WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.200 --> 00:00:00.860
Hello, Internet.

2
00:00:00.881 --> 00:00:07.425
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, with a brief announcement before we jump into this week's episode.

3
00:00:07.926 --> 00:00:22.397
We have received a massive number of requests from many of you in FFP Nation to cover the recent proof published by OpenAI on their solution to the Navier Stokes Millennium Prize problem.

4
00:00:22.777 --> 00:00:31.106
We see it in our DMs and comments, in our email inbox, and we are going to give the people what they want.

5
00:00:31.246 --> 00:00:38.273
We have recorded this week's episode prior to Labor Day weekend on our regular schedule.

6
00:00:38.834 --> 00:00:42.758
Obviously, this news has created a lot of waves, and we have been watching.

7
00:00:42.938 --> 00:00:57.026
working diligently on wrapping our head around not only OpenAI's solution, but many of the larger conversation that have now arisen out of the publication of this paper, among other things.

8
00:00:57.386 --> 00:01:04.810
There is now huge tension within the community of mathematicians as it relates to alignment with AI models,

9
00:01:05.270 --> 00:01:22.073
We've now seen multiple CEOs from all of the major frontier labs come out in support of a new AI safety pacing request for a regulatory framework and government involvement as well as global involvement.

10
00:01:22.693 --> 00:01:30.835
There's been a lot of debate politically about how a democracy can operate in the context of having organizations.

11
00:01:30.955 --> 00:01:40.925
what appear to be increasingly intelligent systems that we may not have quite a handle on how to keep under control.

12
00:01:41.305 --> 00:01:42.867
It is a very complex issue.

13
00:01:43.267 --> 00:01:44.748
It's a very nuanced issue.

14
00:01:45.149 --> 00:01:45.810
There are a lot of

15
00:01:47.050 --> 00:01:53.854
high emotions and tensions coming from all of the different parties involved in this discussion.

16
00:01:54.415 --> 00:02:09.364
And over the last week and a half since OpenAI published their proof, that conversation has reached a fever pitch, in part triggered by a tweet from a former Anthropic researcher who

17
00:02:09.964 --> 00:02:16.466
regarding his personal belief about AI's possibility to cause human extinction.

18
00:02:16.947 --> 00:02:20.968
We are going to be covering all of that in next week's episode.

19
00:02:21.328 --> 00:02:29.811
We are aware about how important the Millennium Prize problem solution, as well as these larger conversations, are for you and FFP Nation to hear.

20
00:02:30.312 --> 00:02:31.472
What is our opinion?

21
00:02:32.184 --> 00:02:36.729
And what is the actual science and mathematics behind the solution?

22
00:02:37.110 --> 00:02:38.571
Is it what it's all cracked up to be?

23
00:02:39.012 --> 00:02:39.893
Is it all hype?

24
00:02:40.293 --> 00:02:42.336
And we will get into all of those details.

25
00:02:42.796 --> 00:02:47.261
This week's episode, as I mentioned, was recorded prior to Labor Day weekend.

26
00:02:47.622 --> 00:02:50.044
We were going to be taking some vacation time.

27
00:02:50.785 --> 00:02:58.718
in order to rest up and relax as we get prepared for a very intense few couple of weeks leading up to the Nobel Prizes.

28
00:02:58.818 --> 00:03:05.749
But science does not wait for those who want time off, and we are going to be sure to get you guys started.

29
00:03:06.209 --> 00:03:11.732
a really, really strong episode on all of those issues next week.

30
00:03:11.772 --> 00:03:16.234
And we appreciate you all having the patience to let us get that correct.

31
00:03:16.535 --> 00:03:24.999
Because as you know, on the show, we really want to focus on the facts and make sure we've gathered them sufficiently to be able to present them to you.

32
00:03:25.059 --> 00:03:28.741
So please, in the meantime, enjoy this laid-back podcast.

33
00:03:28.821 --> 00:03:36.368
relaxing episode, which will be more of a rundown episode covering some of the upcoming things happening in science in the fall.

34
00:03:36.688 --> 00:03:43.014
And we will see you all next week with the Navier Stokes solution and the greater AI conversation.

35
00:03:43.412 --> 00:03:44.152
Hello, Internet.

36
00:03:44.172 --> 00:03:52.234
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

37
00:03:52.774 --> 00:04:01.396
For those who joined us for the last episode, as we mentioned, we are going into our Labor Day weekend and are going to have a little bit of a relaxing episode.

38
00:04:01.976 --> 00:04:05.317
And I will start off with something that is not very scientific.

39
00:04:06.358 --> 00:04:08.459
but is very near and dear to my heart.

40
00:04:08.919 --> 00:04:22.906
And it has to do with the jersey that I currently have on my body, which was purchased at Stamford Bridge during the Carabao Cup against Tottenham Hotspur, the second biggest team in London behind Chelsea.

41
00:04:23.306 --> 00:04:24.967
And this is happening prior to...

42
00:04:26.061 --> 00:04:33.204
our first game against the third biggest team in London, Arsenal, which will be happening on Labor Day on Monday.

43
00:04:33.944 --> 00:04:36.845
And my assumption is that we're going to win that game.

44
00:04:37.425 --> 00:04:52.051
So I'm wearing this jersey in celebration of the unexpected success of Xabi Alonso's vision to bring Chelsea Football Club to a Premier League

45
00:04:53.567 --> 00:04:55.248
Championship in his first year.

46
00:04:55.829 --> 00:04:56.469
It's going to happen.

47
00:04:56.750 --> 00:04:57.410
It's going to happen.

48
00:04:57.911 --> 00:05:01.373
I predicted that for the first time in five years, we're going to beat Arsenal.

49
00:05:02.234 --> 00:05:03.495
I believe it will happen.

50
00:05:03.515 --> 00:05:04.816
You don't beat Arsenal in five.

51
00:05:04.856 --> 00:05:05.477
Let's not talk about it.

52
00:05:05.497 --> 00:05:10.541
Their biggest team in London is Chelsea, Tottenham, Arsenal.

53
00:05:11.522 --> 00:05:13.243
West Ham, we won't even talk about that.

54
00:05:14.106 --> 00:05:15.988
And so up the Chels.

55
00:05:16.629 --> 00:05:18.530
Well done, boys, on a big victory.

56
00:05:18.951 --> 00:05:20.372
I will stop with the sports ball talk.

57
00:05:20.772 --> 00:05:22.935
We're going to have a fun, relaxing episode.

58
00:05:22.955 --> 00:05:24.356
We're just going to do a little bit of a rundown.

59
00:05:24.376 --> 00:05:25.657
We're going into the fall season.

60
00:05:26.478 --> 00:05:27.539
And there's a couple of different...

61
00:05:29.451 --> 00:05:31.873
big scientific events that are happening.

62
00:05:32.133 --> 00:05:37.138
And so we're just going to do a very light overview of what those look like.

63
00:05:37.678 --> 00:05:47.547
So unlike some of our normal deep dives, we're just going to cover the surface, but still keep it focused on the science because this is from First Principles.

64
00:06:01.675 --> 00:06:05.396
So we're beginning the fall season in science.

65
00:06:05.416 --> 00:06:14.379
And one of our main events that we are excited for, some may say it's the Ballon d'Or of science.

66
00:06:14.779 --> 00:06:18.161
It's like the Oscars is the Nobel Prizes.

67
00:06:19.121 --> 00:06:24.643
And we usually, like we did last year, cover the big three.

68
00:06:25.003 --> 00:06:25.163
Yep.

69
00:06:26.248 --> 00:06:29.691
which will be medicine on Monday.

70
00:06:30.131 --> 00:06:32.593
This is going to be from October 5th through 12th.

71
00:06:32.993 --> 00:06:33.954
We care about three days.

72
00:06:34.715 --> 00:06:40.339
Medicine Monday, physics Tuesday, chemistry Wednesday, and then the rest, the rest.

73
00:06:40.459 --> 00:06:40.679
Yeah.

74
00:06:40.899 --> 00:06:43.561
Our marquee games are at the beginning of the week.

75
00:06:44.602 --> 00:06:50.207
And I'm really excited because we did, you did, you did pretty good last year.

76
00:06:50.667 --> 00:06:52.349
I got one out of the three.

77
00:06:52.849 --> 00:06:53.069
Yes.

78
00:06:53.149 --> 00:06:59.535
Last year, which honestly, I don't think you guys understand the probability of getting this right.

79
00:07:00.203 --> 00:07:09.848
In all of chemistry, in all of medicine, in all of physics, to get the prediction right is not easy.

80
00:07:09.948 --> 00:07:11.229
But I got Omar Yagi.

81
00:07:11.509 --> 00:07:12.269
Yes.

82
00:07:12.309 --> 00:07:21.674
We've talked about him a lot, actually, on this podcast, not just for the Nobel Prizes, but also for his transfer to China, to Tsinghua University.

83
00:07:22.554 --> 00:07:27.701
So I got that one right, and I will be making my own predictions this time as well.

84
00:07:28.041 --> 00:07:31.465
Actually, this is something that you guys should say in the comments.

85
00:07:32.540 --> 00:07:37.185
Who do you think is going to get the medicine, physics, and chemistry Nobel Prizes?

86
00:07:37.285 --> 00:07:44.332
I'd like to know so that I can maybe piggyback off of your predictions when we make our prediction episode.

87
00:07:44.352 --> 00:07:46.835
Because I'd like to go two years in a row.

88
00:07:46.875 --> 00:07:47.475
Back to back.

89
00:07:47.495 --> 00:07:49.377
Back to back making a prediction, you know?

90
00:07:49.618 --> 00:07:51.960
You know who else has gone back to back with winning the Prem?

91
00:07:52.300 --> 00:07:52.761
Chelsea.

92
00:07:53.361 --> 00:07:54.102
You know who hasn't?

93
00:07:54.322 --> 00:07:54.683
Arsenal.

94
00:07:56.165 --> 00:07:56.585
Just saying.

95
00:07:56.885 --> 00:07:57.246
Just saying.

96
00:07:57.266 --> 00:07:59.447
Dude, my cousins are going to be so pissed.

97
00:08:00.248 --> 00:08:04.170
For those who are interested in that prediction episode, it's our episode 10.

98
00:08:04.590 --> 00:08:11.855
We did talk about some other things within that episode, but that episode 10 is where we did our Nobel Prize 2025 predictions.

99
00:08:14.096 --> 00:08:15.097
And it's a great episode.

100
00:08:15.137 --> 00:08:34.571
We also covered two of my favorite Nobel Prizes, the LIGO, which is the gravitational wave observatory that first detected gravitational waves, and also CRISPR, which is the great genomic technology that is giving us so many strides in the biomedical field.

101
00:08:36.296 --> 00:08:46.304
And for those who would like to get a preview of what it'll look like when we do our Nobel Prize episodes, it's going to be a little bit different than how we do our normal episodes.

102
00:08:46.364 --> 00:08:54.750
Because each day, we're going to basically do it the day of and release standalones for each of the prizes during Nobel Prize week.

103
00:08:54.770 --> 00:08:55.391
This is a big deal.

104
00:08:55.811 --> 00:08:56.231
Yeah.

105
00:08:56.272 --> 00:08:57.713
This is our favorite time of the year.

106
00:08:58.073 --> 00:09:00.776
So you're going to get live daily drops.

107
00:09:01.316 --> 00:09:06.201
And then we also will compile it into a long form episode.

108
00:09:06.241 --> 00:09:14.969
So last year's episode 11 was a two and a half hour epic that combined each of the days where we stay up until we're up at 2 a.m.

109
00:09:15.669 --> 00:09:17.910
When it first drops, we see the drop.

