WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.131 --> 00:00:08.194
So imagine you've spent about 50 years arguing as a scientific community about whether a legendary material exists.

2
00:00:08.494 --> 00:00:12.176
And then finally, someone has made it and they're holding it in their hand.

3
00:00:12.296 --> 00:00:14.757
We're talking about a material that in theory

4
00:00:15.497 --> 00:00:19.799
is harder than the hardest known material, which is conventional diamond.

5
00:00:19.859 --> 00:00:21.719
This is... Like, this is some beef, dude.

6
00:00:21.739 --> 00:00:24.400
Yeah, this is what beef looks like in the research committee.

7
00:00:24.520 --> 00:00:25.961
Clearly there's something, right?

8
00:00:26.561 --> 00:00:27.261
Hello, Internet.

9
00:00:27.281 --> 00:00:34.804
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

10
00:00:35.484 --> 00:00:45.709
Today we're going to be diving into a paper that is actually a follow-up to our episode 5 story on unbreakable hexagonal diamonds.

11
00:00:45.789 --> 00:00:55.334
This paper was published in Nature on March 4th of 2026 from three Chinese teams from Zhengzhou, Nanjing, and Henan universities.

12
00:00:55.895 --> 00:01:03.959
As always, we're going to learn about the science from the ground up today on this follow-up episode because this is From First Principles.

13
00:01:19.882 --> 00:01:27.931
So imagine you've spent about 50 years arguing as a scientific community about whether a legendary material exists.

14
00:01:28.211 --> 00:01:33.516
And then finally someone has made it and they're holding it in their hand and you can see it with the naked eye.

15
00:01:33.717 --> 00:01:39.042
And that's roughly the situation when it comes to hexagonal diamond or lawns delight.

16
00:01:39.102 --> 00:01:41.425
It's a form of carbon that was first proposed in the 1960s.

17
00:01:43.006 --> 00:01:48.813
And material scientists have been seeking this holy grail ever since.

18
00:01:49.334 --> 00:01:49.594
Okay?

19
00:01:49.835 --> 00:01:52.718
There's been debate about whether it even exists in the first place.

20
00:01:53.039 --> 00:01:53.239
Okay.

21
00:01:53.439 --> 00:01:53.679
Okay?

22
00:01:54.420 --> 00:01:56.783
There's a new paper that's saying that they've actually made it.

23
00:01:57.164 --> 00:02:01.148
And the stakes are quite enormous because we're talking about a material that, in theory...

24
00:02:01.809 --> 00:02:05.852
is harder than the hardest known material, which is conventional diamond.

25
00:02:05.932 --> 00:02:11.517
This is an upgrade on diamonds that we normally have on our ring finger and things like that.

26
00:02:11.877 --> 00:02:18.302
The current benchmark for the hardest material is a conventional diamond, and here we've gone a step further.

27
00:02:18.642 --> 00:02:24.647
So it's a very big deal because in industry, diamonds are applied all over the place, okay?

28
00:02:24.687 --> 00:02:25.748
It's not just used as

29
00:02:27.709 --> 00:02:40.290
the reason why a diamond is so expensive is because the jewelers are artificially crunching the supply while the demand is really high because of all of Hollywood and pop culture and things like that.

30
00:02:40.590 --> 00:02:41.872
But diamond in its...

31
00:02:43.275 --> 00:02:47.637
Core is really effective in all sorts of industry.

32
00:02:47.737 --> 00:02:51.459
For example, diamond-tipped drill bits.

33
00:02:52.059 --> 00:02:57.382
They can board through rock for any type of stuff, oil exploration, mining, anything.

34
00:02:57.802 --> 00:02:59.023
Diamond-coated cutting tools.

35
00:02:59.603 --> 00:03:01.965
They can machine aerospace-grade titanium.

36
00:03:02.025 --> 00:03:06.809
Titanium is a hard metal, but if you've got a diamond-coated saw, you can cut through titanium.

37
00:03:07.169 --> 00:03:10.372
Diamond windows, they protect infrared sensors and military systems.

38
00:03:10.772 --> 00:03:14.816
And the other cool one that I hadn't really thought about was diamond heat sinks.

39
00:03:15.676 --> 00:03:16.517
Oh, interesting.

40
00:03:17.057 --> 00:03:27.465
Diamond is a really good insulator, and it's also a really good heat sink in the means that it can extract heat out of its environment and dump it to something else.

41
00:03:27.945 --> 00:03:36.672
And those are being explored for next-generation computer chips because silicon is sort of meeting its thermal limit when it comes to heat dissipation.

42
00:03:37.032 --> 00:03:41.716
This is why everyone is saying that the data centers up in space won't work.

43
00:03:41.916 --> 00:03:42.156
Right.

44
00:03:45.118 --> 00:03:46.579
dissipating heat.

45
00:03:46.819 --> 00:03:49.220
We have to have giant cooling systems in order to do that.

46
00:03:49.280 --> 00:04:00.284
Well, if you have a chip that has integrated silicon and diamond to manage that heat dissipation, you could now push even further on how big you can make a server rack and things like that.

47
00:04:00.544 --> 00:04:02.905
And so we desperately need these types of materials.

48
00:04:03.345 --> 00:04:04.505
Diamond is one of these things.

49
00:04:04.605 --> 00:04:10.708
And imagine now you can make an upgraded diamond that's going to upgrade all of these industrial applications, right?

50
00:04:11.488 --> 00:04:13.369
And the other reason why this matters

51
00:04:14.009 --> 00:04:33.261
this particular story, is because for the longest time, computational simulations, meaning I take the material, I take all of the atoms and the arrangements of that material, I put that into a computer, and I ask the computer to just churn Schrodinger's equations and what we know about physics and material physics.

52
00:04:34.882 --> 00:04:40.065
If we do that in computer simulation, those simulations suggest that this thing is real.

53
00:04:40.566 --> 00:04:40.726
Mm-hmm.

54
00:04:41.569 --> 00:04:45.435
But for the longest time, we don't have any material samples to analyze.

55
00:04:45.875 --> 00:04:46.316
And so...

56
00:04:47.213 --> 00:04:55.135
There's a fundamental problem now because our physics of what a material should look like is saying one thing, and we've never been able to do it.

57
00:04:55.595 --> 00:05:02.737
So it's almost like a bedrock foundational problem for the field that theoretically this thing should be possible.

58
00:05:03.097 --> 00:05:05.837
Why is it so hard and is it even possible?

59
00:05:05.897 --> 00:05:11.739
Because if it's truly not, then we have to go back to the drawing board on fundamental material science.

60
00:05:12.059 --> 00:05:16.980
And that is a very uncomfortable scenario for everyone in the field.

61
00:05:17.180 --> 00:05:17.360
Right.

62
00:05:17.600 --> 00:05:17.801
Right?

63
00:05:17.941 --> 00:05:18.161
Yes.

64
00:05:18.521 --> 00:05:29.350
And so the status now is we've got a team in China that's synthesized millimeter-sized, pure hexagonal diamond, and it's resolving this 50-year academic debate.

65
00:05:29.671 --> 00:05:31.912
This happened earlier as well in 2005.

66
00:05:32.173 --> 00:05:35.515
As you alluded to, we covered a story in... 2025.

67
00:05:35.535 --> 00:05:35.676
2025.

68
00:05:35.696 --> 00:05:35.956
Yeah, 2025.

69
00:05:35.976 --> 00:05:36.096
Sorry.

70
00:05:36.116 --> 00:05:37.057
We covered a story last year that...

71
00:05:41.040 --> 00:05:42.782
purportedly made hexagonal diamond.

72
00:05:43.062 --> 00:05:51.051
This is another research team in China that is doing the same thing, maybe a bit better, and we'll get into some of the drama there because there's a lot of drama and it's quite hilarious.

73
00:05:51.071 --> 00:05:52.593
We got the tea, everybody.

74
00:05:52.613 --> 00:05:56.557
Okay, so let's start from the basics.

75
00:05:56.737 --> 00:05:56.937
Yes.

76
00:05:57.898 --> 00:05:58.239
Carbon.

77
00:05:59.556 --> 00:06:02.057
Carbon is the sixth element on the periodic table.

78
00:06:02.117 --> 00:06:10.561
It has six protons in its nucleus, usually six neutrons, usually six neutrons in its nucleus, sometimes seven, sometimes eight.

79
00:06:11.281 --> 00:06:15.683
But six protons in the nucleus mean you've got six electrons revolving around the atom.

80
00:06:16.163 --> 00:06:20.465
Two are in the inner shell, but that means there's four that are left for that outer shell.

81
00:06:21.045 --> 00:06:24.747
And if there's four that are left for the outer shell, that means there's four holes that are left for the outer shell.

82
00:06:24.867 --> 00:06:28.634
There's four valence positions where other electrons can come in.

83
00:06:29.054 --> 00:06:35.225
That is the maximum because the total number that you can have in that outer shell on that second ring is eight.

84
00:06:35.866 --> 00:06:38.871
So if you have three, that means you can have like...

85
00:06:40.242 --> 00:06:40.962
Five holes.

86
00:06:41.082 --> 00:06:41.282
Yes.

87
00:06:41.502 --> 00:06:44.603
But with four, you can either give four or you can take four.

88
00:06:44.923 --> 00:06:47.604
So you can make the most bonds that way.

89
00:06:47.624 --> 00:06:47.784
Yes.

90
00:06:47.804 --> 00:06:47.984
Right?

91
00:06:48.104 --> 00:06:49.844
Oxygen can only really make two bonds.

92
00:06:50.944 --> 00:06:53.505
The other ones can only make whatever is less.

93
00:06:53.945 --> 00:06:57.086
But four is right in the middle where I can give four or I can take four.

94
00:06:57.326 --> 00:06:58.746
So I can make the most number of bonds.

95
00:06:58.766 --> 00:07:02.287
That's why it's so important in organic chemistry for life in general.

96
00:07:03.547 --> 00:07:06.549
The big thing is carbon is able to make bonds with itself.

97
00:07:07.130 --> 00:07:09.812
And sometimes it makes these things called allotropes.

98
00:07:10.192 --> 00:07:11.493
This is pure carbon.

99
00:07:11.813 --> 00:07:15.016
There is nothing other than carbon in these substances.

100
00:07:15.416 --> 00:07:17.137
For the longest time, we thought there were only two.

101
00:07:17.257 --> 00:07:19.059
Graphite, which is the pencil lead.

102
00:07:20.160 --> 00:07:22.081
That's pure carbon, nothing else.

103
00:07:22.561 --> 00:07:24.623
And then there is obviously diamond.

104
00:07:25.163 --> 00:07:26.384
Again, pure carbon.

105
00:07:27.465 --> 00:07:32.569
Now, how do we know what the structure of the carbon in these materials is?

106
00:07:34.087 --> 00:07:38.630
Well, usually what we do is we do something called X-ray crystallography.

107
00:07:38.670 --> 00:07:45.815
This was a technique pioneered by William Henry Bragg and his son, William Lawrence Bragg.

108
00:07:46.216 --> 00:07:48.397
We covered some of the drama there.

109
00:07:49.158 --> 00:07:55.602
The fact that William Lawrence Bragg, the son, did all of the math and did all of the actual groundwork.

110
00:07:56.203 --> 00:08:01.407
But William Henry Bragg, his father, published a paper about the technique and did not...

111
00:08:02.392 --> 00:08:03.633
put his son's name on it.

112
00:08:04.053 --> 00:08:11.077
And that was a sticking point for his son, Lawrence, who always wanted to be called by his middle name because that distinguished him from his father.

113
00:08:11.677 --> 00:08:18.781
William Lawrence Bragg and Henry Bragg, they both won the Nobel Prize in 1915, the only father-son duo to win the same Nobel Prize.

114
00:08:19.561 --> 00:08:23.463
And he was 25 at the time, the youngest Nobel Prize winner in the sciences, and he was 25 at the time.

115
00:08:23.523 --> 00:08:31.869
He went on to be the head of Cavendish Lab at Cambridge and managed the empire that was Cavendish Lab at Cambridge University.

116
00:08:31.909 --> 00:08:32.990
The idea is the following.

117
00:08:33.090 --> 00:08:34.791
You shoot X-rays at a crystal.

118
00:08:36.453 --> 00:08:44.018
The crystal is going to have a lattice structure, meaning all of the atoms are going to be arranged in a very nice, regular fashion.

119
00:08:44.599 --> 00:08:46.360
We'll see some of the fashions that they're arranged.

120
00:08:46.380 --> 00:08:49.102
But in any case, it's like Lego blocks that are repetitive.

121
00:08:53.205 --> 00:08:54.185
at certain angles.

122
00:08:54.305 --> 00:09:01.228
And if I have a detector on the end, I can find spots where the X-ray is added up and other spots where the X-ray is canceled out.

123
00:09:01.548 --> 00:09:06.509
And using that pattern, I can discern what is the structure of the crystal inside.

124
00:09:06.529 --> 00:09:07.290
Okay?

125
00:09:07.570 --> 00:09:09.830
That's the whole game with X-ray crystallography.

