WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.051 --> 00:00:00.812
Hello, Internet.

2
00:00:00.832 --> 00:00:08.999
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

3
00:00:10.080 --> 00:00:15.525
We are traveling this week, and so we're going to have a special deep dive episode.

4
00:00:15.646 --> 00:00:20.750
If you couldn't already tell, it's about the Artemis II mission that's coming up.

5
00:00:20.790 --> 00:00:24.934
This should be coming up right before the launch window, which starts on February 6th.

6
00:00:25.795 --> 00:00:32.258
We're going to talk about the Artemis II program, the Artemis program generally, why it's different from Apollo.

7
00:00:33.098 --> 00:00:40.301
We're going to do some debunking of moon landing myths and maybe a little potpourri of other stuff in there as well.

8
00:00:41.161 --> 00:00:46.263
You are going to learn something today because this is from First Principles.

9
00:01:02.123 --> 00:01:06.946
So it's been more than half a century, 50 years since we've gone to the moon.

10
00:01:06.966 --> 00:01:09.667
The final Apollo mission was Apollo 17.

11
00:01:10.267 --> 00:01:11.588
We had a moon buggy.

12
00:01:12.008 --> 00:01:15.130
We had a car on the moon that we were driving around.

13
00:01:15.630 --> 00:01:16.531
It was amazing.

14
00:01:17.471 --> 00:01:24.973
And now the United States, through the NASA, National Aeronautics and Space Administration, we have chosen to go back.

15
00:01:26.053 --> 00:01:26.253
Right?

16
00:01:26.913 --> 00:01:29.974
So I wanted to take this opportunity because Artemis 2 is coming up.

17
00:01:29.994 --> 00:01:31.554
The launch window is February 2nd.

18
00:01:31.854 --> 00:01:33.995
Sorry, February 6th is when it opens up.

19
00:01:34.755 --> 00:01:40.856
I wanted to take this opportunity to talk about some of the differences between the Artemis missions and the Apollo missions.

20
00:01:41.596 --> 00:01:44.557
And then, you know, towards the end of the episode, maybe we'll go into...

21
00:01:45.968 --> 00:01:52.892
something that I never wanted to do, but I guess we're doing, is debunking these absurd moon conspiracy myths.

22
00:01:54.853 --> 00:01:57.334
Let's get started with 1961.

23
00:01:57.874 --> 00:02:03.357
President JFK, John F. Kennedy, commits the United States to go to the moon in a congressional address.

24
00:02:03.717 --> 00:02:15.063
And in 1962, he actually gives a speech at Rice University, which is arguably more famous because he's the one who says, he's the one who says, you know, but why some say the moon?

25
00:02:16.320 --> 00:02:18.961
And they may well ask why climb the highest mountain?

26
00:02:19.621 --> 00:02:22.822
Why 35 years ago fly the Atlantic?

27
00:02:23.042 --> 00:02:28.804
And he's talking about Charles Lindbergh who flew the Atlantic from the United States all the way to Paris.

28
00:02:29.224 --> 00:02:31.325
And then he inserts a joke on his own.

29
00:02:31.345 --> 00:02:33.466
He says, why does Rice play Texas?

30
00:02:33.966 --> 00:02:34.546
And he's.

31
00:02:34.726 --> 00:02:55.098
at rice stadium and that gives a that gets a huge uproar and he uses that uproar to he was a brilliant orator you know and he uses that sort of momentum to be like we choose to go to the moon we choose to go to the moon in this decade and do the other things not because they are easy but because they are hard

32
00:02:55.987 --> 00:02:58.209
That's my best Boston accent.

33
00:02:58.289 --> 00:02:59.971
That was quite good.

34
00:03:00.892 --> 00:03:06.637
But in that statement there, I mean, it's incredibly inspirational.

35
00:03:07.098 --> 00:03:16.086
But in that statement, he actually gives a clue as to why we're doing that in the first place, which is we want to make it so hard that the Soviets can't catch up.

36
00:03:16.767 --> 00:03:19.109
At the time, there was a Cold War sprint.

37
00:03:19.850 --> 00:03:20.050
right?

38
00:03:20.850 --> 00:03:23.491
The Soviets had already beaten us with Sputnik.

39
00:03:23.991 --> 00:03:28.232
Yuri Gagarin was on the cover of Time magazine with a hammer and sickle.

40
00:03:28.532 --> 00:03:37.714
And we wanted to make the finish line so far away that everyone who was playing this race, the space race, had to start over from scratch.

41
00:03:38.134 --> 00:03:39.594
And so we're like, we're going to go to the moon.

42
00:03:39.974 --> 00:03:43.355
Now, Yuri Gagarin and the Mercury astronauts were,

43
00:03:43.535 --> 00:03:45.397
They just went into Earth orbit.

44
00:03:45.437 --> 00:03:49.359
That's about like 100 kilometers to like 200, 300, 500 kilometers.

45
00:03:49.860 --> 00:03:53.022
Now we're doing hundreds of thousands of kilometers.

46
00:03:53.082 --> 00:03:56.345
The moon is 380 kilometers away.

47
00:03:56.405 --> 00:04:04.751
That requires a whole new set of technology, a whole new paradigm shift in how we even approach the space problem.

48
00:04:04.771 --> 00:04:06.032
We've got to land someone.

49
00:04:06.332 --> 00:04:07.433
We've got to bring them back.

50
00:04:08.154 --> 00:04:09.535
We've got to do all these things, right?

51
00:04:09.555 --> 00:04:10.135
Right.

52
00:04:10.435 --> 00:04:15.059
And so the idea was we just make the finish line in classic American fashion.

53
00:04:15.140 --> 00:04:17.442
If we lost, we're just like, no, it's not over.

54
00:04:17.802 --> 00:04:18.463
It's over there.

55
00:04:18.623 --> 00:04:19.163
Yeah.

56
00:04:19.243 --> 00:04:20.004
What are you talking about?

57
00:04:20.164 --> 00:04:20.745
It's over there.

58
00:04:20.825 --> 00:04:22.006
Like we're still running.

59
00:04:22.466 --> 00:04:22.686
Right.

60
00:04:23.607 --> 00:04:29.312
And that's sort of the crucible in which Apollo was born.

61
00:04:29.473 --> 00:04:29.613
Right.

62
00:04:29.653 --> 00:04:29.833
Right.

63
00:04:30.253 --> 00:04:33.516
Now, Apollo was a unilateral U.S. effort.

64
00:04:34.097 --> 00:04:34.978
U.S. astronauts.

65
00:04:36.010 --> 00:04:38.392
U.S. technology, U.S. money.

66
00:04:39.292 --> 00:04:40.613
Everything was American.

67
00:04:41.093 --> 00:04:52.741
And I think an important point just to punctuate that is in an effort to win the Cold War race, we were willing at the time to do everything.

68
00:04:52.841 --> 00:04:53.101
Yeah.

69
00:04:53.441 --> 00:04:58.605
Put the money, recruit the resources, the talent to execute on it.

70
00:04:58.745 --> 00:04:58.945
Yeah.

71
00:04:59.205 --> 00:05:01.246
We don't live in that world anymore.

72
00:05:01.326 --> 00:05:01.807
Exactly.

73
00:05:01.827 --> 00:05:02.347
Exactly.

74
00:05:02.487 --> 00:05:02.968
Exactly.

75
00:05:03.288 --> 00:05:06.993
And so Apollo was this just American, all-American model.

76
00:05:07.474 --> 00:05:08.535
Artemis is very different.

77
00:05:08.575 --> 00:05:09.817
It's an international effort.

78
00:05:10.197 --> 00:05:11.859
There's this thing called the Artemis Accord.

79
00:05:12.019 --> 00:05:13.461
60 countries have signed it.

80
00:05:13.882 --> 00:05:18.027
It's a peaceful, transparent, and sustainable space exploration treaty.

81
00:05:18.728 --> 00:05:22.551
That's saying, you know, we're not going to just expend resources.

82
00:05:22.732 --> 00:05:23.692
It's going to be sustainable.

83
00:05:24.093 --> 00:05:25.234
It's going to be cooperative.

84
00:05:25.574 --> 00:05:28.917
But all of these countries are sort of on the Western block.

85
00:05:29.558 --> 00:05:32.360
It's NATO plus allies, right?

86
00:05:32.920 --> 00:05:35.783
And there is still kind of a space race.

87
00:05:36.083 --> 00:05:38.145
There is kind of a multipolar competition.

88
00:05:38.585 --> 00:05:41.648
China is talking about landing taikonauts.

89
00:05:41.688 --> 00:05:42.929
That's what they call their astronauts.

90
00:05:42.949 --> 00:05:43.329
Taikonauts.

91
00:05:44.071 --> 00:05:47.829
They're planning to land their Taekunauts by the 2030s.

92
00:05:47.849 --> 00:05:48.030
Mm-hmm.

93
00:05:49.602 --> 00:05:52.904
Russia is colluding with China, if that's what you can call it.

94
00:05:52.924 --> 00:05:53.545
Collusion.

95
00:05:53.605 --> 00:05:53.885
Yeah.

96
00:05:54.325 --> 00:05:54.566
Yeah.

97
00:05:54.626 --> 00:05:59.589
So just like we're colluding with like 60 other countries, the two of them are, you know, colluding with themselves.

98
00:06:00.330 --> 00:06:02.071
And it's a very different ballgame now.

99
00:06:02.471 --> 00:06:03.572
Right.

100
00:06:03.632 --> 00:06:06.794
One of our crew that's going on Artemis 2 is Canadian.

101
00:06:07.175 --> 00:06:10.457
That just shows just how different Artemis is from Apollo.

102
00:06:10.537 --> 00:06:14.500
Apollo is just all American astronauts that are like Air Force pilots.

103
00:06:15.040 --> 00:06:15.840
Or Navy pilots.

104
00:06:16.240 --> 00:06:20.681
Now we've got a literal Canadian who's on the mission.

105
00:06:21.882 --> 00:06:33.104
What's interesting, the timing, which they could never have expected, because Artemis has been planning this for such a long period of time, the geopolitical context in which the launch is happening is interesting.

106
00:06:33.324 --> 00:06:33.724
Yeah.

107
00:06:33.844 --> 00:06:40.186
Because the Prime Minister of Canada just came out at the World Economic Forum and gave a speech effectively...

108
00:06:41.206 --> 00:06:57.635
They're calling it the great divorce from a political, social context in terms of Canada no longer viewing the United States as a reliable partner and sort of encouraging the EU as a bloc to think about...

109
00:06:58.519 --> 00:07:03.283
what the future looks like with an unreliable partner in the U S yeah.

110
00:07:03.643 --> 00:07:11.489
And I just bring this up to sort of differentiate that space has always been this arena historically.

111
00:07:12.650 --> 00:07:18.755
There's some things, you know, that are changing that in recent memory, but historically that has been a political.

112
00:07:18.775 --> 00:07:19.035
Yeah.

113
00:07:19.055 --> 00:07:19.215
Yeah.

114
00:07:20.087 --> 00:07:28.482
And everyone recognizes the value of all of us working together because the fruits of that are just so beneficial to everybody.

115
00:07:28.722 --> 00:07:29.764
Yeah.

116
00:07:29.784 --> 00:07:33.150
But this is happening in a geopolitical environment.

117
00:07:34.798 --> 00:07:45.060
That is becoming more contentious, very not similar to the Cold War era, but it's just very – it is not a stable geopolitical context in which this is happening.

118
00:07:45.621 --> 00:07:51.942
But it is great that the collaboration in this is still going forth despite the geopolitical tensions.

119
00:07:51.982 --> 00:07:52.742
Yeah, yeah.

120
00:07:52.842 --> 00:07:54.303
I think you make a very good point.

121
00:07:54.323 --> 00:07:55.503
You know, space is –

122
00:07:56.463 --> 00:07:58.407
off Earth, by definition.

123
00:07:58.587 --> 00:07:58.807
Right?

124
00:07:59.248 --> 00:08:02.293
And it makes you think, okay, Earth is like this rock.

125
00:08:03.755 --> 00:08:05.619
And then there's another rock that

126
00:08:06.972 --> 00:08:08.213
Very few humans have been on.

127
00:08:08.333 --> 00:08:08.634
Fine.

128
00:08:08.694 --> 00:08:09.635
It's all been American.

129
00:08:10.035 --> 00:08:12.538
But we're just on this rock.

130
00:08:12.578 --> 00:08:12.818
Yes.

131
00:08:12.998 --> 00:08:13.218
Right?

132
00:08:13.278 --> 00:08:26.671
And the great thing about the Artemis Accords and the Artemis program to me is that it's one part of American geopolitical policy that has kept that...

133
00:08:28.022 --> 00:08:28.703
Yes.

134
00:08:29.363 --> 00:08:29.644
You know?

135
00:08:31.025 --> 00:08:31.946
I really like that.

136
00:08:32.707 --> 00:08:36.631
So Apollo, it was this flag in the dust model, not like Artemis, right?

137
00:08:36.671 --> 00:08:46.062
Flag in the dust meaning like you just put a—you plant an American flag on the moon, and it's designed to demonstrate the superiority of our liberal democracy.

138
00:08:46.242 --> 00:08:46.362
Right.

139
00:08:46.562 --> 00:08:50.103
That's embedded in capitalism over Soviet communism.

140
00:08:50.544 --> 00:08:53.105
It's an ideological battle that we're trying to win.

141
00:08:53.525 --> 00:08:58.927
It's technological at the end of the day, but the reason why we're spending all that money is because of ideology.

142
00:08:59.147 --> 00:08:59.347
Right.

143
00:08:59.447 --> 00:08:59.647
Right.

144
00:08:59.767 --> 00:09:00.907
And that's very important.

145
00:09:01.348 --> 00:09:06.169
And Artemis is really a paradigm shift towards permanence and sustainability.

146
00:09:06.530 --> 00:09:09.691
Apollo was we get there, we plant the flag, we come back.

147
00:09:09.711 --> 00:09:11.151
No repeatability necessarily.

148
00:09:11.191 --> 00:09:13.412
Like it wasn't the core function.

149
00:09:13.472 --> 00:09:15.773
It's the destination was the goal, not the journey.

150
00:09:15.793 --> 00:09:15.893
Yeah.

151
00:09:15.893 --> 00:09:16.173
Yes.

152
00:09:16.353 --> 00:09:16.574
Yeah.

153
00:09:16.634 --> 00:09:21.297
And in Artemis, we're trying to get there and we're trying to really establish a permanent presence.

