WEBVTT

1
00:00:02.670 --> 00:00:04.030
a listener production.

2
00:00:04.711 --> 00:00:07.432
Today's guest is genuinely a bit of a hero of mine.

3
00:00:07.692 --> 00:00:11.393
Jen Robinson is one of Australia's most famous human rights and media lawyers.

4
00:00:11.413 --> 00:00:23.157
She's a barrister at Dowdy Street Chambers in London, a Rhodes Scholar, and has advised some of the biggest media organizations in the world and has spent her career fighting for freedom of speech and the rights of journalists and women to tell their stories.

5
00:00:23.757 --> 00:00:26.118
She's also been a part of Julian Assange's legal team,

6
00:00:26.478 --> 00:00:30.482
She worked with the New York Times during its investigation into the Murdoch phone hacking scandal.

7
00:00:30.882 --> 00:00:34.605
She's represented political prisoners and human rights defenders around the world.

8
00:00:35.125 --> 00:00:41.010
And she represented Amber Heard in the 2020 UK defamation case bought by Johnny Depp against The Sun.

9
00:00:41.711 --> 00:00:45.594
And that last case is part of what I really wanted to talk to Jen about today.

10
00:00:46.074 --> 00:00:46.335
Because...

11
00:00:46.835 --> 00:00:55.161
We are living in this incredibly strange era where a court case can be happening in an actual courtroom while an entirely different trial is happening simultaneously on TikTok.

12
00:00:55.722 --> 00:00:57.823
We've seen it with Amber Heard and Johnny Depp.

13
00:00:57.863 --> 00:01:02.407
We've seen versions of it since with cases involving some of the biggest celebrities in the world.

14
00:01:02.827 --> 00:01:03.527
Clips are cut up.

15
00:01:04.008 --> 00:01:06.229
Algorithms reward the most outrageous interpretation.

16
00:01:06.530 --> 00:01:10.493
Bot campaigns and coordinated online activity can distort what looks like public opinion.

17
00:01:10.853 --> 00:01:15.857
And suddenly millions of us can feel like we understand a legal case from a 30-second video on our phones.

18
00:01:16.457 --> 00:01:24.461
So I wanted to ask Jen what we should actually be watching out for when a high profile case takes over our feeds and how we distinguish evidence from content.

19
00:01:25.121 --> 00:01:27.362
But this conversation is also about something much bigger.

20
00:01:27.782 --> 00:01:37.287
Jen also wrote the book How Many More Women, which examined the ways that defamation laws and other legal mechanisms can be used against women in journalists who speak out against violence and abuse.

21
00:01:38.247 --> 00:01:41.470
And how that work inspired her documentary, Silenced.

22
00:01:42.030 --> 00:01:43.171
I saw Silenced recently.

23
00:01:43.191 --> 00:01:44.912
I was incredibly moved by it.

24
00:01:45.012 --> 00:01:53.158
I think it's horrifying to see how global this problem is and the personal, legal and financial costs that come with speaking out continue to carry.

25
00:01:53.399 --> 00:01:58.883
But what I loved about this film and about Jen's work more broadly is that it doesn't leave you feeling hopeless.

26
00:01:59.523 --> 00:02:15.610
So today I wanted to talk to her about the reality of trial by TikTok, her experience representing Amber Heard, and what social media has done to her understanding of high profile court cases, the weaponization of defamation law, and the chilling effect this can have on women and journalists, and what Jen thinks needs to change.

27
00:02:24.710 --> 00:02:27.894
Jen, it is such a pleasure to have you on this podcast.

28
00:02:27.914 --> 00:02:33.682
You are, I know, I feel like I say this every time a guest comes on and I, gosh, but like you really are like a hero of mine.

29
00:02:35.755 --> 00:02:37.736
Well, that's such lovely, kind words.

30
00:02:37.816 --> 00:02:38.157
Thank you.

31
00:02:38.197 --> 00:02:39.697
And it's really fun to be here with you.

32
00:02:40.238 --> 00:02:41.499
Thank you so much for coming on.

33
00:02:41.519 --> 00:02:46.181
And I was saying this just before we started recording, but I've seen the film silenced.

34
00:02:46.201 --> 00:02:49.483
I rewatched part of it in the office yesterday prepping for this.

35
00:02:49.563 --> 00:02:52.465
And Justine, my producer, turned to me and was like, girl, are you okay?

36
00:02:52.485 --> 00:02:53.005
You're crying.

37
00:02:53.205 --> 00:02:55.446
It's such an important watch for everyone.

38
00:02:55.667 --> 00:02:55.867
Yeah.

39
00:02:55.887 --> 00:02:56.947
Congrats for making it.

40
00:02:57.007 --> 00:02:57.988
And thank you for making it.

41
00:02:58.548 --> 00:03:12.319
Oh, look, it's something I'm very proud of and something I felt compelled to do as part of the responsibility I feel to contribute to my skills to ending violence against women and talking about it from the perspective that I bring as a free speech lawyer.

42
00:03:12.339 --> 00:03:15.482
But it's a real honour to be able to honour the legacy of my grandmother too.

43
00:03:16.342 --> 00:03:18.784
And you're not the only one who comes away.

44
00:03:18.804 --> 00:03:20.265
It's a very moving film.

45
00:03:21.226 --> 00:03:26.047
And it's, you know, I don't want people to come away crying from it, but I do think the subject matter warrants it.

46
00:03:26.328 --> 00:03:31.209
And actually what I really love seeing people's reaction is that they are moved by these women's stories.

47
00:03:31.269 --> 00:03:34.330
I don't think you can watch that film and not be moved by them.

48
00:03:35.110 --> 00:03:38.391
But also women come out with anger.

49
00:03:38.891 --> 00:03:39.071
Yeah.

50
00:03:39.451 --> 00:03:41.512
And the kind of anger that motivates us to act.

51
00:03:42.028 --> 00:03:43.489
It was such an overwhelm of feelings.

52
00:03:43.809 --> 00:03:44.529
It was anger.

53
00:03:44.690 --> 00:03:45.330
It was sadness.

54
00:03:45.410 --> 00:03:46.671
And it was also hopeful.

55
00:03:47.071 --> 00:03:51.053
I'm so glad you brought your grandmother up because she was such a takeaway from the film for me.

56
00:03:51.414 --> 00:03:52.694
What an incredible woman.

57
00:03:53.155 --> 00:03:55.716
And it was so nice hearing more about you in the film as well.

58
00:03:56.176 --> 00:04:00.079
Like knowing that you grew up in Bury in the South Coast.

59
00:04:00.139 --> 00:04:04.401
And then, you know, what a pivot then to the career that you've had.

60
00:04:05.142 --> 00:04:06.062
Actually, fun fact.

61
00:04:06.182 --> 00:04:06.783
So are you...

62
00:04:07.728 --> 00:04:08.809
Are you Falcon's cousin?

63
00:04:09.349 --> 00:04:10.609
Yes, I am.

64
00:04:11.290 --> 00:04:16.913
So very few people understand Matt Ford, or Falcon as he is known, is my first cousin.

65
00:04:16.933 --> 00:04:18.793
So we grew up together on the South Coast.

66
00:04:19.274 --> 00:04:20.114
That's so funny.

67
00:04:20.294 --> 00:04:21.675
So I'm Falcon's producer.

68
00:04:21.815 --> 00:04:23.856
I've produced The Voice podcast for about six years.

69
00:04:23.956 --> 00:04:24.536
Oh, that's funny.

70
00:04:24.636 --> 00:04:24.997
I know.

71
00:04:25.177 --> 00:04:33.401
People do find it like this kind of, because they have such an amazing following and I'm so proud of him and it's so exciting seeing what he does.

72
00:04:34.002 --> 00:04:42.667
And also for me, such a huge disjunct from the Matt that I knew growing up to seeing this sort of character who's all over the world and doing all these amazing things.

73
00:04:42.727 --> 00:04:43.207
It's amazing.

74
00:04:44.268 --> 00:04:46.350
We're really tight as cousins.

75
00:04:46.370 --> 00:04:48.672
Do you know how big our family is?

76
00:04:48.692 --> 00:04:51.255
I have heard about you have about 30 cousins.

77
00:04:51.935 --> 00:04:52.316
More.

78
00:04:52.356 --> 00:04:56.720
There are 40 first cousins on just... First cousins.

79
00:04:56.760 --> 00:04:57.381
Yeah.

80
00:04:57.401 --> 00:05:01.465
So Matt and I, we have 12 aunties and uncles.

81
00:05:01.485 --> 00:05:02.786
So our mum and dad are one of 12 or 12.

82
00:05:04.108 --> 00:05:05.489
each of the 12 children.

83
00:05:05.529 --> 00:05:06.450
Is this Bernie's side?

84
00:05:06.550 --> 00:05:07.110
Yeah.

85
00:05:07.130 --> 00:05:11.995
So Bernie is my dad's sister and we are, there's 12 of them.

86
00:05:12.015 --> 00:05:13.056
My dad's the eldest of 12.

87
00:05:13.796 --> 00:05:14.997
Then I'm the eldest of six.

88
00:05:15.538 --> 00:05:17.039
I was reading that.

89
00:05:17.059 --> 00:05:22.504
And so Matt and his wonderful sister, Abby, who I just adore, she's like a little sister to me.

90
00:05:23.008 --> 00:05:23.848
We were all really tight.

91
00:05:23.868 --> 00:05:24.708
We grew up together.

92
00:05:24.728 --> 00:05:25.589
We played together.

93
00:05:25.609 --> 00:05:29.230
Yeah, we hung out every summer together.

94
00:05:29.250 --> 00:05:39.932
You know, when people look at Matt and I sort of from afar, given the work that we do, it looks so different that people can't imagine that we are related, but we are.

95
00:05:40.332 --> 00:05:43.573
And also that sense of humour is there, I think, in our whole family.

96
00:05:43.613 --> 00:05:50.915
Like we all love a good laugh, though you just don't see that side of me when I'm, you know, talking about sexual violence and...

97
00:05:51.755 --> 00:05:53.676
you know, detained journalists on the news.

98
00:05:54.016 --> 00:05:55.456
No, no, of course not.

99
00:05:55.536 --> 00:05:59.338
But no, I love Bernie and I love Matt and I love Abby.

100
00:05:59.458 --> 00:06:02.599
So I was like, this is such a fun crossover for me.

101
00:06:02.619 --> 00:06:12.122
Well, this is the first time in a media interview there's kind of been like that, the kind of the connections being made because I think socially people know or people have made the connection on social media, but not...

102
00:06:12.722 --> 00:06:14.764
in an interview, but I absolutely love Matt.

103
00:06:15.064 --> 00:06:19.367
And in fact, he was, I was hoping he'd come to the film screen this week, but he's traveling.

104
00:06:19.427 --> 00:06:21.149
So we'll do something together when he comes back.

105
00:06:21.169 --> 00:06:21.429
I know.

