WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.592 --> 00:00:03.736
And we're just like, let's just put some microphones and some cameras.

2
00:00:04.317 --> 00:00:05.999
And I was like, Lester, you handle that.

3
00:00:06.900 --> 00:00:07.161
Right.

4
00:00:07.661 --> 00:00:08.883
And you handle the science.

5
00:00:08.943 --> 00:00:11.747
How many people lived in the Amazon before 1492?

6
00:00:11.767 --> 00:00:12.848
And how would we even know?

7
00:00:16.933 --> 00:00:27.323
If the evidence is buried under the vast rainforest that so many of us see, that means that there's more than 20,000 additional earthworks.

8
00:00:27.503 --> 00:00:33.048
Just a few years ago, we used to think that there were 10,000 earthworks in the entire Amazon rainforest.

9
00:00:33.408 --> 00:00:35.970
And now we're talking about in this tiny area that we're going to get into.

10
00:00:36.330 --> 00:00:37.191
Hello, Internet.

11
00:00:37.271 --> 00:00:43.477
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD,

12
00:00:43.897 --> 00:00:51.503
Krishna Chowdhury, we are celebrating our one-year anniversary of From First Principles.

13
00:00:51.983 --> 00:00:57.367
It's incredible that we've made it this far, and so many of you, 50 million.

14
00:00:57.894 --> 00:01:01.935
of you across the world have joined us in our first year on the show.

15
00:01:01.955 --> 00:01:12.738
13 million of you are now watching every month as we journey through discovery, curiosity, and science at the frontier.

16
00:01:13.138 --> 00:01:21.320
We're extremely, extremely grateful for all of you in FFP Nation who have been very vocal about what you like and what you don't like.

17
00:01:21.960 --> 00:01:27.406
And we've really taken that to heart as you've seen us evolve the show over our first year.

18
00:01:27.786 --> 00:01:38.997
Again, it is the two of us here, no production staff, no agency, no network, just two friends of almost, I think, 16 years now.

19
00:01:39.117 --> 00:01:39.298
Yep.

20
00:01:39.878 --> 00:01:44.763
Trying to just figure out the world around us as much as we can and as we can.

21
00:01:45.724 --> 00:01:56.816
A small token of our appreciation for so many of you following us, as well as an ability for us to better learn about who you all are and what you want from the show as we enter year two.

22
00:01:57.437 --> 00:02:03.023
We are going to have a merch giveaway for our year one merch giveaway.

23
00:02:03.243 --> 00:02:07.125
at ffppod.com backslash survey.

24
00:02:07.145 --> 00:02:17.949
There are a couple of questions that will help us understand a little bit more about our listeners, who you all are, where you're working, what you care about, what you want us to do on the show.

25
00:02:18.649 --> 00:02:23.931
As we go into our year two, now that we've figured out all of the sound issues,

26
00:02:24.331 --> 00:02:27.755
And the camera issues and other production problems.

27
00:02:28.216 --> 00:02:34.943
We really want to focus on community building and making sure that we are making the show collectively.

28
00:02:35.264 --> 00:02:42.772
Because at the end of the day, this would not be a show without all of you out here in FFP Nation.

29
00:02:42.812 --> 00:02:43.293
We do...

30
00:02:44.433 --> 00:02:49.438
Have a story that we will cover about the history of the Amazon.

31
00:02:49.978 --> 00:03:01.570
And as you notice just in front of us, we have some books that we will be adding to the inaugural from First Principles Library, which is three floating shelves.

32
00:03:01.865 --> 00:03:02.105
Yes.

33
00:03:03.125 --> 00:03:04.146
We're going to expand it, though.

34
00:03:04.366 --> 00:03:05.166
We're going to expand it.

35
00:03:05.186 --> 00:03:05.906
We'll expand it.

36
00:03:06.106 --> 00:03:07.287
We'll eventually get a building.

37
00:03:07.487 --> 00:03:10.028
And the first iteration, we've got some bangers.

38
00:03:10.288 --> 00:03:10.528
Yes.

39
00:03:10.988 --> 00:03:16.690
And we did ask the audience for some suggestions, and some of those suggestions did make it into the library.

40
00:03:17.250 --> 00:03:23.952
As always, we're going to talk about the science from the ground up today, because this is From First Principles.

41
00:03:39.645 --> 00:03:41.066
So today we're going to have a little bit of fun.

42
00:03:41.366 --> 00:03:51.152
We will give you the best science, but we've left out the banter for several months as we've tried to really focus on being as information dense as possible.

43
00:03:51.392 --> 00:03:59.356
But there's so many of you who are new to the show, and we thought it would be helpful to help you understand a little bit more about who we are.

44
00:03:59.817 --> 00:04:04.259
Note, I am not Lamorne Morris from New Girl, okay?

45
00:04:05.260 --> 00:04:07.081
We barely look alike.

46
00:04:08.291 --> 00:04:11.673
Although I did get approached in person.

47
00:04:11.814 --> 00:04:12.474
That was crazy.

48
00:04:12.514 --> 00:04:18.598
Here in the valley by a very nice older gentleman whose daughter apparently loves New Girl.

49
00:04:19.238 --> 00:04:28.304
So Lamorne, I just want you to know, as your apparent celebrity doppelganger, you really are loved out here in the streets.

50
00:04:28.364 --> 00:04:37.250
But for those of you who may be new to the pod and just for us to have the chance to talk about why we are doing this again, do you remember...

51
00:04:38.883 --> 00:04:46.089
It was June, July of last year that we finally decided to maybe do something.

52
00:04:46.629 --> 00:04:47.029
Yeah.

53
00:04:47.110 --> 00:04:47.550
Yeah.

54
00:04:47.630 --> 00:04:51.653
And we had flirted with doing something with other formats.

55
00:04:51.913 --> 00:04:52.093
Yeah.

56
00:04:52.154 --> 00:05:02.862
And this is finally the format that we came up with, which is just like the two of us bantering and talking about science like we've done for the past 10, 16 plus years.

57
00:05:03.503 --> 00:05:05.184
And what's so interesting about this is,

58
00:05:05.524 --> 00:05:07.786
And I don't think people understand.

59
00:05:08.106 --> 00:05:10.168
We literally will just do this.

60
00:05:10.308 --> 00:05:10.528
Yeah.

61
00:05:12.089 --> 00:05:12.590
Regardless.

62
00:05:12.610 --> 00:05:12.950
Yeah, yeah.

63
00:05:12.990 --> 00:05:15.352
We've been doing this since college, right?

64
00:05:15.812 --> 00:05:26.021
Among other friends, like at Princeton undergrad, we would just be hanging out, and we would be talking about the newest paper that came out in whatever field and whatever people are talking about.

65
00:05:26.361 --> 00:05:28.703
And there would be so many other people that were bantering with us.

66
00:05:28.823 --> 00:05:29.864
And now it's just the two of us.

67
00:05:31.065 --> 00:05:33.527
But, yeah, it was so natural to...

68
00:05:34.415 --> 00:05:37.557
And we're just like, let's just put some microphones and some cameras.

69
00:05:38.138 --> 00:05:39.819
And I was like, Lester, you handle that.

70
00:05:40.740 --> 00:05:40.980
Right.

71
00:05:41.480 --> 00:05:42.721
And you handle the science.

72
00:05:42.921 --> 00:05:52.188
And, you know, part of how we connected initially, or among other things, is, you know, we both have science families.

73
00:05:52.729 --> 00:05:53.289
Yeah.

74
00:05:53.309 --> 00:05:55.891
And so that was obviously a connection point.

75
00:05:56.051 --> 00:05:56.732
That's right.

76
00:05:56.932 --> 00:05:58.093
Indian, Zimbabwean.

77
00:05:58.113 --> 00:05:58.973
Yeah.

78
00:06:00.357 --> 00:06:03.268
And I think you got more of a physics lens.

79
00:06:03.529 --> 00:06:05.336
I got more of a biology lens.

80
00:06:06.797 --> 00:06:10.781
And it's immigrants to the U.S. in different ways.

81
00:06:10.861 --> 00:06:13.503
And, you know, L.A. for you growing up.

82
00:06:13.963 --> 00:06:16.585
Jersey, shout out Jersey for me.

83
00:06:16.605 --> 00:06:19.128
A little bit of North Carolina, but you guys were kind of at the tail end.

84
00:06:19.148 --> 00:06:20.349
You know, that wasn't formative.

85
00:06:20.529 --> 00:06:22.811
Yeah, for me, it was like India.

86
00:06:23.071 --> 00:06:25.593
And then L.A. was high school.

87
00:06:26.014 --> 00:06:27.034
So kind of at the tail end.

88
00:06:27.054 --> 00:06:29.496
But then it became formative because it was high school.

89
00:06:29.517 --> 00:06:29.657
Yeah.

90
00:06:30.157 --> 00:06:37.879
You know, when you come from a place like India to America, the first place you really put your roots down becomes a formative experience.

91
00:06:37.919 --> 00:06:42.101
Although, you know, I spent a year plus in Huntsville, Alabama.

92
00:06:42.441 --> 00:06:43.261
Yes, that's right.

93
00:06:43.321 --> 00:06:45.762
Where Marshall Space Flight Center and NASA.

94
00:06:45.782 --> 00:06:47.502
So my dad was a solar physicist there.

95
00:06:47.943 --> 00:06:49.163
And so, you know...

96
00:06:49.907 --> 00:06:54.412
Alabama, Huntsville, Alabama, still, I remember, Challenger Middle School.

97
00:06:54.492 --> 00:06:58.375
I don't know if there's anyone out there who went to Challenger Middle School.

98
00:06:59.537 --> 00:07:01.659
It's also where all the UAP labs are, allegedly.

99
00:07:01.679 --> 00:07:02.660
Yes, yes.

100
00:07:02.880 --> 00:07:03.360
Yeah.

101
00:07:03.420 --> 00:07:07.644
And I mean, I think it's like expanding a lot because Redstone Arsenal is there.

102
00:07:07.905 --> 00:07:13.050
It's one of the few military space places that is expanding rather than going down.

103
00:07:13.070 --> 00:07:13.190
Yeah.

104
00:07:14.030 --> 00:07:16.212
Which is a story for another day.

105
00:07:16.472 --> 00:07:24.556
But ultimately what we're trying to do with the show is build what I've always called an ESPN for science.

106
00:07:24.796 --> 00:07:33.922
You know, so many different aspects of culture have channels that really celebrate them, whether it's award shows like the Grammys and the Oscars and the Emmys.

107
00:07:34.822 --> 00:07:41.986
or things like SportsCenter, or all the different podcasts that are for comedy, and entertainment, and music, and sports.

108
00:07:42.606 --> 00:07:47.409
And there's obviously a huge ecosystem of, quote, science communication.

109
00:07:47.629 --> 00:07:51.191
Obviously, there's the journal and magazine culture.

110
00:07:51.731 --> 00:07:58.475
But with everyone consuming content in vertical video now, sometimes in horizontal,

111
00:07:58.975 --> 00:08:02.076
And I really feel like not a lot of people talking about the frontier in this way.

112
00:08:02.356 --> 00:08:02.597
Yeah.

113
00:08:02.697 --> 00:08:11.680
Where you have both a combination of the expert view that can get into the weeds technically, which is obviously our resident PhD Krishna.

114
00:08:12.400 --> 00:08:15.482
And the every person, which is me.

115
00:08:16.573 --> 00:08:27.258
trying to get a hold of what is going on because our view is that for a whole variety of reasons, progress in the sciences is accelerating.

116
00:08:27.538 --> 00:08:27.778
Yes.

117
00:08:27.958 --> 00:08:38.683
And it is really important for all of us in the general public to understand what is happening because it will be impacting our life directly in the way that the sciences always have –

118
00:08:39.183 --> 00:08:52.848
but at an increasingly fast and I think an increasingly more impactful way, whether you talk about biotechnology, medicine, material science, obviously the devil word of the day, AI.

119
00:08:55.925 --> 00:09:17.928
space exploration it's it is an incredible time to be alive and it's such a pleasure to be able to do this show for you all and we're hopeful that we can continue to make science a part of the zeitgeist with the best science show on the planet data suggests

120
00:09:20.111 --> 00:09:22.032
And we're all about data on the show.

121
00:09:22.052 --> 00:09:24.833
The data suggests that this is what the people want.

122
00:09:25.893 --> 00:09:30.715
But now enough of all of that self-aggrandizing nonsense.

123
00:09:31.536 --> 00:09:37.278
We're going to get back to why you all tune into the show, which is our story, our only story of the day.

124
00:09:37.298 --> 00:09:39.459
A little brief rundown of...

125
00:09:40.858 --> 00:09:44.222
This idea that the Amazon was never empty.

126
00:09:45.283 --> 00:09:46.704
And I'm going to open with this question.

127
00:09:47.445 --> 00:09:51.850
How many people lived in the Amazon before 1492?

128
00:09:52.670 --> 00:10:03.442
And how would we even know if the evidence is buried under the vast rainforest that so many of us see on our social feeds as planes fly over?

129
00:10:04.492 --> 00:10:07.454
Yeah, it's a very strange question.

130
00:10:07.814 --> 00:10:14.038
For the longest time, people thought there was no one in the Amazon before Christopher Columbus came to the New World.

131
00:10:14.798 --> 00:10:18.300
And surprise, surprise, of course that is not true.

132
00:10:19.921 --> 00:10:26.845
There's a new paper out in Nature that was submitted in April 2025, accepted in June.

133
00:10:28.363 --> 00:10:28.683
July.

134
00:10:29.303 --> 00:10:29.584
Sorry.

135
00:10:29.604 --> 00:10:29.764
Yeah.

136
00:10:29.804 --> 00:10:30.164
July.

137
00:10:30.964 --> 00:10:38.328
And it's actually showing that they're, the Amazon is way more populated than we could have ever imagined.

138
00:10:38.988 --> 00:10:39.748
Surprise, surprise.

139
00:10:39.808 --> 00:10:40.028
Yes.

140
00:10:40.468 --> 00:10:40.869
Right.

141
00:10:40.929 --> 00:10:41.289
I'm shocked.

142
00:10:41.309 --> 00:10:42.089
This is my shocked face.

143
00:10:42.389 --> 00:10:42.629
Yeah.

144
00:10:42.729 --> 00:10:43.150
It's, it's,

145
00:10:44.563 --> 00:10:57.966
And getting into sort of the historical tendency of why we think the Amazon was just desolate, and now we're sort of correcting our views, it's a very interesting story.

146
00:10:58.446 --> 00:11:01.587
So we'll start with Gaspar de Carvajal.

147
00:11:01.887 --> 00:11:07.928
He's a Spanish explorer, and he explored the Amazon in 1542.

148
00:11:08.248 --> 00:11:11.809
He went up the Amazon River, and when he went back to the King of Spain...

149
00:11:13.167 --> 00:11:17.616
He talked about crowded cities, advanced societies along the Amazon River.

150
00:11:18.357 --> 00:11:23.808
Later, explorers came to corroborate what he was talking about, and they found no one.

151
00:11:24.825 --> 00:11:25.085
Okay?

152
00:11:25.485 --> 00:11:27.286
This was in a span of about 100 years.

153
00:11:27.767 --> 00:11:30.188
So within 100 years, there was no one.

154
00:11:31.108 --> 00:11:34.670
Historians traditionally say, well, he's just BSing.

155
00:11:35.171 --> 00:11:35.431
Okay?

156
00:11:35.731 --> 00:11:38.172
He was just trying to impress the king of Spain.

157
00:11:38.593 --> 00:11:43.875
He's talking about these wide roads, busy marketplaces, large armies of local warriors.

158
00:11:45.136 --> 00:11:53.961
But, hey, maybe he was just trying to get in with the Spanish royalty, to get more money, to do more expeditions.

159
00:11:54.623 --> 00:11:59.226
There is a current story in geopolitics around the Spanish king right now.

160
00:11:59.666 --> 00:12:07.512
And so this idea of people trying to curry favor or not curry favor is very topical.

161
00:12:07.772 --> 00:12:07.992
Yeah.

162
00:12:08.312 --> 00:12:10.254
Well, this guy was trying to do it, apparently.

163
00:12:10.594 --> 00:12:11.475
That's what we all think.

164
00:12:11.495 --> 00:12:11.915
Okay.

165
00:12:11.935 --> 00:12:15.297
We all think that he was just lying because he wanted some credibility.

166
00:12:15.317 --> 00:12:17.339
He wanted more funding to do more expeditions, right?

167
00:12:17.359 --> 00:12:18.059
Right.

168
00:12:18.239 --> 00:12:29.684
Now it turns out, if we really go back, we're starting to find evidence for more and more civilizations in the Amazon with kind of the techniques that we're going to go over.

169
00:12:30.064 --> 00:12:38.147
And it turns out what probably happened was European diseases like smallpox wiped out 90 to 95 percent of the indigenous population.

170
00:12:38.427 --> 00:12:40.168
And that can happen very, very quickly.

171
00:12:40.308 --> 00:12:42.609
I mean, we saw that with the COVID-19 pandemic.

172
00:12:42.949 --> 00:12:53.454
Now imagine smallpox, which is a much more deadly disease and a much more transmissible disease, exposed to a population that has never seen anything like it, right?

173
00:12:54.934 --> 00:13:11.782
European and Eurasian populations, there's this famous book, Guns, Germs, and Steel, that talks about why European populations and Eurasian populations, because of their proximity to domesticated animals, developed kind of a herd immunity.

174
00:13:12.382 --> 00:13:14.105
to pathogens like smallpox.

175
00:13:14.366 --> 00:13:23.261
But when you introduce that to a completely naive population in the Americas that has never been exposed to cows, domesticated cows and things like that,

176
00:13:24.114 --> 00:13:29.397
Now all of a sudden, something like 90% to 95% of the population can be decimated.

177
00:13:29.777 --> 00:13:34.200
And then when – I mean that kind of number is where societies collapse.

178
00:13:34.300 --> 00:13:34.500
Right.

179
00:13:34.660 --> 00:13:34.881
Right?

180
00:13:35.641 --> 00:13:36.421
Yeah.

181
00:13:36.462 --> 00:13:37.062
What are you going to do?

182
00:13:37.082 --> 00:13:37.442
Yeah, yeah.

183
00:13:37.502 --> 00:13:40.064
With only 10% of your population remaining?

184
00:13:40.284 --> 00:13:45.807
Not evenly distributed across the roles necessary to sustain a society.

185
00:13:45.827 --> 00:13:46.348
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

186
00:13:46.488 --> 00:13:49.890
And so, I mean, whatever society you had –

187
00:13:50.550 --> 00:13:53.411
you're back to the stone ages type of thing, right?

188
00:13:53.791 --> 00:13:59.034
And so whatever society remained, the survivors went back deep into the jungle.

189
00:13:59.334 --> 00:14:06.917
And then perhaps that's why when you see all of the newer explorers come in 100 years after the 1500s, they don't see anyone.

190
00:14:07.577 --> 00:14:09.378
They also don't see any remnants

191
00:14:09.838 --> 00:14:13.161
Because the jungle is a beast, right?

192
00:14:13.741 --> 00:14:18.445
Most of these dwellings are made out of earth and mud and wood.

193
00:14:18.926 --> 00:14:23.169
These are things that are biodegradable, and these are things that trees can grow on, right?

194
00:14:24.190 --> 00:14:25.391
Now the jungle takes over.

195
00:14:26.472 --> 00:14:27.293
You don't see anyone.

196
00:14:27.953 --> 00:14:30.675
You call fraud, and you call them a liar.

197
00:14:31.096 --> 00:14:31.296
Right?

198
00:14:31.776 --> 00:14:34.739
A fair given the information at the time.

199
00:14:35.279 --> 00:14:35.920
I can think of...

200
00:14:36.598 --> 00:14:40.381
my backyard and how quickly it's been taken over by nature.

201
00:14:40.401 --> 00:14:43.084
We have a cement mall in the back that was there.

202
00:14:43.504 --> 00:14:46.727
And then within six to 12 months, you cannot see it.

203
00:14:46.847 --> 00:14:47.067
Yeah.

204
00:14:47.768 --> 00:14:50.290
And you know, I mean, life finds a way in life.

205
00:14:50.590 --> 00:14:50.830
Right.

206
00:14:51.111 --> 00:14:52.332
Shout out Dr. Ian Malcolm.

207
00:14:52.492 --> 00:14:52.932
Exactly.

