of Science in Japan.

35
00:03:05.340 --> 00:03:14.342
And the official citation is for the discovery of nonlinear effects and autocatalysis in asymmetric organic synthesis.

36
00:03:14.602 --> 00:03:15.402
Talk about a mouthful.

37
00:03:15.602 --> 00:03:15.842
Yeah.

38
00:03:16.182 --> 00:03:19.823
But by the end of the episode, we will have unpacked that statement.

39
00:03:20.243 --> 00:03:25.185
And there's a hint in the words nonlinear and asymmetric autocatalysis.

40
00:03:25.545 --> 00:03:31.907
For anyone familiar with biochemistry, this should immediately ring a bell because that's kind of what life is.

41
00:03:32.227 --> 00:03:32.467
Okay.

42
00:03:32.968 --> 00:03:37.029
It's a nonlinear phenomenon because, you know, reproduction happens.

43
00:03:37.469 --> 00:03:39.930
And if you've ever seen the bacterium sort of

44
00:03:41.030 --> 00:04:09.582
expand in a petri dish from one you get two to four to eight and there's this doubling factor so obviously that's non-linear and it's a kind of auto catalysis because it's a bunch of chemical reactions that make themselves right the dna makes more dna makes more dna obviously there are multiple steps in the process but at the end of the day life is non-linear and it is auto catalysis it's also asymmetric because of the kinds of molecules that life prefers

45
00:04:10.752 --> 00:04:17.601
Even though the molecules in life can exist in symmetric parts, life is remarkably consistent with which one it uses.

46
00:04:17.661 --> 00:04:19.304
DNA is a great example of this.

47
00:04:20.706 --> 00:04:26.113
DNA is right-handed, meaning if I were to put my thumb on the axis of a DNA molecule...

48
00:04:26.564 --> 00:04:29.745
The curve is always the way that my fingers wrap around.

49
00:04:29.785 --> 00:04:36.108
It's always going to go right-handed, sort of clockwise, if I were looking up the axis of DNA.

50
00:04:36.128 --> 00:04:39.770
But you can make DNA that is left-handed, right?

51
00:04:40.170 --> 00:04:41.450
It's just that life never does it.

52
00:04:42.051 --> 00:04:53.896
So the two Loretz contributions fit together here because Kagan showed that a small imbalance in a catalyst can produce a substantially greater imbalance in the product.

53
00:04:56.737 --> 00:05:00.960
more right-handed than left-handed, then you can make that nonlinear effect.

54
00:05:01.401 --> 00:05:06.705
And so I found a reaction in which the product becomes the catalyst for making more product.

55
00:05:06.745 --> 00:05:08.286
That's that autocatalysis part.

56
00:05:08.967 --> 00:05:13.330
Okay, so before we unpack the chemistry, what is the surprising part here?

57
00:05:13.391 --> 00:05:18.755
Why wouldn't a small advantage naturally just become a big advantage?

58
00:05:18.775 --> 00:05:18.935
Okay.

59
00:05:19.099 --> 00:05:19.299
Right.

60
00:05:19.599 --> 00:05:23.040
And that's actually what I was asking when I was researching this kind of stuff.

61
00:05:23.541 --> 00:05:30.743
It turns out that making more material and increasing its purity are two different achievements.

62
00:05:30.763 --> 00:05:35.465
So if you repeatedly double, let's say you've got a mixture of 51, 49, but the 51...

63
00:05:40.340 --> 00:05:49.183
of molecules start making their own version and the 49% make their own version, the ratio is going to remain exactly the same, right?

64
00:05:49.483 --> 00:05:55.986
So there's something in the chemistry that has to favor the majority disproportionately for the imbalance to grow.

65
00:05:56.586 --> 00:05:58.767
And that is what this Nobel Prize is about.

66
00:05:58.787 --> 00:05:59.807
That's the key distinction.

67
00:06:00.247 --> 00:06:04.569
It matters for making useful molecules, including pharmaceutical intermediates.

68
00:06:05.009 --> 00:06:08.170
It also gives us an experimental way to investigate molecules.

69
00:06:08.624 --> 00:06:15.132
the holy grail of biochemistry, which is how a world of molecules, an abiotic world,

70
00:06:16.302 --> 00:06:24.723
without a consistent handedness, could give rise to the life that we have on the planet Earth, which is all one particular handedness.

71
00:06:25.644 --> 00:06:32.165
So we've talked a lot about handedness, and it's not just an analogy.

72
00:06:33.305 --> 00:06:37.526
So what does it mean for a molecule to be left or right-handed?

73
00:06:37.706 --> 00:06:43.047
Yeah, we went into detail with our Yang Mills episode, but we'll do it again.

74
00:06:43.407 --> 00:06:45.307
So let's hold our hands...

75
00:06:46.519 --> 00:06:47.500
This is my left hand.

76
00:06:47.560 --> 00:06:48.541
This is my right hand.

77
00:06:49.401 --> 00:06:57.428
There is no transformation that I can do to my right hand, like rotating wise, that will give me my left hand.

78
00:06:57.548 --> 00:06:58.629
Even if I rotate it, right?

79
00:06:59.009 --> 00:07:03.233
Sure, they meet up to form like a prayer hand or a clap.

80
00:07:03.673 --> 00:07:05.735
But these are two separate things, right?

81
00:07:05.995 --> 00:07:08.898
Because in this case, the hand is facing me.

82
00:07:08.958 --> 00:07:09.878
The thumb is to the left.

83
00:07:09.918 --> 00:07:10.959
But the hand is facing me.

84
00:07:10.999 --> 00:07:11.960
My palm is facing me.

85
00:07:12.260 --> 00:07:14.002
And here the back of my hand is facing me.

86
00:07:14.142 --> 00:07:15.403
The front is facing the camera.

87
00:07:15.699 --> 00:07:20.945
So even though the thumb is pointing in the same direction, these are not the same, right?

88
00:07:21.526 --> 00:07:26.191
So it requires this 3D point of view to really understand this.

89
00:07:26.572 --> 00:07:29.675
And the chemistry world has a word for this.

90
00:07:29.735 --> 00:07:32.779
It's called chirality from the Greek word forehand.

91
00:07:33.315 --> 00:07:35.917
And so we would say that our hands are chiral.

92
00:07:36.338 --> 00:07:36.558
Okay.

93
00:07:36.818 --> 00:07:39.741
Now let's look at some of the building blocks of life itself.

94
00:07:40.121 --> 00:07:41.042
This is alanine.

95
00:07:41.162 --> 00:07:42.103
It's an amino acid.

96
00:07:42.383 --> 00:07:46.987
Sometimes you can buy it in a powder if you want to like get swole or whatever.

97
00:07:47.347 --> 00:07:47.548
Right.

98
00:07:47.968 --> 00:07:52.252
And on the left-hand side, we see the chemical diagram of this thing.

99
00:07:52.572 --> 00:07:53.713
There's a carbon at the center.

100
00:07:54.278 --> 00:07:59.619
It's an amino acid, so it's got an amine group, an NH2 to its left, a carboxyl group to its right.

101
00:07:59.759 --> 00:08:00.840
That's a COOH.

102
00:08:01.000 --> 00:08:06.141
And then the R group, which is the thing that changes for every single amino acid.

103
00:08:06.461 --> 00:08:08.721
In this case, it's just a methyl group, CH3.

104
00:08:09.182 --> 00:08:12.542
If you look at that diagram itself, you don't find anything funny.

105
00:08:12.862 --> 00:08:14.823
But if you look at the 3D picture...

106
00:08:16.061 --> 00:08:17.642
You find that there are two versions.

107
00:08:18.183 --> 00:08:23.608
There's the left-handed alumine and the right-handed alumine, which in chemistry they call D-alamine.

108
00:08:24.308 --> 00:08:26.570
L-alamine is the left-hand version.

109
00:08:27.431 --> 00:08:36.138
And these are chiral molecules because just with our hand, there's no way to rotate one hand to make it the other.

110
00:08:36.459 --> 00:08:37.980
There's no way to rotate...

111
00:08:38.508 --> 00:08:44.111
the right-handed enantiomer, which is the right-handed version of this molecule, to make it the left.

112
00:08:44.411 --> 00:08:45.352
It's the same atoms.

113
00:08:46.032 --> 00:08:47.733
It's the same bonds even, right?

114
00:08:47.813 --> 00:08:54.316
The carbons are bonded to the oxygen in exactly the same way and the nitrogen in exactly the same way.

115
00:08:54.616 --> 00:09:00.319
But in one case, the oxygen is coming out of the page, and in the other case, the oxygen is going into the page.

116
00:09:00.659 --> 00:09:07.403
Just like how our hands, in one case, the palm is facing me, but in the other case, the back of my hand is facing me.

117
00:09:09.003 --> 00:09:15.882
This is what we talk about when we're talking about mirror image molecules and why they're chemically alike in some environments

118
00:09:17.299 --> 00:09:20.042
In other environments, you can actually distinguish them.

119
00:09:20.702 --> 00:09:22.244
And that last detail is what matters.

120
00:09:22.284 --> 00:09:26.167
If you look at the left-hand side, the flat diagram does not give you the information.

121
00:09:26.488 --> 00:09:33.294
You need the 3D information to distinguish between the left and the right-handed version.

122
00:09:33.574 --> 00:09:35.756
Now, not everything in life is chiral.

123
00:09:35.897 --> 00:09:37.498
You can have achiral molecules.

124
00:09:37.578 --> 00:09:38.939
For example, there is...

125
00:09:39.838 --> 00:09:45.922
The glycerol molecule, which is just carbons with a bunch of OH groups attached, that is achiral.

126
00:09:45.962 --> 00:09:49.564
If I take a mirror image of that, it's the same.

127
00:09:49.844 --> 00:09:54.947
Fatty acids like betyric acid, again, if I take a mirror image of that, it's going to be exactly the same.

128
00:09:56.148 --> 00:09:57.969
Glucose, on the other hand, is chiral.

129
00:09:58.329 --> 00:09:59.129
So it's ribose.

130
00:09:59.790 --> 00:10:03.732
That's why actually DNA and RNA have a particular handedness,

131
00:10:09.143 --> 00:10:12.244
We only use a particular handedness, and that's what causes the spiral.

132
00:10:12.604 --> 00:10:19.226
Deoxyribose, again, has a particular handedness, in this case right-handed, which is why DNA is right-handed.

133
00:10:19.606 --> 00:10:22.747
So in biology, you have a mixture of both.

134
00:10:23.847 --> 00:10:29.329
But this has crucial implications for biochemistry in general.

135
00:10:29.389 --> 00:10:32.390
Because imagine trying to fit a right-handed organism.

136
00:10:33.244 --> 00:10:54.345
glove into your left hand it's just not going to work right and this has implications in biochemistry because the glove you can imagine is an enzyme that has a particular handedness and it is expecting the same handedness of whatever thing that it's going to bind to right if you give it the other handedness

137
00:10:55.675 --> 00:10:56.576
Things are going to get funny.

138
00:10:58.257 --> 00:11:06.944
One of the big implications of this is, for example, the left-handed carvone, which is the odor that we get from spearmint, right?

139
00:11:07.144 --> 00:11:14.910
We've got a photo of that where we show the left-handed version of carvone is how we get spearmint.

140
00:11:15.711 --> 00:11:19.093
That's the odor that we get from, you know, when we smell mint.

141
00:11:19.453 --> 00:11:21.315
The right-handed version of the same molecule,

142
00:11:25.621 --> 00:11:26.342
get confused.

143
00:11:26.863 --> 00:11:29.226
They start smelling something completely different.

144
00:11:29.286 --> 00:11:30.408
It's the odor of caraway.

145
00:11:31.490 --> 00:11:32.711
The same chemistry...

146
00:11:33.538 --> 00:11:35.540
The same, I shouldn't say the same chemistry.

147
00:11:35.880 --> 00:11:36.741
The chemists will get mad.

148
00:11:37.201 --> 00:11:45.687
The same atoms, the same arrangement of atoms, but in the 3D world, they look entirely different because they are mirror images.

149
00:11:46.068 --> 00:11:50.431
And that has an effect on how we actually sense this molecule.

150
00:11:51.512 --> 00:11:56.055
And so these two forms, they differ in activity, metabolism, side effects.

151
00:11:56.636 --> 00:11:58.817
Sometimes both are useful, sometimes not.

152
00:11:59.298 --> 00:12:00.739
And the point is that their behavior is,

153
00:12:01.072 --> 00:12:05.135
can be measured, and you can infer it by looking at their activity.

154
00:12:05.796 --> 00:12:07.037
This is incredible.

155
00:12:07.157 --> 00:12:19.847
And so I think the next natural question here, now that we kind of understand this idea of handedness, especially that you can look at a 2D diagram versus a 3D diagram, and there's different implications based on how you're looking at it.

156
00:12:20.808 --> 00:12:27.694
How did we, in chemistry, even get to the point where we discovered this idea of left and right-handedness?

157
00:12:27.714 --> 00:12:27.914
Yeah.

158
00:12:27.974 --> 00:12:37.867
Yeah, I mean, the Nobel Prize in Chemistry in this year, 2026, the results form from a long chain of ideas, as is classic in all of science.

159
00:12:38.087 --> 00:12:41.211
And the first result really goes back to the mid-19th century.

160
00:12:41.251 --> 00:12:43.153
It all began with Louis Pasteur.

161
00:12:43.654 --> 00:12:46.718
He was investigating a substance that is important for wine production—

162
00:12:47.768 --> 00:12:49.548
We all like wine here in California.

163
00:12:50.608 --> 00:12:52.749
He was investigating tartaric acid.

164
00:12:53.409 --> 00:12:56.750
He was French, so obviously they're obsessed with wines.

165
00:12:57.450 --> 00:13:05.491
Let me just say, it's been shown in international competitions that California wines are better than French wines.

166
00:13:05.811 --> 00:13:08.091
I heard he's from the French region of Tartaria.

