WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.151 --> 00:00:04.093
Hello, hola, guten tag, and konnichiwaagwan internet.

2
00:00:04.293 --> 00:00:13.758
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

3
00:00:14.519 --> 00:00:18.181
We are in our recap episode for 2025, episode 20.

4
00:00:21.042 --> 00:00:22.425
It's been an incredible year.

5
00:00:22.765 --> 00:00:23.567
How are you, my friend?

6
00:00:24.028 --> 00:00:25.270
The season finale.

7
00:00:25.310 --> 00:00:26.251
Season finale.

8
00:00:26.312 --> 00:00:26.913
Season one.

9
00:00:27.133 --> 00:00:27.754
Yeah.

10
00:00:27.995 --> 00:00:30.399
There will be no cliffhangers on this episode.

11
00:00:30.739 --> 00:00:31.501
Yeah.

12
00:00:31.581 --> 00:00:33.324
But we are going to do a great...

13
00:00:34.222 --> 00:00:58.178
recap of our top five each of us gonna have our top five episodes or stories rather of the year and we'll do one interesting thing at the beginning but i want to just quickly i mean we started this in july yeah end of june and i just can't believe how much people love science

14
00:00:58.732 --> 00:01:08.392
Yeah, it's been like really nice seeing the amount of support that we've been getting, the amount of traction that we've been getting on Instagram, TikTok, YouTube,

15
00:01:09.404 --> 00:01:10.624
Spotify, Apple.

16
00:01:11.125 --> 00:01:14.846
I mean, on Spotify, we were making the charts according to our creator.

17
00:01:15.626 --> 00:01:16.086
Recapped.

18
00:01:16.126 --> 00:01:16.406
Yeah.

19
00:01:16.466 --> 00:01:17.726
So this is an important note.

20
00:01:17.906 --> 00:01:32.691
Shout out to everyone who's watched us on video or listened to us on Spotify because we got a 2025 Instant Hit Award, which means we were one of the few shows this year where

21
00:01:33.651 --> 00:01:36.894
On Spotify, that obviously was an instant hit.

22
00:01:37.034 --> 00:01:37.874
Yeah, yeah.

23
00:01:37.894 --> 00:01:38.695
Which is a huge deal.

24
00:01:38.915 --> 00:01:43.258
And we're in the top 2% of comments, top 2% of shares.

25
00:01:43.699 --> 00:01:44.119
It's great.

26
00:01:44.199 --> 00:01:45.840
It's just really incredible.

27
00:01:45.940 --> 00:01:49.763
It all comes from the audience, and we're extremely grateful for that.

28
00:01:50.203 --> 00:01:52.304
You all are what enable us to continue to do this.

29
00:01:52.905 --> 00:01:58.767
What I will say is, if you haven't already, follow From First Principles on YouTube.

30
00:01:59.188 --> 00:02:00.708
Hit that subscribe button.

31
00:02:01.429 --> 00:02:02.269
Like some stuff.

32
00:02:02.729 --> 00:02:09.553
The algorithms that the billionaires control are what allow us to get our science content to more people.

33
00:02:10.153 --> 00:02:11.313
We don't make the rules.

34
00:02:11.373 --> 00:02:12.133
Don't hate the play.

35
00:02:12.173 --> 00:02:12.974
I hate the game.

36
00:02:13.154 --> 00:02:13.434
Yeah.

37
00:02:13.674 --> 00:02:18.595
So I don't like asking for the subscribe button, but YouTube is huge.

38
00:02:19.055 --> 00:02:24.476
And it's where we've been struggling to get as much reach as we see on Instagram.

39
00:02:24.596 --> 00:02:24.956
Exactly.

40
00:02:25.056 --> 00:02:25.916
And other platforms.

41
00:02:25.956 --> 00:02:30.337
So if you do have a YouTube and you want to watch it there, that would be super, super helpful.

42
00:02:30.357 --> 00:02:34.958
But I was really surprised that Instagram has been our most popular platform.

43
00:02:35.138 --> 00:02:36.138
Yeah, that one's crazy.

44
00:02:36.158 --> 00:02:38.900
We're reaching almost 60K right now.

45
00:02:39.080 --> 00:02:39.320
Yes.

46
00:02:39.700 --> 00:02:41.521
As of the recording of this episode.

47
00:02:41.861 --> 00:02:46.023
We're going to have one of our story videos is going to hit a million in the next.

48
00:02:46.283 --> 00:02:47.464
By the time this episode comes out.

49
00:02:47.624 --> 00:02:47.864
Yeah.

50
00:02:48.084 --> 00:02:51.425
The story about the whales is going to be over a million.

51
00:02:51.445 --> 00:02:52.506
That'll be our first video.

52
00:02:53.272 --> 00:02:53.632
Anywhere.

53
00:02:53.893 --> 00:02:54.093
Yeah.

54
00:02:54.453 --> 00:02:54.993
That would be great.

55
00:02:55.073 --> 00:02:55.894
Over a million views.

56
00:02:56.775 --> 00:03:00.057
So we're going to go ahead and get started with the episode shortly.

57
00:03:00.077 --> 00:03:06.161
But before we get into our recap, we're going to start with some unfortunate news that just happened.

58
00:03:06.181 --> 00:03:06.862
Yeah.

59
00:03:06.922 --> 00:03:08.003
I think literally yesterday.

60
00:03:08.023 --> 00:03:08.403
Yeah.

61
00:03:08.783 --> 00:03:33.762
um the um the unfortunate passing of professor uh nuno loreiro who was the director of the mit plasma science infusion center yeah uh since 2024 there's also just a giant in plasma physics generally yeah uh really bizarre it's been a really weird week for yeah but the brown university issue this one and this was also a result of gun violence yeah

62
00:03:34.102 --> 00:03:34.403
Right.

63
00:03:34.823 --> 00:03:35.724
It's just insane.

64
00:03:36.786 --> 00:03:37.086
Right.

65
00:03:37.246 --> 00:03:37.466
Yeah.

66
00:03:37.667 --> 00:03:43.754
And so we will start with a brief retrospective on Nuno, and then we'll get into our recap.

67
00:03:43.895 --> 00:03:46.338
And as always, we're going to be focused on the science.

68
00:03:46.678 --> 00:03:46.898
Yeah.

69
00:03:47.059 --> 00:03:50.383
Because this is From First Principles.

70
00:04:06.759 --> 00:04:10.737
So, Professor Nuno F.G. Lurero...

71
00:04:12.673 --> 00:04:17.654
He recently died, as recently as yesterday, according to the taping of this episode.

72
00:04:17.694 --> 00:04:20.915
He was the director of the MIT Plasma Science and Fusion Center.

73
00:04:21.455 --> 00:04:22.335
Very unfortunate.

74
00:04:22.715 --> 00:04:27.337
The entire community, the scientific community in Cambridge is reeling from this loss.

75
00:04:27.417 --> 00:04:28.357
Yeah.

76
00:04:28.957 --> 00:04:41.820
And I thought the best way that we can pay homage to a scientist like that is just to focus on his scientific career and some of the great seminal work that he has done in the field of plasma physics.

77
00:04:42.420 --> 00:04:42.620
Right.

78
00:04:43.061 --> 00:04:52.349
Um, I can't comment too much on what happened other than really this guy was an incredible scientist and incredible thinker.

79
00:04:52.890 --> 00:05:04.380
And apart from even a science, um, an incredible educator and someone that sort of cultivated students and the community to do science.

80
00:05:04.620 --> 00:05:06.882
So he seemed like a really incredible guy.

81
00:05:07.703 --> 00:05:07.903
Um,

82
00:05:08.744 --> 00:05:17.006
He really revolutionized our understanding of plasma physics, specifically this problem of magnetic reconnection, which is what we're going to go over.

83
00:05:17.026 --> 00:05:20.267
We're going to go over his seminal paper, the one that made him famous.

84
00:05:21.367 --> 00:05:26.228
And then we're going to go over the work that he was doing currently before his untimely death.

85
00:05:26.768 --> 00:05:27.028
Okay?

86
00:05:27.388 --> 00:05:33.390
And the focus is going to be on that seminal paper and then what he's been doing since recently.

87
00:05:33.450 --> 00:05:33.690
Yeah.

88
00:05:33.770 --> 00:05:33.910
Yep.

89
00:05:34.130 --> 00:05:34.270
Yep.

90
00:05:34.450 --> 00:05:37.331
He's been doing a lot, but we're going to focus on really just two aspects.

91
00:05:37.471 --> 00:05:37.631
Okay.

92
00:05:37.851 --> 00:05:38.091
Okay?

93
00:05:39.111 --> 00:05:43.974
So, it's going to be a deep dive into plasma physics, which I'm pretty excited about.

94
00:05:44.014 --> 00:05:46.936
Look, you know, we love the deep dives.

95
00:05:46.956 --> 00:05:49.038
The comments have told us.

96
00:05:49.338 --> 00:05:50.919
Yeah, they like the deep dives.

97
00:05:50.939 --> 00:05:54.421
And it's going to get technical, but I'm going to walk you through it, okay?

98
00:05:54.461 --> 00:05:54.721
Okay.

99
00:05:54.982 --> 00:05:57.103
And hopefully we can bring everyone along.

100
00:05:57.183 --> 00:05:58.164
So, plasma physics.

101
00:05:58.464 --> 00:05:58.664
Yes.

102
00:05:58.964 --> 00:06:00.025
Plasma is like...

103
00:06:01.293 --> 00:06:05.214
more than 90% of the observable universe, the stuff that gives off light.

104
00:06:05.654 --> 00:06:05.934
Okay.

105
00:06:06.294 --> 00:06:06.855
Not on earth.

106
00:06:07.095 --> 00:06:16.917
On earth, most of the stuff is not plasma, but plasma is effectively, when you get so high temperature and so high energy that the electrons leave the atoms.

107
00:06:17.257 --> 00:06:17.437
Right.

108
00:06:17.537 --> 00:06:17.797
Okay.

109
00:06:18.038 --> 00:06:27.020
You're at such an energy scale where it's just, it's fine if the electrons just go out on their own and you get this kind of ionized gas where, right.

110
00:06:28.824 --> 00:06:32.626
The gas itself is charged, and there's no neutral atoms anymore.

111
00:06:32.946 --> 00:06:33.186
Okay?

112
00:06:33.546 --> 00:06:35.467
That's the stuff that's inside the sun.

113
00:06:35.947 --> 00:06:38.869
That's the stuff that's in the interstellar medium.

114
00:06:39.609 --> 00:06:43.611
And again, more than 90% of the visible universe is plasma.

115
00:06:43.631 --> 00:06:46.052
When we look out into the night sky, we're seeing stars.

116
00:06:46.893 --> 00:06:49.114
Most of that stuff is plasma.

117
00:06:49.134 --> 00:06:49.494
Plasma.

118
00:06:49.754 --> 00:06:49.994
Okay?

119
00:06:50.214 --> 00:06:53.136
When we look at the sun, most of that stuff is plasma.

120
00:06:53.596 --> 00:06:53.816
Okay?

121
00:06:59.736 --> 00:07:01.638
and electromagnetic fields.

122
00:07:02.359 --> 00:07:10.988
This is what's very interesting about plasma physics, is the mathematics becomes immediately non-trivial.

123
00:07:12.029 --> 00:07:12.349
Okay?

124
00:07:12.450 --> 00:07:13.771
It's like extremely hard.

125
00:07:13.791 --> 00:07:15.192
Because fluids by itself...

126
00:07:16.124 --> 00:07:16.984
is a very hard thing.

127
00:07:17.464 --> 00:07:21.806
Which we've discussed, for example, just like simulating fluid dynamics is extremely difficult.

128
00:07:21.846 --> 00:07:22.886
It's extremely difficult.

129
00:07:22.946 --> 00:07:28.708
Like the Navier-Stokes equation with neutral atoms is a millennium problem.

130
00:07:29.008 --> 00:07:40.911
It's one of those seven problems, well now six, that have been unsolved that you get a million dollars if you solve it, which is do the Navier-Stokes equations have an analytic solution for any given geometry?

131
00:07:41.291 --> 00:07:41.552
Okay?

132
00:07:41.972 --> 00:07:42.552
Nobody knows.

133
00:07:43.192 --> 00:07:43.712
We don't know.

134
00:07:43.752 --> 00:07:44.372
We don't know.

135
00:07:44.672 --> 00:07:45.973
But that's for neutral atoms.

136
00:07:46.073 --> 00:07:54.015
Now imagine a fluid where you don't have to just worry about the particles bumping into each other and viscosity and all this stuff.

137
00:07:54.135 --> 00:07:57.356
You also have to worry about the fact that these particles have charge.

138
00:07:57.776 --> 00:08:01.817
And so they're creating electric fields because any charged particle creates electric fields.

139
00:08:02.178 --> 00:08:03.198
But also they're moving.

140
00:08:03.658 --> 00:08:05.179
So that's creating magnetic fields.

141
00:08:05.539 --> 00:08:11.423
And then those magnetic fields are going to affect the other charged particles around, which are going to affect the other charged particles around.

142
00:08:11.743 --> 00:08:15.085
So you have this entirely nonlinear process, right, that's happening.

143
00:08:15.125 --> 00:08:16.586
And it's incredibly difficult.

144
00:08:16.626 --> 00:08:20.088
This is why it's very hard to make fusion happen.

145
00:08:20.668 --> 00:08:22.030
Fission is very easy.

146
00:08:22.070 --> 00:08:23.272
We have fission reactors.

147
00:08:23.433 --> 00:08:23.633
Yes.

148
00:08:23.833 --> 00:08:28.141
All of the nuclear power that we think about is from fission, which is the splitting of atoms.

149
00:08:28.161 --> 00:08:28.361
Yes.

150
00:08:28.622 --> 00:08:32.729
That's a nuclear energy that we're harnessing to create electricity.

151
00:08:32.889 --> 00:08:33.069
Yes.

152
00:08:33.390 --> 00:08:34.251
The holy grail.

153
00:08:35.231 --> 00:08:36.632
would be fusion, right?

154
00:08:36.712 --> 00:08:43.855
Fusion power, because then we could just use hydrogen instead of trying to find like uranium and all this other crazy rare earth stuff.

155
00:08:43.895 --> 00:08:45.215
Hydrogen is just in water.

156
00:08:45.536 --> 00:08:46.736
We just find hydrogen.

157
00:08:46.776 --> 00:08:49.777
We could purify deuterium, which is an isotope of hydrogen.

158
00:08:50.078 --> 00:08:52.979
We'd combine them together and basically replicate the sun

159
00:08:54.415 --> 00:08:55.256
You know, this is the dream.

160
00:08:55.356 --> 00:08:55.756
Yeah, right.

161
00:08:55.776 --> 00:08:59.419
We replicate the sun in a building, and that just feeds us electricity.

162
00:08:59.480 --> 00:09:01.221
We're trying to replicate the sun locally.

163
00:09:01.381 --> 00:09:02.282
Yeah, exactly.

164
00:09:02.542 --> 00:09:03.743
I mean, it would be dope.

165
00:09:04.124 --> 00:09:06.446
It would be what Dr. Octopus wanted to do.

166
00:09:06.466 --> 00:09:08.107
Before he went crazy.

167
00:09:08.187 --> 00:09:08.427
Yes.

168
00:09:08.748 --> 00:09:09.909
In Spider-Man 2?

169
00:09:10.209 --> 00:09:10.649
Spider-Man 2?

170
00:09:11.390 --> 00:09:12.090
Spider-Man 2, right?

171
00:09:12.130 --> 00:09:12.550
Great movie.

172
00:09:12.830 --> 00:09:14.191
Yeah, it's a great movie.

173
00:09:14.211 --> 00:09:15.391
Those were the original, right?

174
00:09:15.491 --> 00:09:16.852
Yes, yes, yes, yes.

175
00:09:17.152 --> 00:09:25.414
And this interaction between the electric fields and the fluids is what is described by magnetohydrodynamics, okay?

176
00:09:25.774 --> 00:09:32.656
Magneto, because there's magnetism involved, the fact that charged particles are moving around, they create a magnetic field.

177
00:09:33.036 --> 00:09:37.938
And hydrodynamics, because it's a fluid of charged particles, right?

178
00:09:37.958 --> 00:09:38.938
So you're combining...

179
00:09:39.618 --> 00:09:48.222
the Maxwell's equations with the Navier-Stokes equations in some sense to create this really complicated physics.

180
00:09:48.743 --> 00:09:56.006
There are multiple layers of dynamic things happening at the same time.

181
00:09:56.346 --> 00:09:56.566
Yeah.

182
00:09:57.027 --> 00:10:03.550
And to be able to have an understanding, you need to be able to model all those dynamic layers and how they change things.

183
00:10:03.790 --> 00:10:04.430
Over time.

184
00:10:04.510 --> 00:10:07.971
Yeah, and each little thing is affecting the other thing, right?

185
00:10:08.031 --> 00:10:14.733
So you can't really make... A lot of the times in physics, we like to be like, in this regime, we don't have to worry about this.

186
00:10:15.293 --> 00:10:17.013
In this regime, we don't have to worry about this.

187
00:10:17.073 --> 00:10:19.354
Well, in plasma, you got to worry about everything.

188
00:10:19.394 --> 00:10:19.594
Right.

189
00:10:19.914 --> 00:10:20.134
Right?

190
00:10:20.414 --> 00:10:28.916
And so it's incredibly difficult to make sense of what is going on, which is why the problem of fusion containment in these reactors is so hard.

191
00:10:29.336 --> 00:10:29.736
Makes sense.

192
00:10:30.056 --> 00:10:30.296
Okay?

