WEBVTT

1
00:00:02.679 --> 00:00:09.042
A particle physicist from Belgium who spent decades turning the South Pole into a telescope.

2
00:00:09.802 --> 00:00:10.422
The target?

3
00:00:10.962 --> 00:00:11.743
The neutrino.

4
00:00:12.283 --> 00:00:15.564
The shyest particle in the universe.

5
00:00:15.624 --> 00:00:19.846
65 billion from the sun pass through your fingernail every second.

6
00:00:20.506 --> 00:00:23.547
Almost none ever stop.

7
00:00:23.707 --> 00:00:27.589
In 1988, Francis Halzen proposed a wild idea.

8
00:00:28.404 --> 00:00:34.056
When a neutrino does hit an atom in ice, it leaves a faint flash of blue light.

9
00:00:34.878 --> 00:00:39.447
So, fill the Antarctic ice with sensors and watch.

10
00:00:40.723 --> 00:00:43.665
By 2011, IceCube was complete.

11
00:00:44.325 --> 00:00:53.330
A cubic kilometer of ice and more than 5,000 light sensors frozen up to two and a half kilometers deep.

12
00:00:53.530 --> 00:00:59.153
In 2013, it found the first evidence of neutrinos from beyond our solar system.

13
00:00:59.873 --> 00:01:07.077
Messengers that fly straight from the most violent places in the cosmos, a new kind of astronomy.

14
00:01:08.103 --> 00:01:11.926
And this is the 2026 Nobel Prize in Physics.

15
00:01:16.370 --> 00:01:17.150
Hello, Internet.

16
00:01:17.170 --> 00:01:25.297
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

17
00:01:25.337 --> 00:01:32.202
We are back for day two of the Nobel Prizes, which is the first solo award.

18
00:01:32.842 --> 00:01:45.045
which also happens to be the first solo physics Nobel Prize winner since 1992, when Georges Sherpak won for the invention of a major class of electronic particle detectors.

19
00:01:45.285 --> 00:01:55.928
Today we are covering a unique telescope called the Ice Cube Neutrino Observatory in Antarctica in the quest to find ghostly messengers from space.

20
00:01:56.028 --> 00:01:59.968
As always, we are going to talk about the science from the ground up today,

21
00:02:03.050 --> 00:02:04.030
That's right.

22
00:02:04.051 --> 00:02:12.597
2026 Nobel Prize in Physics has been awarded to Francis Halzen for laying the foundations for an entirely new type of astronomy.

23
00:02:12.758 --> 00:02:22.806
The official tagline says, For decisive contributions to the IceCube Neutrino Observatory and the discovery of high-energy neutrinos of astrophysical origin.

24
00:02:23.426 --> 00:02:26.649
Now, we've covered Ice Cube before on this podcast.

25
00:02:27.109 --> 00:02:32.533
It is simply said a triumph of human ingenuity and sheer will.

26
00:02:32.934 --> 00:02:34.715
It's located at the South Pole.

27
00:02:35.276 --> 00:02:42.341
This is a telescope that is buried in a kilometer of ice on the South Pole.

28
00:02:42.441 --> 00:02:47.486
It has no mirrors, it has no lenses, and it doesn't collect the light from distant stars.

29
00:02:47.666 --> 00:02:49.167
Instead, it collects light

30
00:02:49.752 --> 00:02:51.693
coming out of the ice itself.

31
00:02:52.094 --> 00:02:55.116
It's like a telescope that's pointed downward in some sense.

32
00:02:55.236 --> 00:03:00.860
And what it's looking for is the light from neutrinos that interact with the ice.

33
00:03:01.300 --> 00:03:07.465
There's interesting interactions that happen, and the light that comes out of that is the data that this thing is collecting.

34
00:03:08.005 --> 00:03:14.470
Those flashes will then give us some idea about the origin of those neutrinos.

35
00:03:15.110 --> 00:03:17.012
And that's the central question.

36
00:03:17.843 --> 00:03:20.325
This observatory is Francis Halsey's baby.

37
00:03:21.386 --> 00:03:28.111
Its recent success at finding high-energy neutrinos of astrophysical origin, and I'm talking about outside the galaxy.

38
00:03:28.412 --> 00:03:29.793
That's what he's winning this award for.

39
00:03:30.173 --> 00:03:32.975
And, you know, it came kind of out of left field for us.

40
00:03:33.135 --> 00:03:34.637
It was not on my radar at all.

41
00:03:34.997 --> 00:03:44.985
But, you know, in 2014, the Ingenuity Awards that are awarded by the Smithsonian, one was given to Francis Halsey, and they had an accompanying project,

42
00:03:46.230 --> 00:03:47.912
comic book thing.

43
00:03:48.432 --> 00:03:49.153
Neutrino Man.

44
00:03:49.173 --> 00:03:50.334
And he was called Neutrino Man.

45
00:03:50.374 --> 00:04:00.145
And on the right-hand side over there, at the very last sort of comic strip, it says, you know, it's on the cover of Science, The Times, Nobel Prize question mark.

46
00:04:00.585 --> 00:04:02.888
So they were already, you know...

47
00:04:03.288 --> 00:04:07.551
Flirting with that idea that perhaps Francis Halsey would get the Nobel Prize.

48
00:04:07.611 --> 00:04:10.653
It's like the Simpsons meme where they predict everything in the future in the Simpsons.

49
00:04:10.673 --> 00:04:12.014
Yeah, exactly.

50
00:04:12.974 --> 00:04:14.255
This time it was the Smithsonian.

51
00:04:14.855 --> 00:04:17.877
So to understand this discovery, we need to understand neutrinos.

52
00:04:18.598 --> 00:04:28.184
And we need to understand why they are uniquely suited to tell us more about how the largest and most powerful particle accelerators in our universe work.

53
00:04:28.264 --> 00:04:28.604
Right.

54
00:04:28.764 --> 00:04:34.951
These are accelerators that are out in deep space, and they make CERN look like a hula hoop for ants.

55
00:04:35.612 --> 00:04:37.113
Honestly, they're insane.

56
00:04:37.474 --> 00:04:39.256
And it's not an easy question to answer.

57
00:04:39.296 --> 00:04:40.497
This is the fundamental question.

58
00:04:40.817 --> 00:04:44.802
How do these particle accelerators work of extragalactic origin?

59
00:04:44.822 --> 00:04:44.982
Yeah.

60
00:04:46.358 --> 00:05:00.530
It's not easy because you need to distinguish between the cosmic neutrinos that come from these particle accelerators out in deep space and all of the neutrinos that we get bathed by on a daily basis that are coming from the Earth's atmosphere, that are coming from the sun.

61
00:05:00.831 --> 00:05:07.236
There's something like 60 billion neutrinos that are passing through my fingernail right now as we tape this episode.

62
00:05:07.797 --> 00:05:13.962
You've got to be able to sift through all of that and find the ones that are coming from way out there, right?

63
00:05:15.367 --> 00:05:16.268
That's what this is about.

64
00:05:16.808 --> 00:05:28.955
And so the first place that we need to start to understand the Ice Cube Neutrino Observatory is probably the middle word in the name.

65
00:05:30.316 --> 00:05:35.559
People might know Ice Cube, not the rapper from California or the actor, if you might know.

66
00:05:35.819 --> 00:05:37.340
People kind of know what an observatory is.

67
00:05:37.800 --> 00:05:40.902
But what are neutrinos?

68
00:05:42.147 --> 00:05:44.649
So neutrinos are an enigmatic particle.

69
00:05:44.689 --> 00:05:49.972
They entered physics in 1930 because people were observing radioactive beta decay.

70
00:05:50.472 --> 00:05:51.753
You need to conserve charge.

71
00:05:52.113 --> 00:05:53.094
So a proton comes out.

72
00:05:53.114 --> 00:05:54.034
That's the positive charge.

73
00:05:54.074 --> 00:05:55.375
But we started with a neutron.

74
00:05:55.815 --> 00:05:58.397
So an electron has to come out so that it balances out.

75
00:05:58.997 --> 00:06:00.518
And people thought, okay, that's enough, right?

76
00:06:00.618 --> 00:06:03.340
But if you look at the data...

77
00:06:04.290 --> 00:06:05.491
energy was being lost.

78
00:06:06.493 --> 00:06:06.773
Okay?

79
00:06:07.254 --> 00:06:08.435
This was a huge conundrum.

80
00:06:08.515 --> 00:06:09.756
People were like, where's the energy going?

81
00:06:09.797 --> 00:06:12.680
Niels Bohr very famously said, maybe energy is not conserved.

82
00:06:13.080 --> 00:06:14.642
Everyone else was like, what are you talking about?

83
00:06:14.802 --> 00:06:17.005
Oh, because we have to have conservation of energy.

84
00:06:17.025 --> 00:06:17.445
Yeah, right.

85
00:06:17.526 --> 00:06:19.127
And because of conservation of energy...

86
00:06:19.748 --> 00:06:21.409
I mean, that's like the central tenet, right?

87
00:06:21.529 --> 00:06:24.691
And Niels Bohr said, well, this experiment shows maybe it's only averaged.

88
00:06:25.091 --> 00:06:27.052
Wolfgang Pauli, on the other hand, was like, no.

89
00:06:27.292 --> 00:06:27.913
Okay?

90
00:06:28.413 --> 00:06:32.395
The conservation of energy is up there on the pedestal.

91
00:06:32.895 --> 00:06:37.478
The universe will have created an accounting trick in order to make it work.

92
00:06:37.638 --> 00:06:41.000
And he wrote this very famous letter to a conference in Tübingen, Germany.

93
00:06:41.080 --> 00:06:44.222
He starts out with, dear radioactive ladies and gentlemen.

94
00:06:45.502 --> 00:06:48.184
And he postulates that there is a particle.

95
00:06:49.188 --> 00:06:57.654
that is neutral, that has the mass of probably zero, and that has a spin of one half to conserve angular momentum.

96
00:06:58.695 --> 00:07:02.317
And this thing he called the neutrino.

97
00:07:02.417 --> 00:07:07.781
Actually, Enrico Fermi coined that term because it's neutral, but it's a small one, so it's the little one.

98
00:07:08.282 --> 00:07:09.362
So hence the neutrino.

99
00:07:09.683 --> 00:07:11.324
Enrico Fermi comes up with this name.

100
00:07:11.824 --> 00:07:12.725
It's postulated.

101
00:07:12.825 --> 00:07:16.207
Finally, they are detected experimentally in 1956 that's the neutrino.

102
00:07:17.728 --> 00:07:39.278
using anti-neutrinos from a nuclear reactor this was by c cohen and f ryan is they both won um ryan's actually won the nobel prize in physics in 1995 he was at the university of california in irvine that was uci's first nobel prize in physics um cohen had passed away in 1974 so he never got to share that nobel prize

103
00:07:39.998 --> 00:07:45.282
And so now neutrinos have become part of a much larger particle zoo that we call the standard model.

104
00:07:45.562 --> 00:07:52.788
All the way from the Higgs, the God particle at the very center, you've got the bosons, which are the force carriers on the outside.

105
00:07:53.628 --> 00:07:56.310
That's the photon, the gluon, and the W and Z bosons.

106
00:07:56.891 --> 00:07:59.873
And then you've got the particles on the outside.

107
00:08:00.353 --> 00:08:01.474
On the top are the quarks.

108
00:08:01.634 --> 00:08:04.816
Those are the things that make up protons and neutrons, the nucleus of the atom.

109
00:08:05.157 --> 00:08:06.738
And on the bottom are leptons.

110
00:08:07.886 --> 00:08:11.629
Leptons are the electron, the muon, and the tau.

111
00:08:11.669 --> 00:08:17.294
Those are the negatively charged, smallish particles that don't interact with the strong nuclear force.

112
00:08:17.874 --> 00:08:20.476
And their partners are the neutrinos.