167
00:13:09.632 --> 00:13:10.192
Is that a thing?

168
00:13:10.752 --> 00:13:11.852
No, it should be.

169
00:13:12.232 --> 00:13:16.553
But in any case, tartaric acid is the stuff that you might recognize

170
00:13:17.597 --> 00:13:18.858
from wine diamonds.

171
00:13:18.978 --> 00:13:27.665
This is the particulates that kind of settle at the bottom of a glass, or sometimes they form in the cork, as you see on the upper right-hand side.

172
00:13:27.965 --> 00:13:32.209
These are little crystals of potassium bipartite, and they...

173
00:13:33.716 --> 00:13:37.178
take on the form, they take on the color of whatever wine is in there.

174
00:13:37.478 --> 00:13:44.682
They're harmless, and sometimes they're actually manufactured in wine barrels, because they'll settle at the bottom, right?

175
00:13:45.162 --> 00:13:54.087
Now, Louis Pasteur heard about tartaric acid, and his colleagues said that sometimes they bent polarized light to the right, and sometimes...

176
00:13:54.947 --> 00:13:57.948
the crystals bent polarized light to the left.

177
00:13:58.628 --> 00:14:00.509
And that really piqued his interest.

178
00:14:00.589 --> 00:14:04.490
So he grew crystals of tartaric acid and examined them under a microscope.

179
00:14:05.690 --> 00:14:09.432
And he discovered they exist in two different variants.

180
00:14:10.052 --> 00:14:14.413
On the left-hand side, we actually see some of the drawings that he made of these crystals.

181
00:14:14.433 --> 00:14:16.314
And you can see they're mirror images of one another.

182
00:14:16.714 --> 00:14:19.775
So the crystals themselves came in these two different forms.

183
00:14:20.195 --> 00:14:27.500
And one of the geniuses of Louis Pasteur is to look under the microscope and notice that difference.

184
00:14:28.400 --> 00:14:31.722
Under a microscope, it's very easy to be like, oh, they're the same crystal.

185
00:14:32.202 --> 00:14:38.867
But the mind of Louis Pasteur, the genius that he was, he noticed that subtle difference that actually...

186
00:14:39.825 --> 00:14:44.489
If you arrange them, because like in the drawing, they come out in this nice arrangement, right?

187
00:14:44.509 --> 00:14:46.011
But that's because he's drawing it that way.

188
00:14:46.311 --> 00:14:51.236
Presumably on the Petri dish where he's looking under the microscope, there are all these different arrangements.

189
00:14:51.536 --> 00:14:55.980
And he was able to notice, right, with a light microscope that there are these two versions.

190
00:14:56.300 --> 00:15:02.346
And there we have actually the Louis Pasteur Institute still has little vials of the bipartite vials.

191
00:15:03.238 --> 00:15:07.700
that he made in these vials, which is absolutely incredible, right?

192
00:15:07.720 --> 00:15:19.066
So he discovered that there's these two variants, each that are mirror images, and then using little tweezers, he separated out samples of one-handedness and samples of another-handedness.

193
00:15:19.326 --> 00:15:21.748
But this is at the aggregate crystal level, okay?

194
00:15:22.368 --> 00:15:31.273
Now, from that aggregate crystal, he dissolved each thing in liquids, and he found that one of them bent light to the right,

195
00:15:32.073 --> 00:15:33.914
and the other one bent light to the left.

196
00:15:33.994 --> 00:15:40.556
This is a classic experiment that we see in, like, when we talk about chirality and molecules that are chiral.

197
00:15:40.916 --> 00:15:49.238
What you do is you have a light source that brings out unpolarized light, unpolarized light meaning the electric field of your light wave is in every direction.

198
00:15:49.939 --> 00:15:56.201
You put that through a polarizer, which is like the stuff, you know, the sunglasses that we have with the polarized sunglasses.

199
00:15:56.481 --> 00:16:00.322
That's literally a polarizing filter that selects for a particular

200
00:16:00.842 --> 00:16:02.946
orientation of electromagnetic field.

201
00:16:03.006 --> 00:16:10.918
Like the light is, you know, oscillating in all these different directions and the polarizer preferentially selects one particular orientation.

202
00:16:11.399 --> 00:16:15.625
So now that you have polarized light that's gone through this set of glasses, you're going to see

203
00:16:15.785 --> 00:16:24.154
you put that through your sample, which is a dissolved liquid that has either the left-hand side version of the crystal or the right-hand side version of the crystal.

204
00:16:24.674 --> 00:16:31.941
And what he noticed was the axis of polarization would rotate as the light propagated through the medium.

205
00:16:32.642 --> 00:16:36.726
And you can tell that by putting another polarizer on the right-hand side and seeing how much comes out.

206
00:16:37.547 --> 00:16:39.249
Depending on the angle, you would get...

207
00:16:40.153 --> 00:16:42.494
a lot of absorption or not absorption at all.

208
00:16:42.894 --> 00:16:43.395
This is interesting.

209
00:16:43.435 --> 00:16:49.958
It's both kind of like a control mechanism on the left-hand side as the polarizer and then like a sensor on the right-hand side as an analyzer.

210
00:16:50.078 --> 00:16:50.498
Exactly.

211
00:16:50.578 --> 00:16:54.900
And this is a classic experiment now that we use in a lot of chemistry labs.

212
00:16:55.201 --> 00:17:05.686
The striking part is that the distinction between the left and right crystals survived dissolving stuff into the liquid and then putting it into this polarizer.

213
00:17:06.046 --> 00:17:06.306
Okay?

214
00:17:06.546 --> 00:17:09.428
So that's telling you that the things that make up the crystal

215
00:17:10.478 --> 00:17:13.182
have that property of left and right handedness.

216
00:17:13.322 --> 00:17:14.424
This was the key observation.

217
00:17:14.444 --> 00:17:16.407
It's not an artifact of the experimental setup.

218
00:17:16.487 --> 00:17:17.148
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

219
00:17:17.168 --> 00:17:23.358
It's not like the crystal is growing in some weird, you know, like the left hand side of the Petri dish has some temperature and the right hand side.

220
00:17:23.598 --> 00:17:25.621
No, it's like literally the things that make up

221
00:17:26.422 --> 00:17:29.865
this crystal are left and right-handed, right?

222
00:17:30.125 --> 00:17:39.833
And this property matters because when it came to these tartaric crystal molecules, the next experiment that he did was whether bacteria preferred one or the other.

223
00:17:40.194 --> 00:17:41.955
And he saw that indeed they did.

224
00:17:42.135 --> 00:17:43.416
This was in 1857.

225
00:17:43.737 --> 00:17:48.441
He investigated what happened if bacteria fermented on tartaric acid

226
00:17:49.493 --> 00:17:52.354
preferred, you know, growth on one medium versus the other.

227
00:17:52.694 --> 00:17:55.455
He saw that bacteria willingly fermented.

228
00:17:55.955 --> 00:18:02.098
The bacteria were great at eating one particular type of tartaric acid.

229
00:18:02.138 --> 00:18:05.619
This is the same type that was found in grapes and found in wine bottles.

230
00:18:05.979 --> 00:18:09.040
But the other type, they did not eat at all.

231
00:18:09.101 --> 00:18:10.521
The bacteria did not grow at all.

232
00:18:10.921 --> 00:18:15.403
And this is the first indication that life's chemistry is somehow chiral.

233
00:18:16.247 --> 00:18:26.578
So Pasteur kind of started this process by separating these different types of crystals, which are at a macro size level, because they had some differences in it.

234
00:18:26.818 --> 00:18:33.725
But the thing he really discovered was this underlying property of what would have been at the time these invisible molecules.

235
00:18:33.765 --> 00:18:34.486
Yes, exactly.

236
00:18:34.566 --> 00:18:35.527
And at that point –

237
00:18:36.207 --> 00:18:37.509
Atomic theory was new.

238
00:18:37.809 --> 00:18:43.174
Like, there wasn't really a sense of, like, atoms and molecules in the sense that we now take for granted, right?

239
00:18:43.414 --> 00:18:45.236
But that was the key conceptual leap.

240
00:18:45.596 --> 00:18:54.105
And later, when researchers began studying life's building blocks, they discovered that naturally occurring amino acids all bend polarized light to the left.

241
00:18:54.952 --> 00:19:01.377
So all of the naturally occurring amino acids, you dissolve them into a solution, the polarized light always bends towards the left.

242
00:19:01.757 --> 00:19:09.483
And this is where we get left-handed amino acids like L-alanine that we were talking about earlier, leucine, valine, every single amino acid that is chiral

243
00:19:10.770 --> 00:19:19.615
Life uses only a particular type of chirality, and that's why we call life homochirality, because homo is the same, chirality meaning this handedness.

244
00:19:21.436 --> 00:19:25.618
Subsequent experiments in sugars found that DNA helix is the opposite.

245
00:19:25.718 --> 00:19:28.840
It's actually right-handed, and the sugars are actually right-handed.

246
00:19:29.160 --> 00:19:34.981
And that's because the glove kind of fits the, you know, the enzymes fit the right-handed version, things like that.

247
00:19:35.341 --> 00:19:38.882
And this insight is pretty incredible, right?

248
00:19:39.482 --> 00:19:44.643
And the next question, obviously, is what happened at the dawn of life to make life's chemistry one-handed?

249
00:19:45.183 --> 00:19:49.183
Because Pasteur was able to create both versions in his lab, right?

250
00:19:49.223 --> 00:19:53.864
If you grow tartaric acid abiotically, you'll get both versions of the crystal.

251
00:19:54.224 --> 00:19:58.025
But everywhere that we see in life, they prefer only one-handedness.

252
00:19:58.805 --> 00:20:07.391
And when we try to figure that out, the main question is, why do living organisms only use one mirror image of the amino acids?

253
00:20:07.431 --> 00:20:10.293
Like, how can this preference even arise?

254
00:20:11.374 --> 00:20:15.477
Now, some chemists just claim that chiral chemistry is unique to life, right?

255
00:20:15.617 --> 00:20:19.980
Maybe it could be that, like, there's, like, you know, some woo-woo thing.

256
00:20:20.060 --> 00:20:20.640
Hand-wavy.

257
00:20:20.780 --> 00:20:27.145
Yeah, hand-wavy woo-woo thing of, like, vitalism, where, like, life has some, like, force, right?

258
00:20:27.165 --> 00:20:27.465
Right.

259
00:20:28.761 --> 00:20:32.542
is beyond the laws of physics as of now that we haven't seen.

260
00:20:32.662 --> 00:20:42.525
But in the 1900s, a German chemist, Willy Markwald, he showed that, no, I can actually make a reaction that prefers one way or the other.

261
00:20:42.705 --> 00:20:46.626
This is the first time that we've found a reaction like this.

262
00:20:46.966 --> 00:20:48.206
He used a catalyst.

263
00:20:48.506 --> 00:20:55.528
A catalyst is basically an intermediary in a chemical reaction that facilitates a chemical reaction.

264
00:20:55.892 --> 00:21:07.004
He figured out that actually if the catalyst itself has a particular handedness, then it will prefer to make products of that same handedness versus the other handedness.

265
00:21:07.324 --> 00:21:08.506
Well, sometimes the other way around.

266
00:21:08.546 --> 00:21:09.266
But in any case...

267
00:21:10.168 --> 00:21:13.470
You've got two different products that you can make, the left and the right-handed version.

268
00:21:13.951 --> 00:21:23.437
If the thing that is making the product is itself right or left-handed, then you can skew the chances one way or the other, right?

269
00:21:23.818 --> 00:21:31.103
And this particular experiment here, this is from the Nobel Committee, the visualizations that they put out.

270
00:21:32.010 --> 00:21:51.977
Here, the key thing is you've got a metal ion that is marked M in black that is associated with a chiral molecule, and then that thing attaches to a substrate, and that entire complex starts creating one particular side of products versus the other.

271
00:21:52.657 --> 00:21:57.339
Now, in this case, both are being created, but one is preferred over the other.

272
00:21:57.959 --> 00:22:01.140
In physical terms, what this really means is that both pathways...

273
00:22:01.974 --> 00:22:04.258
have different activation energies.

274
00:22:04.859 --> 00:22:12.613
We've got a little diagram that kind of shows this, where if we talk about reaction progress on the x-axis...

275
00:22:12.713 --> 00:22:13.014
Okay.

276
00:22:13.567 --> 00:22:16.049
That means going from reactants to products.

277
00:22:16.069 --> 00:22:17.790
You can think about it as a time axis.

278
00:22:17.870 --> 00:22:22.054
It's not exactly, but let's just say for this visual, it's a time axis.

279
00:22:22.394 --> 00:22:25.516
The Gibbs free energy is on the y-axis.

280
00:22:25.717 --> 00:22:31.741
That tells you effectively what is the energy of the chemicals that are involved here.

281
00:22:32.021 --> 00:22:35.384
The reactants have a higher energy and the products have a lower energy.

282
00:22:35.424 --> 00:22:38.026
That's why, just like in physics, you go from high to low energy.

283
00:22:38.427 --> 00:22:41.189
But in order to get there, you have to go through this hill, which is the activation energy.

284
00:22:41.209 --> 00:22:42.730
That's why, just like in physics, you go from high to low energy.

285
00:22:42.970 --> 00:22:49.874
That's why every time you put reactants into a vial, they're not going to immediately go to products.

286
00:22:49.934 --> 00:22:52.996
A lot of times they're going to stay reactants because you have this energy barrier.

287
00:22:53.328 --> 00:22:57.930
when I put my Mentos into my Coca-Cola, it doesn't immediately explode.

288
00:22:57.950 --> 00:22:58.890
There's a little buffer time.

289
00:22:58.950 --> 00:23:00.031
There's a little buffer time.

290
00:23:00.071 --> 00:23:04.933
And that's because, you know, the jiggling is getting over that activation energy.

