WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.131 --> 00:00:00.791
Hello, Internet.

2
00:00:00.811 --> 00:00:06.333
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined again by our co-host and resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

3
00:00:06.373 --> 00:00:08.613
This is From First Principles.

4
00:00:08.893 --> 00:00:19.176
We have four great stories lined up for you all today, starting with scientists have solved the oldest puzzle in the universe and have earned an invite to our game night.

5
00:00:19.196 --> 00:00:20.236
They're going to be on my team.

6
00:00:20.916 --> 00:00:26.217
The second story, scientists recode the genome for programmable synthetic proteins.

7
00:00:26.397 --> 00:00:28.318
Eat your heart out, a Zempic.

8
00:00:29.105 --> 00:00:35.273
Number three, NASA's new radar just pulled off something impossible and may in fact lead us to the aliens.

9
00:00:35.913 --> 00:00:38.296
And we will wrap up with our fourth story.

10
00:00:38.637 --> 00:00:46.847
Physicists confirm that like Superman, light has two identities that are impossible to see at once.

11
00:01:02.869 --> 00:01:04.089
My friend, how are you?

12
00:01:04.389 --> 00:01:04.870
I'm doing well.

13
00:01:04.890 --> 00:01:05.290
How are you?

14
00:01:05.770 --> 00:01:06.530
I'm doing quite well.

15
00:01:07.030 --> 00:01:07.890
Three days in a row.

16
00:01:07.930 --> 00:01:08.711
We've been together.

17
00:01:08.851 --> 00:01:09.091
Yeah.

18
00:01:09.231 --> 00:01:10.331
Now doing episode three.

19
00:01:10.591 --> 00:01:11.511
Yep.

20
00:01:12.171 --> 00:01:14.772
Really excited for what we're going to talk about today.

21
00:01:15.132 --> 00:01:16.793
I this these some of these stories are really interesting.

22
00:01:17.133 --> 00:01:18.953
So oldest puzzle in the universe.

23
00:01:19.233 --> 00:01:20.814
That's 13 billion year old puzzle.

24
00:01:21.214 --> 00:01:24.735
Our first story starts from the Max Planck Institute.

25
00:01:25.035 --> 00:01:25.255
Yes.

26
00:01:26.612 --> 00:01:34.157
Headline, scientists just recreated the universe's first molecule and solved a 13 billion year old puzzle.

27
00:01:34.917 --> 00:01:36.658
What exactly did they solve for?

28
00:01:37.119 --> 00:01:37.319
Yeah.

29
00:01:38.202 --> 00:01:40.944
The first molecule is an interesting one, right?

30
00:01:41.044 --> 00:01:46.007
It's the universe's first composite structure of multiple atoms.

31
00:01:46.628 --> 00:01:47.648
Okay?

32
00:01:47.748 --> 00:01:51.791
In order to really understand this, this story is really about primordial chemistry.

33
00:01:52.131 --> 00:01:52.412
Okay?

34
00:01:52.472 --> 00:01:54.613
It's the first chemistry that the universe saw.

35
00:01:55.534 --> 00:02:03.419
And it's extremely important for understanding the early universe and also for understanding, like, fundamental questions like how we got here.

36
00:02:03.839 --> 00:02:03.959
Right?

37
00:02:03.979 --> 00:02:07.282
Because obviously small things that happened back then –

38
00:02:08.002 --> 00:02:15.366
lead to huge deviations when you stretch out the timeline to 13 billion years when it is now, right?

39
00:02:15.667 --> 00:02:16.567
Like the butterfly effect.

40
00:02:16.727 --> 00:02:17.167
Exactly.

41
00:02:17.247 --> 00:02:26.133
And so things that happened back then, you want to really understand at a nitty-gritty level in order to really make sense of the universe that we see today.

42
00:02:26.953 --> 00:02:27.133
Right.

43
00:02:27.954 --> 00:02:36.120
So this story out of Max Planck Institute in Heidelberg, that's an experimental story, but it also has a theoretical twist.

44
00:02:36.801 --> 00:02:39.763
So when you say experimental versus theoretical, what exactly does that mean?

45
00:02:40.103 --> 00:02:50.892
Experimentally, meaning that in the lab, they actually created this primordial chemistry and then they studied it to see what the reactions could be like back when the universe first started.

46
00:02:51.072 --> 00:02:52.373
So experimentally, they did this.

47
00:02:53.974 --> 00:02:59.478
And then theoretically, they actually got some insight into how we can start modeling that early universe, right?

48
00:02:59.499 --> 00:03:04.422
Because obviously we can't go back and like experiment on the early universe.

49
00:03:04.463 --> 00:03:08.005
The best we can really do is like look with telescopes.

50
00:03:08.326 --> 00:03:13.870
But even the James Webb Space Telescope is only going to look as far back as the first stars because it requires light.

51
00:03:14.070 --> 00:03:14.270
Right.

52
00:03:14.391 --> 00:03:14.591
Right.

53
00:03:14.771 --> 00:03:20.115
And the other, I mean, we could look at the cosmic microwave background, which is going to be part of the story.

54
00:03:20.475 --> 00:03:23.258
And that thing was at 300,000 years after the Big Bang.

55
00:03:23.798 --> 00:03:26.660
So in order to really make sense of this, I think we should start at the very beginning.

56
00:03:26.841 --> 00:03:27.121
Okay.

57
00:03:27.141 --> 00:03:27.721
Start at the top.

58
00:03:27.781 --> 00:03:28.001
Okay.

59
00:03:28.062 --> 00:03:28.822
In the beginning.

60
00:03:29.002 --> 00:03:31.825
In the beginning was a point.

61
00:03:32.825 --> 00:03:35.127
And the point was extremely small, right?

62
00:03:35.207 --> 00:03:36.709
Infinite, tessaline small, they say.

63
00:03:36.749 --> 00:03:37.609
It's a singularity.

64
00:03:37.950 --> 00:03:39.331
And then it pops into existence.

65
00:03:40.526 --> 00:03:46.594
The Big Bang happens and immediately the physics that we know comes into being.

66
00:03:46.974 --> 00:03:48.116
Not exactly immediately.

67
00:03:48.156 --> 00:03:59.290
There's a short time right after the Big Bang where we don't know what the hell is happening because the energies and the densities and the temperature is so high that current physics understanding breaks down.

68
00:03:59.590 --> 00:04:06.175
But if you go past that, the first thing that happens is you're going to get like protons and neutrons.

69
00:04:06.515 --> 00:04:06.795
Okay.

70
00:04:07.295 --> 00:04:09.036
The stuff of ordinary atoms.

71
00:04:09.577 --> 00:04:11.618
Except they're not going to be in atomic form.

72
00:04:13.079 --> 00:04:13.540
How do you mean?

73
00:04:14.280 --> 00:04:14.540
Okay.

74
00:04:14.900 --> 00:04:21.945
Like the sun, for example, the interior of the sun, or most of the sun actually, is in a state called a plasma.

75
00:04:22.245 --> 00:04:22.506
Okay.

76
00:04:22.806 --> 00:04:24.027
Because stuff is so hot.

77
00:04:25.220 --> 00:04:28.423
That the electrons don't want to stick around the nuclei.

78
00:04:29.084 --> 00:04:29.364
Okay?

79
00:04:29.404 --> 00:04:31.666
So you've got hydrogen and helium nuclei in the sun.

80
00:04:32.187 --> 00:04:36.671
But, like, because it's so hot, the electrons can just, like, go off on their own.

81
00:04:37.031 --> 00:04:41.675
And so you have this soup of protons and neutrons and atomic nuclei.

82
00:04:42.016 --> 00:04:45.098
And then you have electrons just bouncing around in a soup of light.

83
00:04:45.759 --> 00:04:46.039
So...

84
00:04:46.900 --> 00:04:53.964
Atoms haven't formed because you need to be cold enough for the electrons to agree to stick around and orbit the nucleus.

85
00:04:54.405 --> 00:04:58.007
If there's too much energy, then the photon will come in and it'll just bounce it right off.

86
00:04:58.027 --> 00:04:58.687
And run away from home.

87
00:04:58.727 --> 00:04:58.928
Right?

88
00:04:59.348 --> 00:05:03.851
And so that's what the – if you've seen the images of the cosmic microwave background.

89
00:05:03.871 --> 00:05:04.031
Yes.

90
00:05:04.231 --> 00:05:08.413
This beautiful, like, map of the early universe in blue, red, and green.

91
00:05:08.513 --> 00:05:09.454
Yes.

92
00:05:10.194 --> 00:05:14.257
And that is the first ever picture of the universe at 300,000 years.

93
00:05:14.317 --> 00:05:15.478
We can't go before that.

94
00:05:16.098 --> 00:05:24.062
We can't go before that because before that, light wasn't free to roam the universe because there were no atoms.

95
00:05:24.322 --> 00:05:30.705
It would just go from one electron to another charged particle to another charged particle and bounce around, and it wasn't free.

96
00:05:30.765 --> 00:05:36.368
Like, okay, the reason why I can see the moon, right, is because the light from the moon is coming all the way.

97
00:05:36.388 --> 00:05:37.429
It's free to travel all the way.

98
00:05:37.449 --> 00:05:39.870
It's free to travel all the way, right, because there's nothing there.

99
00:05:39.970 --> 00:05:45.213
Even like you, right, there's air here, but the air isn't doing much to the light because –

100
00:05:46.353 --> 00:05:47.354
It's pretty diffuse.

101
00:05:47.514 --> 00:05:48.495
There's not a lot of density.

102
00:05:48.655 --> 00:05:51.797
And a lot of it is neutrally charged molecules, right?

103
00:05:52.097 --> 00:05:57.381
It's like the electrons have a neighboring positive charge that they're interacting with.

104
00:05:57.721 --> 00:06:01.564
So the freely flowing light doesn't really interact with it all that much.

105
00:06:01.604 --> 00:06:04.886
But prior to that 300,000-year mark, it's basically darkness.

106
00:06:04.926 --> 00:06:06.387
Yes, it's basically so hot.

107
00:06:06.807 --> 00:06:12.569
that it's like, it's not even, it's like darkness because it's the opposite of lightness of like, of, yeah.

108
00:06:12.609 --> 00:06:17.410
You know, like it's, there's so much light that it's so hot that the light can't go anywhere.

109
00:06:17.430 --> 00:06:21.231
And it doesn't mean anything to see something in that context, in that context.

110
00:06:21.251 --> 00:06:21.451
Right.

111
00:06:21.471 --> 00:06:21.611
Yeah.

112
00:06:21.751 --> 00:06:21.951
Yeah.

113
00:06:21.971 --> 00:06:22.431
Yeah.

114
00:06:22.451 --> 00:06:25.872
Um, so even though, even using the phrase darkness is not technically accurate.

115
00:06:26.012 --> 00:06:26.252
Yeah.

116
00:06:26.512 --> 00:06:31.654
Uh, because it's not, but as an analogy to, as an, in terms of, we can't see it.

117
00:06:31.714 --> 00:06:32.534
We can't see the light.

118
00:06:32.554 --> 00:06:36.035
There's like a wall and we can't see further back in time.

119
00:06:36.215 --> 00:06:36.935
You know, it's funny.

120
00:06:36.955 --> 00:06:48.302
This like reminds me of this idea that in software you have like administrator privileges and then users can access certain aspects of the app, but you can't get into how the core algorithms work.

121
00:06:48.382 --> 00:06:48.582
Yeah.

122
00:06:48.702 --> 00:06:51.464
And it's kind of like the algorithm of the universe at that very base level.

123
00:06:51.764 --> 00:06:54.646
We're currently blocked from being able to actually access.

124
00:06:54.786 --> 00:06:55.226
Exactly.

125
00:06:55.326 --> 00:06:56.787
And, you know, by that analogy.

126
00:06:57.287 --> 00:06:59.809
Even though you can't see that algorithm, right?

127
00:06:59.909 --> 00:07:00.249
Yeah.

128
00:07:00.390 --> 00:07:05.494
You would be able to look at the software and know sort of underlying what's under the hood.

129
00:07:05.514 --> 00:07:15.682
If you're an experienced coder, you could look at an app or any kind of thing and then know sort of what the structure of the underlying database and the algorithm is.

130
00:07:15.702 --> 00:07:16.382
You could reverse engineer it.

131
00:07:16.482 --> 00:07:18.324
And that's sort of what we're trying to do with…

132
00:07:18.864 --> 00:07:23.868
a lot of the other studies were trying to see, okay, what happened before this 300,000 years ago?

133
00:07:23.908 --> 00:07:28.312
Like, were there gravitational waves that were going and propagating?

134
00:07:28.392 --> 00:07:31.434
Was there a discrepancy between matter and antimatter?

135
00:07:31.795 --> 00:07:42.543
All of this stuff, you know, because we're pretty good at physics by now, that we can, like, look at this picture and, like, now start looking at the little details and start piecing together stuff that happened before.

136
00:07:42.843 --> 00:07:44.685
But this story is about stuff that happened after.

137
00:07:44.825 --> 00:07:46.306
So that's the setup.

138
00:07:46.346 --> 00:07:52.009
So the idea is the reason it's the first molecule is because of where in time we're able to do this detection.

139
00:07:52.249 --> 00:07:52.690
Yeah.

140
00:07:52.830 --> 00:07:54.691
As soon as atoms formed, right?

141
00:07:55.011 --> 00:08:00.954
As soon as atoms formed, the first thing they want to do is once it's cold enough, they want to start forming molecules.

142
00:08:01.314 --> 00:08:04.496
Molecules are just like multiple atoms interacting, right?

143
00:08:04.796 --> 00:08:08.659
Like in this room, we've got nitrogen, a lot of nitrogen.

144
00:08:08.679 --> 00:08:10.840
So that's N2, two nitrogen atoms.

145
00:08:11.541 --> 00:08:13.884
that share electrons.

146
00:08:13.964 --> 00:08:15.066
Also oxygen, obviously.

147
00:08:15.226 --> 00:08:16.087
That's why we're alive.

148
00:08:16.949 --> 00:08:20.694
Over here, the universe first created only three elements.

149
00:08:20.794 --> 00:08:22.517
In the beginning, there were only three elements.

150
00:08:22.617 --> 00:08:25.701
Hydrogen, helium, and a little tiny bit of lithium.

151
00:08:26.722 --> 00:08:28.984
But when I say they created these elements, it's the nuclei.

152
00:08:29.184 --> 00:08:30.165
The electrons aren't anywhere.

153
00:08:30.445 --> 00:08:31.625
But these nuclei form.

154
00:08:32.206 --> 00:08:34.227
Hydrogen is just a single proton, right?

155
00:08:34.267 --> 00:08:37.289
It's like kind of a cop-out to even call it.

156
00:08:37.309 --> 00:08:40.451
But it's like, okay, you've got a proton that's hydrogen.

157
00:08:40.691 --> 00:08:43.813
Helium, you've got two protons, two neutrons.

158
00:08:43.993 --> 00:08:48.376
And then lithium, you've got three protons, usually four neutrons.

159
00:08:48.796 --> 00:08:49.256
So lithium-7.

160
00:08:51.959 --> 00:08:56.544
As soon as light breaks free, now electrons can start forming atoms.

161
00:08:56.564 --> 00:08:57.905
So now you've made a hydrogen atom.

162
00:08:58.045 --> 00:09:00.468
You've made helium atoms and lithium atoms.

163
00:09:00.628 --> 00:09:03.010
The first atom to actually form was actually helium.

164
00:09:03.571 --> 00:09:03.851
Okay.

165
00:09:03.931 --> 00:09:04.812
Okay, not hydrogen.

166
00:09:04.872 --> 00:09:05.453
That's interesting.

167
00:09:05.733 --> 00:09:12.057
Yeah, and it kind of makes sense when you think about if you've done chemistry, there's something called the ionization potential.

168
00:09:12.597 --> 00:09:14.738
So helium has a higher ionization potential.

169
00:09:15.078 --> 00:09:21.282
Basically what that means is it's like it likes having electrons around it.

170
00:09:21.642 --> 00:09:23.924
OK, the nucleus, it's got two protons, right?

171
00:09:24.384 --> 00:09:25.105
Two protons.

172
00:09:25.725 --> 00:09:28.647
It's got these two empty spots where electrons can be.

173
00:09:28.687 --> 00:09:31.049
And because there's two protons, the electrons are happy to hang out.

174
00:09:31.169 --> 00:09:31.309
Yep.

175
00:09:31.609 --> 00:09:33.190
With hydrogen, there's a single proton.

176
00:09:33.831 --> 00:09:35.092
So the pull isn't that much.

177
00:09:35.432 --> 00:09:38.254
And so you need the electron has to be sort of lower.

178
00:09:38.654 --> 00:09:41.776
You know, the temperature has to be lower for this thing to make sense.

179
00:09:41.796 --> 00:09:42.137
That makes sense.

180
00:09:42.157 --> 00:09:44.638
But helium has got more of a pull because it's got two protons.

181
00:09:44.658 --> 00:09:45.039
That makes sense.

182
00:09:45.099 --> 00:09:46.059
So helium forms.

183
00:09:47.280 --> 00:09:52.404
And helium is moving around, and there's a bunch of protons, hydrogen atoms, right?

184
00:09:52.784 --> 00:10:02.130
And so all of a sudden you form something called helium hydride, which is helium with a hydrogen proton, but no extra electron.

185
00:10:02.210 --> 00:10:05.132
So only two electrons in this molecule, three protons.

186
00:10:05.152 --> 00:10:05.932
So it's an ion.

187
00:10:06.132 --> 00:10:06.413
Okay.

188
00:10:06.553 --> 00:10:07.193
Okay?

189
00:10:07.233 --> 00:10:07.894
It's an ion.

190
00:10:08.314 --> 00:10:13.077
Helium atom, hydrogen proton, and then the electrons sort of go around it.

191
00:10:13.277 --> 00:10:14.337
All three together.

192
00:10:14.377 --> 00:10:14.577
Yeah.

193
00:10:14.757 --> 00:10:14.997
Yeah.

194
00:10:15.337 --> 00:10:16.298
Okay.

195
00:10:16.318 --> 00:10:19.138
This is the first molecule that was formed.

196
00:10:19.978 --> 00:10:24.319
And having molecules is extremely important for stars.