208
00:14:52.952 --> 00:14:53.292
So, so,

209
00:14:54.633 --> 00:14:58.415
More than about 20 years ago, there was a geographer, Alceur Ranzi.

210
00:14:58.975 --> 00:15:10.100
He's now at the University of Accra, and he was on the right side of an airplane going over the Amazon jungle, and he saw a ring-like structure.

211
00:15:11.017 --> 00:15:12.377
And he's like, that's not natural.

212
00:15:12.878 --> 00:15:13.118
Okay?

213
00:15:13.858 --> 00:15:15.398
It's really never natural.

214
00:15:15.478 --> 00:15:19.039
If you see a perfect ring somewhere, that's almost always man-made.

215
00:15:19.440 --> 00:15:19.680
Okay?

216
00:15:19.720 --> 00:15:22.020
Unless it's like a meteor impact.

217
00:15:22.380 --> 00:15:26.622
But if it's a meteor impact and you can still see it, that's very strange.

218
00:15:26.802 --> 00:15:27.002
Right?

219
00:15:27.362 --> 00:15:28.942
And so he's like, there's got to be something...

220
00:15:31.063 --> 00:15:31.764
that made that.

221
00:15:31.784 --> 00:15:32.845
It's got to be humans.

222
00:15:33.545 --> 00:15:46.835
Decades of subsequent research by Ronzi and his colleagues have slowly revealed that the Amazon was populated by millions of people, even in the most remote areas of the Amazon, right?

223
00:15:47.356 --> 00:15:55.662
And so now researchers suggest that ancient Amazonians were widespread in territories that previously we considered uninhabited.

224
00:15:56.403 --> 00:15:58.444
That's where this current story comes in.

225
00:15:59.185 --> 00:16:02.790
There's a new paper that we talked about out in Nature.

226
00:16:03.071 --> 00:16:03.792
Science covered it.

227
00:16:03.952 --> 00:16:06.095
A lot of press has covered it.

228
00:16:06.897 --> 00:16:24.522
It's showing that in even the most remote areas of the Amazon rainforest, away from rivers, away from the traditional places that we would have expected large-scale civilizations, we are finding structures that demand an economy that is worth millions of people.

229
00:16:25.122 --> 00:16:25.322
Right?

230
00:16:25.542 --> 00:16:33.464
It's one of the most favorite things I think about in archaeology when we look at structures that were built by civilizations of yore.

231
00:16:33.764 --> 00:16:35.545
The structures are a proxy.

232
00:16:35.929 --> 00:16:39.230
for how big the society was.

233
00:16:39.530 --> 00:16:44.332
We look at, I mean, a beautiful example is Egypt, 5,000 years ago.

234
00:16:44.672 --> 00:16:47.693
They built the pyramids, the three giant pyramids of Giza.

235
00:16:48.093 --> 00:16:52.935
The largest one, the pyramid of Khufu, is like one of the largest structures ever.

236
00:16:53.335 --> 00:16:59.197
It was the largest structure for something like 4,000 years before some random cathedral in Europe took over.

237
00:16:59.697 --> 00:17:01.198
Honestly, that's insane.

238
00:17:02.159 --> 00:17:13.365
That's actually insane that Egypt built a structure that was the largest structure, the largest man-made structure on the planet for 4,000 years, right?

239
00:17:13.646 --> 00:17:20.670
If you think about it, like, the people who built the Colosseum, like Julius Caesar and the Romans who built the Colosseum—

240
00:17:21.490 --> 00:17:25.252
They looked at the pyramids like we look at the Colosseum.

241
00:17:26.272 --> 00:17:28.253
It's just insane to think about.

242
00:17:28.653 --> 00:17:33.895
And more importantly, when I look at structures like that, I think about what was the size of their economy.

243
00:17:34.035 --> 00:17:34.235
Right.

244
00:17:34.395 --> 00:17:35.236
In order to be able to.

245
00:17:35.376 --> 00:17:37.096
In order to be able to support the workers.

246
00:17:37.356 --> 00:17:39.297
I mean, sure, there was a lot of slavery involved, right?

247
00:17:39.317 --> 00:17:40.178
Still.

248
00:17:40.198 --> 00:17:40.538
Still.

249
00:17:41.298 --> 00:17:48.923
With, like, getting the stone from, like, random places along the Nile, putting it up in a pyramid environment.

250
00:17:49.183 --> 00:17:50.604
Guys, there weren't any aliens.

251
00:17:50.985 --> 00:17:54.407
It was just an incredibly advanced technology, right?

252
00:17:56.268 --> 00:18:03.513
And an incredibly advanced civilization that could, like, muster together the amount of humans to create something like that.

253
00:18:03.573 --> 00:18:09.037
The idea of taking the work process...

254
00:18:09.837 --> 00:18:21.788
and breaking it down into its fundamental steps in order to be able to scale it, to be able to create infrastructure of that size when no one had ever done that before.

255
00:18:21.888 --> 00:18:30.536
So you have a blank slate and you're like, how do we, we have this imagination as humans, so I have a vision, I want this thing, I want it to look like this.

256
00:18:31.262 --> 00:18:34.924
And they just figured out how to do it without being able to reference how anyone else did it.

257
00:18:34.964 --> 00:18:35.504
Yes, exactly.

258
00:18:35.524 --> 00:18:39.847
No one came in and was like, oh, we have this thing called cement, whatever, right?

259
00:18:40.147 --> 00:18:46.831
And that's, I think, truly what's so – and this is what's so fascinating when we think about some of these –

260
00:18:48.760 --> 00:18:51.583
older generations and cultures in humanity.

261
00:18:52.544 --> 00:18:55.447
And we always come back to kind of the same things.

262
00:18:55.527 --> 00:18:55.787
Yeah.

263
00:18:56.508 --> 00:18:56.748
Right.

264
00:18:56.848 --> 00:19:00.872
And it manifests a little bit differently with little different flavor each time.

265
00:19:01.393 --> 00:19:09.841
But everywhere we look across the planet, we have these highly sophisticated, you know, you know,

266
00:19:10.702 --> 00:19:36.775
of civilizations in time periods where we did not expect there to be this level of collective accomplishment yeah particularly around infrastructure and and all the so i'm really interested because the amazon has always talked about so much it's talked about a lot in it's like egypt and the amazon yeah in terms of you know uh armchair archaeologists yeah uh and and

267
00:19:38.577 --> 00:19:46.660
The Amazon in particular, for a lot of scientists, has been the object of a lot of curiosity.

268
00:19:46.820 --> 00:19:47.060
Yeah.

269
00:19:47.420 --> 00:19:47.740
For some time.

270
00:19:47.760 --> 00:19:54.862
Especially from a standpoint of deforestation, a standpoint of climate change, a standpoint of being a carbon sink.

271
00:19:55.563 --> 00:20:00.944
And now it's gaining credibility from a standpoint of archaeology, which I think is very, very cool.

272
00:20:02.445 --> 00:20:07.727
So the latest paper, Ronzi is actually one of the authors on this paper.

273
00:20:07.747 --> 00:20:07.847
Okay.

274
00:20:08.847 --> 00:20:18.151
It details nearly 200 previously undocumented earthworks in a very small patch of a corner of the rainforest.

275
00:20:18.471 --> 00:20:19.291
I just want to make a quick note.

276
00:20:19.311 --> 00:20:20.992
I think it's 400, not 200.

277
00:20:21.112 --> 00:20:21.972
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.

278
00:20:21.992 --> 00:20:22.312
You're right.

279
00:20:22.392 --> 00:20:22.913
It's double.

280
00:20:22.973 --> 00:20:23.613
It's double that.

281
00:20:23.913 --> 00:20:25.554
Which is crazy, yeah.

282
00:20:25.754 --> 00:20:32.637
And then what's crazy is if you extrapolate the results, right, then that means that there's more than 20,000

283
00:20:34.037 --> 00:20:59.111
additional earthworks because you can like do the math right you can be like i sampled this region and then i found this many i sampled the whole thing and this region was not any special compared to everything else so i can make like a blanket kind of guess 20 000 earthworks in that area and just a few years ago we used to think that there were 10 000 earthworks in the entire amazon rainforest and now we're talking about in this tiny area that we're going to get into

284
00:20:59.791 --> 00:21:04.835
This is like as an analogy, this would be like we found Brooklyn and there's 400 things in Brooklyn.

285
00:21:04.975 --> 00:21:05.195
Yeah.

286
00:21:05.275 --> 00:21:06.516
And then like New York.

287
00:21:07.117 --> 00:21:09.278
And then Jersey, Connecticut.

288
00:21:09.318 --> 00:21:09.519
Right.

289
00:21:09.639 --> 00:21:09.899
Yeah.

290
00:21:09.919 --> 00:21:13.482
So it's like, oh, like everything around here is pretty much the same.

291
00:21:13.522 --> 00:21:13.622
Yeah.

292
00:21:13.642 --> 00:21:14.903
There's 400 in Brooklyn.

293
00:21:14.923 --> 00:21:15.103
Yeah.

294
00:21:15.343 --> 00:21:17.104
So obviously we also have it in Manhattan.

295
00:21:17.124 --> 00:21:17.585
Exactly.

296
00:21:17.645 --> 00:21:18.786
The Bronx, et cetera.

297
00:21:18.886 --> 00:21:18.986
Yeah.

298
00:21:19.006 --> 00:21:19.186
Yeah.

299
00:21:19.546 --> 00:21:21.008
Yeah, it's really, really cool.

300
00:21:21.468 --> 00:21:23.851
So let's talk about how they actually did it.

301
00:21:23.891 --> 00:21:28.616
We always want to focus on the procedure and the methods on this podcast.

302
00:21:28.696 --> 00:21:29.677
They use LIDAR.

303
00:21:30.078 --> 00:21:33.321
It's effectively using a laser, an infrared laser.

304
00:21:33.581 --> 00:21:39.308
What you do is you have a drone or an airplane that has an infrared laser that's sending out laser pulses from...

305
00:21:40.252 --> 00:21:43.115
hundreds of thousands of laser beams per second downward.

306
00:21:43.395 --> 00:21:43.635
Okay?

307
00:21:44.116 --> 00:21:44.937
A laser beam.

308
00:21:45.297 --> 00:21:45.477
Yeah.

309
00:21:45.677 --> 00:21:47.920
It's going to go and scan everything.

310
00:21:48.340 --> 00:21:51.884
And then each laser pulse, it's going to get split when it hits something.

311
00:21:51.904 --> 00:21:52.885
There's going to hit a leaf.

312
00:21:53.525 --> 00:21:55.307
Part of it's going to go through the leaf, right?

313
00:21:55.647 --> 00:21:57.489
And then it's going to hit another leaf.

314
00:21:58.150 --> 00:21:59.872
Every time it hits something, it bounces back.

315
00:22:00.432 --> 00:22:03.135
And sometimes it's going to hit the ground and bounce back.

316
00:22:03.415 --> 00:22:08.017
Have you ever seen these landscape scanning drones in person before?

317
00:22:08.057 --> 00:22:08.537
No, I have not.

318
00:22:08.577 --> 00:22:09.718
It's really creepy.

319
00:22:09.918 --> 00:22:10.078
Really?

320
00:22:10.098 --> 00:22:15.000
Because if you don't know what's happening, you kind of just see this light happening.

321
00:22:15.320 --> 00:22:18.041
And it's clearly programmatic.

322
00:22:18.061 --> 00:22:18.742
Scanning, yeah.

323
00:22:19.242 --> 00:22:21.243
It's actually quite interesting.

324
00:22:21.483 --> 00:22:24.624
But I think the point you bring up there is important is we're sending something down.

325
00:22:24.864 --> 00:22:26.545
When it hits something, it comes back.

326
00:22:26.645 --> 00:22:30.546
Yeah, I mean, LIDAR sounds like radar because it's the same physics, right?

327
00:22:30.906 --> 00:22:31.867
Radar is radio.

328
00:22:31.907 --> 00:22:33.027
Here we're doing it with light.

329
00:22:33.447 --> 00:22:36.328
Not necessarily optical light, mostly infrared, right?

330
00:22:36.608 --> 00:22:42.130
And then what you do is the computers take all that data, and then they remove the top layer of where the leaves are.

331
00:22:42.190 --> 00:22:44.871
You can, like, tell that this bounced back from a leaf.

332
00:22:45.231 --> 00:22:46.712
This went all the way down to the ground.

333
00:22:46.732 --> 00:22:50.373
You can find, like, a sort of floor of where the bounce happened.

334
00:22:50.393 --> 00:22:51.173
Because it takes longer.

335
00:22:51.313 --> 00:22:52.434
Yeah, yeah, exactly.

336
00:22:52.474 --> 00:22:53.475
And you just do the timing.

337
00:22:53.515 --> 00:22:55.877
So you just remove everything that's really short in time.

338
00:22:56.157 --> 00:23:00.221
Yeah, and you look for the extremum in some given time bin, right?

339
00:23:00.501 --> 00:23:06.867
And then once you do that, now you've got a final ground-level data, and then you can look for undulations.

340
00:23:07.247 --> 00:23:08.589
You can be like, there's earthwork.

341
00:23:09.069 --> 00:23:17.074
What that means is there's a mound and then that mound is going to, is going to have a geometric structure and you can find this out through LIDAR, right?

342
00:23:17.114 --> 00:23:21.897
There's a certain characteristics of like human made structure that you can basically map to.

343
00:23:22.077 --> 00:23:22.258
Yeah.

344
00:23:22.278 --> 00:23:22.978
It's not a hill.

345
00:23:23.999 --> 00:23:24.139
Um,

346
00:23:24.599 --> 00:23:26.861
It's got some shape that's like very weird.

347
00:23:27.001 --> 00:23:27.942
Circle as an example.

348
00:23:27.962 --> 00:23:28.842
Circle, square.

349
00:23:28.882 --> 00:23:29.923
Square that you brought up earlier.

350
00:23:29.943 --> 00:23:30.664
Yeah, exactly.

351
00:23:30.964 --> 00:23:40.431
And so the area that they surveyed, the researchers went through the Acre and the Amazonas, which are two states of Brazil, effectively.

352
00:23:41.031 --> 00:23:43.693
The Acre is the one that is bordering Peru.

353
00:23:43.713 --> 00:23:44.594
Okay.

354
00:23:44.614 --> 00:23:45.374
Right next to Peru.

355
00:23:45.454 --> 00:23:51.499
And then Amazonas is the giant one that covers most of the Amazon rainforest.

356
00:23:51.659 --> 00:23:51.879
Right.

357
00:23:52.199 --> 00:23:54.600
Right in that border is where they were looking.

358
00:23:55.040 --> 00:23:57.341
Notice, this is far away from the Amazon River.

359
00:23:58.181 --> 00:24:00.222
The Amazon River is going up top.

360
00:24:00.402 --> 00:24:01.042
Yes, yes.

361
00:24:01.062 --> 00:24:01.222
Right?

362
00:24:01.542 --> 00:24:05.583
These are minor rivers that are tributaries into the Amazon.

363
00:24:06.604 --> 00:24:10.785
More so, they're tributaries very, very far away from the Amazon rainforest.

364
00:24:11.265 --> 00:24:13.906
I mean, sorry, from the central sort of Amazon River.

365
00:24:14.526 --> 00:24:16.627
I think the point you're trying to bring up is...

366
00:24:18.317 --> 00:24:23.443
ancient civilizations would have likely gathered or aggregated around major water.

367
00:24:23.463 --> 00:24:23.643
Yeah.

368
00:24:23.683 --> 00:24:24.745
That's the assumption.

369
00:24:24.765 --> 00:24:29.551
That's the assumption you want to make, especially given what that Spanish guy had seen, right?

370
00:24:29.591 --> 00:24:31.093
Cause he had just gone up the Amazon.

371
00:24:31.113 --> 00:24:33.676
The Amazon is like the easiest navigable river.

372
00:24:35.443 --> 00:24:37.285
It's like a mile wide the whole time.

373
00:24:37.325 --> 00:24:37.505
Right.

374
00:24:37.625 --> 00:24:38.806
So you just like go up, right?

375
00:24:38.866 --> 00:24:40.588
He's not going up these tiny tributaries.

376
00:24:40.929 --> 00:24:47.215
And so the point being this place that we're looking, which is sort of in the southwest.

377
00:24:47.235 --> 00:24:48.737
Yeah, it's like almost towards Peru.

378
00:24:48.757 --> 00:24:49.617
It's almost in Peru.

379
00:24:49.718 --> 00:24:56.645
There are no natural infrastructure that would suggest that –

380
00:24:57.005 --> 00:24:59.206
Human life would congregate in that area.

381
00:24:59.226 --> 00:24:59.626
Exactly.

382
00:24:59.706 --> 00:25:05.189
And that's why the scientists were so surprised at the density of what they found, right?

383
00:25:05.629 --> 00:25:09.771
This is a civilization that the researchers have previously named the Aquiri.

384
00:25:10.131 --> 00:25:13.033
It's named after two of the rivers that are in that region.

385
00:25:13.053 --> 00:25:15.094
They're tributaries into the Amazon, right?

386
00:25:15.414 --> 00:25:19.236
Now, the team identified most of these earthworks in the new study.

387
00:25:19.516 --> 00:25:20.256
They're geoglyphs.

388
00:25:20.296 --> 00:25:23.098
They're ditches that are made in the ground that form geometric shapes.

389
00:25:24.518 --> 00:25:27.500
Some are even more sophisticated with geometric shapes.

390
00:25:28.660 --> 00:25:32.722
They're like a square inside of a circle, or I think it's a circle inside of a square.

391
00:25:34.143 --> 00:25:36.944
If you look over here, clearly human-made, right?

392
00:25:37.264 --> 00:25:38.144
They're in a line.

393
00:25:39.605 --> 00:25:45.928
It reminds you of sort of Teotihuacan near Mexico City, where the Pyramid of the Sun and things like that.

394
00:25:46.488 --> 00:25:47.989
It reminds you of Angkor Wat.

395
00:25:48.569 --> 00:26:17.780
in Cambodia this is sophisticated society right for example if anyone goes to Italy and you know you go through any of the you see the roads you see the grid system in some format the Vatican right right there's permutations and slight differences but there's clearly a network because people are trying to go from point a to point b and you start to see these and and the density like you were saying proximity because I'm not trying to go two miles yeah

396
00:26:18.180 --> 00:26:19.180
To get to the pizza parlor.

397
00:26:19.280 --> 00:26:20.100
Yeah, exactly.

398
00:26:20.341 --> 00:26:24.001
And so, I mean, it's incredible that they're finding this with LiDAR, right?

399
00:26:24.021 --> 00:26:24.441
This is unbelievable.

400
00:26:24.501 --> 00:26:33.124
Now, based on the calculations of the workforce that was necessary to create and maintain these earthworks, and that's where we get into what is the size of the economy?

401
00:26:33.404 --> 00:26:34.904
What is the size of the population?

402
00:26:35.264 --> 00:26:41.465
The researchers estimate that it's up to something like 3 million people could have lived in that tiny region.

403
00:26:41.485 --> 00:26:42.866
There's no way.

404
00:26:42.886 --> 00:26:47.847
Yeah, and the little green dots, those are the images that we saw earlier, right?

405
00:26:48.688 --> 00:26:51.532
This is a massive swath of rainforest.

406
00:26:52.112 --> 00:26:55.537
All of that rainforest looks exactly the same as this swath.

407
00:26:55.938 --> 00:26:58.781
This is a random spot that they picked.

408
00:26:59.122 --> 00:27:04.810
So if we were to extrapolate, you can imagine just the many millions of people

409
00:27:06.467 --> 00:27:13.411
that are living in this part of the rainforest before Columbus showed up, before any of the Europeans showed up.

410
00:27:13.751 --> 00:27:17.192
And this is around 100 to 300 AD, right?

411
00:27:17.212 --> 00:27:23.256
So this is right after death of Christ, like the start of the common era, right?

412
00:27:24.356 --> 00:27:29.759
If we talk about like when the timeline of American civilizations, right?

413
00:27:29.779 --> 00:27:30.099
Right.

414
00:27:31.416 --> 00:27:32.837
this would be right around...

415
00:27:33.297 --> 00:27:35.999
So the Aztec and the Inca, those are very new.

416
00:27:36.339 --> 00:27:39.041
Those are around 1300, 1400 AD.