126
00:09:10.531 --> 00:09:16.192
As a crude analogy, it's almost like making hand puppets with a light source on a wall.

127
00:09:16.513 --> 00:09:19.874
And you're looking at the shadow to determine what is the actual figure.

128
00:09:20.214 --> 00:09:20.634
Exactly.

129
00:09:21.154 --> 00:09:22.815
Yeah, that's basically it.

130
00:09:22.875 --> 00:09:26.358
But in like all three dimensions with like frequency and everything.

131
00:09:26.559 --> 00:09:29.061
Extremely much more complex.

132
00:09:29.161 --> 00:09:29.401
Yeah.

133
00:09:29.461 --> 00:09:36.507
But at the end of the day, what you can do is through that, you can figure out what is the cubic – what is the structure of that crystal inside?

134
00:09:36.887 --> 00:09:40.010
And when we do this with diamond, we figure out that it's a cubic structure.

135
00:09:40.030 --> 00:09:40.390
Yeah.

136
00:09:40.510 --> 00:09:43.613
This is what diamond looks like at the atomic scale.

137
00:09:44.113 --> 00:09:53.080
Each of these blue orbs is a carbon atom, and each carbon atom is attached to four other carbon atoms in this tetrahedral structure.

138
00:09:53.521 --> 00:09:58.585
That orange tetrahedron, that is triangles on triangles.

139
00:09:58.625 --> 00:10:00.686
There's four triangles that are connected together.

140
00:10:01.087 --> 00:10:04.670
It's the first platonic solid that is on our logo right here.

141
00:10:06.138 --> 00:10:08.140
And it's a beautiful structure.

142
00:10:08.700 --> 00:10:12.623
The reason why it's called a cubic diamond is notice that the repetitive...

143
00:10:13.511 --> 00:10:16.794
fundamental unit of the crystal is in the shape of a cube.

144
00:10:16.934 --> 00:10:17.134
Yes.

145
00:10:17.234 --> 00:10:17.434
Right?

146
00:10:18.195 --> 00:10:24.420
If you imagine you can take that same cube, put one right next to it, put one right next to it, and stack, and you get bigger and bigger.

147
00:10:24.780 --> 00:10:30.065
And a diamond is going to have, you know, 10 to the 20 of these carbon atoms or something like that.

148
00:10:30.165 --> 00:10:30.985
An enormous amount.

149
00:10:31.005 --> 00:10:34.708
But at the fundamental scale, that is what the diamond looks like.

150
00:10:34.748 --> 00:10:42.635
The reason why it's so hard is each of those bonds are highly tight covalent bonds where the carbon atoms are sharing...

151
00:10:43.075 --> 00:10:44.836
an electron with the neighboring carbon atom.

152
00:10:44.857 --> 00:10:46.918
Remember I said carbons can do four bonds.

153
00:10:47.338 --> 00:10:49.260
All four bonds are other carbon atoms.

154
00:10:49.540 --> 00:10:52.643
This thing is extremely tightly packed.

155
00:10:53.583 --> 00:10:53.864
Okay?

156
00:10:54.664 --> 00:10:56.626
And it's single bonds that are going in.

157
00:10:56.686 --> 00:10:56.946
Okay?

158
00:10:57.306 --> 00:10:57.566
So...

159
00:10:58.367 --> 00:11:00.388
That's the fundamental unit of stacking.

160
00:11:00.648 --> 00:11:01.228
It's a cube.

161
00:11:01.588 --> 00:11:04.789
Hence, normal diamond is called a cubic diamond.

162
00:11:04.809 --> 00:11:05.310
Yeah, right.

163
00:11:05.330 --> 00:11:05.530
Okay?

164
00:11:06.110 --> 00:11:14.313
Now, in 1962, researchers predicted that there would be a possible hexagonal polymorph of the diamond.

165
00:11:14.773 --> 00:11:19.074
They went through the—this is, you know, 1960, so this is before computers and stuff.

166
00:11:19.434 --> 00:11:36.900
But you can literally sort of do the mathematics of Schrodinger's equation around a carbon atom, and you can make the argument that instead of this cubic structure, there could be a kind of hexagonal structure that is even more stable and even more hard.

167
00:11:36.920 --> 00:11:37.440
Okay?

168
00:11:37.460 --> 00:11:37.680
Okay.

169
00:11:38.909 --> 00:11:40.190
The question is, is that real?

170
00:11:40.570 --> 00:11:40.750
Right.

171
00:11:41.130 --> 00:11:43.812
So 1962, they published this paper in Nature.

172
00:11:44.653 --> 00:11:50.877
And in the 1967, they came up with the Canyon Diablo meteorite.

173
00:11:50.897 --> 00:11:51.837
There were people who were...

174
00:11:54.011 --> 00:11:57.373
analyzing a meteorite that fell in Arizona 50,000 years ago.

175
00:11:57.554 --> 00:12:05.619
If you've ever been to the Grand Canyon, the south side, there is a meteor crater right next to the Grand Canyon sort of exit on the 40 freeway.

176
00:12:05.800 --> 00:12:07.141
I was there when I was very young.

177
00:12:07.161 --> 00:12:13.725
It was one of the first sort of science field trips that my family took, and I got to see the meteor crater in Arizona.

178
00:12:14.046 --> 00:12:16.267
It is an awesome, awesome place.

179
00:12:16.888 --> 00:12:19.930
50 meters is about the size of the meteorite that hit the...

180
00:12:20.370 --> 00:12:25.979
Arizona and it has a bunch of shards that fell all over Arizona and that they've been recovered.

181
00:12:26.360 --> 00:12:26.600
Okay.

182
00:12:27.121 --> 00:12:31.368
Now this meteor hit Arizona extremely fast and,

183
00:12:32.874 --> 00:12:35.716
And meteors are made a lot out of carbon.

184
00:12:35.876 --> 00:12:37.398
There's a lot of carbon in meteors.

185
00:12:38.058 --> 00:12:47.806
When they hit the Earth at this incredible velocity with incredible pressure, there's incredible heat, perhaps the carbon is going to form a weird allotrope.

186
00:12:48.706 --> 00:12:54.711
And so in 1967, a paper came out again in Nature.

187
00:12:56.752 --> 00:12:59.755
Lonsdalite, a hexagonal polymorph of diamond.

188
00:13:00.195 --> 00:13:06.661
They're saying that they found that hexagonal polymorph that was suggested in theory five years ago.

189
00:13:07.161 --> 00:13:07.362
Right?

190
00:13:07.762 --> 00:13:09.083
They named it Lonsdalite.

191
00:13:09.463 --> 00:13:17.391
And just a brief sort of digression into why Lonsdalite, it's named after Dame Kathleen Lonsdale.

192
00:13:18.171 --> 00:13:23.276
She was a foundational x-ray crystallographer and prison reform advocate.

193
00:13:25.004 --> 00:13:26.164
Very, very cool person.

194
00:13:26.244 --> 00:13:26.864
Okay.

195
00:13:26.905 --> 00:13:29.005
She pioneered the use of extra crystallography.

196
00:13:29.025 --> 00:13:32.026
She actually did her PhD under William Henry Bragg, the dad.

197
00:13:32.226 --> 00:13:32.486
Yep.

198
00:13:32.686 --> 00:13:33.006
Okay.

199
00:13:33.766 --> 00:13:37.727
And she wanted to understand the structure of aromatic compounds.

200
00:13:38.187 --> 00:13:44.009
Specifically, she figured out that benzene, which is a six carbon ring with six hydrogens,

201
00:13:44.869 --> 00:13:46.670
That thing is a flat ring.

202
00:13:47.251 --> 00:13:49.433
She figured out that the structure of that thing was flat.

203
00:13:49.673 --> 00:13:56.798
She's one of the first to actually use something called Fourier transforms, which is where you go from frequency space to position space.

204
00:13:57.839 --> 00:14:08.607
The real mathematics behind X-ray crystallography, she's the first one to figure out how to quantitatively use the mathematical theory to understand even more complicated patterns differently.

205
00:14:08.727 --> 00:14:10.348
With extra crystallography, okay?

206
00:14:10.569 --> 00:14:25.521
And so she laid the foundations of, for example, later on when extra crystallography was being used for proteins and other kinds of really weird amorphous solids or DNA, the famous DNA picture that Rosalind Franklin took of the extra crystallography with the X.

207
00:14:25.581 --> 00:14:25.802
Yes.

208
00:14:26.362 --> 00:14:33.948
Her theories are what laid the foundation for that kind of work, to be like, what is the kind of molecule that would give me an X?

209
00:14:34.308 --> 00:14:38.111
And Francis Crick was the one who figured out, okay, it's got to be a spiral, right?

210
00:14:38.211 --> 00:14:48.679
And the spacing of the DNA, the spacing of the dots on that photo tell you how far away nucleotides are in DNA and how far away the turn is on a helix and things like that.

211
00:14:48.959 --> 00:14:50.120
So incredible individual.

212
00:14:50.140 --> 00:14:51.120
She's one of the first to...

213
00:14:52.021 --> 00:14:54.722
first two women elected to the Royal Society.

214
00:14:55.462 --> 00:15:03.424
She was also a Quaker, which is like, it's the religion that Benjamin Franklin is famous for in Pennsylvania and things like that.

215
00:15:03.724 --> 00:15:09.346
So she refused to register for civil defense duties during World War II because they're very non-Russian.

216
00:15:10.146 --> 00:15:28.521
violent people right yes um and she was in prison for a month and her experience in that prison was like she used that experience to become a passionate prison reform advocate right so yes yes all over the place she was great scientific impact great social impact not only by being a

217
00:15:30.443 --> 00:15:41.698
As a woman at the time who are not allowed in these scientific spaces as a generalization, but also still being grounded to that the world is still society.

218
00:15:42.058 --> 00:15:42.439
Yeah.

219
00:15:42.499 --> 00:15:44.101
And it's not just the work we do in a lab.

220
00:15:44.401 --> 00:15:44.842
Exactly.

221
00:15:44.862 --> 00:15:45.383
Yeah.

222
00:15:45.503 --> 00:15:46.484
So incredible woman.

223
00:15:47.473 --> 00:15:54.535
This paper that comes out in 1967 by Frondell and Marvin, they claim to have found the hexagonal diamond.

224
00:15:54.555 --> 00:15:57.616
They named it after Dame Kathleen Lonsdale.

225
00:15:57.716 --> 00:15:58.816
They call it Lonsdalite.

226
00:15:59.216 --> 00:16:07.898
They did X-ray diffraction on this thing, and they showed that it has the same pattern as something called Wurzite, which is a zinc-sulfur mineral that has hexagonal symmetry.

227
00:16:08.358 --> 00:16:10.719
Here what you're looking at is an animation of Wurzite.

228
00:16:11.099 --> 00:16:14.200
Just imagine instead of the two different colors, which are zinc and sulfur,

229
00:16:14.700 --> 00:16:18.322
All of them are the same color because they're all carbon atoms.

230
00:16:18.662 --> 00:16:20.183
That's where all the carbon atoms would be.

231
00:16:20.663 --> 00:16:23.665
There's two things that are different about this compared to the cubic diamond.

232
00:16:23.985 --> 00:16:24.285
Okay.

233
00:16:24.425 --> 00:16:24.625
Yes.

234
00:16:24.885 --> 00:16:27.187
First thing, obviously, is look at the unit cell.

235
00:16:27.507 --> 00:16:28.707
It's a hexagonal prism.

236
00:16:28.887 --> 00:16:29.128
Yes.

237
00:16:29.228 --> 00:16:29.468
Right?

238
00:16:29.608 --> 00:16:29.808
Yes.

239
00:16:29.828 --> 00:16:34.290
There's a hexagon face on the top and the bottom.

240
00:16:34.410 --> 00:16:34.630
Yes.

241
00:16:35.511 --> 00:16:41.454
And the other thing is you're actually packing the carbon atoms closer together because the tetrahedral...

242
00:16:42.692 --> 00:16:50.079
the tetrahedral surfaces are flat compared to before they were sort of at an angle, at that 104.5 degree angle.

243
00:16:50.119 --> 00:16:50.880
Here they're flat.

244
00:16:51.160 --> 00:16:52.822
You're packing more carbon atoms.

245
00:16:53.242 --> 00:16:57.146
The bond length in between these carbon atoms is smaller.

246
00:16:57.707 --> 00:17:05.054
And so the hardness mechanism is because of the resistance to like any form of

247
00:17:06.472 --> 00:17:06.912
Stress.

248
00:17:07.152 --> 00:17:07.352
Right.

249
00:17:07.733 --> 00:17:10.894
This thing is going to be harder than cubic diamond.

250
00:17:11.334 --> 00:17:11.615
Yes.

251
00:17:11.795 --> 00:17:12.035
Okay.