110
00:09:18.230 --> 00:09:24.791
We then dig into the background of it and give an explainer, just like our deep dives that you all are so used to.

111
00:09:25.451 --> 00:09:27.192
It's a really fun time of the year.

112
00:09:27.592 --> 00:09:36.154
Last year's that we covered in that episode where it was macroscopic quantum tunneling for physics, metal organic frameworks for chemistry.

113
00:09:36.534 --> 00:09:42.935
And one of my favorites, which was a sleeper, peripheral immune tolerance in medicine was super fascinating because,

114
00:09:43.275 --> 00:09:44.336
It was very, very interesting.

115
00:09:44.356 --> 00:09:49.718
And we've talked about the immune system a lot in correlation with a lot of our medical or bio stories.

116
00:09:49.878 --> 00:09:56.282
So you can catch either the individual explainers or the big summary episode.

117
00:09:56.342 --> 00:10:04.746
It's definitely worth a watch as we prepare a month from now for one of the most exciting science stories of the year.

118
00:10:05.137 --> 00:10:13.580
And let me just tell everyone who's in the comments and in the DMs telling us to cover the economics prize.

119
00:10:14.141 --> 00:10:17.962
First of all, the economics prize is not a real Nobel Prize.

120
00:10:17.982 --> 00:10:20.803
That's why it's called the Nobel Memorial Prize.

121
00:10:20.863 --> 00:10:25.345
No, it's the Memorial Prize in Economics in Memory of Alfred Nobel Prize.

122
00:10:25.675 --> 00:10:31.577
Because in his will, he did not think that the economics prize was something that he was going to dish out money for.

123
00:10:31.957 --> 00:10:32.197
Why?

124
00:10:32.257 --> 00:10:34.778
Because the economics is not a real science.

125
00:10:35.438 --> 00:10:38.539
And I don't know how many times I need to say this, but I'm just going to say it again.

126
00:10:38.680 --> 00:10:39.260
It's not.

127
00:10:40.560 --> 00:10:41.540
So let's just move on.

128
00:10:42.501 --> 00:10:44.582
All right.

129
00:10:45.142 --> 00:10:46.242
And we will be moving on.

130
00:10:46.262 --> 00:10:53.925
And what's so interesting about the fall, which is why we wanted to do a fall season rundown, is the Nobel Prizes are not the only –

131
00:10:54.777 --> 00:10:59.640
award show that really recognizes science.

132
00:10:59.920 --> 00:11:10.766
And the other one that's coming a little bit sooner, I think it'll be probably a few weeks, but a week or few weeks before the Nobels is going to be the golden goose awards.

133
00:11:11.606 --> 00:11:11.867
And, and,

134
00:11:12.688 --> 00:11:25.451
What's interesting about the Golden Goose Awards, many of you may not be actually super familiar with the Golden Goose Awards, which is done by AAAS, the same nonprofit that produces the journal Science.

135
00:11:25.491 --> 00:11:28.272
We cover a lot on the show.

136
00:11:28.652 --> 00:11:34.113
And the idea behind the Golden Goose Awards is it celebrates federally funded research.

137
00:11:35.051 --> 00:11:37.793
that unexpectedly benefits society.

138
00:11:39.074 --> 00:11:47.601
We talk a lot about this on the pod where the benefit of basic research, you know, sometimes the Nobels are areas where people know that there's something.

139
00:11:47.781 --> 00:11:48.001
Yeah.

140
00:11:48.361 --> 00:11:52.184
And so they go after the thing where they know there's something.

141
00:11:52.464 --> 00:11:52.685
Yeah.

142
00:11:52.965 --> 00:12:00.951
And the Golden Goose is sort of like, well, the thing that they discovered actually had this weird other benefit that was not expected based on what they were studying initially.

143
00:12:01.451 --> 00:12:03.293
And a perfect example of this is,

144
00:12:04.090 --> 00:12:16.694
Which is a callback to our last episode, episode 56, where we talked about combating brain disease, MS, and others through the study of evolutionary pharmacology.

145
00:12:16.754 --> 00:12:17.094
Yes.

146
00:12:17.254 --> 00:12:18.194
That's right.

147
00:12:19.034 --> 00:12:19.614
Right.

148
00:12:19.735 --> 00:12:31.258
In 2013, the Golden Goose Award was given to Dr. John Eng, and he had federally funded research on, drumroll please, Gila monster venom.

149
00:12:32.024 --> 00:12:39.391
Which, as we talked about in our last episode, was the precursor that created GLP-1s like Ozempic and Wegovi.

150
00:12:39.792 --> 00:12:40.312
Wegovi?

151
00:12:40.392 --> 00:12:41.433
I think it's pronounced Wegovi.

152
00:12:42.214 --> 00:12:45.878
And so this is the idea that how do we go from...

153
00:12:47.758 --> 00:12:56.991
a venomous animal in an extreme environment to a diabetes and obesity, weight loss drug.

154
00:12:57.011 --> 00:12:58.874
That's exceptionally popular.

155
00:12:59.294 --> 00:13:01.498
And sometimes the through line is not very clear.

156
00:13:01.518 --> 00:13:02.519
And I think that's the focus.

157
00:13:02.539 --> 00:13:02.639
Yeah.

158
00:13:03.300 --> 00:13:05.322
for the Golden Goose, which is super interesting.

159
00:13:05.342 --> 00:13:10.866
And I think we're exploring potentially adding it into our coverage as a part of the show.

160
00:13:11.086 --> 00:13:11.786
Exactly, yeah.

161
00:13:11.886 --> 00:13:20.013
And I mean, it underscores this idea of fundamental science for science's sake, for curiosity's sake.

162
00:13:20.493 --> 00:13:23.195
The idea that if there is an interesting question out there,

163
00:13:24.703 --> 00:13:34.969
Maybe it is worth pursuing an answer just because it's a question out there that has piqued our curiosity as humanity about the natural world around us.

164
00:13:35.790 --> 00:13:38.411
We don't know what it's going to come up with, right?

165
00:13:40.512 --> 00:13:44.616
There are so many examples of this in the history of science.

166
00:13:44.636 --> 00:13:48.400
I mean, CRISPR came out of us studying the bacterial immune system.

167
00:13:48.820 --> 00:13:55.607
If you told someone, hey, I'm studying the bacterial immune system, they'd be like, why is my taxpayer dollars going to study that?

168
00:13:56.126 --> 00:13:59.929
Well, it gives us all of the genetic technologies that we know and love.

169
00:14:01.110 --> 00:14:04.472
GLP-1 and the Gila monster venom is another one of these.

170
00:14:05.233 --> 00:14:16.121
I think as a society, we need to be very proud of the fact that we support this kind of research because it shows, you know, just sort of where we stand and what we're after.

171
00:14:16.141 --> 00:14:16.962
Yeah.

172
00:14:17.347 --> 00:14:25.173
I know many of you, I'm sure, are being bombarded by GLP One ads in your Instagram and TikTok feeds everywhere.

173
00:14:25.933 --> 00:14:26.714
And you can thank people.

174
00:14:28.323 --> 00:14:33.407
John Ang, who figured out the active ingredient in this Gila monster venom.

175
00:14:33.427 --> 00:14:47.679
And I think this is an active area of conversation right now because there is an ongoing battle within the political architecture around two aspects of grants.

176
00:14:48.079 --> 00:14:51.382
Grants being the money that goes into research and development.

177
00:14:51.962 --> 00:14:56.886
Research and development is a very wide surface area of things.

178
00:14:57.407 --> 00:14:57.687
Yeah.

179
00:14:57.987 --> 00:15:03.168
R&amp;D and funding for basic research does not just exist within the National Science Foundation.

180
00:15:03.668 --> 00:15:12.750
National Science Foundation is 4% of the entire research and development budget that the federal government puts money into.

181
00:15:13.050 --> 00:15:20.992
The majority of that actually goes to, unsurprisingly, the Department of Defense, recently rebranded the Department of War.

182
00:15:21.972 --> 00:15:25.193
The second place is Health and Human Services, HHS.

183
00:15:25.653 --> 00:15:27.373
So a lot of times when people talk about,

184
00:15:27.838 --> 00:15:29.439
Funding for scientific research.

185
00:15:29.899 --> 00:15:33.802
Scientific research happens in a lot of these other agencies.

186
00:15:34.662 --> 00:15:35.783
This includes NASA.

187
00:15:36.584 --> 00:15:38.385
This includes the Department of Energy.

188
00:15:39.869 --> 00:15:55.452
And several others, and the point I'm just bringing up here is while the NSF is probably the agency where the majority of their funding is purely focused on basic research as opposed to applied research, right?

189
00:15:55.492 --> 00:16:00.493
The idea that you have a specific commercial outcome that you're driving towards.

190
00:16:01.533 --> 00:16:09.155
We actually have a great tool on the site now that looks at the history of funding by the federal government and by the private sector.

191
00:16:10.450 --> 00:16:17.917
since the 1950s that shows how the government was the largest funder of this research, both basic and applied.

192
00:16:18.317 --> 00:16:25.043
And the private sector is now well outsizing the federal government in terms of research and development funding.

193
00:16:25.884 --> 00:16:29.107
Most of the private sector is applied versus basic.

194
00:16:29.508 --> 00:16:30.288
That's a key difference.

195
00:16:30.769 --> 00:16:34.752
And so the current battle that's happening around who gets to decide what,

196
00:16:35.673 --> 00:17:00.554
what ideas get grant funding and there's this move to say we want less basic research and more applied research i think one of the big things that's missing from that conversation is the private sector is already well is funding applied research well beyond the scope of anything close to the amount of money that's coming from the federal government yeah and so we're not lacking applied research

197
00:17:01.025 --> 00:17:01.185
Yeah.

198
00:17:01.205 --> 00:17:04.146
Research and like, like we're not lacking funding in that arena.

199
00:17:04.166 --> 00:17:04.586
That's a good point.

200
00:17:04.666 --> 00:17:04.846
Yeah.

201
00:17:04.866 --> 00:17:07.226
Like the federal government does not need to put more money in that.

202
00:17:07.386 --> 00:17:07.607
Yeah.

203
00:17:07.707 --> 00:17:10.227
It's like, so, and again, you can see this directly.

204
00:17:10.407 --> 00:17:15.788
So there's this argument like, Oh, we want federal government funding more things that become commercial technologies.

205
00:17:16.329 --> 00:17:16.669
Why?

206
00:17:16.989 --> 00:17:20.009
There's already too much money going into that arena.

207
00:17:20.410 --> 00:17:27.271
And these basic research ideas that the goal and goose awards identifies that end up having GLP ones.

208
00:17:27.291 --> 00:17:30.852
Like we talked about last episode is going to be a driver of GDP growth in America.

209
00:17:31.172 --> 00:17:31.372
Yeah.

210
00:17:31.672 --> 00:17:32.032
Period.

211
00:17:32.412 --> 00:17:33.573
Because of how successful it is.

212
00:17:34.233 --> 00:17:39.014
And if that federal research grant to study Gila monster venom was not given.

213
00:17:39.034 --> 00:17:39.454
Yeah.

214
00:17:40.274 --> 00:17:40.874
None of that would have.

215
00:17:41.595 --> 00:17:42.955
LA would look very different right now.

216
00:17:42.975 --> 00:17:43.935
I'm just saying.

217
00:17:44.275 --> 00:17:44.515
Yeah.

218
00:17:44.795 --> 00:17:45.316
I'm just saying.

219
00:17:45.596 --> 00:17:45.896
100%.

220
00:17:46.156 --> 00:17:48.216
There's a lot of nuance to the funding conversation.

221
00:17:49.257 --> 00:17:51.117
And I think it's important to understand the data.