197
00:10:25.139 --> 00:10:35.001
And you might be like that's – when I first read about this, I was like really confused because stars are helium-making factories that take hydrogen and make helium.

198
00:10:35.341 --> 00:10:37.522
So there's no molecules on the sun.

199
00:10:37.562 --> 00:10:38.042
Right, right.

200
00:10:38.122 --> 00:10:42.483
Unless it's in the outer, outer – but like inside the sun, there's no molecules.

201
00:10:42.643 --> 00:10:42.903
Okay?

202
00:10:43.303 --> 00:10:47.085
So why do we need molecules in order to make stars?

203
00:10:47.426 --> 00:10:48.486
That's the fundamental question.

204
00:10:48.826 --> 00:10:50.788
We need molecules in order to make stars.

205
00:10:51.268 --> 00:10:56.191
The reason why is we need the universe to cool down drastically.

206
00:10:56.731 --> 00:10:56.991
Okay.

207
00:10:57.371 --> 00:11:02.354
If we're a soup of hot gas, even if it's neutral gas.

208
00:11:02.595 --> 00:11:03.475
Kind of like me this weekend.

209
00:11:04.115 --> 00:11:05.296
Oh, yeah.

210
00:11:05.316 --> 00:11:05.997
I heard about that.

211
00:11:07.578 --> 00:11:09.779
Yeah, but if we're this like soup of hot gas –

212
00:11:10.970 --> 00:11:18.595
The way a star forms is you've got some, like, gas cloud, and then it's going to collapse under gravity, right?

213
00:11:18.695 --> 00:11:21.417
It's going to be spinning very slowly, and it's going to collapse under gravity.

214
00:11:21.437 --> 00:11:24.499
So conservation of angular momentum, it's going to spin faster.

215
00:11:25.080 --> 00:11:29.423
Now, when it collapses, it's going to heat up, right?

216
00:11:29.723 --> 00:11:32.785
Stuff is going to bump into each other and start heating up.

217
00:11:33.145 --> 00:11:34.106
Heating up means what?

218
00:11:34.166 --> 00:11:37.889
Thermodynamically, it means the things are moving faster.

219
00:11:37.909 --> 00:11:38.369
Right.

220
00:11:38.529 --> 00:11:42.631
If things are moving faster, that's kind of like an outward pressure, right?

221
00:11:43.971 --> 00:11:49.473
And if gravity is trying to pull it in, but there's an outward pressure pushing out, there's going to be a balance.

222
00:11:49.874 --> 00:11:51.974
You need to keep having gravity pull in.

223
00:11:52.395 --> 00:11:54.596
So what you need is some kind of pressure release valve.

224
00:11:54.896 --> 00:11:55.356
Okay, right.

225
00:11:55.376 --> 00:11:57.497
Okay, that lets go of all that energy.

226
00:11:57.617 --> 00:11:57.817
Right.

227
00:11:59.202 --> 00:12:01.344
And that's what we mean by cooling down.

228
00:12:01.464 --> 00:12:07.450
We need to cool this thing down and we need to, by conservation of energy, all this energy from the thermal motion has to go somewhere.

229
00:12:08.071 --> 00:12:11.594
And it would be best if it just leaves in terms of radiation.

230
00:12:12.195 --> 00:12:14.197
Remember, radiation is also energy.

231
00:12:14.357 --> 00:12:14.577
Yes.

232
00:12:14.677 --> 00:12:14.858
Right?

233
00:12:15.438 --> 00:12:19.320
But the so there's two ways in which this thermal radiation can go.

234
00:12:19.740 --> 00:12:20.621
One is it stays there.

235
00:12:20.901 --> 00:12:26.824
So things just keep bombing into each other, getting faster and faster, getting faster and faster.

236
00:12:27.264 --> 00:12:30.786
That's just the energy is getting locked in the heat of the thermal motion.

237
00:12:31.406 --> 00:12:37.448
But if we somehow let the radiation just go freely, then we're slowing down.

238
00:12:37.929 --> 00:12:38.209
Got it.

239
00:12:38.309 --> 00:12:38.529
Right?

240
00:12:38.709 --> 00:12:40.050
Because of conservation of energy.

241
00:12:40.350 --> 00:12:41.690
And if we're slowing down, we're cooling.

242
00:12:41.990 --> 00:12:43.491
And then that pressure is no longer there.

243
00:12:43.531 --> 00:12:47.092
And so it can contract even more and then cool more and then contract even more.

244
00:12:47.553 --> 00:12:52.875
So we need some way to dump all of the kinetic energy that is in the motion of heat.

245
00:12:53.755 --> 00:12:55.477
into radiation into light.

246
00:12:55.997 --> 00:12:56.237
Okay.

247
00:12:56.497 --> 00:12:57.098
How do we do that?

248
00:12:57.718 --> 00:13:00.020
Molecules are really good at doing that.

249
00:13:00.260 --> 00:13:00.581
Interesting.

250
00:13:00.601 --> 00:13:05.044
Converting sort of thermal motion into light.

251
00:13:05.685 --> 00:13:05.905
Okay.

252
00:13:06.365 --> 00:13:07.806
And the reason why a molecule can do that.

253
00:13:07.867 --> 00:13:10.469
So like if you just have an atom, it's just a billiard ball.

254
00:13:11.029 --> 00:13:12.650
I mean, atoms obviously radiate, right?

255
00:13:12.670 --> 00:13:19.116
There's the hydrogen energy spectrum where the electron bumps to a higher energy and goes down like these lights that we have in the studio.

256
00:13:20.937 --> 00:13:26.661
I don't know if I don't know what element these guys are, but like old school back when, like we have those like white incandescent lights.

257
00:13:26.741 --> 00:13:26.941
Right.

258
00:13:27.281 --> 00:13:28.141
Those are mercury.

259
00:13:28.422 --> 00:13:35.146
Those are mercury gas and the white would be from the mercury energy levels going up and down because you pump electricity.

260
00:13:35.486 --> 00:13:36.667
The electrons go up and down.

261
00:13:36.707 --> 00:13:39.148
They release light and you get this white light and get that right.

262
00:13:39.168 --> 00:13:42.130
You get like distinct colors that end up being white light.

263
00:13:42.510 --> 00:13:44.672
OK, so individual atoms can do that.

264
00:13:45.372 --> 00:13:48.715
But they can't do that under a certain temperature, okay?

265
00:13:49.056 --> 00:13:53.159
Because those energy levels are discrete because of quantum mechanics, right?

266
00:13:53.440 --> 00:14:02.288
So under a certain energy level, if the photon at that energy is not big enough to kick this transition, then you're just stuck moving around being billiard balls.

267
00:14:02.728 --> 00:14:07.333
Because the temperature is so low that the excitation isn't enough.

268
00:14:07.793 --> 00:14:08.554
To do this.

269
00:14:08.634 --> 00:14:08.874
Okay.

270
00:14:09.094 --> 00:14:10.275
So all of a sudden now you're stuck.

271
00:14:10.335 --> 00:14:11.996
This happens at around 10,000 Kelvin.

272
00:14:12.196 --> 00:14:12.656
Okay.

273
00:14:12.696 --> 00:14:14.938
10,000 Celsius, about 18,000 Fahrenheit.

274
00:14:15.158 --> 00:14:15.458
Okay.

275
00:14:15.478 --> 00:14:17.239
So the universe is like bigger now.

276
00:14:18.540 --> 00:14:19.501
It's cooled down a lot.

277
00:14:20.521 --> 00:14:21.982
But we need to cool down further.

278
00:14:22.723 --> 00:14:23.963
Atoms won't be able to do this.

279
00:14:24.444 --> 00:14:24.664
Okay.

280
00:14:24.744 --> 00:14:26.725
So instead what you have is molecules.

281
00:14:27.245 --> 00:14:29.307
And what molecules can do is they can vibrate.

282
00:14:30.487 --> 00:14:30.707
Right.

283
00:14:30.988 --> 00:14:32.810
They have like vibrational modes of energy.

284
00:14:32.850 --> 00:14:35.974
They can rotate and bump into each other that way.

285
00:14:35.994 --> 00:14:36.254
Yep.

286
00:14:36.474 --> 00:14:36.875
They can.

287
00:14:37.035 --> 00:14:47.367
They have these dipole transitions like each molecule has a quantum state like and so those quantum states are actually at the energy level of this 10,000 and lower.

288
00:14:47.928 --> 00:14:54.372
So if you can make molecules and you can have those molecules then heat up, those molecules will then radiate away.

289
00:14:54.512 --> 00:14:54.692
Yes.

290
00:14:54.813 --> 00:14:56.414
And then you can finally form these stars.

291
00:14:56.914 --> 00:14:57.174
Okay.

292
00:14:57.274 --> 00:14:57.434
Yep.

293
00:14:57.454 --> 00:15:02.698
So understanding this chemistry is really important for understanding the speed at which the universe...

294
00:15:03.258 --> 00:15:06.881
cool down in its first million years.

295
00:15:07.221 --> 00:15:07.421
Yes.

296
00:15:07.461 --> 00:15:07.641
Right?

297
00:15:07.982 --> 00:15:09.863
And that's when those first stars formed.

298
00:15:10.243 --> 00:15:14.446
Those first stars then created the ingredients for other stars.

299
00:15:14.486 --> 00:15:18.970
Like they could be the things that created the galaxy centers, that created galaxies.

300
00:15:19.410 --> 00:15:19.610
Right?

301
00:15:19.710 --> 00:15:24.394
So this is very important for us to understand how we got here, to understand the chemistry at the very beginning.

302
00:15:24.909 --> 00:15:35.217
The idea is here, kind of like we started with, there's a butterfly effect that happens, right, in terms of where the starting point of the universe is and, like, where we are here in this 3D space.

303
00:15:35.798 --> 00:15:49.589
And there are these interesting transition points, one of which is, you know, the transition point from the soup to then having our first molecules, and from the first molecules to then having the first things like stars.

304
00:15:50.209 --> 00:15:53.111
And what's interesting is kind of just the way you talked about it,

305
00:15:54.617 --> 00:16:04.745
it's kind of non-intuitive that you needed molecules to first exist in order for then stars to actually have the capability to even form themselves.

306
00:16:05.045 --> 00:16:16.694
And so the reason why this 13-billion-year-old puzzle is so important is because it fills in this gap of seeing how it went from first molecules to stars,

307
00:16:17.655 --> 00:16:24.160
Which now gives us the ability to understand how long did it actually in this early universe.

308
00:16:24.180 --> 00:16:27.963
We can begin to extrapolate from this to look at star formation.

309
00:16:28.003 --> 00:16:28.263
Yes.

310
00:16:28.423 --> 00:16:34.248
And really begin to have a deeper, more robust understanding of some of those sort of later stage actions.

311
00:16:34.308 --> 00:16:35.048
Yes, exactly.

312
00:16:35.128 --> 00:16:36.550
Like how did the first stars form?

313
00:16:37.210 --> 00:16:40.811
Because when they formed, it would also tell us how big the stars were.

314
00:16:41.191 --> 00:16:41.631
Right?

315
00:16:42.151 --> 00:16:49.973
There's a hypothesis that the supermassive black holes at the center of galaxies are actually these dead first stars.

316
00:16:50.153 --> 00:16:50.333
Right?

317
00:16:50.353 --> 00:16:54.935
Because that's the only way you can have like a million solar masses.

318
00:16:55.315 --> 00:16:55.495
Right.

319
00:16:56.716 --> 00:16:56.916
Right.

320
00:16:57.276 --> 00:16:57.496
Right.

321
00:16:57.656 --> 00:16:57.837
Right.

322
00:16:58.117 --> 00:17:02.921
So it's it's it's extremely important to understand, like, very fundamentally what the universe is about.

323
00:17:03.642 --> 00:17:13.451
And what's what's incredible about this study is that this is not it is it has theoretical implications for how we do simulations, etc.

324
00:17:13.892 --> 00:17:15.814
But this was an experimental result.

325
00:17:16.494 --> 00:17:17.715
This was an experimental result.

326
00:17:17.735 --> 00:17:35.043
So what they did was they were concerned with this helium hydride, helium and H+, and they were concerned with how this interacts with sort of the next few molecules that arise, which is the next molecule that will probably arise is like hydrogen, right, molecular hydrogen, which is H2.

327
00:17:35.803 --> 00:17:41.947
Now, H2 is not very good at dissipating energy because H2 is a symmetric molecule, right?

328
00:17:42.007 --> 00:17:43.408
It's just like mirror image.

329
00:17:43.808 --> 00:17:50.913
So, like, there's some vibrational modes, but there's no dipole in the sense that, like, all of the electrons aren't squished on one side.

330
00:17:51.013 --> 00:17:56.677
With helium and hydrogen, all of the electrons are basically hanging out near the helium because there's two protons in one.

331
00:17:57.457 --> 00:18:01.018
So then you have this electric dipole where there's this charge imbalance.

332
00:18:01.358 --> 00:18:10.039
And that charge imbalance gives the molecule the ability to do a bunch more energy transitions and then dissipate out more heat.

333
00:18:10.079 --> 00:18:12.680
Because there's this empty block that it needs to resolve for.

334
00:18:12.860 --> 00:18:14.600
Yeah, there's an asymmetry.

335
00:18:14.640 --> 00:18:17.601
And then any tiny little thing is going to kick it in a weird way.

336
00:18:18.641 --> 00:18:22.382
Then you get into these quantum states and so on and so forth, which we don't have to get into.

337
00:18:22.682 --> 00:18:24.662
But for hydrogen, H2, it's not very good.

338
00:18:25.022 --> 00:18:26.363
Hydrogen and deuterium.

339
00:18:26.383 --> 00:18:28.566
Deuterium is an isotope of hydrogen.

340
00:18:29.266 --> 00:18:33.731
Chemically, it's the same as hydrogen, but it's got a proton and a neutron, right?

341
00:18:33.771 --> 00:18:35.072
So it's just a little bit heavier.

342
00:18:35.232 --> 00:18:35.472
Got it.

343
00:18:35.492 --> 00:18:40.998
Now, if I have a deuterium and a hydrogen, now there's like a slight imbalance of mass, right?

344
00:18:41.038 --> 00:18:46.003
So then you can have some sort of other stuff, but it's not nearly as good as helium hydride.

345
00:18:46.483 --> 00:18:53.449
So the problem is they wanted to figure out how often does helium hydride transition to helium deuterium.

346
00:18:53.469 --> 00:18:53.589
Yep.

347
00:18:53.750 --> 00:18:53.990
Okay?

348
00:18:54.350 --> 00:19:02.658
Because, like, if this thing is really slow, then helium hydride could stick around for a really long time and dissipate a lot faster.

349
00:19:02.758 --> 00:19:02.918
Yep.

350
00:19:03.238 --> 00:19:04.780
But what they actually found was that...

351
00:19:05.400 --> 00:19:09.543
This helium hydride to helium deuterium is actually quite fast.

352
00:19:10.323 --> 00:19:20.470
Theoretically, it was postulated that it would be quite slow because they thought that there's some kind of energy barrier that prevents this reaction from happening.

353
00:19:20.750 --> 00:19:26.394
But new simulations and somebody actually found a mistake in the old simulations.

354
00:19:26.514 --> 00:19:31.875
because scientists are always like, yeah, you know, like, I don't think sure about that.

355
00:19:31.895 --> 00:19:32.815
Yeah, exactly.

356
00:19:32.895 --> 00:19:34.356
So so they found this mistake.

357
00:19:34.396 --> 00:19:36.116
And so it turns out there is an energy barrier.

358
00:19:36.156 --> 00:19:36.316
Right.

359
00:19:36.716 --> 00:19:41.257
And what better way to experimentally confirm this than to actually make the thing and then make the reaction happen?

360
00:19:41.537 --> 00:19:43.858
And what they found was, yeah, there isn't an energy barrier.

361
00:19:44.138 --> 00:19:53.720
So even at very low temperatures, you can have this transition happening, which means that the helium hydride is turning into this this other not very good molecule.

362
00:19:54.220 --> 00:19:54.380
So.

363
00:19:55.300 --> 00:19:59.506
that kind of slows down the cooling of this universe a little bit, right?

364
00:19:59.686 --> 00:20:05.874
And if it slows down the cooling a little bit, then we need to start re-simulating how those stars formed.

365
00:20:06.214 --> 00:20:10.179
If we were under this assumption that the chemistry was happening this way and now it's happening this way,

366
00:20:10.860 --> 00:20:12.582
It impacts the cooling efficiency.

367
00:20:12.722 --> 00:20:21.169
Because everything will shift on the 13 billion year timeline one way or another based on the rate at which the cooling can happen.

368
00:20:21.189 --> 00:20:23.311
Things either happen sooner or later.

369
00:20:23.331 --> 00:20:23.752
Or later.

370
00:20:23.772 --> 00:20:27.535
Depending on this as one of the many, many, many variables in that equation.

371
00:20:27.655 --> 00:20:27.835
Right.

372
00:20:27.875 --> 00:20:39.907
And then we can use that and then start looking at James Webb Space Telescope observations of the first stars, which are – I mean, this thing is pushing the limits to how far back we can see light, right?

373
00:20:40.187 --> 00:20:46.713
So we're seeing like the first, very first stars that are almost 13 billion – I think there's some that are even older than 13 billion years.

374
00:20:46.793 --> 00:20:51.138
Not older than the universe, but like almost immediately when stars could form, we're seeing that star.

375
00:20:51.578 --> 00:20:51.818
Right.

376
00:20:51.958 --> 00:20:52.138
Right.

377
00:20:52.259 --> 00:21:00.484
Like so it's incredibly exciting to be like, OK, like now we have I think we have a better handle on this primordial chemistry.

378
00:21:00.885 --> 00:21:02.526
And now we can start building these models.

379
00:21:02.586 --> 00:21:04.287
Science is an iterative process.

380
00:21:04.367 --> 00:21:04.607
Right.

381
00:21:04.647 --> 00:21:14.814
So it's like once you do this, now you can do more complicated things and you can push back the envelope further and further into like just how much we know about the early universe.

382
00:21:14.874 --> 00:21:19.337
And this what's interesting is how this kind of ties to obviously James Webb has been.

383
00:21:20.238 --> 00:21:26.900
sort of more in the news, in the popular science news, because of its capability set, how much has been spent on it, etc.

384
00:21:26.960 --> 00:21:27.140
Yeah.

