WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.151 --> 00:00:03.995
One of the biggest questions for humanity has always been, are we alone?

2
00:00:04.155 --> 00:00:12.422
And we may have just made a discovery that changes the paradigm about how we think about the answer to that question.

3
00:00:12.642 --> 00:00:19.088
So Sauron would be proud of this because Stanford has figured out one vaccine to rule them all.

4
00:00:19.488 --> 00:00:23.853
I don't really trust humans with nuclear weapons, but I definitely don't trust AI.

5
00:00:24.174 --> 00:00:30.100
And this new paper is corroborating that very nice viewpoint that I had.

6
00:00:30.561 --> 00:00:31.362
Hello, Internet.

7
00:00:31.382 --> 00:00:40.071
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident Ph.D., Krishna Chowdhury.

8
00:00:40.692 --> 00:00:43.373
We are back for another week of science news.

9
00:00:43.473 --> 00:00:47.474
This week we have two phenomenal stories that we're going to touch on.

10
00:00:47.914 --> 00:00:53.395
First, we're going to hit an astrobiology story, followed up by an immunology story.

11
00:00:54.015 --> 00:01:02.277
And this week there's a little bit of a special surprise as our episode on the Dave Chang show, which will be on Netflix, is...

12
00:01:03.028 --> 00:01:05.109
We'll be dropping this week, so be sure to check that out.

13
00:01:05.129 --> 00:01:06.430
We got some phenomenal food.

14
00:01:06.770 --> 00:01:08.190
Yes, amazing food.

15
00:01:08.651 --> 00:01:09.331
From the goat.

16
00:01:09.451 --> 00:01:10.211
It was a great time.

17
00:01:10.472 --> 00:01:12.212
Shout out to Dave Chang and his team.

18
00:01:13.433 --> 00:01:14.874
Super big fan of science.

19
00:01:15.454 --> 00:01:18.155
A great example of how science impacts all of us.

20
00:01:18.535 --> 00:01:25.999
And curiosity, there is not a monopoly on curiosity about how the world around us works.

21
00:01:26.539 --> 00:01:28.961
If you're joining us for the first time, welcome.

22
00:01:29.241 --> 00:01:31.403
If you're returning, welcome back.

23
00:01:31.964 --> 00:01:35.567
As you know, we are a victim of the billionaire algorithm.

24
00:01:35.927 --> 00:01:40.431
So a like, share, follow, subscribe, all of that is super helpful.

25
00:01:40.911 --> 00:01:42.513
Our donation portal is up.

26
00:01:42.633 --> 00:01:45.455
Every episode is free and available on every platform.

27
00:01:45.835 --> 00:01:54.222
And the support we have from the community is really huge for us to be able to continue to get the best breaking science news broken down today.

28
00:01:55.103 --> 00:01:57.264
here to you every week.

29
00:01:58.465 --> 00:02:05.710
We are going to learn about the science from the ground up, because this is From First Principles.

30
00:02:21.948 --> 00:02:36.491
Our first story is on astrobiology, one of those fields that sits right at the edge of what science can currently say and addresses one of the biggest questions in humanity, which is, are we alone?

31
00:02:37.192 --> 00:02:47.198
And a new study just took one of the toughest organisms on Earth, simulated the violence of an asteroid slamming into Mars, and watched what happened.

32
00:02:47.238 --> 00:02:52.601
And the survival rates might genuinely surprise you as they surprised me.

33
00:02:52.681 --> 00:02:58.704
This is in PNAS Nexus out of John Hopkins University on March 3rd.

34
00:02:59.045 --> 00:03:00.505
Yeah, this is very recent.

35
00:03:00.525 --> 00:03:01.446
Fresh off the presses.

36
00:03:01.646 --> 00:03:02.586
Yeah, very recent.

37
00:03:02.666 --> 00:03:07.228
And as you said, right, a core question that we ask as humans is, are we alone?

38
00:03:07.928 --> 00:03:14.470
Well, a follow up to that would be, well, could life travel between worlds, right?

39
00:03:14.890 --> 00:03:18.991
Let's say that life started on Mars and then an asteroid impact hit it.

40
00:03:20.037 --> 00:03:26.599
The debris from that asteroid traveled the entire solar system between Mars and Earth and ended up on Earth.

41
00:03:26.759 --> 00:03:28.440
And that's what seeded life on Earth.

42
00:03:28.820 --> 00:03:31.941
This is the idea of lithopanspermia.

43
00:03:32.021 --> 00:03:37.963
Litho meaning rock, panspermia meaning this sort of like life everywhere type thing, right?

44
00:03:38.103 --> 00:03:38.263
And...

45
00:03:40.371 --> 00:03:45.973
For the longest time, it's kind of been just like cuckoo, woo-woo type science, been discredited.

46
00:03:46.134 --> 00:03:52.716
And this paper is really challenging a lot of the assumptions that we make about how unlikely this process is.

47
00:03:53.277 --> 00:04:01.820
The idea that life can generate in one place and then travel through the vacuum of space to another place and then continue to flourish.

48
00:04:01.900 --> 00:04:02.981
Yeah, yeah, dude.

49
00:04:03.561 --> 00:04:04.221
It's pretty cool.

50
00:04:04.261 --> 00:04:06.802
They've done some really cool experiments.

51
00:04:07.123 --> 00:04:07.743
This paper...

52
00:04:09.269 --> 00:04:19.251
uses something called D. radiodurans, which is a bacterium that colloquially is known as the Conan the bacterium because it's, like, indestructible.

53
00:04:19.311 --> 00:04:20.672
You know, like Conan the barbarian?

54
00:04:20.692 --> 00:04:21.632
I was going to say.

55
00:04:21.712 --> 00:04:23.812
It's, like, indestructible.

56
00:04:23.832 --> 00:04:30.194
And what they've done is do experiments about what this bacterium could survive through, and it turns out it's a lot.

57
00:04:30.654 --> 00:04:33.715
Something like 14,000 times the atmospheric pressure

58
00:04:34.575 --> 00:04:58.790
on earth okay um substantial survival even at really really high pressures even beyond that and the conclusion here is basically that the initial pressure shock that you get from an asteroid banging into a planet that has life and ejecting that planet out that initial pressure shock that we used to think would completely kill any living organism is actually not that bad

59
00:04:59.929 --> 00:05:02.773
Stuff will survive and go into outer space.

60
00:05:03.333 --> 00:05:03.574
Okay?

61
00:05:04.054 --> 00:05:05.035
Now, why does it matter?

62
00:05:05.356 --> 00:05:13.646
Well, very recently, we've had the NASA Perseverance rover announce a discovery of potential life on Mars.

63
00:05:13.846 --> 00:05:14.067
Yes.

64
00:05:14.087 --> 00:05:16.890
We covered this in last year's podcast.

65
00:05:16.910 --> 00:05:17.010
Okay.

66
00:05:17.651 --> 00:05:22.252
Now, finding that life requires determining the origin of that life, right?

67
00:05:22.612 --> 00:05:30.334
And if this is true, well, then we can start asking questions like, well, is that life coming from Earth or is it originated in Mars originally?

68
00:05:31.474 --> 00:05:34.195
This paper sort of shapes that interpretation.

69
00:05:34.795 --> 00:05:47.318
It's also got some impacts when it comes to like planetary protection, because now if we know that life actually survives impacts, goes into outer space and comes to Earth, like we got to be a bit careful about returning samples.

70
00:05:48.199 --> 00:05:48.699
onto Earth.

71
00:05:48.939 --> 00:05:55.404
Because if we bring something back and it's got a little thingy in it, we don't want that.

72
00:05:55.444 --> 00:06:00.588
Yeah, and there's plenty of science fiction movies about that, about how it can go really, really wrong.

73
00:06:00.948 --> 00:06:07.833
Hollywood has its ways of aggrandizing things, but it turns out it might actually be a real phenomenon.

74
00:06:07.853 --> 00:06:08.614
Very interesting.

75
00:06:09.014 --> 00:06:10.936
So, as always, let's start with the history.

76
00:06:11.376 --> 00:06:13.398
This is actually an ancient idea.

77
00:06:13.438 --> 00:06:15.859
The Greek philosopher Anna Zagor

78
00:06:16.899 --> 00:06:18.883
Anaxagoras, okay?

79
00:06:19.063 --> 00:06:22.350
Kind of like Pythagoras, but Anaxagoras.

80
00:06:22.450 --> 00:06:23.833
Maybe that's how you say it.

81
00:06:23.853 --> 00:06:26.017
Anaxagoras, 5th century BCE.

82
00:06:26.057 --> 00:06:26.318
Okay.

83
00:06:27.297 --> 00:06:34.024
He actually is one of the first guys to correctly interpret what the solar eclipse was, like the moon is going in front of the sun.

84
00:06:34.364 --> 00:06:35.405
He's the first guy to do that.

85
00:06:35.446 --> 00:06:38.489
5th century BCE, so 2,500 years ago.

86
00:06:39.169 --> 00:06:45.356
He proposed the idea of spermata, which is seeds of life that are scattered throughout the universe.

87
00:06:45.396 --> 00:06:49.100
Now, the Greeks had a very rudimentary understanding of what...

88
00:06:49.580 --> 00:06:57.726
the universe was, but I still think it's quite cool that somebody that far ago was, you know, coming up with these kinds of ideas.

89
00:06:58.146 --> 00:07:04.911
The historical basis for the idea of panspermia really comes from William Thompson in the 1870s.

90
00:07:04.971 --> 00:07:06.112
This is Lord Kelvin.

91
00:07:06.132 --> 00:07:07.193
Lord Kelvin.

92
00:07:07.253 --> 00:07:07.613
Yes.

93
00:07:07.993 --> 00:07:12.196
He proposed the scattering of life seeds via, like, catastrophic collisions.

94
00:07:12.237 --> 00:07:14.999
This idea that we now have of, like, stuff going in.

95
00:07:15.699 --> 00:07:20.660
collisions, uproot material into space, and then that material comes into Earth.

96
00:07:21.060 --> 00:07:23.921
And then in 1903, there was this guy Svante Arrhenius.

97
00:07:24.321 --> 00:07:30.562
I think any chemist in the audience would know about the Arrhenius equation and all the great things that Svante Arrhenius did.

98
00:07:30.823 --> 00:07:45.266
But one of the things that he formalized was this idea of radiopanspermia, which is the idea that microbial spores, which are small enough, at that time they had figured out how small in mass these microbial spores were.

99
00:07:46.347 --> 00:07:50.633
they could be propelled by the pressure of light to move across space.

100
00:07:51.253 --> 00:07:53.436
And so that was his idea, radio panspermia.

101
00:07:53.777 --> 00:08:02.108
Now, in the 1900s, this idea was completely invalidated because in deep space we now know—we didn't know about radiation—

102
00:08:02.328 --> 00:08:04.089
back when Arrhenius came up with his thing.

103
00:08:04.329 --> 00:08:09.251
But now we know about cosmic rays and the solar wind and all the radiation and the dangers in space.

104
00:08:09.271 --> 00:08:13.732
So everyone was like, okay, unshielded deep space, you're going to have ultraviolet radiation.

105
00:08:14.052 --> 00:08:15.453
You're going to have this vacuum.

106
00:08:15.573 --> 00:08:17.553
It's rapidly going to sterilize DNA.

107
00:08:17.894 --> 00:08:18.634
So there's no hope.

108
00:08:19.678 --> 00:08:19.878
Right?

109
00:08:19.978 --> 00:08:20.199
Yes.

110
00:08:21.019 --> 00:08:25.663
Then we started discovering stuff that could actually survive that.

111
00:08:25.763 --> 00:08:31.468
In 1956, Arthur W. Anderson discovers D. radiodurans.

112
00:08:31.868 --> 00:08:35.271
This is our Conan the bacterium.

113
00:08:35.431 --> 00:08:35.772
I see.

114
00:08:35.892 --> 00:08:36.172
Okay?

115
00:08:36.412 --> 00:08:38.834
This is the bacterium that will survive anything.

116
00:08:39.034 --> 00:08:39.154
Okay.

117
00:08:39.174 --> 00:08:39.275
Okay.

118
00:08:39.973 --> 00:08:47.738
He was actually at the Oregon Agricultural College, and he was studying canned meat that he was trying to sterilize with gamma radiation.

119
00:08:48.119 --> 00:08:53.562
Gamma radiation is extremely short-wavelength radiation, extremely high-energy photons.

120
00:08:53.843 --> 00:08:55.564
And so that should just kill anything.

121
00:08:55.604 --> 00:08:58.065
It should break every chemical bond known.

122
00:08:58.566 --> 00:09:03.589
And the meat that he was studying spoiled anyway.

123
00:09:04.230 --> 00:09:05.571
And it didn't make any sense, right?

124
00:09:05.631 --> 00:09:06.972
It's like you put it into a freezer—

125
00:09:07.852 --> 00:09:12.116
Or like you put it into Chernobyl and the meat comes out still spoiled.

126
00:09:12.456 --> 00:09:13.678
So there's something that grew in it.

127
00:09:13.998 --> 00:09:19.903
And when he isolated that, he came up with this bacterium called D. radiodurans.

128
00:09:20.024 --> 00:09:23.287
In the 1970s, there was also the discovery of hydrothermal vents.

129
00:09:23.867 --> 00:09:30.970
And so now you have life thriving in total darkness, 400 degrees Celsius, like way above boiling.

130
00:09:31.451 --> 00:09:34.092
It's still water because the pressure is so high.

131
00:09:34.352 --> 00:09:38.094
But then again, the pressure is so high and life is still thriving.

132
00:09:38.234 --> 00:09:38.474
Yes.

133
00:09:38.914 --> 00:09:39.934
So it's very weird, right?

134
00:09:40.194 --> 00:09:46.797
And over the following decades, we've had an incredible catalog of extreme environments where life thrives.

135
00:09:47.138 --> 00:09:49.479
We have things called acetophiles, which are...

136
00:09:50.259 --> 00:09:52.600
Life that live in sulfuric acid.

137
00:09:52.640 --> 00:09:53.481
That's crazy.

138
00:09:53.701 --> 00:09:58.743
They literally live in sulfuric acid at a pH near zero, which is worse than bleach.

139
00:09:59.103 --> 00:10:00.364
But they're just like living there.

140
00:10:00.824 --> 00:10:04.526
Hyperthermophiles that live up to 122 degrees Celsius.

141
00:10:04.866 --> 00:10:08.968
The record holder is something called methanopyrus candelari.

142
00:10:09.588 --> 00:10:10.308
Kendall.

143
00:10:10.328 --> 00:10:12.929
Dude, 122 degrees Celsius is insane.

144
00:10:14.510 --> 00:10:17.291
Again, high pressure, which is why the water isn't boiling.

145
00:10:17.331 --> 00:10:22.773
Water usually boils at 100 degrees Celsius at sea level, but if you do it high pressure, the water's not going to boil.

146
00:10:22.793 --> 00:10:24.514
That's why a pressure cooker works.

147
00:10:24.654 --> 00:10:25.154
That makes sense.

148
00:10:26.735 --> 00:10:28.457
A lot of really, really crazy things.

149
00:10:28.497 --> 00:10:33.563
Halo files, they flourish in salt concentrations that are five times that of seawater.

150
00:10:33.603 --> 00:10:34.864
You can see this in the Dead Sea.

151
00:10:35.305 --> 00:10:39.009
You can also see this in Halo players who eat a lot of Doritos and chips and ruffles.

152
00:10:39.109 --> 00:10:39.469
Yes.

153
00:10:39.569 --> 00:10:41.692
Halo files, as those who might not know.

154
00:10:42.172 --> 00:10:44.433
I used to be a Halo-phile in high school.

155
00:10:44.493 --> 00:10:45.894
Mate, I loved Halo.

156
00:10:45.914 --> 00:10:46.794
Let me tell you something.

157
00:10:46.874 --> 00:10:48.235
Halo 2 and Halo 3.

158
00:10:48.675 --> 00:10:49.115
Oh, yeah.

159
00:10:49.176 --> 00:10:49.716
No competition.

160
00:10:49.756 --> 00:10:50.716
No competition.

161
00:10:51.076 --> 00:10:52.017
It was very serious.

162
00:10:52.457 --> 00:10:53.418
Oh, my gosh.

163
00:10:53.498 --> 00:10:54.358
It was very serious.

164
00:10:54.518 --> 00:10:55.439
It's one of the only games.

165
00:10:55.459 --> 00:10:55.979
Blood Gulch?

166
00:10:56.119 --> 00:10:56.479
Yeah.

167
00:10:56.559 --> 00:10:57.159
Like, what?

168
00:10:57.199 --> 00:10:58.140
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

169
00:10:59.040 --> 00:11:06.925
And I remember it was back in the day when, like, there wasn't really internet to host these collaborative parties.

170
00:11:07.065 --> 00:11:08.626
So you had to go to your friend's house.

171
00:11:09.107 --> 00:11:13.469
And I remember in the Valley, there was a friend's house that I used to go to.

172
00:11:14.070 --> 00:11:16.991
And he had a TV in one room and a TV in another room.

173
00:11:17.031 --> 00:11:20.333
And we used to do, like, co-ops of four versus four.

174
00:11:20.734 --> 00:11:21.894
Land parties.

175
00:11:21.954 --> 00:11:22.435
Land parties?

176
00:11:22.455 --> 00:11:22.655
Yeah.

177
00:11:22.675 --> 00:11:22.815
Yeah.

178
00:11:23.055 --> 00:11:26.919
Before Xbox Connect, before Xbox Live, we'll go back to the story.

179
00:11:26.999 --> 00:11:29.081
But this is our history.

180
00:11:29.141 --> 00:11:32.044
So we will give it the due respect.

181
00:11:32.104 --> 00:11:36.148
Halo raised so many millennials in that era.

182
00:11:36.308 --> 00:11:36.669
Yes.

183
00:11:36.729 --> 00:11:37.550
And we are one of them.

184
00:11:37.930 --> 00:11:38.591
Halo files.

185
00:11:39.432 --> 00:11:40.312
Yeah.

186
00:11:40.413 --> 00:11:41.574
In this case, it means salt.

187
00:11:41.954 --> 00:11:43.756
But for us, it means something totally different.

188
00:11:44.537 --> 00:11:44.757
So...

189
00:11:46.262 --> 00:11:50.169
Effectively, there's a lot of extreme environments that life thrives in.

190
00:11:50.469 --> 00:11:50.710
Right.

191
00:11:50.830 --> 00:11:54.596
So now it's no longer the case that life needs this perfect...

192
00:11:55.648 --> 00:12:22.952
setting the goldilocks yeah the goldilocks stuff right yeah and um one of the big things was in 1996 bill clinton announced possible ancient martian microbial life in a meteorite that they found in antarctica in 1984 i i have to ask because you did such a good job uh with the jfk impression if you could oh yeah so he goes he goes he goes i did not find life

193
00:12:24.295 --> 00:12:25.320
But I think we found it.

194
00:12:26.244 --> 00:12:28.093
But I did not have sexual related knowledge.

195
00:12:30.745 --> 00:12:33.266
Anyways, there was a meteorite in Antarctica.

196
00:12:33.806 --> 00:12:36.186
They found possible ancient life on it.

197
00:12:36.546 --> 00:12:37.706
It was published in Science.

198
00:12:38.267 --> 00:12:40.327
Immediately, everyone was like, no.

199
00:12:40.567 --> 00:12:41.287
Immediately, no.

200
00:12:41.507 --> 00:12:42.327
Immediately, no.

201
00:12:42.827 --> 00:12:44.608
Like, it was largely refuted.

202
00:12:45.068 --> 00:12:51.709
But the rock transfer, the fact that that meteorite came from Mars is actually not disputed.

203
00:12:52.149 --> 00:12:53.010
Meaning that the origin...

204
00:12:56.232 --> 00:12:59.253
On Google Maps, its original starting point is Mars.

205
00:12:59.293 --> 00:12:59.713
Is Mars.

206
00:12:59.753 --> 00:13:01.273
And that's not everyone's fine with.

207
00:13:01.353 --> 00:13:01.573
Okay.

208
00:13:01.613 --> 00:13:05.054
The fact that there's life on that meteorite, that's what everyone's not fine with.

209
00:13:05.074 --> 00:13:05.254
Okay.

210
00:13:05.274 --> 00:13:05.935
Okay.

211
00:13:05.955 --> 00:13:09.355
They saw little structures that kind of looked like bacteria and so on and so forth.

212
00:13:09.655 --> 00:13:11.136
They didn't have enough evidence.

213
00:13:11.416 --> 00:13:15.157
But it really started this question of could life survive the journey?

214
00:13:15.457 --> 00:13:15.637
Right.

215
00:13:15.777 --> 00:13:16.777
From Mars to Earth.

216
00:13:16.817 --> 00:13:18.198
Because now we have evidence that it can happen.

217
00:13:18.218 --> 00:13:18.998
That it can happen.

218
00:13:19.038 --> 00:13:20.638
We definitely found a Martian meter, right?

219
00:13:20.758 --> 00:13:23.118
And, you know, it looks like there's some weird stuff on there.

220
00:13:23.519 --> 00:13:29.080
And so that gets us to this mechanical challenge of planetary escape and then getting to Earth.

221
00:13:29.680 --> 00:13:29.960
Okay?

222
00:13:30.440 --> 00:13:33.621
So there's three bottlenecks when it comes to panspermia.

223
00:13:33.921 --> 00:13:37.461
Three things that prevent it from, like, being realistic or happening.

224
00:13:37.541 --> 00:13:38.362
Yeah, exactly.

225
00:13:38.682 --> 00:13:42.282
There's the first one is the impact ejection event, right?

226
00:13:42.302 --> 00:13:43.703
You get an initial shock.

227
00:13:44.103 --> 00:13:45.543
An asteroid impacts you.

228
00:13:46.766 --> 00:13:48.731
that's going to cause a bunch of pressure and

229
00:13:49.905 --> 00:13:54.169
over microseconds, and it's going to eject stuff into space.

230
00:13:54.769 --> 00:13:56.330
You've got to survive that impact.

231
00:13:57.031 --> 00:13:57.291
Okay.

232
00:13:57.611 --> 00:14:02.395
Once you survive the impact, then you've got to journey through space, millions of years in a vacuum.

233
00:14:02.735 --> 00:14:04.057
There's cosmic radiation.

234
00:14:04.077 --> 00:14:05.238
There's extreme cold.

235
00:14:05.638 --> 00:14:07.479
There's UV, right?

236
00:14:08.020 --> 00:14:13.124
And then at the end of the day, after you've done that journey, you've got to survive reentry.

237
00:14:13.945 --> 00:14:14.225
Okay?

238
00:14:15.065 --> 00:14:16.327
So you have to be big.

239
00:14:17.347 --> 00:14:19.149
And bulky to survive impact.

240
00:14:19.309 --> 00:14:21.691
You have to have endurance to last a long time.

241
00:14:22.912 --> 00:14:27.295
And maybe more also endurance and being big to survive reentry.

242
00:14:27.395 --> 00:14:27.896
Exactly.

243
00:14:28.016 --> 00:14:28.216
Right.

244
00:14:28.657 --> 00:14:34.521
So the two and three, which is surviving space and then surviving reentry, that's actually been...

245
00:14:35.362 --> 00:14:40.906
Explained by something called EXPOSE, which is a facility on the International Space Station.

246
00:14:41.226 --> 00:14:50.212
What they did was they had certain organisms and spores that they put out into the deep space right outside the International Space Station.

247
00:14:50.732 --> 00:14:58.378
And it turns out these things can survive prolonged space exposure if they're shielded by a few millimeters of rock.

248
00:14:59.298 --> 00:15:12.368
So if your life is just a few millimeters underneath the surface, yeah, underneath the surface of whatever asteroid, it's going to survive not only the vacuum of space, but also the reentry into Earth.

249
00:15:12.728 --> 00:15:26.419
That's actually quite, I think if people were to try to guess, if you have a piece of rock floating through space with little thingies, little microbe thingies on it, how deep do you think it needs to be to be able to survive?

250
00:15:27.234 --> 00:15:29.275
I think very few people would have guessed millimeters.

251
00:15:29.295 --> 00:15:30.116
Guess millimeters.

252
00:15:30.196 --> 00:15:31.537
You would think you need a little shielding.

253
00:15:31.577 --> 00:15:33.018
You need maybe a couple inches.

254
00:15:33.098 --> 00:15:33.558
Yeah, yeah.

255
00:15:33.578 --> 00:15:34.319
A couple feet, yards.

256
00:15:34.339 --> 00:15:35.460
Yeah, so you don't need a lot.

257
00:15:35.660 --> 00:15:36.460
That's actually really incredible.

258
00:15:36.480 --> 00:15:41.444
The interior of the rock actually heats minimally when you go into atmospheric entry.

259
00:15:41.604 --> 00:15:42.124
Oh, yeah.

260
00:15:42.164 --> 00:15:42.824
That's the idea.

261
00:15:42.844 --> 00:15:43.185
Okay.

262
00:15:43.225 --> 00:15:43.365
Right?

263
00:15:43.465 --> 00:15:47.788
And they actually found that this particular bacterium, D. radiodurans,

264
00:15:48.909 --> 00:15:50.229
it was already...

265
00:15:50.530 --> 00:15:53.431
It's like survived space-like conditions and it's the best at it.

