WEBVTT

1
00:00:02.659 --> 00:00:04.021
A listener production.

2
00:00:04.801 --> 00:00:14.271
Hi, I'm Justine.

3
00:00:14.472 --> 00:00:15.132
And I'm Sarah.

4
00:00:15.212 --> 00:00:16.574
And this is Big Small Talk.

5
00:00:20.260 --> 00:00:25.681
This is the podcast where we try and cover the entirety of the news cycle, from the serious to the frivolous, all in one place.

6
00:00:25.941 --> 00:00:28.982
Because loving pop culture doesn't mean you don't understand politics.

7
00:00:29.322 --> 00:00:44.126
And today we're going to be talking about Trump offering everyone $5,000 of Republicans' win, Shailene Woodley's ex trying to expose her, anthropic employee warning AI could kill us all, Macklemore kicked off Ed Sheeran's tour, One Nation's visa crackdown, and Sydney Sweeney's ad.

8
00:00:44.486 --> 00:00:54.372
But before we begin today's episode, we would like to start by acknowledging the traditional owners of the land on which we're recording today, the Gadigal people, and pay our respects to Elders past and present.

9
00:00:54.993 --> 00:00:58.335
Before we get into the actual news, welcome, Justine.

10
00:00:58.375 --> 00:01:00.135
Thank you for being here on your deathbed.

11
00:01:00.296 --> 00:01:01.236
That's really good of you.

12
00:01:01.256 --> 00:01:02.577
That's really nice.

13
00:01:02.597 --> 00:01:05.578
To be clear, to be clear, everybody, Sarah hasn't forced me to come in.

14
00:01:05.998 --> 00:01:08.019
Like she was like, we can just cancel this week's episode.

15
00:01:08.039 --> 00:01:10.180
I was like, no, we can't.

16
00:01:10.561 --> 00:01:17.124
I can't live with myself being the reason that Big Small Talk misses an episode for the first time in three years.

17
00:01:17.144 --> 00:01:19.145
Like, like I feel...

18
00:01:19.905 --> 00:01:21.606
This is, guys, I'm sick right now.

19
00:01:21.626 --> 00:01:22.867
I have a cold, to be clear.

20
00:01:23.067 --> 00:01:24.227
I got a, I went to the doctor.

21
00:01:24.267 --> 00:01:25.608
I got viral tested.

22
00:01:26.208 --> 00:01:27.849
I, it's literally the common cold.

23
00:01:28.269 --> 00:01:28.989
Caverns are the best of us.

24
00:01:29.009 --> 00:01:29.750
I'm not exposed.

25
00:01:29.890 --> 00:01:31.771
I was like, Sarah, don't wear a mask in the studio.

26
00:01:31.791 --> 00:01:32.431
I don't know what to do.

27
00:01:32.451 --> 00:01:33.852
No, I mean, I probably gave it to you.

28
00:01:33.912 --> 00:01:35.433
I was sick the week before that.

29
00:01:35.473 --> 00:01:37.253
Yes, so it's been a bit of back and forth.

30
00:01:37.313 --> 00:01:38.394
And then Hannah's in Ireland.

31
00:01:38.834 --> 00:01:39.515
It's all happening.

32
00:01:39.615 --> 00:01:40.295
It's all happening.

33
00:01:40.315 --> 00:01:41.576
So the episode's coming out a day late.

34
00:01:41.916 --> 00:01:42.056
But,

35
00:01:42.676 --> 00:01:46.298
This is my first week on the Big Small Talk podcast.

36
00:01:46.318 --> 00:01:56.422
I've done Big Talk last month and it feels, I can't tell you, do you remember like when you had a big thing coming up or when, you know, when you have a big thing coming up and then you get sick right before it?

37
00:01:56.782 --> 00:01:58.623
Like I was so excited about this week.

38
00:01:58.903 --> 00:02:02.125
This feels like, this feels like the first, cause like I'm a nerd.

39
00:02:02.145 --> 00:02:04.526
So I used to be really into like the first day going back to school.

40
00:02:05.026 --> 00:02:08.147
And this feels like I got sick on the first day going back to school and had to miss out.

41
00:02:08.508 --> 00:02:08.868
So yeah.

42
00:02:09.588 --> 00:02:14.310
I've been emotionally struggling, more than physically struggling with this.

43
00:02:14.770 --> 00:02:15.571
Oh, bless.

44
00:02:16.391 --> 00:02:17.391
Bless my cotton cell.

45
00:02:17.431 --> 00:02:18.172
I love that energy.

46
00:02:18.492 --> 00:02:19.212
How's your week?

47
00:02:19.232 --> 00:02:21.553
Sorry, what's your personal headline of the week?

48
00:02:21.693 --> 00:02:23.434
My personal headline was also that I was sick.

49
00:02:23.794 --> 00:02:31.157
But in saying all of that, I've been so excited to come and do this episode because this is like one of the most jam-packed weeks ever.

50
00:02:31.177 --> 00:02:32.838
We have so much to discuss.

51
00:02:33.218 --> 00:02:34.379
But yeah, welcome to...

52
00:02:34.939 --> 00:02:36.440
Tuesday episode.

53
00:02:36.480 --> 00:02:38.502
What a week to be jumping in.

54
00:02:38.883 --> 00:02:40.844
Also, one last thing about being sick.

55
00:02:41.585 --> 00:02:45.469
It gives me newfound appreciation and disbelief for Taylor Swift.

56
00:02:45.669 --> 00:02:48.431
Because how did that lady do the Ears tour for two years?

57
00:02:48.652 --> 00:02:51.234
She's like in a documentary, she's like, I had the stomach flu.

58
00:02:51.574 --> 00:02:52.635
I had colds.

59
00:02:52.675 --> 00:02:55.318
Like, how did that woman do a three hour concert?

60
00:02:55.598 --> 00:02:56.439
I have no idea.

61
00:02:56.579 --> 00:02:57.199
She's an animal.

62
00:02:57.219 --> 00:02:57.680
She's incredible.

63
00:02:57.700 --> 00:03:00.062
Do you think they have special drugs just for the celebrities?

64
00:03:00.082 --> 00:03:00.202
Yeah.

65
00:03:00.302 --> 00:03:02.946
I don't know, like they'd shot them with adrenaline or something like that.

66
00:03:03.346 --> 00:03:06.711
I honestly think if you're doing something like the Ears tour, there is so much adrenaline involved in that.

67
00:03:06.791 --> 00:03:07.552
Yes, naturally.

68
00:03:07.572 --> 00:03:09.034
I think that is the drug, you know?

69
00:03:09.054 --> 00:03:13.340
I will say being in this studio, this is the most alive I have felt in like three days.

70
00:03:13.380 --> 00:03:14.221
This is our Ears tour.

71
00:03:14.301 --> 00:03:15.463
This is my Ears tour.

72
00:03:17.829 --> 00:03:21.971
Trump will pay people $5,000 if Republicans win the midterms.

73
00:03:22.051 --> 00:03:23.092
At least that's what he said, Sarah.

74
00:03:23.672 --> 00:03:25.333
This was the craziest headline.

75
00:03:25.453 --> 00:03:26.474
It was something to wake up to.

76
00:03:26.514 --> 00:03:26.814
Okay.

77
00:03:27.074 --> 00:03:41.122
So for anyone who missed it, Trump has said, Trump last week said that he will give every American adult a $5,000 dividends check if Republicans hold onto control of Congress in the upcoming midterm elections.

78
00:03:41.693 --> 00:03:41.913
Okay.

79
00:03:42.533 --> 00:03:46.674
I have a billion thoughts on this, but can we backtrack for a second and just explain what the midterms are?

80
00:03:46.814 --> 00:03:47.234
Absolutely.

81
00:03:47.294 --> 00:03:47.614
Okay.

82
00:03:47.654 --> 00:03:49.935
So yeah, you might be like, what the fuck are the midterms?

83
00:03:50.835 --> 00:03:51.575
Why are they happening?

84
00:03:51.595 --> 00:03:52.276
When are they happening?

85
00:03:52.456 --> 00:03:59.377
So the US midterms are basically the big elections that happen at the halfway point during the president's four-year term.

86
00:03:59.777 --> 00:04:01.678
It's not the president though that's on the ballot.

87
00:04:01.698 --> 00:04:03.038
So Trump's not up for election.

88
00:04:03.598 --> 00:04:10.380
It's all 435 House of Rep seats and around a third of the Senate seats that are up for election.

89
00:04:10.400 --> 00:04:10.500
Yeah.

90
00:04:11.140 --> 00:04:13.983
There's also a lot of like elections of state governors that are happening.

91
00:04:14.003 --> 00:04:15.084
We're going to put that to one side.

92
00:04:15.124 --> 00:04:18.647
I just didn't want anyone to be confused if they like saw that headline as well.

93
00:04:18.787 --> 00:04:18.947
Yeah.

94
00:04:19.427 --> 00:04:19.948
Too much going on.

95
00:04:20.228 --> 00:04:27.735
But the reason why this is such a point of focus is because currently Republicans hold the majority in both the House and the Senate.

96
00:04:28.035 --> 00:04:35.242
So they have the ability to pass laws really easily because they control the presidency, the House and the Senate, like all three tiers of government.

97
00:04:35.823 --> 00:04:45.793
So this election is a really big deal for the Republicans because if they lose Congress, they're going to lose most of their ability to pass laws for the second half of their terms.

98
00:04:45.833 --> 00:04:47.195
They lose a lot of power.

99
00:04:47.215 --> 00:04:47.375
Yeah.

100
00:04:47.415 --> 00:05:00.481
But my other understanding with the midterms is like, it's sort of this temperature check halfway through that if you're not happy with the current government, you know, if the country's not happy with the current government or systems, then this is the opportunity to take power away from them.

101
00:05:00.641 --> 00:05:01.322
Yes, exactly.

102
00:05:01.342 --> 00:05:04.263
Because you pretty much like cut them off at the knees for the second next two years.

103
00:05:04.363 --> 00:05:04.603
Yes.

104
00:05:04.723 --> 00:05:12.187
So it's kind of like how much power do Americans want Trump and his administration to have going into his final two years of being president?

105
00:05:12.653 --> 00:05:14.934
Okay, so the Republicans really want to win.

106
00:05:16.174 --> 00:05:17.355
How are things looking for them?

107
00:05:17.675 --> 00:05:18.455
Not great.

108
00:05:18.875 --> 00:05:27.759
So the New York Times presidential approval tracker is telling us that approval ratings for Donald Trump are at an all-time kind of low at the moment.

109
00:05:28.099 --> 00:05:32.180
So Trump currently has around a 60% disapproval rating.

110
00:05:32.581 --> 00:05:34.681
They've collated like multiple surveys.

111
00:05:34.741 --> 00:05:36.282
They're kind of aggregating averages there.

112
00:05:36.322 --> 00:05:41.044
But consistently, it's kind of showing up in the late 50s, early 60% for disapproval.

113
00:05:41.793 --> 00:05:47.736
This is a worse disapproval rating than when Biden was at the end of his term.

114
00:05:47.756 --> 00:05:48.937
Is it really?

115
00:05:48.957 --> 00:05:49.217
Yes.

116
00:05:49.537 --> 00:05:53.860
It's also worse than Trump's disapproval rating was at the end of his first term.

117
00:05:54.200 --> 00:06:00.283
So he's beaten himself and Joe Biden, both of who famously got kicked out of office.

118
00:06:00.824 --> 00:06:04.046
But this totally makes sense why he's now scrambling.

119
00:06:04.306 --> 00:06:05.486
Yeah, you'd be freaking out.

120
00:06:05.526 --> 00:06:07.888
You'd be looking at this and being like, oh, like, fuck.

121
00:06:07.908 --> 00:06:08.008
Yeah.

122
00:06:08.448 --> 00:06:09.508
We want to hold on to power.

123
00:06:09.609 --> 00:06:13.270
How are we going to convince the American voter to keep us in office?

124
00:06:14.130 --> 00:06:17.332
And that brings us to the $5,000 promise.

125
00:06:18.152 --> 00:06:18.852
Shall we take a listen?

126
00:06:19.032 --> 00:06:19.292
Yes.

127
00:06:19.773 --> 00:06:28.316
Because of our economic, tremendous economic success, like in history, we've never had anything like what's happening.

128
00:06:29.096 --> 00:06:33.398
But because of our tremendous strength and success economically,

129
00:06:34.465 --> 00:06:40.834
I will issue a dividend to every adult citizen in the United States of America for $5,000.

130
00:06:44.717 --> 00:06:46.438
So where was he when this happened?

131
00:06:46.538 --> 00:06:46.779
Okay.

132
00:06:46.959 --> 00:06:52.162
So Trump was speaking at the Republican Party's midterm convention in Dallas, Texas.

133
00:06:52.182 --> 00:06:56.766
So this is essentially his pitch to try to keep Republicans in power.

134
00:06:57.526 --> 00:06:59.268
And it came during his keynote speech.

135
00:06:59.608 --> 00:07:01.449
I think it was like roughly an hour into the speech.

136
00:07:01.629 --> 00:07:03.070
It was a two hour speech.

137
00:07:03.291 --> 00:07:05.292
That is a residency.

138
00:07:05.312 --> 00:07:05.933
It was a residency.

139
00:07:07.294 --> 00:07:30.916
that's two-thirds of the era's tour that's crazy it was a really weird long speech sorry like yes conceptualize yes like think about the longest wedding speech you've ever had to sit through or like the longest i don't know like school assembly speech and you're like fuck this is going on forever that was probably 20 minutes no for me it was like 46 minutes it was a bad wedding speech 46 minutes we'll come back to that another time double it

140
00:07:31.436 --> 00:07:33.559
More than double it.