385
00:21:27.420 --> 00:21:49.065
And what's interesting is you have the results we're getting from James Webb over here, but we still have other fundamental science research that impacts how we interpret and analyze this brand new, fresh, highly robust data set in ways that makes it even more valuable than the extremely valuable category that it's already been labeled as.

386
00:21:49.085 --> 00:21:49.285
Yeah.

387
00:21:49.365 --> 00:21:50.607
Yeah, it's kind of cool.

388
00:21:50.627 --> 00:21:52.891
Like, this was done in a lab on Earth, right?

389
00:21:52.931 --> 00:21:53.892
In Heidelberg, Germany.

390
00:21:54.013 --> 00:21:54.193
Right.

391
00:21:54.333 --> 00:22:02.026
Like, so experiments here can tell us about, like, stuff that's happening, you know, the chemistry that's happening, like,

392
00:22:03.169 --> 00:22:04.690
300,000 years after the Big Bang.

393
00:22:04.790 --> 00:22:05.190
Kind of cool.

394
00:22:05.470 --> 00:22:06.190
It is kind of cool.

395
00:22:06.250 --> 00:22:11.093
Please keep all the Big Bang theory jokes to yourself as we've already seen them flooding the comments.

396
00:22:11.173 --> 00:22:12.413
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

397
00:22:12.433 --> 00:22:14.114
Guys, I can talk to girls, okay?

398
00:22:14.574 --> 00:22:15.655
I can talk to them sober.

399
00:22:17.676 --> 00:22:28.120
So that's a fascinating – the universe's oldest puzzle, one of which we now have an interesting answer for courtesy of the Max Planck Institute.

400
00:22:28.881 --> 00:22:30.742
And so we're going to shift to –

401
00:22:31.622 --> 00:22:38.783
Another story that's about really small stuff, which is now coming out of Yale University.

402
00:22:39.904 --> 00:22:45.505
So the story out of Yale is Yale scientists recode the genome for programmable synthetic proteins.

403
00:22:45.545 --> 00:22:56.007
A team of synthetic biologists have rewritten the genetic code of an organism using a novel cellular platform for producing a new class of synthetic proteins.

404
00:22:56.727 --> 00:22:57.768
Very fascinating.

405
00:22:57.868 --> 00:22:59.328
A little bit earlier this year, this came out.

406
00:22:59.829 --> 00:23:08.412
And so, you know, help us understand the implications of the ability to recode the genome for specifically programmable synthetic proteins.

407
00:23:08.552 --> 00:23:09.473
Yeah.

408
00:23:09.633 --> 00:23:14.955
You know, we've talked about synthetic bio on this podcast before, like the power of CRISPR.

409
00:23:15.536 --> 00:23:17.156
This takes it even a step further.

410
00:23:17.496 --> 00:23:17.777
Okay.

411
00:23:17.797 --> 00:23:21.358
This is like, honestly, I thought this was kind of crazy when I read it.

412
00:23:21.478 --> 00:23:21.698
Okay.

413
00:23:21.978 --> 00:23:25.500
So CRISPR is the programmable DNA tool.

414
00:23:25.740 --> 00:23:25.981
Right.

415
00:23:26.241 --> 00:23:28.605
That's the thing that lets us snipe a bit of DNA here.

416
00:23:28.925 --> 00:23:32.792
And then other enzymes will come in and put in whatever custom bit of DNA we want.

417
00:23:33.172 --> 00:23:33.373
Right.

418
00:23:33.874 --> 00:23:36.418
This thing is making like.

419
00:23:38.090 --> 00:23:44.694
So with CRISPR, one can imagine that this genome sequence was maybe possible without humans, right?

420
00:23:45.355 --> 00:23:46.996
Through mutations and stuff like that.

421
00:23:47.076 --> 00:23:47.276
Yes.

422
00:23:47.396 --> 00:23:51.999
Here, we're making synthetic biology that, like, literally could not be possible without humans.

423
00:23:52.279 --> 00:23:56.962
The idea is, like, CRISPR, like, you can see natural processes get the result of what we can do.

424
00:23:56.983 --> 00:23:59.304
Yeah, maybe in a billion – yeah, it'll take, like, forever, right?

425
00:23:59.384 --> 00:24:00.125
Here, we're, like –

426
00:24:00.945 --> 00:24:03.407
So CRISPR, we're using the same Lego blocks, right?

427
00:24:03.427 --> 00:24:03.828
That already exist.

428
00:24:03.888 --> 00:24:04.308
ACTG.

429
00:24:04.568 --> 00:24:04.748
Right.

430
00:24:04.788 --> 00:24:04.989
Right.

431
00:24:05.029 --> 00:24:06.730
That already exist.

432
00:24:06.990 --> 00:24:13.976
We're just reprogramming like how the ACTG is said because we know what the code is and then we can create our own proteins.

433
00:24:14.397 --> 00:24:18.040
Here, we're creating new Lego blocks.

434
00:24:18.260 --> 00:24:18.520
Right.

435
00:24:18.887 --> 00:24:47.405
entirely does that make sense so we're adding more letters to the in this analogy yes not to the dna but to the protein general the protein creation synthesis yeah so so let's go over some basic molecular biology okay because that's what's going to be needed for this okay so dna dna comes in four letters okay there's four building blocks that make up dna and dna is essential to all life right that's where we get the genetic information from and that tells us the blueprint of how to create whatever we want to create

436
00:24:47.925 --> 00:24:50.746
Okay, DNA comes in four letters, A-C-T-G.

437
00:24:50.866 --> 00:24:51.946
These are nucleotides.

438
00:24:51.986 --> 00:24:54.127
They're just like tiny molecules.

439
00:24:54.147 --> 00:24:55.107
They've got three parts.

440
00:24:55.588 --> 00:25:02.510
And you build a ladder on top of each other and you create a giant little, I guess, staircase.

441
00:25:03.070 --> 00:25:04.090
Of the double helix.

442
00:25:04.190 --> 00:25:05.211
Of the double helix, right?

443
00:25:05.271 --> 00:25:14.914
And then the unique DNA, you have unique DNA, I have unique DNA, and that determines like the kind of organism you're gonna be, the facial features, everything and everything.

444
00:25:14.974 --> 00:25:17.515
It determines whether you have good genes or not.

445
00:25:17.915 --> 00:25:18.336
Oh, yeah.

446
00:25:18.796 --> 00:25:19.297
Yes, yes.

447
00:25:19.357 --> 00:25:21.219
Those are the genes we're talking about, people.

448
00:25:21.759 --> 00:25:23.061
Not on the body, in the body.

449
00:25:23.101 --> 00:25:24.402
No, in the body.

450
00:25:24.843 --> 00:25:26.925
And so DNA is pretty standard.

451
00:25:27.125 --> 00:25:27.546
Four things.

452
00:25:28.086 --> 00:25:32.611
Proteins, on the other hand, there's 20 different amino acids that life uses.

453
00:25:32.812 --> 00:25:33.012
Okay.

454
00:25:33.032 --> 00:25:33.272
Okay.

455
00:25:33.593 --> 00:25:35.334
So 20 different building blocks.

456
00:25:35.515 --> 00:25:35.775
Got it.

457
00:25:35.835 --> 00:25:36.055
All right.

458
00:25:36.876 --> 00:25:44.405
Now, what DNA does fundamentally is it tells the cell which proteins to put in a sequence.

459
00:25:44.645 --> 00:25:44.905
Okay?

460
00:25:45.666 --> 00:25:50.872
And what these guys have done is created new amino acids.

461
00:25:51.453 --> 00:25:51.934
Entirely.

462
00:25:52.014 --> 00:25:52.514
Entirely.

463
00:25:52.534 --> 00:25:54.316
Beyond the initial list of 20.

464
00:25:54.336 --> 00:25:54.737
Yes.

465
00:25:54.817 --> 00:25:55.037
Yes.

466
00:25:56.098 --> 00:25:58.279
Oh, that's OK. You see what I'm saying?

467
00:25:58.299 --> 00:25:59.419
No, no, no.

468
00:25:59.479 --> 00:26:00.999
We invented a new Lego block.

469
00:26:01.059 --> 00:26:01.339
Yes.

470
00:26:01.559 --> 00:26:03.660
We invented a new Lego block for proteins.

471
00:26:03.740 --> 00:26:04.700
That's actually OK.

472
00:26:04.820 --> 00:26:07.000
Which is which the implications of which now.

473
00:26:07.220 --> 00:26:07.801
Yeah, we can.

474
00:26:08.081 --> 00:26:09.261
Let's discuss the implications.

475
00:26:09.301 --> 00:26:15.342
First, let's get into the science, which is because I think I mean, experimentally, this is like such a hard thing to do.

476
00:26:15.502 --> 00:26:17.423
OK. And I'm going to get into why.

477
00:26:18.063 --> 00:26:18.543
So first.

478
00:26:19.683 --> 00:26:21.324
Why even do this in the first place?

479
00:26:22.264 --> 00:26:23.864
Why does it make sense to do this?

480
00:26:24.384 --> 00:26:29.146
So here we're going to get into a little bit of mathematics, okay?

481
00:26:29.246 --> 00:26:31.486
So there's four letters in DNA.

482
00:26:31.686 --> 00:26:31.846
Yes.

483
00:26:31.966 --> 00:26:35.267
But I want to code for 20 amino acids.

484
00:26:35.387 --> 00:26:35.607
Yeah.

485
00:26:35.828 --> 00:26:35.988
Yes.

486
00:26:36.208 --> 00:26:37.648
Let's say 20 distinct words.

487
00:26:37.908 --> 00:26:38.108
Okay.

488
00:26:38.348 --> 00:26:38.528
Sure.

489
00:26:38.548 --> 00:26:38.888
Four letters.

490
00:26:38.908 --> 00:26:40.069
Four letters, 20 distinct words.

491
00:26:40.109 --> 00:26:41.029
Okay, 20 distinct words.

492
00:26:41.449 --> 00:26:47.814
Now, I can't just have one letter per word because then I'd only have four words, A, C, T, G. Yes.

493
00:26:48.054 --> 00:26:48.314
Okay?

494
00:26:48.955 --> 00:26:52.357
With two letters per word, I would have 16, right?

495
00:26:52.437 --> 00:26:55.499
I can have A, A, A, T, A, C, A, G, and so on and so forth.

496
00:26:55.819 --> 00:26:59.182
So four times four, 16 words with two letters.

497
00:26:59.582 --> 00:27:01.824
But with three, I have four times four times four.

498
00:27:02.364 --> 00:27:03.945
That's 64.

499
00:27:04.025 --> 00:27:04.185
Yes.

500
00:27:05.166 --> 00:27:05.366
Yeah.

501
00:27:05.707 --> 00:27:08.730
So I can do 64 different words.

502
00:27:08.750 --> 00:27:09.972
Word combinations with those.

503
00:27:10.092 --> 00:27:10.913
But I only have 20.

504
00:27:11.333 --> 00:27:11.494
Right.

505
00:27:11.794 --> 00:27:17.160
So I need a minimum of three, but that means that there's a bunch of repetition.

506
00:27:17.701 --> 00:27:17.861
Right.

507
00:27:17.921 --> 00:27:18.121
Right?

508
00:27:18.322 --> 00:27:19.783
Because I have 64 different...

509
00:27:20.364 --> 00:27:23.146
Possible words, but only 20 different meanings.

510
00:27:23.527 --> 00:27:24.067
Yeah.

511
00:27:24.087 --> 00:27:24.748
So to speak.

512
00:27:24.768 --> 00:27:24.968
Right.

513
00:27:25.048 --> 00:27:28.671
So multiple words are going to mean the same amino acid.

514
00:27:28.691 --> 00:27:28.891
Yeah.

515
00:27:28.991 --> 00:27:29.111
Yeah.

516
00:27:29.271 --> 00:27:29.491
Yeah.

517
00:27:29.731 --> 00:27:29.972
Yeah.

518
00:27:30.112 --> 00:27:31.913
And so there's going to be this redundancy.

519
00:27:32.013 --> 00:27:32.193
Yes.

520
00:27:32.374 --> 00:27:33.595
And life codes for that.

521
00:27:33.655 --> 00:27:33.835
Right.

522
00:27:34.095 --> 00:27:37.418
So, for example, there's one there's one three.

523
00:27:37.698 --> 00:27:39.159
There's three three letter words.

524
00:27:39.519 --> 00:27:42.562
TGA, TAA and TAG.

525
00:27:43.202 --> 00:27:46.545
All of these three code for stop making a protein.

526
00:27:46.985 --> 00:27:47.225
Okay.

527
00:27:47.465 --> 00:27:47.726
Okay?

528
00:27:48.066 --> 00:27:48.306
Okay.

529
00:27:49.147 --> 00:27:57.652
ATG, so, like, you can imagine there's a little, like, enzyme called RNA polymerase that, like, goes down, and it tries to find ATG.

530
00:27:57.852 --> 00:27:58.112
Okay?

531
00:27:58.353 --> 00:27:59.253
That becomes AUG.

532
00:27:59.273 --> 00:28:01.995
I guess it tries to find AUG in mRNA.

533
00:28:02.155 --> 00:28:04.336
mRNA uses a different set of letters.

534
00:28:04.396 --> 00:28:11.301
Instead of T, it uses U. Anyways, there's a little, like, guy who goes down, and he's trying to find AUG.

535
00:28:11.801 --> 00:28:12.001
Okay?

536
00:28:12.282 --> 00:28:13.622
Once he finds AUG, he's like, oh!

537
00:28:13.642 --> 00:28:13.743
Okay.

538
00:28:14.603 --> 00:28:15.504
A protein starts here.

539
00:28:15.885 --> 00:28:16.105
Got it.

540
00:28:16.165 --> 00:28:17.807
Then he recruits a bunch of other stuff.

541
00:28:18.028 --> 00:28:20.651
There's a ribosome that comes in, which is the protein-making factory.

542
00:28:20.992 --> 00:28:22.233
Ribosome attaches over there.

543
00:28:22.534 --> 00:28:25.838
And then now the ribosome goes, okay, what are these three letters?

544
00:28:26.218 --> 00:28:27.440
Okay, I need this thing.

545
00:28:27.981 --> 00:28:28.581
Okay, next.

546
00:28:28.882 --> 00:28:29.743
What are these three letters?

547
00:28:29.823 --> 00:28:31.045
Okay, I need this thing, right?

548
00:28:31.485 --> 00:28:36.947
And so it keeps going until it reaches something called the stop codon, which is a signal to stop.

549
00:28:36.967 --> 00:28:37.907
That's the end of my protein.

550
00:28:38.248 --> 00:28:40.708
And there's TGA, TAA, and TAG.

551
00:28:40.768 --> 00:28:44.610
There's three different words that mean the same thing, stop.

552
00:28:44.790 --> 00:28:45.490
Right, right.

553
00:28:45.730 --> 00:28:55.894
And like in theory, I think I can see where we're going with this because what we're sort of saying is there's this natural redundancy where certain combinations all equal the same action.

554
00:28:56.234 --> 00:28:56.474
Mm hmm.

555
00:28:57.115 --> 00:28:59.137
We don't necessarily need all of those.

556
00:28:59.157 --> 00:29:00.118
We don't necessarily need that.

557
00:29:00.258 --> 00:29:02.520
To have the same action because we already have the action.

558
00:29:02.540 --> 00:29:02.680
Yeah.

559
00:29:03.241 --> 00:29:04.862
So I just need one.

560
00:29:04.983 --> 00:29:05.323
Yep.

561
00:29:05.443 --> 00:29:07.805
We just need one to reliably mean stop.

562
00:29:08.005 --> 00:29:08.286
Yeah.

563
00:29:08.546 --> 00:29:09.487
And then the other two.

564
00:29:09.927 --> 00:29:12.610
What if we coded some crazy meaning?

565
00:29:12.890 --> 00:29:13.090
Yeah.

566
00:29:13.431 --> 00:29:13.651
Right.

567
00:29:13.951 --> 00:29:15.252
That's never been seen before.

568
00:29:15.412 --> 00:29:15.572
Right.

569
00:29:15.753 --> 00:29:20.036
So what if I created an amino acid that's never been seen before that has unique chemical properties?

570
00:29:20.056 --> 00:29:20.296
Yeah.

571
00:29:20.396 --> 00:29:23.719
And then I started using that to create proteins that have never been seen before.

572
00:29:23.739 --> 00:29:23.879
Right.

573
00:29:24.380 --> 00:29:27.322
Not even in the millions of years of biology.

574
00:29:27.342 --> 00:29:27.523
Yes.

575
00:29:27.843 --> 00:29:28.043
Right.

576
00:29:28.143 --> 00:29:29.044
In the trial and error.

577
00:29:29.384 --> 00:29:32.827
Because so proteins are effectively this chain of amino acids.

578
00:29:33.187 --> 00:29:38.592
And on the back of each amino acid is something called a an R group.

579
00:29:38.712 --> 00:29:40.113
I think it's called a residual group.

580
00:29:40.133 --> 00:29:40.273
But.

581
00:29:41.154 --> 00:29:42.055
I might be getting that wrong.

582
00:29:42.075 --> 00:29:42.956
They'll get us in the comments.

583
00:29:42.996 --> 00:29:44.097
Yeah, they'll get us in the comments.

584
00:29:44.137 --> 00:29:47.901
The R group is basically the thing that makes the amino acid what it is.

585
00:29:48.222 --> 00:29:49.783
Sometimes it's like a sulfur atom.

586
00:29:49.843 --> 00:29:52.666
Sometimes it's just a lame carbon atom or a hydrogen atom.

587
00:29:53.007 --> 00:29:55.429
Sometimes it's like a phosphate group, which has a charge.

588
00:29:55.590 --> 00:29:55.850
Okay.

589
00:29:56.190 --> 00:30:04.014
So you can have a bunch of things that have charge, and then those charges on either side will start folding the protein, and that's what gives it the 3D structure.

590
00:30:04.435 --> 00:30:14.640
All of these R groups interacting in this 3D kind of way is what folds this 1D chain into a 3D molecule of a protein that makes –

591
00:30:15.921 --> 00:30:16.981
A protein do what it does.

592
00:30:17.181 --> 00:30:17.301
Right.

593
00:30:17.502 --> 00:30:22.963
But now what if we can have different R groups that like with different elements or like completely unique properties.

