WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.111 --> 00:00:00.911
Hello, Internet.

2
00:00:00.931 --> 00:00:08.654
This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.

3
00:00:08.694 --> 00:00:13.395
We have three great stories lined up for you today, along with the rundown.

4
00:00:13.696 --> 00:00:22.058
We're going to hit astrophysics, genomics, ancient mathematics, couple of housekeeping items at the top of the show.

5
00:00:22.779 --> 00:00:24.959
Our new collaboration episode with

6
00:00:30.081 --> 00:00:32.403
The episode is focused on the future of intelligence.

7
00:00:32.443 --> 00:00:33.403
It's part one of two.

8
00:00:33.423 --> 00:00:35.244
It's a great conversation.

9
00:00:35.665 --> 00:00:36.845
Definitely worth a watch.

10
00:00:37.226 --> 00:00:46.171
And at the end of this story, we're going to do a follow-up from episode 22 as it relates to the Cloud 9 story that we covered, the gas cloud.

11
00:00:46.271 --> 00:00:46.531
Yeah.

12
00:00:46.551 --> 00:00:53.896
Because we got some interesting insight about the naming conventions and some of the background from the scientists who put the paper out.

13
00:00:53.936 --> 00:00:55.117
Yeah, that was really cool.

14
00:00:55.558 --> 00:01:02.484
We sent out the video to the scientists, the authors of that study, and they were gracious enough to give us some of the backstory.

15
00:01:02.664 --> 00:01:03.925
So it's really interesting.

16
00:01:05.167 --> 00:01:10.732
As always, you're going to learn something today because this is from First Principles.

17
00:01:25.388 --> 00:01:44.400
For our first story, we're going to dive into the James Webb Space Telescope in an astrophysics story that was a research paper published in Nature about the little red dots as young, supermassive black holes in dense ionized cocoons.

18
00:01:44.440 --> 00:01:49.983
This is a paper out of the University of Manchester, University of Copenhagen, and the Cosmic Cove.

19
00:01:50.323 --> 00:01:51.664
Dawn Center.

20
00:01:52.065 --> 00:02:07.558
And it's a nature study that reveals that these young supermassive black holes are hiding in dense cosmic cocoons that we were able to sort of get more insight from because of this high fidelity, high quality JWST spectra.

21
00:02:07.738 --> 00:02:07.959
Yeah.

22
00:02:07.979 --> 00:02:09.180
So what's this story all about?

23
00:02:09.200 --> 00:02:09.340
Yeah.

24
00:02:09.860 --> 00:02:14.642
Yeah, so I don't know if you remember, but back in July 2022, JWST came online.

25
00:02:15.102 --> 00:02:17.283
I was traveling in Europe, and it was a whole frenzy.

26
00:02:17.423 --> 00:02:28.587
And within two weeks of when the data was released, we had headlines like this from the Scientific American that said, the first glimpses of early galaxies could break cosmology.

27
00:02:29.047 --> 00:02:32.188
You know, JWST was seeing universe breakers.

28
00:02:32.788 --> 00:02:33.989
And it was like...

29
00:02:34.809 --> 00:02:39.191
All of astrophysics was, you know, oh my God, what's going to happen?

30
00:02:39.251 --> 00:02:40.271
What's going to happen?

31
00:02:40.671 --> 00:02:45.813
And what it was all about was there were these spots of red light everywhere at really high red shifts.

32
00:02:46.794 --> 00:02:49.695
And if they're really far away, that means that they're really old.

33
00:02:49.795 --> 00:02:52.996
But that also means that they're very young for the universe, right?

34
00:02:53.276 --> 00:02:58.098
Because the universe was only less than a billion years old and we were seeing galaxies.

35
00:02:58.298 --> 00:03:01.139
And in order to make galaxies, you need a lot of time, right?

36
00:03:01.440 --> 00:03:01.840
And so...

37
00:03:02.860 --> 00:03:11.891
Even there was like creationists that were like going gangbusters saying that, oh, this is proof of God created the universe and all of that stuff.

38
00:03:12.752 --> 00:03:17.037
So the focus of our study is something called little red dots.

39
00:03:17.478 --> 00:03:19.019
And that is the technical term.

40
00:03:19.580 --> 00:03:20.140
Is it really?

41
00:03:20.360 --> 00:03:22.441
It is literally the technical term.

42
00:03:22.481 --> 00:03:27.004
These are little red dots in the JWST deep field surveys.

43
00:03:27.584 --> 00:03:33.086
And they're at a really high redshift, which means they're very young in terms of when the universe was born.

44
00:03:33.467 --> 00:03:37.869
So this is about a billion years, less than a billion years after the Big Bang.

45
00:03:38.489 --> 00:03:40.470
And the problem is they're really compact.

46
00:03:41.330 --> 00:03:44.692
And the debate is if these are star-filled galaxies...

47
00:03:45.575 --> 00:03:52.196
The galaxies shouldn't have had enough time to become galaxies.

48
00:03:52.256 --> 00:03:52.476
Right.

49
00:03:52.696 --> 00:03:52.997
Okay?

50
00:03:53.297 --> 00:04:01.118
Because it takes time to form stars and then from those stars to amass and become a clustered, gravitationally attracted object like a galaxy.

51
00:04:01.938 --> 00:04:10.220
And this idea is based off of our current cosmological models of how the early universe, the mechanics and the dynamics of the early universe.

52
00:04:10.240 --> 00:04:10.860
Yes, yes.

53
00:04:10.980 --> 00:04:15.122
Based on how much we know dark matter is there, how much we know dark energy is there.

54
00:04:15.602 --> 00:04:22.645
In the beginning, there was not a lot of dark energy because the universe was small and dark energy scales with how big the universe is.

55
00:04:23.025 --> 00:04:26.506
So in the beginning, there was really just a lot of dark energy.

56
00:04:26.946 --> 00:04:32.328
Sorry, there was a lot of dark matter and a lot of normal matter, but more dark matter than normal matter.

57
00:04:32.748 --> 00:04:33.849
And those...

58
00:04:34.709 --> 00:04:40.394
models of our universe tend to not have galaxies so young.

59
00:04:40.734 --> 00:04:40.915
Right.

60
00:04:41.155 --> 00:04:41.415
Okay.

61
00:04:41.835 --> 00:04:43.677
So these became these universe breakers.

62
00:04:43.757 --> 00:04:48.501
And then the debate was, okay, maybe they're not star filled galaxies, but maybe they're just weird, massive black holes.

63
00:04:48.942 --> 00:04:49.182
Okay.

64
00:04:49.262 --> 00:04:53.486
And you would think, okay, like maybe that's going to solve this universe breaking thing.

65
00:04:53.506 --> 00:04:53.866
Okay.

66
00:04:54.046 --> 00:04:59.752
No, it still doesn't because those black holes are, again, too big for how young the universe was.

67
00:04:59.932 --> 00:05:00.132
Right.

68
00:05:00.233 --> 00:05:03.976
So it was a real conundrum for a while, and this paper might have the answer.

69
00:05:04.057 --> 00:05:04.397
Okay.

70
00:05:04.457 --> 00:05:05.098
That's the idea.

71
00:05:05.218 --> 00:05:05.558
Beautiful.

72
00:05:05.618 --> 00:05:10.203
And so it's quite a big deal if it, you know, holds up to scientific scrutiny.

73
00:05:10.503 --> 00:05:15.889
Because it's both, it's going to solve this new problem that has arisen as we've gotten higher quality data that's giving us...

74
00:05:16.770 --> 00:05:23.840
experimentally in the real world information that doesn't quite map onto our existing models of the early universe.

75
00:05:23.921 --> 00:05:24.361
Exactly.

76
00:05:24.381 --> 00:05:30.470
And that's why, I mean, people were so excited when the James Webb Space Telescope went online.

77
00:05:30.510 --> 00:05:31.051
This is exactly what it is.

78
00:05:31.051 --> 00:05:36.417
Because we knew there was going to be all sorts of random stuff that we were going to see that we'd never seen before.

79
00:05:36.917 --> 00:05:39.420
And, you know, we're at the forefront of technology.

80
00:05:39.500 --> 00:05:42.403
It was launched in 2021, late 2021.

81
00:05:42.784 --> 00:05:46.208
It came online in July 2022.

82
00:05:46.828 --> 00:05:49.251
And these deep space fields were crucial.

83
00:05:49.671 --> 00:05:51.333
This is a photo of the James Webb.

84
00:05:51.413 --> 00:05:52.394
It was folded up.

85
00:05:53.288 --> 00:06:02.923
Incredible engineering feat, by the way, to even get such a scientific instrument to be folded up inside a rocket and then have it go to a Lagrange point.

86
00:06:02.943 --> 00:06:06.308
So not even in Earth orbit, really far away from Earth orbit.

87
00:06:07.553 --> 00:06:08.454
Get it parked there.

88
00:06:08.734 --> 00:06:10.615
Have it unfold like origami.

89
00:06:11.135 --> 00:06:12.036
No issues.

90
00:06:12.596 --> 00:06:16.919
And Biden made an announcement being like, we got this amazing data.

91
00:06:17.439 --> 00:06:22.502
And two weeks after that amazing data was published, everyone was like, what's going on?

92
00:06:22.522 --> 00:06:22.662
Right?

93
00:06:24.363 --> 00:06:29.049
So one of the crucial things about the James Webb Space Telescope is it is an infrared telescope.

94
00:06:29.249 --> 00:06:33.154
Unlike the Hubble, which is optical, the James Webb is an infrared telescope.

95
00:06:33.174 --> 00:06:40.784
And the reason why it is sensitive in infrared is because infrared is wavelengths of light that are longer than optical.

96
00:06:41.425 --> 00:06:43.147
And we want it to be that way because...

97
00:06:44.396 --> 00:06:49.779
We want to look at the very depths of the universe, okay, really, really far back.

98
00:06:50.439 --> 00:06:55.802
And because the universe is expanding, you have something called a gravitational red shift.

99
00:06:55.862 --> 00:06:58.564
Actually, no, it's called a cosmological red shift.

100
00:06:59.044 --> 00:07:03.247
What ends up happening is light that is coming from really far away...

101
00:07:04.027 --> 00:07:10.110
As the universe stretches, you can imagine a little sine wave, and then I stretch that sine wave like a spring.

102
00:07:10.550 --> 00:07:12.291
So the wavelength is going to stretch out.

103
00:07:12.952 --> 00:07:18.395
So if I'm in infrared, I can catch these highly red-shifted light.

104
00:07:19.075 --> 00:07:20.856
And that's exactly what we see in this photo.

105
00:07:21.196 --> 00:07:22.497
And we see as we get...

106
00:07:23.097 --> 00:07:37.382
farther and farther into the universe, closer and closer to the Big Bang, the spectra, these unique fingerprints where oxygen should be emitting light or where hydrogen should be emitting light, that stuff gets stretched more and more into the infrared.

107
00:07:37.402 --> 00:07:37.542
Mm-hmm.

108
00:07:38.551 --> 00:07:44.196
The James Webb being an infrared telescope means that we are sensitive to that infrared.

109
00:07:44.216 --> 00:07:44.516
Got it.

110
00:07:44.737 --> 00:07:45.017
Okay?

111
00:07:45.217 --> 00:07:45.397
Right.

112
00:07:45.617 --> 00:07:53.344
So we sort of have, instead of seeing a fuzzier image of things kind of blending, there's more discreteness in what we're looking at because it's...

113
00:07:54.265 --> 00:07:59.686
We're not limited to light has to travel and things are getting squished at these scales.

114
00:07:59.706 --> 00:08:00.066
Stretched.

115
00:08:00.226 --> 00:08:02.027
Sorry, stretched at these scales.

116
00:08:02.407 --> 00:08:07.008
And so we need to expand what we're looking at in order to capture just more clarity.

117
00:08:07.048 --> 00:08:07.288
Yes.

118
00:08:07.528 --> 00:08:08.788
And understanding what it is we're looking at.

119
00:08:08.808 --> 00:08:13.089
Yeah, we want to be sensitive to that correct part of the spectrum, right?

120
00:08:13.229 --> 00:08:13.609
That makes sense.

121
00:08:13.629 --> 00:08:15.729
And so that's where these little red dots come in.

122
00:08:15.769 --> 00:08:18.230
And they're literally called little red dots, okay?

123
00:08:18.250 --> 00:08:18.350
Yeah.

124
00:08:18.970 --> 00:08:26.515
Weird thing about them is they show up all over the place, about 600 million years to 800 million years after the Big Bang.

125
00:08:27.056 --> 00:08:31.119
But then they vanish out of existence 1.5 billion years after the Big Bang.

126
00:08:31.479 --> 00:08:32.540
And we don't see any of them.

127
00:08:33.459 --> 00:08:40.406
It's kind of like dinosaurs where dinosaurs were alive for 300 million years to 65 million years before us.

128
00:08:40.866 --> 00:08:41.727
And then they're just gone.

129
00:08:42.148 --> 00:08:50.776
So these little red dots are like dinosaurs from the early universe that are no longer there in any nearby galaxies.

130
00:08:50.796 --> 00:08:51.737
So it's very weird.

131
00:08:51.797 --> 00:08:52.037
Yes.

132
00:08:52.077 --> 00:08:52.258
Right?

133
00:08:52.278 --> 00:08:52.718
Right.

134
00:08:52.798 --> 00:08:53.559
That is curious.

135
00:08:53.579 --> 00:08:55.660
The other thing about them is they're really small.

136
00:08:56.121 --> 00:08:56.361
Okay?

137
00:08:56.381 --> 00:08:57.442
They're really, really small.

138
00:08:57.902 --> 00:09:02.666
If you look on the right-hand side, on the left-hand side, we've got one of the JWST deep fields.

139
00:09:02.706 --> 00:09:05.728
And on the right-hand side, we have a close-up of one of these red dots.

140
00:09:06.068 --> 00:09:11.712
And if you look really closely, that red dot has a sort of hexagonal hue around it.

141
00:09:12.173 --> 00:09:18.498
That hexagonal hue is an artifact of the James Webb Space Telescope's design because the

142
00:09:19.118 --> 00:09:26.860
The James Webb has a primary mirror and then a secondary mirror that sort of the light comes in primary, goes to the secondary, and then goes to the detector.

143
00:09:27.381 --> 00:09:34.983
And the scaffolding that is holding up that secondary mirror has three sort of...

144
00:09:36.503 --> 00:10:01.361
rods that hold it holds it up so those rods are going to cause something called diffraction spikes okay they're just artifacts of the fact that the secondary mirror has these three rods holding it up in the hubble there's four and so you see for the hubble hubble photographs the diffraction spikes are yeah right in diamond shape but in the james webb they'll be in hexagonal shape makes sense okay so

145
00:10:02.461 --> 00:10:08.103
But the fact that we're seeing those diffraction spikes for those little red dots means that they're localized point sources.

146
00:10:08.463 --> 00:10:13.145
And we can actually calculate how big they are, and they'd be about 150 to 500 light years across.

147
00:10:13.706 --> 00:10:15.806
That's light years across.

148
00:10:15.826 --> 00:10:16.447
Light years.

149
00:10:16.687 --> 00:10:16.927
Right?

150
00:10:17.387 --> 00:10:20.668
The Milky Way is on the order of 100,000 light years.

151
00:10:21.208 --> 00:10:21.469
Okay.

152
00:10:21.549 --> 00:10:21.789
Okay?

153
00:10:22.189 --> 00:10:26.130
The Milky Way is much bigger than these things by a factor of 100 to 1,000.

154
00:10:26.150 --> 00:10:26.351
Okay.

155
00:10:26.371 --> 00:10:26.471
Okay.

156
00:10:27.631 --> 00:10:29.772
So perhaps they are just like black holes.

157
00:10:29.852 --> 00:10:32.112
This is the first clue that maybe they're black holes.

158
00:10:32.492 --> 00:10:35.153
They're really compact objects, right?

159
00:10:35.193 --> 00:10:37.133
They have a lot of activity and a lot of mass.

160
00:10:37.153 --> 00:10:39.134
So, yeah, seems like a black hole.

161
00:10:39.154 --> 00:10:39.514
It tracks.

162
00:10:39.794 --> 00:10:44.235
Okay, so if it's a black hole, we'd like to calculate its size.

163
00:10:44.915 --> 00:10:45.075
Right.

164
00:10:45.375 --> 00:10:47.416
Okay, how do we calculate a black hole size?

165
00:10:47.436 --> 00:10:52.437
Well, in the Milky Way, the way we calculated the black hole size is we had Andrea Ghez from UCLA.

166
00:10:58.486 --> 00:11:18.426
path of stars that were nearby and then you just do newton's laws right and you figure out how big is the compact object on the inside now if we've got a black hole that is at the edge of the universe 13 billion light years away how are we going to do it well we use something called the doppler broadening of spectral lines okay so

167
00:11:19.330 --> 00:11:20.831
Effectively, what's happening is this.

168
00:11:21.392 --> 00:11:27.717
We look at a certain spectra, let's say H-alpha, which is an intrinsic piece of light that comes out of hydrogen.

169
00:11:28.938 --> 00:11:33.381
Now, if the hydrogen is not moving at all and it's static, that line is going to be really sharp.

170
00:11:34.082 --> 00:11:37.865
But in a black hole, there's going to be stuff moving around in an accretion disk.

171
00:11:38.185 --> 00:11:38.385
Right.

172
00:11:38.705 --> 00:11:41.266
So there's going to be hydrogen that's moving away from us.

173
00:11:41.486 --> 00:11:41.666
Yes.

174
00:11:41.726 --> 00:11:43.846
And hydrogen that move that's moving towards us.

175
00:11:43.906 --> 00:11:44.126
Yes.

176
00:11:44.306 --> 00:11:48.707
So there's going to be some bits of H alpha, the light that is going to be blue shifted.

177
00:11:49.067 --> 00:11:50.407
So the wavelength will be shorter.

178
00:11:50.827 --> 00:11:55.728
And then there's going to be some bits that are red shifted because it's moving away and the wavelength is going to be longer.

179
00:11:56.148 --> 00:12:01.949
And what's that going to what that's going to cause is my H alpha line, which used to be just a really well defined frequency.

180
00:12:02.249 --> 00:12:03.229
It's going to broaden.

181
00:12:03.489 --> 00:12:03.849
I see.

182
00:12:03.869 --> 00:12:04.049
Right.

183
00:12:04.109 --> 00:12:05.730
And that's called Doppler broadening.

184
00:12:05.810 --> 00:12:06.850
This is what we're seeing here.

185
00:12:06.870 --> 00:12:06.970
Yeah.

186
00:12:07.130 --> 00:12:08.191
And that's what we're seeing here.

187
00:12:08.231 --> 00:12:11.573
We get a nice Gaussian profile of our spectral line.

188
00:12:11.873 --> 00:12:21.039
And that Gaussian profile from there, we can then back calculate how fast does the gas need to be moving around to create that broadening.

189
00:12:21.219 --> 00:12:21.439
Right.

190
00:12:21.759 --> 00:12:25.182
And then you can apply the Virial Theorem, which is something in basic physics.

191
00:12:25.502 --> 00:12:27.923
The mass is proportional to the velocity squared.

192
00:12:28.324 --> 00:12:35.268
And from that, you get something like a number that is 10 to the 7 to 10 to the 9 times the mass of the sun.

193
00:12:35.368 --> 00:12:40.469
So it's like, you know, a billion to 100 million, tens of million times the mass of the sun.

194
00:12:40.529 --> 00:12:44.170
This is for something that is moving at 2,000 kilometers per second.

195
00:12:44.510 --> 00:12:47.810
That's what we can calculate back from the broadening is the velocity.

196
00:12:47.830 --> 00:12:50.891
And from the velocity, we calculate back the mass.

197
00:12:51.311 --> 00:12:51.591
Got it.

198
00:12:51.771 --> 00:12:52.011
Okay.

199
00:12:52.371 --> 00:12:56.892
So we're getting 10 to the 7 times or 10 to the 9 mass of the sun.

200
00:12:57.192 --> 00:12:58.412
As the scale of these.

201
00:12:59.072 --> 00:13:00.692
Of how big these black holes should be.

202
00:13:00.752 --> 00:13:01.112
Should be.

203
00:13:01.613 --> 00:13:01.813
Right.

204
00:13:01.953 --> 00:13:03.273
How big they should be.

205
00:13:03.473 --> 00:13:03.733
Okay.

206
00:13:04.193 --> 00:13:05.976
So you would think that, okay, we're good, right?

207
00:13:06.076 --> 00:13:07.138
Like, they're not galaxies.

208
00:13:07.158 --> 00:13:08.059
They're just black holes.

209
00:13:09.582 --> 00:13:10.623
Not so fast.

210
00:13:10.944 --> 00:13:11.264
Okay.

211
00:13:11.925 --> 00:13:13.828
There's two problems with these masses.

212
00:13:14.730 --> 00:13:17.814
For one thing, these black holes are way too big for...

213
00:13:19.145 --> 00:13:21.526
whatever galaxy this little red dot is.

214
00:13:21.826 --> 00:13:36.450
If this little red dot is a galaxy and at the center is this active galactic nuclei that's, you know, churning up a bunch of mass and then spewing it out as radiation, then those black holes are about 10 to 100 percent the host stellar mass.

