WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.071 --> 00:00:03.994
So Microsoft products, they're the bane of everyone's existence at work.

2
00:00:04.154 --> 00:00:04.394
Right.

3
00:00:04.454 --> 00:00:07.176
And that work also includes astronauts going to the moon.

4
00:00:07.416 --> 00:00:10.238
Okay, so did you see this leak story about Claude Code?

5
00:00:10.438 --> 00:00:10.618
Yes.

6
00:00:10.718 --> 00:00:13.920
So do I just have Claude's LLM now or what?

7
00:00:14.240 --> 00:00:16.261
Not quite, but let's understand what actually happened.

8
00:00:16.461 --> 00:00:20.184
So your cat could be the key for cancer research in humans.

9
00:00:20.764 --> 00:00:21.505
Very interesting.

10
00:00:21.685 --> 00:00:22.605
Project Hail Mary.

11
00:00:22.745 --> 00:00:24.787
Everyone's complaining about the centrifuge scene.

12
00:00:25.167 --> 00:00:27.929
I think there's something even deeper that's wrong.

13
00:00:27.949 --> 00:00:28.049
Okay.

14
00:00:28.309 --> 00:00:28.969
Hello, Internet.

15
00:00:28.989 --> 00:00:36.953
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident Ph.D., Krishna Chowdhury.

16
00:00:37.473 --> 00:00:47.197
Welcome back to another rundown episode where we're going to just cover five new both science and tech stories this week, just at a super high level.

17
00:00:47.497 --> 00:00:49.878
And we have some some interesting stories to cover.

18
00:00:49.918 --> 00:00:54.400
We're going to start off with the Artemis launch that took off yesterday after several delays.

19
00:00:54.440 --> 00:00:56.461
It was on April 1st, but this is not happening.

20
00:00:56.581 --> 00:00:57.882
An April Fool's joke.

21
00:00:57.942 --> 00:00:58.962
It definitely did take off.

22
00:00:59.402 --> 00:01:07.146
We're going to follow that up with the very viral leak story about Claude, the anthropic model leaking.

23
00:01:07.306 --> 00:01:09.647
Oh, my God, does this mean we get to use AI for free?

24
00:01:09.767 --> 00:01:12.028
We're going to talk about what exactly happened, why.

25
00:01:12.068 --> 00:01:19.231
There's some interesting subtle details about what actually transpired with the Claude leak that happened earlier this week.

26
00:01:19.471 --> 00:01:22.613
There's a major new science paper that suggests that cats –

27
00:01:23.033 --> 00:01:31.923
Maybe one of the best real world models for sort of studying cancer in humans for an interesting reason about location.

28
00:01:32.944 --> 00:01:42.814
There's a trend you may be sensing because we're going to have another leak story about an iPhone spyware tool, two of them actually, that have leaked onto the public internet.

29
00:01:43.215 --> 00:01:45.097
And this is sort of this trend of location.

30
00:01:45.517 --> 00:01:51.782
more nation state level elite spyware tools now becoming more accessible commercially.

31
00:01:52.122 --> 00:01:54.504
What does it mean for you if you're an iPhone user?

32
00:01:55.084 --> 00:02:00.949
And we will then wrap up with a quick review of the science and,

33
00:02:01.289 --> 00:02:07.975
in Project Hail Mary, the ultra-popular new theatrical release featuring Ryan Gosling.

34
00:02:08.335 --> 00:02:13.179
We will have two perspectives on the movie, which we both saw recently.

35
00:02:13.560 --> 00:02:24.129
We're going to cover some topical points, but closely related to the science and first principles, because this is From First Principles.

36
00:02:39.357 --> 00:02:45.601
So yesterday, NASA launched Artemis II, the first crewed mission beyond low Earth orbit.

37
00:02:46.061 --> 00:02:53.466
We've got our trusty Lego-built Artemis II SLS space launch system here that we built out of Legos.

38
00:02:53.626 --> 00:03:00.730
By we, I mean Lester did all the work, and I am going to take credit for it because that is our dynamic, right, as friends.

39
00:03:01.550 --> 00:03:04.953
Anyways, launch date, April 1st, 2026 on April Fool's.

40
00:03:05.773 --> 00:03:06.953
The launch window opened up.

41
00:03:07.534 --> 00:03:10.255
The Earth and the moon were in the right spot.

42
00:03:10.355 --> 00:03:11.595
So, you know, you got to do it.

43
00:03:11.995 --> 00:03:15.016
It's the first crewed mission of the Artemis system.

44
00:03:15.496 --> 00:03:18.317
They tested the SLS rocket and the Orion spacecraft.

45
00:03:18.677 --> 00:03:22.599
Right now, as we are taping this, this is on Thursday, April 2nd,

46
00:03:24.159 --> 00:03:33.643
they have already completed their apogee rays burn, and they've done that high elliptical orbit where they go a little bit far away from the Earth and they test all those systems.

47
00:03:34.003 --> 00:03:40.826
Now they're on their way back, and if everything goes well, then tonight, in about three hours, they are going to go to the moon.

48
00:03:40.846 --> 00:03:41.426
They're going to...

49
00:03:42.868 --> 00:03:46.109
put their rocket launchers on, and go all the way to the moon.

50
00:03:46.289 --> 00:03:47.350
I am really excited.

51
00:03:47.710 --> 00:03:50.571
The crew, four veterans of space.

52
00:03:50.671 --> 00:03:55.053
Actually, no, I should say three veterans of space travel and one rookie.

53
00:03:55.613 --> 00:03:59.875
The three veterans are Reed Wiseman, Victor Glover, and Christina Koch from NASA.

54
00:04:00.335 --> 00:04:04.057
And the rookie is Jeremy Hansen from the Canadian Space Agency.

55
00:04:04.217 --> 00:04:04.797
Can you imagine?

56
00:04:04.877 --> 00:04:05.938
It is his first...

57
00:04:06.658 --> 00:04:10.160
It is his first time in space, and he is going straight to the moon.

58
00:04:10.200 --> 00:04:10.921
It's unbelievable.

59
00:04:11.101 --> 00:04:12.221
What a lucky guy.

60
00:04:12.241 --> 00:04:13.662
Yes, unbelievable.

61
00:04:13.882 --> 00:04:14.123
Yeah.

62
00:04:14.283 --> 00:04:18.805
And I think we have some good graphics here for what it's going to look like.

63
00:04:18.825 --> 00:04:19.065
Yes.

64
00:04:19.246 --> 00:04:26.430
I wanted to actually go through some of the graphics of how the Artemis mission is going to go to the moon because I think it's like –

65
00:04:26.910 --> 00:04:30.212
a really nice exercise in orbital dynamics physics.

66
00:04:30.593 --> 00:04:33.674
So if we go to the first graphic, this is from NASA.

67
00:04:33.715 --> 00:04:40.259
They're showing that Artemis does that apogee rays burn, and then it slingshots around Earth and goes to the moon.

68
00:04:40.659 --> 00:04:43.781
Now you can see the moon is still traveling with the Earth.

69
00:04:43.941 --> 00:04:45.402
It takes three days to get there.

70
00:04:46.163 --> 00:04:49.985
The Artemis is going to meet the moon, slingshot around Earth,

71
00:04:50.145 --> 00:04:51.546
and then return back to Earth.

72
00:04:52.567 --> 00:04:55.690
What I like about this is this is an Earth-centric view.

73
00:04:56.090 --> 00:05:02.156
Okay, so the moon is orbiting around the Earth, and Artemis is going to the moon and back, right?

74
00:05:02.556 --> 00:05:04.858
And the camera is sort of moving with the Earth.

75
00:05:04.918 --> 00:05:05.459
Now, the Earth...

76
00:05:05.619 --> 00:05:05.899
Yeah.

77
00:05:23.611 --> 00:05:30.355
What looks like it to me, when you first look at this thing, right, Artemis is going there, and then it just turns around.

78
00:05:30.495 --> 00:05:30.675
Yes.

79
00:05:30.995 --> 00:05:38.680
And if we notice, it seems like the moon is doing so much work to turn this spacecraft around and head it back to Earth.

80
00:05:38.860 --> 00:05:39.100
Right?

81
00:05:39.761 --> 00:05:43.443
Now let's look at our second video, and that is from the moon's position.

82
00:05:43.463 --> 00:05:47.465
So now the camera is moving with the moon, and you can see now Artemis is approaching.

83
00:05:47.625 --> 00:05:48.186
It's approaching.

84
00:05:48.226 --> 00:05:48.806
It's approaching.

85
00:05:49.627 --> 00:05:51.127
And it gets slightly deflected.

86
00:05:51.207 --> 00:05:51.808
Mm-hmm.

87
00:05:52.288 --> 00:05:55.269
The moon is actually not doing that much work.

88
00:05:55.529 --> 00:05:59.790
So how do you reconcile these two camera angles?

89
00:05:59.850 --> 00:06:03.551
From the camera angle of the Earth, it's like the moon just slingshotted it back.

90
00:06:03.591 --> 00:06:06.832
But from the moon's perspective, there's just a tiny bit correction.

91
00:06:07.092 --> 00:06:09.433
That kind of makes sense because the moon is not that big.

92
00:06:09.693 --> 00:06:11.033
So what exactly is happening?

93
00:06:12.774 --> 00:06:18.035
We've got to understand that when Artemis is going towards the moon, it does a single burn...

94
00:06:19.596 --> 00:06:21.156
And then it launches towards the moon, right?

95
00:06:22.117 --> 00:06:25.117
When it does that, it does that single burn, and then it turns off its engines.

96
00:06:25.758 --> 00:06:28.558
So it's still falling towards the Earth.

97
00:06:29.058 --> 00:06:39.901
It's like we threw a baseball up, and that baseball is going to have a really high velocity, but it's going to keep falling and reducing its velocity because the Earth keeps pulling on it.

98
00:06:40.321 --> 00:06:42.662
So if the moon wasn't there...

99
00:06:43.997 --> 00:06:50.584
Artemis would go all the way to the moon, go way over the moon's limit, but still return back to Earth.

100
00:06:50.624 --> 00:06:54.528
Because Artemis does not have escape velocity from the Earth.

101
00:06:54.648 --> 00:06:56.130
There's a gravitational pull.

102
00:06:56.210 --> 00:06:56.630
Exactly.

103
00:06:56.690 --> 00:06:58.712
So when we go back to the moon's perspective...

104
00:07:00.076 --> 00:07:05.440
Now you see why the moon, even a tiny bit of deflection, is enough to do that slingshot maneuver, right?

105
00:07:05.600 --> 00:07:08.462
Artemis is falling towards the Earth this whole time.

106
00:07:08.963 --> 00:07:14.747
All the moon is doing is just nudging it a little bit more to fall towards the Earth as Artemis goes around.

107
00:07:15.268 --> 00:07:19.671
It's kind of an interesting way to think about perspective in space, right?

108
00:07:19.731 --> 00:07:26.056
It's like Artemis would still return back to Earth, but the moon is just there to kind of have that slingshot.

109
00:07:26.196 --> 00:07:27.137
Just a tiny bit more.

110
00:07:27.817 --> 00:07:34.099
So one of the things we covered in our Artemis episode that we previously did a deep dive on.

111
00:07:34.119 --> 00:07:37.059
So if you want more information on this, we've actually covered this previously.

112
00:07:37.099 --> 00:07:39.120
But the launch is super relevant.

113
00:07:39.160 --> 00:07:41.020
And I know we have one more graphic to show here.

114
00:07:42.400 --> 00:07:51.283
So the first major question you see in every comment thread on every NASA account is, oh, we're going back to the moon, but why aren't we landing?

115
00:07:51.743 --> 00:07:54.503
And this is something we did cover at length in the long form.

116
00:07:58.404 --> 00:07:59.925
We did Apollo in the 60s.

117
00:08:01.046 --> 00:08:02.567
We have not done anything similar.

118
00:08:03.527 --> 00:08:12.452
The first point I want to bring up is that low Earth orbit and going to the moon is the distances are just fundamentally very different.