154
00:09:21.337 --> 00:09:21.537
Right.

155
00:09:21.918 --> 00:09:37.630
President Donald Trump issued an executive order that called to begin construction of a base in 2030 and also have a nuclear reactor be ready to launch towards the lunar surface by 2030.

156
00:09:37.670 --> 00:09:40.212
And NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman said,

157
00:09:41.111 --> 00:09:43.973
purported that sentiment, right?

158
00:09:44.473 --> 00:09:52.759
And this is all to prepare us to go to Mars because we want a permanent base on the moon, and that way from moon we can sort of piggyback and go to Mars.

159
00:09:52.779 --> 00:09:54.981
We can establish a permanent base on the moon.

160
00:09:55.401 --> 00:10:05.148
We can understand what it is like to live on another celestial body without oxygen, without all of the comforts of the Earth's atmosphere and all of the hard things.

161
00:10:05.568 --> 00:10:10.051
If we can do that in our local neighborhood, then we can go to Mars, which is a year away,

162
00:10:10.571 --> 00:10:11.612
Best case scenario.

163
00:10:11.932 --> 00:10:13.153
It becomes this way station.

164
00:10:13.193 --> 00:10:15.314
It's like a training ground and a way station.

165
00:10:15.614 --> 00:10:15.855
Yes.

166
00:10:15.995 --> 00:10:17.035
Or a waypoint, rather.

167
00:10:17.295 --> 00:10:17.536
Yeah.

168
00:10:17.556 --> 00:10:38.569
Or like, you can do a whole, especially, I'm not saying that we're there yet, but there are a bunch of TV shows that talk about how there's all the H3 that's below the surface of the moon, and that's very fuel efficient, and if we can figure out how to mine that, then again, it becomes basically a refueling point on the journey to Mars.

169
00:10:38.589 --> 00:10:38.709
Yeah.

170
00:10:39.009 --> 00:10:40.010
Yeah, exactly.

171
00:10:40.390 --> 00:10:45.075
And in the Apollo paradigm, it was urgency-driven, as you said, right?

172
00:10:45.115 --> 00:10:45.796
We got to win.

173
00:10:46.276 --> 00:10:52.743
And so 2.3% of the total federal budget was given to NASA to make this happen.

174
00:10:52.763 --> 00:10:53.243
That's so crazy.

175
00:10:53.263 --> 00:10:53.964
That's a lot.

176
00:10:53.984 --> 00:10:54.505
That's a lot.

177
00:10:54.705 --> 00:10:55.225
That's a lot.

178
00:10:55.305 --> 00:10:55.566
Okay?

179
00:10:55.706 --> 00:10:56.246
I love...

180
00:10:57.067 --> 00:11:20.850
science and i love technology but 2.3 percent is a lot now if you put that in the context of how much we spend on the military perhaps it's not a lot but i i would say 2.3 percent is is quite a bit right but it's a totally different paradigm with artemis you've got this space economy and the goal is to have a sustained presence right so you've got this lunar getaway you've got

181
00:11:21.490 --> 00:11:32.696
In-situ resource utilization, that thing that you were talking about where we utilize the resources of the moon, and we're partnering with agencies that are commercial.

182
00:11:32.776 --> 00:11:39.440
For example, SpaceX, the Starship human landing system, the way we're going to land on the moon is currently contracted to SpaceX.

183
00:11:39.500 --> 00:11:39.660
Yeah.

184
00:11:40.200 --> 00:11:49.185
Right now, this is the same as before Grumman, which is the predecessor of Northrop Grumman, was actually involved in creating the lunar lander.

185
00:11:49.225 --> 00:11:50.245
So this is not different.

186
00:11:50.305 --> 00:11:54.127
But now with Artemis, it's a completely different scale.

187
00:11:54.648 --> 00:11:55.988
I will just make a quick note.

188
00:11:56.189 --> 00:12:02.232
If you are a fan of Elon Musk and you are not a believer in the moon landing, you should talk to Elon Musk.

189
00:12:02.952 --> 00:12:07.194
Because he's clearly a believer in the moon landing and he got the contract to do it again.

190
00:12:07.314 --> 00:12:07.574
Yeah.

191
00:12:07.875 --> 00:12:10.096
And so I'm just trying to put two and two together here.

192
00:12:10.136 --> 00:12:13.077
The math, the math needs to equal.

193
00:12:13.437 --> 00:12:13.637
Yeah.

194
00:12:14.078 --> 00:12:18.780
And if we were to, if we were to stay on the topic of SpaceX and Elon Musk, there's a side note.

195
00:12:18.880 --> 00:12:20.001
So, um,

196
00:12:21.108 --> 00:12:35.522
NASA Administrator Sean Duffy last year actually reopened the human landing system contract because the Aerospace Safety Advisory Panel is warning that SpaceX's Starship human landing system is going to be years late.

197
00:12:36.122 --> 00:12:36.402
Okay.

198
00:12:36.683 --> 00:12:37.523
He was then fired.

199
00:12:38.644 --> 00:12:43.989
And then he was replaced by Jared Isaacman, who's a billionaire commercial astronaut.

200
00:12:44.009 --> 00:12:44.570
Okay.

201
00:12:45.251 --> 00:12:53.217
Neither the demonstration nor the design certification review, which was supposed to happen in the summer of this past year, has happened.

202
00:12:53.878 --> 00:13:00.523
And there's not really any information about what the status of that human landing system is.

203
00:13:00.964 --> 00:13:04.947
But it's like it's quite urgent because China says they're going to get there by 2030.

204
00:13:05.027 --> 00:13:05.327
Right.

205
00:13:05.467 --> 00:13:05.648
Right.

206
00:13:06.148 --> 00:13:07.429
We're cutting it quite close.

207
00:13:07.469 --> 00:13:07.709
Yes.

208
00:13:08.189 --> 00:13:08.450
You know?

209
00:13:08.550 --> 00:13:14.674
And we know that they are putting all the resources to bear to accomplish the goal.

210
00:13:14.894 --> 00:13:15.415
Yeah.

211
00:13:15.455 --> 00:13:17.756
Given their system and how it's structured, it's top.

212
00:13:17.776 --> 00:13:19.998
You know, they can, they want something to happen.

213
00:13:21.130 --> 00:13:45.875
it happens it happens right because they just say what happens and then and then it happens right um so with all that in mind now we're here with artemis 2 right this is the critical crude validation flight the artemis 2 rocket which we have here that lester has painstakingly made with lego blocks shout out lego if you want to sponsor the show you know we're here yeah

214
00:13:47.313 --> 00:13:56.637
Yeah, well, he made this thing, and this thing is now currently sitting on the launch pad at Kennedy Space Flight Center in Florida.

215
00:13:57.017 --> 00:13:59.098
Which we touched on in our rundown on the last episode.

216
00:13:59.118 --> 00:14:00.158
Yep, yeah, yeah.

217
00:14:00.218 --> 00:14:05.780
And so now, as of the publishing of this episode, it should still be there.

218
00:14:06.500 --> 00:14:10.042
February 6th is when the window opens up and...

219
00:14:11.232 --> 00:14:11.953
Fingers crossed.

220
00:14:12.613 --> 00:14:16.577
And just before we get to the rundown, we're going to break this up into two parts.

221
00:14:16.877 --> 00:14:25.785
I want to just zoom in on this launch window concept because, you know, some of the reaction would be, oh, are the studios not ready for the production?

222
00:14:26.086 --> 00:14:28.688
Or like, oh, of course that it's going to get delayed.

223
00:14:29.068 --> 00:14:33.553
You know, and I think helping understand the idea that when we have a launch window, right, like we are both...

224
00:14:34.013 --> 00:14:37.976
you know, we're spinning and in orbit of the sun and so are as everything else.

225
00:14:38.036 --> 00:14:47.602
And so when you talk about launch windows, it's about how your flight trajectory is going to align with the normal movement of the planetary bodies.

226
00:14:47.662 --> 00:14:48.243
Exactly.

227
00:14:48.903 --> 00:14:49.664
Such that we,

228
00:14:50.544 --> 00:14:51.984
We have a certain amount of fuel.

229
00:14:52.285 --> 00:14:53.205
Everything is very precise.

230
00:14:53.445 --> 00:14:54.825
Everything is very precise.

231
00:14:54.845 --> 00:14:59.927
There's only a few paths to getting there based on what we've built to get there.

232
00:15:00.027 --> 00:15:00.447
Exactly.

233
00:15:00.487 --> 00:15:02.887
And it depends on what we want to do with the moon, right?

234
00:15:02.907 --> 00:15:08.949
We're not landing on the moon with Artemis II, but if we want certain spaces on the moon to be lit up,

235
00:15:09.589 --> 00:15:12.330
We need to time it with the phases of the moon.

236
00:15:12.610 --> 00:15:12.790
Right.

237
00:15:12.990 --> 00:15:13.190
Right.

238
00:15:13.450 --> 00:15:21.212
And so that's why the launch window is like early February and then it's late February and March because the lunar month is 29 days.

239
00:15:21.452 --> 00:15:25.033
And we need to, you can't just go at a random time.

240
00:15:25.113 --> 00:15:25.293
Yes.

241
00:15:25.573 --> 00:15:25.793
Right.

242
00:15:25.913 --> 00:15:26.873
Yes.

243
00:15:27.073 --> 00:15:29.094
It's not the subway where it's just like it's constantly running.

244
00:15:29.114 --> 00:15:30.094
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

245
00:15:30.114 --> 00:15:33.315
There are the dynamics that, and I just wanted to make sure we touched on that briefly.

246
00:15:33.375 --> 00:15:33.935
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

247
00:15:33.975 --> 00:15:34.175
Good.

248
00:15:34.375 --> 00:15:38.716
For folks who might not understand the concept of a launch window, that's kind of where it comes from.

249
00:15:39.896 --> 00:15:45.120
Before we get back to continuing coverage of the main story, many of you have loved the rundown.

250
00:15:45.180 --> 00:15:52.085
It's a quick overview of other stories we can't go so much into depth on because there's only so much time in a day.

251
00:15:52.105 --> 00:15:58.630
So we just hit some highlights of what's going on that's current, recent, breaking, and frontier research.

252
00:15:59.090 --> 00:16:02.412
Our first story in the rundown today is rock art history.

253
00:16:03.533 --> 00:16:06.254
From at least 67,000 years ago.

254
00:16:06.654 --> 00:16:08.815
In Sulawesi.

255
00:16:08.975 --> 00:16:09.295
Which is.

256
00:16:09.375 --> 00:16:12.315
This is now a combination of multiple organizations.

257
00:16:12.335 --> 00:16:13.496
We have Griffith University.

258
00:16:13.876 --> 00:16:14.976
Southern Cross University.

259
00:16:15.036 --> 00:16:15.556
And others.

260
00:16:15.896 --> 00:16:16.737
Published in Nature.

261
00:16:17.877 --> 00:16:20.318
And this is about the outline of a hand.

262
00:16:20.698 --> 00:16:23.318
Made with red pigment on a cave in Indonesia.

263
00:16:23.759 --> 00:16:26.359
That's at least 67,000 years old.

264
00:16:26.399 --> 00:16:28.640
And maybe the world's oldest.

265
00:16:28.660 --> 00:16:28.820
Yeah.

266
00:16:29.931 --> 00:16:32.892
Rock art, according to recent studies.

267
00:16:33.012 --> 00:16:34.052
Yeah, this is incredible.

268
00:16:34.132 --> 00:16:38.113
It's supposed to be on the lost continent of Sulawesi.

269
00:16:38.353 --> 00:16:46.976
So back before the Ice Ages, or during the Ice Ages, I guess, when all of the water of the world was sequestered into glaciers,

270
00:16:47.656 --> 00:16:49.358
The sea level was lower.

271
00:16:49.798 --> 00:16:57.104
And so Indonesia, Papua New Guinea, and Australia were a continuous landmass called Sulawesi.

272
00:16:57.424 --> 00:16:59.086
It's a lost continent, so to speak.

273
00:16:59.426 --> 00:17:06.832
And to date, what they've done is they've dated the mineral crusts that form on top of these paintings.

274
00:17:07.253 --> 00:17:09.975
Because, you know, you could ask, like, how do you know that this thing is 68,000?

275
00:17:11.508 --> 00:17:11.949
Years old.

276
00:17:11.969 --> 00:17:12.169
Yes.

277
00:17:12.369 --> 00:17:24.067
Well, what you can do is you can take the cave paintings and what ends up happening is there's the stuff called cave popcorn that shows up on top of the on top of the cave paintings that.

278
00:17:24.087 --> 00:17:24.187
Yeah.

279
00:17:25.408 --> 00:17:28.590
is at least as old as the cave paintings, right?

280
00:17:28.931 --> 00:17:32.573
Because the cave paintings formed and then this mineral deposit formed.

281
00:17:32.874 --> 00:17:34.535
So we can date the mineral deposit.

282
00:17:34.575 --> 00:17:34.775
Yes.

283
00:17:34.995 --> 00:17:44.622
And using radiocarbon and other kinds of radioactive dating, we can say that this stuff was at least 60,000, 67,000 years old.

284
00:17:44.843 --> 00:17:45.023
Right.

285
00:17:45.303 --> 00:17:47.164
And this puts it as...

286
00:17:48.325 --> 00:17:51.147
Older than the cave paintings in, what's it called?

287
00:17:51.207 --> 00:17:52.028
Laskauks.

288
00:17:52.148 --> 00:17:52.848
Yeah.

289
00:17:52.888 --> 00:17:58.172
Laskauks, France, which we mentioned in the previous episode.

290
00:17:58.232 --> 00:18:00.894
Again, I'm pretty sure that's how it's pronounced.

291
00:18:01.894 --> 00:18:08.159
In the previous episode, we did an ancient math story from Mesopotamia.

292
00:18:08.179 --> 00:18:10.720
Yeah, and we were talking about art in the ancient past.

293
00:18:10.740 --> 00:18:11.341
Laskauks came up.

294
00:18:15.234 --> 00:18:15.834
That's all I'm saying.

295
00:18:16.174 --> 00:18:26.817
Okay, so jokes aside, though, one of the coolest things that I found about this story was that in the same cave, they also had recent paintings from about 3,000 to 4,000 years ago.

296
00:18:27.157 --> 00:18:27.217
Ah.

297
00:18:27.857 --> 00:18:30.017
Which I find kind of incredible.

