WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.091 --> 00:00:10.833
Researchers switched on neurons that were linked to a mouse's cold experience, and its oxygen consumption went up without actually experiencing the cold.

2
00:00:11.353 --> 00:00:16.874
And still, there are neutrinos going through my fingernail because they're going through the earth and then going through my fingernail.

3
00:00:17.134 --> 00:00:19.075
Like, that's how little they interact, right?

4
00:00:19.215 --> 00:00:23.356
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, they actually responded to our...

5
00:00:26.227 --> 00:00:28.028
video on Instagram.

6
00:00:28.349 --> 00:00:29.049
Hello, Internet.

7
00:00:29.069 --> 00:00:37.136
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

8
00:00:37.196 --> 00:00:41.499
We are back for a follow-up on the Nobel Prizes.

9
00:00:41.539 --> 00:00:50.707
The last few episodes we have spent going through the winners of this year's Nobel Prizes in physics, chemistry, and medicine.

10
00:00:51.047 --> 00:00:52.008
And today we're going to take

11
00:00:52.789 --> 00:00:58.154
A little bit of a further look at what researchers are doing with the science of our award winners.

12
00:00:58.615 --> 00:01:04.481
Now we've got four papers that we're going to talk about restoring aspects of vision in people who've lost it.

13
00:01:04.801 --> 00:01:07.804
How activating memory can change metabolism.

14
00:01:08.085 --> 00:01:15.192
A way scientists are using neutrinos to understand the universe around us as well as a little bit about what's going on here at home worldwide.

15
00:01:15.592 --> 00:01:21.735
And then molecular handedness and the search for life, one of my favorite topics.

16
00:01:21.775 --> 00:01:25.516
But before we get into those, there's some interesting comments over the last couple of weeks.

17
00:01:25.556 --> 00:01:31.659
And I wanted to get into a little bit of how the what are the Nobel Prizes and how do they actually get vaccinated?

18
00:01:31.879 --> 00:01:58.610
nominated and so the prizes came out of alfred nobel's will in 1895 and the first one was awarded in 1901 i believe his initial money that was given was actually 31 million swedish kroner at the time uh not inflation adjusted um so this has been going on for more than 120 years yeah not a short period of time uh alfred nobel was the swedish inventor entrepreneur scientist he was a chemist

19
00:01:59.133 --> 00:02:03.417
and businessman who also happened to write both poetry and drama.

20
00:02:03.817 --> 00:02:13.865
So that gives an interesting reference point to his respect for literature, famously known as the inventor of dynamite and holder of 355 patents.

21
00:02:13.885 --> 00:02:18.709
The idea was to recognize work that brought the greatest benefit to humanity.

22
00:02:19.169 --> 00:02:23.573
One interesting note that came up in the comments was who gets to decide the winners?

23
00:02:23.593 --> 00:02:23.873
Yeah.

24
00:02:24.173 --> 00:02:29.962
And notably, there isn't just one committee for the Nobel Prizes that decides all of these.

25
00:02:30.002 --> 00:02:34.408
There's first the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, which awards the ones we focus on.

26
00:02:35.370 --> 00:02:38.635
Some of the ones we focus on physics, chemistry and the economics prize.

27
00:02:39.515 --> 00:02:42.177
which was added later and first awarded in 1969.

28
00:02:42.737 --> 00:02:45.959
Medicine is decided by the Nobel Assembly at the Karolinska Institute.

29
00:02:46.339 --> 00:02:48.100
Literature is the Swedish Academy.

30
00:02:48.701 --> 00:03:00.127
And finally, the Peace Prize is the Norwegian Nobel Committee, which is composed of five members that are appointed by the Storting, which is the Norwegian Parliament.

31
00:03:00.608 --> 00:03:06.171
Interestingly, in Nobel's will, he did not give a reasoning why the Peace Prize –

32
00:03:07.460 --> 00:03:08.521
Was randomly Norway?

33
00:03:08.581 --> 00:03:08.781
Yeah.

34
00:03:09.621 --> 00:03:13.964
There's not really an understanding of where that was coming from.

35
00:03:15.005 --> 00:03:17.806
I wonder if his wife was Norwegian or something.

36
00:03:18.727 --> 00:03:19.407
I have no idea.

37
00:03:19.467 --> 00:03:21.068
It seems kind of random, but yeah.

38
00:03:21.368 --> 00:03:23.810
So different prizes have different committees.

39
00:03:23.870 --> 00:03:30.354
And so if you're unhappy with one prize and how they decide to give it out, it's not necessarily across all of them.

40
00:03:30.954 --> 00:03:35.235
So the way – the other thing that came up is these things are old.

41
00:03:35.815 --> 00:03:37.076
Why are they just getting a prize now?

42
00:03:37.096 --> 00:03:46.238
And I think the way to think about the science prizes in particular is more akin to or similar to the Hall of Fame in sports for all the sports ball fans out there.

43
00:03:46.258 --> 00:03:49.139
So you're recognizing a particular discovery or contribution.

44
00:03:49.699 --> 00:04:00.202
But the work may have happened decades earlier allowing you to sort of see how that contribution has grown over time and how researchers have built on top of it to see where it leads.

45
00:04:00.462 --> 00:04:00.662
Yeah.

46
00:04:01.182 --> 00:04:11.928
This allows us to be able to trace the connection between the original question that was asked and how it's now being implemented, which is part of what makes these follow ups that we do now for the second year running so interesting.

47
00:04:11.948 --> 00:04:18.431
So as always, we're going to talk about the science from the ground up today, because this is from First Principles.

48
00:04:32.906 --> 00:04:37.911
Krishna, let's start with a quick recap of medicine and optogenetics.

49
00:04:39.053 --> 00:04:40.835
Optogenetics won the medicine prize.

50
00:04:42.008 --> 00:04:51.056
Specifically, they recognized Carl Diceroth, Peter Hegemann, and Georg Nagel for discoveries concerning light-gated ion channels and optogenetics.

51
00:04:51.156 --> 00:04:53.938
Those are the three with their artwork.

52
00:04:54.139 --> 00:05:06.970
This is a technology that allows neuroscientists to turn on and off specific neurons in the brain using light, and this allows scientists to establish causal links to

53
00:05:07.290 --> 00:05:15.657
between stimuli, neural firing, like the activity of neurons in the brain, and behavior of the animal at large.

54
00:05:15.877 --> 00:05:19.379
This is one of the first times that we can really do this kind of science.

55
00:05:19.460 --> 00:05:21.061
The notion of causality here.

56
00:05:21.921 --> 00:05:23.683
The notion of causality is what's important.

57
00:05:24.704 --> 00:05:25.444
So how does it work?

58
00:05:25.844 --> 00:05:26.105
Well...

59
00:05:27.000 --> 00:05:31.043
Very briefly, you can think of the neuron as a type of capacitor, okay?

60
00:05:31.303 --> 00:05:35.866
It stores a voltage across a membrane using charges on either side.

61
00:05:35.926 --> 00:05:45.112
These charges, instead of being the electrons of a conventional capacitor in your electrical grid, these are ions like calcium ions, sodium ions, potassium ions.

62
00:05:45.832 --> 00:05:51.136
There's ions on either side of this membrane, on the inside and the outside, and that stores a voltage.

63
00:05:51.756 --> 00:05:56.299
Now, to activate the neuron, all you have to do is introduce a short in the capacitor.

64
00:05:56.560 --> 00:06:07.187
When you introduce a short, the ions can freely flow from the inside of the neuron to the outside or vice versa, and you can sort of activate this thing, and the neuron starts firing.

65
00:06:07.487 --> 00:06:10.289
It can then influence other neurons to fire, right?

66
00:06:11.690 --> 00:06:13.131
What optogenetics lets us do is...

67
00:06:15.566 --> 00:06:17.787
Open up the short circuit on command.

68
00:06:18.248 --> 00:06:18.868
That's the point.

69
00:06:19.228 --> 00:06:21.729
So there's a protein called channel rhodopsin.

70
00:06:22.010 --> 00:06:23.170
It's a type of protein, really.

71
00:06:23.190 --> 00:06:24.291
It's a class of proteins.

72
00:06:24.651 --> 00:06:31.115
And what it does is absorb light and use that energy from the light to open up and close

73
00:06:32.047 --> 00:06:58.074
channels on the membrane such that ions can move from the outside to the inside in this case but sometimes from the inside to the outside it doesn't really right now we've gotten so good at this thing that we've just generalized it as a tool for whatever type of ion transport you want so depending on the channel and the electrical conditions it's going to change the cell's voltage and we can command now turning on neurons we can command turning off neurons and we can see what

74
00:06:59.995 --> 00:07:03.616
That's quite nice if we're trying to understand how the brain works.

75
00:07:03.796 --> 00:07:04.236
Exactly.

76
00:07:04.276 --> 00:07:13.299
Because you can literally poke at the cellular level a neuron in a living animal, in a living brain, and see what happens, right?

77
00:07:14.419 --> 00:07:20.761
So, you know, the brain is still a black box, but at least we can poke at stuff in the black box.

78
00:07:20.881 --> 00:07:23.782
For the AI people in the audience, this is the thing they talk about.

79
00:07:23.842 --> 00:07:24.862
Interpretability.

80
00:07:25.082 --> 00:07:25.282
Yeah.

81
00:07:25.642 --> 00:07:32.528
And it's a vector for us to be able to interpret and make some understanding of what's actually causal links.

82
00:07:32.668 --> 00:07:33.589
Yeah, 100%.

83
00:07:33.629 --> 00:07:48.382
And actually, I mean, you make a good point about like how a lot of times with interpretability in AI, some of the experiments you do are very similar to these optogenetic experiments where you go into a single layer of a neural network and you like silence them.

84
00:07:49.002 --> 00:07:56.625
Or you silence particular neurons and you try to see what kind of output the giant neural network gives out.

85
00:07:57.085 --> 00:08:06.729
Or you try to see what types of inputs are activating specific neurons in the middle latent spaces of these models.

86
00:08:07.109 --> 00:08:07.349
So...

87
00:08:07.849 --> 00:08:21.269
Pretty similar to the kinds of optogenetic experiments we're doing, but it's obviously harder in a biological animal, right, than just like code where you can just go, okay, like if in this layer, you know, flip a coin and turn off all these neurons, right?

88
00:08:21.549 --> 00:08:23.031
So it's pretty important.

89
00:08:23.051 --> 00:08:24.213
This is why it won the prize.

90
00:08:24.493 --> 00:08:29.896
The important combination here is the genetic selection plus the optical timing.

91
00:08:30.256 --> 00:08:37.900
Because what you can do now is you can express this channelrhodopsin-type protein in specific circuits in the brain, right?

92
00:08:37.940 --> 00:08:41.322
You can be like, I only want layer 5 pyramidal neurons.

93
00:08:41.882 --> 00:08:46.085
The way you do that is you figure out a kind of genetic cocktail that only...

94
00:08:46.945 --> 00:08:49.226
Layer 5 pyramidal neurons will respond to.

95
00:08:49.946 --> 00:08:54.208
And in that cocktail, you add the genetic instructions for channel rhodopsin 2.

96
00:08:54.748 --> 00:09:00.911
So the layer 5 pyramidal neurons, they're going to recognize the cocktail.

97
00:09:00.931 --> 00:09:03.232
They're going to be like, oh, I'm going to take this amount of genes in.

98
00:09:03.632 --> 00:09:07.973
Part of the genes that they take in are also the instructions to make that channel rhodopsin.

99
00:09:08.734 --> 00:09:12.435
That goes into the cell membrane, and all of a sudden now we can control using light.

100
00:09:12.695 --> 00:09:14.816
So this shows, you know, different types of neurons.

101
00:09:14.876 --> 00:09:16.557
On the bottom there, that's a pyramidal neuron.

102
00:09:17.712 --> 00:09:19.713
On the top, those are different types of neurons.

103
00:09:20.093 --> 00:09:24.055
And each one you can tag with different types of channelrhodopsins.

104
00:09:24.075 --> 00:09:25.595
And now you can even do multiplexing.

105
00:09:25.915 --> 00:09:28.857
You can be like blue light activates this population.

106
00:09:28.977 --> 00:09:31.097
Green light activates this population.

107
00:09:31.478 --> 00:09:33.218
Red light activates this population.

108
00:09:33.318 --> 00:09:37.300
You can do like strobe-like neurons.

109
00:09:38.822 --> 00:09:46.585
Control of single neurons even sometimes, mostly populations of neurons, but it's an incredibly powerful tool.

110
00:09:47.185 --> 00:09:49.006
Neuronal Burning Man.

111
00:09:49.446 --> 00:09:53.327
And it's sort of akin to this keeping the analogy going.

112
00:09:53.927 --> 00:09:56.368
With AI, we have the code and we can manipulate it directly.

113
00:09:56.408 --> 00:10:03.751
We're giving the code to the neuron cells with the genetic delivery, which then we now know we have the tools to be able to say turn off or on.

114
00:10:04.272 --> 00:10:18.373
But it first needs to be able to do so in a way where we understand that when we turn the lights blue, green, etc., the actual cells themselves have the instructions to respond the way that we want them to.

115
00:10:18.513 --> 00:10:19.174
Exactly, yeah.

116
00:10:19.274 --> 00:10:19.654
And so –

117
00:10:20.175 --> 00:10:23.918
So there's two papers that I want to talk about as a follow-up to that Nobel Prize.

118
00:10:23.938 --> 00:10:26.479
The first one is going to be a direct medical application.

119
00:10:26.980 --> 00:10:32.763
And the second one is going to be more kind of fundamental science-y and really the reason why these three authors won.

120
00:10:32.803 --> 00:10:38.567
But the first one, you know, I think it's still pretty cool that you can directly apply it to a medical therapy.

121
00:10:38.927 --> 00:10:40.889
So this has to do with a vision treatment.

122
00:10:41.369 --> 00:10:45.892
This vision treatment asks the eye's output cells to take over the job

123
00:10:46.412 --> 00:10:48.453
of broken light detectors effectively.

124
00:10:48.533 --> 00:10:59.719
Like there's a, you know, there's a disease called advanced retinitis pigmentosa where the retinal pigments that capture light from the surroundings, they get deteriorated.

125
00:11:00.099 --> 00:11:03.121
This is an attempt to restore vision among those patients.

126
00:11:03.361 --> 00:11:03.601
Okay.

127
00:11:03.861 --> 00:11:10.945
It's a paper from the University of Pittsburgh and actually really a whole consortium out in the New England Journal of Medicine.

128
00:11:11.065 --> 00:11:14.746
Again, I had to get my bootleg version from my friend who's a doctor.

129
00:11:15.967 --> 00:11:17.608
But this was out in October 2026.

130
00:11:17.648 --> 00:11:20.690
So like this month, right?

131
00:11:20.810 --> 00:11:22.531
Very, very recent.

132
00:11:23.352 --> 00:11:30.697
And it examines a optogenetic therapy in 10 people with blindness due to advanced retinitis pigmentosa.

133
00:11:31.177 --> 00:11:36.361
So to understand this approach, let's first actually just review what the retina is as a neural circuit.

134
00:11:36.401 --> 00:11:38.322
So this is what the retina looks like.

135
00:11:38.702 --> 00:11:44.966
The retina is one of my favorite neural circuits, not only because of its simplicity, but also because in undergrad at Princeton,

136
00:11:45.947 --> 00:11:52.255
My senior thesis was on physically modeling the retina as like an electrical circuit in some sense.

137
00:11:52.675 --> 00:11:54.157
It's a very simple circuit, okay?

138
00:11:54.558 --> 00:11:56.820
In the back of the retina are the rods and cones.

139
00:11:57.545 --> 00:12:00.966
This is the stuff that's in the back, like, towards the back of your head.

140
00:12:01.327 --> 00:12:05.108
So the eye, the light is coming from the center, from in front of you.

141
00:12:05.668 --> 00:12:08.530
The sensors are actually in the back, which is weird.

142
00:12:08.950 --> 00:12:15.893
You would think that the sensors, like in a traditional CCD, it goes CCD and then the wires come out from behind it, right?

143
00:12:15.993 --> 00:12:17.073
Here, it's the opposite.

144
00:12:17.173 --> 00:12:25.557
Like, the CCD is kind of in the back and the wires come out forward and then have to go through a hole to get to the brain.

145
00:12:26.118 --> 00:12:33.040
The reason for that is because our detectors, the rods and cones, they deteriorate very quickly because they respond to so much light.

146
00:12:33.580 --> 00:12:37.541
The proteins are always changing shape.

147
00:12:37.981 --> 00:12:39.362
That's going to lead to degradation.

148
00:12:39.842 --> 00:12:48.204
And so you need to be close to blood vessels to trash all of the proteins and get new proteins or get enough energy to get new proteins.

149
00:12:48.224 --> 00:12:48.724
You know what I mean?

150
00:12:48.744 --> 00:12:49.444
Yeah, 100%.

151
00:12:49.544 --> 00:12:51.525
So you need to be close to the trash chute.

152
00:12:51.967 --> 00:12:58.574
The structural shape is related to how it's actually used functionally and proximity to basically the recycle mechanism.

153
00:12:58.634 --> 00:12:58.955
Yeah, yeah.

154
00:12:58.975 --> 00:12:59.315
It matters.

155
00:12:59.535 --> 00:13:00.116
Yeah, exactly.

156
00:13:00.156 --> 00:13:10.026
Like, if the rods were actually in the same design of cameras, then you would just get a buildup of, like, your rhodopsins that have been used up in the front and you'd very quickly...

157
00:13:10.863 --> 00:13:11.783
not be able to see.

158
00:13:11.803 --> 00:13:11.883
See.

159
00:13:12.104 --> 00:13:12.284
Right?

160
00:13:12.544 --> 00:13:14.585
So, okay, that's why the rods and cones are in the back.

161
00:13:14.885 --> 00:13:19.487
And then you have a bunch of cells in the middle that are kind of like processing cells.

162
00:13:19.807 --> 00:13:22.128
There's bipolar cells, amocrine cells.

163
00:13:23.503 --> 00:13:26.866
And at the very end, you have these things called retinal ganglion cells.

164
00:13:27.266 --> 00:13:37.555
These are single cells that have their cell body in our eye, and they've got an axon that goes through the hole that I was talking about from the retina because they're in the front, so you've got to topologically go through the hole.

165
00:13:37.855 --> 00:13:40.818
There's a hole that goes through the eye to your brain.

166
00:13:41.498 --> 00:13:49.480
And it crisscrosses right in the middle, and that's where the center for the circadian rhythm is, all that other kind of stuff.

167
00:13:49.540 --> 00:13:55.321
But in any case, the actual sensors that go all the way to your brain are in the very front.

168
00:13:55.581 --> 00:13:59.401
Those are the retinal ganglion cells, and the cell bodies are in the very front.

169
00:13:59.721 --> 00:14:02.062
There's a little bit of processing that's happening.

170
00:14:02.142 --> 00:14:03.042
I want to be clear here.

171
00:14:03.102 --> 00:14:07.343
This is not just simply whatever I see in this pixel is what I'm sending.

172
00:14:07.363 --> 00:14:07.723
Right?

173
00:14:07.823 --> 00:14:13.725
there's a little bit of data compression that happens within our eye because you can't send all of the raw data, right?

174
00:14:13.765 --> 00:14:14.685
It's a thin wire.

175
00:14:15.725 --> 00:14:16.886
You better not fry it.

176
00:14:16.946 --> 00:14:17.186
Right.

177
00:14:17.226 --> 00:14:18.346
And you better not heat it up.

178
00:14:18.466 --> 00:14:24.148
So you have to sort of compress the data in order to send it to the brain in an efficient manner.

179
00:14:24.388 --> 00:14:25.588
And the retina is doing that.

180
00:14:25.788 --> 00:14:27.949
Our eyes are Pied Piper for data compression.

181
00:14:27.989 --> 00:14:28.389
Yeah, dude.

182
00:14:28.409 --> 00:14:31.750
They're creating zip files in some sense.

183
00:14:31.810 --> 00:14:35.071
The retina itself is creating a zip file to send to the brain.

184
00:14:35.091 --> 00:14:35.231
Yeah.

185
00:14:35.531 --> 00:14:36.713
It's pretty remarkable.

186
00:14:36.733 --> 00:14:39.756
And I love this network for that reason.

187
00:14:39.776 --> 00:14:40.537
It's very simple.

188
00:14:40.577 --> 00:14:43.961
There's only like five or six different types of neurons involved.

189
00:14:44.261 --> 00:14:50.108
And yet you can have this rich machinery for a lot of very cool computation.

190
00:14:50.399 --> 00:14:59.751
And everyone can understand the benefits of having eyes because it's a part of our core five senses and our lived experience in terms of how we interact with the world around us.

191
00:14:59.811 --> 00:15:09.243
And so to have something that's so visceral to everyone's lived experience and the mechanics, the functional mechanics being complex, but in a way that is complex.

192
00:15:10.724 --> 00:15:15.586
simple enough compared to other biological systems is actually quite interesting.

193
00:15:15.686 --> 00:15:16.366
Exactly, yeah.

194
00:15:16.527 --> 00:15:27.812
And the problem that these patients have with this retinitis pigmentosa is that the photoreceptors, the original photoreceptors, get damaged.

195
00:15:27.832 --> 00:15:28.392
Okay?

196
00:15:28.793 --> 00:15:29.093
So...

197
00:15:30.109 --> 00:15:30.709
How do you do this?

198
00:15:30.769 --> 00:15:36.191
Well, the strategy is to give retinal ganglion cells a microbial light-sensitive channel.

199
00:15:36.751 --> 00:15:44.273
You basically do optogenetics on the cells in the very front, the ganglion cells that are sending messages to the brain.

200
00:15:45.073 --> 00:15:48.274
So you're like, okay, I'm not going to care about the photoreceptors and things like that.

201
00:15:48.555 --> 00:15:50.595
I'm not even going to care about the middle circuitry.

202
00:15:50.875 --> 00:15:52.176
I'm just going to go to the output.

203
00:15:52.836 --> 00:15:56.257
I'm going to express my optogenetics in that, and then

204
00:15:57.342 --> 00:16:05.021
You know, when the things light up, the light is going to go in, but it's not going to hit the rods and cones because the rods and cones are kind of degraded, maybe even dead.

205
00:16:05.878 --> 00:16:07.900
The light is going to go hit the channel rhodopsin.

206
00:16:08.000 --> 00:16:12.523
That's going to cause these ganglion cells to fire, which is then going to send the signal to the brain.

207
00:16:12.624 --> 00:16:13.464
So I see what you're saying.