291
00:23:05.133 --> 00:23:13.316
But as you know, the stuff is a runaway reaction because the jiggling creates higher temperature, which then creates more jiggling, which creates more jiggling.

292
00:23:13.576 --> 00:23:16.078
And so more and more stuff go over the activation energy.

293
00:23:16.858 --> 00:23:21.480
What's happening with the chiral catalyst is that the activation energy is decreased

294
00:23:22.195 --> 00:23:30.624
For the ones that are preferred, like let's say the right-hand side has a lower activation than the left-hand side because the catalyst is preferring that one over the other.

295
00:23:30.644 --> 00:23:35.830
And that's why there's more right-hand side reactants or products, I should say, versus the other.

296
00:23:35.850 --> 00:23:42.056
There's more right-hand side products versus the other because the activation energy is lowered because that catalyst itself...

297
00:23:42.757 --> 00:23:43.838
is right or left-handed.

298
00:23:44.498 --> 00:23:52.323
Depending on its handedness of the catalyst, the entry point for the end product of that same handedness has a lower barrier to entry.

299
00:23:52.463 --> 00:23:52.903
Exactly.

300
00:23:53.043 --> 00:23:54.885
And this was in the early 1900s.

301
00:23:55.245 --> 00:24:00.808
The difference was small, but the mere existence of it is revolutionary because this means that it's not just life.

302
00:24:01.549 --> 00:24:08.233
We can create organic stuff in our Petri dish, in our vial,

303
00:24:09.248 --> 00:24:11.409
That creates this asymmetry.

304
00:24:11.630 --> 00:24:13.651
So there's the potential.

305
00:24:13.671 --> 00:24:14.552
You're saying there's a chance.

306
00:24:14.592 --> 00:24:14.772
Yes.

307
00:24:14.812 --> 00:24:15.372
The woo-woo.

308
00:24:15.592 --> 00:24:17.333
It's not the vitality.

309
00:24:17.554 --> 00:24:17.754
Yeah.

310
00:24:17.954 --> 00:24:24.078
And there's a way to fundamentally understand what life is doing to make it homochiral.

311
00:24:24.098 --> 00:24:28.461
Like this is now where we are like, okay, there's a path that we can go down.

312
00:24:28.661 --> 00:24:29.001
Exactly.

313
00:24:29.021 --> 00:24:30.562
To understand that fundamental question.

314
00:24:30.702 --> 00:24:31.103
Exactly.

315
00:24:31.143 --> 00:24:33.204
And this is where the theoretical physicists come in.

316
00:24:33.424 --> 00:24:33.785
Oh, yes.

317
00:24:33.945 --> 00:24:34.165
Right?

318
00:24:35.346 --> 00:24:36.146
This brings us to 1953.

319
00:24:36.186 --> 00:24:36.366
Yeah.

320
00:24:37.967 --> 00:24:43.071
There's an article by Charles Frank from the University of Bristol.

321
00:24:43.131 --> 00:24:45.893
I should say Sir Charles Frank because he was knighted.

322
00:24:45.933 --> 00:24:47.254
He's a fellow of the Royal Society.

323
00:24:47.915 --> 00:24:50.217
And he is a theoretical physicist who...

324
00:24:51.166 --> 00:24:57.829
A colleague describes to him the fact that chemistry and chemists can't really understand why life's asymmetry arose.

325
00:24:58.530 --> 00:25:04.712
And maybe a mathematical solution or like at least a roadmap to understanding this problem would be nice.

326
00:25:05.213 --> 00:25:09.435
And so Charles Frank writes this paper and it's kind of a –

327
00:25:10.135 --> 00:25:14.217
It's a classic theoretical physicist paper of like, this is trivial.

328
00:25:15.357 --> 00:25:20.179
He's the kind of theoretical physicist that everyone hates, especially the experimentalist.

329
00:25:20.559 --> 00:25:20.839
Okay.

330
00:25:21.159 --> 00:25:28.362
Like in his introduction, he talks about how like, you know, this is...

331
00:25:29.740 --> 00:25:30.861
This is... Guys.

332
00:25:30.901 --> 00:25:31.721
Why are you wasting my time?

333
00:25:31.741 --> 00:25:32.562
Yeah, yeah.

334
00:25:32.702 --> 00:25:39.785
And he responds with three categories that we need to establish in order to make something like an asymmetry like this happen.

335
00:25:40.085 --> 00:25:44.548
The first one is that there is a chiral catalyst and an asymmetric reaction.

336
00:25:44.568 --> 00:25:50.311
That's the kind that we had just discussed from Willy Markwald.

337
00:25:51.471 --> 00:25:54.173
The second stipulation...

338
00:25:54.788 --> 00:25:59.509
is that the formation of one of the mirror images is somehow enhanced and the other is dampened.

339
00:26:00.489 --> 00:26:03.370
This means that there's an inhibition of types.

340
00:26:04.050 --> 00:26:05.570
Okay, you're not just making both.

341
00:26:05.890 --> 00:26:08.511
Somehow the presence of one is making the other one worse.

342
00:26:09.111 --> 00:26:09.331
Okay?

343
00:26:09.691 --> 00:26:13.292
And the third is that the chemical reaction has to form the catalyst itself.

344
00:26:14.012 --> 00:26:15.772
You need a runaway reaction.

345
00:26:16.152 --> 00:26:18.773
You need the product itself to go back into the reaction.

346
00:26:19.155 --> 00:26:21.676
and feed in, so you get this nonlinear effect.

347
00:26:21.736 --> 00:26:24.597
So he's putting out a roadmap, okay?

348
00:26:24.937 --> 00:26:29.179
That last part is called autocatalysis, and that's the self-reinforcing effect.

349
00:26:29.479 --> 00:26:37.102
And Frank concludes his report by just laconically noting that a laboratory demonstration may not be impossible.

350
00:26:37.928 --> 00:26:39.368
Like, really?

351
00:26:39.509 --> 00:26:39.689
Yeah.

352
00:26:39.929 --> 00:26:42.950
This is something that classic theoretical physicists do.

353
00:26:43.130 --> 00:26:46.191
It's like, oh, why don't you just figure it out?

354
00:26:46.231 --> 00:26:46.931
Just go do it.

355
00:26:47.051 --> 00:26:47.331
Yeah.

356
00:26:47.391 --> 00:26:48.651
Like, what are you asking me for?

357
00:26:48.711 --> 00:26:48.951
Yeah.

358
00:26:49.152 --> 00:26:50.092
It's like, oh, really?

359
00:26:50.432 --> 00:26:51.172
Okay, nice.

360
00:26:52.373 --> 00:26:58.414
Well, his paper does make waves because now we've got kind of a roadmap on how to get there, right?

361
00:26:58.574 --> 00:27:00.535
And it's spread widely among chemists.

362
00:27:00.895 --> 00:27:04.956
It becomes kind of a chemical puzzle that university lecturers present to their students.

363
00:27:05.016 --> 00:27:06.237
Like, this is an open problem.

364
00:27:06.737 --> 00:27:07.998
Let's see if you guys can figure it out.

365
00:27:08.058 --> 00:27:12.942
Now, Markwald, as I said, had already succeeded in the first condition at the start of the 20th century.

366
00:27:13.642 --> 00:27:21.228
And autocatalysis, asymmetric catalysis, is also something that has been figured out.

367
00:27:21.288 --> 00:27:31.056
The 2001 Nobel Prize in Chemistry recognized William Knowles, Ryoji Noyori, and Barry Sharpless for important chiral catalytic reactions.

368
00:27:31.116 --> 00:27:33.598
This is the autocatalysis that we're talking about.

369
00:27:36.932 --> 00:27:43.017
That led to the industrial route to L-DOPA, which is a pharmaceutical that's used pretty widely.

370
00:27:43.417 --> 00:27:52.784
And in 2021, the Nobel Prize recognized Benjamin List and our favorite chemist on the podcast, David McMillan from Princeton University.

371
00:27:53.004 --> 00:27:54.045
Go Tigers.

372
00:27:54.565 --> 00:27:58.748
They created asymmetric organocatalysis.

373
00:27:58.869 --> 00:28:03.232
So organic chemistry that preferred one way or the other, right?

374
00:28:03.252 --> 00:28:03.412
Yeah.

375
00:28:05.347 --> 00:28:06.427
All of that is fine.

376
00:28:06.927 --> 00:28:20.111
The Nobel Prize in Chemistry this year recognizes the fulfillment of the remaining two conditions, meaning you need inhibition and you need that inhibition paired with catalysis, this runaway reaction.

377
00:28:20.651 --> 00:28:20.871
Okay?

378
00:28:21.692 --> 00:28:26.833
So in nature, there's this 50-50 thing where it happens naturally where it's not asymmetric.

379
00:28:27.293 --> 00:28:33.055
And through 2021, we had all of these different ways to artificially create an asymmetry.

380
00:28:34.477 --> 00:28:42.742
But the thing was to fulfill sort of the ultimate vision, we still had two missing variables.

381
00:28:43.063 --> 00:28:43.723
Yeah.

382
00:28:44.043 --> 00:28:48.746
And those specifically are the difference between the past Nobel Prizes and this Nobel Prize.

383
00:28:48.766 --> 00:28:49.226
Exactly.

384
00:28:49.346 --> 00:28:56.131
In this particular Nobel Prize, we are establishing the nonlinear effect, which is this sort of property that like –

385
00:28:56.920 --> 00:29:04.569
I can get more asymmetry from underlying asymmetry and the fact that we can have a runaway reaction, that autocatalysis part.

386
00:29:04.909 --> 00:29:05.150
Okay?

387
00:29:06.031 --> 00:29:11.497
So to make that question measurable, there's one scientific sort of...

388
00:29:14.741 --> 00:29:16.202
There's one scientific, like...

389
00:29:17.012 --> 00:29:19.734
parameter that I need to introduce to everyone.

390
00:29:20.034 --> 00:29:24.757
And this is the idea of enantiomeric excess, abbreviated EE.

391
00:29:25.217 --> 00:29:30.360
This is the difference between the amount of left-handed stuff and the amount of right-handed stuff.

392
00:29:30.761 --> 00:29:35.944
If I have exactly 50% left and right, that's a 0% excess, right?

393
00:29:35.984 --> 00:29:37.725
Because I have exactly the same.

394
00:29:37.945 --> 00:29:38.806
If I have all of 1%,

395
00:29:40.387 --> 00:29:48.851
all of one type, if I have all of left-handed and no right-handed, that means I have 100% excess of left-handed stuff.

396
00:29:49.471 --> 00:29:54.493
This is a key thing, a key parameter that we're going to have to deal with as we move on.

397
00:29:54.993 --> 00:29:57.674
So a 50-50% mixture, that's a zero.

398
00:29:57.954 --> 00:30:06.638
If I have a 60-40 mixture, that's a 20% excess, because it's really the difference between how much of one I have and how much of the other I have.

399
00:30:07.058 --> 00:30:16.121
And that distinction is essential as we get to talking about how a small starting imbalance is going to create a large ending imbalance.

400
00:30:16.481 --> 00:30:20.403
So 2% excess is almost a coin flip?

401
00:30:20.423 --> 00:30:20.643
Yeah.

402
00:30:20.863 --> 00:30:25.084
And then 51, 49 of the other... That's 2%, right?

403
00:30:25.164 --> 00:30:25.664
That's 2%.

404
00:30:25.684 --> 00:30:27.185
Yeah, and that's almost a coin flip.

405
00:30:27.205 --> 00:30:28.725
Okay, okay, okay, okay, okay.

406
00:30:28.925 --> 00:30:29.146
Yeah.

407
00:30:30.326 --> 00:30:33.347
So I think we now are getting to...

408
00:30:34.892 --> 00:30:36.153
Our Nobel laureates.

409
00:30:36.253 --> 00:30:36.494
Yes.

410
00:30:36.994 --> 00:30:37.915
We know the setup.

411
00:30:39.056 --> 00:30:46.562
And, you know, as a fan of Thierry Henry, the French footballer, although he was an Arsenal player, this is a Chelsea house.

412
00:30:47.183 --> 00:30:51.046
We will start with Henri Cagin.

413
00:30:51.627 --> 00:30:56.952
And so what was it that he discovered as a part of now this setup we've created?

414
00:30:57.032 --> 00:30:57.252
Right.

415
00:30:57.492 --> 00:30:59.614
So now we get to our actual Nobel laureates.

416
00:31:01.198 --> 00:31:06.800
Henri Cagón tries to tackle the nonlinear part of the Nobel description.

417
00:31:07.400 --> 00:31:13.803
Let's suppose that we start with a pure right-handed catalyst that favors right-handed products.

418
00:31:13.963 --> 00:31:15.524
Mark Wald has already shown that.

419
00:31:15.564 --> 00:31:22.166
If you start with the catalyst itself has a particular geometry, then the products are going to favor some particular geometry.

420
00:31:22.406 --> 00:31:28.969
Okay, so let's say the right-handed catalyst favors the right-handed product and the left-handed catalyst favors the left-handed product.

421
00:31:30.054 --> 00:31:55.114
The prevailing wisdom at the time was that if each of these catalysts work independently, then if I start out with, let's say, a 60-40 mixture of catalysts, the ending reactants are also going to be 60-40, because 60% of the catalysts created the 60% products, the 40% of the right-handed stuff created the 40%, and the ratio is going to remain the same, right?

422
00:31:55.735 --> 00:31:58.357
The slope, in this case, is going to be one.

423
00:31:58.417 --> 00:31:59.658
Like, if I start out with some

424
00:32:00.258 --> 00:32:01.920
I'm going to end up with some ratio.

425
00:32:02.520 --> 00:32:04.162
The slope could also be something different.

426
00:32:04.202 --> 00:32:08.726
For example, like, you know, if I start out with 60%, I could end up with 30% of something.

427
00:32:09.086 --> 00:32:12.249
But the line is going to be linear.