113
00:08:21.117 --> 00:08:23.519
For the electron, we've got an electron neutrino.

114
00:08:23.579 --> 00:08:25.961
For the tau, we've got a tau neutrino, so on and so forth.

115
00:08:26.301 --> 00:08:32.806
So these are sort of the fundamental building blocks for everything we see in the world around us.

116
00:08:32.826 --> 00:08:34.988
Yes, everything except for gravity.

117
00:08:35.548 --> 00:08:38.732
is contained in that representation right there.

118
00:08:38.752 --> 00:08:44.178
This is like the periodic table distilled down to its absolute essentials.

119
00:08:44.739 --> 00:08:50.906
And just to clarify, these absolute essentials all have a dance partner, which is a neutrino version of themselves.

120
00:08:51.066 --> 00:08:51.786
Yeah, no.

121
00:08:52.006 --> 00:08:55.427
Well, on the bottom, the three are the tau, muon, and electron.

122
00:08:55.587 --> 00:08:57.928
Those guys have the dance partner on the right-hand side.

123
00:08:58.128 --> 00:08:59.768
That's the V-looking thing.

124
00:09:00.048 --> 00:09:03.709
So the electron neutrino, the tau neutrino, and the muon neutrino.

125
00:09:03.769 --> 00:09:06.330
So neutrinos are only in this lepton category.

126
00:09:06.350 --> 00:09:08.391
Yes, and neutrinos are leptons.

127
00:09:08.491 --> 00:09:13.712
Just like the quarks have their own dance partner, like the up has a down, the strange has a charm.

128
00:09:14.032 --> 00:09:16.433
Similarly, the electrons have their own dance partners.

129
00:09:16.753 --> 00:09:32.880
We just happened to discover neutrinos as the dance partners for the other leptons by way of this kind of entry point with Pauli and Enrico Fermi and his initial questions because we were seeing the loss of energy in beta decay.

130
00:09:32.920 --> 00:09:35.041
That rule can't be broken.

131
00:09:35.141 --> 00:09:35.901
That rule cannot be broken.

132
00:09:38.362 --> 00:09:40.926
Okay, so that's the neutrino.

133
00:09:41.227 --> 00:09:42.849
Okay, so this makes sense.

134
00:09:42.869 --> 00:09:50.040
So now we kind of understand, you know, what is the thing that this Nobel Prize is sort of looking to discover or detect.

135
00:09:51.403 --> 00:09:52.584
But I think as you mentioned earlier...

136
00:09:53.726 --> 00:09:55.387
They're already here on Earth.

137
00:09:55.907 --> 00:09:56.907
Yeah, we've detected them.

138
00:09:56.947 --> 00:09:59.008
Because they make up stuff around us.

139
00:10:00.288 --> 00:10:04.969
And they were originally detected using decay of radioactive material here on Earth.

140
00:10:05.089 --> 00:10:05.289
Right.

141
00:10:05.870 --> 00:10:06.650
So who cares?

142
00:10:07.210 --> 00:10:11.551
Or why does it matter that we detect neutrinos that are coming from space?

143
00:10:11.711 --> 00:10:11.911
Yeah.

144
00:10:12.331 --> 00:10:13.972
This is the big leap.

145
00:10:14.698 --> 00:10:17.580
that is central to this particular Nobel Prize.

146
00:10:17.780 --> 00:10:31.428
So right after Cohen and Ryan's detected the neutrino, it was immediately understood that it would be an ideal astronomical messenger because it's electrically neutral, so it doesn't get messed around by magnetic fields.

147
00:10:32.148 --> 00:10:36.493
And it's only subject to weak interactions or gravitational interactions.

148
00:10:36.553 --> 00:10:39.576
Gravity doesn't really move stuff around all that much.

149
00:10:39.756 --> 00:10:40.016
It's weak.

150
00:10:40.036 --> 00:10:40.897
To be perfectly honest.

151
00:10:40.917 --> 00:10:45.201
Because the neutrino especially, it's weak and the neutrino is like near massless.

152
00:10:45.562 --> 00:10:46.663
So it's just going to like go through.

153
00:10:46.683 --> 00:10:49.786
I mean it can still move around because of the curvature of space-time.

154
00:10:50.206 --> 00:10:51.528
But you know, not by a lot.

155
00:10:52.339 --> 00:10:54.641
And it's not really interacting with other types of matter.

156
00:10:54.721 --> 00:11:01.768
And so it could give us a sense of what's happening in astronomical sources because it's a direct line of sight.

157
00:11:02.601 --> 00:11:03.041
Oh, okay.

158
00:11:03.081 --> 00:11:03.701
That's interesting.

159
00:11:03.761 --> 00:11:03.982
Yeah.

160
00:11:04.122 --> 00:11:12.769
And the first time that this was actually discovered was in 1987 by two Nobel Prize winners, Davis and Koshiba.

161
00:11:12.809 --> 00:11:21.337
They were awarded the Nobel Prize in 2002 for pioneering contributions to astrophysics, in particular the detection of cosmic neutrinos.

162
00:11:21.617 --> 00:11:23.819
These guys are the first who detected cosmic neutrinos.

163
00:11:23.839 --> 00:11:25.060
What they did was...

164
00:11:26.097 --> 00:11:31.002
detect neutrinos from a very significant event, supernova 1987A.

165
00:11:31.322 --> 00:11:39.310
On the right-hand side, that's a picture of the Magellanic Cloud, which is a kind of dwarf galaxy that's orbiting the Milky Way.

166
00:11:39.830 --> 00:11:41.371
In 1987, a star went supernova.

167
00:11:44.154 --> 00:11:46.055
That's really nice because it's really close to us.

168
00:11:46.175 --> 00:11:47.056
It's not in the Milky Way.

169
00:11:47.076 --> 00:11:48.597
If it was too close, we'd be freaked out.

170
00:11:48.957 --> 00:11:57.023
But this is just far enough that you see that central, really bright star that's like outshining almost the entire galactic core over there.

171
00:11:57.604 --> 00:12:00.506
That is a new star that wasn't there like a week before.

172
00:12:00.926 --> 00:12:01.707
That's so unbelievable.

173
00:12:02.567 --> 00:12:04.028
You could see it with your naked eye.

174
00:12:04.488 --> 00:12:05.869
It was a new star that had formed.

175
00:12:05.909 --> 00:12:09.290
People were traveling to the southern hemisphere to see this thing.

176
00:12:09.390 --> 00:12:14.712
And believe me, had I been alive and had the ability, I would have gotten on a flight to see this thing with my naked eye.

177
00:12:14.772 --> 00:12:16.292
I mean, this is incredible, right?

178
00:12:17.353 --> 00:12:18.193
That's a supernova.

179
00:12:18.413 --> 00:12:19.594
That's the light coming from it.

180
00:12:19.954 --> 00:12:23.295
These two detected the neutrinos that came from that explosion.

181
00:12:23.595 --> 00:12:26.856
And that was the first time that we were like, oh, so we can actually do this.

182
00:12:26.916 --> 00:12:28.677
We can do neutrino astronomy.

183
00:12:29.686 --> 00:12:30.307
Right.

184
00:12:30.667 --> 00:12:41.653
It's a pathway by which to observe – usually we use photons to observe or other aspects of the electromagnetic spectrum to observe what's happening in space.

185
00:12:41.693 --> 00:12:41.953
Yeah.

186
00:12:41.973 --> 00:12:42.593
To create a map.

187
00:12:43.394 --> 00:12:44.935
What we're saying is there's another way to do so.

188
00:12:44.955 --> 00:12:45.135
Yeah.

189
00:12:45.455 --> 00:12:50.359
And it happens to be that neutrinos are this other vector for mapping the world, the universe around us.

190
00:12:50.439 --> 00:12:50.920
Exactly.

191
00:12:50.940 --> 00:12:52.381
Is that kind of the right way to think about it?

192
00:12:52.401 --> 00:12:53.142
That's exactly right.

193
00:12:53.282 --> 00:12:59.347
And those particular neutrinos from the supernova 1987A, those were on the order of mega electron volts.

194
00:12:59.487 --> 00:13:02.330
So that's 10 to the 6, like a billion.

195
00:13:03.250 --> 00:13:04.732
Or no, a million electron volts.

196
00:13:04.792 --> 00:13:05.512
Mega is a million.

197
00:13:05.873 --> 00:13:06.993
A million electron volts.

198
00:13:07.014 --> 00:13:07.694
Okay.

199
00:13:07.734 --> 00:13:08.215
Pretty big.

200
00:13:08.275 --> 00:13:08.975
Yeah.

201
00:13:09.255 --> 00:13:12.178
This year, the Nobel Prize recognizes the discovery of...

202
00:13:13.493 --> 00:13:39.700
peta electron volt energies 10 to the 15 okay 10 to the 15 electron volts a tera electron volt is a trillion electron volts a peta electron volt is a thousand trillion electron volts okay this this thing is insane and it's only possible because of an observatory like ice cube okay the reason to pursue these particles comes from a century-old mystery because we know they exist

203
00:13:42.528 --> 00:13:43.509
It's about cosmic rays.

204
00:13:43.549 --> 00:13:47.074
Cosmic rays were first discovered in 1912 by Hess.

205
00:13:47.154 --> 00:13:49.357
He was the Nobel prize winner in 1936.

206
00:13:49.717 --> 00:13:53.101
He, he got on a balloon literally.

207
00:13:53.762 --> 00:13:54.443
And, um,

208
00:13:55.272 --> 00:14:02.237
Like, detected an excess of charged particles in the upper atmosphere coming from, like, extraterrestrial origin.

209
00:14:02.457 --> 00:14:05.620
Dude, physicists back in the day... Back there, right.

210
00:14:05.660 --> 00:14:06.901
We're really putting there...

211
00:14:06.981 --> 00:14:10.863
It's gumshoe work out in the field.

212
00:14:10.904 --> 00:14:11.424
Yeah.

213
00:14:11.544 --> 00:14:11.984
That's fun.

214
00:14:12.164 --> 00:14:12.725
Isn't that hilarious?

215
00:14:12.885 --> 00:14:13.926
Yeah, that's quite fun.

216
00:14:14.046 --> 00:14:14.266
Right.

217
00:14:14.366 --> 00:14:20.711
And so these cosmic rays, we'd figured out, they're mostly protons and charged atomic nuclei that are arriving from space.

218
00:14:21.031 --> 00:14:21.811
And some of these...

219
00:14:22.652 --> 00:14:27.234
cosmic rays reach energies of 10 to the 20 electron volts.

220
00:14:27.514 --> 00:14:32.895
Okay, that's far beyond what anything on Earth that we've built can do.

221
00:14:32.995 --> 00:14:35.496
Okay, CERN is at about 10 to the 12.

222
00:14:35.836 --> 00:14:36.817
This is 10 to the 20.

223
00:14:36.877 --> 00:14:38.677
That's eight orders of magnitude above.

224
00:14:38.957 --> 00:14:47.040
So that's like 10, no, 100 million times more energy per particle than CERN.

225
00:14:47.770 --> 00:14:52.538
Okay, that's not a joke because CERN is like really kind of the limit of what we can do right now.

226
00:14:52.939 --> 00:14:58.508
Okay, there are proposals for larger ones, but even then you're adding like maybe an order of magnitude.

227
00:14:58.528 --> 00:14:59.109
Right, not eight.

228
00:14:59.250 --> 00:15:01.093
And it's like hard to do that.

229
00:15:01.313 --> 00:15:01.574
Okay.

230
00:15:02.597 --> 00:15:05.739
10 to the 20 electron volts is an insane amount.

231
00:15:06.240 --> 00:15:15.266
The very famous Oh My God particle, which we have covered on this podcast before, this was named because researchers shouted, Oh My God, when they saw this particle.

