WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.111 --> 00:00:11.603
So it's something that is out there, it's passing through the earth, probably through us right now, but because it doesn't have any interactions except gravity, we can't really tell.

2
00:00:11.623 --> 00:00:17.148
This fundamental prediction of cold dark matter, which is our best current theory for what it is,

3
00:00:18.049 --> 00:00:29.599
which is mind-blowing when you think of it, which is that every galaxy should be surrounded by an innumerable number of completely dark concentrations of matter.

4
00:00:45.515 --> 00:00:46.256
Hello, Internet.

5
00:00:46.276 --> 00:00:48.817
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nari.

6
00:00:48.877 --> 00:00:56.802
And today I am joined in studio by a very special guest, friend of the pod and astrophysicist, Dan Gilman.

7
00:00:57.483 --> 00:01:03.787
As we await the return of Krishna, who's on family leave, I'm super excited to have a chat with you today.

8
00:01:03.847 --> 00:01:12.573
We are going to be covering and talking about an area that you do research around, which is dark matter.

9
00:01:12.593 --> 00:01:12.693
Yeah.

10
00:01:13.413 --> 00:01:16.194
And I think we're going to have an exciting conversation.

11
00:01:16.214 --> 00:01:20.956
I think the last time I saw you in person was almost three years ago.

12
00:01:21.977 --> 00:01:22.717
Something like that.

13
00:01:22.897 --> 00:01:24.918
Yeah, maybe two years ago or something.

14
00:01:24.998 --> 00:01:25.618
Three, maybe.

15
00:01:25.898 --> 00:01:29.520
It was for Krishna's wedding and just prior bachelor party.

16
00:01:30.400 --> 00:01:42.665
And before we jump into the weeds, I was requested to have you provide an explanation for these two photos of you and Krishna.

17
00:01:43.383 --> 00:01:43.783
Yeah.

18
00:01:43.863 --> 00:01:47.907
So the first one, the one on the right, that was in Thailand.

19
00:01:48.007 --> 00:01:51.409
I think it was like 2017, 2018.

20
00:01:51.509 --> 00:01:55.292
I believe it was Ko-P-P, Ko-Fee-Fee.

21
00:01:56.013 --> 00:01:56.373
I don't know.

22
00:01:56.473 --> 00:01:57.774
I always forget how to pronounce it.

23
00:01:57.915 --> 00:02:00.477
And I think Christian has a broken arm in this photo.

24
00:02:00.497 --> 00:02:01.097
Do we have any...

25
00:02:01.357 --> 00:02:02.138
He broke his arm.

26
00:02:02.218 --> 00:02:02.558
I don't know.

27
00:02:02.638 --> 00:02:03.939
Probably something dumb.

28
00:02:04.059 --> 00:02:05.000
I don't remember what he did.

29
00:02:05.060 --> 00:02:05.801
It's classified.

30
00:02:07.402 --> 00:02:11.244
And then here on the left, you guys are pointing to a couple of plaques, it looks like.

31
00:02:12.185 --> 00:02:15.226
Yeah, the one on the left, the other one was in Vienna.

32
00:02:16.167 --> 00:02:20.389
And we were outside of a famous scientist's house.

33
00:02:20.409 --> 00:02:21.490
I don't remember who it was.

34
00:02:21.570 --> 00:02:23.111
Krishna definitely remembers.

35
00:02:23.491 --> 00:02:24.632
He remembers that kind of stuff.

36
00:02:24.872 --> 00:02:30.856
So Krishna, when you're back, we'll ask you whose house you were at for that photo.

37
00:02:30.916 --> 00:02:31.276
And so...

38
00:02:32.311 --> 00:02:35.893
Before, another thing before we do this, how do you guys actually like know each other?

39
00:02:35.913 --> 00:02:38.315
What's the story behind how you two initially met?

40
00:02:39.155 --> 00:02:41.617
So we were the same year in grad school.

41
00:02:41.637 --> 00:02:43.358
At UCLA.

42
00:02:43.418 --> 00:02:44.118
At UCLA.

43
00:02:44.238 --> 00:02:44.459
Yeah.

44
00:02:44.479 --> 00:02:45.719
So we entered the same year.

45
00:02:46.280 --> 00:02:49.021
The first year of grad school, you have to take a bunch of classes.

46
00:02:49.642 --> 00:02:51.503
So we were taking the same classes together.

47
00:02:51.583 --> 00:02:52.644
We studied together.

48
00:02:53.744 --> 00:02:57.607
Before your first, your second year, you have to pass a big written test.

49
00:02:58.207 --> 00:02:59.927
And so we studied for the test together.

50
00:02:59.947 --> 00:03:02.828
And then we started, we eventually became roommates.

51
00:03:02.968 --> 00:03:06.429
I think after the second year, we became roommates.

52
00:03:06.589 --> 00:03:15.271
I remember when you guys were roommates, because I would come over and I would badger you in the kitchen asking you to explain to me what you're researching.

53
00:03:15.311 --> 00:03:17.471
And you would always be like, well, I don't know, man.

54
00:03:17.531 --> 00:03:18.832
It's kind of in the weeds.

55
00:03:19.132 --> 00:03:20.892
Dude, you guys have been talking.

56
00:03:20.912 --> 00:03:23.293
You guys have been doing this podcast for 10 years.

57
00:03:23.613 --> 00:03:24.033
Really?

58
00:03:24.533 --> 00:03:28.356
I have been listening to you guys do this in our living room for 10 years.

59
00:03:28.416 --> 00:03:29.197
Now you're recording.

60
00:03:29.597 --> 00:03:31.859
It's the only difference.

61
00:03:31.999 --> 00:03:34.121
Which is so true.

62
00:03:34.501 --> 00:03:38.064
And it's something we talk about in terms of like where the inspiration for the show came from.

63
00:03:38.444 --> 00:03:42.568
But since UCLA, you moved out to Chicago.

64
00:03:43.614 --> 00:03:45.456
Yeah, so I bounced around a little bit.

65
00:03:45.536 --> 00:03:48.219
I was in Toronto first as a postdoc.

66
00:03:48.460 --> 00:03:52.805
So after grad school, you do some research contracts.

67
00:03:53.005 --> 00:03:58.571
So I did one at the University of Toronto, and now I'm at the University of Chicago doing another one.

68
00:03:59.492 --> 00:04:00.053
Beautiful.

69
00:04:00.273 --> 00:04:07.800
And for those who are joining us who are longtime listeners, we've talked about Dark Matter before on the pod.

70
00:04:08.561 --> 00:04:12.625
It's usually been around the classic galaxy rotation curve argument.

71
00:04:12.705 --> 00:04:19.452
And we covered the Dark Matter Halo story that came out earlier this year, which is, you know, one line of...

72
00:04:20.913 --> 00:04:23.014
way to think about the question of dark matter.

73
00:04:23.675 --> 00:04:35.740
And I think part of what's going to be so interesting about our conversation today is, you know, in the research that you do, you're coming at it from a different angle that kind of looks at large scale structure and we'll get into that.

74
00:04:36.141 --> 00:04:44.965
But just to kind of start, because it's always still a little bit murky to me, you know, what, let's start with just the basic question from first principles, like what,

75
00:04:45.605 --> 00:04:53.014
What is dark matter and sort of understanding why the case, why we think the case for the existence of dark matter is so strong?

76
00:04:54.017 --> 00:05:04.462
Yeah, so dark matter is something that only appears to interact through gravity with baryonic matter, which is essentially normal matter.

77
00:05:04.662 --> 00:05:06.082
The stuff you and I are made of.

78
00:05:06.142 --> 00:05:07.623
Yeah, the stuff that you and I are made of.

79
00:05:08.123 --> 00:05:13.286
So we know of some forces that mediate interactions between normal matter.

80
00:05:13.846 --> 00:05:19.108
So things like gravity, electromagnetism, the strong force and the weak force.

81
00:05:19.528 --> 00:05:23.170
So dark matter is something that only appears to interact through gravity.

82
00:05:23.830 --> 00:05:32.176
So it doesn't interact through electromagnetism, which means it doesn't interact with light because light is described by electromagnetism.

83
00:05:32.817 --> 00:05:35.479
So it's something that is out there.

84
00:05:35.599 --> 00:05:39.341
It's passing through the earth, probably through us right now.

85
00:05:39.421 --> 00:05:44.325
But because it doesn't have any interactions except gravity, we can't really tell.

86
00:05:44.605 --> 00:05:50.850
It only becomes apparent when you start looking through telescopes at the universe that there's more stuff out there than we can see.

87
00:05:51.610 --> 00:05:52.291
This is interesting.

88
00:05:52.351 --> 00:06:07.486
So the idea is, and I think I remember seeing these statistics of like the actual, what we believe to be the breakdown between, you know, let's call it normal matter and dark matter.

89
00:06:07.566 --> 00:06:11.369
It's actually the majority of the universe based on how we see...

90
00:06:12.050 --> 00:06:23.234
you know, things interacting with gravity, there has to be, what is it, like 60, 70, 80% has to be dark matter to account for what we see in the visible light spectrum.

91
00:06:23.835 --> 00:06:28.876
Yeah, it's about, dark matter is about five times as abundant as regular matter.

92
00:06:30.237 --> 00:06:31.557
But we don't know what it is.

93
00:06:32.458 --> 00:06:33.518
So we're trying to figure it out.

94
00:06:33.958 --> 00:06:37.640
So when we say, what's interesting about dark matter is,

95
00:06:38.918 --> 00:06:58.507
It's invisible to us because it doesn't interact with light itself, but it is not non-interacting because it does interact with gravity, which can subsequently have an effect on objects that do interact with light that we can actually see and measure.

96
00:06:59.597 --> 00:07:00.438
Yeah, exactly.

97
00:07:00.778 --> 00:07:07.006
And so I think that's when people started becoming really convinced that something like dark matter exists.

98
00:07:07.567 --> 00:07:14.435
It was because of things like galaxy rotation curves, you know, the observation that stuff appeared to be.

99
00:07:15.216 --> 00:07:22.062
being pulled by more gravity than you could account for based only on what you could see, based only on starlight.

100
00:07:22.723 --> 00:07:23.624
That makes sense.

101
00:07:23.704 --> 00:07:38.137
And so this is why sometimes, and this kind of begins to dovetail with your area of research, I've heard it described that dark matter as the invisible structure of,

102
00:07:38.857 --> 00:07:39.697
of the universe.

103
00:07:39.977 --> 00:07:57.644
And the reason we say that is, you know, when we look at the, the, the spin of these galaxies, um, it, the, the speed at which the rotation is happening, based on what we can see, it should not be possible is the point based on purely what we can look at.

104
00:07:58.244 --> 00:08:11.737
through these telescopes and these instruments, some of the speed or acceleration or the way in which it operates doesn't make sense unless there is something else there.

105
00:08:13.037 --> 00:08:13.477
That's right.

106
00:08:13.657 --> 00:08:13.877
Yeah.

107
00:08:14.037 --> 00:08:15.978
And that was the early evidence.

108
00:08:16.278 --> 00:08:16.578
Okay.

109
00:08:17.159 --> 00:08:26.983
Now, today we have, you know, we've made that kind of observation, but on, you know, vastly different scales and in different environments.