208
00:16:13.524 --> 00:16:22.351
So the middle and back layers, right, are not – there's a direct connection between what's happening in the ganglion cells in the front that sends the actual signal to the brain that does the interpretation.

209
00:16:22.772 --> 00:16:28.797
And so even if your middle and back machinery is degraded, which is what's happening in this particular disease –

210
00:16:29.317 --> 00:16:31.960
We're just overriding that by saying we're going to take the direct route.

211
00:16:32.040 --> 00:16:32.200
Yeah.

212
00:16:32.220 --> 00:16:41.311
We're going to take the express lane and activate what we need to in the actual sensors that are taking in the light and doing this zip file type compression.

213
00:16:41.371 --> 00:16:41.571
Yeah.

214
00:16:41.671 --> 00:16:42.192
To the source.

215
00:16:42.412 --> 00:16:42.812
Exactly.

216
00:16:43.313 --> 00:16:44.194
That's exactly the point.

217
00:16:44.214 --> 00:16:44.414
Exactly.

218
00:16:44.514 --> 00:16:46.315
And so how do you actually administer this thing?

219
00:16:46.335 --> 00:16:52.798
Well, in the 2026 trial that we're talking about here, each participant received an injection into the worst-seeing eye.

220
00:16:52.838 --> 00:16:53.839
So they had like two eyes.

221
00:16:53.939 --> 00:16:55.599
One of them had this retinitis.

222
00:16:55.640 --> 00:16:56.280
The other one didn't.

223
00:16:56.520 --> 00:17:02.363
So in the worst eye, you inject this kind of capsid, which is like a viral capsid with...

224
00:17:02.983 --> 00:17:04.044
this particular gene.

225
00:17:04.404 --> 00:17:11.187
There's a genome for crimson R, which is the channel rhodopsin type thing.

226
00:17:11.207 --> 00:17:11.427
Yes.

227
00:17:11.487 --> 00:17:14.888
And then you've got a promoter that kind of tags the retinal ganglion cells.

228
00:17:15.449 --> 00:17:23.873
And once those cells see this piece of DNA, they can express the protein on their membranes, and then they are now light sensitive.

229
00:17:23.993 --> 00:17:24.693
Before they weren't.

230
00:17:24.833 --> 00:17:25.933
This is the delivery device.

231
00:17:25.973 --> 00:17:26.174
Yeah.

232
00:17:26.494 --> 00:17:28.114
This is the delivery device, exactly.

233
00:17:28.415 --> 00:17:28.875
And so...

234
00:17:30.077 --> 00:17:36.461
One key point to make here is that we're going not to the photoreceptors, but to the ganglion cells, right?

235
00:17:36.802 --> 00:17:39.624
And I told you that there's some compression that's happening, right?

236
00:17:40.004 --> 00:17:45.388
So you can't just deliver light like it's normal eyes, okay?

237
00:17:45.628 --> 00:17:47.669
You have to use specific types.

238
00:17:47.929 --> 00:17:52.653
You have to do a little bit of the data crunching before you send it in, right?

239
00:17:53.033 --> 00:17:55.895
Because the ganglion cells are expecting a data crunched,

240
00:17:57.417 --> 00:17:59.558
set of numbers, right?

241
00:17:59.838 --> 00:18:00.899
A set of stimuli.

242
00:18:01.119 --> 00:18:03.220
They're not expecting the raw light.

243
00:18:03.700 --> 00:18:05.280
They're expecting all of the...

244
00:18:05.320 --> 00:18:06.981
They're expecting zip files.

245
00:18:07.041 --> 00:18:07.682
Right, right.

246
00:18:07.822 --> 00:18:07.982
Right?

247
00:18:08.042 --> 00:18:11.043
And so you have to give them kind of zip files.

248
00:18:11.343 --> 00:18:12.404
We have to pre-process.

249
00:18:12.484 --> 00:18:13.624
Yeah, we have to pre-process.

250
00:18:13.644 --> 00:18:14.825
And that's why we need goggles.

251
00:18:15.205 --> 00:18:15.445
Okay?

252
00:18:15.665 --> 00:18:17.446
So there are goggles that the patients wear...

253
00:18:18.086 --> 00:18:20.748
that's not going to actually give you the raw image.

254
00:18:20.768 --> 00:18:26.172
So on the lower right, you're seeing what the projected image is from the goggles.

255
00:18:26.412 --> 00:18:29.575
In this case, what they're doing is kind of an edge detection.

256
00:18:29.935 --> 00:18:39.082
The left is just a hand, black and white, but the edge detection is detecting movement and changing pixels, and it's only highlighting those pixels.

257
00:18:39.422 --> 00:18:43.165
Now, one thing that the authors are careful about is that this is not the only type

258
00:18:43.665 --> 00:18:46.449
of pre-processing that the retina does, right?

259
00:18:46.489 --> 00:18:47.991
The circuit is extremely complex.

260
00:18:48.351 --> 00:18:55.019
There are on off cells, there's movement cells, there's all sorts of like different types of, um, processing that happens.

261
00:18:55.079 --> 00:18:56.261
And this is just one of them.

262
00:18:57.022 --> 00:18:57.222
Um,

263
00:18:58.307 --> 00:19:05.589
And furthermore, in the ganglion cells population, there's specialized ganglion cells that do one thing or the other, right?

264
00:19:05.649 --> 00:19:08.310
It's not like all of them respond to edge detection.

265
00:19:08.730 --> 00:19:15.172
In a specific slice, there's going to be some edge detection cells, but there's also going to be some on-off cells and so on and so forth, right?

266
00:19:15.452 --> 00:19:21.194
So this is a crude way of kind of approximating what the retina does, but it's not even close, really, to what the retina does.

267
00:19:21.754 --> 00:19:24.575
The point of this study was to establish safety, right?

268
00:19:24.815 --> 00:19:27.337
OK, so that they can go on and do other studies.

269
00:19:27.557 --> 00:19:27.738
Right.

270
00:19:27.898 --> 00:19:29.359
Because you're doing a lot here.

271
00:19:29.399 --> 00:19:33.723
You're administering some genetics into a patient's eye.

272
00:19:34.003 --> 00:19:35.824
You're trying to see whether it responds to light.

273
00:19:35.844 --> 00:19:39.728
You're trying to make sure that it doesn't give them like epileptic seizures in the worst case scenario.

274
00:19:39.988 --> 00:19:42.510
You know, there's all sorts of things that can go wrong in biology.

275
00:19:42.830 --> 00:19:48.515
So the first and foremost primary purpose of this 2026 study was safety.

276
00:19:48.735 --> 00:19:54.803
The secondary one was to measure, okay, like, does the full-field stimulus, like, change the threshold of the eye?

277
00:19:55.143 --> 00:19:57.566
Can the eye, like, increase threshold sensitivity?

278
00:19:57.606 --> 00:20:04.195
This is why they actually did patients with one eye with retinitis and the other one normal, because then now you can compare, like, how...

279
00:20:04.635 --> 00:20:08.040
How much better is the left eye compared to your control, which is the normal eye?

280
00:20:08.100 --> 00:20:09.582
It makes total sense.

281
00:20:09.622 --> 00:20:11.445
Yeah, it's a well-done study.

282
00:20:11.465 --> 00:20:12.406
There were 10 patients.

283
00:20:12.546 --> 00:20:13.708
That's really clever, actually.

284
00:20:13.748 --> 00:20:14.329
Yeah, yeah.

285
00:20:14.389 --> 00:20:15.630
And it was done pretty well.

286
00:20:15.650 --> 00:20:17.273
The 10-person study, open label.

287
00:20:17.473 --> 00:20:20.978
So that means, I mean, obviously the people know that they're getting the viral vector, right?

288
00:20:21.238 --> 00:20:27.182
There's also, if you wanted to do a real study, you'd have to do a fully blind one where people are getting saline, right?

289
00:20:27.242 --> 00:20:32.325
And then, I don't know, what if the mind-body connection— I see better now.

290
00:20:32.545 --> 00:20:33.606
Things are crazy, dude.

291
00:20:33.626 --> 00:20:34.526
The mind is crazy.

292
00:20:34.566 --> 00:20:34.766
Right.

293
00:20:34.846 --> 00:20:37.548
And, like, that's totally an outcome that could happen.

294
00:20:37.928 --> 00:20:46.634
So this is the first in multiple, but it's a pretty cool scientific payoff, right?

295
00:20:46.674 --> 00:20:50.396
It's a new route into surviving neural circuitry.

296
00:20:51.368 --> 00:21:03.879
One of the things about this story that – because when we talked about the prize originally, it was just looking at sort of the past and how it built up to now this being again an October study that came out literally like this month.

297
00:21:03.959 --> 00:21:04.179
Right.

298
00:21:04.599 --> 00:21:05.680
Just not that long ago.

299
00:21:06.521 --> 00:21:15.869
And how we've taken – an original question which was totally unrelated to giving partial visual restoration –

300
00:21:16.309 --> 00:21:21.293
And we can say like in the clinical context, we can say, okay, well, there's only partial vision repair.

301
00:21:21.754 --> 00:21:24.015
And we talked about this edge detection idea.

302
00:21:24.035 --> 00:21:27.438
Like, okay, well, that's – you're not giving people their sight back.

303
00:21:27.859 --> 00:21:39.148
And it made me think about this idea of, you know, for people like us that currently – maybe not into the future, currently – have our full ability to see in our sight, it can be hard to understand –

304
00:21:39.708 --> 00:21:48.334
the impact of even this first incremental step in someone who was a part of the study and is experiencing it directly.

305
00:21:48.615 --> 00:21:49.735
We can look at the measurements.

306
00:21:50.096 --> 00:21:51.457
We can talk about the calculations.

307
00:21:52.753 --> 00:22:10.038
But there is a real lived experience that is getting fundamentally changed, even if not perfectly back to their original state, by these early steps, which I find it's important to always remember that when we talk about these things ending up in patients –

308
00:22:10.698 --> 00:22:13.779
These are people who didn't even think there was an opportunity for them to get their sight back.

309
00:22:14.939 --> 00:22:19.900
And I think like some of the things now it's like, yes, maybe they can't make a person's face.

310
00:22:19.960 --> 00:22:25.341
Maybe they can't, you know, read perfectly, but they can start doing things.

311
00:22:25.361 --> 00:22:32.502
They were removed from their lived experience that I think is really, really unbelievable.

312
00:22:32.542 --> 00:22:36.823
Again, we started this by looking at like how it was working algae.

313
00:22:37.398 --> 00:22:40.863
Yes, channel rhodopsin was first found in algae by Peter Hegeman.

314
00:22:41.243 --> 00:22:48.373
And then it became, oh, this is a way for us to be able to create and drive action within neurons.

315
00:22:49.754 --> 00:22:53.319
And then now this is being applied by clinical researchers for...

316
00:22:54.120 --> 00:23:08.521
restoration of eyesight and when we you were looking at this idea in algae you were not thinking that oh this is going to lead to restoration in eyesight maybe once you got to the transitional step of understanding you can control neurons obviously the that's pandora's box yeah but um

317
00:23:10.335 --> 00:23:23.921
some of these things can take one of the things that I think is incredible about this discovery, especially is sometimes when you're these researchers, you don't get to live to see the impact on people's real lived experience of the work that you do.

318
00:23:24.221 --> 00:23:24.801
Yeah.

319
00:23:25.002 --> 00:23:30.504
A lot of these researchers have been able, are still around and are able to actually see it come to fruition and

320
00:23:31.953 --> 00:23:37.360
everyday lived experience, which sometimes basic research and lived experience, there's a large delta between these two things.

321
00:23:37.740 --> 00:23:39.382
I think that's just such a cool part of this story.

322
00:23:39.402 --> 00:23:42.125
Yeah, and it's only going to get better, right?

323
00:23:42.286 --> 00:23:42.446
Yeah.

324
00:23:42.626 --> 00:23:44.969
Like, this is the first few things.

325
00:23:45.329 --> 00:23:46.871
I mean, this isn't even the first...

326
00:23:48.880 --> 00:24:13.892
paper that we covered that was trying to restore eyesight we had the prima paper yes earlier but and that one that one was actually much more involved because that involves like a literal chip going in the back of your eye that is responding to infrared great episode that's a crazy episode too yeah so i mean you know we live in a we live in a day and age where like medicine is the frontier right it's it's it's pretty cool the things that we can do

327
00:24:15.044 --> 00:24:19.406
and there are more than one ways to solve the problem and this just happens to be one.

328
00:24:19.546 --> 00:24:37.972
But I think the thing you brought up that's important is safety was the key aspect of the study, but they now have a foundational platform around the, those was it ganglion cells on the front, knowing that there's multiple functional pieces to it.

329
00:24:38.072 --> 00:24:38.332
Okay.

330
00:24:38.352 --> 00:24:40.513
Now we can start to take this,

331
00:24:41.433 --> 00:25:03.294
uh success with doing one to now making it a a multiplex kind of solution and seeing if we can now not just do egg detect edge detection can we get movement can we get these other things it's going to be fascinating to see and a lot of people in the comments were like i'm studying in optogenetics we do it we're doing this and we're doing that so it's an area clearly of of robust interest in research

332
00:25:03.434 --> 00:25:08.156
Yeah, I mean, as I said, every single university has an optogenetics lab, right?

333
00:25:09.337 --> 00:25:20.142
The main justification really for the optogenetics prize is not its application in these niche sort of medical disciplines, which, of course, it's amazing that it's happening.

334
00:25:20.162 --> 00:25:27.065
But the real bread and butter for why optogenetics has transformed neuroscience is because of what I talked about earlier, which is,

335
00:25:27.525 --> 00:25:37.451
this ability to establish causation between neural circuits and behavior, neural circuits and aggregate bodily functions in some sense, right?

336
00:25:38.252 --> 00:25:41.574
It's become the hammer for neuroscience fundamental research.

337
00:25:43.215 --> 00:25:45.716
Especially this is true in simple organisms.

338
00:25:46.097 --> 00:25:55.322
And I wanted to showcase C. elegans, which is the nematode, because I remember actually when I was doing my PhD in physics,

339
00:25:57.299 --> 00:26:01.803
I went to a summer school like in Okinawa, Japan.

340
00:26:01.923 --> 00:26:03.004
It's amazing, right?

341
00:26:03.044 --> 00:26:04.005
That I get to go to like.

342
00:26:04.185 --> 00:26:05.166
I'm going there in 10 days.

343
00:26:05.286 --> 00:26:05.686
Oh, really?

344
00:26:05.706 --> 00:26:06.807
That's where, anyway.

345
00:26:07.067 --> 00:26:07.568
Okinawa.

346
00:26:07.628 --> 00:26:07.968
Yeah, yeah.

347
00:26:07.988 --> 00:26:08.628
That's awesome.

348
00:26:08.648 --> 00:26:13.593
Yeah, no, they have the Okinawa Institute for Science and Technology, OIST, which is on a hill.

349
00:26:14.033 --> 00:26:14.473
Beautiful.

350
00:26:14.513 --> 00:26:16.055
Beautiful architecture over there.

351
00:26:16.075 --> 00:26:21.479
They have like a summer school for computational neuroscience, which I had the pleasure of attending.

352
00:26:22.360 --> 00:26:24.962
I forget who the PI was who gave this talk.

353
00:26:25.002 --> 00:26:26.763
Comment when you see this.

354
00:26:26.823 --> 00:26:33.445
Yeah, but they were talking about their use of optogenetics in C. elegans to understand motor movement, okay?

355
00:26:33.985 --> 00:26:42.048
This particular video is from the Gen Lab at the Research Institute in Toronto, the Tannenbaum Research Institute in Toronto.

356
00:26:42.308 --> 00:26:43.289
Here's what's happening, okay?

357
00:26:44.090 --> 00:26:48.913
You're optogenetically activating the inhibitory motor neurons when the light turns on.

358
00:26:49.053 --> 00:26:50.113
And watch the behavior.

359
00:26:51.294 --> 00:26:52.935
It arrests the behavior, right?

360
00:26:53.495 --> 00:26:55.676
This is a pretty easy causal link, right?

361
00:26:55.716 --> 00:26:57.057
I mean, we already had the causal link.

362
00:26:57.157 --> 00:27:00.639
Obviously, if you inhibit the motor neurons, you're going to stop the movement.

363
00:27:01.179 --> 00:27:24.886
of the of the worm but here it's just so obvious right that when the light turns on the you can imagine right there's little proteins in the neurons of that nematode that are as soon as the light turns on they're letting in ions which are depolarizing the cell or hyperpolarizing the cell in this case because it's inhibitory and it's stopping the activity of the muscles we're hitting the e-brake on the nematode

364
00:27:25.106 --> 00:27:26.067
It's pretty insane, right?

365
00:27:26.087 --> 00:27:27.588
And it happens almost immediately.

366
00:27:27.608 --> 00:27:27.808
Yeah.

367
00:27:28.128 --> 00:27:32.931
And we talked about the time as being a key part of this and the immediacy.

368
00:27:32.951 --> 00:27:36.233
And again, this is just a great visual to express that.

369
00:27:36.413 --> 00:27:38.814
And so this is just like stopping movement.

370
00:27:39.275 --> 00:27:40.776
Now, can you control movement?

371
00:27:40.976 --> 00:27:41.236
Mm-hmm.

372
00:27:41.576 --> 00:27:45.942
This next video is from the Alchema Lab at UMass Chan Medical School.

373
00:27:46.583 --> 00:27:54.032
Here, the animals express a light-gated channelrhodopsin in a pair of motor neurons called RIV.

374
00:27:54.112 --> 00:27:59.359
These neurons innervate the ventral neck muscle, and they're important for the omega turn.

375
00:28:00.060 --> 00:28:00.720
in C. elegans.

376
00:28:01.040 --> 00:28:10.063
And now you'll notice whenever the light turns on, I mean, it shows, I don't know if you can see, there's a little blue thing that says blue light on.

377
00:28:10.623 --> 00:28:14.284
Whenever the blue light turns on, the thing is going to turn left, right?

378
00:28:14.544 --> 00:28:17.545
You are now controlling the motor movement.

379
00:28:17.885 --> 00:28:24.407
You're controlling like the movement of this worm using light by turning lights on and on, on and off.

380
00:28:24.967 --> 00:28:28.428
This is clearly American because it said it can only turn left like NASCAR.

381
00:28:30.001 --> 00:28:31.322
Yeah, yeah, effectively.

382
00:28:32.143 --> 00:28:38.548
But I think the bigger point here is it's not just there is a granularity of control.

383
00:28:39.188 --> 00:28:40.329
And that's the big step here.

384
00:28:40.349 --> 00:28:46.574
It's not just on and off, but like we can actually, that on and off from a behavior perspective can be very specific.

385
00:28:46.634 --> 00:28:47.055
Exactly.

386
00:28:47.115 --> 00:28:55.802
And now using these types of optogenetic tools, we can map out the entire circuit to be like, what is the if-else thing?

387
00:28:56.062 --> 00:29:00.464
code for motor movement in this worm.

388
00:29:00.784 --> 00:29:05.665
See, Elegance is really nice because there's only like 300 neurons, so you can get that kind of granularity.

389
00:29:05.966 --> 00:29:09.627
But now with the advent of large data, with the advent of

390
00:29:10.197 --> 00:29:21.442
artificial intelligence, and with the honing of these types of tools, we could get granularity to much larger neurons, much larger species, mammals perhaps.

391
00:29:21.602 --> 00:29:24.184
And that is the second paper that I want to talk about.

392
00:29:24.584 --> 00:29:29.086
This is In Nature 2025 from Trinity College, Dublin.

393
00:29:31.072 --> 00:29:33.393
And it asks a different kind of question.

394
00:29:33.413 --> 00:29:34.373
This is in mammals.

395
00:29:34.613 --> 00:29:34.853
Yeah.

396
00:29:35.193 --> 00:29:38.754
And here you can do crazier things because mammals don't just move around.

397
00:29:39.074 --> 00:29:41.975
See, elegans, like the worms, you know, they're nice.

398
00:29:42.015 --> 00:29:47.637
They're a nice model organism because they really have very prescribed, typical types of movement.

399
00:29:47.977 --> 00:29:51.258
They eat, they poop, they reproduce, right?

400
00:29:51.278 --> 00:29:51.498
Right.

401
00:29:52.257 --> 00:29:54.398
It's about the spectrum of their behavior.

402
00:29:55.099 --> 00:29:59.201
There's going to be some C. elegans neuroscientists out there who are going to be pissed off.

403
00:29:59.221 --> 00:30:00.662
But like, I'm sorry.

404
00:30:00.782 --> 00:30:02.222
I'm not saying it's a bad thing, right?

405
00:30:02.302 --> 00:30:06.925
For certain questions, it's really good to have very simple model organisms, right?

406
00:30:07.645 --> 00:30:11.107
Several Nobel Prizes have been won by C. elegans scientists, okay?

407
00:30:11.127 --> 00:30:11.928
So don't come at me.

408
00:30:12.208 --> 00:30:14.129
But mammals can do even crazier things.

409
00:30:14.369 --> 00:30:15.770
And in this case, here's what they're asking.

410
00:30:16.090 --> 00:30:21.093
Can retrieving an experience, like reliving a memory by...

411
00:30:21.833 --> 00:30:30.156
activating the neurons that are associated with that memory, can doing that recruit the body's responses to the experience?

412
00:30:30.377 --> 00:30:30.577
Yep.

413
00:30:30.777 --> 00:30:31.057
Okay?

414
00:30:31.377 --> 00:30:35.579
Can, like, the body feel the memory being reactivated?

415
00:30:35.679 --> 00:30:41.121
And because we have the remote control now, it gets weird.

416
00:30:41.141 --> 00:30:41.701
It gets weird.

417
00:30:41.741 --> 00:30:41.941
Right?

418
00:30:42.101 --> 00:30:45.343
I mean, it's a real... Let's just talk about the science, okay?

419
00:30:45.363 --> 00:30:46.503
First, let's just talk about the science.

420
00:30:46.823 --> 00:30:48.364
So, the idea is...

421
00:30:50.005 --> 00:31:02.971
The researchers, in a nutshell, the researchers switched on neurons that were linked to a mouse's cold experience and its oxygen consumption went up without actually experiencing the cold.

422
00:31:03.411 --> 00:31:03.692
Okay?

423
00:31:03.972 --> 00:31:06.413
So the neurons that thought...

424
00:31:07.505 --> 00:31:17.188
that made it think that it was cold, started creating a bodily effect, where it started consuming more oxygen, the metabolism increased, so on and so forth, right?

425
00:31:17.408 --> 00:31:22.550
We already understand that a mammal exposed to the cold can increase heat production.