594
00:30:23.083 --> 00:30:23.223
Right.

595
00:30:23.243 --> 00:30:25.364
That start making the protein do crazy things.

596
00:30:25.624 --> 00:30:32.006
Because what's interesting is you have the chain, but to get the effects, it needs to be into this.

597
00:30:32.386 --> 00:30:33.907
The folded 3D structure.

598
00:30:34.467 --> 00:30:48.533
And sort of what we're now saying is in the wake of something like this, as kind of like a side note, in the wake of something like the Google's product that they put out, which created the library of all the different protein fold structures.

599
00:30:48.633 --> 00:30:50.174
Yeah, Google Alpha Fold.

600
00:30:50.214 --> 00:30:50.474
Alpha Fold.

601
00:30:50.494 --> 00:30:52.235
It won the Nobel Prize in Chemistry last year.

602
00:30:52.315 --> 00:30:52.515
Right.

603
00:30:53.055 --> 00:30:54.176
And so what you're saying.

604
00:30:54.456 --> 00:30:58.898
They're actually using some AI to try and figure out what effect this kind of stuff would have.

605
00:30:59.058 --> 00:31:14.250
But even if we can see what the protein effect is, what this is sort of saying is we're actually changing the factory that builds them to do it out of the box effectively and create these new protein structures, which have these emergent properties that can be –

606
00:31:14.890 --> 00:31:16.271
It's extremely new.

607
00:31:16.371 --> 00:31:21.055
Completely net new than anything we've ever been able to experimentally see.

608
00:31:21.495 --> 00:31:22.076
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

609
00:31:22.176 --> 00:31:26.399
I think this is even like – like CRISPR gives us the ability to make new DNA.

610
00:31:26.819 --> 00:31:27.000
Right.

611
00:31:27.100 --> 00:31:29.662
But like new DNA in terms of like with the same letters.

612
00:31:29.682 --> 00:31:30.582
With the same Lego blocks.

613
00:31:30.763 --> 00:31:31.743
With the same Lego blocks.

614
00:31:31.803 --> 00:31:33.705
This is like new proteins with like –

615
00:31:35.582 --> 00:31:36.723
You know, who knows what?

616
00:31:36.763 --> 00:31:38.425
Who knows what?

617
00:31:38.965 --> 00:31:40.026
We could start imagining.

618
00:31:40.106 --> 00:31:43.149
Now we have – we can use a full vocabulary of 64.

619
00:31:43.609 --> 00:31:46.452
Which if we started with 20 and we now are 64.

620
00:31:46.492 --> 00:31:49.174
And look at the diversity of life that we get with 20.

621
00:31:49.735 --> 00:31:53.098
Let alone now almost tripling, right?

622
00:31:53.398 --> 00:31:57.362
Over-tripling the number of, again, fundamental ways in which you can –

623
00:31:59.224 --> 00:32:00.485
generate and send...

624
00:32:00.745 --> 00:32:02.487
This is actually really, really, really crazy.

625
00:32:02.507 --> 00:32:03.268
Yeah, dude, it's so nuts.

626
00:32:03.288 --> 00:32:03.748
It's so nuts.

627
00:32:03.848 --> 00:32:05.910
And, like, it was actually, like, so hard to do.

628
00:32:06.411 --> 00:32:06.711
I can...

629
00:32:06.791 --> 00:32:07.352
I mean, obviously.

630
00:32:07.372 --> 00:32:07.512
Okay?

631
00:32:07.592 --> 00:32:15.700
It's, like, so hard to keep a bacteria alive and also, like, mess with it so much that, like, you know, this poor bacteria is, like, bro, like...

632
00:32:16.060 --> 00:32:17.301
I have no idea what's going on.

633
00:32:17.661 --> 00:32:17.841
Right?

634
00:32:18.081 --> 00:32:26.587
So what they did was they first started with a strain that already had one of the, I think TAG was, so TAG is one of the other stop codons.

635
00:32:26.627 --> 00:32:26.827
Yes.

636
00:32:27.327 --> 00:32:28.608
Already completely eliminated.

637
00:32:28.968 --> 00:32:29.248
Okay.

638
00:32:29.669 --> 00:32:33.551
They had just like, they had just like done CRISPR enough to remove all of the TAGs.

639
00:32:33.931 --> 00:32:34.592
Okay.

640
00:32:34.672 --> 00:32:35.833
In a separate, or in this.

641
00:32:35.873 --> 00:32:36.313
In a separate.

642
00:32:36.513 --> 00:32:37.314
In a separate context.

643
00:32:37.334 --> 00:32:37.994
In a separate context.

644
00:32:38.014 --> 00:32:40.055
They're like, let's start with that thing because one of them is already done.

645
00:32:40.195 --> 00:32:43.417
Because someone removed it and everything worked fine is what we're sort of saying.

646
00:32:43.457 --> 00:32:49.040
So it's like we feel comfortable that if we recode it for something else, there are not going to be any negative derivative impacts of the removal.

647
00:32:49.280 --> 00:32:50.340
That's already been taken care of.

648
00:32:50.360 --> 00:32:50.500
Yeah.

649
00:32:50.941 --> 00:32:56.844
So next what they did was they said, okay, now I want to – I've got two other stop codons, TAG and TAA.

650
00:32:57.364 --> 00:33:00.146
I'm going to do – what I'm going to do is make TAA the stop codon.

651
00:33:00.206 --> 00:33:01.186
It's the stop codon.

652
00:33:01.386 --> 00:33:04.368
Okay, that's the thing that's going to tell something to stop making a protein.

653
00:33:04.548 --> 00:33:04.708
Yes.

654
00:33:05.008 --> 00:33:07.511
TGA is what I want to repurpose for something else.

655
00:33:07.811 --> 00:33:08.052
Okay.

656
00:33:08.412 --> 00:33:15.600
So first thing what you got to do is there's something called like, so how does the, how does the, how does the cell know to remove?

657
00:33:15.981 --> 00:33:23.149
So to stop protein making once it sees this, there's these things called release factors that are proteins in themselves.

658
00:33:23.289 --> 00:33:23.450
Yes.

659
00:33:24.050 --> 00:33:26.191
And they look at, oh, there's a TGA.

660
00:33:26.231 --> 00:33:27.071
Okay, everybody stop.

661
00:33:27.091 --> 00:33:27.932
Stop what you're doing.

662
00:33:28.212 --> 00:33:28.432
Okay?

663
00:33:28.872 --> 00:33:30.913
So they got that protein kicked it out.

664
00:33:30.993 --> 00:33:31.693
Yep.

665
00:33:31.713 --> 00:33:34.295
They got the gene for that thing.

666
00:33:34.635 --> 00:33:35.975
They booted it out of the genome.

667
00:33:36.015 --> 00:33:40.938
So now that thing doesn't – so that, like, policeman that's there to, like, say, hey, I see a TGA.

668
00:33:40.958 --> 00:33:41.578
You better stop.

669
00:33:41.998 --> 00:33:42.618
That thing's gone.

670
00:33:42.718 --> 00:33:43.799
So we've defunded the police.

671
00:33:43.819 --> 00:33:45.800
Yeah, so we defunded the TGA police.

672
00:33:45.840 --> 00:33:46.620
The TGA police.

673
00:33:46.640 --> 00:33:46.800
Right?

674
00:33:47.300 --> 00:33:49.041
And we've kept the TAA police.

675
00:33:49.141 --> 00:33:49.421
Got it.

676
00:33:49.661 --> 00:33:49.861
Okay?

677
00:33:49.881 --> 00:33:50.062
Got it.

678
00:33:50.262 --> 00:33:50.502
Got it.

679
00:33:51.322 --> 00:33:55.805
And we've deleted a bunch of non-essential genes, so we've made the genome a lot shorter.

680
00:33:57.205 --> 00:33:57.966
This one's interesting.

681
00:33:57.986 --> 00:34:04.770
So there's three genes in the E. coli genetics where TGA happens in the middle.

682
00:34:05.830 --> 00:34:08.452
But, like, something gets put in instead.

683
00:34:08.472 --> 00:34:10.493
Because TGA is sometimes a subcodone.

684
00:34:10.513 --> 00:34:10.653
It is.

685
00:34:10.673 --> 00:34:12.894
Because, you know, biology, there's never a hard, fast rule.

686
00:34:13.194 --> 00:34:16.416
It depends on the context of where this codon is in terms of the rest.

687
00:34:16.856 --> 00:34:17.077
So...

688
00:34:18.097 --> 00:34:21.400
There's three very important genes that has TGA in the middle.

689
00:34:21.720 --> 00:34:26.163
So they were, like, careful enough not to completely remove all TGA.

690
00:34:26.223 --> 00:34:27.504
It wasn't a blanket delete.

691
00:34:27.725 --> 00:34:30.807
It was a delete except for – Yeah, yeah.

692
00:34:31.848 --> 00:34:33.109
And the other parts weren't a delete.

693
00:34:33.249 --> 00:34:34.170
It was a substitution.

694
00:34:34.230 --> 00:34:35.751
Instead of TGA, they put in TAA.

695
00:34:35.771 --> 00:34:36.151
Got it.

696
00:34:36.191 --> 00:34:36.471
Got it.

697
00:34:36.672 --> 00:34:36.992
Okay?

698
00:34:37.212 --> 00:34:37.412
Got it.

699
00:34:37.452 --> 00:34:37.892
Yeah.

700
00:34:37.992 --> 00:34:41.733
So except for this part because if they put a TAA, then that protein is done.

701
00:34:41.753 --> 00:34:42.753
That makes sense.

702
00:34:42.993 --> 00:34:43.173
Right?

703
00:34:43.453 --> 00:34:47.834
So even that, that they're targeting, like, you know, you can't see this.

704
00:34:47.854 --> 00:34:49.614
You're not, like, reading it.

705
00:34:49.815 --> 00:34:58.016
You know, like, you got to make some molecular machinery and experimental apparatus to actually target the correct ones, leave out the ones that are important.

706
00:34:58.236 --> 00:34:58.416
Yes.

707
00:34:58.456 --> 00:34:59.116
So they did that.

708
00:34:59.536 --> 00:35:04.457
Then they ran into some problems, which is release factor two, which is the TAA police.

709
00:35:04.477 --> 00:35:04.778
Yeah.

710
00:35:07.398 --> 00:35:15.962
Was starting to get confused because it started not only like it started recognizing the wrong thing.

711
00:35:16.022 --> 00:35:16.583
Yeah.

712
00:35:16.763 --> 00:35:17.063
Okay.

713
00:35:17.083 --> 00:35:18.924
Because we've messed with this thing so much.

714
00:35:18.944 --> 00:35:19.144
Right.

715
00:35:19.204 --> 00:35:19.364
Right.

716
00:35:19.484 --> 00:35:20.244
Right.

717
00:35:20.365 --> 00:35:24.907
It started sometimes not recognizing TAA because we put in so much of it.

718
00:35:24.987 --> 00:35:25.187
Yeah.

719
00:35:25.307 --> 00:35:30.630
And then somebody would put in a tryptophan amino acid there instead of stopping the protein production.

720
00:35:30.650 --> 00:35:30.890
Got it.

721
00:35:30.970 --> 00:35:31.130
Yep.

722
00:35:31.450 --> 00:35:31.610
Yep.

723
00:35:31.630 --> 00:35:34.512
So then now they're like, okay, we got to make TAA police better.

724
00:35:34.532 --> 00:35:34.972
Right.

725
00:35:34.992 --> 00:35:35.152
Right.

726
00:35:35.867 --> 00:35:37.088
Being like, no, that's a TAA.

727
00:35:37.108 --> 00:35:37.589
You better stop.

728
00:35:37.609 --> 00:35:40.231
To understand the new dynamics that have kind of been created now.

729
00:35:40.531 --> 00:35:40.711
Yeah.

730
00:35:40.811 --> 00:35:43.714
And so they then messed with the TAA genetics.

731
00:35:43.934 --> 00:35:44.074
Yep.

732
00:35:44.234 --> 00:35:44.474
Okay.

733
00:35:44.814 --> 00:35:53.381
Once they did that, they used assays, which are basically like, you know, you do a bunch of like chemistry and pipetting.

734
00:35:53.702 --> 00:35:57.425
And you try to see which proteins are expressed and so on to make sure that this works.

735
00:35:58.245 --> 00:36:05.729
The other thing that I found really interesting was in order to confirm that this worked, they would also infect it with viruses, this bacteria.

736
00:36:06.249 --> 00:36:12.572
And the viral – so the way the virus works is it hijacks the bacterial machinery to, like, make more copies of itself.

737
00:36:12.592 --> 00:36:13.153
To replicate itself.

738
00:36:13.213 --> 00:36:18.675
But if we've done this right, then the virus is coming in looking at this new machinery like, where's my stop?

739
00:36:19.476 --> 00:36:20.696
Like, what's going on?

740
00:36:20.716 --> 00:36:23.178
Where's the factory that I – Yeah, where's the factory that I normally do?

741
00:36:23.238 --> 00:36:24.098
And then it won't work.

742
00:36:24.518 --> 00:36:25.759
That is – That's – Is that kind of –

743
00:36:26.379 --> 00:36:28.021
No, that is very intriguing.

744
00:36:28.121 --> 00:36:28.701
Yeah.

745
00:36:29.422 --> 00:36:33.705
There's so many levels of – I mean, we could have multiple podcasts on just individual aspects of the story.

746
00:36:33.725 --> 00:36:34.365
No, this is so crazy.

747
00:36:34.385 --> 00:36:35.506
Yeah.

748
00:36:35.987 --> 00:36:43.052
Because there's so many layers of current understanding that are required to even be able to attempt to do this.

749
00:36:43.192 --> 00:36:48.776
Yeah, the hierarchy of processes that happen within a cell at the molecular level, right?

750
00:36:48.916 --> 00:36:49.737
I'm talking like –

751
00:36:51.198 --> 00:36:53.618
Yeah, it's just incredible the understanding that we have.

752
00:36:53.658 --> 00:37:01.240
And finally what they did was so now when they're all done, they have TGA and TAG, which are like now we can do whatever we want.

753
00:37:01.280 --> 00:37:02.880
So then they got these two.

754
00:37:02.900 --> 00:37:06.281
They're called nonstandard amino acids basically made up by us.

755
00:37:06.401 --> 00:37:06.741
Right, right.

756
00:37:06.841 --> 00:37:08.121
And they had that initial list.

757
00:37:08.181 --> 00:37:08.441
Yeah.

758
00:37:08.581 --> 00:37:14.022
And so and so then they reworked the chemistry that once you know, there's a part of the ribosome.

759
00:37:14.142 --> 00:37:17.583
It sees some three letter thing and then it's like, OK, I'm going to grab this thing.

760
00:37:17.743 --> 00:37:17.903
Yep.

761
00:37:18.403 --> 00:37:19.865
It started grabbing the right thing.

762
00:37:19.926 --> 00:37:24.312
And to grab this new thing that we made up, we have to make it mimic everything else.

763
00:37:24.512 --> 00:37:24.673
Right.

764
00:37:24.693 --> 00:37:26.716
So that the ribosome doesn't think anything different.

765
00:37:26.736 --> 00:37:28.839
It's just like, oh, this is the login key.

766
00:37:29.260 --> 00:37:29.460
Right?

767
00:37:29.740 --> 00:37:30.542
And so they did that.

768
00:37:30.622 --> 00:37:31.924
And then finally they created...

769
00:37:34.269 --> 00:37:36.010
this new E. coli.

770
00:37:36.050 --> 00:37:37.571
They call it OCHRE.

771
00:37:38.132 --> 00:37:39.433
O-C-H-R-E.

772
00:37:39.793 --> 00:37:41.895
It's a genomically recoded organism.

773
00:37:42.355 --> 00:37:52.923
It's not the first genomically recoded organism, but this is the first one where they've done all of this new... Not just changing... We're not just doing the changing at the DNA level.

774
00:37:53.423 --> 00:37:54.845
It is now producing...

775
00:37:55.605 --> 00:38:02.208
new proteins that we have made up and it is new Lego with new Legos that we gave it.

776
00:38:02.448 --> 00:38:02.628
Yeah.

777
00:38:02.688 --> 00:38:04.588
And it's doing so on its own.

778
00:38:05.129 --> 00:38:08.910
Like we've created it such that it can self sustain this new process.

779
00:38:08.930 --> 00:38:09.110
Yeah.

780
00:38:09.130 --> 00:38:09.250
Yeah.

781
00:38:09.270 --> 00:38:09.430
Yeah.

782
00:38:09.450 --> 00:38:11.071
And it's like alive and it's alive.

783
00:38:12.509 --> 00:38:18.837
With all of this new internal dynamics, part of which we just made up from whole cloth.

784
00:38:18.897 --> 00:38:21.320
Yeah, it's an incredible story.

785
00:38:21.340 --> 00:38:24.144
Like, it's from the Reinhardt and Isaacs lab at Yale University.

786
00:38:24.625 --> 00:38:25.145
Well done.

787
00:38:25.486 --> 00:38:25.706
Well...

788
00:38:25.886 --> 00:38:26.727
I mean, yeah.

789
00:38:27.028 --> 00:38:27.528
This is...

790
00:38:28.229 --> 00:38:39.113
We're definitely going to almost certainly come back to this story because I am sure there are going to be a variety of – Yeah, there's going to be – I mean, this is the first step in creating a 64 Lego block alphabet.

791
00:38:39.433 --> 00:38:39.973
Right.

792
00:38:40.214 --> 00:38:43.395
Actually, it's got to be 62 because you need one to start, one to stop.

793
00:38:43.615 --> 00:38:43.835
Fine.

794
00:38:44.436 --> 00:38:46.077
But 62 is a lot more than 20.

795
00:38:46.338 --> 00:38:47.960
And if we can – yeah, right.

796
00:38:48.040 --> 00:39:04.939
And so, like, the amount of emergent and derivative properties, behaviors, dynamics that result from tripling the number of Lego blocks that are fundamentally a part of this protein and amino acid generation process –

797
00:39:05.319 --> 00:39:09.900
I mean, let the imagination run wild in terms of what...

798
00:39:10.500 --> 00:39:14.001
It's like we've been making houses out of mud huts.

799
00:39:14.201 --> 00:39:15.361
Like, we've been making mud huts.