141
00:07:33.900 --> 00:07:34.581
More than double it.

142
00:07:34.921 --> 00:07:38.466
That's actually, when I read that, I was like, oh, that's actually torture.

143
00:07:38.927 --> 00:07:39.248
Anyway.

144
00:07:39.268 --> 00:07:44.055
The New York Times, funnily enough, they described it as the extended director's cut of speeches.

145
00:07:44.575 --> 00:07:45.998
Because, like, you'd fall asleep.

146
00:07:46.398 --> 00:07:53.522
But like the thing about Trump that we often forget when we hear little snippets of this is he is like weirdly entertaining.

147
00:07:53.542 --> 00:07:54.843
But for two hours?

148
00:07:54.863 --> 00:07:56.264
No, I'm not saying I'd be entertaining.

149
00:07:56.364 --> 00:07:59.926
It's like someone's kooky grandfather's entertaining, but could I listen to him for two hours?

150
00:07:59.946 --> 00:08:03.368
I'm not saying I'd be entertaining, but I'm just saying that like we forget that like

151
00:08:04.008 --> 00:08:05.929
It's kind of a spectacle to watch him.

152
00:08:06.089 --> 00:08:17.616
So I do think there'd be people there who were... Did you think, though, that the reason he made that call, like, halfway through the speech is because he was losing people in the audience and he just kind of, like, threw something out there to keep people awake?

153
00:08:17.736 --> 00:08:23.680
Sarah, I don't think it's possible to put myself in the mind of Donald Trump.

154
00:08:24.020 --> 00:08:26.001
Actually, like, great question.

155
00:08:27.061 --> 00:08:28.462
Great, great bait to run with.

156
00:08:28.602 --> 00:08:29.242
I there's nothing.

157
00:08:29.322 --> 00:08:33.885
I genuinely am like, I cannot fathom what this man is thinking at any point in time.

158
00:08:34.305 --> 00:08:38.186
At one point, he did also say, please pretend that I'm the one running.

159
00:08:38.247 --> 00:08:44.409
Like, please pretend I am running to convince people to get emboldened and like revved up to vote for the Republicans.

160
00:08:44.429 --> 00:08:45.710
I'm sure that would help his cause.

161
00:08:45.950 --> 00:08:46.350
Right now.

162
00:08:46.390 --> 00:08:48.031
With the disapproval rating where it's at.

163
00:08:48.191 --> 00:08:48.911
Bad messaging.

164
00:08:49.271 --> 00:08:50.752
Maybe slightly confused messaging.

165
00:08:51.192 --> 00:08:52.312
Also confusing messaging.

166
00:08:52.592 --> 00:08:55.914
He called this a dividend and I'm like putting that in quote marks.

167
00:08:56.514 --> 00:08:57.514
I mean, I'm no economist.

168
00:08:57.694 --> 00:09:08.238
No, but that's also confusing because a dividend, and this is what my understanding of a dividend is, it's like what a company pays its shareholders when it makes income.

169
00:09:08.418 --> 00:09:08.919
Profit.

170
00:09:09.659 --> 00:09:10.619
Is it profit or income?

171
00:09:10.839 --> 00:09:12.640
It can happen even if they're like...

172
00:09:13.358 --> 00:09:14.538
even if they're not profitable.

173
00:09:14.558 --> 00:09:17.079
Sorry, we're getting very in the weeds of economic terms.

174
00:09:17.099 --> 00:09:23.440
But like typically the company should not be operating at a loss if they are giving out dividends.

175
00:09:23.460 --> 00:09:24.341
It's like a bit of your profit.

176
00:09:24.361 --> 00:09:27.361
It's a bit of the money you make that you give to your shareholders.

177
00:09:27.641 --> 00:09:29.962
So how the frick is he giving dividends?

178
00:09:29.982 --> 00:09:31.042
America's not a company.

179
00:09:31.362 --> 00:09:33.303
You don't have shares in the American economy.

180
00:09:33.323 --> 00:09:34.283
But also you don't have...

181
00:09:34.975 --> 00:09:36.055
You're in debt.

182
00:09:36.135 --> 00:09:38.676
Okay, we're going to come back to that in a sec.

183
00:09:39.676 --> 00:09:42.857
But it's just like, it's just like quite confusing.

184
00:09:42.957 --> 00:09:47.838
And then also he said that the money, the $5,000 checks would have to be spent domestically.

185
00:09:47.858 --> 00:09:49.618
Like that would be a condition of people getting the money.

186
00:09:49.898 --> 00:09:52.458
But he didn't give any indication about like how that would be tracked.

187
00:09:52.478 --> 00:09:56.279
How are you giving people $5,000 and then figuring out where they're spending it?

188
00:09:56.379 --> 00:09:59.900
No, there was zero follow-up, which is what makes me think he just threw it out there.

189
00:09:59.920 --> 00:10:00.140
You get it?

190
00:10:00.400 --> 00:10:06.464
You get it as a gift card to Costco or like Trader Joe's or some other.

191
00:10:06.484 --> 00:10:07.484
It's an Amazon voucher.

192
00:10:07.624 --> 00:10:09.645
It's an Amazon voucher that Bezos gives you.

193
00:10:09.665 --> 00:10:10.606
Yeah.

194
00:10:10.646 --> 00:10:13.107
Do you think that he planned on saying this in his speech?

195
00:10:13.207 --> 00:10:15.429
No, I genuinely think he threw it out there.

196
00:10:15.469 --> 00:10:20.231
And the reason I think that is because he hasn't really been able to consolidate these plans even afterwards.

197
00:10:20.532 --> 00:10:20.872
Okay.

198
00:10:21.272 --> 00:10:22.612
Well, yes.

199
00:10:22.832 --> 00:10:26.113
To counter that, though, not to say, am I countering this?

200
00:10:26.153 --> 00:10:27.313
Am I really countering this?

201
00:10:27.713 --> 00:10:29.394
Devil's advocate for the devil himself.

202
00:10:29.434 --> 00:10:30.934
I don't think this is an argument against it.

203
00:10:30.974 --> 00:10:34.995
It's more just an observation of what happened after, which is that he doubled down on the message.

204
00:10:35.015 --> 00:10:38.936
So I guess even if he didn't intend to do it in the first place, oh man, is he doubling down now?

205
00:10:38.976 --> 00:10:39.796
I think you have to.

206
00:10:39.876 --> 00:10:42.617
That's a very, what choice does he have?

207
00:10:42.937 --> 00:10:46.217
If you make a promise at a convention like that.

208
00:10:46.357 --> 00:10:48.018
To be like, vote for me, vote for my party.

209
00:10:48.038 --> 00:10:48.918
What are you supposed to do?

210
00:10:49.178 --> 00:10:50.179
He has to double down.

211
00:10:50.279 --> 00:10:53.981
So he went on Truth Social and he said, quote, when I say something, I mean it.

212
00:10:54.441 --> 00:10:55.522
So, yeah, that happened.

213
00:10:55.942 --> 00:11:03.267
But some Republicans have come out and criticized it, along with a number of economists, and questioned why this announcement happened in the first place.

214
00:11:03.387 --> 00:11:06.989
Yeah, continue being our economist of the podcast because there's some numbers to crunch here.

215
00:11:07.169 --> 00:11:08.110
Okay, there are numbers to crunch.

216
00:11:08.130 --> 00:11:08.790
Bear with me, everybody.

217
00:11:09.030 --> 00:11:09.431
No.

218
00:11:09.851 --> 00:11:13.734
So one of the reasons, I know she's got a husky voice and numbers to crunch.

219
00:11:13.754 --> 00:11:14.955
This is a great combination.

220
00:11:15.695 --> 00:11:17.757
Why do some people sound so sexy when they're husky?

221
00:11:17.817 --> 00:11:20.139
And I just sound like a teenage boy's training.

222
00:11:20.199 --> 00:11:21.359
I think you sound husky.

223
00:11:21.399 --> 00:11:24.842
Do I sound, do I, like, no, we agree I sound husky.

224
00:11:25.082 --> 00:11:26.023
It's whether I sound sexy.

225
00:11:26.043 --> 00:11:26.743
Oh, a sexy husky.

226
00:11:26.843 --> 00:11:27.964
I think I love a husky.

227
00:11:28.084 --> 00:11:29.626
I think everything's sexy, husky.

228
00:11:30.426 --> 00:11:38.112
I remember one time I got a cold in year 12 and I was doing the school play and I had this like insanely husky voice and my drama teacher was like, I need you to keep it.

229
00:11:38.372 --> 00:11:41.114
And I was like, well, the play's not for two months.

230
00:11:41.214 --> 00:11:42.495
So I don't think I can.

231
00:11:42.555 --> 00:11:44.976
And he would make me pretend.

232
00:11:45.096 --> 00:11:46.557
That's kind of diabolical.

233
00:11:46.778 --> 00:11:50.240
That's kind of like, we need to revisit that at some point.

234
00:11:50.340 --> 00:11:51.001
Crunch those numbers.

235
00:11:51.041 --> 00:11:51.321
Okay.

236
00:11:51.421 --> 00:11:56.605
So one of the reasons why Republicans and economists have come out and been like, this is a crazy idea.

237
00:11:57.305 --> 00:11:59.506
is because it's going to cost so much money.

238
00:11:59.966 --> 00:12:10.808
Given that there are more than 240 million adult citizens in the US, and you times that by $5,000 a person, this would add up to more than $1 trillion in payments for the government.

239
00:12:11.669 --> 00:12:12.389
For context.

240
00:12:12.529 --> 00:12:13.249
Trillion dollars.

241
00:12:13.269 --> 00:12:13.469
Yes.

242
00:12:13.669 --> 00:12:23.232
For context of how a trillion dollars fits into the US economy, the US government spent just over $7 trillion during the last financial year, the 2025 budget.

243
00:12:25.480 --> 00:12:30.762
So that's like one seventh of the entire expenditure of government.

244
00:12:31.103 --> 00:12:32.303
Doesn't it make you think of Austin Powers?

245
00:12:33.144 --> 00:12:33.504
How?

246
00:12:34.024 --> 00:12:35.204
A trillion dollars.

247
00:12:35.264 --> 00:12:36.645
Come on, you don't know that scene?

248
00:12:36.665 --> 00:12:38.026
With the little mini-me- Never mind.

249
00:12:38.146 --> 00:12:39.486
Continue.

250
00:12:41.047 --> 00:12:43.568
told, maybe that's what he was thinking of in this moment.

251
00:12:44.028 --> 00:12:49.851
So Jamie Vance came out and he said that maybe this could be funded by revenue from the tariffs.

252
00:12:49.871 --> 00:12:53.552
So the tariffs that have been collected from foreign countries and companies.

253
00:12:53.993 --> 00:12:58.835
But the cost of a trillion dollars is still way more than the US has raised from these tariffs.

254
00:12:58.855 --> 00:13:03.197
And that was even before the Supreme Court struck down much of Trump's tariffs program last year.

255
00:13:03.217 --> 00:13:05.898
So I don't know how those figures are coming out either.

256
00:13:05.918 --> 00:13:06.018
Yeah.

257
00:13:06.678 --> 00:13:11.280
And the US government has been spending more money than it is bringing in each year.

258
00:13:11.301 --> 00:13:14.542
Well, didn't the debt just reach 40 trillion?

259
00:13:14.562 --> 00:13:15.403
Yes, exactly.

260
00:13:15.683 --> 00:13:20.125
The current government debt as a country is 40 trillion dollars.

261
00:13:20.705 --> 00:13:26.028
So the idea that you would add more to that debt is wild.

262
00:13:26.609 --> 00:13:27.889
Not even speaking economically.

263
00:13:28.049 --> 00:13:28.229
Yes.

264
00:13:28.750 --> 00:13:29.850
If we move to just legally.

265
00:13:30.070 --> 00:13:30.291
Yes.

266
00:13:30.451 --> 00:13:32.152
Is that even possible for him to promise that?

267
00:13:32.252 --> 00:13:32.772
Great question.

268
00:13:33.152 --> 00:13:39.414
Because immediately when this announcement came out, a lot of people online started saying, huh, well, this is a bribe.

269
00:13:39.934 --> 00:13:44.175
And when we think about political bribes, we think, well, those aren't legal.

270
00:13:44.315 --> 00:13:45.855
Fair conclusions that everyone's coming to.

271
00:13:46.375 --> 00:13:50.576
So to be clear, it is illegal under US law to buy votes.

272
00:13:50.756 --> 00:13:53.997
I literally looked it up because I wanted to make sure it's under federal law.

273
00:13:54.017 --> 00:13:55.077
It's under the US code.

274
00:13:55.517 --> 00:13:57.818
However, in this situation, Sarah...

275
00:13:58.578 --> 00:14:01.280
It might be slightly more legally gray.

276
00:14:02.241 --> 00:14:06.284
So parties make a lot of promises at elections.

277
00:14:06.884 --> 00:14:18.333
Like a party will come in and say, if you elect us, we're going to cut taxes for everybody by this amount, or we're going to give like the baby bonus, or we're going to increase the minimum wage.

278
00:14:18.373 --> 00:14:22.516
Like they'll come out and make these big kind of financial promises that will help people's bottom dollar.

279
00:14:22.936 --> 00:14:25.519
And so you could argue like, are those brides as well?

280
00:14:25.539 --> 00:14:27.762
Like, is this kind of like what politics is all about?

281
00:14:27.782 --> 00:14:29.363
But that's a much bigger conversation.

282
00:14:30.345 --> 00:14:35.210
What Trump has done here definitely seems like a much more direct transactional offer than we're used to hearing.

283
00:14:35.651 --> 00:14:38.894
But the BBC spoke to a number of legal experts, some of whom said...

284
00:14:39.575 --> 00:14:40.675
This could be legal.