193
00:10:30.536 --> 00:10:33.337
And the governing equation for the magnetic field in a plasma...

194
00:10:33.997 --> 00:10:56.122
is this which is a pretty a pretty daunting equation okay on the left hand side you have db dt which is the time change how how the magnetic field changes with time and then you've got two terms you've got del cross v cross b which is that's that's what we would call the advection term okay it's basically velocity

195
00:10:57.349 --> 00:11:01.753
Velocity perpendicular with magnetic field is going to give you some kind of force.

196
00:11:02.334 --> 00:11:07.399
And then how that force curls around is going to tell you how the magnetic field.

197
00:11:07.659 --> 00:11:10.983
So there's like all these vectors that are going in, right?

198
00:11:11.303 --> 00:11:16.308
And then, but at the end of the day, that magnetic field is actually going backwards.

199
00:11:16.840 --> 00:11:20.725
parallel with the velocity of those particles because there's two cross-products.

200
00:11:21.085 --> 00:11:25.311
This is something that people would, vector calculus knowledge would know, right?

201
00:11:25.331 --> 00:11:29.916
If you have two cross-products, then actually you're just going in the same direction.

202
00:11:30.157 --> 00:11:32.159
And then the second term there, nu over mu naught,

203
00:11:32.920 --> 00:11:35.281
Del squared B, that looks like a heat equation.

204
00:11:35.662 --> 00:11:35.902
Okay?

205
00:11:36.362 --> 00:11:38.083
And that is your diffusion term.

206
00:11:38.123 --> 00:11:47.149
Basically, you know, if you have a hot, if you have a metal rod and you heat up one part of the metal rod, the heat is going to diffuse across that metal rod.

207
00:11:47.189 --> 00:11:47.369
Right?

208
00:11:47.709 --> 00:11:51.151
And the magnetic field in these plasmas does the same thing.

209
00:11:51.191 --> 00:11:56.714
If you've got a lot of magnetic field here, it's going to sort of diffuse and the magnetic field lines are going to diffuse out.

210
00:11:56.734 --> 00:12:01.117
So the propagation of the magnetic field kind of looks similar to the propagation of heat.

211
00:12:01.537 --> 00:12:01.937
Of heat.

212
00:12:02.417 --> 00:12:03.418
From a mathematical perspective.

213
00:12:03.438 --> 00:12:04.658
From a mathematical perspective.

214
00:12:04.998 --> 00:12:06.619
But there's those two terms, right?

215
00:12:06.659 --> 00:12:09.320
There's the diffusion term, which is that heat kind of term.

216
00:12:09.420 --> 00:12:09.600
Yes.

217
00:12:09.900 --> 00:12:17.062
And then there's the advection term, which is the magnetic field moving in line with the charged particles.

218
00:12:17.502 --> 00:12:19.663
Because you've got that double cross product.

219
00:12:20.223 --> 00:12:20.423
So...

220
00:12:22.507 --> 00:12:26.729
When a plasma is a perfect conductor, in that equation, there was this new, right?

221
00:12:26.769 --> 00:12:29.131
Which is the conductivity.

222
00:12:30.151 --> 00:12:36.395
If a plasma is perfect, then the conductivity is just like amazing.

223
00:12:36.815 --> 00:12:37.715
There's no resistance.

224
00:12:37.775 --> 00:12:38.055
Yeah.

225
00:12:38.176 --> 00:12:38.436
Okay?

226
00:12:38.796 --> 00:12:43.178
And in that case, we don't have to worry about that second term.

227
00:12:43.298 --> 00:12:44.279
The heat-looking thing.

228
00:12:44.299 --> 00:12:44.499
Yeah.

229
00:12:44.519 --> 00:12:46.960
The heat-looking thing is because it's just going to like go.

230
00:12:47.020 --> 00:12:47.260
Go.

231
00:12:47.321 --> 00:12:47.661
Yeah.

232
00:12:47.681 --> 00:12:47.841
Right?

233
00:12:47.881 --> 00:12:48.061
Yeah.

234
00:12:48.441 --> 00:12:49.642
So we don't have to worry about that.

235
00:12:49.722 --> 00:12:52.785
And then we get something called the frozen influx theorem.

236
00:12:53.165 --> 00:12:58.811
Basically what this means is that the magnetic field lines don't actually diffuse out.

237
00:12:58.891 --> 00:13:02.314
They get locked in place with these plasma particles.

238
00:13:02.334 --> 00:13:04.195
So on the left you see straight lines.

239
00:13:04.636 --> 00:13:09.520
And then as the plasma particles move around, the magnetic field lines move around with them.

240
00:13:09.700 --> 00:13:09.981
Got it.

241
00:13:10.001 --> 00:13:10.261
You know?

242
00:13:10.401 --> 00:13:10.741
Yes.

243
00:13:12.082 --> 00:13:13.523
The field lines don't break.

244
00:13:13.963 --> 00:13:15.083
They don't cross.

245
00:13:15.143 --> 00:13:17.003
They don't change their connectivity.

246
00:13:17.624 --> 00:13:24.686
And in some sense, topologically, they're preserving this mathematics across those scales.

247
00:13:24.806 --> 00:13:25.046
Got it.

248
00:13:25.086 --> 00:13:25.346
Okay?

249
00:13:25.786 --> 00:13:28.847
So that would be really great if that's what plasma did.

250
00:13:29.227 --> 00:13:29.407
Right.

251
00:13:29.647 --> 00:13:31.968
And we didn't have to worry about one of the terms in the equation.

252
00:13:32.268 --> 00:13:33.128
It's still difficult.

253
00:13:33.148 --> 00:13:33.548
Yeah.

254
00:13:33.768 --> 00:13:34.889
But, you know, at least there's...

255
00:13:34.949 --> 00:13:36.730
It's incrementally less difficult.

256
00:13:36.750 --> 00:13:38.351
Yeah, it's incrementally less difficult, right?

257
00:13:38.471 --> 00:13:41.693
Like, at least the flux is frozen into the plasma, right?

258
00:13:41.813 --> 00:13:42.053
Okay.

259
00:13:42.253 --> 00:13:44.875
So that's that frozen flux theorem.

260
00:13:44.935 --> 00:13:45.155
Yeah.

261
00:13:45.455 --> 00:13:52.720
As a means by which to try to calculate and understand magnetohydrodynamics.

262
00:13:52.740 --> 00:13:53.380
Yes, yes.

263
00:13:53.520 --> 00:13:55.922
It would be like a great approximation...

264
00:13:56.797 --> 00:13:57.457
If we could do it.

265
00:13:57.557 --> 00:14:01.099
Not dissimilar to the approximation we do with the Stokes equation.

266
00:14:01.259 --> 00:14:01.919
Yeah.

267
00:14:01.939 --> 00:14:04.380
Like in terms of we can't really model.

268
00:14:04.500 --> 00:14:05.160
Exactly.

269
00:14:05.480 --> 00:14:07.441
And so we need some kind of approximation.

270
00:14:07.461 --> 00:14:08.282
Yes, yeah.

271
00:14:08.342 --> 00:14:13.624
So maybe at like certain geometries we can like, you know, and obviously it works.

272
00:14:13.844 --> 00:14:14.044
Yes.

273
00:14:14.064 --> 00:14:14.264
Right?

274
00:14:14.344 --> 00:14:19.226
Like Formula One teams use the Navier-Stokes equation to figure out

275
00:14:19.926 --> 00:14:23.427
how their car is going to do on a certain track, right?

276
00:14:23.827 --> 00:14:30.250
So obviously it works, but then you get to really high magnetic fields, like near the sun or inside of a Takamak.

277
00:14:30.370 --> 00:14:30.650
Yeah.

278
00:14:30.850 --> 00:14:32.631
And then you're like, it doesn't quite work.

279
00:14:32.671 --> 00:14:33.531
It doesn't quite work.

280
00:14:33.951 --> 00:14:34.251
I will.

281
00:14:34.572 --> 00:14:39.113
What's funny, the two videos, two movies I watched on my flight back from North Carolina.

282
00:14:39.233 --> 00:14:39.473
Yeah.

283
00:14:39.713 --> 00:14:43.275
Two days ago was the F1 movie, which he had recommended.

284
00:14:43.295 --> 00:14:43.515
Yeah.

285
00:14:43.895 --> 00:14:44.455
Quite good.

286
00:14:44.475 --> 00:14:46.936
We could have done without the love story, but that's another thing.

287
00:14:46.956 --> 00:14:47.176
Yeah.

288
00:14:47.396 --> 00:14:54.718
And then Tenet, which talked about Tokamaks and nuclear, because they're basically, long story short.

289
00:14:54.738 --> 00:14:55.398
I haven't seen that one.

290
00:14:55.498 --> 00:14:57.039
There was a nuclear nexus.

291
00:14:57.359 --> 00:15:01.800
So it's funny that both things are now being applied here to this one.

292
00:15:01.860 --> 00:15:02.380
Yeah.

293
00:15:03.461 --> 00:15:03.721
So...

294
00:15:04.648 --> 00:15:06.109
Real plasmas, right?

295
00:15:06.169 --> 00:15:10.992
We've got finite resistivity because obviously like zero resistivity is not a thing.

296
00:15:11.012 --> 00:15:11.532
It's not a thing.

297
00:15:11.573 --> 00:15:11.773
Right?

298
00:15:11.873 --> 00:15:12.953
Unless you're a superconductor.

299
00:15:12.973 --> 00:15:17.917
But at this heat, you're not going to be a superconductor.

300
00:15:18.217 --> 00:15:24.881
So the resistivity means that this magnetic field, that second term, you're going to have this diffusion of the magnetic field, right?

301
00:15:25.161 --> 00:15:29.844
And that violation of the ideal magnetohydrodynamics is no longer something that we're going to do.

302
00:15:30.184 --> 00:15:33.707
And what you end up getting is something called current sheets.

303
00:15:34.227 --> 00:15:43.212
Because wherever you have these magnetic fields and they crisscross and you go from, let's say, magnetic field going one way to magnetic field going the other way, you're going to get these current sheets.

304
00:15:43.252 --> 00:15:48.515
Over here, what you're seeing is the current sheets around the sun.

305
00:15:48.615 --> 00:15:50.336
So in the center there, that's the sun.

306
00:15:50.436 --> 00:15:54.959
And then you can see the orbits of the inner planets and the orbit of Jupiter on the outside there.

307
00:15:54.979 --> 00:15:55.339
Yes.

308
00:15:55.739 --> 00:16:00.983
That sheet, it looks kind of like a flamingo dancer when they twirl, right?

309
00:16:01.023 --> 00:16:03.345
And the skirt moves around in a certain way.

310
00:16:03.365 --> 00:16:03.545
Yes.

311
00:16:03.685 --> 00:16:11.411
That sheet is the border between where the magnetic field points towards the sun and where the magnetic field points away from the sun.

312
00:16:11.431 --> 00:16:11.811
Interesting.

313
00:16:11.911 --> 00:16:12.171
Okay.

314
00:16:12.251 --> 00:16:12.491
Okay?

315
00:16:12.812 --> 00:16:18.256
Because imagine, if you have a magnetic field going this way and a magnetic field going this way, you got to pass through zero.

316
00:16:18.396 --> 00:16:18.596
Yes.

317
00:16:18.796 --> 00:16:18.976
Right?

318
00:16:19.076 --> 00:16:20.557
Because you got to do this.

319
00:16:20.597 --> 00:16:21.198
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

320
00:16:21.378 --> 00:16:25.161
And if it's in a small enough space, you have a very high gradient.

321
00:16:25.202 --> 00:16:27.884
You have a very high change in the magnetic field.

322
00:16:27.964 --> 00:16:32.628
And so the current is going to sort of collapse in that plane.

323
00:16:32.688 --> 00:16:33.008
Okay.

324
00:16:33.048 --> 00:16:33.249
Right?

325
00:16:33.309 --> 00:16:34.650
And so you get these current sheets.

326
00:16:34.710 --> 00:16:37.813
This is just a direct consequence of Maxwell's equations.

327
00:16:37.973 --> 00:16:38.193
Got it.

328
00:16:38.213 --> 00:16:38.393
Okay?

329
00:16:38.674 --> 00:16:41.516
So this is, again, just fundamental electrodynamics.

330
00:16:41.616 --> 00:16:43.878
So that's the heliocentric current sheet.

331
00:16:43.898 --> 00:16:44.178
Okay.

332
00:16:44.919 --> 00:17:07.135
you know at where the earth is that current sheet is like very small yeah right very small in magnitude unless you get like these mag massive coronal mass ejections and then and then it destroys our electricity every time i log on onto twitter aka x yeah someone is oh the the the this is the one it's happening this is the one that's gonna wipe everything out yeah yeah

333
00:17:07.792 --> 00:17:08.593
Yeah, exactly.

334
00:17:08.853 --> 00:17:09.714
Well, it never has.

335
00:17:09.874 --> 00:17:12.276
I mean, no, we've had some pretty bad ones, actually.

336
00:17:12.296 --> 00:17:14.998
Yeah, and look, let's knock on wood, because it's a thing.

337
00:17:15.338 --> 00:17:15.859
It is a thing.

338
00:17:15.879 --> 00:17:16.339
It's a thing.

339
00:17:16.539 --> 00:17:25.086
So with this current sheet, right, what's happening is that diffusive term is competing with that heat convective term, right?

340
00:17:25.146 --> 00:17:25.626
Yeah.

341
00:17:26.387 --> 00:17:33.811
What ends up happening is, in the mathematics, what you really care about is the ratio between these two competing forces.

342
00:17:34.251 --> 00:17:37.553
Which is the first part of that equation with the double cross.

343
00:17:37.693 --> 00:17:37.913
Yeah.

344
00:17:37.993 --> 00:17:40.554
And then the thing that looked like the heat equation.

345
00:17:40.614 --> 00:17:41.455
Yes, exactly.

346
00:17:41.735 --> 00:17:44.676
And what you want to do is look at the ratio between these two, okay?

347
00:17:44.696 --> 00:17:44.897
Okay.

348
00:17:45.217 --> 00:17:47.298
This is called a Lundquist number.

349
00:17:47.598 --> 00:17:47.878
Okay.

350
00:17:47.998 --> 00:17:48.238
Okay?

351
00:17:48.859 --> 00:17:49.019
And...

352
00:17:49.779 --> 00:17:55.164
At low Lundquist number, you're going to get a place where resistivity dominates.

353
00:17:55.344 --> 00:17:57.646
And at high Lundquist number, you get that frozen in.

354
00:17:57.666 --> 00:17:59.027
You only care about that first term.

355
00:17:59.388 --> 00:18:02.511
And these are the different typical Lundquist numbers.

356
00:18:02.591 --> 00:18:07.755
So for lab plasmas or something inside of Tokamak, you're looking at 10 to the 3 to 10 to the 10.

357
00:18:08.076 --> 00:18:11.459
But something like the solar corona, where you have massive scales...

358
00:18:11.839 --> 00:18:14.404
You're looking at like 10 to the 12, 10 to the 14, right?

359
00:18:14.624 --> 00:18:18.992
So you have this massive scale difference that you want your physics to work at.

360
00:18:19.072 --> 00:18:19.252
Right.

361
00:18:19.452 --> 00:18:20.835
And this is always tough.

362
00:18:20.855 --> 00:18:21.015
Right.

363
00:18:21.846 --> 00:18:22.286
I get you.

364
00:18:22.466 --> 00:18:23.187
Okay.

365
00:18:23.287 --> 00:18:28.069
The point is the map that we're trying to fill in is really large.

366
00:18:28.189 --> 00:18:29.250
It's really large.

367
00:18:29.290 --> 00:18:32.251
You're going from 10 to the 3 to 10 to the 13.

368
00:18:32.772 --> 00:18:34.433
10 orders of magnitude.

369
00:18:34.593 --> 00:18:34.853
Right?

370
00:18:35.033 --> 00:18:39.795
You're going 10 orders of magnitude, and you're trying to say that the same physics works for everything.

371
00:18:40.056 --> 00:18:40.236
Right.

372
00:18:40.276 --> 00:18:42.017
And the point is that obviously that's not true.

373
00:18:42.037 --> 00:18:43.237
Obviously that's not the case.

374
00:18:43.557 --> 00:18:49.801
Especially if you watched our hypersonics episode where we talked about how supersonic and hypersonic

375
00:18:51.262 --> 00:18:55.247
which is much smaller scales, it doesn't work.

376
00:18:55.448 --> 00:18:59.593
Because then you gotta worry about random stuff.

377
00:18:59.954 --> 00:19:01.496
And that's what ends up happening here.

378
00:19:01.576 --> 00:19:07.484
So before Nuno came along, before he came along,

379
00:19:08.640 --> 00:19:11.022
there was something called a Sweet Parker model.

380
00:19:11.482 --> 00:19:13.123
This was in the late 1950s.

381
00:19:13.564 --> 00:19:16.686
And what they wanted to do was model how these current sheets work.

382
00:19:17.126 --> 00:19:25.812
And what ended up happening was, if you've got a magnetic field going in one direction and a magnetic field going in the other direction, you've got this massive magnetic field gradient.

383
00:19:26.373 --> 00:19:31.416
What's going to end up happening is, there's going to be current that goes into that interface.

384
00:19:31.856 --> 00:19:34.899
And then it's going to get shot out because of the continuity equation.

385
00:19:35.039 --> 00:19:36.260
Continuity equation being...

386
00:19:36.980 --> 00:19:38.942
Stuff that comes in needs to go out, right?

387
00:19:39.422 --> 00:19:43.967
And so if the stuff is coming in in this direction, it needs to shoot out in that direction, right?