215
00:13:37.271 --> 00:13:37.531
Okay?

216
00:13:38.171 --> 00:13:41.012
In contrast, for our Milky Way, the center...

217
00:13:41.892 --> 00:14:04.262
of the galaxy where the black hole is that black hole is only 0.1 percent of the entire mass of the milky way so this is the math is not math the math is not mathing okay sagittarius a star at the center of our milky way is only 0.1 percent of the total mass of the milky way and here i'm getting 10 to 100 the total mass like the whole thing is a black hole they're way too massive yeah

218
00:14:05.162 --> 00:14:05.943
It doesn't make any sense.

219
00:14:05.983 --> 00:14:06.403
Okay.

220
00:14:06.543 --> 00:14:06.843
Okay.

221
00:14:06.883 --> 00:14:07.063
Yeah.

222
00:14:07.503 --> 00:14:13.506
The second thing is, okay, so you're telling me that these black holes are 100 million times the mass of the sun, right?

223
00:14:14.087 --> 00:14:15.287
How did it get that big?

224
00:14:15.807 --> 00:14:19.929
Well, the way that black holes get big is through accretion, right?

225
00:14:19.989 --> 00:14:23.511
It's like taking in mass and it's eating up mass.

226
00:14:23.891 --> 00:14:26.553
And as it eats up all this matter, it gets bigger and bigger.

227
00:14:27.358 --> 00:14:28.539
There's a caveat to it, though.

228
00:14:28.899 --> 00:14:29.139
Okay?

229
00:14:29.399 --> 00:14:31.380
It can't just, like, eat endlessly.

230
00:14:31.580 --> 00:14:34.601
It's not like those video games where you just eat the whole city around you.

231
00:14:34.661 --> 00:14:38.083
Yeah, in like a single moment, you can't do that.

232
00:14:38.563 --> 00:14:40.864
You've got to take your time with your meal.

233
00:14:41.164 --> 00:14:41.705
That's the point.

234
00:14:41.925 --> 00:14:44.066
There's something called the Eddington Limit, okay?

235
00:14:44.446 --> 00:14:48.028
And it says there's a maximum luminosity to accretion rate.

236
00:14:48.808 --> 00:14:55.251
Before I'm eating too much, and when I eat all that much, I'm going to spew out radiation.

237
00:14:55.611 --> 00:14:59.653
That radiation is going to shock all of the rest of my food away.

238
00:15:00.213 --> 00:15:01.314
You see what I'm saying?

239
00:15:01.414 --> 00:15:07.076
It's the same argument of hydrostatic equilibrium that we've been visiting a lot on this podcast.

240
00:15:07.196 --> 00:15:10.818
The idea is if I eat too fast...

241
00:15:11.729 --> 00:15:19.896
Then the radiation from all of that eating, because the black hole is going to accrete all this mass, the mass is going to start heating up.

242
00:15:19.957 --> 00:15:21.298
That's going to cause radiation.

243
00:15:21.338 --> 00:15:25.922
That radiation is going to be enough to shoo all of the rest of my mass away.

244
00:15:26.282 --> 00:15:29.305
So there's a maximum limit at which I can grow.

245
00:15:29.685 --> 00:15:31.307
3,000 calories a day max.

246
00:15:31.507 --> 00:15:32.547
Max, right?

247
00:15:32.607 --> 00:15:34.748
And if you do too much, then there's no food around you.

248
00:15:34.768 --> 00:15:35.188
Right, right.

249
00:15:35.348 --> 00:15:36.288
Okay, that's the idea.

250
00:15:36.448 --> 00:15:37.449
Look, that's very interesting.

251
00:15:37.469 --> 00:15:39.269
Okay, so that's something called the Eddington Limit.

252
00:15:39.429 --> 00:15:45.291
It's named after Arthur Eddington, who's an amazing man of science in history.

253
00:15:45.411 --> 00:15:47.011
Also a bit problematic.

254
00:15:47.451 --> 00:15:48.752
And by a bit, I mean a lot.

255
00:15:49.632 --> 00:15:51.874
That's for another episode.

256
00:15:52.594 --> 00:15:57.298
In any case, he finds this sort of limit to how how much stars can grow.

257
00:15:57.798 --> 00:15:59.280
What's the luminosity of these stars?

258
00:15:59.440 --> 00:16:01.781
And you can apply that same logic to black holes.

259
00:16:01.982 --> 00:16:02.242
Got it.

260
00:16:02.622 --> 00:16:05.925
OK, so from that, we get an accretion rate.

261
00:16:06.125 --> 00:16:07.446
It's like, how much am I eating?

262
00:16:07.666 --> 00:16:07.826
Yes.

263
00:16:08.226 --> 00:16:11.029
And from that, I can have a characteristic growth timescale.

264
00:16:11.709 --> 00:16:37.964
of like how how much time do i need to grow by a certain factor because you know what your limit on eating is and so you'll know if i'm trying to gain 10 pounds or lose 10 pounds yeah how long is that going to take right because you're let you have a max yeah and and for this by a factor of e because everything is an exponential exponential to the e so if i want to grow by a factor of e which is like 2.7 ish i need to wait 50 million years yeah all right sure 50 million years to

265
00:16:41.957 --> 00:16:42.197
All right.

266
00:16:42.877 --> 00:16:51.519
Now, these red dots that we see in the universe, they're at a red shift of seven, which means they're approximately 800 million years after the Big Bang.

267
00:16:51.539 --> 00:16:54.000
800 million years is not a lot of time.

268
00:16:54.060 --> 00:16:54.260
No.

269
00:16:55.340 --> 00:17:00.261
Even especially for growing at only 50 million years per factor of 2.7.

270
00:17:00.561 --> 00:17:00.761
Right.

271
00:17:01.101 --> 00:17:01.401
OK.

272
00:17:01.622 --> 00:17:01.842
Right.

273
00:17:02.002 --> 00:17:03.202
So there's two possibilities.

274
00:17:04.277 --> 00:17:06.060
One is you've got these light seeds.

275
00:17:06.701 --> 00:17:08.584
Light as in like light instead of heavy.

276
00:17:09.265 --> 00:17:09.545
Okay.

277
00:17:09.785 --> 00:17:10.947
You have the first stars.

278
00:17:11.007 --> 00:17:12.570
These are population three stars.

279
00:17:12.630 --> 00:17:13.771
They're the remnants of...

280
00:17:14.660 --> 00:17:23.883
the very first stars, when the very first stars that are, you know, about, let's say a hundred mass, a hundred times the mass of the sun or a thousand times the mass of the sun, very, very old stars.

281
00:17:24.203 --> 00:17:26.324
When they blow up, they're going to make a black hole.

282
00:17:26.924 --> 00:17:29.685
And that black hole is going to be about a hundred times the mass of the sun.

283
00:17:30.485 --> 00:17:40.388
And so in order to reach 10 to the nine times the mass of the sun in 800 million years, you got to be continuously eating at the Eddington limit.

284
00:17:40.808 --> 00:17:41.168
I see.

285
00:17:41.228 --> 00:17:41.348
Okay.

286
00:17:41.368 --> 00:17:43.289
Stuffing your face, stuffing your face, uh,

287
00:17:44.069 --> 00:17:47.970
For like hundreds of millions of years.

288
00:17:47.990 --> 00:17:51.591
You got to be going like the hot dog eating competitions.

289
00:17:51.611 --> 00:17:52.591
Have you seen those?

290
00:17:52.631 --> 00:17:53.252
Kobayashi.

291
00:17:53.512 --> 00:17:55.252
Yeah, dude.

292
00:17:55.652 --> 00:17:59.934
So you got to be in the zone for hundreds of millions of years.

293
00:18:00.174 --> 00:18:00.674
Constantly.

294
00:18:00.714 --> 00:18:01.314
Constantly.

295
00:18:01.334 --> 00:18:01.614
Constantly.

296
00:18:02.466 --> 00:18:26.016
very improbable seems yeah seems improbable to just be going at it yes right okay so the second possibility is there's heavy seeds which is this direct collapse you don't make a star you just got a gas cloud the gas cloud maybe runs into another gas cloud reaches critical mass and then the whole thing just falls inside the schwarzludge radius you get a black hole no star needed for that

297
00:18:27.131 --> 00:18:32.252
The advantage is you can reach that high mass, 10 to the 9 mass of the sun.

298
00:18:33.533 --> 00:18:34.233
You can reach that.

299
00:18:34.913 --> 00:18:36.573
But the condition's got to be perfect.

300
00:18:36.893 --> 00:18:38.374
You got to have really pristine gas.

301
00:18:38.434 --> 00:18:40.534
It's got to be like sort of spherically symmetric.

302
00:18:41.154 --> 00:18:47.116
And you need a lot of UV background so that the gas doesn't cool down to form stars.

303
00:18:47.236 --> 00:18:47.456
Right.

304
00:18:47.476 --> 00:18:50.377
It has to like really just be focused on making a black hole.

305
00:18:50.517 --> 00:18:50.977
Which is...

306
00:18:51.997 --> 00:18:52.498
Improbable.

307
00:18:52.538 --> 00:18:53.098
Right, right.

308
00:18:53.519 --> 00:18:59.685
So the idea is the light seed and heavy seed options don't pass the sniff test.

309
00:18:59.765 --> 00:19:00.766
Yeah, they really don't.

310
00:19:00.826 --> 00:19:02.568
It's like both are like super improbable.

311
00:19:02.908 --> 00:19:06.792
On the one hand, you have like a black hole that is just eating max out.

312
00:19:07.493 --> 00:19:08.273
like in the zone.

313
00:19:08.633 --> 00:19:14.135
And then the second, the conditions to create that first black hole are like perfect.

314
00:19:14.575 --> 00:19:14.815
Okay.

315
00:19:15.095 --> 00:19:18.777
And the number of these little rod dots that we're seeing, it just doesn't make sense.

316
00:19:18.797 --> 00:19:19.337
There's too many.

317
00:19:19.437 --> 00:19:22.318
There's too many for all of them to have just this perfect, uh,

318
00:19:23.178 --> 00:19:45.099
like condition the idea is we're seeing so many of them so you're saying this thing that's improbable is happening like frequently yeah which is the whole point yeah so what are we doing all right so so this was the big conundrum right yes so what can we do well let's point an x-ray telescope at it so they had the chandra x-ray telescope pointed at it no x-rays that's weird okay black holes

319
00:19:45.980 --> 00:19:47.081
spew a lot of x-rays.

320
00:19:47.521 --> 00:19:47.802
Okay.

321
00:19:47.842 --> 00:19:53.806
Because stuff gets really hot, and if stuff gets really hot, it's going to, like, spew out very high-energy radiation.

322
00:19:54.147 --> 00:19:54.547
It also...

323
00:19:54.567 --> 00:19:55.828
There's no radio emissions.

324
00:19:56.128 --> 00:19:57.569
You look at... You look at it from...

325
00:19:58.641 --> 00:20:04.187
the earth with really nice radio telescopes that can localize that point source, no radio emissions.

326
00:20:04.528 --> 00:20:07.651
Black holes should have radio emissions because there's high magnetic fields.

327
00:20:07.972 --> 00:20:12.477
And if charged particles are spinning around in that high magnetic fields, it's going to shoot off.

328
00:20:12.597 --> 00:20:14.899
They're going to shoot off radio waves.

329
00:20:15.220 --> 00:20:17.062
So no x-rays, no radio waves.

330
00:20:17.162 --> 00:20:17.843
What do we have?

331
00:20:17.863 --> 00:20:18.203
What do we have?

332
00:20:18.303 --> 00:20:20.124
Well, let's look at the photo.

333
00:20:20.144 --> 00:20:20.644
What do we have?

334
00:20:20.905 --> 00:20:23.866
Well, the James Webb Space Telescope has a really nice spectrograph, right?

335
00:20:24.166 --> 00:20:30.110
So we can look at the photometric spectra, and this is from a particular little red dot called the cliff.

336
00:20:30.470 --> 00:20:31.050
The cliff.

337
00:20:31.431 --> 00:20:33.532
And the cliff, you can see the cliff, right?

338
00:20:33.592 --> 00:20:33.872
Yeah.

339
00:20:34.152 --> 00:20:38.215
So at shorter wavelengths, you've got a little bit of light coming through in the ultraviolet.

340
00:20:38.435 --> 00:20:38.635
Yeah.

341
00:20:38.795 --> 00:20:41.276
And then right at about 300 and, like, 380 degrees,

342
00:20:45.398 --> 00:20:48.885
nanometers, you get a really high spike.

343
00:20:48.986 --> 00:20:50.910
Everything that's over that 365 nanometers...

344
00:20:54.660 --> 00:20:56.161
You get a lot of light coming in.

345
00:20:56.481 --> 00:20:56.762
Yeah.

346
00:20:56.782 --> 00:20:56.942
Okay?

347
00:20:56.962 --> 00:20:59.043
So you get this, like, distinct V-shape.

348
00:20:59.264 --> 00:20:59.464
Yeah.

349
00:20:59.524 --> 00:21:03.267
This particular one is called the cliff because it's such a nice spectra.

350
00:21:03.407 --> 00:21:03.567
Yeah.

351
00:21:03.747 --> 00:21:03.967
Okay?

352
00:21:04.187 --> 00:21:14.896
So the question is, what would actually cause a spectra like this, where you've got a little bit of ultraviolet, but right at 365, there's nothing, almost nothing.

353
00:21:15.236 --> 00:21:19.920
And then for any wavelength longer than 365, you've got a lot of light coming through.

354
00:21:20.420 --> 00:21:29.182
Well, 365 nanometers, and this is in the rest frame, so they had to shift everything to suppose this thing wasn't moving away.

355
00:21:29.222 --> 00:21:33.262
Because in reality, that light is going to be somewhere in the infrared, right?

356
00:21:33.322 --> 00:21:34.183
Because it's moving away.

357
00:21:34.203 --> 00:21:36.443
But you can shift it back into the rest frame.

358
00:21:36.863 --> 00:21:39.284
And you can say, okay, at 365, there's nothing.

359
00:21:39.644 --> 00:21:46.145
And then anything higher than 365 nanometers, which means lower in energy because higher wavelength, lower energy.

360
00:21:48.494 --> 00:21:49.455
We're getting a lot of light.

361
00:21:49.475 --> 00:21:51.258
Let there be light at 365.

362
00:21:51.558 --> 00:21:55.464
So 365 nanometers is something called the Balmer limit.

363
00:21:55.764 --> 00:21:56.065
Okay.

364
00:21:56.766 --> 00:22:03.975
This is what happens because any piece of light that is higher energy than the 365 nanometer wavelength...

365
00:22:06.452 --> 00:22:07.753
it ionizes hydrogen.

366
00:22:08.373 --> 00:22:15.118
That photon has enough energy to kick out an electron if the electron is in the second shell of hydrogen.

367
00:22:15.499 --> 00:22:15.739
Okay?

368
00:22:16.319 --> 00:22:20.983
So any photon that is in lower energy, meaning longer wavelength,

369
00:22:21.643 --> 00:22:25.845
That's not going to be able to kick out that hydrogen, and it's not going to be able to ionize.

370
00:22:26.285 --> 00:22:32.948
And this is actually something that we see a lot in stellar atmospheres, because stellar atmospheres have a lot of ionized hydrogen.

371
00:22:33.369 --> 00:22:36.590
This is a blueprint of a blue supergiant spectrum.

372
00:22:37.110 --> 00:22:43.614
And there you can see, right at about that Balmer limit, you're going to get a massive discontinuity.

373
00:22:43.694 --> 00:22:44.534
Yes, absolutely.

374
00:22:44.694 --> 00:22:51.195
Where there's a bunch of stuff at a higher wavelength because those photons don't have enough energy to ionize hydrogen.

375
00:22:51.515 --> 00:22:58.137
But the stuff that's with a smaller wavelength, so higher energy, those things ionize hydrogen no problem.

376
00:22:58.197 --> 00:23:00.557
And the electron goes off and does whatever it wants to do.

377
00:23:01.037 --> 00:23:01.237
Right?

378
00:23:02.217 --> 00:23:03.318
So that's the key.

379
00:23:03.818 --> 00:23:10.679
The key here is that the ionized hydrogen around a star could be causing this.

380
00:23:11.697 --> 00:23:12.057
Okay.

381
00:23:12.217 --> 00:23:12.538
Okay?

382
00:23:12.558 --> 00:23:13.178
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

383
00:23:13.198 --> 00:23:26.446
So the key inside of this paper is to say, all right, suppose I were to take that ionized hydrogen idea and I were to put that ionized hydrogen envelope around a black hole.

384
00:23:26.546 --> 00:23:26.906
I see.

385
00:23:27.567 --> 00:23:28.467
What would that mean?

386
00:23:28.487 --> 00:23:29.128
What would that mean?

387
00:23:29.428 --> 00:23:29.708
Okay.

388
00:23:30.569 --> 00:23:32.390
And that's the key inside of this paper.

389
00:23:33.960 --> 00:23:44.485
It's funny because we've been talking about reionization and hydrogen in astrophysics, cosmology, and space in a couple of our previous episodes.

390
00:23:44.825 --> 00:23:50.408
So folks will have a good grounding for this conversation based on several of our past stories.

391
00:23:50.528 --> 00:23:51.048
Yeah.

392
00:23:51.248 --> 00:23:54.450
And this paper came out in, I think it was Nature.

393
00:23:54.590 --> 00:23:55.310
We have the...

394
00:23:55.350 --> 00:23:55.590
Yes.

395
00:23:55.670 --> 00:23:57.651
It was Nature, January 13th, 2026.

396
00:23:59.032 --> 00:23:59.252
Right.

397
00:23:59.492 --> 00:24:05.276
So very recently, and this is photo 13 just to show our folks what the paper looks like.

398
00:24:05.396 --> 00:24:10.278
Little red dots as young supermassive black holes in dense ionized cocoons.

399
00:24:10.318 --> 00:24:12.380
That's where the ionized cocoons comes in.

400
00:24:12.780 --> 00:24:17.542
It's an ionized cocoon of stuff around my black hole.

401
00:24:17.682 --> 00:24:19.884
And the key is that that hypothesis...

402
00:24:20.604 --> 00:24:24.468
then lays to rest all of the different conundrums that we've had.

403
00:24:24.629 --> 00:24:25.009
I see.

404
00:24:25.349 --> 00:24:25.630
Okay.

405
00:24:25.670 --> 00:24:25.990
I see.

406
00:24:26.010 --> 00:24:29.114
Like when we talked about earlier about it's overmassive.

407
00:24:29.154 --> 00:24:29.254
Yeah.

408
00:24:29.274 --> 00:24:30.195
And it's big.

409
00:24:30.295 --> 00:24:31.656
The thing is too big.

410
00:24:32.377 --> 00:24:33.458
The Eddington limit.

411
00:24:33.518 --> 00:24:36.662
So we can't accrete enough to like be able to get to that size.

412
00:24:37.002 --> 00:24:41.928
But the note here is that this, the ionized hydrogen is,

413
00:24:43.118 --> 00:24:57.119
envelope that's around it is what is making what we're measuring or seeing look the way it is and so perhaps these black holes aren't as big as we thought they were i see i see that's the idea okay okay okay so the

414
00:24:57.940 --> 00:25:03.023
The inside of the ionized gas cloud means we can now recalculate the mass of these black holes.

415
00:25:03.464 --> 00:25:10.889
Because the line broadening, before we thought the line broadening just had to do with the hydrogen spinning around the black hole.

416
00:25:11.269 --> 00:25:15.952
And then from that we calculate what the mass should be for it to spin around at that rate.

417
00:25:16.733 --> 00:25:16.973
Okay.

418
00:25:18.230 --> 00:25:32.481
Well, if there's ionized hydrogen, then what we're going to see is not the actual photons from the accretion disk, but we're going to see those photons get released, and then they're going to bounce around in the ionized hydrogen, because the ionized hydrogen is just plasma.

419
00:25:32.862 --> 00:25:38.226
And plasma means that light doesn't really have a free path to travel all the way to us.

420
00:25:38.907 --> 00:25:44.011
It's going from here to there, and so the photons undergo this random walk,

421
00:25:44.571 --> 00:25:48.032
of free electrons in a highly ionized environment.

422
00:25:48.372 --> 00:25:54.533
So you've got the black hole in the center, and it releases a Gaussian profile because of the accretion.

423
00:25:54.893 --> 00:26:05.755
But by the time it gets to us, by the time it gets to the James Webb, it's going to be bouncing around this hydrogen atom, then this electron, then this hydrogen, then this electron, electron, blah, blah, blah.

424
00:26:06.215 --> 00:26:08.816
And you're going to get this Thompson scattering.

425
00:26:09.797 --> 00:26:12.579
the free electrons are going to scatter around.

426
00:26:12.819 --> 00:26:13.059
Yes.

427
00:26:13.479 --> 00:26:13.740
Okay?

428
00:26:13.800 --> 00:26:13.960
Yes.

429
00:26:14.100 --> 00:26:21.284
And when that happens, the Gaussian profile is actually going to resemble more of an exponential decay on both sides.

430
00:26:22.305 --> 00:26:23.566
So the way to test this...

431
00:26:24.822 --> 00:26:34.275
And in physics and in science, really, a lot of times what it comes down to is can you get good enough data to discern one theory from another?

