WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.111 --> 00:00:05.713
And not everything is about genetics, meaning not everything is about the hardware of the DNA.

2
00:00:06.213 --> 00:00:12.535
It's also about the sort of software, which is the epigenetics part of it.

3
00:00:12.615 --> 00:00:18.877
They've done a thorough analysis of the genome and found that up to 7% of the DNA

4
00:00:21.838 --> 00:00:24.621
obeys these kinds of different weird rules.

5
00:00:24.641 --> 00:00:25.962
7%, that's one in 14.

6
00:00:26.342 --> 00:00:28.084
So one in 14 genes, that's not a joke.

7
00:00:28.464 --> 00:00:29.205
Hello, internet.

8
00:00:29.245 --> 00:00:31.707
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare.

9
00:00:31.827 --> 00:00:34.709
And breaking news, the candy man is home.

10
00:00:34.970 --> 00:00:36.771
Oh, ow, oh, what is that?

11
00:00:36.831 --> 00:00:37.732
Someone called a dentist.

12
00:00:37.752 --> 00:00:38.673
Is that a cavity?

13
00:00:39.353 --> 00:00:44.017
We are back here in studio by popular demand after months of...

14
00:00:44.678 --> 00:00:50.363
with just me in my back with our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

15
00:00:50.744 --> 00:00:52.145
Welcome back, good sir.

16
00:00:52.165 --> 00:00:52.886
How are you?

17
00:00:53.166 --> 00:00:53.926
How's it going, man?

18
00:00:55.288 --> 00:01:04.756
I have barely had any sleep over the past two months, but you've been doing a great job with all of your content, and now we are back in the studio.

19
00:01:05.377 --> 00:01:06.578
It's been crazy.

20
00:01:07.339 --> 00:01:08.520
It's been really crazy.

21
00:01:08.700 --> 00:01:09.581
And I remember, like...

22
00:01:10.241 --> 00:01:14.448
The baby came, you know, for our viewers, the baby came two weeks early.

23
00:01:14.528 --> 00:01:21.298
And the day that it happened, we were supposed to record two additional episodes in preparation for my paternity break.

24
00:01:21.818 --> 00:01:24.262
And I texted you from the hospital like, hey.

25
00:01:25.123 --> 00:01:25.763
It's today.

26
00:01:26.424 --> 00:01:27.404
Abort mission.

27
00:01:27.424 --> 00:01:28.325
Abort mission.

28
00:01:28.345 --> 00:01:30.145
We're going to just roll with it.

29
00:01:30.546 --> 00:01:32.387
But I'm glad to be back.

30
00:01:32.427 --> 00:01:33.967
Seems I've missed quite a bit.

31
00:01:34.327 --> 00:01:36.248
Quite a bit has happened in the world.

32
00:01:36.288 --> 00:01:42.992
The most important thing that happened is probably Lewis Hamilton won his first race with Ferrari.

33
00:01:43.012 --> 00:01:45.873
Finally, the promise.

34
00:01:47.468 --> 00:01:50.129
of Lewis Hamilton has paid off for Ferrari.

35
00:01:50.149 --> 00:01:51.990
So I'm wearing my Ferrari gear for that.

36
00:01:52.990 --> 00:01:58.433
We are very grateful to have Krishna back here in the promised land at FFP nation.

37
00:01:58.953 --> 00:02:08.417
And in honor of you entering fatherhood, today's deep dive is going to be about non-Mendelian epigenetic inheritance.

38
00:02:09.097 --> 00:02:15.900
And so we're going to learn about the science from the ground up today, because this is from first principles.

39
00:02:31.885 --> 00:02:39.194
So I was recently blessed with my first child and questions of inheritance are very forward in my mind, right?

40
00:02:40.435 --> 00:02:45.240
Questions that every person of color asks, like, how dark is the baby going to be?

41
00:02:45.841 --> 00:02:49.005
You know, among other things, like what color is RSI is going to be?

42
00:02:49.065 --> 00:02:50.166
Is he going to be an athlete?

43
00:02:50.206 --> 00:02:51.448
But, you know, that's one of the big ones.

44
00:02:52.568 --> 00:02:56.130
if anyone's out there who's brown, they know what I'm talking about.

45
00:02:56.530 --> 00:03:06.075
And so for most of the traits that are out there, you can use rules that were established 160 years ago by this guy called Gregor Mendel.

46
00:03:06.516 --> 00:03:09.797
And these traits follow Mendelian laws of inheritance.

47
00:03:09.857 --> 00:03:14.120
This is the stuff that you learn in like AP Bio, if you ever took AP Bio in high school.

48
00:03:14.620 --> 00:03:16.681
The rules are pretty simple, and we're going to go over them.

49
00:03:16.701 --> 00:03:19.943
There's like these dominant genes, recessive genes, some...

50
00:03:20.643 --> 00:03:22.585
And by and large, those rules work.

51
00:03:24.067 --> 00:03:27.491
But as with all things in biology, there are always exceptions.

52
00:03:28.232 --> 00:03:35.260
And genetics is something that has a bunch of exceptions because you're down to the molecular level and there's always weird stuff happening.

53
00:03:35.920 --> 00:03:41.346
And not everything is about genetics, meaning not everything is about the hardware of the DNA.

54
00:03:41.386 --> 00:03:41.527
Right.

55
00:03:42.007 --> 00:03:48.428
It's also about the sort of software, which is the epigenetics part of things.

56
00:03:48.508 --> 00:03:50.109
This is a very dynamic package.

57
00:03:50.429 --> 00:04:00.111
This is how the DNA is wrapped around inside the cell, how much the DNA has access to protein-making machinery, things like that.

58
00:04:00.751 --> 00:04:06.652
And those things can change much more quickly than the actual genetic sequence itself.

59
00:04:12.513 --> 00:04:15.195
higher level of genetic machinery, right?

60
00:04:15.736 --> 00:04:19.379
And it turns out that those traits can also be inherited.

61
00:04:19.739 --> 00:04:24.262
Like this software package on top of the hardware is something that is also passed down.

62
00:04:24.382 --> 00:04:25.944
And we're just starting to understand that.

63
00:04:26.264 --> 00:04:28.285
There's exceptions for how it gets passed down.

64
00:04:28.606 --> 00:04:32.488
Most of the time, again, it follows Mendelian rules, but sometimes it doesn't.

65
00:04:32.849 --> 00:04:34.230
And that's what this story is about.

66
00:04:34.550 --> 00:04:37.993
There's a new paper out of Johns Hopkins University and Texas A&amp;M,

67
00:04:38.653 --> 00:04:44.819
that is documenting a new type of non-Mendelian inheritance of epigenetics in mammals.

68
00:04:45.440 --> 00:04:54.188
And it's showing that this genetics is far stranger and far more dynamic and far more interesting than I think Mendel could ever have imagined 160 years ago.

69
00:04:54.728 --> 00:04:56.870
And so, like, why is this a big deal, right?

70
00:04:56.890 --> 00:04:57.531
Right.

71
00:04:57.811 --> 00:05:05.735
Obviously, anything related to genetics is a big deal because genetics is like the blueprint of life, is the blueprint for who we are.

72
00:05:06.335 --> 00:05:11.557
But it touches on everything from like why identical twins can have different disease outcomes.

73
00:05:12.118 --> 00:05:12.298
Right.

74
00:05:12.398 --> 00:05:14.899
Identical twins have the same exact DNA.

75
00:05:15.319 --> 00:05:18.901
But sometimes one twin is going to have one disease and the other twin is going to be just fine.

76
00:05:19.181 --> 00:05:21.562
That's because the software package on top is different.

77
00:05:22.082 --> 00:05:22.282
Right.

78
00:05:23.443 --> 00:05:25.144
Diseases can skip generations.

79
00:05:26.096 --> 00:05:29.597
That's something that happens to do with epigenetics.

80
00:05:30.057 --> 00:05:33.698
And sometimes the same gene variant can be benign in one person.

81
00:05:34.058 --> 00:05:40.959
If you do the genetic sequencing of two individuals, they'll have the same gene variant, but one individual will get the disease and the other one won't.

82
00:05:41.600 --> 00:05:43.540
Again, that has to do with the software on top.

83
00:05:43.820 --> 00:05:49.782
So this paper marks like a major shift in how we think about epigenetic inheritance, especially in mammals.

84
00:05:50.342 --> 00:05:53.022
And it shows that this is not actually an exception.

85
00:05:53.082 --> 00:05:54.223
That's the big part.

86
00:05:54.323 --> 00:05:54.623
Okay.

87
00:05:56.603 --> 00:06:07.011
a thorough analysis of the genome and found that up to 7% of the DNA obeys these kinds of different weird rules.

88
00:06:07.091 --> 00:06:08.512
7%, that's 1 in 14.

89
00:06:08.872 --> 00:06:10.633
So 1 in 14 genes, that's not a joke.

90
00:06:11.274 --> 00:06:14.496
That's pretty statistically significant, as we like to say.

91
00:06:14.516 --> 00:06:15.537
Yes, exactly.

92
00:06:15.637 --> 00:06:22.742
That's something that you do have to worry about if we want to get a really comprehensive idea of how genetics affects outcomes and all that stuff.

93
00:06:23.062 --> 00:06:27.426
So we're living through kind of a quiet revolution in the understanding of heredity.

94
00:06:28.186 --> 00:06:32.590
And in this episode, what I want to do is go through how it all started 200 years ago.

95
00:06:32.670 --> 00:06:33.871
We're going to start with Mandel.

96
00:06:34.411 --> 00:06:42.578
Then I'm going to take you through some of the history of the field and then why this particular paper is happening now and not 10 years ago or 20 years ago.

97
00:06:42.618 --> 00:06:48.762
There's some key technological advancements that have happened in recent years that is enabling this kind of analysis.

98
00:06:49.083 --> 00:06:50.164
And it's very, very cool.

99
00:06:50.764 --> 00:07:00.791
There's an interesting, there's a mutual friend that we have that had been doing work around some of this epigenetic stuff, you know, through grant funding through the NHS.

100
00:07:01.152 --> 00:07:05.295
And what is, I think this is very timely because there's been a lot of...

101
00:07:06.215 --> 00:07:21.285
chatter in social media around this idea of generational trauma, sort of a non-scientific term, and the idea that there is an impact on outcomes that are related to these concepts of generational trauma.

102
00:07:21.385 --> 00:07:27.009
And I think this is going to start to brush up against some of these social conversations that have been happening.

103
00:07:27.569 --> 00:07:31.912
And I'm super curious to understand, particularly your point about why now

104
00:07:32.432 --> 00:07:36.376
are we able to start to get a better idea of what's going on on the epigenetic layer?

105
00:07:36.496 --> 00:07:39.278
Yes, that part is really, really cool.

106
00:07:39.338 --> 00:07:41.640
The biotechnology there is really, really cool.

107
00:07:41.721 --> 00:07:55.573
And what you're alluding to is the fact that trauma is something that is not going to affect the genetic layer, but it is going to affect the epigenetic layer, because the epigenetic layer is the one that is dynamic and changes throughout the life of an organism.

108
00:07:56.754 --> 00:07:57.434
By and large...

109
00:07:58.155 --> 00:08:22.615
have the dna that we were born with okay unless you know if you look at tumors there's a lot of mutations there and tumor cells have very different dna compared to um normal benign cells right but epigenetically the reason why this cell is a skin cell and this cell is an eye cell and the the cells inside my brain are neurons that has to do with epigenetics right because

110
00:08:23.739 --> 00:08:29.843
The cell is making a choice what part of the gene to read out from and what part to ignore.

111
00:08:30.243 --> 00:08:32.504
That's the software level that I'm talking about.

112
00:08:32.564 --> 00:08:35.126
So it's extremely important for us to understand, right?

113
00:08:35.526 --> 00:08:38.248
So we're going to start, as always, on this podcast.

114
00:08:38.688 --> 00:08:40.629
Guys, I might be a little rusty.

115
00:08:40.649 --> 00:08:41.490
It's been two months.

116
00:08:43.150 --> 00:08:46.551
As I said, barely any sleep, so just bear with me if I'm a little slow.

117
00:08:46.971 --> 00:08:48.772
But we're going to start, as always, with the history.

118
00:08:48.972 --> 00:08:49.332
Yes.

119
00:08:50.032 --> 00:08:50.772
We're going to go back.

120
00:08:51.193 --> 00:08:55.894
The story of genetics probably begins 160 years ago, improbably, in a monastery.

121
00:09:00.392 --> 00:09:02.573
Okay, Gregor Johann Mendel.

122
00:09:02.633 --> 00:09:03.133
Johann.

123
00:09:03.493 --> 00:09:08.115
He was an Augustinian monk who spent eight years crossbreeding pea plants.

124
00:09:08.416 --> 00:09:13.018
And the green circle, you see the guy in the green circle in the back row?

125
00:09:13.238 --> 00:09:18.100
That's Mendel along with all of his other monks in his monastery.

126
00:09:18.500 --> 00:09:20.741
He was crossbreeding pea plants for like eight years.

127
00:09:20.801 --> 00:09:25.483
He tracked 29,000 plants across multiple generations.

128
00:09:25.503 --> 00:09:26.644
That's huge volume.

129
00:09:26.924 --> 00:09:27.404
It's huge.

130
00:09:27.524 --> 00:09:28.404
This was his hobby.

131
00:09:29.065 --> 00:09:29.205
And...

132
00:09:30.418 --> 00:09:31.539
He took it very seriously.

133
00:09:31.579 --> 00:09:39.102
He's the first guy to really do large-scale statistical analysis of gardening, effectively.

134
00:09:39.822 --> 00:09:40.843
He was the first green thumb.

135
00:09:41.443 --> 00:09:42.603
Yeah.

136
00:09:42.624 --> 00:09:43.524
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

137
00:09:44.044 --> 00:09:45.845
Before Zach Galifianakis had the...

138
00:09:46.245 --> 00:09:53.289
Netflix show about gardening, which, by the way, a good friend of ours, Trevor, is the editor on that show.

139
00:09:53.309 --> 00:09:54.509
So go check it out on Netflix.

140
00:09:54.549 --> 00:09:55.690
It's a really good show, actually.

141
00:09:56.850 --> 00:10:00.012
So you can see his garden today, actually, the Mendel's garden.

142
00:10:00.052 --> 00:10:05.895
You can see it in Brno, which is currently in the Czech Republic, or I think now it's called Czechia.

143
00:10:06.835 --> 00:10:08.696
If I'm watching the World Cup correctly.

144
00:10:08.776 --> 00:10:09.196
I've heard it.

145
00:10:09.336 --> 00:10:09.956
Czechia.

146
00:10:10.036 --> 00:10:10.516
Czechia.

147
00:10:10.596 --> 00:10:12.056
Yeah.

148
00:10:12.196 --> 00:10:13.797
But it used to be called the Czech Republic.

149
00:10:13.817 --> 00:10:14.777
That's what I'm comfortable with.

150
00:10:14.817 --> 00:10:16.397
But Czechia, Czechia, one of those.

151
00:10:16.797 --> 00:10:23.599
You can actually go see the garden and see the beds where he was planting the pea plants, which I think is really cool.

152
00:10:23.679 --> 00:10:27.960
One day when FFP pod goes on a field trip, that is definitely a place we're going to visit.

153
00:10:28.020 --> 00:10:28.740
It's the birthplace.

154
00:10:29.040 --> 00:10:31.261
That garden is the birthplace of genetics, right?

155
00:10:31.601 --> 00:10:32.501
I think that's so cool.

156
00:10:33.782 --> 00:10:35.302
So why peas, first of all?

157
00:10:35.762 --> 00:10:46.244
OK, this is something that we talk about a lot on this podcast and is a staple for the biomedical research community, which is model organisms.

158
00:10:46.484 --> 00:10:46.684
Right.

159
00:10:46.744 --> 00:10:51.545
You have to choose the organism that you want to that you want to study as a system.

160
00:10:52.325 --> 00:10:56.086
And you have to make that choice very deliberately for very specific reasons.

161
00:10:56.146 --> 00:10:58.467
Mendel is one of the first guys to do this.

162
00:10:58.547 --> 00:10:59.367
He chose peas.

163
00:11:00.267 --> 00:11:03.349
Because, one, the garden pea is actually pretty easy to grow.

164
00:11:04.310 --> 00:11:05.530
You don't have to worry about it too much.

165
00:11:06.111 --> 00:11:09.973
It has easily observable contrasting traits.

166
00:11:10.153 --> 00:11:12.094
These are the traits that he was studying.

167
00:11:12.114 --> 00:11:14.796
For example, is the pea round or wrinkled?

168
00:11:15.536 --> 00:11:16.277
That's a binary.

169
00:11:16.657 --> 00:11:18.858
You can look at the thing, and there's no middle ground.

170
00:11:18.878 --> 00:11:20.719
It's either round or it's wrinkled, right?

171
00:11:21.980 --> 00:11:24.602
When you cut up the pea, is it yellow or green inside?

172
00:11:24.622 --> 00:11:25.122
Right.

173
00:11:25.728 --> 00:11:28.369
The flower, is it white or is it purple?

174
00:11:29.049 --> 00:11:40.813
Like these are all binary things that there's no, you know, when you're trying to do statistical analysis by hand, right, you don't have like computer vision nonsense, right, and you just got a notebook.

175
00:11:41.133 --> 00:11:42.814
You're just making tally marks.

176
00:11:42.854 --> 00:11:46.695
So you need really easily identifiable traits that are in binary.

177
00:11:47.295 --> 00:11:49.636
The pea plant has seven of these, which is really nice.

178
00:11:49.916 --> 00:11:50.417
Okay.

179
00:11:50.457 --> 00:11:58.541
So the idea of what you're saying is you want to have the fewest amount of variables to sort of control for one from at least in this time period from a management.

180
00:11:58.601 --> 00:11:59.641
It's like a management challenge.

181
00:11:59.661 --> 00:12:00.422
Exactly.

182
00:12:00.462 --> 00:12:04.964
But two, there's less to deal with in terms of judging outcomes.

183
00:12:05.004 --> 00:12:05.904
Yes, exactly.

184
00:12:05.924 --> 00:12:12.967
There's no subjectivity in what the offspring of this and this was.

185
00:12:13.007 --> 00:12:19.970
You can just be like, okay, I bred round and wrinkled, and I got this many wrinkled, this many round, and I can just make the tally marks.

186
00:12:20.670 --> 00:12:23.471
The other big thing about peat plants is they self-fertilize.

187
00:12:24.051 --> 00:12:27.453
So that means that Mendel can really easily control crosses.

188
00:12:28.293 --> 00:12:42.583
by you can manually just transfer pollen you can like take like a q-tip or i i think he used a paintbrush at the time he would take the pollen from one paintbrush and and put it in the stigma of the other one to like crossbreed manually and i think we've got a we've got a photo of that in

189
00:12:45.145 --> 00:12:46.286
This is how he did it.

190
00:12:46.326 --> 00:12:49.567
He would cut the stamen, which is the male part.

191
00:12:50.368 --> 00:12:51.469
Or am I?

192
00:12:51.509 --> 00:12:51.889
No, no.

193
00:12:51.929 --> 00:12:53.209
The pollen is the male part.

194
00:12:53.229 --> 00:13:02.675
So he would cut the pollen part, and then he would use a brush to take the sperm, effectively, and put it in the female part of the flower.

195
00:13:02.995 --> 00:13:04.816
So this was controlled breeding.

196
00:13:04.916 --> 00:13:05.216
Yes.

197
00:13:05.356 --> 00:13:11.820
Because also, again, the surface area of how you would do so was very discreet.

198
00:13:11.900 --> 00:13:12.020
Yeah.

199
00:13:12.040 --> 00:13:12.200
Yeah.

200
00:13:12.620 --> 00:13:13.020
Exactly.

201
00:13:13.040 --> 00:13:14.561
It's super easy to control, right?

202
00:13:14.921 --> 00:13:18.343
And the first thing he does is he develops true breeding lines.

203
00:13:18.823 --> 00:13:23.906
What that means is he's going to self-pollinate a bunch of pea plants, which pea plants are totally chill with.

204
00:13:24.286 --> 00:13:26.907
They don't care about like, oh, lack of genetic diversity, all that.

205
00:13:26.947 --> 00:13:29.949
They're actually, that's one of the reasons why it's a good thing to use pea plants.