388
00:19:44.748 --> 00:19:54.477
And the idea was that this was a kind of way of figuring out how plasma works at all of the scales.

389
00:19:55.195 --> 00:20:02.503
It was something that they made a bunch of assumptions, but they created an analytic solution of it in the late 1950s.

390
00:20:03.023 --> 00:20:12.153
And that reconnection of the magnetic field going in one direction and the other direction, the lines are going to crisscross, and they could actually calculate a timescale.

391
00:20:13.248 --> 00:20:14.069
That that would happen.

392
00:20:15.109 --> 00:20:15.770
Okay.

393
00:20:15.790 --> 00:20:17.111
So now we've got an observable.

394
00:20:17.411 --> 00:20:21.513
You've done a theory, but a theory is only good as long as you've got an observable.

395
00:20:21.633 --> 00:20:29.158
Because then you can go into experiments, create experimental designs that then would show that that theory is reproducible.

396
00:20:29.419 --> 00:20:30.479
Exactly.

397
00:20:30.539 --> 00:20:31.680
In an observable context.

398
00:20:31.820 --> 00:20:32.601
Exactly, right?

399
00:20:32.741 --> 00:20:35.083
And so we've got these observables, right?

400
00:20:35.623 --> 00:20:48.413
And these sheets, these Sweet Parker sheets, what they're saying is, you know, at something like the sun, near the sun, where you've got a magnetic field line going in one direction and then it comes back in the other direction, so you do have these crisscrosses.

401
00:20:48.854 --> 00:20:50.035
I can see that happening.

402
00:20:50.175 --> 00:20:50.415
Yes.

403
00:20:50.655 --> 00:20:54.979
Those sheets are happening at a certain Lundquist number.

404
00:20:55.379 --> 00:20:58.742
And so I can calculate how long it would take for that

405
00:20:59.502 --> 00:21:02.645
Sheet to stay alive in some sense.

406
00:21:03.066 --> 00:21:03.346
Okay.

407
00:21:04.267 --> 00:21:07.651
And what they calculate is it should stay alive for a few months.

408
00:21:08.091 --> 00:21:08.292
Okay.

409
00:21:08.312 --> 00:21:09.152
Maybe a few years.

410
00:21:09.373 --> 00:21:09.633
Okay.

411
00:21:10.474 --> 00:21:12.236
That is very wrong.

412
00:21:14.338 --> 00:21:14.718
Okay.

413
00:21:15.900 --> 00:21:18.502
Observations show that it doesn't take months or years.

414
00:21:19.063 --> 00:21:20.384
It takes hours or hours.

415
00:21:21.483 --> 00:21:22.884
Minutes for a solar flare.

416
00:21:23.124 --> 00:21:25.025
In Talkamax, it'll take milliseconds.

417
00:21:25.085 --> 00:21:27.207
I was going to say, because at a solar flare scale.

418
00:21:27.227 --> 00:21:28.708
Solar flare, we've seen those things, right?

419
00:21:28.988 --> 00:21:31.630
We can observe them now with our solar telescopes.

420
00:21:31.650 --> 00:21:33.551
And you can just see the solar flare forming.

421
00:21:33.791 --> 00:21:35.993
And within hours and minutes, it'll just shoot out.

422
00:21:36.873 --> 00:21:43.316
Which is incredible because that means anything we're doing locally on the planet is like the Tokamak system for like nuclear power production.

423
00:21:43.336 --> 00:21:43.536
Yeah.

424
00:21:43.837 --> 00:21:47.418
Where we're trying to concentrate it into such a small volume.

425
00:21:47.658 --> 00:21:49.639
Means it's going to be even faster.

426
00:21:49.679 --> 00:21:50.500
The time scale is faster.

427
00:21:50.520 --> 00:21:50.680
Right.

428
00:21:50.960 --> 00:21:53.862
And the time scale on Tokamaks is something like milliseconds.

429
00:21:53.982 --> 00:21:54.142
Right.

430
00:21:54.242 --> 00:21:54.722
That makes sense.

431
00:21:54.742 --> 00:21:55.422
That makes sense.

432
00:21:55.542 --> 00:21:59.384
So now we've got, you said it was going to be months to years.

433
00:21:59.424 --> 00:22:00.165
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

434
00:22:01.125 --> 00:22:03.687
And we're seeing hours to minutes.

435
00:22:03.727 --> 00:22:05.349
So we're at orders of magnitude off.

436
00:22:05.369 --> 00:22:05.869
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

437
00:22:05.989 --> 00:22:07.371
It's not even a factor of two.

438
00:22:07.451 --> 00:22:09.192
It's a factor of like 10 to the six.

439
00:22:09.232 --> 00:22:09.913
Right, right, right.

440
00:22:09.953 --> 00:22:10.173
Right.

441
00:22:10.233 --> 00:22:12.435
There's something really wrong.

442
00:22:12.475 --> 00:22:14.917
The Sweet Parker model is not correct.

443
00:22:14.957 --> 00:22:15.698
Is not correct.

444
00:22:16.199 --> 00:22:16.979
Right.

445
00:22:17.179 --> 00:22:19.582
And I have to say, Parker there...

446
00:22:20.442 --> 00:22:21.783
He's a great plasma physicist.

447
00:22:21.803 --> 00:22:27.625
He's the guy who actually showed that the solar atmosphere is unstable and we should have something like the solar wind.

448
00:22:27.945 --> 00:22:31.166
So he literally predicted the solar wind from first principles.

449
00:22:31.606 --> 00:22:31.787
Right?

450
00:22:32.067 --> 00:22:32.347
So...

451
00:22:33.239 --> 00:22:34.120
All the credit to him.

452
00:22:34.320 --> 00:22:34.740
Kudos.

453
00:22:34.900 --> 00:22:39.463
This guy was someone who could have won the Nobel Prize had he lived long enough, right?

454
00:22:39.663 --> 00:22:39.823
Fair.

455
00:22:39.843 --> 00:22:42.384
But, you know, you win some, you lose some.

456
00:22:42.404 --> 00:22:44.005
Look, that's the next life.

457
00:22:44.065 --> 00:22:44.685
Yeah, yeah.

458
00:22:44.765 --> 00:22:45.326
And then the next life.

459
00:22:45.346 --> 00:22:45.546
Exactly.

460
00:22:45.926 --> 00:22:51.969
So this is where our hero, Nuno Luriero, comes in.

461
00:22:52.049 --> 00:22:52.250
Yes.

462
00:22:52.290 --> 00:22:52.570
Okay?

463
00:22:53.130 --> 00:22:56.332
He is in Princeton Plasma Physics Lab at the time.

464
00:22:57.439 --> 00:22:57.979
Go Tigers.

465
00:22:58.180 --> 00:22:58.360
Yeah.

466
00:22:58.780 --> 00:22:59.761
I was waiting for that.

467
00:23:00.401 --> 00:23:02.322
So he's at Princeton Plaza Physics at the time.

468
00:23:02.342 --> 00:23:05.424
He actually did his earlier training at UCL.

469
00:23:05.584 --> 00:23:06.145
Yes.

470
00:23:06.165 --> 00:23:10.648
And what he notices is that this doesn't work, guys.

471
00:23:10.728 --> 00:23:13.009
And it was a known problem for like 50 years.

472
00:23:13.029 --> 00:23:13.349
Okay.

473
00:23:13.390 --> 00:23:13.570
Right?

474
00:23:13.930 --> 00:23:19.694
But in 2005, he actually showed that these current sheets are violently unstable.

475
00:23:19.754 --> 00:23:24.077
And this is a slide that I got from one of his talks.

476
00:23:24.177 --> 00:23:24.277
Okay.

477
00:23:24.297 --> 00:23:24.417
Okay.

478
00:23:24.884 --> 00:23:27.985
Where in the beginning, he's like, does the sweet Parker Mogadal work?

479
00:23:28.066 --> 00:23:28.326
Sure.

480
00:23:28.646 --> 00:23:29.446
For this regime.

481
00:23:29.806 --> 00:23:32.668
And then he's like, maybe it doesn't.

482
00:23:32.788 --> 00:23:34.549
This guy was cheeky, dude.

483
00:23:34.589 --> 00:23:35.829
Yeah, it's kind of funny, right?

484
00:23:35.849 --> 00:23:37.150
So this is in 2005.

485
00:23:37.190 --> 00:23:40.932
He's doing numerical simulations to show exactly what would happen.

486
00:23:41.092 --> 00:23:44.433
And notice that there's this bubble that's forming.

487
00:23:44.593 --> 00:23:48.095
On the graphic that's to the right of these three examples where it says maybe it doesn't.

488
00:23:48.135 --> 00:23:49.116
Yeah, maybe it doesn't.

489
00:23:49.216 --> 00:23:50.777
And there's a sheet.

490
00:23:51.298 --> 00:23:55.161
And as the sheet is getting sort of stretched, there's a bubble that's forming.

491
00:23:55.181 --> 00:23:55.601
Okay.

492
00:23:55.961 --> 00:23:57.442
That is going to be the main...

493
00:23:58.496 --> 00:24:10.040
contribution that he makes in 2007 with a paper in the physics of plasmas with Laurario Shekhochhin and Cowley.

494
00:24:10.200 --> 00:24:10.380
Yes.

495
00:24:10.420 --> 00:24:11.861
This is the paper that makes him famous.

496
00:24:12.001 --> 00:24:12.281
Okay.

497
00:24:12.301 --> 00:24:12.541
Okay.

498
00:24:12.561 --> 00:24:14.282
This is the one that has the most citations.

499
00:24:14.482 --> 00:24:18.804
It's got like 800 citations, which in plasma physics is like unreal.

500
00:24:19.064 --> 00:24:22.385
Instability of current sheets and formation of plasmoid chains.

501
00:24:22.405 --> 00:24:23.567
Yeah, this is the...

502
00:24:23.607 --> 00:24:26.992
So he was at PPL at the time, Princeton Plasma Physics Lab.

503
00:24:27.052 --> 00:24:27.793
Yes.

504
00:24:28.153 --> 00:24:29.315
PPPL at the time.

505
00:24:29.716 --> 00:24:34.022
And this is the one that puts him on the map of plasma physics.

506
00:24:34.383 --> 00:24:36.486
Because he solves this 50-year-old problem.

507
00:24:36.526 --> 00:24:36.986
Problem.

508
00:24:37.862 --> 00:24:38.282
Not bad.

509
00:24:38.482 --> 00:24:39.162
Not bad.

510
00:24:39.202 --> 00:24:39.642
Not bad.

511
00:24:39.782 --> 00:24:40.263
Not bad.

512
00:24:40.363 --> 00:24:46.304
And for those who might not know, a lot of people tried to solve this problem.

513
00:24:46.404 --> 00:24:48.445
Yes, yes, yes.

514
00:24:48.465 --> 00:24:50.145
This was like a known problem.

515
00:24:50.425 --> 00:24:55.926
And he does it using just like good old-fashioned theoretical physics, analytical theory.

516
00:24:56.327 --> 00:25:00.828
And it's like, it's a technique that we've actually learned in grad school.

517
00:25:01.308 --> 00:25:03.408
But he applies it to this in a very ingenious way.

518
00:25:03.648 --> 00:25:05.729
And I don't, I'm not going to go into the...

519
00:25:06.450 --> 00:25:09.937
nitty-gritty detail, but effectively what he's doing is this, okay?

520
00:25:10.298 --> 00:25:12.502
He says, okay, I've got a thin current sheet, right?

521
00:25:12.963 --> 00:25:16.591
I've got this thin current sheet, and what's happening is...

522
00:25:17.609 --> 00:25:28.799
When I turn up the length scale of this guy and when I turn up the magnetic field of this guy, what's going to happen is that current sheet, which is the interface between the magnetic field going this way and this way.

523
00:25:28.859 --> 00:25:30.420
I want to be able to reconnect it.

524
00:25:30.781 --> 00:25:34.344
And the problem is that that reconnection is happening way faster than I want it to.

525
00:25:34.424 --> 00:25:36.606
Right, right, right.

526
00:25:36.666 --> 00:25:41.490
What he shows is the aspect ratio of that current sheet is...

527
00:25:41.730 --> 00:25:42.791
gets really small.

528
00:25:43.111 --> 00:25:43.331
Okay.

529
00:25:43.432 --> 00:25:43.692
Okay.

530
00:25:43.972 --> 00:25:49.977
At really high magnetic fields, the width of this guy is really small compared to the length of this guy.

531
00:25:50.357 --> 00:25:50.618
Okay.

532
00:25:50.738 --> 00:25:50.958
Okay.

533
00:25:51.058 --> 00:25:51.238
Okay.

534
00:25:51.258 --> 00:25:52.599
And then what he says is...

535
00:25:52.679 --> 00:25:54.221
Meaning it's like a twizzler.

536
00:25:54.501 --> 00:25:54.721
Yeah.

537
00:25:54.841 --> 00:25:55.222
Yeah.

538
00:25:55.262 --> 00:25:55.462
Right.

539
00:25:55.662 --> 00:25:57.203
And I'm like stretching it.

540
00:25:57.283 --> 00:25:58.144
I'm stretching it.

541
00:25:58.164 --> 00:25:58.284
Okay.

542
00:25:58.424 --> 00:25:58.644
Okay.

543
00:25:58.684 --> 00:26:00.146
It's a twizzler and I'm stretching it.

544
00:26:00.206 --> 00:26:00.446
Okay.

545
00:26:00.686 --> 00:26:00.786
Okay.

546
00:26:00.826 --> 00:26:00.966
Yeah.

547
00:26:01.107 --> 00:26:01.387
Yeah.

548
00:26:01.467 --> 00:26:04.810
And then what he does is he does something called perturbation.

549
00:26:05.250 --> 00:26:05.450
Yes.

550
00:26:05.611 --> 00:26:09.316
Which is, he says, okay, suppose I have this Twizzler and there's a tiny little bump.

551
00:26:09.536 --> 00:26:09.757
Yeah.

552
00:26:09.837 --> 00:26:11.659
Tiny little instability for whatever reason.

553
00:26:11.820 --> 00:26:11.960
Sure.

554
00:26:12.140 --> 00:26:12.300
Yeah.

555
00:26:12.340 --> 00:26:12.581
Okay.

556
00:26:12.881 --> 00:26:15.365
Can I trace what happens to that instability?

557
00:26:15.805 --> 00:26:16.046
Okay.

558
00:26:16.486 --> 00:26:20.512
If that instability goes down, if there's a restorative force.

559
00:26:20.632 --> 00:26:20.733
Yeah.

560
00:26:20.753 --> 00:26:20.953
Yeah.

561
00:26:21.113 --> 00:26:21.293
Right.

562
00:26:21.573 --> 00:26:25.497
Then that instability is going to go up and down and it's going to become a kind of like a harmonic oscillator.

563
00:26:25.537 --> 00:26:33.764
This is a very useful tool in graduate school physics is to understand perturbations and how those perturbations grow with time.

564
00:26:33.804 --> 00:26:33.964
Yep.

565
00:26:34.164 --> 00:26:34.324
Yep.

566
00:26:34.464 --> 00:26:44.193
But if there's an instability, then that tiny little fluctuation is going to magnify and create some kind of bigger instability, which will create a bigger instability.

567
00:26:44.713 --> 00:26:49.217
For laymen who might have seen the Aston Kutcher movie, it sounds a lot like the butterfly effect.

568
00:26:49.598 --> 00:26:50.238
Exactly.

569
00:26:50.579 --> 00:26:50.779
Right?

570
00:26:50.879 --> 00:26:56.824
Are we in this sort of chaotic regime where it's going to break free and start doing some random stuff?

571
00:26:56.884 --> 00:26:57.045
Right.

572
00:26:57.105 --> 00:26:57.285
Right.

573
00:26:57.325 --> 00:26:57.525
Okay.

574
00:26:58.346 --> 00:27:02.269
And what ends up happening is he shows that when you have this long sheet of stuff.

575
00:27:02.470 --> 00:27:02.570
Yes.

576
00:27:02.590 --> 00:27:02.690
Yes.

577
00:27:03.110 --> 00:27:08.913
It breaks into chains of smaller little plasmoids, is what he calls it.

578
00:27:09.053 --> 00:27:09.293
Okay.

579
00:27:09.313 --> 00:27:09.573
Okay?

580
00:27:09.913 --> 00:27:11.734
And they're these secondary sheets.

581
00:27:11.814 --> 00:27:18.637
And we've got a photo from exactly that, which is you've got this rubber band that you're stretching, right?

582
00:27:18.677 --> 00:27:18.897
Yes.

583
00:27:19.197 --> 00:27:25.340
And as you stretch that Twizzler, as you were saying, that Twizzler, as you stretch it, it's going to create little beads on it.

584
00:27:25.500 --> 00:27:28.882
To maintain its structure in some sense.

585
00:27:29.022 --> 00:27:29.342
Okay.

586
00:27:29.842 --> 00:27:30.003
Yes.

587
00:27:30.023 --> 00:27:30.243
Okay?

588
00:27:30.343 --> 00:27:30.543
Yes.

589
00:27:30.863 --> 00:27:35.566
And all of that stuff means that the timescale is going to be reduced by orders of magnitude.

590
00:27:36.166 --> 00:27:36.446
Okay.

591
00:27:36.566 --> 00:27:36.766
Got it.

592
00:27:36.786 --> 00:27:36.966
Right?

593
00:27:37.227 --> 00:27:40.628
Because now you're making the system smaller in some sense.

594
00:27:40.648 --> 00:27:40.869
Yes.

595
00:27:40.969 --> 00:27:41.149
Yes.