426
00:31:22.810 --> 00:31:26.671
This is why Joe Rogan is always in his ice baths.

427
00:31:26.771 --> 00:31:27.531
What are these called?

428
00:31:28.111 --> 00:31:28.651
Cold plunges?

429
00:31:28.671 --> 00:31:31.152
Cold plunges, the new brand name.

430
00:31:31.452 --> 00:31:34.493
He's in there with all of his friends in Austin, Texas.

431
00:31:34.753 --> 00:31:36.734
The idea is that you go into this cold plunge,

432
00:31:37.154 --> 00:31:39.936
It, like, momentarily increases your metabolism.

433
00:31:40.316 --> 00:31:44.299
It increases your oxygen intake because your body is like, oh, my God, I'm really cold.

434
00:31:44.419 --> 00:31:47.281
I need to, like, regenerate heat on my own, right?

435
00:31:47.341 --> 00:31:50.923
And this has, like, you know, benefits purported.

436
00:31:51.584 --> 00:31:55.046
Some of it's actually, you know, true and documented in scientific literature.

437
00:31:56.847 --> 00:31:57.428
In any case...

438
00:31:58.498 --> 00:32:02.302
The experimental logic now for this paper is the following.

439
00:32:02.663 --> 00:32:06.247
What we're going to do is we're going to pair an environment with the cold.

440
00:32:06.968 --> 00:32:13.074
So when the mouse is in a certain type of room with certain types of stimuli, we're going to pair that with cold.

441
00:32:13.535 --> 00:32:18.701
So now he's going to associate the stimuli with the experience of cold.

442
00:32:19.768 --> 00:32:26.393
Now, later on, we want to see if the mouse has earned, sorry, has learned that association.

443
00:32:26.693 --> 00:32:32.838
So we're going to put the mouse in that environment again, but no cold, and see if it responds as if it is cold.

444
00:32:33.839 --> 00:32:35.300
And the mice do.

445
00:32:35.680 --> 00:32:37.962
So that means that they have learned that association.

446
00:32:38.282 --> 00:32:38.522
Okay?

447
00:32:39.843 --> 00:32:44.867
Now what we do is we ask, what are the neurons that were activated in this experience?

448
00:32:44.887 --> 00:32:45.007
Okay.

449
00:32:46.402 --> 00:32:47.463
Okay.

450
00:32:47.563 --> 00:32:55.187
So first we need to make sure that we understand that when the mouse has a baseline, without doing any of the optogenetics magic yet.

451
00:32:55.868 --> 00:33:02.852
We got to make sure that it even, there's some construct in its brain that's like, oh, this is cold, I am cold.

452
00:33:02.912 --> 00:33:03.112
Yes.

453
00:33:03.412 --> 00:33:03.592
Right?

454
00:33:03.613 --> 00:33:03.773
Right.

455
00:33:04.493 --> 00:33:05.534
Even without the cold.

456
00:33:05.594 --> 00:33:05.794
Right.

457
00:33:06.354 --> 00:33:06.514
Right.

458
00:33:06.754 --> 00:33:06.935
Right.

459
00:33:07.275 --> 00:33:12.558
So now we've got an association where there's certain neurons that are activating in the brain

460
00:33:13.400 --> 00:33:15.942
That are associated with this cold experience, right?

461
00:33:15.962 --> 00:33:16.202
100%.

462
00:33:16.442 --> 00:33:21.686
And that are eliciting a cold response of elevated oxygen.

463
00:33:21.706 --> 00:33:22.726
This physiological response.

464
00:33:22.747 --> 00:33:23.867
Yeah, more metabolism.

465
00:33:23.887 --> 00:33:24.328
In the body.

466
00:33:24.508 --> 00:33:26.269
Elevated heart rate, that kind of stuff, right?

467
00:33:27.130 --> 00:33:29.131
And now we ask, what are the neurons that are involved?

468
00:33:29.431 --> 00:33:34.174
And can we optogenetically enhance those neurons, right?

469
00:33:34.555 --> 00:33:35.595
That's exactly what they do.

470
00:33:36.016 --> 00:33:39.038
So here, this is figure four of their paper.

471
00:33:40.389 --> 00:33:42.991
This is, again, this is not a deep dive.

472
00:33:43.011 --> 00:33:43.612
This is a rundown.

473
00:33:43.632 --> 00:33:45.473
So we're skipping directly to figure four.

474
00:33:45.493 --> 00:33:47.855
Usually we go one, two, three, right?

475
00:33:48.155 --> 00:33:52.499
Anyways, so on the left-hand side, the green is where the channel rhodopsin is.

476
00:33:52.879 --> 00:33:53.119
Okay?

477
00:33:53.459 --> 00:33:56.622
So the green is the optogenetically tagged neurons.

478
00:33:56.922 --> 00:34:00.485
Those specific neurons are the ones that were activated directly.

479
00:34:00.585 --> 00:34:25.047
during that cold experience which we are able to see because we have these tools to be able to scan yeah yeah and know what was activated before so we're just trying to artificially activate what we've already seen previously yeah yeah and on the right hand side we've got the on on the on the y axis is the volume of oxygen that is consumed like per minute or whatever and then x axis is time and

480
00:34:25.841 --> 00:34:30.223
The blue regions are where we've illuminated those neurons.

481
00:34:30.303 --> 00:34:32.024
So we've activated those neurons.

482
00:34:32.445 --> 00:34:33.805
The oxygen intake goes up.

483
00:34:34.886 --> 00:34:36.187
Nothing is happening to the mouse.

484
00:34:36.427 --> 00:34:39.869
The mouse is not in the environment that it's associated with the cold.

485
00:34:40.129 --> 00:34:40.989
And it's not in the cold.

486
00:34:41.029 --> 00:34:42.170
It's just in a normal...

487
00:34:42.730 --> 00:34:43.511
It's just chilling.

488
00:34:43.731 --> 00:34:44.491
Yes.

489
00:34:44.611 --> 00:34:46.432
And then you activate those neurons.

490
00:34:46.572 --> 00:34:49.794
And all of a sudden, the mouse thinks it's cold, I guess.

491
00:34:50.094 --> 00:34:50.735
We don't know, right?

492
00:34:50.775 --> 00:34:51.415
I don't want to say that.

493
00:34:51.795 --> 00:34:52.676
Sorry, I don't want to say that.

494
00:34:54.059 --> 00:34:59.785
The neurons that are associated with the cold experience are activated, and that causes a physiological response.

495
00:35:00.305 --> 00:35:04.430
We can't say subjectively what the mouse is feeling or thinking, right?

496
00:35:04.490 --> 00:35:05.371
I shouldn't say that.

497
00:35:05.511 --> 00:35:14.480
It's very easy to, and I always make this mistake, even as a trained neuroscientist or whatever, but yeah, it's important to have that distinction.

498
00:35:14.860 --> 00:35:22.366
I think what's so important about the construction we have here is we've now removed the environmental stimuli that was driving this response.

499
00:35:22.727 --> 00:35:34.776
And we're now just artificially, with light, trying to trigger the same thing that the environmental stimuli was doing before in a completely different, unassociated environment.

500
00:35:35.277 --> 00:35:39.580
And we are seeing that as driving the same physiological response.

501
00:35:39.660 --> 00:35:39.981
Exactly.

502
00:35:40.001 --> 00:35:41.202
So we've effectively taken...

503
00:35:41.922 --> 00:36:03.415
The memory of a lived environment in these mice and are able to artificially create, to artificially trigger something that results in a similar physiological response without necessarily making this connection that what the mouse's subjective experience is, is necessarily true.

504
00:36:04.275 --> 00:36:06.196
what it was like when it was in that environment.

505
00:36:06.236 --> 00:36:08.236
But it could be, it could not be.

506
00:36:08.276 --> 00:36:10.297
But it almost doesn't matter because the body is responding.

507
00:36:10.317 --> 00:36:11.577
Yeah, the body is responding, right?

508
00:36:11.617 --> 00:36:14.338
And so we have established a causal link.

509
00:36:14.598 --> 00:36:20.079
And this, in this case, this is in the dentate gyrus, which is a region of the hippocampus of the mouse.

510
00:36:20.699 --> 00:36:26.361
Dente gyrus, very famously, is one of the few regions in the brain where active neurogenesis happens.

511
00:36:26.701 --> 00:36:29.602
There's like new neurons being created in the dentate gyrus.

512
00:36:29.622 --> 00:36:31.522
The other one is the olfactory bulb.

513
00:36:31.682 --> 00:36:33.663
But it's very rare for that to happen, right?

514
00:36:34.245 --> 00:36:35.151
Um, so...

515
00:36:36.115 --> 00:36:40.857
One question that you might ask is like, well, how do you actually tag the cells that are active, right?

516
00:36:41.217 --> 00:36:55.803
And I just wanted to briefly mention, I'm not going to go into too much detail, but this alone, I think, is something that deserves a Nobel Prize in neuroscience, in like physiology and medicine, is the ability to actually even do that, yeah?

517
00:36:56.123 --> 00:37:02.046
It's to use, it's a general strategy that uses activity-dependent gene expression.

518
00:37:02.446 --> 00:37:04.627
The idea is that like when neurons become active,

519
00:37:05.543 --> 00:37:07.605
They start expressing specific genes.

520
00:37:07.825 --> 00:37:09.366
They start transcribing those genes.

521
00:37:09.706 --> 00:37:16.072
And you can have like a tracer that tags exactly those neurons that were active during that experience.

522
00:37:16.112 --> 00:37:16.692
That's really interesting.

523
00:37:16.712 --> 00:37:23.057
And then tag that tracer or like tie that tracer to then when you inject your optogenetic cocktail, right?

524
00:37:23.077 --> 00:37:23.238
Right.

525
00:37:23.998 --> 00:37:31.042
Only the neurons that were active during that time are going to then respond to the optogenetics and express channelrhodopsin.

526
00:37:31.062 --> 00:37:35.664
That's actually a huge... Let us know in the comments if you want us to cover that because there's actually...

527
00:37:35.684 --> 00:37:38.906
I have so many questions about... Because that's a non-trivial component.

528
00:37:38.926 --> 00:37:39.946
It's super non-trivial.

529
00:37:39.966 --> 00:37:40.266
Yeah.

530
00:37:40.326 --> 00:37:40.546
Yeah.

531
00:37:40.566 --> 00:37:42.027
It's super non-trivial.

532
00:37:42.527 --> 00:37:47.810
It's a thing called TRAP2, Targeted Recombination in Active Populations of...

533
00:37:48.229 --> 00:37:48.870
version two.

534
00:37:50.131 --> 00:37:54.234
It's, it's absolutely incredible that we can even do these things, but, but there's two conditions here, right?

535
00:37:54.454 --> 00:38:05.683
You have the activity and then you have an open labeling window, which is like right after, right after the experience of cold and everything that you have the activity, you label those neurons and,

536
00:38:06.161 --> 00:38:11.043
And then if the cells meet both of those conditions, they receive some kind of genetic change.

537
00:38:11.403 --> 00:38:16.085
And then only those things that have the genetic change are the ones that are going to express the optogenetics.

538
00:38:16.365 --> 00:38:22.507
And that way we can only turn on those cells that were important for that particular experience.

539
00:38:22.667 --> 00:38:37.966
So when we talk about that delivery device that we mentioned earlier, this is figuring out what locations do we need to deliver that delivery device to in order for it to generate the expression so when we hit it with the channel adoption, so when we hit it with the light we want to.

540
00:38:38.955 --> 00:38:43.839
what we've labeled and associated with the experience of whatever experiment we're doing.

541
00:38:45.280 --> 00:38:46.561
Like, that's how we know what the map is.

542
00:38:46.761 --> 00:38:47.762
Yeah, yeah, exactly.

543
00:38:48.043 --> 00:38:49.464
And it's a pretty general strategy.

544
00:38:49.684 --> 00:38:51.445
Which means... That's crazy.

545
00:38:51.505 --> 00:38:52.006
That's crazy.

546
00:38:52.186 --> 00:38:53.127
Yo, it's crazy.

547
00:38:53.147 --> 00:38:53.587
That's crazy.

548
00:38:53.607 --> 00:38:55.208
Okay, so the other causal...

549
00:38:55.248 --> 00:38:58.731
Whenever we talk about causal tests in biology, you always want the negative version of it.

550
00:38:59.152 --> 00:39:04.616
Like, you've shown the positive version, which is you activate this thing, the animal responds as if it is cold.

551
00:39:04.976 --> 00:39:05.517
What if you...

552
00:39:06.823 --> 00:39:10.526
put it in the experience of cold, but you deactivate the neurons, right?

553
00:39:10.846 --> 00:39:13.469
Does the animal respond as if it is not cold?

554
00:39:13.829 --> 00:39:16.131
And that's exactly what they did in figure five, right?

555
00:39:16.171 --> 00:39:17.512
So they show the other way around.

556
00:39:17.812 --> 00:39:19.034
This is not optogenetics.

557
00:39:19.054 --> 00:39:20.555
Here they use actually pharmacology.

558
00:39:20.875 --> 00:39:27.521
They use a drug that's activating a receptor in those targeted cells that inhibits those cells.

559
00:39:27.901 --> 00:39:33.326
And then you can deactivate this population, and that's going to trigger the response.

560
00:39:33.982 --> 00:39:44.053
And it's going to suppress the usual learned response of, I am cold, I need to, you know, the body at least needs to increase its metabolism.

561
00:39:44.073 --> 00:39:45.714
So you can show this both ways.

562
00:39:46.415 --> 00:39:48.197
It's incredible paper out in nature.

563
00:39:48.277 --> 00:39:49.979
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

564
00:39:50.359 --> 00:39:54.123
So I want to come back to this idea that we started with this idea of memory.

565
00:39:55.525 --> 00:39:55.665
And.

566
00:39:57.128 --> 00:40:04.633
you know, we talked a lot about the methods and the details, but one of the big ideas here is for memory is something that everyone can relate to.

567
00:40:05.553 --> 00:40:16.840
Uh, whether it's through our own personal lived experience, positive, negative memory, you know, you hear a song come on on the radio and it reminds you of being in high school or you smell the smell of rain in the summer.

568
00:40:17.101 --> 00:40:22.624
And it reminds you of like summer camp back in the day or like, so we, like we kind of have this thought of like memory being backwards looking.

569
00:40:23.304 --> 00:40:23.405
Um,

570
00:40:24.526 --> 00:40:33.438
And I think one of the things that this paper really shifted my thinking around is it's actually a two-way street where –

571
00:40:35.038 --> 00:40:41.202
This idea of memory, and I understand what these caveats of, we don't know what the subjective experience is of these subjects in this study.

572
00:40:41.362 --> 00:40:41.562
Yeah.

573
00:40:42.022 --> 00:41:01.975
But just to generalize it a little bit, your experience, which generates this activation in your brain, which in some cases will relate to how we recall in memory, actually has this aspect where when you are under similar conditions environmentally, you're…

574
00:41:02.629 --> 00:41:05.430
it will prepare your body for that experience.

575
00:41:05.450 --> 00:41:07.251
I mean, the immediate thing I think about is like PTSD.

576
00:41:07.452 --> 00:41:08.192
Yeah.

577
00:41:08.652 --> 00:41:09.312
As an example.

578
00:41:09.513 --> 00:41:09.973
Exactly.

579
00:41:10.593 --> 00:41:18.197
Just in terms of like this connection between memory and then a bodily, physical, physiological response to some future stimulus that's not from the past.

580
00:41:18.217 --> 00:41:19.638
Yeah, that's not really real, right?

581
00:41:19.878 --> 00:41:28.382
But there's some like weird stimulus that then triggers the same neurons that then causes the response that we call PTSD.

582
00:41:29.123 --> 00:41:29.583
I...

583
00:41:32.087 --> 00:41:33.630
In my head, this gets dark very quickly.

584
00:41:33.810 --> 00:41:35.194
Yeah, it gets dark very quickly.

585
00:41:35.274 --> 00:41:38.822
It also, I mean, if we linger on the PTSD aspect a little bit, right...

586
00:41:39.791 --> 00:41:49.859
If you can identify the neural population that creates the response like PTSD, like trauma and things like that, then you can find ways to perhaps delete those neurons, right?

587
00:41:50.679 --> 00:41:52.861
I mean, that's the most crude way of thinking about it.

588
00:41:53.121 --> 00:41:58.846
But there could be ways to restructure that neural network so that those triggers do not trigger anymore, right?

589
00:41:59.166 --> 00:42:01.588
That could be a possible therapy in some future.

590
00:42:03.460 --> 00:42:04.200
Seems pretty cool.

591
00:42:04.641 --> 00:42:09.364
Hugely beneficial for trauma victims of a wide variety of types.

592
00:42:09.564 --> 00:42:10.444
At the same time.

593
00:42:10.904 --> 00:42:11.545
Right.

594
00:42:11.565 --> 00:42:12.605
You know, the immediate.

595
00:42:12.625 --> 00:42:13.046
You know.

596
00:42:13.106 --> 00:42:13.406
Yeah.

597
00:42:13.506 --> 00:42:15.527
Like it, you know.

598
00:42:16.007 --> 00:42:17.048
It's like Total Recall.

599
00:42:17.068 --> 00:42:18.329
You know that movie?

600
00:42:18.409 --> 00:42:18.809
Yeah.

601
00:42:19.069 --> 00:42:20.110
Like the, yeah.

602
00:42:20.150 --> 00:42:22.891
It's literally like you could do Total Recall.

603
00:42:23.452 --> 00:42:28.635
And the, our ability to now understand these biological systems better is,

604
00:42:29.055 --> 00:42:31.638
Like this is the tension that always happens, right?

605
00:42:32.038 --> 00:42:37.063
Which is that, yes, science is an incredible way for us to understand the world around us.

606
00:42:37.083 --> 00:42:45.792
And the discoveries in many cases, understandably, some people's reactions like, oh, some billionaire is going to use this for evil.

607
00:42:45.812 --> 00:42:46.013
Oh, right.

608
00:42:47.210 --> 00:42:59.417
And so I want to make a quick distinction – shout out to my SpongeBob fans out there – between like where – so where we are right now is that we're doing these in model organisms, in this case mice.

609
00:43:00.457 --> 00:43:06.600
This is not necessarily something that has risen to the level of doing so in humans.

610
00:43:07.241 --> 00:43:08.721
And so that delta is not small.

611
00:43:08.742 --> 00:43:09.282
Yeah, yeah.

612
00:43:09.882 --> 00:43:18.230
So this is not like an overnight tomorrow the surveillance state is going to be like manipulating your memories.

613
00:43:18.330 --> 00:43:18.531
No.

614
00:43:18.951 --> 00:43:23.856
But there are always these ethical challenges that arise with these things.

615
00:43:23.876 --> 00:43:25.538
I mean I've seen a lot of like –

616
00:43:27.159 --> 00:43:48.321
science fiction short stories in the in the age of like neural link and these types of brain computer interfaces that that talk about you know a world where having a bci having a brain computer interface is like a mandatory thing right but like just how like nowadays you know everyone has these like medical tests that everyone has to do

617
00:43:48.681 --> 00:43:51.203
like this isn't a weird dystopian world.

618
00:43:52.143 --> 00:43:53.784
There's that Black Mirror episode, right?

619
00:43:53.824 --> 00:44:00.629
Where everyone has that, like the implant in their retina and their brain that like downloads the memories and like you can like relive memories.

620
00:44:00.989 --> 00:44:02.770
This is kind of that, you know?

621
00:44:02.890 --> 00:44:03.831
Yeah.

622
00:44:04.131 --> 00:44:08.734
Black Mirror continues to have been very prescient in many of these intersections.

623
00:44:08.814 --> 00:44:12.176
And Black Mirror is very, very far away, I think, from the technology of today.

624
00:44:12.356 --> 00:44:12.576
Right.

625
00:44:12.637 --> 00:44:17.960
But at the same time, you know, it's incredible just how much we're,

626
00:44:19.149 --> 00:44:24.212
commanding the human body and the human brain as we move forward, right?

627
00:44:24.232 --> 00:44:26.833
And there's still so much left to know, right?

628
00:44:26.893 --> 00:44:29.214
The brain is still very much black boxy.

629
00:44:29.534 --> 00:44:30.054
100%.

630
00:44:30.074 --> 00:44:31.135
But we're chipping at it.

631
00:44:31.555 --> 00:44:36.598
I think these conversations will continue to become more relevant because we are getting to a place where...

632
00:44:37.738 --> 00:44:46.347
the powers that we are discovering are increasingly powerful to make an ineloquent statement.

633
00:44:46.847 --> 00:44:50.911
And so it's never too early to just ask the question.

634
00:44:52.153 --> 00:44:57.518
And it just makes me feel like this idea of memory really became much more interesting than,

635
00:44:57.838 --> 00:45:01.479
After looking at this paper, cause I never thought about it in this.

636
00:45:01.559 --> 00:45:02.639
It's not a one way street.

637
00:45:02.699 --> 00:45:02.919
Yeah.

638
00:45:02.939 --> 00:45:03.179
Yeah.

639
00:45:03.199 --> 00:45:05.599
Now we're getting a, it's two way exchange.

640
00:45:05.639 --> 00:45:09.600
It's, it's, which is again, a totally different way to think about it.

641
00:45:10.240 --> 00:45:15.081
Um, and we're going to have to decide what kinds of interventions we're comfortable with allowing.

642
00:45:15.441 --> 00:45:20.182
Cause obviously we want the benefit, but you know, um, who gets to make that decision?

643
00:45:20.242 --> 00:45:20.462
Yeah.

644
00:45:21.142 --> 00:45:26.523
Uh, but not to end on, uh, in that segment, a, uh,

645
00:45:27.363 --> 00:45:31.046
Awkward place, but we're going to pause to do a little bit of housekeeping.

646
00:45:31.387 --> 00:45:37.472
Again, we're trying to be careful because we want to make a distinction between where we are now and where these things can go.

647
00:45:37.892 --> 00:45:40.914
But where these things can go, we know very much in our history.

648
00:45:41.475 --> 00:45:43.156
When we don't have these conversations early enough.

649
00:45:43.176 --> 00:45:43.617
We will go.

650
00:45:45.818 --> 00:45:47.019
Correct.

651
00:45:47.099 --> 00:45:57.367
For those who are joining us recently, whether it's through our Nobel Prize coverage, Golden Goose, all of our AI math stuff recently, welcome to FFP Nation with Krishna and myself, Lester.

652
00:45:57.407 --> 00:45:58.687
We are very happy to have you.

653
00:45:58.988 --> 00:46:05.852
One of the best ways you can help to support the show is a like, share, a comment, a five-star review on the podcast networks.