428
00:32:12.489 --> 00:32:15.211
Because maybe, like, you know, there's some, like, weird effect that happens.

429
00:32:15.231 --> 00:32:19.035
And, like, one type goes one way and the other type goes the other way.

430
00:32:20.814 --> 00:32:28.978
The line, if I increase the asymmetry on the catalyst side, I will just only linearly increase the asymmetry on the reactant side.

431
00:32:29.858 --> 00:32:31.799
Because these things are working independently.

432
00:32:31.879 --> 00:32:32.099
Right.

433
00:32:32.580 --> 00:32:32.820
Okay?

434
00:32:33.740 --> 00:32:36.842
That is the assumption that Kagan starts to question.

435
00:32:37.482 --> 00:32:37.702
Okay.

436
00:32:37.762 --> 00:32:38.983
Everyone believed this at the time.

437
00:32:39.583 --> 00:32:45.726
Kagan's like, well, you know, if you think about the catalyst itself, we don't actually know how it works.

438
00:32:47.221 --> 00:32:51.644
And during a chemical reaction, we've got this metal atom that's doing a lot of the work.

439
00:32:52.264 --> 00:33:00.729
But the metal atom could be doing different things if there are multiple agents involved.

440
00:33:01.789 --> 00:33:03.290
Metal atoms normally react...

441
00:33:03.680 --> 00:33:06.602
and interact with several molecules simultaneously.

442
00:33:06.942 --> 00:33:09.363
They're not just like, oh, I'm going to stick to this guy.

443
00:33:09.383 --> 00:33:11.565
They're recruiting all sorts of other stuff.

444
00:33:11.605 --> 00:33:21.070
And that's why metals like zinc and things like that are very important for our body as cofactors, because they actually help proteins recruit all sorts of other types of stuff.

445
00:33:21.930 --> 00:33:24.712
Now, here's what he considers, right?

446
00:33:25.332 --> 00:33:29.455
Suppose we've got two chiral molecules.

447
00:33:30.252 --> 00:33:30.953
that are catalysts.

448
00:33:30.993 --> 00:33:35.558
There's a left-handed version and a right-handed version, and we combine it with a metal atom, right?

449
00:33:36.039 --> 00:33:39.343
Now, this metal atom is going to recruit two of these

450
00:33:40.430 --> 00:33:41.451
to create mixtures.

451
00:33:42.252 --> 00:33:43.913
So we're going to get three possibilities.

452
00:33:43.933 --> 00:33:49.919
We're going to get a right-right mixture, a left-right mixture, and then a left-left mixture, right?

453
00:33:50.679 --> 00:33:58.867
But because of combinatorics, if I start out with a certain asymmetry, that asymmetry is only going to grow because of my mixtures.

454
00:33:58.927 --> 00:34:01.249
For example, if I start out with 25% and 75%, I'm going to end up with

455
00:34:05.452 --> 00:34:08.474
6% and 56%.

456
00:34:08.534 --> 00:34:16.058
Like if I start out with 25% left, the combinatorics there is going to be 0.25 squared, which is going to be 0.625.

457
00:34:16.439 --> 00:34:19.440
So these guys are rounding to... Boo.

458
00:34:19.460 --> 00:34:27.925
They should say 6.25%, but this is the popular information and they don't want to deal with decimals like for the plebs, but it should really be 6.25%.

459
00:34:27.965 --> 00:34:29.306
That makes sense.

460
00:34:29.366 --> 00:34:30.767
If you guys are taking the GRE,

461
00:34:31.327 --> 00:34:32.267
Don't round.

462
00:34:32.307 --> 00:34:34.548
Don't do that.

463
00:34:34.688 --> 00:34:37.389
So you get 6.25% of the left-hand side.

464
00:34:37.710 --> 00:34:44.732
You get something like, I think it's 56.25%, or I don't know what the, you know what I mean, of the right-right.

465
00:34:44.912 --> 00:34:47.493
And then the mixture is going to be about 38%.

466
00:34:47.573 --> 00:34:50.074
It's really 37 point something something percent.

467
00:34:50.375 --> 00:34:52.295
But that's the key distinction now, right?

468
00:34:52.776 --> 00:34:56.297
So you've made these mixtures of molecules that have a different...

469
00:34:58.238 --> 00:35:17.163
than what you started it's not that same linear ratio we just talked about previously exactly and now if you create this type of multi-molecular interaction and you try to run your reaction through what are the products going to look like

470
00:35:18.201 --> 00:35:25.806
This is the big paper that comes out in 1986 in the Journal of Chemical Society, the Journal of the American Chemical Society.

471
00:35:26.627 --> 00:35:36.194
He shows that actually for a particular type of reaction called the Sharpless Epoxidation of Geronial, which is depicted on the lower there.

472
00:35:38.150 --> 00:35:38.971
we don't get a line.

473
00:35:39.431 --> 00:35:41.192
We get a nonlinear effect.

474
00:35:41.632 --> 00:35:48.997
If I increase the amount of asymmetry or I increase the amount of right-handed versus left-handed, I don't get a straight line.

475
00:35:49.237 --> 00:35:51.398
I actually get a difference.

476
00:35:51.478 --> 00:35:54.980
I get a slope that is very, very much a nonlinear effect.

477
00:35:55.080 --> 00:36:01.524
The type of reaction here is the Sharpless epoxidation that's named after Barry Sharpless, who won the Nobel Prize in 2001.

478
00:36:01.744 --> 00:36:06.407
So this is building on some of the asymmetric oxidation stuff that

479
00:36:06.700 --> 00:36:08.301
Barry Sharpless had done earlier on.

480
00:36:09.002 --> 00:36:11.764
The left-right catalyst behaves differently.

481
00:36:12.785 --> 00:36:15.947
And that is the key distinction that he's trying to make.

482
00:36:16.007 --> 00:36:19.049
So theoretically, what's happening, he actually tries and figures it out.

483
00:36:19.730 --> 00:36:21.511
Now we have the complete fixture, right?

484
00:36:21.571 --> 00:36:27.156
We've created these left-right catalysts, and we've created the left-left and the right-left.

485
00:36:27.516 --> 00:36:29.918
Sorry, left-left and the right-right, right?

486
00:36:29.938 --> 00:36:30.298
Right.

487
00:36:31.742 --> 00:36:37.206
What ends up happening is the left-right catalyst, the mixture, can't do anything.

488
00:36:37.306 --> 00:36:40.709
It is completely useless.

489
00:36:40.809 --> 00:36:41.149
Inert?

490
00:36:41.589 --> 00:36:42.610
Yeah, in some sense.

491
00:36:42.670 --> 00:36:48.755
It can't react with anything because I guess it's getting confused about which type of reactant to make.

492
00:36:50.240 --> 00:36:53.981
And now, at the very end, you're taking out that middle 38 portion.

493
00:36:54.041 --> 00:36:55.562
Yeah, yeah, from before.

494
00:36:55.602 --> 00:36:57.202
And you get a huge asymmetry.

495
00:36:57.262 --> 00:36:58.463
Yeah, yep, yep.

496
00:36:58.483 --> 00:36:58.683
Right?

497
00:36:59.003 --> 00:37:01.864
Before we had 6%, 38%, 56%.

498
00:37:02.544 --> 00:37:05.785
But the 38% is not creating any reactants.

499
00:37:06.325 --> 00:37:08.766
And so if we look at the reactant distribution...

500
00:37:09.647 --> 00:37:16.932
We only get 10% of reactants and 90% of the right version.

501
00:37:17.572 --> 00:37:20.514
10% of the left version and 90% of the right version.

502
00:37:20.895 --> 00:37:27.999
Which is basically taking up all of the product that would have come out of the left-right because effectively it cannot catalyze.

503
00:37:28.059 --> 00:37:29.881
Yeah, there's no catalysis happening.

504
00:37:30.141 --> 00:37:31.662
And so this is nonlinear.

505
00:37:31.802 --> 00:37:32.062
Yeah.

506
00:37:32.282 --> 00:37:33.263
Because you're starting...

507
00:37:33.503 --> 00:37:33.783
Yeah.

508
00:37:34.023 --> 00:37:36.985
With 25%, 75%.

509
00:37:37.485 --> 00:37:40.747
And you're ending up with a 10% and a 90%.

510
00:37:40.887 --> 00:37:47.891
And specifically, this mixing mechanism is a multiplicative thing, right?

511
00:37:48.131 --> 00:37:50.433
Which is why we're getting that slope, right?

512
00:37:50.673 --> 00:37:54.195
If it was just an additive thing, that the slope would just change.

513
00:37:55.493 --> 00:37:57.494
But like, it would still be a straight line.

514
00:37:57.594 --> 00:38:01.475
The fact that it's multiplicative means that I'm getting a parabola, right?

515
00:38:01.515 --> 00:38:01.696
Yep.

516
00:38:02.096 --> 00:38:07.318
And that's why you've got a curve in that reaction kinetics.

517
00:38:07.618 --> 00:38:07.798
Yep.

518
00:38:08.058 --> 00:38:09.779
That's the key distinction that's happening.

519
00:38:10.119 --> 00:38:12.640
This is the positive nonlinear effect.

520
00:38:13.680 --> 00:38:15.041
And this is the nonlinear part.

521
00:38:16.055 --> 00:38:17.857
Of the Nobel Prize discovery.

522
00:38:17.957 --> 00:38:18.358
Exactly.

523
00:38:18.418 --> 00:38:26.506
So if we go back to the top here, right, the official citation is for the discovery of nonlinear effects –

524
00:38:27.846 --> 00:38:31.227
and autocatalysis and asymmetric organic synthesis.

525
00:38:31.647 --> 00:38:34.748
So now we've identified, this is the first piece.

526
00:38:34.788 --> 00:38:36.929
Yeah, the nonlinear effects, right?

527
00:38:37.249 --> 00:38:38.850
And this is a historic breakthrough.

528
00:38:39.430 --> 00:38:42.991
It's historic because many chemists didn't think it was possible.

529
00:38:43.651 --> 00:38:45.952
And now they start exploring this new phenomenon.

530
00:38:46.432 --> 00:38:51.154
Everyone in chemistry who cares anything about asymmetric catalysis starts exploring this.

531
00:38:51.814 --> 00:38:55.395
One of these chemists is Kenzo Soai at the Tokyo University of Science.

532
00:38:57.876 --> 00:38:59.657
in that Nobel Prize citation.

533
00:39:00.138 --> 00:39:06.002
And before we get to that, let's do some housekeeping because we haven't done that in a while, and I think we deserve it.

534
00:39:06.883 --> 00:39:09.124
A quick opportunity to shill, a quick pause.

535
00:39:09.444 --> 00:39:17.050
So you can find all of the papers that we talk about and go through on the show at our website, ffppod.com.

536
00:39:17.370 --> 00:39:23.995
We do short clips and little bite-sized takes of some of the best science that we talk about on our socials.

537
00:39:24.495 --> 00:39:26.116
at FFP pod.

538
00:39:26.337 --> 00:39:35.483
And, you know, one of the best ways to help this show get seen by more people, the like, share a comment, share it with somebody you think would find it interesting.

539
00:39:35.944 --> 00:39:43.890
Five star on Spotify or any of the podcast networks really helps us get the best science show on the planet out to more people.

540
00:39:44.230 --> 00:39:53.217
And I just want to note, I was so excited when I saw the announcement this morning, because one of the, and you mentioned this earlier,

541
00:39:54.017 --> 00:40:11.245
One of the biggest unlock episodes for me in terms of my mental framework around the sciences was when we talked about, due to the unfortunate passing of Chen Ningyong at the end of last year, we have an episode, The Man Who Unlocked Symmetry.

542
00:40:11.585 --> 00:40:21.430
If any of these concepts are super interesting to you and you want to know more, whether it's about parody violation or the birth of Yang Mills, that episode is an absolute banger.

543
00:40:21.650 --> 00:40:22.691
Yeah, it really is.

544
00:40:22.831 --> 00:40:31.177
And the one thing that I want to mention about that episode and its distinction with this one is the fact that physics does care about the mirror world.

545
00:40:31.257 --> 00:40:31.497
Yes.

546
00:40:31.577 --> 00:40:31.777
Right?

547
00:40:32.097 --> 00:40:37.241
In chemistry, as we said, you can create a petri dish of both left-handed and right-handed stuff.

548
00:40:37.701 --> 00:40:41.704
And you might be thinking, well, you know, does everything in physics...

549
00:40:42.743 --> 00:40:44.924
care about left-handed, right-handed or not.

550
00:40:44.944 --> 00:40:46.485
Like in chemistry, clearly it doesn't.

551
00:40:46.865 --> 00:40:51.607
In physics, in fact, there is a way to tell between left-handed and right-handed stuff.

552
00:40:51.887 --> 00:40:59.651
And we do this great analysis that Richard Feynman actually originally did, where he talked about, you know, if we were to call up an alien...

553
00:41:00.031 --> 00:41:03.372
How would we tell him left versus right hands, right?

554
00:41:03.572 --> 00:41:04.772
We can't use chemistry.

555
00:41:04.992 --> 00:41:11.413
We can't be like, grow some glucose and then make it go through light and see which way the light turns.

556
00:41:11.554 --> 00:41:17.295
Because the glucose on Earth, sure, it's turning to the right-hand side because glucose is right-handed here on Earth.

557
00:41:17.615 --> 00:41:19.735
But the alien is going to grow crystals.

558
00:41:19.835 --> 00:41:23.756
And then like Louis Pasteur, he's going to be like, well, there's two different types of crystals.

559
00:41:23.916 --> 00:41:27.837
And like this type of crystal is going left-hand, this type of crystal is going right-hand.

560
00:41:28.277 --> 00:41:33.420
Or in the worst case scenario, the alien has a left-handed version of life, right?

561
00:41:33.500 --> 00:41:38.664
He's still somehow eating glucose, but his version of glucose is all left-handed.

562
00:41:38.924 --> 00:41:43.327
And so he goes the other way, and he thinks his left is our right.