596
00:27:41.169 --> 00:27:41.349
Right?

597
00:27:42.169 --> 00:27:46.852
Like the system used to be this massive thing with a really large B field and a really large length scale.

598
00:27:47.152 --> 00:27:50.734
Now you're collapsing it into smaller and smaller length scales.

599
00:27:51.094 --> 00:28:01.297
So in this image, what we're seeing is at the top, there is, again, a long Twizzler, quote, unquote, and this example with small beads throughout it at varying sizes.

600
00:28:02.018 --> 00:28:08.620
And then as we go down, we see that those perturbations actually shorten the length of what we're seeing.

601
00:28:08.700 --> 00:28:15.462
And then those beads become more concentrated and larger, almost in their amplitude, right?

602
00:28:15.482 --> 00:28:15.622
Yeah.

603
00:28:15.762 --> 00:28:18.663
Right, because we're basically moving it from –

604
00:28:19.223 --> 00:28:23.348
like this big, a system that's this big to becoming smaller and smaller, right?

605
00:28:23.388 --> 00:28:23.768
Yes.

606
00:28:23.908 --> 00:28:28.133
And so now we're making like smaller and smaller systems with smaller Lundquist numbers.

607
00:28:28.153 --> 00:28:28.693
Yes, got it.

608
00:28:28.713 --> 00:28:29.374
Right?

609
00:28:29.554 --> 00:28:40.105
And now what he effectively showed is that the scaling that happens at this physics is no longer like one over the square root of the Lundquist number, but instead like

610
00:28:40.746 --> 00:28:59.213
the number to the power of something so it's not like a diminishing it's actually a growing thing right okay and this was just from first principles it's a beautiful paper yeah right that that he showed this um and so now he he can he can resolve that giant discrepancy yeah between time scales that we see right right right

611
00:28:59.573 --> 00:29:03.195
Because actually the thing that we're worried about, this is no longer a stable thing.

612
00:29:03.435 --> 00:29:07.857
As we make this thing bigger, it's going to sort of collapse into smaller things.

613
00:29:07.897 --> 00:29:12.119
And as those smaller things become bigger, it's going to collapse into even smaller things.

614
00:29:12.139 --> 00:29:18.922
It's like this weird fractally kind of self-similar thing where like the more you stretch, the smaller the beads become.

615
00:29:18.962 --> 00:29:22.604
And then you're going to make more beads the more you stretch.

616
00:29:22.924 --> 00:29:26.106
And you have this like fractally self-similar effect.

617
00:29:26.146 --> 00:29:26.326
Yes.

618
00:29:26.566 --> 00:29:27.167
That's happening.

619
00:29:27.287 --> 00:29:27.407
Yes.

620
00:29:27.527 --> 00:29:30.330
And this explains a bunch of stuff that we've noticed.

621
00:29:30.350 --> 00:29:32.973
Like that insight in and of itself.

622
00:29:33.113 --> 00:29:33.374
Yeah.

623
00:29:33.614 --> 00:29:33.854
Right.

624
00:29:34.775 --> 00:29:38.900
And the rigorous way in which he showed it in that 2007 paper.

625
00:29:39.020 --> 00:29:39.140
Right.

626
00:29:39.240 --> 00:29:42.384
It was very rigorous because he realized that one of the assumptions...

627
00:29:42.904 --> 00:29:45.266
that Sweet and Parker had made is no longer true, right?

628
00:29:45.326 --> 00:29:47.388
If I actually put in the dependence...

629
00:29:47.569 --> 00:29:51.652
He realized that there's this one term in the equation that they assume to be constant.

630
00:29:52.033 --> 00:29:55.937
But that term is actually dependent on the number itself, right?

631
00:29:55.997 --> 00:29:59.300
And when I put that in and I go through this perturbation analysis...

632
00:30:00.408 --> 00:30:01.129
Doesn't quite work.

633
00:30:01.229 --> 00:30:05.192
So a previously static variable was proven to be dynamic.

634
00:30:05.212 --> 00:30:05.472
Yes.

635
00:30:05.632 --> 00:30:10.737
And obviously, because it was not static but was dynamic, that was the key.

636
00:30:10.877 --> 00:30:14.600
It was a key unlock to then actually understanding the effects that we're trying to model.

637
00:30:14.620 --> 00:30:14.900
Yes, exactly.

638
00:30:14.980 --> 00:30:16.722
And it mattered for these big scales.

639
00:30:16.782 --> 00:30:17.002
Right.

640
00:30:17.202 --> 00:30:17.422
Right.

641
00:30:18.663 --> 00:30:19.664
similar to our hypersonics thing.

642
00:30:19.684 --> 00:30:22.746
It's like it didn't matter when you were at small scale, and so you could ignore it.

643
00:30:23.066 --> 00:30:36.635
But as soon as you start to go to larger scales, things that we label as constants for simplicity in order to be able to just keep the math simple, no longer can be applied and have consistent observable effects.

644
00:30:36.896 --> 00:30:37.076
Mm-hmm.

645
00:30:38.076 --> 00:30:39.778
Yeah, it's a very cool paper.

646
00:30:39.838 --> 00:30:41.860
Again, cited multiple times.

647
00:30:42.200 --> 00:30:44.822
And it applies to astrophysical plasma.

648
00:30:45.162 --> 00:30:48.265
For example, this is a picture of the Venus...

649
00:30:49.959 --> 00:31:13.500
toroid so this is what happens when the solar wind goes and impacts venus which has its own magnetic field and what you can see is you've got the stretching of the magnetic field because of the solar wind and on the top you've got a magnetic field going this way and on the bottom you've got a magnetic field going this way so what's going to happen you're going to get a little plasmoid you know because because those magnetic field lines want to sort of

650
00:31:14.470 --> 00:31:15.131
mesh together.

651
00:31:15.171 --> 00:31:16.232
They don't want to fight.

652
00:31:16.292 --> 00:31:16.493
Yes.

653
00:31:16.833 --> 00:31:16.993
Right?

654
00:31:17.273 --> 00:31:19.496
And so you get the little plasmoid that we were talking about.

655
00:31:19.957 --> 00:31:33.092
And you can see when we talk about the Venus Express, which is the probe that took measurements close to Venus, versus the Pioneer Venus Express, which took...

656
00:31:33.512 --> 00:31:44.153
measurements all the way out yeah it matches the fact that there's a strong magnetic field here and a weaker magnetic field there and the mathematics works out right yeah so it shows that in astrophysical plasma

657
00:31:45.139 --> 00:31:48.101
This hypothesis by Nuno is true.

658
00:31:49.222 --> 00:32:06.815
Just to double-click on that, the point being, Nuno's theory on paper, that can be proven mathematically on paper, had matching observable data from two different Mars, Venus, excuse me, probes, from different distances of where they measured.

659
00:32:07.216 --> 00:32:08.196
And that was...

660
00:32:09.397 --> 00:32:33.879
important in being able to show that it actually worked because we had two in two reference points of distance that's right where the measurements were coming in from and then so we could use the math that nuno sort of established and say does the math match at farther distance from the pvo this closer distance from the x and it and it did and it was great and crucially this is like on top of the fact that his theory

661
00:32:35.598 --> 00:32:38.740
reproduces the time skills that we see on the sun.

662
00:32:39.360 --> 00:32:39.560
Right.

663
00:32:40.340 --> 00:32:40.661
Yeah.

664
00:32:40.681 --> 00:32:42.602
The solar measurements also track.

665
00:32:42.682 --> 00:32:42.902
Yeah.

666
00:32:42.942 --> 00:32:51.286
The solar measurements, the fact that it takes hours to minutes for this reconnection to happen on the surface of the sun and the solar Corona and things like that, that's already taken care of.

667
00:32:51.346 --> 00:32:51.506
Right.

668
00:32:51.606 --> 00:32:52.567
And on top of that,

669
00:32:53.807 --> 00:32:56.789
He's now talking about the magnetic field around planets.

670
00:32:57.189 --> 00:32:59.990
And also in talkamaks, we've like literally seen this.

671
00:33:00.370 --> 00:33:06.153
So in talkamaks, which is a talkamak is like a donut shaped thing where we try to confine plasma.

672
00:33:06.633 --> 00:33:09.535
And in those talkamaks, you can see little plasmoids that form.

673
00:33:10.555 --> 00:33:16.057
And they format the scale that he suggests with this theory.

674
00:33:16.317 --> 00:33:19.538
And it lasts as long as what he suggests in the theory.

675
00:33:19.858 --> 00:33:27.961
And this becomes extremely useful when we are trying to replicate the sun on Earth for fusion research.

676
00:33:28.021 --> 00:33:28.241
Right.

677
00:33:28.821 --> 00:33:29.401
Right.

678
00:33:29.461 --> 00:33:31.582
Because while we have figured out...

679
00:33:32.222 --> 00:33:39.505
with nuclear weapons, how to create fission bombs, which I was just listening to something the other day, so correct me if I'm wrong.

680
00:33:39.525 --> 00:33:47.928
With a fission bomb, it's like you actually have the fission process is actually in the ignition to then create a fusion reaction after the fact.

681
00:33:48.048 --> 00:33:48.288
Yeah.

682
00:33:49.851 --> 00:33:59.417
But because of that two-step fission-fusion combination, that's where you get radioactive fallout as a result of that.

683
00:33:59.437 --> 00:34:06.662
Yeah, because you need a fission bomb in order to spark the fusion bomb.

684
00:34:06.903 --> 00:34:12.587
But if you were able to master fusion and have a pure fusion nuclear weapon—

685
00:34:13.693 --> 00:34:14.593
There would be no fallout.

686
00:34:14.774 --> 00:34:15.834
Yeah, there would be no fallout.

687
00:34:15.854 --> 00:34:22.657
Which would allow you, militarily, the strategy would be, now you can drop a nuke somewhere and have troops right nearby.

688
00:34:22.677 --> 00:34:23.217
Yeah.

689
00:34:23.377 --> 00:34:30.181
To be able to then go in post the fusion explosion because there would be no... Yeah, they'd have to wear sunscreen.

690
00:34:30.581 --> 00:34:30.781
Fair.

691
00:34:30.801 --> 00:34:32.161
Because you don't want the photons.

692
00:34:32.181 --> 00:34:33.262
It could be some distance away.

693
00:34:33.522 --> 00:34:36.122
Yeah, the photons are the main, you know.

694
00:34:36.363 --> 00:34:39.103
But at least you don't have to worry about, like, ionizing radiation.

695
00:34:39.363 --> 00:34:42.404
But, like, yeah, the other main thing is, like, with fusion, right?

696
00:34:42.504 --> 00:34:44.144
Fusion nuclear reactors, for example.

697
00:34:44.164 --> 00:34:44.244
Yes.

698
00:34:44.564 --> 00:34:46.504
Those are, like, relatively easy to control.

699
00:34:46.684 --> 00:34:46.924
Okay.

700
00:34:46.944 --> 00:34:47.224
Okay?

701
00:34:47.464 --> 00:34:49.405
Because you've got these rods of uranium.

702
00:34:49.585 --> 00:34:49.745
Yes.

703
00:34:49.865 --> 00:34:51.805
That are spitting out neutrons.

704
00:34:51.905 --> 00:34:52.105
Yes.

705
00:34:52.285 --> 00:34:56.926
And then in between you can have rods of graphite that slow down the neutrons.

706
00:34:56.966 --> 00:34:57.126
Yes.

707
00:34:57.366 --> 00:34:57.566
Right?

708
00:34:57.926 --> 00:35:01.547
And so you can have this sort of static nuclear reactor.

709
00:35:02.067 --> 00:35:04.149
That is creating heat, creating energy.

710
00:35:04.509 --> 00:35:09.554
That causes steam from water, and then that steam turns a turbine.

711
00:35:09.574 --> 00:35:10.274
Right, right, right, right.

712
00:35:10.334 --> 00:35:13.978
The heat creates motion, which turns a turbine.

713
00:35:13.998 --> 00:35:14.178
Yes.

714
00:35:14.558 --> 00:35:15.379
With fusion...

715
00:35:16.887 --> 00:35:18.268
Isolating fusion, right?

716
00:35:18.348 --> 00:35:19.829
Fusion is happening in plasma.

717
00:35:19.869 --> 00:35:22.231
It's not happening in solid materials.

718
00:35:22.551 --> 00:35:25.193
With fission, you have a rod of uranium.

719
00:35:25.233 --> 00:35:26.614
That thing is fissioning.

720
00:35:26.774 --> 00:35:26.994
Right.

721
00:35:27.074 --> 00:35:28.075
And it's creating energy.

722
00:35:28.435 --> 00:35:33.078
In order to create energy from fusion, you need this plasma, which is super hard to control.

723
00:35:33.158 --> 00:35:35.000
It's super hard to contain.

724
00:35:35.620 --> 00:35:35.960
And then...

725
00:35:37.822 --> 00:35:43.749
Once we have that, we need to have it self-sustaining and then create a heat source that then powers the turbine.

726
00:35:44.149 --> 00:35:45.411
It's a whole thing, right?

727
00:35:45.631 --> 00:35:49.675
And if we don't understand the mathematics fundamentally, then there's no hope.

728
00:35:50.606 --> 00:36:09.347
I will just note, we've talked about this off camera previously, but if you work in a classified program in plasma research and you've maybe figured out how to better control plasma for other use cases, declassify part of it so we can use it for fusion reactions.

729
00:36:09.367 --> 00:36:10.468
Yeah, that'd be great.

730
00:36:10.508 --> 00:36:11.209
Please and thank you.

731
00:36:11.349 --> 00:36:11.990
That'd be great.

732
00:36:14.262 --> 00:36:15.803
So that was his 2007 paper.

733
00:36:15.823 --> 00:36:16.443
Makes sense.

734
00:36:16.603 --> 00:36:17.344
Very big deal.

735
00:36:17.764 --> 00:36:18.304
Huge deal, yes.

736
00:36:18.344 --> 00:36:19.785
He won a bunch of awards for it.

737
00:36:20.085 --> 00:36:20.705
Well-deserved.

738
00:36:20.865 --> 00:36:21.686
Yes.

739
00:36:21.846 --> 00:36:22.626
Can't win a Nobel.

740
00:36:22.846 --> 00:36:23.967
Yeah.

741
00:36:24.187 --> 00:36:24.968
Yeah, not anymore.

742
00:36:25.008 --> 00:36:26.408
Which is really crazy.

743
00:36:26.448 --> 00:36:27.969
Yeah, yeah.

744
00:36:28.869 --> 00:36:31.331
He probably would have been on the shortlist because...

745
00:36:32.631 --> 00:36:35.293
In the future of his life, so that was at Princeton Plasma Physics Lab.

746
00:36:35.333 --> 00:36:36.373
He was kind of a postdoc.

747
00:36:36.754 --> 00:36:39.455
Then he became a professor at MIT, became full professor.

748
00:36:39.775 --> 00:36:45.478
And in 2004, he was the director of the Plasma Science and Fusion Center at MIT.

749
00:36:45.878 --> 00:36:55.844
And that MIT PSFC spun out and created Commonwealth Fusion Systems, which is designing something called SPARK.

750
00:36:56.324 --> 00:36:58.385
It is a small fusion reactor.

751
00:36:58.425 --> 00:36:59.966
I mean, this, it looks kind of big.

752
00:37:00.406 --> 00:37:01.447
Mate, compared to...

753
00:37:02.167 --> 00:37:05.289
Like compared to fusion reactors, that is small.

754
00:37:05.429 --> 00:37:06.870
Okay.

755
00:37:06.930 --> 00:37:08.351
That is quite small.

756
00:37:08.431 --> 00:37:12.793
The goal is to be the first device to achieve a Q factor greater than one.

757
00:37:12.813 --> 00:37:19.077
A Q factor is basically net energy gain, which is how much energy you put in, how much do you get out, the ratio of that.

758
00:37:19.377 --> 00:37:23.320
If you have greater than one, then whatever is that greater than one is...

759
00:37:24.040 --> 00:37:27.982
you can use to power a turbine, which creates electricity.

760
00:37:28.042 --> 00:37:39.386
There was actually, wasn't there an announcement in the last two or three years that one of the national labs achieved net energy gain for some small period of time?

761
00:37:39.506 --> 00:37:40.286
It was very small.

762
00:37:40.886 --> 00:37:43.487
But that was a first of some kind?

763
00:37:43.507 --> 00:37:49.710
It was a first of some kind because, so I don't remember the details, but what ended up happening was they had a diamond anvil cell

764
00:37:50.510 --> 00:37:53.754
with two diamonds attached to each other.

765
00:37:53.874 --> 00:37:55.035
We've covered this actually.

766
00:37:55.055 --> 00:37:56.537
Yeah, we actually covered this.

767
00:37:56.777 --> 00:38:01.242
And inside was a hydrogen deuterium mixture.

768
00:38:01.362 --> 00:38:06.167
And then they put lasers that created fusion inside of that diamond anvil cell.

769
00:38:06.407 --> 00:38:12.634
And they said that, yeah, the amount of energy of the lasers was less than the amount of energy that came out of the fusion.

770
00:38:12.894 --> 00:38:16.819
But like to make the lasers, you know, it's... Look, they're not...

771
00:38:16.899 --> 00:38:20.583
I don't think their end goal is to create... For sure.

772
00:38:20.943 --> 00:38:23.887
Fusion electric power from that, okay?

773
00:38:23.907 --> 00:38:24.768
Because like, what?

774
00:38:24.788 --> 00:38:26.850
You're just going to keep shooting lasers in this?

775
00:38:27.291 --> 00:38:31.956
And then how do I get the energy out of that to come out and like do a turbine?