232
00:15:15.567 --> 00:15:16.647
It was in 1991.

233
00:15:16.687 --> 00:15:18.269
It was discovered in Utah.

234
00:15:18.289 --> 00:15:21.531
There was an array in one of the salt flats in Utah.

235
00:15:21.931 --> 00:15:26.895
And what they figured out was that this thing must have been traveling at 99.99999 with like

236
00:15:29.797 --> 00:15:32.000
15 nines, the speed of light.

237
00:15:32.040 --> 00:15:34.983
This was the fastest thing, this is currently still,

238
00:15:35.925 --> 00:15:39.687
This is the fastest thing that we have ever observed in our universe.

239
00:15:40.068 --> 00:15:43.310
And it begs the question, like, what is actually making it that fast?

240
00:15:43.830 --> 00:15:44.030
Right.

241
00:15:44.450 --> 00:15:53.736
The point is the source of where it came from is an interesting thing to understand because it is basically able to get the closest to the speed of light that we've seen.

242
00:15:53.796 --> 00:15:54.917
Yeah.

243
00:15:55.157 --> 00:15:56.478
Of any massive particle.

244
00:15:56.578 --> 00:15:56.738
Right.

245
00:15:56.778 --> 00:16:00.000
Like, this thing had enough energy, a single particle.

246
00:16:00.120 --> 00:16:03.002
Like, could be a proton, could be maybe an atomic nucleus.

247
00:16:03.322 --> 00:16:03.963
This thing had...

248
00:16:04.743 --> 00:16:13.048
the same amount of energy as like Yamamoto from the Dodgers throwing a baseball, a single particle, right?

249
00:16:13.548 --> 00:16:16.770
It's insane the amount of energy that was packed into this thing.

250
00:16:16.810 --> 00:16:20.112
And it's very non-trivial how you even do that, right?

251
00:16:21.272 --> 00:16:24.434
Let's first talk about like the energy spectrum of cosmic rays, right?

252
00:16:24.474 --> 00:16:27.076
Because you could be like, oh, that's a fluke, right?

253
00:16:27.156 --> 00:16:28.837
It's like, I don't know.

254
00:16:29.604 --> 00:16:37.731
Well, the more and more that we detect, we can actually now trace what's the probability that we're going to get a certain cosmic ray of a certain energy.

255
00:16:37.871 --> 00:16:39.233
And that's called the energy spectrum.

256
00:16:39.553 --> 00:16:40.974
On the left-hand side, that's the plot.

257
00:16:41.114 --> 00:16:45.318
On the y-axis is the flux of how much we're getting.

258
00:16:45.438 --> 00:16:48.901
And on the x-axis is the amount of energy.

259
00:16:48.961 --> 00:16:50.623
Both are in log scale, crucially.

260
00:16:50.663 --> 00:16:52.364
So you're getting a power law.

261
00:16:52.645 --> 00:16:52.865
Now...

262
00:16:53.873 --> 00:16:58.437
The ones that are low energy on the left-hand side, those things are pretty common.

263
00:16:58.477 --> 00:17:01.279
You'll get like one particle per square meter per second.

264
00:17:01.659 --> 00:17:02.280
That's the flux.

265
00:17:02.460 --> 00:17:12.548
So if you had like a detector that was one square meter, every second you'd get a single particle that's like, you know, I don't know, 10 to the 11, 10 to the 12, like the stuff at CERN.

266
00:17:13.048 --> 00:17:17.232
The universe is giving us the stuff at CERN at about one per...

267
00:17:17.772 --> 00:17:19.053
second per square meter.

268
00:17:19.453 --> 00:17:19.674
Okay.

269
00:17:20.014 --> 00:17:26.198
Then there is a knee in this, in, in this plot.

270
00:17:26.439 --> 00:17:26.679
Okay.

271
00:17:27.099 --> 00:17:41.910
The, the feature there is called a knee because up to this energy, which is about like 10 to the, 10 to the 15 electron volts, all, all of the stuff before then is stuff that probably originates within the Milky Way.

272
00:17:41.930 --> 00:17:42.110
Okay.

273
00:17:43.377 --> 00:18:09.096
there's almost a ceiling yeah to how far it could have been from yeah but then there's a little kink and that's telling us that there is another source okay and that other source is probably extra galactic this is where we're getting to like one particle per square meter per year okay okay the the the probability of it coming straight at earth right in our little square meter detector is getting lower and lower

274
00:18:09.990 --> 00:18:20.138
Partly because in every direction, the greater the distance, the easier it is as it travels over that long distance for it to miss Earth because we become an increasingly smaller target.

275
00:18:20.178 --> 00:18:24.141
The source itself is not, I mean, there's not that many sources that are doing this.

276
00:18:24.241 --> 00:18:27.544
And so as it spreads out, like, you know, the probability is very, very low.

277
00:18:27.904 --> 00:18:33.368
And then finally, there's an ankle, and that's one particle per square kilometer per year.

278
00:18:34.089 --> 00:18:36.530
That's at around 10 to the 18, 10 to the 19 kilometers.

279
00:18:38.327 --> 00:18:39.408
Those are the ones that we want.

280
00:18:39.768 --> 00:18:40.008
Okay?

281
00:18:40.028 --> 00:18:41.970
Those are extra, extra galactic.

282
00:18:42.230 --> 00:18:42.850
Right?

283
00:18:43.150 --> 00:18:45.172
There's the ones that happen within our solar system.

284
00:18:45.732 --> 00:18:48.054
Then there's the one that happens within the galaxy.

285
00:18:48.414 --> 00:18:51.977
And then there's the extra galactic, the ones that we don't, like, what?

286
00:18:52.397 --> 00:18:53.638
That's the oh my god particle.

287
00:18:53.678 --> 00:18:53.858
Right?

288
00:18:54.158 --> 00:18:54.338
Yep.

289
00:18:54.679 --> 00:18:57.641
So there's these three sources that we're trying to make sense of.

290
00:18:58.381 --> 00:18:58.581
Right?

291
00:18:59.702 --> 00:19:06.247
In order to find the ones that are really, really energetic, we need to do a lot of work.

292
00:19:07.673 --> 00:19:12.436
Now, before we get into that, let's just try to hypothesize what could even do this.

293
00:19:12.817 --> 00:19:17.140
It's of extragalactic origin that we're talking about.

294
00:19:17.220 --> 00:19:19.642
What kind of particle accelerator would actually do this?

295
00:19:20.422 --> 00:19:34.713
If you do the calculation, you actually figure out that where that ankle was, that marks where the gyro radius of a proton, meaning how big of a circle would be needed for a magnetic field to accelerate that thing,

296
00:19:35.870 --> 00:19:38.311
That exceeds the galaxy.

297
00:19:39.371 --> 00:19:44.954
The gyroradius of a proton that is traveling that fast exceeds galactic scales.

298
00:19:45.234 --> 00:19:47.735
You need a particle accelerator larger than a galaxy.

299
00:19:48.415 --> 00:19:48.935
I don't like it.

300
00:19:48.955 --> 00:19:51.797
If you just do the fundamental physics.

301
00:19:51.857 --> 00:19:52.337
I don't like it.

302
00:19:52.677 --> 00:19:53.477
It's weird.

303
00:19:53.557 --> 00:19:59.500
That's quite... And I'm thinking in my head one thing, but let's see if it's going to go in that direction.

304
00:19:59.540 --> 00:20:00.500
It's ridiculous, right?

305
00:20:00.560 --> 00:20:04.422
So one proposed accelerator is the active galactic nucleus.

306
00:20:04.902 --> 00:20:13.230
I mean, this is where you've got a galaxy that's super energetic in the central region, probably a supermassive black hole that is accreting matter.

307
00:20:13.770 --> 00:20:17.093
And it launches these powerful jets in both directions.

308
00:20:17.594 --> 00:20:25.061
Those jets, when they encounter their surroundings, they create shockwaves and those shockwaves can start accelerating particles.

309
00:20:25.871 --> 00:20:28.272
because the magnetic fields there are not homogenous.

310
00:20:28.292 --> 00:20:29.713
They're not like constant everywhere.

311
00:20:29.993 --> 00:20:30.834
And so you get like these...

312
00:20:31.154 --> 00:20:31.894
Which we've talked about.

313
00:20:31.914 --> 00:20:32.134
Yeah.

314
00:20:32.535 --> 00:20:35.056
And so you get these massive, massive particle jets, right?

315
00:20:35.116 --> 00:20:42.140
So in a simplified picture, the particle would repeatedly create a shock and it would scatter off these magnetic irregularities.

316
00:20:43.032 --> 00:20:48.581
And the particle has to be held in this magnetic field for long enough to gain that kind of energy.

317
00:20:48.741 --> 00:20:51.866
Again, it's not really trivial how this would work, right?

318
00:20:52.126 --> 00:20:54.390
Another source could be clusters of galaxies.

319
00:20:55.091 --> 00:20:57.995
As cold gas accretes and falls into the hot water,

320
00:20:58.685 --> 00:21:01.526
Medium on the inside, that's going to give rise to shockwaves.

321
00:21:01.906 --> 00:21:08.748
And those shockwaves at the outskirts of this cluster could be powerful enough to give off this kind of acceleration.

322
00:21:09.068 --> 00:21:10.048
But the point is we don't know.

323
00:21:10.708 --> 00:21:11.428
And we'd like to know.

324
00:21:11.548 --> 00:21:12.129
We'd like to know.

325
00:21:12.329 --> 00:21:14.109
Where are these ghostly messengers coming from?

326
00:21:14.169 --> 00:21:20.191
Yeah, it's pretty insane that you can create a particle that is that energetic.

327
00:21:20.291 --> 00:21:25.132
It just doesn't make sense how you pack so much energy into such a tiny amount of...

328
00:21:25.972 --> 00:21:26.772
matter, right?

329
00:21:28.453 --> 00:21:31.534
If you want to do that, you want to figure out where these particles came from, right?

330
00:21:31.934 --> 00:21:33.674
Now, for the oh my god particle, right?

331
00:21:33.734 --> 00:21:46.958
You could figure out, oh, it came from that direction, but that's not really a good indication of where it came from, because charged particles can interact with the intergalactic medium, and they can interact with the magnetic fields there to start moving around.

332
00:21:47.318 --> 00:21:54.120
For example, in this particular example, you've got a supernova that's at the edge of our galaxy,

333
00:21:55.589 --> 00:21:58.651
There's a faint blue trace that you're seeing.

334
00:21:58.991 --> 00:22:08.776
That's what a charged particle would do because there's so much magnetic field anomalies in the galaxy that as it's traveling towards us, it's going to start moving around and bending.

335
00:22:09.016 --> 00:22:12.598
So even though the particle came from this direction, the actual source could be somewhere else.

336
00:22:12.798 --> 00:22:13.979
It's like a lazy river.

337
00:22:14.039 --> 00:22:19.342
It's like you can point and say the top of the lazy river is there, but when you're coming down it, it's not just like the line of sight.

338
00:22:19.382 --> 00:22:19.722
Yeah, yeah.

339
00:22:19.742 --> 00:22:21.263
The line of sight could be this way, right?

340
00:22:21.303 --> 00:22:23.164
Even though the mountain is to the right.

341
00:22:23.224 --> 00:22:23.684
Right, right.

342
00:22:24.024 --> 00:22:27.465
So instead, we wouldn't like something that has a clear line of sight.

343
00:22:28.905 --> 00:22:35.966
And that is where we start thinking about what else could we see, right?

344
00:22:36.427 --> 00:22:42.648
There's a particle accelerator that is like flinging these protons and these charged particles at extremely high velocities.

345
00:22:42.748 --> 00:22:45.368
What else could we see in that region that could come at us?

346
00:22:45.848 --> 00:22:46.909
There's two possibilities.