563
00:41:43.787 --> 00:41:45.628
Chemistry cannot make that distinction.

564
00:41:46.028 --> 00:41:47.349
Physics, on the other hand, can.

565
00:41:47.689 --> 00:41:51.332
Chen Ningyang was one of the key people who understood that.

566
00:41:52.012 --> 00:41:53.675
And C.S.

567
00:41:53.736 --> 00:42:01.711
Wu, the very famous Chinese physicist, she did not win the Nobel Prize very controversially, but she proved that that was in fact...

568
00:42:02.367 --> 00:42:12.791
a fact of the universe that parody violation exists in beta decay where neutrons spit out, um, a proton and an electron, but the electron only spins in one direction versus the other.

569
00:42:13.111 --> 00:42:14.152
It's an incredible episode.

570
00:42:14.172 --> 00:42:15.732
It's actually one of my favorites as well.

571
00:42:15.773 --> 00:42:16.573
It's so good.

572
00:42:16.753 --> 00:42:18.193
And beta decay coming up again.

573
00:42:18.494 --> 00:42:18.734
Yeah.

574
00:42:18.774 --> 00:42:20.614
We talked about beta decay yesterday.

575
00:42:20.675 --> 00:42:21.075
So yeah.

576
00:42:21.255 --> 00:42:21.455
Um,

577
00:42:22.055 --> 00:42:28.684
Okay, so with that said, we now have the nonlinear part of this 2026 chemistry, Nobel.

578
00:42:28.724 --> 00:42:32.590
The next word in the Nobel description is autocatalysis.

579
00:42:32.670 --> 00:42:33.531
How do we get there?

580
00:42:33.912 --> 00:42:38.438
Yes, this is where we get into autocatalysis.

581
00:42:40.042 --> 00:42:50.190
The idea of autocatalysis is that the product participates in catalyzing the reaction that produces more of the product that then catalyzes more of the reaction that produces more of the product.

582
00:42:50.230 --> 00:42:53.533
So as the product accumulates, you get this runaway reaction.

583
00:42:53.693 --> 00:43:02.100
And a signature of this type of reaction in reaction kinetics is as time goes on, you get kind of a sigmoid where the first half –

584
00:43:02.560 --> 00:43:07.705
is like exponential because the more and more products you get, you start blowing up.

585
00:43:08.205 --> 00:43:15.812
But as you start running out of the reactants, you reach a baseline where all of the reactants are finally taken care of.

586
00:43:16.552 --> 00:43:19.535
Life has a bunch of this type of autocatalysis.

587
00:43:19.815 --> 00:43:25.600
For example, there's several cycles that we have in life where you create a particular product,

588
00:43:26.200 --> 00:43:29.242
And then that particular product feeds back into the cycle itself.

589
00:43:29.562 --> 00:43:33.165
The Krebs cycle in mitochondria is a great one.

590
00:43:33.185 --> 00:43:36.487
The Calvin cycle in photosynthesis is a great one.

591
00:43:36.808 --> 00:43:38.809
So life does this all the time, right?

592
00:43:38.869 --> 00:43:39.930
And you can imagine like...

593
00:43:40.603 --> 00:43:41.424
Kind of makes sense, right?

594
00:43:41.444 --> 00:43:47.988
If you've got a workshop that builds tools and then the tools build themselves, then you've got this thing going.

595
00:43:48.308 --> 00:43:52.071
This is not recursive self-improvement and we're not talking about AI.

596
00:43:52.131 --> 00:43:58.055
Yeah, we're not talking about AI, although that is also a runaway effect that we should be certainly concerned about.

597
00:43:59.236 --> 00:44:09.843
In any case, so Soai and his collaborators, they start exploring reactions in which organozinc reagents add to aldehydes to make alcohols.

598
00:44:10.945 --> 00:44:12.566
Let's take this particular reaction here.

599
00:44:12.606 --> 00:44:19.232
This is an asymmetric catalytic addition of dimethyl zinc, which is the ME2ZN.

600
00:44:19.512 --> 00:44:22.234
ME is the methyl, so dimethyl group.

601
00:44:22.555 --> 00:44:27.799
This is being attached to a chiral ligand on the left-hand side.

602
00:44:27.819 --> 00:44:29.040
The pH is a phenyl group.

603
00:44:29.060 --> 00:44:30.782
That's a C6H5, okay?

604
00:44:31.322 --> 00:44:33.704
When you scrutinize this thing, look at the product.

605
00:44:34.184 --> 00:44:37.647
The product also has a phenyl with OH.

606
00:44:37.948 --> 00:44:38.228
Mm-hmm.

607
00:44:38.648 --> 00:44:48.774
It's a bit different from the reactant, but it's also kind of similar to the thing that is catalyzing the reaction at the very top, because it's got a phenyl group, an OH group, and extra carbon.

608
00:44:49.094 --> 00:44:58.499
And the carbon, if you can somehow attach it to the N-benzene feridine, the NBN over there, then perhaps you could make more of this stuff.

609
00:44:59.348 --> 00:45:03.950
Okay, so this is kind of a, like, you know, maybe there's something here.

610
00:45:04.391 --> 00:45:05.391
This sparks an idea, right?

611
00:45:05.431 --> 00:45:08.553
Perhaps you can design a reaction where the catalyst forms itself.

612
00:45:09.451 --> 00:45:17.758
Now, at this time, early 1990s, there's several known examples of autocatalytic reactions, but none that are asymmetric.

613
00:45:18.118 --> 00:45:23.923
There's several reactions of this thing doing it, but we need something that prefers one hand over the other.

614
00:45:24.543 --> 00:45:32.590
And by experimenting with many different molecules, SOI succeeds in finding a chiral substance called 5-pyramidal alkanol,

615
00:45:33.330 --> 00:45:34.931
I almost said alcohol.

616
00:45:34.951 --> 00:45:39.275
And chemists with their... Dude, I remember organic chemistry.

617
00:45:39.695 --> 00:45:47.722
Like, if you put down alcohol and not alkanol, which, by the way, the H kind of looks like an N. Like, you get a zero.

618
00:45:48.563 --> 00:45:50.665
So, oh my God, I hate it, Orgo.

619
00:45:51.085 --> 00:45:54.268
But in any case, five-pyramidal alkanol

620
00:45:55.964 --> 00:45:59.568
is a chiral substance that Soai finds that can create itself.

621
00:46:00.108 --> 00:46:11.800
And in a publication in 1995 in Nature, he describes this revolutionary experiment, asymmetric autocatalysis and the amplification of enantiomeric excess of a chiral molecule.

622
00:46:12.261 --> 00:46:13.021
Banger title.

623
00:46:13.562 --> 00:46:17.206
For anyone who is in the field, like this is like, oh, you did it.

624
00:46:18.307 --> 00:46:23.332
And this is literally like the word for word, some of the stuff that the Nobel Committee is citing, right?

625
00:46:23.392 --> 00:46:24.894
Asymmetric autocatalysis.

626
00:46:25.294 --> 00:46:27.316
So great title, 1995.

627
00:46:29.174 --> 00:46:32.918
It's not the end of his work because this is kind of halfway there.

628
00:46:33.198 --> 00:46:38.284
It starts with a 2% excess of one enantiomer and ends up with an excess of 87%.

629
00:46:39.325 --> 00:46:40.025
That's pretty good.

630
00:46:40.146 --> 00:46:46.212
But the reaction is not what life does because in life you start with a little bit of excess and you've got to get to 100%.

631
00:46:47.355 --> 00:46:49.037
It's the Riemann hypothesis.

632
00:46:49.097 --> 00:46:52.000
We got to rule out all of the non-trivial zeros.

633
00:46:52.020 --> 00:46:52.540
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

634
00:46:52.580 --> 00:46:53.721
Even when you get to 100 percent.

635
00:46:53.741 --> 00:46:54.542
Yeah, yeah.

636
00:46:54.682 --> 00:46:55.323
A little different.

637
00:46:55.343 --> 00:46:55.903
A little different.

638
00:46:55.923 --> 00:46:56.344
A little different.

639
00:46:56.364 --> 00:46:59.246
But at least this is like some statistical type thing, right?

640
00:46:59.467 --> 00:47:00.147
We're getting close.

641
00:47:00.207 --> 00:47:00.748
We're getting close.

642
00:47:00.768 --> 00:47:01.809
We're getting close, right?

643
00:47:02.129 --> 00:47:09.136
So another eight years, SOA's lab just continues their search, and they finally find the ultimate autocatalytic process.

644
00:47:09.256 --> 00:47:09.476
In 2003…

645
00:47:11.679 --> 00:47:15.702
They publish in the American Chemical Society Journal.

646
00:47:16.063 --> 00:47:21.147
This journal, by the way, is just one of the goats for chemistry.

647
00:47:21.647 --> 00:47:30.975
In last year's episode, if you look back, a lot of the MOFs, the Metal Organic Framework Papers, came out in the American Chemical Society Journal.

648
00:47:31.015 --> 00:47:35.759
So it kind of goes under the radar compared to nature, science, but...

649
00:47:36.479 --> 00:47:37.040
We see you.

650
00:47:37.100 --> 00:47:37.820
Yeah, we see you.

651
00:47:37.960 --> 00:47:39.041
This thing is a heavy hitter.

652
00:47:40.382 --> 00:47:46.847
This is the first time that anyone had successfully created chirality from non-chiral combinations of molecules since the dawn of life.

653
00:47:47.127 --> 00:47:48.568
This is where he got to 100% chiral.

654
00:47:48.588 --> 00:47:49.769
Sheesh.

655
00:47:50.289 --> 00:47:51.090
Unbelievable.

656
00:47:51.390 --> 00:47:52.951
Since the dawn of life.

657
00:47:52.971 --> 00:47:56.834
Yeah, since the dawn of life, this is the first time.

658
00:47:56.974 --> 00:48:04.320
It's called the Soi reaction, and it is considered by chemists as the most elegant chemical experiment

659
00:48:05.351 --> 00:48:07.372
ever conducted by some chemists.

660
00:48:07.432 --> 00:48:19.295
I just want to note the pronunciation of the last name, So I, being the one that created this, is also just like a sort of aesthetically interesting naming convention.

661
00:48:19.735 --> 00:48:21.196
It's like, So I and I only.

662
00:48:21.496 --> 00:48:23.937
Yeah, I think that is quite funny.

663
00:48:24.177 --> 00:48:30.699
I mean, it's considered one of the most elegant chemical experiments ever conducted, which that is a high bar to me.

664
00:48:32.259 --> 00:48:33.400
So here's what's happening.

665
00:48:33.440 --> 00:48:45.427
When you start the catalytic process, you've got both enantiomers that are present, but a tiny excess of just one creates 100% excess of that one, and that's because...

666
00:48:47.080 --> 00:48:51.944
Effectively, what's happening is one enantiomer takes over the entire reaction.

667
00:48:52.265 --> 00:48:57.929
The left-hand side creates only left-hand catalysts, and the right-hand side creates only right-hand catalysts.

668
00:48:58.210 --> 00:49:06.517
But if you've got a tiny imbalance, the left-hand sides create way more than the right-hand side, which is going to then create way more, which is then going to create way more.

669
00:49:06.837 --> 00:49:09.159
So you start out with something like 0.00005%.

670
00:49:09.379 --> 00:49:10.360
After the first...

671
00:49:14.927 --> 00:49:16.788
run, you get all the way to 57%.

672
00:49:16.908 --> 00:49:18.088
Unbelievable.

673
00:49:18.188 --> 00:49:20.269
After the second run, you get to 99%.

674
00:49:20.549 --> 00:49:23.349
And after the third run, you get to 99.5%.

675
00:49:23.890 --> 00:49:27.651
It's a runaway reaction because of autocatalysis.

676
00:49:27.771 --> 00:49:28.491
That is the key.

677
00:49:28.831 --> 00:49:32.172
The thing is creating itself, which is then creating itself.

678
00:49:32.852 --> 00:49:34.653
Right?

679
00:49:35.513 --> 00:49:38.074
I remember seeing this image in the Nobel materials.

680
00:49:38.294 --> 00:49:41.955
And without necessarily connecting the dots...

681
00:49:43.087 --> 00:49:53.770
understanding, like looking at this runaway in three runs and three rounds, uh, with how small your starting point was in terms of the imbalance clearly was going to be important.

682
00:49:53.850 --> 00:49:54.050
Yeah.

683
00:49:54.510 --> 00:49:57.510
Now the connection as to how and why is fascinating.

684
00:49:57.530 --> 00:49:57.690
Yeah.

685
00:49:57.730 --> 00:49:59.991
And this is, it's like one part in what?

686
00:50:00.031 --> 00:50:00.431
10,000.

687
00:50:00.471 --> 00:50:01.731
I think if I'm doing the math, right.

688
00:50:02.212 --> 00:50:07.013
One part in 10,000 is leading to in three runs, 99.5%, almost at a hundred.

689
00:50:08.799 --> 00:50:08.999
Right.

690
00:50:09.620 --> 00:50:12.402
Just one of them is just dominating just because of the chance.

691
00:50:13.143 --> 00:50:13.323
Right.

692
00:50:14.104 --> 00:50:15.365
Beginning asymmetry.

693
00:50:15.725 --> 00:50:21.311
And the small scale of that chance asymmetry at the beginning is very small.

694
00:50:21.431 --> 00:50:21.671
Yeah.

695
00:50:21.851 --> 00:50:22.111
Yeah.

696
00:50:22.131 --> 00:50:23.192
It could have gone the other way.

697
00:50:23.252 --> 00:50:23.413
Right.

698
00:50:23.453 --> 00:50:26.896
And then in which case we would have had a lot of the of the left hand side.

699
00:50:28.413 --> 00:50:29.475
This is so good.

700
00:50:29.575 --> 00:50:38.525
And so now we've kind of gotten to the point where we understand now all of the component parts of the description.