776
00:38:31.996 --> 00:38:32.177
Yeah.

777
00:38:32.597 --> 00:38:34.437
There's a lot of question marks, okay?

778
00:38:34.617 --> 00:38:38.338
It's probably weapons, if I'm honest.

779
00:38:38.398 --> 00:38:39.698
But it was still very cool.

780
00:38:39.798 --> 00:38:42.379
It was, I believe, Lawrence Livermore lab that was doing it.

781
00:38:42.399 --> 00:38:43.139
That tracks to me.

782
00:38:43.219 --> 00:38:45.020
California again.

783
00:38:45.340 --> 00:38:46.420
California forever, goodbye.

784
00:38:46.460 --> 00:38:47.520
Yeah.

785
00:38:47.620 --> 00:39:01.203
So, talk max, like the spark, the spark is something that is trying to contain plasma, and it's trying to create fusion in the plasma, and then it's trying to then offload that energy to create electricity.

786
00:39:01.283 --> 00:39:01.483
Right.

787
00:39:03.044 --> 00:39:06.127
And it's designed to have this Q factor of greater than one.

788
00:39:07.008 --> 00:39:21.283
It's using actually high temperature superconducting magnets, which means at about 20 Kelvin, which is actually quite hot for superconductors, they're using these rare earth barium copper oxide Rebco magnets that...

789
00:39:22.481 --> 00:39:27.002
And effectively, what they're trying to do is have these magnets go at 12 Tesla.

790
00:39:27.342 --> 00:39:29.563
12 Tesla is insanely strong.

791
00:39:29.603 --> 00:39:29.923
Yeah.

792
00:39:30.043 --> 00:39:30.343
Okay?

793
00:39:30.483 --> 00:39:31.064
Yeah.

794
00:39:31.224 --> 00:39:34.225
Several orders of magnitude above the magnetic field of the Earth.

795
00:39:34.245 --> 00:39:34.685
Okay.

796
00:39:34.765 --> 00:39:42.627
And what they're doing is using these magnets to confine the plasma into a donut, spin it around really fast.

797
00:39:42.667 --> 00:39:42.927
Yes.

798
00:39:43.127 --> 00:39:45.748
And then have that plasma in that spinning...

799
00:39:46.765 --> 00:39:47.505
do the fusion.

800
00:39:47.585 --> 00:39:47.785
Yes.

801
00:39:47.966 --> 00:39:51.947
So the hydrogen is going to combine to make helium release a bunch of energy.

802
00:39:51.967 --> 00:39:52.107
Yes.

803
00:39:52.207 --> 00:39:54.168
And then that energy is going to be used to create electricity.

804
00:39:54.188 --> 00:39:55.429
That's what they're going to try to capture.

805
00:39:55.449 --> 00:39:59.590
And the point is you need that 12 Tesla because you need to be able to confine it.

806
00:39:59.951 --> 00:40:02.072
And that's the reason for that scale.

807
00:40:02.252 --> 00:40:02.692
Exactly.

808
00:40:02.772 --> 00:40:04.953
And at that scale, all of a sudden,

809
00:40:06.130 --> 00:40:25.533
um lorero's legacy matters right all of the theories that he's he's posited at these like high lundquist numbers yes that's what matters so any any code that you have to contain the plasma needs to rely on his theory so there's going to be a bunch of plasmoids that are dominant in that in that talk about

810
00:40:25.913 --> 00:40:27.415
The point is you could not use this.

811
00:40:27.595 --> 00:40:34.003
If you were trying to do fusion energy and you are focused on how do we contain the plasma, you cannot use the Sweet Parker model.

812
00:40:34.103 --> 00:40:34.804
No.

813
00:40:35.004 --> 00:40:37.187
And if you'd be completely wrecked.

814
00:40:37.287 --> 00:40:45.016
But for Nuno, you wouldn't necessarily have a framework for how to even do the math to do the containment of the plasma at that scale.

815
00:40:45.236 --> 00:40:45.697
Exactly.

816
00:40:45.777 --> 00:40:52.085
So when all these AI, all these billionaires and hyperscalers and frontier model companies are saying, we need more energy.

817
00:40:52.205 --> 00:40:55.889
And they're now investing in the small fusion reactor.

818
00:40:55.909 --> 00:40:58.412
It's like now a buzz term in Silicon Valley.

819
00:40:58.453 --> 00:41:01.416
And everyone's investing in all these new companies trying to do it.

820
00:41:01.456 --> 00:41:01.656
Yeah.

821
00:41:02.297 --> 00:41:04.278
All of them have to bend the knees.

822
00:41:04.398 --> 00:41:04.878
All of them.

823
00:41:04.958 --> 00:41:15.721
And be grateful that Nuno did this work because that math is now enabling the innovation for a small form factor fusion nuclear reactors.

824
00:41:15.841 --> 00:41:16.842
And exactly.

825
00:41:16.942 --> 00:41:19.362
With the tokamak design framework.

826
00:41:19.423 --> 00:41:19.783
You got it.

827
00:41:19.903 --> 00:41:20.943
You got it exactly right.

828
00:41:21.043 --> 00:41:21.223
Yeah.

829
00:41:21.583 --> 00:41:23.584
I mean, it's a fundamental science thing.

830
00:41:23.684 --> 00:41:23.844
Right.

831
00:41:23.904 --> 00:41:24.104
Right.

832
00:41:24.164 --> 00:41:26.745
Like, why does the solar corona work the way it does?

833
00:41:26.785 --> 00:41:26.945
Right.

834
00:41:27.465 --> 00:41:28.486
Like, that's how it started.

835
00:41:28.506 --> 00:41:29.106
That's how it starts.

836
00:41:29.126 --> 00:41:35.570
And then how it's going is we've got now maybe a path to create actual fusion on Earth.

837
00:41:36.511 --> 00:41:40.714
Which, again, like, fusion changes everything.

838
00:41:40.874 --> 00:41:41.134
Yeah.

839
00:41:41.634 --> 00:41:42.074
No, no.

840
00:41:42.094 --> 00:41:42.615
Oh, my God.

841
00:41:42.675 --> 00:41:43.495
It changes everything.

842
00:41:43.515 --> 00:41:44.836
It would be ridiculous.

843
00:41:45.277 --> 00:41:46.978
It would be ridiculous if we could get this going.

844
00:41:47.218 --> 00:41:47.558
Right.

845
00:41:47.818 --> 00:41:50.020
And we're now, people are...

846
00:41:51.749 --> 00:42:13.448
So on all the advertisements and stuff I see in the XC, they're now passing simulation tests, right, with different design types, and they're now transitioning into, like, real-world scaled versions of this, which means, like, this is now, like, this is not theoretical in terms of application anymore.

847
00:42:13.488 --> 00:42:17.251
No, this is, like, at Commonwealth Fusion Systems, they're actually doing it.

848
00:42:17.291 --> 00:42:18.132
They're, like, making it.

849
00:42:18.232 --> 00:42:18.432
Right.

850
00:42:18.692 --> 00:42:18.912
You know?

851
00:42:18.932 --> 00:42:19.813
Oh, God.

852
00:42:20.210 --> 00:42:21.271
It's crazy.

853
00:42:21.291 --> 00:42:22.211
We might be close.

854
00:42:22.291 --> 00:42:22.871
We might be.

855
00:42:23.652 --> 00:42:24.632
Let's knock on wood.

856
00:42:24.852 --> 00:42:25.112
Yeah.

857
00:42:25.272 --> 00:42:37.718
But it was, you know, Nuno Loreiro's work really underpins that fundamental science really underpins all of the stuff that these guys are doing, you know, that could truly change the world.

858
00:42:37.918 --> 00:42:41.760
This is why, again, academia and grants for science.

859
00:42:42.380 --> 00:42:45.521
Foundational science is hugely meaningful.

860
00:42:45.941 --> 00:42:51.804
And now the timescales of going from research lab to end product are shortening greatly.

861
00:42:51.884 --> 00:42:52.104
Yeah.

862
00:42:52.204 --> 00:42:53.884
For all the reasons we've talked about all season.

863
00:42:53.964 --> 00:42:54.184
Yeah.

864
00:42:54.464 --> 00:42:54.625
Right?

865
00:42:54.645 --> 00:43:00.067
Like, it's no longer a 30, 40, 50-year cycle in between fundamental discovery.

866
00:43:00.267 --> 00:43:00.527
That's 2007.

867
00:43:00.547 --> 00:43:00.747
Mm-hmm.

868
00:43:00.767 --> 00:43:01.147
20 years.

869
00:43:01.247 --> 00:43:01.847
It's already...

870
00:43:04.268 --> 00:43:05.228
That's crazy.

871
00:43:05.248 --> 00:43:05.828
That's crazy.

872
00:43:05.888 --> 00:43:06.549
That's crazy.

873
00:43:06.669 --> 00:43:06.909
Yeah.

874
00:43:07.089 --> 00:43:07.929
Yeah.

875
00:43:08.009 --> 00:43:09.069
I think it's amazing.

876
00:43:09.189 --> 00:43:14.950
And, you know, the stuff that he did at PPPL, that's probably a DOE contract.

877
00:43:14.970 --> 00:43:15.930
Yep.

878
00:43:16.230 --> 00:43:23.652
I guarantee you there was no private funding when all these people say, oh, like, you know, maybe the private funders could, like, do fundamental science research.

879
00:43:23.712 --> 00:43:24.612
No.

880
00:43:24.692 --> 00:43:28.653
He was trying to figure out, like, why is this 50-year-old model of plasma wrong?

881
00:43:28.673 --> 00:43:28.813
Right.

882
00:43:30.237 --> 00:43:31.840
No one was... No one cared.

883
00:43:31.980 --> 00:43:41.633
No, because it was so far away that no VC would be like, I'm going to see this fruitful at the end of my life.

884
00:43:41.653 --> 00:43:42.134
Yeah.

885
00:43:42.345 --> 00:43:53.475
there was this interesting thing that Demis Asabas, who runs Google DeepMind, was kind of talking about where he's like, they were talking about hallucinations in AI models.

886
00:43:54.116 --> 00:43:59.540
And his whole thing was like, some hallucinations are actually kind of good because there's this whole sort of...

887
00:44:01.990 --> 00:44:12.954
you know, phrase, uh, like phrasing where it's like inventions, all inventions didn't come from explicitly knowing that you, you wanted the outcome of the invention when you were going through the discovery process.

888
00:44:13.374 --> 00:44:13.574
Right.

889
00:44:13.814 --> 00:44:16.495
Like a lot of times inventions come from curiosity and,

890
00:44:17.548 --> 00:44:23.991
And just exploration that then leads to an insight that then converts into an invention.

891
00:44:24.251 --> 00:44:27.353
But you don't always start saying, I want to create a light bulb and then create a light bulb.

892
00:44:27.373 --> 00:44:27.933
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

893
00:44:27.973 --> 00:44:28.133
Right?

894
00:44:28.173 --> 00:44:37.618
And so you kind of need this surface area of exploration that is not tied to shareholder value or an already known end product.

895
00:44:37.638 --> 00:44:38.698
It's just how does it work.

896
00:44:38.738 --> 00:44:39.399
How does it work?

897
00:44:39.499 --> 00:44:42.200
And then once you know how it works, then all of a sudden it's like, wait, wait.

898
00:44:42.220 --> 00:44:43.281
Well, I could – yeah.

899
00:44:43.481 --> 00:44:46.062
Now all of a sudden maybe –

900
00:44:47.145 --> 00:44:50.907
Maybe a small fusion containment thing could actually work.

901
00:44:51.427 --> 00:44:52.748
Because now we know everything, right?

902
00:44:52.788 --> 00:44:52.928
Right.

903
00:44:53.008 --> 00:45:00.732
And now we have high-frequency computing, and we have AI, and we have means to control plasma really effectively, right?

904
00:45:01.012 --> 00:45:06.114
So it's all of the stuff compounding that really gives a lot of these startups room to breathe.

905
00:45:06.194 --> 00:45:06.374
Right.

906
00:45:06.774 --> 00:45:06.955
Right.

907
00:45:06.975 --> 00:45:07.335
Right.

908
00:45:07.355 --> 00:45:07.495
Right.

909
00:45:08.055 --> 00:45:12.239
Yeah, so it's really quite an amazing story.

910
00:45:12.259 --> 00:45:17.524
Nuno Lurario, MIT professor, very unfortunate death.

911
00:45:17.564 --> 00:45:18.344
Yeah.

912
00:45:18.564 --> 00:45:23.569
And also the way that it happened through gun violence, like in his apartment in Boston.

913
00:45:23.609 --> 00:45:25.391
Like, that just sucks.

914
00:45:25.691 --> 00:45:28.133
It's the American story in the modern era.

915
00:45:28.353 --> 00:45:31.556
Yeah, and apparently all we can do is thoughts and prayers.

916
00:45:31.636 --> 00:45:32.537
Look, yeah.

917
00:45:33.238 --> 00:45:36.241
I guess, yeah, thoughts and prayers to his family, and I wish we could do more.

918
00:45:36.361 --> 00:45:40.206
And thank you, Nuno, for what you've provided to humanity.

919
00:45:40.446 --> 00:45:41.688
Yeah, this is amazing.

920
00:45:41.848 --> 00:45:42.949
Amazing legacy.

921
00:45:43.289 --> 00:45:44.391
If we figure out fusion.

922
00:45:44.871 --> 00:45:45.432
Yeah, no.

923
00:45:46.033 --> 00:45:52.240
And if the Nobel Prize was given to posthumous people, he'd be one of them.

924
00:45:52.420 --> 00:46:15.727
yeah um we wanted to make sure we covered this again there's no there's literally no information about what happened yeah yeah it's super unclear actually so it's it's you know there's a lot of weird you know it is yeah you know we'll see what happens and um you know the best to those who knew him his colleagues and his family who you know and his mentors mentors i bet there's a bunch of students that are just

925
00:46:15.927 --> 00:46:30.159
We're just struggling and please, you know, we hope that those around him at the lab, you know, once grieving has passed, you know, continue to aggressively pursue his vision.

926
00:46:30.319 --> 00:46:30.580
Yeah.

927
00:46:31.080 --> 00:46:35.804
And, and, and the work that he's already done because it's, it's a huge foundation.

928
00:46:35.944 --> 00:46:36.405
Yeah, yeah.

929
00:46:36.565 --> 00:46:38.567
I mean, it's amazing, you know?

930
00:46:38.728 --> 00:46:39.889
And it could change the world.

931
00:46:39.909 --> 00:46:41.431
It could literally change the world.

932
00:46:41.451 --> 00:46:45.356
It could be one of the biggest things that happens in the 21st century.

933
00:46:45.396 --> 00:46:48.420
If you're a climate change person, like, you should be all over this.

934
00:46:48.460 --> 00:46:49.441
This is big.

935
00:46:49.502 --> 00:46:50.262
This is a big deal.

936
00:46:50.869 --> 00:46:54.031
We're going to now transition into our season one recap.

937
00:46:54.152 --> 00:46:54.612
Yeah.

938
00:46:55.653 --> 00:46:58.015
19 episodes.

939
00:46:59.115 --> 00:46:59.976
Unbelievable.

940
00:47:00.256 --> 00:47:02.118
Just we covered.

941
00:47:02.178 --> 00:47:04.039
There's so many interesting things that happened this year.

942
00:47:04.239 --> 00:47:04.640
Yeah.

943
00:47:05.720 --> 00:47:07.081
And it was really hard to choose.

944
00:47:07.262 --> 00:47:08.102
Yeah, it really was.

945
00:47:08.643 --> 00:47:09.543
It was hard to choose.

946
00:47:10.004 --> 00:47:12.185
It looks like we're going to start with my five.

947
00:47:12.205 --> 00:47:12.346
Yeah.

948
00:47:12.366 --> 00:47:13.506
We're going to start with your five.

949
00:47:13.947 --> 00:47:15.028
And again, I'm,

950
00:47:15.768 --> 00:47:16.929
I loved all of them.

951
00:47:16.949 --> 00:47:18.490
I think we did 48 total stories.

952
00:47:18.670 --> 00:47:26.196
No, I mean, you know what's interesting is, like, I learned so much with each of the ones that I had to research.

953
00:47:26.236 --> 00:47:26.416
Yeah.

954
00:47:26.816 --> 00:47:28.518
And, like, really get into it.

955
00:47:28.578 --> 00:47:28.738
Yeah.

956
00:47:28.918 --> 00:47:31.340
You know, because we're not in the business of...

957
00:47:32.692 --> 00:47:33.513
Of just talking.

958
00:47:33.633 --> 00:47:34.274
Yeah, right.

959
00:47:35.295 --> 00:47:36.696
I was like, what is this figure?

960
00:47:37.577 --> 00:47:38.819
Right, right, right.

961
00:47:39.119 --> 00:47:44.265
You know, but I learned so much and I just love that we started this podcast.

962
00:47:44.965 --> 00:47:51.412
And again, every single one of the 48 stories we covered this year are incredible, literally on their own.

963
00:47:51.512 --> 00:47:51.733
Yeah.

964
00:47:51.893 --> 00:47:54.295
And so just because it's not included in the top 10 doesn't mean it's not good.

965
00:47:54.335 --> 00:47:54.716
However.

966
00:47:54.896 --> 00:47:59.297
Yeah, and let us know in the comments if we missed one of your favorites.

967
00:47:59.317 --> 00:48:00.817
One of your favorites.

968
00:48:01.097 --> 00:48:03.778
But I think these are quite good.

969
00:48:03.998 --> 00:48:05.018
These are all quite good.

970
00:48:05.638 --> 00:48:08.459
Again, based on what they are about.