347
00:22:47.269 --> 00:22:53.110
This is a diagram showing some of the interactions that could be happening where the particle is accelerating, like at that...

348
00:22:54.017 --> 00:22:56.684
galactic core or at the origin point, right?

349
00:22:57.186 --> 00:22:59.412
This is a proton that's of cosmic ray origin.

350
00:23:00.067 --> 00:23:05.870
It interacts with, let's say, a gamma ray that's nearby, like all of the light and all of the random stuff that's going on.

351
00:23:06.570 --> 00:23:09.471
And it creates a particle of showers, pions.

352
00:23:09.512 --> 00:23:13.834
Those pions then decay into electrons, gamma rays, and neutrinos.

353
00:23:14.274 --> 00:23:15.975
Those are the three that we could kind of look for.

354
00:23:16.955 --> 00:23:18.296
Electrons have the same problem.

355
00:23:18.376 --> 00:23:20.737
They're charged, so they're going to be moving around as well.

356
00:23:21.377 --> 00:23:23.638
Gamma rays are interesting, right?

357
00:23:23.978 --> 00:23:27.340
Because gamma rays, they are uncharged,

358
00:23:28.438 --> 00:23:32.379
So they could be coming straight, and neutrinos are interesting because they're uncharged.

359
00:23:32.699 --> 00:23:35.059
The problem with gamma rays, though, is they're light.

360
00:23:35.719 --> 00:23:37.120
So let me just take a quick step.

361
00:23:37.140 --> 00:23:43.541
So the idea is we're trying to figure out what these giant particle accelerators, like, what are they?

362
00:23:43.641 --> 00:23:44.721
We're trying to understand what they are.

363
00:23:45.061 --> 00:23:49.102
And so we can detect them through the things they shoot across the universe.

364
00:23:49.202 --> 00:23:49.402
Yeah.

365
00:23:49.782 --> 00:23:56.463
And we've just gone through a list of the things we could detect that are not neutrinos that they shoot across the universe and why it doesn't really work.

366
00:23:56.603 --> 00:23:57.444
Yeah, it doesn't really work.

367
00:23:57.484 --> 00:24:04.570
Protons, which is the actual thing, if they came without interacting with anything, that doesn't really work because they're moving around through the galaxy.

368
00:24:06.212 --> 00:24:10.456
Gamma rays could work because at least they're coming straight at us.

369
00:24:10.636 --> 00:24:14.559
But again, they kind of get slowed down sometimes by the intergalactic medium.

370
00:24:15.000 --> 00:24:17.582
They're light, so they interact with the intergalactic medium.

371
00:24:19.133 --> 00:24:22.035
You got to put a telescope in space in order to actually see this thing.

372
00:24:22.095 --> 00:24:24.035
How big of a detector are you going to make in space?

373
00:24:24.055 --> 00:24:24.236
Space.

374
00:24:24.516 --> 00:24:24.716
Right?

375
00:24:24.856 --> 00:24:25.856
So there's an engineering problem.

376
00:24:25.876 --> 00:24:27.257
There's an engineering problem there as well.

377
00:24:27.277 --> 00:24:29.138
Because the Earth's atmosphere doesn't like gamma rays.

378
00:24:29.518 --> 00:24:30.899
Very good for us here on Earth.

379
00:24:30.919 --> 00:24:31.899
Because we don't want gamma rays.

380
00:24:31.919 --> 00:24:32.640
We don't want gamma rays.

381
00:24:32.660 --> 00:24:34.761
But like detecting them is kind of a hassle.

382
00:24:35.101 --> 00:24:37.382
Neutrinos, on the other hand, they're going to shoot right through.

383
00:24:37.802 --> 00:24:39.003
Not just the Earth's atmosphere.

384
00:24:39.063 --> 00:24:40.703
Not just all of intergalactic medium.

385
00:24:40.983 --> 00:24:42.164
But the Earth itself.

386
00:24:42.784 --> 00:24:43.044
Okay?

387
00:24:43.325 --> 00:24:47.386
This makes them kind of a nice target to look for.

388
00:24:47.406 --> 00:24:47.527
Right?

389
00:24:47.547 --> 00:24:47.707
Right?

390
00:24:48.687 --> 00:25:04.356
There's also an approximate energy connection because if the proton itself is at 10 to the 20 electron volts, in that interaction that I showed you with those particles, about 5% of the energy gets deposited into the neutrino.

391
00:25:04.576 --> 00:25:08.318
So we can reverse engineer back to the total initial energy starting point.

392
00:25:08.358 --> 00:25:11.880
Yeah, we can like probabilistically say that the original event...

393
00:25:12.600 --> 00:25:13.961
had some amount of energy.

394
00:25:14.261 --> 00:25:19.443
And so this is where we get into the kinds of neutrinos that we're trying to look at.

395
00:25:19.863 --> 00:25:28.367
If we want something that's 10 to the 20, then maybe we'll look at something that's around 10 to the 18, 10 to the 19 electron volts for the neutrinos.

396
00:25:28.467 --> 00:25:29.947
And that's kind of our target.

397
00:25:30.027 --> 00:25:36.590
So we now have a flux, which is one per square kilometer per year.

398
00:25:37.548 --> 00:25:40.991
And we have a kind of target energy that we want to take a look at.

399
00:25:41.451 --> 00:25:51.280
In our quest to again now find a way to figure out these highly energetic objects that are extra extra galactic.

400
00:25:52.341 --> 00:25:54.683
We've figured out the signature.

401
00:25:55.490 --> 00:26:18.918
that has the least that's least impacted by the sort of intergalactic medium on its journey which allows us then to make the most direct correlation back to that initial energy starting point so like we know what we're looking for yeah and why we are looking for it uh and so then the next obvious question is okay how do we how do we detect a neutrino

402
00:26:19.247 --> 00:26:19.727
That's right.

403
00:26:19.987 --> 00:26:21.208
It sounds very promising.

404
00:26:21.428 --> 00:26:31.651
It sounds very promising, but the same reason why the neutrino is a great candidate for extragalactic astronomy is also a reason why they're notoriously hard to detect.

405
00:26:32.271 --> 00:26:35.292
Namely, they don't interact with a lot of things.

406
00:26:35.452 --> 00:26:37.492
That's the whole point of trying to detect them.

407
00:26:37.612 --> 00:26:40.433
But at the end of the day, if they don't interact with stuff, how are you going to detect?

408
00:26:42.030 --> 00:26:42.511
see them, right?

409
00:26:42.731 --> 00:26:54.676
The reason why I can see light is because the light is readily interacting with the rods and cones in my eye which we talked about yesterday in yesterday's Nobel Prize So, neutrinos don't do this I mean, as I said, right?

410
00:26:54.776 --> 00:27:08.983
Every second 65 billion neutrinos from the sun flow through my fingernail I'm not feeling anything It's unbelievable There are a few ways that the neutrinos do interact and here's how it would happen

411
00:27:10.300 --> 00:27:14.082
On the left, you've got sort of a particle picture of how a neutrino would do something.

412
00:27:14.102 --> 00:27:19.306
The neutrino is coming from the upper left, and it is interacting with a nucleon.

413
00:27:19.766 --> 00:27:22.608
Nucleons are full of quarks, right, the up and down quarks.

414
00:27:22.628 --> 00:27:23.288
There's three of them.

415
00:27:23.308 --> 00:27:25.870
That's why there's two that are just sort of skating by.

416
00:27:26.210 --> 00:27:35.135
And one of the quarks is going to interact with this neutrino using the W or Z bosons, which is the weak nuclear force.

417
00:27:36.116 --> 00:27:37.677
When that interaction happens...

418
00:27:40.493 --> 00:27:42.794
we have either one of two choices, okay?

419
00:27:43.974 --> 00:27:55.819
Either an electron is going to be born that sort of moves off and carries some of the energy from that initial neutrino, or another type of neutrino is going to be born.

420
00:27:56.139 --> 00:28:03.122
Depending on what the interaction was, you can have either an electron coming out or a different type of neutrino coming out, okay?

421
00:28:04.343 --> 00:28:07.984
On the right-hand side, this is the first ever neutrino that was detected

422
00:28:09.743 --> 00:28:11.104
As a photograph.

423
00:28:11.484 --> 00:28:11.964
Okay.

424
00:28:12.205 --> 00:28:14.166
This is in a hydrogen bubble chamber.

425
00:28:15.066 --> 00:28:19.789
You see on the left there, there's just like kind of a source where three things are coming out.

426
00:28:20.470 --> 00:28:22.631
That's where the neutrino interaction happened.

427
00:28:22.751 --> 00:28:23.071
Okay.

428
00:28:23.251 --> 00:28:31.917
We're not seeing the neutrino come from the right-hand side of the page because the neutrino is just coming and then boom, it hits something over there, which caused a spray of particles.

429
00:28:32.577 --> 00:28:33.998
That's how we see if a neutrino...

430
00:28:35.171 --> 00:28:39.784
detection happens if randomly a spray of particles comes out and it's the exact

431
00:28:40.697 --> 00:28:42.498
type of particle that we expect.

432
00:28:42.578 --> 00:28:43.559
It has a fingerprint.

433
00:28:44.019 --> 00:28:44.799
It has a fingerprint.

434
00:28:44.839 --> 00:28:51.082
In this case, there's a proton coming out, there's a collision with a meson, and then there's also a mu meson that's coming out.

435
00:28:51.583 --> 00:28:58.366
And those things are exactly what we would expect if the neutrino interacted with the hydrogen that's in this bubble chamber.

436
00:28:58.726 --> 00:29:04.890
So would it be the case that because they're moving so quickly, it just like we just would see this interaction kind of pop out of nowhere?

437
00:29:05.010 --> 00:29:05.230
Mm-hmm.

438
00:29:05.850 --> 00:29:08.194
Yeah, I mean, because the neutrino we can't detect.

439
00:29:08.214 --> 00:29:08.915
We can't detect it.

440
00:29:09.015 --> 00:29:11.538
We can only see this like... Yeah, okay.

441
00:29:11.739 --> 00:29:17.387
Once the neutrino interacts with something, we can detect the byproducts because the byproducts are charged.

442
00:29:17.567 --> 00:29:21.593
So they're going to be interacting with the electromagnetic field, which then creates light.

443
00:29:22.145 --> 00:29:23.325
Okay, what type of light?

444
00:29:23.485 --> 00:29:25.246
This is Chernkov radiation.

445
00:29:25.686 --> 00:29:33.248
This is the very famous blue light that is emitted in particle, actually in nuclear reactors.

446
00:29:33.868 --> 00:29:44.831
When you have like nuclear reactor rods that are covered with water, those nuclear rods are emitting a bunch of particles that are moving at extremely high energies, right?

447
00:29:45.232 --> 00:29:46.652
Some of those energies are,

448
00:29:47.430 --> 00:29:51.294
lead to speeds that are faster than the speed of light in water.

449
00:29:51.594 --> 00:29:55.298
This is one of the way, way back when we did our IQ.

450
00:29:55.318 --> 00:29:56.560
Speed of light in ice.

451
00:29:56.620 --> 00:29:57.781
Yeah, exactly.

452
00:29:58.181 --> 00:29:59.523
Oh, geez, we'll remember that meme.

453
00:29:59.563 --> 00:30:02.926
Yeah, it was one of our first viral videos, actually.

454
00:30:03.186 --> 00:30:04.167
The idea is the following.

455
00:30:04.227 --> 00:30:04.508
So...

456
00:30:06.017 --> 00:30:11.799
The speed of light in a vacuum is the absolute speed limit of the universe.

457
00:30:12.280 --> 00:30:16.781
But light slows down in stuff because there's stuff that interacts with light.

458
00:30:17.081 --> 00:30:26.966
So as light bounces from one particle to the other, the phase velocity of light is actually slower than the actual velocity of light because of all of these interactions, right?