654
00:46:06.133 --> 00:46:11.496
It really helps us get the best science show on the planet to more people.

655
00:46:11.516 --> 00:46:12.117
Yeah.

656
00:46:12.637 --> 00:46:16.941
One thing that we've been waiting for, but we've taken matters into our own hands.

657
00:46:17.281 --> 00:46:23.466
For those who listen on Apple Podcasts, you've been audio only for so long.

658
00:46:23.946 --> 00:46:31.352
We are transitioning to a new provider to get our videos delivered on Apple Podcasts.

659
00:46:31.372 --> 00:46:34.754
We're looking to push that in November, so keep an eye out on that.

660
00:46:34.774 --> 00:46:41.780
For those who watch on Spotify or YouTube, video is already available as well as on our website, ffppod.com.

661
00:46:42.500 --> 00:46:46.683
A shout out to the big Instagram audience that has been following us for our clips.

662
00:46:47.063 --> 00:46:57.530
One of the best ways to get bite-sized experiences of the pod to help dilute the brain rot that you're getting from other channels.

663
00:46:59.131 --> 00:47:10.899
A recent milestone, which we could not have expected to have passed in our first year and a few months, is FFP Nation is now bigger than Nature Magazine.

664
00:47:11.418 --> 00:47:12.699
On Instagram, Springer Nature.

665
00:47:12.999 --> 00:47:14.140
Yeah, that's crazy.

666
00:47:14.220 --> 00:47:16.081
Which we actually have right here behind us.

667
00:47:16.161 --> 00:47:16.621
Oh, right here.

668
00:47:16.641 --> 00:47:17.102
Look at that.

669
00:47:17.142 --> 00:47:17.522
That one.

670
00:47:17.582 --> 00:47:22.305
We don't have a magazine, but there are more people that now follow us on Instagram than nature.

671
00:47:22.665 --> 00:47:23.225
Sorry, nature.

672
00:47:23.265 --> 00:47:23.766
We love you.

673
00:47:23.826 --> 00:47:25.127
Thank you for all the work that you do.

674
00:47:25.147 --> 00:47:26.828
Thanks for publishing me.

675
00:47:27.348 --> 00:47:28.188
We'll take it from here.

676
00:47:28.208 --> 00:47:29.048
No, no, no.

677
00:47:29.068 --> 00:47:29.448
Just kidding.

678
00:47:29.468 --> 00:47:30.249
Just kidding.

679
00:47:30.289 --> 00:47:40.910
No, but a huge shout out to everybody that continues to just pick up what we're putting down and support this way of talking about science.

680
00:47:41.390 --> 00:47:50.692
And the last thing I'll just make is for those who want to take the experience even further, if you go to our website, there are a variety of different ways to engage in the stories we talk about and take it to the next level.

681
00:47:50.912 --> 00:47:53.772
All the papers we talk about, some fun interactive components.

682
00:47:53.792 --> 00:47:56.573
We want to continue to build these learning tools for us.

683
00:47:57.413 --> 00:48:08.321
Whether you're a graduate student, a PhD, you're a PI at a lab, or you're an undergrad, you're in high school, you're just starting to get interested in these subjects, that is what we are here for.

684
00:48:08.661 --> 00:48:16.867
With that, now let's get back to the science with the next subject for the recap, which is physics.

685
00:48:17.527 --> 00:48:27.163
The Physics Prize this year recognized Francis Halsey's contributions to IceCube and the discovery of high-energy neutrinos from astrophysical sources.

686
00:48:27.784 --> 00:48:30.088
Now, this instrument, IceCube, is...

687
00:48:31.159 --> 00:48:58.995
absolutely wild love it's in the south pole on the antarctic ice sheet the antarctic ice sheet is you know two kilometers plus of sheer ice and what they've done is drill down into the ice sheet and create a giant neutrino detector the only one of its kind in the world funded primarily by nsf and managed primarily by the university of wisconsin where francis halzen is on the faculty um

688
00:48:59.848 --> 00:49:09.575
The idea is to use the ice as a medium in which these rare particle interactions, the ones that neutrinos take part in, become visible.

689
00:49:09.636 --> 00:49:13.779
Because neutrinos are notoriously hard to interact with.

690
00:49:13.839 --> 00:49:16.421
They're called the ghost particle in the standard model.

691
00:49:17.671 --> 00:49:18.751
They whiz right through.

692
00:49:18.791 --> 00:49:28.455
There's about trillions of them going through my fingernail at this very moment per second, even though the sun is on the other side of the earth, right?

693
00:49:28.496 --> 00:49:30.776
It's not even daytime right now in Los Angeles.

694
00:49:31.117 --> 00:49:36.619
And still there are neutrinos going through my fingernail because they're going through the earth and then going through my fingernail.

695
00:49:36.899 --> 00:49:38.820
Like that's how little they interact, right?

696
00:49:38.860 --> 00:49:43.982
So you need a large volume to basically, you know,

697
00:49:46.540 --> 00:49:48.781
hedge the bet in your direction, right?

698
00:49:48.801 --> 00:49:50.381
You're going to have this incident capture.

699
00:49:50.642 --> 00:49:50.842
Yeah.

700
00:49:50.862 --> 00:50:00.365
It's like the probability is so low, but if you flip a coin that's like super low probability a million times, at some point you're going to get heads, right?

701
00:50:00.485 --> 00:50:05.007
Like, you know, it's the gambler's fallacy except in physics.

702
00:50:06.507 --> 00:50:06.687
Right?

703
00:50:06.747 --> 00:50:07.868
So, so what's a neutrino?

704
00:50:07.888 --> 00:50:11.589
Well, a neutrino is a particle that has no negative charge.

705
00:50:12.128 --> 00:50:16.272
And it's got interactions with ordinary matter that is quite infrequent.

706
00:50:16.712 --> 00:50:22.898
But sometimes when it does interact with ordinary matter, it knocks out a charged particle, something like an electron or a muon.

707
00:50:23.158 --> 00:50:24.999
We'll get into more of those details later on.

708
00:50:25.280 --> 00:50:33.707
But effectively, the way it works is those electrons or muons that are going to go through the ice and they're going to travel faster than the speed of light in ice.

709
00:50:33.927 --> 00:50:34.488
In ice.

710
00:50:34.508 --> 00:50:34.608
Yeah.

711
00:50:35.228 --> 00:51:03.388
exactly because the speed of light in ice is about 20% lower than in a vacuum and the speed of light in vacuum is the universal speed limit so you can still technically go a little bit faster than you know that if you get a little bit closer to the speed of light but just faster than the 20% deficit then you're technically going faster than light in that medium and you'll initiate a shock wave in the electromagnetic field essentially and if we can record that shock wave we can figure out

712
00:51:03.729 --> 00:51:07.858
what the direction was of the neutrino that it came, what was the initial momentum, things like that.

713
00:51:08.359 --> 00:51:11.968
And from that, we can understand a little bit more about where that neutrino came from.

714
00:51:13.272 --> 00:51:14.893
So that's how Ice Cube works, right?

715
00:51:15.174 --> 00:51:18.156
And Ice Cube, at the very top, there's a tiny dot.

716
00:51:18.236 --> 00:51:20.038
That's the building that we were just looking at.

717
00:51:20.078 --> 00:51:23.761
Otherwise, this whole thing is a cubic kilometer of ice.

718
00:51:24.101 --> 00:51:26.964
It's a small dot for audio listeners.

719
00:51:27.044 --> 00:51:27.745
It's a very small dot.

720
00:51:27.765 --> 00:51:28.605
It's a very small dot.

721
00:51:28.625 --> 00:51:31.388
This thing is absolutely massive, right?

722
00:51:31.988 --> 00:51:39.375
So what's special about Ice Cube is because it's so big, it can capture high-energy neutrinos.

723
00:51:40.343 --> 00:51:51.607
High-energy neutrinos are neutrinos that come from these sources in the universe that are the greatest, largest, and most powerful particle accelerators ever.

724
00:51:52.107 --> 00:51:52.307
Right?

725
00:51:52.327 --> 00:51:53.388
They make CERN look...

726
00:51:54.119 --> 00:51:57.560
Like tiny, tiny little, I need another thing.

727
00:51:57.640 --> 00:51:58.881
I said Hula Hoot last time.

728
00:51:59.401 --> 00:52:01.362
I should have come with something else.

729
00:52:01.582 --> 00:52:05.123
Some other, you know, those racetracks, the Hot Wheels racetracks?

730
00:52:05.483 --> 00:52:07.284
Yeah, that's what it makes CERN look like.

731
00:52:07.584 --> 00:52:08.964
You know, this thing is massive.

732
00:52:09.004 --> 00:52:19.868
It's the size of galaxies, and it's flinging these charged particles, accelerating them to incredible energies, several orders of magnitude higher than what CERN can do.

733
00:52:21.112 --> 00:52:28.579
If I recall correctly, were we talking about how they're approaching the speed of light in the vacuum?

734
00:52:28.839 --> 00:52:29.379
Not quite.

735
00:52:29.599 --> 00:52:29.860
Yeah.

736
00:52:29.960 --> 00:52:30.140
Right?

737
00:52:30.160 --> 00:52:33.823
Yeah, but it's like 99.99999, and I think it's like 29s.

738
00:52:33.903 --> 00:52:34.604
Right.

739
00:52:34.664 --> 00:52:35.565
It's quite close.

740
00:52:35.765 --> 00:52:38.427
It's like as close as anything has ever gotten, right?

741
00:52:38.667 --> 00:52:39.408
That is massive.

742
00:52:39.608 --> 00:52:45.113
Obviously, light goes at the speed of light, but this is something that is going as close as it can to the speed of light.

743
00:52:45.373 --> 00:52:47.053
and still have a little bit of mass.

744
00:52:47.413 --> 00:52:51.134
So there's a little bit of mass energy in that term.

745
00:52:51.734 --> 00:52:56.315
It can't go truly at the speed of light, but it can get really, really close.

746
00:52:57.155 --> 00:53:03.116
We want to understand how these things work and what is the nature of these things.

747
00:53:04.717 --> 00:53:10.698
The problem is that these giant particle accelerators, they fling out...

748
00:53:11.792 --> 00:53:17.615
Cosmic rays, which is what we've seen before, these are charged particles that move at that speed.

749
00:53:19.216 --> 00:53:23.018
They also fling out gamma rays, and they fling out neutrinos.

750
00:53:23.078 --> 00:53:26.921
There's three types of things that come out of these particle colliders, okay?

751
00:53:28.502 --> 00:53:30.463
The cosmic rays are usually charged particles.

752
00:53:30.483 --> 00:53:37.887
They're like protons or heavy atomic nuclei, which means that they're going to be perturbed by magnetic fields in the extragalactic medium.

753
00:53:38.873 --> 00:53:47.263
And that means that if I saw a cosmic ray come from here, I'm not sure if it actually came from here or if it curved from over there and came from here, right?

754
00:53:47.523 --> 00:53:49.345
So I can't actually localize a source.

755
00:53:49.806 --> 00:53:52.569
Gamma rays, on the other hand, have a similar kind of problem.

756
00:53:52.870 --> 00:53:53.811
They're more straight.

757
00:53:53.891 --> 00:53:55.873
Gamma rays are just photons at the end of the day.

758
00:53:56.274 --> 00:53:56.474
But...

759
00:53:58.205 --> 00:54:07.229
These gamma rays interact with the intergalactic medium, so they can get bent somehow, and they can also lose energy by interaction within the intergalactic medium.

760
00:54:07.569 --> 00:54:10.811
On the other hand, neutrinos just go straight, okay?

761
00:54:11.151 --> 00:54:15.313
Their cross-section with respect to, like, how much they interact with stuff is, like,

762
00:54:15.693 --> 00:54:37.429
tiny tiny tiny so they're just going straight from source all the way to us here on earth right and so if we happen to catch one in antarctica and we can localize where it's coming from we can be pretty sure that it actually is a straight line to the source okay and that's the idea but at the same time they're very rare these high energy neutrinos are extremely rare which

763
00:54:39.925 --> 00:54:41.265
of the size of ice cube.

764
00:54:41.766 --> 00:54:48.747
The rarity of these events, you can calculate, it's something like one per cubic kilometer per year.

765
00:54:49.488 --> 00:54:56.169
So if you had a cubic kilometer detector and you saw this thing, then you'd see one every year.

766
00:54:56.189 --> 00:54:56.930
That's so crazy.

767
00:54:57.290 --> 00:54:57.430
And...

768
00:54:58.937 --> 00:55:01.298
That's why we need a cubic kilometer detector.

769
00:55:01.738 --> 00:55:13.681
It's also – and to come back to like this idea, I think if I recall correctly, part of what we're trying – this is a mapping endeavor because why – like we're trying to understand where it came from.

770
00:55:14.081 --> 00:55:22.903
And so we've now looked at all the options to do this mapping endeavor and we figured out that this is the best thing to – this is the best –

771
00:55:24.366 --> 00:55:33.893
secondary or outcome of a process that's happening very far away for us to try to trace back the source of that process and the scale of that process.

772
00:55:34.153 --> 00:55:51.625
And so fundamentally, you know, the purpose is we're trying to understand astrophysical phenomena that are these massive, quote, particle accelerators that are some of the most violently high energy phenomena.

773
00:55:51.705 --> 00:56:17.999
things in existence in the universe yeah exactly and the key thing here and this kind of follows up to the paper that we're going to talk about is that by studying these astrophysical sources we can also glean insight into the fundamental physics of particles in general and like the standard model we can push the standard model to its limit in terms of you know trying to understand how neutrinos work

774
00:56:18.693 --> 00:56:20.494
They're a very enigmatic particle, right?

775
00:56:20.534 --> 00:56:22.355
And catching them is extremely rare.

776
00:56:22.876 --> 00:56:27.218
The higher the energy, the more kind of esoteric physics you can get into.

777
00:56:27.658 --> 00:56:28.359
And that's the point.

778
00:56:28.759 --> 00:56:37.905
So this next paper, it's the Ice Cube paper from the Ice Cube collaboration published in the Physical Review Letters in August 2026.

779
00:56:38.045 --> 00:56:39.085
So again, very recent.

780
00:56:39.105 --> 00:56:39.766
Very recent.

781
00:56:39.806 --> 00:56:40.406
Very recent.

782
00:56:40.426 --> 00:56:44.389
This is like, you know, two months before Ice Cube won the Nobel Prize.

783
00:56:45.609 --> 00:56:46.490
And it measures...

784
00:56:46.887 --> 00:56:50.630
The three-flavor composition of cosmic neutrinos.

785
00:56:51.070 --> 00:56:54.653
The cosmopolitan ice cube of cosmic neutrinos.

786
00:56:54.973 --> 00:56:58.216
Yeah, that's actually, that should have been the title, honestly.

787
00:56:58.236 --> 00:56:59.717
What are you guys doing at Ice Cube?

788
00:56:59.757 --> 00:57:00.057
Come on.

789
00:57:00.077 --> 00:57:01.398
This branding opportunity.

790
00:57:01.418 --> 00:57:01.839
Yeah, yeah.

791
00:57:02.239 --> 00:57:04.501
So let's review the standard model real quick.

792
00:57:05.501 --> 00:57:06.542
Here's the standard model.

793
00:57:08.144 --> 00:57:11.106
Beautiful, beautiful standard model of particle physics.

794
00:57:12.725 --> 00:57:21.130
Everything that is anything except gravity and maybe dark matter and dark energy, I guess, if those things are real.

795
00:57:21.270 --> 00:57:24.472
So you're saying the majority of the universe?

796
00:57:24.612 --> 00:57:25.332
Yeah, fair enough.

797
00:57:27.213 --> 00:57:28.434
Yeah, things that are normal.

798
00:57:29.154 --> 00:57:29.955
Things that are normal.

799
00:57:31.055 --> 00:57:31.515
It's in here.

800
00:57:31.755 --> 00:57:31.975
Yes.

801
00:57:31.995 --> 00:57:32.215
Okay?

802
00:57:32.735 --> 00:57:37.036
At the center and the four that are flanking the center, those are the bosons.

803
00:57:37.156 --> 00:57:38.997
At the very center is the Higgs boson.

804
00:57:39.657 --> 00:57:45.838
And the four on the side, those are the gluon, the photon, and the W and Z bosons.

805
00:57:46.198 --> 00:57:48.739
The gluon mediates the strong nuclear force.

806
00:57:48.779 --> 00:57:53.540
This is the thing that keeps the nucleus of the atom together.

807
00:57:53.960 --> 00:57:59.801
The photon mediates the electromagnetic force, like, you know, electricity, magnetism, light, and,

808
00:58:00.141 --> 00:58:02.590
And the W and Z bosons mediate

809
00:58:02.976 --> 00:58:04.697
the weak nuclear force.

810
00:58:04.717 --> 00:58:06.179
This has to do with beta decay.

811
00:58:06.439 --> 00:58:13.865
And it turns out that, you know, the photon, the W and Z bosons, they're kind of part of the same sort of gang, the electroweak force.

812
00:58:13.965 --> 00:58:14.705
The weak gang.

813
00:58:15.386 --> 00:58:21.531
And the Higgs boson is just sort of this enigmatic particle that gives the W and Z bosons mass.

814
00:58:21.991 --> 00:58:22.231
Okay?

815
00:58:23.612 --> 00:58:28.356
Finally, on the outer ring, those are the stuff that have mass.

816
00:58:28.917 --> 00:58:29.237
Okay?

817
00:58:29.277 --> 00:58:30.478
Those are the particles that...

818
00:58:31.637 --> 00:58:33.598
create matter in some sense.

819
00:58:34.399 --> 00:58:36.220
The top six are the quirks.

820
00:58:36.721 --> 00:58:42.905
You've got the up and the down, the charm and the strange, and the top and the bottom.

821
00:58:43.706 --> 00:58:45.548
Those come in those pairs.

822
00:58:45.688 --> 00:58:46.489
There's three pairs.

823
00:58:46.909 --> 00:58:55.457
And then on the bottom, you have the leptons, which are the electron and the electron neutrino, the muon and the muon neutrino, and the tau and the tau neutrino.

824
00:58:56.218 --> 00:59:01.764
Crucially, those neutrinos come in three different flavors for the three generations of matter.

825
00:59:02.304 --> 00:59:04.146
And this is the standard model.

826
00:59:04.506 --> 00:59:07.189
Each of these things actually represents quantum fields.

827
00:59:07.989 --> 00:59:11.252
And the particles are excitations in the quantum field.

828
00:59:11.552 --> 00:59:15.796
But the thing that is fundamental is really the field of the thing.

829
00:59:16.256 --> 00:59:25.143
But quantum field theory is very weird, and I need a few more semesters understanding it before I start talking about it in a bit more detail.

830
00:59:25.163 --> 00:59:26.224
We love QFT.

831
00:59:26.824 --> 00:59:33.790
In any case, three types of neutrinos, three different flavors of neutrinos.

832
00:59:34.411 --> 00:59:36.012
The question that we want to ask here...

833
00:59:37.495 --> 00:59:37.697
is...

834
00:59:39.343 --> 00:59:53.949
The flavors of those neutrinos, right, that are observed in IceCube, can we infer something about the physics of the sources that made those neutrinos by looking at the distribution of the flavors of the neutrinos?

835
00:59:54.189 --> 01:00:00.791
Because IceCube is going to see this number of electron neutrinos, this number of tau neutrinos, this number of muon neutrinos.

836
01:00:01.252 --> 01:00:06.594
Using that numbering scheme, the statistics of that, can I tell something about how...

837
01:00:07.294 --> 01:00:12.152
the blazars and those weird particle accelerators at the edge of the universe, how those work.

838
01:00:12.930 --> 01:00:16.052
I have strawberry, I have vanilla, I have chocolate.

839
01:00:16.993 --> 01:00:28.241
If I have more strawberry and then vanilla is the next biggest and then chocolate is the next biggest, it can tell me the source of what produced my cosmopolitan ice cream.

840
01:00:28.281 --> 01:00:29.782
What's wrong with the ice cream machine?

841
01:00:29.822 --> 01:00:31.203
Right, right.

842
01:00:31.383 --> 01:00:36.386
But again, being annoying about the analogy, but this idea that the proportion of the ingredients –

843
01:00:39.508 --> 01:00:45.351
If we take the flavors of ice cream, tell something about the McFlurry machine that made the ice cream.

844
01:00:45.531 --> 01:00:46.552
The In-N-Out.

845
01:00:46.572 --> 01:00:47.272
The In-N-Out.

846
01:00:48.113 --> 01:00:49.393
We're from California here.

847
01:00:49.814 --> 01:00:51.455
We are fans of In-N-Out Burger.

848
01:00:51.855 --> 01:00:56.677
No sponsorship yet, but In-N-Out Burger would be a great sponsor.

849
01:00:56.697 --> 01:00:57.218
We're hungry.

850
01:00:57.738 --> 01:01:00.119
You see how bony we are over here?

851
01:01:00.279 --> 01:01:02.600
We need a little caloric intake anyway.

852
01:01:02.620 --> 01:01:03.181
Yeah, so...

853
01:01:03.781 --> 01:01:05.382
That's the idea, right?

854
01:01:05.422 --> 01:01:10.624
We're trying to measure the distribution of the types of neutrinos that we see in IceCube.

855
01:01:10.644 --> 01:01:13.025
Now, it's useful to separate three different things, okay?

856
01:01:13.445 --> 01:01:17.907
There's the distribution that comes out of the particle accelerator at the edge of the universe.

857
01:01:18.387 --> 01:01:21.048
Then there's all of the stuff that happens in between.

858
01:01:21.368 --> 01:01:26.130
And then there's the statistics of the IceCube detector itself, right?

859
01:01:26.450 --> 01:01:27.690
We're going to separate those three parts.

860
01:01:28.031 --> 01:01:29.451
Let's start with the production, okay?

861
01:01:29.731 --> 01:01:31.192
The production of these neutrinos

862
01:01:31.852 --> 01:01:34.275
happens in probably this way.

863
01:01:34.535 --> 01:01:35.476
This is how we're guessing.

864
01:01:35.816 --> 01:01:40.181
There's a proton that's coming in from these jets, super high energy.

865
01:01:40.361 --> 01:01:47.549
It interacts with a gamma particle, which is a really high beam of high photon of light, high energy photon of light.

866
01:01:48.189 --> 01:01:51.573
And when it interacts with that, it's going to create pions.

867
01:01:51.865 --> 01:01:57.387
Those pions are going to then decay into muons and gamma particles and electrons and so on and so forth.

