WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.111 --> 00:00:02.073
Dark matter quantum mechanics.

2
00:00:02.594 --> 00:00:06.598
That is what we are worried about in this particular scenario.

3
00:00:07.198 --> 00:00:10.982
It's a very weird way to think about it, but it might be the case.

4
00:00:11.603 --> 00:00:18.390
So this new paper from UC San Francisco talks about links between Alzheimer's disease and exercise, but the conclusion was not...

5
00:00:18.790 --> 00:00:19.811
What I thought it would be.

6
00:00:20.091 --> 00:00:20.831
Hello, Internet.

7
00:00:20.851 --> 00:00:31.856
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury, who is today donned in his Ferrari race kit.

8
00:00:32.356 --> 00:00:34.437
We will get to that later in the rundown.

9
00:00:34.517 --> 00:00:38.038
But on this week's episode, we have two great main stories.

10
00:00:38.339 --> 00:00:45.682
We'll start off with an astrophysics story about dark matter, and we're going to follow up with a look into the latest in Alzheimer's research.

11
00:00:46.362 --> 00:00:50.063
For those of you who may be new to the show, be sure to like, share, and subscribe.

12
00:00:50.123 --> 00:00:52.524
If you want to support the show, head to our website.

13
00:00:52.544 --> 00:00:53.945
We have a great donation portal.

14
00:00:54.405 --> 00:01:02.568
And as you already know, we're going to learn about the science from the ground up today because this is From First Principles.

15
00:01:17.425 --> 00:01:23.008
So we're going to begin today with an astrophysics story about dark matter, as we mentioned.

16
00:01:23.388 --> 00:01:28.951
Specifically, scientists think they've found a really good candidate for a dark galaxy.

17
00:01:29.171 --> 00:01:42.799
This is a galaxy almost completely made up of dark matter, no normal matter, that could give us a little bit of a hint into what dark matter actually is, which continues to be an enduring mystery.

18
00:01:42.879 --> 00:01:44.820
So let's dive in.

19
00:01:45.660 --> 00:01:46.821
on what this story is about.

20
00:01:47.401 --> 00:01:54.945
Yeah, I mean, the central question that almost every cosmologist is trying to answer is what is the universe made out of?

21
00:01:55.425 --> 00:01:55.665
Okay?

22
00:01:55.965 --> 00:01:59.467
The current paradigm is something called Lambda Cold Dark Matter.

23
00:01:59.807 --> 00:02:01.909
This is the model for what our universe is.

24
00:02:02.869 --> 00:02:08.511
The normal atoms that we see are only about 5% of everything in the universe.

25
00:02:08.612 --> 00:02:14.534
It turns out that 24% of our universe is something called dark matter, which we have no idea what it is.

26
00:02:14.934 --> 00:02:20.957
All we know is that it is like matter in that it interacts with gravity, but it's not like matter in that...

27
00:02:21.657 --> 00:02:23.238
Light does not care about it.

28
00:02:23.279 --> 00:02:25.400
The electromagnetic field does not care about it.

29
00:02:25.440 --> 00:02:30.605
So it's not so much as dark as it is transparent in every sense of the word.

30
00:02:31.025 --> 00:02:34.848
Like a light beam will just go through dark matter and not interact with it at all.

31
00:02:35.088 --> 00:02:38.291
This is very weird because atoms love interacting with photons, right?

32
00:02:38.311 --> 00:02:40.033
Because they're electrically charged.

33
00:02:40.773 --> 00:02:42.514
Obviously, electromagnetism is a thing.

34
00:02:42.895 --> 00:02:49.539
And then finally, there's about 72% that is like dark energy, which we're not even going to get into this time.

35
00:02:49.780 --> 00:02:51.441
But just to set the stage, right?

36
00:02:51.481 --> 00:02:55.864
Like we only know what 5% of the matter is in our universe.

37
00:02:56.304 --> 00:02:57.365
That's pretty insane.

38
00:02:57.565 --> 00:03:00.107
Can you just repeat that really quick?

39
00:03:00.167 --> 00:03:01.688
It's like 5% normal matter.

40
00:03:01.728 --> 00:03:03.049
That's the stuff that we're made out of.

41
00:03:03.249 --> 00:03:05.111
Atoms, baryons is what it's called.

42
00:03:05.271 --> 00:03:06.432
And the stuff we can see.

43
00:03:07.132 --> 00:03:07.372
Mm-hmm.

44
00:03:07.812 --> 00:03:08.553
Yeah.

45
00:03:08.613 --> 00:03:15.675
And then 95% is stuff that we have no idea about and we're trying to figure out.

46
00:03:16.175 --> 00:03:16.415
Yeah.

47
00:03:17.575 --> 00:03:17.876
Weird.

48
00:03:18.016 --> 00:03:18.396
It's weird.

49
00:03:18.436 --> 00:03:19.276
It is quite weird.

50
00:03:19.396 --> 00:03:24.178
And what this particular story is about is something called a Candidate Dark Galaxy.

51
00:03:24.478 --> 00:03:31.360
This is the second Candidate Dark Galaxy, but it's the one that we have a lot of information on because the first one was kind of...

52
00:03:32.080 --> 00:03:39.203
You know, it's a massive dark matter halo that failed to form a population of stars.

53
00:03:39.563 --> 00:03:47.647
Hubble first identified it, and now they've worked together with the ESA Euclid Observatory that's also in space to figure out some more stuff about it.

54
00:03:47.947 --> 00:03:56.111
It's got an extreme dark matter fraction, meaning 99.9% of this galaxy is dark matter.

55
00:03:56.151 --> 00:03:56.391
Mm-hmm.

56
00:03:56.631 --> 00:04:02.372
That's way off compared to the Milky Way, which is in the 90s, 80s, 70s type of thing.

57
00:04:02.712 --> 00:04:03.893
This is really weird.

58
00:04:04.853 --> 00:04:08.634
We'd actually previously done a story on Dark Matter.

59
00:04:08.994 --> 00:04:09.334
Yes.

60
00:04:09.674 --> 00:04:09.894
Yes.

61
00:04:09.974 --> 00:04:11.354
It's something called Cloud Nine.

62
00:04:11.434 --> 00:04:11.654
Yes.

63
00:04:11.974 --> 00:04:13.935
And that had no stars.

64
00:04:14.135 --> 00:04:14.355
Yes.

65
00:04:14.455 --> 00:04:15.235
This one has a few.

66
00:04:15.635 --> 00:04:16.916
And so that was what they were.

67
00:04:16.996 --> 00:04:18.116
Is this the first relic?

68
00:04:18.556 --> 00:04:18.836
Yes.

69
00:04:18.856 --> 00:04:19.916
Which was the abbreviation.

70
00:04:21.236 --> 00:04:23.377
But this is different than Cloud Nine.

71
00:04:23.397 --> 00:04:23.497
Yes.

72
00:04:23.597 --> 00:04:25.719
Yeah, this could be a proper galaxy.

73
00:04:25.839 --> 00:04:26.119
Okay.

74
00:04:26.199 --> 00:04:28.301
And there are differences that we're going to highlight.

75
00:04:28.361 --> 00:04:29.122
Okay, perfect.

76
00:04:29.802 --> 00:04:31.724
Okay, so let's give some historical context.

77
00:04:32.284 --> 00:04:33.745
There was this guy, Fritz Vicky.

78
00:04:33.986 --> 00:04:35.126
He was at Caltech.

79
00:04:35.567 --> 00:04:43.233
He coined the term dark matter in 1933 because he observed this particular cluster called the coma cluster.

80
00:04:43.814 --> 00:04:50.239
He observed a bunch of galaxies in the coma cluster, and he figured out what the velocities of these galaxies were.

81
00:04:51.019 --> 00:04:52.340
And he figured out that...

82
00:04:53.161 --> 00:04:59.963
How fast these galaxies were moving around some central mass distribution, it didn't make any sense.

83
00:05:00.043 --> 00:05:01.723
They were moving way too fast.

84
00:05:01.803 --> 00:05:09.405
He used something called the Virial Theorem, which is a theorem in basic physics that connects kinetic energy to potential energy.

85
00:05:09.885 --> 00:05:14.506
You can apply the Virial Theorem to the solar system, for example, and everything makes sense.

86
00:05:15.046 --> 00:05:18.369
Because the farther you are out, the slower you move.

87
00:05:19.090 --> 00:05:23.834
The farther you are out, the more potential energy there is, so the less you have for kinetic energy, right?

88
00:05:24.475 --> 00:05:27.918
When he applied it to the coma cluster, those observations didn't make any sense.

89
00:05:28.218 --> 00:05:32.222
There was way more potential energy from gravity than what he saw.

90
00:05:32.862 --> 00:05:39.768
And so he said there's got to be some dark matter there that we can't see that is providing the gravitational potential energy.

91
00:05:40.429 --> 00:05:44.551
There has to be a source for the pole that creates these orbitals.

92
00:05:44.611 --> 00:05:44.852
Yes.

93
00:05:45.212 --> 00:05:49.034
And normally we can see where the source of the gravity is.

94
00:05:49.074 --> 00:05:50.435
Yeah, normally it's stars, right?

95
00:05:50.495 --> 00:05:51.235
And it'll be bright.

96
00:05:51.375 --> 00:05:52.536
And you can't miss it.

97
00:05:52.636 --> 00:05:52.836
Yeah.

98
00:05:53.436 --> 00:05:58.359
So the thing that's weird about this is we're looking, things are moving very fast.

99
00:05:58.399 --> 00:05:58.959
Very fast.

100
00:05:59.340 --> 00:06:02.822
But the thing we can see that would drive that movement is...

101
00:06:03.960 --> 00:06:08.742
is not large enough to explain why they're moving so quickly.

102
00:06:08.822 --> 00:06:21.587
Yeah, and so there's got to be some stuff there that acts like matter in that it's gravitationally bound and it creates a gravitational potential, gravitational force, but it doesn't act like matter in the sense that there's, like, no light coming out of it.

103
00:06:21.607 --> 00:06:21.827
Right.

104
00:06:22.127 --> 00:06:23.548
Okay, and that's what's weird.

105
00:06:23.688 --> 00:06:24.388
There were other...

106
00:06:25.028 --> 00:06:25.688
observations.

107
00:06:25.768 --> 00:06:32.292
Vera Rubin very famously solidified the concept in the 1970s with galaxy rotation curves.

108
00:06:32.332 --> 00:06:37.274
What you can do is figure out how fast stars are moving around a galaxy.

109
00:06:37.755 --> 00:06:40.016
And what you expect is something like the solar system.

110
00:06:40.156 --> 00:06:46.179
Again, the farther you are out, the smaller your velocity, the slower you should be going.

111
00:06:46.459 --> 00:06:51.361
That's why a year on Jupiter is like 15 years, because it takes 15 years to go around the sun.

112
00:06:51.602 --> 00:06:54.343
That's not just because the orbit is bigger.

113
00:06:54.603 --> 00:06:55.663
like the circle is bigger.

114
00:06:55.683 --> 00:06:57.484
It's also that it's moving slower.

115
00:06:57.544 --> 00:06:58.684
It shouldn't be that long.

116
00:06:58.904 --> 00:06:59.844
But it's moving slower.

117
00:06:59.884 --> 00:07:00.905
That's why it's that long.

118
00:07:00.945 --> 00:07:03.965
If it was moving as fast as the Earth, it would be like five years or three years.

119
00:07:04.326 --> 00:07:08.447
And this is a similar graphic we talked about in our Veriruban deep dive.

120
00:07:08.987 --> 00:07:18.029
We're looking at a graph now where we see the expected path for the visible disk sort of dissipating on the X axis.

121
00:07:18.089 --> 00:07:20.790
Yeah, and that would be like if it was normal.

122
00:07:21.111 --> 00:07:26.153
The farther I get away from the galaxy, the slower I should be moving.

123
00:07:26.513 --> 00:07:35.018
What we actually see using Starlight and the hydrogen's 21-centimeter line, 1420 megahertz, is that actually you're just getting faster.

124
00:07:35.258 --> 00:07:39.940
So there's a bunch of invisible matter that is pulling on you that we have no idea how to see.

125
00:07:40.221 --> 00:07:40.501
Okay?

126
00:07:41.375 --> 00:07:44.296
So the question is, what is going on?

127
00:07:44.717 --> 00:07:46.057
What is this dark matter?

128
00:07:46.397 --> 00:07:49.199
Well, the more and more observations we did, the better we got.

129
00:07:49.259 --> 00:07:54.461
In the 1980s, people discovered something called low surface brightness objects.

130
00:07:54.862 --> 00:08:00.064
These became known later on in 2015 as ultra-diffuse galaxies.

131
00:08:00.344 --> 00:08:06.007
In 2015, we made a discovery using something called the Dragonfly Telephoto Array.

132
00:08:06.327 --> 00:08:10.808
Okay, this is a new array that was built by Yale and the University of Toronto.

133
00:08:11.308 --> 00:08:12.708
It's very cool, actually.

134
00:08:13.088 --> 00:08:14.809
You as a camera guy, you're going to love this.

135
00:08:14.869 --> 00:08:18.049
So each of these lenses, so it's in a honeycomb structure, right?

136
00:08:18.489 --> 00:08:22.270
And it's called Dragonfly because the Dragonfly eye very much looks like this.

137
00:08:22.330 --> 00:08:24.030
It's a bunch of like honeycomb lenses.

138
00:08:24.831 --> 00:08:29.171
Each of these lenses is just the off-the-shelf Canon 400mm f2.8 lens.

139
00:08:29.212 --> 00:08:29.432
Really?

140
00:08:29.452 --> 00:08:29.632
Yeah.

141
00:08:31.912 --> 00:08:33.333
It's just no way.

142
00:08:33.433 --> 00:08:42.400
It's there's they just they just bought a bunch of them, put them in a hexagonal array, and then they're compiling the light together to create these images.

143
00:08:42.781 --> 00:08:44.162
That's actually incredible.

144
00:08:44.242 --> 00:08:44.402
Right.

145
00:08:44.442 --> 00:08:46.323
This is something you can get like on Amazon.

146
00:08:46.363 --> 00:08:46.824
Yeah.

147
00:08:46.844 --> 00:08:48.265
But they put a bunch of them together.

148
00:08:48.325 --> 00:08:49.706
Now, the question is, why would you do this?

149
00:08:49.766 --> 00:08:49.986
Right.

150
00:08:50.006 --> 00:08:50.366
Yeah.

151
00:08:50.386 --> 00:08:50.667
Yeah.

152
00:08:51.633 --> 00:09:04.058
Traditionally, you never want to use lenses because the bigger the lens is, one thing you get is aberration, which is the idea that the bigger the lens is, the weight of the lens is going to deform the lens.

153
00:09:04.078 --> 00:09:04.298
Yes.

154
00:09:04.558 --> 00:09:04.718
Right?

155
00:09:04.738 --> 00:09:07.619
Because glass is not like completely metal.

156
00:09:07.799 --> 00:09:08.019
Yes.

157
00:09:08.079 --> 00:09:09.820
So there's some fluid property to it.

158
00:09:10.140 --> 00:09:15.422
So the larger you make the glass lens, it's going to sort of like deform because of the weight of its own lens.

159
00:09:16.167 --> 00:09:41.560
gravity or the other way around and so you're going to get image distortion that way right but what these guys did was a bunch of small lenses put together now what is the advantage now the advantage is for mirrors right if you have a mirror lens which is what modern telescopes all use they all use mirrors the light has to come down and then has to get set back up because it's a mirror so it's going to bounce up and there's a secondary mirror that's going to

160
00:09:41.720 --> 00:09:43.762
That then bounces the light back to a detector.

161
00:09:43.842 --> 00:09:45.863
Usually it's like Warrington in some way or something.

162
00:09:46.143 --> 00:09:49.165
But at the end of the day, you need a secondary mirror.

163
00:09:50.226 --> 00:09:53.529
And that mirror needs to be held up by some kind of scaffolding.

164
00:09:53.929 --> 00:09:56.791
In the James Webb Space Telescope, it's hexagonal scaffolding.

165
00:09:57.211 --> 00:10:02.135
In the Hubble Space Telescope, it's diamond-shaped scaffolding, like in a square 90 degrees.

166
00:10:02.555 --> 00:10:05.978
Which is why when we see the images that these telescopes produce...

167
00:10:07.122 --> 00:10:14.966
The mirror structure or the architecture actually dictates – for example, I remember when James Webb first came out.

168
00:10:15.486 --> 00:10:20.488
Certain objects had a certain star pattern or like a certain visual representation.

169
00:10:20.568 --> 00:10:22.629
There's little like spikes.

170
00:10:22.709 --> 00:10:22.929
Yes.

171
00:10:23.249 --> 00:10:28.692
That was different than Hubble, which is because of this diagonal versus hexagonal structure.

172
00:10:28.712 --> 00:10:30.393
Yeah, and those are called diffraction spikes.

173
00:10:30.813 --> 00:10:33.934
It happens because of scattered light from that scaffolding.

174
00:10:34.034 --> 00:10:34.234
Yes.

175
00:10:34.434 --> 00:10:40.777
Well, if you want to image really, really diffuse things, that becomes a really big problem.

176
00:10:40.897 --> 00:10:42.358
When you say diffuse, what do you mean?

177
00:10:42.478 --> 00:10:44.198
Diffuse by really dim.

178
00:10:44.539 --> 00:10:45.119
Okay, really dim.

179
00:10:45.139 --> 00:10:46.239
Like not a lot of light.

180
00:10:46.299 --> 00:10:46.559
Got it.

181
00:10:46.719 --> 00:10:52.222
As in like so little light that we're pushing the sensitivity of the...

182
00:10:53.142 --> 00:10:59.925
CCD, the actual charge couple device, the thing that is collecting the light and turning it into an electrical signal.

183
00:11:00.025 --> 00:11:00.205
Yes.

184
00:11:00.225 --> 00:11:00.365
Right.

185
00:11:00.425 --> 00:11:03.046
There's a bunch of silicon at the end of your detector.

186
00:11:03.427 --> 00:11:05.167
That's what makes up a charge couple device.

187
00:11:05.507 --> 00:11:08.569
And when the photon hits that silicon, it releases an electron.

188
00:11:08.849 --> 00:11:10.950
And then you're like, oh, I got a little photon from there.

189
00:11:11.170 --> 00:11:11.530
Right.

190
00:11:11.970 --> 00:11:15.672
If you're if you're imaging really diffuse things, even that.

191
00:11:16.312 --> 00:11:19.896
The scaffolding, the scattering from that scaffolding is going to be a problem.

192
00:11:20.316 --> 00:11:21.818
So that's why you want to use lenses.

193
00:11:22.098 --> 00:11:27.643
But you can't use big lenses because of the aberration, like the deformation problem.

194
00:11:27.924 --> 00:11:32.168
So what if these guys just figured from the Dragonfly telephoto array, what if we just use a bunch?

195
00:11:32.348 --> 00:11:32.548
Yes.

196
00:11:32.568 --> 00:11:32.748
Right?

197
00:11:32.768 --> 00:11:35.371
Like we use like 20 or 30 small lenses.

198
00:11:35.451 --> 00:11:36.092
And the compiler.

199
00:11:36.112 --> 00:11:37.253
And we compile them together.

200
00:11:37.533 --> 00:11:59.854
okay that makes sense and it's it was like relatively cheap i can imagine right because you're not like making custom made lenses this is just canon 400 millimeter f 2.8 that you put together calling up carl zeiss we need a custom giant 13 meter yeah and he's like uh how about 10 million dollars like no so so this was this was a really cool thing and in 2015

201
00:12:01.075 --> 00:12:05.096
They came out with these extreme ultra-diffuse galaxies.

202
00:12:05.156 --> 00:12:07.197
Dragonfly 44 is an example.

203
00:12:07.797 --> 00:12:08.737
This is a galaxy.

204
00:12:08.777 --> 00:12:11.198
You can see the faint fuzz in the middle.

205
00:12:11.278 --> 00:12:11.498
Yes.

206
00:12:11.878 --> 00:12:12.779
Not a lot of stars.

207
00:12:12.899 --> 00:12:13.119
Yes.

208
00:12:13.399 --> 00:12:27.283
And from what we can tell from how these things are moving around, when you do spectroscopy and you figure out the Doppler shift, so you figure out how much is the red shift in this direction, the blue shift in this direction, from there we can figure out how fast these things are moving around.

209
00:12:27.443 --> 00:12:27.523
Yep.

210
00:12:27.903 --> 00:12:30.486
And then you back calculate how big does the galaxy have to be.

211
00:12:30.906 --> 00:12:32.328
It's like dark matter dominated.

212
00:12:32.468 --> 00:12:34.410
90% of it is dark matter.

213
00:12:34.450 --> 00:12:35.831
95% of it is dark matter.

214
00:12:36.051 --> 00:12:40.496
So it's this ultra diffuse galaxy that seems to have a lot of dark matter.

215
00:12:40.896 --> 00:12:41.116
Okay.

216
00:12:41.356 --> 00:12:46.882
It's been hard to catch before because usually with normal telescopes, the scattering takes that away.

217
00:12:47.202 --> 00:12:48.063
But now with this new...

218
00:12:48.103 --> 00:13:11.358
new dragonfly telephoto we can start imaging really diffuse structures that that makes it so the the point is with the normal structure uh we need bright objects for it to work well um and these sort of dark matter galaxies where it's predominantly this this thing we don't understand as that does not interact with light it becomes very difficult to see it or to to

219
00:13:11.558 --> 00:13:12.499
image it, I should say.

220
00:13:12.699 --> 00:13:13.499
Yeah, to image it.

221
00:13:13.519 --> 00:13:14.059
To image it.

222
00:13:14.620 --> 00:13:20.663
But with this lens based architecture, it lowers it increases the signal to noise.

223
00:13:20.743 --> 00:13:21.003
Yes.

224
00:13:21.523 --> 00:13:24.004
Such that we can at least get something.

225
00:13:24.144 --> 00:13:25.425
Something, yeah, exactly.

226
00:13:25.505 --> 00:13:27.186
And then this particular paper

227
00:13:28.523 --> 00:13:29.984
is Candidate Dark Galaxy 2.

228
00:13:30.144 --> 00:13:33.907
It is taking these ultra-diffuse galaxies to a whole new level.

229
00:13:33.927 --> 00:13:34.347
Okay.

230
00:13:34.447 --> 00:13:41.772
It's pushing that diffuse into now dark, because now we're getting 99.9% dark matter.

231
00:13:42.252 --> 00:13:42.532
Okay?

232
00:13:43.072 --> 00:13:44.653
And that's really crazy.

233
00:13:44.673 --> 00:13:45.254
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

234
00:13:45.274 --> 00:13:45.414
Okay?

235
00:13:45.434 --> 00:13:45.754
Yeah, yeah.

236
00:13:46.094 --> 00:13:47.976
So why do we even care, right?

237
00:13:47.996 --> 00:13:54.460
This intensive hunt for something like a Candidate Dark Galaxy, it's motivated by two crises that...

238
00:13:55.140 --> 00:13:59.302
that are in the center of this cosmological model that we called Lambda CDM.

239
00:13:59.602 --> 00:14:05.225
You know that thing I told you before about 5% normal matter, 25% dark matter, the rest being dark energy?

240
00:14:05.245 --> 00:14:06.165
I think it was this one, yes.

241
00:14:06.225 --> 00:14:06.925
Yeah, exactly.

242
00:14:07.326 --> 00:14:09.286
So this is the model that we have today.

243
00:14:09.507 --> 00:14:09.687
Yes.

244
00:14:09.847 --> 00:14:10.327
Now, fine.

245
00:14:10.967 --> 00:14:12.508
If that is the model, right?

246
00:14:12.568 --> 00:14:12.708
Right.

247
00:14:12.728 --> 00:14:14.889
There should be consequences of that model.

248
00:14:14.929 --> 00:14:15.109
Yes.

249
00:14:15.249 --> 00:14:18.631
There are certain consequences of the model that we do not see.

250
00:14:19.715 --> 00:14:21.837
The point being we have an understanding of the universe.

251
00:14:21.917 --> 00:14:22.137
Yeah.

252
00:14:22.337 --> 00:14:23.799
And we're like, this is our best guess.

253
00:14:24.159 --> 00:14:28.342
And then there's always people who are like, but that doesn't really make sense for these two reasons.

254
00:14:28.503 --> 00:14:29.944
Got it.

255
00:14:30.344 --> 00:14:31.125
It doesn't compute.

256
00:14:31.265 --> 00:14:32.106
Yeah, it doesn't compute.

257
00:14:32.166 --> 00:14:34.928
And these are the two things specifically that do not compute.

258
00:14:34.948 --> 00:14:37.570
The first one is the missing satellite problem.

259
00:14:37.750 --> 00:14:37.870
Okay.

260
00:14:37.890 --> 00:14:38.071
Okay.