222
00:17:51.137 --> 00:17:58.659
And one of the things we try to do here at FFP is we have seen a lot of comments as we've talked about funding.

223
00:18:00.583 --> 00:18:03.705
And part of the thing we did was like, okay, let's go look at the data.

224
00:18:04.125 --> 00:18:11.549
And not only look at the data, but give you all as the audience the ability to also look at the data and understand what's actually happening here.

225
00:18:12.149 --> 00:18:13.489
We'll continue to talk about this.

226
00:18:13.790 --> 00:18:18.332
There's an ongoing conversation about where funding goes and why.

227
00:18:19.192 --> 00:18:27.677
And one of the interesting things about basic research in the federal government is the majority of it goes to the hard sciences.

228
00:18:27.697 --> 00:18:28.157
Mm-hmm.

229
00:18:28.717 --> 00:18:30.018
And not the social sciences.

230
00:18:30.559 --> 00:18:44.173
And a big talking point, as we've seen, is people interdigitating the culture war without understanding the data of how much of the funding goes to what they perceive to be social sciences that are not important.

231
00:18:44.553 --> 00:18:45.294
They are important.

232
00:18:46.235 --> 00:18:49.119
But the majority of the funding is not going to the things that people are complaining about.

233
00:18:49.159 --> 00:18:49.660
Yeah, yeah.

234
00:18:50.221 --> 00:18:50.962
And it's a very...

235
00:18:51.182 --> 00:18:52.745
So again, check out the tracker.

236
00:18:52.845 --> 00:18:57.491
And those who don't want the funding to go to sciences will use that tiny fringe...

237
00:18:57.712 --> 00:18:58.112
Correct.

238
00:18:58.373 --> 00:18:59.835
To justify...

239
00:19:01.292 --> 00:19:24.362
a blanket wholesale wholesale like overhaul of the federal funding infrastructure look there's a reason why america is at the forefront of technology and it has been since post-war and it's because we have invested clearly in fundamental science right so before you go on your tirade about how oh

240
00:19:24.800 --> 00:19:29.544
You know, it's because taxpayer dollars are going into pseudoscience.

241
00:19:29.864 --> 00:19:31.425
The numbers do not agree with you.

242
00:19:31.805 --> 00:19:32.806
The data does not.

243
00:19:32.866 --> 00:19:33.307
Yeah.

244
00:19:33.387 --> 00:19:33.767
That's not.

245
00:19:33.867 --> 00:19:37.670
And again, we've provided it so that it can be looked at.

246
00:19:37.770 --> 00:19:43.815
And this is like it's a valid conversation to have about like how do we as a democracy choose to spend our money?

247
00:19:43.955 --> 00:19:44.155
Mm-hmm.

248
00:19:45.785 --> 00:19:51.686
Science R&amp;D as compared to the rest of the U.S. national budget is a rounding error.

249
00:19:51.867 --> 00:19:52.467
Yeah, yeah.

250
00:19:52.847 --> 00:19:55.187
And so if you're worried about your taxpayer money.

251
00:19:55.527 --> 00:19:56.828
And the value per dollar.

252
00:19:56.868 --> 00:19:59.768
Yeah, it's like well outside the other ways we spend our money.

253
00:20:00.709 --> 00:20:05.730
Maybe like all these tax credits and stuff we're giving to record profit corporations –

254
00:20:06.170 --> 00:20:09.872
Hey, maybe that's a great area to start to claw back taxpayer dollars.

255
00:20:09.912 --> 00:20:10.192
Yeah.

256
00:20:10.972 --> 00:20:11.593
Just an idea.

257
00:20:12.233 --> 00:20:12.813
Just an idea.

258
00:20:13.553 --> 00:20:22.938
So, again, the Golden Goose Awards really tries to identify this connection between curiosity-based research and these outsized impacts on all of us.

259
00:20:23.738 --> 00:20:27.280
And as you can see, we're just breezing through today, guys.

260
00:20:28.200 --> 00:20:29.582
It's been a couple of tough episodes.

261
00:20:29.602 --> 00:20:36.108
We did Jacobian conjecture, Riemann hypothesis, two-part quantum computing.

262
00:20:36.288 --> 00:20:36.568
Yeah.

263
00:20:37.729 --> 00:20:39.771
Six hours total over two episodes.

264
00:20:39.791 --> 00:20:40.032
Yeah.

265
00:20:40.712 --> 00:20:44.616
And then a phenomenal deep dive on this evolutionary pharmacology episode.

266
00:20:45.517 --> 00:20:48.119
I'm trying to – guys, I'm trying to give Krishna a break here, okay?

267
00:20:48.139 --> 00:20:48.240
Yeah.

268
00:20:49.027 --> 00:20:49.667
It's been a lot.

269
00:20:49.847 --> 00:20:50.348
It's tough.

270
00:20:50.648 --> 00:20:51.348
It's weekly.

271
00:20:52.148 --> 00:20:52.808
It's dense.

272
00:20:53.149 --> 00:20:56.230
We really try to do our research, provide the information.

273
00:20:57.250 --> 00:20:58.150
It's just the two of us.

274
00:20:58.250 --> 00:20:59.191
We're doing the best we can.

275
00:20:59.211 --> 00:21:04.933
We're going to take a quick break here and talk about the shilling we have to.

276
00:21:05.653 --> 00:21:10.075
For those listening for the first time, this is not like our normal episodes.

277
00:21:10.695 --> 00:21:13.056
We're talking about some of our great episodes that go into deep dives.

278
00:21:13.376 --> 00:21:15.137
But one of the things we did want to do.

279
00:21:16.194 --> 00:21:26.820
is take an opportunity to look at one of our recent upgrades that many of you may not know.

280
00:21:27.240 --> 00:21:32.924
I always talk about the website and the fact that it's a great resource.

281
00:21:33.944 --> 00:21:41.829
And I think many may not have noticed that we did a huge – Ooh, look at that.

282
00:21:42.369 --> 00:21:43.610
We did a huge revamp.

283
00:21:44.079 --> 00:21:51.222
On the website, you can see our platonic solids on the homepage now doing our animation around Farm First Principles.

284
00:21:51.262 --> 00:22:01.206
But I wanted to take this opportunity to identify, because we have so many new listeners that have joined us just in the last couple of weeks.

285
00:22:02.007 --> 00:22:05.208
And our archive is absolute gold.

286
00:22:05.848 --> 00:22:09.870
And so I wanted to go through and ask you, our resident PhD, Krishna, to...

287
00:22:10.650 --> 00:22:21.153
What are some of your favorite episodes or ones that you think that the viewers should take a look at if they want to kind of go back into the archives to see something they might be interested in?

288
00:22:21.313 --> 00:22:21.953
Sure.

289
00:22:22.013 --> 00:22:22.174
Yeah.

290
00:22:22.194 --> 00:22:27.255
I mean, one of the big ones that I'm proud of is the Riemann hypothesis episode, episode 53.

291
00:22:28.315 --> 00:22:29.756
But I think a lot of the new...

292
00:22:31.087 --> 00:22:34.589
a lot of the new viewers may have actually come from that.

293
00:22:34.769 --> 00:22:38.411
So let's go to some of the other ones that are a bit older.

294
00:22:39.431 --> 00:22:47.715
The one before that would have to be, I think, if you go down, episode 46 and 47, our America 250 celebration.

295
00:22:48.636 --> 00:22:52.698
This is where I compiled a giant list of some 400-plus viewers

296
00:22:54.448 --> 00:22:58.451
American achievements in science and technology and patents.

297
00:22:59.292 --> 00:23:02.715
And it was something that we had planned for just one episode.

298
00:23:02.735 --> 00:23:03.055
Yep.

299
00:23:03.335 --> 00:23:04.876
And it became so much.

300
00:23:04.936 --> 00:23:08.900
And we had these... We had these... Outrageous outfits.

301
00:23:08.980 --> 00:23:14.344
Outrageous outfits because it was our 250th birthday as a nation, as a nation that has...

302
00:23:14.756 --> 00:23:19.500
contributed so much to humanity in terms of science and technology.

303
00:23:20.561 --> 00:23:24.064
So I would definitely suggest checking those out.

304
00:23:24.144 --> 00:23:27.426
If you want a fast-paced kind of, what did we do?

305
00:23:28.593 --> 00:23:33.536
It just goes through timeline one after the other of all the things that we have done.

306
00:23:34.396 --> 00:23:45.843
And for those who would like to go through the interactive timeline that we actually go through on the episode, you can go through innovation and discovery by discovery at our America 250 page.

307
00:23:46.423 --> 00:23:49.465
It's a great way to just do a retrospective on it.

308
00:23:49.945 --> 00:23:51.906
That is a great episode to reference.

309
00:23:52.346 --> 00:23:53.367
That is fantastic.

310
00:23:53.787 --> 00:23:54.568
So I like that one.

311
00:23:54.588 --> 00:23:55.368
That's a good call out.

312
00:23:55.468 --> 00:23:56.509
Yeah, that one's a good one.

313
00:23:57.810 --> 00:24:07.057
After that, I would say Harder Than Diamond, episode 38, when we did our second new hexagonal diamond.

314
00:24:07.537 --> 00:24:11.880
That one was a really good one because there was such a nice human story behind it.

315
00:24:12.221 --> 00:24:13.782
There were two Chinese groups that...

316
00:24:14.482 --> 00:24:21.524
I think basically hate each other, that were like trying to claim that they had gotten the new hexagonal diamond first.

317
00:24:21.624 --> 00:24:33.408
And we went into some of the intricacies of the reviewer comments about how the reviewers didn't believe them and how this group had to really convince them.

318
00:24:33.908 --> 00:24:36.529
And once they convinced them, the reviewers went to bat for them.

319
00:24:36.649 --> 00:24:38.470
And then they basically had like a...

320
00:24:39.390 --> 00:25:00.345
duel in the press where the old hexagonal diamonds guy were like they didn't do anything new and then the reviewer's like no kind of i mean it's it's it's a really fun cool human story about just how competitive yes science is and specifically how competitive chinese science is in the modern day

321
00:25:00.865 --> 00:25:09.569
I also think another good, interesting part about that episode specifically was unpacking – the word peer review gets thrown around a lot.

322
00:25:09.589 --> 00:25:09.829
Yeah.

323
00:25:10.450 --> 00:25:13.151
What does it actually mean in practice?

324
00:25:13.251 --> 00:25:14.832
How rigorous is it really?

325
00:25:14.892 --> 00:25:15.872
Yeah.

326
00:25:16.373 --> 00:25:26.578
And I think because we, again, went into the actual peer review files and talked about the back and forth, and I think it was a great expose in how –

327
00:25:28.380 --> 00:25:32.545
how robust that process is and what it actually looks like.

328
00:25:32.565 --> 00:25:33.166
That's a great one.

329
00:25:33.306 --> 00:25:34.708
Yeah, that's a really good one.

330
00:25:35.029 --> 00:25:36.651
Episode 35 is really great.

331
00:25:36.791 --> 00:25:41.958
It's about our good friend, Daniel Toker's Science of Consciousness.

332
00:25:42.539 --> 00:25:43.160
He is...

333
00:25:43.620 --> 00:25:45.562
the brain scientist on Instagram.

334
00:25:45.582 --> 00:25:48.204
He has a bunch of followers, a great scientific communicator.

335
00:25:49.065 --> 00:26:00.916
Definitely check out that episode because he had developed a new AI model to not only detect consciousness, but also figure out ways to, you know, wake them up, which is a big deal.