868
01:01:57.707 --> 01:02:02.750
Let's just look at the end of the diagram, the end of the trees, where the branches are, okay?

869
01:02:03.010 --> 01:02:04.510
You've got the positron at the top.

870
01:02:04.630 --> 01:02:04.830
Yes.

871
01:02:04.911 --> 01:02:06.411
Then you've got an electron neutrino.

872
01:02:06.431 --> 01:02:10.613
That's the new E, the V-looking thing with the E. That's an electron neutrino.

873
01:02:11.013 --> 01:02:13.414
Then you've got an anti-muon neutrino.

874
01:02:14.154 --> 01:02:14.775
That's the bar.

875
01:02:15.295 --> 01:02:16.535
And then a muon neutrino.

876
01:02:16.675 --> 01:02:19.337
And then the rest are electron, positron, gamma, gamma.

877
01:02:19.457 --> 01:02:19.777
At the bottom.

878
01:02:19.797 --> 01:02:19.897
Okay?

879
01:02:19.917 --> 01:02:20.017
Okay.

880
01:02:21.674 --> 01:02:22.580
Out of the neutrinos,

881
01:02:23.520 --> 01:02:30.161
We have two mu neutrinos, two muons, two muon neutrinos, and one electron neutrino, right?

882
01:02:30.361 --> 01:02:34.202
So it's a two to one sort of ratio, okay?

883
01:02:34.382 --> 01:02:38.863
Let's not worry about the fact that one of them is an anti-neutrino and the other one's a neutrino.

884
01:02:39.183 --> 01:02:45.944
There's this weird theory that the neutrino is its own antiparticle, but we don't know because, again, we don't know a lot about neutrinos.

885
01:02:46.304 --> 01:02:51.885
But in any case, the signature in our detector would be very similar given if it's a...

886
01:02:53.378 --> 01:02:55.520
muon neutrino or an anti-muon neutrino.

887
01:02:55.540 --> 01:02:56.921
What's really important is the flavor.

888
01:02:57.221 --> 01:02:59.283
And in this case, the flavor is a two-to-one ratio.

889
01:02:59.784 --> 01:03:02.406
Two muon neutrinos, one electron neutrino.

890
01:03:02.686 --> 01:03:02.926
Okay?

891
01:03:03.387 --> 01:03:07.070
That's what we're guessing is the starting distribution.

892
01:03:07.090 --> 01:03:08.511
What's happening at the source.

893
01:03:08.531 --> 01:03:09.552
What's happening at the source.

894
01:03:09.632 --> 01:03:09.892
Okay?

895
01:03:11.053 --> 01:03:12.455
Crucially, no tau flavors.

896
01:03:13.155 --> 01:03:15.537
Yeah, I was going to say, where's my umami?

897
01:03:15.617 --> 01:03:16.718
Yeah, no tau flavors.

898
01:03:16.798 --> 01:03:17.059
Okay?

899
01:03:18.040 --> 01:03:18.300
Now...

900
01:03:19.693 --> 01:03:24.577
From the source, it's going to come through billions of light years to the Earth.

901
01:03:25.098 --> 01:03:30.282
And during that time, it is going to change the mixture because neutrinos mix.

902
01:03:30.783 --> 01:03:41.632
They've got these things called mass eigenstates, which you can imagine are like three directions in your Hilbert space of possible neutrino flavors.

903
01:03:41.732 --> 01:03:43.033
Okay.

904
01:03:43.513 --> 01:03:47.337
They're not really even... You wouldn't even call them like...

905
01:03:48.151 --> 01:03:54.940
What's interesting about neutrinos is like the three relevant directions that you can express what the neutrino is.

906
01:03:55.846 --> 01:03:58.188
aren't even like electron muon tau.

907
01:03:58.569 --> 01:04:01.571
It's like mass one, mass two, mass three.

908
01:04:02.452 --> 01:04:03.053
I don't like it.

909
01:04:03.173 --> 01:04:04.254
Yeah, it's weird.

910
01:04:04.694 --> 01:04:10.840
And the three flavors are expressed as combinations of these three different directions in some sense.

911
01:04:10.860 --> 01:04:21.330
So you can imagine it's kind of like, you know, if we go to the analogy of the ice cream, it's like imagine there's like three ingredients that make up chocolate, vanilla and strawberry, but they come in different like sort of...

912
01:04:22.070 --> 01:04:46.047
proportions for each of them for each of the individual for each of the individual ones but they're like a mystery like box so you could get the dark chocolate chocolate or the milk chocolate yeah yeah and but like but like somehow if the milk chocolate and the dark chocolate combine it gives you strawberry you know neutrinos are weird right but in any case these three mass eigenstates are mixing all the time yeah and so sometimes the electrons

913
01:04:46.873 --> 01:04:51.457
the electron neutrinos will transition to tau neutrinos, will transition to muon neutrinos.

914
01:04:51.897 --> 01:05:00.305
And one of the famous experiments done by the Nobel Prize winners that discovered the neutrinos, Raymond Davis...

915
01:05:01.233 --> 01:05:06.594
he discovered that there's only a third of the neutrinos that we see from the sun showing up in my detector.

916
01:05:07.114 --> 01:05:08.695
And it's like, where are the other two-thirds?

917
01:05:08.715 --> 01:05:13.896
And everyone thought, we went over this in the episode of America 250.

918
01:05:14.356 --> 01:05:19.317
You know, John Bacall at Princeton was going, well, you should be seeing this many events.

919
01:05:19.637 --> 01:05:22.598
And he's like, no, I'm seeing exactly a third of what you're seeing.

920
01:05:23.278 --> 01:05:24.038
So what's going on?

921
01:05:24.318 --> 01:05:29.240
Turns out there's three flavors, and the neutrinos were changing flavor on their way from the sun to the earth.

922
01:05:29.660 --> 01:05:29.880
Okay?

923
01:05:31.383 --> 01:05:31.984
That's the idea.

924
01:05:32.464 --> 01:05:35.426
On the way here, that ratio is going to change.

925
01:05:35.627 --> 01:05:35.827
Yes.

926
01:05:36.327 --> 01:05:45.715
And finally, when we get to our detector, the detector has a different probability of measuring the three different types.

927
01:05:46.136 --> 01:05:46.556
Ah, okay.

928
01:05:46.636 --> 01:05:46.816
Right?

929
01:05:46.856 --> 01:05:50.239
Because it's not like all of these three interactions are created equal.

930
01:05:50.259 --> 01:05:50.880
Right?

931
01:05:50.900 --> 01:05:51.060
Right.

932
01:05:51.750 --> 01:05:58.272
If the tau came in, that has a lower percentage of interacting with the ice than, let's say, the electron neutrino.

933
01:05:58.292 --> 01:06:00.472
So good thing there's not a lot of taus coming from the source.

934
01:06:00.512 --> 01:06:00.732
Yeah.

935
01:06:00.972 --> 01:06:02.393
Well, but we don't know.

936
01:06:02.613 --> 01:06:03.373
Oh, that's true.

937
01:06:03.513 --> 01:06:04.573
That's the theory.

938
01:06:04.593 --> 01:06:07.474
It might transition on the way.

939
01:06:07.614 --> 01:06:07.994
On the way.

940
01:06:08.094 --> 01:06:08.994
So that's the theory.

941
01:06:09.014 --> 01:06:10.935
But it might be the case that it's there, but we just don't.

942
01:06:11.195 --> 01:06:13.155
On the observational level, we actually are not.

943
01:06:13.335 --> 01:06:13.716
You're right.

944
01:06:13.736 --> 01:06:14.516
So you've got to be careful.

945
01:06:14.536 --> 01:06:15.056
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

946
01:06:15.116 --> 01:06:15.236
Right?

947
01:06:15.276 --> 01:06:15.576
I like that.

948
01:06:15.836 --> 01:06:18.877
Now, there's three different signatures for the three different flavors.

949
01:06:18.897 --> 01:06:19.017
Okay.

950
01:06:19.037 --> 01:06:19.137
Okay.

951
01:06:19.317 --> 01:06:24.981
The electron one just looks like kind of like a single track.

952
01:06:25.381 --> 01:06:27.023
The electron one is in the center.

953
01:06:27.243 --> 01:06:28.324
It's not even a track, actually.

954
01:06:28.344 --> 01:06:32.447
It's more of just like an explosion that happens in the center of the detector.

955
01:06:32.727 --> 01:06:35.069
The track, actually, is the muon-looking.

956
01:06:35.469 --> 01:06:40.212
So the muon neutrino looks like a track that goes through the detector.

957
01:06:40.493 --> 01:06:42.794
The electron one is kind of like a central explosion.

958
01:06:42.834 --> 01:06:47.898
You can't really tell where it came from, but you've got a really good estimate of the energy because all of the...

959
01:06:48.298 --> 01:07:10.832
stuff is inside the detector with the muon it's like it's coming through it could have lost energy outside it could have lost energy on its way out like but you know where it's coming from because it's a really nice sort of linear thing and the the tau one has this like double bang idea where like bang bang yeah it goes through one and then it transitions in the middle of the detector it transitions into another

960
01:07:11.725 --> 01:07:32.574
particle and then does another um track i so it dumps a bunch of energy and then it has a little bit of energy left over and then does i just want you to know that i just gave a very very famous sports meme that you have no idea i have no idea what you're talking about and people in the comments will know what i'm talking about

961
01:07:32.794 --> 01:07:33.494
I'm not going to tell you.

962
01:07:33.855 --> 01:07:38.918
I didn't mean to – I just couldn't stop thinking about the double bang because double bang is in the lexicon.

963
01:07:39.418 --> 01:07:40.379
It's a very specific thing.

964
01:07:40.539 --> 01:07:40.699
Really?

965
01:07:40.719 --> 01:07:42.240
And it's not talking about the tau neutrino.

966
01:07:42.640 --> 01:07:43.821
No, dude.

967
01:07:44.321 --> 01:07:48.624
In physics, when people say double bang, everyone knows you're talking about the tau neutrino.

968
01:07:49.044 --> 01:07:54.728
And you're talking about this sort of double explosion that happens because a decay happens in the middle of the track.

969
01:07:55.368 --> 01:07:57.129
Everyone knows that's what you're talking about.

970
01:07:57.169 --> 01:08:03.973
I'm going to now call – and I'm not going to tell you, but what I'm referencing, I'm now going to call it the Tau Neutrino and make it a thing.

971
01:08:04.013 --> 01:08:07.955
For the physics who are also sports fan people, let's make it happen.

972
01:08:08.635 --> 01:08:17.039
But not to take away from your point here, but there are signatures on the observational level that are very unique and have different – they express themselves differently.

973
01:08:17.600 --> 01:08:18.700
They're very distinct.

974
01:08:18.740 --> 01:08:19.461
So we know –

975
01:08:20.422 --> 01:08:21.424
what flavor we're getting.

976
01:08:21.664 --> 01:08:22.105
Exactly.

977
01:08:22.165 --> 01:08:24.830
And we are getting some Tao because we know that it's the double bang.

978
01:08:24.910 --> 01:08:25.411
Yeah, yeah.

979
01:08:25.731 --> 01:08:27.314
But those things are quite rare, right?

980
01:08:27.775 --> 01:08:31.802
But you have to... You have to...

981
01:08:33.078 --> 01:08:39.119
scaffold the actual data that you see with the probability that you would see that thing, right?

982
01:08:39.139 --> 01:08:50.062
Because like, it could be that the thing is actually rare, or it could be that like, there's a lot of it, but it interacting with the ice in my ice cube detector is rare, right?

983
01:08:50.102 --> 01:08:50.682
Which one is it?

984
01:08:50.762 --> 01:08:56.324
And so you have to do a lot of forward modeling to actually figure out what is the incoming mixture from what you see.

985
01:08:56.364 --> 01:09:02.205
There's like a distribution of what you see, and from that you build like, what is it that is actually coming into the earth?

986
01:09:02.945 --> 01:09:03.486
from the source.

987
01:09:03.526 --> 01:09:05.767
The actuality and the possibility are different things.

988
01:09:06.247 --> 01:09:06.827
Very much so.

989
01:09:07.268 --> 01:09:11.009
And so this is what this new analysis did in the physical review letters.

990
01:09:11.570 --> 01:09:20.855
After 11.4 years of IceCube data, they figured out the best fit cosmic flavor fractions, and it's roughly at about 30% electron, 37% muon, 33% tau.

991
01:09:20.975 --> 01:09:21.815
Oh, interesting.

992
01:09:25.997 --> 01:09:27.578
So it's about a third, a third, a third.

993
01:09:27.918 --> 01:09:31.801
And the error is quite big because there's not that many events.

994
01:09:31.861 --> 01:09:33.662
It hasn't been online for that long.

995
01:09:33.782 --> 01:09:36.424
And again, we only have a cubic kilometer, right?

996
01:09:36.744 --> 01:09:37.584
You've got a bigger thing.

997
01:09:37.604 --> 01:09:39.646
You've got more data.

998
01:09:39.946 --> 01:09:41.687
And you can constrain this thing a little bit more.

999
01:09:42.027 --> 01:09:48.891
But for all intents and purposes, we can use at least this data to create some kind of inference about what's happening at the source.

1000
01:09:49.492 --> 01:09:51.453
And we can tell that we're probably correct.

1001
01:09:52.013 --> 01:09:59.745
About the fact that it's a proton that's interacting with the gamma to create a two-to-one ratio muon electron neutrinos.

1002
01:09:59.785 --> 01:10:00.806
Yeah, yeah.

1003
01:10:00.986 --> 01:10:02.088
This is...

1004
01:10:02.108 --> 01:10:07.977
But this is cool because we're gleaning insight into those particle reactions.

1005
01:10:08.753 --> 01:10:10.835
At the edge of our universe.

1006
01:10:10.995 --> 01:10:11.475
This is...

1007
01:10:13.196 --> 01:10:14.477
I have so many thoughts about this.

1008
01:10:14.617 --> 01:10:17.739
It gets back to... And we'll talk about it in a moment.

1009
01:10:17.759 --> 01:10:20.081
But why are we doing this?

1010
01:10:20.161 --> 01:10:21.602
And so I'll leave that for a moment.

1011
01:10:21.642 --> 01:10:23.143
But one of the things that we didn't...

1012
01:10:23.443 --> 01:10:24.764
This is just one aspect, again.

1013
01:10:24.844 --> 01:10:28.027
Paper that came out recently of how we're using this new instrument.

1014
01:10:29.227 --> 01:10:31.269
The Ice Cube Neutrino Observatory.

1015
01:10:32.390 --> 01:10:34.011
To look at things that are very far away.

1016
01:10:34.611 --> 01:10:35.652
A paper that we...

1017
01:10:36.112 --> 01:10:55.142
did not cover which is another aspect of this is this sort of earth tomography um yeah concept which is similar to the muon tomography that we've actually talked about on the pod which was related to um research in like uh volcanology and mapping the pyramids which is basically the hidden chambers in the yeah of the cool

1018
01:10:55.322 --> 01:10:56.002
The Khufu Pyramid.

1019
01:10:56.022 --> 01:10:56.702
Yes, yes.

1020
01:10:56.822 --> 01:10:57.703
In Giza.

1021
01:10:57.963 --> 01:11:00.103
Great, great past episodes for you to look at.

1022
01:11:00.123 --> 01:11:07.545
But it's giving us another way to – the actual instrument of Ice Cube in the Earth Tomography paper was looking at how it passes through the Earth.

1023
01:11:07.685 --> 01:11:07.926
Yeah.

1024
01:11:08.066 --> 01:11:14.087
Which lets us then understand the structure and mapping of the insides of our own planet.

1025
01:11:14.187 --> 01:11:14.467
That's right.

1026
01:11:14.547 --> 01:11:16.368
So this is not just a thing that's looking outward.

1027
01:11:16.988 --> 01:11:20.852
It is also giving us the ability to understand more about our home here on Earth.

1028
01:11:21.393 --> 01:11:30.282
And it goes to this idea that these tools, these instruments that are very expensive are not necessarily single-use.

1029
01:11:30.722 --> 01:11:36.428
And also, you might build them as single-use initially and discover that there are these tools.

1030
01:11:37.086 --> 01:11:48.450
ancillary use cases, these other use cases after the fact that you might not have initially thought was going to be the case, but they're so powerful that we can do a lot of things with them.

1031
01:11:49.250 --> 01:11:54.532
So I think Ice Cube is so cool because I'm a space nerd.

1032
01:11:54.732 --> 01:11:54.912
Yeah.

1033
01:11:54.972 --> 01:11:57.433
And so the space stuff is super interesting to me.

1034
01:11:57.453 --> 01:12:03.915
But the Earth tomography paper, I think, may be worth a follow-up in the future because there's some interesting aspects to that.

1035
01:12:04.275 --> 01:12:06.597
But that's totally fair.

1036
01:12:06.657 --> 01:12:15.642
And like, well, before we move on to the chemistry prize, I do want to linger on some of the reactions that this physics Nobel Prize caused.

1037
01:12:15.762 --> 01:12:16.543
There were reactions.

1038
01:12:16.563 --> 01:12:17.964
There were reactions, okay?

1039
01:12:18.024 --> 01:12:19.865
There's always reactions, right?

1040
01:12:21.706 --> 01:12:22.967
Let's talk about it, okay?

1041
01:12:23.287 --> 01:12:24.508
So there's been a lot of support.

1042
01:12:25.535 --> 01:12:37.345
From the experimental astrophysical community, from the astroparticle community, and from the cosmology community, it's been enormous support for Francis Halsey.

1043
01:12:37.625 --> 01:12:38.846
They think this is a no-brainer.

1044
01:12:38.886 --> 01:12:42.730
They've been calling Ice Cube as something that wins the Nobel Prize for a long time.

1045
01:12:43.350 --> 01:13:00.468
And Sean Carroll, a very famous scientist and physicist and science communicator, I guess, in some sense, he said, Francis Halsey is a great person and, quote, let's turn the Antarctic ice sheet into a neutrino detector.

1046
01:13:01.033 --> 01:13:04.976
is exactly the kind of idea that deserves a prize if you can pull it off.

1047
01:13:05.617 --> 01:13:06.758
Such a good Nobel Prize.

1048
01:13:07.158 --> 01:13:16.926
And if I recall correctly, it's been a while since an astrophysics or cosmology-related topic won the Physics Nobel?

1049
01:13:17.267 --> 01:13:19.488
Yeah, well, I mean, I think the last one was 2020.

1050
01:13:19.769 --> 01:13:22.071
Okay, okay.

1051
01:13:22.751 --> 01:13:23.872
That was Andre Gez.

1052
01:13:23.932 --> 01:13:24.392
That's right.

1053
01:13:24.733 --> 01:13:28.576
And cohort for the Sagittarius A-star Milky Way.

1054
01:13:28.596 --> 01:13:29.537
So not that long ago.

1055
01:13:29.557 --> 01:13:29.757
Yeah.

1056
01:13:29.917 --> 01:13:34.621
Not that long ago, but I mean, it's been happening, right?

1057
01:13:35.642 --> 01:13:40.727
I think the one before that was probably the Dark Energy one by Reese, and...

1058
01:13:44.151 --> 01:13:48.774
I shouldn't call it dark energy because they said the accelerated expansion of the universe.

1059
01:13:48.814 --> 01:13:54.396
The Nobel Committee is very particular because we don't know if it's dark energy or cosmological constant.

1060
01:13:54.656 --> 01:13:57.598
But certainly the accelerated expansion is a thing.

1061
01:13:57.938 --> 01:14:01.460
So for the experimental discovery, they won the Nobel Prize.

1062
01:14:02.800 --> 01:14:03.521
But still, it's...

1063
01:14:05.882 --> 01:14:10.545
So it's in the grand history of Nobel Prizes, astrophysics is certainly rare.

1064
01:14:10.905 --> 01:14:11.745
Fair enough.

1065
01:14:11.905 --> 01:14:12.286
Fair enough.

1066
01:14:12.366 --> 01:14:16.348
It's nice to see astrophysics get some kind of credit, you know.

1067
01:14:17.209 --> 01:14:19.910
So the vast majority of the community was very supportive.

1068
01:14:20.691 --> 01:14:21.992
Some have not been so kind.

1069
01:14:22.832 --> 01:14:28.257
Sabina Hosenfelder, who has a very entertaining show on YouTube.

1070
01:14:29.117 --> 01:14:37.545
Usually I quite enjoy her sass for physics, but every once in a while, I guess in this particular one, I did not enjoy it.

1071
01:14:37.745 --> 01:14:40.327
She had a video titled Benefit to Humankind?

1072
01:14:40.347 --> 01:14:40.447
Yeah.

1073
01:14:41.948 --> 01:14:44.670
Nobel Prize in Physics, you will hate me for saying this.

1074
01:14:44.971 --> 01:14:48.794
Well, hate is a strong word, but I think I will certainly disagree.

1075
01:14:49.094 --> 01:14:51.095
So here's what she said in the video.

1076
01:14:51.135 --> 01:14:53.377
She said, what have we learned from it?

1077
01:14:53.497 --> 01:14:57.540
Well, we have learned that neutrinos exist, which no one doubted.

1078
01:14:58.641 --> 01:15:03.385
It does teach us something about neutrino sources outside our galaxy, but that's pretty much it.

1079
01:15:03.865 --> 01:15:10.090
This Nobel Prize just documents how irrelevant the foundations of physics have become.

1080
01:15:11.136 --> 01:15:11.396
Okay?

1081
01:15:12.056 --> 01:15:13.537
Those are some pretty strong words.

1082
01:15:13.557 --> 01:15:14.938
Those are some pretty strong words.

1083
01:15:15.078 --> 01:15:17.959
Well, I would like to contend step by step, okay?

1084
01:15:18.159 --> 01:15:19.620
So she says, what have we learned from it?

1085
01:15:19.660 --> 01:15:21.741
Well, we've learned that neutrinos exist.

1086
01:15:22.181 --> 01:15:24.622
She says, which no one doubted, right?

1087
01:15:25.222 --> 01:15:27.463
No one doubted that these neutrinos existed.

1088
01:15:27.543 --> 01:15:31.785
And so the fact that we saw them doesn't really change anything.

1089
01:15:32.185 --> 01:15:37.468
Well, there are several Nobel Prizes in our history that do exactly that.

1090
01:15:37.969 --> 01:15:43.552
One of our favorite ones that we've talked about on this show is the Lamb shift from 1947.

1091
01:15:43.612 --> 01:15:55.840
Willis Lamb at the University of Columbia determined that two specific energy levels of the hydrogen atom had distinct energies.

1092
01:15:56.627 --> 01:16:04.914
And there was a tiny, tiny difference in that energy, which he measured using microwave radar technology.