206
00:13:30.429 --> 00:13:39.254
And you keep self-pollinating until all of the offspring are something called true breeding, meaning they always produce the same offspring identical to the parent.

207
00:13:39.894 --> 00:13:41.796
It's like you're making clones over and over.

208
00:13:42.056 --> 00:13:44.960
So now what you do is you're starting out with a clean slate.

209
00:13:45.160 --> 00:13:45.360
Yes.

210
00:13:45.400 --> 00:13:45.780
Right?

211
00:13:46.021 --> 00:13:54.350
There's no genetic variability in this plant and its gametes and its sperm and the egg.

212
00:13:54.610 --> 00:13:54.790
Right?

213
00:13:55.010 --> 00:13:59.015
It's like if I were to take the sperm and the egg of this and combine it, I would just get the same thing again.

214
00:13:59.415 --> 00:14:01.637
So it's like a feedback cycle.

215
00:14:02.338 --> 00:14:03.719
And completely clean, right?

216
00:14:03.939 --> 00:14:09.441
For example, offspring of purple flower times purple flower, always going to give me purple flower at this point.

217
00:14:09.501 --> 00:14:10.962
That's why it's called true breeding.

218
00:14:11.302 --> 00:14:11.842
Okay?

219
00:14:12.003 --> 00:14:15.944
So the idea is we have everyone is effectively genetically the same.

220
00:14:16.024 --> 00:14:16.244
Yeah.

221
00:14:16.324 --> 00:14:21.187
And there's no nonsense in the, like, from one generation to the next.

222
00:14:21.207 --> 00:14:21.747
Yeah.

223
00:14:21.907 --> 00:14:25.569
I'm not getting weird like effects.

224
00:14:25.649 --> 00:14:29.130
It's not just that this line of the generation is the same.

225
00:14:29.190 --> 00:14:36.274
It's that subsequent and prior to some number of generations forward and back are consistently coming in as the same.

226
00:14:36.294 --> 00:14:39.455
So you're also removing the idea that, oh, this one was, but the next one might not.

227
00:14:39.495 --> 00:14:40.435
Yeah, yeah, exactly.

228
00:14:40.475 --> 00:14:47.619
So now when I do crosses in, I take the parent generation, the P, and I do a cross, let's say from a purple and a white.

229
00:14:48.239 --> 00:14:49.700
I'm going to get some weird effects, right?

230
00:14:49.940 --> 00:14:54.743
But I know that's not from the purple doing its own thing or the white doing its own thing.

231
00:14:54.863 --> 00:14:57.165
I know it's because of the interaction of these two.

232
00:14:57.525 --> 00:14:58.345
Does that make sense?

233
00:14:58.365 --> 00:15:00.086
That's why you've got to start with that true breeding.

234
00:15:01.627 --> 00:15:09.072
This is a really important point, which is we're creating the canvas from which we're going to test in a way that removes any prior...

235
00:15:10.838 --> 00:15:11.860
A muddying of the water.

236
00:15:11.900 --> 00:15:12.821
Yes.

237
00:15:12.921 --> 00:15:17.789
So that we can look downstream and say we had a clean foundation with which we're building from.

238
00:15:17.909 --> 00:15:18.310
Exactly.

239
00:15:18.330 --> 00:15:18.430
Yeah.

240
00:15:18.450 --> 00:15:24.500
And now I can isolate the effect to an interaction between two individuals that have different genetics.

241
00:15:24.540 --> 00:15:25.000
That makes sense.

242
00:15:25.021 --> 00:15:25.121
Okay.

243
00:15:25.141 --> 00:15:25.321
Okay.

244
00:15:26.062 --> 00:15:26.843
Here's what he observed.

245
00:15:26.923 --> 00:15:28.445
Okay, so he takes the parent generation.

246
00:15:28.665 --> 00:15:31.187
Let's just talk about the flower color right now.

247
00:15:31.448 --> 00:15:35.412
There's seven other traits that he could look at, but they all actually obeyed these rules.

248
00:15:35.592 --> 00:15:38.495
But it's nice to talk about flower color because it looks good on TV.

249
00:15:38.735 --> 00:15:43.880
Okay, so I'm going to take a true breeding purple and a true breeding white plant.

250
00:15:44.100 --> 00:15:44.941
I'm going to breed those two.

251
00:15:45.918 --> 00:15:51.261
The first generation, that's the F1, the first filial generation is how he put it.

252
00:15:51.761 --> 00:15:53.543
That one has all purple.

253
00:15:53.923 --> 00:15:55.364
Immediately you notice something weird.

254
00:15:55.824 --> 00:15:57.665
You're not getting a mix, right?

255
00:15:57.685 --> 00:16:02.168
You're not getting like lighter purple, like pink.

256
00:16:02.388 --> 00:16:03.108
It's not a blend.

257
00:16:03.268 --> 00:16:03.889
It's not a blend.

258
00:16:03.909 --> 00:16:05.369
It's not a mix of half and half.

259
00:16:05.429 --> 00:16:06.390
It's not even half and half.

260
00:16:06.770 --> 00:16:08.391
It's fully all purple.

261
00:16:08.872 --> 00:16:09.132
Okay?

262
00:16:09.692 --> 00:16:10.873
First thing that's kind of weird.

263
00:16:11.453 --> 00:16:11.693
Okay?

264
00:16:11.933 --> 00:16:12.894
It's almost as if...

265
00:16:14.130 --> 00:16:16.633
The first generation is also true breeding.

266
00:16:17.313 --> 00:16:17.514
Right?

267
00:16:17.854 --> 00:16:21.137
So you're like, hey, so is the white just like doing nothing?

268
00:16:21.257 --> 00:16:21.478
Right.

269
00:16:22.258 --> 00:16:23.139
Is everything coming from one?

270
00:16:23.159 --> 00:16:24.481
Is everything just coming from one?

271
00:16:24.501 --> 00:16:25.061
What's going on?

272
00:16:25.422 --> 00:16:27.504
That's when you do the second cross.

273
00:16:27.544 --> 00:16:34.191
So you do a second filial F2 generation where you take two of the first generation ones and you cross them.

274
00:16:34.671 --> 00:16:35.892
And now you get something weird.

275
00:16:36.193 --> 00:16:37.234
You get the white back.

276
00:16:38.292 --> 00:16:45.175
But the ratio of purple to white is always, and I mean always, 3 to 1 in his notebooks.

277
00:16:45.615 --> 00:16:45.875
Okay.

278
00:16:46.075 --> 00:16:50.997
He's got 29,000 plants that he's doing this with, and it's almost always 3 to 1.

279
00:16:51.137 --> 00:16:54.358
Like, statistically, that's the ratio that he's getting.

280
00:16:55.156 --> 00:16:55.416
Okay.

281
00:16:55.896 --> 00:16:56.676
I think I see it.

282
00:16:56.796 --> 00:16:57.617
It's very weird.

283
00:16:57.637 --> 00:17:00.217
It's very, and with no context and no foundation.

284
00:17:00.237 --> 00:17:00.617
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

285
00:17:00.637 --> 00:17:01.518
Now it's like trivial.

286
00:17:01.738 --> 00:17:01.918
Right.

287
00:17:02.038 --> 00:17:17.621
But it's, why did we, we had two different, the first generation, all only similar to one of the two parents, but the second generation that was bred from that F1 generation where everything was the same as one parent is a three to one ratio of one parent to another.

288
00:17:17.681 --> 00:17:17.901
Yeah.

289
00:17:18.321 --> 00:17:19.602
Almost all of the time.

290
00:17:19.722 --> 00:17:20.522
Almost all of the time.

291
00:17:20.702 --> 00:17:20.942
Okay.

292
00:17:21.222 --> 00:17:24.003
So let's try to figure out how this would happen.

293
00:17:24.023 --> 00:17:24.443
Okay.

294
00:17:24.463 --> 00:17:24.643
Okay.

295
00:17:26.415 --> 00:17:27.135
Mendel doesn't know.

296
00:17:27.616 --> 00:17:27.756
Right.

297
00:17:27.876 --> 00:17:28.136
Okay?

298
00:17:28.456 --> 00:17:30.057
Mendel doesn't know anything about genes.

299
00:17:30.077 --> 00:17:31.377
He doesn't know anything about chromosomes.

300
00:17:31.397 --> 00:17:32.798
He just knows plants are doing this.

301
00:17:32.918 --> 00:17:33.138
Okay?

302
00:17:33.458 --> 00:17:41.041
So he takes a purely sort of empirical approach, which is I'm just going to describe the mathematics as I see it.

303
00:17:41.301 --> 00:17:41.481
Okay?

304
00:17:41.501 --> 00:17:44.102
I want to make up some rules that are just math rules.

305
00:17:44.462 --> 00:17:44.662
Okay?

306
00:17:44.682 --> 00:17:45.283
About what happens.

307
00:17:45.643 --> 00:17:49.544
First thing he figures out, and what we've already seen, is the principle of dominance.

308
00:17:49.864 --> 00:17:50.585
There's two traits.

309
00:17:51.225 --> 00:17:53.386
One of them is going to dominate over the other.

310
00:17:53.426 --> 00:17:53.586
Yeah.

311
00:17:54.127 --> 00:17:57.111
In this case that we saw, it was the purple.

312
00:17:57.471 --> 00:18:00.976
The purple trait, which now we call an allele.

313
00:18:01.937 --> 00:18:04.460
There's two different types of alleles, the purple and the white.

314
00:18:04.901 --> 00:18:08.205
And the purple allele is going to dominate over the...

315
00:18:09.566 --> 00:18:11.247
white allele which we'll call recessive.

316
00:18:11.608 --> 00:18:12.768
So there's dominant and recessive.

317
00:18:12.908 --> 00:18:13.989
That's the first thing you establish.

318
00:18:14.369 --> 00:18:17.831
Second is something that he establishes called the law of segregation.

319
00:18:18.211 --> 00:18:19.812
This is the segregation of traits.

320
00:18:20.032 --> 00:18:20.272
Okay.

321
00:18:20.573 --> 00:18:26.316
What he says is there's actually two copies of an allele that every individual has.

322
00:18:27.326 --> 00:18:36.376
And if I have a true breeding plant, let's say the trait that we're looking for is the color of the flower.

323
00:18:36.977 --> 00:18:45.446
And we're going to denote the type of allele by a capital A if it's dominant and a lowercase a if it's recessive.

324
00:18:45.767 --> 00:18:46.007
Okay?

325
00:18:46.547 --> 00:18:46.828
Now...

326
00:18:48.303 --> 00:18:54.332
If I have something that's true breeding, that means that I have two copies of the same dominant allele.

327
00:18:54.392 --> 00:18:55.293
Capital A, capital A.

328
00:18:55.313 --> 00:18:56.415
That's the one on the left up.

329
00:18:56.896 --> 00:19:00.281
And then the white true breeding is going to be lowercase a, lowercase a.

330
00:19:00.301 --> 00:19:01.242
Or recessive, recessive.

331
00:19:01.442 --> 00:19:01.663
Okay?

332
00:19:02.003 --> 00:19:03.325
Now, when I cross them...

333
00:19:04.078 --> 00:19:08.283
There's going to be four different ways to choose the A and the A, right?

334
00:19:09.084 --> 00:19:15.212
I can choose the first capital A and either of the two lower cases or the second capital A and all that's four total.

335
00:19:15.252 --> 00:19:18.316
But every single time I'm going to get a capital A and a lower case A.

336
00:19:18.556 --> 00:19:21.440
So that first generation is going to have at least one dominant.

337
00:19:22.688 --> 00:19:23.048
Copy.

338
00:19:23.449 --> 00:19:23.949
Capital A.

339
00:19:24.009 --> 00:19:24.530
All the time.

340
00:19:24.910 --> 00:19:27.133
Every single one is going to have a capital A and a lowercase a.

341
00:19:27.373 --> 00:19:34.260
And because the capital A is present, the dominant is present, I'm going to get the dominant phenotype, and the thing is going to be purple.

342
00:19:34.300 --> 00:19:40.966
But now, let's take the first generation, that capital A, lowercase a, which we're going to call heterozygous because there's...

343
00:19:41.527 --> 00:19:43.988
hetero, there's two different copies.

344
00:19:44.188 --> 00:19:44.968
Right, one of each.

345
00:19:45.048 --> 00:19:46.148
One of each, yeah.

346
00:19:46.448 --> 00:19:52.110
Compared to homozygous, which is what we had in the parent generation, that true breeding is now what we call homozygous.

347
00:19:52.630 --> 00:20:01.793
So if we take two heterozygous parents and we cross them, now combinatorically, I'm going to get three...

348
00:20:02.697 --> 00:20:05.339
offspring that have at least a capital A.

349
00:20:05.359 --> 00:20:10.922
There's actually going to be one that's kind of like the true breeding parent in the beginning, the capital A, capital A, right?

350
00:20:10.942 --> 00:20:12.462
That's the one we have in this top left.

351
00:20:12.503 --> 00:20:14.063
Yeah, in the square.

352
00:20:14.263 --> 00:20:15.564
Those are called Punnett squares now.

353
00:20:15.924 --> 00:20:19.006
But the top left, that's capital A, capital A.

354
00:20:19.026 --> 00:20:19.767
That's going to be purple.

355
00:20:20.347 --> 00:20:24.289
The two on the off diagonal, that's going to have a capital A and a lowercase a.

356
00:20:25.049 --> 00:20:27.611
But because there's at least one, I'm still going to get purple.

357
00:20:28.451 --> 00:20:31.233
And only one out of the four is going to have...

358
00:20:32.624 --> 00:20:37.789
homozygous recessive, lowercase a, lowercase a, and that's what's going to be white.

359
00:20:37.869 --> 00:20:38.589
This is interesting.

360
00:20:38.809 --> 00:20:47.457
And I think a key point here is we had the pure breed generation at first, two dominants from one, the purple, two recessives from the white.

361
00:20:47.857 --> 00:20:56.165
The first generation, because you always are going to have that dominant from the purple from the one side, you're always ever going to get this dominant recessive combo.

362
00:20:56.205 --> 00:20:56.405
Yeah.

363
00:20:56.745 --> 00:21:03.049
And so the reason why that first gen, first gen always has always has always that's why you don't ever see the white.

364
00:21:03.109 --> 00:21:03.349
Right.

365
00:21:03.530 --> 00:21:09.053
Because it's always being basically overrun by the recessive white is overrun by the dominant.

366
00:21:09.754 --> 00:21:16.158
The thing that the where you get the diversity of color begins to arise.

367
00:21:17.653 --> 00:21:21.196
When you have two dominant recessive as the parents.

368
00:21:21.216 --> 00:21:22.336
Yeah, the heterozygous parents.

369
00:21:22.356 --> 00:21:23.317
The heterozygous pair.

370
00:21:23.757 --> 00:21:30.982
And that's finally when you start to see from the original P1, the recessive begin to appear.

371
00:21:31.002 --> 00:21:40.069
But also from the math you brought up earlier, it makes sense that only one, it's always going to be three to one because of the way that it's this dynamic pair from each.

372
00:21:40.089 --> 00:21:40.829
Yes, exactly.

373
00:21:40.909 --> 00:21:42.010
It's always going to be three to one.

374
00:21:42.110 --> 00:21:44.392
So this is an empirical rule that he comes up with.

375
00:21:44.452 --> 00:21:45.152
It makes sense.

376
00:21:45.393 --> 00:21:45.613
And...

377
00:21:46.033 --> 00:21:52.816
The other nice thing about this kind of mathematics is it explains something else, which is the law of independent assortment.

378
00:21:53.857 --> 00:22:05.683
What he did, and this is something that we're seeing actually in fruit flies because the particular visual that I found was for fruit flies, but he also did this for pea plants as well.

379
00:22:06.003 --> 00:22:06.263
Okay.

380
00:22:07.304 --> 00:22:09.285
What you can do is you can take...

381
00:22:10.432 --> 00:22:18.811
Two true breeding... You can take a true breeding parent generation with...

382
00:22:20.272 --> 00:22:43.079
different traits in a pea plant you could say it's always purple and it's always tall and i'm going to cross that with always white always short okay so now i have homozygous for two traits in my parents i'm going to get some offspring that are again always purple always tall because the tall part is going to work the same way as the purple part and so everyone's going to be the

383
00:22:46.320 --> 00:22:54.585
Now, if you just do the mathematics, there's going to be 16 different choices instead of four because you're doing four by four across.

384
00:22:55.365 --> 00:23:00.828
And the mathematics is going to be such that I'm going to get a ratio of nine to three to three to one.

385
00:23:01.389 --> 00:23:01.669
Okay.

386
00:23:02.169 --> 00:23:06.352
Nine being I'm going to get the dominant parts of both.

387
00:23:06.372 --> 00:23:06.952
Okay.

388
00:23:07.152 --> 00:23:10.197
Three being I'm going to get the dominant of one, the recessive of the other.

389
00:23:10.517 --> 00:23:14.543
The other three being I'm going to get the dominant of the second one, recessive of the first one.

390
00:23:14.883 --> 00:23:21.573
And only one out of 16, I'm going to recover that first generation of recessive-recessive.

391
00:23:22.014 --> 00:23:22.274
Okay?

392
00:23:22.435 --> 00:23:22.595
Mm-hmm.

393
00:23:22.995 --> 00:23:24.055
It scales.

394
00:23:24.295 --> 00:23:30.337
As you get to more traits here, the ratio of distribution effectively scales accordingly.

395
00:23:30.357 --> 00:23:30.537
Yeah.

396
00:23:30.637 --> 00:23:36.958
And in this particular one, we're looking at fruit flies where we're seeing eye color and body color.

397
00:23:37.339 --> 00:23:37.599
Okay.

398
00:23:37.939 --> 00:23:41.900
And eye color red is dominant and body color brown is dominant.

399
00:23:42.960 --> 00:23:43.260
Black.

400
00:23:44.908 --> 00:23:46.548
For both is recessive.

401
00:23:46.829 --> 00:23:47.849
Eye color, eye body color.

402
00:23:48.049 --> 00:23:49.109
And so we're seeing 9 to 3 to 3 to 1.

403
00:23:49.329 --> 00:23:54.831
And you can go through the Punnett square there and figure out how each of the alleles was matched.

404
00:23:55.191 --> 00:23:56.871
And you can convince yourself that this is the case.

405
00:23:56.911 --> 00:23:57.572
That makes total sense.

406
00:23:57.652 --> 00:23:58.252
Okay?

407
00:23:58.312 --> 00:24:05.394
This is called the independent assortment law, meaning that the two different traits independently...

408
00:24:06.768 --> 00:24:07.589
do combinatorics.

409
00:24:07.910 --> 00:24:09.332
They're not like related to one another.

410
00:24:09.393 --> 00:24:12.338
It's not like the eye color goes with body color.

411
00:24:12.638 --> 00:24:14.000
It's like correlated in some way.

412
00:24:14.060 --> 00:24:15.022
So that, that was his thing.

413
00:24:15.463 --> 00:24:15.703
Okay.

414
00:24:16.024 --> 00:24:17.426
So these are Mendel's laws.

415
00:24:18.260 --> 00:24:25.442
He presented these findings in 1865, published in 1866, Experiments on Plant Hybrids.

416
00:24:25.462 --> 00:24:26.802
The response, complete silence.

417
00:24:27.502 --> 00:24:28.582
Paper is ignored.

418
00:24:28.662 --> 00:24:31.623
It's cited a handful of times over the next 35 years.

419
00:24:32.283 --> 00:24:35.424
He died in 1884, unknown as a scientist.

420
00:24:36.604 --> 00:24:37.104
Terrible.

421
00:24:37.945 --> 00:24:41.545
And his discoveries were buried in some obscure journal.

422
00:24:41.645 --> 00:24:42.026
Terrible.

423
00:24:42.166 --> 00:24:42.946
Okay.

424
00:24:43.066 --> 00:24:46.727
35 years later, we've got three botanists who start doing the same thing.

425
00:24:47.147 --> 00:24:47.247
Okay.

426
00:24:47.267 --> 00:24:47.467
Okay.

427
00:24:48.427 --> 00:24:54.352
Hugo de Vries in the Netherlands, Karl Korins in Germany, and Eric von Schermark in Austria.