285
00:14:41.176 --> 00:14:45.757
And that's because Trump isn't saying that he will only give you the money if you vote for Republicans.

286
00:14:46.177 --> 00:14:49.998
He's going to give every adult American money if the Republicans win.

287
00:14:50.018 --> 00:14:52.139
That's a slightly... Do you see like the difference there?

288
00:14:52.159 --> 00:14:54.620
It's not like, hey, if you vote for me, I'm going to give you $5,000.

289
00:14:54.760 --> 00:14:56.380
It's like... Everyone gets it.

290
00:14:56.400 --> 00:14:57.381
So it's not a specific...

291
00:14:57.521 --> 00:14:57.961
Exactly.

292
00:14:57.981 --> 00:14:58.601
Maintain government.

293
00:14:58.641 --> 00:14:59.281
You get it anyway.

294
00:14:59.301 --> 00:15:00.322
But if you didn't vote for me.

295
00:15:00.742 --> 00:15:02.462
But I think the bigger question here is...

296
00:15:04.418 --> 00:15:07.682
Is this promise even true or legitimate?

297
00:15:07.962 --> 00:15:08.983
Like, do you think...

298
00:15:09.203 --> 00:15:10.124
He would follow through on it?

299
00:15:10.144 --> 00:15:10.465
Yes.

300
00:15:10.785 --> 00:15:10.985
No.

301
00:15:12.046 --> 00:15:13.648
I think that's a fair conclusion to come to.

302
00:15:14.248 --> 00:15:15.830
Well, just his track record.

303
00:15:16.391 --> 00:15:17.292
Yes, but his track...

304
00:15:18.648 --> 00:15:22.170
Yes, but his track record specifically for paying these dividends.

305
00:15:22.411 --> 00:15:26.774
This is not the first time this man has promised dividend checks to people for things.

306
00:15:27.354 --> 00:15:38.041
So back in 2025, Trump announced on Truth Social that a dividend of at least $2,000 a person would be paid to Americans, funded by the tariffs.

307
00:15:38.962 --> 00:15:40.123
Sarah, it's been 10 months now.

308
00:15:40.993 --> 00:15:44.676
And we've seen no further updates, progress, payments.

309
00:15:44.896 --> 00:15:45.937
Of course not.

310
00:15:46.157 --> 00:15:46.938
Of course not.

311
00:15:47.058 --> 00:15:52.283
And so it's just interesting to me that we've literally had the same kind of promise made before.

312
00:15:52.763 --> 00:15:56.146
But he's also had plenty of empty promises, like not even economically.

313
00:15:56.206 --> 00:15:58.348
But this is like a really direct example.

314
00:15:58.388 --> 00:15:59.769
This is like an identical example.

315
00:15:59.789 --> 00:16:00.710
Identical example.

316
00:16:00.930 --> 00:16:02.091
What do you think about the whole thing?

317
00:16:02.451 --> 00:16:04.912
I think it's really desperate from him.

318
00:16:05.472 --> 00:16:12.416
But I also think it's so morally bankrupt to be appealing to people that need money because of the mess that he's made.

319
00:16:13.016 --> 00:16:23.561
And I, you know, for the people online, I've seen so many people online being like, like, I don't know what's coming up in my feed right now, but I'm getting kind of MAGA stuff every now and again, which is really interesting.

320
00:16:23.581 --> 00:16:24.021
That's fascinating.

321
00:16:24.041 --> 00:16:26.802
And it'll be like, you know, I'm really excited for this $5,000.

322
00:16:26.862 --> 00:16:27.143
And I go...

323
00:16:28.987 --> 00:16:34.575
I'm only mad that I didn't get to scam you first, if you actually believe that.

324
00:16:34.635 --> 00:16:42.726
I think it's, yeah, the thing that feels the most kind of heartbreaking or disappointing is that people are feeling so much financial desperation.

325
00:16:42.746 --> 00:16:42.987
Yeah.

326
00:16:43.527 --> 00:16:45.270
And to kind of prey upon that...

327
00:16:45.430 --> 00:16:46.551
And it's like a sugar hit, right?

328
00:16:46.571 --> 00:16:47.231
It's a lifeline.

329
00:16:47.451 --> 00:16:54.276
It's a sugar hit for some, but like that's not actually going to improve anyone's life long term, you know, like that's not actually fixing the problem.

330
00:16:54.296 --> 00:16:56.257
Certainly not going to do anything for the US economy.

331
00:16:56.277 --> 00:16:56.778
Certainly not.

332
00:16:56.798 --> 00:17:01.161
In fact, it's making things worse for like a really temporary relief.

333
00:17:01.421 --> 00:17:01.681
Yeah.

334
00:17:01.901 --> 00:17:03.242
Well, we'll have to see if it works.

335
00:17:03.402 --> 00:17:05.464
The midterms will be coming up in a few months.

336
00:17:05.524 --> 00:17:07.625
Michigan mum Dhani is in the race.

337
00:17:07.765 --> 00:17:08.966
We've talked about him before.

338
00:17:09.006 --> 00:17:11.027
We'll be circling back on this topic.

339
00:17:11.067 --> 00:17:11.848
So yeah, stay tuned.

340
00:17:14.380 --> 00:17:19.884
NFL star Aaron Rodgers tried to expose actress Shailene Woodley and accidentally made her more likable.

341
00:17:20.365 --> 00:17:21.325
I'm obsessed with this story.

342
00:17:21.926 --> 00:17:24.288
Shocked and excited at the way this story panned out.

343
00:17:24.568 --> 00:17:26.029
That's like the only way I can describe it.

344
00:17:26.369 --> 00:17:26.750
Okay.

345
00:17:26.770 --> 00:17:31.814
First up, first up, before we get into the actual story, tell me who is Shailene Woodley?

346
00:17:31.854 --> 00:17:32.214
Shailene Woodley?

347
00:17:32.234 --> 00:17:33.415
You know who Shailene Woodley is.

348
00:17:33.635 --> 00:17:34.596
I know who Shailene Woodley is.

349
00:17:34.616 --> 00:17:37.178
But just give us a little refresher on the life of Shailene Woodley.

350
00:17:37.238 --> 00:17:38.619
Shailene Woodley is an actress.

351
00:17:38.879 --> 00:17:41.981
She was Amy in Life of an American Teenager, which I know you used to watch.

352
00:17:42.001 --> 00:17:42.081
Yes.

353
00:17:42.101 --> 00:17:42.282
Yes.

354
00:17:43.098 --> 00:17:44.419
I think she was very unlikable in it.

355
00:17:45.119 --> 00:17:46.139
She's deeply unlikable.

356
00:17:46.219 --> 00:17:54.803
I used to get home from school and like go on those websites that let you watch American TV shows because they hadn't come out in Australia yet and just like stream it.

357
00:17:55.043 --> 00:17:58.905
I think I only saw like one or two episodes, but I was a big Divergent fan and she's Triss.

358
00:17:58.965 --> 00:18:00.386
She's the main character in Divergent.

359
00:18:00.426 --> 00:18:00.666
Yes.

360
00:18:00.906 --> 00:18:03.927
She was also the Fault in Our Stars and Jane in Big Little Lies.

361
00:18:04.388 --> 00:18:05.088
Huge career.

362
00:18:05.548 --> 00:18:07.929
She does a lot of environmental activism as well.

363
00:18:07.969 --> 00:18:09.610
She made headlines for that.

364
00:18:09.650 --> 00:18:11.370
She's made headlines for that a bunch of times.

365
00:18:11.770 --> 00:18:12.891
She's very spiritual.

366
00:18:12.951 --> 00:18:13.711
She's quite crunchy.

367
00:18:13.831 --> 00:18:14.792
She's super crunchy.

368
00:18:14.832 --> 00:18:15.492
Super crunchy.

369
00:18:15.512 --> 00:18:20.334
She's the kind of friend who would carry crystals around and like... She's a woman off my own heart.

370
00:18:20.394 --> 00:18:21.534
She's you.

371
00:18:21.674 --> 00:18:22.014
Yeah.

372
00:18:22.114 --> 00:18:23.435
And you look alike, so...

373
00:18:24.055 --> 00:18:30.618
Okay, so I've only ever been told that I look like two celebrities, and that is Meryl Streep and Shailene Woodley.

374
00:18:30.638 --> 00:18:31.198
Yes, yes.

375
00:18:31.838 --> 00:18:35.301
And I don't think I see the Meryl Streep as much as I find that hilarious.

376
00:18:35.321 --> 00:18:36.402
And I like telling everyone that.

377
00:18:36.782 --> 00:18:38.643
I do see the Shailene Woodley a little bit more.

378
00:18:38.683 --> 00:18:39.384
Oh, no, 100%.

379
00:18:39.504 --> 00:18:41.145
Sarah was telling me this before we got into the recording.

380
00:18:41.165 --> 00:18:41.606
I was Googling.

381
00:18:41.626 --> 00:18:43.147
I was like, oh, you could be cousins.

382
00:18:43.307 --> 00:18:44.268
I think cousins.

383
00:18:44.368 --> 00:18:46.970
I don't think we look similar, but I think we look like we could be the same.

384
00:18:48.030 --> 00:18:48.511
100%.

385
00:18:48.791 --> 00:18:49.572
And then we have Aaron.

386
00:18:49.812 --> 00:18:50.292
He's there.

387
00:18:50.312 --> 00:18:51.333
Who's Aaron?

388
00:18:51.573 --> 00:18:52.534
Aaron is...

389
00:18:52.554 --> 00:18:53.875
The man I know less about him.

390
00:18:54.315 --> 00:18:58.178
He's one of the biggest American football quarterbacks of this generation.

391
00:18:58.539 --> 00:18:58.839
Sure.

392
00:18:58.899 --> 00:18:59.940
So good for him.

393
00:19:00.020 --> 00:19:04.243
A four-time NFL MVP and Super Bowl winning quarterback.

394
00:19:04.383 --> 00:19:07.446
So I shouldn't be so I shouldn't be so like laissez-faire about that.

395
00:19:07.466 --> 00:19:08.086
Good on him.

396
00:19:08.106 --> 00:19:08.987
That's an accomplishment.

397
00:19:09.007 --> 00:19:10.068
That is an accomplishment.

398
00:19:10.088 --> 00:19:11.409
In the context of this story.

399
00:19:11.509 --> 00:19:14.591
Well, OK, so let's go back onto their relationship a little bit.

400
00:19:14.671 --> 00:19:14.872
So.

401
00:19:15.512 --> 00:19:17.413
They were really private as a couple.

402
00:19:17.433 --> 00:19:22.934
They were also kind of random because they met during the pandemic and they did lockdown together.

403
00:19:23.014 --> 00:19:25.555
They moved in together pretty quickly because of the pandemic.

404
00:19:25.815 --> 00:19:28.115
They got engaged in December 2020.

405
00:19:28.596 --> 00:19:32.937
Then in February 2022, there was reports that they had split.

406
00:19:33.217 --> 00:19:33.357
Mm-hmm.

407
00:19:33.737 --> 00:19:38.180
And Shailene herself has actually remained pretty guarded about the relationship ever since.

408
00:19:38.881 --> 00:19:46.566
In later interviews, she would go on to say that post that relationship, she went through a period of like intense depression and emotional pain about the breakup.

409
00:19:46.606 --> 00:19:53.812
And then she said it was a really lovely relationship and then said like, but still she can't really talk about it because it makes her cry.

410
00:19:54.574 --> 00:19:54.794
Yeah.

411
00:19:55.575 --> 00:19:59.380
Interestingly, though, Aaron has been pretty public even before this.

412
00:19:59.660 --> 00:19:59.920
Right.

413
00:20:00.161 --> 00:20:04.466
So Aaron made comments immediately after their split.

414
00:20:04.566 --> 00:20:06.889
I think it was just days after the reports of their breakup.

415
00:20:07.249 --> 00:20:11.854
He posted what he called his Monday night gratitude writing.

416
00:20:12.762 --> 00:20:14.844
Okay.

417
00:20:14.904 --> 00:20:15.565
We love a men.

418
00:20:15.725 --> 00:20:17.487
No, let's encourage this.

419
00:20:17.507 --> 00:20:18.809
Yeah, a men who journal.

420
00:20:19.289 --> 00:20:19.710
Online?

421
00:20:20.070 --> 00:20:20.350
No.

422
00:20:20.791 --> 00:20:32.623
So he's on his Instagram for his Monday night gratitude writing and he says, again, post breakup, thanks for letting me chase after you the first couple of months after we met and finally letting me catch up to you and be part of your life.

423
00:20:33.264 --> 00:20:35.006
But he didn't only just publicly thank her.

424
00:20:35.106 --> 00:20:37.168
He also publicly apologized to her.

425
00:20:37.789 --> 00:20:43.394
This was more to do with the fact that Aaron became the face of a huge COVID controversy at the time.

426
00:20:43.775 --> 00:20:45.977
When I was researching this, it actually did kind of ring a bell.

427
00:20:46.497 --> 00:20:51.903
So he did a podcast where he spoke about how against the vaccine he was.

428
00:20:52.924 --> 00:20:54.505
He said he wouldn't like...

429
00:20:55.567 --> 00:21:01.094
It was like, I wouldn't adhere to the woke culture or a crazed group of individuals who say you have to do something.

430
00:21:01.174 --> 00:21:02.216
Like that was his reasoning.

431
00:21:02.576 --> 00:21:02.856
Okay.

432
00:21:03.457 --> 00:21:05.720
And that was a huge, huge, huge story at the time, right?

433
00:21:05.941 --> 00:21:06.201
Yes.

434
00:21:06.922 --> 00:21:08.184
Massive fallout for that.

435
00:21:09.565 --> 00:21:11.087
And then he apologized for it.