252
00:17:12.255 --> 00:17:25.742
And I have one just brief question on this visual, just because there's, as a layman, the other visual difference here, and I understand that we're looking at Wartzeit in this example, and the key difference is there's sort of that bottom line,

253
00:17:26.602 --> 00:17:48.735
row right so you have the sort of all the tetrahedrals packed in the hexagonal prism at the top yeah and then there's just like a bottom row of empty space that kind of closes it out yeah well that thing is just going to be repeating over and over i think they're only showing one segment yeah exactly but because it's a crystal it's like gonna just keep repeating makes sense okay yeah no that's a good question now

254
00:17:49.495 --> 00:17:59.138
If we think about how this is different from cubic diamond at a grand scale, not just that, okay, the fundamental unit is hexagonal rather than cubic.

255
00:17:59.258 --> 00:17:59.458
Yes.

256
00:17:59.538 --> 00:18:00.318
That's the first thing.

257
00:18:00.618 --> 00:18:08.801
But now let's consider, like, packing a bunch of carbon atoms, like spheres, in an enclosed space.

258
00:18:08.961 --> 00:18:09.061
Okay.

259
00:18:09.201 --> 00:18:09.861
How do we do that?

260
00:18:09.901 --> 00:18:11.221
Well, there's two ways of doing it.

261
00:18:11.862 --> 00:18:12.442
On the left...

262
00:18:13.398 --> 00:18:14.679
is your cubic diamond.

263
00:18:15.080 --> 00:18:15.340
Okay?

264
00:18:15.780 --> 00:18:22.266
That's the one that we had seen earlier, where the tetrahedrals are in a cubic sort of repeating unit.

265
00:18:22.386 --> 00:18:22.587
Yes.

266
00:18:22.847 --> 00:18:35.839
When you do that, layers of carbon atoms repeat, but they repeat in an A, B, C, A, B, C, A, B, C kind of manner, meaning you're going to get one layer of carbon atoms, mm-hmm,

267
00:18:36.119 --> 00:18:39.982
The B layer, which is on top, is going to fit somewhere in the gaps of that.

268
00:18:40.042 --> 00:18:40.262
Yep.

269
00:18:40.422 --> 00:18:43.225
The C layer is going to fit somewhere on the gaps above that.

270
00:18:43.245 --> 00:18:45.646
But it's going to be slightly offset from the A layer.

271
00:18:45.666 --> 00:18:48.509
So I'm going to get three distinct layers, and it'll repeat like that.

272
00:18:48.609 --> 00:18:48.789
Yep.

273
00:18:49.089 --> 00:18:49.329
Okay?

274
00:18:49.509 --> 00:18:49.690
Yep.

275
00:18:49.810 --> 00:18:54.874
With hexagonal diamond, just because of the nature of the geometry, I only need two layers of stacking.

276
00:18:54.934 --> 00:18:59.577
It's going to be A, then B is going to fit exactly in the gaps.

277
00:18:59.897 --> 00:19:02.820
But because A is slightly different from the previous A... Yeah.

278
00:19:03.592 --> 00:19:07.896
The next layer can just repeat the bottom layer.

279
00:19:08.076 --> 00:19:14.121
So my stacking is going to go A, B, A, B, A, B instead of A, B, C, A, B, C, A, B, C. Yes.

280
00:19:14.581 --> 00:19:17.704
And just for folks who may be listening, I just want to put a disclaimer.

281
00:19:17.744 --> 00:19:23.489
This is a slightly important episode for visual reference points because it's very obvious visually.

282
00:19:23.509 --> 00:19:25.050
It's kind of hard to describe.

283
00:19:25.090 --> 00:19:25.350
It is.

284
00:19:25.370 --> 00:19:26.011
Yeah.

285
00:19:26.671 --> 00:19:28.593
just with audio or, or with voice.

286
00:19:29.113 --> 00:19:34.497
But I think sort of like, what's interesting is you can kind of see the, the offset you're talking about.

287
00:19:34.537 --> 00:19:40.601
Like imagine a staircase that has three stairs, one and then two, like when you're looking at it from the side.

288
00:19:40.641 --> 00:19:40.861
Yeah.

289
00:19:41.162 --> 00:19:44.904
So, you know, the cubic diamond is almost like three steps on the staircase.

290
00:19:44.964 --> 00:19:45.705
Yeah.

291
00:19:45.725 --> 00:19:49.948
Where the offset on the C is significantly farther away from the A. Yeah.

292
00:19:50.088 --> 00:19:51.589
But in the hexagonal, it's just two steps.

293
00:19:52.250 --> 00:19:55.572
And so imagine you're creating like this staircase that's going back and forth.

294
00:19:55.592 --> 00:19:55.692
Yeah.

295
00:19:55.972 --> 00:20:18.002
like this having two versus three yeah you can already think you can already think yes structurally that it would be it would be better it would be harder the things would be closer packed right the bonds would be a bit stronger the layers would be a bit stronger right and just theoretically you can just like kind of imagine that this hexagonal diamond is going to be harder and better than a cubic diamond right

296
00:20:18.222 --> 00:20:18.442
Right.

297
00:20:18.642 --> 00:20:18.822
Right.

298
00:20:19.003 --> 00:20:22.245
We will not be playing the Daft Punk song Harder, Better, Faster, Stronger.

299
00:20:22.305 --> 00:20:24.606
However, it would be a good theme for this episode.

300
00:20:24.626 --> 00:20:25.227
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

301
00:20:25.247 --> 00:20:26.227
We'll put it in the socials.

302
00:20:26.808 --> 00:20:26.988
Right.

303
00:20:27.428 --> 00:20:27.948
So, okay.

304
00:20:27.968 --> 00:20:29.309
Discovery in the 1960s.

305
00:20:29.770 --> 00:20:31.631
This is when they're like, okay, I think we found it.

306
00:20:31.671 --> 00:20:31.871
Right.

307
00:20:31.911 --> 00:20:32.111
Yes.

308
00:20:32.612 --> 00:20:40.657
So in the 1960s in parallel, it's kind of a golden age for high pressure physics because General Electric was...

309
00:20:41.137 --> 00:20:46.742
GE, the company, they achieved the first reproducible synthesis of diamond from graphite.

310
00:20:47.162 --> 00:20:49.404
You know, lab diamonds, synthetic diamonds.

311
00:20:49.464 --> 00:20:51.125
They invented it in the 1960s.

312
00:20:51.165 --> 00:20:52.766
This is General Electric.

313
00:20:52.826 --> 00:20:54.067
Actually, 1954.

314
00:20:54.528 --> 00:20:56.089
They use a kind of belt apparatus.

315
00:20:56.189 --> 00:20:58.851
It's effectively high pressure, high temperature.

316
00:20:59.031 --> 00:20:59.331
Okay?

317
00:20:59.552 --> 00:21:00.492
So you take graphite.

318
00:21:00.632 --> 00:21:05.436
You would subject it to 10 gigapascals, which is 100,000 times atmospheric pressure.

319
00:21:05.797 --> 00:21:07.118
You raise the temperature up to...

320
00:21:07.838 --> 00:21:10.321
a thousand degrees and you get diamond.

321
00:21:10.461 --> 00:21:14.986
This was a triumph in material science, Francis Bundy, Hall, strong and Wentworth.

322
00:21:15.467 --> 00:21:17.029
They got enormous recognition.

323
00:21:17.209 --> 00:21:19.191
They they're in the inventor's hall of fame.

324
00:21:20.312 --> 00:21:22.955
Very controversially, no Nobel prize for them.

325
00:21:23.516 --> 00:21:25.438
It might be because there's four people,

326
00:21:26.419 --> 00:21:28.320
And the Nobel Prize can only go to three.

327
00:21:28.721 --> 00:21:31.723
But usually when that happens, you just wait for one of them to die.

328
00:21:32.263 --> 00:21:34.425
And then you give it to the other three.

329
00:21:34.785 --> 00:21:37.347
But they didn't even do that, which I think is quite controversial.

330
00:21:37.367 --> 00:21:44.071
Because lab-grown diamonds are a game changer for all of these industrial applications that I was telling you about.

331
00:21:44.371 --> 00:21:48.214
So it very much has changed the landscape of material science and industry.

332
00:21:48.654 --> 00:21:50.135
They probably should have gotten the Nobel Prize.

333
00:21:50.316 --> 00:21:52.957
But I think now all four of them have passed away, so it's too late.

334
00:21:53.178 --> 00:21:53.558
Understood.

335
00:21:55.905 --> 00:21:58.126
They've shown that we can make cubic diamond.

336
00:21:58.567 --> 00:22:06.151
And this is also where we get the meme and the, like, colloquialism about strong as a diamond, diamond under pressure.

337
00:22:06.171 --> 00:22:11.114
Like, all of these various thingies is because the way you make diamonds is through.

338
00:22:11.414 --> 00:22:15.337
It's almost like most people kind of know it's like heat and squeezing.

339
00:22:15.397 --> 00:22:15.597
Yeah.

340
00:22:15.817 --> 00:22:16.177
Diamond.

341
00:22:16.217 --> 00:22:19.118
Yeah, that's why it happens deep in the Earth's crust if it's natural.

342
00:22:19.478 --> 00:22:22.440
And here we're just trying to sort of replicate that natural mechanism.

343
00:22:22.460 --> 00:22:23.420
That's why, yeah, exactly.

344
00:22:23.720 --> 00:22:24.621
Harder than a diamond.

345
00:22:24.881 --> 00:22:26.181
The diamond is forever stuff.

346
00:22:26.641 --> 00:22:27.302
That's Hollywood.

347
00:22:27.322 --> 00:22:27.942
That's Hollywood.

348
00:22:28.302 --> 00:22:31.483
That's Hollywood and the De Beers Corporation.

349
00:22:31.924 --> 00:22:34.204
As hard as a diamond, diamond under pressure, that's physics.

350
00:22:34.224 --> 00:22:35.185
Right, right, right.

351
00:22:35.525 --> 00:22:36.345
Right, just to be clear.

352
00:22:36.405 --> 00:22:37.326
Yeah, just to be clear.

353
00:22:37.366 --> 00:22:40.107
There is a difference here in how we approach things.

354
00:22:40.147 --> 00:22:45.069
So people start making lab-grown diamonds, and now we want to make Lanzelite.

355
00:22:45.229 --> 00:22:46.570
We want to make hexagonal diamonds.

356
00:22:46.590 --> 00:22:47.890
We've made cubic diamonds.

357
00:22:48.350 --> 00:22:53.632
We still have not yet made the thing we've already theoretically identified as being possible.

358
00:22:53.692 --> 00:22:54.313
Yeah, yeah.

359
00:22:54.633 --> 00:22:55.653
But there's a lot of problems.

360
00:22:56.093 --> 00:22:57.334
The samples are too small.

361
00:22:57.714 --> 00:22:59.555
The crystals are submicron in size.

362
00:22:59.875 --> 00:23:02.116
And there's no real definitive proof because you need...

363
00:23:03.118 --> 00:23:04.699
A lot of a sample.

364
00:23:04.959 --> 00:23:09.860
And by a lot, I mean even like a millimeter worth of stuff to do anything.

365
00:23:09.980 --> 00:23:10.181
Right.

366
00:23:10.441 --> 00:23:10.661
Right?

367
00:23:11.021 --> 00:23:14.122
So with all of this comes skepticism.

368
00:23:14.562 --> 00:23:16.123
It's like, well, why can't I just make...

369
00:23:17.372 --> 00:23:18.293
Hexagonal diamond.

370
00:23:18.613 --> 00:23:22.355
How come every time I'm trying to make diamond, I always get cubic diamond?

371
00:23:22.455 --> 00:23:22.636
Right.

372
00:23:22.676 --> 00:23:24.077
Which is the stuff that I see on Earth.

373
00:23:24.277 --> 00:23:24.477
Right.

374
00:23:24.537 --> 00:23:29.400
And now you're telling me that this meteor has it, but even the meteorite sample might not be that good.

375
00:23:29.520 --> 00:23:31.281
And that's where we come to 2014.

376
00:23:31.622 --> 00:23:33.163
Nature Communications, there's a paper.

377
00:23:34.511 --> 00:23:52.284
um lawns of the light is faulted and twinned cubic diamond and does not exist as a discrete material what a banger of a title okay it's just like no this is fake for those who might not understand this is like death the definition of a clap back

378
00:23:52.384 --> 00:23:52.644
Yes.

379
00:23:53.505 --> 00:24:01.989
To put in the title does not exist as a discrete material when for like the past 40, 50 years people have been like talking about how this is a thing.

380
00:24:02.089 --> 00:24:02.329
Yes.

381
00:24:02.489 --> 00:24:02.749
Right?

382
00:24:03.129 --> 00:24:05.010
And so here is the argument that he's making.

383
00:24:05.351 --> 00:24:09.653
He's saying that Lonzo Light is just cubic diamond but with something called stacking faults.

384
00:24:10.113 --> 00:24:13.795
What he's saying is if you look at the meteorite samples, okay?

385
00:24:13.815 --> 00:24:14.015
Yes.

386
00:24:15.101 --> 00:24:21.185
There's a bunch of cubic diamond lattice structure, but that cubic diamond lattice structure is not contiguous.

387
00:24:21.565 --> 00:24:29.371
There's like cubic diamond here, and then there's another domain of cubic diamond over here, and the boundary between them is slightly offset.