1093
01:16:05.354 --> 01:16:06.636
This was in 1947.

1094
01:16:06.696 --> 01:16:11.179
So post-war, there was a bunch of radar technology that the U.S. government had developed.

1095
01:16:11.460 --> 01:16:13.521
He used that to find that shift.

1096
01:16:13.842 --> 01:16:22.309
Now, in the 1930s, people had been measuring the spectrum of hydrogen using visible light, and they already knew something was up.

1097
01:16:23.037 --> 01:16:23.277
okay?

1098
01:16:23.597 --> 01:16:28.181
Dirac had came up with his equation for the electron in the late 1920s, and from Dirac's

1099
01:16:32.170 --> 01:16:39.776
equation from Dirac's theories, you can sort of theorize and you can sort of deduce what the energy spacing should be.

1100
01:16:40.096 --> 01:16:47.982
But one of those energies, two of those energy levels should be degenerate, meaning they should have the same energy level.

1101
01:16:48.602 --> 01:16:54.507
And pretty soon, even in the 1930s, using visible light, people had figured out something was up, right?

1102
01:16:55.087 --> 01:16:57.249
It took Willis Lamb to actually measure that thing.

1103
01:16:57.309 --> 01:16:59.991
And there's a very famous, there's a very famous

1104
01:17:01.630 --> 01:17:02.891
interview by Hans Bethe.

1105
01:17:03.391 --> 01:17:05.193
I think it's either by Hans... No, yeah.

1106
01:17:05.473 --> 01:17:13.359
It's a very famous interview by Hans Bethe who said everyone knew that it was there, but until Lam measured it, we were just kind of like...

1107
01:17:13.759 --> 01:17:15.801
It was a coffee conversation.

1108
01:17:16.121 --> 01:17:18.883
It was like, oh, that's kind of interesting.

1109
01:17:18.923 --> 01:17:20.885
And then Lam put a number on it.

1110
01:17:21.265 --> 01:17:22.426
He's like, this is the number.

1111
01:17:22.466 --> 01:17:24.788
This is the shift between those two energy levels.

1112
01:17:25.168 --> 01:17:28.751
And all of a sudden it became a real thing that the theorists were like, okay...

1113
01:17:29.562 --> 01:17:34.463
So now there's a number that I can chase, right, to try and understand what's going on.

1114
01:17:35.044 --> 01:17:43.486
We already knew that no one was surprised that the lamp shift existed, but measuring it was important, right?

1115
01:17:43.806 --> 01:17:46.927
Because it falsifies several theories and it gives room to...

1116
01:17:47.240 --> 01:17:50.422
for theorists to actually propose new theories.

1117
01:17:50.782 --> 01:17:51.962
Same thing happened with the Higgs.

1118
01:17:52.423 --> 01:17:58.546
The Higgs is something that we knew to exist for a very long time, 40 or 50 years since Peter Higgs wrote that paper.

1119
01:17:59.866 --> 01:18:02.368
Measuring its mass is something else.

1120
01:18:02.568 --> 01:18:03.488
We still built CERN.

1121
01:18:03.648 --> 01:18:05.829
Yeah, we still built CERN to measure the mass.

1122
01:18:05.869 --> 01:18:09.551
And I'm sure Sabina Hossenvelder is going to say that CERN is a waste of time too.

1123
01:18:09.591 --> 01:18:12.653
So she's got her opinions, but I would like to say that

1124
01:18:14.776 --> 01:18:20.739
LAM did it with microwaves, even though the visible spectrum people had said that it might not exist.

1125
01:18:21.039 --> 01:18:22.640
I mean, sorry, that it definitely exists.

1126
01:18:22.900 --> 01:18:26.221
And that led to the revolution of QED and quantum field theory.

1127
01:18:26.942 --> 01:18:28.542
That's how we have atomic clocks.

1128
01:18:28.762 --> 01:18:30.303
That's how we have GPS.

1129
01:18:30.463 --> 01:18:31.404
I mean, come on.

1130
01:18:31.464 --> 01:18:32.284
It's pretty nice, right?

1131
01:18:32.644 --> 01:18:38.367
So similarly, in the case of IceCube, observing neutrinos...

1132
01:18:39.202 --> 01:18:44.008
And finding the distribution of the neutrinos, the power distribution, right?

1133
01:18:44.148 --> 01:18:51.917
Of like, not only, yeah, in the case that we just reviewed, which is the flavors of the neutrinos that are coming through, but also the power distribution.

1134
01:18:52.077 --> 01:18:52.197
Yeah.

1135
01:18:52.217 --> 01:18:55.261
Like, how often do I see a neutrino of a certain power?

1136
01:18:55.281 --> 01:18:55.541
Right.

1137
01:18:55.642 --> 01:18:57.724
That is going to constrain the...

1138
01:18:58.686 --> 01:19:05.435
physics, that is going to constrain the physics of the sources and also constrain the physics of the particles themselves.

1139
01:19:05.836 --> 01:19:08.800
That's going to tell us more about neutrinos in general.

1140
01:19:09.380 --> 01:19:14.547
And who knows, at some point in the vast future, it might lead to...

1141
01:19:15.248 --> 01:19:16.970
Things that we can't even dream about.

1142
01:19:17.030 --> 01:19:19.091
This is what we just talked about with optogenetics.

1143
01:19:19.191 --> 01:19:22.894
Optogenetics started with someone looking at how light and algae.

1144
01:19:23.655 --> 01:19:25.717
And now we're solving vision.

1145
01:19:25.857 --> 01:19:26.057
Yeah.

1146
01:19:26.257 --> 01:19:30.120
And understand how to control, to activate neurons in the brain.

1147
01:19:30.220 --> 01:19:30.401
Yeah.

1148
01:19:30.761 --> 01:19:33.843
And so you can't always know where this goes.

1149
01:19:33.863 --> 01:19:34.044
Yeah.

1150
01:19:34.304 --> 01:19:39.268
And I think physics has been, you know, physics has had the luxury over the past century or two centuries of,

1151
01:19:39.728 --> 01:19:58.822
of almost having like an immediate effect on economics right it's like we discover the nucleus on the like 20 years later we build a bomb and it's like dope like yo and so and so hold on hold on i don't want to be careful there's a difference between the scientific process of the bomb

1152
01:19:59.222 --> 01:20:01.023
And the lived experience, just to be clear.

1153
01:20:01.063 --> 01:20:01.803
Yeah, just to be clear.

1154
01:20:01.863 --> 01:20:02.603
Just to be clear.

1155
01:20:02.623 --> 01:20:03.584
Yeah, we split the atom.

1156
01:20:03.624 --> 01:20:05.944
Now we have nuclear fission technology, right?

1157
01:20:06.244 --> 01:20:09.606
We have unlimited power in some sense, right?

1158
01:20:09.986 --> 01:20:12.607
We have radioactive carbon dating.

1159
01:20:12.727 --> 01:20:14.267
We have radiology for cancer.

1160
01:20:14.447 --> 01:20:16.368
We have all of these technologies, right?

1161
01:20:16.388 --> 01:20:19.709
With the quantum mechanics stuff, like 1920s, we had quantum mechanics.

1162
01:20:20.129 --> 01:20:25.211
Like 20 or 30 years later, we're inventing the transistor and superconductivity and all this other stuff.

1163
01:20:25.231 --> 01:20:26.611
And we have phones and supercomputers, all this stuff.

1164
01:20:26.651 --> 01:20:26.811
Right?

1165
01:20:26.892 --> 01:20:27.832
It's like very quick.

1166
01:20:28.633 --> 01:20:35.142
But that's because we've lived in an energy regime where the physics is right there for us.

1167
01:20:35.182 --> 01:20:35.923
It's right there.

1168
01:20:35.943 --> 01:20:36.504
Just touch it.

1169
01:20:36.744 --> 01:20:37.465
You could just touch it.

1170
01:20:37.505 --> 01:20:44.214
You could just tune up the voltage and all of a sudden new physics is happening in front of me, right?

1171
01:20:44.254 --> 01:20:45.616
We've kind of spent...

1172
01:20:46.952 --> 01:21:08.340
our tokens yeah okay and now now we need we need the big models you know in some sense like and so yeah like the progress is going to be a little bit slower because the questions we're starting to ask now require a lot higher energy and a lot more time and a lot more work but that doesn't mean that it's not worth it

1173
01:21:09.858 --> 01:21:16.045
You know, I want to ask a stupid question under that same construction.

1174
01:21:17.006 --> 01:21:18.087
That's the bean is put forth.

1175
01:21:18.267 --> 01:21:18.527
Yeah.

1176
01:21:19.048 --> 01:21:20.930
I want to talk about string theorists.

1177
01:21:21.070 --> 01:21:21.390
Okay.

1178
01:21:22.291 --> 01:21:23.673
She hates string theory.

1179
01:21:23.753 --> 01:21:26.155
You know, they're like, oh, we the thing works.

1180
01:21:26.215 --> 01:21:27.176
It makes predictions.

1181
01:21:27.196 --> 01:21:27.677
Yeah.

1182
01:21:27.817 --> 01:21:30.700
But there would obviously be, but it can't be experimentally tested.

1183
01:21:30.800 --> 01:21:31.221
Yeah.

1184
01:21:31.261 --> 01:21:32.062
No, it's not yet.

1185
01:21:32.142 --> 01:21:32.502
Not yet.

1186
01:21:32.922 --> 01:21:42.112
And so, you know, wouldn't it be fundamentally different between where the string theorists are now, where it can make predictions, versus some experimental...

1187
01:21:43.932 --> 01:22:06.372
detection yeah i think i think i think that's a that's a very good and relevant question as the as a similar kind of analogy because it's basically saying you're saying oh the string theorists already figured it out no you just measured it and it's like well that's a very big difference right it is a very big difference i mean so there there's some there's something to be said about maybe the over exposure right

1188
01:22:06.942 --> 01:22:11.785
of the theoretical physics granting initiatives.

1189
01:22:11.845 --> 01:22:12.106
Yes.

1190
01:22:12.326 --> 01:22:14.487
And let's say string theory.

1191
01:22:14.547 --> 01:22:15.548
Which, yes.

1192
01:22:15.588 --> 01:22:16.308
Maybe that's true.

1193
01:22:16.328 --> 01:22:19.591
I mean, I'm sure that, I think string theory should get funded.

1194
01:22:19.891 --> 01:22:30.078
And actually in the advent of AI solving math problems, like string theory should in some sense get cheaper because you can just like ask, because it's like pure math in some sense.

1195
01:22:30.138 --> 01:22:33.320
And you can just ask AI to solve some of the string theory problems.

1196
01:22:33.460 --> 01:22:36.942
It shouldn't take all the oxygen in the room, which is what a lot of people in the physics community complain about.

1197
01:22:36.962 --> 01:22:40.024
It's become the – it just absorbs.

1198
01:22:40.084 --> 01:22:42.906
It's just like this black hole, a funding black hole.

1199
01:22:43.186 --> 01:22:43.947
And it's like, okay.

1200
01:22:44.107 --> 01:22:47.409
Yeah, but also I've been looking more into it.

1201
01:22:47.629 --> 01:22:48.130
Oh, ooh.

1202
01:22:48.290 --> 01:22:53.373
And it seems that like a lot of the noise against string theory are by –

1203
01:22:54.915 --> 01:23:00.277
The types that don't actually have an in on the physics community at large in the first place.

1204
01:23:00.297 --> 01:23:00.658
That's fair.

1205
01:23:00.678 --> 01:23:01.038
Right?

1206
01:23:01.398 --> 01:23:08.681
Like, there is a truth to it that, like, the string theory community has maybe an outsized role in...

1207
01:23:08.781 --> 01:23:09.342
The cabal.

1208
01:23:09.562 --> 01:23:10.482
Yeah, in the cabal.

1209
01:23:10.802 --> 01:23:13.924
But it's not nearly the extent that, like, is...

1210
01:23:14.948 --> 01:23:17.989
reported in the popular zeitgeist, right?

1211
01:23:18.129 --> 01:23:20.911
It's not like... Because, like, there are quantum gravity...

1212
01:23:20.951 --> 01:23:22.371
There's, like, the loop quantum gravity.

1213
01:23:22.632 --> 01:23:27.294
That's a big initiative that, like, a lot of people are getting money for to explore.

1214
01:23:27.314 --> 01:23:32.476
There's other ways to do grand unified things, right?

1215
01:23:32.556 --> 01:23:34.117
So, yeah, it's...

1216
01:23:36.155 --> 01:23:47.338
I see where you're coming from, and I do think that there's a healthy tension that should happen between the theoretical physics community and the experimental physics community in terms of like you've got to give us stuff to test.

1217
01:23:47.398 --> 01:23:53.740
And the experimental community also has to find experiments that will push the theorists.

1218
01:23:53.840 --> 01:23:55.020
And Ice Cube is one of those.

1219
01:23:55.080 --> 01:23:56.761
It's a perfect example.

1220
01:23:56.901 --> 01:24:01.582
And I think the point I'm trying to land the plane on here is like –

1221
01:24:02.502 --> 01:24:12.126
The experimentalists have a role to play, even if the theorists have arrived at a conclusion prior to the experimentalists being able to show it in lived experience.

1222
01:24:12.166 --> 01:24:12.727
Yeah, yeah.

1223
01:24:12.847 --> 01:24:19.530
And the experimentalists, like experimental physics has a role.

1224
01:24:20.110 --> 01:24:21.731
So what am I trying to say?

1225
01:24:21.771 --> 01:24:24.632
So experimental physicists, they've got...

1226
01:24:26.205 --> 01:24:30.407
An obligation in some sense to just push the frontier at all times.

1227
01:24:30.787 --> 01:24:31.047
Okay.

1228
01:24:31.347 --> 01:24:37.810
When the muon was discovered, there was no theorist that had that on the radar.

1229
01:24:37.850 --> 01:24:38.170
Aha.

1230
01:24:38.470 --> 01:24:38.770
Okay.

1231
01:24:39.030 --> 01:24:41.811
When the muon was discovered, I think it was Wolf.

1232
01:24:41.971 --> 01:24:42.852
No, it was Robbie.

1233
01:24:43.612 --> 01:24:43.992
Oh, yeah.

1234
01:24:44.012 --> 01:24:45.573
It was Robbie who was like, who ordered that?

1235
01:24:46.193 --> 01:24:47.714
Because it didn't make any sense.

1236
01:24:48.214 --> 01:24:48.414
Right.

1237
01:24:48.534 --> 01:24:50.455
We're sitting very nicely.

1238
01:24:50.495 --> 01:24:51.415
We've got the quark.

1239
01:24:51.435 --> 01:24:52.736
We've got the up and the down.

1240
01:24:52.756 --> 01:24:53.976
We've got the electron.

1241
01:24:53.996 --> 01:24:55.657
We've got this nice generation of stuff.

1242
01:24:55.913 --> 01:25:01.675
We even have the neutrino from Pauli being like, you know, let's just do the bookkeeping and make sure the energy is conserved.

1243
01:25:02.035 --> 01:25:05.696
All of a sudden the muon shows up and it's a parallel universe.

1244
01:25:06.116 --> 01:25:09.057
And then the tau shows up and it's another parallel universe.

1245
01:25:10.158 --> 01:25:13.119
We still don't have an answer to those three generations of matter, right?

1246
01:25:13.699 --> 01:25:19.421
But that happened because experimentalists were just pushing the envelope on the types of particles that they could see, right?

1247
01:25:19.441 --> 01:25:23.062
The theorists didn't even have it on their radar that something like this could exist.

1248
01:25:23.082 --> 01:25:23.462
Mm-hmm.

1249
01:25:24.353 --> 01:25:33.640
So experimentalists have an obligation to just keep pushing the envelope on the more and more sensitive the experiments can get, the more and more the parameter sweeps that we can see.

1250
01:25:34.761 --> 01:25:37.163
It's always going to be good for humanity at large.

1251
01:25:38.647 --> 01:25:43.411
My favorite – I think my favorite physical physics experiment continues to be LIGO.

1252
01:25:43.492 --> 01:25:45.133
But that is a previous episode.

1253
01:25:45.954 --> 01:25:49.637
So if you want to know about LIGO, gravitational wave detector.

1254
01:25:50.178 --> 01:25:54.201
And was it the graduate students or postdocs that were driving?

1255
01:25:54.221 --> 01:25:54.382
Yeah.

1256
01:25:54.402 --> 01:25:54.502
Yeah.

1257
01:25:55.158 --> 01:25:58.500
They were driving at the same time as the detection.

1258
01:25:59.041 --> 01:26:00.141
And great story.

1259
01:26:00.161 --> 01:26:02.143
No, like an hour before.

1260
01:26:02.543 --> 01:26:04.424
The PIs were frantically calling them.

1261
01:26:06.105 --> 01:26:07.226
Unbelievable story.

1262
01:26:08.287 --> 01:26:12.649
In any event, that concludes, that was a large digression, but I think an important kind.

1263
01:26:12.890 --> 01:26:13.690
This is a discussion.

1264
01:26:13.970 --> 01:26:15.271
And it's fun and it's healthy.

1265
01:26:15.591 --> 01:26:21.375
One of the things I think I love about our community and FFP nation, we have the smartest comments section on the internet.

1266
01:26:21.435 --> 01:26:23.056
Yes, we really do.

1267
01:26:23.096 --> 01:26:24.137
And I don't think it's close.

1268
01:26:24.497 --> 01:26:27.198
If you think you have a better one, please try.

1269
01:26:27.258 --> 01:26:32.180
Every time we talk about something, there's always like at least five people who are like, oh, yeah, that's my PhD.

1270
01:26:32.600 --> 01:26:34.500
It's unbelievable.

1271
01:26:34.600 --> 01:26:42.623
And shout out to all the folks who are hard at work here in the comments sharing because it makes us feel very nice.

1272
01:26:43.143 --> 01:26:43.544
Very nice.

1273
01:26:43.564 --> 01:26:44.345
Yeah, it really does.

1274
01:26:44.745 --> 01:26:50.953
We will end with our chemistry recap and breeze through this.

1275
01:26:51.413 --> 01:26:54.117
Again, this is a recap episode, so we're trying to have a little bit of fun here.

1276
01:26:54.157 --> 01:26:54.257
Yeah.

1277
01:26:54.397 --> 01:26:58.262
Not going too deep, but let's start with – let's end with, I should say, chemistry.

1278
01:26:59.002 --> 01:27:09.531
The chemistry prize recognizes Henri Kagan and Kenzo Soai for nonlinear effects and autocatalysis in asymmetric organic synthesis.

1279
01:27:09.691 --> 01:27:15.475
Asymmetric in the sense that chemistry has a handedness and it cares about the handedness.

1280
01:27:15.515 --> 01:27:16.776
It cares about mirror images.

1281
01:27:17.156 --> 01:27:22.561
The theme was how reactions can produce an excess of one mirror image form.

1282
01:27:23.401 --> 01:27:28.165
And in suitable systems, it can amplify that small handedness imbalance.

1283
01:27:29.492 --> 01:27:33.035
The central property that we're talking about here is chirality.

1284
01:27:33.355 --> 01:27:38.338
Chirality is a geometric property of 3D molecules.

1285
01:27:39.199 --> 01:27:45.744
Two mirror images, they're different in the sense that the bonds are exactly the same.

1286
01:27:46.244 --> 01:27:47.865
The atoms are exactly the same.

1287
01:27:48.706 --> 01:27:55.150
But the arrangements of them in 3D are exactly mirror flipped in one direction.

1288
01:27:55.611 --> 01:27:57.272
Okay, and these are called enantiomers.

1289
01:27:58.365 --> 01:28:02.946
Here we're looking at two examples of L-alanine and D-alanine.

1290
01:28:02.986 --> 01:28:06.467
These are two enantiomers of the amino acid alanine.

1291
01:28:07.007 --> 01:28:11.028
Same exact molecular formula, but the 3D structures are flipped.

1292
01:28:11.408 --> 01:28:17.949
Now, for unbiased synthesis in a symmetric environment, there's no obvious reason to prefer one over the other.

1293
01:28:18.289 --> 01:28:21.750
But life, for some reason, biology, strikingly,

1294
01:28:22.330 --> 01:28:27.034
uses a consistent handedness for every single molecular species.

1295
01:28:27.735 --> 01:28:34.500
All of the amino acids that could be chiral are always in their left-handed versions in life.

1296
01:28:34.941 --> 01:28:37.843
All of the sugars that could be chiral are in their right-handed version.

1297
01:28:38.424 --> 01:28:40.125
And the prize-winning work,

1298
01:28:40.425 --> 01:28:49.930
this year demonstrates that there's chemical mechanisms through which you can establish an imbalance, and then that imbalance can become a lot larger than it was previously.

1299
01:28:50.590 --> 01:28:56.213
And perhaps it is a way in which you can achieve homochirality from an initially

1300
01:28:57.350 --> 01:29:00.631
you know, sort of balanced environment.

1301
01:29:00.671 --> 01:29:02.232
Like an unbiased initial condition.

1302
01:29:02.312 --> 01:29:03.172
Yeah, exactly.

1303
01:29:04.153 --> 01:29:09.895
Now, before we talk about biological homochirality and the historical origin and all that... You know, light conversation.

1304
01:29:09.975 --> 01:29:10.195
Yeah.

1305
01:29:10.655 --> 01:29:17.398
Before we talk about all that, I do want to do some very light conversation and recap some of the whirlwind...

1306
01:29:18.098 --> 01:29:20.920
The whirlwind of events that happened the morning of Wednesday.

1307
01:29:21.160 --> 01:29:27.565
I just want to preface this for those who might be podcast listeners or audio and video listeners, but don't follow us on socials.

1308
01:29:27.865 --> 01:29:29.006
Yeah, this was crazy.

1309
01:29:29.046 --> 01:29:31.928
This purely happened in the social media.

1310
01:29:32.009 --> 01:29:33.390
On Instagram, really.

1311
01:29:33.470 --> 01:29:34.450
It was all Instagram.

1312
01:29:34.731 --> 01:29:36.432
And so there's a whole universe.

1313
01:29:36.902 --> 01:29:40.886
of FFP that happens on the socials, particularly Instagram.

1314
01:29:40.906 --> 01:29:44.909
So if you don't follow there, this is a very good reason to follow.

1315
01:29:44.929 --> 01:29:45.430
Sorry, please.

1316
01:29:45.450 --> 01:29:46.731
This is crazy.

1317
01:29:46.911 --> 01:29:53.978
So usually with our Nobel coverage, we wake up 15 minutes before the prize and we're watching it live.