106
00:06:21.509 --> 00:06:22.910
I've been trying to get them back in studio.

107
00:06:22.970 --> 00:06:24.311
That's not working.

108
00:06:24.652 --> 00:06:29.315
Speaking of your family and speaking of your grandmother as well, do you mind sharing a little bit about her?

109
00:06:29.355 --> 00:06:33.919
Because I know in the film, you said that she was such a big inspiration for the career that you've had.

110
00:06:33.939 --> 00:06:34.079
Yeah.

111
00:06:34.259 --> 00:06:34.980
In some ways.

112
00:06:35.040 --> 00:06:40.107
What's interesting is that I grew up knowing my grandmother was a survivor of domestic violence.

113
00:06:40.127 --> 00:06:43.171
She left my violent grandfather, who I don't remember meeting.

114
00:06:43.191 --> 00:06:45.093
I think I met him once when I was a baby.

115
00:06:45.734 --> 00:06:48.197
He wasn't part of our lives after she chose to leave him.

116
00:06:49.278 --> 00:06:53.682
And I knew that she went to work in the domestic violence refuges because I used to go there with her as a child.

117
00:06:53.822 --> 00:06:56.465
And I used to go to work with her and play with the kids in the refuge.

118
00:06:56.525 --> 00:07:05.473
So my sister and I were very alert to issues around domestic violence and the trauma that that has on families because we were spending time with these kids.

119
00:07:05.493 --> 00:07:07.415
And our grandmother would explain to us.

120
00:07:07.435 --> 00:07:09.316
So I remember the rules of the refuge.

121
00:07:09.356 --> 00:07:10.497
I remember being in the house.

122
00:07:11.618 --> 00:07:14.819
out in Western Sydney, we knew we were never allowed to answer the front door.

123
00:07:15.219 --> 00:07:27.784
And we knew to be patient and kind with the kids because my grandmother explained to us that they didn't have the privileges that we had and that they had been through very traumatic experiences and it was important that we were kind and patient.

124
00:07:28.064 --> 00:07:32.826
So I think that really had an effect on me growing up in ways that I didn't appreciate at the time.

125
00:07:33.207 --> 00:07:37.028
But what I didn't know about my grandmother is that she was like a litigation friend in the courts.

126
00:07:37.088 --> 00:07:46.273
She was like going to court, making submissions in court as a domestic violence refuge worker when it came to sort of sentencing and all kinds of things.

127
00:07:46.433 --> 00:07:54.417
And she was training the police on domestic violence strategies and helping them to sensitize them about how to be better with women.

128
00:07:55.323 --> 00:07:58.124
And I didn't know any of this, but I went off to university and studied law.

129
00:07:58.144 --> 00:08:03.806
My grandmother, at no point did she, you know, share these experiences with me when I was at my, during my law degree.

130
00:08:04.566 --> 00:08:13.890
And it wasn't until, I must've been in my mid thirties and I was at home with her one night and she, she said she was depressed and I asked her why.

131
00:08:13.910 --> 00:08:20.072
And she said, well, I just heard the statistics about violence against women on the radio and they're not getting better.

132
00:08:20.092 --> 00:08:20.672
Yeah.

133
00:08:20.912 --> 00:08:22.813
In the 20 years since I left the refuge movement.

134
00:08:23.113 --> 00:08:33.200
And I looked at her and I thought, here is this woman who has dedicated her life to turning her experience of domestic violence into something positive for other women, making it easier for other women.

135
00:08:33.801 --> 00:08:38.984
And, you know, she's sitting there contemplating whether all of her efforts were in vain.

136
00:08:39.725 --> 00:08:41.806
And I thought, well, what am I doing about it?

137
00:08:42.167 --> 00:08:43.407
And what are we all doing about it?

138
00:08:43.688 --> 00:08:43.828
Mm-hmm.

139
00:08:44.268 --> 00:08:46.391
And then she started sharing with me more about her life.

140
00:08:46.471 --> 00:08:55.163
I mean, she left the refuge movement only because she had another nervous breakdown because she'd seen another woman killed and it was one too many.

141
00:08:55.223 --> 00:08:55.904
She couldn't go back.

142
00:08:58.281 --> 00:09:00.423
And she started telling me more stories from her work.

143
00:09:00.483 --> 00:09:10.111
And I was like, at what point did you not think in the six years I was doing my law degree that understanding your role in the courts and what you did in the courts would be interesting to me?

144
00:09:10.831 --> 00:09:13.694
I mean, she used to take women to court, keep the car running out the front.

145
00:09:14.314 --> 00:09:19.198
And she'd be inside court literally standing between violent men and these women in court.

146
00:09:19.238 --> 00:09:20.980
She said she's been held up against the wall.

147
00:09:21.000 --> 00:09:21.100
Yeah.

148
00:09:21.640 --> 00:09:27.390
by a man who approached, she stood between him and his former partner, was physically held up against the wall.

149
00:09:27.430 --> 00:09:29.072
These women were absolute heroes.

150
00:09:30.034 --> 00:09:32.358
But she never thought that her story was important.

151
00:09:32.937 --> 00:09:33.918
Isn't that fascinating?

152
00:09:34.078 --> 00:09:35.979
And I made two decisions that day.

153
00:09:36.319 --> 00:09:37.440
How old were you at this time?

154
00:09:37.520 --> 00:09:39.881
I was probably about 35.

155
00:09:41.122 --> 00:09:42.883
I was already practicing law in London.

156
00:09:42.903 --> 00:09:44.104
I was working for Julian Assange.

157
00:09:44.124 --> 00:09:48.947
I was doing all these big media defense cases, defending journalists, doing free speech work.

158
00:09:48.987 --> 00:09:55.290
And I thought, right, I'm going to find a way to use my legal practice to continue her legacy.

159
00:09:55.931 --> 00:09:57.612
So I'm going to start working on violence against women.

160
00:09:57.672 --> 00:09:59.453
I don't know what that looks like yet, but I'm doing it.

161
00:10:00.133 --> 00:10:02.595
And the second point was I'm going to find a way to tell her story.

162
00:10:03.437 --> 00:10:08.901
Because women's stories are so often missed in history because, one, they're not treated as important.

163
00:10:09.181 --> 00:10:10.302
Yeah.

164
00:10:10.322 --> 00:10:16.346
And anyway, here we are with a film that documents my work in this space and tells her story.

165
00:10:16.826 --> 00:10:19.728
So in awe of her and of you and...

166
00:10:20.565 --> 00:10:20.805
Yeah.

167
00:10:21.045 --> 00:10:22.926
And send it to my nan and send it to my mom.

168
00:10:23.006 --> 00:10:34.533
And I'm just... Well, this is... And part of the thing was I actually... One of the things I actually haven't done yet was I wanted to start a project about young women asking questions of their mom and their grandma.

169
00:10:35.182 --> 00:10:39.745
Because, you know, we grow up around these women who have had lives and careers.

170
00:10:40.125 --> 00:10:41.126
Many of them, some haven't.

171
00:10:41.626 --> 00:10:44.248
We kind of treat them as they are in the relationship to us.

172
00:10:44.268 --> 00:10:45.669
So she's my grandma, she's my mum.

173
00:10:45.689 --> 00:10:47.550
We don't think about who she is beyond that.

174
00:10:48.251 --> 00:10:48.531
Enough.

175
00:10:48.911 --> 00:10:49.152
Yeah.

176
00:10:49.452 --> 00:10:50.272
Ask the question.

177
00:10:50.292 --> 00:10:53.314
I was actually ashamed that I hadn't asked her the questions earlier.

178
00:10:54.455 --> 00:10:54.995
You know what?

179
00:10:55.196 --> 00:10:57.637
I had a really fascinating experience this year.

180
00:10:57.877 --> 00:11:01.400
I had a project where I ended up interviewing my mum.

181
00:11:01.961 --> 00:11:02.561
I loved that.

182
00:11:02.661 --> 00:11:04.342
I had never done it before.

183
00:11:04.442 --> 00:11:07.643
And she had, she's such a story relevant to this.

184
00:11:08.023 --> 00:11:11.924
And there was so much I didn't know, even though I lived it and I grew up with it.

185
00:11:12.944 --> 00:11:21.227
Asking and just having that on tape and like having those conversations and seeing it in this like zoomed out way was this like breakthrough movement.

186
00:11:21.267 --> 00:11:25.188
I cannot like recommend enough that people do that, like have an interview with your mom.

187
00:11:25.408 --> 00:11:25.869
Totally.

188
00:11:25.909 --> 00:11:26.610
We all need to do it.

189
00:11:26.670 --> 00:11:31.658
I actually wanted to start some sort of, and I'm putting this out there so in the hope that someone will do it because I don't have the time.

190
00:11:31.759 --> 00:11:32.259
I'll do it.

191
00:11:33.101 --> 00:11:38.269
But that we actually create like an oral history project where young women interview their grandmothers.

192
00:11:38.918 --> 00:11:40.159
Yeah, I'm glad you did that.

193
00:11:40.459 --> 00:11:41.179
More of that.

194
00:11:41.279 --> 00:11:41.960
More of that.

195
00:11:42.200 --> 00:11:44.021
No, and also with the work that you do.

196
00:11:44.041 --> 00:11:47.103
I mean, there's so many things I want to get into in this interview.

197
00:11:47.123 --> 00:11:49.304
I'm probably going to have to like rein myself in a little bit.

198
00:11:49.404 --> 00:11:49.745
That's okay.

199
00:11:49.765 --> 00:11:55.348
But a big takeaway from Silenced, talking about women, but talking about journalists as well, was defamation laws.

200
00:11:56.008 --> 00:11:59.829
and, you know, how they're being used to silence women and journalists.

201
00:11:59.929 --> 00:12:02.550
But can you explain a little bit more about how that's actually happening?

202
00:12:03.170 --> 00:12:03.410
Sure.

203
00:12:03.430 --> 00:12:06.391
And this is my entry to working on violence against women, actually.

204
00:12:06.431 --> 00:12:10.352
So I work in, I practice defamation law at the bar in London.

205
00:12:10.592 --> 00:12:13.453
And so I defend journalists against defamation claims.

206
00:12:13.473 --> 00:12:16.773
So defamation laws are designed to protect people's reputation.

207
00:12:16.813 --> 00:12:19.854
So we are, and it's actually protected under international human rights law.

208
00:12:19.874 --> 00:12:22.795
We are entitled to privacy and to protect our good reputation.

209
00:12:24.358 --> 00:12:37.872
And so defamation is the means by which under domestic law, there's a cause of action that allows you, if someone says something about you that damages your reputation and is untrue, you can sue them for damages.

210
00:12:37.932 --> 00:12:38.152
Yeah.

211
00:12:38.592 --> 00:12:44.198
And I get a court judgment that says, this is not true about this person that damaged their reputation, they're going to get compensation for it.

212
00:12:44.839 --> 00:12:49.365
That sounds all good and well in practice and objectively when you stand back and think about it.