298
00:18:30.077 --> 00:18:34.078
Like, imagine, you know, you're going back to a cave as human beings.

299
00:18:34.098 --> 00:18:40.580
You're going back to a cave that has been this repository of art for 60,000 years.

300
00:18:40.600 --> 00:18:40.740
Yeah.

301
00:18:42.352 --> 00:18:42.973
Isn't that kind of cool?

302
00:18:42.993 --> 00:18:43.974
Yeah, no, it's vague.

303
00:18:43.995 --> 00:18:49.062
To be those human beings, to be like, I go back and like those handprints were 60,000 years ago.

304
00:18:49.182 --> 00:18:49.563
Yeah, yeah.

305
00:18:49.843 --> 00:18:50.324
I don't know.

306
00:18:50.404 --> 00:18:52.307
I think that's really cool.

307
00:18:52.327 --> 00:18:53.969
The human story is so beautiful.

308
00:18:53.989 --> 00:18:55.031
Yeah, it really is.

309
00:18:55.331 --> 00:18:55.792
I like that.

310
00:18:56.332 --> 00:18:57.835
Our story number two.

311
00:18:59.125 --> 00:19:08.775
is about climate change and this concept of elevation-dependent climate change in mountain environments.

312
00:19:09.516 --> 00:19:15.282
This is coming out of the University of Portsmouth in the UK, Montana Technological University,

313
00:19:16.022 --> 00:19:35.476
montana state university and the institute of atmospheric sciences and climate national research council in torino italy published in nature earth and environment the summary here is that mountain regions show rapid environmental change under anthropogenic warming and

314
00:19:36.136 --> 00:19:45.659
The rates of these changes are often stratified by elevation, leading to elevation-dependent climate change, or EDCC.

315
00:19:45.979 --> 00:19:48.380
Yeah, and this is something that I've noticed.

316
00:19:48.500 --> 00:19:57.503
I go to the Himalayas almost every year, maybe every other year, and you can literally kind of see the snow line decreasing, okay?

317
00:19:57.543 --> 00:19:57.743
Yeah.

318
00:19:58.643 --> 00:20:08.032
They analyzed data from 1980 to 2020, and they found that the mountains are actually warming 0.2 degrees Celsius faster than the lowland plains.

319
00:20:08.553 --> 00:20:11.856
And snowfall is increasingly being replaced by rain.

320
00:20:11.976 --> 00:20:15.639
I mean, anecdotally, you saw this when you went to Big Bear right outside Los Angeles.

321
00:20:15.659 --> 00:20:18.842
I literally just experienced this, which is like, it's January.

322
00:20:20.607 --> 00:20:23.188
And normally there's plenty of snow on the ground.

323
00:20:23.789 --> 00:20:27.470
And it was I'd never see I'd never seen the ground.

324
00:20:27.970 --> 00:20:28.210
Yeah.

325
00:20:28.791 --> 00:20:28.971
Yeah.

326
00:20:29.251 --> 00:20:33.313
And for context, there was a lot of precipitation in Southern California.

327
00:20:33.393 --> 00:20:38.495
Now, obviously, this is anecdotal and we don't want to conflate weather versus climate.

328
00:20:38.535 --> 00:20:41.716
But if you look at the gradual trend, this is what they're arguing.

329
00:20:41.736 --> 00:20:42.076
Correct.

330
00:20:42.116 --> 00:20:42.657
From 1980 to 2020.

331
00:20:45.495 --> 00:20:47.495
Snowfall is being replaced by rain.

332
00:20:47.956 --> 00:20:48.216
Okay.

333
00:20:48.716 --> 00:20:50.196
And that means more flooding.

334
00:20:50.396 --> 00:20:54.877
Pakistan had some really bad flooding that killed 1000 people this past summer.

335
00:20:55.497 --> 00:20:56.738
It's only going to get worse.

336
00:20:57.438 --> 00:21:02.499
And mountain regions are really critical for a lot of human population.

337
00:21:02.659 --> 00:21:06.320
Billions of people rely on mountains for their source of water.

338
00:21:06.340 --> 00:21:06.700
Yeah.

339
00:21:06.960 --> 00:21:18.123
And if it's just going to rain instead of being sequestered into ice that then gradually becomes water, that's going to be huge for climate catastrophe.

340
00:21:18.403 --> 00:21:21.224
It does, like, just into it, it does make sense.

341
00:21:21.244 --> 00:21:26.185
If you have the whole concept of heat rises when you're in a house and your attic is hotter than the basement.

342
00:21:26.765 --> 00:21:33.748
It's like, okay, well, at higher elevations, it makes... Yeah, the difference is going to be bigger at those higher elevations.

343
00:21:33.768 --> 00:21:35.689
So that does make sense.

344
00:21:36.670 --> 00:21:47.835
For a lighter story that is not as existential as elevation-dependent climate change is a story that was actually published in the New York Times.

345
00:21:47.875 --> 00:21:52.757
We love to see when science makes it to the front pages of mainstream media because...

346
00:21:53.377 --> 00:21:58.680
In this case, it's about dogs building their vocabulary like toddlers.

347
00:21:59.361 --> 00:22:04.124
And so this is something that, like, makes total sense.

348
00:22:04.324 --> 00:22:04.524
Yeah.

349
00:22:05.385 --> 00:22:06.325
Anyone who's out of dog.

350
00:22:06.826 --> 00:22:09.187
And so the summary on this, this was in science.

351
00:22:09.627 --> 00:22:15.471
Children as young as 18 months can acquire novel words by overhearing third-party interactions.

352
00:22:16.052 --> 00:22:16.732
Don't be nosy.

353
00:22:17.152 --> 00:22:20.955
Demonstrating similar learning processes in non-human species –

354
00:22:21.555 --> 00:22:35.964
would indicate that social cognitive skills supporting this process are not exclusively human, but may have evolved or can develop in other species, offering valuable insights into the origin of language-related cognition.

355
00:22:36.484 --> 00:22:38.766
We're not so special after all.

356
00:22:38.906 --> 00:22:43.669
Yeah, and what I really like about this story is how they did that experiment.

357
00:22:43.989 --> 00:22:44.810
So what they...

358
00:22:45.490 --> 00:22:47.951
looked at was particular types of dogs.

359
00:22:47.971 --> 00:22:54.035
They actually found that herding dogs have a particular knack for this border Cal border collies, Australian shepherds.

360
00:22:54.795 --> 00:22:59.218
What they did was they said, okay, we're going to have the human owners toss a toy back and forth.

361
00:23:00.533 --> 00:23:03.274
While the dog is just monitoring the situation.

362
00:23:03.494 --> 00:23:03.754
Okay.

363
00:23:04.154 --> 00:23:05.795
So there's no reward based learning.

364
00:23:06.315 --> 00:23:10.856
There's no like, oh, here's a treat when you associate this toy with a certain name.

365
00:23:11.396 --> 00:23:15.698
Instead, the humans are going back and forth with this toy and they refer to it.

366
00:23:16.298 --> 00:23:17.759
multiple times in the conversation.

367
00:23:17.779 --> 00:23:19.400
So they're like, this is stingray.

368
00:23:19.820 --> 00:23:20.801
Give me the stingray.

369
00:23:21.201 --> 00:23:22.362
Oh, do you want the stingray?

370
00:23:22.462 --> 00:23:23.343
I'll take the stingray.

371
00:23:23.383 --> 00:23:25.604
And the dog is just sort of passively observing.

372
00:23:25.984 --> 00:23:28.686
And then later on, they test the, the dog.

373
00:23:28.706 --> 00:23:29.867
They're like, bring me stingray.

374
00:23:30.467 --> 00:23:34.570
80% of the time, these dogs, they, they tested 10 dogs.

375
00:23:34.610 --> 00:23:41.854
80% of the time it came back with the correct toy, which is way out of statistical noise, you know?

376
00:23:42.335 --> 00:23:42.455
And,

377
00:23:43.945 --> 00:23:48.790
They had a control with 10 other dogs that I guess didn't show this kind of aptitude.

378
00:23:49.510 --> 00:23:50.591
And they were at baseline.

379
00:23:51.252 --> 00:23:54.915
And I particularly like this because I had my family dog.

380
00:23:55.215 --> 00:23:56.016
She was a Corgi.

381
00:23:57.037 --> 00:23:59.900
She would be able to do exactly this.

382
00:24:00.260 --> 00:24:04.163
And we never taught her with reward-based learning because my dad is like...

383
00:24:04.864 --> 00:24:07.565
philosophically against reward-based learning.

384
00:24:08.706 --> 00:24:15.569
So, you know, we would just like be talking in Urdia and Hindi and English, and she understood all three languages.

385
00:24:15.649 --> 00:24:21.592
And when I, I remember once I was like really surprised, I would tell her like, bring me this toy in Urdia.

386
00:24:22.172 --> 00:24:23.593
And she would bring it.

387
00:24:24.313 --> 00:24:25.714
And exactly that toy.

388
00:24:26.154 --> 00:24:29.315
And once she actually brought the wrong toy, and I said, no, no, no, not that one.

389
00:24:29.395 --> 00:24:30.175
I said this one.

390
00:24:30.616 --> 00:24:32.536
She went back, and then she brought the right one.

391
00:24:32.636 --> 00:24:34.157
It was like, I was like, wow.

392
00:24:34.457 --> 00:24:35.738
But it's all passive learning.

393
00:24:35.858 --> 00:24:36.038
Right.

394
00:24:36.318 --> 00:24:36.598
You know?

395
00:24:36.658 --> 00:24:36.818
Yes.

396
00:24:37.098 --> 00:24:37.619
Very cool.

397
00:24:37.659 --> 00:24:37.859
Yes.

398
00:24:38.559 --> 00:24:45.762
As someone who has three dogs, my lived experience maps onto this, except for one dog who...

399
00:24:47.522 --> 00:24:49.643
doesn't have all the marbles upstairs, but that's...

400
00:24:49.663 --> 00:24:50.663
He's part of the control group.

401
00:24:50.683 --> 00:24:51.523
He's part of the control group.

402
00:24:51.543 --> 00:24:52.044
Yeah.

403
00:24:52.064 --> 00:24:52.524
Correct.

404
00:24:52.584 --> 00:24:55.364
He's part of the control group.

405
00:24:55.764 --> 00:24:57.185
I always love a dog story.

406
00:24:57.525 --> 00:25:03.066
All the animal stories, you guys seem to love the animal stories, and so we will continue trying to touch on them as we can.

407
00:25:03.506 --> 00:25:09.028
The last story in the rundown is about life's chemistry, memory,

408
00:25:09.448 --> 00:25:14.729
is the beginnings of life's chemistry and how it may have began in the cold darkness of space.

409
00:25:14.749 --> 00:25:28.733
This is out of our who's university in Denmark published in nature, astronomy, new experiments reveal that protein precursors can form naturally in deep space under extreme, extreme cold and radiation.

410
00:25:29.033 --> 00:25:35.935
Scientists found that simple amino acid bonds and peptides on interstellar dust long before stars and planet exists.

411
00:25:35.955 --> 00:25:36.415
Okay.

412
00:25:36.976 --> 00:25:42.161
This challenges the idea that complex life and chemistry only happens on planets.

413
00:25:42.482 --> 00:25:46.867
It also boosts the odds that life-friendly ingredients are widespread across the universe.

414
00:25:47.187 --> 00:25:51.171
And for those of you who know me, you know my reaction to that is them aliens.

415
00:25:51.712 --> 00:25:52.513
And they are out there.

416
00:25:52.853 --> 00:25:55.676
They are out there, and apparently they're out in deep space.

417
00:25:55.696 --> 00:25:56.477
In deep space.

418
00:25:56.577 --> 00:25:56.797
Right?

419
00:25:57.418 --> 00:25:59.100
This is a pretty cool study.

420
00:25:59.140 --> 00:26:02.623
They recreated the conditions of the interstellar medium in the lab.

421
00:26:03.044 --> 00:26:05.046
Now, that's, first of all, incredibly hard to do.

422
00:26:05.066 --> 00:26:07.408
You have to maintain a very low vacuum.

423
00:26:07.909 --> 00:26:14.636
You have to have extremely high energy particles because, you know, in the interstellar dust, you've got low density, but you also have, like...

424
00:26:15.568 --> 00:26:18.771
Particles that are like whizzing back and forth at near the speed of light.

425
00:26:19.031 --> 00:26:32.601
So what they did was they simulated cosmic rays using particles from an accelerator, Hun Ren Atomki in Hungary, and they had a little compartment that was close to the conditions of interstellar media.

426
00:26:33.642 --> 00:26:38.649
And we already know that amino acids like glycine can form in the intercellular medium.

427
00:26:38.689 --> 00:26:49.622
But what these guys wanted to do was figure out, can we have complex peptide bonds, meaning amino acid with another amino acid with another amino acid together to create a kind of...

428
00:26:51.218 --> 00:26:53.841
protein, but a smaller version of a protein.

429
00:26:54.261 --> 00:26:57.924
So they could form these peptides, and the implications are immense, right?

430
00:26:57.944 --> 00:27:04.089
Because this means that this is a process that can happen anywhere in the interstellar medium, right?

431
00:27:04.129 --> 00:27:09.173
So if you have exoplanets all over the place, when the exoplanet forms, you could have...

432
00:27:09.833 --> 00:27:19.796
stuff in the interstellar medium that has already created complex molecules that are the precursors for life that then get deposited on the exoplanets.

433
00:27:19.936 --> 00:27:22.876
And then perhaps life is even more abundant than we thought.

434
00:27:23.396 --> 00:27:34.299
I mean, right now we think it's just on Earth, but this kind of research lends credibility to the idea that maybe life, just simple life, is not all that rare.

435
00:27:35.019 --> 00:27:37.580
The ingredients necessary for simple life—

436
00:27:38.847 --> 00:27:48.074
Previously, it's like it has to be water-rich, oxygen-rich, all these variables needed to be true in order for us to see the ingredients.

437
00:27:48.094 --> 00:27:49.054
It's not even life-like.

438
00:27:49.074 --> 00:27:49.695
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

439
00:27:49.735 --> 00:27:50.475
Just the ingredients.

440
00:27:50.495 --> 00:27:51.316
Ingredients, yeah.

441
00:27:51.936 --> 00:28:00.082
Now it's like, okay, well, actually, these ingredients can formulate in a much larger surface area than before.

442
00:28:00.142 --> 00:28:00.342
Yeah.