110
00:08:27.663 --> 00:08:37.087
So from the large scale structure of the universe, the cosmic microwave background, all of these things that are independent of each other, they all point to the existence of space.

111
00:08:37.627 --> 00:08:40.971
Some form of matter that only interacts gravitational.

112
00:08:41.091 --> 00:08:41.892
Ah, that's interesting.

113
00:08:42.152 --> 00:08:49.180
So it's not simply that we've looked at either like one type of object, a celestial object, or one subset of celestial objects.

114
00:08:49.200 --> 00:08:58.731
We've now looked at an array of these different things, and all of them point to there being a missing variable in the equation.

115
00:08:58.751 --> 00:08:58.931
Right.

116
00:08:59.312 --> 00:09:00.093
Yeah, that's right.

117
00:09:00.133 --> 00:09:04.317
So it's the fact that you have lots of independent lines of evidence, right?

118
00:09:04.617 --> 00:09:05.898
You just have one experiment.

119
00:09:05.998 --> 00:09:12.325
Maybe, you know, okay, maybe you don't understand galaxies that well, and that's why you don't understand the rotation curve, right?

120
00:09:12.705 --> 00:09:16.288
But once you start having lots of different phenomena that are all...

121
00:09:17.434 --> 00:09:23.057
you know, reasonably well explained by the existence of dark matter, that's when it becomes really compelling.

122
00:09:23.517 --> 00:09:26.419
And that's why we're trying to figure out what it is.

123
00:09:26.619 --> 00:09:31.281
And we're not so much anymore focused on determining whether it exists.

124
00:09:32.042 --> 00:09:34.483
This is actually a great transition point.

125
00:09:34.563 --> 00:09:42.467
So we're now at the point, and this is where your research comes in, where we've identified that there is a there there.

126
00:09:44.092 --> 00:09:53.666
And now we are trying to better characterize what it actually is, the structure, its component parts.

127
00:09:54.346 --> 00:09:56.209
Are there dark matter particles?

128
00:09:56.910 --> 00:09:57.911
And so –

129
00:10:00.047 --> 00:10:14.962
So we now kind of have an idea of what is dark matter in the sense that it is this thing that interacts with gravity that impacts things we can see all across the universe from multiple instruments and multiple observations.

130
00:10:15.903 --> 00:10:18.424
And now we want to sort of take it a step further.

131
00:10:18.965 --> 00:10:26.228
So in terms of the life of you as a researcher right now looking at this issue, you know, where do you even start?

132
00:10:26.449 --> 00:10:26.669
Right?

133
00:10:26.729 --> 00:10:31.111
Like, like, what is, you know, how do you even define the problem?

134
00:10:31.191 --> 00:10:32.952
Think about where to begin?

135
00:10:33.761 --> 00:10:39.207
Yeah, so let me give you the kind of quick explanation, and then we'll get into the details.

136
00:10:39.407 --> 00:10:39.667
Okay.

137
00:10:39.808 --> 00:10:47.196
So, you know, we want to study dark matter in a way that's sensitive to its particle properties.

138
00:10:47.676 --> 00:10:48.417
Okay.

139
00:10:48.597 --> 00:10:50.659
So the galaxy rotation curve...

140
00:10:51.941 --> 00:10:58.205
types of arguments are not so sensitive to the actual particle nature of dark matter.

141
00:10:58.465 --> 00:11:12.696
They are a little bit, but if you want to understand the particle nature of dark matter and you want to do particle physics with astronomy in the context of dark matter, we have to start looking at how dark matter clusters.

142
00:11:13.456 --> 00:11:28.267
around galaxies that turns out to be one of the most constraining types of measurements you can make is by studying not the large scale structure of the universe, which by the way, is almost impossible to explain without dark matter.

143
00:11:29.268 --> 00:11:35.032
It's actually how dark matter behaves on smaller scales, you know, on scales like galaxies.

144
00:11:35.573 --> 00:11:38.775
So I think we actually have a good picture that we can show.

145
00:11:38.855 --> 00:11:40.537
It's a number six, number six.

146
00:11:40.697 --> 00:11:41.097
Okay.

147
00:11:43.056 --> 00:11:49.659
Right, so this figure came out of a review article about dark matter that's now, I think, eight or nine years old.

148
00:11:49.879 --> 00:11:50.139
Okay.

149
00:11:50.500 --> 00:11:58.183
On the left, that is a computer simulation of what we think a dark matter halo looks like.

150
00:11:58.464 --> 00:11:58.744
Okay.

151
00:11:58.784 --> 00:12:03.486
So a dark matter halo is a gigantic blob of dark matter.

152
00:12:03.786 --> 00:12:07.628
That's the technical term for a giant blob of dark matter, is a dark matter halo.

153
00:12:07.688 --> 00:12:11.130
This has nothing to do with Master Chief, I'm assuming, and Cortana.

154
00:12:11.450 --> 00:12:11.590
Right.

155
00:12:13.263 --> 00:12:15.184
No, it does not.

156
00:12:15.264 --> 00:12:19.505
I don't know what that is, but it definitely doesn't have to be with it.

157
00:12:19.666 --> 00:12:23.667
Halo is a best-selling Xbox game where there's a planet.

158
00:12:23.787 --> 00:12:24.487
Oh, Halo.

159
00:12:24.547 --> 00:12:25.087
That's the ring.

160
00:12:25.107 --> 00:12:26.028
Oh, Master Chief.

161
00:12:26.208 --> 00:12:26.748
All right, sorry.

162
00:12:26.768 --> 00:12:27.808
It took me a second here.

163
00:12:27.968 --> 00:12:30.489
I was too focused on the pretty picture.

164
00:12:30.509 --> 00:12:31.389
I threw you off there.

165
00:12:32.030 --> 00:12:39.332
So on the left here, this is our, at the time, this was our best guess game.

166
00:12:39.592 --> 00:12:45.418
at these clumps of dark matter in relation to where?

167
00:12:46.179 --> 00:12:46.379
Right.

168
00:12:46.439 --> 00:12:49.923
So this is, again, it's a simulation on a supercomputer.

169
00:12:50.603 --> 00:13:00.253
Our galaxy in that picture would be at the center of the bright blob in the middle, and it would be much smaller than the size of this image.

170
00:13:00.914 --> 00:13:01.214
Got it.

171
00:13:01.234 --> 00:13:01.695
So these...

172
00:13:02.295 --> 00:13:06.116
What you're seeing is this dark matter halo that hosts our galaxy.

173
00:13:06.616 --> 00:13:11.597
We think galaxies, for the most part, are inside of dark matter halos.

174
00:13:11.617 --> 00:13:25.440
And this is, in some sense, a prediction of our best theory of dark matter, which is that every galaxy, including our own, should be surrounded by an almost innumerable number of these small clumps of dark matter.

175
00:13:25.701 --> 00:13:31.362
It's almost like our galaxy is being insulated by this dark matter as a way to incubate.

176
00:13:32.482 --> 00:13:35.884
Like the existence and sustainability of the galaxies?

177
00:13:37.245 --> 00:13:39.266
Sure, you can think of it that way if you want.

178
00:13:39.926 --> 00:13:42.508
So on the left, that's our simulation.

179
00:13:43.448 --> 00:13:51.853
And then on the right, we're looking at what looks almost like a sphere imposed on a 2D image.

180
00:13:52.713 --> 00:13:54.114
And what are we looking at on the right?

181
00:13:54.374 --> 00:13:58.236
Right, so on the right, and that's why I like this figure so much.

182
00:14:02.679 --> 00:14:06.341
all of the satellite galaxies of our galaxy that we knew of.

183
00:14:07.242 --> 00:14:11.886
So, you know, as I said, we think galaxies reside inside of dark matter halos.

184
00:14:12.366 --> 00:14:17.950
And so little galaxies that are orbiting around ours are inside of smaller dark matter halos.

185
00:14:18.791 --> 00:14:24.712
And that on the right is a map of the little galaxies that we knew of at the time.

186
00:14:25.292 --> 00:14:34.014
And what you see just looking from left to right is that there's a lot more clumps on the left that we don't see based on starlight, right?

187
00:14:34.074 --> 00:14:43.476
Those clumps, they don't have enough stars and gas in them for us to tell that they're there just by looking up and assigning them a galaxy, right?

188
00:14:43.516 --> 00:14:44.857
So they're completely dark, dark.

189
00:14:45.957 --> 00:15:12.557
gigantic so these are you know a million times to a billion times the mass of our sun these enormous concentrations of dark matter uh which we don't see because they have they they don't have enough stars or enough gas to be detected this is so bizarre um and okay so just to just to make sure i'm tracking here kind of what's interesting is you sort of see on the left the the the bright spots are the clumps of dark matter

190
00:15:13.398 --> 00:15:30.776
And it's almost there's almost like a perfect one to one correlation with the galaxies in our right image, which would track with the thesis or idea that you mentioned, which is that we think galaxies are concentrated around these large clumps of dark matter.

191
00:15:30.796 --> 00:15:31.617
Am I getting that correct?

192
00:15:32.249 --> 00:15:32.529
Yeah.

193
00:15:32.690 --> 00:15:40.778
So the idea is that, you know, galaxies, which are made of regular matter, they form inside of dark matter halos.

194
00:15:40.878 --> 00:15:42.380
So the dark matter halo is there.

195
00:15:42.840 --> 00:15:47.885
It forms earlier than the galaxies because the regular matter is hot at early times.

196
00:15:48.546 --> 00:15:54.270
And so the dark matter is there, and then the gas falls into it, and you form stars, and you form galaxies.

197
00:15:54.550 --> 00:15:57.251
Oh, it's like a pressure cooker for building galaxies.

198
00:15:57.491 --> 00:15:57.912
That's right.

199
00:15:58.032 --> 00:15:58.872
And life.

200
00:15:58.972 --> 00:16:00.073
And life itself.

201
00:16:01.034 --> 00:16:06.217
So to some extent, one implication here is that...

202
00:16:06.977 --> 00:16:18.642
the existence and the concentration of these dark matter halos or clusters is a prerequisite for the formulation of stars and galaxies.

203
00:16:20.343 --> 00:16:24.046
I wouldn't say that it's a prerequisite for the formation of stars.

204
00:16:24.066 --> 00:16:36.055
What I would say is that our current theory, our best theory for what dark matter is, it explains galaxy formation partially by putting galaxies inside of dark matter halos.

205
00:16:36.195 --> 00:16:36.455
Okay.

206
00:16:36.675 --> 00:16:43.881
And it also predicts that there should be way more dark matter halos than we can see from their stars.

207
00:16:44.762 --> 00:16:46.603
It justifies its own existence almost.

208
00:16:47.264 --> 00:16:50.027
Well, it's a concrete prediction of the theory.

209
00:16:50.267 --> 00:16:56.814
And it turns out that if you change the particle physics of dark matter, you can completely change the properties of these clumps.

210
00:16:57.595 --> 00:17:05.083
And so this is why, as you talk about why it's an interesting area of research...

211
00:17:05.964 --> 00:17:25.260
So by having a better model around, you know, these dark matter clumps, etc., we can actually start to poke at its fundamental component parts in a way that we might not be able to in other lines of inquiry in this area.

212
00:17:26.186 --> 00:17:26.906
Yeah, that's right.