261
00:14:38.820 --> 00:14:50.191
These dark matter simulations, when you use that original 5% normal matter, 25% dark matter, blah, blah, blah, you press play on a universe, you set it up in the computer and you press play.

262
00:14:50.531 --> 00:14:59.359
Simulations predict that there should be about 500 orbiting dark matter subhalos around something that is the size of the Milky Way.

263
00:14:59.379 --> 00:14:59.720
Okay.

264
00:14:59.740 --> 00:14:59.920
Okay.

265
00:15:00.240 --> 00:15:06.842
The idea is for every big halo of dark matter condensing, right, dark matter is still gravitationally bound.

266
00:15:07.202 --> 00:15:08.843
So the universe is expanding.

267
00:15:08.943 --> 00:15:10.003
There's a bunch of dark matter.

268
00:15:10.223 --> 00:15:14.484
There's going to be tiny fluctuations where there's a little bit more matter here, a little less matter here.

269
00:15:14.824 --> 00:15:19.806
And so it's going to start clumping because gravity is going to take that over-dense region is what we call it.

270
00:15:19.886 --> 00:15:21.246
And we're going to start clumping that way.

271
00:15:21.506 --> 00:15:24.207
Now, around those big clumps, there's going to be smaller clumps.

272
00:15:24.607 --> 00:15:27.128
Around those smaller clumps, there's going to be even smaller clumps.

273
00:15:27.408 --> 00:15:28.729
There's like a power law structure.

274
00:15:30.129 --> 00:15:35.090
What we expect is there should be a lot more small clumps than what we see.

275
00:15:35.490 --> 00:15:35.810
Right.

276
00:15:35.830 --> 00:15:38.251
That is the missing satellite problem.

277
00:15:38.311 --> 00:15:40.092
We see a couple big clumps.

278
00:15:40.552 --> 00:15:40.792
Yeah.

279
00:15:40.872 --> 00:15:45.253
But the cascading second and third order clumps we should be seeing are not present.

280
00:15:45.333 --> 00:15:45.733
Exactly.

281
00:15:45.773 --> 00:15:47.013
And that's what we're seeing over here.

282
00:15:47.113 --> 00:15:48.174
Okay.

283
00:15:48.974 --> 00:15:52.335
The triangles with the error bars, that's observation.

284
00:15:52.555 --> 00:15:52.795
Yes.

285
00:15:52.915 --> 00:15:54.195
The lines are theory.

286
00:15:54.575 --> 00:15:57.536
And you can see that for larger...

287
00:15:59.266 --> 00:16:00.287
Increasing mass.

288
00:16:00.427 --> 00:16:01.027
We're fine.

289
00:16:01.507 --> 00:16:05.069
So when the mass increases, the observation matches the theory.

290
00:16:05.129 --> 00:16:09.612
Yes, but for these smaller clubs, these satellite galaxies, there's a massive discrepancy.

291
00:16:10.152 --> 00:16:11.373
Orders of magnitude.

292
00:16:11.533 --> 00:16:18.777
Because of the power law, we should be seeing significantly more smaller dark matter clusters or halos.

293
00:16:19.417 --> 00:16:36.448
Than the large ones But the rate of increase of the number From observation Is very like the increase It's quite low There's like a point where it's just like We just see way too few So the question is Maybe these smallest halos are present But they're completely dark

294
00:16:36.928 --> 00:16:37.888
Which is why you don't see them.

295
00:16:37.928 --> 00:16:39.909
There's no stars, so what are you going to see?

296
00:16:40.029 --> 00:16:43.470
It's a bunch of Cloud 9s from our starless Dark Matter cloud story.

297
00:16:43.630 --> 00:16:44.050
Exactly.

298
00:16:44.090 --> 00:16:49.972
And so Cloud 9 was trying to solve the similar problem, and this is kind of solving that similar problem, too, if this is truly there, right?

299
00:16:50.152 --> 00:16:50.432
Okay.

300
00:16:50.592 --> 00:16:54.373
Now, the second, and this is something that Cloud 9 was not doing, so this is novel.

301
00:16:54.853 --> 00:16:55.074
Okay.

302
00:16:55.494 --> 00:16:57.694
It's called the cusp core problem.

303
00:16:57.914 --> 00:16:58.094
Okay.

304
00:16:58.114 --> 00:16:58.675
Here's the idea.

305
00:16:58.735 --> 00:17:02.856
Dark matter does not interact electromagnetically, right?

306
00:17:02.976 --> 00:17:03.196
Right.

307
00:17:03.216 --> 00:17:06.761
There's no, like, you know, electrons, they want to move away from each other.

308
00:17:07.602 --> 00:17:09.585
And protons want to move away from each other.

309
00:17:09.706 --> 00:17:12.550
Even when we have atoms, these atoms, you can't just compact them.

310
00:17:13.151 --> 00:17:17.858
But if you have a particle like dark matter that is only interacting with gravity...

311
00:17:18.418 --> 00:17:27.286
That means that the closer you get to the center of the gravitational potential, the density should just get higher and higher and higher because gravity is just clumping everything together.

312
00:17:27.526 --> 00:17:29.108
There's nothing that's pushing out.

313
00:17:29.328 --> 00:17:29.488
Right.

314
00:17:29.508 --> 00:17:34.192
Like when we think about like hydrostatic equilibrium and things like that, but there's nothing pushing out.

315
00:17:34.332 --> 00:17:34.493
Right.

316
00:17:34.513 --> 00:17:39.137
So the closer you get to the center, the density of dark matter should be higher and higher.

317
00:17:39.197 --> 00:17:40.358
That is not what we see.

318
00:17:40.478 --> 00:17:40.798
Interesting.

319
00:17:40.818 --> 00:17:42.620
We see instead of a cusp.

320
00:17:42.960 --> 00:17:45.161
which would mean in the center we get like a little pointy.

321
00:17:45.321 --> 00:17:45.682
Yeah.

322
00:17:45.862 --> 00:17:52.326
We get a core type where it's like at the center, the dark matter density sort of flattens out.

323
00:17:52.586 --> 00:17:53.106
That's weird.

324
00:17:53.146 --> 00:17:53.766
That is weird.

325
00:17:53.907 --> 00:17:57.529
If dark matter is purely gravitational, why would it just...

326
00:17:58.029 --> 00:17:58.950
flatten out.

327
00:17:59.110 --> 00:18:00.191
It should be continuing.

328
00:18:00.211 --> 00:18:03.634
It should continue to get bigger and bigger as it gets closer and closer to the center.

329
00:18:03.654 --> 00:18:05.456
The density should be higher and higher.

330
00:18:05.476 --> 00:18:06.657
That's not what we're seeing.

331
00:18:06.957 --> 00:18:15.486
Now, okay, the defense that the Lambda CDM people make, like the guys who make the cosmology model and they're drinking the Kool-Aid, right?

332
00:18:15.686 --> 00:18:18.388
They're like, no, there's something called baryonic feedback.

333
00:18:18.468 --> 00:18:20.931
This is the idea that towards the center of the

334
00:18:22.332 --> 00:18:24.554
galaxy, there's a bunch of supernova explosions.

335
00:18:24.854 --> 00:18:25.095
Okay.

336
00:18:25.135 --> 00:18:25.375
Okay?

337
00:18:25.615 --> 00:18:29.859
And that supernova explosion is going to send shockwaves in space-time.

338
00:18:30.339 --> 00:18:33.722
And those shockwaves are sort of going to diffuse the center of that galaxy.

339
00:18:34.023 --> 00:18:37.265
So even though the normal dark matter would create a cusp, right?

340
00:18:37.486 --> 00:18:43.271
Because there's so many explosions happening in the center of the galaxy, that's going to sort of flatten out, right?

341
00:18:43.551 --> 00:18:44.232
Kind of makes sense.

342
00:18:44.252 --> 00:18:44.432
Okay.

343
00:18:44.452 --> 00:18:44.552
Okay.

344
00:18:44.712 --> 00:18:44.892
Right?

345
00:18:44.952 --> 00:18:45.513
That could work.

346
00:18:45.753 --> 00:18:46.073
Okay.

347
00:18:46.153 --> 00:18:48.715
But this is why this particular galaxy is significant.

348
00:18:48.735 --> 00:18:50.157
This galaxy has no stars.

349
00:18:50.557 --> 00:18:51.738
Basically no stars.

350
00:18:52.559 --> 00:18:54.220
So there's no supernova explosions.

351
00:18:54.260 --> 00:18:54.761
Right, right.

352
00:18:54.821 --> 00:18:55.021
Right?

353
00:18:55.061 --> 00:18:57.183
Which means that this should definitely have a cusp.

354
00:18:57.983 --> 00:18:58.103
I see.

355
00:18:58.123 --> 00:19:00.065
That is why it is worth studying.

356
00:19:00.245 --> 00:19:11.615
So the CDG2, it's interesting because... Yeah, and by the way, CDG2, CDG means Candidate Dark Galaxy for those... Oh, okay.

357
00:19:12.785 --> 00:19:16.307
No, my Siri is trying to figure out what a CDG is.

358
00:19:16.367 --> 00:19:19.828
One of the intelligence agencies is apparently trying to hack our phones at the moment.

359
00:19:19.848 --> 00:19:20.889
Sorry about that, guys.

360
00:19:21.209 --> 00:19:22.130
But this is interesting.

361
00:19:22.150 --> 00:19:30.194
So there's currently a cosmological model of normal matter, dark matter, and dark energy.

362
00:19:30.214 --> 00:19:31.994
Like, what is the composition of the universe?

363
00:19:32.014 --> 00:19:32.235
Yeah.

364
00:19:32.855 --> 00:19:38.618
That model has two problems that we just talked about, the missing satellite problem and the cusp core problem.

365
00:19:38.638 --> 00:19:38.778
Mm-hmm.

366
00:19:39.761 --> 00:19:51.351
The folks who are in defense of this Lambda CDM believe that supernova explosions is the reason that we don't see a cusp.

367
00:19:51.471 --> 00:19:54.633
Yeah, it's sort of like blurring stuff out.

368
00:19:54.653 --> 00:19:55.254
It moves around.

369
00:19:55.274 --> 00:19:59.337
It moves around rather than aggregating it, let's say, for example, right?

370
00:19:59.717 --> 00:20:04.741
The problem is, observationally, we've now seen something, which is the CDG-2.

371
00:20:06.093 --> 00:20:10.934
That has a very few amount of stars, which means very few amount of no supernova explosions.

372
00:20:10.954 --> 00:20:12.435
Yeah, no one's dying because no one's alive.

373
00:20:12.655 --> 00:20:13.835
So how do you...

374
00:20:14.015 --> 00:20:14.675
So, no.

375
00:20:15.075 --> 00:20:16.276
Yeah.

376
00:20:16.296 --> 00:20:21.057
So this galaxy can now offer a test to your Lambda CDM.

377
00:20:21.457 --> 00:20:27.039
And this is actually an interesting point about understanding the intersection between theoretical sciences and experimental sciences.

378
00:20:27.079 --> 00:20:27.299
Yeah.

379
00:20:27.539 --> 00:20:31.020
And the experimentals are constantly in the real world looking for...

380
00:20:32.000 --> 00:20:33.481
ways to test.

381
00:20:34.022 --> 00:20:38.685
You need some sort of stability, blah, blah, blah, like something that can be consistently measured.

382
00:20:39.665 --> 00:20:41.146
And we have something now.

383
00:20:41.166 --> 00:20:42.767
Yes, we finally found something.

384
00:20:42.967 --> 00:20:47.711
And we haven't done spectroscopic analysis because we just found it.

385
00:20:48.631 --> 00:20:49.772
That's why it's interesting.

386
00:20:49.812 --> 00:20:52.834
Because now we can get time on the James Webb.

387
00:20:52.854 --> 00:21:00.079
We can get time on the Subaru or the giant Magellan that's going to come up and be like, I want you to stare at that thing for like three days straight.

388
00:21:00.339 --> 00:21:06.086
And I just want to quickly note, you know, because getting time on these instruments is everyone.

389
00:21:06.326 --> 00:21:07.207
There's very few of them.

390
00:21:07.788 --> 00:21:10.571
Everyone thinks their thing that they're studying is the most important thing in the world.

391
00:21:11.332 --> 00:21:15.296
But this seems to be because of the importance of dark matter generally as a concept.

392
00:21:15.316 --> 00:21:15.516
Yeah.

393
00:21:16.277 --> 00:21:19.760
A good candidate to be able to, quote, skip the line.

394
00:21:19.860 --> 00:21:20.080
Yes.

395
00:21:20.360 --> 00:21:20.620
Okay.

396
00:21:21.001 --> 00:21:21.441
Exactly.

397
00:21:21.781 --> 00:21:24.883
And so I want to make a case for why this is important.

398
00:21:25.003 --> 00:21:25.184
Okay.

399
00:21:25.204 --> 00:21:25.344
Right?

400
00:21:25.384 --> 00:21:28.946
And that's what these people did in this particular paper.

401
00:21:29.346 --> 00:21:29.547
Right?

402
00:21:29.827 --> 00:21:32.629
The challenge is how do you defeat Sky Glow?

403
00:21:32.969 --> 00:21:37.592
Sky glow being dark galaxies, these types of dark galaxies that, I mean, there's no stars.

404
00:21:37.632 --> 00:21:38.713
So what are you going to look at, right?

405
00:21:38.733 --> 00:21:39.433
They're super faint.

406
00:21:39.453 --> 00:21:49.560
The signal is often so faint that there's a statistical noise limit when it comes to like your CCD, your charge couple device, the sensor in the back of your camera that is like looking at this thing.

407
00:21:49.600 --> 00:21:50.621
There's a noise, right?

408
00:21:50.701 --> 00:21:52.642
It's going to catch stray photons.

409
00:21:53.082 --> 00:21:55.644
And that noise is going to be higher than the signal that we're getting.

410
00:21:55.904 --> 00:21:57.385
So we can't just like look at the thing.

411
00:21:57.565 --> 00:21:57.765
Right.

412
00:21:57.925 --> 00:21:58.106
Right.

413
00:21:58.126 --> 00:21:59.647
So how do we actually find this thing?

414
00:21:59.947 --> 00:22:01.909
Well, this is for Earth-based.

415
00:22:02.509 --> 00:22:03.870
Even though this is even Hubble, dude.

416
00:22:03.991 --> 00:22:04.651
Oh, interesting.

417
00:22:04.671 --> 00:22:04.911
Yeah.

418
00:22:05.372 --> 00:22:05.632
Interesting.

419
00:22:05.652 --> 00:22:07.534
Because the Hubble has a CCD on it.

420
00:22:07.974 --> 00:22:08.675
I see what you're saying.

421
00:22:08.795 --> 00:22:11.717
And even though it's in outer space, like that thing has a noise.

422
00:22:12.037 --> 00:22:14.500
And then there's something actually called Zodiac Light.

423
00:22:14.820 --> 00:22:15.080
Okay.

424
00:22:15.120 --> 00:22:18.243
There is dust in the solar system, right?

425
00:22:18.543 --> 00:22:23.007
And that dust is going to scatter sunlight into your detector.

426
00:22:23.048 --> 00:22:25.730
Wherever you look, there's going to be dust from the solar system.

427
00:22:25.750 --> 00:22:26.170
That makes sense.

428
00:22:26.231 --> 00:22:27.812
And that is going to have a faint glow.

429
00:22:27.832 --> 00:22:28.333
That makes sense.

430
00:22:28.353 --> 00:22:34.278
And if the thing that you're looking at is a smaller glow than literal dust in our solar system, so what?

431
00:22:34.338 --> 00:22:37.241
We're going to put a Hubble, like, outside the solar system?

432
00:22:37.461 --> 00:22:38.242
We're not doing that.

433
00:22:38.662 --> 00:22:40.904
And then wait like four days to get signal back.

434
00:22:41.444 --> 00:22:44.607
Well, first of all, getting out there is like, you know, it's ridiculous.

435
00:22:44.687 --> 00:22:51.133
So we need to figure out other proxy ways to look for these ultra-

436
00:22:52.338 --> 00:22:56.241
Low-density galaxies, these candidate dark galaxies.

437
00:22:56.682 --> 00:22:57.843
Okay.

438
00:22:57.863 --> 00:22:58.603
Okay?

439
00:22:58.623 --> 00:23:01.826
And the proxy that comes up is called the globular cluster.

440
00:23:02.026 --> 00:23:03.688
These are some of my favorite objects.

441
00:23:03.748 --> 00:23:07.891
They're dense, ancient, they're bright, and they're point-like sources.

442
00:23:08.192 --> 00:23:10.313
They're way, way smaller than galaxies.

443
00:23:10.774 --> 00:23:14.457
They're like these old, old relics of galaxy formation.

444
00:23:14.697 --> 00:23:14.837
Okay.

445
00:23:14.857 --> 00:23:16.319
Not to be confused with the acronym relic.

446
00:23:17.019 --> 00:23:17.520
Just to be clear.

447
00:23:17.540 --> 00:23:18.240
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

448
00:23:18.280 --> 00:23:20.322
Not to be confused with the acronym Relic.

449
00:23:20.342 --> 00:23:23.345
There's so many of these that are around our Milky Way.

450
00:23:23.585 --> 00:23:24.766
They're really small, okay?

451
00:23:24.786 --> 00:23:28.710
They're going to be like hundreds of solar systems to thousands of solar systems.

452
00:23:28.730 --> 00:23:29.671
Wow, that's really small.

453
00:23:29.691 --> 00:23:30.892
It's really small.

454
00:23:31.273 --> 00:23:37.859
And the density of stars in that region is insanely small.

455
00:23:37.939 --> 00:23:38.600
You'll have like...

456
00:23:39.240 --> 00:23:44.204
Like, you know, the closest star to us is like four light years away.

457
00:23:44.384 --> 00:23:47.887
Over there, I think it's like on the order of light days to months.

458
00:23:47.907 --> 00:23:53.452
So it's like comparing the population density of Koreatown in Los Angeles to like Poughkeepsie, New York.

459
00:23:53.512 --> 00:23:53.792
Yes.

460
00:23:53.972 --> 00:23:54.552
Or something else.

461
00:23:54.652 --> 00:23:56.234
Yes, yes.

462
00:23:56.294 --> 00:23:57.235
We are that New York.

463
00:23:57.275 --> 00:23:58.936
Yeah, yeah.

464
00:23:59.136 --> 00:24:00.377
We are Poughkeepsie, New York.

465
00:24:00.397 --> 00:24:00.617
Yeah.

466
00:24:00.877 --> 00:24:02.719
But these galaxies look like Koreatowns.

467
00:24:02.759 --> 00:24:03.760
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

468
00:24:03.780 --> 00:24:06.942
You shouldn't say New York because whenever I think New York, I think New York City.

469
00:24:07.282 --> 00:24:07.842
Sorry.

470
00:24:07.902 --> 00:24:11.244
So let's try like – Poughkeepsie is like the middle of New York State.

471
00:24:11.264 --> 00:24:12.005
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

472
00:24:12.025 --> 00:24:13.526
But let's say like – I don't know where that is.

473
00:24:15.247 --> 00:24:16.267
I only know New York City.

474
00:24:17.128 --> 00:24:17.888
There's only one New York.

475
00:24:17.988 --> 00:24:18.629
Yeah.

476
00:24:18.669 --> 00:24:20.029
You could say like – You know, Nebraska.

477
00:24:20.070 --> 00:24:20.510
Right, right.

478
00:24:20.550 --> 00:24:21.150
You know, Omaha.

479
00:24:21.350 --> 00:24:22.671
Yeah, Omaha, Nebraska.

480
00:24:22.771 --> 00:24:23.752
Okay, fair, fair, fair.

481
00:24:23.852 --> 00:24:24.332
Exactly.

482
00:24:24.592 --> 00:24:25.133
Let's do that.

483
00:24:27.075 --> 00:24:30.637
But that's a helpful reference point.

484
00:24:30.657 --> 00:24:31.077
Yeah, yeah.

485
00:24:31.097 --> 00:24:32.538
So these things are really small.

486
00:24:33.018 --> 00:24:40.542
And so imagine, and these globular clusters, they're actually really important for just history, astronomical history.

487
00:24:41.443 --> 00:24:54.790
Harlow Shapley at Mount Wilson at the Carnegie Observatories, which we're going to have a special coming out soon, he mapped that the sun was not at the center of our galaxy by using these globular clusters.

488
00:24:54.810 --> 00:24:56.811
He observed a bunch of globular clusters,

489
00:24:57.151 --> 00:25:01.234
their positions, how far they were relative to the galactic disk.

490
00:25:01.294 --> 00:25:03.015
And he could figure out we're actually off-center.

491
00:25:03.856 --> 00:25:04.056
Right?

492
00:25:04.116 --> 00:25:09.799
We're not in the center of this galactic, these globular cluster distributions.

493
00:25:09.940 --> 00:25:15.803
So they're really tiny little specks around giant, massive galaxies, right?

494
00:25:16.244 --> 00:25:17.885
And so they become really nice.

495
00:25:18.385 --> 00:25:20.327
for observing a dark galaxy.

496
00:25:20.647 --> 00:25:31.915
Because the galaxy couldn't be there, but if we observe a bunch of globular clusters, there's got to be something that is gravitationally binding the globular clusters in that area.

497
00:25:32.076 --> 00:25:41.863
This vaguely reminds me, and I know I'm always making these stretch connections, when we talked about the radius of the proton story last week, the idea that you cannot directly observe it,

498
00:25:42.023 --> 00:25:44.105
because it's so exponentially small.

499
00:25:44.425 --> 00:25:51.390
And so we have to use these second and third order reference points in order to compute the value.

500
00:25:51.610 --> 00:26:06.541
And similarly, because dark matter does not interact with light, we're using the proximity and the movement and acceleration and angular momentum and et cetera, et cetera, of these globular clusters to derive understanding of this dark matter.

501
00:26:06.581 --> 00:26:07.422
That's exactly right.

502
00:26:07.482 --> 00:26:09.664
Yeah, and so this is what they finally did.

503
00:26:09.724 --> 00:26:14.847
They looked at archival data from the Piper survey, which is of the Perseus cluster.

504
00:26:14.867 --> 00:26:18.490
There's a giant galaxy cluster in the Perseus constellation.

505
00:26:18.510 --> 00:26:18.830
Okay.

506
00:26:18.910 --> 00:26:22.933
Okay, and there was this survey by Hubble Space Telescope.

507
00:26:22.993 --> 00:26:29.978
When they looked there, they reanalyzed that data with something called Dolfot, which is different from Dolfot.

508
00:26:30.018 --> 00:26:31.279
It's like a way to...

509
00:26:31.939 --> 00:26:38.766
Analyze data from Hubble Space Telescope, taking into account like the engineering of the Hubble Space Telescope, what it's capable of, things like that.

510
00:26:39.126 --> 00:26:46.654
And they revealed in this Perseus cluster, they revealed a fourth globular cluster that they hadn't seen before.

511
00:26:46.914 --> 00:26:49.898
If you look over there, there's three blue dots and then there's a red dot.

512
00:26:49.998 --> 00:26:50.178
Mm-hmm.

513
00:26:50.438 --> 00:26:53.879
That red dot is a new globular cluster that they hadn't found before.

514
00:26:54.279 --> 00:26:56.560
And from that, they can be like, now, well, wait.

515
00:26:56.880 --> 00:26:59.040
If there's a new globular cluster, there's four.

516
00:26:59.620 --> 00:27:07.623
Four being in the same small region is really unlikely unless there's something in the middle there that is causing them to clump.

517
00:27:08.343 --> 00:27:12.064
I want to make a brief note here, which is this important kind of...

518
00:27:13.100 --> 00:27:16.044
note about how the importance of data analysis.

519
00:27:16.104 --> 00:27:16.364
Yeah.

520
00:27:16.544 --> 00:27:18.727
Because you have a raw data profile.

521
00:27:19.087 --> 00:27:20.489
And this is the same raw data profile as before.

522
00:27:20.509 --> 00:27:23.572
It's the same raw data profile of like what had happened.

523
00:27:23.733 --> 00:27:27.737
And it's just literally, there's no interpretation on that raw data yet.

524
00:27:27.757 --> 00:27:27.978
Yeah.

525
00:27:28.518 --> 00:27:38.350
However, depending on the parameters and how you filter that raw data, there's a whole spectrum of different conclusions you can make depending on what you're looking for.

526
00:27:38.710 --> 00:27:41.674
And so the idea here is that they change the parameters.

527
00:27:41.834 --> 00:27:42.615
Yeah.

528
00:27:43.075 --> 00:27:45.498
Which is not changing the fundamental data.

529
00:27:45.558 --> 00:27:46.319
No, the raw data is.

530
00:27:46.319 --> 00:27:46.760
It's the same.

531
00:27:46.840 --> 00:27:53.228
It's like if you have a camera with a 400mm lens and you're trying to look at something that's really close to you, it's just going to look like a blur.

532
00:27:53.388 --> 00:27:53.548
Yeah.