701
00:50:38.565 --> 00:50:41.728
And just to say it one more time, the nonlinear effects.

702
00:50:42.008 --> 00:50:43.010
That was Kagan.

703
00:50:43.150 --> 00:50:43.730
That was Kagan.

704
00:50:44.211 --> 00:50:44.711
Kagan.

705
00:50:45.292 --> 00:50:46.653
Kogan, yeah.

706
00:50:46.693 --> 00:50:47.454
No, no.

707
00:50:47.975 --> 00:50:49.776
And then if it's not, you can let us know in the comments.

708
00:50:49.896 --> 00:50:50.877
Yeah, please.

709
00:50:51.278 --> 00:51:00.406
And then autocatalysis, which is what creates this runaway, in asymmetric organic synthesis, which means the inputs –

710
00:51:01.267 --> 00:51:22.736
uh have that slight asymmetry and it only it doesn't always have to have a slight asymmetry but it only requires a slight asymmetry in this example to then create this 100 runaway reaction um and this is fascinating for a lot of reasons obviously we made the connection earlier to uh how you know a couple of things but one of the notes was that

711
00:51:23.916 --> 00:51:28.079
this changes how we make medicines or pharmaceuticals.

712
00:51:28.379 --> 00:51:32.181
So how does that connect to the impacts now that we have this understanding?

713
00:51:32.361 --> 00:51:37.964
Yeah, and this leads to some of why chemists are so motivated by this.

714
00:51:38.024 --> 00:51:42.047
The aim is to produce enantiomers that are as pure as possible.

715
00:51:42.067 --> 00:51:47.330
For example, in pharmaceutical manufacturing, you want a particular type of handedness

716
00:51:47.750 --> 00:51:48.830
for the drug that you're making.

717
00:51:48.850 --> 00:51:51.271
You don't want to do Louis Pasteur where you've got both sides.

718
00:51:52.431 --> 00:52:00.774
The importance of achieving this has been shown by the thalidomide, the thalidomide scandal of the 1960s.

719
00:52:00.854 --> 00:52:02.114
I don't know if you're aware of this.

720
00:52:02.174 --> 00:52:02.694
I was not.

721
00:52:03.014 --> 00:52:11.437
But this is an incredibly dark time in chemistry, in pharmaceuticals, and in the world at large.

722
00:52:11.517 --> 00:52:15.038
Like, aside from war, this is one of the worst disasters

723
00:52:16.049 --> 00:52:19.935
In history that I hadn't really heard about, which I was really surprised by.

724
00:52:20.375 --> 00:52:29.288
So this is the thalidomide scandal of the 1960s when thousands of children were affected by birth defects caused by a sedative, thalidomide.

725
00:52:29.789 --> 00:52:32.813
It was widely given to pregnant women to treat morning sickness.

726
00:52:34.129 --> 00:52:40.335
It's actually incredible that there's so little testing on pregnant women to create such a tragedy.

727
00:52:40.395 --> 00:52:43.137
Tens of thousands of people were affected.

728
00:52:44.158 --> 00:52:49.263
And when researchers analyzed what had happened, they'd realized that it was an active substance.

729
00:52:50.383 --> 00:52:53.306
The mirror image was causing the harm, right?

730
00:52:54.027 --> 00:52:56.929
Both mirror images were in the drug.

731
00:52:57.510 --> 00:52:58.751
And while one of the...

732
00:52:59.674 --> 00:53:02.475
one of the mirror images was actually creating the sedative version.

733
00:53:02.796 --> 00:53:05.577
The other mirror image was causing these defects.

734
00:53:05.877 --> 00:53:14.421
And I want to take a brief note here and talk about why the world at large was very much affected by the thalidomide scandal.

735
00:53:14.482 --> 00:53:18.243
Tens of thousands, I'm talking literally, tens of thousands of birth defects.

736
00:53:18.744 --> 00:53:23.746
The U.S. was spared because of Francis Oldham Kelsey.

737
00:53:23.846 --> 00:53:27.328
And if you go back to that photo that we had, mm-hmm.

738
00:53:29.030 --> 00:53:37.276
Frances Oldham Kelsey is the hero in our story for America because she was a pharmacologist working for the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.

739
00:53:37.796 --> 00:53:47.483
She blocked the drug's approval in the United States despite heavy pressure from the manufacturer Grunenthal, which was a German pharmaceutical company.

740
00:53:48.295 --> 00:53:51.838
They were trying to pressure the FDA to approve this thing.

741
00:53:52.198 --> 00:54:01.826
She saw the writing on the wall in early clinical studies that others had kind of just hand-waved as like, oh, that's just a hand of God, like, chance stuff.

742
00:54:02.127 --> 00:54:05.389
She was looking at the data going, no, no, there's clearly an effect here.

743
00:54:05.770 --> 00:54:07.431
I don't know what you guys are talking about.

744
00:54:07.611 --> 00:54:09.533
She received a lot of pressure.

745
00:54:10.533 --> 00:54:20.281
from lobbyists, from like, you know, I can imagine like as a woman at the time in the 1960s in the Food and Drug Administration as a scientist trying to block approval.

746
00:54:20.661 --> 00:54:25.105
But, you know, it took her and it largely spared the US from this crisis.

747
00:54:25.485 --> 00:54:28.427
There are several other countries that are still dealing with this.

748
00:54:28.808 --> 00:54:31.630
Japan, Australia, a lot of Europe.

749
00:54:32.110 --> 00:54:36.774
These are developed nations that have their own versions of the Food and Drug Administration.

750
00:54:37.114 --> 00:54:39.196
But somehow the pressure from Grunenthal

751
00:54:39.516 --> 00:54:42.398
like actually, you know, they succumb to that pressure.

752
00:54:42.858 --> 00:54:44.058
We did not because of her.

753
00:54:45.299 --> 00:54:52.523
And, you know, there's a photo of President John F. Kennedy giving her the President's Award for Distinguished Federal Civilian Service.

754
00:54:53.924 --> 00:54:57.385
It highlights why the FDA is important.

755
00:54:57.786 --> 00:55:00.267
I want to bring this up in today's climate where...

756
00:55:01.370 --> 00:55:10.635
Apparently, we're just making decisions with the FDA that don't make sense to me, don't make sense to a lot of trained scientists.

757
00:55:11.075 --> 00:55:19.980
I just wanted to show that this is one of those situations where you really need independent thinkers in our government to make informed decisions.

758
00:55:20.941 --> 00:55:22.702
America was spared from that crisis.

759
00:55:23.943 --> 00:55:29.629
When the next crisis comes, we need someone like Francis Oldham Kelsey to do that again.

760
00:55:30.350 --> 00:55:39.540
And just to piggyback on that, I think this also highlights the importance of not allowing commercial influence in America.

761
00:55:41.202 --> 00:56:02.920
sort of public health decisions 100 as well as research and r&amp;d decisions there needs to be a healthy tension there um and this is a perfect example of you don't want it to become too late because you've allowed sort of this runaway corporatism to infect

762
00:56:04.740 --> 00:56:15.703
civic institutions to their own benefit for the sake of shareholder value at the expense of a potential catastrophe that can last generations.

763
00:56:15.723 --> 00:56:18.043
And that's, these decisions can last generations.

764
00:56:18.084 --> 00:56:18.244
Right.

765
00:56:18.324 --> 00:56:20.484
And these countries are still dealing with it to this day.

766
00:56:20.544 --> 00:56:27.186
I think it was only the last decade when that German company... Yeah, very good.

767
00:56:27.266 --> 00:56:27.526
Yeah.

768
00:56:27.546 --> 00:56:29.786
But only in the last decade was that

769
00:56:32.867 --> 00:56:34.208
Which is like 50 years later.

770
00:56:34.569 --> 00:56:34.769
Yeah.

771
00:56:34.789 --> 00:56:35.029
Really?

772
00:56:35.389 --> 00:56:36.330
And a lot of...

773
00:56:36.570 --> 00:56:38.192
I mean, I went in a deep dive on this.

774
00:56:38.272 --> 00:56:49.161
A lot of the original scientists and shareholders and the CEO of that company in the 1960s that was peddling this thing, they were just trying to avoid any sort of responsibility.

775
00:56:49.581 --> 00:56:53.604
They avoided responsibility for most of their life until most of them had passed away.

776
00:56:53.965 --> 00:56:55.626
And then they had the repercussions.

777
00:56:57.047 --> 00:56:59.930
If you guys want to go into a deep dive about...

778
00:57:00.907 --> 00:57:08.291
like how badly things can go wrong, you should look up the thalidomide scandal of the early 1960s.

779
00:57:08.551 --> 00:57:14.734
But I think this highlights something about drug development, which is chirality is a practical design and quality control issue, right?

780
00:57:14.794 --> 00:57:28.461
If two mirror images interact differently with the body, then the manufacturer needs to understand which form is being made, how much of it is being made, and how we can actually create asymmetric synthesis where we can build a preference of one over another, right?

781
00:57:28.641 --> 00:57:30.322
Understanding these nonlinear effects...

782
00:57:32.078 --> 00:57:38.585
helps researchers interpret experiments, identify active species, and decide how to actually improve selectivity.

783
00:57:38.845 --> 00:57:47.975
So this year's Nobel Prizes, the work that they've done is very much important for drug development at large.

784
00:57:48.695 --> 00:58:14.210
this is it's so interesting i think you know i've talked about this previously you know my dad has worked in stage one drug discovery for quite some time um and this is one of those things where you know even in the course of his career uh the change of understanding has impacted what he's been able to do and work on and that it's always touching on stories that have a tangential connection to allow me to understand his work a little bit better i always find uh

785
00:58:15.025 --> 00:58:15.846
Gratifying.

786
00:58:16.307 --> 00:58:21.073
And I know you feel the same when we talk about stuff in the other category for you as well.

787
00:58:21.554 --> 00:58:31.368
But I think this now brings us back to the last missing piece from the beginning of the episode setup, which comes back to this age old question about...

788
00:58:31.848 --> 00:58:32.108
life.

789
00:58:32.608 --> 00:58:40.070
So how does this now, you know, what does all of this say about why biology is homochiral?

790
00:58:40.930 --> 00:58:43.551
It only has one chirality.

791
00:58:43.691 --> 00:58:46.652
Like, how does this now connect to that bigger question?

792
00:58:46.712 --> 00:58:47.132
Right, right.

793
00:58:47.272 --> 00:58:49.552
And you might think that this sort of answers it, right?

794
00:58:49.572 --> 00:58:56.154
Because the So I reaction shows that you can start with a small asymmetry and get, you know, 100% one way or the other.

795
00:58:56.474 --> 00:58:58.455
Now, that is certainly true.

796
00:58:58.635 --> 00:58:59.435
And it has a lot of

797
00:59:00.247 --> 00:59:05.432
compounding effects for drug development, as we talked about, and fundamental chemistry questions at large.

798
00:59:05.792 --> 00:59:10.836
But at the end of the day, the SOI reaction is artificial, and it is a bit different from the chemistry of life.

799
00:59:11.437 --> 00:59:26.470
It still awakens a new enthusiasm in chemists who want to understand life's origins, but the connection to life is limited in some sense, because these experiments demonstrate that the chemical route from little or no-handedness

800
00:59:27.108 --> 00:59:30.991
to a very strong preference for handedness that is certainly possible.

801
00:59:31.632 --> 00:59:39.918
Whether the mechanism 4 billion years ago was exactly the Sawai reaction or some other part, it's not entirely possible.

802
00:59:40.848 --> 01:00:03.393
clear right i mean there's the extreme case where life came from outer space and that already had a handedness so then you know that answers the question so so pan-spermia yeah so origin of life is a is a very is a very different question but this certainly gets to things that are possible right you know it tells you that you don't need like an outside

803
01:00:05.168 --> 01:00:06.029
Like, agent.

804
01:00:06.089 --> 01:00:06.789
Invisible hand.

805
01:00:06.849 --> 01:00:13.894
Yeah, invisible hand, vitalism, like some mysterious force that's in life that creates these building blocks one way or the other.

806
01:00:14.435 --> 01:00:23.962
Now, around the world, researchers are taking the next step, and they're trying to repeat Psoa's achievement, but with the aim of producing homochiral amino acids and sugars.

807
01:00:24.382 --> 01:00:25.963
Right now, we've done simple molecules.

808
01:00:26.243 --> 01:00:29.506
We'd like to make even more complicated molecules, but we need to be careful.

809
01:00:29.746 --> 01:00:30.066
Okay.

810
01:00:30.226 --> 01:00:30.467
Okay?

811
01:00:30.727 --> 01:00:33.409
We do not want to make mirror life.

812
01:00:33.429 --> 01:00:33.769
Okay.

813
01:00:34.317 --> 01:00:42.682
And in the recent times, we've had a lot of, like, alarmist news coming out about Mirror Life.

814
01:00:42.802 --> 01:00:43.523
We have more doomers?

815
01:00:43.903 --> 01:00:44.843
We have a lot of doomers.

816
01:00:45.044 --> 01:00:46.084
There's AI doomers.

817
01:00:46.685 --> 01:00:49.166
The Mirror Life doomers have been around for a while.

818
01:00:49.526 --> 01:00:49.806
Okay?

819
01:00:49.866 --> 01:00:52.008
Ever since we figured out that life is chiral.

820
01:00:52.588 --> 01:00:55.790
And we've been able to make asymmetric catalysis happen.

821
01:00:56.390 --> 01:01:01.333
There have been mirror life doomers that are telling us not to do it.

822
01:01:01.713 --> 01:01:03.254
This is just a few of the headlines.

823
01:01:03.294 --> 01:01:04.794
Mirror life is still hypothetical.

824
01:01:05.075 --> 01:01:07.196
Here's why it should probably stay that way.

825
01:01:07.476 --> 01:01:12.578
There was a news article in Nature that said, how should mirror life research be restricted?

826
01:01:12.939 --> 01:01:13.839
The debate heats up.