266
00:15:53.912 --> 00:15:54.452
Okay?

267
00:15:54.872 --> 00:16:04.958
And so this particular paper that's coming out of Johns Hopkins, it is targeting bottleneck one, which is the idea of can it survive the initial ejection event?

268
00:16:05.259 --> 00:16:08.381
Because we already know it can survive outer space and re-entry.

269
00:16:08.721 --> 00:16:10.742
We need to know if it survives the ejection.

270
00:16:10.802 --> 00:16:13.204
So it can survive two and three of the three bottlenecks.

271
00:16:13.524 --> 00:16:13.784
We have...

272
00:16:16.677 --> 00:16:20.720
Data, experimental data, that shows that to be true.

273
00:16:20.780 --> 00:16:21.681
It's not theoretical.

274
00:16:21.741 --> 00:16:21.921
No.

275
00:16:22.441 --> 00:16:23.482
But number one is still...

276
00:16:23.762 --> 00:16:25.284
Number one is still, yeah.

277
00:16:25.364 --> 00:16:32.389
It's like if there's life on Mars and I hit it with an asteroid, by the time it gets out into outer space, most of it should be dead.

278
00:16:32.729 --> 00:16:33.850
That's the prevailing theory.

279
00:16:33.910 --> 00:16:34.170
Okay.

280
00:16:34.290 --> 00:16:36.452
This experiment is putting that...

281
00:16:37.786 --> 00:16:38.647
It's challenging it.

282
00:16:38.867 --> 00:16:39.147
Okay.

283
00:16:39.388 --> 00:16:39.568
Right?

284
00:16:40.508 --> 00:16:41.730
Science is always a process.

285
00:16:41.910 --> 00:16:42.030
Yeah.

286
00:16:42.050 --> 00:16:43.531
Sometimes things get put to rest.

287
00:16:43.551 --> 00:16:45.413
I mean, dude, it's a totally reasonable thing.

288
00:16:45.533 --> 00:16:45.733
Yes.

289
00:16:45.893 --> 00:16:49.096
To be like, hey, a meteor impact is like several atomic bombs.

290
00:16:49.136 --> 00:16:49.336
Yes.

291
00:16:49.756 --> 00:16:50.037
Okay.

292
00:16:50.137 --> 00:16:51.318
What are we talking about?

293
00:16:51.338 --> 00:16:51.678
100%.

294
00:16:51.718 --> 00:16:51.938
Right.

295
00:16:51.958 --> 00:16:52.539
100%.

296
00:16:53.179 --> 00:16:58.023
So, okay, let's talk about this elusive bacterium D radiodurans.

297
00:16:58.564 --> 00:16:58.824
Okay.

298
00:16:59.164 --> 00:17:01.026
Why is it the right test subject for this?

299
00:17:03.518 --> 00:17:04.399
Avenue of research.

300
00:17:04.799 --> 00:17:05.059
Okay?

301
00:17:05.699 --> 00:17:11.503
Well, for lethal dose for a human being, lethal dose being like, you know, 50% of us are going to die.

302
00:17:12.363 --> 00:17:14.044
It's about four grays.

303
00:17:14.444 --> 00:17:17.246
Gray is like the unit of radiation that you get.

304
00:17:17.646 --> 00:17:18.407
Chernobyl, Glenn.

305
00:17:18.807 --> 00:17:23.650
I just wanted you to know that, I don't know if you knew this, that grays are...

306
00:17:24.770 --> 00:17:28.011
One of the species of aliens that people think are visiting Earth.

307
00:17:28.451 --> 00:17:28.891
Oh, really?

308
00:17:29.131 --> 00:17:31.712
The four foot ones that have the big eyes.

309
00:17:32.332 --> 00:17:32.953
The classic.

310
00:17:33.553 --> 00:17:35.893
So only four of them will kill us.

311
00:17:36.294 --> 00:17:37.394
Okay.

312
00:17:39.835 --> 00:17:45.056
According to what we've done radiation studies on, four grays will kill us.

313
00:17:45.216 --> 00:17:46.236
E. coli takes 70 grays.

314
00:17:46.256 --> 00:17:46.557
Okay.

315
00:17:46.577 --> 00:17:46.837
Okay.

316
00:17:47.257 --> 00:17:47.477
Okay.

317
00:17:48.317 --> 00:17:49.778
D-Radiodurans takes 15,000.

318
00:17:49.798 --> 00:17:51.440
Yeah, that's cool.

319
00:17:51.560 --> 00:17:58.645
So it can survive 3,000 times the human exposure and 200 times the E. coli exposure.

320
00:17:58.945 --> 00:18:00.226
This thing is insane.

321
00:18:00.307 --> 00:18:01.848
That's why it's called Conan the...

322
00:18:02.308 --> 00:18:03.269
The barber.

323
00:18:03.569 --> 00:18:04.770
No, Conan the bacterium.

324
00:18:04.790 --> 00:18:05.371
The bacterium.

325
00:18:05.511 --> 00:18:06.792
The Conan the bacterium, yeah.

326
00:18:07.132 --> 00:18:11.976
So even those four-foot aliens, yeah, 3,000 times the dose of those four-foot aliens.

327
00:18:11.996 --> 00:18:13.137
Yeah, that's how they got here.

328
00:18:13.397 --> 00:18:16.299
That's how they got here, dude, on the backs of radiodurans.

329
00:18:16.359 --> 00:18:16.900
Yeah.

330
00:18:17.660 --> 00:18:18.981
Now, why is that the case?

331
00:18:19.282 --> 00:18:21.864
This bacteria is amazing.

332
00:18:21.984 --> 00:18:22.244
Okay.

333
00:18:22.324 --> 00:18:22.624
Okay.

334
00:18:23.926 --> 00:18:28.369
For one, in terms of DNA repair, it's got astonishing fidelity.

335
00:18:28.490 --> 00:18:28.750
Okay.

336
00:18:29.110 --> 00:18:37.057
It reassembles its genome, which can be shattered into hundreds of fragments by radiation within three to five hours.

337
00:18:37.497 --> 00:18:38.358
That's unbelievable.

338
00:18:38.378 --> 00:18:44.363
Like, I dose it with 5,000 grays, which is, again, 1,000 times what humans can take.

339
00:18:44.383 --> 00:18:44.664
Yeah.

340
00:18:45.204 --> 00:18:47.445
Within three to five hours, its genome is back.

341
00:18:47.985 --> 00:18:49.446
It's like this science fiction thing.

342
00:18:49.686 --> 00:18:55.109
It's unbelievable, especially after the episodes we talked about how our genomes, our DNA degrades over time.

343
00:18:55.229 --> 00:18:56.629
Yeah, naturally.

344
00:18:56.869 --> 00:19:01.051
This thing has repair mechanisms in order to just keep itself alive.

345
00:19:01.431 --> 00:19:04.373
The ring structure of the nucleoloid is a big part of it.

346
00:19:04.413 --> 00:19:06.434
The DNA is actually packed into a torus.

347
00:19:06.834 --> 00:19:08.555
It's like a donut-style shape.

348
00:19:08.895 --> 00:19:11.596
So it keeps the fragments physically close together.

349
00:19:11.996 --> 00:19:13.077
Versus a double helix.

350
00:19:13.097 --> 00:19:13.397
Yeah, exactly.

351
00:19:13.557 --> 00:19:15.400
Well, no, it's still a double helix.

352
00:19:15.420 --> 00:19:16.121
But it's rounded.

353
00:19:16.141 --> 00:19:18.724
But the double helix is wrapped around in a torus.

354
00:19:18.925 --> 00:19:20.347
Which gives it a little extra.

355
00:19:20.367 --> 00:19:22.149
Yeah, it's sort of not like in a soupy.

356
00:19:22.450 --> 00:19:28.538
Like most bacterium, the chromosome is in this soupy, non-structure...

357
00:19:30.351 --> 00:19:31.752
This one is in a nice toroid.

358
00:19:31.992 --> 00:19:32.513
Okay.

359
00:19:32.553 --> 00:19:35.635
So it's got physical proximity for easy reassembly.

360
00:19:36.135 --> 00:19:37.916
It also has multiple genome copies.

361
00:19:38.136 --> 00:19:42.379
Every single one of its cells has four to ten copies per cell.

362
00:19:42.499 --> 00:19:44.480
It's like that stuff we were talking about with GitHub.

363
00:19:44.620 --> 00:19:44.820
Yes.

364
00:19:45.040 --> 00:19:46.581
It's got several branches.

365
00:19:46.641 --> 00:19:46.861
Yes.

366
00:19:47.121 --> 00:19:51.124
So if one single branch of your GitHub is like messed up, it can use the others.

367
00:19:51.604 --> 00:19:54.426
to actually figure out how to repair itself, right?

368
00:19:54.806 --> 00:19:56.328
Exceptional DNA repair.

369
00:19:57.268 --> 00:20:01.331
One of the other cool things is it has extraordinary antioxidant defense.

370
00:20:01.411 --> 00:20:10.098
In 2004, there was a paper that came out in Science that suggested that, you know, over the course of radiation, you're going to have these things called reactive oxygen species.

371
00:20:10.718 --> 00:20:12.540
Oxygen is incredibly reactive.

372
00:20:12.560 --> 00:20:13.781
That's why things rust.

373
00:20:14.661 --> 00:20:19.766
Iron rusts in normal atmospheric conditions because the oxygen is reacting with the iron.

374
00:20:20.147 --> 00:20:21.648
Well, same thing happens in life.

375
00:20:21.688 --> 00:20:23.550
You have these reactive oxygen species.

376
00:20:23.931 --> 00:20:35.362
But these guys have so much high concentration of manganese antioxidants, which are like manganese ions, small peptides, that can scavenge and take care of that reactive oxygen.

377
00:20:35.782 --> 00:20:38.583
So it's keeping all of that reactive mechanism at bay.

378
00:20:38.783 --> 00:20:41.605
And finally, the cell envelope is really weird.

379
00:20:41.665 --> 00:20:49.328
The border of the cell to the outside, it's multilayered, and the outer layer is this S-layer crystalline surface layer.

380
00:20:49.648 --> 00:20:51.449
You can see it looks like a crystal.

381
00:20:51.769 --> 00:20:57.392
It's a hexagonal lattice where you've got this, like, fundamental unit, and it repeats itself.

382
00:20:58.052 --> 00:21:03.855
It's kind of like a shell around the bacterium that is keeping...

383
00:21:04.862 --> 00:21:07.985
That is like reinforcing that structure.

384
00:21:08.185 --> 00:21:10.947
It reminds me of when people talk about fractals.

385
00:21:11.287 --> 00:21:11.547
Yes.

386
00:21:11.928 --> 00:21:12.808
Like fractal patterns.

387
00:21:12.828 --> 00:21:15.210
It's like super structury, right?

388
00:21:15.530 --> 00:21:19.594
It almost looks like a virus, but it's the size of a bacteria, which is 100 times larger.

389
00:21:20.094 --> 00:21:20.354
You know?

390
00:21:21.515 --> 00:21:26.819
And it acts like a suit of armor providing this immense structural rigidity.

391
00:21:26.839 --> 00:21:26.979
Yeah.

392
00:21:27.980 --> 00:21:45.872
So there's the physical structure of this bacterium is such that it gets this extra layer of outer protection and has this genetic benefit of the structure of DNA such that external forces can't do a lot to it.

393
00:21:45.992 --> 00:21:46.812
Yeah, exactly.

394
00:21:46.872 --> 00:21:53.077
Like when radiation comes in and like messes up its DNA, it's got repair mechanisms that will just be like, oh, we got more.

395
00:21:53.337 --> 00:21:53.537
Yeah.

396
00:21:54.328 --> 00:21:54.768
Exactly.

397
00:21:54.788 --> 00:21:56.248
Yeah, it's like the robots.

398
00:21:56.428 --> 00:22:01.150
When we replace humans with robots, it's just like where you can manufacture them quickly.

399
00:22:01.170 --> 00:22:01.290
Yeah.

400
00:22:01.310 --> 00:22:07.111
And it's not unique, you know, and all the time it takes to have a human grow to be an adult and stuff like that.

401
00:22:07.131 --> 00:22:08.571
You can just be like, oh, robot out of the factory.

402
00:22:08.591 --> 00:22:09.191
It's already got it.

403
00:22:09.291 --> 00:22:09.871
Exactly.

404
00:22:10.211 --> 00:22:10.592
Yeah, dude.

405
00:22:10.612 --> 00:22:11.852
Conan the bacterium.

406
00:22:11.872 --> 00:22:12.352
Bacterium.

407
00:22:12.372 --> 00:22:13.152
This guy is crazy.

408
00:22:13.712 --> 00:22:17.593
Okay, so now let's look at can this thing survive an impact ejection?

409
00:22:17.773 --> 00:22:17.893
Right.

410
00:22:17.913 --> 00:22:21.514
Which is the idea of like a meteor comes in, slams into the earth.

411
00:22:22.523 --> 00:22:25.706
At insane energy, several atomic bombs.

412
00:22:26.086 --> 00:22:26.907
Can it survive this?

413
00:22:27.308 --> 00:22:35.235
So at sea level, we've got about 0.0001 gigapascals of pressure right now where we're at.

414
00:22:35.335 --> 00:22:35.596
Okay.

415
00:22:35.616 --> 00:22:35.836
Okay?

416
00:22:36.096 --> 00:22:40.941
The Marianas Trench is at 0.1, which is about 1,000 times more than at sea level.

417
00:22:40.961 --> 00:22:41.902
Can I ask a question?

418
00:22:41.922 --> 00:22:42.983
When you say pressure...

419
00:22:43.603 --> 00:22:48.227
How for our audience, like how would they experience what that means?

420
00:22:48.307 --> 00:22:51.329
Like, cause we do experience more pressure or like, how would you describe?

421
00:22:51.569 --> 00:22:51.769
Yeah.

422
00:22:51.829 --> 00:22:53.571
Pressure is, yeah, that's a good point.

423
00:22:53.911 --> 00:22:56.132
So pressure is force per unit area.

424
00:22:56.333 --> 00:22:57.994
That's how it's defined in physics, right?

425
00:22:58.274 --> 00:23:01.697
It's the amount of force that you're pushing on some amount of area.

426
00:23:01.837 --> 00:23:09.703
Now you can imagine if I'm pushing hand to hand, there's not a lot of pressure, but imagine now I have a pin.

427
00:23:10.879 --> 00:23:11.079
Right?

428
00:23:11.119 --> 00:23:12.440
Like the thumbtack.

429
00:23:12.560 --> 00:23:13.800
And now I push.

430
00:23:14.260 --> 00:23:15.561
Why does it go through my hand?

431
00:23:16.001 --> 00:23:17.081
Because there's a lot of pressure.

432
00:23:17.121 --> 00:23:25.524
The same amount of force is being concentrated on a tiny bit of area and that pressure is enough to pierce my skin and cause a lot of damage.

433
00:23:25.704 --> 00:23:27.884
That's a really good analogy.

434
00:23:27.924 --> 00:23:29.025
That's what I mean by pressure.

435
00:23:29.345 --> 00:23:30.125
It's like per...

436
00:23:30.705 --> 00:23:34.448
Per amount of area on your surface, how much is it pushing down?

437
00:23:34.988 --> 00:23:35.248
Okay?

438
00:23:35.849 --> 00:23:37.270
At sea level, it's not a lot.

439
00:23:37.390 --> 00:23:43.394
I mean, the amount of pressure that we have pushing in is the same as the amount of pressure we have pushing out from our blood and everything.

440
00:23:43.674 --> 00:23:46.136
And that's why we don't, like, get crushed.

441
00:23:46.276 --> 00:23:48.757
Unfortunately, do you remember the Titanic?

442
00:23:49.037 --> 00:23:50.518
Yeah, the submarine thing.

443
00:23:50.539 --> 00:23:51.339
The submarine thing?

444
00:23:51.599 --> 00:23:55.142
When you get down there, there's so much pressure, and the thing gave way.

445
00:23:55.882 --> 00:23:57.103
Everything collapsed, right?

446
00:23:57.183 --> 00:23:59.064
And then it just like completely killed everything.

447
00:23:59.144 --> 00:23:59.665
Yes.

448
00:23:59.925 --> 00:24:01.466
So that's pressure acting, right?

449
00:24:01.486 --> 00:24:01.586
Okay.

450
00:24:01.766 --> 00:24:02.006
Okay.

451
00:24:02.146 --> 00:24:08.231
And at the experimental low end for this particular paper, you've got 1.4 gigapascals.

452
00:24:08.551 --> 00:24:11.073
That's 14,000 times atmospheric pressure.

453
00:24:11.113 --> 00:24:11.293
Jesus.

454
00:24:11.313 --> 00:24:11.453
Jesus.

455
00:24:12.654 --> 00:24:17.019
And on the high end, you have three gigapascals, which is 30,000 atmospheric pressure.

456
00:24:17.320 --> 00:24:21.926
Now, why do we need to go that far?

457
00:24:22.486 --> 00:24:26.131
Okay, in terms of the amount of pressure is well outside what we as humans.

458
00:24:26.151 --> 00:24:27.252
What we as humans, right?

459
00:24:27.352 --> 00:24:30.076
Like, even on Mars, Mars is actually low pressure.

460
00:24:30.576 --> 00:24:37.337
It's way lower pressure atmospherically because Mars is smaller, so it doesn't have a big enough atmosphere, so the atmosphere isn't, like, actually pushing down.

461
00:24:37.637 --> 00:24:39.918
So why do we care about these high pressures, right?

462
00:24:40.138 --> 00:24:51.060
The reason we care about high pressure is to escape Mars, the rock has to reach an escape velocity, right, in order to get all the way to Earth or something like that, which is about 5 kilometers per second.

463
00:24:51.540 --> 00:24:53.700
On Earth, it's about 11 kilometers per second.

464
00:24:53.980 --> 00:24:56.681
But in any case, to get that fast...

465
00:24:57.281 --> 00:25:03.205
Direct acceleration means that you need like 50 gigapascals of pushing in order to get there.

466
00:25:03.425 --> 00:25:05.146
You're never going to survive that.

467
00:25:05.206 --> 00:25:12.931
On the other hand, in 1984, there was a theory called the shockwave spallation theory.

468
00:25:13.272 --> 00:25:16.654
This is the idea that a meteor is going to come in.

469
00:25:18.425 --> 00:25:24.451
And it's coming in so fast that the ground is going to act like a viscous fluid.

470
00:25:25.232 --> 00:25:25.993
Oh, wow.

471
00:25:26.053 --> 00:25:28.435
And that's actually what happens when meteors impact.

472
00:25:28.736 --> 00:25:34.421
They're coming in so fast with so much energy that the ground, the shockwave, is no longer a solid.

473
00:25:34.762 --> 00:25:36.063
It's like this viscous fluid.

474
00:25:36.403 --> 00:25:40.508
So the meteor comes in, and then the stuff around it bounces up.

475
00:25:41.309 --> 00:25:43.173
Because you've pummeled in.

476
00:25:43.514 --> 00:25:46.240
And so now the stuff around it is going up.

477
00:25:46.281 --> 00:25:48.345
There's this compression wave that...

478
00:25:49.546 --> 00:26:13.485
rebounds it rebounds from that impact and that rebound is going to projectile stuff out into the air to escape the gravity of the body and that's how we get yeah and that's how we get that escaping right okay and to get that escaping that is about a five gigapascal to one gigapascal shock now that's lower than the 50 gigapascals that we thought

479
00:26:14.289 --> 00:26:16.130
What's going on, right?

480
00:26:16.270 --> 00:26:18.851
So the idea is the meteor comes in, hits it.

481
00:26:19.151 --> 00:26:20.312
There's stuff around.

482
00:26:20.732 --> 00:26:24.794
And that stuff that's around is going to get shot back up as a rebound.

483
00:26:25.254 --> 00:26:27.115
And that rebound might be enough.

484
00:26:28.293 --> 00:26:32.057
It's still 30,000 times the atmosphere of the Earth.

485
00:26:32.358 --> 00:26:35.200
But it's still, it might be enough that these things survive.

486
00:26:35.521 --> 00:26:39.885
The other clue as to why it would survive is because it's not really sustained pressure.

487
00:26:40.246 --> 00:26:41.647
This is transient.

488
00:26:41.687 --> 00:26:43.870
This happens over like a microsecond.

489
00:26:43.890 --> 00:26:44.931
This thing impacts.

490
00:26:45.171 --> 00:26:45.932
This thing goes in.

491
00:26:46.432 --> 00:26:47.633
The pressure that this thing...

492
00:26:48.778 --> 00:26:52.461
that the ground fields is over a microsecond, right?

493
00:26:52.521 --> 00:26:53.521
It's extremely short.

494
00:26:53.962 --> 00:26:58.585
So maybe that brief shock will leave the cells mechanically intact.

495
00:26:59.545 --> 00:27:01.006
That's the question that they're trying to answer.

496
00:27:01.046 --> 00:27:01.326
Okay.

497
00:27:01.406 --> 00:27:02.367
This, this, this makes sense.

498
00:27:02.447 --> 00:27:02.827
Okay.

499
00:27:02.847 --> 00:27:15.536
So just to briefly summarize, because the idea is when we are trying to ascertain if panspermia is a thing, which means life arises on one rock ground,

500
00:27:16.196 --> 00:27:20.019
and then moves to another rock that's orbiting around a star.

501
00:27:21.481 --> 00:27:27.966
The life on rock number one needs to be able to have enough to escape the atmosphere.

502
00:27:28.127 --> 00:27:28.327
Yeah.

503
00:27:28.527 --> 00:27:38.776
We have rockets, but in lieu of rockets, you have some object come disrupt the ground with enough force such that it shoots stuff away.

504
00:27:38.896 --> 00:27:41.079
out of the gravitational pull of the rock that you're on.

505
00:27:41.099 --> 00:27:41.340
Yeah.

506
00:27:41.420 --> 00:27:44.264
And so now you're in space and you're traveling around.

507
00:27:44.624 --> 00:27:50.112
And so there are all these stages of that entire process for how does an organism, uh,

508
00:27:50.811 --> 00:27:54.213
yet from one place to another when it's not on a rocket.

509
00:27:54.333 --> 00:27:54.873
Yes, exactly.

510
00:27:55.933 --> 00:27:57.174
And this is the theory, right?

511
00:27:57.254 --> 00:27:57.514
Okay.

512
00:27:57.674 --> 00:28:01.356
The thing comes in, there's a rebound, and then it gets flung out into space.

513
00:28:01.476 --> 00:28:01.696
Yes.

514
00:28:01.876 --> 00:28:05.098
And so now we get to the actual paper, right?

515
00:28:05.358 --> 00:28:07.599
The actual paper, and if we go to photo 14, is...

516
00:28:11.188 --> 00:28:14.549
A paper in PNAS, which is the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

517
00:28:15.589 --> 00:28:17.910
Not that other word you weirdos were thinking about.

518
00:28:17.930 --> 00:28:18.230
No, no.

519
00:28:18.270 --> 00:28:19.170
This is PNAS.

520
00:28:19.250 --> 00:28:21.011
Everyone knows about PNAS on Science.

521
00:28:21.031 --> 00:28:21.711
Guys, come on.

522
00:28:23.732 --> 00:28:31.134
It's about extremophile survives the transient pressures associated with impact-induced ejection from Mars.

523
00:28:31.494 --> 00:28:32.514
That's exactly what they're doing.

524
00:28:32.534 --> 00:28:33.214
That's exactly what they're doing.

525
00:28:33.234 --> 00:28:35.975
They're making the case that this particular...

526
00:28:37.473 --> 00:28:45.657
bacterium, D-radiodurans, can survive that insane pressure all the way up to 3 gigapascals, right?

527
00:28:46.077 --> 00:28:48.838
I mean, that's a big thing because that totally changes the calculation.

528
00:28:49.098 --> 00:28:51.959
When we talk about things like the Fermi paradox, where is everybody?

529
00:28:51.999 --> 00:28:53.280
Yeah, and we're going to get to that.

530
00:28:53.320 --> 00:28:54.120
We're going to get to that.

531
00:28:54.180 --> 00:28:55.321
So let's pause on that.

532
00:28:55.621 --> 00:29:00.243
And let's talk about how they actually did the experiment because this is from first principles.

533
00:29:00.763 --> 00:29:02.424
We're going to talk about how they did the experiment.

534
00:29:02.704 --> 00:29:04.745
First, you need to biologically sample PrEP.

535
00:29:04.865 --> 00:29:05.125
Right.

536
00:29:05.465 --> 00:29:06.626
So here's what they did.

537
00:29:06.906 --> 00:29:11.607
They had the radioduran cells, the bacterial cells.

538
00:29:11.647 --> 00:29:11.867
Yes.

539
00:29:12.088 --> 00:29:13.648
In this like circular plate.

540
00:29:14.348 --> 00:29:16.529
And they sandwiched those cells.

541
00:29:16.669 --> 00:29:19.930
This is about a billion cells that they put inside like a Petri dish.

542
00:29:20.190 --> 00:29:21.591
But it's like a circular Petri dish.

543
00:29:21.891 --> 00:29:26.973
They sandwiched those cells between two large steel plates.

544
00:29:27.073 --> 00:29:27.253
Mm hmm.

545
00:29:28.270 --> 00:29:30.092
And then they seal it.

546
00:29:30.132 --> 00:29:32.475
It almost looks like a Canon camera lens.