459
00:30:27.306 --> 00:30:29.847
In ice and in water, it can be as much as 20 to 30% slower.

460
00:30:29.867 --> 00:30:30.247
That gap...

461
00:30:33.498 --> 00:30:42.280
is now accessible to particles because the speed of light in a vacuum is the absolute limit, but this is what the speed of light is doing in all of this media.

462
00:30:42.740 --> 00:30:54.363
So if a charged particle moves faster than the speed of light in the medium, but obviously slower than the absolute limit imposed by Einstein's relativity, you get something called Chernkov radiation.

463
00:30:54.683 --> 00:31:00.464
In the same way that a fighter jet produces a sonic boom when it travels faster than the speed of sound,

464
00:31:01.373 --> 00:31:04.216
In this case, you're getting a light boom.

465
00:31:05.677 --> 00:31:06.738
The light boom!

466
00:31:06.878 --> 00:31:08.139
There you go, yeah.

467
00:31:08.699 --> 00:31:09.860
You get a light boom.

468
00:31:10.001 --> 00:31:13.283
It's a shockwave in the electromagnetic field.

469
00:31:13.484 --> 00:31:14.424
A photonic boom.

470
00:31:14.604 --> 00:31:15.425
A photonic boom.

471
00:31:15.485 --> 00:31:18.268
And that's the radiation that we are trying to catch.

472
00:31:18.688 --> 00:31:29.017
If we can catch Chernkov light, then we can reconstruct what the particle trajectories were, and then from that, then reconstruct what the neutrino was.

473
00:31:31.103 --> 00:31:57.987
was like how big the neutrino was in terms of energy and where it came from now the probability is extremely tiny okay at these peta electron volt energies the neutrino nucleon cross-section meaning like how often does the neutrino interact with quarks that cross-section is on the order of 10 to the minus 33 square centimeters that's like you can imagine this is like the the the target that the neutrino has to hit

474
00:31:58.950 --> 00:32:02.331
on the quark to like get an interaction.

475
00:32:02.651 --> 00:32:04.232
So extremely small.

476
00:32:05.272 --> 00:32:08.794
On top of that, the flux itself is very small.

477
00:32:09.434 --> 00:32:18.057
And so you need a giant, giant detector to be able to achieve any hope of detecting these things.

478
00:32:18.920 --> 00:32:26.122
Even though there's many of them coming through, at the level that we want to see, like the... Yeah, the energies that we want to see, there's not that many.

479
00:32:26.162 --> 00:32:27.143
There's not that many.

480
00:32:27.183 --> 00:32:32.344
When I say 60 billion coming through my fingernail, no, that's like 10 to the 5, 10 to the 6 electron volts.

481
00:32:32.384 --> 00:32:33.504
Those are the earthly ones.

482
00:32:33.524 --> 00:32:35.945
Those are the earthly ones, the solar system-y ones.

483
00:32:36.025 --> 00:32:37.446
We want the extra galactic.

484
00:32:37.466 --> 00:32:41.487
We want the extra galactic ones that are like 10 orders of magnitude above...

485
00:32:42.457 --> 00:32:44.158
Above the stuff that's going through my fingernail.

486
00:32:44.599 --> 00:32:52.525
And so, again, so now we know what a neutrino is, like how you would detect it because of this Chernkov radiation.

487
00:32:52.705 --> 00:33:01.412
It kind of accesses this gap when the speed of light through a medium like water or ice is lower than the absolute limit.

488
00:33:01.452 --> 00:33:03.834
And so there's sort of a signal that goes off.

489
00:33:03.854 --> 00:33:04.695
There's a little blue light.

490
00:33:05.095 --> 00:33:06.056
Oh, no, don't worry.

491
00:33:06.076 --> 00:33:07.518
We're not violating the laws of physics.

492
00:33:07.558 --> 00:33:08.078
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

493
00:33:08.118 --> 00:33:09.640
No, Einstein is still happy.

494
00:33:09.680 --> 00:33:13.223
We just want you to know we're here, right?

495
00:33:13.383 --> 00:33:19.889
So now, because the problem set is clear, this is like a highly improbable event to capture.

496
00:33:19.909 --> 00:33:20.110
Yeah.

497
00:33:20.410 --> 00:33:22.011
So how would we make...

498
00:33:22.932 --> 00:33:48.493
a neutrino observatory because this is very different than hubble and jwst and the other types of observatories that many folks would think about when they hear that word that's right because in in hubble and all of these traditional observatories you just look for the light and light is and then you capture the light and you're good to go here we're looking for like a second messenger right we're not detecting the neutrino we're detecting how the neutrino interacts with the stuff

499
00:33:49.093 --> 00:33:50.673
that we then look at.

500
00:33:50.693 --> 00:33:51.393
Okay.

501
00:33:51.854 --> 00:33:52.854
And we need a lot of it.

502
00:33:53.194 --> 00:33:57.275
We need a lot of stuff because the flux of these events is so small.

503
00:33:58.215 --> 00:34:06.697
The first sort of attempt at doing this was DUMAND, DUMAND maybe, Deep Underwater Muon and Neutrino Detector Project.

504
00:34:06.737 --> 00:34:08.857
This was way back in 1960.

505
00:34:09.237 --> 00:34:13.398
They were trying to create a deep ocean detection project.

506
00:34:13.758 --> 00:34:16.281
off the coast of Hawaii, off the main island.

507
00:34:16.301 --> 00:34:18.423
This was spearheaded by the University of Hawaii.

508
00:34:18.843 --> 00:34:27.871
What they wanted to do was basically on the ocean floor rest a bunch of these detectors, like in this case there's six, that are coming out of the ocean floor.

509
00:34:28.392 --> 00:34:31.935
Each of these detectors is going to detect this light.

510
00:34:32.236 --> 00:34:36.960
It's a bunch of photomultiplier tubes in some sense, which just, once a photon comes in,

511
00:34:37.549 --> 00:34:46.554
that's going to be converted into an electrical signal, very much like a CCD that's in our camera, but like on steroids, like a single photon will set this thing off.

512
00:34:46.854 --> 00:34:47.034
Right.

513
00:34:47.475 --> 00:34:49.276
And it was right off the coast of Hawaii.

514
00:34:50.176 --> 00:34:51.317
There were a lot of problems, though.

515
00:34:51.697 --> 00:34:54.939
The first time you try something as crazy as this, there's going to be problems.

516
00:34:56.313 --> 00:35:00.095
A big thing was measurement backgrounds from ocean bioluminescence.

517
00:35:00.135 --> 00:35:01.076
Yeah, I was going to say.

518
00:35:01.096 --> 00:35:04.898
Because like the living things in the ocean themselves produce light.

519
00:35:05.258 --> 00:35:11.261
And if these things are that sensitive, they're just going to go off on the ocean bioluminescence.

520
00:35:11.321 --> 00:35:19.065
Now, all of that stuff is in the visible range, but that means that we have to tune our detectors for higher frequency light.

521
00:35:19.405 --> 00:35:23.047
And that, you know, removes a whole chunk of stuff that we would be otherwise seeing.

522
00:35:23.067 --> 00:35:23.387
Mm-hmm.

523
00:35:24.785 --> 00:35:32.094
The other thing was the ocean is full of potassium-40, which is a radioactive isotope of potassium.

524
00:35:33.736 --> 00:35:36.539
So there's radiation in the ocean itself.

525
00:35:37.629 --> 00:35:40.990
Like the water itself has dissolved radioactive potassium.

526
00:35:41.470 --> 00:35:45.092
And so you get this massive background, which is just super annoying.

527
00:35:45.312 --> 00:35:47.252
And you're just going to spend all your time filtering out.

528
00:35:47.352 --> 00:35:47.853
Right, yeah.

529
00:35:47.893 --> 00:35:49.933
So the project was canceled in 1995.

530
00:35:50.514 --> 00:35:54.255
It had serious engineering problems, but we learned a lot about it.

531
00:35:54.795 --> 00:35:57.916
Because we learn a lot whenever we try new things.

532
00:35:58.216 --> 00:36:05.599
And now there are new detectors in bodies of water that are actually trying to do the same thing, but in a much bigger sense.

533
00:36:05.719 --> 00:36:08.881
My favorite one is actually the Baikal Neutrino Telescope.

534
00:36:08.901 --> 00:36:13.962
This is in Lake Baikal, which is the largest body of fresh water on the planet.

535
00:36:13.982 --> 00:36:14.763
It has something like...

536
00:36:15.563 --> 00:36:19.725
25% of the world's fresh water in a single lake in Russia.

537
00:36:20.365 --> 00:36:31.629
And they've got a very similar detector from Dumond, where in the bottom they've got these photomultiplier tubes that are arranged in a grid, and they're trying to find neutrinos.

538
00:36:33.209 --> 00:36:36.591
So water-based detection is working, right?

539
00:36:37.831 --> 00:36:42.933
But there are problems with trying to get it to detect the really, really high-energy stuff.

540
00:36:43.490 --> 00:36:48.501
Okay, again, because of some of the background, some of that radiation stuff, so on and so forth.

541
00:36:48.882 --> 00:36:51.127
So this is where our Nobel laureate...

542
00:36:52.738 --> 00:36:53.158
comes in.

543
00:36:54.219 --> 00:36:55.260
This is...

544
00:36:56.220 --> 00:36:59.663
I always love talking about this story because it's one of those...

545
00:37:01.824 --> 00:37:04.226
There's so much deeper than what you see on the headline.

546
00:37:06.387 --> 00:37:13.933
You know, people take away Antarctica and Neutrino, not knowing and understanding the importance of Neutrino in terms of this mapping piece.

547
00:37:14.373 --> 00:37:17.455
How can an observatory be under the ice?

548
00:37:17.815 --> 00:37:18.236
How can...

549
00:37:18.856 --> 00:37:20.997
How can you move faster than the speed of light through ice?

550
00:37:21.037 --> 00:37:21.317
Yeah.

551
00:37:21.717 --> 00:37:23.398
There's a lot of working parts, right?

552
00:37:23.438 --> 00:37:23.818
Yeah, yeah.

553
00:37:23.898 --> 00:37:25.538
And this is where Francis Halsey comes in.

554
00:37:25.758 --> 00:37:32.341
In 1987, he's giving a talk at the University of Kansas about the possibility of detecting neutrinos using water.

555
00:37:32.701 --> 00:37:44.945
And a glaciologist who was in the audience, he informs Halsey that there are Russian plans to detect radio emissions of charged particles produced by neutrino interactions in the Antarctic ice.

556
00:37:45.485 --> 00:37:47.466
They're using radio detectors, okay?

557
00:37:48.533 --> 00:37:52.717
Now, the idea here is that the neutrino collides with an atomic nucleus in the ice.

558
00:37:52.757 --> 00:37:55.499
That creates an electric spark, and that produces a radio wave.

559
00:37:55.980 --> 00:38:06.749
He quickly does some calculations with these colleagues, and he figures out that actually the detection threshold would be too high for the peta-electron volt neutrinos that we really want to see.

560
00:38:06.829 --> 00:38:07.050
Right.

561
00:38:07.370 --> 00:38:07.610
Okay?

562
00:38:08.171 --> 00:38:09.552
So, Halzen's idea...

563
00:38:10.564 --> 00:38:11.464
is wait.

564
00:38:12.245 --> 00:38:13.986
Ice is interesting though, okay?

565
00:38:14.226 --> 00:38:17.867
He's like, instead of radio, what if we used Chernkov radiation?

566
00:38:18.868 --> 00:38:32.634
And him and his research colleague, John Lerned, who was a big part of the Dumont project, he was actually at the University of Hawaii, they come out with this proposal at a conference in Poland in 1988.

567
00:38:33.094 --> 00:38:36.055
This is the proposal for an ice cube-like observatory.

