WEBVTT

1
00:00:02.656 --> 00:00:04.018
A listener production.

2
00:00:04.800 --> 00:00:14.094
Hi, I'm Hannah.

3
00:00:14.155 --> 00:00:14.776
And I'm Sarah.

4
00:00:14.796 --> 00:00:16.118
And this is Big Small Talk.

5
00:00:20.135 --> 00:00:25.519
This is the podcast where we try and cover the entirety of the news cycle, from the serious to the frivolous, all in one place.

6
00:00:25.599 --> 00:00:28.661
Because loving pop culture doesn't mean you don't understand politics.

7
00:00:28.941 --> 00:00:40.229
And today we're going to be talking about OpenAI hacking Medicare, Taylor Swift's new music, Lux Max and Guy clavicular charged, the VMAs, the UN General Assembly, and Susan Sarandon and Hannah Einbender arrested at protest.

8
00:00:40.529 --> 00:00:49.115
But before we begin today's episode, we would like to start by acknowledging the traditional owners of the land on which we're recording today, the Gadigal people, and pay our respect to Elders past and present.

9
00:00:49.525 --> 00:00:51.789
Before we get into the actual news, welcome back.

10
00:00:52.049 --> 00:00:53.191
It's good to be back.

11
00:00:53.451 --> 00:00:53.912
It's great.

12
00:00:54.152 --> 00:00:54.813
Can I just say?

13
00:00:54.833 --> 00:00:57.157
Top three best moments.

14
00:01:00.180 --> 00:01:03.301
Can I just say, I have loved having a two-week break.

15
00:01:03.501 --> 00:01:03.661
Yes.

16
00:01:03.681 --> 00:01:05.522
But my God, the stories were gold.

17
00:01:06.382 --> 00:01:06.922
I know.

18
00:01:07.042 --> 00:01:10.843
I was like trying to stay off my phone, but every time I got my phone, I'd be like... You actually...

19
00:01:11.303 --> 00:01:12.424
I missed two really good weeks.

20
00:01:12.624 --> 00:01:14.044
You missed two jam-packed weeks.

21
00:01:14.264 --> 00:01:15.645
Every week's hard in the news, right?

22
00:01:15.905 --> 00:01:17.325
But like, they were really good.

23
00:01:17.385 --> 00:01:19.166
There was so much conversation to them.

24
00:01:19.186 --> 00:01:19.386
Yeah.

25
00:01:19.746 --> 00:01:19.886
Yeah.

26
00:01:19.946 --> 00:01:21.846
And Justine, Angel.

27
00:01:22.007 --> 00:01:22.287
Angel.

28
00:01:22.307 --> 00:01:22.967
She's so good.

29
00:01:23.047 --> 00:01:23.527
I actually...

30
00:01:23.787 --> 00:01:27.052
I should tell the listeners before she went away, I was like, don't worry, you're much more qualified than me.

31
00:01:27.472 --> 00:01:29.475
Like Justine, legend of the trade.

32
00:01:29.515 --> 00:01:31.178
You know, like she did such a good job.

33
00:01:31.678 --> 00:01:32.359
It was awesome.

34
00:01:32.399 --> 00:01:35.263
It's also so sweet how everyone's been so nice.

35
00:01:35.423 --> 00:01:37.286
You're in such safe hands with Justine.

36
00:01:37.446 --> 00:01:37.587
Yes.

37
00:01:37.607 --> 00:01:38.147
Do you know what I mean?

38
00:01:38.648 --> 00:02:05.018
you haven't realized but clearly soft logic yeah obviously what is this what is happening right now but we did an audience trying to replace ourselves for some weird reason something's fishy about it sounds like something's changing and i'm not sure what they only disclaim it every second episode i put my finger on it um no obviously it's been it's been a stressful thing but when we did the audience survey last week so many nice comments and also just like warm hugs to me and i was like wow thanks guys i needed that more than you

39
00:02:05.878 --> 00:02:07.238
I was reading the comments on Spotify.

40
00:02:07.258 --> 00:02:10.799
People were like, we've loved having you both.

41
00:02:10.839 --> 00:02:13.340
People are saying goodbye to you as if you're leaving this week.

42
00:02:13.360 --> 00:02:13.880
I'm dead.

43
00:02:13.900 --> 00:02:15.680
Guys, we have like at least six months.

44
00:02:15.740 --> 00:02:16.520
No, it's okay.

45
00:02:16.600 --> 00:02:23.782
I really, I think in this sort of industry as well, it feels like it can be touchy and sensitive because so much of what we do is based in personality.

46
00:02:24.422 --> 00:02:29.363
And it's a hard thing emotionally to be transitioning, but it's so nice to have an audience of people who are just like,

47
00:02:29.963 --> 00:02:30.824
Go, you guys.

48
00:02:30.864 --> 00:02:31.804
It's so nice.

49
00:02:32.104 --> 00:02:33.065
I'll be here.

50
00:02:33.105 --> 00:02:37.027
You know, even if I'm campaigning, like I'll try and pop in for things.

51
00:02:37.047 --> 00:02:37.847
She's not dying.

52
00:02:37.867 --> 00:02:38.788
I'm not dying.

53
00:02:39.188 --> 00:02:39.868
I'll be fine.

54
00:02:39.888 --> 00:02:42.350
I might be exhausted, but I'll be present.

55
00:02:42.950 --> 00:02:50.594
I love it because for months before we announced like exactly what the plan was and what was happening to people, just message, does this mean Hannah can't do BST anymore?

56
00:02:50.614 --> 00:02:54.436
And I'm like, we cannot answer this until we have a clear pathway as well.

57
00:02:54.456 --> 00:02:55.156
We don't know yet.

58
00:02:55.176 --> 00:02:55.897
That was the stress.

59
00:02:55.937 --> 00:02:56.657
I love how we know.

60
00:02:56.797 --> 00:02:59.559
We never plan to talk about this and then we just get into it in our personal headlines.

61
00:02:59.699 --> 00:03:01.201
This was not in the planning meeting at all.

62
00:03:01.301 --> 00:03:05.444
But it is a good way for me to, again, bring up the audience survey.

63
00:03:05.464 --> 00:03:07.426
Because that has been so useful.

64
00:03:07.446 --> 00:03:09.067
Nearly 2,000 people have responded on it.

65
00:03:09.647 --> 00:03:12.550
We want as many people as possible to complete that audience survey.

66
00:03:12.750 --> 00:03:17.893
Genuinely, because it really helps with planning for the rest of this year and into next year.

67
00:03:17.993 --> 00:03:20.915
And we do make this show, believe it or not, for you guys, not us.

68
00:03:21.595 --> 00:03:27.279
And also, we do sit, the three of us in a room, a lot and give feedback based on what we think we should do.

69
00:03:27.459 --> 00:03:29.620
And we actually need you to give clear feedback.

70
00:03:29.640 --> 00:03:32.202
So, for example, one of the questions is, do you prefer four or six stories?

71
00:03:32.222 --> 00:03:35.504
Now, for months, I've been banging on about saying we should do four.

72
00:03:35.824 --> 00:03:37.445
The majority of the audience, one, six.

73
00:03:37.465 --> 00:03:38.646
So, dead wrong.

74
00:03:38.746 --> 00:03:38.846
Yeah.

75
00:03:40.707 --> 00:03:42.428
That actually felt like a little victory to me.

76
00:03:42.649 --> 00:03:47.312
I've always been the one to push, like, no, you need to keep the pace, pace, pace, pace.

77
00:03:47.412 --> 00:03:52.936
I don't usually push back on Sarah in the production side of things, but this is one thing I was sure of, and I've been proven wrong yet again.

78
00:03:52.956 --> 00:03:54.817
And I think that's humbling and important.

79
00:03:55.037 --> 00:03:56.818
No, but there was also stuff like, you know...

80
00:03:58.159 --> 00:03:59.160
for Small Talk.

81
00:03:59.540 --> 00:04:05.303
Obviously, we were getting so excited at big guests, which, by the way, I'm continuing with because we've already kind of done it for this year.

82
00:04:06.324 --> 00:04:08.325
She's a huge guest this week.

83
00:04:08.505 --> 00:04:12.028
So it's like ironic that I'm saying this right now because I do have like the biggest guest ever coming up.

84
00:04:12.048 --> 00:04:13.328
The biggest guest ever.

85
00:04:13.348 --> 00:04:14.189
I'm so excited.

86
00:04:14.509 --> 00:04:15.109
I'm so excited.

87
00:04:15.710 --> 00:04:21.413
But it was so interesting that like 80% of the audience doesn't actually care who the guest is.

88
00:04:21.453 --> 00:04:22.434
They care about the topic.

89
00:04:22.914 --> 00:04:23.755
Wait, can we get back to your holiday?

90
00:04:23.835 --> 00:04:24.475
Let's get back to it.

91
00:04:24.535 --> 00:04:26.456
Actually, I was going to say like holiday is one thing.

92
00:04:26.476 --> 00:04:27.457
I got

93
00:04:27.637 --> 00:04:29.418
back on Friday night at like 9pm.

94
00:04:29.879 --> 00:04:34.102
It's Monday afternoon when we're recording this episode, but I slept 19 hours yesterday.

95
00:04:34.142 --> 00:04:36.083
I was not good after getting back from holiday.

96
00:04:36.123 --> 00:04:36.844
I was not well.

97
00:04:36.864 --> 00:04:37.985
Like jet lag?

98
00:04:38.405 --> 00:04:41.467
I suspect the flight food did not treat me very well.

99
00:04:41.707 --> 00:04:42.548
I can't believe you ate it.

100
00:04:43.368 --> 00:04:46.551
Hey, since you, when we fly together, you're like, give me your snacks.

101
00:04:46.751 --> 00:04:47.531
I'm putting my blindfold on.

102
00:04:47.551 --> 00:04:48.212
Hannah don't speak to me.

103
00:04:48.232 --> 00:04:51.714
I was like, I missed the meal because I took five sleeping tablets.

104
00:04:52.395 --> 00:04:53.356
I had to check if you were dead.

105
00:04:53.456 --> 00:04:54.636
I checked your pulse multiple times.

106
00:04:56.787 --> 00:04:57.547
But yeah, I'm recovered.

107
00:04:57.567 --> 00:04:58.388
The holiday was great.

108
00:04:58.448 --> 00:04:59.048
It was needed.

109
00:04:59.428 --> 00:05:04.290
At the Thailand airport for our connection, two women held up their phones and went, I'm listening.

110
00:05:05.151 --> 00:05:09.273
But it was 5 a.m. And to one of them, I was like, Queen, thank you.

111
00:05:09.353 --> 00:05:10.653
And then I said, I'm really sorry.

112
00:05:10.673 --> 00:05:14.555
There's like nothing in the tank right now because it was 5 a.m. and we're out after a 10-hour flight.

113
00:05:14.915 --> 00:05:18.637
And she said, I'm just doing it because you said on the pod to say hello with every person.

114
00:05:18.677 --> 00:05:21.438
I had to say, like, I'm so sorry I'm letting you down right now.

115
00:05:21.458 --> 00:05:24.740
Like, right now, I am not the person you think I am.

116
00:05:24.760 --> 00:05:25.280
I'm joking.

117
00:05:26.335 --> 00:05:29.077
Well, I had my witch's night on the weekend, right?

118
00:05:29.097 --> 00:05:29.357
Of course.

119
00:05:29.617 --> 00:05:33.479
Which, by the way, I cooked and it tasted good last week.

120
00:05:33.559 --> 00:05:34.780
That's actually gold.

121
00:05:34.820 --> 00:05:35.441
Like, stop.

122
00:05:35.521 --> 00:05:36.741
I was talking about how I couldn't cook.

123
00:05:36.821 --> 00:05:37.322
You can't.

124
00:05:37.722 --> 00:05:39.543
But I apparently can.

125
00:05:39.603 --> 00:05:40.163
What did you make?

126
00:05:40.924 --> 00:05:42.505
A slow-cooked lamb shoulder.

127
00:05:42.525 --> 00:05:43.826
Dude, that's pretty tough.

128
00:05:43.866 --> 00:05:44.186
Right?

129
00:05:44.526 --> 00:05:46.907
I thought you were going to say salmon bowls.

130
00:05:48.248 --> 00:05:50.829
I had it my way for and have a minute's steak.

131
00:05:51.829 --> 00:05:53.669
But no, I did the whole shebang.

132
00:05:53.709 --> 00:05:58.831
I did potatoes and a slow roast lamb shoulder and leg.

133
00:05:59.071 --> 00:06:00.791
The whole shebang.

134
00:06:00.811 --> 00:06:01.671
The whole shebang.

135
00:06:02.251 --> 00:06:07.213
And then everyone did tarot cards and birthday books and we hexed people and then we went to the club.

136
00:06:07.653 --> 00:06:10.333
And so then we went out, but we were like, I still had my hat on.

137
00:06:10.873 --> 00:06:13.014
And then I was out and then people go like, oh, I love the pod.

138
00:06:13.034 --> 00:06:15.655
And I was like, this is a crazy way to meet me, actually.

139
00:06:18.075 --> 00:06:18.515
Sorry about that.

140
00:06:19.335 --> 00:06:22.577
My final thing is I'm starting a national tour on Thursday like a normal person.

141
00:06:23.377 --> 00:06:28.538
So Canberra Thursday, Sydney Friday, Adelaide Saturday, Brisbane Sunday, back for the pod.

142
00:06:29.439 --> 00:06:30.679
Your life is...

143
00:06:30.699 --> 00:06:32.360
I'm just... And then we're at Newcastle.

144
00:06:32.460 --> 00:06:34.080
Then we're going Melbourne, Newcastle, Perth.

145
00:06:34.100 --> 00:06:35.081
So please buy tickets.

146
00:06:35.121 --> 00:06:36.621
Perth and Melbourne practically sold out.

147
00:06:37.301 --> 00:06:39.442
But if you're especially Canberra and Adelaide, I need you.

148
00:06:40.562 --> 00:06:40.762
Rise.

149
00:06:40.782 --> 00:06:41.983
Frankly, get up.

150
00:06:42.745 --> 00:06:44.507
Thursday, Canberra, Adelaide, Saturday.

151
00:06:44.707 --> 00:06:45.528
I'm not going to say anything more.

152
00:06:45.568 --> 00:06:46.408
I'm going to need you to rise.

153
00:06:46.909 --> 00:06:47.609
Do a girl solid.

154
00:06:49.071 --> 00:06:50.272
I'm not sure what's happening in those two areas.

155
00:06:50.312 --> 00:06:51.153
I know it's a long weekend.

156
00:06:51.213 --> 00:06:51.973
I'm going to need you to rise.

157
00:06:52.554 --> 00:06:56.217
We love that we've had the longest personal headline and I haven't even heard about Ireland.

158
00:06:56.297 --> 00:06:57.498
I've not said a thing about the trip.

159
00:06:57.878 --> 00:06:59.140
Okay, maybe that's next week.

160
00:06:59.180 --> 00:06:59.780
Lots have happened.

161
00:06:59.980 --> 00:07:01.482
Maybe we can just sprinkle it in throughout the episode.

162
00:07:01.502 --> 00:07:02.282
We should get into it.

163
00:07:02.302 --> 00:07:02.823
Let's get into it.

164
00:07:05.178 --> 00:07:11.205
OpenAI hacked the Medicare portal actually a few months ago, and we are only just hearing about it in the last week.