432
00:26:34.936 --> 00:26:41.365
So the two theories that are competing in this case are it's a Gaussian profile, so it's a bell curve, and the other one is it's a...

433
00:26:42.365 --> 00:26:43.226
Exponential decay.

434
00:26:43.246 --> 00:26:43.426
Yes.

435
00:26:44.086 --> 00:26:50.871
The James Webb telescope is giving us good enough data where we can discern between those two theories.

436
00:26:51.492 --> 00:26:55.575
And that's why it's so important to get really good data.

437
00:26:55.675 --> 00:26:57.837
Which means we have to build really great instruments.

438
00:26:57.877 --> 00:26:58.077
Yeah.

439
00:26:58.217 --> 00:27:01.839
And the James Webb is just a phenomenal instrument.

440
00:27:02.140 --> 00:27:04.622
And so here you can see from their paper, they...

441
00:27:05.482 --> 00:27:07.945
fit an exponential and then they fit a Gaussian.

442
00:27:08.665 --> 00:27:12.369
And the errors when it comes to fitting an exponential are basically zero.

443
00:27:12.389 --> 00:27:13.410
That's the teal color.

444
00:27:13.830 --> 00:27:16.513
And then if you look at the purple, there's plenty of error.

445
00:27:16.553 --> 00:27:16.793
Yeah.

446
00:27:17.214 --> 00:27:17.434
Yes.

447
00:27:17.474 --> 00:27:21.658
The exponential fits this profile a lot better.

448
00:27:21.698 --> 00:27:26.963
The model, the exponential model of the theory to explain why we're seeing this

449
00:27:28.325 --> 00:27:39.605
what we believe to be these black holes look the way they do, this ionization of hydrogen, which then ends up having this exponential decay on this planet.

450
00:27:40.066 --> 00:27:40.406
That...

451
00:27:41.533 --> 00:27:44.574
That we did theoretically on paper.

452
00:27:44.994 --> 00:27:45.414
Yeah.

453
00:27:45.474 --> 00:27:45.614
Yeah.

454
00:27:45.634 --> 00:27:51.015
We're like, okay, if there's a cocoon of hydrogen that's ionized, so a bunch of plasma that's like diffuse.

455
00:27:51.235 --> 00:27:51.435
Yes.

456
00:27:51.535 --> 00:27:52.255
What would it look like?

457
00:27:52.295 --> 00:27:53.676
Well, it would look like an exponential.

458
00:27:53.716 --> 00:27:54.856
So let's fit an exponential.

459
00:27:54.876 --> 00:28:00.597
And then we've got the experimental data of high fidelity from JWST that now it's like, oh yeah, that's exactly what we're seeing.

460
00:28:00.617 --> 00:28:01.397
That's exactly right.

461
00:28:01.437 --> 00:28:01.637
Yeah.

462
00:28:01.937 --> 00:28:05.498
And now instead of 2000 kilometers per second.

463
00:28:05.758 --> 00:28:05.958
Yes.

464
00:28:05.998 --> 00:28:07.619
That the accretion disk is going around.

465
00:28:07.679 --> 00:28:07.899
Yes.

466
00:28:08.419 --> 00:28:08.899
Instead...

467
00:28:09.943 --> 00:28:12.704
it's something like 300 kilometers per second.

468
00:28:13.244 --> 00:28:16.384
So actually, the accretion disk isn't moving all that fast.

469
00:28:16.704 --> 00:28:20.545
The broadening is happening because of the plasma that's all around.

470
00:28:20.565 --> 00:28:23.426
That's surrounding it, not the actual internal structure of the black hole.

471
00:28:23.506 --> 00:28:24.026
Exactly.

472
00:28:24.266 --> 00:28:34.208
So I guess the intuition is then that means the black holes are much smaller and much younger because they're not super massive and they're not going very, very quickly.

473
00:28:34.608 --> 00:28:37.109
That's all being sort of obfuscated by the amount of...

474
00:28:38.109 --> 00:28:55.293
plasma ionized hydrogen that's around this really young small black hole that's exactly right okay yeah and and so when you when you redo the estimate for the mass you get something like 10 to the 5 which is you know several orders of magnitude but below right what we had earlier right

475
00:28:55.553 --> 00:28:56.654
And now this makes sense.

476
00:28:56.694 --> 00:28:57.735
Yeah, now it fits.

477
00:28:57.875 --> 00:28:58.476
Now it fits.

478
00:28:58.516 --> 00:29:01.478
It's like now you can have that light seat of the population three stars.

479
00:29:01.818 --> 00:29:07.043
But this guy doesn't have to constantly eat like a hot dog contest for hundreds of millionaires.

480
00:29:07.063 --> 00:29:07.963
He can take breaks.

481
00:29:08.544 --> 00:29:13.268
He can go sub-Eddington limit, and he'll be fine.

482
00:29:13.508 --> 00:29:14.649
He'll make it to this far.

483
00:29:14.929 --> 00:29:15.169
You know?

484
00:29:16.290 --> 00:29:23.892
And given the volume of these that we're seeing, it then also matches the frequency of its appearance.

485
00:29:24.252 --> 00:29:25.312
This is probable now.

486
00:29:25.412 --> 00:29:26.352
Yes.

487
00:29:26.472 --> 00:29:29.333
And then now it kind of explains why there's so many of them.

488
00:29:29.633 --> 00:29:35.175
The missing X-rays also make sense because all of these X-rays are now going to get absorbed by the plasma.

489
00:29:35.235 --> 00:29:35.415
Right.

490
00:29:35.435 --> 00:29:36.795
So we don't see the X-rays.

491
00:29:36.955 --> 00:29:45.777
The red color makes sense because the cocoon absorbs the high energy light and then re-emits it in the lighter part of the spectrum, the redder part of the spectrum.

492
00:29:45.817 --> 00:29:46.938
I was going to ask earlier.

493
00:29:46.958 --> 00:29:51.660
I'm like, I thought black holes were like black holes of light, but I get the accretion disk and then stuff happens.

494
00:29:51.700 --> 00:29:52.521
I'm like, why is it?

495
00:29:52.881 --> 00:29:53.662
Why was it red?

496
00:29:53.682 --> 00:29:53.982
Yeah.

497
00:29:54.262 --> 00:29:54.882
Yeah.

498
00:29:54.902 --> 00:30:00.105
But it's just, I mean, the stuff around the black hole is so hot that it's releasing a bunch of light.

499
00:30:00.125 --> 00:30:00.446
Right.

500
00:30:00.506 --> 00:30:00.966
Which makes sense.

501
00:30:01.006 --> 00:30:03.788
And then it also explains the black hole mass problem because now...

502
00:30:04.728 --> 00:30:05.949
You don't need this accretion.

503
00:30:06.329 --> 00:30:13.273
And the host mass, you know, before we used to think, oh, this thing is like 10% to 100% of the host galaxy.

504
00:30:13.353 --> 00:30:14.634
As opposed to the 0.1 we see.

505
00:30:14.654 --> 00:30:15.074
Yeah, yeah.

506
00:30:15.154 --> 00:30:19.016
And now you can see the final figure in their paper is actually showing.

507
00:30:19.356 --> 00:30:19.897
So the...

508
00:30:21.953 --> 00:30:26.435
The gray circles are what it would be without their hypothesis.

509
00:30:27.015 --> 00:30:31.197
And you can see the mass is decreasing because they use this exponential fit.

510
00:30:31.237 --> 00:30:34.419
And they're saying, actually, these black holes are not that massive.

511
00:30:34.719 --> 00:30:36.500
And the blue line is what the theory says.

512
00:30:36.520 --> 00:30:37.180
Right.

513
00:30:37.260 --> 00:30:39.021
And it's like lining up very nicely.

514
00:30:39.041 --> 00:30:39.942
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

515
00:30:40.162 --> 00:30:40.342
Right?

516
00:30:40.602 --> 00:30:40.782
Yep.

517
00:30:41.162 --> 00:30:41.302
Yes.

518
00:30:41.342 --> 00:30:42.843
Now, there's caveats.

519
00:30:43.123 --> 00:30:45.044
They only analyzed 12 of these.

520
00:30:45.564 --> 00:30:48.005
And we've seen, you know, several hundred.

521
00:30:48.225 --> 00:30:48.486
Okay.

522
00:30:48.506 --> 00:30:51.027
So it could be that there's a bunch of different things.

523
00:30:51.047 --> 00:30:51.267
Okay.

524
00:30:52.228 --> 00:30:58.594
And it's not like a one answer fits all little red dots, right?

525
00:30:58.654 --> 00:31:01.617
Some of them could be young galaxies, and then there's always more questions.

526
00:31:02.078 --> 00:31:05.661
But this at least puts a lot of the black hole theories.

527
00:31:05.981 --> 00:31:06.202
Yes.

528
00:31:07.342 --> 00:31:07.943
To rest.

529
00:31:07.963 --> 00:31:08.383
To rest.

530
00:31:08.644 --> 00:31:10.546
Like, it's making sense now.

531
00:31:10.586 --> 00:31:10.766
Yes.

532
00:31:10.966 --> 00:31:11.247
Okay?

533
00:31:11.267 --> 00:31:11.988
The universe did...

534
00:31:12.488 --> 00:31:15.972
The Big Bang did start 13.6 billion years ago.

535
00:31:16.593 --> 00:31:21.199
And right after the Big Bang, within a billion years, there were black holes, but they weren't that big.

536
00:31:21.279 --> 00:31:21.779
It's fine.

537
00:31:21.799 --> 00:31:22.260
It's fine.

538
00:31:22.568 --> 00:31:26.753
But because there was so much gas around at the time, you could have these ionized cocoons.

539
00:31:27.093 --> 00:31:30.437
Nowadays, you can't because the gas is so sort of diffuse.

540
00:31:30.797 --> 00:31:32.659
Yeah, we have Pepto-Bismol now, so it's fine.

541
00:31:32.699 --> 00:31:33.180
Exactly.

542
00:31:33.200 --> 00:31:35.662
The universe is 13.6 billion years old.

543
00:31:36.083 --> 00:31:38.606
The universe needs some Pepto-Bismol, you know?

544
00:31:39.246 --> 00:31:40.628
But I thought that was really cool.

545
00:31:40.668 --> 00:31:41.969
Just the way that, you know...

546
00:31:42.890 --> 00:31:53.216
It's a recurring theme in astrophysics research, actually, that the closer you measure something, the better you can discern between two competing theories.

547
00:31:53.576 --> 00:31:53.776
Right.

548
00:31:53.937 --> 00:31:54.157
Right.

549
00:31:54.257 --> 00:31:54.417
Right.

550
00:31:54.817 --> 00:31:58.559
And, like, it goes all the way back to Kepler and Tycho Brahe.

551
00:31:58.579 --> 00:31:59.640
Tycho Brahe was this...

552
00:32:01.103 --> 00:32:09.808
really rich guy who had a very nice observatory, not with lenses and stuff, but an observatory to point out locations of planets.

553
00:32:10.268 --> 00:32:14.911
And he tracked the locations of planets to a really high degree of accuracy.

554
00:32:15.411 --> 00:32:22.535
And then Kepler, who was the mathematician, took that data and he was trying to fit Copernicus's model of circles.

555
00:32:23.096 --> 00:32:26.358
And he's like, the circles don't fit, but the ellipses do fit.

556
00:32:26.378 --> 00:32:27.018
Yeah.

557
00:32:27.178 --> 00:32:34.613
And the difference between the ellipse and the circle was really small because the orbits of the planets are basically circles.

558
00:32:34.673 --> 00:32:34.994
For sure.

559
00:32:35.094 --> 00:32:37.819
But they're more ellipses than they are circles, right?

560
00:32:37.839 --> 00:32:37.979
Yeah.

561
00:32:38.924 --> 00:32:42.005
But there's a very famous quote by Tycho Brahe.

562
00:32:42.025 --> 00:32:42.845
I'm going to paraphrase.

563
00:32:42.865 --> 00:32:47.706
He said that this error is too big for Tycho Brahe to make.

564
00:32:47.806 --> 00:32:48.026
Yeah.

565
00:32:48.566 --> 00:32:48.786
Yeah.

566
00:32:49.226 --> 00:32:49.466
Right?

567
00:32:49.646 --> 00:32:57.948
Like the error between the circle and the ellipse is big enough that I'm pretty sure Tycho Brahe's error bar is smaller than the difference between these theories.

568
00:32:58.008 --> 00:33:00.349
So I'm pretty sure these things are ellipses.

569
00:33:00.369 --> 00:33:00.469
Yeah.

570
00:33:01.489 --> 00:33:04.830
And then he came up with Kepler's three laws and then, you know, Newton ran with it.

571
00:33:05.450 --> 00:33:08.833
So it's an amazing like sort of it's the tradition holds true.

572
00:33:09.234 --> 00:33:12.777
The better data you get, the more you can discern between one or the other theory.

573
00:33:13.198 --> 00:33:18.403
This is why we need to continue to support and invest in frontier research.

574
00:33:19.415 --> 00:33:22.618
It's not necessarily tied to commercial impact.

575
00:33:22.658 --> 00:33:22.879
No.

576
00:33:23.479 --> 00:33:28.284
Because the better instruments will eventually somehow, someway, always is dual use.

577
00:33:28.465 --> 00:33:28.705
Yeah.

578
00:33:28.885 --> 00:33:30.507
It's always dual use.

579
00:33:30.547 --> 00:33:34.611
The better we understand the world around us, the better we can get all the conveniences we love every day.

580
00:33:34.751 --> 00:33:34.972
Yeah.

581
00:33:35.412 --> 00:33:36.313
And this is...

582
00:33:36.373 --> 00:33:39.817
I mean, it was just so cool that now we know that there were black holes...

583
00:33:41.748 --> 00:33:48.895
800 million, like an infant universe had just a bunch of black holes that were just going gangbusters.

584
00:33:49.256 --> 00:33:52.439
Yes, and then started spitting out and creating all of this.

585
00:33:52.539 --> 00:33:54.681
And again, we can see it.

586
00:33:54.701 --> 00:33:55.682
We can literally...

587
00:33:56.523 --> 00:34:18.242
See it now I still get so My mind still gets so weirded out By the idea that Because of the speed of light when we look far enough It's like looking in the past Oh dude it's still weird to me It's very hard for my brain It makes logical sense Yeah of course But then you're like Are you sure Yeah

588
00:34:20.548 --> 00:34:22.791
That's our astrophysics story of the day.

589
00:34:22.811 --> 00:34:27.156
I think we're almost averaging one per week at this point.

590
00:34:27.577 --> 00:34:28.458
Great story one.

591
00:34:29.963 --> 00:34:33.646
We're going to move now into the rundown before we get to story two.

592
00:34:33.666 --> 00:34:41.874
We can't cover every story happening in the frontiers of research labs, not only in the U.S., but across the globe.

593
00:34:42.175 --> 00:34:51.704
It's an incredible time, and it's really important that we kind of keep track of what's going on because these things are eventually going to impact our lives one way together.

594
00:34:51.864 --> 00:34:52.505
or another.

595
00:34:53.006 --> 00:34:54.668
And we're going to start the rundown.

596
00:34:54.708 --> 00:34:57.491
These are some fun stories this week covering a couple different areas.

597
00:34:58.032 --> 00:35:03.519
Our first story in the rundown is about a prehistoric wolf's gut.

598
00:35:03.940 --> 00:35:04.280
Yeah.

599
00:35:04.841 --> 00:35:07.244
Frozen in time and revealed now.

600
00:35:07.504 --> 00:35:09.586
An Ice Age giant.

601
00:35:09.626 --> 00:35:18.975
This is from the Center of Paleogenetics in Stockholm, Sweden and Stockholm University that was published in Genome Biology and Evolution.

602
00:35:19.355 --> 00:35:29.124
The summary here is that a wolf pup that died 14,000 years ago, close to when the woolly rhino went extinct.

603
00:35:29.144 --> 00:35:29.785
Went extinct.

604
00:35:29.885 --> 00:35:31.467
And there's some hair and stuff left.

605
00:35:31.987 --> 00:35:33.167
Yeah, that's still in the stomach.

606
00:35:33.188 --> 00:35:38.029
It's still in the gut, which means that the DNA apparently is well-preserved.

607
00:35:38.069 --> 00:35:44.972
Yeah, because apparently the wolf died pretty soon after having dinner, this wolf pup.

608
00:35:45.292 --> 00:35:48.093
And they don't think that it died from predation or something like that.

609
00:35:48.113 --> 00:35:50.834
They think a landslide just came and knocked its home.

610
00:35:51.314 --> 00:35:55.056
And so it had just had dinner, and then the wolf pup died along with its sister.

611
00:35:55.316 --> 00:35:56.977
And it was found right next to each other.

612
00:35:57.597 --> 00:36:00.118
And what's really cool is the...

613
00:36:00.958 --> 00:36:08.043
the hair and all of this biological material was actually intact in the gut of this wolf pup.

614
00:36:08.163 --> 00:36:16.510
So from there, we can do genetic sequencing and find the genetic remnants of this woolly rhino.

615
00:36:17.090 --> 00:36:25.937
And the key thing is, if the woolly rhino went out because the population dwindled, and there were not that many viable populations,

616
00:36:27.293 --> 00:36:52.678
individuals in the population then what you would expect is a lot of inbreeding and that would leave markers in the genomics but what they found was there was no evidence of inbreeding which means that there was a healthy population even as recent as 14 000 years ago and that's right around the time when all of them died off and that's also right around the time when the ice age ended right so it's probably due to climate change that

617
00:36:53.918 --> 00:36:59.483
This massive, massive species that used to roam Siberia and Canada is now gone.

618
00:36:59.603 --> 00:37:02.586
I didn't even know the woolly rhino was a thing.

619
00:37:02.626 --> 00:37:03.727
Yeah, it's pretty crazy.

620
00:37:03.767 --> 00:37:06.129
It's a rhino, but like... Like hair.

621
00:37:06.149 --> 00:37:06.709
With hair.

622
00:37:06.729 --> 00:37:09.512
I mean, it's a mammal, so it's got hair, but this has a lot of hair.

623
00:37:09.792 --> 00:37:11.974
Because it lives in the winter.

624
00:37:12.815 --> 00:37:13.916
I just found...

625
00:37:14.136 --> 00:37:15.497
This might be totally nonsense.

626
00:37:15.597 --> 00:37:15.777
Mm-hmm.

627
00:37:16.938 --> 00:37:41.681
a pig can become a wild boar if you leave it in the wild like like like what like there's it's it's about the environment that transitions them from being like a generic domesticated domesticated pig versus like what we think of as a wild boar like they're not necessarily different geni or oh really i this look someone in the comments please correct me if i'm wrong

628
00:37:42.121 --> 00:37:46.463
I saw it scrolling, and I was like, this makes... That's pretty crazy.

629
00:37:46.703 --> 00:37:49.724
That means that certain genes turn on and off based on environment.

630
00:37:49.744 --> 00:37:49.965
Right.

631
00:37:50.145 --> 00:37:50.385
Wow.

632
00:37:50.545 --> 00:37:52.566
Which, story for another day.

633
00:37:52.606 --> 00:37:53.246
Yeah.

634
00:37:53.326 --> 00:37:54.687
Number two in the rundown.

635
00:37:55.887 --> 00:38:01.670
And we're going to be doing a lot of this Artemis story because we're coming up on our return to the moon.

636
00:38:01.970 --> 00:38:08.713
NASA rolled out an 11 million pound moon rocket in preparations for the astronauts launch.

637
00:38:08.733 --> 00:38:10.734
There's no journal or institution here.

638
00:38:11.854 --> 00:38:18.879
One of our favorite government agencies, NASA moved a 322-foot-tall rocket out to the launch pad on Saturday.

639
00:38:19.220 --> 00:38:27.806
A key step as the agency prepares for its long-awaited mission to send four astronauts around the moon on the widest orbit.

640
00:38:27.846 --> 00:38:29.107
It's been around the moon.

641
00:38:29.388 --> 00:38:30.328
Not on the moon.

642
00:38:30.629 --> 00:38:33.231
We have been to the moon, but not at this widest orbit.

643
00:38:33.251 --> 00:38:34.912
There were so many comments.

644
00:38:34.932 --> 00:38:35.692
Oh, yeah.

645
00:38:35.753 --> 00:38:37.013
Guys, it's fine.

646
00:38:37.054 --> 00:38:37.554
It's fine.

647
00:38:39.644 --> 00:38:42.165
We've been to the moon, but now we're going really far away.

648
00:38:42.625 --> 00:38:43.525
That's the idea.

649
00:38:43.625 --> 00:38:44.725
That's the idea here.

650
00:38:45.245 --> 00:38:53.327
We did, I think, have someone in our comments that was mentioning that they were a rocket scientist and they were actually driving down.

651
00:38:53.407 --> 00:38:54.287
Yes.

652
00:38:54.367 --> 00:38:56.328
To basically get ready for the launch.

653
00:38:56.428 --> 00:38:57.328
It was really cool.

654
00:38:57.568 --> 00:39:02.349
Some of them, like they worked at Huntsville, Alabama, which is involved with the Artemis program.

655
00:39:02.389 --> 00:39:02.609
Yes.