568
00:38:40.414 --> 00:38:41.016
Their idea.

569
00:38:41.918 --> 00:38:43.702
The earth there is upside down.

570
00:38:43.963 --> 00:38:45.186
Antarctica is at the top.

571
00:38:45.747 --> 00:38:48.093
What they're proposing is to look downward...

572
00:38:48.793 --> 00:39:13.184
into the earth okay so if we were in antarctica our detector would be pointing downwards why because we want to look for neutrinos that have made it all the way through the earth if we look up we're going to get solar we're going to get atmospheric neutrinos we're going to get all sorts of stuff but the really high energy ones don't even care that the earth was there it's built-in filtering that yeah it's very different than the demand problem you're using the

573
00:39:15.287 --> 00:39:16.068
As a filter.

574
00:39:16.809 --> 00:39:17.890
It's pretty amazing.

575
00:39:18.130 --> 00:39:20.153
These two came up with this idea in 1988.

576
00:39:20.473 --> 00:39:22.735
Halzen takes this idea a little bit further.

577
00:39:23.496 --> 00:39:24.618
It's kind of just an idea.

578
00:39:25.438 --> 00:39:29.563
And then in Greenland, it works for the first time.

579
00:39:29.703 --> 00:39:32.967
So Greenland publishes the Greenland Detector...

580
00:39:33.452 --> 00:39:40.301
publishes in 1991 an observation of muons using polar ice caps as a Chernkov detector.

581
00:39:40.782 --> 00:39:49.273
They have a single sort of tube of photomultiplier tubes and they report using ice to detect Chernkov light.

582
00:39:50.373 --> 00:39:53.694
Once this happens, people are like, okay, so there's a chance.

583
00:39:53.754 --> 00:39:55.195
There's a chance this could actually happen.

584
00:39:55.215 --> 00:39:56.595
You're saying there's a chance.

585
00:39:56.635 --> 00:39:56.835
Right?

586
00:39:56.895 --> 00:39:57.135
Yeah.

587
00:39:57.435 --> 00:39:58.776
So now we could actually happen.

588
00:39:59.016 --> 00:40:02.017
The AMANDA project is proposed.

589
00:40:02.057 --> 00:40:05.598
This is the Antarctic Muon and Neutrino Detection Array.

590
00:40:06.258 --> 00:40:12.700
And the AMANDA project in Antarctica subsequently demonstrates the instrumentation that leads to IceCube.

591
00:40:13.984 --> 00:40:17.045
There's photomultiplier tubes that go down into these boreholes.

592
00:40:17.325 --> 00:40:23.027
The holes are drilled using high-pressure hot water systems that are originally pioneered for glaciology.

593
00:40:23.427 --> 00:40:28.728
The physicist just borrowed that and said, hey, you guys have been digging for climate change and glaciology.

594
00:40:29.289 --> 00:40:34.170
Let's do the same kind of tunneling, but now instead I'm going to put all these detectors into the ice.

595
00:40:34.710 --> 00:40:40.832
Amanda was constructed in phases from 1993 and 2000, and Halzen was a driving force.

596
00:40:41.305 --> 00:41:03.062
in amanda and in those early deployments they run into problems namely the ice that's at the very top it's very white right the reason why it's white is because there's a lot of air that's trapped in the ice that's what's causing the diffraction right and you can't really see that far into the ice well

597
00:41:04.398 --> 00:41:10.420
Just the same reason why we can't see into the ice all that far, or the light doesn't penetrate.

598
00:41:10.840 --> 00:41:17.642
Well, that means that the Chernkov light that I'm trying to see also doesn't penetrate through the ice because of all the trapped air particles, right?

599
00:41:18.963 --> 00:41:24.645
They went deeper, and they found that as the ice gets packed, the deeper layers...

600
00:41:25.627 --> 00:41:30.731
don't have a lot of air because the air starts escaping because of all of that high pressure.

601
00:41:31.111 --> 00:41:36.936
So the deeper I go into the Antarctic ice sheet, the clearer the ice gets.

602
00:41:37.591 --> 00:41:37.851
Okay?

603
00:41:38.372 --> 00:41:40.674
That was a big finding of the Amanda project.

604
00:41:41.034 --> 00:41:49.923
And is a driving force behind, you know, now understanding at what depth do we need to go to in order to basically have a clean lens.

605
00:41:50.964 --> 00:41:51.184
Yeah.

606
00:41:51.304 --> 00:41:52.445
As an analogy.

607
00:41:52.505 --> 00:41:53.987
Yeah, that's a very good analogy, actually.

608
00:41:54.247 --> 00:41:56.629
And so all of this was because of Amanda.

609
00:41:56.729 --> 00:42:02.095
And Amanda finally detected atmospheric neutrinos and demonstrated that the method would actually work.

610
00:42:02.535 --> 00:42:07.761
They're able to observe high-energy neutrinos, but these are still from the atmosphere and sort of solar system sources.

611
00:42:08.141 --> 00:42:10.383
But they're saying that now this definitely works.

612
00:42:11.084 --> 00:42:12.005
We just need the money.

613
00:42:12.105 --> 00:42:12.906
We've got a plan.

614
00:42:13.406 --> 00:42:14.127
We need the money.

615
00:42:14.187 --> 00:42:15.709
Show me the money.

616
00:42:16.029 --> 00:42:19.513
NSF comes in, the National Science Foundation, and they make a bet.

617
00:42:21.074 --> 00:42:23.977
They say, all right, we're going to give you a lot of money now.

618
00:42:24.861 --> 00:42:27.262
in order for you to make the Ice Cube project.

619
00:42:28.042 --> 00:42:30.043
Construction completes in 2011.

620
00:42:30.723 --> 00:42:35.985
Ice Cube is now a cubic kilometer worth of detectors.

621
00:42:36.905 --> 00:42:40.086
The building that everyone sees, right?

622
00:42:40.546 --> 00:42:42.987
That's the tiny dot at the very top.

623
00:42:44.307 --> 00:42:46.890
This is such a massive infrastructure project.

624
00:42:46.950 --> 00:42:47.170
Yeah.

625
00:42:47.250 --> 00:42:51.074
It's like really actually hard to, especially in an environment that's not very conducive.

626
00:42:51.094 --> 00:42:52.075
No, it's in Antarctica.

627
00:42:52.095 --> 00:42:54.037
They're building this thing in Antarctica.

628
00:42:54.597 --> 00:42:58.661
That means that their construction timeline is only six months.

629
00:42:58.921 --> 00:42:59.141
Right.

630
00:42:59.161 --> 00:43:02.865
Because you can't go in the winter to construct because everything's dark.

631
00:43:03.486 --> 00:43:03.686
Right.

632
00:43:04.046 --> 00:43:05.428
So you have to go in the summer.

633
00:43:06.482 --> 00:43:07.964
And you have to try and construct this thing.

634
00:43:07.984 --> 00:43:10.526
They did it one at a time, you know, one borehole at a time.

635
00:43:10.907 --> 00:43:15.872
Slowly but surely, they started getting this thing together.

636
00:43:16.573 --> 00:43:21.618
And just to reiterate, the point of, like, why is it so deep and why is it so wide?

637
00:43:22.099 --> 00:43:27.865
It's so deep because we can't detect these extragalactic, highly energetic neutrinos completely.

638
00:43:28.225 --> 00:43:29.366
too close to the surface.

639
00:43:29.486 --> 00:43:34.712
Yeah, we can't detect any neutrinos close to the surface because light just, it starts and it ends.

640
00:43:34.732 --> 00:43:35.492
It starts and it ends.

641
00:43:35.532 --> 00:43:38.916
So if I'm trying to detect light from like a meter or two meters away.

642
00:43:38.956 --> 00:43:41.839
Even if it happened over there, it wouldn't even, light would never make it to your detector.

643
00:43:41.859 --> 00:43:44.942
Yeah, it would just like interact with the air and then you're done.

644
00:43:45.542 --> 00:43:57.072
And then the reason it needs to have such this large surface area is because the thing we're looking for, the extra galactic high energy stuff, is so infrequent.

645
00:43:57.492 --> 00:43:59.954
We need to create the biggest target possible.

646
00:43:59.974 --> 00:44:00.955
Yeah.

647
00:44:00.975 --> 00:44:02.356
And hope we get lucky.

648
00:44:02.376 --> 00:44:03.217
And hope we get lucky.

649
00:44:03.566 --> 00:44:10.849
The other thing for why it can be this big is that if we do catch it, we can really track the whole thing.

650
00:44:11.150 --> 00:44:14.411
And then we have a good idea about what direction it came from.

651
00:44:14.911 --> 00:44:18.993
It's absolutely incredible what they've been able to do.

652
00:44:19.113 --> 00:44:20.694
And this is what a detector looks like.

653
00:44:21.114 --> 00:44:25.796
These are the photomultiplier tube type thingies that go in.

654
00:44:27.277 --> 00:44:29.058
This is called the deep core detector.

655
00:44:29.198 --> 00:44:31.159
It's a densely instrumented,

656
00:44:34.263 --> 00:45:03.008
set of photomultiplier tubes it's a fancy ccd yeah yeah right and there's a bunch of these all the way up and down into the thing okay like just like so it's basically like a you know in ski ball when you have all the balls next to each other like it's just like a long ski ball thing yeah yeah it's a pressure resistant glass sphere because you know it's got you got to get down to really high pressure yeah um it's got a bunch of electronics and it's it's absolutely amazing and so now let's look at what an event looks like here a neutrino is coming in

657
00:45:04.414 --> 00:45:06.515
It interacts somewhere, right?

658
00:45:06.635 --> 00:45:09.076
Like, either it spits out a muon.

659
00:45:09.116 --> 00:45:11.358
In this case, it's a muon that gets spit out.

660
00:45:11.678 --> 00:45:23.844
That muon then travels through the detector and sets off all of these detectors, all of these photomultiplier tubes, with that churn-cove radiation.

661
00:45:23.864 --> 00:45:27.866
The blue glow that you see, that's the churn-cove radiation that is coming out.

662
00:45:27.886 --> 00:45:28.086
Yeah.

663
00:45:28.587 --> 00:45:31.008
That's that secondary signal that we then use to then...

664
00:45:32.856 --> 00:45:35.157
back into the red line, which is the path.

665
00:45:35.277 --> 00:45:49.383
Yeah, because crucially we can tell what photomultiplier reacted first, and what photomultiplier reacted next and next, and so we can retrace with timing what was the path that it came from.

666
00:45:49.603 --> 00:45:51.664
Also with the timing, we can figure out what the speed is.

667
00:45:52.104 --> 00:45:56.866
And so that tells us a lot about at least the speed of the muon.

668
00:45:58.543 --> 00:46:06.980
We don't maybe know what the speed of the original neutrino was because, crucially, when a muon is created, other particles are created that are...

669
00:46:08.033 --> 00:46:35.495
lost in the signal but we have a really good idea of where it came from okay and we've got a probability estimate of sort of how big the original neutrino was now that brings me to my second point which is there's two types of events on the right hand side that's the muon type of event that we've we've noticed there um you know the muon crosses the detector it deposits all of these signatures and that tells us where it came from on the left

670
00:46:36.410 --> 00:46:42.814
You can have a cascade, which is a particle shower that develops over a distance that's really small compared to the detector.

671
00:46:43.154 --> 00:46:46.236
So the entire event is constrained inside of the detector.

672
00:46:46.476 --> 00:46:50.858
And we've got a really good estimate of the total energy, just not where it came from.

673
00:46:50.958 --> 00:46:51.098
Right.

674
00:46:51.199 --> 00:46:51.839
Okay.

675
00:46:51.859 --> 00:46:53.120
We have different problems.

676
00:46:53.200 --> 00:46:54.200
Yeah, we have different problems.

677
00:46:54.240 --> 00:46:56.522
On the left, everything is inside the detector.