165
00:07:11.786 --> 00:07:12.506
Scary headline.

166
00:07:12.707 --> 00:07:13.487
Pretty scary headline.

167
00:07:13.528 --> 00:07:17.192
Also noticing that AI is becoming a feature of every week at the moment.

168
00:07:17.292 --> 00:07:17.472
I know.

169
00:07:17.492 --> 00:07:21.036
This is like when we went through a stage where we had to talk about Trump every single week.

170
00:07:21.136 --> 00:07:24.878
And to be fair, we still could be, but we kind of just decided at a certain point, I can't do it.

171
00:07:25.178 --> 00:07:25.458
Yeah.

172
00:07:25.718 --> 00:07:28.159
Let's just start with, I think, the crux of what's happened.

173
00:07:28.639 --> 00:07:36.723
So last week, the Prime Minister Anthony Albanese revealed that an open AI agent hacked into the Australian Medicare data portal and that this happened...

174
00:07:37.403 --> 00:07:38.703
a little while ago in June.

175
00:07:39.424 --> 00:07:44.285
Anthony Albanese was in New York leading Australia's delegation at the UN General Assembly.

176
00:07:44.725 --> 00:07:52.007
And he was there launching what was basically a campaign for a temporary seat for Australia on the United Nations Security Council.

177
00:07:52.027 --> 00:07:54.608
Now, I'm going to cover that in a later segment more in depth.

178
00:07:54.748 --> 00:07:57.629
This is still about AI hacking Medicare's portal.

179
00:07:58.652 --> 00:08:11.557
And speaking from New York at the General Assembly, at sort of the sidelines of this event, he told reporters what had happened, which was that an open AI agent had gained unauthorised access to the Medicare Statistics Reporting Portal.

180
00:08:11.897 --> 00:08:13.458
It's a lot of words there as well.

181
00:08:13.598 --> 00:08:15.759
So what is the portal?

182
00:08:15.779 --> 00:08:18.220
Like, what did the AI agent actually get?

183
00:08:18.400 --> 00:08:22.482
Okay, so this is a portal that is run by Services Australia.

184
00:08:22.602 --> 00:08:29.545
What it does is it provides data on our healthcare programs, things like the PBS, vaccines, organ donations.

185
00:08:29.565 --> 00:08:31.425
Like there's a lot of annual reporting here.

186
00:08:31.846 --> 00:08:32.986
Very interesting, I know.

187
00:08:33.006 --> 00:08:34.627
Okay, stay with me.

188
00:08:34.647 --> 00:08:35.387
Oh, I'm with you.

189
00:08:35.447 --> 00:08:35.967
Yeah, I'm with you.

190
00:08:36.187 --> 00:08:39.889
So nothing that identifies individuals goes into these reports.

191
00:08:40.229 --> 00:08:48.872
But what's important to note here as well, even in saying that, is that the AI agent did access public-facing and non-public-facing data.

192
00:08:48.992 --> 00:08:50.233
The scary thing is just that it can.

193
00:08:50.593 --> 00:08:51.473
Yes, of course.

194
00:08:51.533 --> 00:08:54.594
And again, it's like, this is not the Medicare itself sort of thing.

195
00:08:54.694 --> 00:09:01.917
It's kind of like this public and non-public-facing component that has, again, not individual information, but different reporting measures.

196
00:09:02.237 --> 00:09:03.498
Not sure it makes me feel better.

197
00:09:03.578 --> 00:09:04.379
No, I know.

198
00:09:04.399 --> 00:09:08.162
But I think it's important to make the disclaimer too as well to try and be as accurate as possible.

199
00:09:08.623 --> 00:09:15.549
What the government has stressed is that the non-public data wasn't, in quotations, particularly sensitive information.

200
00:09:16.189 --> 00:09:23.135
So as you're saying, in this situation, it's less about what the AI agent has accessed and more about the fact that they could gain access.

201
00:09:23.756 --> 00:09:25.657
It's a security breach and that's what matters.

202
00:09:25.678 --> 00:09:26.238
Right.

203
00:09:26.338 --> 00:09:36.584
It's also worth noting that the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare, the Vic Health Department and the New South Wales Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research may have also been affected by the security breach.

204
00:09:37.004 --> 00:09:38.625
So it does go further.

205
00:09:38.925 --> 00:09:39.365
Yeah.

206
00:09:40.106 --> 00:09:40.666
Oh, wow.

207
00:09:40.846 --> 00:09:41.046
Yeah.

208
00:09:41.206 --> 00:09:41.547
OK.

209
00:09:42.367 --> 00:09:44.168
So how did this even happen in the first place?

210
00:09:44.308 --> 00:09:48.771
So, and again, this is according to what the government understands has happened.

211
00:09:49.828 --> 00:09:57.911
OpenAI gave the agent a, in quotations, benign task of researching public medicine's spending.

212
00:09:58.211 --> 00:10:01.812
So then in the process of doing this, it's come across the Services Australia portal.

213
00:10:02.192 --> 00:10:04.793
It tried to ask the portal a series of questions.

214
00:10:05.473 --> 00:10:13.116
And when it didn't get what it needed, it found a security workaround, gained unauthorised access, and then got the information that wasn't even public.

215
00:10:13.558 --> 00:10:15.979
But I don't understand why we're only hearing about this now.

216
00:10:16.599 --> 00:10:21.680
There has been speculation that potentially Albanese withheld this information.

217
00:10:22.340 --> 00:10:24.001
Again, we can't confirm that.

218
00:10:24.021 --> 00:10:25.281
I want to be really clear about that.

219
00:10:25.681 --> 00:10:30.423
But the coalition have accused him of holding onto the info until he was in New York.

220
00:10:30.783 --> 00:10:31.783
What would be the purpose of that?

221
00:10:31.843 --> 00:10:36.504
Well, Sam Altman, the head of OpenAI, was giving a United Nations address.

222
00:10:37.044 --> 00:10:42.286
So there was kind of speculation that given Albanese was in New York at this time, that it coincided with that.

223
00:10:42.927 --> 00:10:47.328
OpenAI has also publicly admitted that they found out about the hacking back in August.

224
00:10:47.861 --> 00:10:55.284
Albanese, again, has, I want to be clear on this, has said that Australia only learned about the breach after OpenAI sent them an email on September 10.

225
00:10:55.644 --> 00:10:56.544
Tough email to send.

226
00:10:56.704 --> 00:11:06.028
Also, can I just say what's interesting about this is that apparently OpenAI literally sent the disclosure to a public inbox of Services Australia.

227
00:11:06.528 --> 00:11:08.549
So they didn't get in touch with the government official.

228
00:11:08.569 --> 00:11:10.690
They didn't try and contact the prime minister's office.

229
00:11:10.710 --> 00:11:13.191
They didn't try and contact the relevant minister's office.

230
00:11:14.051 --> 00:11:19.032
They literally just use like the public disclosures, kind of like Services Australia email.

231
00:11:20.132 --> 00:11:25.313
And I also saw in different reporting that that email inbox is only checked like every 24 hours.

232
00:11:25.713 --> 00:11:27.214
So it took extra time to even pick up on this.

233
00:11:27.254 --> 00:11:29.474
But again, that was different reporting that I read on that.

234
00:11:29.494 --> 00:11:29.854
That's so sus.

235
00:11:30.054 --> 00:11:30.374
Yeah.

236
00:11:30.754 --> 00:11:36.556
Now, Services Australia told the Australian Foreign Intelligence and Cybersecurity Agency on September 15.

237
00:11:36.996 --> 00:11:43.557
My understanding is that Albanese delivered this information in Australia time the 17th of September, but it was September 16th in the US.

238
00:11:43.977 --> 00:11:51.042
Albanese also said he had a frank conversation with Sam Altman where he expressed disappointment that the company took way too long to sort of deliver that information to the government.

239
00:11:51.802 --> 00:12:02.889
And to add to how I think significant and just like ludicrous the situation is, Sam Altman literally met with Richard Miles, who's our deputy PM in San Francisco on the 1st of September.

240
00:12:03.129 --> 00:12:08.773
You know, our understanding is if he did know at the time, they didn't tell Miles about it two weeks before they had the conversation as well.

241
00:12:08.973 --> 00:12:18.041
I wonder if they didn't know, because at least where I've seen other AI stories of like AI going rogue, it could have happened ages ago and no one's really able to pick up on it.

242
00:12:18.341 --> 00:12:25.548
Again, like, of course, I'm coming at this from a biased perspective, as always disclosing that I'm running against Albanese in his seat as an independent.

243
00:12:26.068 --> 00:12:29.251
But ultimately, like a security breach of this nature...

244
00:12:29.671 --> 00:12:32.752
if it was an individual, like there are laws that criminalize that, right?

245
00:12:32.792 --> 00:12:38.113
Like to say you're disappointed that OpenAI hacked a government website, like this is serious.

246
00:12:38.153 --> 00:12:46.515
And I think the language of disappointment when we're talking about like artificial intelligence breaching government, public and non-public facing material, that is serious.

247
00:12:46.575 --> 00:12:53.057
And to know that they could have breached other portals or, you know, frameworks as well of the government, like this is really concerning.

248
00:12:53.077 --> 00:12:53.717
Well, it's also...

249
00:12:53.917 --> 00:12:59.324
Just a week ago, we were talking about the fact that we were getting warnings that AI is going to kill us all.

250
00:12:59.624 --> 00:13:03.209
And then they hack into our Medicare like a week.

251
00:13:03.629 --> 00:13:04.270
It's all just.

252
00:13:04.350 --> 00:13:07.874
And then at the same time, you're watching Zuckerberg do all his meta.

253
00:13:08.035 --> 00:13:09.977
Have you seen all the videos of him with his meta glasses?

254
00:13:10.137 --> 00:13:12.959
doing the like, here's the future and speak to an agent.

255
00:13:12.979 --> 00:13:14.841
And I'm going, this episode sucks.

256
00:13:14.901 --> 00:13:16.102
Like, I hate this timeline.

257
00:13:16.142 --> 00:13:16.602
Totally.

258
00:13:16.922 --> 00:13:25.169
And also like, this is a global story because this is the first time that, you know, the first time we know of that AI has hacked a government system of any kind.

259
00:13:25.329 --> 00:13:26.269
So it's fair to be worried.

260
00:13:26.429 --> 00:13:27.730
It's fair to be worried, of course.

261
00:13:27.810 --> 00:13:37.814
But I think it's also important to say that, like, you know, we've talked on this podcast multiple times, as you've said, about different hacks, different, you know, AI agents in sandbox environments, haha sandbox.

262
00:13:38.135 --> 00:13:42.296
Like there's been so many things that we've spoken about and we're learning quite rapidly about this.

263
00:13:42.797 --> 00:13:46.638
It is kind of complicated to talk about because we don't understand much of the infrastructure of AI.

264
00:13:46.658 --> 00:13:47.959
So we are trying to keep up with AI.

265
00:13:48.339 --> 00:13:51.742
And I think it's important to try and be measured about, okay, what is the risk here?

266
00:13:51.762 --> 00:13:53.664
We're hearing that there's a threat that will kill us all.

267
00:13:53.724 --> 00:13:56.867
We're then seeing government hacking, but let's have a reasoned approach.

268
00:13:57.328 --> 00:14:01.191
My reasoned approach is like, why are we talking about this through disappointment and concern?

269
00:14:01.412 --> 00:14:06.917
This is a much higher threshold if this AI agent is hacking government system and we're not finding out about it for multiple months.

270
00:14:07.017 --> 00:14:17.143
No, but it's also concerning that whenever there is a conversation about AI, it is Sam Altman and, you know, the head of Anthropic going, yeah, no, this is really scary.

271
00:14:17.163 --> 00:14:17.764
We're scared too.

272
00:14:17.824 --> 00:14:18.504
We're not going to stop it.

273
00:14:18.524 --> 00:14:21.446
We're seeing the leaders of AI are scared.

274
00:14:21.686 --> 00:14:27.210
And their speeches are increasingly becoming, you know, we want to be safe and cautioned in this approach and let's take practical steps.

275
00:14:27.510 --> 00:14:30.392
The rhetoric is very much like, we understand your concern, you know.

276
00:14:30.872 --> 00:14:33.413
Again, you are in the power position.

277
00:14:33.453 --> 00:14:33.674
Yeah.

278
00:14:34.054 --> 00:14:35.675
But it's also like...

279
00:14:36.315 --> 00:14:38.918
We know that the government wants to undertake an investigation into this.

280
00:14:39.178 --> 00:14:43.343
They're also establishing a task force, you know, looking at the legality of what's happened here.

281
00:14:43.683 --> 00:14:46.506
They're also going to be, you know, examining emerging cyber threats more broadly.

282
00:14:46.786 --> 00:14:48.528
But doesn't this just feel like jargon?

283
00:14:48.848 --> 00:14:50.010
Like, I'm really struggling with this.

284
00:14:50.050 --> 00:14:51.511
Like, we're going to establish a task force.

285
00:14:51.551 --> 00:14:54.014
I'm like, I think we'll be on the fucking task force.

286
00:14:54.414 --> 00:14:55.055
It sounds like.

287
00:14:55.235 --> 00:14:59.537
When you're in like a big company and HR is saying a lot, but they're not helping you.

288
00:14:59.557 --> 00:15:02.638
Yeah, you're like, this is like the worst PR statement I've ever seen.

289
00:15:02.798 --> 00:15:10.302
No, it's like you are a concerned employee and HR is not on your side, but it wants you to feel safe at work.

290
00:15:11.562 --> 00:15:12.362
That's the feeling.

291
00:15:12.642 --> 00:15:13.763
It's really scary.

292
00:15:13.783 --> 00:15:23.967
But again, we've got to wait for this to unfold a bit more, but it's just really tough to see this alongside and I think kind of overshadowing much of the discussion at the moment about AI, copyright, stealing artists' work.

293
00:15:24.007 --> 00:15:26.748
There's a lot of conversations to be had there as well, which we'll cover in the coming weeks too.

294
00:15:28.972 --> 00:15:32.995
Taylor Swift's new music has arrived and unfortunately, so of my opinion.

295
00:15:35.316 --> 00:15:35.897
Where were you?

296
00:15:35.917 --> 00:15:37.518
I was on the plane.

297
00:15:38.078 --> 00:15:39.199
That's kind of the place to be for it.

298
00:15:39.219 --> 00:15:41.881
Yeah, I was on my second flight, dead tired.

299
00:15:41.921 --> 00:15:43.802
And I thought, you know what, let's lock in.

300
00:15:43.902 --> 00:15:46.804
I got a little bit of Wi-Fi for an hour and I spent them listening to this music.

301
00:15:46.964 --> 00:15:50.908
Also, if anyone's like, I don't want you guys to talk about Taylor Swift, that's fair.

302
00:15:50.928 --> 00:15:51.288
We have to.

303
00:15:51.308 --> 00:15:52.129
It's our job.

304
00:15:52.329 --> 00:15:52.849
But it's okay.

305
00:15:52.869 --> 00:15:53.910
You can skip this segment.

306
00:15:53.970 --> 00:15:54.811
Hey, skip it.

307
00:15:54.931 --> 00:15:55.312
It's allowed.

308
00:15:55.892 --> 00:16:00.917
So on the weekend, Taylor Swift released an extended version of her album, Life of a Showgirl.