443
00:28:00.623 --> 00:28:03.344
So who knows?

444
00:28:04.608 --> 00:28:05.829
I thought that was a pretty cool story.

445
00:28:06.529 --> 00:28:07.010
Very good.

446
00:28:07.450 --> 00:28:07.950
Very good.

447
00:28:08.450 --> 00:28:13.353
And we're going to space with Artemis II, which we will go back to our main story to continue.

448
00:28:13.913 --> 00:28:22.879
So getting back into the Artemis II mission, I want to talk about the mission architecture, some of the orbital mechanics, and the flight profile.

449
00:28:23.259 --> 00:28:23.499
Okay.

450
00:28:24.019 --> 00:28:29.802
So the space launch system, which we have beautifully recreated here in Legos, is...

451
00:28:30.863 --> 00:28:33.365
It uses a lot of spare shuttle parts.

452
00:28:33.725 --> 00:28:36.186
And there's a photo of me in Huntsville, Alabama.

453
00:28:36.307 --> 00:28:45.973
Actually, when I first moved from India to America, I settled in Huntsville, Alabama with my family for about a year because my dad was working at Marshall Space Flight Center as a...

454
00:28:47.135 --> 00:28:48.036
Solar physicist.

455
00:28:48.677 --> 00:28:57.826
And what you notice immediately is that the space shuttle's architecture is very similar to the Artemis II architecture.

456
00:28:57.846 --> 00:28:57.986
Yes.

457
00:28:58.306 --> 00:28:58.487
Right?

458
00:28:58.747 --> 00:29:03.372
It's got this orange central part and then these solid rocket boosters on the two sides.

459
00:29:03.512 --> 00:29:03.732
Yes.

460
00:29:03.812 --> 00:29:03.992
Right?

461
00:29:04.293 --> 00:29:06.174
And that is not a mistake.

462
00:29:06.194 --> 00:29:06.615
Yes.

463
00:29:06.775 --> 00:29:14.660
What they really did was use a lot of the spare shuttle parts to make the space launch system, this SLS, right?

464
00:29:14.960 --> 00:29:17.842
The launch vehicle is something called the SLS Block 1.

465
00:29:18.282 --> 00:29:23.666
It's got a liftoff thrust of about 8.8 million LBF pounds per hour.

466
00:29:25.348 --> 00:29:26.529
I don't know what the F is, actually.

467
00:29:26.549 --> 00:29:27.329
I should probably know that.

468
00:29:27.389 --> 00:29:30.890
But it exceeds the Saturn V. Really?

469
00:29:30.930 --> 00:29:32.231
By 15%.

470
00:29:32.611 --> 00:29:36.333
The Saturn V's thrust was only 7.5 million pounds.

471
00:29:36.573 --> 00:29:36.733
Yeah.

472
00:29:37.393 --> 00:29:37.593
Yes.

473
00:29:37.633 --> 00:29:39.954
This thing is 8.8 million.

474
00:29:40.355 --> 00:29:40.595
Yes.

475
00:29:40.635 --> 00:29:40.895
Okay?

476
00:29:41.115 --> 00:29:43.396
So it's exceeding it by 15%.

477
00:29:44.096 --> 00:29:47.198
Now, you might be asking, like, why is the rocket still so big?

478
00:29:47.778 --> 00:29:48.778
That's something that I ask.

479
00:29:48.798 --> 00:29:54.581
Because it's like we've had 50 years, and the rocket is still so big.

480
00:29:54.661 --> 00:29:54.861
Yes.

481
00:29:56.010 --> 00:29:56.430
What gives?

482
00:29:56.851 --> 00:29:59.573
And why more thrust?

483
00:29:59.733 --> 00:30:01.414
It actually has less payload.

484
00:30:03.235 --> 00:30:05.737
It's got more thrust, but it's got less payload.

485
00:30:05.777 --> 00:30:07.318
Meaning it can carry less stuff.

486
00:30:07.618 --> 00:30:08.719
It can carry less stuff.

487
00:30:08.759 --> 00:30:12.122
So I was quite confused.

488
00:30:12.782 --> 00:30:13.903
Perplexed, one would say.

489
00:30:13.943 --> 00:30:15.284
Perplexed, yes.

490
00:30:15.664 --> 00:30:17.446
By that number.

491
00:30:18.266 --> 00:30:20.388
So here's the idea.

492
00:30:21.128 --> 00:30:21.649
First of all...

493
00:30:22.587 --> 00:30:26.995
The reason why the rocket is so big is because of the rocket equation.

494
00:30:27.536 --> 00:30:27.796
Okay?

495
00:30:28.117 --> 00:30:32.084
At the end of the day, if you want to, like, leave the Earth, you got to...

496
00:30:33.236 --> 00:30:34.897
push on something.

497
00:30:35.498 --> 00:30:36.339
Newton's third law.

498
00:30:36.899 --> 00:30:39.781
Newton's laws are the laws of the universe, right?

499
00:30:39.861 --> 00:30:40.842
Inertia is a thing.

500
00:30:41.323 --> 00:30:47.027
And so in order to... You can't just, like, create electricity really efficiently and then leave.

501
00:30:47.508 --> 00:30:55.434
You literally have to expend material in one direction to push away in order for your rocket to leave.

502
00:30:56.255 --> 00:31:01.920
And the amount of material is kind of a non-negotiable thing if you want to put a giant electronic...

503
00:31:02.560 --> 00:31:25.978
spacecraft into higher earth orbit and then go all the way to the moon okay so that's one of the reasons why it's about the same scale as the saturn 5 rocket and why the starship the big starship are about the same size right it's because you gotta you gotta leave enough material to get out there and the idea is the space is being taken up by primarily fuel mm-hmm

504
00:31:26.888 --> 00:31:33.480
Because that fuel is the thing you're using to expend to give you the thrust to counteract Earth's gravity.

505
00:31:33.900 --> 00:31:34.742
To be able to leave.

506
00:31:34.942 --> 00:31:35.183
Yeah.

507
00:31:35.543 --> 00:31:36.665
You know, to be able to have enough...

508
00:31:37.783 --> 00:31:38.384
Momentum.

509
00:31:38.684 --> 00:31:39.265
To get out.

510
00:31:39.285 --> 00:31:39.745
To get out.

511
00:31:39.945 --> 00:31:40.826
Yeah, exactly.

512
00:31:41.146 --> 00:31:43.929
And so that's the reason why it's about the same size.

513
00:31:44.230 --> 00:31:44.490
Okay?

514
00:31:44.810 --> 00:31:47.053
Now let's get into the why the less payload.

515
00:31:47.393 --> 00:31:51.377
The short answer is that the Saturn V was actually a three-stage rocket.

516
00:31:51.757 --> 00:31:54.080
There was stage one, stage two, stage three.

517
00:31:54.760 --> 00:31:58.304
And with the three-stage rocket, what you can do is you can get out—

518
00:31:59.406 --> 00:32:03.848
And then you can throw away the heavy things and keep going.

519
00:32:03.908 --> 00:32:05.149
Because you have that second stage.

520
00:32:05.189 --> 00:32:05.429
Yeah.

521
00:32:05.529 --> 00:32:09.250
That second stage is not propelling the third stage's mass.

522
00:32:09.270 --> 00:32:09.991
Yeah.

523
00:32:10.011 --> 00:32:10.571
You know what I mean?

524
00:32:10.591 --> 00:32:10.751
Yep.

525
00:32:10.771 --> 00:32:10.951
Yep.

526
00:32:10.971 --> 00:32:11.151
Yep.

527
00:32:11.191 --> 00:32:13.773
But the SLS is a two-stage rocket.

528
00:32:14.253 --> 00:32:14.553
Got it.

529
00:32:14.753 --> 00:32:15.033
Okay.

530
00:32:15.153 --> 00:32:19.975
There's the first stage, which is from here to here, and the solid rocket boosters.

531
00:32:20.335 --> 00:32:21.956
And then the second stage is all the way here.

532
00:32:22.276 --> 00:32:22.456
Right?

533
00:32:22.516 --> 00:32:25.578
And what that means is with the Saturn V...

534
00:32:26.842 --> 00:32:31.745
The first stage only took about 2.5 minutes, gets out of the Earth's atmosphere, and then it leaves.

535
00:32:32.286 --> 00:32:35.428
This thing sticks around for 8.5 minutes.

536
00:32:35.508 --> 00:32:36.589
Oh, that's significantly longer.

537
00:32:36.609 --> 00:32:36.789
Right?

538
00:32:37.229 --> 00:32:37.429
Yeah.

539
00:32:37.850 --> 00:32:46.616
So the whole time, it's hauling all of the sort of mass that isn't really doing anything.

540
00:32:46.656 --> 00:32:46.836
Right.

541
00:32:47.176 --> 00:32:47.816
Right.

542
00:32:48.817 --> 00:32:53.901
Now, the Saturn V dropped its dead weight, its empty tanks, early and often.

543
00:32:53.921 --> 00:32:54.541
Right.

544
00:32:55.013 --> 00:33:01.018
while the SLS carries its massive empty orange core stage, which is this guy, all the way to the top.

545
00:33:01.138 --> 00:33:01.679
That makes sense.

546
00:33:01.839 --> 00:33:02.039
Right?

547
00:33:02.279 --> 00:33:02.700
That makes sense.

548
00:33:02.720 --> 00:33:14.810
Now, when it comes to engines, the engines on the bottom here, the Saturn V used kerosene, which is our hydrocarbon, so carbon with a bunch of hydrogen bonds.

549
00:33:15.310 --> 00:33:22.996
Those bonds are very energetic, meaning that per gram, kerosene has a lot more chemical energy.

550
00:33:23.337 --> 00:33:23.577
Mm-hmm.

551
00:33:24.678 --> 00:33:27.201
The SLS uses hydrogen and oxygen.

552
00:33:27.622 --> 00:33:28.383
I see.

553
00:33:28.423 --> 00:33:29.885
It's just H2 and O2.

554
00:33:30.346 --> 00:33:35.673
Now, hydrogen is lighter, which means that it'll have a higher exhaust velocity.

555
00:33:36.013 --> 00:33:39.899
When it gets out of the rocket, it's going to be moving faster because it's lighter.

556
00:33:40.219 --> 00:33:41.181
But at the same time...

557
00:33:42.259 --> 00:33:44.340
It's lighter, so you need more of it.

558
00:33:44.801 --> 00:33:46.422
The density is lower, right?

559
00:33:46.642 --> 00:33:50.264
So you need a massive sort of thing to hold all that hydrogen.

560
00:33:50.544 --> 00:33:54.567
And when you have a two-stage rocket and you're going all the way up, that's a lot of drag.

561
00:33:54.607 --> 00:33:56.788
That's a lot of friction that you have to account for.

562
00:33:57.388 --> 00:34:03.212
So all of that accounts for this lower weight that I can put on hydrogen.

563
00:34:04.683 --> 00:34:06.244
Earth orbit and all the way to the moon.

564
00:34:06.684 --> 00:34:15.729
The idea is because you need more space for the fuel, which is this hydrogen oxygen mix as opposed to kerosene and liquid O2.

565
00:34:16.189 --> 00:34:22.532
And because you need more of that fuel and you're not dropping stages like it's not a three stage system.

566
00:34:22.552 --> 00:34:22.652
Sure.

567
00:34:22.672 --> 00:34:25.073
You're not able to let go of that dead weight earlier.

568
00:34:25.094 --> 00:34:25.194
Yeah.

569
00:34:25.394 --> 00:34:25.634
Yeah.

570
00:34:26.334 --> 00:34:35.179
You fundamentally have more space taken up by fuel, which means less space for payload, even though you're accomplishing the same objective.

571
00:34:35.340 --> 00:34:38.221
And it's because of these architectural structural choices.

572
00:34:38.321 --> 00:34:38.862
Exactly.

573
00:34:39.022 --> 00:34:39.462
Yeah.

574
00:34:39.562 --> 00:34:43.725
And then one could ask, like, OK, why are we doing this architectural choice?

575
00:34:43.965 --> 00:34:44.185
Yes.

576
00:34:44.345 --> 00:34:47.427
Well, there's something called the Senate launch system.

577
00:34:48.287 --> 00:34:48.387
Okay.

578
00:34:48.407 --> 00:34:48.648
Okay.

579
00:34:49.028 --> 00:34:56.633
And that's basically the idea that, like, you got to get through the U.S. Senate, which is two senators per state.

580
00:34:57.454 --> 00:34:59.315
So all the states got to be happy.

581
00:34:59.875 --> 00:35:02.117
So you've got the NASA centers all over the country.

582
00:35:02.137 --> 00:35:07.461
There's three in California, the Ames Research Center, the Armstrong Flight Research Center in Edwards Air Force Base.

583
00:35:07.541 --> 00:35:07.761
Yes.

584
00:35:08.141 --> 00:35:09.562
Up in the high desert.

585
00:35:09.642 --> 00:35:11.663
And then you've got JPL in Pasadena.

586
00:35:11.804 --> 00:35:11.984
Yes.

587
00:35:12.004 --> 00:35:14.325
You've also got in Louisiana the...

588
00:35:15.526 --> 00:35:17.887
Assembly that actually makes that orange part.

589
00:35:18.507 --> 00:35:20.228
You've got the Kennedy Space Flight Center.

590
00:35:20.248 --> 00:35:23.269
You've got Goddard and all these other things in the eastern seaboard.

591
00:35:23.809 --> 00:35:35.753
On top of that, all 50 states are actually partners with Artemis in the sense that there is a component on Artemis that comes from each of the 50 states.

592
00:35:35.773 --> 00:35:36.033
Mm-hmm.

593
00:35:36.553 --> 00:35:38.574
the nuts and bolts come from Delaware.

594
00:35:39.195 --> 00:35:44.117
And there's like tubing that comes from some random company in California and all this other stuff.

595
00:35:44.137 --> 00:35:47.579
But they, they've done a really good job to sort of like make this like an American.

596
00:35:47.680 --> 00:35:47.940
Yes.

597
00:35:48.100 --> 00:35:53.323
Like, cause you know, Artemis is, as we said with the Artemis Accords, it's like this international collaboration, but yeah,

598
00:35:54.305 --> 00:35:55.086
We're in America.

599
00:35:55.526 --> 00:35:56.687
You got to make everyone happy.

600
00:35:56.747 --> 00:36:06.413
And the Senate launch system has made sure that all 50 states have a stake in this mission, which I thought that was kind of funny.