656
00:39:03.030 --> 00:39:04.890
It's very cool to get feedback like that.

657
00:39:05.410 --> 00:39:11.952
Um, sorry for not immediately being able to pull the name, but comment again and we'll make sure to get your name next time.

658
00:39:12.352 --> 00:39:16.413
Uh, we will have a deep dive on, uh, the Artemis launch and everything soon.

659
00:39:16.453 --> 00:39:18.133
So we will take care of all the moon people.

660
00:39:18.514 --> 00:39:19.594
Want more moon info.

661
00:39:20.074 --> 00:39:23.555
Story number three is about teenagers.

662
00:39:24.015 --> 00:39:24.936
Yeah.

663
00:39:24.996 --> 00:39:30.079
Scientists have found hidden Synap hotspots in the teen brain.

664
00:39:30.440 --> 00:39:34.022
This is out of Kyushu University in Japan.

665
00:39:34.062 --> 00:39:35.884
It was published in Science Advances.

666
00:39:36.404 --> 00:39:41.548
Scientists have discovered that the adolescent brain does more than prune old connections.

667
00:39:41.928 --> 00:39:47.632
During the teen years, it actively builds dense new clusters of synapses in specific parts of neurons.

668
00:39:47.932 --> 00:39:52.335
These clusters emerge only in adolescence and may help shape higher level thinking.

669
00:39:52.375 --> 00:39:58.899
When the process is disrupted, it could play a role in conditions like schizophrenia.

670
00:39:59.300 --> 00:40:03.683
Yeah, this was very exciting to me because, you know, by normal...

671
00:40:04.604 --> 00:40:05.905
neurological dogma.

672
00:40:06.646 --> 00:40:10.268
We grow a lot of synapses as we get into our teenage years.

673
00:40:10.308 --> 00:40:21.475
So like when we're children, when we're toddlers, and then during teenage years, the sort of main understanding is the synapses that don't have a lot of traffic, synapses are ways to connect from one neuron to another.

674
00:40:21.936 --> 00:40:26.879
And when those synapses don't have a lot of traffic, those synapses get deleted, right?

675
00:40:27.139 --> 00:40:30.361
This is saying that actually in certain parts of the brain,

676
00:40:31.578 --> 00:40:32.719
new synapses form.

677
00:40:33.160 --> 00:40:38.144
Not new neurons, but neurons are making new connections while we're teenagers.

678
00:40:38.684 --> 00:40:39.205
This kind of

679
00:40:40.557 --> 00:41:07.220
tracks with how i was as a team you know um specifically they looked at layer five neurons and the cerebral cortex cerebral cortex is the the neocortex part of our brain that's the newest evolved for us mammals the experiments were done in mice and layer five neurons are very cool because these are the neurons that collect a lot of data from the other layers and then send it out to other different parts of the brain so this is very important for trafficking information

680
00:41:07.720 --> 00:41:12.224
and making sense of different sensory stimuli or different ideas and so on and so forth.

681
00:41:12.844 --> 00:41:15.847
The authors do mention that this is experiments in mice.

682
00:41:16.347 --> 00:41:21.812
And, you know, not everything that happens in mice translates to primates and humans, but it's something to look into.

683
00:41:22.252 --> 00:41:30.259
Even in mice, I think it's a pretty big deal because this kind of stuff, I would assume, is conserved across the mammalian lineage, right?

684
00:41:30.299 --> 00:41:30.759
Something is...

685
00:41:31.620 --> 00:41:51.179
deep as making new synapses yeah i wouldn't be surprised if we found it now in primates but this this is you know something that we can study further on i think it's i think it's very cool it definitely maps on to the behavior we see in teenagers yeah that's for sure uh from a from a purely non-scientific perspective it tracks yeah

686
00:41:52.141 --> 00:41:58.729
Story number four is from Penn, University of Pennsylvania and University of Michigan.

687
00:41:58.809 --> 00:42:09.384
Penn and Michigan create the world's smallest programmable autonomous robots because we need more robots.

688
00:42:10.044 --> 00:42:15.545
This was published in Science Robotics and Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

689
00:42:16.185 --> 00:42:35.410
Researchers at UPenn and University of Michigan have created the world's smallest fully programmable autonomous robots, microscopic swimming machines, little Michael Phelps is running around, that can independently sense and respond to their surroundings, independently, and operate for months and cost just a penny each.

690
00:42:35.890 --> 00:42:36.930
Not going to take off in the U.S.

691
00:42:37.372 --> 00:42:37.913
No way.

692
00:42:38.553 --> 00:42:39.895
We don't got pennies anymore.

693
00:42:39.915 --> 00:42:40.816
We don't even have.

694
00:42:41.056 --> 00:42:41.277
Yeah.

695
00:42:41.437 --> 00:42:41.737
Yeah.

696
00:42:41.757 --> 00:42:43.399
You got to buy in bulk now.

697
00:42:44.460 --> 00:42:45.642
But, okay.

698
00:42:45.842 --> 00:42:47.804
All jokes aside, this is pretty crazy, okay?

699
00:42:47.824 --> 00:42:48.385
This is very crazy.

700
00:42:48.405 --> 00:42:49.145
You saw the photo, right?

701
00:42:49.246 --> 00:42:49.606
Yes.

702
00:42:49.666 --> 00:42:51.708
These things are smaller than a grain of salt.

703
00:42:52.229 --> 00:42:56.994
They're powered by light, and they've got a little computer that can let it move in sophisticated ways.

704
00:42:57.014 --> 00:42:57.415
Okay.

705
00:42:57.879 --> 00:42:59.380
This thing is insane.

706
00:42:59.440 --> 00:43:01.300
And they operate at the biological level.

707
00:43:01.680 --> 00:43:04.861
So, you know, they say you can monitor individual cells.

708
00:43:04.881 --> 00:43:06.322
You can have it go inside your body.

709
00:43:07.242 --> 00:43:09.403
You can help with small-scale manufacturing.

710
00:43:09.443 --> 00:43:14.545
Like, imagine a laboratory that's the size of, like, you know, microns by microns.

711
00:43:14.745 --> 00:43:15.105
I think...

712
00:43:15.998 --> 00:43:26.305
It's definitely look, it's it's a cool technological advance, but all those people who are like, there's a chip in my body like this is a weird.

713
00:43:26.405 --> 00:43:27.386
It's a little bit weird.

714
00:43:27.426 --> 00:43:29.107
Now there's some experimental research.

715
00:43:29.127 --> 00:43:29.347
Yeah.

716
00:43:29.387 --> 00:43:29.768
Now there's.

717
00:43:29.788 --> 00:43:30.228
Yeah.

718
00:43:30.348 --> 00:43:32.730
And they operate, you know, with just light.

719
00:43:34.376 --> 00:43:40.739
So they've got little tiny solar panels and then they've got a computer that lets them figure out where they want to go and things like that.

720
00:43:41.340 --> 00:43:46.082
One thing that I thought was really cool is how do you make something that small move around in water?

721
00:43:46.782 --> 00:43:50.344
Because you run into the low Reynolds numbers, right?

722
00:43:50.744 --> 00:43:55.567
The Navier-Stokes equations, when you go down to that scale, water is basically like honey.

723
00:43:56.107 --> 00:43:57.828
And so it's really hard to move around.

724
00:43:57.868 --> 00:43:59.048
So how are they actually doing it?

725
00:43:59.268 --> 00:44:02.290
Well, if you have movable parts, like little flippers and stuff...

726
00:44:02.910 --> 00:44:10.612
One, that's a really inefficient way to move around in honey because, like, as I move this way and then I retract my flippers, I'm actually going to go backwards.

727
00:44:10.912 --> 00:44:14.213
The other thing is movable parts are really bad because they're not durable.

728
00:44:14.373 --> 00:44:14.553
Yes.

729
00:44:14.613 --> 00:44:16.853
They can break, especially if you're moving around in honey.

730
00:44:16.913 --> 00:44:19.414
There's no nanorobotic autozone.

731
00:44:19.434 --> 00:44:20.114
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

732
00:44:20.374 --> 00:44:22.475
And these things are lasting for months on end, right?

733
00:44:22.735 --> 00:44:30.857
The way they do it is they generate electric fields around their chip, and then the electric fields then move around ions—

734
00:44:31.717 --> 00:44:33.278
Because our body has a bunch of ions.

735
00:44:33.578 --> 00:44:37.000
And then that moves around water, which propels them forward.

736
00:44:37.881 --> 00:44:38.961
So there's no moving parts.

737
00:44:39.281 --> 00:44:41.583
I just am so mad at how clever that is.

738
00:44:41.823 --> 00:44:43.164
It's pretty clever, I gotta say.

739
00:44:43.204 --> 00:44:45.045
It's a bit weird.

740
00:44:45.065 --> 00:44:45.985
That's what we're going for.

741
00:44:46.325 --> 00:44:48.146
But at the end, it is pretty clever.

742
00:44:48.166 --> 00:44:52.329
And I think for the right use cases, it can be huge.

743
00:44:52.369 --> 00:44:57.732
For delivering, let's say, medical cargo to one specific site of the body versus another.

744
00:44:57.992 --> 00:44:59.493
Things like that, it could be very useful.

745
00:44:59.813 --> 00:45:07.396
we've been hearing about the potential of nanotechnology since I think I was like in middle school, how it's the next frontier and all these things.

746
00:45:08.336 --> 00:45:15.920
This is a real practical, you know, it reminds me of the programmable protein story we covered from Yale in last season.

747
00:45:16.800 --> 00:45:20.761
We're doing greater and greater things at smaller and smaller scales.

748
00:45:21.502 --> 00:45:24.223
And again, the, the applications, you know,

749
00:45:25.859 --> 00:45:26.559
Eat your heart out.

750
00:45:26.659 --> 00:45:28.480
Yeah, it's it's it's endless.

751
00:45:28.680 --> 00:45:30.201
That's a really, really good story.

752
00:45:30.221 --> 00:45:36.364
Our last story for the rundown today is about Leonardo DiCaprio.

753
00:45:37.064 --> 00:45:37.924
Genetic clues.

754
00:45:37.944 --> 00:45:38.465
Da Vinci.

755
00:45:39.045 --> 00:45:39.945
Oh, excuse me.

756
00:45:41.386 --> 00:45:42.126
It's Golden Globes.

757
00:45:42.626 --> 00:45:43.107
Excuse me.

758
00:45:43.447 --> 00:45:44.307
I saw that clip of him.

759
00:45:44.367 --> 00:45:45.107
Yeah.

760
00:45:47.031 --> 00:45:49.412
Da Vinci, the one from the 1500s.

761
00:45:49.452 --> 00:45:50.212
Yeah.

762
00:45:50.573 --> 00:45:54.374
Genetic clues may be hiding in his artwork.

763
00:45:54.414 --> 00:45:56.295
There were many institutions involved in this one.

764
00:45:57.236 --> 00:46:03.158
The Venter Institute, Vanderbilt, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, and the University of Maryland.

765
00:46:03.739 --> 00:46:05.499
This was out in bioarchive.

766
00:46:06.220 --> 00:46:08.121
And the idea here is that

767
00:46:08.961 --> 00:46:15.967
The artist, inventor, and all-around genius, Da Vinci, was sort of the definition of the Renaissance Man.

768
00:46:16.007 --> 00:46:18.109
Obviously, we have the Da Vinci Code, all these books, all this stuff.

769
00:46:18.510 --> 00:46:22.313
And scientists have been aiming to unlock the secrets of his genius on a genetic level.

770
00:46:22.973 --> 00:46:27.497
But there's just one small problem more than 500 years after his death.

771
00:46:28.563 --> 00:46:32.605
His DNA has proved virtually impossible to locate.

772
00:46:32.845 --> 00:46:33.065
Yeah.

773
00:46:33.265 --> 00:46:33.826
No kids.

774
00:46:33.906 --> 00:46:35.887
His grave was destroyed during the French Revolution.

775
00:46:36.267 --> 00:46:36.467
Yeah.

776
00:46:36.607 --> 00:46:39.188
That's not the only thing that was destroyed in the French Revolution.

777
00:46:39.208 --> 00:46:39.828
Let me tell you that.

778
00:46:40.629 --> 00:46:43.650
But, you know, that's my jab at the French.

779
00:46:43.670 --> 00:46:45.871
There's going to be another one later in the episode.

780
00:46:46.111 --> 00:46:46.712
In any case...

781
00:46:47.453 --> 00:46:55.045
I don't know why, but there's this thing called the Leonardo Project, and they're obsessed with all things Leonardo, and they really want his DNA.

782
00:46:55.906 --> 00:46:57.709
They want to sequence his DNA.

783
00:46:58.229 --> 00:47:02.956
What the project's team did was they swabbed letters that were written by a distant Leonardo relative.

784
00:47:04.010 --> 00:47:09.535
And they also swabbed something called the Holy Child, which is a drawing that was possibly created by Leonardo.

785
00:47:10.075 --> 00:47:19.283
And they found a Y chromosome, which is the chromosome that is in all males, and there's not a lot of mutations.

786
00:47:19.523 --> 00:47:28.211
So if there's a distant Leonardo relative, and then this swab from the letter is actually matching, then it's very highly likely that it is Leonardo.

787
00:47:28.251 --> 00:47:30.553
And this kind of reminded me of there's this...

788
00:47:31.628 --> 00:47:56.178
documentary called the lost leonardo it was about this painting salvatore mundi that was apparently the lost leonardo da vinci painting he he only made a handful of paintings something like 10 or 15 less than 15 and each one of his paintings are masterpieces the first painting that i ever saw was madonna with child in the um gallery at london in london and it is it is like

789
00:47:56.718 --> 00:48:04.764
Quite amazing, just the way that he shades paint together, and the faces that he makes are just, like, incredible.

790
00:48:06.065 --> 00:48:10.889
This particular painting, the Salvatore Mundi, it's sold for $450 million.

791
00:48:11.330 --> 00:48:17.715
It's the most expensive painting to have ever been sold by Christie's, and it is currently owned by Mohammed bin Salman.

792
00:48:18.475 --> 00:48:26.802
of Saudi Arabia, he's trying to open a new art gallery in Saudi Arabia, and this is going to be the big masterpiece there.

793
00:48:27.843 --> 00:48:31.106
It's debated whether Salvatore Mundi is from Leonardo.

794
00:48:31.186 --> 00:48:31.466
Okay.

795
00:48:31.626 --> 00:48:31.906
Okay?

796
00:48:32.347 --> 00:48:43.276
But if we could figure out, like, a scientific way to say this is Leonardo or not, then, you know, you could actually see whether he made the bet was correct or not.

797
00:48:44.137 --> 00:48:49.161
We are giving new meaning to the common phrase, the Da Vinci code.

798
00:48:49.321 --> 00:48:50.582
Yeah.

799
00:48:50.602 --> 00:48:51.083
Oh, yeah.

800
00:48:51.363 --> 00:48:51.863
Nice one.

801
00:48:53.324 --> 00:48:56.427
I do this professionally.

802
00:48:56.907 --> 00:49:01.231
Great five stories on the rundown today.

803
00:49:01.371 --> 00:49:09.938
Prehistoric woolly rhino, the rollout of an 11 million pound rocket in preparation for Artemis II launch.

804
00:49:11.168 --> 00:49:16.916
We figured out why teens get to communicate better in their brain because of all these new synaptic connections.

805
00:49:17.907 --> 00:49:41.078
nanobots are here yeah and we may finally have the dna of leonardo da vinci so that we can genetically replicate him and have a bunch of geniuses running around we are now going to move into our next story which is about something very fascinating that i've never heard of which is time vaults yeah

806
00:49:41.858 --> 00:49:58.830
So in a new paper out in science from both Harvard and the Broad Institute of MIT is this new genetically encoded device for transcriptome storage, information storage, in mammalian cells.

807
00:49:58.850 --> 00:49:58.970
Right.

808
00:50:00.139 --> 00:50:01.900
This story is super interesting.

809
00:50:02.061 --> 00:50:11.928
Yeah, this is pretty incredible because I think it is going to, dare I say, if this is what it purports it to be, this might be something that is Nobel Prize worthy.

810
00:50:12.088 --> 00:50:12.749
Okay, wow.

811
00:50:13.049 --> 00:50:14.650
Okay, I'm going to start there.

812
00:50:15.051 --> 00:50:16.692
There's something called a measurement problem.

813
00:50:17.072 --> 00:50:17.692
In biology.

814
00:50:17.712 --> 00:50:19.473
In physics, we have the measurement problem, right?

815
00:50:19.493 --> 00:50:22.075
Which is like you measure something and then that destroys the system.

816
00:50:22.455 --> 00:50:27.077
Well, in biology, we've got something very similar, which is the destructive nature of observation.

817
00:50:27.197 --> 00:50:39.223
If I want to measure what is happening inside of a cell, I basically have to kill the cell, get all of its contents out, and then do RNA sequencing to figure out what kind of RNA is inside and all that other kind of stuff.

818
00:50:39.503 --> 00:50:42.645
So we can never observe the same cell twice.

819
00:50:43.105 --> 00:50:49.808
And what we have to do is we have to infer biological dynamics using static snapshots of stuff, right?

820
00:50:49.868 --> 00:50:50.228
Interesting.

821
00:50:50.248 --> 00:50:55.170
You've got to break down, and then you've got to break down here, and then you've got to sort of connect the dots in time.

822
00:50:55.470 --> 00:50:56.990
I actually did not know that.

823
00:50:57.010 --> 00:50:57.511
That's interesting.

824
00:50:57.531 --> 00:50:59.431
But if you think about it, that kind of makes sense, right?

825
00:50:59.471 --> 00:51:00.652
How am I going to observe a cell?

826
00:51:00.672 --> 00:51:02.933
Well, I've got to break all of its contents.

827
00:51:02.953 --> 00:51:05.054
I've got to get all the proteins and then sequence the proteins.

828
00:51:05.354 --> 00:51:06.874
Oh, there's this much amount of this protein.

829
00:51:06.894 --> 00:51:08.015
There's this much amount of this.

830
00:51:08.555 --> 00:51:10.836
This is the mRNA profile.

831
00:51:10.856 --> 00:51:11.416
Right.

832
00:51:11.937 --> 00:51:12.958
Which is the transcriptome.

833
00:51:12.978 --> 00:51:14.199
So it's like super nonlinear.

834
00:51:14.579 --> 00:51:25.750
And if you have stuff like cancer and embryonic development, which is nonlinear and non-ergotic, these systems, you can't really piece together a time sequence that confidently.

835
00:51:25.870 --> 00:51:28.693
You can't really understand what's happening in time.

836
00:51:29.574 --> 00:51:31.816
You can understand what's happening in snapshots of time.

837
00:51:32.096 --> 00:51:32.516
Exactly.

838
00:51:32.556 --> 00:51:34.358
So there's a lot of information loss, right?

839
00:51:34.638 --> 00:51:37.200
There's cellular decisions that happen, let's say now.

840
00:51:37.420 --> 00:51:37.600
Yes.

841
00:51:37.720 --> 00:51:43.264
And then the result of that cellular decision is only going to come forward in a few days.

842
00:51:43.384 --> 00:51:43.584
Yes.

843
00:51:43.985 --> 00:51:44.165
Right?

844
00:51:44.245 --> 00:51:46.466
So how do I connect those two things?

845
00:51:46.706 --> 00:51:46.847
Right.

846
00:51:47.047 --> 00:51:50.669
And the existing solutions are something like DNA editing.

847
00:51:50.789 --> 00:51:54.172
In 2014, there was this CRISPR-based tape recorder.

848
00:51:54.192 --> 00:51:54.532
Right.

849
00:51:54.612 --> 00:51:59.937
OK, that what you could do is you could say, OK, I want to watch these specific genes and how they're transcribed.

850
00:52:00.477 --> 00:52:05.381
And there was a tape recorder that you could literally like be like, oh, OK, this thing was transcribed at this time.

851
00:52:05.461 --> 00:52:08.043
I'm going to like keep it and save it in some sort of memory.

852
00:52:08.584 --> 00:52:11.386
But you had to choose beforehand what to record.

853
00:52:12.727 --> 00:52:13.488
It wasn't OK.

854
00:52:13.688 --> 00:52:13.908
Right.

855
00:52:14.068 --> 00:52:14.289
Yeah.

856
00:52:14.429 --> 00:52:18.953
And there's only a few events that you could record before the memory went out.

857
00:52:19.786 --> 00:52:21.888
Okay, and that's where the breakthrough comes in here.

858
00:52:22.128 --> 00:52:23.970
It's called Time Vault, okay?

859
00:52:23.990 --> 00:52:26.112
Genetically Encoded Molecular Archives.

860
00:52:26.492 --> 00:52:32.979
It's a time capsule for cells that stores the secret experiences of their past.

861
00:52:33.778 --> 00:52:34.738
It's very, very cool.

862
00:52:34.778 --> 00:52:43.780
And it's repurposing something called the Vault Particle to physically encapsulate mRNA and store it as the cell just goes about its daily business.

863
00:52:43.860 --> 00:52:47.441
We created almost a cellular backup system like Time Machine on your Mac.

864
00:52:47.581 --> 00:52:47.861
Yeah.

865
00:52:48.722 --> 00:52:49.722
Dude, it's exactly that.