388
00:24:29.451 --> 00:24:36.316
So when I put this through X-ray diffraction, I am going to get artifacts that suggest that there are spots...

389
00:24:36.856 --> 00:24:38.256
where there is hexagonal diamond.

390
00:24:38.336 --> 00:24:44.538
And he goes through and does transmission electron microscopy of the sample of that meteorite, the Canon Diablo meteorite.

391
00:24:45.018 --> 00:24:48.259
And he's showing that there are these stacking faults, there are these boundaries, right?

392
00:24:48.480 --> 00:24:48.660
Yep.

393
00:24:49.200 --> 00:24:56.162
And so if you have enough stacking faults in your cubic diamond, the diffraction pattern is going to resemble...

394
00:24:56.822 --> 00:24:57.703
The hexagonal stuff.

395
00:24:58.003 --> 00:25:00.226
And so you're not actually making hexagonal diamond.

396
00:25:00.246 --> 00:25:02.548
You're just making a bunch of cubic diamond with defects.

397
00:25:02.848 --> 00:25:06.131
And then when you put it through the x-ray diffraction, oh, it's hexagonal.

398
00:25:06.151 --> 00:25:06.852
You can't say that.

399
00:25:07.032 --> 00:25:08.334
So he called it Fugazi.

400
00:25:08.434 --> 00:25:08.994
Yeah.

401
00:25:09.094 --> 00:25:10.896
He's like, no, this is nothing.

402
00:25:10.936 --> 00:25:11.357
This is nothing.

403
00:25:11.377 --> 00:25:11.537
Right?

404
00:25:12.057 --> 00:25:12.198
But...

405
00:25:12.838 --> 00:25:15.460
Meanwhile, computational studies are refusing to give up.

406
00:25:15.780 --> 00:25:16.961
And this is what I was talking about, right?

407
00:25:16.981 --> 00:25:22.245
Like, you go through and you put it in the computer, and the computer is saying this is fine.

408
00:25:22.466 --> 00:25:25.028
This is totally a possible allotrope of carbon.

409
00:25:25.408 --> 00:25:26.028
This works.

410
00:25:26.369 --> 00:25:27.830
The carbon atoms are all happy.

411
00:25:28.070 --> 00:25:29.691
They don't want to go into another phase.

412
00:25:29.971 --> 00:25:30.192
Like...

413
00:25:30.792 --> 00:25:33.254
You set them up like this, they'll stay like this.

414
00:25:33.374 --> 00:25:43.101
Based on the rules of just foundational and basic physics that we understand to be true, you can extrapolate in a computer and it's fine.

415
00:25:43.221 --> 00:25:44.182
Yeah, it's fine.

416
00:25:44.222 --> 00:25:45.943
It totally works.

417
00:25:46.063 --> 00:25:47.224
So what gives?

418
00:25:47.384 --> 00:25:53.669
Which means the theory of the case here is that it is an engineering problem, not a fundamental physics or science problem.

419
00:25:53.749 --> 00:25:55.630
That's kind of what's been the argument.

420
00:25:55.650 --> 00:25:56.831
It's been the argument.

421
00:25:57.512 --> 00:26:00.334
But in order to prove that, you've got to just solve the engineering problem.

422
00:26:00.374 --> 00:26:00.514
Right.

423
00:26:01.534 --> 00:26:11.958
And that requires a lot of fundamental physics At the end of the day And so in 2024 we're at this interesting state The theory says The launch of the light should be real The experiment says Nah

424
00:26:13.952 --> 00:26:15.794
This is where we get into this paper.

425
00:26:16.554 --> 00:26:18.176
Bulk hexagonal diamond.

426
00:26:18.436 --> 00:26:19.877
Great name.

427
00:26:19.997 --> 00:26:20.217
Yes.

428
00:26:20.418 --> 00:26:21.479
Three word.

429
00:26:22.239 --> 00:26:25.862
I haven't seen a shorter nature paper title, to be honest.

430
00:26:26.423 --> 00:26:26.903
Well done.

431
00:26:27.023 --> 00:26:27.544
Right?

432
00:26:27.604 --> 00:26:28.845
Bulk hexagonal diamond.

433
00:26:28.885 --> 00:26:29.245
That's it.

434
00:26:29.285 --> 00:26:29.626
That's it.

435
00:26:30.026 --> 00:26:30.386
That's it.

436
00:26:30.626 --> 00:26:31.347
Nature.

437
00:26:31.687 --> 00:26:33.629
No narrating.

438
00:26:33.889 --> 00:26:34.770
No.

439
00:26:34.790 --> 00:26:35.611
This is what it is.

440
00:26:37.748 --> 00:26:37.928
Right?

441
00:26:37.948 --> 00:26:38.469
It's quite nice.

442
00:26:38.549 --> 00:26:39.189
It's quite nice.

443
00:26:40.230 --> 00:26:42.672
It's a macroscopic pure sample that they've created.

444
00:26:43.533 --> 00:26:43.733
Okay.

445
00:26:43.853 --> 00:26:45.594
They're showing that it's not an artifact.

446
00:26:46.555 --> 00:26:49.097
And let's get into how exactly they did it.

447
00:26:49.257 --> 00:26:49.477
Yes.

448
00:26:49.537 --> 00:26:49.778
All right.

449
00:26:50.018 --> 00:26:50.878
And before we do...

450
00:26:51.299 --> 00:26:51.619
Yes.

451
00:26:52.200 --> 00:26:53.761
I'm going to do some brief show notes.

452
00:26:53.821 --> 00:27:01.367
So if you are listening to this and you were a listener on episode five when we talked about the other group of Chinese teams that did this story...

453
00:27:02.228 --> 00:27:10.616
This is going to be very exciting because all of the stuff we do here, much like science and science research itself, builds on top of each other.

454
00:27:11.117 --> 00:27:21.067
The Nobel Prize aspect, all of these people, all these people and aspects that we really try to weave together is the joy that we get of doing the show.

455
00:27:21.447 --> 00:27:24.550
And you as the supporting community audience are.

456
00:27:24.810 --> 00:27:26.751
are a huge part of why we're able to do that.

457
00:27:27.031 --> 00:27:35.196
So a simple like, share, follow, comment, you would not believe how much comments change how much our video gets shown to other people.

458
00:27:35.716 --> 00:27:47.242
Let's talk more about science, experimental design, breaking science research, and any way that you can engage in our content is super, super helpful for us getting this show to more people.

459
00:27:47.642 --> 00:27:54.026
If you would like to become a patron, you can go over to our website, ffppod.com backslash donate.

460
00:27:54.406 --> 00:27:55.607
make a one-time donation.

461
00:27:56.147 --> 00:28:01.391
If you think this is better than Netflix, you can make a monthly recurring donation, but every little bit helps.

462
00:28:01.611 --> 00:28:16.742
It is the two of us here who both produce, write, distribute, and run the entire show, and we really like to make sure it's at a high level, high quality overlays, great breakdowns, and your support is the key aspect that allows us to do so.

463
00:28:17.322 --> 00:28:20.565
And with that, let's get back into the story.

464
00:28:21.037 --> 00:28:21.257
Yep.

465
00:28:21.438 --> 00:28:22.640
Bulk hexagonal diamond.

466
00:28:23.121 --> 00:28:23.782
How did they do it?

467
00:28:23.883 --> 00:28:24.464
How did they do it?

468
00:28:24.544 --> 00:28:26.247
The challenge is the following, actually.

469
00:28:26.407 --> 00:28:26.668
Okay.

470
00:28:28.307 --> 00:28:31.289
You know, let's ask why is it so easy now?

471
00:28:31.509 --> 00:28:39.233
I mean, it's hard, but why is it so easy to create cubic diamond, normal diamond, but it's so hard to create hexagonal diamond, right?

472
00:28:40.193 --> 00:28:46.337
We're just pressing graphite, but every single time, we're just getting the lab-grown standard diamond.

473
00:28:46.777 --> 00:28:48.117
I want to create hexagonal diamond.

474
00:28:48.458 --> 00:28:52.300
The reason why is that standard high-pressure, high-temperature conditions—

475
00:28:52.960 --> 00:28:59.084
favor the formation of cubic diamond, because cubic diamond is actually a global energy minimum.

476
00:28:59.124 --> 00:29:07.730
You know, when we think about energy landscapes, we can think about orientations and how different orientations of the diamond have different energies.

477
00:29:08.450 --> 00:29:22.519
And it turns out the cubic diamond, even though it's sort of bigger and has that ABC, ABC stacking, that has a lower energy and is more favorable than this AB, AB, smaller configuration.

478
00:29:22.559 --> 00:29:30.905
So you've got to go through a very specific route in order to get to this local minima and avoid the global minimum.

479
00:29:30.925 --> 00:29:31.045
Yeah.

480
00:29:31.085 --> 00:29:31.645
That makes total sense.

481
00:29:31.685 --> 00:29:31.825
Okay.

482
00:29:32.106 --> 00:29:33.026
That's what it turns out.

483
00:29:33.086 --> 00:29:41.211
And that has a lot to do with a lot of the computational work that was done around the hexagonal diamond to figure out why is this not working.

484
00:29:41.652 --> 00:29:42.832
Other people had done that work.

485
00:29:43.012 --> 00:29:43.293
Okay.

486
00:29:43.393 --> 00:29:43.593
Yes.

487
00:29:43.753 --> 00:29:47.015
So this team is like, all right, how are we going to make...

488
00:29:49.382 --> 00:29:58.031
How are we going to make an experimental apparatus that is going to avoid that global minimum, not create a normal diamond and create our hexagonal diamond?

489
00:29:58.332 --> 00:30:07.642
Is it almost like saying we intentionally have to create an experimental apparatus that is not optimizing for...

490
00:30:08.743 --> 00:30:10.224
The easiest, like the best path.

491
00:30:10.324 --> 00:30:10.724
Yeah, yeah.

492
00:30:10.744 --> 00:30:11.484
Like we're in 10s.

493
00:30:11.504 --> 00:30:12.525
Yeah, the easiest.

494
00:30:12.605 --> 00:30:16.146
We need to go and figure out some way to like go off.

495
00:30:16.346 --> 00:30:17.106
Off the right.

496
00:30:17.126 --> 00:30:17.306
You know?

497
00:30:17.406 --> 00:30:17.626
Right.

498
00:30:17.786 --> 00:30:19.807
Like it's like we got two depressions on a hill.

499
00:30:19.867 --> 00:30:21.028
It's like when you're skiing, right?

500
00:30:21.068 --> 00:30:21.208
Yeah.

501
00:30:21.228 --> 00:30:25.369
You don't want to go all the way down to the chairlift.

502
00:30:25.409 --> 00:30:25.569
Yes.

503
00:30:26.069 --> 00:30:31.131
In Mammoth, sometimes you want to go to the outhouse in the back to get your grilled cheese sandwich, right?

504
00:30:31.351 --> 00:30:32.352
But that requires...

505
00:30:33.132 --> 00:30:37.217
Being very cognizant of which turns you're taking down the ski hill, right?

506
00:30:37.297 --> 00:30:43.683
Otherwise, you're just going to end up in the lodge like everyone else and then have to wait like two hours to go up the mountain.

507
00:30:44.604 --> 00:30:45.265
We've all been there.

508
00:30:45.285 --> 00:30:46.146
Yeah, we've all been there.

509
00:30:46.166 --> 00:30:55.295
But no, but that's actually really – that's a really interesting insight in that a suboptimal path can actually lead to the –

510
00:30:58.171 --> 00:31:01.714
the derivative effects that we are looking for.

511
00:31:01.754 --> 00:31:02.034
Yes.

512
00:31:02.215 --> 00:31:04.216
That are not necessarily naturally occurring.

513
00:31:04.236 --> 00:31:04.997
Yes, exactly.

514
00:31:05.037 --> 00:31:08.521
The reason why naturally occurring diamond is always naturally occurring.

515
00:31:08.541 --> 00:31:10.883
That cubic diamond is because the,

516
00:31:12.305 --> 00:31:14.867
it's not a controlled process in the Earth's crust, right?

517
00:31:14.968 --> 00:31:18.591
So it's just easy for the carbon to settle into the natural cubic diamond.

518
00:31:18.831 --> 00:31:23.776
But if we really want to go for this hexagonal thing, it's got to be real tight and real specific.

519
00:31:24.056 --> 00:31:27.099
And perhaps that's why the meteorite was showing these cases, right?

520
00:31:27.139 --> 00:31:29.081
Because, like, I mean, the scenario is crazy.

521
00:31:29.301 --> 00:31:30.522
It's a space rock coming at...

522
00:31:31.843 --> 00:31:33.364
Like, it's very high speed.

523
00:31:33.404 --> 00:31:33.604
Yes.

524
00:31:33.764 --> 00:31:35.344
Tens of kilometers per second.

525
00:31:35.524 --> 00:31:35.745
Right.

526
00:31:35.905 --> 00:31:36.945
Slamming into rock.

527
00:31:37.005 --> 00:31:37.225
Right.

528
00:31:37.325 --> 00:31:37.505
Right.

529
00:31:37.765 --> 00:31:40.126
This is a very key, like, scenario.