428
00:24:54.792 --> 00:24:57.274
And they independently figure all of this out.

429
00:24:57.915 --> 00:25:01.598
And then as they're deep diving into the literature, because the first thing you do is, has someone else done it?

430
00:25:02.098 --> 00:25:04.260
You know, in the modern day, there's a joke in academia.

431
00:25:04.720 --> 00:25:08.463
There's always like a Zhang et al that's done it before.

432
00:25:08.783 --> 00:25:10.184
So back then, they're doing the same thing.

433
00:25:10.204 --> 00:25:11.926
They're trying to find, like, has someone else done it?

434
00:25:12.006 --> 00:25:16.589
And all three of them actually find Mendel's old paper in the literature.

435
00:25:16.609 --> 00:25:17.210
Yeah.

436
00:25:17.590 --> 00:25:21.871
And they realize, so these are the three, and they rediscover Mendel's work in 1900.

437
00:25:22.231 --> 00:25:24.252
And they're like, well, somebody beat us to the punch.

438
00:25:24.732 --> 00:25:27.873
And this is now colloquially known as the rediscovery of Mendel.

439
00:25:28.313 --> 00:25:34.795
And it launched modern genetics because now they're like, okay, so there is some kind of level of understanding that we can figure out, right?

440
00:25:35.375 --> 00:25:45.579
Now, the next focus is always how do we go from empirical math rules to some kind of mechanistic understanding, right?

441
00:25:45.619 --> 00:25:46.659
What is actually happening?

442
00:25:46.699 --> 00:25:46.839
Right.

443
00:25:47.670 --> 00:25:49.032
In the organism that is doing this.

444
00:25:49.212 --> 00:25:49.412
Right.

445
00:25:49.552 --> 00:25:51.374
So we can predict, but we don't know how it works.

446
00:25:51.414 --> 00:25:52.215
Yeah, exactly.

447
00:25:52.475 --> 00:25:52.695
Okay.

448
00:25:53.156 --> 00:25:57.861
So first question, natural question, where are the alleles?

449
00:25:58.581 --> 00:25:58.802
Yeah.

450
00:25:59.062 --> 00:25:59.242
Right?

451
00:25:59.482 --> 00:26:01.224
You're saying there's these two types of alleles.

452
00:26:02.025 --> 00:26:04.548
Well, and it seems like there's like actual stuff.

453
00:26:05.667 --> 00:26:07.147
That's like moving.

454
00:26:07.287 --> 00:26:14.169
And there's like physically two thingies that like get independently, that come out and then they recombine and stuff like that.

455
00:26:14.469 --> 00:26:20.250
But if that's the case, there should be something I can find inside organisms that is an allele.

456
00:26:20.710 --> 00:26:24.251
So Walter Sutton, he's a graduate student at Columbia University at the time.

457
00:26:24.331 --> 00:26:31.832
And he proposes in 1902, 1903 that these alleles are located on chromosomes.

458
00:26:32.092 --> 00:26:34.893
He was actually working on grasshoppers at the time.

459
00:26:36.034 --> 00:26:39.157
And in Grasshoppers, he could stain the chromosomes.

460
00:26:39.677 --> 00:26:45.583
And what he figured was that there's these thread light structures called chromosomes and they come in pairs.

461
00:26:46.524 --> 00:26:47.405
So that's interesting.

462
00:26:47.445 --> 00:26:48.025
That's interesting.

463
00:26:48.045 --> 00:26:52.550
Because the alleles come in pairs and they separate during cell division.

464
00:26:53.130 --> 00:26:57.995
And if you look at the gametes, which are the sperm and the egg, they each get half and half.

465
00:26:59.382 --> 00:27:00.523
So he's like, coincidence?

466
00:27:00.563 --> 00:27:01.063
I think not.

467
00:27:01.103 --> 00:27:02.323
Where there's smoke, there's fire.

468
00:27:02.343 --> 00:27:02.604
Yes.

469
00:27:02.644 --> 00:27:07.026
He's like, this could be the physical basis for Mendelian law of heredity.

470
00:27:08.126 --> 00:27:11.668
People are still doubting it because it's coincidence.

471
00:27:12.028 --> 00:27:12.288
Okay?

472
00:27:12.608 --> 00:27:15.890
You could be missing something that also goes half and half.

473
00:27:16.670 --> 00:27:21.857
Just because it has similar behavior does not mean it's not a causal link.

474
00:27:21.877 --> 00:27:23.038
Yeah, it's not a causal link.

475
00:27:23.479 --> 00:27:24.320
There's a correlation.

476
00:27:24.680 --> 00:27:27.544
But in order to establish causation, you got to dig deeper, right?

477
00:27:27.905 --> 00:27:32.490
And this is where a guy, Thomas Hunt Morgan, comes in, also at Columbia University, early 1900s.

478
00:27:33.091 --> 00:27:44.341
Columbia was doing amazing with just like early biology, like even before DNA, before molecular biology, just like this kind of early rudimentary work.

479
00:27:44.641 --> 00:27:48.865
So Thomas Hunt Morgan at Columbia University, he starts using the Drosophila,

480
00:27:50.052 --> 00:27:50.512
Fruit fly.

481
00:27:50.912 --> 00:27:54.553
He's the one who actually establishes the fruit fly as the model organism.

482
00:27:54.673 --> 00:28:00.074
Nowadays, the fruit fly is used in neuroscience research, development, genetics, all sorts of things.

483
00:28:00.094 --> 00:28:05.195
He's the first guy to be like, let's go to town with the fruit fly.

484
00:28:05.275 --> 00:28:11.837
So Mendel was the pea plant, and then Morgan now moved us into a more complex biological organism.

485
00:28:12.197 --> 00:28:13.759
That is a better model organism.

486
00:28:13.779 --> 00:28:14.740
Yeah, that's an animal.

487
00:28:14.760 --> 00:28:15.140
That's an animal.

488
00:28:15.160 --> 00:28:16.241
So it can learn and stuff.

489
00:28:16.361 --> 00:28:16.862
Right, right.

490
00:28:17.082 --> 00:28:18.063
Like it sleeps.

491
00:28:18.263 --> 00:28:21.626
So you can do... Like there's so many more things you can do with a Drosophila, right?

492
00:28:22.167 --> 00:28:27.372
And Morgan's team discovers that there's some traits that are sex-linked, like red eye color.

493
00:28:27.852 --> 00:28:28.653
Here's what I mean by that.

494
00:28:28.793 --> 00:28:29.053
So...

495
00:28:31.414 --> 00:28:37.238
What he does is he finds a female with red eyes and then a male with white eyes.

496
00:28:37.578 --> 00:28:41.320
And when they have offspring, all of the kids have red eyes.

497
00:28:42.061 --> 00:28:49.685
So you could just be like, oh, red eyes like this, like, you know, homozygous type dominant trait or whatever.

498
00:28:50.266 --> 00:28:51.647
Now, let's take the...

499
00:28:52.367 --> 00:28:54.027
female again that has red eyes.

500
00:28:54.067 --> 00:28:57.228
So in this case, this is going to be a heterozygous female, right?

501
00:28:57.488 --> 00:28:58.989
Because the male had a white eye.

502
00:28:59.329 --> 00:29:04.350
So this female is going to have one red eye allele and one white eye allele.

503
00:29:04.690 --> 00:29:08.632
And now I'm going to cross that with a red-eyed male.

504
00:29:09.632 --> 00:29:09.952
Okay?

505
00:29:10.492 --> 00:29:16.474
So the male, and we've done a true breeding with the male to make sure that the male is fully red.

506
00:29:17.394 --> 00:29:20.995
When we cross it, most of the offspring

507
00:29:22.158 --> 00:29:25.601
In fact, every single one of the female offstrings has red eyes.

508
00:29:26.181 --> 00:29:27.723
But the males are half and half.

509
00:29:28.970 --> 00:29:31.291
They're not even doing three to one.

510
00:29:32.131 --> 00:29:33.312
Now they're doing half and half.

511
00:29:33.752 --> 00:29:33.952
Right.

512
00:29:34.092 --> 00:29:38.214
And he identifies that the red eye allele is actually on the sex chromosome.

513
00:29:38.714 --> 00:29:41.896
And the way sex chromosomes work is we only get one if we're male.

514
00:29:42.356 --> 00:29:42.556
Right?

515
00:29:42.756 --> 00:29:46.138
The Y chromosome isn't really a chromosome, if I'm completely honest.

516
00:29:46.318 --> 00:29:46.498
Right?

517
00:29:46.698 --> 00:29:47.718
We have X and Y.

518
00:29:48.519 --> 00:29:54.542
If you look at the two side by side, the X chromosome is this big and has a bunch of extremely important genes.

519
00:29:54.922 --> 00:29:57.443
The Y chromosome has absolutely, like, nothing.

520
00:29:57.983 --> 00:29:58.203
Right.

521
00:29:58.823 --> 00:30:01.124
It's like it's it's really tiny.

522
00:30:01.704 --> 00:30:08.667
And in fact, it's so tiny that there's it's like the way the chromosome is like tied up.

523
00:30:09.047 --> 00:30:12.448
There's a there's a little centromere that like holds the two strands together.

524
00:30:12.788 --> 00:30:17.890
And the Y chromosome is so tiny that there's very little room for.

525
00:30:19.135 --> 00:30:36.413
genetic recombination and so that's why like the y chromosome like your y chromosome is identical to your dad's y chromosome to his dad's to his dad's for like 10 generations because it's so small that physically you can't like mix things anyways so the point is

526
00:30:37.444 --> 00:30:41.687
He identified a particular chromosome with that trait.

527
00:30:41.808 --> 00:30:42.028
Right.

528
00:30:42.128 --> 00:30:47.993
And the reason why males are coming up 50-50 is because they only get one X chromosome from the mom.

529
00:30:48.313 --> 00:30:48.513
Right?

530
00:30:48.593 --> 00:30:51.776
So either you're going to get the red one or you're going to get the white one.

531
00:30:52.356 --> 00:30:52.556
Right?

532
00:30:52.656 --> 00:30:53.037
That's it.

533
00:30:53.517 --> 00:30:57.000
The females, on the other hand, they're getting one from the mom and one from the dad.

534
00:30:57.460 --> 00:30:59.021
And the dad is guaranteed to be red.

535
00:30:59.061 --> 00:31:02.404
So even if I get the white one from the mom, the dad is guaranteed to be red.

536
00:31:02.444 --> 00:31:05.647
So all of the female offspring are going to have red eye color.

537
00:31:06.007 --> 00:31:07.027
That's fascinating.

538
00:31:07.047 --> 00:31:07.447
Yeah, yeah.

539
00:31:07.728 --> 00:31:09.468
And so we've added another layer here.

540
00:31:09.528 --> 00:31:09.788
Yes.

541
00:31:10.168 --> 00:31:13.509
Because before we were saying the traits were not correlated.

542
00:31:13.669 --> 00:31:14.150
Yeah.

543
00:31:14.190 --> 00:31:15.850
You know, color, size.

544
00:31:16.030 --> 00:31:16.290
Yeah.

545
00:31:16.550 --> 00:31:18.511
But now with sex chromosomes.

546
00:31:18.571 --> 00:31:18.831
Yeah.

547
00:31:18.891 --> 00:31:21.892
Now it's like if they're on that sex chromosome, then the math is a bit different.

548
00:31:22.152 --> 00:31:31.075
And actually the correlated part is the second thing that Thomas Hunt Morgan did, which is he showed that some of the traits happen to be inherited together.

549
00:31:32.150 --> 00:31:39.413
Okay, so before I was showing you about how body color and eye color under Drosophila, they were independently assorted.

550
00:31:39.873 --> 00:31:45.995
But there's some that if I have red and some other trait, those are going to go together.

551
00:31:46.476 --> 00:31:48.256
Okay, why would they go together?

552
00:31:48.276 --> 00:31:53.778
Well, now it's obvious because if they're on the chromosome, if they're on the same chromosome, then they're coming in a package, right?

553
00:31:54.279 --> 00:31:57.200
And so if they're coming in a package, you're going to...

554
00:31:57.860 --> 00:32:02.843
have this correlation, and that violates Mendel's law of independent assortment.

555
00:32:03.023 --> 00:32:14.308
If I order something from Amazon, we thought it was going to come in two separate packages, which could have two different delivery days, but it actually came in a big box with two little boxes in it, and they were shipped at the same time.

556
00:32:14.468 --> 00:32:15.729
Very bad crude analogy.

557
00:32:17.230 --> 00:32:18.390
That's exactly what's happening, right?

558
00:32:18.410 --> 00:32:21.612
And this is actually the first major empirical crack ever.

559
00:32:22.792 --> 00:32:24.653
to Mendel's laws.

560
00:32:25.133 --> 00:32:30.036
This is the first time where it's like, no, Mendel was actually wrong, but also he did, it's fine.

561
00:32:30.296 --> 00:32:31.056
He had no idea.

562
00:32:31.176 --> 00:32:34.418
He did it in a cave with a box of scraps.

563
00:32:34.438 --> 00:32:35.198
Yeah, exactly.

564
00:32:35.218 --> 00:32:35.838
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

565
00:32:35.858 --> 00:32:36.959
So it's fine.

566
00:32:36.999 --> 00:32:38.960
Morgan actually won the Nobel Prize in Physiology.

567
00:32:39.000 --> 00:32:42.562
He's one of the first Americans to win the Nobel Prize in Physiology and Medicine.

568
00:32:42.662 --> 00:32:45.643
And side note about Thomas Morgan, he's quite a character.

569
00:32:45.703 --> 00:32:49.145
So he's the nephew of Confederate General John Hunt Morgan.

570
00:32:49.865 --> 00:32:52.826
who got his butt kicked somewhere in the north.

571
00:32:53.286 --> 00:33:00.449
And then the great-grandson of Francis Scott Key, who is the author of The Star-Spangled Banner.

572
00:33:00.489 --> 00:33:01.009
No way.

573
00:33:01.049 --> 00:33:02.910
Yeah, this guy's quite interesting.

574
00:33:02.970 --> 00:33:17.455
So he established something called the Fly Room in Columbia that became kind of this legendary place where scientists from all over the world would come and hang out and learn about how to take care of...

575
00:33:18.175 --> 00:33:21.896
fruit flies, how to make sure that the crossing is the same.

576
00:33:21.916 --> 00:33:23.536
Because for Mendel, it's pretty easy.

577
00:33:23.556 --> 00:33:24.436
You just cut the thing.

578
00:33:24.456 --> 00:33:25.317
You take a paintbrush.

579
00:33:25.537 --> 00:33:27.757
Here, you've got to make the flies mate and stuff, right?

580
00:33:27.777 --> 00:33:29.377
So it's a bit more of a process.

581
00:33:29.777 --> 00:33:33.638
But there's a lot more room to work with scientifically.

582
00:33:33.698 --> 00:33:41.480
It became this legendary place, established the fruit fly as a model organism, and the lineage of that.

583
00:33:42.280 --> 00:33:48.009
is seen in every single university that does serious biomedical research.

584
00:33:48.109 --> 00:33:50.412
They have a fly lab somewhere doing something.

585
00:33:50.512 --> 00:33:55.479
Isn't it incredible something that people when they're in their house are trying to look for ways to make these things go away?

586
00:33:55.519 --> 00:33:55.719
Yeah.

587
00:33:55.800 --> 00:33:57.342
Not specifically the fruit fly, but just a fly lab.

588
00:33:57.362 --> 00:33:57.502
Yeah.

589
00:33:57.562 --> 00:34:00.284
I mean, yeah, fruit flies are a bit.

590
00:34:00.544 --> 00:34:10.869
And it is a cornerstone of us getting a greater understanding not only of our own lives as humans, but the lives of all animals on the planet.

591
00:34:10.909 --> 00:34:12.050
And it's still going.

592
00:34:12.130 --> 00:34:12.350
Right.

593
00:34:12.430 --> 00:34:13.531
It's still happening.

594
00:34:13.551 --> 00:34:16.732
There's still so much we can learn from the fruit fly.

595
00:34:16.772 --> 00:34:18.333
It's pretty insane.

596
00:34:18.734 --> 00:34:26.158
Another cool thing about Thomas Hunt Morgan is he went on to found the Department of Biology at Caltech when Caltech started in the 1920s.

597
00:34:26.998 --> 00:34:33.181
Caltech was this insane place because, like, they – so they hired, like, the all-stars.

598
00:34:33.702 --> 00:34:42.566
Like, they just poached all of the big – because they just got a bunch of money, I believe, from the Rockefeller Foundation.

599
00:34:43.847 --> 00:34:44.847
Either them or Carnegie.

600
00:34:45.068 --> 00:34:45.208
No.

601
00:34:45.848 --> 00:34:46.468
whatever they're dead.

602
00:34:46.508 --> 00:34:48.909
But like, if they were alive, they'd be pissed that I was mixing them up.

603
00:34:49.169 --> 00:35:00.814
But one of them gave a lot of money and they just, so George Hale, who was kind of the founder at the time, he, he took this Pasadena community college type thing and was like, all right, we're just going to hire the biggest names.

604
00:35:01.074 --> 00:35:02.815
It's kind of like when you start like a new team,

605
00:35:03.495 --> 00:35:06.156
or something, you just hire the best coach.

606
00:35:06.396 --> 00:35:08.397
If you got the money, you hire the best coach.

607
00:35:08.738 --> 00:35:10.499
You hire Erling Haaland or whatever.

608
00:35:10.779 --> 00:35:15.881
The perfect analogy for this in soccer and football is PSG a couple of years ago.

609
00:35:16.161 --> 00:35:16.682
Oh, really?

610
00:35:16.722 --> 00:35:19.843
The French League has been viewed for a while as being sort of a farmer's league.

611
00:35:20.023 --> 00:35:20.824
They got Neymar.

612
00:35:21.084 --> 00:35:23.165
They got Messi.

613
00:35:23.305 --> 00:35:25.726
They got Mbappe, Donnarum, a bunch of other players.

614
00:35:25.746 --> 00:35:27.707
They just got literally all the best players in the world.

615
00:35:27.747 --> 00:35:28.808
Yeah, at the same time.

616
00:35:28.828 --> 00:35:29.488
At the same time.

617
00:35:29.548 --> 00:35:30.949
Yeah, that's what Caltech did.

618
00:35:30.969 --> 00:35:31.529
That's what they did.

619
00:35:31.929 --> 00:35:32.390
In the 1920s.

620
00:35:32.410 --> 00:35:34.531
They got Millikan for physics.

621
00:35:34.591 --> 00:35:38.034
They got Thomas Hunt Morgan for biology.

622
00:35:38.114 --> 00:35:41.837
It was just an insane place to start out like that.

623
00:35:41.917 --> 00:35:45.240
I will note, it doesn't always work because it did not work for PSG.

624
00:35:45.740 --> 00:35:46.380
They had that.

625
00:35:46.881 --> 00:35:48.122
They couldn't win the Champions League.

626
00:35:48.302 --> 00:35:48.982
Oh, they couldn't?

627
00:35:49.143 --> 00:35:54.787
And then Messi and Mbappe left, and Neymar left, and then they won the Champions League.

628
00:35:55.007 --> 00:35:55.927
Oh, that's hilarious.

629
00:35:55.987 --> 00:35:57.428
So it can work.

630
00:35:57.568 --> 00:35:58.268
It can work, yeah.

631
00:35:58.508 --> 00:35:59.769
It worked in Caltech's case.

632
00:36:00.049 --> 00:36:06.992
Yes, certainly, because they became like a top institution immediately, which usually it takes years of work to do that, right?

633
00:36:07.932 --> 00:36:11.353
And his students have won the Nobel Prize too, like John Howard Northrop.

634
00:36:11.373 --> 00:36:23.138
He's a Berkeley professor in 1946, Chemistry Nobel for Isolation and Crystallization of Enzymes, and Hermann Miller won the 1946 Nobel Prize in Medicine for X-rays to make mutations.

635
00:36:23.198 --> 00:36:23.538
Unbelievable.

636
00:36:24.338 --> 00:36:26.419
A big lineage from Thomas Hunt Morgan.

637
00:36:26.740 --> 00:36:30.542
Anyways, after Morgan, then you have the modern synthesis of genetics.

638
00:36:30.562 --> 00:36:37.286
So this is, we've covered this in a previous episode with James Watson and his discovery of DNA.