213
00:12:49.425 --> 00:12:53.691
Of course we should be able to sue if someone publishes something that damages us.

214
00:12:54.111 --> 00:12:56.635
The problem is it's about how that operates in practice.

215
00:12:56.675 --> 00:12:59.939
And so what we show in the film and what I saw in my legal practice is

216
00:13:00.580 --> 00:13:08.043
defending journalists who were doing investigative journalism stories on a serial perpetrator who had been sexually harassing women in the workplace.

217
00:13:08.663 --> 00:13:15.906
So many of those stories never made it to the media because editors were like, well, how many women have accused him?

218
00:13:17.247 --> 00:13:19.028
He's going to sue us for defamation for that.

219
00:13:19.528 --> 00:13:21.309
Do we have the legal budget to report it?

220
00:13:21.689 --> 00:13:23.410
No, let's not report that story.

221
00:13:23.450 --> 00:13:23.550
Yeah.

222
00:13:24.470 --> 00:13:43.014
So what people weren't realising is that the big high-profile cases that we see in the media about sexual misconduct, sexual assault, rape, it's the tip of the iceberg of what's actually going on in our society and the stories that actually reach the media but never get reported because someone will send a defamation letter and say, that's defamatory if you publish it, I'll sue you.

223
00:13:43.494 --> 00:13:50.095
And that can often be enough, because of the cost of defamation proceedings, to cause someone to self-censor and silence the story.

224
00:13:50.775 --> 00:14:00.567
And I was frustrated about that in the pre-MeToo world because I could see so many of these stories about violence against women were never making it into the media and these men were getting away with it.

225
00:14:01.268 --> 00:14:02.489
And it made me angry.

226
00:14:03.110 --> 00:14:04.031
It's so funny.

227
00:14:04.071 --> 00:14:07.375
I remember the first time we got sent a legal letter...

228
00:14:07.935 --> 00:14:08.616
of defamation.

229
00:14:08.996 --> 00:14:10.497
And I was so scared.

230
00:14:10.657 --> 00:14:12.419
And I didn't have any money.

231
00:14:12.719 --> 00:14:13.840
We didn't really know what to do with it.

232
00:14:13.880 --> 00:14:22.427
And at the time, it was such a funny thing because, you know, people would say to us like, oh, well, you're not anyone in media until you've been sent a defamation threat.

233
00:14:22.967 --> 00:14:27.271
But I hated it because I thought, well, the problem that I'm already seeing is like...

234
00:14:27.951 --> 00:14:34.053
even if you have support, you know, even if you have lawyers or whatever it is, generally the advice is it's not worth the headache.

235
00:14:34.273 --> 00:14:35.333
It's not worth the headache.

236
00:14:35.393 --> 00:14:40.594
It's even if you have the truth defence, like it's we can't afford it, especially independent media.

237
00:14:40.654 --> 00:14:44.956
It's like you can't afford to fight these cases.

238
00:14:45.236 --> 00:14:47.196
What does free speech mean if you can't afford to defend it?

239
00:14:47.376 --> 00:14:47.776
Exactly.

240
00:14:47.836 --> 00:14:54.238
And so if you as a journalist working for a small independent outlet can't afford to withstand a defamation threat... Mm-hmm.

241
00:14:54.458 --> 00:14:55.919
What hope does a survivor have?

242
00:14:56.340 --> 00:14:56.520
Exactly.

243
00:14:56.540 --> 00:14:57.201
A woman on her own.

244
00:14:57.641 --> 00:15:01.204
So what I was seeing was most women could not afford to defend themselves.

245
00:15:01.224 --> 00:15:02.465
So they would have to self-censor.

246
00:15:02.485 --> 00:15:10.193
And in the post-MeToo world, so what we saw with MeToo's, so these laws existed and they were already having a chilling effect on the reporting of violence against women.

247
00:15:10.213 --> 00:15:11.514
And I saw it in my practice.

248
00:15:11.714 --> 00:15:12.895
It was frustrating.

249
00:15:13.435 --> 00:15:16.358
Then MeToo happened and we suddenly had this breaking of the cultural silence.

250
00:15:16.378 --> 00:15:20.122
We have women speaking out online, media organisations being braver.

251
00:15:20.302 --> 00:15:20.502
Yeah.

252
00:15:20.702 --> 00:15:27.587
in that political moment to suddenly start rushing out these stories, which in many instances they've been sitting on for a long time.

253
00:15:28.207 --> 00:15:36.453
But suddenly it became acceptable to publish these stories or they were willing to take a punt on it because of the moment in time when women were speaking out.

254
00:15:37.053 --> 00:15:38.334
And we were all hopeful, right?

255
00:15:38.374 --> 00:15:39.935
Weren't you excited when me too happened?

256
00:15:39.955 --> 00:15:41.556
I was like, finally, accountability.

257
00:15:41.656 --> 00:15:45.919
There was a moment there and I would have been, what, starting uni or whatever it was.

258
00:15:45.959 --> 00:15:46.940
I go, oh, amazing.

259
00:15:47.060 --> 00:15:50.843
Like, I'm entering media and all the problems are solved now.

260
00:15:50.944 --> 00:15:51.184
Right.

261
00:15:51.224 --> 00:15:52.405
We can talk about it now.

262
00:15:52.605 --> 00:15:53.586
We can talk about it.

263
00:15:53.606 --> 00:15:54.586
We can report on it.

264
00:15:54.987 --> 00:15:56.368
Women can speak out online.

265
00:15:56.788 --> 00:15:58.750
But as a media lawyer watching it, I was thinking...

266
00:16:01.068 --> 00:16:09.273
I don't think people understand the risks they're taking when they're posting on social media that their boyfriend raped them or their ex-partner hit them.

267
00:16:09.773 --> 00:16:17.739
Because that person is identifiable and when you publish something on social media that is a publication that the world can see, lots of people are reading it.

268
00:16:18.651 --> 00:16:25.376
It is defamatory to accuse someone of sexual violence or gender-based violence, and it should be because it's a terrible thing to do.

269
00:16:25.396 --> 00:16:25.816
Yeah.

270
00:16:25.976 --> 00:16:28.758
So, of course, that will damage people's reputations in the eyes of others.

271
00:16:29.319 --> 00:16:36.724
Now, but if it's true, we should absolutely be able to say that about the person, and they should wear all the consequences that follow from their conduct.

272
00:16:37.365 --> 00:16:41.468
The problem with defamation law is that people know they can weaponise the legal system.

273
00:16:41.488 --> 00:16:41.788
Yeah.

274
00:16:42.148 --> 00:16:46.050
that it's often enough to send a threat letter to silence.

275
00:16:47.470 --> 00:16:52.952
And what we then saw in the wake of Me Too was a massive avalanche of defamation claims.

276
00:16:53.493 --> 00:16:58.835
People being sued for what they posted online, journalists being sued, women being sued for speaking out.

277
00:16:59.475 --> 00:17:03.217
And I had these women coming into my offices saying, Jen, but how can he sue me?

278
00:17:03.257 --> 00:17:03.817
It's true.

279
00:17:05.281 --> 00:17:09.184
And I have to explain, well, yes, he can sue you.

280
00:17:10.225 --> 00:17:13.388
And even if it's true, you now have to prove that in court.

281
00:17:13.548 --> 00:17:16.310
And that takes time and money and expense.

282
00:17:17.291 --> 00:17:20.574
And so do you have the money to prove that it's true in court?

283
00:17:20.834 --> 00:17:22.796
Because if he pursues you, that's what it's going to take.

284
00:17:22.976 --> 00:17:23.677
And it won't matter.

285
00:17:24.878 --> 00:17:26.299
You need to have lawyers who can prove it.

286
00:17:27.866 --> 00:17:29.268
And you need to be able to afford those lawyers.

287
00:17:30.429 --> 00:17:40.740
And what we were seeing was so many women having to apologise to their perpetrator publicly for having called them the rapists they are and promising never to say it ever again.

288
00:17:40.760 --> 00:17:41.901
Yeah.

289
00:17:42.223 --> 00:17:48.288
And not only is it unacceptable for her, because we have the right to free speech.

290
00:17:48.908 --> 00:17:53.552
And as part of broader international human rights protections, we have the right to live free from violence.

291
00:17:53.572 --> 00:17:54.593
We have the right to free speech.

292
00:17:54.613 --> 00:17:56.094
We have the right to tell our story.

293
00:17:56.854 --> 00:18:06.542
So these women's, not only were their rights violated by the violence, the silencing about that violence is another human rights violation on top of that.

294
00:18:07.662 --> 00:18:16.385
And when you put all of that together and then zoom out in terms of the societal impact that we're having, one in three women suffered gender-based violence in our society.

295
00:18:17.086 --> 00:18:22.467
How can it possibly be in the public interest to be silencing and stopping women from talking about it?

296
00:18:22.508 --> 00:18:29.630
Because if we can't talk about it and tell people what happened to us, how can we possibly understand the extent of the problem?

297
00:18:30.250 --> 00:18:31.751
How can government make policy?

298
00:18:32.571 --> 00:18:33.411
How can we deal with it?

299
00:18:33.752 --> 00:18:37.653
For me, it's also looking at then like the court of public opinion with this problem as well.

300
00:18:37.673 --> 00:18:43.916
Because if you hit the dead end with defamation and people don't understand that is because of these limitations that we're having with the law.

301
00:18:44.176 --> 00:18:44.356
Yeah.

302
00:18:44.536 --> 00:18:51.059
Then, you know, you get the likes of Joe Rogan and Piers Morgan and whoever else being like, oh, see, like Me Too's gone too far.

303
00:18:51.439 --> 00:18:53.380
This is all now proof that it went too far.

304
00:18:53.780 --> 00:18:54.660
And I don't know.

305
00:18:54.700 --> 00:18:55.741
I think that was sort of this...

306
00:18:56.581 --> 00:19:00.783
huge backslide that we all noticed, which was... We are in that backslide.

307
00:19:00.943 --> 00:19:02.724
We are so in it right now.

308
00:19:03.585 --> 00:19:12.209
So if you look historically, what's really interesting looking at the history of defamation laws in the context of the civil rights movement, so equal rights for white and black Americans...

309
00:19:12.689 --> 00:19:29.219
In the context of that movement, we also saw an onslaught of defamation claims brought, for example, by the police and others against civil rights activists who were calling out police brutality against black people and about the discrimination against black people.

310
00:19:29.659 --> 00:19:36.883
So historically we've seen defamation claims, like these raft of defamation claims being used to push back on progressive social movements, actually.

311
00:19:37.343 --> 00:19:41.545
And I think the Me Too movement ought to be seen in that context, in that historical context.

312
00:19:41.585 --> 00:19:42.505
We're seeing it again.

313
00:19:42.525 --> 00:19:42.965
Yeah.

314
00:19:43.366 --> 00:19:48.208
So for me, I think we have to zoom out and look at it in that way, which is what we do in the book.