417
00:27:40.342 --> 00:27:43.143
So that's a thousand years after this stuff.

418
00:27:43.504 --> 00:27:50.248
It just tells you how rich the human history in South America and the Americas in general is.

419
00:27:50.268 --> 00:27:54.791
We've got the Olmecs, which might even be preceding this in Mexico.

420
00:27:55.132 --> 00:27:58.934
The Maya is like this giant civilization.

421
00:27:59.054 --> 00:27:59.975
It goes anywhere from like...

422
00:28:00.775 --> 00:28:02.916
3000 BC to 900 AD.

423
00:28:03.217 --> 00:28:09.860
So the Maya is like whenever archaeologists like see stuff that looks kind of like Maya.

424
00:28:10.120 --> 00:28:14.082
But it's like there's no way there's a same civilization that went on for 3000 years, right?

425
00:28:14.562 --> 00:28:14.923
Maybe.

426
00:28:15.103 --> 00:28:15.363
Maybe.

427
00:28:15.543 --> 00:28:15.903
Maybe.

428
00:28:15.983 --> 00:28:22.286
But it could also just be our lack of granularity in seeing the differences, right?

429
00:28:22.707 --> 00:28:23.987
Can I make a small side note?

430
00:28:24.007 --> 00:28:24.227
Yeah.

431
00:28:24.467 --> 00:28:29.230
For all my Nickelodeon heads who are listeners, you mentioned Olmec's.

432
00:28:29.390 --> 00:28:29.611
Yeah.

433
00:28:29.852 --> 00:28:34.930
Have you ever seen the game show in the 90s on Nickelodeon Legends of the Hidden Temple?

434
00:28:34.951 --> 00:28:35.071
Yeah.

435
00:28:36.297 --> 00:28:36.497
No.

436
00:28:36.838 --> 00:28:54.391
So there, there is the, the, the, the whole, the kind of the shtick was that the Olmecs had this hidden temple and these kids would come on the show similar to global guts and they would have to like traverse this, like, you know, mystery pad, like these little mazes in the hidden temple.

437
00:28:54.811 --> 00:29:04.158
And they had different, they had like the silver snakes and they had like the purple iguanas and you would be on a team and you would traverse this hidden temple of the Olmecs.

438
00:29:04.238 --> 00:29:04.819
That's pretty cool.

439
00:29:04.879 --> 00:29:04.999
And,

440
00:29:05.339 --> 00:29:12.169
for the connection there is like, I actually never knew that it was a related to a real thing.

441
00:29:12.229 --> 00:29:12.609
Yeah.

442
00:29:12.810 --> 00:29:19.499
I thought it was the kind of just, you know, took something that was real and, you know, did their movie mad, their TV magic to it.

443
00:29:19.939 --> 00:29:20.100
Um,

444
00:29:20.500 --> 00:29:22.861
But Olmec, real thing.

445
00:29:23.361 --> 00:29:24.282
Olmecs are a real thing.

446
00:29:24.302 --> 00:29:29.704
They're kind of like, you know, in Halo, we have, we've been talking about Halo a lot on this podcast.

447
00:29:29.884 --> 00:29:32.645
But, you know, in Halo, there's like the race called the Forerunners.

448
00:29:32.725 --> 00:29:32.965
Yes.

449
00:29:33.125 --> 00:29:35.446
That came before humans and the Covenant.

450
00:29:35.526 --> 00:29:36.246
Yes.

451
00:29:36.266 --> 00:29:39.468
The Olmecs are kind of like that for Mezzo America.

452
00:29:39.828 --> 00:29:47.831
They came before, they might have been the same time as the Maya, but they definitely came before the Aztecs and the people of Teotihuacan.

453
00:29:48.591 --> 00:29:57.033
And the people of Teotihuacan and the Aztecs regarded the Olmecs as kind of like the forerunners of their civilization.

454
00:29:57.073 --> 00:30:06.475
And if you look at the Olmecs, what we have remaining from the Olmecs is a crude writing system because we don't have a lot that's survived.

455
00:30:06.855 --> 00:30:15.917
And we also have faces, Olmec faces, where a lot of the Aztec art, you know, the characteristic Aztec art with the 2D sort of...

456
00:30:16.777 --> 00:30:23.465
That's derivative of Olmec art because they were descendants of the Olmecs, or at least they tried to say they were.

457
00:30:23.705 --> 00:30:30.973
I mean, the Aztecs were kind of a messed up people, right, with all the human sacrifices and the subjugation of all the other tribes.

458
00:30:31.273 --> 00:30:33.175
But they thought of themselves as like,

459
00:30:33.836 --> 00:30:56.117
descendants of the Olmecs kind of the same way it reminds me of halo yeah where it's like the humans and the covenant they we both thought yeah that we were descendants of the forerunners right and it turns out we're just like fighting each other i just want to say literally on the show they had Olmec was a face carved yeah stone yeah so so those are the famous faces of the it was literally that was the main like person giving you the hints on the show

460
00:30:56.634 --> 00:31:01.436
Someone please in the comments let me know that you have seen this show so I don't feel like a crazy person.

461
00:31:01.636 --> 00:31:02.616
It was such a classic.

462
00:31:02.696 --> 00:31:04.437
I wanted to be on all the game shows on Nickelodeon.

463
00:31:04.477 --> 00:31:08.018
But it's the connection to real history here and understanding.

464
00:31:08.618 --> 00:31:15.661
I think the Halo reference is actually helpful to kind of contextualize how these different Mesoamerican –

465
00:31:16.281 --> 00:31:17.883
ancient civilizations relate to each other.

466
00:31:17.943 --> 00:31:18.403
Yeah, yeah.

467
00:31:18.483 --> 00:31:19.544
I mean, it's really cool.

468
00:31:19.564 --> 00:31:23.267
Like in humanity, we always seek continuity, right?

469
00:31:23.307 --> 00:31:26.950
We always seek a story that we're a part of in the past.

470
00:31:27.430 --> 00:31:34.716
And that's invariant of whether you're from Europe or Asia or even the ancient civilizations of the Americas.

471
00:31:35.057 --> 00:31:36.438
I think it's really cool.

472
00:31:37.519 --> 00:31:39.100
So in the past 40 years,

473
00:31:40.742 --> 00:31:50.090
This is, we're kind of going to transition from this is really cool archaeology to the Amazon rainforest is being destroyed.

474
00:31:51.071 --> 00:31:51.371
Okay?

475
00:31:51.431 --> 00:31:51.651
Yeah.

476
00:31:52.132 --> 00:31:53.233
And this is kind of a problem.

477
00:31:53.253 --> 00:31:53.493
Yeah.

478
00:31:53.613 --> 00:31:55.635
We talk about the real things on this podcast.

479
00:31:55.715 --> 00:31:58.457
It's very cool that we're discovering new archaeology.

480
00:32:00.103 --> 00:32:03.624
new earthworks and new civilizations in the Amazon and new evidence for it.

481
00:32:04.025 --> 00:32:12.248
But the reality of the situation is that the Amazon has lost more than 13% of its vegetation cover in the last 40 years.

482
00:32:12.848 --> 00:32:17.190
And some scientists say that the region might not be able to sustain itself any longer.

483
00:32:17.630 --> 00:32:20.611
If the figure passes 20%, we're already at 13%.

484
00:32:21.231 --> 00:32:25.293
So they, it becomes kind of a conundrum about, you know,

485
00:32:25.751 --> 00:32:33.318
how agriculture is taking over their Amazon rainforest because Brazil is an economy that is hungry, is a developing nation.

486
00:32:34.719 --> 00:32:39.684
It's one where they realize they've got this vast resource of fertile land.

487
00:32:40.244 --> 00:32:40.905
They want to,

488
00:32:42.623 --> 00:32:45.828
exploit it for their agriculture, right, and for their society.

489
00:32:46.449 --> 00:32:57.746
Now, I want to be a bit nuanced here because I think a lot of takes about Amazon deforestation just blames Brazil and blames the farmers in Brazil and these developing countries.

490
00:32:58.567 --> 00:33:01.491
Let's take a look at Europe and let's take a look at America.

491
00:33:01.991 --> 00:33:02.252
Okay?

492
00:33:03.013 --> 00:33:10.041
The American prairie, for example, was a vast ecosystem that rivaled the African Serengeti.

493
00:33:10.842 --> 00:33:12.805
And what did we do to it when we came here?

494
00:33:13.225 --> 00:33:14.507
We turned it into farmland.

495
00:33:16.223 --> 00:33:19.307
Europe has no old growth forests left.

496
00:33:19.467 --> 00:33:21.108
Which is so crazy to me still.

497
00:33:21.189 --> 00:33:27.796
There's like one pocket in the Black Forest in Germany, in the southwest corner of Germany, near Freiburg.

498
00:33:28.116 --> 00:33:29.097
But that's about it.

499
00:33:29.918 --> 00:33:34.763
All of the old growth forest in Europe is done because the Industrial Revolution happened.

500
00:33:35.644 --> 00:33:37.206
The Agricultural Revolution happened.

501
00:33:37.606 --> 00:33:37.986
And they...

502
00:33:38.800 --> 00:33:39.901
They went at it, right?

503
00:33:40.242 --> 00:33:46.048
And so now we're coming upon developing nations that are trying to get that bag, right?

504
00:33:46.408 --> 00:33:54.977
It cannot be only on them to figure out a solution to make preservation of their forest sustainable, okay?

505
00:33:55.197 --> 00:33:57.800
You can't just be like, hey, stop cutting down trees.

506
00:33:59.241 --> 00:33:59.581
It's...

507
00:34:00.768 --> 00:34:01.629
I don't know what to do.

508
00:34:01.989 --> 00:34:03.711
I'm just saying it's not on them.

509
00:34:04.232 --> 00:34:06.013
I think this is – Does that make sense?

510
00:34:06.053 --> 00:34:12.560
It's true about a variety of different issues, which is like you have a generation of what we now call first world countries.

511
00:34:12.640 --> 00:34:12.900
Yeah.

512
00:34:13.461 --> 00:34:20.808
That were able to burn coal, tear down their natural environments in order to accrue a level of wealth –

513
00:34:21.569 --> 00:34:27.313
And socioeconomic status for some, not all of their people.

514
00:34:27.634 --> 00:34:29.075
And it's not evenly distributed.

515
00:34:29.135 --> 00:34:30.816
There's complexities about all of that.

516
00:34:31.356 --> 00:34:31.617
Yes.

517
00:34:32.297 --> 00:34:40.223
But comparatively to the majority of nations on the planet, there's this cohort of first world, quote unquote, first world countries.

518
00:34:40.323 --> 00:34:40.503
Right.

519
00:34:40.683 --> 00:34:42.445
That were the first across the finish line.

520
00:34:42.945 --> 00:34:45.567
So now you're having another batch.

521
00:34:45.867 --> 00:34:46.588
And these happen in batches.

522
00:34:46.608 --> 00:34:49.009
Now you're having the third, fourth, or fifth cohort.

523
00:34:49.450 --> 00:34:50.471
Try to do the same thing.

524
00:34:50.711 --> 00:34:55.714
This is where you see things like BRICS, Brazil, South Africa, China.

525
00:34:55.935 --> 00:34:57.095
China's already there, obviously.

526
00:34:57.295 --> 00:34:57.756
India.

527
00:34:57.836 --> 00:34:58.837
India in there.

528
00:34:58.857 --> 00:35:02.619
Who are now trying to effectively say, we're just doing what you did.

529
00:35:03.340 --> 00:35:07.843
And so, but now there's this almost holier than thou.

530
00:35:08.163 --> 00:35:10.145
Yeah, because they're the ones that have it left.

531
00:35:10.673 --> 00:35:10.913
Right.

532
00:35:11.053 --> 00:35:11.294
Right.

533
00:35:11.434 --> 00:35:11.654
Right.

534
00:35:11.774 --> 00:35:12.435
Because we have nothing.

535
00:35:12.475 --> 00:35:20.101
And now we're more of a globalized society with communications, with supply chain.

536
00:35:20.382 --> 00:35:27.748
And so the things happening over there impact what's happening over here much more than they did years ago, 100 years ago, 200 years ago.

537
00:35:28.149 --> 00:35:29.950
And so I think your point is –

538
00:35:32.250 --> 00:35:34.111
We need to have a broader discussion.

539
00:35:34.351 --> 00:35:36.072
Yeah, it's got to be a global solution.

540
00:35:36.232 --> 00:35:36.492
Right.

541
00:35:36.952 --> 00:35:49.797
Because we can't just, again, ignore that what's driving so much of the climate problem and all these other things is because of the things that the first groups that went through did –

542
00:35:50.918 --> 00:35:52.519
Not the ones we're trying to go through now.

543
00:35:53.160 --> 00:35:54.141
Oh, sorry.

544
00:35:55.202 --> 00:35:56.803
I destroyed all the road behind me.

545
00:35:56.903 --> 00:35:59.846
But like, no, you can't use natural resources to repave it.

546
00:36:00.167 --> 00:36:00.367
Yeah.

547
00:36:00.687 --> 00:36:03.069
It's like, no, I want a good economy.

548
00:36:03.490 --> 00:36:05.191
I want air conditioning all the time.

549
00:36:05.231 --> 00:36:05.412
Right.

550
00:36:05.612 --> 00:36:05.832
Right.

551
00:36:06.192 --> 00:36:08.915
I want to use plastics all the time like you guys are.

552
00:36:09.993 --> 00:36:11.774
So it's a weird take.

553
00:36:11.814 --> 00:36:14.235
I'm probably going to get some hate, but that's what I think.

554
00:36:14.355 --> 00:36:21.419
I think like with everything, unfortunately, have you heard this like bean soup theory?

555
00:36:21.760 --> 00:36:22.360
Let me not go there.

556
00:36:22.580 --> 00:36:26.162
But we just everything there's there.

557
00:36:26.382 --> 00:36:30.204
We need to just there's a lot of we live in a complex adaptive system.

558
00:36:30.264 --> 00:36:30.505
Yeah.

559
00:36:31.085 --> 00:36:32.666
And there are a lot of variables that go into that.

560
00:36:33.326 --> 00:36:37.948
And there's a rush to say it's either this or it's that.

561
00:36:38.248 --> 00:36:39.168
Yeah.

562
00:36:39.569 --> 00:36:45.351
And 99.9% of the time, it's like a little bit of this, a little bit of that, a little bit of this, a little bit of that.

563
00:36:46.071 --> 00:36:49.513
We need to be able to have complex, nuanced conversations.

564
00:36:49.773 --> 00:36:58.776
And it is in all of our benefit to prevent catastrophic ecosystem collapse.

565
00:36:59.697 --> 00:37:02.758
And it is not going to be solved by any one nation.

566
00:37:03.170 --> 00:37:04.210
Yeah, I agree.

567
00:37:04.290 --> 00:37:05.011
At the end of the day.

568
00:37:06.011 --> 00:37:07.492
But this is a sensitive issue.

569
00:37:08.252 --> 00:37:10.332
Obviously, people have very strong opinions about it.

570
00:37:12.293 --> 00:37:14.454
This is a record-level El Nino year.

571
00:37:14.654 --> 00:37:15.534
Yeah.

572
00:37:15.894 --> 00:37:21.796
If you're in Europe, y'all have been having fires going on right now that you do not have the infrastructure to deal with.

573
00:37:22.317 --> 00:37:24.757
Canada has been having fires that are taking over everywhere.

574
00:37:25.458 --> 00:37:27.518
I think it was Seattle, Washington?

575
00:37:27.778 --> 00:37:28.359
Yes, I heard.

576
00:37:28.719 --> 00:37:29.079
Burning.

577
00:37:29.699 --> 00:37:31.960
And look, when I was growing up,

578
00:37:32.937 --> 00:37:33.977
That wasn't what it was like.

579
00:37:34.057 --> 00:37:34.418
Yeah.

580
00:37:34.658 --> 00:37:38.559
So it's progressing fast.

581
00:37:38.699 --> 00:37:42.781
We cannot ignore the reality that's in front of our face.

582
00:37:43.381 --> 00:37:44.801
And it's okay to just talk about it.

583
00:37:45.081 --> 00:37:46.282
We're not prescribing an answer.

584
00:37:46.562 --> 00:37:48.843
We're not saying you can't have plastic straws.

585
00:37:49.363 --> 00:37:55.385
But maybe these large industrial companies need to be a little bit more responsible.

586
00:37:55.465 --> 00:37:55.685
Yeah.

587
00:37:56.265 --> 00:37:57.146
And perhaps we make...

588
00:37:58.046 --> 00:38:19.202
them responsible we make them you know we don't we don't be like please hey can you can you save the can you not like mess up our only home our only home in this vast emptiness can you maybe like try to try to try to not mess up the only home that we have yeah

589
00:38:20.724 --> 00:38:22.465
This was a tangent, as you can see.

590
00:38:23.125 --> 00:38:29.408
We try to keep it tight, but these are complex issues, and sometimes we just need to get it off our chest.

591
00:38:29.868 --> 00:38:34.070
So I think we've earned the right to have a little social-political commentary.

592
00:38:34.090 --> 00:38:36.332
And actually, wait, one more thing before you move on.

593
00:38:36.872 --> 00:38:41.114
I wanted to do a mental exercise, because we're talking about...

594
00:38:42.740 --> 00:38:58.531
We're talking about modern civilization now, us with LiDAR and things like that, coming in and seeing old, old infrastructure and old civilizations, and we're trying to judge the capabilities of the civilizations based on what they've left behind.

595
00:38:58.952 --> 00:39:03.315
For example, with Egypt, we can guess that their economy was insane.

596
00:39:03.455 --> 00:39:08.719
With something like Rome building the Colosseum, we can guess that the economy was insane.

597
00:39:09.599 --> 00:39:10.660
So suppose like...

598
00:39:12.027 --> 00:39:14.129
something crazy happened, right?

599
00:39:14.230 --> 00:39:15.451
And like humans died.

600
00:39:15.932 --> 00:39:16.132
Yeah.

601
00:39:17.153 --> 00:39:20.437
And aliens came back in like a million years, right?

602
00:39:20.537 --> 00:39:22.079
In some insane amount of time.

603
00:39:22.239 --> 00:39:24.601
Like what would they see and what would they judge from us?

604
00:39:25.242 --> 00:39:26.123
I was thinking about this.

605
00:39:26.604 --> 00:39:30.168
Like, for example, even if Earth looks very, very different –

606
00:39:31.211 --> 00:39:35.452
There's quite a possibility that, like, the moon is not going to look that different.

607
00:39:35.872 --> 00:39:42.814
And so if they saw, like, the remnants of Apollo 11 and all of our Apollo missions, they'd be like, this is crazy.

608
00:39:42.834 --> 00:39:44.034
Yeah, they got from there.

609
00:39:44.054 --> 00:39:47.455
They got off that planet with a pretty strong gravitational field.

610
00:39:47.495 --> 00:39:47.695
Yeah.

611
00:39:48.175 --> 00:39:50.256
And, like, it seems they walked around.

612
00:39:50.276 --> 00:39:51.816
There's, like, footprints and stuff.

613
00:39:52.076 --> 00:39:53.677
Because the footprints aren't going to go away.

614
00:39:53.697 --> 00:39:53.877
Right.

615
00:39:54.117 --> 00:39:58.100
Like, there's not enough meteor impacts for the footprints to grow.

616
00:39:58.461 --> 00:39:59.842
They got a car with, like, wheels.

617
00:40:00.202 --> 00:40:02.224
I think they'll know what wheels are, right?

618
00:40:02.304 --> 00:40:04.626
And they might be like, damn.

619
00:40:04.806 --> 00:40:05.687
They were so close.

620
00:40:05.747 --> 00:40:06.568
They were pretty good.

621
00:40:06.588 --> 00:40:07.108
Yeah.

622
00:40:07.168 --> 00:40:09.270
They almost escaped a single point of failure.

623
00:40:09.290 --> 00:40:09.490
Yeah.

624
00:40:09.851 --> 00:40:14.855
Or, like, if they came on Earth, right, and they went and they saw CERN, which is underground.

625
00:40:14.915 --> 00:40:17.958
So it might be, it might be like...

626
00:40:18.798 --> 00:40:21.482
shielded from vegetation loss, right?

627
00:40:21.542 --> 00:40:22.543
And atmospheric loss.

628
00:40:22.563 --> 00:40:24.004
Like I can imagine like Manhattan.