436
00:21:11.608 --> 00:21:23.382
And he said, I didn't realize the kind of shrapnel that was being flaked off what I felt like were the bullets coming at me because I was too locked in on me and defending myself and trying to get the message out.

437
00:21:23.603 --> 00:21:26.867
Specifically said like, and to Shay and to my family, like, I'm sorry kind of thing.

438
00:21:26.887 --> 00:21:27.467
Okay.

439
00:21:27.487 --> 00:21:27.788
Okay.

440
00:21:28.128 --> 00:21:39.920
Now, four years later, Aaron goes on his friend and I believe teammate Cam Haywood's Not Just Football podcast and decides to talk at length about the breakup.

441
00:21:39.960 --> 00:21:41.983
Well, Sarah, it's not just about football, this podcast.

442
00:21:42.083 --> 00:21:42.503
It's not.

443
00:21:42.743 --> 00:21:43.845
They've got to talk about something else.

444
00:21:43.865 --> 00:21:44.806
You're going to wish it was.

445
00:21:45.086 --> 00:21:46.788
You know, then I do, Shailene.

446
00:21:47.348 --> 00:21:47.829
I propose.

447
00:21:48.409 --> 00:21:49.050
And she says yes.

448
00:21:49.150 --> 00:21:52.253
Now, she maybe felt like she was forced to make a decision.

449
00:21:52.293 --> 00:21:52.954
She could have said no.

450
00:21:53.334 --> 00:21:58.800
But not a couple of days after that, she tells me, you know, before we get married, I got to go f*** this guy.

451
00:21:59.641 --> 00:22:04.766
So essentially, he's proposed and she's gone like, yeah, but give me a minute.

452
00:22:04.786 --> 00:22:05.347
I've got to go...

453
00:22:06.541 --> 00:22:07.722
Got to go see about someone else.

454
00:22:07.882 --> 00:22:08.783
Yes.

455
00:22:08.843 --> 00:22:09.524
Pretty intense.

456
00:22:09.724 --> 00:22:10.165
Yeah.

457
00:22:10.605 --> 00:22:20.716
And I'd imagine that, like, sharing that online or sharing that publicly, you would maybe think, oh, I look really good in this story.

458
00:22:20.956 --> 00:22:22.598
Everyone's going to be on my side.

459
00:22:23.059 --> 00:22:23.659
And yet.

460
00:22:23.759 --> 00:22:24.840
And yet, what happened?

461
00:22:25.481 --> 00:22:26.002
Shailene.

462
00:22:27.564 --> 00:22:29.006
hasn't responded to this herself.

463
00:22:29.326 --> 00:22:29.907
Fair.

464
00:22:30.027 --> 00:22:31.528
She's been too busy winning Emmys.

465
00:22:31.968 --> 00:22:33.450
The internet has.

466
00:22:33.550 --> 00:22:36.072
They are on her side from everything I've seen.

467
00:22:36.352 --> 00:22:40.496
She's woken up with admiration and fame from the girls.

468
00:22:40.716 --> 00:22:41.877
I was kind of surprised.

469
00:22:42.017 --> 00:22:44.379
I actually didn't know if that was going to be the case.

470
00:22:44.399 --> 00:22:49.344
And when I was looking through the comments section, because I also got fed this, I was like, oh no, people are like, yeah, the girls.

471
00:22:49.864 --> 00:22:51.605
I think, look, I think it's very tongue in cheek.

472
00:22:51.806 --> 00:22:54.087
The comments are like, I didn't know her game.

473
00:22:55.388 --> 00:22:56.889
Like men in women's fields.

474
00:22:57.270 --> 00:22:58.771
She's a trailblazer.

475
00:22:59.071 --> 00:23:02.173
She's doing extra credit on the decent to men assignment.

476
00:23:02.214 --> 00:23:02.774
Yes.

477
00:23:03.414 --> 00:23:04.575
I understand her.

478
00:23:04.655 --> 00:23:06.116
Girl, was it Theo James?

479
00:23:06.217 --> 00:23:07.578
Like everyone's just sort of like...

480
00:23:08.578 --> 00:23:10.600
No, there was one that was like, that's so dauntless of her.

481
00:23:10.620 --> 00:23:12.782
Throwback to Divergent if you haven't seen.

482
00:23:12.862 --> 00:23:13.162
Yes.

483
00:23:13.522 --> 00:23:15.384
Look, I do think it's just meant to be quite funny.

484
00:23:15.664 --> 00:23:21.549
And again, I think everyone's talking about this very broadly in terms of relationship dynamics, not specifically about this couple.

485
00:23:21.569 --> 00:23:26.413
And I think that's where this conversation's kind of landed, where everyone's been like, well, a lot of guys just go and cheat.

486
00:23:26.873 --> 00:23:28.174
She's kind enough to ask.

487
00:23:28.674 --> 00:23:28.915
In...

488
00:23:29.715 --> 00:23:31.676
His defense, I'm scared to say that.

489
00:23:31.716 --> 00:23:32.397
No, no, no.

490
00:23:32.497 --> 00:23:33.597
I think that's better.

491
00:23:33.617 --> 00:23:36.759
If someone came to you in a relationship after you got engaged and said this to you.

492
00:23:37.240 --> 00:23:38.320
I'd be out of there so far.

493
00:23:38.360 --> 00:23:41.422
Yeah, you'd be kind of like.

494
00:23:41.542 --> 00:23:42.143
Imagine if my friend.

495
00:23:42.163 --> 00:23:44.584
Imagine if I came to you and I was like, hey, this guy.

496
00:23:45.084 --> 00:23:45.545
We're getting engaged.

497
00:23:45.565 --> 00:23:45.885
We love him.

498
00:23:46.325 --> 00:23:46.805
No, no.

499
00:23:46.845 --> 00:23:48.066
I'm getting engaged with someone else, right?

500
00:23:48.186 --> 00:23:49.407
And I've come to you for advice.

501
00:23:49.427 --> 00:23:49.507
Yes.

502
00:23:49.527 --> 00:23:50.368
And I said, hey.

503
00:23:51.442 --> 00:23:59.049
This guy, he's ready to propose and he's told me that he has the ring and he's ready to propose, but he just needs to go fuck his ex really quick.

504
00:23:59.169 --> 00:23:59.890
What do you think of that?

505
00:24:00.090 --> 00:24:02.152
You'd say, Sarah, get the fuck out of there.

506
00:24:02.172 --> 00:24:04.854
I would be like, this is diabolical.

507
00:24:04.874 --> 00:24:05.935
That is diabolical.

508
00:24:06.055 --> 00:24:06.796
Absolutely not.

509
00:24:06.896 --> 00:24:06.996
No.

510
00:24:07.376 --> 00:24:08.237
We have both spoken.

511
00:24:08.257 --> 00:24:09.619
We are both so anti-cheating.

512
00:24:09.659 --> 00:24:10.319
It's not even funny.

513
00:24:10.339 --> 00:24:11.360
Super anti-cheating.

514
00:24:11.480 --> 00:24:11.981
That like...

515
00:24:13.314 --> 00:24:14.574
It just wouldn't even be a question.

516
00:24:14.674 --> 00:24:17.095
Like if it was roles reversed, we'd be like, absolutely not.

517
00:24:17.115 --> 00:24:18.976
I don't even know what I'd do in that situation.

518
00:24:18.996 --> 00:24:19.936
Like who do I call?

519
00:24:19.956 --> 00:24:20.816
Do I call the police?

520
00:24:20.836 --> 00:24:21.897
Like that's how I feel.

521
00:24:22.377 --> 00:24:25.978
Like I, yeah, you would hope like you'd be like, absolutely not.

522
00:24:26.138 --> 00:24:26.338
Yeah.

523
00:24:26.518 --> 00:24:28.179
But again, I think this is the tug in cheek.

524
00:24:28.239 --> 00:24:32.320
And I also think this is like the wider conversation, which is like, well, she did ask him.

525
00:24:32.440 --> 00:24:33.320
Guys don't do that.

526
00:24:33.620 --> 00:24:38.382
And also it kind of plays into this trope where like he's come out and said this now.

527
00:24:38.682 --> 00:24:39.203
why now?

528
00:24:39.283 --> 00:24:40.925
Like, she's just won an Emmy.

529
00:24:41.306 --> 00:24:42.748
She's at her prime.

530
00:24:43.008 --> 00:24:49.337
She's just had this huge milestone and essentially the same, like, fortnight, if not a week from that, he decides to go do this.

531
00:24:49.397 --> 00:24:53.042
And I think it's just like, you know, this attempt to embarrass her.

532
00:24:53.062 --> 00:24:54.564
And everyone's like, actually, no.

533
00:24:55.205 --> 00:24:56.066
We're not going to allow that.

534
00:24:56.286 --> 00:24:59.109
Can I offer another spanner in the works here?

535
00:24:59.249 --> 00:24:59.470
Yes.

536
00:24:59.850 --> 00:25:06.137
Which is that Shailene Woodley has famously talked about being in an open relationship in the past.

537
00:25:06.297 --> 00:25:13.665
She did an interview with the New York Times in 2020 where she talked about how she'd been in a monogamous relationship and an open relationship and...

538
00:25:13.890 --> 00:25:15.431
And I guess like a broader question.

539
00:25:15.452 --> 00:25:16.733
I'm not saying that I don't know.

540
00:25:16.753 --> 00:25:18.114
I don't know what their relationship is here.

541
00:25:18.154 --> 00:25:19.155
We don't know these dynamics.

542
00:25:19.175 --> 00:25:19.756
You're so right.

543
00:25:19.776 --> 00:25:22.458
She might be like, well, I'm happy to commit to you if that's what you want.

544
00:25:22.478 --> 00:25:23.719
It's not really how I roll.

545
00:25:24.240 --> 00:25:27.063
But let me go do this because I'm usually in an open relationship or something.

546
00:25:27.303 --> 00:25:28.124
Or I'm open to that.

547
00:25:28.264 --> 00:25:35.090
I guess it's just like talking about these deeply personal relationship dynamics and, I don't know, issues.

548
00:25:36.011 --> 00:25:43.973
without the kind of understanding, as a member of the public, like the broader context of their relationship and without hearing her side, there's a lot of gaps in information there.

549
00:25:44.153 --> 00:25:49.434
The other thing with this, though, is like we were just saying we hate cheating, but like if you ask it's a question, right?

550
00:25:49.794 --> 00:25:50.894
He could have said no.

551
00:25:51.394 --> 00:25:52.895
So then she doesn't do it.

552
00:25:53.135 --> 00:25:55.055
I'd still be pissed if someone asked me the question.

553
00:25:55.075 --> 00:25:55.835
Of course, of course.

554
00:25:56.015 --> 00:25:58.136
But it's also like she asked the question.

555
00:25:58.516 --> 00:26:00.076
I don't think I'd like to be asked that question.

556
00:26:00.136 --> 00:26:00.416
No.

557
00:26:00.436 --> 00:26:03.517
But it's not cheating because she did like...

558
00:26:04.517 --> 00:26:22.653
simple question and i mean if it revealed that this relationship was just not going to work like they had different intentions or thoughts about what meaning it what it means to be in a relationship and what they want for being in a relationship like the question as well is like when it comes to cheating or like would you want them to ask you or would you want them just to go do it or yeah

559
00:26:25.055 --> 00:26:25.556
Totally.

560
00:26:25.636 --> 00:26:29.900
And like, I've been with my now husband for almost 11 years.

561
00:26:30.400 --> 00:26:34.704
And like, you have to have a lot of conversations in that time about like, well, what do you like?

562
00:26:34.804 --> 00:26:37.867
Not about this necessarily, but just like a lot of questions about like, what do you want for the future?

563
00:26:37.927 --> 00:26:38.828
What do you want for now?

564
00:26:39.248 --> 00:26:40.510
How do you see our relationship?

565
00:26:40.570 --> 00:26:41.831
Like, are we exclusive?

566
00:26:41.851 --> 00:26:44.794
Like all those kinds of things and make sure you're aligned on them.

567
00:26:45.314 --> 00:26:48.117
And relationships work if you are aligned on them.

568
00:26:48.297 --> 00:26:48.657
Yeah.

569
00:26:48.677 --> 00:26:48.937
So yeah.

570
00:26:49.598 --> 00:26:51.020
Clearly they weren't aligned on this.

571
00:26:51.440 --> 00:26:52.922
They weren't aligned, but they were communicating.

572
00:26:52.942 --> 00:26:54.063
But they were communicating.

573
00:26:54.163 --> 00:26:55.544
So thanks for that.

574
00:26:55.565 --> 00:27:01.331
I just need to know more about this, but I am enjoying, and I don't know whether that is really double standard of me.

575
00:27:01.711 --> 00:27:04.554
Like almost definitely is, but like it's very funny.

576
00:27:04.975 --> 00:27:05.255
Yes.

577
00:27:05.335 --> 00:27:06.576
The public reaction.

578
00:27:07.177 --> 00:27:08.478
The public reaction is entertaining.

579
00:27:08.559 --> 00:27:09.640
It's like, yeah, right on.

580
00:27:09.800 --> 00:27:09.900
Yeah.

581
00:27:15.177 --> 00:27:18.279
A former Anthropic employee said AI could kill us all.

582
00:27:18.859 --> 00:27:21.400
And we're all pretty freaked out about that, Sarah.

583
00:27:22.481 --> 00:27:22.721
Yeah.

584
00:27:23.201 --> 00:27:24.922
This story's quite layered, isn't it?

585
00:27:25.022 --> 00:27:25.582
It's quite layered.

586
00:27:25.602 --> 00:27:28.004
And there's a lot of developments to it in a very short space of time.