309
00:16:01.297 --> 00:16:04.040
She's called this like a deluxe version of the album.

310
00:16:04.120 --> 00:16:05.161
It's called The Encore.

311
00:16:05.361 --> 00:16:07.143
It has four brand new tracks.

312
00:16:07.783 --> 00:16:10.166
They're not vault tracks, though, apparently.

313
00:16:10.827 --> 00:16:19.017
According to Taylor Swift herself, she made these new songs on a celebration trip to Sweden with her producers Max Martin and Shellback.

314
00:16:19.217 --> 00:16:23.523
And essentially they were there celebrating the success of the album and then came up with another four songs.

315
00:16:23.543 --> 00:16:23.763
Yeah.

316
00:16:24.824 --> 00:16:28.046
Obviously, anything that Taylor Swift does will shoot to the top.

317
00:16:28.287 --> 00:16:30.008
It will be commercially successful.

318
00:16:30.348 --> 00:16:36.953
She could start just doing, and I think she could be, doing social experiments about what she could put out and still go to the top.

319
00:16:37.593 --> 00:16:45.559
But I think that's a very different kind of success to the success of being critically acclaimed or being revered for the art.

320
00:16:45.579 --> 00:16:50.963
I personally don't think Life of a Showgirl is one of the all-time classics.

321
00:16:51.263 --> 00:16:53.185
I also thought it would grow on me, and it didn't.

322
00:16:53.654 --> 00:17:00.976
I do think it's funny that she saw, I mean, overall, Life of a Showgirl, even though it was big, it didn't get a lot of great reviews.

323
00:17:01.216 --> 00:17:04.757
And it certainly to the general public wasn't particularly well received.

324
00:17:05.117 --> 00:17:10.399
So I do love that she saw all of that feedback and said, I'm going to give them the encore, exactly what they want.

325
00:17:11.499 --> 00:17:14.040
Also, I would say that these songs feel very life of a showgirl.

326
00:17:14.060 --> 00:17:16.780
Like she really hasn't internalized any of the negative feedback.

327
00:17:16.820 --> 00:17:19.181
And they're quite inspirational.

328
00:17:19.201 --> 00:17:25.662
And so like to do this post the release to have these songs, like that's why they do feel like Volt tracks to me.

329
00:17:26.463 --> 00:17:33.744
In saying that, if I believe her, that she wrote these songs in a day in Sweden, then really the takeaway from this is slow down.

330
00:17:34.244 --> 00:17:34.644
Why?

331
00:17:34.784 --> 00:17:36.045
Why would we do it in a day?

332
00:17:36.145 --> 00:17:36.745
Slow down.

333
00:17:36.905 --> 00:17:37.625
Why would we do it in a day?

334
00:17:37.645 --> 00:17:39.726
Let's take some advice we wouldn't take ourselves.

335
00:17:39.806 --> 00:17:41.106
We're writing too fast.

336
00:17:41.927 --> 00:17:56.478
well i think it's interesting because some of the most famous songs of all time were written in under an hour like that's kind of a like didn't like dolly parton right she did she wrote jolene and um i will always love you in the same day yes but it's like a story for the age's

337
00:17:56.538 --> 00:17:57.338
because it's unusual.

338
00:17:57.358 --> 00:17:57.999
That's what I was going to say.

339
00:17:58.019 --> 00:17:59.339
It only becomes a claim.

340
00:17:59.739 --> 00:18:07.783
Now, I've also seen plenty of people comment on the fact that her Opalite music video has Patient for the Encore written in the background.

341
00:18:08.343 --> 00:18:11.265
So knowing Taylor Swift, everything is intentional.

342
00:18:11.305 --> 00:18:13.485
So a lot of people are like, maybe this was always the plan.

343
00:18:13.505 --> 00:18:15.987
Maybe she always knew that was in the back pocket as an option.

344
00:18:16.327 --> 00:18:22.950
But if that's the case, then I don't understand why she vocalised that she had this strict album with only 12 songs.

345
00:18:23.270 --> 00:18:25.471
It was like only 12 songs for her 12th album.

346
00:18:26.071 --> 00:18:28.032
But we know that more is more.

347
00:18:28.332 --> 00:18:32.914
Life of a Showgirl still dropped like three dozen variants of the album, which was enough.

348
00:18:33.154 --> 00:18:33.334
Yeah.

349
00:18:33.974 --> 00:18:36.415
It was enough for fans to start tracking in a spreadsheet.

350
00:18:37.396 --> 00:18:38.256
So I'm not surprised.

351
00:18:38.436 --> 00:18:41.738
I also think part of this is because she knows that she's going to be successful.

352
00:18:41.758 --> 00:18:44.919
She's not really burdened with this, like, I need to prove myself mentality.

353
00:18:45.359 --> 00:18:47.820
And I think that's also potentially part of the problem right now.

354
00:18:48.300 --> 00:18:50.621
So she releases, we consume, it'll go to the top.

355
00:18:50.641 --> 00:18:52.042
There's no reason to stop kind of thing.

356
00:18:52.242 --> 00:18:52.963
Wow, that rhymed.

357
00:18:53.083 --> 00:18:53.783
That was really fun.

358
00:18:53.803 --> 00:18:54.564
I didn't intend to do that.

359
00:18:54.924 --> 00:18:56.525
Also, it's Grammy voting time.

360
00:18:56.966 --> 00:18:58.747
So I do think this is part of the strategy.

361
00:18:59.507 --> 00:18:59.968
And I get it.

362
00:19:00.228 --> 00:19:04.891
There is a belief that Taylor Swift songs need to marinate, as we were saying, and that it might take a few lessons.

363
00:19:05.392 --> 00:19:08.734
And I do believe that because that has happened to a lot of songs of hers with me.

364
00:19:08.754 --> 00:19:11.797
And I'm sure it'll happen to a few songs on this encore as well.

365
00:19:12.617 --> 00:19:14.579
I don't think that's necessarily a good thing, though.

366
00:19:14.619 --> 00:19:14.779
Like...

367
00:19:15.379 --> 00:19:20.841
This is where I start getting like conspiracy theory with myself on, um, is this a social experiment sometimes?

368
00:19:21.482 --> 00:19:27.204
Like, I know we said that about reputation and now I'm like, yeah, she was actually just kind of, maybe she was just ahead of the game on that one.

369
00:19:27.224 --> 00:19:30.425
Like maybe those songs did take a second, but then I don't think it's true for everything.

370
00:19:30.505 --> 00:19:31.906
Like, I don't think it's true for me.

371
00:19:32.246 --> 00:19:34.047
It's true to some things like karma is a cat.

372
00:19:34.127 --> 00:19:37.808
I can eventually like, it's, it's like white noise.

373
00:19:37.828 --> 00:19:38.388
Same actually.

374
00:19:38.428 --> 00:19:39.049
You know what?

375
00:19:39.409 --> 00:19:40.229
Um, what's it for me?

376
00:19:40.309 --> 00:19:42.290
The, uh, the, I'm a monster on the hill.

377
00:19:42.610 --> 00:20:05.833
you know yeah sexy baby sexy baby is poetic as a tall girl i get what she was trying to do there but it sort of landed in the way that all tall girls do with a bit of a thud a six foot two woman i'm like tell you a five fucking 11 chill out and i just i think if before people come for me i just want to say i need you to sit with yourself honestly and say if katie perry released those four songs today

378
00:20:07.629 --> 00:20:09.870
we would annihilate her.

379
00:20:10.270 --> 00:20:15.933
I just think Katy Perry is a good example of someone who we actually did annihilate.

380
00:20:15.993 --> 00:20:20.395
Collectively, the universe, when she was doing like Swish Swish and Woman's World, we said no.

381
00:20:21.376 --> 00:20:21.856
Stop that.

382
00:20:21.976 --> 00:20:24.857
And she was bullied into putting better music out again.

383
00:20:25.478 --> 00:20:28.179
And maybe we need that feedback loop a bit more.

384
00:20:28.783 --> 00:20:30.644
I shouldn't dream about her untrusted judo last night.

385
00:20:30.664 --> 00:20:32.944
I'm only remembering that because of you saying that now.

386
00:20:34.184 --> 00:20:35.345
It's a crazy thing to dream about.

387
00:20:35.705 --> 00:20:36.265
It was.

388
00:20:36.365 --> 00:20:36.745
It was.

389
00:20:37.185 --> 00:20:41.486
So I think for this encore to have made sense whatsoever, she did have to come back with some serious bangers.

390
00:20:41.966 --> 00:20:43.447
I do think this was a double down, though.

391
00:20:43.847 --> 00:20:44.967
Let's start with Patient Zero.

392
00:20:45.667 --> 00:20:53.289
This song is a warning to another woman who's now with one of her exes, and the music video stars Colin Farrell and also Dakota Johnson.

393
00:20:53.409 --> 00:20:54.310
It premiered at the VMAs.

394
00:20:55.790 --> 00:20:57.912
maybe this is one that would grow on me.

395
00:20:58.032 --> 00:20:58.813
I'm open to it.

396
00:20:59.213 --> 00:21:01.335
I just felt like something was missing in the production.

397
00:21:01.656 --> 00:21:03.597
I think the lyrics weren't quite scathing enough.

398
00:21:03.838 --> 00:21:05.119
You wanted a revenge song.

399
00:21:05.139 --> 00:21:07.261
Well, I mean, I guess... Not even that, or deep enough.

400
00:21:07.301 --> 00:21:07.681
I don't know.

401
00:21:07.761 --> 00:21:09.062
It was a good concept.

402
00:21:09.142 --> 00:21:09.483
Yeah.

403
00:21:09.623 --> 00:21:10.564
Also, the angle is...

404
00:21:11.024 --> 00:21:11.745
very relatable.

405
00:21:12.185 --> 00:21:15.347
Like she explained that she wrote the song after hanging out with friends.

406
00:21:15.748 --> 00:21:22.293
And then one shared that an ex new girlfriend had reached out to ask if she'd experienced the same toxic behavior.

407
00:21:22.753 --> 00:21:28.637
And then that got the whole table talking about times it's like similar things has happened to them or like times they wish they reached out, whatever.

408
00:21:29.178 --> 00:21:34.642
And so she landed on patient zero, really liked that as a concept and built the song around it.

409
00:21:35.002 --> 00:21:36.764
But I also think that's why it's somewhat clunky.

410
00:21:37.024 --> 00:21:37.164
Mm hmm.

411
00:21:37.524 --> 00:21:38.585
So let's get into it.

412
00:21:39.086 --> 00:21:41.629
I know he charmed your family and friends.

413
00:21:41.729 --> 00:21:46.855
And you thought it's because he loves you, but it's because he loves how everybody else loves him.

414
00:21:46.875 --> 00:21:47.856
Uh-huh.

415
00:21:48.657 --> 00:21:50.018
I mean, like, that's a two-second clip.

416
00:21:50.619 --> 00:21:54.283
I'm realising after listening to that that I didn't finish listening to Patient Zero on the plane.

417
00:21:54.583 --> 00:21:55.765
Oh, you didn't get to the talking bridge?

418
00:21:55.905 --> 00:21:56.746
That goes on.

419
00:21:56.826 --> 00:21:58.508
When I just heard that, I was shocked.

420
00:21:59.253 --> 00:22:21.403
also say this is like random and I know this is random but like patient zero the concept of patient zero right comes from early HIV research did you know that no like that phrase has been around since the 1980s because there was this like theory of patient zero and then that was debunked and so for decades the term was sort of used to demonize queer sex so it was a good point that was I think

421
00:22:21.923 --> 00:22:23.424
was it Vulture, I think, brought that up?

422
00:22:23.444 --> 00:22:26.606
That was like, her bookishness reached a limit with that one.

423
00:22:26.626 --> 00:22:35.051
It's interesting because it's a question of like, is that an inappropriate use of a phrase or has the phrase taken on new meaning that she is?

424
00:22:35.651 --> 00:22:36.072
Yeah.

425
00:22:36.232 --> 00:22:41.455
It sort of reminds me of like the song, I Hate It Here, that's like without all the racists or whatever.

426
00:22:42.495 --> 00:22:42.896
Clunky.

427
00:22:43.036 --> 00:22:43.216
Yeah.

428
00:22:44.437 --> 00:22:44.877
Cleveland.

429
00:22:46.055 --> 00:22:49.239
I feel like everyone's kind of in agreement on these four tracks.

430
00:22:49.260 --> 00:22:53.085
So it feels like more acceptable to be a critic, but I am finding it tough.

431
00:22:53.105 --> 00:22:56.469
Like I'm, I'm finding it just mean, but I am like, this is terrible.

432
00:22:56.850 --> 00:22:58.552
I love, love.

433
00:22:58.652 --> 00:22:59.974
Like, I don't like that.

434
00:22:59.994 --> 00:23:01.957
I have to be like, what is this?

435
00:23:01.977 --> 00:23:02.678
Can I be serious?

436
00:23:02.698 --> 00:23:02.858
Like,

437
00:23:03.559 --> 00:23:09.082
I think the problematic tone of a lot of criticism has been like, we're upset that she's in love because now her music sucks.

438
00:23:09.222 --> 00:23:10.883
I don't think that- No, I didn't understand.

439
00:23:10.903 --> 00:23:11.503
I don't agree with that.

440
00:23:11.543 --> 00:23:15.325
I also don't agree with the trope that you have to be suffering to be a great artist.

441
00:23:15.345 --> 00:23:16.906
No, it's also not even true in her case.

442
00:23:17.006 --> 00:23:19.087
She's written amazing love songs.

443
00:23:19.688 --> 00:23:20.688
Let's go back to Daylight.

444
00:23:21.269 --> 00:23:22.249
Let's go back to Love Story.

445
00:23:22.409 --> 00:23:23.390
Wow, let's go back to Love Story.

446
00:23:23.430 --> 00:23:23.850
Wait, let's go back.

447
00:23:24.110 --> 00:23:26.411
If she released Love Story today, what would you review it as?

448
00:23:26.991 --> 00:23:28.251
I just love that song, though.

449
00:23:28.291 --> 00:23:32.072
I think to be fair to that song, she was 17, 18 when it came out and we were like 10.

450
00:23:32.112 --> 00:23:35.333
There are songs that you can only write at a certain age.

451
00:23:35.553 --> 00:23:36.273
Do you know what I mean?

452
00:23:36.293 --> 00:23:37.493
And that was of the era.

453
00:23:37.873 --> 00:23:43.275
Look, in defense of us being able to critique this song, she does say, so hate all you like, this is the love of my life.

454
00:23:43.315 --> 00:23:46.355
And so that is the mission that I need to in fact hate on this song.

455
00:23:46.375 --> 00:23:47.316
You know what it feels like?

456
00:23:47.356 --> 00:23:52.577
It feels like sometimes someone missing the point where they're kind of getting ahead of criticism, but you're like, oh, it's, I'm not hating...

457
00:23:53.297 --> 00:23:55.058
the song because it's about the love of your life.

458
00:23:55.078 --> 00:23:56.439
Like, it's just not good.

459
00:23:56.459 --> 00:23:59.101
Look, everyone online sort of saying this, this isn't a fresh take.

460
00:23:59.161 --> 00:24:06.146
But yes, like she's obviously more consumed with the way her relationship is perceived, as opposed to anything else.

461
00:24:06.166 --> 00:24:10.349
Like, she is way more concerned with how the world sees them than how she sees them.