639
00:36:37.306 --> 00:36:42.170
But Avery, McLeod, and McCarty, they showed in 1944 that genes are from DNA.

640
00:36:42.490 --> 00:36:45.211
And then Watson and Crick together, crucially, with...

641
00:36:46.532 --> 00:37:09.548
evidence from rosalind franklin discovered the helical structure of dna and how the the sequence of base pairs is really how genes work we had a huge deep dive on this particularly uh the work of rosalind franklin which in part was not included in a lot of the accolades that came afterwards has since been rectified at least slightly at least slightly at least slightly in the modern era

642
00:37:10.128 --> 00:37:26.114
Um, it's a great deep dive if you haven't watched it already, because that also has a great, uh, the science is great, but the palace intrigue and how the university ecosystem worked and was being established, not only in the UK, but in the U S at the time was, was really, really fascinating.

643
00:37:26.354 --> 00:37:26.654
Um, yeah.

644
00:37:27.314 --> 00:37:30.377
Yeah, and just how many shenanigans went into...

645
00:37:30.577 --> 00:37:31.298
So much shenanigans.

646
00:37:31.358 --> 00:37:33.019
So much shenanigans.

647
00:37:33.359 --> 00:37:40.145
So now we've got kind of a more complete picture of how genes work and how Mendel's laws come from genes.

648
00:37:40.385 --> 00:37:42.267
So I just want to go over all of that, okay?

649
00:37:42.627 --> 00:37:48.873
So first we know now from all of the work is DNA stores the data of these alleles and genes.

650
00:37:49.013 --> 00:37:53.877
And what an allele really is, is one version of the ATGC sequence.

651
00:37:54.037 --> 00:38:19.130
okay the different allele will be a different version of that atgc sequence right and the two alleles are different in only a few base pairs because that's going to code for a different protein and that protein is going to make the different trait for folks who might not know when you say atcg sequence can you clarify yeah yeah yeah good point um the atcgs are the nucleotides that make up dna so dna is a molecule that's kind of a twisted ladder and the rungs of the ladder

652
00:38:23.672 --> 00:38:40.768
of those letters in that ladder tell you what kind of protein to make okay so it's like they're rungs on the ladder they can be in different order and so you can do different things based on the order that they're in yeah and each chromosome comes in with a different rungs on the ladder order from each of the parents in this context

653
00:38:41.132 --> 00:38:41.752
Yes, exactly.

654
00:38:41.772 --> 00:38:49.037
And when we say that there are two alleles, what we really mean is there's two distinct sequences of ATGCs, right, that will code for the protein.

655
00:38:49.077 --> 00:38:52.260
And that DNA is stored in the chromosome.

656
00:38:52.600 --> 00:39:02.467
So when we see the chromosome, like the two strands, each strand is a giant molecule, a single molecule of DNA, that if you were to unravel would be like this big, literally.

657
00:39:03.107 --> 00:39:26.735
like that fits inside every single one of our cells but it's like it's like several inches long that's right it's a single molecule of just atgc strung together right and it's wrapped around a bunch of stuff to create the chromosomes so that's what a chromosome is all right now we know what a chromosome is now each chromosome as we said has two chromatids those are the two different sequences of dna and each allele is located on the different chromatids

658
00:39:27.255 --> 00:39:39.700
So now when we look at the laws of independent assortment and things like that and how to create gametes, well, during meiosis, the two chromatids, they replicate and then they physically separate into different cells.

659
00:39:40.060 --> 00:39:43.302
So the sperm cells all get half one chromatid each.

660
00:39:43.582 --> 00:39:44.922
And that's now making sense, right?

661
00:39:44.942 --> 00:39:46.483
With the whole Punnett squares and all that stuff.

662
00:39:46.503 --> 00:39:47.103
How's that working?

663
00:39:47.343 --> 00:39:50.985
Well, when the egg and the sperm come together, you get half and half to create a whole.

664
00:39:51.650 --> 00:39:51.830
Right.

665
00:39:52.110 --> 00:39:52.250
Right.

666
00:39:52.290 --> 00:39:53.891
So so now that that's making sense.

667
00:39:54.151 --> 00:39:56.013
Now the independent assortment works.

668
00:39:56.273 --> 00:40:00.975
The whole correlated genes also works, because if you're on the same chromatid, then you're going to get the same package.

669
00:40:01.396 --> 00:40:05.718
And then finally, how does the dominant and recessive work?

670
00:40:06.218 --> 00:40:06.419
Right.

671
00:40:07.019 --> 00:40:15.284
Well, a lot of times the dominant version just codes for the protein that works and the recessive version codes for the protein that doesn't work.

672
00:40:16.146 --> 00:40:20.109
So if you get two dominants, you just get maybe a little bit more of the protein.

673
00:40:20.289 --> 00:40:26.813
There can be some gene regulation stuff to downplay one of the chromatids so that I don't have too much of the same protein.

674
00:40:27.013 --> 00:40:29.254
There's actually stuff that goes on there, which is very interesting.

675
00:40:29.535 --> 00:40:37.400
But if I have the heterozygous, meaning one functional type and one dysfunctional type, I still have a working copy, so I can create that gene.

676
00:40:37.700 --> 00:40:40.622
But if I have two dysfunctional types, then I've got no way to create the gene.

677
00:40:41.102 --> 00:40:43.023
Eye color is a very good example of this.

678
00:40:43.383 --> 00:40:45.885
The OCA2 allele combinations...

679
00:40:46.145 --> 00:40:52.829
So there's a gene for melanosome.

680
00:40:53.029 --> 00:40:53.670
Melanosome.

681
00:40:54.030 --> 00:40:56.231
That's the protein that gives brown eye color.

682
00:40:56.391 --> 00:40:56.651
Okay?

683
00:40:57.172 --> 00:41:02.055
And if you've got two versions of that protein, then you're going to create melanosome, and you're going to have brown eyes.

684
00:41:02.655 --> 00:41:05.257
If you've got a single version of the protein...

685
00:41:05.937 --> 00:41:07.338
Body can still create melanosome.

686
00:41:07.618 --> 00:41:16.465
But if you've got no functional melanosome, then it's kind of like the naked retina, or not retina, iris, is the color that you're going to see.

687
00:41:17.045 --> 00:41:24.130
It's a bit more complicated, obviously, because you have green and hazel, and so there's different versions of even melanosome, and there's other little things that go in.

688
00:41:24.410 --> 00:41:27.773
But by and large, this is how dominant versus recessive works.

689
00:41:28.273 --> 00:41:33.237
And this is why people have to wear sunglasses if they have light-colored eyes, because they don't have that melanosome.

690
00:41:33.277 --> 00:41:34.218
That provides that...

691
00:41:35.153 --> 00:41:56.149
additional protection for the eyes yes as as one one example exactly so and so far what we've been covering is effectively it's still been mendelian even like thomas hunt morgan talking about the packages coming together that's still mendelian in some sense right i mean you're kind of proving his point that they come in these packages it's just that some of them are correlated there are now

692
00:41:57.030 --> 00:42:26.178
a growing there is now a growing body of work that there are a lot of exceptions and so that's where we're going to get to next but before we do that we've got some housekeeping some housekeeping here so we are super excited everybody to have our resident phd krishna chowdhury back in the studio we i'm so excited for our upcoming episodes we are working through a studio redesign you might notice that our dock behind us is in a different location we have some neon signs coming in shortly and

693
00:42:26.498 --> 00:42:30.800
And we are adding the FFP bookshelf that will be behind us.

694
00:42:31.261 --> 00:42:34.182
And we are going to have a collection of some of our favorite books.

695
00:42:34.642 --> 00:42:41.326
We would love to get some suggestions for what you think should go into the FFP library.

696
00:42:41.366 --> 00:42:48.590
So over the next couple of episodes, you'll start to see things begin to take place and a little bit of changing of scenery.

697
00:42:48.610 --> 00:42:49.250
If you're interested.

698
00:42:49.370 --> 00:42:50.511
You enjoy the show.

699
00:42:50.651 --> 00:43:07.578
If you are happy to see us back doing these deep dives, not only on the frontier of science research, but the context with how we got there, you can always support the show by sharing clips or your favorite episodes with your friends, family, and colleagues.

700
00:43:07.898 --> 00:43:09.019
You can watch the show.

701
00:43:09.059 --> 00:43:12.260
We always encourage you to watch the show on YouTube and Spotify.

702
00:43:12.280 --> 00:43:14.521
The full video podcast is available there.

703
00:43:14.541 --> 00:43:16.562
You can listen wherever you get information.

704
00:43:16.802 --> 00:43:24.491
your podcasts and for clips or across our socials, TikTok, Instagram X, some of the best key moments from the show.

705
00:43:25.012 --> 00:43:28.156
Easy to send that DM to slide into the DMS.

706
00:43:28.636 --> 00:43:30.759
Getting more eyes on the show is super helpful for us.

707
00:43:31.280 --> 00:43:36.366
If you can support the show directly, we have a donation portal on the website.

708
00:43:36.786 --> 00:43:39.248
FFPPod.com backslash donate.

709
00:43:39.708 --> 00:43:43.211
And if you haven't been to the website, you can watch full episodes.

710
00:43:43.231 --> 00:43:44.232
We have chaptering.

711
00:43:44.512 --> 00:43:49.516
We link out to all of our research papers that we cover connected to each episode.

712
00:43:49.916 --> 00:43:55.360
And I will note there have been some of you that have been asking for an RSS feed for the website.

713
00:43:55.760 --> 00:43:57.542
We are working on that as well.

714
00:43:57.602 --> 00:43:58.963
So keep an eye out for that.

715
00:43:59.503 --> 00:44:01.445
over the next couple of weeks.

716
00:44:01.545 --> 00:44:04.587
So be sure to comment what books you want to see on the bookshelf.

717
00:44:05.088 --> 00:44:08.190
I hope we didn't order neon signs that are too big.

718
00:44:08.210 --> 00:44:09.571
They're going to be quite large.

719
00:44:10.812 --> 00:44:12.433
So hopefully it works out here.

720
00:44:12.474 --> 00:44:18.698
But we are super grateful for all of you in FFP Nation and the audience who have been super supportive of the show.

721
00:44:19.199 --> 00:44:22.241
We are super excited to get back on the hopper here.

722
00:44:22.541 --> 00:44:25.324
We have some great, great episodes lined up.

723
00:44:25.804 --> 00:44:37.653
But before we get to those great episodes, we need to finish up because I'm very curious about how we now talk about epigenetics as it relates to this background we just talked about on Mendelian genetics.

724
00:44:37.753 --> 00:44:37.973
Right.

725
00:44:38.014 --> 00:44:41.816
So what we've talked about so far is just the genetic part of things.

726
00:44:42.157 --> 00:44:44.318
And even then, we've only talked about Mendel's rules.

727
00:44:45.139 --> 00:44:48.622
And from our understanding now, it's been 160 years of study.

728
00:44:49.542 --> 00:44:52.625
It is a gross oversimplification of what is actually happening.

729
00:44:56.035 --> 00:45:17.284
from genetic input what the offspring's genotype is going to be what the offspring's genetic makeup is going to be and then how the offspring is going to look on the outside right but by look i mean like what are the traits that it has okay even if it's on the inside right but that's what we call a phenotype compared to the genotype which is just the actual genetic makeup

730
00:45:17.684 --> 00:45:21.947
Now, as people worked on this over many, many years, anomalies started piling up.

731
00:45:22.227 --> 00:45:22.447
Okay?

732
00:45:22.487 --> 00:45:23.828
There are several.

733
00:45:24.409 --> 00:45:26.690
We are going to focus on just one.

734
00:45:26.710 --> 00:45:27.051
Okay?

735
00:45:27.071 --> 00:45:27.271
Okay?

736
00:45:28.148 --> 00:45:30.170
The anomaly is called paramutation.

737
00:45:30.250 --> 00:45:31.591
It starts with maize.

738
00:45:31.911 --> 00:45:39.837
It was first documented in the 1950s by geneticist Alexander Brink when he was studying the red one locus in maize.

739
00:45:39.917 --> 00:45:42.620
Location of the red one gene in maize.

740
00:45:42.660 --> 00:45:43.520
Maize is just corn.

741
00:45:43.861 --> 00:45:46.923
But biologists always say maize for some reason.

742
00:45:47.303 --> 00:45:47.544
Okay?

743
00:45:48.665 --> 00:45:50.706
Maybe someone can tell me why in the comments.

744
00:45:50.786 --> 00:45:52.608
But I've never seen someone just say corn.

745
00:45:52.628 --> 00:45:52.728
Okay?

746
00:45:53.469 --> 00:46:14.290
but then i look at the photos and it's just corn okay anyways so the the red one location in this organism controls for the anthocyanin pigment okay and that's the pigment that is responsible for the dark coloring of corn kernels you've seen like those like exotic corn that like it's like purple that's what this is okay so that's the trait that we're going to

747
00:46:14.750 --> 00:46:17.933
In Zim, we have this dish called sadza, which is cornmeal.

748
00:46:18.393 --> 00:46:21.356
And you can have sort of different color styles.

749
00:46:21.376 --> 00:46:24.498
You usually don't use when you have that red pigment style.

750
00:46:24.678 --> 00:46:25.999
You'll usually just cook it straight.

751
00:46:26.019 --> 00:46:27.240
You won't make that into cornmeal.

752
00:46:27.561 --> 00:46:28.742
It'll usually be either yellow or white.

753
00:46:28.782 --> 00:46:33.005
But we call it maize back home, which is interesting.

754
00:46:33.165 --> 00:46:35.627
Yeah, but these are Americans that are working on it.

755
00:46:35.707 --> 00:46:38.309
That's why I just want to know what's going on.

756
00:46:38.589 --> 00:46:38.910
Okay.

757
00:46:39.730 --> 00:46:45.492
Even like Dorothy... No, it's Barbara McClintock with the jumping genes.

758
00:46:45.672 --> 00:46:46.833
She discovered those in maize.

759
00:46:47.473 --> 00:46:47.873
It's maize.

760
00:46:47.893 --> 00:46:48.333
It's maize.

761
00:46:48.593 --> 00:46:49.214
Okay, whatever.

762
00:46:49.554 --> 00:46:53.235
Anyways, so let's talk about this red one location, okay?

763
00:46:53.255 --> 00:46:55.516
The anthocyanin pigment pathway.

764
00:46:56.136 --> 00:46:57.797
Here is what he observed, okay?

765
00:46:58.457 --> 00:47:05.920
What I'm going to do is do kind of the same thing that Mendel used to do, which is I'm going to get two true breeding plants, one that has the purple...

766
00:47:07.035 --> 00:47:33.740
pigment thingy and then one that doesn't i'm gonna cross those weirdly i get all recessive even though the purple is the pigment right like so that should be dominant because that's the working pigment according to like what i told you about what is dominant and recessive yes it's not just arbitrary it's just like one is the protein is actually working the other one the protein is not working here if i have a true breeding purple and a true breeding green i'm actually getting no working pigment

767
00:47:34.612 --> 00:47:35.413
I'm getting all green.

768
00:47:35.533 --> 00:47:38.555
It's like the opposite of the F1 generation, right?

769
00:47:38.775 --> 00:47:40.256
This isn't even getting to F2.

770
00:47:40.736 --> 00:47:42.297
This is like in the F1 generation.

771
00:47:42.337 --> 00:47:47.701
It's as if Mendel did purple cross white and got all white.

772
00:47:47.761 --> 00:47:51.864
Okay, that's fascinating, which would not make sense given that it was all purple.

773
00:47:51.884 --> 00:47:55.646
It should have the dominance in all four of the offspring.

774
00:47:55.666 --> 00:47:56.266
Yeah, okay.

775
00:47:56.427 --> 00:47:56.687
So...

776
00:47:57.227 --> 00:47:58.148
Again, what the hell?

777
00:47:58.168 --> 00:47:58.829
What's going on there?

778
00:47:58.889 --> 00:47:59.790
What's going on there?

779
00:47:59.950 --> 00:48:05.635
So now, next thing to do is now, I mean, usually what you do is you take that and then you crossbreed with itself.

780
00:48:06.036 --> 00:48:07.517
So you do a self-fertilization.

781
00:48:07.757 --> 00:48:08.698
But now things are weird.

782
00:48:09.079 --> 00:48:13.503
So now let's cross it with a true breeding purple again, right?

783
00:48:13.723 --> 00:48:16.726
Because let's say something weird happened and I got like recessive, recessive here.

784
00:48:17.687 --> 00:48:19.749
And then the purple...

785
00:48:21.005 --> 00:48:23.848
Or maybe I got like one bit of purple, but like it's not showing up.

786
00:48:24.489 --> 00:48:27.291
In the F2 generation, I should get some purple.

787
00:48:28.352 --> 00:48:28.953
I cross it.

788
00:48:29.053 --> 00:48:30.094
I get all green.

789
00:48:30.815 --> 00:48:31.315
No purple.

790
00:48:31.375 --> 00:48:38.443
It's almost as if the green, whatever it is, has like completely nixed the advantage of the purple gene.

791
00:48:39.448 --> 00:48:40.289
And silenced it.

792
00:48:40.549 --> 00:48:42.210
This is called a paramutation.

793
00:48:42.550 --> 00:48:42.770
Okay.

794
00:48:42.790 --> 00:48:43.190
Fascinating.

795
00:48:43.670 --> 00:48:49.393
And it's also, it's as if there's the newly altered silent allele that's there, right?

796
00:48:49.433 --> 00:48:52.375
Because I know I have the purple allele.

797
00:48:52.775 --> 00:48:54.896
But that purple allele has somehow been silenced.

798
00:48:55.357 --> 00:49:01.000
And now that purple allele, you would assume if it made it with another purple allele, I would get...

799
00:49:01.772 --> 00:49:02.452
I would get purple.

800
00:49:02.712 --> 00:49:10.536
But this purple allele has turned to the dark side somehow and started nixing all of its other compatriots with the purple allele.

801
00:49:10.556 --> 00:49:12.037
We'll call it the Anakin allele.

802
00:49:12.317 --> 00:49:13.438
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

803
00:49:13.498 --> 00:49:14.338
Something like that, right?

804
00:49:14.378 --> 00:49:18.860
It's like you've got like a weird corrupted computer file that now goes and infects every other computer.

805
00:49:19.401 --> 00:49:24.763
And so what this brings up is that there is not this 100% all of the time sort of viewpoint.

806
00:49:24.923 --> 00:49:26.144
That's the first thing, yeah.

807
00:49:26.224 --> 00:49:27.905
Because this should be dominant.

808
00:49:28.805 --> 00:49:30.808
First of all, it's not dominant, but okay, fine.

809
00:49:30.828 --> 00:49:33.931
But now it's making everything else recessive somehow.

810
00:49:34.192 --> 00:49:35.053
It has an ability.

811
00:49:35.814 --> 00:49:37.756
Cross-generation downstream.

812
00:49:37.816 --> 00:49:39.738
It's not just a one-off outlier.

813
00:49:39.818 --> 00:49:40.319
Exactly.

814
00:49:40.900 --> 00:49:41.801
This is very strange.

815
00:49:42.021 --> 00:49:43.182
This was the 1950s.

816
00:49:43.222 --> 00:49:45.405
It was a very big deal when it was discovered.

817
00:49:45.822 --> 00:49:48.964
Okay, and so now we've got a better understanding of what's going on.

818
00:49:49.665 --> 00:49:52.006
So in order to understand this, we've got to understand two things, okay?

819
00:49:52.407 --> 00:49:55.509
First thing is gene regulation.

820
00:49:56.189 --> 00:49:59.952
That is some of the software on top of the genetics, okay?

821
00:50:00.192 --> 00:50:02.994
So we've got two types of gene regulation pathways.

822
00:50:03.335 --> 00:50:05.136
You've got enhancers and promoters.

823
00:50:05.176 --> 00:50:07.157
We've talked about this a lot on the podcast, right?

824
00:50:07.558 --> 00:50:12.121
When you've got a gene, the gene is a recipe for creating a protein, right?

825
00:50:15.178 --> 00:50:18.741
that is telling the machinery to come make the protein.

826
00:50:19.462 --> 00:50:23.205
And then there is a volume control button that is saying how much protein to make.