866
00:52:49.742 --> 00:52:54.103
It's a Time Machine on your Mac, but now at the cellular level.

867
00:52:54.223 --> 00:52:54.903
That's incredible.

868
00:52:54.963 --> 00:52:55.683
It's insane.

869
00:52:55.743 --> 00:52:56.703
No, that's incredible.

870
00:52:57.083 --> 00:52:59.064
Especially given before we were only getting snapped.

871
00:52:59.084 --> 00:53:03.205
Like the scale of difference of capability.

872
00:53:03.325 --> 00:53:03.565
Yeah.

873
00:53:04.205 --> 00:53:29.127
okay it's very cool okay so let's talk about like why this is important right yeah so in physics we like to think of systems as state vectors like all of the particles in a room are going to have position and momenta and if we know those position and momenta then we'll know everything about that system well in biology the state vector is really something called the transcriptome which is the mrna counts there's about 20 000 genes

874
00:53:30.768 --> 00:53:32.889
that are getting expressed in the human body.

875
00:53:33.409 --> 00:53:41.974
And if you could count which genes and how much of that gene is getting expressed in a cell, you could have something like a state vector for that cell.

876
00:53:42.014 --> 00:53:44.135
It could be like, what is the cell state in?

877
00:53:44.975 --> 00:53:51.679
The cells in our skin will have a bunch of genes that express for the proteins that are responsible for our skin.

878
00:53:52.339 --> 00:53:55.661
The cells in our blood will have the blood genes expressed.

879
00:53:56.021 --> 00:53:57.762
The DNA is the same, but...

880
00:53:58.042 --> 00:54:03.724
But how much of which gene is expressed is what matters in terms of what that cell is doing.

881
00:54:03.824 --> 00:54:08.126
It's what differentiates how cells have these different functions.

882
00:54:08.226 --> 00:54:08.926
Exactly, yeah.

883
00:54:09.186 --> 00:54:14.008
And so in nature, you can think of DNA as like a stable read-only memory.

884
00:54:14.128 --> 00:54:15.049
So that's your ROM.

885
00:54:15.529 --> 00:54:18.970
And then your mRNA is a volatile random access memory, right?

886
00:54:18.990 --> 00:54:19.731
That's your RAM.

887
00:54:20.511 --> 00:54:24.893
Now, mRNA has a half-life that's about five to nine hours, which means...

888
00:54:25.813 --> 00:54:30.257
In about every five to nine hours, half of the amount of mRNA that was there is going to be gone.

889
00:54:30.277 --> 00:54:31.218
It's going to be degraded.

890
00:54:31.718 --> 00:54:39.505
And this is a feature and not a bug because the cell can then quickly respond to an environment and forget what it was doing five hours ago.

891
00:54:39.545 --> 00:54:45.690
You want to be able to quickly change what you're doing in case there's some outside stress that comes along, right?

892
00:54:45.870 --> 00:54:47.412
It's sort of this adaptive property.

893
00:54:47.812 --> 00:54:48.333
Exactly.

894
00:54:48.413 --> 00:54:55.358
And there were ways that we could tag the new mRNA to be like, okay, I want to check how much of this new mRNA is going through.

895
00:54:55.398 --> 00:55:03.265
You could tag it with something called 4-thiouridine, which is a specific type of nucleotide that goes into the mRNA and it kind of saves stuff.

896
00:55:03.705 --> 00:55:07.188
But that signal was limited by about 17 hours.

897
00:55:07.248 --> 00:55:09.450
So it's like undetectable after 24 hours.

898
00:55:09.830 --> 00:55:18.177
So your memory was only really 24 hours because you've got these things called exosomes in your cell that are basically the trash collectors.

899
00:55:18.678 --> 00:55:21.480
And they collect all the trash and then they put it out.

900
00:55:21.640 --> 00:55:21.901
Okay.

901
00:55:22.381 --> 00:55:23.122
So, okay.

902
00:55:23.182 --> 00:55:24.763
How do we extend the recording window?

903
00:55:25.063 --> 00:55:29.087
Well, one naive way to do it is just be like delete all the exosomes, all the trash collectors.

904
00:55:29.107 --> 00:55:29.207
Okay.

905
00:55:29.447 --> 00:55:30.628
That's a really bad idea.

906
00:55:32.069 --> 00:55:34.011
Imagine a city without trash collectors.

907
00:55:34.031 --> 00:55:34.631
We don't want that.

908
00:55:34.651 --> 00:55:35.292
We don't want that.

909
00:55:35.372 --> 00:55:35.872
We don't want that.

910
00:55:35.892 --> 00:55:37.794
Some people say that's what L.A. is today.

911
00:55:38.614 --> 00:55:41.176
I will have you know we still have trash and recycling running.

912
00:55:41.196 --> 00:55:42.097
Yeah, and it's not that bad.

913
00:55:42.477 --> 00:55:43.238
It's not that bad.

914
00:55:43.298 --> 00:55:46.040
But you can imagine that's a really bad way of doing things.

915
00:55:46.060 --> 00:55:50.444
You can't stop degradation because that stuff is essential for life to keep moving around.

916
00:55:50.824 --> 00:55:51.445
So instead...

917
00:55:52.590 --> 00:55:57.691
What if we could spatially segregate the mRNA and keep it away from the trash collectors?

918
00:55:58.191 --> 00:55:58.451
Okay.

919
00:55:58.711 --> 00:55:58.892
Right?

920
00:55:58.952 --> 00:56:00.572
We could put it in a vault.

921
00:56:00.812 --> 00:56:02.332
Aha.

922
00:56:02.392 --> 00:56:02.652
I see.

923
00:56:02.692 --> 00:56:07.354
Although the name vault is actually not for, like, you know, a vault to store stuff.

924
00:56:07.734 --> 00:56:14.235
It actually comes from this 1986 paper by Karadasha and Rome at UCLA in the Journal of Cell Biology.

925
00:56:14.255 --> 00:56:14.955
This was 1986.

926
00:56:14.995 --> 00:56:16.076
Okay?

927
00:56:16.396 --> 00:56:21.237
What they were doing was studying coded vesicles, which are, like, just transport spheres that, like—

928
00:56:22.157 --> 00:56:24.898
Package a bunch of stuff and then move it around the cell.

929
00:56:25.138 --> 00:56:27.259
And they kept coming up with this contaminant.

930
00:56:28.119 --> 00:56:28.379
Okay?

931
00:56:28.679 --> 00:56:30.700
There was a contaminant in their sample all the time.

932
00:56:30.800 --> 00:56:35.922
And when they looked really closely at this contaminant, there were these large barrel-shaped organelles.

933
00:56:36.302 --> 00:56:36.522
Okay.

934
00:56:36.923 --> 00:56:37.183
Okay?

935
00:56:37.583 --> 00:56:46.806
And when you went into an electron microscope and took a look at them, these organelles resembled vaulted ceilings of Gothic cathedrals.

936
00:56:47.286 --> 00:56:48.547
So they named them vaults.

937
00:56:49.027 --> 00:56:51.328
And these things are massive.

938
00:56:52.669 --> 00:56:54.910
If you look at the scale bar there, that's 100 nanometers.

939
00:56:55.231 --> 00:56:56.812
That's like the size of some cells.

940
00:56:57.192 --> 00:56:59.194
And these organelles are that big.

941
00:56:59.554 --> 00:57:01.976
And they're the largest non-viral cells.

942
00:57:02.968 --> 00:57:04.649
ribonucleic protein complex.

943
00:57:05.249 --> 00:57:10.433
They've got a mass of approximately 13 megadaltons, which is three times the size of a ribosome.

944
00:57:10.753 --> 00:57:21.820
The ribosome is the factory that makes proteins out of mRNA, and they're pretty big for just like single units of stuff, right?

945
00:57:21.900 --> 00:57:22.740
Not really single units.

946
00:57:22.760 --> 00:57:25.822
There's like subunits that form together to create a ribosome.

947
00:57:25.842 --> 00:57:31.266
But at the end of the day, it's not a fully-fledged organelle with like a membrane and like a full like, you know,

948
00:57:31.967 --> 00:57:32.955
Inside and outside.

949
00:57:33.641 --> 00:57:34.166
This thing...

950
00:57:35.534 --> 00:57:38.616
13 megadolsons at the dimensions of tens of nanometers.

951
00:57:39.116 --> 00:57:41.658
And there's a bunch of them in our cells.

952
00:57:41.718 --> 00:57:43.699
10,000 to 100,000 per cell.

953
00:57:43.919 --> 00:57:44.299
Jesus.

954
00:57:44.459 --> 00:57:44.720
Okay.

955
00:57:45.380 --> 00:57:49.062
A lot of our immune system cells have an overexpression of this stuff.

956
00:57:49.222 --> 00:57:49.482
Okay.

957
00:57:49.803 --> 00:57:53.305
And what's weird is we still don't really know what they're there for.

958
00:57:54.105 --> 00:58:01.670
And they're not essential because if you knock them out in mice, like you just get rid of the protein that makes these vaults, the mice are fine.

959
00:58:03.392 --> 00:58:06.776
So there's some... You know, there's a variety of things.

960
00:58:06.796 --> 00:58:11.922
It's either, you know, evolutionarily over time, we no longer need these things, but they're still around.

961
00:58:12.022 --> 00:58:12.583
Yeah.

962
00:58:12.603 --> 00:58:14.905
Or there's some functionality... That we just haven't figured out.

963
00:58:14.925 --> 00:58:15.666
We don't really quite know yet.

964
00:58:15.686 --> 00:58:18.409
And it's more likely the latter, because there's a lot of stuff that...

965
00:58:19.030 --> 00:58:26.272
Our DNA is made up of introns and exons, so there's stuff that the DNA keeps inside the nucleus, and then there's stuff that gets expressed.

966
00:58:26.552 --> 00:58:27.972
This stuff is getting expressed, right?

967
00:58:28.032 --> 00:58:39.074
If you have 10,000 to 100,000 per cell, clearly evolution by now should have figured out if there's no use for this, why waste time and energy making this stuff?

968
00:58:39.174 --> 00:58:40.494
But it's being expressed.

969
00:58:40.514 --> 00:58:41.535
So there is some reason.

970
00:58:41.575 --> 00:58:42.635
We just haven't quite...

971
00:58:43.115 --> 00:58:44.015
Figured out what that is.

972
00:58:44.275 --> 00:58:54.058
But the advantage is because it's not critical for function, you can use it as this kind of ideal, robust, non-toxic chassis for stuff.

973
00:58:54.798 --> 00:58:55.058
Okay?

974
00:58:55.438 --> 00:58:56.839
So let's get into this vault protein.

975
00:58:56.859 --> 00:58:58.619
What does it look like?

976
00:58:58.759 --> 00:59:02.520
There's a single protein that makes it up that's called a major vault protein.

977
00:59:03.141 --> 00:59:07.822
You get 78 copies of this protein, and it self-assembles.

978
00:59:08.653 --> 00:59:11.275
It doesn't need like something to come in and assemble it.

979
00:59:11.595 --> 00:59:13.856
It's like a bunch of tiny little magnets.

980
00:59:13.896 --> 00:59:16.398
78 of them come together and make this barrel shape.

981
00:59:16.958 --> 00:59:18.879
Beautiful structure, right?

982
00:59:18.939 --> 00:59:21.761
This very beautiful symmetric barrel-like structure.

983
00:59:22.081 --> 00:59:23.262
They're all just coming together.

984
00:59:23.282 --> 00:59:28.725
There's these two subunits that come together, one on each side, 39 on each of them.

985
00:59:30.166 --> 00:59:30.326
And...

986
00:59:31.252 --> 00:59:37.558
The Young's modulus of this thing, like the stress and strain, like how hard it is, it's about as hard as like some plastics or like viral capsids.

987
00:59:37.598 --> 00:59:37.938
Oh, wow.

988
00:59:37.958 --> 00:59:41.421
Which is very good because it's, you know, it's quite sturdy.

989
00:59:41.441 --> 00:59:41.801
Yeah, yeah.

990
00:59:42.302 --> 00:59:47.467
And the other thing is, unlike viral capsids, when you like poke them, the viral capsids are kind of...

991
00:59:48.331 --> 00:59:52.272
They're going to go all over the place, and they're not really going to be able to recover.

992
00:59:52.612 --> 01:00:15.837
With these major vault proteins, there's interactions with that protein, the way it sort of just magnetically locks into place with all of the others, that ensures that if I were to, like, poke it with, let's say, a little tip, like an AFM tip or something like that, with atomic force microscopy tip, the vault protein will break.

993
01:00:16.776 --> 01:00:19.136
And then when I remove the stress, it'll just form back up.

994
01:00:20.298 --> 01:00:28.323
Just naturally, biology has figured out this exact design to make this beautiful barrel-like structure that is resistant to stress.

995
01:00:29.003 --> 01:00:29.864
It's incredible.

996
01:00:30.104 --> 01:00:31.785
And we still don't know what it does.

997
01:00:31.805 --> 01:00:32.245
What it does.

998
01:00:32.265 --> 01:00:34.146
Like 40 years later.

999
01:00:34.166 --> 01:00:35.507
1986, 40 years later.

1000
01:00:35.547 --> 01:00:37.128
We still quite don't know what it does.

1001
01:00:37.608 --> 01:00:42.651
But it is clearly fantastically engineered through evolutionary biology.

1002
01:00:42.772 --> 01:00:44.833
Yeah, it's absolutely amazing, right?

1003
01:00:45.113 --> 01:00:48.315
So how do we get from vaults to now time vaults?

1004
01:00:49.055 --> 01:00:50.576
This is a really funny story, okay?

1005
01:00:50.856 --> 01:00:55.919
So one of these students at the Harvard Lab found Leonard Rome's YouTube channel.

1006
01:00:56.519 --> 01:01:05.044
He's called The Vault Guy on YouTube, and he makes a bunch of YouTube videos about vault proteins and just molecular biology in general.

1007
01:01:05.184 --> 01:01:06.125
Shout out to The Vault Guy.

1008
01:01:06.245 --> 01:01:13.289
And yeah, I guess one of these grad students in the Harvard Lab found the YouTube channel and was like, yo, this vault guy is making some pretty cool stuff.

1009
01:01:13.329 --> 01:01:14.470
Maybe we could use him.

1010
01:01:15.274 --> 01:01:16.595
For our purposes, right?

1011
01:01:17.295 --> 01:01:22.077
And that's where they got the idea of time vaults, and then this paper has come out in Science.

1012
01:01:22.717 --> 01:01:26.919
A genetically encoded device for transcriptome storage in mammalian cells.

1013
01:01:27.439 --> 01:01:32.041
The idea is we're going to use these vaults as our Mac time machine.

1014
01:01:32.101 --> 01:01:32.301
Yes.

1015
01:01:32.741 --> 01:01:32.922
Right?

1016
01:01:32.942 --> 01:01:33.162
Yes.

1017
01:01:33.182 --> 01:01:33.302
Yes.

1018
01:01:34.182 --> 01:01:34.702
Very cool.

1019
01:01:34.962 --> 01:01:35.722
So how do we do that?

1020
01:01:36.923 --> 01:01:38.783
How exactly mechanistically does it work?

1021
01:01:38.803 --> 01:01:44.805
Because, you know, on this podcast, we like to focus on just the Lego blocks of biology.

1022
01:01:44.885 --> 01:01:49.166
And how you put together a bunch of Lego blocks that actually work the way that they're supposed to.

1023
01:01:49.446 --> 01:01:56.728
Because the concept of what they're trying to accomplish and the reason why makes total sense.

1024
01:01:56.848 --> 01:01:56.968
Yeah.

1025
01:01:56.988 --> 01:01:57.088
Yeah.

1026
01:01:58.133 --> 01:02:10.523
And then the entry point of, you know, these vaults being a possible conduit to an engineered kind of functionality is interesting.

1027
01:02:10.543 --> 01:02:12.665
But there's a big gap between those two things.

1028
01:02:12.725 --> 01:02:12.925
Yeah.

1029
01:02:12.945 --> 01:02:14.966
Like, how am I going to get the mRNA inside?

1030
01:02:14.987 --> 01:02:15.187
Yes.

1031
01:02:15.467 --> 01:02:18.189
And then how does it stay inside and all this other kind of stuff?

1032
01:02:18.229 --> 01:02:18.389
Right.

1033
01:02:18.409 --> 01:02:20.091
This is, again, at the molecular level.

1034
01:02:20.151 --> 01:02:20.351
Yes.

1035
01:02:20.651 --> 01:02:23.573
OK. Well, at the molecular level, everything is Lego blocks.

1036
01:02:23.974 --> 01:02:25.014
So let's talk about mRNA.

1037
01:02:25.034 --> 01:02:25.094
OK.

1038
01:02:26.128 --> 01:02:40.790
One of the properties of mRNA is when it comes out, it has something called a poly-A tail, which means at the end of the mRNA, after it gets transcribed from the DNA, there's a bunch of AAA, the adenine, there's just repetition of adenine, and that poly-A tail...

1039
01:02:42.004 --> 01:02:48.067
is kind of like a handle for figuring out where to take this mRNA and things like that.

1040
01:02:48.087 --> 01:02:53.449
You need to be able to grab it without messing with the genetic information that's later, right?

1041
01:02:53.690 --> 01:02:55.670
So you need some kind of handle for the sword.

1042
01:02:56.071 --> 01:02:58.352
It's like on a knife.

1043
01:02:58.632 --> 01:02:58.892
Yeah.

1044
01:02:59.012 --> 01:03:01.113
You don't want the end to be a blade that you're grabbing.

1045
01:03:01.153 --> 01:03:04.315
Yeah, because then you'll mess with the blade or you'll kill yourself.

1046
01:03:05.075 --> 01:03:06.876
So the poly-8 tail is there.

1047
01:03:07.656 --> 01:03:14.386
And the stuff that interacts with the poly-A tail is something called the poly-A binding protein, PABP.

1048
01:03:14.947 --> 01:03:18.493
And what these guys figured is we could have a container and a bait.

1049
01:03:19.618 --> 01:03:19.878
Okay.

1050
01:03:20.359 --> 01:03:23.161
The container is my vault protein shell.

1051
01:03:23.942 --> 01:03:32.429
And my bait would be this protein that interacts with the poly tail and also has a little domain on the protein that interacts with the vault.

1052
01:03:33.109 --> 01:03:33.370
Okay.

1053
01:03:33.690 --> 01:03:38.034
So the PABP, that binding protein, is going to grab the poly A tail.

1054
01:03:38.554 --> 01:03:42.477
And then part of it is going to get stuck to the vault.

1055
01:03:42.537 --> 01:03:42.778
Yes.

1056
01:03:43.078 --> 01:03:43.318
Okay.

1057
01:03:43.378 --> 01:03:45.920
And all of this we can put in a single piece of DNA.

1058
01:03:45.940 --> 01:03:46.140
Mm-hmm.

1059
01:03:46.901 --> 01:03:51.382
Such that when it gets transcribed, the vault protein gets transcribed to make the vault.

1060
01:03:51.603 --> 01:03:56.144
And also the poly-A binding protein gets transcribed.

1061
01:03:56.324 --> 01:03:56.704
You see?

1062
01:03:56.784 --> 01:03:57.604
That is so good.

1063
01:03:57.644 --> 01:04:00.966
And so when I turn this thing on, it makes the whole package.

1064
01:04:01.086 --> 01:04:01.946
It makes my vault.

1065
01:04:02.306 --> 01:04:05.507
And it makes the thing that grabs the mRNA and puts it inside the vault.

1066
01:04:05.647 --> 01:04:17.030
We've created a vertically integrated stack at this molecular level to effectively go through the creation of the individual component parts necessary.

1067
01:04:17.390 --> 01:04:19.631
We don't have to hijack something existing.

1068
01:04:20.011 --> 01:04:22.652
We're literally able to say, no, we want the time vault.

1069
01:04:22.932 --> 01:04:24.633
We want the grab protein, the transporter.

1070
01:04:24.853 --> 01:04:25.453
Yeah.

1071
01:04:25.733 --> 01:04:28.494
And so it's fully self-contained as a process.

1072
01:04:28.614 --> 01:04:28.794
Yeah.

1073
01:04:28.894 --> 01:04:29.655
Fully self-contained.

1074
01:04:29.735 --> 01:04:30.195
Fascinating.

1075
01:04:30.255 --> 01:04:30.895
Amazing, right?

1076
01:04:31.175 --> 01:04:41.920
And then what you can do is this entire genetic circuit, you can turn on and off based on this tet on tet off mechanism, which is effectively what you do is you introduce an antibiotic called doxycycline.

1077
01:04:42.400 --> 01:04:45.761
And then when you introduce it on, this genetic pathway gets triggered.

1078
01:04:45.981 --> 01:04:49.323
So it makes the vault protein and it makes the interaction protein.

1079
01:04:49.903 --> 01:04:50.083
Right.

1080
01:04:50.363 --> 01:04:58.225
And then and then there's another called docs off where I can introduce docs off and then it's going to stop stop the vault protein.

1081
01:04:58.285 --> 01:05:04.607
And so now I have a controlled time window where I can make this time machine.

1082
01:05:05.007 --> 01:05:05.708
I can trigger it.

1083
01:05:06.128 --> 01:05:06.748
It can turn on.