678
00:46:56.802 --> 00:46:58.523
And so we've got a really good estimate of energy.

679
00:46:58.623 --> 00:47:01.885
On the right, there's some events that happened outside the detector.

680
00:47:02.800 --> 00:47:10.666
We don't know how big the event was, but we know exactly sort of where it came from within even like one degree of the sky.

681
00:47:11.207 --> 00:47:13.008
And this is the first time that we can really do this.

682
00:47:13.168 --> 00:47:14.389
Yeah, yeah.

683
00:47:14.909 --> 00:47:26.298
And it's so interesting that when you start looking at these results, the way you just classify these two is like an important... We're still trying to get back to this mapping piece.

684
00:47:26.819 --> 00:47:29.981
And if we had made this 50...

685
00:47:31.142 --> 00:47:33.405
kilometers, right, we would have...

686
00:47:33.486 --> 00:47:38.313
I mean, we'd have multiple events, and we'd track a whole event the whole time.

687
00:47:38.593 --> 00:47:41.698
And so partly this is a limitation of the scale of the system.

688
00:47:41.718 --> 00:47:45.363
Yeah, I mean, this is a cubic kilometer, and it's already like we're...

689
00:47:46.404 --> 00:47:47.524
Getting up to the limits of it.

690
00:47:47.564 --> 00:47:51.786
Yeah, but it's still incredible because for the first time we're able to see it No, 100% right.

691
00:47:52.086 --> 00:47:54.547
Um, it just I think speaks to the complexity of the problem.

692
00:47:54.607 --> 00:48:12.452
Yeah, it's it's absolutely amazing A few things that you know, people don't really think about is like when you make this detector It's a it's a cubic kilometer in ice the instrument samples light at all these separate locations and then tries to reconstruct them you need to calibrate the signal right because there's like background that you need to account for and

693
00:48:12.672 --> 00:48:13.893
There's dust scattering.

694
00:48:13.933 --> 00:48:15.494
There's layers in the ice itself.

695
00:48:15.514 --> 00:48:18.076
The ice is not a perfectly human-engineered thing.

696
00:48:18.116 --> 00:48:19.977
This is we're borrowing from nature itself.

697
00:48:20.297 --> 00:48:21.879
So there's going to be folds in the ice.

698
00:48:22.279 --> 00:48:28.403
And so a clean neutrino comes through, creates a muon that creates the shower.

699
00:48:28.683 --> 00:48:33.867
Well, the ice to the left of it could have a different density than the ice to the right of it.

700
00:48:34.287 --> 00:48:35.648
And so you need to calibrate for that.

701
00:48:35.688 --> 00:48:36.869
So that's not part of your error.

702
00:48:38.628 --> 00:48:41.171
All of these things have to be done by this collaboration.

703
00:48:41.211 --> 00:48:52.164
It's something that you don't really think about, but like in order to really answer the question, you have to be so very, very careful of the nature of your detector and what is the actual, you know, ground truth.

704
00:48:53.013 --> 00:49:03.800
This dovetails with our story on Black Marble and the way they were doing nighttime satellite detection from what was originally a weather satellite.

705
00:49:03.880 --> 00:49:04.640
Yeah.

706
00:49:04.660 --> 00:49:07.742
And the need to do a lot of this data.

707
00:49:08.382 --> 00:49:08.763
Yeah.

708
00:49:09.563 --> 00:49:09.903
Cleaning.

709
00:49:09.923 --> 00:49:12.145
Cleaning and filtering process.

710
00:49:12.205 --> 00:49:16.229
And this has similar but very different challenges.

711
00:49:16.409 --> 00:49:16.569
Yeah.

712
00:49:16.589 --> 00:49:20.173
Because it's not a Carl Zeiss lens, you know, or something.

713
00:49:20.193 --> 00:49:21.234
Yeah, it's not something that we've made.

714
00:49:21.254 --> 00:49:22.455
This is nature itself.

715
00:49:22.815 --> 00:49:24.296
And so there's going to be imperfections.

716
00:49:25.397 --> 00:49:32.624
On top of that, even if we've taken care of all of those systematic irregularities, the background neutrinos are a challenge.

717
00:49:33.257 --> 00:49:35.458
There's so many neutrinos that are coming in, right?

718
00:49:35.498 --> 00:49:36.499
So how do we filter out?

719
00:49:36.959 --> 00:49:38.641
Well, there's three ways that we can do this.

720
00:49:38.781 --> 00:49:39.561
One is direction.

721
00:49:40.442 --> 00:49:43.844
Just look for the ones that are coming up from the ground, right?

722
00:49:43.864 --> 00:49:45.205
Because they had to go through the earth.

723
00:49:45.765 --> 00:49:49.188
And so at least we know that those mostly aren't atmospheric.

724
00:49:50.048 --> 00:49:51.129
Another one is containment.

725
00:49:51.169 --> 00:49:52.850
We require most of the event...

726
00:49:53.257 --> 00:49:55.258
to be inside the detector.

727
00:49:55.298 --> 00:50:00.402
It needs to start inside the detector, and hopefully most of it is contained inside.

728
00:50:00.702 --> 00:50:01.703
And the third is energy.

729
00:50:02.063 --> 00:50:13.330
We can just filter out the low-energy ones and be like, these high-energy ones are definitely not, just because based on our power spectrum that we had earlier, these high-energy ones definitely have to be outside.

730
00:50:13.851 --> 00:50:17.213
And so in 2013, Ice Cube reported two events that

731
00:50:17.797 --> 00:50:20.878
with deposited energies of one peta electron volt.

732
00:50:21.558 --> 00:50:29.241
That was huge for the world because this was the first time that we were having access to neutrino detections at that scale.

733
00:50:29.281 --> 00:50:30.521
That was the whole point of IceCube.

734
00:50:30.601 --> 00:50:30.862
Yes.

735
00:50:31.122 --> 00:50:32.922
And so it was really a big triumph.

736
00:50:33.202 --> 00:50:35.863
It was only two or three years after IceCube had gone online.

737
00:50:36.744 --> 00:50:37.424
And that kind of...

738
00:50:38.492 --> 00:50:42.836
matches the one event per square kilometer per year.

739
00:50:43.716 --> 00:50:47.540
The math actually ended up being in practice.

740
00:50:47.620 --> 00:50:47.900
Yeah.

741
00:50:48.060 --> 00:50:50.942
It's like, oh, we detected the two events that we would have expected.

742
00:50:51.203 --> 00:50:59.329
And on the right-hand side, you can actually match the distribution of, like, how many we were seeing at each of these different energies.

743
00:50:59.349 --> 00:50:59.550
Mm-hmm.

744
00:51:00.730 --> 00:51:07.395
The blue is our model for what the atmosphere and the smaller neutrinos background would look like.

745
00:51:07.716 --> 00:51:11.718
The red is how we're fitting the data for the extragalactic origin.

746
00:51:11.819 --> 00:51:19.924
And what we're seeing is the data is matching the sum of these two curves, right?

747
00:51:19.984 --> 00:51:24.448
The blue for the smaller energies and the red for the larger energies.

748
00:51:24.708 --> 00:51:27.450
Because the larger energies are what we actually care about.

749
00:51:28.675 --> 00:51:29.836
Modeling matters.

750
00:51:29.876 --> 00:51:31.738
Modeling matters, especially in particle physics.

751
00:51:31.778 --> 00:51:32.599
They do a lot of it.

752
00:51:32.719 --> 00:51:33.100
Yeah.

753
00:51:34.041 --> 00:51:36.504
And it's great when your tools map took it.

754
00:51:36.584 --> 00:51:39.987
See, this goes back to this not a black box thing we talk about often.

755
00:51:40.187 --> 00:51:40.408
Yeah.

756
00:51:40.428 --> 00:51:42.310
So we now...

757
00:51:43.193 --> 00:51:51.341
understand what the sort of end product of this Nobel prize was given for, which is this neutrino observatory.

758
00:51:51.581 --> 00:52:02.391
It made these landmark detections, uh, within two, within two years after coming online, which is, you know, it's better than what they were trying to do with Higgs boson, but that's a whole nother story.

759
00:52:02.931 --> 00:52:04.273
Um, and, um,

760
00:52:05.593 --> 00:52:13.897
I still think we come back to where we started, which is the whole purpose of this in the word observatory is to try to understand and map everything around us.

761
00:52:13.937 --> 00:52:21.060
And we, we landed on a limitation, which still leaves me with the question, where are they coming from?

762
00:52:21.080 --> 00:52:32.805
Because what we want to know is what is this object that's generating these energies, that's generating this amount of speed such that when we detect that it's in that peta volt, uh, peta,

763
00:52:33.285 --> 00:52:34.306
Petal-electron volt.

764
00:52:34.326 --> 00:52:36.387
Petal-electron volt scale.

765
00:52:36.567 --> 00:52:36.767
Yeah.

766
00:52:36.987 --> 00:52:38.929
Which we've seen, like, the two we just discussed.

767
00:52:38.949 --> 00:52:39.209
That's right.

768
00:52:39.229 --> 00:52:40.290
And that was the whole point, right?

769
00:52:40.390 --> 00:52:40.570
Yeah.

770
00:52:40.670 --> 00:52:44.112
Now, with the 2013, the two that were detected there, right...

771
00:52:47.499 --> 00:52:55.889
We had a good estimate maybe of the energies, but maybe not like the direction because of those two types of events that I was telling you about.

772
00:52:56.170 --> 00:52:58.252
But certain events we could actually pinpoint.

773
00:52:58.412 --> 00:53:05.501
And in September 2017, Ice Cube detected a high-energy neutrino with a direction that was consistent with a blazar.

774
00:53:05.521 --> 00:53:06.382
A blazar.

775
00:53:07.470 --> 00:53:12.291
The blazar is called TXS 0506 plus 056.

776
00:53:12.391 --> 00:53:14.772
This is at the edge of our universe.

777
00:53:15.672 --> 00:53:17.033
It's extremely tiny.

778
00:53:17.073 --> 00:53:19.133
This is not anywhere near us, okay?

779
00:53:20.354 --> 00:53:21.434
Billions of light years away.

780
00:53:21.554 --> 00:53:24.595
A blazar is an active galaxy with a jet that's directed towards us.

781
00:53:24.635 --> 00:53:30.937
So you can imagine the galaxy's jet is looking straight at us, which is why it's so bright for how far away it is.

782
00:53:31.777 --> 00:53:35.358
The galaxy also brightened in gamma rays.

783
00:53:35.973 --> 00:53:39.655
We have gamma ray observatories that had coincident detection.

784
00:53:40.216 --> 00:53:41.297
We like coincident detection.

785
00:53:41.317 --> 00:53:44.599
We like coincident detection because that means something happened in this blazar, right?

786
00:53:44.619 --> 00:53:48.682
There was some event that released a bunch of gamma rays and a bunch of neutrinos.

787
00:53:49.042 --> 00:53:53.625
Neutrinos, because they're so light, they're like near zero mass.

788
00:53:55.120 --> 00:53:58.281
They travel at about the same speed as light.

789
00:53:58.361 --> 00:54:05.083
Sometimes they even arrive before light because the light interacts with a bunch of stuff and gets delayed and then comes to us.

790
00:54:05.123 --> 00:54:07.544
The neutrino is just on its way from whatever event.

791
00:54:07.904 --> 00:54:15.666
And so in 2017, we got kind of an indication that actually it could be, in fact, these extragalactic jets.

792
00:54:17.026 --> 00:54:22.708
Ice Cube also mapped out the Milky Way with diffuse high-energy neutrinos.

793
00:54:23.668 --> 00:54:26.090
And this, I think, is absolutely incredible.

794
00:54:26.190 --> 00:54:33.655
So here we're seeing maps of our own Milky Way in different bands.