827
00:50:23.705 --> 00:50:26.268
That is the promoter and the enhancer, respectively.

828
00:50:26.308 --> 00:50:27.509
The promoter is the on button.

829
00:50:27.869 --> 00:50:29.230
The enhancer is the volume control.

830
00:50:29.250 --> 00:50:31.132
I loved that episode where we talked about this.

831
00:50:32.052 --> 00:50:33.954
Yeah, we've talked about this a lot, right?

832
00:50:34.214 --> 00:50:40.479
And frequently what happens is the promoter is right next to the gene because basically what happens is you've got the gene on this part.

833
00:50:40.759 --> 00:50:42.300
This is the part that has the recipe.

834
00:50:42.540 --> 00:50:43.821
The promoter is right next to it.

835
00:50:44.041 --> 00:50:50.166
So what it's going to do is take something called RNA polymerase, which is the thing that makes it into RNA that then goes into making proteins.

836
00:50:50.426 --> 00:50:54.889
The promoter is going to be like, yo, RNA polymerase, come over here, attach to me, and then go this way.

837
00:50:55.269 --> 00:50:56.931
And it's going to be like, and it goes that way.

838
00:50:57.191 --> 00:50:59.673
The enhancer can be way far apart.

839
00:51:00.133 --> 00:51:01.975
from where the gene is.

840
00:51:02.435 --> 00:51:07.660
And the genetic code can literally fold such that the enhancer gets close to the promoter.

841
00:51:07.941 --> 00:51:10.243
The enhancer recruits the RNA polymerase to come.

842
00:51:10.723 --> 00:51:15.908
And it's very essential for creating that two-step sort of regulation.

843
00:51:16.029 --> 00:51:16.249
Yes.

844
00:51:16.849 --> 00:51:18.250
So this is genetic regulation.

845
00:51:18.710 --> 00:51:19.951
That's the first thing we've got to understand.

846
00:51:20.411 --> 00:51:23.433
Second thing we've got to understand is epigenetics.

847
00:51:23.953 --> 00:51:29.736
Epigenetics is the software and the modifying of the structure of DNA and chromatin.

848
00:51:29.756 --> 00:51:31.637
Chromatin is the thread that the DNA is.

849
00:51:31.697 --> 00:51:31.898
Right?

850
00:51:32.758 --> 00:51:38.305
So there's two levels to doing this that are, by and large, these are the two levels of epigenetics.

851
00:51:38.625 --> 00:51:40.948
The first one is something called methylation.

852
00:51:41.409 --> 00:51:50.660
Effectively, as I told you, DNA is made up of four distinct nucleotides, A, T, G, and C. Now, the C, the cytosine.

853
00:51:51.767 --> 00:51:56.129
can sometimes be modified by attaching a methyl group.

854
00:51:56.689 --> 00:51:58.550
A methyl group is, I think, just CH3.

855
00:51:59.050 --> 00:52:03.372
You just take a CH3 part of a molecule and you attach it to the cytosine.

856
00:52:03.732 --> 00:52:04.372
When you do that,

857
00:52:05.645 --> 00:52:14.772
If you've got a bunch of cytosine in a segment of DNA that has these methyl groups, the RNA polymerase can't really get to it because you've altered the look.

858
00:52:15.172 --> 00:52:17.594
And the RNA polymerase comes in and is like, I don't know what I'm looking at.

859
00:52:18.275 --> 00:52:19.176
I'm going to go somewhere else.

860
00:52:19.196 --> 00:52:20.076
I'm going to go somewhere else.

861
00:52:20.116 --> 00:52:20.817
Right?

862
00:52:20.997 --> 00:52:27.462
So this is one way to silence parts of the gene, parts of the genetic sequence, by just, like, adding a little chemical tag.

863
00:52:27.722 --> 00:52:31.925
And those are the little tiny, like, red pins that you're seeing.

864
00:52:31.945 --> 00:52:32.246
Okay?

865
00:52:32.266 --> 00:52:32.506
Okay.

866
00:52:32.866 --> 00:52:35.507
And they only attach crucially to the C, the cytosine.

867
00:52:35.907 --> 00:52:39.408
Okay, so the A's, T's, and G's are always left alone.

868
00:52:39.688 --> 00:52:39.928
Okay?

869
00:52:41.248 --> 00:52:57.312
Part of what we're sort of speaking to here is there's, in the practice of your body generating the proteins that your genetics sort of has the instructions for, that's a whole functional process.

870
00:52:57.572 --> 00:52:57.792
Yeah.

871
00:52:58.012 --> 00:52:58.853
In and of itself.

872
00:52:59.473 --> 00:53:07.157
And much like all functional processes and there there are opportunities for it to break down in multiple different places.

873
00:53:07.357 --> 00:53:07.557
Yeah.

874
00:53:07.837 --> 00:53:17.742
And that's where you begin to get the impacts on outcomes, because you might have the instructions, but when you go to the factory to build it.

875
00:53:18.683 --> 00:53:19.784
The power goes off.

876
00:53:19.944 --> 00:53:21.265
The doors are locked.

877
00:53:22.486 --> 00:53:23.847
You offshore it to China.

878
00:53:24.007 --> 00:53:24.428
Whatever.

879
00:53:25.128 --> 00:53:25.689
Exactly.

880
00:53:25.709 --> 00:53:26.529
Yeah, exactly.

881
00:53:26.589 --> 00:53:27.030
Exactly.

882
00:53:27.350 --> 00:53:29.492
And so that's the first part, the methylation.

883
00:53:29.592 --> 00:53:29.812
Okay.

884
00:53:30.092 --> 00:53:35.837
The second step is in order to actually create the chromatin, which is the stuff that makes chromosomes, it's like a thicker...

885
00:53:36.577 --> 00:53:38.838
sort of wool compared to stringy.

886
00:53:39.198 --> 00:53:41.979
The DNA is like a string, and then the chromatin is like wool.

887
00:53:41.999 --> 00:53:45.901
You have to like sort of bunch up a bunch of string together to create the thicker part, right?

888
00:53:46.161 --> 00:53:54.245
And in order to do that, if you bring that photo back, you wrap it around these nucleosomes, which are made up of histones,

889
00:53:55.225 --> 00:54:00.647
So they're like little proteins that you wrap it around, and then those sort of get packaged together.

890
00:54:01.107 --> 00:54:08.510
Now, if you wrap it around that part of DNA that's wrapped around the nucleosome, the RNA polymerase can't get to.

891
00:54:08.550 --> 00:54:13.211
So this is another level of silencing certain parts of the DNA.

892
00:54:13.471 --> 00:54:23.015
If you don't ever want this part of DNA to be expressed in a cell, like let's say you're an eye cell, I don't want the proteins that neurons want.

893
00:54:23.995 --> 00:54:29.657
package it up, and put it in a warehouse, put it in your garage effectively.

894
00:54:29.777 --> 00:54:32.057
Only read the part that tells me how to be an eye.

895
00:54:32.517 --> 00:54:39.779
And this is how it's able to control for if all cells all have the same instruction list, how it only focuses on a certain portion of it in order to...

896
00:54:41.880 --> 00:54:47.584
Build out the complex different parts of us where it's not just reading everything and not really having any idea.

897
00:54:47.604 --> 00:54:50.587
We don't have like a bunch of mini like Krishnas, right?

898
00:54:50.647 --> 00:54:54.530
It's like, no, there's like skin Krishna, hair Krishna and all that other kind of stuff.

899
00:54:54.910 --> 00:54:56.871
So that is...

900
00:54:57.772 --> 00:55:20.068
epigenetics okay these two sort of layers that's that's effectively what we want to focus on um how do we how does this explain the maze paramutation that we observed well it's a combination of the genetic regulation with the epigenetic um silencing okay right here's what's

901
00:55:24.375 --> 00:55:32.542
What that is is tiny little bits of RNA that act like mobile silencers.

902
00:55:33.963 --> 00:55:37.365
A part of the DNA makes this RNA interference thingy.

903
00:55:37.766 --> 00:55:41.289
It's a little piece of RNA that goes and, like, attaches to DNA elsewhere.

904
00:55:41.849 --> 00:55:44.811
And because this thing is small enough, it can just move around the nucleus.

905
00:55:45.212 --> 00:55:45.452
Okay?

906
00:55:45.832 --> 00:55:52.398
And what it does is recruit DNA methylation machinery...

907
00:55:53.387 --> 00:55:55.689
To come in and put those methyl groups in the seas.

908
00:55:56.830 --> 00:55:57.090
Okay?

909
00:55:57.551 --> 00:55:58.792
So now, what's going to happen?

910
00:55:59.833 --> 00:56:06.799
What's going to happen is, I've got my purple trait, and I've got the green trait.

911
00:56:07.880 --> 00:56:11.723
They both actually have the gene for purple.

912
00:56:13.060 --> 00:56:21.735
What's different is that the green one has a mechanism to create this small, tiny thingy of RNA to go and silence that purple gene.

913
00:56:21.835 --> 00:56:22.055
Right.

914
00:56:22.295 --> 00:56:22.596
Okay?

915
00:56:22.756 --> 00:56:22.977
Right.

916
00:56:23.057 --> 00:56:24.279
The purple one doesn't have that.

917
00:56:24.960 --> 00:56:25.982
But now when I cross it,

918
00:56:27.288 --> 00:56:32.729
I'm going to get one of the chromatins is going to have that thing that makes the little tiny RNA, the RNA interference.

919
00:56:32.769 --> 00:56:35.590
But that RNA interference is going to go do it for both.

920
00:56:36.230 --> 00:56:36.450
Right.

921
00:56:36.890 --> 00:56:37.110
Right?

922
00:56:37.170 --> 00:56:46.312
Because it is not limited by – it is able to free flow through the nucleus and do what it did previously to get the green.

923
00:56:46.452 --> 00:56:46.672
Yeah.

924
00:56:46.912 --> 00:56:53.453
And so regardless of the fact that both have this dominant purple, this sort of secondary functional process –

925
00:56:54.388 --> 00:56:57.349
is free to move despite the genetic code and instruction.

926
00:56:57.409 --> 00:56:58.070
Exactly, yeah.

927
00:56:58.410 --> 00:57:09.354
And because now the RNA interference is on both the chromatins, now when I take that and I subsequently breed it with another true breeding purple, again, all the offspring are wrecked.

928
00:57:09.394 --> 00:57:10.274
That makes sense, right.

929
00:57:10.374 --> 00:57:15.676
Because the RNA interference is kind of like this little mini molecular virus type thing, right?

930
00:57:15.857 --> 00:57:19.558
Just because you have the instructions doesn't mean your body is going to execute on them.

931
00:57:19.638 --> 00:57:20.398
Yeah, yeah.

932
00:57:20.518 --> 00:57:28.021
If you've got an agent that's just like erasing it or like putting like a paper on top of the instructions or whatever.

933
00:57:28.041 --> 00:57:30.082
That's a really interesting note.

934
00:57:30.502 --> 00:57:39.405
Again, going back to this idea that there is sort of a few layers between the instruction and the completed production of the protein.

935
00:57:39.505 --> 00:57:39.625
Yeah.

936
00:57:39.645 --> 00:57:39.745
Yeah.

937
00:57:40.585 --> 00:57:48.408
And there are mechanisms that can go and silence component parts in that production process.

938
00:57:48.488 --> 00:57:48.668
Yeah.

939
00:57:49.088 --> 00:57:53.610
And in the case we just brought up, that was happening, even though it was a purple dominant on the green.

940
00:57:53.630 --> 00:57:53.730
Yeah.

941
00:57:53.770 --> 00:57:54.870
That's what was happening.

942
00:57:55.230 --> 00:57:58.351
And so if you just looked purely at the genetic code.

943
00:57:58.371 --> 00:58:01.852
At the genetic thing, you'd be like, this should be, the green should also be purple.

944
00:58:01.892 --> 00:58:03.573
It's got the purple gene on it.

945
00:58:03.913 --> 00:58:09.618
And now this epigenetic layer around the silencing on the C. Yeah, getting methylated.

946
00:58:09.638 --> 00:58:15.523
Getting methylated is what is causing the different phenotypic outcome.

947
00:58:15.623 --> 00:58:16.424
Yes, very good.

948
00:58:16.784 --> 00:58:17.225
Exactly.

949
00:58:17.345 --> 00:58:24.351
And this is non-Mendelian because it's doing all this weird shenanigans, and it's the epigenetics that's doing it.

950
00:58:24.451 --> 00:58:24.691
Okay?

951
00:58:24.992 --> 00:58:29.416
So this is already an example of non-Mendelian epigenetic inheritance.

952
00:58:29.636 --> 00:58:29.796
Mm-hmm.

953
00:58:29.996 --> 00:58:39.921
But for the longest time, this has been ubiquitously reported in plants, insects like Drosophila, because we're so good at Drosophila genome that it's easy to find.

954
00:58:40.402 --> 00:58:44.364
But proving their prevalence in higher-order mammals was next to impossible.

955
00:58:44.764 --> 00:58:45.704
And we're going to get into why.

956
00:58:46.085 --> 00:58:50.867
That's where the technological revolution comes in that enables this paper.

957
00:58:51.187 --> 00:58:53.408
And just a side note, in 2006, there was a paper that...

958
00:58:54.509 --> 00:58:59.096
that showed that mice can have RNA-mediated non-Mendalian inheritance.

959
00:58:59.456 --> 00:59:09.450
But there was a lot of dismissal of the findings because they were like, oh, this is just something that happens in strange transgenic mice.

960
00:59:10.111 --> 00:59:12.634
Because the mouse model that was used here was transgenic.

961
00:59:12.915 --> 00:59:14.016
And I think it's totally fair.

962
00:59:14.617 --> 00:59:15.217
I just want to...

963
00:59:15.237 --> 00:59:16.399
This is the funding issue.

964
00:59:16.459 --> 00:59:17.800
Oh, this is the funding issue thing.

965
00:59:18.001 --> 00:59:19.102
We don't have to get into it.

966
00:59:19.162 --> 00:59:19.843
We don't have to get into it.

967
00:59:19.863 --> 00:59:20.744
The trans mice, yes.

968
00:59:20.824 --> 00:59:23.427
Transgenic mice.

969
00:59:24.088 --> 00:59:24.288
Right?

970
00:59:24.529 --> 00:59:26.091
Please do not cut our funding.

971
00:59:26.631 --> 00:59:28.053
We're not making mice trans.

972
00:59:28.293 --> 00:59:28.994
But in any case...

973
00:59:29.895 --> 00:59:31.516
It was an interesting little finding.

974
00:59:31.616 --> 00:59:33.637
I mean, it got published in Nature, so it was a big deal.

975
00:59:33.718 --> 00:59:35.759
But again, it's in transgenic mice.

976
00:59:36.419 --> 00:59:42.323
It's easier to do analysis in transgenic mice because you've got a very nice blueprint of what the genetics is.

977
00:59:42.363 --> 00:59:46.426
It's not a naturally like sort of super diverse genetic population, right?

978
00:59:46.446 --> 00:59:48.287
So you know exactly what to look for.

979
00:59:49.387 --> 00:59:51.548
But perhaps it's not so general, right?

980
00:59:51.588 --> 00:59:57.049
And if it's an RNA-mediated thing, maybe it's just special, and it's not as general as, like, DNA methylation.

981
00:59:57.369 --> 00:59:59.990
This RNA-mediated mechanism was not through DNA methylation.

982
01:00:00.030 --> 01:00:00.830
It was through something else.

983
01:00:01.070 --> 01:00:02.630
There's a bunch of other stuff that can happen, right?

984
01:00:02.950 --> 01:00:09.852
So the point was they were looking at this mice population is not necessarily representative of the natural world in a way that we can extrapolate the results.

985
01:00:09.872 --> 01:00:10.532
Exactly, yeah.

986
01:00:10.552 --> 01:00:13.853
And it's like, at the end of the day, I want to see, like, is this something I can apply to humans, right?

987
01:00:13.933 --> 01:00:14.113
Right.

988
01:00:15.253 --> 01:00:19.775
So still some scientists suspected that paramutation is probably happening in mammals.

989
01:00:19.815 --> 01:00:22.156
I mean, it's happening in plants so ubiquitously.

990
01:00:22.176 --> 01:00:28.799
There shouldn't be, there's no like first principles reason why it shouldn't be happening in mammals, right?

991
01:00:29.259 --> 01:00:32.481
But you need to actually get the evidence.

992
01:00:32.601 --> 01:00:36.182
And for a long time, it was largely at the level of theory.

993
01:00:36.583 --> 01:00:37.603
Now, why is that the case?

994
01:00:37.683 --> 01:00:38.724
Why is it so hard to prove?

995
01:00:39.244 --> 01:00:41.925
So it has to do with...

996
01:00:43.490 --> 01:00:45.391
measuring DNA methylation.

997
01:00:45.952 --> 01:00:46.192
Okay.

998
01:00:46.352 --> 01:00:46.592
Okay?

999
01:00:46.993 --> 01:00:47.613
How does one...

1000
01:00:48.634 --> 01:00:52.877
If I get a strand of DNA, it's actually very easy to sequence DNA.

1001
01:00:53.417 --> 01:00:53.637
Okay?

1002
01:00:53.657 --> 01:00:53.877
There's...

1003
01:00:54.478 --> 01:00:58.561
Ever since the days of the 1960s and 70s, I mean, we've sequenced the entire human genome.

1004
01:00:58.861 --> 01:01:01.543
Now we've sequenced tens of thousands of human genomes.

1005
01:01:01.563 --> 01:01:02.283
I think it's up to the...

1006
01:01:02.604 --> 01:01:03.905
Even might be millions now.

1007
01:01:04.165 --> 01:01:04.345
So...

1008
01:01:04.605 --> 01:01:08.846
You know, the sequencing DNA is not a big deal because it's distinct.

1009
01:01:09.146 --> 01:01:10.687
A, T, G, C, right?

1010
01:01:10.727 --> 01:01:20.929
There's ways that I can make the A, like, combined with a T that has a little, like, you know, a little GFP tag that, like, lights up a certain color.

1011
01:01:20.949 --> 01:01:23.230
So then, like, every time it's red, I know it's an A.

1012
01:01:23.490 --> 01:01:26.590
Every time it's a G, I know it's green, it's a G, right?

1013
01:01:26.630 --> 01:01:29.251
And, like, there's so many cool sequencing technologies.

1014
01:01:34.240 --> 01:01:55.194
aren't good with methylation okay one way to do it that a lot of people use is bisulfide sequencing okay here's how you do it you take your you take your dna okay you take your dna now your dna is going to have at um atgc's all over some of the c's some of the cytosines is going to have that methyl group

1015
01:01:55.634 --> 01:01:56.634
Those little red pointies.

1016
01:01:56.654 --> 01:01:58.235
Yeah, those little red pointies.

1017
01:01:58.295 --> 01:02:01.036
Here as well, they're little red tags on the Cs, right?

1018
01:02:01.316 --> 01:02:06.138
There's some Cs that are blue, and then there's other Cs you can tell that are not.

1019
01:02:06.438 --> 01:02:09.399
And those are like normal cytosines that aren't methylated, right?

1020
01:02:09.959 --> 01:02:13.700
What you're going to do is you're going to treat it with a detergent, effectively.

1021
01:02:13.780 --> 01:02:20.502
Okay, a chemical treatment that is going to convert unmethylated cytosines into uracils, U's.

1022
01:02:20.962 --> 01:02:22.443
U is the letter that is used in RNA.

1023
01:02:22.463 --> 01:02:22.603
Okay.

1024
01:02:23.063 --> 01:02:23.283
Okay?

1025
01:02:23.864 --> 01:02:30.810
So it's going to leave the cytosines with the methyl alone, but it's going to change the season to use.

1026
01:02:30.910 --> 01:02:31.111
Okay?

1027
01:02:31.351 --> 01:02:32.812
And then I just sequence like normal.

1028
01:02:33.032 --> 01:02:33.233
Right.

1029
01:02:33.613 --> 01:02:34.234
Like I used to.

1030
01:02:34.494 --> 01:02:34.674
Right.

1031
01:02:34.894 --> 01:02:35.134
Okay?

1032
01:02:35.295 --> 01:02:35.495
Right.

1033
01:02:35.555 --> 01:02:36.816
Because I'm good at sequencing.