1084
01:05:06.948 --> 01:05:13.670
It can make all this stuff and it'll just grab a bunch of mRNA, stick it inside the vault protein and then I can make it stop.

1085
01:05:14.780 --> 01:05:22.827
For many listeners may have heard of Doxycycline before because it's like a it's an antibiotic you'll get for like a variety of use cases.

1086
01:05:22.847 --> 01:05:27.251
So I'm like, it's simply just Doxy triggers the initialization of the storage.

1087
01:05:27.731 --> 01:05:31.474
That's again, it's you're not inventing like we're taking things that are already there.

1088
01:05:31.494 --> 01:05:31.895
Yeah.

1089
01:05:31.915 --> 01:05:35.077
But just putting these Lego blocks together in a really clever way.

1090
01:05:35.097 --> 01:05:35.398
Right.

1091
01:05:35.418 --> 01:05:35.578
Yeah.

1092
01:05:36.158 --> 01:05:39.440
And then now you can see if this time vault stuff works, right?

1093
01:05:39.980 --> 01:05:40.140
Yes.

1094
01:05:40.220 --> 01:05:42.962
So you can show that there's no new capture.

1095
01:05:42.982 --> 01:05:52.547
This time vault, the half-life of the mRNA in the time vault is now 132 hours, which is five days instead of the five hours that we had before.

1096
01:05:52.848 --> 01:05:55.669
So the mRNA is sticking around because it's been captured.

1097
01:05:56.049 --> 01:05:59.451
And if I now lyse the cells, it's still in there.

1098
01:05:59.571 --> 01:05:59.932
Mm-hmm.

1099
01:06:00.652 --> 01:06:01.012
Mm hmm.

1100
01:06:01.052 --> 01:06:01.272
Right.

1101
01:06:01.873 --> 01:06:03.033
Yes, this is good.

1102
01:06:03.493 --> 01:06:06.514
So you can now you can now basically tell a cell.

1103
01:06:06.774 --> 01:06:06.994
Yes.

1104
01:06:07.135 --> 01:06:09.215
I want you to save all your memory right now.

1105
01:06:09.335 --> 01:06:09.575
Yes.

1106
01:06:10.476 --> 01:06:10.656
Yes.

1107
01:06:10.856 --> 01:06:11.776
Simply by introducing.

1108
01:06:11.796 --> 01:06:12.517
Yeah.

1109
01:06:12.637 --> 01:06:12.817
Yeah.

1110
01:06:12.957 --> 01:06:13.997
It'll save all the memory.

1111
01:06:14.437 --> 01:06:18.819
And then you can just have the cell go on its merry way because all of the stuff is inside the vault protein.

1112
01:06:18.859 --> 01:06:19.059
Right.

1113
01:06:19.179 --> 01:06:20.820
It's not interacting with the stuff outside.

1114
01:06:20.880 --> 01:06:23.781
And we know that the vault protein is not toxic.

1115
01:06:23.941 --> 01:06:24.161
Yes.

1116
01:06:24.221 --> 01:06:26.682
To the cells themselves because it was already there in the first place.

1117
01:06:26.702 --> 01:06:34.805
So it can just hang around doing the function we want it to because it's non-toxic and it's self-contained, meaning like the mRNA inside cannot escape.

1118
01:06:35.246 --> 01:06:37.567
And also if it gets poked, it'll reconstruct.

1119
01:06:37.607 --> 01:06:39.968
So it sort of has security in that context.

1120
01:06:40.228 --> 01:06:45.390
So the point is you want to be careful when you start doing things like this to not introduce...

1121
01:06:46.050 --> 01:06:49.613
you know, new variables that the system will attack or are not prepared for.

1122
01:06:49.913 --> 01:06:57.599
But the structure we've already walked through really identifies that this is not going to interrupt regularly scheduled programming.

1123
01:06:57.679 --> 01:06:57.939
Exactly.

1124
01:06:57.959 --> 01:07:03.544
While still enabling the capability of capturing the memory of a cell over this long, much longer period of time.

1125
01:07:03.684 --> 01:07:04.164
Exactly.

1126
01:07:04.485 --> 01:07:08.468
And so now you can ask, the mRNA that's inside the vault protein, right?

1127
01:07:08.768 --> 01:07:09.849
How long does that last?

1128
01:07:10.169 --> 01:07:12.711
Well, the thing is lasting for about 17 days.

1129
01:07:12.751 --> 01:07:12.971
Right.

1130
01:07:14.414 --> 01:07:14.694
Okay?

1131
01:07:15.075 --> 01:07:16.556
The stuff that's inside the vault protein.

1132
01:07:16.957 --> 01:07:18.658
And you ask, okay, why is it lasting that long?

1133
01:07:18.678 --> 01:07:21.761
Well, that's actually the inherent physics of RNA.

1134
01:07:22.042 --> 01:07:22.262
Okay.

1135
01:07:22.362 --> 01:07:22.602
Okay?

1136
01:07:23.083 --> 01:07:27.627
RNA is ribonucleic acid versus DNA is deoxyribonucleic acid.

1137
01:07:28.748 --> 01:07:32.392
One of the big differences is, of course, the DNA is double-stranded.

1138
01:07:32.712 --> 01:07:33.973
And RNA is single-stranded.

1139
01:07:34.233 --> 01:07:40.957
So DNA is a bit more stable, obviously, because you've got, you know, a fully-fledged ladder that's sort of protecting the inner bases.

1140
01:07:41.277 --> 01:07:49.602
The other big thing is that the ribose sugar, which RNA has, and DNA has deoxyribose sugar, the ribose sugar has an extra OH.

1141
01:07:50.202 --> 01:07:54.445
Okay, it's got an extra hydroxyl group on the two of that pentagon.

1142
01:07:54.465 --> 01:07:54.865
Yeah, okay.

1143
01:07:54.905 --> 01:07:55.045
Right?

1144
01:07:55.125 --> 01:07:55.786
Yep.

1145
01:07:55.806 --> 01:07:56.186
And that...

1146
01:07:56.806 --> 01:08:00.329
Extra OH, that oxygen, oxygen is always just bad.

1147
01:08:00.349 --> 01:08:02.151
Okay, it just attacks random crap.

1148
01:08:02.491 --> 01:08:07.075
And so the RNA, that extra oxygen goes and attacks the phosphate backbone.

1149
01:08:07.716 --> 01:08:12.620
And that process has a characteristic timescale of 17 days.

1150
01:08:12.700 --> 01:08:22.249
So we're reaching the theoretical limit of how long RNA can just hang around before the chemical RNA itself starts attacking itself.

1151
01:08:23.257 --> 01:08:27.522
We're literally at the, what did we call the Eddington limit?

1152
01:08:27.562 --> 01:08:33.089
Yeah, but in this case it would be the thermodynamic limit of RNA stability.

1153
01:08:33.409 --> 01:08:37.714
But what it's showing is that there's no enzymatic degradation of mRNA.

1154
01:08:38.515 --> 01:08:38.735
Yes.

1155
01:08:38.955 --> 01:08:40.336
There's no other stuff.

1156
01:08:40.376 --> 01:08:42.858
There's no exosomes that are coming in trying to, like, take it out.

1157
01:08:43.138 --> 01:08:44.579
This is just pure physics.

1158
01:08:45.080 --> 01:08:46.781
It's going to last about 17 to 18 days.

1159
01:08:47.021 --> 01:08:53.926
It's locked down but for the fact that the structure of ribose itself will degrade.

1160
01:08:53.986 --> 01:08:55.126
Will degrade the iron.

1161
01:08:55.166 --> 01:08:57.188
Which we – that's a bigger – that's a whole other thing.

1162
01:08:57.208 --> 01:08:59.449
Yeah, that's like – I don't know what to do with that.

1163
01:08:59.549 --> 01:09:00.270
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1164
01:09:00.830 --> 01:09:01.771
Yeah.

1165
01:09:01.951 --> 01:09:04.333
So here you can show that, like, you know, this –

1166
01:09:05.353 --> 01:09:06.734
This is really happening, right?

1167
01:09:07.354 --> 01:09:18.420
So the critical step is once you have the RNA that's present in the cytosol, let's say, versus RNA that's present in the time vault, how do you tell the two apart?

1168
01:09:18.920 --> 01:09:19.521
Right, okay.

1169
01:09:19.701 --> 01:09:27.305
Because if I were to now take the cell and I were to say, okay, I want you to record now, and then in five days I want to read it, right?

1170
01:09:27.365 --> 01:09:27.785
How do I...

1171
01:09:29.144 --> 01:09:31.485
tell what's already there versus what's in the vault.

1172
01:09:31.806 --> 01:09:36.548
Well, I can introduce something called RNAs, which is an enzyme that eats RNA.

1173
01:09:37.349 --> 01:09:44.033
If I make it eat RNA, the stuff that's inside the time vault is protected from this enzymatic degradation.

1174
01:09:44.113 --> 01:09:45.794
Oh my God, bro.

1175
01:09:46.294 --> 01:09:47.235
This is so good.

1176
01:09:47.295 --> 01:09:48.055
It's so good.

1177
01:09:48.075 --> 01:09:48.996
This is so good.

1178
01:09:49.056 --> 01:09:56.340
And so now if you add RNAs, the only stuff that we're going to be able to read afterwards is the stuff that's inside the vault protein.

1179
01:09:58.068 --> 01:09:58.929
It's so good.

1180
01:09:59.309 --> 01:10:04.694
This is, this is, this is... You're watching masters at work here.

1181
01:10:04.734 --> 01:10:06.195
Yeah, this is great.

1182
01:10:06.315 --> 01:10:09.818
I can see why you started off with such a high bar.

1183
01:10:09.838 --> 01:10:10.498
High bar, right?

1184
01:10:11.319 --> 01:10:12.980
There are some caveats.

1185
01:10:13.000 --> 01:10:19.946
For example, it's not going to take in mitochondrial RNA because the mitochondrial RNA is inside the mitochondria, right?

1186
01:10:20.046 --> 01:10:21.167
And it's not going to take in...

1187
01:10:23.282 --> 01:10:25.383
any RNAs that lack a poly-A tail.

1188
01:10:25.423 --> 01:10:25.923
There's some.

1189
01:10:25.943 --> 01:10:28.183
There's always some that are exceptions to the rule.

1190
01:10:28.523 --> 01:10:35.565
And so, you know, the interaction protein is not going to be able to grab that mRNA because there's no poly-A tail to actually grab.

1191
01:10:36.025 --> 01:10:37.965
The capture efficiency is also quite low.

1192
01:10:38.025 --> 01:10:41.666
It only takes in about 3% of the total mRNA, right?

1193
01:10:41.686 --> 01:10:43.027
Because there's so much mRNA.

1194
01:10:43.087 --> 01:10:45.207
So it's only going to take in a small sample.

1195
01:10:45.467 --> 01:10:49.128
And so that low capture rate means that you really need to pool together

1196
01:10:53.489 --> 01:11:20.724
statistical bias right where if you were to do just one cell how do you know that you got all of it if it's only taking three percent but if you do a thousand cells then you're pretty sure that you've got all of the mrna covered that's well that's a solvable we'll solve that yeah and and there's there's ideas later that'll that'll help you solve it but i just want to let you know that in at least in the first iteration of this this is still pretty no this is this is right now that this base is there like i i i'm just shocked at how clever that is

1197
01:11:20.864 --> 01:11:22.626
Yeah, it's really nice, okay?

1198
01:11:22.927 --> 01:11:25.230
And so how do we know that it works?

1199
01:11:25.250 --> 01:11:26.892
Well, they did a really simple experiment.

1200
01:11:27.153 --> 01:11:36.485
What they did was heat shock these cells after... And then right after the heat shock, they had...

1201
01:11:37.650 --> 01:11:39.490
the RNA go into the vault proteins.

1202
01:11:39.970 --> 01:11:40.231
Okay.

1203
01:11:40.451 --> 01:11:49.012
And then they compared the vault proteins right after the heat shock to when you, and then, you know, you wait five days and you sequence the mRNA that's in the vault proteins.

1204
01:11:49.272 --> 01:11:51.253
And then you compare that to the heat shock.

1205
01:11:51.413 --> 01:11:54.153
And then right after you, you lysate and then you do it right.

1206
01:11:54.273 --> 01:12:03.355
If this whole thing worked, then the mRNA that's in the vault proteins right after the heat shock should match normal cells right after the heat shock.

1207
01:12:03.375 --> 01:12:04.576
The transcriptones should match.

1208
01:12:04.616 --> 01:12:04.796
Yes.

1209
01:12:04.896 --> 01:12:06.076
And that's exactly what they found.

1210
01:12:06.436 --> 01:12:30.393
right is that the present transcriptome if you look at five days later the present transcriptome forgot that it was heat shock but the stuff that's inside the vault remembers that it got heat shot because you did the time machine thing you did the backup and you did the backup right then right very beautiful and the figures i gotta say the aesthetics of the figures are also really nice a plus the color coordination of the blue and the red i liked it i don't know look look at

1211
01:12:30.813 --> 01:12:34.897
We like design and aesthetic, both experimental and visual.

1212
01:12:34.917 --> 01:12:35.117
Yeah.

1213
01:12:35.357 --> 01:12:35.898
Yeah.

1214
01:12:36.018 --> 01:12:37.139
So I thought this was really cool.

1215
01:12:37.439 --> 01:12:38.880
So now applications, right?

1216
01:12:39.081 --> 01:12:41.363
They actually went further and went into applications.

1217
01:12:41.383 --> 01:12:44.145
This is the one where people talk about, you know, real world applications.

1218
01:12:44.485 --> 01:12:51.071
So Harvard, when it came out with the story in their press, they talked about how did that cancer cell become drug resistant?

1219
01:12:51.772 --> 01:12:54.534
One of the first things you can do is apply this thing to cancer cells.

1220
01:12:54.835 --> 01:12:55.075
Okay.

1221
01:12:56.960 --> 01:13:04.027
Whenever you do cancer cells and you treat the cancer cells with a drug, there's always 1% of cancer cells that are drug-tolerant persisters.

1222
01:13:04.547 --> 01:13:08.631
You know how you have the soap that kills 99% of germs?

1223
01:13:08.871 --> 01:13:11.934
Well, there's always 1% of germs that get away, right?

1224
01:13:11.994 --> 01:13:13.415
And the same thing happens with cancer.

1225
01:13:13.816 --> 01:13:14.236
If you...

1226
01:13:15.202 --> 01:13:21.468
Target therapy with something called osimertinib, which is a drug for cancer.

1227
01:13:21.668 --> 01:13:23.290
1% of these cancer cells survive.

1228
01:13:23.630 --> 01:13:24.932
Now, the debate is the following.

1229
01:13:25.032 --> 01:13:32.019
Were these cancer cells pre-adapted or was the fact that I introduced the drug causing them to adapt?

1230
01:13:32.877 --> 01:13:38.798
This is a debate that goes all the way back to Charles Darwin and Jean-Baptiste Lamarck.

1231
01:13:39.158 --> 01:13:42.159
There was the idea of how do organisms gain traits?

1232
01:13:42.519 --> 01:13:48.300
The Darwinian model was the one at the top that you see, which is, let's take a population of giraffes, right?

1233
01:13:48.720 --> 01:13:50.781
Why do giraffes have long necks?

1234
01:13:51.101 --> 01:13:58.462
Well, you could have a population that has a bunch of different neck sizes, and then the longer necks could reach the trees and eat the trees.

1235
01:14:02.862 --> 01:14:07.604
And then the subsequent populations got longer and longer necks.

1236
01:14:07.644 --> 01:14:08.904
That's actually the one at the bottom.

1237
01:14:09.345 --> 01:14:09.585
Okay.

1238
01:14:09.985 --> 01:14:28.172
Now, the Lamarckian hypothesis is the hereditary nature of acquired characteristics, meaning the giraffes kept stretching their necks, and then that stretching of the necks made the subsequent population stretch their necks.

1239
01:14:28.892 --> 01:14:31.493
And so now that's why we have longer neck giraffes.

1240
01:14:31.713 --> 01:14:34.214
Would it be almost like an epigenetic kind of theory?

1241
01:14:34.234 --> 01:14:34.814
Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1242
01:14:34.834 --> 01:14:36.194
Like more of an epigenetic theory.

1243
01:14:36.274 --> 01:14:36.974
Exactly, yeah.

1244
01:14:37.074 --> 01:14:41.355
And for what we know from large-scale populations, it's really a Darwinian thing.

1245
01:14:41.635 --> 01:14:44.916
But the Lamarck hypothesis is not completely off-ground, right?

1246
01:14:44.996 --> 01:14:47.217
At the cellular level, we have examples of that.

1247
01:14:47.517 --> 01:14:54.399
For example, with bacteria, when we heat shock bacteria, the bacteria just start taking in DNA from their environment, right?

1248
01:14:54.439 --> 01:15:00.320
So that's kind of Lamarckian because I've been introduced to stress, and then that stress is causing the genetics to change.

1249
01:15:00.360 --> 01:15:00.520
Yes.

1250
01:15:00.580 --> 01:15:02.962
So the question is, what's happening with these cancer cells, right?

1251
01:15:03.363 --> 01:15:10.709
And currently, we can only record the bulk population, which is mostly dead, and then we can record the survivors, which is after the fact.

1252
01:15:11.150 --> 01:15:17.996
So to answer this question in cancer biology, you have to be able to record what's happening before the drug was introduced.

1253
01:15:18.016 --> 01:15:18.216
Yes.

1254
01:15:18.516 --> 01:15:19.177
And then...

1255
01:15:20.816 --> 01:15:23.198
Probe what the survivors were doing.

1256
01:15:23.299 --> 01:15:23.499
Yeah.

1257
01:15:23.619 --> 01:15:23.799
Yes.

1258
01:15:23.979 --> 01:15:24.540
Does that make sense?

1259
01:15:24.560 --> 01:15:24.660
Yes.

1260
01:15:24.700 --> 01:15:26.502
And this is perfect for the time vaults.

1261
01:15:26.542 --> 01:15:26.782
Yes.

1262
01:15:26.802 --> 01:15:31.346
So what they did was they had a protocol where you record for 24 hours with no drug.

1263
01:15:31.927 --> 01:15:35.511
And then you introduce this cancer drug, Osimertinib.

1264
01:15:35.551 --> 01:15:35.671
Yes.

1265
01:15:36.972 --> 01:15:40.356
You record this cancer drug for four days, 99% die.

1266
01:15:40.596 --> 01:15:40.797
Yes.

1267
01:15:40.897 --> 01:15:45.002
And then the ones that survive, let's read out what's inside their vaults.

1268
01:15:45.182 --> 01:15:45.462
Yes.

1269
01:15:45.803 --> 01:15:46.063
Yes.

1270
01:15:46.303 --> 01:15:51.209
And it was definitive evidence for the selection model, meaning that these cancer cells had previously adapted.

1271
01:15:51.229 --> 01:15:51.309
Yes.

1272
01:15:52.030 --> 01:15:54.251
The cancer cells have a very high mutation rate.

1273
01:15:54.371 --> 01:15:56.892
And so they're exploring all of these different possibilities.

1274
01:15:57.172 --> 01:16:03.394
And the 1% of cancer cells that survived had a distinct transcriptional signature before the drug treatment.

1275
01:16:04.335 --> 01:16:09.957
And so now the focus for therapeutics can shift from adaptation to targeting that preexisting state.

1276
01:16:10.097 --> 01:16:16.063
And what they did was they looked at some of the genes that were expressed in those vaults, specifically FN1.

1277
01:16:16.603 --> 01:16:17.444
They knocked that out.

1278
01:16:18.024 --> 01:16:20.867
And then now none of the cancer cells survived that drug.

1279
01:16:20.987 --> 01:16:22.408
So it's like literally working.

1280
01:16:22.449 --> 01:16:24.931
This is actually unreal.

1281
01:16:25.351 --> 01:16:27.413
I want people to understand how unreal this is.

1282
01:16:27.653 --> 01:16:27.854
Yeah.

1283
01:16:27.874 --> 01:16:30.656
Because now you're... Because we can now...

1284
01:16:31.897 --> 01:16:34.901
DVR ourselves.

1285
01:16:35.442 --> 01:16:37.705
We can Mac Time Machine backup ourselves.

1286
01:16:38.045 --> 01:16:42.391
It means we can actually see what happens before the

1287
01:16:43.270 --> 01:16:49.876
Like we can understand after you introduce some external factor, like what the changes are.

1288
01:16:50.476 --> 01:16:54.159
And particularly in the cancer research example you just brought up, this is so fascinating.

1289
01:16:54.399 --> 01:16:55.060
You have all of them.

1290
01:16:55.340 --> 01:16:57.282
You do the recording in the time vault.

1291
01:16:57.662 --> 01:16:58.823
You're doing it over 24 hours.

1292
01:16:59.203 --> 01:16:59.984
You have all of them there.

1293
01:17:00.384 --> 01:17:01.846
Then you introduce the current treatment.

1294
01:17:02.226 --> 01:17:03.107
Yeah, 99% die.

1295
01:17:03.287 --> 01:17:03.987
99 are gone.

1296
01:17:04.288 --> 01:17:05.188
1% are left over.