800
00:39:15.741 --> 00:39:18.462
All of a sudden, now we got steel, motherfucker.

801
00:39:18.522 --> 00:39:19.462
Right, right, right.

802
00:39:19.782 --> 00:39:20.142
You know?

803
00:39:20.242 --> 00:39:20.482
Right.

804
00:39:21.483 --> 00:39:21.903
You know what?

805
00:39:21.963 --> 00:39:22.583
This is...

806
00:39:23.463 --> 00:39:26.764
I'll end with this note because... And this... One thing I wanted to say was like...

807
00:39:28.525 --> 00:39:30.147
It's safety concerns are there.

808
00:39:30.548 --> 00:39:30.908
Of course.

809
00:39:31.149 --> 00:39:31.349
Right?

810
00:39:31.930 --> 00:39:36.918
And I was reading at the very end of this article, they were talking about like how do we do the safety concerns.

811
00:39:37.579 --> 00:39:42.848
One of the things that's interesting is you could make these organisms dependent on this new Lego block.

812
00:39:44.042 --> 00:39:44.402
Okay.

813
00:39:44.442 --> 00:39:44.643
Right?

814
00:39:44.943 --> 00:39:48.386
And that way, if it gets out, it's just going to die.

815
00:39:48.406 --> 00:39:48.646
Oh, die.

816
00:39:48.947 --> 00:39:49.167
Right.

817
00:39:49.287 --> 00:39:51.689
Because these Lego blocks aren't out here.

818
00:39:51.709 --> 00:39:52.009
Right?

819
00:39:52.049 --> 00:39:58.555
Like normal E. coli survives everywhere because it depends on the 20 that are found in us, in plants and everything.

820
00:39:58.616 --> 00:39:58.776
Right.

821
00:39:59.196 --> 00:40:05.081
But, like, if it requires, like, some, like, weird thing that's only found in labs, well, then, yeah.

822
00:40:05.182 --> 00:40:14.670
Because, I guess, the implication of what you're trying to get at is if this newly – if this new form of E. coli were to have a leakage problem –

823
00:40:16.992 --> 00:40:17.212
Yeah.

824
00:40:17.732 --> 00:40:21.153
What would happen in a free in a free environment?

825
00:40:21.333 --> 00:40:21.533
Yeah.

826
00:40:21.813 --> 00:40:25.273
How it would impact flora, fauna, other ecosystems.

827
00:40:25.333 --> 00:40:26.394
Yeah.

828
00:40:26.674 --> 00:40:28.174
Let the conspiracy theories one while.

829
00:40:28.654 --> 00:40:29.234
Yeah.

830
00:40:29.254 --> 00:40:42.576
But one way that we could mandate safety is to say that, like, OK, how about like you these E. coli, like in order to even digest sugar or something like that protein has one of these.

831
00:40:42.616 --> 00:40:42.857
Yeah.

832
00:40:42.917 --> 00:40:43.117
Right.

833
00:40:43.237 --> 00:40:43.417
Right.

834
00:40:43.617 --> 00:40:45.517
So then it can't it's just going to like die.

835
00:40:46.305 --> 00:40:48.986
The world is going to get very, very, very.

836
00:40:49.066 --> 00:40:49.626
I'm sorry.

837
00:40:49.746 --> 00:40:51.087
I stopped you in the middle of something.

838
00:40:51.107 --> 00:40:55.149
No, because I always try to think of analogs to help me kind of frame some of these topics.

839
00:40:55.229 --> 00:41:02.772
And I was talking to someone the other day that they were talking about, obviously, this is related to the UAP issue.

840
00:41:03.492 --> 00:41:04.993
And they kind of made a similar point.

841
00:41:05.033 --> 00:41:09.775
It's like when you look at the periodic table, we have all this certain number of elements that are on there.

842
00:41:10.515 --> 00:41:17.458
But we've only really figured out how to engineer those elements at their current – like at certain isotopic ratios.

843
00:41:18.058 --> 00:41:24.380
So as an analogy, we sort of have like whatever the number is at those set isotopic ratios.

844
00:41:24.540 --> 00:41:31.623
But if we could figure out how to, one, create stable states of these other ones or environments where we do so – Yeah, or like create the magic number element at like 120 or whatever –

845
00:41:31.903 --> 00:41:36.747
then you open up a new set of tools by which you could then engineer things.

846
00:41:36.807 --> 00:41:37.308
Yeah.

847
00:41:37.328 --> 00:41:41.631
But we're not using all of the possible, theoretically possible available tools.

848
00:41:41.651 --> 00:41:41.872
Yes.

849
00:41:42.212 --> 00:41:43.033
In that context.

850
00:41:43.093 --> 00:41:45.595
There's a similar – it's how I'm – It's similar, yeah.

851
00:41:46.496 --> 00:41:50.519
In that context, I will say that we have a much better understanding of physics and chemistry there.

852
00:41:50.839 --> 00:41:51.180
For sure.

853
00:41:51.220 --> 00:41:51.380
Right?

854
00:41:51.420 --> 00:41:59.046
With biology, because there's like 10 to the 10 more moving parts, the possibility is like –

855
00:42:00.087 --> 00:42:06.933
Yeah, it's like we're in biology where physics was, I think, in the 1910s, 1920s.

856
00:42:07.013 --> 00:42:07.233
Okay.

857
00:42:07.273 --> 00:42:08.214
Okay.

858
00:42:08.314 --> 00:42:08.534
Yeah.

859
00:42:08.694 --> 00:42:11.377
Which means – Which is like when we were like, oh, it's an electron.

860
00:42:11.597 --> 00:42:12.738
What is that?

861
00:42:13.579 --> 00:42:16.761
Which means we still have not yet had our – what is it?

862
00:42:16.821 --> 00:42:17.502
Manhattan Project.

863
00:42:17.522 --> 00:42:17.882
Yeah, right.

864
00:42:17.902 --> 00:42:23.347
Like our sort of mid-1900s moment where there's just this incredible explosion.

865
00:42:24.488 --> 00:42:30.253
of like literally, of like practical applications of the fundamental science.

866
00:42:30.273 --> 00:42:31.374
Yeah, dude, it's nuts.

867
00:42:31.394 --> 00:42:32.455
What a great story.

868
00:42:32.475 --> 00:42:34.436
Like even though this story is kind of old.

869
00:42:34.517 --> 00:42:35.397
I think it was February.

870
00:42:35.457 --> 00:42:35.758
Yeah.

871
00:42:36.018 --> 00:42:36.238
Yeah.

872
00:42:36.318 --> 00:42:39.341
But like I came across and I was like, you know, we have to talk about this.

873
00:42:39.461 --> 00:42:41.323
There's got to learn about this.

874
00:42:41.403 --> 00:42:42.383
This is crazy.

875
00:42:42.403 --> 00:42:42.944
This is really good.

876
00:42:43.124 --> 00:42:47.368
It's unfortunate that it was out of our rivals in New Haven, but

877
00:42:47.628 --> 00:42:48.689
Yeah.

878
00:42:48.789 --> 00:42:50.551
Well, they're part of the club.

879
00:42:50.571 --> 00:42:51.892
We'll give it to them.

880
00:42:51.992 --> 00:42:53.713
At least it's not Harvard.

881
00:42:54.975 --> 00:42:55.535
Go Tigers.

882
00:42:56.756 --> 00:42:57.156
Okay.

883
00:42:57.297 --> 00:42:58.998
I'm going to have to sleep on that one.

884
00:42:59.318 --> 00:43:02.841
Our next story, we're going back into space.

885
00:43:03.622 --> 00:43:04.063
That's right.

886
00:43:04.083 --> 00:43:04.923
Like our first story.

887
00:43:05.664 --> 00:43:09.447
NASA's new radar just pulled off something impossible.

888
00:43:09.928 --> 00:43:21.117
So during a close Mars flyby, NASA's Europa Clipper spacecraft tested its radar system, Reason, for the first time in space.

889
00:43:21.357 --> 00:43:21.558
Yeah.

890
00:43:21.598 --> 00:43:25.641
And this is interesting because I said at the top how this might lead us to aliens.

891
00:43:26.001 --> 00:43:30.045
So how do we get from a radar at Mars to aliens?

892
00:43:32.067 --> 00:43:32.528
Aliens.

893
00:43:33.668 --> 00:43:35.170
That's what it's always been about, man.

894
00:43:35.190 --> 00:43:35.970
It's always about aliens.

895
00:43:36.010 --> 00:43:38.152
It's always about aliens.

896
00:43:38.613 --> 00:43:39.914
Not like intelligent life.

897
00:43:40.554 --> 00:43:44.077
I don't think there's sea people in Europa.

898
00:43:44.397 --> 00:43:48.601
But Europa is an extremely important planetoid.

899
00:43:48.781 --> 00:43:49.642
It's not really a planet.

900
00:43:49.662 --> 00:43:50.663
It's a moon of Jupiter.

901
00:43:50.703 --> 00:43:54.866
But if it was going around the sun, it's quite big, honestly.

902
00:43:54.926 --> 00:43:55.427
It's quite big.

903
00:43:55.967 --> 00:43:56.967
It's bigger than our moon.

904
00:43:58.347 --> 00:44:01.568
And it's a planet that has ice on its surface.

905
00:44:02.268 --> 00:44:04.709
And we're pretty sure it has an ocean underneath.

906
00:44:04.849 --> 00:44:05.029
Right.

907
00:44:05.389 --> 00:44:05.629
Okay.

908
00:44:06.249 --> 00:44:08.769
And we're also pretty sure that it's geologically active.

909
00:44:09.329 --> 00:44:09.609
Okay.

910
00:44:09.649 --> 00:44:10.870
So there's like volcanoes.

911
00:44:10.890 --> 00:44:11.930
Okay.

912
00:44:11.950 --> 00:44:22.312
And the reason why that makes us super excited is because those are sort of the conditions where we find a lot of life on Earth in deep sea hydrothermal vents.

913
00:44:22.372 --> 00:44:22.512
Yep.

914
00:44:22.772 --> 00:44:22.952
Right.

915
00:44:22.992 --> 00:44:24.992
Those things are some of my favorite things.

916
00:44:25.112 --> 00:44:52.720
places that you know if i didn't have a um a debilitating fear of water like i would go in a submarine and visit hydrothermal vents yeah yeah um unfortunately that i don't think i'm ever going to do that but like those so hydrothermal vents are places on the earth where there's like basically volcanic geothermal activity happening under under the ocean floor it's been happening probably for billions of years um it's probably where the first life originated around earth

917
00:44:53.601 --> 00:44:58.986
And it's also one of the only places where the fundamental source of energy does not come from the sun.

918
00:44:59.646 --> 00:45:00.187
Oh, interesting.

919
00:45:00.227 --> 00:45:00.387
Right?

920
00:45:00.407 --> 00:45:01.788
That's what's cool.

921
00:45:01.888 --> 00:45:05.832
Everywhere else on Earth, the fundamental source of energy comes from the sun.

922
00:45:06.152 --> 00:45:06.353
Right?

923
00:45:06.433 --> 00:45:06.593
Right.

924
00:45:06.833 --> 00:45:09.495
That becomes like photosynthesized and blah, blah, blah.

925
00:45:09.515 --> 00:45:12.218
But geothermal places, I mean Yellowstone I guess is another.

926
00:45:12.558 --> 00:45:18.424
The bacteria in those thermal pools, they're getting their energy from the kinds of chemical compounds that are coming from Earth.

927
00:45:18.864 --> 00:45:40.137
from the earth hydrothermal vents are pretty nice because like there's so much diversity of life down there um there's bacteria there's like sponges there's like all sorts of crazy stuff so we're thinking europa has that and we want to get there and we want to get there and we want to look at it and this radar system this clipper spacecraft ultimately is destined for europa it's okay

928
00:45:42.318 --> 00:45:43.419
So it's got a long ways.

929
00:45:43.519 --> 00:45:44.880
It was launched last year.

930
00:45:45.200 --> 00:45:45.961
Okay.

931
00:45:46.041 --> 00:45:47.202
It already made its way to Mars.

932
00:45:47.382 --> 00:45:48.903
It's going to do this like gravity assist.

933
00:45:48.963 --> 00:45:50.024
So it's going to go around Mars.

934
00:45:50.064 --> 00:45:52.786
Then it's going to come back to Earth, I think, 2026.

935
00:45:53.327 --> 00:45:53.487
Oh.

936
00:45:53.527 --> 00:45:54.588
Gravity assist from us.

937
00:45:54.988 --> 00:45:55.989
And then shoot off to Japan.

938
00:45:56.069 --> 00:45:57.390
So it's a double rainbow.

939
00:45:57.510 --> 00:45:57.770
Yeah.

940
00:45:57.971 --> 00:45:58.611
All the way.

941
00:45:58.831 --> 00:46:00.793
It's doing a comeback, and then it's going to do it.

942
00:46:01.393 --> 00:46:05.976
And it's got a lot of systems to try and see Europa for what it is.

943
00:46:06.896 --> 00:46:11.899
Usually when we've set stuff to Jupiter, Europa hasn't really been the focus.

944
00:46:11.979 --> 00:46:15.201
There's so many cool things to see around Jupiter and Saturn and things like that.

945
00:46:15.621 --> 00:46:19.743
So this one is specifically designed for Europa.

946
00:46:19.923 --> 00:46:20.844
Very interesting.

947
00:46:21.164 --> 00:46:22.745
It's got two things that are really cool.

948
00:46:22.945 --> 00:46:24.826
One is it's got a really nice thermal camera.

949
00:46:25.547 --> 00:46:30.670
So with the thermal camera, what you can do is you can look at the ice and see if there's parts that are warm, parts that are cold.

950
00:46:30.831 --> 00:46:31.291
Which would be those.

951
00:46:31.311 --> 00:46:35.434
Maybe the warm parts are where the water is coming out or like where the geothermal activity is.

952
00:46:35.814 --> 00:46:37.435
Extremely accurate thermal imaging.

953
00:46:37.735 --> 00:46:40.157
Then there's also a radar system.

954
00:46:40.317 --> 00:46:42.018
The radar is called Reason.

955
00:46:42.899 --> 00:46:48.563
It means it's a short form for radar for Europa assessment and sounding.

956
00:46:49.203 --> 00:46:50.564
Ocean to near surface.

957
00:46:51.324 --> 00:46:51.524
Right.

958
00:46:51.544 --> 00:46:58.907
Because the idea is it's going to be doing its detection at that ice layer and just slightly below that ice layer.

959
00:46:58.927 --> 00:46:59.127
Yeah.

960
00:46:59.427 --> 00:47:05.570
And we will be able to then make – have a better picture of what is actually there.

961
00:47:05.830 --> 00:47:06.891
I mean, how deep is the ice?

962
00:47:06.931 --> 00:47:07.612
First question.

963
00:47:07.632 --> 00:47:11.396
Because how like, you know, maybe we want to go there and drill.

964
00:47:11.476 --> 00:47:14.400
And it's like, but then it's like, OK, how deep do we got to go?

965
00:47:14.480 --> 00:47:20.226
Is this going to be Armageddon where we have to send, you know, you know, to drill two miles into the incoming asteroid?

966
00:47:20.246 --> 00:47:21.327
Yeah, it might be two miles.

967
00:47:21.688 --> 00:47:25.372
I think I mean, they estimate that it's something like 20 kilometers.

968
00:47:25.672 --> 00:47:26.113
Oh, wow.

969
00:47:26.433 --> 00:47:26.753
Oh, okay.

970
00:47:26.833 --> 00:47:29.414
So, and, but, you know, we got robots.

971
00:47:29.474 --> 00:47:29.774
Yeah.

972
00:47:30.214 --> 00:47:31.234
And we can do it.

973
00:47:31.254 --> 00:47:31.734
We can do it.

974
00:47:31.774 --> 00:47:31.994
Yeah.

975
00:47:32.374 --> 00:47:34.835
So the radar, there's two different types of radar.

976
00:47:34.855 --> 00:47:37.655
There's the high frequency radar, which is at nine megahertz.

977
00:47:37.675 --> 00:47:42.516
And that's going to give us like up to 30 kilometers in depth.

978
00:47:42.836 --> 00:47:43.076
Oh, great.

979
00:47:43.096 --> 00:47:45.096
So we'll be able to see like, okay, what's the depth of the ice?

980
00:47:45.136 --> 00:47:46.737
How far away is the ocean?

981
00:47:46.757 --> 00:47:52.078
So if it's below, if the ice is only 20 kilometers, then we would be able to basically detect that.

982
00:47:52.138 --> 00:47:52.698
Like the ocean.

983
00:47:52.718 --> 00:47:53.118
The ocean.

984
00:47:53.158 --> 00:47:54.478
That's the 10 below that.

985
00:47:54.578 --> 00:47:54.758
Yeah.

986
00:47:55.119 --> 00:48:00.204
And then we also have very high frequency, which is at 60 megahertz.

987
00:48:00.304 --> 00:48:02.526
And that gets us to about four kilometers.

988
00:48:02.907 --> 00:48:06.731
But we have a lot higher resolution on spatial features and things like that.

989
00:48:06.771 --> 00:48:10.395
So there we can see what are the fissures in the ice like?

990
00:48:10.435 --> 00:48:11.616
How do those move around?

991
00:48:11.656 --> 00:48:15.220
What is the geologic history of that ice crust?

992
00:48:15.960 --> 00:48:20.643
Because if you look at Europa, there's like these long gashes and like fissures.

993
00:48:21.123 --> 00:48:23.164
Clearly, there's like movement in the ice, right?

994
00:48:23.184 --> 00:48:23.365
Got it.

995
00:48:23.665 --> 00:48:31.349
That's coming from – well, one, it's so close to Jupiter that Jupiter's gravity literally like stretches and squishes it.

996
00:48:31.849 --> 00:48:32.050
Okay?

997
00:48:32.090 --> 00:48:34.391
And that's what's causing the geothermal motion, right?

998
00:48:34.411 --> 00:48:35.972
The moon is geologically dead.

999
00:48:36.412 --> 00:48:37.813
Mars is geologically dead.

1000
00:48:38.113 --> 00:48:44.617
But Europa and Io, which is the even closer moon, they're geologically active because Jupiter is so massive that it literally like –

1001
00:48:45.177 --> 00:49:03.965
squishes and like you know the moon is tugging on the earth and because the earth has a fluid there's tides yes this one this tidal friction but it's it's so powerful that literal planet is doing tides right and it's like squishing and like so there's a lot of geothermal activity there there's probably a lot more in europa that makes sense

1002
00:49:04.265 --> 00:49:05.507
So that's what we're trying to find.