587
00:27:28.544 --> 00:27:30.645
So this all started last week with Jacob Coxon.

588
00:27:30.805 --> 00:27:32.226
He's 27 years old.

589
00:27:32.706 --> 00:27:35.527
He's an AI researcher who previously worked at OpenAI.

590
00:27:35.767 --> 00:27:40.430
And he took to X to write about how he had just resigned from working at Anthropic.

591
00:27:41.381 --> 00:27:52.267
He publicly came out and said that he had left those companies because he believes that neither company is acting responsibly and that AI and the technology that's being developed around AI could kill us all.

592
00:27:53.627 --> 00:27:54.228
Cool, cool, cool.

593
00:27:54.248 --> 00:27:55.548
Cool, cool, cool, cool.

594
00:27:55.809 --> 00:28:00.051
It was this long thread that has been viewed more than 170 million times.

595
00:28:00.391 --> 00:28:07.915
And he said that Anthropic and OpenAI are, and I quote, racing straight to self-improving superintelligence and gambling with our lives.

596
00:28:08.668 --> 00:28:11.590
And you might be wondering, how is AI going to kill us all?

597
00:28:11.830 --> 00:28:12.671
It's a computer.

598
00:28:12.791 --> 00:28:13.571
It's a robot.

599
00:28:13.691 --> 00:28:15.973
It's a machine that I talk to on my computer.

600
00:28:16.013 --> 00:28:17.814
Like, it's my friend.

601
00:28:17.834 --> 00:28:20.316
It's my friend.

602
00:28:21.837 --> 00:28:23.898
Some people have friendships with AI.

603
00:28:23.918 --> 00:28:24.539
I know.

604
00:28:24.659 --> 00:28:24.939
I know.

605
00:28:25.039 --> 00:28:26.400
And it's a different conversation.

606
00:28:26.500 --> 00:28:27.060
Different conversation.

607
00:28:27.080 --> 00:28:28.181
Why is chat going to kill me?

608
00:28:28.261 --> 00:28:28.541
Okay.

609
00:28:28.941 --> 00:28:29.162
So...

610
00:28:30.041 --> 00:28:34.847
Jacob specifically wrote that there will soon be what he calls superhuman systems.

611
00:28:35.587 --> 00:28:44.317
And he describes these as systems that can hack anything, revolutionize any field overnight and acquire real power and resources.

612
00:28:44.337 --> 00:28:44.918
Yeah.

613
00:28:45.491 --> 00:28:54.456
And that even though these companies understand what is happening, they are locked in this money-making race to get there as fast as possible without having appropriate safeguards.

614
00:28:54.476 --> 00:29:00.060
So, for example, like AI could become super intelligent.

615
00:29:00.540 --> 00:29:03.722
It could escape the parameters in which it's given.

616
00:29:03.822 --> 00:29:04.702
It's sandbox.

617
00:29:04.742 --> 00:29:06.944
It could escape the sandbox.

618
00:29:07.404 --> 00:29:10.406
But in terms of like how AI could hurt us, it's like it could...

619
00:29:11.046 --> 00:29:13.569
go and change the water filtration systems.

620
00:29:13.589 --> 00:29:17.753
Like so much of our world is run through computers.

621
00:29:18.053 --> 00:29:20.355
And so that's where the concerns start to come from.

622
00:29:20.375 --> 00:29:24.179
It's not like AI is going to turn into a robot and like physically.

623
00:29:24.219 --> 00:29:26.321
Do you remember that movie, I robot with Will Smith?

624
00:29:27.082 --> 00:29:29.645
Not like the little robots are going to come and like lock us in our houses.

625
00:29:29.665 --> 00:29:29.925
Yeah.

626
00:29:30.315 --> 00:29:35.637
So this post, as you can imagine, blew up, went viral, as I said, got more than 170 million views.

627
00:29:36.238 --> 00:29:39.819
Everyone starts writing about it, like the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal.

628
00:29:40.460 --> 00:29:43.121
And Jacob speaks to CNN's Anderson Cooper.

629
00:29:43.141 --> 00:29:44.261
I think we should take a listen.

630
00:29:44.941 --> 00:29:52.265
Do you agree with him that the current models, the risk is low, but it's just the speed with which this is now improving?

631
00:29:53.049 --> 00:29:54.310
Exactly, I completely agree.

632
00:29:54.450 --> 00:29:56.772
Right now there's no risk of extinction.

633
00:29:57.032 --> 00:30:09.461
The current models, the worst they can do is maybe hack into something, potentially cause a lot of damages in infrastructure, but they're not intelligent enough to outsmart us at the level that would lead to extinction.

634
00:30:10.680 --> 00:30:27.315
What's just crazy is to look at the rate of progress, and there is a very real possibility that in the immediate future, these are years that, like, next year, the year after, recursive self-improvement will happen and will enter the phase of Evan's post where he argues that there's a chance we could all die.

635
00:30:27.879 --> 00:30:29.039
He looks like Harry Potter.

636
00:30:29.479 --> 00:30:33.240
And I think we should adhere to Harry Potter's warnings.

637
00:30:33.900 --> 00:30:35.301
The prophecy is what tells.

638
00:30:35.341 --> 00:30:36.401
That's British.

639
00:30:36.881 --> 00:30:46.403
So things get crazier this week because what Jacob is referencing in that interaction there is a, I don't know if you call them retweets anymore.

640
00:30:46.483 --> 00:30:47.203
I don't know.

641
00:30:47.423 --> 00:30:50.664
But that equivalent from a guy called Evan Hubinger.

642
00:30:50.984 --> 00:30:53.184
He's the alignment science lead at Anthropics.

643
00:30:53.204 --> 00:30:57.285
So he reposted Jacob's post on X and he wrote,

644
00:30:57.745 --> 00:30:58.686
Jacob is correct here.

645
00:30:58.967 --> 00:31:02.050
We really do earnestly believe AI could kill all humans!

646
00:31:02.831 --> 00:31:07.357
I personally think it is a greater than 10% chance within the next decade.

647
00:31:07.958 --> 00:31:15.467
And then another Anthropik employee named Samuel Marks, who works on safety research at the company, also hopped on X.

648
00:31:16.048 --> 00:31:23.414
and said that AI developers believe their tech could cause human extinction and, quote, this could happen in the next few years.

649
00:31:23.714 --> 00:31:29.718
So within, like, 24 hours-ish, you've got three former and current employees.

650
00:31:29.738 --> 00:31:32.240
But I'm confused how current employees are even allowed to say that.

651
00:31:32.721 --> 00:31:37.885
I did see that, like, one of them was like, these are my views and not the views of my employer, Anthropic, at the top of their post.

652
00:31:38.465 --> 00:31:44.990
And so this is all happening so quickly and people are freaking out and it's adding to this kind of, like, online fear and discourse, right?

653
00:31:45.208 --> 00:31:49.995
But I was kind of looking at it being like, are we really that surprised?

654
00:31:50.656 --> 00:32:00.410
Because what we saw last week, yes, were some of the most explicit warnings that we've probably received and from people who work within these companies –

655
00:32:01.219 --> 00:32:08.962
But concerns about AI are nothing new and concerns about AI being raised by people who work for AI tech companies are also nothing new.

656
00:32:09.662 --> 00:32:19.345
So Hugging Face, that was when an open AI agent recently escaped their controlled system, their sandbox, and hacked a platform called Hugging Face.

657
00:32:19.905 --> 00:32:24.667
And that caused a lot of concern because it was demonstrating how AI can kind of go rogue.

658
00:32:25.488 --> 00:32:39.820
So that same month, more than 1,300 employees from companies like OpenAI, Anthropic, Meta, Google, DeepMind, they all signed an open letter calling on the US government to step in and introduce rules that would slow down the development of increasingly powerful AI.

659
00:32:40.480 --> 00:32:55.812
And then in August, more than 100 major tech companies agreed to give organizations like hospitals and critical infrastructure providers access to their strongest AI models, specifically so they could start preparing for the possibility of AI-powered cyber attacks.

660
00:32:56.032 --> 00:32:56.573
So scary.

661
00:32:57.293 --> 00:33:06.838
But Sarah, if we rewind all the way back to 2023, when kind of like AI and Chachibut, it's really kind of hitting the public market.

662
00:33:07.558 --> 00:33:12.140
Industry leaders signed a one sentence statement by the Centre for AI Safety.

663
00:33:12.400 --> 00:33:22.145
Now, this statement said, quote, mitigating the risk of extinction from AI should be a global priority alongside other societal scale risks such as pandemics and nuclear war.

664
00:33:22.305 --> 00:33:23.786
Do you know who signed this, Sarah?

665
00:33:24.645 --> 00:33:26.085
Everyone in tech ever.

666
00:33:26.505 --> 00:33:29.726
Sam Altman, the chief executive of OpenAI.

667
00:33:30.486 --> 00:33:33.807
Demis Hasivis, chief executive of Google DeepMind.

668
00:33:34.067 --> 00:33:37.507
And Dario Amodi, chief executive of Anthropic.

669
00:33:37.908 --> 00:33:40.168
So what has changed since last week?

670
00:33:40.548 --> 00:33:48.090
Okay, so last week definitely sounded a lot of public alarm bells in a way that I don't know if we've seen before.

671
00:33:48.130 --> 00:33:49.330
Definitely not to say people...

672
00:33:49.630 --> 00:33:50.370
It was blunt.

673
00:33:50.910 --> 00:33:51.150
Yes.

674
00:33:51.230 --> 00:33:58.236
And not to say that members of the public have not been rightfully concerned about AI before, but I think this definitely stirred a new level of fear in a lot more people.

675
00:33:58.396 --> 00:34:06.283
Can I just say, I do find it tough when we have been pounding this alarm for so long that people within the companies are now like, I'm sounding the alarm.

676
00:34:06.303 --> 00:34:10.126
And it's like, yeah, buddy, you've also been contributing to it and you've been working there.

677
00:34:10.546 --> 00:34:13.869
I also do find it funny the way that some people sound the alarm within companies.

678
00:34:13.889 --> 00:34:14.950
They're like, yeah, we do believe this.

679
00:34:15.210 --> 00:34:16.070
Yeah, this is a problem.

680
00:34:16.210 --> 00:34:16.410
Yeah.

681
00:34:16.450 --> 00:34:17.151
No, that's what I mean.

682
00:34:17.211 --> 00:34:22.372
It's like interesting that you're raising the alarm now, but you're also actively contributing towards it.

683
00:34:22.452 --> 00:34:24.432
And everyone else has been sounding the alarm for ages.

684
00:34:24.452 --> 00:34:24.812
Totally.

685
00:34:25.293 --> 00:34:34.475
And so what we've seen in this last week has been another example of AI tech leaders and companies being like, yeah, we need to do something about this.

686
00:34:34.935 --> 00:34:46.517
So Anthropics CEO Dario Modi, he published an essay on his website essentially agreeing that things are moving way too fast and proposing a plan for how to slow down AI development to ensure our safety.

687
00:34:47.137 --> 00:34:50.478
So the essay, if you want to read it, it's called We Must Pace the Frontier.

688
00:34:51.158 --> 00:34:54.358
And he lays out a number of things that, you know, should be done.

689
00:34:55.198 --> 00:35:03.760
For one, he says, like, within the company, they're going to give independent third-party evaluators ongoing employee-level access to its AI systems to keep reviewing what's going on.

690
00:35:04.460 --> 00:35:08.363
But they also said that they need industry-wide and global coordination.

691
00:35:08.824 --> 00:35:14.388
And democratic governments need to try and coordinate with authoritarian regimes to make sure that they are enforcing compliance too.

692
00:35:14.808 --> 00:35:24.857
Because there has been fear that if one country puts restrictions on AI, another country that wants to kind of take that control and assert dominance will power ahead with AI.

693
00:35:25.577 --> 00:35:27.579
It's kind of like this weird game of chicken.

694
00:35:27.859 --> 00:35:40.568
Essentially, the crux of this story is, is like, we all know we are racing towards doom, but none of us are willing to slow down commercially because if we stop, our competitor is going to keep going.

695
00:35:41.068 --> 00:35:47.493
Or even if it's not within a democratic government, like another country will develop like and someone else is going to do it.

696
00:35:47.813 --> 00:35:50.215
So we can't slow down because they're not slowing down.

697
00:35:50.495 --> 00:35:52.578
I also don't think it's necessarily just a profit question.

698
00:35:52.598 --> 00:35:58.084
Like, I do think the commercial and profit-driven mentality is definitely driving a lot of these companies.

699
00:35:58.585 --> 00:36:08.317
But also, I think there is genuine concern that, like, oh, a rogue foreign actor or government is going to try and push ahead and use this power –

700
00:36:08.757 --> 00:36:25.458
to take us down so there's also that fear as well it's almost like an arms race it is it is a corporate race totally is an arms race and then like sam altman and elon musk both supported this yeah so they both came out and they were like yep great idea what do you think of all of this that's a great question

701
00:36:25.738 --> 00:36:29.420
This is the first time I am not a conspiracy person.

702
00:36:29.701 --> 00:36:31.362
I am deeply against conspiracies.

703
00:36:31.402 --> 00:36:33.223
I'm a very conspiracy skeptic person.

704
00:36:33.243 --> 00:36:34.824
You're a very pragmatic person.

705
00:36:34.844 --> 00:36:36.945
I'm very like, I want to know all the evidence.

706
00:36:37.185 --> 00:36:38.406
I want to... You're a journalist.

707
00:36:38.466 --> 00:36:39.327
I'm a journalist, baby.

708
00:36:40.608 --> 00:36:41.488
I feel insane.

709
00:36:41.888 --> 00:36:45.491
This is like the first time where I turned to my husband and I was like...

710
00:36:45.991 --> 00:36:47.332
do we have to do something?