1318
01:29:54.984 --> 01:29:58.866
the press conference, 2.45 a.m., the Nobel Committee announces the prize.

1319
01:29:59.306 --> 01:30:05.028
And as soon as the prize is announced, we're like, okay, my predictions didn't work, but oh well.

1320
01:30:05.408 --> 01:30:09.170
I get to devouring their popular information and their scientific background.

1321
01:30:09.450 --> 01:30:23.036
So the Nobel Committee puts out this PDF of popular information and for scientific background, presumably for journalists like me and Lester to sort of understand and create content out of.

1322
01:30:23.056 --> 01:30:23.456
Okay.

1323
01:30:23.476 --> 01:30:23.656
Okay.

1324
01:30:24.416 --> 01:30:29.982
I noticed that in one of the SOI reaction visuals in the popular information, there might have been a mistake.

1325
01:30:30.282 --> 01:30:37.029
Specifically, they had two versions, the two enantiomers of a particular intermediate in the reaction.

1326
01:30:37.450 --> 01:30:42.355
The left version had a dotted link to a zinc-oxygen pair.

1327
01:30:43.345 --> 01:30:47.348
And the right version had the whole thing flipped, but the thing wasn't dotted.

1328
01:30:47.688 --> 01:30:48.628
It was a solid line.

1329
01:30:49.349 --> 01:30:53.952
And I thought, you know, that thing should be dotted because you've already flipped it, so it should probably be dotted.

1330
01:30:54.552 --> 01:30:56.553
I asked ChatGBT, actually, and it said it was fine.

1331
01:30:56.573 --> 01:31:01.136
And then I went through the logic, my own logic, of, like, it should be dotted because it's, like, flipped or whatever.

1332
01:31:01.156 --> 01:31:03.758
And then it, like, spent some time and it was like, oh, yeah, you're right.

1333
01:31:04.118 --> 01:31:04.819
But then I was like...

1334
01:31:05.299 --> 01:31:10.047
You know, I'm still doubting it because it's like, okay, is ChatGPT just telling me I'm right because I am right?

1335
01:31:10.127 --> 01:31:11.690
It's like being sycophantic.

1336
01:31:11.750 --> 01:31:11.951
Right.

1337
01:31:12.171 --> 01:31:12.371
Right?

1338
01:31:12.852 --> 01:31:16.038
So we get to the podcast recording.

1339
01:31:16.058 --> 01:31:16.178
Right.

1340
01:31:17.712 --> 01:31:19.993
And I'm still, like, wondering if I'm right or wrong.

1341
01:31:20.033 --> 01:31:22.735
But I go off on a limb and say, I think I made a mistake.

1342
01:31:23.435 --> 01:31:24.996
We post it on Instagram.

1343
01:31:25.156 --> 01:31:28.738
Mind you, this is five hours after it was announced.

1344
01:31:28.758 --> 01:31:30.880
Yeah, this is five hours after it's announced.

1345
01:31:31.060 --> 01:31:34.202
I mean, I should have really called up some of my chemistry friends.

1346
01:31:34.262 --> 01:31:41.066
But, you know, I'm not going to wake them up at, like, 6 a.m. Be like, hey, can you check this enantiomer for me?

1347
01:31:41.226 --> 01:31:41.406
And...

1348
01:31:43.348 --> 01:31:46.209
They'll be like, I'm deleting you from my contacts.

1349
01:31:46.569 --> 01:31:50.970
So we talk about it on the podcast.

1350
01:31:51.130 --> 01:31:52.510
We post it on Instagram.

1351
01:31:53.390 --> 01:31:54.671
It gets a lot of traction.

1352
01:31:55.031 --> 01:31:58.291
There's a lot of chemists in the audience saying that I am actually right.

1353
01:31:58.331 --> 01:32:05.013
And they notice another mistake, which is that the flipped version was actually...

1354
01:32:06.083 --> 01:32:09.526
it was connected to the isopropyl group in the right version.

1355
01:32:09.566 --> 01:32:11.428
On the left, it's connected to the oxygen.

1356
01:32:11.748 --> 01:32:18.395
It should be connected to the oxygen because the oxygen has two bonds, one to the carbon ring, one to the rest of the zinc isopropyl thing, right?

1357
01:32:18.455 --> 01:32:21.818
But the isopropyl doesn't have any bonds left to go to the carbon.

1358
01:32:21.838 --> 01:32:22.679
It doesn't make any sense.

1359
01:32:22.979 --> 01:32:27.864
So the chemist, the actual organic chemist in the audience, actually noticed that.

1360
01:32:28.124 --> 01:32:29.946
There are several organic chemist...

1361
01:32:30.751 --> 01:32:41.635
teachers in the audience who are just, you know, they fulfill the stereotypical organic chemistry teacher of just being like masochists.

1362
01:32:41.715 --> 01:32:45.437
And they're like, this is a great test problem.

1363
01:32:45.917 --> 01:32:47.458
This is a great homework problem.

1364
01:32:47.478 --> 01:32:51.979
To all the undergrads who are going to get this as a problem in the future, apologies in advance.

1365
01:32:52.019 --> 01:32:55.981
Yeah, I pity your students like I pitied myself when I was in Orgo.

1366
01:32:56.461 --> 01:32:57.482
God, that...

1367
01:32:58.862 --> 01:33:00.004
Yeah, you guys are all the same.

1368
01:33:00.324 --> 01:33:03.528
All of the Orgo teachers are all the same.

1369
01:33:03.808 --> 01:33:12.017
In any case, so the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, they actually responded.

1370
01:33:12.238 --> 01:33:12.498
Yes.

1371
01:33:12.978 --> 01:33:13.699
To our...

1372
01:33:13.719 --> 01:33:13.799
Yes.

1373
01:33:13.839 --> 01:33:14.040
Yes.

1374
01:33:15.332 --> 01:33:15.772
Video.

1375
01:33:16.433 --> 01:33:27.261
On Instagram, they posted a photo of the Futurama scientist, and they said, dear FFP pod, we are very glad that you like the material and find it useful.

1376
01:33:27.301 --> 01:33:29.042
We certainly do like the material.

1377
01:33:29.222 --> 01:33:35.107
The popular information and the scientific background is essential for getting me the...

1378
01:33:35.827 --> 01:33:39.870
the background that I need to like do this episode in five hours.

1379
01:33:40.270 --> 01:33:40.471
Right.

1380
01:33:40.531 --> 01:33:43.453
So yeah, they said, thank you for reading it so carefully.

1381
01:33:43.973 --> 01:33:44.554
Good catch.

1382
01:33:44.974 --> 01:33:48.597
You are certainly correct about the error in figure six, which has been now corrected.

1383
01:33:48.917 --> 01:33:51.339
We have posted the updated version on our website.

1384
01:33:52.426 --> 01:34:01.349
And the updated version has not only the dotted line, which I noticed, but also the oxygen getting flipped, which means that they actually read our comments.

1385
01:34:01.830 --> 01:34:10.573
So FFP Nation, you have impact on what is being decided in terms of the public information, the popular information.

1386
01:34:10.993 --> 01:34:12.094
from the Nobel Prize Committee.

1387
01:34:12.154 --> 01:34:13.515
Yeah, absolutely insane.

1388
01:34:13.535 --> 01:34:17.899
By the way, this is already, like, something that I never could have imagined.

1389
01:34:18.079 --> 01:34:18.860
This is ridiculous.

1390
01:34:18.900 --> 01:34:27.507
This is ridiculous that, like, the Royal Academy of Sciences in Sweden, the guys who were in charge of giving the physics and the chemistry Nobel Prize

1391
01:34:28.408 --> 01:34:47.174
and disseminating the information about them are actually responding to us and like we caught an error and they're like they're gracious enough and true scientists exactly like be like yeah you know what that's a mistake we're gonna correct it and so yeah i'm freaking out you're freaking out we're both like okay what do we do what do we do we like wake up the next day or whatever it's like what's happening

1392
01:34:47.334 --> 01:34:54.416
Yeah, so we're like, okay, well, and then I'm like, okay, I'll make a response video in my bedroom, right?

1393
01:34:54.776 --> 01:34:57.637
So, because we didn't have a plan.

1394
01:34:57.877 --> 01:34:58.097
Right.

1395
01:34:58.537 --> 01:35:02.098
It was like, once chemistry is done, it's like, I want to take the week off.

1396
01:35:02.118 --> 01:35:02.578
Yeah, right.

1397
01:35:02.598 --> 01:35:04.299
We were supposed to be on vacation until today.

1398
01:35:04.399 --> 01:35:08.220
And then this happened, so I'm like, okay, I'll make a video at my desk.

1399
01:35:08.380 --> 01:35:08.700
Yeah.

1400
01:35:09.913 --> 01:35:21.258
We make a quick reply video, and at the end of the whole thing, I do a cheeky, like, you know, if you guys are interested in a podcast covering the Nobel Prizes, like, we're... We're available.

1401
01:35:21.298 --> 01:35:22.218
We're available.

1402
01:35:22.238 --> 01:35:28.161
And the Royal Academy of Sciences in Sweden, they respond.

1403
01:35:28.201 --> 01:35:32.802
They say, dear Krishna and Lester, you are both very welcome to Stockholm in 2027.

1404
01:35:33.163 --> 01:35:38.565
I've passed your email addresses on to our press officer, who will send you a reminder when press accreditation...

1405
01:35:39.105 --> 01:35:46.107
accreditation when press accreditation opens in early september hope to see you then yes uh yes

1406
01:35:47.137 --> 01:35:49.039
How about yes?

1407
01:35:49.359 --> 01:35:55.625
And my comment with our podcast account is literally, wait, I can't believe that worked.

1408
01:35:55.845 --> 01:36:06.455
It's so – there's so many things that are so incredible about this because for those of you who have been with us for a long time, the original construction for the show was this idea of we're trying to build an ESPN for science.

1409
01:36:06.935 --> 01:36:10.879
And so many comments on our Nobel coverage independent of this were like –

1410
01:36:11.539 --> 01:36:19.563
It would be incredible if you guys could be there like it's the NFL and do reporting the way ESPN does it.

1411
01:36:20.103 --> 01:36:23.605
And it's literally now manifested itself in real time.

1412
01:36:23.625 --> 01:36:34.691
I want to make one last reference to this because, again, it's incredibly humbling and we're incredibly gracious to the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences for –

1413
01:36:35.765 --> 01:36:36.705
Even engaging with it.

1414
01:36:36.925 --> 01:36:37.806
Yeah, yeah.

1415
01:36:37.846 --> 01:36:53.731
Like even – You know, like that's – And it's a testament to what the scientific community is about, which is it's a collaborative search for the truth and the right answer without ego, which we can all participate in, including you in the comments.

1416
01:36:54.391 --> 01:37:02.054
A funny added tidbit was the American Chemical Society, which is like the trade organization –

1417
01:37:02.454 --> 01:37:07.766
or chemists, has a publication called Chemical and Engineering News.

1418
01:37:08.567 --> 01:37:10.632
And this was now a few days after this.

1419
01:37:11.741 --> 01:37:24.125
It came up in our Instagram feed where the title of the article, which unfortunately we don't have an overlay for, was something to the effect of, you know, we think there was a mistake in the chemistry Nobel.

1420
01:37:24.425 --> 01:37:26.285
And it looks like some – oh, go ahead.

1421
01:37:26.365 --> 01:37:27.246
It was editorial.

1422
01:37:27.606 --> 01:37:30.706
How many chemists does it take to check a stereo center?

1423
01:37:31.107 --> 01:37:35.788
The 2026 Nobel announcement sparked a frenzy of chirality fact-checking.

1424
01:37:36.208 --> 01:37:39.509
Turns out nailing stereochemistry is tough for everyone.

1425
01:37:39.749 --> 01:37:43.591
Yeah, and I sent you the screenshot, and I'm like, is this movie about us?

1426
01:37:44.231 --> 01:37:49.434
And then midway through the article, they had been looking at this similarly to how you were in the early morning.

1427
01:37:49.734 --> 01:37:55.417
And then someone on their team frequents Instagram and was like, look, guys, we're not the only one.

1428
01:37:55.437 --> 01:37:58.058
And by that time, it had gone super viral already.

1429
01:37:58.218 --> 01:38:00.019
And I actually read the article.

1430
01:38:00.359 --> 01:38:06.142
They noticed discrepancy in the stereochemistry illustrations in the press conference.

1431
01:38:06.162 --> 01:38:08.883
Because the press conference, they have material in the back.

1432
01:38:09.290 --> 01:38:13.795
And some of the versions of the molecules there had, because stereochemistry is very difficult.

1433
01:38:13.895 --> 01:38:20.322
And so then they mentioned that actually even in the popular information, we had noticed that there was a discrepancy.

1434
01:38:20.442 --> 01:38:25.688
So it's just shout out to all the chemists that chimed in.

1435
01:38:26.068 --> 01:38:26.969
Y'all are the goats.

1436
01:38:27.370 --> 01:38:29.192
This was a team victory.

1437
01:38:29.772 --> 01:38:32.314
It takes a village and you were part of that village.

1438
01:38:32.654 --> 01:38:41.838
And so when we're reporting live from Stockholm next year, we will be sure to have you all with us in our spirits.

1439
01:38:41.858 --> 01:38:52.104
And we're going to try to come up with some clever ideas to spice up what is otherwise a very understandably dry and academic endeavor.

1440
01:38:52.384 --> 01:38:55.305
So we'll try to find clever ways to make it exciting.

1441
01:38:55.566 --> 01:38:55.906
Anyway.

1442
01:38:56.564 --> 01:38:57.464
I'm excited about it.

1443
01:38:57.484 --> 01:38:58.205
I'm so excited.

1444
01:38:58.245 --> 01:38:58.465
Yeah.

1445
01:38:58.485 --> 01:39:01.246
I've already blocked out my calendar for that week.

1446
01:39:01.266 --> 01:39:02.907
I've only ever been to Sweden.

1447
01:39:02.927 --> 01:39:06.869
I've been to Sweden a few times, but it was to play football at the Gatia Cup in Gothenburg.

1448
01:39:06.969 --> 01:39:07.569
Wow.

1449
01:39:07.769 --> 01:39:08.730
Which is not Stockholm.

1450
01:39:08.750 --> 01:39:09.370
So I've never been.

1451
01:39:09.950 --> 01:39:11.011
And I was very young then.

1452
01:39:11.311 --> 01:39:13.012
And so I'm very excited to go as an adult.

1453
01:39:13.252 --> 01:39:13.552
Oh, dude.

1454
01:39:13.772 --> 01:39:14.272
I'm so excited.

1455
01:39:14.292 --> 01:39:18.554
And get some of that sort of Scandinavian humor that I hear so much about.

1456
01:39:18.574 --> 01:39:18.715
Yeah.

1457
01:39:18.855 --> 01:39:19.135
Yeah.

1458
01:39:19.255 --> 01:39:19.535
Anyway.

1459
01:39:20.035 --> 01:39:20.575
It's going to be good.

1460
01:39:21.296 --> 01:39:22.356
Not excited for the food, though.

1461
01:39:22.536 --> 01:39:23.697
But, you know.

1462
01:39:24.613 --> 01:39:27.635
Maybe I'll be wrong, but I haven't heard good things.

1463
01:39:27.656 --> 01:39:28.376
I'm going to be honest.

1464
01:39:28.396 --> 01:39:29.137
Surprise us.

1465
01:39:29.157 --> 01:39:29.737
Surprise us.

1466
01:39:29.777 --> 01:39:30.698
Put us on game, guys.

1467
01:39:31.238 --> 01:39:31.539
All right.

1468
01:39:31.639 --> 01:39:35.582
So the follow-up that I want to do for the chemistry Nobel Prize.

1469
01:39:37.110 --> 01:39:47.276
asks if we can measure the handedness that we were talking about, right, with stereochemistry, the idea that you have these mirror molecules and the idea that life is homochirality.

1470
01:39:47.377 --> 01:39:48.577
It's a single-handedness.

1471
01:39:49.158 --> 01:39:54.681
Well, can we measure chirality in the first place in very limited samples?

1472
01:39:55.682 --> 01:39:56.462
Why is that important?

1473
01:39:56.482 --> 01:40:05.628
Well, for the origin of life stuff, it's important because it's possible that life arose elsewhere and came to Earth on a meteorite.

1474
01:40:06.764 --> 01:40:11.528
And if the life on that meteorite, you know, if the sample size there, it's like a bottleneck effect.

1475
01:40:11.909 --> 01:40:23.318
If the sample size there is very, very small and the skew is one way versus the other, that could introduce the initial asymmetry that causes the asymmetry that we see today.

1476
01:40:23.518 --> 01:40:26.081
This is a very strong candidate for panspermia.

1477
01:40:26.321 --> 01:40:26.721
Exactly.

1478
01:40:26.741 --> 01:40:28.022
So panspermia is the idea.

1479
01:40:28.062 --> 01:40:29.423
How did life become homochiral?

1480
01:40:29.724 --> 01:40:34.788
Well, the idea is that a meteorite comes in from outer space and,

1481
01:40:35.607 --> 01:40:42.734
You have this racemic primordial soup, racemic meaning like both left and right-handed, doesn't matter which.

1482
01:40:43.194 --> 01:40:44.175
It's sort of an equal...

1483
01:40:46.205 --> 01:40:49.146
It's an equal proportion.

1484
01:40:49.606 --> 01:40:53.106
And then finally, you have mechanisms that create homochirality.

1485
01:40:53.146 --> 01:41:01.668
For example, ultraviolet radiation selects for one over the other, or a meteorite comes in and introduces a little bit of imbalance.

1486
01:41:02.028 --> 01:41:06.309
That causes homochirogenesis, which is what this Nobel Prize is about.

1487
01:41:06.409 --> 01:41:09.969
The idea of going from a racemic mixture of 50%, 50%, plus 0.0001%,

1488
01:41:13.651 --> 01:41:18.679
And then that's sort of taking over and becoming the homochirality landscape that we see today, right?

1489
01:41:19.079 --> 01:41:24.729
So a meteorite can contain amino acids without ever having contained life.

1490
01:41:26.211 --> 01:41:27.814
And their molecular handedness...

1491
01:41:28.576 --> 01:41:33.759
adds a clue to maybe how life on Earth arose and why it became homocryl.

1492
01:41:33.779 --> 01:41:34.319
That's the idea.

1493
01:41:34.639 --> 01:41:37.700
This October 2026 paper, again, just this year.

1494
01:41:37.720 --> 01:41:38.501
It's happening right now.

1495
01:41:38.821 --> 01:41:43.403
Just this year, just this month in Nature Communications on the 5th of October.

1496
01:41:43.483 --> 01:41:49.266
So like two days before the Chemistry Nobel Prize in chirality.

1497
01:41:49.306 --> 01:41:51.487
This is from Osaka University in Georgia Tech.

1498
01:41:52.147 --> 01:41:58.833
It examines an electrical discrimination technique for amino acid and anti-humors.

1499
01:41:58.893 --> 01:42:11.605
It's trying to say, if you were to give me a meteorite sample that has a very small number of amino acids, can I still give you a sense of what the anti-humor landscape is?

1500
01:42:11.625 --> 01:42:15.388
What the left versus right-handedness is on that meteorite.

1501
01:42:17.053 --> 01:42:17.493
Meteorite.

1502
01:42:17.933 --> 01:42:19.354
Now, why is this difficult?

1503
01:42:19.734 --> 01:42:34.680
Well, if the sample size is really, really small, it's going to be really hard to use conventional strategies, because conventional strategies involve, like, effectively doing a chemical reaction, some kind of mass spectrometry, and, like...

1504
01:42:36.395 --> 01:42:47.267
you do kind of a mass spectrometry liquid chromatography, which is the idea of taking a bunch of these samples and separating them by mass.

1505
01:42:47.587 --> 01:42:52.233
And then with liquid chromatography, you have them go through liquids

1506
01:42:53.276 --> 01:42:58.937
And the different types of enantiomers, the red and the left-handed, are going to go through that differently based on their little chemistry.

1507
01:42:59.257 --> 01:43:02.438
And that's going to tell you the mixture of left versus right.

1508
01:43:02.498 --> 01:43:06.139
But you need a lot of source material to pull that off.

1509
01:43:06.159 --> 01:43:07.539
Yeah, you need a lot of source material.

1510
01:43:07.559 --> 01:43:08.339
Which you can't do here.

1511
01:43:08.619 --> 01:43:08.759
Right.

1512
01:43:09.079 --> 01:43:14.280
So the researchers here, they're introducing this mechanically controllable break junction technique.

1513
01:43:14.640 --> 01:43:15.220
Here's the idea.

1514
01:43:15.481 --> 01:43:17.101
You've got a narrow goal junction.

1515
01:43:18.123 --> 01:43:20.944
that you break to create a kind of tunnel, okay?

1516
01:43:21.224 --> 01:43:26.866
And the separation of the two gold plates can be sort of adjusted.

1517
01:43:27.906 --> 01:43:33.848
You hook that up to electrodes, and the gap, you make kind of a molecular scale gap.

1518
01:43:34.948 --> 01:43:39.149
And then you let the samples go through that molecular scale gap.

1519
01:43:39.169 --> 01:43:40.110
This is so ridiculous.

1520
01:43:40.130 --> 01:43:40.370
Okay?

1521
01:43:41.210 --> 01:43:43.951
And what you're relying on are quantum tunneling effects.

1522
01:43:43.971 --> 01:43:44.371
Yes.

1523
01:43:44.391 --> 01:43:44.691
Okay?

1524
01:43:44.711 --> 01:43:44.931
Okay.

1525
01:43:46.082 --> 01:43:46.923
It's pretty insane.

1526
01:43:47.283 --> 01:43:49.645
The solution involves quantum tunneling.

1527
01:43:49.985 --> 01:43:50.866
Because here's what's happening.

1528
01:43:50.886 --> 01:43:51.987
You've got that gold gap.

1529
01:43:52.407 --> 01:43:53.548
The molecules go through.

1530
01:43:53.988 --> 01:44:00.393
And depending on whether they're left or right-handed, they're going to cause a current to go through that gap.

1531
01:44:00.573 --> 01:44:03.155
Because the current is going to quantum tunnel through.

1532
01:44:04.116 --> 01:44:05.837
It's not a classical effect here.

1533
01:44:05.877 --> 01:44:07.579
So how does quantum tunneling actually work?

1534
01:44:07.839 --> 01:44:09.400
Well, here's how it actually works.

1535
01:44:09.760 --> 01:44:10.000
So...

1536
01:44:11.201 --> 01:44:12.843
You've got these electrodes on two sides.

1537
01:44:13.304 --> 01:44:14.625
Extremely small gap.