462
00:24:10.369 --> 00:24:12.031
And I think you see that in the difference in songwriting.

463
00:24:12.051 --> 00:24:16.274
Like when you hear some of the other love songs that she's written in the past, she's writing about what she loves about them.

464
00:24:16.554 --> 00:24:20.737
Whereas this love song is very much just about like, fuck you guys, this is what we look like.

465
00:24:20.957 --> 00:24:21.277
I don't know.

466
00:24:21.297 --> 00:24:25.640
It's a really different approach and way of writing about those emotions.

467
00:24:25.800 --> 00:24:27.602
And it's also like we've seen it in Wood.

468
00:24:27.622 --> 00:24:28.622
We've seen it now in Cleveland.

469
00:24:28.642 --> 00:24:30.183
Like it's the same message.

470
00:24:30.203 --> 00:24:34.686
But can I say actually like I like Wood actually aged on me well.

471
00:24:34.746 --> 00:24:36.267
Like I think that song's so fun.

472
00:24:36.628 --> 00:24:37.088
Cleveland.

473
00:24:37.148 --> 00:24:37.748
No, Wood.

474
00:24:38.069 --> 00:24:39.610
Like when I first listened to it, I was like, whoa, Taylor.

475
00:24:40.570 --> 00:24:54.244
whoa but like i really enjoyed like that's a boppy song like i listen to when i'm like going for a run like i love that song yeah like i like that kind of sexy fun she's in love yeah she's having a great time with travis we get it like we get what you're saying

476
00:24:55.805 --> 00:24:56.466
But you know what I'm saying?

477
00:24:56.486 --> 00:25:03.050
Like, even Wishlist, I understood the political critique of, like, a bit, like, people concerned that it's kind of a right-wing swing with this, like, marriage thing.

478
00:25:03.070 --> 00:25:03.930
I was kind of like, oh, that's a bit fun.

479
00:25:03.950 --> 00:25:05.051
Like, I think it's a fun song.

480
00:25:05.371 --> 00:25:06.332
I get where she's coming from.

481
00:25:06.392 --> 00:25:06.852
I listen to it.

482
00:25:06.872 --> 00:25:07.412
I like it.

483
00:25:07.833 --> 00:25:08.893
Look, I get what you're saying there.

484
00:25:09.113 --> 00:25:10.134
You're a pop girly.

485
00:25:10.514 --> 00:25:10.954
I am.

486
00:25:10.974 --> 00:25:11.415
You are.

487
00:25:11.595 --> 00:25:11.755
But...

488
00:25:11.915 --> 00:25:13.997
Cleveland, I literally had to turn it off again.

489
00:25:14.037 --> 00:25:15.498
I was like, I'm not sure I can finish this.

490
00:25:15.518 --> 00:25:18.741
But I am a lyrics person over a music person.

491
00:25:19.201 --> 00:25:23.985
Like, even if a song's objectively bad, if I think the lyrics are good, I could probably convince myself to like it.

492
00:25:24.005 --> 00:25:25.887
And I think that's sometimes the marinating for me.

493
00:25:25.987 --> 00:25:29.330
But I'm struggling to connect with these songs as a whole.

494
00:25:29.410 --> 00:25:31.611
And I tried to reflect on why that was.

495
00:25:31.631 --> 00:25:33.233
Were you reflecting on the fact that you're...

496
00:25:34.639 --> 00:25:34.959
Sad.

497
00:25:36.220 --> 00:25:37.340
Maybe you're a different lifestyle.

498
00:25:37.560 --> 00:25:39.581
Maybe I haven't found Travi Baby yet.

499
00:25:39.781 --> 00:25:43.042
I was just going to say, I'm just going to, I'm a devil's advocate you here.

500
00:25:43.562 --> 00:25:44.403
Let's like, analyze.

501
00:25:44.443 --> 00:25:45.763
Someone's not liking a love song right now.

502
00:25:45.783 --> 00:25:47.304
Do you think, wonder why?

503
00:25:47.324 --> 00:25:48.024
Wonder why that is?

504
00:25:48.224 --> 00:25:49.425
No, do you know what it is?

505
00:25:49.805 --> 00:25:51.965
I do love love, but I don't want your football husband.

506
00:25:51.986 --> 00:25:54.466
And I don't like that you keep talking to me as if I want Travi Baby.

507
00:25:54.566 --> 00:25:55.947
I don't specifically

508
00:25:56.067 --> 00:25:57.828
It is a little bit of projection, isn't it?

509
00:25:57.868 --> 00:25:59.548
Like, it's a bit like you want him.

510
00:25:59.588 --> 00:26:00.288
It's like, no.

511
00:26:00.329 --> 00:26:02.229
No, I am really happy for you.

512
00:26:02.269 --> 00:26:06.991
Despite what you seem to think, I think we're all actually really happy about you and Travi baby.

513
00:26:07.571 --> 00:26:12.193
But I do not want your specific relationship as much as you seem to think that I do.

514
00:26:12.573 --> 00:26:16.374
Like, what I care about is your ability to connect to me.

515
00:26:16.854 --> 00:26:22.256
I like to be able to take what you've written and twist them so that it feels relevant to my life or my aspirations.

516
00:26:22.276 --> 00:26:24.037
This is the criticism of...

517
00:26:24.757 --> 00:26:47.307
of the fandom though is that like not everything's for you and it's not gonna fit you at every point in your life if all those great tales of songs is because you're like oh it's like she stole my diary and now i'm like this is definitely your diary not mine because it's too specific to travis and fame and things that are like a little bit out of touch which is the point of life for showgirl i get it can i actually add something to this as well i wasn't afraid to do it before i don't know why i'm asking permission now

518
00:26:48.808 --> 00:26:51.370
At first I was like, well, we just can't relate right now to this feeling.

519
00:26:51.531 --> 00:26:54.593
But I think it actually leans into the criticism, right?

520
00:26:54.633 --> 00:26:57.796
That she's played Girl Next Door for a really long time.

521
00:26:57.856 --> 00:27:00.659
And one of our criticisms has been, well, she's not Girl Next Door.

522
00:27:00.699 --> 00:27:01.759
She's a billionaire.

523
00:27:02.360 --> 00:27:06.564
And so like maybe we should stop having her play our little bestie.

524
00:27:06.744 --> 00:27:06.964
Yeah.

525
00:27:07.024 --> 00:27:07.504
But actually...

526
00:27:07.524 --> 00:27:08.045
I take it back.

527
00:27:08.345 --> 00:27:10.707
Now that she's not and she's playing herself.

528
00:27:10.867 --> 00:27:12.268
Well, we realise we can't connect with it.

529
00:27:12.548 --> 00:27:15.149
This is the thing I'm kind of going, I just don't like the music.

530
00:27:15.190 --> 00:27:16.290
It's not that I can't connect to it.

531
00:27:16.390 --> 00:27:17.971
I'm just going, it's not very good to me.

532
00:27:18.031 --> 00:27:18.912
I have a double whammy.

533
00:27:18.932 --> 00:27:20.973
I have both problems on my head.

534
00:27:20.993 --> 00:27:24.956
But I'm going, oh, is it unfair to critique because it just doesn't apply to me?

535
00:27:24.996 --> 00:27:26.617
But also, I just don't think I'm enjoying it.

536
00:27:26.697 --> 00:27:28.738
It kind of is a little column A, column B.

537
00:27:28.978 --> 00:27:32.301
The other thing, like if we look at some of the lyrics, though, there was another really good point.

538
00:27:32.321 --> 00:27:33.601
Shout out to Swiftologist.

539
00:27:33.781 --> 00:27:35.483
He's really entertaining to watch, I must say.

540
00:27:36.243 --> 00:27:41.666
But if you look at some of the lyrics from the song, she goes, she's not as hot as she was, but she was only a four.

541
00:27:42.006 --> 00:27:42.966
She was never a girl's girl.

542
00:27:42.986 --> 00:27:46.288
And she was just a, no, maybe I'd like these looks better.

543
00:27:46.308 --> 00:27:46.928
She just swore.

544
00:27:47.008 --> 00:27:49.470
I love a swear word in a song and she keeps taking them out.

545
00:27:49.830 --> 00:27:52.551
And with all of that money, why is she dressed like trash?

546
00:27:52.971 --> 00:27:54.332
When she smiled, it's annoying.

547
00:27:54.472 --> 00:27:56.473
And have you seen her stumbling clumsily?

548
00:27:56.733 --> 00:27:57.934
Would you even call that dancing?

549
00:27:57.974 --> 00:28:03.677
Now, the point of this was like, she's kind of acknowledging the hate and criticisms that she gets online all the time.

550
00:28:04.377 --> 00:28:10.824
But, like, these are not the core criticisms that is actually online about her right now.

551
00:28:10.844 --> 00:28:16.830
Like, if you think about it, there are actually some quite valid criticisms of Taylor Swift that we've spoken about a lot on this podcast.

552
00:28:16.850 --> 00:28:25.538
Like, political alignment or engagement, the billionaire status, the sucking money out of fans, questionable acquaintances, like...

553
00:28:26.519 --> 00:28:30.663
None of that, like that is the bulk of why people are feeling this unease towards her right now.

554
00:28:31.264 --> 00:28:34.567
It's not because she dances at a watchers.

555
00:28:34.587 --> 00:28:40.353
I think I want to add to that as well that like there is an element of exhaustion I find with like the perpetual victimhood.

556
00:28:41.392 --> 00:28:45.774
Like, because what you're saying, right, is here's all this good faith or like valid criticism.

557
00:28:46.274 --> 00:28:48.375
Even if it's not expressed in good faith, it can be valid.

558
00:28:49.295 --> 00:28:52.957
And here's like her re-angling to say how horrible everyone is.

559
00:28:53.457 --> 00:28:56.458
But again, she's not going to write songs about valid criticism.

560
00:28:56.478 --> 00:29:04.121
Like I'm not expecting her to write a song about like the capitalism of creating 36 vinyl editions and remixes of one.

561
00:29:04.141 --> 00:29:05.301
She's not going to do it, you know.

562
00:29:05.321 --> 00:29:05.842
Of course she's not.

563
00:29:06.042 --> 00:29:08.243
I mean, it kind of was maybe Who's Afraid of Little Old Me.

564
00:29:08.323 --> 00:29:08.603
But...

565
00:29:09.481 --> 00:29:10.362
It's interesting.

566
00:29:10.402 --> 00:29:11.403
Oh, please play a little.

567
00:29:11.703 --> 00:29:12.704
I'd love you to play a little.

568
00:29:13.244 --> 00:29:15.225
I'm really having a hard time with it.

569
00:29:32.387 --> 00:29:38.894
I've also seen, now we're just in a think piece, but a lot of people have been talking about the different relationships.

570
00:29:39.014 --> 00:29:40.055
Oh, the Joellen stuff?

571
00:29:40.175 --> 00:29:40.375
Yes.

572
00:29:40.595 --> 00:29:51.046
I think you have to bring up, because I don't think that's really fair that they keep, but I do think it's interesting how all of us, when we're in different relationships, it brings out a different insecurity in us.

573
00:29:51.066 --> 00:29:54.990
I'm not projecting this on Taylor Swift, but I'm just saying I do think that's quite a universal experience that...

574
00:29:55.530 --> 00:29:57.350
different relationships bring out different sides of you.

575
00:29:57.991 --> 00:30:00.091
I think that is natural that that happened.

576
00:30:00.511 --> 00:30:09.973
I think Maddie and Joe were so like indie and whatever in their own ways that I think that brought out that folklore evermore taught to poets.

577
00:30:09.993 --> 00:30:13.134
Like there was definitely, you can see what she's trying to prove with those albums.

578
00:30:13.554 --> 00:30:20.895
And then I think in this, I wonder if it's like their dynamic is now also trying to like, it really matters to be liked.

579
00:30:21.416 --> 00:30:23.256
It's also super American.

580
00:30:23.276 --> 00:30:23.476
Yeah.

581
00:30:24.440 --> 00:30:25.301
Super American.

582
00:30:25.341 --> 00:30:26.362
Do you find it jarring?

583
00:30:26.462 --> 00:30:27.783
It's so American.

584
00:30:27.823 --> 00:30:28.623
It's all American.

585
00:30:28.723 --> 00:30:33.067
And I think like, it's just like this interesting thing to watch is you're like, I guess we all do it at relationships.

586
00:30:33.087 --> 00:30:35.409
It's very fly the eagle, fly the flag.

587
00:30:35.449 --> 00:30:37.590
It's very interesting.

588
00:30:37.691 --> 00:30:38.711
I can feel that.

589
00:30:38.952 --> 00:30:41.894
I will say, I'm going to, I know we've done too much on this.

590
00:30:42.054 --> 00:30:44.316
God, but I didn't realize you were going to unlock something like this in me.

591
00:30:44.336 --> 00:30:45.096
I know a lot to say about this.

592
00:30:45.116 --> 00:30:45.977
This is the thing about Hales.

593
00:30:45.997 --> 00:30:47.758
Because I don't want to be unfair.

594
00:30:47.818 --> 00:30:48.899
It's fascinating.

595
00:30:48.959 --> 00:30:50.741
I don't want to be unfair, you know, but.

596
00:30:51.081 --> 00:30:51.641
Pink clouding?

597
00:30:52.462 --> 00:30:53.863
That was interesting to me.

598
00:30:54.223 --> 00:30:58.264
It's about her, like, kind of apologizing to an ex that she should have treated better.

599
00:30:58.744 --> 00:31:01.585
People think it might have been Tom Hiddleston that she's talking about.

600
00:31:02.365 --> 00:31:04.166
Really weird if that's where she's going.

601
00:31:04.206 --> 00:31:07.227
No, but listen to the lyrics and you, I kind of get it.

602
00:31:07.727 --> 00:31:08.928
Babylon, I actually like.

603
00:31:09.348 --> 00:31:10.248
Didn't like it at first.

604
00:31:10.388 --> 00:31:11.648
Listened to it about three times since.

605
00:31:11.949 --> 00:31:15.790
I think that one is the closest to, like, that's a classic Taylor Swift track.

606
00:31:15.970 --> 00:31:16.110
Mm-hmm.

607
00:31:16.530 --> 00:31:18.672
I had to figure out what it was about first.

608
00:31:18.933 --> 00:31:21.375
And then I was like, okay, I could handle this.

609
00:31:21.736 --> 00:31:25.119
But nonetheless, with this album, Taylor Swift has broken Spotify records.

610
00:31:25.620 --> 00:31:27.082
She shot to the top of Spotify.

611
00:31:27.122 --> 00:31:31.006
She became the most streamed female artist in a single day in 2026.

612
00:31:31.406 --> 00:31:36.612
And Patient Zero became Spotify's most streamed song by female artists in a single day this year so far.

613
00:31:37.232 --> 00:31:38.113
Also earlier this year.

614
00:31:38.714 --> 00:31:44.036
Taylor Swift was named the most streamed artist of all time since Spotify was launched nearly 20 years ago.

615
00:31:44.476 --> 00:31:50.018
She also made history in June as the youngest woman to be inducted into the Songwriters Hall of Fame.

616
00:31:50.419 --> 00:31:50.959
Mass appeal.

617
00:31:51.039 --> 00:32:00.603
Look, look, again, I just, I was interested when this came out and especially off the back of like Olivia Rodrigo's just released, you know, recently, like a lot's been coming out, Charlie XCX, like.