533
00:27:53.568 --> 00:27:55.991
Because a 400mm lens is trying to look at things far away.

534
00:27:56.232 --> 00:27:58.975
But if you change to a 30, whatever, 24mm lens, all of a sudden...

535
00:28:01.418 --> 00:28:06.460
You can see the thing because you changed the way in which you're trying to analyze the information.

536
00:28:06.620 --> 00:28:12.022
Well, but I want to be cautious there because what you just talked about is actually different raw data.

537
00:28:12.342 --> 00:28:12.882
Ah, okay.

538
00:28:12.902 --> 00:28:13.083
Right?

539
00:28:13.163 --> 00:28:16.104
If you're switching out lenses, the raw data is different.

540
00:28:16.124 --> 00:28:16.764
Okay, that's fair.

541
00:28:17.144 --> 00:28:17.324
Right?

542
00:28:17.344 --> 00:28:17.744
No, that's fair.

543
00:28:17.764 --> 00:28:20.545
Here, I do want to make a distinction because this is important.

544
00:28:21.026 --> 00:28:22.386
Here, we're doing the same.

545
00:28:22.766 --> 00:28:23.887
We got the same photo.

546
00:28:24.087 --> 00:28:24.307
Yes.

547
00:28:24.527 --> 00:28:24.787
Okay?

548
00:28:24.807 --> 00:28:25.327
That's a good point.

549
00:28:25.367 --> 00:28:26.868
But we're now putting it through...

550
00:28:28.114 --> 00:28:31.617
Like, you know, on your computer, on Photoshop.

551
00:28:31.698 --> 00:28:35.201
We got, like, Photoshop the newest version versus, like, the old version.

552
00:28:35.461 --> 00:28:38.484
And now we can do, like, oh, contrast this way.

553
00:28:38.704 --> 00:28:41.587
And, like, the, you know, the color thing.

554
00:28:41.807 --> 00:28:46.312
And you're like, oh, I want to do this color more and this color less kind of thing.

555
00:28:46.332 --> 00:28:47.012
That's a really good point.

556
00:28:47.032 --> 00:28:48.053
That's the data analysis.

557
00:28:48.113 --> 00:28:48.614
No, that's fair.

558
00:28:48.654 --> 00:28:49.735
If you switch out a lens...

559
00:28:50.055 --> 00:28:50.675
That's raw data.

560
00:28:50.695 --> 00:28:51.116
No, no, no.

561
00:28:51.136 --> 00:28:52.316
You're switching out to engineering.

562
00:28:52.436 --> 00:28:55.438
No, that's a very fair point.

563
00:28:55.658 --> 00:28:56.959
The Photoshop analogy is correct.

564
00:28:56.979 --> 00:29:00.800
Yeah, they did like Dolphot Photoshop instead of Daofot Photoshop.

565
00:29:00.861 --> 00:29:02.121
It's a different Instagram filter.

566
00:29:02.181 --> 00:29:03.162
Yes, yes.

567
00:29:03.262 --> 00:29:04.903
And they're like, oh, there's four instead of three.

568
00:29:04.923 --> 00:29:05.543
Yeah.

569
00:29:06.603 --> 00:29:07.044
Exactly.

570
00:29:07.084 --> 00:29:07.344
Okay.

571
00:29:07.524 --> 00:29:07.705
Yes.

572
00:29:07.985 --> 00:29:08.425
Exactly.

573
00:29:08.445 --> 00:29:10.087
But they did Instagram on the Hubble.

574
00:29:10.187 --> 00:29:10.628
On the Hubble.

575
00:29:10.788 --> 00:29:11.028
Yes.

576
00:29:11.268 --> 00:29:11.469
Yes.

577
00:29:11.589 --> 00:29:11.889
Okay.

578
00:29:12.069 --> 00:29:12.249
Yes.

579
00:29:12.330 --> 00:29:12.470
Yes.

580
00:29:12.490 --> 00:29:12.590
Yes.

581
00:29:12.610 --> 00:29:12.750
Yes.

582
00:29:12.790 --> 00:29:12.990
Yes.

583
00:29:13.110 --> 00:29:13.311
Yeah.

584
00:29:13.371 --> 00:29:14.772
And then they found this fourth one, right?

585
00:29:14.792 --> 00:29:15.533
And that was critical.

586
00:29:15.913 --> 00:29:21.419
And when they stacked, so then they got their ESA colleagues at the European Space Agency.

587
00:29:21.580 --> 00:29:23.642
European Space Agency has something called Euclid.

588
00:29:23.982 --> 00:29:24.102
Okay.

589
00:29:24.122 --> 00:29:24.222
Okay.

590
00:29:24.923 --> 00:29:31.668
And they used the Euclid image of the same spot with the Hubble image from the Spain same spot, stacked them together.

591
00:29:32.249 --> 00:29:40.155
And now you could reveal the same ultra faint diffuse glow in between those four globular clusters.

592
00:29:40.575 --> 00:29:45.779
Those four globular clusters that were there, there was actually a little bit of light coming from the middle.

593
00:29:46.179 --> 00:29:47.520
So there are a few stars.

594
00:29:47.620 --> 00:29:49.622
Not that many, but there's a chance.

595
00:29:50.563 --> 00:29:53.525
And this is why cross-referencing data sources...

596
00:29:54.330 --> 00:29:55.701
You can get a little more...

597
00:29:58.196 --> 00:30:26.375
Fidelity Exactly And so with that diffuse glow Now you can start fitting models And you can say What is the amount of stellar mass That's in that diffuse glow Right in the middle The amount of light that I'm getting is very little But from that I can make an estimate Given how far I know it is How far away it is The Perseus cluster We can be like That's about 10 to the 6 suns So it's about 2 million suns

598
00:30:27.265 --> 00:30:27.525
Okay?

599
00:30:27.685 --> 00:30:28.226
It's not a lot.

600
00:30:29.286 --> 00:30:39.272
But from what we know about the number of globular clusters and how luminous they are, we can also back-calculate the amount of dark matter that should be there.

601
00:30:39.933 --> 00:30:44.055
And the dark matter is something like 10 to the 10.

602
00:30:44.075 --> 00:30:45.576
So 10 billion suns.

603
00:30:49.152 --> 00:31:00.838
So we've got 10 billion suns worth of dark matter and only 2 million suns worth of normal matter, meaning that the halo mass fraction, the amount of dark matter versus normal matter, is 99.94 to 99.98%.

604
00:31:00.898 --> 00:31:02.959
This is where we get the 99.98%.

605
00:31:06.541 --> 00:31:14.744
Yeah, the size of the dark matter halo is about that of the Large Magellanic Cloud, which is one of the – it's the biggest satellite galaxy to the Milky Way.

606
00:31:15.144 --> 00:31:16.725
You can only see it in the southern hemisphere.

607
00:31:17.105 --> 00:31:22.787
But the number of stars there is like a thousand times less than what we see in the Large Magellanic Cloud.

608
00:31:23.327 --> 00:31:23.567
Okay?

609
00:31:23.787 --> 00:31:28.709
So this is like a really, really tiny, tiny fraction.

610
00:31:28.729 --> 00:31:29.029
Yeah.

611
00:31:29.875 --> 00:31:30.975
Of what should be there.

612
00:31:31.135 --> 00:31:32.476
There's not that many stars.

613
00:31:32.716 --> 00:31:34.316
There's like one in a thousand stars.

614
00:31:34.596 --> 00:31:35.276
Of what it should be.

615
00:31:35.597 --> 00:31:35.877
Right.

616
00:31:36.357 --> 00:31:36.857
And that's.

617
00:31:37.577 --> 00:31:38.097
That's weird.

618
00:31:38.137 --> 00:31:40.978
And that goes in direct.

619
00:31:41.318 --> 00:31:42.939
That experimental data.

620
00:31:43.139 --> 00:31:43.379
Mm-hmm.

621
00:31:43.599 --> 00:31:45.559
Goes into direct conflict.

622
00:31:45.939 --> 00:31:47.200
With the Lambda CDM.

623
00:31:47.220 --> 00:31:47.660
Right.

624
00:31:48.500 --> 00:31:49.361
No, no, no.

625
00:31:49.421 --> 00:31:58.506
It doesn't necessarily go into direct conflict because the Lambda CDM does suggest that there should be a lot of dark matter galaxies.

626
00:31:58.526 --> 00:31:58.767
Okay.

627
00:31:58.907 --> 00:32:00.127
It's just now we found one.

628
00:32:00.488 --> 00:32:00.808
I see.

629
00:32:00.868 --> 00:32:01.068
Right?

630
00:32:01.448 --> 00:32:05.431
And now this is where we get into how could this be possible, right?

631
00:32:05.531 --> 00:32:05.811
Okay.

632
00:32:05.911 --> 00:32:13.075
Now, the first hypothesis is something called the failed giant hypothesis, which is something like Cloud9, which we covered in a very recent episode.

633
00:32:13.116 --> 00:32:13.336
Yes.

634
00:32:13.516 --> 00:32:16.538
The idea is you've got some massive halo that's destined to be a galaxy.

635
00:32:16.558 --> 00:32:16.698
Right.

636
00:32:17.830 --> 00:32:22.092
And then early star formation makes the globular clusters around it.

637
00:32:22.372 --> 00:32:25.193
But then star formation somehow abruptly just, like, stops.

638
00:32:25.474 --> 00:32:30.416
And so you just get a bunch of dark matter, a few stars, and these globular clusters around.

639
00:32:30.676 --> 00:32:37.139
If I recall, there's, like, some threshold where it's right in the sweet spot where it will maintain versus continuing.

640
00:32:37.159 --> 00:32:39.580
The weird thing is this is bigger than that threshold, though.

641
00:32:40.220 --> 00:32:40.861
I did check.

642
00:32:40.921 --> 00:32:41.301
Okay.

643
00:32:41.461 --> 00:32:47.966
And this 10 to the 10 solar masses, so 10 billion solar masses, is larger than the threshold that we had over there.

644
00:32:48.026 --> 00:32:49.707
So it shouldn't just be like cloud nine.

645
00:32:49.747 --> 00:32:50.888
Yeah, it's not like cloud nine.

646
00:32:50.928 --> 00:32:52.649
Otherwise, it would be a relic and there would be no stars.

647
00:32:52.669 --> 00:32:53.790
There's still a few stars.

648
00:32:54.030 --> 00:32:54.250
Fair.

649
00:32:54.290 --> 00:32:54.490
Right?

650
00:32:55.311 --> 00:32:57.633
The other thing could be like something called a quenching mechanism.

651
00:32:57.653 --> 00:32:59.114
There's something called ram pressure.

652
00:32:59.434 --> 00:33:02.056
So this is a photo of the Perseus cluster.

653
00:33:02.176 --> 00:33:02.356
Yes.

654
00:33:02.376 --> 00:33:03.537
You can see a lot of the...

655
00:33:04.638 --> 00:33:13.397
starlight is coming from these large galaxies, and the blue sort of haze is from the dark matter that we've mapped out because of all of the

656
00:33:14.572 --> 00:33:16.294
velocity measurements that we've taken.

657
00:33:16.874 --> 00:33:23.701
And one can imagine that in this really vibrant cluster, you had this early dark matter halo with a bunch of dark matter.

658
00:33:23.761 --> 00:33:29.066
And it was like, it had a bunch of cold gas is what we call because cold gas is like the gases are moving around.

659
00:33:29.366 --> 00:33:30.807
So it can clump in and form stars.

660
00:33:31.348 --> 00:33:37.554
So it was destined to be a galaxy kind of like the large Magellanic cloud, but maybe like some other galaxy just rammed into it.

661
00:33:38.054 --> 00:33:41.337
and then stripped it of all of the star-making material.

662
00:33:41.657 --> 00:33:47.062
So now it didn't have any star-making material, and it's just stuck being like this dark galaxy.

663
00:33:47.722 --> 00:33:49.544
That's actually interesting.

664
00:33:49.604 --> 00:33:56.250
So there's these theories, and more testing and more observation is going to tell which one is correct.

665
00:33:56.630 --> 00:34:01.374
What I'm really excited about is what I was telling earlier, which is this cusp and core model.

666
00:34:01.434 --> 00:34:01.915
Why do...

667
00:34:04.797 --> 00:34:07.598
Why does dark matter not form a cusp, right?

668
00:34:08.718 --> 00:34:10.259
We need to do more spectroscopy.

669
00:34:10.359 --> 00:34:11.919
We don't have that data right now.

670
00:34:11.999 --> 00:34:13.359
All we have is photometric data.

671
00:34:13.740 --> 00:34:24.502
What we'd have to do is figure out the spectra to figure out the redshift and the blueshift and all of the really nitty-gritty details of what that dark matter clump looks like.

672
00:34:24.663 --> 00:34:28.944
Because what we'd expect, given that there's no stars, is there's no smoothing out.

673
00:34:29.504 --> 00:34:33.005
And because there's no smoothing out, right, then the...

674
00:34:35.412 --> 00:34:36.393
We should have a cusp.

675
00:34:36.433 --> 00:34:43.258
We should have a higher density of dark matter in the center, and we should have low density out in the outside.

676
00:34:43.298 --> 00:34:45.079
We shouldn't have this flattened profile.

677
00:34:45.199 --> 00:34:45.379
Right.

678
00:34:45.419 --> 00:34:50.983
Where in the middle, there's just a bunch of dark matter, but there's no real big over density right at the center.

679
00:34:51.063 --> 00:34:51.263
Right?

680
00:34:51.303 --> 00:34:55.086
There's no, like, clump of dark matter that's super dense in the center.

681
00:34:55.406 --> 00:34:55.927
So that...

682
00:34:57.307 --> 00:35:05.970
That would be the case if we accept the current models of lambda dark matter, which is lambda CDM, which is the idea that dark matter is some kind of particle.

683
00:35:06.330 --> 00:35:10.411
It doesn't interact with itself unless it's through gravity.

684
00:35:11.711 --> 00:35:13.452
And now we get a cusp.

685
00:35:13.632 --> 00:35:15.012
If we see the cusp, great.

686
00:35:15.212 --> 00:35:15.452
Right.

687
00:35:15.932 --> 00:35:16.152
Okay?

688
00:35:16.432 --> 00:35:18.453
If we don't see the cusp, what does that mean?

689
00:35:26.402 --> 00:35:29.603
Further clarify, is there a core or is there a cusp?

690
00:35:29.643 --> 00:35:29.903
Yes.

691
00:35:30.803 --> 00:35:33.204
And if there is a cusp... Then we're good.

692
00:35:33.384 --> 00:35:33.624
Great.

693
00:35:34.185 --> 00:35:36.505
This Lambda CDM, well done.

694
00:35:36.605 --> 00:35:36.805
Yeah.

695
00:35:37.185 --> 00:35:42.767
Experimental data is now further validating the theory.

696
00:35:42.947 --> 00:35:43.167
Mm-hmm.

697
00:35:43.588 --> 00:35:48.229
If it continues to be a core, which is kind of what it appears to be.

698
00:35:48.249 --> 00:35:48.489
Yeah.

699
00:35:48.729 --> 00:35:49.569
It appears that, like...

700
00:35:49.589 --> 00:35:50.430
It appears that way.

701
00:35:50.470 --> 00:35:50.650
Yeah.

702
00:35:50.670 --> 00:35:50.770
Yeah.

703
00:35:51.377 --> 00:35:54.539
Then we got to go look back at the drawing board a little bit.

704
00:35:54.559 --> 00:35:54.679
Yes.

705
00:35:54.819 --> 00:35:57.060
Then we got to be like, what exactly is dark matter?

706
00:35:57.160 --> 00:36:01.203
Is dark matter really just like another particle, like a proton or an electron?

707
00:36:01.623 --> 00:36:08.267
That, fine, the only thing that's different about it is it doesn't have any charge and it doesn't interact with electromagnetic field.

708
00:36:08.367 --> 00:36:09.407
It doesn't interact with light.

709
00:36:09.848 --> 00:36:10.208
Right?

710
00:36:10.268 --> 00:36:11.209
That's the normal thing.

711
00:36:11.249 --> 00:36:11.769
And that's like...

712
00:36:12.169 --> 00:36:13.770
Like, naively, I would expect that.

713
00:36:13.870 --> 00:36:23.374
It's just another particle, but it doesn't interact with light, which is why we see its effects across giant scales of the universe, but not, like, you know, nitty-gritty stuff.

714
00:36:23.914 --> 00:36:24.995
This one is pretty cool.

715
00:36:25.035 --> 00:36:26.655
There's something called fuzzy dark matter.

716
00:36:26.935 --> 00:36:29.757
This is very different from lambda-CDM.

717
00:36:30.017 --> 00:36:30.237
Okay?

718
00:36:30.517 --> 00:36:30.817
Okay.

719
00:36:30.877 --> 00:36:42.843
Fuzzy dark matter means that dark matter is not tiny little like particles, but it's fuzzy in the sense that it's super light, meaning billions of times lighter than the electron.

720
00:36:43.283 --> 00:36:44.064
And what does that mean?

721
00:36:44.404 --> 00:36:46.185
If it's billions and that's and that's.

722
00:36:46.985 --> 00:36:50.329
Some of the lightest stuff, it's going to be lighter than quarks, electrons.

723
00:36:51.070 --> 00:36:54.053
It's at the order of even lighter than neutrinos type of thing.

724
00:36:54.393 --> 00:37:01.161
It is so light that if we were to calculate the quantum mechanics of a particle that's that light, the wavelength...

725
00:37:02.168 --> 00:37:07.251
The de Broglie wavelength, because, you know, remember in quantum mechanics, every particle is a wave and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

726
00:37:07.611 --> 00:37:11.234
Well, the larger the particle is, the shorter the de Broglie wavelength.

727
00:37:11.674 --> 00:37:11.934
Okay.

728
00:37:12.394 --> 00:37:17.097
So electrons have a wavelength that's like around like ultraviolet X-ray-ish.

729
00:37:18.338 --> 00:37:22.801
This thing at 10 to the minus 22 electron volt mass.

730
00:37:24.075 --> 00:37:29.083
would have a wavelength that is hundreds of light years big.

731
00:37:29.804 --> 00:37:30.586
Oh, my God.

732
00:37:30.746 --> 00:37:30.986
Right?

733
00:37:31.627 --> 00:37:36.655
Its quantum wavelength, if you were to create a quantum wave out of it, would be the size of several...

734
00:37:37.668 --> 00:37:40.170
Like, it would be like a big chunk of the universe.

735
00:37:40.330 --> 00:37:41.711
I mean, sorry, of the galaxy.

736
00:37:42.312 --> 00:37:42.512
Right?

737
00:37:42.572 --> 00:37:43.353
This is...

738
00:37:43.613 --> 00:37:47.456
So the wavelength would be larger than the distance between them.

739
00:37:47.896 --> 00:37:48.197
Right.

740
00:37:48.337 --> 00:37:48.617
Okay?

741
00:37:48.697 --> 00:37:49.198
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

742
00:37:49.218 --> 00:37:50.879
Now, what does that remind us of?

743
00:37:50.959 --> 00:37:53.421
That reminds us of Bose-Einstein condensates.

744
00:37:53.441 --> 00:37:54.422
Ah!

745
00:37:54.442 --> 00:37:54.922
Right?

746
00:37:55.062 --> 00:37:55.603
Yes, yes.

747
00:37:55.623 --> 00:37:59.106
Because in a Bose-Einstein condensate, the waves of each particle...

748
00:38:00.238 --> 00:38:03.760
pile on top of one another to create a single quantum wave.

749
00:38:04.100 --> 00:38:06.442
And that's why they don't sort of clump together.

750
00:38:06.602 --> 00:38:19.049
So what this particular theory is saying is there's some kind of inherent quantum pressure that's at the scale of galaxies that is creating a core with a flat density.

751
00:38:19.069 --> 00:38:26.433
You've got a Bose-Einstein condensate of this fuzzy dark matter particle that is at the size of a galaxy, and that's why you don't get a cusp.

752
00:38:26.493 --> 00:38:26.633
Yeah.

753
00:38:27.807 --> 00:38:28.868
It's so fascinating.

754
00:38:29.088 --> 00:38:37.793
So this could be, you know, this Canada Dark Galaxy could be a proving ground for something like fuzzy dark matter.

755
00:38:38.233 --> 00:38:39.114
It's very interesting.

756
00:38:39.414 --> 00:38:47.418
From my layman's perspective, I like only because we've so recently talked about Bose-Einstein Conversates.

757
00:38:47.438 --> 00:38:49.760
So I have a mental model of what that actually means.

758
00:38:50.360 --> 00:38:51.520
And so I'm like, yeah, that sounds right.

759
00:38:51.860 --> 00:38:52.501
Yeah.

760
00:38:52.581 --> 00:38:53.341
That sounds about right.

761
00:38:53.401 --> 00:38:54.401
That sounds so cool.

762
00:38:54.601 --> 00:38:54.781
Yes.

763
00:38:54.841 --> 00:38:59.383
Imagine a particle whose quantum wavelength is the size of a galaxy.

764
00:38:59.403 --> 00:39:00.423
That's unbelievable.

765
00:39:00.523 --> 00:39:01.283
That's unbelievable.

766
00:39:01.963 --> 00:39:02.884
That would be very cool.

767
00:39:02.944 --> 00:39:09.526
So, I mean, so this is quite a big deal in, you know, in that I'm curious.

768
00:39:09.626 --> 00:39:16.508
I would be curious to see how other folks and institutions begin to sort of digest and interpret the paper.

769
00:39:16.648 --> 00:39:16.868
Mm-hmm.

770
00:39:17.627 --> 00:39:20.888
But I think like we were talking about earlier, there are certain things that happen when it happens.

771
00:39:20.948 --> 00:39:23.389
It's like, okay, all the big guns point over there.

772
00:39:23.429 --> 00:39:24.670
Yeah, let's point over there.

773
00:39:24.870 --> 00:39:28.011
You think it has the potential to reach that threshold?

774
00:39:28.031 --> 00:39:29.031
I think so.

775
00:39:29.132 --> 00:39:30.212
I mean, we know where it is.

776
00:39:30.572 --> 00:39:31.332
Yeah.

777
00:39:31.532 --> 00:39:35.014
We know like sort of the base spectrometry data.

778
00:39:35.114 --> 00:39:42.057
So I can imagine there's going to be a lot of follow-up studies on this from all the top telescopes and institutions.

779
00:39:42.357 --> 00:39:43.097
Because why not?

780
00:39:43.277 --> 00:39:47.378
Yeah, it's a testing ground for particle physics in some sense.

781
00:39:47.398 --> 00:39:47.698
Yes.

782
00:39:47.878 --> 00:39:48.118
Right?

783
00:39:48.438 --> 00:39:48.738
Yes.

784
00:39:49.098 --> 00:39:49.798
Which is very cool.

785
00:39:49.818 --> 00:39:51.219
This is very, very cool.

786
00:39:51.519 --> 00:39:53.139
This is very, very good.

787
00:39:53.759 --> 00:39:58.100
This was out of the astrophysical journal letters.

788
00:39:58.300 --> 00:39:59.320
Mm-hmm.

789
00:39:59.880 --> 00:40:02.061
And we have our institutions here.

790
00:40:02.141 --> 00:40:06.062
This would have been, because I want to make sure we cover who did the paper for this.

791
00:40:06.082 --> 00:40:06.662
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

792
00:40:06.802 --> 00:40:07.342
Good point.

793
00:40:07.722 --> 00:40:09.242
I'm just pulling this up now.

794
00:40:10.423 --> 00:40:12.423
Yeah, so it was in astrophysical journal letters.

795
00:40:14.399 --> 00:40:18.163
And it includes, oh, several institutions.

796
00:40:18.543 --> 00:40:20.965
Yeah, it's usually several institutions.

797
00:40:21.005 --> 00:40:21.666
There's a lot of folks.

798
00:40:21.686 --> 00:40:24.709
But if we want to name a few, University of Toronto is a big one.

799
00:40:24.869 --> 00:40:25.109
Yes.

800
00:40:25.610 --> 00:40:25.850
Um...

801
00:40:27.292 --> 00:40:29.314
Yeah, University of Toronto is one of the big ones.

802
00:40:29.594 --> 00:40:31.455
Yes, and this was in collaboration.

803
00:40:31.515 --> 00:40:31.976
And Yale.

804
00:40:32.396 --> 00:40:34.858
Because, like, you know, it's the...

805
00:40:34.918 --> 00:40:39.621
These guys love that ultra-dark, you know, diffuse stuff.

806
00:40:39.641 --> 00:40:42.344
University of Santa Cruz, California Santa Cruz.

807
00:40:42.884 --> 00:40:43.344
So, yeah.

808
00:40:43.745 --> 00:40:44.545
Big shout-outs to all the team.

809
00:40:44.565 --> 00:40:45.826
This is a really interesting story.

810
00:40:45.846 --> 00:40:48.448
I mean, I still continue to be so fascinated by Dark Matter.