315
00:19:48.488 --> 00:19:56.296
But what we really wanted to show in the film is I think there's this tendency, you know, when I talk about defamation, people say, oh, but why did she go to the media?

316
00:19:56.316 --> 00:19:57.417
She should have gone to the police.

317
00:19:57.557 --> 00:19:59.619
And if it was true, she should have gone to the police.

318
00:19:59.739 --> 00:20:01.040
And what about his reputation?

319
00:20:01.060 --> 00:20:02.942
It's going to ruin his life and his career.

320
00:20:02.962 --> 00:20:03.483
Hmm.

321
00:20:03.763 --> 00:20:11.107
And I think, well, okay, one, so few cases are ever investigated and prosecuted by the police.

322
00:20:11.667 --> 00:20:19.791
So if we are going to limit our public discussion, in the UK it's something like 2% of rape cases are prosecuted, which effectively means it's been decriminalised.

323
00:20:20.411 --> 00:20:21.371
But 2% of cases.

324
00:20:21.451 --> 00:20:27.374
In Australia it's maybe a little bit higher, but let's just say 10% of cases are prosecuted here.

325
00:20:27.394 --> 00:20:30.316
That means we can't talk about 90% of cases of violence against women, ever.

326
00:20:31.296 --> 00:20:39.326
And so that can't be right because if we're going to deal with violence against women, we have to talk about all of it, whether it ends up in the criminal justice system or not.

327
00:20:40.167 --> 00:20:46.194
And then the other point I sort of make is like women lie in, the reported statistics are 2% of cases.

328
00:20:47.578 --> 00:21:03.272
So why are people so concerned about the 2% of cases where women lie as opposed to the vast damage to individual women, their families, their communities, our national economy as a result of violence against women?

329
00:21:04.173 --> 00:21:06.315
It's just like where are we putting the focus and why?

330
00:21:07.035 --> 00:21:08.296
I think this is just the...

331
00:21:09.357 --> 00:21:15.442
The PR, the narrative of it all, which is that men are being falsely accused and like they're doing a great job with their PR on that.

332
00:21:15.502 --> 00:21:18.324
A lot of people really believe that stat is a lot higher than it is.

333
00:21:18.584 --> 00:21:19.604
But who does that serve?

334
00:21:20.065 --> 00:21:23.327
It's an old trope about violence that women lie.

335
00:21:23.527 --> 00:21:24.168
Yeah.

336
00:21:24.188 --> 00:21:29.311
Universally, the women that I interview, they speak out because they want it to stop.

337
00:21:30.112 --> 00:21:32.033
They speak out because they want to help other women.

338
00:21:32.874 --> 00:21:35.736
None of this nonsense of she wanted revenge, she wanted to make money –

339
00:21:36.016 --> 00:21:37.017
Women do not make money.

340
00:21:37.457 --> 00:21:39.818
Also, look at the reality of speaking out.

341
00:21:39.919 --> 00:21:40.999
No one does that.

342
00:21:41.299 --> 00:21:42.400
Unless it's true.

343
00:21:42.420 --> 00:21:54.988
And that's what I wanted to show in the film was the lived experiences of survivors who speak out and the journalists who report their stories to show just how hard it is and what it means to be sued for defamation.

344
00:21:55.028 --> 00:22:01.392
The very real personal, emotional, economic, physical toll that it has on people is,

345
00:22:01.873 --> 00:22:03.854
Both survivors and journalists, by the way.

346
00:22:04.594 --> 00:22:06.094
Have you actually been through a defamation trial?

347
00:22:06.354 --> 00:22:07.215
No.

348
00:22:07.275 --> 00:22:08.415
I hope it never happens to you.

349
00:22:08.475 --> 00:22:09.115
No, I know.

350
00:22:09.455 --> 00:22:12.396
Look at what Lisa Wilkinson's been through with the Bruce Lerman case.

351
00:22:12.436 --> 00:22:12.716
I know.

352
00:22:12.776 --> 00:22:14.077
Millions of dollars in fees.

353
00:22:14.857 --> 00:22:17.538
You know, it's really affected her career and her ability to work.

354
00:22:17.558 --> 00:22:17.658
Yeah.

355
00:22:18.358 --> 00:22:25.745
It's taken years of her life to get to a point where the judge found that it was true, what she reported was true, that Brittany Higgins was raped in Parliament.

356
00:22:26.245 --> 00:22:34.293
But all of this stress and money to get to the point to prove that she reported something in the public interest and it was true.

357
00:22:34.713 --> 00:22:40.778
Honestly, one of the most emotional parts of the film for me was when Amber Heard and Brittany Higgins hugged each other.

358
00:22:40.798 --> 00:22:41.899
Oh, that was big.

359
00:22:41.920 --> 00:22:44.402
Amber said, you're in a really unfun club.

360
00:22:45.302 --> 00:22:49.303
And, oh, I couldn't believe the bravery of these women.

361
00:22:49.503 --> 00:22:51.304
Yeah, it makes me cry thinking about it too.

362
00:22:51.584 --> 00:22:52.004
Yeah.

363
00:22:52.244 --> 00:22:54.945
You'll make me cry looking at you talk about it.

364
00:22:55.185 --> 00:22:55.525
Yeah.

365
00:22:55.845 --> 00:23:05.048
It was really important for me to get them together as women who have been, obviously Amber on a global scale, but Brittany here in Australia, vilified.

366
00:23:06.149 --> 00:23:08.730
And Amber didn't even speak out and go to the media.

367
00:23:09.171 --> 00:23:12.553
You know, her ex-husband dragged this case into the media.

368
00:23:12.593 --> 00:23:15.756
She went, she did what perfect victims are supposed to do.

369
00:23:15.796 --> 00:23:22.901
She went and got a restraining order to stop him having access to her property where they lived because he would come in and trash the place.

370
00:23:22.941 --> 00:23:30.827
So she went and got a restraining order in the court and then never spoke about it to the media, signed a non-disclosure agreement and got on with her life.

371
00:23:32.350 --> 00:23:33.310
He was the one that brought it up.

372
00:23:33.390 --> 00:23:48.935
But both of those women, whether they chose to speak to the media, Britney chose to speak to the media, both of those women have become the subject of global and or national media controversy because of their experiences and have really suffered for it.

373
00:23:49.135 --> 00:23:49.395
Yeah.

374
00:23:49.655 --> 00:23:55.297
Both being forced to give evidence of sexual violence live online broadcast to the world.

375
00:23:56.297 --> 00:24:00.438
At least in Brittany's case, we have contempt protections in this country, which meant it couldn't be recorded and shared.

376
00:24:00.658 --> 00:24:02.719
Amber's was cut up and shared and put all over the internet.

377
00:24:03.079 --> 00:24:10.801
I want to get into that because I think this is the other part of this discussion and having you here today to talk about, like especially focusing on Amber Heard's case.

378
00:24:10.901 --> 00:24:12.302
Like, I don't think enough people...

379
00:24:12.822 --> 00:24:23.047
realized, interestingly, that there was a UK trial first and that Johnny Depp filed for defamation against The Sun over reports of domestic violence against Amber and that The Sun decided to use the truth defense.

380
00:24:23.107 --> 00:24:31.290
And as you said, that meant that even though she's not the one that gave the interview to The Sun, she was then called in as a witness to defend her truth.

381
00:24:32.091 --> 00:24:32.171
And

382
00:24:32.940 --> 00:24:39.125
Being there for her at that time, what was it like explaining that to her, talking her through that case?

383
00:24:39.806 --> 00:24:52.917
My first phone call with Amber when she called to talk about whether I would act for her, I was actually already working on this book and was following cases around the world, including what happened in the Geoffrey Rush case with...

384
00:24:54.638 --> 00:24:55.840
the complainant in that case.

385
00:24:56.320 --> 00:25:02.886
And so I said to her, I was like, look, you're in a difficult position, just as what happened in the Geoffrey Rush case.

386
00:25:03.967 --> 00:25:09.412
A tabloid newspaper has reported this story without talking to you, without your consent, without...

387
00:25:11.275 --> 00:25:17.122
you know, you're giving an interview, but they've reported the fact, and now they're running a truth defence, which means your truth is on trial.

388
00:25:17.162 --> 00:25:20.846
So if you don't give evidence, they could settle the case.

389
00:25:21.487 --> 00:25:30.297
So if she chose, if she said to The Sun, I don't want anything to do with your tabloid journalism, I don't want to be involved in this, what will be a media circus, then...

390
00:25:30.577 --> 00:25:37.699
They might have made the commercial decision at the newspaper to say, well, we don't think we can win it without her testimony, so let's just settle it.

391
00:25:37.779 --> 00:25:42.440
And Johnny Depp could have run around the world saying, look, the Sun refused to defend this.

392
00:25:42.861 --> 00:25:43.801
They know it's not true.

393
00:25:43.861 --> 00:25:44.701
I know it's not true.

394
00:25:44.801 --> 00:25:45.441
She's a liar.

395
00:25:45.641 --> 00:25:46.282
I'm off the hook.

396
00:25:46.422 --> 00:25:47.142
I'm off the hook.

397
00:25:48.202 --> 00:25:51.403
And I said to her, so you're in a terrible position.

398
00:25:52.883 --> 00:25:57.004
So you either stay out of it and that's the risk that happens or you give evidence.

399
00:25:57.104 --> 00:26:12.026
But I said, watching what happened in the Geoffrey Rush trial where the complainant was reticent to support the Daily Telegraph's defence and so didn't become involved until very late in the process and that I think affected the way the case could be prepared.

400
00:26:12.586 --> 00:26:14.627
So if we're going to do it, we need to get involved now.

401
00:26:15.627 --> 00:26:17.648
And so I worked with her for two years on that evidence.

402
00:26:17.688 --> 00:26:22.649
She agreed to give evidence for the son and I worked with her and the son's lawyers in preparing that evidence.

403
00:26:23.309 --> 00:26:26.930
And we proved that Johnny Depp was violent towards her on 12 separate occasions.

404
00:26:28.050 --> 00:26:29.770
And there's a long reasoned decision judgment.

405
00:26:30.491 --> 00:26:35.032
And for me, that was a really satisfying win for women, for Amber and for women.

406
00:26:35.052 --> 00:26:43.894
It was heralded by domestic violence groups saying, look, this shows that powerful men can't weaponise the legal system and defamation to silence allegations of domestic violence.

407
00:26:44.514 --> 00:26:52.162
Women were coming out saying, you know, if this has happened to you, you can talk about it and people will defend your truth.

408
00:26:52.823 --> 00:27:02.172
And then he sued her personally in the United States and it went before a jury in Virginia, a conservative state, where there's no anti-slap protections.

409
00:27:02.192 --> 00:27:02.933
Yeah.

410
00:27:03.473 --> 00:27:07.274
where the jury was not sequestered, where it was broadcast live online.

411
00:27:07.754 --> 00:27:11.955
And in the context of what became this, I wasn't in that trial.

412
00:27:12.075 --> 00:27:14.315
I represented Amber in the UK, not in the US.