213
00:17:27.006 --> 00:17:33.128
So what we want to do is essentially count how many of these clumps there are and measure how dense they are.

214
00:17:33.468 --> 00:17:39.550
Those are sort of the two, you know, two of the most interesting types of measurements you can make.

215
00:17:39.990 --> 00:17:41.091
But it's hard, right?

216
00:17:41.151 --> 00:17:43.191
Because they don't interact with light.

217
00:17:43.912 --> 00:17:46.672
We can't like detect them directly.

218
00:17:46.852 --> 00:17:49.993
We have to rely only on gravity, but it's not impossible.

219
00:17:50.153 --> 00:17:51.174
So let me give you a

220
00:17:52.774 --> 00:17:54.495
Think about this situation for a second.

221
00:17:54.515 --> 00:17:54.796
Okay.

222
00:17:54.976 --> 00:17:55.216
Okay.

223
00:17:55.256 --> 00:17:58.698
Suppose that we couldn't see the moon for whatever reason.

224
00:17:58.838 --> 00:18:03.640
Maybe it was, we're on a planet where it's always cloudy, but there's a moon and there's an ocean.

225
00:18:03.920 --> 00:18:04.160
Okay.

226
00:18:04.801 --> 00:18:10.384
So you would be able to infer that something like the moon exists based on the tides.

227
00:18:11.380 --> 00:18:14.543
Because the moon's gravity is partially responsible for the tides.

228
00:18:14.623 --> 00:18:20.109
It's the idea, you know, it's the graphics you see where Earth is here and the moon as it goes around.

229
00:18:20.409 --> 00:18:27.557
You see the water on the surface of the Earth track with the orbiting of the moon, which is what actually generates the tides itself.

230
00:18:28.080 --> 00:18:28.460
That's right.

231
00:18:28.480 --> 00:18:29.320
Yeah.

232
00:18:29.340 --> 00:18:39.463
So even if you were in a situation where you couldn't see the moon, we would be able to infer that it exists, which I guess in this analogy is like the rotation curve argument.

233
00:18:39.723 --> 00:18:43.664
So we're pretty sure that there's stuff there, but we could take it one step further.

234
00:18:43.824 --> 00:18:44.064
Right.

235
00:18:44.224 --> 00:18:48.685
And you could also estimate properties of the moon based on the tides.

236
00:18:50.266 --> 00:19:14.384
The point is through indirect observation, even though we can't directly observe dark matter, in your analogy, if the moon was dark matter and we couldn't directly observe it because we were in a cloud of whatever, nuclear dust everywhere, we would still be able to infer that it's there because it has direct impacts on some derivative observation, which in this case is the tides.

237
00:19:15.108 --> 00:19:15.528
That's right.

238
00:19:15.928 --> 00:19:16.128
Yeah.

239
00:19:16.288 --> 00:19:20.630
And so it turns out that, you know, we don't use tides in astrophysics.

240
00:19:20.650 --> 00:19:26.273
What we can actually use is light because it turns out that light is actually bent by gravity.

241
00:19:26.293 --> 00:19:30.254
So a gravitational field will deflect the path of light.

242
00:19:30.754 --> 00:19:31.995
We can see light.

243
00:19:32.595 --> 00:19:44.060
And so we can use the fact that images of astronomical objects will be slightly distorted by the gravity from dark matter to study the dark matter, even though we can't detect the dark matter directly.

244
00:19:44.720 --> 00:19:45.941
Okay, very interesting.

245
00:19:45.981 --> 00:20:03.671
So in this case, just keeping with this analogy, if dark matter is the moon, and then the water of the ocean that causes the tides is light, the water gets disturbed by the moon, which creates high, low tide and all that flow.

246
00:20:04.212 --> 00:20:09.034
Similarly, dark matter impacts light as it's traveling into our instruments.

247
00:20:09.054 --> 00:20:09.695
Okay.

248
00:20:10.115 --> 00:20:13.939
And it's going to distort it a little bit in the same way the moon would distort the tide.

249
00:20:14.459 --> 00:20:20.985
And we can measure that distortion to then derive some understanding of the size.

250
00:20:22.206 --> 00:20:27.430
And the two measurements were size and... And the internal structure of these clumps.

251
00:20:27.530 --> 00:20:28.331
Of these clumps.

252
00:20:28.671 --> 00:20:29.652
Am I getting that right?

253
00:20:29.692 --> 00:20:30.593
That's exactly right.

254
00:20:30.653 --> 00:20:31.454
Very interesting.

255
00:20:31.754 --> 00:20:31.994
Okay.

256
00:20:32.255 --> 00:20:32.495
Okay.

257
00:20:32.595 --> 00:20:33.676
And so this is where...

258
00:20:35.023 --> 00:20:37.225
where your area of research focuses.

259
00:20:37.565 --> 00:20:37.765
Right.

260
00:20:37.805 --> 00:20:40.527
So that was the longest intro of all time, right?

261
00:20:40.547 --> 00:20:41.647
That's the problem.

262
00:20:41.848 --> 00:20:48.272
But that's the best part is really understanding deeply what are we trying to, what are we looking for trying to measure?

263
00:20:48.807 --> 00:20:49.407
Yeah, that's right.

264
00:20:49.448 --> 00:20:55.692
So we are trying to measure the properties of these small, I say small, keep in mind that they're enormous, right?

265
00:20:55.712 --> 00:20:58.814
But from a cosmological standpoint, they're very small.

266
00:20:59.014 --> 00:21:05.439
These small clumps of dark matter using light and the deflection of light by the gravity of those clumps.

267
00:21:05.899 --> 00:21:10.603
Imagine if I asked you to describe the room that we're in now using gravity.

268
00:21:10.623 --> 00:21:11.964
Okay.

269
00:21:12.544 --> 00:21:15.947
This, maybe that's gives you another way of thinking about this, right?

270
00:21:16.027 --> 00:21:16.327
Okay.

271
00:21:16.607 --> 00:21:22.796
It's a very challenging thing to do is to understand the structure of some material using only gravity.

272
00:21:22.856 --> 00:21:23.617
But we can do it.

273
00:21:24.498 --> 00:21:26.381
I literally was like, I don't even know where to start.

274
00:21:27.923 --> 00:21:29.305
But this is fascinating.

275
00:21:29.405 --> 00:21:31.708
And so now...

276
00:21:33.610 --> 00:21:37.133
That sets the table really nicely because I think I understand the problem set.

277
00:21:37.754 --> 00:21:57.209
And there's so many implications to being able to better understand this area because it'll totally impact our ability to map the early models of the universe and, you know, different types of existing space-based telescope and ground-based telescope missions.

278
00:21:57.229 --> 00:21:57.409
Yeah.

279
00:21:58.245 --> 00:22:14.755
When we now talk about you as a researcher having clearly defined the problem now that we're trying to look at, you know, what is now what is your day to day kind of look like in trying to solve for that now well defined problem?

280
00:22:15.876 --> 00:22:27.314
Yeah, so what I do to study these dark matter clumps, and by I, I mean my collaboration and myself, so we use an effect called gravitational lensing.

281
00:22:27.855 --> 00:22:30.399
So this is the bending of light by gravity.

282
00:22:31.601 --> 00:22:36.265
And we use that effect to try to study the properties of these dark matter clumps.

283
00:22:36.986 --> 00:22:46.796
And I can come back a little bit later to give some more ideas, but the main picture is that we will take our best theories for what dark matter can be.

284
00:22:47.957 --> 00:23:03.941
We will predict from those theories what the properties of these clumps are, and then we'll try to simulate how that would change the deflection of light around astronomical objects in a way that we can measure and detect statistically.

285
00:23:04.481 --> 00:23:10.603
Okay, so that's the kind of structure of how it is we're going to go about this process.

286
00:23:10.623 --> 00:23:11.223
Okay.

287
00:23:11.443 --> 00:23:15.127
Um, where do you think is the best place to start in trying to understand this?

288
00:23:15.368 --> 00:23:19.512
So again, I'm really curious about how, like, what is it that you do?

289
00:23:20.113 --> 00:23:20.313
Yeah.

290
00:23:20.333 --> 00:23:20.433
Yeah.

291
00:23:20.533 --> 00:23:25.499
So let me, uh, let me, uh, let me, let me try to explain lensing a little bit more.

292
00:23:25.699 --> 00:23:25.919
Okay.

293
00:23:25.960 --> 00:23:27.541
And then once, uh, once, uh,

294
00:23:28.642 --> 00:23:31.283
We have a clear understanding of what gravitational lensing is.

295
00:23:31.343 --> 00:23:34.324
Then I'll give you some more details about the day-to-day.

296
00:23:34.484 --> 00:23:34.844
Makes sense.

297
00:23:34.864 --> 00:23:37.205
So why don't we start with number two.

298
00:23:37.385 --> 00:23:37.885
Number two.

299
00:23:37.945 --> 00:23:38.765
Let's pull that up.

300
00:23:39.446 --> 00:23:46.268
So this was one of the first images released by NASA after the James Webb Space Telescope.

301
00:23:46.808 --> 00:23:47.468
went into space.

302
00:23:48.428 --> 00:23:50.249
And this is a cluster of galaxies.

303
00:23:51.249 --> 00:24:01.672
And behind this cluster of galaxies are a bunch of other galaxies whose light is being distorted by the gravitational field of this foreground galaxy cluster.

304
00:24:02.252 --> 00:24:08.794
So this galaxy cluster is billions of light years away, and the sources behind it are another few billion light.

305
00:24:08.834 --> 00:24:13.135
I mean, so these are, you know, we're looking across most of the observable universe.

306
00:24:13.155 --> 00:24:13.475
Right.

307
00:24:13.575 --> 00:24:22.144
So the idea is like if we're here at this point right in front of my face, a billion light years away is one dot on this image.

308
00:24:22.905 --> 00:24:29.752
And then right behind it in our line of sight, another billion light years away is another dot of a light source.

309
00:24:30.433 --> 00:24:33.857
Again, from a line of sight perspective that comes directly into our instrument.

310
00:24:34.297 --> 00:24:34.717
That's right.

311
00:24:35.117 --> 00:24:44.761
But because you have this gigantic concentration of material in between us and the light source, we see those distant sources magnified and distorted.

312
00:24:44.781 --> 00:24:46.281
So if we zoom in now.

313
00:24:46.521 --> 00:24:47.482
Yes.

314
00:24:47.602 --> 00:24:47.742
Right.

315
00:24:47.762 --> 00:24:50.843
So this is a zoomed in part of that wider image.

316
00:24:50.903 --> 00:24:51.123
Yes.

317
00:24:51.423 --> 00:24:54.464
And you see in the top center, there is this bright light.

318
00:24:54.724 --> 00:24:55.905
uh, yellow objects.

319
00:24:55.965 --> 00:24:56.205
Yes.

320
00:24:56.265 --> 00:25:04.070
That's a regular galaxy in the cluster and the yellow, the other yellow banana that you see kind of draped on top.

321
00:25:04.170 --> 00:25:04.390
Yes.

322
00:25:04.610 --> 00:25:08.992
That is a background galaxy that is being warped and distorted.

323
00:25:09.092 --> 00:25:18.498
It's not, sorry, it's not actually being warped and distorted, but our image of it, what we see is a warped and distorted image of that source.