971
00:48:08.739 --> 00:48:09.879
And in no particular order.

972
00:48:10.259 --> 00:48:11.380
Yeah, these are not ranked.

973
00:48:11.520 --> 00:48:12.220
These are not ranked.

974
00:48:12.240 --> 00:48:12.840
It's just top ten.

975
00:48:12.900 --> 00:48:13.400
So, okay.

976
00:48:13.480 --> 00:48:19.981
So, from my list of five, the first one we're going to cover or touch on is the Vera Rubin Observatory.

977
00:48:20.161 --> 00:48:21.022
Yes.

978
00:48:21.382 --> 00:48:22.122
Episode four.

979
00:48:22.142 --> 00:48:22.242
Yeah.

980
00:48:23.583 --> 00:48:24.224
This was amazing.

981
00:48:24.244 --> 00:48:25.125
This was really good.

982
00:48:25.165 --> 00:48:27.688
So for those who know, I'm the UFO guy on the pod.

983
00:48:27.768 --> 00:48:28.088
Yeah.

984
00:48:28.609 --> 00:48:35.157
And so, you know, obviously anything that's going to help us better understand the universe around us, I'm all for.

985
00:48:35.417 --> 00:48:38.981
But I think the thing that really got me going about this episode was the...

986
00:48:40.403 --> 00:48:41.364
There was a couple of things.

987
00:48:41.464 --> 00:48:42.204
It's the scale.

988
00:48:42.244 --> 00:48:46.568
The way you described it, I think, in the episode was we're moving from photo to video.

989
00:48:46.768 --> 00:48:47.749
Yeah.

990
00:48:47.889 --> 00:48:48.509
In astronomy.

991
00:48:48.549 --> 00:48:48.769
Yeah.

992
00:48:49.350 --> 00:48:50.651
And that resonated.

993
00:48:50.671 --> 00:48:52.873
Of the entire southern night sky.

994
00:48:52.933 --> 00:48:53.133
Right.

995
00:48:53.353 --> 00:49:01.379
Like the scale difference between what we knew before and what we will now know and also the daily data dumps and accessibility.

996
00:49:01.679 --> 00:49:03.341
There's so many great aspects to the story.

997
00:49:03.421 --> 00:49:04.381
Yeah.

998
00:49:04.541 --> 00:49:05.182
I love this one.

999
00:49:05.242 --> 00:49:09.107
Yeah, and this one, you know, so I was looking up like, you know, what they've been doing.

1000
00:49:09.548 --> 00:49:13.132
They've just been doing what they normally do, which is just data dumps.

1001
00:49:13.553 --> 00:49:18.058
And now there's just so much data and astronomers are wrangling with how do we, how do we,

1002
00:49:18.987 --> 00:49:20.249
interpret all of this data.

1003
00:49:20.289 --> 00:49:20.469
Yes.

1004
00:49:20.649 --> 00:49:20.869
Right.

1005
00:49:21.270 --> 00:49:23.753
But one of the few things that I wanted to highlight.

1006
00:49:24.213 --> 00:49:28.498
So there's one photo of the galaxy M61 messy object.

1007
00:49:28.658 --> 00:49:29.159
M61.

1008
00:49:29.199 --> 00:49:30.140
You see that thread?

1009
00:49:30.700 --> 00:49:30.921
Yes.

1010
00:49:30.981 --> 00:49:34.064
That's coming out of the bottom right galaxy.

1011
00:49:34.104 --> 00:49:34.325
Yes.

1012
00:49:34.825 --> 00:49:36.107
We didn't know that existed before.

1013
00:49:36.127 --> 00:49:36.227
Yeah.

1014
00:49:37.628 --> 00:49:42.451
That's just a thread of stars that's just getting ejected by that galaxy.

1015
00:49:42.471 --> 00:49:43.171
That's unbelievable.

1016
00:49:43.191 --> 00:49:43.991
And that's crazy.

1017
00:49:44.011 --> 00:49:44.392
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1018
00:49:44.412 --> 00:49:46.193
Because first of all, what?

1019
00:49:46.393 --> 00:49:47.373
Yeah.

1020
00:49:47.433 --> 00:49:48.974
Why is there just a...

1021
00:49:49.654 --> 00:49:51.676
It's like a water gun of stars.

1022
00:49:51.756 --> 00:49:52.296
Stars.

1023
00:49:52.656 --> 00:49:53.476
Just getting shot out.

1024
00:49:53.537 --> 00:49:55.738
Just getting shot out by a galaxy.

1025
00:49:55.978 --> 00:49:56.438
Stars.

1026
00:49:56.818 --> 00:49:57.659
Yeah, stars.

1027
00:49:58.659 --> 00:50:00.860
Across many light years.

1028
00:50:00.940 --> 00:50:02.861
Hundreds and thousands of light years.

1029
00:50:03.122 --> 00:50:05.443
Just getting shot out for who knows how long.

1030
00:50:05.483 --> 00:50:06.303
Because the...

1031
00:50:07.944 --> 00:50:09.466
The trail is quite long, right?

1032
00:50:09.486 --> 00:50:12.650
So it's just been doing it in one direction for a very long time.

1033
00:50:12.670 --> 00:50:14.091
We've never seen that before.

1034
00:50:14.151 --> 00:50:14.952
That's crazy.

1035
00:50:14.972 --> 00:50:15.793
Never seen that before.

1036
00:50:16.133 --> 00:50:21.299
So that's Messy Object 61, which, by the way, the fact that it has a name M61 means that

1037
00:50:23.425 --> 00:50:29.473
It's been studied since Messier created that catalog.

1038
00:50:29.874 --> 00:50:30.154
Okay?

1039
00:50:30.214 --> 00:50:31.817
And we didn't know that that existed.

1040
00:50:32.157 --> 00:50:32.457
Okay?

1041
00:50:32.477 --> 00:50:33.279
So this is new.

1042
00:50:33.339 --> 00:50:33.879
Brand new.

1043
00:50:33.939 --> 00:50:34.120
Yes.

1044
00:50:34.340 --> 00:50:34.921
Which is crazy.

1045
00:50:34.941 --> 00:50:35.121
Yes.

1046
00:50:35.381 --> 00:50:37.825
And the second one is a photo of the Virgo cluster.

1047
00:50:37.845 --> 00:50:37.925
Yes.

1048
00:50:37.965 --> 00:50:38.145
Yes.

1049
00:50:39.167 --> 00:50:40.187
Beautiful photo.

1050
00:50:40.548 --> 00:50:42.968
And you can see how diffuse those galaxies are.

1051
00:50:42.988 --> 00:50:43.389
Okay?

1052
00:50:43.989 --> 00:50:47.830
The key thing is, this is an average of about a thousand images.

1053
00:50:47.850 --> 00:50:52.212
They probably have tens of thousands now, but this is an average of a thousand images.

1054
00:50:52.252 --> 00:50:56.314
And when you average a thousand images, the signal to noise ratio goes up, right?

1055
00:50:56.354 --> 00:50:58.494
The noise goes down because you're averaging.

1056
00:50:58.574 --> 00:51:04.637
And you see how those diffuse like clouds of just stars, that's not something we've seen before.

1057
00:51:05.377 --> 00:51:09.883
Like on the right-hand side, you've just got this random cloud with no real structure.

1058
00:51:10.564 --> 00:51:14.108
We're seeing like a bunch of those in the Vera Rubin, right?

1059
00:51:14.168 --> 00:51:16.071
Those are galaxies that we've never seen before.

1060
00:51:16.977 --> 00:51:20.400
Because usually we're like, oh, spiral galaxies, they're like concentrated.

1061
00:51:20.540 --> 00:51:22.321
Now we just got a cloud of like stars.

1062
00:51:22.341 --> 00:51:23.182
Yeah, right, right, right.

1063
00:51:23.602 --> 00:51:24.723
But we can now identify.

1064
00:51:25.304 --> 00:51:32.329
Because we're taking so many photos of the exact same patch of sky over and over again that we can average.

1065
00:51:32.629 --> 00:51:40.095
And the signal to noise ratio goes like square root of N. So the more we take photos of, the lower that noise becomes.

1066
00:51:40.395 --> 00:51:44.419
And we can really start seeing this incredible detail, right?

1067
00:51:44.439 --> 00:51:44.879
Yeah.

1068
00:51:44.939 --> 00:51:46.080
we're turning the light.

1069
00:51:46.100 --> 00:51:55.692
Like we, we, I can't emphasize enough how little we've actually looked like if earth, if like, if our solar system is like a house, right?

1070
00:51:55.732 --> 00:51:56.172
No, no.

1071
00:51:56.293 --> 00:51:59.396
We've, we've barely looked out of one of the windows of the house.

1072
00:51:59.416 --> 00:52:01.078
No, we've seen Zillow photos.

1073
00:52:01.138 --> 00:52:01.499
Yeah.

1074
00:52:03.451 --> 00:52:04.393
That's what it is, dude.

1075
00:52:04.553 --> 00:52:05.995
Like, we... Yeah.

1076
00:52:06.396 --> 00:52:08.880
If our universe is a house, we've seen Zillow photos.

1077
00:52:09.020 --> 00:52:09.541
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1078
00:52:09.621 --> 00:52:09.801
Yeah.

1079
00:52:09.961 --> 00:52:10.422
Right, right.

1080
00:52:10.722 --> 00:52:14.969
Like, we've not... And now we're, like, putting in, like, ring cameras, you know?

1081
00:52:14.989 --> 00:52:18.134
To really see in a different room, like, the...

1082
00:52:19.255 --> 00:52:24.436
And the volume of data that it's producing is such that, you know.

1083
00:52:24.516 --> 00:52:25.296
Yeah.

1084
00:52:26.117 --> 00:52:30.057
And now it's up to the astronomers to really try to crunch through.

1085
00:52:30.357 --> 00:52:32.678
We've identified like thousands of asteroids.

1086
00:52:32.818 --> 00:52:32.978
Yep.

1087
00:52:33.358 --> 00:52:37.119
We've identified thousands of transient objects.

1088
00:52:37.239 --> 00:52:38.499
It's going to be great, dude.

1089
00:52:38.639 --> 00:52:41.400
And the more sophisticated the algorithms get, the better it'll be.

1090
00:52:41.420 --> 00:52:42.200
And it's open source.

1091
00:52:42.400 --> 00:52:42.600
Yeah.

1092
00:52:42.980 --> 00:52:43.920
Open science.

1093
00:52:44.081 --> 00:52:45.141
That's what's great about it.

1094
00:52:45.201 --> 00:52:47.662
That's your U.S. taxpayer funding.

1095
00:52:47.722 --> 00:52:47.902
Right.

1096
00:52:48.162 --> 00:52:52.684
Going into just like, we got a ring camera on the universe now.

1097
00:52:53.204 --> 00:52:55.845
That's a great way to spend taxpayer money.

1098
00:52:55.865 --> 00:52:56.085
100%.

1099
00:52:56.205 --> 00:52:56.846
Oh, my gosh.

1100
00:52:56.866 --> 00:52:57.306
100%.

1101
00:52:57.366 --> 00:52:58.026
Yeah.

1102
00:52:58.146 --> 00:52:59.187
Aliens coming soon.

1103
00:53:00.187 --> 00:53:04.389
Story number two, K218B DMS dimethyl sulfide?

1104
00:53:04.409 --> 00:53:05.269
Dimethyl sulfide.

1105
00:53:05.289 --> 00:53:05.909
Look at me.

1106
00:53:05.989 --> 00:53:08.370
I'm learning something this season, y'all.

1107
00:53:08.470 --> 00:53:08.991
Episode 8.

1108
00:53:09.891 --> 00:53:11.072
That was episode eight.

1109
00:53:11.092 --> 00:53:13.714
This was the drama.

1110
00:53:13.734 --> 00:53:17.316
This was the best evidence yet.

1111
00:53:17.396 --> 00:53:19.197
Yeah, best evidence yet on BBC.

1112
00:53:19.217 --> 00:53:20.278
Yeah, of life.

1113
00:53:20.398 --> 00:53:21.378
And then a week later.

1114
00:53:21.419 --> 00:53:22.639
Later, immediately.

1115
00:53:22.899 --> 00:53:28.223
And so I think the reason I like this story is because we really covered how the peer review process works.

1116
00:53:28.323 --> 00:53:28.563
Yeah.

1117
00:53:28.824 --> 00:53:33.028
When the delta between the news headline and where the science is.

1118
00:53:33.108 --> 00:53:33.329
Yeah.

1119
00:53:33.509 --> 00:53:37.714
And how each of these universities or labs is competing.

1120
00:53:37.814 --> 00:53:38.554
Yeah.

1121
00:53:39.055 --> 00:53:43.120
And why the process of science works because of reproducibility.

1122
00:53:43.400 --> 00:53:48.225
But also just you explaining to me how we do the atmospheric understanding.

1123
00:53:48.245 --> 00:53:48.345
Yeah.

1124
00:53:48.586 --> 00:53:49.307
And the atmosphere.

1125
00:53:49.887 --> 00:54:16.213
retrieval and how we do that transit method to figure out the yes and what i loved about this story was how the the postdoc who put out the paper a week after yeah yeah that like he actually met he re he re um i guess he re-instagrammed yeah he didn't retweet but on instagram he reposted yeah are real oh yeah about that and he was like am i the drama because we were literally talking about how a week later yeah he's like yeah yeah

1126
00:54:18.627 --> 00:54:20.409
Like that was that Oxford Cambridge beef.

1127
00:54:20.869 --> 00:54:21.790
God, that was great.

1128
00:54:21.830 --> 00:54:22.070
Yeah.

1129
00:54:22.130 --> 00:54:26.074
And it was shout out to Tyler for yes, for for posting that.

1130
00:54:26.114 --> 00:54:26.634
That was dope.

1131
00:54:26.714 --> 00:54:27.875
That was great.

1132
00:54:28.196 --> 00:54:28.916
Great story.

1133
00:54:29.317 --> 00:54:34.341
So again, as you can see, I have a real space, a real space rotation to the first two.

1134
00:54:34.621 --> 00:54:39.706
The third one that was really fascinating to me was the story we covered on Oncogan.

1135
00:54:39.866 --> 00:54:40.086
Yeah.

1136
00:54:40.546 --> 00:54:43.828
The AI Genome Project in episode 15.

1137
00:54:44.769 --> 00:54:50.992
And I actually just talked to my mom about this who works in clinical trials and is focused on the future of precision medicine.

1138
00:54:51.693 --> 00:54:58.036
And it was just the experimental – like what they – all of the different pieces they put together.

1139
00:54:58.257 --> 00:54:58.517
Yeah.

1140
00:54:59.157 --> 00:55:01.899
And the redundancy and really how well thought out it was.

1141
00:55:02.899 --> 00:55:10.285
To make sure that the genomes that they were generating with this AI was not linked to anything personal.

1142
00:55:10.425 --> 00:55:10.665
Yes.

1143
00:55:10.765 --> 00:55:11.086
You know?

1144
00:55:11.326 --> 00:55:11.826
No HIPAA violations.

1145
00:55:11.846 --> 00:55:20.513
It truly was no HIPAA violations, but we're creating this data set that is going to be used to train AI models to detect cancer.

1146
00:55:21.053 --> 00:55:33.900
And the fact that when they – with using those newly generated AI genomes, using existing tools like DeepTumor, they were actually able to increase the efficacy of detection in edge cases.

1147
00:55:33.940 --> 00:55:34.760
Yeah.

1148
00:55:34.820 --> 00:55:39.862
Basically proving that the genomes were not just junk data.

1149
00:55:39.922 --> 00:55:40.183
Yeah.

1150
00:55:40.343 --> 00:55:41.363
Right?

1151
00:55:41.623 --> 00:55:43.624
Like an existing tool was better off.

1152
00:55:43.644 --> 00:55:46.326
It was better off having it as a part of its data set.

1153
00:55:46.346 --> 00:55:46.546
Yeah.

1154
00:55:47.186 --> 00:55:48.186
That was a great one.

1155
00:55:48.206 --> 00:55:48.807
I love that story.

1156
00:55:48.827 --> 00:55:50.007
That was a great one.

1157
00:55:50.047 --> 00:55:50.247
Yeah.

1158
00:55:50.267 --> 00:55:50.407
Yeah.

1159
00:55:50.427 --> 00:55:54.689
And that was originally because it was from the University of Toronto.

1160
00:55:54.709 --> 00:55:54.829
Yes.

1161
00:55:54.869 --> 00:55:57.210
And Toronto lost the World Series.

1162
00:55:57.250 --> 00:55:57.991
Yeah.

1163
00:55:58.051 --> 00:55:58.311
Look.

1164
00:55:58.451 --> 00:55:59.611
The LA Dodgers won.

1165
00:55:59.671 --> 00:56:00.172
We're from LA.

1166
00:56:00.192 --> 00:56:01.092
What do you want us to do?

1167
00:56:01.172 --> 00:56:03.753
May I just repeat what is already known?

1168
00:56:03.773 --> 00:56:06.394
The LA Dodgers are back-to-back world champions.

1169
00:56:06.414 --> 00:56:08.015
We did give Toronto's love, though.

1170
00:56:08.395 --> 00:56:09.836
You know, we made sure we gave you guys some.

1171
00:56:09.856 --> 00:56:13.817
That was an incredible scientific achievement from the University of Toronto.

1172
00:56:13.977 --> 00:56:15.318
And the implications are great.