1034
01:02:36.876 --> 01:02:38.137
I'm not good at the...

1035
01:02:39.298 --> 01:03:07.562
like finding where the methyl is but this is one way right because i've just i've taken all the ones that don't have the methyl groups i've turned them into another letter and then now i just sequence like normal and i'm like oh this is a u the dna shouldn't have a u that's probably where the the c was right or i can like i can i can sequence the original gene and then i can sequence the gene after um treating it with this detergent and wherever the difference is that's where the c's are wherever the c remains that's where the methyl groups are

1036
01:03:08.042 --> 01:03:10.945
Right, and now we know where the methylated cytosine is.

1037
01:03:10.985 --> 01:03:15.209
Yeah, because any cytosine that survived had to have had a methyl group on it.

1038
01:03:15.369 --> 01:03:15.950
That makes sense.

1039
01:03:16.230 --> 01:03:25.799
Which now gives us a different map to analyze that's not just indistinguishable Cs, methylated versus non-methylated.

1040
01:03:26.179 --> 01:03:27.800
Now, you can imagine treating...

1041
01:03:28.863 --> 01:03:54.642
molecule like DNA with chemical is not a good idea okay and of course not because what ends up happening is something called catastrophic DNA degradation here's how sequencing works okay you've got a giant thing of DNA when I treat it with detergent it's gonna break up into short parts okay and I'm gonna get a bunch of different short parts and now I have a combinatoric puzzle to stitch together all of these short parts into a big part right

1042
01:03:55.590 --> 01:03:55.870
Yes.

1043
01:03:56.331 --> 01:04:00.233
The problem is these short reads, they're about 150 bass pairs long, max.

1044
01:04:00.614 --> 01:04:01.294
It's not a lot.

1045
01:04:01.314 --> 01:04:01.694
It's not a lot.

1046
01:04:01.754 --> 01:04:02.015
Okay?

1047
01:04:02.275 --> 01:04:04.156
Because a lot of times nothing happens.

1048
01:04:04.636 --> 01:04:04.877
Okay?

1049
01:04:05.117 --> 01:04:16.385
And so if I've got repetitive sequences of DNA, I could just fool myself into thinking, oh, this is all part of the same sequence rather than this is the first repeat, this is the second repeat.

1050
01:04:16.425 --> 01:04:20.188
It's kind of like, have you seen that like crazy puzzle of the Beatle White album?

1051
01:04:20.328 --> 01:04:20.568
Mm-hmm.

1052
01:04:20.968 --> 01:04:21.168
Right.

1053
01:04:21.188 --> 01:04:24.831
Where it's just it's the Beatles white album and it just says the Beatles with a white.

1054
01:04:25.191 --> 01:04:28.873
And like it's incredibly difficult because everything is white.

1055
01:04:29.274 --> 01:04:35.298
So imagine here, like if I've got repeated sections of DNA, I don't know whether this thing came from this part or this part of this part.

1056
01:04:35.318 --> 01:04:35.538
Right.

1057
01:04:35.698 --> 01:04:36.398
100 percent.

1058
01:04:36.458 --> 01:04:39.260
And some puzzle pieces go together when they're not supposed to be next to each other.

1059
01:04:39.280 --> 01:04:39.460
Yeah.

1060
01:04:39.560 --> 01:04:39.801
Yeah.

1061
01:04:40.101 --> 01:04:40.301
Yeah.

1062
01:04:40.381 --> 01:04:43.303
Because because just, you know, just kind of like.

1063
01:04:43.363 --> 01:04:49.128
Yeah, it's like this side of the puzzle piece goes together, but when you put it together with the rest, the other three parts don't make any sense.

1064
01:04:49.268 --> 01:04:52.211
Yeah, like it's a really incredibly hard puzzle, right?

1065
01:04:52.571 --> 01:04:54.173
So that's one reason why you don't want that.

1066
01:04:54.613 --> 01:04:57.535
The next is loss of allelic phasing, right?

1067
01:04:57.616 --> 01:05:04.001
If I want to study non-Mandelion inheritance, what I'd really like to know is which parent the epigenetic mark came from.

1068
01:05:04.301 --> 01:05:06.864
That's why the maze thing was such a big deal, right?

1069
01:05:06.884 --> 01:05:08.785
Because I could tell what was happening.

1070
01:05:09.066 --> 01:05:10.147
But in order to do that,

1071
01:05:11.068 --> 01:05:19.035
What that requires is each of these short reads to have a mutation from one parent and not from the other.

1072
01:05:19.476 --> 01:05:25.581
It's like, oh, this part is a T. I know that the mom had the T here and not the dad had a C here.

1073
01:05:25.621 --> 01:05:27.163
So I know that this part comes from the mom.

1074
01:05:27.523 --> 01:05:35.430
But if I have short enough reads that are 150, the probability of getting one of these single nucleotide permutations in my short read is very low.

1075
01:05:35.671 --> 01:05:35.811
Mm-hmm.

1076
01:05:36.191 --> 01:05:36.431
Right.

1077
01:05:36.971 --> 01:05:41.874
Because the shorter the thing is, the probability of something going wrong is right, is not that high.

1078
01:05:41.934 --> 01:05:42.094
Right.

1079
01:05:42.234 --> 01:05:45.335
So the methylation could be different between two identical.

1080
01:05:45.595 --> 01:05:47.776
But I don't know which one came from the mom, which one came from the dad.

1081
01:05:47.796 --> 01:05:48.857
That's actually a really good point.

1082
01:05:48.977 --> 01:05:51.298
And that's that's fundamentally.

1083
01:05:51.578 --> 01:05:56.504
Yeah, the whole point of what you're trying to do is you need to be able to make that connection.

1084
01:05:56.524 --> 01:06:01.570
Yeah, I'd like to know which paternal chromosome it came from, from the entire whole genome.

1085
01:06:01.610 --> 01:06:03.332
It's like you have two white puzzles.

1086
01:06:03.453 --> 01:06:06.677
One is the Beatles' White Album, and one is whatever, the White Stripes' White Album.

1087
01:06:06.697 --> 01:06:06.817
Yeah.

1088
01:06:07.257 --> 01:06:08.158
And it's like the white pieces.

1089
01:06:08.178 --> 01:06:10.059
Yeah, and now you're taking the white pieces from the end.

1090
01:06:10.179 --> 01:06:11.199
It's like they're all white.

1091
01:06:11.219 --> 01:06:11.520
Yeah.

1092
01:06:11.820 --> 01:06:13.301
But is this the white out?

1093
01:06:13.341 --> 01:06:14.401
Yes.

1094
01:06:14.421 --> 01:06:15.342
That's exactly right.

1095
01:06:15.362 --> 01:06:16.422
That's a good analogy.

1096
01:06:16.482 --> 01:06:16.843
Exactly.

1097
01:06:16.863 --> 01:06:17.223
Okay.

1098
01:06:17.263 --> 01:06:17.523
Okay.

1099
01:06:17.643 --> 01:06:18.744
So that's been the problem.

1100
01:06:19.064 --> 01:06:19.704
I don't know how to do it.

1101
01:06:19.724 --> 01:06:19.884
Yeah.

1102
01:06:19.904 --> 01:06:30.150
It's like we've been relying on the sequencing technology that gives us the sequence of DNA, but it's not designed for methylation reads.

1103
01:06:30.531 --> 01:06:30.731
Right.

1104
01:06:30.831 --> 01:06:31.191
Right.

1105
01:06:31.311 --> 01:06:34.713
Which is key for us to be able to identify, you know,

1106
01:06:36.360 --> 01:06:40.241
Where we're going to see these mutations that cause the dominant to get suppressed.

1107
01:06:40.261 --> 01:06:40.721
Yeah, yeah.

1108
01:06:40.801 --> 01:06:42.042
And all of this weird shenanigans.

1109
01:06:42.122 --> 01:06:43.082
All the weird stuff we just talked about.

1110
01:06:43.102 --> 01:06:43.702
All the weird stuff.

1111
01:06:43.742 --> 01:06:46.483
It kind of derives, at least in part, from this.

1112
01:06:46.563 --> 01:06:50.144
From understanding which chromosome is the parent, right?

1113
01:06:50.184 --> 01:06:51.764
Which chromatid came from which parent.

1114
01:06:52.024 --> 01:06:52.244
Okay.

1115
01:06:52.684 --> 01:06:55.625
So now we get to why it's happening now.

1116
01:06:55.645 --> 01:06:58.486
The Oxford Nanopore Revolution.

1117
01:06:59.006 --> 01:06:59.266
Okay.

1118
01:06:59.646 --> 01:07:01.587
This is an insanely cool technology.

1119
01:07:01.607 --> 01:07:01.747
Mm-hmm.

1120
01:07:03.270 --> 01:07:03.970
Here's how it works.

1121
01:07:04.530 --> 01:07:04.790
Okay.

1122
01:07:05.431 --> 01:07:07.331
It goes to biophysical detection.

1123
01:07:07.931 --> 01:07:14.553
What you do is you take your native DNA strand and you pass it through a nanopore.

1124
01:07:15.353 --> 01:07:18.674
It's a little hole in a membrane, kind of like ion channels.

1125
01:07:20.374 --> 01:07:27.416
There's a membrane that separates in and out, and then you've got a little hole that's made out of protein that one strand of DNA goes through.

1126
01:07:27.476 --> 01:07:32.357
There's a thing above it that unzips the DNA so that one strand goes this way, one strand goes through.

1127
01:07:32.377 --> 01:07:32.637
Okay.

1128
01:07:32.657 --> 01:07:32.857
Okay.

1129
01:07:33.537 --> 01:07:38.178
And what you're going to do is measure the current across the membrane.

1130
01:07:38.818 --> 01:07:39.078
Okay?

1131
01:07:40.499 --> 01:07:43.339
The current that's going through from this side to this side.

1132
01:07:44.200 --> 01:07:48.221
Now, A, T, G, and C are different molecules.

1133
01:07:48.721 --> 01:07:50.121
They have different sizes.

1134
01:07:50.481 --> 01:07:51.782
They have different little residues.

1135
01:07:51.982 --> 01:07:53.122
They have different shapes.

1136
01:07:53.682 --> 01:08:01.364
And so every time the four goes through, there's going to be a tiny different current for each of the four.

1137
01:08:04.654 --> 01:08:05.414
Isn't that sick?

1138
01:08:05.534 --> 01:08:07.835
I'm so... We're so smart, dude.

1139
01:08:07.935 --> 01:08:09.016
Isn't that so sick?

1140
01:08:09.056 --> 01:08:09.996
That's very clever.

1141
01:08:10.036 --> 01:08:14.938
The visual analogy I sort of think about is like if you unzip the zipper of your jacket, it's like the unzipping of the DNA.

1142
01:08:14.998 --> 01:08:15.098
Yeah.

1143
01:08:15.178 --> 01:08:21.721
And each of these are then going into something that's going to read each segment of four, which is basically just going to have a different fingerprint.

1144
01:08:21.901 --> 01:08:22.281
Exactly.

1145
01:08:22.321 --> 01:08:23.882
Like imagine your zipper.

1146
01:08:23.902 --> 01:08:24.822
Let's go with that analogy.

1147
01:08:24.842 --> 01:08:25.243
I like that.

1148
01:08:25.543 --> 01:08:30.205
Imagine your zipper, but each of those tiny little zip thingies is a different...

1149
01:08:31.145 --> 01:08:32.286
Composition of plastic.

1150
01:08:32.686 --> 01:08:32.946
Okay?

1151
01:08:33.347 --> 01:08:37.430
And so when I go through this, like, little hole, it's going to sound different.

1152
01:08:37.710 --> 01:08:37.930
Right?

1153
01:08:38.511 --> 01:08:41.112
The red plastic is going to sound different from the white plastic.

1154
01:08:41.313 --> 01:08:45.656
And so if I've got a little sound recorder that just records the...

1155
01:08:45.756 --> 01:08:45.936
Right?

1156
01:08:46.436 --> 01:08:48.198
I can then have a computer program.

1157
01:08:49.356 --> 01:08:52.778
decode what type of plastic was the four zipper parts.

1158
01:08:52.878 --> 01:08:53.698
And that's what's happening here.

1159
01:08:53.718 --> 01:08:56.900
And so on the right-hand side, you see the current versus the time.

1160
01:08:57.020 --> 01:08:57.620
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1161
01:08:58.181 --> 01:08:59.681
Completely different signatures.

1162
01:09:00.202 --> 01:09:02.823
And then you've got like, you know, it's probably not even machine learning.

1163
01:09:02.843 --> 01:09:06.585
This is a very simple like computational task to do.

1164
01:09:06.705 --> 01:09:07.546
This is really good.

1165
01:09:07.666 --> 01:09:07.866
Okay.

1166
01:09:08.166 --> 01:09:15.010
Now, this was originally invented for just genome sequencing because A, T, Gs, and Cs, right?

1167
01:09:15.030 --> 01:09:15.490
Yeah.

1168
01:09:15.930 --> 01:09:20.493
But now a C with a methyl group is going to sound even more different.

1169
01:09:20.954 --> 01:09:21.274
Bingo.

1170
01:09:21.714 --> 01:09:22.054
You see?

1171
01:09:22.215 --> 01:09:22.535
Bingo.

1172
01:09:22.615 --> 01:09:22.795
Yeah.

1173
01:09:22.975 --> 01:09:23.415
Makes total sense.

1174
01:09:23.455 --> 01:09:27.458
And so there's just going to be a fifth signature that I have to look for.

1175
01:09:27.658 --> 01:09:28.199
Yep.

1176
01:09:28.459 --> 01:09:30.000
I mean, it makes total sense.

1177
01:09:30.300 --> 01:09:31.041
It makes total sense.

1178
01:09:31.081 --> 01:09:32.222
Why is this advantageous?

1179
01:09:32.502 --> 01:09:34.383
One, you can do ultra-long reads.

1180
01:09:34.403 --> 01:09:36.204
You're not treating the thing with detergent.

1181
01:09:36.445 --> 01:09:36.645
Right.

1182
01:09:37.305 --> 01:09:37.525
Right?

1183
01:09:38.826 --> 01:09:43.309
You just stick this thing through, and you can get hundreds of thousands of base pairs.

1184
01:09:43.329 --> 01:09:49.113
We're going from 150 to now several orders of magnitude of how long you can make the read, right?

1185
01:09:49.293 --> 01:09:56.197
So it's like, you know when sometimes you go to the Airbnb and you open the puzzle box and half of it's done?

1186
01:09:56.698 --> 01:09:57.578
So you're like, yo!

1187
01:09:59.219 --> 01:09:59.499
Right?

1188
01:09:59.980 --> 01:10:02.841
Because then you can post it on Instagram like two hours later.

1189
01:10:02.901 --> 01:10:05.702
I did it.

1190
01:10:05.923 --> 01:10:28.074
It's a really interesting note, though, that through this biophysical detection method, which again was used for sequencing, the point is because we understood the methylation process in and of itself, you could then extrapolate that the C in this biophysical detection is going to just have, again, that slightly different fingerprint.

1191
01:10:28.294 --> 01:10:30.475
And that's all you need to look for now.

1192
01:10:30.915 --> 01:10:36.117
And again, just this narrow... And again, now being able to sequence longer... Yeah, it's huge.

1193
01:10:36.297 --> 01:10:41.419
Gets back to this chromatid... Yeah, because now you've got a longer sequence.

1194
01:10:41.639 --> 01:10:46.241
In 100,000 base pairs, you're going to be able to identify which one came from the mom and which one came from the dad.

1195
01:10:46.481 --> 01:10:46.601
100%.

1196
01:10:48.510 --> 01:10:49.070
Isn't that sick?

1197
01:10:49.170 --> 01:10:56.455
And the thing is, this Oxford nanopore evolution was not necessarily for methylation detection.

1198
01:10:56.675 --> 01:10:58.396
It's just someone was like, wait a minute.

1199
01:10:58.456 --> 01:11:01.277
Yeah, the physics works out here, right?

1200
01:11:01.898 --> 01:11:09.762
It's called Oxford nanopore detection because it was a technology licensed by Oxford nanopore technologies of Oxford, UK.

1201
01:11:10.183 --> 01:11:14.485
They licensed the patent, but the patent actually is a University of California patent.

1202
01:11:15.326 --> 01:11:34.144
It was developed in UC Davis and UC Santa Cruz The fundamental research comes from David Deamer He started in UC Davis and then Santa Cruz poached him He's like, yeah, I'll go live in Santa Cruz Santa Cruz is kind of nice It's kind of nice And I really do think that this is something that is Nobel Prize worthy

1203
01:11:34.464 --> 01:11:40.891
Because it is now the foremost way of not just doing methylation, but also just sequencing DNA, right?

1204
01:11:40.911 --> 01:11:41.291
In general.

1205
01:11:41.512 --> 01:11:45.336
In general, like this is now, it's super fast because you go, right?

1206
01:11:45.376 --> 01:11:47.478
And then have a computer just read the whole thing.

1207
01:11:48.078 --> 01:11:50.821
And these ultra-long reads are just good...

1208
01:11:51.642 --> 01:12:14.027
regardless right right for any number of contexts where we have a specific focus for this episode but the applications the applications are endless and and um oxford nanoport technologies they created something called a mini on sequencing device it's like a tabletop sequencing device so you can just like have it it it's not like the giant machines that you used to be it's just a tabletop just stick your pipette in and then it'll just do the thingy

1209
01:12:14.407 --> 01:12:22.037
Is it analogous maybe to the sort of the phase shift from vacuum tubes to like desktop personal computer or desktop to mobile?

1210
01:12:22.218 --> 01:12:26.263
Yeah, I would say like desktop to like laptop.

1211
01:12:26.283 --> 01:12:27.044
Okay, desktop to laptop.

1212
01:12:27.064 --> 01:12:27.625
You know what I mean?

1213
01:12:27.645 --> 01:12:29.748
Because laptop I can now like go anywhere.

1214
01:12:29.768 --> 01:12:31.470
I don't have to be plugged into a wall somewhere.

1215
01:12:31.630 --> 01:12:33.311
Exactly, and things like that.

1216
01:12:33.631 --> 01:12:35.312
And so I think it's a very big deal.

1217
01:12:35.493 --> 01:12:43.538
And they actually took one to the International Space Station because they do weird genetics experiments up there with plants and how they deal with microgravity.

1218
01:12:43.558 --> 01:12:43.938
It makes sense.

1219
01:12:44.138 --> 01:12:45.019
It makes sense, right?

1220
01:12:45.059 --> 01:12:46.560
How does bacteria deal with microgravity?

1221
01:12:46.580 --> 01:12:53.184
Because ultimately, if you want to extend life to several years in space, you need to understand how...

1222
01:12:53.364 --> 01:12:57.707
Does the genetics at the molecular biology level, do they care?

1223
01:12:58.107 --> 01:12:59.148
Probably they shouldn't,

1224
01:12:59.588 --> 01:13:04.490
Because the gravitational potential difference between, like, one end of the cell and the other shouldn't be that much.

1225
01:13:04.550 --> 01:13:05.970
But, you know, you never know with biology.

1226
01:13:05.990 --> 01:13:06.290
Right, right.

1227
01:13:06.410 --> 01:13:06.670
Right.

1228
01:13:06.690 --> 01:13:07.050
You got to.

1229
01:13:07.511 --> 01:13:08.771
Is the factory going to shut down?

1230
01:13:08.791 --> 01:13:09.151
Yeah.

1231
01:13:09.171 --> 01:13:13.693
Like, just because I took out, like, a tiny bit of wind, effectively.

1232
01:13:13.793 --> 01:13:13.993
Right.

1233
01:13:14.553 --> 01:13:15.733
That's, like, going in one direction.

1234
01:13:15.973 --> 01:13:19.494
So the ISS is using a mini ion sequencing device on it.

1235
01:13:19.554 --> 01:13:20.255
That's really cool.

1236
01:13:20.395 --> 01:13:20.515
Yeah.

1237
01:13:20.535 --> 01:13:20.695
Yeah.

1238
01:13:21.535 --> 01:13:24.838
So now finally, with this, we can get to the paper at hand.

1239
01:13:25.258 --> 01:13:26.099
An hour in.

1240
01:13:26.319 --> 01:13:26.520
Yes.