629
00:40:26.094 --> 00:40:28.315
All of the buildings might crumble and fall.

630
00:40:28.515 --> 00:40:30.236
Maybe the steel will still be there.

631
00:40:30.296 --> 00:40:38.621
And the fact that we have pure steel in these sort of columns, they might be like, this is pretty cool.

632
00:40:38.641 --> 00:40:41.463
It'll be just a bunch of pointies coming out of the ground.

633
00:40:41.483 --> 00:40:42.143
Yeah.

634
00:40:42.503 --> 00:40:45.625
But CERN, for example, it's underground and it's a giant thing.

635
00:40:45.965 --> 00:40:48.407
And there's massive magnets, right?

636
00:40:48.427 --> 00:40:50.568
There's going to be wires of pure copper, right?

637
00:40:50.868 --> 00:41:13.351
and silicon and all of this other stuff they're gonna look at that and be like this is nice i like this yeah right yeah like that those are the things that i think would be our pyramids yeah right if the aliens came down and searched for our pyramids or our coliseum yeah they would they would find cern and ligo and the moon landing you know i think that's kind of cool to think about

638
00:41:14.745 --> 00:41:24.054
As a last note on that, it's sort of like for civilizations that came before us, large-scale infrastructure was the thing that was signature of it.

639
00:41:24.474 --> 00:41:32.061
For our generation, it's almost like large-scale – I don't want to use scientific loosely, but like this instrumentation.

640
00:41:32.081 --> 00:41:32.322
Yeah.

641
00:41:33.002 --> 00:41:57.042
um that's like pure and like yeah you know what i mean it's like single focus single function it's not to honor some dead pharaoh it's not to facilitate the transfer of goods and services it's purely it kind of speaks to oh we they became a curiosity based yeah civilization where they had some level of abundance or sustainability

642
00:41:57.422 --> 00:42:04.847
not evenly distributed, that allowed them to spend money on things that didn't have a direct functional outcome to their own survival.

643
00:42:04.887 --> 00:42:05.267
Exactly, yeah.

644
00:42:05.287 --> 00:42:06.308
That's really interesting.

645
00:42:06.508 --> 00:42:06.968
It is, right?

646
00:42:06.988 --> 00:42:07.669
That's really interesting.

647
00:42:07.689 --> 00:42:11.091
Because they would look at CERN and they would see the electromagnets.

648
00:42:11.131 --> 00:42:15.094
They would see the solenoids of the copper becoming electromagnets.

649
00:42:15.334 --> 00:42:23.099
And they could probably discern, because they know the laws of electromagnetism, that these were giant magnets that were curving the thing, you know?

650
00:42:23.599 --> 00:42:28.621
And there's these giant centers where the two beams sort of meet.

651
00:42:28.981 --> 00:42:30.702
So you see the two beams meeting up.

652
00:42:30.722 --> 00:42:35.403
And then right where those two beams meet up, coincidentally, there's a giant detector, right?

653
00:42:35.464 --> 00:42:38.365
That's the size of, like, a building underground.

654
00:42:38.725 --> 00:42:41.506
So maybe that's a particle collider.

655
00:42:41.526 --> 00:42:42.046
Like, you know?

656
00:42:42.666 --> 00:42:43.266
That's really good.

657
00:42:43.306 --> 00:42:43.567
I know.

658
00:42:43.587 --> 00:42:44.127
That's a good one.

659
00:42:44.247 --> 00:42:45.247
I like that.

660
00:42:45.347 --> 00:42:47.268
I was just thinking, whenever I think about, like...

661
00:42:48.495 --> 00:42:49.135
Old stuff.

662
00:42:49.396 --> 00:42:49.576
Yeah.

663
00:42:49.656 --> 00:42:55.660
I think what would a civilization 10,000 years, a million years from now look at us and say, damn, that was sick.

664
00:42:55.800 --> 00:42:56.020
Yeah.

665
00:42:56.120 --> 00:42:56.300
Right?

666
00:42:56.560 --> 00:42:59.462
If the International Space Station is still floating around.

667
00:42:59.502 --> 00:43:00.162
It's still floating around.

668
00:43:00.222 --> 00:43:03.785
Probably not because it's going to – Yeah, it's going to – But like if it was –

669
00:43:04.705 --> 00:43:06.046
Actually, James Webb Space Telescope.

670
00:43:06.066 --> 00:43:06.586
Yeah, that will be.

671
00:43:06.606 --> 00:43:08.907
That thing is at Lagrange 2 or something, right?

672
00:43:08.927 --> 00:43:10.867
That's like way off of Earth orbit.

673
00:43:10.887 --> 00:43:13.848
So that thing is just going to be following us around the sun.

674
00:43:13.868 --> 00:43:14.909
Like if they saw that.

675
00:43:15.129 --> 00:43:16.670
It's a techno signature, you know?

676
00:43:16.750 --> 00:43:16.950
Yeah.

677
00:43:17.070 --> 00:43:19.250
If they saw that, they'd be like, this is insane.

678
00:43:19.671 --> 00:43:19.871
Yeah.

679
00:43:19.891 --> 00:43:20.171
Right?

680
00:43:20.191 --> 00:43:21.111
They were looking for us.

681
00:43:21.231 --> 00:43:22.012
Yeah.

682
00:43:22.032 --> 00:43:23.232
We just came a little late.

683
00:43:23.252 --> 00:43:24.192
We missed the train to the train.

684
00:43:24.432 --> 00:43:33.656
That's really interesting because when you – a lot of times people in sports and entertainment and media or whatever, even in life, think about legacy.

685
00:43:33.796 --> 00:43:33.996
Yeah.

686
00:43:34.559 --> 00:43:36.779
But I always talk about things at like three scales.

687
00:43:36.799 --> 00:43:39.220
You have the individual or four scales.

688
00:43:39.240 --> 00:43:46.802
You have the individual unit, the family unit, your like community unit, which could be neighborhood, city, state, nation state.

689
00:43:47.362 --> 00:43:49.162
And then you have the civilizational unit.

690
00:43:49.542 --> 00:43:57.964
And a lot of times the legacy conversation is talked about in the individual, family, or neighborhood like context.

691
00:43:58.064 --> 00:43:58.164
Yeah.

692
00:43:58.184 --> 00:43:58.304
Yeah.

693
00:43:58.944 --> 00:44:02.289
What is our civilizational legacy to an outside observer?

694
00:44:02.329 --> 00:44:02.569
Yes.

695
00:44:02.930 --> 00:44:04.272
If we were to just disappear.

696
00:44:04.652 --> 00:44:05.073
Right now.

697
00:44:05.133 --> 00:44:07.316
Like for our generation, not for the past.

698
00:44:07.336 --> 00:44:07.536
Yeah.

699
00:44:07.857 --> 00:44:09.679
That's a...

700
00:44:09.819 --> 00:44:10.861
I'm going to think about that more.

701
00:44:11.201 --> 00:44:11.441
Yeah.

702
00:44:11.502 --> 00:44:12.964
I really do like that quite a bit.

703
00:44:13.404 --> 00:44:14.566
I really do like that quite a bit.

704
00:44:14.926 --> 00:44:15.107
And...

705
00:44:16.394 --> 00:44:30.841
you might all know what's coming next because this kind of just fascinating, incredible, deep, and fun conversation is brought to you by From First Principles.

706
00:44:32.462 --> 00:44:36.143
We currently are just the two of us, as we mentioned earlier.

707
00:44:36.563 --> 00:44:39.244
And so now we have to shill the pod a little bit.

708
00:44:39.804 --> 00:44:42.544
For those of you who are listening for the first time, welcome.

709
00:44:42.704 --> 00:44:43.605
The water's warm.

710
00:44:43.825 --> 00:44:45.145
FFP Nation is growing.

711
00:44:45.585 --> 00:44:50.586
One of the best ways that you can support the show, that we can continue to have these fascinating conversations.

712
00:44:50.986 --> 00:44:55.407
Like, share, comment, subscribe on any of the platforms you may listen to us on.

713
00:44:55.748 --> 00:44:58.288
We're available as a video podcast on Spotify.

714
00:44:58.708 --> 00:45:01.349
Coming soon in video to Apple Podcasts.

715
00:45:01.829 --> 00:45:02.889
So keep an eye out for that.

716
00:45:03.550 --> 00:45:07.131
You can also listen to us on your favorite podcast app.

717
00:45:07.251 --> 00:45:09.251
We're on all the podcast applications.

718
00:45:09.691 --> 00:45:21.635
Our website, ffppod.com, has the research papers we talked about, including the one we just talked about in this past Amazon story, which, again, was in Nature in July 2026.

719
00:45:21.675 --> 00:45:28.137
This was out of the Ibero-American Institute of Finland and the University of Helsinki.

720
00:45:28.937 --> 00:45:38.026
about LiDAR scanning to penetrate through the canopy in the Amazon to learn that it was much more populated and dense than we did before.

721
00:45:38.466 --> 00:45:45.973
If you would like to support this show monetarily in this economy, you can go to ffppod.com backslash donate.

722
00:45:46.513 --> 00:45:53.780
One thing we've not talked about before but is going to be super helpful for us, if you're listening on Spotify and Apple, a five-star podcast,

723
00:45:54.120 --> 00:45:58.525
review will do wonders for us to get this to more people.

724
00:45:59.606 --> 00:46:08.556
And if you are in the journal club or have technical, curious or science friends to talk to, this is a great show to send over to them.

725
00:46:09.477 --> 00:46:13.358
For those of you watching our clips, send them in groups, send them to DMs.

726
00:46:13.658 --> 00:46:17.940
The clips is the best way to onboard people to being scientifically curious.

727
00:46:18.280 --> 00:46:33.104
And I want to just do a reminder before we get into wrapping up the episode with the books that we are going to add into the library that we are trying to build community around the show as we enter year two.

728
00:46:33.784 --> 00:46:37.107
Part of what we need to understand is who are our listeners.

729
00:46:37.287 --> 00:46:42.291
And so we have our giveaway where we're going to have merch given out.

730
00:46:42.592 --> 00:46:43.312
Then we're going to choose.

731
00:46:43.332 --> 00:46:44.713
We're going to start with 10 people.

732
00:46:45.694 --> 00:46:46.295
10 people.

733
00:46:46.715 --> 00:46:47.876
We might increase it to 20.

734
00:46:47.896 --> 00:46:51.920
It's going to get some of our free merch, not just what we have on right now.

735
00:46:52.340 --> 00:46:58.303
You can go to our shop and see all the other stuff, T-shirts, sweaters, swag bags.

736
00:46:58.343 --> 00:47:00.344
We have a great field notebook.

737
00:47:00.664 --> 00:47:01.845
There's a ton of stuff in there.

738
00:47:02.385 --> 00:47:11.389
If you can complete our survey to help us better understand what you want us to do in our second year, that's over at ffppod.com backslash survey.

739
00:47:11.650 --> 00:47:14.231
To all of those who say, what does Lester do on the show?

740
00:47:14.671 --> 00:47:15.632
I shill the website.

741
00:47:20.479 --> 00:47:25.014
And so we are now going to transition into the christening

742
00:47:26.258 --> 00:47:31.301
of our brand new library, which just a bunch of shelves behind us.

743
00:47:31.661 --> 00:47:38.604
So you can see some of the books that Krishna has put together for our inaugural christening of the FFP library.

744
00:47:38.784 --> 00:47:43.286
So for those of you who are watching, as you can see, there's an empty set of three floating shelves behind us.

745
00:47:43.346 --> 00:47:47.689
And we're going to christen our new library with some of the books here.

746
00:47:47.789 --> 00:47:49.469
And we're going to do it one shelf at a time.

747
00:47:49.790 --> 00:47:54.152
So Krishna, what are we going to put into the library?

748
00:47:54.893 --> 00:47:57.618
with our first shelf here in the collection.

749
00:47:57.638 --> 00:48:00.023
We have two piles, different contexts.

750
00:48:00.324 --> 00:48:02.328
So what is our first set of books?

751
00:48:02.861 --> 00:48:07.382
Yeah, so I thought a lot about what we were trying to put in the shelves.

752
00:48:08.262 --> 00:48:18.004
The first shelf I want to christen with the textbooks that made me the, you know, physicist, thinker, whatever you want to call it, that I am.

753
00:48:18.224 --> 00:48:22.905
I'm going to start with mathematics, and then we're going to go into physics and biology, okay?

754
00:48:23.425 --> 00:48:30.466
So, the first mathematics book, Baby Rudin, Principles of Mathematical Analysis,

755
00:48:32.642 --> 00:48:38.612
This is called Baby Rudin because I cried like a baby while I was reading this thing.

756
00:48:39.494 --> 00:48:42.098
This was my first semester at Princeton University.

757
00:48:42.859 --> 00:48:44.502
There was a course called Math 215.

758
00:48:46.465 --> 00:48:49.708
It was called analysis in a single variable.

759
00:48:50.109 --> 00:48:51.150
That was the tagline.

760
00:48:51.450 --> 00:48:56.836
And then the description in the syllabus was analysis in a single variable.

761
00:48:56.916 --> 00:49:01.360
I get to the first lecture, and it's Peter Sarnak, who is a legend in mathematics.

762
00:49:01.380 --> 00:49:04.523
He's got this thick South African accent.

763
00:49:04.884 --> 00:49:06.746
And he goes, what is a number?

764
00:49:07.106 --> 00:49:08.848
And I'm like, what are we talking about?

765
00:49:10.629 --> 00:49:10.949
And right?

766
00:49:11.569 --> 00:49:13.050
What's going on?

767
00:49:14.150 --> 00:49:15.091
And this is the book.

768
00:49:15.151 --> 00:49:17.211
This is the textbook for it.

769
00:49:17.351 --> 00:49:19.012
It was an insane course.

770
00:49:19.072 --> 00:49:22.173
It was one of the most formative courses in my life.

771
00:49:23.033 --> 00:49:28.755
The first lecture we get into what it means to be a number, what it means to be a real number.

772
00:49:28.795 --> 00:49:35.857
That's stuff that I was talking to you about, countability, and the fact that real numbers are uncountable, but rational numbers are countable.

773
00:49:36.957 --> 00:49:42.820
And there's functions that are continuous everywhere, but you can't differentiate anywhere.

774
00:49:43.120 --> 00:49:45.161
It's like really, really strange things.

775
00:49:45.621 --> 00:49:48.323
Basically, it's the foundations of calculus.

776
00:49:48.943 --> 00:49:54.606
Because when Newton invented it, like every good physicist, he was very hand-wavy.

777
00:49:54.786 --> 00:49:56.567
He was like, limits approach.

778
00:49:57.567 --> 00:49:58.328
And it's obvious.

779
00:49:58.448 --> 00:50:04.051
And for most smooth functions that we deal with on a day-to-day basis as physicists...

780
00:50:04.711 --> 00:50:06.032
it's totally fine, right?

781
00:50:06.292 --> 00:50:11.477
And as a physicist, I can totally understand why he would choose to present calculus that way.

782
00:50:11.817 --> 00:50:18.523
But pretty soon, like within about 50 years of him saying all that and 100 years of him saying all that, mathematicians start saying, well, what about this?

783
00:50:18.883 --> 00:50:19.644
And what about that?

784
00:50:20.004 --> 00:50:23.608
And it turns out there's like functions that are completely non-intuitive,

785
00:50:24.974 --> 00:50:35.267
There's functions that are continuous everywhere, meaning I can take a pen and I can draw it out theoretically, but I could never find a slope anywhere on that function.

786
00:50:35.287 --> 00:50:37.650
That's a really weird thing to do.

787
00:50:39.172 --> 00:50:41.735
Baby Rudin, Principles of Mathematical Analysis.

788
00:50:43.508 --> 00:50:45.509
Honestly, a great time.

789
00:50:45.869 --> 00:50:49.990
Once you get over the trauma and everything, it's an amazing, amazing book.

790
00:50:50.810 --> 00:50:51.831
I'll take it here, actually.

791
00:50:51.851 --> 00:50:52.611
Oh, okay, yeah.

792
00:50:52.631 --> 00:50:53.171
Yes, yes.

793
00:50:53.631 --> 00:50:53.931
All right.

794
00:50:54.632 --> 00:51:02.174
Next one is actually, it's my favorite course that I ever took at Princeton University.

795
00:51:02.514 --> 00:51:06.115
My favorite course that I ever took at Princeton University was a mathematics course.

796
00:51:06.255 --> 00:51:09.236
It was not a physics course, even though I was a physics major.

797
00:51:09.796 --> 00:51:11.237
It was complex analysis.

798
00:51:12.674 --> 00:51:16.097
The author, Elias Stein, was actually my professor at the time.

799
00:51:16.898 --> 00:51:19.780
He's also the PhD advisor of Terence Tao.

800
00:51:20.381 --> 00:51:20.481
Ah.

801
00:51:20.701 --> 00:51:23.623
So we've got a lot of Terence Tao in the comments lately.

802
00:51:23.663 --> 00:51:24.464
Yeah.

803
00:51:24.924 --> 00:51:27.407
This book is absolutely amazing.

804
00:51:27.887 --> 00:51:31.510
It is not like Baby Rudin because this is gentle.

805
00:51:32.111 --> 00:51:33.332
This brings you in.

806
00:51:33.992 --> 00:51:35.734
And it treats you fairly.

807
00:51:36.154 --> 00:51:37.876
And it treats you like you're a human being.

808
00:51:37.896 --> 00:51:37.996
Yeah.

809
00:51:38.816 --> 00:51:44.502
And it goes on to show some of the most beautiful things in mathematics.

810
00:51:44.642 --> 00:51:56.132
It starts with the invention of i, the imaginary number, and it goes on to talk about the Cauchy-Riemann equations, how to take integrals in the complex plane.

811
00:51:57.073 --> 00:52:02.258
It talks about the Riemann zeta function.

812
00:52:02.897 --> 00:52:08.420
It talks about the prime number function, which is how many prime numbers there are as you get higher and higher.

813
00:52:08.440 --> 00:52:12.563
It turns out it's related to the log of how high you get.

814
00:52:14.264 --> 00:52:25.090
And have you ever heard that weird math thing that's like all of the numbers added up, like 1 plus 2 plus 3 plus 4, all of them added up to infinity is negative 1 twelfth?

815
00:52:25.800 --> 00:52:26.080
No.

816
00:52:26.400 --> 00:52:28.801
Okay, that's something that we can get into.

817
00:52:29.081 --> 00:52:33.303
But it turns out the sum of all the natural numbers is negative 112.

818
00:52:33.844 --> 00:52:35.684
And this is the key to understanding that.

819
00:52:35.905 --> 00:52:36.865
Complex analysis.

820
00:52:37.205 --> 00:52:44.488
It has to do with holomorphic functions and the fact that everything is okay in complex analysis.

821
00:52:44.768 --> 00:52:48.470
Stuff that is not allowed in real analysis becomes allowed in complex analysis.

822
00:52:48.810 --> 00:52:50.131
It's absolutely beautiful.

823
00:52:50.631 --> 00:52:51.471
It's my favorite thing.

824
00:52:51.591 --> 00:52:54.993
If you would like us to cover it, let us know in the comments.

825
00:52:56.702 --> 00:53:00.984
Finally, the next one, I lost the cover to this, but this is also Elias Stein.

826
00:53:01.004 --> 00:53:03.606
This is part of his analysis series.

827
00:53:03.966 --> 00:53:05.227
This is Fourier analysis.

828
00:53:05.947 --> 00:53:09.209
This was instrumental for physics in general, right?

829
00:53:09.369 --> 00:53:11.390
Understanding Fourier analysis.

830
00:53:11.751 --> 00:53:16.073
There's a lot of really non-intuitive things about Fourier analysis.

831
00:53:16.093 --> 00:53:19.515
Like the fact that I can add up a bunch of sines and cosines...

832
00:53:19.858 --> 00:53:25.183
And I can get a convergent function, but then the derivative of that function can be divergent, which is really weird.

833
00:53:25.203 --> 00:53:30.669
Like, the derivative will blow up, but the function itself will approach, like, a really nice steady value.

834
00:53:30.789 --> 00:53:33.792
Again, really weird things.

835
00:53:33.812 --> 00:53:40.418
This was a great course, but this was actually the last course in higher mathematics that I took at Princeton University.

836
00:53:40.779 --> 00:53:43.702
I also took, at the same time, algebra with Galois theory.