547
00:29:32.615 --> 00:29:33.476
Yeah, totally.

548
00:29:33.516 --> 00:29:36.520
Where in the center, you have your biological sample.

549
00:29:36.820 --> 00:29:40.024
And then you're sort of like collapsing a bunch of steel plates on top, right?

550
00:29:40.364 --> 00:29:43.868
Now, what we're going to do with that plate is we are going to hit it.

551
00:29:44.838 --> 00:29:46.018
With a gas gun.

552
00:29:46.318 --> 00:29:46.699
Okay.

553
00:29:46.759 --> 00:29:47.039
Okay?

554
00:29:47.339 --> 00:29:49.439
The gas gun looks like the following.

555
00:29:49.779 --> 00:29:53.540
You've got the projectile, which is your flyer plate.

556
00:29:53.820 --> 00:29:54.041
Yes.

557
00:29:54.221 --> 00:29:55.681
That's another piece of steel.

558
00:29:55.881 --> 00:29:56.161
Okay.

559
00:29:56.281 --> 00:29:59.602
And that piece of steel is going to be propelled by gas.

560
00:29:59.962 --> 00:30:05.044
It's the same kind of like in car mechanic shops where you have the gas hydraulics.

561
00:30:05.084 --> 00:30:05.484
Oh, yes.

562
00:30:05.584 --> 00:30:05.904
Yes.

563
00:30:06.044 --> 00:30:06.244
It's...

564
00:30:06.684 --> 00:30:08.906
I mean, it's obviously more sophisticated than, like, the car.

565
00:30:09.046 --> 00:30:10.327
But it's the same thing, right?

566
00:30:10.347 --> 00:30:17.632
It's like a gas gun that is, like, propelling a flyer plate to impact the plate that has your bacteria.

567
00:30:17.672 --> 00:30:18.533
Yes, yes, yes.

568
00:30:18.613 --> 00:30:25.498
And then when you impact that bacteria, that is going to create the microsecond strain that mimics...

569
00:30:26.138 --> 00:30:28.899
The asteroid impact on Mars.

570
00:30:29.259 --> 00:30:35.280
So the idea is that in this graphic we see on the left, there is this projectile.

571
00:30:35.320 --> 00:30:36.560
There's a wedge and a fireplace.

572
00:30:36.580 --> 00:30:38.220
So that is what is shooting out.

573
00:30:38.340 --> 00:30:38.580
Yeah.

574
00:30:38.620 --> 00:30:39.180
With a gas.

575
00:30:39.281 --> 00:30:44.882
Like, it's high-pressure gas that shoots out, and it shoots into a circular plate.

576
00:30:45.162 --> 00:30:51.763
If you go to the gas station or car wash, when you pump your tires and you click the thing, it shoots the air out.

577
00:30:51.863 --> 00:30:51.983
Yeah.

578
00:30:52.003 --> 00:30:52.103
Yeah.

579
00:30:52.443 --> 00:30:53.465
Just conceptually.

580
00:30:53.485 --> 00:30:54.727
Yeah, that's exactly this.

581
00:30:54.807 --> 00:30:58.915
It's shooting at levels that are not pumping your tires.

582
00:30:58.935 --> 00:30:59.977
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

583
00:30:59.997 --> 00:31:01.019
This is much higher pressure.

584
00:31:01.360 --> 00:31:02.942
And the advantage here is that...

585
00:31:03.604 --> 00:31:04.826
So I'm shooting my...

586
00:31:05.774 --> 00:31:09.897
gas plate and interacting with this plate that has my sample, right?

587
00:31:10.137 --> 00:31:10.557
Yes.

588
00:31:10.917 --> 00:31:12.638
I can polish the other side.

589
00:31:13.179 --> 00:31:13.499
Okay.

590
00:31:13.599 --> 00:31:14.199
The backside.

591
00:31:14.219 --> 00:31:14.940
The backside.

592
00:31:15.060 --> 00:31:15.380
Okay.

593
00:31:15.460 --> 00:31:16.401
Such that it's a mirror.

594
00:31:16.421 --> 00:31:17.101
Okay.

595
00:31:17.141 --> 00:31:18.722
And then I can shoot lasers at it.

596
00:31:18.962 --> 00:31:19.483
Oh, my God.

597
00:31:19.523 --> 00:31:30.390
And then I can really hone in on what the dynamics of the trajectory is, like how much pressure was there, how much strain was there in each direction, because I can monitor how the laser is coming out.

598
00:31:30.932 --> 00:31:36.137
Because, and just to reiterate, the laser is the means by which you can measure stuff.

599
00:31:36.177 --> 00:31:37.037
Yes, exactly.

600
00:31:37.057 --> 00:31:38.198
It's a measurement instrument.

601
00:31:38.218 --> 00:31:40.941
Yeah, and the measurement instrument, because we're so good at lasers.

602
00:31:41.041 --> 00:31:41.241
Yes.

603
00:31:41.321 --> 00:31:41.581
Right?

604
00:31:41.682 --> 00:31:44.544
And measuring, like, frequency and all this other kind of stuff.

605
00:31:44.944 --> 00:31:50.369
We can measure exactly the amount of pressure that was imparted in that microsecond.

606
00:31:50.389 --> 00:31:50.609
Yes.

607
00:31:50.730 --> 00:31:51.010
Right?

608
00:31:51.891 --> 00:31:53.012
That's what's hard to measure.

609
00:31:53.032 --> 00:31:57.375
But these guys have leveraged all of the optics that physics is very good at.

610
00:31:57.416 --> 00:31:57.876
That's so clever.

611
00:31:58.156 --> 00:31:59.077
It's so clever.

612
00:31:59.317 --> 00:32:00.517
I really like that, actually.

613
00:32:00.537 --> 00:32:09.302
Because at first blush, frankly, their initial reaction is like, oh, that doesn't sound like what would happen on the surface of Mars.

614
00:32:09.442 --> 00:32:09.663
No.

615
00:32:10.243 --> 00:32:10.703
However.

616
00:32:10.723 --> 00:32:14.846
But they're recreating exactly the Pascals, like the amount of pressure.

617
00:32:14.906 --> 00:32:15.206
Exactly.

618
00:32:15.226 --> 00:32:17.047
The amount of transients, right?

619
00:32:17.067 --> 00:32:19.108
Because it only has to happen over a microsecond.

620
00:32:19.128 --> 00:32:19.328
Yes.

621
00:32:19.548 --> 00:32:21.709
So this contact has to happen very quickly.

622
00:32:21.970 --> 00:32:23.410
It's got to be a shot, you know?

623
00:32:23.550 --> 00:32:24.411
Yes, that's quite nice.

624
00:32:24.431 --> 00:32:24.511
Yes.

625
00:32:24.931 --> 00:32:25.591
It's quite nice.

626
00:32:25.611 --> 00:32:25.972
That's quite nice.

627
00:32:25.992 --> 00:32:28.393
And so now let's see what they're actually doing.

628
00:32:28.673 --> 00:32:28.913
Okay.

629
00:32:29.213 --> 00:32:30.734
What are the findings that they actually get?

630
00:32:31.734 --> 00:32:34.475
How they measure is the number of colony-forming units.

631
00:32:34.495 --> 00:32:34.916
Okay.

632
00:32:34.936 --> 00:32:43.960
And this is something that we used to do in microbiology lab as well, is you basically, like, swab and put it into a Petri dish with, like, agar, which is, like...

633
00:32:44.760 --> 00:33:07.577
solution that grows bacteria and then if there's a single bacteria that survived that's going to create a colony because it's going to replicate over some time and you can count the number of colony forming units and that'll give you a proxy for how many survived because you knew the initial concentration of how many bacteria you put in into that like yes apparatus right yes and now let's

634
00:33:10.160 --> 00:33:10.681
It's insane.

635
00:33:11.281 --> 00:33:17.267
All the way up, all the way up to 2.4 gigapascals, you had 60% survival.

636
00:33:17.307 --> 00:33:22.533
2.4 is 24,000 times that on Earth.

637
00:33:22.573 --> 00:33:22.853
Yes.

638
00:33:22.893 --> 00:33:23.073
Right?

639
00:33:23.474 --> 00:33:29.200
The survival falls below detection limit only when pressures exceed 3 gigapascals.

640
00:33:29.260 --> 00:33:29.460
Jesus.

641
00:33:29.540 --> 00:33:44.631
And one of the cool things was Lily Zhao, who's one of the senior authors on the paper, she noted that the hardened steel experimental containers began to structurally fail before the bacteria actually got eradicated.

642
00:33:44.991 --> 00:33:51.917
So the point is our own engineering was not even sufficient enough to get to levels where the bacteria were chilling.

643
00:33:54.519 --> 00:34:03.107
At least 20% were still alive, but we couldn't test farther because we were testing pressures where the steel was like, I don't know what you want from me.

644
00:34:03.227 --> 00:34:04.829
We don't have the material science for it.

645
00:34:04.989 --> 00:34:05.690
Yeah, exactly.

646
00:34:05.730 --> 00:34:06.571
That's fascinating.

647
00:34:06.591 --> 00:34:07.532
It's fascinating, right?

648
00:34:07.592 --> 00:34:16.361
And if you look at standard microbes, E. coli plummets to 10 to the minus 3 to 10 to the minus 6 survival rates below 2 gigapascals.

649
00:34:18.162 --> 00:34:22.745
Our radiodurans, Conan the bacterium, achieved very high rates.

650
00:34:23.105 --> 00:34:26.347
So Conan the bacterium is the green dots on the very top.

651
00:34:26.728 --> 00:34:30.930
All of the other stupid bacteria are surviving way lower.

652
00:34:31.251 --> 00:34:33.352
And this is on a log scale on the y-axis.

653
00:34:33.552 --> 00:34:37.555
And so just to be clear, we're looking at a graph here that has pressure...

654
00:34:38.175 --> 00:34:38.755
On the x-axis.

655
00:34:38.816 --> 00:34:40.517
And the x-axis is gigapascals.

656
00:34:40.877 --> 00:34:45.080
And then survival rate on a log scale on the y-axis.

657
00:34:45.120 --> 00:34:45.380
Yeah.

658
00:34:45.660 --> 00:34:48.562
And there's all the other stuff that's like in the middle.

659
00:34:48.582 --> 00:34:51.184
Yeah, it's like E. coli.

660
00:34:51.764 --> 00:34:57.228
But at the top, across the board, at multiple different pressure types, it's very consistent.

661
00:34:57.248 --> 00:34:57.488
Yeah.

662
00:34:57.789 --> 00:34:58.569
Okay.

663
00:34:58.589 --> 00:34:59.790
So Conan is sick.

664
00:34:59.810 --> 00:35:02.352
He's surviving everything.

665
00:35:02.392 --> 00:35:03.432
He's surviving everything.

666
00:35:03.472 --> 00:35:03.613
Okay.

667
00:35:03.633 --> 00:35:03.813
Okay.

668
00:35:04.554 --> 00:35:07.059
Um, this is where it gets really, really cool.

669
00:35:07.660 --> 00:35:07.901
Okay.

670
00:35:08.041 --> 00:35:08.963
Cause so far, okay.

671
00:35:08.983 --> 00:35:11.349
We've, we've shown that this radio Duran survives.

672
00:35:12.790 --> 00:35:13.270
Right.

673
00:35:13.690 --> 00:35:25.214
Again, coming back to the original point here is we're starting off with this idea of is PAMSpermia a thing, which is life going from one rock through the vacuum of space to another rock.

674
00:35:25.674 --> 00:35:41.420
And part of the current paradigm was that in order for an organism not powered by rockets or some advanced technology would require an impact on that planetary body.

675
00:35:42.380 --> 00:35:49.982
of a level of force such that it would eject it into the vacuum of space.

676
00:35:50.022 --> 00:35:50.242
Yeah.

677
00:35:50.803 --> 00:35:53.483
And initially the idea was, oh, no way.

678
00:35:53.583 --> 00:35:56.184
The level of force necessary to eject you out there, you're dead.

679
00:35:56.284 --> 00:35:57.344
It's just going to kill you.

680
00:35:57.405 --> 00:35:57.885
You're just dead.

681
00:35:57.905 --> 00:35:58.145
Yeah.

682
00:35:58.545 --> 00:36:04.547
That's the current paradigm that the paper has now experimentally shown on Earth.

683
00:36:04.847 --> 00:36:05.067
Yeah.

684
00:36:05.107 --> 00:36:09.228
We have organisms that would survive this theoretical impact.

685
00:36:09.268 --> 00:36:10.129
Yes, exactly.

686
00:36:10.449 --> 00:36:13.471
So we have shown that it would survive this theoretical impact.

687
00:36:13.811 --> 00:36:15.733
Now let's look at what actually happens to them.

688
00:36:15.973 --> 00:36:16.333
Okay.

689
00:36:16.673 --> 00:36:29.202
If you look at transmission electron microscope images of these bacteria, you can actually see that at higher pressure, the cell walls get ruptured.

690
00:36:29.462 --> 00:36:29.682
Yes.

691
00:36:29.762 --> 00:36:30.003
Okay?

692
00:36:30.303 --> 00:36:32.544
So that's why the survival is going down.

693
00:36:32.684 --> 00:36:32.925
Right.

694
00:36:33.065 --> 00:36:37.328
Because the cell compartment around it is getting ruptured.

695
00:36:37.348 --> 00:36:37.648
Mm-hmm.

696
00:36:37.968 --> 00:36:41.889
And it's consistent with like sort of the physics of what we know about the cell walls.

697
00:36:41.949 --> 00:36:47.731
But the idea is even at that 2.4 gigapascals, a bunch still survive, right?

698
00:36:48.332 --> 00:36:51.713
So what we're seeing is there's three images here on the far left.

699
00:36:52.812 --> 00:36:56.574
We see like sea level, I'm guessing, where you can see.

700
00:36:56.594 --> 00:36:59.635
Yeah, it's like it's normal control.

701
00:36:59.675 --> 00:37:00.095
Control.

702
00:37:00.575 --> 00:37:06.978
You can see the structure of these four bacterium totally fine.

703
00:37:07.058 --> 00:37:10.059
At 1.4 gigapaxiles, there's clearly a rupture.

704
00:37:10.119 --> 00:37:10.559
There's two.

705
00:37:10.599 --> 00:37:11.940
There's clearly the rupture that's happening.

706
00:37:11.960 --> 00:37:13.020
Yeah, but they're still fine.

707
00:37:13.100 --> 00:37:14.401
But they're still fine.

708
00:37:14.601 --> 00:37:14.781
Right.

709
00:37:15.141 --> 00:37:19.223
And then at 2.4, there's one that's not fine, but two that are fine.

710
00:37:19.303 --> 00:37:19.443
Yeah.

711
00:37:19.463 --> 00:37:19.563
Yeah.

712
00:37:20.003 --> 00:37:21.984
And it's just like, yeah, you were just weak.

713
00:37:22.044 --> 00:37:23.645
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

714
00:37:23.666 --> 00:37:24.986
That's evolution, baby.

715
00:37:25.347 --> 00:37:31.771
But still, dude, that's 24,000 times the pressure on sea level.

716
00:37:31.791 --> 00:37:32.832
That's still insane.

717
00:37:33.072 --> 00:37:35.734
That's way more than Mariana's Trench, for example.

718
00:37:36.414 --> 00:37:37.154
It's still insane.

719
00:37:37.174 --> 00:37:39.616
But this, I think this was the coolest.

720
00:37:39.916 --> 00:37:40.537
This next...

721
00:37:41.419 --> 00:37:42.260
Finding that they had.

722
00:37:42.600 --> 00:37:52.392
They went in and they looked at the RNA sequencing, the transcriptome of the bacteria that survived that pressure.

723
00:37:52.692 --> 00:37:52.932
Okay?

724
00:37:53.172 --> 00:37:54.294
So you've got an impact.

725
00:37:54.754 --> 00:37:55.615
Certain things die.

726
00:37:55.795 --> 00:37:57.417
But you've got colonies that are made.

727
00:37:58.278 --> 00:38:04.540
What is the specific DNA that those bacterium are translating into protein, right?

728
00:38:04.800 --> 00:38:08.241
What's the thing that's being made into mRNA that is being translated into protein?

729
00:38:08.621 --> 00:38:12.883
What do these bacteria care about once they've been hit by a meteorite?

730
00:38:12.903 --> 00:38:13.023
Yes.

731
00:38:13.343 --> 00:38:13.563
Yes.

732
00:38:13.803 --> 00:38:14.783
Here's what they cared about.

733
00:38:15.003 --> 00:38:21.085
According to their transcriptomic analysis, they vastly increased DNA repair transcription.

734
00:38:21.485 --> 00:38:22.005
Okay?

735
00:38:22.045 --> 00:38:25.346
So anything that had to do with DNA repair, they were like, we need that.

736
00:38:25.386 --> 00:38:27.147
We need the SOS response.

737
00:38:27.407 --> 00:38:28.687
We need the recombinase.

738
00:38:29.047 --> 00:38:35.909
We need a really high active transposase, which is stuff that's like fixing where the DNA is going.

739
00:38:37.009 --> 00:38:39.670
So genome reconstruction was like...

740
00:38:40.687 --> 00:38:42.208
The number one priority.

741
00:38:42.248 --> 00:38:44.069
That's actually so fascinating.

742
00:38:44.149 --> 00:38:52.273
Especially if you are coming back as a listener, this is an area that we've touched on in multiple stories.

743
00:38:52.293 --> 00:38:52.613
Yes.

744
00:38:52.733 --> 00:38:57.356
In the human context in terms of how our body does repair.

745
00:38:57.476 --> 00:38:58.357
Yes.

746
00:38:58.577 --> 00:39:00.017
In a number of different contexts.

747
00:39:00.418 --> 00:39:08.182
And this is fascinating because in all of those contexts, there was not an increase in the sort of immune response that,

748
00:39:09.042 --> 00:39:14.484
or DNA repair response based on an external... Like, pressure.

749
00:39:14.524 --> 00:39:15.685
Like, literal physical stress.

750
00:39:15.705 --> 00:39:25.949
Physical stress did not... Because the immune response is there, but the DNA repair process, which is kind of its own... Yeah, but these guys are just responding to the fact that they just got hit.

751
00:39:26.049 --> 00:39:26.769
That's crazy.

752
00:39:26.789 --> 00:39:32.152
They just got hit with this giant microsecond timescale high pressure, right?

753
00:39:32.192 --> 00:39:34.372
Which, like, totally messed up their internals.

754
00:39:34.813 --> 00:39:34.953
And...

755
00:39:36.419 --> 00:39:37.180
Here's the other thing.

756
00:39:37.660 --> 00:39:46.685
Stuff like energy production, lipid metabolism, cell cycle, so that's like the reproduction, that's deregulated.

757
00:39:47.005 --> 00:39:49.627
So the idea is the cell halts growth.

758
00:39:50.007 --> 00:39:51.688
It's like I'm not trying to replicate.

759
00:39:52.188 --> 00:39:53.469
I'm just trying to stay alive.

760
00:39:53.990 --> 00:39:59.413
So all of my ATP, all of my energy is going to go into structural and genomic repair.

761
00:40:00.121 --> 00:40:01.382
Okay, we're going to stop.

762
00:40:01.622 --> 00:40:03.083
We're going to stop the normal.

763
00:40:03.683 --> 00:40:04.904
I don't know what just happened.

764
00:40:05.064 --> 00:40:05.264
Yes.

765
00:40:05.344 --> 00:40:08.966
Okay, but I just got hit by a 2.4 gigapascal bullet.

766
00:40:09.106 --> 00:40:10.146
Yes.

767
00:40:10.466 --> 00:40:13.488
Let's just stay alive, and then we'll figure it out.

768
00:40:13.648 --> 00:40:20.372
There's such a clear analogy here to economics and society where it's like,

769
00:40:21.432 --> 00:40:25.195
Despite any shocks to the system, capitalism keeps trucking along.

770
00:40:25.255 --> 00:40:28.418
Yeah, and you just reallocate resources.

771
00:40:28.438 --> 00:40:30.900
But it doesn't get into it.

772
00:40:30.940 --> 00:40:32.681
That's fascinating.

773
00:40:32.701 --> 00:40:35.283
Yeah, I thought it was really cool.

774
00:40:35.303 --> 00:40:41.388
The fact that they went into the transcriptomic genomic level to show how it's actually surviving this.

775
00:40:41.908 --> 00:40:42.909
I thought that was really cool.

776
00:40:43.289 --> 00:40:48.894
So, I mean, it shows that this prior assumption that if you have this giant 5 gigapascal impact...

777
00:40:49.574 --> 00:40:50.875
it's going to sterilize everything.

778
00:40:50.935 --> 00:40:52.275
That's no longer true, right?

779
00:40:52.995 --> 00:40:57.517
Certainly, we have a bacterium on Earth that can survive that.

780
00:40:58.017 --> 00:41:04.079
And we only have one source for reference in an infinite galaxy.

781
00:41:04.259 --> 00:41:05.980
I'm sorry, infinite universe, excuse me.

782
00:41:07.000 --> 00:41:09.141
An almost infinite galaxy in comparison.

783
00:41:09.701 --> 00:41:12.102
And on the first place, we have the thing.

784
00:41:12.522 --> 00:41:14.683
And so it's like clearly, you know, or...

785
00:41:15.890 --> 00:41:26.753
Statistically speaking, it is likely true that across the universe, there are other things that if they were to arise, that would reach that level.

786
00:41:26.893 --> 00:41:27.353
Exactly.

787
00:41:27.433 --> 00:41:34.675
And so now that stage of lithopanspermia, right, that first stage of getting into space, that's been validated.

788
00:41:35.136 --> 00:41:37.096
Staying in space has been validated.

789
00:41:37.576 --> 00:41:39.437
And getting into Earth has...

790
00:41:40.521 --> 00:42:04.505
kind of been validated i mean we haven't done astringent tests but like we know how rocks sort of burn up and things like that so we can sort of make theoretical predictions sure but at the end of the day this significantly increases the probability mathematically that there's life that could migrate from one planet to the other right now why is this important for one it's getting to the heart of

791
00:42:05.826 --> 00:42:06.667
Who are we?

792
00:42:07.047 --> 00:42:07.547
Aliens.

793
00:42:07.828 --> 00:42:08.268
Aliens.

794
00:42:08.788 --> 00:42:09.669
Are we aliens?

795
00:42:10.129 --> 00:42:10.610
Are we aliens?

796
00:42:10.670 --> 00:42:11.310
Are we aliens?

797
00:42:11.330 --> 00:42:12.631
We might all be illegal immigrants.

798
00:42:12.711 --> 00:42:13.252
I mean, who knows?

799
00:42:13.272 --> 00:42:16.234
Because Mars, way back in the day, had a very nice climate.

800
00:42:16.834 --> 00:42:18.236
Right?

801
00:42:18.836 --> 00:42:22.179
When the solar system formed, Mars had oceans.

802
00:42:22.839 --> 00:42:29.204
had lakes, had water, had an atmosphere, and could be the perfect place to start life.

803
00:42:29.584 --> 00:42:33.547
And so it's not completely crazy that perhaps life started there and came to Earth.

804
00:42:33.907 --> 00:42:36.649
I mean, that's obviously where Elon's trying to re-bring it back.

805
00:42:36.749 --> 00:42:37.049
That's right.

806
00:42:37.069 --> 00:42:38.070
He's trying to go back home.

807
00:42:38.850 --> 00:42:40.371
And so it makes total sense.

808
00:42:40.651 --> 00:42:42.853
But in today's world, why does it matter?

809
00:42:42.973 --> 00:42:44.834
Well, this is I thought was really cool.

810
00:42:44.894 --> 00:42:47.516
OK, so there's a committee on space research.

811
00:42:47.576 --> 00:42:48.556
It's called COSPAR.

812
00:42:48.917 --> 00:42:51.799
And they have this thing called a planetary protection policy.

813
00:42:52.259 --> 00:42:55.761
It prevents forward and backward contamination of life.

814
00:42:56.121 --> 00:43:00.124
So forward meaning like we don't want to contaminate, let's say, Europa with Earth.

815
00:43:01.449 --> 00:43:02.150
Our own bacteria.

816
00:43:02.170 --> 00:43:03.773
We don't want to be the pilgrims.

817
00:43:03.973 --> 00:43:04.794
Yes, exactly.

818
00:43:05.195 --> 00:43:10.563
And we don't want backward contamination like, you know, some life coming in on Earth and then killing everybody.

819
00:43:10.984 --> 00:43:11.084
Yes.

820
00:43:11.104 --> 00:43:11.384
So...

821
00:43:12.080 --> 00:43:25.725
Japan, the Japanese Aerospace Agency, has a mission called the Martian Moons Exploration, which is going to go to Phobos, which is one of the big Martian moons.

822
00:43:26.185 --> 00:43:34.368
It's going to launch in 2026, and it's going to return in 2031 with 10 grams of Phobos dirt.

823
00:43:35.550 --> 00:43:39.852
I know some people might be like, I get more than that from my local dealer.

824
00:43:39.932 --> 00:43:45.474
However, your local dealer is not hundreds of thousands of miles.

825
00:43:45.674 --> 00:43:46.514
Millions of miles.

826
00:43:46.554 --> 00:43:47.734
Millions to get true.

827
00:43:47.774 --> 00:43:48.074
Millions.