1297
01:17:05.288 --> 01:17:10.052
You can look at the 1% that are left over and say, what is it about these guys that's different?

1298
01:17:10.853 --> 01:17:13.177
And then now we can attack the thing like the FN1.

1299
01:17:13.517 --> 01:17:18.125
That's different because we are able to now actually see over time do it again.

1300
01:17:18.385 --> 01:17:19.127
And now they all die.

1301
01:17:19.287 --> 01:17:19.467
Yeah.

1302
01:17:19.607 --> 01:17:21.110
That's incredible.

1303
01:17:21.210 --> 01:17:21.350
Yeah.

1304
01:17:21.370 --> 01:17:21.470
Yeah.

1305
01:17:22.215 --> 01:17:23.136
That's incredible.

1306
01:17:23.296 --> 01:17:24.897
Do you understand what we can do with that?

1307
01:17:24.917 --> 01:17:25.898
Yeah, that's so cool.

1308
01:17:26.238 --> 01:17:31.943
You can use this for like, and the fact that these vault proteins are just ubiquitous in mammalian cells.

1309
01:17:31.963 --> 01:17:32.143
Yes.

1310
01:17:32.364 --> 01:17:34.906
Means that you can just apply this all over the place.

1311
01:17:34.926 --> 01:17:35.346
Exactly.

1312
01:17:35.626 --> 01:17:45.935
This almost feels, conceptually, as I try to put it into my brain, it feels CRISPR-esque as being a platform versus a single point solution.

1313
01:17:45.955 --> 01:17:46.676
Exactly, yeah.

1314
01:17:47.176 --> 01:17:48.797
This is a really big deal.

1315
01:17:48.857 --> 01:17:49.997
It's a really big deal.

1316
01:17:50.097 --> 01:17:54.119
Once it percolates and people poke, hold, reviewer two, poke the hole.

1317
01:17:54.179 --> 01:17:54.999
Yeah.

1318
01:17:55.260 --> 01:17:56.520
No, but people are very excited.

1319
01:17:56.540 --> 01:17:57.020
Excited about this.

1320
01:17:57.040 --> 01:17:59.341
From the press coverage that I've seen, people are very excited.

1321
01:17:59.361 --> 01:18:01.982
This is, I mean, holy moly.

1322
01:18:02.002 --> 01:18:02.223
Yeah.

1323
01:18:02.363 --> 01:18:02.963
It's very cool.

1324
01:18:03.263 --> 01:18:04.103
And what a great name.

1325
01:18:04.123 --> 01:18:04.724
Time Vaults?

1326
01:18:04.784 --> 01:18:04.984
Yeah.

1327
01:18:05.164 --> 01:18:05.604
Great name.

1328
01:18:05.884 --> 01:18:06.284
Well done.

1329
01:18:06.564 --> 01:18:07.125
Great name.

1330
01:18:07.205 --> 01:18:07.945
Well done on that one.

1331
01:18:07.965 --> 01:18:10.406
Whoever was doing the branding, right?

1332
01:18:10.726 --> 01:18:11.006
Yeah.

1333
01:18:11.026 --> 01:18:12.047
The branding on that one was great.

1334
01:18:12.167 --> 01:18:12.367
So.

1335
01:18:12.627 --> 01:18:13.227
What's the future?

1336
01:18:13.268 --> 01:18:16.030
Well, we want to overcome this 3% capture efficiency.

1337
01:18:16.090 --> 01:18:16.290
Sure.

1338
01:18:16.490 --> 01:18:16.650
Right?

1339
01:18:16.890 --> 01:18:24.095
So one thing that I thought was really cool, the idea was you can put in inside the vault protein, you can put in something called reverse transcriptase.

1340
01:18:24.676 --> 01:18:31.241
And what that's going to do is take the mRNA that's getting stuck inside the vault protein and reverse transcribe that into DNA.

1341
01:18:31.941 --> 01:18:37.227
Now the DNA is going to last much longer than the 17 days that's the thermodynamic limit for RNA.

1342
01:18:37.607 --> 01:18:43.053
And so you could like have weeks of time vaults, right?

1343
01:18:43.413 --> 01:18:49.360
So it's almost like there's a short-term memory in the mRNA storage that gets – and then sort of like how we record.

1344
01:18:49.420 --> 01:18:53.744
We record onto a small hard drive, and then we dump it onto our archive drive for long-term storage.

1345
01:18:53.764 --> 01:18:53.945
Yeah.

1346
01:18:54.285 --> 01:18:55.066
It's exactly that.

1347
01:18:55.426 --> 01:18:55.646
Yeah.

1348
01:18:55.726 --> 01:19:00.710
The other thing could be like you could have molecular identifiers per vault per cell.

1349
01:19:01.410 --> 01:19:03.652
And then it's kind of like a barcode for each cell.

1350
01:19:03.992 --> 01:19:08.475
And then you could be like these mRNA came from this cell and these mRNA came from this cell.

1351
01:19:08.515 --> 01:19:11.897
So you get the aggregate, but you also get single cell resolution.

1352
01:19:11.917 --> 01:19:12.078
Mm-hmm.

1353
01:19:12.718 --> 01:19:13.539
Kind of cool, right?

1354
01:19:13.999 --> 01:19:14.559
To think about.

1355
01:19:15.120 --> 01:19:19.143
You could combine this time vaults with super resolution and expansion microscopy.

1356
01:19:19.463 --> 01:19:22.425
So then you could locate where the time vaults were in a cell.

1357
01:19:22.846 --> 01:19:24.827
Right now, they're just sort of lysed and in a test tube.

1358
01:19:25.108 --> 01:19:27.229
But imagine, you know, you'd stick it under a microscope.

1359
01:19:27.249 --> 01:19:29.531
You could locate where in the cell it is.

1360
01:19:29.591 --> 01:19:30.672
Is it next to the nucleus?

1361
01:19:30.752 --> 01:19:33.094
Is it next to the endoplasmic reticulum?

1362
01:19:33.134 --> 01:19:33.854
So on and so forth.

1363
01:19:33.894 --> 01:19:35.816
Is it next to the cell membrane?

1364
01:19:36.971 --> 01:19:41.934
Synthetic organelles, you could have programmable delivery vehicles that will just go through.

1365
01:19:42.774 --> 01:19:44.815
I think it's very, very cool.

1366
01:19:44.855 --> 01:19:46.176
My mind is just racing.

1367
01:19:46.796 --> 01:19:48.397
Yeah, there's so much that you can do with this.

1368
01:19:48.978 --> 01:19:50.458
This was a go.

1369
01:19:50.518 --> 01:19:56.842
Again, we don't always like to give credit to two of our arch rivals in Harvard and MIT.

1370
01:19:57.522 --> 01:19:59.803
But kudos, guys.

1371
01:19:59.823 --> 01:20:00.564
This was a good one.

1372
01:20:00.904 --> 01:20:05.466
Still not Princeton, but we'll give credit where credit's due.

1373
01:20:05.506 --> 01:20:06.147
This one's a good one.

1374
01:20:07.392 --> 01:20:08.533
I thought that was really cool.

1375
01:20:08.593 --> 01:20:09.735
That was fantastic.

1376
01:20:09.915 --> 01:20:13.358
Time volts storing my brain.

1377
01:20:13.919 --> 01:20:19.144
Every week, I know for those of you who watch and listen, my brain is constantly being, my mind is constantly being blown.

1378
01:20:19.164 --> 01:20:22.487
But the implications of some stuff we talk about is just insane.

1379
01:20:22.848 --> 01:20:25.390
We're going to go to our last main story of the day.

1380
01:20:25.410 --> 01:20:25.510
Yeah.

1381
01:20:26.071 --> 01:20:39.018
which is going to be about ancient mathematics, ancient maths, as they say, across the pond, which right now we're having some sibling rivalry with.

1382
01:20:39.379 --> 01:20:44.001
This story is in the Journal of World Prehistory.

1383
01:20:44.021 --> 01:20:52.406
The dawn of art and mathematics, ancient Mesopotamian pottery, reveals early mathematical thinking.

1384
01:20:53.085 --> 01:20:53.345
Yes.

1385
01:20:53.806 --> 01:20:56.608
So we've been thinking about math, the maths, for quite a while.

1386
01:20:56.628 --> 01:20:57.248
For quite a while.

1387
01:20:57.308 --> 01:21:01.572
And it used to be that we thought math from the fourth millennium BC, right?

1388
01:21:01.592 --> 01:21:06.536
The Sumerian city-states, they had these, like, tablets that had stuff like the Pythagorean theorem.

1389
01:21:06.776 --> 01:21:09.979
They even had the quadratic formula, like, figured out.

1390
01:21:10.439 --> 01:21:10.659
Which...

1391
01:21:11.640 --> 01:21:13.240
I think it's very, very cool, right?

1392
01:21:13.301 --> 01:21:22.423
And they had a base 60 system, which we still use today when we talk about, like, minutes to an hour, seconds to a minute, angles, things like that.

1393
01:21:22.443 --> 01:21:23.543
We still use base 60.

1394
01:21:24.144 --> 01:21:33.606
This is a new discovery that says that Halifian pottery, which is 6,000 BC, it's in northern Mesopotamia.

1395
01:21:33.786 --> 01:21:35.807
This might contain geometric sequences.

1396
01:21:37.148 --> 01:21:39.190
and the first evidence of humans doing math.

1397
01:21:39.230 --> 01:21:42.613
This is 1,000 to 2,000 years before the Sumerian city-states.

1398
01:21:42.994 --> 01:21:43.254
Okay?

1399
01:21:43.895 --> 01:21:47.178
And it's a pretty cool study, and we're going to get into it.

1400
01:21:47.278 --> 01:21:47.798
I have some...

1401
01:21:49.520 --> 01:21:52.022
I don't know much about anthropology, and so maybe I'm...

1402
01:21:52.839 --> 01:21:56.141
Maybe I'm not getting it, but I think it's still a really cool study.

1403
01:21:56.301 --> 01:21:59.343
And we'll get into some of the qualms that I have later on, but it's not much.

1404
01:21:59.663 --> 01:21:59.903
Okay.

1405
01:22:00.324 --> 01:22:04.806
So this time period is 6th millennium BC, late Neolithic revolution, right?

1406
01:22:05.367 --> 01:22:12.191
The Halifians were this culture that were widely dispersed in a network in northern Iraq and Syria.

1407
01:22:12.311 --> 01:22:14.993
So this is above the Euphrates and the Tigris rivers.

1408
01:22:15.133 --> 01:22:15.273
Mm-hmm.

1409
01:22:16.862 --> 01:22:20.223
Sixth century, sixth millennium BC, way, way back.

1410
01:22:20.283 --> 01:22:20.543
Okay.

1411
01:22:20.823 --> 01:22:29.245
So this is right when we're coming out of the post ice age stabilization, the climate is becoming sort of stabilized and the world population is about 40 million.

1412
01:22:29.786 --> 01:22:30.726
It's quadrupling.

1413
01:22:30.786 --> 01:22:32.166
It's like growing really fast.

1414
01:22:32.626 --> 01:22:34.267
Humans are, you know, getting better.

1415
01:22:34.867 --> 01:22:42.013
They used to live in these distinctive circular toloid dwellings, mud brick dwellings, agricultural villages.

1416
01:22:42.433 --> 01:22:45.155
They used to have dry farming, so no irrigation as of yet.

1417
01:22:45.175 --> 01:22:50.099
They were just relying on the rains to make wheat and barley.

1418
01:22:50.239 --> 01:22:52.181
They used to have herding for sheeps and goats.

1419
01:22:53.081 --> 01:22:53.261
And...

1420
01:22:54.262 --> 01:23:00.265
Before the Halafians, most of the art was dominated by animals.

1421
01:23:00.805 --> 01:23:01.066
Okay?

1422
01:23:01.366 --> 01:23:07.929
This is an example of cave paintings from 40,000 years ago from Laskaux, France.

1423
01:23:08.970 --> 01:23:11.091
I believe that's how they pronounce it over there.

1424
01:23:11.131 --> 01:23:12.291
That's how it's spelled anyways.

1425
01:23:12.391 --> 01:23:13.952
So I don't know any better.

1426
01:23:14.372 --> 01:23:20.175
But 40,000 years ago, they were making a bunch of cave paintings that were a bunch of really beautiful animals and things like that.

1427
01:23:20.215 --> 01:23:20.416
Right?

1428
01:23:21.116 --> 01:23:22.577
Halafian pottery comes in.

1429
01:23:23.548 --> 01:23:24.449
6000 BC.

1430
01:23:25.209 --> 01:23:26.390
Very beautiful, first of all.

1431
01:23:26.671 --> 01:23:29.093
The pottery itself is like really, really nice.

1432
01:23:29.113 --> 01:23:29.713
Okay.

1433
01:23:30.213 --> 01:23:31.595
And this pottery...

1434
01:23:32.553 --> 01:23:38.898
contains a shift between just focusing on animals to now also focusing on the botanical world.

1435
01:23:39.178 --> 01:23:39.438
Okay.

1436
01:23:39.638 --> 01:23:39.898
Okay.

1437
01:23:40.178 --> 01:23:47.183
So if you go to the next slide, there's examples of plants on pottery, plant art.

1438
01:23:47.524 --> 01:23:55.990
And this is a really fundamental cognitive shift from this hunter-gatherer, animal-centered view to now farmers and plant-centered.

1439
01:23:56.290 --> 01:23:57.531
The vegetarians, man.

1440
01:23:57.751 --> 01:23:57.992
Yeah.

1441
01:23:58.432 --> 01:24:01.238
I mean, because farming becomes the way of life, right?

1442
01:24:01.418 --> 01:24:02.681
To create civilization.

1443
01:24:02.881 --> 01:24:03.182
100%.

1444
01:24:03.202 --> 01:24:04.504
To create population.

1445
01:24:04.885 --> 01:24:05.125
So...

1446
01:24:06.458 --> 01:24:13.463
The idea with this paper is maybe this change is what's creating now mathematics and the need for mathematics.

1447
01:24:13.483 --> 01:24:21.828
Because you're shifting into this system that naturally benefits from some foundational mathematics.

1448
01:24:21.848 --> 01:24:22.369
Mathematics, right?

1449
01:24:22.389 --> 01:24:25.951
Because now you have communal stuff that you need to split up.

1450
01:24:26.031 --> 01:24:26.512
Yeah, yeah.

1451
01:24:26.632 --> 01:24:26.892
Okay?

1452
01:24:27.152 --> 01:24:30.394
So let's get into the history of human mathematical thought, right?

1453
01:24:31.075 --> 01:24:33.977
Paleolithic, there was this thing called the Ishano bone.

1454
01:24:34.537 --> 01:24:45.187
which was discovered in the Congo in 1960, it's thought that the first example of mathematics, now it's in a Belgian museum because, of course, the Belgians... Boo!

1455
01:24:45.488 --> 01:24:48.430
Yeah, the Belgians did great things for the Congo, right?

1456
01:24:48.550 --> 01:24:52.474
And for those who are listening, my face is very sarcastic.

1457
01:24:53.275 --> 01:24:57.679
Okay, the Belgians were probably the worst colonizers of all the colonizers.

1458
01:24:58.099 --> 01:24:58.320
So...

1459
01:24:58.820 --> 01:25:01.422
But they got the bone and now it's in one of their museums.

1460
01:25:01.882 --> 01:25:02.163
Great.

1461
01:25:02.683 --> 01:25:05.005
So why do we think this is a mathematical tool?

1462
01:25:05.025 --> 01:25:11.750
Well, it's got all these like notches on it that happen to be prime numbers, which is very cool.

1463
01:25:11.770 --> 01:25:12.010
Yeah.

1464
01:25:12.150 --> 01:25:12.350
Yeah.

1465
01:25:12.370 --> 01:25:12.550
Right.

1466
01:25:12.791 --> 01:25:13.011
Yeah.

1467
01:25:13.371 --> 01:25:16.553
Like 20,000 years ago, they're putting in these notches that are prime numbers.

1468
01:25:16.634 --> 01:25:17.814
It could be like a counting tool.

1469
01:25:17.975 --> 01:25:19.035
This is very advanced.

1470
01:25:19.396 --> 01:25:19.556
Yeah.

1471
01:25:19.576 --> 01:25:19.716
Right.

1472
01:25:20.356 --> 01:25:23.038
So for 20 anyway, 20,000 years ago.

1473
01:25:23.058 --> 01:25:23.459
Right.

1474
01:25:23.479 --> 01:25:23.679
Right.

1475
01:25:24.926 --> 01:25:29.451
There's some criticism that maybe it's just a tally stick or like the notches are for better grip.

1476
01:25:29.792 --> 01:25:32.615
But the prime numbers are kind of specific.

1477
01:25:32.735 --> 01:25:33.456
Specific.

1478
01:25:33.976 --> 01:25:34.237
Right.

1479
01:25:34.257 --> 01:25:34.457
Yeah.

1480
01:25:34.637 --> 01:25:36.399
So I like that one.

1481
01:25:37.440 --> 01:25:37.620
OK.

1482
01:25:37.721 --> 01:25:39.723
I'm just going to go ahead and say I like that one.

1483
01:25:40.503 --> 01:25:43.285
Then there's an understanding about Neanderthal yarn.

1484
01:25:43.705 --> 01:25:54.510
This came out, and what they were doing was microscopic analysis of yarn that they found in Neanderthal cave, and it showed evidence of an intertwined three-ply cord.

1485
01:25:54.910 --> 01:25:55.230
Okay.

1486
01:25:55.451 --> 01:26:01.554
And if it's intertwined like that, you know, where it's like you're doing braids, then there's some understanding of mathematics, right?

1487
01:26:01.574 --> 01:26:05.175
You got to do three and then one under and then two and then one under, so on and so forth.

1488
01:26:05.195 --> 01:26:05.455
Okay.

1489
01:26:06.196 --> 01:26:07.957
So maybe the Neanderthals had...

1490
01:26:08.715 --> 01:26:10.657
basic mathematical concepts, right?

1491
01:26:10.957 --> 01:26:13.099
Then we get into about 8,000 BC.

1492
01:26:13.179 --> 01:26:16.081
There's something called the token system, which is, again, in Mesopotamia.

1493
01:26:16.401 --> 01:26:24.007
These early farmers used geometric clay tokens like triangles, cones, spheres, for one-to-one accounting.

1494
01:26:24.087 --> 01:26:28.871
And there's evidence that three cones would mean three measures of barley and so on and so forth, right?

1495
01:26:29.332 --> 01:26:33.515
And amidst this is where we get the Halafian Gap, right?

1496
01:26:33.595 --> 01:26:35.456
which is where this paper sort of fits in.

1497
01:26:35.716 --> 01:26:35.976
Okay.

1498
01:26:36.456 --> 01:26:47.041
It's a paper that was out very recently, and it's showing that the Halafian period, which is about 6,000 to 5,000 BC, it predates the Sumerian writing, and perhaps...

1499
01:26:48.077 --> 01:26:58.320
The pottery is evidence that it's not just aesthetics that they were going for, but they were going for some kind of mathematical codification for their agricultural society.

1500
01:26:58.340 --> 01:26:58.660
Okay.

1501
01:26:58.860 --> 01:26:59.120
Okay?

1502
01:26:59.681 --> 01:27:04.922
And this is—we're getting into something called cognitive archaeology, which is reconstructing ancient thought.

1503
01:27:05.322 --> 01:27:06.563
It's always very hard to do.

1504
01:27:06.683 --> 01:27:06.783
Yes.

1505
01:27:06.803 --> 01:27:06.903
Yes.

1506
01:27:07.663 --> 01:27:33.947
ethnomathematics which is inferring math from indirect indications like we did with that bone yes from the congo so it's very hard to do all right so this is not an exact science but i still think it's incredibly cool because i love thinking about how we got here how do we get out of the cradle of civilization yeah yeah and how do we form this kind of amazing society right yes to think about something that happened 8 000 years ago is is i think very very cool yes so

1507
01:27:34.828 --> 01:27:35.710
Let's get into the paper.

1508
01:27:35.750 --> 01:27:41.479
They did a survey of pottery from 29 different agricultural sites across northern Mesopotamia.

1509
01:27:41.579 --> 01:27:42.381
Archaeological sites.

1510
01:27:42.793 --> 01:27:43.033
Yes.

1511
01:27:43.454 --> 01:27:43.634
Yes.

1512
01:27:43.654 --> 01:27:44.174
What did I say?

1513
01:27:44.635 --> 01:27:45.115
Agriculture.

1514
01:27:45.195 --> 01:27:45.515
Oh, yeah.

1515
01:27:45.555 --> 01:27:45.756
Yeah.

1516
01:27:45.956 --> 01:27:46.897
Archaeological sites.

1517
01:27:46.997 --> 01:27:49.359
I guess they were agricultural, but you're right.

1518
01:27:49.439 --> 01:27:55.344
This is archaeological sites where they analyze tens of thousands of painted shards of pottery.

1519
01:27:56.165 --> 01:27:59.948
So they have one thing that's very important is they have a very large statistical sample.

1520
01:28:00.409 --> 01:28:01.189
This is quite rare.

1521
01:28:01.209 --> 01:28:06.514
I was going to say that's I was literally going to say I can't imagine there's a lot of archaeological sites where we have that volume.