601
00:36:06.773 --> 00:36:11.436
So this is actually an interesting point, which is that there is this social political dynamic.

602
00:36:11.776 --> 00:36:19.040
This is not a purely whatever is technologically most efficient and X, Y, and Z is how we're going to do it.

603
00:36:19.601 --> 00:36:21.102
It is necessarily...

604
00:36:21.882 --> 00:36:35.510
having to negotiate so that everyone gets their chunk of flesh, their piece of meat to be able to say, oh, like we're supporting NASA because the factory that's in the harbor does X and Y.

605
00:36:35.690 --> 00:36:38.372
So again, it's not operating in a vacuum.

606
00:36:38.612 --> 00:36:40.413
It has to get appropriations from somewhere.

607
00:36:40.874 --> 00:36:46.057
And those appropriations, meaning money and support, come with strings attached in some cases.

608
00:36:47.138 --> 00:36:54.562
And this is kind of part of like, again, when we're no longer having the specter of Cold War justifying the spin.

609
00:36:54.642 --> 00:36:54.882
Yeah.

610
00:36:55.282 --> 00:36:57.623
You kind of need to get everybody to sit at the table.

611
00:36:57.764 --> 00:36:58.224
Exactly.

612
00:36:58.264 --> 00:36:58.644
Yeah.

613
00:36:59.004 --> 00:37:03.507
And what I what I loved about that abbreviation is like the Senate launch system, SLS.

614
00:37:03.547 --> 00:37:03.707
Yes.

615
00:37:03.907 --> 00:37:09.390
Is the same as the space launch system, which is the acronym that is used by NASA to.

616
00:37:09.430 --> 00:37:09.750
Yes.

617
00:37:10.350 --> 00:37:32.620
get us to orbit right okay so now that's going to get us to orbit yes okay now once we get us to orbit so that's this first part which is the solid rocket boosters yes and this first part all the way up to here yes that's going to get us all the way into earth orbit yes okay now from there we want to get to high earth orbit now in apollo only after two to three hours you just straight up go to the moon okay

618
00:37:32.940 --> 00:37:33.200
Okay?

619
00:37:33.420 --> 00:37:35.662
You do like one or two rounds on Earth.

620
00:37:35.702 --> 00:37:37.242
Make sure everything is checked out.

621
00:37:37.322 --> 00:37:38.843
And then you're like, all right, we're going to the moon.

622
00:37:39.223 --> 00:37:39.604
We go.

623
00:37:40.184 --> 00:37:40.584
It's a race.

624
00:37:40.604 --> 00:37:41.185
You're not hanging out.

625
00:37:41.345 --> 00:37:41.785
Yeah, yeah.

626
00:37:42.345 --> 00:37:44.586
These guys are all about risk mitigation.

627
00:37:44.706 --> 00:37:44.967
Okay?

628
00:37:45.207 --> 00:37:52.531
So in Artemis, what ends up happening is we actually go into a high Earth orbit before we go to the moon.

629
00:37:53.351 --> 00:37:54.432
The idea here is...

630
00:37:55.594 --> 00:38:01.919
We want to go into high Earth orbit because we want to fire the rocket boosters up here and make sure that nothing is wrong.

631
00:38:02.079 --> 00:38:05.062
If something is wrong, you get back in about...

632
00:38:05.948 --> 00:38:08.570
I think it's 45 hours and you can get back.

633
00:38:08.610 --> 00:38:08.810
Yeah.

634
00:38:08.870 --> 00:38:09.110
Yeah.

635
00:38:09.190 --> 00:38:09.370
Okay.

636
00:38:09.390 --> 00:38:13.352
You don't have to wait days all the way to go to the moon and back like in Apollo 13.

637
00:38:13.713 --> 00:38:13.893
Right?

638
00:38:14.653 --> 00:38:17.515
So what they do is something called the apogee rays burn.

639
00:38:17.675 --> 00:38:20.757
Apogee is the idea that you have this elliptical orbit.

640
00:38:20.817 --> 00:38:22.598
Kepler's laws comes back here.

641
00:38:22.698 --> 00:38:23.779
Yes.

642
00:38:24.099 --> 00:38:27.721
Whenever you have gravity, the orbits are actually going to be ellipses.

643
00:38:28.021 --> 00:38:30.583
So what you do is you have a first orbit that is circular.

644
00:38:30.603 --> 00:38:30.983
Mm-hmm.

645
00:38:31.263 --> 00:38:34.304
And then you do a burn, which adds velocity.

646
00:38:34.644 --> 00:38:38.506
And then you go into an elliptical orbit where you go far away from the Earth and then you come back.

647
00:38:38.906 --> 00:38:52.892
And that elliptical orbit is anywhere from 68,000 miles, which is about like a fifth of the way to the moon, all the way back to 235 miles over a 42-hour period.

648
00:38:52.912 --> 00:38:55.453
So you're doing this really highly elliptical orbit.

649
00:38:56.053 --> 00:38:58.234
To sort of just gauge the systems.

650
00:38:58.274 --> 00:38:58.454
Yes.

651
00:38:58.794 --> 00:39:00.015
Make sure everything is working.

652
00:39:00.355 --> 00:39:05.477
Now, in the Apollo missions, they were gauging these systems with intermediate Apollo missions.

653
00:39:05.497 --> 00:39:06.417
You had Apollo 8.

654
00:39:06.477 --> 00:39:08.938
You had Apollo 6, 7, and so on and so forth.

655
00:39:09.138 --> 00:39:13.700
You had all the Gemini missions that were going in to make sure that everything was working.

656
00:39:14.020 --> 00:39:16.982
Here, you're doing it all at once because we want to save money.

657
00:39:17.502 --> 00:39:22.264
I was actually going to say the reason why we don't just get all these incremental missions because we're not...

658
00:39:22.844 --> 00:39:29.111
The military industrial complex and that geopolitical sort of nexus is not funding this.

659
00:39:29.312 --> 00:39:29.592
Yes.

660
00:39:30.053 --> 00:39:33.356
And so we have to scrape every dollar we can for everywhere.

661
00:39:33.376 --> 00:39:40.705
I mean, literally, there's funding getting canceled actively right now for NASA that literally supports this economy.

662
00:39:40.825 --> 00:39:41.125
Yeah.

663
00:39:41.505 --> 00:39:46.808
And we don't have 2.3% of GDP going towards this, going towards this, right.

664
00:39:46.848 --> 00:39:47.908
This is very different.

665
00:39:47.948 --> 00:39:48.168
Yeah.

666
00:39:48.228 --> 00:39:48.489
Yeah.

667
00:39:48.509 --> 00:40:00.294
So the analogy is imagine you're a sports, a sports team, you're an owner of a sports team and you have to compete with like a program, the program from the past when you had $10 billion and now you have 500 million.

668
00:40:00.474 --> 00:40:01.355
Yeah.

669
00:40:01.375 --> 00:40:04.276
You can't recruit the best players for $500 million.

670
00:40:04.296 --> 00:40:04.676
And so anyway.

671
00:40:06.877 --> 00:40:10.560
Yeah, so there's a risk mitigation strategy here, right?

672
00:40:10.580 --> 00:40:10.880
Yes.

673
00:40:10.901 --> 00:40:16.545
But during that high Earth orbit, what they're going to do is they're going to check out everything that's happening at this very top.

674
00:40:16.645 --> 00:40:16.806
Yes.

675
00:40:17.086 --> 00:40:17.326
Okay?

676
00:40:17.666 --> 00:40:20.709
One of the things that they're going to do is manually fly Orion.

677
00:40:20.809 --> 00:40:22.971
Orion is this upper part right here.

678
00:40:23.211 --> 00:40:23.411
Yes.

679
00:40:23.431 --> 00:40:23.711
Right?

680
00:40:23.731 --> 00:40:23.912
Right.

681
00:40:24.492 --> 00:40:31.014
What they're going to do is detach that from the rest of the spaceship, and they're going to just do maneuvering.

682
00:40:31.074 --> 00:40:32.214
They're going to get out.

683
00:40:32.454 --> 00:40:33.614
They're going to turn it around.

684
00:40:33.954 --> 00:40:34.874
They're going to approach.

685
00:40:34.934 --> 00:40:35.795
They're going to go back.

686
00:40:36.095 --> 00:40:40.376
They're going to have this thing autonomously move, and then they're going to have it go back and forth.

687
00:40:40.656 --> 00:40:45.677
What you want to do is really nitty-gritty get into the details of are all of the controls working?

688
00:40:46.325 --> 00:40:46.525
Right?

689
00:40:46.605 --> 00:40:52.111
Like, when I move this joystick this way, is it responding the way that I want it to?

690
00:40:52.671 --> 00:40:56.154
All of these things Apollo was already doing with Gemini and things like that.

691
00:40:56.174 --> 00:40:58.337
They had separate missions.

692
00:40:58.537 --> 00:40:59.758
This we're all doing in one.

693
00:41:00.178 --> 00:41:01.740
That's a really important distinction.

694
00:41:01.800 --> 00:41:06.304
And also, the way you describe that, too, it's kind of crazy.

695
00:41:06.364 --> 00:41:07.505
Oh, yeah, we're just going to fly up.

696
00:41:07.625 --> 00:41:08.726
We're just going to detach.

697
00:41:08.967 --> 00:41:10.148
And then it's just going to, you know...

698
00:41:11.508 --> 00:41:33.869
move around and then eventually it'll cut like that's pretty it's pretty insane that's pretty insane and it's even more insane that we did it like 50 years ago yeah i mean with a lot more money but still also true very very cool um and then finally if everything works out right the crew manually flies orion relative to the rest of the spacecraft and

699
00:41:34.995 --> 00:41:39.158
Then we're going to do the translunar injection, which is this hybrid free return.

700
00:41:39.198 --> 00:41:46.343
What we're going to do is when the spacecraft reaches perigee, which is when it's closer to the Earth.

701
00:41:46.743 --> 00:41:52.587
When it's closest to the Earth, that's when it has the least potential energy in terms of gravity because it's close to the Earth.

702
00:41:52.927 --> 00:41:54.909
But that means it's moving faster.

703
00:41:54.949 --> 00:41:55.129
Yes.

704
00:41:55.169 --> 00:41:55.329
Right?

705
00:41:55.349 --> 00:41:56.770
That's actually Kepler's second law.

706
00:41:56.910 --> 00:41:57.050
Yes.

707
00:41:57.230 --> 00:41:59.372
That, like, the closer you get, the faster you move.

708
00:41:59.392 --> 00:41:59.552
Mm-hmm.

709
00:42:00.703 --> 00:42:05.485
When it's moving faster, that's when we want to do the burn to go to lunar orbit.

710
00:42:05.546 --> 00:42:11.809
This is something called the Obereth effect, which basically says that if you want to change your trajectory...

711
00:42:12.755 --> 00:42:18.136
The fastest way to change your trajectory is to do it when your velocity is highest.

712
00:42:18.456 --> 00:42:21.117
Because then your delta V actually has the most effect.

713
00:42:21.617 --> 00:42:21.897
Okay?

714
00:42:22.297 --> 00:42:23.118
So that's what they're doing.

715
00:42:23.338 --> 00:42:27.339
They're going to do this hybrid free return, which means they're going to go all the way to the moon and back.

716
00:42:27.719 --> 00:42:30.459
And they're going to do it in such a way that they're farthest away from the moon.

717
00:42:30.799 --> 00:42:32.500
They can see the moon and the earth.

718
00:42:32.520 --> 00:42:33.000
Right?

719
00:42:33.444 --> 00:42:35.145
They're going to swing around.

720
00:42:35.725 --> 00:42:37.526
The moon is going to slingshot them back.

721
00:42:37.686 --> 00:42:41.927
And then if everything goes well, then the return, the total mission is going to be about 10 days.

722
00:42:42.448 --> 00:42:44.268
There's going to be a direct Earth entry.

723
00:42:44.989 --> 00:42:50.571
And the Orion is capable of doing a skip entry where it sort of slows down with the Earth's atmosphere once.

724
00:42:50.931 --> 00:43:01.655
And then it comes back and it lands somewhere in the Pacific Ocean right off the coast of California where we have our Navy, our beautiful American Navy with the warships and the helicopters.

725
00:43:03.336 --> 00:43:05.098
You know, pick them up.

726
00:43:05.519 --> 00:43:06.900
That's where the military comes back.

727
00:43:07.040 --> 00:43:07.301
Yes.

728
00:43:07.701 --> 00:43:07.961
Yes.

729
00:43:08.682 --> 00:43:09.824
After we've done all the hard stuff.

730
00:43:10.184 --> 00:43:10.424
Yeah.

731
00:43:10.444 --> 00:43:13.147
Then they come and do a little quick Uber ride back home.

732
00:43:13.348 --> 00:43:13.828
Exactly.

733
00:43:14.289 --> 00:43:16.992
This is not a shot like we, the men and women who support.

734
00:43:17.012 --> 00:43:17.532
It's great.

735
00:43:17.552 --> 00:43:18.233
It's fantastic.

736
00:43:18.353 --> 00:43:20.476
It's just, it's an appropriations problem.

737
00:43:20.696 --> 00:43:20.896
Yeah.

738
00:43:20.996 --> 00:43:21.777
It's not a...

739
00:43:22.778 --> 00:43:48.955
armed services service members problem yeah and i mean we're going to get into the armed services when we talk about the crew because the crew a lot of them are from the armed services so let's talk about the crew we've got four astronauts they've been selected for the nasa artemis 2 mission commander reed wiseman pilot victor glover mission specialist christina coke and mission specialist jeremy hansen and can i just say

740
00:43:50.040 --> 00:43:51.542
Quite a good looking.

741
00:43:51.642 --> 00:43:52.604
Good looking crew.

742
00:43:53.224 --> 00:43:54.366
This is a good looking crew.

743
00:43:54.386 --> 00:43:55.768
This is a good looking crew, dude.

744
00:43:56.088 --> 00:43:58.552
And I am sure there was someone on NASA that.

745
00:43:59.453 --> 00:44:00.474
Look, I don't know.

746
00:44:00.494 --> 00:44:02.097
I don't know.

747
00:44:02.217 --> 00:44:05.521
But like the photogenicness of the crew.

748
00:44:06.600 --> 00:44:10.345
I'm sure there was someone who was like, this is going to be good on Twitter.

749
00:44:10.405 --> 00:44:11.366
This is going to be good on Instagram.