336
00:26:00.936 --> 00:26:00.996
Um,

337
00:26:01.156 --> 00:26:27.097
like people in comas it was it was a huge deal and it was a really eye-opener for me because i didn't know a lot about this subject so when i was researching it um i had a bunch of calls with him i mean he's a good friend of ours a former classmate at princeton university so it was really nice to be able to just call up the first author yeah on the phone and be like hey what what was this figure exactly and then he'd be like well okay this is how i did it it was really cool to see that happen

338
00:26:27.455 --> 00:26:31.597
And if you want to see me with extra short hair, this is a great episode to check out.

339
00:26:32.277 --> 00:26:34.398
And when you say AI models, I want to be clear.

340
00:26:34.418 --> 00:26:38.540
There's a difference between what people think of just generative AI.

341
00:26:38.680 --> 00:26:39.380
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

342
00:26:39.400 --> 00:26:40.220
Sure.

343
00:26:40.641 --> 00:26:46.423
AI is a very broad term that addresses a wide variety of the technology.

344
00:26:46.463 --> 00:26:46.603
Yeah.

345
00:26:46.783 --> 00:26:51.005
And there are amazing ways in which it's being used in scientific context.

346
00:26:51.185 --> 00:26:51.865
Exactly, yeah.

347
00:26:52.005 --> 00:26:52.686
That was a very good one.

348
00:26:52.726 --> 00:26:53.466
Yeah, that was a good one.

349
00:26:54.166 --> 00:26:58.909
Episode 33, this is where can human neurons really play Doom?

350
00:26:58.929 --> 00:26:59.570
Oh, Doom!

351
00:27:00.270 --> 00:27:01.090
Can it play Doom?

352
00:27:01.111 --> 00:27:02.031
Classic question.

353
00:27:02.111 --> 00:27:09.616
We really went into the nitty gritties of what does that mean for a human petri dish of neurons to play Doom?

354
00:27:10.256 --> 00:27:14.859
How do you actually train a petri dish of human neurons to play Doom?

355
00:27:15.360 --> 00:27:19.423
How do you keep it alive long enough for it to learn how to play Doom?

356
00:27:19.603 --> 00:27:20.444
Because that was the claim.

357
00:27:20.724 --> 00:27:21.925
Yeah.

358
00:27:21.945 --> 00:27:24.246
And it turns out there's a little bit of hype.

359
00:27:25.657 --> 00:27:27.678
There's also some really cool science.

360
00:27:28.059 --> 00:27:34.243
But if you want to understand what is hype and what is science, that's a great way of figuring that out.

361
00:27:34.503 --> 00:27:37.485
What has been deemed wetware engineering.

362
00:27:37.905 --> 00:27:38.245
Yes.

363
00:27:39.726 --> 00:27:45.931
In the intelligence community, wetware or wetworks, I should say, is a very different connotation.

364
00:27:45.951 --> 00:27:48.412
But that is not the scope of this show.

365
00:27:48.693 --> 00:27:48.913
Yeah.

366
00:27:49.053 --> 00:27:49.573
Moving on.

367
00:27:49.993 --> 00:27:51.935
Next one, I'll actually go back to episode 23.

368
00:27:51.955 --> 00:27:52.055
23.

369
00:27:52.075 --> 00:27:52.175
Okay.

370
00:27:52.195 --> 00:27:52.295
Okay.

371
00:27:54.250 --> 00:28:11.611
um time vaults oh classic this one was this is a classic this one was crazy i mean it starts with um james webb telescope's little red dots which is already that's a great astrophysics story if you guys are interested but i think the real gem in this one is the time vault story

372
00:28:12.492 --> 00:28:36.123
um i think it's a future noble prize they basically i mean you you made the analogy of it's a mac time machine yeah it's but for your cells but for your cells which is it has incredible implications yeah for cancer research for just understanding how cells work in general i thought that was a that was a really really cool one this was one of my favorite episodes we've ever done

373
00:28:37.023 --> 00:28:43.028
Again, we've iterated on the show a couple of times, doing multiple stories in a single episode versus doing a deep dive.

374
00:28:43.808 --> 00:28:44.989
It's been an ebb and flow.

375
00:28:45.570 --> 00:28:49.913
But the Time Vaults segment in this episode is top tier.

376
00:28:50.293 --> 00:28:55.437
It's been one of our most popular clips, like set of clips on social media.

377
00:28:55.697 --> 00:28:56.138
100%.

378
00:28:56.158 --> 00:29:00.141
Because it is such an incredible, it's so incredible what they did.

379
00:29:00.161 --> 00:29:00.961
It's so good.

380
00:29:00.981 --> 00:29:01.442
It's so good.

381
00:29:01.742 --> 00:29:02.803
Next one, episode 20.

382
00:29:03.143 --> 00:29:03.643
Okay.

383
00:29:03.703 --> 00:29:04.124
This was...

384
00:29:05.504 --> 00:29:26.392
the fusion story that got us on joe rogan yes this is our christmas special in end of 2025 yes i'm so it was it was an unfortunate sort of situation because mit plasma physicist professor nuno lorero had been recently just murdered in cambridge in his apartment in

385
00:29:27.192 --> 00:29:30.336
what seems like a crazy, crazy situation.

386
00:29:30.376 --> 00:29:30.656
Yeah.

387
00:29:30.696 --> 00:29:39.286
But we wanted to just give him and his science the due spotlight that it deserves.

388
00:29:39.466 --> 00:29:42.930
And we talked about some of the science that he was responsible for.

389
00:29:43.330 --> 00:29:45.253
We went pretty deep and we talked about

390
00:29:46.313 --> 00:29:53.123
some of the fusion problems that he had solved, and some of the problems that his science is still solving to this day.

391
00:29:53.804 --> 00:29:59.232
This idea of fast magnetic reconnection, which is really fascinating.

392
00:29:59.252 --> 00:29:59.933
And obviously...

393
00:30:02.273 --> 00:30:24.428
This area, particularly within circles in this new nuclear age in America, it's really important because we've seen a lot of these micro-nuclear reactor startups and there's this reinvigoration of looking at this as a means of energy production.

394
00:30:24.608 --> 00:30:25.049
Exactly.

395
00:30:25.209 --> 00:30:29.672
And there's some fundamentals in here that are interesting as it relates to understanding that.

396
00:30:30.550 --> 00:30:56.282
that boom, um, it did get us shout out to, to young Jamie who pulled us up out of the blue, uh, while they were talking about, uh, UFOs, yeah, where the connection was, I don't really remember, but, uh, we did get a, a huge shout out there, which again, yeah, I mean, look, regardless of what you think about the Joe Rogan podcast, it's the, it's the biggest podcast out there.

397
00:30:56.803 --> 00:30:59.384
And for, for two unknowns like us,

398
00:30:59.794 --> 00:31:02.615
who just started a podcast like six months ago.

399
00:31:02.915 --> 00:31:05.016
At that point, it was five months in.

400
00:31:05.136 --> 00:31:10.079
Yeah, like five months in to get like a shout out on the Joe Rogan podcast.

401
00:31:10.119 --> 00:31:11.299
We thought it was a pretty cool deal.

402
00:31:11.779 --> 00:31:24.965
And I will say, if we can bring that audience in and talk to them and help them understand the idea of what we try to do it from, first principles, we can start to kind of, again, combat this anti-science movement, this conspiracy-laden movement.

403
00:31:25.045 --> 00:31:28.847
And just like we have the tools to understand information.

404
00:31:28.907 --> 00:31:29.127
Yeah.

405
00:31:30.277 --> 00:31:30.837
We got to do it.

406
00:31:31.278 --> 00:31:34.920
Next one, episode 19, the one right before the double helix episode.

407
00:31:34.961 --> 00:31:35.901
We were on a heater.

408
00:31:36.282 --> 00:31:37.522
That one was a good episode.

409
00:31:37.542 --> 00:31:39.684
I got to say, that one was a good episode.

410
00:31:40.264 --> 00:31:41.225
The Watson and Crick.

411
00:31:41.265 --> 00:31:42.466
Watson is not the guy.

412
00:31:43.947 --> 00:31:45.508
Christian in his Chamath fit.

413
00:31:46.369 --> 00:31:49.152
And I literally do the thing.

414
00:31:50.214 --> 00:31:52.316
I think you literally called it out, right?

415
00:31:52.356 --> 00:31:53.478
Yeah, yeah.

416
00:31:53.518 --> 00:31:59.785
This was about the human story behind the discovery of the structure of DNA.

417
00:32:00.246 --> 00:32:03.349
It was commemorating James Watson, who had recently died.

418
00:32:04.050 --> 00:32:07.231
his legacy, both the good and a lot of the bad.

419
00:32:07.271 --> 00:32:09.492
We don't shy away from the bad on this podcast.

420
00:32:09.832 --> 00:32:18.094
So we talked about Watson, Crick, and Rosalind Franklin, and that human story, which is full of drama.

421
00:32:18.234 --> 00:32:20.295
It's like something that you could make a movie out of.

422
00:32:20.315 --> 00:32:20.595
100%.

423
00:32:20.615 --> 00:32:21.215
Yeah.

424
00:32:21.495 --> 00:32:27.697
And I believe, actually, Natalie Portman is going to be starring in a movie very soon where she is playing Rosalind Franklin.

425
00:32:27.937 --> 00:32:29.998
Oh, so for the... Yeah, I heard on The Grapevine...

426
00:32:30.358 --> 00:32:40.467
So for the producers who are working on that, scientific advisors, even for creator marketing promotion, were the best in the business.

427
00:32:40.527 --> 00:32:40.808
Yeah.

428
00:32:41.068 --> 00:32:41.849
You know where to find us.

429
00:32:41.889 --> 00:32:42.789
Yep, exactly.

430
00:32:43.050 --> 00:32:48.234
This is actually, it's the same episode that has the first Unbreakable Diamonds story.

431
00:32:48.555 --> 00:32:49.135
Ah, yes, yes.

432
00:32:49.295 --> 00:32:50.176
So the first episode.

433
00:32:52.438 --> 00:33:20.463
group that showed hexagonal diamonds and then they're the ones that were shitting on the the more recent episode yes um but the hacking the human brain one was really cool because it was a mind reading brain computer interface yes yes that at its at its face was something that is very benign because you know a lot of people have debilitating paralysis and so they can't actually express what they mean this is something that was reading inner

434
00:33:21.952 --> 00:33:23.833
Well, it gets a little hairy.

435
00:33:23.933 --> 00:33:24.974
It gets very dicey.

436
00:33:25.054 --> 00:33:28.435
We get into some of these questions there.

437
00:33:28.975 --> 00:33:37.440
I will note for those who are watching the show right now, you can see the production has evolved quite a bit.

438
00:33:37.460 --> 00:33:38.720
Yeah, it has actually.

439
00:33:38.740 --> 00:33:39.361
Look at that.

440
00:33:39.421 --> 00:33:42.082
Since we started, it's taken a while.

441
00:33:43.262 --> 00:33:45.924
But one of the things that's always been consistent...

442
00:33:46.604 --> 00:33:50.246
is we've been overlay heavy since day one.

443
00:33:50.306 --> 00:33:53.468
Always citing sources has been a key part of the show.

444
00:33:54.869 --> 00:33:57.190
Shout out Princeton Tigers, as you can see.

445
00:33:57.610 --> 00:34:00.192
This is a very trip down memory lane.

446
00:34:00.212 --> 00:34:01.313
This is a month in.

447
00:34:01.633 --> 00:34:02.333
This is literally.

448
00:34:02.954 --> 00:34:05.795
I mean, this is our fifth episode.

449
00:34:05.875 --> 00:34:08.177
We had just five weeks in.

450
00:34:08.777 --> 00:34:10.918
We were just like, yeah, let's just keep going.

451
00:34:11.158 --> 00:34:13.500
Look at how we look so old now.