837
00:53:44.302 --> 00:53:48.284
The textbook is not here because I don't want to talk about that experience.

838
00:53:48.304 --> 00:53:50.365
It is not getting added to the collection.

839
00:53:50.385 --> 00:53:53.087
That's not getting added because I don't want to talk about that experience.

840
00:53:53.547 --> 00:53:54.988
That's a class that I PDFed.

841
00:53:55.228 --> 00:53:56.449
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

842
00:53:56.509 --> 00:53:58.590
Remember when we could do pass, defail?

843
00:53:58.750 --> 00:53:59.250
I passed.

844
00:53:59.370 --> 00:53:59.831
I passed.

845
00:53:59.931 --> 00:54:01.411
I did not get a D or a fail.

846
00:54:01.471 --> 00:54:06.574
No D, no F. But I don't want to think about what the letter would have been had I not done that.

847
00:54:06.914 --> 00:54:11.497
This is not a file that you can open in Adobe having a class that's PDFed.

848
00:54:11.870 --> 00:54:12.150
Yeah.

849
00:54:12.451 --> 00:54:23.361
Is not maybe a Princeton-specific thing, but... Usually it's just pass-fail, but Princeton's one of those like, I'll give you a D. So you got to work a little bit.

850
00:54:23.401 --> 00:54:24.863
Remember that selection process.

851
00:54:24.883 --> 00:54:25.363
Yeah, yeah.

852
00:54:26.184 --> 00:54:26.444
All right.

853
00:54:26.484 --> 00:54:27.726
So that was the mathematics.

854
00:54:27.966 --> 00:54:29.627
Now let's get into the physics.

855
00:54:29.788 --> 00:54:32.250
The first physics textbook I'd like to talk about...

856
00:54:33.422 --> 00:54:34.623
is again, the Bible.

857
00:54:35.204 --> 00:54:37.326
This is Landau Lifshitz Mechanics.

858
00:54:37.946 --> 00:54:43.991
A lot of the viewers and a lot of the grad students in the audience will know this book by a different way.

859
00:54:44.992 --> 00:55:10.108
cover okay they're gonna know the the newer version with like there's like circles and like yellow circles everywhere this is the original um version that my dad actually gave me um and it's one that he wants back dad you're not gonna get this back okay this this was a formative experience because this was classical mechanics um my second year first semester um this is a crazy textbook this is by lev landau who's the

860
00:55:11.028 --> 00:55:13.230
legendary Russian physicist.

861
00:55:14.611 --> 00:55:19.154
In the first two pages, he proves that mass cannot be negative.

862
00:55:20.555 --> 00:55:20.795
Okay?

863
00:55:20.935 --> 00:55:21.856
In the first two pages.

864
00:55:22.156 --> 00:55:24.538
And I remember reading this going, this is insane.

865
00:55:25.198 --> 00:55:32.503
That, like, we just take for granted as an axiom the axiom of least action.

866
00:55:32.764 --> 00:55:34.505
That, like, everything goes by least action.

867
00:55:34.525 --> 00:55:36.166
You have, like, a Lagrangian and stuff like that.

868
00:55:36.446 --> 00:55:38.688
And from that, you can prove that mass is negative.

869
00:55:38.708 --> 00:55:38.868
Yeah.

870
00:55:38.928 --> 00:55:42.891
And then a lot of the problems in here are just like insanely hard.

871
00:55:43.191 --> 00:55:45.413
And he has problems and solutions.

872
00:55:45.613 --> 00:55:54.459
There's a colloquial saying about Landau-Lifschitz, which is not a thought of Lifschitz, not a word from Landau.

873
00:55:54.519 --> 00:55:55.700
Because Landau was kind of...

874
00:55:56.480 --> 00:56:22.451
narrating and lift shits is the guy who typed this this sounds like the show yeah you're the guy narrating and i'm the guy who types but this this absolutely an amazing textbook um formative for classical mechanics and it's a textbook that that i definitely used um this also reminds me of all the rugrats fans out there dr lip shits uh the doctor and rugrats slightly different pronunciation

875
00:56:23.487 --> 00:56:24.609
equally impactful.

876
00:56:25.309 --> 00:56:25.790
Definitely.

877
00:56:27.292 --> 00:56:29.674
Next one on our list of textbooks.

878
00:56:30.575 --> 00:56:32.477
We've alluded to this before.

879
00:56:32.677 --> 00:56:34.760
Thermodynamics by Enrico Fermi.

880
00:56:36.762 --> 00:56:39.685
This is one of those where he treats you like a human being.

881
00:56:41.376 --> 00:56:42.617
He treats you like a human being.

882
00:56:43.217 --> 00:56:44.738
Enrico Fermi, Thermodynamics.

883
00:56:44.758 --> 00:56:47.359
This is a great textbook for intro thermodynamics.

884
00:56:47.680 --> 00:56:51.242
You don't want to get into statistical mechanics and the theory of atoms and things like that.

885
00:56:51.262 --> 00:56:54.384
You just want to talk about heat, temperature, entropy.

886
00:56:55.124 --> 00:56:57.225
This is an amazing, amazing read.

887
00:56:57.705 --> 00:56:58.866
Really short, you can tell.

888
00:56:59.627 --> 00:57:01.308
But just really informative.

889
00:57:01.768 --> 00:57:04.870
PV equals NRT, equations of state of gases.

890
00:57:06.077 --> 00:57:06.977
Absolutely amazing.

891
00:57:07.418 --> 00:57:23.865
And also on our ranking in our Oppenheimer Scientist ranking episode, which if you have not watched, is a fantastic deep dive in the concentration of brilliance and genius that was applied to, unfortunately, the nuclear program.

892
00:57:24.025 --> 00:57:27.570
Yeah, and I think Enrico Fermi was top five in that, right?

893
00:57:27.810 --> 00:57:28.110
Yes, yes.

894
00:57:28.131 --> 00:57:29.052
And totally deserved.

895
00:57:29.072 --> 00:57:29.753
Totally deserved.

896
00:57:30.213 --> 00:57:31.295
Okay, next one.

897
00:57:31.655 --> 00:57:35.901
So I gave you the first textbook on classical mechanics, which was Landau-Lifschutz.

898
00:57:35.941 --> 00:57:36.141
Yes.

899
00:57:36.662 --> 00:57:38.664
This next one is the bane of my existence.

900
00:57:40.066 --> 00:57:41.869
Goldstein, classical mechanics.

901
00:57:42.970 --> 00:57:44.010
Look at how thick this is.

902
00:57:45.031 --> 00:57:47.472
And then it's just the worst.

903
00:57:47.852 --> 00:57:49.132
It's just the absolute worst.

904
00:57:49.633 --> 00:57:54.154
It's so dense, and it covers literally everything that has to do with classical mechanics.

905
00:57:54.735 --> 00:57:56.355
But the problems are insane.

906
00:57:56.915 --> 00:58:03.658
Like, no reasonable person would assign more than two in a homework problem.

907
00:58:03.718 --> 00:58:04.938
And guess how many we got?

908
00:58:05.059 --> 00:58:05.999
A lot more than two.

909
00:58:06.019 --> 00:58:06.559
A lot more than two.

910
00:58:06.619 --> 00:58:06.899
Okay?

911
00:58:07.179 --> 00:58:08.180
So, Goldstein.

912
00:58:08.200 --> 00:58:08.420
Classic.

913
00:58:08.440 --> 00:58:08.600
Classic.

914
00:58:10.199 --> 00:58:18.969
You know, a lot of trauma with this textbook, but I do know classical mechanics really well now because of this, right?

915
00:58:19.249 --> 00:58:26.537
And this is a really good precursor to learning quantum mechanics because this goes over kind of the subtleties.

916
00:58:26.958 --> 00:58:30.121
It goes over Poisson brackets really well, which is something that...

917
00:58:30.813 --> 00:58:33.535
becomes commutators in quantum mechanics.

918
00:58:33.676 --> 00:58:38.400
So it's like a kind of really nice bridge between classical and quantum mechanics.

919
00:58:38.680 --> 00:58:40.762
It's still a terrible textbook, I have to say.

920
00:58:40.862 --> 00:58:44.165
It doesn't explain stuff, but the problems are pretty insane.

921
00:58:45.306 --> 00:58:55.174
If you want some light summer reading as you get ready for year two of FFP, pick up the second edition of classical mechanics.

922
00:58:55.354 --> 00:58:57.576
All right, here's another bane of my existence.

923
00:58:57.636 --> 00:58:57.757
Okay.

924
00:58:58.542 --> 00:59:01.205
Jackson, classical electrodynamics.

925
00:59:01.766 --> 00:59:05.631
I think every physicist would agree that this is the bane of their existence.

926
00:59:06.191 --> 00:59:06.431
Okay?

927
00:59:07.172 --> 00:59:11.878
Most physicists learn electrodynamics first using the Griffiths textbook.

928
00:59:12.479 --> 00:59:13.540
It's a great textbook.

929
00:59:13.660 --> 00:59:14.421
I don't have it here.

930
00:59:15.622 --> 00:59:15.803
But...

931
00:59:16.635 --> 00:59:20.117
That's the one that I first learned electromagnetism with.

932
00:59:20.777 --> 00:59:26.959
This is the second version of that, where it's like, okay, now let's talk about the real stuff.

933
00:59:27.039 --> 00:59:31.121
This is where, like, if you want to know how antennas work, this is it.

934
00:59:31.441 --> 00:59:39.445
If you want to know how light propagates through random medium, even if the medium is not homogenous, it's like a really weird medium, this is where it happens.

935
00:59:39.465 --> 00:59:40.105
Yeah.

936
00:59:41.534 --> 00:59:53.022
What's kind of cool about this is there are problems in this textbook that require a lot of thought, but there are also things that now I encounter in my research and in my job.

937
00:59:53.082 --> 00:59:57.125
Like I work at a quantum computing company where we're doing spin qubits, right?

938
00:59:57.465 --> 01:00:04.070
And part of confining individual electrons to create spin qubits is to create a kind of...

939
01:00:05.168 --> 01:00:15.594
egg carton-like landscape of potentials where it's like positive 5 volts, negative 5 volts, and so on and so forth, that geometry is a homework problem in Jackson.

940
01:00:15.974 --> 01:00:20.356
Why he would think that's a reasonable homework problem, I'm not sure.

941
01:00:20.896 --> 01:00:21.737
Okay?

942
01:00:21.797 --> 01:00:22.677
He was a maniac.

943
01:00:23.218 --> 01:00:30.982
But Jackson is another one of these trauma-inducing physics textbooks that now, given the years –

944
01:00:32.310 --> 01:00:49.410
past that i look back on i'm like okay this was pretty legit uh two notes on this one uh if we go back to our episode where we covered the ice cube neutrino detector yeah we talked about how light moves through ice yeah that's in there

945
01:00:50.150 --> 01:00:53.151
which was a very viral and popular clip that we had.

946
01:00:53.171 --> 01:00:54.432
Yeah, Cherenkov radiation.

947
01:00:54.472 --> 01:00:59.294
The fact that if a charged particle moves faster than light in a medium, it's going to create a shockwave.

948
01:00:59.534 --> 01:01:00.215
Yep, that's in there.

949
01:01:00.415 --> 01:01:07.718
Literally everything that you could ever want from an electrodynamics textbook about any electrical phenomenon is in here.

950
01:01:08.442 --> 01:01:18.669
And for all of my UAP fans, one of the things people talk about is that how these UAP allegedly move around is a part of extended electrodynamics.

951
01:01:18.769 --> 01:01:18.989
Yeah.

952
01:01:19.129 --> 01:01:20.590
And so you have to start here first.

953
01:01:20.610 --> 01:01:20.830
Yeah.

954
01:01:20.870 --> 01:01:23.692
You got to do the homework problems before you get there.

955
01:01:23.712 --> 01:01:23.832
Yep.

956
01:01:23.852 --> 01:01:23.972
Yep.

957
01:01:25.304 --> 01:01:27.645
This is one of my favorite textbooks, thermal physics.

958
01:01:27.986 --> 01:01:34.009
This was my introduction to my favorite subject in physics, which is statistical mechanics.

959
01:01:34.590 --> 01:01:38.932
I took thermodynamics with Enrico Fermi, but that was in my first year.

960
01:01:39.252 --> 01:01:42.134
It was part of the intro physics curriculum.

961
01:01:42.434 --> 01:01:44.615
Thermodynamics by Enrico Fermi is very gentle.

962
01:01:44.956 --> 01:01:46.657
This one is also actually very gentle.

963
01:01:46.957 --> 01:01:48.478
Kittel and Cromer, thermal physics.

964
01:01:49.438 --> 01:01:53.421
In the first chapter, or maybe the second chapter, he proves...

965
01:01:53.961 --> 01:01:58.485
the second law of thermodynamics using two state systems, like a magnetic spin system.

966
01:01:59.186 --> 01:02:04.030
And that's a proof that I still have internalized and memorized.

967
01:02:04.150 --> 01:02:14.699
And it was a very deep thing for me to realize that the second law of thermodynamics is like something you can just like realize from math and combinatorics.

968
01:02:15.520 --> 01:02:29.071
This goes into all the way from phase transitions, like the Stefan Boltzmann law that we talked about in the last episode, the T to the fourth dependence, ideal gas law, how you can get the ideal gas law from just talking about quantum particles.

969
01:02:29.932 --> 01:02:34.756
It's an amazing textbook as the first textbook for deep statistical mechanics.

970
01:02:34.976 --> 01:02:36.157
I would highly recommend.

971
01:02:36.617 --> 01:02:39.620
It's honestly one of my favorite physics textbooks of all time.

972
01:02:42.502 --> 01:02:42.722
Yep.

973
01:02:44.816 --> 01:02:54.562
We've dealt with classical mechanics, electromagnetism, and statistical mechanics, the last of the four pillars of modern physics.

974
01:02:55.538 --> 01:02:56.458
is quantum mechanics.

975
01:02:57.479 --> 01:03:00.440
Here we have Sakurai and Napolitano.

976
01:03:01.060 --> 01:03:06.681
This is in line sort of similar to Landau-Lifschitz in that Sakurai is the brains behind the textbook.

977
01:03:07.182 --> 01:03:09.182
Napolitano is the editor.

978
01:03:10.102 --> 01:03:17.465
Modern quantum mechanics, this is an amazing textbook for the first half because the first half was written by Sakurai during his lifetime.

979
01:03:17.825 --> 01:03:22.906
The second half, Napolitano and a bunch of his colleagues took over, and you can see the...

980
01:03:25.568 --> 01:03:27.189
You can see the decrease in quality.

981
01:03:27.489 --> 01:03:46.206
It's still very good, but J.J. Sakurai's way of introducing quantum mechanics first using the Stern-Gerlach experiment, where the first lesson in this book is just about why you need imaginary numbers to describe quantum mechanics.

982
01:03:46.366 --> 01:03:49.509
It's a very simple description of an experiment, and he says...

983
01:03:50.308 --> 01:03:59.034
The only way that you can describe this experiment is if the internal dynamics involve complex numbers, if they involve the imaginary unit i.

984
01:03:59.194 --> 01:04:00.515
It's absolutely amazing.

985
01:04:00.535 --> 01:04:03.397
And then he goes into the Heisenberg picture, the Schrodinger picture.

986
01:04:03.457 --> 01:04:09.942
He builds angular momentum, the theory of everything that we know and love in quantum mechanics.

987
01:04:10.342 --> 01:04:12.484
Absolutely phenomenal textbook.

988
01:04:12.784 --> 01:04:15.146
This is what I used in my graduate studies.

989
01:04:15.706 --> 01:04:17.508
In undergrad, I used Griffiths.

990
01:04:18.668 --> 01:04:21.151
But in graduate studies, you use Sakurai.

991
01:04:21.531 --> 01:04:29.078
And every physics nerd knows J.J. Sakurai, modern quantum mechanics.

992
01:04:29.238 --> 01:04:32.041
I'll just make a note for those who may be new.

993
01:04:32.601 --> 01:04:41.089
We've covered so many of the concepts that you just talked about on several of our previous podcasts in a variety of ways.

994
01:04:41.389 --> 01:05:03.170
frontier research that we build from first principles the history of the understanding that enabled those uh frontier projects um and it's one of the topics that i personally find super fascinating and clearly the audience does as well because so many people react in a positive way anytime yeah

995
01:05:03.710 --> 01:05:04.651
we do those discussions.

996
01:05:04.811 --> 01:05:11.276
It looks like we have two final textbooks left for our first section of the library.

997
01:05:12.677 --> 01:05:15.179
This one is experiments in modern physics.

998
01:05:15.779 --> 01:05:23.485
There was a course at Princeton University, again, a great course at Princeton University called experiments in modern physics.

999
01:05:24.308 --> 01:05:30.072
It was training you in how to do experiments, how to figure out what the noise level is, how to figure out what your error bars is.

1000
01:05:30.672 --> 01:05:38.638
And what they would have you do is basically spend two weeks doing specific experiments that are legendary.

1001
01:05:39.078 --> 01:05:45.022
So, for example, you could do the Cavendish experiment that measured Big G.

1002
01:05:46.379 --> 01:06:06.121
way back in like i think the 1800s i think maybe late 1700s you can do the millican oil drop experiment where you measure the charge of a single electron you can do the lamb shift experiment which is what we see on the cover over here you the one of the ones that i did was measuring the 21 centimeter line the 1420 hertz

1003
01:06:08.115 --> 01:06:20.883
in the galaxy and charting the gas in the galaxy and showing that the galaxy is rotating, calculating how fast the galaxy is rotating by taking a little dish and putting it at different spots in the galaxy and measuring the Doppler shift.

1004
01:06:21.283 --> 01:06:27.827
So a lot of these seminal experiments are described in great, great detail in this book.

1005
01:06:28.227 --> 01:06:35.332
It's absolutely phenomenal for someone who is interested in experimental physics and especially interested in the history of,

1006
01:06:36.188 --> 01:06:42.111
of how way back when they were still able to get their error bars so small.

1007
01:06:42.251 --> 01:06:47.113
Michelson-Morley, another one that is described in this book.

1008
01:06:47.654 --> 01:06:48.234
It's a great book.

1009
01:06:49.014 --> 01:06:56.518
And I will yet again note that if you are a longtime listener of this podcast and you just heard that description...

1010
01:06:57.900 --> 01:07:10.404
of what you get in experiments in modern physics, you'll notice an overlap with the topics that we cover because every single thing that you just mentioned, Michael, some morally the lamb shift, uh, the 1420 hydrogen line.

1011
01:07:10.444 --> 01:07:17.107
I think I remember back to, there was a story we talked about, uh, the formation of, um, it was, uh,

1012
01:07:18.167 --> 01:07:19.248
Oh, it's escaping me now.

1013
01:07:19.528 --> 01:07:24.590
But we talked about an astrophysics story where it was the accretion disk.

1014
01:07:25.111 --> 01:07:25.731
Oh, yeah, yeah.

1015
01:07:25.771 --> 01:07:27.852
No, the galactic rotation.

1016
01:07:27.952 --> 01:07:28.332
Yes.

1017
01:07:28.592 --> 01:07:30.753
And measuring that like, oh, dark matter.

1018
01:07:30.773 --> 01:07:32.154
Yeah, it was a dark matter halo.

1019
01:07:32.374 --> 01:07:37.196
Yeah, it was the fact that like the galactic rotation curve is flat after some time.

1020
01:07:37.336 --> 01:07:39.717
That's something that is here.

1021
01:07:39.777 --> 01:07:45.260
So as you can see, as we continue to build the narrative and the story and the history of

1022
01:07:45.700 --> 01:07:46.140
who we are.

1023
01:07:46.160 --> 01:07:48.942
You can see how that bleeds into the content we cover.

1024
01:07:49.002 --> 01:07:54.986
Now, the last, but not the least, is the one and only biology book to start the collection.

1025
01:07:55.006 --> 01:07:55.266
That's right.

1026
01:07:55.286 --> 01:07:58.588
This is the one and only biology textbook that's going to be on the shelf.

1027
01:07:59.268 --> 01:08:02.991
This was formative for my interest in biology.

1028
01:08:03.571 --> 01:08:07.954
And you can tell from this podcast, I'm very interested in biology from a physics perspective.

1029
01:08:08.714 --> 01:08:12.637
This is Fundamentals of Molecular Biology by Elizabeth Allison.