324
00:25:18.698 --> 00:25:28.601
So what we're saying is for those who are listening on audio, we always encourage, because we do so many visuals on the show, but many of you have probably seen these JWST images.

325
00:25:29.061 --> 00:25:37.884
We sort of see a diffuse circular object, which is our galaxy that's closer to us in this one, two, three line of sight point explanation we did earlier.

326
00:25:38.404 --> 00:25:41.065
And then the kind of yellow, orange is banana.

327
00:25:42.303 --> 00:26:00.487
Are we saying that it is, for the most part, a similar diffuse circular galaxy cluster, but on its way to us, the light on its way to us is being manipulated by all the gravitational and other things going on.

328
00:26:00.547 --> 00:26:06.808
So it comes a little, it looks funky to us in the image, but that's not literally what it looks like in real life.

329
00:26:07.218 --> 00:26:11.560
Yeah, it's probably a boring looking, you know, regular galaxy.

330
00:26:11.580 --> 00:26:12.661
Maybe it's interesting.

331
00:26:12.701 --> 00:26:14.762
Maybe it's a spiral galaxy or something pretty, right?

332
00:26:15.042 --> 00:26:19.664
So what we see is this, you know, warped banana type structure.

333
00:26:19.824 --> 00:26:20.004
Yes.

334
00:26:20.145 --> 00:26:25.127
And that's a purely optical effect caused by the deflection of light by gravity.

335
00:26:25.147 --> 00:26:30.250
In this case, by this bright cluster member that has enough stars in it that we can see.

336
00:26:30.470 --> 00:26:31.230
Makes sense.

337
00:26:31.250 --> 00:26:32.571
So this is gravitational lensing.

338
00:26:32.591 --> 00:26:36.213
And by the way, you see lots of other cool bananas in this image, right?

339
00:26:36.233 --> 00:26:37.013
That's not the only one.

340
00:26:37.413 --> 00:26:58.895
So when you say gravitational lensing, right, what you mean is the optical distortion that arises when we use our telescopes to look deep into the universe and there is the foreground...

341
00:27:01.017 --> 00:27:10.850
the foreground point light source is impacting our ability to observe the background point light source on its journey to our devices.

342
00:27:11.937 --> 00:27:12.137
Yeah.

343
00:27:12.317 --> 00:27:19.901
So there is some lens, in this case it's gravity, that is distorting the image of some background source.

344
00:27:20.281 --> 00:27:28.646
Oh, so you're literally using lens in the way, like it's almost like glasses, like we're putting on bifocals and it's distorting the light on its way in.

345
00:27:28.706 --> 00:27:28.886
Right.

346
00:27:29.026 --> 00:27:30.247
Gravity bifocals.

347
00:27:30.567 --> 00:27:31.387
Gravity bifocals.

348
00:27:31.407 --> 00:27:31.767
That's right.

349
00:27:32.248 --> 00:27:33.228
So that's the idea.

350
00:27:33.628 --> 00:27:40.572
And so we can use that effect to study all forms of matter, regular matter and dark matter, because they both have gravity.

351
00:27:40.592 --> 00:27:40.852
Right.

352
00:27:40.912 --> 00:27:41.594
Oh, that's a good point.

353
00:27:41.815 --> 00:27:42.638
We'll come back later.

354
00:27:42.658 --> 00:27:44.885
You know, one of the challenges, we'll come back to that point later.

355
00:27:44.965 --> 00:27:45.888
One of the challenges is,

356
00:27:47.051 --> 00:27:54.253
disentangling the contribution of dark matter to this lensing effect from the contribution of regular matter to this lensing effect.

357
00:27:54.373 --> 00:27:56.873
Because they all interact with gravity and got it.

358
00:27:57.093 --> 00:27:57.293
Okay.

359
00:27:57.313 --> 00:27:59.754
So I propose we circle back to that.

360
00:27:59.814 --> 00:28:00.054
Okay.

361
00:28:00.194 --> 00:28:03.735
Let me tell you more exactly about what we, what we actually do with these lenses.

362
00:28:03.775 --> 00:28:10.336
Cause it turns out that some lenses are better than others for some gravitational lenses are better than others for this.

363
00:28:11.096 --> 00:28:13.197
And the particular kind of

364
00:28:14.208 --> 00:28:18.092
a lensing system that we study are called strong gravitational lenses.

365
00:28:18.372 --> 00:28:18.672
Okay.

366
00:28:18.812 --> 00:28:20.874
As opposed to weak gravitational lenses.

367
00:28:20.894 --> 00:28:21.895
We like the strong ones.

368
00:28:22.015 --> 00:28:30.242
So in my silly glasses or contacts analogy, if you're a negative 0.5 or a negative 1, that's weak lensing.

369
00:28:30.302 --> 00:28:33.926
If you're a negative 4 or negative 5 like I am, strong lensing.

370
00:28:34.106 --> 00:28:37.409
If you can't see your hand, then you need strong lensing.

371
00:28:38.049 --> 00:28:41.296
So let's introduce Strong Lensing.

372
00:28:41.316 --> 00:28:43.119
So let's look at The Fish, number five.

373
00:28:43.179 --> 00:28:43.600
Number five.

374
00:28:43.620 --> 00:28:45.083
All right, so this was a movie...

375
00:28:46.214 --> 00:28:50.975
I believe Yashar Hitzave was the first one to use this movie to discuss strong lensing.

376
00:28:50.995 --> 00:28:51.295
Okay.

377
00:28:51.655 --> 00:28:54.836
This is just a movie made on Earth of a fish tank.

378
00:28:55.816 --> 00:29:02.858
There's a goldfish in the fish tank, and you'll see that as it approaches the corner of the tank, the fish becomes doubly imaged.

379
00:29:03.398 --> 00:29:05.499
So we see two images of the fish.

380
00:29:06.179 --> 00:29:07.339
But there are not two fish.

381
00:29:07.559 --> 00:29:09.079
But there's only one fish, right?

382
00:29:09.119 --> 00:29:15.441
So what's happening is the light is being deflected by the glass, in this case the corner of the fish tank.

383
00:29:16.081 --> 00:29:22.844
In such a way that there are two paths through space that connect our eyes with the fish.

384
00:29:23.024 --> 00:29:25.605
So, you know, light takes two different paths.

385
00:29:25.965 --> 00:29:31.007
It gets bent by the glass in the fish tank and then it becomes...

386
00:29:31.267 --> 00:29:32.408
Yeah, to us.

387
00:29:32.688 --> 00:29:32.868
Right.

388
00:29:32.888 --> 00:29:34.269
So it's like light is bending.

389
00:29:34.369 --> 00:29:38.472
So we're looking at the corner of the fish tank, this sort of left side.

390
00:29:39.313 --> 00:29:43.756
As the fish comes across, the light's coming into my left eye from the left side.

391
00:29:44.737 --> 00:29:53.723
But as it's coming, as it gets closer to that corner, light is now traveling down the glass from the right side and coming to my right eye.

392
00:30:01.208 --> 00:30:06.373
this because it just happens to be at the right angle to see it coming from both points.

393
00:30:06.593 --> 00:30:06.793
Yeah.

394
00:30:06.933 --> 00:30:09.536
So those are two images of the same fish.

395
00:30:10.056 --> 00:30:12.058
Both images are just as valid, right?

396
00:30:12.078 --> 00:30:14.040
I mean, it's not like one of them is a fake image, right?

397
00:30:14.100 --> 00:30:14.260
Right.

398
00:30:14.300 --> 00:30:21.866
It's just, you know, we see two images of this background source, which in this case is a fish, because the foreground...

399
00:30:22.547 --> 00:30:26.630
deflector, which in this case is a fish tank, is bending the light.

400
00:30:26.650 --> 00:30:27.051
I see.

401
00:30:27.351 --> 00:30:27.711
I see.

402
00:30:27.911 --> 00:30:36.038
So in cosmology, you replace the fish with the galaxy and the fish tank with another galaxy, and then you understand strong lensing.

403
00:30:36.258 --> 00:30:36.678
I see.

404
00:30:36.758 --> 00:30:38.760
So the fish is the background galaxy.

405
00:30:38.780 --> 00:30:39.420
That's right.

406
00:30:39.620 --> 00:30:43.103
And then the glass of the fish tank is the foreground galaxy.

407
00:30:43.904 --> 00:30:49.228
And so we can look at the image of the background galaxy being warped

408
00:30:50.415 --> 00:30:56.577
To be able to define the glass of the fish tank, to be able to better understand the structure of the glass of the fish tank.

409
00:30:56.857 --> 00:30:57.557
Yeah, totally.

410
00:30:57.597 --> 00:31:03.780
So you could imagine that even if you couldn't see the fish tank for some reason, you could infer that there's something there.

411
00:31:03.800 --> 00:31:05.000
I see where we're going with this.

412
00:31:05.020 --> 00:31:06.601
Because it's producing these two images of the fish.

413
00:31:06.681 --> 00:31:19.425
So in this analogy, if the glass of the fish tank was dark matter, which we couldn't see, we would be able to infer that there was a piece of glass that was at a right angle right here because we're seeing two fish like that.

414
00:31:19.878 --> 00:31:20.619
Yes.

415
00:31:20.779 --> 00:31:22.500
We can even take it a step further, right?

416
00:31:22.981 --> 00:31:28.285
If this fish tank had a bunch of defects in it, like dents and stuff, those would be the clumps.

417
00:31:28.526 --> 00:31:32.669
And they would affect the small scale structure of the fish.

418
00:31:32.709 --> 00:31:43.579
So if we saw a fish that had a bunch of small deformations in addition to being doubly imaged, we might conclude that whatever lens is there is clumpy on some scale.

419
00:31:43.859 --> 00:31:46.241
And we can extract that from the image.

420
00:31:46.281 --> 00:31:46.401
Okay.

421
00:31:46.421 --> 00:31:46.702
Okay.

422
00:31:47.422 --> 00:31:49.284
That's very helpful.

423
00:31:49.424 --> 00:31:53.647
And so the concept here is gravitational lensing.

424
00:31:54.528 --> 00:31:57.810
And it is a methodology by which...

425
00:31:59.772 --> 00:32:07.138
It's something that happens because of the way optics works and the way light and gravity interact.

426
00:32:07.978 --> 00:32:12.542
We can see these lenses throughout all of our different sky surveys and et cetera, et cetera.

427
00:32:13.022 --> 00:32:16.085
And we can use the structure of the lens...

428
00:32:17.729 --> 00:32:20.470
to do a whole bunch of science around it.

429
00:32:21.510 --> 00:32:22.350
Yeah, that's right.

430
00:32:22.530 --> 00:32:26.931
So you can do lots of different cool science with lensing, not just dark matter.

431
00:32:27.011 --> 00:32:27.291
Okay.

432
00:32:27.412 --> 00:32:33.233
You can also use them to measure distances, which are sensitive to the expansion rate of the universe.

433
00:32:33.833 --> 00:32:36.254
For example, you can use lensing to study the stars.

434
00:32:36.274 --> 00:32:36.754
Mm-hmm.

435
00:32:37.274 --> 00:32:40.256
because, you know, regular matter also contributes to this effect.