452
00:34:13.620 --> 00:34:14.000
Come here.

453
00:34:15.699 --> 00:34:16.360
We do.

454
00:34:16.380 --> 00:34:16.960
Oh, my gosh.

455
00:34:16.980 --> 00:34:19.442
We've aged so much in that time.

456
00:34:19.462 --> 00:34:20.303
In like a year.

457
00:34:20.323 --> 00:34:20.843
In a year.

458
00:34:20.863 --> 00:34:21.264
Oh, my God.

459
00:34:21.644 --> 00:34:23.446
Look, the content hamster wheel is tough, y'all.

460
00:34:23.486 --> 00:34:24.126
I don't recommend it.

461
00:34:24.146 --> 00:34:25.127
Well, I'm a father, right?

462
00:34:25.167 --> 00:34:27.910
So I don't know what your excuse is.

463
00:34:27.930 --> 00:34:29.071
Look, look, look.

464
00:34:29.191 --> 00:34:30.031
I agree with you.

465
00:34:30.392 --> 00:34:31.733
My hairline is not receding.

466
00:34:31.773 --> 00:34:32.674
I was born this way.

467
00:34:33.454 --> 00:34:59.506
uh so that's not where it's coming from yeah and then finally i think i think the last one i would say is just episode one if you want to see like where we started where we started where we yeah it was it was i just i still remember this day when we were like you know what yeah whatever let's let's let's post it oh my god look at this we still had the platonic solids the color scheme is different now we've we've honed in on it honed in on it we didn't have a logo yet yep um

468
00:35:00.306 --> 00:35:05.113
I'm still wearing Princeton at the time because I thought I needed to wear it for every episode.

469
00:35:05.694 --> 00:35:06.916
Studio is very different.

470
00:35:08.538 --> 00:35:09.279
Not that different.

471
00:35:09.300 --> 00:35:09.860
Same, same.

472
00:35:09.900 --> 00:35:10.381
Same, same.

473
00:35:10.501 --> 00:35:10.742
Yeah.

474
00:35:10.922 --> 00:35:11.443
But different.

475
00:35:11.543 --> 00:35:14.848
And at the time, we just basically had two static videos of both of us.

476
00:35:15.539 --> 00:35:18.161
awkwardly looking at each other across the video in the middle.

477
00:35:18.341 --> 00:35:18.541
Yeah.

478
00:35:18.621 --> 00:35:20.582
So clearly we've come a long way.

479
00:35:20.902 --> 00:35:31.249
But that's as a small kind of – for those who may be new to the show and haven't gone through the archive, there's a lot of great, great stuff.

480
00:35:31.269 --> 00:35:32.049
That's evergreen.

481
00:35:32.129 --> 00:35:33.830
It's stuff that's still relevant.

482
00:35:34.330 --> 00:35:38.813
Unlike news and sports where like this week it's relevant, next week it's not.

483
00:35:39.854 --> 00:35:41.755
A lot of what we talk about is timeless.

484
00:35:42.856 --> 00:35:43.356
And there is –

485
00:35:44.641 --> 00:35:46.142
It's not by accident.

486
00:35:46.602 --> 00:35:49.164
So again, the website is great.

487
00:35:49.324 --> 00:35:50.045
Actually, you know what?

488
00:35:50.085 --> 00:35:50.425
Hold on.

489
00:35:50.505 --> 00:35:51.366
We're having fun today.

490
00:35:51.406 --> 00:35:52.927
Let me do a couple more things.

491
00:35:52.947 --> 00:35:54.528
Yeah, no, you should show them, dude.

492
00:35:54.548 --> 00:35:55.149
This is sick.

493
00:35:55.189 --> 00:35:58.751
Because there's a couple things on the website that folks might not be aware of that are there.

494
00:35:58.811 --> 00:35:59.212
And so...

495
00:35:59.892 --> 00:36:06.095
When you come to the homepage, one of the things you'll be able to see is, we talked about the science funding piece earlier.

496
00:36:06.675 --> 00:36:09.016
Our science funding explorer is very robust.

497
00:36:09.396 --> 00:36:21.041
And so if you don't really understand who pays for American science and the history of that, we have a great sort of story view that'll take you through the history of how this has happened.

498
00:36:21.061 --> 00:36:22.762
And you can just see from this slide.

499
00:36:22.862 --> 00:36:33.013
View here, the red line we're looking at is the federal government and how it used to spend for research and development in the U.S. going back to the late 50s, 60s, and 70s, where the federal government was the biggest driver here.

500
00:36:33.033 --> 00:36:36.497
This is where we're getting things like Manhattan Project, et cetera, et cetera.

501
00:36:36.617 --> 00:36:37.558
That was the Cold War.

502
00:36:38.138 --> 00:36:39.079
So it made sense.

503
00:36:39.099 --> 00:36:39.300
Yeah.

504
00:36:39.400 --> 00:36:41.082
There was a military incentive, blah, blah, blah.

505
00:36:41.522 --> 00:36:49.567
But basically after 1980, industry is orders of magnitude more in spending on research and development.

506
00:36:49.587 --> 00:37:03.515
So this is why when we talk about this argument about the federal government shouldn't be spending on basic science research, you need to understand the scope of the volume of how much money is being spent by the federal government versus – it's literally 5x.

507
00:37:03.775 --> 00:37:03.995
Yeah.

508
00:37:04.275 --> 00:37:06.517
So it's just very different.

509
00:37:06.537 --> 00:37:06.957
Yeah.

510
00:37:07.037 --> 00:37:08.118
There's great charts.

511
00:37:08.278 --> 00:37:09.398
It's super interactive.

512
00:37:09.518 --> 00:37:12.980
But we also have the ability for you to dig in by agency.

513
00:37:13.300 --> 00:37:18.383
So if you want to know, right, so we have this ranked here in terms of, like, what agencies get the most money.

514
00:37:19.264 --> 00:37:22.886
And this is sort of looking at the current year's budget.

515
00:37:23.246 --> 00:37:24.226
DOD is number one.

516
00:37:24.867 --> 00:37:27.548
Department of Health and Human Services is number two.

517
00:37:27.908 --> 00:37:31.330
Department of Energy, NUCES, is number three.

518
00:37:31.810 --> 00:37:32.291
NASA.

519
00:37:33.075 --> 00:37:40.057
unsurprisingly, number four, only then, yeah, do we get to the National Science Foundation, which could take so much oxygen in the room.

520
00:37:41.078 --> 00:37:42.078
NSF is $7 billion.

521
00:37:42.098 --> 00:37:44.219
DOD is $95 billion.

522
00:37:44.319 --> 00:37:44.519
Yeah.

523
00:37:44.779 --> 00:37:51.501
So like, we're not even this day, but people would be surprised to know that Department of Commerce and Agriculture and the VA and DOT, and,

524
00:37:52.281 --> 00:37:57.403
And these agencies also have very interesting research programs.

525
00:37:57.503 --> 00:38:03.966
And again, you can click into any of these to see a breakdown of like how that budget has changed over time.

526
00:38:04.526 --> 00:38:06.127
What are they spending their money on?

527
00:38:06.487 --> 00:38:11.209
So there's the Office of Science in the DOE versus Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy.

528
00:38:11.529 --> 00:38:15.250
And you can see how those budget ranges have changed over time.

529
00:38:15.731 --> 00:38:19.192
Nuclear energy, as you can see in the DOE, has seen a huge boost.

530
00:38:20.154 --> 00:38:23.855
It's always been big, but especially recently has seen a huge boost.

531
00:38:23.956 --> 00:38:26.036
So it's very detailed.

532
00:38:27.037 --> 00:38:31.718
It's well worth a look to really get a grounding about what's happening in that space.

533
00:38:31.838 --> 00:38:37.681
Another cool thing is all of our research papers that we cover, you can get to here.

534
00:38:37.701 --> 00:38:39.521
So if you're like, oh, where's the DOI link?

535
00:38:39.561 --> 00:38:40.602
Like, where's the research paper link?

536
00:38:40.882 --> 00:38:43.823
Go to the website, the quantum computing episode we just did.

537
00:38:44.461 --> 00:38:45.822
We have the research paper right here.

538
00:38:45.862 --> 00:38:49.765
You can get to it, what the paper is, what episodes we cover in those papers.

539
00:38:50.266 --> 00:38:52.948
We've really spent a lot of time trying to build an ecosystem that's interesting.

540
00:38:53.569 --> 00:39:10.343
And as a fan of the prem, we've now implemented our science transfers, our transfer market, something that's making people very upset because the idea that the U.S. is losing its edge is amathema, whatever the word is, is just so counter to their worldview.

541
00:39:10.883 --> 00:39:23.128
We're still building it out piece by piece, but you can start to see with our first 37 scientists we've put in here who are big names, global laureates, people who've won big prizes, leaders of labs.

542
00:39:23.529 --> 00:39:24.589
It's not looking good right now.

543
00:39:25.149 --> 00:39:30.272
It's not a complete data set, but you'll be able to look at each of the transfers individually, their effective date.

544
00:39:30.612 --> 00:39:33.973
You can see where they're coming from, where they're going, what the sources are for it.

545
00:39:34.533 --> 00:39:35.674
This is really cool stuff, y'all.

546
00:39:35.714 --> 00:39:37.155
And we already talked about the America 250.

547
00:39:37.175 --> 00:39:37.315
Yeah.

548
00:39:38.395 --> 00:39:42.716
I'll just mention, if you want to support the show, the shop's got a couple things in it.

549
00:39:43.676 --> 00:39:44.497
It's got some good stuff.

550
00:39:44.797 --> 00:39:46.117
We just added the platonic tea.

551
00:39:46.497 --> 00:39:50.318
I think we're going to order some of these bone platonic teas.

552
00:39:50.338 --> 00:39:51.638
We're going to get some of these soon.

553
00:39:52.078 --> 00:39:55.579
So in any event, we'll stop shilling.

554
00:39:55.939 --> 00:39:57.580
We had to take a little bit of time to talk about it.

555
00:39:57.620 --> 00:39:57.860
Yeah.

556
00:39:58.480 --> 00:39:58.580
Uh...

557
00:39:59.040 --> 00:40:01.221
Because we have to fill some airtime here, everybody.

558
00:40:01.441 --> 00:40:02.242
We're having a good time.

559
00:40:02.322 --> 00:40:02.802
We're having a break.

560
00:40:02.822 --> 00:40:09.625
We're going to get back to the rest of the fall season calendar as we are going through some of the exciting things.

561
00:40:09.645 --> 00:40:15.528
The next thing we're going to talk about, we did not talk about the launch, which occurred on August 30th.

562
00:40:16.468 --> 00:40:16.849
That's right.

563
00:40:16.869 --> 00:40:19.810
But we are going to do a little discussion today.

564
00:40:20.330 --> 00:40:25.233
on the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope, which is already launched.

565
00:40:25.253 --> 00:40:40.863
What we're seeing now is a visual of how it's going to deploy as it reaches L2, Lagrange Point 2, which is its destination, with the first images, again, space-based telescope,

566
00:40:42.123 --> 00:40:47.947
very similar to the James Webb Space Telescope in that it's space-based, but very different in what it's going to be capturing.

567
00:40:48.447 --> 00:40:54.171
We should be expecting images in early 2027, which is fantastic.

568
00:40:54.191 --> 00:41:00.615
So, again, we're watching this deployment sequence here, which I think is so good.

569
00:41:00.855 --> 00:41:01.075
Yeah.

570
00:41:01.756 --> 00:41:05.838
I mean, there's so many things that have to go right in order for this thing to work.

571
00:41:06.299 --> 00:41:10.982
And did you know that this started its life as a spy satellite?