1003
00:49:05.667 --> 00:49:08.071
And it's going to be really interesting.

1004
00:49:08.712 --> 00:49:17.865
The cool part to me was, you know, you could ask, like, why can't you just – So here, it was right on Mars, and they're testing the radar and the thermal imaging there.

1005
00:49:17.885 --> 00:49:19.067
They're doing basically a dry run.

1006
00:49:19.227 --> 00:49:19.547
Mm-hmm.

1007
00:49:19.687 --> 00:49:19.787
Okay.

1008
00:49:19.907 --> 00:49:24.668
It's already on its way, but they're like, while we're on the way, let's just make sure everything is right.

1009
00:49:24.708 --> 00:49:28.429
And Mars is like the best studied thing outside the earth and the moon.

1010
00:49:28.609 --> 00:49:28.829
Fair.

1011
00:49:29.129 --> 00:49:30.109
In the solar system, right?

1012
00:49:30.370 --> 00:49:37.491
So it's like when we take a picture with the radar on Mars, we know exactly what to expect because we've taken a thousand photos already.

1013
00:49:37.511 --> 00:49:38.491
So we have something to match it to.

1014
00:49:38.511 --> 00:49:38.651
Yeah.

1015
00:49:38.691 --> 00:49:40.992
And then it's like there better not be any new surprises.

1016
00:49:41.292 --> 00:49:41.552
Got it.

1017
00:49:41.652 --> 00:49:43.252
Because if they are, it's not Mars.

1018
00:49:43.452 --> 00:49:44.293
It's your instrument.

1019
00:49:44.313 --> 00:49:44.773
That makes sense.

1020
00:49:44.793 --> 00:49:44.953
Right?

1021
00:49:45.193 --> 00:49:46.773
So everyone's like fingers crossed.

1022
00:49:46.813 --> 00:49:47.473
Everything worked.

1023
00:49:47.853 --> 00:49:48.493
Everything worked.

1024
00:49:48.674 --> 00:49:53.614
One thing that was interesting was like, why didn't you just like test this here?

1025
00:49:54.155 --> 00:49:54.355
Right?

1026
00:49:54.395 --> 00:49:55.455
NASA's JPL made it.

1027
00:49:55.635 --> 00:49:56.215
Yep.

1028
00:49:56.335 --> 00:49:59.376
The radar was actually made by UT Austin.

1029
00:49:59.396 --> 00:50:02.596
The thermal imaging was made by Arizona, I believe.

1030
00:50:02.816 --> 00:50:03.616
All the universities.

1031
00:50:03.857 --> 00:50:03.977
Yep.

1032
00:50:04.077 --> 00:50:05.697
And so it's like, why didn't you just test it?

1033
00:50:05.717 --> 00:50:10.978
Well, the antenna for this radar is like as big as a football field.

1034
00:50:11.538 --> 00:50:12.038
Oh, right.

1035
00:50:12.058 --> 00:50:16.120
That's like so in order to test it like, OK, fine.

1036
00:50:16.140 --> 00:50:19.201
You can like in order to fully test it in the thing.

1037
00:50:19.801 --> 00:50:21.361
This thing is assembled in a clean room.

1038
00:50:21.561 --> 00:50:23.182
It's in the biggest clean room in JPL.

1039
00:50:23.542 --> 00:50:32.745
And that thing can like sort of barely fit this clipper probe because the solar panels are so massive because like, you know, Jupiter is five times away from the.

1040
00:50:33.325 --> 00:50:34.405
the sun is Earth.

1041
00:50:34.525 --> 00:50:37.806
So like you have one 25th of the amount of light.

1042
00:50:38.266 --> 00:50:44.528
So you need a giant football field size solar panel to like power the radar and the thermal imaging.

1043
00:50:44.548 --> 00:50:46.508
And this thing comes at a cost of energy.

1044
00:50:46.868 --> 00:50:53.050
And so you're fitting it in this like, in this giant high bay clean room at JPL.

1045
00:50:53.310 --> 00:50:54.570
You want everything to be sterile,

1046
00:50:55.170 --> 00:50:58.812
Now, you like in order to test radar, you need to bounce it off something far away.

1047
00:50:58.892 --> 00:50:59.052
Right.

1048
00:50:59.352 --> 00:50:59.532
Right.

1049
00:50:59.592 --> 00:51:03.233
So they tested each individual component, but they didn't test the whole thing.

1050
00:51:03.313 --> 00:51:03.473
Right.

1051
00:51:03.634 --> 00:51:06.555
The first time that they're testing the real big thing and like work.

1052
00:51:07.075 --> 00:51:07.715
Everything was great.

1053
00:51:07.735 --> 00:51:08.896
Talk about tight sphincters.

1054
00:51:08.996 --> 00:51:12.317
I mean, I just I mean, I went to I think I told you about this recently.

1055
00:51:12.337 --> 00:51:15.218
I went to up in Santa Barbara.

1056
00:51:15.699 --> 00:51:18.640
Redwire Space was doing a deployment test for their.

1057
00:51:19.500 --> 00:51:21.061
solar arrays for the Artemis program.

1058
00:51:21.141 --> 00:51:21.581
Oh, yeah.

1059
00:51:21.941 --> 00:51:26.464
And I went into it was a much smaller clean room, but it was still quite large.

1060
00:51:26.524 --> 00:51:27.405
Yeah.

1061
00:51:27.945 --> 00:51:34.929
And just to see the amount of time and the scale of this thing, I mean, the scale of this thing is unbelievable.

1062
00:51:35.189 --> 00:51:35.389
Yeah.

1063
00:51:35.409 --> 00:51:38.331
So we saw it, you know, deploy itself out.

1064
00:51:38.611 --> 00:51:42.193
And the reason for that is they want to have it in a smaller, tighter package.

1065
00:51:43.033 --> 00:51:43.574
To launch it.

1066
00:51:43.594 --> 00:51:45.155
To get it off the earth.

1067
00:51:45.235 --> 00:51:45.436
Yeah.

1068
00:51:45.696 --> 00:51:50.840
But then still be able to have the surface area, like you're saying, to be able to be valuable.

1069
00:51:51.821 --> 00:51:56.045
And even something like that, there was a whole process, scrub down, et cetera.

1070
00:51:56.205 --> 00:51:56.545
Yeah.

1071
00:51:56.665 --> 00:51:59.247
So the scale of this stuff.

1072
00:52:00.188 --> 00:52:20.597
is is incredible and it I can only imagine I saw how nervous they were just doing that test here on the ground and they'd already had a successful one for the the first solar array and they were just doing the second one so there was already a level of confidence they'd be fine let alone be like okay yeah when it's going by Mars yeah you know nothing looks no there's no like broken pixel somewhere yeah yeah yeah yeah

1073
00:52:20.997 --> 00:52:27.219
And it's like they got about 60 gigs of data from 40 minutes of radar on Mars, and the pictures look fantastic.

1074
00:52:27.299 --> 00:52:27.639
Fantastic.

1075
00:52:27.659 --> 00:52:35.401
So I think it's going to be a really great thing to see in 2030 when we get those Europa flybys because it's going past Europa 50 times.

1076
00:52:35.761 --> 00:52:40.923
It's going to get as low as 16 kilometers from the surface, which is pretty close.

1077
00:52:40.943 --> 00:52:41.543
That's quite close.

1078
00:52:41.743 --> 00:52:42.683
That's like real close.

1079
00:52:42.903 --> 00:52:47.244
So if there is if there is signs.

1080
00:52:47.344 --> 00:52:49.225
If there's signs of life, that's going to be great.

1081
00:52:49.285 --> 00:52:51.845
We're going to even I mean, signs of life would be crazy, right?

1082
00:52:51.945 --> 00:52:59.267
Like if we if we I mean, it does have some equipment to find like, you know, trace gases and things like that if it came out.

1083
00:52:59.327 --> 00:53:01.868
But like even signs of like a liquid ocean.

1084
00:53:01.948 --> 00:53:05.309
No, that's exactly because here's the thing.

1085
00:53:06.570 --> 00:53:13.617
We're trying to understand how many things are unique to our planet versus abundant in the universe.

1086
00:53:14.057 --> 00:53:21.565
And as more and more of these fundamental properties become confirmed as being – because if there's water on Europa –

1087
00:53:22.205 --> 00:53:28.511
It's fair to extrapolate that water is relatively abundant, more generally in the larger universe, just statistically speaking.

1088
00:53:28.531 --> 00:53:30.933
And there's a lot of water on Europe apparently, right?

1089
00:53:31.213 --> 00:53:32.935
It might be all frozen, but I don't think so.

1090
00:53:32.955 --> 00:53:33.916
A lot of people don't think so.

1091
00:53:33.936 --> 00:53:35.938
And if it's liquid, specifically if it's liquid water.

1092
00:53:38.639 --> 00:53:40.620
It just opens the door more and more.

1093
00:53:41.120 --> 00:53:47.001
Again, there are levels of what we mean by life and biosignatures and not all life off planet.

1094
00:53:47.021 --> 00:53:50.202
It necessarily is intelligent life, but even the presence of microbial life.

1095
00:53:50.422 --> 00:53:51.262
In our own solar system.

1096
00:53:51.282 --> 00:53:52.582
In our own solar system.

1097
00:53:52.662 --> 00:53:52.882
Right.

1098
00:53:52.922 --> 00:53:53.983
This is in our backyard.

1099
00:53:54.483 --> 00:53:57.543
Would have – I mean I think that would be just magical.

1100
00:53:57.943 --> 00:54:00.164
But at a minimum, I think what's great about this is –

1101
00:54:01.708 --> 00:54:08.651
You know, good thing we got this thing off last year before our funding got cut because NASA is really struggling right now.

1102
00:54:08.671 --> 00:54:11.532
I mean, we're working with trying to get some programs.

1103
00:54:11.592 --> 00:54:13.313
And it's just it's just total bloodbath.

1104
00:54:13.353 --> 00:54:13.753
No, dude.

1105
00:54:13.773 --> 00:54:15.274
NASA is definitely struggling.

1106
00:54:15.314 --> 00:54:15.554
Yeah.

1107
00:54:15.654 --> 00:54:16.834
So we got it out there.

1108
00:54:16.854 --> 00:54:17.494
We got it out there.

1109
00:54:17.514 --> 00:54:19.255
And now it's like now it's on a trajectory.

1110
00:54:19.295 --> 00:54:19.595
Right.

1111
00:54:19.635 --> 00:54:20.896
We can't stop it.

1112
00:54:20.996 --> 00:54:21.256
Yeah.

1113
00:54:21.276 --> 00:54:21.936
It's in a vacuum.

1114
00:54:21.956 --> 00:54:25.098
I mean, even the last story that we had with with Yale.

1115
00:54:25.358 --> 00:54:25.578
Yeah.

1116
00:54:25.758 --> 00:54:28.359
That one's funded by NIH and NSF.

1117
00:54:29.099 --> 00:54:29.800
And obviously.

1118
00:54:29.820 --> 00:54:30.720
And actually DARPA.

1119
00:54:31.860 --> 00:54:32.521
I don't like that part.

1120
00:54:32.541 --> 00:54:32.781
Yeah.

1121
00:54:32.801 --> 00:54:34.181
It's like, I don't know.

1122
00:54:34.341 --> 00:54:36.782
I don't know why DARPA is doing a new Lego.

1123
00:54:37.283 --> 00:54:49.768
If anyone remembers the Call of Duty where I think it featured Kevin Spacey as the villain, they basically did this thing where they created a genetic, you know, basically the weapon only impacted people that had this certain.

1124
00:54:49.988 --> 00:54:54.770
It was very DARPA's connection to the synthetic protein thing gives me that.

1125
00:54:54.850 --> 00:54:55.550
It's a little inky.

1126
00:54:55.610 --> 00:54:55.770
Yeah.

1127
00:54:55.830 --> 00:54:57.051
It gives me that Call of Duty vibe.

1128
00:54:57.091 --> 00:54:57.911
Yeah.

1129
00:54:58.191 --> 00:54:58.611
Not fun.

1130
00:54:58.851 --> 00:54:59.092
Not fun.

1131
00:55:00.512 --> 00:55:08.641
Our last story is out of MIT.

1132
00:55:08.922 --> 00:55:11.925
It's actually shocking to see some fundamental science coming from MIT.

1133
00:55:11.965 --> 00:55:15.249
I know Caltech is more well known for that.

1134
00:55:15.329 --> 00:55:18.292
But credit where credit is due.

1135
00:55:18.392 --> 00:55:20.415
Famous double slit experiment holds up.

1136
00:55:20.855 --> 00:55:31.740
When stripped of its quantum essentials, MIT physicists confirm that, like Superman, light has two identities that are impossible to see at once.

1137
00:55:31.880 --> 00:55:40.084
So, you know, one of the things that we always talk about is there's stuff happening at the size that we are, and then there's stuff happening at the quantum level.

1138
00:55:40.665 --> 00:55:44.967
And our understanding of these two things is relatively robust, but they don't kind of...

1139
00:55:45.347 --> 00:55:46.567
They don't blend really well.

1140
00:55:46.587 --> 00:55:47.328
Yeah.

1141
00:55:47.468 --> 00:55:53.269
But it seems like this particular aspect, we're kind of seeing some consistency in both spaces maybe.

1142
00:55:53.309 --> 00:55:54.070
But I don't know.

1143
00:55:54.110 --> 00:55:55.510
Yeah, exactly.

1144
00:55:55.690 --> 00:56:01.072
I mean, we're basically finding out that the world really is quantum.

1145
00:56:01.492 --> 00:56:02.752
Okay.

1146
00:56:03.252 --> 00:56:06.093
And it's really a confirmation on something that we already knew.

1147
00:56:06.673 --> 00:56:10.254
But it's an incredible experiment in its own right.

1148
00:56:10.654 --> 00:56:12.434
So that's why I really loved it.

1149
00:56:12.454 --> 00:56:13.715
We love experimental design.

1150
00:56:13.735 --> 00:56:15.955
This looks like it's brand new, July 28th.

1151
00:56:16.395 --> 00:56:18.496
So this is, again, this stuff is happening.

1152
00:56:18.596 --> 00:56:19.596
This stuff is happening now.

1153
00:56:19.776 --> 00:56:21.296
Every week, all the time.

1154
00:56:21.417 --> 00:56:21.617
Yeah.

1155
00:56:21.697 --> 00:56:24.197
So the idea is the double slit experiment.

1156
00:56:24.237 --> 00:56:27.398
It's one of the most famous experiments in all of physics.

1157
00:56:27.558 --> 00:56:31.359
It's something that sort of confirms...

1158
00:56:32.259 --> 00:56:35.980
this duality, this wave and particle picture of light.

1159
00:56:36.060 --> 00:56:38.901
And it's like, is an electron a particle?

1160
00:56:39.001 --> 00:56:40.082
Is an electron a wave?

1161
00:56:40.382 --> 00:56:43.023
I mean, it's like both, but also not both.

1162
00:56:43.423 --> 00:56:44.163
It's an electron.

1163
00:56:44.563 --> 00:56:45.884
And a photon, what is a photon?

1164
00:56:45.904 --> 00:56:46.684
Well, it's a photon.

1165
00:56:46.724 --> 00:56:48.184
Sometimes it behaves like waves.

1166
00:56:48.625 --> 00:56:50.045
Sometimes it behaves like particles.

1167
00:56:50.625 --> 00:56:53.506
Einstein very famously did not like this.

1168
00:56:53.606 --> 00:56:53.966
Yeah.

1169
00:56:54.126 --> 00:56:54.347
Right?

1170
00:56:54.667 --> 00:56:55.687
This is the spooky...

1171
00:56:55.867 --> 00:56:58.609
Yeah, he had a lot of problems with quantum mechanics.

1172
00:56:58.689 --> 00:57:03.252
One of them was the spooky action at a distance, which is something that we're actually going to come to.

1173
00:57:03.292 --> 00:57:09.036
And then the other one was this idea of the wave-particle duality.

1174
00:57:09.076 --> 00:57:12.038
It's like, no, the world is just well-defined.

1175
00:57:12.678 --> 00:57:12.878
Right.

1176
00:57:13.019 --> 00:57:13.239
Right?

1177
00:57:13.459 --> 00:57:13.639
Right.

1178
00:57:14.019 --> 00:57:15.600
Like, God wouldn't do that.

1179
00:57:15.640 --> 00:57:17.281
God wouldn't create ambiguity.

1180
00:57:17.321 --> 00:57:17.622
Yes.

1181
00:57:17.782 --> 00:57:18.242
Yeah, yeah.

1182
00:57:18.282 --> 00:57:25.127
The world is well-defined, and there's – I don't know what you're talking about effectively.

1183
00:57:25.147 --> 00:57:25.387
Okay?

1184
00:57:25.787 --> 00:57:31.050
This whole thing started back in 1801 when Thomas Young made the first double slit experiment with light.

1185
00:57:31.250 --> 00:57:33.131
He wanted to show the wave property of light.

1186
00:57:33.471 --> 00:57:35.632
So the idea is the following.

1187
00:57:37.073 --> 00:57:40.014
You've got a light source, okay, like from here.

1188
00:57:40.755 --> 00:57:45.377
You create a single slit, like let's say this way.

1189
00:57:45.917 --> 00:57:47.458
You create a horizontal slit this way.

1190
00:57:47.478 --> 00:57:48.339
You've got a light source.

1191
00:57:48.679 --> 00:57:50.120
Back then, he didn't have lasers, right?

1192
00:57:50.400 --> 00:57:51.780
So he needed a way to create a very –

1193
00:57:53.861 --> 00:57:57.903
sort of monochromatic like light of the same color and things like that.

1194
00:57:57.963 --> 00:58:01.185
So he's got a prism that spreads it apart.

1195
00:58:01.505 --> 00:58:04.327
And then he targets only one color, right?

1196
00:58:04.547 --> 00:58:06.468
And then you can be sure that it's just one.

1197
00:58:06.828 --> 00:58:09.109
Otherwise, white light, there's a bunch of – you're not going to get anything.