436
00:32:40.276 --> 00:32:43.597
So you can use it to study stars around different galaxies.

437
00:32:44.158 --> 00:32:48.820
For us, we're interested in using it to study the dark matter and in particular to study these clumps.

438
00:32:49.400 --> 00:32:52.622
And I think we actually have another picture that would be helpful here.

439
00:32:52.702 --> 00:32:55.903
It's the, let's see, it is number eight.

440
00:32:56.143 --> 00:32:56.604
Number eight.

441
00:32:56.624 --> 00:32:57.184
No, I'm sorry.

442
00:32:57.224 --> 00:32:57.544
No, no.

443
00:32:57.904 --> 00:32:58.344
Number nine.

444
00:32:58.585 --> 00:32:59.185
Number nine.

445
00:32:59.225 --> 00:33:00.305
Let's go to number nine.

446
00:33:00.325 --> 00:33:00.405
Yes.

447
00:33:00.766 --> 00:33:00.946
Yes.

448
00:33:01.546 --> 00:33:09.828
So yeah, this is another cluster of galaxies that's producing a strong gravitational lensing effect.

449
00:33:10.508 --> 00:33:15.269
So here there's G1 through G4.

450
00:33:15.469 --> 00:33:16.750
You see them labeled there.

451
00:33:17.170 --> 00:33:19.650
And then there's this giant blue arc.

452
00:33:19.950 --> 00:33:20.191
Yes.

453
00:33:20.831 --> 00:33:25.792
So that blue arc is a galaxy that's behind this cluster.

454
00:33:26.872 --> 00:33:29.953
So that background galaxy is being lensed around.

455
00:33:29.973 --> 00:33:30.053
Yes.

456
00:33:30.493 --> 00:33:32.095
and it forms this distorted arc.

457
00:33:32.696 --> 00:33:44.089
And you see there in the bottom right that galaxy G4, which is associated with this other group of galaxies, it happens to be right on top of the arc.

458
00:33:44.349 --> 00:33:44.589
Yes.

459
00:33:45.450 --> 00:33:48.093
And you can see that the arc does this little...

460
00:33:48.914 --> 00:33:50.815
you know, jog around G4.

461
00:33:50.875 --> 00:33:51.095
Yes.

462
00:33:51.515 --> 00:33:54.097
So the G4s here splits this arc in two.

463
00:33:55.598 --> 00:34:04.042
And you can imagine that even if you didn't see G4 at all, here we can see it because it has enough stars to be detected directly.

464
00:34:04.563 --> 00:34:11.206
But even if we couldn't see G4 there, we could infer that there's some massive objects at that position because the arc is split around.

465
00:34:11.226 --> 00:34:13.348
The arc would be split around it.

466
00:34:13.368 --> 00:34:15.949
And the arc is massive.

467
00:34:16.249 --> 00:34:17.290
I mean, it's so...

468
00:34:18.050 --> 00:34:22.072
And so would this be an example of strong gravitational lensing?

469
00:34:22.712 --> 00:34:23.292
Yeah, that's right.

470
00:34:23.412 --> 00:34:36.017
So here, G1 through G3 and, yeah, G1, G2, and G3, they are massive enough to produce two images of this background galaxy.

471
00:34:36.037 --> 00:34:38.899
You see that there's another little counter arc there on the left.

472
00:34:38.939 --> 00:34:39.499
On the left, yep.

473
00:34:39.519 --> 00:34:39.679
Yep.

474
00:34:40.319 --> 00:34:44.421
So here, those guys are producing the lensing effect.

475
00:34:45.181 --> 00:34:54.084
And then we can detect the presence of this other clump because it's impinging on the lensed image of this background source.

476
00:34:54.104 --> 00:34:55.065
Yes, makes sense.

477
00:34:55.425 --> 00:34:55.725
Makes sense.

478
00:34:55.745 --> 00:34:56.885
This is so fascinating.

479
00:34:57.326 --> 00:35:02.788
It's like kind of a hard thing to visualize or to mentally track.

480
00:35:02.888 --> 00:35:07.329
I think the fish tank analogy was very helpful in trying to create some grounding.

481
00:35:07.349 --> 00:35:08.230
Yeah.

482
00:35:09.050 --> 00:35:22.482
You know, because I think part of what your point is, if we look at this image, and I think where we're going with this is let's imagine G4, which is right on the arc, which is the lens from the background galaxy that G1 through G3 are creating.

483
00:35:23.203 --> 00:35:24.564
If G4 had no light...

484
00:35:25.885 --> 00:35:27.165
There was no point light source.

485
00:35:27.986 --> 00:35:34.588
Because it's so massive, it's having its own almost mini lens on the other lens.

486
00:35:35.568 --> 00:35:44.971
We could subsequently make some characterizations about G4 being there because it is impacting the larger lens from G1 through G3.

487
00:35:45.151 --> 00:35:46.571
Is that correct?

488
00:35:46.791 --> 00:35:47.532
Yeah, exactly.

489
00:35:47.572 --> 00:35:48.852
So here, you know...

490
00:35:50.506 --> 00:35:54.431
Here, G4 is so big that it has a galaxy in it and we can see the galaxy, right?

491
00:35:54.451 --> 00:35:56.373
So this is just a proof of concept.

492
00:35:56.453 --> 00:36:00.538
What we're really interested in is these dark matter clumps that don't have galaxies.

493
00:36:01.038 --> 00:36:02.921
Conceptually, it's very similar, right?

494
00:36:02.941 --> 00:36:08.187
They would introduce some perturbation or some small deformation of the lensed image, right?

495
00:36:08.467 --> 00:36:10.489
It wouldn't be as obvious as this case.

496
00:36:11.110 --> 00:36:13.092
But the idea is the same.

497
00:36:14.092 --> 00:36:14.733
I get it now.

498
00:36:14.833 --> 00:36:15.133
I get it.

499
00:36:16.474 --> 00:36:20.517
The canvas on which you're trying to paint is the lens itself.

500
00:36:20.577 --> 00:36:30.704
You can look at the light arcs, you know, that are happening and see, do we see anything, any perturbations in the light arcs or the lens?

501
00:36:30.745 --> 00:36:30.845
Yeah.

502
00:36:31.545 --> 00:36:34.831
where there are not necessarily point light sources like a large galaxy.

503
00:36:35.171 --> 00:36:43.505
Because if you do see that, that is a potentially good candidate or indicator of underlying dark matter clumps on the lens.

504
00:36:44.081 --> 00:36:44.822
Yeah, exactly.

505
00:36:45.162 --> 00:36:46.844
Very interesting.

506
00:36:47.084 --> 00:36:48.265
Very interesting.

507
00:36:48.385 --> 00:36:55.172
And what helps look at smaller clumps is actually having a more compact source.

508
00:36:55.753 --> 00:36:56.434
Okay.

509
00:36:56.474 --> 00:36:56.894
How do you mean?

510
00:36:57.194 --> 00:36:59.977
So imagine that you were at a football field.

511
00:37:00.218 --> 00:37:00.498
Okay.

512
00:37:00.838 --> 00:37:04.882
And there's a gigantic floodlight that's shining down onto the field.

513
00:37:05.022 --> 00:37:05.243
Yes.

514
00:37:05.283 --> 00:37:07.365
It's this huge lamp, basically, right?

515
00:37:07.385 --> 00:37:07.565
Yes.

516
00:37:08.553 --> 00:37:14.057
and someone held up a magnifying glass in front of that lamp or in front of that light.

517
00:37:14.077 --> 00:37:14.497
Okay.

518
00:37:14.937 --> 00:37:24.124
You probably wouldn't be able to tell that the magnifying glass is there because the, the, this lamp is so enormous, right?

519
00:37:24.264 --> 00:37:32.609
So like you have this huge source and you put some little, you know, lens in front of it, but it doesn't really change what you see when you look up at this giant floodlight.

520
00:37:32.669 --> 00:37:32.910
Right.

521
00:37:33.730 --> 00:37:37.413
So, but if you do that same thing with a flashlight,

522
00:37:38.199 --> 00:37:45.624
So if someone is shining a flashlight and you put the same little magnifying glass in front of the flashlight, then you're going to tell there's something there, right?

523
00:37:45.644 --> 00:37:45.804
Yes.

524
00:37:46.185 --> 00:37:49.767
Because all of a sudden this flashlight gets a thousand times brighter, right?

525
00:37:49.787 --> 00:37:49.947
Yes.

526
00:37:50.508 --> 00:37:56.252
And so it's actually really helpful to look at lenses where you have a really compact lens.

527
00:37:56.932 --> 00:38:01.373
source that's being lensed, not like a whole galaxy that becomes lensed into an arc.

528
00:38:01.734 --> 00:38:12.477
Oh, we actually want to find lenses that have a really tiny source because then they're really sensitive to really tiny, you know, lensing perturbations from these smaller dark matter clumps.

529
00:38:12.517 --> 00:38:13.898
So actually, this is an interesting note.

530
00:38:14.258 --> 00:38:20.680
So when we say strong gravitational lensing, it doesn't necessarily mean visually when we look at these images, big arc.

531
00:38:20.760 --> 00:38:20.920
Yeah.

532
00:38:21.840 --> 00:38:30.182
It just means the effect is strong, but we actually want tighter from the again, from the talking about it visually.

533
00:38:30.462 --> 00:38:42.405
We want a tighter, more concentrated lens because we are going to be more able to detect these sort of smaller perturbations from dark matter than we would if it was this giant lens.

534
00:38:43.565 --> 00:38:45.806
And it's the, it's the perfectly like the analogy.

535
00:38:45.826 --> 00:38:50.347
You just said you wouldn't be able to see the magnifying glass if it was a floodlight, but you would if it was a flashlight.

536
00:38:50.567 --> 00:38:51.707
And so we're looking for flashlights.

537
00:38:52.228 --> 00:38:53.508
Yeah, we're looking for flashlights.

538
00:38:53.968 --> 00:38:54.328
That's right.

539
00:38:54.368 --> 00:38:57.429
And there's actually, you know, nature provides flashlights for us.

540
00:38:57.949 --> 00:39:02.170
And sometimes they get strongly lensed, which by the way, maybe we should have said this earlier.

541
00:39:02.270 --> 00:39:02.450
Yes.

542
00:39:02.670 --> 00:39:08.432
So what distinguishes strong lensing from weak lensing or some other type of lensing is the appearance of multiple images.

543
00:39:08.452 --> 00:39:08.972
Yeah.

544
00:39:09.398 --> 00:39:12.680
So like you had multiple, you know, two fish, right?

545
00:39:12.700 --> 00:39:14.462
So that was a strong lens by a fish tank.

546
00:39:14.482 --> 00:39:16.783
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

547
00:39:16.803 --> 00:39:18.525
So we want to find strong lenses.

548
00:39:18.765 --> 00:39:22.127
This is the dream scenario for dark matter, right?

549
00:39:22.528 --> 00:39:29.212
You have a bunch of strong lenses where you have multiple images of a point-like background source.

550
00:39:29.653 --> 00:39:36.418
And so in the fish tank example, when you say multiple images, we're talking about how when we're looking at the corner of the fish tank, we saw the fish twice.

551
00:39:37.555 --> 00:39:42.357
Is part of what you're saying that the multiple images can also be more than two?