119
00:08:12.472 --> 00:08:12.732
Oh, yeah.

120
00:08:12.852 --> 00:08:13.232
Insane.

121
00:08:13.592 --> 00:08:18.215
We've got 200,000 miles to the moon and low Earth orbit is like 100 miles.

122
00:08:18.275 --> 00:08:18.455
Right.

123
00:08:18.515 --> 00:08:18.935
Tops.

124
00:08:19.155 --> 00:08:19.356
Right.

125
00:08:19.656 --> 00:08:19.876
Right.

126
00:08:20.116 --> 00:08:21.897
So it's just these are just different.

127
00:08:21.937 --> 00:08:22.117
Yeah.

128
00:08:22.177 --> 00:08:23.758
Like several orders of magnitude.

129
00:08:23.778 --> 00:08:23.878
Yeah.

130
00:08:23.978 --> 00:08:24.118
Right.

131
00:08:24.158 --> 00:08:24.659
You can run.

132
00:08:24.879 --> 00:08:28.341
If you can be good at a 5K, that doesn't mean you're going to be good at an ultra marathon.

133
00:08:28.381 --> 00:08:28.602
Yeah.

134
00:08:28.902 --> 00:08:29.963
You need different training.

135
00:08:30.083 --> 00:08:30.183
Yeah.

136
00:08:30.203 --> 00:08:33.665
You need different diet, body mechanics, all these things.

137
00:08:33.725 --> 00:08:34.746
And this isn't even a 5K.

138
00:08:35.607 --> 00:08:36.327
I think it's closer.

139
00:08:36.367 --> 00:08:41.251
Like, it's like a 400 meter relay versus a marathon.

140
00:08:41.311 --> 00:08:41.491
Right.

141
00:08:41.511 --> 00:08:41.691
Right.

142
00:08:41.892 --> 00:08:42.092
Right.

143
00:08:42.352 --> 00:08:42.572
Right.

144
00:08:43.052 --> 00:08:45.034
So pretty insane.

145
00:08:45.454 --> 00:08:52.239
And part of the reason why, again, we're not landing is the analogy I brought up when we did the long form episode is,

146
00:08:53.080 --> 00:09:00.683
If you're the Dallas Cowboys, the football team, and you won so many Super Bowls decades ago, that doesn't mean you're going to win Super Bowls today.

147
00:09:00.943 --> 00:09:01.144
No.

148
00:09:01.284 --> 00:09:08.887
You have different personnel, different coaching, different financial incentives, and knowledge is lost when you don't continue.

149
00:09:09.367 --> 00:09:16.730
You have dynasties because you have the same coach coming back with the same training staff, the same offensive, defensive coordinators, and you're able to build that muscle memory.

150
00:09:17.090 --> 00:09:20.272
When you have decades that go past, we just don't actually have...

151
00:09:20.952 --> 00:09:21.532
The tools.

152
00:09:22.072 --> 00:09:27.315
Also with Apollo at the time, we did several of these exact same types of missions.

153
00:09:27.335 --> 00:09:28.535
Yeah.

154
00:09:28.555 --> 00:09:32.037
Making sure we can get into lower orbit, then making sure we can get around into the orbit of the moon.

155
00:09:32.297 --> 00:09:36.699
But always coming back before we ultimately landed the rover.

156
00:09:36.899 --> 00:09:39.600
And this time around, we're just doing literally...

157
00:09:40.220 --> 00:09:41.261
The same process.

158
00:09:41.301 --> 00:09:41.502
Yeah.

159
00:09:41.802 --> 00:09:46.869
It's why it's Artemis 2, because 3 and 4 are ultimately going to get us to that landing spot.

160
00:09:47.089 --> 00:09:53.417
While we relearn with newer tools, newer systems, a new gaffer coach, a new personnel, all these things.

161
00:09:53.497 --> 00:09:56.121
And just to continue on that point, with Apollo, right—

162
00:09:56.601 --> 00:09:59.543
Apollo 8 and Apollo 10 went to the moon and never landed.

163
00:09:59.643 --> 00:09:59.843
Right.

164
00:09:59.963 --> 00:10:04.265
Because you got to make sure you can get there and also scope out sort of a parking spot.

165
00:10:04.586 --> 00:10:05.486
That's what they're doing here.

166
00:10:05.846 --> 00:10:11.289
They're going towards the back of the moon because they want to scope out a parking spot about where to land for Apollo 3.

167
00:10:11.750 --> 00:10:12.590
Sorry, Artemis 3.

168
00:10:12.730 --> 00:10:16.212
Maybe also check out what the Chinese are doing on the dark side of the moon, which we can't see.

169
00:10:16.512 --> 00:10:16.832
Right.

170
00:10:17.092 --> 00:10:17.493
From Earth.

171
00:10:17.513 --> 00:10:17.833
Right.

172
00:10:18.093 --> 00:10:19.134
Yeah.

173
00:10:19.334 --> 00:10:31.459
And just to linger on that point, actually, with the dark side of the moon, right, one of the big things is that Artemis is going to go around the moon and see that dark side, which hasn't been seen by astronauts in a very long time.

174
00:10:33.220 --> 00:10:41.504
Right now, as of the taping of this episode, so Thursday, April 2nd, one day after the launch, the moon has a full moon phase.

175
00:10:42.085 --> 00:10:43.825
The moon is a full moon in the sky, right?

176
00:10:43.885 --> 00:10:46.787
But what that means is the dark side of the moon is completely dark.

177
00:10:47.416 --> 00:10:47.636
Okay.

178
00:10:47.937 --> 00:10:55.449
In three days, it's going to be a waning gibbous, which means that most like, you know, 70% of the moon is going to be light for us.

179
00:10:56.150 --> 00:10:59.256
But when they get to the other side of the moon, it's going to be like pretty dark.

180
00:10:59.897 --> 00:11:01.099
There's going to be a line, though.

181
00:11:02.195 --> 00:11:04.196
Where they're going to see a crescent.

182
00:11:04.897 --> 00:11:06.237
The moon is going to be kind of a crescent.

183
00:11:06.257 --> 00:11:08.158
Because part of it is going to be lit up by the sun.

184
00:11:08.478 --> 00:11:09.599
But the rest is going to be dark.

185
00:11:10.039 --> 00:11:12.020
And I had a naive question.

186
00:11:13.161 --> 00:11:15.182
Shouldn't you time it so that it's a new moon?

187
00:11:15.342 --> 00:11:17.243
That way the dark side of the moon is lit up.

188
00:11:17.704 --> 00:11:17.904
Right?

189
00:11:18.744 --> 00:11:19.264
I looked it up.

190
00:11:19.645 --> 00:11:20.905
It's a pretty clever...

191
00:11:22.306 --> 00:11:23.367
timing that they've done.

192
00:11:23.988 --> 00:11:27.132
The reason is, if you've ever been to the Grand Canyon, have you been to the Grand Canyon?

193
00:11:27.152 --> 00:11:27.453
I have not.

194
00:11:27.613 --> 00:11:27.853
Okay.

195
00:11:28.274 --> 00:11:29.315
But you definitely should.

196
00:11:29.335 --> 00:11:31.157
It's one of the greatest places on Earth, by the way.

197
00:11:31.838 --> 00:11:36.845
But if you go to the Grand Canyon, the best pictures are taken at sunrise and sunset.

198
00:11:36.865 --> 00:11:36.945
Hmm.

199
00:11:37.405 --> 00:11:37.685
Okay.

200
00:11:37.985 --> 00:11:38.205
Why?

201
00:11:38.245 --> 00:11:42.106
Because there's shadows and shadows give you a profile of the canyon.

202
00:11:42.146 --> 00:11:43.186
That's actually okay.

203
00:11:43.246 --> 00:11:43.566
Okay.

204
00:11:44.027 --> 00:11:57.530
If you go when it's fully light or if you take photos of the Grand Canyon, when the sun is overhead, the photos don't look so good because you don't get that contrast between shadows and you can't really tell topographically the terrain that well.

205
00:11:57.910 --> 00:12:05.192
So they want to go when they're at a cusp between light and dark, because that's when we can see terrain really, really well.

206
00:12:05.512 --> 00:12:07.132
Especially if we're looking for a parking spot.

207
00:12:08.353 --> 00:12:36.674
being able to understand what the surface looks like matters and this is a more ideal circumstance so in three days when they get there there's actually going to be a line they're going to see a crescent on the dark side and that's when they can really see craters and things like that really really well so I thought that was really cool the final thing that I wanted to talk about was the problems that they've been having I think their toilet broke but I think they fixed it so that's good because that would be definitely I want to go home right

208
00:12:37.575 --> 00:12:38.378
I like the moon.

209
00:12:39.301 --> 00:12:42.691
The moon is great, but like, yo, the toilet is broken.

210
00:12:44.100 --> 00:12:44.440
Come on.

211
00:12:44.740 --> 00:12:44.941
No.

212
00:12:45.161 --> 00:12:45.861
I want to go home.

213
00:12:45.881 --> 00:12:46.181
That's tough.

214
00:12:46.201 --> 00:12:46.642
That's tough.

215
00:12:46.782 --> 00:12:47.482
I want to go home.

216
00:12:48.123 --> 00:12:50.404
When that happens at an Airbnb, I get a hotel.

217
00:12:50.465 --> 00:12:50.845
Yeah.

218
00:12:50.925 --> 00:12:51.145
Right?

219
00:12:51.605 --> 00:12:52.286
I'm not staying.

220
00:12:53.006 --> 00:12:57.870
And then I will petition Airbnb for a discount or whatever later.

221
00:12:58.130 --> 00:12:59.451
So they fixed the toilet.

222
00:12:59.491 --> 00:13:00.091
So that's good.

223
00:13:00.892 --> 00:13:04.274
The next thing that broke, though, was their Microsoft applications.

224
00:13:04.635 --> 00:13:09.198
So astronauts just like us use Microsoft and Outlook.

225
00:13:09.418 --> 00:13:09.558
Yeah.

226
00:13:09.718 --> 00:13:10.819
Apparently was not working.

227
00:13:10.839 --> 00:13:18.806
If you go to the news, Artemis 2 astronauts find two Outlook instances running on their computers.

228
00:13:19.386 --> 00:13:22.969
And they had to call Houston to fix it because they couldn't open Outlook.

229
00:13:23.109 --> 00:13:27.093
And so Houston had to remote into their computer to figure out what was going on.

230
00:13:27.473 --> 00:13:29.415
I don't know if, like, NASA uses Teams.

231
00:13:30.035 --> 00:13:35.180
But anyone who's used Microsoft Teams knows that it is probably the worst thing.

232
00:13:35.660 --> 00:13:38.541
tool ever, but yet we're just stuck with it.

233
00:13:38.822 --> 00:13:46.085
And I guess NASA is also stuck with outdated Microsoft applications on a computer that's going to the moon.

234
00:13:46.345 --> 00:13:46.626
Yes.

235
00:13:46.946 --> 00:13:54.109
I don't know that I don't think this is proprietary information, but I work at Disney Streaming, and they had to move from Slack to Teams.

236
00:13:54.169 --> 00:13:54.810
To Teams?

237
00:13:54.910 --> 00:13:55.630
Oh my gosh.

238
00:13:55.650 --> 00:13:57.091
You can imagine how fun that was.

239
00:13:57.611 --> 00:13:57.971
Oh, dude.

240
00:13:58.231 --> 00:13:58.752
Oh my god.

241
00:13:58.852 --> 00:13:59.412
It's incredible.

242
00:13:59.452 --> 00:14:01.933
Microsoft continuing to cause problems, even in space.

243
00:14:02.033 --> 00:14:02.694
Even in space.

244
00:14:02.874 --> 00:14:03.274
Even in space.

245
00:14:03.294 --> 00:14:04.875
We're trying to go to the moon, and

246
00:14:05.515 --> 00:14:05.995
Outlook?

247
00:14:06.516 --> 00:14:06.936
Outlook?

248
00:14:07.256 --> 00:14:07.596
Really?