1241
01:13:26.620 --> 01:13:27.821
An hour into our episode.

1242
01:13:27.861 --> 01:13:29.542
This is the paper that we were talking about.

1243
01:13:29.602 --> 01:13:29.822
Okay.

1244
01:13:29.882 --> 01:13:33.586
Non-Mendelian inheritance of DNA methylation patterns in mice.

1245
01:13:33.646 --> 01:13:34.787
It was out in Nature Genetics.

1246
01:13:35.147 --> 01:13:36.508
It was during my paternity break.

1247
01:13:36.548 --> 01:13:38.150
And I was like, oh, this is really cool.

1248
01:13:38.330 --> 01:13:43.995
But now I can read that title and understand why this is a big deal.

1249
01:13:44.435 --> 01:13:44.875
That's right.

1250
01:13:44.895 --> 01:13:45.335
You miss me?

1251
01:13:45.516 --> 01:13:45.836
Yeah.

1252
01:13:45.876 --> 01:13:48.657
Like this is, ladies and gentlemen, the greatest.

1253
01:13:48.837 --> 01:13:49.997
This is why it's the greatest.

1254
01:13:50.017 --> 01:13:53.199
But like, and it's important because these words have meaning.

1255
01:13:53.299 --> 01:13:53.459
Yeah.

1256
01:13:53.479 --> 01:13:56.580
A lot of times people see these titles and they're just like, ah, it's just big words.

1257
01:13:56.600 --> 01:13:56.700
Yeah.

1258
01:13:56.720 --> 01:13:57.501
They don't mean anything.

1259
01:13:57.521 --> 01:13:59.802
There's actually real, even in this short title.

1260
01:13:59.822 --> 01:14:00.942
Even in the short title, you get it.

1261
01:14:01.082 --> 01:14:04.544
And it's in mice, not transgenic mice, not like special mice, just mice.

1262
01:14:05.084 --> 01:14:06.125
Just plain old mice.

1263
01:14:06.145 --> 01:14:07.227
That's why it's very important.

1264
01:14:07.647 --> 01:14:08.849
He's doing it in mammals, right?

1265
01:14:08.889 --> 01:14:10.732
Because this is from the 2006 one.

1266
01:14:10.752 --> 01:14:13.435
This is basically the next stage, the next development there.

1267
01:14:13.776 --> 01:14:14.817
Yeah.

1268
01:14:15.117 --> 01:14:17.921
One of the key authors, Andrew Feinberg, he's from Johns Hopkins, okay?

1269
01:14:18.202 --> 01:14:21.486
He has a career in disease genetics and epigenomics.

1270
01:14:21.506 --> 01:14:21.866
He's like...

1271
01:14:22.467 --> 01:14:25.469
One of the epigenomics guys at the conferences, right?

1272
01:14:25.769 --> 01:14:28.131
Like that's like giving the presidential lecture or whatever.

1273
01:14:29.011 --> 01:14:35.995
And then David Threadgill at Texas A&amp;M, he's been studying human-like complex genetics in mice.

1274
01:14:36.436 --> 01:14:42.359
So they decided that they wanted to collaborate about 10 years ago trying to study epigenomics in the mouse model.

1275
01:14:42.740 --> 01:14:45.801
And they're trying to compare methylation patterns in response to diet.

1276
01:14:46.922 --> 01:14:48.184
in these inbred strains.

1277
01:14:48.264 --> 01:14:59.099
And they realize that in order to do that, what they really want to observe is allele-specific epigenomics, meaning this allele came from the mom, this allele came from the dad, how is the methylation changing, all of that kind of stuff.

1278
01:14:59.593 --> 01:15:05.715
Which this methodology we just talked about before is an enabling layer to that specific research question.

1279
01:15:05.775 --> 01:15:06.415
Exactly, yeah.

1280
01:15:06.756 --> 01:15:09.156
And so now we can start doing that.

1281
01:15:09.216 --> 01:15:12.337
The model that they chose was something called the collaborative cross model.

1282
01:15:13.118 --> 01:15:20.060
This is key here because what this collaborative cross mouse model is, is it's derived from eight distinct founder strains.

1283
01:15:20.360 --> 01:15:24.422
So the founder strains are kind of like your P generation in the Mendels, like the true breeding.

1284
01:15:25.082 --> 01:15:27.843
But because now you're combining these eight different

1285
01:15:29.178 --> 01:15:31.600
models, you get a lot of genetic diversity.

1286
01:15:31.980 --> 01:15:33.742
And so it's much more closer.

1287
01:15:33.882 --> 01:15:37.565
It's much closer to like, you know, normal organisms.

1288
01:15:38.205 --> 01:15:42.709
But they're still lab in the sense that I still have very nice sequencing data about them.

1289
01:15:42.729 --> 01:15:46.172
So I can still do very nice nitty gritty comparisons.

1290
01:15:46.632 --> 01:16:00.893
Okay, so that's the strains they use the specifically one the strains that they use with the CC 019 and the CC 037 those are the two specific like sort of F2 or in this case like FN generations right there's so many that you can make.

1291
01:16:01.574 --> 01:16:04.216
And the experimental design is actually quite simple.

1292
01:16:04.256 --> 01:16:07.097
It's kind of like Mendelian experiments, okay?

1293
01:16:07.457 --> 01:16:20.685
What you do is you take your CC019 and your CC037, those lines, very well established what the epigenetic markers are there and what the genetics are there.

1294
01:16:21.005 --> 01:16:26.008
So even though they're not like true reading in a sense, you have a good understanding of what the genetics are.

1295
01:16:26.348 --> 01:16:28.929
Now you cross them and then you cross those again, right?

1296
01:16:29.109 --> 01:16:29.970
Just like in Mendel's.

1297
01:16:30.610 --> 01:16:48.043
experiments but in this case what we're looking at is the methylation pattern on the chromatin instead of the actual genetic sequence okay so the genetic sequences could be the same but depending on whether this chromatin came from the mom this one came from the dad all of these things are now going to start changing

1298
01:16:48.683 --> 01:16:48.923
Okay.

1299
01:16:50.004 --> 01:16:56.006
This is very, and it, and it makes sense now why it would be changing one, because we understand the sex chromosome.

1300
01:16:56.026 --> 01:17:01.349
So you get one from each two, because the methylation is going to change what proteins are actually produced or what's suppressed.

1301
01:17:01.769 --> 01:17:08.512
And so now with all of that understanding and background and context and the ability to actually, um,

1302
01:17:09.152 --> 01:17:14.878
detect and sequence the methylated C. Nice.

1303
01:17:15.319 --> 01:17:19.423
Like that is – they can now do real statistical analysis.

1304
01:17:19.443 --> 01:17:19.863
Exactly.

1305
01:17:19.903 --> 01:17:25.109
That's meaningful in this because they've done the mice work.

1306
01:17:25.409 --> 01:17:26.671
They've done all the other background work.

1307
01:17:27.331 --> 01:17:28.773
Anyway, so that – It's very, very cool.

1308
01:17:28.793 --> 01:17:29.854
It's all kind of just –

1309
01:17:30.154 --> 01:17:36.816
And one final thing that I want to mention before we get into the results is, again, about methods, because we do want to focus on methods in this.

1310
01:17:37.136 --> 01:17:42.997
So we've got the mouse models of CC19 and CC37.

1311
01:17:43.537 --> 01:17:53.560
Now, when you sequence the offspring's DNA, right, usually when you want to put together, even when you've got these long reads, you've got to have a reference genome to put stuff together to.

1312
01:17:53.860 --> 01:17:57.561
But we don't really have a reference genome for the offspring of these two genes.

1313
01:17:58.001 --> 01:17:58.621
lines, right?

1314
01:17:59.002 --> 01:18:05.525
And it's not great to just use one or the other, because you really, you're going to have to have like some middle ground.

1315
01:18:05.685 --> 01:18:11.168
And so one thing that I do want to talk about is like in traditional bioinformatics pipelines, right?

1316
01:18:11.708 --> 01:18:17.411
You've got these, and I think photo 30 will show that in a traditional bioinformatics pipeline, right?

1317
01:18:17.431 --> 01:18:26.015
You've got fragmented DNA, even if they're long, you sequence the DNA, then you get all these unaligned sequences, and then you try to align those sequences to a reference genome.

1318
01:18:26.395 --> 01:18:26.635
Okay.

1319
01:18:26.915 --> 01:18:36.157
And the reference genome is something that you get, like if you've got a human genetics, right, you've got the human genome project and you align your own DNA to that because there's not going to be that many differences.

1320
01:18:36.217 --> 01:18:36.397
Right.

1321
01:18:36.678 --> 01:18:39.978
But here, those tiny differences are going to matter in this study.

1322
01:18:40.298 --> 01:18:40.478
Right.

1323
01:18:40.739 --> 01:18:46.320
And so what they did was they actually solved it by constructing a pseudo hybrid intermediate genome.

1324
01:18:46.700 --> 01:18:56.923
Which is, I think, very cool that they were careful enough to create this kind of custom software that constructs a synthetic reference genome for every single cross.

1325
01:18:57.523 --> 01:19:03.165
And it includes all of the strain-specific insertions of the parent genomes.

1326
01:19:03.545 --> 01:19:06.206
But it's like unbiased analysis of what the...

1327
01:19:07.666 --> 01:19:11.207
what the kids are going to be showing in terms of methylation.

1328
01:19:11.327 --> 01:19:17.989
And this is important because, again, that reference genome is – otherwise you're kind of – you have literally no reference.

1329
01:19:18.009 --> 01:19:18.469
Yeah, exactly.

1330
01:19:18.489 --> 01:19:19.369
And then it's impossible.

1331
01:19:19.409 --> 01:19:21.010
But you can't use one or the other.

1332
01:19:21.030 --> 01:19:22.490
You've got to use this like hybrid.

1333
01:19:22.510 --> 01:19:22.910
Hybrid of both.

1334
01:19:22.930 --> 01:19:24.311
And so they were careful enough to do that.

1335
01:19:24.371 --> 01:19:25.231
I thought that was quite cool.

1336
01:19:25.251 --> 01:19:28.412
That's an important – again, shows they're really trying to –

1337
01:19:29.512 --> 01:19:35.035
do it in a robust fashion, especially also from a replication perspective.

1338
01:19:35.235 --> 01:19:35.895
Exactly, yeah.

1339
01:19:36.115 --> 01:19:38.657
So now we can finally get to the results figures, okay?

1340
01:19:39.037 --> 01:19:41.478
So let's talk about the control, okay?

1341
01:19:41.798 --> 01:19:44.620
So Mendelian baseline.

1342
01:19:44.660 --> 01:19:49.942
93% of the time, the epigenetics is doing what Mendel's laws say.

1343
01:19:50.843 --> 01:19:53.224
Here's how we're going to read these figures, okay?

1344
01:19:53.264 --> 01:19:55.165
All of the subsequent figures are going to be the same way.

1345
01:19:57.617 --> 01:20:01.951
So the pink is coming from the mom.

1346
01:20:02.452 --> 01:20:03.656
The green is coming from the dad.

1347
01:20:04.839 --> 01:20:14.161
What we're looking at on the y-axis is the percent methylation, the amount of methyl methylation, meaning how much of the Cs have a methyl attached to it.

1348
01:20:14.341 --> 01:20:14.982
Okay?

1349
01:20:15.062 --> 01:20:17.542
100% would mean every single C has a methyl group attached.

1350
01:20:17.602 --> 01:20:21.843
Zero means none of the Cs have a methyl attached.

1351
01:20:22.223 --> 01:20:22.403
Right?

1352
01:20:23.044 --> 01:20:27.305
And what we're looking at on the x-axis is just along the DNA.

1353
01:20:27.865 --> 01:20:28.105
Okay?

1354
01:20:28.485 --> 01:20:31.906
So along the DNA, you can see that there's a certain region

1355
01:20:32.746 --> 01:20:37.988
where the mom has almost no methyl groups attached to the C's, and the dad has a bunch.

1356
01:20:38.588 --> 01:20:38.828
Okay?

1357
01:20:39.469 --> 01:20:48.372
The solid green lines and the solid purple lines are the parent generation, and then there's dotted green lines and dotted purple lines for the kids.

1358
01:20:49.072 --> 01:20:57.716
The key thing to see here is that the dotted green is on top of the solid green, and the dotted purple is on top of the solid purple, meaning...

1359
01:21:00.129 --> 01:21:04.710
The methyl pattern of the kids is the same as the moms or the dads.

1360
01:21:04.730 --> 01:21:05.431
Nothing's changed.

1361
01:21:05.571 --> 01:21:05.751
Right.

1362
01:21:05.791 --> 01:21:06.911
Like I got the chromatin.

1363
01:21:07.332 --> 01:21:08.112
I got the methyl.

1364
01:21:08.632 --> 01:21:09.272
Nothing changed.

1365
01:21:09.512 --> 01:21:10.913
Nothing weird happened in between.

1366
01:21:10.953 --> 01:21:12.394
So this is the Mendelian baseline.

1367
01:21:12.614 --> 01:21:12.814
Yes.

1368
01:21:12.994 --> 01:21:13.214
Okay.

1369
01:21:13.414 --> 01:21:21.297
And they actually use two different tissues from the liver and from the muscle to see how like if there's any organ dependent effects that are happening.

1370
01:21:21.397 --> 01:21:21.658
All right.

1371
01:21:21.678 --> 01:21:22.678
That's actually good.

1372
01:21:22.918 --> 01:21:23.398
Yeah.

1373
01:21:23.478 --> 01:21:23.758
Yeah.

1374
01:21:23.858 --> 01:21:24.819
So this is like normal.

1375
01:21:25.379 --> 01:21:25.639
Okay?

1376
01:21:25.659 --> 01:21:28.902
This is something that we thought should happen every single time.

1377
01:21:29.102 --> 01:21:29.302
Yes.

1378
01:21:30.103 --> 01:21:30.363
All right.

1379
01:21:30.403 --> 01:21:32.245
Now let's look at our first anomaly.

1380
01:21:32.325 --> 01:21:37.309
And because what we're saying is 93% of the time Mendelian genetics holds up.

1381
01:21:37.830 --> 01:21:37.970
Yeah.

1382
01:21:37.990 --> 01:21:40.832
But there's this 7% outlier where it doesn't.

1383
01:21:41.413 --> 01:21:43.675
And that's what... And that's... That's weird.

1384
01:21:43.835 --> 01:21:44.035
Yeah.

1385
01:21:44.535 --> 01:21:45.516
And that's where the weirdness is.

1386
01:21:45.576 --> 01:21:45.817
Okay?

1387
01:21:46.177 --> 01:21:48.899
Now let's look at non-dominant transacting...

1388
01:21:52.423 --> 01:21:54.286
So methylated, what is it?

1389
01:21:54.767 --> 01:21:56.108
Something, QTLs.

1390
01:21:56.249 --> 01:21:57.791
I forget what the full form is.

1391
01:21:57.831 --> 01:21:59.313
But the ME is the methylated part.

1392
01:21:59.333 --> 01:21:59.894
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1393
01:21:59.934 --> 01:22:00.154
Okay?

1394
01:22:00.395 --> 01:22:07.445
Here, what we're looking at is, let's look at the liver, which is the first figure, the first sort of middle figure, okay?

1395
01:22:07.805 --> 01:22:08.226
At the top.

1396
01:22:09.096 --> 01:22:12.558
Over there, what you're seeing is the top line is the pink solid.

1397
01:22:13.078 --> 01:22:15.239
The bottom line is the green solid.

1398
01:22:15.539 --> 01:22:18.521
So that's the mom methylation and the dad methylation.

1399
01:22:18.541 --> 01:22:21.602
You can see the mom has a lot of methylation in this region.

1400
01:22:22.162 --> 01:22:24.403
The dad has almost no methylation in this region.

1401
01:22:24.423 --> 01:22:25.764
Which is an invert of what we just like.

1402
01:22:25.844 --> 01:22:26.324
Yeah, yeah.

1403
01:22:26.564 --> 01:22:29.466
But that's not what's important because this part of the gene might be different.

1404
01:22:29.926 --> 01:22:33.809
What's important is the dotted lines are all in the middle.

1405
01:22:33.829 --> 01:22:35.590
They're not coinciding to one or the other.

1406
01:22:36.111 --> 01:22:41.775
Meaning that I got the DNA from them, but then the methyl parts are half and half.

1407
01:22:41.795 --> 01:22:42.375
They're blended.

1408
01:22:42.395 --> 01:22:43.036
They're blended.

1409
01:22:43.056 --> 01:22:43.716
They're blended.

1410
01:22:43.756 --> 01:22:44.237
That's fascinating.

1411
01:22:44.257 --> 01:22:45.337
That's non-Mendelian.

1412
01:22:45.778 --> 01:22:46.798
That's what we're looking at, okay?

1413
01:22:46.818 --> 01:22:47.319
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1414
01:22:47.339 --> 01:22:49.781
The offspring, some of the methylation is there.

1415
01:22:49.941 --> 01:22:51.102
Some of the methylation is not.

1416
01:22:51.142 --> 01:22:51.662
That's interesting.

1417
01:22:51.702 --> 01:22:52.403
Some of the...

1418
01:22:53.203 --> 01:22:56.584
Some of the female chromosome is getting more methylated.

1419
01:22:56.784 --> 01:22:57.264
Or sorry, no.

1420
01:22:57.304 --> 01:22:59.265
Some of the female chromosome is getting less methylated.

1421
01:22:59.525 --> 01:23:01.746
And some of the male chromosome is getting more methylated.

1422
01:23:02.206 --> 01:23:05.327
Yeah, because based on where they are, they're in.

1423
01:23:05.987 --> 01:23:08.308
Again, the male is the one that almost has none.

1424
01:23:08.668 --> 01:23:11.249
But the offspring are blended.

1425
01:23:11.289 --> 01:23:13.470
And so that's why the dotted lines are all in the middle.

1426
01:23:13.490 --> 01:23:13.850
In the middle.

1427
01:23:13.970 --> 01:23:16.050
So you're going to be higher and the opposite.

1428
01:23:16.591 --> 01:23:17.511
Very interesting.

1429
01:23:17.571 --> 01:23:17.871
Okay.

1430
01:23:18.051 --> 01:23:18.291
Okay.

1431
01:23:18.531 --> 01:23:18.851
Okay.

1432
01:23:18.951 --> 01:23:19.912
Now let's go to the next one.

1433
01:23:19.932 --> 01:23:20.152
Yes.

1434
01:23:20.192 --> 01:23:20.792
This one's weird.

1435
01:23:21.392 --> 01:23:23.455
This is the CAPN11 gene.

1436
01:23:24.557 --> 01:23:28.763
What we're looking at here is effectively paramutation.

1437
01:23:29.404 --> 01:23:29.705
Okay.

1438
01:23:30.025 --> 01:23:30.306
Okay.

1439
01:23:32.249 --> 01:23:35.053
So in this one, in this particular region,

1440
01:23:36.981 --> 01:23:40.364
The mom has, let's say, intermediate methylation.

1441
01:23:40.524 --> 01:23:43.066
The solid pink line is like 50%.

1442
01:23:43.566 --> 01:23:45.768
The dad is all the way down to like 10%.

1443
01:23:46.189 --> 01:23:50.112
Okay, those are the solid green line that's way down there in that highlighted region.

1444
01:23:50.472 --> 01:23:51.293
And the mom is down.

1445
01:23:51.613 --> 01:23:53.415
There's a dip, but it's only 50%.

1446
01:23:54.455 --> 01:23:59.900
The dotted pink line and the dotted green line are all on top of the green.

1447
01:24:01.631 --> 01:24:06.216
None of the mom's effects of methylation have come through in the subsequent offspring.

1448
01:24:06.696 --> 01:24:07.837
Okay, so that's that top part.

1449
01:24:08.418 --> 01:24:11.861
Now let's look at the F2 generation, okay, which is in the bottom.

1450
01:24:12.322 --> 01:24:15.165
Every single offspring has the methylation pattern of the dad.

1451
01:24:16.648 --> 01:24:19.449
It's like the mom's methylate, like obviously the genes are there.

1452
01:24:19.649 --> 01:24:19.849
Right.

1453
01:24:19.929 --> 01:24:22.530
But the mom's methylation pattern is completely gone.