1030
01:08:13.617 --> 01:08:19.540
great, great textbook that really goes into depth about kind of the processes, like the Lego block.

1031
01:08:19.881 --> 01:08:25.383
You know, I always talk about like Lego blocks in biology and how everything is just trying to be Lego blocks.

1032
01:08:25.784 --> 01:08:27.585
This is kind of where I get that from.

1033
01:08:29.466 --> 01:08:38.351
Part of this course was also doing a molecular biology lab where we grew bacteria with GFP, green fluorescent protein, and then we –

1034
01:08:41.252 --> 01:08:58.550
We expressed recombinant DNA, so we had a plasmid with the green flesh and protein, and that also had a little antibiotic attached to it, or a way to circumnavigate the antibiotic so that you could only select for bacteria that had the plasmid, and then you could isolate the plasmid, and you could isolate the GFP protein from...

1035
01:08:59.711 --> 01:09:04.534
That was one of my favorite courses at Princeton was like just doing this lab and like manipulating life.

1036
01:09:05.335 --> 01:09:11.299
Like live, you know, you'd come back the next week and the bacteria were grown and like you could like do things with it.

1037
01:09:13.040 --> 01:09:14.842
Absolutely cool.

1038
01:09:14.922 --> 01:09:16.563
This book is also amazing.

1039
01:09:16.623 --> 01:09:18.204
Also, cool thing.

1040
01:09:18.344 --> 01:09:24.429
One of the guest lectures during that course was Shirley Tillman, who was the president at the time of Princeton University.

1041
01:09:24.449 --> 01:09:24.529
Yes.

1042
01:09:24.990 --> 01:09:27.513
I think I've told you the story, but I'll briefly share it.

1043
01:09:27.753 --> 01:09:33.321
So as you mentioned, guest lecturer Shirley Tillman, my first day on campus,

1044
01:09:34.098 --> 01:09:38.601
I was with a teammate of mine walking north on the campus.

1045
01:09:39.102 --> 01:09:40.303
We were there for preseason.

1046
01:09:41.243 --> 01:09:43.105
And so no one else was yet there.

1047
01:09:43.665 --> 01:09:44.366
And we're walking.

1048
01:09:44.426 --> 01:09:47.188
We're just trying to figure out where our classes are going to be and stuff.

1049
01:09:47.648 --> 01:09:51.711
And this nice person walked up to us and asked us where we're from.

1050
01:09:51.791 --> 01:09:53.553
And are we acclimatizing well?

1051
01:09:54.133 --> 01:09:54.954
And we were like, yes.

1052
01:09:55.014 --> 01:09:56.075
And we asked who it was.

1053
01:09:56.135 --> 01:09:56.515
Yeah.

1054
01:09:58.016 --> 01:10:00.197
I think I don't want to get the story wrong.

1055
01:10:00.237 --> 01:10:05.720
So I'll just say they had asked, you know, who we were and then we asked who they were.

1056
01:10:06.280 --> 01:10:09.241
And then she said, Shirley Tillman.

1057
01:10:09.261 --> 01:10:10.722
And we were like, Oh, so what do you do?

1058
01:10:12.735 --> 01:10:14.356
She's like, oh, I'm the president of the university.

1059
01:10:14.796 --> 01:10:26.402
So that gives you an idea of where my lack of context was at the time as an 18-year-old who was just obsessed about being able to be there but also play soccer at the same time.

1060
01:10:27.162 --> 01:10:29.464
I will also note that one of the best bands –

1061
01:10:30.284 --> 01:10:33.685
at the university at the time was Shirley and the Tillmans.

1062
01:10:34.045 --> 01:10:34.865
That was a good band.

1063
01:10:35.005 --> 01:10:35.626
Great band.

1064
01:10:36.246 --> 01:10:37.166
Great band name.

1065
01:10:37.366 --> 01:10:38.046
Yeah.

1066
01:10:38.286 --> 01:10:43.528
And so for all of those, if any of you who are band members are listening, we all remember.

1067
01:10:43.968 --> 01:10:44.828
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1068
01:10:44.868 --> 01:10:45.748
You are not forgotten.

1069
01:10:45.788 --> 01:10:46.789
You are not forgotten.

1070
01:10:46.929 --> 01:10:48.289
Formative for all of us.

1071
01:10:48.389 --> 01:10:51.010
And that completes our first shelf.

1072
01:10:51.955 --> 01:10:59.102
In the library, we're going to come back with the second, which will be a little bit smaller, but we'll expand.

1073
01:10:59.142 --> 01:10:59.343
Yes.

1074
01:10:59.723 --> 01:11:09.533
So now we are moving on to shelf number two after placing our first shelf of textbooks with an esoteric collection in this selection.

1075
01:11:09.952 --> 01:11:17.777
Yep, we're going to start off our esoteric collection with Relativity by the one and only Albert Einstein.

1076
01:11:18.078 --> 01:11:19.899
This is a pretty short book.

1077
01:11:20.019 --> 01:11:20.899
It's quite fancy.

1078
01:11:20.919 --> 01:11:24.662
If you look at the pages, it's like ruffled pages.

1079
01:11:24.742 --> 01:11:25.302
You know what I mean?

1080
01:11:25.322 --> 01:11:26.363
It's like a Harry Potter book.

1081
01:11:26.483 --> 01:11:27.104
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1082
01:11:27.144 --> 01:11:29.225
It's kind of cool.

1083
01:11:29.265 --> 01:11:33.628
2007 is the date that I have here.

1084
01:11:33.648 --> 01:11:34.809
Krishnachadur, December 19th, 2007.

1085
01:11:36.610 --> 01:11:38.910
I didn't understand anything about relativity.

1086
01:11:38.930 --> 01:11:41.651
2007, I was in sophomore year of high school.

1087
01:11:41.851 --> 01:11:43.211
Okay.

1088
01:11:43.531 --> 01:11:48.592
But the magic of relativity is you can like try and read it even in high school and kind of get it.

1089
01:11:49.072 --> 01:11:49.252
Okay.

1090
01:11:49.272 --> 01:11:54.813
It's not like quantum mechanics where I have – I still have no idea what the hell they're talking about.

1091
01:11:55.173 --> 01:12:01.014
Relativity is like one of these nice things about physics that just kind of makes sense the more and more you think about it.

1092
01:12:01.775 --> 01:12:03.915
And Einstein, fair play to him –

1093
01:12:04.515 --> 01:12:07.137
He's a really good explainer of relativity.

1094
01:12:07.698 --> 01:12:07.958
Okay?

1095
01:12:08.038 --> 01:12:15.644
It's not like Heisenberg, where he wrote the 1925 Umdeutung paper, and then people still read it today, and it's like, how did you come up with that?

1096
01:12:15.985 --> 01:12:19.067
Relativity, especially special relativity, kind of makes sense.

1097
01:12:19.087 --> 01:12:22.690
And then when you graduate to general relativity, it still kind of makes sense.

1098
01:12:22.910 --> 01:12:26.553
It's a beautiful textbook, in his own words, the man himself, Albert Einstein.

1099
01:12:28.275 --> 01:12:30.697
First in our esoteric collection.

1100
01:12:31.428 --> 01:12:33.549
Next one, Arnold Sommerfeld.

1101
01:12:33.789 --> 01:12:34.029
Yes.

1102
01:12:34.089 --> 01:12:35.689
We've talked about Arnold Sommerfeld.

1103
01:12:36.609 --> 01:12:44.051
He's the mentor to so many of the greats, including Wolfgang Pauli, Heisenberg.

1104
01:12:44.091 --> 01:12:56.574
He was Heisenberg's PhD advisor and kind of saved his PhD thesis because Heisenberg nearly failed and Arnold Sommerfeld had to go to bat for him and make sure that he passed.

1105
01:12:57.354 --> 01:12:59.057
and go on to greatness.

1106
01:12:59.237 --> 01:13:11.455
Arnold Summerfield never won the Nobel Prize, but he mentored something like 10 Nobel Prize winners, including Hans Bethe, Wolfgang Pauli, just some of the greats of all time.

1107
01:13:11.856 --> 01:13:12.978
He had the first...

1108
01:13:14.250 --> 01:13:17.771
collection of lectures on theoretical physics.

1109
01:13:17.991 --> 01:13:24.874
Nowadays, a lot of times people use Landau-Lifschitz, which we covered with the mechanics textbook that I had earlier.

1110
01:13:25.194 --> 01:13:32.737
Landau-Lifschitz also has a textbook on fluid mechanics, statistical physics, field theory, and all the works, right?

1111
01:13:33.277 --> 01:13:36.639
And it's kind of become a gold standard for graduate textbooks.

1112
01:13:37.000 --> 01:13:40.422
But before Landau-Lifschitz, there was Arnold Sommerfeld.

1113
01:13:41.643 --> 01:13:45.345
This is volume six, partial differential equations in physics.

1114
01:13:45.626 --> 01:13:50.649
You can imagine he had a mechanics, he has an optics, he has statistical mechanics.

1115
01:13:51.329 --> 01:13:52.330
One of the greats of all time.

1116
01:13:53.011 --> 01:13:56.393
And one of our earliest episodes we covered...

1117
01:13:57.473 --> 01:14:09.537
that relationship in depth, which again, Mr. Schill here, some of our library of previous episodes is just phenomenal around the history, particularly in physics.

1118
01:14:09.617 --> 01:14:17.980
And so if you're interested in the relationship between these people and how that relates to the growth of the field in our understanding, it's like our episode 2345,

1119
01:14:19.060 --> 01:14:23.902
We're very heavy in that arena in some of these early developmental protests.

1120
01:14:24.042 --> 01:14:26.382
Yeah, it's how we first got viral on Instagram.

1121
01:14:26.402 --> 01:14:26.622
Yeah.

1122
01:14:27.123 --> 01:14:30.043
Is with the Sommerfeld-Heisenberg episode.

1123
01:14:30.063 --> 01:14:30.244
Yes.

1124
01:14:30.604 --> 01:14:34.085
Where we covered the 1925 paper and the 100-year anniversary of it.

1125
01:14:34.205 --> 01:14:34.425
Yes.

1126
01:14:34.505 --> 01:14:36.245
Back in 2025, last year.

1127
01:14:36.365 --> 01:14:36.586
Yes.

1128
01:14:36.846 --> 01:14:37.486
A year later.

1129
01:14:37.606 --> 01:14:38.406
A year later.

1130
01:14:38.486 --> 01:14:40.007
Look at us.

1131
01:14:40.987 --> 01:14:41.547
Who to thunk?

1132
01:14:41.747 --> 01:14:42.347
Not me.

1133
01:14:42.607 --> 01:14:44.268
Yeah, not me.

1134
01:14:44.668 --> 01:14:46.589
Another one from our previous episodes.

1135
01:14:46.669 --> 01:14:47.189
Another one.

1136
01:14:48.075 --> 01:14:49.656
Schrodinger's What is Life?

1137
01:14:50.137 --> 01:14:56.962
We covered this in detail in our DNA episode where we covered James Watson and his work with DNA.

1138
01:14:57.843 --> 01:15:01.926
What is Life is a seminal textbook in biological physics.

1139
01:15:02.387 --> 01:15:07.651
This is where a physicist tried to tackle the question, what is life, with biology.

1140
01:15:07.691 --> 01:15:13.836
This is where he predicted that DNA would be an aperiodic crystal.

1141
01:15:14.317 --> 01:15:14.637
Why?

1142
01:15:15.057 --> 01:15:15.478
Because...

1143
01:15:16.643 --> 01:15:22.926
It has to store information, which means that it can't just be the same thing over and over again.

1144
01:15:23.006 --> 01:15:29.848
It can't be something like starch or cellulose, which is just glucose, glucose, glucose, glucose everywhere, because there's no information.

1145
01:15:29.888 --> 01:15:30.769
It's just all glucose.

1146
01:15:31.109 --> 01:15:36.471
But if you have something like an aperiodic crystal, like something with bits, where it's a 0-1-1-0-0-1-1-0,

1147
01:15:38.692 --> 01:15:42.494
Then you can all of a sudden store all of the information that is needed for life.

1148
01:15:42.874 --> 01:15:58.163
And he reasoned from first principles that if we wanted a molecular basis for information storage, we needed something like a crystal that had regular parts, but different sequences to store all of the diversity.

1149
01:15:58.883 --> 01:16:03.886
He predicted the structure of DNA before we even knew that it was DNA that we were looking for.

1150
01:16:03.966 --> 01:16:05.187
It's absolutely incredible.

1151
01:16:06.127 --> 01:16:07.708
Erwin Schrödinger, what is life?

1152
01:16:08.491 --> 01:16:16.299
The double helix episode is a great way to dig into that concept that you just covered, which is fascinating to me.

1153
01:16:18.001 --> 01:16:23.727
And also the history of the discovery of the double helix and kind of some of the non-scientific social drama.

1154
01:16:23.747 --> 01:16:24.567
Yeah.

1155
01:16:25.408 --> 01:16:29.611
of the real world humanity that relates to these early discoveries is also quite interesting.

1156
01:16:29.731 --> 01:16:29.951
Yeah.

1157
01:16:30.531 --> 01:16:30.712
Yeah.

1158
01:16:30.832 --> 01:16:32.113
It's, it's absolutely amazing.

1159
01:16:32.413 --> 01:16:32.653
Okay.

1160
01:16:33.033 --> 01:16:36.275
This one S Subramanyam Chandrasekhar.

1161
01:16:36.675 --> 01:16:37.656
The Thundershaker.

1162
01:16:37.756 --> 01:16:38.016
Yeah.

1163
01:16:38.837 --> 01:16:39.798
Yeah.

1164
01:16:39.838 --> 01:16:41.839
Chandrasekhar's Radiative Transfer.

1165
01:16:41.879 --> 01:16:44.220
This is a seminal textbook in astrophysics.

1166
01:16:44.761 --> 01:16:52.126
It's talking about how radiative phenomenon goes through ionized atmospheres, stellar atmospheres, and,

1167
01:16:52.946 --> 01:16:56.168
This thing is like an end-all, be-all for that subject.

1168
01:16:56.528 --> 01:16:57.689
It's absolutely incredible.

1169
01:16:57.729 --> 01:17:08.535
He uses principles of symmetry to talk about radiative transfer in astrophysics, which is very different from how normal astrophysicists used to do it at the time.

1170
01:17:09.015 --> 01:17:12.257
Normal astrophysicists used to make a phenomenological model.

1171
01:17:12.657 --> 01:17:16.440
They'd make some kind of model that would be like, oh, okay, so this is happening and this is happening.

1172
01:17:16.720 --> 01:17:17.800
Here, he went through...

1173
01:17:19.940 --> 01:17:28.322
like symmetry principles to be like, this needs to happen because of the symmetry of the stellar atmosphere, because of the symmetry of the geometry and things like that.

1174
01:17:28.362 --> 01:17:29.962
It's a very physics-y approach.

1175
01:17:30.462 --> 01:17:31.303
Now, I'm going to be honest.

1176
01:17:31.883 --> 01:17:41.705
I've only read very small parts of this, but I asked my father, who's an astrophysicist and a big fan of Chandrasekhar, and he has like five or six textbooks.

1177
01:17:42.885 --> 01:17:48.288
And this is on loan, by the way, from the Chowdhury family exhibition.

1178
01:17:48.468 --> 01:17:50.929
So he wants it back maybe in like a year.

1179
01:17:50.989 --> 01:17:52.070
It's on permanent loan.

1180
01:17:52.110 --> 01:17:53.370
Yeah, it's on permanent loan.

1181
01:17:53.390 --> 01:17:53.931
Yeah.

1182
01:17:55.232 --> 01:18:02.038
So I asked him, you know, of all of the Chandrasekhar textbooks, which would you say is his most seminal work?

1183
01:18:02.639 --> 01:18:03.780
And he said, radio transfer.

1184
01:18:03.800 --> 01:18:05.762
And I'm like, okay, thank you.

1185
01:18:07.083 --> 01:18:09.065
That's going in the FFP pod library.

1186
01:18:09.946 --> 01:18:13.709
Absolutely legendary astrophysicist and physicist in general.

1187
01:18:14.470 --> 01:18:16.832
So I'm glad that we have this thing here.

1188
01:18:19.335 --> 01:18:19.655
All right.

1189
01:18:21.449 --> 01:18:21.909
Next one.

1190
01:18:22.590 --> 01:18:22.990
Gibbs.

1191
01:18:24.111 --> 01:18:24.811
Yes.

1192
01:18:24.851 --> 01:18:27.153
Elementary principles in statistical mechanics.

1193
01:18:27.273 --> 01:18:42.464
This is the graduation of statistical mechanics into a formal field where we go from Boltzmann, Maxwell Boltzmann distribution, Raleigh-Jean's Law, all the way up to now Gibbs talking about

1194
01:18:43.397 --> 01:18:46.039
Chemical Potential, talking about the Gibbs ensemble.

1195
01:18:46.479 --> 01:18:50.382
This is the book that put American theoretical physics on the map.

1196
01:18:50.882 --> 01:18:51.143
Okay?

1197
01:18:51.703 --> 01:18:55.866
Now, he is from Yale University, but we'll forgive him for that.

1198
01:18:56.707 --> 01:18:58.548
He still deserves to be in our library.

1199
01:18:58.588 --> 01:19:00.509
And I had to do a lot of soul searching.

1200
01:19:00.549 --> 01:19:01.410
Yeah, I plead the fifth.

1201
01:19:01.770 --> 01:19:03.632
To really convince myself.

1202
01:19:03.652 --> 01:19:03.912
Yeah.

1203
01:19:04.192 --> 01:19:10.453
But Willard Gibbs, we covered him in the 250-year America anniversary.

1204
01:19:10.534 --> 01:19:16.255
This guy was definitely a legend, and he put American science, American theoretical physics on the map.

1205
01:19:16.835 --> 01:19:23.357
He completed the Gibbs ensemble to create all of the statistical mechanics that we know and love today.

1206
01:19:24.237 --> 01:19:28.358
This is why chemists love statistical mechanics is because of Willard Gibbs.

1207
01:19:28.758 --> 01:19:29.618
Or maybe they hate him.

1208
01:19:29.738 --> 01:19:30.098
I don't know.

1209
01:19:30.478 --> 01:19:33.559
But in any case, you can't deny that it's hella useful.

1210
01:19:34.259 --> 01:19:37.160
I mean, it describes chemistry, right?

1211
01:19:37.361 --> 01:19:49.946
We've remained number one in theoretical sense, and that may not continue to be the case unless we continue to invest in the hard and fundamental sciences.

1212
01:19:50.166 --> 01:19:50.567
That's right.

1213
01:19:51.007 --> 01:19:56.229
All right, the next esoteric edition, Albert Einstein, philosopher-scientist.

1214
01:19:57.310 --> 01:20:01.792
This is actually a collection of essays about Albert Einstein

1215
01:20:02.969 --> 01:20:07.411
by the preeminent physicists and mathematicians of his time.

1216
01:20:08.011 --> 01:20:11.172
There are several biographies of Albert Einstein.

1217
01:20:11.733 --> 01:20:17.635
I didn't want to include the biographies of Albert Einstein because they're written today based on stuff that people said.

1218
01:20:18.035 --> 01:20:19.896
This is what people actually said.

1219
01:20:20.576 --> 01:20:20.836
Okay?

1220
01:20:21.397 --> 01:20:27.624
There's an essay from Niels Bohr talking about how much of a legend Albert Einstein is.

1221
01:20:28.025 --> 01:20:32.470
There's an essay from Kurt Godel talking about how ridiculous Albert Einstein is.

1222
01:20:32.790 --> 01:20:33.611
Wolfgang Pauli

1223
01:20:34.562 --> 01:20:45.349
Arnold Sommerfeld, like all of the who's who of people who could say stuff about the GOAT and this is it, right?

1224
01:20:45.409 --> 01:20:53.034
It's like imagine interviewing the star NBA players in Jordan's time and they're all talking about how ridiculous Jordan is.

1225
01:20:53.494 --> 01:20:58.957
And how like Jordan is here and like we're a step below, right?

1226
01:20:59.197 --> 01:21:00.078
That's this book.

1227
01:21:00.260 --> 01:21:08.024
The football reference would be if you had today all the star footballers talking about Messi.

1228
01:21:08.285 --> 01:21:17.710
You listen to Beckham, you listen to Neymar, you listen to Thierry Henry, Vinny, all these legends who in their own right have earned the right to be at their plateau.