711
00:36:47.472 --> 00:36:51.114
Like, do we need to like get camping equipment?

712
00:36:51.134 --> 00:36:55.517
Do we need to like get camping filtration straws, like the water and stuff?

713
00:36:55.557 --> 00:36:59.480
Like just to have on hand, like what control do I have over the situation?

714
00:36:59.520 --> 00:37:02.101
So I feel a bit crazy.

715
00:37:02.162 --> 00:37:02.462
Yes.

716
00:37:02.762 --> 00:37:10.987
And speaking of Black Mirror, I just think that like, it's so weird how science fiction keeps predicting the world with so much

717
00:37:12.288 --> 00:37:14.417
academics or like AI or robots.

718
00:37:14.437 --> 00:37:17.028
When The Simpsons come up with an episode on this, we're fucked.

719
00:37:17.048 --> 00:37:17.530
We're so fucked.

720
00:37:20.227 --> 00:37:28.009
bad week to be an otherwise inoffensive millennial favorite with people rightfully outraged at both Pink and Ed Sheeran in defense of Macklemore.

721
00:37:28.169 --> 00:37:30.870
That's the biggest sentence with so many- So much going on.

722
00:37:30.890 --> 00:37:31.870
So many buzzwords in there.

723
00:37:32.331 --> 00:37:37.312
Basically, this all started because Macklemore said, free Palestine on stage.

724
00:37:39.273 --> 00:37:46.535
This whole story just infuriates me because if there's something you should know about me, it's that I have always fucked with Macklemore.

725
00:37:46.615 --> 00:37:47.095
Like, I-

726
00:37:47.575 --> 00:37:48.236
Babe, same.

727
00:37:48.596 --> 00:37:51.818
I remember my whole family went to a Macklemore concert once, like in the Mosh pit.

728
00:37:52.339 --> 00:37:52.779
Incredible.

729
00:37:52.799 --> 00:37:53.279
Mom and dad included.

730
00:37:53.299 --> 00:37:53.880
Favourite song?

731
00:37:53.980 --> 00:37:54.480
What is it?

732
00:37:54.800 --> 00:38:03.487
It's Can't Hold Us, but mainly, mainly, it's actually, like I was literally going to say this, like sometimes I listen to Downtown and just like pretend I'm saving up for a moment.

733
00:38:03.627 --> 00:38:04.808
Girl, Can't Hold Us?

734
00:38:04.828 --> 00:38:07.730
If you're having a bad day, put that song on.

735
00:38:07.750 --> 00:38:07.790
I.

736
00:38:08.670 --> 00:38:12.133
I was in a choir and we did it years ago.

737
00:38:12.294 --> 00:38:16.437
I also like genuinely thought homophobia ended with same love.

738
00:38:16.537 --> 00:38:17.158
It did.

739
00:38:17.258 --> 00:38:19.260
I was like, oh, glad he sorted that.

740
00:38:19.300 --> 00:38:20.321
Yeah, it's all gone now.

741
00:38:20.401 --> 00:38:21.502
It was ridiculous.

742
00:38:21.542 --> 00:38:24.564
Like, if you need a refresher on Macklemore, though, he's a rapper.

743
00:38:24.624 --> 00:38:25.785
His real name is Benjamin.

744
00:38:26.226 --> 00:38:27.267
And his breakout song.

745
00:38:27.307 --> 00:38:27.547
Yes.

746
00:38:27.927 --> 00:38:30.089
And his breakout song was Thrift Shop in 2012.

747
00:38:30.109 --> 00:38:31.730
But that's when he was Macklemore and Ryan Lewis.

748
00:38:31.971 --> 00:38:33.172
His name is not Macklemore.

749
00:38:33.652 --> 00:38:33.892
No.

750
00:38:34.413 --> 00:38:35.713
He's last known Malcolm Moore?

751
00:38:35.794 --> 00:38:36.534
No, it's not.

752
00:38:36.554 --> 00:38:37.435
Oh.

753
00:38:37.835 --> 00:38:38.876
No, I don't know where Malcolm Moore...

754
00:38:38.936 --> 00:38:40.657
I don't have that information for you.

755
00:38:40.677 --> 00:38:41.257
I wish I did.

756
00:38:41.337 --> 00:38:42.618
Yeah, disappointed.

757
00:38:42.658 --> 00:38:45.500
But he's committed to being independent as an artist.

758
00:38:45.520 --> 00:38:47.581
He's still never signed with a major label.

759
00:38:48.422 --> 00:38:51.724
And a lot of his music is about kind of like social justice, I would say.

760
00:38:52.305 --> 00:38:55.907
The reason we're talking about Malcolm Moore today is because of Ed Sheeran, though, and

761
00:38:56.167 --> 00:39:04.211
And again, I just want to say, I think it's crazy that these two, I would have otherwise said are the safest bets in Hollywood, like the safest bets in the industry.

762
00:39:04.512 --> 00:39:05.312
What do you mean by that?

763
00:39:05.332 --> 00:39:06.012
Like harmless.

764
00:39:06.252 --> 00:39:06.453
Yeah.

765
00:39:06.473 --> 00:39:09.674
Like I would, you'd never think they would be at the center of a controversy, you know?

766
00:39:10.054 --> 00:39:12.636
Very, the whole aesthetic is wholesome.

767
00:39:12.956 --> 00:39:15.277
But basically Malcolm Moore and Ed Sheeran are pals.

768
00:39:15.297 --> 00:39:17.018
They've been friends for like 13 years.

769
00:39:17.398 --> 00:39:21.901
And Malcolm Moore is opening for Ed Sheeran on his loop tour at the MetLife Stadium.

770
00:39:22.061 --> 00:39:22.921
And he says this.

771
00:39:22.941 --> 00:39:23.362
Amazing.

772
00:39:24.906 --> 00:39:32.288
One of the main reasons why I wanted to come on this tour with my brother, my dear brother Ed Sheeran.

773
00:39:32.388 --> 00:39:50.132
One of the reasons was because I wanted to stand up here on stages and stadiums across America and say two words that are very near and dear to my heart.

774
00:39:50.932 --> 00:39:52.593
Free Palestine.

775
00:39:54.712 --> 00:39:56.313
There's more to that speech as well.

776
00:39:56.573 --> 00:39:58.234
It's on his Instagram.

777
00:39:58.514 --> 00:39:59.714
You can find it on TikTok easily.

778
00:39:59.734 --> 00:40:01.595
I actually recommend to go listen to it.

779
00:40:01.655 --> 00:40:02.216
It was great.

780
00:40:02.616 --> 00:40:09.099
He then goes on to play a song called Hines Hall, which is a song that he's written about student protesters.

781
00:40:09.559 --> 00:40:15.502
And its title refers to the Columbia University's Hamilton Hall, which protesting students renamed Hines Hall.

782
00:40:16.523 --> 00:40:22.646
While he played that song, had visual footage of the devastation of Gaza on the screen behind him.

783
00:40:22.666 --> 00:40:22.986
Mm-hmm.

784
00:40:23.286 --> 00:40:27.350
Which again, I'm just looking at this and I'm going like, okay, listen to his song.

785
00:40:28.391 --> 00:40:29.431
He's clear about his message.

786
00:40:29.451 --> 00:40:30.552
He has been for years.

787
00:40:31.213 --> 00:40:32.614
This is not coming out of the blue.

788
00:40:32.694 --> 00:40:32.794
No.

789
00:40:33.095 --> 00:40:34.536
He wanted to come on stage and do this.

790
00:40:34.556 --> 00:40:37.418
He says that this was a big part of why he's done this.

791
00:40:37.879 --> 00:40:39.940
He has preloaded visuals ready.

792
00:40:40.081 --> 00:40:40.321
Yes.

793
00:40:40.701 --> 00:40:42.102
I don't understand the shock and horror now.

794
00:40:42.122 --> 00:40:44.463
Like, did Ed not know that that was part of his set?

795
00:40:44.663 --> 00:40:50.045
Like, did the entire team of people that organized this, no one thought to piece together this could be an outcome?

796
00:40:50.145 --> 00:40:50.726
Oh, completely.

797
00:40:50.766 --> 00:40:51.686
It's so weird to me.

798
00:40:52.206 --> 00:41:06.753
Then, as I was reading the BBC, after the performance, a campaign group called Stop Antisemitism came after him, saying that Jewish fans bought tickets to see Ed Sheeran sing and not to be ambushed by Michael Moore's anti-Israel propaganda.

799
00:41:06.953 --> 00:41:07.093
Mm-hmm.

800
00:41:08.107 --> 00:41:20.572
So then, the following night, Malcolm Moore returned to stage and said, To all of my Jewish brothers and sisters, criticism of Israel, criticism of apartheid, being against genocide is in no way a criticism of you.

801
00:41:20.853 --> 00:41:24.874
To be clear, anti-Semitism is a real and horrific problem.

802
00:41:24.974 --> 00:41:25.194
Yeah.

803
00:41:25.354 --> 00:41:30.637
To equate speaking up about the human rights of one group of people with,

804
00:41:31.417 --> 00:41:35.679
as saying, well, that, you know, is being against the human rights of some other group.

805
00:41:36.140 --> 00:41:37.160
It doesn't, I think...

806
00:41:37.520 --> 00:41:39.541
It's really dangerous to conflate the two.

807
00:41:39.581 --> 00:41:42.483
Yeah, that's what's quite scary about this rhetoric.

808
00:41:42.503 --> 00:41:46.545
But this is what the rhetoric has been, which is really tough.

809
00:41:46.985 --> 00:41:50.387
Then, in the midst of all this, Pink enters the chat.

810
00:41:51.467 --> 00:41:53.288
shock twist to me, to be really honest.

811
00:41:53.348 --> 00:41:57.408
I've not been keeping up with the lives and political views of Pink, to be really frank.

812
00:41:57.428 --> 00:42:00.289
No, again, this story just ends up because I'm like, Pink?

813
00:42:00.649 --> 00:42:03.250
These artists were all in the same font before this, to me.

814
00:42:03.350 --> 00:42:04.490
Like, this is so weird.

815
00:42:04.810 --> 00:42:09.171
So Pink reshared the post-bi-stop antisemitism.

816
00:42:10.031 --> 00:42:13.432
Again, like, I was radicalized by Dear Mr. President as a child.

817
00:42:13.832 --> 00:42:17.172
She has lyrics like, how do you sleep while the rest of us cry?

818
00:42:17.432 --> 00:42:18.133
How do you dream when a

819
00:42:20.233 --> 00:42:20.573
Yes.

820
00:42:20.893 --> 00:42:28.037
Does she not know that there have been 20,000 Palestinian children that have been murdered and 44,000 more that have life-altering injuries?

821
00:42:28.837 --> 00:42:32.479
That creator, Matt XIV, who I love, he- On Instagram?

822
00:42:32.599 --> 00:42:32.839
Yes.

823
00:42:32.899 --> 00:42:33.099
Yes.

824
00:42:33.540 --> 00:42:35.520
Had a really great description for this.

825
00:42:35.801 --> 00:42:38.822
He said this is like a cognitive roadblock.

826
00:42:39.182 --> 00:42:40.483
It's like cognitive dissonance.

827
00:42:40.523 --> 00:42:46.566
Like it's like this inability, like if you can say I'm for mothers, I'm for children, I'm here to stop war, but you cannot see it in this instance.

828
00:42:46.626 --> 00:42:46.926
Yes.

829
00:42:47.346 --> 00:42:48.447
That is a cognitive roadblock.

830
00:42:48.467 --> 00:42:48.627
Mm-hmm.

831
00:42:49.307 --> 00:42:57.492
Anyway, after reposting that to her stories, she rightfully started to receive backlash and started losing followers, like a lot of followers.

832
00:42:57.672 --> 00:42:58.512
And so she crashed out.

833
00:42:59.193 --> 00:43:04.375
Again, I don't follow Pink, but I did see screenshots of what was on her story that day.

834
00:43:04.816 --> 00:43:10.659
And she just like manically started reposting a bunch of stuff like being liked by everyone is a clown's job.

835
00:43:10.839 --> 00:43:11.880
And what do you mean?

836
00:43:12.000 --> 00:43:13.340
Probably what I fucking said.

837
00:43:13.621 --> 00:43:17.163
And if my honesty offends you, imagine how much I can't stand your bullshit.

838
00:43:17.183 --> 00:43:17.303
Yeah.

839
00:43:18.123 --> 00:43:18.464
What?

840
00:43:19.545 --> 00:43:20.305
And it just kept going.

841
00:43:20.325 --> 00:43:21.346
Like, that's just a few of them.

842
00:43:22.067 --> 00:43:23.589
Then she posted an apology.

843
00:43:24.089 --> 00:43:30.596
Pink then goes on and says, what I need to be able to say as a Jewish mom is that scared me and it scared the people that I love.

844
00:43:31.156 --> 00:43:31.917
I don't understand.

845
00:43:31.937 --> 00:43:39.765
Like, if you listen to all of Macklemore's message on stage of him just being like preaching love, I don't understand how you listen to that and said, I'm scared.

846
00:43:40.083 --> 00:43:50.548
Well, I think something that I find hard about these statements is that they're just bringing in a whole lot of information into one place.

847
00:43:50.888 --> 00:43:55.590
It feels like when you have an argument with someone and you just start bringing things up.

848
00:43:55.770 --> 00:43:55.990
Yeah.

849
00:43:56.170 --> 00:43:56.270
Yeah.

850
00:43:56.290 --> 00:44:01.692
And it's just like, it's really difficult to actually have a dialogue or an actual conversation at that point.

851
00:44:01.893 --> 00:44:02.873
I 100% agree.