1538
01:44:14.646 --> 01:44:17.489
You need an incredibly small gap.

1539
01:44:18.049 --> 01:44:27.901
And when whatever substrate goes through, whatever left-handed or right-handed enantiomer, if it's right in the middle and if it's left-handed, it's going to cause a current.

1540
01:44:27.921 --> 01:44:28.221
Mm-hmm.

1541
01:44:28.862 --> 01:44:30.763
And if it's not, then it's going to not cause a current.

1542
01:44:31.043 --> 01:44:36.265
And depending on the shape of that current, you should be able to tell if it's left or right-handed.

1543
01:44:36.585 --> 01:44:37.246
That's the idea.

1544
01:44:37.846 --> 01:44:46.009
The tunneling current is the signal with which we can detect the handedness when we look at quantum tunneling.

1545
01:44:46.029 --> 01:44:50.331
And it's so funny that macroscopic quantum tunneling won last year as the Nobel.

1546
01:44:50.391 --> 01:44:51.451
Yeah, in physics.

1547
01:44:51.531 --> 01:44:51.972
In physics.

1548
01:44:52.012 --> 01:44:54.753
It's just these things, again, the connections are just...

1549
01:44:55.393 --> 01:44:55.854
Exactly.

1550
01:44:56.674 --> 01:44:57.535
That's a good point, actually.

1551
01:44:57.555 --> 01:44:58.456
Yeah.

1552
01:44:58.496 --> 01:44:58.796
Anyway.

1553
01:44:59.456 --> 01:45:00.437
And so, all right.

1554
01:45:00.457 --> 01:45:01.939
So how do you actually do this in practice?

1555
01:45:01.979 --> 01:45:04.341
Well, they got a bunch of samples together.

1556
01:45:04.361 --> 01:45:08.104
They like built samples out of like, you know, make sure that they already knew.

1557
01:45:08.384 --> 01:45:12.667
They're like, okay, I'm going to put this amount of L alanine and this amount of D something.

1558
01:45:12.707 --> 01:45:12.908
Right.

1559
01:45:13.328 --> 01:45:21.735
And what they want to do is train machine learning model to discern between one type of an ant tumor and another.

1560
01:45:21.755 --> 01:45:21.875
Right.

1561
01:45:22.035 --> 01:45:25.637
This is where we're controlling now what's going to go through this gold apparatus.

1562
01:45:25.697 --> 01:45:25.917
Yeah.

1563
01:45:26.177 --> 01:45:27.818
Knowing what the hand-in-ness is.

1564
01:45:27.838 --> 01:45:29.198
Knowing what the ground truth is.

1565
01:45:29.418 --> 01:45:42.344
Before we put it in, because we want to test to see if this architecture and the hypothesis that the quantum tunneling and the tunneling current will trigger based on the hand-in-ness actually happens when we are controlling the input.

1566
01:45:42.484 --> 01:45:43.224
Yes, exactly.

1567
01:45:43.444 --> 01:45:47.686
Like, we want to make sure that, like, even in a controlled scenario, this actually works before testing it on...

1568
01:45:48.066 --> 01:45:49.948
Like actual meteorite stuff, right?

1569
01:45:50.008 --> 01:45:50.188
Yes.

1570
01:45:50.269 --> 01:45:52.371
And so this is how it actually works.

1571
01:45:52.451 --> 01:46:00.499
You make your mixture that's very prescribed, and you know what the signals look like, and then you train on your data.

1572
01:46:01.200 --> 01:46:05.244
And on the right-hand side, you see the actual versus the predicted.

1573
01:46:05.304 --> 01:46:06.265
The actual is 20, 20, 20.

1574
01:46:06.926 --> 01:46:10.128
There's five different versions of these amino acids.

1575
01:46:10.248 --> 01:46:10.909
It's quite close.

1576
01:46:11.189 --> 01:46:12.330
And it's pretty close, right?

1577
01:46:12.390 --> 01:46:14.091
It's getting you to 22, 15.

1578
01:46:14.531 --> 01:46:16.652
Like, it's not something that's crazy.

1579
01:46:17.173 --> 01:46:20.355
But again, this is the first iteration, and it's getting pretty close.

1580
01:46:20.655 --> 01:46:20.835
Right?

1581
01:46:21.175 --> 01:46:24.357
So the predicted versions, at least it's not missing anything.

1582
01:46:24.777 --> 01:46:28.240
It's not like, oh, there's none of this, when actually there's 20%.

1583
01:46:28.760 --> 01:46:33.023
I mean, only one of the five bands is a difference of five.

1584
01:46:33.083 --> 01:46:34.704
The other are effectively a difference of two.

1585
01:46:34.984 --> 01:46:36.805
Yeah, it's getting close.

1586
01:46:36.826 --> 01:46:38.967
And this is the first time that we're doing something like this, right?

1587
01:46:39.328 --> 01:46:41.369
Now, how does this do on real world samples?

1588
01:46:41.749 --> 01:46:44.332
Well, they got samples from two different meteorites.

1589
01:46:44.372 --> 01:46:52.498
There's one meteorite from the Diego de Almagoro in the Atacama Desert in Chile.

1590
01:46:52.778 --> 01:46:57.682
And then there's another one that's the Merchinson meteorite extract from Victoria, Australia.

1591
01:46:58.083 --> 01:47:00.545
These are two meteorites that had amino acids on them.

1592
01:47:01.292 --> 01:47:06.198
They took those samples and they tried to look at if it would actually work.

1593
01:47:07.139 --> 01:47:07.900
Didn't do so well.

1594
01:47:07.920 --> 01:47:08.361
Okay.

1595
01:47:08.481 --> 01:47:08.761
Okay.

1596
01:47:09.743 --> 01:47:13.788
On the x-axis is the stuff that we get from liquid chromatography.

1597
01:47:13.808 --> 01:47:13.928
Okay.

1598
01:47:15.345 --> 01:47:18.067
On the y-axis is the stuff that we get from this new method.

1599
01:47:18.628 --> 01:47:26.734
And if it's perfect agreement, everything should lie on the green dotted line in the diagonal, right?

1600
01:47:27.054 --> 01:47:28.696
But obviously it's not, right?

1601
01:47:29.056 --> 01:47:36.022
One thing that we do know for sure that's happening is that if there is an imbalance, the method tells you that there is an imbalance.

1602
01:47:36.222 --> 01:47:39.084
It's just doing an imbalance in the other direction almost.

1603
01:47:39.144 --> 01:47:40.285
It's like uncorrelated.

1604
01:47:40.865 --> 01:47:42.867
So you might say that it's kind of...

1605
01:47:44.647 --> 01:47:48.651
It's kind of surprising that this got into nature communications, given that it's a negative result.

1606
01:47:49.031 --> 01:47:53.255
But I still think it's kind of nice because it's the first time that we're doing something like this.

1607
01:47:53.295 --> 01:47:58.000
And I think that's what the editors really saw in this paper is like this is a challenging problem.

1608
01:47:59.645 --> 01:48:02.546
perhaps it requires more data to do the machine learning.

1609
01:48:02.626 --> 01:48:06.947
Perhaps it requires more careful analysis, so on and so forth.

1610
01:48:07.007 --> 01:48:13.109
But really these researchers, they're trying to distinguish mirror image molecules.

1611
01:48:13.169 --> 01:48:13.409
Yeah.

1612
01:48:13.689 --> 01:48:13.929
Right.

1613
01:48:14.009 --> 01:48:14.209
Yeah.

1614
01:48:14.269 --> 01:48:22.832
Which means it's again, the same atoms, the same mass, the same geometry, almost just flipped in one direction to another.

1615
01:48:23.172 --> 01:48:23.412
So,

1616
01:48:24.232 --> 01:48:27.714
The quantum tunneling effect is going to be very small.

1617
01:48:27.754 --> 01:48:28.095
Yeah.

1618
01:48:28.215 --> 01:48:31.677
The difference is going to be very small between a left-handed and a right-handed version.

1619
01:48:32.057 --> 01:48:32.918
But there's a chance.

1620
01:48:33.298 --> 01:48:35.839
You can clearly see that in the control experiment.

1621
01:48:36.420 --> 01:48:40.422
And now all we have to do is tweak the knobs.

1622
01:48:40.622 --> 01:48:41.603
It's a translation problem.

1623
01:48:41.623 --> 01:48:47.907
It's a translation problem to get to the actual kind of distributions that we would see on an actual meteorite.

1624
01:48:47.927 --> 01:48:49.348
This is going to get very important because...

1625
01:48:50.092 --> 01:48:50.852
Moving forward.

1626
01:48:51.012 --> 01:49:05.458
And there's a reason why Japan and America are collaborating on this, because we've covered the space missions that they are going to be pursuing in the near future, where they're trying to get samples of asteroids from Phobos on Mars.

1627
01:49:05.518 --> 01:49:05.738
Yes.

1628
01:49:05.858 --> 01:49:09.140
And from like these random asteroids in the asteroid belt.

1629
01:49:09.740 --> 01:49:11.820
And they're bringing back the samples, right?

1630
01:49:12.041 --> 01:49:19.302
Even these meteorites that they're talking about, the Merchinson and the Diego de Almogoro meteorite, those are the ones that have been contaminated by Earth.

1631
01:49:19.342 --> 01:49:24.483
You don't know if those amino acids are from the Earth somehow creeping in, right?

1632
01:49:24.883 --> 01:49:36.446
This is the Martian moons explorations, MMX, which we covered a few episodes back, which the target launch date is actually approaching.

1633
01:49:37.286 --> 01:49:37.967
in a few days.

1634
01:49:38.427 --> 01:49:39.167
Oh, very nice.

1635
01:49:39.507 --> 01:49:44.069
And it's, you know, it's arrival is scheduled for late 2027 on Mars.

1636
01:49:44.510 --> 01:49:47.611
And then the retrieval targeted for 2031.

1637
01:49:47.891 --> 01:49:49.892
We've already done this with an asteroid.

1638
01:49:50.012 --> 01:49:50.913
Yeah.

1639
01:49:50.933 --> 01:49:51.993
And returned the sample.

1640
01:49:52.273 --> 01:49:54.414
And so this is the scale up of that same idea.

1641
01:49:54.734 --> 01:50:00.017
The point being, we're going to be able, we now have the methodology to start to retrieve more of these things.

1642
01:50:00.417 --> 01:50:02.841
We know that meteorites can carry amino acids.

1643
01:50:02.981 --> 01:50:14.856
We might see other things as we get more of these from celestial bodies, both ones that are local to our solar system and ones that are coming in or traveling throughout our solar system.

1644
01:50:15.406 --> 01:50:23.190
Or if it's like a muamua that are interstellar objects, which is more difficult and there's challenges and timing and blah, blah, blah.

1645
01:50:23.210 --> 01:50:24.170
But next time we're going to be ready.

1646
01:50:24.190 --> 01:50:24.811
We're going to be ready.

1647
01:50:25.251 --> 01:50:26.652
We're going to be ready.

1648
01:50:27.152 --> 01:50:37.757
And it's so cool because I think the point about negative results getting published, I actually think is a good side note just to briefly touch on, which is I think they do matter a lot.

1649
01:50:38.457 --> 01:50:48.203
And my understanding is there's currently a skew where negative results proportionally are obviously not published as much as like I found the thing.

1650
01:50:49.363 --> 01:50:58.828
But there is, I think, benefit to encouraging people to take the effort to publish negative results because it is helping draw the path.

1651
01:51:02.190 --> 01:51:12.238
Um, and you know, especially for complex problems like this, we need to celebrate people taking the time and spending the money to do so, even if they didn't get the thing.

1652
01:51:12.438 --> 01:51:12.639
Yeah.

1653
01:51:12.999 --> 01:51:18.023
Um, and so I do think to your point, it is interesting that it did get published, but I think it matters.

1654
01:51:18.203 --> 01:51:19.324
Yeah, I think it does matter.

1655
01:51:19.404 --> 01:51:30.510
And I mean, it's the first step to an instrument that could tell us the enantiomer ratio, the left and right handed ratio on these meteorites, right?

1656
01:51:30.570 --> 01:51:32.971
And it could even like lead to a space instrument.

1657
01:51:33.191 --> 01:51:33.431
Yes.

1658
01:51:33.811 --> 01:51:35.392
Like on the International Space Station.

1659
01:51:35.412 --> 01:51:35.532
Yes.

1660
01:51:35.612 --> 01:51:36.533
Or like on these...

1661
01:51:37.193 --> 01:51:59.471
asteroid probes themselves right which can do it you know without having to bring it back yeah which would be uh fantastic i i think this brings us back to there was this sort of thought earlier around ice cube that i was kind of thinking about which is this whole question of why does this stuff matter how does it impact us and like with ice cube

1662
01:52:00.252 --> 01:52:18.004
The thing that it made me think about is, you know, two of like the most important questions that many people have, you know, particularly across cultures and across religious practices is, you know, where did we come from and what is our kind of purpose in life?

1663
01:52:18.024 --> 01:52:18.985
Like what is the purpose of life?

1664
01:52:19.045 --> 01:52:21.246
What is our place in the universe?

1665
01:52:21.346 --> 01:52:26.970
These are questions that are so important to billions of people, deeply important to billions of people on the planet.

1666
01:52:28.110 --> 01:52:43.215
And the through line both with Ice Cube and this like meteorite amino acid handedness detection concept kind of poke at the exact same question but in a way that's not through theology or philosophy.

1667
01:52:43.936 --> 01:52:44.776
And it's also secular.

1668
01:52:44.796 --> 01:52:53.899
It's not necessarily people who are religious that all ask these questions because we're looking at these things at these grand scales of the universe around us.

1669
01:52:53.919 --> 01:52:54.179
Yeah.

1670
01:52:54.439 --> 01:53:01.088
And they are poking at that same curiosity, that same internal thing that's within us, just in a different way.

1671
01:53:01.249 --> 01:53:02.110
Yeah.

1672
01:53:02.410 --> 01:53:06.416
And so, you know, people practice...

1673
01:53:08.305 --> 01:53:14.046
in a religious context, if you're secular, it's fine, or a philosophical context, asking these exact same questions.

1674
01:53:14.726 --> 01:53:19.367
And it's not looked at in the same way as when we ask these questions from a scientific perspective.

1675
01:53:19.627 --> 01:53:21.227
It's the same thing.

1676
01:53:21.347 --> 01:53:21.988
It's the same thing.

1677
01:53:22.008 --> 01:53:23.388
To me, it's the same thing, right?

1678
01:53:23.468 --> 01:53:28.129
Like, who am I, who are you, and what the hell is all this?

1679
01:53:28.269 --> 01:53:29.649
It's always that same question.

1680
01:53:29.849 --> 01:53:35.030
The interesting thing about Ice Cube is that it has both the –

1681
01:53:35.770 --> 01:53:39.811
Potential to help us understand some of the physical aspects of that question very, very far away.

1682
01:53:40.191 --> 01:53:42.512
But also some aspects of the questions close at home.

1683
01:53:43.192 --> 01:53:56.775
And this handedness, this chirality question is another two-way street similar to our memory story because it's both about origins of life.

1684
01:53:58.422 --> 01:54:16.240
Ultimately, the Nobel Prize was given in part to this idea that you can have a small imbalance in left and right-handedness that becomes a runaway reaction that then creates effectively like a 95, 99 percent proportion of one or the other handness even though your original balance –

1685
01:54:16.420 --> 01:54:17.961
Yeah, was effectively 50-50.

1686
01:54:18.121 --> 01:54:19.261
Was effectively 50-50.

1687
01:54:19.301 --> 01:54:20.242
That's very interesting.

1688
01:54:20.282 --> 01:54:21.082
Yeah.

1689
01:54:21.422 --> 01:54:38.149
And then when you talk about origin of life, it is a question that you have to then ask, which is, okay, well, if our basis is homochiral and you look at this idea of panspermia, if you have this sort of unbiased soup as the starting point.

1690
01:54:38.269 --> 01:54:39.530
And a small bias came in.

1691
01:54:39.550 --> 01:54:39.870
Yeah.

1692
01:54:40.710 --> 01:54:45.872
There seems to be a very easy to jump to conclusion through line between those two things.

1693
01:54:45.892 --> 01:54:46.932
I'm not saying that that's the case.

1694
01:54:47.132 --> 01:54:49.593
Yeah, but it's there.

1695
01:54:49.693 --> 01:54:50.913
It's cool to think about.

1696
01:54:51.053 --> 01:54:52.434
It's very cool to think about.

1697
01:54:52.474 --> 01:54:56.115
And then the reverse of that is we're now in a place as a human species where –

1698
01:54:57.706 --> 01:54:58.527
We're going to Europa.

1699
01:54:59.067 --> 01:54:59.468
Yeah.

1700
01:54:59.588 --> 01:55:06.636
Where we think there's going to be maybe something underneath these ice sheets that are life.

1701
01:55:07.717 --> 01:55:10.540
But similar to a meteorite's landing –

1702
01:55:12.162 --> 01:55:24.633
And having impact here in terms of how life happens, both from a origin of life and the mirror life problem, which is a potential threat, which many people had opinions about.

1703
01:55:24.733 --> 01:55:27.055
And like it's complicated and we have solutions.

1704
01:55:27.075 --> 01:55:27.296
Yeah.

1705
01:55:27.596 --> 01:55:28.897
But it's, you know, not ideal.

1706
01:55:29.037 --> 01:55:29.858
Yeah, it's not ideal.

1707
01:55:30.158 --> 01:55:33.101
When we go somewhere else, it's like, you know, colonial times.

1708
01:55:34.329 --> 01:55:36.491
where we introduce things that this environment hasn't seen.

1709
01:55:36.511 --> 01:55:37.431
Like this tiny bacteria.

1710
01:55:37.731 --> 01:55:57.846
And then all of a sudden, you know, and we should be, as we can continue to increase our power to probe the universe, we both need to be careful about how we do that to ourselves, which links to our first story, and how we can now activate the physiological reaction from memory, how we explore our local solar system.

1711
01:55:58.086 --> 01:56:00.828
I mean, these are such incredibly awesome things

1712
01:56:01.488 --> 01:56:21.443
conversations to be having because we're now getting so good at this stuff yeah and i just i i love this time of year for science because i think the nobel prizes like give us an opportunity just like step back you know we're usually on this podcast we're always talking about the current event totally and things like that right the nobel prize always like

1713
01:56:22.257 --> 01:56:25.858
is an opportunity to step back and be like, yeah, that was sick, right?

1714
01:56:25.898 --> 01:56:34.441
Like 20 years ago when Peter Hegeman, actually no, 30 years ago when Peter Hegeman figured out this algae has a one millisecond time response to light.

1715
01:56:34.721 --> 01:56:35.302
That's sick.

1716
01:56:35.402 --> 01:56:36.462
Unbelievable.

1717
01:56:36.502 --> 01:56:37.142
That's cool.

1718
01:56:37.422 --> 01:56:37.562
Right.

1719
01:56:37.582 --> 01:56:38.763
That like he did that, right?

1720
01:56:38.803 --> 01:56:43.764
And then Soai, doing the Soai reaction like 20 years ago.

1721
01:56:46.353 --> 01:56:53.598
Francis Halsey trying to figure out how to do Antarctic neutrino astronomy again 20-30 years ago.

1722
01:56:54.599 --> 01:56:57.240
And spent years doing it in the ocean and being like ah.

1723
01:56:57.280 --> 01:56:58.121
Yeah it doesn't work.

1724
01:56:58.141 --> 01:56:59.442
Doesn't work that well.

1725
01:56:59.642 --> 01:57:01.783
There's all this bioluminescence that's annoying.

1726
01:57:02.684 --> 01:57:06.066
It's I just I love this time of year.

1727
01:57:06.526 --> 01:57:10.309
And we now are the official show.

1728
01:57:10.793 --> 01:57:36.427
covering the golden goose awards and next year uh the nobel prizes so shout out to triple as shout out to the royal swedish academy of sciences uh details tbd yeah um but uh we again find our way to be able to make two hours of just when we're having a relaxing follow-up this was pretty relaxing it was it was the last couple weeks i've been intense guys yeah uh

1729
01:57:36.827 --> 01:57:43.156
Very intense on the material, on the schedule, especially because we had to do daily drops and travel.

1730
01:57:43.537 --> 01:57:46.081
We really appreciate you all so much for joining us.

1731
01:57:46.121 --> 01:57:50.888
If you've made it to the end, what should be our comment for the comments?

1732
01:57:51.614 --> 01:57:53.917
Give us an idea on what to do when we're in Sweden.

1733
01:57:54.397 --> 01:58:03.327
It can be from – if you've been to Sweden or if it's just random like stuff that – me, me, Sweden, Scandinavian stuff.

1734
01:58:03.567 --> 01:58:03.827
Yeah.

1735
01:58:04.288 --> 01:58:05.849
Don't just say eat Swedish meatballs.

1736
01:58:05.929 --> 01:58:06.971
That might not be a thing.

1737
01:58:07.011 --> 01:58:09.173
But something – give us a deep cut.

1738
01:58:09.293 --> 01:58:11.275
Yeah.

1739
01:58:11.435 --> 01:58:13.778
And maybe Zlatan will be there and we can hang out with Zlatan.

1740
01:58:14.718 --> 01:58:19.459
My name is Lester Nari, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

1741
01:58:19.720 --> 01:58:22.500
Thank you for joining us for our Nobel follow-up.

1742
01:58:22.900 --> 01:58:32.763
We will be having a couple of interview episodes coming up over the next several weeks as we get into spooky season and as the weather cools down, although there was just a wildfire on Mulholland.

1743
01:58:33.173 --> 01:58:34.114
like earlier today.

1744
01:58:34.154 --> 01:58:35.175
LA, baby.

1745
01:58:35.195 --> 01:58:36.596
The Santana winds are kicking up.

1746
01:58:36.676 --> 01:58:38.017
And we're having that.

1747
01:58:38.278 --> 01:58:38.978
Santana winds.

1748
01:58:39.479 --> 01:58:42.461
We've had three hurricanes off the coast.

1749
01:58:42.501 --> 01:58:43.462
The Kelvin wave.

1750
01:58:43.843 --> 01:58:44.583
The beach is gone.

1751
01:58:45.964 --> 01:58:46.805
Homes are gone.

1752
01:58:46.845 --> 01:58:52.250
There's a great white, a 20-foot great white that's swimming around, and so you can't swim.

1753
01:58:52.670 --> 01:58:53.291
No surfing.

1754
01:58:54.852 --> 01:58:55.633
We're going to need help.

1755
01:58:55.713 --> 01:58:57.775
We will see you all next week.