1454
01:24:22.550 --> 01:24:25.671
The mom's epigenetics have been completely silenced.

1455
01:24:25.871 --> 01:24:27.552
In both F1 and F2?

1456
01:24:27.632 --> 01:24:28.192
Yes.

1457
01:24:28.572 --> 01:24:30.493
And in F2, subsequently, yes.

1458
01:24:30.693 --> 01:24:31.293
Yeah.

1459
01:24:31.313 --> 01:24:35.014
F2 is there to show that like whatever happened to F1, it didn't recover.

1460
01:24:35.255 --> 01:24:35.495
Right.

1461
01:24:35.775 --> 01:24:36.275
Right.

1462
01:24:36.375 --> 01:24:41.777
Whatever happened in that first generation, the grandkids now just get no influence from the mom's epigenetics.

1463
01:24:41.997 --> 01:24:44.778
All of the epigenetic influence is coming from the dad.

1464
01:24:45.698 --> 01:24:47.078
In this particular allele.

1465
01:24:47.118 --> 01:24:47.819
Right, right, right.

1466
01:24:48.079 --> 01:24:48.299
Right?

1467
01:24:48.459 --> 01:24:48.679
Right.

1468
01:24:49.139 --> 01:24:50.059
This is very weird.

1469
01:24:50.119 --> 01:24:50.979
This is very weird.

1470
01:24:50.999 --> 01:24:54.280
This is something that we saw in the maze, right?

1471
01:24:54.360 --> 01:24:54.520
Right.

1472
01:24:54.540 --> 01:25:01.762
Where it's like, even when I crossed the purple with the green, the grandkids all were all green.

1473
01:25:01.882 --> 01:25:05.123
This is the suppression thing we talked about there.

1474
01:25:05.243 --> 01:25:07.683
Now the allele is completely suppressed.

1475
01:25:07.803 --> 01:25:09.864
And so now we're seeing this in animals as well.

1476
01:25:09.884 --> 01:25:14.705
We'd seen it in the maze before, but now we're seeing it in more complex biology.

1477
01:25:15.385 --> 01:25:17.507
which is fascinating.

1478
01:25:18.087 --> 01:25:22.871
And there are some very cool consequences of this that we'll talk about at the very end, okay?

1479
01:25:23.692 --> 01:25:30.737
The last few figures that I want to talk about, this next one, figure number 34, this is, I think, figure 6 and 7.

1480
01:25:31.098 --> 01:25:33.880
This shows some emergent epigenetic patterns.

1481
01:25:34.060 --> 01:25:37.183
Again, the main thing to see is that the dotted...

1482
01:25:37.803 --> 01:25:42.947
pink and green lines are different from the solid ones.

1483
01:25:43.367 --> 01:25:49.972
The one on the left, figure six, that shows something very weird, which is that the offspring sometimes just have more methylation than either of the parents.

1484
01:25:51.013 --> 01:25:53.414
So that, I don't even know how that got there.

1485
01:25:53.495 --> 01:25:55.096
And neither of your parents got there.

1486
01:25:55.116 --> 01:25:58.038
It's not even a blend or one of the parents is dominant over the other.

1487
01:25:58.058 --> 01:25:59.679
Which would make almost more sense?

1488
01:25:59.699 --> 01:26:00.299
Yeah, yeah.

1489
01:26:00.380 --> 01:26:01.140
This one's just like...

1490
01:26:01.580 --> 01:26:02.021
This doesn't.

1491
01:26:02.061 --> 01:26:04.823
Yeah, that's why they're calling it emergent epigenetic.

1492
01:26:04.963 --> 01:26:06.144
You know, it's just like...

1493
01:26:06.724 --> 01:26:07.424
Put it in that bin.

1494
01:26:07.464 --> 01:26:09.025
Yeah, we'll come back to that later.

1495
01:26:09.085 --> 01:26:09.685
Yeah, yeah.

1496
01:26:09.725 --> 01:26:13.126
It's like this happens, and we report it.

1497
01:26:13.146 --> 01:26:15.867
So now you've got a science.

1498
01:26:15.967 --> 01:26:18.548
And then on the right-hand side, we've got genomic imprinting.

1499
01:26:19.068 --> 01:26:25.010
This is, again, this is similar to the mom and dad thing, but here.

1500
01:26:25.410 --> 01:26:28.531
So in the mom and dad one, it didn't actually matter.

1501
01:26:30.235 --> 01:26:37.057
which chromosome, if the allele came from the mom or if the allele came from the dad.

1502
01:26:37.357 --> 01:26:41.138
Because both sets of alleles, if they were from the mom or the dad, it was allele-specific.

1503
01:26:41.518 --> 01:26:43.559
Here, it's actually mom and dad-specific.

1504
01:26:43.839 --> 01:26:49.341
It's a process where certain genes are expressed in a parent-of-origin-specific manner.

1505
01:26:49.601 --> 01:26:52.782
In this case, the epigenetics is expressed in a parent-of-origin manner.

1506
01:26:53.222 --> 01:26:53.482
Okay?

1507
01:26:54.002 --> 01:26:56.443
So, if the methylation is with the mom...

1508
01:26:57.323 --> 01:27:00.825
Only then is there going to be methylation in the kid.

1509
01:27:01.746 --> 01:27:02.026
Okay?

1510
01:27:03.007 --> 01:27:04.888
It doesn't matter what type of allele it is.

1511
01:27:05.729 --> 01:27:07.070
Which is actually an important distinction.

1512
01:27:07.090 --> 01:27:08.070
Yeah.

1513
01:27:08.090 --> 01:27:10.612
So it's a parent of origin...

1514
01:27:12.174 --> 01:27:20.657
So there can both be allele-specific divergence in methylation in the FN generations.

1515
01:27:21.617 --> 01:27:25.819
And that can be true on top of the fact that there's this genomic imprint.

1516
01:27:26.099 --> 01:27:26.339
Yeah.

1517
01:27:26.359 --> 01:27:28.319
They're not necessarily independently true.

1518
01:27:28.960 --> 01:27:29.160
Yeah.

1519
01:27:30.400 --> 01:27:32.381
So it's super, super, super...

1520
01:27:33.413 --> 01:27:33.893
complex.

1521
01:27:33.953 --> 01:27:38.436
Yeah, because the combinatorics becomes quite difficult.

1522
01:27:38.516 --> 01:27:40.778
The last one I thought was actually really, really cool.

1523
01:27:42.059 --> 01:27:51.444
I mean, I think all of this stuff is really, really cool, but here what we're seeing is a difference in one organ-dependent methylation.

1524
01:27:52.185 --> 01:27:54.827
So the same region in the liver versus the muscle.

1525
01:27:54.847 --> 01:27:59.269
The muscle has about 80% methylation in both males and females.

1526
01:28:00.330 --> 01:28:01.191
And in the liver, the

1527
01:28:01.851 --> 01:28:07.134
The males have 80% methylation, but the females have something like 50% methylation.

1528
01:28:07.154 --> 01:28:07.934
This is crazy.

1529
01:28:08.014 --> 01:28:09.835
Highly significant difference.

1530
01:28:09.855 --> 01:28:10.535
This is crazy.

1531
01:28:10.635 --> 01:28:10.875
Okay.

1532
01:28:10.915 --> 01:28:15.758
So you can also have divergence across organs and on top of sex.

1533
01:28:16.018 --> 01:28:17.078
Now, why is this important?

1534
01:28:17.538 --> 01:28:22.281
This was found, so it's hypermethylated in females and then not that much in males, right?

1535
01:28:22.301 --> 01:28:23.101
Yeah.

1536
01:28:23.241 --> 01:28:23.962
Why is this important?

1537
01:28:23.982 --> 01:28:25.723
Well, it's found exclusively in the liver.

1538
01:28:25.823 --> 01:28:26.684
What does the liver do?

1539
01:28:26.744 --> 01:28:36.953
One of the big things that the liver does is dictate tissue-specific, like, it dictates hormonal environments.

1540
01:28:37.654 --> 01:28:40.496
It dictates how drugs are detoxified.

1541
01:28:41.056 --> 01:28:41.337
So...

1542
01:28:42.432 --> 01:28:49.062
This could be one of the main reasons why certain drugs work one way in one sex and then not in another sex.

1543
01:28:49.302 --> 01:28:49.583
Yeah.

1544
01:28:49.663 --> 01:28:49.863
Right?

1545
01:28:50.023 --> 01:28:50.204
Right.

1546
01:28:50.764 --> 01:28:51.986
Because that's a known effect.

1547
01:28:52.086 --> 01:28:52.267
Right.

1548
01:28:52.487 --> 01:28:53.749
That's kind of mysterious.

1549
01:28:53.929 --> 01:28:54.089
Right.

1550
01:28:54.129 --> 01:28:54.790
This could be it.

1551
01:28:55.513 --> 01:28:59.294
Like the epigenetics is different in the liver, but not in other places.

1552
01:28:59.314 --> 01:29:14.258
That's a really important potential insight among many in this is that there is this organ-specific epigenetic difference in methylation in the liver, which would affect drug delivery.

1553
01:29:14.278 --> 01:29:14.378
Yeah.

1554
01:29:15.838 --> 01:29:39.553
um yeah and drug like like efficacy efficacy yeah right right right kind of crazy i yeah oh my i'm thinking about so many things but i i want to be not we will talk for the next three hours i mean obviously this has very deep implications that's that's right that's the main headline and um what it's really saying is look future clinical genetics

1555
01:29:40.705 --> 01:29:45.067
is now going to need to focus on genetics and epigenetic risk.

1556
01:29:45.807 --> 01:29:53.171
Okay, if we want to start charting, you know, like how an individual's genome is going to affect their life and so on and so forth, right?

1557
01:29:53.531 --> 01:29:57.773
There's also some very cool just like fundamental science things that are happening here.

1558
01:29:59.074 --> 01:30:03.177
that have to do with, for example, evolution, the foundational science of evolution.

1559
01:30:03.657 --> 01:30:07.400
There used to be this theory called the Waddington's theory of genetic assimilation.

1560
01:30:07.761 --> 01:30:13.005
Basically, it's saying that environmentally induced traits can become hard-coded into the DNA.

1561
01:30:13.305 --> 01:30:14.846
This is not very Darwinian.

1562
01:30:14.866 --> 01:30:20.651
Darwinian is just natural selection, survival of the fittest.

1563
01:30:21.111 --> 01:30:22.853
It's like the offspring get a random assortment.

1564
01:30:23.653 --> 01:30:25.455
And then they live their lives.

1565
01:30:25.615 --> 01:30:29.818
And then if they survive, they procreate, right?

1566
01:30:30.199 --> 01:30:37.545
What Waddington's theory is saying, it's more Lamarckian in the sense that your life is going to dictate your genetic makeup.

1567
01:30:38.045 --> 01:30:39.787
Now, for a long time, this was discredited.

1568
01:30:40.067 --> 01:30:45.071
And for good reason, because genetics is, like, as I said, the DNA part is, like, very hard-coded, right?

1569
01:30:45.692 --> 01:30:50.556
But now there's a link between the software and perhaps the hardware.

1570
01:30:50.596 --> 01:30:50.856
Yeah.

1571
01:30:51.236 --> 01:30:51.637
Because...

1572
01:30:53.091 --> 01:31:17.757
methylated cytosines which are um the c's with the methyl groups those are inherently chemically unstable okay so what that means is they frequently mutate into thiamine t's so if i have more methylation i'm going to have more mutations and i'm going to have more t's where there should be c's at three times a higher rate so what's the conclusion that means that

1573
01:31:19.170 --> 01:31:34.339
If among the inherited epigenetic traits, right, if my life is changing the methylation pattern, that methylation pattern could change the hardware itself because of this 3x difference in mutation rate.

1574
01:31:36.440 --> 01:31:39.001
It's a recursive self-improvement or not improvement.

1575
01:31:39.021 --> 01:31:39.781
Or not improvement.

1576
01:31:39.841 --> 01:31:40.881
Yeah, it could go either way.

1577
01:31:40.901 --> 01:31:41.601
It could go either way.

1578
01:31:41.742 --> 01:31:42.322
Kind of crazy.

1579
01:31:44.142 --> 01:31:46.403
It's always been the conversation about nature versus nurture.

1580
01:31:46.443 --> 01:31:47.904
It's more like nature and nurture.

1581
01:31:48.264 --> 01:31:50.525
And there's this combination between the two.

1582
01:31:51.305 --> 01:32:01.409
And as this sort of continues to permeate as now posing some very difficult questions, yeah.

1583
01:32:02.469 --> 01:32:08.511
And there is an obviously the sort of epigenomics and epigenetics conceptually have now been around for some time.

1584
01:32:08.811 --> 01:32:20.915
These are the kind of big results that I think put us into a new frame, you know, a new what do they call it?

1585
01:32:22.055 --> 01:32:30.438
The Overton window on this is moving a little bit to now really think about, OK, because I think your point is over the course of your life.

1586
01:32:31.399 --> 01:32:45.898
If your life itself is impacting the methylation on these cytosines that then go from C to T and your offspring fundamentally get different genetics as a result of that, that's pretty meaningful.

1587
01:32:46.078 --> 01:32:46.278
Yeah.

1588
01:32:46.959 --> 01:32:47.600
Yeah.

1589
01:32:47.640 --> 01:32:48.201
That's pretty huge.

1590
01:32:48.281 --> 01:32:48.621
Right?

1591
01:32:48.661 --> 01:32:48.822
Yeah.

1592
01:32:50.063 --> 01:32:53.706
I mean, even in terms of disease risk, this is a big deal, right?

1593
01:32:54.587 --> 01:33:02.294
Because you can explain now how a mutated allele could epigenetically silence a healthy allele.

1594
01:33:02.354 --> 01:33:04.115
So it's not just all about genetics.

1595
01:33:04.255 --> 01:33:12.423
Even if you're a heterozygote and you've got the correct allele to survive the disease, if you've got some shenanigans going on like this...

1596
01:33:13.204 --> 01:33:19.192
and the healthy allele just doesn't even get expressed, you're biologically null for that gene, right?

1597
01:33:20.433 --> 01:33:21.915
This makes me think about things like...

1598
01:33:25.648 --> 01:33:32.614
like anemia being more prominent in like Mediterranean or African populations.

1599
01:33:32.654 --> 01:33:33.254
Yeah.

1600
01:33:33.554 --> 01:33:34.675
And it's like, is there?

1601
01:33:35.216 --> 01:33:38.558
Well, that one, that one is actually a single nucleotide polymorphism.

1602
01:33:38.698 --> 01:33:38.918
Yeah.

1603
01:33:38.979 --> 01:33:42.521
That's actually, there's like a straight up hardwired genetic difference.

1604
01:33:42.541 --> 01:33:43.742
That's not an epigenetic thing.

1605
01:33:43.782 --> 01:33:43.982
Yeah.

1606
01:33:44.243 --> 01:33:49.807
And that one's well documented because the, the, the mutation is, I believe in the, that's great.

1607
01:33:49.827 --> 01:33:51.909
In the heme protein or something like that.

1608
01:33:52.489 --> 01:33:55.910
That like affects the shape of red blood cells.

1609
01:33:55.950 --> 01:33:56.150
Yeah.

1610
01:33:56.391 --> 01:34:01.152
Where you cannot store the hemoglobin as well.

1611
01:34:01.212 --> 01:34:01.492
Yeah.

1612
01:34:01.532 --> 01:34:02.113
Hemoglobin is.

1613
01:34:03.033 --> 01:34:04.494
It's like in a weird shape.

1614
01:34:04.534 --> 01:34:05.534
Some of them are in a weird shape.

1615
01:34:05.554 --> 01:34:07.515
So then that makes the cell a weird shape.

1616
01:34:07.615 --> 01:34:09.135
But there's so many other things, right?

1617
01:34:09.155 --> 01:34:10.936
And this is like there are traits.

1618
01:34:10.996 --> 01:34:11.556
I forget which.

1619
01:34:11.576 --> 01:34:12.977
But like there's some traits where like the.

1620
01:34:13.817 --> 01:34:16.898
There's like weak evidence that shows that the grandmother's exposure to stuff.

1621
01:34:18.159 --> 01:34:20.500
Alters the disease risk of grandchildren.

1622
01:34:20.520 --> 01:34:21.120
Yeah.

1623
01:34:21.480 --> 01:34:21.721
Okay.

1624
01:34:22.022 --> 01:34:27.556
And maybe that's another episode that we could do, but like, this is, this is now getting to that question.

1625
01:34:27.576 --> 01:34:27.677
Yeah.

1626
01:34:28.627 --> 01:34:37.332
And we can now ask, we can actually probe at it in a much more robust fashion.

1627
01:34:37.473 --> 01:34:38.253
Yeah.

1628
01:34:38.513 --> 01:34:45.237
Not just create a framework or have things that we can't quite then follow up with empirical data.

1629
01:34:45.277 --> 01:34:45.437
Yeah.

1630
01:34:45.517 --> 01:34:53.522
And I mean, the next step, the next clear step, and this is something that Feinberg and his colleagues are doing next, is to do this long read sequencing stuff for humans.

1631
01:34:53.742 --> 01:34:53.923
Yeah.

1632
01:34:54.123 --> 01:34:54.303
Right.

1633
01:34:54.383 --> 01:34:55.924
And seek paramutation in humans.

1634
01:34:56.404 --> 01:34:57.285
Which makes total sense.

1635
01:34:57.366 --> 01:35:06.398
So, because if it's like 7% in mice, it could even be higher in humans because humans are a relatively recent evolutionary...

1636
01:35:07.678 --> 01:35:29.752
organism right and our mutation rate is hella high and that mutation rate we've only we're really talking at the hardware level if the hardware level is already high imagine what the mutation rate at the software level is you know this is fascinating a big big return episode for our resident phd krishna chowdhury new rules

1637
01:35:30.492 --> 01:35:36.173
for this idea of non-Mendellian inheritance of epigenetics.

1638
01:35:36.213 --> 01:35:42.995
I mean, there's so much here that we, again, we can't cover everything in these pods.

1639
01:35:43.055 --> 01:35:51.557
There's a lot of detail that we can't quite dive as much into, but hopefully we gave a nice overview for folks who are interested in this conversation.

1640
01:35:51.857 --> 01:35:59.919
And again, like I mentioned, there's so many social, cultural conversations around this idea of quote-unquote generational trauma

1641
01:36:00.539 --> 01:36:05.683
and its impacts on your actual physical outcome.

1642
01:36:06.244 --> 01:36:09.286
And we're starting to be able to actually poke at some of these areas in interesting ways.

1643
01:36:10.347 --> 01:36:15.311
Do we want to leave, because this is a long one, so if you've made it this far, congratulations.

1644
01:36:16.091 --> 01:36:18.213
You are a lifelong learner like the rest of us.

1645
01:36:18.673 --> 01:36:24.398
Do we want to have any questions for folks to leave in the comments for this episode?

1646
01:36:24.978 --> 01:36:25.258
Oh, yeah.

1647
01:36:25.278 --> 01:36:31.760
Well, I was going to say what you guys should do is tell us what books to put on the, as you said, in the thing.

1648
01:36:31.841 --> 01:36:32.041
Yes.

1649
01:36:32.081 --> 01:36:40.043
But if you made it this far, and do you have any advice for a new father?

1650
01:36:40.223 --> 01:36:40.684
That's a good one.

1651
01:36:40.744 --> 01:36:45.405
Even if you're single and you don't have kids, just give me some, like, really terrible advice.

1652
01:36:45.445 --> 01:36:48.947
I want to see, like, the worst advice you can think of.

1653
01:36:49.667 --> 01:36:49.887
Yeah.

1654
01:36:50.567 --> 01:36:59.650
Um, my name is Lester Nare joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD and welcome back to Zaddy Krishna Chowdhury.

1655
01:37:00.170 --> 01:37:01.491
Um, it's great to have you back.

1656
01:37:01.651 --> 01:37:03.251
This is always so, so fun.

1657
01:37:03.411 --> 01:37:04.031
It's good to be back.

1658
01:37:04.091 --> 01:37:13.634
Um, we got, uh, some fun ones coming up for you guys, uh, here in the next couple of weeks as we get back on our regular scheduling cycle.

1659
01:37:14.055 --> 01:37:18.316
We appreciate you all for staying with us and we will see you all next week.