413
00:27:15.295 --> 00:27:17.335
So I was an observer to those proceedings.

414
00:27:17.756 --> 00:27:23.497
But it was really disappointing because having just won the trial in the UK, where it's actually really difficult.

415
00:27:24.117 --> 00:27:26.017
The UK has a more difficult standard of proof.

416
00:27:26.337 --> 00:27:26.817
About to ask.

417
00:27:26.837 --> 00:27:29.358
The burden was on us, was on the newspaper.

418
00:27:29.758 --> 00:27:31.358
So it was on the side of the newspaper.

419
00:27:32.138 --> 00:27:36.061
for whom Amber was a witness, to prove that he was violent towards her.

420
00:27:36.542 --> 00:27:37.222
And we proved it.

421
00:27:37.763 --> 00:27:42.506
So when it went off to the US and she was being sued there, I actually said, I was like, great, now you're in the US.

422
00:27:42.526 --> 00:27:44.488
We proved it in the more difficult jurisdiction.

423
00:27:46.190 --> 00:27:46.831
You'll be fine.

424
00:27:46.951 --> 00:27:48.852
First Amendment, United States.

425
00:27:48.872 --> 00:27:50.073
Did you think that was like...

426
00:27:50.314 --> 00:27:51.915
I said, we proved it when the burden was us.

427
00:27:51.975 --> 00:27:56.799
Now it's on him to not only prove that it didn't happen, but prove that you lied with malice.

428
00:27:57.300 --> 00:27:59.281
And there's no evidence of malice in this case.

429
00:27:59.922 --> 00:28:00.643
Quite the contrary.

430
00:28:00.803 --> 00:28:02.024
If you look at his text messages.

431
00:28:02.124 --> 00:28:02.764
No.

432
00:28:02.804 --> 00:28:06.448
It was all about him wanting to destroy her after she left him.

433
00:28:07.543 --> 00:28:07.983
And so...

434
00:28:08.003 --> 00:28:11.006
Global humiliation, to quote.

435
00:28:11.286 --> 00:28:18.132
Honestly, I thought that case should be an easy slam dunk win for her council after we won in the UK.

436
00:28:18.867 --> 00:28:24.970
You were with her when she received the news that she was going to be sort of slapped with this $50 million.

437
00:28:25.230 --> 00:28:25.630
I was.

438
00:28:25.750 --> 00:28:37.236
We were in London when the news broke that he was suing her for $50 million and over an opinion piece that she'd written that had been legaled by her lawyers and by the ACLU.

439
00:28:37.456 --> 00:28:39.657
So she was the Women's Rights Ambassador.

440
00:28:39.697 --> 00:28:40.877
This is how this whole case came about.

441
00:28:41.037 --> 00:28:41.998
Yeah, it was the op-ed.

442
00:28:42.498 --> 00:28:54.362
an op-ed that she wrote in her capacity as Women's Rights Ambassador for ACLU, the biggest civil liberties group in the United States and incredibly well respected.

443
00:28:55.622 --> 00:29:11.788
The organisation that she had pledged to give all of her divorce settlement money to, or a large chunk of it to this organisation, and had given some of it before Depp sued her and she couldn't afford to keep giving the money because she had to then defend herself against his legal suit.

444
00:29:13.032 --> 00:29:19.775
So she did this op-ed and all it was was really saying, I'm a survivor and we need to better protect survivors.

445
00:29:20.095 --> 00:29:23.536
She didn't speak about the violence she suffered.

446
00:29:23.756 --> 00:29:26.237
She didn't name Johnny Depp as the perpetrator.

447
00:29:27.477 --> 00:29:31.659
And as is public now, Amber is a survivor of domestic violence in her own family.

448
00:29:33.179 --> 00:29:37.381
She was also a recognised domestic violence survivor by the UK court, by the way, but she didn't get into it.

449
00:29:37.521 --> 00:29:40.422
All she said was we have to better protect survivors when they speak out.

450
00:29:41.002 --> 00:29:42.823
And he sued her for $50 million.

451
00:29:42.903 --> 00:29:46.866
And I remember sitting with her in London and I was like, this is obscene.

452
00:29:47.947 --> 00:29:49.108
And it's also forum shopping.

453
00:29:49.128 --> 00:29:51.449
I'm like, you've already sued the Sun and lost.

454
00:29:51.910 --> 00:30:00.636
Also, given all of that context, knowing that, knowing his legal team knows that, you're just like, how is that not perceived as just like monstrous behaviour?

455
00:30:00.916 --> 00:30:09.022
I really think the Amber Heard trial is something we are already doing and will continue to do over the next few years, where we will all look back on this and go, what...

456
00:30:09.762 --> 00:30:10.783
the fuck happened there.

457
00:30:11.083 --> 00:30:11.443
Totally.

458
00:30:11.463 --> 00:30:12.703
Well, that's why in my book...

459
00:30:12.743 --> 00:30:33.212
So I didn't intend to write so much about that case in my book because I've worked on lots of cases and really working with Amber and the son in defending that case that he took against the son, that was like a couple of sentences in a chapter in our book, which the film is based on, really where we were saying, look, the truth defence works, so if it's true, you go to court, you can prove it.

460
00:30:33.632 --> 00:30:36.174
But as we were about to press print on our book...

461
00:30:37.334 --> 00:30:38.955
The decision came down in the United States.

462
00:30:39.435 --> 00:30:45.318
And I remember just sitting there watching it live on the BBC and texting support to her.

463
00:30:45.678 --> 00:30:57.823
And when they read the verdict, I cried because I thought, how can they have heard the evidence that I know is there and reach that conclusion?

464
00:30:58.183 --> 00:30:59.364
That is terrifying.

465
00:30:59.904 --> 00:31:02.245
That is terrifying for every woman.

466
00:31:02.325 --> 00:31:04.126
Every lawyer should find that terrifying, actually.

467
00:31:04.966 --> 00:31:09.368
But for her personally, I thought she's going to walk out past that awful scene at court.

468
00:31:09.388 --> 00:31:23.294
I just sat there and I was like, I have to write about this because I don't think the public has, because of the awful, like the way it played out online, people were not understanding what was happening because, you know, so many people come up to me, oh, Amber's a liar.

469
00:31:23.314 --> 00:31:24.175
She's this, she's that.

470
00:31:24.275 --> 00:31:25.215
Using all this phraseology.

471
00:31:25.235 --> 00:31:26.576
And I was like, how do you know that?

472
00:31:27.396 --> 00:31:28.677
I've been watching the trial.

473
00:31:28.717 --> 00:31:30.059
I said, have you been watching the trial?

474
00:31:30.079 --> 00:31:30.719
Yeah.

475
00:31:31.240 --> 00:31:33.702
As a lawyer, I find it funny when people say, I've been watching the trial.

476
00:31:33.722 --> 00:31:34.743
It's like, oh, you watched the trial.

477
00:31:34.844 --> 00:31:38.887
So you sat and watched weeks and weeks of hearing live online.

478
00:31:39.188 --> 00:31:40.029
You could have.

479
00:31:40.109 --> 00:31:41.850
I mean, people could have and some people did.

480
00:31:42.551 --> 00:31:45.412
But most people are like, oh, no, I've just been watching the snippets on social media.

481
00:31:45.432 --> 00:31:46.913
I said, well, you're not watching the trial.

482
00:31:47.333 --> 00:31:52.675
You're watching the snippets that there was a huge online campaign against her.

483
00:31:53.175 --> 00:32:01.539
You are watching the snippets that are deliberately picked up, packaged, in many instances, manipulated and pushed out online.

484
00:32:01.559 --> 00:32:02.279
Yeah.

485
00:32:02.459 --> 00:32:04.480
I couldn't get over the social media campaign.

486
00:32:04.500 --> 00:32:09.821
And I remember before the US trial, I actually warned her lawyers and said, we've got to do something about what's happening in the online space.

487
00:32:09.861 --> 00:32:11.842
Because for us in the UK, it doesn't matter.

488
00:32:11.862 --> 00:32:14.023
We're in front of a judge, but you're in front of a jury.

489
00:32:14.243 --> 00:32:27.767
And unless they're sequestered, where they're not allowed to have access to their phones, and even if they are, the online space of what people are absorbing about this trial is actually affecting people's perception of it in very real ways, even intelligent people.

490
00:32:28.508 --> 00:32:29.608
I've had so many women...

491
00:32:31.080 --> 00:32:41.811
who I've confronted about this and have self-reflected and expressed feeling embarrassment about how taken in they were by the social media campaign as feminists.

492
00:32:42.511 --> 00:32:43.292
Absolutely.

493
00:32:43.532 --> 00:32:48.578
Who didn't really, who were taken in by it and didn't critically assess what was happening.

494
00:32:48.998 --> 00:32:51.841
That's why I think we are in a moment of reflection on this.

495
00:32:52.141 --> 00:32:54.564
I ended up writing a whole chapter, Her Truth on Trial Twice,

496
00:32:55.144 --> 00:33:03.593
because I wanted people to have the facts from the UK trial compared to what was happening in the US so that they would have the material to be able to push back.

497
00:33:04.353 --> 00:33:06.255
And I think we're now starting to see that.

498
00:33:06.536 --> 00:33:08.357
And we're hoping the film will be part of it.

499
00:33:08.438 --> 00:33:08.658
Yeah.

500
00:33:08.958 --> 00:33:14.804
Because people just didn't know the UK trial even happened because of this like raft of online nonsense.

501
00:33:15.224 --> 00:33:17.106
Well, it's a conversation that we're having

502
00:33:17.907 --> 00:33:22.328
Definitely every year since we've started the podcast, there's a different sort of, we call it like trial by TikTok.

503
00:33:22.588 --> 00:33:22.828
Yes.

504
00:33:23.028 --> 00:33:27.570
And I'm really fascinated about how this will continue to shape culture.

505
00:33:28.070 --> 00:33:35.812
Because if we look at the hate that Amber Heard received, it was this like clear, horrific, don't be an Amber messaging.

506
00:33:36.332 --> 00:33:39.593
And Johnny was successfully portrayed as a victim.

507
00:33:40.313 --> 00:33:44.154
And Amber was seen as this imperfect victim or unlikable.

508
00:33:44.274 --> 00:33:46.515
And we've seen this with other women in the media since.

509
00:33:47.175 --> 00:33:55.983
And, you know, like I remember vividly going on TikTok and I couldn't escape like body language experts and, you know, people that were, I've watched it.

510
00:33:56.443 --> 00:34:00.526
I've been up late watching every single second and here's what you need to know from the trial.

511
00:34:00.586 --> 00:34:01.567
And it was so confusing.

512
00:34:01.587 --> 00:34:06.952
And just as you said, intelligent friends or anyone was saying like, oh, I can't keep up.

513
00:34:06.972 --> 00:34:09.474
I don't really know what's happening, but she's a bit crazy.

514
00:34:09.754 --> 00:34:11.676
Or it was mutual abuse, though.