572
00:41:11.002 --> 00:41:11.442
Yeah.

573
00:41:11.822 --> 00:41:13.583
I saw some headlines about this.

574
00:41:13.623 --> 00:41:14.983
Yeah, it's pretty crazy.

575
00:41:15.063 --> 00:41:21.544
The mirror is from a former spy satellite that the military was like, oh, we're not using anymore.

576
00:41:21.564 --> 00:41:23.985
And NASA was like, well, can we have it?

577
00:41:24.205 --> 00:41:26.906
And then they put it on this thing.

578
00:41:27.166 --> 00:41:30.447
The mirror is actually identical to the Hubble mirror.

579
00:41:30.927 --> 00:41:31.347
Yes.

580
00:41:31.587 --> 00:41:35.868
But the camera is very different, which is why this particular...

581
00:41:37.507 --> 00:42:00.537
telescope is going to be very different and there it is flying to l2 which is just behind the earth where the james webb space telescope is hanging out and we can see how far we're talking like we you know are we talking about the the orbit of the moon well past and we talked about artemis 2 and now it's crazy and we can sort of see the the orbital mechanics here a little bit

582
00:42:00.797 --> 00:42:02.678
Yeah, it's just behind the Earth.

583
00:42:02.978 --> 00:42:09.020
If the sun is in front, this is behind, and it's going to be orbiting that L2 point, the Lagrange 2 point.

584
00:42:09.600 --> 00:42:22.724
And so I saw this description where it talked about how we can think about the James Webb Space Telescope as like a zoom lens on a camera looking really far away to the beginnings of the universe.

585
00:42:22.984 --> 00:42:26.645
And Roman is more like this wide-angle telescope

586
00:42:27.145 --> 00:42:45.762
survey camera very much like hubble yeah trying to just capture although no i would say it's i would say it's very much like vera rubin ah yeah that's a very good point yes because vera rubin is one of these survey telescopes for a very large field of view that's very hubble is kind of like james webb and that it's still zoomed it's still zoomed in that's very fair yeah no that's very fair

587
00:42:46.122 --> 00:42:54.730
And there's so many aspects of science, dark matter, huge exoplanet census through this microlensing concept.

588
00:42:54.950 --> 00:43:02.477
There are so many things like we talked about in our Verirubin episode, which was important, is this idea that let's just capture all the data.

589
00:43:02.617 --> 00:43:02.837
Yeah.

590
00:43:04.287 --> 00:43:07.209
Dump it down and then let people have at it.

591
00:43:07.329 --> 00:43:07.549
Yeah.

592
00:43:07.650 --> 00:43:16.596
And there's so much science you can do once we start actually doing these, you know, Sloan Digital Sky Survey, Vera Rubin Surveys, and now this Roman.

593
00:43:16.756 --> 00:43:26.143
And the sports analogy, because for all the sports ball fanatics, I'm so determined to continue this ESPN for Science concept.

594
00:43:26.163 --> 00:43:26.764
Yeah.

595
00:43:27.584 --> 00:43:34.588
It's like we're in the process now where we're going through training camp as we prepare for the first season of this new signing.

596
00:43:35.328 --> 00:43:37.549
And it's a very promising signing.

597
00:43:37.750 --> 00:43:38.430
Yes, it is.

598
00:43:38.610 --> 00:43:49.236
I mean, the thing that I think everyone is excited about is the fact that it has the same resolution as Hubble, but the field of view is something like 100 times larger.

599
00:43:49.596 --> 00:43:52.778
So it can see a bigger patch of the sky at the same fidelity.

600
00:43:52.798 --> 00:43:53.258
Right.

601
00:43:54.038 --> 00:44:01.182
And a lot of astronomers are really excited because it's going to answer questions about dark energy and dark matter.

602
00:44:01.522 --> 00:44:06.865
Me personally, if you were to ask me, I am very excited about this idea of microlensing.

603
00:44:07.386 --> 00:44:09.167
And you're going to like this idea because...

604
00:44:09.827 --> 00:44:15.330
So most of the planets, most of the exoplanets that we know about are from Kepler.

605
00:44:15.830 --> 00:44:18.432
And Kepler was a transiting observatory, right?

606
00:44:18.452 --> 00:44:19.092
Yeah.

607
00:44:19.192 --> 00:44:24.316
which means that the planet has to go in front of the star, and then the star's light is going to dip.

608
00:44:24.817 --> 00:44:31.842
And if that dip is rhythmic, then we know that the planet has gone in front, and it's gone in front, and it's gone in front, and we know that there's a planet there.

609
00:44:32.163 --> 00:44:37.287
And then we can do all sorts of nice analyses about the atmospheric...

610
00:44:37.917 --> 00:44:39.098
Retrieval.

611
00:44:39.138 --> 00:44:42.941
Yes, atmospheric retrieval, what is the atmosphere on this planet, and so on and so forth.

612
00:44:43.361 --> 00:44:47.984
But in order to find those types of planets, you have to get very lucky.

613
00:44:48.384 --> 00:44:48.624
Right.

614
00:44:48.725 --> 00:44:59.232
Because the angle of that solar system, the axis or the plane of rotation of that solar system, has to be in line with however the Earth is looking at.

615
00:44:59.792 --> 00:45:00.532
At that star.

616
00:45:00.612 --> 00:45:01.793
Our line of sight to the star.

617
00:45:01.833 --> 00:45:02.093
Yeah.

618
00:45:02.153 --> 00:45:10.154
Like if the star is over there, then the solar system better be rotating this way such that the plate is like edge on.

619
00:45:10.355 --> 00:45:10.555
Right.

620
00:45:10.635 --> 00:45:14.015
If the star is over there, then it better be edge on and so on and so forth.

621
00:45:15.156 --> 00:45:17.616
And that's because it relies on the transit method.

622
00:45:18.276 --> 00:45:20.537
What about solar systems that are oblique?

623
00:45:20.877 --> 00:45:21.057
Right.

624
00:45:21.097 --> 00:45:25.678
For example, the star is like this and the planet is revolving this way.

625
00:45:29.779 --> 00:45:31.020
Yeah, there's no eclipse.

626
00:45:31.040 --> 00:45:31.920
In our line of sight.

627
00:45:32.141 --> 00:45:36.403
Yeah, so there's no dip in the brightness.

628
00:45:36.583 --> 00:45:37.284
What about then?

629
00:45:38.324 --> 00:45:40.986
That's where this micro-lensing technique comes in.

630
00:45:41.506 --> 00:45:51.753
Okay, what they're using is piggybacking off of Einstein's general relativity to say that when there's a star, let's say the star is right here and there's a background star behind it.

631
00:45:52.133 --> 00:45:58.917
If the star moves in front, it's going to gravitationally lens that light, and the background star is going to get a little bit brighter.

632
00:45:59.627 --> 00:46:10.778
Well, if there's a star and a planet right in front, then I'm going to see a sort of spike in that gravitational lensing, right?

633
00:46:10.898 --> 00:46:24.010
And so now this is a technique where we can start having access to solar systems, exoplanets, that no longer have that constraint, you know?

634
00:46:24.610 --> 00:46:35.792
And if you're interested in this topic, we actually talked to a friend of the pod, astrophysicist Dan Gilman, while you were on paternity leave, about how scientists actually study dark matter.

635
00:46:36.152 --> 00:46:46.454
And we talked in depth about this concept of strong gravitational lensing, but it'll at least be somewhat adjacent to this idea, which is very interesting.

636
00:46:46.594 --> 00:46:52.535
And again, to your point, it is a very important distinction between the transit method in terms of...

637
00:46:53.055 --> 00:46:54.556
how we do exoplanet detection.

638
00:46:54.576 --> 00:46:55.496
Yeah.

639
00:46:56.336 --> 00:47:01.639
His reference point for this idea of gravitational lensing is for dark matter detection.

640
00:47:01.659 --> 00:47:03.880
Yes, and it's an incredible episode.

641
00:47:04.740 --> 00:47:08.322
And this one is, you know, you can use gravitational lensing for exoplanets itself.

642
00:47:08.402 --> 00:47:09.982
And also, shout out to Dan.

643
00:47:10.062 --> 00:47:12.863
He's actually organizing a conference right now at the university.

644
00:47:12.943 --> 00:47:13.804
Oh, ho, ho, ho.

645
00:47:14.304 --> 00:47:16.766
At the University of Chicago at the KICP.

646
00:47:17.386 --> 00:47:22.129
It's a dark matter physics in the era of large surveys conference.

647
00:47:22.269 --> 00:47:23.990
So best of luck to you, Dan.

648
00:47:24.750 --> 00:47:27.192
Hopefully the conference goes well.

649
00:47:28.247 --> 00:47:35.592
There's some news headline I just saw the other day about Slack finding, figuring out something about dark matter.

650
00:47:36.153 --> 00:47:37.914
And I don't remember what the headline was, but it was.

651
00:47:37.934 --> 00:47:38.274
Oh, yeah.

652
00:47:38.494 --> 00:47:39.495
I don't think it was Slack.

653
00:47:39.555 --> 00:47:42.637
It was, well, maybe it was Slack, but it was direct detection.

654
00:47:42.697 --> 00:47:42.977
Correct.

655
00:47:43.337 --> 00:47:44.018
Of dark matter.

656
00:47:44.218 --> 00:47:45.359
There was a news headline.

657
00:47:46.259 --> 00:47:50.362
I was tempted to do a story on it, but I want to.

658
00:47:50.522 --> 00:47:51.383
It's a little early.

659
00:47:51.743 --> 00:47:53.224
It's a little early.

660
00:47:53.244 --> 00:47:53.905
Let's let them cook.

661
00:47:54.225 --> 00:47:55.626
The Sigma is not that high.

662
00:47:56.126 --> 00:47:56.306
And...

663
00:47:59.020 --> 00:48:01.983
it's a notoriously hard measurement to make.

664
00:48:02.804 --> 00:48:03.945
I mean, all power to them.

665
00:48:04.185 --> 00:48:12.674
If, if we get a coincident measurement at another direct detection, dark matter, like Japan has one, Italy has one in these mines.

666
00:48:12.975 --> 00:48:18.240
The South Dakota one is in a mine and they, you know, they purport to have found a dark matter particle.

667
00:48:18.260 --> 00:48:18.961
Um, um,

668
00:48:19.546 --> 00:48:25.968
If there is a coincident detection with the same mass and the same energy scale, that's a Nobel Prize waiting to happen, right?

669
00:48:26.448 --> 00:48:27.208
Immediately.

670
00:48:27.468 --> 00:48:29.428
Yeah, that is an immediate.

671
00:48:29.949 --> 00:48:31.929
Immediately, yes.

672
00:48:32.309 --> 00:48:33.109
Immediately, yes.

673
00:48:33.129 --> 00:48:35.330
We're not going to wait until you're on your deathbed for that one.

674
00:48:35.370 --> 00:48:39.451
Yeah, so I'm waiting for this type of coincident detection.

675
00:48:39.811 --> 00:48:42.752
If it does happen, we will 100% cover it.

676
00:48:43.092 --> 00:48:43.852
It's very exciting.

677
00:48:44.792 --> 00:49:06.565
uh to uh stay tuned for future news there uh we just have two more in our fall season update to cover uh and we thought this was going to be a short episode but like always we find a way to yap away uh so our next one uh many of you know i'm a big space fan so pulled a lot of space stuff for this

678
00:49:07.085 --> 00:49:12.547
But this is some of the most exciting things at the frontier that people all feel very resonant around.

679
00:49:12.768 --> 00:49:21.051
And our next story is going to be about JAXA's Martian Moon exploration mission.