530
00:31:40.186 --> 00:31:40.386
Yes.

531
00:31:40.847 --> 00:31:41.367
That makes sense.

532
00:31:41.707 --> 00:31:45.368
So with that in mind, let's try to figure out how are we going to do this, right?

533
00:31:45.668 --> 00:31:49.550
Are we going to manufacture our hexagonal diamond and not cubic diamond?

534
00:31:49.650 --> 00:31:49.790
Yes.

535
00:31:49.810 --> 00:31:52.631
They use something called a kawaii-type large volume press.

536
00:31:53.391 --> 00:31:57.213
So this was conceptualized by Professor Naoto Kawaii.

537
00:31:58.173 --> 00:32:04.060
It's a uniaxial hydraulic press with six steel anvils that are inward.

538
00:32:05.001 --> 00:32:06.202
Here's the key idea here.

539
00:32:06.302 --> 00:32:07.383
There's multiple stages.

540
00:32:08.284 --> 00:32:09.586
There's the inner stage.

541
00:32:10.026 --> 00:32:11.668
Then there's the second stage anvil.

542
00:32:11.748 --> 00:32:13.150
And then there's an outer stage anvil.

543
00:32:13.510 --> 00:32:14.691
What I'm going to do is press...

544
00:32:15.664 --> 00:32:19.947
And when I press, the intermediate stage is going to press from all directions.

545
00:32:20.928 --> 00:32:21.268
Okay?

546
00:32:21.689 --> 00:32:24.271
So it's not just going to give me this kind of force.

547
00:32:24.311 --> 00:32:27.433
It's going to give me an all-direction type of force.

548
00:32:27.553 --> 00:32:34.538
And then that all-direction type of force is going to press on an even smaller thing that is going to then let me control how...

549
00:32:35.380 --> 00:32:39.222
And in what direction and how much I am able to put pressure.

550
00:32:39.682 --> 00:32:40.823
So that's my high pressure.

551
00:32:41.203 --> 00:32:45.946
And then high temperature, I can just make the thing hot from a variety of different mechanisms.

552
00:32:45.966 --> 00:32:50.368
Because the variable here that needs to be modified is not the heat, but the pressure.

553
00:32:50.588 --> 00:32:51.288
And here's why.

554
00:32:51.588 --> 00:32:52.809
The pressure is what matters.

555
00:32:55.671 --> 00:33:02.354
They actually started not with just normal graphite, but with a specific type of graphite called highly oriented graphite.

556
00:33:03.359 --> 00:33:04.740
pyrolytic graphite.

557
00:33:05.201 --> 00:33:06.642
This is a photo from their supplement.

558
00:33:07.143 --> 00:33:11.166
On the top is the normal graphite that you use in lead, in pencil lead.

559
00:33:11.867 --> 00:33:15.050
Graphite is a bunch of layers of carbon rings, okay?

560
00:33:15.290 --> 00:33:17.072
It's layers on layers of carbon rings.

561
00:33:17.352 --> 00:33:20.575
But in naturally occurring graphite, the layers are kind of...

562
00:33:21.558 --> 00:33:22.799
you know, off each other.

563
00:33:22.839 --> 00:33:24.299
They're not completely flat.

564
00:33:24.720 --> 00:33:25.020
Okay?

565
00:33:25.300 --> 00:33:29.202
What I want is exactly flat graphite.

566
00:33:29.642 --> 00:33:29.902
Okay?

567
00:33:30.202 --> 00:33:34.585
Not off where, like, some carbon atoms are closer than other carbon atoms.

568
00:33:34.905 --> 00:33:36.106
I want exactly flat.

569
00:33:36.366 --> 00:33:47.371
So they created a high-pressure environment and then a rapid cooling thing to make your amorphous graphite, so to speak, this very highly oriented pyrolytic graphite.

570
00:33:47.812 --> 00:33:48.912
Now, what is the advantage there?

571
00:33:49.432 --> 00:33:50.273
The advantage there...

572
00:33:51.358 --> 00:33:55.736
is that the graphite itself has ABAB memory.

573
00:33:57.761 --> 00:33:59.202
Oh, very interesting.

574
00:33:59.222 --> 00:34:00.123
You see where it's going?

575
00:34:00.143 --> 00:34:00.383
Yeah.

576
00:34:00.403 --> 00:34:00.583
Yep.

577
00:34:01.444 --> 00:34:01.544
Yep.

578
00:34:01.564 --> 00:34:01.704
Yep.

579
00:34:02.405 --> 00:34:07.970
The cooking, the material that they're trying to cook with already has the geometry of their end product.

580
00:34:08.010 --> 00:34:08.250
Right.

581
00:34:08.710 --> 00:34:09.471
Right.

582
00:34:09.611 --> 00:34:12.974
And naturally occurring graphite is naturally imperfect.

583
00:34:12.994 --> 00:34:13.214
Yes.

584
00:34:13.334 --> 00:34:20.440
And those imperfections lead to getting to lead to the destination of the global minima.

585
00:34:20.621 --> 00:34:21.321
Mm-hmm.

586
00:34:21.581 --> 00:34:21.802
But...

587
00:34:23.723 --> 00:34:24.484
Oh, that's so interesting.

588
00:34:24.784 --> 00:34:37.033
But because we are now making sure that we're having A5 Wagyu beef going in and not around the corner grocery store beef going in, we're going to get exactly what we want as the chef on the outcome.

589
00:34:37.053 --> 00:34:37.513
Exactly.

590
00:34:37.573 --> 00:34:40.355
And so this, you can already see the A, B, A, B stacking.

591
00:34:40.575 --> 00:34:45.819
You can imagine the lower layer is B, the upper layer is A, and now I can just stack this on top of one another.

592
00:34:45.979 --> 00:34:46.539
Yes, yes.

593
00:34:46.619 --> 00:34:51.063
And so now when I press on them, perhaps that geometry is going to be perfect.

594
00:34:51.703 --> 00:34:52.203
preserved.

595
00:34:52.323 --> 00:34:52.924
That makes sense.

596
00:34:53.384 --> 00:34:54.425
There's another problem though.

597
00:34:54.745 --> 00:34:56.926
Just because you start with ABAB graphite, right?

598
00:34:57.006 --> 00:34:59.508
It's going to be ABAB one on top of the other.

599
00:35:00.048 --> 00:35:06.072
If I push from all directions, that might cause the graphite to scrunch up, losing that symmetry.

600
00:35:06.412 --> 00:35:10.855
So I need to be able to only press from the top and bottom.

601
00:35:11.195 --> 00:35:11.475
Okay.

602
00:35:11.736 --> 00:35:13.937
Now in any type of press, that's very difficult.

603
00:35:14.477 --> 00:35:18.740
But what they did was they added...

604
00:35:20.485 --> 00:35:22.887
layer of aluminum on top and the bottom.

605
00:35:23.407 --> 00:35:29.450
And what that alumina does is not distribute any of the stress laterally just because of the way aluminum works.

606
00:35:29.530 --> 00:35:31.992
And all of the stress was in the up and down direction.

607
00:35:32.012 --> 00:35:36.114
So they had the press, and on the press they layered aluminum on the top and the bottom.

608
00:35:36.154 --> 00:35:39.556
So that when they were pressing, the stress was only in the vertical direction.

609
00:35:39.576 --> 00:35:39.736
Yes.

610
00:35:40.037 --> 00:35:40.317
Okay?

611
00:35:40.337 --> 00:35:40.517
Yes.

612
00:35:41.137 --> 00:35:41.838
Once they do that,

613
00:35:42.598 --> 00:35:45.160
Finally, this is how it should work in theory.

614
00:35:45.540 --> 00:35:48.022
They did large-scale molecular dynamic simulations.

615
00:35:48.062 --> 00:35:50.844
Here we've got layers on layers of that ABAB graphite.

616
00:35:51.485 --> 00:35:53.246
And you can see a tiny defect is forming.

617
00:35:53.567 --> 00:35:56.909
And as you press, the orange is that hexagonal diamond.

618
00:35:57.229 --> 00:35:58.791
It rapidly forms, right?

619
00:35:59.031 --> 00:36:07.237
There's kind of a nucleation zone where the defect kind of starts and the layers of graphite are covalently bonding to one another.

620
00:36:07.758 --> 00:36:10.580
And then as you press more and more, it rapidly sort of like...

621
00:36:11.842 --> 00:36:13.503
Like a contagion.

622
00:36:13.683 --> 00:36:13.983
Yes.

623
00:36:14.103 --> 00:36:14.583
Right?

624
00:36:14.663 --> 00:36:17.024
That bond sort of spreads out.

625
00:36:17.804 --> 00:36:21.845
It propagates from this initial inciting incident location.

626
00:36:22.605 --> 00:36:32.949
And this is so... Now understanding the component parts, this makes a lot more sense in terms of, you know...

627
00:36:33.729 --> 00:36:38.213
Because normally what you would get in this use case is the spreading of cubic diamonds.

628
00:36:38.233 --> 00:36:38.453
Yeah.

629
00:36:38.714 --> 00:36:49.844
But because we've created our specific type of graphite, because we've created the specific pressure mechanism, and we've coded it at the top and bottom to make sure the pressure was distributed.

630
00:36:49.904 --> 00:36:50.164
Yeah.

631
00:36:50.204 --> 00:36:53.787
And as you can see, it's only being squished this way vertically, right?

632
00:36:53.807 --> 00:36:53.967
Right.

633
00:36:53.987 --> 00:36:55.229
It's not being squished the other way.

634
00:36:55.289 --> 00:36:55.469
Right.

635
00:36:55.489 --> 00:36:55.769
Right.

636
00:36:55.909 --> 00:37:00.433
And so those two dimensions, this dimension and the one inside and out, is being preserved.

637
00:37:00.753 --> 00:37:02.474
The only part that's getting squished is vertical.

638
00:37:02.534 --> 00:37:06.117
And that's why we're getting very specific hexagonal graphite.

639
00:37:06.177 --> 00:37:07.238
Sorry, hexagonal diamond.

640
00:37:07.258 --> 00:37:07.458
Yes.

641
00:37:07.638 --> 00:37:13.262
And so this is the molecular dynamic simulation where they show this is how we think it should happen.

642
00:37:13.462 --> 00:37:14.423
This was part of their paper.

643
00:37:14.663 --> 00:37:18.586
And obviously for this type of paper, you want to show the mechanism.

644
00:37:18.886 --> 00:37:19.127
Okay?

645
00:37:19.147 --> 00:37:22.749
So this was a very cool molecular dynamic simulation that they're showing.

646
00:37:22.769 --> 00:37:23.490
Okay.

647
00:37:25.110 --> 00:37:28.373
They do the experiment, and they come up with samples.

648
00:37:28.453 --> 00:37:29.774
These are what the samples look like.

649
00:37:29.814 --> 00:37:30.034
Yes.

650
00:37:30.595 --> 00:37:34.238
You've got some pretty large samples, so that bar is 200 microns.

651
00:37:34.378 --> 00:37:34.578
Yes.

652
00:37:34.618 --> 00:37:35.899
Five of those is a millimeter.

653
00:37:36.080 --> 00:37:36.320
Okay.

654
00:37:36.340 --> 00:37:40.163
So this is about the size of a millimeter plus, which means I can see it with my naked eye.

655
00:37:40.263 --> 00:37:40.423
Right.

656
00:37:40.463 --> 00:37:43.206
Before, everything was like submicron level.

657
00:37:43.246 --> 00:37:51.333
Like, I had to go into the Canyon Diablo meteorite, go under a scanning tunneling microscope, and even then, there was that dude who was like, no, this is just cubic diamond.

658
00:37:51.793 --> 00:37:52.534
Right here.

659
00:37:52.594 --> 00:37:54.937
The whole thing they're saying is hexagonal diamond.

660
00:37:55.058 --> 00:37:55.258
Yes.

661
00:37:55.498 --> 00:37:55.759
Okay.

662
00:37:55.919 --> 00:37:56.119
Yes.

663
00:37:56.880 --> 00:38:03.169
And, and the, the, the, the idea being it both passes just like the kind of the sniff test because of its size.

664
00:38:03.209 --> 00:38:08.997
Like, it's just like, Oh, well, if you can't make it that big, then I don't care, but it then also makes it easier to look at it.

665
00:38:09.057 --> 00:38:14.622
Yeah, because now with something this big, I can actually start doing x-ray diffraction studies in a clean manner.

666
00:38:14.963 --> 00:38:17.785
I can do transmission electron microscopy in a clean manner.

667
00:38:18.306 --> 00:38:20.568
And so at first, all they did was x-ray diffraction.

668
00:38:21.109 --> 00:38:26.434
And this thing called selected area electron diffraction, which is just instead of x-rays, you're using electrons.

669
00:38:27.094 --> 00:38:29.236
And they did a Vickers hardness scale.

670
00:38:30.498 --> 00:38:32.640
On the left, you're seeing the...

671
00:38:34.642 --> 00:38:35.503
X-ray diffraction.

672
00:38:35.723 --> 00:38:35.943
Yes.