811
00:40:48.528 --> 00:40:52.111
I know, friend of the pod, Dan Gilman has dedicated his life to...

812
00:40:52.251 --> 00:40:56.953
And he did a postdoc at the University of Toronto, so I wonder if he knows some of these guys.

813
00:40:57.434 --> 00:40:58.594
I'll tell him to send them.

814
00:40:58.614 --> 00:40:59.875
Yeah, share it, Dan.

815
00:40:59.895 --> 00:41:01.235
Share it with the team.

816
00:41:01.516 --> 00:41:04.877
And if folks want to give us any follow-ups, comments, or corrections, please let us know.

817
00:41:04.997 --> 00:41:05.277
Yeah.

818
00:41:05.337 --> 00:41:08.599
Great astrophysics first story on Dark Matter.

819
00:41:08.619 --> 00:41:10.080
A kind of continuation...

820
00:41:10.600 --> 00:41:21.451
On our Cloud9 story, which was fascinating and well worth the watch if you haven't seen it, to get a little bit deeper into that use case where the cluster does not reach the level where it can produce stars.

821
00:41:21.531 --> 00:41:21.751
Yeah.

822
00:41:21.811 --> 00:41:24.094
And so it remains sort of this, like, empty mass.

823
00:41:24.214 --> 00:41:25.455
Yeah, the relic.

824
00:41:25.495 --> 00:41:26.076
The relics, yes.

825
00:41:26.096 --> 00:41:26.456
Cloud9.

826
00:41:26.696 --> 00:41:26.936
Cloud9.

827
00:41:27.497 --> 00:41:29.758
So we're going to move into the rundown now.

828
00:41:29.918 --> 00:41:35.762
And for those who are new to the show, we usually cover several main stories where we do a big deep dive.

829
00:41:35.842 --> 00:41:40.284
But the rundown allows us to talk about other breaking science research that we find interesting.

830
00:41:40.604 --> 00:41:45.187
We're going to start with a follow-up to a story we covered in episode four.

831
00:41:45.347 --> 00:41:45.527
Yes.

832
00:41:45.567 --> 00:41:48.809
One of our early stories about the VersiRubin Observatory.

833
00:41:49.489 --> 00:41:51.970
It has now launched its real-time discovery engine.

834
00:41:52.391 --> 00:41:52.651
So...

835
00:41:53.739 --> 00:41:57.821
This is now about eight months later, and it's a pretty major update.

836
00:41:58.141 --> 00:41:58.542
Yeah, yeah.

837
00:41:58.562 --> 00:42:10.788
This one's insane because the Varosiruban Observatory is unlike any other observatory out there because it's this giant thing where astronomers cannot get time on it, right?

838
00:42:11.028 --> 00:42:19.673
Usually when there's an observatory and you're like, oh, like in the last story, hey, I want to look at this candidate dark galaxy in the Perseus cluster.

839
00:42:20.173 --> 00:42:20.973
I need four nights.

840
00:42:21.634 --> 00:42:21.834
And...

841
00:42:22.414 --> 00:42:31.158
That application is going to go to whoever's in charge of that telescope time, and they're going to decide from all the applications who is going to get time to look at what.

842
00:42:31.498 --> 00:42:38.040
The Veris-Ereuben Observatory is an observatory that is just taking a photo of the entire night sky every three nights.

843
00:42:38.460 --> 00:42:43.222
That is its job, light clockwork, fully automated, and that's all it's doing.

844
00:42:43.282 --> 00:42:45.063
It's not focusing on particular things.

845
00:42:45.263 --> 00:42:45.963
That's what it's doing.

846
00:42:46.404 --> 00:42:49.285
And what that means is it's going to find a lot of data,

847
00:42:50.255 --> 00:42:51.676
Every night there's going to be new data.

848
00:42:51.976 --> 00:43:00.679
And what it can do is historically look at what did that position in the night sky look like a month ago, a year ago, 10 years ago?

849
00:43:00.739 --> 00:43:08.222
Because all of the archival astronomical data of maybe the Hubble pointed at it at some point or maybe the James Webb pointed at it six months ago.

850
00:43:08.862 --> 00:43:11.123
It can compare images between Hubble.

851
00:43:11.703 --> 00:43:16.708
what it saw that particular night, and what other telescopes have seen that particular night.

852
00:43:17.088 --> 00:43:19.871
And if there's anything different, send out an email alert.

853
00:43:20.291 --> 00:43:29.741
And so on its first night that this real-time discovery machine was operating, it sent out 800,000 alerts.

854
00:43:30.441 --> 00:43:35.606
It found 800,000 candidates for new stuff that scientists could look at.

855
00:43:36.307 --> 00:43:38.208
So this is incredible.

856
00:43:38.508 --> 00:43:51.972
And we talked about this when we did the story because the technology behind it is unreal in terms of the volume and the – it's like going from CRT 480p TVs to 4K.

857
00:43:54.913 --> 00:43:55.894
Yeah.

858
00:43:56.914 --> 00:43:58.676
And so that's in terms of resolution.

859
00:43:58.696 --> 00:43:58.876
Yes.

860
00:43:59.136 --> 00:44:01.578
The main thing is it's going from photographs to movies.

861
00:44:01.598 --> 00:44:02.879
Movies, right, which we talked about.

862
00:44:02.899 --> 00:44:04.560
And so we're seeing, like, motion.

863
00:44:04.600 --> 00:44:05.481
Motion, right.

864
00:44:05.521 --> 00:44:09.043
We're seeing, for example, asteroids, because the asteroids will move.

865
00:44:09.443 --> 00:44:12.486
And so that's going to be a motion transient that the Vera Rubin can catch.

866
00:44:12.766 --> 00:44:17.029
We're seeing supernovae, which are going to be, oh, there was no light bulb there.

867
00:44:17.369 --> 00:44:19.871
And then now there's a tiny, faint light bulb on that galaxy.

868
00:44:19.891 --> 00:44:21.032
That means a star exploded.

869
00:44:21.392 --> 00:44:22.153
And we've got about...

870
00:44:22.693 --> 00:44:45.213
you know two or three weeks to catch that star exploding so all these transient events these fleeting celestial events that's what the vera rubin was out for right that's why it's called the legacy survey of space and time the lsst that's the program it's for 10 years it's going to go along these alerts are going to be insane um

871
00:44:46.844 --> 00:44:51.986
It's expected to generate up to 7 million alerts per night.

872
00:44:52.127 --> 00:44:52.367
Yeah.

873
00:44:52.747 --> 00:44:56.269
And we're already on track because the first night it was already 800,000.

874
00:44:56.509 --> 00:44:59.590
I mean, this is incredible because there's not that many astronomers out there.

875
00:45:00.110 --> 00:45:00.270
Right.

876
00:45:00.290 --> 00:45:00.971
Okay, in the world.

877
00:45:01.431 --> 00:45:03.732
And those astronomers don't have a lot of time.

878
00:45:03.912 --> 00:45:04.112
Right.

879
00:45:04.192 --> 00:45:09.775
So this is really the advent, I think, of decentralized astrophysics research.

880
00:45:09.895 --> 00:45:12.296
Like, now we can have citizen scientists, for example.

881
00:45:12.636 --> 00:45:15.298
If you're, like, in a high school or, like...

882
00:45:16.098 --> 00:45:22.483
You know, some advanced program where you want to do scientific research, but you don't have access to data.

883
00:45:22.883 --> 00:45:26.185
This is an incredible resource now to do small little projects.

884
00:45:26.225 --> 00:45:29.067
I don't know, you want to get ahead in your college application.

885
00:45:29.468 --> 00:45:30.488
This is something you could do.

886
00:45:30.548 --> 00:45:37.874
You could go on the Vera Rubin website and find data and look at some of these alerts and be like, hey, which alert do I want to like...

887
00:45:38.434 --> 00:46:06.843
dig a little bit deeper into things like that um you can also i mean this is going to be huge for machine learning and ai because handling seven million alerts a night no human can do that right but creating a machine learning pipeline that can you know sparse through all those alerts figure out which is the one that actually might require human attention from somebody with a phd in astrophysics and so on it's going to be huge i i i this is this i think when we did our end of the year episode for season one i brought up

888
00:46:06.943 --> 00:46:24.949
this episode 4 is one of my favorites because I still just think technically from technical execution largest camera in the world the data pipeline build being able to actually process and make available

889
00:46:26.018 --> 00:46:45.173
Immediately, that volume of data Within two minutes, I think Is a significant technological challenge In and of itself And then the open sourcing of it Right, out of the box Meaning there's no gatekeeping There's no this and that I think it's a beautiful testament To the spirit of what

890
00:46:45.913 --> 00:47:10.927
science yeah in the modern era can look like yeah there's understandable reasons why not every system is like that yeah and i mean this is this is something that i think the u.s taxpayer should be very proud of yes this is you almost entirely a u.s effort by the u.s national science foundation and the u.s department of energy do we baby like this is this is really cool that our taxpayer dollars are going into something like this very

891
00:47:11.067 --> 00:47:36.175
cool first story um we're gonna move into our story number two our story number two this one is a material science and ai story as scientists have used ai to help them find new types of magnets uh which can be used in an innumerable number of industries so what what exactly is going on with these new magnetic materials yeah so finding rare earth free permanent magnets

892
00:47:36.955 --> 00:47:37.315
I.e.

893
00:47:37.636 --> 00:47:47.682
permanent magnets that don't require these rare earth minerals that like we have to mine for that are really hard to find that maybe we have to make a deal with China with and so on and so forth.

894
00:47:47.782 --> 00:47:56.227
Like that's crucial for reducing the manufacturing cost and the supply chain vulnerabilities of electric vehicles and electric vehicles.

895
00:47:56.327 --> 00:47:58.189
If we can make them cheaper.

896
00:47:58.209 --> 00:47:58.309
Yeah.

897
00:47:59.029 --> 00:48:01.450
easier to make, they can be the future, right?

898
00:48:01.750 --> 00:48:02.850
Not just electric vehicles.

899
00:48:02.890 --> 00:48:04.210
I mean, batteries go in everything, right?

900
00:48:04.270 --> 00:48:06.591
Medical devices, renewable energy systems.

901
00:48:06.931 --> 00:48:22.294
And what this team at the University of New Hampshire has done is use an AI system to extract data from thousands of scientific reports and train a model that will predict the magnetic behavior of materials, of novel materials, right?

902
00:48:22.354 --> 00:48:27.096
And you have now a searchable database of something like 67,000 magnetic compounds.

903
00:48:29.136 --> 00:48:34.837
And out of those, they found 25 new candidates that will remain magnetic at high temperatures.

904
00:48:35.458 --> 00:48:36.318
Very interesting.

905
00:48:36.358 --> 00:48:51.921
Because the hotter you make a magnet, the more jiggling there is, which means that the local alignment between your magnetic elements, like in iron, for example, the iron has like a valence electron that creates a gross magnetic field around the atom.

906
00:48:52.021 --> 00:48:58.743
When iron becomes magnetic, like when you take a paperclip and you put it around a permanent magnet, that paperclip becomes magnetic, right?

907
00:48:59.103 --> 00:49:04.127
Because all of the iron atoms sort of align to make a big magnetic field.

908
00:49:04.427 --> 00:49:06.709
Well, if you heat up that paperclip, you're done.

909
00:49:06.969 --> 00:49:10.872
But if you put that paperclip in the freezer and you come back hours later, it'll still be magnetic.

910
00:49:11.333 --> 00:49:16.417
The point is we want to find magnetic materials that remain magnetic at high temperatures.

911
00:49:16.477 --> 00:49:20.240
Because that will give us industry applications.

912
00:49:20.600 --> 00:49:21.981
And that's what this is doing.

913
00:49:22.061 --> 00:49:25.404
And it vastly accelerates material science.

914
00:49:26.724 --> 00:49:40.893
You know, because millions of time consuming lab tests can now be churned through with this machine learning algorithm and you can find like a searchable digital resource that you can then be like, okay, I want to find a particular magnetic material that does this and this.

915
00:49:42.066 --> 00:49:43.027
You got something.

916
00:49:43.107 --> 00:49:43.927
This is great.

917
00:49:43.967 --> 00:49:45.608
So this was out of Nature Communications.

918
00:49:45.688 --> 00:49:46.229
Would it be...

919
00:49:47.269 --> 00:49:50.832
So, I mean, obviously, the thing that comes to my mind is...

920
00:49:51.512 --> 00:49:54.874
It makes me think of, like, a magnetic version of AlphaFold.

921
00:49:55.715 --> 00:49:56.855
Yeah, kind of.

922
00:49:57.056 --> 00:49:59.437
It's like a material science version of it.

923
00:49:59.457 --> 00:50:00.778
Like, directionally speaking.

924
00:50:00.798 --> 00:50:02.299
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

925
00:50:02.579 --> 00:50:07.242
I think it's still a little far from I give you a novel material and you predict.

926
00:50:07.642 --> 00:50:08.263
This is still...

927
00:50:08.683 --> 00:50:09.664
There's all of these...

928
00:50:11.185 --> 00:50:15.647
there's all of these thousands of scientific papers that have already come out with a bunch of stuff.

929
00:50:16.047 --> 00:50:19.509
How do I centralize that and create an understanding?

930
00:50:19.809 --> 00:50:29.795
So it's more so taking the existing data and making someone be able to iterate on ideas based on existing data.

931
00:50:30.876 --> 00:50:34.738
AlphaFold was really sort of saying, here's all possible ideas.

932
00:50:35.175 --> 00:50:36.136
Protein structures.

933
00:50:36.196 --> 00:50:39.659
Yeah, from all of the sequences that we know, even the ones that we haven't found.

934
00:50:39.719 --> 00:50:44.764
Which is a different thing because that's generating net new data versus just interpreting past data.

935
00:50:44.864 --> 00:50:46.626
Okay, so there's a difference there.

936
00:50:46.646 --> 00:50:47.987
Yeah, but it's getting there, right?

937
00:50:48.007 --> 00:50:48.628
We're getting close.

938
00:50:48.768 --> 00:50:49.549
That's very cool.

939
00:50:49.709 --> 00:50:50.730
Very, very, very, very good.

940
00:50:50.930 --> 00:50:51.150
Yeah.

941
00:50:51.411 --> 00:50:55.114
Story number three is a climate science story with a bit of anthropology.

942
00:50:55.314 --> 00:50:56.055
Yeah.

943
00:50:56.175 --> 00:50:58.497
There's new science about what actually went wrong.

944
00:51:00.319 --> 00:51:01.982
On Easter Island.

945
00:51:02.303 --> 00:51:02.583
Yes.

946
00:51:02.703 --> 00:51:03.244
What went wrong?

947
00:51:03.485 --> 00:51:05.468
So Easter Island is very famous, right?

948
00:51:05.588 --> 00:51:06.650
This is Rapa Nui.

949
00:51:07.090 --> 00:51:09.294
It has those giant...

950
00:51:10.253 --> 00:51:17.939
statues of these like heads with torsos that are facing out into the ocean.

951
00:51:19.000 --> 00:51:28.408
And for the longest time, the popular narrative was that the society collapsed there because of self-inflicted ecocide, meaning they cut down all the trees.

952
00:51:29.048 --> 00:51:37.075
And then by the time that the European colonizers came, there was a decimated population that was like almost starving and blah, blah, blah.

953
00:51:37.375 --> 00:51:37.635
Okay.

954
00:51:39.156 --> 00:51:41.256
That turns out to not be entirely true.

955
00:51:41.636 --> 00:51:42.017
Shocking.

956
00:51:42.177 --> 00:51:48.239
Shocking that the European colonizers made up a... A story about the history.

957
00:51:48.419 --> 00:51:54.801
Yeah, a story about the history that is conducive to them and says, oh, the natives didn't know what they were doing.

958
00:51:54.821 --> 00:51:55.461
What they were doing.

959
00:51:55.901 --> 00:51:56.181
Okay.

960
00:51:56.321 --> 00:51:58.362
It turns out from new sediment core data...

961
00:51:59.283 --> 00:52:03.547
What they did was they studied hydrogen isotopes of plant leaf waxes.

962
00:52:03.567 --> 00:52:04.167
Okay.

963
00:52:04.707 --> 00:52:10.412
And these things preserve sort of a climate history across climates, across centuries, right?

964
00:52:10.692 --> 00:52:19.379
So by studying the hydrogen isotope data there, what they actually found out was that the annual rainfall there dropped sharply.

965
00:52:19.399 --> 00:52:19.520
Yeah.

966
00:52:20.200 --> 00:52:25.145
by almost 24 to 31 inches during the mid 16th century.

967
00:52:25.485 --> 00:52:31.731
And this is right before sort of the European explorers went and like saw what was happening.

968
00:52:31.751 --> 00:52:31.971
Right.

969
00:52:32.431 --> 00:52:38.377
And so what's happening is instead of like entirely collapsing due to deforestation and conflict,

970
00:52:38.717 --> 00:52:53.289
which is the original theory, what probably happened is the Rapa Nui people adapted to the severe climate stress, and they shifted their rituals, their power structures, and their ceremonial centers to respond to that climate stress.

971
00:52:53.549 --> 00:52:55.891
And it emphasizes more like human resilience

972
00:52:56.893 --> 00:53:05.277
And that the history of Easter Island is way more complicated than what this overconsumption narrative that the colonizers had pushed.

973
00:53:06.258 --> 00:53:07.078
Surprise, surprise.

974
00:53:07.358 --> 00:53:07.939
Classic.

975
00:53:08.339 --> 00:53:09.399
Very fascinating.

976
00:53:10.080 --> 00:53:19.184
We could probably, I'm sure some people would be like, hydrogen isotopes of plant leaf waxes being able to be analyzed over centuries in and of itself.

977
00:53:19.205 --> 00:53:19.405
Yeah.

978
00:53:19.565 --> 00:53:20.825
I would love to understand that.

979
00:53:20.925 --> 00:53:21.326
Yeah, yeah.

980
00:53:21.346 --> 00:53:22.626
That's a good one for a deep dive.

981
00:53:22.646 --> 00:53:23.227
Because it's...

982
00:53:24.287 --> 00:53:38.357
That's so curious to me, but clearly is hugely impactful in both this historical climate science-related research, but also mapping it in this case, which is what's kind of interesting to an anthropological lens as well.

983
00:53:38.377 --> 00:53:42.119
Yeah, I mean, it's a technique that's very similar to when people do ice cores.

984
00:53:42.539 --> 00:53:43.100
Have you heard of that?

985
00:53:43.200 --> 00:53:43.760
No, no, no.

986
00:53:44.080 --> 00:53:47.843
They barrel like an ice cylinder in an Antarctic glacier.

987
00:53:47.863 --> 00:53:47.963
Okay.

988
00:53:48.383 --> 00:53:58.991
And because Antarctic glaciers are like so old, layers of that are going to give you a recorded history of the climate going back almost millions to tens of millions of years.

989
00:53:59.391 --> 00:53:59.592
Right.

990
00:53:59.812 --> 00:54:07.457
So similarly, plant waxes like leaf waxes are stuff that are very old because it's not like.

991
00:54:08.358 --> 00:54:10.339
It's not like a plant in that it was just born.

992
00:54:10.579 --> 00:54:15.242
It's like it created the wax, and then the wax has sort of persisted across centuries.

993
00:54:15.262 --> 00:54:17.963
It's kind of like in Jurassic Park when you have the resin.

994
00:54:18.003 --> 00:54:20.044
Resin is a plant residue.

995
00:54:20.164 --> 00:54:23.346
It's not wax, but it's a type of residue that can last forever.

996
00:54:23.406 --> 00:54:24.346
Through the ages.

997
00:54:24.446 --> 00:54:27.187
Similarly, leaf wax is something that can last through the ages.

998
00:54:27.467 --> 00:54:33.429
So it gives us like a diary of what the climate was like in that locality.

999
00:54:33.769 --> 00:54:39.750
If we can really analyze it at that atomic resolution, which is what these guys did at the Columbia Climate School.

1000
00:54:39.950 --> 00:54:40.771
Fascinating.

1001
00:54:41.171 --> 00:54:44.132
This was a paper in Communications Earth.

1002
00:54:44.972 --> 00:54:45.092
Yeah.

1003
00:54:45.892 --> 00:54:54.997
Again, I think we'll continue to see as scientific tools and instruments and the funding that goes to support those endeavors continues to grow in capability.

1004
00:54:56.698 --> 00:55:00.701
We will be illuminating more about as much about our past.

1005
00:55:00.761 --> 00:55:01.001
Yes.

1006
00:55:01.621 --> 00:55:04.883
As we will about where we are going as a species.

1007
00:55:05.544 --> 00:55:08.185
Our fourth and final story in the rundown.

1008
00:55:08.225 --> 00:55:09.226
This one's a weird story.

1009
00:55:09.926 --> 00:55:13.448
About psychology, language, and baby chickens.

1010
00:55:13.528 --> 00:55:13.788
Yes.

1011
00:55:14.449 --> 00:55:17.030
And I don't know much about it on purpose.

1012
00:55:18.371 --> 00:55:26.415
And before we get into it, I would like to take our audience on a trip to Bahrain and ultimately Italy.

1013
00:55:26.635 --> 00:55:26.895
Okay.

1014
00:55:27.376 --> 00:55:30.037
We just ended Formula One testing in Bahrain.

1015
00:55:30.197 --> 00:55:30.437
Yes.

1016
00:55:30.918 --> 00:55:34.960
The season opener is happening in Australia at the end of this week.

1017
00:55:36.295 --> 00:55:36.935
For F1.

1018
00:55:37.115 --> 00:55:37.876
For Formula 1.

1019
00:55:37.936 --> 00:55:42.458
Of course I'm talking about Formula 1, the greatest sport alive today.

1020
00:55:42.678 --> 00:55:45.740
And Ferrari is back, baby.

1021
00:55:47.101 --> 00:55:48.441
Ferrari is so back.

1022
00:55:48.501 --> 00:55:51.543
This is going to be our year, dude.

1023
00:55:51.823 --> 00:55:54.644
We haven't had a driver's championship since 2007.

1024
00:55:54.704 --> 00:55:57.486
We haven't had a constructor's championship since 2008.

1025
00:55:57.526 --> 00:55:58.826
I'm not blaming anybody.

1026
00:55:58.887 --> 00:56:03.129
I'm just saying this is the reality of the situation.

1027
00:56:03.929 --> 00:56:07.851
But we've got Charles Leclerc, who I'm personally a fan of Charles Leclerc.

1028
00:56:08.212 --> 00:56:10.193
Lewis Hamilton, one of the greatest of all time.

1029
00:56:10.433 --> 00:56:12.294
Also, congratulations to Charles.

1030
00:56:12.334 --> 00:56:13.415
I think he just got engaged.

1031
00:56:13.435 --> 00:56:13.875
He did.

1032
00:56:14.135 --> 00:56:15.276
No, he just got married.

1033
00:56:15.556 --> 00:56:18.197
He got married in Monaco.

1034
00:56:18.437 --> 00:56:21.159
He's a Monogasque, a native Monaco driver.

1035
00:56:21.519 --> 00:56:24.081
Most drivers go there for the tax reasons.

1036
00:56:24.121 --> 00:56:24.401
He was...

1037
00:56:24.501 --> 00:56:38.802
born there I was born in it yeah yeah he was born in it exactly Ferrari had a great testing in Bahrain Charles Leclerc was one second clear of Mercedes George Russell okay

1038
00:56:40.063 --> 00:56:48.549
I know everyone's going to be like, oh, during testing, everyone is like, you know, they're putting artificial masses on their car and they're like gaming the system to not.

1039
00:56:48.889 --> 00:56:50.630
But a second is crazy.

1040
00:56:51.311 --> 00:56:59.036
And what gives me hope is that Haas, which is an American team that is an engine customer of Ferrari.

1041
00:56:59.276 --> 00:57:01.878
So Ferrari's engine is the same engine that's in the Haas industry.

1042
00:57:03.098 --> 00:57:22.823
in the Haas car Haas is also doing really well during testing so that's like it's like a you know in science we look for coincident data to to suggest that there's an underlying invariant right and as a scientist i'm just saying ferrari is bad okay and dude we're we're we're gonna run away with it it's gonna be amazing

1043
00:57:23.103 --> 00:57:28.268
Can I ask a quick question before we continue, which is, did the wing thing get figured out?

1044
00:57:28.308 --> 00:57:28.788
No, no, no.

1045
00:57:28.828 --> 00:57:30.770
Ferrari has an amazing wing.

1046
00:57:30.850 --> 00:57:31.831
I don't know if we're going to...

1047
00:57:31.911 --> 00:57:32.792
The upside down thing?

1048
00:57:32.812 --> 00:57:33.192
Yeah, yeah.

1049
00:57:33.212 --> 00:57:38.977
So Ferrari has a wing that flips when it goes from a curve to a straight.

1050
00:57:39.338 --> 00:57:41.179
We don't have DRS this season because...