249
00:14:08.396 --> 00:14:24.824
Another just brief fun fact that I'll touch on is a lot of people have been commenting on the difference in the quality of the media capture on the launch, right, versus SpaceX, which is in Blue Origin, which have been the commercial space that we've seen so far.

250
00:14:25.504 --> 00:14:28.027
And this kind of just goes back to a couple of different things, right?

251
00:14:28.107 --> 00:14:29.268
The purposes are different.

252
00:14:30.609 --> 00:14:31.570
Funding is different.

253
00:14:33.032 --> 00:14:38.877
The sales aspect for the commercial airliners, space companies, matters a lot.

254
00:14:38.998 --> 00:14:39.198
Yeah.

255
00:14:39.298 --> 00:14:42.641
And so that is their product, is showing off the thing actually in space.

256
00:14:42.881 --> 00:14:43.842
They invest heavily in that.

257
00:14:43.862 --> 00:14:47.005
They also have now a network of stuff they can use up there to do so.

258
00:14:47.666 --> 00:14:47.826
And –

259
00:14:48.727 --> 00:14:59.150
When we're crunched for budgets in NASA, which have gotten even more crunched in the current administration, the money for the media budget is the first thing to go.

260
00:14:59.230 --> 00:14:59.470
Yeah.

261
00:14:59.670 --> 00:15:05.331
And while you can focus on life support systems and things that are mission critical, safety, et cetera, et cetera.

262
00:15:05.351 --> 00:15:07.232
So this is why funding in science.

263
00:15:07.492 --> 00:15:08.372
You want good stuff?

264
00:15:08.432 --> 00:15:10.252
Tell them to stop defunding NASA.

265
00:15:10.593 --> 00:15:11.693
They also gave the...

266
00:15:12.753 --> 00:15:30.244
astronauts iphone 17 pro maxes okay to take photos while they're like like non science related just fun photos while they're up there as well so i'd be curious to see uh what those look like yeah i wonder if they have any photos of them fixing the toilet

267
00:15:32.955 --> 00:15:33.996
That's got to be fun.

268
00:15:34.036 --> 00:15:35.076
I wonder who had to do it.

269
00:15:35.517 --> 00:15:37.518
I bet it was the rookie Canadian.

270
00:15:37.538 --> 00:15:37.738
100%.

271
00:15:37.758 --> 00:15:38.358
It has to be.

272
00:15:38.378 --> 00:15:39.299
It has to be.

273
00:15:39.859 --> 00:15:40.800
You haven't been here yet.

274
00:15:40.840 --> 00:15:41.420
Yeah.

275
00:15:41.801 --> 00:15:42.841
This is your first time.

276
00:15:42.861 --> 00:15:43.582
This is your first time.

277
00:15:43.622 --> 00:15:44.682
You got to get a little hazing.

278
00:15:44.782 --> 00:15:45.543
Yeah.

279
00:15:46.003 --> 00:15:48.645
So it's great to see the Artemis launch finally happen again.

280
00:15:48.685 --> 00:15:49.986
We have our model behind us.

281
00:15:50.026 --> 00:15:51.807
We did a deep dive episode previously.

282
00:15:52.167 --> 00:15:59.852
So if you want a little bit more detail on actually what's happening, I will note the other last thing is they've actually changed the timing of Artemis 3 and 4.

283
00:16:00.213 --> 00:16:03.795
It looks like the goal now is mid-2027 for Artemis 3.

284
00:16:04.135 --> 00:16:07.438
And then 2028 is when we're going to go to the moon.

285
00:16:08.679 --> 00:16:14.663
Some astute observers have sort of made the note that that is a very aggressive timeline.

286
00:16:14.683 --> 00:16:15.183
Yeah.

287
00:16:15.603 --> 00:16:20.608
There is a new head of NASA who's a private business type.

288
00:16:20.788 --> 00:16:21.669
Jared Isaacman?

289
00:16:21.729 --> 00:16:21.969
Yes.

290
00:16:22.029 --> 00:16:22.409
Yeah.

291
00:16:22.470 --> 00:16:28.755
And more of the Elon prototype versus a more research scientist type of prototype.

292
00:16:28.895 --> 00:16:29.095
Yeah.

293
00:16:29.216 --> 00:16:32.218
We will see what transpires.

294
00:16:32.358 --> 00:16:33.940
I do think it is an aggressive timeline.

295
00:16:33.980 --> 00:16:34.080
Yeah.

296
00:16:34.180 --> 00:16:38.402
I think it's an aggressive timeline, but I think it's also correct.

297
00:16:38.542 --> 00:16:39.843
I think we need to be aggressive.

298
00:16:40.203 --> 00:16:40.543
I agree.

299
00:16:40.684 --> 00:16:40.884
Yeah.

300
00:16:41.004 --> 00:16:41.784
I agree with you.

301
00:16:41.844 --> 00:16:42.424
Yeah, I agree.

302
00:16:42.525 --> 00:16:44.546
Look, we all know who's coming for it.

303
00:16:44.586 --> 00:16:45.326
Yeah, we got to go.

304
00:16:45.486 --> 00:16:46.106
We got to go.

305
00:16:46.146 --> 00:16:46.827
We got to go now.

306
00:16:47.027 --> 00:16:47.227
Yes.

307
00:16:47.267 --> 00:16:48.128
We got to make it happen.

308
00:16:48.148 --> 00:16:48.308
Yes.

309
00:16:48.768 --> 00:17:01.275
If you've seen For All Mankind, you've literally seen this story before, and that's exactly what's happening is there's a clear geopolitical incentive by all of the spacefaring nations that the moon is –

310
00:17:02.835 --> 00:17:04.136
a strategic asset.

311
00:17:04.656 --> 00:17:16.819
And whoever gets there first has free roam to establish, again, where is the helium-3, where potential ice and water deposits, all this stuff is going to matter.

312
00:17:17.239 --> 00:17:22.100
And if you're there first, it's hard for the other people to get into those locations.

313
00:17:22.220 --> 00:17:22.800
Exactly.

314
00:17:22.940 --> 00:17:28.581
It's a crude analogy, and I understand that it's not perfect because of the history of colonialism and everything.

315
00:17:28.701 --> 00:17:30.842
But if I may, I'd like to...

316
00:17:31.744 --> 00:17:34.385
compare this to the conquest of the new world.

317
00:17:34.425 --> 00:17:34.705
Yeah.

318
00:17:34.785 --> 00:17:35.025
Right.

319
00:17:36.245 --> 00:17:45.247
Apparently the Norwegians were here in like 700 years to 400 years before Christopher Columbus came and the rest of the European nations.

320
00:17:45.307 --> 00:17:45.587
Right.

321
00:17:46.127 --> 00:17:50.188
But the Norwegians are not, we don't speak Norwegian.

322
00:17:50.388 --> 00:17:50.548
Right.

323
00:17:51.048 --> 00:17:51.568
In America.

324
00:17:51.828 --> 00:17:52.049
Right.

325
00:17:52.689 --> 00:17:58.390
We don't even speak Spanish because even though the British were like second to, I think probably fifth,

326
00:17:59.649 --> 00:18:04.954
They had the resources to build colonies, right, in this continent, in at least North America.

327
00:18:05.254 --> 00:18:13.762
So if history has anything to say about this, we need to be there and we need to go there and we need to, like, actually stay and make a presence.

328
00:18:14.886 --> 00:18:15.546
Absolutely.

329
00:18:15.686 --> 00:18:22.570
And the last note to your point is as a part of the recent changes at NASA, they've canceled all the Mars related stuff.

330
00:18:22.770 --> 00:18:23.010
Yeah.

331
00:18:23.110 --> 00:18:26.832
And now we're saying instead of doing basically a moon base.

332
00:18:27.052 --> 00:18:27.272
Yeah.

333
00:18:27.432 --> 00:18:28.273
Is now the priority.

334
00:18:28.373 --> 00:18:28.993
Yeah.

335
00:18:29.113 --> 00:18:30.134
And I also get that.

336
00:18:30.194 --> 00:18:30.334
Right.

337
00:18:30.394 --> 00:18:31.154
It's like Mars.

338
00:18:31.174 --> 00:18:31.855
We've done a lot.

339
00:18:32.155 --> 00:18:33.876
And also there's still like rovers.

340
00:18:34.416 --> 00:18:36.357
Somehow JPL is so amazing.

341
00:18:36.417 --> 00:18:37.097
Incredible.

342
00:18:37.177 --> 00:18:41.740
That like they plan for a two year rover and then it's still going like 15 years later.

343
00:18:41.760 --> 00:18:41.880
Right.

344
00:18:41.900 --> 00:18:42.060
Right.

345
00:18:42.220 --> 00:18:43.781
Like the wheels are broken and everything.

346
00:18:43.801 --> 00:18:46.262
I was like, no, I still got it.

347
00:18:46.543 --> 00:18:47.643
Still got it.

348
00:18:48.224 --> 00:18:49.945
So, yeah, I get it.

349
00:18:50.125 --> 00:18:52.366
And I'm looking forward to the next few years.

350
00:18:52.426 --> 00:18:58.850
I think it's going to be an amazing era for space exploration, for mankind in general.

351
00:18:59.050 --> 00:19:03.052
I can't wait for in about a few days if everything goes well and they do go to the moon.

352
00:19:03.412 --> 00:19:08.976
We're going to be able to look at the moon and cover it up with our thumb and be like, there are like four people.

353
00:19:09.056 --> 00:19:09.456
Right there.

354
00:19:09.676 --> 00:19:09.996
There.

355
00:19:10.136 --> 00:19:10.297
Yeah.

356
00:19:10.517 --> 00:19:11.217
Like right now.

357
00:19:11.337 --> 00:19:11.478
Yeah.

358
00:19:11.538 --> 00:19:20.625
And they will be looking at the earth and they'll be able to cover it up with their thumb and be like, everyone except for four people are behind my thumb.

359
00:19:20.725 --> 00:19:21.846
It's, it's so.

360
00:19:21.946 --> 00:19:22.987
It's going to be incredible.

361
00:19:23.207 --> 00:19:24.888
It's like living in the 1970s.

362
00:19:24.909 --> 00:19:28.832
Like, imagine looking at the moon and being like, there's like four people there right now.

363
00:19:29.052 --> 00:19:29.252
Right.

364
00:19:30.253 --> 00:19:30.813
Fascinating.

365
00:19:30.993 --> 00:19:32.295
Always been a big lover of space.

366
00:19:32.355 --> 00:19:32.655
Yeah.

367
00:19:32.755 --> 00:19:33.816
That's something we both share.

368
00:19:33.836 --> 00:19:34.576
It's going to be amazing.

369
00:19:34.616 --> 00:19:36.838
So we'll see as things continue to progress.

370
00:19:37.459 --> 00:19:38.339
If you have.

371
00:19:38.359 --> 00:19:38.980
Yeah.

372
00:19:39.160 --> 00:19:44.563
If you are a debunker about the moon landing, go watch our debunking video we already did and comment there.

373
00:19:45.564 --> 00:19:47.165
Moving on to our story number two.

374
00:19:48.065 --> 00:19:53.789
Anthropic accidentally leaked part of Claude Code's internal source code.

375
00:19:53.909 --> 00:19:58.552
So this, for those who may not know, Anthropic is one of the sort of primary...

376
00:19:59.072 --> 00:20:07.538
AI model creators along with Google's deep mind, open AI, Facebook's meta, whatever they're doing over there.

377
00:20:07.858 --> 00:20:26.010
There's a European player that no one ever talks about, but you know, these foundation models, the brains behind the chat based AI generative AI revolution we've seen have been crown jewels and is basically what the entire U S economy in terms of GDP growth in the last year or two is effectively based on.

378
00:20:26.050 --> 00:20:26.291
So yeah,

379
00:20:27.011 --> 00:20:32.174
Whether you like it or not, our financial futures are kind of pegged to this stuff being successful in some way.

380
00:20:32.814 --> 00:20:39.978
But Anthropic just had a pretty embarrassing AI security issue, which has been a little bit overhyped in the headlines.

381
00:20:40.058 --> 00:20:40.298
Okay.