1198
00:58:09.449 --> 00:58:13.711
So he has a horizontal slit in this direction that lets in a specific color of light.

1199
00:58:14.031 --> 00:58:16.973
And then here he's got two slits, one up and one down here.

1200
00:58:17.353 --> 00:58:17.573
Okay.

1201
00:58:17.853 --> 00:58:23.278
And the idea is the light is going to, if it's a wave, well, if it's a particle, it's going to like spray like a bullet.

1202
00:58:23.698 --> 00:58:24.699
And then there's two slits.

1203
00:58:24.899 --> 00:58:26.401
So it's going to spray like bullets here.

1204
00:58:26.821 --> 00:58:31.185
And then if I have a detector, then I'm going to see two lumps of where the light landed.

1205
00:58:31.225 --> 00:58:31.365
Right.

1206
00:58:31.485 --> 00:58:32.145
If it's a particle.

1207
00:58:32.245 --> 00:58:32.426
Right.

1208
00:58:33.006 --> 00:58:40.654
If it's a wave, on the other hand, just like how ocean waves spread out and they interfere with each other, the light is going to spread out over here.

1209
00:58:41.094 --> 00:58:44.217
Then it's going to hit these guys and spread out from these two points.

1210
00:58:44.597 --> 00:58:46.359
And then it's going to create an interference pattern.

1211
00:58:46.419 --> 00:58:47.300
Right.

1212
00:58:47.740 --> 00:58:51.004
Kind of like the moiré patterns that we were talking about last week.

1213
00:58:51.124 --> 00:58:51.304
Yes.

1214
00:58:51.444 --> 00:59:00.109
Right, where you have like this, these fringes going out and then they create light, dark, light, dark, light, dark fringes on the detector.

1215
00:59:00.209 --> 00:59:00.469
Okay.

1216
00:59:00.929 --> 00:59:05.351
And when we saw these light, dark, light, dark fringes, you can calculate from the wavelength of light.

1217
00:59:05.371 --> 00:59:08.013
You can calculate like how far apart the light dark should be.

1218
00:59:08.453 --> 00:59:09.994
And they're exactly that far apart.

1219
00:59:10.254 --> 00:59:15.637
You can do the math and like, okay, it's pretty, pretty awesome that like, yep, it's, it's a particle.

1220
00:59:15.937 --> 00:59:16.117
Right.

1221
00:59:16.177 --> 00:59:17.318
I mean, sorry, light is a wave.

1222
00:59:17.678 --> 00:59:17.918
Okay.

1223
00:59:18.298 --> 00:59:19.619
Then comes the quantum revolution.

1224
00:59:19.639 --> 00:59:22.042
We start understanding that light might actually be a particle.

1225
00:59:22.182 --> 00:59:23.343
It might be quantized, right?

1226
00:59:23.643 --> 00:59:31.171
Max Planck uses the quantum of light to demonstrate black body radiation, which is like why stuff that's hot glows the way it does.

1227
00:59:31.611 --> 00:59:39.900
And then Einstein himself actually uses light being a particle to explain the photoelectric effect, which is how solar panels work and things like that.

1228
00:59:40.720 --> 00:59:42.501
Okay, so fine.

1229
00:59:42.541 --> 00:59:50.983
Light can be a particle in a wave, but you could sort of justify that by saying that even Newton thought light was a particle.

1230
00:59:51.083 --> 00:59:52.764
And now we're going back to this idea.

1231
00:59:52.844 --> 00:59:58.825
Maybe there's some discreteness in the way that light acts.

1232
00:59:59.546 --> 01:00:04.947
Then in 1927, George Thompson won the Nobel Prize for this.

1233
01:00:05.107 --> 01:00:07.168
He did the same experiment with electrons.

1234
01:00:07.968 --> 01:00:11.353
And he found that electrons also displayed this interference pattern.

1235
01:00:11.693 --> 01:00:11.954
Okay?

1236
01:00:12.294 --> 01:00:13.816
So now we're in this spot.

1237
01:00:14.176 --> 01:00:15.799
We're now electrons are becoming waves.

1238
01:00:16.159 --> 01:00:17.080
They used to be particles.

1239
01:00:17.160 --> 01:00:18.963
Light, that was a wave, is now a particle.

1240
01:00:18.983 --> 01:00:19.303
Particle.

1241
01:00:20.747 --> 01:00:34.452
On top of that, when people try to theoretically formulate all this stuff, people like Heisenberg and Schrodinger and Bohr, they come up with quantum mechanics, which now starts having things like the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle.

1242
01:00:34.493 --> 01:00:39.474
This idea that, okay, whatever system I'm looking at, I can't know too much about it.

1243
01:00:39.655 --> 01:00:42.136
If I know the position well enough, I'm not going to know the momentum.

1244
01:00:42.516 --> 01:00:45.097
So on and so forth.

1245
01:00:45.177 --> 01:00:46.277
Which is such a funny thing.

1246
01:00:46.357 --> 01:00:47.698
I still find that so...

1247
01:00:48.478 --> 01:00:50.780
And infinitely fascinating as a mental thing.

1248
01:00:50.840 --> 01:00:51.200
Yeah.

1249
01:00:51.381 --> 01:00:52.101
Even as – yeah.

1250
01:00:52.121 --> 01:00:53.682
And I mean Einstein did as well, right?

1251
01:00:53.702 --> 01:00:55.244
And he's like, this is crazy stuff.

1252
01:00:55.344 --> 01:00:56.104
Yeah.

1253
01:00:56.345 --> 01:01:06.573
So then they're like – so then Einstein's – like one of the rebuttals to this double slit experiment was, okay, like you've got a bunch of stuff going.

1254
01:01:07.014 --> 01:01:08.595
And so these guys are interacting, right?

1255
01:01:08.955 --> 01:01:11.657
What if I made the light source so dim?

1256
01:01:11.918 --> 01:01:12.098
Mm-hmm.

1257
01:01:12.378 --> 01:01:14.339
That only a single photon ever went through.

1258
01:01:14.359 --> 01:01:14.760
Okay.

1259
01:01:14.820 --> 01:01:15.480
This whole thing.

1260
01:01:15.640 --> 01:01:15.820
Yep.

1261
01:01:15.920 --> 01:01:21.103
So it went through one, and then presumably, naively, you would think it would go through one of the slits, and then it would...

1262
01:01:21.123 --> 01:01:21.263
Right.

1263
01:01:21.444 --> 01:01:21.624
Right?

1264
01:01:21.824 --> 01:01:26.727
But if it went through one of the slits, then I should see just two lumps, not the interference pattern.

1265
01:01:26.987 --> 01:01:27.127
Right.

1266
01:01:27.427 --> 01:01:33.871
Even if I do a single photon, it somehow splits, interferes with itself, which already, you're like, what?

1267
01:01:33.951 --> 01:01:35.572
Why is it interfering with itself?

1268
01:01:35.752 --> 01:01:36.413
What does that mean?

1269
01:01:36.433 --> 01:01:36.833
What does that mean?

1270
01:01:36.853 --> 01:01:38.394
And it's creating an interference pattern.

1271
01:01:38.474 --> 01:01:38.734
Okay.

1272
01:01:38.814 --> 01:01:39.074
Okay?

1273
01:01:39.755 --> 01:01:40.475
Next question...

1274
01:01:41.796 --> 01:01:45.279
Next obvious question is to be like, okay, which slit did it go through?

1275
01:01:45.679 --> 01:01:47.180
We only let a single photon through.

1276
01:01:47.700 --> 01:01:48.801
Which slit did it go through?

1277
01:01:48.821 --> 01:01:53.604
Well, if we start attaching detectors on the slits, then it becomes a particle again, and we see two lumps.

1278
01:01:54.105 --> 01:01:55.366
We don't see the interference pattern.

1279
01:01:56.053 --> 01:01:57.094
Okay.

1280
01:01:57.234 --> 01:01:59.835
So this was already getting weird, and Einstein had an idea.

1281
01:02:00.195 --> 01:02:00.535
Okay.

1282
01:02:00.575 --> 01:02:02.896
So Einstein's like, no, this is some weird stuff.

1283
01:02:02.916 --> 01:02:03.296
Yeah, yeah.

1284
01:02:03.397 --> 01:02:03.597
Okay.

1285
01:02:03.917 --> 01:02:07.859
So he had this ingenious – it's in 1927 Solvay Conference.

1286
01:02:07.959 --> 01:02:13.901
You've seen this photo of the greatest human minds at the time in one spot.

1287
01:02:13.921 --> 01:02:14.842
Never to be repeated again.

1288
01:02:14.862 --> 01:02:15.042
Right.

1289
01:02:15.142 --> 01:02:16.083
Never to be repeated again.

1290
01:02:16.123 --> 01:02:17.843
Honestly, it's never going to happen.

1291
01:02:18.384 --> 01:02:21.925
Like more than half of them won Nobel Prizes in physics.

1292
01:02:22.666 --> 01:02:23.106
Just like –

1293
01:02:23.786 --> 01:02:40.017
to be a fly on the wall it was the Avengers before the event yeah yeah 100 percent um and so he has this idea of like okay well you know I have this first slit right before it gets to the two now if the light is going and it makes its way to the bottom

1294
01:02:41.397 --> 01:02:45.342
then it's going to bump the slit up a little bit upwards, right?

1295
01:02:45.422 --> 01:02:47.005
Because of the momentum transfer.

1296
01:02:47.105 --> 01:02:51.510
Like conservation of momentum, the light got deflected downwards, so the slit is going to bump upwards.

1297
01:02:51.571 --> 01:02:54.695
Similarly, if the light goes upward, the slit is going to get bumped downwards.

1298
01:02:54.955 --> 01:02:55.536
So I could –

1299
01:02:56.617 --> 01:02:59.620
Instead of watching the light at the two slits.

1300
01:02:59.660 --> 01:02:59.860
Yep.

1301
01:02:59.901 --> 01:03:00.061
Yep.

1302
01:03:00.101 --> 01:03:00.261
Yep.

1303
01:03:00.301 --> 01:03:00.461
Yep.

1304
01:03:00.501 --> 01:03:00.761
Yep.

1305
01:03:00.882 --> 01:03:01.022
Yep.

1306
01:03:01.042 --> 01:03:04.685
Einstein's like, he's a tough cookie, dude.

1307
01:03:04.805 --> 01:03:05.927
It's like, he's not going to give up.

1308
01:03:06.087 --> 01:03:08.529
Cause like the problem was I was watching it at the two slits.

1309
01:03:08.629 --> 01:03:08.950
Right.

1310
01:03:08.990 --> 01:03:11.232
And then, and then, you know, it's like, Oh, well you messed with it.

1311
01:03:11.272 --> 01:03:11.592
Yeah.

1312
01:03:11.672 --> 01:03:11.853
Right.

1313
01:03:11.933 --> 01:03:16.197
And, but he's like, no, now I'm going to mess with it over here before it even gets to the two slits.

1314
01:03:16.217 --> 01:03:16.417
Yes.

1315
01:03:16.798 --> 01:03:17.038
Okay.

1316
01:03:17.639 --> 01:03:18.459
I'm going to watch it.

1317
01:03:19.200 --> 01:03:23.148
I want to watch the slit go up and down, and based on that, infer which direction it went.

1318
01:03:23.268 --> 01:03:23.408
Right.

1319
01:03:23.488 --> 01:03:26.193
And then from there, I can tell which slit it went.

1320
01:03:26.213 --> 01:03:26.334
Right.

1321
01:03:26.354 --> 01:03:26.514
Right?

1322
01:03:26.834 --> 01:03:27.015
Right.

1323
01:03:28.295 --> 01:03:32.978
And then my interference pattern should still be there, but I'll also know which way it went.

1324
01:03:34.158 --> 01:03:34.979
This is a tough one.

1325
01:03:35.239 --> 01:03:38.601
Bohr said this was a tough one.

1326
01:03:39.141 --> 01:03:48.467
So he goes back, and him and Heisenberg – it was basically the dynamic was Einstein would propose a problem, and then Bohr and Heisenberg would stay up all night trying to figure out what was wrong with it.

1327
01:03:49.487 --> 01:03:51.969
And then they'd come back the next day, and they'd have an explanation.

1328
01:03:52.089 --> 01:03:52.929
This was the explanation.

1329
01:03:52.949 --> 01:03:53.590
It's a very good one.

1330
01:03:54.550 --> 01:03:57.012
Bohr said, okay, in order to actually –

1331
01:03:57.952 --> 01:04:08.520
tell whether the slit was bumped up or bumped down, I would have to know very precisely which way the slit was going before and which way the slit was going after.

1332
01:04:09.000 --> 01:04:14.925
I need to know a difference in momentum in order to tell if it went up or down.

1333
01:04:15.065 --> 01:04:16.666
I need to measure that very precisely.

1334
01:04:18.367 --> 01:04:24.852
But if I measure that very precisely, if I measure the momentum very precisely, what happens to my position?

1335
01:04:25.709 --> 01:04:28.250
Oh, you know, my position is no longer definite.

1336
01:04:28.330 --> 01:04:28.530
Right.

1337
01:04:28.630 --> 01:04:30.891
Which means the slick could be here, here, here, here.

1338
01:04:31.331 --> 01:04:33.252
The slits position gets fuzzy.

1339
01:04:33.372 --> 01:04:33.712
Yeah.

1340
01:04:33.752 --> 01:04:38.594
Even though I know that it went up or down, but I don't know where it was when it went up or down.

1341
01:04:38.854 --> 01:04:44.316
You know that it's going up the y-axis or down the y-axis, but the actual tick mark on the on the side, it's.

1342
01:04:44.958 --> 01:04:45.198
Yeah.

1343
01:04:45.238 --> 01:04:45.679
It's fuzzy.

1344
01:04:45.759 --> 01:04:45.999
Yes.

1345
01:04:46.259 --> 01:04:47.260
That's fuzzy.

1346
01:04:47.380 --> 01:04:48.381
That's getting fuzzy, right?

1347
01:04:49.121 --> 01:04:52.784
And how fuzzy that gets means that you have a pretty wide slit.

1348
01:04:52.964 --> 01:04:53.144
Right.

1349
01:04:53.425 --> 01:04:56.027
Which means the light could have come from up here or up down there.

1350
01:04:56.087 --> 01:04:56.267
Yeah.

1351
01:04:56.487 --> 01:05:00.851
Which means that this path and this path are no longer equally distant.

1352
01:05:00.971 --> 01:05:01.211
Right.

1353
01:05:01.251 --> 01:05:03.272
So you're not going to get that interference pattern anymore.

1354
01:05:03.312 --> 01:05:05.054
The interference pattern is going to get smudged out.

1355
01:05:06.090 --> 01:05:06.730
This, okay.

1356
01:05:06.770 --> 01:05:08.171
This is, does that make sense?

1357
01:05:08.251 --> 01:05:12.312
And so you can't see, even, even if you try to do the cheating.

1358
01:05:12.432 --> 01:05:12.612
Right.

1359
01:05:12.852 --> 01:05:19.775
Before the thing happens to your detector, the, the, the physics knows the cheating is happening.

1360
01:05:19.915 --> 01:05:20.955
It's, it's, it's funny.

1361
01:05:20.975 --> 01:05:25.977
Cause I mean, does this tie to, I mean, is this kind of the ties to Heisenberg's uncertainty principle?

1362
01:05:26.057 --> 01:05:26.197
Yeah.

1363
01:05:26.237 --> 01:05:28.178
This is, this is Heisenberg uncertainty principle.

1364
01:05:28.198 --> 01:05:29.638
Because the idea is you can only know one of the two.

1365
01:05:29.778 --> 01:05:30.459
Yeah.

1366
01:05:30.499 --> 01:05:32.119
You can't know both position or momentum.

1367
01:05:32.139 --> 01:05:32.339
Yeah.

1368
01:05:32.599 --> 01:05:34.540
And like that, it's just what it is.

1369
01:05:34.740 --> 01:05:37.102
Yeah, it is just what it is.

1370
01:05:37.242 --> 01:05:38.202
This is what it is, right?

1371
01:05:38.483 --> 01:05:41.705
And because of that, like you trying to cheat one step before.

1372
01:05:41.925 --> 01:05:42.345
Doesn't matter.

1373
01:05:42.385 --> 01:05:46.588
Doesn't matter because you'll have destroyed the interference pattern already up here.

1374
01:05:48.009 --> 01:05:53.112
This reminds me of like video games where it's like you can't – the rules of the game are defined.

1375
01:05:53.532 --> 01:05:58.936
And so like if you try to like walk to the edge of the forest, it'll just like – there's no edge of the forest.

1376
01:05:58.976 --> 01:06:00.497
Yeah, it'll just make you circle around.

1377
01:06:00.757 --> 01:06:00.977
Right.

1378
01:06:01.057 --> 01:06:01.237
Right.

1379
01:06:01.297 --> 01:06:01.497
Yeah.

1380
01:06:01.517 --> 01:06:01.778
Yeah.

1381
01:06:02.518 --> 01:06:03.279
So, okay.

1382
01:06:03.539 --> 01:06:12.426
And so I think there's a long history of people asking these very ostensibly straightforward questions.

1383
01:06:12.446 --> 01:06:12.906
Where to go?

1384
01:06:13.167 --> 01:06:13.347
Right.

1385
01:06:13.567 --> 01:06:13.747
Right.

1386
01:06:13.787 --> 01:06:14.588
We have two slits.

1387
01:06:14.608 --> 01:06:14.868
Yeah.

1388
01:06:15.148 --> 01:06:16.689
We have one singular photon.

1389
01:06:16.729 --> 01:06:16.950
Yeah.

1390
01:06:17.230 --> 01:06:19.672
We're sending it towards those two slits.

1391
01:06:19.772 --> 01:06:19.952
Yeah.

1392
01:06:19.992 --> 01:06:20.793
Which one did it go through?

1393
01:06:20.853 --> 01:06:21.834
And which one did it go through?

1394
01:06:21.854 --> 01:06:22.674
And it's like, don't ask.

1395
01:06:23.675 --> 01:06:23.875
Right?

1396
01:06:23.895 --> 01:06:27.078
And Einstein's like, bro, this is our job as physicists.

1397
01:06:27.298 --> 01:06:27.438
Right?

1398
01:06:27.678 --> 01:06:28.618
What are we talking about?

1399
01:06:28.638 --> 01:06:29.398
If we can't like.