795
00:54:34.035 --> 00:54:36.837
The first is radio, optical.

796
00:54:36.877 --> 00:54:42.300
This is what we see with our naked eye if you go to Joshua Tree, or even better, if you go to the middle of middle of nowhere.

797
00:54:43.381 --> 00:54:44.142
And gamma rays.

798
00:54:45.002 --> 00:54:45.803
And neutrinos...

799
00:54:46.683 --> 00:54:47.324
Or on the bottom.

800
00:54:47.924 --> 00:54:48.705
Very blobby.

801
00:54:48.985 --> 00:54:54.149
But you don't understand just how hard it is to catch neutrinos and create a picture at that.

802
00:54:54.269 --> 00:54:54.509
Yeah.

803
00:54:54.790 --> 00:54:55.110
Right?

804
00:54:55.570 --> 00:54:58.673
Using a cubic kilometer worth of ice.

805
00:54:59.033 --> 00:55:01.115
We've created a map of the Milky Way.

806
00:55:01.195 --> 00:55:02.616
And it kind of matches, right?

807
00:55:02.636 --> 00:55:09.162
The central blob in the center is the galactic nucleus where the supermassive black hole Sagittarius A star is.

808
00:55:09.922 --> 00:55:14.529
Along with a bunch of other star-forming regions, all sorts of random nonsense that's happening.

809
00:55:14.769 --> 00:55:18.295
And that is the region that is brighter in the neutrino band as well.

810
00:55:18.435 --> 00:55:21.700
This is a map of our Milky Way using neutrinos.

811
00:55:21.800 --> 00:55:23.442
I think that's absolutely incredible.

812
00:55:24.496 --> 00:55:31.099
It makes me think of the history of other sort of astronomical imaging and the progress when you start.

813
00:55:31.199 --> 00:55:33.020
Like it goes from blobby to resolve.

814
00:55:33.040 --> 00:55:37.222
Like I think like the cosmic microwave background kind of went from blobby to more resolve.

815
00:55:37.262 --> 00:55:38.743
But it kept its same structure.

816
00:55:39.043 --> 00:55:44.566
But as we got better over time, you know, the resolution just became more well defined and it's –

817
00:55:45.146 --> 00:55:46.627
And we kind of see it.

818
00:55:46.847 --> 00:55:50.630
Maybe we will get to a level that looks similar with neutrinos.

819
00:55:50.650 --> 00:55:51.590
But you've got to start somewhere.

820
00:55:51.610 --> 00:55:57.054
And this is because of the difficulty level as compared to the other three types.

821
00:55:57.334 --> 00:55:59.055
We can put stuff in space for the gamma rays.

822
00:55:59.295 --> 00:56:03.397
We can put the CCD on camera on the ground and in space.

823
00:56:03.738 --> 00:56:04.178
No problem.

824
00:56:04.258 --> 00:56:04.418
Yeah.

825
00:56:04.438 --> 00:56:05.839
But we need a massive thing.

826
00:56:05.859 --> 00:56:05.999
Right.

827
00:56:07.540 --> 00:56:08.640
For the neutrinos.

828
00:56:08.680 --> 00:56:13.781
We need a whole ice cube that is one kilometer by one kilometer by one kilometer.

829
00:56:14.042 --> 00:56:14.622
Big ice cube.

830
00:56:14.682 --> 00:56:15.482
Yeah, it's insane.

831
00:56:16.142 --> 00:56:19.883
One of the most important things that Ice Cube has done is actually falsify certain theories.

832
00:56:20.203 --> 00:56:22.143
Science is all about falsification, right?

833
00:56:22.444 --> 00:56:25.604
A theory is testable, and if we can falsify it, we are making progress.

834
00:56:37.827 --> 00:56:58.547
gamma ray bursts we don't really know what gamma ray bursts are but there's a burst of gamma rays from singular sources we have found no significant association in the samples that we've discussed and so those absences constrain the models because the people who are you know talking smack about oh it's it's obviously gamma rays you know what's the big deal well where are they

835
00:56:59.127 --> 00:56:59.307
Right?

836
00:56:59.327 --> 00:56:59.947
That's tough.

837
00:57:00.047 --> 00:57:06.469
We see gamma rays from gamma ray bursts, but not that many neutrinos of this really high energy.

838
00:57:06.609 --> 00:57:09.610
Because we would be able to do coincident detection with this as well.

839
00:57:10.831 --> 00:57:11.191
Not there.

840
00:57:11.271 --> 00:57:12.031
It's not there.

841
00:57:12.051 --> 00:57:12.831
I don't know what to tell you.

842
00:57:12.891 --> 00:57:13.912
I don't know what to tell you, right?

843
00:57:14.012 --> 00:57:16.913
So the achievement is recognized by this prize.

844
00:57:17.373 --> 00:57:17.573
Yeah.

845
00:57:17.813 --> 00:57:17.973
Right?

846
00:57:18.013 --> 00:57:20.174
This prize is recognizing that exact achievement.

847
00:57:20.514 --> 00:57:20.694
Yeah.

848
00:57:21.733 --> 00:57:23.375
This is the Nobel Committee drawing.

849
00:57:23.636 --> 00:57:25.418
Which we can now understand very well.

850
00:57:25.458 --> 00:57:26.880
Which we can now understand very well.

851
00:57:27.201 --> 00:57:32.408
It's showing a proton, which is in red, or a charged particle.

852
00:57:32.809 --> 00:57:35.372
It's sad because it's moving around because of...

853
00:57:36.370 --> 00:58:03.669
extragalactic magnetic fields and the magnetic fields in the milky way there's a gamma ray that's also coming from these particle accelerations that are happening outside of our galaxy but those things start interacting with the matter and they get stopped the neutrino on the other hand it's like the they use the v as kind of an angry eyebrow you see that and this thing is just coming at us yeah it's coming straight at us into the ice cube detector and

854
00:58:04.073 --> 00:58:06.875
And it's going to create the detection that we want.

855
00:58:07.375 --> 00:58:08.476
This is so funny.

856
00:58:08.556 --> 00:58:13.200
And then it's got the little sensors inside the ice with the circles, right?

857
00:58:13.220 --> 00:58:16.582
Like the similar shape for it.

858
00:58:17.322 --> 00:58:18.543
This is actually quite a good one.

859
00:58:18.744 --> 00:58:19.384
This one's pretty good.

860
00:58:19.424 --> 00:58:20.325
Yeah, this is quite nice.

861
00:58:20.345 --> 00:58:22.506
Yeah, this one's pretty good.

862
00:58:22.726 --> 00:58:23.527
I quite like that one.

863
00:58:23.807 --> 00:58:30.512
So Halzen, who is the Nobel Prize winner this year, Francis Halzen,

864
00:58:31.975 --> 00:58:33.776
He's been instrumental with IceCube.

865
00:58:34.937 --> 00:58:41.042
He helped carry the idea from a conversation about Antarctic ice into a fully built observatory.

866
00:58:41.702 --> 00:58:48.387
The University of Wisconsin is the main backing institution for IceCube.

867
00:58:49.388 --> 00:58:51.890
But IceCube is a massive, massive enterprise.

868
00:58:51.970 --> 00:58:56.593
It involves 450 scientists across 58 research institutions.

869
00:58:56.979 --> 00:58:59.380
across 14 different nations.

870
00:58:59.740 --> 00:59:02.101
It cost $280 million.

871
00:59:02.501 --> 00:59:07.903
A majority of that came from the National Science Foundation over several decades of work.

872
00:59:08.883 --> 00:59:22.288
And they're going to be upgrading to IceCube Gen 2, which is going to make an even bigger detector for even more frequent events and even more precise determination of energy and origin.

873
00:59:22.308 --> 00:59:23.288
Yeah.

874
00:59:23.488 --> 00:59:28.213
This is University of Wisconsin's 20th Nobel Prize affiliation in the three sciences.

875
00:59:28.813 --> 00:59:30.775
So they're on a roll.

876
00:59:30.875 --> 00:59:31.696
Yeah.

877
00:59:31.716 --> 00:59:32.557
They're doing quite well.

878
00:59:32.637 --> 00:59:37.442
Maybe we'll put up our Nobel Prize top 10 power rankings.

879
00:59:37.962 --> 00:59:38.723
Yeah.

880
00:59:38.743 --> 00:59:40.164
So we know who's balling.

881
00:59:40.324 --> 00:59:40.705
Exactly.

882
00:59:40.725 --> 00:59:41.586
Because that's a lot.

883
00:59:41.686 --> 00:59:42.426
That's a lot, right?

884
00:59:42.466 --> 00:59:42.707
Yeah.

885
00:59:42.747 --> 00:59:42.987
So –

886
00:59:44.128 --> 00:59:46.769
These detectors, they're going to be absolutely amazing.

887
00:59:46.929 --> 00:59:50.129
I am myself looking forward to Ice Cube Gen 2.

888
00:59:50.529 --> 00:59:51.489
Gen 2 is going to be great.

889
00:59:51.529 --> 00:59:53.430
Because that's going to collect even more events.

890
00:59:53.950 --> 00:59:55.550
It's going to improve the source picture.

891
00:59:56.950 --> 00:59:59.991
It's going to account for which objects actually produce it.

892
01:00:00.471 --> 01:00:05.852
You know, we can get statistics about, oh, this many blazars, this many this, this many that.

893
01:00:06.212 --> 01:00:07.392
It's going to be really, really nice.

894
01:00:08.392 --> 01:00:11.013
I just, I really want to...

895
01:00:12.613 --> 01:00:18.957
As we end on this image, you know, our curiosity as a species about the universe around us is so interesting.

896
01:00:18.977 --> 01:00:20.878
And we continue to try to find ways to learn more.

897
01:00:20.918 --> 01:00:29.523
And this is a very, very clever, somewhat non-intuitive, unless you kind of have an understanding of the space way to think about it.

898
01:00:30.164 --> 01:00:31.044
It's in the ice.

899
01:00:31.144 --> 01:00:32.205
It's looking down.

900
01:00:32.265 --> 01:00:35.687
It's looking for this set sort of secondary event.

901
01:00:35.887 --> 01:00:37.488
It's not a primary detection.

902
01:00:38.509 --> 01:00:41.591
These things that we're looking for that these neutrinos come from,

903
01:00:42.168 --> 01:00:46.532
are still a mystery and certainly Nobel worthy.

904
01:00:47.133 --> 01:00:49.415
Again, solo Nobel.

905
01:00:49.535 --> 01:00:50.116
It's been a while.

906
01:00:50.156 --> 01:00:50.677
It's been a while.

907
01:00:50.837 --> 01:00:52.318
And they're not that frequent.

908
01:00:54.721 --> 01:00:59.926
And I know we've touched on this a couple of times before anything with space for longtime listeners.

909
01:01:00.566 --> 01:01:03.469
You guys know, this is one of my favorite things to discuss.

910
01:01:04.010 --> 01:01:04.110
We,

911
01:01:06.352 --> 01:01:09.375
I think the physics ones are always some of the most interesting.

912
01:01:09.975 --> 01:01:17.461
We are going to be back tomorrow for the last day of our coverage for the Nobel Prizes, which will be in chemistry.

913
01:01:18.022 --> 01:01:24.687
If you have not checked out our coverage of the physiology and medicine Nobel, we did do that yesterday.

914
01:01:24.967 --> 01:01:39.301
yesterday uh it's quite good many of you liked that coverage as well you can check out all of our past episodes at ffppod.com as well as all the research papers that we covered in this and last uh yesterday's and tomorrow's episodes

915
01:01:40.322 --> 01:02:01.385
socials ffp pod we have video available watch the video it's great we do all these overlays that are really important to understand this my name is lester nari joined as always by my co-host and our resident phd krishna chowdhury our last day of nobel coverage will be upon us our favorite time of the year we will see you all tomorrow