1051
00:57:41.399 --> 00:57:45.883
So for those who are also listening, Formula One is all about the formula, right?

1052
00:57:45.963 --> 00:57:47.104
Which is the...

1053
00:57:47.925 --> 00:58:08.614
regulations that the formula one gods produce saying these are the rules for how you can build a car and then every car manufacturer looks at those rules and says where can we read between the lines and create little efficiencies that others might not and ferrari figured out that there's nothing against the

1054
00:58:09.717 --> 00:58:15.884
building a rear wing that will entirely flip 180 degrees, depending on what part of a racetrack you're on.

1055
00:58:15.924 --> 00:58:18.988
Because during straights, you want low drag,

1056
00:58:21.037 --> 00:58:22.198
because you just want to go straight.

1057
00:58:22.638 --> 00:58:29.163
During curves, you want high downforce, because you want more grip so that you can take corners faster.

1058
00:58:29.644 --> 00:58:36.609
And those two can have different wing configurations on the rear wing, based on the aerodynamics that you get, and so on and so forth.

1059
00:58:36.929 --> 00:58:40.472
And most people just have a flap that goes like this, and then goes down.

1060
00:58:40.512 --> 00:58:41.473
This thing is going...

1061
00:58:42.525 --> 00:58:44.728
is turning around 180 degrees.

1062
00:58:45.028 --> 00:58:47.051
And all these other teams were like, yeah, we thought of that.

1063
00:58:47.171 --> 00:58:47.851
I know you didn't.

1064
00:58:48.312 --> 00:58:49.533
You didn't think of that, okay?

1065
00:58:49.834 --> 00:58:53.538
Okay, you saw it, and you're like, oh, we better, like, cover our... No, you didn't think of that.

1066
00:58:53.618 --> 00:58:55.300
Ferrari thought of that.

1067
00:58:55.500 --> 00:58:55.961
That's right.

1068
00:58:56.501 --> 00:58:59.845
Anyways, I'm going off about Ferrari because this next...

1069
00:59:00.628 --> 00:59:01.810
I'm going to bring it back to science.

1070
00:59:01.910 --> 00:59:02.210
Okay.

1071
00:59:02.611 --> 00:59:02.871
Okay.

1072
00:59:03.152 --> 00:59:07.939
This next rundown study is from the University of Padua in Italy.

1073
00:59:07.959 --> 00:59:08.420
Okay.

1074
00:59:08.500 --> 00:59:09.782
It was out in the journal Science.

1075
00:59:09.882 --> 00:59:10.123
Okay.

1076
00:59:10.623 --> 00:59:12.026
And that's the connection to Italy.

1077
00:59:12.186 --> 00:59:12.426
Okay.

1078
00:59:14.533 --> 00:59:14.893
That's it.

1079
00:59:15.214 --> 00:59:17.936
I just wanted to go on a rant about how Ferrari's going to win.

1080
00:59:18.597 --> 00:59:21.980
But, dude, this paper is pretty insane.

1081
00:59:22.121 --> 00:59:22.381
Okay.

1082
00:59:22.701 --> 00:59:25.684
Because it didn't make any sense to me why it should be possible.

1083
00:59:25.944 --> 00:59:28.207
Have you ever heard of something called the Boba Kiki effect?

1084
00:59:28.987 --> 00:59:30.349
I only know about Kiki.

1085
00:59:30.709 --> 00:59:31.530
Do you love me?

1086
00:59:31.970 --> 00:59:32.671
Are you riding?

1087
00:59:32.731 --> 00:59:34.112
But I don't know about the Boba Kiki.

1088
00:59:34.132 --> 00:59:34.413
All right.

1089
00:59:34.433 --> 00:59:36.194
So let's pull up the overlay.

1090
00:59:36.214 --> 00:59:36.355
Okay.

1091
00:59:36.375 --> 00:59:36.655
Okay.

1092
00:59:36.855 --> 00:59:37.195
Okay.

1093
00:59:37.375 --> 00:59:37.675
All right?

1094
00:59:38.376 --> 00:59:40.997
So you see the two shapes.

1095
00:59:41.597 --> 00:59:44.038
There's a green sort of blobby shape.

1096
00:59:44.218 --> 00:59:44.418
Yeah.

1097
00:59:44.699 --> 00:59:46.759
And then there's a blue pointed shape.

1098
00:59:46.920 --> 00:59:47.240
Okay.

1099
00:59:47.360 --> 00:59:51.922
And just for listeners, so we're looking at an image that currently, can I say this?

1100
00:59:51.962 --> 00:59:52.482
Yeah, go ahead.

1101
00:59:52.542 --> 00:59:52.722
Okay.

1102
00:59:52.742 --> 00:59:52.922
Yeah.

1103
00:59:53.162 --> 00:59:58.665
So it currently has what appeared to be two baby chickens or birds of some kind or ducks.

1104
01:00:00.426 --> 01:00:05.950
in the middle, and these two shapes at the top right and left-hand corners.

1105
01:00:06.551 --> 01:00:09.313
The one on the left is a green blob.

1106
01:00:09.333 --> 01:00:11.395
The one on the right is like a blue star kind of thing.

1107
01:00:11.415 --> 01:00:12.156
Star kind of thing.

1108
01:00:12.176 --> 01:00:13.216
Pointy.

1109
01:00:13.256 --> 01:00:15.598
Which one is Boba and which one is Kiki for those shapes?

1110
01:00:16.119 --> 01:00:19.902
Oh, Boba's obviously the blob and Kiki is obviously the thing.

1111
01:00:19.942 --> 01:00:20.802
Why did you say that?

1112
01:00:21.243 --> 01:00:23.405
Oh, because in my head, I don't know, Kiki is like

1113
01:00:26.487 --> 01:00:26.707
Yeah.

1114
01:00:26.787 --> 01:00:27.087
It's like...

1115
01:00:27.107 --> 01:00:27.667
It's pointy.

1116
01:00:27.707 --> 01:00:28.308
It's pointy.

1117
01:00:28.348 --> 01:00:28.588
Yeah.

1118
01:00:29.008 --> 01:00:30.988
Boba is blobby.

1119
01:00:31.448 --> 01:00:32.249
That's exactly right.

1120
01:00:32.349 --> 01:00:34.309
Like, phonetically?

1121
01:00:34.389 --> 01:00:34.789
Yeah.

1122
01:00:35.010 --> 01:00:36.610
And this is the Boba Kiki effect.

1123
01:00:36.730 --> 01:00:37.610
Oh, is it really?

1124
01:00:37.730 --> 01:00:39.111
That's entirely what it is.

1125
01:00:39.191 --> 01:00:41.391
If anyone said the blue was Boba, you're crazy.

1126
01:00:41.451 --> 01:00:42.992
No, literally nobody does.

1127
01:00:43.172 --> 01:00:44.412
But here's what's crazy.

1128
01:00:44.552 --> 01:00:44.772
Okay.

1129
01:00:44.792 --> 01:00:49.214
You know, you would think that, okay, maybe we're... You know, we grew up in a Western society.

1130
01:00:49.654 --> 01:00:50.154
We are...

1131
01:00:51.838 --> 01:00:54.781
We are exposed to Western language.

1132
01:00:54.801 --> 01:00:55.001
Yes.

1133
01:00:55.301 --> 01:00:57.023
And so perhaps that has something to do with it.

1134
01:00:57.243 --> 01:00:57.784
That makes sense.

1135
01:00:57.804 --> 01:01:04.390
No, they have done research with multiple language groups, most famously the Tamil language group, which is in India, South India.

1136
01:01:04.650 --> 01:01:08.214
That is an entirely different language group from English.

1137
01:01:08.314 --> 01:01:10.175
English comes from the Indo-European family.

1138
01:01:11.028 --> 01:01:11.868
These guys are Tamils.

1139
01:01:11.888 --> 01:01:15.991
They're not even Hindi because Hindi and Sanskrit still comes from the Indo-European family.

1140
01:01:16.591 --> 01:01:19.813
The Tamil language comes from the Dravidian family, which is native to India.

1141
01:01:20.153 --> 01:01:23.975
It is completely separate from Indo-European family language.

1142
01:01:24.295 --> 01:01:27.777
And they still believe that the left is Boba and the right is Kiki.

1143
01:01:27.997 --> 01:01:30.719
You go to other cultures entirely...

1144
01:01:31.419 --> 01:01:32.299
Boba Kiki works.

1145
01:01:32.559 --> 01:01:34.660
You go to infants, Boba Kiki works.

1146
01:01:35.000 --> 01:01:45.223
So it was thought that this Boba Kiki effect, meaning Boba goes to blobby, rounder things and Kiki goes to pointier things, is something that is innate within human language.

1147
01:01:45.643 --> 01:01:45.923
Okay?

1148
01:01:45.963 --> 01:01:46.404
Interesting.

1149
01:01:46.424 --> 01:01:47.564
Across human languages.

1150
01:01:48.084 --> 01:01:49.385
And so far, so good.

1151
01:01:49.886 --> 01:01:51.307
Until this paper.

1152
01:01:51.427 --> 01:02:00.774
This paper played recordings of humans saying either Boba or Kiki to naive three-day-old chicks and presented them with two panels that had food behind it.

1153
01:02:01.195 --> 01:02:01.575
Okay.

1154
01:02:02.556 --> 01:02:06.399
And the chicks knew which one was Boba and which one was Kiki.

1155
01:02:06.419 --> 01:02:07.419
Shut the front door.

1156
01:02:07.560 --> 01:02:11.543
These are three-day-old chicks that had the Boba Kiki effect.

1157
01:02:12.648 --> 01:02:13.410
I don't believe it.

1158
01:02:13.570 --> 01:02:14.993
No, but it works.

1159
01:02:15.153 --> 01:02:16.375
That's so...

1160
01:02:16.676 --> 01:02:18.539
Meaning there is...

1161
01:02:18.599 --> 01:02:19.862
This is not a language thing.

1162
01:02:19.942 --> 01:02:21.024
It's not a language thing.

1163
01:02:21.044 --> 01:02:21.886
That's what's key, yeah.

1164
01:02:21.946 --> 01:02:22.627
This is like...

1165
01:02:23.351 --> 01:02:31.879
There is something inherent in the sound of Boba versus Kiki that maps onto the architecture of physical objects.

1166
01:02:32.500 --> 01:02:34.381
Okay?

1167
01:02:34.462 --> 01:02:36.163
And you can start thinking, like, why?

1168
01:02:36.263 --> 01:02:39.506
And actually, it doesn't seem that weird anymore.

1169
01:02:39.787 --> 01:02:48.234
When you start thinking about the physics of sound and the physics of Boba and Kiki, the word Boba and the sound Buh-

1170
01:02:49.153 --> 01:02:50.294
That's lower frequency.

1171
01:02:50.495 --> 01:02:51.917
You associate that with bass.

1172
01:02:52.017 --> 01:02:52.257
Yep.

1173
01:02:52.377 --> 01:02:52.597
Right?

1174
01:02:52.898 --> 01:02:53.058
Yep.

1175
01:02:53.258 --> 01:02:56.943
Kiki is like the ding, like the high frequencies.

1176
01:02:57.043 --> 01:02:57.223
Yeah.

1177
01:02:57.984 --> 01:03:04.352
Rounder objects, when sound goes through them, the higher frequencies are going to sort of get absorbed.

1178
01:03:04.372 --> 01:03:04.873
Yeah.

1179
01:03:05.273 --> 01:03:10.177
Around that, the rounder frequencies are going to get deflected and so forth and so on and so forth.

1180
01:03:10.457 --> 01:03:14.399
The sharper an interface is on the physics of an object, right?

1181
01:03:14.960 --> 01:03:18.843
The sharper the sound that is going to come out of that object.

1182
01:03:18.903 --> 01:03:20.804
Just because of the way sound is, all right?

1183
01:03:20.844 --> 01:03:27.649
The sharper the thing is, the shorter the wavelength, the shorter the wavelength, the higher the frequency, the more we get that ding sound.

1184
01:03:28.458 --> 01:03:28.678
Right.

1185
01:03:28.958 --> 01:03:34.842
It's literally just Fourier analysis is what we would think if someone's an electrical or sound engineer.

1186
01:03:35.523 --> 01:03:39.305
It's like the Fourier analysis of sound around the physics of objects.

1187
01:03:39.645 --> 01:03:43.127
The smoother an object is, the basier the sound that comes out.

1188
01:03:44.148 --> 01:03:49.752
And so even chicks, their brains, three day old chicks, their brains.

1189
01:03:50.524 --> 01:03:58.194
There's some innate physics calculation that's happening within them that's saying the higher frequency has to come from a pointier object.

1190
01:03:58.965 --> 01:03:59.806
That is so...

1191
01:04:00.206 --> 01:04:01.327
It's so weird.

1192
01:04:01.467 --> 01:04:02.168
Unbelievable.

1193
01:04:02.368 --> 01:04:05.490
But the way that you explained it does... Yeah, then it kind of makes sense.

1194
01:04:05.510 --> 01:04:06.631
Then it kind of makes sense.

1195
01:04:06.831 --> 01:04:13.917
What I'm surprised about is that a three-day-old chick has neural mechanisms within its brain to make that distinction.

1196
01:04:14.317 --> 01:04:21.063
That this is so invariant across anyone that has brains, I guess, because this is not even a mammal.

1197
01:04:21.243 --> 01:04:21.903
Right.

1198
01:04:22.023 --> 01:04:22.244
Right?

1199
01:04:22.304 --> 01:04:24.425
This thing diverged very, very far away from us.

1200
01:04:24.445 --> 01:04:24.706
That's...

1201
01:04:24.906 --> 01:04:27.488
Hundreds of millions of years ago, before the dinosaurs.

1202
01:04:27.508 --> 01:04:27.788
Yeah.

1203
01:04:28.733 --> 01:04:30.694
There's a deeper architecture here.

1204
01:04:30.774 --> 01:04:31.454
Yeah.

1205
01:04:31.634 --> 01:04:32.775
There's a deeper... Not architecture.

1206
01:04:32.795 --> 01:04:37.156
There's a deeper insight about why that would be true.

1207
01:04:37.336 --> 01:04:37.556
Yeah.

1208
01:04:37.696 --> 01:04:51.121
Not only because of the cross-species level similarities, but also that you don't need brains that have developed for a long amount of time to have some sort of like...

1209
01:04:52.050 --> 01:04:55.656
you know, learned understanding of the physics of the universe.

1210
01:04:55.696 --> 01:04:55.936
Yeah.

1211
01:04:56.016 --> 01:04:56.197
Yeah.

1212
01:04:56.237 --> 01:05:00.884
They've just made this association because like over the years, this is what's true, right?

1213
01:05:00.904 --> 01:05:01.085
Right.

1214
01:05:01.105 --> 01:05:05.852
The buzz sound comes from rounder objects and the cause sound comes from pointier objects.

1215
01:05:06.053 --> 01:05:06.273
Right.

1216
01:05:06.791 --> 01:05:15.340
And it's like even like a short, a small neural network that we train with reinforcement learning, for example, would come up with the Boba Kiki effect.

1217
01:05:15.400 --> 01:05:20.866
Where let's say the input of this neural network was the sound and then the output was a decision between the two.

1218
01:05:21.006 --> 01:05:25.110
Through reinforcement learning, it would learn that the lower frequencies are the rounder frequencies.

1219
01:05:25.270 --> 01:05:50.452
things that but the fact that like you know we did this going all the way back to our common ancestor between birds and mammals which is 100 million years plus and before the dinosaurs and it's still true and it's yeah yeah and it's it's across all these animals right i think that's so cool that to think about and also what a weird experiment to run yeah right like who was like hey let's test boba and kiki

1220
01:05:52.097 --> 01:05:52.798
On baby chicks.

1221
01:05:52.998 --> 01:05:57.941
Who knew Drake was so attuned to Frontier Science Research when he made that song?

1222
01:05:58.241 --> 01:05:58.521
Mm-hmm.

1223
01:05:59.102 --> 01:06:00.082
Whatever that song's called.

1224
01:06:00.122 --> 01:06:00.983
Do you love me?

1225
01:06:01.963 --> 01:06:03.825
Four great rundown stories.

1226
01:06:04.905 --> 01:06:12.250
We're going to jump now back into our main story, our second story of the day, which is around Alzheimer's research.

1227
01:06:12.630 --> 01:06:13.471
This one's very cool.

1228
01:06:13.851 --> 01:06:19.315
So this one is a health and medicine story about Alzheimer's disease and exercise.

1229
01:06:19.615 --> 01:06:19.775
Yeah.

1230
01:06:19.795 --> 01:06:19.895
Yeah.

1231
01:06:19.955 --> 01:06:23.856
So scientists think they figured out exactly how exercise reduces the risk of Alzheimer's.

1232
01:06:23.976 --> 01:06:34.318
It reports a new paper in cell by a group out of the University of California, San Francisco, in this Bacar Aging Research Institute.

1233
01:06:34.778 --> 01:06:37.079
And so we've actually done a lot.

1234
01:06:37.119 --> 01:06:38.439
I mean, we just did last episode.

1235
01:06:38.459 --> 01:06:40.620
We did something on ALS.

1236
01:06:40.660 --> 01:06:44.141
We've talked about Alzheimer's research, I think, multiple times.

1237
01:06:44.181 --> 01:06:44.801
Yeah, multiple times.

1238
01:06:44.821 --> 01:06:46.561
Multiple times on the pod previously.

1239
01:06:50.763 --> 01:06:55.529
millions of people, families, siblings, co-workers, etc.

1240
01:06:56.050 --> 01:07:00.276
And so there's a link between the disease and exercise.

1241
01:07:00.336 --> 01:07:01.597
I'm curious what that link is.

1242
01:07:01.617 --> 01:07:05.663
Yeah, and I mean, it's not like that surprising that exercise...

1243
01:07:07.190 --> 01:07:08.251
Is good for you.

1244
01:07:08.891 --> 01:07:09.112
Right.

1245
01:07:09.412 --> 01:07:10.453
This is something we've known.

1246
01:07:10.833 --> 01:07:12.874
But what I love about this study.

1247
01:07:12.995 --> 01:07:13.455
Is we've.

1248
01:07:13.935 --> 01:07:14.195
Again.

1249
01:07:14.316 --> 01:07:15.396
It's about the mechanism.

1250
01:07:15.857 --> 01:07:17.718
It's the Lego blocks that are coming together.

1251
01:07:18.239 --> 01:07:20.320
There's a pathway from exercise.

1252
01:07:20.821 --> 01:07:22.742
To the biochemistry of Alzheimer's.

1253
01:07:23.162 --> 01:07:24.423
That these guys have traced.

1254
01:07:24.603 --> 01:07:24.924
Okay.

1255
01:07:24.964 --> 01:07:25.444
From the.

1256
01:07:25.924 --> 01:07:27.105
From me running.

1257
01:07:27.706 --> 01:07:29.407
To me not getting Alzheimer's.

1258
01:07:29.767 --> 01:07:30.988
Or getting Alzheimer's later.

1259
01:07:31.188 --> 01:07:31.469
Okay.

1260
01:07:31.509 --> 01:07:32.550
And that biochemical.

1261
01:07:32.570 --> 01:07:32.670
Okay.

1262
01:07:33.350 --> 01:07:36.373
string of Lego blocks is what is super interesting to me.

1263
01:07:36.813 --> 01:07:37.393
Okay.

1264
01:07:38.254 --> 01:07:42.317
We potentially have a discovery of the pathway by which this is happening.

1265
01:07:42.357 --> 01:07:49.323
Yes, because if we have a discovery of the pathway, the biochemistry of what this is happening, then perhaps we can get the benefits of...

1266
01:07:49.680 --> 01:07:50.620
Without the exercise.

1267
01:07:50.640 --> 01:07:51.560
Right, right, right.

1268
01:07:51.620 --> 01:07:58.582
Because we understand the mechanistic dynamics that are driving the process.

1269
01:07:58.802 --> 01:08:04.783
And this could be huge because then for people who maybe can't do exercise but have Alzheimer's, this could be a big thing.

1270
01:08:05.163 --> 01:08:08.563
Or for those who want to do exercise but get added benefit, you know, a boost.

1271
01:08:08.683 --> 01:08:09.364
It's huge, right?

1272
01:08:09.644 --> 01:08:09.884
Okay.

1273
01:08:10.024 --> 01:08:10.224
Okay.

1274
01:08:10.244 --> 01:08:11.504
So we're going to start with the human brain.

1275
01:08:11.904 --> 01:08:13.104
80 billion neurons.

1276
01:08:13.604 --> 01:08:16.305
It's the most complex object in the universe.

1277
01:08:16.325 --> 01:08:16.705
Okay.

1278
01:08:17.760 --> 01:08:23.044
And stuff can go wrong because it is the most recent of our organs to evolve, right?

1279
01:08:23.244 --> 01:08:28.548
Most of the mutations that create human beings have to do with brain development.

1280
01:08:28.788 --> 01:08:34.432
And what that necessarily means is the brain is going to have a lot of stuff go wrong because it's still in the phase of...

1281
01:08:35.414 --> 01:08:55.187
the genetics is trying stuff out we're in the beta version right yeah we're still in the beta version even though the beta version is doing really well like but but the no one's turned off the the code um like edits yeah it's like no one's frozen the main yeah yeah you know github people people are still merging branches exactly it's like it's like no no we're doing like

1282
01:08:55.267 --> 01:08:56.228
We're okay.

1283
01:08:56.268 --> 01:08:57.168
Can we stop?

1284
01:08:57.208 --> 01:08:58.449
We have some bug fixing to do.

1285
01:08:58.509 --> 01:08:59.250
Yeah, exactly.

1286
01:08:59.310 --> 01:09:03.333
And so the bug fixing is what's crucial, and it happens a lot later on in life.

1287
01:09:03.793 --> 01:09:06.575
And for a long time, the brain is sort of studied in isolation.

1288
01:09:06.595 --> 01:09:13.020
There's like a – you imagine like the brain is an island, and we think about the mind, and everything that's happening in the brain is isolated to the brain.

1289
01:09:14.221 --> 01:09:22.707
But very recently, that has progressed to be the brain, the mind, and the body are connected, and we need to figure out a holistic approach.

1290
01:09:23.899 --> 01:09:48.036
understanding of the entire system right and that's where this research comes in they've identified a biochemical pathway that links the liver to the blood to the brain and it shows the systemic benefits of exercise and how they are transformed or transferred to the brain without actually having to do exercise that's the idea oh my goodness okay and it's it's able to it's able to

1291
01:09:49.610 --> 01:09:53.333
trace the entire story from exercise to brain benefits.

1292
01:09:53.673 --> 01:09:53.933
Okay?

1293
01:09:54.193 --> 01:10:04.761
The mechanism is from a particular enzyme that I'm only going to say once because these biochemists and organic chemistry people, they love just making the world's longest word.

1294
01:10:05.441 --> 01:10:08.243
I think that's what they're going for, is like Guinness Book of World Records.

1295
01:10:08.283 --> 01:10:09.204
Anyways, here we go.

1296
01:10:09.224 --> 01:10:09.664
Okay, guys?

1297
01:10:09.985 --> 01:10:15.789
It's called glycosylphosphatidylonocytol, specific glycosylphosphatidylonocytol,

1298
01:10:17.730 --> 01:10:20.072
phospholipase D1.

1299
01:10:20.552 --> 01:10:25.937
We are going to refer to this enzyme throughout our story as GPLD1.

1300
01:10:26.277 --> 01:10:35.365
So whenever you hear me say that word, that is the particular enzyme that we have discovered in the liver and all of its benefits all the way up to the brain.

1301
01:10:35.918 --> 01:10:44.022
I just want to take a brief note to distinguish that although it has all of the same letters with a couple of extras.

1302
01:10:44.042 --> 01:10:44.803
Yes, it's not Ozempic.

1303
01:10:44.843 --> 01:10:45.583
Is that where you're going?

1304
01:10:45.683 --> 01:10:47.844
It is not a G. We're not talking about GLP-1.

1305
01:10:47.884 --> 01:10:48.064
Yes.

1306
01:10:48.124 --> 01:10:49.785
This is GPLD-1.

1307
01:10:50.085 --> 01:10:50.666
Exactly.

1308
01:10:50.686 --> 01:10:50.806
Yes.

1309
01:10:50.866 --> 01:10:51.746
So those are different things.

1310
01:10:51.766 --> 01:10:52.807
Those are very different things.

1311
01:10:52.967 --> 01:10:53.927
GPLD-1.

1312
01:10:53.967 --> 01:10:54.948
This is not Ozempic.

1313
01:10:55.268 --> 01:11:00.591
And what it does is act on blood vessels surrounding the brain to repair age-related damage.

1314
01:11:01.371 --> 01:11:02.612
And that's what we're going to get into.

1315
01:11:02.812 --> 01:11:06.494
So this is like a cleanup crew that goes in to fix stuff.

1316
01:11:06.834 --> 01:11:07.074
Mm-hmm.