1229
01:21:17.810 --> 01:21:19.711
Yeah.

1230
01:21:19.911 --> 01:21:20.992
Not quite the same.

1231
01:21:23.041 --> 01:21:23.682
Kind of the same.

1232
01:21:23.702 --> 01:21:24.323
Kind of the same.

1233
01:21:24.543 --> 01:21:28.670
But Einstein, to me, feels like Messi is an alien.

1234
01:21:29.050 --> 01:21:29.311
Yeah.

1235
01:21:29.691 --> 01:21:31.094
He's absolutely an alien.

1236
01:21:31.234 --> 01:21:32.316
Yeah.

1237
01:21:32.916 --> 01:21:35.881
But he's still, he's still like, you know, in the same...

1238
01:21:39.709 --> 01:22:02.972
region yeah yeah there's distance yeah there's distance but like cristiano ronaldo's like people say people argue yeah i think with einstein no one argues yeah no one he's the one he's the one in the 1900s he's the one he's the one yeah and so you know yeah um it's so word for word bar for bar what people actually say yeah yeah yeah it's like hear it from niels bohr himself

1239
01:22:03.472 --> 01:22:05.313
About how ridiculous Einstein was.

1240
01:22:05.333 --> 01:22:06.793
No rose-colored glasses.

1241
01:22:06.853 --> 01:22:08.854
No postmodern interpretation.

1242
01:22:08.894 --> 01:22:09.434
Yeah, yeah.

1243
01:22:09.514 --> 01:22:12.475
It's just, the guy's like, no, this is insane.

1244
01:22:12.595 --> 01:22:14.035
How is this a single human being?

1245
01:22:16.036 --> 01:22:18.417
All right, speaking of ridiculous single human beings.

1246
01:22:18.437 --> 01:22:18.737
Yes.

1247
01:22:19.297 --> 01:22:22.378
The greatest work in scientific literature.

1248
01:22:23.477 --> 01:22:24.617
is Newton's Principia.

1249
01:22:25.258 --> 01:22:29.519
And our library would not be complete without a copy of Newton's Principia.

1250
01:22:30.299 --> 01:22:40.522
This is the beginning of the scientific revolution as we see it today, where we think of the universe as understandable.

1251
01:22:41.062 --> 01:22:50.405
We think of the universe as something that mathematics can tackle and describe in a way that is unprecedented

1252
01:22:51.185 --> 01:22:51.686
before him.

1253
01:22:52.188 --> 01:22:52.468
Okay?

1254
01:22:52.929 --> 01:22:57.921
He said that the same laws that apply on earth are the ones that apply in the cosmos, right?

1255
01:22:58.181 --> 01:23:00.948
He said the same way that the apple falls from the tree is,

1256
01:23:01.870 --> 01:23:04.191
is the same way that the moon falls towards the earth.

1257
01:23:04.571 --> 01:23:06.032
It's not that he noticed the apple.

1258
01:23:06.072 --> 01:23:09.193
He was like sitting under the apple tree and he's like, oh, I got hit by an apple.

1259
01:23:09.574 --> 01:23:10.174
Apples fall.

1260
01:23:10.514 --> 01:23:12.755
Everyone knows apples fall, right?

1261
01:23:13.115 --> 01:23:20.138
Galileo described how all apples and like, you know, balls of lead will fall at the same rate.

1262
01:23:20.498 --> 01:23:21.719
That wasn't the key thing.

1263
01:23:21.819 --> 01:23:27.422
The key thing was the way that the apple falls is also the same way that the moon is falling.

1264
01:23:27.802 --> 01:23:30.083
And if I were to include the three laws here,

1265
01:23:30.863 --> 01:23:36.171
that he came up with, the fact that the moon is moving and it's just falling in the direction of the force.

1266
01:23:36.632 --> 01:23:39.696
There's a force that is centripetal, that is 1 over r squared.

1267
01:23:41.399 --> 01:23:42.159
All of those things.

1268
01:23:42.779 --> 01:23:49.021
He also invented calculus, by the way, on the way to describe everything about the world.

1269
01:23:49.041 --> 01:23:50.362
The calculus was a side hustle.

1270
01:23:50.402 --> 01:23:51.862
It's like, I need something to explain it.

1271
01:23:51.882 --> 01:23:53.743
Let me just invent.

1272
01:23:53.883 --> 01:23:54.923
Yeah.

1273
01:23:55.043 --> 01:24:02.006
And what I really love about this is, like, when he was describing, for example, Kepler's laws and...

1274
01:24:03.366 --> 01:24:26.387
describing how the moon falls and how a comet goes around the sun he didn't actually use any calculus he just used geometric constructions like the stuff like the compass and needle stuff from way back in the greek days that's what he used to describe all of the mathematics because he knew the calculus was going to be this new thing and he didn't want to over index on this new thing that he invented right

1275
01:24:27.608 --> 01:24:31.731
Lest people say, oh, you just made up some stuff.

1276
01:24:32.231 --> 01:24:35.933
But here it's like, no, it's just geometry and the few rules that I made.

1277
01:24:36.253 --> 01:24:37.314
It's absolutely beautiful.

1278
01:24:37.354 --> 01:24:42.617
And the work that he did, he described Kepler's laws, which were established 50 years earlier.

1279
01:24:43.077 --> 01:24:44.438
with just pure geometry.

1280
01:24:44.558 --> 01:24:52.801
He's like, there's a triangle, and the triangle has this much, and that's why it's going to fall this much, and the areas are going to be equal to when it's closer and when it's farther away.

1281
01:24:53.121 --> 01:24:54.082
Absolutely incredible.

1282
01:24:54.462 --> 01:24:55.583
The genius of this guy.

1283
01:24:55.623 --> 01:25:01.205
And he's another one of these Einsteins where all of his peers were like, what is going on?

1284
01:25:01.905 --> 01:25:03.286
How is this a real person?

1285
01:25:03.406 --> 01:25:03.766
Alien.

1286
01:25:03.986 --> 01:25:04.907
Yeah.

1287
01:25:04.967 --> 01:25:09.869
Joseph Bernoulli, the guy behind Bernoulli's principle, he was like, what is this guy?

1288
01:25:11.340 --> 01:25:13.722
Which is, again, crazy to even say.

1289
01:25:13.742 --> 01:25:17.926
There's a guy who has a thing named after him, and he's talking about Newton like, I don't know.

1290
01:25:17.946 --> 01:25:18.807
I don't know.

1291
01:25:19.127 --> 01:25:19.567
I don't know.

1292
01:25:19.727 --> 01:25:20.108
I don't know.

1293
01:25:20.328 --> 01:25:21.489
I just came up with one thing.

1294
01:25:21.509 --> 01:25:22.590
He came up with everything.

1295
01:25:22.630 --> 01:25:23.130
Yeah, yeah.

1296
01:25:23.250 --> 01:25:23.751
Out of whole cloth.

1297
01:25:23.871 --> 01:25:24.652
Absolutely amazing.

1298
01:25:24.832 --> 01:25:25.072
Yeah.

1299
01:25:25.352 --> 01:25:27.174
Newton's Principia.

1300
01:25:27.354 --> 01:25:29.236
The greatest work in scientific literature.

1301
01:25:29.296 --> 01:25:31.017
And I will stand by that.

1302
01:25:31.438 --> 01:25:35.941
Some of the most legendary additions to the esoteric collection.

1303
01:25:35.961 --> 01:25:36.222
Yeah.

1304
01:25:36.702 --> 01:25:39.203
in the library, our second shelf of three.

1305
01:25:39.744 --> 01:25:51.270
Again, the library is a living document, and so we have three remaining books that we will go through as we place our esoteric collection onto the shelf.

1306
01:25:51.570 --> 01:26:03.556
And if you wanted an excuse to migrate from being an audio listener to watching the podcast on video, coming soon to Apple Podcasts, but already available on YouTube and Spotify,

1307
01:26:04.549 --> 01:26:05.711
we're having a great time today.

1308
01:26:05.731 --> 01:26:13.299
You're missing how amazing these look and Krishna holding the book up so he makes sure it gets in the clip on Instagram.

1309
01:26:13.539 --> 01:26:14.140
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1310
01:26:14.180 --> 01:26:15.962
No, I only did that for the second one.

1311
01:26:17.638 --> 01:26:26.241
For longtime listeners of the podcast, you may have noticed the platonic solids as our sort of emblem, as our logo.

1312
01:26:26.261 --> 01:26:31.043
You're going to see it in the top right corner of our videos.

1313
01:26:31.983 --> 01:26:37.685
The platonic solids are something that we chose early on at the very beginning when we started this podcast.

1314
01:26:38.085 --> 01:26:45.808
We were thinking about what is the symbolism that encapsulates what we're trying to do.

1315
01:26:47.480 --> 01:26:52.881
The Platonic solids are introduced in Plato's Dialogues, which I have a copy of here.

1316
01:26:53.421 --> 01:27:00.502
This next shelf, the third and final shelf, is going to consist of philosophy in a broad sense.

1317
01:27:00.802 --> 01:27:10.024
And again, it's a living document, or it's a living library, so if you guys have other books that you want to include there, please let us know.

1318
01:27:10.444 --> 01:27:11.764
But for now, we've got three.

1319
01:27:11.824 --> 01:27:13.885
We're going to start with Plato's Dialogues.

1320
01:27:14.445 --> 01:27:16.025
This is a copy from way back...

1321
01:27:16.617 --> 01:27:21.140
that includes both Timaeus and the Republic.

1322
01:27:21.500 --> 01:27:21.740
Okay?

1323
01:27:22.501 --> 01:27:34.769
So, in Plato's dialogue Timaeus, he introduces these platonic solids, and he says that these are the shapes that are his answer for the question, what is the universe made out of?

1324
01:27:35.770 --> 01:27:35.970
Now...

1325
01:27:36.910 --> 01:27:41.312
I like that for the reason that he's even asking that question, right?

1326
01:27:41.973 --> 01:27:47.796
It's kind of cool that someone's asking, what is the material, like, what's the stuff made out of?

1327
01:27:48.196 --> 01:27:50.397
And he says, everything is made out of platonic solids.

1328
01:27:50.417 --> 01:27:54.759
There's some hidden geometric building blocks that make up the world.

1329
01:27:55.620 --> 01:28:01.083
And Timaeus is kind of like a first attempt at, you know, what we as physicists do.

1330
01:28:01.523 --> 01:28:05.985
try to chase all the time, which is a unified field theory.

1331
01:28:06.025 --> 01:28:06.926
Theory of everything.

1332
01:28:06.946 --> 01:28:08.107
Right, a theory of everything.

1333
01:28:08.127 --> 01:28:10.188
Well, Plato had his version of a theory of everything.

1334
01:28:10.488 --> 01:28:11.468
I mean, it's wrong.

1335
01:28:11.769 --> 01:28:12.789
It's not made out of shapes.

1336
01:28:12.849 --> 01:28:17.131
But, I mean, if you ask string theorists, they'll say, yes, it's made out of shapes.

1337
01:28:17.211 --> 01:28:19.233
It's just that the shape is in 11 dimensions.

1338
01:28:19.573 --> 01:28:21.734
Okay.

1339
01:28:21.834 --> 01:28:25.216
But the philosophy is there, right?

1340
01:28:25.316 --> 01:28:29.018
Where, like, as physicists, we want to find unification.

1341
01:28:29.638 --> 01:28:30.759
And I think Plato was...

1342
01:28:31.479 --> 01:28:36.340
one of these philosophers that really suggested that very early on.

1343
01:28:38.001 --> 01:28:54.286
What I also love about Plato is the fact that, you know, in his Republic there's the very famous allegory of the cave, which talks about how human perceptual senses have a limitation.

1344
01:28:55.046 --> 01:28:55.306
Okay?

1345
01:28:56.267 --> 01:28:58.991
The fact that, I mean, let's go over the allegory of the cave.

1346
01:28:59.011 --> 01:29:09.928
The idea is that there's these philosopher kings or whatever that are creating real shapes, and the shapes are getting projected as shadows on a wall.

1347
01:29:10.429 --> 01:29:11.811
And all we humans are doing...

1348
01:29:12.291 --> 01:29:14.794
are looking at the shadows and thinking that they're real.

1349
01:29:15.174 --> 01:29:17.997
This is how the matrix comes out to be, right?

1350
01:29:18.017 --> 01:29:23.202
Where it's like all of our senses are actually fooling us into thinking that there's a hidden reality underneath.

1351
01:29:23.662 --> 01:29:29.648
I mean, the deeper and deeper we go into physics, it turns out there's a lot of truth to that idea, right?

1352
01:29:30.068 --> 01:29:33.612
The other reason why I love platonic shapes is just the geometry of it is so cool.

1353
01:29:34.252 --> 01:29:36.214
The fact that there are only five of them.

1354
01:29:36.515 --> 01:29:36.655
Mm-hmm.

1355
01:29:37.144 --> 01:29:38.265
and no more, right?

1356
01:29:38.505 --> 01:29:44.388
There are only five three-dimensional objects where every single face is exactly the same.

1357
01:29:44.408 --> 01:29:49.310
You've got the tetrahedron, which is the triangle with a bunch of four equilateral triangles.

1358
01:29:49.330 --> 01:29:52.291
You've got the cube, obviously, with square, square, square, square.

1359
01:29:53.572 --> 01:29:56.473
You've got the octahedron, the dodecahedron.

1360
01:29:56.894 --> 01:29:59.055
And Plato, in Timaeus, he...

1361
01:29:59.895 --> 01:30:12.273
Constructed this mathematical cosmology where the physical world was consisting of these shapes, and each of the shapes had to do with an element that the universe is made out of.

1362
01:30:12.313 --> 01:30:15.839
Like the tetrahedron was fire, the cube is earth.

1363
01:30:16.319 --> 01:30:17.840
The icosahedron is water.

1364
01:30:17.880 --> 01:30:20.182
The dodecahedron is the cosmos itself.

1365
01:30:20.562 --> 01:30:23.544
And then there's like an ether, which is crazy that he thought of an ether.

1366
01:30:23.584 --> 01:30:27.626
And then we borrowed it in the 1900s to describe how electromagnetism worked.

1367
01:30:27.947 --> 01:30:29.388
Turns out that's not exactly true.

1368
01:30:29.428 --> 01:30:38.834
But again, it's like, it's very cool to see like, you know, from 2000 years ago, 2500 years ago, this trail of intellectual thought still coming down.

1369
01:30:39.894 --> 01:30:42.556
The idea that the universe is understandable, right?

1370
01:30:42.716 --> 01:30:45.939
At a first principles level from building blocks.

1371
01:30:46.699 --> 01:30:47.720
I think that's very cool.

1372
01:30:47.820 --> 01:30:52.924
And so that's why Plato gets on our philosophy shelf.

1373
01:30:53.064 --> 01:30:55.406
The inaugural selection.

1374
01:30:55.446 --> 01:30:57.367
The inventor of the concept of Legos.

1375
01:30:57.707 --> 01:30:58.108
Yes!

1376
01:30:58.548 --> 01:31:01.130
And then one day the Fire Nation attacked.

1377
01:31:01.610 --> 01:31:01.850
Yeah.

1378
01:31:03.431 --> 01:31:07.832
For those Avatar fans, the last airbender Avatar in the audience.

1379
01:31:08.053 --> 01:31:09.493
Yes, that's exactly right.

1380
01:31:09.933 --> 01:31:19.556
So, you know, we're going from Plato, which is this idea that realism, a true reality exists in the realm of forms.

1381
01:31:19.996 --> 01:31:22.036
There's this idea like the theory of forms.

1382
01:31:22.377 --> 01:31:27.538
If you've seen that very famous painting, I think it's by Raphael, it's in the Vatican,

1383
01:31:27.919 --> 01:31:32.180
where Plato, it's all of the Greek philosophers in a single painting.

1384
01:31:33.741 --> 01:31:38.502
Actually, my favorite philosopher, Diogenes, who's just a troll, is like in a corner there.

1385
01:31:38.802 --> 01:31:49.045
The funniest, my favorite, even though Plato's awesome, just from a personal perspective, my favorite philosopher is Diogenes, because he invented trolling.

1386
01:31:49.726 --> 01:31:57.464
Um, there's a famous story where Plato said, I, I, I'm paraphrasing, but Plato said, um, how do you define a human being?

1387
01:31:57.825 --> 01:31:59.248
It's a featherless biped.

1388
01:32:00.592 --> 01:32:06.397
And then Diogenes got a chicken and plucked all of his feathers.

1389
01:32:06.477 --> 01:32:12.862
And then came into Plato's lecture, and he was like, Behold, a human.

1390
01:32:12.922 --> 01:32:14.543
Diogenes the degenerate.

1391
01:32:14.563 --> 01:32:16.005
Dude, he's so degenerate.

1392
01:32:16.025 --> 01:32:16.965
We love it.

1393
01:32:17.125 --> 01:32:19.768
I mean, he trolled Alexander the Great.

1394
01:32:19.808 --> 01:32:21.909
When Alexander the Great was like, what can I do for you?

1395
01:32:21.929 --> 01:32:24.371
He's like, step out of the sun for me.

1396
01:32:24.411 --> 01:32:25.492
You're in the way of the light.

1397
01:32:25.953 --> 01:32:27.274
Like, to Alexander the Great.

1398
01:32:27.314 --> 01:32:28.395
Like, this guy did not...

1399
01:32:28.915 --> 01:32:29.215
care.

1400
01:32:29.816 --> 01:32:30.957
So I love that about him.

1401
01:32:31.697 --> 01:32:34.299
It's not someone that I, let's say, aspire to be.

1402
01:32:34.479 --> 01:32:34.699
Sure.

1403
01:32:34.900 --> 01:32:37.041
But he's still funny.

1404
01:32:37.281 --> 01:32:40.764
Well, sometimes you gotta be the original contrarian.

1405
01:32:40.824 --> 01:32:41.404
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1406
01:32:41.665 --> 01:32:42.725
And he was the original.

1407
01:32:43.186 --> 01:32:48.910
Anyway, so Plato, in this giant painting by Raphael about

1408
01:32:49.407 --> 01:32:54.731
It's about all of the philosophers in the school of Athens.

1409
01:32:55.431 --> 01:33:03.897
There's Plato and Aristotle, and Plato is pointing at the sky because he's saying that the true reality is in this world of forms, right?

1410
01:33:03.957 --> 01:33:09.401
And we're just peons looking at, through our senses, some random nonsense.

1411
01:33:09.441 --> 01:33:09.641
Yes.

1412
01:33:09.842 --> 01:33:10.082
Okay?

1413
01:33:11.163 --> 01:33:12.163
Some representation.

1414
01:33:12.403 --> 01:33:14.685
Yeah, some representation based on our senses.

1415
01:33:14.705 --> 01:33:15.826
But not the true form itself.

1416
01:33:15.846 --> 01:33:16.046
Yeah.

1417
01:33:16.527 --> 01:33:18.128
Well, he was kind of late to the party.

1418
01:33:18.208 --> 01:33:18.628
Oh, okay.

1419
01:33:19.089 --> 01:33:23.672
Because a thousand years ago, the Hindus... Of course.

1420
01:33:24.193 --> 01:33:27.535
In the Upanishads wrote exactly this down, okay?

1421
01:33:27.775 --> 01:33:30.698
The Upanishads are something that I grew up learning about.

1422
01:33:32.299 --> 01:33:33.180
It's a school of...

1423
01:33:34.164 --> 01:33:39.930
Hindu philosophy called Advaita Vedanta, which is this non-dual representation of the world.

1424
01:33:40.010 --> 01:33:43.674
The fact that consciousness and the material world are one and the same.

1425
01:33:43.974 --> 01:33:45.095
They're not actually separate.

1426
01:33:45.355 --> 01:33:50.821
This is very different from, I think, Western philosophy that talks about a creator having created creation.

1427
01:33:50.901 --> 01:33:51.101
Yes.

1428
01:33:51.282 --> 01:33:51.482
Right?

1429
01:33:53.284 --> 01:33:56.767
You know, God said, let there be light, and there was light, and then it was all good.

1430
01:33:58.689 --> 01:34:04.172
In Hindu philosophy, especially in Advaita philosophy, Advaita means non-dual.

1431
01:34:04.192 --> 01:34:07.073
Advaita means two, and then A is like a non.