827
01:01:13.899 --> 01:01:19.222
My favorite one is mirror life is a mass extinction risk we don't need to take.

828
01:01:20.402 --> 01:01:23.043
I want to go a little bit into some of this.

829
01:01:23.323 --> 01:01:24.224
So what is mirror life?

830
01:01:24.704 --> 01:01:33.507
What it means is the molecules and the proteins that make up these organisms would be completely mirrored from the ones that we have.

831
01:01:33.787 --> 01:01:45.171
This would require mirrored sugars, mirrored DNA, mirrored proteins, like everything, literally everything that this particular life form that we create would have the opposite version.

832
01:01:50.212 --> 01:01:54.574
has issues if it is created and if it escapes the lab.

833
01:01:55.355 --> 01:01:57.276
Some really, really bad issues, okay?

834
01:01:57.536 --> 01:02:08.962
Because suppose you create a mirror bacterium, like a bacteria where everything is the opposite chirality from normal life, okay?

835
01:02:09.002 --> 01:02:11.203
So that means the amino acids are right-handed.

836
01:02:11.643 --> 01:02:13.364
That means the sugars are left-handed.

837
01:02:13.844 --> 01:02:14.765
Everything is opposite.

838
01:02:15.145 --> 01:02:19.387
What that means is that you can have a bacteria that...

839
01:02:20.732 --> 01:02:28.154
proliferates, but there is no defense mechanism on the earth that is suited to combat this thing.

840
01:02:29.254 --> 01:02:37.417
The viruses, like the bacteriophages that prey on the bacteria, they require chiral mechanisms to get into the bacteria.

841
01:02:37.657 --> 01:02:44.479
Well, if the bacteria has the opposite-handedness, the virus can't really screw itself into the bacterium and kill it.

842
01:02:44.619 --> 01:02:45.019
It can't.

843
01:02:45.059 --> 01:02:46.059
The Lego blocks don't.

844
01:02:46.199 --> 01:02:46.399
Yeah.

845
01:02:46.740 --> 01:02:48.180
A lot of our antibiotics...

846
01:02:48.980 --> 01:02:55.581
are chiral in nature, and they require the specific chirality of the bacterial proteins to attach and then destroy.

847
01:02:57.621 --> 01:03:10.464
Now you've got, you know, there's no predation, there's no effective predation, and the accompanying increase in the bacteria would create this runaway reaction, because the bacteria would just start eating, suppose it's photosynthetic, right?

848
01:03:10.804 --> 01:03:18.225
It doesn't, it would just, like all it needs is water, which is not chiral, carbon dioxide, which is not chiral, and sunlight.

849
01:03:18.917 --> 01:03:19.919
Which is not chiral.

850
01:03:20.761 --> 01:03:24.048
And it would just create the opposite type of glucose, the opposite type of proteins.

851
01:03:24.530 --> 01:03:24.790
Boom.

852
01:03:24.850 --> 01:03:26.273
You get a runaway reaction, right?

853
01:03:26.614 --> 01:03:26.995
Mm-hmm.

854
01:03:28.008 --> 01:03:43.732
In humans, we've got an innate human immune system, and the first line of human defense in the immune system against microbial threats relies on a pattern of recognition where you've got antibodies reacting to the invaders, or you've got antigens.

855
01:03:43.872 --> 01:03:45.612
No, the antigens are the invaders.

856
01:03:45.953 --> 01:03:52.694
The antibodies react to them, recognize, and then you've got the second line of defense that characterizes, okay, we need to start an immune response.

857
01:03:53.074 --> 01:03:55.515
Well, if our antibodies do not...

858
01:03:56.780 --> 01:04:22.198
recognize the antigens and they have no hope of recognizing the antigens because they can't because you literally can't make the opposite chirality antibody yeah that that's dangerous right that's dangerous yeah it's this is getting weird right um so immune systems will go bad instead of causing standard infections the mirror pathogen is going to act more like a cancer

859
01:04:23.599 --> 01:04:26.380
because we're not gonna even have an immune response to this thing.

860
01:04:26.740 --> 01:04:30.641
The mirror pathogen is just gonna go in and it's gonna start occupying space.

861
01:04:30.821 --> 01:04:41.164
It's gonna start reproducing and creating a runaway reproductive reaction that's gonna use bodily energy resources and there's gonna be no existing countermeasures.

862
01:04:42.565 --> 01:04:46.426
This is a very scary prospect, right?

863
01:04:46.866 --> 01:04:50.947
So image mirror life is really quite a danger.

864
01:04:51.543 --> 01:04:53.465
OG Doomers might be on to something there.

865
01:04:53.525 --> 01:04:54.185
Yeah, yeah.

866
01:04:54.365 --> 01:04:59.970
This is from way back, and they've been calling for bans on this thing for a very long time.

867
01:04:59.990 --> 01:05:01.011
Now, what's the current status?

868
01:05:01.351 --> 01:05:06.355
Now, mirror life does not exist, and it can't form naturally because natural...

869
01:05:06.755 --> 01:05:11.558
So biology prefers one-handedness and mirror life is necessarily the other-handedness.

870
01:05:11.718 --> 01:05:13.960
Should we put a qualifier there that says on Earth?

871
01:05:14.540 --> 01:05:14.840
On Earth.

872
01:05:15.581 --> 01:05:15.961
We should.

873
01:05:16.161 --> 01:05:17.802
Just as a – not that it's – Yeah.

874
01:05:18.222 --> 01:05:21.264
We haven't seen extraterrestrial life at this point in time.

875
01:05:21.284 --> 01:05:21.564
Yeah.

876
01:05:21.584 --> 01:05:21.765
But –

877
01:05:22.565 --> 01:05:26.546
That's also a reason why bringing stuff back is not a good idea as well.

878
01:05:26.606 --> 01:05:27.906
Yes, exactly.

879
01:05:28.346 --> 01:05:32.267
And that's also a reason why bringing stuff there is not a good idea as well, right?

880
01:05:32.307 --> 01:05:40.508
So that's why when we go to places like Europa to look for life, we better know that all of our equipment is sterilized in some sense, right?

881
01:05:40.968 --> 01:05:43.689
Because Europa could have the other handedness of life.

882
01:05:44.029 --> 01:05:46.749
Now, it's challenging to build mirrored life, right?

883
01:05:47.029 --> 01:05:50.410
You need to create a central dogma that is a mirrored central dogma.

884
01:05:50.690 --> 01:06:05.893
Like, for example, nobody's created a mirrored ribosome where all of the amino acids and all of the RNA are exactly the opposite type, let alone some major components like the tRNAs that are required for protein synthesis and things like that.

885
01:06:05.913 --> 01:06:07.713
You would need a mirrored DNA.

886
01:06:07.733 --> 01:06:09.013
You would need a mirrored RNA.

887
01:06:09.033 --> 01:06:11.574
You would need mirrored RNA polymerases.

888
01:06:11.914 --> 01:06:13.594
So all of this stuff needs to happen.

889
01:06:13.734 --> 01:06:15.955
And like you'd really need to like try.

890
01:06:16.095 --> 01:06:16.875
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

891
01:06:17.195 --> 01:06:17.475
You know?

892
01:06:17.595 --> 01:06:17.775
Yeah.

893
01:06:18.215 --> 01:06:27.128
Um, it, it, there's so many similarities with the ongoing AI safety conversation, just in terms of like, there being two camps, people are like, this shouldn't happen.

894
01:06:27.388 --> 01:06:31.313
Uh, and then other folks saying, well, we don't even, we're not even close.

895
01:06:31.494 --> 01:06:31.714
Yeah.

896
01:06:31.774 --> 01:06:32.014
Right.

897
01:06:32.115 --> 01:06:34.197
It has that same, uh, dynamic.

898
01:06:34.778 --> 01:06:35.019
Um, um,

899
01:06:36.427 --> 01:06:49.377
Part of the challenge with things like this is because we are increasing in our ability to do scientific innovation generally, AI enabled or not, the gap time between we don't have any of the component parts to having the component parts.

900
01:06:50.038 --> 01:06:53.420
It's not necessarily the time compression there is non-trivial.

901
01:06:53.601 --> 01:06:54.041
Exactly.

902
01:06:54.221 --> 01:06:54.461
Yeah.

903
01:06:54.601 --> 01:06:59.827
And so right now, the best we've got is like a scientific moratorium.

904
01:06:59.907 --> 01:07:05.493
OK, in 2024, there was an international coalition of 38 leading scientists, including some Nobel laureates.

905
01:07:05.813 --> 01:07:08.816
They published this landmark call for a halt.

906
01:07:09.357 --> 01:07:12.140
And what they're effectively doing is like a taboo strategy.

907
01:07:12.200 --> 01:07:14.983
Like, I'm not going to review papers that...

908
01:07:16.068 --> 01:07:17.991
you know, forward mirror life.

909
01:07:18.672 --> 01:07:21.435
Maybe we don't fund research that forwards mirror life.

910
01:07:21.455 --> 01:07:32.591
There's major international bodies that recently issued critical reports like the UNESCO international bioethics committee, the world health organization, the UN secretary general's scientific advisory, but like,

911
01:07:33.942 --> 01:07:44.667
Yeah, we've seen how in the current world environment, geopolitically and otherwise, unfortunately, these entities that are meant to create collective action have struggled.

912
01:07:44.827 --> 01:07:45.867
Yeah.

913
01:07:46.267 --> 01:07:51.790
And we've seen a breakdown, unfortunately, in the ability to get global collaboration on things.

914
01:07:53.132 --> 01:07:54.193
a lot of different things.

915
01:07:54.373 --> 01:07:54.613
Yeah.

916
01:07:54.633 --> 01:07:55.694
So we're kind of in a tough spot.

917
01:07:55.794 --> 01:07:56.234
Yeah.

918
01:07:56.474 --> 01:08:01.337
And it's complicated by the fact that not everyone even agrees that we should just like sweepingly ban this thing.

919
01:08:01.377 --> 01:08:06.980
There's some synthetic biologists that argue that a blanket ban would be premature because we're so far away from it.

920
01:08:07.420 --> 01:08:14.585
And, you know, mirror image peptides and biomolecules, they can currently be used to design safer, highly stable drugs.

921
01:08:14.805 --> 01:08:18.027
You know, beneficial mirror molecules can make...

922
01:08:19.067 --> 01:08:47.155
better drugs effectively and that's very far away from living self-replicating mirror cells sounds a lot like sam altman right yeah um i don't think there's a whole like usa versus china debate here right because i think everyone agrees that let's not do this um but there's no like supremacy mirror life supremacy going on but but there's there's some like debate about you know maybe not a blanket ban it kind of reminds me of you know um when we were talking about

923
01:08:49.278 --> 01:09:05.849
Sudhir Parikh, the CEO of AAAS, he was talking about how some of the advice that he gave the Senate Scientific Advisory Committee was used on the floor of Congress to, like, steer legislation.

924
01:09:05.949 --> 01:09:16.075
One of the examples that he gave us, and we'll have the interview coming out soon, he said that, you know, there was a ban for any chimeras of human, animal, or animal, animal animals.

925
01:09:18.728 --> 01:09:25.272
Well, the blanket ban would stop any genetic modification from happening, right?

926
01:09:25.312 --> 01:09:27.273
And that's a huge ban, right?

927
01:09:27.534 --> 01:09:32.697
So there's, like, room to do this, but at the same time, like...

928
01:09:34.963 --> 01:09:58.197
like animal animal chimeras are not an existential risk for all life on earth so the fact that like right now we're just we're just oh it's taboo like let's not do it guys i think we should have a little i think we should get our act together here guys like the more i researched this i was like how are we just how are we just like let's not do it guys that's like our best strategy

929
01:10:00.404 --> 01:10:01.227
It doesn't make any sense.

930
01:10:01.889 --> 01:10:06.545
And it's fascinating because once you get into the details to understand what's functionally happening –

931
01:10:07.173 --> 01:10:09.494
It's clear where the risk comes from.

932
01:10:09.854 --> 01:10:10.454
Exactly.

933
01:10:10.774 --> 01:10:14.274
It's a lot easier to see the risk than some of the RSI debate.

934
01:10:14.334 --> 01:10:18.455
Although I am more doomer than non-doomer on recursive self-improvement.

935
01:10:18.835 --> 01:10:23.076
But I think it requires more infrastructure around it.

936
01:10:23.556 --> 01:10:25.377
This is like once it's created and it's out.

937
01:10:25.597 --> 01:10:27.097
No, it's like – It's really bad.

938
01:10:27.117 --> 01:10:27.697
It's really bad.

939
01:10:27.857 --> 01:10:28.577
It's really bad.

940
01:10:28.657 --> 01:10:30.157
All you need is like one bacteria.

941
01:10:30.177 --> 01:10:30.358
Right.

942
01:10:30.478 --> 01:10:30.878
Exactly.

943
01:10:31.018 --> 01:10:31.558
Yeah.

944
01:10:31.718 --> 01:10:32.118
Exactly.

945
01:10:32.198 --> 01:10:32.478
So –

946
01:10:33.098 --> 01:10:36.999
I'm going to end on a lighter note than existential dread.

947
01:10:37.719 --> 01:10:44.621
Before we end, I want to mention that I'm pretty sure I caught a mistake by the Nobel Committee's press material.

948
01:10:44.722 --> 01:10:45.142
Uh-oh.

949
01:10:45.322 --> 01:10:45.582
Okay?

950
01:10:45.882 --> 01:10:49.523
So on the left-hand side is the popular science background.

951
01:10:50.850 --> 01:10:54.533
That's an image of the Sawa chemical reaction.

952
01:10:55.174 --> 01:11:03.241
The intermediary is the left and right versions of the catalyst that then, you know, auto catalyze themselves and create the runaway reaction.

953
01:11:04.122 --> 01:11:04.302
And...

954
01:11:05.433 --> 01:11:09.917
If you notice on the left-hand side, the colored versions, this is the popular science.