1317
01:11:08.455 --> 01:11:10.296
But the way they fix stuff is very interesting.

1318
01:11:10.336 --> 01:11:10.616
Okay.

1319
01:11:10.836 --> 01:11:11.096
Okay?

1320
01:11:11.136 --> 01:11:13.177
And that's where the Lego blocks comes in.

1321
01:11:13.237 --> 01:11:13.497
Okay.

1322
01:11:13.537 --> 01:11:14.478
And that's what I like about it.

1323
01:11:14.798 --> 01:11:14.998
All right.

1324
01:11:15.018 --> 01:11:16.519
So let's talk about Alzheimer's real quick.

1325
01:11:18.220 --> 01:11:23.423
Most common cause of dementia, 60% to 70% of all cases of dementia are Alzheimer's.

1326
01:11:24.003 --> 01:11:27.225
Globally, there's about 50 million people living with dementia.

1327
01:11:27.265 --> 01:11:27.425
Okay.

1328
01:11:28.165 --> 01:11:29.226
Right now in 2021.

1329
01:11:29.507 --> 01:11:33.791
And if we look at a 2050 projection in the future, right, people are living longer.

1330
01:11:34.232 --> 01:11:37.835
And if people are living longer, these age-related diseases are going to go up.

1331
01:11:38.216 --> 01:11:45.263
And so by 2050, there's projections of 100 to 150 million individuals globally.

1332
01:11:45.503 --> 01:11:49.548
That's nearly triple of today living through these symptoms.

1333
01:11:49.808 --> 01:11:50.188
Okay?

1334
01:11:50.208 --> 01:11:50.388
Okay.

1335
01:11:51.272 --> 01:11:53.273
Black Americans are two times more likely.

1336
01:11:53.714 --> 01:11:57.116
Hispanic Americans are 1.5 times more likely.

1337
01:11:57.616 --> 01:12:02.420
Women make up approximately two-thirds of the U.S. Alzheimer's population.

1338
01:12:02.480 --> 01:12:07.823
Yeah, and nearly twice the risk, lifetime risk, versus men at the age of 65.

1339
01:12:08.104 --> 01:12:10.045
So there's a lot of these disparities that go on.

1340
01:12:10.325 --> 01:12:12.226
We still don't know much about why.

1341
01:12:12.287 --> 01:12:14.288
I mean, you can imagine economic and social...

1342
01:12:14.628 --> 01:12:23.791
issues, diet issues with black Americans and Hispanic Americans versus white people who just they're in a different economic bracket on average.

1343
01:12:24.271 --> 01:12:32.513
So these on average statistics comes through and it's a big crisis in medicine to figure out what is going on and how do we help it.

1344
01:12:33.053 --> 01:12:37.374
It was first identified in 1906 by Dr. Alois Alzheimer.

1345
01:12:37.534 --> 01:12:38.635
He was a German doctor.

1346
01:12:39.235 --> 01:12:42.556
He identified these extracellular amyloid plaques

1347
01:12:43.256 --> 01:12:44.536
in patients with dementia.

1348
01:12:45.897 --> 01:12:50.138
And since then, we've been studying these things called amyloid plaques.

1349
01:12:50.578 --> 01:12:56.579
The idea is you've got this accumulation of a protein called beta amyloid, okay?

1350
01:12:56.780 --> 01:12:59.760
There are these peptides, and that's the primary cause.

1351
01:13:00.120 --> 01:13:06.702
You get a bunch of amyloid precursor proteins, so this is whatever is the precursor to amyloid.

1352
01:13:07.222 --> 01:13:09.463
They denature in some way, and they

1353
01:13:10.363 --> 01:13:11.964
get together, right?

1354
01:13:12.184 --> 01:13:16.646
And when they get together, they create these plaques of amyloid.

1355
01:13:16.986 --> 01:13:20.527
And those plaques then get in the way of all of the neural machinery.

1356
01:13:20.908 --> 01:13:22.088
I get you.

1357
01:13:22.728 --> 01:13:28.531
There's a highway, and then these roadblocks just start auto-generating and blocking the flow of stuff.

1358
01:13:28.651 --> 01:13:30.352
Yeah, and there was genetic link, right?

1359
01:13:30.392 --> 01:13:35.614
Because early-onset familial Alzheimer's was caused by mutations in this protein.

1360
01:13:35.774 --> 01:13:36.054
Got it.

1361
01:13:36.074 --> 01:13:37.275
In the gene for this protein.

1362
01:13:37.455 --> 01:13:37.735
Got it.

1363
01:13:38.015 --> 01:13:41.364
So you can imagine, okay, that seems like something that we should target.

1364
01:13:43.602 --> 01:13:51.346
There was a big discrepancy between targeting this pathway and actual clinical advantage.

1365
01:13:51.466 --> 01:13:52.266
Okay.

1366
01:13:52.927 --> 01:13:59.690
The drug failure rate from 2002 to 2012 is something like 99.6%.

1367
01:13:59.970 --> 01:14:08.615
And even today, like this is a headline from last year, Novo Nordisk shares plunge after the Alzheimer's drug trial fails to hit the key target.

1368
01:14:08.735 --> 01:14:09.175
Interesting.

1369
01:14:09.195 --> 01:14:22.678
Okay, so there's so much research that is going into Alzheimer's, but when we try stuff in animal studies, when we try stuff in a Petri dish, and then when we go in and try to fix the myeloid crisis in the brain of patients, it doesn't quite work.

1370
01:14:22.718 --> 01:14:25.658
There's only a weak correlation, it turns out, the more of the research we do.

1371
01:14:25.938 --> 01:14:30.839
There's only a weak correlation between the total plaque load in the brain and cognitive severity.

1372
01:14:30.879 --> 01:14:38.001
Because the more and more that we've been able to do brain scans of healthy patients, we figured out that some of these healthy patients...

1373
01:14:38.601 --> 01:14:57.332
Have a myeloid plaques So that can't be the whole story It's not a single source It's not the single source of the problem It may be part of it Yeah, but it can't be that Oh, a myeloid plaque, One Direction Causes Alzheimer's Because there's plenty of people that have a myeloid plaques That don't have Alzheimer's Okay?

1374
01:14:57.512 --> 01:14:57.672
Mm-hmm

1375
01:14:58.112 --> 01:15:05.136
Furthermore, there's a timing problem because the amyloid plaques, they start accumulating like 20 years before the actual symptoms.

1376
01:15:05.196 --> 01:15:09.719
So by the time you've got the symptom and you're trying to treat this thing, it's like the forest fire has already started.

1377
01:15:09.779 --> 01:15:09.979
Yeah.

1378
01:15:10.379 --> 01:15:10.859
Yeah.

1379
01:15:10.879 --> 01:15:11.059
Right.

1380
01:15:11.199 --> 01:15:11.400
Yep.

1381
01:15:11.500 --> 01:15:11.900
That tracks.

1382
01:15:11.920 --> 01:15:12.180
Yeah.

1383
01:15:12.776 --> 01:15:22.138
And so there's been recent approval of certain drugs, but it only shows a modestly slow decline in early stage patients.

1384
01:15:22.178 --> 01:15:22.978
But it's not a cure.

1385
01:15:23.058 --> 01:15:25.338
It doesn't reverse the effects of Alzheimer's.

1386
01:15:25.498 --> 01:15:25.678
Right.

1387
01:15:26.018 --> 01:15:30.439
And sometimes it carries risks like brain swelling and hemorrhage.

1388
01:15:30.899 --> 01:15:33.980
So this amyloid paradigm is really under pressure.

1389
01:15:34.440 --> 01:15:34.620
Right.

1390
01:15:34.860 --> 01:15:38.721
And we need to find a new way to figure out what's going wrong in Alzheimer's brains.

1391
01:15:39.121 --> 01:15:41.141
And is there a way to reverse the effects?

1392
01:15:41.241 --> 01:15:43.723
Not just stop, not just slow down, but reverse.

1393
01:15:44.284 --> 01:15:54.292
Because, I mean, even just looking at this data, the drug failure rate that you mentioned of 99.6% was across almost over 200 programs in a 10-year time span.

1394
01:15:54.312 --> 01:15:54.512
Yeah.

1395
01:15:54.792 --> 01:15:57.374
So it's not like it's from a lack of trying.

1396
01:15:57.534 --> 01:15:57.935
No, no.

1397
01:15:57.975 --> 01:16:03.900
It's like we're trying, but the fundamental issue we're having is maybe the philosophy with which we're going about.

1398
01:16:04.643 --> 01:16:04.883
Right.

1399
01:16:04.943 --> 01:16:05.163
This.

1400
01:16:05.704 --> 01:16:09.726
If you're the Dallas Cowboys, you're like, why haven't we been to the playoffs in 30 years?

1401
01:16:09.766 --> 01:16:13.129
It's like you're looking at everything but the source of the problem, which might be, you know.

1402
01:16:13.729 --> 01:16:14.049
Yeah.

1403
01:16:14.449 --> 01:16:15.330
Or if you're Ferrari.

1404
01:16:15.470 --> 01:16:16.431
Yeah.

1405
01:16:16.491 --> 01:16:16.931
Never mind.

1406
01:16:16.951 --> 01:16:17.812
That's a source.

1407
01:16:17.872 --> 01:16:19.373
For another day.

1408
01:16:19.473 --> 01:16:19.713
Yeah.

1409
01:16:19.913 --> 01:16:20.994
I don't want to get into that.

1410
01:16:21.014 --> 01:16:21.554
We're doing well.

1411
01:16:21.614 --> 01:16:22.195
It's going to be fine.

1412
01:16:22.395 --> 01:16:22.995
Anyways.

1413
01:16:23.015 --> 01:16:26.517
So we need to change the way that we're approaching this problem.

1414
01:16:26.577 --> 01:16:26.818
Right.

1415
01:16:26.918 --> 01:16:27.138
Okay.

1416
01:16:27.378 --> 01:16:29.940
So now let's think about the brain from a mechanistic sense.

1417
01:16:30.140 --> 01:16:30.380
Okay.

1418
01:16:30.500 --> 01:16:32.962
The brain is only about 2% of the body mass.

1419
01:16:33.262 --> 01:16:33.402
Mm-hmm.

1420
01:16:33.702 --> 01:16:37.844
But it uses up 20% of the body's energy.

1421
01:16:38.324 --> 01:16:38.604
Okay?

1422
01:16:39.044 --> 01:16:43.386
All of that glucose, all of that oxygen, 20% is going to our brain.

1423
01:16:43.786 --> 01:16:44.046
Okay?

1424
01:16:44.606 --> 01:16:51.669
It's got about 400 miles of capillaries in our brain that is supplying energy to the neurons.

1425
01:16:52.709 --> 01:16:58.051
Now, all of that energy has to get through from the blood into the neurons.

1426
01:16:58.611 --> 01:16:58.832
Right?

1427
01:16:59.192 --> 01:17:02.033
And it has to go through something called the blood-brain barrier.

1428
01:17:02.293 --> 01:17:02.453
Mm-hmm.

1429
01:17:03.568 --> 01:17:08.030
This is an incredible plumbing system that we have in our brain.

1430
01:17:08.630 --> 01:17:08.891
Okay?

1431
01:17:09.191 --> 01:17:11.372
It's different from everywhere else in the body.

1432
01:17:11.812 --> 01:17:15.334
Everywhere else in the body, normal blood vessels, they carry blood.

1433
01:17:15.974 --> 01:17:16.234
Okay?

1434
01:17:16.794 --> 01:17:21.677
And they've got these, like, gaps where...

1435
01:17:22.663 --> 01:17:25.107
Stuff can go in, stuff can go out from the blood.

1436
01:17:25.408 --> 01:17:36.626
So, you know, hemoglobin can go through, oxygen can go through, glucose can go through, little tiny metabolites can go through from, let's say, our muscles to the blood back and forth.

1437
01:17:38.300 --> 01:17:42.682
The junctions in the piping are loose, literally.

1438
01:17:43.123 --> 01:17:45.704
There's like gaps.

1439
01:17:46.304 --> 01:17:51.227
In the blood-brain barrier, the junctions are what we call tight junctions.

1440
01:17:51.527 --> 01:17:57.030
These brain endothelial cells, which are the cells that line the blood vessels in our brain—

1441
01:17:57.570 --> 01:18:06.152
have tight junctions, and they're so tight that 99% of large molecules and 95% of small molecules do not make it through.

1442
01:18:06.492 --> 01:18:09.173
Not even glucose can go through unescorted.

1443
01:18:09.733 --> 01:18:18.956
There are literally things called transport proteins that have to take glucose from the blood through a special kind of passage into the brain.

1444
01:18:19.656 --> 01:18:20.697
It's like a clean room.

1445
01:18:21.598 --> 01:18:24.122
The analogy I think of, it's like flying.

1446
01:18:24.262 --> 01:18:27.786
Regular blood vessels are like flying back in the day where there's no TSA.

1447
01:18:27.846 --> 01:18:28.347
Yeah, dude.

1448
01:18:28.607 --> 01:18:29.228
Yeah.

1449
01:18:29.368 --> 01:18:30.930
But the blood-brain barrier is like TSA.

1450
01:18:30.970 --> 01:18:31.190
Yes.

1451
01:18:31.470 --> 01:18:32.231
It is exactly like.

1452
01:18:32.251 --> 01:18:33.132
Take your shoes off.

1453
01:18:33.192 --> 01:18:33.413
Yeah.

1454
01:18:33.693 --> 01:18:34.514
Got to scan your bags.

1455
01:18:34.534 --> 01:18:35.095
Yeah, yeah.

1456
01:18:35.976 --> 01:18:54.633
Random search Come to the back room Yeah exactly The brain is like Because the brain is like Arguably the most important thing for our humans Like there's a lot of security Between what's coming in And what's going out Which makes sense Totally makes sense And

1457
01:18:56.815 --> 01:19:08.679
If these blood-brain barriers fail, if these junctions fail, the tight junctions, if they become leaky like with normal blood vessels, then that's going to lead to nonspecific leakiness.

1458
01:19:08.979 --> 01:19:11.280
We're going to get inflammatory compounds that come in.

1459
01:19:11.560 --> 01:19:12.760
We're going to get cytokines.

1460
01:19:13.140 --> 01:19:18.642
That's going to drive neuroinflammation, and that's going to exacerbate any Alzheimer's-related pathology.

1461
01:19:18.762 --> 01:19:19.042
I see.

1462
01:19:19.062 --> 01:19:19.202
I see.

1463
01:19:19.262 --> 01:19:21.203
So now there's a new hypothesis here.

1464
01:19:21.463 --> 01:19:25.149
Not the amyloid hypothesis, but the vascular hypothesis.

1465
01:19:25.529 --> 01:19:34.022
This is the hypothesis that says systematic vascular disruption caused by aging, caused by high blood pressure...

1466
01:19:35.575 --> 01:19:38.077
That's going to loosen up the capillaries in our brain.

1467
01:19:38.737 --> 01:19:42.880
And that's actually a primary driver for neurodegradation.

1468
01:19:44.261 --> 01:19:44.541
Okay?

1469
01:19:44.601 --> 01:19:44.782
Yeah.

1470
01:19:44.942 --> 01:19:50.405
So the idea is we have two sort of thought processes here.

1471
01:19:50.886 --> 01:19:58.211
One is this myeloid plaque accumulation is the driver of this neurodegenerative stuff.

1472
01:19:58.972 --> 01:20:00.813
Then the other idea is that

1473
01:20:02.426 --> 01:20:15.735
The degradation of the blood blame barrier on the capillaries, the 400 miles of capillaries in your brain, is like the inciting incident that then enables a whole slew of derivative stuff.

1474
01:20:15.776 --> 01:20:16.016
Yes.

1475
01:20:16.076 --> 01:20:18.878
Like that is a – It's a precursor to the amyloid stuff.

1476
01:20:18.918 --> 01:20:19.438
Got it.

1477
01:20:19.458 --> 01:20:20.359
Ah, that's right.

1478
01:20:20.399 --> 01:20:20.999
Yes, right.

1479
01:20:21.219 --> 01:20:24.742
Like it's not just that the amyloid piece is not connected at all.

1480
01:20:24.902 --> 01:20:25.122
No, no.

1481
01:20:25.362 --> 01:20:26.323
But it's not the first.

1482
01:20:26.503 --> 01:20:27.384
It's not the first thing.

1483
01:20:27.804 --> 01:20:30.566
And perhaps there's something upstream that we can tackle.

1484
01:20:30.646 --> 01:20:30.967
Okay.

1485
01:20:30.987 --> 01:20:31.967
That we can put a dam on.

1486
01:20:32.248 --> 01:20:32.508
Okay.

1487
01:20:32.608 --> 01:20:32.828
Okay.

1488
01:20:33.008 --> 01:20:34.569
And usually this stuff is a hurdle, right?

1489
01:20:34.589 --> 01:20:39.293
Because the blood-brain barrier structurally prevents most drugs from reaching the brain.

1490
01:20:39.353 --> 01:20:39.553
Right.

1491
01:20:39.754 --> 01:20:39.934
Right?

1492
01:20:40.254 --> 01:20:40.955
We've heard about that.

1493
01:20:40.995 --> 01:20:43.617
Like, oh, this thing can cross the blood-brain barrier.

1494
01:20:43.877 --> 01:20:46.239
And then, like, the valuation goes up by a lot.

1495
01:20:46.259 --> 01:20:46.379
Right.

1496
01:20:46.379 --> 01:20:48.141
because it can cross the blood-brain barrier, right?

1497
01:20:48.601 --> 01:20:50.303
People are trying to do nanoparticles.

1498
01:20:50.323 --> 01:20:52.905
You might have heard of nanoparticles that go through the blood-brain barrier.

1499
01:20:53.225 --> 01:21:00.352
You can also do sonic disruption, where you send high-frequency sound, and that sound disrupts the blood-brain barrier.

1500
01:21:00.372 --> 01:21:05.316
But it's like, well, if we're trying to fix the blood-brain barrier, we don't want to... You know, it's like a...

1501
01:21:06.097 --> 01:21:07.799
Catch-22 type situation.

1502
01:21:07.819 --> 01:21:07.999
Yes.

1503
01:21:08.119 --> 01:21:16.006
And this particular paper is leveraging that hypothesis to actually treat the brain by targeting that blood-brain barrier itself.

1504
01:21:16.027 --> 01:21:17.168
You're not going to pass through it.

1505
01:21:17.448 --> 01:21:21.311
We're trying to repair the plumbing there.

1506
01:21:21.452 --> 01:21:21.652
Yes.

1507
01:21:22.012 --> 01:21:22.292
Okay?

1508
01:21:22.312 --> 01:21:22.473
Yes.

1509
01:21:23.013 --> 01:21:27.699
Now let's get into this particular paper in this particular lab at UCSF.

1510
01:21:28.160 --> 01:21:34.228
So they first started out by doing this technique called heterochronic parabiosis.

1511
01:21:34.688 --> 01:21:39.875
The idea is you take an old mouse and young mouse and you join up...

1512
01:21:40.516 --> 01:21:42.418
their vasculature, their blood.

1513
01:21:42.698 --> 01:21:42.958
Okay.

1514
01:21:43.118 --> 01:21:48.783
And so it's kind of like that thing on Netflix where, like, you know, the old guy is getting, like, the... Yeah, it's what Peter Thiel's doing, right?

1515
01:21:48.863 --> 01:21:51.605
Yeah, like the young person's blood.

1516
01:21:51.925 --> 01:21:54.367
Well, this is, like, the genesis of that.

1517
01:21:54.487 --> 01:21:54.787
Okay.

1518
01:21:54.927 --> 01:21:55.208
Okay?

1519
01:21:55.428 --> 01:22:03.074
They did this in Mice First, and the old mice that were exposed to the young blood showed neurological rejuvenation.

1520
01:22:03.454 --> 01:22:05.296
So new neurons, better memory.

1521
01:22:05.696 --> 01:22:08.138
It was actually reversing the effects of dementia.

1522
01:22:08.278 --> 01:22:09.059
Very interesting.

1523
01:22:09.119 --> 01:22:09.359
Okay?

1524
01:22:09.599 --> 01:22:14.312
The introduction of new blood was actually basically having neurological positive benefits.

1525
01:22:14.432 --> 01:22:14.854
Exactly.

1526
01:22:15.094 --> 01:22:17.060
And so now you can start thinking, well, okay –

1527
01:22:17.857 --> 01:22:20.958
maybe other interventions could make the blood young.

1528
01:22:21.438 --> 01:22:25.439
One of the easy things is aerobic exercise, right?

1529
01:22:25.940 --> 01:22:26.640
Like cardio.

1530
01:22:27.240 --> 01:22:28.440
It's a potent intervention.

1531
01:22:28.700 --> 01:22:30.121
It delays cognitive decline.

1532
01:22:30.401 --> 01:22:35.943
And maybe that cardio and exercise is doing something else to the blood that is causing that blood to rejuvenate.

1533
01:22:36.563 --> 01:22:38.924
Okay, I just want to pause really quick because I'm tracking.

1534
01:22:38.944 --> 01:22:45.926
So the idea is this heterochronic parabiosis is this idea of a younger person

1535
01:22:47.007 --> 01:23:09.010
rodent uh has better the blood is the blood is better it's better so if you're like reversing all this like stuff yeah and so if you put that younger rodent blood in an older rodent it makes the older rodent better like that's the first yeah that's the first thing we know that's true that yeah yeah you did the surgery you make them share blood boom it's done yeah and so

1536
01:23:11.497 --> 01:23:24.534
When we look at an activity like exercise, so the point is it's indicating that, oh, like the blood has an impact on neurological maintenance and growth and degradation.

1537
01:23:24.554 --> 01:23:25.155
Exactly, yeah.

1538
01:23:25.615 --> 01:23:28.579
And exercise impacts the blood.

1539
01:23:28.599 --> 01:23:28.880
Yeah.

1540
01:23:28.900 --> 01:23:29.060
Yeah.

1541
01:23:30.646 --> 01:23:33.229
The more you exercise, the more it keeps it sort of, let's say, youngish.

1542
01:23:33.289 --> 01:23:33.689
Exactly.

1543
01:23:33.789 --> 01:23:41.880
And actually, the exercise impacts the blood in a very specific way because they're signaling molecules that are released by our organs during exercise.

1544
01:23:41.900 --> 01:23:43.361
They're called exerkinds.

1545
01:23:43.922 --> 01:23:46.085
Kinds meaning like these signaling molecules.

1546
01:23:46.105 --> 01:23:47.827
Exer meaning it's coming from exercise.

1547
01:23:47.927 --> 01:23:48.107
Yes.

1548
01:23:48.227 --> 01:23:52.490
And examples are like irisin, which stimulates brain-derived neurotropic factors.

1549
01:23:52.890 --> 01:23:54.371
Neurons live longer that way.

1550
01:23:54.671 --> 01:23:56.072
There's more synaptic plasticity.

1551
01:23:56.112 --> 01:23:58.553
There's clustering, which reduces neuroinflammation.

1552
01:23:58.893 --> 01:24:01.415
So all of our organs are releasing this.

1553
01:24:01.495 --> 01:24:02.556
The muscles release stuff.

1554
01:24:02.816 --> 01:24:03.776
The heart releases stuff.

1555
01:24:03.796 --> 01:24:05.437
The kidneys, the liver releases stuff.

1556
01:24:05.717 --> 01:24:07.959
Even the bone releases stuff into our blood.

1557
01:24:08.499 --> 01:24:13.083
And these are all signaling factors that facilitate inter-organ communication.

1558
01:24:13.364 --> 01:24:17.548
Like if the brain wants to coordinate with the liver, the liver wants to coordinate with the kidneys and so on and so forth.

1559
01:24:17.908 --> 01:24:19.590
And all of this is happening in our blood.

1560
01:24:19.910 --> 01:24:25.875
And so the key insight here is that, well, how do we make the blood younger?

1561
01:24:26.356 --> 01:24:28.218
It's because of these extra kinds, which are...

1562
01:24:29.313 --> 01:24:30.874
released during exercise.

1563
01:24:31.694 --> 01:24:42.599
And what Saul Valeda's lab in UCSF did in 2020 is they reported in Science that the exercise was actually...

1564
01:24:44.933 --> 01:24:53.416
The effects of exercise were happening because of this liver-derived enzyme, GPLD1, whose name I'm not going to say.

1565
01:24:53.996 --> 01:24:58.118
But that's the subject of this particular paper.

1566
01:24:58.478 --> 01:25:02.339
In 2020, they discovered this enzyme.

1567
01:25:02.919 --> 01:25:04.480
Can we just hold on this for a quick second?

1568
01:25:04.500 --> 01:25:05.540
Because I think this is important.

1569
01:25:06.000 --> 01:25:08.561
So what you're saying is in this 2020 paper, in science...

1570
01:25:11.950 --> 01:25:17.292
We had this understanding that when you exercise, all your body starts sending these extra kinds.