750
00:44:11.386 --> 00:44:16.933
I have seen actually that almost all the posts about Artemis, it's going very viral.

751
00:44:16.993 --> 00:44:17.674
Yeah.

752
00:44:17.814 --> 00:44:18.855
With the crew backgrounds.

753
00:44:18.895 --> 00:44:19.456
Yeah.

754
00:44:20.016 --> 00:44:21.458
It looks like a Hollywood movie.

755
00:44:21.799 --> 00:44:23.461
Dude, they look good.

756
00:44:23.661 --> 00:44:23.901
Yeah.

757
00:44:24.282 --> 00:44:24.442
Okay?

758
00:44:24.462 --> 00:44:24.622
Yeah.

759
00:44:24.762 --> 00:44:25.003
Yeah.

760
00:44:25.503 --> 00:44:25.703
Yeah.

761
00:44:25.923 --> 00:44:26.964
It's not weird, guys.

762
00:44:27.024 --> 00:44:28.504
I'm just saying they look good.

763
00:44:28.824 --> 00:44:30.265
You're just using your observational skills.

764
00:44:30.285 --> 00:44:30.385
Yeah.

765
00:44:30.425 --> 00:44:31.025
I'm just – yeah.

766
00:44:31.165 --> 00:44:31.705
Yeah.

767
00:44:31.725 --> 00:44:33.666
Symmetric faces, that kind of thing.

768
00:44:33.786 --> 00:44:34.646
It's very scientific.

769
00:44:34.866 --> 00:44:36.407
Okay.

770
00:44:36.667 --> 00:44:36.907
Anyways.

771
00:44:37.167 --> 00:44:37.427
Okay.

772
00:44:37.487 --> 00:44:39.548
So let's start with Commander Reed Wiseman.

773
00:44:40.108 --> 00:44:42.489
He spent 165 days in space.

774
00:44:42.529 --> 00:44:46.651
He's a graduate of the Renesler Polytechnic Institute in Troy.

775
00:44:47.451 --> 00:44:49.092
RPI, we did a paper from them.

776
00:44:49.252 --> 00:44:50.612
That was the string theory paper.

777
00:44:50.672 --> 00:44:50.852
Yes.

778
00:44:51.172 --> 00:44:52.333
From two episodes ago.

779
00:44:52.373 --> 00:44:52.453
Yes.

780
00:44:52.993 --> 00:44:58.356
He did a bachelor's in computer engineering, and then he did a master's in engineering at Johns Hopkins.

781
00:44:58.516 --> 00:45:00.196
It's engineering, but we'll give him.

782
00:45:00.657 --> 00:45:06.600
He's a captain in the U.S. Navy, and he is going to be the commander of this mission.

783
00:45:06.900 --> 00:45:15.264
And that photo you saw, he's proudly wearing the U.S. Navy sort of insignia on the ISS when he was there.

784
00:45:15.424 --> 00:45:15.644
Yes.

785
00:45:16.064 --> 00:45:16.324
All right.

786
00:45:16.644 --> 00:45:18.825
Next, we've got pilot Victor Glover.

787
00:45:18.886 --> 00:45:21.567
He spent 167 days in space.

788
00:45:21.947 --> 00:45:24.568
He's a high school quarterback from Ontario, California.

789
00:45:24.648 --> 00:45:26.029
Southern California boy.

790
00:45:26.650 --> 00:45:27.910
This guy's from SoCal.

791
00:45:28.250 --> 00:45:31.012
He went to Cal Poly Slow in San Luis Obispo.

792
00:45:31.052 --> 00:45:31.252
Yes.

793
00:45:31.552 --> 00:45:35.675
BS in engineering, master's from Air University, which I didn't know was a thing.

794
00:45:36.035 --> 00:45:43.279
So apparently the Air Force just has a university that is, it doesn't have a campus, but you can take courses as part of the Air Force.

795
00:45:43.319 --> 00:45:48.363
And he took it on campus at Edwards Air Force Base in Southern California, and he got his master's.

796
00:45:49.618 --> 00:45:54.123
And that was a photo of him working on some hydroponics plant experiment in the ISS.

797
00:45:54.583 --> 00:45:57.046
Next, we've got Christina Koch.

798
00:45:57.086 --> 00:45:59.768
She has spent 328 days in space.

799
00:45:59.868 --> 00:46:00.449
Oh, gee.

800
00:46:01.009 --> 00:46:03.251
She's going to be the first woman on the moon.

801
00:46:04.433 --> 00:46:05.694
She's actually the longest.

802
00:46:05.754 --> 00:46:06.615
Not on.

803
00:46:07.035 --> 00:46:07.456
Just to be...

804
00:46:08.056 --> 00:46:11.779
Yeah, and not as of yet, but she's also going to be on Artemis 3 to get on the moon.

805
00:46:11.819 --> 00:46:13.740
But she'll be the first woman to...

806
00:46:13.940 --> 00:46:14.541
Knock on wood.

807
00:46:14.641 --> 00:46:15.141
Knock on wood.

808
00:46:15.161 --> 00:46:18.603
Yeah, I don't want to do commentator's curse or anything.

809
00:46:18.884 --> 00:46:23.107
But she's going to at least be the first woman, if everything goes well, to round the moon.

810
00:46:23.187 --> 00:46:23.387
Yes.

811
00:46:24.067 --> 00:46:26.309
And be the furthest woman in outer space.

812
00:46:26.990 --> 00:46:32.555
She's actually quite cool because she had an electrical engineering and a physics bachelor's.

813
00:46:32.735 --> 00:46:33.476
We love to see it.

814
00:46:33.536 --> 00:46:37.259
We love to see a physics bachelor's from NC State in Raleigh.

815
00:46:37.319 --> 00:46:37.679
Yeah.

816
00:46:37.759 --> 00:46:38.000
Which...

817
00:46:38.140 --> 00:46:39.361
It's pronounced Raleigh.

818
00:46:39.641 --> 00:46:40.422
Oh, whatever.

819
00:46:41.122 --> 00:46:44.284
And then an MS in electrical engineering from the same place.

820
00:46:44.444 --> 00:46:45.404
Yes.

821
00:46:45.825 --> 00:46:49.307
She's got the longest single continuous stay in space for a woman.

822
00:46:49.907 --> 00:47:00.032
And part of her paradigm was, you know, her extended mission is being used to study the physical, biological, and mental effects of long-term space travel on women.

823
00:47:00.072 --> 00:47:03.954
Because we have a ton of data of long-term space travel on men.

824
00:47:04.034 --> 00:47:04.235
Yes.

825
00:47:04.415 --> 00:47:04.595
But...

826
00:47:05.788 --> 00:47:11.431
Moving forward, we need all the data from everywhere, right?

827
00:47:11.491 --> 00:47:14.792
So her 328 days is going to be crucial for that understanding.

828
00:47:15.292 --> 00:47:19.974
She's worked in Antarctica, Goddard Space Flight Center, and the Applied Physics Lab at Johns Hopkins.

829
00:47:20.234 --> 00:47:21.535
The Applied Physics Lab is like...

830
00:47:22.597 --> 00:47:25.518
Kind of like the JPL of Maryland.

831
00:47:25.698 --> 00:47:28.178
You know how JPL is associated with Caltech.

832
00:47:28.238 --> 00:47:30.359
Applied Physics Lab is associated with Johns Hopkins.

833
00:47:30.379 --> 00:47:30.519
Got it.

834
00:47:30.779 --> 00:47:34.560
It's kind of this independent research entity that does crazy good stuff.

835
00:47:35.000 --> 00:47:35.260
Okay.

836
00:47:35.320 --> 00:47:35.940
Okay.

837
00:47:36.140 --> 00:47:39.421
The photo actually shows her with the Cold Atom Lab.

838
00:47:39.861 --> 00:47:40.982
This is really cool.

839
00:47:41.282 --> 00:47:45.623
So what they did on the ISS was create a quantum experiment.

840
00:47:45.643 --> 00:47:45.943
Okay.

841
00:47:46.043 --> 00:47:59.507
They're cooling rubidium atoms down to near absolute zero, billionth of a degree near absolute zero, and they're creating a Bose-Einstein condensate, which is this fifth form of matter, on the International Space Station.

842
00:47:59.847 --> 00:48:03.068
So they can do, like, quantum physics experiments on Earth.

843
00:48:03.248 --> 00:48:25.783
on the international space station this is like science fiction stuff yeah dude i mean the iss is crazy because you have like a you have like a university physics lab but in outer space in zero g it's one of the craziest things that we've made as human beings and she was she was doing that in that photo that was that was incredible and then finally we've got jeremy hansen the squid yeah and you know he's canadian so we don't have to talk about it

844
00:48:26.724 --> 00:48:27.385
No, I'm just kidding.

845
00:48:27.645 --> 00:48:30.028
I mean, Toronto lost to the Dodgers.

846
00:48:30.048 --> 00:48:31.790
We will never forget.

847
00:48:31.910 --> 00:48:32.531
I'm sorry.

848
00:48:32.631 --> 00:48:33.532
It's just how it goes.

849
00:48:34.032 --> 00:48:34.873
It's okay, everyone.

850
00:48:34.933 --> 00:48:39.138
I was born in Montreal, so I am also Canadian by at least birth.

851
00:48:39.398 --> 00:48:40.840
We support our community.

852
00:48:42.175 --> 00:48:44.658
Maybe current slash former allies.

853
00:48:44.698 --> 00:48:44.998
Yeah.

854
00:48:45.098 --> 00:48:45.979
I don't know anymore, right?

855
00:48:45.999 --> 00:48:46.840
You don't know how it's going.

856
00:48:46.860 --> 00:48:47.180
Anyways.

857
00:48:47.201 --> 00:48:47.481
Okay.

858
00:48:47.501 --> 00:48:52.146
So jokes aside, one thing that struck me about him is he's had zero days in space.

859
00:48:52.286 --> 00:48:52.466
Yes.

860
00:48:52.486 --> 00:48:54.268
This is going to be his first time in space.

861
00:48:54.288 --> 00:48:54.488
Yes.

862
00:48:54.809 --> 00:48:56.090
He's going around the moon.

863
00:48:56.110 --> 00:48:57.071
It's pretty crazy.

864
00:48:57.091 --> 00:48:59.374
What a lucky, lucky individual.

865
00:48:59.414 --> 00:48:59.534
Yes.

866
00:48:59.554 --> 00:48:59.634
Yes.

867
00:49:00.274 --> 00:49:04.676
He got his bachelor's from the Royal Military College in space science.

868
00:49:04.856 --> 00:49:06.277
And then a master's in physics.

869
00:49:06.457 --> 00:49:07.117
Another physics.

870
00:49:07.438 --> 00:49:10.399
Yeah, and I checked out his master's thesis, by the way.

871
00:49:11.620 --> 00:49:13.340
I scrolled through his master's thesis.

872
00:49:13.360 --> 00:49:16.322
The first thing was the abstract was written in French, and I was already...

873
00:49:17.022 --> 00:49:18.443
ticked off by the whole thing.

874
00:49:18.463 --> 00:49:19.664
I was like, what the hell?

875
00:49:19.964 --> 00:49:23.626
Yeah, but then actually he wrote in English because of course science is done in English.

876
00:49:24.446 --> 00:49:29.809
The master's thesis was wide field of wide field view of satellite tracking.

877
00:49:30.990 --> 00:49:31.470
Very cool.

878
00:49:31.790 --> 00:49:39.274
Because what he ended up doing was basically creating a really cheap CCD camera that could track satellites.

879
00:49:39.294 --> 00:49:39.775
Very easy.

880
00:49:41.741 --> 00:50:06.336
accurately and then from that figure out what satellites were doing what it was a really cool master's thesis to be honest he's got the rank of colonel in the royal canadian air force and now he's going to be going to the moon and i have to say um the crew has a great sense of humor they were on the cobert report for an interview last year and it's one of the funniest interviews just a little tidbit that i want to share from that interview um

881
00:50:07.908 --> 00:50:16.074
Jeremy Hansen was seated at the end because he's the tallest of them, but Colbert made a joke about how you're Canadian, so you're seated at the end.

882
00:50:16.975 --> 00:50:33.768
But the funniest thing was, you know, he acknowledged that the U.S. could do this on its own, but it's an incredible testament to what NASA is doing as an international entity to bring together someone from the Canadian Air Force to go into space.

883
00:50:34.829 --> 00:50:36.310
The funniest thing that he said was...

884
00:50:37.326 --> 00:50:42.829
there was a joke about, Colbert asked, so who's gonna turn the oxygen tanks?

885
00:50:43.549 --> 00:50:49.292
That's a reference to Apollo 13 because the explosion on Apollo 13 happened because the...

886
00:50:51.087 --> 00:50:57.009
the pilot on Apollo 13 was asked to turn on the oxygen tank stirring thing.

887
00:50:57.749 --> 00:51:02.971
And that oxygen tank stirring is what created the explosion that became Apollo 13.

888
00:51:03.331 --> 00:51:03.531
Right.

889
00:51:03.591 --> 00:51:09.072
So, so it's sort of this like taboo in NASA, like cause somebody has got to stir the oxygen tanks.

890
00:51:09.112 --> 00:51:09.953
So who's it going to be?

891
00:51:10.053 --> 00:51:13.054
And Jeremy, very, very funny.

892
00:51:13.074 --> 00:51:17.435
He was like, actually, I've been asking to throw one switch and they've told me that I can do that.

893
00:51:18.015 --> 00:51:19.317
It was so funny, dude.

894
00:51:19.357 --> 00:51:19.677
Well done.

895
00:51:19.717 --> 00:51:22.060
Because everybody else was just like laughing their ass off.

896
00:51:22.080 --> 00:51:22.760
Yeah, well done.

897
00:51:22.780 --> 00:51:23.401
Well done.

898
00:51:23.621 --> 00:51:24.622
He understood the assignment.

899
00:51:24.642 --> 00:51:25.023
Yeah, dude.

900
00:51:25.123 --> 00:51:26.144
I thought it was just so funny.

901
00:51:26.184 --> 00:51:28.927
And the chemistry in the crew is just so great.

902
00:51:28.967 --> 00:51:29.127
Yes.

903
00:51:29.187 --> 00:51:32.651
Like, I'm really looking forward to this being a success.

904
00:51:33.752 --> 00:51:34.013
You know?

905
00:51:34.033 --> 00:51:34.813
That's so good.

906
00:51:34.833 --> 00:51:35.915
Oh, it's so good.