382
00:20:40.398 --> 00:20:42.299
But it's still somewhat significant.

383
00:20:43.280 --> 00:20:44.561
So Claude Code.

384
00:20:44.941 --> 00:20:46.462
So if we think about the structure, we have...

385
00:20:47.022 --> 00:20:54.025
Claude is the model, the actual brains that responds to you when you type into claude.com and get it back.

386
00:20:54.065 --> 00:20:55.025
This is an LLM?

387
00:20:55.045 --> 00:20:56.025
That's LLM, right.

388
00:20:56.046 --> 00:20:57.666
It's where all the model weights are.

389
00:20:57.706 --> 00:21:02.188
It's where they do all this really expensive training to make these things super smart.

390
00:21:02.208 --> 00:21:09.831
They're basically growing the intellectual response that we get when they train these models.

391
00:21:10.091 --> 00:21:12.272
But Claude Code is simply a...

392
00:21:13.052 --> 00:21:39.700
interface and orchestrator for an architecture for you specifically initially for coding software coding but has now evolved into what they call co-work uh as well for people who do things like financial modeling uh deck creation other just business related functions they all live within this thing called the cloud code application you can either have it as a terminal or on the cloud desktop app okay now

393
00:21:40.760 --> 00:21:44.383
Initially, this leak was reported on March 31st.

394
00:21:45.564 --> 00:21:48.827
And how it happened was...

395
00:21:49.328 --> 00:21:51.569
This is a little bit in the weeds, so I'll kind of keep it topical.

396
00:21:52.570 --> 00:21:53.831
There was a release of...

397
00:21:54.747 --> 00:22:08.230
a new version of Cloud Code, and on NPM, which is a package managing platform, there was a small addendum that was added by one of their internal developers that had a 60-megabyte JavaScript source map.

398
00:22:08.870 --> 00:22:14.072
And basically you were able to use that to reconstruct the entire TypeScript project.

399
00:22:14.392 --> 00:22:23.354
So people were able to basically get 500,000 lines of the actual code base that is what Cloud Code is across roughly 1,900 files.

400
00:22:24.937 --> 00:22:25.845
And what was...

401
00:22:27.423 --> 00:22:52.788
fascinating to see was Korean developers, when they woke up, saw that this had happened, immediately pulled the package down, rebuilt Cloud Code, released it as basically a free open source version on GitHub, and it was the fastest growing repo on GitHub in history, reaching 50,000 stars in two hours, 100,000 in the first day, and it just exploded like wildfire.

402
00:22:53.088 --> 00:22:56.449
I think part of that was because people were confusing the model

403
00:22:57.533 --> 00:22:58.493
For Claude Code.

404
00:22:58.733 --> 00:22:59.513
Oh, okay, I see.

405
00:22:59.754 --> 00:23:01.994
So they thought, oh, we just got the weights.

406
00:23:02.234 --> 00:23:02.614
Correct.

407
00:23:02.794 --> 00:23:04.215
Oh, my God, the weights are public.

408
00:23:04.235 --> 00:23:04.495
Correct.

409
00:23:04.555 --> 00:23:05.095
Okay, got it.

410
00:23:05.215 --> 00:23:05.475
Okay.

411
00:23:05.575 --> 00:23:07.855
Early on, people were like, oh, the weights went out.

412
00:23:07.875 --> 00:23:10.256
But it really is just that Claude Code.

413
00:23:10.296 --> 00:23:10.496
Right.

414
00:23:10.756 --> 00:23:12.637
They still have the crown jewels.

415
00:23:12.997 --> 00:23:15.717
And the irony of this story, there's a couple of things.

416
00:23:16.017 --> 00:23:19.838
It was basically an internal developer who screwed up with the release package.

417
00:23:19.878 --> 00:23:20.978
Yeah, someone's getting fired.

418
00:23:21.039 --> 00:23:22.599
They already got fired, and they tweeted about it.

419
00:23:22.659 --> 00:23:23.279
Oh, okay, great.

420
00:23:23.319 --> 00:23:25.079
It's already on Twitter or X or whatever.

421
00:23:25.139 --> 00:23:25.340
Yeah.

422
00:23:25.520 --> 00:23:26.320
And so that went out.

423
00:23:28.040 --> 00:23:34.103
I think it's the speed in this space is astronomical.

424
00:23:34.724 --> 00:23:35.744
That is interesting.

425
00:23:35.764 --> 00:23:43.749
In a day, basically, developers are able to wake up, recreate it, not only in, they did it in like- Probably using cloud code.

426
00:23:43.909 --> 00:23:44.589
Exactly, exactly.

427
00:23:44.889 --> 00:23:50.396
And they recreated, I think, in JavaScript and then just built a version in Rust like immediately.

428
00:23:50.836 --> 00:23:58.285
And it's the ingenuity of developers now and because they have coding assistant tools, things can move very, very quickly.

429
00:23:58.305 --> 00:23:59.306
Wow, that's incredible.

430
00:23:59.667 --> 00:24:02.750
And so the wrapper around the model leaked, not the core model.

431
00:24:02.790 --> 00:24:03.872
Not the core model, okay.

432
00:24:04.192 --> 00:24:14.657
But the other irony for Anthropic is when you look at the personalities of all the between Google, OpenAI, and Anthropic is the top three, arguably.

433
00:24:15.037 --> 00:24:17.638
Anthropic has been very heavy on the sort of AI safety.

434
00:24:18.199 --> 00:24:22.061
You know, we are focused on that piece and security and all this matters.

435
00:24:22.541 --> 00:24:31.025
So for them to have be the first ones to have such a catastrophic leak of something fundamental, it's not really good for the brand.

436
00:24:31.085 --> 00:24:31.325
Mm-hmm.

437
00:24:32.246 --> 00:24:39.171
especially when OpenAI just finished closing their highest, the highest funding round, venture capital funding round.

438
00:24:39.191 --> 00:24:44.796
I think it was $122 billion in the history of funding ever, literally like a day or two before this happened.

439
00:24:45.176 --> 00:24:46.657
So the race is on.

440
00:24:47.918 --> 00:24:53.703
No, you're not just going to get, you know, clawed on your computer by default, but, you know,

441
00:24:54.263 --> 00:25:09.252
Cloud code is quite nice, and there's a lot of interesting insights in how they set up the harness around the model to make it practical that is going to continue to be used by developers outside of just using their tools.

442
00:25:09.272 --> 00:25:09.372
Yeah.

443
00:25:10.773 --> 00:25:19.058
I mean, I'm sure by now there's probably like a dedicated team at OpenAI that is like, what's the best part of this that we can put into ours?

444
00:25:19.359 --> 00:25:19.759
I'm sure.

445
00:25:20.539 --> 00:25:20.960
I'm sure.

446
00:25:21.380 --> 00:25:22.401
And it's funny.

447
00:25:22.421 --> 00:25:29.986
There's like an undercover mode or something that was a part of the leaked code base that was specifically a tool to prevent this stuff from happening.

448
00:25:30.006 --> 00:25:30.566
Oh, hilarious.

449
00:25:30.886 --> 00:25:31.927
And clearly that did work.

450
00:25:31.987 --> 00:25:33.448
And that also got leaked.

451
00:25:33.508 --> 00:25:33.848
Jesus.

452
00:25:33.908 --> 00:25:34.448
Yeah.

453
00:25:35.529 --> 00:25:37.450
So tough day for Dario Amadei.

454
00:25:37.991 --> 00:25:39.011
Keep fighting the good fight.

455
00:25:39.451 --> 00:25:41.092
AI safety is important.

456
00:25:41.413 --> 00:25:43.254
Operational security is also important.

457
00:25:43.894 --> 00:25:44.955
So that's our story number two.

458
00:25:44.995 --> 00:25:47.676
I'm going to take a brief pause for some show notes.

459
00:25:48.237 --> 00:25:53.460
If you love the show, everything you can do to support us is helpful, whether that's a like, a share, or a comment.

460
00:25:53.960 --> 00:26:00.609
Bringing us up at Journal Club, the billionaire algorithm, we have to continue to fight to get awareness and relevance.

461
00:26:00.649 --> 00:26:04.053
And all of that engagement really helps us get seen by more people.

462
00:26:04.394 --> 00:26:07.678
It continues to just be the two of us who are running this podcast.

463
00:26:07.978 --> 00:26:09.841
No advertisers at this moment in time.

464
00:26:10.401 --> 00:26:10.641
Right.

465
00:26:10.821 --> 00:26:12.342
We're doing it for the love of the game.

466
00:26:12.522 --> 00:26:12.742
Yeah.

467
00:26:12.802 --> 00:26:18.966
And so if you want to support us financially, you can go to FFPPod.com backslash donate.

468
00:26:19.266 --> 00:26:22.368
And that is the place in which you can help support us in that way.

469
00:26:22.668 --> 00:26:24.169
But enough of all that nonsense.

470
00:26:24.409 --> 00:26:26.690
Let's move to our third story.

471
00:26:27.030 --> 00:26:30.152
So our third story is about a new science paper out in science.

472
00:26:30.172 --> 00:26:30.592
Yeah.

473
00:26:30.732 --> 00:26:37.315
that suggests that cats may be one of the best real-world models for human cancer and studying human cancer.

474
00:26:38.336 --> 00:26:45.519
It sounds a bit weird, but when you think about it, at the end of the day, it's all about animal models.

475
00:26:46.080 --> 00:26:47.760
And we talk about this a lot on the podcast.

476
00:26:47.780 --> 00:26:58.566
The fact that when we do biomedical research, a lot of times we're looking for a model of a certain disease or a certain ailment, and we want to replicate that in some kind of...

477
00:26:59.949 --> 00:27:02.931
animal that we study, that we can study in great detail.

478
00:27:02.991 --> 00:27:05.093
A lot of time that has to do with rodents, right?

479
00:27:05.193 --> 00:27:09.015
Rodents are the bread and butter of a lot of biomedical labs.

480
00:27:09.896 --> 00:27:19.622
But rodents don't get cancer the same way that humans do, because they are not exposed naturally to the kind of carcinogens that humans are in day-to-day life.

481
00:27:20.543 --> 00:27:24.045
So you have to induce cancer, you have to give them genetic mutations.

482
00:27:24.405 --> 00:27:24.986
Now, that...

483
00:27:25.798 --> 00:27:30.903
obviously has a lot of benefits, and there's a lot of incredible cancer research that goes on there.

484
00:27:31.204 --> 00:27:32.585
But there's parts that are missing.

485
00:27:33.446 --> 00:27:35.228
It turns out domesticated cats...

486
00:27:36.560 --> 00:27:42.925
live with human beings and are exposed to the same type of carcinogens that we are as human beings.

487
00:27:43.365 --> 00:27:52.051
And so the types of cancer that cats get, domesticated cats, are very similar to the types of cancers that humans get.

488
00:27:52.352 --> 00:28:00.918
And so if we can study how domesticated cats get cancer, their genomes, their oncogenomes is what we should say, because this is specific to...

489
00:28:01.438 --> 00:28:09.281
the genomics represented in the tumors, in the cancer tumors, those are going to have all these different types of mutations that cause the cancer.

490
00:28:10.261 --> 00:28:16.924
If we can study that, that can then supplement a lot of the other research that's happening with cancer.

491
00:28:16.984 --> 00:28:19.485
And that is what this particular paper is doing.

492
00:28:19.745 --> 00:28:25.807
The paper was published in Science called The Oncogenome of the Domesticated Cat, which

493
00:28:27.108 --> 00:28:37.196
It's from a bunch of collaborators, the University of Bern, from Cornell, from the Ontario Veterinary College, and from the Wellcome Sanger Institute.

494
00:28:38.057 --> 00:28:41.499
The researchers effectively sequenced about 500 individuals.

495
00:28:42.320 --> 00:28:45.281
500 cat tumor and normal tissue pairs.

496
00:28:45.421 --> 00:28:51.362
So you get, you know, the tissue from the tumor and you get the tissue from the normal part of the cat.

497
00:28:51.803 --> 00:28:53.903
And so then you can compare what the mutations were.