673
00:38:36.263 --> 00:38:41.125
On the X-axis is like an angle of like how the X-ray that's coming in is getting bumped out.

674
00:38:41.445 --> 00:38:45.567
And then on the Y-axis, you're seeing like what the absorption rate is, right?

675
00:38:45.587 --> 00:38:45.707
Yes.

676
00:38:45.727 --> 00:38:46.787
Like the detector.

677
00:38:46.888 --> 00:38:47.108
Yes.

678
00:38:47.428 --> 00:38:54.551
And the little spots are where you're seeing the distances between atoms.

679
00:38:54.931 --> 00:38:59.173
And they're saying that this is key to showing that this is an hexagonal diamond.

680
00:38:59.193 --> 00:38:59.433
Yes.

681
00:38:59.473 --> 00:39:01.434
They also do the Vickers hardness scale.

682
00:39:01.454 --> 00:39:01.534
Yes.

683
00:39:02.867 --> 00:39:04.408
Now I can read the peer review.

684
00:39:04.468 --> 00:39:04.729
Yes.

685
00:39:05.329 --> 00:39:05.549
Okay.

686
00:39:05.569 --> 00:39:05.789
Yes.

687
00:39:06.030 --> 00:39:07.150
So what do you think, right?

688
00:39:07.170 --> 00:39:09.272
The peer reviewers are going to read this.

689
00:39:09.292 --> 00:39:16.718
I just want to note really briefly because there is a little bit of a – in the zeitgeist right now, there is a public debate about –

690
00:39:18.259 --> 00:39:23.564
Chinese universities and the legitimacy of the work that they do.

691
00:39:24.444 --> 00:39:31.210
I'm saying this is what the zeitgeist conversation is like in the U.S. And this was published in Nature.

692
00:39:31.330 --> 00:39:32.371
Yeah.

693
00:39:32.611 --> 00:39:35.213
Which is a Springer publication from the U.K.

694
00:39:35.353 --> 00:39:37.435
So, you know, and there...

695
00:39:38.676 --> 00:39:43.341
What's great, which you talked about this recently, is they're now putting the reviewer notes on these papers.

696
00:39:43.381 --> 00:39:43.601
Yeah.

697
00:39:43.741 --> 00:39:47.005
So you can get a little bit more of an insight into how the sausage was made.

698
00:39:47.045 --> 00:39:47.245
Yeah.

699
00:39:47.405 --> 00:39:51.249
To make a better characterization about your own perspective of the study.

700
00:39:51.389 --> 00:39:55.754
And so I'm just, I know that there's, I think there's been a little bit of poo-pooing that's been undeserved.

701
00:39:55.934 --> 00:39:56.694
Yeah.

702
00:39:57.175 --> 00:39:58.737
And you can go just look.

703
00:39:58.977 --> 00:39:59.157
Yeah.

704
00:39:59.237 --> 00:40:00.939
And you can look and see what people are saying.

705
00:40:00.999 --> 00:40:01.179
Right.

706
00:40:01.499 --> 00:40:01.680
And...

707
00:40:02.638 --> 00:40:08.201
If we look at that peer review paper, so version zero, that's the one that they initially submit to the editor.

708
00:40:08.481 --> 00:40:13.903
The editor then deems, okay, I mean, if it's bulk hexagonal diamond, this does deserve getting published into Nature.

709
00:40:14.204 --> 00:40:21.127
So now I'm going to put it off and give it for review to some of the top scientists in the field who know what they're talking about.

710
00:40:21.207 --> 00:40:22.348
Okay.

711
00:40:22.768 --> 00:40:24.649
In this case, reviewer one.

712
00:40:25.369 --> 00:40:29.972
comes back after version zero, and he says, overall, this paper should be rejected.

713
00:40:30.692 --> 00:40:31.553
Classic.

714
00:40:31.713 --> 00:40:33.074
Usually it's reviewer two.

715
00:40:34.335 --> 00:40:39.918
Because like reviewer one is like, because imagine you're like opening up your peer review file, right?

716
00:40:39.998 --> 00:40:42.520
And usually like reviewer one is like kind of nice about it.

717
00:40:42.580 --> 00:40:44.221
And then reviewer two is just going at it.

718
00:40:44.581 --> 00:40:50.044
Here, like, I guess the editor didn't change the, you know, because the editor could have just like changed.

719
00:40:50.304 --> 00:40:52.246
It doesn't matter who reviewer one and two is.

720
00:40:52.346 --> 00:40:52.606
Right.

721
00:40:53.825 --> 00:41:00.068
But anyways, they open up the peer review file and imagine the first overall this paper should be rejected.

722
00:41:00.388 --> 00:41:00.628
Okay?

723
00:41:00.968 --> 00:41:01.168
Yes.

724
00:41:01.328 --> 00:41:03.669
So here's the complaint that reviewer number one is making.

725
00:41:03.729 --> 00:41:10.392
He's saying that basically the x-ray diffraction and this electron diffraction, those two data sets are inconsistent.

726
00:41:10.452 --> 00:41:13.113
We don't know what the original version of the figures are, right?

727
00:41:13.133 --> 00:41:13.813
So we can't see.

728
00:41:14.173 --> 00:41:18.395
But apparently they were inconsistent and they didn't analyze different axes.

729
00:41:18.415 --> 00:41:18.675
Right.

730
00:41:18.795 --> 00:41:23.258
Like, you know, with a crystal, there's like different directions that I can sort of probe.

731
00:41:23.478 --> 00:41:31.002
I can just rotate my sample on my X-ray diffraction apparatus, and then I can probe different directions of the crystal.

732
00:41:31.043 --> 00:41:31.603
They didn't do that.

733
00:41:31.943 --> 00:41:32.984
I think that's fair.

734
00:41:33.284 --> 00:41:33.984
That's totally fair.

735
00:41:34.004 --> 00:41:34.405
I think that's fair.

736
00:41:34.425 --> 00:41:41.969
They also didn't do this thing called Reitveld refinement, which is a way to computationally clean up diffraction data, which apparently like everyone does.

737
00:41:42.069 --> 00:41:42.770
So they didn't do that.

738
00:41:43.010 --> 00:41:43.490
Okay.

739
00:41:43.510 --> 00:41:46.312
And they're using – this one I thought was really hilarious.

740
00:41:46.592 --> 00:41:47.773
They're using diamond –

741
00:41:48.293 --> 00:41:55.337
cubic diamond, the normal diamond, to probe the hardness of this thing, and they're claiming that this thing is harder.

742
00:41:56.638 --> 00:41:59.259
That doesn't quite make any sense.

743
00:41:59.279 --> 00:42:00.480
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

744
00:42:00.500 --> 00:42:00.640
Right?

745
00:42:00.660 --> 00:42:05.542
You've got something that's really hard, and then you're scratching it with something that you're claiming is not as hard.

746
00:42:06.303 --> 00:42:06.463
Right.

747
00:42:06.483 --> 00:42:07.824
But then how are you scratching it?

748
00:42:07.844 --> 00:42:07.984
Right.

749
00:42:08.004 --> 00:42:08.184
Right.

750
00:42:09.294 --> 00:42:12.536
If the original thing is not as hard, right?

751
00:42:12.596 --> 00:42:18.300
And are you really sure that the scratch you made is, like, enough to give you data for the Vickers hardness scale?

752
00:42:18.340 --> 00:42:18.540
Right.

753
00:42:18.660 --> 00:42:18.860
Right?

754
00:42:19.020 --> 00:42:23.823
If it's harder than the thing that you're using to scratch, like, we're in unknown territory here.

755
00:42:23.843 --> 00:42:31.888
Because usually when we talk about how hard is something, we take a normal diamond that we know is at a hardness of 10, and we scratch it, and then we see what the indentation is.

756
00:42:32.128 --> 00:42:34.630
And then from that, you can calculate, okay, where is it on the hardness scale?

757
00:42:34.870 --> 00:42:37.672
Here you're saying this is harder than the thing we're using to probe it.

758
00:42:37.772 --> 00:42:37.932
Right.

759
00:42:37.952 --> 00:42:38.072
Right.

760
00:42:38.172 --> 00:42:38.894
Doesn't make any sense.

761
00:42:38.954 --> 00:42:40.096
No, it doesn't.

762
00:42:40.457 --> 00:42:42.903
The radio speaker dial does not go to 11.

763
00:42:43.063 --> 00:42:43.223
Yeah.

764
00:42:43.584 --> 00:42:43.825
Okay.

765
00:42:44.065 --> 00:42:44.947
So that's reviewer one.

766
00:42:45.007 --> 00:42:46.391
Reviewer two was very nice about it.

767
00:42:46.791 --> 00:42:47.192
Okay.

768
00:42:47.313 --> 00:42:47.914
He said, you know...

769
00:42:49.640 --> 00:42:52.101
Bulk hexagonal diamond is a very important thing.

770
00:42:52.201 --> 00:42:52.381
Yes.

771
00:42:52.401 --> 00:42:56.943
Therefore, the study seems important and could deserve to be published in a journal like Nature.

772
00:42:56.963 --> 00:42:58.144
He's saying you've got a chance.

773
00:42:58.184 --> 00:42:58.404
Yes.

774
00:42:58.824 --> 00:43:00.105
But I'm not convinced.

775
00:43:00.185 --> 00:43:00.385
Okay.

776
00:43:00.405 --> 00:43:08.109
He says the data obtained from these many different methods to characterize the sample looks convincing in principle, but there's some important questions that remain.

777
00:43:08.789 --> 00:43:09.950
So the authors go back.

778
00:43:10.150 --> 00:43:10.330
Yes.

779
00:43:10.350 --> 00:43:10.650
Yes.

780
00:43:11.010 --> 00:43:18.498
And the key thing is with reviewer two, the concerns that he said, the important questions that remain are very similar to author one.

781
00:43:18.578 --> 00:43:18.818
Okay.

782
00:43:18.919 --> 00:43:19.559
To reviewer one.

783
00:43:19.579 --> 00:43:19.679
Yeah.

784
00:43:19.779 --> 00:43:21.441
Except reviewer one was straight up like this.

785
00:43:21.461 --> 00:43:21.862
Yeah.

786
00:43:21.882 --> 00:43:22.262
This is not.

787
00:43:22.302 --> 00:43:22.963
This.

788
00:43:23.243 --> 00:43:23.724
I don't know what.

789
00:43:23.744 --> 00:43:25.666
What are we doing here?

790
00:43:25.706 --> 00:43:25.946
Yeah.

791
00:43:26.126 --> 00:43:26.366
Okay.

792
00:43:26.607 --> 00:43:29.610
So the authors come back and they did do multiple directions.

793
00:43:29.650 --> 00:43:29.750
Okay.

794
00:43:29.930 --> 00:43:30.170
Okay.

795
00:43:30.290 --> 00:43:30.410
Okay.

796
00:43:30.430 --> 00:43:36.392
So in this one, if you see, this is figure two, two A and B show AB stacking.

797
00:43:36.592 --> 00:43:37.052
You see that?

798
00:43:37.292 --> 00:43:38.772
You see the little orange dots?

799
00:43:38.832 --> 00:43:40.813
That's AB, AB, AB, AB.

800
00:43:40.833 --> 00:43:43.313
This is electron microscopy.

801
00:43:43.433 --> 00:43:44.033
Very clear.

802
00:43:44.173 --> 00:43:44.393
Yes.

803
00:43:44.693 --> 00:43:45.454
Very clear, right?

804
00:43:45.734 --> 00:43:48.074
On the bottom row, you see hexagonal lattice.

805
00:43:48.194 --> 00:43:49.054
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

806
00:43:49.074 --> 00:43:49.254
Okay?

807
00:43:49.555 --> 00:43:50.635
Yeah, it is quite clear.

808
00:43:50.715 --> 00:43:51.575
It's like it's there.

809
00:43:51.875 --> 00:43:53.937
The ABAB stacking is in the top row.

810
00:43:54.458 --> 00:43:57.301
They've done the simulation on the right-hand side of what it should look like.

811
00:43:57.621 --> 00:44:01.425
And on the bottom row, they're showing the hexagonal stacking.

812
00:44:01.726 --> 00:44:03.407
Very nice.

813
00:44:03.648 --> 00:44:07.572
And this is exactly what the peer review process is.

814
00:44:07.912 --> 00:44:10.535
The point is that we want to get things done.

815
00:44:10.815 --> 00:44:35.596
accurate as accurately as possible and as correctly as possible and so it's a it's a natural back it's a natural back and forth and um credit to the editor of this thing he didn't take the reviewer one feedback too seriously and gave the authors another chance right yes um especially because i mean reviewer two had like positive things to say and said that there is definitely a chance i think if both editors i mean if both reviewers were like no yeah it would have been kind of bad right it would have been bad

816
00:44:35.836 --> 00:44:38.799
So anyways, they did show the multiple directions.

817
00:44:38.839 --> 00:44:41.201
They showed that ABAB stacking and the hexagonal stuff.

818
00:44:41.622 --> 00:44:43.684
They also did this Reitfeld analysis.