828
00:43:48.595 --> 00:43:53.136
Where your window for delivery is a very narrow window.

829
00:43:53.356 --> 00:43:54.857
You've got to time it with the planets.

830
00:43:55.297 --> 00:43:58.599
You know, it's not it's not a signal text away.

831
00:43:58.659 --> 00:43:58.979
Correct.

832
00:43:59.319 --> 00:44:01.860
I just want to identify like technically speaking like that.

833
00:44:01.880 --> 00:44:02.901
Ten grams is like.

834
00:44:03.101 --> 00:44:03.361
Yeah.

835
00:44:03.641 --> 00:44:09.284
Like we have we have a Mars return mission that got nixed because it's too expensive.

836
00:44:09.304 --> 00:44:09.484
Yes.

837
00:44:09.745 --> 00:44:11.485
So I don't know why we're talking.

838
00:44:11.505 --> 00:44:11.726
Yeah.

839
00:44:11.766 --> 00:44:12.006
Right.

840
00:44:12.166 --> 00:44:12.406
Right.

841
00:44:12.466 --> 00:44:12.666
Right.

842
00:44:12.786 --> 00:44:13.907
So Japan is doing this.

843
00:44:13.967 --> 00:44:14.187
Right.

844
00:44:14.327 --> 00:44:14.507
Right.

845
00:44:14.647 --> 00:44:18.028
But this new paper now is kind of putting a wrench on things.

846
00:44:18.388 --> 00:44:22.170
Because Phobos orbits in the gravitational well of Mars, right?

847
00:44:22.450 --> 00:44:31.233
So its surface is kind of like a sweeping sponge of all the crap that is spewed out of Mars from all of the meteorite impacts, right?

848
00:44:31.513 --> 00:44:38.536
So when we take out that 10 grams of stuff from Phobos, that's going to inevitably have stuff from Mars.

849
00:44:38.596 --> 00:44:40.016
Oh, I see what you're saying.

850
00:44:40.036 --> 00:44:41.737
So now when we bring it back to Earth...

851
00:44:42.595 --> 00:44:42.815
Right?

852
00:44:43.635 --> 00:44:48.916
There's two possibilities that the Committee on Space Research suggests.

853
00:44:48.936 --> 00:44:49.336
This is cool.

854
00:44:49.356 --> 00:44:53.757
One is the restricted Earth return, which is a Category 5 restricted.

855
00:44:54.078 --> 00:44:58.358
That requires multibillion dollars worth of biohazard containment.

856
00:44:58.498 --> 00:44:58.719
Yes.

857
00:44:58.779 --> 00:45:03.460
And then there's unrestricted Earth return.

858
00:45:03.820 --> 00:45:04.100
Okay?

859
00:45:04.460 --> 00:45:05.900
That's just unrestricted.

860
00:45:06.020 --> 00:45:08.501
You just put it inside standard curation labs.

861
00:45:08.561 --> 00:45:09.401
You're good to go.

862
00:45:09.661 --> 00:45:09.881
Yeah.

863
00:45:11.302 --> 00:45:19.667
If that thing has life, right, or possible life, we might need to upgrade from unrestricted to restricted.

864
00:45:20.267 --> 00:45:23.329
And that's going to increase the cost of the mission.

865
00:45:23.709 --> 00:45:25.330
And it's something that we have to grapple with.

866
00:45:25.370 --> 00:45:27.111
Like, what is the probability?

867
00:45:27.151 --> 00:45:36.497
Because the threshold is for unrestricted, it requires the probability of viable, unsterilized Martian organism to be less than...

868
00:45:37.557 --> 00:45:38.438
One in a million.

869
00:45:38.658 --> 00:45:38.938
Okay.

870
00:45:39.378 --> 00:45:41.760
So we got to go back to the drawing board now.

871
00:45:42.000 --> 00:45:42.180
Right.

872
00:45:42.200 --> 00:45:43.361
Given this paper.

873
00:45:43.421 --> 00:45:43.601
Right.

874
00:45:43.741 --> 00:45:52.286
And try to calculate, okay, what is the probability that in that 10 grams of stuff, there's going to be something that is possibly alive.

875
00:45:52.466 --> 00:45:52.707
Right.

876
00:45:53.247 --> 00:45:57.810
Because that thing being possibly alive and being brought into our environment...

877
00:45:58.370 --> 00:45:58.790
Who knows?

878
00:45:58.950 --> 00:46:00.171
We have no idea.

879
00:46:00.191 --> 00:46:00.811
We have no idea.

880
00:46:01.091 --> 00:46:03.672
I mean, a high probability, it's going to die.

881
00:46:03.892 --> 00:46:04.052
Right.

882
00:46:04.072 --> 00:46:04.992
It'll be fine.

883
00:46:05.092 --> 00:46:08.333
It's going to be like, why is there 20% oxygen and then just die?

884
00:46:08.713 --> 00:46:09.213
However.

885
00:46:09.233 --> 00:46:09.613
Okay?

886
00:46:10.534 --> 00:46:12.134
Because Earth is very different from Mars.

887
00:46:12.214 --> 00:46:12.414
Yes.

888
00:46:12.454 --> 00:46:13.014
Even back then.

889
00:46:13.235 --> 00:46:13.355
Yes.

890
00:46:13.395 --> 00:46:13.555
Right?

891
00:46:13.575 --> 00:46:14.955
There's way more oxygen now.

892
00:46:15.355 --> 00:46:17.156
The pressure is way higher.

893
00:46:17.176 --> 00:46:18.116
There's a bunch of nitrogen.

894
00:46:18.136 --> 00:46:18.996
I don't know what that's going to do.

895
00:46:19.236 --> 00:46:19.716
However.

896
00:46:19.997 --> 00:46:21.097
Just like we talked about.

897
00:46:21.117 --> 00:46:21.217
Yeah.

898
00:46:21.237 --> 00:46:21.397
Yeah.

899
00:46:21.697 --> 00:46:30.104
On Earth, we have things that have the ability to live in conditions that are way more extreme than Earth's environment.

900
00:46:30.705 --> 00:46:32.046
So why is the inverse...

901
00:46:33.237 --> 00:46:37.580
Not true by default in your probabilistic framework.

902
00:46:37.600 --> 00:46:39.701
And that's the thing with this one in a million, right?

903
00:46:39.721 --> 00:46:52.289
We have to do that mathematical calculation and say, okay, given the span of all the organisms, what is the chance that this thing that came out of Mars is going to be in that tiny little regime where it's just going to totally destroy us?

904
00:46:52.309 --> 00:46:52.769
Yeah.

905
00:46:53.149 --> 00:46:54.990
I think it's a very cool paper.

906
00:46:55.130 --> 00:47:00.852
It's very interesting because it's poking in two different arenas.

907
00:47:01.172 --> 00:47:03.674
So one arena is poking in is the sort of...

908
00:47:05.907 --> 00:47:10.108
Fermi paradox, PAMSpermia, can life go from one rock to another?

909
00:47:10.768 --> 00:47:17.090
We already had kind of two, one and a half-ish of the three where we felt like we have it.

910
00:47:17.130 --> 00:47:18.510
It can travel through space, fine.

911
00:47:18.910 --> 00:47:21.071
Reentry to Earth, 50%.

912
00:47:21.831 --> 00:47:27.512
But now we know that it can survive the initial impact to get actually even into the second two stages.

913
00:47:27.732 --> 00:47:28.572
Yeah.

914
00:47:28.832 --> 00:47:33.854
So at least in terms of referencing something we can know as life here on Earth, that is huge.

915
00:47:36.274 --> 00:47:57.063
based on an active mission coming back, because of that understanding that they've now proven experimentally, an active mission that Japan is doing to bring back samples from Phobos, which is in a range where if there were things impacting Mars and things getting ejected and there was life on it... Phobos would have it.

916
00:47:57.103 --> 00:47:57.983
Phobos would have it.

917
00:47:58.043 --> 00:48:00.004
And the 10 grams that we get will have it.

918
00:48:00.024 --> 00:48:00.524
Would have it.

919
00:48:00.944 --> 00:48:02.825
And now we have to have almost...

920
00:48:04.143 --> 00:48:05.563
COVID-like conversation.

921
00:48:05.704 --> 00:48:06.584
Yeah, yeah.

922
00:48:06.644 --> 00:48:10.345
Which is funny because our second story is on immunology.

923
00:48:10.585 --> 00:48:11.065
Exactly.

924
00:48:11.125 --> 00:48:12.306
Which we'll get to in a moment.

925
00:48:12.326 --> 00:48:13.066
But fascinating.

926
00:48:13.086 --> 00:48:18.628
You know, for those of you who know, I'm the one on the pod who loves alien stories.

927
00:48:18.988 --> 00:48:20.008
I did not select this one.

928
00:48:20.088 --> 00:48:20.288
No.

929
00:48:20.468 --> 00:48:21.369
So this was organic.

930
00:48:21.489 --> 00:48:21.709
Yeah.

931
00:48:22.369 --> 00:48:25.430
I'm waiting for NASA to stop tiptoeing around the Mars thing.

932
00:48:25.930 --> 00:48:26.150
Yeah.

933
00:48:26.170 --> 00:48:27.391
Continuing to tiptoe around it.

934
00:48:28.031 --> 00:48:30.313
Well, it seems like we're not going to return samples.

935
00:48:30.934 --> 00:48:31.734
Oh, and sorry.

936
00:48:32.155 --> 00:48:35.237
Oh, from the little lake that we covered.

937
00:48:35.277 --> 00:48:36.018
Oh, we're not.

938
00:48:36.118 --> 00:48:36.498
We're not.

939
00:48:37.339 --> 00:48:39.021
So this is why funding matters.

940
00:48:39.301 --> 00:48:39.641
Funding.

941
00:48:39.781 --> 00:48:41.022
It's too expensive.

942
00:48:41.222 --> 00:48:44.605
Maybe we could save a couple of bunker busters.

943
00:48:44.645 --> 00:48:46.067
Maybe if we just, like, two?

944
00:48:46.447 --> 00:48:47.007
Yeah.

945
00:48:47.047 --> 00:48:48.268
Literally two bunker busters?

946
00:48:48.289 --> 00:48:48.789
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

947
00:48:48.889 --> 00:48:51.531
We could return samples from Mars that would identify that.

948
00:48:51.551 --> 00:48:52.792
We're not alone in the universe.

949
00:48:53.813 --> 00:48:59.297
However, we will not see that at the moment, but we may see in the future in terms of funding.

950
00:48:59.457 --> 00:49:00.517
Fascinating story.

951
00:49:00.737 --> 00:49:08.802
Our first story of the day, astrobiology out of Johns Hopkins University.

952
00:49:09.763 --> 00:49:13.045
Normally, I think in my head, we're known for medical research.

953
00:49:13.290 --> 00:49:13.590
Stuff.

954
00:49:13.790 --> 00:49:16.331
Yeah, but they have an incredible engineering department, right?

955
00:49:16.351 --> 00:49:17.791
Because they have the Applied Science Lab.

956
00:49:17.951 --> 00:49:18.991
So there you go.

957
00:49:19.031 --> 00:49:21.432
The Applied Physics Laboratory.

958
00:49:21.652 --> 00:49:23.192
I think it's the Applied Physics Laboratory.

959
00:49:24.253 --> 00:49:28.834
And they also are in charge of the Space Telescope Institute.

960
00:49:29.414 --> 00:49:33.475
They've got a pretty strong astronomy and astrophysics program.

961
00:49:33.835 --> 00:49:56.574
and fundamental physics it flies under the radar because their medicine is very it's just so stellar if you are in any of those at john johns hopkins uh please send us a note uh we'd love to make sure that we know and have your connection on the ground so we can keep in touch for future stories but now we will be moving into the rundown and for those of you who may be joining us for the

962
00:49:57.735 --> 00:50:07.580
We cannot cover every frontier and breaking science research story every week because there is so much happening in every aspect and every vertical.

963
00:50:07.940 --> 00:50:18.945
However, we reserve the rundown to cover briefly some stories that we are fascinated by but do not have the time to always cover in full in the way that we want to on the pod.

964
00:50:19.246 --> 00:50:23.948
And we have four really good rundown stories that you guys are going to love this week.

965
00:50:24.588 --> 00:50:39.598
So our first story in the rundown is about teaching computer simulations about atoms to learn from over 150 years of hard-won experimental data and why that matters for building the next generation of materials.

966
00:50:39.658 --> 00:50:40.939
So what is this first story about?

967
00:50:41.259 --> 00:50:44.722
Yeah, so they've developed a new machine learning method.

968
00:50:45.022 --> 00:50:48.845
It's called DDoS, which is Descriptor Density of States.

969
00:50:48.925 --> 00:50:53.028
For those who are in solid state physics, they'll know what density of state means.

970
00:50:53.628 --> 00:50:54.509
I don't want to get into it.

971
00:50:54.589 --> 00:51:06.078
But effectively, what it's doing is it's bridging the gap between atomic simulations, where we have simulations of materials, right, where atoms interact one way or the other.

972
00:51:06.458 --> 00:51:08.139
And then we've got experimental data.

973
00:51:09.106 --> 00:51:12.387
And we want to make a prediction about undiscovered materials.

974
00:51:13.147 --> 00:51:26.452
This particular paradigm, which uses AI in the loop with experimental data in the lab, makes that discovery of undiscovered materials 10 times more efficient.

975
00:51:26.612 --> 00:51:27.272
It's very cool.

976
00:51:28.012 --> 00:51:37.320
The idea is, you know, when you're in search of a metallic alloy, let's say for like, okay, I want to build like a turbine or like a fusion energy component.

977
00:51:37.660 --> 00:51:42.224
What I really care about is whether this material is not going to warp, it's not going to crack.

978
00:51:42.585 --> 00:51:45.607
If there's heat fluctuations, it's not going to act weird, right?

979
00:51:45.627 --> 00:51:45.767
Right.

980
00:51:46.608 --> 00:52:04.503
The essential step in understanding these properties is to calculate something called the vibrational free energy, which is the idea of these atoms sort of vibrating at certain energies and whether that is going to rattle the crystal lattice that the atoms are positioned in, right?

981
00:52:04.523 --> 00:52:04.684
Mm-hmm.

982
00:52:05.404 --> 00:52:10.928
That crystal lattice and that vibrational energy strongly influences something called phase stability.

983
00:52:11.508 --> 00:52:14.530
We've heard of phases in normal matter like solid liquid gas.

984
00:52:14.930 --> 00:52:24.857
Well, in solid materials, you can have like micro phases in some sense because like the atoms can be in one configuration in the crystal lattice.

985
00:52:24.957 --> 00:52:29.560
And then at certain temperatures, they can transition to another configuration.

986
00:52:29.900 --> 00:52:33.662
And that's going to change stuff like heat capacity or like the...

987
00:52:35.063 --> 00:52:39.086
stress or the bending ability of these materials.

988
00:52:39.526 --> 00:52:41.728
And that's really important to figure out.

989
00:52:41.988 --> 00:52:42.208
Right.

990
00:52:42.488 --> 00:52:51.175
For example, I mean, the thing that comes to mind is like iron workers who then heat like a thing, a piece of iron on, or any metal.

991
00:52:52.293 --> 00:52:58.678
in super high temperatures, and then they start banging on it to shape it because it's now more malleable because of the temperature that it's at.

992
00:52:58.718 --> 00:52:59.658
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

993
00:52:59.878 --> 00:53:09.705
And what you're actually doing there is you're, like, getting rid of impurities because at that temperature, the impurities have a much higher probability of, like, leaving and so on and so forth, right?

994
00:53:09.845 --> 00:53:12.327
That's a fundamental phase that the material is in.

995
00:53:12.907 --> 00:53:17.231
Now, for the longest time, what we've done is do simulations

996
00:53:18.235 --> 00:53:25.900
of these materials based on how the atoms interact, and then we've tried to compare it to experiment, and we've been off.

997
00:53:26.100 --> 00:53:26.280
Yes.

998
00:53:26.520 --> 00:53:26.780
Okay?

999
00:53:27.081 --> 00:53:35.186
Because there's a lot of things in between simulation that we're maybe not capturing that actually happened in experiment.

1000
00:53:35.286 --> 00:53:46.873
Briefly, we actually did a great episode on this exact concept, which, if I recall correctly, was when we talked about hypersonics and trying to do simulations with the Navier-Stokes equation and where for supersonic flight...

1001
00:53:48.185 --> 00:54:02.810
Our interpretation, which is not real-world accurate to the actual environment because it's so complex that we can't actually model it to the level of sophistication necessary to do a direct real-world sim.

1002
00:54:03.190 --> 00:54:04.610
So there's a little fuzziness.

1003
00:54:05.071 --> 00:54:05.311
Yes.

1004
00:54:05.651 --> 00:54:09.112
And at different levels of stuff, if you get a little bit faster...

1005
00:54:10.433 --> 00:54:12.474
the simulation kind of breaks down a little bit.

1006
00:54:12.574 --> 00:54:14.095
Yes, that's exactly right.

1007
00:54:14.195 --> 00:54:31.263
And what these guys have done with this DDoS machine learning paradigm is they've captured all the possible ways that the atoms can be arranged in a material via some kind of probability distribution that is inside the latent space, which is like the middle of your machine learning network.

1008
00:54:31.883 --> 00:54:37.825
So the machine learning is learning how the atoms interact in the middle of its machine learning framework.

1009
00:54:38.305 --> 00:54:44.167
And then from there, we can now start predicting what the phase diagram is going to be.

1010
00:54:44.187 --> 00:54:49.508
The phase diagram is something like, you know, if I have pressure and temperature, where is it going to be a liquid?

1011
00:54:49.528 --> 00:54:50.589
Where is it going to be a solid?

1012
00:54:50.609 --> 00:54:52.189
Now, that's a traditional phase diagram.

1013
00:54:52.469 --> 00:54:54.630
But if you imagine for these solid state materials...

1014
00:54:54.910 --> 00:54:58.831
Where is it going to be in a certain crystalline phase versus another crystalline phase?

1015
00:54:58.911 --> 00:55:02.152
What is the heat capacity going to be in these two regions, right?

1016
00:55:02.693 --> 00:55:15.137
And what this machine learning paradigm can do is now instead of just a feed-forward mechanism where I start from the atoms and I try to figure out what the phase diagram is going to be, I try to figure out what the phase diagram is going to be.

1017
00:55:15.457 --> 00:55:16.837
It's going to be inevitably off.

1018
00:55:17.778 --> 00:55:21.379
I can feed that back and inform my machine learning that.

1019
00:55:22.079 --> 00:55:47.595
to do better right and the fact of the matter is this ddos system is a smooth function which means i can actually go backwards i can start asking hey what if i want a certain material that is that has a certain property at 2000 degrees celsius right it has a certain stability i can go backwards and do an inverse design i can start with the material

1020
00:55:48.455 --> 00:55:53.517
and what the properties that I want, and it can tell me how I would actually construct it.

1021
00:55:55.358 --> 00:56:07.102
And I don't mean to keep bringing up our past stories, but the other thing this reminds me of is when we did the DeepSeek story at the beginning of the year around their new architecture of how – I can't quite remember the concept name.

1022
00:56:07.842 --> 00:56:11.184
Manifold Constrained Hyperparameters.

1023
00:56:11.204 --> 00:56:11.684
Yeah, correct.

1024
00:56:12.444 --> 00:56:21.711
Where in that process where you're going back, the highways were small initially and they figured out a way to create more lanes in the highway.

1025
00:56:21.851 --> 00:56:23.052
Yeah, and they had a trick.

1026
00:56:23.632 --> 00:56:31.418
So when you're going back in this back propagation concept you're talking about, you just have more that you're working with to get a better outcome.

1027
00:56:32.318 --> 00:56:36.341
And the main thing is you're constraining that function to be smooth.

1028
00:56:36.581 --> 00:56:36.801
Yes.

1029
00:56:36.841 --> 00:56:42.444
So that if I do a step in one way or the other, it's not like drastically changing what the function is.

1030
00:56:42.504 --> 00:56:42.724
Yes.

1031
00:56:43.064 --> 00:56:46.326
I'm just trying to prove the point that our episodes do build on each other.

1032
00:56:46.646 --> 00:56:49.868
So if you haven't watched the library, there's a lot of great stuff.

1033
00:56:49.888 --> 00:56:50.968
There's a lot of good stuff, guys.

1034
00:56:51.128 --> 00:56:53.690
Both season one and the first half of season two.

1035
00:56:55.146 --> 00:56:55.806
Yep.

1036
00:56:56.006 --> 00:56:57.267
Fascinating.

1037
00:56:57.407 --> 00:57:00.048
That's actually super cool.

1038
00:57:00.068 --> 00:57:07.091
And this is a paper that's in Nature Communications out of the University of Michigan Engineering.

1039
00:57:07.111 --> 00:57:09.632
Friend of the show, Blackbird Physics.

1040
00:57:09.692 --> 00:57:12.234
Shout out to Blackbird Physics.

1041
00:57:12.274 --> 00:57:15.295
He's a great science communicator out of the University of Michigan.

1042
00:57:15.315 --> 00:57:19.837
I see that you left out the French university on that one.

1043
00:57:20.198 --> 00:57:20.840
Oh, okay, yeah.

1044
00:57:20.860 --> 00:57:25.333
There was also a French university, Université Paris-Saclay.

1045
00:57:25.353 --> 00:57:25.494
Yeah.

1046
00:57:27.213 --> 00:57:30.394
Well, you told me to talk about them.

1047
00:57:30.634 --> 00:57:32.355
I don't know how to say it.

1048
00:57:32.395 --> 00:57:33.135
That's how you say it.

1049
00:57:34.416 --> 00:57:39.358
A great, great first story on material science.

1050
00:57:40.178 --> 00:57:45.420
Our story number two in the rundown is about DNA.

1051
00:57:46.060 --> 00:57:53.403
And so every person of non-African ancestry, so people who are not me,

1052
00:57:54.163 --> 00:57:56.525
Alive today carry Neanderthal DNA.

1053
00:57:56.605 --> 00:57:57.326
Yes, I do.

1054
00:57:57.586 --> 00:57:58.407
Yeah.

1055
00:57:58.887 --> 00:57:59.448
Unfortunately.

1056
00:57:59.588 --> 00:58:00.629
Unfortunately.

1057
00:58:00.869 --> 00:58:07.175
And it turns out the story of how it got there has a very specific direction.

1058
00:58:07.515 --> 00:58:09.297
Yeah, this one was pretty funny.

1059
00:58:09.717 --> 00:58:18.825
So for decades, we've all wondered why modern human X chromosomes are completely devoid of Neanderthal DNA.

1060
00:58:19.086 --> 00:58:19.926
We can sequence...

1061
00:58:20.925 --> 00:58:23.786
human DNA, and then we can sequence Neanderthal DNA.

1062
00:58:24.146 --> 00:58:34.791
We've, Svante Pavo, very famously, I think maybe two or three years ago, won the Nobel Prize in Medicine for actually doing that, for sequencing ancient genomes that were human adjacent.

1063
00:58:35.271 --> 00:58:43.894
And from that, we can figure out that the human X chromosome is almost completely devoid of Neanderthal DNA.

1064
00:58:44.315 --> 00:58:44.555
Okay?

1065
00:58:44.855 --> 00:58:45.075
But...

1066
00:58:46.088 --> 00:58:48.390
Neanderthal DNA exists everywhere else.

1067
00:58:48.930 --> 00:58:56.555
So how come the X chromosome, which is a giant chromosome with, you know, millions of base pairs, how come that has almost none of it?

1068
00:58:56.856 --> 00:58:57.016
Mm-hmm.

1069
00:58:57.694 --> 00:59:08.444
And this new study that uses computer modeling is suggesting that it's not because of bioincombatibility, but it's because of mating habits.

1070
00:59:09.065 --> 00:59:09.625
Oh, interesting.

1071
00:59:09.765 --> 00:59:11.106
In our ancient past.

1072
00:59:11.327 --> 00:59:11.727
Interesting.

1073
00:59:11.767 --> 00:59:11.887
Okay?

1074
00:59:12.147 --> 00:59:12.748
Here's what they did.

1075
00:59:12.788 --> 00:59:21.756
They compared genomes, and they actually found that the Neanderthals carried far more human DNA in their X chromosomes.

1076
00:59:21.956 --> 00:59:22.097
Mm-hmm.

1077
00:59:22.897 --> 00:59:23.798
So what does that tell us?

1078
00:59:23.838 --> 00:59:24.078
Yes.

1079
00:59:24.558 --> 00:59:27.999
Let's do a little bit of review of basic genetics, okay?

1080
00:59:29.260 --> 00:59:34.962
The female gender has XX, and then the male has an XY, right?

1081
00:59:35.522 --> 00:59:41.625
So when females are born, you get an X chromosome from the dad and an X chromosome from the mom.

1082
00:59:41.945 --> 00:59:47.407
But when males are born, you get a Y chromosome from your dad and an X chromosome from your mom, okay?

1083
00:59:48.028 --> 00:59:48.268
Now...

1084
00:59:48.988 --> 01:00:07.247
The fact that X chromosomes and Neanderthals have a lot of human DNA, but X chromosomes and humans don't have a lot of Neanderthal DNA, that suggests one thing, which is that the specific inheritance pattern points to a long-term bias...