498
00:28:54.283 --> 00:29:03.086
This is very similar to that story that we did of the guy in Australia who built an mRNA vaccine for his dog's cancer.

499
00:29:03.666 --> 00:29:04.606
He did the same thing, right?

500
00:29:04.646 --> 00:29:11.048
He sequenced the normal genome and the genome of the tumor to find out how to target that tumor.

501
00:29:11.068 --> 00:29:11.208
Yeah.

502
00:29:12.048 --> 00:29:19.190
In this case, it's 500 pairs of genomes from 13 different tumor types.

503
00:29:19.610 --> 00:29:24.352
It's the first large-scale genomic atlas of cancer in domesticated cats.

504
00:29:24.812 --> 00:29:27.613
Obviously, this helps cats and vets more.

505
00:29:29.133 --> 00:29:30.955
understand how cats get cancer.

506
00:29:31.335 --> 00:29:38.180
But what I really like about this is this idea of the one medicine or one health approach.

507
00:29:38.620 --> 00:29:39.561
That's the big idea.

508
00:29:40.002 --> 00:29:49.409
It's the fact that veterinary medicine and human medicine should not be treated as completely separate, siloed parts of medicine.

509
00:29:49.809 --> 00:29:56.054
Because cancer at the end of the day, if you look at a big picture, right, cancer is a genomic disease.

510
00:29:59.016 --> 00:30:07.605
And if we can study multiple species that get similar types of cancer, then we can study invariants that...

511
00:30:08.901 --> 00:30:16.104
are unique to the cancer and the idea, the physics of cancer, let's say, from that first principle.

512
00:30:16.564 --> 00:30:22.287
And it has nothing to do with where the cancer is happening, whether it's in a cat or if it's in a human, right?

513
00:30:22.547 --> 00:30:26.429
It's a fundamental first principles understanding of what the cancer is doing.

514
00:30:26.869 --> 00:30:35.753
So they've identified 31 driver genes, and these are genes that drive cancer mutations later on.

515
00:30:36.313 --> 00:30:41.037
Okay, so you can have a gene that has a mutation and then that drives other types of mutations, right?

516
00:30:41.258 --> 00:30:42.759
So that's what's called a driver gene.

517
00:30:42.779 --> 00:30:44.581
They identified 31 driver genes.

518
00:30:44.881 --> 00:30:54.029
There was this particular gene called TP53, and that one was the most frequently mutated gene showing up in about 33% of cat tumors.

519
00:30:57.460 --> 00:31:02.563
And that's a gene that's also going to show up in human cancers.

520
00:31:02.623 --> 00:31:11.948
So already we're getting a lot of these very familiar genetic motifs in both the human case and the cat case.

521
00:31:13.292 --> 00:31:20.140
When it comes to carcinoma, one of the clearest parallels was this other gene called FBXW7.

522
00:31:20.541 --> 00:31:25.306
It was altered in more than 50% of the tumors that were studied in the cat.

523
00:31:25.646 --> 00:31:28.950
And again, that's another gene that's very, very prevalent in human beings.

524
00:31:29.311 --> 00:31:32.775
So if we can really start understanding how these cats get these...

525
00:31:33.986 --> 00:31:52.618
mutations, what are the carcinogenic sort of drivers of those kinds of mutations, then you can do something called comparative oncology, where if the cats and the humans get similar tumors, then perhaps the treatment and the biological insight can flow in both directions.

526
00:31:52.638 --> 00:31:52.838
Right.

527
00:31:53.039 --> 00:32:02.765
We can use the human treatment to inform on how to treat a cat, and we can use the cat genomics to inform on the fundamentals of the human treatment.

528
00:32:03.638 --> 00:32:04.039
Cancer.

529
00:32:04.439 --> 00:32:05.721
So I thought it was a very cool study.

530
00:32:05.981 --> 00:32:12.709
I think one of the things from this story that immediately clicked in my head when we put in the show notes was...

531
00:32:13.723 --> 00:32:20.005
This idea that when we use, you know, we use animal models for research, you know, for a whole host of things.

532
00:32:21.246 --> 00:32:32.449
But this idea for cancer specifically that we basically induce, we artificially create cancer in mice and rats and other rodents we do in the lab.

533
00:32:33.150 --> 00:32:33.350
And...

534
00:32:34.450 --> 00:32:35.451
It's a very simple idea.

535
00:32:35.812 --> 00:32:38.895
Domesticated cats live in the same environment as they're human.

536
00:32:38.955 --> 00:32:39.175
Yeah.

537
00:32:39.375 --> 00:32:48.083
And so their natural cancer is, from an environmental inducement perspective, is very closely mapped to our lived experience.

538
00:32:48.384 --> 00:32:51.687
And it makes very logical sense that...

539
00:32:53.328 --> 00:33:08.298
This is the whole nature-nurture thing, that the environment does create a better platform for study in terms of being able to take... Because we've talked about with ALS, I think it was a story where we talked about in animal models it doesn't translate.

540
00:33:08.678 --> 00:33:10.919
Alzheimer's, animal models it doesn't translate.

541
00:33:10.959 --> 00:33:12.500
Consciousness, it doesn't translate.

542
00:33:13.181 --> 00:33:15.262
And so at least in a small...

543
00:33:17.203 --> 00:33:35.301
portion as it relates to naturally occurring cancers and oncology studies that that overlap to improving animal models made total sense yeah yeah that's cool to see in an actual study here yeah i thought that was very cool that was great we're gonna move on to our fourth story before we wrap up with project hail mary which is

544
00:33:35.942 --> 00:33:44.413
This headline in Reuters and TechCrunch, a major hacking tool has leaked online, putting millions of iPhones at risk.

545
00:33:44.934 --> 00:33:47.858
And here's what you need to know.

546
00:33:47.978 --> 00:33:50.140
So we both have iPhones.

547
00:33:50.381 --> 00:33:50.621
Yes.

548
00:33:51.082 --> 00:33:52.824
I would like my iPhone not to be at risk.

549
00:33:52.904 --> 00:33:53.865
Yes, yeah, me too.

550
00:33:54.185 --> 00:34:06.152
And, you know, spyware, we've grown up in the generation where we've seen Facebook hacks and, you know, we've seen the rise of information warfare across nation states for a whole variety of geopolitical advantages.

551
00:34:06.952 --> 00:34:19.800
And so what this story is about is researchers have uncovered that two very powerful iPhone hacking toolkits, Dark Sword and Karuna, or at least parts of them, have leaked online in a public account.

552
00:34:20.440 --> 00:34:23.022
GitHub repo, which just basically means anyone can download this.

553
00:34:23.403 --> 00:34:23.823
Oh, wow.

554
00:34:23.923 --> 00:34:36.755
And historically, these toolkits have been very lucrative for organizations to sell to nation states and intelligence community types and other non-state actors.

555
00:34:36.855 --> 00:34:37.195
Yeah.

556
00:34:37.215 --> 00:34:39.658
Who want to have targeted hacks of, you know...

557
00:34:40.718 --> 00:34:46.623
As long as you don't have your people leaking stuff on Signal, you want to be able to get to them.

558
00:34:46.944 --> 00:34:47.204
Yeah.

559
00:34:47.444 --> 00:34:50.967
So the software itself is actually not new.

560
00:34:51.407 --> 00:34:52.849
The actual toolkits themselves.

561
00:34:53.329 --> 00:34:57.552
It's general availability for the regular public is what's new.

562
00:34:57.793 --> 00:34:57.973
Right.

563
00:34:57.993 --> 00:34:58.153
Yeah.

564
00:34:58.193 --> 00:34:59.254
This is just on GitHub.

565
00:34:59.434 --> 00:34:59.614
Right.

566
00:34:59.854 --> 00:35:02.276
Because normally something like this would be...

567
00:35:03.290 --> 00:35:09.892
tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands, millions of dollars to be able to, you know, have someone do on your behalf to get access.

568
00:35:09.912 --> 00:35:15.853
Because obviously Apple spends a ton of money and their whole brand identity is around privacy first.

569
00:35:16.353 --> 00:35:18.994
We're secure, local only, yada, yada, yada.

570
00:35:19.254 --> 00:35:22.015
So this idea that we're having government-grade exploits

571
00:35:22.575 --> 00:35:25.959
Escape into the Wild, I think is the core idea for this story.

572
00:35:26.379 --> 00:35:28.361
It was first reported on March 18th.

573
00:35:28.701 --> 00:35:35.929
It should be noted that for Dark Sword, it specifically targets iOS 18.4 through 18.62.

574
00:35:36.549 --> 00:35:38.311
And what's interesting about iPhones...

575
00:35:38.351 --> 00:35:41.634
I'm going to check my iOS version right after this episode.

576
00:35:41.654 --> 00:35:41.774
Right.

577
00:35:41.835 --> 00:35:42.015
Right.

578
00:35:43.356 --> 00:35:50.161
What I will say is, you know, for most people, you're not doing anything that anyone is going to go through the effort to target as a practical matter.

579
00:35:50.702 --> 00:35:57.968
But also, one of the big differences between Android and iOS as ecosystems and the audiences is that...

580
00:35:59.624 --> 00:36:08.535
Usually when there's new OS update, upwards of 80 to 90% of the iPhone install base just automatically accepts the auto update.

581
00:36:09.036 --> 00:36:14.122
And so the surface area of risk is relatively low, but the number looks to still be about 30%.

582
00:36:14.202 --> 00:36:19.044
220 million to 270 million iPhones could still be exposed to this.

583
00:36:19.524 --> 00:36:21.005
So it's, it's non-zero.

584
00:36:22.225 --> 00:36:35.131
The downloads, you know, I are trying to be taken down from GitHub because obviously Apple has a lot of control there, but there's dozens of sort of sites in the, in Ukraine, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Malaysia, et cetera, that,

585
00:36:35.751 --> 00:36:37.471
You know, it's very prominent there.

586
00:36:37.551 --> 00:36:37.851
Wow.

587
00:36:38.052 --> 00:36:41.112
These are obviously areas where there's active conflict happening.

588
00:36:41.172 --> 00:36:46.093
And so, I mean, the story we just talked about where the astronauts on Artemis have iPhones.

589
00:36:46.133 --> 00:36:46.373
Yeah.

590
00:36:46.933 --> 00:36:48.714
They're not doing anything classified on there, hopefully.

591
00:36:48.734 --> 00:36:53.895
But it's, of course, technology that they want to preserve and protect.

592
00:36:54.455 --> 00:36:57.176
I was surprised that they just had off.

593
00:36:57.656 --> 00:36:58.876
They might not be off the shelf.

594
00:36:58.936 --> 00:36:59.196
Yeah.

595
00:36:59.596 --> 00:37:02.597
But I was surprised that it was an Apple product that they brought with them.

596
00:37:03.257 --> 00:37:03.857
It's curious.

597
00:37:04.197 --> 00:37:06.638
With Karuna, it has a wider spectrum.

598
00:37:06.658 --> 00:37:08.979
It impacts iOS 13 through 17.

599
00:37:09.179 --> 00:37:14.061
So there's DarkSword, which is the first sort of hacking protocol.

600
00:37:14.081 --> 00:37:14.262
Yes.

601
00:37:14.422 --> 00:37:16.082
And then Karuna is the second one.

602
00:37:16.142 --> 00:37:16.382
Yes.

603
00:37:16.422 --> 00:37:16.623
Okay.

604
00:37:16.663 --> 00:37:20.864
And so DarkSword is more modern because it sort of targets iOS 18.

605
00:37:21.044 --> 00:37:21.765
18, okay.

606
00:37:22.285 --> 00:37:27.827
Karuna is for the older iOS 13 to 17, which is much, much fewer phones, especially for high-value targets.

607
00:37:28.327 --> 00:37:30.868
It's less likely that they're going to be on these older versions.

608
00:37:30.888 --> 00:37:32.029
So...

609
00:37:33.189 --> 00:37:35.531
What does it allow the hacker to do?

610
00:37:35.631 --> 00:37:36.891
It can get your messages.