1173
00:56:15.478 --> 00:56:40.082
just going to be yeah um and again this is another we've covered a lot of ai stories and for me what this was was like ai gets talked about as like oh image generation and ai slop yeah and like ai girlfriends right but this is not this is going to save lives no straight up literally yeah and it is it's important to understand that in a lot in multiple research environments um

1174
00:56:41.143 --> 00:56:49.856
Folks are finally finding ways to get practical effects and outputs from a variety of use cases.

1175
00:56:49.876 --> 00:56:50.797
Yeah, that's a great point.

1176
00:56:50.817 --> 00:56:53.000
ML, RL, AI, whatever you want to label it as.

1177
00:56:54.062 --> 00:56:55.744
Number four was time crystals.

1178
00:56:55.945 --> 00:56:56.505
Time crystals.

1179
00:56:56.525 --> 00:56:57.126
Group temperature.

1180
00:56:57.707 --> 00:56:58.368
Time crystals.

1181
00:56:58.388 --> 00:56:59.329
Room temp time crystals.

1182
00:56:59.509 --> 00:57:00.329
Episode 9.

1183
00:57:00.410 --> 00:57:01.831
University of Colorado Boulder.

1184
00:57:01.891 --> 00:57:02.692
Yes, yes.

1185
00:57:02.972 --> 00:57:06.335
Yeah, the OGs of solid state physics.

1186
00:57:06.395 --> 00:57:10.779
Yes, and I just like that one because I never heard about a time crystal.

1187
00:57:10.939 --> 00:57:11.519
That was crazy.

1188
00:57:11.539 --> 00:57:14.022
Macroscopic room temperature time crystal.

1189
00:57:14.062 --> 00:57:17.745
Yeah, yeah, that was pretty cool because we got to go through the whole...

1190
00:57:18.946 --> 00:57:25.511
You know, from Frank Wolchek talking about the theoretical time crystal, and then somebody saying, eh, that's probably not possible.

1191
00:57:25.791 --> 00:57:28.253
And then somebody else saying, yeah, but you could do it this way.

1192
00:57:28.333 --> 00:57:34.317
And then now to where we've got this repertoire of time crystals, and this is the first one that's macroscopic.

1193
00:57:34.337 --> 00:57:35.638
You can see with the naked eye.

1194
00:57:35.959 --> 00:57:37.180
It's at room temperature.

1195
00:57:37.200 --> 00:57:37.300
Yeah.

1196
00:57:38.020 --> 00:57:38.660
It's crazy.

1197
00:57:38.960 --> 00:57:39.621
Such a good one.

1198
00:57:39.841 --> 00:57:40.461
Yeah.

1199
00:57:40.821 --> 00:57:48.364
And then the last one for me was just our Nobel week episode, macroscopic quantum tunneling, especially.

1200
00:57:49.464 --> 00:57:50.184
That was amazing.

1201
00:57:50.244 --> 00:57:52.745
Nobel prize week was really incredible.

1202
00:57:53.505 --> 00:58:06.630
This year's awards were all great, but I think that the structure of it and how we did the journey of like, because what it really, I like, I think showed and represented was how science is an iterative process.

1203
00:58:06.650 --> 00:58:07.190
Yeah.

1204
00:58:07.310 --> 00:58:09.812
that spans decades and generations.

1205
00:58:10.572 --> 00:58:20.019
And everything that we want that it gives us modern life is on the basis of scientific progress over generations.

1206
00:58:20.699 --> 00:58:24.042
And the awards this year were incredibly...

1207
00:58:24.802 --> 00:58:53.728
complex and i think those episodes did a great job for a layman or anyone who doesn't has no basis for any of the understanding can really kind of get why this award matters yeah yeah and and what i remember from it is like waking up at 2 a.m to watch the to watch the things with you and then be like okay now i gotta i gotta do it because we dropped it those we dropped it live yeah we dropped it yeah dude and it was it was a great experience it was like the commitment that

1208
00:58:54.808 --> 00:58:59.472
to this podcast and like to really getting and doing it right.

1209
00:58:59.492 --> 00:59:00.373
I love that.

1210
00:59:00.693 --> 00:59:01.234
It was great.

1211
00:59:01.834 --> 00:59:04.516
And, and it worked and, you know, it blew up.

1212
00:59:04.536 --> 00:59:04.817
It was great.

1213
00:59:04.837 --> 00:59:07.339
Some of our biggest episodes were the Nobel episodes.

1214
00:59:07.359 --> 00:59:10.461
A lot of you discovered us during that week.

1215
00:59:10.682 --> 00:59:12.183
And we will be doing it next year.

1216
00:59:13.004 --> 00:59:19.829
We're looking to hopefully get either a university or the Nobel committee to allow us to,

1217
00:59:20.570 --> 00:59:28.933
to be a participant in the process to help elevate this beyond what they already do and make it accessible to the new gen.

1218
00:59:30.133 --> 00:59:31.414
So those are my five.

1219
00:59:32.374 --> 00:59:33.894
Not exclusive, but those are good.

1220
00:59:34.295 --> 00:59:36.015
And so, okay, now let me start with mine.

1221
00:59:36.395 --> 00:59:39.296
My first one is the programmable synthetic proteins.

1222
00:59:39.336 --> 00:59:40.637
This was episode three.

1223
00:59:41.137 --> 00:59:42.897
This one just like blew my mind.

1224
00:59:43.058 --> 00:59:44.338
It was out of Yale University.

1225
00:59:45.598 --> 00:59:48.739
Effectively, yeah, boo, but also wow.

1226
00:59:49.000 --> 00:59:49.700
Because...

1227
00:59:50.640 --> 00:59:57.385
They effectively like, you know, we're used to 20 building blocks when we create proteins and they're like, what if we could have 60?

1228
00:59:57.565 --> 00:59:57.765
Yes.

1229
00:59:58.106 --> 01:00:04.790
You know, because it takes three codons, sorry, it takes three nucleotides to create a codon.

1230
01:00:05.271 --> 01:00:10.514
So three ATGCs, that's four choices in three bins.

1231
01:00:10.595 --> 01:00:12.436
So four to the three is 64.

1232
01:00:12.816 --> 01:00:16.399
You need a few of them to tell your protein machinery to start.

1233
01:00:16.839 --> 01:00:19.462
creating a protein and stop creating a protein.

1234
01:00:19.923 --> 01:00:27.493
But the question is, all of that others, you know, all of those, the rest of the 60 are getting mapped onto 20.

1235
01:00:27.953 --> 01:00:29.776
What if I could map them onto 60?

1236
01:00:30.056 --> 01:00:32.599
And this was the first step in that, right?

1237
01:00:32.980 --> 01:00:34.302
They made a fully...

1238
01:00:35.577 --> 01:00:36.517
Like bacteria.

1239
01:00:36.537 --> 01:00:42.199
They made a full bacteria that incorporated a new amino acid into a protein.

1240
01:00:42.239 --> 01:00:44.560
I thought that was absolutely insane.

1241
01:00:44.600 --> 01:00:45.080
Unbelievable.

1242
01:00:45.140 --> 01:00:46.000
That they could do this.

1243
01:00:46.080 --> 01:00:46.440
Unbelievable.

1244
01:00:46.460 --> 01:00:46.741
You know?

1245
01:00:47.561 --> 01:00:48.781
That was a really good one.

1246
01:00:48.901 --> 01:00:52.242
That was, it like blew my mind when I was researching it.

1247
01:00:52.282 --> 01:00:53.263
That was episode three.

1248
01:00:53.703 --> 01:00:57.344
And then the rest of them are all about science history because I love science history.

1249
01:00:57.364 --> 01:00:57.524
Yes.

1250
01:00:57.804 --> 01:00:59.625
So we've got the DNA episode.

1251
01:00:59.925 --> 01:01:02.987
I don't have to talk too much about that because that was just our last episode.

1252
01:01:04.328 --> 01:01:05.689
People loved that episode.

1253
01:01:05.709 --> 01:01:06.709
Watson's not the guy.

1254
01:01:06.949 --> 01:01:08.130
Watson is not the guy.

1255
01:01:09.051 --> 01:01:13.293
Turns out he was a racist piece of...

1256
01:01:13.673 --> 01:01:15.374
But the human story is fascinating.

1257
01:01:15.394 --> 01:01:15.855
The way that...

1258
01:01:16.535 --> 01:01:19.536
There was the competition between England and Caltech and all that.

1259
01:01:19.636 --> 01:01:21.397
I just loved looking that up.

1260
01:01:21.757 --> 01:01:24.138
The LIGO episode, which was episode 10.

1261
01:01:24.278 --> 01:01:25.259
Yes, that was a great one.

1262
01:01:25.279 --> 01:01:26.119
That was a great one.

1263
01:01:26.619 --> 01:01:33.682
That little story about how the postdocs were like running around, you know, just an hour before the actual signal came.

1264
01:01:33.822 --> 01:01:59.266
in and they were just like driving their jeeps yes along the along the instrument and then people were like just freaking out because they didn't know if it was a psyop right right they didn't know if it was a conspiracy or something i loved that also the actual engineering that went into ligo is unbelievable yeah yeah it is yeah being sensitive to 10 to the minus 21 in stress and then we're replicating that in three locations now yeah yeah

1265
01:01:59.786 --> 01:01:59.986
Yeah.

1266
01:02:00.627 --> 01:02:01.087
Amazing.

1267
01:02:02.288 --> 01:02:04.650
The Heisenberg episode, which is episode five.

1268
01:02:04.950 --> 01:02:05.751
Very popular.

1269
01:02:05.771 --> 01:02:07.092
That one was very popular.

1270
01:02:07.112 --> 01:02:07.592
Very popular.

1271
01:02:07.612 --> 01:02:07.872
Yeah.

1272
01:02:08.032 --> 01:02:08.232
Yeah.

1273
01:02:08.332 --> 01:02:14.237
I love like going through his original paper that, you know, set it all up.

1274
01:02:14.297 --> 01:02:14.497
Yes.

1275
01:02:14.857 --> 01:02:15.718
Yeah.

1276
01:02:15.838 --> 01:02:17.740
And that whole non-commutation.

1277
01:02:17.800 --> 01:02:18.040
Yes.

1278
01:02:18.200 --> 01:02:18.400
Yes.

1279
01:02:18.460 --> 01:02:19.421
Yeah.

1280
01:02:19.581 --> 01:02:22.143
A, B, not equal to B, A.

1281
01:02:22.483 --> 01:02:23.023
Yeah, exactly.

1282
01:02:23.043 --> 01:02:25.504
When we were talking about vector multiplication.

1283
01:02:25.584 --> 01:02:27.825
Yeah, matrix multiplication on vectors.

1284
01:02:27.885 --> 01:02:29.145
Matrix multiplication on vectors.

1285
01:02:29.305 --> 01:02:29.745
Exactly.

1286
01:02:29.765 --> 01:02:33.947
There's a lot of debate in the comments on that one because people would saw the graphic but didn't listen.

1287
01:02:34.087 --> 01:02:34.347
Yeah.

1288
01:02:34.427 --> 01:02:35.847
And so they thought we were not, anyway.

1289
01:02:35.947 --> 01:02:36.988
Yeah.

1290
01:02:37.088 --> 01:02:40.769
And then finally the Chen Ning Yang episode, which is episode 14.

1291
01:02:41.389 --> 01:02:47.711
And that one where we had the discussion about symmetry and how the fundamental laws of symmetry govern the universe.

1292
01:02:47.751 --> 01:02:50.052
And we can overturn the whole...

1293
01:02:50.772 --> 01:03:09.432
idea of how we do physics by asking a fundamental question like what are the symmetries of the universe okay i do an experiment here and i do an experiment over there the laws of the physics that are the same yes what does that mean what does that mean and like yeah it's just so beautiful was that think about was that the episode with the the left hand right hand left car yeah yeah yeah

1294
01:03:09.972 --> 01:03:12.653
Left and right, the chirality of stuff.

1295
01:03:12.913 --> 01:03:17.195
That was really... All of the history episodes and the deep dives were really popular.

1296
01:03:17.215 --> 01:03:18.675
I know there's someone on YouTube.

1297
01:03:19.235 --> 01:03:20.996
We see the comments, not all of them.

1298
01:03:21.036 --> 01:03:21.976
It's tough to keep up.

1299
01:03:22.317 --> 01:03:24.197
But someone was like, I want more.

1300
01:03:24.737 --> 01:03:25.018
Yeah.

1301
01:03:25.138 --> 01:03:28.839
Deep dive, single subject history, go through all the details episodes.

1302
01:03:30.160 --> 01:03:33.945
And so as we go into season two, we have some interesting ideas.

1303
01:03:34.585 --> 01:03:36.507
And so the core format will be there.

1304
01:03:37.088 --> 01:03:39.210
We'll do almost exactly like we did this year.

1305
01:03:39.351 --> 01:03:40.892
Some episodes will have multiple stories.

1306
01:03:41.433 --> 01:03:42.614
Some will be the deep dives.

1307
01:03:43.435 --> 01:03:47.079
Maybe we might even be going directly into some...

1308
01:03:48.090 --> 01:04:04.715
labs yeah to do some on-site episodes 26 you know uh we've got some some interesting things planned uh i'm gonna quickly honorable mention uh from from the wife yeah about her favorite episode she said if you don't include me you're in trouble so

1309
01:04:05.575 --> 01:04:18.541
I'm including her three, which were the double slit MIT replication episode three, the diamond, the harder than diamond episode five episode, and also a double tap on the Rosalind Franklin.

1310
01:04:19.101 --> 01:04:20.082
She's a women in STEM.

1311
01:04:20.262 --> 01:04:20.542
Yeah.

1312
01:04:20.622 --> 01:04:21.102
We love it.

1313
01:04:21.302 --> 01:04:21.722
We love it.

1314
01:04:21.782 --> 01:04:25.464
So we're going to wrap up with a corrections section.

1315
01:04:25.544 --> 01:04:25.804
Yes.

1316
01:04:25.924 --> 01:04:31.707
And so one of the things I love about this pod is that there's a surprising amount of comments.

1317
01:04:31.727 --> 01:04:32.127
Yeah.

1318
01:04:32.367 --> 01:04:48.063
from folks, whether you're doing your PhD currently, whether you're in a research lab, or just are into science generally, for folks who had some comments about how we framed things, and we want to give an opportunity to do a couple of key corrections from our past episodes.

1319
01:04:48.123 --> 01:04:48.323
Yeah.

1320
01:04:48.563 --> 01:04:52.087
And we'll maybe do something to incorporate this better into season two.

1321
01:04:52.367 --> 01:04:52.487
Yeah.

1322
01:04:52.527 --> 01:04:55.270
And so we're now going to talk about some of these corrections.

1323
01:04:55.290 --> 01:04:58.092
Yeah, and I wanted to piggyback off what you said.

1324
01:04:58.152 --> 01:05:05.378
It's really a testament to our audience that we're getting corrections at such a fine level.

1325
01:05:05.418 --> 01:05:06.319
Yeah, very detailed.

1326
01:05:06.339 --> 01:05:14.145
And look, I would much rather you're scrolling on Instagram and you're commenting about science versus nonsense.

1327
01:05:14.345 --> 01:05:14.585
Yeah.

1328
01:05:14.805 --> 01:05:15.566
So we love it.

1329
01:05:15.926 --> 01:05:23.649
And please continue to pop in your viewpoints, your thoughts, because that's the whole point is we're trying to have a conversation.

1330
01:05:23.889 --> 01:05:24.689
Yeah, exactly.

1331
01:05:25.069 --> 01:05:29.891
So the first one is kind of a general one, which was during the whale episode.

1332
01:05:30.372 --> 01:05:34.153
Our one video that's going to reach a million on Instagram by the time we drop this.

1333
01:05:34.253 --> 01:05:34.633
Yeah.

1334
01:05:34.713 --> 01:05:40.716
There were a lot of corrections about the fact that, you know, when you're in a sailboat, you can actually go against the wind.

1335
01:05:41.456 --> 01:05:45.199
The correction is you can't actually go directly against the wind.

1336
01:05:45.219 --> 01:05:49.583
You have to tack at an angle that's offset from the wind.

1337
01:05:49.603 --> 01:05:57.389
I actually know this because during my grad school at UCLA, UCLA has a marina in Marina del Rey, and they offer— Marina del Rey?

1338
01:05:57.830 --> 01:05:59.271
Yeah, Marina del Rey.

1339
01:05:59.611 --> 01:06:01.813
And they actually offer sailing classes.

1340
01:06:02.408 --> 01:06:15.412
And so I got a sailing license at the UCLA Marina, and they taught us how to tack and go against the wind and effectively use Bernoulli's principle to go against the wind at an angle.

1341
01:06:15.832 --> 01:06:19.213
And you can sort of go like this, right?

1342
01:06:19.333 --> 01:06:20.333
At the end of the day, though...

1343
01:06:21.167 --> 01:06:24.568
Pythagorean theorem, you're not going to be going directly against the wind.

1344
01:06:24.588 --> 01:06:27.969
So if you're a whale in the ocean, you can still outrun a boat.

1345
01:06:28.049 --> 01:06:33.951
So the main point was the whales learned how to go directly against the wind and outrun boats.

1346
01:06:34.051 --> 01:06:34.732
Right, right.

1347
01:06:35.172 --> 01:06:41.854
Regardless of the fact that, yes, sailboats can, using tacking, go not directly against the wind, but in the direction where...

1348
01:06:42.074 --> 01:06:44.435
The point is the whales will be able to outrun.

1349
01:06:44.455 --> 01:06:47.058
Yeah, like imagine you're a whaler and you see them.

1350
01:06:47.639 --> 01:06:49.361
You're not going to be like, I'm going to go get them.

1351
01:06:49.381 --> 01:06:51.003
You're going to be like, no, that's a lost cause.