515
00:34:11.996 --> 00:34:15.457
And I was like, you don't understand what mutual abuse, you don't understand what abuse is then.

516
00:34:15.477 --> 00:34:16.177
Right.

517
00:34:16.317 --> 00:34:22.659
But also, if it was mutual abuse, this is why I say don't, if it was mutual abuse, and it wasn't, but if it was mutual, mutual abuse isn't a thing.

518
00:34:23.480 --> 00:34:24.980
Someone is the aggressor.

519
00:34:25.540 --> 00:34:28.621
And if a woman acts in self-defense, that does not make it mutual abuse.

520
00:34:29.061 --> 00:34:29.941
Yeah, no, no.

521
00:34:30.362 --> 00:34:36.403
And also, like, this is what I mean, like women are held to these perfect victim stereotypes.

522
00:34:37.164 --> 00:34:41.165
I mean, there were even comments made by one of the jurors that they didn't like the way Amber cried.

523
00:34:42.517 --> 00:34:43.238
I remember that.

524
00:34:43.358 --> 00:34:48.843
And that was like part of their rationale for deciding that she wasn't telling the truth.

525
00:34:48.923 --> 00:34:51.866
I'm like, how are you supposed to cry?

526
00:34:52.447 --> 00:34:59.814
We cannot hold women up to these impossible perfect victim standards in order to believe them.

527
00:35:00.094 --> 00:35:00.675
Yeah.

528
00:35:00.695 --> 00:35:02.497
So not everyone will react the same way.

529
00:35:03.057 --> 00:35:05.359
Trauma has an effect on the way that women react.

530
00:35:06.148 --> 00:35:18.036
Some women don't want to be seen as a victim, so find it very hard to hold themselves together in a way that makes it hard for someone else who's sitting back watching going, I don't think I'd react that way if I was raped.

531
00:35:18.056 --> 00:35:27.603
And it's like, well, it's not, we have to accept that there's a whole range of reactions to that kind of trauma and holding women to these ridiculous stereotypes of what,

532
00:35:28.663 --> 00:35:30.244
we believe a victim should look like.

533
00:35:30.764 --> 00:35:41.409
And that's why in the criminal justice context, all of this, we acknowledge in the criminal justice context, these male-centric myths about gender-based violence and what is or is not a perfect victim or a real victim.

534
00:35:42.670 --> 00:35:46.672
In a criminal justice context, if you go before a judge, there are jury directions.

535
00:35:46.832 --> 00:35:50.294
So if you go before, if you were before a jury, which you would be in this country,

536
00:35:51.554 --> 00:36:00.299
A judge will say, you must exclude any sense of who looks like a perpetrator, who looks like a victim.

537
00:36:00.719 --> 00:36:04.521
You need to exclude those stereotypes from your mind and just look at the objective evidence.

538
00:36:05.161 --> 00:36:07.222
That did not happen in this case.

539
00:36:07.782 --> 00:36:08.883
And I think it's really dangerous.

540
00:36:08.903 --> 00:36:10.544
Like you said, this thing of don't be an amber.

541
00:36:11.822 --> 00:36:29.008
What is really scary about this trial is not just what it meant for Amber or for me as a lawyer watching it going, how can they have turned those facts on their head and what it means for everybody in a justice system, but what it means to every woman who watched that.

542
00:36:30.109 --> 00:36:39.352
So I say to people all the time, well, anecdotally, I had colleagues calling me going, my client won't go ahead now because they saw what happened to Amber, because everyone knows I represented her.

543
00:36:39.632 --> 00:36:39.832
Yeah.

544
00:36:40.652 --> 00:36:43.433
This don't be an Amber thing actually does affect women.

545
00:36:44.034 --> 00:36:50.156
Women, a lot of women globally were like, well, why would I take this forward if I'm going to be treated that way?

546
00:36:50.896 --> 00:36:55.298
And the thing I say to people too, because there was, as you know, it was everywhere on TikTok.

547
00:36:55.338 --> 00:36:56.739
I had friends, kids coming home.

548
00:36:57.099 --> 00:37:00.360
Friends were calling me saying, my son just came home and said Amber Heard is a gold digger.

549
00:37:00.500 --> 00:37:01.620
I was like, he's 12.

550
00:37:01.900 --> 00:37:05.742
But not only that, that shocked me was the amount of women that,

551
00:37:06.182 --> 00:37:06.443
Oh, yeah.

552
00:37:06.463 --> 00:37:06.983
Against Amber.

553
00:37:07.444 --> 00:37:11.188
Oh, that is a whole... What is scary about that?

554
00:37:11.248 --> 00:37:22.199
And I would say this to all those women and to everyone, I say, look, Amber Heard is never going to see or is very unlikely to see what you posted about her online or what you've said in private conversations like this about her.

555
00:37:22.580 --> 00:37:23.901
But do you know who is going to hear it?

556
00:37:25.458 --> 00:37:29.106
the people in your life who have suffered gender-based violence and have never spoken about it?

557
00:37:29.266 --> 00:37:33.716
And do you think they'll ever come and tell you their story if they hear you speak that way about Amber Heard?

558
00:37:34.237 --> 00:37:35.279
And the answer is no.

559
00:37:35.580 --> 00:37:36.081
Of course.

560
00:37:42.148 --> 00:37:55.064
The thing that's scary about these cases and trial by TikTok is, you know, like we know in Amber's case, like Tortoise Media proved that, you know, 50% of the comments were and posts were bots.

561
00:37:55.645 --> 00:37:56.005
Right.

562
00:37:56.025 --> 00:37:59.669
And that is so terrifying because I think...

563
00:38:00.170 --> 00:38:13.246
And I'm interested in your take on this, but from what I understand is it was like, okay, we had hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of thousands of comments and posts that were enabled by a PR company to rewrite the public narrative.

564
00:38:14.367 --> 00:38:17.871
From that, we then did have organic posts of people then jumping on board.

565
00:38:18.432 --> 00:38:22.698
But is it because that sort of herd mentality that we feel emboldened and being in the majority?

566
00:38:23.219 --> 00:38:30.250
Was that misogyny already there or did the bots like... Well, I saw it in the UK trial and then it went, was insane during the US trial.

567
00:38:30.310 --> 00:38:32.974
So it is important for people to realise that over 50%

568
00:38:34.295 --> 00:38:35.875
of that online activity was inauthentic.

569
00:38:35.895 --> 00:38:47.798
So it was, there was a deliberate campaign to generate that public discussion, which then was picked up and leveraged and echoed and repeated by groups who were, had aligned purposes.

570
00:38:47.818 --> 00:38:52.878
So like the misogynistic manosphere, you know, it became a part of the culture war, right?

571
00:38:53.239 --> 00:38:54.199
That's going on right now.

572
00:38:54.959 --> 00:39:00.980
And so from my point of view, it's important to, for the public to understand that they were duped by an online campaign.

573
00:39:02.798 --> 00:39:09.166
I also think it's important to acknowledge that it wasn't just the online campaign, that there was, you know, the rest of the activity was genuine.

574
00:39:10.308 --> 00:39:17.557
I'm not a social media expert, so I can't tell you how much of, how much that inauthentic campaign contributed or built that

575
00:39:19.337 --> 00:39:25.779
organic engagement by real people, how much of that would have happened anyway had it not been for the campaign.

576
00:39:25.959 --> 00:39:26.499
I don't know.

577
00:39:27.020 --> 00:39:28.640
What we do know is that it contributed to it.

578
00:39:28.760 --> 00:39:34.462
And what's scary about this, I remember, and to your point of like this is becoming part of our culture, I don't know.

579
00:39:34.602 --> 00:39:36.663
When we saw the whole Blake Lively thing start to play out.

580
00:39:37.204 --> 00:39:40.806
So for me, I sat there watching this because I'd watched it play out with Amber.

581
00:39:40.946 --> 00:39:44.208
And because I was in the middle of the case, I watched it differently, right?

582
00:39:44.269 --> 00:39:46.770
Because I knew what was happening in the case and I knew the facts.

583
00:39:46.810 --> 00:39:58.058
So I was watching these false narratives being put out, propaganda, anti-Amber pieces going out, and then watching them ricochet and echo and grow in momentum around the internet.

584
00:39:58.818 --> 00:40:01.679
So I watched that in real time happen and I could see that it was happening.

585
00:40:02.699 --> 00:40:05.180
It just took a long time for the rest of the world to catch up to that.

586
00:40:05.960 --> 00:40:14.142
When the Blake Lively stuff happened and with the release of It Ends With Us, I was sitting back watching it, not being at the centre of it this time, but just observing it.

587
00:40:14.222 --> 00:40:15.943
And I thought, this isn't right.

588
00:40:17.243 --> 00:40:20.704
Suddenly, I was like, she's a stated feminist.

589
00:40:20.884 --> 00:40:22.805
She's bringing out this film about domestic violence.

590
00:40:23.646 --> 00:40:29.768
Why is there so much chat about her being this awful anti-feminist person and about her conduct around this film?

591
00:40:30.488 --> 00:40:38.951
Or suddenly there were all these videos of her from 20 years ago making an off comment that was generated around the time of the film's release.

592
00:40:39.071 --> 00:40:40.052
And I remember thinking...

593
00:40:41.353 --> 00:40:43.896
And this feels all too coordinated to me.

594
00:40:44.597 --> 00:40:45.999
This doesn't feel real to me.

595
00:40:46.239 --> 00:40:49.243
And then I kept saying to friends, are you seeing this online?

596
00:40:49.363 --> 00:40:53.028
I don't follow celebrity culture, but I was being fed it.

597
00:40:53.328 --> 00:40:55.310
God, when did the penny drop for you then?

598
00:40:55.370 --> 00:40:56.372
So four months later...

599
00:40:57.072 --> 00:41:12.864
Blake Lively files a suit saying that there had been retaliation against her for making a sexual harassment allegation and that she claimed there was a deliberate campaign run against her in the context of that publicity campaign in retaliation for her sexual harassment complaint.

600
00:41:13.412 --> 00:41:16.033
I sent it to everyone going, see, I told you so.

601
00:41:16.153 --> 00:41:25.437
And what's more interesting is it came out that the same PR people that acted for Johnny Depp acted for Justin Baldoni and those messages saying we can take down anyone.

602
00:41:25.477 --> 00:41:26.317
We can, what was it?

603
00:41:26.557 --> 00:41:28.058
Bury anyone.

604
00:41:28.518 --> 00:41:39.402
When I saw that, I was like, I hope people start to now look back differently on what happened to Amber because we're now seeing it happen again and we'll keep seeing it happen again.

605
00:41:40.262 --> 00:41:44.666
Unless we start holding these people accountable and calling it out when it happens.

606
00:41:45.346 --> 00:41:53.253
And so I really hope, like for me, like we wrote our book and made this film because I want people to watch this film and actually reflect...

607
00:41:55.011 --> 00:42:03.533
on what they think they thought they knew about Amber Heard's case, how they reacted to her, and what drove that reaction.