618
00:32:00.803 --> 00:32:06.565
That is my main thing here that I go, if you look at these other pop girlies and what they're putting out, the quality.

619
00:32:06.625 --> 00:32:10.308
quality of what they're putting out, the messages they're sending, the complexity.

620
00:32:10.348 --> 00:32:12.590
And a lot of them are doing pop really well.

621
00:32:12.710 --> 00:32:14.672
Chapel Rhone is a great example of doing pop really well.

622
00:32:15.012 --> 00:32:19.036
Livy Rodrigo's album, half of it, really happy, in love songs.

623
00:32:19.416 --> 00:32:24.460
Sabrina Carpenter is like the tongue in cheek pop, but she does it in such an effective way.

624
00:32:24.880 --> 00:32:27.042
They're still able to connect with all of us.

625
00:32:27.503 --> 00:32:30.205
And I think this is like this, that's an interesting comparison.

626
00:32:30.305 --> 00:32:33.188
If someone else came out with these four songs, would we be like, what?

627
00:32:34.128 --> 00:32:34.429
Yes.

628
00:32:34.569 --> 00:32:34.769
Hmm.

629
00:32:40.593 --> 00:32:56.464
looks maxing influencer clavicular has been charged with the rape of a teenage girl i just want to put a content warning at the top of this segment that we will be discussing sexual assault and rape but if also we need support after listening to this segment please contact 1-800-RESPECT on 1-800-799-7233 so what happened this is a really disturbing story

630
00:33:02.937 --> 00:33:07.282
And for those who don't know, Clavicula, his real name is Brayden Peters.

631
00:33:07.402 --> 00:33:11.547
I'm going to refer to him as Brayden Peters in this segment because I don't think someone...

632
00:33:11.627 --> 00:33:16.933
I think we should be calling him by his name, his legal name, when we're talking about the allegations against him.

633
00:33:17.373 --> 00:33:19.976
Now, this is a 20-year-old influencer who...

634
00:33:20.797 --> 00:33:24.359
Has a lot of infamy on the internet.

635
00:33:24.939 --> 00:33:26.620
No, he's known, I suppose.

636
00:33:26.980 --> 00:33:30.122
And he creates what's called looks-maxing content.

637
00:33:30.242 --> 00:33:34.544
Now, this is the sort of extreme end of self-improvement content.

638
00:33:34.904 --> 00:33:41.028
He's advocated for using what we can describe as some pretty severe or relentless sort of tactics to...

639
00:33:41.688 --> 00:33:46.393
to achieve, I'm going to say in quotations, physical attractiveness, because they're going to each their own on this.

640
00:33:46.833 --> 00:33:48.815
But it's really scary what he was engaging in.

641
00:33:48.835 --> 00:34:00.727
So he was publicly speaking about and engaging in hitting himself in the face with a hammer so his bones would grow back sharper or taking meth to suppress his appetite.

642
00:34:00.747 --> 00:34:01.088
Yeah.

643
00:34:01.328 --> 00:34:05.790
He even live streamed his nose job prior to Paris Fashion Week.

644
00:34:06.110 --> 00:34:09.951
He also went quite viral here when an Australian... Oh, God.

645
00:34:10.011 --> 00:34:11.092
Thank you for bringing that up.

646
00:34:11.112 --> 00:34:14.573
So he was interviewed by a... Is it a 60 Minutes or Spotlight reporter?

647
00:34:14.593 --> 00:34:15.733
I think it was 60 Minutes.

648
00:34:15.753 --> 00:34:16.373
I think it was 60 Minutes.

649
00:34:16.714 --> 00:34:17.954
And this guy was hot.

650
00:34:18.154 --> 00:34:19.595
They sent their hottest reporter in.

651
00:34:19.635 --> 00:34:20.435
He sent their hottest reporter.

652
00:34:20.455 --> 00:34:21.475
Actually, we saw him at the Lugies.

653
00:34:21.495 --> 00:34:22.456
Thank you for saying that.

654
00:34:22.516 --> 00:34:23.716
Okay, so I turn.

655
00:34:23.856 --> 00:34:25.717
I'm like two wines in and I turn to Sarah and I go...

656
00:34:26.257 --> 00:34:28.918
That guy over there is the guy that outmogged Clavicular.

657
00:34:28.938 --> 00:34:29.558
Is that how you say it?

658
00:34:29.878 --> 00:34:30.638
Would you say outmogged?

659
00:34:30.858 --> 00:34:31.018
Yeah.

660
00:34:31.178 --> 00:34:31.338
Yeah.

661
00:34:31.598 --> 00:34:32.179
Outmogged Clavicular.

662
00:34:32.199 --> 00:34:35.119
And you turn and you were like, your facial recognition is strong.

663
00:34:35.139 --> 00:34:37.900
And I was like, I'm like, I can, I can recognize journalists from segments.

664
00:34:37.980 --> 00:34:38.980
I'm like, there you are.

665
00:34:39.020 --> 00:34:40.321
And that guy, memorable.

666
00:34:40.341 --> 00:34:40.581
Yeah.

667
00:34:40.901 --> 00:34:43.982
Clavicular also like, he is a large creator.

668
00:34:44.022 --> 00:34:48.043
He has 3 million followers across TikTok, Instagram, and a messaging app called Kik.

669
00:34:48.083 --> 00:34:49.223
I didn't realize people used Kik.

670
00:34:50.184 --> 00:34:51.345
Is that a Gen Z thing?

671
00:34:51.885 --> 00:34:54.186
I thought it was us in high school.

672
00:34:54.686 --> 00:34:55.486
Is that a Gen Z thing?

673
00:34:55.546 --> 00:34:56.167
Is it Alpha?

674
00:34:56.187 --> 00:34:56.947
Yes, Alpha's next.

675
00:34:57.427 --> 00:35:00.569
We sound fucking old saying that.

676
00:35:00.589 --> 00:35:02.569
I just said, is outmogged the correct term?

677
00:35:02.589 --> 00:35:03.610
Is outmogged the correct term?

678
00:35:03.650 --> 00:35:04.630
And is that a Gen Z thing?

679
00:35:04.670 --> 00:35:05.651
No, I guess we're Gen Z.

680
00:35:05.731 --> 00:35:06.351
What's the next one?

681
00:35:06.371 --> 00:35:08.092
We're like elder Gen Z though.

682
00:35:08.132 --> 00:35:09.352
We are elder Gen Z. Yeah.

683
00:35:09.893 --> 00:35:17.596
Last week, Brayden Peters, otherwise known as Clavicula, was charged in connection with the rape of a teenage girl at his family's house in Cape Cod.

684
00:35:17.856 --> 00:35:19.137
So what do we know about this so far?

685
00:35:19.317 --> 00:35:23.579
So actually it was an independent publication called The Bulwark that first broke the story.

686
00:35:23.639 --> 00:35:25.440
Actually, they have a great podcast, highly recommend it.

687
00:35:25.460 --> 00:35:30.763
They were one of the trusted independent pods I listened to in the lead up to the US election in 2024.

688
00:35:31.283 --> 00:35:39.068
But according to the court records, Brayden Peters has been charged with giving a 17 year old girl vodka on a live stream and then raping her at a family home.

689
00:35:39.988 --> 00:35:46.073
We also should note at this point that his lawyers, one of his lawyers, has told media that he is innocent.

690
00:35:46.453 --> 00:35:51.017
This alleged rape is also said to have occurred back in May of 2025.

691
00:35:51.517 --> 00:35:58.642
The alleged victim survivor is also an influencer who Clavicula had paid to film looks-maxing videos.

692
00:35:59.583 --> 00:36:06.112
He'd invited her to his family home in Cape Cod because she thought that meeting him would boost her presence online.

693
00:36:07.214 --> 00:36:11.680
Apparently his mother and grandmother were in the house at the time of the attack, and

694
00:36:12.338 --> 00:36:18.141
And the lawsuit also claims that Brayden Peters' mother knew that excessive amounts of alcohol were being served.

695
00:36:18.561 --> 00:36:24.544
The victim survivors also told investigators that Brayden Peters had served her alcohol while on an internet live stream.

696
00:36:25.305 --> 00:36:28.746
He'd allegedly told her to lie on camera and say that she was 18.

697
00:36:29.367 --> 00:36:34.809
At one point, she allegedly said, wait, I'm so drunk though, before she and Brayden Peters kissed.

698
00:36:35.290 --> 00:36:39.732
After the live stream concluded, she told police he had had sex with her several times.

699
00:36:40.290 --> 00:36:47.737
An investigator wrote that she didn't have the ability, the capacity to consent, and that she didn't tell anyone the full extent of what had happened.

700
00:36:47.757 --> 00:36:53.743
But in April, she sued Brayden Peters in Miami with similar allegations to what is contained in these criminal charges.

701
00:36:54.103 --> 00:36:54.844
Has he responded?

702
00:36:55.484 --> 00:36:56.284
Mostly through lawyers.

703
00:36:56.664 --> 00:37:05.907
But when this Bullwalk article came out, Cliverkiller posted several times on X about the alleged victim and he wrote things like, in quotations, trying to get my attention in any way possible.

704
00:37:06.027 --> 00:37:07.207
A lawsuit?

705
00:37:07.387 --> 00:37:07.927
Seriously.

706
00:37:08.368 --> 00:37:09.368
Really petty of you.

707
00:37:10.128 --> 00:37:15.650
He also wrote in another post on that same day, happens to all successful young men, people try to come for your money.

708
00:37:15.930 --> 00:37:16.770
Greed is evil.

709
00:37:17.270 --> 00:37:23.992
It's also really important now that we point to the fact that Braden Peters has gotten in trouble with the law before.

710
00:37:24.613 --> 00:37:33.036
In March of this year, he was arrested in Florida after officials said that he had started a physical brawl between two women at an Airbnb rental and posted the footage online.

711
00:37:33.376 --> 00:37:34.556
Those charges were later dropped.

712
00:37:34.956 --> 00:37:45.160
And in April, he was also charged with unlawfully shooting a firearm after a viral video showed him and others firing a gun at a dead alligator in the Florida Everglades.

713
00:37:45.712 --> 00:37:51.397
The thing is, this is so devastating because it's unfortunately not surprising.

714
00:37:51.897 --> 00:37:52.078
No.

715
00:37:52.198 --> 00:37:58.984
And I think this is where we need to make the connection between looks maxing, which is like this like extreme self-improvement culture.

716
00:37:59.064 --> 00:38:02.406
But the fact that it is, its foundations are an insult culture.

717
00:38:02.647 --> 00:38:02.827
Yeah.

718
00:38:03.407 --> 00:38:03.607
And...

719
00:38:04.348 --> 00:38:17.313
You know, this is a very clear part of the manosphere, which relentlessly tells men to always be improving themselves, to meet this impossible beauty standard, but that dominance is at the root of masculinity.

720
00:38:17.634 --> 00:38:25.857
And when we position dominance as kind of like this measure of manhood, that encourages or incites violence against women.

721
00:38:25.897 --> 00:38:26.017
And...

722
00:38:26.017 --> 00:38:28.398
And again, I don't want to, again, this is a criminal investigation.

723
00:38:28.418 --> 00:38:29.318
We need to let that unfold.

724
00:38:29.738 --> 00:38:41.143
But having a separate conversation now about like the root cause of a lot of these issues is that this is men monetizing, encouraging other men to engage in, you know, violence towards self and others in many ways.

725
00:38:41.163 --> 00:38:46.565
If you're encouraging men to take meth and hammer themselves in the face for, you know, sharper bones.

726
00:38:47.185 --> 00:38:50.166
No, but also, again, it's rooted in entitlement.

727
00:38:50.404 --> 00:38:54.568
And it's rooted in a self-hatred that is projected and externalised onto others, right?

728
00:38:54.608 --> 00:38:55.129
Those like that.

729
00:38:55.269 --> 00:39:06.521
And again, we've mentioned a lot on the pod recently and you did an episode with Chanel Contos recently, but it comes back to a lot of what she said in a National Press Club address about this like commercialisation of these violent attitudes.

730
00:39:07.022 --> 00:39:09.004
It's a business model, first and foremost.

731
00:39:09.124 --> 00:39:09.384
Yes.

732
00:39:09.404 --> 00:39:09.765
The Manosphere.

733
00:39:09.785 --> 00:39:10.085
The Manosphere.

734
00:39:10.205 --> 00:39:20.611
And ultimately, I think, you know, what is missing here is this piece that like men are taught to be the most emotionally disconnected and physically masculine appearance of themselves and to treat women poorly.

735
00:39:20.631 --> 00:39:21.891
And that's some sort of form of success.

736
00:39:21.931 --> 00:39:28.155
But actually what women are asking for in the people that they date, have intimate experiences with, is someone who's emotionally connected to themselves.

737
00:39:28.615 --> 00:39:34.859
We're also not guessing with his connection or how deep he might be in Manosphere content.

738
00:39:34.879 --> 00:39:37.901
Like he was partying with Tristan, Tristan Tate.

739
00:39:38.121 --> 00:39:38.401
Yeah.

740
00:39:38.661 --> 00:39:48.208
It's one of those things where when I see look-smaxing influencers, I often feel a level of real sympathy for that desire and that feeling that must be so difficult and isolating.

741
00:39:48.228 --> 00:39:48.328
Yeah.

742
00:39:48.868 --> 00:39:59.913
But then we find out about, you know, these allegations and we're going, okay, well, it's not that you, you know, your self-struggle has become, you know, potentially allegedly violence against others.

743
00:39:59.953 --> 00:40:02.554
And it's like my sympathy ends there as well, you know?

744
00:40:02.654 --> 00:40:03.715
Well, that's the thing.

745
00:40:03.995 --> 00:40:09.257
Him partying with Tristan Tate, but also with white supremacist neo-Nazi Nick Fuentes.

746
00:40:09.338 --> 00:40:10.058
Nick Fuentes.

747
00:40:10.498 --> 00:40:14.080
And the group was seen singing along to Kanye West's song, Hail Hitler.

748
00:40:14.260 --> 00:40:15.640
This is like the crux of the issue.

749
00:40:15.660 --> 00:40:16.181
It's kind of like...

750
00:40:16.921 --> 00:40:26.548
We're expected to have empathy for men that are actively engaging in violent rhetoric and how that is like spread out into entire communities and users like for commercial gain.

751
00:40:26.568 --> 00:40:37.297
And it's like it is so difficult to be like trying to bring people in and have better conversations in this environment where there's such extreme dialogue and action playing out as well.

752
00:40:37.457 --> 00:40:37.657
Yeah.

753
00:40:40.256 --> 00:40:42.157
So the VMAs happened on Monday.

754
00:40:42.277 --> 00:40:43.638
Here's everything you need to know.

755
00:40:44.058 --> 00:40:48.840
Also, fun fact, we're actually recording a day early this week because you're away tomorrow.

756
00:40:49.240 --> 00:40:51.301
So this has actually happened today.

757
00:40:51.321 --> 00:40:52.682
So I've been watching the VMAs today.

758
00:40:52.822 --> 00:40:53.482
Great job.

759
00:40:53.522 --> 00:40:53.982
Great job.

760
00:40:54.522 --> 00:40:59.625
So it hasn't had a lot of time to sit with me, but let's do a bit of a run through.

761
00:40:59.705 --> 00:41:00.425
It's very fresh.

762
00:41:01.085 --> 00:41:02.126
Let's start with the red carpet.