955
01:11:09.937 --> 01:11:13.500
So, you know, they got some graphic artists to, like, make this version.

956
01:11:14.200 --> 01:11:17.983
They're showing the left version of it and then the right version of it.

957
01:11:18.064 --> 01:11:18.544
It's flipped.

958
01:11:18.784 --> 01:11:18.984
Yes.

959
01:11:19.084 --> 01:11:19.285
Right?

960
01:11:19.385 --> 01:11:19.625
Okay.

961
01:11:20.345 --> 01:11:27.111
But let's look at the molecule in a little bit greater detail, okay?

962
01:11:27.511 --> 01:11:29.333
If this molecule was completely flat...

963
01:11:30.560 --> 01:11:33.461
then all I'd have to do is just flip the left into the right.

964
01:11:33.881 --> 01:11:37.842
And then I would, those two are not enantiomers if they're completely flat.

965
01:11:38.222 --> 01:11:48.744
The fact that they're not flat comes from the fact that on the left, there's a dotted line that's attaching the zinc group to the organic molecule.

966
01:11:48.864 --> 01:11:53.585
And on the right-hand side, there's a solid line that is attaching the zinc to the solid molecule.

967
01:11:53.946 --> 01:11:57.606
Now in chemistry, the convention is dotted line means it's moving away.

968
01:11:58.327 --> 01:12:00.127
And solid line means it's moving towards.

969
01:12:01.492 --> 01:12:15.418
But if you're flipping it, then the zinc that's away on the left-hand side, as I turn it and flip it, the zinc is going to come towards me on the right-hand side.

970
01:12:16.019 --> 01:12:19.040
Those two are the same molecule, right?

971
01:12:19.400 --> 01:12:26.744
In the scientific background, they were a bit more careful because I think they just copy and pasted the image from the paper itself.

972
01:12:27.617 --> 01:12:32.647
And there, it's showing the left and the right versions of that molecule.

973
01:12:34.229 --> 01:12:35.050
It's not flipped.

974
01:12:35.350 --> 01:12:35.610
Right.

975
01:12:36.470 --> 01:12:38.231
And one of them is dotted going away.

976
01:12:38.412 --> 01:12:40.333
One of them is solid going towards.

977
01:12:40.973 --> 01:12:41.734
Uh-oh.

978
01:12:42.094 --> 01:12:42.574
Right?

979
01:12:42.774 --> 01:12:43.375
I see it.

980
01:12:43.615 --> 01:12:50.079
Yeah, so on the left-hand side, what would have been correct is both of them are either dotted or you don't flip.

981
01:12:50.319 --> 01:12:51.219
And one of them is dotted.

982
01:12:51.279 --> 01:12:52.040
One of them is solid.

983
01:12:52.060 --> 01:12:52.560
Yep, yep.

984
01:12:52.580 --> 01:12:53.161
You see what I'm saying?

985
01:12:53.181 --> 01:12:54.161
I see exactly what you're saying.

986
01:12:54.321 --> 01:12:59.144
Because by having it flipped in this orientation, you're actually changing the in and outness of the zinc.

987
01:12:59.204 --> 01:12:59.665
Yeah, yeah.

988
01:13:00.485 --> 01:13:05.836
Yeah, the zinc is going away from me on the left, but if I flip it to the right, it would be coming towards me.

989
01:13:05.896 --> 01:13:06.898
It's the same molecule.

990
01:13:07.319 --> 01:13:09.643
On the other hand, if it's the opposite version, then...

991
01:13:10.787 --> 01:13:13.468
As I flip it, it would be a dotted line on the right as well.

992
01:13:14.988 --> 01:13:16.089
We're awaiting comments.

993
01:13:16.629 --> 01:13:16.929
Right.

994
01:13:16.949 --> 01:13:21.311
So if there's any chemists out there that like have some justification for this, like let me know.

995
01:13:21.331 --> 01:13:24.492
But I'm pretty sure the Nobel Committee made a mistake here.

996
01:13:24.612 --> 01:13:26.792
The Nobel Committee has been very quiet since this tweet.

997
01:13:27.573 --> 01:13:27.893
You know?

998
01:13:28.813 --> 01:13:34.235
But given what we've gone through, it makes total sense why these are representing different things.

999
01:13:34.295 --> 01:13:34.755
Yeah, yeah.

1000
01:13:35.015 --> 01:13:37.777
On the right-hand side, we're seeing true chirality, right?

1001
01:13:37.797 --> 01:13:41.359
We're seeing the enantiomers that are left-handed and right-handed.

1002
01:13:42.080 --> 01:13:44.341
On the left-hand side, we're actually seeing the same molecule.

1003
01:13:44.361 --> 01:13:45.302
Yeah, yeah.

1004
01:13:45.542 --> 01:13:47.123
Because all you're doing is rotating it.

1005
01:13:48.832 --> 01:13:50.273
Oh, that's a good one.

1006
01:13:50.634 --> 01:13:53.557
In case people didn't think we did our homework.

1007
01:13:53.817 --> 01:13:54.237
Yeah.

1008
01:13:54.357 --> 01:13:58.481
This is proof positive that we spend the time.

1009
01:13:59.122 --> 01:14:00.343
So in the comments, right?

1010
01:14:00.483 --> 01:14:03.887
FFP pod greater than Nobel Committee.

1011
01:14:03.927 --> 01:14:04.247
Let's go.

1012
01:14:05.729 --> 01:14:07.090
Or I'm wrong and let me know.

1013
01:14:10.713 --> 01:14:19.960
We have spent a lot of time this week waking up early, putting all these materials together so we could have had daily drops with the detailed understandings of each of the moving parts.

1014
01:14:20.341 --> 01:14:23.743
I just want to quickly kind of go through what we've talked about today.

1015
01:14:23.763 --> 01:14:28.968
So we started with two hands that cannot be made identical by rotating them.

1016
01:14:29.008 --> 01:14:33.732
From that small geometric difference, we reached a problem that connects the molecules in medicine to,

1017
01:14:34.092 --> 01:14:35.472
to the building blocks of life.

1018
01:14:36.033 --> 01:14:41.674
Pasteur, Louis Pasteur, made molecular symmetry experimentally visible.

1019
01:14:42.014 --> 01:14:43.955
This was our wine example earlier.

1020
01:14:44.035 --> 01:14:49.796
Cagan showed why the behavior of mixed-handed catalyst need not be a simple average.

1021
01:14:50.096 --> 01:14:55.918
And so I demonstrated a reaction in which self-production and amplification work together.

1022
01:14:56.218 --> 01:14:59.459
This non-linearity we talked about then, this autocatalysis theory.

1023
01:15:00.159 --> 01:15:02.840
A tiny starting imbalance does not always stay tiny.

1024
01:15:03.161 --> 01:15:03.701
Fascinating.

1025
01:15:03.961 --> 01:15:08.203
Under the right chemical conditions, it can shape almost the entire outcome.

1026
01:15:08.723 --> 01:15:12.125
That is the idea behind this year's Chemistry Nobel.

1027
01:15:12.585 --> 01:15:14.826
And it leaves an excellent question open.

1028
01:15:15.106 --> 01:15:19.968
Which other chemical systems can turn a small beginning into a strongly ordered result?

1029
01:15:20.308 --> 01:15:22.069
Which is what we just ended on.

1030
01:15:22.109 --> 01:15:24.370
Maybe we need to be a little bit careful about it.

1031
01:15:24.410 --> 01:15:26.512
when it comes to some of the mirror life stuff.

1032
01:15:26.852 --> 01:15:35.660
If there's a step in the story that you would like us to unpack further, in addition to the FFP Greater Than Nobel Committee in the comments, please let us know.

1033
01:15:36.001 --> 01:15:41.626
Again, all the papers and the sources are available at ffppod.com.

1034
01:15:41.906 --> 01:15:43.748
On socials, you can get all of our clips.

1035
01:15:44.328 --> 01:16:10.678
at ffp pod uh oh look our little give it a like just popped up on the screen uh for those watching on youtube that timing was quite nice look that was no hands look mom no hands i i want to take a but i know this is running a little long but i want to just take a last moment since this is going to be our last episode from the nobels um i want to give a huge big uh shout out to our resident phd krishna chowdhury this week who's been an absolute champion of

1036
01:16:10.998 --> 01:16:14.121
These are extremely dense and complex issues.

1037
01:16:14.722 --> 01:16:26.453
As I mentioned, we are up all morning recording first thing after several hours to deliver a deeply technical but conversational and approachable podcast.

1038
01:16:26.653 --> 01:16:30.696
episode right when it happens so you can really get this immediately.

1039
01:16:31.376 --> 01:16:42.444
Krishna is a big part, not only in every episode, but especially in Nobel Prize week, for us to be able to deliver the correct and accurate and still

1040
01:16:44.045 --> 01:16:45.666
enjoyable result here.

1041
01:16:45.866 --> 01:16:49.048
And, you know, I really just want to give you some flowers.

1042
01:16:49.108 --> 01:16:56.632
It's a hugely challenging thing for us to accomplish this, um, in, in, in this time period with just the two of us.

1043
01:16:57.332 --> 01:17:02.195
Um, and to get it out to you with high production value, making us look pretty.

1044
01:17:02.655 --> 01:17:11.599
Um, so, you know, in the comments, uh, if you made it to the end of the episode, please give Christian a big shout out because, um, this is, this is real work.

1045
01:17:11.880 --> 01:17:12.360
And, uh,

1046
01:17:12.780 --> 01:17:18.062
It's a pleasure to be able to produce this show alongside one of my favorite science communicators.

1047
01:17:18.102 --> 01:17:24.685
My name is Lester Nare, alongside, again, one of my favorite people, Krishna.

1048
01:17:25.205 --> 01:17:29.206
Is there anything from the week that you want to just end on before we let the people go here?

1049
01:17:31.767 --> 01:17:38.330
I want to end on the fact that, you know, I think Nobel, I think in a grand scheme, if we zoom out,

1050
01:17:39.022 --> 01:17:48.773
The Nobel Prizes are a great way to recognize scientists for a lifelong career in advancing a particular field.

1051
01:17:49.193 --> 01:17:51.636
But prizes aren't everything.

1052
01:17:52.116 --> 01:17:56.181
And science is so much bigger than the few individuals that get the Nobel Prize.

1053
01:17:56.201 --> 01:17:56.861
Yeah.

1054
01:17:57.702 --> 01:18:01.386
Even in today's episode, we talked about all of the stuff that led up to it.

1055
01:18:01.946 --> 01:18:07.551
In the Ice Cube episode, I mean, there's 450 people involved in Ice Cube.

1056
01:18:07.952 --> 01:18:09.553
Only one person got the Nobel Prize.

1057
01:18:09.994 --> 01:18:11.855
It was his baby, and it kind of makes sense.

1058
01:18:11.955 --> 01:18:15.138
But let's not forget about all of the scientists that work...

1059
01:18:15.843 --> 01:18:18.284
for creating science.

1060
01:18:18.404 --> 01:18:23.547
You know, they're just as much heroes as the Nobel Prize winners.

1061
01:18:23.587 --> 01:18:28.089
And that's why a big part of the show is just highlighting science as it happens throughout the year.

1062
01:18:28.109 --> 01:18:29.750
It's a team sport.

1063
01:18:29.810 --> 01:18:30.671
This is not tennis.

1064
01:18:31.311 --> 01:18:37.434
And again, we do always try to, for example, when we show the papers, show the whole author byline.

1065
01:18:38.014 --> 01:18:39.295
So everyone gets that recognition.

1066
01:18:39.475 --> 01:18:39.635
Yeah.

1067
01:18:39.655 --> 01:18:40.915
Because I think it's a really good point.

1068
01:18:41.316 --> 01:18:45.897
We are trying to create an entry point into this to make it enjoyable.

1069
01:18:46.337 --> 01:18:51.278
But we are extremely grateful to the entire research community.

1070
01:18:52.058 --> 01:18:57.180
And we are trying to elevate your stories in this love letter to science.

1071
01:18:57.280 --> 01:19:01.081
And one thing I will also say is that, you know, the...

1072
01:19:01.681 --> 01:19:03.922
Getting up at 2.30 in the morning, it's not just me.

1073
01:19:04.042 --> 01:19:05.622
You're doing it too.

1074
01:19:05.823 --> 01:19:14.906
And, you know, the fact that we can, like, produce this thing, release it day of, release a bunch of social clips the day of, that's all Lester.

1075
01:19:15.006 --> 01:19:23.269
And, you know, be sure to look at, like, all of the advancements that we've had in our automatic caption creation and things like that.

1076
01:19:23.549 --> 01:19:24.270
Pretty cool stuff.

1077
01:19:25.672 --> 01:19:37.987
We are one of the best teams in science entertainment, and we are trying to build off the shoulders of giants of the many researchers who don't get their stories told as often as other things.

1078
01:19:38.027 --> 01:19:40.470
And so it's a pleasure for us both to...

1079
01:19:40.670 --> 01:19:44.875
To be able to bring the show to you for many of the new listeners, we have a great back catalog.

1080
01:19:44.915 --> 01:19:45.395
Check it out.

1081
01:19:45.856 --> 01:19:49.060
We are going to go get some rest.

1082
01:19:50.341 --> 01:19:56.548
Next episode will be our interview episode from the Golden Goose Awards, which was, I can't believe that was last week.

1083
01:19:57.229 --> 01:20:09.559
When we were in D.C., we'll have three interviews with all of the awardees that won this year and that will be followed up by our interview with AAAS CEO Sudip Parikh.

1084
01:20:09.699 --> 01:20:13.142
And we may do a Halloween special, but we haven't decided.

1085
01:20:13.162 --> 01:20:15.284
We're going to take a couple days for a breather.

1086
01:20:15.625 --> 01:20:20.709
We appreciate you all and FFP Nation for joining us, and we will see you all next week.