852
00:44:03.553 --> 00:44:06.755
Then billionaire stadium owner Robert Kraft

853
00:44:08.020 --> 00:44:18.368
started mounting pressure through a campaign that eventually then made the decision to cancel Macklemore and said that his advocacy should not come at the expense of the Jewish community.

854
00:44:19.009 --> 00:44:21.591
Macklemore then posted on his Instagram about the ordeal.

855
00:44:21.931 --> 00:44:23.392
But a little snippet of this, he said,

856
00:44:25.554 --> 00:44:28.677
that Kraft said I would not be allowed to perform in his stadium.

857
00:44:29.037 --> 00:44:35.202
Ed also told me that Kraft had rallied some of the other stadium owners and collectively they gave him an ultimatum.

858
00:44:35.643 --> 00:44:39.446
If Macklemore stays on the tour, you will not be allowed to play in our venues.

859
00:44:39.976 --> 00:44:46.500
So the billionaire stadium owner goes to Ed, you can't perform in my stadiums if Macklemore is opening for you.

860
00:44:46.941 --> 00:44:48.342
So Macklemore's off the tour.

861
00:44:48.542 --> 00:44:48.702
Yeah.

862
00:44:49.122 --> 00:44:57.948
Which I find, well, I'm sorry, but I also just find that really insane considering these are the same venues that allowed a Kanye West concert.

863
00:44:59.129 --> 00:45:03.252
The same venues that allowed Kanye to perform, who literally has a song called Hail Hitler.

864
00:45:03.832 --> 00:45:04.012
Yep.

865
00:45:04.532 --> 00:45:04.733
What?

866
00:45:04.753 --> 00:45:04.953
Yeah.

867
00:45:05.558 --> 00:45:05.738
Yep.

868
00:45:05.938 --> 00:45:07.299
I don't have any other response.

869
00:45:07.620 --> 00:45:11.063
So why are people so mad at Ed?

870
00:45:11.303 --> 00:45:13.585
Because that's really the conversation online right now.

871
00:45:13.605 --> 00:45:16.287
And I think the question is just like, well, why would he accept that, you know?

872
00:45:17.248 --> 00:45:19.850
Why would Ed allow Malcolm Wall to be kicked off the tour?

873
00:45:19.990 --> 00:45:20.711
Why would he allow that?

874
00:45:20.731 --> 00:45:23.012
Or why wouldn't he stand down with him if that's the case?

875
00:45:23.653 --> 00:45:28.057
I get that it was the powers that be that made the decision and not Ed personally.

876
00:45:28.077 --> 00:45:28.177
Yeah.

877
00:45:28.717 --> 00:45:30.460
But he could have said no.

878
00:45:30.901 --> 00:45:32.744
Yes, it would have cost him commercially.

879
00:45:33.265 --> 00:45:36.371
But he, Ed Sheeran is worth $400 million already.

880
00:45:36.992 --> 00:45:38.194
Like, he has F you money.

881
00:45:39.356 --> 00:45:43.721
Why don't we F you someone?

882
00:45:44.081 --> 00:45:45.202
He could have stood on business.

883
00:45:45.403 --> 00:45:46.644
He could have refunded those tickets.

884
00:45:46.664 --> 00:45:48.025
He still could have paid his crew.

885
00:45:48.045 --> 00:45:58.336
It could have been an opportunity to stand with not only his friend, but with Palestinian children and say no to the powers that be and say that you do not get to control us.

886
00:45:58.997 --> 00:46:17.026
like that yeah and instead he's played it commercially safe but ironically i think it is costing him way more now he also seems very selectively apolitical like when i looked into it i was like you've stopped ukraine oh yes he's been like a vocal supporter of ukraine and it's war against russia

887
00:46:17.486 --> 00:46:21.811
But then he had a big response this morning that was pretty fascinating.

888
00:46:22.151 --> 00:46:24.954
Those who come to my shows do not expect a political forum.

889
00:46:25.215 --> 00:46:28.959
I respect Macklemore's strength of purpose to stand up and shout for what he believes.

890
00:46:29.239 --> 00:46:32.543
However, there is room for multiple approaches to the same end piece.

891
00:46:32.983 --> 00:46:35.686
He also does call it a conflict as well.

892
00:46:35.866 --> 00:46:39.030
Like when explaining the conflict between Israel and Palestine.

893
00:46:39.488 --> 00:46:40.729
And that isn't the end of the story.

894
00:46:41.109 --> 00:46:43.131
Things like rapidly start progressing from there.

895
00:46:43.311 --> 00:46:53.058
So then Phineas, who was also supposed to be an opener for Ed Sheeran, drops out in solidarity with Malcolm Moore and said artists must not be allowed to be silenced when they speak up for the oppressed.

896
00:46:53.399 --> 00:47:00.324
So then Lucas Graham, Aaron Rowe and Ed Sheeran's own band then also pulled out in solidarity with Malcolm Moore.

897
00:47:00.804 --> 00:47:08.146
I think that Macklemore had it right and made a really good point in his statement when he said that he's not a victim in this situation.

898
00:47:08.366 --> 00:47:09.446
Neither is Ed Sheeran.

899
00:47:09.966 --> 00:47:17.928
At the end of the day, the people who are victims in this situation are not wealthy celebrities who are opening stadium tours or performing, you know, in huge venues for millions of dollars.

900
00:47:18.388 --> 00:47:22.589
It's people who are literally losing their lives and their families in war.

901
00:47:23.469 --> 00:47:27.910
And so, I don't know, don't walk away feeling too sorry for anyone of these celebrities here.

902
00:47:30.355 --> 00:47:31.136
Wake up, sweetie.

903
00:47:31.216 --> 00:47:37.242
Sydney Sweeney has a brand new viral rage bait ad, and this time it's for a sports gambling company.

904
00:47:37.262 --> 00:47:38.263
Yay!

905
00:47:39.495 --> 00:47:40.136
Who was it?

906
00:47:40.276 --> 00:47:44.239
There was a thing I saw this morning that was like, he's calling her Sweeney Pie.

907
00:47:44.359 --> 00:47:48.222
So it's like, sweetie pie, we can't be doing that.

908
00:47:49.643 --> 00:47:51.405
This, I'm so annoyed that we have to talk about this.

909
00:47:51.665 --> 00:47:53.086
No, I love that we're talking about this.

910
00:47:53.386 --> 00:47:58.871
There's been a viral commercial for Novig, which has been viewed more than 22 million times.

911
00:47:59.931 --> 00:48:01.493
And that was just in the first two days of its release.

912
00:48:01.713 --> 00:48:02.854
But what is Novig quickly?

913
00:48:03.225 --> 00:48:05.567
Novik is a sports betting company.

914
00:48:05.988 --> 00:48:13.915
In this ad, Sydney's nude body is covered by footballs and basketballs and just like numerous other sporting equipment.

915
00:48:14.135 --> 00:48:14.375
Yes.

916
00:48:14.735 --> 00:48:22.562
Basically, the premise is that Sydney is playing or pretending to play a bunch of different sports while wearing very little clothing.

917
00:48:22.582 --> 00:48:23.423
She's like naked.

918
00:48:23.443 --> 00:48:23.543
Yeah.

919
00:48:23.663 --> 00:48:25.964
Yeah, though, it's like, it's really hard to describe.

920
00:48:26.244 --> 00:48:32.006
At one point, she sort of perched topless on top of a basketball hoop, which is one that she looks particularly naked.

921
00:48:32.566 --> 00:48:35.608
And she says like that they just want to show just sports.

922
00:48:35.928 --> 00:48:38.569
She actually says sports nine times in this ad.

923
00:48:38.769 --> 00:48:40.890
She also says things like, you can't trade this.

924
00:48:41.110 --> 00:48:42.030
I just look good here.

925
00:48:42.430 --> 00:48:48.052
Yeah, I guess the point of the ad then is to be like, this is a sports betting app.

926
00:48:48.392 --> 00:48:49.253
It's just sports.

927
00:48:49.833 --> 00:48:50.033
Yes.

928
00:48:50.913 --> 00:49:01.596
Frankly, I think that sports betting is bad enough in itself without us having to do another round of like, what do we think Sydney Sweeney was thinking here?

929
00:49:01.636 --> 00:49:04.176
And like, let's try and psychoanalyze what the point of this was.

930
00:49:04.196 --> 00:49:05.537
Like, why would she do this?

931
00:49:06.617 --> 00:49:12.398
And when I actually, when I first saw this ad and I hadn't heard anyone else commentate on it yet, like I hadn't seen any traction.

932
00:49:12.838 --> 00:49:14.219
A, I didn't really flinch when I saw it.

933
00:49:14.259 --> 00:49:14.779
But then B,

934
00:49:20.180 --> 00:49:23.762
we do not react to this because it is so obviously rage bait.

935
00:49:24.223 --> 00:49:27.304
And because maybe then if we don't react, the bit will be over.

936
00:49:27.464 --> 00:49:29.365
Like it's like the gimmick will be up kind of thing.

937
00:49:29.626 --> 00:49:30.786
Poor sweet Sarah.

938
00:49:31.447 --> 00:49:42.393
Because I just think like when we're talking about Sydney Sweeney, and I know I've already said this on the podcast, but like I just I do I do get it because I find the trajectory of her career so fascinating to me.

939
00:49:42.433 --> 00:49:44.814
Like, is she completely conscious of what she's doing?

940
00:49:44.854 --> 00:49:46.255
Like we used to genuinely debate that.

941
00:49:46.835 --> 00:49:56.238
and like, why does someone who's in such an incredible position in her career and getting genuinely great roles keep choosing this particular direction?

942
00:49:56.318 --> 00:49:59.339
And like, she also surely doesn't need the money, you know?

943
00:49:59.379 --> 00:50:01.720
Like, she has spoken about how she needs the money though.

944
00:50:02.280 --> 00:50:02.540
What?

945
00:50:02.961 --> 00:50:03.421
Has she?

946
00:50:03.461 --> 00:50:03.761
Yes.

947
00:50:03.982 --> 00:50:04.262
No.

948
00:50:04.282 --> 00:50:04.502
Okay.

949
00:50:04.522 --> 00:50:15.912
So back in 2022, she did an interview with The Hollywood Reporter where she said that she couldn't afford to take a six month break from acting and she relies on brand deals to essentially sustain her life.

950
00:50:16.132 --> 00:50:16.292
2022.

951
00:50:16.732 --> 00:50:16.893
Yeah.

952
00:50:16.913 --> 00:50:17.954
Look, it's been four years.

953
00:50:18.014 --> 00:50:18.734
It's been four years.

954
00:50:18.774 --> 00:50:20.175
And think of everything she's done since that.

955
00:50:20.636 --> 00:50:23.899
2022 would have been like, if I'm not wrong, like kind of start of Euphoria.

956
00:50:23.919 --> 00:50:24.119
Yeah.

957
00:50:24.783 --> 00:50:27.204
No, Euphoria was already going by then.

958
00:50:27.284 --> 00:50:27.484
Maybe.

959
00:50:27.504 --> 00:50:30.385
But look, her situation has definitely changed since then.

960
00:50:30.565 --> 00:50:33.207
But whenever I see her doing ads and I'm like, why is she doing that?

961
00:50:33.247 --> 00:50:35.988
I always think of all the movies she's done since.

962
00:50:36.088 --> 00:50:37.989
Plus the like American Eagle ad.

963
00:50:38.049 --> 00:50:39.669
The like, the soap.

964
00:50:39.689 --> 00:50:42.611
Like she, I don't think she needs that bag that badly.

965
00:50:42.771 --> 00:50:44.531
Or she's really bad with her money.

966
00:50:45.212 --> 00:50:48.213
But like, I'd love to know the extent of Scooter Braun's encouragement.

967
00:50:48.453 --> 00:50:48.853
of this?

968
00:50:48.913 --> 00:50:51.976
Not that that really matters, but like obviously he'd be in these conversations.

969
00:50:52.356 --> 00:50:55.478
Like these are all questions I will continue to not really have answers for.

970
00:50:56.078 --> 00:50:58.680
Actually, that's not entirely true on that money thing as well.

971
00:50:59.161 --> 00:51:01.342
She's actually an investor of this godawful company.

972
00:51:01.622 --> 00:51:10.629
So the co-founder of Novig posted on LinkedIn, Sydney first came to us as an investor with an interest in prediction markets.

973
00:51:11.209 --> 00:51:18.132
She's now also a strategic partner who helped shape the creative and served as the face of our first major brand campaign.

974
00:51:18.392 --> 00:51:20.793
So they're saying it's not like she stumbled across a gambling ad.

975
00:51:20.813 --> 00:51:26.096
She sought out the gambling industry, became a partner and then helped plan the creative.

976
00:51:26.536 --> 00:51:35.340
In saying all of that, if a Sydney Sweeney ad was to get a huge reaction, I am so glad that it's the reaction that we've seen.

977
00:51:36.180 --> 00:51:47.511
because female athletes around the world have collectively seen this ad and gone, okay, if you want to use women in a sporting context to get attention, let's talk about women in sports.

978
00:51:47.731 --> 00:51:49.393
Let's actually talk about women in sports then.

979
00:51:50.114 --> 00:51:52.796
There was an American gymnast, Gracie Kramer.

980
00:51:52.916 --> 00:51:54.618
She was one of the first athletes to respond.

981
00:51:54.658 --> 00:51:56.260
She's one that I saw early on.

982
00:51:56.600 --> 00:51:58.802
She posted a reel of herself actually competing and

983
00:51:59.863 --> 00:52:08.308
looking incredible with the words, I don't know what Sydney Sweeney was doing, but this is what women in sport looks like, and then captioned it because it really is that deep.

984
00:52:08.909 --> 00:52:13.451
Arianne Tipmus is another one who has been furious about this ad.