763
00:41:02.206 --> 00:41:03.426
Have you seen any looks from it yet?

764
00:41:03.446 --> 00:41:03.706
Yeah.

765
00:41:03.746 --> 00:41:04.727
Taylor Swift, great look.

766
00:41:05.467 --> 00:41:06.427
Her best look.

767
00:41:06.547 --> 00:41:07.248
I think her best look ever.

768
00:41:07.268 --> 00:41:07.748
She was amazing.

769
00:41:07.768 --> 00:41:09.008
I actually think it was her best look ever.

770
00:41:09.268 --> 00:41:10.649
Oh my God, I loved it.

771
00:41:10.689 --> 00:41:12.930
If you heard our segment earlier and thought we were only here for criticism, no.

772
00:41:13.110 --> 00:41:14.250
No, credit where it's due.

773
00:41:14.470 --> 00:41:15.491
Credit where it's due.

774
00:41:15.951 --> 00:41:18.732
I do love VMA fashion because it's so much more fun.

775
00:41:19.092 --> 00:41:21.393
But yeah, I would say Taylor was best dressed for me.

776
00:41:21.713 --> 00:41:23.494
I also thought Charli XCX looked amazing.

777
00:41:24.154 --> 00:41:24.434
Amazing.

778
00:41:24.934 --> 00:41:26.335
Put them together for a photo.

779
00:41:27.135 --> 00:41:28.395
No, but God, they looked good.

780
00:41:28.595 --> 00:41:30.156
Troye Sivan also I enjoyed.

781
00:41:30.176 --> 00:41:32.957
He was quite experimental, but he had like feathers under his coat.

782
00:41:33.397 --> 00:41:42.979
I would say the big trends was you were either dressed kind of like gothic period piece, like a Wuthering Heights, but all black vibe, or you were in sparkles.

783
00:41:43.139 --> 00:41:44.660
It didn't seem to be much in between.

784
00:41:44.800 --> 00:41:48.741
If we go to the show, Madonna, of course, opened the show.

785
00:41:49.041 --> 00:41:51.602
She brought out both Sabrina Carpenter and Charlie XCX.

786
00:41:51.662 --> 00:41:51.922
Yeah.

787
00:41:52.622 --> 00:41:54.543
And can I just say, the stage presence.

788
00:41:54.643 --> 00:41:56.344
Sabrina is so good at performances.

789
00:41:56.464 --> 00:41:57.365
My God.

790
00:41:57.745 --> 00:41:58.346
She's amazing.

791
00:41:58.706 --> 00:42:04.910
Also, just crazy to think, I'm pretty sure the last time Madonna performed at the VMAs was when she kissed Christina and Britney Spears on stage.

792
00:42:05.410 --> 00:42:05.510
Oh.

793
00:42:06.308 --> 00:42:06.948
Great callback.

794
00:42:07.088 --> 00:42:14.931
Yeah, she started the medley by performing Bring Your Love with Sabrina and then moved to Dance Terrier, which is what she's done with Charlie.

795
00:42:15.271 --> 00:42:16.791
They collaborated on the remix together.

796
00:42:17.632 --> 00:42:21.053
And then there were just a bunch of celebrity cameos in this.

797
00:42:21.453 --> 00:42:27.515
Her longtime friend Debbie Mazar came out, which was a nice little full circle moment because she actually is nice.

798
00:42:27.515 --> 00:42:28.896
name checked in the song as well.

799
00:42:29.336 --> 00:42:38.181
Julia Garner, the actress, joined them on stage too, which is interesting because she's long been rumoured to be playing Madonna in the biopic that's upcoming.

800
00:42:38.341 --> 00:42:38.742
Really?

801
00:42:39.542 --> 00:42:41.543
Julia Garner played Inventing Anna.

802
00:42:42.324 --> 00:42:43.284
Oh, yeah.

803
00:42:43.324 --> 00:42:44.065
Can you picture her?

804
00:42:44.085 --> 00:42:45.285
Yeah.

805
00:42:45.345 --> 00:42:47.367
Sombra was on stage as well.

806
00:42:47.527 --> 00:42:49.428
And then somewhat randomly, Seth Rogen.

807
00:42:50.522 --> 00:42:52.423
Why Seth Rogen was there, I'm not entirely sure.

808
00:42:52.443 --> 00:42:56.386
I have not pieced that puzzle together yet, if anyone would like to fill that in for me.

809
00:42:56.446 --> 00:42:57.766
But it was a great performance.

810
00:42:58.107 --> 00:43:00.148
Other big moments or things worth mentioning.

811
00:43:00.568 --> 00:43:01.509
Snoop Dogg hosted.

812
00:43:02.129 --> 00:43:04.971
Kacey Musgraves gave the tribute to Dolly Parton.

813
00:43:04.991 --> 00:43:06.632
She sang, I Will Always Love You.

814
00:43:07.152 --> 00:43:11.194
Also, Sombra did a great job with Ray and Teddy Swims and Adam Lambert.

815
00:43:11.254 --> 00:43:12.915
And they did the George Michael tribute.

816
00:43:13.396 --> 00:43:15.297
Love their music, but it's like really emotive.

817
00:43:15.557 --> 00:43:18.319
No, and like, because it's been 10 years since George Michael's death.

818
00:43:19.139 --> 00:43:22.801
Ray crushed her performance of I Will Overcome and Where Is My Husband.

819
00:43:22.821 --> 00:43:24.943
She is an amazing vocalist.

820
00:43:25.043 --> 00:43:26.063
Star power on her.

821
00:43:26.123 --> 00:43:27.124
Amazing performer.

822
00:43:27.144 --> 00:43:27.924
Incredible.

823
00:43:28.585 --> 00:43:35.509
Taylor Swift then made VMA History on Sunday, becoming the first ever recipient of the Artist Director Honor.

824
00:43:36.269 --> 00:43:38.591
And Dakota Johnson presented her with the award...

825
00:43:39.171 --> 00:43:43.856
I think this is cool because she did direct 18 of her own music videos.

826
00:43:43.876 --> 00:43:44.396
18.

827
00:43:44.436 --> 00:43:45.637
That's amazing.

828
00:43:45.657 --> 00:43:46.338
It's really good.

829
00:43:46.398 --> 00:43:49.241
And like, I think the first one she ever did was The Man.

830
00:43:49.281 --> 00:43:50.682
I was about to say I thought it was The Man.

831
00:43:50.822 --> 00:43:51.243
Yeah.

832
00:43:51.483 --> 00:43:52.604
She did everything in The Man.

833
00:43:52.664 --> 00:43:56.948
Like it was like, I remember because it was like directed by, produced by, starred in.

834
00:43:57.088 --> 00:43:57.629
No, no.

835
00:43:57.809 --> 00:43:58.810
I think she's great at it.

836
00:43:59.030 --> 00:44:00.712
This award makes sense for the VMAs.

837
00:44:01.192 --> 00:44:03.695
I would like to say though, the VMAs.

838
00:44:04.035 --> 00:44:07.236
to me, felt more and more this year like an industry machine.

839
00:44:07.376 --> 00:44:08.076
It always has been.

840
00:44:08.096 --> 00:44:12.957
I remember we spoke about the VMAs a few weeks ago and I was like, this is a show created by the industry.

841
00:44:13.497 --> 00:44:22.459
It is voted by the people, but at the same time, the nominations are decided by and the awards are decided by and ultimately the winner is also decided by the industry, I discovered.

842
00:44:22.999 --> 00:44:32.742
But what's interesting about this new award is that the literal executive of the VMAs did an interview about this new award and why they decided to do it.

843
00:44:32.762 --> 00:44:33.862
I'm going to play a little snippet.

844
00:44:33.982 --> 00:44:40.125
It was an idea, quite frankly, the kernel of the idea actually, you know, came from external.

845
00:44:40.345 --> 00:44:41.046
I'll leave it at that.

846
00:44:41.486 --> 00:44:46.089
Essentially, he's saying that the idea for this came from an external source.

847
00:44:46.429 --> 00:44:51.471
And then he goes on to say this, like, now might even be considered like a bigger honor than even the Vanguard Award.

848
00:44:52.372 --> 00:44:56.854
Everyone immediately was like, OK, so someone's team suggested this award.

849
00:44:56.954 --> 00:44:57.255
Yeah.

850
00:44:58.815 --> 00:45:07.579
And like, I know that's potentially gossip, but the more I learn about so many award shows now is you're like, yeah, actually, this is all people's teams and this is all...

851
00:45:07.999 --> 00:45:10.500
Influence and negotiation and... Yeah.

852
00:45:10.640 --> 00:45:13.642
Plays into, well, that's a good way to get someone there.

853
00:45:13.662 --> 00:45:18.544
I was going to say, like, you know, when Taylor Swift is an award show, it draws a lot more attention to that award show.

854
00:45:18.564 --> 00:45:20.344
100%, which speaks to the influence.

855
00:45:20.445 --> 00:45:24.706
But it is interesting to be like, and then we came up with this award from external sources.

856
00:45:26.347 --> 00:45:28.989
Then there was the premiere of her new music video, Patient Zero.

857
00:45:29.129 --> 00:45:29.730
It's a good watch.

858
00:45:30.070 --> 00:45:30.910
I've only watched it once.

859
00:45:30.930 --> 00:45:32.451
I haven't had a full time to marinate on it.

860
00:45:32.491 --> 00:45:33.512
Might have more thoughts later.

861
00:45:34.013 --> 00:45:37.175
There was also a really special Nirvana reunion.

862
00:45:37.675 --> 00:45:48.503
So the surviving members of the band, Dave, Crist and Pat, came back together to accept the Video Vanguard Award more than 30 years after Nirvana first appeared at the VMAs.

863
00:45:49.123 --> 00:45:54.827
And Crist used the moment to pay tribute to Kurt Cobain, who died by suicide in 1994, and...

864
00:45:55.808 --> 00:46:04.634
And he spoke about how none of them could have imagined how much Nirvana's music and sound and whole aesthetic would come to mean to people, even still today.

865
00:46:05.054 --> 00:46:10.137
And how the band still resonates with people because they are hungry for something authentic and uncompromising.

866
00:46:10.677 --> 00:46:16.161
He also finished by saying Kurt would have loved his legacy and still gives people permission to simply come as you are.

867
00:46:18.082 --> 00:46:18.682
Winners of the night.

868
00:46:19.643 --> 00:46:21.504
The big award of the night is Video of the Year.

869
00:46:21.604 --> 00:46:22.225
Taylor Swift won.

870
00:46:22.873 --> 00:46:23.633
Big night for Taylor.

871
00:46:23.953 --> 00:46:24.734
Big night for Taylor.

872
00:46:24.774 --> 00:46:26.214
She won for The Fate of Ophelia.

873
00:46:26.694 --> 00:46:29.375
And also she dedicated that win to Dolly.

874
00:46:29.675 --> 00:46:31.196
Opalite also won Best Direction.

875
00:46:31.556 --> 00:46:32.796
Artist of the Year was Madonna.

876
00:46:33.076 --> 00:46:34.737
I think she won about seven awards.

877
00:46:35.117 --> 00:46:37.277
She did get kind of confused at points, I noticed.

878
00:46:37.357 --> 00:46:42.219
And when I was watching, like, at one point she needed, like, Charlie and Troye Sivan to remind her what the count is.

879
00:46:43.257 --> 00:46:44.218
and then she just had a launch.

880
00:46:44.238 --> 00:46:45.819
She's like, I've won again.

881
00:46:46.580 --> 00:46:49.762
Song of the Year was BTS with Swim.

882
00:46:49.842 --> 00:46:50.343
Right.

883
00:46:50.383 --> 00:46:51.684
Best Pop was Lisa.

884
00:46:52.164 --> 00:47:02.113
And this was really cute because she came on stage and I think she was, it was such a stacked category that I think she was a bit of an underdog in the category and she got on stage and she just looked so overwhelmed and then she started, she was like crying.

885
00:47:02.833 --> 00:47:09.639
Best Collab, Madonna and Sabrina, which I was surprised because I did think Stateside was going to win.

886
00:47:10.139 --> 00:47:10.459
Yes.

887
00:47:10.639 --> 00:47:13.081
And I just didn't love this song.

888
00:47:13.101 --> 00:47:13.162
No.

889
00:47:13.602 --> 00:47:16.244
But I will say the speech was quite funny.

890
00:47:16.264 --> 00:47:16.744
Let me show you.

891
00:47:16.905 --> 00:47:21.308
I would like to briefly say how this collaboration came about.

892
00:47:22.529 --> 00:47:25.111
Everybody who knows me knows how impatient I am.

893
00:47:26.012 --> 00:47:34.679
And when five days passed and I still didn't get connected with Sabrina and didn't hear back from her about whether she wanted to do a song with me.

894
00:47:36.220 --> 00:47:39.303
Five days, I DM'd her.

895
00:47:40.552 --> 00:47:40.752
Yeah.

896
00:47:42.334 --> 00:47:44.736
And... Sabrina's like, two not six.

897
00:47:44.756 --> 00:47:45.437
This is a true story.

898
00:47:45.477 --> 00:47:46.418
She answered me back.

899
00:47:47.159 --> 00:47:49.882
And I don't know, within weeks we were in the studio together.

900
00:47:49.922 --> 00:47:50.883
It was fabulous.

901
00:47:53.376 --> 00:47:56.698
I just, if you were to bring me like, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.

902
00:47:56.778 --> 00:47:57.298
I'm sorry.

903
00:47:57.318 --> 00:47:58.078
I was on holiday.

904
00:47:59.159 --> 00:47:59.859
Five days as well.

905
00:47:59.879 --> 00:48:00.999
She's probably on tour, the poor girl.

906
00:48:01.019 --> 00:48:01.900
She's been on tour for like a year.

907
00:48:01.920 --> 00:48:02.380
She's so busy.

908
00:48:03.220 --> 00:48:04.141
Best new artist?

909
00:48:04.661 --> 00:48:05.181
Sienna.

910
00:48:05.301 --> 00:48:05.922
Sienna Spiro.

911
00:48:05.962 --> 00:48:07.742
Is that that girl you put me on to?

912
00:48:07.762 --> 00:48:08.182
Yes.

913
00:48:08.202 --> 00:48:09.063
Great Expectations.

914
00:48:09.103 --> 00:48:09.383
Yes.

915
00:48:09.423 --> 00:48:10.724
The live version's so much better.

916
00:48:10.784 --> 00:48:12.924
She, oh, I'm going to play a snippet again.

917
00:48:12.944 --> 00:48:15.365
That's going to be my top song this year after you put me on to it in the pod.

918
00:48:15.486 --> 00:48:16.326
She is so good.

919
00:48:16.426 --> 00:48:18.907
I really think she's like next gen Adele.

920
00:48:19.387 --> 00:48:20.507
No, she's fucking good.

921
00:48:20.527 --> 00:48:21.368
Her voice is insane.

922
00:48:21.788 --> 00:48:22.708
Really good.

923
00:48:22.868 --> 00:48:23.448
She's so good.

924
00:48:23.468 --> 00:48:24.108
And it was so cute.

925
00:48:24.128 --> 00:48:31.170
When she did the paparazzi and you get to the end of the carpet, she had a little bag with her and she was so excited to be there.

926
00:48:31.190 --> 00:48:34.051
She got out of disposal and started taking photos of the paparazzi.