611
00:37:36.991 --> 00:37:38.132
It can get your browsing data.

612
00:37:38.152 --> 00:37:44.795
It can get your location history and crypto-related information once the device has been compromised.

613
00:37:45.015 --> 00:37:56.301
And so, you know, it's not – the idea here is it's less about your iPhone is removable now, not only because most of us aren't doing anything that's actually worth the effort to –

614
00:37:56.761 --> 00:38:18.810
get it on there because you still have to install it and so a lot of times the way you get is when you get a website where it says oh you have something wrong click here to download a fix so you still need to get it onto the device but once it's onto the device it can then remotely execute a whole bunch of stuff um so like links and attachments and emails can be a point of a vector for attack attachments and i message etc etc so it is

615
00:38:19.750 --> 00:38:30.101
Not ideal, but I think the bigger point here is it's similar to the drone issue that we've seen in warfare in the Middle East.

616
00:38:30.181 --> 00:38:30.461
Okay.

617
00:38:30.602 --> 00:38:31.523
Where the cost...

618
00:38:32.766 --> 00:38:40.371
is getting so low for things that used to be reserved for much more sophisticated shops.

619
00:38:40.571 --> 00:38:43.633
And it's not only happening on the battlefield.

620
00:38:43.673 --> 00:38:49.477
It's now also happening in the information war space, where now you're getting sort of what used to be a nation-state-only capability.

621
00:38:49.657 --> 00:38:52.720
Any Tom, Dick, or Harry can kind of get it off the shelf now.

622
00:38:53.060 --> 00:38:55.922
Again, it is more of a signal about...

623
00:38:56.903 --> 00:39:08.195
The larger things to come as more of these tools, again, if Anthropic can't keep their model under wraps, if iPhone is still having exploits that are now getting to the public, it's a constant battlefield.

624
00:39:08.235 --> 00:39:12.400
So trying to do a little bit of separation between what is real versus what is hype.

625
00:39:12.961 --> 00:39:14.422
But I do think there is.

626
00:39:15.565 --> 00:39:26.096
This is a space to watch as spyware generally becomes more generally accessible on top of the fact that now there's all these coding assistants and coding agents.

627
00:39:26.156 --> 00:39:31.522
So some high school kid who's clever, usually the best stuff comes from high school and early college kids.

628
00:39:31.682 --> 00:39:31.883
Right.

629
00:39:32.483 --> 00:39:35.346
You know, we've seen this cycle of...

630
00:39:36.127 --> 00:39:40.609
ransomware with hospitals where they lock down hospital system software until you pay in crypto.

631
00:39:41.230 --> 00:39:42.610
I don't think this is going away.

632
00:39:43.110 --> 00:39:51.234
And I've been surprised at how little has spilled into the public in all these proxy wars in terms of the information war component.

633
00:39:51.675 --> 00:39:55.036
But this leak, I think, is a signal that we're going to see more of this in the coming years.

634
00:39:55.316 --> 00:39:56.657
Yeah, that's pretty scary.

635
00:39:56.677 --> 00:39:58.278
I mean, people, when they talk about...

636
00:39:59.068 --> 00:40:02.690
you know, leaks and like getting through cryptography.

637
00:40:03.230 --> 00:40:08.393
I think there's a lot of hype around, oh, quantum computing is going to, you know, change the game.

638
00:40:08.773 --> 00:40:10.014
And that's certainly true.

639
00:40:10.054 --> 00:40:17.077
Like if it works and we do have a fault tolerant, scalable quantum computer, it is going to break encryption, right?

640
00:40:17.177 --> 00:40:19.238
That's kind of an inevitability.

641
00:40:19.278 --> 00:40:23.440
But even before then, there's all these like cheap tricks.

642
00:40:23.580 --> 00:40:23.780
Yes.

643
00:40:24.301 --> 00:40:24.561
That...

644
00:40:25.562 --> 00:40:27.484
Probably we should be concerned about.

645
00:40:27.724 --> 00:40:27.964
Yes.

646
00:40:28.064 --> 00:40:34.831
Make sure your admin password on any critical infrastructure software you guys have is not password or zero, zero, zero, zero.

647
00:40:35.011 --> 00:40:35.652
Yeah.

648
00:40:35.932 --> 00:40:39.075
So, again, just two leaked stories this week.

649
00:40:40.156 --> 00:40:42.959
You know, I think these are all getting a lot of attention.

650
00:40:42.999 --> 00:40:43.219
Yeah.

651
00:40:43.319 --> 00:40:45.361
And the coverage is not quite perfect.

652
00:40:45.381 --> 00:40:48.043
Well, I'm glad you covered it because I learned a lot there.

653
00:40:48.244 --> 00:40:48.464
Nice.

654
00:40:48.724 --> 00:40:50.606
We're going to move into Project Hail Mary.

655
00:40:50.786 --> 00:40:52.227
Yes.

656
00:40:52.347 --> 00:40:55.370
Our last note of the day in this rundown episode.

657
00:40:55.811 --> 00:40:56.852
You had seen it first.

658
00:40:56.952 --> 00:40:58.613
I saw it first, and then I told you to see it.

659
00:40:58.633 --> 00:40:59.334
You told me to go see it.

660
00:40:59.454 --> 00:41:01.957
I was hyped about it because I love every space movie.

661
00:41:02.137 --> 00:41:05.560
All the early Rotten Tomatoes stuff, et cetera, was hot.

662
00:41:05.600 --> 00:41:06.421
Was hot, yeah.

663
00:41:06.621 --> 00:41:07.241
It was hot.

664
00:41:07.942 --> 00:41:08.743
So what did you think?

665
00:41:11.361 --> 00:41:11.862
You know what I mean?

666
00:41:11.942 --> 00:41:12.903
It was all right.

667
00:41:14.004 --> 00:41:15.065
It was all right.

668
00:41:15.625 --> 00:41:18.948
No, you know, I think that it was beautifully shot.

669
00:41:19.149 --> 00:41:21.751
Like, I love the visual language of the film.

670
00:41:22.312 --> 00:41:24.314
I thought the visual language was fantastic.

671
00:41:24.334 --> 00:41:25.895
The cinematography was fantastic.

672
00:41:27.837 --> 00:41:30.299
You know, I think the concepts were really interesting.

673
00:41:30.379 --> 00:41:32.662
Like, also, spoiler alert,

674
00:41:33.202 --> 00:41:33.642
Warning.

675
00:41:33.983 --> 00:41:37.445
So if you haven't seen it yet, we are going to talk about the actual details.

676
00:41:37.505 --> 00:41:45.069
So like the Petrovillin concept and like the narrative tension of like what was happening and why it was important, I thought was great.

677
00:41:45.769 --> 00:41:54.975
I really had a hard time getting emotionally invested into the relationship between Ryan Gosling's character and Rocky.

678
00:41:55.435 --> 00:41:55.816
Oh, okay.

679
00:41:55.936 --> 00:42:01.360
I might have just been having an off day, and I was feeling a little bit like the Grinch, but I just couldn't get into it.

680
00:42:01.841 --> 00:42:05.904
That's very interesting because I had the opposite experience.

681
00:42:06.325 --> 00:42:16.213
I was, like, super emotionally invested in Rocky the Alien, and I thought, like, as a film, I thought it was a masterpiece, honestly, because...

682
00:42:17.895 --> 00:42:26.006
I've seen a lot of films with probably a higher budget or a higher production value where I could not care less about the main characters.

683
00:42:26.426 --> 00:42:29.931
A good example is the Formula 1 F1 movie.

684
00:42:30.071 --> 00:42:33.536
At the end, I really couldn't care if Brad Pitt won.

685
00:42:34.477 --> 00:42:42.760
Or if Lewis Hamilton won at the, at that last race, because like the way that they set up the character, I just wasn't, there was no arc.

686
00:42:42.800 --> 00:42:45.221
There was no like time to identify with him.

687
00:42:45.341 --> 00:42:49.802
I don't know why, but somehow the way that they, to me, at least, right.

688
00:42:49.822 --> 00:42:51.643
The way that they, they, they,

689
00:42:52.800 --> 00:42:58.386
had Rocky come up and like his struggles of like, he, like his crew died and all this other stuff.

690
00:42:58.406 --> 00:43:00.869
There's like, there was so much that I could identify with.

691
00:43:00.909 --> 00:43:04.112
I actually like, I think this was better than interstellar.

692
00:43:05.198 --> 00:43:12.162
In terms of a movie, in terms of something that I could emotionally feel and be a part of.

693
00:43:12.663 --> 00:43:18.266
There are scenes in Interstellar that I emotionally resonated with.

694
00:43:18.286 --> 00:43:23.830
Like the fact when he was talking to his kids and he saw the kids just grow up in an hour.

695
00:43:24.730 --> 00:43:29.253
That was kind of crazy because obviously I know about general relativity and things like that.

696
00:43:29.273 --> 00:43:31.294
But seeing it on screen is pretty insane.

697
00:43:31.314 --> 00:43:32.035
Yeah.

698
00:43:32.735 --> 00:43:39.501
But yeah, I think in terms of that, like the movie and the characters, I thought it was amazing.

699
00:43:39.641 --> 00:43:40.342
I don't agree.

700
00:43:40.522 --> 00:43:40.742
Okay.

701
00:43:40.802 --> 00:43:43.664
No, I'm really fascinated by that take.

702
00:43:43.804 --> 00:43:44.225
Yeah.

703
00:43:44.525 --> 00:43:46.427
Again, I have to probably watch it again.

704
00:43:46.447 --> 00:43:48.789
It just might have been not the right day for me.

705
00:43:48.949 --> 00:43:49.709
Yeah.

706
00:43:50.270 --> 00:43:52.792
But saying it's better than Interstellar is heresy.

707
00:43:52.832 --> 00:43:53.493
Yeah.

708
00:43:53.593 --> 00:43:55.494
To me, I will go ahead and say that.

709
00:43:55.554 --> 00:43:57.716
I think the science of Interstellar is cooler.

710
00:43:58.157 --> 00:43:58.657
For sure.

711
00:43:59.157 --> 00:43:59.378
But...

712
00:43:59.998 --> 00:44:08.044
I think in terms of a movie where I resonated with the characters and I was like emotionally locked in and I was just like, what's going to happen?

713
00:44:08.125 --> 00:44:08.725
Oh, my gosh.

714
00:44:09.145 --> 00:44:10.166
I think this one was like.

715
00:44:10.827 --> 00:44:23.957
I think here's where maybe I will get a point of agreement with you, which is the one relationship that definitely was forced and didn't make sense or didn't have enough time to marinate was between Carl, the security guard driver, and Ryan Gosling's character.

716
00:44:24.157 --> 00:44:25.178
That was a bit rushed.

717
00:44:25.198 --> 00:44:27.359
They just immediately became buddy-buddy.

718
00:44:27.379 --> 00:44:29.521
And I was like, all right, that's a little too...

719
00:44:29.761 --> 00:44:30.621
It was a little too fast.

720
00:44:30.641 --> 00:44:31.602
A little too fast.

721
00:44:31.642 --> 00:44:32.983
So I think we can agree on that one.

722
00:44:33.163 --> 00:44:34.404
Yeah.

723
00:44:34.464 --> 00:44:35.525
I'll agree with you on that one.

724
00:44:35.885 --> 00:44:36.826
But let's continue.

725
00:44:36.886 --> 00:44:37.126
Yeah.

726
00:44:37.166 --> 00:44:37.646
So, okay.

727
00:44:37.726 --> 00:44:38.287
Well, anyways.

728
00:44:39.067 --> 00:44:46.132
So I want to cover some of the things that I found good about the science and some of the things that I was just like, that kind of doesn't make sense.

729
00:44:46.192 --> 00:44:47.513
Again, I want to just say that...

730
00:44:47.933 --> 00:44:51.097
The movie itself, I still think, was just really well done.

731
00:44:51.517 --> 00:44:52.979
So let's start with the good.

732
00:44:53.199 --> 00:44:53.340
Yep.