552
00:39:43.117 --> 00:39:44.618
Sometimes, yeah, they can be four.

553
00:39:44.738 --> 00:39:46.198
And those are actually the ones we like.

554
00:39:46.618 --> 00:39:46.838
Okay.

555
00:39:46.858 --> 00:39:47.379
There's four.

556
00:39:47.479 --> 00:39:48.679
Very interesting.

557
00:39:48.779 --> 00:39:49.159
Okay.

558
00:39:49.579 --> 00:39:50.840
Let's look at one.

559
00:39:50.860 --> 00:39:51.620
So number seven.

560
00:39:51.800 --> 00:39:52.841
Yes.

561
00:39:52.941 --> 00:39:55.862
So this is a quadruply imaged quasar.

562
00:39:55.882 --> 00:39:56.182
Wow.

563
00:39:56.202 --> 00:39:56.342
Wow.

564
00:39:56.722 --> 00:40:02.506
So nature provides point-like background sources in the form of quasars.

565
00:40:02.726 --> 00:40:07.930
So a quasar is a black hole that is eating matter.

566
00:40:09.150 --> 00:40:14.014
And so all of the matter around it gets really, really hot and it shines extremely brightly.

567
00:40:14.154 --> 00:40:18.116
And they are extremely compact, so they're essentially like point sources.

568
00:40:18.817 --> 00:40:21.899
And in this case, you have this yellow blob in the middle.

569
00:40:22.099 --> 00:40:22.319
Yes.

570
00:40:22.459 --> 00:40:23.840
So that's a regular galaxy.

571
00:40:23.860 --> 00:40:23.940
Yes.

572
00:40:24.040 --> 00:40:24.241
Yes.

573
00:40:25.321 --> 00:40:32.545
And that regular galaxy is situated directly in front of another galaxy that has a quasar in it.

574
00:40:33.365 --> 00:40:39.488
And so in addition to this ring, which is a lens light from the background galaxy coming around.

575
00:40:39.568 --> 00:40:39.708
Yes.

576
00:40:39.728 --> 00:40:42.570
And so we see it, you know, around the deflector in front.

577
00:40:42.590 --> 00:40:42.810
Yes.

578
00:40:43.550 --> 00:40:46.412
we actually see four images of the central quasar.

579
00:40:47.733 --> 00:40:49.214
This is one of the coolest things.

580
00:40:49.334 --> 00:40:55.437
So those are four duplicate images of the bright point-like center of that background galaxy.

581
00:40:55.558 --> 00:40:56.858
This is unbelievable.

582
00:40:56.898 --> 00:41:04.243
And we're saying one of them is kind of that solitary one slightly to the right of the center, like galaxy cluster.

583
00:41:04.583 --> 00:41:10.187
And then we sort of have three on the edge of what this outer ring of the lens looks like.

584
00:41:11.747 --> 00:41:15.009
And so I just want to make sure and clarify that I'm understanding this correctly.

585
00:41:15.049 --> 00:41:16.550
There's two things happening here.

586
00:41:17.370 --> 00:41:24.374
It is both the lens of the background galaxy itself, which is kind of the orange ring.

587
00:41:25.574 --> 00:41:30.917
And then in addition to that, because the quasar inside that background galaxy is,

588
00:41:32.458 --> 00:41:46.987
based on the way you described it, it's such a key source of light because it's eating so much and creating a lot of heat and subsequently giving off a ton of light in and of itself as an individual quasar.

589
00:41:47.348 --> 00:41:53.992
That's the purple that we're seeing in addition to the lens of the whole galaxy that the quasar is inside itself.

590
00:41:54.544 --> 00:42:01.912
Yeah, so if you saw an image of that background source, which here it's being lensed, so it looks really weird, right?

591
00:42:01.932 --> 00:42:11.422
But if you saw an image of that galaxy without lensing happening, it would probably be a spiral galaxy with a really bright spot right in the middle.

592
00:42:11.682 --> 00:42:11.903
Right.

593
00:42:11.963 --> 00:42:12.123
Right.

594
00:42:12.363 --> 00:42:12.543
Right.

595
00:42:12.803 --> 00:42:27.329
Now, if you put a giant galaxy in front of it, instead of seeing a spiral galaxy with a bright spot right in the middle, we're seeing four images of that bright spot and then the galaxy around that bright spot being lensed around into this really, really cool.

596
00:42:27.369 --> 00:42:29.309
This is so fascinating.

597
00:42:29.409 --> 00:42:30.310
My goodness.

598
00:42:30.330 --> 00:42:30.870
Yes.

599
00:42:31.130 --> 00:42:31.791
Oh my God.

600
00:42:31.831 --> 00:42:33.111
That's so interesting.

601
00:42:33.231 --> 00:42:33.412
Yeah.

602
00:42:33.452 --> 00:42:39.936
So these things are, I mean, it's one of the most in your face examples of Einstein's general relativity.

603
00:42:40.076 --> 00:42:40.316
Right.

604
00:42:40.356 --> 00:42:44.859
I mean, you point a really good telescope into space and you find these things.

605
00:42:44.919 --> 00:42:48.461
This is the whole, the, uh, space time curvature piece.

606
00:42:48.541 --> 00:42:51.003
Like, like that, that, that, that, um, yeah,

607
00:42:53.104 --> 00:43:17.798
gravity creates these wells that light travels around and it's so concentrated gravity and all like it's such a it's so not intuitive to me like just it like it makes sense everything you're saying makes sense but thinking about it makes my brain hurt a little bit because it's like well why does it do that but like i know there's a reason why it does that but it still is not naturally intuitive for me

608
00:43:19.091 --> 00:43:22.433
Yeah, I mean, it takes a while to wrap your head around.

609
00:43:22.994 --> 00:43:24.134
But that's fascinating.

610
00:43:24.194 --> 00:43:44.868
And so now I think it makes a lot of sense why, with that explanation of strong lensing, strong gravitational lensing, and an understanding of dark matter and the base research question around wanting to find and be able to measure these small clumps of dark matter, I can sort of now get why...

611
00:43:46.418 --> 00:44:03.482
these concentrated point light source background galaxies that create like the tight ring that then have these multiple images because what I would sort of guess from the way you've set this up is that each of those, you now have four...

612
00:44:04.980 --> 00:44:17.429
in that case, four images of the same thing that you can then analyze in a variety of different ways as opposed to just having one image of the same thing with a well-characterized understanding of the gravitational impacts and things like that.

613
00:44:17.770 --> 00:44:22.393
Yeah, so it's actually, it's really important to have, and this is why strong lensing is so important.

614
00:44:22.473 --> 00:44:24.395
It's important to have the multiple images

615
00:44:25.224 --> 00:44:38.936
Because if you just have one image, it's not possible to disentangle what the source actually intrinsically looks like and what kind of, you know, lensing deformation might be happening in between you and the source.

616
00:44:39.016 --> 00:44:39.336
Right.

617
00:44:39.576 --> 00:44:39.716
Right.

618
00:44:39.736 --> 00:44:48.804
But if you have multiple images of the same source, it's much easier to disentangle what the source actually looks like from what kind of distortions might be there.

619
00:44:48.904 --> 00:44:50.706
What's so funny is, I mean, if you, if.

620
00:44:51.246 --> 00:44:55.768
As many know, I'm the resident UAP guy on the podcast on identified anomalous phenomena.

621
00:44:55.788 --> 00:45:03.830
And one of the challenges with detection, characterization, and evaluation is you need multi-sensor systems.

622
00:45:03.950 --> 00:45:11.613
Because if you just have one source, an infrared detector or, you know, electro-optical or, you know, full motion video,

623
00:45:12.473 --> 00:45:17.594
It's hard to understand distance and speed and all these things with only one reference point.

624
00:45:17.914 --> 00:45:27.836
So a similar like it tracks conceptually that you want to be able to have multiple points to be able to triangulate to disentangle in the way that you described.

625
00:45:28.216 --> 00:45:35.238
Is it also help with disentangling the impacts of the regular gravity versus the gravity driven by dark matter?

626
00:45:37.034 --> 00:45:38.996
Yeah, so that's a good question.

627
00:45:39.116 --> 00:45:51.304
And it's one of the main challenges in my research is finding ways to model these gravitational lens systems in a way that allows you to disentangle the two signals, right?

628
00:45:51.364 --> 00:45:52.525
One of them is dark matter.

629
00:45:52.985 --> 00:45:54.526
The other one is regular matter.

630
00:45:54.586 --> 00:46:01.031
They're both producing a gravitational lensing effect, and we want to isolate the one from these clumps.

631
00:46:01.711 --> 00:46:08.416
What helps is that these clumps, they look very different or they're predicted to look very different from a galaxy, right?

632
00:46:08.756 --> 00:46:17.242
So they are these concentrated blobs of mass, whereas the galaxy, you know, the one that we were just looking at, maybe we can pull it up here again.

633
00:46:17.322 --> 00:46:18.402
It was number seven.

634
00:46:18.522 --> 00:46:18.703
Yep.

635
00:46:19.863 --> 00:46:20.043
Right.

636
00:46:20.524 --> 00:46:30.691
It looks, you know, the scales here are a little bit difficult to comprehend, I think, but, you know, this galaxy is much...

637
00:46:32.802 --> 00:46:35.363
it does not look like the clumps that we're looking for.

638
00:46:36.283 --> 00:46:47.207
So we, we can use the fact that the predicted properties of these dark matter halos produces a very different kind of lensing effect from the galaxy itself and from the regular matter.

639
00:46:47.727 --> 00:46:50.128
And that allows us to, to disentangle them.

640
00:46:50.448 --> 00:46:52.329
And again, that's a prediction of the theory, right?

641
00:46:52.349 --> 00:46:53.009
That we're testing.

642
00:46:53.029 --> 00:46:53.409
Yeah.

643
00:46:54.169 --> 00:47:00.271
If you had no information, if you had no idea what you were looking for, then the task would be a lot harder.

644
00:47:00.411 --> 00:47:01.051
Right, right.

645
00:47:01.331 --> 00:47:06.713
And this comes back to kind of, I think, understanding what you're...

646
00:47:06.873 --> 00:47:13.935
I think now we have a good structure and setup for myself and the listeners on, okay...

647
00:47:14.775 --> 00:47:15.836
What is dark matter?

648
00:47:16.096 --> 00:47:19.237
Why do we think it exists?

649
00:47:19.918 --> 00:47:24.880
What are the ways in which we have tried to prove its existence?

650
00:47:25.461 --> 00:47:28.983
We talked about galaxy rotation curves versus now gravitational lensing.

651
00:47:29.383 --> 00:47:30.263
What is lensing?

652
00:47:30.663 --> 00:47:31.644
Why does it happen?

653
00:47:33.685 --> 00:47:38.628
And as we look to better characterize dark matter...

654
00:47:39.909 --> 00:47:56.259
measuring, looking at and measuring strong gravitational lensing is an indirect way for us to start to better understand the structure of these small dark matter clumps.

655
00:47:56.699 --> 00:48:06.205
And so that's kind of now the intellectual thought process that brings us back to my question that I'm not going to let you leave the studio without answering, which is...

656
00:48:06.825 --> 00:48:09.449
So what is it that you do every day?