927
00:48:34.551 --> 00:48:35.371
That's iconic.

928
00:48:35.831 --> 00:48:37.891
Okay, this is her live.

929
00:48:38.011 --> 00:48:44.033
And you know how there's sort of a curse for people that it's the new artists and it's so nerve wracking.

930
00:48:44.213 --> 00:48:48.714
You're in one of the biggest industry rooms that a lot of people sound nervous.

931
00:48:49.574 --> 00:49:13.904
Oh, I sing just to know I'm alive And I cried all the tears I could cry If happiness is just an illusion You were the best I ever had If you can't be what I want And the things you say are true All I need is regret Expectation of you

932
00:49:15.757 --> 00:49:16.097
Awesome.

933
00:49:16.558 --> 00:49:17.499
Unbelievable.

934
00:49:17.579 --> 00:49:18.699
Great Expectations Live.

935
00:49:18.800 --> 00:49:20.341
It's like the Spotify studios or something.

936
00:49:20.501 --> 00:49:20.881
So good.

937
00:49:20.901 --> 00:49:21.442
Save It Now.

938
00:49:21.602 --> 00:49:22.443
It's so good.

939
00:49:22.683 --> 00:49:28.507
Olivia Rodrigo, despite really not getting any nominations and not being there, she did win Best Alternative for The Cure.

940
00:49:28.948 --> 00:49:34.452
Taylor Swift is now also the most awarded artist in VMA's history with 30 wins.

941
00:49:34.993 --> 00:49:35.894
And your final question?

942
00:49:36.973 --> 00:49:40.354
Where did this new award come from?

943
00:49:40.374 --> 00:49:41.575
Look, I love the VMAs.

944
00:49:41.595 --> 00:49:42.575
I think it's a really fun watch.

945
00:49:42.735 --> 00:49:47.937
But I do think, I keep coming back to it, I think we're just seeing the commodification of award shows more and more.

946
00:49:48.297 --> 00:49:50.418
I think your investing in journalism has brought it to us.

947
00:49:50.438 --> 00:49:51.158
Like, I wouldn't have known.

948
00:49:51.258 --> 00:49:52.839
I just think they're all a bit like that.

949
00:49:53.059 --> 00:49:53.339
Yeah.

950
00:49:53.579 --> 00:49:56.720
But, except the last culture eases.

951
00:49:56.760 --> 00:49:57.720
Yeah.

952
00:49:57.960 --> 00:50:01.682
The only true journalism out there is last culture eases.

953
00:50:02.402 --> 00:50:04.623
Last time we spoke about them, Matt Bowen did like our post.

954
00:50:04.663 --> 00:50:04.983
Really?

955
00:50:05.043 --> 00:50:05.303
Yeah.

956
00:50:06.294 --> 00:50:06.574
Huge.

957
00:50:06.594 --> 00:50:08.776
Did you marry Beth Barone like one of our posts?

958
00:50:08.856 --> 00:50:09.737
Oh, dude, that's huge.

959
00:50:10.017 --> 00:50:10.917
It was really big.

960
00:50:10.937 --> 00:50:11.698
Best day of my life.

961
00:50:14.240 --> 00:50:22.266
Anthony Albanese has been at the United Nations General Assembly speaking to our biggest challenges and taking images with many world leaders, including Donald Trump.

962
00:50:23.548 --> 00:50:24.649
Big week last week.

963
00:50:24.749 --> 00:50:37.016
I feel like every time I open my phone on my lovely holiday, I was just seeing lots of different pictures of world leaders meeting each other, speaking to different challenges, mostly, as we said earlier, about things like artificial intelligence, about genocide in Gaza.

964
00:50:37.076 --> 00:50:40.558
I mean, I saw Benjamin Netanyahu gave a speech at the General Assembly.

965
00:50:40.578 --> 00:50:41.598
I don't know why that's allowed.

966
00:50:42.759 --> 00:50:46.261
But half of the national delegations walked out there.

967
00:50:46.861 --> 00:50:47.662
which was awesome.

968
00:50:47.742 --> 00:50:48.843
And it was really interesting.

969
00:50:48.943 --> 00:50:54.647
I mean, the fact that Netanyahu is allowed to speak when Israel's actively perpetrating a genocide in Gaza is disturbing.

970
00:50:54.888 --> 00:50:59.151
But I think it also is interesting to look at the maps of where in the world delegations stayed.

971
00:50:59.551 --> 00:51:04.715
You can actually see a lot of recordings and reportings of which nations left the room and which stayed.

972
00:51:05.196 --> 00:51:07.457
Can we also talk about the photo of Albo and Trump?

973
00:51:07.637 --> 00:51:08.178
Yeah, interesting.

974
00:51:08.198 --> 00:51:08.918
What did you think of this?

975
00:51:09.339 --> 00:51:11.500
Something about a selfie is crazy to me.

976
00:51:11.541 --> 00:51:13.962
Yeah, so he got a selfie with Trump last year.

977
00:51:13.982 --> 00:51:14.423
Mm-hmm.

978
00:51:14.803 --> 00:51:20.545
And there was sort of a similar reaction, obviously, where another 12 months, I think it was almost 12 months ago, I think it was late last year.

979
00:51:20.565 --> 00:51:22.885
You just know there's people around them that could take the photo.

980
00:51:23.245 --> 00:51:24.666
Is the selfie on purpose?

981
00:51:24.766 --> 00:51:35.029
Well, what's interesting to me is that a lot of the posts made in the days before that or around this sort of UN General Assembly were more sort of professional diplomatic photos with different world leaders.

982
00:51:35.089 --> 00:51:43.391
So Emmanuel Macron from France, I think it's Pedro Sanchez from Spain, like lots of different world leaders shaking hands, smiling, more professional images.

983
00:51:44.091 --> 00:51:49.094
The selfie to me was interesting because it looks far more personable than I think is necessary.

984
00:51:49.295 --> 00:51:57.040
You know, I posted about this last week and obviously, again, bias here, but I don't know why that was what they wanted to exhibit.

985
00:51:57.120 --> 00:51:59.582
Or maybe that was the only opportunity that was there.

986
00:51:59.702 --> 00:51:59.882
Mm-hmm.

987
00:52:00.322 --> 00:52:02.985
You know, a lot of people said like they're our biggest strategic partner.

988
00:52:03.045 --> 00:52:04.106
Like, of course he needs this.

989
00:52:04.126 --> 00:52:05.888
But I think that photo wasn't needed.

990
00:52:06.149 --> 00:52:06.869
A meeting, sure.

991
00:52:07.070 --> 00:52:07.650
Like, I get it.

992
00:52:07.690 --> 00:52:13.617
But also it's interesting because it's fascinating in this era of Pauline Hanson's rise where she is compared to Trump a lot.

993
00:52:14.038 --> 00:52:17.662
But Australians have a much lower approval rating of Donald Trump than Pauline Hanson.

994
00:52:18.442 --> 00:52:21.544
So even a lot of Pauline Hanson supporters would be against Donald Trump in the US, right?

995
00:52:21.564 --> 00:52:24.626
Because it's actually watching those policies play out in real time.

996
00:52:25.127 --> 00:52:28.009
Is it because of the bid at the moment?

997
00:52:28.269 --> 00:52:29.570
This is what's interesting, right?

998
00:52:29.650 --> 00:52:31.111
So you're absolutely right.

999
00:52:31.271 --> 00:52:38.395
He's been there because Australia is kind of vying for a temporary position on the UN Security Council.

1000
00:52:38.435 --> 00:52:39.156
Which is a big deal.

1001
00:52:39.376 --> 00:52:43.759
We're basically advocating for a non-permanent seat on the Security Council for two years, so 2029 and 2030.

1002
00:52:43.799 --> 00:52:44.059
What is...

1003
00:52:46.016 --> 00:52:46.376
Yes.

1004
00:52:46.456 --> 00:52:47.437
Let's go back.

1005
00:52:47.477 --> 00:52:48.618
Let's take a step back.

1006
00:52:48.678 --> 00:52:58.466
So the UN Security Council is a body that's primarily responsible for maintaining international peace and security through things like peacekeeping operations, global sanctions.

1007
00:52:58.966 --> 00:53:05.192
And the Australian government has said it wants a seat to have a stronger voice in the decisions that affect Australians and our region.

1008
00:53:05.932 --> 00:53:09.315
So Albo's speech at the UN very much underscored this intention.

1009
00:53:09.735 --> 00:53:15.639
He explicitly talked about the bid, but he also talked about how we need to see global cooperation.

1010
00:53:15.679 --> 00:53:24.486
He stressed this importance of, you know, elevating the voices of smaller nations, middle powers, saying that the world can't be run by the whims of the loudest voices and the richest companies.

1011
00:53:25.427 --> 00:53:27.588
Again, like you're saying the right things.

1012
00:53:27.608 --> 00:53:28.129
Yeah.

1013
00:53:28.449 --> 00:53:33.313
I don't think the action reflects that, but that's what I want to be hearing from a leader.

1014
00:53:33.353 --> 00:53:36.135
But I want that to be reflected in our domestic policy as well.

1015
00:53:36.535 --> 00:53:42.380
And Albanese also, you know, said a lot on climate change and AI at the UN General Assembly as well.

1016
00:53:42.460 --> 00:53:49.065
So talking about those, that is difficult to stomach again, looking at how many coal mines Labor is approving right now.

1017
00:53:49.125 --> 00:53:52.568
So it's these things of like, I'm liking what I'm hearing, but the action doesn't back it up.

1018
00:53:53.148 --> 00:54:02.115
So there's a lot to kind of be looking at here as it unfolded and seeing lots of different leaders speaking and also how different leaders are approaching Donald Trump.

1019
00:54:02.675 --> 00:54:04.397
So we've seen, you know, the Prime Minister of Spain.

1020
00:54:04.437 --> 00:54:06.118
We've seen Mark Carney in Canada.

1021
00:54:06.138 --> 00:54:08.720
We've seen so many different world leaders.

1022
00:54:09.160 --> 00:54:09.661
Distance.

1023
00:54:09.961 --> 00:54:10.782
Pushing back.

1024
00:54:11.322 --> 00:54:14.324
And, you know, Trump wasn't actually there to see Albanese's speech.

1025
00:54:14.364 --> 00:54:16.026
He was hosting Xi Jinping at the White House.

1026
00:54:16.886 --> 00:54:21.730
So looking at kind of what happened and what unfolded, there's obviously a lot more to it that can be contained in this segment.

1027
00:54:22.310 --> 00:54:32.578
But again, it's kind of interesting to look at the context of you and what Mamdani said about Netanyahu in the months before the UN General Assembly, thinking about how Mamdani approaches Donald Trump.

1028
00:54:33.038 --> 00:54:43.967
Even in that week, did you see that was such an interesting speech outside of Gracie Manchin, where again, there's this approach which is strong, which is interested in negotiating, interested in speaking.

1029
00:54:44.847 --> 00:54:45.448
Because...

1030
00:54:46.028 --> 00:54:47.128
He respects Mamdani.

1031
00:54:47.148 --> 00:54:49.909
Trump likes being in the orbit of people that are popular.

1032
00:54:50.830 --> 00:54:55.971
And I think that that alignment is like Mamdani's not sitting at his feet trying to vie for his attention.

1033
00:54:55.991 --> 00:54:59.972
Mamdani is standing up to him, but in a way that is manageable and gets the best for New Yorkers.

1034
00:55:00.473 --> 00:55:03.394
So I think it's a really interesting contrast.

1035
00:55:03.714 --> 00:55:10.896
But I'm also really keen to see what the outcome of this UN Security Council bid is following on from this kind of pitch for Australia to be on for two years.

1036
00:55:13.298 --> 00:55:22.251
Oscar-winning actress Susan Sarandon and hack star Hannah Einbinder were both arrested in New York on Thursday while taking part in a protest against Netanyahu.

1037
00:55:22.712 --> 00:55:27.259
There was a protest that was because of his address at the UN General Assembly.

1038
00:55:27.539 --> 00:55:28.220
And the protest was also...

1039
00:55:28.300 --> 00:55:30.924
organized by Jewish Voice for Peace.

1040
00:55:31.324 --> 00:55:35.210
And people were holding up signs like stop arming Israel and end the genocide.

1041
00:55:35.590 --> 00:55:38.895
And then police said that this group was blocking the intersection.

1042
00:55:39.436 --> 00:55:43.962
And after they were warned to move and they didn't, a number of protesters then got taken into custody.

1043
00:55:44.162 --> 00:55:52.705
including these two massive stars, as well as Democratic congressional candidate Daria Liza and a New York City council member.

1044
00:55:53.225 --> 00:55:59.747
And the pictures of these actors then being led away from protests in cuffs went viral on social media.

1045
00:56:00.467 --> 00:56:10.570
I think it's a really big deal for stars of that caliber, not only to be actively speaking up for Palestine, but to be showing up at protests and willing to get arrested.

1046
00:56:10.950 --> 00:56:13.091
And I don't think it's particularly surprising from these two.

1047
00:56:13.191 --> 00:56:16.292
Like, they have been very vocal about Gaza for a long time.

1048
00:56:16.432 --> 00:56:23.715
Susan actually said again earlier this month that she is losing acting work because of her views.

1049
00:56:24.175 --> 00:56:28.677
And Hannah has spoken about the potential career consequences that she's faced now, too.

1050
00:56:29.117 --> 00:56:36.303
But she says basically she sees staying silent as a much greater cost and saying that her career could never be more important than even one human life.

1051
00:56:36.643 --> 00:56:37.884
I just think this is interesting as well.

1052
00:56:37.904 --> 00:56:42.868
Like we haven't even spoken about this on the podcast, which is crazy because I am his number one fan, Mark Ruffalo.

1053
00:56:43.028 --> 00:56:49.373
Oh, as we know, Cher famously met Mark Ruffalo with her Hollywood signatures book when she traveled there at the age of 10 or 12.

1054
00:56:51.652 --> 00:56:51.992
maybe 10.

1055
00:56:52.012 --> 00:56:53.553
I think it was 10.

1056
00:56:53.813 --> 00:56:54.793
I pulled up a seat.

1057
00:56:56.793 --> 00:56:58.154
I went into the hotel.

1058
00:56:58.334 --> 00:56:59.554
I saw him there.

1059
00:57:00.054 --> 00:57:01.534
It was my first night in LA.

1060
00:57:01.654 --> 00:57:02.515
I was like, amazing.

1061
00:57:02.555 --> 00:57:03.295
My first celebrity.

1062
00:57:03.315 --> 00:57:04.415
I'm going to meet so many of them.

1063
00:57:04.895 --> 00:57:06.856
I walked right up to him and I was like, hello.

1064
00:57:07.076 --> 00:57:09.236
I absolutely love the movie Suddenly 30.

1065
00:57:09.376 --> 00:57:12.277
And it's lovely to meet you, Matty from Suddenly 30.

1066
00:57:12.817 --> 00:57:14.037
And he thought it was so entertaining.

1067
00:57:14.077 --> 00:57:18.858
And he was having dinner with his parents that I pulled up a chair and sat on their table and

1068
00:57:21.859 --> 00:57:25.660
And he wrote in my little autographs book, like, to sweet Sarah, follow your dream.

1069
00:57:25.680 --> 00:57:26.280
Did you keep it?

1070
00:57:26.540 --> 00:57:28.321
Yeah, I'll put the photo up of me.