1571
01:25:17.652 --> 01:25:23.754
And the benefit of that is it helps sort of sustain.

1572
01:25:24.815 --> 01:25:31.017
It's almost like this maintenance process for the body where it keeps you at stable state, for lack of a better way to put it.

1573
01:25:32.878 --> 01:25:36.679
We know that it comes from exercise, which drives a process that the body enacts.

1574
01:25:38.555 --> 01:25:45.662
The discovery that there is a singular protein that comes out of the liver in this 2020 paper.

1575
01:25:45.822 --> 01:25:47.344
That is improving cognition.

1576
01:25:47.544 --> 01:25:50.027
Is improving cognition out of all the extra kinds.

1577
01:25:50.047 --> 01:25:50.667
Yeah.

1578
01:25:50.687 --> 01:25:52.349
And other ones could be as well, right?

1579
01:25:52.409 --> 01:25:56.213
But this one particularly found this, that is like the signal is way high.

1580
01:25:57.093 --> 01:26:02.596
Of all the impacts, this one is the one that has the most and is a key for focus and attention.

1581
01:26:02.896 --> 01:26:07.038
I just think that's kind of a crazy idea in and of itself.

1582
01:26:07.378 --> 01:26:07.598
Yeah.

1583
01:26:07.718 --> 01:26:09.759
There's an enzyme coming out of the liver.

1584
01:26:10.079 --> 01:26:10.279
Yeah.

1585
01:26:10.679 --> 01:26:18.863
There's an enzyme coming out of the liver that is improving cognition demonstrably in older mice when they do exercise.

1586
01:26:19.343 --> 01:26:19.523
Right.

1587
01:26:19.543 --> 01:26:19.823
Right.

1588
01:26:20.552 --> 01:26:22.073
That's fascinating.

1589
01:26:22.153 --> 01:26:22.853
And that was in 2020.

1590
01:26:22.893 --> 01:26:24.353
There's a problem, though.

1591
01:26:25.354 --> 01:26:28.094
This enzyme, GPLD1, is massive.

1592
01:26:28.675 --> 01:26:29.015
Okay.

1593
01:26:29.555 --> 01:26:32.836
So it's not making it through the blood-brain barrier.

1594
01:26:33.056 --> 01:26:34.616
So what exactly is it doing?

1595
01:26:34.716 --> 01:26:36.537
And that's why there's a giant... You see the question mark?

1596
01:26:36.577 --> 01:26:36.797
Yes.

1597
01:26:36.877 --> 01:26:39.698
BBB, and then there's a question mark, and it points to the hippocampus.

1598
01:26:39.898 --> 01:26:40.818
Like, yeah, what is going on?

1599
01:26:41.199 --> 01:26:46.300
How is this massive GPLD1 enzyme that cannot cross the blood-brain barrier...

1600
01:26:46.320 --> 01:26:49.021
I mean, even glucose can't pass the blood-brain barrier.

1601
01:26:49.241 --> 01:26:50.723
Let alone an enzyme of this size.

1602
01:26:50.803 --> 01:26:51.063
Okay.

1603
01:26:51.083 --> 01:26:55.007
So how exactly is it making mice smarter and their brains bigger?

1604
01:26:55.207 --> 01:26:57.289
Because it's not going directly to the source.

1605
01:26:57.329 --> 01:26:57.649
Exactly.

1606
01:26:57.689 --> 01:26:58.891
Apparently, because it can't pass.

1607
01:26:58.951 --> 01:26:59.471
Because it can't.

1608
01:26:59.651 --> 01:26:59.972
It can't.

1609
01:27:00.092 --> 01:27:01.273
So what is it exactly doing?

1610
01:27:01.313 --> 01:27:01.593
Okay.

1611
01:27:01.673 --> 01:27:04.736
And that is what this 2026 breakthrough is about.

1612
01:27:04.836 --> 01:27:05.157
Okay.

1613
01:27:05.177 --> 01:27:05.417
Okay?

1614
01:27:05.737 --> 01:27:08.180
It's unpacking the mechanistic...

1615
01:27:08.965 --> 01:27:37.701
Reason how that GPLD1 Is affecting the brain It's not actually going through the blood brain barrier It's maintaining the blood brain barrier Itself Okay It's like the gates themselves The TSA Is what this thing is maintaining Yes Very interesting So here's the mechanism GPLD1 is something called a phospholipase That's what the D is there Somehow Okay

1616
01:27:38.769 --> 01:27:45.012
And what it's doing is its function is to cleave something called the GPI anchor.

1617
01:27:45.692 --> 01:27:48.814
These are anchors that tether proteins to cell membranes.

1618
01:27:49.154 --> 01:27:50.455
The cell has an outside.

1619
01:27:51.075 --> 01:27:52.075
That's the cell membrane.

1620
01:27:52.175 --> 01:27:52.335
Yes.

1621
01:27:52.355 --> 01:27:55.497
And there's a bunch of proteins that are tethered to the cell membrane.

1622
01:27:55.517 --> 01:27:57.638
You can imagine a boat on a dock, right?

1623
01:27:57.678 --> 01:28:00.039
The boat is not actually attached to the dock.

1624
01:28:00.059 --> 01:28:05.061
There's like rope that attaches a boat to the dock and a bunch of like those like sailor knots.

1625
01:28:05.141 --> 01:28:05.261
Yes.

1626
01:28:05.281 --> 01:28:05.422
Right?

1627
01:28:05.442 --> 01:28:05.542
Yes.

1628
01:28:05.722 --> 01:28:05.942
Yes.

1629
01:28:06.602 --> 01:28:08.445
That's a tethering protein.

1630
01:28:08.785 --> 01:28:09.086
Okay.

1631
01:28:09.266 --> 01:28:14.433
And what this GPLD1 is doing is attacking that tethering protein.

1632
01:28:14.613 --> 01:28:14.874
Okay.

1633
01:28:14.894 --> 01:28:16.556
Now, why is that a good thing?

1634
01:28:16.716 --> 01:28:17.577
Yeah.

1635
01:28:17.597 --> 01:28:22.384
You would think that if a protein is tethered to the cell membrane, you want to keep it there.

1636
01:28:22.504 --> 01:28:22.744
Yes.

1637
01:28:23.687 --> 01:28:23.907
Right.

1638
01:28:24.047 --> 01:28:25.408
That's exactly what I think.

1639
01:28:25.488 --> 01:28:26.548
That's what you should think.

1640
01:28:27.389 --> 01:28:32.732
If there's too many proteins, though, on that cell membrane, what's going to happen to your dock?

1641
01:28:32.952 --> 01:28:33.832
The dock's going to break down.

1642
01:28:33.852 --> 01:28:34.873
The dock's going to break down.

1643
01:28:34.913 --> 01:28:38.234
If there's too many boats, that's why you've got to pay for slips.

1644
01:28:38.254 --> 01:28:43.477
You can't just free-for-all dock to the dock, right?

1645
01:28:43.877 --> 01:28:47.641
If there's too many boats, the dock is going to float away, and then it's just chaos.

1646
01:28:47.681 --> 01:28:47.902
Yes.

1647
01:28:48.242 --> 01:28:55.971
So you've got to have a way to have slips and, like, untether boats that are causing the dock architecture to rupture.

1648
01:28:56.091 --> 01:28:56.271
Yes.

1649
01:28:56.411 --> 01:28:58.574
That is what GPLD1 is doing.

1650
01:28:58.634 --> 01:28:58.934
I see.

1651
01:28:58.954 --> 01:28:59.535
I see.

1652
01:29:00.636 --> 01:29:01.437
They got a target.

1653
01:29:02.078 --> 01:29:04.340
This target must be on the blood-brain interface.

1654
01:29:04.460 --> 01:29:11.889
And then they used actually transcriptomics to figure out that there's this specific protein called TNAP, tissue nonspecific alkaline phosphatase.

1655
01:29:12.550 --> 01:29:16.073
This is a boat that docks to the membrane.

1656
01:29:16.174 --> 01:29:16.354
Yeah.

1657
01:29:16.594 --> 01:29:17.775
Okay?

1658
01:29:18.236 --> 01:29:20.639
And this thing on its own has its own, like...

1659
01:29:21.464 --> 01:29:22.626
job.

1660
01:29:22.686 --> 01:29:29.896
This particular T-nap protein, it involves promoting bone mineralization, and in the brain it does a variety of other stuff.

1661
01:29:30.277 --> 01:29:37.687
But in the brain, if it's anchored to the cell membrane, if there's too many of that anchoring,

1662
01:29:38.457 --> 01:29:42.980
then the cell membrane of your blood-brain barrier is going to start breaking down.

1663
01:29:43.060 --> 01:29:45.942
And then all of a sudden, your tight junctions start becoming loose.

1664
01:29:46.442 --> 01:29:48.223
That was the hypothesis.

1665
01:29:48.323 --> 01:29:48.623
Okay.

1666
01:29:48.703 --> 01:29:48.983
Okay?

1667
01:29:49.143 --> 01:29:49.384
Okay.

1668
01:29:49.464 --> 01:30:01.011
And the key action was that if you circulate this GPLD1 drug, which is something that cuts, it's a scissor for the ropes that tether the boat, then what that's going to do is act as a molecular scissor.

1669
01:30:01.351 --> 01:30:02.571
It's going to cut that anchor.

1670
01:30:02.912 --> 01:30:04.693
The TNAP is going to go off.

1671
01:30:04.713 --> 01:30:04.933
Mm-hmm.

1672
01:30:05.313 --> 01:30:09.315
And you're going to maintain the blood-brain barrier structure.

1673
01:30:10.015 --> 01:30:11.216
And that is what is key.

1674
01:30:11.596 --> 01:30:14.277
So to recap, you exercise.

1675
01:30:14.838 --> 01:30:18.759
The liver produces this GPLD1 enzyme.

1676
01:30:18.859 --> 01:30:26.143
That GPLD1 enzyme that goes into the brain and it maintains the blood-brain barrier by cutting...

1677
01:30:27.792 --> 01:30:34.314
The anchor between this TNAP gene and the cells that maintain that blood-brain barrier.

1678
01:30:34.394 --> 01:30:45.617
Because the TNAP at too much volume begins to degrade the actual structure of these tight joints in the blood-brain barrier.

1679
01:30:46.017 --> 01:30:49.658
And they're not currently, for whatever reason, self-regulated.

1680
01:30:49.778 --> 01:30:50.498
There are no slips.

1681
01:30:50.538 --> 01:30:51.078
Yes, exactly.

1682
01:30:51.138 --> 01:30:55.823
Yeah, I mean, yeah, the self-regulation is the GPLD-1.

1683
01:30:55.903 --> 01:30:56.964
Right, right.

1684
01:30:57.264 --> 01:30:58.746
That's the function.

1685
01:30:58.926 --> 01:30:59.106
Right.

1686
01:30:59.326 --> 01:31:02.690
GPLD-1 is kind of like the boat, I guess the dock.

1687
01:31:02.770 --> 01:31:03.170
Coast Guard.

1688
01:31:03.390 --> 01:31:04.131
Yeah, the Coast Guard.

1689
01:31:04.171 --> 01:31:05.973
It's like you don't have a slip.

1690
01:31:06.013 --> 01:31:06.213
Right.

1691
01:31:07.434 --> 01:31:12.539
But currently, at least in the context of this study, the only source –

1692
01:31:14.311 --> 01:31:18.554
for the GPL-D1 is exercise.

1693
01:31:18.654 --> 01:31:19.975
Is the liver during exercise.

1694
01:31:20.115 --> 01:31:32.442
That is, in the context of what we're looking at, that is the only way we can generate enough Coast Guard people to patrol the docks to maintain the structural integrity of the blood-bain barrier, which can then be a driving force for the...

1695
01:31:35.443 --> 01:31:37.163
The plaques we talked about earlier.

1696
01:31:37.243 --> 01:31:37.464
Yeah.

1697
01:31:37.684 --> 01:31:48.506
Because now when, you know, random stuff gets in, that maybe starts denaturing the plaque proteins, which causes amyloid plaques, which causes Alzheimer's.

1698
01:31:48.566 --> 01:31:48.886
Okay.

1699
01:31:48.986 --> 01:31:49.286
Right?

1700
01:31:49.386 --> 01:31:49.946
This is very cool.

1701
01:31:49.966 --> 01:31:50.646
From the top down.

1702
01:31:50.686 --> 01:31:53.987
And I think it's worth really, like, lingering on this for a bit.

1703
01:31:54.027 --> 01:31:54.627
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1704
01:31:54.647 --> 01:31:58.308
We've created a molecular cascading mechanism.

1705
01:31:58.428 --> 01:31:58.668
Yes.

1706
01:31:58.888 --> 01:32:02.209
From exercise to preventing Alzheimer's.

1707
01:32:02.229 --> 01:32:02.429
Yes.

1708
01:32:02.449 --> 01:32:02.729
Yes.

1709
01:32:02.849 --> 01:32:03.069
Right?

1710
01:32:03.109 --> 01:32:03.229
Right.

1711
01:32:03.249 --> 01:32:04.690
There's now a link between the two.

1712
01:32:04.750 --> 01:32:04.970
Yes.

1713
01:32:05.490 --> 01:32:08.112
And it's literally exercise.

1714
01:32:08.552 --> 01:32:12.974
The liver produces a specific exerkind, which is this GPLD1.

1715
01:32:13.054 --> 01:32:13.274
Yes.

1716
01:32:13.394 --> 01:32:15.636
That then goes to maintain the blood-brain barrier.

1717
01:32:15.736 --> 01:32:15.936
Yes.

1718
01:32:16.056 --> 01:32:18.097
Once the blood-brain barrier is maintained...

1719
01:32:18.955 --> 01:32:21.997
Alzheimer's gets reduced because maybe that is the key issue.

1720
01:32:22.717 --> 01:32:23.378
Right?

1721
01:32:23.898 --> 01:32:30.622
The key issue is potentially there's no TSA preventing whoever wants to come into the airport getting into the airport.

1722
01:32:30.662 --> 01:32:31.123
Exactly.

1723
01:32:31.923 --> 01:32:37.527
And then what we're looking at when we had the amyeloid hypothesis was a specific type of –

1724
01:32:38.267 --> 01:32:40.487
Person that was getting through at the airport.

1725
01:32:40.507 --> 01:32:40.647
Yeah.

1726
01:32:40.988 --> 01:32:43.508
But not... And like causing problems inside the terminal.

1727
01:32:43.568 --> 01:32:43.828
Right.

1728
01:32:43.988 --> 01:32:44.228
Yeah.

1729
01:32:44.368 --> 01:32:44.828
But that was...

1730
01:32:44.988 --> 01:32:46.589
It's potentially just a single use case.

1731
01:32:46.609 --> 01:32:46.829
Yeah.

1732
01:32:47.049 --> 01:32:48.569
Versus understanding the systemic structure.

1733
01:32:48.589 --> 01:32:48.949
Exactly.

1734
01:32:48.989 --> 01:32:49.129
Yeah.

1735
01:32:49.229 --> 01:32:49.569
Okay.

1736
01:32:49.629 --> 01:32:51.650
And let's just go through some of the experiments that they did.

1737
01:32:51.690 --> 01:32:54.430
So they did alkaline phosphate labeling of TNAP.

1738
01:32:54.550 --> 01:32:54.750
Yes.

1739
01:32:54.790 --> 01:32:56.191
TNAP is this thing that...

1740
01:32:56.231 --> 01:32:57.831
The boat that is docking too often...

1741
01:32:58.011 --> 01:32:58.211
Yes.

1742
01:32:58.271 --> 01:32:59.291
...to the blood-brain barrier.

1743
01:32:59.531 --> 01:33:01.912
And you can see on the left there is old animals.

1744
01:33:02.312 --> 01:33:04.872
There's lots of TNAP along the blood vessels.

1745
01:33:05.212 --> 01:33:08.073
And on the right is an old animal that does exercise.

1746
01:33:08.794 --> 01:33:11.055
the amount of TNAP is drastically reduced.

1747
01:33:11.075 --> 01:33:11.896
That's incredible.

1748
01:33:11.916 --> 01:33:12.156
Right?

1749
01:33:12.476 --> 01:33:17.400
So there you can see just very much in the staining of this particular enzyme that we're getting a lot.

1750
01:33:17.440 --> 01:33:24.426
They also did novel object recognition and YMASE, which are these behavioral tests for old mice.

1751
01:33:24.606 --> 01:33:24.927
Okay.

1752
01:33:24.967 --> 01:33:30.111
Like, if the old mice have dementia, they can't do well on these where's the cheese type of task.

1753
01:33:30.411 --> 01:33:32.833
But you can actually recover dementia.

1754
01:33:33.262 --> 01:33:39.125
and reverse cognitive decline by treating old mice with GPLD1.

1755
01:33:39.465 --> 01:33:48.689
You could treat old mice with GPLD1 without having them do exercise, and then there was a profound reversal in the deficits in this particular behavioral maze, right?

1756
01:33:48.709 --> 01:33:53.191
So they could find the cheese faster and all that other kind of stuff, and remember where the cheese was.

1757
01:33:53.912 --> 01:33:57.053
And just to be clear, what you're saying here is...

1758
01:33:58.814 --> 01:34:08.470
You can artificially introduce GPLD1 into these aged mice who already have an accumulation of TNAP happening.

1759
01:34:08.610 --> 01:34:08.771
Yeah.

1760
01:34:08.791 --> 01:34:08.891
Yeah.

1761
01:34:10.156 --> 01:34:14.961
And it still works when it's not necessarily coming from exercise.

1762
01:34:14.981 --> 01:34:15.961
Because it's the same enzyme.

1763
01:34:16.122 --> 01:34:16.342
Yeah.

1764
01:34:16.522 --> 01:34:18.384
So it doesn't necessarily – it doesn't have to come from exercise.

1765
01:34:18.444 --> 01:34:22.768
It's like this singular benefit from exercise we can replicate by just injecting.

1766
01:34:23.028 --> 01:34:23.828
And then we're good to go.

1767
01:34:23.949 --> 01:34:28.953
And we're seeing that even when the – you don't have to do it preemptively or preventatively.

1768
01:34:29.093 --> 01:34:29.273
No.

1769
01:34:29.393 --> 01:34:30.114
You can do it even after.

1770
01:34:30.134 --> 01:34:32.857
This is already an old mice that has Alzheimer's-like symptoms.

1771
01:34:32.997 --> 01:34:33.197
Yes.

1772
01:34:33.257 --> 01:34:34.658
It's bad at the Y maze.

1773
01:34:34.838 --> 01:34:35.059
Right.

1774
01:34:35.299 --> 01:34:35.719
And you –

1775
01:34:36.800 --> 01:34:39.081
Artificially insert it, and it gets better.

1776
01:34:39.201 --> 01:34:39.701
It gets better.

1777
01:34:39.721 --> 01:34:41.461
It finds the cheese, right?

1778
01:34:41.741 --> 01:34:42.542
So this is huge.

1779
01:34:42.882 --> 01:34:45.623
And for blood-brain barrier repair, right?

1780
01:34:46.223 --> 01:34:58.726
So let's look at the difference between how much leakage is happening when you've got an aged mice that has leakage versus one where we treat it with GPLD1.

1781
01:34:59.086 --> 01:35:03.788
On the left, you can see the pink is all of where...

1782
01:35:04.513 --> 01:35:05.293
The leakage happened.

1783
01:35:05.373 --> 01:35:05.693
Okay.

1784
01:35:05.713 --> 01:35:05.994
Okay?

1785
01:35:06.274 --> 01:35:07.634
It's all over the hippocampus.

1786
01:35:07.654 --> 01:35:09.015
This is a slice of the hippocampus.

1787
01:35:09.135 --> 01:35:13.777
On the right, most of the pink is on that blood-brain barrier in the corner.

1788
01:35:13.837 --> 01:35:18.378
There's no huge spots in the middle of the neurons because there's not that much leakage.

1789
01:35:18.398 --> 01:35:18.659
Leakage.

1790
01:35:18.799 --> 01:35:21.560
Because you've treated them with GPLD1, right?

1791
01:35:21.940 --> 01:35:24.701
So I think this is really, really cool.

1792
01:35:24.721 --> 01:35:27.622
This is – I mean – so it's cool for a couple of reasons.

1793
01:35:27.722 --> 01:35:29.003
It's, again, understanding –

1794
01:35:31.704 --> 01:35:44.594
Think what you talked about, connecting the biochemistry processes of the body to these neurological long-term symptoms and being able to trace that story from...

1795
01:35:46.835 --> 01:35:50.977
Which, again, we only talked about one of the exerkinds, which is this GPL.

1796
01:35:50.997 --> 01:35:51.378
GPL.

1797
01:35:51.478 --> 01:35:52.058
There could be more.

1798
01:35:52.098 --> 01:35:52.999
There could be more.

1799
01:35:53.239 --> 01:36:02.964
So, again, if there's a fundamental that's interesting, independent of the specifics of them looking at Alzheimer's as their initial use case.

1800
01:36:03.685 --> 01:36:10.809
And then how they then tried to test this.

1801
01:36:12.188 --> 01:36:12.648
In mice.

1802
01:36:12.808 --> 01:36:13.048
Yeah.

1803
01:36:13.529 --> 01:36:14.189
And saw the exact...

1804
01:36:14.209 --> 01:36:15.409
They did all the right things.

1805
01:36:15.909 --> 01:36:16.110
Right?

1806
01:36:16.650 --> 01:36:24.873
And when we compared it to the amyloid experimentation and why it didn't work, it clearly works or it doesn't.

1807
01:36:24.953 --> 01:36:25.213
Yeah.

1808
01:36:25.233 --> 01:36:26.393
You know what I mean?

1809
01:36:26.433 --> 01:36:26.874
Exactly.

1810
01:36:27.134 --> 01:36:27.374
Yeah.

1811
01:36:27.554 --> 01:36:29.795
Like, you have amyloid plaques in people, and they're fine.

1812
01:36:30.515 --> 01:36:33.636
But when you introduce this GLPD-1 into...

1813
01:36:33.816 --> 01:36:35.157
It's not like they just continue being...

1814
01:36:36.221 --> 01:36:37.303
ineffective at the YMAZ.

1815
01:36:37.423 --> 01:36:38.324
Exactly, yeah.

1816
01:36:38.505 --> 01:36:43.653
And, you know, one could say, oh, this is in mice, there's obviously going to be issues, right?

1817
01:36:43.753 --> 01:36:44.134
Always.

1818
01:36:44.474 --> 01:36:46.217
But that's what's cool about this.

1819
01:36:46.377 --> 01:36:46.638
Okay.

1820
01:36:46.658 --> 01:36:47.499
That's what's cool about this.

1821
01:36:47.539 --> 01:36:50.183
So TNAP, like, okay, so...

1822
01:36:51.335 --> 01:36:53.416
How did they implement GPLD1 in mice?

1823
01:36:53.676 --> 01:36:53.896
Yes.

1824
01:36:54.016 --> 01:37:05.481
They've got this procedure where what you effectively do is you increase... You put the gene for GPLD1 inside a viral vector or like in some kind of plasmid chunk of DNA.

1825
01:37:05.841 --> 01:37:06.902
You stick that into mice.

1826
01:37:07.642 --> 01:37:12.544
You increase the blood pressure such that the liver gets infused with this piece of DNA.

1827
01:37:12.805 --> 01:37:15.466
And then the liver makes the GPLD1.

1828
01:37:15.786 --> 01:37:16.566
Can't do that in humans.

1829
01:37:16.606 --> 01:37:17.167
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1830
01:37:17.187 --> 01:37:17.327
Okay?

1831
01:37:17.687 --> 01:37:18.967
But here's what's cool.

1832
01:37:19.167 --> 01:37:19.408
Okay.

1833
01:37:19.428 --> 01:37:20.188
The TNAP...

1834
01:37:21.429 --> 01:37:23.632
Is already something that we've been worried about.

1835
01:37:23.832 --> 01:37:24.133
Okay.

1836
01:37:24.233 --> 01:37:24.493
Okay.

1837
01:37:24.553 --> 01:37:29.420
That TNAP gene, the boat that gets anchored, that's already something that we've worried about.

1838
01:37:29.821 --> 01:37:38.292
And there is a small molecule drug called SBI-425 that is already approved to inhibit TNAP.

1839
01:37:38.793 --> 01:37:39.093
Okay.

1840
01:37:39.253 --> 01:37:39.654
The boat.

1841
01:37:40.114 --> 01:37:40.354
Okay.

1842
01:37:40.374 --> 01:37:41.095
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1843
01:37:41.175 --> 01:37:42.676
It's already getting in the way of the boat.

1844
01:37:42.816 --> 01:37:43.176
Okay.

1845
01:37:43.196 --> 01:37:48.059
And it's successfully been used in preclinical studies to prevent blood vessel calcification.

1846
01:37:48.219 --> 01:37:48.420
Okay.

1847
01:37:48.440 --> 01:37:52.502
Because remember, TNAP has to do with calcification and bone meturation.