819
00:44:43.964 --> 00:44:52.392
This is a kind of computational trick where you say, okay, what if the sample is fully hexagonal or it's a mixture of hexagonal and cubic?

820
00:44:52.813 --> 00:44:55.135
What would the theoretical distribution look like?

821
00:44:55.415 --> 00:44:58.158
And then if I take a difference of the two, which model fits better?

822
00:44:58.298 --> 00:44:58.438
Yes.

823
00:44:58.578 --> 00:45:02.282
And the one that's purely hexagonal fits better than the one that's a mixture.

824
00:45:02.503 --> 00:45:02.743
Okay?

825
00:45:02.983 --> 00:45:05.205
So this is the analysis that reviewer one wanted.

826
00:45:05.345 --> 00:45:05.486
Yes.

827
00:45:05.506 --> 00:45:06.006
He got it.

828
00:45:06.166 --> 00:45:06.347
Yes.

829
00:45:06.527 --> 00:45:09.230
So the other thing, there's a question about uniformity.

830
00:45:09.490 --> 00:45:11.051
How uniform is the sample?

831
00:45:11.111 --> 00:45:11.852
Which is a good question.

832
00:45:11.872 --> 00:45:12.713
Which is a good question.

833
00:45:12.993 --> 00:45:15.816
So here they took 11 different random samples.

834
00:45:16.057 --> 00:45:16.277
Mm-hmm.

835
00:45:16.697 --> 00:45:39.906
of like a part of their sample and they did x-ray diffraction on that to show that the x-ray diffraction that comes out of whatever part of the sample is pretty identical right this is these are 11 different x-ray diffraction experiments but they all look basically the same like the the spacing of the yeah of the maxima yeah of your x-ray diffraction is about the same yeah right it's also just beautiful

836
00:45:40.186 --> 00:45:41.307
Yeah, very beautiful.

837
00:45:41.347 --> 00:45:44.470
And the hexagonal structure that you see is indicative.

838
00:45:44.491 --> 00:45:45.772
Yeah.

839
00:45:46.092 --> 00:45:55.222
I have never looked at that much extra crystallography or electron microscopy photography.

840
00:45:55.762 --> 00:45:59.926
But I can see the thingy without much...

841
00:46:00.547 --> 00:46:01.068
Analysis.

842
00:46:01.668 --> 00:46:02.389
Yeah.

843
00:46:02.849 --> 00:46:13.080
And finally, they also, instead of doing the Vickers hardness scale, which is like the scratching on the diamond thing, reviewer one suggested that they should do something called pulsed echo experiments.

844
00:46:13.380 --> 00:46:13.600
Okay.

845
00:46:13.620 --> 00:46:15.762
This is a way that you can like basically send...

846
00:46:16.463 --> 00:46:18.844
sound waves effectively through a material.

847
00:46:18.944 --> 00:46:19.504
Yeah.

848
00:46:19.524 --> 00:46:24.045
And the response of that material lets you calculate the elastic modulus of that material.

849
00:46:24.065 --> 00:46:24.405
That makes sense.

850
00:46:24.445 --> 00:46:27.186
And then there's ways to back calculate what the hardness is.

851
00:46:27.286 --> 00:46:27.626
That makes sense.

852
00:46:27.646 --> 00:46:33.128
So he said, if your scratch test and this echo experiment give you the same number, then I'll believe you.

853
00:46:33.188 --> 00:46:33.488
Okay.

854
00:46:33.508 --> 00:46:34.108
So they did it.

855
00:46:34.965 --> 00:46:35.645
It did come out.

856
00:46:36.046 --> 00:46:39.308
It showed that Young's modulus was bigger than Diamond's.

857
00:46:39.648 --> 00:46:44.511
And so finally, version 3, which is the fourth version, because you start with version 0.

858
00:46:44.551 --> 00:46:44.771
Yes.

859
00:46:44.991 --> 00:46:49.334
So with version 3, reviewer 1 finally says that he's happy with the version.

860
00:46:49.534 --> 00:46:52.596
He says the authors revised the paper according to the recommendations.

861
00:46:53.036 --> 00:46:58.259
Now the paper and supplement provide all the relevant information, and the results are truly convincing!

862
00:46:58.279 --> 00:46:58.539
Mm-hmm.

863
00:47:00.140 --> 00:47:04.123
And in the middle, he's saying that I believe refining all of this was worth it.

864
00:47:04.183 --> 00:47:10.226
So he's kind of saying, I know I gave you guys a hard time, but I think it was worth it because now I think this paper is stellar.

865
00:47:10.466 --> 00:47:13.368
And at the end, he says, congratulations for this important work.

866
00:47:13.468 --> 00:47:15.570
And he signs his own name, Oliver...

867
00:47:17.274 --> 00:47:17.815
Chowonar.

868
00:47:17.995 --> 00:47:18.375
Yeah, yeah.

869
00:47:18.695 --> 00:47:21.478
He's from the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, I believe.

870
00:47:21.498 --> 00:47:21.938
So he did.

871
00:47:22.258 --> 00:47:22.939
He put his name.

872
00:47:22.999 --> 00:47:23.719
He doesn't have to.

873
00:47:23.860 --> 00:47:24.080
Right.

874
00:47:24.180 --> 00:47:24.360
Right.

875
00:47:24.440 --> 00:47:27.082
But he put his own name there to show, okay, this is who I was.

876
00:47:27.122 --> 00:47:27.322
Yeah.

877
00:47:27.823 --> 00:47:28.944
Appreciate the work you did.

878
00:47:29.004 --> 00:47:29.204
Right.

879
00:47:29.364 --> 00:47:32.587
So reviewer one turns out to be like kind of a hard ass.

880
00:47:32.667 --> 00:47:37.671
But the paper is quite incredible because now no one can say anything.

881
00:47:37.691 --> 00:47:38.352
No, this is.

882
00:47:38.452 --> 00:47:44.837
And I think this is the key point of why I wanted to preface the cultural moment and the sort of judgment of, you know.

883
00:47:46.828 --> 00:47:48.149
this process really does matter.

884
00:47:48.290 --> 00:47:51.373
And I do think some of the feedback that was brought up makes total sense.

885
00:47:51.393 --> 00:47:52.053
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

886
00:47:52.214 --> 00:47:53.195
Like, very reasonable.

887
00:47:53.215 --> 00:47:54.816
And, like, reviewer two said the same stuff.

888
00:47:54.836 --> 00:47:55.016
Right.

889
00:47:55.097 --> 00:47:55.297
Yeah.

890
00:47:55.557 --> 00:47:58.920
And if it worked, it was easily resolvable.

891
00:47:59.061 --> 00:47:59.261
Yeah.

892
00:47:59.301 --> 00:48:01.663
It didn't require a huge refactor or anything like that.

893
00:48:01.683 --> 00:48:02.544
You've got the sample.

894
00:48:02.844 --> 00:48:05.487
Just do a little more double-checking.

895
00:48:05.507 --> 00:48:05.627
Yeah.

896
00:48:05.647 --> 00:48:05.807
Yeah.

897
00:48:06.528 --> 00:48:07.709
And fascinating.

898
00:48:07.849 --> 00:48:09.590
Yeah.

899
00:48:09.670 --> 00:48:11.411
And again, we covered this in episode five.

900
00:48:11.672 --> 00:48:11.892
Right.

901
00:48:11.992 --> 00:48:14.894
And in a slightly different, similar but slightly different way.

902
00:48:14.954 --> 00:48:15.194
Yes.

903
00:48:15.394 --> 00:48:16.535
So now let's talk about that.

904
00:48:16.655 --> 00:48:16.955
Okay.

905
00:48:17.015 --> 00:48:17.376
All right.

906
00:48:17.836 --> 00:48:21.859
So this particular paper is coming out of Zhengzhou University.

907
00:48:22.579 --> 00:48:27.344
in China, also Nanjing University in China, and you said Hunan University, right?

908
00:48:27.384 --> 00:48:27.764
In China.

909
00:48:28.025 --> 00:48:31.508
These are all sort of like in the northern central part of China.

910
00:48:31.548 --> 00:48:33.010
And I want to just pronounce it.

911
00:48:33.050 --> 00:48:33.570
And in the east.

912
00:48:33.851 --> 00:48:35.252
Hanan versus Hunan.

913
00:48:35.272 --> 00:48:35.973
Okay, sorry.

914
00:48:36.013 --> 00:48:36.954
Oh, okay.

915
00:48:37.274 --> 00:48:37.835
Yeah, fair.

916
00:48:38.395 --> 00:48:39.096
Fair, totally enough.

917
00:48:39.456 --> 00:48:47.721
And the paper that we covered last year was out of the Shanghai Advanced Research in Physical Sciences Center in China, right?

918
00:48:47.801 --> 00:48:50.903
And that was synthesis of bulk hexagonal diamond.

919
00:48:51.343 --> 00:48:57.707
Already funny, because these guys use synthesis of bulk hexagonal diamond, and these guys just like, bulk hexagonal diamond.

920
00:48:57.727 --> 00:48:58.768
Right?

921
00:48:58.928 --> 00:49:00.168
Okay, also in Nature.

922
00:49:00.469 --> 00:49:00.689
Yes.

923
00:49:01.149 --> 00:49:05.792
Now, this new paper does not cite...

924
00:49:07.293 --> 00:49:08.674
That older one from last year.

925
00:49:09.114 --> 00:49:09.614
Oh, no.

926
00:49:09.875 --> 00:49:10.415
No.

927
00:49:10.715 --> 00:49:11.055
Okay?

928
00:49:11.235 --> 00:49:12.616
I thought that was pretty hilarious.

929
00:49:13.137 --> 00:49:24.823
Because the reviewer comments, and reviewer two actually does acknowledge this, that a recent paper has come out that shows synthesis of bulk hexagonal diamond.

930
00:49:25.224 --> 00:49:29.826
But he says that this paper was submitted before that one got accepted.

931
00:49:29.886 --> 00:49:32.328
So it's not like these guys knew about that paper, right?

932
00:49:32.508 --> 00:49:32.688
Right.

933
00:49:33.328 --> 00:49:35.670
But what that also tells me is that...

934
00:49:37.674 --> 00:49:45.421
These guys, Lai and other authors from Zhengzhou University, had the chance to cite that paper and did not.

935
00:49:45.461 --> 00:49:45.661
Yes.

936
00:49:46.021 --> 00:49:47.703
Because they saw it in the reviewer comments.

937
00:49:47.723 --> 00:49:48.183
Yep.

938
00:49:48.203 --> 00:49:53.528
Also, if you're in the field, you're not going to not be aware of a nature paper that came out saying the same thing.

939
00:49:53.588 --> 00:49:53.748
Right.

940
00:49:53.908 --> 00:49:54.089
Right?

941
00:49:54.549 --> 00:49:58.392
And they were in the process of revision, which means they could have easily snuck in that.

942
00:49:58.472 --> 00:49:58.653
Yep.

943
00:49:59.273 --> 00:49:59.854
But they didn't.

944
00:49:59.914 --> 00:50:00.114
Yep.

945
00:50:00.374 --> 00:50:02.536
Okay, I think already that's hilarious.

946
00:50:02.576 --> 00:50:03.016
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

947
00:50:03.036 --> 00:50:04.717
Okay, there's clearly something.

948
00:50:04.897 --> 00:50:08.600
We didn't sample your chord from your 1967 hit.

949
00:50:08.640 --> 00:50:09.681
No, no, no, no, no.

950
00:50:09.781 --> 00:50:11.042
Yeah, yeah.

951
00:50:11.222 --> 00:50:19.628
And that same group from the Shanghai University also did another paper in February, but this was in Nature Materials.

952
00:50:20.581 --> 00:50:26.266
And again, it was a general approach for synthesizing hexagonal diamond using post-graphite phases.

953
00:50:26.586 --> 00:50:28.347
So slightly different method, but still.

954
00:50:28.527 --> 00:50:28.727
Right.

955
00:50:29.068 --> 00:50:31.029
No mention of even this paper.

956
00:50:32.570 --> 00:50:34.652
This is... Like, this is some beef, dude.

957
00:50:34.672 --> 00:50:37.594
Yeah, this is what beef looks like in the research committee.

958
00:50:37.614 --> 00:50:39.716
Clearly there's something, right?

959
00:50:42.378 --> 00:50:44.660
So I wanted to dig a little bit deeper.

960
00:50:44.860 --> 00:50:45.040
Yes.

961
00:50:45.280 --> 00:50:48.203
So Nature has a news article about this, right?

962
00:50:48.223 --> 00:50:48.363
Yes.

963
00:50:49.738 --> 00:51:00.425
Where they talk about this paper and all of the other research around it, and nature being nature, they have to acknowledge that they themselves published a previous paper on it.

964
00:51:00.785 --> 00:51:02.586
So what's going on?

965
00:51:02.786 --> 00:51:05.888
So I'm just going to read a little bit snippet of that news article, right?

966
00:51:06.269 --> 00:51:12.333
First of all, we see Shauner, who's the reviewer number one—

967
00:51:13.213 --> 00:51:22.281
He gives a brief expose about, like, he says that the pattern of the defraction peaks that are obtained very closely mimic that of hexagonal diamond.