1352
01:06:51.043 --> 01:06:53.946
They're going literally against the wind.

1353
01:06:54.086 --> 01:06:54.847
So we get it.

1354
01:06:54.907 --> 01:06:55.648
Yeah, we get it.

1355
01:06:55.768 --> 01:06:56.869
But that wasn't the...

1356
01:06:57.860 --> 01:06:58.380
Context.

1357
01:06:58.400 --> 01:06:58.640
Yeah.

1358
01:06:58.800 --> 01:07:00.181
Watch the full episodes, okay?

1359
01:07:00.201 --> 01:07:03.641
The clips are not always the full context.

1360
01:07:04.021 --> 01:07:23.426
The other one, so during the DNA episode, I talked about how Chargaff at Columbia University used human sperm to establish the ratio between A, T, G, and C. And he showed that A and T are exactly the same, and G and C are exactly the same.

1361
01:07:23.786 --> 01:07:26.927
And I made the statement that sperm is mostly DNA.

1362
01:07:26.947 --> 01:07:27.387
Mostly DNA.

1363
01:07:28.147 --> 01:07:29.228
Yes, that's not true.

1364
01:07:29.428 --> 01:07:30.829
Okay, and that's a fair point.

1365
01:07:31.369 --> 01:07:35.212
Sperm is mostly, again, proteins and a bunch of other random stuff.

1366
01:07:35.672 --> 01:07:43.017
But my point was that there's more DNA per volume in sperm than there are in other cells.

1367
01:07:43.477 --> 01:07:50.501
And so if you want the greatest bang for your buck in terms of trying to analyze DNA per volume, sperm is a great...

1368
01:07:51.662 --> 01:07:54.025
you know, the sort of sample to get.

1369
01:07:54.365 --> 01:07:55.826
It's not all DNA.

1370
01:07:56.087 --> 01:07:56.267
Yeah.

1371
01:07:56.307 --> 01:08:01.512
But the DNA per volume is the most functional and beneficial for the use case.

1372
01:08:01.572 --> 01:08:01.832
Yes.

1373
01:08:02.112 --> 01:08:02.773
Of doing the demo.

1374
01:08:02.833 --> 01:08:03.314
Exactly.

1375
01:08:03.394 --> 01:08:04.495
So yeah, that was fair play.

1376
01:08:04.515 --> 01:08:05.115
That's a good one.

1377
01:08:05.135 --> 01:08:05.496
Okay.

1378
01:08:05.636 --> 01:08:06.056
Um, um,

1379
01:08:06.817 --> 01:08:11.798
Whenever I talk about transcription and translation, whenever I get excited, I mix up the two.

1380
01:08:11.878 --> 01:08:12.158
Okay.

1381
01:08:12.238 --> 01:08:13.579
Okay, but I do know what they mean.

1382
01:08:14.179 --> 01:08:17.399
Transcription is DNA to RNA.

1383
01:08:17.500 --> 01:08:17.680
Yes.

1384
01:08:18.100 --> 01:08:20.060
And it's in the word, right?

1385
01:08:20.120 --> 01:08:23.061
Transcribe from the same language to the same language.

1386
01:08:23.101 --> 01:08:26.762
There's a little bit of difference because instead of T, you're using U.

1387
01:08:27.242 --> 01:08:30.683
But instead of ATGC, you use AUGC.

1388
01:08:31.103 --> 01:08:33.863
But it's the same, nucleotide to nucleotide.

1389
01:08:37.084 --> 01:08:39.405
nucleotide to amino acid, right?

1390
01:08:39.445 --> 01:08:42.905
So it's a different language altogether, and that's why you're translating.

1391
01:08:43.386 --> 01:08:46.626
And, you know, when I get excited, sometimes I say the wrong thing.

1392
01:08:46.646 --> 01:08:46.726
Yes.

1393
01:08:47.146 --> 01:08:49.307
But hopefully you guys know what I mean.

1394
01:08:49.547 --> 01:08:50.167
Duly noted.

1395
01:08:50.387 --> 01:08:51.427
Yeah.

1396
01:08:51.487 --> 01:08:53.168
The fourth one, sodium batteries.

1397
01:08:53.388 --> 01:08:55.248
Sodium batteries are actually a thing.

1398
01:08:55.308 --> 01:08:55.428
Yes.

1399
01:08:55.788 --> 01:08:59.309
And we made it seem like sodium batteries weren't a thing.

1400
01:08:59.349 --> 01:09:00.530
Sodium batteries are a thing.

1401
01:09:00.550 --> 01:09:03.270
There's active companies that are actually trying it.

1402
01:09:03.810 --> 01:09:06.471
Solid state sodium batteries are not a thing.

1403
01:09:06.511 --> 01:09:06.671
Right.

1404
01:09:07.031 --> 01:09:07.251
Right.

1405
01:09:07.371 --> 01:09:12.493
And that's sort of the holy grail that the Chicago UCSD paper was trying to solve.

1406
01:09:12.614 --> 01:09:12.774
Right.

1407
01:09:12.794 --> 01:09:13.014
Right.

1408
01:09:13.154 --> 01:09:21.457
They're trying to get closer to that solid state sodium battery because then we could start using it for EVs and long term storage and all this other kind of stuff.

1409
01:09:21.517 --> 01:09:22.638
Yes.

1410
01:09:22.738 --> 01:09:25.219
So they made a real leap forward in that solid state.

1411
01:09:25.479 --> 01:09:26.199
Solid state.

1412
01:09:26.379 --> 01:09:28.100
Where there's no liquid electrolyte.

1413
01:09:28.340 --> 01:09:28.500
Right.

1414
01:09:28.520 --> 01:09:29.221
That's going around.

1415
01:09:29.241 --> 01:09:30.021
Right.

1416
01:09:30.461 --> 01:09:32.082
Which if you listen to the full episode is...

1417
01:09:33.185 --> 01:09:58.884
you know yeah yeah we we did make it a thing but okay fine we'll take it play um and then finally airplane speed the hypersonics episode this this one i got a lot of a lot of uh poopoo for it is not 250 miles per hour it is in fact 500 miles per hour and i should have i should have like known this because you know from here to new york is like 3 000 miles it takes six hours like five hours like 500 miles

1418
01:10:00.045 --> 01:10:24.611
per hour that kind of makes sense but um what really incensed me about this is because um one of my friends good friends from college told me that he recommended it to one of his friends yes um justin honenstein justin if you're if you're listening if you're listening um i understand that you don't want to listen to any of our podcasts because because we made that one error and we're not acknowledging it well here i am acknowledging it

1419
01:10:25.551 --> 01:10:26.231
Here I am.

1420
01:10:26.892 --> 01:10:30.814
This guy, by the way, I've interacted with him a few times.

1421
01:10:30.954 --> 01:10:31.975
I think he's just jealous.

1422
01:10:32.055 --> 01:10:32.735
Yeah, I get it.

1423
01:10:32.775 --> 01:10:35.517
Because we beat him in beer pong in 2011.

1424
01:10:35.937 --> 01:10:37.718
Thanksgiving 2011, I don't forget.

1425
01:10:38.158 --> 01:10:40.040
We beat you, me and Alan.

1426
01:10:40.060 --> 01:10:41.901
We beat you in beer pong in 2011.

1427
01:10:42.001 --> 01:10:44.102
And then we sang a Jason Derulo song.

1428
01:10:44.802 --> 01:10:46.163
And we sang it really well.

1429
01:10:46.223 --> 01:10:47.304
He was harmonizing.

1430
01:10:47.324 --> 01:10:48.665
And we sang it really well.

1431
01:10:48.685 --> 01:10:49.645
Maybe he's jealous.

1432
01:10:50.126 --> 01:10:52.667
And now he doesn't want to listen to our podcast.

1433
01:10:52.967 --> 01:10:53.908
Well, Justin...

1434
01:10:55.371 --> 01:11:00.115
Now I've admitted that I said 250 when I should have said 500.

1435
01:11:00.796 --> 01:11:09.303
And so for those still watching at the end, you know our trend where now at the end of the show, it's helpful for us to know that people actually reach the end.

1436
01:11:09.783 --> 01:11:18.230
And so for those still listening, whether it's a podcast or you're watching the video, in the comment thread, if you want to go ahead and put...

1437
01:11:19.131 --> 01:11:23.456
Justin, they apologized, or Justin, we're waiting for you.

1438
01:11:23.836 --> 01:11:26.199
Or anything funny Justin.

1439
01:11:26.239 --> 01:11:29.323
Justin, if you have a bit that you want to put...

1440
01:11:30.148 --> 01:11:31.069
Put it in the comments.

1441
01:11:31.729 --> 01:11:37.933
We want to get Justin back on the train, listening for not only our season one episodes, but moving forward to season two.

1442
01:11:38.614 --> 01:11:42.016
And again, we're not above reproach here.

1443
01:11:42.096 --> 01:11:42.296
No.

1444
01:11:42.316 --> 01:11:42.516
Right?

1445
01:11:42.937 --> 01:11:43.237
No.

1446
01:11:43.257 --> 01:11:44.418
That was fair play, Justin.

1447
01:11:44.438 --> 01:11:45.758
A hundred percent.

1448
01:11:45.939 --> 01:11:53.864
And we are willing, again, because the whole point here, like the fundamental concept of science we talk about every day is it's an iterative process.

1449
01:11:53.904 --> 01:11:54.945
This was our first season.

1450
01:11:55.585 --> 01:12:00.472
We literally started it in my garage that's now converted into this unbelievable studio.

1451
01:12:00.532 --> 01:12:00.952
Amazing.

1452
01:12:01.353 --> 01:12:05.078
And we are very excited for what we're going to be able to do next season.

1453
01:12:06.841 --> 01:12:09.484
We do know – just a couple of notes before we wrap up.

1454
01:12:10.283 --> 01:12:17.990
We've heard the comments about all the sound and the angles and the colors, all the production people, all that's been solved.

1455
01:12:18.611 --> 01:12:20.773
So now the color matching is good.

1456
01:12:20.933 --> 01:12:21.153
Yeah.

1457
01:12:21.353 --> 01:12:24.176
If I bang on the table, it doesn't get picked up as much anymore.

1458
01:12:24.496 --> 01:12:25.998
I also don't bang on the table as much.

1459
01:12:27.159 --> 01:12:28.400
So we, we hear you.

1460
01:12:28.840 --> 01:12:31.142
We're listening as we go into next season.

1461
01:12:31.943 --> 01:12:34.944
A lot of folks have asked us about whether we're going to do interviews.

1462
01:12:36.005 --> 01:12:39.266
The focus of this show is not to be an interview show.

1463
01:12:39.687 --> 01:12:43.228
There are plenty of science podcasts that are interview shows.

1464
01:12:43.929 --> 01:12:49.111
That being said, we do have plans to do some interesting interviews.

1465
01:12:50.544 --> 01:13:00.414
Focus or featurettes that will both be virtual and in person with labs or research teams in what they're working on.

1466
01:13:00.474 --> 01:13:05.440
So we will be incorporating interview style content next year.

1467
01:13:05.920 --> 01:13:06.200
But...

1468
01:13:06.781 --> 01:13:09.282
This is not the core focus of the show.

1469
01:13:09.902 --> 01:13:19.245
The show is really meant to look at what is breaking research in the verticals and industries we're interested in and talking about those from first principles.

1470
01:13:19.706 --> 01:13:22.006
That is still the fundamental DNA of the show.

1471
01:13:22.647 --> 01:13:27.849
And we want to stick and focus on making sure that that is our core entry point.

1472
01:13:28.149 --> 01:13:28.569
However...

1473
01:13:30.215 --> 01:13:31.396
we only had six months this year.

1474
01:13:31.456 --> 01:13:32.536
Next year we have a full year.

1475
01:13:33.056 --> 01:13:35.237
And so we can splice in a couple of interviews.

1476
01:13:36.098 --> 01:13:39.039
And we have some good ones that I think you guys will enjoy quite a bit.

1477
01:13:39.559 --> 01:13:57.606
Not least of which will be my finally convinced my dad, at a minimum, who's a parasitologist, Harvard postdoc, has had some incredible things he's done in his life to come on and talk about one of the things he discovered

1478
01:13:58.638 --> 01:14:06.080
almost two decades, maybe even three decades ago, that is now actually going to be going into production by a pharma company.

1479
01:14:06.440 --> 01:14:07.940
And so that'll be at least one of them.

1480
01:14:08.480 --> 01:14:10.361
And we have a couple more that are exciting.

1481
01:14:10.421 --> 01:14:25.264
And if you are on a research team, if you're a fan of the pod and you're a PhD, a postdoc, the principal investigator, and you would like us to talk about what you're researching, yeah,

1482
01:14:26.360 --> 01:14:27.481
Please email us.

1483
01:14:27.541 --> 01:14:29.904
Our email is available on the social platforms.

1484
01:14:29.944 --> 01:14:31.265
It'll be available on the website.

1485
01:14:32.166 --> 01:14:36.590
Or shoot us a DM on any of the social platforms and let us know what you're doing.

1486
01:14:36.630 --> 01:14:42.376
We'd be happy to explore potentially having you guys on the pod and talking about your research.

1487
01:14:43.277 --> 01:14:48.358
Again, this is not an invite for people who have created their own research paper on the side.

1488
01:14:48.378 --> 01:14:55.940
Unfortunately, we have to keep it pegged to published or research institutions that are associated with either a university or a mainstream lab.

1489
01:14:56.200 --> 01:14:58.941
That's just where our box is and what we're focused on.

1490
01:14:59.321 --> 01:15:04.182
And so maybe some point in the future, we can take folks not associated with that.

1491
01:15:04.202 --> 01:15:06.442
But that is currently our focus.

1492
01:15:07.043 --> 01:15:08.523
So if you have sent us papers...

1493
01:15:09.243 --> 01:15:10.909
that you've created on your own.

1494
01:15:11.009 --> 01:15:11.772
We appreciate it.

1495
01:15:12.013 --> 01:15:13.679
This is just not the platform for those.

1496
01:15:13.699 --> 01:15:14.461
Um,

1497
01:15:15.510 --> 01:15:19.093
And I'll wrap up with our new website will go out for season two.

1498
01:15:19.514 --> 01:15:21.756
Our new leaderboards will also go out for season two.

1499
01:15:22.516 --> 01:15:26.820
And we will have a new way to support the show via direct donation.

1500
01:15:27.521 --> 01:15:31.144
Because, again, there's only two people on the FFP team.

1501
01:15:31.244 --> 01:15:33.066
It's literally just the two of us.

1502
01:15:33.086 --> 01:15:33.546
It's just us.

1503
01:15:33.866 --> 01:15:35.228
There's no production assistant.

1504
01:15:35.428 --> 01:15:36.168
There's no editor.

1505
01:15:36.188 --> 01:15:37.830
There's no social media person.

1506
01:15:38.030 --> 01:15:38.991
There's no assistant.

1507
01:15:39.411 --> 01:15:39.972
It's just us.

1508
01:15:40.252 --> 01:15:41.013
It's a lot of work.

1509
01:15:41.733 --> 01:15:50.398
And so doing a weekly show at this scale, video and audio, also with the social distribution, is quite a bit.

1510
01:15:50.478 --> 01:15:55.761
And so all of the engagement, the best way you can support currently, share it with your lab.

1511
01:15:56.161 --> 01:15:59.023
If you're in a lab meeting, a research team meeting, talk about the show.

1512
01:15:59.303 --> 01:15:59.863
Yeah, please.

1513
01:15:59.943 --> 01:16:00.243
Please.

1514
01:16:00.263 --> 01:16:00.804
Would love that.

1515
01:16:00.904 --> 01:16:03.906
If you're on socials, share it in your DMs, repost it to your story.

1516
01:16:04.586 --> 01:16:05.987
Every little piece of engagement –

1517
01:16:06.587 --> 01:16:08.989
helps us battle the billionaire algorithm.

1518
01:16:09.309 --> 01:16:11.291
We are trying to make science sexy.

1519
01:16:11.611 --> 01:16:15.935
We're trying to make it popular and hip and expand it to more people.

1520
01:16:16.435 --> 01:16:21.699
And all of you have been a huge help in helping get this show to reach.

1521
01:16:21.959 --> 01:16:25.762
I mean, we're doing 3 million views on Instagram a month.

1522
01:16:25.782 --> 01:16:27.444
We're doing a million on TikTok.

1523
01:16:27.864 --> 01:16:29.105
It's just unbelievable.

1524
01:16:29.185 --> 01:16:33.329
Again, the fastest growing, we are one of the fastest growing science pods globally.

1525
01:16:34.110 --> 01:16:34.610
in the world.

1526
01:16:35.171 --> 01:16:36.792
And that's all because of you, the audience.

1527
01:16:36.832 --> 01:16:45.778
And we're incredibly grateful that the random chemistry that this friendship has around this has, has really resonated with so many of you.

1528
01:16:46.279 --> 01:16:47.299
It's been an incredible year.

1529
01:16:47.700 --> 01:16:48.640
Yes, it really has.

1530
01:16:49.541 --> 01:16:50.802
And we're excited for next year.

1531
01:16:51.642 --> 01:16:58.447
As always, I'm your host, Lester Nari joined by the smartest and the best science communicator on the planet.

1532
01:16:59.508 --> 01:17:02.290
And our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

1533
01:17:03.308 --> 01:17:04.430
We'll see you all next year.

1534
01:17:04.830 --> 01:17:05.672
Happy holidays.

1535
01:17:06.553 --> 01:17:11.781
And with that, the 2025 season has come to an end.

1536
01:17:12.181 --> 01:17:16.648
This is from First Principles.