608
00:42:03.753 --> 00:42:05.154
Was it unconscious bias?

609
00:42:05.414 --> 00:42:06.774
Was it the online campaign?

610
00:42:07.354 --> 00:42:10.135
And how might we approach the next case that comes up?

611
00:42:10.435 --> 00:42:17.196
It's a really tough one because I think everyone would have to hold a mirror up to themselves, not only a mirror up to Johnny and to the men in all of

612
00:42:19.397 --> 00:42:30.370
You know, it was so convincing for so many people to be tricked by this that you'd have to sort of admit, I think, you know, similar that was like, oh, I did fall down a bit of a rabbit hole on something.

613
00:42:30.470 --> 00:42:32.552
And what does that say about me?

614
00:42:32.892 --> 00:42:37.398
But it's actually like, yes, it probably says, you know, something to interrogate on us all, but like...

615
00:42:37.858 --> 00:42:49.184
We're at this transition, this pivotal time in social media, in the world right now, that Blake and Amber were sort of just the first and people didn't understand what the bot campaigns were.

616
00:42:49.224 --> 00:42:50.425
They didn't even know that was a thing yet.

617
00:42:50.665 --> 00:42:59.010
So I hope that people are able to look back and be like, okay, just because I might have got something wrong doesn't mean that I'm a bad person or done the wrong thing.

618
00:42:59.090 --> 00:43:00.591
It's just we're all part of it.

619
00:43:00.651 --> 00:43:01.791
It's a bot campaign.

620
00:43:01.871 --> 00:43:02.972
We've never seen that before.

621
00:43:03.292 --> 00:43:06.833
I think we are – and I actually – I don't want to be overly critical.

622
00:43:06.873 --> 00:43:10.354
Look, if I sit back – and I used to say this about Julian Assange.

623
00:43:10.494 --> 00:43:16.296
People had certain views about Julian Assange and I would sit back and say, look, I'm happy to sit and talk to you about it.

624
00:43:16.376 --> 00:43:24.319
But if I wasn't at the centre of it and I was sitting back and just consuming the media coverage about Julian Assange, I might share your views too.

625
00:43:24.959 --> 00:43:29.601
Because the media coverage has been so filled with government propaganda and really negative about him.

626
00:43:30.162 --> 00:43:31.902
So, of course, you're going to be affected by that.

627
00:43:32.463 --> 00:43:44.128
But this is where media literacy comes in and people educating themselves that perhaps the narrative they're getting about a particular person in the media or online may not be the truth.

628
00:43:45.029 --> 00:43:47.090
And looking for alternative sources...

629
00:43:47.590 --> 00:43:56.528
But I think we also need to, I think government also needs to have a good look at how the online space and the algorithms are being...

630
00:43:58.068 --> 00:44:08.638
manipulated and used to push particular narratives, particularly to young boys in our society, including the misogynistic content about Amber Heard and the Johnny Depp trial.

631
00:44:08.798 --> 00:44:08.978
Yeah.

632
00:44:09.098 --> 00:44:10.379
That was part of this problem.

633
00:44:11.300 --> 00:44:23.492
And the impact that's having on young boys and young girls in our society and what it will mean in the future about equality for this country, about violence against women in this country is really scary.

634
00:44:23.512 --> 00:44:23.652
Yeah.

635
00:44:24.112 --> 00:44:26.973
I don't blame those young boys who are being affected by this.

636
00:44:27.353 --> 00:44:30.454
I blame us, all of us collectively.

637
00:44:30.594 --> 00:44:31.875
I blame the platforms.

638
00:44:32.395 --> 00:44:34.276
I blame the people propagating this material.

639
00:44:34.796 --> 00:44:37.777
I blame the platforms and I blame our policymakers.

640
00:44:37.797 --> 00:44:48.741
I suppose my other question is, when we have moments like this online that take over and dominate the space and dominate public opinion, how does it impact their right to a fair trial?

641
00:44:49.446 --> 00:44:51.528
Look, in front of a judge, I don't think it does.

642
00:44:51.948 --> 00:44:57.492
Our judges are trained to ignore what's happening in the public space and objectively assess the evidence before them.

643
00:44:57.872 --> 00:45:01.555
I think when you're in front of a jury, it's a very different prospect.

644
00:45:03.056 --> 00:45:11.182
So I do think that the online space had a material effect on the outcome that that jury came to, the verdict they came to.

645
00:45:11.222 --> 00:45:12.023
That's my opinion.

646
00:45:12.043 --> 00:45:12.603
Yeah.

647
00:45:12.963 --> 00:45:16.788
I also just think the verdict was the jurors got the law wrong.

648
00:45:17.489 --> 00:45:18.550
They didn't understand the law.

649
00:45:19.311 --> 00:45:24.737
They were swayed by the male-centric myths and tropes that Johnny Depp's team were deliberately using.

650
00:45:26.058 --> 00:45:31.083
Basically, I mean, they said things like this is portrayed as a Me Too case, which it's not, by the way.

651
00:45:32.245 --> 00:45:33.926
What happened to Amber happened before Me Too.

652
00:45:34.026 --> 00:45:36.349
So Me Too has nothing to do with what happened to her.

653
00:45:37.510 --> 00:45:43.296
It's only post the Me Too movement people actually started to care that he had been violent towards her.

654
00:45:44.357 --> 00:45:48.321
He was still getting, that was the whole, the whole point was no one cared.

655
00:45:48.441 --> 00:45:49.362
There was no repercussion.

656
00:45:49.402 --> 00:45:51.304
They were still casting him in films.

657
00:45:51.925 --> 00:45:54.607
And suddenly after the Me Too movement, she did not speak out.

658
00:45:54.687 --> 00:45:56.049
People started to go, hang on a second.

659
00:45:56.249 --> 00:45:59.392
Didn't he, didn't she get a domestic violence restraining order?

660
00:46:00.072 --> 00:46:01.253
And that started the whole thing.

661
00:46:01.694 --> 00:46:05.818
But they would say things in court like, oh, this is a Me Too case, but no one else has accused him.

662
00:46:08.100 --> 00:46:13.205
And so it's like, well, just because no one else is standing here accusing him doesn't mean he didn't do it.

663
00:46:13.285 --> 00:46:13.805
No, I know.

664
00:46:13.966 --> 00:46:15.367
But that plays to people.

665
00:46:15.387 --> 00:46:16.988
They're like, oh, well, he didn't do it to anyone else.

666
00:46:17.008 --> 00:46:18.590
So he mustn't have done it in this case.

667
00:46:20.129 --> 00:46:22.611
It doesn't seem to matter what the evidence is.

668
00:46:22.951 --> 00:46:27.935
Even with Blake Lively, she had some huge wins in her case, and yet it didn't seem to move the needle.

669
00:46:28.236 --> 00:46:42.607
If I'm even thinking like the Diddy trial, for example, like the amount of people online that were saying that Cassie, his ex-girlfriend, was a willing participant because she stayed is just a fundamental misunderstanding of how abuse and trauma works.

670
00:46:42.727 --> 00:46:43.268
It's the same.

671
00:46:43.388 --> 00:46:44.469
They said the same with Amber.

672
00:46:44.629 --> 00:46:45.429
Why did she stay?

673
00:46:45.950 --> 00:46:48.152
In Amber's case, she gave evidence in court saying...

674
00:46:48.832 --> 00:46:52.656
I loved him and I had grown up in a violent home where my mother stayed.

675
00:46:52.976 --> 00:46:55.278
So I was taught that you stuck it out.

676
00:46:56.119 --> 00:47:00.063
And also he was a drug addict and I was trying to help him get better.

677
00:47:00.143 --> 00:47:06.569
And I believe that if I could help him get better and stop abusing drugs and alcohol, that the violence would stop.

678
00:47:07.810 --> 00:47:09.252
And so she stayed to try to help him.

679
00:47:09.924 --> 00:47:12.267
But people are like, oh, she stayed, so it can't be true.

680
00:47:13.107 --> 00:47:17.692
But also, can you imagine you're Amber Heard and you're in love with Johnny Depp, who's one of the biggest celebrities in the world.

681
00:47:18.373 --> 00:47:20.055
It's not that easy to go to the police.

682
00:47:20.776 --> 00:47:25.080
If you make a decision to go to the police, you are starting a huge global controversy.

683
00:47:26.578 --> 00:47:29.941
The deterrence that sits around that.

684
00:47:29.961 --> 00:47:34.365
And also so many women, Amber included, didn't want to go to the police.

685
00:47:34.385 --> 00:47:39.429
They don't want their partner, whatever they've done to them, they don't want them to go to prison.

686
00:47:40.110 --> 00:47:40.330
No.

687
00:47:40.610 --> 00:47:42.512
And that is a very common...

688
00:47:42.972 --> 00:47:47.116
I hear that a lot from women who, you know, their partner was violent towards them.

689
00:47:47.136 --> 00:47:48.137
They've got kids together.

690
00:47:48.157 --> 00:47:49.798
They don't want to see their partner in prison.

691
00:47:49.838 --> 00:47:52.200
They don't want to deny their kids access to their dad.

692
00:47:52.741 --> 00:47:54.382
They just want to get out of the relationship.

693
00:47:54.977 --> 00:47:57.339
And so going to the police is not always the answer.

694
00:47:58.079 --> 00:48:03.484
We have to find alternative ways of managing this, and also there's the very real economic concern.

695
00:48:03.724 --> 00:48:04.444
Absolutely.

696
00:48:04.645 --> 00:48:08.528
For many women in this country, leaving is economically impossible.

697
00:48:08.868 --> 00:48:12.691
Our frontline services are overstretched beyond belief.

698
00:48:13.131 --> 00:48:23.559
I'm such a huge supporter of our refuge movement and women's shelters, not just because my grandmother worked there, but because we know they save lives.

699
00:48:23.659 --> 00:48:23.760
Yeah.

700
00:48:23.780 --> 00:48:23.940
Yeah.

701
00:48:24.420 --> 00:48:29.821
And we need to give them more money to give them more spaces to ensure that the women who need to leave can.

702
00:48:30.061 --> 00:48:30.301
Yeah.

703
00:48:30.601 --> 00:48:36.863
So I just think like people need to check their prejudices about these old male-centric myths about gender-based violence.

704
00:48:36.923 --> 00:48:38.423
If it's true, why didn't she go to the police?

705
00:48:38.443 --> 00:48:39.743
If it's true, why didn't she leave?

706
00:48:39.783 --> 00:48:40.564
Why did she stay?

707
00:48:41.224 --> 00:48:43.804
There are so many reasons why women stay.

708
00:48:44.564 --> 00:48:46.385
And it's often altruistic.

709
00:48:46.905 --> 00:48:49.448
for the kids, for him, to help him.

710
00:48:49.468 --> 00:48:55.334
It makes me so angry that people don't understand this and all won't.