985
00:52:13.812 --> 00:52:18.775
She called it an absolute joke and said that I can't describe how infuriated I feel when I watch this.

986
00:52:19.775 --> 00:52:23.417
You know, people have been saying this is a kick in the face to women who have dedicated their lives to sport.

987
00:52:23.677 --> 00:52:26.558
Swimmer Lani Pallister said she had no words.

988
00:52:26.998 --> 00:52:28.679
It just went on and on and on and on.

989
00:52:28.699 --> 00:52:34.781
Like every feels like every athlete, every female, every female athlete was making these videos, but they were so fun to watch.

990
00:52:34.801 --> 00:52:37.082
Like I loved watching all of them.

991
00:52:37.282 --> 00:52:38.602
I was like, wow, that's so impressive.

992
00:52:38.622 --> 00:52:39.543
Everything that they're doing.

993
00:52:40.103 --> 00:52:50.111
But again, at the same time, I'm just like, damn, this rage bait advertising only works if we all get angry and repost and debate it and turn it into international headlines.

994
00:52:50.371 --> 00:52:50.571
Yeah.

995
00:52:50.832 --> 00:52:53.374
I think it's annoying that that's worked again for Sydney.

996
00:52:53.714 --> 00:52:55.635
But at the same time, I completely get it.

997
00:52:55.655 --> 00:53:02.961
And I've loved and watched every single one of these videos that have been put out by these female athletes because I'm like, yeah, they don't have to be the bigger person here.

998
00:53:03.362 --> 00:53:04.122
Yeah.

999
00:53:04.142 --> 00:53:07.325
I have complicated thoughts on this, to be really honest.

1000
00:53:07.645 --> 00:53:08.306
To be clear...

1001
00:53:09.168 --> 00:53:10.669
I totally get the outrage.

1002
00:53:11.349 --> 00:53:12.690
I would also be outraged.

1003
00:53:13.090 --> 00:53:26.416
If someone was trying to sell something and decided to put a naked woman pretending to be like a journalist or an investigative journalist or working in an office or something like that as the bait for that ad, I would be so mad.

1004
00:53:26.616 --> 00:53:30.517
Also just annoying that it proves that not only does rage bait work, but sex sells.

1005
00:53:31.138 --> 00:53:31.598
Totally.

1006
00:53:31.998 --> 00:53:38.681
I guess I'm just like, aren't we doing exactly what the ad and the betting company want us to do?

1007
00:53:38.801 --> 00:53:39.381
No, totally.

1008
00:53:39.421 --> 00:53:41.122
Which is, which is goes to your point.

1009
00:53:41.183 --> 00:53:41.423
Yeah.

1010
00:53:41.703 --> 00:53:44.705
But I also get that like, I wouldn't let that slide either.

1011
00:53:45.245 --> 00:53:47.466
You actually annoyed me so much as well.

1012
00:53:47.847 --> 00:53:56.292
Was Sydney then seemingly responded to the criticism by posting a bunch of old images on her story from ESPN's famous body issue?

1013
00:53:57.572 --> 00:54:01.695
which was a series that would photograph these elite athletes nude.

1014
00:54:02.155 --> 00:54:12.281
The point of the ESPN body issue was to speak to the fact that these athletes' bodies were their instruments and that they were like elite performers and like this was their tool, right?

1015
00:54:12.581 --> 00:54:15.343
The entire point was like, look at what our bodies can do.

1016
00:54:15.423 --> 00:54:15.643
Yeah.

1017
00:54:16.103 --> 00:54:19.566
That does not equate to what Sydney Sweeney has just done here.

1018
00:54:19.666 --> 00:54:20.246
It's so weird.

1019
00:54:20.266 --> 00:54:27.011
Like the ad repeatedly makes Sydney Sweeney look like she's clearly not there to play any of the sports properly.

1020
00:54:27.051 --> 00:54:31.334
She's just that it'll look good, which is not the same thing as the ESPN issue.

1021
00:54:31.575 --> 00:54:32.415
She's also not an athlete.

1022
00:54:32.735 --> 00:54:38.620
It also, I think, really leans into this idea of women being kind of like a bit dumb.

1023
00:54:38.980 --> 00:54:40.221
You know, like it's just sport.

1024
00:54:40.681 --> 00:54:44.423
It really does kind of play into a stereotype that is degrading and demeaning.

1025
00:54:44.703 --> 00:54:45.544
But it's interesting.

1026
00:54:45.784 --> 00:54:51.627
I've been really trying to like sit on this in myself and figure out why do I have so much disappointment in this ad?

1027
00:54:51.908 --> 00:54:55.990
Because on the other hand, I think a lot of us support women in being able to...

1028
00:54:56.150 --> 00:54:59.331
to model nude, to profit and monetize their bodies.

1029
00:54:59.351 --> 00:55:02.472
Like a lot of people in progressive spaces, I think, also would share those views.

1030
00:55:02.972 --> 00:55:18.098
And so I personally have been trying to interrogate within myself, what is it about this ad that distinguishes it for me from other advertisements or instances where women are monetizing, profiting off, using their bodies to sell something?

1031
00:55:18.738 --> 00:55:23.222
And that's kind of like a tension that, and I don't necessarily have an answer for that at this moment.

1032
00:55:23.722 --> 00:55:24.563
I think I do.

1033
00:55:24.703 --> 00:55:25.063
Tell me.

1034
00:55:25.083 --> 00:55:27.285
I just think it's about motive.

1035
00:55:27.826 --> 00:55:28.166
Yes.

1036
00:55:28.406 --> 00:55:29.207
Is it the sport?

1037
00:55:29.307 --> 00:55:31.168
Is it the factors for a betting company?

1038
00:55:31.249 --> 00:55:31.529
Yes.

1039
00:55:31.729 --> 00:55:37.514
And the fact that given the track history with Sydney Sweeney, she knew exactly what this would do and exactly what this would play into.

1040
00:55:37.654 --> 00:55:37.874
Yes.

1041
00:55:38.435 --> 00:55:46.942
And it sounds like it's also kind of like the assumed, fairly assumed intentionality behind the ad, which is like, we want to enrage people.

1042
00:55:46.962 --> 00:55:47.102
Mm-hmm.

1043
00:55:47.542 --> 00:55:50.547
I'm all for like having that conversation.

1044
00:55:50.567 --> 00:55:53.030
And we've had that different times on the podcast.

1045
00:55:53.050 --> 00:55:56.656
Like Sabrina Carpenter's album was a good example of that.

1046
00:55:56.736 --> 00:55:59.600
The first time something happened with Sydney, we gave space to that.

1047
00:55:59.800 --> 00:56:00.041
Yes.

1048
00:56:00.121 --> 00:56:02.124
I think this is too far gone past that.

1049
00:56:02.384 --> 00:56:02.864
I agree.

1050
00:56:03.105 --> 00:56:08.750
But I think it's important in these situations to be interrogating in yourself what draws the line for you.

1051
00:56:09.150 --> 00:56:10.471
But also, this is punching down.

1052
00:56:11.012 --> 00:56:15.376
It's not her just emboldening herself and like, here's my body as an athlete.

1053
00:56:15.676 --> 00:56:17.638
She knew exactly who this would be punching down on.

1054
00:56:17.858 --> 00:56:19.099
Yes, completely.

1055
00:56:19.419 --> 00:56:24.423
And also the fact that it is for a gambling company, which we know is

1056
00:56:25.164 --> 00:56:33.898
on another layer here, like, preys upon people who have addiction issues, preys upon financial insecurity, creates financial insecurity.

1057
00:56:33.918 --> 00:56:37.543
Like, the whole thing is just layers upon layers of work.

1058
00:56:40.103 --> 00:56:42.566
Okay, we are now at the Q&amp;A for this week.

1059
00:56:42.866 --> 00:56:51.037
And we have a bit of an interesting Q&amp;A because it's more just a bunch of messages that we've been sent in reels off the back of the Emmys that just happened.

1060
00:56:51.357 --> 00:56:52.118
All the Emmys.

1061
00:56:52.238 --> 00:56:52.518
I know.

1062
00:56:52.558 --> 00:56:58.866
And people, I mean, we didn't make it a story this week because there was just so much going on, but there was pretty much people just asking what we liked and didn't like.

1063
00:57:00.127 --> 00:57:02.169
Sarah, what did you like and not like?

1064
00:57:02.689 --> 00:57:03.830
I loved Meg Salter.

1065
00:57:04.491 --> 00:57:05.852
Yes, dressed as an Emmy.

1066
00:57:06.052 --> 00:57:07.253
Dressed as an Emmy.

1067
00:57:07.293 --> 00:57:08.854
Meg Salter I've spoken about before.

1068
00:57:08.894 --> 00:57:09.895
She's so funny.

1069
00:57:10.616 --> 00:57:13.998
She was also the star of Lena Dunham's Netflix series as well.

1070
00:57:15.139 --> 00:57:16.681
I just think she's one to watch.

1071
00:57:16.921 --> 00:57:23.046
I think she's just really like such satire, such performance, such high status humor.

1072
00:57:23.166 --> 00:57:25.848
I saw her doing an interview on the red carpet and she was like, I just had this at home.

1073
00:57:26.108 --> 00:57:27.129
They're like, what was the inspiration by the look?

1074
00:57:27.149 --> 00:57:27.810
She's like, I just found it.

1075
00:57:27.830 --> 00:57:28.590
I pulled this off the rack.

1076
00:57:28.610 --> 00:57:28.911
Yeah.

1077
00:57:29.171 --> 00:57:30.172
It's so funny.

1078
00:57:30.272 --> 00:57:31.433
She's fully dressed as an Emmy.

1079
00:57:31.473 --> 00:57:32.854
If anyone hasn't seen it, go look it up.

1080
00:57:32.874 --> 00:57:34.275
It's so, like, fully spray painted gold.

1081
00:57:34.295 --> 00:57:35.096
Cosplaying as an Emmy.

1082
00:57:35.116 --> 00:57:39.960
And her in the background of all the videos of the actual broadcast is so funny.

1083
00:57:40.341 --> 00:57:44.905
Taylor Swift didn't go, but she was in a scene.

1084
00:57:45.245 --> 00:57:46.186
Yes, a pre-record.

1085
00:57:46.286 --> 00:57:50.490
Pre-recorded with Mariska, who is the star of Lauren or SVU.

1086
00:57:50.650 --> 00:57:52.491
SVU, which is one of the best shows of all time.

1087
00:57:52.551 --> 00:57:55.814
One of her favourite shows, Her Cat, famously named after Olivia Benson.

1088
00:57:55.874 --> 00:57:56.174
Yes.

1089
00:57:56.574 --> 00:58:02.558
And they did a scene with the cast and Taylor where they're sort of trying to figure out whether Taylor would go to the Emmys.

1090
00:58:02.598 --> 00:58:08.002
But it's clearly a lot of drops about, I believe, TV, Taylor's version, next albums.

1091
00:58:08.382 --> 00:58:09.563
I've seen so many...

1092
00:58:09.783 --> 00:58:31.949
theories online she like said this string of words to the camera remember the words but yeah it was ridiculous and there's like all these theories like are they is it like do you take like the first letter of each one and it spells out a sentence or do the words other words code for something i know i heard one theory that she is going to be on snl on the 3rd of october with dakota johnson and she'll be like singing a song there potentially called sugar

1093
00:58:32.409 --> 00:58:33.730
I don't know how you found that.

1094
00:58:33.770 --> 00:58:34.130
That's hilarious.

1095
00:58:34.150 --> 00:58:35.391
Go look at the theories.

1096
00:58:35.711 --> 00:58:39.694
It's so funny that the whole skit was making fun of this exact behaviour.

1097
00:58:39.814 --> 00:58:41.516
No, but it was also encouraging it.

1098
00:58:41.576 --> 00:58:42.617
Encouraging it.

1099
00:58:42.737 --> 00:58:43.517
100%.

1100
00:58:43.637 --> 00:58:46.279
But yeah, that was my top moments.

1101
00:58:46.299 --> 00:58:50.482
I personally loved Matthew Rhys' historic win.

1102
00:58:50.783 --> 00:58:52.864
Matthew Rhys is the star of Widow's Bay.

1103
00:58:53.885 --> 00:58:55.046
Also iconic...

1104
00:58:55.666 --> 00:59:00.269
gay character in Brothers and Sisters, the old drama that I used to watch growing up.

1105
00:59:00.610 --> 00:59:13.919
So he won Best Actor for a comedy for Widow's Bay, also won Best Leading Actor for the limited series, The Beast and Me, like first time that anyone's won Best Actor in two different shows and two categories on the same night.

1106
00:59:14.259 --> 00:59:23.125
But also in that same breath, I want to acknowledge that I think this was one of the first Emmys, if not the first Emmy, where we didn't see any actors of colour win a major award.

1107
00:59:24.166 --> 00:59:25.287
Yeah, I did see that.

1108
00:59:25.427 --> 00:59:31.971
Which is kind of unsurprising in the sense that this is definitely a criticism and a recurring theme that we've seen across award shows.

1109
00:59:32.352 --> 00:59:37.735
But as somebody who's a huge fan of Paradise and a big fan of Sterling K. Brown, a bit annoyed.

1110
00:59:38.156 --> 00:59:38.336
Fair.

1111
00:59:40.740 --> 00:59:42.861
Thank you so much for listening this week.

1112
00:59:43.001 --> 00:59:54.144
If you wanted to leave a comment, tap the bell, leave a review, get over on our Instagram, which is bigsmalltalk underscore pod and give it a follow or message in the broadcast channel, the besties chat.

1113
00:59:54.424 --> 00:59:57.305
We'd love to see you there and we will see you next Tuesday.

1114
00:59:57.665 --> 00:59:57.985
Bye.