1522
01:28:06.714 --> 01:28:06.994
Yes.

1523
01:28:07.114 --> 01:28:07.615
Of stuff.

1524
01:28:07.915 --> 01:28:08.155
Yes.

1525
01:28:08.335 --> 01:28:14.480
So this is a lot of data from tens of thousands of shards from all over this geography.

1526
01:28:14.900 --> 01:28:21.165
And what we find, what they find is vegetal motifs, so motifs of plants that are a shared cultural language.

1527
01:28:21.846 --> 01:28:26.349
The entire Halafian territory had this language.

1528
01:28:26.550 --> 01:28:29.032
If you look at pottery from one end all the way to the other—

1529
01:28:29.692 --> 01:28:30.512
You've got plants.

1530
01:28:30.672 --> 01:28:32.893
So that means this isn't like a one-off thing.

1531
01:28:32.953 --> 01:28:33.153
Right.

1532
01:28:33.393 --> 01:28:33.673
Okay?

1533
01:28:33.953 --> 01:28:38.935
This is a kind of cultural language that goes across the entire civilization.

1534
01:28:39.355 --> 01:28:39.535
Right?

1535
01:28:39.855 --> 01:28:43.256
And there's an average frequency of these motifs, which is pretty significant.

1536
01:28:43.617 --> 01:28:45.977
About 4% to 6% of all of the pottery has this.

1537
01:28:46.337 --> 01:28:50.779
And given the amount of data that we have, we can actually be very confident that this is there.

1538
01:28:51.119 --> 01:28:51.339
Right?

1539
01:28:51.459 --> 01:28:51.659
Mm-hmm.

1540
01:28:52.519 --> 01:28:55.200
Now, the motifs are classified into four basic categories.

1541
01:28:55.560 --> 01:28:56.841
And there's a critical subgroup.

1542
01:28:57.715 --> 01:29:00.217
There's a bunch of large flowers, okay?

1543
01:29:00.777 --> 01:29:07.103
And these flowers are on big bowls and the bases of these bowls, and they happen to be in radial patterns.

1544
01:29:07.223 --> 01:29:07.443
Yes.

1545
01:29:07.723 --> 01:29:11.786
Here you can see there's four, then you have eight, so you get this doubling, right?

1546
01:29:11.806 --> 01:29:11.987
Yes.

1547
01:29:12.027 --> 01:29:17.391
You get four, which is a cross, and then you half each of the crosses, so you get a doubling and you get eight.

1548
01:29:17.451 --> 01:29:17.671
Yes.

1549
01:29:17.751 --> 01:29:20.734
And then these radial encodings don't just stop at eight.

1550
01:29:21.214 --> 01:29:22.374
They keep going on and on.

1551
01:29:22.694 --> 01:29:25.355
So then you get 16, you get 32.

1552
01:29:25.715 --> 01:29:28.996
And the one that's really crazy for me is all the way to 64.

1553
01:29:29.076 --> 01:29:29.536
Yeah.

1554
01:29:29.736 --> 01:29:30.816
Okay.

1555
01:29:31.336 --> 01:29:32.537
Getting 32 pedals.

1556
01:29:32.957 --> 01:29:34.177
I can imagine you do four.

1557
01:29:34.217 --> 01:29:38.278
Then you, you know, you do the pizza cut for eight and then you do another pizza cut for 16.

1558
01:29:38.558 --> 01:29:40.258
Then you do another pizza cut for 32.

1559
01:29:40.559 --> 01:29:47.120
But if you've ever cut pizzas for like a large group of people and you've only got one pizza, which happened to me once, it was the worst party ever.

1560
01:29:47.660 --> 01:29:51.121
You can't get to 64 because then at that point it's like you're doing like a lot of

1561
01:29:51.161 --> 01:29:53.401
It's like atoms of bread, you know?

1562
01:29:53.802 --> 01:29:59.583
And so what they did with the 16, with the 64, is they divided it into four quadrants.

1563
01:30:00.183 --> 01:30:10.465
And then they had 16 in each, a 4x4 sort of, a 4x4 grid in each of the four quadrants to give 16 times 4, which is 64.

1564
01:30:10.605 --> 01:30:10.845
Yes.

1565
01:30:10.885 --> 01:30:13.886
This is pretty convincing that there is some mathematics.

1566
01:30:14.146 --> 01:30:14.346
Yes.

1567
01:30:14.586 --> 01:30:14.746
Yes.

1568
01:30:14.826 --> 01:30:15.646
That's happening, right?

1569
01:30:15.686 --> 01:30:16.066
Yeah.

1570
01:30:16.086 --> 01:30:18.467
That level, the complexity, once you start getting to that size.

1571
01:30:18.487 --> 01:30:20.207
I mean, also, these designs are beautiful.

1572
01:30:20.287 --> 01:30:21.468
These designs are beautiful.

1573
01:30:21.508 --> 01:30:22.568
For 8,000 years ago.

1574
01:30:22.588 --> 01:30:22.788
Yeah.

1575
01:30:22.808 --> 01:30:23.448
They're not just like.

1576
01:30:23.468 --> 01:30:25.809
Like, the patterns are amazing.

1577
01:30:26.229 --> 01:30:26.449
Yeah.

1578
01:30:26.489 --> 01:30:27.509
The checkerboard.

1579
01:30:27.609 --> 01:30:27.829
Yes.

1580
01:30:27.889 --> 01:30:29.430
The radially outward.

1581
01:30:29.450 --> 01:30:29.570
Yes.

1582
01:30:29.810 --> 01:30:32.251
Like, even in terms of symmetry.

1583
01:30:32.431 --> 01:30:32.951
Yes.

1584
01:30:32.991 --> 01:30:35.692
8,000 years ago, this is incredible symmetry.

1585
01:30:35.832 --> 01:30:36.892
I totally agree.

1586
01:30:37.532 --> 01:30:40.873
I mean, I can barely get that out of chat GPT today.

1587
01:30:40.993 --> 01:30:41.173
Yeah.

1588
01:30:43.462 --> 01:30:50.930
So the authors argue that there's some kind of consistent use of these two to the power of two, two to the power of three.

1589
01:30:50.950 --> 01:30:54.193
So you get four, eight, 16, 32, and 64.

1590
01:30:54.213 --> 01:30:55.335
And these are not –

1591
01:30:58.637 --> 01:30:59.357
By coincidence.

1592
01:30:59.377 --> 01:31:01.038
There's some kind of having logic, right?

1593
01:31:01.278 --> 01:31:05.199
Where the sequence emerges because of some intuitive geometric operation.

1594
01:31:05.559 --> 01:31:09.381
We are dividing a circle into a bunch of parts, right?

1595
01:31:09.781 --> 01:31:12.642
And now comes the theoretical side of things.

1596
01:31:12.762 --> 01:31:17.104
These Halifian villages used to have communal sharing economy.

1597
01:31:17.484 --> 01:31:23.186
And then the crops, like grain or barley, had to be shared out fairly to everyone in the population.

1598
01:31:23.226 --> 01:31:25.146
So they had the sharing economy.

1599
01:31:25.166 --> 01:31:26.027
What do we call it now?

1600
01:31:26.227 --> 01:31:26.647
With the...

1601
01:31:27.347 --> 01:31:56.402
the uber and the instacart oh yeah what are those called it's not sharing a con it's is it uber pool no the the creator economy anyway yeah they used to have that they used to have that yeah all the way back then right and there's there's more um there's more evidence that there used to be complex geometric subdivisions because if you look at the stamp seals from the halafian period the stamp seals also have this very nice geometric pattern and these were seals that were used to mark property and secure trade items so

1602
01:31:56.502 --> 01:32:00.343
So it supports this idea that there's some sophisticated economic administration.

1603
01:32:00.483 --> 01:32:00.683
Yes.

1604
01:32:00.963 --> 01:32:07.665
And perhaps this kind of economic administration would require basic mathematics of two to the power of whatever.

1605
01:32:07.805 --> 01:32:08.025
Yes.

1606
01:32:08.225 --> 01:32:08.405
Right.

1607
01:32:08.685 --> 01:32:08.945
Okay.

1608
01:32:09.506 --> 01:32:13.967
Now, there are examples of other numbers.

1609
01:32:14.847 --> 01:32:15.107
Okay.

1610
01:32:15.127 --> 01:32:15.347
Okay.

1611
01:32:15.647 --> 01:32:18.368
Like, there are examples of six or seven numbers.

1612
01:32:19.943 --> 01:32:20.443
6, 7.

1613
01:32:20.483 --> 01:32:22.164
Or like 12, 13.

1614
01:32:22.504 --> 01:32:27.165
And what the authors argue is that these show less meticulous craftsmanship.

1615
01:32:27.605 --> 01:32:29.666
This is where I'm like, I don't know.

1616
01:32:29.686 --> 01:32:32.367
That still looks pretty good to me.

1617
01:32:32.427 --> 01:32:32.627
Right?

1618
01:32:32.847 --> 01:32:35.307
6, 7, 12, 13.

1619
01:32:35.347 --> 01:32:36.628
These still look very beautiful.

1620
01:32:36.948 --> 01:32:37.268
So...

1621
01:32:37.967 --> 01:32:38.287
I don't know.

1622
01:32:38.347 --> 01:32:40.269
I'm not an anthropologist.

1623
01:32:40.669 --> 01:32:47.295
Maybe there's some way to quantify that these are less beautiful than the ones that were 16 and 32.

1624
01:32:48.416 --> 01:32:50.558
There's also some pushback in the CNN article.

1625
01:32:50.899 --> 01:32:56.944
There was a professor, Jens Harup, from Roskedeik University in Denmark.

1626
01:32:56.984 --> 01:33:01.568
He specializes in Mesopotamian mathematics, and he was not convinced.

1627
01:33:01.588 --> 01:33:02.950
He said that the symmetry...

1628
01:33:03.470 --> 01:33:09.453
is just an isolated incident of mathematical technique rather than the evidence of a broader mathematical reasoning.

1629
01:33:09.513 --> 01:33:13.856
If you just got to divide the circle nicely, of course you're going to get powers of two.

1630
01:33:14.336 --> 01:33:23.201
Now, he's an expert in Mesopotamian mathematics, which tells me that he's probably of the Sumerian city-states camp, and he wants the Sumerian city-states to be first.

1631
01:33:23.521 --> 01:33:28.664
So, you know, obviously with science there's a lot of, like, human tension.

1632
01:33:28.744 --> 01:33:28.924
Yes.

1633
01:33:29.484 --> 01:33:32.646
And it's worth something to think about, like, you know,

1634
01:33:33.917 --> 01:33:35.000
Is this just symmetry?

1635
01:33:36.043 --> 01:33:40.554
Or is consistently dividing a circle into 32 equal parts and then 64, it's...

1636
01:33:42.527 --> 01:34:06.323
inherently performing a mathematical operation without written symbols right yeah it's an open question i i think it's the symmetry is clear to me yes and to me we've had a lot of discussions about symmetry on this podcast and so symmetry is inherently a mathematical principle yes so to me i i think this is pretty cool right if you have not listened to it check out our chen ying yang episode i think it's episode 18 or 19

1637
01:34:07.664 --> 01:34:08.444
From season one, yeah.

1638
01:34:08.464 --> 01:34:12.646
From season one, where we go deep into the concept of symmetry.

1639
01:34:13.626 --> 01:34:17.987
And that was a lot of fan favorite episodes.

1640
01:34:18.167 --> 01:34:28.790
What's interesting here is I do, I think, get the tension of, like, there's, it looks aesthetically good versus understanding a broader mathematical context of why it looks so good.

1641
01:34:28.970 --> 01:34:29.211
Yeah.

1642
01:34:29.771 --> 01:34:31.211
That feels fair to me.

1643
01:34:31.231 --> 01:34:31.751
Yeah, yeah.

1644
01:34:32.011 --> 01:34:35.853
Like, I can sort of see, like, yeah, like, you know, I make things that look good all the time.

1645
01:34:35.893 --> 01:34:36.953
I don't know the math behind it.

1646
01:34:36.973 --> 01:34:37.073
Yeah.

1647
01:34:37.093 --> 01:34:37.193
Yeah.

1648
01:34:38.174 --> 01:34:43.942
But given how early it is, even being able to compute aesthetic value.

1649
01:34:44.142 --> 01:34:44.362
Yeah.

1650
01:34:44.763 --> 01:34:46.986
And have it all over the civilization.

1651
01:34:47.126 --> 01:34:47.366
Right.

1652
01:34:47.887 --> 01:34:53.034
And clearly it was a part of some aspect of culture, whether it's economics or otherwise.

1653
01:34:53.154 --> 01:34:53.374
Yeah.

1654
01:34:53.675 --> 01:34:55.477
That it's not just...

1655
01:34:56.551 --> 01:35:19.671
for it's clearly a shared visual language yes right yeah yes yes and so i this this is interesting so what what is your what is your conclusion here my conclusion is that i do think that they were doing something mathematical because of the 64 okay that's all yeah the 64 bowl with the four quadrants and then that was the four by four grid in each of them that was like yeah

1656
01:35:19.811 --> 01:35:22.713
That was pretty like, oh, okay, that's like, you know, they're doing something.

1657
01:35:22.853 --> 01:35:23.133
Yeah.

1658
01:35:23.414 --> 01:35:23.954
No.

1659
01:35:24.054 --> 01:35:25.355
But again, it could just be symmetry.

1660
01:35:25.695 --> 01:35:30.598
I like to think that there's mathematics because I just like to find the beauty in things.

1661
01:35:30.698 --> 01:35:33.620
But, you know, who knows?

1662
01:35:34.821 --> 01:35:36.963
For those who have stayed this long...

1663
01:35:38.039 --> 01:35:42.141
And worked through mathematics, which you've always said we're never going to cover mathematics.

1664
01:35:42.181 --> 01:35:44.483
And you broke your rule because it's so good.

1665
01:35:45.143 --> 01:35:47.064
And it was kind of light mathematics.

1666
01:35:47.144 --> 01:35:48.545
Light, you know, mathematics light.

1667
01:35:48.925 --> 01:35:50.086
What do you guys think?

1668
01:35:50.246 --> 01:35:55.729
Do you think this Halafi work on the pottery and stuff, do you think it's math?

1669
01:35:56.209 --> 01:35:56.989
Do you think it's art?

1670
01:35:57.409 --> 01:35:57.950
Do you think it's...

1671
01:35:58.650 --> 01:36:00.834
Art math, math art.

1672
01:36:00.994 --> 01:36:02.156
Let us know in the comments.

1673
01:36:02.356 --> 01:36:06.042
As always, we like to know how folks get to the end of the episode.

1674
01:36:06.783 --> 01:36:08.626
And it just helps us with that little comment.

1675
01:36:09.708 --> 01:36:10.830
We are going to...

1676
01:36:12.217 --> 01:36:18.441
wrap up here today with a follow-up from the cloud nine story.

1677
01:36:18.461 --> 01:36:19.502
Yeah.

1678
01:36:19.882 --> 01:36:24.586
Potential for dark matter gas cloud from the last episode.

1679
01:36:24.606 --> 01:36:25.727
I'll let you take it away here.

1680
01:36:25.847 --> 01:36:26.067
Yeah.

1681
01:36:26.107 --> 01:36:30.990
I mean, we, at the end of the last episode, we asked our audience, what do you guys think?

1682
01:36:32.211 --> 01:36:33.592
caused the name Cloud9.

1683
01:36:34.213 --> 01:36:41.860
And, you know, some of the authors of the episode that we sent the link to, they actually made it that far as well, which is great.

1684
01:36:41.880 --> 01:36:42.441
Yes, yes.

1685
01:36:42.641 --> 01:36:45.263
And they were asking...

1686
01:36:45.283 --> 01:36:46.284
They actually let us know.

1687
01:36:46.624 --> 01:36:46.805
Yes.

1688
01:36:46.945 --> 01:36:49.087
What is the story behind the name Cloud9?

1689
01:36:49.127 --> 01:36:49.327
So...

1690
01:36:50.528 --> 01:36:57.089
This particular response comes from Alejandro Lambe, but actually most of the authors of that study responded with very similar takes.

1691
01:36:57.409 --> 01:37:00.090
I'll just sort of paraphrase how he put it.

1692
01:37:00.510 --> 01:37:09.951
So back in February 2023, he read a paper about a potential dark galaxy candidate that was identified by the FAST telescope, which is the big Arecibo-like telescope in China.

1693
01:37:10.552 --> 01:37:18.433
And the authors were initially unaware of Alejandro's earlier paper where he had described this idea of relics.

1694
01:37:18.613 --> 01:37:18.793
Yes.

1695
01:37:18.973 --> 01:37:23.737
He was one of the original authors of that relics paper being like, hey, there should be something like this out there.

1696
01:37:23.897 --> 01:37:24.077
Yes.

1697
01:37:24.138 --> 01:37:25.198
So he emails them.

1698
01:37:25.779 --> 01:37:29.342
The gas cloud that he emailed them about turned out to actually be a galaxy.

1699
01:37:29.522 --> 01:37:32.605
So when you point at optical telescope, you see stars and it's just a galaxy.

1700
01:37:33.065 --> 01:37:34.907
Then the same fast guys.

1701
01:37:34.927 --> 01:37:35.007
Yes.

1702
01:37:35.267 --> 01:37:35.427
Yes.

1703
01:37:36.268 --> 01:37:58.947
in china they look at this object cloud nine and cloud nine was named cloud nine because it was the ninth object that they had seen in that direction okay so it was just the cloud nine and in china there's no sort of cultural meaning for the phrase cloud nine the fast guys then emailed alejandro back being like hey this could be a new candidate and this was the ninth cloud in their radio survey

1704
01:38:00.340 --> 01:38:03.782
The authors were aware of Alejandro, and then they sort of teamed together.

1705
01:38:04.222 --> 01:38:07.164
They went, looked at the analysis from the VLA.

1706
01:38:07.444 --> 01:38:16.028
The VLA actually could pinpoint where Cloud 9 was because the fast telescope is this giant thing that's just sort of like stuck to the Earth, right?

1707
01:38:16.288 --> 01:38:19.710
So it doesn't have very good angular resolution on where this thing is coming from.

1708
01:38:20.110 --> 01:38:22.872
VLA could then pinpoint and be like, it's actually right there.

1709
01:38:23.312 --> 01:38:26.834
Once you have those coordinates, then you can go to the Hubble guys at NASA and be like, hey, look—

1710
01:38:28.412 --> 01:38:31.534
I actually know where it is, and I'd really like to look at it.

1711
01:38:32.435 --> 01:38:37.177
The Hubble guys gave the authors some time, and that's where we get that paper from Cloud9.

1712
01:38:37.497 --> 01:38:44.321
They kept the name because, you know, if it turns out that Cloud9 is a relic, then the authors would be on Cloud9.

1713
01:38:44.401 --> 01:38:46.423
So they kept that name for that reason.

1714
01:38:46.743 --> 01:38:47.823
But that's what's behind it.

1715
01:38:49.444 --> 01:38:50.164
Which is very cool.

1716
01:38:50.184 --> 01:38:53.305
We always love naming conventions on this show.

1717
01:38:53.325 --> 01:38:54.245
Yeah.

1718
01:38:54.785 --> 01:38:56.986
And it was great to get outreach from everyone on the team.

1719
01:38:57.046 --> 01:38:58.246
Yeah, that was awesome.

1720
01:38:58.546 --> 01:39:14.970
If we happen to cover, if you're listening now and you happen to be in a lab on a research team, having had a story by us covered at some point and there is a correction, you can always make sure you reach out to us to facilitate that correction in a future episode.

1721
01:39:16.350 --> 01:39:18.791
We do our best to cover it as accurately as possible.

1722
01:39:19.291 --> 01:39:21.072
But there's no one better than the experts.

1723
01:39:21.232 --> 01:39:30.474
And so we are really grateful that the team for the relics paper were just so enthusiastic in providing feedback and loving the coverage.

1724
01:39:31.595 --> 01:39:35.096
This was a fantastic episode 23.

1725
01:39:35.116 --> 01:39:35.376
Yeah.

1726
01:39:36.176 --> 01:39:38.877
The Time Vault story is still so nuts to me.

1727
01:39:39.699 --> 01:39:41.520
wrapping notes for housekeeping.

1728
01:39:41.960 --> 01:39:48.104
Again, if you want us to cover a paper, you can go to FFPPod.com backslash submissions.

1729
01:39:48.524 --> 01:39:57.729
We have a Reddit style upvote, downvote ranking board on there that can help you in the community, provide us stories you want us to cover in the future.

1730
01:39:58.269 --> 01:40:05.653
As we mentioned earlier in the pod, we do have an Artemis special coming up next week.

1731
01:40:06.393 --> 01:40:08.955
So that will be a one story deep dive.

1732
01:40:09.895 --> 01:40:11.897
we will probably still do a rundown as well.

1733
01:40:12.697 --> 01:40:18.721
But just if you're listening this far, you're a fan, just be aware of that so you're not disappointed when you tune in next week.

1734
01:40:19.101 --> 01:40:21.323
We're going to get into a bunch of weeds.

1735
01:40:21.343 --> 01:40:29.628
I am your host, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chaudhary.

1736
01:40:30.288 --> 01:40:32.970
This is From First Principles.