711
00:48:55.815 --> 00:49:01.741
And so that's why I really hope lots of people see the film, to listen to these women's lived experiences.

712
00:49:02.422 --> 00:49:08.207
It did such a good job at humanising these names and these figures that we've heard a thousand times over.

713
00:49:08.828 --> 00:49:12.371
You know, even with Britney, when I was watching, I had forgotten that she was 24.

714
00:49:12.431 --> 00:49:12.791
Yeah.

715
00:49:13.592 --> 00:49:18.236
You know, like there were so many things in it that I went, wow, this is someone's name I've seen in the headlines and I've been reporting on.

716
00:49:18.256 --> 00:49:20.198
But there is that distance, I suppose.

717
00:49:20.799 --> 00:49:24.222
You know, you have a degree of separation when you're coming at it through just headlines.

718
00:49:24.242 --> 00:49:24.462
Yeah.

719
00:49:24.803 --> 00:49:30.046
Well, also, I think for me with Brittany too, there's just been so much noise in the media, right?

720
00:49:30.506 --> 00:49:31.607
What is it, five years now?

721
00:49:31.667 --> 00:49:33.388
Yeah, that you get fatigued with it.

722
00:49:33.408 --> 00:49:34.548
You get fatigued by it.

723
00:49:34.568 --> 00:49:42.033
You're just so overwhelmed by all the different aspects of the story, like the various legal processes, the judicial review, the criminal case, the...

724
00:49:42.733 --> 00:49:46.896
You know, the controversy around Parliament, the, you know, defamation proceedings.

725
00:49:47.537 --> 00:49:52.781
Ultimately, I think sometimes people forget she was a 24-year-old woman who was raped in Parliament.

726
00:49:53.261 --> 00:49:56.043
Can we not get back to that and what that means for her?

727
00:49:56.304 --> 00:49:56.584
I know.

728
00:49:56.904 --> 00:49:59.806
The number of articles in The Australian about Brittany Higgins is...

729
00:50:00.887 --> 00:50:02.188
It's diluted.

730
00:50:02.288 --> 00:50:04.871
I mean, it's so disproportionate.

731
00:50:05.091 --> 00:50:06.592
But that's exactly the tactic.

732
00:50:06.652 --> 00:50:18.083
If you kind of flood the space, whether it's in tabloid, whether it's in media, whether it's bot campaigns online, is you successfully create this perception that they're the controversial figure.

733
00:50:18.103 --> 00:50:18.343
Right.

734
00:50:18.843 --> 00:50:19.123
Right.

735
00:50:19.223 --> 00:50:28.589
And so that's why I also wanted to locate Brittany, not just have her tell her story and to put it all together in one space because people forget because so much has happened.

736
00:50:28.609 --> 00:50:36.895
So I wanted them to hear her voice and see the story put together in a short period, but also locate her in the context of the broader problem globally.

737
00:50:37.875 --> 00:50:46.801
What is really interesting and both interesting and scary to me is the commonalities between her cases and cases I see around the world, and I'll list them for you.

738
00:50:47.562 --> 00:50:50.284
A young woman who speaks out about her rape or sexual assault.

739
00:50:51.224 --> 00:50:56.888
Horrendous discussion of her in the media, filled with male-centric tropes about why she's a liar.

740
00:50:57.268 --> 00:51:04.914
Then legal proceedings, being caught up and tied up in legal proceedings, on and on, online media campaigns against them which are horrific.

741
00:51:04.934 --> 00:51:05.114
Horrific.

742
00:51:05.774 --> 00:51:12.476
To the point where the woman involved wants to take her own life and does try to take her own life or has to leave the country.

743
00:51:13.597 --> 00:51:15.237
All of that happened in Brittany's case.

744
00:51:15.677 --> 00:51:18.518
All of that happened in Shiora Ito's case in Japan.

745
00:51:19.119 --> 00:51:28.102
All of that is happening in at least three or four other cases I could list in different countries around the world, some of which I can speak about publicly, some of which I can't.

746
00:51:28.902 --> 00:51:31.943
So it is not just that this is Brittany Higgins.

747
00:51:33.164 --> 00:51:36.566
It is that her case is emblematic of a much bigger problem.

748
00:51:36.586 --> 00:51:37.566
So it's not just about her.

749
00:51:37.586 --> 00:51:45.430
There's nothing particular about her in many ways or what happened to her that is about her or the particular perpetrator.

750
00:51:46.070 --> 00:51:47.491
The same pattern plays out.

751
00:51:48.051 --> 00:51:56.415
And for the women involved, that's why, to your point about how powerful it was to see Amber and Brittany come together in this film, it was so important to me to get them together and,

752
00:51:57.615 --> 00:52:05.558
And it's kind of a miracle we managed it because no one else knows what it's like to be at the center of these things and these women.

753
00:52:06.538 --> 00:52:11.299
And even though I'm a lawyer who worked very closely with Amber, I've observed it and experienced it with her.

754
00:52:11.419 --> 00:52:13.440
I don't know what it's like to be the person at the center of it.

755
00:52:14.622 --> 00:52:17.823
And you did experience, like people came for you as well, right?

756
00:52:18.043 --> 00:52:18.824
Oh, absolutely.

757
00:52:19.064 --> 00:52:24.366
But as a lawyer, you know, I'm one step removed and I have broad shoulders.

758
00:52:24.406 --> 00:52:27.347
But yes, absolutely, they came for me, like death and rape threats.

759
00:52:28.388 --> 00:52:29.008
It's scary.

760
00:52:29.408 --> 00:52:38.532
Online campaigns about my personal life, about my professionalism, about, you know, what did or didn't happen in the case.

761
00:52:38.992 --> 00:52:39.972
It still goes on today.

762
00:52:40.012 --> 00:52:41.333
I just don't look at it anymore.

763
00:52:42.053 --> 00:52:43.554
There's so many crazy people on the internet.

764
00:52:44.234 --> 00:52:44.454
Yeah.

765
00:52:44.835 --> 00:53:05.529
And one of the things from our book is that women say to me here in Australia when they read it and give me their reaction all around the world is how validating it is for them to understand that it wasn't just them, that they weren't going crazy, that it wasn't just their experiences, that this is actually part of a broader cultural and legal cultural problem.

766
00:53:05.789 --> 00:53:11.873
I think we're in a really scary time that just even the reputation of someone being litigious is enough to shut down newsrooms.

767
00:53:12.173 --> 00:53:12.874
And that's...

768
00:53:14.518 --> 00:53:16.600
That's not going to bode well for democracy.

769
00:53:16.840 --> 00:53:20.643
I hear that all the time of people that I need to avoid talking about and things like that.

770
00:53:20.823 --> 00:53:21.564
No, of course.

771
00:53:21.644 --> 00:53:30.411
But you know this, as a journalist, if someone is known to be wealthy and litigious and you are going to do a story about them, there's caution.

772
00:53:31.192 --> 00:53:31.552
Totally.

773
00:53:31.913 --> 00:53:33.494
There is a decision in that newsroom.

774
00:53:33.754 --> 00:53:35.316
Are we willing to take this risk?

775
00:53:35.696 --> 00:53:38.598
Are we willing to risk our legal budget on this?

776
00:53:39.459 --> 00:53:40.259
Can we fight it?

777
00:53:40.440 --> 00:53:41.700
Can we prove this in court?

778
00:53:42.161 --> 00:53:51.586
These are the conversations that the public doesn't understand we have as journalists and as lawyers for journalists when you're weighing up whether to publish a story.

779
00:53:52.266 --> 00:53:58.870
So the stories that end up in the public domain are just, you know, a small fraction of the stories that actually could be reported.

780
00:53:58.930 --> 00:54:00.230
Journalists know so much more.

781
00:54:00.991 --> 00:54:03.172
And the reason for that is the law.

782
00:54:03.212 --> 00:54:04.353
Like, look, we've just seen

783
00:54:05.673 --> 00:54:19.138
And I've got to be careful about the way I talk about it, but we've just seen there's been a suppression order recently about text messages about high profile sportsmen talking in derogatory ways about violence against women that the ABC wanted to report upon.

784
00:54:19.198 --> 00:54:28.442
And as a result of legal action taken by them and they can't be named because of the suppression order, it's a public fact that the suppression order exists to stop the publication of the.

785
00:54:29.102 --> 00:54:55.957
text messages of high-profile footballers, male footballers talking derogatory in ways about violence against women, which in this context where we're talking about the culture in our, for example, AFL, around what's happened with the Sydney Swans, the question of the culture in male professional sports in this country is right at the forefront of our discussion right now and there's a suppression order preventing us from being able to see

786
00:54:57.438 --> 00:54:58.279
Who is this protecting?

787
00:54:58.499 --> 00:55:00.320
Who is this protecting and why?

788
00:55:00.340 --> 00:55:02.162
Yeah.

789
00:55:02.462 --> 00:55:08.807
I care about free speech from a much bigger perspective, which is not just about violence against women, it's about what that means for our democracy.

790
00:55:09.768 --> 00:55:22.278
But in the context of a national emergency on violence against women, in the context of massive real concerns about culture and rape culture in our professional sports, in our private boys' schools...

791
00:55:23.825 --> 00:55:31.449
that you've got these reputation management tools silencing, using the law to silence discussion of these stories, I think is really problematic.

792
00:55:32.550 --> 00:55:39.113
To me, if we can't talk about violence against women and we can't call these people out for their conduct, how are we ever going to change it?

793
00:55:39.647 --> 00:55:40.328
Well, exactly.

794
00:55:40.388 --> 00:55:42.629
And that's why we haven't seen the stats change.

795
00:55:43.070 --> 00:55:46.332
And so much of that is because we can't speak freely.

796
00:55:46.432 --> 00:55:50.075
And that's like the most powerful tool we have as women is to be able to keep talking to each other.

797
00:55:50.315 --> 00:55:53.778
But I'm just so grateful for the work that you do and that you continue to do.

798
00:55:54.538 --> 00:55:56.500
And I couldn't recommend this film

799
00:55:56.990 --> 00:55:58.331
any more than I have.

800
00:55:58.351 --> 00:56:00.392
I think every woman should watch it.

801
00:56:00.592 --> 00:56:01.733
Every man should watch it.

802
00:56:02.774 --> 00:56:03.094
Amen.

803
00:56:03.394 --> 00:56:08.058
But thank you so much for coming on this show and for speaking at length with me about this.

804
00:56:08.278 --> 00:56:09.679
It's been just an honour to have you on.

805
00:56:10.239 --> 00:56:12.280
Oh, thank you for such a thoughtful conversation.

806
00:56:12.320 --> 00:56:15.783
And I really hope that the film helps journalists like you as well.

807
00:56:15.803 --> 00:56:23.968
And that's part of my aim, that we help women and men who want to speak out about their abuse and make it easier for journalists like you to be able to report on it.

808
00:56:24.048 --> 00:56:24.989
So thank you for your work.

809
00:56:25.189 --> 00:56:26.090
Thank you for coming on.