1400
01:06:29.438 --> 01:06:29.918
Like.

1401
01:06:31.179 --> 01:06:33.619
And so that was Boar's response, right?

1402
01:06:33.759 --> 01:06:33.879
Right.

1403
01:06:33.899 --> 01:06:37.340
And so what these guys, what these guys at MIT did was.

1404
01:06:37.420 --> 01:06:42.421
OK, so when we get into that slip problem, right, we're trying to figure out which way it went.

1405
01:06:42.561 --> 01:06:43.121
Yeah.

1406
01:06:43.321 --> 01:06:49.722
One of the things is you need the momentum to be so precisely determined to understand which way the photon kicked it.

1407
01:06:49.782 --> 01:06:50.723
Right.

1408
01:06:50.763 --> 01:06:51.723
The photons momentum.

1409
01:06:52.583 --> 01:06:56.484
is very small compared to even if I have a one gram mirror, right?

1410
01:06:56.724 --> 01:07:04.487
Or a one gram thingy like that one gram is going to have a momentum uncertainty that's like massive just because it's so big.

1411
01:07:04.547 --> 01:07:04.707
Right.

1412
01:07:05.087 --> 01:07:05.327
Okay.

1413
01:07:05.727 --> 01:07:13.109
So you need to in order to actually do this thing where I'm trying to figure out which way the electron went, the thing that is doing the electron.

1414
01:07:13.629 --> 01:07:13.869
Sorry.

1415
01:07:13.889 --> 01:07:21.972
The thing that is doing the pushing of that photon, the thing that is creating this disturbance of the photon needs to be extremely small.

1416
01:07:22.472 --> 01:07:23.493
And that's what these guys did.

1417
01:07:23.714 --> 01:07:26.216
The idea is we were doing this at larger scales before.

1418
01:07:26.236 --> 01:07:27.137
The slit is massive.

1419
01:07:27.277 --> 01:07:32.663
And so the spectrum of your error is so massive because of the scales.

1420
01:07:32.683 --> 01:07:34.785
Yeah, you can't even do the experiment.

1421
01:07:34.865 --> 01:07:36.367
There's no meaningful results that come from that.

1422
01:07:36.387 --> 01:07:41.672
So we're just saying if we go really, really, really, really small, you decrease –

1423
01:07:42.773 --> 01:08:09.860
the the the band yes of the possible error which at least allows you to start to maybe get at at this question which way did it go and if i figure out which way did it go does it really destroy the interference pattern right right because that's what quantum mechanics says right quantum mechanics says that no matter how i'm how small i make the slit if i try to cheat and get information about which way it went i'm going to destroy the interference pattern right okay that's what these guys found they made slits out of single atoms okay

1424
01:08:10.513 --> 01:08:10.773
Okay?

1425
01:08:11.094 --> 01:08:19.240
So what they did was they suspended these atoms, which it was either lithium-7, super light, or dysprosium.

1426
01:08:19.500 --> 01:08:20.240
Dysprosium?

1427
01:08:20.320 --> 01:08:21.481
Yeah.

1428
01:08:21.521 --> 01:08:22.002
162.

1429
01:08:22.162 --> 01:08:24.263
It's a very heavy element on the periodic table.

1430
01:08:24.644 --> 01:08:27.266
They suspended these atoms in a light beam.

1431
01:08:27.286 --> 01:08:38.254
You can do that now where you have these optical tweezers that can hold atoms at a certain spot in a little potential well.

1432
01:08:39.015 --> 01:08:41.858
Um, and it's ultra cold.

1433
01:08:41.878 --> 01:08:43.320
So they're really, they're really cold.

1434
01:08:43.821 --> 01:08:51.330
Um, and then you can have now single photons move through and they'll interact with the atoms and then create my interference pattern.

1435
01:08:51.711 --> 01:08:54.694
And then what I can do is I can turn off the light and,

1436
01:08:55.255 --> 01:08:57.937
and then have the interaction like a microsecond later.

1437
01:08:58.018 --> 01:09:01.461
So gravity hasn't had time to sort of impact it.

1438
01:09:02.101 --> 01:09:04.123
It's still sort of like there, suspended.

1439
01:09:04.503 --> 01:09:09.888
But in that fraction of time, now it's no longer in this potential well, so it can start spreading out a little bit.

1440
01:09:10.288 --> 01:09:12.010
And then if a photon hits it,

1441
01:09:12.470 --> 01:09:13.671
Then it'll kick it.

1442
01:09:13.731 --> 01:09:13.892
Right.

1443
01:09:13.932 --> 01:09:18.756
Because before it was like confined in this like, well, so it was a pretty rigid slit basically.

1444
01:09:18.776 --> 01:09:24.902
But now we're getting to this movable where we can measure like I can like in principle figure out which Adam moved more.

1445
01:09:24.942 --> 01:09:25.463
Yeah.

1446
01:09:25.783 --> 01:09:27.304
And then be like, oh, it was that one.

1447
01:09:27.344 --> 01:09:28.646
Yeah.

1448
01:09:28.866 --> 01:09:29.507
Of the two.

1449
01:09:29.847 --> 01:09:31.108
Yeah.

1450
01:09:31.228 --> 01:09:31.689
Yeah.

1451
01:09:31.749 --> 01:09:32.349
In principle.

1452
01:09:32.369 --> 01:09:35.292
They didn't do this, but they're like, in principle, we could have that information.

1453
01:09:35.572 --> 01:09:37.815
And then all of a sudden the interference pattern disappears.

1454
01:09:39.036 --> 01:09:52.967
And they could tune it such that the amount of spread that they were getting in these atoms' wave functions was proportional to how much the interference pattern was being destroyed.

1455
01:09:53.668 --> 01:09:55.429
So it's at its very fundamental level.

1456
01:09:55.469 --> 01:10:01.915
I mean, Einstein and Bohr couldn't even dream of this kind of experiment, where single atoms are now my slits.

1457
01:10:02.035 --> 01:10:02.215
Right.

1458
01:10:02.515 --> 01:10:02.655
Right.

1459
01:10:02.675 --> 01:10:03.815
But but that's what they did.

1460
01:10:03.895 --> 01:10:15.019
And like and they're getting this beautiful interference like and they're getting the knockoff of the interference as they do this thing where if you wait longer, then it spreads out more than the interference is even worse.

1461
01:10:16.859 --> 01:10:17.820
So this this is.

1462
01:10:19.540 --> 01:10:24.922
As we've gone to a higher level of, let's say, resolution by going super, super small.

1463
01:10:25.102 --> 01:10:25.702
Yeah.

1464
01:10:26.222 --> 01:10:28.663
It's holding up.

1465
01:10:28.683 --> 01:10:41.327
The wave-particle duality is holding true even at the smallest scales we can get to, which means that the universe is just weird.

1466
01:10:41.605 --> 01:10:42.707
Yeah, it's just a weird thing.

1467
01:10:43.008 --> 01:10:45.732
I mean, this isn't like the biggest test for quantum mechanics, right?

1468
01:10:45.752 --> 01:10:46.734
Because there's bigger tests.

1469
01:10:47.135 --> 01:10:47.776
There's like stuff.

1470
01:10:48.077 --> 01:10:52.705
There's like tests that won the Nobel Prize in Physics two years ago that...

1471
01:10:54.301 --> 01:11:02.188
It's like Bell's experiment where you send two particles far away from each other and then you collapse this one and see if that affected this one.

1472
01:11:02.769 --> 01:11:04.971
It's like looking for correlations far, far away.

1473
01:11:05.491 --> 01:11:06.812
This is the non-locality?

1474
01:11:06.832 --> 01:11:08.213
Yeah, this is the non-locality thing.

1475
01:11:08.253 --> 01:11:11.236
That's really the thing that Einstein was worried about the most.

1476
01:11:11.296 --> 01:11:12.217
Got it.

1477
01:11:12.857 --> 01:11:14.659
Because these things are not discreet.

1478
01:11:14.679 --> 01:11:15.680
Yeah, yeah.

1479
01:11:16.521 --> 01:11:27.751
So Bohr remembers – so what happened in the 1927 conference, we basically have these stories about, oh, Einstein did this and then Bohr did this.

1480
01:11:27.911 --> 01:11:28.572
It's from Bohr.

1481
01:11:29.331 --> 01:11:29.591
Okay.

1482
01:11:29.872 --> 01:11:42.549
So like Bohr has maybe like embellished it a little bit and he kind of, you know, now when we revisit history, it turns out Bohr might have missed the point on what was Einstein's biggest qualm, which is the action at a distance.

1483
01:11:42.569 --> 01:11:42.889
I got you.

1484
01:11:42.909 --> 01:11:45.392
Like Einstein's question was like, if I haven't.

1485
01:11:45.973 --> 01:11:48.193
Like if I have a it's a very simple thing, right?

1486
01:11:48.274 --> 01:11:52.674
Even with this double slit experiment, I've got I've got an interference pattern here.

1487
01:11:52.934 --> 01:11:54.595
And you're saying that it interfered with itself.

1488
01:11:54.695 --> 01:11:54.935
Fine.

1489
01:11:54.955 --> 01:11:55.795
I'll even give you that.

1490
01:11:56.215 --> 01:11:58.676
But then at the end of the day, I only see one particle.

1491
01:11:59.176 --> 01:11:59.376
Right.

1492
01:11:59.696 --> 01:12:03.937
It's that if I if I average over multiple particles, then I see the interference pattern.

1493
01:12:04.117 --> 01:12:04.317
Right.

1494
01:12:04.497 --> 01:12:05.917
Because it's like one particle comes in.

1495
01:12:06.277 --> 01:12:07.117
It puts it here.

1496
01:12:07.358 --> 01:12:08.778
Another particle comes in, puts it here.

1497
01:12:09.098 --> 01:12:11.078
And over time, I'll see an interference pattern.

1498
01:12:11.458 --> 01:12:13.819
But you're telling me there's a wave function that's everywhere.

1499
01:12:14.579 --> 01:12:15.939
But then I get only one particle.

1500
01:12:16.419 --> 01:12:19.400
How does the rest of the wave function know that I'm going to collapse here?

1501
01:12:19.480 --> 01:12:19.680
Right.

1502
01:12:20.040 --> 01:12:20.240
Right?

1503
01:12:20.480 --> 01:12:21.761
Why don't I see two particles?

1504
01:12:21.781 --> 01:12:22.781
Right, right, right, right, right.

1505
01:12:22.841 --> 01:12:23.021
Right.

1506
01:12:23.321 --> 01:12:24.201
It's a very good question.

1507
01:12:24.221 --> 01:12:24.381
Right.

1508
01:12:24.521 --> 01:12:30.823
It's like, how does this part of the wave function know, okay, don't trigger the detector because the other part is doing it over there, you know?

1509
01:12:30.923 --> 01:12:31.063
Yeah.

1510
01:12:31.123 --> 01:12:33.784
And so that was really Einstein's main qualm.

1511
01:12:33.944 --> 01:12:34.704
Right.

1512
01:12:35.484 --> 01:12:38.425
Which this is not solving for at all.

1513
01:12:38.445 --> 01:12:39.085
It's just reconfirming.

1514
01:12:39.105 --> 01:12:44.366
This is solving this sort of complementarity thing and showing that it really lasts even at the smallest of scales.

1515
01:12:45.027 --> 01:12:45.808
Oh, my God.

1516
01:12:45.828 --> 01:12:47.910
So there's still a lot more fundamental research to be done.

1517
01:12:47.950 --> 01:12:53.457
This was done at MIT by the Fedoseev and Ketterbach Lab.

1518
01:12:55.159 --> 01:12:56.761
NSF and DOD funding.

1519
01:12:56.942 --> 01:12:57.262
Of course.

1520
01:12:57.422 --> 01:12:58.684
Yeah.

1521
01:12:58.784 --> 01:13:01.327
All really, really valuable fundamental research.

1522
01:13:01.367 --> 01:13:01.608
Again.

1523
01:13:02.188 --> 01:13:03.329
We should fund science.

1524
01:13:03.409 --> 01:13:04.369
We should fund science.

1525
01:13:04.589 --> 01:13:07.011
Like this kind of stuff is so cool.

1526
01:13:07.171 --> 01:13:10.172
I'm trying to dig into the spooky action at a distance.

1527
01:13:10.332 --> 01:13:14.794
It's so – quantum mechanics, because you always talk to me about this stuff, even in our private conversations.

1528
01:13:14.814 --> 01:13:15.555
I'll recommend you a book.

1529
01:13:15.595 --> 01:13:17.556
It's called What is Real.

1530
01:13:17.856 --> 01:13:19.657
I forget the author, but it's an amazing book.

1531
01:13:19.717 --> 01:13:20.357
I have a copy.

1532
01:13:20.397 --> 01:13:20.697
I'll send it.

1533
01:13:20.717 --> 01:13:21.398
I'll give it to you.

1534
01:13:21.438 --> 01:13:25.240
Yeah, no, definitely, because it seemed – there's always this argument.

1535
01:13:25.800 --> 01:13:26.180
It's funny.

1536
01:13:26.340 --> 01:13:27.961
Earlier you were talking about like we're pretty good.

1537
01:13:28.221 --> 01:13:29.862
The physics stuff, we have a lot of that.

1538
01:13:30.662 --> 01:13:31.363
We're quite good.

1539
01:13:31.383 --> 01:13:33.343
The biology people, they'll catch up.

1540
01:13:33.904 --> 01:13:43.828
But this area of sort of quantum mechanics, the inability to quantize gravity, whatever, like all – there's always the argument that we've already figured it all out.

1541
01:13:43.909 --> 01:13:47.270
Physics all happened in this time period that we kind of just went through.

1542
01:13:47.290 --> 01:13:51.912
I mean that's what they told Einstein and Max Planck before they did quantum mechanics, right?

1543
01:13:52.072 --> 01:13:52.953
So you never know.

1544
01:13:54.595 --> 01:14:03.408
It's certainly like, I think we're poised for like a lot of cool discoveries, both in physics and in biology.

1545
01:14:03.788 --> 01:14:05.511
I think in biology, the tools are now there.

1546
01:14:05.671 --> 01:14:05.831
Right.

1547
01:14:05.851 --> 01:14:07.854
Where it's like we can start doing crazy experiments.

1548
01:14:07.874 --> 01:14:08.035
Right.

1549
01:14:08.355 --> 01:14:18.843
Before, like with the physics stuff, like the tools were only just catching up because electricity and magnetism had just been mastered in the late 1800s, right, with Edison and Maxwell.

1550
01:14:18.903 --> 01:14:22.946
So then we could start – we could have like these like massive electrical apparatuses.

1551
01:14:23.306 --> 01:14:27.349
And so once electricity and magnetism was solved, then we could go on to this thing.

1552
01:14:27.669 --> 01:14:34.675
You know, it's like now maybe like once we're getting – you know, there's a lot of possibilities on where this can go.

1553
01:14:35.555 --> 01:14:42.460
And just to be clear, it's sort of the sandbox that we're playing in is well-defined.

1554
01:14:42.480 --> 01:14:45.482
There are just some corners of it, like this area of quantum mechanics.

1555
01:14:45.522 --> 01:14:50.226
We're still just trying to fill in some of the mosaic, but we know where the box is, right?

1556
01:14:50.266 --> 01:14:51.567
Because we're able to do things like this.

1557
01:14:51.587 --> 01:14:53.848
Yeah, we're able – I mean the fact that we're able to do things, right?

1558
01:14:53.888 --> 01:14:58.332
Like the fact that we're able to suspend two atoms in a laser, that's because we know a lot about quantum mechanics.

1559
01:14:58.352 --> 01:14:58.552
Correct.

1560
01:14:58.572 --> 01:14:58.872
Correct.

1561
01:14:58.972 --> 01:14:59.132
Right?

1562
01:14:59.152 --> 01:15:00.072
That we can even do that.

1563
01:15:00.153 --> 01:15:00.313
Right.

1564
01:15:00.513 --> 01:15:00.793
Yeah.

1565
01:15:00.833 --> 01:15:00.993
Right.

1566
01:15:01.353 --> 01:15:05.615
So it's like – I just – I continue to be fascinated by this stuff.

1567
01:15:05.955 --> 01:15:09.356
Four really, really great stories this week.

1568
01:15:09.836 --> 01:15:13.178
Again, we touched on the universe's oldest puzzle.

1569
01:15:13.278 --> 01:15:13.698
That's right.

1570
01:15:14.498 --> 01:15:15.499
First ever chemistry.

1571
01:15:15.999 --> 01:15:25.443
For being able to really understand how stars form, now being able to sort of re-simulate the early universe, connecting to stuff coming out of James Webb.

1572
01:15:26.663 --> 01:15:28.204
A huge study out of Yale –

1573
01:15:30.345 --> 01:15:32.305
programmable synthetic proteins.

1574
01:15:32.345 --> 01:15:33.285
That one is still nuts to me.

1575
01:15:33.305 --> 01:15:33.986
That one's crazy.

1576
01:15:34.006 --> 01:15:35.386
That one's nuts to me.

1577
01:15:35.686 --> 01:15:38.107
We have the Europa mission, new radar reason.

1578
01:15:38.487 --> 01:15:42.588
It's going to look at the oceans, the potential liquid oceans, but at least the ice.

1579
01:15:43.209 --> 01:15:45.789
It has two capability sets.

1580
01:15:45.989 --> 01:15:53.792
And then finally, kind of reconfirming an oldie, but at a level of clarity that kind of

1581
01:15:54.572 --> 01:15:55.673
Puts to bed like it.

1582
01:15:55.693 --> 01:15:57.853
Yes, this is we were right guys.

1583
01:15:57.893 --> 01:16:09.218
Yeah, yeah Yeah, yeah, and it just opens up new possibilities for research again Because now we're getting down to this level again with everything you can always move left or right a lane And it's like what if we tried this?

1584
01:16:09.378 --> 01:16:15.340
Yeah fundamental concept of how to build the experiment, but apply it Yeah over here.

1585
01:16:15.360 --> 01:16:15.780
Yeah, and

1586
01:16:16.160 --> 01:16:21.669
And that, ladies and gentlemen, is why we always like to talk about first principles here.

1587
01:16:21.870 --> 01:16:27.639
My name is Lester Nare, joined again by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

1588
01:16:28.000 --> 01:16:29.142
We will see you guys next week.