733
00:44:53.800 --> 00:45:03.672
So I loved the way that the population dynamics, I thought, was very cool in that in Tau Ceti,

734
00:45:05.634 --> 00:45:11.935
The reason why that astrophage is not runaway exploding is because there's a predator.

735
00:45:12.336 --> 00:45:19.897
Predator prey dynamics is one of the first things that you learn about in differential equations and how there can be stable equilibria.

736
00:45:19.917 --> 00:45:21.158
So I thought that was really cool.

737
00:45:21.658 --> 00:45:30.860
The idea that the acceleration of the spaceship was creating gravity and that once Ryan Gosling and his spaceship arrived at Tau Ceti...

738
00:45:31.600 --> 00:45:52.283
the spaceship stopped pushing yeah and then he was in zero g yeah i thought that was really cool like that switch because like when he when he first wakes up there's still gravity yes right and i was i was like what is going on how is there gravity in space if he's in space yes and then it switched off and then there was zero g i thought that was really cool that was a nice time

739
00:45:52.543 --> 00:45:56.447
That was a really nice touch because I was like, ah, okay, now I see that.

740
00:45:57.688 --> 00:46:03.193
The details of Rocky the alien I thought were very cool in that even Rocky slept.

741
00:46:03.733 --> 00:46:07.697
This is something that we talked about in our episode about why jellyfish sleep, right?

742
00:46:07.977 --> 00:46:09.979
Jellyfish have a decentralized brain.

743
00:46:10.280 --> 00:46:11.861
They don't have a central nervous system.

744
00:46:11.881 --> 00:46:12.642
They don't have like...

745
00:46:13.522 --> 00:46:24.188
The reasons to sleep like we do, but yet they still sleep because it's a part of a DNA repair mechanism fundamentally at the end of the day and a cellular repair mechanism.

746
00:46:24.448 --> 00:46:27.290
And so the fact that even Rocky had a sleep-wakes cycle.

747
00:46:28.215 --> 00:46:31.176
Because he's got some form of neurons, right?

748
00:46:31.196 --> 00:46:36.037
He's got some form of information capacity and information churning ability.

749
00:46:36.617 --> 00:46:41.839
And so to have even someone like Rocky sleep, I thought that was a really good touch.

750
00:46:42.179 --> 00:46:49.501
I think that is something that I would expect if we ever see aliens, intelligent aliens at least, that they would also sleep.

751
00:46:50.901 --> 00:46:57.003
His use of – so, you know, he uses echolocation to sense his environment.

752
00:46:58.622 --> 00:47:10.728
So he doesn't have any eyes and he doesn't have any way to feel electromagnetic radiation because I think their species is evolved in a high pressure, very dark environment.

753
00:47:12.369 --> 00:47:22.334
So he used, I don't know if you saw, but he had like a little iPad that would make texture out of whatever Ryan Gosling was seeing.

754
00:47:22.634 --> 00:47:24.775
And he had a little crystal that would...

755
00:47:25.515 --> 00:47:49.641
take in electromagnetic rays and then transfer that into this like tactile ipad thing i thought that was pretty cool that was quite that was quite um because then he can see the ipad by bouncing sound waves yes off of it yes um that was clever yeah i i i thought that was clever i also like the fact that rocky had emotions i think there's a lot of like alien movies out there where like these aliens are like super emotionless and like don't

756
00:47:51.318 --> 00:47:54.181
you know, that they're just super logical and things like that.

757
00:47:54.361 --> 00:48:00.947
I like the fact that Rocky had, like, emotions of sadness, happiness, like, missing his partner, things like that.

758
00:48:01.368 --> 00:48:06.293
Because if we look around in the animal kingdom, emotions are everywhere, right?

759
00:48:06.473 --> 00:48:08.475
In not just, I would say...

760
00:48:09.075 --> 00:48:33.931
um mammals but there there's evidence for emotion in birds and reptiles things like that and so it's kind of an evolutionary trick where you know there's some hormones or pheromones or chemicals in our brain that perhaps give us the illusion of emotion and it's like an evolutionary trick to get us to be attached to something or to an outcome or to an individual but i think that same kind of evolutionary trick would be there um

761
00:48:34.852 --> 00:48:36.874
For an evolved system somewhere else.

762
00:48:37.014 --> 00:48:37.794
So I like that.

763
00:48:38.075 --> 00:48:41.237
Now, of course, these are like just soft, soft opinions.

764
00:48:41.297 --> 00:48:41.677
Totally.

765
00:48:41.758 --> 00:48:45.581
And I want to add two things, I think, to what I think the film did good.

766
00:48:47.402 --> 00:48:51.005
The sound design was out of this world.

767
00:48:51.085 --> 00:48:51.305
Yeah.

768
00:48:51.605 --> 00:48:52.866
I went to see it in IMAX.

769
00:48:53.126 --> 00:48:53.367
Oh, nice.

770
00:48:53.387 --> 00:48:53.527
Nice.

771
00:48:53.867 --> 00:48:56.950
The sound design is so good.

772
00:48:57.030 --> 00:48:57.290
Yeah.

773
00:48:57.611 --> 00:49:00.313
It is because it's space.

774
00:49:00.513 --> 00:49:01.614
Using silence well.

775
00:49:01.995 --> 00:49:09.742
Like a lot of times you hear sounds in space movies and it's like, oh, that's the sound from Jurassic Park mapped with a little bit or whatever, right?

776
00:49:10.222 --> 00:49:11.162
It was very unique.

777
00:49:11.182 --> 00:49:12.403
They clearly did a lot of work there.

778
00:49:12.443 --> 00:49:13.703
The sound design was exceptional.

779
00:49:14.063 --> 00:49:18.105
And I just want to double click on how visually stunning it was.

780
00:49:18.865 --> 00:49:21.946
It was a beautiful, it was beautiful to watch and look at.

781
00:49:22.066 --> 00:49:22.847
Yeah.

782
00:49:24.007 --> 00:49:30.089
And, and just, and I think from an original screenplay design, screenplay perspective for a space movie.

783
00:49:30.430 --> 00:49:31.190
Yeah.

784
00:49:32.030 --> 00:49:35.932
I think they did a good job of not just repeating the same space movie again.

785
00:49:36.052 --> 00:49:36.312
Yes.

786
00:49:36.712 --> 00:49:37.212
I do.

787
00:49:37.332 --> 00:49:38.493
I do agree with that.

788
00:49:38.613 --> 00:49:38.893
The,

789
00:49:39.733 --> 00:49:50.459
Probably, I'm probably going to watch it again, but I really want to skip through, like, the part where Rocky, like, has to get out of his atmosphere and be in pain.

790
00:49:50.719 --> 00:49:57.622
Because, like, that sound design was really well done because I was, like, feeling it because I had already attached, like, emotional weight to Rocky.

791
00:49:57.642 --> 00:49:59.403
And then I'm like, oh, like, this guy's dying.

792
00:49:59.943 --> 00:50:01.724
Like, so I was, I was, like, going through it.

793
00:50:01.744 --> 00:50:06.987
And I'm probably going to fast forward that part because I really did not enjoy watching that part.

794
00:50:06.987 --> 00:50:15.329
But the part before where they're like doing the fishing in the atmosphere, the score was absolutely incredible.

795
00:50:15.629 --> 00:50:20.730
Like, dude, everyone in the theater was locked in during that part.

796
00:50:20.830 --> 00:50:26.691
Like everyone, you know that meme where they're like, you're like this and then you grab the controller.

797
00:50:27.051 --> 00:50:28.711
Everyone in the theater was like, all right, let's.

798
00:50:28.731 --> 00:50:32.232
That was probably one of the best intensity moments of the whole film.

799
00:50:32.312 --> 00:50:32.552
Yeah.

800
00:50:32.892 --> 00:50:34.233
And it was, that was quite nice.

801
00:50:34.253 --> 00:50:35.433
That was really, really cool.

802
00:50:35.453 --> 00:50:35.973
That was quite nice.

803
00:50:36.193 --> 00:50:38.114
So all of that I really liked.

804
00:50:38.474 --> 00:50:43.495
There are a few things about the science that I'm not sure I buy.

805
00:50:43.515 --> 00:50:43.895
Okay.

806
00:50:43.915 --> 00:50:44.155
Okay.

807
00:50:44.475 --> 00:50:55.698
And I want to cover this because a lot of the coverage that I'm seeing is that Andy Weyer, who's the author of the book, is, like, really nitty-gritty about the science, right?

808
00:50:57.038 --> 00:51:00.619
So perhaps there are reasons because I haven't read the book.

809
00:51:00.999 --> 00:51:03.180
I did a bit of research to see, like, what the...

810
00:51:04.340 --> 00:51:24.142
what what the justification for these these points were i'm still not buying it so perhaps in the comments you can tell me if you disagree the first one has nothing to do with andy wire that just has to do with ryan gosling never having been in a molecular biology lab remember the centrifuge scene yeah have you seen all of the all of the scientists on tiktok and instagram no

811
00:51:24.742 --> 00:51:33.148
Everyone had like a gasp during the centrifuge scene because he puts two samples right next to each other on the centrifuge.

812
00:51:33.248 --> 00:51:41.174
OK, I got a 15 minute lecture during my Princeton undergrad bio lab because I did that.

813
00:51:41.654 --> 00:51:44.116
And then like the centrifuge started doing this.

814
00:51:44.556 --> 00:51:46.838
And then the grad student who was my T.A.

815
00:51:46.878 --> 00:51:49.359
had to like unplug the centrifuge.

816
00:51:49.379 --> 00:51:51.261
And he was like, you're a physics major.

817
00:51:51.281 --> 00:51:51.381
Yeah.

818
00:51:51.861 --> 00:51:54.102
Like, are you... What are you doing?

819
00:51:54.162 --> 00:51:55.943
And then I thought about it for like five seconds.

820
00:51:55.983 --> 00:51:59.025
I'm like, yeah, that was really dumb.

821
00:51:59.305 --> 00:52:00.265
Because you got to balance.

822
00:52:00.285 --> 00:52:02.587
You got to put one on one side and one on the other side.

823
00:52:02.807 --> 00:52:04.328
And the thing is, it wasn't even like a...

824
00:52:05.287 --> 00:52:08.869
The scene wasn't even off to the side.

825
00:52:09.189 --> 00:52:12.651
The camera focuses in on the centrifuge, and then he puts the two.

826
00:52:12.831 --> 00:52:13.812
So it's just full.

827
00:52:13.892 --> 00:52:21.736
The entire field of view is this centrifuge that I know is about to break, and I'm sure he only has one centrifuge up there.

828
00:52:21.756 --> 00:52:21.996
Right.

829
00:52:22.077 --> 00:52:22.777
So what?

830
00:52:23.237 --> 00:52:26.099
Now he's going to have to spin it manually or something, right?

831
00:52:26.159 --> 00:52:27.900
So that centrifuge definitely broke.

832
00:52:27.980 --> 00:52:28.180
Yeah.

833
00:52:28.340 --> 00:52:29.181
in the story.

834
00:52:29.341 --> 00:52:34.026
So that was pretty hilarious that everybody on TikTok was like going after that.

835
00:52:34.206 --> 00:52:40.452
The second thing was, so Ryan Gosling mentions that, or his character, mentions that Rocky's...

836
00:52:42.334 --> 00:53:02.162
alien technology is like primitive in the sense that they don't know about relativity but they're really good at material science okay now they're so good at material science that they can literally build anything they want with the xenonite right right um which has xenon in some form i can totally buy that xenon has other allotropes that is not like

837
00:53:02.682 --> 00:53:03.243
gas, right?

838
00:53:03.283 --> 00:53:07.648
There's ways to manipulate xenon to be a material that we haven't really thought of.

839
00:53:07.708 --> 00:53:12.374
Condensed matters is a nascent field, even by today's standards.

840
00:53:12.774 --> 00:53:13.856
So I can buy that.

841
00:53:14.276 --> 00:53:15.357
What I don't buy...

842
00:53:16.488 --> 00:53:27.133
is that an alien civilization is so advanced that they can literally 3D print Xenonite and things like that, but they don't know about relativity, okay?