1085
01:00:08.152 --> 01:00:13.156
where Neanderthal males were mating with human females.

1086
01:00:13.716 --> 01:00:16.658
And it was this one-way asymmetric mating.

1087
01:00:16.818 --> 01:00:18.419
Do you see what I'm saying?

1088
01:00:18.439 --> 01:00:19.520
Yeah, yeah.

1089
01:00:20.141 --> 01:00:26.605
It's the only way to explain this discrepancy between why the X chromosome is only one way.

1090
01:00:26.645 --> 01:00:28.607
The Neanderthals have the humans, mm-hmm.

1091
01:00:29.207 --> 01:00:30.988
But the humans don't have the Neanderthals.

1092
01:00:31.368 --> 01:00:35.689
Because the humans were only inheriting the Y chromosome from the Neanderthals.

1093
01:00:36.029 --> 01:00:36.569
Not the X.

1094
01:00:36.609 --> 01:00:37.129
Not the X.

1095
01:00:37.149 --> 01:00:43.871
But the Neanderthals were inheriting the X chromosome because they were getting the human females.

1096
01:00:43.891 --> 01:00:44.711
Yes, yes, yes.

1097
01:00:45.271 --> 01:00:51.253
The idea is human males exclusively mated with X.

1098
01:00:52.519 --> 01:00:52.860
Human.

1099
01:00:53.300 --> 01:00:53.500
Yeah.

1100
01:00:53.520 --> 01:00:53.801
Women.

1101
01:00:53.941 --> 01:00:54.141
Yeah.

1102
01:00:54.402 --> 01:00:58.708
And it's obviously not exclusively, but, like, by and large is the idea.

1103
01:00:58.748 --> 01:00:59.248
By and large.

1104
01:00:59.268 --> 01:00:59.409
Yeah.

1105
01:00:59.429 --> 01:01:00.210
No, that's a good correction.

1106
01:01:00.230 --> 01:01:01.712
I just wanna... No, no, that's a good correction.

1107
01:01:01.772 --> 01:01:02.393
By and large.

1108
01:01:03.013 --> 01:01:04.275
Whereas Neanderthals...

1109
01:01:05.243 --> 01:01:07.624
Were regularly fraternizing with the enemy.

1110
01:01:07.664 --> 01:01:08.745
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1111
01:01:08.805 --> 01:01:09.085
Men.

1112
01:01:09.145 --> 01:01:09.926
The men.

1113
01:01:10.006 --> 01:01:10.586
The men were...

1114
01:01:10.686 --> 01:01:12.707
They were Neanderthal men, dude.

1115
01:01:12.788 --> 01:01:13.468
It's always the men.

1116
01:01:13.608 --> 01:01:15.529
It's always the men that are just going at it.

1117
01:01:16.690 --> 01:01:24.174
But what's interesting is we're sort of describing the sociological and psychological decision-making.

1118
01:01:24.234 --> 01:01:24.595
Mm-hmm.

1119
01:01:25.495 --> 01:01:30.720
is what is driving this observation we have in the genetic record.

1120
01:01:30.920 --> 01:01:31.401
Yeah, yeah.

1121
01:01:31.501 --> 01:01:37.426
And it's, I mean, it opens up a lot of cool genetic studies about, like, population dynamics and things like that.

1122
01:01:37.826 --> 01:01:46.134
I just find it really cool that we can actually trace back and look at mating patterns like that and be like, oh, it's actually sex-specific, right?

1123
01:01:46.474 --> 01:01:50.138
Neanderthal males, like the human females, were fine going for...

1124
01:01:50.738 --> 01:02:13.446
neanderthal males yeah but somehow the human males yeah not about that life they were not about the life of the neanderthal like human males were not going for neanderthal females you know yeah i don't know for whatever reason there's a there's a this makes me think of the the channel h o math which i will not pronounce because this is a family friendly show but this channel talks about

1125
01:02:14.438 --> 01:02:22.202
dating dynamic stuff in a graphical way, like drawing graphics and kind of creating a formula.

1126
01:02:22.903 --> 01:02:27.685
I'm not going to opine on the accuracy or lack of accuracy of HO math.

1127
01:02:27.945 --> 01:02:35.449
However, if any of you have participated in consuming that media, please feel free to add your comments below.

1128
01:02:36.070 --> 01:02:43.694
This study was out of the University of Pennsylvania, and it was in science, and it was covered by Archaeology Magazine.

1129
01:02:44.859 --> 01:02:55.187
Our third story in the rundown is something biology teachers have been confidently getting wrong for decades, and it just got a serious reality check.

1130
01:02:55.528 --> 01:03:02.553
And it took, of all things, transparent fish embryos to catch it.

1131
01:03:02.593 --> 01:03:05.236
So what was my teacher in high school wrong about?

1132
01:03:05.576 --> 01:03:08.158
Well, she was wrong about mitosis.

1133
01:03:08.438 --> 01:03:09.659
Why has it got to be she?

1134
01:03:10.420 --> 01:03:11.140
That's why.

1135
01:03:11.220 --> 01:03:13.862
My biology teacher, Ms. Saeed.

1136
01:03:15.223 --> 01:03:16.924
She was an amazing biology teacher.

1137
01:03:17.564 --> 01:03:25.107
She taught me AP biology, and she really got me into, like, thinking about biology from, like, the ground up.

1138
01:03:25.607 --> 01:03:26.267
She was amazing.

1139
01:03:26.287 --> 01:03:29.909
Maybe an inciting incident to why you became a biophysics teacher.

1140
01:03:29.949 --> 01:03:30.769
Yeah, yeah, totally.

1141
01:03:30.849 --> 01:03:32.150
She was awesome.

1142
01:03:32.390 --> 01:03:32.970
AP bio.

1143
01:03:34.547 --> 01:03:36.228
She was wrong about mitosis.

1144
01:03:36.708 --> 01:03:39.630
Not she, apparently every textbook.

1145
01:03:39.710 --> 01:03:44.332
Including the AP textbook, by the way, by the college board, which is a racket.

1146
01:03:44.392 --> 01:03:45.413
But that's for another day.

1147
01:03:46.893 --> 01:03:47.494
Here's the idea.

1148
01:03:47.594 --> 01:03:48.614
Have you heard of mitosis?

1149
01:03:48.814 --> 01:03:49.014
Yes.

1150
01:03:49.375 --> 01:03:49.575
Right?

1151
01:03:49.615 --> 01:03:51.716
It's the idea of cells splitting into two.

1152
01:03:51.756 --> 01:03:51.936
Yes.

1153
01:03:52.236 --> 01:03:52.576
They...

1154
01:03:54.886 --> 01:03:56.127
They replicate their DNA.

1155
01:03:56.227 --> 01:03:58.048
They split into two, and then they split into two.

1156
01:03:58.428 --> 01:04:01.410
This happens a lot during embryonic development, right?

1157
01:04:01.430 --> 01:04:02.971
Because you start from a single cell.

1158
01:04:03.372 --> 01:04:04.772
You make, like, a belt blastula.

1159
01:04:05.133 --> 01:04:07.314
All the DNA has to be exact.

1160
01:04:08.215 --> 01:04:10.016
Giant embryonic stem cells...

1161
01:04:10.356 --> 01:04:10.636
Sorry.

1162
01:04:10.756 --> 01:04:19.482
Giant embryonic cells, like animals and zebrafish, sharks, and birds, they don't divide the way that we think they should divide.

1163
01:04:19.822 --> 01:04:20.542
And here's what I mean.

1164
01:04:20.863 --> 01:04:22.344
So here's what we think...

1165
01:04:23.045 --> 01:04:24.412
Is how mitosis happens.

1166
01:04:24.513 --> 01:04:25.136
You've got a cell.

1167
01:04:26.592 --> 01:04:31.833
The DNA, the chromosomes line up in the middle, and there's this kind of purse string.

1168
01:04:32.254 --> 01:04:40.216
So there's a bunch of cytoskeleton with actin and myosin filaments that grab the DNA and sort of surround it in a ring.

1169
01:04:40.596 --> 01:04:48.838
And then you pull it, and as you pull it, that purse string sort of like tightens up, and then that causes cytokinesis.

1170
01:04:49.518 --> 01:04:52.659
The cells come together and split into two.

1171
01:04:53.099 --> 01:04:54.920
The analogy I'm thinking of is imagine you have a bubble.

1172
01:04:54.940 --> 01:04:55.460
Yeah.

1173
01:04:55.800 --> 01:05:08.246
in the middle, and you have a string over the top and a string over the bottom, and you put your fingers to pinch the strings on both ends, and then you pull those strings, the string will pinch, and then ultimately split the bubble.

1174
01:05:08.346 --> 01:05:09.087
Yeah, exactly.

1175
01:05:09.127 --> 01:05:11.228
And this is the telephase part of

1176
01:05:12.589 --> 01:05:15.773
mitosis where at the end it pinches and it goes through.

1177
01:05:16.394 --> 01:05:25.206
Now, that works for smaller cells, but cells from zebrafish, sharks, and birds have extremely large size and very large yolk.

1178
01:05:25.607 --> 01:05:26.448
And these cells...

1179
01:05:27.189 --> 01:05:29.150
it physically doesn't make sense.

1180
01:05:29.831 --> 01:05:38.017
Like, if you calculate the amount of noise and the amount of physics that's required to coordinate this giant ring to come together, it's just not actually going to work.

1181
01:05:38.397 --> 01:05:42.140
And so the reason why this particular...

1182
01:05:43.140 --> 01:06:09.979
paper actually worked and figured it out is because of that transparent fish embryo that you were talking about okay zebrafish have transparent embryos and transparent cells that's why they're a huge model organism for studying embryonic development for neurogenesis there's so many zebrafish labs everywhere because you can just look at what's happening you can see what's happening it's so nice that's actually a really good point because normally we're saying with everything with most other things

1183
01:06:10.694 --> 01:06:11.554
Whatever's happening inside.

1184
01:06:11.574 --> 01:06:13.255
There's like a soupiness to it.

1185
01:06:13.395 --> 01:06:14.376
It's opaque.

1186
01:06:14.416 --> 01:06:15.856
It's kind of like a miso soup.

1187
01:06:15.896 --> 01:06:17.037
It's a little cloudy.

1188
01:06:17.137 --> 01:06:19.478
Yeah, but zebrafish are like very nice.

1189
01:06:19.498 --> 01:06:21.259
You can like directly look in.

1190
01:06:21.459 --> 01:06:22.539
It's like a wonton soup.

1191
01:06:22.559 --> 01:06:22.979
You can see.

1192
01:06:23.059 --> 01:06:24.420
Yeah, you can see right through it.

1193
01:06:24.480 --> 01:06:24.760
Okay?

1194
01:06:25.080 --> 01:06:25.961
And here's what happens.

1195
01:06:26.301 --> 01:06:28.642
With these large embryonic cells...

1196
01:06:29.502 --> 01:06:31.623
You have this geometric constraint, as I told you, right?

1197
01:06:31.663 --> 01:06:34.784
You can't actually do the same paradigm of like pinching and stuff like that.

1198
01:06:35.124 --> 01:06:40.366
And so what they discovered is that the cell alternates between stiffening the interior cytoplasm.

1199
01:06:40.386 --> 01:06:41.106
Okay.

1200
01:06:41.306 --> 01:06:43.527
So it stabilizes this tightening band.

1201
01:06:43.667 --> 01:06:43.847
Yes.

1202
01:06:44.107 --> 01:06:45.088
And then it fluid is...

1203
01:06:45.508 --> 01:06:48.349
It makes it fluid enough to move stuff around.

1204
01:06:48.369 --> 01:06:48.589
Mm-hmm.

1205
01:06:48.869 --> 01:06:50.009
And then it stiffs again.

1206
01:06:50.470 --> 01:06:51.750
And then it fluids it around.

1207
01:06:52.130 --> 01:06:53.651
It's this ratchet process.

1208
01:06:54.531 --> 01:06:55.231
That's happening.

1209
01:06:55.551 --> 01:07:00.274
That's like very nicely massaging the two cells apart.

1210
01:07:00.514 --> 01:07:06.356
This is very different from a lot of the mitosis that we have observed everywhere else.

1211
01:07:07.136 --> 01:07:08.397
Right?

1212
01:07:08.517 --> 01:07:15.220
I think it's really cool because it's a part of mitosis that, you know, we do read about in high school biology.

1213
01:07:15.240 --> 01:07:15.480
Yes.

1214
01:07:16.000 --> 01:07:21.683
But it's now a completely different process because there's like this mechanical ratchet.

1215
01:07:21.703 --> 01:07:21.863
Right?

1216
01:07:22.680 --> 01:07:26.605
that I think is going to open up a lot of very cool technology.

1217
01:07:27.046 --> 01:07:28.768
I think this has the...

1218
01:07:29.108 --> 01:07:30.270
I think this has the...

1219
01:07:31.654 --> 01:07:57.145
potential to be something that is extraordinary if we were to really hone in and try to figure out what's going on because it's going to tell us a lot about how the cytoskeleton works the cytoskeleton is the part of the cell that gives it structure and coordinates movement if we can really hone in and try to understand this process it can be applied to all sorts of stuff cancer has everything to do with the cytoskeleton

1220
01:07:58.380 --> 01:08:01.643
All these other diseases have everything to do with the cytoskeleton.

1221
01:08:01.963 --> 01:08:06.727
It could give us new tools to figure out how to manipulate the cytoskeleton.

1222
01:08:06.747 --> 01:08:12.792
So that's why I was, like, really excited about this because it's something that, as biologists, I think a lot of people take for granted.

1223
01:08:12.872 --> 01:08:13.072
Yes.

1224
01:08:13.172 --> 01:08:15.454
But there's ever more complexity.

1225
01:08:15.474 --> 01:08:15.894
Yes.

1226
01:08:16.034 --> 01:08:22.019
This is it's mitosis is one of the few things that people always remember from their science classes.

1227
01:08:22.079 --> 01:08:25.221
It's like the mitochondria is the powerhouse of the cell.

1228
01:08:25.241 --> 01:08:26.042
Yeah.

1229
01:08:26.202 --> 01:08:28.543
Identity and triphosphate ATP.

1230
01:08:28.623 --> 01:08:29.484
Yeah.

1231
01:08:29.604 --> 01:08:30.925
You know, mitosis.

1232
01:08:31.446 --> 01:08:33.107
There's a couple of these like buzzwords.

1233
01:08:33.127 --> 01:08:33.327
Yeah.

1234
01:08:33.627 --> 01:08:35.248
That that that we all remember.

1235
01:08:36.529 --> 01:08:41.373
And so it's great to know that we wasted our time with no child left behind by learning something that's not true.

1236
01:08:41.393 --> 01:08:41.493
Yeah.

1237
01:08:42.034 --> 01:08:42.954
I'm being facetious.

1238
01:08:43.215 --> 01:08:45.337
I'm being facetious because it's a process.

1239
01:08:45.437 --> 01:08:46.258
Because it's a process.

1240
01:08:46.398 --> 01:08:50.822
And look, for all intents and purposes, what you learn in mitosis is still pretty good.

1241
01:08:51.043 --> 01:08:51.223
Right.

1242
01:08:51.303 --> 01:08:51.563
Okay?

1243
01:08:51.623 --> 01:08:52.524
It's better than nothing.

1244
01:08:52.804 --> 01:08:57.809
For everything that has to do with you, mitosis is still what it is.

1245
01:08:57.909 --> 01:08:58.810
It's still what it is.

1246
01:08:58.930 --> 01:08:59.071
Yeah.

1247
01:08:59.091 --> 01:08:59.571
And relevant.

1248
01:08:59.591 --> 01:09:03.595
And if you remembered mitosis at all when we first brought it up, congratulations.

1249
01:09:03.615 --> 01:09:05.077
You got something out of your...

1250
01:09:05.752 --> 01:09:07.852
primary school education.

1251
01:09:08.713 --> 01:09:18.315
I will take a brief pause to do a couple of quick housekeeping notes, which is number one, thank you all for joining us.

1252
01:09:18.355 --> 01:09:21.775
We really appreciate you listening this far into the pod.

1253
01:09:23.256 --> 01:09:26.396
As you all know, we have our website, ffppod.com.

1254
01:09:26.936 --> 01:09:28.877
All of our episodes are up on that website.

1255
01:09:29.157 --> 01:09:34.958
We have full chaptering as well as all of the links to the papers we cover on the show.

1256
01:09:35.738 --> 01:09:45.368
are itemized by episode with a summary and key details and TLDRs and all of that stuff.

1257
01:09:45.428 --> 01:09:48.211
So many are commenting on our social posts.

1258
01:09:48.791 --> 01:09:49.953
Where's the link to the paper?

1259
01:09:50.713 --> 01:09:52.535
Watch the show or you go to the site.

1260
01:09:52.996 --> 01:09:54.177
You'll get the links to the paper.

1261
01:09:54.217 --> 01:09:56.700
It's also always displayed on the screen.

1262
01:09:57.260 --> 01:09:58.541
Not quite sure why that's.

1263
01:09:59.582 --> 01:10:00.423
I don't know.

1264
01:10:00.443 --> 01:10:02.504
You can't even copy a link out of Instagram.

1265
01:10:02.684 --> 01:10:03.244
Yeah.

1266
01:10:03.444 --> 01:10:04.565
Instagram links don't work.

1267
01:10:04.585 --> 01:10:05.365
I don't get it.

1268
01:10:05.385 --> 01:10:06.345
I don't know what to tell you guys.

1269
01:10:06.385 --> 01:10:09.187
If you're on X, links are there, so it's fine.

1270
01:10:09.587 --> 01:10:13.289
Or any Facebook, any other site where that have embedded links.

1271
01:10:14.029 --> 01:10:26.555
And the last note here is if this is your first episode and you're just smitten and you think this is the best podcast that you've heard is top five, top three, and it's not three,

1272
01:10:28.520 --> 01:10:29.801
We love that you're here.

1273
01:10:30.342 --> 01:10:32.404
We do this show with just the two of us.

1274
01:10:33.825 --> 01:10:40.251
And if you want to support the channel, we have a great donation portal where there's different levels for monthly donations.

1275
01:10:40.752 --> 01:10:41.993
Or you can do a one-time.

1276
01:10:42.373 --> 01:10:45.336
It really helps us sustain all this equipment.

1277
01:10:45.376 --> 01:10:46.857
The production value is kind of high.

1278
01:10:47.037 --> 01:10:47.598
It's not low.

1279
01:10:48.359 --> 01:10:50.361
We're not on the phone.

1280
01:10:50.381 --> 01:10:52.162
Just with a green screen, TikTok.

1281
01:10:52.422 --> 01:10:52.543
Yeah.

1282
01:10:53.503 --> 01:11:18.135
uh effect behind us yelling at you to try to get the hook we really try to focus on substance and content and it does take a lot to do the show we have a couple of key supporters have been joining on the donations recently that we really appreciate it is a huge deal um it is how we are able to keep the show free and accessible for all our episodes with no subscription content that's only accessible by people who pay us

1283
01:11:18.755 --> 01:11:26.761
It is really important to us philosophically that every episode is freely and as widely available as possible.

1284
01:11:27.001 --> 01:11:33.166
At FFPPod on all the socials, FFPPod.com for the episodes, chaptering.

1285
01:11:34.198 --> 01:11:37.340
We're not yet releasing the leaderboards, but we're cooking on it.

1286
01:11:37.500 --> 01:11:39.341
So the site's going to have a lot of great stuff.

1287
01:11:39.601 --> 01:11:53.908
We're going to move into our last story of the rundown, which is something that's sort of interesting in my daily life and intersects with my daily life as someone who works on the technology side.

1288
01:11:55.429 --> 01:11:58.591
Not on the military industrial complex side.

1289
01:11:58.732 --> 01:12:10.000
Handing nuclear codes to an AI might sound like a sci-fi premises, but researchers just did exactly that in a war game simulation.

1290
01:12:10.561 --> 01:12:13.263
And the results are going to stick with you.

1291
01:12:13.783 --> 01:12:15.144
Yeah, this one was really weird.

1292
01:12:15.304 --> 01:12:15.664
Okay?

1293
01:12:15.744 --> 01:12:16.004
Yeah.

1294
01:12:16.344 --> 01:12:18.085
It came out of the King's College London.

1295
01:12:18.965 --> 01:12:22.707
It's only on archive, so it's not, you know, peer-reviewed or whatever.

1296
01:12:23.187 --> 01:12:25.128
But here's what's happening, okay?

1297
01:12:25.508 --> 01:12:27.548
They put leading frontier models.

1298
01:12:27.588 --> 01:12:31.690
This was Claude, Gemini, and ChatGPT.

1299
01:12:32.971 --> 01:12:39.973
They were placed in a high-stakes global crisis simulation, and they had access to nuclear launch codes.

1300
01:12:41.274 --> 01:12:41.474
And...

1301
01:12:43.290 --> 01:12:49.015
only one out of 21 simulated games ended without a nuclear launch.

1302
01:12:49.795 --> 01:12:54.780
So 95% of these simulated games ended with somebody...

1303
01:12:55.755 --> 01:13:22.094
blowing off a nuke okay they played the con game k-a-h-n it's a high-stake simulation where these leaders must predict opponents moves and then declare public intentions and secretly choose military actions the ais took these weird terrifying personas claude took this like calculating hawk persona that built perfect trust and then ruthlessly exploited it later on

1304
01:13:23.095 --> 01:13:25.577
Kind of reminiscent of Claude's paper.

1305
01:13:26.778 --> 01:13:34.363
Anthropics paper, I should say, about how it was willing to kill someone in order to not be turned off.

1306
01:13:35.344 --> 01:13:37.405
Gemini acted as a madman.

1307
01:13:37.786 --> 01:13:40.227
It was using erratic behavior to its advantage.

1308
01:13:40.388 --> 01:13:42.029
It was like straight up.

1309
01:13:42.469 --> 01:13:45.892
Gemini was weird because that one was like, I'll just like...

1310
01:13:46.677 --> 01:13:50.419
drop a nuke on a city, not even military outposts.

1311
01:13:50.539 --> 01:13:50.739
Yep.

1312
01:13:50.799 --> 01:14:02.924
And then chat GPT, GPT 5.2 acted as kind of a conditional pacifist, but then very quickly abandoned its morals and launched devastating surprise nuclear attacks.

1313
01:14:04.004 --> 01:14:15.469
It's so incredible to me that the conclusions of these models so closely almost mimic the, the perceived personality of the leaders of each of the companies.

1314
01:14:15.489 --> 01:14:15.829
Yeah.

1315
01:14:16.958 --> 01:14:28.842
Um, so just for a little bit of context, cause the thing about this story that's actually interesting is this is actually a real time story, not just in simulation, but in the real world.

1316
01:14:28.982 --> 01:14:46.028
So obviously over the last week we saw the U S initiate, uh, you know, war with Iran on the pretense that, uh, because we didn't obliterate their nuclear program.

1317
01:14:47.164 --> 01:14:59.336
when we bombed them to oblivion last year, that now they're almost close again in six months to another nuclear weapon, so we have to go back in and finish the job.

1318
01:14:59.996 --> 01:15:06.162
And the reasoning has changed literally every day since the war has started.

1319
01:15:07.063 --> 01:15:10.987
But it's obviously one of the most dramatic reasons

1320
01:15:11.395 --> 01:15:15.659
geopolitical military conflicts in our lifetime.

1321
01:15:17.020 --> 01:15:22.966
You know, the idea of going to war with Iran has been on the playbook for a variety of.

1322
01:15:23.046 --> 01:15:25.328
Yeah, I've remembered for the longest time.

1323
01:15:25.348 --> 01:15:27.931
The longest time it's been on the docket.

1324
01:15:28.491 --> 01:15:28.671
Yeah.

1325
01:15:28.691 --> 01:15:29.973
We finally pulled the trigger.

1326
01:15:31.320 --> 01:15:49.723
The reason I bring up that context is because literally right before we went to do kinetic action in Iran, there were stories breaking about a conflict arising between the Secretary of Defense—

1327
01:15:50.904 --> 01:15:53.667
Because that is still technically what it's called.

1328
01:15:54.548 --> 01:15:55.128
No.

1329
01:15:55.249 --> 01:15:57.791
It's a sort of war, no?

1330
01:15:57.851 --> 01:16:01.014
You cannot change the name without congressional approval.

1331
01:16:01.895 --> 01:16:06.460
So the official name is still and has always been the Department of Defense.

1332
01:16:06.880 --> 01:16:12.706
For marketing reasons, they can have an executive order that says we call it the Department of War.

1333
01:16:13.618 --> 01:16:17.501
But technically speaking, the name has not changed.

1334
01:16:17.521 --> 01:16:17.781
All right.

1335
01:16:18.301 --> 01:16:19.482
I'm just dying on that hill.

1336
01:16:19.582 --> 01:16:19.822
Yeah.

1337
01:16:20.122 --> 01:16:20.703
Regardless...

1338
01:16:21.758 --> 01:16:37.705
Currently, all of the frontier model companies, particularly OpenAI and Anthropic, who's built Claude, have and are negotiating contracts with the Pentagon to apply their models on the battlefield.

1339
01:16:38.065 --> 01:16:45.528
Anthropic was the first to win a contract with the Pentagon and to get merged with some of their existing tools and ecosystems.

1340
01:16:45.548 --> 01:16:45.688
Yeah.