1432
01:34:08.834 --> 01:34:10.414
There, it's one and the same.

1433
01:34:10.774 --> 01:34:15.476
Like, the creation and the creator cannot be separated.

1434
01:34:15.496 --> 01:34:15.737
Right?

1435
01:34:15.997 --> 01:34:16.197
Right.

1436
01:34:17.249 --> 01:34:20.852
I really like that, but that's from a more philosophical point of view.

1437
01:34:22.193 --> 01:34:33.242
In the line of Plato and his idea of forms and the idea that the senses are limited, the Upanishads definitely talk about that a thousand years earlier.

1438
01:34:33.983 --> 01:34:39.147
There's the Shvetashvatara Upanishad that talks about the origin of Maya.

1439
01:34:39.247 --> 01:34:45.673
Maya is this idea that when we talk about the world as an illusion, it's...

1440
01:34:47.347 --> 01:34:48.589
Maya is the illusion.

1441
01:34:48.649 --> 01:34:52.476
That's the Hindu sort of word for it, the Sanskrit word for it.

1442
01:34:52.876 --> 01:34:59.587
It's defining this as like a cosmic mechanism that turns some singular reality, right?

1443
01:35:00.048 --> 01:35:01.230
A singular reality...

1444
01:35:01.546 --> 01:35:05.090
into all of the manifestations that we see here today.

1445
01:35:05.490 --> 01:35:16.442
And, you know, a lot of times, now this is where I'm going off on a personal limb, a lot of times people think of Hinduism as a polytheistic religion because we've got millions of gods and all this other kind of stuff.

1446
01:35:16.822 --> 01:35:18.805
But, you know, if you go down to this level,

1447
01:35:19.909 --> 01:35:20.409
It's this.

1448
01:35:20.690 --> 01:35:20.970
Right.

1449
01:35:21.470 --> 01:35:26.333
There's a singular reality that is getting manifested in all these sorts of forms, right?

1450
01:35:26.654 --> 01:35:30.356
There's all these forms of the divine that you can worship and things like that.

1451
01:35:30.376 --> 01:35:31.237
You don't have to worship.

1452
01:35:31.297 --> 01:35:32.197
I don't know if I worship.

1453
01:35:32.237 --> 01:35:41.144
But this idea that all of the manifestation and all of the richness that we see in the world is from a singular reality.

1454
01:35:41.744 --> 01:35:43.105
I really like that concept.

1455
01:35:43.591 --> 01:35:45.757
Not all of the gods have admin privileges.

1456
01:35:45.977 --> 01:35:47.180
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1457
01:35:47.200 --> 01:35:49.847
There is only one super admin.

1458
01:35:49.947 --> 01:35:50.549
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1459
01:35:50.569 --> 01:35:51.571
And he's like, he's...

1460
01:35:53.120 --> 01:35:54.361
He's distributing.

1461
01:35:54.421 --> 01:35:54.621
Right.

1462
01:35:54.761 --> 01:35:54.941
Right?

1463
01:35:55.001 --> 01:35:57.502
But all of the other ones are really just them.

1464
01:35:57.722 --> 01:35:58.643
An extension.

1465
01:35:59.323 --> 01:36:00.323
He or she or them.

1466
01:36:00.423 --> 01:36:00.644
Yes.

1467
01:36:00.984 --> 01:36:03.225
Like being, like, just like trolling.

1468
01:36:03.465 --> 01:36:03.685
Yes.

1469
01:36:04.325 --> 01:36:04.525
Yes.

1470
01:36:04.605 --> 01:36:05.086
In the world.

1471
01:36:05.326 --> 01:36:05.546
Yes.

1472
01:36:05.606 --> 01:36:06.206
Right?

1473
01:36:06.726 --> 01:36:12.129
There's another Upanishad that I really like, which is the Keno Upanishad, which maybe we'll talk about in some sense.

1474
01:36:12.289 --> 01:36:14.350
That deals with the question of consciousness.

1475
01:36:14.770 --> 01:36:17.711
The Keno Upanishad is really the who Upanishad.

1476
01:36:17.731 --> 01:36:18.612
Like, who am I?

1477
01:36:19.052 --> 01:36:19.612
Who are you?

1478
01:36:19.832 --> 01:36:20.753
And what is all this?

1479
01:36:20.773 --> 01:36:21.333
Mm-hmm.

1480
01:36:21.553 --> 01:36:22.794
Right?

1481
01:36:22.854 --> 01:36:25.535
It's talking about who is the seer behind the eye.

1482
01:36:25.836 --> 01:36:30.939
The eye is like this instrument that is taking in photons and then creating an image.

1483
01:36:31.099 --> 01:36:31.299
Yeah.

1484
01:36:31.419 --> 01:36:33.260
But who is the thingy?

1485
01:36:33.420 --> 01:36:34.481
And then interpreting it.

1486
01:36:34.601 --> 01:36:34.821
Yeah.

1487
01:36:34.861 --> 01:36:36.662
And then who defines how it's interpreted?

1488
01:36:36.702 --> 01:36:37.122
Yeah, yeah.

1489
01:36:37.142 --> 01:36:39.023
Because the way you interpret and the way I interpret.

1490
01:36:39.063 --> 01:36:39.223
Yeah.

1491
01:36:39.344 --> 01:36:40.304
And what is the consciousness?

1492
01:36:40.384 --> 01:36:41.045
Is it the same?

1493
01:36:41.425 --> 01:36:41.625
Right.

1494
01:36:41.665 --> 01:36:41.865
Right?

1495
01:36:41.945 --> 01:36:43.286
Is it the same entity that is...

1496
01:36:43.646 --> 01:36:46.847
I mean, I'm not going to say that I'm an expert in it.

1497
01:36:46.967 --> 01:36:50.068
I'm still reading a lot, and I'm still trying to understand the whole thing.

1498
01:36:50.108 --> 01:36:56.330
But it's crazy cool that, like, as humans, we've been thinking about this from different points of view, right?

1499
01:36:56.430 --> 01:36:57.971
Plato's been thinking about the forms.

1500
01:36:58.271 --> 01:37:00.752
The Upanishads have been thinking about the illusion.

1501
01:37:01.372 --> 01:37:04.653
And now we get to modern quantum mechanics, right?

1502
01:37:05.043 --> 01:37:06.104
What is real?

1503
01:37:06.144 --> 01:37:06.884
With what is real.

1504
01:37:07.204 --> 01:37:08.205
This is an amazing book.

1505
01:37:08.225 --> 01:37:13.468
This was actually in one of the comments where people talked about what's a book that we should have.

1506
01:37:13.488 --> 01:37:16.309
This is something that I already read, and I'm a huge fan of this book.

1507
01:37:16.709 --> 01:37:19.111
Adam Becker, PhD in...

1508
01:37:19.992 --> 01:37:29.659
astrophysics, I believe, absolutely wonderful exposition of the state of reality and that question of what is real in quantum mechanics.

1509
01:37:29.799 --> 01:37:30.700
Is it the wave function?

1510
01:37:31.280 --> 01:37:32.501
Is the wave function a real thing?

1511
01:37:32.641 --> 01:37:37.365
If the wave function is a real thing, what the hell is a collapse of a wave function?

1512
01:37:37.445 --> 01:37:39.086
How come it collapses for me?

1513
01:37:39.586 --> 01:37:41.648
And then does it also collapse for you?

1514
01:37:42.088 --> 01:37:44.750
But then you're collapsing at a different time.

1515
01:37:45.110 --> 01:37:47.432
So how does your collapse know that mine collapsed?

1516
01:37:47.957 --> 01:37:51.219
It goes over the Copenhagen interpretation.

1517
01:37:52.139 --> 01:38:00.865
It then goes over Einstein's qualms with the Copenhagen interpretation in a way that is a lot more subtle than people give Einstein credit for.

1518
01:38:01.085 --> 01:38:03.426
They say, oh, Einstein just didn't like quantum mechanics.

1519
01:38:03.746 --> 01:38:07.148
Well, there's really good reasons why he didn't like quantum mechanics.

1520
01:38:07.448 --> 01:38:08.329
And this goes into that.

1521
01:38:08.629 --> 01:38:11.851
And then he goes into the bomb interpretation with the pilot waves.

1522
01:38:12.301 --> 01:38:18.565
And he goes into the Bell's inequality that we covered in the America 250 episode.

1523
01:38:18.585 --> 01:38:22.207
And he goes into some of the real implications.

1524
01:38:22.287 --> 01:38:28.771
Also Everett's multi-worlds interpretation and the many-worlds interpretation where there's just one giant wave function.

1525
01:38:29.151 --> 01:38:30.492
The reason why I like...

1526
01:38:31.132 --> 01:38:47.356
Everett's many worlds interpretation is because, kind of selfishly, it aligns with my pre-existing philosophical theories that I've learned from the Upanishads, which is there is one reality, and we are all seeing manifestations of that one reality.

1527
01:38:47.576 --> 01:38:53.197
Well, according to Everett, there is one universal wave function that we are all entangled with,

1528
01:38:53.717 --> 01:38:55.999
And I am entangled with the observation.

1529
01:38:56.739 --> 01:39:02.363
Like when I observe a photon here versus here, it's because I am entangled with the photon.

1530
01:39:02.483 --> 01:39:07.666
And so I observed it here because the part of my wave function is entangled with observing the photon here.

1531
01:39:07.967 --> 01:39:12.550
There's another part of my wave function that is entangled with the photon being observed over there.

1532
01:39:12.590 --> 01:39:13.490
And that went over there.

1533
01:39:14.051 --> 01:39:15.672
And I can never get access to it.

1534
01:39:15.752 --> 01:39:18.594
And in that universe, Spider-Man is Tobey Maguire.

1535
01:39:18.614 --> 01:39:20.835
And in this universe, Spider-Man is Tom Holland.

1536
01:39:20.975 --> 01:39:22.095
Exactly, yeah.

1537
01:39:22.135 --> 01:39:23.776
This is where Marvel and everything comes in.

1538
01:39:24.056 --> 01:39:36.261
But yeah, the reason why I'm an Everettian and a many worlds person is because, you know, I come from the Eastern philosophy of like a one wave function universe, a one reality universe.

1539
01:39:36.521 --> 01:39:39.922
And that comes from my reading of the Upanishads since I was a child.

1540
01:39:40.263 --> 01:39:43.424
So these are the three that are going into the philosophy of...

1541
01:39:44.623 --> 01:39:44.903
shelf.

1542
01:39:45.283 --> 01:39:46.645
And there's only three.

1543
01:39:46.805 --> 01:39:55.174
So if there's more, if there's some Buddhist stuff that aligns with that philosophy, I know there's some Mahayana Buddhism that goes into the world being an illusion.

1544
01:39:55.534 --> 01:40:02.462
I'm not fully aware of Buddhist philosophy, but if you guys have some ideas, please let us know.

1545
01:40:02.822 --> 01:40:05.806
If there's any other philosophical books that

1546
01:40:06.126 --> 01:40:09.007
that you'd like us to put on the shelf, please let us know.

1547
01:40:09.447 --> 01:40:13.007
But now I think you guys kind of have an understanding of what we're going for.

1548
01:40:13.227 --> 01:40:16.368
And it's not that we're only going for this interpretation.

1549
01:40:17.068 --> 01:40:20.289
If there are other interpretations that are compelling, I would love to read it.

1550
01:40:21.409 --> 01:40:23.469
I'm not sold because I don't know what's going on.

1551
01:40:23.969 --> 01:40:27.390
And that's being okay saying, I don't know.

1552
01:40:27.430 --> 01:40:28.590
Yeah, I don't know.

1553
01:40:28.610 --> 01:40:29.390
I don't know.

1554
01:40:29.510 --> 01:40:30.610
This is a weird question.

1555
01:40:31.030 --> 01:40:33.511
And it might be beyond science because the scientific method –

1556
01:40:34.151 --> 01:40:53.294
relies on observation right and if what how do you rely on something that's unobservable yeah yeah and it's like i'm i'm i'm trying to question what the active observation is exactly so yes this is the last note i'll make on this what is real um for those who are uh

1557
01:40:54.932 --> 01:41:21.492
interested in a visual a visual example of this idea of the everettian interpretation uh is the movie cloverfield paradox which got really bad reviews it's in the cloverfield yeah no i didn't watch it because it got i i loved cloverfield it got really bad reviews but it it dealt with this concept in a way that was intriguing and it had

1558
01:41:21.939 --> 01:41:31.865
You know, it was sort of Marvellian a little bit, but it did it, you know, Earth was basically having a fuel crisis, an energy crisis.

1559
01:41:32.426 --> 01:41:44.253
They built this giant energy producing apparatus in space and this universe and this universe bumped up against each other.

1560
01:41:44.273 --> 01:41:44.873
Oh, interesting.

1561
01:41:44.973 --> 01:41:45.254
Okay.

1562
01:41:45.274 --> 01:41:45.654
And then...

1563
01:41:47.735 --> 01:41:50.038
Hijinks ensues.

1564
01:41:50.179 --> 01:41:56.828
And it really was an interesting way to visualize what would be the human experience.

1565
01:41:58.357 --> 01:42:04.320
Because obviously we don't have it on a regular basis unless UAP are interdimensional.

1566
01:42:04.981 --> 01:42:06.121
They may be interdimensional.

1567
01:42:06.141 --> 01:42:06.382
Come on.

1568
01:42:06.422 --> 01:42:07.602
It's the one-year anniversary episode.

1569
01:42:07.622 --> 01:42:09.003
We're not going to not talk about it.

1570
01:42:09.023 --> 01:42:12.905
I got it in here I think three or four times legitimately in this episode.

1571
01:42:13.225 --> 01:42:19.949
Last thing I'll just note is when you're talking about the Maya as this concept, it's almost – it's convenient.

1572
01:42:19.969 --> 01:42:20.409
The illusion.

1573
01:42:20.449 --> 01:42:20.749
The illusion.

1574
01:42:20.769 --> 01:42:21.530
The grand illusion.

1575
01:42:21.670 --> 01:42:27.373
It's funny that we talked about the Mayans earlier in the Amazon story and kind of that word root came back.

1576
01:42:27.473 --> 01:42:27.573
Yeah.

1577
01:42:27.813 --> 01:42:43.362
At the end here, we are again at the two hour mark for those who are still listening, which apparently is many of you because the stats are telling us, especially on Apple Podcasts, that many of you are listening all the way through, which we are super grateful for.

1578
01:42:43.962 --> 01:42:45.623
Thank you for making it through.

1579
01:42:45.663 --> 01:42:49.906
We had a little bit more of a relaxed episode today, just kind of meandering through.

1580
01:42:49.926 --> 01:42:50.706
Hey, we deserve it.

1581
01:42:50.726 --> 01:42:51.947
It's been a year, okay?

1582
01:42:52.327 --> 01:43:01.292
We wanted to sort of just enjoy for a second and not be totally over-analytical about the substance, but it really is a blessing.

1583
01:43:02.373 --> 01:43:06.098
to be able to have so many of you all want to listen to these concepts, these ideas.

1584
01:43:06.598 --> 01:43:19.935
Again, we really focus on frontier research and try to give the story arc, experimental design and an understanding of what are we actually talking about when we say we have a high temperature memorister or that we've discovered a dark matter halo or,

1585
01:43:20.455 --> 01:43:27.744
or we model MOFs, organic frameworks.

1586
01:43:27.784 --> 01:43:28.906
Yeah, MOFs.

1587
01:43:28.926 --> 01:43:29.386
MOFs.

1588
01:43:29.566 --> 01:43:30.307
Metal organic frameworks.

1589
01:43:30.347 --> 01:43:33.111
Metal organic frameworks from the Nobel Prizes last year.

1590
01:43:33.271 --> 01:43:35.133
We're going to cover the Nobel Prizes this year again.

1591
01:43:35.794 --> 01:43:38.137
We have a great episode that I'm excited about.

1592
01:43:38.597 --> 01:43:41.499
about the summer transfer window for American scientists.

1593
01:43:41.919 --> 01:43:50.063
I mean, these are things that I think we find interesting and entertaining to know about, and it's great to share them with you all all the time.

1594
01:43:50.763 --> 01:43:52.604
I will end with one last reminder.

1595
01:43:53.204 --> 01:44:01.628
We're trying to build community this year, so please go ahead and head over to ffppod.com backslash survey, especially if you're still listening now.

1596
01:44:01.948 --> 01:44:03.309
You are a part of the core audience.

1597
01:44:03.769 --> 01:44:06.010
Want to know about who you are, what you want to hear about.

1598
01:44:06.350 --> 01:44:07.710
We don't know what to do for a community.

1599
01:44:07.730 --> 01:44:08.791
Should we do an Instagram group?

1600
01:44:09.111 --> 01:44:14.493
Should we do a Discord, a TikTok group, a YouTube thing?

1601
01:44:15.293 --> 01:44:16.693
Do we do something on our own?

1602
01:44:17.093 --> 01:44:18.394
You know, where do you all live?

1603
01:44:18.934 --> 01:44:24.556
Apparently, none of you are on X because we have no – none of you engage with us on X, which is fine.

1604
01:44:24.656 --> 01:44:25.736
One less thing for us to manage.

1605
01:44:25.756 --> 01:44:26.437
Yeah.

1606
01:44:26.557 --> 01:44:27.317
But, you know –

1607
01:44:27.877 --> 01:44:32.499
You guys always ask us questions, and we've been really focused on just making sure the show is produced.

1608
01:44:33.100 --> 01:44:44.025
And I think now we're ready to try to figure out how do we make this a community of the curious and help kind of all of us connect and share in a way where we can build something powerful.

1609
01:44:44.265 --> 01:44:45.826
Then it's individual parts.

1610
01:44:47.007 --> 01:44:51.009
And with that, I think for the comment to leave in the comments if you've made it this far.

1611
01:44:51.429 --> 01:44:54.171
is which book in the collection is your favorite?

1612
01:44:54.611 --> 01:44:58.794
If you've already read it or you're most interested by it, let us know in the comments.

1613
01:44:59.475 --> 01:45:08.301
I will leave the final word to our resident PhD before we wrap up this incredible episode 52, our one-year anniversary.

1614
01:45:08.602 --> 01:45:09.302
How many weeks in a year?

1615
01:45:09.322 --> 01:45:09.382
52.

1616
01:45:10.703 --> 01:45:11.543
Yeah, we did it.

1617
01:45:11.744 --> 01:45:12.364
We did it.

1618
01:45:12.964 --> 01:45:19.367
I just have to say thank you so much to all of our listeners, to all of the community that is FFP.

1619
01:45:20.007 --> 01:45:31.913
I really, you know, when we started Me and Lester a year ago, I don't think either of us had any idea of what this podcast would become for, like, us.

1620
01:45:33.053 --> 01:45:36.915
It's really, like, kind of become a big part of our lives today.

1621
01:45:37.490 --> 01:45:38.851
a welcome part of our lives.

1622
01:45:39.151 --> 01:45:46.894
And the whole reason is because we've got a community of you guys trying to consume our content, share our contact.

1623
01:45:48.454 --> 01:45:49.475
We really appreciate it.

1624
01:45:50.175 --> 01:45:55.477
There's, there's no words to say, you know, just how transformative this whole experience has been.

1625
01:45:55.717 --> 01:45:58.678
And we hope to continue this for many years to come.

1626
01:45:58.778 --> 01:46:06.781
So please continue supporting us, giving us all of the shares, you know, talk, talk about us in your labs,

1627
01:46:07.262 --> 01:46:10.825
Talk about us in your classes, in your workplace.

1628
01:46:11.385 --> 01:46:13.647
I know there's a lot of you that just do random things.

1629
01:46:14.127 --> 01:46:18.290
There's always room to talk about stuff that we cover in FFP pod.

1630
01:46:19.772 --> 01:46:34.459
You either die a hero or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain, and we will be dying as heroes in the quest to continue to cover frontier and the history of science in a way that is accessible to everybody.

1631
01:46:35.400 --> 01:46:42.964
I am Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD and my biffles,

1632
01:46:43.684 --> 01:46:46.789
Krishna Chowdhury, we love you all.

1633
01:46:46.849 --> 01:46:47.910
Thank you again so much.

1634
01:46:48.131 --> 01:46:53.699
Oh, we didn't yet put these books on the third shelf, but you'll see them on the third shelf in the next episode.

1635
01:46:54.160 --> 01:46:56.463
And we will see you all next week.