1848
01:37:52.522 --> 01:37:52.863
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1849
01:37:52.883 --> 01:37:57.446
So, like, sometimes, like, there's calcification, like, calcium deposits that happen in blood.

1850
01:37:57.586 --> 01:37:57.766
Yeah.

1851
01:37:57.806 --> 01:38:02.389
And so this particular drug was developed in order to circumnavigate that.

1852
01:38:02.449 --> 01:38:02.629
Yes.

1853
01:38:02.789 --> 01:38:03.510
But it's like, well...

1854
01:38:04.718 --> 01:38:12.420
This thing doesn't have to cross the blood-brain barrier because what it could do is go into the blood and inhibit the boats from anchoring.

1855
01:38:13.320 --> 01:38:13.520
Right?

1856
01:38:13.620 --> 01:38:22.523
Now, this is a—we're taking our understanding from the study that it's about boats anchoring to the dock and too many boats anchoring to the dock that is then—

1857
01:38:23.503 --> 01:38:27.224
creating the physics of the dock to not be tight and be loose.

1858
01:38:27.264 --> 01:38:28.224
And now there's leakage.

1859
01:38:28.585 --> 01:38:31.145
Well, what if we just like messed with the boats?

1860
01:38:31.745 --> 01:38:32.546
Right.

1861
01:38:32.626 --> 01:38:32.806
Right.

1862
01:38:33.626 --> 01:38:34.686
And that's what they did.

1863
01:38:34.846 --> 01:38:35.207
Okay.

1864
01:38:35.547 --> 01:38:39.248
And the oral SBI 425, the,

1865
01:38:40.860 --> 01:38:45.241
It successfully mimicked this GPLD1 gene therapy in the mice.

1866
01:38:45.261 --> 01:38:46.341
Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait.

1867
01:38:46.361 --> 01:38:49.082
This is actually probably the craziest piece of this.

1868
01:38:49.342 --> 01:38:53.823
So in the mice, we had to do gene therapy in order to instigate.

1869
01:38:53.843 --> 01:38:57.104
We had to do this weird stuff that we can't do in humans.

1870
01:38:57.124 --> 01:38:59.865
But now it's like, what if we just feed the mice this drug?

1871
01:39:01.119 --> 01:39:05.125
Right, which is already approved for a different use case.

1872
01:39:05.165 --> 01:39:07.087
Yeah, some random, you know, calcification.

1873
01:39:07.187 --> 01:39:13.496
But the point is it has the same – it creates the same exact GPLD1.

1874
01:39:13.596 --> 01:39:14.798
I keep saying GLP1.

1875
01:39:15.559 --> 01:39:16.340
GPLD1 –

1876
01:39:19.705 --> 01:39:21.546
generation, enzyme generation.

1877
01:39:21.566 --> 01:39:21.766
Yeah.

1878
01:39:22.326 --> 01:39:24.187
Just take, and it's already in oral format.

1879
01:39:24.267 --> 01:39:27.948
Yeah, it's already in oral format, and it's mimicking the gene therapy, right?

1880
01:39:27.988 --> 01:39:28.408
That's unbelievable.

1881
01:39:28.428 --> 01:39:32.910
Maybe it's not doing what the gene therapy exactly is doing, but effectively, what do we want?

1882
01:39:33.090 --> 01:39:33.270
Right.

1883
01:39:33.290 --> 01:39:35.271
We want to maintain the blood-brain barrier.

1884
01:39:35.291 --> 01:39:35.371
Yes.

1885
01:39:35.411 --> 01:39:36.471
That is our end case.

1886
01:39:36.511 --> 01:39:36.731
Yes.

1887
01:39:37.212 --> 01:39:37.452
Right?

1888
01:39:37.532 --> 01:39:37.752
Yes.

1889
01:39:37.952 --> 01:39:39.312
And by whatever means necessary.

1890
01:39:39.352 --> 01:39:40.193
Well, we already have...

1891
01:39:40.953 --> 01:39:43.454
SBI-425 that's been approved for other stuff.

1892
01:39:43.474 --> 01:39:43.694
Yes.

1893
01:39:44.114 --> 01:39:44.835
And it's doing it.

1894
01:39:45.095 --> 01:39:45.315
Right.

1895
01:39:45.895 --> 01:39:46.135
Right.

1896
01:39:46.635 --> 01:39:49.016
So now this is now a bioavailable pill.

1897
01:39:49.236 --> 01:39:49.657
Yes.

1898
01:39:50.437 --> 01:39:51.657
That can treat Alzheimer's.

1899
01:39:51.918 --> 01:39:52.158
Yes.

1900
01:39:52.438 --> 01:39:54.559
Purely by targeting the blood-brain barrier.

1901
01:39:54.639 --> 01:39:54.879
Yes.

1902
01:39:55.019 --> 01:39:56.980
By targeting this vascular interface.

1903
01:39:57.120 --> 01:39:57.340
Yes.

1904
01:39:57.380 --> 01:39:58.860
Between the blood and the brain.

1905
01:39:58.920 --> 01:39:59.721
Maintaining that.

1906
01:40:00.401 --> 01:40:05.567
It circumnavigates this historic blood brain barrier drug delivery problem we don't have to worry about.

1907
01:40:05.587 --> 01:40:06.227
Right.

1908
01:40:06.288 --> 01:40:07.068
Is it going to get through?

1909
01:40:07.188 --> 01:40:10.152
Because what we're worried about is actually maintaining it in the first place.

1910
01:40:10.252 --> 01:40:10.532
Yes.

1911
01:40:11.193 --> 01:40:17.119
We want to make sure that in the analogy we brought up about TSA in the airport or the boat in the dock in the Coast Guard.

1912
01:40:18.020 --> 01:40:20.623
We want to make sure that the Coast Guard is always patrolling the dock.

1913
01:40:20.723 --> 01:40:21.183
Exactly.

1914
01:40:21.223 --> 01:40:27.345
Because what's happening is Coast Guard, over time, people retire, and then there's not enough staffing issues.

1915
01:40:27.386 --> 01:40:27.646
Yes.

1916
01:40:27.986 --> 01:40:37.269
And then all of a sudden, these TNAPs are just having a field day, kind of like the Chinese fishermen people off the coast of Chile and all over the place that are just totally unregulated.

1917
01:40:37.289 --> 01:40:37.529
Yeah.

1918
01:40:38.150 --> 01:40:40.831
But if you had some Coast Guard there, and then there's no less TNAP.

1919
01:40:40.851 --> 01:40:41.231
Yeah.

1920
01:40:41.791 --> 01:40:47.313
And the final thing I want to bring up about this paper is they did do their homework with actual human tissue.

1921
01:40:47.333 --> 01:40:49.734
Because so far, it's always been in...

1922
01:40:51.281 --> 01:40:53.322
In mice, in particular mice.

1923
01:40:54.683 --> 01:41:00.767
So in humans, they looked at autopsied cortical tissue of older adults with Alzheimer's dementia.

1924
01:41:01.527 --> 01:41:09.832
The TNAP protein levels are elevated there, which means there's a lot of these TNAP boats that are anchored to the dock of the blood-brain barrier.

1925
01:41:10.453 --> 01:41:16.477
The GPLD1 levels were elevated in active, healthy, elderly humans.

1926
01:41:16.757 --> 01:41:18.338
So those who are active and healthy...

1927
01:41:18.958 --> 01:41:20.379
The Coast Guard was up.

1928
01:41:20.879 --> 01:41:24.061
So already we're seeing these like large scale correlations.

1929
01:41:24.561 --> 01:41:24.801
Right.

1930
01:41:25.101 --> 01:41:29.263
And it's hope that this could actually work perhaps in humans.

1931
01:41:29.904 --> 01:41:34.446
I thought it was a very cool study because they did a comprehensive research in mice.

1932
01:41:34.626 --> 01:41:35.186
Yes.

1933
01:41:35.306 --> 01:41:37.167
And they didn't leave the human part.

1934
01:41:39.402 --> 01:41:51.501
Because the point is the insights that were derived from the studies in mice are in terms of autopsy data from past Alzheimer's patients, both those who are active and inactive.

1935
01:41:52.277 --> 01:42:06.702
basically mimic the levels both in the TNAP inhibitors being more present on the blood, as well as exercise increasing this enzyme level.

1936
01:42:06.782 --> 01:42:07.942
Yeah, this GPLD one.

1937
01:42:08.002 --> 01:42:15.625
That helps to maintain the structure of the blood vessels and the tight junctions of the blood-beam barrier, which, again, seems to be as a...

1938
01:42:16.942 --> 01:42:31.885
competing theory to the amyloid hypothesis, a potential high, it's like lower in the stack of processes because you want to basically attack a problem as close to the source as possible.

1939
01:42:32.505 --> 01:42:34.025
The amyloid plaques is not the source.

1940
01:42:34.085 --> 01:42:35.826
Yeah, it seems it's not.

1941
01:42:35.846 --> 01:42:38.126
It seems it's not, but this might be.

1942
01:42:38.226 --> 01:42:38.846
Getting closer.

1943
01:42:39.427 --> 01:42:40.627
To what it's going on.

1944
01:42:40.987 --> 01:42:44.107
And also just an interesting conceptual way

1945
01:42:47.888 --> 01:42:51.989
neurodegenerative diseases.

1946
01:42:52.109 --> 01:42:52.529
Exactly.

1947
01:42:52.629 --> 01:42:53.529
As a holistic thing.

1948
01:42:53.549 --> 01:42:54.409
As a holistic thing.

1949
01:42:54.469 --> 01:42:57.770
It's like this thing involves the liver, the blood, and the brain.

1950
01:42:57.810 --> 01:42:58.290
Yes.

1951
01:42:58.390 --> 01:43:01.091
The brain is no longer like an island that you have to think about.

1952
01:43:01.211 --> 01:43:01.351
Right.

1953
01:43:01.371 --> 01:43:05.892
I mean, I think the future is looking very bright for this particular study.

1954
01:43:06.012 --> 01:43:13.193
Of course, I don't want to do commentator's curse, but the GPLD-1, which is like your Coast Guard, that thing targets all kinds of boats.

1955
01:43:13.253 --> 01:43:13.413
Mm-hmm.

1956
01:43:13.593 --> 01:43:14.394
Not just TNAP.

1957
01:43:14.754 --> 01:43:19.057
It's targeting all sorts of GPI-anchored proteins, hundreds of others.

1958
01:43:19.137 --> 01:43:22.599
So those could be targets for new therapies, right?

1959
01:43:23.740 --> 01:43:25.421
You could have a...

1960
01:43:26.001 --> 01:43:31.405
I mean, I anticipate there's going to be a surge in peripheral TNAP inhibitors, not just...

1961
01:43:31.765 --> 01:43:34.808
this SBI 425, there could be other stuff.

1962
01:43:35.008 --> 01:43:35.228
Right.

1963
01:43:35.448 --> 01:43:36.189
So, yeah.

1964
01:43:36.229 --> 01:43:46.398
And I think that's an important point that the, the SBI 425 already being an approved drug, like is huge because it sort of shows the, the drug development, the,

1965
01:43:46.858 --> 01:43:57.101
It's scaffolding to get to an end result, even if you don't use exactly – like you can at least reach – like see what the pathway is to success here around how to approach it.

1966
01:43:57.461 --> 01:44:04.383
Because there's the research, but then the whole drug discovery process from stage one or phase one to phase four, quite complex.

1967
01:44:04.403 --> 01:44:08.664
You have early stage drug discovery where they're just trying to figure out like the active ingredients.

1968
01:44:09.164 --> 01:44:13.005
Then you give it to the chemists because they have to figure out how do you actually deliver it to the patient.

1969
01:44:13.025 --> 01:44:13.145
Right.

1970
01:44:14.065 --> 01:44:14.825
Is it intravenous?

1971
01:44:14.885 --> 01:44:15.565
Is it oral?

1972
01:44:15.625 --> 01:44:15.805
Yeah.

1973
01:44:16.066 --> 01:44:16.626
Dosing?

1974
01:44:17.106 --> 01:44:17.986
What is the half-life?

1975
01:44:18.506 --> 01:44:19.166
All that kind of stuff.

1976
01:44:19.406 --> 01:44:22.187
Then you get into sort of early preclinical trials.

1977
01:44:22.327 --> 01:44:24.627
Yeah, where it's like, okay, let's make sure it doesn't kill the mice.

1978
01:44:24.687 --> 01:44:24.867
Right.

1979
01:44:25.108 --> 01:44:27.668
Then you get into clinical trials, FDA approval.

1980
01:44:27.728 --> 01:44:30.089
I mean, it is a very complex and long thing.

1981
01:44:30.309 --> 01:44:31.829
And this is already halfway through.

1982
01:44:31.969 --> 01:44:33.729
So that's a huge deal.

1983
01:44:33.909 --> 01:44:34.570
Yeah.

1984
01:44:34.930 --> 01:44:36.190
Fascinating story.

1985
01:44:36.430 --> 01:44:37.851
Yeah, I thought that was very cool, actually.

1986
01:44:37.911 --> 01:44:38.912
It's very cool.

1987
01:44:38.992 --> 01:44:51.481
And I think what's been so interesting in this journey on the show, for me, right, having the benefit of just having you able to really, again, having a first principles general science understanding is not super common, unfortunately.

1988
01:44:51.541 --> 01:44:52.361
Mm-hmm.

1989
01:44:56.264 --> 01:45:09.007
almost 30 episodes in to be able to make these connections across stories because there's fundamentals about the process of this early stage research or frontier research that track.

1990
01:45:09.127 --> 01:45:23.010
I mean, we talked earlier about the proton piece and how that's like measurement not of direct observation but indirect observation is a concept, and it can manifest when you're zooming in really, really small or when you're zooming out really, really far.

1991
01:45:23.450 --> 01:45:25.971
I mean, this is a really, really cool story.

1992
01:45:26.551 --> 01:45:27.511
And great work.

1993
01:45:27.551 --> 01:45:30.993
This, again, was from UCSF.

1994
01:45:31.093 --> 01:45:31.933
Yeah, UCSF.

1995
01:45:31.953 --> 01:45:33.673
They do amazing work there.

1996
01:45:33.713 --> 01:45:34.674
Lots of Nobel Prizes.

1997
01:45:35.214 --> 01:45:35.754
Oh, my God.

1998
01:45:35.934 --> 01:45:37.595
Fascinating, fascinating story.

1999
01:45:37.895 --> 01:45:40.856
And, again, I just want to make a quick sort of caveat here.

2000
01:45:41.876 --> 01:45:46.458
The point of this show is to talk about breakthrough and frontier research from first principles.

2001
01:45:47.018 --> 01:45:53.540
There is a large delta or a big gap in between a research paper coming out and it having –

2002
01:45:54.487 --> 01:45:58.671
you know, over-the-counter or prescription medication available to people.

2003
01:45:59.071 --> 01:46:04.996
And so just to be very clear about that point, we very much understand that, one, there needs to be replication.

2004
01:46:05.016 --> 01:46:07.358
There's a whole process of implementation.

2005
01:46:07.478 --> 01:46:09.119
There's a lot of stuff that can go wrong in the middle.

2006
01:46:09.219 --> 01:46:11.801
And so the middle is there's a lot there.

2007
01:46:11.942 --> 01:46:12.162
Mm-hmm.

2008
01:46:12.502 --> 01:46:13.803
this show is not about the middle.

2009
01:46:13.843 --> 01:46:19.725
It is, it is about kind of the beginning of the story, but it's important just to be clear that, that, that is, that is the case.

2010
01:46:19.905 --> 01:46:20.666
Yeah.

2011
01:46:20.806 --> 01:46:21.006
Yeah.

2012
01:46:21.266 --> 01:46:23.627
And so, you know, I know some folks will be like, yeah, this is still early.

2013
01:46:23.867 --> 01:46:24.107
Yes.

2014
01:46:24.307 --> 01:46:24.527
Yeah.

2015
01:46:24.887 --> 01:46:28.909
But isn't it cool that we figured out this Coast Guard boat docking thing?

2016
01:46:29.069 --> 01:46:34.071
It's the concepts and the ideas are really an understanding how we got there.

2017
01:46:34.231 --> 01:46:34.492
Yeah.

2018
01:46:34.792 --> 01:46:35.352
Is the point.

2019
01:46:35.372 --> 01:46:35.552
Yeah.

2020
01:46:35.592 --> 01:46:36.072
That's the point.

2021
01:46:36.092 --> 01:46:37.933
I mean, it's kind of cool.

2022
01:46:38.373 --> 01:46:40.094
Because there's so many things you can get from this.

2023
01:46:40.114 --> 01:46:41.675
So in any event, um,

2024
01:46:42.455 --> 01:46:43.316
Fantastic.

2025
01:46:43.616 --> 01:46:45.417
We started with dark galaxies.

2026
01:46:45.497 --> 01:46:50.141
Again, space and then neuroscience, some great rundown stories.

2027
01:46:50.261 --> 01:46:54.104
I want to do a couple of quick housekeeping notes before we wrap up for the day.

2028
01:46:54.684 --> 01:46:59.308
Number one is if you are listening to this episode and you've made it all this way.

2029
01:46:59.928 --> 01:47:05.073
congratulations because some of the stuff is really hard to grok when you're just only listening.

2030
01:47:05.574 --> 01:47:10.358
And if you are curious and want to know more, we have a video podcast.

2031
01:47:10.378 --> 01:47:19.126
So you can watch this on YouTube, on Spotify and soon coming soon, because we just got the announcement email, Apple podcasts, you know,

2032
01:47:19.306 --> 01:47:22.789
is introducing videos later this spring.

2033
01:47:22.809 --> 01:47:31.316
So if you are an Apple podcast listener, you are on the precipice of receiving video as a first-class object, just like we have on YouTube.

2034
01:47:31.576 --> 01:47:32.637
Spotify, it's not our fault.

2035
01:47:33.017 --> 01:47:34.619
That's just they haven't implemented it yet.

2036
01:47:34.959 --> 01:47:35.659
So that's exciting.

2037
01:47:35.679 --> 01:47:40.143
We do a ton of graphics and visuals that help really understand what's going on here.

2038
01:47:40.563 --> 01:47:41.704
So please take a watch.

2039
01:47:42.025 --> 01:47:42.565
If you're interested,

2040
01:47:42.685 --> 01:47:44.947
You are listening on Spotify or Apple.

2041
01:47:44.987 --> 01:47:50.833
A five-star helps us significantly to get this out to more people.

2042
01:47:50.973 --> 01:47:51.714
And some comments.

2043
01:47:51.974 --> 01:47:52.995
And some comments, too.

2044
01:47:53.055 --> 01:47:55.178
So many of you talk about how this is your favorite podcast.

2045
01:47:55.818 --> 01:47:58.180
Go ahead and comment it on every show that you feel that way.

2046
01:47:58.601 --> 01:47:59.462
Share it with a friend.

2047
01:47:59.542 --> 01:48:00.283
Bring it to lunch.

2048
01:48:00.883 --> 01:48:03.024
at your journal club, if you're at a lab.

2049
01:48:03.885 --> 01:48:05.085
It's really helpful for us.

2050
01:48:05.485 --> 01:48:07.326
We make this show freely available.

2051
01:48:07.626 --> 01:48:09.287
There's no subscription content.

2052
01:48:09.627 --> 01:48:11.668
There's no exclusive back-end content.

2053
01:48:12.109 --> 01:48:15.550
It's all the episodes and all the clips are available for everybody.

2054
01:48:15.871 --> 01:48:22.834
And so if you want to support us directly and become a patron, you can go to ffppod.com backslash donate.

2055
01:48:23.114 --> 01:48:26.716
You can do a one-time donation or you can do a monthly donation.

2056
01:48:27.136 --> 01:48:27.937
That's what helps us

2057
01:48:28.697 --> 01:48:29.658
Do all the editing.

2058
01:48:29.718 --> 01:48:30.839
Get all of the equipment.

2059
01:48:31.339 --> 01:48:33.961
Do travel for some of our special stories.

2060
01:48:34.902 --> 01:48:38.364
Maybe for those who have reached the end of the episode, maybe I'll do a little tease here.

2061
01:48:38.764 --> 01:48:40.386
That, you know, you only will know.

2062
01:48:40.406 --> 01:48:43.108
Well, you might have seen it on our Instagram story.

2063
01:48:43.128 --> 01:48:43.408
Yeah.

2064
01:48:44.704 --> 01:48:59.287
We have recently had the wonderful experience of getting to be interviewed on the Dave Chang show with David Chang, the famous chef and owner of the Momofuku restaurant group.

2065
01:48:59.307 --> 01:49:03.829
Being able to have food made for you by one of the goats is.

2066
01:49:04.309 --> 01:49:07.249
Yeah, it wasn't like, oh, we got takeout from Momofuku.

2067
01:49:07.309 --> 01:49:07.969
Yeah, no, no.

2068
01:49:08.010 --> 01:49:09.610
Dave Chang is making me.

2069
01:49:10.480 --> 01:49:11.260
I can't say, actually.

2070
01:49:11.280 --> 01:49:12.420
I want you guys to see what he made us.

2071
01:49:12.440 --> 01:49:13.781
You'll have to have a last episode.

2072
01:49:15.021 --> 01:49:18.822
But that should be coming out on Netflix.

2073
01:49:18.962 --> 01:49:26.724
Our first Netflix placement, as well as Spotify, by a week, probably a week from when this episode comes out, a week or 10 days.

2074
01:49:27.204 --> 01:49:32.245
And so keep an eye on our socials at FFPpod for when that comes out.

2075
01:49:32.545 --> 01:49:33.345
It's a great interview.

2076
01:49:33.365 --> 01:49:36.726
You get to see us in the real world, outside of the studio.

2077
01:49:37.026 --> 01:49:37.886
We had a great time.

2078
01:49:37.926 --> 01:49:39.207
Big shout out to Dave's team.

2079
01:49:40.787 --> 01:49:43.570
David Meyer, Christine, you guys are fantastic.

2080
01:49:43.590 --> 01:49:44.371
We had a great time.

2081
01:49:44.391 --> 01:49:52.017
And we look forward to you inviting Krishna when you guys need the science of food or food science expertise.

2082
01:49:52.418 --> 01:49:53.479
I will do anything for food.

2083
01:49:53.899 --> 01:49:54.700
Friend of the pod.

2084
01:49:54.920 --> 01:49:57.502
Shout out to Dave Chang and co. Really appreciate that.

2085
01:49:58.083 --> 01:49:59.804
My name is Lester Nare.

2086
01:50:00.104 --> 01:50:00.725
Hold on.

2087
01:50:00.825 --> 01:50:01.085
Yes.

2088
01:50:03.227 --> 01:50:03.728
The comments.

2089
01:50:04.829 --> 01:50:07.391
I want you guys to give me an alternate comment.

2090
01:50:09.831 --> 01:50:10.732
GPLD1.

2091
01:50:11.392 --> 01:50:12.373
What does it stand for?

2092
01:50:12.473 --> 01:50:12.693
Yes.

2093
01:50:12.974 --> 01:50:17.098
Because the one that we have, which, you know, just for old time's sake, I'm going to try.

2094
01:50:17.658 --> 01:50:23.824
Glycosylphosphatidylonatosol specific phospholipase D1.

2095
01:50:24.204 --> 01:50:25.145
I would like something better.

2096
01:50:25.405 --> 01:50:25.726
Thank you.

2097
01:50:26.186 --> 01:50:26.946
That's a great call.

2098
01:50:27.106 --> 01:50:27.347
Yes.

2099
01:50:27.987 --> 01:50:32.408
So, again, listening all the way, you'll get a little couple secret nuggets in here.

2100
01:50:32.949 --> 01:50:33.809
Send over the comment.

2101
01:50:34.349 --> 01:50:35.950
Keep an eye out for us on Dave Chang.

2102
01:50:36.510 --> 01:50:40.251
And we may or may not start to do some in-pod giveaways.

2103
01:50:40.752 --> 01:50:47.994
And so, you know, you might want to listen because he might be maybe someone who gets some special merch or who knows?

2104
01:50:48.315 --> 01:50:48.635
Who knows?

2105
01:50:48.695 --> 01:50:49.075
Who knows?

2106
01:50:51.167 --> 01:50:58.732
Bringing it back, I'm Lester Nari, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

2107
01:50:59.212 --> 01:51:04.935
We really appreciate you guys so much, especially those who listen all the way to us ranting for two hours.

2108
01:51:04.955 --> 01:51:06.956
We tried to do two stories this week to make it last.

2109
01:51:06.976 --> 01:51:07.977
Yeah, and it's still two hours.

2110
01:51:08.017 --> 01:51:08.797
And it's still two hours.

2111
01:51:08.817 --> 01:51:10.258
We got to work on that.

2112
01:51:10.819 --> 01:51:13.200
We will be back next week with our next episode.

2113
01:51:13.560 --> 01:51:16.202
This is From First Principles.