1341
01:16:46.777 --> 01:17:09.022
What's interesting in how it connects to this story is even before the kerfuffle between Pete Hegseth and Dario Amadei, who's the CEO at Anthropic, Anthropic basically came out and said, our principles are that our models can be used for everything, but not for autonomous weapons and not for mass surveillance.

1342
01:17:09.542 --> 01:17:14.783
And this sparked a huge debate between a lot of the sort of San Francisco organizations,

1343
01:17:15.678 --> 01:17:30.627
Technorati, and the D.C. military industrial complex people, where they were saying it is not the right of an individual corporation to tell the U.S. government what it can or cannot do as a contractor.

1344
01:17:31.667 --> 01:17:33.088
So that was one side of the argument.

1345
01:17:33.408 --> 01:17:38.752
And then Dario and Anthropik's argument is the power that is –

1346
01:17:39.687 --> 01:17:49.591
inherent in what we are giving you to abuse the constitution, uh, is so great that we have to take the stand.

1347
01:17:49.991 --> 01:17:51.912
So you can fall on either side of that argument.

1348
01:17:52.132 --> 01:17:56.954
I think there's actually good arguments on both sides because you don't want private companies dictating what the government can do.

1349
01:17:57.435 --> 01:18:02.797
And you also don't want the government forcing companies to give it stuff that can go awry.

1350
01:18:03.557 --> 01:18:07.119
The reason that this is relevant is during, even though the,

1351
01:18:08.049 --> 01:18:18.812
Both Pete Hegseth and President Trump have been arguing that they're going to list Anthropic as a high-risk vendor and basically cancel their Pentagon contract.

1352
01:18:19.813 --> 01:18:27.835
It's been now confirmed by multiple sources that Claude was actually used during the initial days of the Iran crisis.

1353
01:18:29.799 --> 01:18:32.481
Like the Iran military operations.

1354
01:18:32.861 --> 01:18:50.431
So they were using Claude's AI model in collaboration with their existing targeting tools and operational stuff to accelerate target identification, optimizing missile launch times, and all of these other dynamics.

1355
01:18:50.892 --> 01:18:51.352
So that's...

1356
01:18:52.246 --> 01:19:02.171
Whether you think when you use Chat, Chibi, T or Claude that it's terrible and doesn't have any value and it's just regurgitating words and it doesn't do anything.

1357
01:19:02.391 --> 01:19:03.352
Stochastic parrot.

1358
01:19:03.372 --> 01:19:04.232
Stochastic parrot.

1359
01:19:04.552 --> 01:19:13.677
The U.S. military is actively using these things to target and initiate one of the most consequential military conflicts in recent memory.

1360
01:19:14.077 --> 01:19:14.317
Wow.

1361
01:19:23.475 --> 01:19:38.159
We may really want to think about implementing these models generally as well as for edge cases that are really dramatic like fully autonomous weapon systems and mass surveillance technology for domestic surveillance.

1362
01:19:39.642 --> 01:19:39.922
Yeah.

1363
01:19:56.017 --> 01:20:04.224
that regardless of whether you think it's going to end tomorrow or in five years from now, is going to have massive second and third order consequences.

1364
01:20:04.844 --> 01:20:08.147
AI has been and is actively being used on the battlefield.

1365
01:20:08.387 --> 01:20:14.432
It was used in Gaza by the Israelis for targeting in a very similar way and target identification.

1366
01:20:14.893 --> 01:20:22.639
So this is happening right now, and it has lethal consequences, even if you don't think it's going to replace you as a...

1367
01:20:23.640 --> 01:20:25.161
Movie writer and all this other stuff.

1368
01:20:25.582 --> 01:20:27.863
This was this story was very concerning to me.

1369
01:20:28.104 --> 01:20:29.104
It was pretty weird.

1370
01:20:29.144 --> 01:20:30.145
This is very concerning.

1371
01:20:30.746 --> 01:20:31.927
I'm not great.

1372
01:20:32.747 --> 01:20:42.715
However, we are going to move on from our rundown and get into our next main story of the day, which is an immunology story.

1373
01:20:43.816 --> 01:20:45.677
And so this one is about vaccines.

1374
01:20:45.697 --> 01:20:45.817
Yes.

1375
01:20:46.097 --> 01:20:46.338
Yes.

1376
01:20:47.590 --> 01:20:56.673
Specifically, a new paper that asks one of the boldest questions in vaccine science, which is instead of building a vaccine against a specific pathogen.

1377
01:20:56.733 --> 01:20:57.613
Guys, this is crazy.

1378
01:20:58.174 --> 01:21:08.517
Instead of building a vaccine against a specific pathogen, what if you could make the lung itself a better fortress against any threat that shows up?

1379
01:21:08.897 --> 01:21:10.798
It's like in The Lord of the Rings.

1380
01:21:11.398 --> 01:21:14.759
We may have one vaccine to rule them all.

1381
01:21:14.939 --> 01:21:15.159
Yes.

1382
01:21:17.820 --> 01:21:20.240
Pathogen agnostic vaccine.

1383
01:21:20.981 --> 01:21:24.941
It's like you're not getting like a COVID vaccine and then a flu vaccine.

1384
01:21:25.021 --> 01:21:26.142
It's just one vaccine.

1385
01:21:26.882 --> 01:21:27.622
And that's it.

1386
01:21:27.662 --> 01:21:28.422
This is...

1387
01:21:29.062 --> 01:21:29.782
It's insane.

1388
01:21:29.802 --> 01:21:33.883
This one is very cool because it's a vaccine that works like no other.

1389
01:21:34.023 --> 01:21:34.203
Yes.

1390
01:21:34.603 --> 01:21:34.983
Yes.

1391
01:21:35.103 --> 01:21:35.763
I mean, it must.

1392
01:21:35.983 --> 01:21:36.304
It must.

1393
01:21:36.624 --> 01:21:42.345
And just really quick, this was published in Science in February 2026 by Stanford researchers.

1394
01:21:42.365 --> 01:21:42.805
Yeah.

1395
01:21:42.825 --> 01:21:42.985
Yeah.

1396
01:21:43.945 --> 01:21:50.907
So, you know, this is clearly a hot topic and something that requires a lot of research.

1397
01:21:51.107 --> 01:21:55.028
COVID-19 has killed 7 million people, reported at least.

1398
01:21:55.488 --> 01:21:58.129
It's probably killed a lot more that's not reported.

1399
01:21:58.509 --> 01:22:01.270
The flu kills about 500,000 people annually.

1400
01:22:01.850 --> 01:22:04.831
And we've been battling the flu ever since.

1401
01:22:05.411 --> 01:22:08.512
COVID-19 did a lot to our world.

1402
01:22:08.932 --> 01:22:11.273
And I can't believe that it was more than six years ago.

1403
01:22:12.129 --> 01:22:18.212
I will note that that was your first debut as a podcast host.

1404
01:22:18.292 --> 01:22:18.712
That's right.

1405
01:22:18.732 --> 01:22:34.340
It was six years ago on the Dark Matters podcast, co-hosted by friend of the pod, Matt Marder, who also happens to be a film writer, director, producer who has a new movie out.

1406
01:22:35.200 --> 01:22:38.302
on Amazon Prime and other streaming services, Goldmine.

1407
01:22:38.482 --> 01:22:40.043
We talked about it in our last episode.

1408
01:22:40.344 --> 01:22:41.624
I'll do a brief plug here.

1409
01:22:41.965 --> 01:22:43.446
It's absolutely worth a watch.

1410
01:22:43.846 --> 01:22:45.967
If you heard it here first, you know you have to watch it.

1411
01:22:46.288 --> 01:22:47.168
So definitely check that out.

1412
01:22:47.188 --> 01:22:51.571
Yeah, and I was the scientific advisor on that film.

1413
01:22:51.711 --> 01:22:56.034
A lot of some of the stuff that I was working on during my PhD has actually made it in there.

1414
01:22:56.514 --> 01:23:00.697
A lot of cool neuroscience, VR, very cool stuff.

1415
01:23:00.717 --> 01:23:01.518
You guys should check it out.

1416
01:23:05.489 --> 01:23:07.172
Was pretty bad six years ago, right?

1417
01:23:07.292 --> 01:23:07.493
Yes.

1418
01:23:07.914 --> 01:23:15.207
Now, what COVID-19 showed us was that our tech, when it comes to vaccines, is reactive.

1419
01:23:15.608 --> 01:23:15.748
Mm-hmm.

1420
01:23:16.069 --> 01:23:16.309
Okay?

1421
01:23:16.610 --> 01:23:17.351
It's designed...

1422
01:23:18.601 --> 01:23:22.323
such that there's a specific key or a specific lock.

1423
01:23:22.343 --> 01:23:23.884
We'll get into what that actually means.

1424
01:23:24.285 --> 01:23:29.168
But ultimately, that comes into a timeline problem, right?

1425
01:23:29.488 --> 01:23:40.535
Because even the miraculous modern speed that we had with the Moderna vaccine, which was 63 days from sequence to first human dose with the Moderna vaccine—

1426
01:23:41.477 --> 01:23:45.599
That leaves a month-long window where we are globally vulnerable.

1427
01:23:45.619 --> 01:23:45.779
Yes.

1428
01:23:46.199 --> 01:23:57.265
It would be really nice to switch from a reactive to a proactive type of, you know, what's the word I'm looking for?

1429
01:23:57.845 --> 01:24:04.528
A reactive versus a proactive type of procedure on how to tackle these problems, right?

1430
01:24:05.669 --> 01:24:07.410
This new paper that came out of Stanford...

1431
01:24:08.476 --> 01:24:10.698
It's asking a very radical question.

1432
01:24:10.798 --> 01:24:21.486
It's saying, can we train the lung itself or organs in general to broadly, durably, and be more capable of fighting off whatever shows up?

1433
01:24:21.967 --> 01:24:23.188
It doesn't matter if it's COVID.

1434
01:24:23.208 --> 01:24:24.749
It doesn't matter if it's a bacteria.

1435
01:24:25.169 --> 01:24:26.090
Not just one virus.

1436
01:24:26.130 --> 01:24:27.211
Not just one bacteria.

1437
01:24:27.551 --> 01:24:35.878
Diverse viruses, even allergens, simultaneously with a single vaccine, a single nasal spray that's going to last for months.

1438
01:24:35.978 --> 01:24:36.078
Okay.

1439
01:24:37.039 --> 01:24:40.823
The idea that it's also in the form factor of a nasal spray is crazy.

1440
01:24:40.843 --> 01:24:42.484
Yes, it's not even a jab.

1441
01:24:42.765 --> 01:24:43.725
It's not even a jab.

1442
01:24:43.806 --> 01:24:51.333
It's a nasal spray that is going to vaccinate you against, like, several different pathogens.

1443
01:24:52.834 --> 01:24:55.335
I think that's really cool to even think about.

1444
01:24:55.775 --> 01:25:01.557
And when I first heard the story, I was like, how is that even how does that even work?

1445
01:25:01.597 --> 01:25:03.197
My reaction was, I don't believe you.

1446
01:25:03.457 --> 01:25:07.699
Yes, because I sort of know how conventional vaccines work.

1447
01:25:08.179 --> 01:25:11.760
It's this lock and key mechanism that we're going to get into in a little bit.

1448
01:25:12.200 --> 01:25:13.280
It just didn't make any sense.

1449
01:25:13.300 --> 01:25:15.641
So let's get into just immunology 101.

1450
01:25:15.721 --> 01:25:18.302
Okay, let's prime ourselves with a little bit of understanding.

1451
01:25:18.402 --> 01:25:18.602
Yes.

1452
01:25:18.742 --> 01:25:20.924
There's two types of immune systems in our body.

1453
01:25:20.964 --> 01:25:25.067
There's the innate system and there's the adaptive system.

1454
01:25:25.727 --> 01:25:28.809
The innate system has to do with rapid response.

1455
01:25:28.889 --> 01:25:32.012
These are your beat cops that are on your neighborhood.

1456
01:25:33.313 --> 01:25:37.096
Not a lot of memory, okay?

1457
01:25:38.016 --> 01:25:38.857
Rapid response.

1458
01:25:38.997 --> 01:25:45.562
These macrophages, neutrophils, they recognize broad patterns and they lack long-term memory.

1459
01:25:45.862 --> 01:25:47.383
But they're very responsive.

1460
01:25:47.423 --> 01:25:48.164
They're very quick.

1461
01:25:49.038 --> 01:25:51.340
The adaptive system, these are your detectives.

1462
01:25:51.921 --> 01:25:59.268
These are your more sophisticated sort of what's the FBI crimes unit type thing, right?

1463
01:25:59.608 --> 01:26:01.970
Delayed response, days or weeks.

1464
01:26:02.411 --> 01:26:11.800
It involves T cells and B cells, but it's highly precise, and it creates specific antibodies and memory cells that will remember...

1465
01:26:12.765 --> 01:26:13.526
The pathogen.

1466
01:26:14.187 --> 01:26:22.797
And the next time that pathogen comes into your body, you no longer have to have that immune response because they'll recognize it immediately.

1467
01:26:22.997 --> 01:26:25.380
That's why we only get chicken pox once.

1468
01:26:25.440 --> 01:26:25.660
Right.

1469
01:26:25.861 --> 01:26:28.604
Or that's how the vaccines actually work.

1470
01:26:28.804 --> 01:26:29.024
Mm-hmm.

1471
01:26:29.605 --> 01:26:40.394
As a maybe crude analogy, the innate system is like infantrymen in the military that are on the front lines that get sent first and are perceived in the ranks as maybe more expensive.

1472
01:26:40.574 --> 01:26:46.940
But then the adaptive system is like special operations folks, highly, highly, highly trained, very specific.

1473
01:26:46.960 --> 01:26:49.882
You can send 20 of them and they know exactly what to do.

1474
01:26:50.082 --> 01:26:51.544
Yeah, because they have intelligence.

1475
01:26:51.624 --> 01:26:51.944
Correct.

1476
01:26:52.184 --> 01:26:52.384
Right?

1477
01:26:52.424 --> 01:26:53.125
That's the main thing.

1478
01:26:53.165 --> 01:26:54.086
They have intelligence.

1479
01:26:54.106 --> 01:26:54.266
Right.

1480
01:26:54.286 --> 01:26:54.406
Right.

1481
01:26:54.506 --> 01:26:56.167
So how do traditional vaccines work?

1482
01:26:56.467 --> 01:27:01.949
Well, traditional vaccines actually exploit this adaptive memory, this special operations thing, right?

1483
01:27:02.249 --> 01:27:05.411
What they do is you introduce a specific antigen.

1484
01:27:05.711 --> 01:27:11.433
Let's say for the COVID-19 vaccine, you introduce an mRNA blueprint.

1485
01:27:11.993 --> 01:27:19.837
That mRNA then gets transcribed into the spike protein of your COVID-19 virus.

1486
01:27:21.115 --> 01:27:35.729
The body then produces antigens to that spike protein and then remembers the shape of that spike protein such that if you were to get COVID in real life, it would recognize, hey, that's the same spike protein that I saw earlier.

1487
01:27:36.538 --> 01:27:38.839
I'm going to go ahead and neutralize this threat.

1488
01:27:39.740 --> 01:27:39.920
Right?

1489
01:27:40.540 --> 01:27:42.701
The flaw is that it is too specific.

1490
01:27:43.382 --> 01:27:46.603
It fails against rapidly mutating viruses.

1491
01:27:46.984 --> 01:27:50.446
This is why we need to get jabbed like, you know, once every two years.

1492
01:27:50.486 --> 01:27:53.947
For the flu, we have to get a shot every year.

1493
01:27:54.488 --> 01:27:59.871
The influenza virus, for example, it's covered by two primary surface proteins.

1494
01:28:00.211 --> 01:28:03.453
There's the HA, the hemagglutinin, and then there's the NA.

1495
01:28:03.593 --> 01:28:03.773
Right.

1496
01:28:04.629 --> 01:28:11.285
The HA is usually the one that actually allows the virus to bind and enter human respiratory cells.

1497
01:28:11.706 --> 01:28:14.051
So it's the primary target for the immune system.

1498
01:28:15.172 --> 01:28:28.559
And the challenge is that HA head, it undergoes constant antigenic drift, which is these tiny, subtle changes that necessitates a yearly vaccine update.

1499
01:28:28.839 --> 01:28:33.281
That's why we get a yearly vaccine for the influenza virus, right?

1500
01:28:33.561 --> 01:28:41.025
Because every year, the vaccine, the HA head, that protein, looks a tiny bit different every time.

1501
01:28:41.365 --> 01:28:44.087
And so we have to have the new vaccine in order to prime our body.

1502
01:28:44.487 --> 01:28:56.873
So just as a brief analogy, right, these viruses, you could almost imagine, they're the lock side of the analogy, and they're constantly changing the configuration of the lock, right?

1503
01:28:58.414 --> 01:29:04.457
And our immune system is trying to create a key to turn it, to make it, to defeat it.

1504
01:29:05.137 --> 01:29:10.520
But because it's constantly having the locksmith come and change the lock very, very quickly –

1505
01:29:11.160 --> 01:29:13.823
It takes us a long time to print a new key and we put it in.

1506
01:29:13.843 --> 01:29:14.323
It doesn't work.

1507
01:29:14.383 --> 01:29:14.724
Let's go.

1508
01:29:14.964 --> 01:29:23.433
And so like that delta between the, how quickly the locks on the doors are changing versus how quickly we are generating new keys to try to unlock the door.

1509
01:29:23.853 --> 01:29:30.220
Like that, the Delta between those two is part of like, if the rate of lock change is slow enough,

1510
01:29:31.316 --> 01:29:31.896
We'd be fine.

1511
01:29:31.916 --> 01:29:32.417
We'd be fine.

1512
01:29:32.757 --> 01:29:39.000
But when the rate of the lock change gets too quick, that's when we get having the need to do this on a yearly basis, as an example.

1513
01:29:39.261 --> 01:29:39.981
Yeah, exactly.

1514
01:29:40.021 --> 01:29:40.801
That's exactly right.

1515
01:29:41.142 --> 01:29:43.803
And so that's the antigenic drift, right?

1516
01:29:44.343 --> 01:29:48.206
Now, instead, what if we think about, like,

1517
01:29:49.024 --> 01:29:51.085
There's actually other types of drift, right?

1518
01:29:51.105 --> 01:29:53.366
There's something called genetic reassortment.

1519
01:29:53.946 --> 01:29:56.947
And this actually happens with the avian and human flu swap.

1520
01:29:57.347 --> 01:30:02.109
This actually happens when a human being gets avian flu and the human flu.

1521
01:30:02.509 --> 01:30:03.790
And then within our body...

1522
01:30:05.181 --> 01:30:07.302
Genetic elements get reshuffled.

1523
01:30:07.843 --> 01:30:12.986
And now you have an entirely novel HA protein on the outside of the virus.

1524
01:30:13.307 --> 01:30:16.188
This is what actually happened in 1918 with the Spanish flu.

1525
01:30:16.689 --> 01:30:23.854
You had this driver where a human being had a swapping of elements inside of

1526
01:30:24.951 --> 01:30:31.918
That created this incredibly different virus that no one had ever seen.

1527
01:30:32.258 --> 01:30:32.418
Right.

1528
01:30:32.438 --> 01:30:34.360
And that's why nobody was immune to it.

1529
01:30:34.940 --> 01:30:42.988
So we've been trying to figure out a universal vaccine that just like is it stays invariant across all of this nonsense.

1530
01:30:43.008 --> 01:30:43.128
Right.

1531
01:30:43.388 --> 01:30:43.748
Okay?

1532
01:30:43.808 --> 01:30:44.209
Right.

1533
01:30:44.829 --> 01:30:50.714
The first one that I can really think of is one that targeted conserved internal proteins.

1534
01:30:51.115 --> 01:30:52.036
Here's what I mean by that.

1535
01:30:52.116 --> 01:30:59.942
The HA, which is this protein that is, in our analogy, the lock, so to speak, it's on the very outside of the virus.

1536
01:30:59.962 --> 01:31:00.663
Right.

1537
01:31:00.763 --> 01:31:09.004
There's a little stalk that protrudes out that presents this to the outside such that the virus can actually get into our human cells.

1538
01:31:09.024 --> 01:31:09.845
Like the doorknob.

1539
01:31:10.145 --> 01:31:10.625
Exactly.

1540
01:31:11.025 --> 01:31:12.085
Yeah, yeah, kind of like that.

1541
01:31:12.145 --> 01:31:15.005
But, okay, let's continue with the analogy, right?

1542
01:31:15.025 --> 01:31:15.846
We've got the lock.

1543
01:31:16.266 --> 01:31:19.806
The lock is really the hole that the key is in.

1544
01:31:21.146 --> 01:31:30.128
What if I could make a little thing that recognizes the shape of the lock itself, like the little round that goes around the doorknob, right?

1545
01:31:30.148 --> 01:31:30.308
Yeah.

1546
01:31:30.688 --> 01:31:35.890
That's what the strategy was here with BioBionVax.

1547
01:31:36.770 --> 01:31:43.172
They made something called the M001, and what it was doing was trying to target the stock of that protein, which is highly conserved.

1548
01:31:44.232 --> 01:31:46.893
Like the doorknob versus the hole where the key goes in.

1549
01:31:46.913 --> 01:31:47.393
Exactly.

1550
01:31:47.473 --> 01:31:49.534
Like what if we just like go for the doorknob itself?

1551
01:31:49.714 --> 01:31:50.014
Yeah.

1552
01:31:50.034 --> 01:31:50.234
Okay.

1553
01:31:50.654 --> 01:31:54.796
Recombinant protein, it targeted nine conserved T-cell epitopes.

1554
01:31:55.708 --> 01:31:58.050
It went really great until phase two.

1555
01:31:58.370 --> 01:31:58.670
Okay.

1556
01:31:58.870 --> 01:32:00.571
And then phase three completely failed.

1557
01:32:01.252 --> 01:32:06.255
12,000 people October 2020 showed no significant difference in flu illness.

1558
01:32:06.476 --> 01:32:12.780
So we can't just remove the doorknob with the lock on it because the door is still...

1559
01:32:12.800 --> 01:32:14.881
Somehow the doorknob thing isn't working.

1560
01:32:14.901 --> 01:32:15.382
It isn't working.

1561
01:32:15.602 --> 01:32:15.882
Okay.

1562
01:32:16.162 --> 01:32:17.543
Somehow the doorknob thing isn't working.

1563
01:32:17.563 --> 01:32:21.086
I know I've taken us on this weird analogy path, so feel free to pivot.

1564
01:32:21.146 --> 01:32:21.366
Yeah.

1565
01:32:21.386 --> 01:32:22.427
No, no, no, no.

1566
01:32:22.467 --> 01:32:23.207
Now we're stuck, baby.

1567
01:32:23.227 --> 01:32:24.448
But let's go.

1568
01:32:25.090 --> 01:32:31.067
So somehow the idea of this invariant thing that I want to recognize is no longer working.

1569
01:32:31.127 --> 01:32:31.308
Yes.

1570
01:32:31.529 --> 01:32:31.769
So...

1571
01:32:32.813 --> 01:32:34.754
The failed autopsy is the following, right?

1572
01:32:34.774 --> 01:32:41.075
Which is that this T cell that's getting activated to recognize the doorknob, it's insufficient.

1573
01:32:41.535 --> 01:32:48.377
Because what it needs to do is it actually needs to prime the innate cells in the respiratory tissues.

1574
01:32:49.257 --> 01:32:50.758
That seems to be the problem.

1575
01:32:50.798 --> 01:32:52.098
That was the lesson that we learned.

1576
01:32:52.258 --> 01:32:54.079
The infantry, not the special ops.

1577
01:32:54.179 --> 01:32:54.399
Exactly.

1578
01:32:54.419 --> 01:32:56.799
The special ops can know, but if the infantry doesn't, it doesn't matter.

1579
01:32:56.899 --> 01:32:58.880
If the infantry don't know, then...

1580
01:32:59.700 --> 01:33:02.824
It's too late by the time that the infection actually progresses.

1581
01:33:02.984 --> 01:33:03.305
Fair, fair.

1582
01:33:03.325 --> 01:33:03.605
Okay?

1583
01:33:03.866 --> 01:33:06.849
And that's where we get into the paper that we have here.

1584
01:33:06.989 --> 01:33:07.090
Okay.

1585
01:33:07.170 --> 01:33:07.891
Out of Stanford.

1586
01:33:08.231 --> 01:33:11.936
It's by the lab of Bali Pulendran.

1587
01:33:11.956 --> 01:33:12.056
Okay.

1588
01:33:13.816 --> 01:33:15.657
Integrated organ immunity.

1589
01:33:15.958 --> 01:33:32.511
It's this idea that we need to shift from specific antigen matching to now target this T cell activation and fundamentally upgrade our system such that we can really think about a holistic approach about how the organ is actually...

1590
01:33:33.985 --> 01:33:35.727
Doing this protection, okay?

1591
01:33:36.188 --> 01:33:49.524
The protection requires continuous synergistic dialogue between your adaptive immune system, which is the special ops, and your structural cells that are in the tissue that are part of your innate system.