968
00:51:22.381 --> 00:51:29.587
And to demonstrate hexagonal structure conclusively, there's a few more peaks that I really wanted to see.

969
00:51:30.047 --> 00:51:32.629
Once I saw that, the new paper shows those peaks.

970
00:51:32.789 --> 00:51:33.850
That's why I believe it.

971
00:51:34.150 --> 00:51:34.391
Okay?

972
00:51:34.631 --> 00:51:39.355
So he's, you know, true to his word, reviewer number one gave them a hard time, but...

973
00:51:39.815 --> 00:51:44.539
And then went to go comment on the public thing and said, I was the reviewer.

974
00:51:44.819 --> 00:51:45.340
I believe it.

975
00:51:45.520 --> 00:51:47.521
I stand by this paper along with the author.

976
00:51:47.581 --> 00:51:47.761
Right.

977
00:51:47.822 --> 00:51:49.243
Which is a crazy.

978
00:51:49.263 --> 00:51:49.463
Yeah.

979
00:51:49.683 --> 00:51:50.023
Okay.

980
00:51:50.083 --> 00:51:50.964
You know, that's cool.

981
00:51:51.004 --> 00:51:51.424
Yeah.

982
00:51:51.464 --> 00:51:51.625
Right.

983
00:51:51.825 --> 00:51:52.105
Yeah.

984
00:51:52.205 --> 00:51:57.269
Now they mentioned last year, another research group independently reported making hexagonal diamond.

985
00:51:57.289 --> 00:51:58.770
This is the 2025 paper.

986
00:51:58.830 --> 00:51:59.051
Yes.

987
00:51:59.231 --> 00:52:00.212
Out of Shanghai.

988
00:52:00.232 --> 00:52:00.332
Yes.

989
00:52:01.334 --> 00:52:04.999
And they get a quote from those authors.

990
00:52:05.339 --> 00:52:06.441
Oh, no.

991
00:52:06.501 --> 00:52:07.462
From last year's paper.

992
00:52:08.043 --> 00:52:13.950
And that guy, Ho Quang Mao, from Shanghai, he says, It looks like the new paper is very similar to ours.

993
00:52:14.451 --> 00:52:17.415
I have to say, I cannot see any difference.

994
00:52:17.435 --> 00:52:17.495
No.

995
00:52:19.037 --> 00:52:21.220
He's quoted, right?

996
00:52:21.400 --> 00:52:26.606
And then he says, but we're glad they have reproduced our results.

997
00:52:26.666 --> 00:52:29.890
Which is effectively a scientific way of saying they didn't do anything new.

998
00:52:30.071 --> 00:52:32.454
Right.

999
00:52:32.554 --> 00:52:37.280
It's effectively they're saying, I can't believe a reproduction paper also got into nature.

1000
00:52:37.300 --> 00:52:37.460
Right.

1001
00:52:37.660 --> 00:52:39.721
So something happened, bro.

1002
00:52:39.742 --> 00:52:39.922
Yeah.

1003
00:52:40.082 --> 00:52:40.322
Yeah.

1004
00:52:40.402 --> 00:52:42.303
Like something happened with these two groups.

1005
00:52:42.884 --> 00:52:48.868
And Shauner, who's the reviewer number one, he did a minor clap back.

1006
00:52:48.988 --> 00:52:49.228
Yeah.

1007
00:52:49.348 --> 00:52:50.829
He said it's almost the same.

1008
00:52:51.190 --> 00:52:51.350
Yeah.

1009
00:52:51.370 --> 00:52:55.693
But he pointed out that the x-ray analysis by Mao and his colleagues, this is the previous paper.

1010
00:52:55.793 --> 00:52:55.973
Yeah.

1011
00:52:57.549 --> 00:53:03.714
That X-ray analysis lacked one or two of the diffraction peaks that are expected to be seen in hexagonal diamond.

1012
00:53:04.394 --> 00:53:10.499
So he's saying this paper has a definitive hexagonal diamond X-ray diffraction pattern.

1013
00:53:10.539 --> 00:53:10.739
Right.

1014
00:53:11.120 --> 00:53:12.521
That perhaps the other one didn't.

1015
00:53:12.601 --> 00:53:13.141
Right.

1016
00:53:13.181 --> 00:53:15.503
But this whole Sega is hilarious to me.

1017
00:53:15.823 --> 00:53:24.010
And you actually brought this up when we did episode five where you said, I think there might be another team that is working on this.

1018
00:53:24.470 --> 00:53:25.171
Within China.

1019
00:53:25.191 --> 00:53:26.072
Within China.

1020
00:53:26.372 --> 00:53:28.754
But these guys got out first.

1021
00:53:28.794 --> 00:53:29.735
Yeah.

1022
00:53:30.376 --> 00:53:36.882
And you had literally, like, I wish, we'll try to see if we can do a, like, a throwback thing here.

1023
00:53:36.922 --> 00:53:42.167
Because your statement on that episode is almost literally exactly what happened.

1024
00:53:42.207 --> 00:53:45.270
And it turns out it was this team that was doing it.

1025
00:53:45.810 --> 00:53:47.132
I mean, so two things.

1026
00:53:47.333 --> 00:53:48.535
One, this is hilarious.

1027
00:53:48.615 --> 00:53:51.399
I love scientific beef and beef among scientists.

1028
00:53:51.499 --> 00:53:53.122
I wonder what conferences are like.

1029
00:53:53.282 --> 00:53:53.643
Oh, yeah.

1030
00:53:55.425 --> 00:53:57.128
Because I think the point is like this is –

1031
00:53:59.240 --> 00:54:03.524
It is a 50-plus-year-old unsolved problem.

1032
00:54:03.805 --> 00:54:12.953
So the prestige and the street cred and yada yada that you'll get from it for being first matters a lot.

1033
00:54:13.614 --> 00:54:16.757
Especially in the material size because this resolves the simulation.

1034
00:54:17.838 --> 00:54:20.341
Like people who are poo-pooing, oh, the Sims are wrong.

1035
00:54:21.602 --> 00:54:22.763
Well, I guess not.

1036
00:54:22.903 --> 00:54:23.684
Yeah, I guess not.

1037
00:54:23.744 --> 00:54:24.864
I guess this thing is real, right?

1038
00:54:25.084 --> 00:54:25.785
So that's one thing.

1039
00:54:25.805 --> 00:54:27.846
This is hilarious, and science beef is also funny.

1040
00:54:28.226 --> 00:54:35.211
I think, two, this shows just how good China has gotten with fundamental material science research.

1041
00:54:35.491 --> 00:54:37.392
Because they're having internal beef.

1042
00:54:37.653 --> 00:54:37.833
Right.

1043
00:54:37.853 --> 00:54:38.253
Right.

1044
00:54:38.393 --> 00:54:38.553
Right.

1045
00:54:38.573 --> 00:54:38.893
Okay.

1046
00:54:38.953 --> 00:54:39.133
Yeah.

1047
00:54:39.173 --> 00:54:41.455
There's institutions within China.

1048
00:54:41.535 --> 00:54:41.735
Yes.

1049
00:54:42.135 --> 00:54:43.436
That are beefing with each other.

1050
00:54:43.616 --> 00:54:43.816
Right.

1051
00:54:44.376 --> 00:54:45.877
About like who came first.

1052
00:54:45.937 --> 00:54:46.137
Right.

1053
00:54:46.397 --> 00:54:48.718
It's not even China is saying we're first.

1054
00:54:48.818 --> 00:54:48.998
Right.

1055
00:54:49.258 --> 00:54:50.379
It's like who among us.

1056
00:54:50.639 --> 00:54:51.079
Is first.

1057
00:54:51.259 --> 00:54:51.740
Is first.

1058
00:54:52.040 --> 00:54:52.220
Right.

1059
00:54:52.800 --> 00:54:53.580
It's China.

1060
00:54:53.921 --> 00:55:00.644
Chinese science has made leaps and bounds in terms of where they were just 20 years ago compared to where they are now.

1061
00:55:00.984 --> 00:55:01.184
Right.

1062
00:55:01.284 --> 00:55:01.464
Yep.

1063
00:55:01.504 --> 00:55:04.246
Where 20 years ago, this kind of competition was unheard of.

1064
00:55:04.266 --> 00:55:04.406
Right.

1065
00:55:04.426 --> 00:55:04.666
Right.

1066
00:55:05.107 --> 00:55:06.816
And now we're at this stage.

1067
00:55:07.419 --> 00:55:07.720
It is.

1068
00:55:08.142 --> 00:55:09.148
It's very impressive.

1069
00:55:10.007 --> 00:55:16.690
If you're watching this on a clip, be sure to watch the full episode because the details are very juicy.

1070
00:55:16.710 --> 00:55:18.491
The actual science is fascinating.

1071
00:55:19.231 --> 00:55:21.472
Why it worked is fascinating.

1072
00:55:21.672 --> 00:55:23.773
How much grief the reviewers gave them.

1073
00:55:24.213 --> 00:55:24.413
Right.

1074
00:55:24.433 --> 00:55:27.014
This was not easy for these scientists to publish.

1075
00:55:27.114 --> 00:55:27.334
Right.

1076
00:55:27.554 --> 00:55:30.616
And this is not coming out of the South China Morning Post.

1077
00:55:30.676 --> 00:55:30.916
No.

1078
00:55:31.396 --> 00:55:37.019
Or, you know, an outlet that you can perceive to have geopolitical reason to frame it one way or another.

1079
00:55:37.039 --> 00:55:37.859
Yeah.

1080
00:55:39.437 --> 00:55:47.280
And also the material science implications of this, as you brought up at the beginning, from industrial applications, et cetera, obviously there's a scaling issue, yada, yada, yada.

1081
00:55:47.380 --> 00:55:48.860
All this normal stuff we caveat.

1082
00:55:49.320 --> 00:55:54.442
Regardless, hugely, hugely impactful.

1083
00:55:54.702 --> 00:55:56.263
And I think sort of...

1084
00:55:57.985 --> 00:55:58.786
We'll see how...

1085
00:55:58.806 --> 00:56:04.635
This is now six, seven months later from our first coverage.

1086
00:56:04.915 --> 00:56:10.724
We'll see how the story progresses, but this seems to be a little bit of the closing of the book on a couple of the aspects.

1087
00:56:10.744 --> 00:56:11.405
Yeah, yeah.

1088
00:56:11.445 --> 00:56:12.166
I mean, there's two...

1089
00:56:12.987 --> 00:56:15.668
There's two big research groups that have shown that this thing can work.

1090
00:56:15.828 --> 00:56:15.988
Right.

1091
00:56:16.008 --> 00:56:19.428
I'm sure now other countries and other labs are going to replicate this thing.

1092
00:56:19.769 --> 00:56:22.649
Now the big question mark is, can this thing scale?

1093
00:56:22.889 --> 00:56:23.009
Yes.

1094
00:56:23.109 --> 00:56:28.090
Or do we have to figure out a new way to create hexagonal diamond that scales... Industrially.

1095
00:56:28.130 --> 00:56:28.971
Industrially, right?

1096
00:56:29.031 --> 00:56:29.531
But it works.

1097
00:56:29.691 --> 00:56:30.391
Yeah.

1098
00:56:30.431 --> 00:56:30.931
We can do it.

1099
00:56:32.271 --> 00:56:34.052
Great story again out of...

1100
00:56:35.292 --> 00:56:54.344
out of nature on march 4th zhang zhao nanjing and uh hanan universities in china a follow-up to our episode five um if you liked this episode if you like again seeing the connections our last deep dive episode had a very similar thing if you're a long-time listener

1101
00:56:55.004 --> 00:56:58.185
You're probably like me where you're starting to get these things much quicker.

1102
00:56:58.525 --> 00:57:03.287
You can see how they all relate to each other, how we build on top of the past work.

1103
00:57:03.647 --> 00:57:05.928
We are truly standing on the shoulders of giants.

1104
00:57:06.548 --> 00:57:13.030
Now, should we ask for the comment for this episode to create a replacement for the De Beers Diamonds Are Forever?

1105
00:57:13.490 --> 00:57:15.491
Some diamonds marketing.

1106
00:57:15.671 --> 00:57:15.891
Yeah.

1107
00:57:16.331 --> 00:57:18.972
Some, not diamonds are hexagonal, but something.

1108
00:57:19.072 --> 00:57:19.792
Something, yeah.

1109
00:57:20.232 --> 00:57:21.572
Come up with your best tagline.

1110
00:57:21.752 --> 00:57:25.933
Best tagline, because we need a rebrand for diamonds now, because it's technically a different thing.

1111
00:57:26.053 --> 00:57:27.174
Yeah, there's two types.

1112
00:57:27.194 --> 00:57:27.834
There's two types.

1113
00:57:27.914 --> 00:57:29.014
Yeah.

1114
00:57:29.074 --> 00:57:29.534
Two types.

1115
00:57:30.195 --> 00:57:37.397
I am your host, Lester Nari, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

1116
00:57:37.417 --> 00:57:42.478
We appreciate you all joining us on this journey, and we will see you later this week.