657
00:48:09.690 --> 00:48:10.170
Yeah.

658
00:48:10.190 --> 00:48:12.474
Now that we have all the groundwork, I can tell you.

659
00:48:12.875 --> 00:48:14.337
So, you know, I, uh,

660
00:48:15.838 --> 00:48:28.409
I'm interested in finding ways to use these lenses, gravitational lenses, to distinguish between dark matter theories that make different predictions for these clumps of dark matter.

661
00:48:28.870 --> 00:48:36.677
So that's what me and my colleagues think about on a daily basis is how we can make this measurement statistically.

662
00:48:36.717 --> 00:48:38.679
And so there's a few different angles, right?

663
00:48:38.699 --> 00:48:39.719
So one is the data.

664
00:48:40.260 --> 00:48:41.761
So we try to observe...

665
00:48:42.882 --> 00:48:46.406
uh, as many of these, uh, gravitational lenses as we can.

666
00:48:46.426 --> 00:48:50.029
Uh, the other one is from the, the theory and the modeling side.

667
00:48:50.089 --> 00:48:59.297
So, you know, you, you, maybe you have some theory of dark matter that predicts that these clumps are less numerous than our, than some other theory.

668
00:48:59.318 --> 00:48:59.378
Um,

669
00:48:59.938 --> 00:49:05.181
We'll think about how to simulate lenses with those predictions built into the simulations.

670
00:49:06.041 --> 00:49:21.328
And we'll compare those simulations with reality in a statistical sense and try to determine whether the physics that we put into our simulations of these lenses looks, if it produces data that looks like the real thing.

671
00:49:21.868 --> 00:49:28.692
And if we succeed in doing that, then we think that maybe the physics that we put into our simulations for the dark matter is correct.

672
00:49:28.712 --> 00:49:29.252
Yeah.

673
00:49:29.933 --> 00:49:54.193
that so the okay i i think i'm tracking so there's there's like uh there's two there's two inputs almost one input on one end is existing theories on uh the formation of dark matter uh theoretical frameworks uh that provide an argument as to why this is the way it works there's you know n number of these that you could potentially be using and

674
00:49:55.014 --> 00:50:07.126
That becomes an input into the models you create, the simulations, that would then generate examples of gravitational lensing.

675
00:50:07.846 --> 00:50:08.067
Right?

676
00:50:09.548 --> 00:50:12.090
Because we have, like, so that's one input.

677
00:50:12.110 --> 00:50:15.093
And then the other input on the other side is we have all this data.

678
00:50:16.354 --> 00:50:21.838
that's been taken from our real world with real gravitational lensing, and we know where all those objects are.

679
00:50:23.579 --> 00:50:26.041
And so we take sort of a model of the physics of the world.

680
00:50:26.961 --> 00:50:42.352
We add the extra ingredient of the dark matter physics, and we see can we generate a lens in the simulation that maps to a lens that we've already captured and we have well characterized.

681
00:50:43.140 --> 00:50:44.261
Yeah, exactly.

682
00:50:44.341 --> 00:50:50.148
So, you know, this picture, the lens that we were looking at, yes, this guy.

683
00:50:51.150 --> 00:51:02.623
So, you know, we can simulate on supercomputers lenses that look very, very similar to this, almost exactly like this, but they have different clumps of dark matter around.

684
00:51:03.384 --> 00:51:13.751
And they, you know, some theories of dark matter with different properties from these clumps will do a little bit better than others at explaining this particular lens.

685
00:51:14.232 --> 00:51:16.613
So each one gives you a little bit of information.

686
00:51:17.294 --> 00:51:26.440
So, you know, maybe dark matter theory A is like twice as likely if we only had this example of a gravitational lens, we would maybe think...

687
00:51:26.880 --> 00:51:29.782
okay, the clumps, you know, maybe they have these properties.

688
00:51:29.822 --> 00:51:31.683
So dark matter theory A is a little bit better.

689
00:51:32.304 --> 00:51:40.308
What makes it powerful is when you do it with 30 lenses or a hundred lenses or in the future, maybe a thousand lenses.

690
00:51:40.328 --> 00:51:53.837
That's when we can start to make really, really, you know, we're already making interesting statements about dark matter, but we're about to be in a new era where we'll be able to do these experiments with thousands or tens of thousands.

691
00:51:54.778 --> 00:52:09.132
This is actually a good note because I think one of the things, so the reason I kind of talked about it as inputs earlier is one of those, the input on the real world side is dependent on

692
00:52:10.292 --> 00:52:17.495
are space-based and ground-based telescopes, and ideally space-based because we get rid of the atmosphere and the distortion and dealing with that is no fun.

693
00:52:18.375 --> 00:52:36.203
But it's sort of currently inherently a limited data set, but that seems to be on the path to changing, not only with Vera Rubin, which is already online and producing an unbelievable amount of data that's available online,

694
00:52:36.423 --> 00:53:03.654
like they're doing dumps every day or every three days right now, as well as the, I believe it's called the Roman Space Telescope, which is slated to launch later in 2026, both of which, as I guess, quote, sky surveys, are going to just have an unbelievable amount of data, which would data from either of those two now become an input into that real-world confirmation data set.

695
00:53:04.923 --> 00:53:06.003
Yeah, definitely.

696
00:53:06.684 --> 00:53:10.965
So you mentioned the Vera Rubin Observatory and the Roman Space Telescope.

697
00:53:10.985 --> 00:53:15.507
There's also another European mission called the Euclid Mission.

698
00:53:16.087 --> 00:53:24.491
So these are surveys that are going to look at huge swaths of the sky in unprecedented detail.

699
00:53:24.731 --> 00:53:29.853
So the Roman Telescope, for example, is like the Hubble Space Telescope,

700
00:53:30.765 --> 00:53:41.816
has a similar diameter mirror, and the images that it will produce will be of similar quality to the Hubble Space Telescope, but the field of view is 100 times larger.

701
00:53:41.836 --> 00:53:42.978
That's incredible.

702
00:53:42.998 --> 00:53:49.664
And it's going to look at a huge part of the sky, and it's going to find, we think, hundreds or thousands of lenses.

703
00:53:50.045 --> 00:53:51.646
And by the way, I mean, these lenses, they...

704
00:53:52.907 --> 00:53:58.289
They look bright and spectacular, but they're actually really difficult to find because they are so small.

705
00:53:58.589 --> 00:54:07.412
So the examples that we were looking at, this quadruple image, quasar, for example, that is about one one thousandth of a degree.

706
00:54:08.372 --> 00:54:09.012
On the sky.

707
00:54:09.032 --> 00:54:09.513
Okay.

708
00:54:10.113 --> 00:54:10.513
Say more.

709
00:54:11.374 --> 00:54:17.397
So, you know, this is not something that you can just look at an image from a telescope and find, right?

710
00:54:17.417 --> 00:54:19.138
I mean, it's so tiny.

711
00:54:19.218 --> 00:54:21.719
I mean, it's really challenging to find these things.

712
00:54:22.840 --> 00:54:30.564
Is this an area where... And I think you were explaining to me just because I want people to understand that scale a little bit better.

713
00:54:30.624 --> 00:54:31.565
Like the moon...

714
00:54:32.365 --> 00:54:36.587
is what as compared to like, we'd like people can have a reference point for the moon.

715
00:54:37.047 --> 00:54:38.988
So the moon is like something.

716
00:54:39.188 --> 00:54:42.030
And then the thing we're looking for is a fraction of that.

717
00:54:42.250 --> 00:54:42.450
Yeah.

718
00:54:42.470 --> 00:54:42.610
Yeah.

719
00:54:42.630 --> 00:54:45.892
So the moon, it's about a quarter of a degree or so.

720
00:54:46.012 --> 00:54:46.312
Okay.

721
00:54:46.332 --> 00:54:50.114
So about 1000th of the size of the moon, give or take.

722
00:54:50.894 --> 00:54:57.075
So, you know, they, and they're really tiny, but bear in mind, these are enormous galaxies producing the lensing effect.

723
00:54:57.195 --> 00:54:59.656
The reason they're so tiny is because they're so far away.

724
00:54:59.736 --> 00:55:04.317
They're just millions of light years in the past.

725
00:55:05.137 --> 00:55:20.081
That's so, that's so, so what, one of the things that's, that has become a conversation, and this was actually something that Krishna in his interview with John Mulcahy at Carnegie Observatories asked him about, which is.

726
00:55:21.141 --> 00:55:23.263
because they had a brief discussion on Vera Rubin as well.

727
00:55:24.044 --> 00:55:44.483
And the impact that AI is going to have in the detection and characterization and data processing pipelines, again, with still a human in the loop, but if you're taking 800 terabytes of a data set and you can narrow it down to candidate targets that then can go to human review, that seems like it's going to have...

728
00:55:45.003 --> 00:55:54.195
huge impact in terms of trying to more aggressively and quickly kind of get from the 30 lens candidates to the thousands number.

729
00:55:54.215 --> 00:55:59.602
I mean, what do you, how do you feel about the role that AI will have in your research particularly?

730
00:56:00.363 --> 00:56:00.643
So I,

731
00:56:02.087 --> 00:56:05.992
It's definitely going to have a huge impact on astronomy.

732
00:56:06.012 --> 00:56:09.516
I think it's too early to say exactly what it's going to look like.

733
00:56:09.536 --> 00:56:10.457
That's fair.

734
00:56:10.697 --> 00:56:18.366
But I think it's safe to say that it's definitely going to be around and it's going to fundamentally change the way science is done.

735
00:56:19.547 --> 00:56:27.970
You know, AI is already excelling at finding lenses because they really don't look like that much other stuff in the universe.

736
00:56:28.030 --> 00:56:28.210
Right.

737
00:56:28.230 --> 00:56:30.590
A ring with four really bright point sources.

738
00:56:31.951 --> 00:56:35.252
You know, it could be maybe four stars or something.

739
00:56:35.532 --> 00:56:43.674
But, you know, AIs are really good at finding lenses and telling the difference between four stars and four images of a quasar, for example.

740
00:56:43.734 --> 00:56:45.855
And they can do it much faster than...

741
00:56:46.435 --> 00:56:52.702
Like a poor grad student has to look through like terabytes of data to find these little things.

742
00:56:52.742 --> 00:56:52.982
Right.

743
00:56:53.843 --> 00:56:57.107
People also use machine learning to model lenses.

744
00:56:57.828 --> 00:57:05.656
You know, some people have tried generating lots of examples with clumps of dark matter in these simulated images.

745
00:57:05.896 --> 00:57:13.240
uh, lenses, showing them to neural networks and then essentially showing that neural network, a real lens and saying, what is dark matter?

746
00:57:13.720 --> 00:57:15.581
You know, tell us the properties of these clumps.

747
00:57:15.621 --> 00:57:15.902
Yeah.

748
00:57:16.242 --> 00:57:18.503
So people are trying all of this kind of stuff.

749
00:57:18.523 --> 00:57:18.623
Yeah.

750
00:57:19.860 --> 00:57:27.205
I don't know yet to what degree it's going to be successful, but it's extremely interesting.

751
00:57:27.225 --> 00:57:33.549
I mean, in general, astronomy has been a great test bed for AI because there's so much data.

752
00:57:33.669 --> 00:57:33.889
Right.