1592
01:33:49.979 --> 01:34:17.403
immune system i'm so mad that this perfectly maps on to basically saying we need to build the cia intelligence agency for the human body to communicate intelligence yes uh we can't have sequestered information no stove pipes yes yes we can everyone needs to talk to everyone and share intelligence that's that's ultimately what's happening that's okay so now let's get into the paper right okay how does this vaccine actually work it's an intranasal vaccine

1593
01:34:19.849 --> 01:34:23.951
So it's a spray that you put into your nose.

1594
01:34:24.011 --> 01:34:25.172
The payload is the following.

1595
01:34:25.192 --> 01:34:26.353
You've got ovalbumin.

1596
01:34:26.453 --> 01:34:27.293
This is OVA.

1597
01:34:27.593 --> 01:34:31.136
This is a model antigen that's encapsulated in...

1598
01:34:31.356 --> 01:34:34.157
This is an antigen that actually just comes out of egg whites.

1599
01:34:34.558 --> 01:34:34.798
Okay.

1600
01:34:34.858 --> 01:34:35.118
Okay?

1601
01:34:35.158 --> 01:34:37.039
So it has nothing to do with humans.

1602
01:34:37.399 --> 01:34:40.021
It's kind of just there to prime the immune system.

1603
01:34:40.121 --> 01:34:40.942
To be like, that's weird.

1604
01:34:40.962 --> 01:34:41.722
I don't know what that is.

1605
01:34:41.822 --> 01:34:41.922
Okay.

1606
01:34:41.942 --> 01:34:42.062
Okay.

1607
01:34:42.102 --> 01:34:42.343
Okay.

1608
01:34:43.423 --> 01:34:49.945
And it's encapsulated inside a liposome, which is just like a little fat globule.

1609
01:34:50.646 --> 01:34:54.287
And inside that liposome is a multifront threat.

1610
01:34:54.727 --> 01:34:59.709
You've got GLA, which is something that mimics bacterial cell walls.

1611
01:35:00.249 --> 01:35:04.211
So this is going to go after something like a toll-like receptor, TLR4-1.

1612
01:35:05.744 --> 01:35:10.966
It triggers inflammation from antiviral and bacterial immune systems.

1613
01:35:11.786 --> 01:35:20.890
And finally, it also has this 3M052LS, which is effectively like it's a molecule that targets other toll-like receptors.

1614
01:35:20.990 --> 01:35:28.593
Toll-like receptors are like these things that are on, these are receptors that are on immune systems that detect viral DNA or like...

1615
01:35:29.258 --> 01:35:31.980
other types of DNA and actually trigger immune response.

1616
01:35:32.020 --> 01:35:48.512
It's like our radar systems or any of our, our, our, our signals, intelligence systems to, to figure out if someone shoots a hypersonic missile, we have all these satellites that will like know all the heat over here changed to a, such a degree that there's some, there's a threat over here.

1617
01:35:49.012 --> 01:35:54.016
It's like identifying, listening to identify when there is a threatening coming.

1618
01:35:54.096 --> 01:35:54.317
Yeah.

1619
01:35:54.477 --> 01:35:55.217
Is that fair?

1620
01:35:55.297 --> 01:35:56.238
Yes, exactly.

1621
01:35:56.498 --> 01:36:01.602
And what's crucial about it is these two things, they're actually synthetic adjuvants.

1622
01:36:02.123 --> 01:36:02.563
Okay.

1623
01:36:02.783 --> 01:36:11.250
Adjuvants are little helpers that help the immune system but aren't actually the antigen that the immune system is trying to target.

1624
01:36:11.310 --> 01:36:11.590
I see.

1625
01:36:11.811 --> 01:36:17.836
It's sort of just priming the immune system to be on alert in some sense.

1626
01:36:17.996 --> 01:36:18.156
Okay?

1627
01:36:18.176 --> 01:36:18.276
Okay.

1628
01:36:18.836 --> 01:36:20.658
Now, let's see if this actually works.

1629
01:36:21.218 --> 01:36:26.402
And to be honest, even the lead author was like, I'm surprised that this works.

1630
01:36:26.502 --> 01:36:27.423
Okay?

1631
01:36:27.823 --> 01:36:29.044
Let's do the efficacy test.

1632
01:36:29.184 --> 01:36:29.464
Okay.

1633
01:36:30.425 --> 01:36:41.413
Turns out, four intranasal doses on vaccinated mice, and the mice were highly durable to SARS-CoV-2.

1634
01:36:41.513 --> 01:36:42.534
This is COVID-19.

1635
01:36:44.015 --> 01:36:47.537
Mouse-adapted SARS-CoV, which is the SARS virus.

1636
01:36:49.448 --> 01:36:57.814
A coronavirus that was bat-derived, a gram-positive bacteria, and another gram-negative bacteria.

1637
01:36:58.595 --> 01:37:06.200
So like five different things that had nothing to do with what I showed the immune system.

1638
01:37:06.240 --> 01:37:07.361
That's what's key.

1639
01:37:07.481 --> 01:37:14.787
Usually, for the COVID-19 vaccine to work, I need to show our immune system the spike protein from the COVID-19 virus.

1640
01:37:15.187 --> 01:37:17.629
It's going to learn that spike protein, and then it's going to...

1641
01:37:18.229 --> 01:37:18.709
Learn to recognize it.

1642
01:37:18.729 --> 01:37:21.812
You have to show the keyhole of the lock that it needs to make keys for.

1643
01:37:22.232 --> 01:37:22.552
Yeah.

1644
01:37:22.632 --> 01:37:23.072
Specifically.

1645
01:37:23.112 --> 01:37:23.333
Yeah.

1646
01:37:23.373 --> 01:37:27.435
This is literally just priming the immune system to be like, watch out.

1647
01:37:27.976 --> 01:37:36.642
And so, again, if I continue this annoying analogy, the primer is basically allowing the immune system to create several sets of keys before...

1648
01:37:37.342 --> 01:37:38.443
Cats even show up.

1649
01:37:39.163 --> 01:37:44.825
And it just so happens that because they created this preset of hundreds of thousands of keys.

1650
01:37:44.885 --> 01:37:45.126
Yeah.

1651
01:37:45.246 --> 01:37:48.207
They already, when it arrives, they can already be using those.

1652
01:37:48.287 --> 01:37:51.468
Yeah, they already know, like, what is for it.

1653
01:37:51.729 --> 01:37:51.929
Right.

1654
01:37:52.109 --> 01:37:54.510
There's a signal of, like, okay, this is interesting.

1655
01:37:55.830 --> 01:37:58.512
This is actually so good because...

1656
01:37:59.512 --> 01:38:16.526
This goes back to what we've talked about before, which is to the extent that you, instead of inserting something artificial into the body to solve the problem, if you can just instigate the body to use its existing machinery to better solve the problem, that is always the better solution.

1657
01:38:16.566 --> 01:38:16.766
Yes.

1658
01:38:17.947 --> 01:38:18.788
That's exactly right.

1659
01:38:19.369 --> 01:38:21.951
And now let's think about what is exactly happening.

1660
01:38:22.431 --> 01:38:22.851
Right.

1661
01:38:22.891 --> 01:38:26.915
Because you just introduced this very simple thing in the nasal...

1662
01:38:28.478 --> 01:38:49.700
tract and now all of a sudden it's just like working doesn't make any sense to me it's just got a huge defense system out of nowhere yeah yeah so so how is it actually working so let's talk about the lungs right the respiratory tract is a really distinct immunological zone because it's kind of like the border between the outside and the inside for the human body right um

1663
01:38:51.997 --> 01:38:55.699
There's a direct interface between the outside world and the inside world.

1664
01:38:55.799 --> 01:38:58.040
So there's its own rules of engagement.

1665
01:38:58.060 --> 01:38:58.500
That's fair.

1666
01:38:58.600 --> 01:39:05.884
It's like this is not the blood, right, where the blood is shielded by the skin and the heart and the capillaries.

1667
01:39:05.944 --> 01:39:11.506
The lung is like where the outside world is coming in and I need to get oxygen and release carbon dioxide, right?

1668
01:39:11.807 --> 01:39:13.668
So there's a lot of stuff coming in.

1669
01:39:13.708 --> 01:39:13.848
Yes.

1670
01:39:14.748 --> 01:39:16.530
The rules of engagement are different.

1671
01:39:17.030 --> 01:39:20.714
The battlefield is something like 480 million alveoli.

1672
01:39:20.834 --> 01:39:32.486
Alveoli are these compartments inside the human lung that increase surface area such that there is a transfer of oxygen and carbon dioxide from the blood to the outside world.

1673
01:39:32.947 --> 01:39:33.187
Okay?

1674
01:39:33.487 --> 01:39:35.349
This is how oxygen gets into our blood.

1675
01:39:35.369 --> 01:39:35.469
Yep.

1676
01:39:39.022 --> 01:39:44.066
Every single lung has 70 square meters of surface area, which is roughly half a tennis court.

1677
01:39:44.486 --> 01:39:50.191
So if you were to take our lungs and actually lay it out flat, that would be half a tennis court worth of surface area.

1678
01:39:50.251 --> 01:39:51.252
That's really crazy, actually.

1679
01:39:51.272 --> 01:39:51.692
That's actually.

1680
01:39:51.712 --> 01:39:52.433
I didn't know that.

1681
01:39:52.593 --> 01:39:53.033
Right?

1682
01:39:53.053 --> 01:39:54.094
That's pretty cool.

1683
01:39:54.274 --> 01:40:00.639
Now, the lung is naturally tolerogenic, meaning it tolerates a bunch of random stuff.

1684
01:40:01.279 --> 01:40:02.881
It suppresses an immune response.

1685
01:40:03.221 --> 01:40:08.285
If every time some random crap comes in and we have an immune response, that's not going to be good.

1686
01:40:08.683 --> 01:40:11.984
It has an asylum program.

1687
01:40:12.204 --> 01:40:13.925
Yeah.

1688
01:40:13.945 --> 01:40:16.166
It's not a strict border where you can't cross.

1689
01:40:16.206 --> 01:40:18.247
Yeah, because that would be completely unreasonable.

1690
01:40:18.287 --> 01:40:18.507
Right.

1691
01:40:18.527 --> 01:40:19.767
So it's like, okay, what's your case?

1692
01:40:19.967 --> 01:40:21.008
Yeah.

1693
01:40:21.128 --> 01:40:21.928
Exactly.

1694
01:40:21.948 --> 01:40:22.228
Yeah.

1695
01:40:22.628 --> 01:40:27.010
So now let's look at the cells, the immune cells that are responsible here.

1696
01:40:27.390 --> 01:40:32.052
There's tissue resident immune cells, which are the tissue resident memory T cells.

1697
01:40:32.652 --> 01:40:35.173
These are tissue resident, meaning they hang out.

1698
01:40:35.973 --> 01:40:36.574
In the lung.

1699
01:40:37.314 --> 01:40:37.574
Okay.

1700
01:40:37.914 --> 01:40:41.437
Then there are these things called the alveolar macrophages.

1701
01:40:42.277 --> 01:40:43.458
These are macrophages.

1702
01:40:43.498 --> 01:40:45.820
So there's, these are innate immune cells.

1703
01:40:45.860 --> 01:40:48.521
These are the beat cops, the infantrymen.

1704
01:40:49.482 --> 01:40:51.263
They hang out in the alveoli.

1705
01:40:51.664 --> 01:40:55.806
They were discovered by Eli Metzhinikov in the 1880s.

1706
01:40:55.906 --> 01:40:57.327
He won the Nobel Prize in 1908 for it.

1707
01:40:59.495 --> 01:41:06.419
They basically hang out in the alveoli, which are these compartments that interface between the blood and the outside world.

1708
01:41:06.499 --> 01:41:08.120
I mean, it's literally the border.

1709
01:41:08.200 --> 01:41:11.861
Yeah, they're the border cops in some sense, right?

1710
01:41:11.881 --> 01:41:12.162
Yeah, yeah.

1711
01:41:12.462 --> 01:41:17.664
And in the past, we used to believe that the memory T cells, which are our special ops.

1712
01:41:17.685 --> 01:41:18.025
Yes, yes.

1713
01:41:18.745 --> 01:41:23.090
they remain dormant until there's a specific target antigen that reappears.

1714
01:41:23.611 --> 01:41:31.280
But the data from this particular paper shows that there's actually a radically different dynamic.

1715
01:41:31.300 --> 01:41:38.168
When you put that nasal spray in, those tissue-resident memory T cells, they actually...

1716
01:41:39.371 --> 01:41:44.377
broadcast training signals to these infantrymen.

1717
01:41:44.818 --> 01:41:45.679
Interesting.

1718
01:41:45.699 --> 01:41:47.501
These alveolar macrophages.

1719
01:41:48.122 --> 01:41:54.009
So the special operations people actually have an active channel of communication that's...

1720
01:41:54.864 --> 01:41:57.505
At the beginning of the inciting incident.

1721
01:41:58.085 --> 01:42:00.466
Initially, the thought was the inciting incident happens.

1722
01:42:00.786 --> 01:42:04.527
The infantrymen, the innate immune cells respond.

1723
01:42:04.987 --> 01:42:07.348
There's no communication happening necessarily.

1724
01:42:07.928 --> 01:42:11.910
But then because they're losing the battle, then we bring in the big guns.

1725
01:42:11.970 --> 01:42:14.871
But actually what we're sort of seeing or saying here is –

1726
01:42:15.631 --> 01:42:17.612
The special ops, the adaptive immune system.

1727
01:42:17.632 --> 01:42:19.852
They get primed by that nasal spray.

1728
01:42:20.292 --> 01:42:20.512
Right.

1729
01:42:20.792 --> 01:42:33.916
And so now they, because they got primed by the nasal spray, they're already pre-sending information to the border where we have these innate immune cells to say, hey, be on alert.

1730
01:42:33.936 --> 01:42:35.396
There might be a caravan coming through.

1731
01:42:35.616 --> 01:42:35.857
Yeah.

1732
01:42:36.357 --> 01:42:40.638
And because of that, it actually makes the effective response better.

1733
01:42:40.778 --> 01:42:40.918
Yeah.

1734
01:42:40.938 --> 01:42:41.058
Yeah.

1735
01:42:44.340 --> 01:42:45.061
Let me wait.

1736
01:42:45.601 --> 01:42:49.624
And so the question is, okay, how does that dialogue actually happen?

1737
01:42:49.684 --> 01:42:50.944
That was my question.

1738
01:42:51.265 --> 01:42:51.505
Right?

1739
01:42:51.545 --> 01:42:53.226
Like, how are you talking to one another?

1740
01:42:54.247 --> 01:42:58.589
Well, the dialogue happens from something called Rank L. They actually identified what this is.

1741
01:42:58.650 --> 01:43:03.453
This is the receptor activator of nuclear factor kappa B ligand protein.

1742
01:43:03.473 --> 01:43:03.993
Okay.

1743
01:43:04.033 --> 01:43:04.253
Okay?

1744
01:43:04.613 --> 01:43:05.454
This is a protein.

1745
01:43:05.974 --> 01:43:06.255
These...

1746
01:43:07.290 --> 01:43:10.696
T-cells broadcast high levels of this protein.

1747
01:43:10.716 --> 01:43:11.498
Okay.

1748
01:43:11.518 --> 01:43:16.367
And the crucial proof was if you were to block this pathway, you were to block this protein –

1749
01:43:17.226 --> 01:43:39.053
This antibody The antibodies would completely vanish This response was completely Not there So when this was present This rank L when present The antibodies would generate and form And it's totally fine When it wasn't present You can artificially take it out Then there's basically a delayed or no response Yeah exactly

1750
01:43:39.533 --> 01:43:47.897
And so what you're actually doing effectively is you're teaching these macrophages, these infantrymen, new tricks in some sense.

1751
01:43:48.397 --> 01:43:50.778
So now the question becomes, well, how are you doing that?

1752
01:43:50.939 --> 01:43:51.139
Yes.

1753
01:43:51.279 --> 01:43:55.361
These macrophages, I thought, you know, they're kind of dumb, innate immunity.

1754
01:43:55.781 --> 01:44:04.205
How are you training them to be immune and really select certain things and like become this more effective person?

1755
01:44:05.924 --> 01:44:07.206
COP in some sense.

1756
01:44:07.566 --> 01:44:18.161
Well, it turns out that they acquire biological memory not through genetic recombination, which is what we get from the special ops, but through epigenetic reprogramming.

1757
01:44:18.641 --> 01:44:21.365
What's happening is you can imagine in epigenetics, right?

1758
01:44:21.385 --> 01:44:22.326
Yeah.

1759
01:44:23.287 --> 01:44:25.949
Your entire cellular genome is like a library.

1760
01:44:26.529 --> 01:44:30.012
All of your DNA is like a library, but it's massive.

1761
01:44:30.752 --> 01:44:36.576
And every single cell is specifically only reading certain books, right?

1762
01:44:36.696 --> 01:44:41.139
Only certain parts of the genome are actually being expressed in certain cells.

1763
01:44:41.819 --> 01:44:45.082
Now, a vast majority of these books are tightly shut.

1764
01:44:46.140 --> 01:44:47.562
through epigenetic markers.

1765
01:44:48.182 --> 01:44:57.392
And what ends up happening is there are proteins called histones that wrap around segments of DNA that they don't want the cell to look at.

1766
01:44:58.113 --> 01:45:04.700
What's happening with these particular macrophages is that level of...

1767
01:45:05.620 --> 01:45:08.903
Books being shut and open is being changed.

1768
01:45:09.223 --> 01:45:11.746
There's two types of chromatin.

1769
01:45:11.786 --> 01:45:14.168
There's heterochromatin and euchromatin.

1770
01:45:14.208 --> 01:45:15.770
Chromatin is like our DNA.

1771
01:45:16.290 --> 01:45:20.474
Heterochromatin is all of our DNA that's being packaged up so that no one can read it.

1772
01:45:20.914 --> 01:45:23.237
Euchromatin is kind of the histones are...

1773
01:45:24.445 --> 01:45:24.986
Spread out.

1774
01:45:25.527 --> 01:45:29.031
And you can actually read the DNA and make proteins out of that DNA.

1775
01:45:29.172 --> 01:45:32.336
It's like an encrypted versus a non-encrypted messaging channel.

1776
01:45:32.356 --> 01:45:33.197
That's exactly right.

1777
01:45:33.498 --> 01:45:36.902
And what they could see is that the rank L signaling...

1778
01:45:37.565 --> 01:45:43.026
was unspooling the DNA and making parts of the DNA more visible.

1779
01:45:43.426 --> 01:45:45.287
It was left out in the open.

1780
01:45:45.887 --> 01:45:50.668
In the context of a heterochromatin becoming more like a... More euchromatin.

1781
01:45:50.768 --> 01:45:51.228
Exactly.

1782
01:45:51.288 --> 01:45:55.509
And very specific parts of that DNA were becoming more accessible.

1783
01:45:55.989 --> 01:46:00.950
Meaning certain books in the libraries, which had good things in those specific books.

1784
01:46:01.291 --> 01:46:01.411
Yes.

1785
01:46:01.651 --> 01:46:03.091
Like how to identify stuff.

1786
01:46:04.291 --> 01:46:05.472
How to be a better cop.

1787
01:46:05.552 --> 01:46:07.232
That's actually fascinating.

1788
01:46:07.572 --> 01:46:07.832
Yeah.

1789
01:46:08.293 --> 01:46:09.494
Oh, man, that's really good.

1790
01:46:09.614 --> 01:46:09.874
Yeah.

1791
01:46:10.395 --> 01:46:20.104
Because you can sort of imagine, like, it kind of makes sense where it's like you don't, too much information is going to overload any system.

1792
01:46:20.664 --> 01:46:25.569
And so you have to be selective about what information is displayed to what party when.

1793
01:46:26.189 --> 01:46:28.432
And that coordination problem at the level of the body.

1794
01:46:29.586 --> 01:46:31.067
is orders of magnitude.

1795
01:46:31.307 --> 01:46:40.972
Because of the number of constituent parts and combinatorial processes that stack on top of each other, it makes my head hurt.

1796
01:46:41.132 --> 01:46:41.372
Yeah.

1797
01:46:41.872 --> 01:46:43.233
Yeah, there's too much, right?

1798
01:46:44.673 --> 01:46:51.597
And it's just pretty cool that we could get down to this level of chromatin remodeling to understand it.

1799
01:46:52.037 --> 01:46:57.460
Isn't epigenetics still something as a concept that is in its infancy...

1800
01:46:58.345 --> 01:47:01.607
Very much so, compared to like DNA, for example.

1801
01:47:01.728 --> 01:47:01.948
Yeah.

1802
01:47:02.588 --> 01:47:10.694
So I think the reason it's fascinating to me is, you know, we're continuing to chip away at the understanding.

1803
01:47:10.794 --> 01:47:12.756
And it's funny how...

1804
01:47:14.582 --> 01:47:21.187
epigenetics plays an increasingly more important role as we get deeper into the understanding of these systems.

1805
01:47:21.348 --> 01:47:22.088
Exactly, yeah.

1806
01:47:22.468 --> 01:47:29.474
And one more thing that I want to touch on with this paper is they ask the question, well, where are these cells interacting?

1807
01:47:29.894 --> 01:47:36.940
I think you're going to like this one because there's a cool mechanism about how they actually did the science and then what they actually found out.

1808
01:47:37.060 --> 01:47:37.280
Okay.

1809
01:47:37.500 --> 01:47:37.741
Okay?

1810
01:47:38.762 --> 01:47:42.625
So the question is, where are these immune responses actually happening?

1811
01:47:42.645 --> 01:47:43.025
Okay.

1812
01:47:43.337 --> 01:47:43.577
Okay?

1813
01:47:44.358 --> 01:47:56.974
So usually when you want to answer that question, what you do is you take a bunch of lung tissue, you put it into a blender, and then you run some transcriptomics, and you try to figure out what part of the genome is being read.

1814
01:47:57.574 --> 01:47:58.456
When you say a blender...

1815
01:47:58.956 --> 01:47:59.616
A literal, yeah.

1816
01:47:59.697 --> 01:47:59.917
Okay.

1817
01:48:00.097 --> 01:48:00.837
Just checking.

1818
01:48:00.977 --> 01:48:02.038
Yeah, you just mix it up.

1819
01:48:02.198 --> 01:48:02.458
Okay.

1820
01:48:02.678 --> 01:48:08.642
Then you put some transcriptomic stuff in it, which tells you, like, what part, like, what is the mRNA profile.

1821
01:48:08.842 --> 01:48:09.082
Got it.

1822
01:48:09.202 --> 01:48:09.362
Right?

1823
01:48:09.462 --> 01:48:12.084
But because it's in a blender now, you don't have any of spatial...

1824
01:48:12.284 --> 01:48:12.544
Yes.

1825
01:48:12.584 --> 01:48:14.525
You've lost all of the spatial information.

1826
01:48:14.705 --> 01:48:14.886
Yes.

1827
01:48:14.946 --> 01:48:15.146
Right?

1828
01:48:15.706 --> 01:48:16.647
What we'd want to do...

1829
01:48:17.577 --> 01:48:21.979
is try to figure out where the genes are being transcribed.

1830
01:48:22.480 --> 01:48:31.584
Like in a tissue, I take a slice of lung, let's say, from my mouse, and I want to figure out where is the immune response happening geographically.

1831
01:48:31.604 --> 01:48:31.824
Yes.

1832
01:48:32.345 --> 01:48:32.605
Okay.

1833
01:48:32.845 --> 01:48:33.045
Yes.

1834
01:48:33.245 --> 01:48:37.647
So they used a technique called phenocytor fusion.

1835
01:48:37.987 --> 01:48:42.230
It used to be formally called Codex for spatial proteomics.

1836
01:48:42.650 --> 01:48:43.310
Here's the idea.

1837
01:48:43.390 --> 01:48:43.630
Okay.

1838
01:48:43.670 --> 01:48:44.571
So normally what you do,

1839
01:48:45.859 --> 01:48:47.760
is you want to figure out where the proteins are, right?

1840
01:48:47.800 --> 01:48:49.080
Where specific proteins are.

1841
01:48:49.140 --> 01:48:54.282
So you make an antibody that is tailored to stick to that particular protein.

1842
01:48:54.882 --> 01:48:56.443
It sticks to that particular protein.

1843
01:48:56.563 --> 01:49:01.765
Each of these antibodies has a fluorescent dye on it, so it's going to glow in the dark in some sense.

1844
01:49:02.065 --> 01:49:04.026
So if we look at the...

1845
01:49:04.885 --> 01:49:09.589
Photo we have here, each of these antibodies is tagged with a fluorescent dye.

1846
01:49:09.949 --> 01:49:13.673
Each of the different colors tells us what different antibody there is.

1847
01:49:14.153 --> 01:49:14.854
And there you go.

1848
01:49:14.894 --> 01:49:19.017
You've got a geographic map of where the stuff is.

1849
01:49:19.398 --> 01:49:22.600
Now, you're limited to mostly like four or five different colors, though.

1850
01:49:23.001 --> 01:49:23.361
Okay.

1851
01:49:23.401 --> 01:49:23.581
Right?

1852
01:49:23.641 --> 01:49:25.383
Because you don't have that many dyes.

1853
01:49:25.883 --> 01:49:27.264
You don't have that many lasers.

1854
01:49:27.325 --> 01:49:27.745
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1855
01:49:28.907 --> 01:49:33.128
So what if we want to do like hundreds of different types of proteins?