907
00:51:36.255 --> 00:51:36.515
Yeah.

908
00:51:37.797 --> 00:51:39.799
So, I think we've covered...

909
00:51:41.233 --> 00:51:42.214
Structure of the mission.

910
00:51:42.374 --> 00:51:42.614
Yeah.

911
00:51:43.374 --> 00:51:44.115
What it's aiming to do.

912
00:51:44.235 --> 00:51:57.964
Artemis 2 is a part of a long-term project that will ultimately end with having a semi-permanent slash the goal of having a semi-permanent slash permanent presence on the moon.

913
00:51:58.164 --> 00:51:58.364
Yeah.

914
00:51:58.444 --> 00:52:02.807
And so for folks who are saying, oh, they're going to the moon but not landing.

915
00:52:02.927 --> 00:52:03.267
Why?

916
00:52:03.287 --> 00:52:07.330
I come back to my sports analogy, which was like, imagine...

917
00:52:08.513 --> 00:52:13.077
You're the GM or the head coach or the manager of an English Premier League soccer team.

918
00:52:14.118 --> 00:52:14.338
Right.

919
00:52:14.798 --> 00:52:15.159
In the 90s.

920
00:52:15.239 --> 00:52:18.121
Let's say I'm Alex Ferguson at Manchester United.

921
00:52:19.117 --> 00:52:20.118
I have Beckham.

922
00:52:20.398 --> 00:52:22.619
I have Paul Scholes.

923
00:52:23.180 --> 00:52:25.201
I have Gary Neville, Roy Keane.

924
00:52:25.221 --> 00:52:26.302
I have all these great players.

925
00:52:26.642 --> 00:52:27.803
We win five champions.

926
00:52:27.823 --> 00:52:28.944
We have five Premier Leagues.

927
00:52:29.504 --> 00:52:30.525
Most winningest team ever.

928
00:52:31.025 --> 00:52:31.585
It's amazing.

929
00:52:32.146 --> 00:52:33.547
What made that team work?

930
00:52:34.087 --> 00:52:34.868
We had the money.

931
00:52:35.748 --> 00:52:36.729
We had the talent.

932
00:52:37.609 --> 00:52:40.391
And then all of the je ne sais quoi that makes teams work.

933
00:52:40.471 --> 00:52:40.731
Yeah.

934
00:52:41.772 --> 00:52:43.834
Now fast forward 25 years.

935
00:52:45.254 --> 00:52:47.416
And same Manchester United.

936
00:52:47.436 --> 00:52:47.536
Yeah.

937
00:52:48.838 --> 00:52:50.179
We don't have any of those players.

938
00:52:50.799 --> 00:52:52.360
The players we now have, meh.

939
00:52:53.501 --> 00:52:54.201
Not comparable.

940
00:52:54.642 --> 00:52:56.003
The money we now have, meh.

941
00:52:56.403 --> 00:52:59.525
Not as effective because the Qataris have come in with money.

942
00:52:59.945 --> 00:53:01.526
The Americans have come in with money.

943
00:53:02.627 --> 00:53:05.849
And so now all the best players, all the talent, all the info.

944
00:53:05.869 --> 00:53:09.791
You've let Carrington, where we do training, it's run down now.

945
00:53:10.292 --> 00:53:15.475
None of the people that were there in the 90s that knew how we built a championship winning team.

946
00:53:15.675 --> 00:53:15.835
Yeah.

947
00:53:16.115 --> 00:53:16.936
None of them are here anymore.

948
00:53:17.356 --> 00:53:19.659
It's a bunch of new people who've never done it before.

949
00:53:20.920 --> 00:53:25.504
That analogy is exactly why you can't just rinse, repeat, going to the moon.

950
00:53:25.544 --> 00:53:27.045
Yeah, you can't just go to the moon.

951
00:53:27.706 --> 00:53:33.251
All of the different component parts that make a Super Bowl winning team, a premiership winning team.

952
00:53:34.232 --> 00:53:37.335
It's hard to go back to back to do just winning sports.

953
00:53:37.375 --> 00:53:37.635
Yeah.

954
00:53:38.196 --> 00:53:38.376
Right?

955
00:53:38.436 --> 00:53:40.478
And back to back years with the same everything.

956
00:53:40.498 --> 00:53:40.638
Right?

957
00:53:42.044 --> 00:53:51.147
Imagine trying to do the most impossible task in humanity with almost none of the muscle memory from the first time.

958
00:53:51.667 --> 00:54:00.790
I just bring that analogy to try to help people reframe how they think about this because it's just not – it's not the same anything.

959
00:54:01.010 --> 00:54:01.250
Yeah.

960
00:54:01.970 --> 00:54:07.233
And so, of course, we're going to have to, again, we don't have 2% of the GDP to go forward.

961
00:54:07.253 --> 00:54:10.614
Like, money is really a big driver of us being able to do stuff.

962
00:54:10.794 --> 00:54:12.175
And we just, there's just not the money there.

963
00:54:12.675 --> 00:54:25.442
But we're going to, with that entry point, talk about a couple of the myths that arise as it relates to any conversation about the moon.

964
00:54:26.742 --> 00:54:26.962
Yeah.

965
00:54:27.122 --> 00:54:27.963
And so the first...

966
00:54:29.661 --> 00:54:32.862
Myth, which is one that always comes up immediately.

967
00:54:33.503 --> 00:54:37.444
I was shocked in our last video about Artemis, which was in the rundown, and it was barely anything.

968
00:54:38.244 --> 00:54:39.845
And everyone was just going crazy.

969
00:54:40.105 --> 00:54:40.345
Yeah.

970
00:54:41.166 --> 00:54:42.026
And I didn't expect it.

971
00:54:42.466 --> 00:54:49.869
Myth number one is about Van Allen belt radiation or Van Allen radiation belts being impassable.

972
00:54:50.009 --> 00:54:50.289
Yes.

973
00:54:51.029 --> 00:54:52.030
This is myth number one.

974
00:54:52.451 --> 00:54:52.711
Yes.

975
00:54:53.011 --> 00:54:55.593
So what are the Van Allen radiation belts?

976
00:54:55.673 --> 00:55:09.162
Well, the Earth has a magnetic field, and so it traps radiation from the cosmic background, from the sun, from all over the place, into these sort of donuts around the Earth.

977
00:55:09.583 --> 00:55:15.887
There's an inner belt, which is mostly high-energy protons, and then there's an outer belt that's mostly high-energy electrons.

978
00:55:16.527 --> 00:55:19.910
And the myth is that you can't go through without killing yourself.

979
00:55:20.490 --> 00:55:25.095
That is totally false because the transit time, you can actually calculate the transit time.

980
00:55:25.115 --> 00:55:27.417
We're going at about 11 kilometers per second.

981
00:55:27.778 --> 00:55:33.664
Let's say even slower, 6 kilometers per second, which the escape velocity of the Earth is 11 kilometers per second.

982
00:55:34.424 --> 00:55:38.669
If you were to calculate how big that belt is, you spend about 8 minutes on the Earth.

983
00:55:40.049 --> 00:55:43.573
through the core, and about an hour through the whole thing.

984
00:55:44.294 --> 00:55:46.757
Now, the Apollo missions had shielding.

985
00:55:46.777 --> 00:55:53.164
They had aluminum blocks that would block alpha radiation, which is helium nuclei going through and beta particles.

986
00:55:53.784 --> 00:55:55.967
And it's effective against most particles, but...

987
00:55:56.127 --> 00:56:01.691
You know, you still have to be concerned about bremsstrahlung radiation, which is when electrons come through and they slow down.

988
00:56:01.731 --> 00:56:06.034
And if the electrons slow down, then because of electromagnetism, they're going to release light.

989
00:56:06.375 --> 00:56:08.436
And that light is usually in the form of x-rays.

990
00:56:08.776 --> 00:56:09.277
Right.

991
00:56:09.397 --> 00:56:11.018
So there's going to be some x-ray radiation.

992
00:56:11.318 --> 00:56:18.564
Well, the result is that the Apollo 11 dose was about 0.18, 0.18 rads, which is comparable to a CT scan.

993
00:56:18.584 --> 00:56:18.724
Mm-hmm.

994
00:56:19.144 --> 00:56:19.324
Right.

995
00:56:19.664 --> 00:56:22.626
It's far below the lethal dose of 400 rads.

996
00:56:22.786 --> 00:56:28.368
So if you have had a CT scan, you've had as much radiation exposure as going through the NLM belt.

997
00:56:28.548 --> 00:56:28.769
Yes.

998
00:56:29.209 --> 00:56:41.955
And with Artemis, actually, what I found was really funny was the Artemis 1, which is the mission that preceded Artemis 2, they had mannequins called Helga and Zohar that had active dosimeters, which are...

999
00:56:42.962 --> 00:56:47.446
you know, radiation meters that track the amount of radiation that they're getting.

1000
00:56:47.607 --> 00:56:50.649
If you've watched Chernobyl, it's the thing that goes click.

1001
00:56:50.750 --> 00:56:53.072
Yeah, yeah, 3.6 runking, you know?

1002
00:56:53.112 --> 00:56:54.573
Yeah.

1003
00:56:54.753 --> 00:57:04.463
So the preliminary data from those dosimeters show that while the environment is harsh, the shielding and the short transit time is enough to keep that dose well within safety limits.

1004
00:57:04.763 --> 00:57:07.685
And it looks like the lethal dose is 400 rads.

1005
00:57:07.885 --> 00:57:08.125
Yes.

1006
00:57:08.465 --> 00:57:11.027
And so we're talking about 0.18 at the Apollo times.

1007
00:57:11.147 --> 00:57:11.367
Yeah.

1008
00:57:11.627 --> 00:57:13.449
And so we're not even... Yeah.

1009
00:57:13.729 --> 00:57:22.234
And, I mean, you do it so that the trajectory of the mission actually, like, avoids the big part of that radiation belt, right?

1010
00:57:22.474 --> 00:57:24.396
You know where the donut is.

1011
00:57:24.616 --> 00:57:24.796
Yes.

1012
00:57:24.856 --> 00:57:26.357
And you can figure out how to avoid it.

1013
00:57:26.657 --> 00:57:28.338
And this is why launch windows are a thing.

1014
00:57:28.458 --> 00:57:29.479
Yes, exactly.

1015
00:57:29.819 --> 00:57:29.999
Yeah.

1016
00:57:30.499 --> 00:57:32.321
So the second one...

1017
00:57:32.501 --> 00:57:32.681
Yes.

1018
00:57:32.701 --> 00:57:32.841
Yes.

1019
00:57:34.038 --> 00:57:56.438
flags are waved in a vacuum right this was the flag that was waving and it's like oh how is it waving if it's in a vacuum and then there's no air actually i would actually like to suggest that the flag waving is actually a characteristic of the vacuum and here's why so in a vacuum there's no atmosphere correct so with a flag that's waving

1020
00:57:57.643 --> 00:58:06.515
If the air is very still, like it is in the studio, then the friction from the air is going to stop the waving so that the flag is going to be still.

1021
00:58:07.476 --> 00:58:08.477
If there's no air...

1022
00:58:09.490 --> 00:58:15.071
and I give the flag a certain amount of momentum, it's kind of like a pendulum swinging back and forth.

1023
00:58:15.531 --> 00:58:16.571
It's going to keep waving.

1024
00:58:16.911 --> 00:58:22.952
The only friction is coming from the internal friction of the fiber in the flag itself, right?

1025
00:58:23.592 --> 00:58:32.574
And so the fact that it kept sort of going in the simple harmonic motion is a feature of the fact that there's nothing there to slow it down.

1026
00:58:33.114 --> 00:58:38.935
The point being, if you go, like imagine like Heroes of Iwo Jima putting the flag down on the ground...

1027
00:58:39.235 --> 00:58:41.638
And then you try to adjust it for the camera and whatever.

1028
00:58:42.038 --> 00:58:43.580
You're going to introduce some momentum.

1029
00:58:43.980 --> 00:58:46.563
There's no way you can place the flag without introducing momentum.

1030
00:58:46.603 --> 00:58:47.383
Yes, exactly.

1031
00:58:47.784 --> 00:58:53.049
And the fact that it kept sort of swinging a little bit is because there's nothing else to slow it down.

1032
00:58:53.390 --> 00:58:56.753
And the damping effect of the fiber itself is actually too small.

1033
00:58:57.914 --> 00:59:00.657
Over a few oscillations, it does slow down, which you see.

1034
00:59:01.077 --> 00:59:02.619
But, you know, it's not enough.

1035
00:59:04.228 --> 00:59:05.229
These are just like layups.

1036
00:59:05.449 --> 00:59:06.150
Yeah, yeah.

1037
00:59:06.550 --> 00:59:06.930
Next one.

1038
00:59:07.110 --> 00:59:11.073
Next one is this non-parallel shadows imply multiple light sources.

1039
00:59:11.173 --> 00:59:15.797
So it happened in a studio because the shadows are not pointing in the same direction.

1040
00:59:16.077 --> 00:59:17.838
This one's like the most dumb to me.

1041
00:59:18.178 --> 00:59:25.544
Because like anyone who's taking a photograph has seen that the lights point towards a common center.

1042
00:59:25.684 --> 00:59:25.904
Yes.

1043
00:59:26.204 --> 00:59:33.050
Like just go outside when the sun is out and then look at, take a photo with your phone of two light poles.

1044
00:59:33.070 --> 00:59:33.650
Yeah.

1045
00:59:34.115 --> 00:59:36.379
And they'll be pointing to some source.

1046
00:59:36.399 --> 00:59:43.612
They're not going to be parallel just because of the nature of photography and the idea that you've got a single source that is capturing this.

1047
00:59:44.567 --> 01:00:08.552
guys that one's so dumb guys okay the next one is the no stars in the sky there's no stars in the sky in any of the photographs well the reason for that is the optical dynamic range right if you want if you want to take photographs the surface of the moon is 30 times brighter than the stars so anyone who's done photography knows that if you want to if you want to f-stop of like f11 and uh

1048
01:00:11.010 --> 01:00:36.729
exposure time of 1 250th of a second you're not going to get anything i mean right i deal with this trying to set up our cameras and i'm trying to make us look beautiful but i'm like slightly darker than yeah yeah it's this whole thing right and actually i wanted to show that photograph because we actually installed in apollo 16 we installed a far ultraviolet camera yes and on the right we see that far ultraviolet camera and there you can actually see stars there's a photo

1049
01:00:41.587 --> 01:00:43.409
Jokes aside, that's an incredible photograph.