680
00:49:21.071 --> 00:49:24.553
I should say Martian Moon's exploration mission.

681
00:49:24.573 --> 00:49:30.155
We're now looking at their fancy video breakdown of what we're going to do.

682
00:49:30.475 --> 00:49:34.699
And JAXA, real quick, is the Japanese version of NASA.

683
00:49:34.739 --> 00:49:35.019
Correct.

684
00:49:35.039 --> 00:49:35.560
That's correct.

685
00:49:35.600 --> 00:49:45.950
And this is a mission that is in collaboration with NASA as well as the European Space Agency, ESA, along with both the French and German space agencies.

686
00:49:45.970 --> 00:49:54.738
The idea is to do a survey of Mars' two moons, Phobos and Deimos, and to land on Phobos.

687
00:49:55.018 --> 00:49:55.699
That's crazy.

688
00:49:55.719 --> 00:49:56.559
To take a sample.

689
00:49:56.820 --> 00:49:57.720
Okay.

690
00:49:58.181 --> 00:50:00.523
And, you know, so we're seeing here it's getting close.

691
00:50:01.384 --> 00:50:02.565
And it's slowing down.

692
00:50:02.625 --> 00:50:03.486
Slowing down.

693
00:50:03.506 --> 00:50:05.527
Because, you know, we got to slow it down.

694
00:50:06.544 --> 00:50:17.390
And what we've covered on the pod before here, and I'll actually pull up this next video example, where we're going to see it's going to drop its little probe.

695
00:50:17.690 --> 00:50:19.371
This is very similar to the Hayabusa 2.

696
00:50:19.411 --> 00:50:20.892
Very similar, yes.

697
00:50:21.152 --> 00:50:27.136
And it's effectively like the level up where they took a sample from an asteroid, which has been returned to Earth.

698
00:50:27.696 --> 00:50:29.597
And so now we're like, okay, let's do one better.

699
00:50:29.978 --> 00:50:32.399
And so this is a very interesting example.

700
00:50:32.619 --> 00:50:34.240
We're now seeing the solar panels pop out.

701
00:50:34.740 --> 00:50:35.100
Wow.

702
00:50:35.120 --> 00:50:36.701
The real structure, right?

703
00:50:37.261 --> 00:50:39.942
And it's super fascinating.

704
00:50:40.503 --> 00:50:45.165
It takes a village to make something like this happen, and then it goes and retrieves it.

705
00:50:45.305 --> 00:50:46.225
Retrieves it, right.

706
00:50:46.245 --> 00:50:48.126
Yeah, from the surface, comes back up.

707
00:50:48.526 --> 00:50:51.167
Again, very similar to Hayabusa 2, which we covered on the pod.

708
00:50:51.587 --> 00:50:58.150
And then it's going to return back to Earth, and then it's going to just shoot it, apparently, at Australia.

709
00:50:58.170 --> 00:50:59.231
At Australia, yeah.

710
00:51:02.533 --> 00:51:09.731
But the core scientific question that it seems like they're looking to answer with this is, are Mars' moons captured asteroids?

711
00:51:10.792 --> 00:51:13.574
Or are they debris created by a giant impact?

712
00:51:13.934 --> 00:51:14.695
Ah, okay, okay.

713
00:51:14.735 --> 00:51:30.885
Kind of like, because there's a hypothesis that our own moon is created by debris from giant impact when a Mars-sized object ran into us like, you know, a few hundred million years into our existence, like four billion years ago.

714
00:51:32.006 --> 00:51:33.306
That's exactly right.

715
00:51:33.367 --> 00:51:33.987
That's interesting.

716
00:51:34.307 --> 00:51:39.210
And we now know we can land on something, send something down, collect something.

717
00:51:39.270 --> 00:51:46.355
And when we talked about Hayabusa 2, it's like had a little detonation to loosen up the asteroid surface to be able to collect it and come up.

718
00:51:46.835 --> 00:51:49.797
And so this is going to be, again, an interesting next step here.

719
00:51:50.698 --> 00:51:55.161
It's sort of like Jax is moving up from the championship to the prem.

720
00:51:55.181 --> 00:51:57.302
They're moving up the division in complexity.

721
00:51:58.263 --> 00:51:59.864
And so we shall see –

722
00:52:01.385 --> 00:52:07.530
This is now slated for October 20th for a launch window.

723
00:52:07.730 --> 00:52:08.611
Okay.

724
00:52:08.631 --> 00:52:11.713
And looking to return samples to Earth by 2031.

725
00:52:11.813 --> 00:52:13.654
It is a long drive.

726
00:52:14.935 --> 00:52:21.260
So this is, again, in this fall window, something that's super exciting and we'll keep an eye on.

727
00:52:21.701 --> 00:52:23.122
Yeah, that is super exciting.

728
00:52:23.242 --> 00:52:26.985
Speaking of ions, which is something we've talked about a lot in The Brain in recent episodes.

729
00:52:27.005 --> 00:52:27.365
No, I'm kidding.

730
00:52:28.306 --> 00:52:37.032
For our last piece of coverage here, we will talk about, surprisingly, another space story.

731
00:52:37.212 --> 00:52:37.633
All right.

732
00:52:37.933 --> 00:52:42.256
And this is the BepiColombo Mercury Arrival.

733
00:52:43.097 --> 00:52:43.757
So this is...

734
00:52:44.744 --> 00:52:56.339
What is the second and most complex mission to orbit Mercury, the first rock from the sun, going towards Mercury's tough because it's so close to the sun.

735
00:52:56.359 --> 00:52:58.502
There's so many challenges of doing that.

736
00:52:58.883 --> 00:53:01.626
We've had some solar, you know, missions go and,

737
00:53:02.767 --> 00:53:24.395
have been very impressive yeah i mean some of the ones like straight up like go and like touch the sun it's very impressive yeah like the parker solar probe which is named after eugene parker who we um cover in the america 250 he's the one who um postulated that something like the solar wind should exist so again plugging that episode that's a great episode

738
00:53:25.235 --> 00:53:31.281
Interestingly, Mercury is the least explored planet of the inner solar system.

739
00:53:31.702 --> 00:53:39.689
And one of the goals of learning about Mercury would be to shed light on the history of the entire solar system.

740
00:53:39.709 --> 00:53:40.330
That makes sense.

741
00:53:40.350 --> 00:53:42.532
Given its proximity to the parent star.

742
00:53:42.612 --> 00:53:46.896
It's named after Giuseppe Bepi Colombo.

743
00:53:47.897 --> 00:54:03.819
who's a scientist, mathematician, and engineer, yes, they exist, triple threat, at the University of Padua in Italy, who first proposed this idea of interplanetary gravity assist maneuvers, which was used by the 1974 Mariner 10 mission

744
00:54:05.941 --> 00:54:10.646
And if anyone has watched Interstellar is now it's in every movie.

745
00:54:10.746 --> 00:54:10.927
Yeah.

746
00:54:11.007 --> 00:54:11.707
It's everything.

747
00:54:11.748 --> 00:54:13.429
When we do – It's how we got to Pluto.

748
00:54:13.449 --> 00:54:14.330
It's how we get anywhere.

749
00:54:14.370 --> 00:54:15.311
It's how we get anywhere.

750
00:54:15.532 --> 00:54:16.072
Yeah.

751
00:54:16.613 --> 00:54:19.456
It's packed with a bunch of scientific instruments.

752
00:54:19.596 --> 00:54:25.362
And so part of what they're looking to do in terms of the questions they're trying to answer is why is there ice –

753
00:54:26.243 --> 00:54:31.207
In the polar craters of Mercury, given how close it is to the sun and how hot it is.

754
00:54:31.287 --> 00:54:31.948
Oh, interesting.

755
00:54:32.028 --> 00:54:32.428
Yeah.

756
00:54:32.929 --> 00:54:34.830
Why does Mercury have a magnetic field?

757
00:54:35.871 --> 00:54:37.573
That is a weird one, actually.

758
00:54:37.593 --> 00:54:37.813
Right?

759
00:54:38.473 --> 00:54:41.416
And what are the mysterious hollows on its surface?

760
00:54:41.436 --> 00:54:44.739
Because it has these hollow areas on its surface.

761
00:54:45.039 --> 00:54:46.400
And so there's a couple of different...

762
00:54:47.124 --> 00:54:48.345
components to the mission.

763
00:54:48.965 --> 00:54:50.986
It has the Mercury Planetary Orbiter.

764
00:54:51.726 --> 00:54:58.809
It has the Mercury Magnetospheric Orbiter, which is specifically around this idea of studying the magnetic fields.

765
00:54:58.949 --> 00:55:02.130
And it has the Mercury Transfer Module.

766
00:55:02.190 --> 00:55:07.653
Now, it launched in 2018 from Europe's spaceport.

767
00:55:07.733 --> 00:55:08.953
Europe's still in the game.

768
00:55:10.294 --> 00:55:12.134
It's in operation and en route to Mercury.

769
00:55:12.895 --> 00:55:15.876
It's done several Mercury flybys already.

770
00:55:16.415 --> 00:55:16.896
Oh, okay.

771
00:55:17.276 --> 00:55:26.488
October 21, June 22, June 23, September 24, December 24, and January 25.

772
00:55:26.528 --> 00:55:28.590
Its arrival at Mercury is scheduled.

773
00:55:28.830 --> 00:55:31.273
And it's basically – it's been tuning its – Oh, okay.

774
00:55:31.334 --> 00:55:32.895
It's sort of tuning its approach –

775
00:55:33.536 --> 00:55:34.817
They've been testing the systems.

776
00:55:35.177 --> 00:55:35.357
Yep.

777
00:55:35.637 --> 00:55:49.526
It's expected to arrive around Christmastime, 2026, December 2026, and to begin routine scientific operation, hopefully around April of 2027.

778
00:55:50.106 --> 00:55:55.650
And the two orbiters that we discussed, the ESA is going to be doing the

779
00:55:56.390 --> 00:56:11.638
planetary orbiter studying mercury itself jaxa japanese space agency is going to be the one studying the magnetosphere and so it's it's a weird planet it is and we don't really have enough data to make any conclusions around it and so

780
00:56:13.113 --> 00:56:18.338
This has been an eight-year road trip, and we're finally getting to our destination to be able to do the science.

781
00:56:18.598 --> 00:56:19.318
Yeah.

782
00:56:19.358 --> 00:56:20.499
And this should be pretty interesting.

783
00:56:20.680 --> 00:56:22.781
Yeah, I'm actually quite excited about that.

784
00:56:22.881 --> 00:56:26.805
Mercury, you know, you remind me of all the things that make Mercury so weird.

785
00:56:26.865 --> 00:56:31.729
One of the things is, as you mentioned here in the notes, enormous iron core.

786
00:56:32.290 --> 00:56:38.035
That's a weird one because, like, if you've ever seen a photo of Earth and its core –

787
00:56:38.795 --> 00:56:44.904
um the core is about the size of the pit of a peach and then the meat of the peach is like the mantle

788
00:56:45.767 --> 00:56:50.528
With mercury, it's kind of like, you know those lint chocolates?

789
00:56:50.989 --> 00:56:51.889
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

790
00:56:51.909 --> 00:56:57.971
Or something where it's mostly the core and then there's a layer of crust.

791
00:56:58.051 --> 00:56:58.551
Of the chocolate.

792
00:56:58.571 --> 00:56:59.651
That's what mercury is like.

793
00:57:00.151 --> 00:57:04.593
Most of it is iron and then the crust and mantle are very, very thin.

794
00:57:05.053 --> 00:57:08.834
Now, one of the reasons for that is because mercury is closer to the sun and

795
00:57:09.734 --> 00:57:27.530
And so when the solar system formed, the heavier elements were closer to the sun, while the lighter elements sort of just got like blown off by the protostellar wind that happens when you first start like making that furnace of a star, right?