843
00:53:27.474 --> 00:53:33.056
Because relativity to me is a very fundamental part of the fabric of the universe.

844
00:53:33.457 --> 00:53:37.118
I can forgive them for not understanding general relativity maybe, okay?

845
00:53:37.379 --> 00:53:39.760
But special relativity has everything to do with...

846
00:53:40.340 --> 00:54:01.345
just electromagnetism in general electricity and magnetism and i know for a fact that they know about electricity and magnetism for two reasons um well let's actually three reasons first um in the scene where ryan gosling is like trying to um in the scene where the the spaceship the earth hail mary spaceship is like

847
00:54:02.932 --> 00:54:05.455
Turning around to create artificial gravity.

848
00:54:07.777 --> 00:54:12.463
There's antennas on Rocky's spaceship that are tracking.

849
00:54:12.983 --> 00:54:14.385
Those antennas are using light.

850
00:54:15.206 --> 00:54:15.466
Okay.

851
00:54:15.726 --> 00:54:22.153
They're using some kind of radar because that's what the only thing that goes in empty space is light.

852
00:54:22.213 --> 00:54:22.393
Right.

853
00:54:22.433 --> 00:54:23.595
Electromagnetic radiation.

854
00:54:23.635 --> 00:54:23.855
Right.

855
00:54:23.915 --> 00:54:28.679
So clearly he's using electromagnetic radiation in some rudimentary way, right?

856
00:54:29.059 --> 00:54:32.922
So you can say, oh, he just like, he knows it's like in some rudimentary way.

857
00:54:33.602 --> 00:54:33.882
Fine.

858
00:54:35.183 --> 00:54:40.067
Second, he's literally 3D printing like entire spaceships worth of xenonite.

859
00:54:40.127 --> 00:54:40.287
Right.

860
00:54:40.547 --> 00:54:45.731
How are you manipulating that material if not with electromagnetic fields?

861
00:54:46.412 --> 00:54:46.632
Right.

862
00:54:46.992 --> 00:54:48.053
And if you're doing that...

863
00:54:49.444 --> 00:54:50.925
How do you not know about relativity?

864
00:54:50.965 --> 00:54:54.669
Because relativity is really a consequence of Maxwell's equations, right?

865
00:54:54.769 --> 00:55:05.258
If you know electricity and magnetism, you know if you're trying to manipulate charged particles, right, you know that when they move, they create a second type of force called magnetism.

866
00:55:05.598 --> 00:55:06.899
And then you know that...

867
00:55:07.640 --> 00:55:12.043
The interplay between electricity and magnetism has to go at the speed of light.

868
00:55:12.403 --> 00:55:19.707
And then you can make logical sort of deductions about, well, what's the, like, how is this working, right?

869
00:55:20.507 --> 00:55:24.290
Like, it's really a logical argument what relativity is.

870
00:55:24.750 --> 00:55:30.113
And third, about the material science, right?

871
00:55:30.513 --> 00:55:35.236
There's two materials that I know for a fact Rocky knows exist in terms of elements.

872
00:55:35.376 --> 00:55:37.297
First, oxygen.

873
00:55:39.483 --> 00:55:51.372
oxygen, he knows about oxygen because if you remember, there's a scene where Ryan Gosling goes through, goes to meet Rocky, and then Rocky's pointing at the little capsule that's a gift for him.

874
00:55:51.592 --> 00:55:56.276
That scene, by the way, was hilarious, where he kept pointing, and Ryan Gosling was like, oh, we want to keep doing it.

875
00:55:56.396 --> 00:55:57.477
Oh, you're pointing.

876
00:55:57.857 --> 00:56:02.961
He opens the thing, he sees two beads of eight and eight.

877
00:56:03.341 --> 00:56:03.621
Okay?

878
00:56:04.122 --> 00:56:08.005
And that's meant to be oxygen, because oxygen has eight protons and eight

879
00:56:09.180 --> 00:56:23.989
electrons and so an O2 molecule is 8 and 8 notice Rocky did not make 16 and 16 mm-hmm so Rocky knows about charge yeah okay yeah if he did 16 and 16 that means oh I just got it

880
00:56:24.429 --> 00:56:25.631
I just weighed oxygen.

881
00:56:25.751 --> 00:56:26.152
That's good.

882
00:56:26.212 --> 00:56:26.412
Right?

883
00:56:26.492 --> 00:56:29.136
And it's like 16 things in here and 16 things in here.

884
00:56:29.156 --> 00:56:36.066
No, he did eight and eight, which means he's either referring to the protons or he's referring to the electrons, which means he knows about positive and negative charge.

885
00:56:36.367 --> 00:56:39.051
So he knows fundamentally about electricity and magnetism.

886
00:56:39.371 --> 00:56:47.118
knows about charge, Coulomb's Law, and they have some rudimentary form of understanding the mechanics of chemicals and chemical bonds.

887
00:56:47.138 --> 00:56:47.839
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

888
00:56:47.879 --> 00:56:48.159
Okay?

889
00:56:48.199 --> 00:56:51.542
So you can't tell me that he doesn't know about electricity and magnetism.

890
00:56:51.562 --> 00:56:52.483
That's very interesting.

891
00:56:52.563 --> 00:56:53.804
He has to know about light.

892
00:56:54.284 --> 00:56:58.488
He has to know that light is a manifestation of this thing.

893
00:56:58.708 --> 00:57:03.293
That was, like, immediate to us in the 1800s when we figured out that

894
00:57:03.993 --> 00:57:10.037
The electricity and magnetism are governed by Maxwell's equations and the speed of light just pops out.

895
00:57:10.537 --> 00:57:15.761
The second thing, like along that vein, you're manipulating xenon.

896
00:57:16.121 --> 00:57:17.542
Xenon is a pretty heavy element.

897
00:57:17.582 --> 00:57:17.842
Right.

898
00:57:17.982 --> 00:57:18.242
Okay.

899
00:57:18.442 --> 00:57:18.562
Right.

900
00:57:18.582 --> 00:57:21.284
I think it's like 54 or something like that on the right hand side.

901
00:57:22.685 --> 00:57:28.769
When you're manipulating heavy elements, relativistic corrections become ever so important in chemistry.

902
00:57:28.809 --> 00:57:31.931
Because the heavier an element is, the faster the electrons are moving.

903
00:57:32.251 --> 00:57:34.212
The electrons move close to the speed of light.

904
00:57:34.552 --> 00:57:46.580
And now the chemistry of that material has everything to do with the fact that as electrons move closer to the speed of light, they get heavier, which means the atom is going to get smaller, which means they're going to shield the...

905
00:57:47.592 --> 00:58:07.022
nucleus more which means the outer electrons are going to do weird things that's why gold is the color it is that's why mercury is liquid and that's i think if if he's manipulating xenonite at that fidelity that's there's no way that they don't understand relativity

906
00:58:08.157 --> 00:58:09.358
It's a very compelling argument.

907
00:58:09.378 --> 00:58:09.959
I'm just saying.

908
00:58:10.039 --> 00:58:11.460
No, it's a very compelling argument.

909
00:58:11.480 --> 00:58:16.524
You can't be that good at material science and not know the fundamentals of our universe.

910
00:58:17.064 --> 00:58:17.325
Okay?

911
00:58:17.365 --> 00:58:20.787
It's not like physics is not something like, oh, I only need quantum mechanics.

912
00:58:20.807 --> 00:58:21.128
Well, no.

913
00:58:21.488 --> 00:58:26.232
In order to do that level of quantum mechanics, you need to understand, like, electron spin.

914
00:58:26.292 --> 00:58:27.653
Where does electron spin come from?

915
00:58:27.933 --> 00:58:28.994
That's from relativity.

916
00:58:29.394 --> 00:58:33.378
So I just don't buy that argument, that just because he uses echolocation—

917
00:58:33.958 --> 00:58:36.139
Means that, oh, he doesn't know about relativity.

918
00:58:36.159 --> 00:58:37.019
He doesn't know about light.

919
00:58:37.340 --> 00:58:41.081
We don't see the strong nuclear force, and yet we understand it pretty well.

920
00:58:41.201 --> 00:58:41.402
Right.

921
00:58:41.802 --> 00:58:42.022
Right.

922
00:58:42.082 --> 00:58:42.262
Right.

923
00:58:42.622 --> 00:58:51.806
And also, it's one of those things where even if you're not, part of your point is like you would have stumbled upon it indirectly.

924
00:58:51.826 --> 00:58:51.966
Yeah.

925
00:58:52.207 --> 00:58:54.808
Even if you weren't trying to discover it directly.

926
00:58:54.828 --> 00:58:55.108
Yes.

927
00:58:55.248 --> 00:58:55.468
Yeah.

928
00:58:56.049 --> 00:59:04.517
Perhaps we had an easier time because we live in an environment where we can see things, where light travels long distances and blah, blah, blah.

929
00:59:04.817 --> 00:59:10.442
But I'm saying if they have the fidelity of material science ability that they do.

930
00:59:11.123 --> 00:59:18.189
In the movie, there's just no way that they haven't stumbled upon something as fundamental as relativity.

931
00:59:18.770 --> 00:59:19.851
This is a hot take.

932
00:59:20.011 --> 00:59:21.893
You got to hear fresh off the griddle.

933
00:59:21.993 --> 00:59:24.235
I just don't think it makes sense.

934
00:59:24.795 --> 00:59:26.657
And if that's it, that's really good.

935
00:59:26.677 --> 00:59:26.997
That's it.

936
00:59:27.077 --> 00:59:27.437
That's it.

937
00:59:27.457 --> 00:59:28.378
Which is really good.

938
00:59:28.418 --> 00:59:29.960
And to be fair...

939
00:59:30.640 --> 00:59:33.882
I don't mind that this was part of the plot point, okay?

940
00:59:33.902 --> 00:59:40.385
Because I understand when it comes to, like, doing science fiction and art, you have to be able to, you know, take a little bit out.

941
00:59:40.705 --> 00:59:49.569
Because I think it's a big part of the plot that Rocky has extra fuel because he didn't take into account the fact that relativity makes his...

942
00:59:50.189 --> 00:59:50.409
Right.

943
00:59:50.649 --> 00:59:51.389
Trip shorter.

944
00:59:51.490 --> 00:59:51.630
Right.

945
00:59:51.670 --> 00:59:53.010
So he had like over.

946
00:59:53.290 --> 00:59:54.090
Yes.

947
00:59:54.611 --> 00:59:59.572
Overcompensated and has a lot more fuel, which is why he can give some to Ryan Gosling.

948
00:59:59.973 --> 01:00:01.713
So I don't mind.

949
01:00:01.833 --> 01:00:02.694
I'm just pointing it out.

950
01:00:02.754 --> 01:00:02.954
Right.

951
01:00:03.014 --> 01:00:05.054
And I don't want to this.

952
01:00:05.194 --> 01:00:07.775
I don't think this takes away from how much I enjoyed the film.

953
01:00:07.815 --> 01:00:07.995
Right.

954
01:00:08.035 --> 01:00:08.156
Right.

955
01:00:08.196 --> 01:00:10.256
And how much I enjoyed the science behind the film.

956
01:00:10.276 --> 01:00:13.097
There's still so much that made me think as a scientist.

957
01:00:13.217 --> 01:00:14.958
And to be fair, this also made me think.

958
01:00:15.218 --> 01:00:36.486
a lot yeah so i very much enjoyed it i would recommend it to anyone and let me know if you guys think my take about relativity is correct i would be curious to see those comments we have gone long on this rundown episode thank you all for joining us for another week of fascinating stories we did not include

959
01:00:37.166 --> 01:00:39.327
a segment of Are You Smarter Than a Scientist?

960
01:00:39.387 --> 01:00:42.549
Because we were so loaded with actual stories to cover.

961
01:00:42.969 --> 01:00:47.371
We will be sure to bring that back in the next rundown.

962
01:00:47.971 --> 01:00:55.995
I'm your host, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

963
01:00:56.395 --> 01:00:58.896
We will see you all next week.