1050
01:00:43.429 --> 01:00:43.550
It is.

1051
01:00:43.910 --> 01:00:45.853
It's the Earth with the stars in the background.

1052
01:00:45.873 --> 01:00:46.413
Yes, yes.

1053
01:00:46.433 --> 01:00:46.994
Look at that.

1054
01:00:47.154 --> 01:00:50.158
And it has a sort of crescent, you know, glow.

1055
01:00:51.319 --> 01:00:52.000
It's amazing.

1056
01:00:52.060 --> 01:00:55.104
It puts our place among the stars in the cosmos.

1057
01:00:55.224 --> 01:00:56.206
I think that's really cool.

1058
01:00:56.466 --> 01:00:56.666
Yes.

1059
01:00:56.686 --> 01:00:57.207
Debunked.

1060
01:00:57.427 --> 01:00:57.607
Yes.

1061
01:00:58.088 --> 01:00:58.308
Yes.

1062
01:00:58.468 --> 01:00:58.709
Okay.

1063
01:00:58.969 --> 01:01:00.510
And now let's look for direct evidence.

1064
01:01:00.691 --> 01:01:00.951
Okay.

1065
01:01:01.291 --> 01:01:08.198
So proving the landings, there was this thing called a lunar rate laser ranging, um, Apollo 11, 14 and 15.

1066
01:01:08.238 --> 01:01:11.260
They left retro reflector arrays on the moon.

1067
01:01:11.641 --> 01:01:15.645
And so you can point lasers to the specific points on the moon.

1068
01:01:15.665 --> 01:01:15.725
Um,

1069
01:01:16.225 --> 01:01:18.786
where Apollo 11, 14, and 15 were there.

1070
01:01:19.146 --> 01:01:20.947
I mean, we know the coordinates of where the moon are.

1071
01:01:21.247 --> 01:01:24.828
And nowadays, the laser can be localized to just that part of the moon.

1072
01:01:25.089 --> 01:01:29.010
And if you point it at other parts of the moon, you're not going to get the laser to bounce back.

1073
01:01:29.370 --> 01:01:34.432
But if you point it where Apollo 11, 14, and 15 were, you will get the laser to point back.

1074
01:01:34.912 --> 01:01:35.813
And you can actually...

1075
01:01:36.753 --> 01:01:37.953
Measure the round trip time.

1076
01:01:37.994 --> 01:01:39.894
It's going to be about 2.5 seconds.

1077
01:01:40.014 --> 01:01:49.618
And nowadays our clocks are so good that you can measure the distance moving away because the moon is moving away at about 3.8 centimeters per year.

1078
01:01:50.118 --> 01:01:59.121
And so every year, if you were to do this experiment, you would actually see the time delay increasing by a tiny, tiny margin because the moon is moving away.

1079
01:01:59.661 --> 01:02:04.605
This is very dear to me because there was this thing called the Brons-Dickey theory out of Princeton.

1080
01:02:04.945 --> 01:02:06.426
There was a new theory for gravity.

1081
01:02:06.446 --> 01:02:11.409
What they said was perhaps the gravitational constant, which is G, is not actually constant.

1082
01:02:11.469 --> 01:02:16.173
But it's actually a scalar field that varies across the cosmos in space and time.

1083
01:02:16.673 --> 01:02:19.615
And one of the ways to do this was to measure gravity.

1084
01:02:20.452 --> 01:02:23.434
The distance to the moon very, very precisely.

1085
01:02:23.774 --> 01:02:31.199
And that's actually one of the reasons why the Apollo astronauts left these retro-reflective mirrors.

1086
01:02:31.259 --> 01:02:34.982
Because the Princeton team pitched this idea to NASA.

1087
01:02:35.362 --> 01:02:41.667
And we're like, hey, this would be a cool way to measure G. It's like a fundamental test of general relativity.

1088
01:02:41.687 --> 01:02:43.128
Yes, because we're now on a body...

1089
01:02:43.808 --> 01:03:09.403
uh rock rocky body off planet and that's like really far away so it's maybe perhaps outside of the sort of friction of the earth if there's like some scalar field that like the earth is dragging or some kind of thing like that you know yes so so i thought that was really cool yes the second thing is the lunar reconnaissance orbiter which is like a satellite that goes around the moon and takes photos of the moon can actually see tracks of apollo 17's

1090
01:03:12.018 --> 01:03:13.239
Car rides, right?

1091
01:03:13.259 --> 01:03:15.000
You literally see the car rides.

1092
01:03:15.320 --> 01:03:21.084
And then you can go and see Apollo 17 and look at their footage and be like, oh, they went here.

1093
01:03:21.104 --> 01:03:23.286
And then you can check the tracks and be like, oh, they went here.

1094
01:03:23.606 --> 01:03:24.487
They spent some time there.

1095
01:03:24.527 --> 01:03:27.029
And then they went here and they spent some time there on their moon buggy.

1096
01:03:27.409 --> 01:03:29.410
And they've been taking photos since 2009.

1097
01:03:29.971 --> 01:03:33.073
The resolution is about half a meter per pixel.

1098
01:03:33.413 --> 01:03:36.095
So you can literally see the tracks, right?

1099
01:03:36.755 --> 01:03:38.637
The verification also comes with other...

1100
01:03:39.964 --> 01:04:01.947
nation states the japanese with selene and kaguya and the indian isro they made chandrayaan one they've taken photographs of the apollo 11 and apollo 2 lunar modules that are left on the moon i just don't get it right so you can literally like what so what you're telling me that the the japanese and the indians and the european space agency everyone is colluding

1101
01:04:03.390 --> 01:04:08.152
And then also that the Chinese or Russians aren't calling this out and making a big whole stink about it.

1102
01:04:08.172 --> 01:04:13.793
Yeah, and actually that takes me to my final point, which is the Russians, why didn't they say anything?

1103
01:04:14.654 --> 01:04:17.575
In 1969, when we went to the moon, they could have easily been like, no, they didn't.

1104
01:04:18.055 --> 01:04:19.235
You know what they did instead?

1105
01:04:19.255 --> 01:04:24.517
They denied that there was ever a race in the first place.

1106
01:04:25.248 --> 01:04:25.548
Okay?

1107
01:04:25.989 --> 01:04:31.713
This is archival photographs of their Saturn V, their version of the Saturn V. It was actually bigger.

1108
01:04:32.233 --> 01:04:32.734
It failed.

1109
01:04:32.874 --> 01:04:33.474
Of course it did.

1110
01:04:33.534 --> 01:04:34.335
But... Look at it.

1111
01:04:34.655 --> 01:04:35.055
Look at it.

1112
01:04:35.215 --> 01:04:35.876
I mean, it failed.

1113
01:04:36.236 --> 01:04:44.562
Jokes aside, the fact that they even got this far is insane, given the amount of technology that they were behind on in terms of computing and things like that.

1114
01:04:44.882 --> 01:04:45.143
But...

1115
01:04:46.150 --> 01:04:46.951
Back to the jokes.

1116
01:04:47.091 --> 01:04:49.073
Of course it failed because it's the Russians.

1117
01:04:49.473 --> 01:04:51.315
But at the end of the day, you know what they did?

1118
01:04:51.715 --> 01:04:54.618
They were like, we weren't even trying to go to the moon.

1119
01:04:55.158 --> 01:04:56.259
I don't know what you guys are talking about.

1120
01:04:56.279 --> 01:04:58.742
I mean, yeah, you guys went to, I mean, good for you, I guess.

1121
01:04:58.842 --> 01:05:01.164
But like, we were never even trying.

1122
01:05:01.644 --> 01:05:02.565
That was their retort.

1123
01:05:02.605 --> 01:05:04.867
Their retort was not, they never went to the moon.

1124
01:05:05.248 --> 01:05:07.730
Their retort was, we didn't even know we were in a race.

1125
01:05:08.968 --> 01:05:17.879
Whether you look at it geopolitically, whether you look at it from what you can reproduce with current instruments, like, again, you can, you can, it's visible.

1126
01:05:17.899 --> 01:05:18.981
You have a laser pointer.

1127
01:05:19.001 --> 01:05:23.446
If you have a high-powered telescope, multiple other countries have verified this to be true.

1128
01:05:24.657 --> 01:05:25.358
Guys.

1129
01:05:25.378 --> 01:05:30.280
The flag, the vacuum, everything just doesn't...

1130
01:05:30.420 --> 01:05:34.121
I was really surprised at how many people were so adamant.

1131
01:05:34.141 --> 01:05:36.222
It's not even a minority of the American public.

1132
01:05:36.242 --> 01:05:36.622
No, no, no.

1133
01:05:36.642 --> 01:05:38.363
That's the thing that really bothers me.

1134
01:05:38.423 --> 01:05:44.206
It's a really significant number of people, and I was unfamiliar with their game.

1135
01:05:44.226 --> 01:05:45.706
Yeah.

1136
01:05:45.906 --> 01:05:47.727
It's not a good game, guys.

1137
01:05:48.268 --> 01:05:48.808
Everything is...

1138
01:05:49.775 --> 01:06:09.990
Anyway, what we do in space is so cool and so incredible and is standing on the shoulders of an unbelievable amount of math, physics, biology, chemistry, work.

1139
01:06:10.731 --> 01:06:14.854
That has been going on now for a very long time.

1140
01:06:15.674 --> 01:06:22.379
And it's important to me that like all of those people who have sacrificed and done this work to like make this happen.

1141
01:06:22.919 --> 01:06:32.406
And like ultimately as a species, we will, I believe, and I have to believe from my own spirit that we will be traveling the stars one day.

1142
01:06:32.506 --> 01:06:32.726
Yeah.

1143
01:06:32.806 --> 01:06:33.907
Maybe not in our lifetime.

1144
01:06:33.927 --> 01:06:34.027
Yeah.

1145
01:06:34.327 --> 01:06:39.051
Maybe the aliens can help us a little bit with getting a little bit, get that interstellar thing going.

1146
01:06:39.752 --> 01:06:49.640
But regardless, like this is like such an important aspect of I think our identity as a species of being explorers and having curiosity and wisdom.

1147
01:06:50.061 --> 01:06:53.304
And it's like the perfect distillation of all of those aspects.

1148
01:06:54.024 --> 01:07:00.009
And to just minimize the work and the efforts and the blood, sweat, and tears that so many people put in.

1149
01:07:00.850 --> 01:07:04.453
you know, to all efforts related to space.

1150
01:07:05.494 --> 01:07:08.876
Um, it just, it's just a huge disservice to a huge number of people.

1151
01:07:09.196 --> 01:07:13.580
Also for all the Elon bros again, Elon knows we went to the moon.

1152
01:07:13.640 --> 01:07:13.840
Yeah.

1153
01:07:14.260 --> 01:07:16.082
So you like to believe everything he says.

1154
01:07:16.142 --> 01:07:17.403
Why don't you believe him about this?

1155
01:07:18.205 --> 01:07:20.346
Like, you know, he's your man.

1156
01:07:20.406 --> 01:07:28.170
No, he's part of the, you know, it's part of the thingy.

1157
01:07:28.430 --> 01:07:38.215
Huge shout out to all the countries that are in the Artemis Accords, NASA, Canadian Space Agency, ESA, to the crew that is going to get ready to go out there.

1158
01:07:38.675 --> 01:07:39.616
The launch window works.

1159
01:07:39.676 --> 01:07:40.436
You know, hopefully we do.

1160
01:07:40.636 --> 01:07:43.418
They're doing a lot on this mission all at the same time.

1161
01:07:44.338 --> 01:08:07.287
there's a lot of moving parts and so you know best of luck and godspeed to the crew this is just going back to the moon is awesome it's just awesome and I can't wait to see where this goes Apple TV plug because For All Mankind season 5 is coming out in March and if you haven't watched it before the idea is

1162
01:08:08.147 --> 01:08:22.082
It's the revisionist history of what would happen if the U.S. got to basically the moon for like – basically if we were second and they got to the moon first and we were second and how that would have changed the entire architecture of history.

1163
01:08:22.303 --> 01:08:22.803
It's quite good.

1164
01:08:24.105 --> 01:08:28.650
And so this is – we're not living in that timeline, I guess, thankfully.

1165
01:08:28.970 --> 01:08:29.571
Thankfully, yeah.

1166
01:08:30.163 --> 01:08:33.626
Well, before we end, we should do a... What should they comment?

1167
01:08:34.007 --> 01:08:34.387
Ah, yes.

1168
01:08:34.727 --> 01:08:36.169
And so I propose...

1169
01:08:36.769 --> 01:08:41.073
I didn't know what LBF meant when the lift off the rust, 8.8 million LBF.

1170
01:08:41.133 --> 01:08:41.334
Yes.

1171
01:08:41.414 --> 01:08:42.435
It's pound something.

1172
01:08:42.635 --> 01:08:42.855
Yes.

1173
01:08:43.395 --> 01:08:47.639
Why don't you guys tell us or come up with your favorite acronym, LBF.

1174
01:08:47.760 --> 01:08:49.481
LBF.

1175
01:08:49.601 --> 01:08:50.122
That's a good one.

1176
01:08:50.462 --> 01:08:50.562
Yeah.

1177
01:08:50.582 --> 01:08:51.083
That's a good one.

1178
01:08:51.443 --> 01:08:52.824
So if you've made it this far...

1179
01:08:53.645 --> 01:08:56.766
Type in what you think LBF means when it comes to thrust.

1180
01:08:56.846 --> 01:08:59.227
It's got to be, don't make some random crap up.

1181
01:09:00.387 --> 01:09:01.748
Make it like a thrust thing.

1182
01:09:04.509 --> 01:09:07.790
As you know, my name is Lester Nare.

1183
01:09:07.890 --> 01:09:14.632
Here is your host, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD and moon landing debunker,

1184
01:09:15.790 --> 01:09:16.751
Krishna Chowdhury.

1185
01:09:17.471 --> 01:09:18.853
Again, this was our off weeks.

1186
01:09:18.893 --> 01:09:20.694
We just did the one story deep dive.

1187
01:09:20.734 --> 01:09:22.956
We'll be back next week.

1188
01:09:23.296 --> 01:09:34.626
We may have some teasers of a secret project we're working on, but if not then soon, as always, we really appreciate you all and our commitment to staying curious.

1189
01:09:35.607 --> 01:09:38.029
This is from First Principles.