796
00:57:27.570 --> 00:57:30.192
Like imagine you've got the gas cloud that's like collapsing.

797
00:57:30.552 --> 00:57:33.015
The heavier elements are in the center.

798
00:57:33.355 --> 00:57:34.856
The lighter elements are in the center.

799
00:57:35.817 --> 00:57:36.337
periphery.

800
00:57:36.637 --> 00:57:41.638
And then when you create fusion, there's going to be intense stellar wind that's going to blow off everything.

801
00:57:41.658 --> 00:57:48.340
That's why Jupiter and Saturn and Neptune and Uranus are the gas giants that are on the outside and the rocky planets are on the inside.

802
00:57:48.600 --> 00:57:53.181
Well, Mercury is like the extreme version of the rocky planets, right?

803
00:57:53.201 --> 00:57:57.621
Where like the heaviest elements, like iron, which is where fusion stops.

804
00:57:58.242 --> 00:58:01.042
So that's where you're going to have most abundance.

805
00:58:01.262 --> 00:58:03.083
Mercury is going to have most of the iron.

806
00:58:03.523 --> 00:58:04.643
But what's weird is like

807
00:58:05.443 --> 00:58:13.727
For how small Mercury is, its core should basically be solid.

808
00:58:13.947 --> 00:58:15.207
Like, it should have cooled off.

809
00:58:15.888 --> 00:58:22.951
But the fact that it still has a magnetic field means that there's some activity happening within the core that is creating the magnetosphere.

810
00:58:23.231 --> 00:58:25.812
That's how magnetic fields originate, right?

811
00:58:25.892 --> 00:58:27.773
It's because of charged particles moving around.

812
00:58:27.793 --> 00:58:29.433
That's why the Earth has a magnetic field.

813
00:58:29.794 --> 00:58:32.995
It's because the core, the outer core mostly, is, like, moving around.

814
00:58:33.035 --> 00:58:34.896
And that's why we think— It's got a little jiggle.

815
00:58:35.456 --> 00:58:35.677
Yeah.

816
00:58:35.837 --> 00:58:37.339
Have you seen the movie, The Core?

817
00:58:37.500 --> 00:58:38.241
It's a great movie.

818
00:58:38.261 --> 00:58:38.902
No, no, I haven't.

819
00:58:38.942 --> 00:58:40.304
Dude, it's a great movie.

820
00:58:40.404 --> 00:58:41.125
Okay.

821
00:58:41.426 --> 00:58:45.573
Actually, even though a lot of science people hate on it because it's like terrible science.

822
00:58:45.873 --> 00:58:47.616
Yeah, it's terrible science, but like.

823
00:58:48.690 --> 00:59:11.053
it's a great movie look it's i'm not gonna lie it's entertaining yeah yeah the the earth's core stops spinning so then the magnetic field stops being a magnetic field and then we're about to get roasted by the sun so they have to like go into the core to restart the core by nuking it come on like that's that that's dope that sounds very entertaining it's dope dude um

824
00:59:11.694 --> 00:59:15.236
The science not so much, but like the human stories behind it.

825
00:59:15.497 --> 00:59:16.497
Stanley Tucci's in it.

826
00:59:16.537 --> 00:59:19.419
He's like one of the main big scientists.

827
00:59:19.779 --> 00:59:21.541
Of course he is.

828
00:59:21.621 --> 00:59:23.142
Who's like one of the famous scientists.

829
00:59:23.222 --> 00:59:32.688
And the ego of the Stanley Tucci character is just so very on point with some of the big egos that I've interacted with in academia.

830
00:59:33.028 --> 00:59:38.172
Anyways, so Mercury is like this enigma because it still has a magnetic field.

831
00:59:38.792 --> 00:59:42.254
But it shouldn't because it's small enough to have cooled off.

832
00:59:42.594 --> 00:59:44.375
You know, the moon doesn't have a magnetic field.

833
00:59:44.735 --> 00:59:46.996
And the moon is comparable to the size of Mercury.

834
00:59:47.296 --> 00:59:48.497
So it is a bit weird.

835
00:59:48.597 --> 00:59:49.277
What's going on?

836
00:59:49.377 --> 00:59:50.538
Yeah.

837
00:59:51.438 --> 00:59:58.262
Thank you all for dealing with us in our half break week where we wanted to have a little bit of fun.

838
00:59:59.042 --> 01:00:01.303
talk about some of our favorite history.

839
01:00:01.703 --> 01:00:05.545
I'm going to ask two questions for those who may still be watching.

840
01:00:06.146 --> 01:00:08.667
We're keeping this almost exactly at an hour.

841
01:00:08.727 --> 01:00:09.907
This is record time.

842
01:00:11.048 --> 01:00:13.549
The Yap Sesh is going to cut at record time.

843
01:00:13.829 --> 01:00:15.070
The two questions I have is,

844
01:00:16.066 --> 01:00:20.528
Of all of the things we covered today, which one of them do you want us to do a deep dive on?

845
01:00:20.608 --> 01:00:22.509
Like, no bells is happening.

846
01:00:23.270 --> 01:00:25.070
Are folks interested in the Golden Goose Awards?

847
01:00:25.711 --> 01:00:30.693
Do they want us to look at any of these space missions and get a little bit more deep into what's going on there?

848
01:00:31.494 --> 01:00:32.434
So that's question number one.

849
01:00:32.854 --> 01:00:33.715
Then question number two is...

850
01:00:34.395 --> 01:00:37.577
For potential longtime listeners, what's your favorite episode?

851
01:00:37.757 --> 01:00:38.017
Yes.

852
01:00:38.258 --> 01:00:39.799
We talked about some of our favorite episodes.

853
01:00:40.059 --> 01:00:44.181
I would love to know what brought you to the show.

854
01:00:44.642 --> 01:00:46.543
What was one where you're like, oh, this was fire.

855
01:00:47.183 --> 01:00:48.084
This is this.

856
01:00:48.264 --> 01:00:48.524
This.

857
01:00:48.564 --> 01:00:49.785
You guys were in your bag.

858
01:00:50.548 --> 01:00:51.309
On this episode.

859
01:00:51.329 --> 01:00:52.069
Yeah.

860
01:00:52.329 --> 01:00:52.910
It helps us.

861
01:00:53.250 --> 01:00:55.292
It helps us know kind of where to go and what to do.

862
01:00:56.292 --> 01:01:04.259
But again, kind of like the rundown format for those who've come to the show for a while, where we touch on different things and give you a little smorgasbord.

863
01:01:04.839 --> 01:01:06.400
That was the goal for this episode.

864
01:01:06.780 --> 01:01:08.762
At some point in the future, we'll,

865
01:01:08.942 --> 01:01:13.867
when we have the ability to do so, a deep dive a week and a rundown a week would be ideal.

866
01:01:14.047 --> 01:01:14.247
Yeah.

867
01:01:14.547 --> 01:01:17.790
So you get to know exactly what's happening at the frontier right when it happens.

868
01:01:18.271 --> 01:01:27.379
But then when you still get the best part of the show, which is the real first principles deep dive, which in my view is like, that's our, our,

869
01:01:28.580 --> 01:01:31.562
That's our Michelin star dish.

870
01:01:31.622 --> 01:01:35.265
You can't get anywhere else because this is the best science show on the planet.

871
01:01:35.385 --> 01:01:35.966
I'm Lester Nari.

872
01:01:36.026 --> 01:01:41.590
I joined, as always, by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

873
01:01:41.930 --> 01:01:43.412
We are going to get out of your hair.

874
01:01:43.472 --> 01:01:46.874
We hope you all enjoyed your Labor Day weekend.

875
01:01:47.295 --> 01:01:48.856
We are about to go into ours.

876
01:01:49.316 --> 01:01:50.077
Up the Chels.

877
01:01:50.777 --> 01:01:51.457
Can you believe it?

878
01:01:51.797 --> 01:01:52.538
It's unbelievable.

879
01:01:53.118 --> 01:01:54.579
Arsenal, it's unbelievable.

880
01:01:54.759 --> 01:01:55.579
I don't know what to tell you.

881
01:01:55.940 --> 01:02:00.402
You thought just because you beat us for the last five years meant that you were just going to stomp all over us in your own house.

882
01:02:00.862 --> 01:02:03.024
I'm sorry to tell you, times have changed.

883
01:02:03.884 --> 01:02:05.485
Enzo Fernandez, who needs him?

884
01:02:05.645 --> 01:02:06.445
He can go to Man City.

885
01:02:06.906 --> 01:02:07.226
It's fine.

886
01:02:07.246 --> 01:02:07.766
We don't need him.

887
01:02:08.547 --> 01:02:11.068
Y'all thought, our center, oh, we're going to get Trout's.

888
01:02:11.708 --> 01:02:13.009
Oh, we have a good team.

889
01:02:13.029 --> 01:02:14.750
It's a good team.

890
01:02:15.410 --> 01:02:16.591
We had a great transfer window.

891
01:02:16.611 --> 01:02:18.332
Wait, so is Enzo not coming back to Chels?

892
01:02:18.792 --> 01:02:19.172
He's not.

893
01:02:19.553 --> 01:02:19.973
It's okay.

894
01:02:20.153 --> 01:02:20.654
It's okay.

895
01:02:20.934 --> 01:02:24.297
There's a lot of drama around it, which we're not going to get into because this is not a sports show.

896
01:02:24.417 --> 01:02:24.597
Yeah.

897
01:02:24.617 --> 01:02:25.678
But there's some great drama.

898
01:02:26.138 --> 01:02:27.940
Well, I didn't like him anyways.

899
01:02:27.980 --> 01:02:29.621
We got $125 million for him.

900
01:02:29.801 --> 01:02:30.001
Yeah.

901
01:02:30.722 --> 01:02:31.342
That's pretty good.

902
01:02:31.783 --> 01:02:32.003
Look.

903
01:02:32.563 --> 01:02:33.524
And you got rid of Enzo.

904
01:02:33.544 --> 01:02:34.465
No, I'm just kidding.

905
01:02:34.485 --> 01:02:35.286
And he didn't want to be there.

906
01:02:35.526 --> 01:02:38.869
Look, if you don't want to play for the Blues, for the badge, if you don't want to play for this, that's okay.

907
01:02:38.889 --> 01:02:39.289
We get it.

908
01:02:39.629 --> 01:02:40.010
Move on.

909
01:02:40.750 --> 01:02:42.912
You wanted to go to Real Madrid, and you ended up in Man City.

910
01:02:43.092 --> 01:02:43.833
I don't know what to tell you.

911
01:02:44.493 --> 01:02:49.136
You guys are probably going to get relegated for your crimes against the league because of all your cheating.

912
01:02:49.176 --> 01:02:55.320
So look, when we see Enzo Fernandez next season in the championship, I'm just look, and we're going to win the prem.

913
01:02:55.340 --> 01:02:58.463
We're going to be world champions from the FIFA world club world cup.

914
01:02:58.823 --> 01:02:59.984
And we're going to be prem champions.

915
01:03:00.704 --> 01:03:03.886
And, you know, unlike Arsenal, we have a champions league.

916
01:03:04.286 --> 01:03:05.447
You know, I don't know what to tell you.

917
01:03:05.607 --> 01:03:06.608
I'm sorry for your loss.

918
01:03:07.128 --> 01:03:09.970
You're going to come to the Stanford bridge and you're also going to lose.

919
01:03:11.111 --> 01:03:11.491
I'm done.

920
01:03:11.832 --> 01:03:13.072
We will see you all next week.