1071
00:57:28.441 --> 00:57:31.502
It's really funny because I just was so excited afterwards.

1072
00:57:31.542 --> 00:57:33.362
I took a photo with the autograph.

1073
00:57:33.382 --> 00:57:34.883
My dad had to come get me and apologize.

1074
00:57:34.983 --> 00:57:35.423
Awesome.

1075
00:57:35.463 --> 00:57:36.183
Anyway, love that man.

1076
00:57:40.224 --> 00:57:48.994
He has been a really interesting case of like Hollywood blacklisting him at the moment because of how vocal he's been about Palestine, but about so many social causes.

1077
00:57:49.014 --> 00:57:50.615
Like he's just a fucking legend.

1078
00:57:50.896 --> 00:57:53.739
Also, did you watch Sterling Point?

1079
00:57:54.179 --> 00:57:54.419
No.

1080
00:57:55.000 --> 00:57:55.961
The like YA.

1081
00:57:56.001 --> 00:57:56.482
What is that?

1082
00:57:56.702 --> 00:57:56.862
Oh.

1083
00:57:57.002 --> 00:57:57.602
You'd love it.

1084
00:57:57.762 --> 00:57:58.422
You'd love it.

1085
00:57:58.862 --> 00:58:02.643
It's like a new, really big TV show that's set in Canada.

1086
00:58:02.683 --> 00:58:04.383
I think it's on Prime.

1087
00:58:04.423 --> 00:58:06.944
Sorry, the whole of my feed is the love hypothesis.

1088
00:58:07.344 --> 00:58:09.444
And Lily Reinhart is just killing.

1089
00:58:09.464 --> 00:58:14.005
So I'm missing everything else because it's just like, oh my God, Prime is really putting the whole back into the ads for that.

1090
00:58:14.125 --> 00:58:19.326
Yeah, but Sterling Point is, I don't know, it's kind of like a teenage show, but it's a really fun watch.

1091
00:58:19.566 --> 00:58:26.187
And the brother, I don't think people know this, but the brother of the girl in it, the brother of Annie is Mark's.

1092
00:58:26.787 --> 00:58:27.007
son.

1093
00:58:27.407 --> 00:58:28.368
Of course.

1094
00:58:28.388 --> 00:58:32.311
And now when I watch it, I go, I can actually totally see that resemblance and the humor.

1095
00:58:32.771 --> 00:58:33.612
I'm so off.

1096
00:58:33.832 --> 00:58:35.473
I'm so off base right now.

1097
00:58:35.493 --> 00:58:36.534
Let me get back to this story.

1098
00:58:36.934 --> 00:58:41.497
But the point of this is I think this is coming at a really interesting time in Hollywood.

1099
00:58:41.597 --> 00:58:44.760
I think the past two weeks, especially, we have seen more and more celebs

1100
00:58:45.420 --> 00:58:51.249
speak out and feel like they can now comfortably label this a genocide and speak to it.

1101
00:58:51.309 --> 00:59:00.922
And even if it's not that, like I do think this Ed Sheeran and Malcolm Moore controversy has also led people to say, I stand in solidarity with Malcolm Moore.

1102
00:59:01.647 --> 00:59:14.550
Which is an interesting way to like not be able to advocate your political position, but to advocate an industry position like I support this artist's right to speak rather than I support what they're saying.

1103
00:59:14.670 --> 00:59:15.190
You know what I mean?

1104
00:59:15.230 --> 00:59:17.471
Or maybe trying to do both at the same time without saying it themselves.

1105
00:59:17.491 --> 00:59:17.711
Yeah.

1106
00:59:17.991 --> 00:59:21.972
Maybe it's being able to see the fallout so tangibly for Ed Sheeran right now.

1107
00:59:22.052 --> 00:59:31.134
I don't know what it is, but really an interesting example of this is Adam Brody, who of course is currently starring in Nobody Wants This and he's Jewish himself.

1108
00:59:31.914 --> 00:59:40.705
And he has now publicly called for a free Palestine and said that he very explicitly that he believes in what happening in Gaza is a genocide.

1109
00:59:41.206 --> 00:59:50.437
And he was also asked why, if he feels this strongly, why we haven't heard him talk about this on red carpet or while promoting nobody wants this.

1110
00:59:51.218 --> 00:59:53.841
And his answer was basically, no one's asked me.

1111
00:59:54.262 --> 01:00:06.675
He said 99% of the questions he gets are about the show and acknowledged that because he's not, you know, turning up wearing a pin or doing something that actively invites that conversation, the question generally doesn't come up.

1112
01:00:07.096 --> 01:00:11.120
And that he actually admires people who do make a point of doing that.

1113
01:00:11.921 --> 01:00:17.242
But he also made clear that this isn't a new position for him or something that he's only just started thinking about.

1114
01:00:17.562 --> 01:00:21.563
He said that Israel and Gaza come up a lot for him in private conversations.

1115
01:00:22.564 --> 01:00:26.584
And yeah, so when he was finally asked directly, he didn't really hedge it.

1116
01:00:26.724 --> 01:00:29.685
He said, put me down as thinking it's a genocide.

1117
01:00:29.905 --> 01:00:31.666
Put me down for wanting a free Palestine.

1118
01:00:32.306 --> 01:00:41.648
And then he said that while it's awful that it's taken so much death and suffering to get to this point, it feels like things are finally reaching a breaking point that in his view should have come much earlier.

1119
01:00:42.610 --> 01:00:48.183
it's kind of interesting to say that like I haven't been asked and you're like if it should have come much earlier maybe you could have been part of that

1120
01:00:48.992 --> 01:00:52.473
Yeah, I wonder how many people take this position now.

1121
01:00:52.493 --> 01:00:53.314
It's an interesting...

1122
01:00:54.074 --> 01:00:56.015
It's also like we are three years in.

1123
01:00:56.035 --> 01:00:56.295
Yes.

1124
01:00:56.615 --> 01:00:58.515
I don't understand how this is the breaking point.

1125
01:00:58.535 --> 01:00:59.636
This occupation has been very much longer.

1126
01:00:59.676 --> 01:01:10.920
And also the... What is interesting, and I get it because I think a lot of people who are interviewed regularly, like him, would think like, oh, I'll just wait to be asked and then I'll say something.

1127
01:01:11.440 --> 01:01:13.781
But at a certain point it is this question of like, well...

1128
01:01:14.601 --> 01:01:20.669
Would you not understand the platform and influence you have outside of a context where you're being asked on a red carpet or in an interview?

1129
01:01:21.390 --> 01:01:22.431
Like, I don't know.

1130
01:01:22.691 --> 01:01:22.952
Sorry.

1131
01:01:23.412 --> 01:01:25.595
I am not here to criticize someone who's doing the right thing.

1132
01:01:25.615 --> 01:01:27.538
No, but it's more just a shift in Hollywood.

1133
01:01:27.558 --> 01:01:28.579
Fascinating approach.

1134
01:01:28.679 --> 01:01:30.622
Even Theo Vaughn on his podcast.

1135
01:01:31.962 --> 01:01:36.827
The Yovan on his podcast recently, like since this Malcolm Moore and Ed Sheeran stuff was like, what's going on?

1136
01:01:37.007 --> 01:01:38.008
I don't stand for this.

1137
01:01:38.088 --> 01:01:39.670
This is like, this doesn't make any sense.

1138
01:01:39.790 --> 01:01:41.071
I'm against this occupation.

1139
01:01:41.131 --> 01:01:41.892
And it's like, wow.

1140
01:01:42.032 --> 01:01:42.292
Okay.

1141
01:01:42.613 --> 01:01:49.400
Even Amelia de Moldenburg, who's the chicken shop date, had her SNL monologue for UK SNL.

1142
01:01:49.940 --> 01:01:53.802
and took a pretty hard, like, took a jab at Ed Sheeran in it.

1143
01:01:54.202 --> 01:01:58.043
And again, I wonder, would people have been ballsy enough to do that a year ago?

1144
01:01:58.063 --> 01:02:01.004
No, and I think it's interesting because these people are all leaders.

1145
01:02:01.324 --> 01:02:01.484
Yeah.

1146
01:02:01.504 --> 01:02:08.027
You know, and Adam Brody, like, especially as a Jewish person, it would be, like, there'll be a lot of personal consequence for speaking out about this as well.

1147
01:02:08.427 --> 01:02:11.108
And I'm sure he's experienced anti-Semitic attacks.

1148
01:02:11.128 --> 01:02:12.609
Like, I'm absolutely sure of it.

1149
01:02:12.649 --> 01:02:16.470
And so to say that is so powerful and courageous.

1150
01:02:16.810 --> 01:02:18.091
But it is interesting to look back on, like,

1151
01:02:18.611 --> 01:02:21.775
Them sort of saying like people now saying like, oh, you know, it's reaching a breaking point.

1152
01:02:21.795 --> 01:02:22.515
We don't need to be speaking up.

1153
01:02:22.535 --> 01:02:25.118
It's like, well, we all we all have been.

1154
01:02:25.138 --> 01:02:25.939
Yeah.

1155
01:02:26.360 --> 01:02:39.394
And again, it's this context I kind of come back to where it's often the people that have the least that are the most that are the first to risk what they have, you know, and it's people that often have more wealth and power and influence that sit back and watch it play out before they feel like they can speak up.

1156
01:02:42.105 --> 01:02:46.787
Okay, thank you so much for making it to the Q&amp;A part of this podcast.

1157
01:02:46.867 --> 01:02:53.250
If you wanted to send a question in, please do so on the SpeakPipe, which is in our broadcast channel on Instagram.

1158
01:02:53.270 --> 01:02:55.191
So you can have a look in there and you can actually send in.

1159
01:02:55.231 --> 01:02:56.892
It's really nice to be able to hear everyone's voices.

1160
01:02:56.932 --> 01:02:57.572
So please do that.

1161
01:02:57.892 --> 01:03:00.153
Also, please, again, push to the audience survey.

1162
01:03:00.374 --> 01:03:01.494
It will be in the show notes.

1163
01:03:01.514 --> 01:03:02.835
So definitely please fill that out.

1164
01:03:04.009 --> 01:03:14.621
We have had this episode going for a while, but I do want to use this Q&amp;A section as a bit of an opportunity to acknowledge that we got got by Nanya Business.

1165
01:03:14.722 --> 01:03:17.525
Oh, thank you for bringing this up.

1166
01:03:17.545 --> 01:03:17.825
We got got.

1167
01:03:18.166 --> 01:03:18.866
We got got.

1168
01:03:19.507 --> 01:03:20.128
We got caught.

1169
01:03:20.168 --> 01:03:20.668
Finally.

1170
01:03:20.708 --> 01:03:21.829
It was so funny.

1171
01:03:21.849 --> 01:03:27.473
I saw this thing on socials and I thought, oh, this would be funny because we'd spoken about Channing Tatum's burner account on your business.

1172
01:03:28.494 --> 01:03:30.635
And we kind of made a fake version.

1173
01:03:30.655 --> 01:03:33.418
So it looked like he'd commented on our post.

1174
01:03:33.658 --> 01:03:34.198
Yep.

1175
01:03:34.458 --> 01:03:36.280
Very clearly, clearly an edit.

1176
01:03:36.860 --> 01:03:38.762
But then I wake up at like...

1177
01:03:39.342 --> 01:03:40.163
5am or whatever.

1178
01:03:40.183 --> 01:03:44.908
I'd been struggling sleeping because I'm dog sitting and the dog keeps waking me up.

1179
01:03:45.049 --> 01:03:52.237
And I roll over, I'm half asleep and I see this message from Hannah that goes, guys, none of your business has commented.

1180
01:03:52.257 --> 01:03:52.877
None of your business.

1181
01:03:53.118 --> 01:03:55.541
Because also- Channing Tatum has commented.

1182
01:03:55.761 --> 01:03:58.564
Also, I think I was at Oktoberfest in Munich.

1183
01:03:59.974 --> 01:04:01.475
And I think I'd had a Stein.

1184
01:04:02.355 --> 01:04:06.817
And I'm like looking at the comments and I'm like, oh, you did the butterfly picture.

1185
01:04:07.177 --> 01:04:07.857
I couldn't believe it.

1186
01:04:08.117 --> 01:04:11.359
And also I'm like, oh, so I just think, I also look at the time in Australia.

1187
01:04:11.379 --> 01:04:14.600
I'm like, it's like 3 a.m. And I'm like, I'm going to be ahead of the curfew.

1188
01:04:14.860 --> 01:04:16.361
So I like text you and Justine.

1189
01:04:16.381 --> 01:04:16.981
I'm like, God.

1190
01:04:17.443 --> 01:04:19.544
when you wake up, you get to see this.

1191
01:04:19.564 --> 01:04:20.265
It was your mind.

1192
01:04:20.285 --> 01:04:23.887
Anyway, so obviously Sarah wakes up and like rampages to post about it.

1193
01:04:23.907 --> 01:04:25.308
But like half asleep.

1194
01:04:25.368 --> 01:04:28.129
Like I literally woke up at 5am, was like, amazing.

1195
01:04:28.169 --> 01:04:29.250
That's hilarious.

1196
01:04:29.490 --> 01:04:31.651
Reposted it, went back to sleep.

1197
01:04:31.731 --> 01:04:35.653
And then just seeing guys, no, there's an extra underscore.

1198
01:04:35.674 --> 01:04:37.214
There's an extra underscore and that is someone else.

1199
01:04:37.234 --> 01:04:38.655
But I'd like to know who thought of that.

1200
01:04:38.715 --> 01:04:40.836
Who thought to create a secondary non-new business?

1201
01:04:40.856 --> 01:04:41.157
Genius.

1202
01:04:42.117 --> 01:04:46.279
But yeah, we got got by Nanya underscore underscore underscore business.

1203
01:04:46.539 --> 01:04:48.400
It was funny nonetheless, though.

1204
01:04:48.440 --> 01:04:48.721
Yes.

1205
01:04:48.881 --> 01:04:49.781
Funny nonetheless.

1206
01:04:49.981 --> 01:04:53.983
And then we thought we have to talk about the fact that I felt like a grandma that got tricked by AI.

1207
01:04:54.304 --> 01:04:56.405
Yeah, as we both did.

1208
01:04:56.505 --> 01:04:56.765
Yeah.

1209
01:04:58.902 --> 01:05:00.923
Thank you so much for listening again this week.

1210
01:05:01.083 --> 01:05:05.826
Please join the Besties channel, leave a review, tap the bell, tap five stars.

1211
01:05:06.166 --> 01:05:06.707
Woo-woo!

1212
01:05:06.727 --> 01:05:07.347
We love that.

1213
01:05:07.427 --> 01:05:08.268
Thank you so much.

1214
01:05:08.328 --> 01:05:09.849
Woo-woo!

1215
01:05:10.169 --> 01:05:12.310
Enjoy Sarah's witchy Instagram content, you know.

1216
01:05:12.330 --> 01:05:13.251
Thank you.

1217
01:05:13.551 --> 01:05:15.092
And get tickets to the live show, hey.

1218
01:05:15.732 --> 01:05:16.193
Last one.

1219
01:05:16.313 --> 01:05:17.553
Thank you so much.

1220
01:05:17.713 --> 01:05:20.615
And we'll see you this Thursday for Small Talk and then see you next Tuesday.

1221
01:05:20.635 --> 01:05:21.516
See you next Tuesday.