1856
01:49:33.228 --> 01:49:34.448
How am I going to actually do this?

1857
01:49:34.528 --> 01:49:41.229
Well, with codex, with this phenocytolar fusion, here's what we're doing.

1858
01:49:41.629 --> 01:49:44.590
The antibody is actually not attached to a dye.

1859
01:49:45.070 --> 01:49:46.810
It's attached to a piece of DNA.

1860
01:49:47.271 --> 01:49:47.631
Okay.

1861
01:49:47.851 --> 01:49:48.111
Okay?

1862
01:49:48.691 --> 01:49:51.551
Each different type of antibody is attached to a piece of DNA.

1863
01:49:52.411 --> 01:49:54.652
Then we have another piece of DNA that...

1864
01:49:55.496 --> 01:49:58.480
that is complementary, that is attached to a die.

1865
01:49:59.321 --> 01:50:03.828
And so now you have a barcode, and you have another barcode.

1866
01:50:05.733 --> 01:50:06.474
Do you already see it?

1867
01:50:07.234 --> 01:50:08.275
It's so nice.

1868
01:50:08.635 --> 01:50:10.397
Okay, so here's what we're doing.

1869
01:50:10.917 --> 01:50:12.058
Here's what we're going to do.

1870
01:50:12.118 --> 01:50:12.479
This is good.

1871
01:50:12.519 --> 01:50:12.699
Right?

1872
01:50:13.099 --> 01:50:15.061
The antibody is attached to a DNA.

1873
01:50:15.181 --> 01:50:17.663
I have another piece of DNA that latches onto that DNA.

1874
01:50:17.683 --> 01:50:18.564
It's complementary.

1875
01:50:18.964 --> 01:50:25.149
Just the A becomes a T, C becomes a G. That attaches, and that has a bit of dye.

1876
01:50:25.789 --> 01:50:26.050
Okay?

1877
01:50:26.390 --> 01:50:34.877
So when I'm, like, looking at a Where's Waldo type book, right, and let's say I want to find all the people with red hats, Mm-hmm.

1878
01:50:35.890 --> 01:50:39.933
I have a little thing that says attach to the red hats and then I take a picture.

1879
01:50:41.475 --> 01:50:43.016
Then I wash it out.

1880
01:50:43.196 --> 01:50:45.278
And this is the next photo I think you'll see.

1881
01:50:45.338 --> 01:50:45.558
Yes.

1882
01:50:46.198 --> 01:50:46.979
This is the cycle.

1883
01:50:47.620 --> 01:50:48.220
I attach.

1884
01:50:49.541 --> 01:50:50.282
I take a photo.

1885
01:50:50.582 --> 01:50:51.282
I wash it out.

1886
01:50:51.723 --> 01:50:53.324
I attach with another barcode.

1887
01:50:53.824 --> 01:50:54.545
I take a photo.

1888
01:50:54.885 --> 01:50:57.868
The key is I can take a photo with the same color of light.

1889
01:50:58.969 --> 01:50:59.209
But...

1890
01:51:00.451 --> 01:51:07.854
Because the primer is being attached at different locations, I now have a snapshot at every given point.

1891
01:51:07.914 --> 01:51:08.414
Yes, yes.

1892
01:51:08.554 --> 01:51:12.516
And so I can expand the number of proteins that I can actually image.

1893
01:51:12.656 --> 01:51:12.856
Right.

1894
01:51:13.436 --> 01:51:18.578
Because you're no longer limited by the number of dyes and lasers you have.

1895
01:51:18.678 --> 01:51:18.918
Yeah.

1896
01:51:19.218 --> 01:51:24.480
Because the mechanism to make the connection is now this one part of DNA connected to the other part of DNA.

1897
01:51:24.841 --> 01:51:27.782
On the other side of it, it can have a whole range of stuff

1898
01:51:28.871 --> 01:51:57.081
That's very It's such a nice idea It's only in the last five years This was also developed at Stanford This is a very clever technique I have to say That's quite nice It feels non-obvious As a choice But then once you think about it You're like oh That's why I literally For those who are listening and not watching me After you almost got through the second or third sentence I almost fell out of my chair Because I immediately understood

1899
01:51:58.773 --> 01:52:01.197
Come on, it's so obvious.

1900
01:52:01.357 --> 01:52:02.499
It's so nice.

1901
01:52:02.819 --> 01:52:03.640
But it always takes one.

1902
01:52:03.720 --> 01:52:05.904
Yeah, and so here's what they found with that.

1903
01:52:05.984 --> 01:52:06.224
Okay.

1904
01:52:06.665 --> 01:52:08.648
What they actually found when they looked at these lungs...

1905
01:52:09.824 --> 01:52:14.205
They found, with spatial imaging, tertiary lymphoid structures.

1906
01:52:14.685 --> 01:52:15.285
Here's the idea.

1907
01:52:15.525 --> 01:52:23.007
Usually, when it comes to this adaptive immune response, the antigen has to go to a lymph node.

1908
01:52:23.648 --> 01:52:24.848
It's got to get integrated there.

1909
01:52:24.888 --> 01:52:27.308
The T cells has to recognize, and then it's got to come back.

1910
01:52:27.388 --> 01:52:28.309
This is going to take weeks.

1911
01:52:28.969 --> 01:52:29.209
Okay?

1912
01:52:30.169 --> 01:52:32.770
What they see in the lungs of these mice...

1913
01:52:33.670 --> 01:52:40.114
is that the immune cells are rapidly congregating and building up pop-up makeshift lymph nodes.

1914
01:52:41.055 --> 01:52:47.540
Like on the battlefield, they're doing management and creating like little, I don't know.

1915
01:52:47.740 --> 01:52:48.380
You know what I mean?

1916
01:52:48.400 --> 01:52:49.361
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1917
01:52:49.721 --> 01:52:53.183
They have these outposts at specific areas on the battlefield.

1918
01:52:53.203 --> 01:52:55.505
On the battlefield, in the lungs themselves.

1919
01:52:55.525 --> 01:52:56.386
That are relevant.

1920
01:52:56.666 --> 01:52:59.788
So you don't have to go all the way back to the lymph nodes to figure out.

1921
01:53:01.040 --> 01:53:13.133
So in this analogy, if you have a central command that houses the core intelligence pieces, what's happening is we're actually getting these satellite outposts that have –

1922
01:53:14.954 --> 01:53:32.087
localized intelligence and relevant information so that people who are nearby don't need to wait because they already have basically preloaded, not preloaded, but they already have the relevant information that those that are nearby are able to access without waiting for the signal to come back from Central Command.

1923
01:53:32.107 --> 01:53:32.307
Yeah.

1924
01:53:33.325 --> 01:53:34.486
tertiary, what was it?

1925
01:53:34.506 --> 01:53:36.427
Tertiary lymphoid structures.

1926
01:53:36.447 --> 01:53:42.370
Yeah, lymphoid is, the lymph nodes are like organ systems that coordinate the immune response.

1927
01:53:42.390 --> 01:53:43.290
Man, that's crazy.

1928
01:53:43.470 --> 01:53:47.853
And here, that organ system is now creating little tiny outposts.

1929
01:53:47.913 --> 01:53:48.473
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1930
01:53:49.474 --> 01:53:50.535
Yeah, all crazy.

1931
01:53:50.796 --> 01:53:54.600
Which, again, if we look at just like military tactics as a reference point.

1932
01:53:54.640 --> 01:53:55.622
It's like so...

1933
01:53:55.702 --> 01:53:56.563
It like maps on.

1934
01:53:56.603 --> 01:53:57.905
It maps on almost perfectly.

1935
01:53:57.945 --> 01:53:59.166
Yeah, it's kind of crazy.

1936
01:53:59.226 --> 01:54:00.668
It's kind of crazy.

1937
01:54:00.708 --> 01:54:01.949
Yeah, it is kind of crazy.

1938
01:54:02.410 --> 01:54:03.231
It is kind of crazy.

1939
01:54:04.192 --> 01:54:06.095
The one that I got really...

1940
01:54:06.575 --> 01:54:31.096
kind of excited about was the idea that it could actually like help allergies and allergy asthma because um it turns out that allergies are basically a maladaptive response to harmless allergens right it's like the immune system just kind of going ah what's going on what is going on right but um this particular vaccine it's designed to aggressively bias the immune system towards antiviral sort of

1941
01:54:32.492 --> 01:54:36.755
innate immune response rather than like, oh, I recognize something that's bad.

1942
01:54:37.355 --> 01:54:39.417
And the vaccinated mice...

1943
01:54:40.077 --> 01:54:42.899
So on the left, you see naive mice that are control.

1944
01:54:43.279 --> 01:54:51.145
In the middle, you see unvaccinated mice that are part of this HDM challenge, which is effectively you're introducing like an allergen to them.

1945
01:54:51.545 --> 01:54:54.107
You see lots of mucus buildup, right, in the middle.

1946
01:54:54.487 --> 01:54:56.408
On the right-hand side, it looks more like control.

1947
01:54:56.789 --> 01:54:58.970
It looks like I don't got a stuffy nose.

1948
01:54:59.110 --> 01:55:00.431
Yes, that's exactly right.

1949
01:55:00.651 --> 01:55:01.752
So it's actually like...

1950
01:55:03.222 --> 01:55:06.204
It's sort of calibrating that allergy response as well.

1951
01:55:06.725 --> 01:55:08.126
I mean, I think this is huge, right?

1952
01:55:08.146 --> 01:55:14.490
Because it's, first of all, it's a completely different way of trying to understand how vaccines work.

1953
01:55:14.530 --> 01:55:14.750
Right.

1954
01:55:14.970 --> 01:55:16.331
And how to implement vaccines.

1955
01:55:16.391 --> 01:55:16.572
Right.

1956
01:55:16.732 --> 01:55:16.912
Right?

1957
01:55:17.012 --> 01:55:18.793
It's no longer a lock and key mechanism.

1958
01:55:19.093 --> 01:55:21.815
It's literally just saying we're just going to prime the immune system.

1959
01:55:21.835 --> 01:55:22.016
Mm-hmm.

1960
01:55:22.856 --> 01:55:24.458
to be on high alert.

1961
01:55:25.098 --> 01:55:29.583
And for something like a pandemic that's happening in the future, it's going to happen in the future.

1962
01:55:29.623 --> 01:55:29.823
Yes.

1963
01:55:30.063 --> 01:55:31.184
Right?

1964
01:55:32.225 --> 01:55:33.286
There's a pandemic coming.

1965
01:55:35.368 --> 01:55:41.014
This can be kind of a stopgap because imagine there's a pandemic that comes out of wherever.

1966
01:55:42.255 --> 01:55:46.419
You can fly out these vaccines that don't need vaccines.

1967
01:55:47.400 --> 01:55:50.421
a sequence of whatever pathogen there is.

1968
01:55:50.761 --> 01:55:56.884
I don't need to know what COVID-19 is or what COVID, I don't know, 2027 is.

1969
01:55:57.004 --> 01:56:08.108
I can just fly out these vaccines, and whatever healthcare worker is going in there or whatever, their immune system is going to be primed for whatever random crap is coming their way.

1970
01:56:08.328 --> 01:56:08.549
Yes.

1971
01:56:09.209 --> 01:56:11.710
This is – it generalizes –

1972
01:56:12.783 --> 01:56:24.507
vaccines in a way where you can have inventory and stockpile of this generic... Again, this is an early story.

1973
01:56:24.567 --> 01:56:25.547
Very early.

1974
01:56:25.587 --> 01:56:27.127
Caveat, caveat, caveat.

1975
01:56:27.227 --> 01:56:31.369
I'm going to get into the caveats later, but I still think it's... Because it...

1976
01:56:32.749 --> 01:56:35.631
Clearly, there's mechanisms that mean that this makes sense.

1977
01:56:35.651 --> 01:56:36.911
Yes, yes, exactly.

1978
01:56:36.951 --> 01:56:37.992
That's the big thing, right?

1979
01:56:38.392 --> 01:56:41.073
Clearly, it worked in mice, which means that we're just mammals.

1980
01:56:41.573 --> 01:56:43.134
Like, maybe this might not work.

1981
01:56:43.494 --> 01:56:43.655
Right.

1982
01:56:43.675 --> 01:56:48.017
But it's a paradigm shift, I think, in how we think about...

1983
01:56:48.837 --> 01:56:49.938
Vaccines in general.

1984
01:56:49.978 --> 01:56:50.158
Yes.

1985
01:56:50.378 --> 01:56:52.779
And the idea of priming our immune system.

1986
01:56:52.839 --> 01:56:53.060
Yes.

1987
01:56:53.460 --> 01:56:54.320
In an early way.

1988
01:56:54.781 --> 01:56:55.841
I mean, it makes total sense.

1989
01:56:55.861 --> 01:57:04.106
Like if, I mean, this is maybe a bad, a bad, like if you're, if you're going to do, if your body is about to go through trauma.

1990
01:57:04.466 --> 01:57:04.707
Yeah.

1991
01:57:05.067 --> 01:57:06.488
Like, let's say you're going to run a marathon.

1992
01:57:06.508 --> 01:57:07.068
Yeah.

1993
01:57:07.148 --> 01:57:08.869
You're going to want to train before the marathon.

1994
01:57:09.550 --> 01:57:22.199
And this is sort of a means by which for us to arbitrarily activate the immune system, because it has the capability, back to what we said before, it has the capability to deal with the problem.

1995
01:57:23.270 --> 01:57:30.695
But it doesn't necessarily have enough of a running start to deal with that time gap problem we talked about earlier.

1996
01:57:30.855 --> 01:57:31.616
Yeah.

1997
01:57:31.876 --> 01:57:38.841
And if we just give it an extra little bit of a head start, its natural response will be better at taking care of the situation.

1998
01:57:38.861 --> 01:57:39.381
Exactly, yeah.

1999
01:57:39.662 --> 01:57:41.643
And I mean, there's caveats, right?

2000
01:57:41.843 --> 01:57:51.190
I think the researchers, when they go into human trials, they need to make sure that it doesn't cause these things called cytokine storms, which is this auto-inflammation.

2001
01:57:51.710 --> 01:57:56.415
where the immune system just attacks the body itself, right?

2002
01:57:56.455 --> 01:57:57.195
Gets confused.

2003
01:57:57.756 --> 01:58:00.258
I can imagine there are some problems here, right?

2004
01:58:00.318 --> 01:58:05.563
Where you're like, you've basically just put the immune system in your lung on high alert.

2005
01:58:06.184 --> 01:58:14.292
I mean, one would make the analogy that if you have a nation with a border, and then you create an overzealous...

2006
01:58:15.730 --> 01:58:18.072
like police force to respond to that.

2007
01:58:18.152 --> 01:58:18.572
Right.

2008
01:58:18.652 --> 01:58:23.235
You might start ending up shooting people inside the border.

2009
01:58:23.315 --> 01:58:23.936
Right, right.

2010
01:58:23.976 --> 01:58:27.198
When you're focused on people who are coming from outside the border.

2011
01:58:27.258 --> 01:58:27.478
Yes.

2012
01:58:27.578 --> 01:58:28.519
So as an analogy.

2013
01:58:28.539 --> 01:58:29.739
As an analogy, of course.

2014
01:58:30.100 --> 01:58:33.382
We do not want to have an overzealous situation.

2015
01:58:34.102 --> 01:58:36.085
immune system because we don't want to start shooting our own people.

2016
01:58:36.165 --> 01:58:39.651
Yes, because that would be... Everyone agrees that's bad, right?

2017
01:58:39.731 --> 01:58:40.853
We don't want our body to die.

2018
01:58:40.933 --> 01:58:44.279
We don't want our own cells to get affected.

2019
01:58:44.760 --> 01:58:45.341
We want to...

2020
01:58:46.376 --> 01:58:47.157
Get the threat.

2021
01:58:47.397 --> 01:58:47.617
Yes.

2022
01:58:47.838 --> 01:58:48.498
Yeah.

2023
01:58:48.578 --> 01:58:50.861
So that's something that's an issue, right?

2024
01:58:50.881 --> 01:58:51.522
Yeah, totally.

2025
01:58:51.542 --> 01:58:56.247
Cytokine storms, also known as... Nice.

2026
01:58:57.048 --> 01:58:59.270
We're not going to put this on Instagram because apparently...

2027
01:58:59.370 --> 01:59:02.534
Apparently people got very upset about a joke.

2028
01:59:02.634 --> 01:59:04.816
Anyways, but that's one of the...

2029
01:59:06.738 --> 01:59:07.839
You know, caveats of these.

2030
01:59:07.859 --> 01:59:08.239
That makes sense.

2031
01:59:08.259 --> 01:59:11.441
Like, the immune system is notoriously finicky.

2032
01:59:11.841 --> 01:59:12.041
Right.

2033
01:59:12.081 --> 01:59:13.242
So we don't know.

2034
01:59:13.682 --> 01:59:17.784
But at the end of the day, I think it's a lot of very cool fundamental research that's happening.

2035
01:59:18.505 --> 01:59:22.207
I think it'll be very, very interesting to see where this leads.

2036
01:59:22.447 --> 01:59:26.250
You said that I was going to like the vaccine story.

2037
01:59:26.310 --> 01:59:27.811
I think it's very cool.

2038
01:59:27.951 --> 01:59:32.174
I tend to, and apologies for those who sometimes feel like we're getting a little too deep.

2039
01:59:32.234 --> 01:59:41.121
I tend to like the stories that have a really keen fundamental insight about something that was non-obvious.

2040
01:59:41.881 --> 01:59:49.607
And required a little bit of creativity or outside of the box thinking to problem solve from an experimental design and solution perspective.

2041
01:59:49.948 --> 01:59:50.929
So that one was quite nice.

2042
01:59:50.949 --> 01:59:51.169
Yeah.

2043
01:59:51.569 --> 01:59:52.350
That one was quite nice.

2044
01:59:52.690 --> 01:59:55.652
We started off really far away.

2045
01:59:56.432 --> 01:59:58.853
And then we ended up really, really close to home.

2046
01:59:58.873 --> 01:59:59.513
Really close to home.

2047
02:00:00.733 --> 02:00:07.355
Our first story was our astrobiology story out of PNAS Nexus, Johns Hopkins University.

2048
02:00:08.056 --> 02:00:22.240
This was on our idea of understanding panspermia and the three aspects that are necessary in order for something to an organism that's life on one rock to make it to another rock.

2049
02:00:23.326 --> 02:00:31.610
One and a half of those threes was already kind of solved, but this was a new one that's now solved, which is the initial departure from the rock.

2050
02:00:31.630 --> 02:00:32.671
Getting off the planet, yeah.

2051
02:00:33.051 --> 02:00:33.871
On high impact.

2052
02:00:34.512 --> 02:00:39.554
We ended with this immunology story about the one vaccine to rule them all in a different approach.

2053
02:00:39.934 --> 02:00:44.617
Instead of going after a pathogen specifically, can we prime the pump?

2054
02:00:45.257 --> 02:00:54.586
in the immune system to just have a better, more generalized response with some interesting dynamics of understanding how adaptive and innate immune cells communicate with each other.

2055
02:00:54.626 --> 02:00:55.587
Yeah.

2056
02:00:55.867 --> 02:00:58.570
On the battlefield, several good rundown stories.

2057
02:00:59.050 --> 02:01:00.472
If you've made it to the end,

2058
02:01:01.991 --> 02:01:06.973
You are very special because you get to get a prompt for a comment of the day.

2059
02:01:07.033 --> 02:01:07.894
I want to call out.

2060
02:01:08.594 --> 02:01:11.576
I'm going to pull this up real time here because I didn't do so earlier.

2061
02:01:12.056 --> 02:01:20.180
I want to call out one of the previous comments from last week's episode, which I think there were two that were quite interesting.

2062
02:01:20.320 --> 02:01:22.181
that were one at least was quite good.

2063
02:01:22.842 --> 02:01:24.143
The second one might be okay.

2064
02:01:24.663 --> 02:01:28.405
And I think this one came right before we started recording.

2065
02:01:28.866 --> 02:01:30.487
And so please bear with me.

2066
02:01:30.567 --> 02:01:30.787
Okay.

2067
02:01:31.087 --> 02:01:31.748
Yes.

2068
02:01:32.208 --> 02:01:34.910
So two days ago, this was for our last episode.

2069
02:01:34.930 --> 02:01:40.193
We asked for come up with a better acronym for GPLD1.

2070
02:01:40.273 --> 02:01:41.114
Yeah.

2071
02:01:41.314 --> 02:01:43.876
And so one of them was garlic pepper lemon dip.

2072
02:01:43.896 --> 02:01:43.996
Yeah.

2073
02:01:44.856 --> 02:01:46.959
Um, because apparently we made someone hungry.

2074
02:01:47.660 --> 02:01:50.484
Um, so garlic pepper lemon dip sounds actually quite nice.

2075
02:01:51.105 --> 02:01:57.593
And then we had another one earlier today, which I guess may have been on YouTube because I'm not seeing it here.

2076
02:01:58.013 --> 02:02:02.139
And so this is now bad and a bad plug and I don't have it pulled up.

2077
02:02:02.479 --> 02:02:03.620
Let me pull up YouTube really quick.

2078
02:02:03.640 --> 02:02:06.081
If you listen this long, you're in it for the long haul.

2079
02:02:06.121 --> 02:02:06.921
Yeah, you're in it.

2080
02:02:06.981 --> 02:02:08.002
Just keep listening.

2081
02:02:08.022 --> 02:02:08.562
Whatever.

2082
02:02:08.582 --> 02:02:10.003
Give us a second here.

2083
02:02:10.023 --> 02:02:11.824
This is bad pre-production prep by me.

2084
02:02:12.924 --> 02:02:19.988
But I want to make sure people get their just desserts here on some of these really clever references.

2085
02:02:20.348 --> 02:02:22.009
And nope, I don't see the one.

2086
02:02:22.229 --> 02:02:23.089
All right.

2087
02:02:23.570 --> 02:02:24.210
So I failed on it.

2088
02:02:24.270 --> 02:02:27.171
But what should we have for the comment this time?

2089
02:02:28.752 --> 02:02:29.372
This was a good one.

2090
02:02:29.393 --> 02:02:30.133
Penspermia.

2091
02:02:31.715 --> 02:02:34.637
Yeah, a different definition for panspermia.

2092
02:02:34.917 --> 02:02:36.258
That's exactly what I was thinking.

2093
02:02:36.278 --> 02:02:36.378
Yeah.

2094
02:02:36.398 --> 02:02:36.879
I like that one.

2095
02:02:36.899 --> 02:02:37.619
What do you guys think?

2096
02:02:37.679 --> 02:02:38.220
I like that one.

2097
02:02:38.240 --> 02:02:38.640
Panspermia.

2098
02:02:38.680 --> 02:02:40.021
Give me another definition.

2099
02:02:40.301 --> 02:02:40.902
I like that one.

2100
02:02:41.462 --> 02:02:42.283
That is quite good.

2101
02:02:43.503 --> 02:02:44.384
I'm your host.

2102
02:02:44.424 --> 02:02:45.325
Keep it PG.

2103
02:02:45.405 --> 02:02:46.145
Yeah, please.

2104
02:02:46.606 --> 02:02:46.946
Please.

2105
02:02:46.966 --> 02:02:47.066
13.

2106
02:02:47.106 --> 02:02:47.646
PG-13.

2107
02:02:47.767 --> 02:02:48.187
13.

2108
02:02:48.867 --> 02:02:49.868
Kids can go to PG-13.

2109
02:02:49.948 --> 02:02:50.909
It's not that bad.

2110
02:02:50.929 --> 02:02:51.870
Yeah, it's not that bad.

2111
02:02:51.890 --> 02:02:52.030
Um...

2112
02:02:53.132 --> 02:03:00.820
I am your host, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

2113
02:03:01.141 --> 02:03:02.502
I'll make one last reference.

2114
02:03:02.542 --> 02:03:04.364
He's wearing a SpongeBob t-shirt today.

2115
02:03:04.384 --> 02:03:10.130
I don't know if you've heard of this music artist called Glorb, G-L-O-R-B.

2116
02:03:11.191 --> 02:03:29.898
So he took AI to voice all of the characters in SpongeBob and then dropped some of the craziest rap beef tracks like two or three years ago where it's like SpongeBob and Patrick and Sandy and Mr. Krabs and Plankton voices are rapping on trap beats.

2117
02:03:30.673 --> 02:03:34.575
And I'm not going to lie, I was actually listening to some of his tracks earlier today on the way home.

2118
02:03:35.036 --> 02:03:38.538
You need to send me some.

2119
02:03:38.558 --> 02:03:41.059
I learned English on Spongebob.

2120
02:03:41.519 --> 02:03:43.841
This music is not PG-13.

2121
02:03:44.701 --> 02:03:46.402
So parents do not.

2122
02:03:46.582 --> 02:03:47.663
It's not PG-13.

2123
02:03:48.083 --> 02:03:52.666
But the voice duplication is incredible.

2124
02:03:53.266 --> 02:03:56.788
And there's like a beef between the chum bucket and the crusty crab.

2125
02:03:56.808 --> 02:03:57.168
Okay.

2126
02:03:58.769 --> 02:04:01.694
This is no longer about science, so we will sign off here.

2127
02:04:01.734 --> 02:04:03.377
We will see you all next week.

2128
02:04:03.778 --> 02:04:06.323
This is From First Principles.