753
00:57:34.429 --> 00:57:36.171
And the parameter space is so enormous.

754
00:57:38.672 --> 00:57:44.476
Yeah, I think that the challenge for AI, in my opinion, is doing it in a way that humans are going to believe.

755
00:57:44.696 --> 00:57:45.036
Yeah.

756
00:57:45.096 --> 00:57:46.717
So the AI tells you something.

757
00:57:47.258 --> 00:57:54.402
It did some really complicated analysis that maybe you don't really understand how it drew the conclusion that it did.

758
00:57:55.383 --> 00:58:00.206
And so making it a believable tool for scientists, I think, is the challenge.

759
00:58:00.226 --> 00:58:01.327
But people are working on that.

760
00:58:01.347 --> 00:58:01.807
Yeah.

761
00:58:02.047 --> 00:58:04.930
So they're trying to understand how the AI is drawing.

762
00:58:04.950 --> 00:58:13.437
You know, if it makes some interesting statement about the properties of clumps in a lens, for example, how did it get to that conclusion just from looking at the lens?

763
00:58:14.738 --> 00:58:15.678
It makes total sense.

764
00:58:15.698 --> 00:58:19.602
I mean, it's obviously going to be continuing to impact a variety of areas of science.

765
00:58:19.722 --> 00:58:20.823
And I just...

766
00:58:21.403 --> 00:58:31.210
This is so fascinating and I have so many questions, but I'm going to try to have us land the plane here with a couple of just clarifications.

767
00:58:31.230 --> 00:58:32.171
I'm going to come back to this.

768
00:58:32.291 --> 00:58:38.435
And so when you wake up in the morning and you grab a cup of coffee and you head to the lab, you're,

769
00:58:38.758 --> 00:58:50.127
you know, a large part of your day is like, you know, working and designing with the theoreticians around what, like, understand, you have to understand the dark matter theory quite well.

770
00:58:51.308 --> 00:58:56.972
And so part of it is like continuing to stay, you know, abreast on that component part.

771
00:58:57.233 --> 00:59:05.259
But it seems like a lot of the current work is around building, running, and testing the simulation process.

772
00:59:06.763 --> 00:59:08.965
Yeah, I'd say that's the core of what we want to do.

773
00:59:09.005 --> 00:59:12.608
We want to take the predictions of dark matter theories and simulate them.

774
00:59:12.828 --> 00:59:13.028
Yeah.

775
00:59:13.168 --> 00:59:18.412
There's a lot of work in actually going from the dark matter theory to understanding how the clumps are going to look.

776
00:59:18.693 --> 00:59:18.893
Right.

777
00:59:19.493 --> 00:59:29.802
And so there's a lot of kind of stuff around the simulations, a lot of physics that you have to understand in order to know what the theories are predicting, actually, for the properties of these clumps.

778
00:59:29.922 --> 00:59:30.122
Right.

779
00:59:30.382 --> 00:59:32.724
And, you know, the other thing about research is,

780
00:59:33.044 --> 00:59:39.345
is that it's very rarely a straight line from idea to paper or conclusion, right?

781
00:59:39.366 --> 00:59:47.287
Sometimes you go on these, you know, you end up somewhere completely different from where you anticipated or from where you planned you would be.

782
00:59:48.608 --> 00:59:55.349
There's this quote, it's a Dwight D. Eisenhower quote that says, plans are useless, but planning is essential.

783
00:59:55.449 --> 00:59:56.630
Yes, yes.

784
00:59:56.750 --> 01:00:01.531
So the idea is that, you know, if you've thought through a problem really well and you've mapped the road to a solution,

785
01:00:03.191 --> 01:00:08.996
is more relevant than whatever you thought the conclusion or the end goal would be.

786
01:00:09.156 --> 01:00:16.942
And so there's a lot of times in research where, you know, you start with some idea and it leads to some completely different investigation.

787
01:00:17.842 --> 01:00:20.524
And that's what makes it exciting for me, at least.

788
01:00:21.105 --> 01:00:22.225
A hundred percent.

789
01:00:22.346 --> 01:00:31.212
If you're still listening here and that ethos resonates with you, I encourage you to watch our Carnegie interviews because, you know,

790
01:00:32.453 --> 01:00:34.293
Mulcahy said exactly the same thing.

791
01:00:34.313 --> 01:00:36.694
I mean, he had this story about his...

792
01:00:36.894 --> 01:00:42.955
He was studying black holes for his thesis, but he was part of a project that made a breakthrough discovery, and it was almost by accident.

793
01:00:43.475 --> 01:01:00.398
You know, it was not necessarily what their initial assumption was, and one of his things he always tells the lead researchers at the Carnegie Observatories is, we need to leave space to explore, to be creative, to do things that might not be exactly what we think it will be, because that's where...

794
01:01:01.358 --> 01:01:02.299
discovery happens.

795
01:01:03.400 --> 01:01:07.403
And so I'm going to leave you here with one last question.

796
01:01:08.224 --> 01:01:13.468
And because we might have to come and have you come back for a part two, because I could talk to you all day about this.

797
01:01:15.009 --> 01:01:18.032
As you look now at, you know, where your current work is,

798
01:01:19.252 --> 01:01:30.639
and where you guys are in terms of your process and you look forward at the different things, all the telescopes coming online, the compute getting better, getting cheaper, well, maybe not cheaper anymore.

799
01:01:30.719 --> 01:01:40.304
But what does, in your view, what would be a landmark result for you?

800
01:01:40.885 --> 01:01:44.047
Or how would you define success?

801
01:01:44.467 --> 01:01:48.189
And relatedly, how would you characterize the implications of that?

802
01:01:50.310 --> 01:01:50.550
Oof.

803
01:01:51.331 --> 01:01:51.851
That's a deep one.

804
01:01:51.971 --> 01:01:52.312
I know.

805
01:01:52.352 --> 01:01:52.952
That's a big one.

806
01:01:52.972 --> 01:01:55.534
So, yeah.

807
01:01:55.574 --> 01:02:00.378
So I think you asked about what would be a landmark result and then how would I define success?

808
01:02:00.758 --> 01:02:02.039
Which are different things.

809
01:02:02.299 --> 01:02:02.540
Yeah.

810
01:02:02.580 --> 01:02:09.825
So, you know, being a success, you can be a successful scientist without ever having like some massive impact.

811
01:02:09.885 --> 01:02:16.631
Obviously, it would be nice to like, you know, be the one that discovered so-and-so dark matter particle or something like that.

812
01:02:16.691 --> 01:02:17.632
But, you know.

813
01:02:18.372 --> 01:02:35.861
I think it'd be nice if, you know, what would make me happy in my career is if I can advance the state of the field and help train younger scientists like the next generation, you know, working with grad students and undergrads and teaching.

814
01:02:36.381 --> 01:02:40.083
I mean, that's something that I'm personally interested in alongside my research.

815
01:02:40.143 --> 01:02:40.584
Okay.

816
01:02:40.664 --> 01:02:42.324
Obviously, I'm also interested in...

817
01:02:43.405 --> 01:02:48.573
doing research and it would be great to, if we could figure out what dark matter is, that would also be awesome.

818
01:02:49.374 --> 01:02:55.783
Uh, and then, you know, on that line of interest, I'm really interested now.

819
01:02:56.023 --> 01:02:58.126
And, uh, there are some theories that, uh,

820
01:02:59.127 --> 01:03:05.090
have very particular predictions that look very different from what our best current understanding of dark matter is.

821
01:03:06.411 --> 01:03:17.817
And they have some kind of smoking gun signals that if you could detect them, that would be very strong evidence in favor of this other kind of dark matter.

822
01:03:17.977 --> 01:03:18.078
Okay.

823
01:03:18.098 --> 01:03:18.198
Okay.

824
01:03:19.197 --> 01:03:42.454
So I'm very interested in those kinds of theories and also just testing this fundamental prediction of cold dark matter, which is our best current theory for what it is, which is mind blowing when you think of it, which is that every galaxy should be surrounded by an innumerable number of completely dark concentrations of matter that only interact through gravity.

825
01:03:42.474 --> 01:03:42.574
Yeah.

826
01:03:43.696 --> 01:03:53.369
If we can demonstrate evidence of the existence of these clumps of dark matter, that would be extremely interesting and really profound.

827
01:03:54.010 --> 01:03:56.453
And yeah, it would be mind-blowing, I think.

828
01:03:57.275 --> 01:03:57.815
I am...

829
01:03:59.878 --> 01:04:09.983
I cannot wait, but I do take your point to heart, though, which is, as with many people in the sciences, it is the journey, not the destination.

830
01:04:10.563 --> 01:04:15.026
And it is a community and a collective effort to better our understanding of the world around us.

831
01:04:15.066 --> 01:04:22.890
And just being able to participate in that process and also pass the bug of curiosity and exploration on to the next generation.

832
01:04:23.810 --> 01:04:43.465
is exactly why we have this show and we are able to bring on really incredible uh researchers who also happen to be friends we've been talking to for years uh i i dan i really appreciate you coming in today we're gonna have you back for part two because you just dropped the bomb there at the end and i want to dig into to more and i know krisha's gonna want to poke fun

833
01:04:44.185 --> 01:05:12.458
at you and banter probably and banter um again we had dan gilman in studio today astrophysicist looking at gravitational strong gravitational lensing as a means by which to study dark matter um thank you for sharing your your both your intellect and as well as a little bit into a window into what is it really like for research and how you think about this problem set um

834
01:05:13.298 --> 01:05:21.901
For those who are still listening, as you know, Krishna is a new dad and will be returning to the pod here in a couple of weeks.

835
01:05:22.421 --> 01:05:31.083
We have some great interviews like this one lined up in the meantime, and he will be back and fired up and ready to go.

836
01:05:31.143 --> 01:05:35.685
I can't tell you how antsy he is to get back in the catbird seat.

837
01:05:36.545 --> 01:05:42.567
But I let him know that FFP Nation will be here waiting for the return of our resident PhD.

838
01:05:43.307 --> 01:05:48.229
A big round of applause again for Dan Gilman for joining us on the pod today.

839
01:05:48.309 --> 01:05:50.970
Thank you, good sir, for sharing all of your wonderful expertise.

840
01:05:51.330 --> 01:05:52.351
We look forward to having you back.

841
01:05:52.651 --> 01:05:52.891
Thanks.

842
01:05:53.431 --> 01:05:54.712
Thanks to you guys.

843
01:05:55.232 --> 01:05:55.872
I appreciate it.

844
01:05:55.892 --> 01:05:57.693
And you guys are doing a great thing for science.

845
01:05:57.934 --> 01:06:00.035
This is a debut.

846
01:06:00.115 --> 01:06:01.496
We're going to start seeing him everywhere.

847
01:06:01.516 --> 01:06:03.517
He's going to start bragging to all of it at Journal Club.

848
01:06:03.557 --> 01:06:05.178
Hey, guys, you see my pod?

849
01:06:05.198 --> 01:06:07.019
You see how beautiful I look?

850
01:06:08.420 --> 01:06:12.902
As always, I am your captain speaking here, Lester Nare.

851
01:06:13.222 --> 01:06:15.504
This is From First Principles.

852
01:06:16.004 --> 01:06:17.645
We will see you all next week.
